+ All Categories
Home > Documents > 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)!...

2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)!...

Date post: 17-Oct-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 3 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
706
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
Transcript
Page 1: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&'#()#*(+&,#&!&$)#$-('!()#$&-#%(-,./%&)#(0'.)1(

/)1)$-+(!0'2(%3-(2&**1-(4&#,*'2(%'(%3-(+)&%-(/-0&'*5(

(

)(1-6&$',0)/3&$)1(+%"*.()#*(&%+(/'++&71-($'##-$%&'#(8&%3(

%3-()0$3)-'1',&$)1(-9&*-#$-(

(

/)0%(&&5($)%)1',"-()#*(+.#'/+&+(

(

:;((

(

,<=><?(/?@><?A<(

(

(

)(BCDE<E(E=:F<BBDG(BH((

(

%CD("I<JDAE<B;(HK(7<AF<I@C?F(?IG(L+?M<DIN?OP("I<JDAE<BQ(G<(0HF?(

(

KHA(BCD(RH<IBS/CG(MAH@A?F(<I(L+B=G<(!<>H>H@<T<(D(1DBBDA?A<(GD>(9<T<IH('A<DIBD()IB<TH(D(>O&A?I(/ADS

<E>?F<THO5(

( (

(

(

(

&IEB<B=BD(HK()ATC?DH>H@;(?IG()IB<U=<B;(

%CD("I<JDAE<B;(HK(7<AF<I@C?F(

+=MDAJ<EHAV(*A5(2?AB<I(7HFF?E(

(

(

(

(

*<M?AB<FDIBH(G<(+B=G<('A<DIB?><(

L+?M<DIN?OP("I<JDAE<BQ(G<(0HF?(

+=MDAJ<EHAV(*A5EE?(1HADG?I?(+<EB(

(

!

Page 2: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

University of Birmingham Research Archive

e-theses repository This unpublished thesis/dissertation is copyright of the author and/or third parties. The intellectual property rights of the author or third parties in respect of this work are as defined by The Copyright Designs and Patents Act 1988 or as modified by any successor legislation. Any use made of information contained in this thesis/dissertation must be in accordance with that legislation and must be properly acknowledged. Further distribution or reproduction in any format is prohibited without the permission of the copyright holder.

Page 3: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! "##!

$%&'!(()!*%'%+,-./)!

!

!

!

/0%1$+/2!

3/&(%+!

*,4/!

456789:;!

:<89!=><?9@!

5:!;A9!

17?978!

?9BC<D!65@9!5B!

C;?!

EB5F9:<:69G!

456789:;!;C;D9! /?)!(:?6BCE;C5:H:<89!5I!;A9!@56789:;H;C;D9!5I!;A9!DC;9B<BJ!

;9K;!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! $D<69! 5I! EB5F9:<:69! =LA9:! M:5L:G)! $9BC5@! =9?)! 1)N)GO!

NC:PQ?!B9CP:!=R9<B!5I!;A9!MC:PQ?!B9CP:O!LA9:!M:5L:G!

49?6BCE;C5:! 49?6BCE;C5:! 5I! ;A9! @56789:;! <:@! ;A9! E5?C;C5:! 5I! ;A9!

C:?6BCE;C5:H;9K;!LC;AC:!C;!=LA9:!E5??C>D9G!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

SC;A!?9BC<;C5:?!=%OTO*))G!LA9:!@CII9B9:;!?96;C5:?!5I!;A9!?<89!?57B69!<B9!89:;C5:9@!!!

!

!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!1<C:!5B!5BCPC:<D!E7>DC6<;C5:!5I!;A9!;9K;)!

'B<:?D<;C5:2!$7>DC6<;C5:!7?9@!I5B!;A9!;B<:?D<;C5:!5I!;A9!;9K;)!

'B<:DC;9B<;C5:2!$7>DC6<;C5:!7?9@!I5B!;A9!;B<:?DC;9B<;C5:!5I!;A9!;9K;)!

*5889:;2!$7>DC6<;C5:!;A<;!89:;C5:?!;A9!;9K;!5B!65889:;?!C;)!

!

! !

Page 4: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! "#V!

!!

%)()W! X<88<8<;!

456789:;!;C;D9! &56M!?;9D9!5I!NC:P!19:;7A5;9E!(Y!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! S<@C!X<88<8<;)!19:;)!(Y)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'A9! ?;9D9! L<?! 9K967;9@! 5:! >9A<DI! 5I! 19:;7A5;9E! (YO! ;A9!

D<?;!MC:P!5I!;A9!WW;A!4J:<?;JO!>J!;A9!FCZC9B!%89:98A<;O!;A9!

I7;7B9! MC:P! <:@! I57:@9B! 5I! ;A9! W[;A! 4J:<?;J)! (;!

6588985B<;9?! ;A9! ?7669??I7D! 658ED9;C5:! 5I! <! \7<BBJC:P!

9KE9@C;C5:! C:! ;A9! @9?9B;! B9PC5:! 5I! ;A9! S<@C! X<88<8<;)!

1C:O!;A9!P5@!5I!*5E;7?O!L<?!;A9!+5B@!5I!;AC?!9<?;9B:!@9?9B;O!

<:@!;A9!9KE9@C;C5:?!L9B9!65:?C@9B9@!;5!>9!7:@9B!AC?!?E96C<D!

6<B9)!'A9!;9K;!C?!LBC;;9:!C:!;L5!A5BCZ5:;<D!DC:9?!<:@!:C:9;99:!

65D78:?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

D)!]G!!"#$%"&'%#'%(%'&%&)'%*'+%,-%+.$%(%,*)!!!

!

=))G!$BC85B@C<D!ICB?;!B<:MC:P!C:!;A9!ED<69!5I!;A9!

A5BCZ5:^@L9DD9B?O!P5@Q?%,-/%P5@!5I!;A9!,-!9:@5L9@!LC;A!DCI9!=))G!

!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!*57J<;!^!15:;9;!W_W[2!:5)!W_[O!EE)!_V^W``!<:@!ED)![#)!!

N79:;Z!W_[`2!W[W!II)!!

36A9:M9D!W_ab2!:5?)!]][!<:@!]bbO![a]^[ab!<:@![aV^[a_)!

'B<:?D<;C5:2!+C6A;A9C8!W_#"^W_V`O!(2!WW])!!

T%&!(2!]"_^]]"!<:@!]b[^]b")!!

! !

Page 5: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! "#_!

%)()[! T7><?;C?!W!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BC>9@!>D56M!IB58!;A9!E<D<69W!5I!'9DD!T<?;<!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! '9DD!T<?;<)!%8)!()!

49?6BCE;C5:! TD56M!LC;A!E<B;!5I!;A9!X5B7?!:<89!5I!;A9!MC:P!%89:98A<;!(!

IB58!;A9!E<D<69W!5I!'9DD!T<?;<)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%*#0'%,-%%

!

NC:P!5I!;A9!,-!

U5;9?2! W! (:! c<BC@Q?! E7>DC6<;C5:! ;A9! >D56M! C?! EB9?9:;9@! <?! >9D5:PC:P! ;5! ;A9! ;98ED9! 5I!

%89:98A<;!(((O!<665B@C:P!;5!AC?!EB9FC57?!C:;9BEB9;<;C5:!5I!;A9!>7CD@C:P!<?!<!;98ED9)!

47BC:P! ;A9!657B?9!5I! 6D9<BC:P!<;! ;A9!:5B;A9<?;!65B:9B!5I! ;A9! ;98ED9!<B9<! ;AB99! DC89?;5:9!

>D56M?! @<;9@! ;5! ;A9! B9CP:! 5I! %89:98A<;! (! L9B9! I57:@! ;7B:9@! 7E?C@9! @5L:)! 'A9! 85?;!

C:;9B9?;C:P! C?! ;A9!PB9<;9?;!>D56MO!LAC6A!8CPA;!A<F9!>99:! ;A9! DC:;9D!5I! ;A9!@55BL<J!5I! ;A9!

;98ED9! =ED)! 0G)!,:! ;A9! >D56M! ;A9B9! <B9! ?69:9?! C:! B9DC9I! B9EB9?9:;C:P!%89:98A<;! (((! <;! AC?!

d7>CD99! I9?;CF<D)! T9D5L! ;A9! ?MJ^?CP:O! ;A9! MC:P! C?! ?A5L:! ?C;;C:P! 5:! AC?! ;AB5:9! C:! <! MC5?MO!

L9<BC:P!d7>CD99!B5>9?!<:@!;A9!6B5L:!5I!.EE9B!<:@!+5L9B!/PJE;)!X5B7?!<:@!39;A!<B9!?A5L:!

LC;A!A78<:!A<:@?!5II9BC:P!AC8!?J8>5D?!E5??C>DJ!?CP:CIJC:P!657:;D9??!J9<B?!5I!B7D9)!T9:9<;A!

;A9!@57>D9!MC5?M!C?!<!A5BCZ5:;<D!B5L!5I!9:CP8<;C6!?CP:?)!%>5F9O!57;?C@9!;A9!MC5?MO!;A9B9!<B9!

;A9!?;<:@<B@?!5I!S9EL<L9;!5I!;A9!U5B;A!<:@!357;A)!T9D5L!5:!;A9!BCPA;!<:@!D9I;O!P5@!Q10*2(3'24!C?!@9EC6;9@!L9<BC:P!<!D95E<B@!?MC:!<:@!>BC:PC:P!5II9BC:P?!<:@!LAC?A9?!I5B!DCI9O!?;<>CDC;J!<:@!L9DI<B9! ;5! ;A9!MC:P)!'L5!?C8CD<B!F9B;C6<D! DC:9?!5I! C:?6BCE;C5:?! B965B@C:P! ;A9!MC:PQ?! ICB?;!

56.^I9?;CF<D!5667EJ!;A9!BCPA;!<:@!D9I;!>5B@9B?!5I!;A9!>D56M)!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!c<BC@!W_a]2!_]O!ED)!WW)!

!

! !

Page 6: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! "V`!

%)()"! +C?A;!W!

456789:;!;C;D9! *5:;B5D!:5;9!C:!C:M!IB58!+C?A;!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! +C?A;)!%8)!()!

49?6BCE;C5:! 38<DD!65:;B5D!:5;9!C:!C:M!?;5:9!IB58!;A9!ID55B!5I!;A9!EJB<8C@!

5I!+C?A;)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%7*0%%

!7*0%!

U5;9?2!!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!%B:5D@!W__`2!aWO!:5)!%")!!$1!]2WO!##)!!

! !

Page 7: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! "VW!

%)()]! /D9EA<:;C:9!

=3!W]`G!

456789:;!;C;D9! TD56M!C:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!3<;9;^;98ED9!<;!/D9EA<:;C:9!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! /D9EA<:;C:9)!39?)!()!

49?6BCE;C5:! TD56M! 3! W]`! IB58! /D9EA<:;C:9! ;98ED9!LC;A! ]! F9B;C6<D! DC:9?!

C:?6BCE;C5:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%899:%*;%*%"+2*#0'%

!

+5B@!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!36A9:M9D!W_#b>2!WWVO!I)!W`)!!

$1!b2WO![[_)!

!! !

Page 8: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! "V[!

%)()b! ET9BDC:!"`[_!

456789:;!;C;D9! T7CD@C:P!C:?6BCE;C5:!5I!39?5?;BC?!(!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! $<EJB7?!T9BDC:!"`[_)!39?)!()!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'A9!5BCPC:<D!;9K;!L<?!EB5><>DJ!6<BF9@!5:!<!?;9D9!5B!<!L<DD!5I!

;A9! ;98ED9! 5I! %;78! <;! X9DC5E5DC?)! 'A9! F9B?C5:! ;A<;! A<?!

?7BFCF9@!C?!<!65EJ!5:!<!D9<;A9B!B5DDO!8<@9!>J!<:!WV;A!4J:<?;J!

?6BC>9)!'A9!658E5?C;C5:!;B9<;?!;A9!I57:@<;C5:!5I!;A9!;98ED9!

<:@!<!E<D<69)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!WG%),'%*#0'%(%#)('<%)"+%-(#'%(%.&.0%*.%+,%$(<02)'94%#(+0%*0%#"'2#&%,*)%0.&%#*;%#+0%+%#'%0,,0'%%%%D)!WWG%$('9*94%0$%+%$(<%,-%(%0.-%**%"+'9$%(%&-'<%+.$9[*94%*9$]%&094%0#)94%%

!

%EE9<B<:69!5I!;A9!MC:P!C:!;A9!@57>D9!6B5L:)!

%!?9??C5:!;55M!ED<69!C:!;A9!.&.0)!,:9!;55M!657:?9D!LC;A!AC?!I5DD5L9B?O!;A9!658E<:C5:?!

5I!;A9!#"'2#&O!D)!E)!A)O!;A9!5IIC6C<D?!<;!;A9!ED<69!5I!EBCF<6J!!!

!

X9!e&<^X<B<M;9f!I<?AC5:9@!89!<?!<!@L9DD9B!5I!

;A9!,-!<?!<!><>JO!>9I5B9!(!6<89!I5B;A!IB58!

;A9!;ACPA?)!'5!89!L<?!PCF9:!C;?!D9:P;A!<:@!C;?!

>B9<@;A!

!U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!3;9B:!WV#]2!Vb^_a!<:@!ED?)!W^")!!

@9!T76M!W_"V2!]V^b#)!!

-59@C6M9!W_#]2!_`=9G)!

,?C:P!W__[>2!WW`)!

'B<:?D<;C5:2!T%&!(O!]_V^b`a)!!

+C6A;A9C8!W_#"^W_V`O!(2!WWa^WW#)!!

/B8<:![``b2!]_^b[)!!

!! !

Page 9: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! "V"!

%)()a! g/!]#[#a!

456789:;!;C;D9! U<5?!5I!39?5?;BC?!(!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<M)!39?)!()!

49?6BCE;C5:! U<5?!I57:@9@!?57;A!5I!;A9!L9?;9B:!5>9DC?M!5I!;A9!#;A!EJD5:!

<;! N<B:<M)! (:?6BCE;C5:! 5:! ;A9! I<69! 5I! ;A9! :<5?! 5:! ;A9! D9I;!

?C@9)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%=+<%(%>1(*2?,%*;%#'%'&0<%(+$%*4+%@+%)*'<%"+2,&%%!

!

T9D5F9@!>J!%87:^&<O!+5B@!5I!;A9!'AB5:9?!5I!

;A9!;L5!+<:@?O!;A9!E9BI96;!X5B7?!LA5!B9?C@9?!

C:!;A9!"+2,&!

U5;9?2!!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!1<6<@<8!W_]a2!aWO!ED)!_)!!

$1![2[O!W#W)!

!! !

Page 10: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! "V]!

%)()#! '5@!W!!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!39?5?;BC?!(!<;!'5@!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! '5@)!39?)!()%49?6BCE;C5:! '9K;!C:?6BC>9@!5:!;A9!L9?;!I<69!5I!;A9!B9<B85?;!?;<:@C:P!L<DD!

5I!;A9!;98ED9!5I!'5@O!?57;A!5I!;A9!<KC<D!@55BL<J)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

D)!WG%899:>-94%,*)%0.&%#*;%%

!

eB5J<D!657:6CDf!C:!AC?!>-O!D)!E)!A)!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!T<B>5;C:!h!*DiB9!W__W2!VO!ED)!W^[O!I)!"O!D)!W)!

&9@I5B@!W_V#2!"aO!I)!W)!

!! !

Page 11: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! "Vb!

%)()V! 198EAC?!!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!%89:98A<;!((!IB58!;A9!;98ED9!5I!$;<A!<;!1C;!

&<AC:<!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 198EAC?)!%8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!6<BF9@!5:!<!EC:M!PB<:C;9!>D56M!I57:@9@!7E5:!5:9!

5I!;A9!65D5??7?!5I!&<89?9?!((! C:!IB5:;!5I!;A9!;98ED9!5I!$;<A!

<;!1C;!&<AC:<!B9E5B;C:P!5:!<:!9KE9@C;C5:!;5!3JBC<^$<D9?;C:9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!WG%99%+%7*0%&-'%A%)&%%D)![G%*#0'%;$'<%B"+2C&2?,%(%!%*%"+28,&:!%%D)!"G%$(<%(%"+2*#0'%%%D)!bG%!%*%"+2*#0'%%D)!_G%,"+%(%$!'94%*;'%(%"+2*#0'%%D)![[G%.$'%*%$*$%+%#'"2#&%%D)![aG%-&'<02,%,-%.#4%*#0'%%D)!"[G%"+2*#0'%%

!

));5!;A9!7*0%<!IC9D@!5I!W`!)&!!

NC:P!5I!.EE9B!<:@!+5L9B!/PJE;!39?5?;BC?!C:!

;A9!D<M9!5I!;A9!"+28,&:!!

=,II9BC:P?H?<6BCIC69?G!;5!;A5?9!LA5!<B9!C:!;A9!

"+2*#0'!!

'A9!D<M9H@C?;BC6;!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'!!

1<?;9B!5I!9F9BJ!EB5E9B;J!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'!!

T9C:P!>B57PA;!;5!;A9!#'"2#&!!

$BC:69?!5I!;A9!,-%I5B!;A9!EB5;96;C5:!5I!;A9!MC:P!!

"+2*#0'%

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!X<B;LCP!%D;9:8jDD9B!h!157??<!W__W2!]O!W^"k!bO!bk!VO!_k!WaO![[k!W#O!["k!WVO![ak![[O!

"[k!ED)!W)!

c<B<P!W_V`2!#b^V2!##!II)O!ED)!"^b)!

$1!"2[O!V[")!

!

! !

Page 12: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! "Va!

%)()_! +<A7:!W!

456789:;!;C;D9! S<DD!@965B<;C5:!IB58!+<A7:!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! +<A7:)!39?)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! cB<P89:;!5I!L<DD!@965B<;C5:!IB58!;A9!?C;9!5I!;A9!$JB<8C@!5I!

39?5?;BC?!(()!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%*;%,-%%

!

+5B@!5I!;A9!,-!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!$9;BC9!h!TB7:;5:!h!17BB<J!W_["2!ED)!Wa)W_)!

!

! !

Page 13: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! "V#!

%)()W`! 19@<87@![a!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!39?5?;BC?!(((!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 19@<87@)!39?)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! 3<:@?;5:9!>D56M!LC;A!W!A5BCZ5:;<D! DC:9! C:?6BCE;C5:!LC;A! ;A9!

6<B;576A9!5I!39?5?;BC?! (((! I57:@! C:! IB5:;!5I! ;A9!@55B!5I! ;A9!

-B9<;!*57B;!5I!;A9!;98ED9!5I!19@<87@)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%e))f!)&#'%5''%$*09#*%$,;%D+E%,-%*#0'%;$'<%%

!

e))f!'A9!I5B9CP:!657:;BC9?!5I!%?C<O!;A9CB!$*0%>9C:P!7:C;9%I5B!;A9!,-%5I!;A9!MC:P!5I!.EE9B!<:@!+5L9B!/PJE;!e39?5?;BC?!(((f!

!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!TC??5:!W_[a^"aO!(Y2!a#O!I)!"#O!:5)![`bW)!!

$1!b2WO!W]")!

!

! !

Page 14: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! "VV!

%)()WW! /Z>9;!X9D8C!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!39?5?;BC?!(((!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! /Z>9;!X9D8C)!39?)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!6<BF9@!5:!<!PB<:C;9!E5B;<D!I57:@!<;!/Z>9;!X9D8CO!

;A9! ?57;A9B:! <B9<! 5I! NA<;<:<^l<:;CB)! 'A9! ;9K;! B9E5B;?! ;A<;!

39?5?;BC?! (((! B9:9L9@! ;A9! 85:789:;O! ICB?;DJ! 9B96;9@! >J!

%89:98A<;!((()!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!WG%#;&%.&.&0[<]%,-%>1(*2(2)&'%%

!

455B!5I!;A9!.&.&0[<]%5I!;A9!,-%5I!%89:98A<;!

!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!X<><6AC!W_b]2!]bW)!!

3Z<IBm:?MC!W__V2!W`[^a)!

!! !

Page 15: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! "V_!

%)()W[! /K!6c<B57M!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!<!I<C9:69!>9<@!5I!l799:!5;C2C&2?,!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! '9DD!9D^4<>^n<)!W[;A^W";A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! -B99:! I<C9:69! >9<@! ?A<E9@! C:! ;A9! I5B8! 5I! <:! 9D5:P<;9@!

6JDC:@9B! B9?98>DC:P! <! E9BI789! F<?9)! 'L5! DC:9?! 5I!

C:?6BCE;C5:?! <B9! 9:PB<F9@! 5EE5?C;9! 9<6A! 5;A9B!LBC;;9:! C:! <!

B96;<:PD9!LC;A!;A9!A9<F9:!?CP:!<>5F9!C;)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%F#0'2;$'<%5;C2C&2?,%,*)%.'%5;C%G.<'%@+%-+<2$;%G.<'%*;%H&2!%-+<2$;%,-%(+<'%%

!

NC:P!5I!.EE9B!<:@!+5L9B!/PJE;O!5;C2C&2?,I%DCFC:P!I5B9F9BO!>9D5F9@!5I!35>9M!;A9!

c<CJ78C;9O!;A9!X5B7?!LA5!C?!C:!;A9!c<CJ78O!

8<?;9B!5I!;A9!D<M9^D<:@!ED9<?C:P!;A9!,-!!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!X<><6AC!W_b]2!]a"O!:5)!V)!

!! !

Page 16: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! "_`!

%)()W"! g/!a"`#!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!F4+2-'"!!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!U9B9A5;9E!()!

49?6BCE;C5:! F4+2-'"%@9?6BC>9?!;A9!L<J!A9!B9:9L9@!;A9!L5B?ACE!5I!,?CBC?!C:! %>J@5?! LC;A! ;A9! P5D@! ;A<;! 6<89! IB58! ;A9! ?E5CD?! 5I! ;A9!

U7>C<:!L<B)!X9!;A9:!B9E5B;?! C:!@9;<CD!<>57;! ;A9!EB569??C5:!

5I!;A9!PB9<;!,?CBC?O!LAC6A!A9!A<?!65:@76;9@!C:!E7B?7<:69!5I!

;AC?!5B@9B)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%J9%KE%),$D'E%-(94%-+%#'%@+%(%,-%%%%J9%ALE%,-,094%.;,-$%'+%8$'+0%,&%(:%M0*'%#"+%"0%$+9#*%+%7*0%DNE%%

!

%EE9<B<:69!5I!XC?!1<d9?;J!5:!;A9!?9<;!5I!

X5B7?!C:!;A9!,-%%XC?!>5<;?!C:!;A9!?9<?5:!5I!;A9!C:7:@<;C5:!e5I!

;A9!PB9<;!BCF9Bf!C:!M0*'%<BBCF9@O!A<FC:P!>99:!8<@9!I5B!;A9%7*0%DNE%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!

/@9D2!W_#]2!WV^_O!I)!Wb^[`O!II)!W^[)!!

X9D6M!W_#b<2![WO!,BCP)!D)![O!E)![]O!,BCP)!D)!Wa)!!!

$C9E9B!W_[_2!#"^#)!!

$1!b2WO!]])!

!! !

Page 17: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! "_W!

%)()W]! g/!bW_WW!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!O&%*4+%?>25;C2-'"%!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<MO!XJE5?;JD9!X<DD)!35>9MA5;9E!(YO!W";A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 3;9D9!B9P<B@C:P!;A9!EB5FC?C5:?!;5!>9!@9DCF9B9@!;5!;A9!YCZC9B!C:!

;A9!7*09!(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!WbG%,P0%)*'0%)&%'&'<%$*0%+%7*0%..0'%%

!

$B5FC?C5:?!5I!B<6M?!5I!L<;9B!E5;?!5I!;A9!5IIC69!

5I!;A9!FCZC9BO!$*0%=;5!>9!>B57PA;G!;5!;A9!7*0%%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!

X9D6M!W_a_<2!W_a^VO!I)![O!ED)!W#O!D)!Wb)!!

X9D6M!W_#b<2!"")!!

1C5?C!W_VW2!]^WW)!$1![2[O!b[)!

!! !

Page 18: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! "_[!

%)()Wb! T1c%!

"V)[`a]!

=E&9C?:9B!((!

456789:;!;C;D9! $<EJB7?!&9C?:9B!((!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! U<P<!9@!49CBO!')!]`V)!39?)!()!

49?6BCE;C5:! $)! &9C?:9B! ((! C?! ;A9! ?965:@! 5I! I57B! B5DD?! I57:@! C:! ')! ]`V! <;!

U<P<! 9@! 49CB! C:! W_`])! (;! C?! 9??9:;C<DDJ! ;A9! B965B@! 5I!

;B<:?<6;C5:?!5I!;A9!B5J<D!@56MJ<B@!L5BM?A5E!<;!'AC?!@7BC:P!

B9P:<D! J9<B?! Wb! ;AB57PA! WV! 5I! 39?5?;BC?! ()! 'A9! <6;CFC;C9?! 5I!

;A9!L5BM?A5E! <B9! P9:9B<DDJ! 65::96;9@!LC;A! 6<BE9:;BJ! <:@!

B96<?;C:P!5I!89;<D!;55D?)!!

396;C5:!/!<:@!-!65:?C?;!5I!<@8C:C?;B<;CF9!5B@9B?!5I!;A9!$(<2+%*$0'% '&'<% $(<2+% -0'% "+02L% ,1*'42$P+I% o5F9B?99B! 5I! ;A9! 6C;JO!FCZC9BO!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!?CK!PB9<;!6A<E9D?!,1*'42$P+9%396;C5:!T!65:?C?;?!5I!<6657:;?!@CFC@9@! C:!?CK!E<B;?2! ;A9! ICB?;!

=DD)! W^W[G! >9C:P! <! DC?;! 5I! >5<;! 9\7CE89:;! B969CF9@! ;AB57PA!

;A9! <P9:6J! 5I! 5$25".0O! ;A9! ?965:@! =DD)! W"^[]G! <! >BC9I!C:?;B76;C5:! B9P<B@C:P! ;A9! @C?E<;6AC:P! 5I!89:!LC;A! <:! $*0^F9??9DO!;A9!;ACB@!=DD)![b^"`G!<:@!;A9!I57B;A!=DD)![b^"`G! DC?;?!5I!

?7EED989:;<BJ!>5<;?!E<B;?O!;A9!ICI;A!=DD)!"]^"#G!<:@!;A9!?CK;A!

=DD)! "]^"#G! DC?;?! 5I!L55@9:!E<B;?! C:! <??56C<;C5:!LC;A! 65EE9B!

<857:;?)!

396;C5:! g! 65:;<C:?! ;A9! <6657:;! PCF9:! ;5! ;A9! @56MJ<B@!

L5BM?A5E!5I!;A9!"+2,&9%396;C5:!%!65:;<C:?!<6657:;!5I!I<6CDC;C9?!PCF9:!;5! ,;2C&0O! ;A9!65EE9B?8C;A!5I!;A9!"+2,&)!396;C5:!N!EB5FC@9?!<!@<CDJ!B5?;9B!I5B![[V!@<J?2!5EE5?C;9!9<6A!

@<J!9:;BJ!<B9!ICP7B9?!<BB<:P9@!C:!ICF9!;5!9CPA;!65D78:?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%T!D)!W`G%.*-0%*4+0%+.$%7*0%%T!D)!WWG%#&-0%,->0%*4+%7*0%%g!D)![G%+)'%-('<%8+.:<'%+%0)+'%*'%"+2,&%%%/!D)![G%$(<02+%"+%*0%"+2,&%*'<0%(%'&20+%%%/!D)!"G%$+%*9'*%+.$'%7,P9'09'*%,&,&9'09'*%p&D'E9*9$%*9'09'*%-*,%+.$'%#).$%#0'%AQR%DNE%7,P%S#%-*,%%%%/!D)!]G%K%DNE%;p&%7,P%-*,%AR9RRR%DNE%'+%+%7*0%-+%0,%#%$(9'*%*;%(C%$"9$%#'%+%7*0!%

!-55@!\7<DC;J!<6<6C<!.*-0!;A9!7*0!PCF9?!!#&-0O!<857:;O!P55@!\7<DC;J!5I!;A9!7*0!!%:!5B@9B!;5!;A9!?;9L<B@?!5I!;A9!"+2,&%LA5!<B9!C:!;A9!'AC:C;9!:589!!'A9!?;9L<B@?!5I!;A9!"+2,&%LA5!<B9!C:!;A9!'AC:C;9!:589!!399!;A<;!J57!?A<F9!J57B?9DF9?!<:@!8<J!J57!EB9E<B9!<665B@C:P!;5!9F9BJ!LAC6A!(!5B@9B9@!;5!J57O!<:@!?9:@!@5L:?;B9<8!Wb`!=qG!-P&'!5I!LA9<;O!!@57>D9!=qG!-P&'!8<D;!<:@!W`)```!=qG!'+^D5<F9?!;5!;A9!7*0!I5B!9<6A!5:9!J57)!(!?A<DD!B96M5:!C;!<;!;A9%7*0!

Page 19: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! "_"!

%-!D)!WG%$(<02+%"+%*0%"+2,&%*'<0%(%'&20+%%%-!D)![^"G%$+%S+'%*&%*%$(<02+%"+%*'<D0E%8+:%$''%$(00%*0%,++<'%*'%"+2,&%%%!D)!"`G%.$%*94%-('<%"+2,&%%N!D)![G%,-,0%)%0)+'%*'%"+2,&%%

!'A9!?;9L<B@?!5I!;A9!"+2,&%LA5!<B9!C:!;A9!'AC:C;9!:589!!U5L!<?!I5B!;A9?9!?;9L<B@?!LA5!?A<DD!;<M9!;A9!$(02>5<;?!5I!;A9!A<DD!5I!;A9!"+2,&%%-CF9!;5!AC8O!;A9!65EE9B?8C;A!5I!;A9!"+2,&!!&5<?;9B!5I!;A9!@56MJ<B@!L5BM?A5E!5I!;A9!"+2,&%%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!3C8E?5:!W_a"^W__a2!ED)!W[O!D)![k!ED)!W`O!D)!Wk![WO!ED)!VO!D)![k!ED)!]O!D)!"`k![WO!ED)!VO!D)!

]k![#O!ED)!bO!D)!W`)!

!

! !

Page 20: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! "_]!

%)()Wa! E&9C?:9B!(((!

456789:;!;C;D9! $<EJB7?!&9C?:9B!(((!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! U<P<!9@^49CBO!')!]`V)!39?)!()!

49?6BCE;C5:! $)! &9C?:9B! (((! C?! ;A9! ;ACB@! 5I! I57B! B5DD?! I57:@! C:! 5:9! 5I! ;A9!L55@9:!65IIC:?!C:!;58>!:5)!]`V!<;!U<P<!9@^49CB)!'A9!PB9<;!E<B;! 5I! ;AC?! E<EJB7?! C?! @9F5;9@! ;5! B9E9;C;CF9! <6657:;?! 5I!L5BM89:! 98ED5J9@! @<J! >J! @<J! 5B! <??CP:9@! ;5! ;A9!8C?69DD<:957?! ;<?M?! ?E96CIC9@! >J! ;A9! A9<@C:P?)! (:! ;AC?!B9PC?;9B!5667E<;C5:?!65::96;9@!;5!;A9!"+2,&!<B9!6C;9@!;LC69)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%g!D)!W[G!&'"/4&$%)'%(%"+2,&%%4!D)![WG!+)'%-#;0%"+2,&I%KRR%-#;0!

!

,:9!LA5!6<BBC9?!L55@!C:!;A9!"+2,&%%%6657:;!5I!-#;0O!E<D<69O![``!-#;0%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!3C8E?5:!W_a"^W_VaO!(((2!$D)!_%O!W#%)!

!

! !

Page 21: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! "_b!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!W!1<BC9;;9!WV#[2!a^V)!![!l7CBM9!W__`2!WW)!"!l7CBM9!W__`2!W#)!

%)()W#! *<CB5!*-!

bV`a_!^

ET57D<\!WV!

456789:;!;C;D9! $<EJB7?!T57D<\!WV!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 4B<!%>7!9D^U<P<)!W";A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'A9! ;L5! @56789:;?! P9:9B<DDJ! M:5L:! <?! $<EJB7?! T57D<\!

L9B9! @C?65F9B9@! >J! 1<BC9;;9! @7BC:P! AC?! WVa`! ?9<?5:! 5I!

9K6<F<;C5:! <;! 4B<! %>7! 9D^U<P<k! ;A9J! L9B9! I57:@! 5:! ;A9!

PB57:@! >9AC:@! <! 65IIC:! ;5P9;A9B! LC;A! <! >7BC<D! 9\7CE89:;!

>9<BC:P! ;A9! :<89! 5I! U9I9BA5;9E)W!'A9! E<EJBC! <B9! C:! ;L5!

@CII9B9:;!A<:@?O!>7;!>5;A!89:;C5:!<!MC:P!35>9MA5;9E!<:@!<!

FCZC9B! ,*)0% <:@! 6<:! >9! <??CP:9@! ;5! ;A9! 9<BDJ! ;5! 8C@! W";A!

4J:<?;J)[!'A9! D<BP9?;!$)!T57D<\!65:;<C:?! ;A9!@<CDJ!<6657:;?!

5I! C:6589! <:@! 9KE9:@C;7B9! <;! ;A9! E<D<69! C:! 'A9>9?! 5F9B!

;L9DF9!@<J?! C:! ;A9!?965:@!<:@!;ACB@!85:;A?!5I! C:7:@<;C5:O!

J9<B! "! =EB5><>DJ! 5I! 35>9MA5;9E! ((G)"!T9;L99:! ;A9! D<?;! @<;9!

5:!;A9!65:;C:757?!+6T'U!<:@!;A9!ICB?;!@<;9!5:!;A9!V6+#U!DC9?!<!P<E! 5I! 9D9F9:!@<J?)! (;! C?! I<B! IB58! 6D9<B! ;A<;! ;A9! C:;<6;! ;9K;!

L57D@!5BCPC:<DDJ!A<F9! C:6D7@9@!9:;BC9?! I5B!9<6A!@<J?!5I! ;A9!

8C??C:P!9D9F9:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%3![Wk![bk![Vk!"Wk!]Wk!]"k!]_k%+6T'U!bVk!a]G%%%.$%+%"+2,&%(%,P%*%0."00%)*'<%%%(*'%*'%!*,%..'%*%+('%"+%(*%,0'%%%(*'%*'%!*,%..'%*%,P<0%,!&%%%3!W[G!

!

.$%+%"+2,&%(%,P%*%0."00%)*'<%%%

!

!

!

49DCF9B9@!;5!;A9!"+2,&%<;!;A9!<BBCF<D!5I!;A9!67E>9<B9B?!5I!;A9!,7;9B!$<D<69!

!

cCK9@!E5B;C5:!5I!;A9!EB5FC?C5:C:P^\7<B;9B?!

PCF9:!;5!;A9!E95ED9!5I!;A9!A57?9!5I!:7B?9?!

!

cCK9@!E5B;C5:!5I!;A9!EB5FC?C5:C:P^\7<B;9B?!

PCF9:!;5!;A9!5B@C:<BJ!9:;B<:;?!

!

!

!

49DCF9B9@!;5!;A9!"+2,&%<;!;A9!<BBCF<D!5I!;A9!67E>9<B9B?!5I!;A9!,7;9B!$<D<69!

!

Page 22: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! "_a!

!

!

! !

(*'%*'%,P0%..'%*%+('%"+%(*,0'%%%(*'%*'%,P<0%,!&%..0%*94%(%!*,%%%%%%3!aO!W]O!WVO![[O![aO![#O![_O!"#O!]aO!a"O!#WG%%DW"0'E%$$'9*%$(<2+%,7*0'<%*%C&"%?*942(2$;%-+9#%(%"+'9*94%-+9#%%!

!

D0"0'E%$$'9*%#!%*%)*'<%5*;<%-+9#%(%"+'9*%0."0%@X&2$;%-+9#%%%%3!"ak!a`k!#]G!

,P0%(%0&)<%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%)'4%0.%)*'<%$*0%*%+,%"*%%

cCK9@!E5B;C5:!5I!EB5FC?C5:?!PCF9:!;5!;A9!

E95ED9!5I!;A9!A57?9!5I!:7B?9?!

!

cCK9@!E5B;C5:!5I!;A9!5B@C:<BJ!9:;B<:;?!

B9P7D<BDJ!?7EEDC9@!=qG!IB58!;A9!EB5FC?C5:C:P^

\7<B;9B!

!

!

!

=;A9!6588C??C5:G!7E5:!LAC6A!6<89!;A9!

C:;9BC5B!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!C::9B!E<D<69O!>9C:P!

=;A9!6588C??C5:G!7E5:!LAC6A!A9!A<@!;5!

6589!I5B;A!

=;A9!6588C??C5:G!7E5:!LAC6A!6<89!;A9!

?6BC>9!5I!;A9!,7;9B!$<D<69!39:>J!O!>9C:P!=;A9!

6588C??C5:G!7E5:!LAC6A!;A9!67E>9<B9B!

X9\<C>!A<@!6589!I5B;A!

!

!

$B5FC?C5:?!I5B!;A9%0&)<!5I!;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)!!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!

36A<BII!W_[[O!ED?)!W]^WbO!W#O!WV^W_k!W_^[`k![`^[[k!["^[bk![a^[#k![#^[Vk![_k![_^"`k!"]^"ak!]`^

]"k!]"^]])!!

1<BC9;;9!WVa#2!ED)!"`)[k![a)Wk![O!ED)!b]k![O!ED)!"]k!ED)!"`)[k!ED)![#)[^[Vk![W)[^[[k!ED)!WV)W]k!ED)!

WV)Wk!F5D)![!ED)!][)[)!

$1!W2[O!a`])!

Page 23: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! "_#!

%)()WV! ETB55MDJ:!

"b)W]]a!

456789:;!;C;D9! &5J<D!9@C6;!<@@B9??9@!;5!;A9!FCZC9B!,*)0!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 'A9>9?W)!35>M)!((!=qG)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'A9! E<EJB7?! 65:;<C:?! ?9F9:! ;9K;?! 5I! F<BJC:P! D9:P;A! <:@!

?65E92! ;L5! ;9K;?! 5:! ;A9! +6T'U! <B9! <! E<CB! 5I! B5J<D! @96B99?!LAC6A! L9B9! C:?9B;9@! C:;5! ;A9! ?E<69?! D9I;! IB99! <I;9B! ;A9!

658ED9;C5:! 5I! ;A9! 8<C:! B9PC?;9B)! 'A9! ;L5! @96B99?! <B9!

<@@B9??9@!;5!,*)0O!<!FCZC9B!LA5!?998?!;5!>9!C@9:;CIC9@!LC;A!

;A9! FCZC9B! C:! ET57D<\! WV! LA5! L5BM9@! @7BC:P! ;A9! B9CP:! 5I!

35>9MA5;9E!(()!!(I!B9?;5B<;C5:!5I!;A9!ICB?;!@96B99!C?!<669E;9@O!

>5;A! @56789:;?! L9B9! ?9:;! ;5! ;A9!)&% *%0-(0% *% *$0'% +#'O!o;A9! >7B9<7! 5I! ;A9! B9E5B;9B! 5I! ;A9! ?57;A9B:! 6C;Jr[)! 'A9!

?7>d96;!5I!>5;A!@96B99?!C?!;A9!?<89!C:@CFC@7<DO!<!69B;<C:!M&<I%LA5!L<?! <EE<B9:;DJ! P7CD;J! 5I! ?589!5II9:69! <P<C:?;! <!8<:!

>J!;A9!:<89!5I!5,*)0Y9%%%)!(:?9B;C5:!T!5:!;A9%+6T'U%T)!(:?9B;C5:!*!5:!;A9!+6T'U!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)!D)!aG%#"+9*%D)#G%#(#0%7&<8':%,1;$%#&%?(*<2,*)%%D)!VG%+%..%C&D0E'%(%#!%$+D0E%$&'%D)!_G%*#0'%-#0'%(%7+D<E%-&'<%)*'%+('%%%D)W`G%'CCD0E%(2,%+0$%%5,*)0%%D)!WWG%M&<%(%+.$'%$*9'094%+%7*0%%D)!W[G%0!.9$'094%-+%"&%'CC%$+9*94%%D)W"G%(.094%*#0'%(2,DCE%#'%#.(9%D)!W]G%$%$*9'094%(%#&0%*#0'%%D)!WbG%+%7*0%%T)!D)bG%+%..%899:%'&8(:0%DNE%(%"+89:$%(%.&$D'E%DNE%+('%*%7*0%(%'&0'%DNE%+%$&'2#)'<0%5B!)'%#&-0DNE%%%D)!aG%+.$9*9$%(%)&%*%..%+(8'%7*(0:%M&<%*%0&'%DNE%(%+.$'%.$9'0%*9$%+%+('%7*(0a%%(.094%*#0'%%%%%%D)!#G%(2,C%#.(%(%$+'%(2,8C:%(.0%$+<0%+.$'%$)%+.$'9C%&0$%$0%*'<%(%7*0%$)%$+9C%&0$%'0%-+%

!'A9!9D@9B!5I!;A9!E5B;<D!,1;$!?5:!5I!?(*<2,*)!A<?!E9;C;C5:9@!?<JC:P2!8<J!<!658eED<C:;!C:qf!LBC;C:P!=qG!>9!8<@9!>J!PB<69!!5I!;A9!MC:PQ?!I<Fe5Bf!<P<C:?;!;A9!<6657:;<:;!=qG!C:!6A<BP9!5I!=qG!EBC?5:9B?!LA5!A<?!6588C;;9@!<!FC5D<;C5:!<P<C:?;!;A9!I7PC;CF9!5,*)0!M&<O!6<7?C:P!AC8!;5!>9!>B57PA;!;5!;A9!7*0!<:@!\79?;C5:9@!65:69B:C:P!;A9!FC5D<;C5:!LAC6A!A9!A<?!6588C;;9@!?5!A9!?<C@)!T9A5D@O!C;!A<?!>99:!A9<B@)!*<7?9!;A<;!A9!>9!>B57PA;!7:@9B!P7<B@!=qG!!;5!;A9!7*0!!!3<JC:P!C:?5D9:;!5:9?!=qG!<B9!C:!e8Jf!@58<C:!=qG!;B<:?E5B;C:P!=qG!E95ED9!;5!;A9!7*0%C:%;A9!?9CZ7B9%DNE%!;5!$&'2#)'<0]/C:!;A9!6A<BP9!5I!=qG%5I!8J!9?;<;9^L5BM9B?!=qGb!!+9;!;A9B9!>9!PCF9:!;5!89!IB58!;A9!5IIC69!5I!;A9!$B5FC@9B^5I^E95EDe9!;A9!898>9B?f!5I!;A9!A57?9A5D@!5I!M&<O!;A9!<667B?9@!=qGO!D9;;C:P!=;A98G!>9!PCF9:!;5!;A9!898>9B?!5I!8J!A57?9A5D@)!35!A9!?<C@!!T9A5D@O!LA<;!A<F9!>99:!@5:9!A<F9!>99:!A9<B@)!T9eA5fD@!;A9!5B@9B?=qG!E9B;<C:C:P!

Page 24: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! "_V!

%%%%D)!VG%$+0%$0%*'<%(%*$0'2+#'%$)%$+9C%+94%!%

;A9B9;52!+9;!AC8!!LA5!C?!C:!;A9%7*0!6589=qG)!'A9:!?A<DD!J57!6<7?9!=<!@CB96;CF9G!;5!>9!C??79@!=65:69B:C:PG))!!'A9!E95ED9!;A9B95I)!+9;!AC8!LA5!C?!C:!;A9!357;A9B:!*C;J!6589?)!'A9:!?A<DD!J57!;<M9!<6;C5:!<P<C:?;!AC8)!

U5;9?2!W!X<J9?!W_bb2!Wa^#)![!l7CBM9!W__`2!W]W)!"!X<J9?!W_bb2!#[^"k!#a^#k!VW)!l7CBM9!I5DD5L?!X9D6MQ?!;B<:?6BCE;C5:!5I!;A9!9KEB9??C5:!<;!D)!W`^

WWO!#,*)0%0$%"&<9$%8*;:%(%+.$'%;5!>9!;B<:?D<;9@!oB9@998!89!8J!e+5B@fr)!5,*)0!<:@!M&<!L57D@!:5;!>9!E9B?5:<D!:<89?!>7;!F9B>?!C:!;A9!d7?;!6C;9@!EAB<?9!LAC6A!L57D@!>9D5:P!;5!<!

?E96CIC6!I5B87D<!I5B!E9;C;C5:C:P!<!?7E9BC5BO!C:!l7CBM9!W__`2!W][!6C;C:P!X9D6M!W_#b<2!WW^[O!

:5?)!Wa^W#)%]!X<J9?!W__b2!##)!b!l7CBM9!W__`2!W]b)!a!#,*)%0$%"&<9$%*;DNE%(%+.$'%.$9'0%*9$%+%.;&0I%oB9@998!89O!1J!+5B@O!>J!A<FC:P!89!PCF9:!

=E95ED9qG!I5B!B9ED<6989:;?r!C:!l7CBM9Q?!;B<:?6BCE;C5:?2!l7CBM9!W__`2!W]b)!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!X<J9?!W_bb>2!#W^[O!ED)!bO!C:?9B;!TO!D)!WWsWb)!!

X9D6M!W_#b<2!WW)!

!

! !

Page 25: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! "__!

!

%)()W_! ET1!W`#ba!

E&<89??978!

(((!

456789:;!;C;D9! $<EJB7?!&<89??978!(((!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 'A9>9?O!&<89??978)!W";A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'AC?! E<EJB7?! C?! E<B;! 5I! <! ?9BC9?! 5I!8<PC6<DO!89@C6<DO! BC;7<D!

<:@!DC;9B<BJ!;9K;?!IB58!<!L55@9:!>5K!I57:@!C:!5:9!PB<F9!5I!

;A9! D<;9!1C@@D9!NC:P@58! ;58>?!@C?65F9B9@!>J!l7C:>9DD! C:!

WV_a!7:@9B!;A9!EB96C:6;?!5I! ;A9!&<89??978)!'A9!V6+#U%5I!$<EJB7?! &<89??978! (((! 65:?C?;?! 5I! ;AB99! 65D78:?! 5I! @<J!

<6657:;O! <:@! <! ?A5B;! :5;9! I<B;A9B! 5:! C:! ;A9! B5DD)! %DD! C;98?!

@<;9!;5!J9<B!a!5I!<:!7::<89@!MC:P)!'A9!<6657:;?!65:69B:!

@C?;BC>7;C5:?! 5I! <! F<BC9;J! 5I! 65885@C;C9?! C:6D7@C:P!(+-'O!o5CDr!=D)!WWGO!#(0O!oF9P9;<>D9?r!=D)!abGO!ID57B!<:@!PB<C:!=D)!a"^]O! aaO! #WO! #]^bO! #V^_G)! T9;L99:! ;A9! >9:9IC6C<BC9?! 5I! ;A9?9!

@C?;BC>7;C5:?!<B9!89:;C5:9@!<!E9B?5:<D!9?;<;9!^!"+$9$O!o8<J!

9?;<;9r!=D)!V[GO!;A9!7:?E96CIC6!(7+O!o?;5B9A57?9r!=DD)!Wb!<:@![[G!<:@!;A9%7*0!<;!D)!W_)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!WVG%,P0%DNE%#*0%*%H&2(+$%%D)!W_G%.$%*%7*0%

!

[!EB5FC?C5:?!=qG!5I!/PJE;!

!

;5!>9!PCF9:!;5!;A9!7*0%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!T<B:!W_ba2!ED)![]O!D)!W_)!!

-<B@C:9B!W_bb2!ED)!a"^])!$1!b2WO!aa)!

*5889:;2!l7CBM9!W__`2!W_]^b)!

!

! !

Page 26: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]``!

%)(()W! X<88<8<;!

]`!

456789:;!;C;D9! &56M!C:?6BCE;C5:!5I!>1"$2#&2$"$%$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! X<888<8<;)!19:;)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! &56M! C:?6BCE;C5:! 658E5?9@! >J! 5:9! A5BCZ5:;<D! C:?6BCE;C5:!<:@!I57B!F9B;C6<D?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!"G%-+<%-+<0%(,&'%*;'%!"##'%*'%"+2*#0'%

!

%B;C?<:!C:!9F9BJ!65?;DJ!?;5:9!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!

$7>>DC6<;C5:2!*57J<;!h!15:;9;!W_W[2!]a^#O!:5)!]`O!ED)!WW)!!

+9E?C7?!W_#"O!((2!W]_!A)!

*5889:;2!S<B@!W_V[2!:5)!__#)!

!

! !

Page 27: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]`W!

%)(()[! 11%!b#)_b!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!>1*2$'94%$+%*%H4$%=>1*2$'94%?5:!5I!H4$G!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 'A9>9?)!19:;)!((!

49?6BCE;C5:! &96;<:P7D<B! ?;9D9! LC;A! 65B:C69! 65:;<C:C:P! 5:9! DC:9! 5I!

C:?6BCE;C5:)! (:?C@9! ;A9! IB<89! <! #! A5BCZ5:;<D! DC:9?! C:?6BCE;C5:!

@9F9D5E?! 5F9B! <:@! 5:! ;A9! BCPA;! ?C@9! 5I! ;A9! B9EB9?9:;<;C5:!

LC;A! ;A9!@969<?9@! <:@!AC?!LCI9! ?A5L:! ?9<;9@! <;! <! ;<>D9!5I!

5II9BC:P?! C:! IB5:;! 5I! [! B9PC?;9B?! LC;A! 5II9BC:P^>9<B9B?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:?!IB58!;A9!9:6D5?9@!E5B;C5:!5I!;A9!?;9D9)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!WG%)*'<%$&0'%(%"+2*#0'%%D)![G%$(<2$;%*%*#0'%(%,-94%

%D)![G%$0%*94%0+0%(%C#0(%C#0%+%+0'<%"+2*#0'%

%%%

D)!"G%'"<2,0<%!*0'%'C*%(%,-%%%%D)!]G%+)%#'2+.94%(%"+2*#0'%

!

c5B985?;!5I!5IIC69?!C:!;A9%"+2*#0'!!

(:;C8<;9!5I!;A9!MC:P!C:!AC?!,-!!

,:9!;5!LA58!;A9!PB9<;!5:9?!5I!;A9!U5B;A!

<:@!;A9!357;A!6589!>5LC:P!<;!;A9!P<;9?!5I!

;A9!"+2*#0'%!!

,:9!LA5!EB969@9?!AC?!9:;57B<P9!C:!;A9!,-%!

,:9!LA5!M:5L?!AC?!?;<:@C:P!C:!;A9%"+2*#0'%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!cC?6A9B!W_a`2![bV!II)!I)!W^[O!ED)!#O!D)!b^a^#^V)!!

36A9:M9D!W_ab2!["a^["V)!

$1!W2[O!VW`)!

*5889:;2!45K9J!W__V2!W[]O!W#[O![b]O!"bbO!"_W)!!

!

!

! !

Page 28: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]`[!

%)(()"! 8*<CB5!

")a)[b)W!

456789:;!;C;D9! cB<P89:;<BJ!?;9D9!!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 4B<!%>7!9D^U<P<)!19:;)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! cB<P89:;! 5I! <! ?;9D9! >9D5:PC:P! ;5! <! 65:;98E5B<BJ! 5I!

19:;7A5;9E!((!IB58!4B<!%>7!9D^U<P<)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!]G%0*%*%"+2*#0'%,'94%*;%7+%#'%-+<%#+0.%"+2*#0'%%

!

,:9!LA5!C?!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%C:!AC?!6A<8>9BO!

+5B@!5I!;A9!?9<;O!5:9!LA5!C?!<;!;A9!A9<@!5I!

;A9!65:;B5DD9B?!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

*DiB9!h!Y<:@C9B!W_]V2!]]O!t!"`O!D)!])!!

36A9:M9D!W_ab2!["_)!

$1!W2[O!b_a)!

!! !

Page 29: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]`"!

%)(()]! 3A<;;!9B!

&CP<D!]b_!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!=+0%!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3A<;;!9B!&CP<D)!19:;)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! -B<IIC;5!6<BF9@!5:!;A9!?57;A9B:!?C@9!5I!;A9!F<DD9J!5I!3A<;;!9B!

&CP<D)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%$0%*94%0+0%(%C#0(%C#0%+%+0'<%"+2*#0'%

!

,:9!;5!LA58!;A9!PB9<;!5:9?!5I!;A9!U5B;A!

<:@!;A9!357;A!6589O!>5LC:P!<;!;A9!P<;9?!5I!

;A9!"+2*#0'!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!SC:D56M!W_]#2!aVO!ICP)!"_O!WP)!!

*5889:;2!45K9J!W__V2![b])!

!! !

Page 30: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]`]!

%)(()b! .*!W]"""!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!=*2'02-'"I%85:<B6A!5I!X9B85:;AC?!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %B8<:;!q)!19:;)!((!=qG!

49?6BCE;C5:! &96;<:P7D<B! DC89?;5:9! ?;9D9! ?7BB57:@9@! >J! <! >D56M^>5B@9B!

?A5LC:P!;A9!5L:9B!?;<:@C:P!LC;A!<!?;<II!<:@!<!?69E;9B!C:!AC?!

A<:@?k!>9I5B9!AC8!;A9B9!C?!<!Wa!DC:9?!C:?6BCE;C5:O!LAC6A!?;<B;?!

<?! <! EB<J9B! C:F5MC:P! ,?CBC?! <:@! 65:;C:79?! <?! <:!

<7;5>C5PB<EAJ)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%%"^]G%(+0'D9$E%(%7'%*'%#(+0%0+%,-%),0%$(%,Z%-+%*;94%0+0%7+%"-0<94!$+<%#;)'%(%$,+'%DNE%;0%*'<%-(%"++D9$E%$(%$;%0&!%

!

+5F9!5I!89!L<?!C:!;A9!>5@J!5I!;A9!657B;C9B?O!

;A9!PB9<;!5:9!5I!;A9!,-O!<:@!AC8!LA5!L<?!

9:;AB5:9@W!;A9B9)!(!L<?!5:9!LA5!9:;9B9@!;A9!

P<;9L<J!C:!;A9!EB9?9:69!5I!AC?!+5B@!=LC;AG!

;A9!PB9<;!5:9?!>9AC:@!AC8O!;A9!@55BM99E9B?!

>5LC:P!C:!;A9!ED<69!LA9B9!XC?!1<d9?;J!L<?)!

(;!L<?!LC;A!;A9!A9<B;!9K<D;9@!;A<;!(!9:;9B9@!

;A9B9!

!

U5;9?2!+C;9B<BCDJ2!),0I%o;5!<EE9<B!C:!PD5BJrO!c*42!WVb)!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!3;9L<B;!W_#a^V"O!((2![`O!:5)!VaO!ED)!WV)!!

-59@C6M9!W_a[<2![b!II)O!ED)![)!

*5889:;2!45K9J!W__V2!"W`)!

!! !

Page 31: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]`b!

%)(()a! 8N5E9:<PA9:!

U*-!%/(U!V_W!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!?;9D9!5I!>1*'4!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 4B<!%>7!9D^U<P<)!19:;)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! cB<P89:;?!5I!<!?;9D9!65:;<C:C:P!W]!DC:9?!C:?6BCE;C5:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

D)!aG%,P%7*%,-%0+%#(+0%%

!

,:9!LA5!9:;9B!C:!;A9!,-I%;A9!PB9<;!5:9!5I!;A9!658E<:C5:?!

!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!15P9:?9:!W_"`2!_[^"O!ED)!_V)!!

*DiB9!h!Y<:@C9B!W_]V2!]b^a)!!

36A9:M9D!W_ab2!["[)!$1!W2[O!b_#)!

!! !

Page 32: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]`a!

%)(()#! 3A<;;!9B!

&CP<D!]#"!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!W#$2*+%!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3A<;;!9B!&CP<D)!19:;)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! -B<IIC;5!6<BF9@!5:!;A9!?57;A9B:!?C@9!5I!;A9!F<DD9J!5I!3A<;;!9B!

&CP<D)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%(.-%S*0'<%(%,-%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!?67DE;5B?!C:!;A9!,-!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!SC:D56M!W_]#2!aVO!ICP)!"_O!WP)!!

*5889:;2!45K9J!W__V2![b])!

!! !

Page 33: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]`#!

%)(()V! X<;:7>![]!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!O&<!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! X<;:7>O!PB)![])!19:;)!(Y)!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!C:!;A9!8<C:!6A<8>9B!<;!;A9!?C@9!5I!;A9!

B9EB9?9:;<;C5:!5I!;A9!5L:9B)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)![G%+)%*#0'%-*,%P*;'94%%D)!#^VG%**%(!,9#*%(%+C%#*.%*%"+2*#0'%$0%*%-(%*%*$0'%+,%#0&!%(2,%-+'%(+%+'*'%"+2*#0'%%%

!

%6\7<C:;<:69!5I!;A9!MC:P!<:@!AC?!P*;'!!

'A9J!A<@!:5!8<@9!:5!6<8E<CP:!C:!;A9!;C89!

5I!I9<B!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'[%(!;<M9!<L<J!IB58!;A9!

6C;J!5:!;A9!@<J!5I!B5>>9BC9?!<L<J!IB58!;A9!

L5B;A!A5BB5B!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'!%

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!%:;A9?!W_[V2!b]O!ED)![])!!

*5889:;2!45K9J!W__V2!Waa)!!!

!! !

Page 34: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]`V!

%)(()_! X<;:7>![b!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!F-+<!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! X<;:7>O!PB)![b)!19:;)!(Y)!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!C:!;A9!8<C:!6A<8>9B)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!"G%-+$%*%7*0%7+%#)+%..94%%%%D)!#G![99]%$;%*%7*0%(-%()"!94%%D)!W"G%$(<2+%"+2*#0'%*'%).$%)*'$%%

!

*5:;9:;!C:!;A9!7*0!5F9B!;A9!657:?9D!5I!LA<;!?<C@!>J!AC8!

!

e))f!;A9!A9<B;!C:!;A9!7*0%C?!I7DD!>J!AC?!<B8!!

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'I%5:9!LA5!I<B9?!@5L:?;B9<8!<:@!?<CD?!7E?;B9<8!

!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!%:;A9?!W_[V2!b#^VO!ED)![aO!:5)![bO!D)!W")!

!! !

Page 35: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]`_!

%)(()W`! X<88<8<;!

WW"!

456789:;!;C;D9! -B<IIC;5!IB58!;A9!S<@C^X<88<8<;!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! X<88<8<;)!19:;)!(YO!R)![)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

D)!W[G%)'(0%"+2,&%)'(0%*;%*'%"+2-.%$&'%*;'%*'%"+2*#0'%%

!

39<D9B!5I!;A9!"+2,&I%?9<D9B!5I!<DD!LA<;!C?!C:!;A9!"+2-.I%5IIC69!5I!9F9BJ;AC:P!C?!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!*57J<;!h!15:;9;!W_W[2!E)!V`O!:5)!WW"O!ED)![_O!D)!W[)!!

36A9:M9D!W_ab2![aa)!!

TB9<?;9@!W_`a^`#O!W2!t!]]]^V)!!

$1!#2WO!""W)!!!

!! !

Page 36: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]W`!

%)(()WW! X<;:7>!W]!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!F'+2-'"!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! X<;:7>O!PB)!W])!WW;A!4J:)!=qG!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!C:!;A9!8<C:!6A<8>9B)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!#G%$+'%#C(%*%$;9$%(%$"0'%*%"+2*#0'%%%%D)!VG%P*;0'%*'%"+2*#0'%-,$%%%D)!_G%(+0'9$%*;9$%(%7*0%.&.&'%DNE%"+%%%D)!W[G%+.$%"+%#*0<%-'"%(%0"'%[*'%P*;']%+)%#*.9$%(%7*0%,7*0'<%%

!

(!@C@!?9BFC69!I5B!1J!+5B@!C:!;A9!8C??C5:?!

5IHI5B!;A9!"+2*#0'%!

'A9!8<PC?;B<;9?!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'%B9d5C69!!

(!L<?!D5F9@!>J!1J!+5B@!C:!;A9!7*0%5I!;A9!A57?9!5I!;A9!8<PC?;B<;9?!=qG!

!

,:9!LA5!6<7?9@!;A<;!;L5!E99B?!P5!?<;C?IC9@!

LC;A!;A9!F9B@C6;!5I!;A9!P*;'O!5:9!LA5!M:5L?!;A9!C:?C@9!5I!;A9!,7*0'<!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!%:;A9?!W_[V2!"[^"O!ED)!W#O!:5)!W]O!D)!#^V)!!! !

Page 37: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]WW!

%)(()W[! 3<\\<B<!W!

456789:;!;C;D9! cB<P89:;!5I!<!?;9D9!LC;A!;A9!:<89!5I!>1*;2$(<!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3<\\<B<)!W`;A!4J:)!=qG!

49?6BCE;C5:! cB<P89:;!5I!<!?;9D9!IB58!3<\\<B<)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)![G%('<%*%"+2,&%

!

$B96C?9!C:!;A9!"+2,&%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!l7C>9DD!WVa#^W_"b2!ED)!V)])!!

$1!"2[O!ba])!

! !

Page 38: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]W[!

%)(()W"! T9B?A9A!b!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!,-&2*2)*'!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! T9B?A9AO!')!b)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58!=W`HWW;A!4J:)qG)!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:?!C:!<:@!<B57:@!;A9!9:;B<:69!;5!;A9!;58>)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

D)!W[G!$0%*94%,&'%-+<2'"%@'2*;0%(-%$;%*%*#0'%,&%-&%7*0%)#4%(%7&P02$;%!

!

D)!W]G!)*'<%#'%(%"+2*#0'%%

!

$B96C57?!?;5:9!6589?!;5!AC8O!;A9!6AC9I!5I!@'2*;0!?<;C?IJC:P!;A9!9<B;A!5I!;A9!MC:PO!;A9!@55B!>9AC:@!;A9!7*0%E7:C?AC:P!;A9!B9>9DDC57?!!

c5B985?;!5I!E5?C;C5:!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'!

U5;9?2!/EC;A9;?!>9PC::C:P!LC;A!)*'<!?;!<:@!)*'<%*%#'%<B9!B9D<;CF9DJ!65885:!<:@!8<J!<EE9<B!

LC;A57;!85@CIC9B?!5B!I5DD5L9@!>J!<!D56<;C5:O!5I;9:!65::96;9@!LC;A!;A9!E<D<69O!C:!LAC6A!;A9!

5IIC6C<D!?9BF9@)!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!U9L>9BBJ!WV_"O!((2!ED)!"]O!ED)!W"O!D)!W[!<:@!W])!

*5889:;2!45K9J!W__V2!W#")!

3C8E?5:!h!4<FC9?!W_V`2!WV)!

!! !

Page 39: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]W"!

%)(()W]! T9B?A9A!V!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!!,-&!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! T9B?A9AO!'!V)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58!=W`HWW;A!4J:)qG!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:?!5:!;A9!D9I;!A<:@!5I!;A9!L<DD)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!bG%-#0'9$%(*'%(%,7*0'<%%%D)!_G%)"+9C0$%(%-#$%(&,%#;&0%*%(#0%*#0'%%%

!

1J!I<F5BHEB<C?9!L<?!65:;C:757?!C:!;A9!

,7*0'<!!

(!>96<89!<?!5:9!;B7DJ!EB<C?9@O!;A9!C:?;B76;5B!

5I!;A9!6ACD@B9:!5I!;A9!MC:PO!5:9!LA5!M:5L?!

;A9!>7?C:9??!C:!;A9!,-!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!U9L>9BBJ!WV_]O!((2!"_^]`O!ED)![WO!D)!b!<:@!_)!!

$1!]2!WO!WV[)!

'B<:?D<;C5:2!45K9J!W__V2!""b)!

!! !

Page 40: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]W]!

!%)(()Wb! 39<D!]Wa!!^!

T1!aa#[V!=9K!

3E9:69B^

*A7B6CDD!

*5DD96;C5:G!

456789:;!;C;D9! 39<D!5I!W+2*;%$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:!=9K!3E9:69B^*A7B6ACDD!*5DD96;C5:G)!WW;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%$+<2,'%*%"+2,&%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!"+2,&%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!1<B;C:!W_#W2!:5)!]WaO!ED)!W]O!WV)!!$9;BC9!W_Wa2!W"O![`!*5889:;2!S<B@!W_V[2!:5)!]#a)!

! !

Page 41: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]Wb!

%)(()Wa! 39<D!:5)!W`[!h!

1C6A<9DC@C?!

*5DD96;C5:!=9K!

TD<:6A<B@;!

65DD96;C5:G!

456789:;!;C;D9! 39<D!5I!>1;%$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! *D<J!?9<D!C8EB9??C5:!IB58!%E<B;89:;!W#!=&558!V]G)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%-+<2"+%*%"+2,&%

!

1<d5B@585H@589?;C6!?9BF<:;!5I!;A9!"+2,&%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!1<B;C:!W_#W2!:5)!W`[O!ED)!VO!])!!*5889:;2!S<B@!W_V[2!:5)!_V")!

!! !

Page 42: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]Wa!

%)(()W#! X<;:7>!Wa!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!F-+<2#!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! X<;:7>O!PB)!Wa)!WW;A!4J:)!=qG!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!C:!;A9!8<C:!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!;58>)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!WG%$(<2+%*$0'%'&'<%#&;%$(<2+%G(,0%-&'<2,%-&'<02,%(%"+2*#0'%%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6C;JO!FCZC9BO!@CP:C;<BJO!

5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!.EE9B!/PJE;!EBC:69!5I!;A9!

EBC:69?!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!%:;A9?!W_[V2!"b^#O!ED)!WaO!:5)!WaO!D)!W)!!! !

Page 43: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]W#!

%)(()WV! X<;:7>!["!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!\-0'<2*)'%]!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! X<;:7>O!PB)![")!%8)!()!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!C:!;A9!8<C:!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!;58>)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!]G%$0%*%-(%*9$%*$0'9$%+,%#0&%!%(2,%-+'%(+%+'*'%"+2*#0'%%

!

(!;<M9!<L<J!IB58!;A9!6C;J!5:!;A9!@<J!5I!;A9!B5>>9BC9?!<L<J!IB58!;A9!L5B?;!A5BB5B?!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!%:;A9?!W_[V2!b[^"O!ED)![`O!:5)![")D)!])!!! !

Page 44: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]WV!

%)(()W_! X<;:7>!"W!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!\-0'<2*)'!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! X<;:7>)!%8)!()!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!C:!;A9!8<C:!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!;58>)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!#G%$+'%,*)%*%"+2*#0'%%

!

1<@9!C:!DCI9!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'!%

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!%:;A9?!W_[V2!a#O!ED)![_O!:5)!"W!

!! !

Page 45: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]W_!

%)(()[`! 3<\\<B<!WW3\!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;<;79!5I!^'"!!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3<\\<B<)!%8)!()!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:! 5:! ;A9! ?9<;! 5I! ;A9! ?;<;79! 5I! ^'"% IB58! AC?!

8<?;<><!<;!3<\\<B<k!WW!?A5B;!A5BCZ5:;<D! DC:9?!5I! C:?6BCE;C5:!

C:!;A9!IB5:;O!>9;L99:!;A9!D9P?)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

D)!_G!$0*%G(,0%*%"+2*#0'%%!!

!

$CDD<B!5I!.EE9B!/PJE;C<:!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!cCB;A^-7::!W_[a2![#"^##O!ED)!VWO[)!!

*5889:;2!45K9J!W__V2![bb)!!

S<B@!W_V[2!:5)!W#)!

!! !

Page 46: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ][`!

%)(()[W! 3<\\<B<!WV0!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!Q1-<<%!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3<\\<B<)!%8)!()!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)!(:?6BCE;C5:?!5:!;A9!I<D?9!@55B!5I!Q1-<<%%T)!(:?6BCE;C5:?!5:!;A9!:5B;A9B:!?;<;79!5I!Q1-<<I%IB<P89:;!:5)!

#)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%%)!!

D)![G%-+<2#!'&%*%"+2*#0'%%6)![G%$0*%G(,0%*%"+2*#0'%%T)!

#(+%,&%*%"+2*#0'%%

!

!

N99E9B!5I!?96B9;?!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'%!!

.EE9B!/PJE;C<:!ECDD<B!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'!!

!

-B9<;!658E<:C5:!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!cCB;A^-7::!W_[a2![V`^V"O!ED)!V"k!VbO!:5)!#)!

*5889:;2!45K9J!W__V2!WW"O![bb)!!

cC?6A9B!W_Vb2!["O!:u!W``]6)!""O!:u!W[_V6)!!

S<B@!W_V[2!:5)!W#O!W`Wa)!

!! !

Page 47: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ][W!

%)(()[[! X<88<8<;!-!

aW!

456789:;!;C;D9! -B<IIC;5!5I!W-(0%>1(*<!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! S<@C!X<88<8<;)!%8)!(!h!39?)!()!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'A9! C:?6BCE;C5:! B9I9B?! ;5! ;A9! 9KE9@C;C5:! ;5! ;A9! S<@C!

X<88<8<;!7:@9B!%89:98A<;!(!<:@!39?5?;BC?!()!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

D)!W`G!(!,%"*%'(%7+%#'%-+9$%-+%$+'!..'9$%*;'%#!(%*;%0.9$%%*94%(%C&0'%*;'%*'%"+2*#0'%%%D)![WG!!.'00%#'#0%';0'%0+-%(%,*0%!+0%*;%*%C&0'%*%$&0'%*;'%*'%"+2*#0'%(%"+2-.%*%*;%,*)%0.&%#*;!

!

'AC?!658ED9;9!<B8J!C?!7:@9B!8J!65:;B5D!<:@!

9K967;9!<DD!(!?<JO!<DD!(!6588<:@!;5!AC8!<>57;!

<DD!;A9!L5BM?!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'!!

*7?AC5:?O!?7EE5B;?O!?<:@<D?!<:5C:;9@!LC;A!

8JBBAO!><P?O!<DD!=C?!:969??<BJG!I5B!;A9!L5BM?!

5I!9F9BJ!6A<BP9!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'O!IB58!;A9!

;B9<?7BJ!5I!;A9!+5B@O!D)!E)!A)!

!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!c<B57;!W__]2!W]b^#O!I)![)!!

-5J5:!W_b#2!E)!V"O!:5)!aWO!ED)!["^]O!D)!W`O!D)![W)!!

$1!#2WO!"WW)!

!! !

Page 48: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ][[!

%)(()["! +57FB9!*!W!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!F#02=*'0!!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!%8)!(!h!39?)!(!

49?6BCE;C5:! &57:@^;5EE9@!?;9D9!B9EB9?9:;C:P!F#02=*'0%<:@!AC?!LCI9!C:!IB5:;!5I!<!;<>D9!5I!5II9BC:P?!<;!;A9!BCPA;^A<:@!>5;;58)!%:!

C:?6BCE;C5:!5I!Wa!DC:9?!C?!D56<;9@!<>5F9!;A9!ICP7B9?!<:@!<!;9K;!

5I!_!F9B;C6<D!DC:9?!C?!5:!;A9!D9I;!?C@9!5I!;A9!B9EB9?9:;<;C5:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!bG%('<%(%"+2*#0'%

!

$B96C?9!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!3C8E?5:!W_#]2!%U,*!a)[O!ED)!W])!!

39;A9!W_b_2!VWO!D)!W#)!

*5889:;2!45K9J!W__V2!"WaO!"_[)!!

!! !

Page 49: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]["!

%)(()[]! +9C@9:!b!=Y!

]G!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!W"20&0'2,&%$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!39?)!()!

49?6BCE;C5:! *<F9;;5!<:@!;5B7?!?;9D9!LC;A!W"!A5BCZ5:;<D!DC:9?!;9K;!5F9B!;A9!

B9EB9?9:;<;C5:! 5I! ;A9! @969<?9@! <:@! AC?! LCI9! C:! IB5:;! 5I! <!

;<>D9!<:@!<!b!B9PC?;9B!EB569??C5:!5I!5II9BC:P^>9<B9B?)!'A9!W"!

DC:9?!C:?6BCE;C5:!C?!C:!;A9!7EE9B!A<DI!5I!;A9!?;9D9)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%%D)!WWG%).$9*9$%)*'$9*9$%7*0%+)%*%$+$9$%-&0%-+%(.0'%%

!

(!I<B9@!@5L:?;B9<8!<:@!(!?<CD9@!7E?;B9<8!;5!

;A9!7*0I%5:9!LA5!M:5L?!;5!A<F9!@5:9!85B9!

;A<:!5B@9B9@!

!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!3C8E?5:!W_#]2!%U,*![`)WO!ED)!"`)!!

39;A9!W_b_2!#[O!D)![`)!!

X5DL9B@<!h!T59?9B!W_`VO![2!ED)!])!

!! !

Page 50: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ][]!

%)(()[b! ''!a`!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!>1*$2'42$P+!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 'A9>9?O!''!a`)!39?)!()!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!?57;A!L<DD!5I!;A9!;58>)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%.+%'&%+%'"-'%*'%,-%0+%

!

%BBCF<D!<;!;A9!D<:@!IB58!;A9!C::9B!=DC;)!;A9!

6<F9B:qG!5I!;A9!PB9<;!,-!!

U5;9?2!'A9!?57;A!L<DD!5I!;A9!;58>!B9EB9?9:;?!;A9!;B<:?E5B;!5I!;A9!5L:9BQ?!65IIC:)!'A9!

@9EC6;9@!?69:9?!?998!;5!A<F9!>99:!?;<P9?!5I!;A9!d57B:9J)!'AC?!A<D;!C?!9:;C;D9@2!o%BBCF<D!<;!

;A9!D<:@!IB58!;A9!C::9B!=DC;)!;A9!6<F9B:qG!5I!;A9!PB9<;!,-rO!E9BA<E?!B9I9BBC:P!;5!;A9!;58>)!

4<FC9?!W_[`2![W)!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!4<FC9?!W_[`2!ED)![W)!!

$1!W2[O!W[W^")!

!! !

Page 51: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ][b!

%)(()[a! T<:M9?!1?)!

U5)!0((!*!]!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!\.02>1$*'94!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! S<@C!X<DI<)!39?)!()!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'A9! BCPA;! ?C@9! 5I! ;A9! ?;9D9! C?! 5667EC9@! >J! ;A9! B5J<D! I<D65:!

<>5F9!;A9!E<D<69!I<v<@9O!LC;A!EB5;96;CF9!I5B87D<!<;!C;?!><6M!

<:@! ;A9!X5B7?^:<89!5I! 39?5?;BC?! ()! 'A9!8C@@D9! C?! 5667EC9@!

>J![!F9B;C6<D! DC:9?!;9K;O!<:@!;A9!EB5E9B! C:?6BCE;C5:?!@9F9D5E!

5:!;A9!D9I;!A<DI!5I!;A9!?;9D9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%%D)!W^[G%-+<2#!'&%,&%(%#&-94%#+%(%-&'%+)<'%$(<2$;%@+%*;%,-%%%%D)!aG%0+%,&%(%"+2*#0'%

!!

N99E9B!5I!;A9!?96B9;?!LAC6A!5:DJ!5:9!A9<B?O!

