+ All Categories
Home > Documents > d¾PRJ[nG`^W `^]^a8F KMJ|KcDVLH a i FO]^H FOS...

d¾PRJ[nG`^W `^]^a8F KMJ|KcDVLH a i FO]^H FOS...

Date post: 01-Aug-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 0 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
36
Transcript
Page 1: d¾PRJ[nG`^W `^]^a8F KMJ|KcDVLH a i FO]^H FOS ...hopf.math.purdue.edu/Porter/s-catsv2.pdfGKUKcFOWYKcJ[eLF{KcD FOS,NMJ KcDVAK&d KcDG]pHGa d_ FOeL]^H KMJ nGHGW FOSMN K.VLH WzKcDGFjP

������������ ������������������ ����� ��! ����#"���$�&%'�������� �������(�&)* + �*�,�-�.�������� ����.��

/�021436587:9<;,3>=?5A@B=

CEDGFIHGJLKMFONQPRFOSMFITGSUFOT�VLSUFOWYXZJ[S,V\NUFOSU]^FON,JLX_K.V8`^abNQKcD�V8K,d�efVhg[FI]^HYijV8e[FOHY]^Hk`lVAKcFImLnGHGF�VLHGWYFhV8SM`pomLnG`porqLs[s[t�uvV8HGW�u-Pw]pKMDrNMJ[xIFzy.D�VLH�e[FON{uR]pH|KcDGF�}�HG]pgLFOSMNU]pK~o'JLX���V#��VLeLn��H�V�u�KcD�F\��VLH�VLS�o|d~NM`^VLHGWGN{uv]^H� FOT�KMFOx���FOS{u�q8s[s[t��kCEDGF!o�VLNMNUnGxIFzKcDGF�VLn�WG]^F{HGyOF�abHGJ?PwN�NMJ[xIF�VL��NUKcSMVLy{K�D�J[x�J8KcJ[TfoYKcDGF{J[SUo|VLHGW�VLNi�FO]pHGFOS��,VLxITGNIP�VLN�]^H�KcDGF�VLnGWG]pFOHGy{F*]pH�i�VLe[FOH>u�]pKI]^N�NMV8XZF\KMJ|VLNUNMnGxIF�KcD�V8KIKcD�F�HGJ8KcFON$VLNMNUnGxIF*VSMFhV8NMJ[H�V8�G`^F,abHGJ?Pw`^F{WGe[F,JLX�J[nGSw�6J�J[a�u���qL�8�2u�J[SwVLHfo�F{��n�]pg8VL`^F{HfKEKcF!��K�]pX�J[HGF,yOVLH���F�XZJ[nGH�W��

��D�VAKwWGJIKMDGF,HGJLKMFONwNMF!K�JLn�KwKcJ�WGJb�

�����h  ¡£¢�¤#¥ ¦¨§�©�ªQ«E¬-�{­IªQ¡j®c¯ °I± ¡²³°�´#µO¥ �{¬ §'ª �E¶|ª�¢�±v¤#�h¤³· ¦¸´*¬�¹«�°I  ªQ¡�¯\º

» C�JjSMF{g�]pNM]pK�NMJLx�FRJ[`^WG]pNMD&x$V8KMFOSU]lVL`fJ[H�VL�GNUKMScVLy!K�DGJLx�JLKMJ[Tfo¼VLHGW�NU]^xITG`^]pyO]^VL`^`½o�F{HGSM]py.DGFOW¾yOV8KcF{e[J[SU]^FON{uKcD�VAK¿NUFOFOxIN&KMJ���FI�6F{]^HGe\nGNMF{W|]^HkKcJ�W�Vho�ÀÁN¼SMF{NMnGSUe[FOH�yOFzJLX�]^HfKcF{SMF{NUK&]^HkKcDGF$VLSMFOV�VLH�W�KcJ�KcS�o#KcJg�]^F{PÂ]pKw]pH�V¾HGF!PÃ`p]^e[DfKhuBJ[SwT6F{SMD�V8TGNEXZSMJ[xÄHGF{PÅW�]^SMF{y{KM]^J[HGN{Æ

» C�J¿]^HfKcSUJBWGn�yOF � FOefVL`�yhVAKcFOeLJ[SM]pFON�V8HGW$g8VLSM]pJ[nGN_JLKcD�FOSRKMJBJL`^NvnGNMF{W��fo�KMDGF�Ç�]^yOF�È~C�J[nG`pJ[nGNMF�e[SMJLnGTzJLXVL�GN�KcScV8y{K�DGJ[xIJLKcJLTbo�KcDGF{J[SM]pNUKMN�V8HGW�`p]^HGa�KcD�FOx�]^HfKMJ¾NMJ[xIF,JLX�KMDGF,J[`^W�FOSE]^W�FhVLN{Æ» C�J�]^HfKcSUJBW�nGyOF&mLJ?ofVL`2ÀÁN��bn�VLNU]^yhVAKcFOeLJ[SM]pFONOu�ÉZTGSMF!g�]^J[nGNU`po�yOVL`^`pFOW�P�FOVLa\�,VLH�y{J[xITG`^F���F{N���n�K�dEVLe[SUFOFPw]pKMDYÊ�HGWGS�ËF�KcD�V8K�DG]^NQHGJLx�F{HGyO`^V8KcnGSUF�]^Nj�6F!KMKcF{SQNMJzPw]p`^`�V8WGJ[T�KQ]½K�Ì�VLHGWkNMDGJ?PÍDGJ?PÎKMD�V8KQKcD�FOJ[S�o`^]pHGabN¼]pH#Pw]pKcDkNUJ[x�F�J[`pWk]^WGFOVLN,JLX�ÏRJfVLSMW�x$VLHYVLH�WYÐvJ[e8Khu�ÑjPEo[F{S&V8HGW'�,VLH>u�V8HGW|��JLSMWG]pFOS¼VLHGWx¿o�NMF{`pXÒÆ

» C�J�VLNUaz`^JLKMNEJLX���n�FONUKM]^J[H�N�JLX�x¿o�NMF{`pXVLHGW\JLX�KcDGF,SMFOVLWGF{SO�CEDGF¿HGJ8KcFON�]^H�yO`^n�WGFQNMJ[xIF,x$VAKcFOSU]lVL`6XZSMJ[xÓKMDGF¾ÔÕ��n��6JGÀ�VLS�Kc]pyO`^F8u��Ötf×A�2uGPwDG]^y.D\P�VLN�]pKMNMF{`pX���VLNMF{W*J[H\HGJLKMFONXZJ[S�VIyOJ[nGSUNMF¾VAK�KMDGF#ØRÙAÚcÛ?Ù�Ü.Û!Ý2ÞàßLÙ*ØváLÝ~Üãâ�ÙAÚ!ÞãÜIÜ\ä6Ù.å�ÙAæ^ÙMâLÞçá$]pH|è?é[é�èLu���n�KjKMDGF¿J?g[F{SM`^VLT³D�VLN��6F{FOH#a8FOT�KVLN�NUx$VL`p`�VLN�]pN_XZFOVLNM]p�G`^F�VLN_KcDGF�TGnGSUT6J[NUF�VLH�W$KcDGF�VLnGW�]^FOH�yOFjJ8X�KcDGF�K~P�J¿NMF{KMN�JLX:H�JLKcF{N�VLSUF�WG]½ê>F{SMF{HbK�VLHGWKcDGF�VL�GN�KcScV8y{K¼DGJ[xIJLKcJLTbo�KcDGF{J[SUo³D�VLN¾ÔëxIJ?g[F{W'J[H�À½u�]^HkT�VLS�Khu:KcJ�KMSUo³KMDGF�HGF{PìxIF{KMDGJ�WGNQJ[n�K¼J[H#KcD�J[NMFNcVLxIF¾ÔëJ[`pW�ÀGTGSUJ[�G`pFOxINEVLHGW�KcJIV8KUK.VLy.azH�F{PÅJ[H�FON�VLNEP�F{`^`2�

Ê�N�nGNUn�VL`:PwDGF{H�o[JLn�KcS�o�KcJINMT�FOy{]pXào#ÔÁ`^FhV8SMHG]pHGe�J[n�Kcy{J[xIFONOÀGoLJ[n*F{HGW*n�T³VLNUa�]pHGe�PwDGJ$D�V8N�WGJLHGF¼KMDGF`^FhV8SMHG]pHGeGuBKMDGF¼VLnGWG]pFOHGy{F?�³í�FOSMDGVLTGNO�_CEDGF¼`^F{y{Kcn�SMFOS{u�x�JLNUKwyOF{SUKcVL]^HG`½o��

î�ïñð:ò�óBô�õçö�÷�ø�öBù�öBò�úñûè

Page 2: d¾PRJ[nG`^W `^]^a8F KMJ|KcDVLH a i FO]^H FOS ...hopf.math.purdue.edu/Porter/s-catsv2.pdfGKUKcFOWYKcJ[eLF{KcD FOS,NMJ KcDVAK&d KcDG]pHGa d_ FOeL]^H KMJ nGHGW FOSMN K.VLH WzKcDGFjP

d¾PRJ[nG`^W�`^]^a8F�KMJ|KcD�VLH�a�i�FO]^H�FOS��,VLxITGNzV8HGW<DG]^N�yOJ[`p`^FOVLe[nGF{NzV8K�KcDGF#ü�F{SMH�}�H�]pg[F{SM]pNUKñýVAKzXZJ[S�KMDGF]^Hfg�]pK.VAKc]^JLHIKMJ�e[]pgLF�KMDGFjK.V8`^abN�JLX>PwDG]^y.DzKMDGFONUF�HGJLKMFONEVLSUF�V¿NUnGxIx$VLS�oIVLHGWzKMJ&KcD�FQü�FOSMHz}�HG]½g[FOSU]^N�KñýV8KRXZJ[SKcDGF�NUnGTGT�J[SUKRKcD�VAK�x�VLWGFwKcDGFjg�]pNM]pKRT�J[NMNU]^�G`pFLufKcJ�mLJLN�ËF,þ*V8H�n�FO`:ÿ,VLSUy[Ë� VñÈ���VL`pyO]^H�FONOu�mLJLNMnRËF��wFOxIFOW�]^J[NRVLHGWKcDGF{]^S¿y{J[`^`pFhVLeLnGFON¼VLHGW�XZJ[S¼KMDGFzÑ�F{T�VLS�K.VLxIFOHfKcJ�WGF�þ�V8KcDGF{x$VAKc]^yOV*ü�nGHGWGVLx�F{HfK.VL`v]^HYKcDGF$}�HG]½g[F{SMNM]pW�VLWWGF\��VY��VLe[nGHGV�uvC�F{HGFOSU]pXZFLuRNM]px�`^VLSM`½oYVLHGW VL`^NUJkKMJ���VLSM`pJ[N � ]^xITGNUJ[H�u_Ï�FOS�KcSMVLHGW�C�J�FOH�u_ÊjH�WGS�ËF�mLJ?ofVL`2u��`^FOxIFOH�N�ÏRFOSMeLFOSOu�Ê�HGWGS�ËF&i�]^SUNMy.DGJ?Pw]pK��¼VLHGW\JLKcDGF{SMN�V8KEKMDGF¼Ç�]^y{FQx�F{F{KM]^HGe�]^H\þ�V?o�q8s[s[t�uBNM]^H�yOFQKcD�VAK�]pNPwDGFOSUF$�G]½KcNQJLX�]^WGFOVLNQKcD�V8K¼d�D�VLWYe[`^FOVLHGFOWYJ?g[F{S¿V�`^JLHGe[]^NUDkT6F{SM]^J�WkJLX�KM]^xIF��GKUKcFOWYKcJ[eLF{KcD�FOS,NMJ�KcD�VAK&dKcDG]pHGa�d_��FOeL]^H�KMJ�nGHGW�FOSMN�K.VLH�WzKcDGFjP�Vho�KMD�V8K�V&`^J8K�JLX:KMDG]^H�e[N�]pHbKMFOSU`^J�y.a¾]^H�KMDG]^N�VLSMFOV¿��F{KMKMFOS_KcD�VLH�d-W�]^W�6F!XZJ[SMF8�

CEDGF{NMF�H�JLKcF{NRD�VhgLFQVL`^NUJ&��FOH�F��GKUKcFOW�XZSMJ[xìy{J[x�xIFOHfKMNR�fo$mL]^x � KcVLNMD�F{ê�VLHGWzNUJ[xIF�JLX>DG]^N_yOJL`^`^FOVLe[nGF{NJ[H*V8H\FOVLSM`p]^F{S�g[F{SMNM]pJ[H��

�Ä°I¤z¬�ªQ¤z¬�¡ �� ï� Bú?öbø�ó����ZöBû �

è[�½è ��VAKcFOeLJ[SM]pFONEPw]pKMD\NU]^xITG`^]pyO]^VL`:ÔëDGJLx�È NMF{KMNOÀ¨�&�¼�&�¼�¼�¼�¼�¼�&�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼�&�,�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼� qè[�ëq ü�SUJ[xÓNU]^xITG`^]pyO]lV8`�SUFONUJ[`^n�KM]^J[H�N�KcJ È yhV8KMNO���&�¼�&�¼�¼�¼�¼�¼�&�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼�&�,�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼� �è[�Át CED�F¿ÑjPEoLFOS�È~�,VLHYÔÁNM]px�T�`^]^y{]lVL`�e[SUJ[nGT�J[]^W>ÀBXZnGHGy!KcJ[S{���¼�¼�¼�&�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼�&�,�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼� �

� �6ú�����ïLú����ñö �qB�½è CED�FIÔÁDGJ[xIJLKcJLTbo�ÀGyOV8KcF{e[J[S�oÂ�¼�,�&�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼�&�¼�¼�¼�¼�¼�&�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼�&�,�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼� �qB�ëq C�FOH�NMJ[SU]^HGe�VLHGW���JLKMFOHGNUJ[SM]pHGe<�,�&�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼�&�¼�¼�¼�¼�¼�&�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼�&�,�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼� �

� � ö�����ö�û� �ò�÷! \ó�ù'ó�ú?ó�"$#!%¿ó'&�ö(�Aö�ò6ú � ö�����ö�û*) +t��½è �,VLH\VLH�W\PRFhVLa��,VLH�y{J[HGWG]½Kc]^JLHGN��¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼�&�¼�¼�¼�¼�¼�&�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼�&�,�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼� ét��ëq Ç�FOS�g[FON �,�&�¼�¼�&�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼�,�&�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼�&�¼�¼�¼�¼�¼�&�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼�&�,�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼�£è[èt��Át ,�n�V8NM]½È yhV8KMFOe[JLSM]^F{N¿�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼�,�&�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼�&�¼�¼�¼�¼�¼�&�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼�&�,�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼�£è?tt��-� i�J[xIJLKcJ[Tfo$yOJ[DGF{SMF{HbK�HGF{SUg[F{NÅ�,�&�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼�&�¼�¼�¼�¼�¼�&�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼�&�,�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼�£è?t

. / ô0#�ö�� �21 �ò! 3 �ù|ù'ó�ïAð54vó:ï� �õ6�2û� �ú7�Zó6ò�8,ù'ó��ñö³û9�çù:"�õ;�çï<�= �õ2õ>#Yö�ò����çï?&�ö�÷4ï� �ú?öbø�ó��?�Zö�û*) A@�G�½è i�VLxIx�J�y.abN¼�¼�¼�&�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼�,�&�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼�&�¼�¼�¼�¼�¼�&�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼�&�,�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼�£è���G�ëq i�VLxIx�J�y.abNE]^H�KcDGF,TGSUFONUFOHGy{F¿JLXV¾yhVL`pyOnG`pnGNEJLX�`^F{XàKEXZSMVLy{KM]^J[H�NO�(�¼�¼�&�¼�&�,�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼�£è?é

B CD� û�"E �ï[ö�û*F CD� ï� �ú?öbø�ó'���Zö�ûG �ò�÷H�>ö�ø� �õ�ï� �ú?öbø�ó'���Zö�û*) � ×B�½è C È~NUT�VLy{FONOu C È~yOV8KcF{e[J[SM]pFON{�r�&�¼�,�&�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼�&�¼�¼�¼�¼�¼�&�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼�&�,�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼��qLt×B�ëq � FOefVL`:yOV8KcF{e[J[SU]^FON��¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼�,�&�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼�&�¼�¼�¼�¼�¼�&�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼�&�,�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼��q?�

I J Gù|ûK �ù: GòE�Rô¿ö( GðML � ï� Bú?öbø�ó����ZöBû � B���½è ÏR]^NM]px�T�`^]^y{]lVL`�xIJ�WGFO`pN�XZJ[SwV¾�G]^yOV8KcF{e[J[SUoL� �&�¼�&�¼�¼�¼�¼�¼�&�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼�&�,�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼��qL����ëq C�VLxINcVLx�VLHG] È � F{efVL`�P�FOVLa L È yhV8KMFOe[JLSM]^F{N³�¼�&�¼�&�¼�¼�¼�¼�¼�&�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼�&�,�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼��q*����Át CED�F¿í�J[]^HGyOVLS�ËF�PRFhV8a L È~eLSMJ[nGT�J[]pW�JLXC�VLxINcVLx�VLHG] �¼�¼�¼�&�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼�&�,�¼�&�¼�¼�&�¼� t�è

@ %&ó�ò�ïfõ6��û9�çó�òDN � �

q

Page 3: d¾PRJ[nG`^W `^]^a8F KMJ|KcDVLH a i FO]^H FOS ...hopf.math.purdue.edu/Porter/s-catsv2.pdfGKUKcFOWYKcJ[eLF{KcD FOS,NMJ KcDVAK&d KcDG]pHGa d_ FOeL]^H KMJ nGHGW FOSMN K.VLH WzKcDGFjP

O P ¹�«�¢¼¬�ª�·�°I±v�OªQ¡QSRTQ U:VXWZY\[^]S_�`aY\bdcd`eWZfgbZ`Thji�kT`Tl\`aV�knmofp]qhsr?bAYtWAbtu�'FjVLNMNUnGx�FwPRFjD�Vhg[FjV¼yOV8KcF{e[J[S�owv PwDGJ[NUFjJ[��xUF{y{KMNRPw]^`p`��6F�WGF{HGJLKcF{W$�foI`^J?PRFOS_yhVLNUFj`^F!KMKMFOSOu<y�u-z6u|{�u��O�{�OuV8K�`^FhV8NUK�]^H�KcDGF¼e[F{HGFOSU]^y,yhVLNUFLu6VLHGW�XZJ[SwFhVLy.D�T�VL]pSEJLX�NUnGy.D³J[��xUF{y{KMNOuÉ=y\}2z�Ì!u�V�NM]px�TG`p]^y{]lVL`�NMF!K~v\É>y\}2zGÌ�]pNe[]pgLFOH�ÆGXZJ[SEFOVLy.D�KMSM]pTG`^F~y\}�z�}�{¾JLX�J[��xUF{y{KMN�JLXEv�u�PRF&DGV?gLF¿V¾NU]^xITG`^]pyO]lV8`�x�VLT�u�yhVL`p`^FOW��.Ù��jå�Ù?Û!ÞàÝçÞãÙ��

v\É>y\}2z�Ìq��v\É6z'}�{fÌq����v\É=y\}�{[Ì!ÆVLHGW�XZJ[SEFhVLy.D�J[��xUF{y{K�y#V¾x�VLT �

��s8����v\É=y\}�y6ÌKcD�V8K¿ÔëH�V8x�F{NOÀ>JLS¿ÔëT�]^y.abNQJ[n�KOÀ6KcD�F$Ôë]pWGFOHfKM]pK~o*VLSMSUJñP,À6]^H*KMDGF¾NMF!KQJLXRsAÈ NM]^xITG`p]^yOF{NwJLX^v\É=y\}�y6Ì��QCEDG]^NQW�VAK.V]^N�KMJzNcVAKc]^N�Xào�KcDGF&J[�fgB]pJ[nGNjVA�B]^J[xINOu6VLNMNUJBy{]lV8KM]pg�]pK~o�VLHGW³]pWGFOHfKc]½K~o[u6NMnG]½K.VL�G`½o\VLW�VLTBKcFOW�KcJ$KMDG]^N�NM]pKMn�V8KM]^J[H��� nGy.D4VkNMF!KInGT�Pw]p`^`���F�yhVL`p`^F{W�VrÛ!Þ>�jå�æÕÞo�!ÞçáLæàæ���Ü���Ú�Þo����Ü��5�MáLÝ~Üãâ�ÙAÚ��'J[S¾xIJ[SUF�NM]^xITG`½o�á*� �� �MáLÝ~Üãâ�ÙAÚ��A��vH�SM]^y.D�FOW'yOV8KcF{e[J[S�o*KcD�FOJ[S�o#]^N,VzPRFO`^`FONUKcVL�G`p]^NMD�FOWY�GScVLH�y.D�JLX_yOV8KcF{e[J[SUo*KcDGF{J[SUoL�¾d K,D�VLN,x$V8Hbo*nGNMF!XZnG`KcJ�J[`^NRVLHGWzH�JLKEVL`p`�JLX�KcD�FOx D�Vhg[FjoLF{KE��FOF{HzF!�BTG`pJ[]pKMFOW$XZJ[SvKcD�FjT�VLS�Kc]pyOnG`^VLSvyhVLNUF�JLX È~yhVAKcFOeLJ[SM]pFON�V8HGWz]pKMNVLTGTG`p]^yhVAKc]^JLHGN�]^H�DGJLx�JLKMJ[Tfo$KMDGFOJ[S�o[�

���E���\�>�\��� � JLx�FkVLnBKcDGJ[SUN�nGNMFkKcDGF³KMFOSUx NM]px�TG`p]^y{]lVL`wyhVAKcFOeLJ[SUo4XZJLSzPwD�V8K�P�FkD�VhgLFYKMFOSMxIFOW VNM]^xITG`p]^yO]^VL`^`½o¾FOH�SM]^y.D�FOW\yhV8KMFOe[J[S�o[�-CEDGF{SMF¼]^NwV¾yO`pJ[NMFQ`p]^HGa�Pw]pKMD�KcDGFQHGJ8Kc]^JLH�JLXNU]^xITG`^]pyO]^VL`�yhV8KMFOe[J[S�o$KMD�V8K]^N_yOJ[HGNU]^N�KcFOHfKRPw]pKcDInGNMVLe[Fj]pH�NU]^xITG`^]pyO]^VL`�KMDGFOJLSUo¾å�Ü!ÚwÛ?Ü!ubNU]^HGy{FjVLHfoINM]px�T�`^]^y{]lVL`p`po,F{HGSM]py.DGFOWzyOV8KcF{e[J[S�o�yhVLH�6F¼KcDGJ[n�e[DfK�JLXvV8N�V�NU]^xITG`^]pyO]^VL`>J[�(xUFOy{K�]^H�KcDGFIÔëyOV8KcF{e[J[SUo\JLX�yhV8KMFOe[J[SU]^F{NOÀ½u6�GnBKQV$NU]^xITG`^]pyO]lV8`^`po�F{HGSM]py.DGFOWyhV8KMFOe[J[S�o�]^N_HGJLKtxUnGN�K�V,NM]px�TG`p]^y{]lVL`BJ[��xUFOy!K�]pHIKMDGF,ÔëyOV8KcF{e[J[SUo�J8X�yhVAKcFOeLJ[SM]pFONOÀ�VLH�W�HGJ8K�VL`p`�NMnGy.D$NM]^xITG`p]^yO]^VL`J[��xUFOy!KcN�yOJ[SUSMFONUT6JLHGW KMJYNUnGy.D4F{HGSM]py.DGFOW�yhV8KMFOe[JLSM]^F{NO��CED�V8KI��FO]^H�eYNMVL]^W�KcDGV8KInGNcVLeLF\H�FOFOW HGJLKIyhV8nGNMFTGSMJ[��`^FOxIN¿T�SMJ?g�]^WGF{W'KcDGF$SMFhV8WGFOS&]^N�VhP�VLSMF$JLX�KcD�FznGNcV8e[F$]pH'KcDGF�T�VLT�FOS¼KcJ*PwDG]py.DrSMF!XZFOSMF{HGyOF$]^N¿��FO]pHGex$VLW�FL�

 ~¡ �ù:"�õçö�ûÉZ]àÌ u�KcDGF,yhVAKcFOeLJ[SUo�J8XNU]^xITG`^]pyO]lV8`�NUF{KMNK¢DGFOSUF

É;£¤}�¥_̧¦0¢©¨«ªwÉ�� L ���¬£¤}�¥_Ì!Æ

��J[x�T�J[NU]pKc]pJ[H¬¢�XZJ[S®­¬¯ É;£¤}�¥_Ìa¦BuZ°±¯ É6¥�}�²ÃÌa¦�u�NMJ³­¬¢�� L ���¤£´� ¥EuZ°³¢

�� L ���¬¥�� ²Îu

°pµ�­¤¢¶¨ É�� L ���¬£¸·§¹�ºT»K¼�½�'�

�� L ���

�� L ���¬£¿¾XÀ ¦�Á ¼�Â���

�� L ���¬¥Ã»� ²ÃÌ!Æ

d~WGFOHfKc]½K~oÄ¢ÆÅeÇ ½ ¢���s8����£ ÈÉ� £|u

ÉZ]^]àÌ�Ê�Ë�Ì�uGÔÁKMDGFLÀfyOV8KcF{e[J[SUo�JLX>NUT�VLy{FONjÉçJLX�yOJLnGSMNUFLubKcDGF{SMF�VLSMFwHbnGxIFOSUJ[nGN-g8VLSM]^VLHfKcN��GnBK_oLJ[nIyhVLH�VL`^xIJ[N�KTG]^y.a$PwD�]^y.DGF!g[FOS�J[HGFQo[JLn�`p]^aLF,V8N�`pJ[HGe�VLNEKMDGF,yOJ[HGN�KcSUnGy{KM]^J[HGNEPRJ[SMaBÌ�¢

Ê�Ë�Ì�É=Í�}�Î�̧¦0¢©¨!Ï~Ë�Ì�É� ¦ ��ͤ}�οÌ

��J[x�T�J[NU]pKc]pJ[H�VLHGW�]pWGFOHfKc]½Kc]pFONwVLSUF¼W�F���HGF{W³VLHGVL`^J[eLJ[nGNM`½o�KcJI]^H�Éç]lÌ!�ÉZ]^]^]lÌ�ü�J[S-FOVLy.D0Íru(ÎЯ¬ÑÓÒ�Ô�ufKcD�FEyhV8KMFOe[J[S�o¾JLX6NMx�VL`^`ByhV8KMFOe[JLSM]^F{NOu[KMDGFOH�P�FwNU]^xI]^`lV8SM`po,eLF{KDÕ\Ò�Ô{É>ͤ}�ξÌ�u

Õ\Ò�Ô{É>ͤ}�ξ̧¦Ó¨HÑÖÒ�ÔhÉU� L �\��ͤ}2Î�Ì�×t

Page 4: d¾PRJ[nG`^W `^]^a8F KMJ|KcDVLH a i FO]^H FOS ...hopf.math.purdue.edu/Porter/s-catsv2.pdfGKUKcFOWYKcJ[eLF{KcD FOS,NMJ KcDVAK&d KcDG]pHGa d_ FOeL]^H KMJ nGHGW FOSMN K.VLH WzKcDGFjP

�'F,`^FOVhg[F,KcDGF,JLKMDGFOSEN�KcSMn�y{Kcn�SMF¼nGT\KMJ¾KcDGF,SMFOVLWGF{SO�ÉZ]pg�Ì�Õ�Ø*Ù[u>KcD�F¾yhV8KMFOe[J[S�o³JLXRyOSUJ[NMNUFOWYyOJ[xITG`pF!�BFON�¢�NMF{F\�ÁqL�A��XZJ[S���V8y.a�eLSMJ[nGH�W�V8HGWkJLKcDGF{SQSMF!XZFOSMF{HGyOF{NOu

VLHGW\C�J[H�a�N{u��Ú�ftA��XZJ[SwV�x�J[SUF�WGF!K.VL]p`^FOW�KMSMFhVAKcxIFOHfKwJLXKMDGF,NM]px�TG`p]^y{]lVL`p`po�F{HGSM]py.DGFOW�yhV8KMFOe[JLSUo�N�KcSMn�y{Kcn�SMFLÆÕ�Ø*ÙbÉ6ÛÓ}�ܾÌ�¢©¨ÝÑÖØ*ÙbÉ=Þ_É L Ì�ßdÑà}�á�Ì

��J[x�T�J[NU]pKc]pJ[H�D�VLNEKMJI��F,WGF��GHGFOW�nGNM]pHGeIVLH\VLTGTGSUJ?�B]px$V8KM]^J[HzKMJ¾KcDGF,]^W�FOHfKc]½K~o[u�VLe[VL]^H�NMF{F��Ú�ftA�ã�ÉàgGÌ�Õ�âäã½ u�KcDGF&yhV8KMFOe[JLSUo\JLX-T�J[NM]½Kc]½g[F¼y.D�VL]^H�yOJ[xITG`pF!�BFON�JLX-xIJBWGn�`^FON�J?g[F{S�V$y{J[x�x¿n�K.V8KM]pgLF¼SU]^HGe³£|�É2Ñ�F{KcVL]^`pNEVLSUF¼`pF{XàK�KMJIKMDGF,SMFOVLWGFOS{u�J[S�XZJ[`p`^J?P�XZSMJ[x KcDGF¼Ñ�J[`pWBÈÒ�,VLHzKMDGFOJ[SUFOx�V8HGW�F���VLx�T�`^FIÉZg�]lÌ��6F{`^J?P,� ÌÉàgB]lÌ Éo²åË�Ç ½ Ì!u�KMDGFzyOV8KcF{e[J[SUo�JLXwNU]^xITG`^]pyO]lV8`Æ£�È~xIJBW�nG`^F{NO�³CEDGF�N�KcSUnGy{KMnGSMFzn�NMFON¾KMFOHGNUJ[S�TGSUJBWGn�y{KPw]pKcD�KcD�F,XZSUFOF¼NM]px�TG`p]^y{]lVL`'£�È~xIJ�WGnG`^FQJLH

�� L ��KcJIWGF���HGF,KcDGF¾ÔÁDGJ[x\À�VLHGW�KcDGF,yOJLx�T�J[NM]½Kc]pJ[H�u�NUJ�]pNEg[FOS�o

x�nGy.D*`p]^a8F�Éç]lÌ!�d~Hre[F{HGFOSMVL`EVLHfo'yhV8KMFOe[J[S�o'J8X�NU]^xITG`^]pyO]^VL`�J[��xUF{y{KMNI]pHrV'ÔÁHG]^y{FzFOHGJLnGe[D�À�yOV8KcF{e[J[S�o'D�V8N�V³NM]^xITG`p]^yO]^VL`

FOHGSU]^y.DGxIFOHfKhu�VL`pKMDGJ[nGe[D\KcDGF¿e[FOHGF{ScVL`�VLSUe[nGxIFOHfKjKMD�V8K�eL]pg[F{NjKcD�F�yOJ[H�NUKcSUnGy{KM]^J[H*WGJBF{N�HGJLK�VL`pP�Vho�N�x$V8aLFKcDGF,NUKMSMnGy!KcnGSUF¿V8NwKMScVLH�NMT�VLSUFOHfKjVLNE]pKwxI]^e[DfKE��FL�

CEDGF{SMFR]^N�VLH�F{g�]pWGFOHfK�H�JLKc]pJ[H&J8X È FOHGSU]^y.DGF{W¿XZnGHGy!KcJ[S{u[NMJ�P�F�e[F{KV�yOV8KcF{e[J[SUo¼JLX>ÔëNUx$VL`p`ãÀ È~yOV8KcF{e[J[SU]^FON{uWGFOHGJ8KcFOW �0ÑÓÒ�Ô��0æjX_yOJLnGSMNUFLu�HGJ[HGF¾J8X_KMDGF�VL��J?g[F¾F!��VLxITG`pFON,VLSUFzÔëNUx$VL`p`ãÀ½�IÉZ��]½KcD#SMF{efVLSUWkKMJ³ÔëNUx$V8`^`½ÈHGFONUNOÀ½uwVL`pKMDGJ[nGe[D�NUJ[x�F!Kc]px�F{N�VYNUx$VL`p`^HGF{NMN¾y{J[HGWG]½Kc]^JLH�]pN¾FONUNMFOHfKM]lVL`2u�J[HGF\yhV8H JLXàKMFOH�]^e[H�J[SMF��bnGF{NUKc]pJ[HGNJLX�NUx$V8`^`^H�FONMN�VLHGW�u�XZJ[SQ]pHGNUKcVLHGy{FLu:yOJLHGNM]pWGFOS,NM]px�T�`^]^y{]lVL`�ÔÁNMF!KcN{À�PwD�FOSMFIVLy!Kcn�V8`^`po�KMDGF�yOJ[`p`^FOy!Kc]pJ[HGNjJ8X�NU]^x¾ÈTG`^]pyOFON�VLSMF�HGJLKRKcSMn�`po�ÔëNUF{KMNOÀ:ÉZWGFOT�FOH�WG]^HGe¿J[H$o[JLnGS�y.DGJ[]pyOF�JLX�x�F!KcDGJ�WGN_XZJ[SRDGVLHGWG`p]^HGe&NMnGy.DzXZJ[n�HGW�V8KM]^J[H�V8`��n�FONUKM]^J[H�N.Ì!�ëÌQSReç èp_ä]Sh bZ`Thji�kT`al\`TV�k³_äY\bé]qkTê�Wä`a]SëpbMWZ]Ðì�r?l�VXWZb$RCEDGF�XZJ[SMe[F!KMXZnG`_XZnGHGy!KcJ[S³íî¢�ÑÖÒ�Ô0� á³ïÖØ�Ì'âZð�D�VLN�V³`^F!XàK�VLW�xUJL]^HfKhu�ñ��'i�FOSUFòá±ïÖØ�Ì'âZð�WGFOH�JLKcF{N�KMDGFyhV8KMFOe[J[S�o$J8X:WG]^SUFOy!KcFOW$e[ScVLT�DGN�Pw]pKMD�ÔÁ]^WGF{HfKc]pK~oI`pJBJ[T�NOÀ½uBNUJwí XZJ[SMe[F!KcN�xUnGNUKRKcDGF�y{J[xIT6J[NU]pKM]^J[H¾Pw]pKMDG]^H�FhVLy.DNMx�VL`^`�yhVAKcFOeLJ[SUo��Gn�KESUFOxIFOx���FOSUNRKMD�V8KEy{FOSUKcVL]^H�`^J�J[TGN�VLSMF�NMT�FOyO]^VL`�ÔÁ]^W�FOHfKc]½K~o�`pJBJLTGNOÀ½��CEDGFjXZSUFOF�yOV8KcF{e[J[S�oXZnGHGy{KMJ[S_DGFOSUF�KcVLaLF{NOu���F{K~PRFOF{H�VLHfo¾K~P�J&J[��xUF{y{KcN{uGVL`p`GNUKMSM]pHGe[N_JLX�y{J[x�T�J[NMVL�G`^F��>Ù�� � Þ6��Ü���ÝçÞàÝ6�¾VLSMSUJ?PwN_KMD�V8KNUK.V8SUK�V8K�KMDGFp��SUNUKEJ[�(xUFOy{K�V8HGW�FOHGW\V8K�KMDGFQNMF{yOJ[H�W��SæQH�FQyhVLHzKMDG]^HGa�JLX�ñÎ]pWGFOHfKM]pXào�]^HGe&KcDGFQJ[`pWz]^W�FOHfKc]½K~oVLSMSUJñPÃV8K�VLH\J[��xUF{y{K�y*Pw]½KcD�KcDGF,F{x�T�K~ozNUKcSU]^HGeIV8K�y��

CEDG]pNvVLW�xUJ[]pHfK-T�VL]pS�e[]pgLFON_V�yOJLx�J[HGVLW�J[HGÑÓÒ�Ô�]^H�KcD�F�n�NMn�VL`GP�Vho[u�VLHGW�DGF{HGyOF�VjXZnGHGy!KcJ[SU]lVL`�NM]^xITG`p]^yO]^VL`SMFONUJ[`^nBKc]^JLH�u�PwDG]^y.D*PRF&Pw]p`^`:WGF{HGJLKMF�ªwÉ=óRÌ�� ó��,d~H³xIJ[SMF,WGF!K.VL]p`ãuGPRF¿PwSM]½KcFàÏ«¨ôñõí XZJ[SEKcDGF¼XZnGHGy{KMJ[ST�VLSUK�JLX�KcDGF,yOJLx�J[HGVLW�uGKcD�F&nGH�]pK�JLXKMDGF&VLW�xUnGHGy!Kc]pJ[Hnö÷¢(ø�Ç(ù�úAû>ü�ý�þ�� ípñìe[]½g[F{N�KMDGF&y{J[x�nG`½Kc]pTG`^]pyhV8KM]^J[HñÖöäíÿ¢�Ï ��Ï � VLHGWzKcD�F�yOJ[n�HG]pKEJ8X�KMDGFQVLW7xUnGy{KM]^J[HzeL]pg[F{N��õ¢(ñõíH��øéÇ�� º�� uBKMD�V8KE]pNOu��õ¢*ÏÝ��øéÇ��vÇ�JñPXZJ[S~óìVzNUx$V8`^`�yhV8KMFOe[JLSUo[u:NUF{KÓªwÉ=óŖ¦¬¨ÿÏ ¦ ã É=ó�Ì&Pw]½KcD³XçVLy{F�x$V8TGN�Ç ¹ ¢�Ï

¦ ã É=ó�ÌÖ� Ï ¦ É>ó�Ì¿e[]pgLFOH#�foÇ ¹ ¨ÝÏ

¦ � ¹ �7Ï ¹ ubVLH�W�NU]^xI]^`lV8SM`poQXZJLSKcDGFwWGF{e[FOH�FOScV8yO]^F{N_PwD�]^y.DInGNMFEKcD�F�y{J[x�nG`½Kc]pTG`^]pyhV8KM]^J[H¼]^HIVLHIVLH�V8`^J[e[JLnGNXZJ[SMx�n�`lV���É2Ç�JLKcFQKMD�V8KwKcDGF{SMF¼VLSUF,K~PRJ$y{J[Hfg[F{HbKM]^J[H�NjT�J[NMNU]^�G`pFQDGFOSUFL��CED�F&JLKMDGFOSEPw]p`^`�nGNUF�Ç ¹ ¨ÝÏ ¹ �7Ϧ � ¹ �CEDGFQJ[HG`½o�F!ê>F{y{KEJ8X�NMnGy.D�V¿y.DGVLHGe[FQ]pNRKcJ¿SMF{gLFOSUNMF�KcD�F�WG]^SUFOy!Kc]^JLH$JLX�y{FOSUKcVL]^H�Ô VLSUSMJ?PwNOÀB]^H�WG]lVLeLScVLxINR`^V8KcF{S

J[H��vCEDGFQK~P�J�NM]px�TG`p]^y{]lVL`�NUKMSMnGy!KcnGSUFON�VLSMF¾ÔÁWGn�VL`2À�KcJ�FOVLy.D�J8KcDGF{SO�ëÌCEDG]pNpªwÉ>ó�Ì,]^N�V$NM]px�T�`^]^y{]lVL`6J[��xUF{y{K�]pH¤ÑÖÒ�Ô�utªwÉ=ó�ÌÓ¢ ��� ü � ÑÖÒ<Ô�u�NMJ$WGJBF{NjHGJ8Kj]px�xIFOWG]^V8KcF{`po$e[]pgLFON

nGNQV�NU]^xITG`^]pyO]^VL`^`½o�FOHGSU]^y.DGF{W#yhV8KMFOe[J[S�o[u�DGJ?P�F!g[F{SQ]pKcN�NM]px�T�`^]^y{]lVL`6NMF!K�JLX-JL��xUFOy!KcNj]pN�y{J[HGN�K.VLHfKQ��FOyOVLnGNMFGíVLHGWnñÎKcJ�J[azHGJ8KcFQJLX�KcDGF,]pWGFOHfKc]½K~o�`^J�J[TGN{�

d~H�x�J[SUF�W�F{K.V8]^`ãu�`^F!KÓË��÷¢�ÑÓÒ�ÔÓ� ª��KÔ�Ù$��F�KMDGF�XZnGH�y{KcJLS¼KMD�V8K�T�]^y.abN¿J[nBK&KMDGF$NUF{K�J8XEJ[��xUF{y{KcN¿JLXEVNMx�VL`^`�yhV8KMFOe[JLSUo[u6KcDGF{HÄË��AÉoªwÉ>ó�ÌUÌG¢���� ü � ª��KÔ�Ù¾]^N�V$yOJ[H�NUK.V8HbKQXZn�HGy{KMJ[SjPw]pKMD*g8VL`^n�F¿KcDGF¿NMF{KÖË��AÉ=ó�Ì¿JLX

Page 5: d¾PRJ[nG`^W `^]^a8F KMJ|KcDVLH a i FO]^H FOS ...hopf.math.purdue.edu/Porter/s-catsv2.pdfGKUKcFOWYKcJ[eLF{KcD FOS,NMJ KcDVAK&d KcDG]pHGa d_ FOeL]^H KMJ nGHGW FOSMN K.VLH WzKcDGFjP

J[��xUFOy!KcNEJLX\ó���þ�J[SUFQF!��VLy!Kc`po�]pKR]^N�V¿WG]^NUyOSUF{KcFjNM]^xITG`p]^yO]^VL`�NMF!KhuBNM]^H�yOF,VL`p`�]½KcN_XçVLyOFQV8HGW�WGFOeLFOHGF{ScVLy!ozx�VLTGNVLSMF&�G]ÚxUF{y{Kc]pJ[HGN{��}�NM]pHGe�KMDGJ[NMF&�G]ÚxUF{y{KM]^J[HGNwKcJ�]^WGF{HfKc]pXào�KMDGF¿T�J[NUNM]^��`^F¼WG]pê6FOSUFOHfK�NUF{KcNjJLX-J[��xUF{y{KMNOu6o�]pFO`^W�NjVyOJ[HGN�K.VLHfK&NM]px�TG`p]^y{]lVL`�NMF!K,PwDGFOSUF$VL`p`KcD�F�XçV8yOFIVLHGWkWGF{e[FOHGF{ScVLy!oYx$VLT�N,VLSMF¾]pWGFOHfKc]½K~o#x�VLTGNOu�]2�ÁF8��P�F�WGJD�Vhg[F&V¬�.Ù���Û!Ýãá*��Ý�NU]^xITG`^]pyO]lV8`�NUF{KO�4_ö�ù|ù: ��Ü!Ý�� ¢���� ü � ÑÖÒ�Ô��!Ü$á\Û!Þ>�jå�æÕÞo�!ÞçáLæRÙ�� �hÜ��!ÝwÞ>�ÄÑÓÒ�Ô¾Û"!ä���YÝ=��áLÝSË��AÉ#�EÌ�Þ^Û$á �.Ù���Û!Ýãá*��ÝwÛ!Þ>�jå�æÕÞo�!ÞçáLæ�Û?Ü!Ý$ ÞàÝ=�\ßAáLæ%!�Ü�Ü~ð'&-ÛOá*��(*)�ÙAÚ¿ÜMá����¿å�áLÞàÚ¼É=y\}2z�Ìq¯¬Ü~ð+&_æ^Ü!Ý

�QÉ>y\}2z�Ìa¦Ö¨-,/.į0�D¦1�W�J[x�É2.�Ì�¨ y\}MyOJ�WGJ[x*É2.�ÌƨHz43(}$ ��Ü!Ú.Ü5&�Ù�6õ�.Ù�!BÚcÛ?Ü5&�WGJLx�ÚcÜ#6hÜ!ÚcÛ¼Ý~ÙIÝ=��Ü���Ù��IáLÞ>�768!é�$�!ÝçÞãÙ��#Þ>�9�D¦�Û!Þ>�$�.ܾÙAÝ=��Ü!Ú $ Þ^Û?ÜwWGJLx*É#.�Ì $ Ù�!�æ �0��áLßLÜ�>ÙG�$ÜMá*��Þ>��â�&Û!Þ>�¾Þàæ½áLÚ�æ��*6hÙAÚEy{JBW�J[x0(: Þ<;'ät��Üw�.ÙAæàæ^Ü��!ÝçÞãÙ��=,/��É=y\}2z�Ìa¦41 L ¯?>@3:��áAÛ�Ý=��Ü�Û!ÝçÚ8!��!Ý2!�Ú.Ü$Ù�6�á�Û!Þ>�jå�æÕÞo�!ÞçáLæ:Û?Ü!Ý��QÉ>y\}2zGÌ $ ÞàÝ>�A6{á��.Üá*�'�÷��Üãâ�Ü��>Ü!ÚMá��!ÞãÜ.Û�Þ>�'��!��.Ü��B6�Ú.Ù��ÓÝ=��Ù?Û?ܾÙ�6B�C(: ÞàÞ<;#ät��Ü��.Ù��jå�Ù?Û!ÞàÝ2ÞãÙ��³Þ>�YÜMá����\æ^Ü!ßLÜ!æ�Ù�6@� Þ>�'��!ä�.Ü.Û

�QÉ>y\}2z�Ì��D�QÉ=z�}�{[Ì^�E�QÉ>y\}�{fÌ�×F Þ>�¾Þàæ½áLÚ!æ��IÝ>��ܼÞ6��Ü���Ý2ÞàÝ6�w�Iá!å#Þ>�9�QÉ>y\}�y6Ì&Þ^Û���Ü#G��>Ü��záAÛ�ÅoÇIH�&_Ý=��ܼÞ6��Ü���ÝçÞàÝ6�záLÝ\y�Þ>�#Ý=��Ü��MáLÝ~Üãâ�ÙAÚ��J�Æð�(: ÞàÞàÞ<;#ät��ÜQÚ.Ü.Û"!�æÕÝçÞ>��âIÛ!Ý2Ú8!ä�!Ý !�ÚcÜ¿Þ^Û¿á*� ~� Ü���Ú�Þo����Ü��3�MáLÝ~Üãâ�ÙAÚ��K&vÝ>��áLÝ $ Þàæàæ�áLæëÛ?ÙL�!Ü���Ü��>ÙAÝÒÜ��M�C( N