PB9<;!C:!AC?!5IIC69O!8CPA;J!C:!AC?!@CP:C;JO!<!

8<PC?;B<;9!<;!;A9!I5B9IB5:;!5I!;A9!E95ED9O!

;A9!I<F5BC;9!5I!X5B7?!5I!;A9!,-!!

%!F9BJ!PB9<;!5:9!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!1<6<@<8!W_]a2!aWO!ED)!_)!!

38C;A!W_#a2!b`^[)!!

$1!#2!WO!W"`)!

!! !

Page 52: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ][a!

%)(()[#! X<88<8<;!

W["!

456789:;!;C;D9! -B<IIC;5!5I!,P,2$;!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! S<@C!X<88<8<;)!39?)!(O!R)!Wa)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

D)!bG%(#$%,&0'%(%$&'%*;'%*'%"+2*#0'%!

T5B:!=>9;L99:G!;A9!PB9<;?!C:!;A9!5IIC69!5I!

9F9BJ;AC:P!C?!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!*57J<;!h!15:;9;!W_W[2!VaO!:5)!W["O!D)!a)!!

-5J5:!W_b#2!V#O!:5)!a])!!

$1!#2!WO!""W)!!

!! !

Page 53: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ][#!

%)(()[V! X<88<8<;!

V#!

456789:;!;C;D9! -B<IIC;5!5I!>1(*2-&'!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! X<88<8<;)!39?)!(O!R)!"V)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

D)!Wb^WaG!,"+0%(%!*,0%#%(%,P0%*%"+2*#0'%!

1<?;9B!5I!;A9!?;5B9?O!8<:!5I!;A9!EB5FC?C5:?!

I5B!;A9!"+2*#0'%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!*57J<;!h!15:;9;!W_W[2!a]^aO!:5)!V#O!ED)![`O!D)!Wa)!$!

$1!#2WO!""W)!

!! !

Page 54: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ][V!

%)(()[_! 11%!W[)WV]!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!=*'20#+'%!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!39?)!(O!R)!W#)!

49?6BCE;C5:! &96;<:P7D<B! E<C:;9@! DC89?;5:9! ?;9D9! LA5?9! ?7BI<69! C?!

@CFC@9@!C:!;L5!A<DF9?)!(:!;A9!7EE9B!A<DI!C?!;A9!C:?6BCE;C5:!C:!"!

DC:9?!<:@!Wa!65D78:?k!C:!;A9!D5L9B!A<DIO!;A9!5L:9B!C?!?9<;9@!

5:! ;A9! D9I;O! I<6C:P! <:! 5II9BC:P! ;<>D9O! ;L5! ?5:?! <:@! <!

@<7PA;9B)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!bG%#*0%P*%(%"+2*#0'%%D)!VG%)+"9*9$%-;#0%+%"+2-.%$0%_"%(%,9$%(%"+2*#0'%%

!

TB<F9!?965:@!C:!;A9%"+2*#0'!!

(!@9DCF9B9@!6D5;AC:P!;5!;A9!;B9<?7BJO!;A9!

<6657:;C:P!>9C:P!C:!8J!A<:@?!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!39;A9!W_b_2!#_^V`O!D)!aO!W`)!$1!b2WO!W`[)!

'B<:?D<;C5:2!+C6A;A9C8!W_VV2!W`]^b)!

*5889:;2!45K9J!W__V2!"#b)!

!! !

Page 55: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ][_!

%)(()"`! X<;:7>!]_!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!>1(*2(-&'!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! X<;:7>)!39?)!(O!R)!"W)!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!C:!;A9!8<C:!6A<8>9B)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%J9%QE%+#%'"%!0$%(%,,0<%-+%-*D'E%*;%*%"+2*#0'%%

!

YCPCD<:;O!(!L<?!5:9!IB99!5I!?D99EC:P!C:!9F9BJ!

5667E<;C5:H6588<:@!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!%:;A9?!W_[V2!#aO!ED)!"W)!!

*5889:;2!45K9J!W__V2!"V")!

!! !

Page 56: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]"`!

%)(()"W!!!!!!!! %??C7;!W!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!\4^-,"<!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %??C7;O!')!W)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58!=39?)!(G)!!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)! a! A5BCZ5:;<D! DC:9?! C:?6BCE;C5:! 5:! ;A9! 8<C:! @55B! 5I! ;A9!

;58>)!

T)! (:?6BCE;C5:! 5:! ;A9! D9I;! ?C@9! 5I! ;A9! 69:;B<D! @55B! 5I! ;A9!

;58>)!

*)! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:! ;A9!PB9<;!A<DDO!9<?;!L<DDO! ?57;A!?C@9!5I! ;A9!

@55B)!

4)! (:?6BCE;C5:! 5:! ;A9! 98>B<69! 5I! ;A9! @55B! 5I! ;A9! 8<C:!

9:;B<:69)!

/)!'C;D9?!5I!;A9!5L:9B!B9E9<;9@!C:!;A9!;58>)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%%) D)!Wb"G%-'"2$;%@+%*;%,-%

%T) D)!W#WG%$0%+#<%,&%*%"+2*#0'%%*) D)![[`G%*#0'%-##0%@+%-'"2$;% ,-%+)%#'2+.94%

(%"+2*#0'%%%

D)!["WG%0+%)*'<%*%#'%(%"+2*#0'%%

D)! []`^WG% $(<2$;% @+% *;% ,-% '**94% )*'<%($'<094%

%4) D)!W"aG%$(<%(2;&-%"+2,&%%/) D)![W]^bG%0,%-+2)0%*%$(<%,-%

!%) $D9<?C:P!;5!X5B7?O!+5B@!5I!;A9!,-!!T) -B9<;!?57;A9B:!ECDD<B!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'!!*) c<F5B9@! >J! X5B7?! ED9<?C:P! ;A9! ,-O! 5:9!

LA5!M:5L?!AC?!?;<:@C:P!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'!!

!-B9<;!I5B985?;!5I!E5?C;C5:!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'!

!c<F5BC;9! 5I! X5B7?O! +5B@! 5I! ;A9! ,-O! LA5!EB585;9?!AC8!>9I5B9!AC?!E99B?!

!4) ,:9!LA5!C?!C:!IB5:;!5I!;A9!"+2,&!!/) .:C\79!I5B!5:9!LA5!C?!C:!;A9!,-!

!U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!15:;9;!W_[V2!bb!II)!!

15:;9;!W_"`^"b2!]b!II)!

-BCIIC;A!WVV_2!ED)!]O!D)![[`k!ED)!bO!DO!W"WO![]`k!ED)!"O!D)!W"[O!D)!Wb"O!D)!W#Wk!ED)!_O!D)!"]a)!

.&N!Y((2!bbO!b#O!aW)!

$1!]2!WO![aW^[)!!

*5889:;2!45K9J!W__V2!W[]O![bbO!"b[)!!

!! !

Page 57: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]"W!

%)(()"[! *-![`b"_!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!=*'02@'"!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58!=39?)!(G)!49?6BCE;C5:! %)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!IB5:;!?C@9!5I!;A9!?;9D9)!

T)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!><6M)!(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!%)!D)!#G%S(%(.'%*'%,-%%%%D)!W[G%*;%#+)%,&%(+0'%*#0'%(%0#)'%"+2,&%%%D)!W]^WbG%#,+%(&,'%+%,-%%%%D)!Wb^WaG%$0%*94%0+0%(%C#0(%C#0%+%+0'<%"+2*#0'%%%D)!W_G%#(+%(%"+2*#0'%%`9%D)"G%$0%+#<%,&%*%"+2*#0'%%D)bG%0+%#*.%(%7*0%"+2*#0'%%%D)!aG%(*)%..%-&"%-+%#!(%,-%%

!,:9!LA5!IC:@?!;A9!?E996A!5I!;A9!,-%%!!+5B@!5I!;A9!657:?9DO!D5F9@!>J!;A9!MC:P!C:!;A9!A<DD!5I!;A9!"+2,&!!,:9!LA5!B<C?9?!7E!1<n<;!;5!;A9!,-%%!!,:9!;5!LA58!;A9!PB9<;!5:9?!5I!;A9!U5B;A!<:@!;A9!357;A!6589O!>5LC:P!<;!;A9!P<;9?!5I!;A9%"+2*#0'!!*58E<:C5:!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'!!!-B9<;!?57;A9B:!ECDD<B!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'!!,:9!PB9<;!5I!I9<B!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'!!/IIC6C9:;!5I!;A9!?96B9;!?E996A!C:!;A9!>7?C:9??!5I!;A9!,-!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!+<:P9^36AwI9B!W_`[^[bO!((!2!Wb]^WbbO!D)!>"^>bk!Wb"O!D)!>!Wb^>Wak!!Wb[O!D)!>#)!!

$1!b2!WO!]b)!

*5889:;2!45K9J!W__V2!][O!]aO!baO!Wa]O![bbO![b_O![V#O!"#")!!

S<B@!W_V[2!:5)!WaO!W"`[)!

! !

Page 58: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]"[!

%)(()""! T1!W_#!

ebVWf!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!>1*'4!_+%*!5*'!=>1*'4!?5:!5I!5*'G!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58!=39?)!(G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'A9!?;9D9!C?!@<;9@!;5!B9CP:!5I!39?5?;BC?!(!<:@!L<?!D56<;9@!C:!

;A9!FC6C:C;J!5I!;A9!?<:6;7<BJ!5I!,?CBC?)!(;!65:;<C:?!<:!

C:F56<;C5:!;5!,?CBC?!<:@!AC?!65DD9<P79!W"20&20'!:9<B!;A9!B9EB9?9:;<;C5:!5I!>1*'4!LC;A!AC?!D9I;!<B8!B<C?9@!C:!<!P9?;7B9!5I!

PB99;C:P)!'A9!A5BCZ5:;<D!DC:9?!<:@!;A9!F9B;C6<D!65D78:?!5I!;A9!

B9?;!5I!;A9!?;9D9!65:?C?;!5I!<!6<;<D5P79!5I!FCB;79?!5I!;A9!

@5:5B)!'A9!;C;D9?!<B9!IB58!;A9!D5L9B!B9PC?;9B!5I!F9B;C6<D!

65D78:?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

*5D)!W#G%*4+%(%7*0%)&0%%*5D)!W_G%('<%(%"+2*#0'%+)%..'%(%)&%*;%%

!

T9<7;CI7D!5I!;A9!7*0%5I!;A9!5IIC69%!

$B96C?9!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'I%5:9!LA5!M:5L?!LA<;!C?!?<C@!C:!9F9BJ!5IIC69!

!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!3C8E?5:!W_#]2!%U,*!b)[O!ED)!W[)!!

X'T1O!((2!ED)![")!!

39;A9!W_b_2!VWO!D)!")!

'B<:?D<;C5:2!+C6A;A9C8!W_#"^W_V`O!((2!W[[)!

*5889:;2!45K9J!W__V2![]])!!

!

! !

Page 59: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]""!

%)(()"]! X9\<C>![!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3ABC:9!5I!5+*2"0'!!!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! /D9EA<:;C:9)!39?)!()!

49?6BCE;C5:! ]!C:?6BCE;C5:?!<B9!6<BF9@!5:!;A9!?57;A9B:!L<DD!5I!;A9!?ABC:9!

9B96;9@!>J!5+*2"0'!I5B!;A9!@9CIC9@!X9\<C>!<:@!AC8?9DI)!'C;D9!

C?!C:!;A9!.EE9B!B9PC?;9B!5I!;A9!C:?6BCE;C5:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!b^aG%$(<2+%*#0'%*(''94%..0%*94%$$0%(%"+2*#0'%$*%#(+0%$(<0%,-%%%%

!

,:9!LA5!<;;9:@?!;A9!MC:P!C:!AC?!d57B:9J?O!

5:9!;5!LA58!C;!C?!?<C@O!oS9D6589!;5!;A9!"+2*#0'!>J!;A5?9!LA5!<B9!C:!;A9!n-r!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!X<><6AC!W_Vb2![bO!I)!W@O!ED)!_<)!!

*5889:;2!45K9J!W__V2!"_V)!!

cB<:M9!W__]2![`a)!

!! !

Page 60: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]"]!

%)(()"b! T1!W_a!

eWW##f!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!>1+'242*2'02'!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! S<@C!X<DI<O!357;A9B:!'98ED9)!39?)!()!

49?6BCE;C5:! R9DD5L!?<:@?;5:9!?;9D9!5I!>1+'242*2'02'%LC;A!X5B7?!<:@!#6+6C7!B9EB9?9:;<;C5:!5:!;A9!BCPA;!?C@9!<:@!#!A5BCZ5:;<D!DC:9?!;9K;!

5:!;A9!D9I;)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

D)![G%$(<2$;%@+%*;%,-%%

!

c<F5BC;9!5I!X5B7?O!+5B@!5I!;A9!,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!X'T1O!]2!ED)!"O!D)![)!!

*5889:;2!45K9J!W__V2![a])!!

!! !

Page 61: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]"b!

%)(()"a! E.*!"[W[V!

456789:;!;C;D9! +9;;9B!5I!5*2;0;0!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! +<A7:)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! +9;;9B!LBC;;9:!>J!;A9!?9BF<:;!5I!;A9!E9B?5:<D!9?;<;9!5*2;0;0%;5!<!MC:P!LA5?9!:<89!C?!D5?;)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!b^aG%S(9*94%DNE%;&C%$(%(%)*+'%*%P*;'<%*%0%)'(9*94%+%7*0%%

!

X9!I57:@!;A9!?9BF<:;!;A9B9!C:!;A9!9:6D5?7B9!

5I!;A9!@C?;BC6;^657:6CDD5B!=<I;9BG!A9!A<@!?<CD9@!

;5!;A9!7*0%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!*5DDC9B!h!l7CBM9![``[2!aa^#)!!

$1!]2WO!WW[)!

!! !

Page 62: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]"a!

%)(()"#! E.*!"[[`[!

456789:;!;C;D9! +9;;9B!5I!>1$2$;!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! NA<7:)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! +9;;9B!5I!;A9!?9BF<:;!5I!;A9!E9B?5:<D!9?;<;9!>1$2$;%;5!<!MC:P!LA5?9!:<89!C?!:5;!?E96CIC9@)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)![G%899:%+%$*'%*9#'%,P0%(%7*0%%

!

e))f!;5!>BC:P!I5B!;A9!EB5FC?C5:?!IB58!;A9%7*0!

U5;9?2!!

! !

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!-BCIIC;A!WV_V2!#bO!ED)!"WO!D)!][)!!

*5DDC9B!h!l7CBM9![``[2!WW`^")!!

S9:;9!W__`2!#_O!:5)!_#)!

$1!]2WO!WW[)!

!! !

Page 63: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]"#!

%)(()"V! E.*!"[[``!

456789:;!;C;D9! +9;;9B!5I!M"0!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<A7:)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! +9;;9B!5I!M"0!;5!;A9!D<@J!5I!;A9!A57?9!5;C2-'"!(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%(#%P#*%$++'%(%7*0%+%)'%*;'%

!

SA<;!C?!>9C:P!@5:9!C:!;A9!7*0%C?!85B9!

@CIIC67D;!;A<:!<:J;AC:P!=9D?9G!

!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!-BCIIC;A!WV_V2!#[^"O!ED)!"`O!D)!#)!!

*5DDC9B!h!l7CBM9![``[2!V]^bO!:5)!W`])!$1!]2WO!WW[)!

! !

Page 64: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]"V!

%)(()"_! 8%?L<:!

W]#W!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!?;9D9!LC;A!DC?;!5I!B5J<D!E9B?5::9D!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! S<@C!9D^X7@C)!39?)!(O!R)!W#)!

49?6BCE;C5:! TD<6M! PB<:C;9! ?;9D9!LC;A! "! A5BCZ5:;<D! DC:9?! C:?6BC>9@! 5F9B! [!

F9B;C6<D!<:@!_!A5BCZ5:;<D! DC:9?!LC;A!;L5!ICP7B9?!<:@![!5;A9B!

?A5B;!DC:9?!>9D5LO!65:;<C:C:P!<!DC?;!5I!E9B?5::9D!98ED5J9@!C:!

<!\7<BBJ!9KE9@C;C5:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!W[G%#%ARR%7*0%$(<02+%(#2,&'%%

!

W``!89:!5I!;A9!7*0I%6AC9I!EB5?E96;5B?!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!c<MABJ!W_b[2!:5)!aO!I)!["^]O!ED)!_O!D)!W[)!!

3<@9M!W_V`2!Wa^#)!!

39JIBC9@!W_VW2!WW^")!!

$1!#2WO!"W_^[`)!!

!! !

Page 65: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]"_!

%)(()]`! T1!b#[!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!>1*'4%!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!39?)!(O!R)!"_)!

49?6BCE;C5:! +C89?;5:9!B96;<:P7D<B!?;9D9k!;A9!W]!DC:9?!;9K;!ICDD?!;A9!7EE9B!

E<B;!LACD9!;A9!D5L9B!E<B;! C?!5667EC9@!>J!;A9!B9DC9I!?69:9?!C:!

;AB99!B9PC?;9B?!?9E<B<;9@!>J![!DC:9?!5I!C:?6BCE;C5:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

DD)!V^_G!$($9*9$%"-%$&0'%(#0%*;0%0"0'%(%"+2*#0'!

!

(!L<?!PB<:;9@!;5!B9<6A!5D@!<P9!LC;A!8J!

6ACD@B9:!A5D@C:P!5IIC69!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'!!

U5;9?2!!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!3C8E?5:!W_#]2!%U,*!b)WO!ED)!W[)!!

X'T1O![2!ED)![[)!!

'B<:?D<;C5:2!+C6A;A9C8!W_VV2!W`#)!

!! !

Page 66: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]]`!

%)(()]W! -+!S%c!"b!

=5D@!:5)!]`G!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!W"20&0'2,&!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!39?)!(^%8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! &57:@^;5EE9@! ?;9D9! LC;A! ;A9! 5L:9B! <;! ;A9! D9I;! >5;;58!

?9<;9@!C:!IB5:;!5I!<:!5II9BC:P!;<>D9!<:@![b!DC:9?!C:?6BCE;C5:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!W]^WaG%$#'9$%(%).$9$%+%*.%)+'%7*0%"4%0*%-(94%!)'(0%*'<0%(%"+2*#0'%,*)0%*'%+%,+<'%(&&%#'&9$%+%"+2*#0'%$+D9CE%0$%(%,P%**%..94%$0&%#4'%-+!%&;9$%#'%0&%*9$%0,+'%"+$9$%-#$9$%0$%(%,-%(+0'9$%(%#'*%#'"2#&%$0%*.%*'9$%$&'%(%,-%(%..%(+%-(2*'+0%$(<%)*'%,&%(%&;.0%

!

SA9:!(!A<@!P5:9!:5B;A!;5!5II9B!?<D7;<;C5:?!<;!

;A9!7*0O!;A<;!LAC6A!>9D5:P?!5I!XC?!1<d9?;JO!!

;A9!?9<D9B?!LA5!<B9!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%%<:@!;A9!E95ED9!<;!;A9!,+<'%?99!8J!<@8C;;<:69!;5!;A9!

"+2*#0'O!(!>9C:P!8<@9!;5!9:;9B!7:<::57:69@!

=))G)!%:!5K!L<?!?D<7PA;9B9@!I5B!8J!89<DO!I99;!

>9!?;CBB9@!;A98?9DF9?!I5B!89)!%?!5:9!EB<C?9@!

@C@!(!6589!I5B;A!IB58!;A9!n-O!5:9!>9D5F9@!5I!;A9!#'"2#&)!c5B!5IIC69!A<@!>99:!65:I9BB9@!5:!89!>J!;A9!n-O!:<89DJ!;A<;!5I!6AC9I^EBC9?;!<:@!

PB9<;!6A<8>9BD<C:!C:!%>J@5?)!

!

U5;9?2!!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!3C8E?5:!W_#]2!%U,*![`)[O!ED)!"`)!!

39;A9!W_b_2!#]O!D)!W"^W]O!Wa^#)!

3EC9P9D>9BP!!h!$xB;9B!W_`[O!((2!ED)!]O!:5)!])!

1j:6A9:!N<;<D5P2!a"O!D)!W^VO!D)!Wbk!E)!#bO!D)!<#)!

!! !

Page 67: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]]W!

%)(()][! T9:C!X<?<:![!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!>1(*2(2-&'!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! T9:C!X<?<:O!')![)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58!=39?)!(!h!%8)!((G!

49?6BCE;C5:! %^/)!'C;D9?!5I!;A9!5L:9B!c)! TC5PB<EAC6<D! C:?6BCE;C5:?! 6<BF9@! 5:! ;A9! d<8>?! 5I! ;A9!@55BL<J! ;5! ;A9! 8<C:! 6A<8>9BO! 65:?C?;C:P! 5I! b! A5BCZ5:;<D!DC:9?!<:@!Wa!F9B;C6<D!DC:9?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%%) +)%#'2+.94%(%"+2*#0'%%%T) 0+%899:'%(%"+2*#0'%%%*) -#<%,&'%(%"+2*#0'%%4) (+<%P;*'%*'%7*0%%/9%0+%$.'%(%"+2*#0'%%%c)!D)!VE%($%$.*%#%$'4%$&00%)4'%-#''%(%"+2*#0'%(+0'94%(%#'"2#&%%%D)!W"G%$0%(%-'"%$*%*709#*%$*9*9$%*;0%!&%*9$%-#$9C0$%-+9#%(%"+2*#0'%%%%%D)!WaG%,-,%*%+.$%*9$%(+%'#'%*%S#0%"+%*0%#&0%*0%a&-.%C&%YRRR%(%*-;09#*%-#$%$*C%-+9#%(%"+2*#0'%+%'*0%+*"'%*'%$+0%4&%*9$%;&C09#*%*;%*%"+2*#0'%%%%%

!%) ,:9!LA5!M:5L?!AC?!?;<:@C:P!C:!;A9!"+2

*#0'!!T) -B9<;!5I!I<F5B?!=qG!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'!!*) ,:9!LA5!C?!I<F5B9@!PB9<;DJ!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'!!4) T9D5F9@!5I!;A9!P;*'!5I!;A9!7*0!!/) -B9<;!5I!69:?C:P!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'!!!%?!<!8<:!B9ED<69?!<:!<P9@!I<;A9BO!<665B@C:P!;5!;A9!I<F5B?HEB<C?9?!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%=<:@G!AC?!D5F9!C:!;A9!#'"2#&!%&9;7B:C:P!><6M!C:!E9<69O!;A9J!A<@!:5;!@96B9<?9@)!(!>B57PA;!;A9!P5D@!<EE5C:;9@!;5!89)!(!L<?!I<F5B9@HEB<C?9@!I5B!C;!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'!!T9A5D@O!P<F9!;5!89!;A9!?7E9BC:;9:@9:;!5I!;A9!P<:P9B?!5I!;A9!@58<C:?!=qG!5I!;A9!A9B@?89:!5I!;A9!,BJK!:<89O!>7DD?!"```!5I!;A9CB!@B<7PA;!?;56M)!(!L<?!I<F5B9@HEB<C?9@!I5B!C;!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%<;!9<6A!<::7<D!566<?C5:!=5B!J9<BG!5I!?;56M^;<MC:P)!(!B9:@9B9@!<DD!;A9CB!;&C0!=EB5@769G!;5!;A9!"+2*#0')!

U5;9?2!!

(:!*2!'A9!;9B8!P;*'!L<?!7?9@!IB58!;A9!9<BDJ!1C@@D9!NC:P@58!;5!B9I9B!;5!<!PB57E!5I!

8<PC?;B<;9?!C:!<!P9:9B<D!?9:?9O!5B!85B9!?E96CIC6<DDJ!;5!;A9!D<L!657B;?)!c*42![V`k!-/-2![W])!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!U9L>9BBJ!WV_"O!(2!ED)!#^W#)!$D)!V^_O!$D)!Wb)!

.&N!Y((2![WO!D)!Wbk![[O!D)!W"k!W]O!D)!W"k!W_O!D)!W"O!D)!#sWbsWV^W_)!

+9E?C7?!W_W"2!#VO![)!

$1!]2WO!W]W^])!

*5889:;2!S<B@!W_V[2!:5)!#Wa)!!

45K9J!W__V2!W[]O!WaaO!W#[O!"#")!!

!

Page 68: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]][!

!%)(()]"! T9B?A9A!W!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!\-0'<2*)'!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! T9B?A9AO!')!W)!%8)!(!h!39?)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!C::9B!L<DD! DO!<;!;A9!D9I;!?C@9!5I!;A9!3ABC:9!

9:;B<:69)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!]G%$(<2+%#!'&%8"+:2*#0'%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!?96B9;?!5I!;A9!8"+:2*#0'!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!U9L>9BBJ!WV_]O!((2!ED)!#O!E)![])!

$1!]2WO!W##^_)!

!! !

Page 69: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]]"!

%)(()]]! 49CB!&CI9A!W!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!F4+27*(0!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 49CB^&CI9A)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58!=39?)!(!^!%8)!((G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!?57;A9B:^A<DI!5I!;A9!>D<6M^L<DD)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!_^W`G%)*'<%#'%(%"+2,&%%%

!

c5B985?;!5I!E5?C;C5:!C:!;A9!"+2,&!

U5;9?2!?99!<>5F9)!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!15:;9;!W_"a2!E)!W]`)!!

*5889:;2!45K9J!W__V2!W#[)!

!! !

Page 70: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]]]!

%)(()]b! T1!W]a!

eb#]f!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!B*'<25('D<E!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?!U5B;A!,II9BC:P!*A<E9D)!%8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! '<DDO! B57:@^;5EE9@! ?;9D9! LC;A! <! LC:P9@! ?7:^@C?M! C:! ;A9!

D7:9;;9O! <! [[! A5BCZ5:;<D! DC:9?! ;9K;! <:@! <! B9EB9?9:;<;C5:! 5I!

;A9!5L:9B!<:@!AC?!85;A9B!C:!;A9!D9I;^?C@9!<;!;A9!>5;;58)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!V^_G!?&&%$0'94!(%.;&0W%(%#),'%@+%*;%,-%

!

,:9!LA5?9!658C:P!C?!<L<C;9@!<;!;A9!6B5LC:P!

<;!;A9!<EE9<B<:69!5I!X5B7?O!+5B@!5I!;A9!,-!!

U5;9?2!W!c*42!"[W)!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!3C8E?5:!W_#]2!%U,*!][)[O!ED)!aW)!!

X'T1O![2!ED)!V^_)!!

39;A9!W_b_2!#bO!D)!WW)!!

$1!b2!WO!_b)!

*5889:;2!45K9J!W__V2!WaV)!!!

!! !

Page 71: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]]b!

%)(()]a! T9BDC:!W[`"!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!IB58!S<@C!X7@C!=qG!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! S<@C!X7@C)!%8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! 3;9D9!6588985B<;C:P!<:!9KE9@C;C5:!;5!<:!<89;AJ?;!8C:C:P!

<:@!DC?;C:P!;A9!5IIC6C<D?!C:F5DF9@!C:!C;)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)![G%$$9*D9$E%+%-#(*%*%-(94%-*2,%#+%*%#(+0%*#0'%*%#'"2#&%(.0%*94%(%'&%"*%%%%%%D)![^"G%(.0%-(94%*%#8+99:%(%.&.0%

!

(!6<89!I5B!<89;AJ?;O!5:!>9A<DI!5I!XC?!

1<d9?;JO!;5P9;A9B!LC;A!<!@CP:C;<BJ!5I!;A9!

658E<:C5:?!5I!;A9!MC:P!>9D5:PC:P!;5!;A9!#'"2#&I%LA5!A<@!>99:!?E5M9:!;5!AC8!C:!;AC?!

9KE9@C;C5:!=DC;)!D<:@G!!

!

XC?!1<d9?;J!8<@9!6588<:@!I5B!e;AC?qf!

@CP:C;<BJ!C:!;A9!<7@C9:69!A<DD!=.&.0G!!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!3<@9M!W_V`2!:5)!W]VO!E)!_"O!ED)![aO!D)![)!

39JIBC9@!W_VW2!W`#)!

36AwI9B!h!/B8<:!h!SB9?ZC:?MC!h!&<:M9!h!T5B6A<B@;!W_a_O!W2![ba)!

$1!#2!WO!b)!

!! !

Page 72: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]]a!

%)(()]#! +9C@9:!a!=Y!

bG!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!B"+2C&2?,!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!%8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! *<F9;;5! <:@! ;5B7?! ?;9D9! LC;A! <! 6B5??^?6A989! 65B:C69k! ;A9!

@969<?9@! C?! ?A5L:! C:! ;A9! 8C@@D9! ?9<;9@! C:! IB5:;! 5I! <:!

5II9BC:P!;<>D9!<:@!@9C;C9?!@C?E5?9@!C:!]!B9PC?;9B?!7:@9B!AC8)!

'9K;! C:?6BC>9@! C:! 65:69:;BC6! ?\7<B9?! <B57:@! ;A9! 69:;B<D!

B9EB9?9:;<;C5:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%$(<2+%'&%=-0%"+2*#0'%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!+5L9B!/PJE;!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!3C8E?5:!W_#]2!%U,*![")"O!ED)!"])!

X5DL9B@<!h!T59?9B!W_`VO![2!ED)!b)!

!! !

Page 73: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]]#!

%)(()]V! T1!W]b!

eV[Vf!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!5&2(*'0!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!%8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! $<C:;9@!DC89?;5:9!?;9D9!LC;A!<!>C5PB<EAC6<D!C:?6BCE;C5:!PCFC:P!

;A9!?7669??C5:!5I!%89:98A<;!(O!39?5?;BC?!(!<:@!%89:98A<;!

(()!%!W`!F9B;C6<D! DC:9?!C:?6BCE;C5:!6<BF9@!5:!;A9!7EE9B!B57:@^

;5EE9@! E<B;! 5F9B! ;A9! [! B9PC?;9B?! 5I! B9EB9?9:;<;C5:?! 5I! ;A9!

@969<?9@!C:!IB5:;!5I!<:!5II9BC:P!;<>D9!<:@!AC?!I<8CDJ)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

D)!WG!$(<2$;%@+%*;%,-%%D)!#G%#!%*%)*+'%"+2,&%!

!

c<F5BC;9!5I!X5B7?O!+5B@!5I!;A9!,-!!

36BC>9!5I!;A9!?9BF<:;?!5I!;A9!"+2,&!

U5;9?2!!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!X'T1O![2!ED)![W)!!

1<:79DC<:!W__a2!""`O!D)!")!

*5889:;2!45K9J!W__V2!W[`O!WW)!

!! !

Page 74: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]]V!

%)(()]_! 3C:<C!]#!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!LC;A!:<89!<:@!;C;D9!5I!=*D'0E2-'"!?5:!5I!5&'2-+!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3C:<C!=39B<>C;!9D^NA<@C8G)!%8)!((O!R)![]!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!I<69!5I!;A9!B56M!<;!;A9!A9<@!5I!;A9!F<DD9J!

5I! 39B<>C;! 9D^NA<@C8)! 'A9! ;9K;! C?! <B;C67D<;9@!LC;A! ]! F9B;C6<D!

65D78:?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!]G!+)%#'%+.94%(%"+2*#0'%%

!

,:9!LA5!M:5L?!AC?!?;<:@C:P!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!h!$99;!h!y9B:J2!##O!ED)!WaO!D)!])!!

$1!#2!WO!"]b)!

*5889:;2!45K9J!W__V2!W[]O!W[)!

!! !

Page 75: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]]_!

%)(()b`! 47BA<8!

UW_"b!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!a*(02-'"!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! S<@C!-<?7?)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58!=39?)!((G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! &57:@^;5EE9@! ?;9D9! LC;A! ;A9! LC:P9@^@C?M! C:! ;A9! D7:9;;9k!

7:@9B!C;!;A9!5L:9B!C?!B9EB9?9:;9@!?;<:@C:P!>9I5B9!<!I5B8!5I!

,?CBC?^X5B7?! <:@! C:?6BCE;C5:?! <B9! D56<;9@! >9;L99:! ;A9!

ICP7B9?)!!

%)!#!F9B;C6<D! DC:9?! C:?6BCE;C5:!<;!;A9!>5;;58!5:!;A9! D9I;!?C@9!

5I!;A9!?;<:@C:P!5L:9B)!

T)!W!DC:9!C:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!D9I;!?C@9!5I!;A9!5L:9B)!

!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%%)!!

6)!WG%$(<2+%,7*0'<%%6)!]^bG%)"+%(%,-%'(%'7$%'"2+.%*%,-%'"'2+%*%#'"2#&%%`9%6)!WG%$+<2,'%*<%"+82,&:%

%

!

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!n7*0'<!!

,:9!LA5!PB9L!C:!;A9!n-O!5:9!LA5!@59?!:5;!@C?5>9J!;A9!C:?;B76;C5:?!5I!;A9!n-!5B!;A9!7;;9B<:69!5I!;A9!#'"2#&!

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!"+82,&:!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!3<J9@!W_##2!ED)!V<)!!

TCB6A!WVV`2!ED)!(Y)!!

UC>>C!W_#a2!]b!II)O!b`O!ED)!W`)!!

3<J9@!W_##2!W]WO!ED)!V!<)!!

$1!#2!WO!""V)!

*5889:;2!45K9J!W__V2!"b]O!"_W)!!

cB<:M9!W_V]2!:5)!"`#)!!

T9BD9F!W_#V2![]WO![]V)!!

!

! !

Page 76: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]b`!

!%)(()bW! T9:C!X<?<:!"!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!@*(02-'"!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! T9:C!X<?<:O!')!")!1C@@D9!NC:P@58!=%8)!((!^!39?)!((G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'A9! PB9<;! C:?6BCE;C5:O! 65:?C?;C:P! 5I! [[[! F9B;C6<D! DC:9?O! C?!

C:6C?9@! 7E5:! ;A9! @<@5! LAC6A! B7:?! B57:@! ;A9! L<DD?!

C889@C<;9DJ!>9:9<;A!;A9!E<C:;C:P!5I!;A9!8<C:!6A<8>9B)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!W``G%0+%-#D0E'9$%(%#'"2#&%+%#(+%0,$%%*;%%%D)W`]^bG%$,;%*%P*;'%*'%,-%+%.$%-#0%DNE%)4'0%.7*9$%)4'0%-#0'%)"+'%(%D*#0'E%;&-%."'%+%*'%*#0'%.#94%%%%D)Wb"^bG%#(+%0,'<%,&%$(%*%#(+0%,!&%$*0%"+2*#0'%%%J)!W#V^WV]G%+*94%,*)%(%+%*%M,'%.$.$0%(+%*%,*)<0%-+%$#94%*%)+%*'+%(%"+94%(*)%*%DNE%*--%#'94%*%.'%)4'%-#'%*'%)+%*#0'%(+0'94%(!#'"2#&%

!

-B9<;!L<?!8J!EB<C?9HI<F5B!C:!;A9!#'"2#&%85B9!

;A<:!<:J!657B;C9B!

!

eSA9:f!L9B9!65DD96;9@!=qG!;A9!P*;'!5I!;A9!,-!I5B!<L<B@C:P!EB<C?9HI<F5BO!9\7<D!=qG!L<?!8J!

<EEB5F<D!=qG!;5!;A9!EB<C?9?HI<F5B?!;A<;!;55M!

ED<69!C:!;A9!=B5J<DG!EB9?9:69)!=5BG!;A9!

7;;9B<:69!5I!;A9!MC:P!AC8?9DI!

!

.:C\79!IBC9:@O!PB9<;!5I!I<F5B!<85:P!;A9!

657B;C9B?O!<>7:@<:;!$*0!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'!!

'A<;!C?!:<89!8CPA;!e>9f!DCFC:P!C:!;A9!857;A!

5I!;A9!M,'O!9?;<>DC?A9@!C:!;A9!857;A!5I!;A9!

DCFC:PO!7E5:!AC?!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!)'2*'+!=:96B5E5DC?G!C:!AC?!A57?9!9?;<>DC?A9@!I5B9F9BO!

AC?!?9<;!5I!;A9!9F9BD<?;C:PO!<665B@C:P!;5!;A9!

I<F5B!5I!;A9!MC:P!e<:@f!AC?!D5F9!C:!;A9!#'"2#&%%

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!U9L>9BBJ!WV_"O!(2!ED)!#^W#)!$D)!V^_O!$D)!Wb)!

.&N!Y((2![WO!D)!Wbk![[O!D)!W"k!W]O!D)!W"k!W_O!D)!W"O!D)!#sWbsWV^W_)!

+9E?C7?!W_W"2!#VO![)!

$1!]2!WO!W]W^])!

*5889:;2!45K9J!W__V2!W[]O!WaaO!W#[O!"#")!!

! !

Page 77: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]bW!

%)(()b[! T9B?A9A![!456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!\-0'<2-'"!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! T9B?A9AO!')![)!%8)!((!h!39?)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!B9E9<;9@!;LC69!5:!;A9!57;9B!DC:;9D?!5I!;A9!

P<;9L<J!5I!;A9!;58>)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)0%(%$(<%,-%%$+<2",'%-&'<2,%)'(0%;$'<%#(+%0,'<%$(<2$;%@+%*;%,-%%

!

$B5;96;5B!5I!AC8!LA5!C?!C:!;A9!n-!!

$BC:69!<:@!657:;O!?9<D9B!5I!.EE9B!<:@!+5L9B!

/PJE;O!7:C\79!IBC9:@O!I<F5BC;9!5I!X5B7?O!+5B@!

5I!;A9!,-%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!U9L>9BBJ!WV_]O!(2!ED)!a!<:@!WaO!E)![b)!!

$1!]2WO!W##^_)!

'B<:?D<;C5:2!45K9J!W__V2!"b")!!

!! !

Page 78: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]b[!

%)(()b"! 39<D!WW"[!

!

456789:;!;C;D9! $BCF<;9!:<89!?9<D!5I!@+$!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! +<A7:)!39?)!(((!h!%8)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%$+<2,'%*%,-%$(<2+%-0'2*'+%(&,%8)+0:9*;%$(&)%%

!

,IIC6C<D!C:!;A9!,-)!,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!;98ED9O!

d7?;CIC9@O!F9:9B<;9!5I!;A9!+5B@!

!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!1<B;C:!W_##2!V_O!:u!WW"[O!ED)!#O!W])!!

$9;BC9!WV_W2!ED)!_O!WVk!E)!W])!!

U9L>9BBJ!W_`a2!ED)!W"O!WbO!E)!W"")!!

*5889:;2!&<:M9!W_"b^##2!:5)!][W)!

!! !

Page 79: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]b"!

%)(()b]! 47BA<8!

UW_"a!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!5*20#+'2,*)!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58!=39?)!(((G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! &96;<:P7D<B! ?;9D9! LC;A! <! LC:P9@^?7:! @C?M! 5:! ;A9! ;5E)! 'A9!

7EE9B! E<B;! C?! 5667EC9@! >J! ;A9! ICP7B9?! 5I! ,?CBC?! 5:! ;A9! D9I;!

<:@! <! P5@! C:! ;A9! I5B8! 5I! <! d<6M<D! 5:! ;A9! BCPA;O! LC;A!

B9EB9?9:;<;C5:?!>9;L99:! ;A98)!'A9! D5L9B!A<DI!5I! ;A9!?;9D9!

C?!@CFC@9@!C:!"!B9PC?;9B?2!C:!;A9!ICB?;!5:9!;A9!@969<?9@!<:@!AC?!

LCI9! <B9! B9EB9?9:;9@! ?9<;9@! <;! ;A9! 5EE5?C;9! ?C@9?! 5I! ;A9!

;<>D9!5I!5II9BC:P?k! C:! ;A9!?965:@O!<!8<D9!<:@!<! I98<D9!?9<;!

5:! 6A<CB?k! C:! ;A9! ;ACB@! ;A9B9! <B9! "! I98<D9?! ICP7B9?! 5I! ?8<DD!

?CZ9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!"G%$+<2,'%*%"+2,&%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!"+2,&!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!cB<:M9!W_V]2!:5)!W`aO!b``)!!

TCB6A!WVV`2![#`!I)O!ED)!b)!!

*5889:;2!X5@d<6A9!h!T9BD9F!W_#b2!a)!!

cB<:M9!W_V"2![#)!

!! !

Page 80: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]b]!

%)(()bb! *-![`[b_!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!LC;A!:<89!<:@!;C;D9!5I!b1(*<!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!39?)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! 3<:@?;5:9! B57:@^;5EE9@! ?;9D9! 5I% ,*)2*$0'2',2'0! LC;A! a!A5BCZ5:;<D!DC:9?!;9K;!C:!;A9!D5L9B!E<B;!>9<BC:P!:<89!<:@!;C;D9!

5I!b1(*<9!(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%J9%YE%$+<2,'%*%"+2,&%b1(*<%(&,%)+0%%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!"+2,&I%b1(*<%d7?;CIC9@!

!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!cB<:M9!W_V"2![#)!

/D!&<>CQC!W_##2![W)!!

+<:P9!h!36AwI9B!W_`[^[bO!(2![#V)!

3<J9@![``V2![aa)!

*5889:;2!cB<:M9!W_V]2!:5)!W`a)!!

T9BD9F!W_#V2![]W)!!

!! !

Page 81: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]bb!

%)(()ba! T1![]_!

eW[W"f!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!5;C2)0%$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!39?)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! SAC;9! DC89?;5:9!?;9D9!LC;A!EB<J9B?! ;5!,?CBC?^NA9:;<89:;C7O!

+5B@!5I!%>J@5?!<:@!5;A9B!P5@?!I5B!A9B9@C;<BJ!EBC:69!5;C2)09%'A9! C:?6BCE;C5:! 65:;<C:?! <:! 97D5PJ! 5I! ;A9! @969<?9@!

B9EB9?9:;9@! 5:! ;A9! D9I;! ?C@9! 5I! ;A9! ?;9D9! ;5P9;A9B!LC;A! AC?!

I<8CDJ! C:! I57B! FCP:9;;9?)! 'A9! C:?6BCE;C5:! @9F9D5E?! C:! ]!

A5BCZ5:;<D! DC:9?! C:! ;A9! D7:9;;9!<:@! C:!#!F9B;C6<D! DC:9?!5:! ;A9!

?C@9!5I!;A9!B9EB9?9:;<;C5:?)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%%6)!]G%#)"+%*%@+%*;%,-%

!

1<@9!C:!DCI9!>J!X5B7?O!+5B@!5I!;A9!,-%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!3C8E?5:!W_V]2!%U,*!a_)[O!ED)!V)!!

X'T1O!"2!ED)!"#)!

*5889:;2!45K9J!W__V2!"##)!

!! !

Page 82: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]ba!

%)(()b#! ET1!W`#b[!

!=E&<89??978!

*G!

456789:;!;C;D9! $<EJB7?!IB58!398:<)!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 398:<)!39?)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! $<EJB7?! 65:;<C:C:PO! 5:! ;A9! +6T'UO! 65EC9?! 5I! <! :78>9B! 5I!

@C?E<;6A9?! ?9:;! IB58! ;A9! I5B;B9??! 5I! 398:<! @7BC:P! ;A9!

B9CP:! 5I! 39?5?;BC?! ((()! SBC;9B?! 5I! AC?! 65BB9?E5:@9:69! <B9!

7:M:5L:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

D)!W`^WWG!$0%7&0%*;%*%"+2*#0'%,*)%0.&%#*;%,.%0.&!

!

%DD!;A9!<II<CB?!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'%<B9!?<I9!<:@!EB5?E9B57?!

!

U5;9?2!!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!38C;A9B!W_]b2!_O!ED)!bO!D)!_k!E)!W`O!ED)!aO!D)!WWk!E)!aO!ED)![O!D)!WW)!!

$1!W2[O!a#_)!!

!! !

Page 83: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]b#!

%)(()bV! 81<:6A!

""`a!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!5;C2)02+*2942*4+%!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!39?)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:!;A9!D7:9;;9!<;!;A9!;5E!5I!;A9!?;9D9!;A9B9!<B9!]!A5BCZ5:;<D!

DC:9?! 5I! C:?6BCE;C5:?k! >9D5L! ;A9! D7:9;;9! C?! <! ?69:9!

B9EB9?9:;C:P! ;A9! @969<?9@! ?9<;9@! 5:! <! ;AB5:9! >9I5B9! <!

;<>D9!5I!5II9BC:P?!ED9:;CI7DDJ!EB5FC@9@!LC;A! I55@!<:@!@BC:M)!

,:! ;A9! 5EE5?C;9! ?C@9! 5I! ;A9! 5II9BC:P! ;<>D9! ;A9B9! <B9! a!

ICP7B9?! <BB<:P9@! C:! [! B5L?! 5I! "! 9<6A)! .:@9B! ;A9! ?69:9!

>9PC:?!;A9!AC?;5BC6<D!C:?6BCE;C5:!LAC6A!5667EC9?!;A9!LA5D9!5I!

;A9!D5L9B!E<B;!5I!;A9!?;9D9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!W^[G%0.&%-(94%(%).$%+%#)+'%=*'0%5''%#"+%-(94%+%#"&'%5C(C%(%+*9#*%+.$'%-(94%'"%*4+%0.&%+%7*0%,*)%0.&%#*;%%%%6)!W[^W"G%),$%-(%*%F#0'2;$'<%B,2C&02?,%(&,2)+0%(%!(,2#%(-2#%-+%#'%@+%*'%,*)0%+.$'%-(94%$+$%C&'%(%,-&%(%)'%+%S#%-(94%(%#%c%*%7*0%%%%%D)!W#G%,-,9*9$%).$%0$%-+%-#%(%#%L%*%7*0!

!

XC?!1<d9?;J!L9:;!@5L:!;A9!BCF9B!;5!

5F9B;AB5L!;A9!=*'0%5I!5''9%XC?!1<d9?;J!

<BBCF9@!<;!<!B9PC5:!LA5?9!:<89!C?!5C(C9%XC?!1<d9?;J!8<@9!<!EB5?E9B57?!>9PC::C:P!5I!

B9;7B:C:P!;5!;A9!7*0I%D)!E)!A)!!

SA9:!;A9!8<d9?;J!5I!;A9!MC:P!5I!.EE9B!<:@!

+5L9B!/PJE;!=39?5?;BC?!(((G!<B5?9!C:!;A9!

@57>D9^6B5L:!5:!;A9!X5B7?^;AB5:9!5I!;A9!

MC:PO!XC?!1<d9?;J!6<7?9@!89!;5!<@5E;!;A9!

EB5I9??C5:!5I!L<BBC5B!5I!;A9!P7<B@!=qG!>J!;A9!

?C@9!5I!XC?!1<d9?;J!<85:P!#!89:!5I!;A9!7*0%%'A9:!(!6<89!@5L:?;B9<8!C:!<;;9:@<:69!

<85:P!a!89:!5I!;A9%7*0%!

U5;9?2!!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!39;A9!W_b_2!V"O!D)!"O!_!<:@!_)!!

$1!b2WO!aa)!!

$99;!W_W]>2!]^bO!D)!*W]sW#k!ED)!W^[O!D)!*[)!!

-<B?;<:P!W_`W2!ED)!]^b)!

!! !

Page 84: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]bV!

%)(()b_! %>J@5?!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!W#+2#+'9#*%$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!39?)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! +C89?;5:9! ?;9D9! IB58! ;A9! 6989;9BJ! 5I! %>J@5?)! %;! ;A9! D9I;^?C@9!>5;;58!;A9!@969<?9@!C?!?A5L:!C:!IB5:;!5I!AC?!5II9BC:P?k!W#!A5BCZ5:;<D!DC:9?!5I!C:?6BCE;C5:!658E5?9!;A9!8<C:!;9K;)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%$+<2,'%*%,-%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!,-%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

cB<:MI5B;!W_[V2!:5)!aO!ED)![`O!ICP)![)!

*5889:;2!S<B@!W_V[2!:5)!]b_)!

!! !

Page 85: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]b_!

%)(()a`! T9BDC:!W[`]!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!>1<27+2*4+'!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!39?)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'A9!B57:@^;5EE9@!?;9D9!?A5L?!;A9!?;<:@C:P!ICP7B9!5I!,?CBC?O!

7:@9B!;A9!LC:P9@!?7:!@C6MO!LAC6A!I<69?!;A9!;C;D9?!5I!39?5?;BC?!

((()!T9D5L!C?!;A9!8<C:!;9K;!C:![]!DC:9?)!%;!;A9!>5;;58!>17+2*4+'!?C;?! I<6C:P! <:! 5II9BC:P^;<>D9! <:@! 898>9B?! 5I! AC?! I<8CDJ)!

37>?C@C<BJ! ;9K;?O! 65:?C?;C:P!5I! ;A9! ;C;DC:P!5I! 39?5?;BC?! (((! <:@!

;A9! 9EC;A9;?! 5I! >17+2*4+'O! B7:! C:! F9B;C6<D! 65D78:?! <D5:P! ;A9!

57;9B! 9@P9?! 5I! ;A9! ?;9D9)! >17+2*4+'! L<?! 6A<BP9@! LC;A! ;A9!5BP<:CZ<;C5:! 5I! ;A9! <::7<D! I9?;CF<D! 5I! ,?CBC?! C:! LAC6A! ;A9!

?;<;79! 5I! ;A9! P5@! d57B:9J9@! >9;L99:! AC?! ;98ED9! <:@! AC?!

;58>)!

!

%)!1<C:!;9K;)!

T)!,:9!65D78:!C:?6BCE;C5:!C:!;A9!D9I;^?C@9!65B:C69)!

!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)!

%a^#G!$0%)"+%*9C%$#%(%#.'<%-(94%.0&D'E%0,%*%,-%!

!

!

["G!$*$%#8'%W#$+2)*'2$(*'%*;:%W#$+%&;.0%*%,-94%%T)!

0+%$.'%(%"+2*#0'%

!

=;A9!MC:P!C?!?E9<MC:PG!R57!A<F9!C:@99@!PB5L:!

7E!<?!<!I5?;9B^?5:!5I!1J!1<d9?;J!<:@!?5D9!

E7ECD!5I!;A9!,-!!

(!>B57PA;!e,?CBC?!NA9:;<89:;A9?O!+5B@!5If!

%>J@5?O!;5!AC?!,-!!

!

1<P:<;9!5I!69:?C:P!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!36AwI9B!W_`]2!""^bO!I)!!

%zTO!(2!W#`)!

3C8E?5:!W_#]2!%U,*!W)WO!ED)!W)!!

39;A9!W_b_2!#`^#WO!D)![W)!$1!b2!WO!_#)!

'B<:?D<;C5:2!+C6A;A9C8!W_VV2!_V^__)!

*5889:;2!S<B@!W_V[2!:5)!#Wa)!

!! !

Page 86: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]a`!

%)(()aW! %?L<:!;58>!

"a!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!5&2+*"'2'0I%EBC:69!5I!/D9EA<:;C:9)!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %?L<:)!39?)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)! (:?6BCE;C5:?! 5F9B! <:@! 5:! 9C;A9B! ?C@9! 5I! ;A9! @55BL<J!

D9<@C:P!IB58!;A9!I5B9657B;!C:;5!;A9!C:;9BC5B!5I!;A9!;58>)!

!

T)! (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!65F9B9@!P<DD9BJ! C:!IB5:;!5I!;A9!;58>!

EB5E9BO! ?7EE5B;9@!>J!a!?\7<B9!ECDD<B?!LAC6A!L9B9! C:?6BC>9@!

5:!<DD!I57B!I<69?)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%%%)!D)!b^aG!-+%.;&'%(%S+'%*;0%)&#0'%$(<2+%*#0'%$"&'2#'*%8*:94%$*$0%(.&%(%;&C0%-P&0'%#('%#+$%#S+%(%7*0%#-2*'+%*%-;2#.%!#"%-*C%(%!"#%.$%*#0'%(%,-%-+%-(09C%(%*'+%,-,0%)'4%-+%*'+%D99E%$(<2+%,-,0%0+%(%"+2*#0'%#"..%"+2-.%!!!!!!D)!_^WWG!$0%.7*9*9$%-('0%+%C&0'%(%(*$2"+9$%-#$9*%0$%-(94%[-+94]%0+%,!&%+%P*;'%-*0'%'&%D$#$E%,"+%(%),0%"+2*#0'%(*)'%(%)'%*;'%(-%(%7C+0%,"+%(%,P0%#)0#%(%&)'%*94%*;'%**%.$%S&09$+%+%.;-'9$%"+2-.%(%.;-'9$%!!!!!!!T)!$CDD<B!bG%)*'%*#0'%0;&%NW%*94%#)+<%,-%

!!=,:9!LA5?9G!:<89!C?!7E5:!;A9!?CP:9;^BC:P?!C:!<DD!;A9!;AC:P?!5I!I5B9CP:!657:;BJ!C:!;A9!B5J<D!<E<B;89:;?O!;5!LA58!;A9!EB5@769!5I!(.&!C?!B9E5B;9@O!:<89DJ!;A9!;BC>7;9!5I!;A9!EBC:69?!5I!;A9!@9?9B;?O!E<??C:P!;A9!:CPA;!=qG!C:!;A9!;98ED9!5:!;A9!PB9<;!I9<?;^@<JO!B969CFC:P!EB9?9:;?!5I!;A9!65?;DJ!;AC:P?!PCF9:!>J!;A9!MC:P!C:!;A9!,-O!d7>CD<:;!=qG!C:!;A9!@CFC:9!><BM!>9I5B9!;A9!P5@!=))GO!PB9<;!5F9B?99B!5I!?ACE?!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'O!I7B:C?AC:P!;A9!;B9<?7BJ!!(!<EE5C:;9@!6B<I;?89:!;5!;A9!L5BM!C:!8J!;58>O!<:@!XC?!1<d9?;J!EB<C?9@!89!5:!<6657:;!5I!C;!F9BJ!PB9<;DJ!<:@!F9BJ!5I;9:!C:!;A9!EB9?9:69!5I!;A9!657B;C9B?!<:@!;A9!+<@J!5I!;A9!D<:@k!C;!>9C:P!EB5FC@9@!LC;A!I7B:C;7B9!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'O!<@5B:9@!LC;A!F9BJ!B9\7C?C;9O!ICDD9@!LC;A!5B:<89:;?O!EB5FC@9@!LC;A!>B9<@^5II9BC:P?O!IC;;9@!57;!LC;A!<DD!;A<;!L<?!>9:9IC;C:P!;5!C;)!(!L<?!:5;!<DD5L9@!;5!D<6M!LA<;!C?!B9\7CB9@O!;A9!;B9<?7BJ!L<?!=;A9!ED<69G!LA9:69!;A5?9!;AC:P?!L9B9!<?M9@!I5B!89)!!!(:!IB5:;!5I!;A9!MC:PO!5E9:!;5!AC8!6588<:@9B!5I!;A9!,-%!

U5;9?2!W!7:B9<@<>D9!?CP:)!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!W_`_>2!W["^W][2!W""O!ED)!V6)!!

/@9D!W_a[2!W`"^])!!

.&N!Y((2![^"O!aO!D)!Wb)!!

$1!b2!WO!["V^_)!

!!

Page 87: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]aW!

%)(()a[! T1!Wb]!

ebabf!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!>1(*<<!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!39?)!(((!q!

49?6BCE;C5:! $<C:;9@! DC89?;5:9! ?;9D9! 5I! ;A9! $<D<69^P7<B@C<:! 5I! $A<B<5A!

>1(*<<%LC;A!B9EB9?9:;<;C5:!5I!5II9BC:P?!C:!;A9!D7:9;;9O!<!DC:9!5I! C:?6BCE;C5:O! <! ?69:9! 5I! ;A9! 5L:9B! <:@! ;L5! 5II9BC:P?!

>9<B9B?!LC;A!?6<;;9B9@! C:?6BCE;C5:?O!<! DC:9!5I! C:?6BCE;C5:!<:@!

<:5;A9B!?69:9!LC;A!;A9!5L:9B!<6658E<:C9@!>J!I57B!L589:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%$+<2,'%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!"+2,&O!D)!E)!A)!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!X'T1O![2!ED)!W`)!

*5889:;2!cB<:M9!W_V]2!:5)!W`a)!!

T9BD9F!W_#V2!![]Wk!>s6)!!

cB<:M9!W_V"2![#)!

9D^3<J9@!![``V2![a[)!

!! !

Page 88: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]a[!

%)(()a"! *-![`W]`!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!>1<2)+2*4+'!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!39?)!(((!^!%8)!((()!!

49?6BCE;C5:! &57:@^;5EE9@! ?;9D9! LC;A! 9J9?! C:! ;A9! D7:9;;9O! <!

B9EB9?9:;<;C5:! 5I! ;A9! @969<?9@! C:! IB5:;! 5I! <! ;<>D9! 5I!

5II9BC:P?! <:@! ;L5! 5II9BC:P! >9<B9B?! C:! ;A9!8C@@D9O! <! B5L! 5I!

@CP:C;<BC9?! M:99DC:P! <;! ;A9! >5;;58)! '9K;! 65:?C?;?! 5I! "!

A5BCZ5:;<D! DC:9?! <>5F9! ;A9! ICP7B<;CF9! ?69:9! <:@! W! DC:9! 5I!

C:?6BCE;C5:! >9;L99:! ;A9! 69:;B<D! B9EB9?9:;<;C5:! <:@! ;A9!

D5L9?;!5:9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!"G%$+<2,'%*%"+2,&%%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!C:!;A9!"+2,&!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!cB<:M9!W_V]2!:5)!["b)!!

3C8E?5:!W_#]2!%U,*!W)"O!ED)![)!!

*5889:;2!T9BD9F!W_#V2![]WO![]#)!

+<:P9!h!36AwI9B!W_`[^[bO!(2!Wab)!!

!! !

Page 89: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]a"!

!

%)(()a]! *-![`b"V!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!5'"2$;2'2+,!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58!=%8)!(((G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 47BC:P! ;A9! B9CP:! 5I! %89:98A<;! (((! 5'"2$;2'2+,% 9B96;9@! I5B!AC8?9DI! <! I7:9B<BJ!85:789:;! <;! %>J@5?! C:! ;A9! ?A<E9! 5I! <!

;<DDO!IB99?;<:@C:P!DC89?;5:9!?;9D9!LAC6A!C?!C:?6BC>9@!5:!>5;A!

I<69?!<:@!5:!;A9!;AC6M:9??!5I!;A9!?C@9?)!,:!;A9!B96;5O!7:@9B!

;A9!B57:@!;5EO! ;A9!?;<:@C:P!ICP7B9!5I!,?CBC?! I<69?!;A9!;C;DC:P!

5I!%89:98A<;!(((O!<:@!5:!;A9!V6+#U!;A<;!5I!39?5?;BC?!((()!'A9!V6+#U! 65:?C?;?! 5I! <:! <7;5>C5PB<EAJ! <:@! <:! (:?;B76;C5:! C:!LAC6A!BCPA;!65:@76;!C?!@9IC:9@!C:!;9B8?!5I!D5J<D;J!;5!;A9!MC:P)!

(:?6BCE;C5:?! IB58! ;A9! +6T'U! 65:;<C:C:P! <! ?;JDCZ9@!

<7;5>C5PB<EAJ!DC8C;9@!;5!?9DI^D<7@<;5BJ!9EC;A9;?)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

D)!bG!$(<2+%C&0'%*;0%*%"+2*#0'!!

D)!VG!$0%+#<%,&%*%"+2*#0'!!

D)!W`G!#(+%@+%*;%,-!!

!

,F9B?99B!5I!<DD!;A9!L5BM?!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'!!

-B9<;!?57;A9B:!ECDD<B!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'!!

cBC9:@!5I!X5B7?O!+5B@!5I!;A9!,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!+<:P9^36AwI9B!W_`[^[bO!((2!W]b^Wb`O!ED)!]`)!!

1<BC9;;9!WVV`O![2!"]!<:@!ED?)![]^[a)!!

39;A9!W_b_2!#`O!D)!W)!$1!b2WO!]b)!

N<8<D!W_"V2![ab!II)!

N<8<D!W_]`2![`_!II)!

'B<:?D<;C5:2!+C6A;A9C8!W_#"^W_V`O!(2!W[#)!!

/B8<:![``b2!V]^Vb)!

*5889:;2!45K9J!W__V2!]bO![bb)!S<B@!W_V[2!:5)!Wa)!

!! !

Page 90: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]a]!

%)(()ab! +57FB9!/!

WW`b"!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;<;79!5I!>1(*2(2-&'2*2,*)!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! c<CJ78)!%8)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! 3;<:@C:P!?;<;79!LC;A!F9B;C6<D!C:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!@5B?<D!ECDD<B)!

'C;D9!C:?6BC>9@!5:!;A9!D9I;!?C@9^I<69!5I!;A9!ECDD<B)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%-+<2#!'&%*%#'%0+'%(%,-%0+%*;2G.<'%%

!

N99E9B!5I!?96B9;?!C:!;A9!PB9<;!ED<69!5I!;A9!

PB9<;!,-%5I!=;A9!;98ED9!5IG!*B565@CD5E5DC?!C:!

;A9!c<CJ78)!

!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!49D<:P9!W_V#2!a_^#W)!!

/F9B?!W_[_2!_a)!!

Y<:@9B?D9J9:!W_#b2!Wa_!<)>)!

!

! !

Page 91: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]ab!

%)(()aa! +57FB9!*!""!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!M"<!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!%8)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! &57:@! ;5EE9@! ?;9D9! LC;A! 9J9?! C:! ;A9! D7:9;;9! <:@! <!

B9EB9?9:;<;C5:! 5I! ;A9! @969<?9@! C:! IB5:;! 5I! ;A9! ;<>D9! 5I!

5II9BC:P?! C:! ;A9! 8C@@D9)! 'A9! ;9K;! @9F9D5E?! C:! "! A5BCZ5:;<D!

DC:9?!>9;L99:!;A9!D7:9;;9!<:@!;A9!ICP7B9?!<:@!C:!#!A5BCZ5:;<D!

DC:9?! 7:@9B! ;A9! B9EB9?9:;<;C5:)! 'C;D9! B9E9<;9@! C:! ?9F9B<D!

E<B;?!5I!;A9!?;9D9)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%$+<2,'%*%"+2,&%%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9%"+2,&%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!3C8E?5:!W_#]2!%U,*!W)W`O!ED)!])!!

-<J9;!WVVa2!ED)!bV)!

*5889:;2!cB<:M9!W_V]2!:5)!["b)!!

T9BD9F!W_#V2![]WO![]#)!!

S<B@!W_V[2!:5)!]#a)!

!

! !

Page 92: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]aa!

%)(()a#! X<88<8<;!

W#!

456789:;!;C;D9! -B<IIC;5!5I!@'"<!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! X<88<8<;)!%8)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%%D)!Wa^W#G!$"0'<%0+%*;'%,-%+%$*$/0%*'%(*0%*%-(%*94%%

!

-B9<;!89??9:P9B!5I!9F9BJ!,-%I5B!;A9!$*0!5I!9F9BJ!85:789:;?!5I!XC?!1<d9?;J!

!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!!*57J<;!h!15:;9;!W_W[2!]`O!ED)!bO!:5)!W#O!D)!W#)!!

$1!#2!WO!""W)!

!

! !

Page 93: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]a#!

%)(()aV! T1!W#b!

eW`Wf!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!F;2"02W#+'2#*!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!%8)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! -B9J! DC89?;5:9! ?;9D9! IB<89@! >J! <! ;5B7?! 5B:<89:;! <:@!

?7B857:;9@!LC;A!<!E<D8^>B<:6A!65B:C69)!'A9!?7BI<69!LC;AC:!

;A9! IB<89! C?! @CFC@9@! C:! ;AB99! E<B;?2! C:! ;A9! 7EE9B85?;O! 5:!

9C;A9B! ?C@9! 5I! V! F9B;C6<D! DC:9?! 5I! ;9K;O! ;A9B9! C?! <! ?;<:@C:P!

ICP7B9!5I!F;2"025*2W#+'% C:! B9DC9IO!LC;A! <! ?C:PD9! F9B;C6<D! DC:9!>9AC:@! AC8)! _! F9B;C6<D! DC:9?! 5I! ;9K;! <B9! 6<BF9@! C:! ;A9! BCPA;!

A<:@!A<DI!5I!;A9!69:;B<D!E5B;C5:O!<:@!C:!;A9!D9I;!A<:@!F;2"025*2W#+'!C?!@9EC6;9@!?C;;C:P!>9I5B9!<!;<>D9!65F9B9@!LC;A!?DC69?!5I!>B9<@! C:! IB5:;!5I!LAC6A! D<C@!5;A9B!5II9BC:P?)!c9L! DC:9?!5I!

;9K;!<:@!?589!@9?6BCE;CF9!D<>9D?!<6658E<:J!;AC?!?69:9)!!

%)! (:?6BCE;C5:! 5EE5?C;9! ;A9! D9I;! A<:@! ICP7B9! 5I! F;2"025*2W#+'9%T)!(:?6BCE;C5:!C:!IB5:;!5I!;A9!ICP7B9!5:!;A9!BCPA;)!

*)! TC5PB<EAC6<D! C:?6BCE;C5:! 5667EJC:P! ;A9! BCPA;! A<:@! A<DI! 5I!

;A9!8C@@D9!?96;C5:!5I!;A9!?;9D9)!

4)!'9K;!C:!;A9!>5;;58!?96;C5:!5I!;A9!?;9D9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

%)%0*2-+%*%*4+2-&'<%!(#0%"+2,&%F;2"02W#+'2#*%(%(&&94%W#$+%(&,%)'4%(2;&-%"#.<'%-'"94%(%,-94%&0$%$;94!%%%%`9%0*2-+%*%*4+2-&'<%!(#0%"+2,&%F;2"02W#+'2#*%(%(&%&94%)*'%"+$94%*4+0'%W"20&0'%(%$094%-'"%+%,-94%*%#)()2$;%0*0'%*'+%-0'%(%-,,0'%%%%%d9%..%(.00%$*%*4+2-&'<%!(#0%"+2,&%F;2"02W#+'2#*%(&,2)+0%)"+%+.0<%*%*#0'%#;&'D<E%@+%*;%,-%$0%$+9*9$%%#(+%7+%+.%*#0'%(%-;2#.%%%%%\9%*4+2-&'<%!(#0%"+2,&%F;9$2"02W#+'2#*%%

!

'A9!?CPA;!5I!;A9!N99E9B!5I!;A9!4C<@98O!

B9;<C:9B!5I!;A9!"+2,&O!F;2"025*2W#+'I%C?!5E9:9@!;A<;!=[G!A9!8<J!?99!,?CBC?!LA9:!A9!C?!

d7?;CIC9@!C:!;A9!EB9?9:69!5I!;A9!'L5!/::9<@?!

LA9:!A9!B9?;?!="G!C:!AC?!,-!<:@!AC?!A9<B;!C?!PD<@!I5B9F9B!

!

'A9!?CPA;!5I!;A9!N99E9B!5I!;A9!4C<@98O!

B9;<C:9B!5I!;A9!"+2,&O!F;2"025*2W#+'I%C?!5E9:9@!;A<;!=[G!A9!8<J!?99!;A9!>9<7;J!5I!

W"20&0'%;!C:!AC?!P55@DJ!EB569??C5:O!LA9:!A9!9:;9B?!C:!E9<69!="G!C:;5!AC?!,-!5I!49DCPA;O!;A9!EBC9?;A55@!5I!;A9!;98ED9!>9C:P!C:!PD<@:9??)!

!

3E996A!5I!;A9!N99E9B!5I!;A9!4C<@98O!?9BF<:;!

5I!;A9!"+2,&O!=[G!;A9!d7?;CIC9@!F;2"025*2W#+'I%<!6ACD@!LA5!PB9L!7E!<;!;A9!I99;!5I!;A9!MC:PO!<!

@C?6CED9!="G!5I!X5B7?O!+5B@!5I!;A9!,-!?<J?2!(!<6;9@!<?!658E<:C5:!LA5!6<BBC9?!=]G!;A9!

NC:PQ?!I55;^9F9B!<;!;A9!56.^I9?;CF<D!!

'A9!N99E9B!5I!;A9!4C<@98O!B9;<C:9B!5I!;A9!"+2

Page 94: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]aV!

,&I%F;2"02W#+'2#*!U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!TD<6M8<:!W_]a2!W!II)O!ED)!W)!!

X'T1!((2!ED)![)!$1!b2WO!_a)!

'B<:?D<;C5:2!+C6A;A9C8!W_VV2!W[")!!

$<BMC:?5:!W__W2!W]`^W)!

!

! !

Page 95: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]a_!

%)(()a_! +57FB9!*!b!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!a'2#'<20+'!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!%8)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! &57:@!;5EE9@!?;9D9!LC;A!9J9?!C:!;A9!D7:9;;9!<:@!b!B9PC?;9B?!

LC;A! B9EB9?9:;<;C5:! 5I! 5II9BC:P?! ;5! ;A9! @969<?9@O! ?A5L:!

?9<;9@!C:!IB5:;!5I!<!;<>D9!5:!;A9!D9I;!A<DI!5I!;A9!ICB?;!B9PC?;9B)!

(:?6BCE;C5:!@9F9D5E?! C:!]!A5BCZ5:;<D! DC:9?!7:@9B!;A9! D7:9;;9O!

>9;L99:!;A9!ICP7B9!<:@!C:!;A9!65B:C69!5I!;A9!?;9D9)!

%^*)!'C;D9?!B9E9<;9@!?9F9B<D!;C89?!C:!;A9!C:?6BCE;C5:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%%9%$(<2+%,7*0'<%*%)&%*%"+%*%)'(0%%%T9%$(<2+%,7*0'<%*%"+D0E%*%)'(0%%%*)%$+<2,'%*%"+2,&%%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!,%7*0'<%5I!;A9!5IIC69!5I!;A9!A57?9!5I!;A9!?9<D9B!

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!,%7*0'<%5I!;A9!A57?9!5I!;A9!?9<D9B!

%,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9%"+2,&%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!3C8E?5:!W_#]2!%U,*!W)#O!ED)!")!!

*5889:;2!cB<:M9!W_V]2!:5)!["b)!!

T9BD9F!W_#V2![]WO![]#)!!

S<B@!W_V[2!:5)!]#a)!

!

! !

Page 96: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]#`!

%)(()#`! X<88<8<;!

]"!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!>1(*2(2-&'!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! S<@C!X<88<8<;)!%8)!(((O!R)![)!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:! C:! ;A9!8<C:!A<DD! 658E5?9@!>J!W!A5BCZ5:;<D! DC:9!

<:@!W[!F9B;C6<D!DC:9?)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!W`G!-'"2$;%@+%*;%,-%%

!

$D9<?C:P!;5!X5B7?O!+5B@!5I!;A9!,-!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!*57J<;!^!15:;9;!W_W[^W"2!ED)!W]O!]_!k!W"O!D)!W`)!!

$1!#2!WO!""W)!

*5889:;2!45K9J!W__V2![a]O!"b[)!

!

! !

Page 97: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]#W!

%)(()#W! 17?{9!

-7C89;!*!a!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!W#+'2#*2,*)%!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!39?)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! &57:@^;5EE9@! ?;9D9! LC;A! 9J9?! C:! ;A9! D7:9;;9! <:@! W`!

A5BCZ5:;<D!DC:9?!C:?6BCE;C5:)!'C;D9!B9I9BB9@!;5!W#+'2#*2,*)%<:@!;5!>1(*<)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!"O!a^#G%$+<2,'%*%"+2,&%%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!"+2,&!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!15B9;!W_`_2!*aO!ED)!bO!a)!!

3<J9@![``V2![ab)!

*5889:;2!cB<:M9!W_V]2!:5)!W`aO!b``)!!

X5@d<6A9!h!T9BD9F!W_#b2!a)!!

/D!&<>CQC!W_##2![W)!!

cB<:M9!W_V"2![#)!

!

! !

Page 98: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]#[!

%)(()#[! 8$C;;!

*<B:9PC9!

]bbV!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!F;2,*)%?5:!5I!5;C2-'"e!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58!=U9I)!(!h!35>)!(YG)!

49?6BCE;C5:! T<?9!5I!<!?9<;9@!ICP7B9!C:!>D<6M!?;5:9O!I57:@!C:!;A9!ICDDC:P!5I!

;A9!6A<8>9B!0!bV!C:!*989;9BJ!5I!%>J@5?)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!

D9I;!?C@9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%#(+%,-%%%

!

*58E<:C5:!5I!;A9!,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!U<FCDD9!^!$99;!h!X<DD!W_W"^W]2!$D)!Wbk!E)!WWb)!

*5889:;2!45K9J!W__V2!"#")!

!

! !

Page 99: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]#"!

%)(()#"! &(N!W`a!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!F;2!&;'%!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N788<)!39?)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! &56M!C:?6BCE;C5:2!"!A5BCZ5:;<D!DC:9?!;9K;)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)![G%$+<2,'%*%"+2,&%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!"+2,&!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!47:A<8!h!g<:?9::!W_a`^#O!W2!:5)!W`a)!

*5889:;2!cB<:M9!W_V]2!:5)!"`#)!!

T9BD9F!W_#V2![]WO![]V)!

!

! !

Page 100: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]#]!

%)(()#]! 3C:<C!_V!^!

,(1!Vaa"!

=,BC9:;<D!

(:?;C;7;9!

17?978O!

*AC6<P5O!.3%G!!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;<;79;;9!!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3C:<C!=39B<>C;!9D^NA<@C8G)!%8)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! 38<DD!B9@!?<:@?;5:9!?;<;79;;9!5I!<!?C;;C:P!L58<:!C:!<! D5:P!

6D5?9^IC;;C:P!P<B89:;)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!><6M!5I!;A9!?9<;)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%6)![G%@+%*;%,-%

!

X5B7?O!+5B@!5I!;A9!,-!!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!h!$99;!h!y9B:J!W_b[^bbO!((2!W`bO!ED)!"")!!

$1!#2WO!"bV)!

!

! !

Page 101: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]#b!

%)(()#b! 3C:<C!WW`!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!LC;A!;A9!:<89?!<:@!;C;D9!5I!?*942#*;%<:@!?*2#*;!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3C:<C!=39B<>C;!9D^NA<@C8G)!%8)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! &57:@^;5EE9@! ?;9D9!LAC6A! I5B89@! ;A9!U5B;A!$5B;C65!5I! ;A9!

3<:6;7<BJ!<;!39B<>C;!9D^NA<@C8)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!L9?;!9@P9!

DC?;C:P!;A9!9KE9@C;C5:<BJ!?;<II)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%DD)!a^#G!$+<2,'%*%"+2,&%%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!"+2,&!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!^!$99;!^!y9B:J!W_b[^bb2!WW[^"O!ED)!"b%)!

*5889:;2!T9BD9F!W_#V2![]WO!:5)![[k![]VO!:5)!Wa_)!!

cB<:M9!W_V]2!:5)!"V")!

!

! !

Page 102: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]#a!

%)(()#a! 3C:<C!WW[!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!5*42+'!!!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3C:<C!=39B<>C;!9D^NA<@C8G)!%8)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! &57:@^;5EE9@!?;9D9!LAC6A!L<?! D56<;9@!<;!;A9!:5B;AL9?;9B:!

65B:9B! 5I! ;A9! $5B6A! C:! ;A9! 3<:6;7<BJ! <;! 39B<>C;! 9D^NA<@C8)!

(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!9<?;!I<69!5I!;A9!?;9D9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)![G!+)%#'%+.94%(%"+2*#0'%%

!

,:9!LA5!M:5L?!AC?!?;<:@C:P!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!^!$99;!^!y9B:J!W_b[^bb2!E)!WW]O!ED)!"#O!D)!/)!!

$1!#2!WO!"bb)!

*5889:;2!45K9J!W__V2!W[])!

!

! !

Page 103: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]##!

%)(()##! 3C:<C!WW]!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!LC;A!:<89!<:@!;C;D9!5I!5$2*<2W#+'%!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3C:<C!=39B<>C;!9D^NA<@C8G)!%8)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! &57:@^;5EE9@! ?;9D9! I5B8C:P! ;A9!9<?;!L<DD! 5I! ;A9! 3<:6;7<BJ!

<;!39B<>C;!9D^NA<@C8)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!?57;A9B:!9@P9!5I!;A9!

?;9D9!65:;<C:C:P!<!DC?;!5I!5IIC6C<D?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%J9%cE%$+<2,'%*%"+2,&%%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!"+2,&!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!h!$99;!h!y9B:J!W_b[^bb2!WW#O!ED)!"VO!D)!S)!!

39JIBC9@!W_VW2!WabO!W##)!!

$1!#2WO!"bb)!

*5889:;2!T9BD9F!W_#V2![]WO![]_)!!

cB<:M9!W_V]2!:5)!]VV)!!

!! !

Page 104: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]#V!

%)(()#V! 3C:<C!Vb!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!LC;A!:<89!<:@!;C;D9!5I!F;2(#W%$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3C:<C!=39B<>C;!9D^NA<@C8G)!%8)!(((O!R)!])!

49?6BCE;C5:! 3;9D9!LC;A! DC?;! 5I! 5IIC6C<D?)! (:?6BCE;C5:! 5:! ;A9! :5B;A! 9@P9! 5I!;A9!85:789:;)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

D)!aG!$+<2,'%*%"+2,&%%%%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!"+2,&%%!

U5;9?2!W!'A9!@56789:;!65:;<C:?!<!DC?;!5I!:<89?!5I!;A9!658E<:J!5I!J57;A?!9:;B7?;9@!;5!

X<;A5B)!'A9!;C;D9!>1+<%,$'%*<%"+2,&%%>9D5:P?!;5!<!8<:!:<89@!F;2(#9!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!h!$99;!h!y9B:J!W_b[^bb2!_[O!ED)![")!

*5889:;2!T9BD9F!W_#V2![bWO![][)!!

cB<:M9!W_V]2!:5)!#W_)!

!! !

Page 105: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]#_!

%)(()#_! 3C:<C!Va!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!LC;A!:<89!<:@!;C;D9!5I!>1*<!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3C:<C!=39B<>C;!9D^NA<@C8G)!%8)!(((O!R)!b)!

49?6BCE;C5:! &56M! ?;9D9! IB58! 39B<>C;! 9D^NA<@C8! :5L! C:! ;A9! *A<@LC6M!

17?978O! T5D;5:O! :5)! bV)`b)W)! (:?6BCE;C5:! 5:! ;A9! 7EE9B!

E5B;C5:!5I!;A9!?;9D9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%#+%"+2,&%%

!

*57B;C9B!5I!;A9!"+2,&!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!h!$99;!h!y9B:J!W_b[^bb2!!ED)![a)!!

39JIBC9@!W_VW2!"W[!I)!

*5889:;2!45K9J!W__V2!"#")!!

cB<:M9!W_V]2!:5)!bWV)!!

!! !

Page 106: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]V`!

%)(()V`! 3C:<C!V#!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!LC;A!:<89!<:@!;C;D9!5I!5&2>1*"0%!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3C:<C!=39B<>C;!9D^NA<@C8G)!%8)!(((O!R)!b)!

49?6BCE;C5:! cB<P89:;<BJ!B57:@^;5EE9@!?;9D9)!'A9!8C@@D9!E5B;C5:!D<6MC:P!

C:! <DD! I57B! I<69?)! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:! ;A9!U5B;A!9@P9!5I! ;A9! ?;9D9!

LC;A!DC?;!5I!5IIC6C<D?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!9<?;!I<69!5I!;A9!?;9D9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%%)%@+%D99E%*;%,-%

!

X5B7?!=))G!+5B@!5I!;A9!,-!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!^!$99;!^!y9B:J!W_b[^bb2!!_bO!ED)![]O!D)!/)!!

39JIBC9@!W_VW2!"W[!I)!!

$1!#2WO!"]V^_)!

*5889:;2!45K9J!W__V2!"#")!!

cB<:M9!W_V]2!:5)!bWV)!!

!! !

Page 107: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]VW!

%)(()VW! 3C:<C!VV!^!

8$ACD.:CF!/!

Wb`"`!%^*!!

456789:;!;C;D9! 38<DD!?;9D9!LC;A!;C;D9!<:@!:<89!5I!@+20+2+,%W!!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 39B<>C;!9D^NA<@C8)!%8)!(((O!R)b)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 38<DD!B57:@^;5EE9@!?;9D9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!aG%@+%*;%,-%

%X5B7?!+5B@!5I!;A9!,-%!

U5;9?2!W!'A9!:<89!5I!;A9!5L:9B!C?!D5?;)!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!h!$99;!h!y9B:J!W_b[^bbO!((2!_aO!ED)![[O!D)!a)!!

$1!#2!WO!"]V)!

!! !

Page 108: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]V[!

%)(()V[! 3C:<C!_[!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!LC;A!;A9!:<89?!<:@!;C;D9!5I!I57B!5IIC6C<D?2!5$2*<2W#+'I%5"%DNE%a*(0I%a*(0!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3C:<C!=39B<>C;!9D^NA<@C8G)!%8)!(((O!R)!W")!

49?6BCE;C5:! &57:@^;5EE9@!?;9D9! C:?6BC>9@!5:!<DD! I57B!?C@9?!LC;A!<! DC?;!5I!

5IIC6C<D?)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!L9?;!I<69)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!aG%$+<2,'%*%"+2,&%%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!"+2,&!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!^!$99;!^!y9B:J!W_b[^bb2!W``O!ED)![#)!!

39JIBC9@!W_VW2!WabO!W##)!

*5889:;2!cB<:M9!W_V]2!:5)!]VV)!!

T9BD9F!W_#V2![]WO![]_)!!

!! !

Page 109: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]V"!

%)(()V"! 3C:<C!W]"!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!LC;A!:<89!<:@!;C;D9!5I!>10942*9$!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3C:<C!=39B<>C;!9D^NA<@C8G)!%8)!(((O!R)!W#)!

49?6BCE;C5:! &57:@^;5EE9@! ?;9D9! >B5M9:! C:! ;L5! E<B;?! <:@! >7CD;! C:! ;A9!

?57;A! L<DD! 5I! ;A9! $5B6A! 5I! ;A9! 3<:6;7<BJ! <;! 39B<>C;! 9D^

NA<@C8)! (:?6BCE;C5:! 5:! ;A9! L9?;^I<69! 65:;<C:C:P! <! DC?;! 5I!

5IIC6C<D?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!]G!$+<2,'%*%"+2,&%%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!"+2,&!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!^!$99;!^!y9B:J!W_b[^bb2!W][O!ED)!b"%)!

39JIBC9@!W_VW2!3)!Waa)!

*5889:;2!cB<:M9!W_V]2!a]O!]")!

!! !

Page 110: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]V]!

%)(()V]! 3C:<C!WWb!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!LC;A!:<89!<:@!;C;D9!5I!O(#D0E!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3C:<C!=39B<>C;!9D^NA<@C8G)!%8)!(((O!R)!WV)!

49?6BCE;C5:! &57:@^;5EE9@!?;9D9!IB58!;A9!,D@!%EEB5<6A!;5!;A9!3<:6;7<BJ!

<;!39B<>C;!9D^NA<@C8)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!L9?;^I<69!65:;<C:C:P!

<!DC?;!5I!5IIC6C<D?)!

!

%) S9?;!I<69)!+C?;!5I!B5J<D!E9B?5::9D)!!

T) 357;A!/@P9)!3CK!F9B;C6<D!DC:9?!C:?6BCE;C5:)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%%)!

DD)!V^_G%$+<2,'%*%"+2,&%%%%T)!!

DD)![^"G%-&%*#0'%(&,94%#+0%*0%#'"2#&%%%%

!

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!"+2,&%%%/K<D;C:P!;A9!MC:P!LA9:!A9!?99?!;A9!5IIC6C<D?!5I!

;A9!#'"2#&%%%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!^!$99;!^!y9B:J!W_b[^bb2!!WWVO!ED)!"VO!D)!3)!!

$1!#2!WO!"]V)!

*5889:;2!cB<:M9!W_V]2!:5)!#W_)!!

T9BD9F!W_#V2![bWO![][)!!

!! !

Page 111: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]Vb!

%)(()Vb! 3C:<C!W`b!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!39B<>C;!9D^NA<@C8W)!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3C:<C!=39B<>C;!9D^NA<@C8G)!%8)!(((O!R)!"`)!

49?6BCE;C5:! &57:@^;5EE9@!?;9D9!C:?6BC>9@!5:!<DD!I57B!?C@9?!LAC6A!?;55@!C:!

;A9! :5B;A9<?;9B:! 65B:9B! 5I! ;A9! ?<:6;7<BJ! <;! 39B<>C;! 9D^

NA<@C8)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5I!;A9!:5B;A!9@P9!65:;<C:C:P!<!D5:P!DC?;!5I!

:<89?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!#G!-+<2"+%*%"+2,&%%

!

1<d5B@585H@589?;C6!?9BF<:;!5I!;A9!"+2,&!

U5;9?2!W!'A9!:<89!5I!;A9!;C;D9Q?!5L:9B!C?!D5?;)!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!^!$99;!^!y9B:J!W_b[^bb2!W`V^W`O!ED)!"])!

17B:<:9!W_#b2!"`)!!

39JIBC9@!W_VW2!W#`O!W#"O!W#a)!

*5889:;2!cB<:M9!W_V]2!#_b)!

!! !

Page 112: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]Va!

%)(()Va! 3C:<C![b!^!

8*<CB5!g/!

"Vb#"!!

456789:;!;C;D9! 38<DD!;<>D9;!5I!@;2,&%!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 1<PA|B<A)!%8)!(((O!R)![)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%DD)!"^]G%@+%*;%,-%%

%X5B7?!+5B@!5I!;A9!,-!!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!h!$99;!h!y9B:J!W_b[^bbO!((2!#_O!ED)!W`O!D)!])!!

$1!#2WO!"][)!

!! !

Page 113: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]V#!

%)(()V#! 3C:<C!bW!

456789:;!;C;D9! &56M!C:?6BCE;C5:!5I!?*42#*;!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 39B<>C;!9D^NA<@C8)!%8)!(((O!R)!"V)!

49?6BCE;C5:! &56M! C:?6BCE;C5:!5:!?;9D9k!5:!;A9! D9I;!;A9B9!<B9!B98<C:?!5I!<!

?69:9! B9EB9?9:;C:P! ;A9! MC:P! %89:98A<;! (((! LC;A! +5L9B!

/PJE;C<:! E95ED9! L5B?ACEEC:P! X<;A5B)! %;! ;A9! BCPA;! 5I! ;AC?!

?69:9!;A9B9!<B9!V!F9B;C6<D!DC:9?!5I!C:?6BCE;C5:O!;A9!ICB?;!;L5!5I!

LAC6A!<B9!A<DI^@9?;B5J9@)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

D)!"^]G!+)%*#0'%(+<!8-+<:2#!'&%8"+:2*#0'!!

!

D)!#G!@+%*;%,-!!%

!

'B79!B5J<D!<6\7<C:;<:69O!>9D5F9@!eM99E9B!5If!

?96B9;?!5I!;A9!8"+:2*#0'!!

X5B7?O!+5B@!5I!;A9!,-!!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!h!$99;!h!y9B:J!W_b[^bbO!((2!#_O!ED)!WVO!D)!#)!

$1!#2WO!"]V)!

!! !

Page 114: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]VV!

%)(()VV! 3C:<C![V!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!LC;A!:<89!<:@!;C;D9!5I!5*;2'$24<%!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3C:<C!=1<PA|B<AG)!%8)!(((O!R)!][)!

49?6BCE;C5:! &56M!;<>D9;!LC;A!DC?;!5I!5IIC6C<D?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%6)!VG%-+<2"+%*%"+2,&%%

!

1<d5B@585H@589?;C6!?9BF<:;!5I!;A9!"+2,&%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!17B:<:9!W_#b2!"`)!!

39JIBC9@!W_VW2!W#`O!W#"O!W#a)!!

-<B@C:9B!h!$99;!h!y9B:J!W_b[^bb2!a_O!ED)!W[O!D)!#)!

*5889:;2!cB<:M9!W_V]2!:5)!#_b)!

!! !

Page 115: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]V_!

%)(()V_! 3C:<C!b"!

456789:;!;C;D9! &56M!C:?6BCE;C5:!5I!5;C2-+2-;!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3C:<C!=39B<>C;!9D^NA<@C8G)!%8)!(((O!R)!]])!

49?6BCE;C5:! +<BP9!B56M!?;9D9!LC;A!65B:C69@!;5E)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

D)!_G!#+%"*%..94%#(+0!*#0'%,-%$($%$&0'%*%*#0'%#P&0%;&094%.0&%*#0'!

!

'AC?!:5>D9!?<J?2!J57!B5J<D!658E<:C5:?!5I!;A9!

,-O!PCF9!EB<C?9!;5!;A9!MC:PO!9K;5D!AC?!8CPA;O!

EB<C?9!;A9!MC:P!

!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!h!$99;!h!y9B:J!W_b[^bb2!#_O!ED)!W#O!D)!_)!!

$1!#2WO!"]b)!

!! !

Page 116: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]_`!

%)(()_`! 3C:<C!b]!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!LC;A!:<89!<:@!;C;D9!5I!M'-20+!?5:!5I!>1'0!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3C:<C!=39B<>C;!9D^NA<@C8G)!%8)!(((O!R)!]b)!

49?6BCE;C5:! *5B:C69!B56M!?9D9!IB58!1C:9!*!<;!39B<>C;!9D^NA<@C8)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

D)!aG!0%#''%*%*'<%(%,-%%%%

!

))C:P!%?C<!I5B!;A9!5:9!LA5!C?!C:!;A9!n-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!h!$99;!h!y9B:J!W_b[^bb2!V`O!ED)!WVO!D)!a)!!

$1!#2!WO!"]b)!

*5889:;2!45K9J!W__V2!"_V)!

!! !

Page 117: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]_W!

%)(()_W! &(N!WW#!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!&)'<2-'"0%$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N788<)!%8)!(((!=qG)!

49?6BCE;C5:! &56M!C:?6BCE;C5:2!"!A5BCZ5:;<D!DC:9?!;9K;)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%J9%YE%$+<2,'%D*E%,-%%%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!cB<:M9!W_V]!2!:5)![)!!

47:A<8!h!g<:?9::!W_a`^#O!W2!:5)!WW#)!

!! !

Page 118: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]_[!

%)(()_[! &(N!WWV!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!&)'<2)'"0%$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N788<)!%8)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! &56M!C:?6BCE;C5:2!b!A5BCZ5:;<D!DC:9?!;9K;)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%JJ9%KI%QE%$+<2,'%D*E%,-%%%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!47:A<8!h!g<:?9::!W_a`^#O!W2!:5)!WWV)!

*5889:;!2!cB<:M9!W_V]!2!:5)![)!

!! !

Page 119: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]_"!

%)(()_"! T1![W_!

e[bbf!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!5'(2#&94%$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!%8)!(((^(Y)!

49?6BCE;C5:! &57:@^;5EE9@! ?;9D9! LC;A! B9EB9?9:;<;C5:! 5I! ;A9! 5L:9B! <:@!AC?! I<8CDJ)! (:?6BCE;C5:! C:! ;A9! D7:9;;9!>9;L99:! ;A9! ICP7B9?!5I!%:7>C?!<:@!,?CBC?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%-+<2"+%*%"+2,&%

!

1<d5B@585H@589?;C6!?9BF<:;!5I!;A9!"+2,&%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!X'T1!((2!ED)!b`)!!*5889:;2!S<B@!W_V[2!]#a)!!! !

Page 120: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]_]!

%)(()_]! 39<D!:5)!WWWW!

h!$ACD<@9DEAC<!

/)_W_[!

456789:;!;C;D9! 39<D!5I!@+%$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?O!'58>!:5)!W`V)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! +<EC?D<Z7DC!<:@!P5D@!BC:P)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%-+<2#!'&%"+2*#0'%)'(0%;_'<%$(<2+%)'(00%%

!

N99E9B!5I!?96B9;?!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'I%?9<D9B!5I!;A9!MC:P!5I!.EE9B!<:@!+5L9B!/PJE;O!5F9B?99B!

5I!;A9!?9<D9B?!

!U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!1<B;C:!W_#W2!:5)!WWWWO!ED)!"]O![)!!

-<B?;<:P!W_`W2!]!<:@!"[O!ED?)!W!=;5EG!<:@!Wb)!!

U9L>9BBJ!W_`a2!W_#O!ED)!]"O!"W)!

*5889:;2!S<B@!W_V[2!:5)!W`Wa)!

!! !

Page 121: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]_b!

%)(()_b! T1!"W_!

e[bWf!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!B*'<%-,&D'E9$!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!W[;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! $<C:;9@!DC89?;5:9!B96;<:P7D<B!?;9D9!LC;A!<!a!A5BCZ5:;<D!DC:9?!

C:?6BCE;C5:!<>5F9!;A9!B9EB9?9:;<;C5:!5I!;A9!5L:9B!C:!IB5:;!5I!

<!;<>D9!5I!5II9BC:P?)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!bG%$(<2+%,7*0'<%*%"+2,&%%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!,7*0'<!5I!;A9!"+2,&!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!X'T1!"2!ED)!"b)!!

*5889:;<BJ2!S<B@!W_V[2!:5)!V[)!

!! !

Page 122: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]_a!

%)(()_a! *-![`[#V!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!G(#02+*2#;!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?!=:5B;A9B:!:96B5E5DC?G)!W[;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! &57:@^;5EE9@! ?<:@?;5:9! ?;9D9! LC;A! _! F9B;C6<D! DC:9?!

C:?6BCE;C5:!C:!;A9!7EE9B!A<DI)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%6)![G%@+%,-%%%

!

X5B7?!5I!;A9!,-!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!+<:P9!h!36AwI9B!W_`[^[b2![_"O!ED)![`O!D)!<)!!

$1!b2WO![aV)!

!! !

Page 123: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]_#!

%)(()_#! *-![`#W[!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!>1*$2*'2(*2'02S;!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!W[;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! &96;<:P7D<B!?;9D9!LC;A!W[!A5BCZ5:;<D!DC:9?!C:?6BCE;C5:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

D)!"G%#(+%+%7*0%%D)WWG!.;*9*9$%,-94%*;%-+<%$+'%-##'!!!

!

*58E<:C5:!5I!;A9!7*0%!

(!9:;9B9@!C:!AC?%,-I%+5B@!5I!;A9!5II9BC:P^8<M9B?!

!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!+<:P9!h!36AwI9B!W_`[^[b2!"V]O!ED)!bVO!D)!"!<:@!WW)!!

$1!b2WO![ab)!

!! !

Page 124: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]_V!

%)(()_V! 8N5E9:<PA9:!

U*-!%/(U!

Wb"_!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!B*'<2)'$2(2#42#*;!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! +<A7:)!W[;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:! 5:! ;A9! ><6M! ?C@9! 5I! ;A9! B57:@^;5EE9@! ?;9D9!

@965B<;9@!>J!9J9?!C:!;A9!D7:9;;9O!<!65B:C69!LC;A!W!C:?6BC>9@!

DC:9! <:@! <! ;9K;! 5I! LAC6A! 5:DJ! a! A5BCZ5:;<D! DC:9?! <B9!

EB9?9BF9@)!'A9!;9K;!65:?C?;?!5I!<:! C:F56<;C5:!5I! ;A9!EBC9?;!

5"$% ;5! ?9F9B<D! MC:@?! 5I! 5IIC6C<D?! ;5! 8<M9! ;A98! >BC:P!

5II9BC:P?!;5!;A9!;58>!5I!B*'<2)'$2(2#42#*;9%T9;L99:!;A98!

<B9!DC?;9@!;A9!I7:6;C5:<BC9?!5I!;A9!E<D<69)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

D)![^"G!*;'%*'<%"+2*#0'%%

!

%DD!LA5!>9D5:P!=I7:6;C5:<BC9?G!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!!N59I59@^$9;9B?9:!W_]V2!ED)!WW>O!F9B?5O!D)!")!!

%B:5D@!W__`2!W]#)!!

$1!]2WO!V[)!

!! !

Page 125: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ]__!

%)(()__! T1!["[!

e[Wbf!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!5*;2#02(,!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!W[;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! +C89?;5:9! ?;9D9! 5I! 5*;2#02(,% LC;A! EB<J9B?! ;5! %E7<;7^&<O!+5B@!5I!%>J@5?!I5B!AC8!<:@!AC?!I<8CDJ)!'C;D9!<;!;A9!>5;;58!5I!

;A9!?;9D9!B9I9BB9@!;5!<!I<8CDC<B!5I!;A9!5L:9B)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

-+<2"+%*%"+2,&%%

!

1<d5B@585H@589?;C6!?9BF<:;!5I!;A9!"+2,&%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!X'T1O!"2!ED)!]a)!

*5889:;2!S<B@!W_V[2!_V")!!

!! !

Page 126: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b``!

%)(()W``! T1!W_"!

[baa]!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!\.025;C!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!W[;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! &57:@^;5EE9@! ?;9D9! LC;A! WW! DC:9?! 5I! C:?6BCE;C5:! 5F9B! ;A9!

B9EB9?9:;<;C5:! 5I! ;A9! @969<?9@! C:! IB5:;! 5I! <! ;<>D9! 5I!

5II9BC:P?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

6)!a^VG%"-94%0,,0'%)*'<%#'%(%#'"2#&%7+0%(%#.(%(.0%0,%-+<0%(%;&-%*;%'&0<%D99E%#-9#%.4&%*#0'9+'%-'+<0%#0.%*;%,-%%

!

X9!9:;9B?!C:!;A9!EBCF<6J!I5B985?;!5I!E5?C;C5:!

C:!;A9!#'"2#&%@7BC:P!;A9!@<J!;5!A9<B!;A9!7:C\79!L5B@!5I!;A9!6AC9I?!C:!;A9!EB9?9:69!5I!

;A9!+5B@!5I!;A9!;L5!D<:@?!=))G%J57B!657:6CD!5I!;A9!EB5FC?C5:?!5I!J57B!MC:P!>9\79<;A!5I!;A9!

+5B@!5I!;A9!,-%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!3C8E?5:!W_#]2!%U,*!")WO!ED)!V)!!

X'T1O!]2!ED)!"#)!!

$1!b2WO!_a)!

!

! !

Page 127: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b`W!

%)(()W`W! *-![`b#W!

456789:;!;C;D9! TD56M!5I!?(*<2,*)!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?O!:5B;A9B:!:96B5E5DC?)!W[;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! TD56M! LC;A! B9EB9?9:;<;C5:! 5I! ;A9! @969<?9@! <:@! 5II9BC:P^

>9<B9B?)!'A9!C:?6BCE;C5:!5I!a!F9B;C6<D!DC:9?!C?!5F9B!;A9!5L:9B!

?A5L:!?9<;9@!C:!IB5:;!5I!<!>B9<@^;<>D9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%6)!WG%+)%#'%+.94%(%"+2*#0'%%%6)!"G%$(<2+%7*0%*%)&%*%$(<2+%)'(%

!

,:9!LA5!M:5L?!AC?!?;<:@C:P!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%%,F9B?99B!5I!;A9%7*0%C:!;A9!5IIC69!5I!;A9!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!?;5B9A57?9%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!3C8E?5:!W_#]2!%U,*!"])WO!ED)!b[)!

+<:P9!h!36AwI9B!W_`[^[b2![`_O!ED)!]aO!D)<W)!

$1!b2WO![a#)!

!

! !

Page 128: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b`[!

%)(()W`[! T1!"W"!

e[]_f!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!G"2##!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!W[;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! SAC;9! DC89?;5:9! B57:@^;5EE9@! ?;9D9! LC;A! 9J9?! C:! ;A9!

D7:9;;9)! 'C;D9! DC?;9@! <85:P! 5;A9B?! C:! ;A9! #! A5BCZ5:;<D! DC:9?!

C:?6BCE;C5:!<;!;A9!>5;;58!5I!;A9!?;9D9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

D)!"G%$+<2,'%*%"+2,&%%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!"+2,&!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!X'T1O!"2!ED)![`)!!

*5889:;2!S<B@!W_V[2!:5)!]#a)!!

!

! !

Page 129: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b`"!

%)(()W`"! T1![]W!

e["#f!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!W#+!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!W[;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'C;D9! B9E9<;9@! C:! >5;A! ;A9! 65D78:?! 5I! C:?6BCE;C5:?! <;! ;A9!

?C@9?! 5I! ;A9! 69:;B<D! B9EB9?9:;<;C5:! ?A5LC:P! ;A9! 5L:9B! C:!

IB5:;!5I!;A9!;<>D9!5I!5II9BC:P?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

$+<2,'%*%"+2,&%%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!"+2,&!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!X'T1O!]2!ED)!"V)!!

*5889:;2!S<B@!W_V[2!:5)!]#a)!

!

! !

Page 130: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b`]!

%)(()W`]! *-![`[b]!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!?.2'02-Z&20.-02;;<!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!W[;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! cB<P89:;<BJ!?;9D9!LC;A!#!DC:9?!C:?6BCE;C5:?!5:!C;?!+6T'U9%(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

DD)!"^]G!0+%-#0'%(%#'"2#&%*;%#)&!*4+%(%,-%!

-B9<;!5I!EB<C?9?HI<F5B?!C:!;A9!#'"2#&O!+5B@!5I!P55@!B9898>B<:69!C:!;A9%,-%%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!+<:P9!h!36AwI9B!W_`[^[bO!(2![`O!D)!"^]k!ED)!WV)!

!

! !

Page 131: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b`b!

%)(()W`b! X9\<C>!]_!^

8%?L<:!

W""#!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;<;79!5I!;A9!8CDC;<BJ!5IIC69B!5*;0!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! X9\<C>)!W[;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! TB5L:C?A! ?<:@?;5:9! ?;<;79! 5I! 5*;0! 5:! <! 67>C6<D! ?9<;)!(:?6BCE;C5:?!<B9!65F9BC:P!<DD!E<B;?!5I!;A9!?9<;)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)![^"G!+.$%(%-+%-+<0D2'"E%,!&%+%-+<%-('%*;'%*'%"+2*#0'%+%#)(2$;0%%

!

,:9!LA5!PCF9?!5B@9B?!;5!;A9!6AC9I?!5I!;A9!

87D;C;7@9!85B9!;A<:!<:J!6AC9I!5I!;A9!6B<I;!5I!

;A9!"+2*#0'%;5!;A9!?9BF<:;?!=DC;)!;5!o;A5?9!?;57;^A9<B;9@rG!

!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!*5889:;2!X<><6AC!W_Vb2!#aO!I)!WWO!ED)!W[a^VO!D)!9)!

!

! !

Page 132: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b`a!

%)(()W`a! X9\<C>!_!^

8%?L<:!

W"#"!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3<:@?;5:9!?;9D9!5I!5&2+*"0'!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! /D9EA<:;C:9)!W[;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 3;9D9! B9E5B;C:P! 5:! L5BM?! @5:9! C:! ;A9! ?<:6;7<BJ! <;!

/D9EA<:;C:9! <:@! 5II9BC:P?! 9?;<>DC?A9@! I5B! C;?! L5B?ACE)!

$9BA<E?! C;! 5BCPC:<DDJ! >9P<:!LC;A! ;A9! :<89! 5I! ;A9! B9CP:C:P!

MC:P! 5B!L<?! 9F9:! EB969@9@!>J! ;A9! J9<B! C:!LAC6A! ;A9! ?;9D9!

L<?!6<BF9@O!>7;!;A9!C:C;C<D!E<B;!C?!D5?;)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!WG%D..09*94E%$$0D'E%(%"+2*#0'%$*%D#(+E0%$(<%,-%%

%S9D6589!C:!;A9!A57?9!5I!;A9!MC:P!>J!;A9!

658E<:C5:?!LA5!<B9!C:!;A9!,-!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!X<><6AC!W_VbO!W2!"aO!I)!"k!ED)![]O!D)!W)!

*5889:;2!cB<:M9!W__]2!Wb]^bO!ED)!W)!!

!

! !

Page 133: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b`#!

%)(()W`#! *-![`#]V!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!?(*2$$2,*)!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!W[;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 3;9D9!LC;A!:C6A9!I5B!?;<;79!LC;A!;A9!5L:9B!?A5L:!?9<;9@!5:!

;A9! D9I;!5I! C;!<:@!;A9!5II9BC:P?!5:!;A9!BCPA;)! (:?6BCE;C5:?!<B9!

@C?E5?9@! C:! ;A9! D7:9;;9O! C:! "! A5BCZ5:;<D! DC:9?! <>5F9! ;A9!

@969<?9@!<:@!C:!#!A5BCZ5:;<D!DC:9?!<;!;A9!>5;;58O!7:@9B!;A9!

B9EB9?9:;<;C5:?)!

%)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!D9I;!?C@9!5I!?;9D9!65B:C69)!

T)!#!A5BCZ5:;<D!DC:9?!<;!;A9!>5;;58)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)!!

D)!W^[G%(%-'"%)+%*'+%,&%*;%"'%$(<2+%7*0%%%T)!!

D)!"G%(*%-#0'%(%#'"2#&%$(<2+%7*0%#)(%C&'%%%D)!#G%$(<2+%7*0%%

!

T9C:P!C:!E9<69!LC;A!;A9!PB9<;!P5@O!+5B@!5I!

;A9!?MJO!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!7*0!!

cCB8!5I!EB<C?9?HI<F5B?!C:!;A9!#'"2#&I%5F9B?99B!5I!;A9%7*0I%LA5!A<?!E5L9B!!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!7*0!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!3C8E?5:!W_#]2!%U,*!"])[O!ED)!b[)!

$1!b2WO![a#)!

+<:P9!h!36AwI9B!W_`[^[b2!"V[O!ED)!b#O!D)!P")!

!

! !

Page 134: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b`V!

%)(()W`V! 1C6A<9DC@C?!

3;9D9!%!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!W*($!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!W[;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! &57:@^;5EE9@! ?<:@?;5:9! ?;9D9! LC;A! ,?CBC?! AJ8:)! 'C;D9!

B9I9BB9@!;5!;A9!P5@)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%%3C@9!%O!D)!WWG%*;%#)&%('<%,-%%%

!

+5B@!5I!;A9!E9BI96;!B9898>B<:69!C:!;A9!,-!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!3C8E?5:!W_#]2!%U,*!aW)WO!ED)"#)!!

17:B5!W_a`2!ba^#`2!b#^_O!ED)!])!

!

! !

Page 135: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b`_!

%)(()W`_! '7BC:!*<;)!

Wa[V!=[#aG!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!5*2"0!!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!W[;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! &57:@^;5EE9@! ?;9D9! LC;A! 6<F9;;5! <:@! ;5B7?! >9D5L)! c57B!

F9B;C6<D! DC:9?! C:?6BCE;C5:! C:! ;A9! D7:9;;9! >9;L99:! ;L5! 9J9?O!

5:9!5:!9<6A!?C@9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

D)!"^]G!('<%*%"+2*#0'!!

$B96C?9!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%!

U5;9?2!!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!3C8E?5:!W_#]2!%U,*!bb)[O!ED)!#])!

45:<@5:C!W_V#hW_V_O!W2!W]_O!Wa]O!ICP)!b[!I)O!#V!I)O!W#VO!""V)!!

45:<@5:C!W_V#hW_V_O![2%_Wh_]O!W`VO!WW_O!ICP)!W[]hW[aO!W[V)!!45:<@5:C!W_V#hW_V_O!"2![`Vh[W`O![baO!ICP)!"`ah"WbO!"W_!I)!

!

! !

Page 136: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! bW`!

%)(()WW`! .*!W]"Vb!

456789:;!;C;D9! cB<P89:;!5I!<!3;9D9!!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?!=;98ED9!5I!,?CBC?G)!W[;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! cB<P89:;! IB58! ;A9! BCPA;! ?C@9! 5I! ;A9! ?;9D9! >9<BC:P! <:!

C:?6BCE;C5:!5I!W[! DC:9?!LAC6A!B965B@?!;A9!65:?;B76;C5:!5I!<:!

5II9BC:P^6A<E9D!<;!%>J@5?!>J!<:!5IIC6C<D!5I!;A9!MC:P)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

D)!]G!$(<%"+2*#0'%!

!

SA5!C?!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'!

U5;9?2!!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!3;9L<B;!W_#a^V"O!((2!ED)![`)!

U<FCDD9!h!$99;!h!X<DD!W_W"^W]O!W2!ED)!aW)a)!

$1!b2WO!]_)!

!

! !

Page 137: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! bWW!

%)(()WWW! T1![WV!

e[]"f!!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!B*'<27'<2(2-&'!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!W[;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! +C89?;5:9! ?;9D9!LC;A!EB<J9B?! ;5!,?CBC?! I5B! ;A9!5IIC6C<D!B*'<27'<2(2-&'%LA5!C?!?9<;9@!C:F5MC:P!;A9!P5@)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

!D)!W[G!*;%#)&%*4+%(%,-%"+2,&%!

+5B@!5I!P55@!B9898>B<:69!C:!;A9!,-%"+2,&%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!3C8E?5:!W_#]2!%U,*!a[)[O!ED)!V])!!

X'T1O!]2!ED)!"WO!D)!W[)!

!

! !

Page 138: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! bW[!

%)(()WW[! T1!b`a!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!f(-2$!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!W[;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! &96;<:P7D<B!PB<:C;9!?9E7D6AB<D!?;9D9!5I!f(-2$O!<!EBC9?;!5I!;A9!P5@@9??! X<;A5B! C:! 49:@9B<AO! LC;A! ;A9! @969<?9@! ?A5L:!

?9<;9@!5:!<!6A<CBO!AC?!?5:!<@5BC:P!<!P5@!<:@!;A9!898>9B?!5I!

AC?!I<8CDJ!M:99DC:P!C:!<@5B<;C5:)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%$+<2,'%*%,-%%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!T7@P9!W_`_2![W#O!:5)!#V")!$1!(2!V`_)!!

*5889:;2!cB<:M9!W_V]2!:5)!#V])!

!

! !

Page 139: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! bW"!

%)(()WW"! 39<D!#]"<!

!

11%!

[a)#)"W[!=/K!

*<B:<F5:!

*5DD96;C5:G!

456789:;!;C;D9! 39<D!5I!F(;9#*9$2*9$DNE!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!W[;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%$(<2+%,7*0'<%*%"+2-.%"+2,&%

!

,:9!LA5!C?!C:!;A9!,7*0'<%C:H5I!;A9!;B9<?7BJ!5I!;A9!"+2,&!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!1<B;C:!W_##2!a[O!:u!#]"<O!ED)!"]O!W#)!!

!

! !

Page 140: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! bW]!

%)(()WW]! *-!W]Va!

456789:;!;C;D9! ,II9BC:P^3;9D9!5I!,1"'<!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 4<A?A7BO!1<?;<><!U5B@!:5)![])!W[;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! '5B7?!<:@!65B:C69!?;9D9!I5B!5II9BC:P?O!LC;A!C:?6BCE;C5:?!5F9B!

<:@!>9D5L!;A9!8C@@D9!?69:9!B9EB9?9:;C:P!;A9!5L:9B!C:!IB5:;!

5I!<!;<>D9!5I!5II9BC:P?)!'C;D9!65:;<C:9@!C:!;A9!]!F9B;C6<D!DC:9?!

C:?6BCE;C5:!<;!;A9!BCPA;!?C@9!5I!;A9!;5E!5I!;A9!?;9D9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

D)!"G!$(<2+%#0'%!"#0'%"+2,&%%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!:5>D9!ED<69?!5I!;A9!"+2,&!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!15BP<:!WVb#2!(O!ED)!WW)!!

*5889:;2!cC?6A9B!W_Vb2!VO!:u!"[a<)!!

!

! !

Page 141: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! bWb!

%)(()WWb! /Z>9;!&7?A@C!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;<;79!5I!>1(*<!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! /Z>9;!&7?A@C)!W[;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! -B9J! ?\7<;;C:P! ?;<;79! 5I! <! ACPA! 5IIC6C<DO! ;A9! 7EE9B! E<B;!

<>5F9! ;A9! L<C?;! >9C:P! 8C??C:P)! 'A9! ?;<;79! A<?! a! F9B;C6<D!

DC:9?!5I!C:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!D<E!5I!;A9!?;<;79!<:@!W!A5BCZ5:;<D!

DC:9!5:!;A9!><?9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!bG!#(&<%@+%-+<2$;%,-%%

!

%??56C<;9@!5I!X5B7?!LA5!C?!C:!;A9!n-!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!%@<8!W_b_2![Wb)!

*5889:;2!45K9J!W__V2!"#W)!!

cC?6A9B!W_Vb2!""O!:u!W[_b<)!

!

! !

Page 142: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! bWa!

%)(()WWa! +9C@9:!b[!=Y!

__G!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!?;9D9!5I!?+0'%!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!W[;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 3<:@?;5:9!?;9D9!LC;A!;5B7?!<:@!65B:C69!LC;A!BC>>5:^E<;;9B:O!

[!d<6M<D?!<;!;A9!;5E!<:@!I7:9B<BJ!?69:9?!IB<89@!C:!a!?\7<B9?!

?7BB57:@9@!>J!C:?6BCE;C5:?)!'C;D9!B9I9BB9@!;5!5:9!5I!;A9!89:!

B9EB9?9:;9@!C:!5:9!5I!;A9!?\7<B9?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%$+<2,'%*%"+2,&%%%%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!"+2,&%%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!cB<:M9!W_V]2!:5)!#W_)!!

X5DL9B@<!h!T59?9B!W_`VO![2!ED)!]`)!!

39JIBC9@!W_VW2!Wb_!II)O!Wa#!II)!

*5889:;2!T9BD9F!W_#V2![bWO![][)!!

S<B@!W_V[2!]#a)!

!

! !

Page 143: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! bW#!

%)(()WW#! 4<A?A7B!

456789:;!;C;D9! cB<P89:;!5I!;A9!?;<;79!5I!=*'02*#0%$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! X<88<8<;)!W[;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! cB<P89:;!5I!<!@C5BC;9!?;<;79!IB58!;A9!I7:9B<BJ!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!:5B;A9B:!EJB<8C@!<;!4<A?A7B)! (:?6BCE;C5:!658E5?9@!>J!<!7:C\79!F9B;C6<D!C:?6BC>9@!65D78:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)+"%,-%

!

,:9!LA5!C?!<;!;A9!A9<@H65:;B5DD9B!5I!;A9!,-%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!15BP<:!WV_b^W_`"2!b")!

*5889:;2!S<B@!W_V[2!:5)!WW]`)!

!

! !

Page 144: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! bWV!

%)(()WWV! ET9BDC:!

W`]#`!

456789:;!;C;D9! &9E5B;!65:69B:C:P!;A9!?D<F9^PCBD!5*2;'!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!W[;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! XC9B<;C6! IB<P89:;<BJ! E<EJB7?! @<;9@! 8C@L<J! >9;L99:! ;A9!

W[;A! <:@! ;A9! WV;A! 4J:<?;J)! (;! 65:;<C:?! ;A9! 5B@9B! ?9:;! IB58!

;A9! *57B;! 5I! FCZC9B! %89:98A<;! ;5! ;A9! B9E5B;9B! 5I!

/D9EA<:;C:9!X9M<C>!65:69B:C:P!;A9!?C;7<;C5:!5I!;A9!?D<F9^PCBD!

5*2;')!'A9!EB9?9:;!C:?6BCE;C5:!C?!IB58!;A9!ICB?;!?96;C5:!5I!;A9!

;9K;!LC;A!;A9!5B@9B!;5!>BC:P!;A9!B9E5B;!IB58!;A9!*57B;!5I!;A9!

YCZC9B)!!!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!aG%7&;%"0%-+%+.$'%+)9#*%#'%$)%$+$9C%[)4']%"+2*#0'%D)!#G%($'%*%7*'%$*$'%(%)&%*%'&'<%$*$'%-+$%*%'(%>1'4942#*;%U*%(%[7+0]%

!

35!B7:?!LA<;!A9!B9E5B;9@)!'AC?!C?!?9:;!IB58!

;A98!5I!C;)!'A9:!J57!?A<DD!<6;));A9!"+2*#0')!*5EJ!5I!;A9!D9<;A9B!B5DD!LAC6A!L<?!>B57PA;!

IB58!;A9!5IIC69!5I!;A9!FCZC9BO!LAC6A!;A9!-+$%*%'(!=8<?;9B!5I!;A9))G%>1'4942#*;%>B57PA;!5:!;AC?!@<J)!

!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!38C;A9B!W_]V2!"[O!ED)!#O!D)!()a)!!

X9D6M!W_#b<2!bW)!

!! !

Page 145: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! bW_!

%)(()WW_! 4<A?A7B!:5)!

[``!

456789:;!;C;D9! cB<P89:;<BJ!?;<;79;;9!5I!M020&-2"'-%$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 4<A?A7B)!W[;A!4J:)!=qG!

49?6BCE;C5:! +C89?;5:9! E9@9?;<D! I5B! <! ?;<;79;;9! IB58! 4<A?A7B)! ,:! ;A9!7EE9B! ?7BI<69! ;A9B9! C?!<! B96;<:P7D<B! B969??! I5B! ;A9!><?9!5I!;A9!?;<;79;;9)!,:!;A9!IB5:;!?C@9!5I!;A9!E9@9?;<D!;A9B9! C?!<:!C:6C?9@! ?69:9! B9EB9?9:;C:P! [! 89:! ?;<:@C:P! I<6C:P! 9<6A!5;A9B)! T9;L99:! ;A98! ;A9B9! C?! <! :78>9B! 5I! 5II9BC:P?! <:@!<>5F9!;A9CB!A9<@!;A9B9! C?!<!A5BCZ5:;<D! C:?6BCE;C5:O!;A9!BCPA;!E<B;!5I!C;!65:;<C:C:P!;A9!;C;D9!<:@!:<89!5I!;A9!E9B?5:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!"G%$+<2,'%*%"+2,&%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!"+2,&%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!c<MABJ!W_aWO!((2!b]O!ICP)!"bW)!

*5889:;2!S<B@!W_V[2!:5)!]#a)!

!! !

Page 146: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b[`!

%)(()W[`! '7BC:!W"`!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!5*;!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!W[^W";A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 3<:@?;5:9!?;9D9!LC;A!;A9!5L:9B!B9EB9?9:;9@!5:!;A9!BCPA;^

?C@9!C:?C@9!<!IB<89!I5B89@!>J!AC9B5PDJEA?)!(:?6BCE;C5:!

658E5?9@!>J!;L5!A5BCZ5:;<D!DC:9?O!9:@C:P!5:!;A9!D9I;!?C@9O!

;A<;!@9?69:@?!@5L:!;A9!?;9D9)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!_G%#!%"+2*#0'%%

!

36BC>9!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!cC?6A9B!W_Vb2!"]O!:5)!W"V`<)!!

1<?E9B5!WVV[2!W[W)!

!! !

Page 147: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b[W!

%)(()W[W! &5@C:!][!

456789:;!;C;D9! cB<P89:;!5I!><?^B9DC9I!%$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!W[;A!4J:)!=qG!

49?6BCE;C5:! cB<P89:;! 5I! ><?^B9DC9I! LC;A! B9EB9?9:;<;C5:! 5I! <! 8<:!>9;L99:!;L5!;<>D9?!5I!5II9BC:P)!'A9!;C;D9!C?!<>5F9!AC?!ICP7B9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%$+<2,'%*%"+2,&%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!"+2,&%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!&5@C:!W_a#^V2!:5)!][)!

*5889:;2!S<B@!W_V[2!:5)!]#a)!

!! !

Page 148: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b[[!

%)(()W[[! *-!#``"a!

456789:;!;C;D9! U<5?!5I!>1$094%$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!W[;A!4J:)!=qG!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'C;D9!B9I9BB9@!;5!5:9!5I!;A9!5II9BC:P!89:!B9EB9?9:;9@!C:!;A9!?;9D9O!:5;!;5!;A9!5L:9B)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%$+<2,'%*%"+2,&%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!"+2,&%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!&59@9B!W_W]2!W[[^b)!

*5889:;2!S<B@!W_V[2!:5)!]#a)!

!! !

Page 149: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b["!

%)(()W["! 1<B?9CDD9!:5)!

["!

456789:;!;C;D9! SAC;9!?<:@?;5:9!>D56M!5I!B*2(#%$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!W[;A^W";A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'C;D9!B9I9BB9@!;5!5:9!5I!;A9!5II9BC:P!89:!B9EB9?9:;9@!5:!;A9!>D56MO!:5;!;5!;A9!5L:9B)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%-+<2"+%*%"+2,&%

!

1<d5B@585H@589?;C6!?9BF<:;!5I!;A9!"+2,&%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!1<?E9B5!WV_`2!WW])!

*5889:;2!S<B@!W_V[2!:5)!]#a)!

!! !

Page 150: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b[]!

%)(()W[]! '7BC:!Wa[`!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!B*2(#%$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!W[;A^W";A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! &96;<:P7D<B! ?;9D9! LC;A! ;A9! 5L:9B! B9EB9?9:;9@! C:! <@5BC:P!E5?C;C5:! C:! IB5:;!5I! ;A9! ;<>D9!5I! 5II9BC:P?)!%;! AC?! BCPA;! A<:@!;A9B9!<B9!I57B!65D78:?!5I!C:?6BCE;C5:)!(:!;A9!>5;;58!E5B;C5:!?9F9B<D!;C;D9?!5I!;A9!5L:9B!<B9!DC?;9@!C:!W[!C:?6BC>9@!65D78:?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%6)!bG%-+<2"+%*%"+2,&%

!

1<d5B@585H@589?;C6!?9BF<:;!5I!;A9!"+2,&%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!1<?E9B5!W_V[2!WW])!

*5889:;2!S<B@!W_V[2!:5)!_V")!

!! !

Page 151: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b[b!

%)(()W[b! cD5B9:69!:5)!

[bW[!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!>1;$%$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!W[;A^W";A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! &57:@^;5EE9@!?<:@?;5:9!?;9D9!LC;A!"!A5BCZ5:;<D!DC:9?!8<C:!C:?6BCE;C5:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!"G%$+<2,'%*%,-%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!,-%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!T5?;C665!W_b_2!]VO!:5)!]b)!

*5889:;2!S<B@!W_V[2!:5)!]b_)!

!! !

Page 152: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b[a!

%)(()W[a! }<PB9>!:5)!V!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!N%$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!W[;A^W";A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! &57:@^;5EE9@!?;9D9!LC;A!9J9?!<:@!%:7>C?!C:!;A9!D7:9;;9!<:@!WW! 65D78:?! 5I! C:?6BCE;C5:! 7:@9B! LAC6A! ;A9! @969<?9@! C?!?A5L:! ?9<;9@! C:! IB5:;! 5I! <! ;<>D9! 5I! 5II9BC:P?k! 5II9BC:P^>9<B9B?!<:@!I<8CDC<B?!5I!;A9!5L:9B!<B9!B9EB9?9:;9@!C:!?C:PD9!IB<89?! C:! ;A9! D5L9B!E<B;!5I! ;A9! ?;9D9)!'C;D9! B9I9BB9@! ;5!5:9!I<8CDC<B!5I!;A9!5L:9B)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!"G%$+<2,'%*%,-%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!,-%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!3<D9A!W_#`2![[^["O!:5)!V)!

*5889:;2!S<B@!W_V[2!:5)!]b_)!

!! !

Page 153: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b[#!

%)(()W[#! 8,K%?A8!=9K!

l799:?!*!l*!

WW`_G!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!B*'<27'<2(2-&'!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!/:@!5I!;A9!W[;A!h!>9PC::C:P!5I!;A9!W";A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! &57:@^;5EE9@! DC89?;5:9! ?;9D9! LC;A! ;A9! 5L:9B! 5II9BC:P! C:!

IB5:;!5I!<!W_!DC:9?! C:?6BCE;C5:!65:;<C:C:P!<!EB<J9B!;5!,?CBC?)!

'C;D9!B9I9BB9@!;5!;A9!P5@)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!!

D)!W[G%*;%#)&%*4+%(%,-%%

!

+5B@!5I!P55@!B9898>B<:69!C:!;A9!,-!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!3C8E?5:!W_#]2!%U,*!a[)WO!ED)!V])!!

38C;A9B!h!4<MC:!W_"_2!ED)![`O!E)!WbV^_O!D)!W[)!

!! !

Page 154: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b[V!

%)(()W[V! 3;9D9!

1<P@9>7BP!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!>1'!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!U9I)!()!!

49?6BCE;C5:! &57:@^;5EE9@! ?;9D9! LC;A! ;A9! B9EB9?9:;<;C5:! 5I! ;A9!

@969<?9@!<;!<!;<>D9!5I!5II9BC:P?! C:!;A9!8C@@D9!>9;L99:!WW!

F9B;C6<D! C:?6BCE;C5:?!C:!;A9!7EE9B!<:@!;A9!D5L9B!E<B;!5I!;A9!

85:789:;)!(:?6BCE;C5:!C:!;A9!7EE9B!A<DI)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%6)![G%$+<2,'%*%,-%!

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!3C8E?5:!W_#]2!%U,*!a`O!ED)!][)!!

*5889:;2!cB<:M9!W_V]2!:5)!"V])!!

T9BD9F!W_#V2![]WO![]V)!!

!! !

Page 155: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b[_!

%)(()W[_! 39<D!b]b!

!

11%!

W`)W"`)[_#!

456789:;!;C;D9! 39<D!5I!=*!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! /K^17B6A!*5DD96;C5:)!W";A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%$(<2+%#'%*%"+28,&:%-'"%.$%*#0'%M'-2#C+20#$+%*%C&%*94%%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!ED<69!C:!;A9!"+28,&:I!<!>55:!LAC6A!;A9!MC:P!M'-2#C+20#_+%PCF9?!I5B!AC?%C&!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!1<B;C:!W_##2!]aO!:u!b]bO!ED)!"#O!"W)!!

*5889:;2!&<:M9!W_"b2!W]_O!W"k!Wa[O!W#)!!

!! !

Page 156: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b"`!

%)(()W"`! *-![``#b!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!5*;02(2,%$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!W";A!4J:)!=qG!

49?6BCE;C5:! *<F9;;5! <:@! ;5B7?! ?;9D9! LC;A! B9EB9?9:;<;C5:! 5I!;A9!

@969<?9@!<;! ;A9!I7:9B<D!><:\79;!<:@!6<BBC9B?!5I! 5II9BC:P?!

LC;AC:!?CK;99:;A!E<:9D?)!'A9! C:?6BCE;C5:! C?!6<BF9@!<B57:@!;A9!

ICP7B9?)!'A9!;C;D9!C?!B9I9BB9@!;5!5:9!5I!;A9!5IIC6C<D?!B9EB9?9:;9@!

C:!;A9!?;9D9!;5P9;A9B!LC;A!;A9!5L:9B)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%<G%$+<2,'%*%"+2,&%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!"+2,&!!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!3C8E?5:!W_#]2!%U,*!W#)WO!ED)![a)!!+<:P9!h!36AwI9B!W_`[^[bO!(2!V_^_[)!!*5889:;2!cB<:M9!W_V]2!:5)!aW`)!!T9BD9F!W_#V2![]`)!S<B@!W_V[2!:5)!]b_)!!! !

Page 157: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b"W!

%)(()W"W! T1!"Wb!

e[][f!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!H&2++0D'E!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!W";A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! SAC;9! DC89?;5:9! B57:@^;5EE9@! ?;9D9! LC;A! 9J9?! C:! ;A9!

D7:9;;9)!'C;D9!B9I9BB9@!;LC69!;5!I<8CDC<B?!5I!;A9!5L:9B)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%-+<2"+%*%"+2,&%%

!

1<d5B@585H@589?;C6!?9BF<:;!5I!;A9!"+2,&!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!X'T1!"2!ED)![#)!!

*5889:;2!S<B@!W_V[2!:5)!_V")!

!! !

Page 158: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b"[!

%)(()W"[! 11%!

"b)#)bb!

456789:;!;C;D9! ?!5I!;A9!6AC9I!5I!EBC9?;!^+2*-2),94!!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! XC9B<M5:E5DC?)!W";A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! &57:@^;5EE9@!E<C:;9@! DC89?;5:9! ?;9D9!LC;A! <! E<CB! 5I! D<BP9!

8<PC6! 9J9?! C:! ;A9! D7:9;;9! <:@! ;A9! ;9K;! >9D5L! C:! WW!

A5BCZ5:;<D! DC:9?!<:@!b!?A5B;^F9B;C6<D!65D78:?)!,:!;A9! D5L9B!

D9I;!?C@9!<B9!;A9!?;<:@C:P!ICP7B9?!5I!^+2*-2),94!<:@!AC?!LCI9)%(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%DD)!a^_G%?2,%*%@+%$*.%-+%'4%(%-+9$%+%7*0%+%$*$%@+%F)*%-*2,%=0'94%>1#0'%(,&2)+0%$+9*94%0$%-+<2"'%-,0%$#0'%$#'%S+'%+)9*94%D0E$%(%#+%(*)%*%*'+2-0'94%99%-+%<2'"%#0.D'E9*94%,-,9$%).$9C0$%(%(&,0%*4+%(-9*9_%^+%F)*<%-+%,0<%-*,%(0'%94%*'+%'*(%)&2*4+%*%H'2'&0<%)'4%-+%*#0'%

!!

X57B?O!<F9:P9B!5I!XC?!c<;A9BO!P<F9!89!<!

6588C??C5:!;5!;A9!7*0!=DC;)!ED<69@!C:!8J!I<69!

;5!;A9%7*0G!;5!I9;6A!X5B7?!5I!U9MA9:!;5P9;A9B!LC;A!AC?!85;A9BO!(?C?O!d7?;CIC9@)!!X9!

<EE5C:;9@!89!<?!6588<:@9B!5I!<!?ACE!<:@!

6B9L!>96<7?9!A9!M:9L!89!;5!>9!<!

658E9;9:;!5IIC6C<D!C:!AC?!;98ED9O!FCPCD<:;!

65:69B:C:P!AC?!<??CP:89:;?)!'A9:!(!I<B9@!

@5L:?;B9<8!<:@!(!;55M!X5B7?!5I!U9MA9:!

7E5:!8J!<B8?!;5P9;A9B!LC;A!;AC?!P5@@9??O!

AC?!85;A9BO!C:!;A9!P55@!5IIC69!5I!(;d;<LJ!C:!

;A9!EB9?9:69!5I!;A9!MC:P!AC8?9DI!!

!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!X<J9?!W_]#2!"^WW!<:@!ED)!(()!

'B<:?D<;C5:2!+C6A;A9C8!W_##2!W"`)!!

!

! !

Page 159: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b""!

%)(()W""! /@I7!W!

456789:;!;C;D9! O(-0!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! /@I7!?;9D9)!W";A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%W#+'2#*2,*)%$+<2,'%*<%,-%%

!

W#+'2#*2,*)I%5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!

,-%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!!

%DDC5;!W_"b2!"bO!:5)![`)!!

S<B?6A<7!1U!W]W[a")!!

3Z<IB<:?MC!W_V`2!]"!I)O!:5)![)!!

*5889:;2!cB<:M9!W_V]2!:5)!#V])!

!

! !

Page 160: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b"]!

%)(()W"]! +9C@9:!]a!!

=Y!W`bG!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!?;9D9!5I!5*;!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!W";A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! &57:@^;5EE9@! ?;9D9! LC;A! 7:IC:C?A9@! ;5B7?! 5B:<89:;!

658E5?9@!>J!;AB99!B9PC?;9B?2!<!"!A5BCZ5:;<D! DC:9?! C:?6BCE;C5:!

65:;<C:C:P! <:! 5II9BC:P! I5B87D<!;5!,?CBC?!<:@!%:7>C?k! <!8<:!

?;<:@C:P! C:! IB5:;! 5I! <! ;<>D9!5I! 5II9BC:P! <:@! <! L58<:! <:@!

;AB99!5;A9B!L589:!?9<;9@!<;!<:5;A9B!;<>D9k![!L589:!<;!<:!

5II9BC:P! ;<>D9! <:@!"!L589:! <;!<:5;A9B! 5:9O! ;A9! D<?;! [!

B9PC?;9B?! >9C:P! ?9E<B<;9@! >J! ;L5!5II9BC:P!I5B87D<!;5!,?CBC?!

<:@!5;A9B!?6<;;9B9@!C:?6BCE;C5:?)!!

%)! 'C;D9! B9I9BB9@! ;5! ;A9! 5L:9B! <;! ;A9! "B@! DC:9! 5I! ;A9! "!

A5BCZ5:;<D!DC:9?!C:?6BCE;C5:!<;!;A9!;5E!5I!;A9!?;9D9)!

T)!'C;D9!B9I9BB9@!;5!5:9!5I!;A9!5II9BC:P^>9<B9B?!<;!;A9!>5;;58!

5I!;A9!?;9D9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)!

D)!"G%$+<2,'%*%,-%%T)!

-+<2"+%*%,-%%

%,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!,-%%!

1<d5B@585H@589?;C6!?9BF<:;!5I!;A9!,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!X5DL9B@<!h!T59?9B!W_`VO![2!ED)!"b)!

*5889:;2!cB<:M9!W_V]2!:5)!aW`)!!

T9BD9F!W_#V2![]`)!!

S<B@!W_V[2!]b_!<:@!<EE9:@CKO!_V`<)!

!

! !

Page 161: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b"b!

%)(()W"b! ''!ab!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!,-&'<!IB58!AC?!;58>!C:!'A9>9?!:5)!ab!=5I!+5B@!

*<B:<F5:Q?!9K6<F<;C5:?WG!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 'A9>9?O!''!ab)!W";A!4J:)!=qG!

49?6BCE;C5:! &96;<:P7D<B! DC89?;5:9!?;9D9!>9<BC:P!<!W[! DC:9?! C:?6BCE;C5:!<;!

;A9!;5E!<:@!;A9!B9EB9?9:;<;C5:!5I!;A9!@969<?9@!C:!IB5:;!5I!<:!

5II9BC:P! ;<>D9! <;! ;A9! >5;;58)! '9K;! B965B@?! ;A9! 8C:C:P!

5E9B<;C5:?!65:@76;9@!>J!;A9!5L:9B!C:!;A9!E9:C:?7D<!5I!3C:<C!

<:@! AC?! B9;7B:! ;5! ;A9! E<D<69! LA9B9! A9! >B57PA;! EB96C57?!

?;5:9?!<:@!89;<D?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

D)%_G!$$9*D9$E%(%-'"%+%,-94%$*$9*94%'"<%)&#0'%(%;$&%*%`&0'%;$&%"#.'%>170%;$&%+0.%=*2C&0%%%

!

(!B9;7B:9@!C:!E9<69!;5!AC?!,-)!(!>B57PA;!;5!AC8!

;A9!>9?;!5I!;A9!I5B9CP:!D<:@?!C:!:9L!89;<D!5I!

`&0'O!?AC:C:P!89;<D!5I!>170O!A<B@!89;<D!5I%=*2C&0)!!

U5;9?2! W!*<B:<F5:O! -)! /)! ^! *<B;9BO! X)! W_W[)! g_V6% h63+#>% ij"JU+3'_U*#% 3'% H76;6#% AkRc2AkAA)!+5:@5:2!ED)!"`)!

,:!AC?!B9;7B:!;5!;A9!$<D<69!,-&'<!>B57PA;!LC;A!AC8!EB96C57?!?;5:9?!<:@!89;<D?!IB58!8<:J!

@CII9B9:;! D<:@?)! 'AB99! F<BC9;J! 5I! 89;<D?! <B9! :<89@! ICB?;! 5I! <DD2! o:9L! 65EE9BrO! o?AC:C:P!

65EE9Br!<:@!oA<B@!65EE9Br)!-<B@C:9B!W_W#2!"a)!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!W_W#2!"b^"aO!ED)!_)!!

36A9:M9D!W_ab2![V[^")!$1!W2[O!aW#)!

!

! !

Page 162: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b"a!

%)(()W"a! +9C@9:!_!=Y!

VVG!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!`;!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 3<:@?;5:9! B57:@! ;5EE9@! ?;9D9! LC;A! <! W"! A5BCZ5:;<D! DC:9?!

C:?6BCE;C5:! C:! ;A9! D7:9;;9O! <:! 5II9BC:P! ?69:9! C:! ;A9!8C@@D9!

<:@!<!EB569??C5:!5I!5II9BC:P^>9<B9B?!<;!;A9!>5;;58)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!W"G%$(<2+%(!,%*%"+2*#0'%%

!

*588<:@9B!5I!;A9!E<D<69!P7<B@!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!X5DL9B@<!h!T59?9B!W_`VO![2!ED)!W`)!!

*5889:;2!S<B@!W__[2![W`)!

!

! !

Page 163: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b"#!

%)(()W"#! ''!ab>!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!,-&'<!IB58!AC?!;58>!C:!'A9>9?!:5)!ab!=5I!+5B@!

*<B:<F5:Q?!9K6<F<;C5:?WG!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 'A9>9?O!''!ab)!W";A!4J:)!=qG!

49?6BCE;C5:! +C89?;5:9!?;9D9!>9<BC:P!<!W`!DC:9?!C:?6BCE;C5:!<:@!?A5LC:P!<;!

;A9! >5;;58! ;A9! @969<?9@! ?9<;9@! C:! IB5:;! 5I! <! ;<>D9! 5I!

5II9BC:P?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

DD)!_^W`G!**%#"%$+$%-+%*%+'%*;%(%$"%+%$+0%"+2*#0'%+2,!n-&0%$+9*9D$E%(%0"'%$(&)%$(<2+%!%,-&'<%!

!

U9F9B!@C@!(!;A9!>C@@C:P!5I!<:J!8<:!C:!B9FC?C:P!

;A9!6<;;D9^DC?;?[!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'O!@7BC:P!<DD!;A9!DCI9;C89!;A<;!(!?E9:;!C:!8J!>7?C:9??!

!

U5;9?2!W!*<B:<F5:O! -)! /)! ^! *<B;9BO! X)! W_W[)! g_V6% h63+#>% ij"JU+3'_U*#% 3'% H76;6#% AkRc2AkAA)!+5:@5:2!ED)!"`)![!+C;9B<DDJ2!$+0%~!o6<;;D9^;<KrO!C:!c*42![#)!U)T)! %;! 'A9><:! 6<EC;<D! ,-&'<! ?998?! ;5! A<F9! L5:! I5B! AC8?9DI! ;A9! E5?C;C5:! 5I! <! 6B7?;9@!

657B;C9BO!:5L!E9BI5B8C:P!6588C??C5:?!I5B!;A9!B5J<D!A<BC8O!:5L!?7E9BC:;9:@C:P!AC?!8<?;9BQ?!

L<B@B5>9O! :5L! <P<C:! 9K9B6C?C:P! <! P9:9B<D! 65:;B5D! 5F9B! ;A9! I7:9B<BJ! 67D;?! 5I! ;A9! D56<D!

:96B5E5DC?)!,:!?9F9B<D!566<?C5:!A9!L57D@!<EE9<B!;5!A<F9!>99:!6588C??C5:9@!;5!6<BBJ!57;!

;A9!69:?7?!5I!;A9!B5J<D!A9B@?)!XC?!?5D9!;C;D9!C?!o39<^6<E;<C:rO!DC;)!o?7E9BC:;9:@9:;!5I!<!=?A99;!

5IG!L<;9Br)!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!W_W#2!""^"]O!ED)!V)!!

36A9:M9D!W_ab2![V[^")!$1!W2[O!aW#)!!! !

Page 164: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b"V!

%)(()W"V! 39<D!b]#!!

!

$ACD<@9DEAC<!

W`WWa!

456789:;!;C;D9! 39<D!5I!=*2-'"%$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! T7A9:O!'58>!XW[)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%!(#0%"+2,&%0-(%,*)%

!

&9;<C:9B!5I!;A9!"+2,&I%B9E9<;C:P!DCI9!!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!1<B;C:!W_#W2!:5)!b]#O!ED)!W"O![`)!!&<:M9!W_"b^##O!(2!Wb`O!W[)!!1<6CF9B!h!S55D9J!W_WW2!W]"!<:@![W_O!ED)!bV)!*5889:;2!S<B@!W_V[2!:5)!W`Wa)!

!! !

Page 165: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b"_!

%)(()W"_! 39<D!]"]!

!

*D9F9D<:@!

W])##[!

456789:;!;C;D9! 39<D!5I!W#+2C&2+,2,*)0!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)! -CF9:! >J! g5A:! X7:;C:P;5:! %B;! <:@! $5DJ;96A:C6!

'B7?;)!/<BDJ!Wb;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%$+<2,'%*%,-%%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!1<B;C:!W_##2!"_O!:5)!]"]O!ED)!W"O!Wa)!!

SCDDC<8?!W_WV2!W#[O!ED)!00Y((!=_G)!!

SCDDC<8?!W_[a2!VW)!

*5889:;2!&<:M9!W_"b2!VaO!WV)!!

!! !

Page 166: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b]`!

%)(()W]`! 39<D!Waa"!

!

T1!"`b]W!

456789:;!;C;D9! 39<D!5I!5'7!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%$+<2,'%*%.&.&0<%*%,-%%

!

,IIC6C<D!C:!=,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6A<8>9BG!C:!;A9!

.&.&0<%5I!;A9!,-%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!1<B;C:!W_#W2!W[#O!:5)!Waa"O!ED)!"V)")!!

*5889:;2!S<B@!W_V[2!:5)!]_V)!!

&<:M9!W_"b2!"[WO![_)!

!! !

Page 167: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b]W!

%)(()W]W! 39<D!""W!

!

T1!"#a_b!=9K!

17B6A!

*5DD96;C5:G!

456789:;!;C;D9! 39<D!5I!,*)2#*!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)+"%,-%0-(%,*)%%

!

,:9!LA5!C?!<;!;A9!A9<@!5I!;A9!,-)!&9E9<;C:P!DCI9!

!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!1<B;C:!W_##O!"WO!:5)!""WO!ED)!W]O!Wa)!!

U9L>9BBJ!W_`a2!W]WO!ED)!0Y(!=]G)!

*5889:;2!&<:M9!W_]_2![#WO![`)!!

!! !

Page 168: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b][!

%)(()W][! 39<D!"_#!

!

.*!WW][V!

456789:;!;C;D9! 39<D!5I!W$&0!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)+"%,-%%

!

,:9!LA5!C?!<;!;A9!A9<@H65:;B5DD9B!5I!;A9!,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!1<B;C:!W_##2!"aO!:5)!"_#O!ED)!"#O![_)!!

$9;BC9!W_W#2!ED)!0Y(!=W"),G)!

!! !

Page 169: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b]"!

%)(()W]"! 39<D!"_V!

!

.*!WW]V`!

456789:;!;C;D9! 39<D!5I!W$&0!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)+"%,-%%

!

,:9!LA5!C?!<;!;A9!A9<@H65:;B5DD9B!5I!;A9!,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!1<B;C:!W_##2!"aO!:5)!"_VO!ED)![bO!W])!!

$9;BC9!W_[b2!ED)!00(Y!=W")TU<G)!

!

! !

Page 170: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b]]!

%)(()W]]! 39<D!]``!

!

*AC6<P5!

WVbVW!

456789:;!;C;D9! 39<D!5I!W$&0!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! /K!17B6A!*5DD96;C5:)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)+"%,-%0-(%,*)%%

!

,:9!LA5!C?!<;!;A9!A9<@H65:;B5DD9B!5I!;A9!,-9%&9E9<;C:P!DCI9!

!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!1<B;C:!W_##2!"aO!:u!]``O!ED)!W"O!W])!!

$C9B!W_`a^#2!Va)!!

!

! !

Page 171: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b]b!

%)(()W]b! 39<D!]`W!

!

1C6A<9DC@C?!

*5DD96;C5:!=9K!

TD<:6A<B@!

*5DD96;C5:G!

456789:;!;C;D9! 39<D!5I!W$&0!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:!=1C6A<9DC@9?!*5DD96;C5:G)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)+"%,-%%

!

,:9!LA5!C?!<;!;A9!A9<@H65:;B5DD9B!5I!;A9!,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!1<B;C:!W_##2!"aO!:5)!]`W)!

!

! !

Page 172: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b]a!

%)(()W]a! 39<D!aa[!

!

1C6A<9DC@C?!

*5DD96;C5:!=9K!

TD<:6A<B@!

*5DD96;C5:G!

456789:;!;C;D9! 39<D!5I!F;2+2#-0<!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 1C6A<9DC@9?!*5DD96;C5:)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)+"%,-%%

!

,:9!LA5!C?!<;!;A9!A9<@H65:;B5DD9B!5I!;A9,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!1<B;C:!W_##2!bbO!:u!aa[)!!

-<7;AC9B!W_"W!(((2!W[a)!

!

! !

Page 173: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b]#!

%)(()W]#! 39<D!WVWb!

456789:;!;C;D9! $BCF<;9!:<89!?9<D!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<A7:)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)+"%,-%%%

!

,:9!LA5!C?!<;!;A9!A9<@H65:;B5DD9B!5I!;A9!,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!1<B;C:O!E)!W"_O!:5)!WVWbO!ED)!]#O!W_)!!

$9;BC9!W_VW2!W]O!ED)!(0!=W`G)!

!

! !

Page 174: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b]V!

%)(()W]V! 39<D!WW]W!

!

T1!"`b]V!

456789:;!;C;D9! 39<D!5I!@+2!42-'"!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%$+<2,'%*%,-%%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!1<B;C:!W_##2!V_O!:5)!WW]WO!ED)!#O!W])!!

*5889:;2!&<:M9!W_"b2![b"O![)!

!

! !

Page 175: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b]_!

%)(()W]_! 49CB!&CI9A!#!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!F'2,*)!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 49CB!&CI9AO!:5)!#)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:?!C:!;A9!9:;B<:69!A<DD)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!WaG%80+:9$%-#0'%*4+'%#"+9*9$%,-%$;9$%&0'%%

!

e(!L<?!PB9<;!5If!>9<7;CI7D!EB<C?9?HI<F5B?!(!

9:;9B9@!C:!;A9!,-I%8J!A9<B;!=I7DD!5IG!5II9BC:P?!

!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!-BCIIC;A!WVV_2!ED)!WV!=Y((GO!D)!Wa)!!

$1!b2WO!W)!

!

! !

Page 176: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! bb`!

%)(()Wb`! 3C:<C!]W[!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!IB58!3C:<C!5I!B*'<2-'"!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3C:<C)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! +5L9B! E<B;! 5I! <! D<BP9! ?;9D9! ?;<:@C:P! C:! ;A9! $5B;C65! *57B;)!

(:?6BCE;C5:!5I!]!DC:9?!5:!;A9!9<?;!I<69)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

D)![G!+)%+.%#'94%(%"+2*#0'%899:%%%%D)!"G%#,"+%,-%(%7+!!!

!

,:9!LA5!M:5L?!AC?!?;<:@C:P!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%e))f!!

!

,:9!LA5!EB5FC@9?!;A9!,-!LC;A!:969??C;C9?!!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!h!$99;!h!y9B:J!W_b[^bb2![`_O!ED)!V#)!!

$1!#2WO!"b])!

!

! !

Page 177: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! bbW!

%)(()WbW! T1c%!

[_)WW"`!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!=*'02(2-&'!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 398:<!c5B;)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!]G%#-;W9*%$*094%,-%,"+0%-0'%%

!

,:9!LA5?9!5II9BC:P?!8<M9!;A9!n-!C:!I9<?;O!9\7CE89:;!5I!;A9!;98ED9!=qG!

!

U5;9?2!W#-;2!I9?;DC6A!8<:6A9:O!C:!S>!(Y2![W")!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:!2!47:A<8!h!g<:??9:!W_a`^#2!b_)!!

g<::?9:!W_b[2!]][^bO!ED)!]a)!!

$1!#2WO!W]b)!

!

! !

Page 178: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! bb[!

%)(()Wb[! 3C:<C!W]]!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!?*2#;4!IB58!3C:<C)!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3C:<C)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!?C@9!5I!<!IB99?;<:@C:P!?;9D9)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

D)!WG!8$+<:2,'%*%,-!!

!

e5F9B?99Bf!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!,-!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!h!$99;!h!y9B:J!W_b[^bb2!W]"O!ED)!bW)!!

$1!#2!WO!"ab)!

!

! !

Page 179: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! bb"!

%)(()Wb"! 3C:<C!W]`!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!IB58!3C:<C!5I!NW!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3C:<C)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! &57:@^;5EE9@!?;9D9!IB58!;A9!$5B;C65!*57B;!5I!;A9!;98ED9!5I!

X<;A5B)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!?57;A!9@P9!5I!;A9!?;9D9!)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

DD)!W^[G!*'+%)'(0!899:%7;7;%'&0<%D)&#0'E%*%*'<%(%,-!

!

'A9!@CFC:9!?9<D9B!e))f%LA5!;B9<@?!;A9!I5B9CP:!D<:@?!I5B!AC8!LA5!C?!C:!;A9!,-!!

U5;9?2!W'A9!:<89!5I!;A9!5L:9B!C?!D5?;)!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

-<B@C:9B!h!$99;!h!y9B:J!W_b[^bb2!W"_O!ED)!bW)!

$1!#2WO!"ba)!

!

! !

Page 180: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! bb]!

%)(()Wb]! +9C@9:!]W!=Y!

#G!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!?,2#&2-'"2$;2,*)!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'A9!?;9D9!C?!5BP<:CZ9@!C:!;L5!B9PC?;9B?2!C:!;A9!D7:9;;9!;A9B9!C?!

<! @9@C6<;5BJ! I5B87D<! ;5! ,?CBC?k! C:! ;A9! D5L9B! E<B;! <! ;5B7?^

?;9D9! C?! 6<BF9@! C:! B9DC9I! C?! B9EB9?9:;9@! LC;A! ;A9! @969<?9@!

?E996A! C:?6BC>9@! C:?C@9! C;)! %;! ;A9! >5;;58! ;A9B9! <B9!

B9EB9?9:;<;C5:?! 5I! ;A9! 5L:9B! C:! IB5:;! 5I! ;A9! ;<>D9! 5I!

5II9BC:P?!<:@!?69:9!5I!?<6BCIC69)!#!F9B;C6<D!DC:9?!5I!C:?6BCE;C5:!