CEDGFITGSUJBJLXR]^NQFOVLNUoL��d~HYT�VLS�Kc]pyOnG`^VLSOu�KMDG]^N,NMD�JñPwN,KcDGV8K�ª�É>óRÌ�]pN,V\NU]^xITG`^]pyO]^VL`^`½o�FOHGSU]^y.DGF{W'yOV8KcF{e[J[SUoL�CEDGF*WGF{NMy{SM]^TBKc]^JLH�J8XjKcD�F�NU]^xITG`^]pyOFON¿]^H�FhVLy.D WG]^xIFOHGNU]^J[H�JLX�ªwÉ=óRÌzKcD�V8KIN�K.VLS�KzV8KGÒrV8HGW F{HGW4VAKO�z]pN]^HfKcnG]½Kc]½g[FO`½ok�bnG]pKMFzNM]px�TG`pFL��CEDGF�VLSUSMJ?PwN¾]^HYKcDGFzyOV8KcF{e[J[S�o[uDÏ¿É=ó�Ì�y{J[SMSUFONMT�J[HGWrKMJ³NUKMSM]^H�e[N¿JLXwN�o�x��6JL`^NSMFOT�SMFONUFOHfKc]pHGe¾HGJ[H�È~]^W�FOHfKc]½K~oIVLSMSUJñPwN�]^Hwó ]½KcNMF{`pXÒubKcDGJLNMFjN�KcSU]^HGe[NR�6F{]^HGeIÔëy{J[xIT6J[NMVL�G`pFLÀb]^H�VLN�x¿nGy.D�VLNRKMDGFWGJ[x�VL]^H\JLXKMDGF�Å � ý VLSUSMJ?PÅx�nGN�Kj��F&KMDGF¼yOJ�WGJ[x�VL]^H�JLX�KMDGF$É6Å��<èñÌ � ý JLHGF¿V8HGW*NUJzJ[H��EÏRFOyhV8nGNMF�J8XKcD�]^NP�F¼D�Vhg[F?¢ª�É>ó�ÌTð¿y{J[HGNU]^NUKMNwF!��VLy{KM`po�J8XNUnGy.D*y{J[x�T�J[NMVL�G`^FQy.DGVL]^HGNwJLX�x�VLTGNE]^H÷ó�u�HGJ[HGF,JLX�PwDG]py.D�]pN�KcDGF,]^W�FOHfKc]½K~o6ƪ�É>ó�Ì yOJ[HGNU]^N�KcNwJLX�NMnGy.D\yOJLx�T�J[NcV8�G`^F�y.DGVL]^HGNEJ8X�x�VLTGNE]pH±ó�u:HGJ[HGFQJLX�PwDG]py.D�]pN�KcD�FQ]^WGF{HbKM]pK~oLu�KcJ[eLF{KcD�FOSPw]pKcD�V¾y.DGJ[]pyOF,JLX��GScVLy.a8F{KUKc]^H�eGƪ�É>ó�Ì � yOJ[HGNU]^N�KcNwJLX�NMnGy.D\yOJLx�T�J[NcV8�G`^F�y.DGVL]^HGNEJ8X�x�VLTGNE]pH±ó�u:HGJ[HGFQJLX�PwDG]py.D�]pN�KcD�FQ]^WGF{HbKM]pK~oLu�KcJ[eLF{KcD�FOSPw]pKcD�V¾y.DGJ[]pyOF,JLX�K~P�JI`^F!g[FO`pNwJLX��ScVLy.a8F{KMKM]^HGe�ÆVLHGW�NMJ�J[H��vü�VLy{FQVLHGW�W�FOe[F{HGFOSMVLy{o�x�VLTGN�SUFOxIJ?g[FQJ[S�]pHGNMF{SUKE��ScVLy.a8F{KcN{u��Gn�KwyhV8SMF�x�n�NUKw��F�K.VLa8FOH�PwDGFOHSMFOxIJ?g�]^HGe¾]pHGHGFOSUx�JLNUK���ScVLy.a8F{KcN�VLN�KMDGFQyOJLx�T�J[NM]½Kc]pJ[HGNRKMD�V8KEyOVLHzKcD�FOH�K.VLa8FQTG`lV8yOF�yOVLH�SMFONUnG`pK�]^H�y.D�VL]pHGNPw]pKcDk]pWGFOHfKc]½Kc]pFON�PwDG]py.DkKMDGFOHYHGF{FOW'SUFOxIJ?gB]pHGeGu�NUFOF*�-�A�ãu�KMD�V8K,]^N�PwDfo³KMDGF�yOJ[x�VLHGW�]^y�WGF{NMy{SM]^TBKc]^JLHY]pNQNMJx�nGy.D*NU]^xITG`^F{SOu�VLNE]pKwx�VLH�VLeLFONwVL`p`>KcD�VAKw]pKcNUFO`½XÒ�

C�J�n�HGWGFOSUNUKcVLHGW5ªwÉ=ó�̾]^HYe[FOH�FOScV8`_]½K¼T�VhoBN,KcJ�F!��VLxI]^HGF¾KMDGF�NU]^xITG`^F{NUKQXZF!PìyhVLNUFON{��CEDGF$a8F{oYyhVLNUFONVLSMF�PwDGF{H ós¨�� L �2u�KcDGF¾JLSMWG]pH�VL`�,AsQPÐ×9×9×�P L 3�yOJLHGNM]pWGFOSUFOWYVLN,VzyhVAKcFOeLJ[SUo*]^H³KcD�F¾nGNMn�V8`P�VhoL�¿CEDGFyhVLNUFON L ¨¨s#VLH�W L ¨ è�e[]pgLFzHGJ#NUnGSMTGSU]^NUFONO�:ªw��sA��D�VLN¿J[HGF�J[��xUF{y{K�s#V8HGW ªw��s8� É2sé}.s*]^N¿]^NMJLx�J[SUTGDG]pyKcJ���sA�ãu:V8NjKcDGF¿J[HG`po\NU]^xITG`^]pyOFON�VLSUF�WGFOeLFOHGF{ScV8KMF¾yOJ[TG]pFON�J8X-KcDGF�]pWGFOHfKM]pK~o[�Öªw�ÕèO��`p]^a8F{Pw]^NUF¿D�V8NQV$KcSU]pg�]lVL`

NM]^xITG`p]^yO]^VL`vNUKMSMnGy!KcnGSUFLu_�6F{]^HGewxUnGN�K¾KcDGF�yOV8KcF{e[J[S�o��ÕèO��y{J[HGNM]pWGFOSUFOW VLN¾VLH È~yOV8KcF{e[J[SUoL�'CEDG]pHGe[N¾WGJ#eLF{Kx�J[SUF�]pHfKcFOSUFON�Kc]^H�erV8K L ¨ qB� CED�F*aLF!o4DGF{SMF�]^N�KcDGF�]^WGF{HbKM] ��yOV8Kc]pJ[H�JLXÖªw�Áqñ�~ÉçsA}�q[Ì�� CED�FOSMF³VLSMF�K~P�JHGJ[HBÈ WGFOe[F{HGFOSMV8KcF,N�KcSM]pHGe[NEJ[SETGV8KcDGN�KMD�V8Kw`pFhVLWzXZSUJ[x s�KcJIq�uGNMJwªw�Áqñ�~ÉçsA}�q[Ì_Pw]p`^`6D�Vhg[FQK~P�J�g[F{SUKM]^yOF{NO�vCEDGF�GScVLy.a8F{KUKcFOW�N�KcSM]pHGe�ÉUÉ2s�èñÌ{É�èñqLÌMÌ�J[HzSUFOxIJñg�]pHGe¿]pHGHGFOS_�GSMVLy.aLF!KcNEe[]½g[FONQÉ2sfq[ÌvVLHGW$J[n�KcF{S��GSMVLy.aLF!KcN{u�É2s�è?ÌOÉ�è?q[ÌNMJISMFOT�SMFONUFOHfKcNjV\è!È~NM]px�T�`^F!�

Éçs�èñÌ{É�èñq[Ì�R ð S R � STS // Éçsfq[Ì×

Page 6: d¾PRJ[nG`^W `^]^a8F KMJ|KcDVLH a i FO]^H FOS ...hopf.math.purdue.edu/Porter/s-catsv2.pdfGKUKcFOWYKcJ[eLF{KcD FOS,NMJ KcDVAK&d KcDG]pHGa d_ FOeL]^H KMJ nGHGW FOSMN K.VLH WzKcDGFjP

æ�KMDGFOSRNM]px�TG`p]^y{]lVL`BDGJ[xIN�VLSUFjVL`p`��Ös8�6J[S_FOxIT�K~o[�-d K_KcDbnGN�]pNRT�J[NUNM]^��`^FwKcJ&g�]pNMn�VL`p]^NUFpªw��qA�6VLN�V¼yOJ[Tfo�JLX_��qA�

Pw]pKcD�VIqñÈ~y{FO`p`�e[J[]pHGe�KcJ?P�VLSMWGNEKMDGF,�6JLKUKcJ[x3¢è

��===

====

s //

U@@������� q

CEDGFwHGF!��KvyhV8NMF L ¨Ât�]pNF{gLFOHIx�JLSMF�]pHbKMFOSUFONUKM]^HGe��ƪw��tA�~É=Å�}WV�Ì�Pw]p`^`��6FQÉç]àÌ�FOxIT�K~o�]½XXVOP�ÅUu�Éç]p]àÌ:]^NMJLx�J[SUTGDG]pyKcJ��Ös8��]pXXÅD¨YV$JLS®ÅD¨ZV��<è[u�Éç]p]^]lÌ_]^NUJ[xIJ[SMTGD�]^y�KcJ � � è{���fo�KcD�F¼NMVLxIF&SUFhVLNUJ[HG]^H�e$VLNwPRF xUnGN�KjNMVhPÅXZJ[SV�¨HÅ�[�q¾VLH�W\KMD�V8Kw`^FOVhg[FON~ªw��tA�~ÉçsA}.tfÌ���CEDG]^Nw]pNwV�NU�bn�VLSMF8u � �ÕèO� � u�VLN�XZJ[`p`^J?PwNK¢

É2sfq[Ì{ÉãqLt[Ì RTR ð � S R �W\ S]S // Éçs[tfÌ

É2sBèñÌOÉÒèñq[ÌOÉ2qLtfÌRTR ð S R � S]S R]R �W\ STS º

OO

·§¹�ºT»99sssssssssssssssssss

R]R ð S]S RTR � S R �W\ STS // É2s�èñÌ{É�è?t[ÌRTR ð S R \ STS^OO

PwDGFOSUF$KcDGFIWG]^VLe[J[H�V8`ÆÇ<ÅeÒ�° ¨ ÉUÉ2s�èñÌ{É�èñqLÌOÉãq8tfÌMÌ�uEÒ¤¨ ÉMÉMÉçs�èñÌ{É�èñq[ÌUÌOÉUÉãqLtfÌUÌMÌjV8HGW_�0¨ ÉUÉMÉçs�èñÌMÌ{ÉMÉÒèñq[ÌOÉ2qLtfÌUÌMÌ!�Éçd K�]^Nw]^H�NUKcSUnGy{KM]pgLF,KMJ�y.D�FOy.a�KcD�VAKEKcDG]pN�]pNEyOJ[SUSMF{y{Khuä��SUNUKM`po���FOyOVLnGNMF¼d�x�Vho�D�Vhg[F¼NM`p]^TGT�FOW�nGT|É��ëÌIV8NwPRFO`p`VLNwNMFOF{]^HGe�KcD�F¼xIFOy.DGVLHG]^NUx ]^H\VLy!Kc]pJ[H��Æ�wFOxIJ?gB]pHGe¾KcDGF,]pHGHGFOSUx�JLNUKw�GSMVLy.aLF!KcN�]^N�Ç<ðhu�VLHGW\NMJ�J[H>� Ì

CEDGF�yOVLNMF�JLXqªw�Ú�8�-]^NjPRJ[S�KcDYWGJ[]^H�eG�&dwPw]^`p`HGJ8K,WGScVhP KcDGF�WG]^VLe[ScV8x�N�DGFOSUF�V8`pKcD�J[nGe[D#V8NMT�FOy{KMN&J8XR]½KD�Vhg[F$]px�T�`^]^yOV8Kc]pJ[HGN�`lV8KMFOS{u���n�K¼NMnGe[eLFONUK¼KcD�]^N¼VLN¼VLHYF!�BFOSUyO]^NUFL��ÊjN¼x�]pe[DfK,�6F�F!�BT�FOy!KcFOW ª�� �L� É2sA}��bÌj]^N,VyOnG��FL�

` ö�ù: A�AðCEDGFvDG]pNUKMJ[SUojJLXbKcDG]pN:yOJ[HGN�KcSUnGy{KM]^J[H,]^N:]pHfKcFOSUFON�Kc]^H�eG��Ê|gLV8SM]lV8HbK�JLX�]½Khu?�GnBK�Pw]½KcD�KMJ[T6JL`^J[e[]pyhVL`p`poEF{HGSM]py.DGFOW

yhV8KMFOe[J[SU]^F{N�VLN_KcDGF�FOH�WzSMF{NMnG`½Khu�]^Nv]^HIKcDGFwP�JLSMa�JLX�Ï�J[VLSMWGx�VLH�VLHGWIÐvJ[eLKhu6��qA�6VLHGW$VL`^NUJ¿]^H�ÐvJ[eLKOÀÁN_T�VLT�FOS{u�Ú���8�ã� � FOefVL`2ÀÁNjNUKcn�WGFOHfK¿��F{]pKMy.DYn�NMFOW�VzNM]px�]p`lVLS�yOJLHGNUKMSMnGy!Kc]^JLHkKMJ�WGFONUyOSU]^��F�V�DGJLx�JLKMJ[Tfo*y{J[xIx�n�K.VAKc]pgLFyOnG��F�É2VLy!Kcn�VL`p`po�Vn��Ù��$ÙAÝ~Ù.å'�¬�.Ù���Ü!ÚcÜ���Ý~�"!a�!ÜñÌ�u:y{XÒ�$�Áq8é8�ãu�V8HGW#KcDG]pNjP�V8NQnGNMF{W��fo � F{efVL`�]pH#DG]^N�XçVLx�JLnGNT�VLT�FOSOu��ÖtcbA�2uAn�HGWGFOS:KMDGF-H�VLxIF-JLX�KcDGF�ÔÁF!�BTG`pJ[NM]pJ[H�ÀhJLX�ó���Ê�`^`8KMDG]^N�P�VLN�NUKM]^`p`L]^H�KMDGF-KcJ[T�J[`pJ[e[]^yOVL`?XZScVLxIF{PRJ[SUaVLHGWkKcDGF�`^]pHGa�Pw]½KcD#KcD�FIy{J[xIJ[H�VLWkSMF{NMJ[`pn�Kc]pJ[H#P�V8N¼N�Kc]p`^`�HGJ8K,]^HkF{g�]^W�FOHGy{FL�IÊj`pKMDGJ[nGeLDY]½K,NMF{FOxIN¼`p]^a8FO`poKcD�V8Kj�,VLH*abHGF!P JLX�KMDG]^N�`^]pHGa$��F{K~PRFOF{HYD�J[x�J8KcJ[Tfo�y{J[DGFOSUFOHGy{F¾VLHGW\KcDGF&yOJ[xIJ[H�V8WG]^yQSUFONMJL`^n�KM]^J[HGN��fo\V8K`^FhV8NUK�è?é��Ls�u�Éçy{XÒ� �Õèñ×A�lÌ!u-KMDGF�yOJ[HGN�KcSUnGy{KM]^J[H�WGJ�FON�HGJLK�NUFOF{x KcJYVLTGT�FhVLS¾]pH�DG]^N�PRJ[SMa�Pw]pKcD�ÑjPEoLFOSIVLN�6F{]^HGe¾`p]^HGa8FOWzPw]pKMD�yOJ[D�FOSMF{HGyOF,nGHfKM]^`�x�n�y.D\`^V8KcF{SO�v��JLSMWG]pFOS�x�VLWGFjKMDGFQ`^]pHGa�F!�BTG`p]^yO]½K�]pHk�-�A��VLHGW�NUDGJ?P�F{WDGJ?PÃ�:FO]½Kcy.D�VLH�W � FOefVL`2ÀÁN_P�JLSMaw��KMKcF{W�]^H$KMJ�KcDGFQT�VAKMKcF{SMH��vi�]^N�xIJLKM]pg8V8Kc]pJ[H�P�VLN�XZJLSRKcD�FQWGFONUyOSM]pT�Kc]pJ[H�JLXDGJ[xIJLKcJ[Tfo#y{J[DGF{SMFOHfK&WG]lV8e[ScVLxINQJLX_KcJ[T�J[`pJ[e[]^yOVL`�NMT�VLy{FON{�òæjKcDGF{S,g8VLSU]lVLHfKMN,PRFOSUF$V8`^NMJ\VLT�T�VLSMF{HfK&]pHYKMDGFFhVLSU`po�P�JLSMa*J8X_þ*Vho³J[H*J[T6F{ScVLW�NOu�V8HGW#`^]pHGaLF{W³]^H\Pw]pKcD � K.VLNUDGF{ê�ÀÁN�PRJ[SMa\J[H³D�]^e[DGF{S�VLNUNMJ�yO]^V8Kc]½gB]½K~o\VLHGWyOJ[xIx�n�KcV8Kc]½gB]½K~o�ÔÁnGT�KcJ�DGJ[xIJLKMJ[Tfo6À½�

��J[SUWG]^F{S�VLHGW í�J[S�KcF{SOuQ�Öé8�2uRn�NMFOW�VLH VLH�VL`½oBNU]^N¾JLXjVk`^J�yhVL`p`po��,VLH�NM]^xITG`p]^yO]^VL`^`½o#FOH�SM]^y.D�FOW�yOV8KcF{e[J[S�o]^Hfg[J[`½g�]^HGe�KcDG]pNwyOJ[HGN�KcSUnGy{KM]^J[H\KcJ$T�SMJ?g[F¿V�e[F{HGFOSMVL`^]pNcV8KM]^J[H�JLXÐvJ[eLKhÀ�NEKcDGF{J[SMF{x�J[H*yOV8KcF{e[J[SM]pFONwJLX-D�J[x�JAÈKcJ[Tfo�yOJLDGFOSUFOHfKIWG]lVLeLScVLxIN�JLXjV#e[]pgLFOH�K~oBT�FL� Éà�'FzPw]p`^`�SUF{Kcn�SMH�KcJ#KcDG]pN�VLNMT�FOy!K�Vk��]pK�`lVAKcFOS¿]^HrKcDGF{NMFHGJLKcF{NOuG��n�KwVLHzF{`^F{x�F{HbKcVLSUo�]^HfKMSMJ�WGnGy{KM]^J[HIKcJ¿KMDG]^N_KcDGF{J[SUo�yhV8H��6FjXZJLnGHGWz]pHk�Áq8�8�ã�ëÌ�ü]pH�VL`^`½o�Ï�]p`^`�ÑjPEo[F{SOuÑQVLH��,VLHrVLHGW�mLn�NUKc]pH � xI]pKcD>uE�Õè?é8�2u-]^HfKcSUJBWGn�yOFOW�V�NM]^xI]^`^VLSQyOJLHGNUKMSMnGy!Kc]^JLH|XZJ[S�VLH�óÄPwDG]^y.Dr]pN�VLH ÈyhV8KMFOe[J[S�o�KcJ¼NUKcVLSUKvPw]½KcD�ubVLH�W�xIJLKc]½g8V8KcF{W¾]pK-�fo�NcVho�]^H�e¼KMD�V8K È XZnGHGy!KcJ[SUN_Pw]½KcD�WGJ[x�VL]pH�KcDG]pN È yhV8KMFOe[J[S�oyOJ[SUSMFONUT6JLHGWGFOW�KcJDd � ��Ù��$ÙAÝÒÙ.å'���.Ù����e!�Ý áLÝçÞàßLÜàó � �LÞçá?âLÚUá*�¿Û!uvoLF{K¼KcDGF!okWGJ\HGJLK,NMF{FOx KcJ\��F�VhP�VLSMFIJLX

Page 7: d¾PRJ[nG`^W `^]^a8F KMJ|KcDVLH a i FO]^H FOS ...hopf.math.purdue.edu/Porter/s-catsv2.pdfGKUKcFOWYKcJ[eLF{KcD FOS,NMJ KcDVAK&d KcDG]pHGa d_ FOeL]^H KMJ nGHGW FOSMN K.VLH WzKcDGFjP

KcDGF³D�]^NUKMJ[SUo�J8XQKcDGF�yOJ[HGN�KcSUnGy{KM]^J[H�uwV8HGW4WGJ�HGJLKzSUFhVL`p`po�xUnGN�Kc]½XàorKcDGF�yO`lV8]^x KcDGV8K$]½K$W�JBF{N�PwD�V8K�KcDGF!oNcVho[�\CEDGFO]pS&g�]^F!PwT6JL]^HfK¿]pN,DGJ?P�F!g[FOS¾]px�T�J[S�K.VLHfK&VLNOu���VLNU]^yhV8`^`poLu:Pw]pKcD�]^H�KMDGF$NUF{KUKc]^H�e*JLX®,�nG]p`^`pFOHkx�J�WGF{`yhV8KMFOe[J[S�o#NUKMSMnGy!KcnGSUFON{u�KMDG]^NQTGSUJ?gB]pWGFON¼V�yOJ?���GScV8HbK,SUFOTG`^VLyOF{x�F{HfK&y{J[HGN�KcSMn�y{Kc]pJ[H��0æjXRyOJ[n�SMNMF8u�VLHfo#JLKcD�FOSyOJ*����ScVLHfK¼SMF{TG`lVLy{FOxIFOHfK,yOJLnG`^Wk��F¾NMnG�GN�Kc]½Kcn�KMFOWkXZJ[SQ]pK,V8HGWkNMJ�P�JLnG`^WkNUKM]^`p`�VL`p`^J?P XZJ[SQV�WGFONUyOSU]^T�KM]^J[HkJLXDGJ[xIJLKcJ[Tfo�y{J[DGFOSUFOHfK�W�]lVLe[SMVLxINE]^H�KcD�V8K�y{J[HfKcF!��KO��CED�]^Nw]^xIT6JLSUK.V8HbKEg�]pF{PwT�J[]^HfK�yhVLH*VL`^NUJI��F,KcScV8yOFOW\KcJÿ,SUJLKcDGF{HGWG]pFOy.a�ÀÁNgf�!BÚcÛ"!�Þ>��â F Ý á��5h?Û!u:�Áq[qñ�ã�

CEDGF\ÑQ� � F!��KcF{HGNM]pJ[H J8XjKcD�F\y{J[HGN�KcSMn�y{Kc]pJ[H�uj� èhé8�ãuRVL`½KcDGJ[n�e[D�NM]^xITG`pF$KcJYWGJGu_]^N¾JLXàKMFOH�nGNMF!XZnG`�VLHGWNMJ'Pw]p`^`E��F�J[nBKc`^]pHGFOW�HGF��BKO��d X�ó¨]pNIVL`^SUFhVLW�o�V È yhV8KMFOe[JLSUo[u�KMDG]^H�arJLXQ]pK�VLN�V�NU]^xITG`^]pyO]^VL`�yOV8KcF{e[J[SUoLuKcDGF{H V8TGTG`po�]pHGe�KMDGF È~yOJLHGNUKMSMnGy!Kc]^JLH|KcJ³FOVLy.D�ó�¦|Pw]^`p`_eL]pg[FzV*�G]^NU]^xITG`^]pyO]^VL`yOV8KcF{e[J[SUoLu-]ã��FL�#V\XZnGHGy{KMJ[Sª�É>ó�Ì:¢�� � ü �i� � ü � ÑÖÒ<Ô���æjXjKMDG]^N�PRF\KcVLaLF�KcD�F�WG]^VLe[J[HGVL`�NUJYKMDGF�y{J[`^`pFOy!Kc]^JLHrJLX L È~NU]^xITG`^]pyOFON¾]pNª�É>ó�Ìa¦�j ¦6uGV8HGW$�foIHGJLKM]^yO]pHGe,KcD�V8K_KcD�FjSMF{NMnG`½K�DGVLN�V¼yOJ[HGN�K.VLHfK�NM]^xITG`p]^yO]^VL`�NUF{K�JLX:J[��xUF{y{KMNOu�KMDGFOH�V8TGTG`po¾KMDGF`^FOxIx�V��QSRlk m�fpYonÝcipSY\_ér�qôV�ëÃmobA`�h i�k�`al\`aV�k³[S_ä]Sê�i�]S`sr0uJt�ê�ëpl$WZ]^_\R��F!KÓ£ ��F�V�NM]^xITG`p]^yO]^VL`:NMF!Kh��Ç�FhVLS�KMDGF¾NUKcVLSUK,JLXRNM]px�T�`^]^y{]lVL`:D�J[x�J8KcJ[Tfo*KMDGFOJLSUo[u��,VLH#NUDGJ?P�F{W'DGJ?P,u�]pX£ P�VLNjSMFOW�nGyOF{W�ÉZKcDGV8Kj]pNOu�]pXD£wðjP�VLNQVINM]^H�e[`^F!KcJ[H�Ì�u�KcDGF{H*KcDGF¼XZSMF{F¿e[SUJ[nGT*XZnGH�y{KcJLSjVLT�TG`^]pFOW�KMJ±£ ]pH*VNMnG��KM`^F�P�VhoLuefVhg[F$V\NU]^xITG`^]pyO]^VL`�eLSMJ[nGTYPwDGJ[NUF$DGJ[xIJLKMJ[Tfo#e[SMJLnGTGN,P�F{SMF�KcDGJ[NUF$JLX�£|u�Pw]½KcD�V�NUDG]pXàK¼JLXWG]^xIFOHGNU]^J[H>���]pKMD�ÑjPEo[FOSE]pHY� è9�8�ãuBDGFQefVhg[F�KMDGFQHGF{yOFONUNcVLS�o�g8VLSM]^VLHfK�JLX�KcDGV8KEyOJLHGNUKMSMnGy!Kc]^JLH�KMJ¾FOH�V8�G`^F�]½KKcJ�VLTGTG`½o$KcJ¾KMDGF,HGJ[HBÈ SMFOW�nGyOF{W*yhV8NMFL�vCEDG]pNwe[]pgLFON�VzÔëNU]^xITG`^]pyO]lV8`6e[SUJ[nGT�J[]^W>ÀZï�É;£kÌ�VLNEXZJ[`p`^J?PwNK¢

CEDGF&J[��xUF{y{K�NUF{KjJLXvVL`p`�KMDGF¿eLSMJ[nGT�J[]pWGN®ï$É6£kÌa¦�Pw]^`p`:�6F&]^H*��]ÚxUFOy!Kc]½g[F¼yOJ[SUSMFONUT6JLHGWGFOH�yOF�Pw]pKMD�KMDGF&NUF{KJLXgLFOSUKM]^y{FON®£wð�JLXX£|�S��BTG`p]^yO]½Kc`½o�KMDG]^NEJ[�(xUFOy{K�NUF{K�Pw]^`^`6�6FQPwSU]pKMKMFOHu, yv1<y�¯¬£wðw3b�

CEDGF,e[SUJ[nGT�J[]^Wòï�É;£ķ¦�]^NEe[F{HGFOSMV8KcF{W��fo�F{WGe[FONz³¢ Ç Ç � ×K×9×�Ç�¦ ã z0� Ç<ð�Ç � ×9×9×�Ç�¦ ã z XZJ[S z³¯¤£G¦ ã

Pw]pKcDkSUFO`lVAKc]^JLHGN Ù9ð2y:¨ÐÅoÇ ·5x6·sy{z|z|z ·�} H ��Ç�J8KcF¾NM]pHGyOF¾KMDGFONUFpxUn�NUK�Ôëab]p`^`ãÀ�NMJLx�F¾JLX_KcD�FIeLFOHGF{ScV8KM]^HGe�F{WGe[FON{u�KMDGFSMFONUnG`pKM]^HGe�e[SUJ[nGT�J[]^Wòï�É;£ķ¦�]^NEN�Kc]^`p`�V�XZSMF{F,e[SMJ[n�T6J[]pW��Ñ�F���HGF~. ¹ y ¨ Ù ¹ ã y XZJ[S Å?� s�u¼VLHGW�uQXZJ[SnÅ?� s�u7� ¹ y¸¨ Ç ¹ ã y�u,�Gn�K³XZJLSnÅ ¨ s�u7��ð y ¨

É Ç y6ÌOÉ Ç(ð�y6Ì � �CEDGF{NMF�W�F���HG]½Kc]pJ[HGN:o�]^FO`pW�V�NM]^xITG`p]^yO]^VL`LeLSMJ[nGT�J[]pW&V8N]^N�FOVLNM]p`po,y.DGF{y.aLFOWIVLH�W�u[VLN�]^N�yO`pFhVLS{uL]½KcN�NM]^xITG`p]^yO]^VL`NMF{KvJ8X�J[��xUFOy!KcN-]pNyOJLHGNUKcVLHfKhufNMJj]pK-V8`^NMJ�yhVLH¾��F�y{J[HGNM]pWGFOSUFOW�VLN�VjNM]px�TG`p]^y{]lVL`p`po�FOHGSU]^y.DGF{W¾e[SMJ[n�T6J[]pW�u�ï�É;£kÌ��

ÉçÇjÏj��Ï�F!P�VLSUFIKMDGFOSUFzVLSUF�NMF{gLFOSMVL`�Ô�K~o�T6J[N{À�]pH#KcDGFIJ[SM]pe[]^HGVL`�T�VLT�FOS¼SMF{`lV8KM]^HGezKMJ�KMDGFONUF�XZJ[SUx�nG`lV8F�XZJ[SKcDGF,yOJLHGNUKMSMnGy!Kc]^JLH*VLH�W�]pH\NUJ[xIFQJLX�KMDGF,SMF{`lV8KMFOW�x$VAKcFOSU]lVL`2� Ì

Ê�Nz�6F!XZJ[SMF*]pKz]pN$]pHGNUKMSMnGy!Kc]pgLF³KcJ|y{J[xITGn�KcF*NMJ[xIF³F!��VLxITG`pFON�VLH�W�P�F³Pw]p`^`�`^J�J[a�V8K÷ï�É���qA�lÌ$VLHGW

ï$É��Öt8�2�RÌ�NU]^xITG`^]pyO]lV8`^`po�FOHGSU]^y.DGF{W*e[SUJ[nGT�J[]^W�VLSUFQXZSMFOF,e[SUJ[nGT�J[]^W�N�]^H�FhV8y.D*NM]px�T�`^]^y{]lVL`�WG]px�F{HGNM]pJ[H�u�KMDGFO]pS

NUKcSUnGy{KMnGSMF�yOVLH|��FzyO`pFhVLSU`pokNUFOFOH|XZSUJ[x KcDGF$e[FOHGF{ScV8KM]^HGe�e[ScV8TGDGNO�³ü�JLS&]pHGNUKcVLHGyOF8u�ï$É��ÁqA�lÌTð¿]^N&KMDGF$XZSUFOF

e[SMJ[n�T6J[]pW�J[H�KcDGF,e[SMVLTGDè

���<

<<<<

<<<

s ð � //

ð AA�������� q

b

Page 8: d¾PRJ[nG`^W `^]^a8F KMJ|KcDVLH a i FO]^H FOS ...hopf.math.purdue.edu/Porter/s-catsv2.pdfGKUKcFOWYKcJ[eLF{KcD FOS,NMJ KcDVAK&d KcDG]pHGa d_ FOeL]^H KMJ nGHGW FOSMN K.VLH WzKcDGFjP

PwDG]^`pNUK®ï�É��Áqñ�àÌ ]pN�KcDGFQXZSMF{F,e[SMJ[n�T6J[]pW�J[H�KcDGF,e[SMVLTGD

è �W���<

<<<<

<<<

s ð �W� //

ð W AA��������ð �AA�������� q

i�FOSUF�]½K,]^N�PRJ[SUKMD�H�JLKc]pHGe�KcD�V8KM��ðñÉ s�è?q[Ìp¨(É sfqLÌ�×lÉ èñq[Ì � �Ii�]^eLDGFOS,WG]px�F{HGNM]pJ[HGN�WGJ\HGJLK¼D�VhgLF$VLHfokHGJLHBÈWGFOe[F{HGScVAKcF¼e[FOHGF{ScV8KMJ[SMN{�Ê�efVL]^H�Pw]pKcDÄï�É

��Öt8�lÌ!u�]pH³WG]^xIFOH�NM]^JLH#s$P�F¾DGV?gLF¾KcDGF¿XZSUFOF¾e[SUJ[nGT�J[]^W*J[H³KcDGF¾W�]^SMF{y{KMFOW#e[SMVLTGD#e[]½g[F

�bo�KMDGF�è{È~NUaLF{`pKcJLH\J8X��Öt8�ã�vd~H\WG]^xIFOH�NM]^JLH\qBuGKcDGF,e[F{HGFOSMV8Kc]pHGe�WG]^SUFOy!KcFOW�e[SMVLTGD\]^N

è \W\

��===

====

====

==

����

s

@@�������������

@@�������������

@@������������� //

ð �W\��=

====

====

====

ð �W���=

====

====

====

t

q�W\W\

@@�������������

i�FOSUF�J[HG`½o&V�XZF{P�JLX�KMDGFEVLSUSMJ?P�`lVL��FO`pN�DGV?gLFE�6F{FOH¾e[]½g[F{H��ÆæjKcD�FOSMN�VLSMF�FOVLNUo¼KcJjTGSMJ?g�]^WGFQÉç�Gn�Kx�J�WGF{ScV8KMFO`poDGJ[SMSU]^�G`pF¼KMJ$K~o�T6F{NMF!K&]pH³V$NUFOHGNU]^�G`pF¿P�V?o��ëÌ!�QCEDGJLNMF�XZSMJLx sIKcJ è¾VLSUF s�è?q�u s�èLè�VLHGW sBè?tBÆ>KMDGJ[NUF¿XZSMJ[x èKcJ q�V8SMF èñq[q�VLH�W èñq8tBu�VLHGWò��H�V8`^`poIXZSMJLx s¾KcJ t�u�PRF&DGV?gLF sLt[tB�

CEDGF¼HGF��BKjWG]^xIFOH�NM]^JLH�]pN�JLHG`po�VI`^]½KMKc`pF�xIJ[SMF,yOJLx�TG`p]^yOV8KcF{W��Rd K�D�VLN�F!��KMScV�W�FOe[F{HGFOSMV8KcF¿VLSMSUJñPwN�NMnGy.DVLN s�è[èñqzV8HGW s�èñq[q�XZSUJ[x s$KcJ è¾�Gn�K¼V8`^NMJ$�6F!K~P�F{FOH�KMDGFONUF¾K~P�J�g[F{SUKM]^yOF{NQD�VLN s�è?qLtBu:y{J[x�]pHGe$XZSUJ[x¸KMDGFHGJ[HBÈ WGFOe[F{HGFOSMV8KcF�KMDGSMF{FQNM]px�TG`pF!��JLX

���tA�ã�-CEDGF�XZn�`^`�WG]lVLeLScVLx ]^NRFhVLN�ozKcJ¿WGScVhP É2VLHGW�V8efVL]^HzV¿�G]pK�KcSM]py.afo

KcJ�K~oBT�FONUF{K�]^H\V¾HGFhVAK�P�Vho�Ì!u�VLHGW�]^N�KMDGFOSUF{XZJ[SUF&`pF{XàK�ÔëVLN�VLH\F!�BFOSUyO]pNMFLÀ½�` ö�ù: A�Að�ûÉZ]àÌ�CEDGFwXZnGHGy!KcJ[S^ïÃD�V8NRV,SM]pe[DfK_VLW�xUJ[]pHfK � VLHGW�KcD�F�n�HG]pK^£´� �ôï�É;£kÌ�]^NvV�PRFhVLa�FO�bnG]½g8VL`^F{HGyOFwJLX

NM]^xITG`p]^yO]^VL`GNUF{KcN{�-CEDG]^NR]^NRT�VLSUKRJLX�KMDGFjSUFONUnG`pKRKcD�V8K�NMDGJ?PwN�KMD�V8K�NM]^xITG`p]^yO]^VL`^`½o,FOHGSU]^y.DGF{W�e[SMJLnGT6JL]^WGN_x�J�WGF{`VL`^`�DGJ[xIJLKMJ[Tfo�K~oBT�FON{u>XZJ[SwPwDG]^y.D*NMFOF&KcDGF&J[SM]pe[]^H�V8`�T�VLT�FOS{u-�Õè��8��J[SwKcDGF&�6J�J[a��fo#ÿQJ�FOSMNUN�VLH�W#m[VLSUWG]^HGF8u�ÁqBè{�ã�

ÉZ]^]àÌ�d KR]pN�K.VLHfKcVL`^]pNM]^H�e�KcD�V8KvKMDGFwWGF���H�]pKc]pJ[H�JLXtª�É>ó�ÌEXZJ[SvV,yhVAKcFOeLJ[SUoõó V8HGW�J8X�ï�É;£kÌXZJ[SvV,NM]^xITG`p]^yO]^VL`NMF{KÖ££V8SMF¿gLFOSUo*NM]px�]p`lVLS�oLF{KQg[F{SUo*WG]pê6FOSUFOHfKh�j��Dfo*WGJBF{NjKcD�F¿K~Pw]^N�KQJBy{yOnGS�]^H*KMDGF�Ç<ðQJLX^ï�É;£kÌU����DfoWGJ#KcDGF�NMJLnGSMy{F�VLHGWrK.VLSUe[F{K�x�VLTGN�V8K�FhVLy.D�`^F!g[F{`�]^H5ï�É;£kÌ¿F{HGW n�T VAK�KcDGFò�{FOSMJ8KcD�VLHGW ��SUNUK¾g[F{SUKMF!�ScV8KMDGFOS�KcD�VLH�KcDGF�NUFOF{x�]pHGe[`po�xIJ[SUF&H�VAKcnGSMVL`E�{FOSUJLKcD#V8HGW L � ý KMD�V8KjJBy{yOnGS�]^H¬ªwÉ>ó�ÌU��d~H³XçV8y{K�]^N�KMDGFOSUF�VgLV8SM]lV8HbKRJLX:KMDGFpï�É;£kÌvyOJ[HGN�KcSUnGy{KM]^J[H$KMD�V8KR]^NRHGFhVLSUFOS_KcJ¿KMDGF�ªwÉ=óRÌ�yOJ[HGN�KcSUnGy{KM]^J[H$Pw]½KcDGJLn�K���FO]pHGe¿xIFOSUFO`poVLSUKM] ��y{]lVL`p`poINMJb�

Page 9: d¾PRJ[nG`^W `^]^a8F KMJ|KcDVLH a i FO]^H FOS ...hopf.math.purdue.edu/Porter/s-catsv2.pdfGKUKcFOWYKcJ[eLF{KcD FOS,NMJ KcDVAK&d KcDG]pHGa d_ FOeL]^H KMJ nGHGW FOSMN K.VLH WzKcDGFjP

� � ¬-±v´#«E¬-´#±-ªç RTQ m�fpY mofp]Sh ]ÆWZ]Si�pÓu�l�VXWZY\[^]S_ pd XEÕ�]^NwVLH È~yOV8KcF{e[J[SUoLu�P�F,yhV8H\XZJ[SUx V�yhV8KMFOe[JLSUo³Þ�ð�ÕYPw]½KcD�KcDGF,NMVLx�F,J[�(xUFOy{KMNjV8HGW�D�VhgB]pHGe

É=Þ�ð�Õ�ÌOÉ=Í�}�Î�Ì�¨!Þ�ðAÉ>Õ_É>ͤ}�Î�ÌMÌ�×ü�JLSQ]^HGN�K.VLHGy{FLu:]½X�Õ ¨ Õ�� u:KMDGF¾yhV8KMFOe[JLSUo#JLX��R�4È yOJ[xITG`^F��BFONOu:KMDGFOHÄÞ�ð�Õ�� ¨���Ë�É=Ñ�� Ì.u:KcDGF¾y{J[SMSUF!ÈNMT�J[HGWG]pHGe,DGJ[xIJLKcJ[Tfo¿yhV8KMFOe[J[S�o[� � ]^xI]^`lV8SM`pojP�FwyOJLnG`^W�J[��KcVL]^H�VQe[SUJ[nGT�J[]^W¾F{HGSM]py.DGFOWIyhVAKcFOeLJ[SUo¾n�NM]^H�e,KMDGFXZnGHGW�VLxIFOHfKcVL`:e[SMJLnGT6JL]^WYÉçy!XÒ�Rÿ¼VL��SM]^F{`�VLH�W0�>]pNMx�VLH�u:��qLs8�lÌ!�

æ�HGF¾yOVLH�ÔÁWGJGÀ>NMJ[xIF¾FO`pFOxIFOHfK.VLS�o³DGJLx�JLKMJ[Tfo�KMDGFOJLSUo#]pHkVLHfo È yhV8KMFOe[JLSUo[utÕ�u��fo*NcVho�]^HGe�KcD�VAK�K~P�Jx$VLT�N ­�ðK}�­ ¢�Í´� ÎÎ]pHGÕ³VLSMF�DGJ[xIJLKcJLTG]^yw]pX>KcDGF{SMFj]pN�V8H�� ¯nÕ_É>ͤ}�Î¾Ì Pw]pKMD±Ç<ð5�¿¨«­ uZÇ �¿¨«­7ðh�CEDG]pN�KMDGFOJ[S�o�Pw]p`^`�HGJLK��6F¼g[FOS�o³SU]^y.D³nGH�`^FONUNQV8KQ`pFhVLN�KjNUJ[xIF�`^J?P WG]px�F{HGNM]pJ[H�VL`��,VLH³y{J[HGWG]½Kc]^JLHGNjV8SMF

NcV8KM]^N��GFOW��#CEDGF È~yOV8KcF{e[J[S�o[uXÕ-u]^N¿yOVL`^`pFOW4æ^Ù��MáLæàæ����¿á*��]½XEFhVLy.D:ÕvÉ=Í�}�ξ̼]pN�V³�,VLHry{J[xITG`^F��>u�æ^Ù��MáLæàæ��$ ÜMá�hAæ����¿á*�#]½X��{�O�Ou�F!KcyL��Éçd X�o[J[n�D�Vhg[F¼HGJLK�x�F!K,ÔÁPRFhVLa��,VLH\yOJLx�TG`pF!�BFON{À��6F!XZJ[SMF8u�o[J[n\Pw]^`^`6NMJ�J[H\x�F{F{KKcDGF{x�]^H�FhVLSUHGFON�Kh�ëÌ

CEDGFQKMDGFOJ[S�o�]^NQÔÁe[FOJLx�F!KcSM]pyhVL`p`po�À�HG]^y{FOS�KcJ¾PRJ[SMazPw]½KcD�]pX�Õ�]^NQÝ~Ü���Û?ÙAÚcÜ��\J[S��.ÙAÝ~Ü���Û?ÙAÚcÜ��L�ç Reç mGYEëpbé]S_�`Tëp[ V�ëCr U�]ÆWAYEëpbé]S_�`Tëp[J ö�ò�ûOó��ñö�÷d X�XZJ[SwVL`p`�£ ¯ uZͤ}2Î^}9¯3Õ-uGKcD�FOSMF,]pNwVLH�JL��xUFOy!K~£��ß�Í�]^H±Õ�NMnGy.D\KcD�V8K

ÕvÉ;£ �ßpͤ}�ξÌ�� ¨ É;£¤}TÕ_É=Í�}�ξÌH�V8Kcn�ScVL`p`po�]^H3£|uZÍ VLHGWnÎ�uGKcD�FOH÷Õ']pNENcVL]pW�KcJ��6F�Ý~Ü���Û?ÙAÚcÜ���J?g[F{S �

%&ó�ú?ö�ò�û{ó'�ñö�÷Ñ�n�V8`^`poLuB]½X�PRF,SMF{��n�]^SMF,J[�(xUFOy{KMN �ÕvÉ;£¤}�οÌ�NMnGy.D\KcD�V8K

Õ_É>ͤ} �ÕRÉ6£¤}�Î&ÌMÌ�� ¨ É6£¤}�Õ_É>ͤ}�Î�ÌKcDGF{H�PRF¼NMVho±Õ']pN��.ÙAÝÒÜ���Û?ÙAÚcÜ���J?g[FOS �

C�J�e[VL]^HkNMJLx�F�]^HfKMnG]pKM]pg[F�XZF{FO`p]^HGe�XZJ[SQKcD�FONMF8u�KMDG]^HGa*JLX £��ß�Í VLN,��FO]pHGe�£ TGSMJ�WGnGy!K&Pw]½KcD¬Íru�VLHGW�ÕRÉ;£¤}�Î&ÌjVLN�KcDGF¿J[��xUFOy!KQJLX-XZnGH�y{Kc]pJ[HGN�XZSMJ[x¿£ KcJ±Î���CEDGF{NMF�PRJ[SMW�N�WGJ�HGJLKOu>V8N�NMnGy.D>u�x$V8aLF�NUFOHGNUF¾]^He[FOHGF{ScVL`2uB��n�K�WGJ&KcFO`p`�J[HGFjKMDGFjNUJ[SUK�JLX�K.V8NMabN�KcD�FONMFjyOJ[HGN�KcSUnGy{KM]^J[HGN_Pw]^`p`���FjNUF{K�KMJ¿WGJ��-CEDGF{oIPw]^`p`�HGJLK���Fx�nGy.D*n�NMFOW\F!�BTG`p]^y{]pKc`½o$D�FOSMF,DGJ?PRF{gLFOSO�� �ñó�"-ó�û9�Zú��çó�ò : �#6'(@�¿á*�jå�Û&á*�'��fwÙAÚ�ÝÒÜ!Ú�&��l�a����;�#6�ÕÂÞ^Û¾á�æ^Ù��MáLæàæ��L�¿á*� ~� �MáLÝ~Üãâ�ÙAÚ���ÝÒÜ���Û?ÙAÚcÜ��*ÙAßLÜ!Ú Ý>��Ü���Ýãá�hAÞ>��âõøò�ÄÍ ¨