<B9! 6<BF9@! 5:! >5;A! ?C@9?! 5I! ;A9! ?;9D9)! 'A9! 9KEB9??C5:!

<EE9<B?!C:!>5;A!;A9!F9B;C6<D!C:?6BCE;C5:!=65D78:!]!5I!;A9!D9I;!

?C@9!<:@!65D78:!"!5I!;A9!BCPA;!5:9G)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

@+%*;%,-%!

X5B7?O!+5B@!5I!;A9!,-%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!X5DL9B@<!h!T59?9B!W_`VO![2!ED)!#O!B96;5?!D)!])!

!

! !

Page 181: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! bbb!

%)(()Wbb! *-![`#b`!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!U4%?)2(&,2$++!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?O!:5B;A!:96B5E5DC?)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! &57:@! ;5EE9@! ?;9D9)! "! A5BCZ5:;<D! DC:9?! ;9K;! 6<BF9@! C:! ;A9!

D7:9;;9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)![G%+0.%#+4%+)%#'%+.94%0+%-#0'%(%"+2*#0'%%%%D)!"G%$(<2$;%@+%*;%,-%%

!

cCB8!5I!E<??C5:O!5:9!LA5!M:5L?!AC?!

?;<:@C:PO!PB9<;!5I!I<F5B?!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%%c<F5BC;9!5I!X5B7?O!+5B@!5I!;A9%,-%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!+<:P9!h!36AwI9B!W_`[^[b2!"V]O!ED)!bVO!D)!<")!!

$1!b2WO![ab)!

!! !

Page 182: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! bba!

%)(()Wba! ET9BDC:!

W``[W!

456789:;!;C;D9! $<EJB7?!5I!@P&2$'4!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! +<A7:)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! $<EJB7?!IB58!+<A7:!DC?;C:P!B5J<D!E9B?5::9D)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!aG%#&0%,'9$%*%$0'%*0%,P0%'&%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%%DD)!a^#G%0.&%+%7*0%*%,0#%)4'%;&P%#"%'"<%%

!

-7<B@!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!C:658C:P!5I!

L<;9B!<:@!?7EEDC9?!5I!;A9!D<:@!5I!;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)!

!

EB5PB9??!;5!;A9!7*0%C:!D)!E)!A)!5I!5CD!5:9!;C89!

=))G!

!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!36A<BII!W_[]<2!]b^aO!ED)!_)!!

$1!]2WO!WW[)!

!! !

Page 183: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! bb#!

%)(()Wb#! *-![`]#a!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!W+2*#0'2$02'*$!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! l7B:<)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! cB<P89:;!5I!<!?<:@?;5:9!?;9D9!IB58!l7B:<)!(:?6BCE;C5:!C:!;A9!

7EE9B!B9PC?;9B)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!bG%$(&)%$$%)+%*;%'&0<%*;%-#0'%(%#'"2#&%

!

Y9:9B<;9@!7:@9B!;A9!+5B@!5I!;A9!;L5!D<:@?O!

+5B@!5I!EB<C?9?HI<F5B?!C:!;A9!#'"2#&!!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!+<:P9!h!36AwI9B!W_`[^[b2!#])!ED)!""O!D)!<b)!!

$1!W2[O!b_V)!

!! !

Page 184: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! bbV!

%)(()WbV! *-![`[VV!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!=+2+02+<2'2"+$2"$!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! ]!A5BCZ5:;<D!DC:9?!C:?6BCE;C5:!<;!;A9!;5E!5I!;A9!?;9D9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!"G%)+%#'%+.94%0+%-#0'%(%"+2*#0'%

!

,:9!LA5!M:5L?!AC?!?;<:@C:P)!-B9<;!5I!

EB<C?9?HI<F5B?!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!+<:P!!h!36AwI9B!W_`[^[b2!"`"O!ED)![[O!D)!"<!

$1!b2!WO![ab)!

!! !

Page 185: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! bb_!

%)(()Wb_! *-![`]Vb!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3<:@?;5:9!3;9D9!!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:! IB58! ;A9! IB<P89:;! 5I! ;A9! ><6M?C@9! 5I! <! ?;9D9!

LA5?9!5L:9B!C?!7:M:5L:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!"G%80&'%N:$+%&)'%*%"+2*#0'%7&;%+%*$0'%*%H--%DNE%

!

eB5<@!qf!8<@9!PD5BC57?!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%?9:;!;5!;A9!6C;J!5I!H--%DNE%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

+<:P9!h!36AwI9B!W_`[^[b2!VWO!D)!T")!

!! !

Page 186: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ba`!

%)(()Wa`! *-![`]b#!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!3;9D9!5I!FCZC9B%W*)'$!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?O!U5B;A9B:!:96B5E5DC?)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! &96;<:P7D<B! ?<:@?;5:9! ?;9D9)! 'C;D9! B9I9BB9@! ;5! <! 8<:!

B9EB9?9:;9@!C:!;A9!?965:@!B9PC?;9B!5I!;A9!?;9D9)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%CG%#!%P.0'%(%"+2*#0'%

!

4B<I;?8<:!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!+<:P9h!36AwI9B!W_`[^[bO![2!bbO!D)!C)!$1!b2WO![aa)!

*5889:;2!S<B@!W_V[2!W]]a)!

!! !

Page 187: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! baW!

%)(()WaW! *-![`bWV!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!?;9D9!5I!899:a*(0%*)'!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?O!L9?;9B:!:96B5E5DC?)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! &96;<:P7D<B!PB<F9?;5:9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!]G%$(<2+%(+-0'%*;0'%*%"+2*#0'%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!<DD!;A9!5CD?!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!+<:P9!h!36AwI9B!W_`[^[b2!WW"O!ED)!"bO!D)!<])!

$1!b2WO!b")!

!! !

Page 188: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ba[!

%)(()Wa[! T7A9:!

456789:;!;C;D9! cB<P89:;!5I!D9;;9B!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! T7A9:)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! cB<P89:;!5I!<!1C@@D9!NC:P@58!D9;;9B!65:;<C:C:P!<!]!F9B;C6<D!

DC:9?!;9K;!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%6)!W^[G%899:%(&,'%(%7&;9*9$%D*%*;E%,*)%0.&%#*;%899(2:%7&0%*;%*%"+2*#0'%D,.%0.&E%%

!

e))f!;B7;A!C:!;A<;!LAC6A!(!A<F9!?9:;!;5!;A9!

8<?;9B!D)!E)!A)!e))f!<DD!;A9!65:69B:?!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'%=<B9!?<I9!<:@!L9DDG!!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!38C;A!W_#a2!E)!""O!ED)aW)[a)!!

$1!#2WO!W"W)!

!! !

Page 189: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ba"!

%)(()Wa"! *-![``Vb!

456789:;!;C;D9! 5.(2*0%DNE%$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?O!:5B;A9B:!:96B5E5DC?)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 3<:@?;5:9! B57:@^;5EE9@! I7:9B<BJ! ?;9D9)! 'C;D9! B9I9BB9@! ;5!

5:9!5I!;A9!5II9BC:P!89:!B9EB9?9:;9@!5:!;A9!?;9D9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%@G%-+<2"+%*%"+2,&%

!

1<d5B@585H@589?;C6!?9BF<:;!5I!;A9!"+2,&%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!+<:P9!h!36AwI9B!W_`[^[bO!(2!W``)!*5889:;2!S<B@!W_V[2!:5)!_V")!!! !

Page 190: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ba]!

%)(()Wa]! *-![`W`]!

456789:;!;C;D9! ,*)0%$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?O!:5B;A9B:!:96B5E5DC?)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 3<:@?;5:9! B57:@^;5EE9@! I7:9B<BJ! ?;9D9)! 'C;D9! B9I9BB9@! ;5!

5:9!5I!;A9!5II9BC:P!89:!B9EB9?9:;9@!5:!;A9!?;9D9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%-+<2"+%*%"+2,&%

!

1<d5B@585H@589?;C6!?9BF<:;!5I!;A9!"+2,&%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!+<:P9!h!36AwI9B!W_`[^[bO!(2!W[#^V)!*5889:;2!S<B@!W_V[2!:5)!_V")!!! !

Page 191: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! bab!

%)(()Wab! *-![`aWa!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!?,2*4+%$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?O!:5B;A9B:!:96B5E5DC?)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! &57:@^;5EE9@! ?<:@?;5:9! ?;9D9)! (:?6BCE;C5:! B9I9BBC:P! ;5! <!

8<:!B9EB9?9:;9@!C:!<!D5L9B!IB<89!5I!;A9!?;9D9)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%@G%-+<2"+%*%"+2,&%

!

1<d5B@585H@589?;C6!?9BF<:;!5I!;A9!"+2,&%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!+<:P9!h!36AwI9B!W_`[^[bO!(2![bb^a)!*5889:;2!S<B@!W_V[2!:5)!_V")!!! !

Page 192: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! baa!

%)(()Waa! *-![`]"b!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!>1(*<2C(9#%$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! '5B7?! <:@! 6<F9;;5! ?;9D<)! (:?6BCE;C5:! 5:! ;A9! D9I;! ?C@9! 5I! ;A9!

?;9D9)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)![G%)+"2,-%

!

,:9!LA5!C?!;<!;A9!A9<@!5IH65:;B5DD9B!5I!;A9!

,-%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!+<:P9!h!36AwI9B!W_`[^[bO!((2!"[^"")!*5889:;2!S<B@!W_V[2!:5)!Wb[[)!!! !

Page 193: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ba#!

%)(()Wa#! *-![`a[#!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!F;2,*)%$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?O!:5B;A9B:!:96B5E5DC?)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:! 5I! ;AB99! A5BCZ5:;<D! DC:9?! C:! ;A9!8C@^B9PC?;9B! 5:!

;A9!D9I;!?C@9!5I!;A9!?;9D9)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%AO!:G%#!(0%"+2,&%

!

&9;<C:9B!5I!;A9!"+2,&%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!+<:P9!h!36AwI9B!W_`[^[bO!(2![ab^a)!*5889:;2!S<B@!W_V[2!:5)!Wb[[)!!! !

Page 194: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! baV!

%)(()WaV! *-![`["b!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!@#;02$$2(2-'"%$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! &57:@^;5EE9@! ?;9D9)! 'C;D9! B9I9BB9@! ;5! ;L5! 5I! ;A9! 89:!

B9EB9?9:;9@!C:!;A9!"B@!B9PC?;9B!5I!;A9!?;9D9)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)![G%#!(0%"+2,&%

!

&9;<C:9B!5I!;A9!"+2,&%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!+<:P9!h!36AwI9B!W_`[^[bO!(2![ab^a)!*5889:;2!S<B@!W_V[2!:5)!Wb[[)!!! !

Page 195: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ba_!

%)(()Wa_! *-![``"`!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!W#$+2#*2"0%$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)!(:?6BCE;C5:?!5I!a!65D78:?!<;!;A9!BCPA;!;5E?C@9!5I!;A9!?;9D9)!

T)!WW!65D78:?!5I!;9K;!C:!;A9!8C@@D9!5I!;A9!?;9D9)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)!

6)!"G%$(<2+%"+2*#0'%%T)!

6)!_G%(&,%)*'2!%*%"+2,&%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'%!

!

(:?E96;5B!5I!;A9!P<B@9:!5I!;A9!"+2,&!!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

+<:P9!h!36AwI9B!W_`[^[bO!(2!"V^]`)!*5889:;2!S<B@!W_V[2!:5)!#V_)!!! !

Page 196: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b#`!

%)(()W#`! *-![`W]_!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!>1-(#2*2&)'20&#2-'"%$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'C;D9!B9I9BB9@!;5!5:9!5I!;A9!5II9BC:P!89:!B9EB9?9:;9@!5:!;A9!

?;9D9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%CG%$+<2,'%*%"+2,&%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!"+2,&!!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!+<:P9!h!36AwI9B!W_`[^[bO!(2!W#b^##)!*5889:;2!S<B@!W_V[2!:5)!]#a)!!! !

Page 197: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b#W!

%)(()W#W! *-![`[[b!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!?#0'2#*;2#%$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?O!:5B;A9B:!:96B5E5DC?)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'C;D9!B9I9BB9@!;5!5:9!5I!;A9!5II9BC:P!89:!B9EB9?9:;9@!5:!;A9!?;9D9)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%CG%$+<2,'%*%"+2,&%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!"+2,&%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!+<:P9!h!36AwI9B!W_`[^[bO!(2![]b)!*5889:;2!S<B@!W_V[2!:5)!]#a)!!! !

Page 198: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b#[!

%)(()W#[! T9BDC:!W[``!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!H$'2*;2$(&-%$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%6)!]G%$(<2+%#!%*%"+2,&%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!LBC;C:P!C:!;A9!"+2,&%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!%zTO!(2!W##)!

*5889:;2!S<B@!W_V[2!"b")!!! !

Page 199: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b#"!

%)(()W#"! T9BDC:!#"`_!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!N%$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'C;D9!B9I9BB9@!;5!5:9!5I!;A9!5II9BC:P!89:!B9EB9?9:;9@!5:!;A9!?;9D9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%9G%$+<2,'%*%"+2,&%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!"+2,&%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!%zTO!(2!WV#)!*5889:;2!S<B@!W_V[2!"b")!!! !

Page 200: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b#]!

%)(()W#]! '57D5?9!WWVW!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!5*2"0%$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! &96;<:P7D<B!?;9D9!LC;A!<:!C:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!65B:C69)!%;!;A9!;5E! ;A9! @969<?9@! C?! ?A5L:! ?9<;9@! C:! IB5:;! 5I! <:! 5II9BC:P!<;;9:@<:;)! %;! ;A9! >5;;58O! ]! IB<89?! 65:;<C:! ;A9!B9EB9?9:;<;C5:!5I!5L:9BQ?!9:;57B<P9)!!

%) 'C;D9!5I!;A9!5L:9B!!T) 'C;D9!B9I9BB9@!;5!5:9!5I!;A9!<;;9:@<:;?!B9EB9?9:;9@!

5:!;A9!?;9D9)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%%)%$+<2,'%*D'E%,-%%T)%$-(#*%,-%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!,-!!

%;;9:@<:;!5I!;A9!,-%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

3C8E?5:!W_#]2!%U,*!bb)])!*5889:;2!S<B@!W_V[2!ba_)!!! !

Page 201: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b#b!

%)(()W#b! 39<D!:5)!

W"]_!h!.*!

WW"]W%!

456789:;!;C;D9! 39<D!5I!5&899:2$;'%DNE%$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%$(<2+%#'%*%,-%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!ED<69HE5?C;C5:H?9<;!5I!;A9!,-%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!1<B;C:!W_#W2!:5)!W"]_O!ED)!]O!V)!*5889:;2!S<B@!W_V[2!"[[)!!! !

Page 202: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b#a!

%)(()W#a! 39<D!:5)!

W]#b!

456789:;!;C;D9! 39<D!5I!5*,,2$;%$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .B5:<B;C!c5B;)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! *D<J!?9<D!C8EB9??C5:!IB58!%E<B;89:;!W#!=&558!V]G)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%$+<2,'%*%"+2,&%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!"+2,&%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!1<B;C:!W_#W2!:5)!W]#b)!!&9C?:9B!h!SA99D9B!W_"`2!bWO!ICP)!]O![])!!&9C?:9B!W_bb2!bbO!W_)!47:A<8!h!g<:?9::!W_`a`^#O!((!2!aaO!W_)!*5889:;2!S<B@!W_V[2!:5)!]#a)!

!! !

Page 203: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b##!

%)(()W##! %D:LC6M!:5)!

W_"a!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!W#+2'#2*2,*)%$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! c7:9B<BJ! ?;9D9! C:! ;A9! ?A<E9! 5I! <! P<;9L<J! 5B! <! EB5EJD5:!LA9B9!;A9!5L:9B!C?!B9EB9?9:;9@!LC;A!AC?!5L:!I<8CDJ)!.:@9B!;A9!ICB?;!B9PC?;9B!C:!LAC6A!<B9!B9EB9?9:;9@!;L5!7B<97?O!,?CBC?!<:@!;A9!d<6M<D!P5@O!;A9B9!C?!<!@CFC?C5:!LC;A!;C;D9?!B9I9BB9@!;5!;A9!$A<B<5A)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%$+<2,'%*%"+2,&%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!"+2,&%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

TCB6A!WVV`2!ED)!b)!

*5889:;2!S<B@!W_V[2!:5)!]#a)!

!! !

Page 204: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b#V!

%)(()W#V! .*!W]a_a!

456789:;!;C;D9! cB<P89:;!5I!;A9!?;<;79!5I!@*C0%$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! +5L9B! E<B;! 5I! <! ><?<D;! ?;<;79;;9! 5I! @*C0% ?9<;9@! 5:! ;A9!PB57:@)! XC?! D<E! <:@! IB5:;! 5I! ;A9! D9P?! <B9! C:6C?9@!LC;A! I57B!A5BCZ5:;<D!DC:9?!5I!AC9B5PDJEAC6!C:?6BCE;C5:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!]G%)+"%,-%

!

,:9!LA5!C?!<;!;A9!A9<@H65:;B5DD9B!5I!;A9!,-%!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!$<P9!W_#a2!"[O!:5)!"])!

*5889:;2!S<B@!W_V[2!:5)!WW]`)!

!! !

Page 205: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b#_!

%)(()W#_! ET9BDC:!

W`[]V!

456789:;!;C;D9! $<EJB7?!T9BDC:!W`[]V%$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! +<A7:)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! $<EJB7?!B965B@C:P!B5J<D!FC6;7<D?!@9DCF9B9@!;5!;A9!&9?C@9:69!IB58!;A9!'98ED9)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%6)![G%899:%+%7*0%(%7+0%"*%7+%%,*)%*#08':%+%)&%*%$(<2+%)'('%*%(*)'%%>1*"0%'"<%.094%(%5)(25*0#+'%(&,2)+0%-*,%)*"2!%%

!

e@9?E<;6Af!;5!;A9!7*0%5:!;AC?!@<J!>9<BC:P!;A9!B5J<D!FC6;7<D?!e))f!

LC;A!B9I9B9:69!;5!;A9!>7B9<7!5I!;A9!*D5;A^I9?;CF<D!5I!%:7>C?!7E5:!AC?!857:;<C:!C:!5)(25*0#+'%;B79^5I^F5C69!<?!L9DD!<?!I5B!;A9!3<:@^I9?;CF<D)!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!l7CBM9!W___2!a#)!

!! !

Page 206: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! bV`!

%)((()W! E$<BC?!TC>!U<;!WV"^W_]!=E$BC??9G!

456789:;!;C;D9! 'A9!1<KC8?!5I!$;<A5;9E!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 4B<!%>7!9D^U<P<)!WW;A^W[;A!4J:)!49?6BCE;C5:! 'A9!1<KC8?!5I! $;<A5;9E!<B9! M:5L:! ;A<:M?! ;5! I57B!E<EJBC2!

;A9!E$BC??9O!;A9!ET1!EB9?9BF9@!C:!;L5!?9BC9?!5I!IB<P89:;?O!:5?)! W`"#W! <:@! W`]"bGO! ;A9! ET1! W`]`_! <:@! ;A9! ;<>D9?! 5I!*<B:<F5:!:5)! WO!V6+#UO! I57:@9@! <;!4B<!%>7! 9D^U<P<!@7BC:P!;A9!9K6<F<;C5:?!5I!+5B@!*<B:<F5:!EB9?9BF9@!C:!;A9!17?978!5I!*<CB5!:5)!]W#_`)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!%]]WG%)D&E(%#&9C%*%-+<02'"%]][G%$(<2+9C%*%"+2*#0'%]]"G%0**%"+9C%(*%-+%)0'94%]]]G%\;&09C%(%#'%$+<%

!(:6DC:9!J57B!><6M!C:!IB5:;!5I!;A9!?7E9BC5B!J57O!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'%=?5!;A<;G!J57B!A57?9!LCDD!B98<C:!5:!C;?!P55@?!<:@!J57B!B9L<B@!LCDD!>9!C:!AC?!=BCPA;G!ED<69)!!

U5;9?2!!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!}m><!W_ba2!bWO!D)!W")W`O!:5)!]][)!*<8C:5?!W_ba2!b[^"O!ED?)![V^"`)!g7:P9![``"2!WVW)!Y9B:7?![``W2!W`W)!!!! !

Page 207: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! bVW!

%)((()[! $<EJB7?!1CDDC:P9:!

456789:;!;C;D9! 'A9!(:?;B76;C5:!5I!NC:P!%89:98A<;!(!I5B!AC?!?5:!39?5?;BC?!(!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!W[;A!4J:)!49?6BCE;C5:! 'A9! ;9K;! C?! EB9?9BF9@! C:! ;A9! $<EJB7?!1CDDC:P9:! 5I! ;A9! WV;A!

4J:<?;JO! ;AB99! L55@9:! ;<>D9;?O! ?589! E<EJB7?! IB<P89:;?!<:@! :789B57?! 5?;B<6<! 5I! ;A9! ?<89! E9BC5@)! 'A9! 5BCPC:<D!F9B?C5:!5I! ;AC?! ;9K;!L<?! 658E5?9@!>J!<! B5J<D! ?6BC>9!5I! ;A9!W[;A!4J:<?;JO!EB5><>DJ!<;! ;A9!>9A9?;!5I! ;A9!MC:P!39?5?;BC?! (!<I;9B!;A9!<??<??C:<;C5:!5I!AC?!I<;A9B!%89:98A<;!()!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!%1![OVG%$*%$0%!.$%'0%7**0%(%7*0%

!%B9!B9>9D?!;<M9:!57;!IB58!;A9!7*0q!!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!Y5D;9:!W_]b2!W`]^W[V)!!'B<:?D<;C5:2!+C6A;A9C8!W_#"^W_V`O!(2!W"#)!-BCIIC;A!WV_a2!"b^bW)!!1<?E9B5!W_W])!!Y5D;9:2!W`]^W[V)!!+5E9Z!W_a"2![_^""!<:@!ED?)!]^V)!!X9D6M!W_a_>)!!'B<:?D<;C5:2!T%&O!(O!]#]^]V")!!/B8<:![``b2!#[^#])!!!! !

Page 208: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! bV[!

%)((()"! E+9:C:PB<@!WWWa%O!E15?65L!]abVO!E*<BD?>9BP!a!

456789:;!;C;D9! 'A9!(:?;B76;C5:!<@@B9??9@!;5!NC:P!19BCM<B9!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!W[;A!4J:)!49?6BCE;C5:! 'A9! ;9K;! C?! EB9?9BF9@! C:! ;AB99! IB<P89:;<BJ! E<EJBC! LAC6A!

5:DJ! E<B;DJ! 658ED989:;! 5:9! <:5;A9B)! 'A9J! <B9! $<EJB7?!+9:C:PB<@! WWWa%! @<;C:P! IB58! ;A9! ?965:@! A<DI! 5I! ;A9! WV;A!4J:<?;JO! $<EJB7?!15?65L! ]abV! IB58! ;A9! 9:@! 5I! ;A9! WV;A!4J:<?;J!<:@!$<EJB7?!*<BD?>9BP!a!IB58!;A9!?<89!E9BC5@)!'A9!L5BM!C?!6<?;!C:!;A9!I5B8!5I!<:!(:?;B76;C5:!?E5M9:!>J!<:!5D@!MC:P! ;5! AC?! ?5:! <:@! ?7669??5B)! 'A9! :<89! 5I! ;A9! I<;A9B! C?!<??789@! ;5! >9! ;A<;! 5I! 5:9! 5I! ;A9! ?9F9B<D! MC:P?! 5I! ;A9!_;AHW`;A!4J:<?;J!LA5!>5B9!;A9!:<89!NA9;J)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!%$!b#G%'#$%.&(09C%(+<%'0%7*0%%$!#W^[G%$09C%+)%'0%#+%*%7*0%+9#%%$!W`WG%0..0%#0'%(%.;,$0%#+D0E%(9#%.+%+C%+%7*0%%

!&<C?9!J57B!R57;A?O!;A9!7*0%LCDD!D5F9!J57!!R57!M:5L!LA<;!7*0!I5B9;5D@!<>57;!C;W!!

'A9!B9PC5:!5I!198EAC?!LC;A!W`)```!89:O!5IIC6C<D?!<B9!C:!C;!?C:69!;A9!;C89!C;!L<?!<!7*0!

U5;9?2!W!'A9!?9:;9:69!C?!B9I9BB9@!;5!;A<;!>9I5B92!o@5!:5;!@9<D!LC;A!;A9!357;AD<:@r!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!Y5D;9:!W_]b2!"^V"!<:@!ED?)!W^])!!'B<:?D<;C5:2!+C6A;A9C8!W_#"^W_V`O!(2!W"#)!! !

Page 209: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! bV"!

%)((()]! +57FB9!*!"`!456789:;!;C;D9! %!XJ8:!;5!,?CBC?!5:!;A9!?;9D9!5I!5;C2$+<%!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!W[;A!4J:)!49?6BCE;C5:! 'A9!+6T'U!5I!;A9!?;9D9!C?!C:?6BC>9@!LC;A!<!AJ8:!;5!,?CBC?O!;A9!

F9B?5!LC;A! <! AJ8:! ;5!1C:)! T5;A! <B9! B96C;9@! >J! ;A9! 5IIC6C<D!5;C2$+<% <:@! <B9! EB969@9@! >J! ;A9! EB<J9B! 5I! 5II9BC:P?)! 'C;D9!B9I9BB9@!;5!,?CBC?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!%@G!*;%#)&%*4+%(%,-%

!+5B@!5I!I<89!C:!;A9!,-!!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!39;A9!W_b_2!a]O!D)!V)!'B<:?D<;C5:2!+C6A;A9C8!W_#"^W_V`O!(2![`[^[`")!!$C9BB9;!WV#]^WV#VO![2!b_^a`)!!X<??<:!W_[_2!a^[_)!!-<J9?;!WVVa2!ED?)!KDFCC!<:@!DCCC)!!!

! !

Page 210: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! bV]!

%)((()b! Y<BC57?!456789:;!;C;D9! 'A9!'<D9!5I!3C:7A9!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! W[;A!4J:<?;J)!49?6BCE;C5:! 'AC?! L5BM! C?! M:5L:! >J! ?9F9B<D! 65EC9?)! 'A9! ;L5! EBC:6CE<D!

8<:7?6BCE;?! <B9! $)! T9BDC:! "`[[! LAC6A! @<;9?! IB58! ;A9! W[;A!4J:<?;J! <:@!$)! T9BDC:! W`]__!LAC6A!@<;9?! ;5! ;A9! 9:@!5I! ;A9!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!%!;ACB@!8<d5B!65EJ!C?!5:!<!D<BP9!5?;B<65:!C:!;A9!%?A85D9<:!17?978O!,KI5B@O!@<;C:P!;5!;A9!W_;A!4J:<?;J)!

%) $B9?9:;<;C5:!5I!3C:7A9)!

T) /?6<E9!5I!3C:7A9)!

*) /7D5PJ!5I!39?5?;BC?!()!

4) 3C:7A9Q?!<BBCF<D!;5!&9;d9:7)!

/) 'A9!B5J<D!<:?L9B!<:@!;A9!65:I9??C5:!5I!3C:7A9)!

c) *5EJ!5I!;A9!B5J<D!5B@9B!5I!39?5?;BC?!(!I5B!;A9!B9;7B:!5I!

3C:7A9!;5!/PJE;)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!%)!&!V^_G%$0%7*0%(%#S+%$;0%(%S(0%(+0%+0'<%0+'<%)'(0%%T)!T!V^_G%$+'9$%#('%(%)*'<'%*%C&9$%#"+%+%7*0%"*%%%T!"bG%-*,%..9*94%*9$%"-9*9C%**%-+%!#%_*%$0%0*%)"+'%(%7*0%%%*)!T!]a^]#G%..%C0$%*94%0!;9$%*94%*-(*%#&94%,P%+%,-%$'9*94%$0,'%*'%$'94%%%T!b`G%*'.%.&+D0E%)&#0'%$0%$'4%(94%(%7*0%,-94%%%%4)!T!_]^_bG%0-<'94%0"D0E'<%)..%)*'<D0E%+%7*0%&;94%-+9$%%T!W]_^Wb`G%0,+%0,+D0E!*%7&094%$0%('+9$%(%7*0!%T!WbbG%*4+%"+9$%0#)%#'9$%#)&0<9$%$(%,-%%%T!Wba^#G%*'+%*;%!&D0E%0,+'%'*%-'"9C%.$9C%0$%+%7*0%%T!WabG%-'"%*9$%*#0'%*%O('%,*)9$%(%)'"'94%*.9$%

!'A9!7*0!L<?!C:!?CD9:69O!A9<B;?!L9B9!C:!857B:C:PO!;A9!PB9<;!@57>D9!P<;9?!L9B9!?9<D9@!!(!@C@!8J!L<J!?57;AL<B@?)!(!@C@!:5;!ED<:!;5!B9<6A!;AC?!7*0%!'A9:!A9!?<C@!;5!89O!oSAJ!@C@!J57!6589!A9B9q!X<?!<:J;AC:P!A<EE9:9@!C:!;A9!7*0q%%!!'A9:!(!?E5M9!;5!AC8!C:!B9EDJ!;5!AC82!C:@99@!AC?!?5:!A<?!9:;9B9@!;A9!n-I%A9!A<?!;<M9:!;A9!C:A9BC;<:69!5I!AC?!I<;A9B!!X9!C?!5:9!?7EEB9??C:P!;A9!I5B9CP:!D<:@?O!LACD9!AC?!I<;A9B!?;<J9@!LC;A!AC8!C:!AC?!n-%!%!%:@!<:J!9:F5J!5:!AC?!L<J!;5!5B!IB58!;A9!7*0O!A9!?;5EE9@!>J!89!!!'A9!I7PC;CF9!ID99?!IB58!AC?!?7BB57:@C:P?O!>7;!8J!B9E7;<;C5:!C?!C:!;A9!7*0%%1J!9?;<;9!C?!IC:9O!8J!ED<69!C?!>B5<@O!8985BJ!5I!89!C?!C:!;A9!n-%%SA<;9F9B!P5@!I<;9@!;AC?!IDCPA;O!>9!PB<6C57?!<:@!>BC:P!89!><6M!;5!;A9!7*0%%1<J!;A9!MC:P!5I!/PJE;!>9!65:;9:;!LC;A!89O!

Page 211: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! bVb!

)+'%-*0'%*''%(%,-94%#.(9_%0"'0%*'%7+.09#%%%/)!T!W#a^##G%0*%$*%-(94%7&;94%*9$%7+%&0'%*'%)+0'%#&0_94%$;%*%;&C%$(%($%-Z&%*%)&#'%*;'%*#0'%*'%*#0'%(#0%(%,-94%-+%+._'%#.(9$%0"0'9#*%%c)!T!WVbG%"'9C%'*%*''%(%,-%T!WVaG%(*9#%+0.9#%(%($*%."'9#%'"9#%(%*#0<'%*'%'&%(#0%%!T!WV#G!99#%(%,7*0'<%0&-9C%!"##0%*%..9#*%*9C%,*)9C%(%&0'9#*%!T!WVVG%$+%*9C%$0'%+%O('%(&&C%7*0%)"+9*9C%$(94%#*9C%'&%+%+0'<%0+'<%%!T![`bG%;&C%*%,-%5&2*7'%..%D99E%%T![W]G!=))G!*;%#$&%#$&D0E%+)D<E'%#$&94%T![WbG!(%-(%*%#'"2#&%,*)%0.&%#*;%0*'%;&C%$(%#*.D0E%..%D99E!%%T![""G%(,%0$%(%7*0%(%#'9'*%*'9C%$#%-;#%&)'%*'%%%T![]WG%$0%"0%$+9*%;&C%_(%(%)*'$%%T![][G%-.;9$%-+%@+%0&'%S(-%'#0%*'<%(2#&%"7+'%T![]"G%7&;94%$"0'%+%7*0%+%+.$'%+)9'0%+.9$*%-(94!T![]]G%$0'%$(<2+%#C'<0%(*)%*%"+2*#0'%-*,%,-,0%&'"0%(2)'94%%%`%KlQE%7+%&0'%*'%*#0'%)+94%*%5'<0%_0%#&%(9$%-+%#*$%;'%+%@+%0&'%%T![]aG%.($9*9$%0,%#%$(%*;%(%+*94%_*00%*;%-+%$+<94%!#"9*9$%4&$9*9$%T![]#G%-'&0%!;;%,')%(&,9$%+%"-'<9$%.($%*%>1'_2'&0<%%T![]VG%-.D2'&E9*%+4%.0&'%$0%$&!9*9$%#%AR%(%$0'%#%AR%T![]_G!(%!(D'E%-+%#'&9$%+%,-%.7*9*9$%'&%$(D<E'D0E%!#"0%

8<J!(!DCF9!C:!AC?!ED9<?7B9O!PB99;C:P!;A9!8C?;B9??!LA5!C?!C:!AC?!,-!<:@!A9<BC:P!A9B!6ACD@B9:Q?!89??<P9?)!!%:@!XC?!1<d9?;J!?9:;!;5!89O!LC;A!>57:;J!5I!B5J<D!PCFC:PO!;5!PD<@@9:!;A9!A9<B;A!5I!AC?!A78>D9!?9BF<:;O!DCM9!<:J!B7D9B!5I!<!657:;BJO!<:@!;A9!MC:PQ?!6ACD@B9:!LA5!L9B9!C:!AC?!n-!D9;!89!A9<B!;A9CB!>7?C:9??!!!'AC?!C?!J57B!A9<F9:!LA5!C?!C:!;A9!n-I%%C;!C?!?;<>D9O!C;!C?!EB5?E9B57?O!C;?!A9<@!C?!@965B<;9@!LC;A!=;A9!9:?CP:?G!5I!;A9!MC:P@58!5I!;A9!D<:@!<:@!C;?!6ACD@B9:!<B9!C:!;A9!<7@C9:69!6A<8>9B)!R57!LCDD!?;5B9!7E!;A9!L9<D;A!PCF9:!>J!;A98O!<:@!DCF9!5:!;A9CB!>57:;J!$B9E<B9!J57B!B9;7B:!;5!/PJE;!;A<;!J57!8<J!?99!;A9%7*0!LA9B9!J57!>5B:O!MC??!;A9!9<B;A!5I!;A9!PB9<;!@57>D9!P<;9?!!'A9!?9BF<:;!5I!;A9!,-%?<J?!=))G!!'A9!+5B@!5I!@C?69B:89:;O!LA5!E9B69CF9?!;A9!E95ED9O!@C?69B:9@!C:!;A9!8<d9?;J!5I!;A9!#'"2#&I%D)!E)!A)O!LA<;!;A9!?9BF<:;!LA5!(!<8!L<?!<IB<C@!;5!?<J!%SA9;A9B!(!<8!C:!;A9!7*0I%LA9;A9B!(!<8!C:!;AC?!ED<69O!(;!C?!J57!LA5!F9CD?!;AC?!A5BCZ5:!5I!8C:9!!'AC?!A78>D9!?9BF<:;!;A9:!6<89!?57;AL<B@?O!<:@!(!A<D;9@!;A9!S<J?!5I!X5B7?)!'A9!6588<:@9B!LA5!L<?!C:!6A<BP9!5I!;A9!P<BBC?5:!!A9!?9:;!<!89??<P9!;5!;A9!7*0!;5!C:I5B8!;A98!;A9:!XC?!1<d9?;J!?9:;!;A9!P55@!5F9B?99B!5I!I5B<P9B?!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'%;5!6589O!<6658E<:C9@!>J!D<@9:!>5<;?O!<:@!>9<BC:P!>57:;J!5I!B5J<D!PCFC:P!I5B!;A9!3JBC<:?!LA5!A<?!6589!LC;A!89O!D9<@C:P!89!;5!;A9!S<J?!5I!X5B7?k!<:@!(!<::57:69@!9<6A!5:9!>J!AC?!:<89)!/F9BJ!?9BFC:P!8<:!L<?!<;!AC?!@7;J)!!(!?9;!?<CDO!LC;A!M:9<@C:P!<:@!>B99@C:P!>9?C@9!89O!7:;CD!(!B9<6A9@!;A9!A<B>5B!5I!(;d;<LJ)!!!SA9:!C;!L<?!@<L:O!F9BJ!9<BDJ!C:!;A9!85B:C:P!;A9J!6<89!<:@!6<DD9@!89O!;9:!89:!658C:PO!;9:!89:!P5C:P!;5!D9<@!89!;5!;A9!n-9%%(!;576A9@!;A9!PB57:@!>9;L99:!;A9!?EAC:K9?!

Page 212: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! bVa!

T![b`G%(#02*#0'%,-,D0E%(%0('%-+%$+'%)#409$%#(+0%#'&0%+%0&)%-+%+.$'9$%-+%0&'%,7*0'<%%%%T![b[G%S(9*9$%-(94%-+%#'%0+'%(%0('%*'%.,(%%0*9CD0$E%+4%%`%KQYE%.0*9C0$%-+%7'9$%)(9*9D$E%0$%(%;&-94%%%%T![V`G%$094%+%#(+%(,%%T![VWG%#+0%+.$'%94%(%P&;%!*<'%%T![V[G%0.&9'*%+%,7*0'<%.0&'%+%$+'%%T![V"G%-*,94%"+'9$%+94%(%7*0%(%T![V]G%,7*0'<%(#02*#'%-+%+.$'%*%,9#*%%T![VbG%!(9#*%)%+0'<%0+0'<%%%T![_#G%$0%$**%*9$%%T![_VG%!;&%(%,-%#"%Y%#"%l%(%7+0%

<?!;A9!B5J<D!6ACD@B9:!?;55@!C:!;A9!E5B;<DO!B969CFC:P!89k!<:@!;A9!IBC9:@?!LA5!7?A9B!<;!;A9!ECDD<B9@!A<DD!E7;!89!5:!;A9!L<J!5I!;A9!,7*0'<!(!I57:@!XC?!1<d9?;J!5:!;A9!PB9<;!;AB5:9!C:!;A9!E5B;<D!=<!MC5?MG!5I!9D96;B78)!'A9:!(!L<?!?;B9;6A9@!57;!5:!8J!>9DDJ!7:65:?6C57?!5I!8J?9DI!C:!IB5:;!5I!AC8!!X9!LCDD!>9!<!IBC9:@!<85:P!;A9!5IIC6C<D?O!!A9!LCDD!>9!ED<69@!C:!;A9!8C@?;!5I!;A9!657B;O!!EB5699@!;5!;A9!B5>C:P!,7*0'<!=6A<8>9BG!;5!<;;9:@!5:!AC8�!(!L9:;!I5B;A!IB58!;A9!<7@C9:69!6A<8>9BO!LC;A!;A9!B5J<D!6ACD@B9:!PCFC:P!;A9CB!A<:@?)!%:@!L9!L9:;!;AB57PA!;A9!PB9<;!@57>D9!E5B;<D)!!19<D?!L9B9!>B57PA;!;5!89!IB58!;A9!,-%;AB99!5B!I57B!;C89?!<!@<J!!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!39;A9!W_[V2!"^W#)!'B<:?D<;C5:2!+C6A;A9C8!W_#"^W_V`O!(2![`[^[`")!!$<BMC:?5:!W__#2![#^]")!!

! !

Page 213: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! bV#!

%)((()a! ET9BDC:!"`""!=ES9?;6<BG!

456789:;!;C;D9! 'AB99!'<D9?!5I!L5:@9B!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!W[;A!4J:)!=qG!49?6BCE;C5:! $<EJB7?!T9BDC:!"`""O!;A9!>9PC::C:P!5I!LAC6A!C?!D5?;O!65:;<C:?!

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b;A)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!%]OV^W`G%,-,9*%+.$9*%8-(%*%*#0':2;$'<%F;2C&%(&,2)+0%$'<9'0%'&%-('%W;&28$:*+%+%!.0%(-<'%*%7*0A%%%]O![]^bG%..9$*%*94%8-(94:%8_0%.;7*9*9$%,'%*;'%*':%"+28*#0':%8,*)%0.&%#*;:%+%--%*9$%#'%P;'%*%S(%*9$%#<%..9$*%*94%\&\&2(2,*)%QIA2KE%-0<2%&%0.&%-(9C%+%!%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%,"+%*9C%;&0%(%*4+0'%*;0'%*'%7*0%,-9C%%%%aO!W"^]G%0+!9*%-(94%-+%7+0%*4+%-*2,%"+2*#0'%,*)%0.&%#*;%($%P$94%"+9*%4P&9*94%7+<%-;'%-+<2'"%%\&\&2(2,*)%(%;0%*;%*4+%%%VOa^#G%$0'%"0%$+9*%\.$%(2).%(%0#)%*'<%#&%*#0'%\.942@+%$(94%)+2(2)'%#"+94%+%7*0%,P%"0%_+9*%#&%*#0'%\.942@+%+%#(_D'E%*%-(%*%*#0'2;$'<%B04%(&,2)+0%%VO#^W`G%..9$*%#&2*#0'%\.942@+%$'<%,*)%0.&%#*;%*;9$%$0%$**9$%\.$%..9$*%-(94%$#%$*%*!$%#0 0.&%"0%$+9*9-(94%+%0&)<%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%%%_OWVG%0.&%"0%$+%*%-(94%+%,-94%

!'A9:!;A9!8<d9?;J!5I!;A9!MC:P!5I!.EE9B!<:@!+5L9B!/PJE;!F;2C&O!d7?;CIC9@O!A<@!;A9!LCI9!5I!W;&2$*+!;<M9:!<L<J!;5!<!ED5;!5I!D<:@!:5B;A!5I!;A9!7*0!!eXC?!1<d9?;Jf!?<C@!;5!AC82!(!A<F9!eP5:9!;AB57PA!<DD!;A9!B558?f!C:!;A9!"+28*#0':O!D)!E)!A)O!C:!?9<B6A!5I!<!?9<;!5I!A9<D;A!=?589!B9DC9IG!I5B!8J?9DI)!'A9:!\&\&2(2,*)!?<C@!;5!AC82!L57D@!;A<;!R57B!1<d9?;J!EB5699@?!;5!;A9!D<M9!5I!"+2,&I%D)!E)!A9[%ICDD!<!>5<;!LC;A!<DD!;A9!>9<7;C9?!IB58!C:?C@9!J57B!n-!%XC?!1<d9?;J!?E9:;!<DD!;A9!@<J!8<MC:P!A5DC@<J!;5P9;A9B!LC;A!;A9!9:;CB9!"+2*#0'I%D)!E)!A)!<:@!?5!A9!B9L<B@9@!;A9!ACPA!D96;5B!\&\&2(2,*)!LC;A!9F9BJ!P55@!;AC:P%!\.$!;A9:!6<89!:5B;AL<B@?!C:!;A9!><BP9!C:!LAC6A!EBC:69!\.942@+%L<?)!%I;9B!A9!A<@!B9<6A9@!;A9!7*0O!$BC:69!\.942@+%9:;9B9@!C:;5!B9E5B;!;5!;A9!1<d9?;J!5I!MC:P!*A95E?!!%:@!EBC:69!\.942@+%?<C@2!Ä35F9B9CP:!=D)E)A)�GO!1J!+5B@O!(!A<F9!>B57PA;!\.$)Ä!XC?!1<d9?;J!?<C@2!oP5!<:@!>BC:P!AC8!;5!89�Ä!XC?!1<d9?;J!EB5699@9@!;5!;A9!<7@C9:69!A<DD!5I!;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)r!!%:@!;A9:!XC?!1<d9?;J!L9:;!C:;5!;A9!,-!!

U5;9?2!W!A9B9!;A9!L5B@!7*0!A<?!;A9!6C;J^@9;9B8C:<;CF9)!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!$7>DC6<;C5:2!+9EE9B![``V2!"]O!"aO!"_O!]]O!!

Page 214: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! bVV!

TD<6M8<:!W_VV2!]O!ED)!]O!D)!_k!bO!ED)!]O!D)![[O!ED)!b!D)![k!E)!#O!ED)!aO!D)!W]k!W`O!ED)!VO!D)!aO!W`k!W[O!ED)!_O!D)!WV)!39;A9!W_b_2![a^"a)!'B<:?D<;C5:2!!$<BMC:?5:!W__#2!W`_O!WWWO!O!WW]O!WWa)!+C6A;A9C8!W_#"^W_V`O!(2![Wa^[WV)!TB7::9B!'B<7;!W_#a2!W"^W])!!

! !

Page 215: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! bV_!

!%)((()#! E+9:C:PB<@!

WWWb!456789:;!;C;D9! 'A9!?;5BJ!5I!;A9!3ACELB96M9@!3<CD5B)!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!!49?6BCE;C5:! 'A9!5:DJ!EB9?9BF9@!65EJ!5I!;A9!;<D9!A<?!>99:!@C?65F9B9@!>J!

-5D9:C?6A9II! C:! ;A9! (8E9BC<D!17?978!5I! 3;)! $9;9B?>7BP! =$)!3;^$9;9B?>7BP! WWWbG! <:@! :5;AC:P! C?! M:5L:! <>57;! C;?!EB5F9:<:69)! 'A9! ;<D9! ;9DD?! <>57;! <! ACPA! 5IIC6C<D! B9;7B:C:P!IB58! <:! 9KE9@C;C5:! ;A<;! I<CD9@! C:! C;?! 5>d96;CF9O! I5B! A9! C?!I9<BI7D! 5I! ;A9! B969E;C5:! <L<C;C:P! AC8! <;! 657B;)! ,:9! 5I! AC?!<;;9:@<:;?!9KA5B;!AC8!657B<P9O!<:@!<?!<:!9K<8ED9!5I!A5L!<!@C?<?;9B!6<:!8<J!;7B:!C:;5!<!?7669??O!;9DD?!AC8!<!8<BF9D57?!<@F9:;7B9!;A<;!A<EE9:9@!;5!AC8!J9<B?!<P5)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!%DD)!Wa#^_G%,-,9*%..9*94%*9%$%(2,%'0%+%#"+%+%7*0%*%&;.%K%(9C%P*$9C%(%7+.09C%+*"$9C%(%7*0%P+#D'E9C%%%%DD)!W#[^bG%).$%+%7*0%*%$'<%#"+9*9*%+%7*0%-+%&;.%K%($%..'9*94%*;'%,-,9*%,P9C0$%-+%$'<(%(#9*9$%*9S%$*0%"*%$*$9*9$%(%7*0%*%'&%"*%,-,9*%*'+%$&09*94%*9$%)'94%-+%P*;0'%'&%+%.+94%

!X9!?<C@!;5!892!oR57!LCDD!B9<6A!;A9%7*0!C:!;L5!85:;A?O!J57!LCDD!98>B<69!J57B!6ACD@B9:O!J57!LCDD!ID57BC?A!<;!;A9!7*0O!J57!LCDD!>9!>7BC9@)!!S9!?<CD9@!:5B;A!;5!;A9!7*0%5I!;A9!MC:P)!S9!B9<6A9@!;A9!7*0!C:!;L5!85:;A?O!<DD!A9!A<?!?<C@)!(!L9:;!C:!;5!;A9!MC:P)!(!EB9?9:;9@!AC8!;A9!PCI;?!(!A<@!>B57PA;!I5B!;A9!7*0!IB58!;A<;!C?D<:@)!X9!EB<C?9@!P5@!I5B!89!C:!;A9!EB9?9:69!5I!;A9!657:6CD5B?!5I!;A9!LA5D9!D<:@)!!!

U5;9?2!!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!!-5D9:C?6A9II!W_W[2!ED?)!W^V)!TD<6M8<:!W_"[2!]#O!D)!Wa#^_k!W#[^b)!'B<:?D<;C5:2!!+C6A;A9C8!W_#"^W_V`O!(2![WW^[Wb)!/B8<:!W_`a2!W!II)!!

! !

Page 216: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b_`!

%)((()V! $<EJB7?!+9C@9:!"]]!

456789:;!;C;D9! 'A9!%@85:C;C5:?!5I!(E7L9B!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! $<EJB7?!+9C@9:!()"]]O!+6T'U)!+<;9!1C@@D9!NC:P@58)!49?6BCE;C5:! 'A9! ;9K;! C?! EB9?9BF9@! C:! <! ?C:PD9O! 876A! @<8<P9@! 65EJO!

$<EJB7?!+9C@9:!"]]O!LAC6A!@<;9?!IB58!;A9!W_;A!4J:<?;J)!!(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!%[)W`G%$02(#%#;)0'%0)&0%.+$0'%&((%%[)WWG%.+0'%"+2*#0'%,*)%0.&%#*;%(*%+0.%%%%")V^_G%-.%*;0%P*2L&[-2$]%$*<'%*'%C&0'%*;D'E%C4&%[99]%*'%"+2*#0'%n*)%0.&%#*;%%%%"O!W`^W[G%$02(#%&;0%'*<%[#"&0]'DNE%!(,0'%*%;&C%*%[-&],<'%-.%0,-%.;,'%$+'$0%(&,0%*0'%!'&0%C&'2-(00%.&[+'%DNE%P(0D'E2,-%_0%"+2-.%+2(%(2)('%;&C094!%%%%%#)a^#G%(*'%7*0%-+%#*.%(,%S&0'%*;D0E9$%+%0.D'E%-&<'%**%)#42,%%#)_^W`G%(*'%P*;'%*'%'&%.+'<%+%)'%'&%.+%(%"+<'%*#0'%(*'%!"#0%-+%!.<'%#+0%(%!*,%%

%

%

%

W`)"^aG%+(<'%+4%'&%(-0%!*,%*%*#0'%(%7&$9%$%_*9'0%*9$%*%;0%*;0%$0%"+2*#0'%n*)%0.&%#*;%+%+.94%(%)('%;&C094%*'4%$'%;.'%&".0%+(0%*'4%-.'%"&P'%-('<%(+-'%*'#%"#!D'E%P*0%*-[;0']%P*$0%;&C0%*;%*4+%$$94%$+0%$0%0.4%#C'9#'%(%"+2*#0'%n*)%0.&%#*;%**%!0'0%(2[99]%*[4]&!%%%%%%W`)aG%-.0%)4'$0%*0%7*0%["4]%!"#%#;P%P*;'%%W`)#^VG%-[.0%)4'$0%*0%7*0%"4%!"#]%#;P%%W`)V^_G%[-.0%)4'$0%*02]%7*0%"4%!"#%,!&%7"0%

!$5B;<D?O!ECDD<B?!<:@!L<DD?!<B9!>7B:C:Pk!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'!?;<:@?!ICB8!<:@!9:@7BC:P!!49?;B5J9@!C?!P5D@O!IC:C?AC:P!C?!;A9!?;5B[C:P!7E!5I!;A9!8<;9BC<D?!=qGW!5I!9F9BJ!L5BMO!7:65F9B9@![))]%C?!;A9!"+2*#0'!!!/D9EA<:;C:9O!'AC:C?O!;A9!.EE9B!/PJE;C<:!:589?!A<F9!:5;!E<C@!;<K!>96<7?9!5I!;A9![?;BCI9])!49?;B5J9@!<B9!PB<C:O!M5ADO!$+'$^IB7C;O!C?!;A9!EB5IC;!=qGO!8<<;!?;C6M?!:7;!?;C6M?O!?AB7>!L55@O!<:@!;A9!L5BM!5I!;A9!6B<I;?89:O!65D56J:;AO!I9:7PB99MO!<:@!;A9!EB5IC;?!5I!;A9!,-!SA<;!C?!<!;B9<?7BJ!I5B!LC;A57;!C;?!;<K9?q!!+55MO!;A9!7*0!C?!I9<BI7D!IB58!L<:;)!T7;!1J!+5B@!LCDD!?;CB!7E!?;BCI9!7:5EE5?9@)!!+55MO!;A9!657:6CD!5I!;A9!D<:@!C?!@BCF9:!<L<J!;AB57PA!;A9!D<:@k!X9!LA5!L<?!@BCF9!<L<J!C?!:5L!C:!;A9!9?;<;9?!5I!;A9!MC:P)!+55MO!L9<D;AJ!D<@C9?!<B9!5:!>5<B@?k!5IIC6C<D?!<B9!C:!;A9!L5BMA57?9!!+9;!;A9!8<B?AD<:@!L99E)!'A9!MC:PQ?!?;5B9A57?9!C?!<!IB99!I5B!<DD!I5B!9F9BJ5:9O!<:@!;A9!LA5D9!"+2*#0'I%D)!E)!A)O!C?!LC;A57;!C;?!@7;C9?)!'5!C;!?A57D@!>9D5:P!PB<C:!<:@!><BD9JO!I5LD!<:@!IC?Ak!;5!C;!?A57D@!>9D5:P!LAC;9!DC:9:!<:@!IC:9!DC:9:O!>B5:Z9!<:@!5CDk!;5!C;!?A57D@!>9D5:P!"#!D'E^8<;;C:P!<:@!P*28<;;C:PO!=D5;7?G!>7@?!<:@!LA9<;!?A9<F9?!h!LC;A!9F9BJ!P55@!658C:P!=B9<@JG!8<@9)!(I!658ED<C:;!<>57;!;A9?9!DC:P9B?!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%=D)!E)!A)G!:5!5:9!6<:!>9!IB99!IB58!=;A9!D5??G!5I!;A9?9!;AC:P?)!!49?;B5J!;A9!9:98C9?!5I![;A<;]!IC:9!7*0!LC;A!?ED9:@C@!657:6CD5B?)!4[9?;B5J!;A9!9:98C9?!5I!;A<;!IC:9!7*0]!?ED9:@C@!5I![))]![49?;B5J!;A9!9:98C9?!5I]!;A<;!IC:9!7*0!LC;A!

Page 217: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b_W!

%AR9k2ARE%[-.0%)4'$0%*0%7*0]%"4%!"#%%%W`)W`^WWG%[-].0%)4'$0%*0%7*0%"4%[!"#99]%%W`)WW^W[G%[-.0%)4'$0%*0%7*0%"]4%!"#%,!&%)&0%%

8<:J!D<L?![49?;B5J!;A9!9:98C9?!5I]!;A<;!IC:9![7*0]!!49?;B5J!;A9!9:98C9?!5I!;A<;![IC:9]!7*0!![49?;B5J!;A9!9:98C9?!5I!;A]<;!IC:9![7*0]!LC;A!8<:J!5IIC69?)!!

U5;9?2!W!c5B!$*<'%<?!o8<;9BC<D?r!?99!c<7DM:9B!W_a]2![b)%!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!/:8<B6A![``b)!'B<:?D<;C5:2!+C6A;A9C8!W_#"^W_V`O!(2!W]_^Wa")!!-<B@C:9B!W_`_<)!!/B8<:![``b2!_[^W`V)!!c<7DM:9B!W_ab2!b"!II)!!c<7DM:9B!W_a]2![]!II)!! !

Page 218: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b_[!

T)()W! *<CB5!g/!]W#_`!h!*<B:<F5:!;<>D9;!(!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!<:@!;<>D9;!5I!NC:P!N<85?9!B9E5B;C:P!AC?!L<B!<P<C:?;!;A9!XJM?5?!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!N<85?9O!R)!W#)!49?6BCE;C5:! 'A9! ?;9D9!5I!N<85?9!A<?!>99:! I57:@! C:! ;A9! I57:@<;C5:?!5I!

;A9! "B@! EJD5:! <;! N<B:<M)! 'A9! ;9K;O! B9E5B;C:P! ;A9! 65:IDC6;!>9;L99:!;A9!MC:P!<:@!;A9!XJM?5?!6<:!>9!658E<B9@!;5!;A<;!EB9?9BF9@! 5:! ;A9! *<B:<F5:! '<>D9;! IB58! 'A9>9?)!(:;B5@76;5BJ!9KEB9??C5:!C:!;A9!?;9D9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!%D)![G%..%(.00%*%-(94%,-94%*%.&.&'%0+0%*'<%(2)'94%%

!3<JC:P!;AC:P?!C:!;A9!EB9?9:69!5I!XC?!1<d9?;J!C:!AC?!,-!>J!;A9!657:6CD!5I!;A9!PB9<;!5:9?!LA5!<;;9:@!AC8!!!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!*<B;9B!W_W[2!ED)![#^V)!!X9D6M!W_#b<2!V"!=*'GO!D)![)!!,B9:!W__#2!W")!!+<6<7!W_"_2![bW)!$1!W2[O!aWV)!!! !

Page 219: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b_"!

T)()[! N<B:<M!W!456789:;!;C;D9! '98E9?;!?;9D9!5I!%A85?9!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<M)!%A85?9)!!49?6BCE;C5:! cB<P89:;?!5I!<!?;9D9!9B96;9@!>J!;A9!$A<B<5A!%A85?9!C:!;A9!

;98ED9! 5I! N<B:<M)! 'A9! IB<P89:;<BJ! ?96;C5:! @9?6BC>9?! <:!5II9BC:P^69B985:J!EB5><>DJ!65:?C?;C:P!5I!<!EB569??C5:!5I!;A9!C8<P9! 5I! %87:! <:@! E9BA<E?! <D?5! ;A5?9! 5I! 5;A9B! 'A9><:!P5@?)!'A9!65:;9:;!5I!;A9!IC:<D!D<67:<!C:!;AC?!?96;C5:!=DD)!b^aG!C?!7:69B;<C:O! >7;! EB5><>DJ! C:F5DF9@! 89:;C5:! 5I! ;A9! MC:PQ?!B9;7B:! IB58! 'A9>9?! ;5! AC?! B9?C@9:69)! 'A9! 6D<7?9?! I5DD5LC:P!;AC?! P<E! 65:;<C:! ;A9! @9?6BCE;C5:! 5I! ;A9! MC:PQ?! B9;7B:! ;5!'A9>9?!<:@!AC?!9:657:;9B!LC;A!%87:Q?! C8<P9)! (:!/PJE;C<:?Q!8C:@O! ;A9!6<;<?;B5EA9!@9?6BC>9@! C:! ;A9! ?;9D9!L<?! ?99:!<?!<!8<:CI9?;<;C5:! 5I! %87:Q?! @9?CB9! ;A<;! %A85?9! B9;7B:9@! ;5!'A9>9?! <:@! 5I! ;A9! P5@Q?! @98<:@! ;A<;! A9! ;7B:9@! AC?!<;;9:;C5:!;5!;A9!65:@C;C5:!5I!;A9CB!;98ED9?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!!D)!"G%D99E%0*9$*%-(94%)*'%+%+8.$'%*94%99:%0,;%)+%(%)'%'&%,&8;'99%D)!]G%99#:*%)+%.$9'0%-+%(899:%"*%$#'%S+'%#!(%%%D)!bG%899:%-,094%7*(%(%+2"+%"*%b0'94%7+%+!08'%0*9$*%-(94%)%+%7*0%%D)!aG%"+2,&%,*)%D0E.&%#D*;E%$#'%S+'%*'+:%"*%,&%-+%&;<'%8,*%#:0%-(94%8)+94%$0:%*'+0%-+%!*'%-*09#*%*%8*;0:%%%D)!W[G%#"+%"0%$+9*%-(94%+%7*0%*%W&#'%*;0%-#%(%8*;0:%#!(%"*%!#"94%&;D'E9*94%%%%D)!W]G!#*.(%"0%$+9*%-(94%(%7*0%"+2,&!!!%

!XC?!1<d9?;J!?<CD9@!7E?;B9<8!e;5!PCF9!AC8f!<!E7B9!5II9BC:P)!%I;9B!;AC?!5II9BeC:P^69B985:J!!));Af98O!<:@!;A9J!L9B9!E7;!5:!;A9!e))f!;AC?!e:589fO!LACD9!;A9!EB569??C5:<D!C8<P9!!e))fO!AC?!>5@J!7:C;9@!LC;A!AC?!;98ED9O!AC?!DC8>?!C:!d5J)!e'A9:!XC?!1<d9?;J!?<CD9@!@5L:?;B9<8!;5!;A9!7*0%"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)!>7;!;AC?!PB9<;!P5@f!L<?!@9?CBC:P!;A<;!XC?!(:6<B:<;C5:!eB9;7B:?!;5!AC8fO!LACD9!;A9!P5@?!L9B9!<?MC:P!I5B!e<DDf!;A9CB!67D;!?9BFC69?!!SA<;!XC?!1<d9?;J!@C@!L<?!;5!<BBCF9!<;!'A9>9?!<:@!P5D@!9:657:;9B9@!;A9!P5D@!5I!AC?!EB569??C5:<D!C8<P9O!?5!;A<;!A9!B969CF9@!LA<;!A9!A<?!@9?CB9@!SA<;!XC?!1<d9?;J!@C@!L<?!;5!B9?;!C:!;A9!7*0%"+2,&O!D)!E)!A)!!!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!SC9:9B!^!%DD9:!W__V)!!! !

Page 220: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b_]!

T)()"! N<B:<M![!456789:;!;C;D9! 45:<;C5:!?;9D9!5I!l799:!%A85?9!U9I9B;<BC!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<MO!"B@!$JD5:)!%A85?9O!#!R)!49?6BCE;C5:! &96;<:P7D<B! ?<:@?;5:9! ?;9D9! I57:@! C:! ;A9! "B@! EJD5:! 5I! ;A9!

;98ED9!5I!N<B:<MO!>7CD;!>J!%89:A5;9E!(((!LC;A!B9^7?9@!>D56M?!IB58!5;A9B!85:789:;?)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!%D)!WG%[-&'2#"99]%%&;.%l%&)'%#0%c%)+%-(%*%*#0'%;$'<%F;2"-'<2?,%#&%?,%>1,-2(#%,*)%.'%+%*--%$+0%(2;&-%%%D)![G%[P*;'<0]%*0%#&'0%*$0'%0*'%-0'2*'+%*'%>1(*%...'%(%-(%*%#'"2%%D)!"G%2#&%,*)%0.&%#*;%(%7+0%["*%+2..]%[0**%'&%N]%$&0'%*'%-(%*'+%#*<%*%>1(*%*%-('%*'+%-('%*#0'%%D)!]G%0+'%7*('%*4+%-.'%>1,-2(#%F4+2$+<%,*)9'$%

![R9<B!5I!MC:P@58))]!;A9!];A!85:;A!5I!&)'I!;A9!#;A!7:@9B!;A9!8<d9?;J!5I!;A9!NC:P!5I!.EE9B!<:@!+5L9B!/PJE;O!F;2"-'<2?,I%;A9!?5:!5I!&<O!%A85?9O!;A<;!A9!8<J!DCF9!I5B9F9B!<:@!C:!9;9B:C;J)!1<@9!C:!;A9!EB9?9:69!5I!![;A9!657:6CD5B?]!5I!;A9!;9BBC;5BJ!5I!'A9>9?!=qG!<:@!;A9!;98ED9!EBC9?;A55@!5I!%87:)!'AC?!C?!LA<;!L<?!?<C@!>J!;A9!8<d9?;J!5I!;A9!#'"%2#&I%D)!E)!A)!5:!;AC?!@<J2!o;A9!5IIC69!5I!;A9!3965:@!EBC9?;!5I!%87:!e?A<DDf!>9D5:P!;5!;A9!-5@Q?!SCI9O!%-B9<;!&5J<D!SCI9O!7:C;9@!LC;A!;A9!LAC;9!6B5L:O!%A85?9!U9I9B;<BCO!DCFC:P)!!!

U5;9?2!!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!*A9FBC9B!W_"b^a2!W"#O!ED)![)!-C;;5:!W_#a2!$D)!W])!-C;;5:!W_#_2!"[#^""W)!19:7!W_##2!V_^W``)!'B<:?D<;C5:!<:@!;B<:?DC;9B<;C5:2!'B<E<:C![``[2!Wb[^Wab)!!!! !

Page 221: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b_b!

!T)()]! N<B:<M!"!456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!'A7;85?9!C:!;A9!;98ED9!5I!%87:!<;!N<B:<M!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<M)!'A7;)!((()!49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:! 5I! 'A7;85?9! (((! 5:! ;A9! ?57;A9B:! L<DD! >7CD;! >J!

'A7;85?9!<:@!X<;?A9E?7;!C:!;A9!;98ED9!5I!%87:!<;!N<B:<M)!(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!!D)!W[G!.$9*94%),$%@+%(%7*0%W&#'!!!D)!["G!*4+0%(.0'%'*%..'%)+9#*%#.(%*'%*0%(%#'"2#&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%

!3A9!8<@9!X5B7?!<EE9<B!C:!;A9!7*0%5I!'A9>9?!!X5L!E9BI96;!C?!;AC?!?E996A!;A<;!L<?!?<C@!>9I5B9!7?O!LAC6A!L9!A<F9!A9<B@!C:!;A9!#'"2#&I%D)!E)!A)!!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!Wa`O!W]k!WabO!W`)!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!!TB7P?6A!WVV"^WV_WO!Y(2!W[VW^W[_`)!!1<BC9;;9!WV#b2!ED)!W]^Wa)!!@9!&57P{!WV##^#_2!Wab^W#b)!!!! !

Page 222: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b_a!

T)()b! N<B:<M!]!456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:?!5I!'A7;85?9!(((!6<BF9@!5:!;A9!?57;A!L<DD!5I!

'A7;85?9!(((Q?!c9?;CF<D!X<DD!<;!N<B:<M!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<M)!'A7;)!(((O!R)![")!49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!C:!LAC6A!'A7;85?9!(((!9KEB9??9?!AC?!PB<;C;7@9!;5!

%87:!I5B!;A9!PB9<;!FC6;5BJ!<665B@9@!;5!AC8!<;!19PC@@5!6<BF9@!5:!;A9!>D56M?!5I!;A9!c9?;CF<D!X<DD!5I!'A7;85?9!((()!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!!6)!WG!)"+%-(#'%*#0'%(%.&.0%*%$(<%0+'%(%[,-]94%!D)!#[G!=-(%+.$'E%'"'!O('%$.;0!"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%+%!*0'%*'+%%

!'A9B9!5667BB9@!<!?C;;C:P!5I!;A9!MC:P!C:!;A9!<7@C9:69!A<DD!5I!;A9!L9?;!C:!AC?![,-]%!=1J!1<d9?;J!6588<:@9@G!;A9!>9?;!5I!/PJE;O!;A9!?5CD!5I!;A9!"+2,&O!D)!E)!A)!;5!;A9!PB<:<BJ!5I!@CFC:9!5II9BC:P?!!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;9K;2!-<B@C:9B!W_b[2!Wa^W#O!ED)!((O!65D)!#[)!!.&N!(Y2!W[b[O!W[k!W[abO!WW)!!! !

Page 223: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b_#!

T)()a! N<B:<M!b!456789:;!;C;D9! %::<D?!5I!'A7;85?9!(((!6<BF9@!5:!;A9!L<DD?!5I!;L5!A<DD?!

D56<;9@!>9AC:@!;A9!a;A!EJD5:!C:!;A9!;98ED9!5I!N<B:<M!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<M)!'A7;)!((()!49?6BCE;C5:! 'A9!?96;C5:!C?!;A<;!@9?6BC>C:P!;A9!><;;D9!5I!19PC@@5O!I57PA;!

>9;L99:!;A9!/PJE;C<:?O!D9@!>J!MC:P!'A7;85?9!(((O!<:@!;A9!3JBC<:!*5:I9@9B<6J!A9D@!>J!;A9!B7D9B!5I!l<@9?A)!47BC:P!;A9!8<B6A!;5!19PC@@5!;A9!MC:P!<:@!AC?!<B8J!?;5EE9@!<;!;A9!;5L:!5I!R9A989:!C:!5B@9B!;5!@C?67??!LAC6A!B5<@!;5!;<M9!;5!;A9!6C;J)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!%D)!WV^W_G!0.%[-(94]%*.0'2+%-*2,%(!,94%*)'%D99E%%%D)!"_G!..0'%(%-(%*%#'"2#&%,*)%0.&%#*;%

![XC?!1<d9?;J]%6588<:@9@!<!65:?7D;<;C5:!C:!IB5:;!5I!AC?!FC6;5BC57?!<B8J!=))G!!SA<;!L<?!?<C@!>9I5B9!;A9!8<d9?;J!5I!;A9!#'"2#&I%D)!E)!A)!!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!abWO!W)!!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!U9D?5:!W_W")!!c<7DM:9B!W_][2!bO!A)!!1<?E9B5!WVb"2!]V!II)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!TB7P?6A!WVV"^WV_WO!Y2!WWb"^WWaV)!!+9E?C7?!W_#"O!(((2!"W>^"[)!!!! !

Page 224: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b_V!

T)()#! 398:<!W!456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!'A7;85?9!(((!IB58!398:<!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 398:<)!'A7;)!(((O!R)![)!49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:! 5:! ;A9! 9K;9BC5B! I<69! 5I! ;A9! 9<?;! L<DD! 5I! ;A9!

'98ED9!5I!\.0*%<;!398:<)!(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!!D)![G%\..'%(%-(%*%#'"2#&%,*)%0.&%#*;%*%)'(0%;$'<%#(+%0,'<%*#0'%#&%$(<2+%?#0'%8F-<:%%%D)!"G%$(%(%+.$%)'$%'0%"&%-'"02*'+%$+9*9*#0'2%;$'<%*;%'&0<%*;%$+'%)'0%O&02),2?,I%@+%)"+02*'+%[(&,2)+0]%*%[*'+0%*;0%H&25'$]%%%D)!]G%(%-0'2*'+%*'%'4%\.0*%)*'<%H&25'$%%%

!SA<;!L<?!?<C@!>9I5B9!;A9!8<d9?;J!5I!;A9!#'"2#&I%D)!E)!A)!;5!;A9!?9<D9B!5I!;A9!MC:PO!;A9!?5D9!IBC9:@O!;A9!MC:PQ?!?5:O!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!357;A9B:!D<:@!8F-<:2!o+9;!;A9!@CFC:9!5II9BC:P?!>9!=B9G6<BF9@O!LAC6A!;A9!NC:P!5I!.EE9B!<:@!+5L9B!/PJE;O!+5B@!5I!;A9!'L5!+<:@?O!+5B@!5I!;A9!&C;7<DO!O&02),2?,I!;A9!X5B7?!4CFC:9^5I^TCB;A?O!ed7?;CIC9@fO!8<@9!I5B!<DD!;A9!eP5@?f!5I!eU7>C<fO!C:!;A9!;98ED9!5I!AC?!I<;A9B!\.0*I%I5B985?;!5I!U7>C<)r!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!W_]O!W^a)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!*<8C:5?!W__V2!]"^]]O!ED)![b)!45B8<:!W_VV2!W_[)!47:A<8!h!g<:?9::!W_a`O!(2!V^WW)!!!! !

Page 225: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! b__!

T)()V! 1c%![")#""!456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!'A7;85?9!(((!<;!-9>9D!T<BM<D%$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!'A7;)!((()!49?6BCE;C5:! 396;C5:!@9?6BC>C:P!9KE9@C;C5:?!C:!U7>C<!<:@!3JBC<)!!(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!%D)![VG%(.-'%0$%(2+%#'"2#&%,*)%0.&%#*;%'*0%+*"'%*;'%(%)('<0%-+%,-,0%,!&%+%$#0'%,"+0%-+02+%;&C0%%#'$0%(%&;0%7;*<%%%%%D)!"`G%(.-%*9$%[(%\&7<]%'*0%+*"'%*;'%(%,!%(&,%*%?(**%$*0%+%#'"2#&%,*)%0.&%#*;%$0%*9$%)0.'%+%O('%#)*'0%899:%(&8,:%*%FS&0%(%#'"%*%H&2*'+%#0.%#'%(&8,:%($%!#%+%#"+'%+%7*0!%%%DD)!]a^VG%8999:%0+0%*;0%+(**%."0'2*#0'%+%#)*'%$(9#*%+%$*'%;$&<'%*;'%[99]%[!)]%*'2'&%+%#'"2#&%D,*)%0.&%#*;E%0+0%*0%[99]%0+0%*%?'*0%#'&%*&%*%#*0'%-+%$-0%+%(+<'%*'#*%$<$%7+%;&C09#*%+%;0%7+%-(94%+%7*0%(%7+%(&,%*;%*4+%$*0%($%*.'%*;'%*'%-(9$%%%%%%

!'A9B9!L9B9!>7CD;!;A9B9!I5B!#'"2#&I%D)!E)!A)O!9<6A!<:@!9F9BJ!@<J!)('<02?ACE?!<:@!8<:J!,-,02?ACE?O!85B9!;A9:!;A9B9!<B9!6B9L?!5I!?<CD5B?!C:!<@@C;C5:!;5!;A9!;BC>7;9?! e)))f;A9!>9@57C:!5I!%?C<!C:!CF5BJ!<:@!9>5:J)!!'A9B9!C?!A9L:!I5B!89!C:!\&7<!9<6A!<:@!9F9BJ!J9<B!65:?C?;C:P!5I!B9<D!,!2L55@!5I!+9><:5:O!=C;G!C?!>B57PA;!;5!;A9!#'"2#&I%D)!E)!A)!$B96C57?!L55@!6589?!I5B!89!;5!/PJE;O!>B57PA;!?57;AO!e)))f!B9<D!e)))f!IB58!FS&0O!(&8,^L55@f!DCM9!<D<><?;9B!I5B!?7EEDJ!;5!;A9%7*0!!%DD!;A9!EBC:69?!5I!+9><:5:!e)))f!;A9!B5J<D!?ACE?O!;5!;B<F9D!?57;A!;A9B9C:O!;5!I9;6A!<DD!MC:@?!5I!EB96C57?!P55@?!e)))f!;A9!?57;A9B:!D<:@O!;5!#'"2#&%=D)!E)!A)G)!'A9!EBC:69?!5I!e)))f!'A9!EBC:69?!5I!?'*0!@B<PP9@!;A9?9!ID<P!E5D9?!LC;A!5K9:!;5!;A9!A<B>5BO!<:@!;A9J!6<89!LC;A!;A9CB!;BC>7;9?!;5!;A9!ED<69!LA9B9!XC?!1<d9?;J!L<?O!;5!;A9!7*0!C:!e)))f!LC;A!<DD!P55@!EB5@76;?!;A<;!L9B9!>B57PA;!<?!EB96C57?!P55@?!IB58!;A9!?57;AO!e)))f!6A<BP9@!<?!;BC>7;9?!5I!;A9!<::7<D!B9\7CB989:;?O!<?!<DD!?7>d96;?!5I!1J!1<d9?;J)!!

U5;9?2!!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!.&N!(Y2!W["#O!W^[k!W["#O!_^W`k!W[][O![^])!'B<:?DC;9B<;C5:!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!49!T76M!W_]V2!ba^a")!c5B!E7>DC?A9@!;B<:?D<;C5:?2!*788C:P!W_V[)!!X<::CP!W__b)!!X9D6M!W_V])!&9C?:9B!h!&9C?:9B!W_"")!!! !

Page 226: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a``!

T)()_! N<B:<M!a!456789:;!;C;D9! '9K;!5I!*5B5:<;C5:!5I!X<;?A9E?7;!IB58!;A9!&9@^*A<E9D!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<M)!X<;?A)! !49?6BCE;C5:! '9K;! C:?6BC>9@!5:!;A9!>D56M?!5I!;A9!&9@!*A<E9D! I57:@! C:!;A9!

"B@!EJD5:!5I!N<B:<M)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5I!;A9!?57;A9B:!I<v<@9!5I!;A9!6A<E9D)!%)!cCB?;!?96;C5:!@9?6BC>C:P!;A9!5B<67D<B!EB569??C5:!5I!%87:!C:!;A9!;98ED9!5I!N<B:<M)!!T)! 'ACB@! ?96;C5:2! EB56D<8<;C5:! 5I! %87:O! EB569??C5:! <:@!9:;AB5:CZ<;C5:!5I!X<;?A9E?7;)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!%)!DD)!b^#G%#"+%-(94%+%'"%$'+0%-+%;$&<'%,&'%0+'%+%#;&0<%*%,-%*#0'%*'<%-+%S#%*%-+'%0.-0%%%%DD)!_^W[G%0*9$*%-(%F;2+2.+%#).9*%-+94%+%$&;'%-+%;$&<'%+%#;&0<%$(*'%,-%*%0#)'%*'%**%0&$2+94%*'<%-+%(&,%*%'"%$'+0%$*%+#%*;'%'&0<%(%7*0%.#+0%*0%,-9#%%%T)!DD)!W_^[[G%#"+%-(94%+%-.%!"#%+0'<%0+'<%*%*;'%'&0<%#'%$#%*#0'%!(#%+%-0'%*'%>1(*%,P%-(94%+%)*'%,-%*%**%0&$2+94%"+2>1(*%%%%%%

!XC?!1<d9?;J!<BBCF9?!;5!;A9!A9<@!5I!;A9!BCF9B!I5B!<!F9BJ!>CP!5B<6D9!;5!;A9!@57>D9!P<;9?!5I!;A9!,-%5I!;A9!MC:P!LAC6A!C?!5:!;A9!?C@9!5I!;A9!B5<@!5I!;A9!5II9BC:P?!!'A9:!;A9!1<d9?;JO!+5B@!5I!;A9!.:CF9B?9!A<@!AC?!A9<@!C:6DC:9@!;5!;A9!9<?;!8<MC:P!<:!5B<6D9!;5!;A9!L9?;9B:!@57>D9!P<;9!5I!;A9!,-!C:!;A9!A<DD!5I!**%0&$2+94O!LAC6A!C?!5:!;A9!><:M!5I!;A9!A9<@!5I!;A9!BCF9Bk!'A9!+<@J!5I!;A9!'L5!+<:@?!6<89!IB58!C:?C@9!;A9!?<6B9@!ED<69?!5I!A9B!n-%%XC?!1<d9?;J!<BBCF9?!;5!;A9!F9:9B<>D9!6A<E9DO!<:@!=qG!;A9!PB9<;!@57>D9!P<;9!5I!;A9!+<@J!5I!;A9!'L5!+<:@?!I5B!;A9!9?;<>DC?A89:;!5I!;A9!B5J<D!9?65B;!;5!;A9!;98ED9!5I!%87:)!XC?!1<d9?;J!=;A9!P5@G!9:;9B?!C:;5!;A9!IB5:;!5I!;A9!,-%:<89@!**%0&$2+94O!A57?9!5I!%87:!!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!-C;;5:!W_#]2!a"!II)!!+<6<7!^!*A9FBC9B!W_##^#_2!tWa[^Wa#)!!! !

Page 227: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a`W!

T)()W`! 49CB!9D^T<A<BC!W!

456789:;!;C;D9! '9K;!5I!*5B5:<;C5:!5I!X<;?A9E?7;!IB58!49CB!9D^T<A<BC!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 49CB!9D^T<A<BC)!X<;?A)!49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:! IB58! ;A9! ?57;A9B:! I<v<@9! IB58! ;A9! ;98ED9! 5I!

49CB!9D^T<A<BC)!!'9K;!B965:?;B76;9@!5:!;A9!><?C?!5I!;A9!658E<BC?5:!LC;A!;A9!?<89!C:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!N<B:<M)!!%)! cCB?;! ?96;C5:!@9?6BC>C:P! ;A9!5B<67D<B!EB569??C5:!5I!%87:!C:!;A9!;98ED9!5I!N<B:<M)!!T)! 'ACB@! ?96;C5:2! EB56D<8<;C5:! 5I! %87:O! EB569??C5:! <:@!9:;AB5:989:;!5I!X<;?A9E?7;)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!%)!!DD)!b^#G%#"+%8-(94%+%'"%$'+0%-+%;$&<'%,&'%0+'%+%#;&0<%*%,-%*#0'%*'<%-+%S#%*%-+'%0.-0:%%%%DD)!_^W[G%0*9$*%-(%8F;2+2.+%#).9:*%-+94%+%$&;'%-+%;$&<'%8+%#;&0<%$(*'%,-%*%0#)'%*'%**%0&$2+94%*'<%-+%(&,%*%'"%$'+0%$*%+#%*;'%'&0<%(%7*0%.#+0%*0%,-9#:%%!!T)!%DD)!W_^[[G%8#"+%-(94%+%-.%!"#:%+0'<%0+'<%*%*;'%'&0<%8#':%$#%*#0'%8!(#%+%-0'%*'>(*%,P%-(94%+%)*'%,-%*%**%0&$2+94%>1(*%"+:%%%%%

!eXC?!1<d9?;Jf!<BBCF9?!e;5!;A9!A9<@!5I!;A9!BCF9B!I5B!<!F9BJ!>CP!5B<6D9!;5!;A9!@57>D9!P<;9?!5I!;A9!,-%5I!;A9!MC:P!LAC6A!C?!5:!;A9!?C@9!5I!;A9!B5<@!5I!;A9!5II9BC:P?f!!'A9:!;A9!1<d9?;J!e5I!;A9!+5B@!5I!;A9!.:CF9B?9f!A<@!AC?!A9<@!C:6DC:9@!;5!;A9!9<?;!8<MC:P!<:!5B<6D9!e;5!;A9!L9?;9B:!@57>D9!P<;9!5I!;A9!,-!C:!;A9!A<DD!5I!**%0&$2+94O!=o(Q8!:5;!I<B9!IB58!AC8rG!LAC6A!C?!5:!;A9!><:M!5I!;A9!A9<@!5I!;A9!BCF9Bk!'A9!+<@J!5I!;A9!'L5!+<:@?!6<89!IB58!C:?C@9!;A9!?ED9:@5B?!5I!A9B!n-f!%eXC?!1<d9?;J!<BBCF9?!;5!;A9!F9:9B<>D9!6A<E9DfO!<:@!;A9!@57>D9!PB9<;!P<;9!5I!;A9!+<@J!5I!;A9!'L5!+<:@?!eI5B!;A9!9?;<>DC?A89:;f!5I!;A9!B5J<D!e9?65B;!;5!;A9!;98ED9!5I!%87:)!XC?!1<d9?;J!=;A9!P5@G!9:;9B?!C:;5!;A9!IB5:;!5I!;A9!,-%:<89@!**%0&$2+94%=o(Q8!:5;!I<B9!IB58!AC8rGO!A57?9!5I!%87:f!!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!U<FCDD9!WV_b^W_`VO!Y(2!VO!$D)!a)!!39;A9!W_"[2!t_V)!!+<6<7!^!*A9FBC9B!W_##^#_2!tWba^WbVO!Wa[^Wa#)!!! !

Page 228: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a`[!

T)()WW! 49CB!9D^T<A<BC![!

456789:;!;C;D9! *5B5:<;C5:!'9K;!6<BF9@!5:!;A9!1C@@D9!*5D5::<@9!<;!49CB!9D^T<A<BC!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 49CB!9D^T<A<BC)!X<;?A)!49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!:5B;A9B:!L<DD!5I!;A9!8C@@D9!65D5::<@9!5I!

;A9!;98ED9!5I!49CB!9D^T<A<BC)!(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!!DD)![^"G!.$%,*)%(%,7*0'<W)?%(%,-%(+D0'E%*%,-D'E%..9$*%*9#%-(94%!(%+9'%&)9'%.$9*9[$]%(%,7*0'<%%%D)!]G!(&&9'%'"2+.9'%(%,-%$+'%C&0%!"#0%!"#9'%#,-%#)('<%&)'%(%-C&09'%%%%D)!aG%),$9'%(%,-%7C+%-&'9'%(%#)('<%%%%DD)!V^W`G!.$9$*%-(9$%$*$9'0%*94%*#0'%!"#0%#,-0%#(+0%!*0'%*'%7*0%-&'<2,%+)'<0%+%$+'9#*%0.'%-+%.$'%-(%*%5&'%@+%"*%(%,7*0'<94%(%,-94%8(+D0':E%*%,-D'E%)"+%-(#'%*#0'%.#94%%D)!WWG%(%.&.0%*%$(<%W+'%$0%+('0%$"0%*%-+%7'09#*%(%#'"2#&%

!-CFC:P!DCI9!C:!;A9!C:;9BC5B!5I!;A9!,-I%D5F9@!>J!;A9%,-9%3<C@!>J!X9B!1<d9?;J!='A7;85?9!(G2!o6589O!J57!<B9!?AC:C:PO!(!;<M9!J57!C:!;A9!,7*0'<!!R57!?99!J57B!B7D9?!C:!;A9%,-I%J57B!C&0%8<@9!:5>D9O!B969CFC:P!J57B!@CP:C;JO!J57B!457>D9!6B5L:!?AC:C:P!C:!J57B!8<PC6!FCB;79!!R57!<EE9<B!C:!PD5BJ!=J57!<B9!9:;AB5:9@G!C:!;A9%,-%<:@!J57B!A9<@!C?!<@5B:9@!LC;A!;A9!457>D9!*B5L:%%!1J!1<d9?;J!A<?!8<@9!6589!;A9!B5J<D!:5>D9?O!;A9!@CP:C;<BC9?!<:@!;A9!658E<:C5:?O!;A9!9:;57B<P9!5I!;A9!7*0O!;A9!EBC:6CE<D!6AC9I?!;5!9K967;9!J57B!6588<:@O!C:!5B@9B!;5!PCF9!;A9!8<d9?;J!5I!X5B7?Q!@<7PA;9B!C:!AC?!,7*0'<!C:!AC?%,-I%>9D5F9@!C:!;A9%,-9%'A9B9!5667BB9@!<!?C;;C:P!5I!;A9!MC:P!C:!;A9!<7@C9:69!A<DD!5I!;A9!S9?;)!'A9?9!E95ED9!<B9!5:!;A9CB!>9DDC9?!C:!;A9%#'"2#&%!

U5;9?2!W!c5B!;A9!C:;9BEB9;<;C5:!5I!;A9!?CP:?^PB57E!<?!,7*0'<!?99!U<FCDD9!WV_a2!_#O!:5;9!:5)!])![!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2![bbO!W`^Wbk![baO!"O!_^W#k![b#O!W^[)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!!U<FCDD9!WV_b^W_`VO!(((2!b_^a`)!!3EC9P9D>9BP!WV_#2!_#O!ED)![)!!U<FCDD9!WV_a2!_W^W`b)!!! !

Page 229: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a`"!

!T)()W[! 49CB!9D^

T<A<BC!"!456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!l799:!X<;?A9E?7;!B9P<B@C:P!;A9!9KE9@C;C5:!;5%

M0*'!<;!49CB!9D^T<A<BC!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 49CB!9D^T<A<BC)!X<;?A)!49?6BCE;C5:! %^T)! Y<BC57?! C:?6BCE;C5:?! IB58! ;A9! 8C@@D9! ;9BB<69?! 5I! ;A9!

;98ED9!5I!49CB!9D^T<A<BC)!%)!T9D5L!;AC?! C:?6BCE;C5:!;A9B9!C?!<!B9EB9?9:;<;C5:! 5I! ?5D@C9B?! 8<B6AC:P)! T)! X<;?A9E?7;! C?!@9?6BC>9@!B969CFC:P!PCI;?!<I;9B!;A9!9KE9@C;C5:!?9:;!;5!M0*')!*)! (:?6BCE;C5:! IB58! ;A9! 1C@@D9! *5D5::<@9O! 357;A9B:! S<DD)!396;C5:!B9E5B;C:P!;A9!?E996A!5I!%87:!;5!;A9!\799:)!4^/)! (:?6BCE;C5:! 5I! ;A9! _;A! J9<B! 5I! l799:! X<;?A9E?7;!B9P<B@C:P!;A9!9KE9@C;C5:!;5%M0*'!<;!49CB!9D^T<A<BC)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!%)!#"+%0"0'2*#0'%+%H&2*'+%-*,%(!,%*'<%(2)'94%'"2(%0+0%*0%M0*'%#;%(%$)'%*;'%*4+'%(%#'"2#&%,*)%0.&%#*;%*%@0'2@+%*;'%M0*'%@+D2'"E%,*)%0.&%-('9#%!!!T)!-+%$(&%*%0"0'2*#0%-*,%(!,94%(%)'<02,*'<0%*0%M0*'%-+%S#0<%0&.20+%+%!#"%0+0%*0%)&#'%'*%$,;%*9#*%'%-*P'%$+"%$04%.P+%$)'%*;%$(%'&2(+$%($%0..'%(%#'"2#&%D,*)%0.&%#*;E%%%*)!!F#0'2;$'<%.#94%=&,'2C&2?,%#"+%-(%*%#'"2#&%,*)%0.&%#*;%+%+0.%*%*;%*'+0%#.(%0.%(%#'20+'%*.0'2+&%*'%*'+%.#94%.,+%0&0'%+%M0*'%%!!4)!D)!WG%+*"'%k%)"+%-(#'%(%.&.0%),$D'E%*#0'%(%#)('<%-+%#'%0+'%*'%.,(%7*0%.#+0%*0%,-94%#'&%#+0%#(+0%*0%#'"2#&%+%#.(%#!(%*%0.'%%%%%D)!W]G%#(*'9*94%M0*'%(%7*094%!/)!F#0'%!"#0%#+0%*0%#'"2#&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%$#'%0.%*'D0E%(%-(%*%#'"2#&%,*)%0.&%#*;%*%+"2,'%-&'<2,%*#0'%)'(0%#(+%0,'<%$(<2+%%

!%BBCF<D!>J!;A9!9:F5J!5I!;A9!MC:P!C:!;A9!-5@Ä?!+<:@!;5P9;A9B!LC;A!;A9!9KE9@C;C5:!LA5!L<?!<6658E<:JC:P!AC8!>9I5B9!;A9!EBC:69?!5I!M0*')!TBC:PC:P!5I!9F9BJ!P55@!;AC:P!IB58!;A9!#'"2#&!=D)!E)!A)G!;5!X<;A5BO!8C?;B9??!5I!M0*'O!I5B!;A9!DCI9O!EB5?E9BC;J!<:@!A9<D;A!5I!X9B!1<d9?;J!!$C;6AC:P!6<8E!5I!;A9!9:F5J!5I!;A9!MC:P!<:@!AC?!9KE9@C;C5:!5:!;A9!1JBBA^;9BB<69?!5I!M0*'!:9<B!;A9!?9<O!;5!B969CF9!;A9!EBC:69?!5I!;AC?!I5B9CP:!D<:@!<:@!9F9BJ;AC:P!IB58!/PJE;!<?!6588<:@9@!C:!;A9!#'"2#&%=D)!E)!A)�G!!!$9;C;C5:!5I!;A9!1<d9?;J!5I!;A9!#'"2#&I%D)!E)!A)!;5!;A9!?;<CB?!5I!;A9!+5B@!5I!;A9!P5@?!<:@!C:?;B76;C5:?!L9B9!A9<B@!IB58!;A9!-B9<;!'AB5:9O!<:!5B<6D9!IB58!;A9!P5@!AC8?9DI2!o9KED5B9!;A9!B57;9?!;5!M0*'!=))Gr!!(:!;A9!_;A!J9<B!;A9!l799:!L<?!C:!;A9!<7@C9:69!A<DDk!<EE9<B<:69!5I!;A9!MC:P!C:!;A9!@57>D9!6B5L:!5:!;A9!PB9<;!;AB5:9!5I!P5D@!C:!;A9!?<6B9@!7*0%5I!AC?!,-[%L<DM!5I%5IIC6C<D?!<:@!657B;C9B?!5I!;A9!#'"2#&%;5!A9<B!;A9!P7C@9!5I!;A9!6588<:@)!%3A9!8<@9!M0*'!9?;<>DC?A9@!C:!AC?!7*0%%!4CP:C;<BC9?!<:@!5IIC6C<D?!5I!;A9%#'"2#&I%D)!E)!A)"%*588<:@!5I!;A9!1<d9?;J!C:!;A9%#'"2#&I%D)!E)!A)!;5!;A9!X9B9@C;<BJ!EBC:69O!1<J5BO!?9<D9B!5I!;A9!

Page 230: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a`]!

!!! !

)'(0%F-#<%+%#;$D'E%(!&%8+:%M0*'% MC:PO!?5D9!658E<:C5:!<:@!;B9<?7B9B!F-#<%;5!?9:@!<B8J!;5!M0*'%!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!"["O!W#k!"[]O!Wk!"[bO!W#k!"][O!W`k!"]_O!WW^W[k!"b"O![k!"b]O!W]O!Wb)!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;9K;2!U<FCDD9!WV_b^W_`VO!(((2!WV^W_O!ED)!a_^#`O!ED)!#b^#aO!ED)!V"^V])!1<BC9;;9!WV##2!bO!W`)!U<FCDD9!W_`a2!W`"O!ED)!((()!396;C5:!c2!'B<:?DC;9B<;C5:!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:!?99!49!T76M!W_]V2!]V^b")!c5B!<!E7>DC?A9@!;B<:?C;C5:!5I!;A9!ICB?;!?96;C5:O!?99!!S9B>B576M!W_]_2!#a^#_)!!c5B!;A9!B98<C:C:P!?96;C5:?!?992!TB9<?;9@!W_`a2!W`[^W[[O!tt![]a^[_bO!<:@!C:!E<B;C67D<B!I5B!;A9!B9?E96;CF9!?96;C5:?!?992!t![b"O!t![bbO!tt![ba^[b#O!t![a`O!t![aWO!t![abO!t![aa)!

Page 231: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a`b!

T)()W"! N<B:<M!#!456789:;!;C;D9! ,>9DC?M!C:?6BCE;C5:!5I!l799:!X<;?A9E?7;!C:!;A9!;98ED9!5I!

%87:!<;!N<B:<M!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<M)!X<;?A)!49?6BCE;C5:! !(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!!D)!W]G%$*C%"0%#*.(9*9$%(%,-%#)&9*9$%0.&%P(&09$%%

!(;!L<?!89!LA5!9:d5J9@!8J?9DI!C:!;A9!,-I%(!L<?!B9898>9B9@!>J!8J!6B9<;9?!!!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!"a]O!Wa^W#)!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!+9E?C7?!W_#"O!(((2![]!@)!!! !

Page 232: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a`a!

T)()W]! N<B:<M!V!456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!%89:A5;9E!((!C:!IB5:;!5I!;A9!V;A!EJD5:!<;!N<B:<M!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<M)!%8)!(()!49?6BCE;C5:! 'A9!IB<P89:;?!5I!;A9!?;9D9!A<F9!>99:!I57:@!>J!1)!1<7BC69!

$CDD9;! C:!IB5:;!5I!;A9!V;A!EJD5:!5I!N<B:<M!'98ED9)!'A9J!L9B9!E<B;!5I!<!EC:M!PB<:C;9!?;9D9!B9?;5B9@!>J!39;J!()!!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!D5L9B!B9PC?;9B)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!!DD)![^"G!*'+%*4+%?,%($'<%'$'%.#+%*;%*'+0%*#<'%?,%(%,-%>1"'250'%%%D)!bG%0&.D'E%-(94%!"#0%#+0%*0%#'"2[#&]%%D)!aG%[#(+0]%,PD<0E%(%,-%%

!-55@! P5@! DCM9! &<O! ;A9! 5:9! LA5! C?! DCM9! ;A9!A5DJ!C8<P9!5I!<DD!;A9!P5@?O!;A9!MC:P?ACE!5I!&<!C:!;A9%,-%5I!N<B:<M!!*588<:@! C??79@! C:! XC?! 1<d9?;J! =<:@G! ;A9!:5>D9!657B;C9B?!5I!;A9!#'"2[#&]%*58E<:C5:?!C:;C8<;9?!5I!;A9%,-%

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!W"W_O!W#^_k!W"[`O!_^W`)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!+9I9>FB9!W_[]2!W"_^W]b%!!! !

Page 233: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a`#!

T)()Wb! -CZ<!W!

456789:;!;C;D9! 'A9!PB9<;!?EAC:K!?;9D9!5I!%89:A5;9E!((!<;!-CZ<!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! -CZ<)!%8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'A9!85:789:;!C?!<!B57:@^;5EE9@!DC89?;5:9!?;9D9!LC;A!<![#!

DC:9?!C:?6BCE;C5:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!D)!W_G!5.(9'0%(%"+2*#0'%*%$'94%C&%*)'%(%W&#'%*.(%$;%*%-(94%#.(94%#'%

!(I!5:9!DC?;9:?!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%;5!AC?!I<;A9B^?;B5:P^>7DD!5I!'A9>9?O!XC?!1<d9?;JQ?!A9<B;!L<?!PD<@!;5!A9<B!C;!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!W[VWO!Wb^Wa)!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!X<??<:!W_"#2!W[_!II)O!ED)!W) !

! !

Page 234: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a`V!

T)()Wa! *<CB5!W!

456789:;!;C;D9! 39MA89;!?;<;79!5I!%89:A5;9E!(((!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! *<CB5O!-9ZCB9A^-<B@9:)!%8)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'C;D9!B9I9BB9@!;5!;A9!P5@@9??!39MA89;)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%*;'%,-%%

!+<@J!5I!;A9!,-%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(YO!W#a]O!W_)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!+9C;Z![``[O!(Y2!"[)!!-<7;AC9B!W_[`2!W_[O!aV)!!39;A9!W_["2!]"!II)!!

! !

Page 235: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a`_!

!

T)()W#! 35D9>!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:?!I5B8!;A9!'98ED9!5I!35D9>!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 35D9>O!U7>C<)!%8)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)! (:?6BCE;C5:! 5:! ;A9! :5B;A! I<69! 5I! ;A9! :5B;A! ?C@9! 5I! ;A9!P<;9L<J!>9;L99:! ;A9!657B;!<:@! ;A9!57;9B!AJE5?;JD9!5I! ;A9!;98ED9O!W?;!B9PC?;9B!=D9I;!?C@9G)!T)! (:?6BCE;C5:! 5:! ;A9! :5B;A! I<69! 5I! ;A9! :5B;A! ?C@9! 5I! ;A9!P<;9L<J!>9;L99:! ;A9!657B;!<:@! ;A9!57;9B!AJE5?;JD9!5I! ;A9!;98ED9O!W?;!B9PC?;9B!=BCPA;!?C@9G)!*)! (:?6BCE;C5:! 5:! ;A9! :5B;A! I<69! 5I! ;A9! :5B;A! ?C@9! 5I! ;A9!P<;9L<J!>9;L99:! ;A9!657B;!<:@! ;A9!57;9B!AJE5?;JD9!5I! ;A9!;98ED9O!#;A!B9PC?;9B!=D9I;!?C@9G)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)!

-'"%(%,-%$$%-+%$+'%$++0'%*;%*%@;2D#.E%%T)!

-'"%(%,-%$*%*8#0:%)4'%$$'%-+%'*'&'%8(%7+0%Y%*:%@;2D#.E%%*)!

-'"%(%,-%$*%*#0%)4'%$$'%-+%'*'&'%(%87+0%AY:%*%@;2D#.E%%

!

&9?;C:P!C:!;A9!,-%LA9:!658C:P!;5!E9BI5B8!<DD!

;A9!BC;9?!5I!;A9%56.^I9?;CF<D!!

&9?;C:P!C:!;A9!,-!LA9:!658C:P!IB58!;A9!@<C?!

e5:!@<J!"f!5I!;A9!56.^I9?;CF<D!!

!

&9?;C:P!C:!;A9!,-!LA9:!658C:P!IB58!;A9!@<C?!

e5:!@<J!W"f!5I!;A9!56.^I9?;CF<D!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!-C5BPC:C!W__V)!!

! !

Page 236: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! aW`!

T)()WV! 1<DM<;<![!

456789:;!;C;D9! SC:9!d<B!?9<DC:P!:5)!]#!IB58!1<DM<;<!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 1<DM<;<)!%8)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%$(<2+%)'(0'%(%'&%-0'%*'%"+2,&%

!,F9B?99B! 5I! ;A9! ;B9<?7BC9?H9:6D5?7B9?! C:! ;A9!8<:?C5:!5I!;A9!"+2,&!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!W_b]O!W]^Wa)!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!X<J9?!W_bW2!ICP?)!aO!VO!W[O!W])!!+9<AJ!W_#V2![_^"W)!!

! !

Page 237: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! aWW!

T)()W_! %8<B:<!W!

456789:;!;C;D9! 'A9!9<BDC9B!EB56D<8<;C5:!5:!;A9!>57:@<BJ!3;9D9!!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %8<B:<)!%8)!(Y)!

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l799:)!T)!'A9!MC:P!<@@B9??9?!;A9!657B;)!!396;C5:! %! C?! B9E9<;9@! C:! 5:9! 5I! ;A9! ?;9D<9! 9! 6<BF9@! C:!?57;A9<?;9B:! ACDD?! 65:;<C:C:P! ;A9! ?965:@! 5B@C:<:69O! ;A9!3;9D9!%)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%Y((G%$+<2",'0'%,&0'%(%,-%*4+D0E%-+%,*'D0E%(%!0'<%%0Y(((G%8..':%-(94%$*$9*9$%#(+0%0+0%,-%$(<D0E2+%(*4<'%8$(<:02+%C&0'%#+0%*;%8P*;':%#'&0%$*$9'0%*94%-+2,%0*%$*9#*%-+%-0'9#*%(2;&-%-(94%-+9#*%D99E%%%%%D)!WaG%*%'&%*%>1'*%"&%*;0%(%&)'2>1'*%(%'&%#'%$+9$%"+2-,<%*%"&%>1'*%%%%D)!W#G%(%&)'2>1'*%$+9$%*9$%"+<'%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%$+9$%"+<'%*%'&%-('%*#0'%

!%:@!;A9!EBC:69??O!PB9<;!C:!;A9!,-O!I<CB!5I!I<69O!>9<7;CI7D!C:!;A9!@57>D9!ED789?!!'A9:!?<C@!XC?!1<d9?;JO!oTBC:P!89!;A9!MC:PQ?!658E<:C5:?!<:@!;A9!PB9<;!5:9?!5I!,-I%;A9!?7E9BFC?5B?!5I!;A9!P7<B@O!;A9!e5F9B?99Bf!5I!;A9!L5BM?O!;A9!5IIC6C<D?!<:@!<DD!;A9!e657B;f!C:!C;?!9:;CB9;J)!35!;A9J!L9B9!D9@!C:!;5!AC8!<;!5:69O!<:@!;A9J!D<J!5:!;A9CB!>9DDC9?!C:!AC?!E9B?5:Q?!EB9?9:69!=))G!!(:!;A9!(?D<:@!5I!%;9:O!LA5?9!d7>CD99?!<B9!@C?;C:P7C?A9@!<;!&)'2>1'*%C:!;AC?!ED<69!?A<DD!(!8<M9!;A9!X57?9!5I!&9d5C6C:P!I5B!;A9!%;9:O!8J!I<;A9B)!=%:@G!<;!&)'2>1'*%C:!;AC?!ED<69!?A<DD!(!8<M9!I5B!8J?9DI!;A9!"+<'%5I!$A<B<5AO!D)E)A)!=<:@G!(!?A<DD!8<M9!;A9!"+<'!5I!;A9!MC:PQ?!*AC9I!SCI9r))!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!17B:<:9!^!Y<:!3C6D9:!W__"2!a_^W`_O!ED?)![^W[O![[O!["%O!"WTO!"[)!!4<FC9?!W_`"^VO!b2![V^"WO!ED?)![_^"[O!"#^"V)!!.&N!(Y2!W_ab^V`!=#]_G)!!3<:@8<:!W_"V2!W`"^WWV)!!

Page 238: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! aW[!

TB9<?;9@!W_`a^#2![2!"_]^]``)!!'B<:?D<;C5:2!17B:<:9!W__b2!"#)!!X9D6M!W_aW2!"]]^]#)!!+C6A;A9C8!W_#"^W_V`O!(2!]V^b[)!!

! !

Page 239: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! aW"!

!

T)()[`! %8<B:<![!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;<;79;;9!5I!F4+2*4+02,1'*^F4+2'<'<!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %8<B:<)!%8)!(Y)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 3<:@?;5:9! ?;<;79;;9! 5I! U9I9B;C;C)! (:?6BCE;C5:! 5:! ;A9! ><6M^

?7EE5B;!C:!W!F9B;C6<D!65D78:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%@+2-2>1'*%.$%,*)%.'%*--%8*#0'%-(':%0+'%*;'%,-%,&'%(+'%(%"+2>1'*%*;'%'&0<%F4+2*4+02,1'*!!*4+2'<'<%8,*)%.'%*--:%

!X5B7?^%;9:!PCF9:!DCI9!I5B9F9B!65:;C:7<DDJO!<:@!;A9!=NC:PQ?G!*AC9I!SCI9O!;A9!D<@J!5I!;A9!,-O!PB9<;!5I!D5F9!C:!;A9!X57?9!5I!%;9:O!;A9!+<@J!5I!;A9!'L5!+<:@?O!F4+2*4+02,1'*^F4+2'<'<O!=8<J!?A9!DCF9!I5B9F9B!65:;C:7<DDJG!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!X'T1!V2![_O!ED)![a!=:5)!_"bG)!'B<:?D<;C5:2!17B:<:9!W__b2!][)!!

! !

Page 240: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! aW]!

T)()[W! %8<B:<!"!

456789:;!;C;D9! Y5;CF9!?A<>;C!5I!F4+2*4+02,1'*^F4+2'<'<!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %8<B:<)!%8)!(Y)!

49?6BCE;C5:! Y5;CF9!3A<>;C!5I!U9I9B;C;CO!<!6<D6C;9!ICP7BC:9O!@9E5?C;9@!C:!;A9!B5J<D!;58>O!B965:?;B76;9@!>J!;L5!IB<P89:;?!;A<;!L9B9!<6\7CB9@!>J!;A9!TB55MDJ:!17?978!=:5)!"")bWG!<:@!;A9!+57FB9!=%/!__`]G)!W!65D78:!C:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!IB5:;<D!E<B;!5I!;A9!ICP7B9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%$+<2",'%,&'%(%,-%-#<'%*%*#0'2;$'<%F4+2)"+2?,%W,2*2?,%#&%?,%&)'2>1'*%,&%(%,-,0%F4+2*4+02>1'*2F4+2'<'<%,*)%.'%*--%

!X9B9@C;<BJ!EBC:69??O!PB9<;!5:9!C:!;A9%,-O!I<F5B9@!5I!;A9!NC:P!5I!.EE9B!<:@!+5L9B!/PJE;!F4+2)"+2?,%W,2*2?,%?5:!5I!&<!&)'2>1'*I%D5:P!C:!AC?!DCI9;C892!;A9!MC:PQ?!6AC9I!LCI9!F4+2*4+02>1'*2F4+2'<'<I%8<J!?A9!DCF9!I5B9F9B!e65:;C:7<DDJf!=))G!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!+59>9:!W_Va)!!%D@B9@!W_VV2![[_^["`)!!'B<:D?<;C5:2!17B:<:9!W__b2!]a/)")!! !

Page 241: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! aWb!

T)()[[! 39?9>C!

456789:;!;C;D9! &9DC9I!LC;A!'C;D9?!5I!l799:!U9I9B;C;C!IB58!'98ED9!5I!39?9>C!C:!U7>C<!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %8<B:<)!%8)!(Y)!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!357;A9B:!*5D78:)!+9I;!?C@9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%DD)!W^[G%$+<2",'%0+'%-#0'%899*.(:%(+0'%-*0'%G(,0%H&2(-0%899(:%,-%P(&%('+%&)'%899:%*#0'%-('%0+'%(+0'94%8F4+2*4+02>1'*2*4+2'<'<:%,*)%.'%8*--:%

!X9B9@C;<BJ!EBC:69??O!PB9<;DJ!I<F5B9@O!?L99;!5I!D5F9O!D<@J!5I!.EE9B!<:@!+5L9B!/PJE;!=ÅC:!;A9G!,-O!LA5!>9<B?!LC;:9??!;5!;A9!A5BCZ5:!<:@!<?69:@?!=qG!;5!e))fO!;A9!PB9<;!NC:PQ?!*AC9I!LCI9O!AC?!>9D5F9@O!eF4+2*4+02>1'*2*4+2'<'<O!8<J!?A9!DCF9!e65:;C:7<DDJf)!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!TB9<?;9@!W_`V^_2!#`^#[O!ICP)!][)!!3<:@8<:!W_"V2!WbWO!*+Y(()!! !

Page 242: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! aWa!

T)()["! *-!]Wbab!

456789:;!;C;D9! 'A9!B9?;5B<;C5:!C:?6BCE;C5:!5I!'7;<:MA<87:!5:!;A9!?;9D9!9B96;9@!C:!;A9!;98ED9!<;!N<B:<M!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<M)!'7;)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'A9! B9@^PB<:C;9! ?;9D9!L<?! DJC:P! C:! ;A9! :5B;A^9<?;! 65B:9B! 5I!

;A9!PB9<;!XJE5?;JD9!X<DD!>9I5B9!;A9!"B@!$JD5:!5I! ;A9!;98ED9!

5I!N<B:<M)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!D)!WWG!$#'%-(94%(%,-94%!_(<D'E%(%"+2,&%,*)2)"+2C&2?,%($%?,%(%7*0%"'%%%%D)![[G%-(94%,*)%0.&%#*;%-(0%-(0'%!(><'%);&<'%0*%(!;&C0!(!"+2*#0'%$"9'0%;&C09#*%+%%899:!,-%*;%'&0<%%%!D)! [#G% 7+0% "*% $09'09$% (% ,-% *4+% $(<D'E% "+2,&%,*)2)"+2C&2?,%(&,%)+0!

!'A9:!XC?!1<d9?;J!C?!C:!AC?!,-O!9?;<;9!5I!,*)2)"+2C&2?,%='A7;85?9!(GO!DCM9!&<!C:!;A9!7*0%5I!;A9!?MJ!!XC?!1<d9?;JO!8<J!A9!DCF9!EB5?E9B!<:@!>9!C:!A9<D;AO!A<?!65:?96B<;9@!89:!<:@!L589:!?D<F9?O!?C:P9B?!<:@!@<:69B?!LA5!<B9!?9BF<:;!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%<:@!;A9CB!L<P9?!<B9!6A<BP9@!;5!;A9!e))f!,-%5I!;A9!+5B@!5I!;A9!'L5!+<:@?!!,:!;AC?!@<J!(!L<?!C:!;A9!P55@!,-O!LAC6A!C?!;A9!9?;<;9!5I!,*)2)"+2C&2?,%d7?;CIC9@!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!'9K;2!.&N!(YO![[2![`[VO!:5)!##[O!D)!#k![`"WO!D)!Wb)!+9PB<C:!W_`#<2!Wa[!II)k!I<?6)!"O])!!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!T9::9;;!W_"_)!!

! !

Page 243: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! aW#!

!

T)()[]! g/!aW]VW!

456789:;!;C;D9! -5D@9:!?ABC:9!5I!'7;<:MA<87:!IB58!AC?!;58>!<;!'A9>9?!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 'A9>9?)!'7;)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'C;D9!B9I9BB9@!;5!(?C?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%F;D'E%,-%(+0'%%

!'A9!>9D5F9@!8C?;B9??!=(?C?G!5I!;A9!,-%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;9K;2!+9C;Z![``[O!(Y2!"[)!!T9C:DC6A!h!3<D9A!W_V_2!][O!*%&'/&!W`V)!!

! !

Page 244: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! aWV!

!

T)()[b! E'7BC:!q!^

*5B5:<;C5:!

'9K;!5I!

X5B98A9>!

456789:;!;C;D9! *5B5:<;C5:!'9K;!5I!X5B98A9>!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N)!X5B98A9>)!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:! <;! ;A9! ><6M! 5I! ;A9! ?;<;79! 5I! X5B98A9>! <;! ;A9!

'7BC:!17?978)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!_G%$+9*9C%%$.*%'&0<%+%,-,0%+*"'%,!&%#($%%%D)!W`G%899:%.&.&'%(%C#$%+%+0'<%"+2*#0'%#"+9*94%0+0%".'%!G(,0%H&2(-0%,09#*%".%(%#0.94%#0&!9#*%*%%-+94%($%*'+%%%%%!D)!W"G!0.&%*%@+%(%-,,0%+%>1"'2#0'%*$0'%*;%*--%#&94%(%P*$94%+%>1"'2#'%+%;#%(2;&-%>1(*%+%#0.%*94%0"'94%*%*#0'%*%$+'%,-,094%$#'%%%%%D)!W]G%8),0%@+:%(%*;94%*4+%>1"'2+#'%(&&%$*94%-(%*%*'+%"*%@+%*;%*%@0'2*#0'%#&94%-*,94%(%;#2*#0'%+.$'9*94%0"'94%*#'94%$#'%+94%>1(*2?,%&;)%(%+!0%(&&9*94%%%%D)!WbG%7+0%+.$'%-'"094%,-,9*94%*#0'%!"#$%"*%+2",'%-+<2'"%'&0<%@+2(2*;%0.&9*94%+%"+2*#0'%+.$9*94%*#0'%7+%-&'94%+%M+2W+%*%#&'94%!"#'%W+'%D)!WaG%8@C&0%,094:%(%*<*<%-'"9*9#%*4+09#%#(*9*9#%#D<E%(%-&'94%+%M#.'%*;0%M+2F#+%(%$77<%),,094%F-;'%W.<'%F'2)0.%>1#'%F;'2-<'%@+%5'7%M#.'%'(%)*'%*%5'2W+'%%%%%

!U5L!A9!<6;9@!<?!FC69P9B9:;!5I!;A9!'L5!+<:@?!5F9B!<!E9BC5@!5I!8<:J!J9<B?!=<:@G!B9E5B;9@!!e))f!;A9!657:6CD5B?!@5C:P!5>9C?<:69!<;!;A9!P<;9?!5I!;A9!%"+2*#0'O!;A9!PB9<;!5:9?!5I!;A9!UC:9!T5L?!<EEB5<6AC:P!AC8O!357;A!<?!L9DD!<?!U5B;AO!;A9CB!<B8?!57;?;B9;6A9@!<;!AC?!9:657:;9BO!<:@!;A9J!E<C@!A5:5B!;5!AC?!I<69!<?!=;5G!<!P5@!!'A9!EB5699@!5I!X5B7?!B9d5C6C:P!;5!'A9>9?O!;A9!6C;J!5I!;A9!+5B@!5I!/;9B:C;JO!AC?!?5:!C:!AC?!98>B<69O!;5!>1"'2#'I%C:!5B@9B!;5!C:;B5@769!AC8!C:;5!;A9!EB9?9:69!5I!%87:!I5B!;A9!A<:@C:P!5F9B!;5!AC8!5I!AC?!5IIC69!5I!MC:P!5B!I5B!;A9!8<MC:P!5I!AC?!E9BC5@!=5I!DCI9G)!e'A9!<EE9<B<:69!C:!PD5BJ!5I!%87:f!C:!AC?!>9<7;CI7D!I9?;CF<D!C:!357;A9B:!,E9;)!'A9:!@C@!;A9!1<d9?;J!5I!;AC?!P5@!?99!X5B7?O!+5B@!5I!@0'2*#0'O!AC?!?5:!LC;A!AC8!C:!;A9!NC:PQ?!C:@76;C5:!C:!5B@9B!;5!PCF9!;5!AC8!AC?!5IIC69!<:@!AC?!;AB5:9)!%87:^&<!d5C:9@!C:!;A9!d7>CD<;C5:!LA9:!A9!A<@!?99:!!5:!;A9!@<J!5I!8<MC:P!AC?!?7>8C??C5:)!'A9B97E5:!A9!>9;55M!AC8?9DI!;5!AC?!:5>D9O!;A9!X9B9@C;<BJ!$BC:69O!*AC9I;<C:!5F9B!;A9!'L5!+<:@?O!X5B98A9>)!'A9:!A9!EB5699@9@!;5!;A9!"+2*#0'%=LA9:G!A9!A<@!ED<69@!AC8!>9I5B9!AC8?9DI!;5!;A9!M+2W+%5I!AC?!:5>D9!@<7PA;9B!;A9!-B9<;!=WaG!e5I!1<PC6O!A9B!<B8?f!C:!L9D658C:P!<;;C;7@9!<:@!?A9!98>B<69@!AC?!>9<7;J!<:@!9?;<>DC?A9@!A9B?9DI!5:!AC?!I5B9A9<@O!<:@!;A9!4CFC:9!/::9<@O!;A9!+5B@?!5I!;A9!M+2F#+O!L9B9!C:!9K7D;<;C5:!<;!AC?!

Page 245: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! aW_!

!

!

! !

%%%D)!W#G%-C*0%+%P&D$E%*%"'%-,0%*%-'"%>1(*%(2,%'*%$#$%>1(*%0$%#&94%7+%-&'94%+%,-%+%#(*%),094%-+<2'"94%+%#P&D$E%,-,094%($2P.94%!!!

PD5BC57?!<BC?C:PO!U9MA>9;O!W.<'O!U9C;AO!(?C?O!U9EA;AJ?O!X5B7?O!39;A!<:@!;A9!658ED9;9!/::9<@!;A<;!EB9?C@9?!5F9B!;A9!PB9<;!?9<;?O!!e<:@!;A9J!B<C?9@!qf!;A<:MI7D!6D<85B!;5!;A9!9CPA;!5I!;A9!A9<F9:O!B9d5C6C:P!<;!;A9!P55@!ED9<?7B9!5I!%87:)!T9A5D@O!%87:!C?!6589O!AC?!?5:!C:!IB5:;!5I!AC8O!;5!;A9!,-%C:!5B@9B!;5!9?;<>DC?A!AC?!6B5L:!7E5:!AC?!A9<@!<:@!C:!5B@9B!;5!EB5D5:P!AC?!E9BC5@!DCM9!;5!AC8?9DI)!!!!

U5;9?2! 'A9! ?9\79:69!5I! 9F9:;?! @C?6D5?9@! C:! ;A9! ;9K;! C?! ;A9! I5DD5LC:P2! ;A9! ICB?;! ?;9E! C?! ;A9!

B5J<D!C:@76;C5:!=;#2*#0'G!C:;5!;A9!;98ED9!5I!N<B:<MO!;A9!:9L!MC:P!>9C:P!<6658E<:C9@!>J!<!

6B5L@!5I!5IIC69B?!;5P9;A9B!LC;A!;A9!EBC:6CE<D!8<PC?;B<;9?!5I!;A9!D<:@!<:@!;A9!67D;^C8<P9!5I!

X5B7?!5I%@0'2*#0'O!<;;9:@9@!>J!AC?!EB5EA9;)! (:;5!;A9!EB9?9:69!5I!%87:O!;A9J!6<89!<8C@!

D57@! B9d5C6C:P! 5I! >5;A! E5E7D<69! <:@! EBC9?;A55@)! 'A9:! %87:! EB5699@?! ;5! ;A9! "+2*#0'!;5P9;A9B! LC;A! X5B98A9>! C:! IB5:;! 5I! ;A9! P5@O! 7:;CD! ;A9J! 6<89! ;5! ;A9! "+20+! 5I! %87:Q?!

@<7PA;9BO! ;A9! -B9<;^5I^1<PC6O! LA5O! A<FC:P! PB99;9@! ;A9! MC:PO! 9?;<>DC?A9@! A9B?9DI! 5:! AC?!

I5B9A9<@O!LACD9!;A9!F<BC57?!PB9<;!P5@?!5I!;A9!M+2*#+! C:@7DP9@!C:!8CPA;J!?A57;?!5I! d5J)!'A9!

EB5>D98!A9B9! C?! ;5!@9IC:9!;A9!I<6;7<D!89<:C:P!5I!;A9!"+2*#0')! (;! C?!A9B9!;A<;!%87:!ED<69?!

;A9!6B5L:!5:!X5BA989>Q?!A9<@O! ;A57PA! C:! ;A9! ?9:;9:69!LA9B9! ;AC?! C?!:<BB<;9@! =D)!#GO! ;A9!

?J:5:J857?!,-%C?!98ED5J9@)!'A<;!;A9!;L5!;9B8?!<B9!?J:5:J857?!C?!6D9<B!IB58!;A9!I<6;!;A<;!

C;!L<?! IB58!;A9!"+2*#0'! ;A<;!%87:! C??79@! I5B;A! =DD)!W_^[`G!LA9:! ;A9! B9DCPC57?!69B985:C9?!

L9B9!<;!<:!9:@)!U5L!C;!C?!6D9<B!;A<;!<!;98ED9O!:5;!;A9!@L9DDC:P^ED<69!5I!<:!9<B;ADJ!MC:P!L<?!

;A9! ?69:9! 5I! ;A9! <6;7<D! 65B5:<;C5:)! %665B@C:P! ;5!-<B@C:9B! C;!87?;! >9! C@9:;CIC9@!LC;A! ;A9!

+7K5B!'98ED9!>96<7?9!;A9!E7BE5?9!5I!;A9!I9?;CF<D!L<?!;5!65:@76;!;A9!C8<P9!5I!%87:^&<!;5!

AC?! ?57;A9B:^X<BC8)! (I! ?5O! L9! 87?;! ;AC:M! ;A<;! X5B98A9>! A<@! E<B;C6CE<;9@! C:! ;A9! PB9<;!

?57;AL<B@! EB569??C5:! IB58! N<B:<M! ;5! +7K5BO! LA9B9O! C:! ;A9! I5DD5LC:P! @<J?O! ?E96CIC6!

65B5:<;C5:!69B985:C9?!LCDD!A<F9!E9BI5B89@)!'L5!5;A9B!;98ED9?!<B9!89:;C5:9@!C:!;A9!;9K;2!

;A9! "+20+! <:@! ;A9! "+2*#+! ;A<;! 657D@! >9! C@9:;CIC9@! LC;A! ;A9! F9BJ! <:6C9:;! ?<:6;7<BC9?! 5I!XC9B<65:E5DC?!C:!.EE9B!/PJE;!<:@!T7;5!C:!49D;<!B9?E96;CF9DJ)!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!W_b"2!W"!II)!

Page 246: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a[`!

T)()[a! 47ED)!*-!

"]Wa[!

456789:;!;C;D9! X5B98A9>Q?!@96B99!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<M)!X5B98A9>)!

49?6BCE;C5:! X5B98A9>Q?!@96B99!<;!N<B:<M)!47EDC6<;9!5I!;A9!C:?6BCE;C5:!C:!

*<CB5!17?978!*-!"]Wa[)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!(O!tWO!W"G%$+%$+<%*94%"&%*(-<%0,%*%,->0%7+%'&<94%'*4<'%+%+)%!(#%"+2,&%,*)%80.&%#*;:%D99E%#.(%,!%8*%,'%-*C'%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;:%%%%(O!tWO!WbG%$+%,-,80:%*;%*'<%-'+%+%*&%*%W,;0'%#0'%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%(O!t[O!W#G%0**94%-+%!(8#%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;:%%(O!t[O!W#O!W_G%#.(%8,!:%*;%*%,'%8-*C'%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;:%%%(O!t[O![`G%$+$94%8!(#%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;:%%(O!t"O![WG%0**%*&%*%#.(%8,!:%*%,'%-*C'%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%D99E%#.(%,!%%8*%,'%-*C'%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;:%%%%(O!t"O![[E%8)+%+%#.(%,!%*;%*%,'%-*C'%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;:%%%(O!t]O![bG!0**%"&%$(<2+%$-0!*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%(O!t]O![aG!0**%"&%$(<2+%$-0!*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%-+%!('%+%$+'%$+0%(%'&%+2.+94%%%%(O!tbO![#^[VG%0**%*&%*%8+0.0:%*%"+2*#0'%%%(O!tbO![_G!$($%'0%"&%*C'%*%'&%0.<'%0#4D0E%)+%(C%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%-+%$+'%'&%0.<'%*%-;%

!'A9!EBCF<;9!E9B?5:?!>7CD@!I5B!AC8!<!>5<;!5:!AC?!;9:;!;5!>9!<>D9!;5!?9BF9!;A9!"+2,&O!D)!eE)!A)f!=))G!?9BFC:P!=A9<BC:P!;A9!6<DDC:PG!eC:!;A9!?;5B9A57?9!5I!;A9!5II9BC:P?!5I!;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)f!!!%?!I5B!<:J!>5<;!;A<;!C?!E7;!;5!L5BM!I5B!;A9!>9:9IC;!5I!W,;0'!5I!;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)%!X9!C?!5:!;5!<6658E<:J!e;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)f!!,:9!LA5!?9BF9?!=A9<B?!e;A9!6<DDC:PfG!9F9BJ;AC:P!C:!;A9!?;5B9A57?9!e5I!;A9!5II9BC:P?!5I!;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)f!!X9!8<M9?!e;5!<6658E<:J!;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)f!!T9C:P!5:9!LA5!?9BF9?!=A9<B?!e;A9!6<DDC:PfG!I5B!;A9!?;5B9A57?9!5I!;A9%5II9BC:P?!<;!;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)!=))G!5:9!LA5!?9BF9?!=A9<B?!;A9!6<DDC:PG!e;A9!?;5B9A57?9!5I!;A9%5II9BC:P?!5I!;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)f!!,:9!LA5!?9BF9?!=A9<B?!;A9!6<DDC:PG!e;A9!?;5B9A57?9!5I!;A9%5II9BC:P?!5I!;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)f!!'A9!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!A9B@?!5I!;A9!"+2,&I%!D)!E)!A)%%%'A9!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!A9B@?!5I!;A9!"+2,&I!D)!E)!A)O!<BBCF9!;5!8<M9!;A9!C:?E96;C5:!C:!;A9!LA5D9!D<:@!!'A9!e<P9:;?f!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'!!'A9B9I5B9!PCF9!;A9!65:;BC>7;C5:!;5!;A9!9KE9@C;C5:O!:5;!E<C@O!;5!P7<B@!;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!

Page 247: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a[W!

>1"&'%'*0%+*"'%$0%*D*E%0#4%'09'0%-+%S+S%+%-&'%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%%%(O!taO!"WG%(2($''%*&%*%'&%#(0%*%*&%*%W,;0'%#0'%8"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;:%%(O!taO!"[G%$090%+%"&%;&C%*!8"+2,&:%,*)%0.&%#*;%%%(O!taO!""G!8$++<%*&%*%'&%#(0%*%*&%*!W,;0'%#0'%"+2,&%!(':%+%'&%#(0%8+%"&:%;&C%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%(%*&%*%,0'%*%)'%-*,%*&%*%'#'DNE%*%*&%*%"+<'%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%899:*%"+2,&%*'<%7+%#(0%%%((O!"G%+)*9*9$%P;94%+%&094%#&-9*9$%.+2,%(%7*094%D99E%*4+0%;$'%+)0%0.,%$(<D0E27'!#.(<D0E%(.'%"+2*#0'%7"0%*0%,+<'%%%%((O!]G%.$9*9$%'"2+.%(%-+9#*%7"0%(%7+0<'9#*%$(<%8,-:%%((O!aG%)+%$+%-&'<2,%*;%-(%*'+%*;%*'<%$0'0%+%#.(%+%..%#0%-(#0%+%$+'%0"D'E%(%7*0%'&%P*;'%+.<'%+%0"D'E%%m%((O!#G%$*%-(02*'+%*0%+&02"+%-&'<02,%*0%7*0%*%D'&E%"*%-*,%%(((O!_G%#.4&0%(%)'%"+2*#0'%$0%#0'%0**9#*%-+%!.%.$0%-+%!*0'<%

A)O%;5!8<M9!;A9!d57B:9J!5I!;A9!,E9;!I9?;CF<DO!9F9BJ!J9<B?O!LC;A57;!AC?!8C??C:PO!;5!EB9E<B9!C:!<:;C6CE<;C5:!5I!;A9!<BBCF<D!5I!;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)!!'A5?9!LA5!65DD96;!;A9!I5@@9B!I5B!;A9!W,;0'%5I!;A9!e"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)f!%(;!=;A9!I5@@9BG!LCDD!>9!I5B!;A9!;<K!5I!;A9!e"+2,&fI%D)!E)!A)!!'A5?9!LA5!EB5@769!;A9!I5@@9B!I5B!;A9!W,;0'!5I!;A9!"+2>&%SU!;5!65DD96;!;A9!I5@@9B!eI5B!;A9f!;<K!5I!;A9%"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)O!C:!;A9!A9B@!;5P9;A9B!LC;A!I5@@9B!5I!;A9!<B9<?!5I!;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)!e))f!C:!;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)O%LA5!<B9!<??CP:9@!;5!;A9!I5@@9B!!!(!M:5L!AC?!C:;9BC5B!9:;CB9DJ!=>96<7?9G!(!B9<6A!;A9!@99E!5I!AC?!7*0!=))G!LC;A!<!65BB96;!;98E9BO!<>D9!;5!I<;A58!;A9!;A57PA;?O!5>9@C9:;!;5!;A9!C:d7:6;C5:?!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'%%<:@!;A9!D<L?!5I!;A9!657B;!!(!P<F9!5B@9B?!;5!;A98!<:@!D<L?!C:!;A9CB!@<J?!C:!;A9!8,-:!!/F9BJ!8<d5BO!9F9BJ!EB5EA9;!LA5!C?!;5!A9<B!LA<;!A<?!>99:!?<C@O!A9!C?!?9;!;5!B9:@9B!d7?;C69!C:!;A9!7*0%5I!8<PC?;B<;9?!8<@9!;5!d7@P9!!'A9?9!<B9!;A9!EB5EA9;?!5I!;A9!?<:6;7<BC9?O!;A9!8<d5B?!5I!;A9!7*0!5I!;AC?!D<:@!!%8ED9!?7EEDC9?!5I!;AC:P?!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'I%LACD9!;A9J!B969CF9!-+%!.%B<;C5:?!<;!;A9!;L5!PB<:<BC9?!!!

U5;9?2!'B<:?DC;9B<;C5:!IB582!NB76A;9:!W_VW)!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2![W]]O!W`^WWk![W]bO!#!<:@!W`k![W]aO!bO!W"O!Wa!<:@!W_k![W]#O!W`k![W]VO!Vk![W]_OW!<:@!Wak![Wb`O!W[^Wbk![WbWO!W]!<:@!WVk![Wb[O!]^W`k![WbbO!W[^W]!<:@!WVk![Wb#O!W^[!<:@!W`k![WbVO!Wak![W]`^[Wa[)!!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!NB76A;9:!W_VW)!!

! !

Page 248: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a[[!

!

T)()[#! N<B:<M!V!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:?!IB58!;A9!;98ED9!5I!$;<AO!N<B:<M!A<DD!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<M)!X5B98A9>!=qGW)!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!357;A!L<DD!5667EC9@!>J!<!B9DC9I!LC;A!$;<AO!

NA5:?7O!17;!<:@!X<;A5B)!'C;D9!B9I9BB9@!;5!;A9!P5@@9??!17;)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%%@G!@*0'%(+0'%(%,-%*%*;%*'+0%%%

!T9D5F9@!8C?;B9??!C:!;A9!,-%5I!<DD!;A9!P5@?!

U5;9?2!W+9PB<C:!W_`[2!__)!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;9K;2!+9PB<C:!W_`[2!__)!*5889:;<BJ2!+9C;Z![``[O!Y2![]V)!

!

! !

Page 249: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a["!

T)()[V! N<B:<M!W`!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!X5B98A9>!IB58!;A9!];A!$JD5:!5I!N<B:<M!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! '98ED9!5I!$;<AO!N<B:<M)!X5B98A9>)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'A9! ?;9D9! B9EB9?9:;?! X5B98A9>! 5II9BC:P! ID5L9B?! ;5! ;A9!

'A9><:! 'BC<@9)! (:?6BCE;C5:! :9<B! ;A9! B9EB9?9:;<;C5:! 5I! ;A9!

P5@@9??!17;!LC;A!<!DC5:^A9<@)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%W+'2@C&0%*;'%,-%%%

!W+'2@C&0%8C?;B9??!5I!;A9!,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!.&N!(Y2![W"[O!Wb)!X<BC!W_#a>2!W`"O!$D)!W])!!+9PB<C:!W_`[2!WWW)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!TB9<?;9@![``WO!(((2!W]O!:5;9!6)!!*5889:;<BJ2!+9C;Z![``[O!(((2!(Y2!"[)!!!

! !

Page 250: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a[]!

!

T)()[_! *-!W")W)[W)W]!

456789:;!;C;D9! cB<P89:;!5I!<!?;9D9!5I!X5B98A9>!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!X5B98A9>)!

49?6BCE;C5:! cB<P89:;!5I!<!?;9D9!B9EB9?9:;C:P!MC:P!X5B98A9>!5II9BC:P!C:!

IB5:;!5I!$;<A)!'C;D9!EB5><>DJ!B9I9BB9@!;5!;A9!MC:P)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%%D)!WG!D*#0'%;$'<%E%899:%*;%(%,-%*%>1"'2#0'%

!=NC:P!5I!.EE9B!<:@!+5L9B!/PJE;G!e))f!+5B@!5I!;A9!,-%5I!'A9>9?!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;9K;2!.&N!(Y2![W""O!W])!! !

Page 251: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a[b!

!

T)()"`!

!

198EAC?!W!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:?!IB58!;A9!;98ED9!5I!$;<A!<;!198EAC?!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 198EAC?)!X5B98A9>)!

49?6BCE;C5:! l7<B;ZC;9!?;9D9!IB58!;A9!;98ED9!5I!$;<A!<;!198EAC?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!bG%$09'$%*94%+%"+2*#0'%+.$9*94%*#0'%7+%-&'<2,94%+%"+20+%#&94%!"#%W+'2[@C&0']%%%D)!aG%>1(*%(2,%*'%$#$%>1(*%$0%#094%7+%-&'94%+%,-%+%#(*'%),094%-+%'"94%+%#P&$94%,-,094%%%

!1<J!A9!6589!;5!;A9!"+2*#0')!X9!ED<69@!AC8!<;!;A9!A9<@!5I!C;O!5F9B!;A9!PB9<;!A57?9!5I!AC?!:5>D9O!9D@9?;!@<7PA;9B!W+'2[@C&0']9%%87:O!>9A5D@!%87:!6589?O!LC;A!AC?!?5:!C:!IB5:;!5I!AC8O!;5!;A9!,-I%;5!9?;<>DC?A!;A9!6B5L:?!5F9B!AC?!A9<@O!<:@!8<MC:P!D5:P!;A9!E9BC5@!5I!AC?!DCI9!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;9K;2!.&N!(Y2![W[WO!WV^[`k![W["O!#^W`)!!4<B9??J!W_`[2![#^V)!!$9;BC9!W_`_O!(2!ED)!a)!!

! !

Page 252: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a[a!

T)()"W! E*-!bV`"V!

456789:;!;C;D9! $<EJB7?!T57D<\!W#!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 'A9>9?)!WV;A!4J:<?;J!=%8)!((G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! $<EJB7?!65:;<C:C:P!<!XJ8:!;5!%87:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!(((O!W"G!$(<%,-%

!,:9!LA5!C?!C:!;A9!,-%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;9K;2!+9C;Z![``[O!(2![[_)!!1<BC9;;9!WV#W^#aO!((2!aO!ED)!WW^W")!!+7C?9DDC![``])!!

! !

Page 253: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a[#!

T)()"[! %>J@5?!W!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:?!IB58!;A9!,?CBC?!37C;9!5I!;A9!;98ED9!5I!39;J!(!<;!%>J@5?!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?O!-B9<;!'98ED9O!;A9!,?CBC?!37C;9)!39;J!()!!

49?6BCE;C5:! %) %)! (:?6BCE;C5:! C:! ;A9! <669??^@55BL<J! 5I! ;A9! ,?CBC?!

37C;9)!(::9B!;AC6M:9??)!357;A!3C@9)!!

T) (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!(::9B!,?CBC?!X<DD)!!

*) (:?6BCE;C5:?! IB58! ;A9! 3965:@! X<DD! 5I! ,?CBC?)!

49@C6<;5BJ!;9K;)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)!Wa"2]G!$+9*94%(%(**094%*%$'94%W**4+%-+<2$;%=*2(,&D'E2?,%-0'%$+'%*94%,-%$+%*94%#&%?,%=+$%*2M'-%($%?,%%%Wa"2aG%$+9*94%(%(**094%*%$'94%W#$+%-+<2$;%=*2(&,D'E2?,%-0'%$+'%*94%"+2,&%$+'%*94%#&%?,=+$%*2M'-%.$%,*)%%!T)!!*5D78:!"O!Wab2aG%$+'%*94%,-%(%C&'%(*)%*--D'E%$+94%.$%,*)%($%?,%.'%%%*5D78:!bO!WabOW[G%$+'%*94%,-%!"#$%+%#;&%.0&'%*'+0%$+94%.$%,*)%($%?,%.'%%%*5D78:!VO!WabO!aG!$+'%*94%"+2,&%!"#$%-+%#'%,)'%*%..'%D99E$+'%*94%,-%0,;%(&D0E%(%$*+%-.%*4+%%%Wa#2#G!D99E%=&,D'E2?,%#.#+%,-%#,&%#!(%*'4%W#$+%8N:%#0%(%$+'%7+'94%D99E%%%*)!WaV2W`G!*4+0%-0'94%!"#$%,-%*'%*'+0%$+9C%*;%-+%#7+'%-&'<0%*'40%*'+0%%!!Wa_2W^[G%$+9*94%(**094%*%$'94%W#$+%-+<2$;%=*2=,&D'E2?,%-0'%$+'%*94%,-%0+%(#'%$+'%&)0%$+94%.$%,*)%($%?,%.'%%

!X9!A<?!8<@9!<?!AC?!85:789:;!I5B!AC?!I<;A9B!W**4+O!B9?C@C:P!<;!;A9!'98ED9!5I!=*2(,&D'E2?,O!;A9!8<MC:P!I5B!AC8!5I!<!,-%8<@9!I5B!AC8!>J!;A9!?5:!5I!&<O!39;J!(O!DCM9!&<!!X9!A<?!8<@9!<?!AC?!85:789:;!I5B!AC?!I<;A9B!,?CBC?O!B9?C@C:P!<;!;A9!'98ED9!5I!=*2(,&D'E2?,O!;A9!8<MC:P!I5B!AC8!5I!<!"+2,&%8<@9!I5B!AC8!>J!;A9!?5:!5I!&<O!39;J!(!19B9:E;<AO!PCF9:!DCI9!!!'A9!8<MC:P!I5B!AC8!5I!<!,-O!5I!9;9B:<DDJ!?ED9:@C@!L5BMO!;A<;!A9!8<J!<;;<C:!oPCF9:!DCI9r!DCM9!&<!I5B9F9B!!'A9!8<MC:P!I5B!AC8!5I!<:!<7P7?;!,-%<;!;A9!E5B;<D!5I!;A9!U9;A9BL5BD@!5I!;A9!P5@?O!;A<;!A9!8<J!<;;<C:!oPCF9:!DCI9r!DCM9!&<!I5B9F9B!!'A9!8<MC:P!I5B!AC8!5I!<:!<7P7?;!"+2,&I%C:!<!ED<69!PD5BC57?!I5B9F9B!=))G!;A9!8<MC:P!I5B!AC8!5I!<!,-%<!:9L!5I!>9<7;CI7D!LAC;9!DC89?;5:9!!=))G=&,'2?,O!LA5!65:?96B<;9?!;A9!,-!<:@!8<M9?!PB9<;!;A9!C8<P9!5I!,?CBC?O!e?<;C?IJC:Pqf!AC8!@5C:P!AC?!ED9<?7B9!=))G!!!X5L!>9<7;CI7D!C?!J57B!<7P7?;!;98ED9O!<!,-!I5B!;A9!*5:6D<F9?!5I!-5@?O!J57!A<F9!@5:9!9F9BJ;AC:P!;5!ED9<?9!;A9!A9<B;?!5I!J57B!I<;A9B!P5@?!!X9!A<?!8<@9!<?!AC?!85:789:;!I5B!AC?!I<;A9B!,?CBC?O!B9?C@C:P!C:!;A9!;98ED9!5I!=*2=,&D'E2?,O!;A9!8<MC:P!I5B!AC8!5I!<!8CPA;J!,-!I5B!E9BI5B8C:P!>9:9I<6;C5:?O!;A<;!A9!8CPA;!

Page 254: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a[V!

%!Wa_2#G%$+'%*94%,-%!"#$%+%#;&%.0&'%*'+0%$+94%.$%,*)%($%?,%.'%%%Wa_2W`G!$+'%*894:%,-%!"#$%(%#*'%&)'%*'%"'%$+94%.$%,*)%.'!

<;;<C:!PCF9:!DCI9!DCM9!&<!I5B9F9B!!'A9!8<MC:P!I5B!AC8!5I!<:!<7P7?;!,-%<;!;A9!E5B;<D!5I!;A9!@9:CZ9:?!5I!;A9!U9;A9BL5BD@O!;A<;!A9!8<J!<;;<C:!oPCF9:!DCI9r!DCM9!&<!I5B9F9B!!'A9!8<MC:P!I5B!AC8!5I!<:!<7P7?;!,-%B9?98>DC:P!;A9!A5BCZ5:!5I!A9<F9:O!;A<;!A9!8CPA;!<;;<C:!PCF9:!DCI9!I5B9F9B!!

U5;9?2!!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!(2!Wa[^Wa_)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!*<DF9BD9J!W_""^W_b_k!ED)!WV)!!!

! !

Page 255: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a[_!

T)()""! %>J@5?![!456789:;!;C;D9! 'A9!%>J@5?!@96B99!5I!39;J!(!<;!U<7BC!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! U<7BC!=U7>C<G)!39;J!(O!R)!])!49?6BCE;C5:! &56M!67;!C:?6BCE;C5:!B9D<;C:P!;5!;A9!MC:PQ?!;98ED9!<;!%>J@5?)!

%) 39;J!(Q?!<EEB5F<D!>J!;A9!P5@?)!

T) NC:PQ?!EC9;J!;5!,?CBC?!<;!%>J@5?!<:@!AC?!F<?;!

I57:@<;C5:?!;A9B9)!

*) 'A9!496B99)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!%D)!bG%.(.%*'+0%+%)094%+%#-'"%$;%*#0'2;$'<%0**%*4+%;#9#*%*#0'%(%,-%!"#$%%%%D)!VG%,-%$(9#%#7C%'0+$%(%*;0%(&,%*%'"%#('%%%%%D)![_G%..'%0&.D'E%&0<9'0%(%-(%*%#'"2#&%,*)%0.&%#*;%(%7+0%"*%'&'<%#+0%#(+0%P*;'%#.(<0%#&2*#0'%*%O!%-+<0%".'%$(<2+%*;0%-&'<2,0%'#0%0-<'%G(,0%H&2(-0%C&%.*;0%-+<%$-0%#+<'%+0.%*;%*%"+2*#0'%+('%*;0%7&;0%(%0"'%+%O!%0&.D'E%..%$0%0.9*9-(94%+.$'%-*9'0%'&%-0'%*'%--%(%+*"'%*#0'2;$'<%=*2(&,'2?,%7+02$;%(%&;.0%-+%*0%-+%'&%)'%#"&'%G(,0%H&2(-0%%%%%%%%%DD)!"]^"aG%+%'(%(%+.$'%'79'0%+%&-'%*;%*%'&%-0'%=*2(&,'2?,%7+02$;%(%&;.0%(%#)'%[99]%*(''9#*%$[(]%#&2*#0'%*;%-+<%".'%*;%+0.0%*;%*%"+%+0.%*%"+2*#0'%[+(]'%7&;%(%0"'%+%O!%+%'(%(%+.$'%'79'0%C&0%,&0%$0%#,-0%,*)0%'"%*#0'2;$'<%'&%&;.0%[*;]%['&%-0'%*']%--%(%+*"'%*#0'2;$'<%'&%-0'%=*2(&,'2?,%7+02$;%(%&;.0%(%-0,%+%"0%(%#)+0%(%#'*%$[(]%#&2*#0'%*;%-+<%".'%*;%-&'<2,%*;%C&%.*[;%-+<%$]-0%*;%-+<%F-#<%+0.%*%"+2*#0'%[+(']%7&;%$"'%+%O!%

!'A9!P5@?!A<F9!7:C;9@!;5!EB5;96;!AC8!<:@!;5!E<6CIJ!;A9!A9<B;A!5I!;A9!MC:P!5I!.EE9B!<:@!+5L9B!/PJE;O!;A9J!A<F9!65:@76;9@!AC8!C:;5!;A9!:5>D9!,-!!'A9!,-!LC;AC:!C;!C?!876A!98>9DDC?A9@!LC;A!IC:9!P5D@!;B79!<:@!IB9?A!IB58!;A9!@9?9B;!!!496B99!C??79@!C:!;A9!8<d9?;J!5I!;A9!#'"2#&O!D)!E)!A)!5:!;AC?!@<J!;5!=;A9G!FCZC9BO!=;A9G!8<PC?;B<;9?O!;A9!657B;C9B?O!;A9!657B;?!5I!d7@P9?O!;A9!NC:PQ?!?5:!5I!N7?AO!;A9!;B55E!6588<:@9B?O!;A9!5F9B?99B!5I!P5D@O!;A9!8<J5B?!<:@!;A9!65:;B5DD9B?!5I!6<8E?!5I!.EE9B!<:@!+5L9B!/PJE;O!;A9!6A<BC5;99B?O!;A9!?;<>D9^8<?;9B?!<:@!?;<:@<B@^>9<B9B?O!9F9BJ!<P9:;!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'O!<:@!9F9BJ5:9!?9:;!5:!<!8C??C5:!;5!N7?A)!'A9!496B99!?;<;9?2!XC?!1<d9?;J!6588<:@9@!;A<;!B9P7D<;C5:!>9!8<@9!I5B!;A9!'98ED9!5I!1CDDC5:!R9<B?!=5IG!;A9!NC:P!5I!.EE9B!<:@!+5L9B!/PJE;!=*2(&,'2?,9%o'A9!A9<B;!C?!A<EEJ!C:!%>J@5?r!>9!EB5;96;9@!5:!L<;9B!<:@!5:!D<:@!;AB57PA57;!;A9!:589?!5I!.EE9B!<:@!+5L9B!/PJE;!!;5!EB9F9:;!<:J!C:;9BI9B9:69!LC;A!<:J!D<:@!>9D5:PC:P!;5!;A9!X57?9!5I!=*2(&,'2?,9%n'A9!A9<B;!C?!A<EEJ!C:!%>J@5?r!C:!;A9!657:;BJ!E<B;?!))[C:]!;A9CB![d57B:9J?]!>J!<:J!YC69B5JO!<:J!6AC9I!5I!I5B9CP:!65:;C:P9:;?O!<:J!C:?E96;5B!>9D5:PC:P!;5!;A9!A57?9!5I!C:?E96;C5:!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'!<:@!<:J!E9B?5:!?9:;!;5!8C??C5:!;5!N7?AO!C:!5B@9B!;5!EB9F9:;!6<;;D9O!<??9?O!LC:9O!P5<;?O!5B!5;A9B!<:C8<D?!>9D5:PC:P!;5!;A9!X57?9!9;6)!>9C:P!;<M9:!>J!B5>>9BJ!=8!-0,E%U+%;<%03<%U4%J_;6+'<%D(%#)+0%*%0#'*E%>J!<:J!FC69B5JO!<:J!6AC9I!5I!I5B9CP:!65:;C:P9:;O!<:J!8<J5BO!<:J!\79BJO!<:J!6AC9I!

Page 256: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a"`!

5I!;A9!?;<>D9O!<:J!6AC9I!5I!U7>C<:?O!<:J!C:?E96;5B?!>9D5:PC:P!;5!;A9!"+2*#0'!<:@!5B!<:J!E9B?5:!?9:;!C:!8C??C5:!;5!N7?A!!

U5;9?2!!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!N&(!(2!]aO!W]k!]#O!#k!b`O!W[!^!bWO![)!

-BCIIC;A!W_[#2!W"_^[`V)!

/@P9B;5:!W_]#2![W_^"`)!!

-<B@C:9B!W_b[2![]^"")!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !

Page 257: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a"W!

!T)()"]! %>J@5?!"!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:?!IB58!;A9!-<DD9BJ!5I!;A9!NC:P?!5I!;A9!;98ED9!5I!

39;J!(!<;!%>J@5?!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?O!-B9<;!'98ED9O!-<DD9BJ!5I!;A9!NC:P)!39;J!()!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!-<DD9BJ!5I!NC:P?!LC;A!DC?;!5I!?<:6;7<BC9?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

]`%G!@+%(%)+"%"+%,-%%

!

X5B7?!C:!)+"%"+%,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

'9K;2!N&(!(2!WV[OV)!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!$1!Y(2![b!=[[]^[[bG)!!

1<BC9;;9!WVa_^V`2!ED)!]b)!!

4j8C6A9:!WVVbO!((2!ED?)!b[^b])!!

!

! !

Page 258: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a"[!

T)()"b! l7B:<!W!

456789:;!;C;D9! '98ED9!5I!39;J!(!<;!l7B:<!!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! l7B:<)!39;J!()!!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:?! IB58! ;A9! XJE5?;JD9! ?C@9^&558! b)! 49@C6<;5BJ!;9K;!IB58!;A9!U5B;AO!357;A!<:@!/<?;!L<DD?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!DD)!Wb^WaG!$+'%*9#*%,-%!"#$%(%-0'%D#E)(%*'+0%0**%#*%-'"%(%$*;%!

!'A9!8<MC:P!I5B!;A98!=P5@?!<:@!P5@@9??9?G!5I!<:!<7P7?;!,-%<?!<!;98ED9!<:@!=<B6AC;96;7B<DG!C8<P9!I5B!;A9!P5@?!LA9:!;A9J!B9?;!C:?C@9!;A9!L<DD?!!

U5;9?2!!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!!N&(!(2![WaO!Wb)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$1!((2!]W[!=]_G)!!*ABC?;5EA9!W_b`2!W[]^W[a)!!U9D?5:!W_][2!W"]O!ICP)!")!!

! !

Page 259: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a""!

T)()"a! N<B:<M!WW!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!XJE5?;JD9!X<DD!5I!N<B:<M!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<M)!39;J!()!

49?6BCE;C5:! S<DD! B9EB9?9:;<;C5:! 5I! 39;J! (! 5II9BC:P! <! 6D9E?J@B<! ;5!W+'2@C&0)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%*;'%,-%%

!+<@J!5I!;A9!,-%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;9K;2!!U9D?5:!W_VW2!W_WO")!!*5889:;2!+9C;Z![``[O!(((2!a`")!!

! !

Page 260: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a"]!

T)()"#! N<B:<M!W[!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:?!IB58!;A9!1<C:!X<DD!5I!%87:!'98ED9!<;!N<B:<M!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<M)!39;J!()!

49?6BCE;C5:! +C?;?! 5I! @CFC:C;C9?! 6<BF9@! 5:! ;A9! 65D78:?! 5I! ;A9! 1<C:! X<DD!