��ÕèO� �ßàÍ~& $ Ü,â�Ü!ÝEá�â�Ù?ÙK����8æÕÞ>�'��Ü!Ú@68!��$�!ÝÒÙAÚ¿Û"!ä���YÝ=��áLÝ�6hÙAÚ¾Ý>��Ü÷�.Ù�G��OÚMáLÝçÞãÙ���Û¾ÚcÜ!æ½áLÝçÞàßLÜ�Ý~ÙGø�á*�'� $ ÜMá�h³Ü��+!�ÞàßAáLæ^Ü��$�.Ü.Û¾Ýãá�hfÜ��rÝÒÙD�!Ü

��Ù��$ÙAÝÒÙ.å'��Ü��+!BÞàßAáLæ^Ü��$�.Ü.Û5&�Ý=��Ü��MáLÝ~Üãâ�ÙAÚ��àÕM��áAÛ&á3�.Ù�G��OÚUáLÝ2ÞãÙ�� �MáLÝÒÜãâ�ÙAÚ��¾Û!Ý2Ú8!ä�!Ý !�ÚcÜ+( NÊÎy{J*���GSMV8Kc]pJ[H�yhV8KMFOe[J[S�o�NUKMSMnGy!KcnGSUF¿]pNDxUn�NUK�J[HGF¼JLX�x$VLHfozg8VLSU]lVLHfKMN�J8XKcD�F&V8�GNUKMScVLy!KjDGJLx�JLKMJ[TfozKcD�FOJ[S�oNUKcSUnGy{KMnGSMF_]^HfKMSMJ�WGnGyOF{WQKcJw�6FvV8�G`^F�KMJ�T�nGNMD,KcDGSUJ[nGe[D,DGJLx�JLKMJ[TfojK~o�T�FRV8SMe[nGxIFOHfKMN:]^HQT�VLS�Kc]pyOnG`^VLS�NMF!KMKM]^HGe[N{�CEDGFOSUFQVLSMF�g8VLSM]^VLHfKcN_JLX�KcD�]^N_SMFONUnG`pKOuBW�nGFjKcJ¿�,VLx�T�NOu�NMFOF�SMF!XZFOSMF{HGyOF{NE]^H³�ÁqL�A�ãubPwDGFOSUF�Õ#]pNR��JLKMD�KcF{HGNMJLSMFOWVLHGWryOJ8KcFOH�NMJ[SUFOWrJ?g[F{S VLH�W'KcDGF$yOJ[HGy{`^nGNU]^J[H�]^N¼KcD�V8KÖÕ<D�V8N�V¬,�nG]p`^`^F{H�xIJ�WGFO`vyhVAKcFOeLJ[SUo�NUKMSMnGy!KcnGSUFL�CEDGF�F!��VLxITG`pFONjJ8X-`^J�yhVL`p`poz�¼V8H È~yhVAKcFOeLJ[SM]pFONj]pHGyO`pnGWGFÓÊ�Ë�Ì�u�ÓÒ L u��DØ�Ì�Ç�VLH�W3Õ�Ø*Ù[u6��n�K�HGJ8K�Õ\Ò�ÔwJ[S ]pKcNUFO`½XÒ�

é

Page 10: d¾PRJ[nG`^W `^]^a8F KMJ|KcDVLH a i FO]^H FOS ...hopf.math.purdue.edu/Porter/s-catsv2.pdfGKUKcFOWYKcJ[eLF{KcD FOS,NMJ KcDVAK&d KcDG]pHGa d_ FOeL]^H KMJ nGHGW FOSMN K.VLH WzKcDGFjP

  ¡ ªQ±�­IªQ¡�¢�¤#¥ ¢ °I  °¾¬�°L£9¤ � °I²³ªQ±-ªQ¤z¬ ¡ ªQ±�­IªQ¡*¥k�RTQ qôV�ëgV�ëCrgc:Y�V�¦§qôV�ëgl�]SëCrà`§WZ`T]SëpbÏ�F{XZJ[SUFjPRF�e[F{K�e[J[]pHGe¿J[H�KcDG]pN�NMF{y{KM]^J[H�uB]pK_Pw]^`p`���FQV¿eLJBJ�W$]pWGFhV,KcJ��GSU]^HGe&KcJ¿KMDGF�XZJ[SUF�KMDGF�WGF���HG]pKM]^J[H�N�JLX�¿á*�:�.Ù��jå�æ^Ü{¨*VLHGW $ ÜMá�hA�¿á*� �.Ù��jå�æ^Ü{¨'ÉçJ[SM�+!�áAÛ!Þ � �MáLÝÒÜãâ�ÙAÚ��BÌ!�Ê�N�n�NMn�VL`[PRF_NMF{K

�� L ��¨©� ÉT�Ö}ñ� L �àÌ�¯ u8KMDGFOH,XZJ[S:FOVLy.DÓÅUuLs�ª!Å�ª L uñP�FvyOVLH¼XZJLSMxÃVwNMn��GNM]px�TG`p]^y{]lVL`

NMF{KOu¬« ¹ � L �2u6JLX�� L ���fo\WG]^NUyhVLSUWG]^HGeIKcDGF¼KcJ[T�WG]^xIFOH�NM]^JLH�VL` L È NM]px�TG`pF!��ÉZe[]pgLFOH��bo\KcD�F&]pWGFOHfKc]½K~o\x$VLT\J[H

� L �àÌvVLHGW�]pKcN�Å � ý XçVLyOF8���'F�x�nGN�KRVL`^NUJ&WG]pNMyOVLSMW$VL`^`�KMDGF�WGFOe[F{HGFOSMVLyO]pFONRJLX>KMDGFONUFjNM]px�T�`^]^y{FON{��CEDG]pNR]pH�XZJ[SUx$VL`WGF���H�]pKc]pJ[H�WGJ�FONwHGJLKwe[]½g[F¼VzÔëT�]^y{KMnGSMF8À�JLX�PwD�V8KwP�F,D�VhgLFLu�NMJ�P�F,Pw]^`p`>`p]^NUK�KcDGFQg8VLSM]pJ[nGNEyOVLNMF{N�XZJ[S L ¨ qB�« ð �ÁqA��¨ è ­ ðW®°¯B±<²�³2´¶µ�·|¸]¸¹·|º�»

s@@�������

// q«*!�ÁqA��¨ è

��===

====

s@@������� q

« � �ÁqA��¨ è��=

====

==

s // qÊìx$VLT±Ì:¢�¼ � Ü�]pNQV½�¿á*��G��OÚUáLÝçÞãÙ��']pX_e[]½g[F{HkVLHfo L u�ÅwV8NQVL��JñgLFIVLHGWkVLHfo�É L }2Å Ì~È DGJ[SMH#]pH�¼�u:]2�ÁF8�VLHfo�x$VLT3­ ¢I« ¹ � L ��� ¼�u�VLH�W L È~NM]px�T�`^F!�6uZ­�ð~¢ � � L �$� Ü$u�NMn�y.D�KcDGV8K

« ¹ � L � Âsx //

¹ ¦w¾��

¼ü��

�� L �  þ // Ü

yOJ[xIx�n�KMFONOu�KMDGFOH\KcDGF{SMF¼]^N�VLH�­ ¢�� L �t� ¼ NUnGy.D*KMD�V8K�Ì'­�¨å­�ð�V8HGW¬­�×|Å L�¿ ¨«­ u�]2�ÁF8� ­#`^]pXàKMN�­�ðjVLHGWF!��KcF{HGWGN�­ �Ê NM]^xITG`p]^yO]^VL`GNUF{KhuA£|u�]pN�VL�¿á*�¬�.Ù��jå�æ^Ü{¨�]pX�KMDGF�nGH�]^�bnGFjx�VLT³£g�

��Ös8�6]^N�V&�,VLH³���GSMV8Kc]pJ[H���CED�]^N

]^N¼FO�bnG]pg8VL`pFOHfK¼KcJ\NcVho�]^HGe\KcD�V8K&F{gLFOS�o'DGJLSMH']pH:£ D�VLN�V÷��`p`^FOS{u�]2�ÁF8��VLHfo:­ ¢�« ¹ � L �q� ΨF!��KMFOHGWGN¼KcJVLH ­5¢

�� L �X� ÎI�,CEDG]^N�y{J[HGWG]½Kc]pJ[H*`pJBJ[abN�KcJ���F�TGnGSUFO`po�JLX_V$eLFOJ[xIF{KMSM]^y&H�V8KMnGSMF���n�KQ]^H�XçVLy{KQDGVLNQVLH

]^xIT6J[S�K.VLHfKwV8`^e[F{�GScVL]pyÁÀ�Vhg[JLnGSOÆ�XZJ[SE]pHGNUKcVLHGyOFQ]½XÆ­ ¢c« ��qA��� Îì]pNwV�D�J[SMH�u�]½KEyOJLHGNM]pNUKcN�JLXV¾WG]lVLeLScVLx^��?

????

??º ??�������

JLX�ÔÁyOJ[xIT�J[NcVL��`^FLÀ�VLSMSUJ?PwN�]pH3£|�_d XD­#]^NwVõ��`^`pFOS{u�]pKw`pJBJLa�NE`p]^a8F^��?

????

??

¾ //

º Â??�������

è?s

Page 11: d¾PRJ[nG`^W `^]^a8F KMJ|KcDVLH a i FO]^H FOS ...hopf.math.purdue.edu/Porter/s-catsv2.pdfGKUKcFOWYKcJ[eLF{KcD FOS,NMJ KcDVAK&d KcDG]pHGa d_ FOeL]^H KMJ nGHGW FOSMN K.VLH WzKcDGFjP

VLHGW�J[HGFEyOVLH¾KcDG]pHGa&J8X�KMDGF�KcD�]^SMW�XçV8yOF ¿ V8NvV�yOJ[xIT6JLNM]pKMF�JLX�Ò&VLHGWL�?��CEDG]^NRÔëy{J[x�T�J[NU]pKcF8À ¿ ]^N�HGJ8KvnGNMn�V8`^`ponGHG]^�bnGF{`po\WGF���HGFOW#�fo�Ò�VLHGW0�?u6�Gn�K�]pN¼ÔÁnGT*KMJ$DGJLx�JLKMJ[Tfo�Àp��d X�PRF¿PwSM]½KcF ¿ ¨ Ò��,VLNjV�NMD�J[SUKMD�VLHGW³KMDGFOH]pX�° ¢I« ð ��qA�'� £�]pNwVID�J[SMH�uBP�F,KcDG]pHGa$J8XE° V8N���FO]pHGe

· ??�������  //

VLHGW�KcJ���HGW�V0�G`^`^F{S�]^N�KMJ���HGW�VIWG]^VLe[SMVLxH

??

??· ??�������  //

VLHGW#KcDbnGN�KMJ³ÔëNUJ[`pgLFLÀ>KMDGF¾FO�bn�V8KM]^J[HÄÇ�y ¨Ã�¾XZJ[S®y']pH³KcFOSUx�NjJLXSÇ�VLH�W��[�&d KQKMD�n�NQSMFO�bnG]pSMF{NQ]^H#e[F{HGFOSMVL`NMJ[xIF*V8TGTGSMJh�B]^x�V8KMF�]^Hfg[F{SMNMF\XZJ[SGÇ�u�]^HrXçVLy!Khu_K.VLab]^H�e~��KcJY�6F�VYW�FOe[F{HGFOSMV8KcF�è{È~NU]^xITG`^F��|TGnBKcNIJ[HGF\]^HF!��VLy{KM`po�NUnGy.D³V�T�J[NM]½Kc]^JLH��

d~H�x�VLHfo¼nGNMF!XZnG`�yOVLNMF{NOufPRF�WGJ�HGJ8K-VL`½P�Vho�ND�VhgLFE]^Hfg[F{SMNMF{NvVLHGW�NUJjP�VLHfK�KcJ�W�]^NMyOVLSMW�VLHfo¿SUFO�bnG]^SUFOxIFOHfKKcD�V8K¿P�J[n�`^W|]px�TG`½o³KcD�F{o'VL`pP�VhoBN¿F!�B]^N�Kh�³CEDG]pN�`^FOVLWGN¼KcJ*KMDGF�PRFhVLa8FOS�XZJ[SUx J8X�KcDGFz�¼V8H|yOJ[H�WG]pKM]^J[H�]^HPwDG]^y.D�]^H�FhVLy.D�WG]^xIFOH�NM]^JLH�HGJ�SUFO�bnG]pSMFOxIFOHfK�]^NEx�VLWGFQXZJ[S�KMDGF,F!�B]^N�KcF{HGyOF&JLXE�G`^`^F{SMNEJ[H\DGJ[SUHGNEKcD�VAK�xI]^NUNJ[n�KwKcDGFà�{FOSMJ8KcD\J[SE`lVLN�KEXçVLyOF{NO�Rþ�J[SUF,F!��VLy{KM`po'¢

/ öcÄ�ò��àú7�çó�òÊ NM]^xITG`p]^yO]^VL`�NUF{K 1 ]^Njá $ ÜMá�h7�¿á*�¬�.Ù��jå�æ^Ü{¨zJ[SC�+!GáAÛ!Þ � �MáLÝ~Üãâ�ÙAÚ��¾]pX>XZJLS�VLHfo L VLH�W�sePÆÅ9P L uBVLHfo

É L }5ÅGÌ~È DGJ[SMH�]pHn£�D�VLN�Võ��`^`pFOS{�` ö�ù: A�Að�ûÉZ]àÌEmLJ?ofVL`2u���q[×A�2u�nGNMF{N�KcD�F,KMFOSUx Þ>�ä�>Ü!Úp��ÙAÚ��³XZJLSwVLHfo�É L }5ÅGÌ~È DGJ[SMH�]pHn£ Pw]pKMD�s�PÇÅ�P L �_CEDGFQK~P�J

SMFOx�VL]pHG]^HGe¾yOVLNMF{NjV8SMF�KcD�FOH\yOJ[Hfg[F{HG]^F{HfKc`po�yOVL`^`pFOW|Ù�!�ÝÒÜ!Úp��ÙAÚ���Û!�ÉZ]^]àÌ�ü�J[S,VLHfo#NMTGVLyOF0Íru:]pKMNQNM]pHGe[nG`^VLS�yOJLx�TG`pF!�6u�ªDÅ L °�É>ÍYÌj]^NQeL]pg[F{H��fo ªDÅ L °>É=ÍY̧¦÷¨ Ï�Ë�Ì�É

� ¦ }�ÍYÌPw]pKcD�KcDGF�P�F{`^`�a�H�JñPwHzXçV8yOF�V8HGW$WGF{e[FOH�FOScV8y{ozx�VLTGN{��CEDG]pN�NM]px�T�`^]^y{]lVL`BNMF!K�]^N�VL`pP�Vho�N�V¿�,VLH$yOJ[xITG`^F���VLN]^NEKcDGF,SUFO`lVAKcFOW3ÊõË�Ì�É>ͤ}�οÌwV8N�xIFOHfKM]^J[HGF{W\VL�6J?gLFL�

k�Reç ÈôY\_ ÉSY�bCEDGF$yOV8KcF{e[J[SM]pyhVL`vV8H�VL`^JLe[nGF�JLX�KMDGF$NU]^HGeLnG`lVLSQy{J[xITG`^F��k]^N{u�JLX�yOJ[nGSUNMF8u�KcD�F$HGF{SUg[F?¢�]pX�Êì]^N¼V�yOV8KcF{e[J[SUoLu]pKcNÓ�>Ü!Ú�ßLÜ!u¬Ë½�9ØGÉ2ÊRÌ�u�]^NwKcD�F¿NM]px�T�`^]^y{]lVL`>NMF{KjPw]pKcDDËD�9Ø�É Ê_Ìa¦n¨ ÑÓÒ�Ô{ÉU� L �o}5Ê_Ì�u�PwDGF{SMF\� L ��]^NwKcDGF�yOV8KcF{e[J[S�oVLNMNUJBy{]lV8KMFOW$KMJ&KcD�F���HG]½KcF�J[SMW�]^H�VL`�� L ��¨Ì,As�PÂè7På×9×9× P L 3b�-CEDGF�XçVLyOFjVLHGW$W�FOe[F{HGFOSMVLy{o�x$V8TGN�V8SMF�KMDGFJ[�fgB]pJ[nGNwJ[HGF{N�n�NM]^H�e�KMDGF,yOJ[xIT�J[NM]½Kc]^JLH�VLHGW\]^WGF{HfKc]pKM]^F{N�]^HQÊE�

CEDGFQXZJ[`p`^J?Pw]^H�e�]^N�PRFO`p`:a�H�JñPwH*VLHGW\FhVLN�ozKcJ�TGSUJ?g[FL�4_ö�ù|ù: :�: Þ<;MËD�9Ø�É Ê_Ì�Þ^Û¿áLæ $ á*�?Û $ ÜMá�hAæ��A�¿á*��(: ÞàÞ<;MËD�9Ø�É Ê_Ì�Þ^ÛC�¿á*�#Þ 6&á*�'��Ù���æ��IÞ 6BÊ Þ^Û¿á�âLÚcÙ�!ñå�ÙAÞ6�c( N

æjX:y{J[nGSMNUF�xIJ[SMF�]^N_KcSMn�FL�vÇ�J8K�J[H�`poIWGJ�FON�V8Hbo�]^H�HGFOS_DGJ[SUHz]^HOËD�9Ø�É ÊRÌ�D�Vhg[FQVà��`^`pFOS{uB]½KRDGVLN�F!��VLy!Kc`½oJ[HGFà��`^`pFOSO�_C�J�F���T�SMFONUNjKcD�]^NEPw]pKMD�x�VA�B]^x�n�xÄXZJ[SUyOF,KcDGF,XZJ[`^`pJ?Pw]^HGe�]pWGFhVBu�JLXàKcF{H³V8KUKcSM]p�Gn�KMFOW�KcJ$ÿ,SMVLFOxIF� FOefV8`:J[S�KcJ$ÿ,SUJLKcD�FOHGWG]pFOy.a�u�]^N�gLFOS�o�nGNMF!XZnG`ã�

è[è

Page 12: d¾PRJ[nG`^W `^]^a8F KMJ|KcDVLH a i FO]^H FOS ...hopf.math.purdue.edu/Porter/s-catsv2.pdfGKUKcFOWYKcJ[eLF{KcD FOS,NMJ KcDVAK&d KcDG]pHGa d_ FOeL]^H KMJ nGHGW FOSMN K.VLH WzKcDGFjP

�:F{K�ÌQ�<s�u[V8HGW�yOJLHGNM]pWGFOS�KcDGFR]^HGy{SMFhV8NM]^H�ejx�VLTGNÍ� ¹ ¢��ÕèO�'� � Ì���e[]½g[F{H¿�foA� ¹ É2sfÌ�¨ Å�VLHGWA� ¹ É�è?Ì^¨ Å8[�è[�ü�JLS�VLHfo\NM]px�TG`p]^y{]lVL`�NUF{K�ÛÎyOJ[H�NM]^W�FOSMF{WkVLN�VIXZnGHGy{KMJ[S~ÛТ¶��� ü � ª��KÔ�Ù[u6PRF�yOVLH³F{g8VL`pn�V8KMF�ÛÍJLH*KcDGF{NMF� ¹ VLHGW�u6HGJLKM]^HGeIKcD�V8KC� ¹ ÉÒèñÌ ¨Î� ¹ ã ÉçsfÌ!u�PRF�e[F{K�V�XçVLxI]^`½o�JLX-XZnGHGy!Kc]pJ[HGN~ÛSüõ� Û u6PwDG]py.D*o�]^FO`pW#V$y{J[HGFWG]lVLeLScVLx\uBXZJ[SE]pHGNUKcVLHGy{FLuGXZJ[SḎ¨ tA¢Ûqü

Ï R Â x S**UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU

Ï R Â y S

AAA

AAAA

AAAA

AAAA

AAAA

Ï R Â Ð S

��+++

++++

++++

++++

++++

++++

Û · þ��Û ·5x //

· þ��

Û~ð

Û ·�x // Û~ðVLHGW\]^H�e[FOH�FOScV8`ãu�KMD�n�N�o�]^F{`^W�V�x$V8T

�B� ÌG�\¢<ÛSüp� Û � Ï þ�Û � Ï þS×K×9×Z� Ï þ�Û ×CEDGF$x�VLTGN{uÍ�B� ÌG�ãu�D�Vhg[F��6F{FOH�yhVL`p`^FOW#KMDGF F ÜãâfáLæÆ�Iá!å�Û�V8HGW�Pw]p`^`�SUFOyOn�S¼KMDGSMJ[n�e[DGJ[n�K,KMDGF�SUFON�K¿JLXRKcDGF{NMFHGJLKcF{NO�4_ö�ù|ù: ��#6�ÛH¨Ñ˽�9ØGÉ2ÊRÌB6hÙAÚQÛ?Ù��$ÜjÛ��IáLæàæE�MáLÝÒÜãâ�ÙAÚ��MÊÒ&�Ý=��Ü��A6hÙAÚ�Û7&_Ý>��Ü F ÜãâfáLæt�Iá!å�Û&áLÚcÜM�OÞ �hÜ��!ÝçÞãÙ���Û+(� �ñó�ó4Ó

Ê NM]px�T�`^F!�9. ¯�˽�9ØGÉ2Ê�Ì=ü$y{J[SMSUFONMT�J[HGW�NjnGHG]p�bnGFO`½ozKcJIV�yOJ[xIT6JLNcVL�G`pF�Ì�È~y.DGVL]^H�JLX�VLSMSUJñPwN�]^HQÊEu�VLHGWDGFOHGy{F&F���VLy{KM`pozKMJ�]½KcNE]^x�VLe[F�nGHGWGF{S�KMDGF,SMF{`^F{g8VLHfK � F{efVL`:x�VLT�� N

Ï�F!KMKMFOSEKcD�V8H�KMDG]^Nw]pN�KcSMn�F*¢� �ñó�"-ó�û9�Zú��çó�òd��#6^ÛìÞ^Û�á¿Û!Þ>�jå�æÕÞo�!ÞçáLæ�Û?Ü!Ý�Û"!�����Ý>��áLÝ�Ý=��Ü F ÜãâfáLæ��Iá!å�Û�áLÚcÜg�OÞ �hÜ��!ÝçÞãÙ���Û�Ý>��Ü���Ý>��Ü!ÚcÜjÞ^Û�á³�MáLÝÒÜãâ�ÙAÚ��,Û!Ý2Ú8!ä�!Ý !�ÚcÜÙ��#Ý=��Ü��LÞàÚcÜ��!Ý~Ü���âLÚUá!åä�

Û //// Û~ðoo×

�Iá�hAÞ>��â�ÞàÝ�á3�MáLÝ~Üãâ�ÙAÚ�� $ ��Ù?Û?Ü��>Ü!Ú!ßLÜQÞ^Û¼Þ^Û?Ù��$ÙAÚ~åä��Þo��ÝÒÙIÝ>��ÜjâLÞàßLÜ��±ÛA(� �ñó�ó4Ó

C�J�e[F{K�yOJLx�T�J[NM]½Kc]pJ[H$o[JLn�nGNUFÛ � Ï þ Û ÈÉ� Û � ·�x��Û ×

ÊjNMNUJBy{]lV8KM]pg�]pK~o$]^NEe[]½g[F{H��fo÷Û \ �-CEDGF&J8KcDGF{S�`^VhPwNwVLSMF,FhV8NUo[u�V8HGW�]p`^`pnGx�]pH�V8KM]^HGeGu[KMJ�y.DGFOy.a�� NCEDGFQy{J[HGWG]½Kc]pJ[H*Ô � FOefV8`�x$V8TGNEVLSUFQV��G]ÚxUF{y{KM]^J[H�À�]^N�yO`^JLNMFO`½o$SUFO`^V8KcF{WzKcJ¾HGJLKM]^J[H�N�JLXvÔÁKMDG]^H�HGFONUNOÀ�VLNEn�NMFOW

�bo$Ï�SUJñPwHzVLHGWzi�]^e[eL]^HGNv]^HIKcDGF�NUKMnGW�o�JLX:y{SMJ[NUNMFOW�y{J[xITG`^F���F{N�V8HGW$KcD�FO]^S_SMF{`lV8KM]^J[H�NMDG]pT�KMJ7Ô-È e[SMJ[n�T6J[]pWGNOuNMFOF8u�XZJ[SE]^HGN�K.VLH�yOFLu�� �L�2u�VLHGW�VL`^NUJ�KcJIÑ�nGNUa�]pH�À�N,ÔÁDfo�T6F{SMe[SUJ[nGT�J[]^W�À�y{J[HGWG]½Kc]pJ[H�u:�Õè9�L�2�

Ê�HGJLKcD�FOS�SUFONUnG`pK_KcD�VAK�]pNRNUJ[x�F!Kc]px�F{N_n�NMF{XZn�`ãu�]^NRV&SMF���HGF{x�F{HbK�JLX�ÔÁe[SMJLnGT6JL]^WGNve[]½g[F��¼V8HzyOJ[xITG`pF!�BFON{À ¢½�CEDGF&T�SMJ�JLX]pN�ÔÁKMDGF,NcVLxIFLÀ ¢

èñq

Page 13: d¾PRJ[nG`^W `^]^a8F KMJ|KcDVLH a i FO]^H FOS ...hopf.math.purdue.edu/Porter/s-catsv2.pdfGKUKcFOWYKcJ[eLF{KcD FOS,NMJ KcDVAK&d KcDG]pHGa d_ FOeL]^H KMJ nGHGW FOSMN K.VLH WzKcDGFjP

4_ö�ù|ù: .��Ü!ÝEÛݨÕËD�9Ø�É Ê_Ì�&jÝ>��ÜÖ�>Ü!Ú�ßLÜ�Ù�6&áò�MáLÝ~Üãâ�ÙAÚ���Ê*(: Þ<;MÖ~�ä�$É L }.sfÌ � ��ÙAÚ��­¤¢c« ð � L ��� Û

6hÙAÚ $ ��Þo���n­É2s�èñÌ�Þ^Û$á*�rÞ^Û?Ù��$ÙAÚ åä��Þ^Û��¿��áAÛ$áMGvæàæ^Ü!Ú'( F Þ>�¾Þàæ½áLÚ!æ���á*�ä�³É L } L Ì � ��ÙAÚ��¤°:¢�« ¦ � L �S� Û-6hÙAÚ$ ��Þo����°>É L �<è L ̼Þ^Û¿á*�³Þ^Û?Ù��$ÙAÚ åä��Þ^Û���&E��áAÛ¿á*Gvæàæ^Ü!Ú'(: ÞàÞ<; F !ñåfå�Ù?Û?Ü�­ÃÞ^Û\á¬�$ÙAÚ åä��Þ^Û�� Þ>�=Ê $ ÞàÝ=�'Ý>��Ü¿å�ÚcÙ.å�Ü!Ú�Ý;�#Ý>��áLÝ×6hÙAÚ�á*�ä� L &¿á*�ä�YÉ L }csfÌ � ��ÙAÚ��=Ø墫 ð � L ��� Û ��áLß?Þ>��â³­�Þ>�|Ý>��Ü�É2sA}OèñÌ�å�Ù?Û!ÞàÝçÞãÙ��a&���áAÛ�áJGvæàæ^Ü!Ú5&EÝ=��Ü��Ä­�Þ^Û�á*�|Þ^Û?Ù��$ÙAÚ åä��Þ^Û��L( : F Þ>�¾Þàæ½áLÚ�æ��$ ÞàÝ=�*É L }.sfÌ,ÚcÜ~å�æ½á��.Ü��O�K�$É L } L Ì $ ÞàÝ>�\Ý>��ܾÙ��Oß?ÞãÙ�!bÛõ����á*��â�Ü.Û+(Ù; N

` ö�ù: A�AðmLJ?ofV8`�]pH³��q[×A��NUnGe[e[F{NUKMFOW$KMD�V8KvKcDGF�H�VLxIFQÔÁPRFhV8a��,VLH�yOJ[xITG`pF!�6Àpu�VLNv]pHbKMSMJ�WGnGy{FOW$�fo�Ï�JfV8SMWGx�VLHIVLHGW

ÐvJ[eLKhu��Áqñ�ãu�yOJ[n�`^Wz��Fjy.D�V8HGe[FOWzKMJ¿KcDGV8K�JLX-ÔÁ�bn�VLNU]½È~yOV8KcF{e[J[S�o6ÀbKcJ¿NUKcSUFONUN�KcDGF�VLH�VL`pJ[eLo¾Pw]pKMDzyhVAKcFOeLJ[SM]pFON-å�Ü!ÚÛ?Ü&VLNQÔTÚYÙ?Û!Ý��.Ù��$�.Ü~å�ÝàÛ&á*�'�$ÚcÜ.Û"!�æÕÝZÛ¾Ù�6��MáLÝ~Üãâ�ÙAÚ���Ý>��Ü.ÙAÚ��ò�Má*���!Ü¿Ü{¨[ÝÒÜ��'��Ü���Ý~ÙO�+!�áAÛ!Þ � �MáLÝÒÜãâ�ÙAÚ�ÞãÜ.ÛfÀ½u���q[×A�2�d KQPRJ[nG`pW#D�Vhg[F��6F{FOHYHG]^y{F�KcJ�D�VhgLFIF��BTG`^J[SUFOW�mLJ?ofVL`2ÀÁN�PRJ[SUa³J[H#�bn�VLNU]½È~yOV8KcF{e[J[SU]^FONjx�J[SUF¿XZnG`p`po[u>FL��eG��Áq[×ñ�ãu��GnBK�KM]^xIF�WG]pW\H�JLK�VL`^`pJ?P ]½Kh�-CEDGFQXZJ[`p`^J?Pw]^H�e¿XZF{PÂNMFOy!Kc]pJ[HGNXxUnGNUK�NUa8VAKcF,KcDGF,NMn�SUXçVLy{F¼J8X�KMDGFQKcDGF{J[SUoL�k�Rlk Û�êpVÆbZ`or?l�VXWAY�[^]^_�`TY\b��V8KcF{e[J[SM]pFONjo�]pFO`^W*��nGVLNM] È~yhVAKcFOeLJ[SM]pFON�g�]^V�KcDGF¿HGFOS�g[F¾yOJLHGNUKMSMnGy!Kc]^JLH��Ö,�n�VLNM] È~yOV8KcF{e[J[SM]pFON�oB]pFO`pW*yhVAKcFOeLJ[SM]pFON�bozV�Ô�XZnGHGW�VLxIFOHfKcVL`>yOV8KcF{e[J[SUo�ÀByOJ[HGN�KcSUnGy{KM]^J[HzKMD�V8K�]pN�`pF{XàKEV8W�xUJ[]^HfK_KcJ¾HGF{SUgLFL�vCEDG]^N�yhVLH���Fjy{J[HGNUKMSMnGy!KcF{WnGNM]pHGejKcD�F�XZSMF{F�yhVAKcFOeLJ[SUo&e[FOH�FOScVAKcFOW¾�fo¼KcDGF�è{È~NUaLF{`^F{KMJ[H¾JLXäÛ&ufVLHGW&KcDGF{H�XçVLy{KMJ[SM]pHGejJ[nBK��fo�V�yOJ[HGeLSMnGF{HGyOFe[FOHGF{ScV8KMFOW³�fo�KMDGF&�GVLNM]py&SUFO`lVAKc]^JLHGN�¢^°A­QÜ â�u�J[HGF,XZJ[SwFhV8y.D*yOJLx�x�nBKc]^H�e\è!È~NMT�DGFOSUFzÉ>°�}�â�}�­�Ì�]^H3Û¿�EÏ_oVÞÝ � Û~åä��Ü!Ú.Ü$]^N&x�FOVLHfK¾V*x�VLT Ò5¢×ß � ��qA��� Û¿uKMD�n�N¾e[]pg�]^H�e�KcD�SMFOF�XçVLyOF{NOu�É;Ò<ð�}�Ò }2Ò � Ì&`^]pHGaLF{W|]^H'KMDGFJ[�fgB]pJ[nGN�P�Vho[�¼CEDGF�è{È~NUTGDGF{SMF¾]^NjNcVL]pW*KcJ���Fn�.Ù����e!�Ý2Þ>��â�]½X-KcDGF{SMF¾]pNQV�qñÈ~NU]^xITG`^F��6u¬�õ¯ Û � u�NMnGy.D#KMD�V8KÒ ¹ ¨åÇ ¹ ��XZJ[S ÅE¨ sA}Oè�}�qB�CEDG]pNjÔ�XZnGHGW�VLxIFOHfKcVL`>yOV8KcF{e[J[SUo�À�XZn�HGy{KMJ[SEVL`pNMJ�D�V8NEV¿g[F{SUo�HGFOV8KEWGF{NMy{SM]^TBKc]^JLH�WGnGFjKMJ�Ï�JfVLSUWGx$V8H�VLHGWÐvJ[eLKh��ÉZCEDGF,KcSMFOV8KcxIFOHfKwDGF{SMF¼]^NwVLWGVLT�KcF{W\XZSUJ[x ��q[×A�2�ëÌ

��F�VLNMNUnGx�Fwe[]½g[F{H�V,�bn�VLNU]½È~yOV8KcF{e[J[S�oõÛ¿���'SU]pKcF�°A­ � âI]½X-É>°'}�ât}�­�Ì�]pNvV¼y{J[xIx�n�Kc]pHGe�è{È NMTGD�FOSMF8�v�:F{Ky\}2z÷¯¬Û~ðjVLHGW\`^F{K�Û É=y\}2z�ÌƨÎ,?­¬¯¬Û 1�yò¨åÇ ­'}2zG¨HÇ(ð�­à3b�Rd XÆ­'}�°±¯¬Û É>y\}2zGÌ�u�KcD�FOH�u�NMn�e[e[FON�Kc]½g[FO`½oPwSM]pKM]^HGeGÙ9ð2y÷¨ è+Hfu4_ö�ù|ù: Bät��Ü�6hÙ�!BÚ,ÚcÜ!æ½áLÝ2ÞãÙ���Û®­�è+H � °¶&�°�è+H � ­�&vè+á9­ � °�á*�'�$è+á�° � ­4áLÚcÜ�Ü��+!�ÞàßAáLæ^Ü���Ý�( N

CEDGF,TGSUJBJ8X]pNEFhVLN�o[���FIPw]p`^`-NMV?o:­ãâ °#]pX�VLHfokJLX�KcD�FONMF�]^N,NcVAKc]^NT��FOW|VLHGW'yOVL`^`äâ¾u�KMDGF3��Ù��$ÙAÝ~Ù.å'�\Ú.Ü!æ½áLÝçÞãÙ����zd K&]^N¼VLH

FO�bnG]pg8VL`pFOHGy{F,SMFO`^V8Kc]pJ[H�J[HòÛ É>y\}2z�Ì!� � F!KpâäËXÛ É=y\}�zGÌƨ Û É=y\}�zGÌ{ågâ��d XD­Ä¯�Û É>y\}2zGÌ�uA°±¯�Û É6z'}�{fÌ�V8HGWnân¯¤Û É>y\}�{fÌ�uGKcDGF{H\KMDGF,SMFO`^V8Kc]pJ[H±°A­ � â�]^HGW�nGyOF{N�V¾x�VLTt¢

âäËXÛ É=y\}2z�Ìq�ÄâäËXÛ É6z'}�{fÌÆ� â�ËEÛ É>y\}�{fÌ�×� �ñó�"-ó�û9�Zú��çó�ò �ät��ÜÖ�Iá!å�Û

âäËXÛ É=y\}�zGÌq�ÄâäËXÛ É6z'}�{fÌÆ� âäËXÛ É>y\}�{fÌâLÞàßLÜ¿áò�.Ù��jå�Ù?Û!ÞàÝ2ÞãÙ��*æ½á $ 6hÙAÚ&á3�MáLÝÒÜãâ�ÙAÚ��K&EâäËXÛ7&_Ý>��Ü���Ù��$ÙAÝÒÙ.å'�±�MáLÝ~Üãâ�ÙAÚ���Ù�6 ÛA( Nè?t

Page 14: d¾PRJ[nG`^W `^]^a8F KMJ|KcDVLH a i FO]^H FOS ...hopf.math.purdue.edu/Porter/s-catsv2.pdfGKUKcFOWYKcJ[eLF{KcD FOS,NMJ KcDVAK&d KcDG]pHGa d_ FOeL]^H KMJ nGHGW FOSMN K.VLH WzKcDGFjP

æjX�yOJ[n�SMNMF8uéâ�ËEÛ4]^NKMDGF�XZnGHGWGVLx�F{HfK.VL`ByhV8KMFOe[J[S�o�JLX'Û<nGT�KMJQH�V8KMnGScVL`�]^NMJLx�J[SUTGDG]pNMx\��ü�SUJ[xÎT�SMF{g�]pJ[nGNyOJ[xIx�F{HfKcNEP�F¼D�Vhg[F?¢%¿ó��ñó�õ2õ= Z��# Öæ�+!�áAÛ!Þ � �MáLÝÒÜãâ�ÙAÚ��àÛÓÞ^Û¿á��¿á*�:�.Ù��jå�æ^Ü{¨IÞ 6&á*�'��Ù���æ��IÞ 6�â�ËEÛÄÞ^Û¿á¾âLÚcÙ�!?å�ÙAÞ6�c( N

k�R#ç èô]Sh ]ÆWA]qi�p l�]qfpY\_äY�ëqW!ëpY\_ ÉSY�bÏ�F{XZJ[SUF*]pHbKMSMJ�WGnGy{]^HGeYKcDG]pNIKMJ[TG]^y8uESMF{yhVL`p`�NUJ[xIF�JLXQKMDGF*]pHfKcnG]½Kc]^JLH���FOD�]^HGW4D�J[x�J8KcJ[Tfo�yOJLDGFOSUFOHfK�ÉçD���yL�ëÌWG]lVLeLScVLxINO�YÉZÊjefVL]pH�KMDGFOSUF$]^N&VLH|J?gLFOSUg�]pF{P JLX�KMDG]^N¼KcDGF{J[SUoY]^H4��t[×A�RVLHGWrV�KcDGJ[SUJ[nGe[D']^HfKcSUJBWGn�y{Kc]pJ[HY]^H�ÁqL�A�ã�ëÌ

 ~¡ �ù:"�õçö�û�ó4Ó~&�)½ïZ)¼÷E�= Gø��7 �ù|û0�2ò Ï~Ë�Ì )èñÌ�Ê WG]^VLe[SMVLxÄ]pHGWGF���F{W��fo�KMDGF,NMx�VL`^`6yhV8KMFOe[J[S�o[u���qA�2u

Í�ÉÒèñÌ éR � S##G

GGGGGGG

Í�É2s[Ì éR ð � S //

éR ð S é

R ð � S;;wwwwwwww Í�ÉãqLÌ

]^NwD���yL�v]pX�KcD�FOSMF,]pNENMT�FOyO] ��FOW*V¾DGJ[xIJLKcJ[TfoÍ�É2s�èñqLÌS¢<ø±��Í�ÉçsfÌÆ�ÃÍ�Éãq[Ì�}

Í�Éçs�èñq[Ìq¢�Í�Éçsfq[Ì�âHÍ�ÉÒèñq[̧Í�É2s�è?Ì�×q[Ìwü�J[S�V�WG]^VLe[ScV8x ]^HGW�F!�BFOW#�fo'��tA�o¢EÑ�SMVhP V$tAÈ NM]^xITG`pF!�6u�x$V8SMab]^HGe�KcD�F&g[F{SUKM]^yOF{N~Í�ÉçsfÌ!u��O�{�Ou�Í�É2tfÌ�u

KcDGF�F{WGe[F{NpÍ�É6ŹVBÌ�u>F!KcyL�½u>KMDGF&XçVLy{FONpÍ�É=ÅêVXÅGÌ�u>F{KMyL��CED�F¾DGJ[xIJLKcJ[T�]^FON�Í�É=ÅêVXÅGÌ���K�KcJ[eLF{KcD�FOS�KMJzx�VLaLF¿KMDGFNM]^W�FON�JLX�V¾NU��nGVLSMF

Í�ÉÒè?tf̧Í�É2s�è?Ìé

R �W\ Sé

R ð S// Í�Éãq8tfÌaÍ�ÉÒèñq[̧Í�É2s�è?Ì

Í�Éçs[tfÌé

R ð \ S OO éR ð �W\ S // Í�ÉãqLt[ÌaÍ�Éçsfq[Ì

éR �W\ S

éR ð � SOO

VLHGW�KcDGF,WG]^VLe[ScV8xÄ]pN�x�VLWGFQD>�Áy8�_�fo�NUT6F{yO]½XàoB]pHGeIVINUFOy{J[HGW*`pF{gLFO`:DGJ[xIJLKMJ[TfoÍ�É2s�è?qLtfÌq¢�ø � ��Í�É2sfÌÆ�ÃÍ�ÉçtfÌ

��`^`p]^HGe¿KMDG]^NwNU��nGVLSMF8�CEDGF{NMF�yhV8H ��F�yOJ[HfKM]^HbnGFOWrXZJ[S¾`^VLSMeLFOS�� L �2�5æjX�yOJ[n�SMNMF8uRKMDG]^N�]pN¾HGJLK¾D�JñPÄKcDGFzKMDGFOJLSUor]pN¿XZJ[SMx�VL`p`po

NMT�FOyO] ��FOW>u���n�K�]pKETGSUJ?gB]pWGFON�NMJLx�FQnGH�WGFOSUNUK.V8HGWG]^H�e�JLX�KcD�F¼�GVLNM]py¼]pWGFhVB�CEDGFwKcD�FOJ[S�o¾P�VLN_]^H�]pKc]^VL`^`½o,WGF{gLFO`pJ[T6F{W$�fo¾ÐvJ[eLKOu��Ú�*�L�ãufXZJ[`p`^J?Pw]^H�eQx�F!KcDGJ�WGNv]^HfKcSUJBW�nGyOF{WIPw]½KcD�Ï�JfVLSUWBÈ

x$VLH>u_�ÁqA�wÉçNMF{FIVL`^NUJzKcDGF¾SUF{XZFOSUFOHGy{FON&]^H³KcDGV8K,NMJ[n�SMyOF¾XZJ[SjJLKcDGF{SQFhVLSU`^]pFOS�T�V8T6F{SMNQJ[H#KcD�F�V8SMFhV[Ì!�¾��JLSMWG]pFOS�-�8��T�SMJ?g�]^WGF{N�V�NM]px�T�`^F È~yOV8KcF{e[J[SUo$KcDGF{J[SUozP�Vho�JLX�P�J[SUab]^HGe�Pw]pKMD\D>�Áy8�_W�]lVLe[SMVLxINEVLHGW\DGFOH�yOF¼SMFO`pFhVLNUFOWVLHYÔëVLSUNMFOHGVL`ãÀGJ8XyOV8KcF{e[J[SM]pyhVL`6KcJ�J[`^N�XZJ[S�PRJ[SUa�]pHGe¾Pw]pKMD\D>�Áy8�RWG]^VLe[SMVLx�N{� � JLx�F,JLX�KcD�VAKw]^N�PRJ[SMa8FOW*JLn�K�]^HKcDGF,T�VLT�FOSUNOu��Õè?s/ë�è?tA�

è9�

Page 15: d¾PRJ[nG`^W `^]^a8F KMJ|KcDVLH a i FO]^H FOS ...hopf.math.purdue.edu/Porter/s-catsv2.pdfGKUKcFOWYKcJ[eLF{KcD FOS,NMJ KcDVAK&d KcDG]pHGa d_ FOeL]^H KMJ nGHGW FOSMN K.VLH WzKcDGFjP

�>ó�ù'ö ` ö�û9��õàúñûÉZ]àÌ:d X'Íî¢�óH� Ê�Ë�Ì�]^N�V�yOJ[xIx�n�KcV8Kc]½g[F�W�]lVLe[SMVLx VLHGW�PRFESMF{TG`lV8yOF�NUJ[xIF�JLX�KcD�FqÍ�É;Ò�Ì��bo&DGJ[xIJLKMJ[Tfo

FO�bnG]pg8VL`pFOHfK�ÎzÉ6ÒBÌ�Pw]½KcD�NMT�FOy{] ��F{W�DGJLx�JLKMJ[Tfo�FO�bnG]½g8VL`^F{HGyOFQW�VAK.VA¢­�É6Ò�Ì ¢�Í�É;Ò�ÌÆ� Î$É;Ò�Ì�} °>É;Ò�Ìq¢(ÎzÉ6Ò�Ì^�ÃÍ�É6ÒBÌ

�rÉ6ÒBÌq¢�°>É6ÒBÌ�­�É;Ò�Ì�âåø�Çä} £�É;Ò�Ìq¢�­�É;Ò�̧°�É6Ò�Ì�âåøéÇä}KcDGF{H$P�F�yhVLH�yOJ[x¿�G]^HGFEKMDGFONUFjW�V8KcV&]pHbKMJ¼KMDGF�yOJ[HGN�KcSUnGy{KM]^J[H�JLX:V¼D��Áy8�-WG]lV8e[ScVLxsÎ �GVLNMF{WzJ[H�KMDGF�J[��xUFOy!KcNÎ�É;Ò�Ì�VLHGW\DGJ[xIJLKMJ[TfozyOJLDGFOSUFOHfKjx�VLTGN

­¤¢�Íg� Î�} °±¢(Î ��Í�}�F!Kcy8�pux$VLab]pHGe�Í V8HGW�Î D�J[x�J8KcJ[Tfo�F{��n�]pg8VL`^F{HfK�VLNwD��Áy8�vWG]lVLeLScVLxINO�

ÉZCEDG]^NE]pN,ÔÁSMFOVL`^`½o�ÀGV¾SMF{NMnG`½KjV8�6J[nBKw��nGVLNM] È~yhVAKcFOeLJ[SM]pFONOu�NMFOF$��q[×A�2� ÌÉZ]^]àÌ-ÐvJ[eLKOu��Ú�*�L�ã�d X^óì]^N,V�NUx$VL`p`�yhVAKcFOeLJ[SUoLu�KcDGF{SMFI]^N,V�yhV8KMFOe[JLSUo¬ÑÖË?â�É>ó®}�ÊòË�Ì�ÌjJ8X�D���yL�¾W�]lVLe[SMVLxINQVLHGWkDGJ[xIJLKMJ[Tfo

yO`lV8NMNMF{N�J8XD���yL�vx�VLTGNE��F{K~PRFOF{H*KcDGF{x��_þ\J[SMF{JñgLFOSwKcDGF{SMF¼]^NwVLH�F{��n�]pg8VL`^F{HGyOF,JLX�yhVAKcFOeLJ[SM]pFONÑÖË*â�É=ó®}�Ê÷Ë�Ì�ÌQì� �¤Ë�É6ÊõË�Ìaí�Ì

CEDG]^N�P�VLN�F!��KMFOHGWGF{W#SMF{TG`lVLy{]^HGewÊ�Ë�Ì*�fo�V�e[F{HGFOSMVL`�`^J�yhVL`p`poz�¼V8H�NU]^xITG`^]pyO]lV8`^`po�F{HGSM]py.DGFOW*yOJ[xITG`^F!KcF¼yhV8K�ÈFOe[J[S�o[u¶��u�]^H���éA�ã�

ÉZ]^]^]lÌR��JLSMWG]pFOS&É�è?é*�[sfÌ!u��-�A�ã�ÿQ]pgLFOH÷ó�u�V�NMx�VL`^`6yhV8KMFOe[J[S�o[u�KMDGFOH�KcD�F È yhV8KMFOe[J[S�o3ªwÉ=óRÌ�]^NENUnGy.D�KcD�V8K�V�D>�Áy8�_W�]lVLe[SMVLx JLX�K~oBT�F�ó

]^H3Ê�Ë�Ì\]pNEe[]pgLFOH\TGSMF{yO]^NUFO`½o��fo�VLH ÈãXZnGHGy{KMJ[Sñs¢�ªwÉ>ó�Ì�� Ê�Ë�Ì

CEDG]^N�NMnGe[eLFONUKMFOW*KMDGF¿F���KcFOH�NM]^JLH³JLX�D>�Áy8��W�]lVLe[SMVLxIN�KcJ$J8KcDGF{S�y{J[HfKcF!��KMN�NMnGy.D³VLN�V�e[FOH�FOScV8`�`pJByOVL`^`½oz�,VLH È yhV8KMFOe[J[S�o[u��ÅV8HGWkNMnGe[eLFONUKMN�KcDGF¾W�F���HG]½Kc]pJ[H³JLXvDGJLx�JLKMJ[Tfo*y{J[DGF{SMFOHfK,WG]^VLe[SMVLx�]^HkV È~yOV8KcF{e[J[SUo³VLHGWKcDbnGN�V�D>�Áy8�_H�FOSUgLF¿JLXVLH È~yhVAKcFOeLJ[SUoL�

/ öcÄ�ò��àú7�çó�ò Éã��J[SUWG]^F{S¼É�è?é��LsfÌ!u��Ú�8�2uG��VLNUFOW�J[H�FhVLSU`^]^F{S�]^W�FhVLNwJLX�ÐvJ[eLKOu�VLHGW�Ï�JfVLSUWGx�VLHBÈ ÐvJLeLKh�ëÌÿQ]pgLFOH V4NM]px�TG`p]^y{]lVL`p`po<F{HGSM]py.DGFOW yhV8KMFOe[JLSUo©��u¿KcD�F!��Ù��$ÙAÝ~Ù.å'�H�.Ù���Ü!ÚcÜ���ݱ�>Ü!Ú�ßLÜ�JLX��ju¿WGFOHGJ8KcFOWËD�9Ø9ý z ¾ z É2��Ì!u�]pN�KcDGF,NM]px�T�`^]^y{]lVL`:ÔÁNMF!KhÀGPw]pKMD

ËD�9Ø9ý z ¾ z É#�EÌa¦Ó¨ ��ÑÓÒ�Ô{Éoªw� L �;}��EÌ�×C�J�nGHGWGF{SMN�K.VLHGWkNU]^xITG`^F&D��Áy8�&W�]lVLe[SMVLxINjVLH�W³KcDbnGN7ËD�9Ø9ý z ¾ z É#�EÌ�u>P�F¾Pw]p`^`�nGHGT�V8y.a*KcDGF¿WGF���H�]pKc]pJ[H#JLXDGJ[xIJLKcJ[Tfo�y{J[DGF{SMFOH�yOFL�CEDGFw��SMN�K�KcDG]pHGe*KMJ³HGJLKMFz]^N¼KcD�V8K&XZJ[S�V8Hbo L VLH�W�s_ª ÅAPÎViª L u^ªw� L �~É=Å�}WV�Ìe�¨

��ÕèO�<î � ¹ � u�KMDGFÉ]V���ÅZ��èñÌ~È yOnG��F�eL]pg[F{H$�foIKcDGF�TGSMJ�WGnGy!K�JLX¶V��nÅZ�'è�yOJ[T�]^FONRJLX � �ÕèO�ã�CED�n�N�P�FjyhVLH�SMFOW�nGyOFjKMDGFjD�]^e[DGF{S

DGJ[xIJLKcJ[Tfo�WGV8K.V�KcJ���FO]pHGe~xUnGNUKwKcDGV8KhuGx�VLTGNEXZSUJ[xÓDG]pe[DGF{SEWG]^xIFOHGNU]^J[HGVL`>y{nG�6F{NO�Ç�F!��K�NMJ[xIF,HGJLK.VAKc]^JLHt¢ÿQ]pgLFOH�NM]px�TG`p]^y{]lVL`�x�VLTGN

­ ¢(£ � ��É=y\}2z�Ì�}èñ×

Page 16: d¾PRJ[nG`^W `^]^a8F KMJ|KcDVLH a i FO]^H FOS ...hopf.math.purdue.edu/Porter/s-catsv2.pdfGKUKcFOWYKcJ[eLF{KcD FOS,NMJ KcDVAK&d KcDG]pHGa d_ FOeL]^H KMJ nGHGW FOSMN K.VLH WzKcDGFjP

­ � ¢(£ � �E�QÉ=z�}�{[Ì�}P�F,Pw]^`p`>WGF{HGJLKcF,KcD�F¼y{J[xIT6J[NU]pKMF

£ �¬£ � � ��É=y\}2z�Ì��0�QÉ=z�}�{[Ì ¾� �QÉ>y\}�{fÌxUnGNUK��fod­ � ׶­ JLS÷­ � ­ � Éà�'F*VL`^SUFhVLW�o�D�VhgLF#NMFOF{H4KcDG]pN$]pH KcD�F³D���yL�ÃWG]^VLe[SMVLx VL��JñgLF*XZJ[SGóè �Öt8�2�Í�É�èñq8tfÌaÍ�Éçs�èñÌR]pNwVLy{KMn�VL`p`poGÍ�É�èñq8tfÌOÉ=ø³��Í�Éçs�èñÌUÌ!u�PwDG]p`^N�K Í�ÉãqLt[ÌaÍ�Éçs�èñq[Ìv]^NEF!��VLy!Kc`½ozPwD�V8K�]pKwN�K.V8KMFON{� Ì� n�TGT6JLNMF,HGJ?PÃKcDGV8KEP�F¼D�Vhg[FQKMDGF,D��Áy8�RW�]lVLe[SMVLxjñs¢�ªwÉ=ó�Ì�� �j�vCEDG]pNE]^NwVLH È XZnGHGy!KcJ[S�VLH�W�NUJZ¢KcJIFhVLy.D\J[��xUF{y{K~Ò�JLX�ó�u�]½KwVLNUNM]^eLHGN�VLH�JL��xUFOy!K~ñ�É;Ò�Ì�JLXÍ�jÆXZJ[SEFhVLy.D�NUKMSM]^H�eIJ8Xy{J[x�T�J[NMVL�G`^FQx�VLTGNE]pH÷ó�u

.�¨ÍÉo­�ðK}9×9×9×�}�­7¦[ÌNUK.V8SUKc]pHGeIV8K®ÒzVLH�W�F{HGWG]^H�e�VAK*�ñu�V�NM]px�T�`^]^y{]lVL`�x�VLT

ñ�É2.�Ìq¢�ªwÉ=óRÌ{É2sA} L [�èñÌ�� ��É;ñ�É;Ò�Ì�}2ñ$É2�{ÌUÌ�}KcD�V8K�]pNOu�V¾DG]pe[DGFOSED�J[x�J8KcJ[Tfo

ñ�É2.�Ìq¢ � �ÕèO� ¦ � ��É;ñ�É;Ò�Ì�}�ñ�É �!ÌUÌ�}NMnGy.D\KcD�V8K

ÉZ]àÌR]½XÆ­7ð�¨ ÅeÇ�u�ñ$É#.�Ìƨåñ�É ß<ð�.�Ì{É ÌäØ?Ë"V³� � � è{� ¦ � ÌÉZ]^]àÌv]pXD­ ¹ ¨ÝÅoÇ�u�s�P�ÅäP Lñ$É#.�Ìƨåñ�É ß ¹ .-ÉT×^É6ø ¹ �0ï´�¤ø ¦ � ¹ Ì�}

PwDGFOSUFMï ¢<ø � ��øz]^N�KMDGF,x�nG`pKM]^TG`p]^yOV8Kc]½g[F�NUKcSUnGy{KMnGSMF¼J[Hòø0¨��ÕèO���fo�KcD�F�ÔÁx�VA�6À�XZnGHGy!Kc]^JLH\JLH�,Asé}hè�3bÆ

ÉZ]^]^]lÌv]½XÆ­�¦Ó¨ÝÅoÇ�u�ñ�É2.:Ìƨåñ$É2ß�¦�.�Ì�ÆÉZ]pg�Ì ¹ ñ�É2.�ÌK1 É=ø ¹ � �~,As�3õ�nø ¦ � ¹ Ì�¨Hñ�É ß ¹ .�Ì�}hè7ª!Å�ª L �<è[ÆÉàgGÌ ¹ ñ$É#.�Ì/1ÕÉ6ø ¹ � �=,bè�3��¤ø ¦ � ¹ Ì^¨Hñ$É#.¬ð¹ Ì�×|ñ�É2. ¹ Ì�u�PwDGFOSUFM. ¹ ¨ É;­�ð9}9×K×9×K}�­ ¹ � VLHGW�.¬ðZ¨ÍÉo­ ¹ }9×9×K×�}�­�¦fÌ���'F,D�Vhg[F¼nGNUFOW0ß ¹ XZJ[S�KMDGFQXçVLyOF,J[T�FOSMV8KcJ[SUNE]^H�KcD�F¼H�FOSUgLF&J8XXów�CEDGF,NUT6F{yO] �GyhV8KM]^J[H�JLX�NMnGy.D*VID�J[x�J8KcJ[Tfozy{J[DGF{SMFOHfK�WG]lV8e[ScVLx yhV8H���F,NMTG`p]pKE]pHbKMJ¾K~P�JIT�VLS�KcNK¢

É2VfÌ�NMT�FOy{] ��yOV8Kc]pJ[H�JLX�yOFOS�K.VL]pH�DGJ[xIJLKcJ[Tfo$yOJ[DGF{SMF{HbK,Û!Þ>�jå�æÕÞo�.Ü.Û!u�]2�ÁF8�-FO`pFOxIFOHfKcNw]^HQ˽�9Ø9ý z ¾ z É2��Ì!ÆVLHGWÉç��Ì�NMT�FOy{] ��yOV8Kc]pJ[H�u�g�]^V¾VINU]^xITG`^]pyO]lV8`�x�VLTGT�]^HGe¿XZSUJ[xñ˽�9ØGÉ>óEÌjKMJ�˽�9Ø9ý z ¾ z É2��Ì!u�JLX�DGJ?PÂKMDGFONUF&]pHGWG]½gB]pWGn�VL`T�VLSUKMN&ÉZXZSMJLx É2VfÌUÌ�JLX�KcDGF,WG]^VLe[ScV8xÓVLSUF,e[`^nGF{W�KcJ[e[F!KcDGF{SO�

CEDGF�NMF{yOJ[H�W$T�VLS�KvJLX>KMDG]^N-]pNvFhVLN�o�VLNv]pK_VLxIJ[nGHfKMNvKMJ¼V¼NU]^xITG`^]pyO]lV8`�x�VLTLËD�9Ø�É=ó�Ì�� ˽�9Ø9ý z ¾ z É2��Ì!u�VLHGWNMJ�PRFzV8SMFI`^F{XàKQPw]½KcDYKcDGF0��SMN�K¿TGVLSUKO�$CEDGFIXZJ[`^`pJñPw]pHGezKcD�FOJ[SUFOx P�VLN¿TGSUJ?g[FOW'�bo���JLSMWG]pFOS&VLHGWYx¿o�NMFO`½XÒu�Gn�KwKcDGF,]pWGFhV�P�VLN�F{NMNUFOHfKc]^VL`^`½oz]^H\Ï�J[VLSMWGx�VLH�VLH�W\ÐvJ[e8KhÀ�NE`^FOy!KcnGSUF,HGJLKcF{NOu�`^]paLF�NUJ�x¿nGy.D�F{`^NUFL�J &�ö�ó��ñö�ù : �Wò{��;�#6B�ÍÞ^Û¿áIæ^Ù��MáLæàæ����¿á*� �� �MáLÝ~Üãâ�ÙAÚ���Ý=��Ü��9ËD�9Ø9ý z ¾ z É2��̼Þ^Û&á��+!�áAÛ!Þ � �MáLÝ~Üãâ�ÙAÚ���( N

d K�NMF{FOxINEKcJ��6FQKMDGF,yhVLNUF¼KMD�V8K�]pXà��]^NEJ[H�`po�`pJByOVL`^`½oIPRFhV8a�`½o��,VLH�uGKMDGFOH½ËD�9Ø9ý z ¾ z É#�EÌ�HGF{FOW*H�JLK��6F,V��nGVLNM] È~yhVAKcFOeLJ[SUoL�

è?�

Page 17: d¾PRJ[nG`^W `^]^a8F KMJ|KcDVLH a i FO]^H FOS ...hopf.math.purdue.edu/Porter/s-catsv2.pdfGKUKcFOWYKcJ[eLF{KcD FOS,NMJ KcDVAK&d KcDG]pHGa d_ FOeL]^H KMJ nGHGW FOSMN K.VLH WzKcDGFjP

CEDGFwTGSUJBJ8X6J8X�KMDGFEKcDGF{J[SMF{x ]^N]^H¾KcDGFETGVLT6F{SOu��Öé8��VLH�WI]pN-HGJLK-KMJBJQy{J[x�T�`^F!�6��CEDGFwFONMNUFOHfKc]^VL`GXZFhVAKcnGSUF�]pNKcD�V8K�KcD�F,gLFOS�o�W�F���HG]½Kc]pJ[H�ÉçnGHGTGVLy.aLF{W³g[FOSUNM]pJ[H�ÌEJLX�DGJLx�JLKMJ[Tfo�yOJLDGFOSUFOHfKjW�]lVLe[SMVLxÓx�VLa8FON�]pK�yO`pFhVLS�KMD�V8KT�VLSUKMNwJLX�KMDGF,W�V8KcVID�VhgLF,KMJ���FQyOJLx�T�J[NMF{W\KMJ[e[F!KcDGF{SOu�ÉçSUFOyOVL`^`>KMDGF,yOJ[xIT�J[NM]½Kc]^JLHzJLX�NM]^xITG`p]^yO]^VL`�x$V8TGN

­ ¢(£ � ��É=y\}2z�Ì�}­ � ¢(£ � �E�QÉ=z�}�{[Ì�}

VL�6J?gLF¿VLH�W�DGJ?PÂ]^xIT6J[S�K.VLHfKRKcD�V8KwP�VLNw]^H�KcD�F¼n�HGT�VLy.a8FOW³WGF���HG]½Kc]^JLH�Ì!���F³KcDbnGN�D�Vhg[F#KMD�V8K�VrDGJ[xIJLKMJ[Tfo�y{J[DGFOSUFOHfK\WG]lV8e[ScVLx ÔÁ]^NOÀ�VrNM]^xITG`p]^yO]^VL`Ex�VLT ñ ¢g˽�9ØGÉ>ó�Ì5�ËD�9Ø9ý z ¾ z É2��ÌRVLH�W$KcD�VAK@ËD�9ØKý z ¾ z É2�EÌ_]^NRV¿�bn�VLNM] È~yOV8KcF{e[J[SUoL�^æjX:yOJ[n�SMNMF8u�KcD�F�nGNMnGVL`6T�SMJ�JLX:KcD�VAKhu�]pXtÍ V8HGW÷Î

VLSMF¾NU]^xITG`^]pyO]lV8`:NMF{KMNOu�VLHGWÄÎ ]pNQ�,VLH�u>KMDGFOH É=Í�}�ξÌj]^N��¼V8HkVLNjPRFO`^`2u�F!��KMFOHGWGNQKMJ\DGV?g�]pHGeòÎ V��bn�VLNM] ÈyhV8KMFOe[J[S�o�VLH�W�KMDGFQSMF{NMnG`½Kw�6F{]^HGe�V��bn�V8NM]½È yhV8KMFOe[JLSUo[���vVLSU`^]pFOSRPRF,SMF!XZFOSMSUFOW�KcJGÑÖË*â�É>ó�}5�EÌj]^H�y{J[HGHGF{y{KM]^J[HPw]pKcD�ÐvJ[eLKOÀÁN¾KcD�FOJ[SUFOx\��CEDGF�HGFhV8KIP�V?o�J8X�]^HfKMSMJ�WGnGyO]pHGekKcDG]pNI]pNIVLN±âäË É Ë½�9ØGÉ>ó�Ì�}5˽�7ØKý z ¾ z É2�EÌUÌ!u�KMDGFXZnGHGW�VLxIFOHfKcVL`�yhVAKcFOeLJ[SUo*JLXvKcDGF�XZnGH�y{Kc]pJ[H#�bn�VLNU]½È~yOV8KcF{e[J[S�o[�¼d~H³XçVLy{KOu�KcDG]pN�]^N�F{NMNUFOHfKc]^VL`^`½o�KMDGF�P�Vho³ÐvJLeLK��SMN�KjWGF{NMy{SM]^��FOW\]pKO�

Ï�F!XZJ[SMFwPRFj`^FOVhg[F�DGJ[xIJLKcJ[Tfo¾y{J[DGF{SMFOH�yOFLuBKcDGF{SMF�]^NRV¼T�J[]^HfKvKcDGV8K�]pN-P�J[S�KcD�HGJLKc]pHGe,XZJ[S-KcDGF�`^]pHGabN_Pw]½KcDVL`^e[F{�GScV8]^y¼VLHGW³yOV8KcF{e[J[SU]^yhV8`�xIJ�WGFO`pNwXZJLS�DGJLx�JLKMJ[Tfo�K~oBT�FON{�jCEDGF È yhV8KMFOe[JLSM]^F{NOu$ªw� L �ãu6yOJ[HfK.V8]^H³VI`^JLK�JLXKcDGF�]^HBXZJ[SMx�V8Kc]pJ[H'H�FOFOW�FOW�XZJ[S�KcDGF�y{J[HGN�KcSMn�y{Kc]pJ[H�JLX�NMnGy.D�x�J�WGF{`^NO��Ê�e[J�JBWrF��GV8x�TG`pFzJLX�KcDG]pN�]^N�KMDGF]^HfKcF{SMy.D�VLH�e[F&`^VhPÃVLH�W�]½KcNE`^]pHGabN�Pw]pKMD³ÿQScVho$yhV8KMFOe[J[SU]^F{N�V8HGW�ÿ,SMV?oze[SMJ[n�T6J[]pWGNO�

��J[H�NM]^W�FOSƪw� �L�2�CEDGF�]px�T�J[S�K.VLHfK�]^H�XZJLSMx�V8Kc]pJ[HQ]^N�]^H&KMDGF�NU]^xITG`^]pyO]^VL`[NMF!K�ªw� �L�~ÉçsA}2�bÌ���CED�]^N]pNVjtAÈ~y{nG�6F8uNMJ¿]pN-NUKM]^`^`�SMFhV8NMJ[H�V8�G`po¾FOVLNUo¾KMJQgB]pNMn�V8`^]^NUFL�i�FOSUF�]½Kv]^N{�CEDGF�HGJLKcV8Kc]pJ[H�]^N-HGJLK_]pHbKMFOHGW�FOW�KMJ,�6FwyOJLx�TG`pF{KMFO`poyOJ[HGNU]^N�KcFOHfK�Pw]pKMD\FOVLSM`p]^F{S�nGNMF{N���n�K�]^NExIFhVLHfKwKcJ���F¼xIJ[SUFQNMFO`½XF��BTG`lVLHGV8KcJ[S�o[�

É2s�è?ÌOÉ�èhtfÌOÉçt*�bÌ // É2s�èñÌ{É�èñqLÌOÉãq8tfÌOÉçt*�bÌ

É2sBèñÌOÉÒè9�bÌ //

77ooooooooooo É2sBèñÌOÉÒèñq[ÌOÉ2q?�bÌ55kkkkkkkkkkkkkk

Éçs[tfÌ{É2t*�bÌ //

OO

Éçsfq[ÌOÉ2qLtfÌ{É2t*�bÌ

OO

É2s*�bÌ //

77oooooooooooo

OO

É2sfq[Ì{Éãq?�fÌ55kkkkkkkkkkkkkk

OO

CEDG]^NR`^J�J[abN_x&oBN�KcF{SM]^JLnGNO��ÊH�8È~NU]^xITG`^F��¾D�V8N�×Qg[FOS�Kc]pyOFON{uGVLH�W$DGF{HGyOF�×,KcF!KcSMVLDGFOW�ScVL`�XçVLyOF{NO���vVLy.D�JLX�KcD�F�×KcF{KMScVLD�FOWGSMVL`�XçVLyOF{NEPw]^`^`6yOJ[HfKMSM]^��n�KcF¼V¾NM�bn�VLSUF¼KMJ¾KcDGF¼VL��J?g[F,WG]lV8e[ScVLx\ubo[F{KjV¾yOnG��F,D�VLN��¾NM�bn�VLSUFQXçVLyOF{NO�ÉçCEDG]pHGe[N¼e[F{K�Ô�P�J[SUNMF8À�]pH�ªw��×A�~ÉçsA}�×[Ì�u:PwDG]^y.D�]^N¼V3�AÈ~yOn��6F8u�NUJ*D�VLNÖ��yOnG��FON¿VLN¼]pKcNQXçVLy{FON{u��GnBK

���×A�_D�VLN

J[HG`po��¾XçV8yOFON{� Ì�Ï�VLy.a�KcJ�KcDGF,F!��KMScV¾XçVLyOF8uGKcDG]pNE]^NÉ2sBèñÌOÉÒèñq[ÌOÉ2q?�bÌ R ð S R � S R �W\�ó S // Éçs�èñÌ{É�èñq[Ì{ÉãqLt[ÌOÉ2t?�bÌ

É2sfq[Ì{Éãq?�fÌ R ð � S R �W\�ó S //

R ð � S R ��ó SOO

R ð � S R �W\�ó SÉ2sfqLÌOÉãq8tfÌOÉçt*�bÌ�×

R ð � S R �W\ S R \�ó SOO

è/b

Page 18: d¾PRJ[nG`^W `^]^a8F KMJ|KcDVLH a i FO]^H FOS ...hopf.math.purdue.edu/Porter/s-catsv2.pdfGKUKcFOWYKcJ[eLF{KcD FOS,NMJ KcDVAK&d KcDG]pHGa d_ FOeL]^H KMJ nGHGW FOSMN K.VLH WzKcDGFjP

CEDGF¿V8SMSMJ?PìÉ2s�èñqLÌq¢�É2sfq[Ì�� É2s�è?ÌOÉ�è?q[ÌRPw]^`p`ãu�]^H\VID�J[x�J8KcJ[Tfozy{J[DGF{SMFOHfK�WG]lV8e[ScVLx\u�x�VLa8F¼]½KcNwVLT�T6FOVLSMF{HGyOFVLNEKcDGF,DGJ[xIJLKMJ[Tfo[u

Í�É2s�èñqLÌS¢<ø±��Í�ÉçsfÌÆ�ÃÍ�Éãq[Ì�}Í�Éçs�èñq[Ìq¢�Í�Éçsfq[Ì�âHÍ�ÉÒèñq[̧Í�É2s�è?Ì�}

KcDbnGNwKcDG]pN�NM�bn�VLSUF&]px�T�`^]^F{N_KMD�V8KEKMDGF,DGJ[xIJLKcJ[T�]^FON^Í�É2sBèñq[Ì�VLH�W3Í�É2qLt*�bÌ_]^HfKcF{ScVLy!Kwx�]pHG]^x�VL`^`½o[��Ñ�SMV?Pw]pHGeKcDGF{x VLN¼qñÈ yOF{`^`^N�]^H³KMDGF�nGNUn�VL`P�Vho[u�KMDGF¾NM�bn�VLSUF�P�F�D�VhgLF�VL�6J?gLF¾]^NjKMDGF�]^HfKMFOSMy.DGVLHGe[F¾NU��nGVLSMF�VLH�WkKMDGF]^HfKcF{SMy.D�VLH�e[F¾`lVhP Pw]^`p`�DGJL`^W#]^H³KMDG]^NjNUo�NUKMFOx TGSUJ?gB]pWGFOW#KMDG]^N�NU�bn�VLSMF¾]pNOu�]pH#NMJ[xIF�NUFOHGNUFLu�yOJ[xIx�n�KcV8Kc]½g[F8�d~HYxIJ�WGFO`pN�XZJ[S�DGJ[xIJLKcJ[Tfo L ÈãK~oBT�FON�XZJLS L �ÎtBu6KcD�FONMF¾]pHfKcFOSUy.D�VLHGeLF¾NM�bn�VLSUFON,e[]pgLF�T�VLS�K�JLXvKMDGF�T�VL]pSM]pHGeNUKcSUnGy{KMnGSMF��6F!K~P�F{FOHrWG]½ê>F{SMF{HbK&`^F!g[F{`^N,JLX�KMDGFIx�J�WGFO`2��CED�F{o�VLSMF�KcD�FOSMFI]^H>u�NMVho[u�KMDGF$��J[HGWGnGy.DRËFzx�J�WGF{`ÉãqñÈ yOSMJLNMNMF{W�x�J�WGnG`pFON.ÌvVLN�KMDGF�í�FO]½ê>F{S�`^]½XàKc]^H�eGu�Éçy!XÒ�_��J[HGWGnGy.DRËFLu��ÙbA�àÌ_VLHGWz]pH$KcD�FQ�:JBW�VhoIxIJBWGF{`ãu>Éçy{SMJ[NUNMFOWNM�bn�VLSUFONOu:y!XÒ�¾�Öt[s8�lÌ!u6VLN�KMDGF0âBÈ~x�VLT��wd~H#V�e[FOHGF{ScVL`�WG]^xIFOH�NM]^JLH�u L u6KMDGFOSUF&Pw]p`^`��6F&T�VL]pSM]^H�e[N�`p]^a8F¼KMDG]^N�XZJ[SVLHfo�NMTG`p]pKMKM]^HGe¿JLX�,Asé}hè�}9×9×K×�} L 3¿J8X�KMDGFQXZJ[SMxô,Asé×pè�×K×9×9×�}8Å�3¿VLHGW�,�Å�}9×9×9×�} L 3b�õ öø÷ ¤IªQ±¹¬ù ¢�¤ ¢ ¢¿    °�«Òú ¶|°�«�¢¿µh�h¡¢¼¬-�O°I¤iûÍ  °I±vª ¡��h  £#µh�O«��O¢¿µhµ'¤

ªQ¤#±v�h«R²³ªQ¥ «w¢&¬ª�·�°I±_�{ªQ¡*¥d~H�DG]pN�J[SU]^e[]pH�VL`�yOJ[HfKcSU]^�GnBKc]^JLHY��t[�A�>KcJIVL��NUKcSMVLy{KwD�J[x�J8KcJ[TfoIKcDGF{J[SUoLu',Qn�]^`^`pFOHz]pHfKcSMJ�WGnGy{FOW�KcD�FQHGJLKc]pJ[H�JLXV¤�$ÙK��Ü!æ��MáLÝ~Üãâ�ÙAÚ��8� � nGy.DYVzy{J[HfKcF!��K,]pN�VzyhVAKcFOeLJ[SUoLu�ÑIu6KcJ[e[F!KcDGF{SjPw]pKMD³KcDGSUFOF�y{`lVLNUNMF{NQJLX_x$VLT�NK¢wP�FOVLaFO�bnG]pg8VL`pFOHGy{FON{u@� ¨ ÑÒü z  z Æ����GSMV8Kc]pJ[HGN{uq­'Å��n¨gÑ Â�¹ ^ ÆEVLHGW�yOJ*�G�GScV8KM]^J[H�NOu ¿ Ë?­�Å��3¨ Ñ�¾ � Â2¹ ^ u_NcV8KM]^N�XàoB]pHGeyOFOS�K.VL]pH4VA�B]pJ[x�N¾NUJ'V8NIKMJ�e[]½g[F�VYeLFOHGF{ScVL`EXZScV8x�F!P�J[SUa'XZJ[S�ÔÁWGJ[]^H�e�DGJLx�JLKMJ[Tfo|KcD�FOJ[S�o6À½� æ�HGF\JLXjKMDGFyOJ[HGN�KcSUnGy{KM]^J[HGN¼DGF�nGNUFOW�P�VLN&V�yhV8KMFOe[J[SU]^yOVL`�`^J�yhV8`^]^NMV8Kc]pJ[H³V8`^SMFOVLW�o³PRFO`p`-abHGJ?PwH�XZSMJLx ÿ,VL�GSM]pFO`2ÀÁN�KMDGFONU]^NVLHGW�KMDGF�P�J[SUakJLX�KMDGFzü�SMF{HGy.D'NUy.DGJ�J[`vJLXwVL`pe[FO�GSMVL]^y¾eLFOJ[xIF{KMFOSMN{u�É2ÿ,SUJLKcD�FOHGWG]pFOy.a�u�ÐvF{SMWG]pFOS{u�F!KcyL�ëÌ<VLHGWyOJ[HGy{nGSMSUFOHfKc`½o�Pw]½KcD*KMDGF¿T�nG�G`^]pyhV8KM]^J[H\JLX��Öt[�8�2u�NUKcn�WG]^F{W#]^H*NUJ[xIF&WGF{T�KcD#�fo³ÿ¼V8�GSM]pFO`�VLHGW0�>]^NMx�VLH�u���qLs8�2�CEDGFzx�VL]^HkT�J[]^HfK,P�V8N&KcDGV8K&KMDGFzV8H�VL`^JLe[nGFON,JLX�DGJ[xIJLKcJ[TfokF{��n�]pg8VL`^F{HGyOF{NOu�]^HY]^xIT6J[S�K.VLHfK¼]^H�NUK.V8HGyOF{N¿JLXDGJ[xIJLKcJ[T�]^yhV8`�J[S�DGJ[xIJ[`^J[eL]^yhV8`�VL`pe[FO�GSMV�uGPRFOSMF&J[HG`½o³ÔÁPRFhV8a\F{�bnG]pg8VL`pFOHGy{FONOÀ�NMJIPwDG]^`pNUKwPw]pKMD*V�DGJ[xIJLKMJ[TfoFO�bnG]pg8VL`pFOHGy{F&��F{K~PRFOF{H³K~P�J�NMT�V8yOFON{u6oLJ[n³VLSUF&eL]pg[F{H\K~PRJzx�VLTGN{u�J[HGF¼]^H\FhVLy.D³W�]^SMF{y{KM]^J[H�u�TG`^nGN�JLXyOJ[nGSUNMFNMJ[xIF¾DGJ[xIJLKcJLTG]^F{NOu>PwDGF{HYoLJ[nkD�Vhg[F8u�XZJLSQ]^HGN�K.VLHGy{FLu�Vz�bn�VLNU]½È ]^NMJLx�J[SUTGDG]pNMx��6F!K~P�F{FOHYK~P�J\y.D�VL]pH#yOJ[x¾ÈTG`^F���F{NOu�oLJ[n#J[HG`½o�DGVLW³J[HGF¿x$VLT�]^H³JLHGF�WG]pSMFOy!Kc]pJ[Ht¢®­�¢�ÑÐ� á¨KcJ[eLF{KcD�FOSjPw]½KcD*KMDGF�abHGJ?Pw`^F{WGe[F¿KMD�V8K­�ý0¢���ýñÉ;Ñ&Ì�� ��ý?É6á�ÌjP�VLN&VLHY]^NUJ[x�JLSMTGDG]pNMx\�¾CEDGFIT�VLSUKM]lVL`NMJ[`pn�Kc]pJ[H³P�V8N¼KMJ�e[J�KcJ�KcD�F�ÔÁDGJ[xIJLKMJ[TfoyhV8KMFOe[J[S�o�À:�bo*XZJ[SMx�VL`^`½o�]^Hfg[F{SUKM]^HGezKMDGF¾P�FOVLa³FO�bnG]½g8VL`^F{HGyOF{NOu:KcDbnGN,e[F!KMKc]pHGezXZJ[SUx$VL`�x�VLTGNQe[J[]pHGe�]^H³KMDGFJ[TGT�J[NM]½KcF¼WG]^SUFOy{KM]^J[H>��ÉZCEDG]^N�x$Vho�`pJBJLa$`^]paLF,y.DGFOV8Kc]pHGeGu��Gn�K�SMFOVL`^`½oz]^N�HGJ�P�JLSMNMF¼KcD�V8H*]^HfKMSMJ�WGnGyO]pHGe¾XZScVLy�ÈKc]^JLHGNQ]^HfKcJzKMDGF¾]^HfKMFOe[F{SMNOu:NUJ\VLNQKcJ���F�VL�G`^F&KcJ�NMJ[`½g[F¾y{FOSUKcVL]^H#F{�bn�V8Kc]pJ[HGN{u�V8HGWkJLX_yOJ[nGSUNMF¾KcD�F¾WGF{KcVL]^`pFOWyOJ[HGN�KcSUnGy{KM]^J[H\]^NEy{`^J[NUFO`po$SMF{`lV8KMFOW��ëÌ¿�'FQKcDbnGN�FOH�W�nGT�Pw]pKMD\VIyOV8KcF{e[J[SUo÷Ñ$�Ù� � �ã�CEDG]pN,yOJ[HGN�KcSUnGy{KM]^J[Hk]^NQgLFOSUokn�NMF{XZn�`ãu��Gn�K,KcD�]^NQDGJ[xIJLKMJ[Tfo³yhVAKcFOeLJ[SUo#W�JBF{NG�>ÙAÝjyhVLT�KMnGSMF�KcD�FID�]^e[DGF{SJ[SMWGF{SDGJLx�JLKMJ[Tfo¼]^H�XZJ[SUx$VAKc]^JLHQ]^xITG`^]pyO]pK�]^HõÑ���ü�JLS�]pHGNUKcVLHGyOF8uLKcD�F�TGSUJ[�G`^F{xÅJLX�KcD�F�ÔÁ�6F{NUKhÀñP�V?o¼KcJ�D�VLHGW�`^FDGJ[xIJLKcJ[TfoI`^]px�]½KcNvVLH�WzyOJ[`p]^xI]pKMNOufVLH�Wzx�JLSMF�e[FOHGF{ScVL`p`po�WGF{SM]½g[FOW��,VLH�F!��KcF{HGNM]pJ[HGN{uG]^H$V¿x�J�WGF{`�yOV8KcF{e[J[S�oNMF{KUKc]pHGej]pN�N�Kc]^`p`fyOF{HbKMScVL`�KcJ�x�nGy.D¿J8XGKcDGF_P�JLSMa,J[H¾VL��NUKcSMVLy{K�DGJ[xIJLKMJ[TfoQKcDGF{J[SUoLu�Éçy!XÒ�ä��Ü.Û�þvÿÜ!Ú�ÞàßAáLÝ~Ü"!BÚcÛ!uñ�foÿ,F{J[SMe[FEþ*VL`pKMNM]pHG]^JLKM]^N{uG�Öt�èO�BNMF{FwVL`^NUJI��tfqñ�ãufÑ�F{HG]^NÒÈ���D�V8SM`^F{N-��]pNM]^H�NMab]ãÀ�NKcD�FONM]pNOubVLH�W¾NMnG�GNUFO�bnGF{HbK_PRJ[SMa�u�Éçy!XÒ��Á×BuM�8�vVLH�WYSUFO`^V8KcF{W#T�VLT�FOSMNcÌ!u�KMDGF¾SMF{NMnGx�ËF�JLX_CEDGJ[x�VLNMJ[H>ÀÁNQHGJ8KcF¾��JBJ[abN�T�nG�G`^]pNMDGF{Wk�bo#��DbnGy.a³�'F{]^��FO`2u�Ú�f�A�V8HGW³��V8SM`^JLN � ]^xITGNMJ[H>ÀÁN{u�Öt[é8�2u�XZJ[SwF!��VLxITG`^FhÌ!�Rd~H³V�NMFOSU]^F{N�JLX�VLSUKM]^y{`^FON&�Õèñ×Kë�èKbA��TGnG�G`p]^NUDGFOW\]^HYè?é��[sBuÑjPEo[FOSRVLHGWI�,VLHITGSMJLT6J[NUFOW�VQHGFhV8K_NUJ[`^n�KM]^J[H�KMJQKcDG]pN-TGSMJ[��`^FOx\u[NU]^xITG`^]pyO]lV8`�`pJByOVL`^]pNcV8KM]^J[H�NO�:�'FEPw]p`^`�`p]^xI]pKJ[nGSMNUFO`½g[FONwKcJIJ[HGFQJ8XKcD�F,K~PRJ�g[FOSUNM]pJ[HGNwDGFOSUFLu�KcD�F¼DGVLx�xIJ�y.a$`^J�yhV8`^]^NMV8Kc]pJ[H��

�

Page 19: d¾PRJ[nG`^W `^]^a8F KMJ|KcDVLH a i FO]^H FOS ...hopf.math.purdue.edu/Porter/s-catsv2.pdfGKUKcFOWYKcJ[eLF{KcD FOS,NMJ KcDVAK&d KcDG]pHGa d_ FOeL]^H KMJ nGHGW FOSMN K.VLH WzKcDGFjP

ç~RTQ èôV�h h ]�l4¦�bÿ,]½g[FOH'V�yOV8KcF{e[J[SUo Ñ�u�V8HGW|V�NMnG��yhVAKcFOeLJ[SUo~� u�DGV?g�]pHGe�KMDGF�NMVLxIF�y{`lVLNUN&JLX�J[��xUF{y{KcN{u�yOJLHGNUKMSMnGy!K¾V ÈyhV8KMFOe[J[S�o5¥���É6ÑÖ}8� Ì&JLS�¥��qѨXZJ[S¾NUDGJ[S�KhuvKcDGF¤��á*���$Ù��5h*æ^Ù��MáLæÕÞ^ÛOáLÝ2ÞãÙ��<Ù�60Ñ $ ÞàÝ=�|ÚcÜ.Û~å�Ü��!ݼÝ~Ù½� u_VLNXZJ[`^`pJñPwN�¢

CEDGF,J[�(xUFOy{KMN�J8XD¥��qÑÍVLSMFQKcD�F¼NMVLxIF,VLNEKcDGJ[NUF,JLXDÑÿQ]pgLFOH$K~PRJ�J[��xUFOy!KcNqÍ�V8HGW÷Î$u�KcDGFJÅfÈ~NM]px�T�`^]^y{FONvJLX�¥��qÑ�É=Í�}�Î�ÌvPw]^`^`���FjKcD�F��USMF{WGnGy{FOW�D�VLxIx�J�y.abN

JLX:Pw]^W�KMDQÅ$VLHGW�V8Hbo�`^F{HGeLKMD��¿��F{K~PRFOF{H3Í V8HGW÷Î$� � nGy.D\V&KcDG]pHGe�]pN�V¿y{J[x�x¿n�K.V8KM]pgLF�WG]^VLe[SMVLxìJLX:XZJ[SUxÑ�ð�j ��

Ñ�ð�j ���

×K×9× Ñ�ð�j ¦ � ��

4444

4444

4444

4444

4

Ñ j ��

Ñ j ���

×K×9× Ñ j ¦ � �� FF

FFFF

FFFF

Í

DDDD

DDDD

D

2222

2222

2222

2222

2

�����������������

zzzzzzzzz �����

�����

�����

Î

�� � j ��

�� � j ���

×K×9× Ñ�� � j ¦ � ��

xxxxxxxxxx

Ñ��'j Ñ��'j � ×K×9× Ñ��'j ¦ �

]^H�PwDG]^y.DÉç]àÌRKMDGF,`^F{HGeLKcD L JLX�KcDGF,D�V8x�xIJBy.a�yhVLH���F¼VLHfo�]^HfKcF{e[FOSJ��s�uÉç]^]lÌ�VL`p`>KcDGFQgLFOSUKM]^yOVL`�x�VLTGN�VLSMFQ]pH½�ìuÉç]^]p]àÌv]^H�FhV8y.D�y{J[`^nGxIH�JLX�DGJ[SU] �OJLHbKcVL`>x�VLTGN{u�VL`p`�x$V8TGN�e[J�]^HzKMDGF,NcVLxIFQWG]pSMFOy!Kc]pJ[H�Æ�]½X�KcDGF!o�e[J�`^F!XàKhu�KMDGFOHKcDGF!o�D�Vhg[F,KcJ��6F,]pHD� ÆTG`^nGNEK~PRJ�SUFOWGn�y{Kc]pJ[H\yOJ[HGW�]pKc]pJ[HGN{uÉç]pg�ÌRKMDGF,x$VLT�N�]pH�VLW�xMVLy{FOHfK�yOJ[`pnGx�H�NEe[J�]^H�WG]½ê>F{SMFOHfK�WG]pSMFOy!Kc]pJ[HGNOuVLHGWÉZg�Ì�HGJ�y{J[`^n�x�H�y{J[HfK.VL]pHGNwJ[HG`po$]^WGF{HfKc]pK~o$x$V8TGNO�

ÉZd X�]pHzx�VLHG]^T�nG`lV8KM]^HGe¼D�VLxIxIJBy.abNOu�KcDGF{NMF,`lV8NUK�K~PRJ�yOJ[H�WG]pKM]^J[HGNR�6F{yOJ[xIFjg�]^JL`lV8KMFOW��KMDGFOH�]½K�]^N�NM]^xITG`pFKcJ�SUFOWGnGy{FjKcD�FjD�VLxIxIJBy.a¾�fo[u�XZJ[S_F!��VLxITG`^F8uBy{J[x�T�J[NU]^HGe&VLW�xMVLy{FOHfK�y{J[`^n�x�HGN_]pX>KcDGF!o�T�J[]pHbKR]^HIKcDGF�NcVLxIFWG]^SUFOy{KM]^J[H�J[S�bo�SUFOxIJ?gB]pHGe,VQyOJ[`pnGxIH¾JLX>]pWGFOHfKM]pKc]pFON{�D�wFOT�FhV8KMFOWInGNMFwJLX�KcDGFESUFOWGn�y{Kc]pJ[HGNvx�V?o¿�6FEH�FOFOW�FOW��æQH�F�SUFOWGnGy!Kc]pJ[H�x�Vho³y{SMFhVAKcF�V\HGF{FOWYXZJ[S,VLHGJLKMDGFOS,J[H�FL�Id K&]pNQJLXàKcF{H�n�NMF{XZn�`vKMJ\PRJ[SUa³Pw]pKcDknGH�SMFOW�nGyOF{WD�VLxIx�J�y.abN�V8HGW�KcDGF{H\KMJ�SUFOWGnGy{FL�ëÌ

CEDGF�XçVLy{F$VLH�W�WGF{e[FOH�FOScV8y{oYx$V8TGN¼VLSMFIWGF��GHGFOW�]^HkKcDGFIJ[�fg�]^J[nGNQP�Vho[uEÉZSMF{x�F{x��6F{SQKcDGF�g[F{SUKc]pyOF{N¿JLXNMnGy.D V'NU]^xITG`^F�� VLSMF\KcDGF'Ô|�O]pe��hV8e[NOÀvXZSMJ[x�Í KMJ�ξÌ�uEDGJ?P�F!g[F{SzKcDGF!o4x�V?o�SUFONMn�`pKz]pH4V'H�J[HBÈ~SUFOWGn�yOFOWD�VLxIx�J�y.a��

��J[xIT�J[NM]½Kc]^JLHz]^NE�fo�yOJLHGyhV8KMFOH�VAKc]^JLH�XZJL`^`^J?PRFOW��fo�SMF{WGnGy!Kc]^JLHt¢¥ � Ñ�É=Í�}�ξÌ��¤¥ � Ñ�É;Î�}��ÌÆ� ¥ � Ñ�É=Í�}��Ì�}

F!�BT�VLHGW�]^HGe¾KcD�FQ]^HfKcF{SUg[F{HG]^H�e0Î HGJBW�F�]^HfKcJ�V¿gLFOS�Kc]^yOVL`>`p]^HGF�Pw]pKMD�]^WGF{HbKM]pKM]^FON�VLHGW�KcD�FOH�SMF{WGnGyO]pHGe¾]pX�H�FOFOW�6F8�

�vVLy.D�¥ � Ñ�É=ͤ}2Î�Ì�]^N¾KcD�F\W�]^SMF{y{KI`^]px�]½K¿J8XjHGF{SUgLFON$J8X�NMx�VL`p`�yhVAKcFOeLJ[SM]pFON�]^H�VLH�J[�fg�]^J[nGN¾P�Vho[u�]2�ÁF8�]^HGy{SMFhV8NM]^H�e�KMDGF,`^F{HGeLKcD L JLX�KcDGF,D�V8x�xIJBy.abN{u�VLHGW\NMJI]^NE]½KcNMF{`pX�V���nGVLNM] È~yhVAKcFOeLJ[SUoL�

è?é

Page 20: d¾PRJ[nG`^W `^]^a8F KMJ|KcDVLH a i FO]^H FOS ...hopf.math.purdue.edu/Porter/s-catsv2.pdfGKUKcFOWYKcJ[eLF{KcD FOS,NMJ KcDVAK&d KcDG]pHGa d_ FOeL]^H KMJ nGHGW FOSMN K.VLH WzKcDGFjP

ç~Reç èôV�h h ]�l4¦�bd`Të WäfpY ip_äY\bAY�ëpl�Yÿ]�tòVÐl�V�kal\ê�k�êpbM]�t3kaY�t�WZt�_äVÆl$Wä`a]qëpb$Rd X�KMDGF�T�VL]pS�É;Ñà}8� ̼NMV8Kc]pN���F{N�VLHforJLXwKcDGF�n�NMn�VL`�ÔëyOVL`^y{nG`^nGN¾J8X�XZSMVLy{KM]^J[H�NOÀ�K~o�T�F�yOJ[H�WG]pKM]^J[HGN{u�KcDGF{H�KMDGFDGJ[xIJLKcJ[TfoIK~o�T6FQJLX:KMDGJ[NUFQHGFOS�g[FON�VL`pSMFOVLW�oINUKcVL�G]^`p]^NUFON�FOVLSM`½oIJ[H�]^H$KMDGFQTGSUJBy{FONMN¼ÉZ]ã��FL�XZJLS�NMx�VL`^` L Ì!�-CEDGFVLSMe[n�x�F{HbK�e[]pgLFOHz]pHk� èh�8�>]pN�]pHGWG]^SUFOy!Khu�NMJ�`pF{K�n�N��GSM]pF'ÀGo�NMF{FjPwDfozJ[H�F�JLX:KcD�FONMFQy{`lVL]px�Nv]pNRKcSUnGFL� � nGTGT�J[NMFKcD�V8K¿É6ÑÖ}8� ÌRNMV8Kc]pN���F{N�VIyOVL`^y{nG`^nGNEJ8X`pF{XàKEXZScV8y{Kc]pJ[HGN{u�KcDGF{HÉç]àÌ,PwDGFOHGF!g[F{S�KcD�FOSMF�]pN�V³WG]lV8e[ScVLx Í ð�� Í Â� Î ]pH5ѨPw]pKMD� «¯-� uvKMDGFOH�KcD�FOSMF�]pN�V³WG]lV8e[ScVLxÍ ð Â��� Î ð��� ÎìNMJ�KcD�V8K��w¯�� VLH�W��é­ò¨«­ ð �uVLHGW\NM]^xI]^`^VLSM`½oÉç]^]lÌ�]½X�­�}�°Ä¢�Í � ο¯�ÑÄVLHGW� ¢'Í � Í ð ¯i� ]^NQNUnGy.DYKMD�V8KÖ­� ¨ °� �u6KMDGFOHkKcD�FOSMF¾]pNQV��¬¯Z�NMnGy.D\KcD�V8K��é­ò¨��<°��É2ÏRo�KcD�]^N�x�FOVLHGN�VLHfo\PRJ[SUW³]^H*VLSMSUJñPwN�JLX�Ñ VLHGW0� � yhV8H³�6F&SMF!PwSM]pKUKcF{H�KcJ�e[F{KjVL`p`�KcDGF&JBy{yOnGSUSMFOH�yOFONJLXvVLSUSMJ?PwN�XZSUJ[x§� � KcJIKcDGF&`^F!XàKjJLX�KcDGJLNMF�ÔÁJ[SUWG]^H�V8SUo�À�VLSMSUJñPwN�XZSMJ[x¸Ñ��®�vVLy.D³JLX�KMDGF,K~P�JzNUnG�GN�KcSM]pHGe[NyhVLH'KMDGFOH'�6F�yOJ[xIT6JLNMFOW�KcJ*SUFOWGn�yOF$KMDGFIPRJ[SUW'KcJ³JLHGF�J8X�KcDGFIXZJ[SMx�� � ¿ u�]ã��FL��V\`^F{XàK¼XZScV8y{Kc]pJ[H��ëÌ4C�JnGHGWGF{SMNUKcVLHGW�DGJ?PÂKcD�]^N�SUFhVLy!KcNEPw]pKMD\DGVLx�xIJ�y.a�N{uGyOJLHGNM]pWGFOSwV¾NM]px�T�`^FjyOVLNMFQPwDGF{SMF,KcDGFQy.D�J[NMF{H�g[F{SUKMF!�\JLXKcDGF,D�VLxIxIJBy.a³¥ � Ñ$É>ͤ}�οÌ�]^NwNM]px�T�`po

Í Ñüoo

¾// Πι�·oo

TGSMJ?g�]^WGF¾Pw]½KcD�� ¯v�ì����F�yOJ[H�NUKcSUnGy{K&V�HGF!PìWG]lV8e[ScVLx\u>n�NM]^H�e\KMDGF�`^F{XàKjXZScVLy!Kc]^JLHGNQSMnG`pF\Éç]lÌ!u:e[]½gB]pHGe�Vè{È~NU]^xITG`^F��$Pw]½KcD�KcDGF,e[]½g[F{H\gLFOSUKMF!�*V8KwJ[H�F¼F{HGWt¢

Í Ñüoo

¾//ü

��

Îü ���

ι�·oo

Í Í¹©·oo ¾ � // Ñ ð Îü �oo

}

NMJ�P�VLN�DGJ[xIJLKMJ[TG]^y�KcJIVzÔë`pF{XàKw�G]^VLNMF{W�À�D�VLxIx�J�y.a*É�� ð Ì � ¿ ð �æjX�yOJ[nGSUNMF8u�]pX�KcDGF,`pFOHGeLKMD�JLX�KMDGF,D�VLxIx�J�y.aID�VLW\�6F{FOH\e[SMFOV8KcF{S�KcDGF{H\KMDGF,y.D�VL]^H�JLX_ÔÁx�J?g[F{NOÀGKMJI`p]^HGa]pK_KcJ¿KMDGF&ÔÁ`^F!XàK��G]^VLNMF{W³À�XZJLSMx PRJ[nG`^W$�6F�`^J[HGeLFOSO�ÊjefVL]pH$JLX�yOJ[nGSUNMF8u�VL`pKMDGJ[nGeLD$yOJLx��G]^HGV8KcJ[SU]lVL`p`po¼XZFhVLNU]^�G`pFVIWGF!K.VL]p`^F{W�TGSMJ�JLX�KcD�V8KEKMDGF,`^F!XàKw��VL]^NUNMF{W�D�V8x�xIJBy.abN�Pw]½KcD�g[F{SUKc]pyOF{N�JLX�KcD�F,XZJLSMx

Íg� Ñ � ÎTGSMJ?g�]^WGF�V³W�F{XZJ[SUx$V8KM]^J[H'SMF{KMScVLy!K�JLX�¥��SÑ�É=Í�}�ξÌ&]pN¿KcF{y.DGHG]^yOVL`^`½o'�bnG]½KcFzxIFONUNUoL����g[F{H�Pw]½KcD�V³�6F!KMKMFOSa�H�JñPw`pFOWGeLF�JLXvPwD�VAK¼KMDGF0¥��qÑ�É=Í�}�Î�Ìj`pJBJ[abNQ`p]^aLF8u>KcD�FOSMF�]pNQNUKc]p`^`�KcDGF�TGSUJ[�G`^F{x(JLX_y{J[x�T�J[NU]pKc]pJ[H��¼C�P�J`^F{XàK��G]lV8NMFOW�DGVLx�xIJ�y.a�NRyOJ[xIT�J[NMF��bo$yOJ[H�yhV8KMFOH�V8KM]^J[H�KcJ�e[]½g[FjV�x�J[SUF�eLFOHGF{ScVL`�XZJ[SMx JLX�D�VLxIxIJBy.a�KMD�V8KKcDGF{H�e[F!KcNwSMF{WGnGy{FOW\�bo$KcDGF,`^F!XàK�XZScV8y{Kc]pJ[HGNESUnG`^F{NOuG�GnBKEKcDGF{NMF¼SMnG`pFONEWGJò�>ÙAÝ�eL]pg[F,V¾HGJLSMx�VL`6XZJ[SUxÄXZJ[S�KMDGFyOJ[xIT6JLNM]pKMFL�_þ�n�y.D*VLNE]pHzKcDGFQy{J[xIT6J[NU]pKMFjJLXVLSMSUJ?PwNE]^H�V��bn�VLNU]½È~yOV8KcF{e[J[S�o[u�KMDGFQyOJ[xIT�J[NM]½KcF�DGF{SMFQ]pNEJ[HG`poWGF���H�FOW*n�T\KMJ�DGJLx�JLKMJ[Tfo[�� n�TGT6JLNMF$PRFz`^F!Kõ¥ É>ͤ}�ο̼��F$KcDGF�NM]px�TG`p]^y{]lVL`�NUF{K¿JLXwNMnGy.Dr`pF{XàK¿�G]lVLNUFOW|DGVLx�xIJ�y.a�N{u�KMDGFOHr]½K¿]pN¿VWGF{XZJ[SUx$VAKc]^JLH�SMF{KMScVLy!K�JLXD¥��SÑ$É>ͤ}�οÌ!�-Ê�XàKMFOSwyOJLx�T�J[NM]½Kc]pJ[H$PRF&SUFOWGnGy{F¼KMJ�e[F{K�V�WG]lV8e[ScVLx

¥ É>ͤ}�οÌ��¬¥ É;Î�}��Ì //� _ì��

¾ � ¦w¾ º��**TTTTTTTTTTTTTTT

¥ É>ͤ}��Ì� _ì��¥ � Ñ$É>ͤ}�οÌ��¬¥ � Ñ�É;Î�}��Ì // ¥ � Ñ�É=ͤ}���Ì

û Â · ¾ Â OO

qLs

Page 21: d¾PRJ[nG`^W `^]^a8F KMJ|KcDVLH a i FO]^H FOS ...hopf.math.purdue.edu/Porter/s-catsv2.pdfGKUKcFOWYKcJ[eLF{KcD FOS,NMJ KcDVAK&d KcDG]pHGa d_ FOeL]^H KMJ nGHGW FOSMN K.VLH WzKcDGFjP

CEDG]^N�`pJBJLa�N�VLN�]pX�]½KNUDGJ[nG`pW¿P�JLSMa,P�F{`^`ãu8�Gn�K]pXGPRF�`^J�J[a,V8K�KcDGF�VLNMNUJBy{]lV8KM]pg�]pK~o¼Vñ��]pJ[x\u8]½K]pNSMF{TGSMF{NMF{HbKMFOW��foV�yOJ[xIx�n�KcV8Kc]½g[F_WG]lVLeLScVLx\uLV8HGW�P�F�D�Vhg[FESMF{TG`lV8yOFOW¾FOVLy.D¾JLX�KMDGF�HGJ�WGFONJLX�KcD�VAK-WG]lV8e[ScVLxÅ�fo¿VjDGJ[xIJLKMJ[TfoFO�bnG]pg8VL`pFOHfK�JL��xUFOy!Khu-NMJ³PRFzSU]^NMake[F!KMKM]^HGe*V*DGJ[xIJLKcJLTboky{J[DGF{SMFOHfK�WG]^VLe[SMVLx�u�HGJLK�V*yOJLx�x�nBK.V8KM]pg[FIJ[HGF8�CEDG]^N�]pN�DGVLTGT�FOHG]pHGez]^H�NM]^W�F�¥��qÑ�u>NUJ$KcD�]^NjW�JBF{NjHGJLKjx$VAKMKcF{S�NUJ�x�nGy.D���Êj`½KcDGJ[n�e[D³V8KUKcF{x�T�KM]^HGeIKcJzy{n�KWGJ?PwH*KcDGF&NM] �OF¼JLXKMDGF�ÔÁDGJ[x¾È~NUF{KcN{À�WGJBF{NjV8`^`^J?PÂnGN�xIJ[SUF¼y{J[HfKcSUJ[`�J?gLFOSjNUJ[xIF¿VLNUT6F{y{KMNjJLX�KcDGF&NM]pKMn�V8KM]^J[H�u]pK�VL`pNMJ�D�VLNw]pKMNEWGJ?PwHGNM]pWGFL�

CEDGF$NMJ[`pn�Kc]pJ[H|]^N¼KcJ³N�KcnGWBo'KcD�F�DGJ[xIJLKcJ[TfokKcD�FOJ[S�o'JLX È~yOV8KcF{e[J[SM]pFON¾V8N¿NMn�y.D���CED�]^N¿Pw]p`^`v`^FOVLWrnGN��VLy.azKcJ?P�VLSMW�N�KMDGF � FOefV8`�x$V8TGN�VLN�P�F{`^`�VLNwy{J[HfKc]^HbnG]pHGe¾KcJ�]^HfKMFOScV8y{KwPw]pKMD\D�J[x�J8KcJ[Tfozy{J[DGF{SMFOH�yOFL�ü�J[S�VENMD�J[SUK�Kc]px�F8uhXZJ[S:KcDGFvTGn�SMT�J[NMFvJLX�F!�BT6JLNM]pKM]^J[H>uhP�FvPw]^`p`LSMF{NUKMSM]^y!K�J[nGSMNUFO`½g[FON�KcJ�NMx�VL`p` È~yhVAKcFOeLJ[SM]pFONPw]pKcD�V¤���BFOW�NMF!KIJLXjJL��xUFOy!KcNOu! �u-NMV?oLu�VLH�W È XZn�HGy{KMJ[SMN¾Pw]^`p`���FzKcDGF�]pWGFOHfKc]½K~o|J[H�J[�(xUFOy{KMNO�|��FzPw]^`p`WGFOHGJ8KcF�KMDGF$yOV8KcF{e[J[S�okJLXENMn�y.D'KcDG]pHGe[N¼�fo�ªõ�wÑÓÒ�Ô{å" I�kÉçCED�F$x�V8KcF{SM]lV8`-DGFOSUF$]^N¼VLWGVLT�KcF{W'XZSMJLx � èhé8�ã�ëÌ

CEDG]^N_yhV8KMFOe[JLSUo¾D�V8N�VQyO`pJ[NMF{W$NU]^xITG`^]pyO]lV8`�xIJ�WGFO`�yOV8KcF{e[J[SUo�NUKcSUnGy{KMnGSMF�]^H¾PwDG]py.D�KcD�F�NU]^xITG`^]pyO]^VL`BN�KcSUnGy{KMnGSMF]^N¾xIJ[SMF�J[S¾`^F{NMN¾J[�fg�]^J[n�NOuv]^H|PwDG]py.D�V³x$VLT5á � á ð ]^N¾V*PRFhV8a|FO�bnG]½gLV8`^FOH�yOFYÉçSUFONUT��rV����GSMV8Kc]pJ[H�Ì�uPwDGFOHGF!g[F{SOu6XZJLSEF{g[F{SUo�T�V8]^SEJLX�J[��xUF{y{KcN{uäy\}2z±¯# Iu�KcDGF,SUFONUKMSM]py{KcF{W�x�VLT

á#É=y\}�zGÌÆ� á ð É>y\}2z�Ì]^N�VIP�FOVLa*F{��n�]pg8VL`^F{HGyOFzÉçSUFONMT>�p���GScVAKc]^JLH�Ì!�¿É2Ç�JLKcF8u6KcDGV8K�NUF{g[F{ScVL`JLX-KcDGF¿yOJ[HGN�KcSUnGy{KM]^J[HGN�P�F�DGV?gLF���FOFOH`^J�J[ab]^HGe¼V8K_efVhg[F�nGN_P�FOVLa¾FO�bnG]½gLV8`^FOH�yOFONR]^H�KcDG]pNvNMFOH�NMFLu�XZJ[Sv]^HGN�K.VLH�yOFLuAªwÉ=óRÌ®��ó ]pN_JLHGF�NUnGy.D�VLH�WIKMD�V8KKcDGF����GSMVLHfK�J[��xUFOy!KcN�VLSMFQKMDGF,`^J�yhVL`p`po��,VLH È yhV8KMFOe[J[SU]^F{N�J?gLFOS� �Ì��Ç�JñP V8NRPRF�abHGJ?PÂV8HboIJLX:KMDGFjyOV8KcF{e[J[SU]^FONqª��~ÑÖÒ�Ô{å" ÅXZJ[SMx NMn��6yOV8KcF{e[J[SM]pFONRJLX�KcD�FjyhVAKcFOeLJ[SUo�JLX:NU]^x¾ÈTG`^]pyO]lV8`�yhV8KMFOe[JLSM]^F{NOu�ÑÓÒ�Ô%$�&('8�ECED�]^N�yhV8KMFOe[J[S�o\VL`^NUJ$D�V8NjVIyO`^JLNMFOW�NM]px�TG`p]^y{]lVL`6x�J�WGFO`:yOV8KcF{e[J[S�o�N�KcSUnGy{KMnGSMFVLHGW¾KcDGFEH�FOSUgLF�VLHGW�yhV8KMFOe[JLSM]^yOVL`�SUFhVL`p]^NMV8Kc]pJ[H&XZnGH�y{KcJLSMN-]^H�WGnGyOFwV8H¾FO�bnG]pg8VL`pFOHGy{FEJLX�DGJ[xIJLKcJLTbo&yhVAKcFOeLJ[SM]pFONÉçF{gLFOH¾JLX�KcDGFRNM]^xITG`p]^yO]^VL`L`pJByOVL`^]pNcV8KM]^J[H�N�]pXBo[J[n¿P�VLHfK�Ì��6F!K~P�F{FOH0ÑÖÒ<Ô $ &)' VLHGW¿KMDGF�yOV8KcF{e[J[S�o,JLX��G]pNM]^xITG`p]^yO]^VL`NMF{KMN�ª�$�&)'8����]pKcD�]^H÷ÑÖÒ�Ô%$*&)'�PRF¼VLSMFjnGNMF{W\KMJ¾yOJ[HGNU]^WGF{SM]pHGewª~�ÓÑÖÒ�ÔRVLNwV�XZnG`^`�NMnG��yhVAKcFOeLJ[SUoL�S�wFO`^V8KcF{WzKcJKcDGF¾TGSUJ[�G`pFOx¸JLXvSMF{WGnGyO]pHGe�KcDGF¿NM] �{F�JLXvKcD�F0¥ � Ñ�É=ͤ}2Î�Ì�NQ]pNjKcD�F��bnGFON�Kc]^JLHYJ8XvWGF{KMFOSMxI]^H�]^HGe$KMDGF�SUFONMn�`pKJLX�SUFONUKMSM]py{Kc]pHGe�KcD�F¼]pHGWGnGy{FOW\HGFOS�g[F,XZnGHGy!KcJ[SEKcJwªp�õÑÖÒ�Ô��RCED�F¼NUJ[`^nBKc]^JLH�]^NEScVAKcDGF{S�NUnGSMT�SM]^NU]^HGeA¢

��J[H�NM]^W�FOSwKcDGF¼XZnG`^`:NUnG�6yOV8KcF{e[J[S�o�J8X�ª $ &)',W�F{KcF{SMxI]^HGF{W*�fo�KcDGJLNMF¿JL��xUFOy!KcN�Í NMnGy.D�KcD�V8K�Éç]lÌqÍ���sA��]pNVIWG]pNMy{SMF{KMF,NM]^xITG`p]^yO]^VL`�NMF!K�ÉZy{XÒ�-KcD�F¼y{J[HGWG]½Kc]pJ[H�J[H�KcDGF,J[��xUF{y{K�NM]px�T�`^]^y{]lVL`�NUF{K�]^H\VLH È yhV8KMFOe[JLSUo�Ì!ÆVLHGWÉç]^]lÌ_XZJ[SEF!g[FOS�o�]^HfKcF{e[FOSÆ̽� qBu�KMDGF � FOefV8`:x$VLT

�B� ÌG�\¢�Í�� ÌG��� Í��ÕèO�\� éÀ ðoÁ�Í��ÕèO�\�

éÀ ðoÁé×9×9×Z�

éÀ ðoÁ*Í��ÕèO�

]^N�V�P�FOVLa�FO�bnG]½gLV8`^FOH�yOF,JLX�NM]^xITG`p]^yhV8`6NUF{KcN{�ü�J[S�SMFOVLNMJLHGNIKMD�V8KIPw]^`p`��6F{yOJ[xIF\yO`^FOVLSMF{S�`^V8KcF{SOu_P�F�Pw]^`p`EyhVL`p`�KcDGF{NMF*JL��xUFOy!KcN F ÜãâfáLæ®�MáLÝÒÜãâ�ÙAÚ�ÞãÜ.Û�J[S

NMJ[xIF{KM]^xIFON F ÜãâfáLæ�Ý � �MáLÝ~Üãâ�ÙAÚ!ÞãÜ.Û!�pæjXvyOJ[nGSUNMF8u>KcDGF{SMF�]pN�V$H�JLKc]pJ[H³JLX � F{efVL`�sAÈ~yOV8KcF{e[J[SU]^FON{u>�GnBKjKcD�FONMF�V8SMFxUnGNUK,HGF{SUgLFON,JLXvJ[SUWG]^H�V8SUo�yhV8KMFOe[J[SU]^F{NO����F¿Pw]^`p`�WGF{HGJLKMF�KcDGF�yOV8KcF{e[J[S�o*JLXvKMDGFONUF � FOefV8`�è{È yhV8KMFOe[J[SU]^F{Nj�foª��K°éÒ,+a�~ÑÖÒ�Ô��-CEDGF�SMF{NMnG`½K�JLX�ÑjPEoLFOS{uG�,VLH�VLH�W � xI]pKcD>u��Õè?é8�2uB]pN_KMD�V8KRKcDGF�H�FOSUgLFjXZSMJLxjÑÖÒ�Ô%$*&)'�KcJ�ª�$�&)'AuSMFON�KcSU]^y{KMN�KMJ$e[]½g[FOH*VLH³F{��n�]pg8VL`^F{HGyOF¼JLX-D�J[x�J8KcJ[Tfo�yhVAKcFOeLJ[SM]pFON��6F!K~P�F{FOH ª���ÑÓÒ�Ô�VLH�W¬ª��K°éÒ�+���ÑÖÒ<Ô��wd~HT�VLSUKM]^y{nG`lVLS�KMDG]^NwNMV?o�N�KcD�V8KjVLHfo � F{efVL`�yhV8KMFOe[JLSUo�]pNwPRFhV8a�`½o\FO�bnG]pg8VL`pFOHfKwKcJ�V��G]pNM]px�TG`p]^y{]lVL`�NMF!K�KMD�V8K�]^N�VHGFOS�g[F�JLXRV�NM]^xITG`p]^yO]^VL`^`½o$F{HGSM]py.DGFOWkyOV8KcF{e[J[SUoL� � F{efVL`�yhV8KMFOe[J[SU]^F{N,VLSMF¿PRFhV8aLFOH�FOW'NU]^xITG`^]pyO]^VL`�g[F{SMNM]pJ[HGN,JLXKcDGF�VL`pe[FO��ScVL]py¿NUKMSMnGy!KcnGSUFON¼e[]pgLFOH#�fo³KMDGF¾yhV8KMFOe[JLSM]^yOVL`�Vñ��]pJ[xINOu>NUJ�KcDG]pN�]^N�]pH#x$V8Hbo�P�Vho�N¼VzyOJ[D�FOSMF{HGyOFKcDGF{J[SMF{x XZJ[S � FOe[VL`:yhV8KMFOe[JLSM]^F{NEScV8KMDGFOSw`p]^aLF�KcDGF,yOJLDGFOSUFOHGy{F&KcD�FOJ[SUFOxINwXZJLSE�G]^yOV8KcF{e[J[SM]pFON{u�F{KMyL�

qBè

Page 22: d¾PRJ[nG`^W `^]^a8F KMJ|KcDVLH a i FO]^H FOS ...hopf.math.purdue.edu/Porter/s-catsv2.pdfGKUKcFOWYKcJ[eLF{KcD FOS,NMJ KcDVAK&d KcDG]pHGa d_ FOeL]^H KMJ nGHGW FOSMN K.VLH WzKcDGFjP

- . ¹�¡×£³¢�«wªQ¡�/ . ¹�«�¢¼¬�ª�·�°I±v�OªQ¡�¢�¤#¥ � ª�·�¢�µ�«w¢&¬ª�·�°I±_�{ªQ¡*¥CEDGF�SMFhV8NMJ[H|KMD�V8K � F{efVL`�yOV8KcF{e[J[SU]^FON�VLSM]pNMF�VLN&KcDGF!o|WGJk]^N&�6F{NUK�NUJ[nGe[DfK�]^H|KMDGFzT�V8T6F{S\��tcbñ���fo � F{efVL`2uVL`pKMDGJ[nGe[D*]pK�]^NjH�JLK�KcD�FOSMF¿�Gn�K�SMV8KcD�FOS�]pH�� èhé8��KMD�V8K�KcDGF!o�PRFOSUF¾]^HfKcSUJBWGn�yOFOW>u��Gn�KjHGJLKQH�V8x�F{W#VLN�NUnGy.D��Éçd~HkXçVLy{K,KcD�FO]^Sp�GSMNUK¼H�V8x�]pHGe�NMF{FOxIN¼KMJ\��F�]^H � ]px�TGNUJ[H�À�N��Ú�fsA�ã�ëÌ�d~H��ÖtcbA�2u:J[HGF�JLX�KMDGF�x$V8]^HkVL]px�NjP�VLNKcJ�e[F{K¾ÔÁnGTBÈãKcJ8È DGJ[xIJLKcJLTbo�À�x�J�WGF{`^NjXZJ[S�VL`^e[F{�GScV8]^y¿N�KcSUnGy{KMnGSMF{N&NUJ�V8N�KcJ���F�VL�G`^F&KcJ�]pKMFOSMV8KcF¾y{`lVLNUNM]pXào�]pHGeNMT�VLy{F�yOJ[H�NUKcSUnGy{KM]^J[H�NOu-KcJ³XZJ[SUx NMT�FOy{KMScV³XZJ[S&NUKcn�W�o�]^HGekyOJLSMSMF{NMT�J[HGWG]pHGe³y{J[DGJ[xIJ[`^JLeLo#KcDGF{J[SM]pFON¾V8HGW|KcJDGFO`pT³ÔëWGF{`^J�J[TG]pHGeGÀ�NMT�VLy{FONEPwDGF{SMF,VLTGT�SMJ[TGSU]lV8KMFL�Ð_V8SM]^JLnGN�VLT�TGSMJfV8y.DGFONwD�VLW���FOF{H�KcSM]pFOW�uBHGJLKcVL�G`poIKcDGV8KEJLXÏ�JfVLSUWGx$V8H�VLHGW�ÐvJ[eLKOu��Áqñ�ã�-d~H�FhV8y.D�yOVLNMF�KMDGF,]^WGFOV¿P�VLNEKMJ¾x�]pSMSMJLSRKcD�FQDGJ[xIJLKcJ[Tfo$yOJ[DGF{SMF{HbK�VL`pe[FO��ScVL]pyNUKcSUnGy{KMnGSMF{N�KMD�V8KwJ�yOyOn�SMSMF{W�]pH�`^J�J[T�NMT�V8yOFON{u6F!Kcy8�

Ê�N�VLH�F!��VLxITG`^F¼JLX�KMDGF¿TGSUJ[�G`pFOx\u � FOefVL`�xIFOHfKc]pJ[HGNwKcDGF¼XZJ[`^`pJñPw]pHGeZ¢ � nGTGT�J[NUFÖÕr]pNjVIyhV8KMFOe[JLSUo�VLHGWKcD�V8K,y{J[TGSUJBWGn�y{KcN,F���]pNUK,]pH�Õ-��i�J?PÍ]pN�KcDG]pN�SMF"À�FOy!KcFOWY]^H³KMDGF�HGFOS�g[F�JLXÆÕ��<d KQg[F{SUo#H�FhVLSU`po#V8yO�bnG]^SUFON,VyOJ[xIT6JLNM]pKM]^J[H�`^VhP,uGNM]pHGyOFQXZSMJLxjÍ V8HGW3Í � u�JLHGF,e[F{KMN�Í � ¨ÝÍ 10 Í � u�VLHGW�K~PRJ*è{È NM]^xITG`p]^yOF{N

Í ��Í � � Í � }�Gn�K�Í � ]^NjJLHG`po�WGF{KMFOSUx�]pHGFOW#nGT³KMJ�]^NUJ[x�JLSMTGDG]pNMx\�Q�:F{K~Õ � �6F�KMDGF�yOV8KcF{e[J[SUo*JLX_NMnGy.DkWG]^VLe[SMVLx�N{u>]2�ÁF8�]^H�PwDG]^y.D�KcD�F¼xI]^W�WG`^F�]pN�KcDGF,y{J[TGSMJ�WGnGy!K�JLX�KMDGF,FOHGW�NO�_CEDGFOSUF&]pNwV¾XZn�HGy{KMJ[S

� � ¢?Õ � � Õ��òÕVLHGW�KcDG]pNE]^NwVLH\FO�bnG]½gLV8`^FOH�yOF,JLX�yhV8KMFOe[J[SU]^F{NOuG�GnBK�KMDGFOSUF,]^N�VL`^NUJ�VzÔëy{J[x�T�J[NU]pKc]pJ[H�`lVhP,À

ï ¢*Õ � �ÃÕe[]pgLFOHr�foYTG]^y.ab]^H�e³J[n�K¼KcDGF$yOJ[TGSUJBW�nGy{KO�*CEDG]pN¿`^J�J[abNà��HGFz�GnBK�]^HYXçVLy{K&KcDG]pN¼KMFOHfK.VAKc]pgLFzx�nG`½Kc]pTG`^]pyhV8KM]^J[HVLefVL]pH¾DG]pKMN�KcDGFETGSUJ[�G`pFOxÍJ8X�VLNUNMJ�yO]^V8Kc]½gB]½K~o[��CEDGFEKcDGF{J[SUo�JLX�x�J[H�J[]^W�V8`ByOV8KcF{e[J[SM]pFON�P�VLNvHGJLK_VLN-W�F{g[F{`^J[T�FOWKcDGF{H|]^H è?écb?��VLN¿]½K¼]^N¼HGJ?P,u�VLHGW � FOefV8`ãÀ�N&HGFOV8K&NMJ[`pn�Kc]pJ[HYP�VLN¼KcJ*NU]^WGF�È~N�KcFOT�KcDGF�]^NMNUnGFL�\i�F�XZJ[SUx�F{W'VyhV8KMFOe[J[S�o³Õ \ yOJLHGNM]pNUKc]pHGe�JLXVL`^`6WG]lVLeLScVLxIN�JLX�XZJ[SMx

Í //

((RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR

��222

2222

2222

2222

Í ���

Í �oo

vvllllllllllllllll

������������

�����

Í �W\Í \

<<xxxxxxxx Í �W\bbFFFFFFFF

Í \bbFFFFFFFF

OO

<<xxxxxxxx

KcDGF�HGJLKcV8Kc]pJ[H�]^HGWG]pyhV8KM]^HGe�KMD�V8K_FhV8y.D$NMT�`^]pKv`p]^HGFEy{J[SMSUFONUT6J[H�WGN_KMJ¼KMDGF�x�]pWGWG`^FRKcFOSUxì�6F{]^HGeQKMDGF�y{J[TGSUJBWGn�y{KJLX�KMDGFQK~P�JIFOH�WGNO�_Êj`p`6KcD�F¼n�NMn�VL`:HGV8KcnGSMVL`�]pNMJ[xIJ[SMT�DG]^NUx�NR�6F!K~P�F{FOH³x�n�`pKc]pTG`^F�yOJ[T�SMJ�WGnGy{KMN�VLSMFQF{HGyOJ�WGFOW]^H�KcDGF,J[H�F¼yOV8KcF{e[J[S�o[�vCEDGFOSUF&]pNwVLH�FO�bnG]½gLV8`^FOH�yOF,JLX�yhV8KMFOe[J[SU]^F{N

� \ ¢*Õ \ � Õ��òÕ��òÕNMFOH�WG]^HGe�KcD�F�V8�6J?g[FYWG]^VLe[ScV8x KMJÂÉ>Í }�Í � }�Í \ ÌzVLHGW V4ÔÁKMFOSUH�VLSUo�JLT6F{ScV8KM]^J[H�À�Õ \ � ÕÎNMF{HGWG]pHGe�KMDGFWG]lVLeLScVLxÓKMJwÍ �W\ y{J[xIT�V8Kc]p�G`poLu�nGT�KMJ�NUT6F{yO] ��VL�G`pF&DGJLx�JLKMJ[TG]pFONOuGPw]½KcD�KcDGF&NUKMSMnGy!KcnGSUF¿J[n�KM`^]pHGFOW\FhVLSU`^]pFOSO�

q[q

Page 23: d¾PRJ[nG`^W `^]^a8F KMJ|KcDVLH a i FO]^H FOS ...hopf.math.purdue.edu/Porter/s-catsv2.pdfGKUKcFOWYKcJ[eLF{KcD FOS,NMJ KcDVAK&d KcDG]pHGa d_ FOeL]^H KMJ nGHGW FOSMN K.VLH WzKcDGFjP

CEDGFkVLW�g8VLHfK.V8e[F*]pNIKMD�V8K�V8`^`wJLXQKcD�]^N$yOVLH4��F³FOH�yOJ�WGFOW<�fo�KcDGF³H�FOSUgLF#VLHGW4KMDbnGNz�fo KMDGF³y{`lVLNUNM]pXào�]pHGeNMT�VLy{F$N�KcSMn�y{Kcn�SMF�VLN&V C È NMT�VLy{FL��CEDGF C È NMT�VLy{F$x�VLy.DG]pHGFOS�o#]^N¼HGJ?Pì�bnG]pKMFIPRFO`p`va�H�JñPwH�V8N&]½K&DGVLNOu�XZJ[S]^HGN�K.VLHGy{FLu�y{J[HGNM]pWGFOSMVL�G`pF¼]px�T�J[S�K.VLHGy{F�]^H�N�oBxIxIF{KcSU]^yQJ[T�FOSMVLW�KcDGF{J[SUoLu��Gn�KwPwD�V8K�VLSUFQKcDGF,WGF���HG]pKM]^J[H�NE]^HKcD�V8KwKMDGFOJ[S�o�VLHGW\DGJ?PÃW�J�KMDGF{o�SUFO`^V8KcF�KMJIJLnGSwx$VL]pH$KcD�FOxIFL�2 RTQ 3�r?bZipVÆl�Y\b5463�r?l�VXWAY�[^]^_�`TY\btR/ öcÄòE�àú7�Zó�ò

ÉZ]àÌjCEDGFIyhV8KMFOe[JLSUo C ]^N�KMDGFIyhV8KMFOe[J[S�o³PwDGJ[NUF�JL��xUFOy!KcN�V8SMFIVL`^`E��HG]pKMF�NMF{KMN¿V8HGWYPwD�J[NMFIx�JLSMTGDG]pNMxINXZSMJ[x¿ª KMJGÏ VLSUF¼KMDGF¼x$VLT�N87G¢Zª5� 9zÉ=ÏjÌwNUnGy.D*KMD�V8K�PwDGFOH¬Ò�:¨o�à¯:ª KMDGFOH;7GÉ6ÒBÌ=<;7�É �!Ì�¨?>G��CEDGFyOJ[xIT6JLNM]pKMFQJLX@70¢�ª �A9zÉ=ÏjÌEVLHGWDØ�¢�Ï �A9�Éeí�ÌE]pNCB!¢�ª:�D9�Éeí�ÌEPwDGF{SMF6B�É6Ò�ÌƨFE ^HGJI R Ï S ØÉ2�!Ì!�

ÉZ]^]àÌvÊ C®� Û~å�á��.Ü,]pNwV�XZn�HGy{KMJ[S Ûÿ¢ C � ü ��Ï�Ë�Ì\NMnGy.D\KcD�V8KÉ2VfÌ�Û¾ÉçsfÌ�]^NEy{J[HfKcSMVLy{KM]^�G`pFLÆVLHGWÉç��ÌjXZJ[S,VLHfo L u:KcDGF�x�VLT÷ÌZ¦¤¢�Û¾É L Ìp� Û¾ÉÒèñÌ��LKMKMKZ�¤Û�É�èñÌN OJP Q¦

]pHGWGnGy{FOWY�bo*KcDGF�x�VLTGNàÅH�±¢�èG� L ]^H CPwDGFOSUFÓÅR�fÉ�è?Ì^¨o,�Å�3TS L uG]^N�V¾DGJ[xIJLKMJ[TfozFO�bnG]½g8VL`^F{HGyOF8�

CEDGF{SMFz]pN�VLHrJL�bg�]pJ[nGN¿XZnGH�y{KcJLSe� � C PwD�]^y.D|K.V8aLFON\�|ïz��KMJ*KcD�FzNMF!Keï VLHGW5­å¢�� ïz�®� � L �_KcJ7GÉ6Å Ì�¨-,"Vw¯ L 1�­�É6Å���èñÌ�P_VOªÝ­É6Å~Ì53b�-��J[xIT�J[NM]pHGeQV C È~NUT�VLyOF Û Pw]pKcD\ÉàKcDGF�J[TGT�J[NM]½KcF�JLXcÌ�KMDG]^N�XZnGHGy{KMJ[Se[]pgLFON�VLH|n�HGWGFOSU`po�]^H�e³NM]px�TG`p]^y{]lVL`-NUT�VLyOFzXZJLS&KcD�F C È NMT�V8yOFL� ÉZÊjN¿PRF�D�Vhg[FzKMFOHGWGF{WrKcJ³y{J[HGyOF{HfKcScVAKcF�J[HNM]^xITG`p]^yO]^VL`[KcD�FOJ[S�o¿SMV8KcDGF{S�KMD�VLH¾J[H�KMDGF�KcJLT6J[`pJ[e[]pyhVL`[NU]^WGF8u[P�F�yOJ[nG`pW�FO�bn�V8`^`po,PRFO`p`�D�Vhg[FESUFOTG`^VLyOF{WzÔëNUT�VLy{FLÀVLNxIFhVLH�]^HGewKcJ[T�J[`pJ[e[]^yOVL`[NUT�VLyOF��boIÔÁNMT�VLy{FLÀLVLN�xIFhV8HG]^HGe�NM]px�TG`p]^y{]lVL`8NMF{KOu[]^H¼PwDG]^y.D¿yhVLNUF�V C È~NUT�VLyOF_P�JLnG`^W�6F¼V��G]^NU]^xITG`^]pyO]lV8`�NMF{KwPw]½KcD�NM]pWGF,yOJ[HGW�]pKc]pJ[HGN{� Ì

æ�nGS�KcVLNMa³]pNQHGJLKQKMJ\SUF{g�]^F!PÍKMDGF¾yOJ[HfKMFOHfKcN¼JLX � FOefV8`ãÀ�N¾è?écb?��T�VLT�FOS{u:NMJ�KcDGF�HGF���K&T�J[]pHbKjKcJ�HGJLKMFI]pNKcDGF,WGF���HG]pKM]^J[H�JLXV C È yhV8KMFOe[JLSUo[�vCEDG]pNEXZJ[`^`pJñPwNRKcDGF,NcV8x�FQxIJBW�FO`o¢Ê C È yhV8KMFOe[JLSUo#]pN¿V�XZnGHGy!KcJ[S�ÕH¢ C � ü � ÑÖÒ<Ô�NMnGy.D'KMD�V8KzÉ2VfÌ�ÕvÉ2sfÌ�]^N¼FO�bnG]½g8VL`^F{HbK,KMJ³V�J[HGF�VLSMSUJñPyhV8KMFOe[J[S�o[uvVLH�W Éç��Ì¿V8N��6F!XZJ[SMF�F!�ByOF{T�K�P�FOVLa'D�J[x�J8KcJ[TfoYFO�bnG]½gLV8`^FOH�yOFz]pN¿SMF{TG`lV8yOFOWr�fo'FO�bnG]pg8VL`pFOHGy{FzJLXyhV8KMFOe[J[SU]^F{NO�

d K�]^NEH�JLK�NMnGSUTGSM]pNM]^H�e�KMD�V8K�]pX�Õ�]^N�V C È~yhVAKcFOeLJ[SUoLu�VLTGTG`½oB]pHGe�HGFOS�g[F¿VLHGW�KcDGF{H�e[F{J[xIF{KcSU]^yQSUFhVL`p]^NcVAKc]^JLHÉç]ã��FL��KcVLab]^HGe�]½KcNEyO`^VLNMNU]pXào�]^H�e¾NMT�VLy{F?ÌEe[]pgLFON�V C ëbNMT�VLy{FL�CEDGFRx�JLNUK�XZnGHGW�V8x�F{HbKcVL` C È yhV8KMFOe[J[S�o,]^N�PwDGFOH�ª��KÔ�Ù Â2¹ ¦�]^N:KcD�F�yhVAKcFOeLJ[SUo,JLXA��HG]pKMFRNUF{KMNnGHGW�FOSW�]^N=xUJL]^HfKnGHG]^JLH�u�VLHGWzPRFQK.VLa8F,VLH�J[��xUF{y{K L XZJ[S�FOVLy.D\H�V8Kcn�ScVL`6H�n�x��6F{S L �-CEDGF,SUFONMn�`pKc]pHGe C È~yhVAKcFOeLJ[SUo�]^NEy{`^J[NUFO`poSMFO`^V8KcF{W�KMJ#KcDGF�WG]pN=xUJ[]pHbK�nGHG]^JLH�J8XjKcD�F\N�o�x�xIF{KMSM]^y�eLSMJ[nGT�N�VLHGW�KcDbnGN�KcJ#XZSMF{F\N�o�x�xIF{KMSM]^y�xIJ[HGJL]^W�VL`

yO`^JLNMFOW\yhVAKcFOeLJ[SM]pFONOu���n�K�F!�BTG`^JLSM]^H�e¾]^H�KcD�VAKwWG]^SUFOy{KM]^J[H�PRJ[nG`pW�KcVLaLF,nGNwKcJ�J�XçVLSwV?�GFO`^W>�` ö�ù: A�Að�ûÉZ]àÌRd Kw]pNEHGJLKwJ[�fg�]^J[n�NwKMJ�NUK.V8SUKEPw]pKMD�PwDbo�KMDGFQNUKMSMnGy!KcnGSUF&J8X�V C È~NMTGVLyOF,]^NE��nG]^`½K�J[H C VLHGW\HGJLKXxUn�NUKJ[H�����CEDGF�T�J[]^HfK�]^N{u>VLH�W*KcDG]pNj]pN�]px�T�J[SUKcVLHfK�XZJLS�KMDGF�VL`½KcF{SMH�V8KM]pgLF&]pWGFhVLN�KcD�VAKjPRF¿Pw]^`p`���F¿`pJBJLa�]pHGeIV8K

`lV8KMFOSOu�]pX\ÛÅ]^NwV C È~NUT�VLy{FLuGPRF¼yOVLH�XZJ[SMxÓV�yO`^VLNMNU]pXào�]^HGe C È~NUT�VLy{FàÜ�Û¿�vÊjHfo C È~NUT�VLy{F,o�]pFO`^W�NEV¾NM]^xITG`p]^yO]^VL`NMT�VLy{F,VLN�V8�6J?g[F�VLHGW�DGF{HGyOFQV&NMT�VLy{F91 ÛL1L�fozn�NM]^H�e&KcD�F�e[FOJLx�F!KcSM]pyhVL`�SUFhVL`p]^NcVAKc]^JLH³ÉàKcFOy.D�HG]^yOVL`^`½o�J[HGF�nGNUFONKcDGF�XZJ[SMx J8X�SMFOVL`^]pNcV8KM]^J[H�KMD�V8KRWGJ�FON_HGJLK_nGNMF�KcDGF�WGF{e[FOHGF{ScVLy{]^F{NOu�y!XÒ�w�ÖtcbA��VLefV8]^H�Ì��CEDGF�yO`lV8NMNM]½Xào�]^HGe,NMTGVLyOFÜ�ÛÃ]^NRe[]pgLFOH��fo�V8NMNM]pe[HG]pHGe&KMJ¾V���HG]½KcFjNUF{K®ª�u�KcDGF�SUFhVL`p]^NMV8Kc]pJ[H�J8X�KMDGF C È~NUT�VLyOF�ÏVU ��� Û�Éoª:�±ÏjÌ!��CED�]^NP�J[n�`^W\HGJLK��6F,T�J[NMNU]^�G`pF,]pX�J[HGF,yOJ[H�NM]^W�FOSMF{W0xUnGN�KwKcDGF,nGHGW�FOSM`½o�]^HGeINM]px�TG`p]^y{]lVL`�NMTGVLyOF8u6�GnBK�NUnGe[e[F{NUKMN�KMD�V8KKcDGF,yO`^VLNMNU]pXào�]^H�eINUT�VLy{F¼xI]^eLDbK��6FQKcD�J[nGe[DfK�JLXVLN�V���]^NM]px�T�`^]^y{]lVL`�NUT�VLyOF8�

qLt

Page 24: d¾PRJ[nG`^W `^]^a8F KMJ|KcDVLH a i FO]^H FOS ...hopf.math.purdue.edu/Porter/s-catsv2.pdfGKUKcFOWYKcJ[eLF{KcD FOS,NMJ KcDVAK&d KcDG]pHGa d_ FOeL]^H KMJ nGHGW FOSMN K.VLH WzKcDGFjP