<I;9B!;A9![:@!$JD5:)!,:9!5I!;A9!;C;D9?!5I!P5@@9??!17;)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%W+'2@C&0%*;D'E%,-D'E%%%

%W+'2@C&0O!+<@J!5I!;A9!,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;9K;2!*ABC?;5EA9!W_bb2!3)"b!UB)!]`)!*5889:;2!+9C;Z![``[O!(Y2!"[)!!!

!

!

!

! !

Page 261: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a"b!

T)()"V! Y<BC57?!

456789:;!;C;D9! T<;;D9!5I!l<@9?A)!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! &<8)!((O!R)!b)!

49?6BCE;C5:! $598!B9I9BBC:P! ;A9!&<89??C@!8CDC;<BJ!6<8E<CP:!<P<C:?;! ;A9!XC;;C;9?! C:! <;;98E;! ;5! @C?D5@P9! ;A98! IB58! ;A9! U5B;A9B:!3JBC<)! (:?6BC>9@! 5:! ;A9! L<DD?! 5I! ;A9! ;98ED9?! 5I! %>J@5?O!+7K5BO! N<B:<MO! %>7! 3C8>9DO! <@! &<89??978)! '9K;!B965:?;B76;9@!>J!C;?!F9B?C5:?!C:2!W) %>J@5?2!;98ED9!5I!&<89?9?!((O!:5B;A^L9?;!L<DDk!

[) N<B:<M2!XJE5?;JD9!X<DD!<:@!L<DD!5I!;A9!657B;!>9;L99:!;A9!_;A!<:@!;A9!W`;A!EJD5:k!

") +7K5B2! EJD5:O! L<DD! 9<?;! <:@! ?57;A^9<?;! 5I! ;A9! 657B;! 5I!&<89?9?! ((!<:@!L9?;!L<DD!5I! ;A9!657B;!5I!%89:A5;9E! (((!

<;!+7K5Bk!

]) &<89??9782![:@!EJD5:k!

b) $<EJB7?!3<DDDC9B!((()!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!t[#`^[#WG!7&<9$%DP(&9$NE%$($9$%#*%$(<'0%.#%(2;&-9$%'*%*0%7+0%$09$%(%,-%%t"``^"`WG%8,-,%*%+,%*94:%$094%$"0'<94%S+%!,'%(%.+'94%-+%+*%0+%*%-(9$%*%#'"2#&%,*)%0.&%#*;%-+%*%@+0%C&%*)'%(+$%(&,'%%%t""V^""_G!"-%(%-'"%+%H&2(+$%+%?,(##D0E%,&%*%)'0%-'"%(%,-94%,*)%0&#%($%?,%$(<%&)'%!

!(!?A<DD!?;5E!;5!I99@C:P!;A98!8J?9DI!E9B?5:<DDJ!9F9BJ!@<J!;A<;!(!<8!C:!;A9!,-!!'A9:!A9!=;A9!B7D9B!5I!X<;;CG!@C?E<;6A9@!AC?!9:F5JO!>9<BC:P!<!D9;;9B!C:!AC?!A<:@O!C:!;A9!8CPA;J!:<89!5I!8J!8<d9?;J!5I!;A9!#'"2#&%5I!X5B7?O!3;B5:P!T7DDO!>9D5F9@!5I!1<n<;!!%BBCF<D!C:!/PJE;O!<;!$CB<89??9!-B9<;!C:!YC6;5BC9?O!<:@!B9?;C:P!C:!AC?!,-%5I!DCI9!<:@!@58C:C5:!DCM9!&<!LA5!C?!C:!;A9!X5BCZ5:!!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!((2!V[OWb^V"OWk!_`OWb^_WOWk!W``OW^a)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!+9E?C7?!W_#"2!F5D)!(((O!W_#>k!F5D)!YO!"_`)!!$1!Y((2!"Vb)!!!N79:;Z!W_[V^W_]")!!X<??<:!W_[_)!!'B<:?D<;C5:2!+C6A;A9C8!W_#"^W_V`O!((2!a[^#W)!!T%&!(((2!tt![_V^"[#)!!c<7DM:9B!W_bV2!_"!II)!!-<B@C:9B!W_a`)!!SCD?5:!W_[#2![aa^[V#)!!

! !

Page 262: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a"a!

T)()"_! .:CF9B?C;J!

17?978!

$9::?JDF<:C<!

UB)!

[_)W`#)_bV!

456789:;!;C;D9! T9;^3A9<:!?;9D9!5I!&<89?9?!((!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! T9;A^3A9<:)!&<8)!((O!R)!WV)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!DD)!W`^WWG!D#E-.9*94%)"+%.$94%)'$%,&(0%-'"%+%,-&%)"+0%(%;0'%*'<%$;09#*%$;9#*%$09#*%*94%'0'%(%0&-%'"%+%,-94%,*)%0&#%"+%?,2(##02>1(*%,&%)'0%!

!SA<;!L<?!5B@9B9@!>J!AC8O!A<?!5667BB9@)!X9!6<7?9?!;A9!%?C<;C6!;5!B9;B9<;!\7C6MDJO!ICPA;C:P!A<FC:P!>96589!<>58C:<;C5:!;5!;A9CB!A9<B;?)!'A9J!6589!;5!AC8!<DD!;5P9;A9B!LC;A!>5L9@!A9<@!;5!AC?!,-!5I!DCI9!<:@!@58C:C5:O!$CB<89??9O!-B9<;!5I!YC6;5BC9?!!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!((2!WbWOW^[)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$1!Y((2!"#_)!!&5L9!W_"`2!ED)!]V)!!

! !

Page 263: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a"#!

T)()]`! Y<BC57?!

456789:;!;C;D9! 1<BBC<P9!?;9D9!5I!&<89?9?!((!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! Y<BC57?)!&<8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! 1<BBC<P9!?;9D9O!I57B!>D56M?!IB58!/D9EA<:;C:9W)!1<BBC<P9!?;9D9!IB58!N<B:<MO!(0!$JD5:[)!1<BBC<P9!?;9D9!IB58!%8<B<!S9?;")!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!D)!][G!#&'%8'&%0+%,&'%*%B'&:%-'"#%(%,-%"+2*#0'%-+%!(#9$0%'$%0+%+,%*;!!

!'A9!@<7PA;9B!5I!;A9!-B9<;!&7D9B!5I!X<;;C!L<?!C:?;<DD9@!C:!;A9!,-%"+2*#0'I%<6658E<:JC:P!;A9!?5F9B9CP:!9F9BJ!@<J!!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!N&(!((2![bbOW)!W!$1!Y2![[b)!49!15BP<:!WV_]^W_`_O!Y5D)!WO!W[WO!WW#^WWV)!!N79:;Z!W_[b2!WVW!II)![!$1!((2!b_!=b]G)!N79:;Z!W_[b2!WVW!II)!"!$1!Y((2!Wb_!="G!6P!][Wb])!!

!

!

!

! !

Page 264: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a"V!

T)()]W! +57FB9!*![V]!

456789:;!;C;D9! T9:;B9?A!?;9D9!!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!&<8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!D)!_G%..9*%-(94%$*$%*9$%''%,+P%*'%"+2,*)%,+P0%*'%7*0%!

!'A9:!XC?!1<d9?;J!?<C@2!oTBC:P!89!;A9!E9B?5::9D!5I!;A9!X57?9!5I!+CI9O!<:@!;A9!I7:6;C5:<BC9?!5I!;A9!7*0e%!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!((2![VbO_)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!+9I9>FB9!W_]_2![[]^[[b)!!49!T76M!W_]V2!W`a^W`_)!!!

! !

Page 265: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a"_!

T)()][! *<CB5!*)[WO!

*)[[!

456789:;!;C;D9! 'LC:!?;9D<9!IB58!%>7!3C8>9D!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>7!3C8>9D)!&<8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!U5B;A!?;9D9!=*)[WG!IB58!;A9!-B9<;!'98ED9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!D)!VG!*#0'2;$'<%W#$2(&,2?,2#'"2*2?,%#&%?,%?,2(+2(#0%.$%,*)%$*$%;!0'%D(%#;$0E%+%H&2(+$%#+0%S+%$*$%*0%$*09#*%+%,-94%!

!NC:P!5I!;A9!357;A9B:!<:@!U5B;A9B:!/PJE;O!W#$2(&,2?,2#'"2*2?,O!?5:!5I!&9O!&<89?9?O!PCF9:!DCI9!LA5!6<BBC9?!;A9!B9>9D?!;5!/PJE;O!=LACD9G!;A9CB!6AC9I?!>9<B!;A9CB!;BC>7;9!;5!AC?!,-%!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!!N&(!((2!"W#OWa)!$1!Y((2!__!=W[G!45:<@5:C!W_a`)!!!

! !

Page 266: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a]`!

T)()]"! %>J@5?!b!

456789:;!;C;D9! 49@C6<;5BJ!(:?6BCE;C5:!5I!%>J@5?!!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! '98ED9!5I!39;J!(!<;!%>J@5?)!39;J!()!

49?6BCE;C5:! WWa!F9B;C6<D! DC:9?! C:?6BCE;C5:!5I!&<89?9?! ((!5:! ;A9!?57;A9B:!A<DI!5I! ;A9!L<DD! <;! ;A9! B9<B!5I! ;A9! ICB?;! 657B;!5I! ;A9! ;98ED9!>7CD;! >J! 39;J! (! <;! %>J@5?)! (;! ?A5L?! &<89?9?! ((! ?<CDC:P! ;5!%>J@5?O!LA9B9!A9! IC:@?!39;J! (! C:!AC?! ;98ED9!7:IC:C?A9@!<:@!AC?! 9:@5L89:;?! FC5D<;9@)! X9! C889@C<;9DJ! ?7885:?! AC?!657B;!<:@!5IIC6C<D?!<:@!;5!<::57:69!;5!;A98!AC?!C:;9:;C5:!;5!658ED9;9!AC?!I<;A9BQ?!>7CD@C:P)!%)!3E996A!5I!,?CBC?!T)!3E996A!5I!&<89?9?!((!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!D)!aG!$09C%),$%($%-+%S'94%($%+0.%?,%-+%.&$%-+'%"'%$09C%(%*#0D'E%;$'<%(%*4+09C%(%7*0!!!!!D)!]#G!S+S9*94%0$%(%"+<'%$"'2*#0'%(%#*'%*4+0%,-!!

!R57!<EE9<B!5:!J57B!;AB5:9!DCM9!&<!ID57BC?A9?!LA9:!A9!6B5??9?!;A9!?MJ!C:!\7<DC;J!5I!MC:P!5I!.EE9B!<:@!+5L9B!/PJE;O!;A<:M?!;5!J57B!\7<DC;C9?O!C:!;A9!7*0!!!X9!=39;J!(G!9\7CEE9@!89!LC;A!A57?9A5D@!L589:O!<!B5J<D!A<B98O!DCM9!;A9!>9<7;C9?!5I!;A9!,-!!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<7;AC9B!W_WW2!b[^aa)!!-<7;AC9B!W_W[)!!T%&!(((2!tt![ba^[VW)!1<?E9B5!WVa#)!!1<BC9;;9!WVa_!^V`O!(2!ED)!]^_)!!

! !

Page 267: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a]W!

T)()]]! %>J@5?!a!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:?!5I!&<89?9?!((Q?!'98ED9!<;!%>J@5?!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!&<8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:! ;A9!U5B;A!S<DD! C:! ;A9! (:;9BC5B!5I! ;A9!c9?;CF<D!X<DD)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!!$(<%,-94%0&0&%--<%&)0%+%)0$%-0'94%*%H&20+%!

!X9!LA5!L<?!C:!AC?!,-!;55M!657:?9D!<?!5:9!LA5!?9<B6A9@!I5B!>9:9I<6;C5:?O!;5!65:?;B76;!AC?!;98ED9!I5B!;A9!'AC:C;9!U589!!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!((2!b"bOW`^WW)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$1!Y(2!"])!!1<BC9;;9!WVV`O!((2!ED)!#)!!SB9:ZC:?MC!W_"[^]`O!((2O!ED)!WVV)!!U<FCDD9!W_"`2!ED?)!"W^"[)!!

! !

Page 268: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a][!

T)()]b! +7K5B!W!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:?!IB58!;A9!;98ED9!5I!+7K5BO!c5B9657B;O!@9@C6<;C5:?!<:@!c9?;CF<D!5I!,E9;!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! +7K5B)!&<8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:! 5:! ;A9! 357;A! L<DDO! L9?;! A<DI! <:@! 5:! ;A9! S9?;!L<DDO!?57;A!A<DI)!+C?;!5I!B5J<D!E9B?5::9D!>9<BC:P!;BC>7;9!;5!;A9!MC:P)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%$(<2+%*$0'%'&'<%#(+0%*#0'%)'(0%,-%D99E%$0%(%0&-%7+%$*0%

!'A9!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6C;JO!;A9!FCZC9BO!;A9!B5J<D!658E<:C5:?O!?9<D9B!5I!;A9!,-%D99E!LA5!6589!C:!5>9C?<:69O!>9<BC:P!;A9CB!;BC>7;9!%!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!((2!a`VO_)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$1!((2!"`V!=[_H"`G)!!4<B9??J!WV_"2!"W)!!%>@!/D!&<ZCM!W_#]2!W]V)!!%>@!/D!&<ZCM!W_#b2!W[_)!!

! !

Page 269: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a]"!

!

T)()]a! 11%!b])WVb!

456789:;!;C;D9! /:@5L89:;!3;9D9!5I!&<89?9?!((!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 'A9>9?)!&<8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'A9! DC89?;5:9! ?;9D9! 65:;<C:?! ;A9! 9:789B<;C5:! 5I! ;A9!EB5E9B;J! <:@! C:6589! 5I! <! ;98ED9O! EB9?78<>DJ! ;A9!&<89??978O! LAC6A! &<89?9?! ((! L<?! ;5! >7CD@! C:! L9?;9B:!'A9>9?)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!DD)!#^VG!..0'%(%-(%#'"2#&%(%7+0%"*%0**%*'+2-0'%W#$2(&,2?,2#'"2*2?,%.$%,*)%899:%(%!*0'%-'"02*'+%*%"+2>1(*2?,%*#0'%*'+0%!!

!SA<;!L<?!?<C@!>9I5B9!;A9!8<d9?;J!5I!;A9!#'"2#&%5:!;AC?!@<J2!;A9!;98ED9!5I!!W#$2(&,2?,2#'"2*2?,I%PCF9:!DCI9!?A<DD!>9!e))f!IB58!;A9!PB<:<BJ!5I!;A9!@CFC:9!5II9BC:P?!5I!;A9!/?;<;9!5I!%87:^&<O!MC:P!5I!;A9!P5@?)!!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!((2!#W`O!_^W`)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!!N<8<D!W_W_2!Wb")!365;;!W_ba2!V"^V]O!:5)!WW)!!

! !

Page 270: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a]]!

!

T)()]#! N<B:<M!W"!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!XJE5?;JD9!X<DD!5I!N<B:<M!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<M)!&<8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! S<DD!B9EB9?9:;<;C5:!5I!&<89?9?!((!B7::C:P!>9I5B9!W+'2@C&0!<:@!5II9BC:P!C:69:?9!<:@!DC><;C5:!;5!;A9!'A9><:!'BC<@)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%*;'%,-%%%

!+<@J!5I!;A9!,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;9K;2!U9D?5:!W_VW2!W[O")!*5889:;2!+9C;Z![``[O!(((2!a`")!!

! !

Page 271: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a]b!

!

T)()]V! &<89??978!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!&<89??978!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 'A9>9?O!&<89??978)!&<8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!<B6AC;B<F9!5I!;A9!;98ED9!5I!&<89??978!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%%)%%$+'9*94%,-%0+%D#E)(0%!"#$%*#0'%;$'<%"#.'%#'%-'"%*%*;%*'+0%(%-;94%*4+%$*;%%%%T)!!

$+'9*94%0#)'%),00%(%)'42-+%*%-0'94%0+%#'%),0%*%*;%*'+0%(%-;%$*;%%%%

!

!

'A9!8<MC:P!I5B!AC8!5I!<!PB9<;!,-%=<:@G!;A9!?ABC:9?!5I!;A9!MC:P!5I!.EE9B!<:@!+5L9B!/PJE;!

<:@!;A9!/::9<@O!=<:@G!;A9!?9<;!5I!E9<69!5I!

;A9!+5B@!5I!;A9!P5@?!C:!AC?!I9<?;!5I!;A9!

>9<7;CI7D!F<DD9J!

!!

'A9!8<MC:P!I5B!AC8!5I!<!657B;!5I!;A9!

<EE9<B<:69!C:!IB5:;!5I!AC?!;98ED9!5I!;A9!

-B9<;!39<;!=I5B!;A9G!<EE9<B<:69?!5I!;A9!+5B@!

5I!;A9!P5@?!C:!;A9!c9<?;!5I!;A9!Y<DD9J!

!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!4<B9??J!WV_V2!V[)!

%

% %

Page 272: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a]a!

T)()]_! 198EAC?![!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:?!IB58!;A9!$<D<69!5I!19B9:E;<A!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 198EAC?)!19B9:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!8<C:!@55BL<J!D9<@C:P!C:;5!;A9!65D78:9@!6A<8>9B)%!T)! (:?6BCE;C5:?! 5:! ;A9! 65D78:?! 5I! ;A9!8<C:! A<DDW)! 369:9! 5I!;A9!MC:P!658C:P!IB58!;A9!E<D<69)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)!D)!"G%F#+'%*;D'E%,-%%%T)!D)!bG!),$D'E%*#0'%($%?,!(!,-%*%&)'%!DD)!W^[G!),$D'E%*#0'%(%,-%#'"%,*)%-&94%8($%?,:%!!

!F#+'O!+<@J!5I!;A9!,-%%%%%EE9<B<:69!5I!;A9!MC:P!DCM9!&<!C:!;A9%,-!%%EE9<B<:69!5I!;A9!MC:P!C:!;A9%,-I%L57D@!;A<;!A9!EB5;96;?!DCI9O!DCM9!&<!!

U5;9?2!!W!(:!;A9!8C@@D9!5I!9<6A!65D78:?!C?!;A9!B9EB9?9:;<;C5:!C:!B9DC9I!5I!;A9!MC:P!658C:P!57;!5I!AC?!,-)!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!(Y2!b]OW]k!bbOV^_)!!/@P<B!W_`b2!W``^W`")!!*5889:;2!+9C;Z![``[O!(Y2!"[)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$1!(((2![_")!cC?A9B!W_W#2![[]!II)!!!

! !

Page 273: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a]#!

T)()b`! T<A;C8!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;<;79!><?9!5I!l799:!U9I9B;<BC!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! T<A;C8!=X9DC5E5DC?G)!&<8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!D)![G!*#0'%-('%F4+$2'<2=0'%(+$'2=0'%*4+'%0+'%-#D0E'%-*'%*4+0'%8"+:2*#0'!!

!-B9<;!&5J<D!SCI9O!F4+$2'<I!>9D5F9@!5I!17;O!P55@!85;A9BO!PB9<;DJ!I<F5B9@O!1C?;B9??!5I!8<C@9:?!5I!;A9!8"+:2*#0'%!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!((2!V]VO!a)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!!$1!(Y2!bV)!!U<FCDD9!^!-BCIIC;A!WV_`2!aaO!ED)!00(2!W")!!!

! !

Page 274: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a]V!

!

T)()bW! *-!][Wb]!

456789:;!;C;D9! -B57E^?;<;79!5I!l799:!U9I9B;<BC!<:@!$BC:69!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<M!6<6A9;;9)!&<8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!?7BI<69!>9;L99:!;A9![!ICP7B9?)!%) 'C;D9!B9I9BB9@!;5!;A9!\799:)!

T) 'C;D9!B9I9BB9@!;5!;A9!EBC:69)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)!D)!WG!899:%,-%*4+'%-+%%T)!DD)!"^]G!-&'<2,%+"2,'%#(+%,&%(%"+2*#0'%0+%0+0%899:%,-!!

!eC:!;A9f!,-I%>9<7;CI7D!5I!I<69%%%X9B9@C;<BJ!EBC:69!<:@!8<J5BO!IBC9:@O!PB9<;!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%PB9<;9?;!5I!;A9!PB9<;!5:9?!eC:!;A9f!,-%!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!((2!V]V2W"k!V]V2Wb)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!!+9PB<C:!W_`a^[b2!a_aO!((O![`!I)O!ED)!W#)!!49?B56A9?!^!U5>D9657B;!W_#a2!#b^#V)!!!

! !

Page 275: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a]_!

!

T)()b[! +7K5B![!

456789:;!;C;D9! &9EB9?9:;<;C5:!5I!l799:!U9I9B;<BC!>9I5B9!&5J<D!6ACD@B9:!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! +7K5B!'98ED9)!&<8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! c5B9657B;!5I!&<89?9?!((O!(:;9BC5BO!S9?;!L<DD!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!D)!bG!W+%)*'%*%@+%*;%,-%!

!*AC9I!5I!;A9!X<BC8!5I!X5B7?O!+5B@!5I!;A9!,-!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!((2!V]_Oa)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$1!((2!"`V!=[VG)!!4<B9??J!WV_"2!"W^"[)!!

! !

Page 276: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ab`!

T)()b"! TB7K9DD9?!

17?978!

c)#b``!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;<;79!5I!l799:!U9I9B;<BC!LC;A!$BC:69!19BC;578Q?!ICP7B9!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! +7K5B!'98ED9)!&<8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! c5B9657B;!5I!&<89?9?!((O!(:;9BC5BO!S9?;!L<DD!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!D)!WG!8(%,-:%*4+0'9#'%*7(%,7*0'<%0&+)%7+%)*%S+%)*(9#'!

!eC:!;A9!,-f%A9B!>9<7;J!E9BF<@9?!;A9!,7*0'<O!=LACD9G!A9B!IB<PB<:69!ICDD?!;A9!65D5::<@9!A<DD!=0&+)E%!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!((2!VbbOb)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<E<B;!W_][2!#b^##O!ICP?)!]^a)!!

! !

Page 277: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! abW!

T)()b]! Y<BC57?!

456789:;!;C;D9! 496B99!5I!>D9??C:P!$;<A!7E5:!&<89?9?!((!<:@!(((!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! Y<BC57?)!&<8)!((!="b;A!J9<BG!<:@!&<8)!(((W)!

49?6BCE;C5:! W!%>7!3C8>9DO!?;9D9!6<BF9@!5:!>D56M?!>9;L99:!;A9![!L9?;9B:!ECDD<B?!C:!;A9!8<C:!L<DD!5I!;A9!-B9<;!'98ED9)![!N<B:<MO!$JD5:!(0O!S9?;!SC:P)!"!%M?A<!=39BB<!S9?;GO!I<v<@9!5I!;A9!357;A9B:!SC:P!5I!$JD5:)!]!19@C:9;!X<>7O! I<v<@9!5I! ;A9!S9?;!LC:P!5I!$JD5:! (O!-B9<;!'98ED9!5I!&<89?9?!((()!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%$+9*94%7*0%,&%!"#$%+%*)'%'&!%H&2(+$%M+2?,2(##02(+$2>1(*%.$%,*)%+.94%-+<2'"%'&%$(%#)*0'%*'%"'%-(9C%(*%(%,-94!%!

!X9!A<?!8<@9!<:!<7P7?;!7*0%;5!?;B9:P;A9:!;A9!>5B@9B?!5I!/PJE;2!$CB<89??9O!PCF9:!DCI9)!(;!?;<:@?!ICB8!7E5:!9<B;A!DCM9!;A9!ECDD<B?!5I!X9<F9:)!R57B!1<d9?;J!?;<:@?!ICB8!C:!AC?!,-%!

U5;9?2!W!%!6D5?9!@7EDC6<;9!5I!;A9!?;9D9!L<?!?9;!7E!>J!&<89?9?!(((! C:!AC?!;98ED9!5I!19@C:9;^X<>7O!C:!-<B@C:9B!W_WV2!WVW)!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!((2![a_OW`)!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!W!$1!Y((2!W`a)!-<B@C:9B!W_WV2!WVW)!!U<FCDD9!WVV[2!WW_^W"V)!!y9B:J!^!/@9D!W_a`)!![!$1!((2!b_!=bbGk!T<BP79;!W_a[2![b]O!ED)!"#6O!D9I;)!!"!Y9B657;;9B!W_a[k!ED)!"bO!<^>)!!]!U9D?5:!W_"[2!ED?)!W`]^b^a)!!!

!

! !

Page 278: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ab[!

T)()bb! 19@C:9;!

X<>7!W!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:?!5:!;A9!L<DD?!5I!;A9!;98ED9!5I!19@C:9;!X<>7!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 19@C:9;!X<>7)!&<8)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)! S<DD! B9EB9?9:;<;C5:! LC;A! &<89?9?! (((! 5II9BC:P! C:69:?9!

>9I5B9! %87:^&<! <:@! W+'2@C&0k! ?69:9! LC;A! &<89?9?!

5IIC6C<;C:P!>9I5B9!%;78!<:@!W+'2@C&0k!?69:9!LC;A!&<89?9?!

(((!5II9BC:P!>57\79;?!;5!A78<:^A9<@9@!17;)!!

T)! (:?6BCE;C5:?! 5:! ;A9! L<DD?! 5I! ;A9! @55B?! DC:MC:P! ;A9! >CP!

;98ED9!LC;A!;A9!E<D<69)!

*)! (:?6BCE;C5:?! 5I! ;A9! <B6AC;B<F9! 5I! &<89??978! LAC6A!

7:@9BDC:9?! ;A9! 65::96;C5:! 5I! ;AC?! >7CD@C:P! LC;A! ;A9! Y<DD9J!

c9<?;)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%%)%*;'%,-%%%T)%,&%*#0'%(%($''%?,%+.%,-'%0#)'94%!!*)!$+'9*94%,-'%0+%#)(0%**%"+D0E!!!%

!+<@J!5I!;A9!,-%%'A9!PB9<;!MC:P!PB5L?!DCM9!&<!C:!AC?!,-%0#)'%%'A9!8<MC:P!I5B!AC8!5I!<!PB9<;!,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;9K;2!U9D?5:!W_"`^W_#`2!F5D!Y2!"]"O!Tk!F5D!Y(2!"#aO%[k!Y5D)!Y((2!b`]OTW)!4<B9??J!WV_V2!V[)!!XxD?6A9B!W_[]^W_[V2!ED)!W["!T)!*5889:;2!+9C;Z![``[O!(Y2!"[)!!

!

!

! !

Page 279: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ab"!

T)()ba! 19@C:9;!

X<>7![!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!;98ED9^E<D<69!5I!19@C:9;!X<>7!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 'A9>9?O!19@C:9;!X<>7!'98ED9)!&<8)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! %) (:?6BCE;C5:! IB58! ;A9! ICB?;! 657B;O! ?57;A!L<DDO! @55BL<J! *O!

L9?;!?C@9!5I!;A9!E<??<P9)!369:9!B9EB9?9:;C:P!&<89?9?!(((!

9:;9BC:P!;A9!LC:@5L!5I!B5J<D!<EE9<B<:69?!;5!<@@B9??!AC?!

657B;)!

T)! ! (:?6BCE;C5:! IB58! ;A9! ICB?;! 657B;O! ?57;A!L<DDO! @55BL<J! 4)!

369:9! B9EB9?9:;C:P!&<89?9?! (((! 9:;9BC:P! ;A9! ;98ED9! o;5!

6<7?9! AC?! I<;A9B! %87:! ;5! <EE9<B! C:! AC?! I9<;! 5I! ;A9!

Y<DD9Jr)!

W) (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!9<?;!?C@9!5I!;A9!E<??<P9)!

[) (:?6BCE;C5:! 5:! ;A9! L9?;! ?C@9! 5I! ;A9! E<??<P9! =<2!

C:?6BCE;C5:! 5:! ;A9! D9I;! ?C@9! 5I! ;A9! ?69:9)! >2!

C:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!BCPA;!?C@9G)!

*)! (:?6BCE;C5:! 5:! ;A9! @57>D9! I<D?9^@55B! IB58! ;A9! ;AB5:9!

B558!5I!;A9!ICB?;!E<D<69)!'A9!@57>D9!I<D?9^@55BO! C:! IB5:;!

5I! LAC6A! ?;55@! ;A9! ;AB5:9O! L<?! ?9;! >9;L99:! ;L5!

ECD<?;9B?!C:!;A9!B9<B!L<DD)!,:!;A9!;L5!D9<F9?!;A9!L<DMC:P!

MC:P! C?! ?A5L:! LC;A! ?;<II! C:! A<:@! <?! CI! A9! L9B9! 658C:P!

IB58! ;A9! C:;9BC5B! 5I! ;A9! E<D<69)! %6658E<:JC:P!

C:?6BCE;C5:?! ?;<;9! 5:! ;A9! BCPA;! ?C@9! 5I! ;A9! MC:P! <:@! ;A9!

D9I;)!

W)!!!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!BCPA;!?C@9)!

[)!!!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!D9I;!?C@9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%) %899#;&:<'%(%,-%!"#$%*'<%($%&)'%*%?,%

%T) %W9%899#;&:<'%(%,-%!"#$%*'<%($%&)'%*%?,%%[<9%),$D'E%*#0'%($%?,%(%,-%*%-0'94%!"#$%+%#),$%,$'94%>(*%(%-;94%*%$*;%%%[>9%-P&%,*%(%"+$94%($%*#0'2;$'<%(%),094%%(%-+'%-+<2'"%#;&<'%(%,-%!"#$%*'<%($%&)'%*%?,%%%!

!

e@5f5B?!;A9!:5>D9!,-I%DCM9!&<!C:!;A9!A5BCZ5:!!

!

e@5f5B?!;A9!:5>D9!,-I%DCM9!&<!C:!;A9!A5BCZ5:!!

%EE9<B<:69!5I!;A9!MC:P!DCM9!&<!C:!AC?!,-%5I!AC?!:5>D9!;98ED9!;5!8<M9!AC?!I<;A9B!<EE9<B?O!

%87:O!C:!AC?!c9<?;!5I!;A9!Y<DD9J!

>9<7;CI7D!B7D9B!C:!AC?!P5C:P!DCM9!MC:P!5I!.EE9B!

<:@!+5L9B!/PJE;!C:!AC?!<EE9<B<:69!C:!A9<F9:!

7E5:!;A9!@55B?!5I!;A9!:5>D9!,-%DCM9!&<!C:!;A9!A5BCZ5:!

%

Page 280: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ab]!

*)!

W)%),$D'E%*#0'%(%,-%*%-0'94%!"#$%%%[9%),$D'E%*#0'%($%?,%(%,-%*%,*)%0&#%%%

!

%EE9<B<:69!5I!;A9!MC:P!C:!;A9!,-%5I!AC?!<7P7?;!;98ED9!

!

%EE9<B<:69!5I!;A9!MC:P!DCM9!&<!C:!AC?!,-%5I!DCI9!<:@!I5B;7:9!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!%^T2!XxD?6A9B!W_bW2!ED)!["V!TO!["_)!*2!XxD?6A9B!W_]W2!ICP)![VO!ED)!"#)!%

! !

Page 281: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! abb!

T)()b#! %>7!3C8>9D!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:?!IB58!;A9!;98ED9!5I!%>7!3C8>9D!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>7!3C8>9D)!&<8)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%*;'%,-%%%

!+<@J!5I!;A9!,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;9K;2!+9C;Z![``[O!(Y2!"[)!!+9E?C7?!WV_#^W_W"O!(((2!WV_@)!!!

! !

Page 282: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! aba!

T)()bV! /D9EA<:;C:9!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!&<89?9?!(((!<;!/D9EA<:;C:9!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! /D9EA<:;C:9)!&<8)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!<!;98ED9!>D56M!IB58!;A9!\7<J!5I!/D9EA<:;C:9O!

E<B;! 5I! <! @96B99! ?<I9P7<B@C:P! ;A9! ;98ED9! 5B! ;98ED9?! 5I!

D56<D!P5@!NA:78)!'A9!>D56M! ?A5L!E5B;C5:!5I!WW!A5BCZ5:;<D!

DC:9?! 5I! LAC6A! ;A9! ICB?;! [! >9D5:P! ;5! ;A9! C:;B5@76;C5:O! ;A9!

@96B99! C;?9DI! >9PC::C:P! C:! ;A9!"B@! DC:9!<;! ;A9!8C@@D9!5I! ;A9!

>D56M)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%

..'%0&.D'E%&0<9'0%(%-(%*%#'"2#&%,*)%0.&%#*;%(%7+0%"*%'&'<%#+0%#(+0%P*;'%#.(<0%-&'<2,0%'#0%0-<'%G(,0%H&2(-0%C&%.*;0%-+<%$-0%#+<'%+0.%*;%*%"+2*#0'%+('%*;0%7&;0%(%0"'%+%#)'%

%

!

496B99!<@@B9??9@!C:!;A9!8<d9?;J!5I!;A9!#'"2#&O!D)!E)!A)!5:!;AC?!@<J!;5!=;A9G!FCZC9BO!=;A9G!5IIC6C<D?O!;A9!657B;C9B?O!;A9!657B;?!5I!d7@P9?O!

;A9!8<J5B?!<:@!;A9!65:;B5DD9B?!5I!6<8E?!5I!

.EE9B!<:@!+5L9B!/PJE;O!;A9!6A<BC5;99B?O!;A9!

?;<>D9^8<?;9B?!<:@!?;<:@<B@^>9<B9B?O!9F9BJ!

<P9:;!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'O!<:@!9F9BJ5:9!?9:;!5:!<!8C??C5:!;5!;A9!657:;BJ!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!N&(!Y2!"][^"]b)!

-BCIIC;A!W_[#2!W"_^[`V2![`#^V)!

!

! !

Page 283: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ab#!

T)()b_! $<D9?;C:9!

%B6A<95D5PC6<D!

17?978!5I!

g9B7?<D98!

"a)W__"!

456789:;!;C;D9! TB5:Z9!?;<;79^><?9!5I!&<89?9?!Y(!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 19PC@@5)!&<8)!Y()!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'C;D9!B9I9BB9@!;5!W+'2@C&0!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!D)!]G%*;'%,-D'E%

!+<@J!5I!;A9!,-%!

U5;9?2!;C;D9!B9I9BB9@!;5!;A9!MC:P!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!Y(2![#VO#)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!!$1!Y((2!"VW)!!+57@!W_]V2!W"b^aO!ICP?)!"#]^b)!!

! !

Page 284: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! abV!

!

T)()a`! T1!W_]!

456789:;!;C;D9! *B5??L5B@!3;9D9!5I!&<89?9?!Y(!LC;A!XJ8:?!;5!17;!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<MO!'98ED9!5I!17;)!&<8)!Y()!!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'C;D9?!B9I9BB9@!;5!P5@@9??!17;)!%) X5BCZ5:;<D!;9K;k!

T) Y9B;C6<D!;9K;)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)!D)!WWG%!4<'9#%(%,-%%!D)!][G%*;'%7*09#%%T)!6)![[G%W+%!4<'%(%,-%%

!X9B!=17;Q?G!@CP:C;J!C:!;A9%,-!!=17;G!+<@J!5I!A9B!7*0!!!-B9<;!5I!@CP:C;J!C:!;A9!,-!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!!N&(!Y(2![_`O!W[k![_#O!Wak!"`]O![[)!!3;9L<B;!W_#W2!_`!II)O!ED?)![]^[#)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$1!((2![#`)!!*5889:;2!+9C;Z![``[O!((2!]a]k!(Y2!W[[)!! !!

! !

Page 285: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ab_!

!

T)()aW! E'7BC:!=<G!

456789:;!;C;D9! $<EJB7?!IB58!;A9!'7BC:!17?978!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 'A9>9?)!WV;A^W_;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!D)!W!<:@!#G!#!%*%"+2,&%%D)!VG!--D0E%+*"0'%*%"+2,&%%D)!W`G!W+%"+2-.%*%"+2,&%%

!36BC>9!5I!;A9!"+2,&%!'98ED9!=qG!5I!1CDDC5:!J9<B?!5I!;A9!"+2,&!!-B9<;!5:9!5I!;A9!;B9<?7BJ!5I!;A9%"+2,&!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;9K;2!X9D6M!W_bV2!]aW)!!T5;;C!^!$99;!W_W#2!B96;5!(0!WO!#^V!<:@!W`!=~!ED)![bG)!!

! !

Page 286: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! aa`!

T)()a[! E%:<?;<?C!(Y!

456789:;!;C;D9! $<EJB7?!%:<?;<?C!(Y!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!39;J!()!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)!%!D9;;9B!5I!<@7D<;C5:!;5!;A9!$A<B<5A!=~!%:<?;<?C!((O!bOaG!

T)!$B<C?9!;5!;A9!49D;<!B9?C@9:69)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%G!bOaG!!(%,*)%0.&%#*;%7&;%"0%+%+.$+%+)9'0%@+%(%,-%(+<%=&,'%,*)%0.&%#*;%&)'%*'<%?,%$(94!!!!bO_G!$0%..9'0%*9C%#)+D0E%'&0<%*;%$09C%-'"9'0%(%,-%,*)%0.&%#*;%'09C%-+%#.(%(.0'%*%'&0<%*;0%'09C%S+%--%*%(#.+0%%%T)%%aOWG%P.%-(94%,*)%0.&%#*;%;)*%,&%*)'%+*94%%%aOb^aG%"&%;)*%*'<%7*094%*#0%($%&)'%*%"'%?,2(#2#02(+$2>1(*%#$%(94%(%*'+%!

!(:!DCI9O!EB5?E9BC;J!<:@!A9<D;A)!'AC?!D9;;9B!C?!I5B!;A9!C:I5B8<;C5:!5I!;A9!X5B7?!5I!;A9!,-O!>9D5F9@!5I!1<n<;!D)!E)!A)!;A9!A5BCZ5:!C:!LAC6A!&<!C?!!R57!=;A9!$A<B<5AG!B9I9B!;A9!65:@C;C5:!5I!9F9BJ!657:;BJ!LACD?;!J57B!<B;!B9?;?!C:!;A9!,-I!D)!E)!A)!R57!A9<B!;A9!?E996A!5I!<DD!657:;BC9?O!J57!E5??9??!8CDDC5:?!5I!J9<B?!!!XC?!1<d9?;J!D)!E)!A)!A<?!>7CD;!AC8?9DI!<!6<?;D9!LA5?9!:<89!C?!-B9<;!5I!YC6;5BC9?!!'A9!6<?;D9!LAC6A!C?!LC;AC:!AC?!7*0!C;!C?!DCM9!;A9!A5BCZ5:!5I!A9<F9:O!?,2(#2#02(+$2>1(*%C?!C:!C;!<?!P5@!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!W_"#2!]`OWk!]`Oa)!'B<:?D<;C5:2!*<8C:5?!W_b]2!Wb")!!

! !

Page 287: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! aaW!

T)()a"! E-7B5>!TT!

456789:;!;C;D9! $<EJB7?!-7B5>!cB<P89:;?O!TT!Ksb!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!&<8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! $<B;!5I!<!?C:PD9!?A99;!EB9?9BFC:P!;A9!B98<C:?!5I!_!DC:9?!IB58!

;A9! >5;;58! 5I! ;A9! E<P9k! ;A9B9C:! <B9! 9:789B<;9@! [!

5F9B?99B?! 5I! EB5EA9;?O! [! 5F9B?99B?! 5I! 6<;;D9! <:@! ]! 5;A9B!

EB5EA9;?!5I!@CII9B9:;!;98ED9?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!bG%$(<2+%$-0%*)'%*%*&%(*(*'%*%"+2,&!%

!,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6<;;D9!5I!A9B@?!5I!$A<B<5A!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!-<B@C:9B!W__b2!"b2!#)!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!WVO!:5)!b#)!!

! !

Page 288: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! aa[!

T)()a]! ET1!W`aV"!

456789:;!;C;D9! $<EJB7?!*A9?;9B!T9<;;J!(((!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!19B9:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! $<EJB7?!6<BBJC:P!<!D9;;9B!;5!;A9!FCZC9B!M&2*2-#<!<@@B9??9@!>J!;A9! ?6BC>9! 5I! ;A9! ;58>! oC*2-"2!4O! <! 6D9BM! 5I! ;A9! L5BM?! C:!6A<BP9!5I!65BB9?E5:@9:69!LC;A!;A9!;58>!5I!19B9:E;<A!<:@!

LC;A! ;A9! 8<C:;9:<:69! 5I! ;A9! L5BM89:! 98ED5J9@! C:! C;?!

9K6<F<;C5:)!'A9!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!'B9<?7BJ!5I!;A9!$A<B<5A!<:@!

;A9! @9E7;J^5IIC69B! 5I! ;A9! 'B9<?7BJ! 5I! ;A9! $A<B<5A! <B9!

\79?;C5:9@!;5!EB5FC@9!8C??C:P!8<;9BC<D?!I5B!;A9!L5BM!?76A!<?!

6AC?9D?!<:@!PJE?78)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%$(<2+%"+2-.%*%"+2,&%%$.*0%*%"+2-.%*%"+2,&%%

!,F9B?99B!5I!$A<B<5AQ?!;B9<?7BJ!!49E7;J!5I!$A<B<5AQ?!;B9<?7BJ!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!-<B@C:9B!W_"b2!(O![]^[ak!ED?!WW2!WWO!WW2!W[)!!N&(!(Y2!V#O![^")!!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!"WO!:5)!W`"k!WVVO!:5)!abW)!!

! !

Page 289: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! aa"!

T)()ab! ET5D5P:<!

W`_]!

456789:;!;C;D9! $<EJB7?!T5D5P:<!W`_]!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 198EAC?!=qG)!19B9:)O!R)!WV)!!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)!396;C5:![2!EB5FC?C5:?!I5B!;A9!MC:PQ?!3965:@!g7>CD99)!

T)!396;C5:!"2!<!D9;;9B!5I!C:?;B76;C5:)!

*)!396;C5:!b2!<!D9;;9B!<>57;!<PBC67D;7B<D!8<;;9B?)!

4)!396;C5:!a2!D9;;9B)!

/)!396;C5:!#2!(:?;B76;C5:?!I5B!;A9!3965:@!g7>CD99)!

c)!396;C5:!V2!D9;;9B!<>57;!?589!J57:P!65:?6BCE;?)!

-)!396;C5:!WW2!<!D9;;9B!;5!<!EBC9?;!<:@!AC?!?E57?9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)!WO"^]G!#!%*#0'%$(<2+%"+%M'-2(2-;%*%"+%`&2*2?,%(+2>1(*%,*)%0.&%#*;%(%=*2*4+%-+%..%*%$(<2+%-('%*%"&%)"!%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%T)!WO_G!=,-0%#!%*%"&%)"!%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%*)![OVG!8#.(9$:%"&%7&;%[O_G%8*9:$!$+%*%"&<%*;9$%,*)%0.&%8#*;%-+%$(<:%(%$'%*%*&%-'+0%*%"&%$-0%,&%*%[OW`G!?,(##02(+<2>1(*%e*%7*0%Nf!-*,%*&%-'+0%*%"&%$-0%,&%*%`&2*2?,2(+<2>1(*!"OWG!*%7*0!!!!"OW^[G!$-0'<0%*%'&%($*'%"+2,&!%!4)!"ObG%%=,-0%#!%*%"&%)"!%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%i9%]OWG%=,-0%#!%*%"&%)"!%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%c)!bOWG%=,-0%#!%*%"&%)"!%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%-)!#OW`G%=,-0%#!%*%"&%)"!%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%

%M'-2(2-;I%B5J<D!?6BC>9!<:@!?;9L<B@!5I!;A9!A57?9!5I!`&2*2?,%(+2>1(*I%D)!E)!A)!C:!198EAC?O!?E9<M?!;5!;A9!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!L5BM?A5E!5I!;A9!<B85BJ!5I!;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)!!=,-0O!?6BC>9!5I!;A9!<B85BJ!5I!;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)!!%(!A<F9!B969CF9@!;A9!D9;;9B!LAC6A!1J!+5B@!?9:;!;5!89!65:69B:C:P!;A9!I55@!I5B!;A9!A5B?9?!5I!;A9!-B9<;!3;<>D9!5I!?,(##02(+<2>1(*%e5I!;A9!7*0%Nf!<:@!I5B!;A9!A5B?9?!5I!;A9!-B9<;!3;<>D9!5I!`&2*2?,%(+2>1(*%>9D5:PC:P!;5!;A9!7*0%%*7D;CF<;5B?!5I!;A9!($*'^IC9D@?!5I!"+2,&!%%=,-0O!?6BC>9!5I!;A9!<B85BJ!5I!;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)!!!=,-0O!?6BC>9!5I!;A9!<B85BJ!5I!;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)!!=,-0O!?6BC>9!5I!;A9!<B85BJ!5I!;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)!!=,-0O!?6BC>9!5I!;A9!<B85BJ!5I!;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!

Page 290: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! aa]!

! A)!U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!W_"#2!ED)!WO!b^ak![O!bk!"O!"^ak!"O!WWk!]O!]k!bO!Wk!#O!W`)!!'B<:?D<;C5:2!*<8C:5?!W_b]2!]O!#O!WW^WaO![[)!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!W#VO!:5)!aW[k![bVO!:5)!W#V_)!!

! !

Page 291: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! aab!

T)()aa! ET1!W`[]"!

456789:;!;C;D9! $<EJB7?!%:<?;<?C!((!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!19B9:)O!R)!")!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)!$B<C?9!;5!;A9!49D;<!&9?C@9:69)!

T)!%!D9;;9B!5I!<@7D<;C5:!;5!;A9!$A<B<5A!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)%%WOWG%P.%-(94%,*)%0.&%#*;%;)*%,&%*)'%+*94%%%WOb^aG%"&%;)*%*'<%7*094%*#0'%($%&)'%*%"'%?,2(#2#02(+$2>1(*%%%T)!!bOaG!(%,*)%0.&%#*;%7&;9"0%+%+.$'%+)9'0%+%,-%,*)%0.&%#*;%(+$%(,&'%&)'%*'%?,%$(9#'%%%aOWG%$0%..9'0%*9C%#)+D0E%'&0<%*;%$09C%-'"9'0%(%,-9C%'09C%-+%#.(%(.0'%*%'&0<%*;0%'09C%S+%--%*%(#.+0!

%XC?!1<d9?;J!D)!E)!A)!A<?!>7CD;!<!6<?;D9!LA5?9!:<89!C?!-B9<;^5I^YC6;5BC9?!!'A9!6<?;D9!LAC6A!C?!LC;AC:!AC?!7*0%;A9!MC:P!C?!DCM9!;A9!A5BCZ5:!5I!A9<F9:!5I!;A9!?MJ!5I!&<89?9?!>9D5F9@!5I!%87:!!!(:!DCI9O!EB5?E9B!<:@!A9<D;A)!'AC?!D9;;9B!C?!I5B!;A9!C:I5B8<;C5:!5I!;A9!MC:P!5I!;A9%,-I%D)!E)!A)O!>9D5F9@!5I!1<n<;O!;A9!A5BCZ5:!C:!LAC6A!&<!C?!!R57!=;A9!$A<B<5AG!B9I9B!;A9!65:@C;C5:!5I!9F9BJ!657:;BJ!LACD9!J57!B9?;!C:!J57B!,-%J57!A9<B!;A9!?E996A!5I!<DD!657:;BC9?O!J57!E5??9??9?!8CDDC5:?!5I!J9<B?!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!W_"#2!WO!b!<:@!_^W`)!'B<:?D<;C5:2!*<8C:5?!W_b]2!bOak!bOW`)!!

! !

Page 292: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! aaa!

T)()a#! ET1!W`[]a!

456789:;!;C;D9! $<EJB7?!%:<?;<?C!(((!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!19B9:)O!R)!")!

49?6BCE;C5:! &9E5B;!5:!;A9!49D;<!&9?C@9:69!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

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bG%,;0%*%'&%..%_*7(&%."-0%.'0%.&;0%*%,'%)'%$+"%%[OaG%*.(%O&2*2O('%$0%$'$%-+%;$'%0.<%*%!%*%7*0%(%#!*%;.$*0%%%[O#G%*%@+2*'%;+<0%!;*0%-+%;S0%*%M7+'2($2*'%%[OVG%,.0%*%8a+2*':%*%`,<2*'%70'*0%*%-&'2,%*0<%"&%.D&E;%,&%*)'0%"&%!%%%[O_G%@+2*'%S+%-(&'%M&2!2@+%S+%-#(*%*&<94%,-,0%-+%0.$%(D$E*$%"&%-0%%%[OW`G%C&0%(94%7+0%*;%+!0'%-(#'%(%7*094%**%..D9'0E%*94%-*+%!+$0%$(9#'%($%,&0%%%

!

'A9!?6BC>9!M&<;#%PB99;?!AC?!+5B@O!;A9!?6BC>9!>1(*2$"'9%(:!DCI9O!EB5?E9BC;J!<:@!A9<D;A)!'AC?!D9;;9B!C?!I5B!!

1J!+5B@Q?!C:I5B8<;C5:)!%:5;A9B!89??<P9!;5!

1J!+5B@!;5!;A9!9II96;!;A<;!(!<BBCF9@!<;!"+2?,2=##02(+$2>1(*I%D)!E)!A)!<:@!I57:@!!C;!C:!e9K;B989DJf!P55@!65:@C;C5:)!%!IC:9!

@C?;BC6;!LA5?9!DCM9!9KC?;?!:5;^A<FC:P!;A9!D<J^

57;!=(%#*'%*G!5I!'A9>9?)!(;!L<?!e&<!LA5!I57:@9@!C;f!AC8?9DI)!'A9!7*0!ED9<?<:;!;5!DCF9!C:2!C;?!657:;BJ?C@9!C?!I7DD!5I!9F9BJ;AC:P!P55@O!

<:@!C;!A<?!I55@?!<:@!FC6;7<D?!9F9BJ!@<J)!(;?!

E5:@?!A<F9!IC?A9?O!C;?!E55D?!A<F9!!

>CB@?)!(;?!89<@5L?!<B9!F9B@<:;!LC;A!A9B><P92!

;A9!$&.#^ED<:;!C?!<!67>C;!<:@!A<DI!=ACPAGO!<:@!;A9!6<B5>!C?!DCM9!;A9!;<?;9!!

5I!A5:9J!C:!;A9!@<8E!?5CD)!(;?!PB<:<BC9?!<B9!

I7DD!5I!><B9DJ!<:@!9889Bk!;A9J!@B<L!:9<B!;5!

;A9!?MJ)!,:C5:?!<:@!D99M?!

5B!;A9!'+^D9;;769!5I!;A9!PB5F9k!E589PB<:<;9?O!

<EED9?!!<:@!5DCF9?k!ICP?!5I!;A9!5B6A<B@O!<:@!!

89DD5L!LC:9!5I!N<:M989!=O&2*2O('G!?7BE<??C:P!A5:9J)!&9@!0.<^IC?A!5I!;A9!D<M9!5I!;A9!7*0!=;A<;!DCF9?G!5:!D5;7?!ID5L9Bk!;.$*^IC?A!!5I!;A9!@+^L<;9B?O!;+<^IC?A!;5P9;A9B!LC;A!;S^IC?A!=<:@G))*^IC?A!5I!;A9!M7+'^L<;9B?O!!!,.0^IC?A!5I!;A9!e@))L<;9B?f!5I!T<<DO!70'*^IC?A!5I!;A9!BCF9B!857;A!;A9!ICP^;B99!=qG5I!-B9<;!5I!

YC6;5BC9?!D,&%*)'0G)!!'A9!L<;9B?!5I!X5B7?!A<F9!?<D;!<:@!;A9!M&2!2@+2L<;9B?!:<;B5:)!(;?!?ACE?!?<CD!I5B;A!<:@!855B!=?5!;A<;G!I55@!<:@!FC6;7<D?!<B9!C:!C;!

9F9BJ!@<J)!g5J!@L9DD?!C:!AC?!7*0O!<:@!:5!5:9!?<J?!oS57D@!;A<;!=(!A<@�G!7:;5!C;)!'A9!?8<DD!C:!

C;!<B9!DCM9!!

Page 293: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! aa#!

[OWWG%(<%*%$+$%*94%*&<94%-;94%*0%"'%-*,%*&<94%'"2'+0%-.!

;A9!PB9<;)!*589O!D9;!7?!69D9>B<;9!I5B!C;!C;?!

I9?;CF<D?!5I!A9<F9:!<:@!C;?!6<D9:@<B!I9?;CF<D?)!!

!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!W_"#2!WOWW)!!'B<:?D<;C5:2!*<8C:5?!W_b]2!WOWW)!!

! !

Page 294: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! aaV!

T)()aV! ET1!W`[]a>!

456789:;!;C;D9! $<EJB7?!%:<?;<?C!(((!V6+#U!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!19B9:)O!R)!")!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)!396;C5:!W)!/:;BJ!5I!<!>55M!5I!<6657:;?)!

T)!396;C5:!")!/K;B<6;?!IB58!;A9!d57B:<D!5I!<!>5B@9B!5IIC6C<D!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)!WOWG!!#"%(%$*<'%(%899:%"+2*#0'%@+2"+%,*)%0.&%#*;%(%$*0%*%$(<2+%!T)!!bOV^_G%'#$%*%>1*020&0%C.*%*%"&%$-%"+2,&%*%`&2?,2(+<%>1(*%7*<%Dp7*0E!

%&969CFC:P!LA<;!L<?!>B57PA;!IB58!=qG!e))f!;A9!"+2*#0'!D)!E)!A)!<?!<!;BC>7;9!5I!;A9!?;9L<B@!%%-5C:P!7E!>J>1*020&0O!6A<BC5;99B!5I!;A9!-B9<;!3;<>D9!5I!;A9!$A<B<5A!5I!`&2?,2(+<%>1(*!D)!E)!A)!5I!;A9!7*0!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!W_"#2!WOWk!bOV^_)!!'B<:?D<;C5:2!*<8C:5?!W_b]2!W`]^bk!W`V^_)!!

! !

Page 295: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! aa_!

T)()a_! E3<DDC9B!(!

456789:;!;C;D9! $<EJB7?!3<DDC9B!(!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!19B9:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)!(:?;B76;C5:?!<?!;5!@9DCF9BC9?!5I!6<;;D9!<:@!I<B8!EB5@769)!

T)!%!B9E5B;!<>57;!<PBC67D;7B<D!8<;;9B?)!

*)!*58ED<C:;!<>57;!;A9!;<MC:P!<L<J!5I!69B;<C:!IC9D@?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!%)!"Ob^]OW^bO]^bOW`^aO_^#O_^VO[^VO#^_O_G!-+<%#&0%#!0%*%"+2-.%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;!!]O[G!$$+9$%7&;%(%7&;%+%..%$(%(<%$*0'%(*-'%0*9*%'&<9$%!,'%-+%#"+%+9C%$09C%-+%+.$%$*0'%0,%*%(*-'%*4+'%DlIYE%(%$;0%,*%,*)0'%#-0'%&".%"&%-+%#(0%*'<%$09#*%+%*&%0#)0'%"+2*#0'%@+2"+%,*)%0.&%#*;!!!*)!_OWG!-+<%#&0%#!0%>1(*2(2$*0'%*%"+2-.%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%..%*%#!%M*2'&20+'%+*'%+%$*0'%*9C%#!%"*%*%..%DkIKE%-*,%..%+*'%#($%*%*%-+<%$-0%>1(*2(0$&%#&%>1(*2(2$"'%*%"&%$-0%,&%*%?,2(##02(+$2>1(*%,*)%0.&%#*;%*%7*0%!!!!_ObG!-+<%$-0%>1(*2(0$&%#&%>1(*2(2$"'%*%"&%$-0%,&%*%?,2(##02(+$2>1(*%,*)%0.&%#*;%*%7*0%&#%&#%(%'&%0*0'%DkILE%"&%($''%#"+%+9'*%$09'*%$09'*%.S#%*94%&-'%"+<%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%#0'%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%,-,*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%DkIcE%#0'%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%($*'2'&0%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;I%!(02'&0%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%+*($'2'&0%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%,*<'2'&0%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%$0%*-&%(%#'%DkIqE%*;%&;$094!!!!

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

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!W_"#2!#_2_k!V`2!"O!a^VO!W]k!V[2bk!V"2"O]k!Vb2#k!Vb2Wbk!Va2W`k!V#2b^#k!

Page 296: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a#`!

V#OW`^Wbk!VV2")!'B<:?D<;C5:2!*<8C:5?!W_b]2!"`]^bO!"`#O!"W[O!"WbO!"W#O!"W_O!"[WO!"["O!"[aO!"[_)!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!]`"O!:5)!W"a")!!

! !

Page 297: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a#W!

T)()#`! E%:<?;<?C!Y!

456789:;!;C;D9! $<EJB7?!%:<?;<?C!Y!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!39;J!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)!/:\7CBC9?!LC;A!B9P<B@!;5!;L5!B7:<L<J!?D<F9?!

T)! +9;;9B! 65:69B:C:P! ;A9! ;B<:?E5B;! <:@! 9B96;C5:! 5I! ;AB99!

?;9D<9!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!W_O]G!'09$%-+%..9*9DAkIQE%"&%?,2@+2&)'%##*;%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%"&<9*%*;%@+%,*)%0.&%#*;%*4+%$(%(<%$+$94%--0%*%-;#'%7+0%DAkILE%*;%$09*%-#'94%(%(*'%(%*&%0#)'%"+2*#0'%@+2"+%,*)%0.&%#*;%(%Y%$&-%G*0%k%7+0!!![]ObH[bO[G!0;&%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%!

!(!?<J!;5!&<^X<B<MA;92!M99E!;A9!$A<B<5A!D)!E)!A)O!57B!P55@!+5B@!D)!E)!A)!C:!A9<D;A)!+9;!AC8!69D9>B<;9!8CDDC5:?!5I!d7>CD99?!<:@!8<J!L9!>9!C:!I<F5B!@<CDJ)!c7B;A9B!(!?9;!I5B;A!IB58!;A9!>B5<@!A<DD!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'!D)!E)!A)!C:!;A9!;ACB@!85:;A!5I!G*0O!@<J!:C:9!!!T7;D9B!5I!;A9!$A<B<5AO!D)!E)!A)!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!W_"#2!#`O!Wk!#`O!W`)!'B<:?D<;C5:2!*<8C:5?!W_b]2![bb)!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2![[]O!:5)!##V)!!

! !

Page 298: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a#[!

T)()#W! ET1W`[]b!

456789:;!;C;D9! $<EJB7?!%:<?;<?C!Y()!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!39;J!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)!396;C5:!W2!5E9:C:P!EB5;565D!

T)!396;C5:![2!<!D9;;9B!5I!658ED<C:;?!

4)!&9E5B;!;5!<!?7E9BC5B!5:!F<BC57?!>7?C:9??!8<;;9B?!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)!!D)!]G!(%"*%7+0%$09'0%(%M+2?,(##02(+<2>1(*%,*)%0.&%#*;%D)!bG%"&%C&%,&%*%M&2?,2@+2&)'<%"+2*#0'%,*)%#*;%*4+%*%--%*%-;28#.:!D)!aG%-+%$+%-#<%>1(*%*%M+2?,(##02(+<2>1(*%,*)%0.&%#*;%!T)!D)!"#G!-+<%#&0%#!0%*%"+2-.%*%%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%!D)!]#G!#!%*%$(<2+%"+2-.%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%!!4)!DD)!a]^abG!($%"&%*'+%-'"0%*%>1(*2?,%8@+%*'+099:%*;%W#+%*'<%-'+%"&%"+2-.%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%(&,'%!!!D)!V[G!"+2-.%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%!

!,:!;AC?!@<J!;A9!MC:P!L<?!C:!M+2?,(##02(+<2>1(*O!o;A9!-B9<;!357D!5I!&<^X<B<MA;9rO!;A9!>9<7;CI7D!"+2*#0'!D)!E)!A)!5I!8CDDC5:?!5I!d7>CD99?!@5C:P!;A9!ED9<?7B9!5I!%87:!5I!M+2?,(##02(+<2>1(*O!D)!E)!A)!!!*AC9I!5I!;A9!B965B@^M99E9B?!5I!;A9!'B9<?7BJ!5I!;A9!$A<B<5AO!D)!E)!A)!!36BC>9!5I!;A9!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!;B9<?7BJ!5I!;A9!$A<B<5AO!D)!E)!A)!!!+CM9LC?9! ;A9! @CFC:9! 5II9BC:P?! 5I! %87:^&9!eMC:P! 5I! ;A9! P5@?))fO! +5B@! 5I! 'A9>9?O! >9I5B9!LA58! <:! 5II9BC:P! A<?! >99:! <EE5C:;9@! >J!;A9!'B9<?7BJ!5I!;A9!$A<B<5A!D)!E)!A)!!'B9<?7BJ!5I!;A9!$A<B<5A!D)!E)!A)!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!W_"#2!#[O!W`^W[k!#b)!'B<:?D<;C5:2!*<8C:5?!W_b]2![#_^"``)!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!]`"O!:5)!W"a])!!

! !

Page 299: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a#"!

T)()#[! E%:<?;<?C!(((%!

456789:;!;C;D9! $<EJB7?!%:<?;<?C!(((%)!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!W_;A!4J:<?;J!=:5;!9<BDC9B!;A<:!&<89?9?!((G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! ,@@! ?A99;! 65:;<C:C:P! <! @7EDC6<;9! 5I! $<EJB7?! %:<?;<?C! (Y!

WbOWW^WaO#)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!DD)!]^bG!"&%#%*'<%(%#*%$094%+%*&%0,;'%+%$+$%-*P'%o.<%*%"+2*#0'%@+2"+%,*)%0.&%#*;%#+('%*%'&!,*D'E%"&%#!

!'A5?9!<85:P!;A98!;A<;!<B9!PB5L:!89:!LCDD!P5!;5!;A9!E5?C;C5:^A57?9?%D0,;'E!;5!8<M9!>99B!5I!N9@J!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'!D)!E)!A)!<:@!#(+'2>B9L!5I!;A5?9!LA5!<B9!89:!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!W_"#2!""O!b^#)!'B<:?D<;C5:2!*<8C:5?!W_b]2!W[`)!!

! !

Page 300: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a#]!

T)()#"! $)!X<BBC?!(!

456789:;!;C;D9! $<EJB7?!X<BBC?!()!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!&<8)!((()!!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!$+9*9C%,-%!"#$%*#0'%(%7*09#%%

!(!A<F9!@5:9!<!:5>D9!nÇ!B5J<D!C:?C@9!C;!=;A9!;98ED9G!!

U5;9?2!'A9!9KEB9??C5:! ,-%*#0'%(%7*0%-0'!8<M9?!?CP:CIJ! ;A9!9KC?;9:69!5I!<!oB5J<D!E<D<69r!>7CD;!C:?C@9!;A9!I7:9B<BJ!;98ED9!C;?9DI)!!!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!$7CDD9;!WV_a2!Waa^W#a)!c5B!$<EJB7?!X<BBC?!?992!T7@P9!W_["2!ED)!(((O!W)WW^YO!W)")!!

! !

Page 301: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a#b!

T)()#]! ET1!W``b"!

456789:;!;C;D9! $<EJB7?!T1!W``b"!+6T'U9!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!&<8)!(0O!R)!W#O!@<J!V)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'A9! ;9K;!5I! ;A9! B96;5!65:?C?;?!5I!9CPA;!E<P9?!5B! 65D78:?)! (;!65:;<C:?! ;A9! @9E5?C;C5:?! 5I! 9CPA;! ;AC9F9?! B9P<B@C:P! ;A9CB!@C?E5?<D! 5I! 69B;<C:! 5>d96;?! 5B! \7<:;C;C9?! 5I! 65EE9B! ?;5D9:!IB58! ;A9! Y<DD9J! 5I! ;A9! l799:?! IB58! <! ;58>! LAC6A! C?! :5;!?E96CIC9@)! 'A9?9! @9E5?C;C5:?! <B9! ?;<;9@! ;5! A<F9! >99:! E7;!C:;5!LBC;C:P!I5B!;A9!<??C?;<:69!5I!;A9!EBC:69!5I!;A9!S9?;!$É^LB^n! <:@! 69B;<C:! 5;A9B! 5IIC6C<D?! 5I! ;A9! U96B5E5DC?! C:! ;A9!B965F9BJ!5I!;A9!?;5D9:!EB5E9B;J)!/<6A!DC?;?!65:?C?;?!5I!<!?9BC9?!5I!:<89?!5I!E9B?5:?!>9<BC:P!F<BC57?!;C;D9?O!<:@!9<6A!:<89!C?!I5DD5L9@!>J!<!\7<:;C;J!5I!65EE9B!9KEB9??9@!C:!.6;6*)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!$<P9!WO!D)!WWG%#!%*%7*0%%$<P9!]O!D)!WG%#!%*%"&%"+%*%"+2,&%!!

!36BC>9!5I!;A9!7*0!!36BC>9!5I!;A9!A57?9!5I!;A9!$A<B<5A!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$99;!W_"`2!(O!W`[^W`_k!((O!ED)!0Y((()!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!b[VO!:5)!W#V#)!!

! !

Page 302: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a#a!

T)()#b! E'7BC:!

W_"`H[`b`s[`W"!

456789:;!;C;D9! $<EJB7?!'7BC:!*<;!W_"`H[`b`s[`W")!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!&<8)!(0O!R)!a^#)!

49?6BCE;C5:! g57B:<D!5I!B<;C5:?)!

%)!&96;5!5I!E[`W"!

T)!&96;5!5I!EW_"`s[`b`!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)!D)!bG%#!0%"&%!*0'<%*%"+2,&%%T)![O_G!"&%'&'<%)0%*%"+2,&!$(<2+%!*0'<%*%"+2,&%!!

!36BC>9?!5I!;A9!PB<:<BC9?!5I!;A9!$A<B<5A!!!YCZC9BO!I<:^>9<B9B!5I!;A9!$A<B<5AO!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!PB<:<BC9?!5I!;A9!$A<B<5A!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!N&(!Y(2!a`WO!bk!a`WO!Wa)!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!W"WO!:5)!]"`)!!

! !

Page 303: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a##!

T)()#a! ET1!W`[[W!

456789:;!;C;D9! $<EJB7?!%>>5;)!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!&<8)!(0)!

49?6BCE;C5:! $<EJB7?! %>>5;! B965B@?! <:! C:?E96;C5:! 5I! ;58>?O! B5J<D! <:@!

5;A9BLC?9O! EB58E;9@! >J! B9E5B;?! 5I! ED7:@9BC:PO! ;5P9;A9B!

LC;A! 69B;<C:! 9F9:;?! <BC?C:P! 57;! 5I! ;AC?! C:?E96;C5:! <:@!

C:F5DFC:P! F<BC57?! 'A9><:! 5IIC6C<D?! <:@! ;A9! ?;<II! 5I! ;A9!

U96B5E5DC?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!(!"G%#!%*%"&%$(<2+%"+0<%-.%*D'E%"+2,&%%*)%0.&%#*;!!(!ak!((!aG!0-(0%*%"+2,&!!(!#^VG%-&'<2,%=.&<0%"&%(%0+%,&%*%"&%(%)+%,&%!"#$%%8*%--%*%+*"0'%*:%"+2,&%*)%0.&%#*;%8-+:%$(*''%0&#'%%(!b^ak!((!bk!(Y!#!<:@!W[k!Y!W[^W"!<:@![Wk!Y((!]!<:@!_G!#!%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%(((!bOW]G!0;&%*%"+2,&%!

!36BC>9!5I!;A9!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!@57>D9!;B9<?7BJ!5I!;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)!!X9B<D@!5I!;A9!"+2,&!!$BC:69!5I!=.&<0O!5I!;A9!-B9<;!<:@!U5>D9!:96B5E5DC?!I5B!8CDDC5:!J9<B?!5I!;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)O%C:!;A9!S9?;9B:!'A9>9?!!36BC>9!5I!;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)!!!T7;D9B!5I!;A9!"+2,&!

U5;9?2!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!$99;!W_"`O!((2!ED)!(^(Y)!!X9D6M!W_bV2!b[`O!b"[)!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!'B<:?D<;C5:2!$99;!W_[b2!"#^"V)!$99;!W_"`O!(2![V^][)!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!b[VO!:5)!W#Vak!b"[k!b"[O!:5)!W#__)!!

!

! !

Page 304: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a#V!

T)()##! 17?{9?!

&5J<7K! @Q%B;!

9;! @QXC?;5CB9!!

@7!

*C:\7<:;9:<CB9!!

456789:;!;C;D9! $<EJB7?!+95E5D@!((!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!&<8)!(0)!

49?6BCE;C5:! XC9B<;C6! E<EJB7?! 65:;<C:9@! C:! ;A9! 6<FC;J! 5I! <! I7:9B<BJ!

L55@9:! ?;<;79;;9! LC;A! <! E<C:;9@! C:?6BCE;C5:! PCFC:P! ;A9!

:<89!5I!O&<O! ?7E9BC:;9:@9:;!5I!L5BM?!<:@!B5J<D! ?6BC>9! C:!;A9!;98ED9!5I!;A9!MC:PO!>B57PA;!IB58!;A9!Y<DD9J!5I!;A9!UCD9!

>J!;A9!47M9!5I!TB<><:;O!;A9!I7;7B9!+95E5D@!(()!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!(!]G!-+<%(.&%0,&%*%"&%)+%,&%!"#<%*%--%*%+*"0'%*%"+2,&!!(!bk!((!WbG!#!%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%!(!W]G%-&'<2,%=.&<0%*%"&%)+%,&%!"#$%8*%--%*%+*"0'%*:%"+2,&%%,*)%0.&%#*;%-+%$(*''%0&#'%%

!-B9<;!6AC9I!5I!E5DC69!5I!;A9!PB9<;!<:@!:5>D9!:96B5E5DC?!5I!8CDDC5:?!5I!J9<B?!5I!"+2,&!!36BC>9!5I!;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)!!$BC:69!5I!=.&<0O!5I!;A9!-B9<;!<:@!U5>D9!:96B5E5DC?!I5B!8CDDC5:!J9<B?!5I!;A9%"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)O!C:!;A9!S9?;9B:!'A9>9?!%

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!X9D6M!W_bV2!b"[)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!*<E<B;!h!-<B@C:9B!h!F<:!@9!S<DD9!W_"a2!Wa_^_"O!ED)!W`^Wa)!!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!"_]O!:5)!W"[])!!

! !

Page 305: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a#_!

T)()#V! E'7BC:![`#]!

456789:;!;C;D9! $<EJB7?!'7BC:![`#])!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!&<8)?!(0O!R)!V)!

49?6BCE;C5:! g57B:<D!5I!L5BM!DC?;C:P!?9F9B<D!5IIC6C<D?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

"[2WO![2[O![2bk![2aG!;-C%(%"&%)+%*%"+2,&!!

!39BF<:;!C:!;A9!:96B5E5DC?!5I!;A9!"+2,&!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!N&(!Y(2!a`VO!W[O!W]k!a`_O!W^[)!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2![abO!:5)!_W#)!!

! !

Page 306: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! aV`!

T)()#_! +5B@!%8A9B?;!

*5DD)!Y(!

456789:;!;C;D9! $<EJB7?!%8A9B?;)!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!&<8)!(0)!

49?6BCE;C5:! (;Q?!<!AC9B<;C6!E<EJB7?!I5B89BDJ!C:!;A9!65DD96;C5:!5I!'A9!&CPA;!

X5:)! +5B@!%8A9B?;!5I!X<6M:9J!<:@!>9<BC:P! ;A9!:78>9B!Y(!

<85:P! ;A9! /PJE;C<:! E<EJBC! IB58! ;A<;! 65DD96;C5:)! 'A9!

E<EJB7?! C?!<;!;A9!EB9?9:;! C:!<!E<6MC:P!6<?9! C:!;A9! DC>B<BJ!5I!

1B)! $C9BE5:;! 15BP<:! C:! U9L! R5BM)! (:! 65:;<C:?! ;A9!

65:I9??C5:!5I!<!;AC9IO!LA5?9!:<89!C?!D5?;)!'A9!;CD9!<EE9<B?!C:!

;A9!DC?;!5I!E<P9!"!LC;A!;A9!:<89?!5I!9CPA;!89:!LA5!L9B9!C:!

;A9! B5>>9@! ;58>! <:@!L9B9! ;<M9:! ;5! C@9:;CIJ! ;A9! ?69:9! 5I!

;A9!6BC89)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!(((!!#G%#!%(%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%

!36BC>9!5I!;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!X9D6M!W_bV2!b[`)!!$99;!W_"`O!(2!]b^bWk!((2!ED)!(Y^Y)!!

! !

Page 307: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! aVW!

T)()V`! ET1!W``b[!

456789:;!;C;D9! $<EJB7?!T1W``b[!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!&<8)!0(!=qG)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'AC?!E<EJB7?!T)1)!W``b[!C?!<!E7ZZDC:P!@56789:;!;A<;!B9E5B;?!

;A9! I<6;?! @9<DC:P!LC;A! [! PB57E?!5I! ;A9I;?)! 'C;D9?! B9I9BB9@! ;5!

;A9!5IIC6C<D?!C:F5DF9@!C:!;A9!C:?E96;C5:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!(!]k!0!WVII)G!$(<2+%"+2-.%"+2,&%%,*)%0.&%#*;%$(<2+%!*0'<99$(<2+%"+2*#0'%%%(!bG%#!%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%#+<'%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%$(<2+%"+2*#0'%%(Y!WG!$(<2+%%"+2-.%"+2,&%%,*)%0.&%#*;%$(<2+%%!*0'<%*#0'%

!,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!;B9<?7BJ!5I!;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)O!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!;L5!-B<:<BC9?!))5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'%!36BC>9!5I!;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)O!I<:^>9<B9B!5I!;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)O%5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'%%,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!;B9<?7BJ!5I!;A9!"+2,&%I%D)!E)!A)O!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!;L5!B5J<D!-B<:<BC9?!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!X9D6M!W_bV2!b`b)!!$99;!W_"`O!((2!ED)![b)!!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!'B<:?D<;C5:2!$99;!W_"`O!(2!W"b^W#W)!!

! !

Page 308: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! aV[!

T)()VW! ET1!W``b]!

456789:;!;C;D9! $<EJB7?!T1!W``b]!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!&<8)!0()!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'AC?! E<EJB7?! >9<B?! ?9F9B<D! 7:65::96;9@! ;9K;?! 65:;<C:C:P!

@CII9B9:;!65:I9??C5:?!5I!;AC9F9?!5I!&<89??C@!;58>?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!(!"G!#!%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%

!36BC>9!5I!;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)!

U5;9?2!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!$99;!W_"`O!((2!ED)!Y(()!X9D6M!W_bV2!b[`)!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!'B<:?D<;C5:2!$99;!W_"`O!(2!b[^a")!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!b"[O!:5)!W#__)!!

! !

Page 309: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! aV"!

T)()V[! ET1!W`"V"!

456789:;!;C;D9! $<EJB7?!T1!W`"V"!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!&<89?9?!0()!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'A9!E<EJB7?!@9?6BC>9?!<! ?9BC9?!5I! C:F9?;CP<;C5:?! 65:69B:C:P!

;A9! ?;9<DC:P! 5I! ?CDF9B! <:@! P5D@! IB58! &<89??C@! ;58>?)!1B?)!

T7BPA! EB9?9:;9@! C;! ;5! ;A9! TBC;C?A! 17?978! C:! WVbaO!

<EE<B9:;DJ!LC;A57;!<:J!B965B@!5I!C;?!9<BDC9?;!AC?;5BJ)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!(!"k!((!bG!$(<2+%"+0<2-.%"+%*%"+2,&%%,*)%0.&%#*;%$(<2+%!*00'<%*#0%%((!]^bG%-('%*%(%#;&0<%*%"&%"+%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%D99E%$(<2+%"&%"+%*%"+2,&%%,*)%0.&%#*;%D99E%"+$9$%(%"&%(%"+%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%

!,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!@57>D9!;B9<?7BJ!5I!;A9!"+2>&I%D)!E)!A)O!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!;L5!B5J<D!-B<:<BC9?!!*5EE9B!>9D5:PC:P!;5!;A9!@55B?!5I!;A9!A57?9!5I!;A9!"+2>&I%D)!E)!A)!=))G!(!9:;9B!C:!;A9!A57?9!5I!;A9!"+2,&%I%D)!E)!A)!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!X9D6M!W_bV2!b`b)!$99;!W_"`O!((2!ED)!00(()!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!$99;!W_"`O!(2!W[[^W[#)!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!"WO!:5)!W`")!!X9D6M!W_bV2!b`b)!!

! !

Page 310: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! aV]!

T)()V"! E'7BC:!

WV_as[``a!

456789:;!;C;D9! '7BC:!'<K<;C5:!$<EJB7?O!+6T'U!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!&<8)!0(O!R)!W[)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'A9! ;9K;! 5I! ;A9! +6T'UO! @<;9@! C:! R9<B! W[! 5I! &<89?9?! 0(!

65:69B:?! ;A9! B969CE;?! 5I! 65B:! IB58! F<BC57?! ;5L:?! ;5! ;A9!

?57;A!5I!'A9>9?O!;A9CB!;B<:?E5B;!;5!;A9!?57;A9B:!6<EC;<D!<:@!

;A9CB!@9DCF9BJ! C:;5! ;A9!<EE5C:;9@!PB<:<BC9?)!'A9!E9B?5:<P9!

B9?E5:?C>D9!I5B!;A9?9!EB5699@C:P?!L<?!;A9!?6BC>9!\-0'<2(#9!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

"WO"G!-&'<0%*%*&%".'%"+2,&!!!

!*<E;<C:!5I!;A9!;B55E?!5I!;A9!"+2,&!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!W__b2!"aO")!$D9J;9!h!&5??C!WVa_^WV#ak!ED?)!+0Y)*)*+(Y^*+Y((()!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!"W"O!:5)!W`b#)!! !

Page 311: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! aVb!

T)()V]! E'7BC:!T!

456789:;!;C;D9! $<EJB7?!'7BC:!T)!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!W_;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! %!D9;;9B!IB58!;L5!B5J<D!?6BC>9?!;5!;A9CB!?7E9BC5B!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!F?)![O[G!#!%!,'%*%"+2,&!!

!+9;;9B!LBC;9B!5I!;A9!"+2,&!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!W_"#2!W[aO!b)!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!b#bO!:5)!W_[_)!!

! !

Page 312: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! aVa!

T)()Vb! +CF9BE55D!

17?978!!

1)!WWWa[!

1)!WWWVa!

456789:;!;C;D9! $<EJB7?!1<J9B!%!<:@!T)!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 'A9>9?)!+<;9!W_;A!4J:)!h![`;A!4J:)!=qG!

49?6BCE;C5:! $<EJBC!65:69B:C:P!;A9!;58>^B5>>9BC9?!5I!;A9!D<;9!&<89??C@!

E9BC5@!<;!'A9>9?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!%!aG!$(<2+%"+2*#0'!!%!W"O!T!"G!$(<2+%!*0'<%*%!*00'%*D'E%"+2,&%%,*)%0.&%#*;%

!,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'!!,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!;L5!PB<:<BC9?!5I!;A9!-B<:<BC9?!5I!;A9!"+2>&I%D)!E)!A)!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;9K;2!X9D6M!W_bV2!b`b)!!$99;!W_[`2!$<EJB7?!1<J9B!%!W"O!T"k!]O!b)!!!

! !

Page 313: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! aV#!

T)()Va! E'7BC:%!

456789:;!;C;D9! $<EJB7?!'7BC:!%)!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!+<;9!W_;A!4J:)!h![`;A!4J:)!=qG!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)!396;C5:!W2!C:?;B76;C5:?!65:69B:C:P!?589!EB569@7B9!

T)!396;C5:!]2!EB5;9?;!<P<C:?;!;A9!65:?6BCE;C5:!5I!69B;<C:!89:!

I5B!I5B69@!D<>5B!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

T)![OW`G!-+<%#&0%#!0%*%'&%#'%'&%!*0'%"+2,&%(%=*2*4+!!"OW`G!"-%*&%0#)'%"+2*#0'!@+2"+%,*)%0.&%#*;%#0%($%'&%.*%7&%*'%*0%"&%(2,%*0<'%,P&%0*%0,%,*)0%$0%)&%-+%(D0E'%%!]O[G!0,%-+<%$-0%0,%!(#0%"+2,&!,*)%0.&%#*;899:%DlIYE%;*%(*'C%$$9C%-*0%#*%*%8=*2*4+:%!!

!'A9! 6AC9I! 5I! ;A9! B965B@^M99E9B! 5I! ;A9! 5IIC69!5I!;A9!PB<:<BJ!5I!$A<B<5A!C:!198EAC?!!SA5!B9<6A9?!;A9!>B5<@!A<DD!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'! D)!E)!A)!A9!C?!9K<6;DJ!DCM9!;A9!L9<F9?!5I!;A9!?9<O!5:9!B98<C:?!<DCF9!LACD9!<!;A57?<:@!@C9!!(;!C?!<!?;<>D9^8<?;9BO!5B!<!B9;<C:9B!5I!$A<B<5A!D)! E)! A)! e))f! LA5! <D5:9! 6588<:@99B?! ;A9!87D;C;7@9!5I!L5BM9B?!eLA5!<B9!C:!198EAC?f!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!W_"#2!W["O!W`k!W[]O!_^W`)!'B<:?D<;C5:2!*<8C:5?!W_b]2!]]_O!]#")!!

! !

Page 314: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! aVV!

T)()V#! E-BCIIC;A!

456789:;!;C;D9! $<EJB7?!-BCIIC;A)!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 'A9>9?!=qG)!W_;A^[`;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

"D)!WG%#!%*%"+%)+%,&%!"#%--%+*"0'%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%!

!36BC>9!5I!;A9!PB9<;!<:@!:5>D9!U96B5E5DC?!5I!8CDDC5:!J9<B?!5I!$A<B<5A!D)!E)!A)!!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!y9B:J!W_"_2!W[2W)!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!b##O!:5)!W_"[)!!

! !

Page 315: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! aV_!

T)()VV! E+<:?C:P!

456789:;!;C;D9! $<EJB7?!+<:?C:P)!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)![`;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 396;C5:!W`2!;C;D9?!5I!<!B5J<D!?6BC>9!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!_O]G%($%D#..9$E%*9C%#(+0%DkIQE%0,0%($%-D*E'<094%*&<94%$-0%"&%$(<2+%(!,%"&%-+<%".0'%"&%#C'%*'<%-&'<2,%#*%"&%'&<2#+<'%DkILE%).*0%D*%"&%(!,E%"&%#!%"&%,&%D*E%.$<0%"&%-+<%$0,'<%$0%-+%,P%#"+%*%*&<%0#)'%"+2*#0'%@+2"+%,*)%0.&%#*;%!

!*589! =D9;! 89! @9?6BC>9G! ;5! J57! L59?! 5I! <!?5D@C9B! 9F9:! <?! AC?! ?7E9BC5B?! <B9!8<:J2! ;A9!P9:9B<DO! ;A9! 6<E;<C:! 5I! ;A9! DC97;9:<:;!6588<:@9BO! ;A9! ?6BC>9!5I! ;A9!<B8J! ;A9!#C'^5IIC6C9B!LA5!C?!C:!IB5:;!5I!;A98O!;A9!?;<:@<B@^>9<B9BO! ;A9! DC97;9:<:;! 6588<:@9BO! ;A9!?6BC>9! 5I! ;A9! <B8JO! ;A9! 6588<:@9B! 5I! ICI;J!89:O! <:@! ;A9! P<BBC?5:^6<E;<C:)! 'A9J! P5! C:!<:@!57;!5I!;A9!TB5<@!X<DD!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'!D)!E)!A)!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!W_"#2!W`#2!Wb^WVk!W`_OW^[)!!'B<:?D<;C5:2!*<8C:5?!W_b]2!]``)!!

! !

Page 316: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a_`!

T)()V_! E'7BC:!*-'!

b]`bW!

456789:;!;C;D9! $<EJB7?!'7BC:!*-'!b]`bW!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)![`;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 1<PC6!E<EJB7?!IB58!;A9!17?978!5I!'7BC:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%F'+0%(%,-%%%

!'A9!P5@?!C:!;A9!,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;9K;2!+9C;Z![``[O!(Y2!]#V)!!$D9J;9!^!&5??C!WVa_^WV#a2!ED)!W"[)!!!

! !

Page 317: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a_W!

!

T)()_`! E)TC>DC5;Ai\79!

U<;C5:<D9! W_aO!

((!

456789:;!;C;D9! $<EJB7?!TC>DC5;Ai\79!U<;C5:<D9!W_aO((!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)![`;A!4J:)!=R)!W`!5I!W-(2(#0'G!

49?6BCE;C5:! +9;;9B! <@@B9??9@! ;5!\-0'<2(#! ;5!`'72,1(*O! ?9BF9@! <?! ;A9!;L5! ?6BC>9?! 5I! ;A9! U96B5E5DC?! 5I! 'A9>9?! @7BC:P! ;A9! [`;A!

4J:<?;J!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%((O!B;)!!W^[G!$+<%*%"+%)+%,&%!"#%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%((O!B;)!!WG!#!%*%"+%)+%,&%!"#%--%+*"0'%*%"+2,&!"!

!-7<B@C<:!5I!;A9!PB9<;!<:@!:5>D9!:96B5E5DC?!5I!$A<B<5AO!D)!E)!A)!!36BC>9!5I!;A9!PB9<;!<:@!:5>D9!U96B5E5DC?!5I!1CDDC5:!R9<B?!5I!$A<B<5A!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!S9:;9!W_a#2!]O!W`)!!y9B:J!W_"_2![WO!W^[)!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!b""O!:5)!WV`")!!

! !

Page 318: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a_[!

T)()_W! Y<BC57?!

456789:;!;C;D9! ,:58<?;C65:!5I!>1(*2(2$"'!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)![W;A^[[;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'A9! ?5^6<DD9@!,:58<?;C65:! 5I! >1(*2(2$"'! C?! M:5L:! >J! :C:9!@CII9B9:;! 8<:7?6BCE;?! LAC6A! 65:;<C:! PB<;9B! 5B! ?8<DD9B!E5B;C5:?! 5I! ;A9! ;9K;k! C;! C?! DCM9! <! DC?;! 5I! <@8C:C?;B<;CF9! <:@!5667E<;C5:<D! ;C;D9?)!'A9!@<;9!LA9:! >1(*2(2$"'! DCF9@!8<J!>9!65:d96;7B9@! ;5!>9! ;A9! F9BJ! 9:@!5I! ;A9![`;A!4J:<?;J! <:@!<DD!;A9!8<:7?6BCE;?!L9!E5??9??!?A5L!I9<;7B9?!<??56C<;C:P!;A98!LC;A!;A9![W;A!5B!;A9![[;A!4J:<?;J)]!'A9!-5D{:C?6A9II!E<EJB7?!<D5:9!A<?!EB9;9:?C5:?!;5!<!:9<BDJ!658ED9;9!;9K;O!;A9!B9?;!5I!;A9!;9K;?!65:;<C:?!IB<6;C5:?!5I!C;2!$)!X5@@!=TBC;)!17?)!W`[`[GO!;A9! ?;BCE! 5I! D9<;A9B! TBC;)! 17?)! W`"#_O! ;A9! &<89??978!E<EJB7?!IB<P89:;?O!;A9!*<CB5!5?;B<65:!g)!a#W``O!;A9!L55@9:!LBC;C:P^>5<B@! TBC;)! 17?)! [Wa"bO! ;A9! $)! T57D<\! (Y! <:@! <!IB<P89:;<BJ!E5;?A9B@!IB58!;A9!&<89??978)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%#!%*#0%(%7*0%"+2*#0'A%%$(<2+%"+2*#0'K%%$(<2+%,7*0'<%*%"+2*#0'Y%%

!

&5J<D!?6BC>9!5I!;A9!7*0!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'%!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'!!

*A<8>9BD<C:!!5B!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!C:;9BC5B!5I!

"+2*#0'%!

U5;9?2!!W)!$<EJB7?!X5@@O!TBC;)!17?)!W`[`[O!;LC69!C:!;A9!?;BCE!5I!+9<;A9B!TBC;)!17?)!W`"#_![)!?;BCE!5I!D9<;A9B!TBC;)!17?)!W`"#_)![)! -5D{:C?6A9II! E<EJB7?O! $<EJB7?! X5@@! =TBC;)! 17?)! W`[`[GO! ?;BCE! 5I! D9<;A9B! =TBC;)! 17?)!W`"#_G)!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'B<:?D<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!W_]#2![]O!Vbk![ak!_"k!]]O!W[")!!!

! !

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"!#$%&'()%!*+",-!."/.01!

Page 319: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a_"!

T)(()W! +57FB9!*!]_!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!?;9D9!5I!$,-!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!W#;A!4J:)!=qG!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)![G%(*%(+'%(%"+2*#0'%*;%-#0%(%#'"2#&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%!

!

cCB8!5I!D5F9!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'O!+5B@!5I!EB<C?9?HI<F5B?!C:!;A9!#'"2#&%D)!E)!A)!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!.&N!(Y2![W#`O!W`)!

!

! !

Page 320: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a_]!

T)(()[! /DM<>!W!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!>1&-2(#2F);'%C:!AC?!;58>!<;!/DM<>%

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! /DM<>)!W#;A!4J:<?;Jq!

49?6BCE;C5:! %) TC5PB<EAC6<D!C:?6BCE;C5:)!!

T) &9E5B;! 5:! ;A9! B9L<B@?! B969CF9@! >J! >1&-2(#2F);'%@7BC:P!AC?!6<B99B!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)!

D)!"G%$0%(+0'9$%(%#'"2#&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%T)!

D)![G%(*%(+'%(%"+2*#0'%*;%-#0%(%#'"2#&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%

!

(!L<?!5:9!>9D5F9@!C:!;A9!#'"2#&I%D)!E)!A)!!

!

cCB8!5I!D5F9!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'I%+5B@!5I!EB<C?9?HI<F5B?!C:!;A9!#'"2#&I%D)!E)!A)!

U5;9?2!!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!.&N!(Y2!"]O!W]k!"VO!]^b)!

+9E?C7?!W_#"2!'9K;!(Y2!]a)!

!

! !

Page 321: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a_b!

T)(()"! ''![]!

456789:;!;C;D9! 'A9><:!;58>!5I!;A9!B5J<D!?;9L<B@!F;2>1(*!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 'A9>9?)!'A7;)!(^(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!?57;A9B:!L<DD!5I!;A9!;58>)!

T)! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!?;9D9!6<BF9@!5:!;A9!9<?;9B:!L<DD!5I!;A9!

;58>)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)!!0."0%(%#'"2#&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%T)!!D)!W#G%$(<2+%)&0%"+2*#0'!!

!T7;D9B!C:!;A9!#'"2#&O!D)!E)!A)!!!!,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!:9CPA>5BA55@!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!$1!(2!WO!]W^][O!ab)!!

T57BC<:;!WVV#2!_b^_#)!

.&N)!(Y2!Wb"O!b)!!

4<FC9?!h!-<B@C:9B!W_W"2!Wb)!!

N<8EE!W__a2![`_^[W`O!ICP)!W`]!=E)![`[G!<:@!ICP)!WW`)!

*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2![a"O!:5)!_`a)!

!

!

!

! !

Page 322: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a_a!

T)(()]! /DM<>![!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!M&2-+<!<;!/DM<>!!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! /DM<>)!'A7;)!(!h!X<;?A)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'A9!C:?6BCE;C5:!L<?!6<BF9@!5:!;A9!><6M!L<DD!5I!;A9!8<C:!A<DD!

5I!;A9!;58>!<:@!A<@!;A9!?A<E9!5I!<!B57:@^;5EE9@!?;9D9!LC;A!

<!:C6A9!C:!C;?!69:;9B)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!DD)!["^[]G!$0%-#;9*9$%DrE%)'%*;'%*'%"+2*#0'%,*)%0.&%#*;%%

!(!657:;9@!=ÅG!<DD!;AC:P?!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'I%D)!E)!A)!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!WWVO!WW)!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!'JD5B!W_Vb2!ED)!Wa)!!'B<:?D<;C5:)!+C6A;A9C8!W_#"^W_V`O!((2!Wa^[W)!!!

! !

Page 323: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a_#!

T)(()b! ''!Va!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:! IB58! ;A9! ;58>! 5I!=*2)"+2+,2#*;D0EO! EB5EA9;! 5I!%87:!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3A9CMA!%>@!9D^l7B:<)!'A7;85?9!((H(((!^!%89:A5;9E!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'C;D9?!B9E9<;9@!?9F9B<D!;C89?!C:!;A9!;58>)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%-+<2'"%,&%(%"+2*#0'%%%#)*'<9*94%#'94%(%,-!%

!-B9<;!6AC9I!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%%,:9!LA5?9!E5?C;C5:!L<?!EB585;9@!C:!;A9!,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!.&N!(Y2!_[aO!WWk!_[#O!W)!!4<FC9?!^!4<FC9?!W_"")!!45B8<:!W__b2!W]W^Wb])!!$1!(O!WO!W#b^W#V)!!YCB9J!WV_W2!W_#^[Wb)!!$AC9D!WVVa^W_`"O!(2!W[#^W[_)!!15:@!W_`b2!ab^_a)!!N<8EE!W_aa2!""V^"]`O!ICP?)![W_^[[`)!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!]["O!:5)!W]][)!!

! !

Page 324: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a_V!

T)(()a! ''!VW!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!?;9D9!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!>1**<!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3A9CMA!%>@!9D^l7B:<O!''!VW)!%8)!(O!'A7;)!(H((O!X<;?A)!<:@!'A7;)!

((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! TC5PB<EAC6<D!C:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!?;9D9!5I!>1**<!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!D)!#G%-&"%+&%-+%)+'%"+2*#0'%,*)%0.&%#*;%%!D)!W]G!$0%-#0'9$%(*'$%(%,-%(+0'9$%)+%!*0'%#&-%*90$%-(94%(%(+0'%,C09$%-+%!*'%*'%"+2*#0'%(%7+'%-+0%*'%+,%*;%!!!D)!WVG!-('9#%(+$9*9#%0$%+)9*9#%$C+09$%(%#'"2#&!!#)0.9*9#%0$%(%$)0'%#,&9*9#%0$%(-9*9#%$&(9$%(%-.%*;0%(%!#+%*;%*4+%*%"+2*#0'!!%%%D)![`G%$;9$%+%0+0%$(<0%,-%

!,:9!LA5!M99E?!?CD9:;!<>57;!;A9!<II<CB?!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'I%D)!E)!A)!!1J!EB<C?9!L<?!E9B8<:9:;!C:!;A9!,-O!<:@!8J!D5F9!L<?!LC;A!;A9!657B;C9B?)!!XC?!1<d9?;J!A<@!>9?;5L9@!89!LC;A!?9BF<:;?O!<:@!8J!I55@!L9:;!;5!;A9!PB<:<BC9?!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'%9F9BJ!?C:PD9!@<J!!X9B!1<d9?;JO!?A9!D5F9@!89O!?A9!A<FC:P!B965P:CZ9@!8J!\7<DC;C9?!C:!;A9!#'"2#&[%?A9!9:BC6A9@!89!LC;A!E5??9??C5:?O!?A9!8<@9!89!PB9<;!<:@!ICDD9@!8J!9?;<;9!LC;A!?CDF9BO!P5D@O!<:@!9F9BJ!P55@!;AC:P!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'%%1J!A9<B;!C?!;5!;A9!PB9<;?!LA5!>9D5:P!;5!;A9!,-!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!T57BC<:;!WV_[2!W`a^#)!!T57BC<:;!WV_"2!#"^#])!!.&N!(Y2!bVO!#k!a`O!W]^W#k!a[O![k!a"O!Wb)!4<FC9?!W_a"2!W_^[`)!!T57??<6!WV_a)!$1!(O!W2!Wb_^Wa")!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!'B<:?D<;C5:2!4ZC5>9M!W__[)!!

! !

Page 325: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! a__!

T)(()#! *-![#VWb!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:?! 5I! 3:=LG^Ñ8?O! 5IIC6C<D! 5I! ;A9! EBC:69! W&.2(#O!!IB58!;A9!I7:9B<BJ!;98ED9!5I!;A9!EBC:69!C:!*<CB5!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! *<CB5O!;98ED9!5I!W&.2(#9%'A7;)!((()%

49?6BCE;C5:! 'C;D9!B9E9<;9@!;LC69!C:!;A9!;9K;)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!W"O!WbG%.&+9$%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%!

!

(!L<?!?7>@79!5I!;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!W`a_O!_!<:@!Wb)!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!-B{><7;!W_`W2!W`W^W`")!!

!

! !

Page 326: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #``!

T)(()V! T1!b"#!=qG!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;<;79!5I!5*D9$E2*4+!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!'A7;)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!D)! aG! -+<2'"% ,&% (% "+2*#0'% =))G! (*% ';<'% (%,7*0'<%

!-B9<;!6AC9I! C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%=))G! ICB8!?<:@<D?! C:!;A9!,7*0'<%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!b]bO!W")!$7>DC6<;C5:2!3A<BE9!WV"#^WVbbO!(2!bb^ba)!!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!]["O!:5)!W]][)!!

! !

Page 327: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #`W!

T)(()_! ''!V]!

456789:;!;C;D9! 'A9><:!;58>!5I!;A9!B5J<D!A9B<D@!>1&(2*.-!!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3A9CMA!%>@!9D^l7B:<)!'A7;)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)!,II9BC:P!I5B87D<!

T)!$B<J9B!;5!;A9!37:^P5@!

*)!(:?6BCE;C5:!65::96;9@!LC;A!;A9!?69:9!5I!;A9!EB9?9:;<;C5:!5I!

3JBC<:?!;5!;A9!;AB5:9^A<DD!5I!;A9!MC:P!

4)!36<;;9B9@!;C;D9?!B9I9BB9@!;5!;A9!5L:9B!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)!D)!]G%,&%(%"+2*#0'%%T)!D)!#G%-#0'9$%(%"+2*#0'%,*)%0.&%#*;%(%7+'27+0%%*)!D)!WG%),$D'E%*#0'%(%#'%0+'%(%,-%*0%>10*0%%4)!$(<2$;%(%#'%,-%*;94%%%$(<2+%+0'<%"+2*#0'%%%*;%0*(0'%(%"+2*#0'%,*)%0.&%#*;%%%%#+%,&%(%"+2*#0'%%)+"%C&0'%*;D0E'%*'%"+2*#0'!%$(<2+%!*,<%"+2*#0'%*#0'2;$'<%%!

!-B9<;!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'!!!c<F5B9@!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'O!D)!E)!A)!9F9BJ!@<J!!!%EE9<B<:69!5I!;A9!MC:P!C:!;A9!PB9<;!?9<;!5I!;A9!,-%5I!X9DC5E5DC?!!'A9!5:9!LA5!C?!C:!;A9!A9<B;!5I!;A9!?9<;!5I!;A9!,-%5I!AC?!+5B@!!,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!@55B?!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'!!+5B@!5I!;A9!A57BDJ!EBC9?;!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'I%D)!E)!A)!!-B9<;!5IIC6C<D!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%%4CB96;5B!5I!<DD!L5BM?!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'!%,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!8<P<ZC:9?!5I!"+2*#0'!5I!;A9!MC:P!5I!.EE9B!<:@!+5L9B!/PJE;!!

U5;9?2!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$1!(2!WO!Wa#^W#`)!!YCB9J!WV_W2!""#^"aW)!!YCB9J!WVVa2!"_^]`)!!.&N)!(Y2!_"#!II)!!N<8EE!W_aa2!""[^""aO!ICP?)![Wa^[W#)!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!W_bO!:5)!aVWk!]bWO!:5)!Wbbak!b``O!:5)!Wa_W)!!

Page 328: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #`[!

T)(()W`! +57FB9!*![a!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!>1*2$'94!IB58!AC?!;58>!<;!4B<Q!%>7!9D^U<P<!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 4B<Q!%>7!9D^U<P<O!''!Wbb)!'A7;)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! TC5PB<EAC6<D!;9K;!5:!;A9!?;9D9!5I!>1*2$'94!IB58!AC?!;58>)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!D)!aG%#)"+%'"2+.%(%"+2*#0'%,*)%0.&%#*;%%%%DD)!a^#G%.$94%&0'2_;%(%,-%8P(&:%!4<'%(%7*0%#'%0+'%%D)!_G%*#%(.0%*%_(<%,-%%%D)!W[G%0.&%,-%%D)![WG%)+"%C&0'%*;0'%*'%"+2*#0'%,*)%0.&%#*;%%!D)! [[G% $&0'9$% "0% (% "+2*#0'% ,*)% 0.&% #*;%0*0'9$%"0%(%#'"2#&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%D)![aG%#%*4+%+%,-%

!'A9!5:9!LA5!8<M9?!<:!5B@9B!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'I%D)!E)!A)!!X9!PCF9?!5II9BC:P?!C:!;A9!,-O!5:9!LA5!6B9<;9?!@CP:C;J!C:!;A9!7*0%5I!;A9!-B9<;!39<;!!%! ;5:P79! ;A<;! ?E9<M?! I5B! ;A5?9! LA5! <B9! C:!;A9!,-!!$B5?E9B57?!,-%!*5:;B5DD9B!5I! <DD! ;A9!L5BM?!5I! ;A9!"+2*#0'I% D)!E)!A)!!'AC?!L<?!8J!5IIC69!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'I%D)!E)!A)k!;AC?!L<?!8J!@7;J!C:!;A9!#'"2#&I%D)!E)!A)!!%!>9<7;CI7D!8<:!<;!;A9!,-%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!_a#OV!<:@!W`^WWk!_aVO!Vk!_#"OW!<:@!Wbk!_#bO#)!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$C9BB9;!WV#]^WV#VO!((2![b^[#)!!/BC6A?9:!W_"#^W_]`2!b")!!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!]bWO!:5)!Wbba)!! !

Page 329: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #`"!

T)(()WW! '7BC:!=<G!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!@9@C6<;9@!;5!M&2*02*<%>J!AC?!?5:!5!2-&'2'$!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!'A7;)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! &57:@^;5EE9@!?<:@?;5:9!?;9D9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%"+D0E%-#_/-#0'%(%#'"2#&%*)%0.&%#*;%

!,:9! LA5! P59?! 7E! I5B! ;A9! I<F5B?HEB<C?9?! C:!;A9!#'"2#&I%D)!E)!A)!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!W`WVO!#^V)!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!1<?E9B5!WVV"2!W[_)!!

! !

Page 330: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #`]!

T)(()W[! *-!][W[W!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!?;<;79!5I!F4+2"+'2+,%IB58!N<B:<M!6<6A9;;9!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<M)!'A7;)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:! ;A9!><6M^ECDD<B! 5I! <! M:99DC:P! ?;<;79! IB58! ;A9!

N<B:<M! 6<6A9;;9)! %! B5J<D! >7;D9BO! F4+2"+'2+,I% LA5! A<@!

<6658E<:C9@! 'A7;85?9! (((! 5:! 5:9! 5I! AC?! 9KE9@C;C5:?! ;5!

$<D9?;C:9! =&9;d9:7GO! L<?! >J! <! ?E96C<D! @96B99! 5I! ;A9! MC:P! C:!

6A<BP9!5I! I57B! 65L?! IB58!\&7<O!>9?C@9?! ;L5!/PJE;C<:!5:9?!<:@! <! >7DD! LAC6A! A9! A<@! >B57PA;! ;5! >9! @9@C6<;9@! C:! ;A9!

I7:9B<BJ!;98ED9!5I!'A7;85?9!(((!5:!;A9!L9?;!?C@9!5I!'A9>9?)W!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!W]G%,P%-+9#%$(<2+%+0'<%F;2#*<%$$%-+9#%#!%*#0'%%%D)!WbG%>1(*2(#%...'%(%-(%*%#'"2#&%%%D)!WaG%,*)%0.&%#*;%$09#*%+%)'9C%(%7+09C%%D)!W#G%*%,*)%$+%(%)'%$&09*9C%%D)!WVG%$09#*%(%#&%*%#&%$0,%%%%D)!W_G%(%$0,%(%+.$9#'%+%7*0%$(<2+%$-0%%D)![`G%$+%$0'<%*;%+%(.0'%(%+.$%#.(%%D)![WG%'0%*9#*%(%)&%*#0'%%%

!'A9!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!P<;9L<J!F;2#*<!9:;9B9@!65:69B:C:P!C;k!<:@!;A9!B5J<D!?6BC>9!!>1(*2(#!6<89!65:69B:C:P!C;)!SA<;!L<?!?<C@!>9I5B9!;A9!8<d9?;J!5I!;A9!#'"2#&%D)!E)!A)!o'A9J!?A<DD!>9!7:@9B!J57B!<7;A5BC;J!;AB57PA!J57B!@<J?!5I!DCI9)!%?!I5B!<I;9B!J57!A<F9!<;;<C:9@!5D@!<P9O!;A9J!?A<DD!>9!IB58!?5:!;5!?5:O!A9CB!!;5!A9CB)!45!:5;!PCF9!;A98!;5!;A9!7*0I%=;A<;!C?G!;A9!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6<;;D9)!%?!I5B!<:J5:9!LA5!?A<DD!6589!;5!6D<C8O!@5!:5;!<DD5L!;A98!;5!>9!A9<B@!C:!<:J!5IIC69!5I!;A9!MC:P)!!

U5;9?2!W!-<B@C:9B!W_b[2!Wb)!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;9K;2!.&N!(Y2!W`[WO!W^_)!!

! !

Page 331: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #`b!

T)(()W"! *-!bbW!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!?;<;79!5I!>1(*2-'"%!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<MO!'98ED9!5I!NA5:?7)!'A7;)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!><6M!ECDD<B!5I!;A9!?;<;79)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)![G%+%#78++%(:%,-%

!

3E5M9?8<:!LA5!8<M9?H6<7?9?!E9<69!eC:f!;A9!

,-!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!WV"aO!])!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!T5B6A<B@;!W_WW^"aO!((2!ED)!_[)!!!!% %

Page 332: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #`a!

T)(()W]! *-!b]#!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!?;<;79!5I!=*2)"+2#*;!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!'A7;)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! -B<:C;9!?;<;79!LC;A![!F9B;C6<D!65D78:?!5I!C:?6BCE;C5:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!#G%0+%(+0'%(%"+2*#0'%%D)!VG%*;%$(&'%(%#'"2#&!

!

-B9<;!5I!D5F9!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%%$5??9??5B!5I!PB<6C57?:9??!C:!;A9!#'"2#&%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!__"O!W"^W])!%

% %

Page 333: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #`#!

T)(()Wb! ''!V#!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!F)2=0*!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3A9CMA!%>@!9D^l7B:<)!'A7;)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! cB<P89:;! 5I! <! ?69:9! LC;A! #! DC:9?! 5I! C:?6BCE;C5:! IB58! ;A9!

;58>!:5)!V#)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%6)!]G%(*%(+D0E'%(%"+2*#0'%%

!

cCB8!5I!D5F9!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!-7M?A!W__b)]])!%

% %

Page 334: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #`V!

T)(()Wa! ''!V[!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:?!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!>1(*2(2-&'!!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3A9CMA!%>@!9D^l7B:<)!'A7;)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'C;D9?! LBC;;9:! 5:! ;A9! I7:9B<BJ! 65:9?! I57:@! @7BC:P! ;A9!

9K6<F<;C5:?!5I!;A9!;58>)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!>O! PG% #!% ,&%(% "+2*#0'% ,*)%0.&% #*;% >1(*2(2-&'%%%6G%#!%,&%(%"+2*#0'%%%@G%-#;%$'%(%!*0'%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%

!-B9<;! ?6BC>9! C:! ;A9!"+2*#0'I% D)! E)! A)O! >1(*2(2-&'%!-B9<;!?6BC>9!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%%*57:;9B! 5I! PB<C:! C:! ;A9! PB<:<BJ! 5I! @CFC:9!5II9BC:P?!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!W`[aO!]^bO!_O!WW)!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!15:@!W_`b2!_]^_a)!!4<B9??J!^!T57BC<:;!WV_"2![_bO![]_)!!N<8EE!W_aa2!"[a^""`O!ICP?)![W`^[WW)!!$1!(O!W2!Wa"^Wa#)!!4<FC9?!h!-<B@C:9B!W_Wb)!#)!!!!!!!!!

! !

Page 335: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #`_!

T)(()W#! 3;)!c9BBC5D!

65DD96;C5:!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!?;9D9!5I!;A9!FCZC9B!W#+2D*)'E!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!'A7;)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! -B<:C;9!?;9D9!IB58!3;)!c9BBC5D!65DD96;C5:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!D)!"G%-+<2#!'&%*%"+2*#0'%

!

N99E9B!5I!?96B9;?!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!W`"`O!_)!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!47BC:P9!W_`"2![VH[_)!!

! !

Page 336: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #W`!

T)(()WV! *-![#VWb!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!?;<;79^?;9D9!5I!5&2;&#''!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 'A9>9?)!'A7;)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'A9!?;9D9!65:;<C:?!;A9!8<BBC<P9!65:;B<6;!5I!5&2;&#''Q?!?D<F9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!DD)!]^bG!7+.0%*%C&"%*%"+2*#0'%

!*ACD@B9:!5I!;A9!:7B?9BJ%5I!;A9!"+2*#0'%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!W"a_O!b)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!+C:<P9!W_"_2![W#!II)O!$D)![]^[b)!!-B{><7;!^!1<?E9B5WV]a^W_WaO!(2![)!%!

! !

Page 337: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #WW!

T)(()W_! Y<BC57?!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!F-<%!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! U7>C<)!'A7;)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)!TC5PB<EAC6<D! C:?6BCE;C5:!6<BF9@!5:!;A9!L<DD!5I! ;A9!;98ED9!

5I!398:<)!

T)! (:?6BCE;C5:! 5I! ;A9! FC69B5J! F-<% IB58! AC?! B56M^;58>! C:!

U7>C<)%

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)!

P*%+#2'"%*%*;%,-%%T)!

D)!"G%0+%$*0%(%#'"2#&%[,*)%0.&%#*;]%

!

TB<F9O!FCPCD<:;!I5B!;A9!+5B@!5I!;A9!,-%%%-B9<;!5I!$*0!C:!;A9!#'"2#&I%[D)!E)!A)]!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!.&N!(Y2!_V]O!bk!_V#O!_)!

+9E?C7?!W_#"2!((2!ba<)!

%

% %

Page 338: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #W[!

T)(()[`! 3CD?CD9A!W#!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:?!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!;A9!FCZC9B!,('0!!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! -9>9D!3CD?CD9AO!?ABC:9!:5)!W#)!'A7;)!((()!^!X<;?A)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%-+<2#!'&%*%"+2*#0'%%

!N99E9B!5I!?96B9;?!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!]_"O![)!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!+9E?C7?!W_#"2!(((!["!>C?)!3ABC:9!W#)!!*<8C:5?!^!g<89?!W_a"O!ED)!]a)!%

% %

Page 339: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #W"!

T)(()[W! *-!a]V!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:?!5:!;A9!?;<;79!5I!@"02#*;0!!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<MO!'98ED9!5I!17;)!'A7;)!(((!^!X<;?A)!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)!cB5:;<D!C:?6BCE;C5:?)!T)!(:?6BCE;C5:?!5:!;A9!?C@9)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

s9%D)!WWG%$(<%$;%*%$(<%,-%%`9%D)!WG!(*%-#0'%,&%(+D0E'%#)*'<%*%"+2*#0'%%%%D)!bG%#(#%*%@+%*;%,-%%

!c<F5BC;9!5I!;A9!5:9!LA5!C?!C:!;A9!,-!!!cCB8!5I!EB<C?9?HI<F5B?O!PB9<;!5I!D5F9O!;A9!5:9!LA5!C?!C:!IB5:;!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'!!!c5DD5LC:P!X5B7?O!;A9!+5B@!5I!;A9!,-%!

U5;9?2!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!]V[O!"k!]V"O!_^W`k!]V]O!]k!]V]OV)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!T9:?5:!h!-57BD<J!!h!U9L>9BBJ2!WVa_^W_]_2!"W"^"W])!!%

% %

Page 340: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #W]!

T)(()[[! ''!b"!N!

456789:;!;C;D9! c7:9B<BJ!65:9!:5)!WV`!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!>1(*2(2-&'!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 'A9>9?O!''!b")!'A7;)!(((!^!X<;?A)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!#!%,&%(%"+2*#0'%,*)%0.&%#*;!!

!-B9<;!?6BC>9!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'I%D)!E)!A)!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!15:@!W_`b2!_]^_a)!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!b`VO!:5)!W#[b)!!

! !

Page 341: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #Wb!

T)(()["! T1!]V!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!?;9D9!5I!5*2*4+!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 'A9>9?!=IB58!>9AC:@!;A9!*5D5??CG)!'A7;)!((()!^!X<;?)!

49?6BCE;C5:! TD<6M!PB<:C;9! ?;<;79!LC;A! ;9K;! 6<BF9@! C:! I57B;99:!A5BCZ5:;<D!

DC:9?!5:!;A9!@B9??O!C:![!F9B;C6<D!65D78:?O!5:9!5:!9<6A!?C@9!5:!

;A9!7EE9B!?7BI<69!5I!;A9!E9@9?;<D!<:@!C:!b!A5BCZ5:;<D!DC:9?!5:!

;A9!IB5:;!I<69!5I!;A9!E9@9?;<D)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!aG%-+<2'"%,&%(%"+2*#0'!

!-B9<;!6AC9I!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!X'T1!V2![O!ED)!b)!%

% %

Page 342: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #Wa!

T)(()[]! ''!WW!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:?!5:!;A9!U5B;A<8E;5:!?;9D9!W!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!\-0'<!!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 4B<Q!%>7!9D^U<P<)!'A7;)!(((!h!X<;?A)!

49?6BCE;C5:! %) TC5PB<EAC6<D!;9K;)!

T) 'CD9?!5I!;A9!5L:9B!B9E9<;9@!?9F9B<D!;C89?!C:!;A9!;9K;)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)!D)!]G%$+<2",'%-&'<2,%)'(0%)'(%!"##0%(%"+2*#0'%\-0'<%%D)!W"G%$+<2",'%-&'<2,%(-%$;%@+%*;%,-%\-0'<%%%D)!W]G%$+<2",'%-&'<2,%0#'*%+.%(%#'"2#&%%%%%D)!W_G%!"#$%)'+D0E%,-94%D99E%!"#$%#!(%,-%%%DD)![`^[WG%0.%-(94%$+'%[r]%(%.,(%*%'"%)&#'%(%7*0%0#)'%@;'%%`9%+)%#!'&%*;%*%,-%%#)*8':<%#'94%(%,-%

!$BC:69!<:@!8<J5BO!?9<D9B!?9<DC:P!EB96C57?!;AC:P?!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'I%\-0'<%!$BC:69!<:@!8<J5BO!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!A9<B;!5I!X5B7?!+5B@!5I!;A9!,-I%\-0'<!!$BC:69!<:@!8<J5BO!;A9!5:9!LA5!L<DM9@!<B57:@!C:!;A9!#'"2#&%=DC;)!oIB99!5I!I55;!C:!;A9!#'"2#&G!%U5>D9!5I!LA<;!>9D5:P?!;5!AC?!,-%D99E%:5>D9!<;!;A9!P7C@9!5I!;A9%,-%!XC?!1<d9?;J!6588<:@!;5!@5![r]%5I!P5D@!<;!;A9!A9<@!5I!;A9!ACDD!657:;BC9?!5I!;A9!7*0%5I!;A9!I5B;CIC9@!9:6D5?7B9?!5I!;A9!c9?;CF<D!!,:9!LA5!M:5L?!<DD!;A9!?96B9;?!5I!;A9!,-%%,:9!LA5?9!E5?C;C5:H?;<;7?!L<?!EB585;9@!C:!;A9!,-%!

U5;9?2!W!'A9!85:789:;! C?!P9:9B<DDJ!M:5L:!<?!U5B;A<8E;5:!?;9D9!>J!;A9!:<89!5I!1<B\7C?!

5I!U5B;A<8E;5:!LA5!@C?65F9B9@!C;!C:!WV_V)!

[!'A9!;9B8!7*0!C?!I5DD5L9@!>J!;A9!@9;9B8C:<;CF9!5I!;A9!T<;;D989:;!9:6D5?7B9!=-/-2!,W"G!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!][WO!Wbk!][aO!b!<:@!W"k!][_O!"^]!<:@!W`)!.&N!(Y2!]]_O!aO!W[)!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!3EC9P9D>9BP!W_``2!WWb)!!+9E?C7?!W_W"O!((2![#O!W`)WW)!!-<Dm:![``#2!###^#VV)!!N<8EE!W__a2!W_`^W_[O!ICP)!_")!$1!(O!W2![W^[])!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!]b"O!:5)!Wbab)!!

% %

Page 343: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #W#!

T)(()[b! ''![``!

456789:;!;C;D9! 'A9><:! ;58>! 5I! ;A9! 5F9B?99B! 5I! ;A9! @9?9B;?! 5:! ;A9! L9?;!\.D<E!!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! NA5MA<)!'A7;)!(((^%8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! 1<C:!C:?6BCE;C5:!C:!;A9!;58>)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!D)![G!-+<%*%"&%#&0%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%!

!*AC9I!5I!;A9!B9PC89:;!5I!;A9!"+2,&O!D)!E)!A)!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N)!(Y2!__bO!WW)!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$1!(2!WO!"`"^"`])!!4<B9??J!^!T57BC<:;!WV_"2![#"O!]OW"k![#bO"`)!!N<8EE!W_aa2!]Vb^]V#O!ICP?)!"#V^"#_)!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!"_#O!:5)!W""a)!!

! !

Page 344: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #WV!

T)(()[a! ''!_a!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:?!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!>1(*2(2$"'!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3A9CMA!%>@!9D^l7B:<)!'A7;)!(((!h!%8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%('<%(&,%(%;&-%*;94%$+%&)%*%*;%,-'%*2,&2*%(*)94%*%*#0'%%%$(&)<%)+%*#0'%(%,-%%%,*)0<%@+%(%,-94%$(<2$;%,&%(%"+2*#0'%,P%-+%*;94%0,,0%

%,&%(%"+2*#0'%,*)%0.&%#*;%!*;%$(&'%(%#'"2#&!

!'B7DJ!EB96C?9!5:9!C:!;A9!EB9?9:69!5I!AC?!+5B@!LA5!@C@!LA<;!C?!7?9I7D!IB58!;A9!+5B@!5I!;A9!,-'!<?!876A!<?!A9!L<?!9IIC6C9:;!I5B!;A9!MC:P!!&9F9B9@!5:9!>9I5B9!;A9!MC:P!C:!;A9!,-!!/<B?!5I!X5B7?O!+5B@!5I!AC?!,-I!;A9!PB9<;!65:IC@<:;!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'I%LA5!9:;9B?!;5!AC?!+5B@!C:!EBCF<;9!%-B9<;!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'O!D)!E)!A)!!$5??9??5B!5I!PB<6C57?:9??!C:!;A9!#'"2#&!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!W][VO!Wb^WaO!W#k!W]"`O!Vk!W]"VO!W"O!W])!!

! !

Page 345: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #W_!

!

T)(()[#! ''!_]!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:?!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!M&2#+!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3A9CMA!%>@!9D^l7B:<)!'A7;)!(((!h!%8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'C;D9!5I!;A9!5L:9B)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%$(<2$;%,&%(%"+2*#0'%!

!-B9<;!I<F5B9@!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!W]"`O!Vk!W]baO!Wa)!!

! !

Page 346: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #[`!

T)(()[V! ''!VV!

456789:;!;C;D9! 'A9!'A9><:!;58>!5I!;A9!DC97^;9:<:;!6588<:@9B!5I!;A9!<B8J!M72#02)+!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3A9CMA!%>@!9D^l7B:<)!'A7;)!(((!h!%8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)! (:?6BCE;C5:!:9<B! ;A9! B9EB9?9:;<;C5:!5I!M72#02)+% B969CFC:P!ID5L9B?)!

`9%(:?6BCE;C5:!:9<B!;A9!B9EB9?9:;<;C5:!5I!I99@C:P!;A9!?5D@C9B?!C:!IB5:;!5I!;A9!MC:P)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%%)!TG%,&%(%"+2*#0'%,*)%0.&%#*;%%T)!D)![WG%#'&0%*0%(*4&'%,*)0%*0%#%+%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%+%#*(9#'%(%'%$04%[*]%$&0%$+"%DrE!!

!!-B9<;!C:!;A9%"+2*#0'O!D)!E)!A)!!!4B<L!5I!DCFC:P!?5D@C9B?!;5!;A9!$A<B<5AO!D)!E)!A)!;5!I99@!5:!>B9<@O!899;!5I!5KO!LC:9!=ÅG!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N)!(Y2!W]a`)!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$1!(2!WO!W#_^WVW)!!N<8EE!W_aa2!"][^"]]O!ICP)![[[)!!YCB9J!WV_W2![Va^"W`)!!/C?9B8<::!W__b2!ab^V`)!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!W_bO!:5)!aVW)!!

! !

Page 347: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #[W!

T)(()[_! ''!_b!

456789:;!;C;D9! c7:9B<BJ!65:9?!5I!;A9!ACPA!EBC9?;!5I!%87:O!=+<!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3A9CMA!%>@!9D^l7B:<O!''!_b)!'A7;)!(((^%8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! c7:9B<BJ!65:9!LC;A!5:9!DC:9!5I!C:?6BCE;C5:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)'(0%*;%(%"+2*#0'%!

!X9!LA5!?9<D?!9F9BJ;AC:P!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N)!(YO!W]WbO![)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!-:CB?!W__b2![""^[b])!!-:CB?!^!-B5;A9!^!-7M?6A)!W__#)!b#^V")!!N<8EE!W_aa2!"bV^"a`O!ICP)!["]9%%$1!(O!W2!W_b^W_#)!!YCB9J!WV_W2!""#^"aW)!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!]b[O!:5)!Wba[)!!

! !

Page 348: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #[[!

T)(()"`! ''!_#!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!Q1(*2(2-&'!!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3A9CMA!%>@!9D^l7B:<)!'A7;)!(((!h!%8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%0"%'&0<%@+D0E%(%,-94%%%,&%(%"+2*#0'%,*)%0.&%#*;%%(*%-#0%(%#'"2#&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%

!,:9!LA5!5E9:?!;A9!;L5!D<:@?!5I!X5B7?!C:!AC?!,-!!-B9<;!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'I%D)!E)!A)!!cCB8!5I!EB<C?9?HI<F5B?!C:!;A9!#'"2#&I%D)!E)!A)!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!W]W[O!]k!W]W"O![!<:@!b)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!W_W`2!V#!II)!!N<8EE!W_aa2!"a]^"a#O!ICP?)![]]^[]a)!!$1!(O!W2![`"^[`])!!

!

!

! !

Page 349: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #["!

T)(()"W! ''!_[!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!502(2*0'!!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3A9CMA!%>@!9D^l7B:<)!'A7;)!(((!h!%8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)'(0%;$'<%#0+%*%7*0%%%(&&%,;0%;&-%*%"&%#0+$%7*0%$+0'%-+%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%$+%-##0'/-##'%$(<2,-%(%7+'27+0%*'%+,%*;%%%%(&&%;0%*4+%*0%"+2*#0'%%%%(*%-#0%(%#'"2#&%%

!39<D9B!5I!.EE9B!<:@!+5L9B!/PJE;!LA5!@BC:M?!C:!;A9!7*0!!!399C:P! ;A9! E7BCIC6<;C5:! 5I! EB9?9:69! 5I! ;A9!7*0!><:\79;!I5B!;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)!!,:9!LA5! @C@!LA<;! C?! EB<C?9@HI<F5B9@!LC;AC:!;A9!,-!@7BC:P!;A9!657B?9!5I!9F9BJ!@<J!!!,:9!LA5!?99?!?589;AC:P!>9<7;CI7D! C:! ;A9!"+2*#0'%!cCB8!5I!EB<C?9?HI<F5B?!C:!;A9!#'"2#&!

!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!W]]_O!b^aO!W`O!W]k!W]b`O!_O!W"k!W]b[O!W`)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!T<7@!W_"b2!W"V^Wb`)!!TBJ<:![``W2!a"^#[)!!N<8EE!W_aa2!"b`^"b[O!ICP?)![[V^[[_)!!$1!(OW2!WV#^WV_)!!SB9:Z?C:?MC!W_["^]`O!(2![_#)!!!

! !

Page 350: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #[]!

T)(()"[! ''!ba!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:?!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!W#+2-&'%!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3A9CMA!%>@!9D^l7B:<)!'A7;)!(((!h!%8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!DD)!#^VG%,P%7+%*4+'%;0%7+%*#0'%"+%-#0%(%#'"2#&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%

!,:9! LA5! 9:;9B?! >9<BC:P! P55@! ;AC:P?! ;5! ;A9!ED<69! >9<BC:P! ;A9! MC:P! <:@!LA5! 6589?! I5B;A!EB<C?9@HI<F5B9@!IB58!;A9!#'"2#&I!D)!E)!A)!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!W]#VOW`)!!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!T9C:DC6A^399>9B!h!3A9@C@!W_V#2!a#)!!N<8EE!W__a2![a[^[a#O!ICP)Wb]^Wbb)!15:@!W_`b2!ab^_a)!!$1!(O!W2!WWW^WW")!!SB9?ZC:MC!W_["^]`O!(2!WVV)!!!

! !

Page 351: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #[b!

T)(()""! ''!W``!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!YCZC9B!?)2($2+,!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3A9CMA!%>@!9D^l7B:<)!'A7;)!(((!h!%8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! %) 'A9!47;C9?!5I!;A9!YCZC9B)!T) 'C;D9?!B9I9BB9@!;5!;A9!YCZC9B!<:@!AC?!9:;57B<P9)!*) (:?6BCE;C5:?!5:!L<DD?!%^TW!B9EB9?9:;C:P!?)2($2+,!<7@C9:69)!4) ,;A9B!;C;D9?)!=/C6AD9B![```O!:5)!]`_O!"`"G)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)!!&WO%'"2+.%*%-(#'%*%$(<2+%*%*$0'!'&'<%*%*$0'%+#'%*%7*0%(%)&%*%'&'<%%%&"I% #($9'0% *94% )'(% )'(0% +% *0%0*9#'% +% *0%#($9'D0E% *94% )+'% (**00% +#D0E% (-'D0E% "+%"++'%*;'%!!&]O!(%"+2*#0'!#($D0E%*94%,P%,P'%*;'%+%"+2*#0'%#($D0E%*94%$+%S+'%,P'%*;'%"++'%*;'%+%#&'0%*%7*0%,P9#*%"+$9#*%$*%0"0'<94%.$.$%,P%"+$%#($%*94%$(<02+%!*0'%$(<02+%0%)+'%!!!!&bO! 9#*% ,P94% S+'% +% *.2)+'% *;% ,*)%0.&% #*;% $0%#($D0E%*94% )+'% '&0<%(%"+94% +,% *;% ,P94% +% "+2,&%)4'% $(<2+% )'(% ,-,94% +% #*'% (-''% 8):+% (*(*%'&'<%(%0;*%(%"&%#;&%*%+0'<%0+'<%)+%%%%%%&aO% $(<2+% )'(% $$94% (% -#94% -*,% #($'% *94% +% ..%7&09C% *;% ,.%0.&% #($9*% *9$% $+<% *;% #!(% +% ..%7&09C% *;% ,.% 0.&% "+2*#0'% ,.% 0.&% )+% '&'<%#($94%*%$(<2+%)'(%+%..%%%%%&#O%7&09C%*;%,.%0.&%#'%*;'%*%7*0%,.%80.&:%#($D0E%*9$%)'(%)'(0%+%*0%0*9#'%+%*0%$*%$+<%*;%#!(%)+2$+2(2)'%#($%0,%*%0,%(%"&%#+%K%)+%'&'<%7D&E;94%%%

!(:?;B76;C5:!I5B!;A9!?9??C5:!5I!;A9!P5F9B:5B!5I!;A9!6C;JO!;A9!FCZC9B!5I!;A9!357;A9B:!*C;J!<:@!5I!;A9!7*0%C:!;A9!>7B9<7!5I!;A9!FCZC9B!!'5!AC8!5:9!B9E5B;?!;A9!6D5?C:P!5I!;A9!9:6D5?7B9?!5:!;C89!<:@!;A9CB!5E9:C:P!5:!;C89)!'5!AC8!C?!B9E5B;9@!;A9!65:@C;C5:!5I!;A9!?57;A9B:!<:@!:5B;A9B:!P7<B@!E5?;?)!SA9:!9F9BJ;AC:P!;A<;!A<?!;5!D9<F9!;A9!!"+2*#0'%D9<F9?O!=;A<;!C?!B9E5B;9@!;5!AC8)!SA9:!9F9BJ;AC:P!;A<;!A<?!;5!9:;9B!;A9!"+2*#0'%9:;9B?O!=;A<;G!C?!B9E5B;9@!;5!AC8)!%?!I5B!9F9BJ;AC:P!;A<;!A<?!;5!9:;9B!5B!D9<F9!;A9!<B9<!5I!;A9!7*0%C;!=DC;)!;A9JG!LCDD!D9<F9!<:@!9:;9B2!C;!C?!AC?!89??9:P9B!LA5!?99?!C;!;A<;!C;!D9<F9?!<:@!9:;9B?)!'A9!5F9B?99B?!5I!;A9!E5DC6989:!<:@!;A9!5F9B?99B?!5I!=;A9G!@C?;BC6;!B9E5B;!;5!AC8!;A9CB!<II<CB?)!U5L!A9!?A<DD!9:;9B!;5!PB99;!;A9!+5B@O!D)!E)!A)O!9<6A!@<J!LA9:!;A9!<II<CB?!5I!;A9!'L5!+<:@?!A<F9!>99:!B9E5B;9@!;5!AC8!C:!AC?!B9?C@9:69)!X9!?A<DD!9:;9B!;A9!"+2,&!LA9:!;A9!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!;B9<?7BJ!A<?!@B<L:!7E!AC?!E5?C;C5:!<;!;A9!:5B;A9B:!ID<P?;<II)!'A9:!;A9!FCZC9B!?A<DD!85F9!=C:G!IB58!;A9!9<?;!C:!;A9!@55BL<J!5I!;A9!PB9<;!@57>D9^P<;9)!!'A9!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!;B9<?7BJ!?A<DD!6589!;5!899;!AC8!<:@!A9!?A<DD!B9E5B;!;5!AC8!?<JC:P2!<DD!J57B!<II<CB?!<B9!?57:@!<:@!EB5?E9B57?)!/F9BJ!B9?E5:?C>D9!I7:6;C5:<BJ!A<?!B9E5B;9@!;5!89!?<JC:P2!<DD!J57B!<II<CB?!<B9!?57:@!<:@!EB5?E9B57?O!"+2*#0'%C?!?57:@!<:@!EB5?E9B57?)!'A9:!;A9!FCZC9B!?A<DD!B9E5B;!;5!;A9!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!;B9<?7BJ!?<JC:P!o<DD!J57B!<II<CB?!<B9!?57:@!<:@!eEB5?E9B57?fO!9F9BJ!@9E<B;89:;!5I!;A9!7*0!C?!?57:@!<:@!EB5?E9B57?)!'5!AC8!5:9!B9E5B;?!;A9!6D5?C:P!5I!;A9!9:6D5?7B9?!5:!;C89!A<F9!>99:!B9E5B;9@!;5!89!>J!9F9BJ!B9?E5:?C>D9!I7:6;C5:<BJ)!U5L!

Page 352: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #[a!

%!&VO%+%0*%#;&%*;%*%"+2*#0'%+%+.$8':%,P%,8P0:'%*;'%"++'%*;'%(2($''%$*%0"0'<94%.$.$%)"+%(%#!%(%+.$D0E%#)(%#+%*;%(%0.,2+D<E'%(%)&94%$+%)"+%#C%+%%%%&_I%0,%(%*&%*%#+0%$(<%)&94%)+94%.$94%$*9'D0E%+%8,:+<'t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

<I;9B!>5;A!5IIC6C<D?!A<F9!B9E5B;9@!;5!9<6A!5;A9BO!;A9!FCZC9B!?A<DD!?9:@!!57;!;5!5E9:!9F9BJ!@55BL<J!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'%?5!<?!;5!9:?7B9!;A<;!9F9BJ;AC:P!LAC6A!A<?!;5!9:;9B!9:;9B?!<:@!DCM9LC?9!9F9BJ;AC:P!LAC6A!A<?!;5!D9<F9!=D9<F9?G)!(;!C?!AC?!89??9:P9B!LA5!?99?!C;!;A<;!=C;G!A<EE9:?!>J!89<:?!5I!LBC;C:P)!(;!C?!:5;!;5!>9!<DD5L9@!;A<;!=<:JG!6AC9I!5IIC6C<D!65:;B5D?!;A9!@C?E9:?<;C5:!5I!d7?;C69!C:!AC?!=5L:G!>7B9<7)!SA9:!<!?9F9B9!<667?<;C5:!C?!D9F9D9@!<;!5:9!5I!;A9!5IIC6C<D?!C:!AC?!>7B9<7O!A9!=;A9!6AC9I!5IIC6C<DG!LCDD!?99!;5!C;O!;A<;!A9!=;A9!?7>5B@C:<;9!5IIC6C<DG!C?!;<M9:!;5!;A9!,+<'9!(;!C?!;A9!FCZC9B!LA5!LCDD!E7:C?A!AC8!<665B@C:P!;5!AC?!5II9:69)!(;!C?!:5;!;5!>9!<DD5L9@!;A<;!<:J!5IIC6C<D?!65:;B5D?!=E7:C?A89:;!>JG!>9<;C:P!C:!AC?!>7B9<7)!%:J5:9!LA5!A<?!;5!>9!d7@P9!<:@!;A7?!I<DD?!7:@9B!;A9!658E9;9:6J!5I!;A9!>7B9<7!=5I!;A9!FCZC9BGO!LCDD!A<F9!;5!>9!B9E5B;9@!;5!AC8!=;A9!6AC9I!5IIC6C<DGO!?5!;A<;!A9!8<J!A<:@!AC8!=;A9!?7>5B@C:<;9!5IIC6C<DG!5F9B!;5!C;!=;A9!>7B9<7!5I!;A9!FCZC9BG!!=))G!%?!I5B!<:J5:9!LA5!?A<DD!8<M9!<!E9;C;C5:!;5!;A9!FCZC9B!65:69B:C:P!IC9D@?O!C;!C?!;5!AC8=?9DIO!;A9!FCZC9BG!;A<;!A9!5B@9B?!AC8O!C:!<@@C;C5:!;A9!A9<BC:P!5I!!;A9!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!IC9D@?!<:@!;A9!657:6CD!5I!;A9!8<;)!X9!LCDD!8<M9!;5!AC8!<!@9D<J!5I!;L5!85:;A?!I5B!AC?!IC9D@?!C:!.EE9B!<:@!+5L9B!/PJE;)!T7;!<?!I5B!AC?!IC9D@?!;A<;!>5B@9B?!5:!;A9!357;A9B:!*C;J!<:@!;A9!7*0O!A9!8<M9?!;5!AC8!<!@9D<J!5I!=5:DJG!;AB99!@<J?O!!<665B@C:P!;5!;A9!D<L)!X9!A9<B?!9F9BJ!E9;C;C5:9B!<665B@C:P!;5!;AC?!D<L!LAC6A!C?!C:!A<:@)!!(;!C?!A9!LA5!@C?E<;6A9?!9F9BJ!89??9:P9B!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'%?9:;!;5!;A9!8<J5B?!<:@!;A9!?9;;D989:;^D9<@9B?[%C?!A9!LA5!@C?E<;6A9?!9F9BJ5:9!LA5!LCDD!6CB67D<;9!<DD!89??<P9?!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'%%(;!C?!LA5!8<M9?!=~<??98>D9?G!;A9!;5;<D!5I!;A9!<B8J!65:;C:P9:;!;A<;!9?65B;?!;A9!+5B@!LA9:!e?<CDC:P!@5L:?;B9<8f!<:@!7E?;B9<8)!(;!C?!A9!LA5!5BP<:CZ9?!;A9!B98<C:@9B!5I!;A9!<B8J!;A<;!?;<J?!>9AC:@!C:!;A9!357;A9B:!*C;J!<:@!C:!;A9!7*0%<665B@C:P!;5!LA<;!A<?!>99:!?<C@!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%%

Page 353: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #[#!

&[]I%*'4%#;;%+%#0&%*70'%)'4%..'%(%"+2*#0'%*'4%#;;%P*;'<0%%%%&[bI%*0%0%+%$+'%,%(%'&%+2.+94%*'4%#;;%-&'<02,%-P&02-00'%+%#C&%+%!(0%*'4% $++% $(<2+!!*'%(%)&% *% "+2*#0'% *'4% $++% #.(% -&'<02,% -P&02-00'%"++D0E%-+%+*94%*%!(,0%'&2(-0%%%%%%%%&[aI% #($9'D0E% *94% (.0'% *;D'E% #($9'D0E% *94%)+'%(**0%!(,%*.+'%*;%*'<%+% ,0&'% 899:%*'4% $++%-&C%*%#"&'%*;%*'4%#.(%#0%%%%%%%&[#I%*'4%#.(%,*,*%*;%(%899:%*'4%.7*%.7*0%*;%%%%&[VI%+%,+<'%$0%*94%!*0%*;%(%"+2*#0'%*'4%#.(%0.'%*;D'E%%%%%&[VO%899:%*;%(%*$0'%+#'%(%7*0%*'4%)'(%%&[_I% #'% -+% )'(94% *'4% #.(%(#0'% *;'% *'4% $++%);'% $*0% *% S#02"+0% #($% *94% DNE% .&.&'% 0+'%-'+9#%,P0%+%S#94%*'4%#.(%-+9#%*;%$**'%DNE%%%%&"`I%*%,+<'%.+"'%*;%*%,+<'%*'4%#.(%*'4%0*%"+2*;0%-*>%$(<2+%)'(%D99E%%!!&"]I!*'4%!&,%,-,0%+%!&,0%*;%*94%#0%*'4%#;;%0"0'<D0E%*;%*%"+2*#0'%+%899:%)'4%0**%*;%(%(!,%D99E%%%&"bO%*D'NE4%)'(%0.0%*;%*%899:%'#(%*%(*$02

C;!C?!A9!LA5!@C?E<;6A9?!;5!67;!@5L:!?J6<85B9?!<665B@C:P!;5!LA<;!A<?!>99:!?<C@!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%C;!C?!A9!LA5!@C?E<;6A9?!;A9!657:6CD5B?!!5I!;A9!@C?;BC6;!;5!65:?;B76;!;A9!=C:D9;H57;9BG!6A<::9D?!C:!;A9!LA5D9!657:;BJ)!(;!C?!A9!LA5!@C?E<;6A9?!;A9!8<J5B?!<:@!;A9!?9;;D989:;!D9<@9B?!;5!;<M9!6<B9!5I!;A9!67D;CF<;C5:?!<:@!;A9!A<BF9?;)!(;!C?!A9!=;A9!FCZC9BG!LA5!<EE5C:;?!;A9!5F9B?99B!5I!E5DC6989:!C:!;A9!>7B9<7!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'9%(;!C?!A9!LA5!A5D@?!;A9!A9<BC:P!5I!;A9!8<J5B!<:@!;A9!?9;;D989:;^D9<@9B?!LA5!A<F9!P5:9!57;!C:!AC?!:<89!;5!.EE9B!<:@!+5L9B!/PJE;)!%(;!C?!;5!AC8!;A<;!9F9BJ!8<;;9B!A<?!;5!>9!B9E5B;9@)!(;!C?!;5!AC8!;A<;!;A9!<II<CB?!5I!;A9!I5B;B9??!5I!.EE9B!/PJE;!A<F9!;5!>9!B9E5B;9@!=<?!L9DDG!9F9BJ!<BB9?;!5I!=<:JG!5:9!LA5!C?!C:F5DF9@!C:!ED7:@9BC:P!!e))f)!(;!C?!A9!LA5!<??CP:?!;A9!?E5CD?!=5I!L<BG!;5!9<6A!;5L:!@C?;BC6;)!(;!C?!A9!LA5!d7@P9?!AC8!=;A9!ED7:@9B9BG)!!!(;!C?!A9!LA5!A9<B?!<:J!658ED<C:;!e))f!LA9:!<!8<:!P59?!;5!D<L!LC;A!AC?!65DD9<P79)!(;!C?!A9!LA5!<EE5C:;?!<:J5:9!;5!>9!<EE5C:;9@!!;5!;A9!,+<'9%(;!C?!;5!AC8!=;A9!FCZC9BG!;A<;!<:J5:9!LA5!A<?!;5!>9!C:;9BB5P<;9@!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'!A<?!;5!6589k!C;!C?!A9!LA5!A9<B?!9F9BJ!@96B99!=5I!;A9!MC:PG!!+5B@!5I!;A9!?57;A9B:!6C;J!=<:@G!;A9!7*0I%C;!C?!A9!LA5!LCDD!?9<D!!C;!LC;A!AC?!?9<D!=))G)!(;!C?!A9!LA5!A9<B?!9F9BJ!6<?9)!(;!C?!A9!LA5!65DD96;?!;A9!@9DCF9BC9?!5I!;A9!L5BM?A5E?)!'5!AC8!=qG!;A9!PB9<;!657:6CD!B9E5B;?!C;?!@9DCF9BC9?!=<:@G!;A9!B9F9:79?!<;!AC?!?C@9)!(;!C?!A9!LA5!A9<B?!;A9!L5BM?A5E!E9B?5::9D!=qG!9F9BJ;AC:P!@9DCF9B9@!;5!=qG!;A9!,+<'%<:@!9F9BJ;AC:P!5II9B9@!;5!;A9!,+<'9!(;!C?!A9!LA5!A9<B?!65:69B:C:P!C;)!(;!C?!;A9!FCZC9B!LA5!5E9:?!;A9!-5D@!X57?9!;5P9;A9B!LC;A!;A9!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!;B9<?7BJ!!C;! C?! A9! LA5! <??CP:?! ?ACE?! ;5! 9F9BJ5:9! ;5!LA58! <! ?ACE! :99@?! ;5! >9! <??CP:9@)! (;! C?! A9!LA5! @C?E<;6A9?! 9F9BJ! 89??9:P9B! 5I! ;A9! "+2*#0'%;5!e))f!LA9:!;A9!+5B@!C?!5:!9KE9@C;C5:!!(;!C?!A9!LA5!?9<D?!9F9BJ!LBC;;9:!@96B99!5I!e))f!

Page 354: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #[V!

'#(0%#;;%(%0"0'%*'%"+2*#0'%%!!T)!D)!aG!$+%-##'%$(<%,-%!!D)!_G!#(+0%"+2,&%"+$9#*%7+*%-&'<2,%'&'<%-+%0!&%-C*0%%D)!W#G%$$'%(%-'"%(%#'"2#&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%D)!W_G%!#"9*94%-#0%*;%,-%!*)!D)!VG!$(<2$;%*%$(<%,-%-+<2#!'&%*%"+2*#0'%%%%4)!$(<2+%*%#'"2#&%!!

@5P!5I!;A9!P7<B@?8<:!5I!@5P?!@C?E<;6A9?!5:!<!8C??C5:!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'!!!%%5:9!LA5!8<M9?!LA<;!C?!EB<C?9@HI<F5B9@!>9C:P!C:!;A9!,-!!;A9!658E<:C5:?!5I!;A9!"+2,&I%;A9J!P5!I5B;A!;A9!EBC:69!<:@!FCZC9B!I5B!EB<C?9?!<:@!9K7D;<;C5:?!!(!6<89!57;!C:!E9<69!C:!;A9!#'"2#&O!D)!E)!A)!!(!B969CF9@!9F9BJ!I<F5B?!5I!;A9!,-%!!c<F5B9@!5I!;A9!5:9!LA5!C?!C:!;A9!A9<B;A!5I!;A5?9!LA5!<B9!C:!;A9!,-[%M99E9B!5I%?96B9;?!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%%,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!#'"2#&%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!.&N!(Y2!WWWVO!W]^Wbk!W`_]O!Wak!W`_bO!bO!W#)!4<FC9?!W_"b)!4<FC9?!W_]")!N<8EE!W_aa2!"#`^"#"O!ICP?)![b`^[b[)!$1!(O!W2![`a^[W])!YCB9J!WVV_)!cB99@![``W<2!"#a^"V")!!WYCB9J!WVV_2!ED)!")!U9L>9BBJ!W_``2!ED)![H")!+9E?C7?!W_#"O!(((2![#`)!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!Y<:!@9!T55B:!W_V_)!!! !

Page 355: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #[_!

T)(()"]! ''!Vb!

456789:;!;C;D9! 'A9><:!;58>!5I!;A9!DC97;9:<:;^6588<:@9B!5I!;A9!<B8J%,1(*2(2-;)!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 'A9>9?)!'A7;)!(((!h!%8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)!'C;D9?!5I!;A9!5L:9B)!

T)! (:?6BCE;C5:! 5:! ;A9! L<DD! (g! 5I! ;A9! ;58>! ?A5LC:P! ;A9!

EB9E<B<;C5:!5I!;A9!I7:9B<BJ!EB569??C5:)!

*)!(:?6BCE;C5:?!5:!;A9!L<DD?!X-O!-/O!c/!@9?6BC>C:P!,1(*2(2-;Q?!E<B;C6CE<;C5:! ;5! ;A9! 69B985:J! 5I! 65B5:<;C5:! 5I! %89:A5;9E!

(()!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

s9%-#<%*%$(<%,-%%,P%(%7"0%*%$(<%,-%%%%,&%(%"+2*#0'%%`9%(%('<%$$%(%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%*9$p4%

!

$B<C?9@HI<F5B9@!5:9!>J!LA5!C?!C:!;A9!,-!!

,:9!LA5!5>9J?!;A9!D<L?!5I!;A9!5:9!LA5!C?!C:!

;A9!,-!!

-B9<;!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'!!

!

SC;A!EB96C?C5:O!A9!P59?!;5!;A9!$A<B<5AO!D)!E)!

A)!

!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!_`"O!W"k!_`bO!W`)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$1!(2!WO!W#`^W#b)!!YCB9J!WVV_2![[_^Vb)!$C9AD!WVVa^W_`"O!(2!W`_^WW"k!W[b^W[#)!!/C?9B8<::!W__b2!ab^V`)!!YCB9J!WV_W2![[]^[Vb)!!-:CB?!h!-B5;A9!h!-7M?6A!W__#2!b#^V")!!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!W_bO!:5)!aVW)!!

! !

Page 356: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #"`!

T)(()"b! 'A9>9?!W!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!?;9D9!5I!\0&2+2*--%

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 'A9>9?)!'A7;)!(((!^!%8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! TC5PB<EAC6<D!C:?6BCE;C5:)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%DD)!b^aG%**%$0%#")%$(%#'"2#&%%%

!

U5!I<7D;!5I!8C:9!6<89!57;!C:!;A9!#'"2#&!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!.&N!(Y2!W]VWO_)!$9;BC9!WV_a2!ED)!Wb)!!

! !

Page 357: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #"W!

T)(()"a! ''!W"W!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!YCZC9B!>1(*^02#+!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 'A9>9?)!'A7;)!(((!h!%8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

DD)!W^bG!)"+%*#0'%-(#'%*#0'%(%8.&.0%*:%$(<20+'%*#0'%;$'<%=*2)"+2?,%+.$%,*)%#'&%8#+0%#(+0%*#0'%!"#0:%#,-0%#'%0,,0%$(<0%)*'<%0+0%*0%#'"2#&%!*<'%#+0%@+%(%,-94%+%*.%)+'%*#0'%8,*)%0.&%#*;:%%

!

%!?9??C5:!5I!;A9!MC:P!LAC6A!;55M!ED<69!C:!;A9!

e<7@C9:69!A<DDf!5I! ;A9!S9?;!?C@9!>J!MC:P!=*2)"+2?,% e'A7;85?9! (((f! PCF9:! DCI9)! 4B<L! 5I!

5IIC6C<D?! e<:@! ;A9! IBC9:@?! 5I! ;A9! :5>D9! MC:PfO!

;A9!@CP:C;<BC9?!5I!;A9!EBCF<;9!<7@C9:69!B558O!

;A9!6A<8>9BD<C:?O!;A9!8<P:<;9?!5I!;A9!#'"2#&O!;A9!9:;57B<P9!5I!oX5B7?!C:!;A9!,-r!;5!65:?7D;!;A9! <II<CB?! 5I! ;A9! MC:P% e8<J! A9! DCF9O! >9!

EB5?E9B57?!<:@!L9DDf!

!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!W"V`!W[^Wak!W"V]2!WV^W_)!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!4ZC5>9M!W__]2!#bO!ED)!VW)!!

!

!

!

! !

Page 358: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #"[!

T)(()"#! 'A9>9?![!

456789:;!;C;D9! $<EJB7?!65:69B:C:P!;A9!C:?;<DD<;C5:!5I!YCZC9B!W2#+!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 'A9>9?)!'A7;)!(((!h!%8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%87*9C%*;%'&0<%$0%@+:%(%"+94%$'4%$'<0%*#0'%(%,-94%

!

R57!=;A9!YCZC9BG!<EEB5<6A!;A9!+5B@!5I!;A9!;L5!

D<:@?!LA9:!X5B7?!C?!C:!AC?!A57?9O!;A9!I<;A9B^

MC:P!LA9:!;A9!B7DC:P!MC:P!C?!C:!AC?!,-!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

'9K;!<:@!E7>DC6<;C5:2!.&N!(Y2!W"V]O!WV^W_)!

!

! !

Page 359: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #""!

T)(()"V! ''!#]!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:?!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!H*D0E2*<!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3A9CMA!%>@!9D^l7B:<)!'A7;)!(((O!%8)!((!<:@!'A7;)!(Y)!!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)!(:?6BCE;C5:!B9I9BBC:P!;5!;A9!5L:9B!<:@!AC?!LCI9!

T)!$B<C?9!;5!;A9!MC:P)!