ÉZ]^]àÌ_d Kj]pNwPRJ[S�KcD³SUFOyhV8`^`^]pHGe�KcD�F&N�KcSMn�y{Kcn�SMF¿J8X-��VhPEg[FOSUFLÀ�NQVL`pe[FO�GSMVL]^y�KMDGFOJLSM]^F{NOu���q*�8�2u�XZJLS�y{J[xIT�VLSM]pNMJ[H>�æQH�F�P�Vho¿KMJ�g�]^F{P�KMDGFONUF�]pN�KMJQnGNMFENUJ[x�F�FO`^F{x�F{HfK.VLS�o¿]pWGFhVLN�XZSMJ[x KcJ[T�J[NKMDGFOJLSUo[��CEDGFEyhVAKcFOeLJ[SUo¿JLXä��HG]½KcFNMF{KMNE]^NRe[]pgLFOHzKcD�F�NUKMSMnGy!KcnGSUFQJLX�V¿��VLNU]^yjVL`^e[F{�GScV8]^y�NM]pKMFpÊAðE�fo�K.VLab]^H�e�FOTG]px�JLSMTGDG]pyEXçVLx�]p`^]pFON_VLN�y{JñgLFOSU]^HGeNM]^F!g[F{NO�wCEDGF¿xI]^H�]^x�VL`6y{J?g[FOSU]^HGe$NM]^F!g[F{Nj]^H�WGnGyOF¼yOJL`^]^xI]pK�yOJ[H�FON¿è 0 è�KMKMK 0 è�� L u�NMJIKcD�VAKjNUDGFhVhg[F{N�J[HKcDGF¾V8`^e[F{�GScVL]py,NM]pKMF�VLSUF¿e[SMVLWGF{W³NMF!KcN�,�Í�É L Ìe1 L �Ås�3bu�FOH�WGJ?P�F{WkPw]½KcD³��]ÚxUFOy!Kc]pJ[HGN�Í�É L Ì@� ¨ Í�É�è?Ì ¦ XZJ[SL � s��-Ê�H\VL`^e[F{�GScV8]^yjKMDGFOJ[S�oz]pN�KcDGF{H*VzÔÁyOJ[TGSUJBW�nGy{K�TGSUFONMF{SUg�]^H�eGÀ�F!��KcF{HGNM]pJ[HnÊ J8XXÊéðjVLH�W*V0Ê È x�J�WGF{`J[S~ÊéðMÈÒVL`pe[FO�GSMV¾]^N�V�TGSUFONUDGFhV8X�J[H¤Ê u�PwDG]py.D*SUFONUKMSM]py{KcNwKcJ$VINUDGFhVAXvJ[H�Êéð?�,É � JLx�F,JLX�KMDGF¼`^]^H�a�Nw��F{K~PRFOF{HKcDGF�x�J�WGF{SMH�KcDGF{J[SUo�JLX6P�FOVLaAÔ-È~yOV8KcF{e[J[SM]pFON{ubVLHGW$JLT6F{ScVLWGNRVLN_V&eLFOHGF{ScVL`p]^NcVAKc]^JLH¾JLX:��VhPEg[F{SMFLÀ�NEVL`pe[FO��ScVL]pyKcDGF{J[SM]pFONIVLSMF�y{J[HGNM]pWGFOSUFOW�]^H�Ï�F{SMe[F{SOuQ�ÕèO�2u�V8HGW ]pH�SMFO`^V8KcF{W�VLSUKM]^yO`pFON¾xIFOHfKc]pJ[HGF{W�KMDGFOSUFL��CEDG]^N¾]pN¾g[FOS�oSMFO`pF{g8VLHfK�KMJ�KcDGF~�GH�VL`6KMDGFOxIF�JLX:KMDGFONUFQHGJLKMFONOu�H�VLxIFO`po�KMDGF�`^]pHGa¾Pw]pKMD�VL`^eLFO�GSMVL]^y�x�J�WGFO`pN_XZJLS�DGJ[xIJLKMJ[TfoK~oBT�FON�VLHGW$KMDGFjy{J[SMSUFONMT�J[HGW�]^HGe&DG]^e[D�FOS_J[SMWGF{S�yOV8KcF{e[J[SM]pFON{� Ì¿d K�]^N_yO`^FOVLSvKcD�V8K � F{efVL`ãÀ�N C È NMT�VLy{FONEV8SMF�V¼`lVA�J[S�Ôën�TBÈ KMJ8È~DGJLx�JLKMJ[Tfo�À�gLFOSMNU]^J[H�JLX�VL`pe[FO��ScVL]py�KcD�FOJ[SU]^FON{���'FQNUDGJ[nG`pW\VL`^NUJ�HGJLKMFQJ[n�KEKcDGV8K�KcD�FOSMF,V8SMFQ`^]pHGabNPw]pKcD\J[T�FOSMVLWGNwJLX�gLV8SM]^JLnGN�K~o�T6F{NOu��Gn�K�V�WG]^NUyOnGNUNM]pJ[H�J8X�KMDGFONUF,PRJ[nG`pW\KcVLaLF,nGNwKcJ�J�XçVLSwV?�GFO`^W>�2 Reç W®Y\[^V�kwl�VXWAY�[^]^_�`TY\bCEDGF¾KcDGF{J[SUo*JLX È yhV8KMFOe[J[SU]^F{NQ]^NjKMJBJ�N�KcSM]py{K�XZJLSQyOJ[Hfg[F{HG]^F{HGyOF8��ÊjNQPRF¾D�Vhg[F�NMF{FOHkKcDGF¾H�JLKc]pJ[H#JLX � FOe[VL`è{È~yOV8KcF{e[J[SUo'NMDGJLnG`^Wr��F�V*P�FOVLaLF{HGFOW�g[F{SMNM]pJ[H�JLXwKcD�VAK¾JLX È yhV8KMFOe[JLSUorV8HGWrP�F�D�VhgLF\W�]^NMy{nGNMNUFOW�KcDGF{x]^H�XZJ[SUx$V8`^`po¼FOVLSM`p]^FOS{��Ê�xIJ[SMF�XZJLSMx�VL`�KcSUFhV8KMx�F{HfKR]pN-e[]pgLFOHI]^H�NMF!g[F{ScVL`�TG`lV8yOFON{��CEDGFwXZJ[`^`pJ?Pw]^HGe�]pN_VLW�VLT�KMFOWXZSMJ[x C�J�FOH�À�N&�Ú�bqñ�ã�

/ öcÄ�ò��àú7�çó�ò�û» Ê F ÜãâfáLæ�Ý � å�ÚcÜ��MáLÝÒÜãâ�ÙAÚ��$]pNENMT�FOy{] ��F{W��fo\V�XZnGHGy!KcJ[S

Ûÿ¢X� � ü � Éç]2�ÁF8�,V$�G]^NU]^xITG`^]pyO]^VL`�NMF!K�Ì�NUnGy.DkKcD�V8K~Û~ð,]^NjV$yOJLHGNUKcVLHfK,NM]^xITG`p]^yO]^VL`�NUF{K,yhV8`^`^F{W'Ý>��Ü¿Û?Ü!ÝjÙ�6IÙ�� �hÜ��!ÝZÛÙ�6¬Û¿�

» Ê �$ÙAÚ åä��Þ^Û����6F!K~P�F{FOH#K~PRJ � FOefV8`Rè{È TGSMF{yhV8KMFOe[JLSM]^F{Nj]pNjV$HGV8KcnGSMVL`�KcScV8HGNUXZJ[SUx$VAKc]^JLH���F{K~PRFOF{HkKMDGFXZnGHGy!KcJ[SUN�XZSUJ[x ��� ü KMJ �

» Ê � FOefV8`-è{È~TGSUFOyOV8KcF{e[J[SUo³Û ]^NwV F ÜãâfáLæ�Ý � �MáLÝ~Üãâ�ÙAÚ���]pX�XZJ[SEFhV8y.D|� ÌG�2uGKcDGF � F{efVL`:x�VLT��� ÌG�\¢<Ûqü~� Û � Ï þEÛ � Ï þ^×9×9×A� Ï þ\Û }

]^NwV�DGJ[xIJLKcJLTbo$FO�bnG]½gLV8`^FOH�yOF,JLX�NM]^xITG`p]^yO]^VL`�NMF!KcNO�» ü�J[S�VLHfo � FOefVL`�è{È yhV8KMFOe[JLSUo�Û&u8PRF�WGF���HGF�]½KcNÆ��Ù��$ÙAÝÒÙ.å'�à�MáLÝÒÜãâ�ÙAÚ��J�¤ËBÉ6Û�Ì:VLN�KMDGF_yhV8KMFOe[J[S�o,D�Vhg�]^HGeÛ~ð�VLNw]pKMNENMF{K�JLXJ[��xUF{y{KcN�VLH�W3Þ�ðAÉ=Û ÌEVLNw]pKMNENMF!K�J8XxIJ[SMT�DG]^NUx�N{�

» Ê x�J[SUTGDG]pNMx JLX � FOefV8`-è{È~yOV8KcF{e[J[SM]pFON�­¤¢<ÛH� Ü ]pNwVLH|Ü��+!BÞàßAáLæ^Ü��$�.Ü�]pX�]pK�NcV8KM]^N��GFONEKcDGFQXZJ[`p`^J?Pw]^H�eyOJ[H�WG]pKM]^J[HGN�¢è[��ü�J[SEFhVLy.D'� ÌG�\¯���uGKMDGF,x�JLSMTGDG]pNMx ­�üÖ¢<Ûqü�� Üqü¼]^NwVLH\FO�bnG]½g8VL`^F{HGyOF,JLX�NM]px�TG`p]^y{]lVL`�NMF!KcN{ÆqB�wCEDGF,]^HGW�nGyOF{W�XZnGHGy!KcJ[SB��Ë�É;­�Ìq¢��¤ËBÉ6ÛQÌÆ� �¤ËBÉ;ܾÌ�]pNwVLH\FO�bnG]pg8VL`pFOHGy{FQJLX�yOV8KcF{e[J[SU]^FON{�

q?�

Page 25: d¾PRJ[nG`^W `^]^a8F KMJ|KcDVLH a i FO]^H FOS ...hopf.math.purdue.edu/Porter/s-catsv2.pdfGKUKcFOWYKcJ[eLF{KcD FOS,NMJ KcDVAK&d KcDG]pHGa d_ FOeL]^H KMJ nGHGW FOSMN K.VLH WzKcDGFjP

CEDGF¾yhV8KMFOe[JLSUo�JLX � FOe[VL`�è{È TGSMF{yhV8KMFOe[JLSM]^F{N�Pw]p`^`��6F¿WGFOHGJ8KcFOWrè��YXàØ?ÑÓÒ�Ô���d KjyOJ[HfK.V8]^HGNjKMDGF�yOV8KcF{e[J[SUo�JLXÉçNMx�VL`p`àÌ È~yhVAKcFOeLJ[SM]pFON�V8N�PRF¿D�VhgLF�NMF{FOH���d K�V8`^NMJID�VLNjV±,�nG]p`^`^F{H�yO`^JLNMFOW�x�J�WGF{`�yOV8KcF{e[J[S�o�NUKcSUnGy{KMnGSMF¿]^HPwDG]^y.D$KMDGF�yOJ*����ScV8KM]^J[HGN_VLSUF�KMDGF�x�J[H�J[x�JLSMTGDG]pNMxINOufV8HGW�KMDGF®�G�GScVLHfKRJ[��xUF{y{KcN�VLSMF�F!��VLy!Kc`½o¾KcDGF � FOe[VL`�è{ÈyhV8KMFOe[J[SU]^F{NOufxIJ[SMF{JñgLFOS_V�xIJ[SMTGD�]^NMx ��F{K~PRFOFOH � FOe[VL`�è{È yhV8KMFOe[J[SU]^F{N�]^NvVjPRFhVLa¿FO�bnG]pg8VL`pFOHGy{FE]^H�èt�ZXÖØ?ÑÖÒ<Ô]pX�VLHGWkJ[HG`½o³]pX_]½KQ]^N,VLHkF{��n�]pg8VL`^F{HGyOF¾J8X � F{efVL`Eè{È yhV8KMFOe[JLSM]^F{N�]^H³KMDGFIVL��JñgLF�NMFOH�NMFL��Éçü�JLSQx�J[SUF�J[H#KcD�]^NNUKcSUnGy{KMnGSMF8u�NMFOF,KcD�F¼TGVLT6F{Sw�bo � ]^xITGNMJLH�u��Öt��8�2� Ì` ö�ù: A�AðX)

Ê�`pKcD�J[nGe[D��bnG]pKMF*VYnGNMF!XZnG`�]pHfKcFOSUx�F{WG]lVAKcF�yOJ[H�yOFOTBKh��d¿XZFOF{`EKcD�V8K\Ôpè{È~TGSUFOyOV8KcF{e[J[SUo�À_NMF{FOxINzVkNM`^]pe[DfKx�]pNMHGJ[xIFOS{uG]pKw]pN�VLNw]pX�P�F¼yhVL`p`^F{W�V¾WG]pSMF{y{KcF{W*e[SMVLTGD\V�ÔëTGSUFOyOV8KcF{e[J[SUoL��CEDGF{SMF¼]^NwHGJ�VL`^eLFO�GSMVL]^y�N�KcSUnGy{KMnGSMF]^Hfg[J[`½g[F{W*]^HzKMDGF,HGJLKM]^J[H��-d_D�Vhg[F¼NUKMnGy.a�Pw]pKMD�KMDGFQKcF{SMxI]^H�VLJL`^J[eLo�XZJ[S�P�VLHfK�JLXVI��F{KUKcFOSEKMFOSMx\�

��F,D�Vhg[F¼NMFOF{H�KMD�V8K È yhV8KMFOe[JLSM]^F{N�VLHGW � FOefV8`:yhV8KMFOe[J[SU]^F{NEx�J�WGFO`>T�VLSUKMN�J8XDGJLx�JLKMJ[Tfo$KMDGFOJ[S�o�P�F{`^`2�Ê�K¼KMDGF�NcVLxIF�Kc]px�Fõï$É6£kÌQ]pNQV È e[SMJ[n�T6J[]pWkVLHGW#PRF�HGJ8KcFOWkKcDGV8KQKcDGF{NMFIx�J�WGF{`�VL`p`�DGJ[xIJLKcJLTbo�K~o�T6F{NO�d~H|VLHfo#JLX_KcD�FONMF�x�J�WGF{`^NOu:]½KQ]^N¼VL`½P�Vho�N,SMF{`lV8KM]pg[F{`po*FhVLN�o#KcJ�F!��KcSMVLy{K&]^HBXZJ[SMx�V8Kc]pJ[H*]pH�`pJ?PÍWG]px�F{HGNM]pJ[HGN{u�Gn�K�KMDGF�`^F!g[F{`JLXEÔëVL`^eLFO�GSMVL]^y{]pK~o�À�]^H*NUnGy.Dkx�J�WGF{`^N�]^Nj`p]^xI]pKMFOW�VLHGW³x�VLHfo*T�FOJLTG`^F&D�Vhg[F�NUFhVLSUy.DGFOWkXZJ[S L ÈyhV8KMFOe[J[SU]^yOVL`:x�J�WGF{`^NwJLX�D�J[x�J8KcJ[TfozKMDGFOJ[S�o�J[S�JLX�DGJLx�JLKMJ[TfozK~o�T6F{N�KMD�V8K�]^HGy{J[SMT�J[SMV8KcF,��JLKcD\e[FOJLx�F!KcSM]pyVLHGW|V8`^e[F{�GScVL]py�VLNMT�FOy!KcN¼JLX�KMDGF�KcDGF{J[SUoL��Ï�VLNUFOW'JLH � F{efVL` È~yhVAKcFOeLJ[SM]pFON,VLHGW�DG]^N,WGF{`^J�J[TG]pHGe�x$VLy.D�]^HGF�JLX��tcbñ�ãu�J[HGF�e[F{KMNRKcD�FjC�VLx�NMVLx�VLHG]�x�J�WGF{`^NOu6� �GèO�2u�XZJLS_PRFhVLa L È yhV8KMFOe[JLSM]^F{N�V8HGW�PRFhVLa L È e[SMJLnGT6JL]^WGN-XZJ[SRVLHfoL �

[ \ ¢¿  ¡¢�  ¢¿¤#� ÷ ªj¢Aú ]I¹�«�¢¼¬�ª�·�°I±v�OªQ¡CEDGF�TGSUJ[�G`pFOxÅJLXé��HGWG]pHGe�eLJBJ�W L È~yOV8KcF{e[J[SM]pyhVL`Lx�J�WGFO`pN:XZJ[S:KcDGF_e[FOJLx�F!KcSM]pyvW�V8K.VwFOH�yOJ�WGFOW�]pH¿VwDGJ[xIJLKMJ[TfoK~oBT�F�yhV8x�FIKcJ�KMDGF$XZJ[SUF�Pw]½KcD�ÿQSMJLKMDGFOH�WG]^F{y.a�À�N�HGJ8KcFON{u��ÁqLqA��V8HGWr]^H�T�VLSUKM]^y{nG`lVLS¼DG]pN¿`^F!KMKMFOS,KcJÄ,�nG]p`^`^F{HKcDGF{SMFO]pH���d~H�KMDG]^N¾D�F\NUnGe[e[F{NUKMFOW KMD�V8K�KcD�FOSMF�NUDGJ[nG`pW���F�x�J�WGF{`^N¾JLX�DGJ[xIJLKcJLTbo�K~o�T6F{NIKMD�V8K�Éç]lÌ&P�F{SMF`^FONUN¾SMF{WGnGHGW�V8HbK�]pH'KcD�FO]^S�ÔëW�VAK.V³NUKMJ[ScV8e[FLÀ�KcD�VLH>u-NcVho[uvNM]px�T�`^]^y{]lVL`-NUF{KMN¾J[S�NM]px�T�`^]^y{]lVL`e[SMJ[n�TGNOu�Éç]p]àÌQD�VLWKcDGF¿VLW�g8VLHfK.VLeLFONjJ8X-KcDGF&x�] ��F{W*V8`^e[F{�GScVL]py,yOJ[x���]^H�V8KMJ[SM]py,T6J?PRFOSjJ8X-yhV8KMFOe[JLSM]^F{N¾ÉZy{XÒ�EKcDGF¼P�Vho�]^H\PwDG]^y.DKcDGF³XZnGH�W�VLxIFOHfK.VL`�e[SUJ[nGT�J[]^W4J8X¼V|NM]^xITG`p]^yO]^VL`�y{J[x�T�`^F!� F{HGyOJ�WGFONzKMDGF³e[SMVLTGD4KMDGFOJ[SUF{KM]^y³N�KcSMn�y{Kcn�SMF#JLXKcDGF\è{È~NUaLF{`^F{KMJ[H|V8HGWYKMDGF�VL`^e[F{�GScV8]^y�H�VAKcnGSUF�JLX�T�V8KMD�y{J[HGyhVAKcFOHfKcV8Kc]pJ[H�Ì!uRÉZ]^]^]lÌ�D�VLW�V�DG]^e[D�`po³W�F{g[F{`^J[T�FOWDGJ[xIJLKcJ[Tfo�KcD�FOJ[S�o�KMD�V8K_P�VLN�yOJ[HGNU]^N�KcFOHfK�Pw]½KcDzF{HGJ[nGeLDzDGJ[xIJLKcJLTboIy{J[DGFOSUFOHGy{F,VLHGWzyOV8KcF{e[J[S�oIKMDGFOJLSUo�KcJFOH�VL��`^FwDGJ[xIJLKcJLTbo�VLH�VL`pJ[e[nGF{N-JLX6NMDGFOV8X>KMDGFOJ[SUF{KM]^yEyOJLHGNUKMSMnGy!Kc]^JLHGN-KcJ¼�6FEx�VLWGF¼ÉZNUK.V8y.a�KcDGF{J[SUo�Ì!u�VLH�W³ÉZ]pg�ÌXZJ[S�PwDG]^y.D\yOJLnG`^W���F,WGF{gLFO`^JLT6F{W*V¾DG]pe[DGFOS�J[SMWGF{SEg[FOSUNM]pJ[H�JLX�KMDGF,nGHG] ��FOW�ÿ,VL`^J[]pN�È~í�J[]pHGyhVLS�ËF�KMDGFOJ[S�o$KMD�V8KFOHGy{J[x�TGVLNMNUFON���JLKMD�y{`lVLNUNM]^yOVL`�ÿ,VL`^JL]^NKMDGFOJ[S�o�VLHGWIKcDGF�ÿ,VL`^JL]^N�y{J[SMSUFONMT�J[HGW�FOHGy{F�KcDGV8KvyO`^VLNMNU] ��F{NRy{JñgLFOSU]^HGeNMT�VLy{FON�]^HzKcF{SMxINwJLXEÞ É>ÍYÌ�ëbNMF{KMNOu�ÉZy{XÒ�_Ï�J[SUyOFOn��\VLHGW*m[VLHGF{`^WG] �OFLu:��t8�lÌ!�CEDGF{SMF$VLSMFIHGJ?PìP�F{`^`vabHGJ?PwHrTGSMJL�G`^F{x�N,]^HYnGNU]^HGe\KcDGFIDG]^F{ScVLSUy.Dfo�J8XENUKMSM]^y!K L È~yOV8KcF{e[J[SM]pFONQXZJ[S¼NMnGy.DV�KcVLNMa�u�VLN�KMDGF�NUKcSU]^y!KcHGF{NMN,ab]^`^`pN�yOF{SUKcVL]^H#N�KcSMn�y{Kcn�SMF�KcD�V8K,]pN�HGF{FOWGF{W']pX_J[H�F¾]^N�KcJ�xIJ�WGFO`�NUT�VLy{FON,PwDG]^y.DD�Vhg[FLu-XZJ[S&]^HGN�K.VLH�yOFLuHGJ[HBÈãKcSM]½g�]lVL`-��DG]½KcFOD�FhVLW|T�SMJ�WGnGy{KMNO��ÉZCEDGFzyOSUJ[NMNUFOW�yOJLx�TG`pF!�YxIJBW�FO`^N&JLX¼� �L�2u�XZJ[SF!��VLxITG`^F8uQVLSMF�VL�G`pF³KcJ�D�Vhg[F'V�SUFO`lVAKc]pgLFO`½o4NM]px�T�`^F#NUKMSMnGy!KcnGSUF���FOyOVLnGNUF�KcD�F{o�WGJ�HGJLK�KcS�o<KcJ�x�J�WGF{`��DG]pKMFODGFOVLW¾TGSMJ�WGnGy!KcN{�CEDGF!o�yhV8H¿KcDbnGN���FRKMDGJ[nGeLDbKJLX�F{]pKcD�FOS�V8N]^H�yOJ[xITG`^F!KcF_x�J�WGF{`^N:XZJ[S�V8`^`fDGJ[xIJLKMJ[TfoK~oBT�FON&J[S,yOJ[xITG`pF{KcF¾xIJ�WGFO`pN�XZJ[S¼V\SUFONUKMSM]py{KcF{W'y{`lVLNUN¼J8X�DGJ[xIJLKMJ[Tfo³K~o�T6F{NOuHGVLx�F{`po�KcDGJ[NUFIPw]½KcDkKcSU]pg�]lVL`��DG]pKMFODGFOVLWkTGSMJ�WGnGy!KcNO�ëÌ�ü�SUJ[x¸VzTGnGSMF{`po�yhV8KMFOe[JLSM]^yOVL`�T6J[NU]pKM]^J[H�u�KcDGF¿TGSMJ[��`^FOx¨VLSU]^NMF{N�]^H#W�]^xIFOHGNU]^J[H*t�uPwDGFOSUF¾tAÈ~eLSMJ[nGT�J[]pWGNwyhVLHGH�JLK�yOVLT�Kcn�SMF�V8`^`�DGJ[xIJLKcJLTbo�q?È K~o�T6F{NO��CEDGF�TGSUJ[�G`pFOx�]^NwKcD�F¿]^HfKMFOSMy.DGVLHGe[F&`lVhP,��'F�NcVhPÎDGJ?P ]½KQyOJ[SUSMF{NMT�J[HGWGF{WYKMJzK~P�J\DGJ[xIJLKcJLTG]^F{N&ÔÁNM`^]pWG]^H�eGÀ6J?gLFOS,FhVLy.DYJLKMDGFOS{u:�Gn�KQKcDGV8KQDGJ[xIJLKMJ[TfoyOJ[xIx�n�KcV8Kc]½g[F�NU�bn�VLSMF�]^NH�JLKvV�KMSM]pg�]^VL`fJ[HGFEV8HGW3��Ù?Ü.Û�F{HGyOJ�WGFEN�KcSMn�y{Kcn�SMFL�ÆæQH�F�NMJ[`pn�Kc]pJ[H¿]pN�KMJ�nGNMF{WIÿ,SMVhoe[SMJ[n�T6J[]pWGNOu�ÉçNMF{FEKcDGFEWG]pNMy{nGNMNU]^J[H�VLH�WISUF{XZF{SMFOH�yOFONv]pH\�ÁqIbñ�ãuLXZJLS�]^HGN�K.VLH�yOF?Ì���ÊjH�JLKcDGF{S-SMF{`lV8KMFOW¾J[HGF�]^NKMJQnGNMF

q[×

Page 26: d¾PRJ[nG`^W `^]^a8F KMJ|KcDVLH a i FO]^H FOS ...hopf.math.purdue.edu/Porter/s-catsv2.pdfGKUKcFOWYKcJ[eLF{KcD FOS,NMJ KcDVAK&d KcDG]pHGa d_ FOeL]^H KMJ nGHGW FOSMN K.VLH WzKcDGFjP

KcSM] È~e[SUJ[nGT�J[]^W�NOuLKMDGFwHGF!��KR`^F{gLFO`�nGT�XZSMJ[xÍ�G]^yOV8KcF{e[J[SM]pFONvVLH�W��G]pe[SMJLnGT6JL]^WGN{��C�VLxINcVLx�VLHG]2ÀÁN-V8TGTGSMJ[VLy.D$nGNUFON� FOefV8`�yhV8KMFOe[JLSUo�]^WGFOVLN�KcJ¾F{HGyOJ�WGF�KMDG]^NRHGFOy{FONMNMVLSUo�`^VLy.aIJLX-ÔëN�KcSU]^y{KMHGFONUNOÀ�VLH�W�J[��K.V8]^HGN_P�FOVLa L È yhV8KMFOe[JLSM]^F{Ne[FOHGF{ScVL`p]^NU]^HGe¾�G]pyhV8KMFOe[JLSM]^F{N�XZJ[SwVL`p` L �½�^�RTQ _ `abZ`Thji�kT`Tl\`aV�k³h ]Br�Y�kTbZt�]^_!Va`�`Tl�VXWAY\[S]^_ p^RÊjN_VQNUK.V8SUKc]pHGeQT�J[]^HfK�XZJ[SJ[nGS-`^J�J[a&V8KvC�VLx�NMVLx�VLHG]ãÀ�NxIJ�WGFO`pNOu[y{J[HGNM]pWGFOS-KMDGF�qñÈ~W�]^xIFOHGNU]^J[H�V8`�VLHGVL`^J[eLnGF�JLXKcDGF�ÿ,SUJLKcDGF{HGWG]pFOy.a[È � F{efVL`�yOJ[H�WG]pKM]^J[H¼e[]pgLFOH�]pH�í-SMJLT6J[NU]pKM]^J[H¿qB��CED�V8K�NUDGJ?P�F{W¾KcD�V8K�]pXAÛ P�VLN�V�NM]^xITG`p]^yO]^VL`NMF{K�NMn�y.D�KcDGV8KEXZJ[SwVL`p`AÌQ� qBuGKcDGF � F{efVL`:x�VLTGN

�B� ÌG�\¢<ÛSüp� Û � Ï þ Û � Ï þ ×K×9×Z� Ï þ Û }P�F{SMF¼�G]ÚxUF{y{Kc]pJ[HGN{u�KcDGF{HnÛÅP�VLNwKcDGF,HGF{SUg[F¼JLXV¾yhV8KMFOe[J[S�o[��ÉZ��FQPw]^`p`(xUnGN�K�NMVhozKcD�VAK�ÛÅ]pN�V½Ý � �>Ü!Ú�ßLÜ!�ëÌÿQJ[]^H�e¾nGT�JLHGF,WG]^xIFOHGNU]^J[H>uGV¾nGNMF!XZnG`�TGSMJ�yOF{NMN�]^N�ÔÁyhV8KMFOe[JLSM] �GyhV8KM]^J[H�À½��CEDG]pNwDGJ[SMSU]^�G`pFjPRJ[SMW\]^NE]pH�XçV8y{KV¼e[J�J�WIKMFOSMxÎXZJ[S_VLH�]px�T�J[S�K.VLHfKvTGSUJBy{FONMN{�-Ê�x�J[H�J[]^W�]^N_V,NMF!KRPw]½KcDINMJ[xIFwF!��KcSMV¼N�KcSMn�y{Kcn�SMFL�R��V8KMFOe[JLSM]pXào]pK¿VLHGW']½K¼]^N¼V�NUx$VL`p`-yhV8KMFOe[JLSUo#Pw]pKMD|V\NM]^H�e[`^F�J[��xUF{y{KO�\Ê xIJ[HGJ[]pW�VL`�yOV8KcF{e[J[SUoY]pN&V\yhV8KMFOe[JLSUokPw]pKMD'Vx�nG`pKM]^TG`p]^yOV8Kc]pJ[H�����V8KcF{e[J[SU]pXào�]pKwVLH�W�]pKE]pNEV��G]^yOV8KcF{e[J[S�o$Pw]pKMD�V�NM]pHGe[`^FjJ[��xUFOy!Kh�vd~H�KcDGFQyOV8KcF{e[J[SU] ��yOV8Kc]pJ[HTGSMJ�yOF{NMN-VLH�JLKcDGF{S]pWGFhV�VL`^NUJjJ�yOyOn�SMNO�D�v�bn�V8`^]pK~o,]pN�V�e[SMFOV8K]pWGFhV�XZJ[S�F{`^F{x�F{HbKMNOu8�Gn�K-V�T6J�J[SM`½oQ��FOD�Vhg[F{W�J[HGFXZJ[Svx�J[H�J[]^WGN�PwD�FOSMF�]^NUJ[xIJ[SMTGD�]^NMxÎ]^N-xIJ[SMFwH�VAKcnGSMVL`ã���V8KcF{e[J[SU]pXào�VLH�W�]pNMJ[xIJ[SMT�DG]^NUxÎ]pN_H�JLK_NMJ¼H�V8Kcn�ScVL`2uFO�bnG]pg8VL`pFOHGy{F¾�6F!K~P�F{FOHYyhV8KMFOe[JLSM]^F{N�]^N�PwD�V8K,]^NjHGFOF{WGFOW��&ÊjNQJ[H�F�yhV8KMFOe[JLSM] �GFONjKMDGF¾aLF!o³KcJ�NUnGyOy{FONMN¼]^N�KcJnGNMF¼FO�bnG]½gLV8`^FOH�yOFONwF���y{FOT�KjT6JLNMNM]p�G`po$]^HzKMDGFQKcJ[T\WG]^xIFOH�NM]^JLH�V?g8VL]p`lVL��`^FL�

��V8KMFOe[JLSM]pXào�]pHGe�KMDGF�ÿQSMJLKMDGFOHGW�]^FOy.a[È � FOefV8`yOJLHGWG]pKM]^J[H>u6`pF{KpÛÍ�6F¾V��G]^NU]^xITG`^]pyO]lV8`�NMF!Kh����F�yhVLH³KMDG]^H�aJLXKMDG]^NwVLN

Ûÿ¢�É � � ü Ì � � ª��KÔ�ÙJ[S

Ûÿ¢X� � ü � ×Ï�JLKcDYP�Vho�N�V8SMF�nGNMF!XZnG`ãu��Gn�K¿V�P�J[SUW']pN¼H�FOFOW�FOW|J[HYHGJLKcV8Kc]pJ[H��Id X�Û¸¢à��� ü � }:KcD�FOH�XZJLS$� ÌG��¯Æ��uÛqüG¢¶��� ü � ª��KÔ�Ù¾VLHGW³]½KcNwgLV8`^nGF¼J[H��cbA��]^N®Ûqüwj d�]^H\KcDGF�J8KcDGF{SjHGJLKcV8Kc]pJ[H�����J[HBXZnGNM]pJ[H³yhV8H#VLSM]pNMF¿VL�6JLn�KPwDG]^y.D�ÔÁg8VLSU]lVL�G`pFLÀ�]pN,y.D�VLHGe[]pHGe�VLHGW�PwD�]^y.DYyOJ[HGN�K.VLHfKOuNMJ\KcDGFIHGJLKcV8Kc]pJ[HÄÛ üfe D�VLN¼�6F{FOH']pHfKcSMJ�WGnGy{FOWkKcJ]^HGWG]pyhV8KMF&KMD�V8KQV8HbobKMDG]^HGezV8XàKcF{S�KcD�Fhg�]^N�g8VLSUo�]^H�eG�jd~H#WG]px�F{HGNM]pJ[H#q�u6KcD�]^Nj]pNjHGJ8KjKcDGV8K�F{NMNMF{HfKc]lV8`�Gn�K�]^HDG]^e[D�FOSwWG]^xIFOH�NM]^JLHGN�]pKw]pNwV¾e[SMFOV8KwDGFO`pT��

Ê�NMNMn�x�F$KMD�V8K\ÉZ]àÌ�Û ðie ]^N¿V*yOJLHGNUKcVLHfK�NM]^xITG`p]^yO]^VL`�NUF{Khu�PwSU]pKUKcFOHrNU]^xITG`poÄÛ�ð�VLHGWryOVL`^`pFOW�KMDGF�Û?Ü!Ý&Ù�6Ù�� �hÜ��!ÝZÛ$JLX Û&u�ÉZ]^]àÌ�XZJLS&FOVLy.D�ÌM¯Ç��uXÛSüfew¯ ]^N¼V�è{È HGFOS�g[F8u�VLHGW4Éç]p]^]àÌ�u�VLefVL]pHYXZJLS¼FOVLy.D�Ì�¯Ç��u�KMDGFx�J[SUTGDG]pNMx �B� ÌG�\¢*Ûqüfeq��Û e®� Ï þ Û e®� Ï þ ×K×9×ä� Ï þ Û e9}]^N�VLH�FO�bnG]½gLV8`^FOH�yOF,JLX�yhV8KMFOe[J[SU]^F{NO�

d~H�JLKMDGFOS�PRJ[SMW�NwÛ�]pN¾V|Ô � F{efVL`�qñÈ yhV8KMFOe[JLSUo�ÀJ[S¾T�FOSUD�VLTGN�ÔÁCV8x�NMVLx$V8HG]½È � FOefV8`_PRFhVLarqñÈ~yOV8KcF{e[J[SUo�À½���D�V8K�WGJ�FONwNMnGy.D*V¾�6FOVLNUKM]^F,`^J�J[aI`^]^a8F?�

ü�J[SwVLHfo�TGVL]^S,É�Ì�}�bLÌq¯0> � u�P�F¼yhV8H\KMDG]^HGa�JLXVLHfo3Ò³¯¤Ûqüwj dEV8N���FO]pHGeIV\É Ì�}�bLÌ~È TGSM]pNMx\uÒ³¢�� Ì����

��jbñ��� ÛÓ×

CEDGF�y{J[HGWG]½Kc]pJ[H|KcD�VAK0Û~ðie�]^N¾yOJLHGNUKcVLHfKhu�]px�T�`^]^F{N&KMD�V8KGÛ~ð�j d¾]pN�KcDGF�NcV8x�FzXZJ[S�V8`^`!b���ü�J[S¾]^H�NUK.V8HGyOF8u�VÉ�è�}hè?Ì~È~T�SM]^NUxÄPRJ[nG`pW�H�VAKcnGSMVL`^`½oz`^J�J[aI`^]paLF¼V¾NM�bn�VLSUFLu��Gn�K�NM]pHGyOF¼]pKw]pNEyOJ[HGN�K.VLHfK�]^H�KcD�F&NUFOyOJLHGW*WG]pSMF{y{Kc]pJ[HP�F¼e[F{K�VLNwV���F{KMKMFOSwTG]py{Kcn�SMF*¢

qL�

Page 27: d¾PRJ[nG`^W `^]^a8F KMJ|KcDVLH a i FO]^H FOS ...hopf.math.purdue.edu/Porter/s-catsv2.pdfGKUKcFOWYKcJ[eLF{KcD FOS,NMJ KcDVAK&d KcDG]pHGa d_ FOeL]^H KMJ nGHGW FOSMN K.VLH WzKcDGFjP

k k k k k k k kkkkkkkkkk k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k kk k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k k kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk

k k k k k k k kkkkkkkkkmln o k k k k k k k kkkkkkkkk kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk

kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk��eG�Eè

CEDGF&]½KcF{ScV8KMFOW�XçVLyOF,x�VLTGN�XZSUJ[x Û üpe KcJ0Û�ð�o�]^F{`^W\V¾x$V8TÛ üfe � Û�ð~� ×9×9×�Û�ð

VLHGW�]pX-É=y�ð�}9×K×9×K}�y(üAÌq¯�Û~ðS��×9×9×�Û~ð?ubKcDGF{HzP�F�x�Vho�KcDG]pHGa¾JLX:KcD�Fj]^HfgLFOSMNUFQ]^x�VLe[FwJLX_É>y�ð�}9×9×9×�}�y(üAÌ_�fo�KcD�]^Nx$VLT$VLNvKcDGF&è{È~HGF{SUgLF¾É2V8HGW�KMD�n�N�yhVAKcFOeLJ[SUo�Ì-JLX�KcD�J[NMF�TGSM]pNMxIN_DGV?g�]pHGe&KMDGF¾É>y�ð9}9×9×9×�}�y(üAÌvVLN_KMDGFO]pS_gLFOS�Kc]^y{FON]^H$KMDGF���SUNUKEW�]^SMF{y{KM]^J[H����'F�Pw]^`^`�W�FOHGJLKMFjKcD�]^N��fowÛqüfe?É>y�ð�}9×9×9×�}�y(üñÌ!�-d~H$J[nGS�NU]^xITG`^F�yhV8NMFjPRF�D�Vhg[FSÌ÷¨ è[uVLHGW3Û e É=y�ð�}�y Ì�yOJ[HGNU]^N�Kc]^H�eIJ8X�KMDG]^HGeLNE`^]^a8F*¢

q q q q q q q qqqqqqqqq qqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqq q q q q q q q qq q qq q q q q

rts rvuw q q q q q q q qqqqqqqqqq q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q qq q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q ��e��_q

CEDGF&NU]^xITG`^]pyO]^VL`�NMF{K®Û e�]^NwV�è{È HGFOS�g[F8u�NUJ�Þ^Û�V¾yOV8KcF{e[J[SUo'¢-XZJ[SEFOVLy.D;bA� q�uGKcDGF � F{efVL`�x�VLT�B�cbA��¢<Û j dS� Û j � Ï þ\Û j � Ï þ^×9×9×A� Ï þEÛ j }

]^N�V���]ÚxUFOy!Kc]pJ[H��CED�]^N�]pN�]^H�DGFOSU]pKcF{Wz�fo�KMDGF�]pHGWG]pg�]pWGn�VL`�Û eñÉ>y�ð�}�y ÌÒNO�vü�J[S�]pHGNUKcVLHGy{FLu�KMDG]^HGeLN�]^HwÛ j � `pJBJ[a`^]^a8F*¢

x x x x xx x x x x xx x x x x xx x x x x xx x x x x x xx x x x x xx x x x x xx x x x x xx x x x x xx x x x x x xx x x x x xx x x x x xx x x x x xx x x x x x xx x x x x xx x x x x xx x x x x xx x x x x xxx x x x x x x x x x x xxxxxxxxxxxxxx x x x x x x x x x x xxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx x x x x x x x x x x xxxxxxxxxxxxx

x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x xx x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x

x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x xx x x

xxxxxx

x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x xx x x x x x x x x x x xxxxxxxxxxxxx x x x x x x x x x x x xxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx

x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x xx x x x x x x x x x x xxxxxxxxxxxxxyvz

yt{

|}| }

��eG�_tVLHGW�VLNEKcDGF,WG]^VLe[ScV8xÄ]pNE]^HfKcF{HGWGFOW\KcJ�]^H�WG]^yOV8KcF8uGyOJ[xIT�J[NM]½Kc]^JLH$P�JLSMabN�T�FOS�XZFOy!Kc`poL�

CEDGF � F{efVL`:x�VLTGN �B� ÌG�\¢*Ûqüfeq��Û e®� Ï þ�Û e®� Ï þ^×K×9×ä� Ï þ\Û e9}VLSMF¼VL`p`�FO�bnG]½gLV8`^FOH�yOFON�JLX�yhV8KMFOe[JLSM]^F{NO�vC�J�N�K.VLS�K�KMJ�nGHGWGF{SMNUKcVLHGW*KMDG]^N�PRF¼`^J�J[azV8KÆ̱¨ÃqB�vCEDGF¼TGSU]^NMxÄXZJ[SbÖ¨ è¼`^J�J[abNE`^]^a8F*¢

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~ ~~~~ ~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~

~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~

~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ���v�

�t� �t�

��eG����'F³DGV?gLF³KcDGSUFOF'ÔÁ`^J*�OFOH�e[FLÀRNMD�VLT�FOW4gLFOS�Kc]^yOVL`�XçV8yOFON{u&ÉçFhV8y.D4Pw]pKcD4V�qñÈ~y{FO`^`)gLVLSUSMJ?P e[JL]^HGeYXZSMJ[x£KcJLT�KcJ�6JLKUKcJ[x$Ì�VLHGW�KMDGF¾ÔëDGJLSM] �{J[HfK.VL`2ÀBKMSM]lV8HGe[nG`^VLSwqñÈ yOFO`p`^N,ÉZHGJIVLSMSUJ?PÃNMD�JñPwH�]^H�KcD�F¼W�]lVLe[SMVLx$Ì!�

d XSÛ � e P�VLN�Þ^Û?Ù��$ÙAÚ~åä��Þo�¼KMJ3Û e � Ï þ Û e KMDGFOHkKcDGF�XZSUJ[HfKQK~P�J�XçVLy{FON{u�KMDGFIqñÈ yOFO`p`^N�Ò�VLHGW��?u�P�JLnG`^WnGHG]^�bnGF{`porW�F{KcF{SMxI]^HGF�KMDGF�KcDG]pSMW�XçVLyOF8u�VLH�W�KMD�n�N$VkyOJ[xIT�J[NM]½KcFLu_�Gn�K�VL`p`�PRF�D�VhgLF�]pN�KcD�V8K��B�Áqñ�w]^N�VLH

qIb

Page 28: d¾PRJ[nG`^W `^]^a8F KMJ|KcDVLH a i FO]^H FOS ...hopf.math.purdue.edu/Porter/s-catsv2.pdfGKUKcFOWYKcJ[eLF{KcD FOS,NMJ KcDVAK&d KcDG]pHGa d_ FOeL]^H KMJ nGHGW FOSMN K.VLH WzKcDGFjP

Ü��+!BÞàßAáLæ^Ü��$�.Ü�JLX:yOV8KcF{e[J[SU]^FON{���Fj`^F!K�����qA�\¢<Û e � Ï þäÛ e � Û � e �6FjVLH$]pHfg[FOSUNMF�F{�bnG]pg8VL`pFOHGy{FL�-CEDGF{SMF�V8SMFH�V8Kcn�ScVL`:]pNMJ[xIJ[SMT�DG]^NUx�N� � ¢��B�Áqñ�����qA� ÈÉ� ø�Çä} VLHGW ���qA�¹����qA� ÈÉ��øéÇä×

CEDGF$J[�fg�]^JLnGN&W�F���HG]½Kc]pJ[HYXZJLS,KMDGFIyOJ[xIT6JLNM]pKMF¾P�J[n�`^W'��FwÇ ����qA� É;Òä}5�!Ì!u��Gn�K&]pK,]pN&��F{KUKcFOS,KcJ\TGSUFOTGSUJBy{FONMNKcDG]pHGe[N�V��G]½K$V8NIKMDG]^N�WGJ�FON�HGJLKIe[]pgLF��bnG]½KcF�KcDGF\SM]pe[DfKzV8HGNUPRFOS{� � nGTGT�J[NMF\KcD�VAK�Pw]½KcDG]pHMÛ e É=y�ð�}�y Ì�uÒ3¢A­¤¨v� ­ ð VLHGW\KcD�V8K�Pw]pKMDG]^H3Û eñÉ>y }�y � Ì�u¬�à¢�°³¨v� ° ð �&ÉZ��F¼Pw]p`^`:nGNUF�Ô qñÈ~y{FO`^`2À�VLSUSMJ?PwNjNU]^HGy{F&KcDGV8Kj]pNPwD�V8KwP�F¼DGJ[T�FQKcDGF!ozPw]^`p`>��F,`lV8KMFOSO�ëÌ�CEDGFOSUF¼VLSMF,]^NUJ[xIJ[SMTGD�]^NMxIN�Pw]½KcDG]pH÷Û e®� Ï þ�Û ehu� � Éo­�}�°�Ìq¢�����qA�m��ÁqA� Éo­�}�°�ÌD¨v� Éo­'}�°GÌ�}

VLHGW� � Éo­ ð }�° ð Ì�¢��B�ÁqA�m��Áqñ�~É;­ ð }�° ð Ìƨv� É;­ ð }�° ð Ì�}

VLHGW\DGFOHGy{F¿V¾y{J[x�T�J[NU]pKcF�B�ÁqA�m��Áqñ�~É;­'}�°�Ì�� y R  j » S¨v� Éo­�}�°�Ì R º9¼ ^ S¨v� Éo­ ð }�° ð Ì@� y R Â�� j »i� S(� x¨5� �B�ÁqA�m��Áqñ�~É;­ ð }�° ð Ì�×

�'SU]pKc]pHGeO. ¨?����qA� Éo­�}�°�Ì�VLH�W#NM]^xI]^`^VLSM`½oO. ð ¨?��ÁqA� Éo­ ð }�° ð Ì!u6PRF�D�VhgLF�K~P�J�J[�(xUFOy{KMN�JLX-KMDGF�yhVAKcFOeLJ[SUo3Û � eVLHGW�VLNÒ����qA��]^N�VLH$F{�bnG]pg8VL`pFOHGy{FLu�]½K_]^NvXZnG`^`½o¾XçVL]pKMD�XZnG`�VLHGW$FONMNUFOHfKc]^VL`^`½o�NMnGS>xUFOy!Kc]pgLFL�_i�J?PRF{gLFOS�PRFjD�Vhg[FjJ[nGSyOJ[xIT6JLNM]pKMF&]pH�Û ep� Ï þEÛ eñÉ �B�Áqñ�¹.�}5����qA�]. ð Ì�u6NUJ$KcDGF{SMF&]^N�VInGHG]p��n�F��³¯ Û � e?É#.$}�. ð Ì�x�VLTGT�FOW�WGJ?PwH³KcJ$]½K�bou����qA�2�¿�'F¾NUF{KÓ­v�õð2°n¨ÐÇ É2.:Ì!u�VLHGW ­ ð �õð2° ð ¨ Ç É2. ð Ì!u:e[]½gB]pHGe�V�NMF{HGNM]p�G`^F¾W�F���HG]½Kc]pJ[H#JLX ��ÙAÚ�Þm�AÙ���Ý áLæyOJ[xIT6JLNM]pKM]^J[H�J8X�è{È~VLSMSUJ?PwNOu�VLH�W\KMDGFOHnÒ���ð8��¨åÇ É#�LÌ�VLNwyOJLx�T�J[NM]½KcF,q?È~yOF{`^`2���F�Pw]^`p`bHGJLK�eL]pg[FRKcDGF�y{J[xITG`^F!KcF�T�SMJ�JLX�JLX�KMDGF�XçVLy!K�KcD�VAK-VLHfo&CVLxINcV8x$VLH�]½È � FOefVL`�q?È~yhVAKcFOeLJ[SUo¼WGF���HGFONV���]^yhVAKcFOeLJ[SUo�VLHGW�ß?Þo�.Ü�ßLÜ!Ú.ÛOáL�,CEDGF�V8�6J?g[F�xUn�NUK,e[]½g[FONQNUJ[xIF�JLXvKcDGFAÀ�V?gLJ[nGSQJLXvKMDGF¾x�F!KcDGJ�W��,d~H³KcD�]^NVLTGTGSUJfVLy.Dk]pKQ]pN�gLFOSUo³FhVLN�o³KcJ�x�VLaLF�VzNM`^]pT³NMJ�`pF{K�n�NSxUnGNUK,HGJ8KcF�KcDGV8K�KcD�F�VLSMe[n�x�F{HbKMN���FO]^H�e�nGNMF{W�V8SMFx�J[SUF�J[S-`pFONMN-]pWGFOHfKM]^yhV8`BKcJ�KMDGJ[NUFEnGNMF{WIKMJQTGSMJ?g[FEKMDGFESMF{NMnG`½KvJ[H¾SMF{TG`lVLy{FOxIFOHfKvnGT¾KcJQNUT6F{yO] ��FOW�DGJ[xIJLKMJ[TfoFO�bnG]pg8VL`pFOHGy{FzJLXwNUT�VLyOF{N¾]^H'V³yOJ[xIx�n�KcV8Kc]½g[FIWG]lVLeLScVLx NUJkVLN&KMJ³e[F{K�V³DGJ[xIJLKcJLTboYy{J[DGFOSUFOHfK¾WG]^VLe[SMVLx��d K�NMD�J[nG`^W\KcDbnGN���F¿T�J[NUNM]^��`^FQKcJzn�NMF¿]pWGFhV8N�XZSUJ[x�KcD�V8KjVLSUFhV�J8X-DGJ[xIJLKcJLTbo�y{J[DGF{SMFOH�yOFLu�VLHGW³F���T�FOSU]^F{HGyOFJLXENM]px�]p`lVLSjTGSMJ[��`^FOxIN¼]^HYJLKcDGF{S¿V8SMFhV8N&KcJ�NMDGJLSUKcF{H'KcD�F�TGSUJBJ8XEe[]pgLFOH��boYC�VLxINcVLx�VLHG]�ÉàKcDGF�WGF{KcVL]^`pN&V8SMFJ[x�]½KMKMFOW�XZSMJ[x �Ú��èO�àÌ�uG�Gn�K�VLSUF,]^HGy{`^nGWGF{W�]^H�KcDGFQKMDGFONU]^NwJ[H�PwDG]^y.D�KcDGV8K�VLSUKM]^yO`pF�]^NE�GVLNMF{W��^�Reç mGV�h béV�h V�ë�`or,W®Y\[SV�k0c�Y\V�¦��qr?l�VXWAY\[S]^_�`aY�b�'FjPw]p`^`�HGJLK�e[]pgLF�V�WGF!K.VL]p`^FOWIKcSUFhV8KMx�F{HbK�JLX:KcD�F�F!��KcF{HGNM]pJ[H�JLX:KcD�FONMFQ]pWGFhV8NRKcJ L WG]^xIFOH�NM]^JLHGNO��d KRP�JLnG`^WK.VLa8FIn�TYKMJBJ�x�n�y.D�NUT�VLyOF�DGF{SMF8�0��V8KMDGFOS�PRF¾Pw]^`p`�XZJ[`p`^J?P KcDGF¾NUnGxIx$VLS�o³JLXvKMD�V8K,F!��KMFOHGNU]^J[HYe[]pgLFOHk�fo� ]^xITGNMJLH�]pH³�Öt[é8�2�EÉ;æQH�F�PRJ[SMW�JLX>P�VLSUHG]^HGe�u�]pHIKMD�V8K_NMJLnGSMy{F�KMDGF�JLHG`po�K~o�T�FONRJLX L È~yhVAKcFOeLJ[SM]pFON-KcD�VAKRJ�yOy{nGSVLSMFIKcDGFIP�FOVLa L È~yOV8KcF{e[J[SM]pFON¼�6F{]^HGe�WGF{gLFO`pJ[T6F{W|]^HYKcD�VAK¿NUF{KMKM]^HGe�uNMJ�KcDGF$VLn�KcD�J[S&JLx�]½KcN,KcDGF$VLW�xUFOy!Kc]½g[FÔÁPRFhVLa�ÀRyOJ[HGNU]^N�KcFOHfKM`po[� i�F�NUKcV8KcF{N�KcD�]^NIFhVLSU`po�J[H �Gn�Kz]½KIx�FOVLHGN�KcD�V8K$]pKI]^NIW�VLH�e[FOSUJ[nGN�KMJ ÔÁWG]^T>À_]pHfKcJKcDG]pN�T�VLT�FOSQV8`pKcD�J[nGe[D\P�F{`^`�PRJ[S�KcD#SMFOVLWG]pHGe$XZSMJLx¸KMDGF�NUKcVLSUKjXZJ[S�KMDGF�]^W�FhVLN�]½KjW�]^NMy{nGNMNUFON¼VLHGW#W�F{g[F{`^J[T�NO��'F¾Pw]^`p`�yOVL`^`�KcDGF{NMFIJ[��xUF{y{KcN¾ÔÁC�È � PRFhVLa L È~yOV8KcF{e[J[SM]pFON{À>KcJ�WG]pNUKM]^HGe[n�]^NMD³KMDGFOx¸XZSMJ[x¸KcDGF¾J8KcDGF{SQx�J�WGFO`pNV?g8VL]p`lVL��`^FL�ë̼��FQPw]^`^`>`lVLnGH�y.D\]pH\V8KQÔÁKMDGF,WGFOF{T*F{HGW�ÀM�

/ öcÄ�ò��àú7�çó�òÊ ä � F $ ÜMá�h L � �MáLÝÒÜãâ�ÙAÚ���]^NwV¾XZnGHGy{KMJ[S

Û ¢X� � ü �A�C��ÒXÅ�É L �<èñÌ�ÑÖÒ�Ô�}PwDGFOSUFT�Á��Ò�Å>É L �<èñÌTÑÓÒ�Ô�]pN�KcDGF,yOV8KcF{e[J[SUozJLXC�È � P�FOVLaYÉ L �4èñÌ È_yhV8KMFOe[JLSM]^F{NOuGNUnGy.D*KMD�V8K

q*�

Page 29: d¾PRJ[nG`^W `^]^a8F KMJ|KcDVLH a i FO]^H FOS ...hopf.math.purdue.edu/Porter/s-catsv2.pdfGKUKcFOWYKcJ[eLF{KcD FOS,NMJ KcDVAK&d KcDG]pHGa d_ FOeL]^H KMJ nGHGW FOSMN K.VLH WzKcDGFjP

» Û~ð�]^NwV�NMF!K�ÉZ]ã��FL�vV¾WG]pNMyOSUF{KMF&C�È � PRFhV8aYÉ L �<èñÌ È~yhVAKcFOeLJ[SUo�Ì!Æ» XZJ[SEFhV8y.DwÌQ� qBu�KcD�F � FOefVL`:x�VLT

��� ÌG�\¢�Û üpe ��Û e � Ï þEÛ e � Ï þ�×9×9×Z� Ï þ�Û e }]^NwVLH'É L �<è?Ì~È~F{�bnG]pg8VL`pFOHGy{FQJLX�PRFhV8aYÉ L �<èñÌ È~yhVAKcFOeLJ[SM]pFONO�

` ö�ù: A�Að�û��`pFhVLSU`po�NMJ[xIF,SMFOx�VLSUa�N�VLSUFQyhVL`p`^F{W�XZJLSK¢

Éç]àÌ�d K,]^N�y{`^FhV8SjKcD�VAK¼VLHfo³C�È � PRFhVLa L È~yOV8KcF{e[J[S�o³]^N�V�NUT6F{yO]^VL` L È~NM]px�T�`^]^y{]lVL`:NUF{K&VLHGW#y{J[nG`pWY��F¾FO�bn�V8`^`poP�F{`^`:NMT�FOy{] ��F{W*�fo

Ûÿ¢�Él� � ü Ì ¦ � ª��KÔ�Ù<×CEDGF�HGJLKcV8Kc]pJ[H:Û üpe ]pN&KMDGFzJ[�fg�]^J[n�N�F!��KcF{HGNM]pJ[HrJLXEKMD�V8K¿PwD�]^y.D|P�VLN¾nGNMF{W�]^H'yOVLNMF L ¨¨qB�#CEDbnGN�KMDGFÉ L �4èñÌ È~NM]px�T�`^]^y{]lVL`�NUF{K®ÛqüfewNcV8KM]^N��GFON

Û üfe ÉM�cb �o}ñ�cb � �;}9×9×K×K}ñ�cb�¦ � �àÌ�¨ Ûqüwj d x j d y j z|z|z j d } � x ×ÊÓXZnGSUKMDGFOS¿F!��KcF{HGNM]pJ[HrJLXEKcD�FzHGJLKcV8Kc]pJ[H']pN�VL`pNMJ³nGNUF{XZnG`2�#�:F{KG² ¨�ÉM�|ï �o}K×9×9×�}ñ� ﱦ � �àÌ,�6FzVLH|J[��xUF{y{KJLX@� ¦ � VLHGW �|ïz��¯v��u�KMDGFOH�Éo²H}�ï\ÌjJ[SQx�JLSMF�y{J[SMSUFOy{KM`porÉo²H}ñ�|ïz�lÌ!u�WGFOH�JLKcF{N&V8HYJL�bg�]pJ[nGNQJ[��xUF{y{K¼JLX� ¦ ����F�Pw]p`^`PwSU]pKMFGÛ8��XZJLS�KcDGFIJ[�fg�]^J[nGN,NU]^xITG`^]pyO]lV8`�NUF{Khu�]^H#PwDG]py.D�KMDGF���SMN�K�É L �ÂèñÌ È g8VLSU]lVL�G`pFONQV8SMFÔëy{`lVLxIT6F{W�ÀbV8K�²Î�-ü]pH�VL`p`po�]½X�² ¯�� ¦ � ý VLH�W÷² ð ¯�� ý XZJ[SvNMJ[xIF�â�KcDGF{HzV&H�JLK.V8KM]^J[H0Û R �Áj � � S Pw]p`^`G��FnGNMF{W³]^H�KcDGF¼J[�fg�]^J[n�N�P�Vho[��CEDG]pN�]pNwT�VLSUKM]^y{nG`lVLSU`po$nGNMF!XZnG`:PwDGFOHIJ ð ¨Ås*ýõ¢¶¨ìÉ2sA}K×9×9×�}.sfÌ ¯~� ý ��FOyhV8nGNMFJLXKMDGF,HGF!��K�SMF{x$VLSUa��Éç]^]lÌ�CED�F�SMF{��n�]^SMF{x�F{HfK�KcD�VAKDÛ~𮢶¨HÛ ðie ��FEVjNUF{K-]pN�KcJj�6F�]pHfKcFOSUTGSMF!KcF{W�VLN�xIFhVLHG]pHGe�KMD�V8K]pK�]^N�V�yOJ[HGN�K.VLHfKÉ L ��èñÌ È~NU]^xITG`^]pyO]lV8`>NMF!Kh�Qd Kj]^NjH�JLKQD�VLSUW*KcJ$NMDGJ?P KcD�V8K�VLN�KMDG]^N�Pw]^`p`���F&KMDGF�yhV8NMF¿XZJ[SjVL`^`�]pHbKMFOSUx�F{WG]lV8KMFWGF���H�]pKc]pJ[HGNQJLX_C�È � PRFhV8a�ÅbÈ~yOV8KcF{e[J[S�o[u�sDPÎÅ=P L u�KMDG]^NjyOJ[HGW�]pKc]pJ[H³]px�TG`p]^F{N�KcDGV8K,]^H³KMDGF L È NM]^xITG`p]^yO]^VL`NMF{K�Û¿u�]½X�Ì ¹ ¨Âs¾XZJ[SENUJ[x�FàÅUu�KMDGFOH3Ûqü x j z|z|z j ü } ¨HÛqü x j z|z|z j ü� � x j ð } � �Òu�]ã��FL�v]½Kw]^Nw]^HGW�FOT�FOHGWGF{HfKjJLX�KcD�F¼g8VL`pnGFONwJLXÌ ¹ ã }9×9×K×K}oÌZ¦����'FvPw]^`p`fnGNMFvKcDGF_KcF{SMx L � å�ÚcÜ��MáLÝ~Üãâ�ÙAÚ��jXZJ[S�V L È~NM]px�T�`^]^y{]lVL`8NMF!Khu*Ûÿ¢�É ��� ü Ì ¦ � ª��KÔ�Ù�}?PwDG]^y.DNcV8KM]^N��GFONQKcDGFõ�GSMNUK,y{J[HGWG]½Kc]pJ[Ht¢®Û~ðzÞ^Û�á�Û?Ü!ÝQVLH�W#DGFOHGy{F�D�VLN�KcD�FIT�SMJ[T�FOS�K~o³JLXwÔÁyOJ[HGN�K.VLH�y{o�À�x�F{HbKM]^J[H�FOWVL�6J?gLFL�Éç]^]p]àÌjCEDGF$yhV8KMFOe[J[S�okJLXEC�È � P�FOVLa L È~yOV8KcF{e[J[SU]^FON¼]^N¼WGF���HGFOWr]pH�KMDGF$J[�fg�]^JLnGN¼P�Vho[u-�GnBKhu�JLX�yOJ[nGSUNMF8u�ÞàÝZÛWGF���H�]pKc]pJ[H�Pw]^`^`�W�FOT�FOHGWzJLH�KcDGV8K_JLX�PRFhVLa�É L ��è?Ì~È~yOV8KcF{e[J[SU]^FON_VLH�W�KcD�F�yOV8KcF{e[J[SUo�KMDGF{o¾XZJ[SUx VLHGW�NMJ¿JLH��ÊjN�PRF�D�VhgLF�V�H�JLKc]pJ[H�J8X�P�FOVLa*qñÈ~yOV8KcF{e[J[SUo�]pH\KMDG]^N�NMF!KMKM]^HGeGu�KMD�V8K�W�JBF{N�HGJ8KjyOVLnGNMF�V�TGSUJ[�G`^F{x��R��D�V8K]^N�xIJ[SMFjJLX�V��6J8KcDGF{S�]^N�KMD�V8K�KMDGF�WGF���HG]½Kc]^JLH�VL`^NUJ¾WGFOT�FOH�WGNESMF{yOnGSUNM]pgLFO`½o�J[H�V¿HGJ8Kc]^JLH�JLX�FO�bnG]½gLV8`^FOH�yOFQJLXP�FOVLaYÉ L �4èñÌ È~yOV8KcF{e[J[SM]pFON{�

J ����ò�ï� Bú7�çó�òÊ L È~TGSUFOyhVAKcFOeLJ[SUo³Pw]p`^`���F¾NcV8]^W#KcJ���FDÝ � ÝçÚ8!é�$�MáLÝãác�Oæ^ÜI]pXvXZJ[S,V8`^`Ʋ ¯ÃÉl�'Ì ¦ � u\Û8�¸]pN,V�yOV8KcF{e[J[S�oÉç]ã��FL�-]pN�KcDGF,HGF{SUgLF¿JLXV¾yhV8KMFOe[J[S�o�Ì!�

d X^ÛÍ]pN�è{ÈãKcSMn�HGyhV8KcVL�G`pFLu�KcDGF{HkPRF¾yhV8H³XZJ[SMx¸VkÉ L � èñÌ~È TGSMF{yhV8KMFOe[J[S�onÏ®Û&u�yhVL`p`^F{W�KcD�F�Ý � Ý2Ú8!��$�MáLÝ2ÞãÙ��JLX�Û¿u�PwDG]^y.DkVLNUNMJ�yO]^V8KcF{N�KcJ÷² KcDGF�NUF{KQJ8Xv]^NMJLx�J[SUTGDG]pNMx y{`lVLNUNMFONQJ8X-J[��xUF{y{KcNQJ8X-KcDGF&yhV8KMFOe[J[S�o[utÛ8�$�jd XÛ ]pNQè{È KMSMnGH�yhV8KcVL�G`^F8u�KcD�FOSMF,]pNwVIH�VAKcnGSMVL`�xIJ[SMTGD�]^NMxÄJLX�É L �<èñÌ È~NM]px�T�`^]^y{]lVL`�NUF{KMNOu

� É=ÛQÌOÉ;²ÃÌ ¢�Û R �Áj ð S ��Ï¿É6Û�Ì R � S }PwDG]^y.D�NMFOH�WGNjV8H\JL��xUFOy!KjJLX�KcD�F¼yOV8KcF{e[J[S�o÷Û�� KcJ�]½KcNw]^NUJ[x�JLSMTGDG]pNMx yO`^VLNMN{�

qLé

Page 30: d¾PRJ[nG`^W `^]^a8F KMJ|KcDVLH a i FO]^H FOS ...hopf.math.purdue.edu/Porter/s-catsv2.pdfGKUKcFOWYKcJ[eLF{KcD FOS,NMJ KcDVAK&d KcDG]pHGa d_ FOeL]^H KMJ nGHGW FOSMN K.VLH WzKcDGFjP

��F�Pw]p`^`�NMV?o�KMD�V8KSÛÂ]^N�Å � ÝçÚ8!é�$�MáLÝãác�Oæ^Ü�XZJ[S�qAªÇÅ�ª L ]½X:VLHGW�J[HG`½o�]pXtÛ ]^NjÉlÅ®��èñÌ È KMSMnGHGyOV8K.V8�G`^F�VLHGWÏ � � ÛÎ]pNQè{È KMSMnGH�yhV8KcVL�G`^F8��Ç�JñPÃNMnGTGT�J[NUF¼KMD�V8K�Û ]pN ÅbÈ KMSMnGHGyOV8K.V8�G`^F8u�VLHGW�KMD�V8K¼è�ªHâ0ªÑŽP L �RCEDGFOHKcDGF{SMF¼]^NwV¾x�JLSMTGDG]pNMxÄJLXEÉ L � â�Ì~È~NU]^xITG`^]pyO]^VL`�NMF{KMNOu

� ý É6Û�Ì�� ¢�Û R �Áj ð ¯ S � Ï ý É=ÛQÌ R � S }XZJ[S®² ¯�� ¦ � ý u�VLH�W�V8�G�GSMF!g�]lV8KM]^HGe�Éo²Ý}.s ¹ ÌRKMJw² ¹ uGe[]½g[F{H*VLNEKMDGF,yOJ[xIT6JLNM]pKMF

Û R � ¯ S�� R Ï S)��� ¯ � xH��$� Ï¿É=ÛQÌ R � ¯ � x S�� R��Ï S)��� ¯ � yi���� Ï � É6Û�Ì R � ¯ � y S ��� ×9×9××9×K×Z��� Ï ý � É6Û�Ì R � x S � R��

¯ � x Ï S)����S��� Ï�É=ÛQÌ R � ¯ � x S ×

L � ö��t���=�A �õZöBò�ï[öÊ�NjP�F¿D�Vhg[F�VL`pSMFhV8W�o\HGJLKcF{W�u:VLH*FO�bnG]pg8VL`pFOHGy{F�JLXvyOV8KcF{e[J[SM]pFON�]^N�VIXZnGHGy{KMJ[SOu�­ ¢äÛ � ÜÓKcDGV8K�]pN¾Éç]lÌXZnG`^`½o³XçVL]pKMD�XZnG`-V8HGW4ÉZ]^]lÌjFONMNUFOHfKc]^VL`^`½o#NMn�S=xUFOy!Kc]½g[FL��d XRP�F�P�VLHfK¿KcJ\WGF���HGF�KMDGFIHGJLKc]pJ[HkJLX L È~F{��n�]pg8VL`^F{HGyOF8uJ[HGF¾VLT�TGSMJfV8y.D³]^N�KcJze[F{HGFOSMVL`^]pNMF,KcDGF{NMF�K~PRJzTGSUJ[T6F{SUKM]^FON{��ü�J[S L ¨ÍqBu'ÛìVLHGW¤Ü VLSMF&HGJ?P �G]^yOV8KcF{e[J[SM]pFON{uÔÁXZnG`p`po�XçVL]pKMD�XZnG`ãÀ�HGJ?PÃxIFhV8HGNEKcD�V8KEXZJLSEFhVLy.D�T�VL]^S�JLX�J[�(xUFOy{KMNOuäy\}2zw¯� ��AÉ6Û�Ì!��KcD�F¼]pHGWGnGy{FOW�XZnGHGy!KcJ[S

Û¾É=y\}�zGÌÆ� Ü�Éo­�y\}�­�z�Ì]^N&VLH'F{��n�]pg8VL`^F{HGyOF�JLX�yOV8KcF{e[J[SU]^FON&VLHGW'NM]^xI]^`^VLSM`½okÔëF{NMNMF{HfKc]lV8`^`pokNUnGS=xUF{y{KM]pg[F8À�eLFOHGF{ScVL`p]^NMF{N¼KMJ*NMV?o�]pHGe�KMD�V8KF{g[F{SUo*J[��xUFOy!K�]pH¤ÜÓ]pN�F{��n�]pg8VL`^F{HfKjKcJ$VLH*JL��xUFOy!KQJLX�KMDGF&XZJ[SUx¿­'y#XZJ[S�NMJ[xIF¿JL��xUFOy!K~ykJLXÆÛ&����]½KcD�J[nGS`^]^H�a¾�6F!K~P�F{FOH�C�È � PRFhVLa$qñÈ yhV8KMFOe[J[SU]^F{N�VLH�Wz�G]^yOV8KcF{e[J[SU]^FONRVLHGWzVL`^NUJ¿KcDGF�KcSUnGHGyhVAKc]^JLH�u�PRF�yOVLHzNMF{F�KcD�VAK�V�G]^yOV8KcF{e[J[SUoIyOVLHz��F�KcSUnGHGyOV8KcF{W$K~Pw]^y{FL�vd X:J[HGFjVLTGTG`p]^F{N^Ï J[HGy{F�KMDGFOH$PRF�SUFOTG`^VLyOF�FhVLy.D�yOV8KcF{e[J[SUoGÛ�É=y\}2z�Ì�bo�]pKMNjNUF{K�J8Xv]^NMJLx�J[SUTGDG]pNMx y{`lVLNUNMFON{u6KMD�n�N~Ï¿É6ÛQÌw]^N�V$yhVAKcFOeLJ[SUo�VLHGWnÏ � É6ÛQÌw]^NwKcDGF¿NMF{KjJLXv]^NUJ[xIJ[SMTG]pNMxyO`lV8NMNMF{N&]pH¬Ï�É=ÛQÌ��¾CEDGF�yO`lV8]^x¸]^N�KcDGV8K�­M¢tÛ � Ü�]^NQF{NMNMF{HfKc]lV8`^`po*NMnGS>xUFOy!Kc]pgLF�]½XRVLHGWYJ[HG`po*]pX�Ï � Éo­�Ìj]pNNMnGS>xUFOy{KM]pgLFL�� n�TGT6JLNMFàÏ � Éo­�Ì�]^NENUnGS=xUF{y{KM]pg[F8u�VLHGW0��]^N�VLH�J[��xUF{y{K�JLXÆÜ$uGKMDGFOH\KcDGF{SMF,]^N�VLH\J[��xUF{y{K~Ò$]^HòÛ VLHGW�VLH]^NMJLx�J[SUTGDG]pNMx¸]^H�Ï¿É;Ü�Ìj�6F!K~P�F{FOH=�¿VLHGW ­�É6Ò�Ì!�¼CED�V8K,]^HfKMFOSMT�SMF{KMN,VLNQNcVho�]^H�ezKcDGF{SMF�]^NQVzTGVL]^S�JLXjè!È~yOF{`^`pN� ¢¶�~� ­É;Ò�Ì!u>VLHGW � ¢ä­�É;Ò�Ì � �?u6PwDGJ[NUF�yOJLx�T�J[NM]½KcF{N�VLSUF&]pNMJ[xIJ[SMT�DG]^y,KcJIKcDGF�SUFONUT6F{y{Kc]½g[F�]pWGFOHfKM]pKc]pFON{u]ã��FL��KcD�FOSMF&VLSUFQWG]lVLeLScVLxIN

­�É;Ò�Ì�

BBB

BBBB

B�� ¹�· //

� >>|||||||| �

� � B

BBBB

BBB�

­�É;Ò�Ì ¹�· //

� >>|||||||| ­�É;Ò�Ì

}

PwDG]^y.D�NMFOF{x�Nw`p]^aLF,V¾TGSUF{KUK~o�e[JBJ�Wzg[F{SMNU]^J[H\JLX�FO�bnG]pg8VL`pFOHfK�J[��xUF{y{KcN{�RCED�F¼y{J[Hfg[F{SMNMF&]^NENU]^xI]^`lV8SO�C�VLxINcVLx�VLHG]2u��Ú�Gè{�ãu�e[FOH�FOScV8`^]^NUFON_KcDG]pNR]pWGFhV,KcJ¿F{NMNUFOHfKc]^VL`>NUnGS=xUF{y{Kc]½g�]pK~oI]^H�DG]^e[D�FOS_WG]^xIFOHGNU]^J[H�NOu�VLHGW�u�VLN� ]^xITGNMJLH'HGJLKMFON&]^H<�Öt[é8�2u�KMDG]^N¼yhV8H'��F�g�]^F!P�F{WrVLN¿NMVhoB]pHGe�KMD�V8K�­Ý¢\Û � Ü(�6F!K~P�F{FOH|K~PRJ³C�È � P�FOVLa

L È~yOV8KcF{e[J[SU]^FON�]^NjV�FONUNMF{HbKM]lVL`p`po\NMn�S=xUFOy!Kc]½g[F¾]pXEÏ ¦ É;­�Ì�]pN�NUnGS=xUF{y{Kc]½g[F8�Qd~H*XçVLy{KOu>DGF&T6JL]^HfKcN�J[n�KjKMD�V8Kj]pX^­�]pNVLH L È~F{��n�]pg8VL`^F{HGyOF8uGKcDGF{H3Ï ¦ Éo­�Ì�]pNwV¾�G]ÚxUF{y{Kc]pJ[H��

CEDbnGN,P�F�D�VhgLF$VLN,V�WGF���HG]½Kc]^JLH³KcD�V8K¼V�xIJ[SMT�DG]^NUx ­M¢�Û � ܸJ8X�C�È � PRFhV8a L È~yOV8KcF{e[J[SU]^FONj]^N,VLHL È~F{�bnG]pg8VL`pFOHGy{F¼]½X�VLHGW\J[HG`po$]pX�Éç]lÌRFhVLy.D�T�VL]pS�JLX�J[��xUFOy!KcN{u�y\}�z±¯# ��AÉ=ÛQÌ!��KMDGF,]^HGW�nGyOF{W�xIJ[SMT�DG]^NUx

Û e É=y\}2z�ÌÆ� Ü e Éo­'y\}�­'zGÌt[s

Page 31: d¾PRJ[nG`^W `^]^a8F KMJ|KcDVLH a i FO]^H FOS ...hopf.math.purdue.edu/Porter/s-catsv2.pdfGKUKcFOWYKcJ[eLF{KcD FOS,NMJ KcDVAK&d KcDG]pHGa d_ FOeL]^H KMJ nGHGW FOSMN K.VLH WzKcDGFjP

]^N�VLH�É L �<èñÌ È~F{��n�]pg8VL`^F{HGyOFQJ8X�PRFhVLaYÉ L �<èñÌ~È yhV8KMFOe[JLSM]^F{NOu�V8HGW�Éç]^]lÌ^Ï ¦ É;­�Ì�]^NENUnGS=xUF{y{KM]pg[F8�CEDG]pN¿F{NMNMF{HfKc]lV8`^`po¬�GHG]^NUDGFON¼KcDGF�WGF���H�]pKc]pJ[H'J8XEC�È � PRFhV8a L È~yhVAKcFOeLJ[SUoYVLN¼P�F$HGJ?P D�Vhg[F�V�P�J[SUab]^HGe

WGF���H�]pKc]pJ[H�XZJ[SwVL`p`>KcDGFQKMFOSMxINE]^HfgLJ[`pgLFOW��d KR]^N_VLx�n�NM]^H�e¿VLH�W$�bnG]pKMF�n�NMF{XZn�`�KMD�V8K^Ï<e[]pgLFON�V,XZnGH�y{KcJLS_XZSUJ[x �C��ÒXÅ L ÑÖÒ<ÔKcJ6�C��ÒXÅ*É L �YèñÌ^ÑÖÒ�Ô��

^�Rlk m�fpY?¡n]q`Tëpl�VÆ_£¢Yÿc�Y\V�¦��qr?[^_ä]Sê�i�]q`�rg]ätDmGV�h béV�h V�ë�`CVLxINcV8x$VLH�]_W�F���HGF{N¾V\XZn�HGW�VLxIFOHfK.V8`Rí�J[]^H�yhVLS�ËF L È~e[SUJ[nGT�J[]^WkXZJ[S&VLH|VLSU�G]pKMScVLS�o#NMTGVLyOF³Í VLHGW'VLHfo L �CEDGFOSUF&V8SMF�NUJ[x�FjFOSMSUJ[SMN�]^H$KMDGFQTGnG�G`p]^NUDGFOWzgLFOSMNU]^J[H>uGNM]pHGyOFQV8H�V8KMKMFOxIT�KwV8KwV8H�]pKcF{ScV8KM]pgLFjWGF���HG]pKM]^J[H�XçVL]^`pNNM]^H�yOF�H�JjKcJ[T�J[`pJ[eLo�DGVLN��FOF{H�NMT�FOy{] ��F{W�J[H¿KMDGF�NUF{K�J8X�NM]px�TG`p]^y{FON:]^HfgLJ[`pgLFOW�u[D�JñPRF{gLFOS�KMDG]^N�NM`p]^T¼]^N�SMFOy!Kc] ��FOW`lV8KMFOS_J[HzVLH�W�KcD�F�XZnG`p`�VLTGTGSUJfVLy.D$PRJ[nG`pW$NMF{FOxìKcJ&e[]pgLFjV,XçVL]^SU`po¾y{`^FOVLSvx�F!KcDGJ�W�XZJ[S_WGF���HG]^H�e&KcD�F�efV8WGe[F{KO�d K�D�VLNwKcJ��6F&SMF{x�F{x��6F{SMF{W�KcDGV8K�KMDGF¿SUFONUnG`pK�Pw]^`p`:�6F¿V�PRFhVLa L È e[SMJLnGT6JL]^W�u�NUJz]^H\WG]^xIFOH�NM]^JLH L ¨ q¾P�Fe[F{KwV���]^e[SUJ[nGT�J[]^W�VLHGW�HGJ8KwV¾qñÈ e[SMJ[n�T6J[]pW$J[S�V¿WGJ[nG��`^F�e[SUJ[nGT�J[]^WIPw]pKMDzyOJ[H�HGFOy!Kc]^JLH��vCEDG]^N�xIFhV8HGNRKMD�V8KKcDGF�JL��xUFOy!KE]^NRScV8KMDGFOS�`^VLSMeLFL��i�FOSUF�P�FjPw]p`^`�V8KUKcFOxIT�KRKcJ�WGF{NMy{SM]^��FjKMDGF��G]pe[SMJ[n�T6J[]pW��foIK.VLab]pHGe¾VLT�V8SUK�KMDGFyOJ[HGN�KcSUnGy{KM]^J[Hk]^H³KMD�V8KQyOVLNMF8�¿��F�]^HG]½Kc]^VL`^`½o�e[]pgLF¿KcD�F¾yOJ[HGN�KcSUnGy{KM]^J[Hk]^H#eLFOHGF{ScVL`-V8N�]pKQ]pN�FhV8NM]^F{S�KcJ�WGJ�]½KKcD�V8KwP�Vho[�

�:F{K�Í£��F�V�NUT�VLy{F¾VLHGWIJ ¨ É2ï }9×9×K×K}�ﱦ[Ì!u6VLH³J[�(xUFOy{K�JLXä� ¦ �j�:F!K � � ¢©¨�¥¤

} ��KMKMK���¦¤

x uÉçHGJLKMFzKcDGF�SUF{gLFOSMNMVL`EJLX�J[SUWGFOScÌ!�Yd XjsÞª§ÅZª L � è[u-NUF{Kw² ¦ � �n¨ É2ï }K×9×9×K}�ﱦ � � � Ì¿VLHGWM² ð¦ � � ¨É2ﱦ � � ã }9×9×9×�}�ﱦ[ÌwV8HGW�XZJ[SEFhVLy.D*seª!ÅäªYﱦ � �Lu�`pF{K�� ¹ WGFOHGJ8KcF,KcDGFàÅ � ý g[F{SUKcF��\JLX� ¤

} �M§ ��:F{KÍZ� ¨-,?­¤¢ � � ��Í�1�XZJ[SwVL`p`�Å�}�seªÇÅ�ª L �4è*}wXZJLSwVL`^`tÅ�}�sLª!Å�ªYﱦ � �VLHGW�XZJ[SwVL`^`'¡:¯

� � } �M§ }�¡ ð ¯ � � �} �¨§ }­�É=¡Æ}©� ¹ }�¡ ð Ì�¨H­ ¹ É>¡ ð ÌRPwDGF{SMF�­ ¹ ¯�ÍZ� } �¨§ 3Ç�JLKMF�KcD�V8K,]½Xäﱦ � ��¨ sBu�KcDGF{HYKMDGFOSUF¾]^NQJ[HGF�gLFOS�KcF!�#J[HG`po*JLXvKcDGF¾y{J[SMSUFONUT6J[H�WG]^HGe

� ð NMJ�KcDGF{H¬Íª� ¨Íª� } �M§ �\CEDG]^N&FOHGy{JBWGF{N�]^HfKMJ³V�NUnG��yOJ[xITG`^F���JLXEKcDGF L È NM]^xITG`p]^yO]^VL`NU]^HGeLnG`lVLS,y{J[x�T�`^F!�6u�KcDGFzy{J[HGN�K.VLHGy!oSMnG`pF,KMD�V8KEPRF&H�FOFOW�XZJ[SwV�PRFhVLa L È~yhVAKcFOeLJ[SUoL�

\ó6ù�ó�úhó'"�# �2ò ÍZ��:F{Kp­'}�°��6F,K~P�J$FO`^F{x�F{HfKcNjJ8XDÍZ�$�E�'F,Pw]^`p`:NcVho�KMD�V8Kp­�VLH�Wn°\VLSUF&DGJLx�JLKMJ[TG]py&V8HGW�PwSU]pKcF�­uâÿ°

J[S ­n¨ °z]pX�KcD�FOSMF,]pN�V¦�¬¯¤ÍZ�Áj NMnGy.D\KcD�VAKÁ��ðAÉ«�>Ìƨ«­kVLHGW½��É(�>Ìƨݰ��Ri�J[xIJLKcJ[Tfo$]^NwVLH\FO�bnG]½gLV8`^FOH�yOFSMFO`^V8Kc]pJ[H�VLHGW�PRF,Pw]p`^`�W�FOHGJLKMF,�bo Í�� KMDGF,NMF!K�J8XDGJLx�JLKMJ[Tfozy{`lVLNUNMFON{�

��]½KcD�KcDGF�J[�fg�]^J[nGN_]^W�FOHfKc] ��yhV8KM]^J[H�NOufP�F�HGJ?P<WGF���HGFLu­¬®¦GÉ=ÍYÌ%� ¢¶¨ Í#� Pw]pKMDIKMDGFj]pHGWGnGy{FOWIXçVLyOF�VLHGWWGFOe[F{HGFOSMVLy{o\x�VLTGN{�J &�ö�ó��ñö�ù � �¯®�Ý{�ät��Ü L � Û!Þ>�jå�æÕÞo�!ÞçáLæ�Û?Ü!Ý�¬®¦GÉ=Ík̼Þ^Û&á�ä � F $ ÜMá�h L � âLÚcÙ�!ñå�ÙAÞ6�c( N�>ó�ôw&\ �úz÷�ó�ö�ûG�ZúIõZó�ó�ð�õ;�Zð�ö��çò4÷��2ù'ö�ò�û9�Zó6ò���NCEDGF&WGF��GHG]pKM]^J[H�JLXDÍZ�ÓD�VLN��bnG]pKMF�VIXZF!P NMnG��yhV8NMFONQF!g[F{H³Pw]pKcD L ¨Îq�u>NMJIP�F&K.VLa8F¿KcDGF{x�J[HGF�VAK�V

Kc]^xIFL����F,D�Vhg[F¾Ô�XZJ[S�VL`^`�Å6u�seªÇÅ�ªÅè[À ¢Å ¨ sA¢ XZJLS&V8`^`�ÅMus=ª Å�ª ï � u@� ¹ u�KMDGFGÅ � ý g[F{SUKMF!�rJ8X� ¤

y uVLHGW'XZJLS&V8`^`Æy ¯� ¤

x u�J[HGF�D�VLN­�É�� ¹ }�y Ì�¨ô­ ¹ É=y Ì��_i�J?P�F!g[F{SjKcDG]pNETG`lV8yOFON�HGJISMF{NUKcSU]^y!Kc]^JLH\JLH�­#NM]pHGyOF,KcD�FOSMF¼VLSUF,HGJIg8VLSU]lVL��`^FONE]pH�XZSMJ[HfKJLXKMDGF£� ¹ �-d K�xIFOSUFO`½ozNUKcV8KcF{NEKcD�V8K~­ ¹ ¨H­�É�� ¹ } Ì!�

t�è

Page 32: d¾PRJ[nG`^W `^]^a8F KMJ|KcDVLH a i FO]^H FOS ...hopf.math.purdue.edu/Porter/s-catsv2.pdfGKUKcFOWYKcJ[eLF{KcD FOS,NMJ KcDVAK&d KcDG]pHGa d_ FOeL]^H KMJ nGHGW FOSMN K.VLH WzKcDGFjP

Å ¨(è�¢ XZJLS&V8`^`�ÅMus=ª Å�ª ï u@� ¹ u�KMDGFGÅ � ý g[F{SUKMF!�rJ8X� ¤

x uVLHGW'XZJLS&V8`^`Æy � ¯� ¤

y u�J[HGF�D�VLN­�É=y � }�� ¹ Ì ¨ ­ ¹ u6�GnBKQDGFOSUF�­ ¹ D�VLNÓ�>Ù�g8VLSU]lVL��`^FON{u�]pK�]^N�VIyOJ[H�NUK.V8HbKjgLV8`^nGF8��CEDGF¿TG]^y!KcnGSUF&XZJ[Sp² ¨ÄÉ�è�}OèñÌ]^NjJ8X_V$NM�bn�VLSUF¿Pw]pKMD³yOJLHGNUKcVLHfK�g8VL`^nGF{NjJ[H�KcDGF¼g[FOS�Kc]pyhVL`�NM]^W�FON�V8N�]^H�J[nGSjW�]^NMy{nGNMNU]^J[H*JLX-KcDGF¿�G]^yOV8KcF{e[J[SUox�J�WGFO`>FhVLSU`^]^F{S�]^H�KMDGFONUF&HGJ8KcFON{�

° ° ° °°°°°°° ° ° °°°°°°°°°°° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° °°°°°°°°°°° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° °°°°°° ° ° ° °°°°°°°°°°°° ° ° °°°°°° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° °°°°°°°°°°°° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° °°°°°°°°°° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° °°°°° ° ° ° °°°°°°°°°° ° ° ° °°°°°° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° °°°°°°°°°° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° °°°°°°°°°° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° °°°°° ° ° ° °°°°°°°°°°° ° ° ° °°°°°° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° °°°°°°°°°° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° °°°°°°°°°° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° °°°°° ° ° ° °°°°°°°°°° ° ° ° °°°°°° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° °°°°°°°°°°° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° °°°°°°°°°° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° °°°°° ° ° ° °°°°°°°°°° ° ° ° °°°°°° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° °°°°°°°°°°° ° ° ° ° ° ° °°°°°°°°°°° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° °°°°°° ° ° ° °°°°°°°°°°° ° ° °

°°°°°° ° ° ° °°°°°°° ° ° ° ° °°°°°° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° °°°°°°°°°°° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° °°°°°° ° ° ° °°°°°°°°°°° ° ° °°°°°° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° °°°°°°°°°° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° °°°°°°°°°°° ° ° ° ° ° ° °°°°°° ° ° ° °°°°°°°°°°° ° ° °°°°°° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° °°°°°°°°°°°° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° °°°°°°°°°° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° °°°°° ° ° ° °°°°°°°°°°°° ° ° °°°°°° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° °°°°°°°°°°°° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° °°°°°°°°°° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° °°°°° ° ° ° °°°°°°°°°° ° ° ° °°°°°° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° °°°°°°°°°° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° °°°°°°°°°°° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° °°°°° ° ° ° °°°°°°°°°° ° ° ° °°°°°° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° °°°°°°°°°°° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° °°°°°°°°°° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° °°°°° ° ° ° °°°°°°°°°°° ° ° °±

��e��_×CEDGF&T�]^y{KMnGSMF�XZJLSwVLH�F{`^F{x�F{HbKw]pH÷Í R � j S ]pNENM]^xI]^`^VLSOuBV�g[F{SUKc]pyhVL`:T�SM]^NUx�u

� � � � u� � VLNw��VLNMF¼VLH�W\Pw]½KcD

Ôëy{J[HGNUKcVLHfKhÀGgLFOSUKM]^yOVL`>F{WGe[FON{u�]ã��FL�-`p]^aLF�KcDGFQNUD�VLT�F�P�FQNMVhPÂFOVLSM`p]^FOSR]^HzKMDGF�WG]pNMyOn�NMNM]pJ[H�JLX��G]^yOV8KcF{e[J[SU]^FON{u�]2�ÁF8���ew��J[H\T�VLeLF¼qIbB�-CEDGF¼yhVLNUFÓ² ¨ÍÉÒè�}�q[Ì�]pNwV¾DGJ[SM] �OJ[HfKcVL`�TGSU]^NMxÄPw]pKcD�y{J[HGNUKcVLHfK�FOHGWGN{�

C�J�NUKcn�W�o�KcDGF,DGJLx�JLKMJ[TfozSUFO`lVAKc]^JLH�uBPRF&H�FOFOW�KcJI`^J�J[a�V8K ÍZ�Áj �d~HkT�VLS�Kc]pyOnG`^VLSjPRFI`pJBJLa³V8K�Í j j ¢�KMDGFOSUF�V8SMF�KcD�SMFOF�yOVLNMF{NAŬ¨ sA}hè�}.qé×>Ê�N&V8�6J?g[F¾KMDGF�yhVLNUFOŬ¨ìs]^xIT6J[NUFON¼HGJ*y{J[HGWG]½Kc]pJ[H�JLH�KcD�F�NU]^HGe[n�`lVLS,x�nG`½Kc] È~TGSU]^NMx´­�u�NM]^H�yOF�KcDGF�SMnG`pFIxIFOSUFO`½okNUK.VAKcFONõ­�É�� ¹ } } Ìਭ ¹ É } Ì_]pH�V¿NMF{HGNMFqxUnGN�KEWGF���HG]^H�e0­ ¹ �CEDGFQyOJ[H�WG]pKM]^J[HIXZJ[S@ÅG¨Îè[uBDGJ?P�F!g[FOSw]px�TG`p]^F{NvKMD�V8KRXZJ[S�VL`p`�gLFOS�Kc]^y{FON� ¹ JLX

� ¤y u ­�É>y \ }�� ¹ }�y Ì�¨ ° ¹ É>y Ì�}]ã��FL��]^N:]^H�WGFOT�FOHGW�FOHfKJ8X�KMDGF-g8VLSM]^VL�G`^F�XZSMJ[x

� ¤ Ð ��ü]^H�V8`^`poEXZJLSàÅw¨Ãq�uñKMDGFvSMF{NUKcSU]^y!Kc]^JLHQ]^N�KcDGV8KE­�É=y \ }�y � }�� ¹ Ì]^N�V�yOJ[HGN�K.VLHfK�XZnGHGy{KM]^J[H>��CEDG]pNjxIFhVLH�N�KcDGV8KQV$D�J[x�J8KcJ[Tfo�yhV8H³�6F¿SMFOT�SMFONUFOHfKcF{WYVLN�V$NU]^HGeLnG`lVLSwy{nG�6F¿]^HÍ ]^H�PwDG]py.D�KMDGF&`pF{XàK�VLH�W*SM]pe[DfKEg[F{SUKc]pyhVL`:XçVLy{FON�VLSMF¼yOJLHGNUKcVLHfKhu�KcDGF,KcJLT*VLH�W*��JLKMKMJ[x�VLSUF¼]pHGWGF{T6F{HGWGFOHfKJLXRKMDGF¾KcDG]pSMWkWG]pSMFOy!Kc]pJ[HkVLHGWkKcDGF¾J8KcDGF{S,K~PRJ�XçVLyOF{N¼DGV?gLF�H�J\J8KcDGF{S¼SUFON�KcSM]py{KM]^J[H�u>]ã��FL��KcD�FID�J[x�J8KcJ[Tfo³]pNTGSMF{yO]^NUFO`½o³VIDGJ[xIJLKcJ[Tfo\SMF{`lV8KM]pgLF¼KMJ�KcD�F��6JLnGHGW�VLS�o\JLX�KcD�F�NM�bn�VLSUFON�]pH*WG]px�F{HGNM]pJ[HrÉÒè�}hèñÌ��wCEDG]^N�x�VLa8FON]pKQ`pJBJ[a\VLNQ]½X-KcDGF¾C�VLxINcVLx�VLHG]��G]pe[SMJ[n�T6J[]pW³]^NjFONMNUFOHfKc]^VL`^`½o�KMDGF¾NcV8x�F¾V8N�KcD�V8K�JLXRijVLSUWG]^F8u:�,VLx�T�NQVLHGW�,]pFO��JBJLx�u�É2ij�,�¼Ì!u-�Áq?�8�ã��d KQPRJ[nG`pWk�6F¾]pHbKMFOSUFONUKM]^HGe�KMJ\NUFOF�]pX_C�VLxINcVLx�VLHG]2ÀÁN�P�FOVLaktAÈ~eLSMJ[nGT�J[]pW³yOJ[n�`^W�6F�VLW�VLTBKcFOW>uBV8NRyOVLHIKMDG]^Nv�G]pe[SMJLnGT6JL]^W¾yhV8NMFLubKcJ&VL`p`^J?P�XZJ[S_V¼HGJ8Kc]^JLHIJ8X>KcD�]^HGHGF{NMNvXZJ[`^`pJ?P�F{WI�foIV,�bnGJLKc]pFOHfKKcJGu�NMVho[u�V�ÿQScVho*eLSMJ[nGT�J[]pW�u�VLHGVL`^J[eLJ[nGNM`½o�KcJ$KMDGF�P�Vho*]^H³PwDG]py.D³KcDGF�i��¼� �G]pe[SMJ[n�T6J[]pW*`pFhVLWGNj]^H���qLt8�2uKcJ�V�q?È~e[SUJ[nGT�J[]^W�uBJ[SwV¾WGJ[nG��`^FQe[SUJ[nGT�J[]^W�Pw]pKMD�yOJ[HGH�FOy{KM]^J[H�NO�

² � °�¤#«�µh´#¡��{°�¤|º�'F³DGV?gLF#`^J�J[aLF{W<V8K�KcDGF*P�Vho4]pH PwDG]py.D È yhV8KMFOe[J[SU]^F{NOuEKcDGF{]^S�DGJ[xIJLKcJ[Tfo�yOJLDGFOSUFOHfK�XZJ[SMx\u � F{efVL`&è{ÈyhV8KMFOe[J[SU]^F{NOuGV8HGW�u�T6F{SMD�VLT�NOu�KMDGFO]pSR]½KcFOSMV8KcF{W�XZJ[SUx�ufKMDGF�C�È � P�FOVLa L È~yOV8KcF{e[J[SM]pFON{uBF{HbKMFOS�]pHfKcJ&KMDGF�K~PRJ¾aLF!oVLSMFOVLN�J8XvVL�GN�KcScV8y{K�DGJ[xIJLKcJ[TfozKMDGFOJLSUo[� � J[x�F,JLXKcDGF¼NMJ[n�SMyOF{NjnGNUFOW³DGV?gLF¿��FOF{H*XçVL]^SU`po$SMFOy{FOHfKhu�NMJIKcDGF{SMF]^NwNUKM]^`^`>V¾`^JLK�KMJ�W�JG�vi�F{SMF,]^NwV�`^]pNUKEJLX�NMJLx�FQ�bnGF{NUKc]pJ[HGN{u�NUJ[xIFQ�6F!KMKcF{SEKcD�VLH\JLKMDGFOSUNK¢

è[����D�V8KQ]pN�KcD�F�TGSMF{yO]pNMF¾`^]pHGa���F{K~PRFOFOHkKcD�F¾ÑjPEo[F{S�ÈÒ�,VLH È~eLSMJ[nGT�J[]pW³VLHGW#NU]^xITG`^]pyO]^VL`�yOJLDGFOSUFOHGy{F?���D�V8K�W�J�DGJLx�JLKMJ[TfokyOJ[D�FOSMF{HfK�NM]px�T�`^]^y{FON,]^H ï�É;£kÌ�KcFO`p`-J[HGF$VL�6JLn�K,KcDGFIx�J�WGF{`^N.� Ñ�J\KMDGF{oY`pFhVLWkKcJe[JBJ�W#WGF{NMyOSU]^T�KM]^J[H�N�JLX_DG]^eLDGFOS�]pHfKcFOSUy.D�VLHGeLFIF{`^F{x�F{HbKMN,VLH�VL`pJ[e[J[n�NM`po�KMJ�KcDGF�P�Vho³]^H³PwD�]^y.Dkx$V8TGNjXZSMJLxª�� �L��KcJ�V È yhV8KMFOe[J[S�o�TGSMJ�WGnGy{F&KMD�V8K�]^HfKcF{SMy.D�V8HGe[F¼NM�bn�VLSUF?�4ÉZCEDGF¼PRJ[SUa\J8X�Êj`p]�þ�n�KM`^n�VLHGW*x&oBNUFO`½X�J[HDG]^e[D�FOSwJ[SMW�FOSwí�F{]pê6FOSwT�VL]pSM]pHGe[N�]pH\NU]^xITG`^]pyO]^VL`�e[SMJ[n�TGNwx$Vhoz��F,JLX�SMFO`pF{g8VLHGy{F,DGFOSUFLu�y{XÒu��Öt[t�uMt*�L�2� Ì

qB�vCEDGF¼C�VLx�NMVLx�VLHG]�xIF{KMDGJBW�N�K.VLS�KcNEPw]pKMD*V¾NMTGVLyOFàÍ V8HGW�T�SMJ�WGnGyOF{NjV�x�nG`½Kc] È~NM]px�T�`^]^y{]lVL`�NM]^H�e[nG`lV8SyOJ[xITG`^F��6�|CED�V8K�xIF{KMDGJBW�y{J[nG`^Wr��F�VLTGT�`^]^F{W|KcJkJLKMDGFOS�K~o�T�FONIJLX�J[��xUFOy!KhuvXZJ[S¾F!��VLxITG`pFLu_V#NM]^xITG`p]^yO]^VL`e[SMJ[n�T�u�V¾yhV8KMFOe[JLSUo[uGVLHGW�NMJ�J[H�����DGV8KwWGJ¾KcDGFQy{J[SMSUFONUT6J[H�WG]^HGeIí�J[]^HGyOVLS�ËF�PRFhV8a L È e[SMJ[n�T6J[]pWGN�KMFO`^`6J[HGFh�

tfq

Page 33: d¾PRJ[nG`^W `^]^a8F KMJ|KcDVLH a i FO]^H FOS ...hopf.math.purdue.edu/Porter/s-catsv2.pdfGKUKcFOWYKcJ[eLF{KcD FOS,NMJ KcDVAK&d KcDG]pHGa d_ FOeL]^H KMJ nGHGW FOSMN K.VLH WzKcDGFjP

É;�wFOxIFOx���FOSvKcD�VAK�yOV8KcF{e[J[SM]pFON_x�J�WGF{`�áLæàæ�DGJ[xIJLKcJLTbo¾K~o�T�FON{�_CED�F{opxUnGNUKRWGJ&]pK_]^H�ScV8KMDGFOSRV&WG]m³IyOnG`½K_P�VhoXZSMJ[xÓKMDGF,T6JL]^HfKEJLX�gB]pF{P JLX�yOVL`^y{nG`lVAKc]^JLHGNO�ëÌ

t���d~N�]pK�KcSUnGF�KcDGV8K�KcD�FEÑjPEo[F{S�ÈÒ�,VLH¾DGVLx�xIJ�y.a¼`pJByOVL`^]pNcV8KM]^J[H,JLX�� í Pw]pKMD�SMF{NMT�FOy!K_KMJ�`^F!g[F{`�DGJ[xIJLKMJ[TfoFO�bnG]pg8VL`pFOHGy{FON�]^NÔÁyO`pJ[NMF{`poQSUFO`^V8KcF{W,KMJGÀ ÉoªwÉ=ó�Ì�}5ËD�9Ø9ý z ¾ z É#�EÌMÌ>XZJ[S¬�Y`pJByOVL`^`½o��¼V8H��zd X�NUJ¼ÔÁDGJ?P|y{`^J[NUFLÀ~�zÊr`pJLKJLX`p]^e[DfK�J[H�KcDG]pN�TGSMJL�G`^F{xÓD�VLNE��FOF{H�NUDGFOW\�fozÐvJ[eLK�]^H��Ú�f×A��]pHzKcDGFQKcJLT6J[`pJ[e[]pyhVL`�NMF!KMKM]^HGeG�-CED�F¼�bnGF{NUKM]^J[HP�J[n�`^WÂNUFOF{x KMJ ��FYJLX�T�V8SUKc]pyOnG`^VLS�]^xIT�J[SUKcVLHGyOF#eL]pg[F{H KMDGFYnGTGNMn�SMe[F�JLX�]pHbKMFOSUFONUK�]^HÝÛ�´�È yhV8KMFOe[JLSM]^F{NSMFONUnG`pKM]^HGe¾XZSUJ[xÓHGF!P VLTGT�SMJfVLy.D�FONwKcJ��bn�VLHfKcnGx�W�F{XZJ[SUx$V8KM]^J[H>�

�G�#��VLHrJ[HGF�yOJ[HGN�KcSUnGy{KIV*D�J[x�J8KcJ[TfoYyOJ[D�FOSMF{HfK�HGFOS�g[FzXZJ[S¿V*e[FOH�FOScV8` � F{efVL`�yOV8KcF{e[J[S�o<ÉZTGSMJ[�GVL�G`poo[FONcÌIV8HGWrPwD�V8KIVLSUF�]pKcN¾T�SMJ[T�FOS�Kc]^F{N.��d~H eLFOHGF{ScVL`�PwDGV8K�]^N�KMDGF�TGSMF{yO]pNMF�SMF{`lV8KM]^J[HGNUDG]^T'�6F!K~P�F{FOH��bn�V8NM]yhV8KMFOe[J[SU]^F{NQÉ2V8N�V&PRFhVLa8FOHG]pHGe¾JLX�yOV8KcF{e[J[SM]pFONcÌRVLHGW � FOefV8`6yOV8KcF{e[J[SM]pFON�É2VL`pNMJ�V¼P�FOVLaLF{HG]^HGe¾J8X:yhV8KMFOe[JLSM]^F{N.ÌU�ÉçCEDG]pN��bnGF{NUKM]^J[H\]^N�g8VLe[n�FLu�JLX�yOJ[n�SMNMF8u�VLHGW�P�J[n�`^W�`^FOVLW�KcJ�x$V8Hboz]^HfKcF{SMTGSUF{K.VAKc]^JLHGNO�ëÌ

×B�_��V8H�J[H�F¼n�HGT�VLy.a�V¾C�È � PRFhVLa�tAÈ yhV8KMFOe[JLSUoz]pH\V�NUFOHGNU]^�G`pFQP�Vho��*d~N�]½KENMF{HGNM]p�G`^FQKMJ�KMSUo��[�����i�J?PÍT�J?P�F{SUXZnG`-]pN�KcDGF�ÑQ� � yOJLDGFOSUFOHGy{FIKMDGFOJ[SUFOx(XZJLS � FOe[VL`�yhVAKcFOeLJ[SM]pFON.� ��VLH�VzyO`^FOVLS�ÔÁNUK.V8HGWBÈ

VL`^J[H�FLÀ�T�SMJ�JLX��6Fje[]pgLFOH�KcD�VAK�WGJ�FONEHGJ8KEWGFOT�FOH�W\JLH�V�`^JLK�JLX�F!��KcSMV¾x$VLy.D�]^HGF{SUo��*i�J?P yOJLHGNUKMSMnGy!Kc]pgLF,yhVLH]pKw��F¼x�VLWGFh�bB�-d X�oLJ[n\KcVLaLF,V�C�È � P�FOVLa L È yhV8KMFOe[JLSUo�V8NEVLH L È NM]^xITG`p]^yO]^VL`�NMF!K�VLHGW�F!��KMScVLy!K&Éç]àÌ_]pKcN�WG]lVLeLJ[H�VL`6VLHGWÉç]^]lÌ�]pKMN,ÊjSUKM]^H�þ*V*�{nGS¼yOJ�WG]lVLeLJ[H�VL`2u>PwD�V8K¼WGJ�FON,KcDGF�N�KcSMn�y{Kcn�SMF�KcD�V8K¼SUFONMn�`pKcN¼`^J�J[a�`^]^a8F?�Âd~N,]pK,SUFO`^V8KcF{W�uT6F{SMD�VLT�NÆxUnGN�K�]^H�KcDGF,e[SUJ[nGT�J[]^W�yOVLNMF8uGKcJIDfoBT�FOSUyOSUJ[NMNUFOW³y{J[x�T�`^F!�BF{N�JLSEDbo�T�FOSUe[SMJ[n�T6J[]pWGNOu��Õè9�L�2�

���¿C�J\yOJ[xITG`pF{KcF�KMDGFzÔ ÿ,SUJLKcDGF{HGWG]pFOy.a#TGSUJ[e[ScV8x�xIFLÀ�JLXRTGnGSMNUnG]^H�e�N�K.VLy.abNOu�Éç]2�ÁF8��KcJ�yOJLHGNUKMSMnGy!KzÉçVLHGWNUKcn�W�o�Ì,N�K.VLy.abN¼JLX_x�J�WGFO`pNjXZJ[SQDGJLx�JLKMJ[Tfo L È K~o�T�FON&VLHGW#KcJ�TGSUJñgLF¾XZJ[S�KcDGF¾`pJByOVL`^`½o\yOJ[HGN�K.VLHfK L È NUKcVLy.abNOuNMJ[xIF¼XZJLSMx JLXvÿ¼VL`pJ[]^NÒÈÒí�J[]^HGyOVLS�ËFjyOJ[SUSMFONUT6JLHGWGFOH�yOF¿KMDGFOJ[SUFOx���F{K~PRFOF{H#FO�bnG]pg8VL`pFOHGy{F&y{`lVLNUNMF{N�JLX L È~N�K.VLy.abNVLHGW�KMDGF¼yOJ[SUSMFONUT6JLHGWG]^H�e L [ è{ÈãK~oBT�F¼x�J�WGFO`:J8XKcD�F¿��VLNUF&NUT�VLy{F¿J[SEKcJLT6J[NcÌ!u�J[HGF¼HGF{FOWGNjV�e[J�JBW�KcD�FOJ[S�oJLX:DGJ[xIJLKMJ[Tfo�y{J[DGF{SMFOH�yOFjPw]½KcD�KMDGJ[NUFjxIJBWGF{`^N{�CEDGF�y{nGSMSUFOHfKEVAKMKcF{x�TBKcN��fo � ]px�TGNUJ[H�ubC�JBF{H�VLHGWzJ8KcDGF{SMNÉçNMF{F�T�VLT�FOSMN�]pH|KcDGF�SUF{XZFOSUFOHGy{FONcÌ�e[JYV³`pJ[HGe³P�V?o'KcJ?P�V8SMWGN�NMn�y.D�V#e[JfV8`ãuvVLHGW�]pH|P�J[SUa|�fo|JLKMDGFOSUN�]^HKcDGF{J[SMF!Kc]^yOVL`-TGDfo�NM]pyONOuNM]^xI]^`^VLS�VLTGTGSUJfVLy.DGF{N¿D�Vhg[FI��FOFOHYKcSU]^FOWY]^H#gLFOSUoYNUT6F{yO]lV8`-yhVLNUFON�ÉçVL��FO`^]^VLH#xIJBWGF{`^N{ugB]^V&y.D�V8]^H$y{J[xITG`^F���F{N�F!KcyL�ëÌ!�-CED�FONMFj`lV8KUKcFOS_VLT�TGSMJfV8y.DGFON�n�NMF�V¼`^JLK_JLX>KcDGF�x$VLy.D�]^HGF{SUo�NMa8F{KMy.DGFOW�]^HIKcDGF{NMFHGJLKcF{NO��d K�]^N�TGSUJ[��VL�G`½o'XçVL]pS¿KcJkNMV?orKMD�V8KIVL`p`�KcD�FONMF�VLTGT�SMJfVLy.D�FONINMn�ê6FOS¾XZSMJLx KcD�F�e[n�`pX��6F!K~P�F{FOH�KMDGFKcFOy.D�HG]^yOVL`�H�V8Kcn�SMF,JLX�KcDGF,x�VLy.DG]^H�FOSUozVLHGW�KcDGF,NU]^xITG`^F�]pHfKcnG]½Kc]^JLHGN���FODG]pHGW�KcDGF{x��

CEDG]pNj`^VLNUKj��n�FONUKM]^J[H#]pN�KMD�n�NjKcJ�V8NMa\]^Nj]½KjT�J[NUNM]^��`^F&KMJze[]½g[F�V�yO`^FOVLSj]pHfKcnG]½Kc]pgLF¿V8TGTGSMJ[VLy.D�u>KMJzNcVho[u:qñÈNUK.V8y.a�NRnGNM]pHGeQKcDGF � F{efVL` È~yhVAKcFOeLJ[SUo&x$V8y.DG]^HGF{SUo�KMD�V8KvWGJ�FONvHGJ8Kve[F{K_��J[e[e[F{WIW�JñPwHI]^HIV�KcF{y.DGHG]pyhVL`�xIJ[ScV8NMNJLXÖ,�nG]^`p`^F{Hrx�J�WGFO`wyOV8KcF{e[J[SUorKMDGFOJLSUo[u�VLH F{HGJ[SUx�J[n�N$VLxIJ[nGHfKIJLX�PRFhV8a�]pHA��HG]½K~oryhVAKcFOeLJ[SUorKMDGFOJ[S�o�J[SNM]^xI]^`^VLSQx�VLy.DG]^H�FOSUoL�*CEDG]pN¿]pN&HGJ8K¿KcJ*NcVho�KMD�V8K¿VLTGTGSUJfVLy.DGF{N¾nGNM]pHGe�KMDGJ[NUFz]^WGFOVLN�V8SMF$H�JLK¿T�SMJ?g�]^WG]pHGe³VHGFOy{FONMNMVLSUo$NUKMFOT$JLH�KcD�F�SUJfVLW�KMJ&n�HGWGFOSUNUKcVLHGWG]pHGe¿KcD�F�ÿQSMJLKMDGFOH�WG]^F{y.a¾TGSMJ[��`^FOx\ub�Gn�K_KcJ&VLNMa¾XZJ[S_V¼NM]^xITG`pFVLTGTGSUJfVLy.D�KcD�V8KwPw]p`^`�V8]^W�KcDGF,e[F{J[xIF{KcSU]^y�]pHfKcnG]½Kc]^JLH��

µ ª�¶[ªQ±-ªQ¤#«wªQ¡� è{���j�>Ï�FOSUe[FOS{u�Êì��F{`^`pnG`lVLS�Ç�F{SUgLF�XZJ[S�i�]^e[DGF{SQ��V8KMFOe[JLSM]^F{NOu6ÊjW�g8VLHGy{FONQ]pHkþ*V8KMDGNO�½u�è?�[é³ÉãqLs[s[q[Ì,èLè��/ë

èKb[×B��Áqñ��m��>þ��6Ï�JfVLSUWGx�VLH*V8HGW¬�,�>þY�6ÐvJ[eLKOuv·&Ù��$ÙAÝ~Ù.å'������ßAáLÚ�Þçá*��Ý�áLæ�â�Ü+�OÚMáLÞo�QÛ!ÝçÚ8!��!Ý2!�Ú.Ü.Û�Ù��kÝÒÙ.å�ÙAæ^ÙMâLÞo�MáLæ

Û~å�á��.Ü.Û!uG��F{y{KMnGSMF¼Ç�J8KcFONw]pH*þ�V8KcDGN�t*�cbBu�É�èhécbLtfÌ�u � TGSU]^HGe[F{S�ÈãÐvFOSM`^VLeG���tA�¿üR��Ï�J[SUyOF{nB��VLH�W�ÿ���m[VLHGFO`p]^WZ�{FLu£¸wáLæ^ÙAÞ^Û�ät��Ü.ÙAÚ�ÞãÜ.Û!uv��VLx��GSU]^WGeLF � Kcn�WG]^F{N�]^HrÊ�W�g8VLHGyOF{W þ*V8KcD�F!È

x�V8KM]^yON{u4b[qBu:ÉãqLs[sBèñÌ!uG��VLx��GSU]^WGe[F,}�HG]pgLFOSUNM]pK~o�ívSUFONUNO�t[t

Page 34: d¾PRJ[nG`^W `^]^a8F KMJ|KcDVLH a i FO]^H FOS ...hopf.math.purdue.edu/Porter/s-catsv2.pdfGKUKcFOWYKcJ[eLF{KcD FOS,NMJ KcDVAK&d KcDG]pHGa d_ FOeL]^H KMJ nGHGW FOSMN K.VLH WzKcDGFjP

�Ú�8���,��Ï�SUJ?PwH*VLH�W*í�� m���i�]^e[eL]^HGN{u�C�FOHGNUJ[S�T�SMJ�WGnGy{KMN�VLHGW�DGJ[xIJLKcJLTG]^F{N�XZJ[SÒÔ-È~eLSMJ[nGT�J[]pWGN�VLH�W�y{SMJ[NUNMFOWy{J[xITG`^F���F{NOÀ½u�m���í-nGSMF,ÊjT�TG`^]pFOW�Êj`pe[FO�GSMV�uZ��b�ÉÒè?é��cb[Ì�è{ÈÒt[tB�

�Á×ñ�¿Ñ�� È��j���]^NU]^HGNUab]ãud~x�VLe[F{N¿WG]pSMF{y{KcF{N�yOJLDGJ[xIJ[`^J[eL]^�bnGFON¼W�VLH�N�`^F{N¿yhVAKBËFOeLJ[SM]pFON¿W�Fzx�J�Wv¹F{`^FON{uTGSUFOTGSU]^HfK}�HG]pgLFOSUNM]pKBËF¼íVLSU]^N*bBu � F{T�KcF{x��GSUF¿q8s[sfqB�

���A�¿Ñ�� È��j����]^NU]^HGNUa�]2u:í-SMJ[T�SM]!ËF!KBËF{NQnGHG]pgLFOSUNMFO`p`^F{NQF{KQF��BKMFOHGNU]^J[H�N¼W�F��¼V8H#W�ËFOSU]pgvËFOF{NOu�TGSMF{TGSM]pHfK¼}�HG]½g[FOSUNM]½KBËFí�VLSM]pN*bBu � F{T�KcF{x��GSMF&qLsLsfqB�

� bñ�¿Ñ��:��J[HGWGnGy.DRËFLu-þ\JBWGn�`^FON¼��SUJ[]^N�ËFON&ÿ³ËFOHRËF{ScVL`p]^N�ËF{NQWGFI�:J[HGe[nGF{nGS&qBu�m���í-nGSMF�Ê�TGTG`^]pFOWkÊj`pe[FO��ScV�u�t*��uÉÒè?é��*�fÌ!u�èñ×L×ñÈ.è/b?���

�-�A��m�� È�þY����J[SMW�]^FOS{u � nGSQ`^V$HGJLKM]^J[H#WGF¾W�]lVLe[SMVLxIx�F&DGJ[xIJLKcJ[T�]^�bnGFOxIFOHfKjyOJ[DRËF{SMF{HbKOuí-SUJBy8�:t�ËFOxIF���J[` È`pJB�bnGFQNUnGSw`^F{Nj��VAKBËFOeLJ[SM]pFONOu�ÊjxI]^FOH�N¼É�è?é��LsfÌ!u-Øvá���ÞãÜ!ÚcÛÓ��Üzä6Ù.å¬(!¸�ÿÜ?Ù��L(�þQÞ º (^u�qLt�u^É�è?é*�fq[Ì�é[t¿Ècè[èñqB�

��éA��m�� È�þY�:��J[SUWG]^F{SQVLHGW#CQ�:í�J[SUKMFOS{u�ÐvJ[eLKhÀ�N�CEDGF{J[SMF{x(J[HY��VAKcFOeLJ[SM]pFON�JLXRi�J[x�J8KcJ[Tfo³��J[DGFOSUFOHfK¼Ñ�]lVñÈeLScVLxINOuÚ#áLÝ>�a(àf�ÚcÙ��+(�Øvá*�L�K(�f^��ÞàæT( F Ù��+(:è?s[s\ÉÒè?é��[�fÌ�uG�f×wëBé[s��

� è?sA��m�� È�þY�G��J[SUWG]^F{S�V8HGWzCQ�Bí�J[S�KcFOS{u�þ*V8TGN���F{K~PRFOF{H\D�J[x�J8KcJ[Tfo�yOJLDGFOSUFOHfKEWG]^VLe[ScV8x�N{ufC�J[T>�BÊ�TGTG`^N{�puGq*�ÉÒè?é����[Ì�q[×[×ñÈÒqIb[×B�

� è[è{��m�� È�þY����JLSMWG]pFOSRVLHGW$CQ��í�J[SUKMFOSOuBü]p�GScVLHfK_WG]^VLe[ScV8x�N{ufSMFOy!Kc] ��VLy{KM]^J[H�N�VLH�WzV,yOJ[HGN�KcSUnGy{KM]^J[HzJ8X:�:JBWGV?oLum���í-nGSUF,ÊjTGTG`p]^F{W\Ê�`^e[F{�GScVBu��cb�É�è?éLé[sfÌ�è[èLè{È.èñq��G�

� èñqñ��m�� È�þY����J[SUWG]^F{SEVLHGW�CQ��í�J[SUKMFOSOu���V8KcF{e[J[SM]pyhVL`6ÊjNUT6F{y{KcNEJ8XX�-�bnG]½gLV8SM]lV8HbKEi�J[xIJLKcJLTboLu�Ê�TGTG`^]pFOW\��V8K�ÈF{e[J[SU]^yhV8` � KcSUnGy{KMnGSMF{N���ÉÒè?é[é[�fÌ�è?éf×&È�qBèñqB�

� è?tA��m�� È�þY�_��J[SMWG]pFOS�VLH�W CQ�ví�J[SUKMFOSOu�i�J[xIJLKMJ[Tfo|yOJLDGFOSUFOHfK$yOV8KcF{e[J[S�o|KcDGF{J[SUoLu�C�ScVLH�NO�-ÊjxIFOS{�_þ*V8KMD��� JBy8�pu�t*�[é�ÉÒè?é[écbLÌ�è�È�×?�G�� è9�8��m���Ñ�nGNUab]^H�u � ]^xITG`^]pyO]lV8`�þ�F!KcDGJ�WGN�VLHGW KcDGFkd~HfKcF{SMTGSUF{K.VAKc]^JLHÂJLX¿C�SU]^TG`pFY��J[DGJ[xIJ[`^JLeLo[u�þ�FOxIJ[]^SUN

Ê&� þY� � �½u�ÐvJ[`ã��t�u�è?�Lt�u�É�èhécb[×[Ì��� èñ×ñ�¼� ��ÿ¾�BÑjPEoLFOSEV8HGWzÑ����,VLH�u � ]^xITG`p]^yO]^VL`G�:J�yhVL`p] �OV8Kc]pJ[H�JLX���V8KMFOe[J[SU]^F{NOu�m���í-nGSUFjÊjT�TG`^]pFOW$Ê�`^e[F{�GScVBu

èKb\ÉÒè?é��[s[ÌEqL�cbKë�q?�*�G�� è?�A�¼� ��ÿ���ÑjPEoLFOSwVLH�W�Ñ��G�¼V8H�u���VL`pyOnG`^V8Kc]pHGe � ]px�T�`^]^y{]lVL`��:J�yhVL`p] �hVAKc]^JLHGNOuBm���í-nGSUF¼Ê�TGTG`p]^FOW�Ê�`^e[F{�GScVBu

è9��ÉÒè?é��[s[Ìjè/bKëBtf×��� è/bñ�¼� �_ÿ¾�-ÑjPEoLFOS�VLHGW Ñ��-�,VLH�u�ü�nGH�y{Kc]pJ[H ��J[xITG`^F���F{N�]^H�i�J[xIJLKMJ[TG]^yOVL`�Ê�`^e[F{�GScVBu_C�J[T�J[`^JLeLo[u�è?é

ÉÒè?é��[s[ÌS�bqIb7ë����[s��� è��A�¼� ��ÿ���ÑjPEoLFOS�VLHGW|Ñ���,VLH�u�i�J[xIJLKcJLTboYCEDGF{J[SUo|VLHGW � ]^xITG`^]pyO]lV8`vÿ,SUJ[nGT�J[]^W�NOu�í-SUJBy8���QJ[HG]pHGa��

Ç�FOWGF{SO��ÊjaAVLW>�puä�Ib\ÉÒè?é��*�fÌ!u�tcb8éAÈÒt��Lé��� è?éA�¼� ��ÿ¾��ÑjPEo[F{SOu�Ñ���þ����,VLH>u�VLHGW*m���i&� � xI]pKMD�u�i�JLx�JLKMJ[Tfo���J[xIx�n�KcV8Kc]½g[F,Ñ�]^VLe[ScV8x�NEV8HGW\KMDGFO]pS

�wFhV8`^] �OV8Kc]pJ[HGN{uGm���í-nGSUF¼Ê�TGTG`p]^FOW�Ê�`^e[F{�GScV�u�×Ib�É�è?é��LéfÌE×&È�q?�G��ÁqLsA�¿í��_ÿ¼V8�GSM]pFO`EVLH�W4þ��ä�>]pNMx�VLH�u&ØváLæ �"!Bæ%!fÛ³Ù�6O)>ÚUá��!Ý2ÞãÙ���Û�á*�'��·¼Ù��$ÙAÝÒÙ.å'�<ät��Ü.ÙAÚ��8uS�-SMe[F{���Rþ*V8KMD��

Ï�VLHGW�tf×Bu�ÉÒè?é[�cb[Ì�u � T�SM]^H�e[FOSÒÈ ÐvFOSU`lVLe��t*�

Page 35: d¾PRJ[nG`^W `^]^a8F KMJ|KcDVLH a i FO]^H FOS ...hopf.math.purdue.edu/Porter/s-catsv2.pdfGKUKcFOWYKcJ[eLF{KcD FOS,NMJ KcDVAK&d KcDG]pHGa d_ FOeL]^H KMJ nGHGW FOSMN K.VLH WzKcDGFjP

�ÁqBè{�¿í��vÿ¾�-ÿQJBF{SMNMN�V8HGW�m��-ü���m[VLSMWG]pHGFLu F Þ>�jå�æÕÞo�!ÞçáLæ»·¼Ù��$ÙAÝÒÙ.å'�<ät��Ü.ÙAÚ��8uví-SUJ[e[SMF{NMN�]^H�þ�V8KcDGF{x$VAKc]^y{NÐvJL`ã�>èKb?�Gu�ÉÒè?é[é[éfÌ�u�Ï�]pSMabD�ýVLnGNUFOS{�

�Áq[qñ�&Ê&��ÿ,SUJLKcD�FOHGWG]pFOy.a�u�É�èhé��[tfÌ�uf�!BÚcÛ"!�Þ>��âIÛ!Ý á��5h?Û!uGx�VLHbnGNUyOSM]pT�KhuG�[s[sL[ T�V8e[FON{����ÁqLtA�¿�¾��Ê¿��ijV8SMWG]pFLu��¾�ëi¼���,VLxITGN{uVLH�W:�,��� ���Q]^F{�6J�J[x\u:Ê DGJ[xIJLKcJ[Tfo�qKëbe[SMJ[n�T6J[]pW#JLXwV\ijVLn�NMWGJ[S�ê

NUT�VLy{FLu�ÊjTGT�`^]^F{W���V8KcF{e[J[SM]pyhVL` � KcSUnGy{KMnGSMF{NOu'��ÉãqLs[sLsfÌ!uGqLs[é/ë�q8t*�G��Áq?�8�¿�¾��Ê¿�>ijVLSUWG]^F8u��¾�ëi¼���,VLxITGNOu>VLHGWÄ�,��� �>�Q]^FO��J�J[x�u�Ê DGJLx�JLKMJ[Tfo\�G]^e[SUJ[nGT�J[]^W�JLX_V$KcJLT6J[`pJ[e[]pyhVL`

NUT�VLy{FLu�ÊjTGT�`^]^F{W���V8KcF{e[J[SM]pyhVL` � KcSUnGy{KMnGSMF{NOu'��ÉãqLs[sBèñÌ�t�è[è!ÈÒtfqIb�Áq[×ñ�&Ê&�6mLJño[VL`ãu�,�n�VLNU]½È yhV8KMFOe[J[SU]^F{N�V8HGW³�,VLH�yOJ[xITG`^F��BFONOu>m���í-nGSMF&ÊjTGTG`p]^F{W�Ê�`^e[F{�GScV�u�è/bL×�É2qLs[sfq[ÌwqLsIbñÈ

qLq[qB��ÁqL�A�¿�¾��i&���,VLxITGN�V8HGW<CQ��í�J[SUKMFOSOuÁÖg�!Û!ÝçÚMá��!ݼ·¼Ù��$ÙAÝ~Ù.å'��á*�'� F Þ>�jå�æ^ܽ·¼Ù��$ÙAÝÒÙ.å'� ät��Ü.ÙAÚ��Au,è?é[écb�u

��J[SU`^W � yO]pFOHfKc] ��yL��ÁqIbñ�¿�¾�vi¼�R�,VLxITGNIVLHGW�CQ�_í�J[S�KcF{SOuwqñÈ e[SMJLnGT6JL]^WrFOH�SM]^y.D�x�F{HbKMN$]pH�D�J[x�J8KcJ[TforKcD�FOJ[S�o�VLHGW VL`^e[F{�GScVBu

�jÈãKcDGF{J[SUoLu�q[×\ÉãqLs[s[q[Ì�tcbLt¿È^�fsLé���Áq*�A�¿üR�b� ����VhPEg[F{SMFLu�ü�nGHGy{KMJ[SM]^VL` � F{x$VLHfKM]^yON_JLX>Êj`^eLFO�GSMVL]^yECEDGF{J[SM]pFON{uGí-SMJ�yL��ÇjVAKh�bÊjyOVLW�� � yO]2�b} � ÊÃ×Ls

ÉÒè?é[�[t[Ìq�[�[éMëé�cbLqB�|��ÁqLéA���,��Ñ����:FO]½Kcy.D�u�CED�F&i�J[xIJLKcJ[Tfo���J[x�x¿n�K.V8KM]pgLF¼��nG�6F8u6m�����JLHGWGJ[H�þ*V8KMD�� � J�yL��É2q[Ì!u�é\É�èhécb?�bÌ�u�qLt

È�q8é����t[sA��m�� ÈÒ�-���:J�W�Vho[u � TGVLyOF{NwPw]½KcD÷��HG]½KcF{`pozx�VLHfozH�J[HBÈ KMSM]½gB]^VL`>D�J[x�J8KcJ[TfozeLSMJ[nGT�NOu�m���í-nGSUFL��ÊjT�TG`ã�GÊ�`^e[F�È

��ScV�u�q��³ÉÒè?é��fq[Ì�è/bLé¿È�qLsfqB���t�è{��ÿ¾� þ*VL`pKMNM]pHG]^JLKM]^N{u d~HfKMSMJ�WGnGy{KM]^J[H ¹V `lV KcDRËF{J[SM]pF WGF{N Ñ�ËFOSU]pg8V8KMFOnGSUNOu Vhg8VL]p`lVL�G`pF V8K

DfKUKcTt¢¾g¿gAPEPEP,��x$VAKcD�� xUnGNMNU]^F{n���XZS�gÁÀñx$V8`pKcNU]^Htgz���tfqñ��ÿ¾�fþ�VL`pKMNM]^H�]^JLKM]^NOu8��V�CEDRËFOJLSM]^F�WGFE`ãÀ�DGJ[xIJLKcJLTG]^FvWGF�ÿQSMJLKMDGFOH�WG]^F{y.a�u[Pw]½KcD�K~PRJ¼VLTGT�FOHGWG]pyOF{N-�bo¾Ñ��ÖÈÒ�j�

��]pNM]pHGNMab]ãu�TGSUFOTGSU]^HfKwt[tfq�u�d~HGN�Kc]pKMn�K�W�F,þ*V8KMD�ËFOx�V8Kc]p�bnGFON�W�F,mLnGNMNU]^F{n�u�É2í�VLSM]pNE�¦Â íV8SM]^N@b¦g¾��Ç~� � ÌmLn�HGF&qLs[sfqB�

��t[tA�&Ê&�:þ�nBKc`^n³VLHGW#CQ��í�J[SUKMFOS{u�ÊjTGT�`^]^yOV8Kc]pJ[HGN�JLX_í�F{]pê6FOS�TGVL]^SU]^HGe[N�]^H�KcDGF�þ\JBJ[SUF�yOJLx�TG`pF!��JLX_VzNU]^x¾ÈT�`^]^y{]lVL`�e[SUJ[nGT�u�CEDGF{J[SUo�VLHGW\ÊjTGTG`p]^yOV8Kc]pJ[HGN�JLX���V8KMFOe[J[SU]^F{NOuä�Gu�Ç�JG�4bBu�ÉÒè?é[é��[Ì�è9�<�AÈcè/bLt��

��t*�8�&Ê&�vþ�n�KM`^n�VLHGWrCQ�ví�J[SUKMFOS{uRd KMFOScVAKcFOW�í�FO]pê6FOS¾TGVL]^SU]^HGe[N&]^H|KMDGF�þ�JBJLSMFzy{J[x�T�`^F!�|JLX�V#NM]^xITG`p]^yO]^VL`eLSMJ[nGT>uGÊjTGT�`^]^F{W���V8KcF{e[J[SM]pyhVL` � KcSUnGy{KMnGSMF{NOu�é\ÉãqLs[sBèñÌjè[è[è�È�è?t[sB�

��tf×ñ�&CQ�ñí�J[SUKMFOS{uLÊj��NUKcSMVLy{K�i�J[x�J8KcJ[TfoQCEDGF{J[SUo'¢�CEDGF_d~HbKMFOSMVLy{KM]^J[H¼JLXG��V8KcF{e[J[SUo�CEDGFOJ[S�o&VLHGW&i�J[xIJLKcJLTboCED�FOJ[S�o[u6��nG��JGu�qLs[sfq��

��t[�A�¿Ñ��_ÿ¾��,�nG]p`^`^F{H�u_i�J[xIJLKMJ[TG]^yOVL`�Ê�`^e[F{�GScV�uR�:FOy!KcnGSUF*Ç�JLKcF{N�]pH�þ�V8KcDGN{�-g[J[` .�� u � TGSU]^HGeLFOS�ÈãÐvFOSU`lVLeGuÉÒè?é[�cbLÌ!���tcbñ��ÿ¾� � F{efVL`2u���V8KcF{e[J[SU]^FONwV8HGW³��JLDGJ[xIJ[`^J[e8o$CEDGF{J[SM]pFON{u�C�J[T�J[`pJ[eLo[u>è?t\É�è?écb��bÌ�qLé[t¿ÈRt�è?qB�

tf×

Page 36: d¾PRJ[nG`^W `^]^a8F KMJ|KcDVLH a i FO]^H FOS ...hopf.math.purdue.edu/Porter/s-catsv2.pdfGKUKcFOWYKcJ[eLF{KcD FOS,NMJ KcDVAK&d KcDG]pHGa d_ FOeL]^H KMJ nGHGW FOSMN K.VLH WzKcDGFjP

��t��A���j� � ]^xITGNUJ[H�u�ÊÍyO`pJ[NMF{W³xIJBWGF{`�N�KcSUnGy{KMnGSMF¿XZJLSCË�È yhV8KMFOe[JLSM]^F{NOu6]^HfKcF{SMH�VL`�i�JLx�u6ÇwÈ NUK.V8y.a�N�VLHGW³e[F{HBÈF{ScVL`p] �{FOW � FO]½XZFOS�KUÈ g8VLH��,VLxIT�FOH�u�Vhg8VL]p`lVL�G`pF�V8KK¢_VLS�Ãj]pg�u�VL`pe8È~e[F{J[xªgLécbLs*�[s[s[���

��t[éA���j� � ]^xITGNMJ[H>u��:]^xI]pKcNR]^H L È yhV8KMFOe[JLSM]^F{NOu�Vhg8VL]p`lVL�G`pF�V8KK¢vVLS�Ãj]pg�u�VL`pe8È~eLFOJ[xªgLécbLs*�[s�è?s���Ú�fsA���j� � ]px�T�NMJ[H�uq��ê>F{y{Kc]½g[F�e[FOHGF{ScVL`p] �{FOW � ]^F!XZFOSUK�È g8VLH �,VLx�T�FOH$¢�DGJ?P�KMJ�yOVL`^y{nG`lV8KMF�ÄqÍruEVhg8VL]^`^VL�G`^F

VAK9¢ÁVLS�Ãj]pg�uG�[ÈÒVL`pe,gLécb�è?s[s�è[èL��Ú�Gè{�A��8CV8x�NMVLx$V8HG]ãu � nGS-`pFONH�JLKc]pJ[HGN�WGF L È~yOV8KBËF{e[J[SM]pF�F!K L È e[SMJ[n�T6Jhý � WGF�H�J[H¾NUKMSM]^y!KcF{N�gB]^VjWGF{N-FOHGNUFOx��G`pFONx¿nG`pKM]½È~NU]^xITG`^]pyO]^VLnB�6uf�jÈ~CEDGF{J[SUoLu:è?�\É�è?éLé[éfÌE×Bè{È~é[é���Ú�bqñ�¿Ï���C�J�ýFOH�u�ÐvFOSUNEnGHGF�]pHbKMFOSUTGS�ËF!K.V8KM]^J[Hze[VL`^J[]pNM]pFOHGHGFwWGFj`lV&KMD�ËFOJ[SU]^F�WGF�`ãÀ�DGJ[xIJLKMJ[TG]^F8uB��VLDG]^F{SMN�W�F�C�JLT��

ÿ*ËFOJLx���Ñ�]½ê�ByhV8KO��ÉZKMJIVLTGT�FhVLScÌ!��Ú�ftA�&Ê&��í��C�J[HGabNOu¾ät��Ü.ÙAÚ��ká*�'�ká!åfå�æÕÞo�MáLÝ2ÞãÙ���Û�Ù�6ò�!ÚcÙ?Û.Û?Ü����.Ù��jå�æ^Ü{¨BÜ.Û!u�f^�a(Tþ7(¾ät��Ü.Û!Þ^Û!u}�HG]½g[FOSUNM]½K~o|JLX

�'VL`pFONOuGÏ�VLHGe[JLSOu�É�èhé[é[tfÌ�uGVhg8VL]^`^VL�G`^F�XZSMJ[x3¢�DfKMKMTt¢¾g¿gAPEPEP,��]^H�XZJ[SUx$VAKc]^y{NOu���VLHGeLJ[SO�ÁVLyL��nGaÁg8TGn��G`^]pyMgB�½�p�g8x$VAKcDGF{x$V8KM]^y{N�g8SUFONMFOVLSMy.DÅg8TGSMF{TGSM]pHfKcN�g8é[tÆgLVL`peLKcJLT�é[t���DfKcxI`(�¾é[t��½è/b�Ú���8���,��þ��GÐvJLeLKhu�i�J[xIJLKcJ[Tfo�`p]^xI]pKMN�VLH�W�y{J[`^]px�]½KcNOu�þ*V8KMD��4��½u:è?t*��É�èhécbLtfÌ�èLè{È�×[q���Ú�b×ñ���,��þ���ÐvJ[e8Khu�i�JLx�JLKMJ[Tfo#DGJ[xIJ[xIJ[SMT�DG]^NUx�NjVLHGWkKcDGFIijV8x�xIJBy.a*�:JByOVL`^] �hV8KM]^J[H�u>Ï�J[`2� � J�yL��þ*V8KO�

þ\F!�B]^yOVLH�VItcb�É�è?é[é[q[ÌS�ft�è!ȧ���<�B��Ú�f�A���j�[��FO]p�6F{`ãufi�J[xIJLKcJ[Tfo¾F{HGWGN_VLHGWICEDGJ[x�VLNUJ[H�x�J�WGFO`�yhV8KMFOe[J[SU]^F{NOu � FO`pFOy!K.V¼þ*V8KMD���É2Ǽ� � �ëÌ�b�ÉãqLs[sBèñÌ

×8t[tAÈ�×8�*�G�CQ�ëí�J[SUKMFOSOuþ*V8KcD�FOx�V8Kc]pyON�Ñ�FOT�V8SUKcxIFOHfKOu� y.DGJ�J[`:JLX�d~H�XZJ[SMx�V8KM]^yON{u}�HG]½g[FOSUNM]½K~o�JLX��'VL`pFONwÏ�VLH�e[J[SOuÏ�VLHGe[JLSOuÿQPEo�HGF{WGW�u�����×�b�èh}�CQu}�HG]½KcFOW��Q]^HGeLWGJ[x\�

t[�


Recommended