*)! 'C;D9?! B9E9<;9@! ?9F9B<D! ;C89?! C:! ;A9! ;58>! <:@! 5;A9B!

85:789:;?!5I!H*D0E2*<)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%%)%(*%-#0%(%#'"2#&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%T)%.$94%,*)%0.&%#*;%*.(%$;%(%#'"2#&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%%*)!,Z%-+%*;94%.#+0%(%,-%%%7+%-+<2$;%*%_(<%,-%

!cCB8!5I!EB<C?9?HI<F5B?!C:!;A9!#'"2#&I%D)!E)!A)!!X9! PCF9?! DCI9!EB5?E9BC;J! <:@!A9<D;AO! ?L99;!5I!A9<B;!C:!;A9!#'"2#&O!D)!E)!A)!!!,:9!LA5!A<?!<669??!;5!AC?!+5B@!C:!;A9!?<6B9@!ED<69!C:!;A9%,-%%c<F5BC;9!5I!;A9!5:9!LA5!C?!C:!;A9!,-%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!W``_O!Wk!W`W"O!W#k!W`WaO!ak!W`WaO!W[k!W`WaO!Wb)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$1!(O!W2!W]]^W]a)!!36A9CD!WV_W2!b_W^a`")!!TB<6M!h!TB<6M!W_#b)!!TB<6M!h!TB<6M!W_##2!"a)!!!!

! !

Page 360: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #"]!

T)(()"_! ''!#"!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!;58>!5I!NW!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 'A9>9?)!X<;?A)!

49?6BCE;C5:! %) (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!D9I;!E<B;!5I!;A9!:5B;AL9?;!L<DD)!

T) (:?6BCE;C5:! IB58! ;A9! 69:;B<D! E<B;! 5I! ;A9! :5B;A9<?;!

L<DD)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)!

6)!_G%0#'*%*(''%(%"+2*#0'%,*)%0.&%#*;%

T)!

#(*%$&0'%(%"+2*#0'%,*)%0.&%#*;!

!

,:9!LA5!?;BC@9?!IB99DJ!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'O!D)!E)!A)!

!

,:9!LA5!8<C:;<C:9@!;A9!5IIC69?!C:!;A9%"+2*#0'O!D)E)A)!

U5;9?2!W!'A9!:<89!5I!;A9!5L:9B!5I!;A9!;58>!A<?!>99:!9B<?9@!<:@!6<::5;!>9!8<@9!57;!LC;A!

69B;<C:;JO!?992!3<F9^35@9B>9BPA!W_b#2!W)!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!3<F9^35@9B>9BPA!W_b#)!%

% %

Page 361: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #"b!

T)(()]`! ''!"b"!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!5*2*2=0'%<;!49CB!9D^T<A<BC!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 'A9>9?O!49CB!9D^T<A<BC)!X<;?A)!!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!S9?;!L<DDO!?57;A!?96;C5:)W%T)!'A9!I<D?9!@55B!?;9D9!)[!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%%)!*;'%,-%%T)!-+<2'"%,&%(%"+2*#0'%%

!!1C?;B9??!5I!;A9!,-%!!-B9<;!6AC9I!C:!;A9%"+2*#0'!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!W!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;9K;2!+9C;Z![``[O!(Y2!"[)!!45B8<:!W__W2!ED)!a_O!3S![b)![!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;9K;2!45B8<:!W__W2!W"aO!*#]k!ED)!#`^#W)!!45B8<:!W__V2!WW`O!%EE9:@CK!")!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$1!(O!W2!]W#^]WV)!!N<8EE!W_aa2!bVV)!!

! !

Page 362: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #"a!

T)(()]W! ''!#W!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!5*2*2=0')!!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3A9CMA!%>@!9D^l7B:<)!X<;?A)!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)!(:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!:5B;A%L<DD)W%T)!47<D!5II9BC:P!?69:9?!IB58!C:;9BC5B!DC:;9D!5I!8<C:!@55BL<J)[!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%%)!..0'%*9$%*''%(%$;%#0.0%*9$%[$(*']%0.9*9$%(%#'"2#&%,*)%0.&%#*;%-+%C&'%$;%-('9#%+%P.%99%%%T)!'9K;!#O!"#G%-+<2'"%,&%(%"+2*#0'%%

!!SA<;!C?!C:!;A9!A9<B;!C?!?E5M9:!;5!89O!LA<;!C?![AC@@9:]!C?!B9F9<D9@!;5!89)!(!6588<:@9@!C:!;A9!#'"2#uI%D)!E)!A)O!ED<::C:P!;A9!@9?CB9!5I!A9B!1<d9?;J!;5!>7CD@!))!%!-B9<;!6AC9I!C:!;A9%"+2*#0'!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

'9K;2!W.&N!(Y2!]``OW")!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!45B8<:!W_VV)!!

45B8<:!W__W2!"#O!'9K;!#k!$D)!W"<O>)!![45B8<:!W__W2!$D)!_<O>)!!

45B8<:!W__b2!V"^V_)!!

$1!(O!W2!W"_^W][)!!

N<8EE!W__a2![_V^"`[O!ICP?)!WV]^WV#)!

!

! !

Page 363: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #"#!

T)(()][! ''!#W>!

456789:;!;C;D9! ,?;B<65:!IB58!;A9!'58>!5I!5*2*2=0'!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3A9CMA!%>@!9D^l7B:<O!''!#W)!X<;?A)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'C;D9?!B9E9<;9@!?9F9B<D!;C89?!5:!<:!5?;B<6<!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!

5*2*2=0'!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%$(<2+%,7*0'<%%$(<2+%7*0%%$(<2+%"+2*#0'%%$(<2+%"+2*#0'%-('%D;$&E%%

!,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!,7*0'<!!,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!7*0%%,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'%%,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!65EE9B!5I!;A9%"+2*#0'!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;9K;2!X9D6M!W_bV2!]#a)!!X<J9?!W_][2!]b!II)!U5?)!]#O!B96;5![k!b_^aWk!V"O!Wk!W"WO!"k!W]`O!W)!!!

!

! !

Page 364: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #"V!

T)(()]"! T1!WbW"!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:?!5:!;A9!?;<;79!5I!5*2*2=0'!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!X<;?A)!

49?6BCE;C5:! &9@!\7<B;ZC;9!67>9!?;<;79)!!

%)!cB5:;!?C@9!!T)!&57:@!?C@9!5I!><?9?!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)!

$(<2+%,7*0'<%%%T)!

+.$9#*%0$%+%+&%"+2*#0'%,*)%0.&%#*;%0;&2-+%(%0&'%,-%%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!,7*0'<%%!

,:9!LA5!C?!6D9<B!?CPA;9@!5:!;A9!L<J!5I!;A9!,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;9K;2!X9D6M!W_bV2!]#a)!!X'T1!Y2!_k!ED)![_)!!!!

! !

Page 365: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #"_!

T)(()]]! T1!W#]!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:?!5:!<!?C;;C:P!?;<;79!5I!5*2*2=0'!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!X<;?A)!

49?6BCE;C5:! TD<6M!PB<:C;9!?;<;79!5I!5*2*2=0'!C:!,?CBC<:!I5B8O!A5D@C:P!;A9!

EBC:69??!F4+02?,!C:!;A9!I5D@?!5I!AC?!B5>9!!

%)!cB5:;!?C@9!!T)!&CPA;!?C@9!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)!$(<2+%,7*0'<%%T)!(*%-#0'%(%#'"2#&%

!,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!,7*0'<%%!cCB8!5I!EB<C?9?HI<F5B?!C:!;A9%#'"2#&%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;9K;2!X9D6M!W_bV2!]#a)!!X'T1!Y2!W`^WW2!ED)!"`H"[)!!

! !

Page 366: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #]`!

T)(()]b! 'A9>9?!q!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!?;<;79!5I!5*2*2=0'!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! '98ED9!5I!17;O!'A9>9?)!X<;?A)!

49?6BCE;C5:! N:99DC:P! ?;<;79! 5I! 5*2=0'! A5D@C:P! >9I5B9! AC8! <! X<;A5B^

A9<@9@!?ABC:9)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!><6M!5I!;A9!?;<;79!LC;A![[!

A5BCZ5:;<D!DC:9?!5I!AC9B5PDJEA?)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!WbG%)+"%,-%%DD)!W#^VG%)+"%)+"0%-+%C&D0E'%*;D0E'%*'%"+2*#0'!

!

,:9!LA5!C?!<;!;A9!A9<@H65:;B5DD9B!5I!;A9!,-%%*5:;B5DD9B!5I!;A9!65:;B5DD9B?!5I!<DD!;A9!L5BM?!

5I!;A9!"+2*#0'%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;9K;2!T9:?5:!h!-57BD<JO!WV__2!E)!"`"!=WbO!W#^VG)!

%

! !

Page 367: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #]W!

T)(()]a! ''!W[#!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!C:!;A9!;58>!5I!5(2(2$&-!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3A9CMA!%>@!9D^l7B:<)!X<;?A)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 3;9D9!D56<;9@!C:!IB5:;!5I!;A9!I<D?9^@55B!<;!;A9!>5;;58!5I!;A9!

;58>!LC;A!"b!A5BCZ5:;<D!DC:9?!5I!C:?6BCE;C5:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

"D)![G%0+%-#0'%(%"+2*#0'%,*)%0.&%#*;%%!

!-B9<;!5I!EB<C?9?HI<F5B?!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'I%D)!E)!A)!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N)!(Y2!]_]2!W#)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$1!(2!WO![]W^[]")!!T57BC<:;!WV_`2!W#]!II)!!N<8EE!W_aa2!]W#^]WVO!ICP)!"`V)!3wF9^3x@9B>9BPA%W_b#2!WW^[W)!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2![]#O!:5)!Vb`k![]VO!:5)!VbW)!!

! !

Page 368: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #][!

T)(()]#! *-!b#_!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;<;79!5I!5*2*2=0'!C:!;A9!;98ED9!5I!17;!<;!N<B:<M!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<M)!X<;?A)!

49?6BCE;C5:! Y5;CF9!?;<;79!5I%5*2*2=0'%5II9BC:P!<!?C?;B78)!!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!VG%#,&0%#(*)0%%%D)!_G%C&0'%**%#7%-+%($%0.'%(%#'"2#&%,*)%0.&%#*;%0.9*94!0**%[-+%#99]%%%D)!W`G%*% ,&'%(*)94%-+2$;%)"+%*%(D$E%0.'% ,P&0%(*)%(%$+'%($%#'%$;%*'%-(94%+9#%%%D)!WbG%#(+%)+"%,-%*#0'%%%D)!W#G%)+"%C&0'%*;'%*%"+2*#0'%,*)%0.&%#*;%

!

,:9! LA5! 8<M9?! ;A9! L5BM?! PB9<;! <:@!

9K69DD9:;O!!

=(Q8G! :5;! @9<I! ;5! LA<;! L<?! 6588<:@9@! C:!

;A9! #'"2#&I% D)! E)! A)! (;!L<?! 6588<:@9@! ;5!89!

;5!>9![5:!<6657:;]!!

5I!;A9!PB9<;:9??!5I!AC?!9K69DD9:;!C:!;A9!A9<B;)!

,:9! 9K69DD9:;! C:! <6;C:P! C:! <665B@! LC;A! ;A9!

@9?CB9!5I!XC?!1<d9?;J!5F9B!C;)!

!

*58E<:C5:! <:@! 65:;B5DD9B! 5I! ;A9! ,-! 5I! ;A9!MC:P!

!

*5:;B5DD9B!5I!;A9!9F9BJ!L5BM!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'I%D)!E)!A)!

%U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!]`_O!Wbk!]WWO!Vk!]WWO!Wa)!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!X9D6M!W_bV2!]#])!!45B8<:!W_VV2![W`O!%EE9:@CK!")!!36A7D8<:!W_a_^#`2!]`)!!T5B6A<B@;!W_WW^W_"aO!((2!W[#^W"`O!$D)!__)!!T9:?5:!^!-57BD<J!WV__2!"``!II)%!

!

! !

Page 369: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #]"!

T)(()]V! ''!__!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:?!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!5*D$E2*4+!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3A9CMA!%>@!9D^l7B:<)!X<;?A)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%$(<28$;:%$(<%,-%%$*P%'&0<%*%*;%,-%%%-+<2'"%#(+0%,-%!

!c<F5BC;9!5I!;A9!5:9!LA5!C?!C:!;A9!,-!!!,:9!LA5!7:C;9?!;A9!'L5!+<:@?!I5B!;A9!+5B@!5I!;A9!,-!!*AC9I!5I!;A9!658E<:C5:?!5I!;A9!,-%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!b]`O!"k!b]WO!W#)!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;9K;2!$1!(2!WO!W_#^[`")!!T5F5;!W__#2!W`b^WW`)!!TB56M![``W<2!"#a^"V")!49?B56A9?^U5>D9657B;!W_Va)!!U9D?5:!W_Va2!"a^]W)!!N<8EE!W_aa2!"a`^"a]O!ICP?)!["b^[]")!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!]["O!:5)!W]][)!!

!

%

!

!

!

%

%

%

!

!

! !

Page 370: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #]]!

T)(()]_! 3CD?CD9A!WW!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!5*<2*4+!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! -9>9D!3CD?CD9AO!?ABC:9!:5)!WW)!%8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! !(:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!B558!TO!:5B;A!L<DD)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%-+<%'&%,'%"+2,&%(%*-0'%+#<'%

!*AC9I! 5I! ;A9! 6A<8>9BH?;5B9B558!5I! ;A9!"+2,&!C:!;A9!357;A9B:!*C;J!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!*<8C:5?!^!g<89?!W_a"2!ED)!["![)!!

! !

Page 371: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #]b!

T)(()b`! ''!*W!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!?;9D9!5I!>1(*2-'"!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 'A9>9?)!%8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! TD<6M!PB<:C;9!?;<;79!LC;A! ;9K;! C:6C?9@! C:! I57B;99:!A5BCZ5:;<D!

DC:9?!5:!;A9!@B9??O!C:!;L5!F9B;C6<D!65D78:?O!5:9!5:!9<6A!?C@9!

5I! ;A9! 7EE9B! ?7BI<69! 5I! ;A9! E9@9?;<D! <:@! C:! ICF9! A5BCZ5:;<D!

DC:9?!5:!;A9!IB5:;!5I!;A9!E9@9?;<D)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%-8#<:%*%*;%'&0<%(%,-!

!

$B<C?9@HI<F5B9@!5:9!5I!;A9!+5B@!5I!;A9!'L5!

+<:@?!5I!;A9!,-%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!W_"VO!WW)!!

! !

Page 372: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #]a!

T)(()bW! ''!]V!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!>1(*2(2-&'%!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 'A9>9?O!''!]V)!%8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!:5B;A9B:!<B6AC;B<F9!5I!;A9!;ACB@!A<DD)!

T)!Y<7D;!;9K;!5F9B!;A9!:5B;A9B:!<B6AC;B<F9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%%9%-+<2'"%,&%(%"+2*#0'%%T)%+)%#!'&%*;%*%,-%

!

-B9<;!6AC9I!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'%!

3E5M9?8<:!LA5!8<M9?H6<7?9?!E9<69!eC:f!;A9!

,-!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;9K;2!3wF9^3x@9B>9BPA!W_b#2!ED)!]`)!%

! !

Page 373: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #]#!

T)(()b[! ''!_"!

456789:;!;C;D9! 'A9><:!;58>!5I!;A9!ACPA!?;9L<B@!o*2>1(*!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3A9CMA!%>@!9D^l7B:<)!%8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!L9?;!A<DDO!:5B;A!?C@9!5I!;A9!X<DD!

T)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!?57;A!?C@9!5I!;A9!L9?;!S<DD)!!

*)!,;A9B!9KEB9??C5:?!C:!;A9!;58>)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)!!

D)!"G!0,'<!$(<0%)'%,-%%%D)!WVG%0+0%,-%%T)!

6)!WG%$+'<94%"0%$0%*#0'%(%,-94%%%6)!VG%$+%-##'%$(<2,-%%*)!

$09*%+",'%-&'<2,%(+0'%(%#'"2#&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%%(-%"+2*#0'%(%-.%-+%*;0%,&'%*;'%!"#'%%%#,+%(&,'%+%,-%

!

.:C\79!5I!;A9!5:9?!LA5!<B9!C:!;A9!,-!!!

'A9!PB9<;!5:9?!5I!;A9!,-!!!

!

,:9!LA5!L<?!AC?!9J9?!LA9:!;A9!MC:P!L<?!C:!

;A9!,-%!

,:9!LA5!@C@!LA<;!C?!I<F5B9@HEB<C?9@!LC;AC:!

;A9!,-%%%(!L<?!;A9!A9B9@C;<BJ!EBC:69!<:@!8<J5BO!

>9D5F9@!C:!;A9!#'"2#&I%D)!E)!A)!!

,:9!LA5!ICDD?!;A9!"+2*#0'%LC;A!?CDF9BO!P5D@!<:@!<DD!65?;DJHF<D7<>D9!?;5:9H89;<D!

!

,:9!LA5!EB9?9:;?!;B7;AH<6;?!BCPA;I7DDJ!

;5L<B@?!;A9!,-%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!!

'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!W"VbO!V^_k!W"VaO!W_k!W"_`)!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!$1!(2!WO!W_`^W_])!!

4<FC9?!W_"`2!ED)!Vk!W"k![bk!bVO%)!!

49L<6A;9B!W_V`2!a_^#") N<8EE!W_aa2!"b[^"baO!ICP)!["`)!!

4<FC9?!W_"`2!ED)!Wa!=aGk!]]O!]k!"b)!

*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!WbbO!:5)!b[#k!b`]O!:5)!W#`a)!

!

! !

Page 374: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #]V!

T)(()b"! ''!W`W!

456789:;!;C;D9! 'A9><:!;58>!5I!;A9!6AC9I^D96;5B!EBC9?;!H*20+0!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3A9CMA!%>@!9D^l7B:<)!%8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! TC5PB<EAC6<D!C:?6BCE;C5:!5I!;A9!;58>)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!bG!,P%-#$%8"+$:%8.$:%'+<'%*%$(<%,-%%%!D)!WbG%0+%(%$&0'94%(%"+2*#0'%!

!/:;9BC:P!I<F5B9@HEB<C?9@!ePCFC:Pf!B9?E96;?!;5!;A5?9!LA5!<B9!C:!;A9!,-!!(8E5B;<:;!5:9!C:!AC?!5IIC69?!C:!;A9%"+2*#0'%

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N)!(Y2!W]#]O!Wbk!W]#bO!])!$7>DC6<;C5:2!4<FC9?!W_"b2!ED)![O!ICP)!VO!E)!b")!!N<8EE!W_aa2!"#"^"#bO!ICP?)![b"^[b])!!$1!(OW2![W]^[Wb)!!1<6N<J!W_W]2!VV^_aO!9?E)!E)!_W)!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2![]"O!:5)!V"#)!!

! !

Page 375: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #]_!

T)(()b]! %8<B<A!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!;A9!FC69B5J!5I!U7>C<!W#+2#&''!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %8<B<A!S9?;)!%8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! #!A5BCZ5:;<D!DC:9?!C:?6BCE;C5:?!<;!;A9!>5;;58!5I!;A9!?;9D9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%DD)!b^aG%+.$9*94%0+%-&'<2,%#(+0%#,&9*94%+%0+0%"+2*#0'!!!

!1<@9!PB9<;!<:@!8<J5B!5I!;A9!657B;C9B?O!LA5!8<M9?!;A98!PB9<;9B!;A<:!;A9!PB9<;!5:9?!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!W]VbO![`)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!c<CB8<:!W_"_2!ED)!0Y()Wk!!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!W_bO!:5)!aVW)!!

! !

Page 376: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #b`!

T)(()bb! ''!a]!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!@C&2+2*--!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3A9CMA!%>@!9D^l7B:<)!'A7;)!(Y)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'C;D9?!5I!;A9!5L:9B!B9E9<;9@!C:!?9F9B<D!?96;C5:?!5I!AC?!;58>)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%(*%-#0D'E%(%#'"2#&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%-#<%*%$(<%,-%%#,&9*%*;%'&0<%(%,-%

!

cCB8!5I!EB<C?9?HI<F5B?!C:!;A9!#'"2#&I%D)!E)!A)!!

$B<C?9@HI<F5B9@!5:9!C:!;A9!,-%%,:9!LA58!;A9!+5B@!5I!;A9!'L5!+<:@?!6<7?9@!;5!>9!PB9<;!C:!;A9!,-%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!Wb#"O!WVk!Wb#]O!WWk!Wb#]O!WV)!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!N<8EE!W__a2![V"O!ICP)!W#[)!!

$1!(OW2!W[V^W[_)!!

+9E?C7?!W_#"O!(((2![a`)!!

U9L>9BBJ!W_[V2!V])!

!

! !

Page 377: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #bW!

T)(()ba! ''!#a!

456789:;!;C;D9! 'A9><:!;58>!5I!;A9!ACPA!?;9L<B@!H*0*&!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3A9CMA!%>@!9D^l7B:<)!'A7;)!(Y)!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!5:9!5I!;A9!ECDD<B?!5I!;A9!A<DD)!

T)!(:?6BCE;C5:?!5:!;A9!D9I;!L<DD!5I!;A9!9:;B<:69!A<DD)!

*)! (:?6BCE;C5:! B9D<;9@! ;5! ;A9! B9EB9?9:;<;C5:! 5I! ;A9! 5II9BC:P!

5L:9B!!

4)!'C;D9!5I!;A9!5L:9B!C:!;A9!;58>!

/)!$CDD<B!C:?6BCE;C5:!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)!6)!WG%)'(0%;$'<%,&%(%"+2*#0'%%%6)!]G%0,'<%(-2$;%*%*;2'&0<%-#<%*%$(<%,-!!T)!6)!V^_G!-#<%*%$(<%,-!!6)!WWG!)+"%G(,0%H&2(-0%(-%"+2*#0'%(%-0%.4&0!!*)!6)!]G%"+%(%-#0%(%#'"2#&%,*)%0.&%#*;%!4)!(-%"+2*#0'%,*)%0.&%#*;%(%-0%.4&0%!/)!#.'8<:%D#.'<E%@+%(%,-94%!

!-B9<;!?9<D9B!5I!.EE9B!<:@!+5L9B!/PJE;!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%%c<F5B9@!>J!;A5?9!LA5!<B9!C:!;A9!,-!!!$B<C?9@HI<F5B9@!5:9!>J!LA5!C?!C:!;A9!,-!!%@8C:C?;B<;5B!5I!;A9!.EE9B!<:@!+5L9B!/PJE;O!5:9!LA5!ICDD?!;A9!"+2*#0'%I55@!<:@!EB5FC?C5:?!!!,:9!LA5!6589?!I5B;A!IB58!;A9!#'"2#&O!D)!E)!A)O!LC;A!EB<C?9?HI<F5B?!!,:9!LA5!ICDD?!;A9!"+2*#0'O!D)!E)!AO!LC;A!I55@!<:@!EB5FC?C5:?!!c5B?;9B!6ACD@!5I!X5B7?!C:!AC?!,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!

'9K;2!!.&N)!(Y2!Wb#VO!W"O!Wa^W#k!Wb#_O!_k!WbVWO!WO!a)!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!$1!(2!WO!W]_^Wb`)!!

$C9AD!WVVa^W_`"O!(2!W`V!/<)!!

T57BC<:;!WVV_2!Wba^WbV)!!

N<8EE!W__a2!"W[^"W"O!ICP)!W__)!!

3wF9^3x@9B>9BPA!W_b#2!b`^b[)!

*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!W_bO!:5)!aVW)!

!

Page 378: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #b[!

T)(()b#! ''!#V!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!;A9!B96B7C;C:P!?6BC>9?!@+2(2-;%!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3A9CMA!%>@!9D^l7B:<)!'A7;)!(Y)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%$(<2+%"+2*#0'%%%$(<2+%"+%*%,'%"+2,&%%%,P%7+%*4+'%;0%7+%*#0'%"+%(%-#0%(%#'"2#&%,*)%0.&%#*;!

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'%!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!A57?9!5I!;A9!B558!5I!;A9!"+2,&%%,:9! LA5! 9:;9B?! >9<BC:P! P55@! ;AC:P?! ;5! ;A9!

ED<69! >9<BC:P! ;A9! MC:P! <:@! 5:9! LA5! 6589?!

I5B;A! IB58! ;A9! #'"2#&O! D)! E)! A)O! LC;A!

EB<C?9?HI<F5B?!

!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!Wb_[O!Wb^Wa)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!T57BC<:;!WVV_2!]W"^]"]O!ED)!Y)!!TB<6M!h!TB<6M!W_V`2![b)!!$1!(O!W2!Wb[^Wba)!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!]#O!:5)!WbV)!!

! !

Page 379: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #b"!

T)(()bV! ''!_`!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!;A9!E5DC69^6AC9I!F;2>1(*!!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3A9CMA!%>@!9D^l7B:<)!'A7;)!(Y)!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!L9?;!L<DDO!?57;A!?C@9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)!

6)!WG%+*"'%L%%6)![G%0&.D'E2&0D<'E%%6)!"G%(%-(%*%#'"2#&%,*)%0.&%#*;%(%7+0%%6)!]G%"*%*%-&'<2,%'#0%,-,0%%6)!bG%*0%G(,0%H&2(-0%'&%0&.%%6)!aG%*%-(%,*)%0.&%#*;%!#"%$&0'%*4+0'%(%-#0%[*'%)+]%*#0'%+%$+'%%6)!#G%)+'0%*%'&<0%#+<'%F;[2>1(*]%*%*#0'%-,0%[>1(*]%2(+0'%0*%"-9*94%$&0'%$094%-+%!(#%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%(''%*%$;94%%%%T)!

,&%(%"+2*#0'%!

!

R9<B!a)!

%!6588<:@!C??79@!!

C:!;A9!8<d9?;J!5I!;A9!#'"2#&%D)!E)!A)!5:!;AC?!@<J!;5!;A9!8<J5BO!6588<:@9B!5I!;A9!ID99;!!

5I!?57;A9B:!<:@!:5B;A9B:!/PJE;)!'A9!

6588<:@!

<?!?<C@2!o1J!1<d9?;JO!D)!E)!A)O!A<?!6588<:@9@!

;A9!B969CFC:P!5I!<!P55@!5D@!<P9!C:!I<F5B?!

e>9I5B9!;A9f!MC:PO!C:!5B@9B!;5!?9;;D9!;A9!<II<CB?!

5I!;A9!3;<:@<B@^>9<B9B!F;[2>1(*]%5I!;A9!MC:PQ?!>5<;?!T9D5F9@!5I!e%87:fr)!X9!B9<6A9@!

;A9!5D@!<P9O!A9!C?!5:!I5DD5LC:P!;A9%"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)!=<:@G!AC?!B96;C;7@9)!

!

-B9<;!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!WaWVO!b^W")!.&N!(Y!Wa[[O!W[)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!4<FC9?!W_[">2!W^WVO!ED)![a)!!N<8EE!W_aa2!"]V^"]_O!ICP)![[a)!!$1!(OW2!WV"^WVb)!!

! !

Page 380: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #b]!

T)(()b_! T1!W]V!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9! 5I! F4+2-&'O! 6AC9I! 5I! L5BM89:! 5I! ;A9! '98ED9! 5I!

'A7;85?9!(Y!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!'A7;)!(Y)!

49?6BCE;C5:! +C89?;5:9! B57:@^;5EE9@! ?;9D9! 5I!F4+2-&'O! LA5O! @7EDC6<;9@O!<@5B9?!,?CBC?!<:@!(?C?!5:!5:9!?C@9!<:@!1C:!5:!;A9!5;A9B)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

TG%-+<%C&0'%*%'&%-0'%*%"+2,&%(%&;.0%%%4G%$(<2+%C&0'%*%'&%-0'%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%

!

,F9B?99B! 5I!L5M?! 5I! ;A9!-0'%5I! ;A9!"+2,&% C:!%>J@5?!

!

,F9B?99B!5I!L5BM?! C:! ;A9! D<:@!5I! ;A9!-0'%5I!;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!WaW"O![!<:@!b)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!X'T1!Y((2!W"k!ED)!]")!!!

! !

Page 381: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #bb!

T)(()a`! *-!"]`[[!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:?!5:!;A9!?;9D9!5I!;A9!6AC9I!5I!L5BM89:!F4+2-&'!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!'A7;)!(Y)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 3<:@?;5:9!?;9D9)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5I!;A9!;ACB@!B9PC?;9B)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!D)!bG%-+<%C&0'%*%'&%-0'%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%

!,F9B?99B!5I!L5BM?!5I! ;A9! =85B;7<BJG! ;98ED9!5I!;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!WaW[O!Wa)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!+<6<7!W_`_2!][O!ED)!V)!!TB7P?6A!WVV"^WV_WO!Y2!_b`!I)!!$C9AD!WVVa^W_`"O!(((2!ED?)!VWPO!V[)!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!][`O!:5)!W]"W)!!

! !

Page 382: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #ba!

!

T)(()aW! +9C@9:!Y!]"!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!;A9!6588<:@9B!5I!3CD9!F;$!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!'A7;)!(Y)!

49?6BCE;C5:! &57:@^;5EE9@! ?<:@?;5:9! ?;9D9)! (:?6BCE;C5:! 5I! ;A9! D5L9B!

B9PC?;9B)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

D)!"G!$+<2",'%-&'<2,%#+%(%$&'94%,&%(%"+2*#0'%!

$BC:69!<:@!8<J5BO!:5>D9!C:!AC?!E5?C;C5:O!PB9<;!

C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!Wa"bO!#)!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!T59?9B!W_`b^W_"[O!a2!ED)!W"O![[)!%!

! !

Page 383: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #b#!

T)(()a[! ''!"V!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!\#+2C&2+2#*%%

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3A9CMA!%>@!9D^l7B:<)!'A7;)!(Y)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%*;%,-%%%

!+5B@!5I!;A9!,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!36AC<E<B9DDC!W_["^[#2!W`a)!!4<FC9?!W_[">2!W^V)!!$1!(OW2!a_^#`)!!*5889:;2!+9C;Z![``[O!(((2!a`")!!

! !

Page 384: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #bV!

T)(()a"! ''!a"!

456789:;!;C;D9! 'A9><:!;58>!5I!;A9!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!;B9<?7BJ!5;C2-'"!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3A9CMA!%>@!9D^l7B:<)!'A7;)!(Y)!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)!(:?6BCE;C5:!@9?6BC>C:P!;A9!5L:9B!FC?C;C:P!;A9!E<D<69)!

T)!(:?6BCE;C5:!@9@C6<;9@!;5!5;C2-'"%<:@!AC?!LCI9)!

*)!'C;D9!B9E9<;9@!?9F9B<D!;C89?!C:!;A9!;58>!

4)!5;C2-'"%C:!IC?AC:P!?69:9!!

/)!cB<P89:;!5I!C:?6BCE;C5:!C:!;A9!8C@@D9!65BBC@5B!5I!;A9!;58>)!

c)!cB<P89:;!5I!C:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!9:;B<:69!A<DD)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)!!

D)!WG%(&0%!*0'%*%"+2*#0'%,*)%0.&%#*;%%%D)!W[G%$+%-##0'/-##'%$(<2,-%(%7+'27+0%*'%+,%*;%%D)!W]G%(-%"+2*#0'%(%8-.%*;0:%$(<2+%)'(0'%5;C2-'"%%T)!!

D)![G%,&%(%"+2*#0'%0+%(%,-%%*)!!

-#<%*%$(<%,-%%4)!

DD)!a^#G%(&,%8*:%@+%(%,-%(%7+'27+0%*'%+,%8*;:%%/)!!

(*%-#0/-#0'%(%#'"2#&%%c)!!

0+%(%,-%%

!

*5:;B5DD9B?!5I!;A9!PB<:<BC9?!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'I%D)!E)!A)!

!

,:9!LA5!@C@!;A<;!LAC6A!C?!EB<C?9@!LC;AC:!;A9!

,-!@7BC:P!;A9!657B?9!5I!9F9BJ!@<J)!!

'A9!"+2*#0'%>9C:P!I7DD!5I!e?CDF9B!<:@!P5D@fO!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!;B9<?7BC9?H9:6D5?7B9?O!5;C2-'"!!

!

-B9<;!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'I%C8E5B;<:;!C:!;A9!,-%%%$B<C?9@HI<F5B9@!>J!LA5!C?!C:!;A9!,-!!

!

,:9!;B79!e;5f!X5B7?!C:!;A9!,-!@7BC:P!;A9!657B?9!5I!e9F9BJf!@<J!

!

cCB8!5I!EB<C?9?HI<F5B?!C:!;A9!#'"2#&%%%,:9!PB9<;!C:!;A9!,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!WbV[O!bO!W[^W"O!W#k!WbV]O!W]O!W_)!

Page 385: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #b_!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!$1!(2!WO!W_"^_]k!"a)!!$C9AD!WVVa^W_`"O!(2!W[]!U)!4ZC5>9M!^!&<ZC\!W__`)!!N<8EE!W__a2![V`^[V"O!ICP?)!WaV^W#W)!!$1!(OW2!W[b^W[V)!''!a"2!!4ZC5>9M!^!%>@9D!&<ZC\!W__`2!]`O!]aO!b`O!b[O!abO!#[)!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!W_bO!:5)!aVW)!!

! !

Page 386: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #a`!

T)(()a]! ''![_b!

456789:;!;C;D9! \-0'<2(#0%

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3A9CMA!%>@!9D^l7B:<)!'A7;)!(Y!h!%8)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!?57;A!L<DD!:9<B!;A9!B9EB9?9:;<;C5:!5I!;A9!

E<B9:;?!5I!;A9!@969<?9@!>9I5B9!<:!5II9BC:P!;<>D9)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%0+%(%,P%+%"+2*#0'!

!

-B9<;!5:9!LA5!9:;9B?!;A9!"+2*#0'%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!9D!3<J9@!h!'5?C!W_V"2!W")!

%

% %

Page 387: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #aW!

T)(()ab! *<CB5!q!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!?;<;79!5I!F)'2($*!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!%8)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! 3;<;79!PB57E!5I!F)'2($*9%

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!VG%0+%-#0'%(%,-%*%*#0'%,*)%0.&%#*;%!

!

-B9<;!5I!EB<C?9?HI<F5B?!C:!;A9!,-!5I!;A9!MC:P!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!W_`_O!Wa)!%

% %

Page 388: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #a[!

T)(()aa! *-!"]W#b!!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!?;9D9!5I!M&2?,2(2-;!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! X9DC5E5DC?)!%8)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!VG%-#$%*%*'+%*4+%7*%,-%#'"%*%*#0'!

%$B<C?C:P!;A9!P55@!P5@O!5:9!LA5!<EEB5<6A9@!;A9!,-I%EB5;96;C:P!;A9!MC:P!!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2![W#[O!WW)!!

! !

Page 389: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #a"!

T)(()a#! T1!ba_[_!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!<!8788CI5B8!ICP7B9!5I!O&2*2>1(*%

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!%8!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! Y5;CF9! 8788CI5B8! ICP7B9! 5I! O&2*2>1(*% LC;A% [! F9B;C6<D!65D78:?!5I!C:?6BCE;C5:)%

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%6)![G%(*%(+D0E'%(%"+2*#0'%%

!

cCB8!5I!D5F9!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%%

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;!<:@!E7>DC6<;C5:2!'<JD5B![``W2!:5)!_aO!E)!W"b)!%

% %

Page 390: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #a]!

T)(()aV! 198EAC?!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!?;<;79!5I!=+%"+%0+%>%1(*2-'"!!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 198EAC?)!%8)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

D)!]G!*#0'%(-2$;%0;&%-+%(%0&'%,-%+&%#7+$%(%#'"2#&%%D)!VG%,P9$%+%,-%%D)![bG%-#0D'E9$%(*%(%"+2*#0'%%

!

,:9!LA5!C?!6D9<B!?CPA;9@!5:!;A9!L<J!5I!;A9!

,-[%(Q8!;A9!857;A!;A<;!8<@9!#'"2#&!65:;9:;!%%(!9:;9B!C:!;A9%,-%%,:9!LA5?9!EB<C?9?HI<F5B?!B98<C:!ICB8!C:!;A9%"+2*#0'%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!W#_]O!bk!W#_]Oa)!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$9;BC9!W_W"2!ED)!#VHV`)!!!

! !

Page 391: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #ab!

T)(()a_! cD5B9:69!

[bab!

456789:;!;C;D9! \-0'<2(#0%

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!%8)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! &96;<:P7D<B!I<D?9^@55B!?;9D9)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!BCPA;!d<8>)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%,P%-+%.#+0%(%#'"2#&%,*)%0.&%#*;!

!

,:9!LA5!A<?!<669??!;5!;A9!?<6B9@!ED<69!C:!

;A9!#'"2#&I%D)!E)!A)!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!W_W"O!W")!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!36AC<E<B9DDC!WVV#2!*<;!:5)!Wb#`)!%

% %

Page 392: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #aa!

T)(()#`! T1!"ab!

456789:;!;C;D9! \-0'<2(#0%

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!%8)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! $<C:;9@! DC89?;5:9! B57:@^;5EE9@! ?;9D9)! (:?6BCE;C5:! IB58! ;A9!

];A! B9PC?;9B! C:! ;A9! a! 65D78:?! ;9K;! <;! ;A9! D9I;! ?C@9! 5I! ;A9!

5II9BC:P!B9EB9?9:;<;C5:)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%0,0%*%'&%7*<'%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;!

!

3<CD5B!5I!;A9!>5<;Q?!65:;C:P9:;!5I!$A<B<5AO!D)!

E)!A)!

!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!X'T1!#2!ED)!]a)!%

! !

Page 393: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #a#!

T)(()#W! T1!W[W`!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;<;79;;9!5I!;A9!?;<:@<B@!>9<B9B!O&2(#!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!%8)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! -B9J!PB<:C;9!?;<;79;;9!5I!O&2(#%C:!<!?\7<;;C:P!E5?C;C5:)!'C;D9!C:!;A9!b!A5BCZ5:;<D!DC:9?!C:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!P<B89:;)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!bG%)'(0%;$'<%,&%(%"+2*#0'!!

!39<D9B!5I!;A9!MC:P!5I!.EE9B!<:@!+5L9B!/PJE;O!PB9<;!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!W_["2!Wb)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!X'T1!Y(((2!W[^W"O!ED)!W")!!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!W_bO!:5)!aVW)!!

! !

Page 394: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #aV!

T)(()#[! +J5:!VV!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!;A9!FCZC9B!M'-2(#0!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!%8)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! &96;<:P7D<B! ?<:@?;5:9! B57:@^;5EE9@! ?;9D9)! (:! ;A9! 7EE9B!

B9PC?;9B! C:! IB5:;! 5I! ,?CBC?! ;A9B9! <B9! [! ?J889;BC6<D!

B9EB9?9:;<;C5:?!5I!;A9!5L:9B!C:!<@5B<;C5:)!'C;D9!65:;<C:9@!C:!

;A9!b!65D78:?!5I!C:?6BCE;C5:!<;!;A9!BCPA;!?C@9!5I!M'-2(#)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%6)![G%,&%(%"+2*#0'!!

!-B9<;!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!W_Wb2!W)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!Y<BCDD9!W_"`2!]_#)!!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!W_bO!:5)!aVW)!!

! !

Page 395: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #a_!

T)(()#"! *-!bV"!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;<;79!5I!Q1(*2-'"O!?5:!5I!@"0!!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<M)!%8)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! 3<:@?;5:9!67>9^?;<;79)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!67>9!D5L9B!E<B;!5I!

;A9!>5@J)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!D)!]G!$+%7"0%*%$(<2+%,-%%!D)!bG%.$%(%-+%*#0'%#(+0%(.00%"+'%(%7*0%,-%%%D)!aG%(*%-#0D'E%(%#'"2#&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%D)!#G!W+%0+0%#,-%#(+0%0,%-+!.4.0%*%$(<D0E%,-%%%D)!VG%"+D0E%D(E%-#_/-#0%(%#'"2#&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%

!,:9! LA5! 6<BBC9?! 57;! ;A9! D<L?! I5B! ;A9! 5:9!LA5!C?!C:!;A9!,-!!!*588<:@! 5I! ;A9! MC:P! ;5! ;A9! 658E<:C5:?)!S5B@?!;A<;!6589!I5B;A!;A9!7*0%5I!;A9!,-!!cCB8!5I!EB<C?9?HI<F5B?!C:!;A9!#'"2#&I%D)!E)!A)!!'A9!PB9<;!5I!;A9!P55@!5:9?!@CP:C;J!5I!IBC9:@?O!;A9!5:9!LA5!C?!7E5:!;A9!E7ECD?!5I!;A5?9!LA5!<B9!C:!;A9!,-%!,:9!LA5!6589?!I5B;A!EB<C?9?HI<F5B?!IB58!;A9!#'"2#&I%D)!E)!A)!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!WVWaO!_k!WVW#OWb)!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!T5B6A<B@;!W_WW^W_"aO!((2!W"]^W"_O!ED)!W``^W`])!!!

! !

Page 396: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ##`!

T)(()#]! '7BC:!=>G!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;<;79!5I!;A9!%87:!EBC9?;!,&**!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!%8)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! T<?<D;!?;<;79)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

D)!WG%0+%(+0'%(!"+2*#0'%(*%-#0%(%#'"2#&%%!

'A9!PB9<;!5:9!>9D5F9@!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'[%ICB8!5I!

EB<C?9?HI<F5B?!C:!;A9%#'"2#&%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!WV_]O!#^V)!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!!1<?E9B5!WVV[2!W[a)!!

! !

Page 397: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ##W!

T)(()#b! ''!b#!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!;A9!;58>!5I!B,2(2-&'9!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3A9CMA!%>@!9D^l7B:<)!%8)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%$(<2+%"+%*%D*&%*%"+<'E%%"+2,&%%$(<2+%S#%"+%*%"+2,&%%#!%*%!*0'%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%#!%-#;%$'%*%!*0'%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%%$094%0,'<%*%#'"2#&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%0+%(%$&'94%(%"+2*#0'%,*)%0.&%#*;%

!,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!A57?9!5I!;A9!"+2,&%%,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!?C@9!5I!;A9!A57?9!5I!;A9%"+2,&%%36BC>9!5I!;A9!PB<:<BJ!5I!;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)!!36BC>9! <:@! B96M5:9B! 5I! ;A9! 65B:! C:! ;A9!PB<:<BJ!5I!;A9!$A<B<5AO!D)!E)!A)!!X9!C?!;A9!5:9!C:!;A9!#'"2#&I%D)!E)!A)!!-B9<;!5:9!C:!AC?!5IIC69!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'I%D)!E)!A)!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!WV]WO!WWk!WV][O!"!<:@!W]k!WV]]O!#k!WV]]O!W#k!WV]#2!W)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!SB9?ZC:?MC!W_[#O!(2![`"^bk!WV_k!W_`k!W_#^V)!!TB56M![``W>2!"a]^"#b)!!N<8EE!W__a2![a#^[a_O!ICP)!Wba)!!$1!(O!W2!WW"^WW_)!!+5B9;!WVV_2!WW"^W"[)!!Y<BCDD9!W_]`2!ED)!ab=WG)!*5889:;2!X9D6M!W_bV2!b``)!!%D^%J9@C![``a2!bbaO!:5)!WVb")!!

! !

Page 398: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ##[!

T)(()#a! ''!WVW!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!;A9!;58>!5I!F;2>1(*!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! NA5MA<)!%8)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%0*2,&%*$0'%(%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%

!455B!5E9:9B! C:! ;A9! 6C;J!LC;A! ;A9!$A<B<5AO! D)!E)!A)!!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!4<FC9?!W_[b2!ED)!b)!!N<8EE!W_aa2!]a#^a_O!ICP)!"a])!!19MAC;<BC<:!W__#2![W^[V)!$1!(O!W2![Va^V_)!!

! !

Page 399: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ##"!

T)(()##! 1<DM<;<!

456789:;!;C;D9! *C;<;C5:?!5I!=+<2M'-!C:!<!d<B^D<>9D!IB58!1<DM<;<!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 1<DM<;<)!%8)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

D)!"]G! $(<2+%"+%M'-%(+$09$%*% '&%-0'%"+2,&% ,*)%0.&%#*;%%D)!b_G!-(2*'+%$(<2+%"+%*%'&%-0'%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!A57?9!5I!$;<AO!(!<8!D5F9@!5I!

$;<A!5I!;A9!-0'%5I!;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)!!

$B5EA9;!<:@!?;9L<B@!5I!;A9!-0'%5I!;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)!

!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!W_b]O!W]^Wa)!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!X<J9?!W_bW2!ICP!#O!:5)!b_)!!

! !

Page 400: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ##]!

T)(()#V! 3<\\<B<!W!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:?! IB58! ;A9! ;58>! 5I! ;A9! ?7E9BC:;9:@9:;! 5I! ;A9!

A57?9!=,$&%

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3<\\<B<)!%8)!(((!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)'(0%,&%(%"+2*#0'%%$.*0%*&%*%$(*'<0%"+2-.%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%

!

-B9<;!?9<D9B!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%!

49E7;J! 5I! ;A9! L9?;9B:! =>B<:6A9?G! 5I! ;A9!

;B9<?7BJ!5I!;A9!$A<B<5AO!D)!E)!A)!

!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2![Wa"O!W"k![Wa]O!W_k![WabO![)!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!l7C>9DD!h'A58E?5:!W_W[2!ED)!aa)!!!

! !

Page 401: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ##b!

T)(()#_! ''!W_[!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:?!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!a+D$E094%C:!'A9>9?!S9?;!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! /D^%??<?CI)!%8)!(((!h!(Y)!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)!(:?6BCE;C5:!C:!;A9!?57;A!?C@9!5I!;A9!E5B;C65?!=D)!"^]G)!

T^*)! (:?6BCE;C5:! 5:! ;A9! I<69! 5I! ;A9! B56M! ;5! ;A9! BCPA;! 5I! ;A9!

@55BL<J! 65:;<C:C:P! W]! DC:9?! LAC6A! <B9! ;A9! AJ8:! ;5! &<!

?E5M9:!>J!a+D$E094%=D)!Wk!D)!W"G)!

4)!(:?6BCE;C5:!65:;<C:C:P!;A9!XJ8:!;5!,?CBC?!=D)!"G)!

/)!&CPA;!A<:@!?C@9!5I!;A9!9:;B<:69!d<8>?!=D)!"G)!

c)! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!69CDC:P!5I! ;A9!65BBC@5B! =D)!WG!<:@!5:!;A9!

?57;A!?C@9!5I!;A9!E5B;C65?!=D)!"G)!

-)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!69CDC:P!5I!;A9!65BBC@5B=D)!]G)!

X)! (:?6BCE;C5:! <>5F9! l799:! '(J9! C:! ;A9! ?69:9! B9EB9?9:;9@!

;A9!9B96;C5:!5I!;A9!4d9@!=D)!WG)!'C;D9?!B9I9BB9@!;5!;A9!\799:)!

()! (:?6BCE;C5:! 5F9B! ;A9! B9EB9?9:;<;C5:! 5I! ;A9! \799:! <:@! ;A9!

MC:P!C:!;A9!>5<;!@B<L:!>J!;L9:;J!E9B?5:?!C:!;A9!?9\79:69!5I!

;A9!@;25.%?69:9)!'A9!;C;D9!C?!B9I9BB9@!;5!;A98)!!

+)! (:?6BCE;C5:! IB58! ;A9! WW! DC:9?! ;9K;! 65::96;9@! LC;A! ;A9!

B9EB9?9:;<;C5:?!5I!;A9!@;25.!5I!MC:P!%89:A5;9E!((()!'A9!;9K;!

C?! 5F9B! ;A9! ?69:9! 5I! MC:PQ?! ><D@<6AC:k! C:! IB5:;! 5I! ;A9!

><D@<6AC:!;A9B9!<B9!;L5!;<>D9?!5:!LAC6A!<B9!EB96C57?!?;<II?)!

%665B@C:P!;5!;A9!;9K;!;A9J!L9B9!EB9?9:;9@!>J!;A9!MC:P!;5!;A9!

@CII9B9:;!5IIC6C<D?!<:@!:5>D9?!C:!566<?C5:!5I!;A9!56.^I9?;CF<D)!

1)! (:?6BCE;C5:! 5F9B! ;A9! B9EB9?9:;<;C5:! 5I! ;A9! E<D<69! C:! ;A9!

?69:9!5I!;A9!56.^I9?;CF<D)!

U)!,;A9B!;C;D9?)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!!

%)!!D)!"G%,P%+%,-%"+$%7+%-#0'%%D)! ]G% $+<2",'% -&'<2,% -+<2#!'&% *% "+2*#0'% !"#9$%D(E%#+0%(%"+2*#0'%%%T9%$(<2$;%@+%*;%,-D'E%%

!,:9! LA5! 9:;9B?! ;A9! ,-% <:@! 6589?! 57;! LC;A!EB<C?9?HI<F5B?!$BC:69!<:@!8<J5BO!M99E9B!5I!?96B9;?!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'O!5:9!LA5! C?!<669E;9@!>J! ;A9!5IIC6C<D?!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'%!c<F5B9@HEB<C?9@!5I!X5B7?O!+5B@!5I!;A9!,-D'E!!

Page 402: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ##a!

*)%$+09%"+$%(%7'%=0'94%**%&;D0E%-'"%(%7*0%%%%4)%(*%899:%%+%*--%7+%,-D'E%%%/)%7+$%*(''%(%"+2*#0'%%c)%)+"%,-%*#0'%#!%%%-)%"+$'%0*%*899:%,-%*%7+%899:%%X)% $+<2",'%0+'%-#0'%-*0'%'&0%*;0%(-%,-%(%(+0'%*#0'%%%()%#(+0%$;%#'"2#&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%+)!D)![G!*#0'%;$'<%*;% '&0<%F;2=&,'2?,% #&%(+$94%>1(*2-'"2-P&'2W&#'%.$% ,*)94% $+'%@;25.% '"<%*%-(94!!!!D)!"G!),$D'E%*#0'%+%+0'<%0+'<%"+0<%,-984:%*%-,$%%#'&%#+0%%%D)! ]G! *#0'% 899:% $(<2)*'<% *'% +('% +0'<% *#0'%+)0%$+0%,-,0%D)!bG%)+"0%,-%*#0'%#,-0%D99E%%1)!),$D'E%(%,-%$%*%*#0'%%,-94%(%"+2-,$%%U)!!0,%'"D<E%(%$#0'%"+2*#0'%%%0-(D0E%'"<%*#0'%*%$(<2,-%%

X9! 6<7?9?! ;A9! 9:;B<:69! C:! ;A9! >5@J! 5I! AC?!85;A9BO! ;A9! E9<69! :5;! >9C:P! 69<?9@! C:! ;A9!7*0%%cCB8!e))f!9;9B:<DDJ!C:!;A9!,-D'E%!,:9!ED9<?C:P!5I!?;9E!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%%,:9!LA5! C?! <;! ;A9! A9<@H65:;B5DD9B! 5I! ;A9! ,-I%B5J<D!?6BC>9!!/:;B<:69!5E9:!;5!;A9!,-%e))f!!X9B9@C;<BJ!EBC:69??O! PB9<;!5I! I<F5B?O!8C?;B9??!5I!9F9BJ! D<:@O! ICDDC:P! ;A9! ,-%<?!>9D5F9@!5I! ;A9!MC:P!!*58E<:C5:?!5I!A9<B;!5I!;A9!#'"2#&I%D)!E)!A)!!!NC:P! 5I! .EE9B! <:@! +5L9B! /PJE;O! 5I! ;A9! 'L5!+<:@?!?5:!5I!F;2=&,'2?,I%AC?!D5F9@!4%>1(*2-'"2-P&'2W&#'I%8<J!A9! PCF9! DCI9O! >9C:P!8<@9! ;A9!ICB?;!@;25.%>J!XC?!1<d9?;JO!<EE9<B<:69!5I!;A9!MC:P!<;!;A9!@57>D9!P<;9?!5I!,-!=qGI%5I!B9d5C69O!ID5L!5I!B5J<D!657B;C9B?!e))f% EBC9?;?! 5I! ;A9! E95ED9! =P5C:PG! ;5! ;A9!P<;9L<JO! <6\7<C:;<:69! 5I! ;A9! MC:PO! ;A9!<@8C:C?;B<;5B?!5I!;A9!?ACE?O!;A9!65:;B5DD9B?!5I!;A9!,-I%!<@8C:C?;B<;5B!5I!;A9!65:;B5DD9B?!5I!;A9!?<6B9@!>5<;?!5I!;A9!,-I%B5J<D!@CP:C;<BC9?!=))G!!%EE9<BC:P!C:!;A9!,-!C:!B9D<;C5:!;5!;A9!MC:P!!XC?!,-%C:!;A9%X57?9!5I!&9d5C69!!!.:C\79! 5:9! LA5! C?! ;A9! ICB?;! <85:P! ;A9!L5BM9B?H?;<II!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'%%cCB?;!B5J<D!A9B<D@!5I!;A9!5:9!LA5!C?!C:!;A9!,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!WVa]Obk!WVa#O!#k!WVaVO!WO!WWO!Wak!WVaVO!W[O!Wak!WV#[O!W[O!WbO!WVk!WV#"O![O!a)!!!

$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!c<MABJ!W_]"2!]bV!II)!!

*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!]][O!:5)!Wb[`)!

!

Page 403: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ###!

T)(()V`! ''!W_[!>C?!

456789:;!;C;D9! XJ8:!;5!;A9!37:!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!a+D$E094%C:!'A9>9?!S9?;!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! /D^%??<?CI)!%8)!(Y)!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!:5B;A!?C@9!5I!;A9!F9?;C>7D9)!

%)!XJ8:!;5!;A9!&C?C:P!37:)!

T)!XJ8:!;5!;A9!39;;C:P!37:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%%)!6)!W^[G% $&0%?,%.0&%8-'":94%(%,-%,*)%&)'%*'%"'%8$*:%$+<2",'%-&'<2,%$(<2$;%@+%*;%,8-:%8$(<2+%"+:%*#0'%-('%0+'%$(<2+%"+%'"<%a+094%8(&,2)+0:%%%%T)!6)!W^"G% $&0%?,%-'"24%(% ,*)%&)'% $(*'%*'%"'% $*%$+<2",'%-&'<2,%#(+%0,%'P*%(%*;94%$(<2$;%@+%*;%,-% *#0'% 0-(% *#0'% #!% $(<2+% "+% a+094% (&,2)+0%%%

!

!%@5B<;C5:! 5I! &<! C:! ;A9! 85B:C:P! =LA9:! A9!BC?9?G! C:! ;A9! A5BCZ5:! 5I! ;A9! A9<F9:! e>Jf! ;A9!A9B9@C;<BJ! EBC:69! <:@! 657:;O! ;A9! I<F5BC;9! 5I!X5B7?! +5B@! 5I! ;A9! ,8-:O! ;A9! e?;9L<B@f! 5I! ;A9!NC:PQ?!*AC9I!SCI9O!;A9!ICB?;!B5J<D!A9B<D@O%a+094!ed7?;CIC9@f!!%@5B<;C5:! 5I! &<! <?! A9! ?9;?! C:! DCI9! C:! ;A9!

L9?;9B:!A5BCZ5:!5I!A9<F9:!>J!;A9!A9B9@C;<BJ!

EBC:69! <:@! 657:;O! ?5D9! 658E<:C5:! LA5! A<?!

<669??!;5!AC?!+5B@O!I<F5BC;9!5I!X5B7?!=LA5!C?G!

+5B@!5I! ;A9! ,-O! ;A9! ICB?;! MC:PQ?! =A9B<D@G! MC:PQ?!?6BC>9!<:@!?;9L<B@O!a+094O!d7?;CIC9@!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!/ECPB<EAC6!37BF9J!W_V`2!"[^""O!ED)!#k!"VO!ED)![`k!ED?)!bWO!#W)!

'B<:?D<;C5:2!17B:<:9!W__b2!b_O!"`*k!a`O!:5)!"`4)!

%

!

!! !

Page 404: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ##V!

T)(()VW! T7><?;C?!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;<;79!5I!a+D$E094%!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! T7><?;C?)!%8)!(((!h!(Y)!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BC>9@!><?9!5I!<!?8<DD!?;<;79)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)+"%,-%*;%'&0<%%%#)"+9*94%(%7*0%,-94%#!%*#0'%*%(+0'94%)+"%,-%

!

,:9!LA5!C?!<;!;A9!A9<@H65:;B5DD9B!5I!;A9!,-%5I!;A9!+5B@!5I!;A9!;L5!D<:@?!

!

1<@9!C:!DCI9!>J!AC8!C:!;A9!7*0%5I!AC?%,-O!B5J<D!?6BC>9!AC?!>9D5F9@O!<;! ;A9!A9<@H65:;B5DD9B!5I!

;A9!,-%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!WV#aO!a!<:@!WW^W[)!!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!U<FCDD9!WV_W2!ED)!"bX)!!%

% %

Page 405: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! ##_!

T)(()V[! +57FB9!%!bW!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!?;<;79!5I!>1(*2(2-&'!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!%8)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! +5L9B!E<B;!5I!<!?9<;9@!?;<;79!5I!>1(*2(2-&'9!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!D)!]G%-+<2'"%,&%(%"+2*#0'%#!%*#0'%*%(+94%

!-B9<;!6AC9I!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'I%?6BC>9!5I!AC?!6<:<D!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!W_`WO!WV)!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$C9BB9;!WV#]^#VO!((2!"V)!!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!]["O!:5)!W]][)!!!

! !

Page 406: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #V`!

T)(()V"! .:M:5L:!!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;<;79;;9!5I!;A9!3;<:@<B@^>9<B9B!O&2(#D0E!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!%8)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! -B9J^PB<:C;9! ?;<;79;;9! C:! <! ?\7<;;C:P! E5?C;C5:k! C:?6BCE;C5:?!

C:6C?9@!5:! ;A9! IB5:;!5I! ;A9! BCPA;!<B8O!5:! ;A9! D5L9B!E<B;!5I!

;A9!P<B89:;!C:!IB5:;!5I!;A9!D9P?!<:@!5:!;A9!><6M!?7EE5B;)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

D)!bG!)'(0%,&%(%"+2*#0'%%!

!

-B9<;!?9<D9B!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!WV["O!Wb)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!X'T1O!Y(((2!ED)!W")!!

! !

Page 407: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #VW!

!

T)(()V]! ''!bb!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:?!I5B8!;A9!;58>!5I!;A9!FCZC9B!?,2(#D$E0!!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3A9CMA!%>@!9D^l7B:<)!%8)!(((^(Y)!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)!36<;;9B9@!;C;D9?!C:!;A9!;58>)!

T)!T7BC<D!EB569??C5:!5I!?,2(#)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!?965:@!B9PC?;9B)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)!-+<2#!'&%*%"+2*#0'%%%$&0%(%"'%7*0%(%-0'%$--<%(%7*0%0#)'%%%-*C9#Dp4E%+%,-%*%*;9#Dp4E%$(<2+%*$0'%'&'<%% %%##*;%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%(.00%*%*;%,-%%,P%+%,-%"+$%7+%-#0'%%%0"%(&,'%(%7+'27+0%-*C%#<%+%,-%*%*;9#%%%$+<2",'%-&'<2,%#(+%,&%.+"2#<%+%,-%(%*;9#%$(<2+%*$0'%'&'<%%%T)!!(#%0.&%(%-#<%*;%'&0<%$(<2+%*$0'%'&'<%?,2(#%(&,2)+0%%$(%*#0'%#&%*%O!%$(%*#0'%0-(%'"<%$(%$(<2+%"+2-.%0+%$(%*#0'%0-(%#*D0E%(%*;2'&0<%%#(+0%0+0%,-%#+0%0+0%*%*$0'%!

!N99E9B!5I!?96B9;?!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%%$B<C?9?!;5!;A9!?MJO!d7>CD<;C5:!C:!;A9!;98ED9!=qGO!g7>CD<;C5:!C:!;A9!7*0%5I!;A9!>B5<@!A<DD!!X9!5II9B?!;5!;A9!,-%I5B!AC?!+5B@O!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6C;JO!FCZC9B!!,:9!LA5!8<M9?!>9!A9<D;AJ!;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)!!S5B@?!5I!;A9!+5B@!5I!;A9!,-%%,:9!LA5!9:;9B?!;A9!E<D<69!<:@!6589?!57;!LC;A!EB<C?9?HI<F5B?!!4C?E9:?9B!5I!d7?;C69!@<CDJ!<:@!LA5!EB9?9:;?!C;!;5!;A9!,-!5I!C;?!+5B@!!'A9!A9B9@C;<BJ!EBC:69!<:@!657:;O!PB9<;!IBC9:@O!5:9!LA5!5II9B?!;5!;A9!,-%I5B!AC?!+5B@O!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6C;J!<:@!FCZC9B!=))G!!!c5DD5LC:P!;A9!EB569??C5:!5I!;A9!I<F5BC;9O!;A9!>9D5F9@!5I!;A9!+5B@!5I!;A9!;L5!D<:@?O!;A9!6C;J!5F9B?99B!<:@!FCZC9B!?,2(#O!d7?;CIC9@2!>J!;A9!FCZC9B!5I!N7?A!>J!;A9!ICB?;!oMC:PQ?!A9B<D@r!>J!;A9!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!PB9<;!;B9<?7BJO!>J!;A9!?965:@!MC:PQ?!A9B<D@!5I!;A9!+5B@!5I!;A9!;L5!D<:@?!!>J!;A9!PB9<;!658E<:C5:?!5I!;A9!,-%;A9!PB9<;!5IIC6C<D?!5I!;A9!6C;J!

U5;9?2!!

Page 408: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #V[!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!W##"O!"k!W##VO!ak!W##_O!W#k!W#V`O!Wk!W#V[O!a!<:@!W[k!W#VbO!WWk!W#V_O!b^Wk!W#V_O!

[`)!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!T57BC<:;!WVV[2![#_^[V])!!

4<FC9?!W_]W2!ED)!WW^W"O!WVO!"`O!]`)!!

cB99@![``W>2!]`V^]W")!!

$1!(OW2!W`b^WWW)!!

X9D6M!W_aW2![b[^")!

'B<:?D<;C5:2!17B:<:9!W__b2!aWO!:5)!"[%k!a]O!:5)!"[c)!

!

! !

Page 409: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #V"!

T)(()Vb! ''!W`#!

456789:;!;C;D9! 'A9><:!;58>!5I!;A9!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!E<D<69!F4+2#)+0!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3A9CMA!%>@!9D^l7B:<)!%8)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! %^c)!'C;D9?!5I! ;A9!5L:9B! C:!AC?! ;58>! C:!@CII9B9:;! ?96;C5:?!5I!

;A9!;58>)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)!

DD)!]^aG%#(+%'"<"7*%*%@+%(%7*0%,-94%+%*#0%%%T)!

DD)!W^aG%#(+%'C*%,P%-+%,-%%%4)!!

DD)!W^[G%,&%(%"+2*#0'%,*)%0.&%#*;%-&0'<%*%0+0%,-%%/)!

,*)0<%*#0'%(%,-94%%c)!!

D)!WWG%(-%"+2*#0'%(%7+'97+0%(%;0%*;%*4+%%!

!

cCB?;!658E<:C5:!LA5!<EEB5<6A9?!X5B7?!

LC;AC:!AC?!7*0%,-!;5!;A9!MC:P!!

*58E<:C5:!LA5!6589?!6D5?9!<:@!9:;9B?!C:;5!

;A9!,-%!!

-B9<;!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'I%D)!E)!A)O!I5B985?;!5I!;A9!

PB9<;?!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'O!D)!E)!A)!!

!

/<B?!5I!;A9!MC:P!C:!AC?!,-%!

!

,:9!LA5!ICDD?!;A9!"+2*#0'!9F9BJ!@<J!LC;A!9F9BJ!P55@!;AC:P!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

'9K;2!.&N)!(Y2!WVVWO!aO!W`O!W]k!WVV[O[^")!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!$1!(2!WO!W"ak![[]^[[b)!

+4!'9K;!(((O![bW^b[)!!

X9D6M!W_ba2!WW^[a)!!

N<8EE!W_aa2!"Va^"V#O!ICP?)![aV^[a_)!!

*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!W_bO!:5)!aVW) !

! !

Page 410: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #V]!

T)(()Va! +9C@9:!Y!W]!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!=+2M'-%<:@%M'-2(#!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 198EAC?)!%8)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! +C89?;5:9! ?;9D9! 5I! ;A9! B96;<:P7D<B! ;JE9! LC;A! B<C?9@! IB<89!

<:@!<!6<F9;;5!65B:C69)!/@P9?!LC;A!C:?6BCE;C5:?!?7BB57:@!;A9!

;9K;! <:@! B9DC9I?! 5:! ;AB99! ?C@9?)! 'A9B9! C?! <D?5! <! DC:9! 5I!

C:?6BCE;C5:!5F9B!;A9!6<F9;;5!65B:C69)!'A9!?;9D9!C?!@CFC@9@!C:;5!

;AB99!E<B;?2!;A9!7EE9B!E<B;!C:!;A9!I5B8!5I!<!:<5?!65:;<C:C:P!

ICF9! A78<:! ICP7B9?k! ;A9! 8C@@D9! E<B;! B9EB9?9:;C:P! ;L5!

5II9BC:P! ?69:9?k! ;A9!>5;;58!E<B;!LC;A! <! EB<J9B! I5B!=+2M'-9%'C;D9! C:?6BC>9@!5:!;A9!7EE9B!D9@P9!5I!;A9!IB<89O!B9I9BB9@!;5!

M'-2(#2!BCPA;!A<DIO!D5L9B!DC:9)%

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%,&%(%"+2*#0'!!

!

-B9<;!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!W_WW)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!T59?9B!W_`b^W_"[O!Y(2!ED)!WbO!:5)![#)!!T5??9^-BCIIC;A!W_bb2!ED)!W])!!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!W_bO!:5)!aVW)!!

! !

Page 411: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #Vb!

T)(()V#! '7BC:!b`!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!?;<;79!5I!a+2*;!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!%8)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! T<?<D;!?;<;79!LC;A![!F9B;C6<D!65D78:?!5I!C:?6BCE;C5:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)![G%0+%(+'%(%"+2*#0'%

!

-B9<;!5I!D5F9!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%%

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!c9BBJ!WV_"2!W[a)!!!

! !

Page 412: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #Va!

T)(()VV! %8<B:<!]!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;<;79!5I!=0'2*4+'!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %8<B:<)!%8)!(Y)!

49?6BCE;C5:! c7:9B<BJ! ?;<;79!>9D5:PC:P! ;5!=0'2*4+'I%8<J5B!5I! ;A9! ;5L:!

5I!F4+02#<! C:!1C@@D9! /PJE;)! (:?6BCE;C5:! 5:! ;A9! ><6M! 5I! ;A9!

?;<;79O!D9I;!?C@9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%DD)!W^"G%-'"%.$%*#0'%a*(0%*;2-+%W+'%*'+%,&%*;%+%"'%.$94%,P%-#<%"+%(+0%-#0D'E94%(*%"+2*#0'%*%C&%*%#&9#'%#,*)%+*9#%-&'<2,%=,0%*%F4+0#<%

!

%!>55:!LAC6A!;A9!MC:P!PCF9?!5I!NA:78!5I!

W+'I%;A9!PB9<;!P5@O!+5B@!5I!;A9!A9<F9:O!<?!A9!PCF9?!=;A9!89<:?!5IG!9:;9BC:P!I<F5B9@!<:@!

@9E<B;C:P!>9D5F9@O!=<?G!5:9!LA5?9!EB<C?9?!

<B9!9?;<>DC?A9@!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'2!I5B!;A9!C&!5I!A9B!?5:!LA5!6<7?9?!A9B!:<89!;5!DCF9O!;A9!

8<d5B!=,0!5I!F4+02#<!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!4<B9??J!W_WV2!b"^#)!!

3<:@8<:!W_"V2!W"#O!*00(Y)!!

'B<:?D<;C5:2!17B:<:9!W__b2![`%)!

!

! !

Page 413: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #V#!

T)(()V_! -7B5>!

456789:;!;C;D9! +9;;9B!IB58!;A9!3;9L<B@!5I!198EAC?!>1"<!;5!;A9!MC:P!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! -7B5>)!%8)!(Y)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'A9! @56789:;! L<?! I57:@! C:! @7EDC6<;9! <;! -7B5>O! :9<B! ;A9!

c<CJ78)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%DD)!_^WWG%8"0%*%*;9$%,*)%0.&%#*;%+%+.$':%+)%'0%8+%*'<:%"&%+%"+%*%$'49C%M'-%+#0'%$*;94%*;%,*)2'&0<%,.0%08.&%"&%"+:%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;I%(%!#%*%"&%*%"+<'%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%(%!#%"&%.8($%"+2,:&%,*)%0.&%#*;%#*;%(%!#0%#*;0%D99E%

!

e'AC?!C?!=<!65887:C6<;C5:!qG!;5!1J!+5B@O!

D)E)Af)!;5!D9;!,:9!=;A9!NC:PG!M:5L!;A<;!;A9!

;98ED9!5I!J57!I<;A9B!$;<AO!357;A!5I!XC?!S<DDO!

;A9!+5B@!5I!,*)2'&0<O!C?!EB5?E9B57?!<:@!ID57BC?AC:Pk!;A<;!;A9!A57?9!5I!$A<B<5AO!D)E)A)!

C?!C:!P55@!5B@9Bk!;A<;!;A9!"+<'%=A57?9?G!5I!;A9!$A<B<5AO!D)E)A)!C?!C:!P55@!5B@9Bk!<:@!;A<;!;A9!

\7<B;9B!5I!;A9!$A<B<5AO!D)E)A)!C?!C:!P55@!5B@9B!

<:@!?967BC;J!=))G!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!-BCIIC;A!WV_V2!_W^_[k!ED)!"V)!!

3<:@8<:!W_"V2!W]#^]V!=*0+(YG)!!

+xAB!W_#b2!W][^W]])!!

S9:;9!W_V`2![V)!

'B<:?D<;C5:2!17B:<:9!W__b2![[)!

!

! !

Page 414: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #VV!

T)(()_`! ''!WVV!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!;A9!67E>9<B9B!M&2+*2*4+!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 'A9>9?)!%8)!(Y)!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!9K;9BC5B!d<8>?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%T)%$+<2",'%-&'<2,%0,D'<E%*%*#0'%S#%#'%0,'<%,P%,-%"+%7+%-#0'%$(<2+%C&0'%*;D0E'%*#0'%(%"+2>1'*%

!

'A9!A9B9@C;<BJ!EBC:69!<:@!657:;O!;A9!?5D9!

<;;9:@<:;!5I!;A9!MC:P!C:!EBCF<;9!ED<69O!5:9!

LA5!9:;9B9@!;A9!,-!<:@!6<89!57;!LC;A!

I<F5B?O!;A9!5F9B?99B!5I!<DD!;A9!MC:PQ?!L5BM!

EB5d96;?!C:!;A9!X57?9!5I!%;9:!

!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!4<FC9?!W_["<2!W"#^W]b)!!

3<:@8<:!W_"V2!W]`^W]")!%'B<:?D<;C5:2!17B:<:9!W__b2!abO!:5)!""O[)!

!! !

Page 415: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #V_!

!T)(()_W! %8<B:<!b!

456789:;!;C;D9! ,?;B<65:!IB58!/D^%8<B:<!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %8<B:<)!%8)!(Y)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%.$%+%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%.&'%#.(2,!%@+2*)'%$+"%*4+<%-+%&,,%(*2P+-'%l%899:%(#27&+A%'&2*;'A%$!#%(%899:%(#27&+%

!

-CF9:!;5!;A9!"+2>&I%D)!E)!A)O!>J!;A9!A<:@!5I!;A9!?9BFC;5B!@+2*)'I%F9BJ!P55@!LC:9!C:!d<B?O!]!(*^F9??9D?O!5I!;A9!6<E<6C;J!5I!=qGO!(*^F9??9D?!=))G!;5P9;A9B!LC;A!W!8?^><?M9;O!W!'&^65:;<C:9B!LC;A!=qG!(#^><?M9;!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!$9:@D9>7BJ!W_bW2!WaWO!ED)!V]!=]G)!!

!

! !

Page 416: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #_`!

T)(()_[! %'!W!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!\799:!H<<!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %8<B:<)!%8)!(Y)!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!:5B;A^L<DDO!DC:;9D!5I!;A9!@55B!5I!;A9!;58>)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%DD)!"^aG%$+<2",'%0+D'E%-#0D'E%*;'%(+0'%(-%,-%(%*4+0%-('%G(,0%H&2(-0%*#0'%-('%0+'%(+0'94%*;'%'&0<%H<<%

!

'A9!A9B9@C;<BJ!EBC:69??O!PB9<;!5I!I<F5B?O!D<@J!

5I!6A<B8O!?L99;!5I!D5F9O!LA5!ICDD?!;A9!,-%LC;A!A9B!>9<7;JO!8C?;B9??!5I!.EE9B!<:@!+5L9B!

/PJE;O!;A9!MC:PQ?!6AC9I!LCI9O!AC?!>9D5F9@O!D<@J!

5I!;A9!'L5!+<:@?!H<<%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!4<FC9?!W_`"^VO!"2!ED)!WV)!!

3<:@8<:!W_"V2!"VO!ED)!0+(Y)!!

'B<:?D<;C5:2!4<FC9?!W_`"^VO!"2!Wb^Wa)!!

17B:<:9!W__b2!W"#O!:5)!aa)_)!

!

! !

Page 417: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #_W!

T)(()_"! %'!"!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!C:!;A9!;58>!5I!,&2(#!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %8<B:<)!%8)!(Y)!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!d<8>?!5I!;A9!57;9B!@55BO!D9I;!?C@9)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%%G%8-'"%.$%*#0':%D99E%F4+2)"+2?,%W,2*2?,%.$94%+%8,P:%"+'%(%"+2*#0'%-,0%7*(%+!0'%+,%*;%*%C&%*%*#0'%#!%(+0'94%$(<2+%+0'<%$(<2+%"+%*%"+%&)2*2>1'*%,&%(%,-,094%8,&2(#:%%%TG%8*#0'%.$%-'":%D99E%.$94%#'%+.%(%7*0%,-%(&&%*#0'%W,2*2?,%

!

e%!>55:!LAC6A!;A9!MC:P!PCF9?f!=;5!@+2>1'*G!=<:@G!F4+2)"+2?,W,2*2?,t%8<J!A9!PB<:;!9:;BJ!

<:@!9KC;!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'I%DC8>?!>9C:P!ICDD9@!

LC;A!d5J!9F9BJ!@<J!I5B!;A9!C&!5I!;A9!MC:PQ?!?6BC>9O!AC?!>9D5F9@O!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!IB5:;!A<DD!

<:@!?;9L<B@!5I!;A9!X57?9!5I!&)*2>1'*I%!e%!>55:!LAC6A!;A9!MC:P!PCF9?f!=;5!@+2>1'*%<:@!&)*2>1'*G!8<J!A9!PB<:;!<!?;<;C5:!LC;AC:!;A9!

7*0%,-%C:!5B@9B!;5!?99!;A9!MC:P!W,2*2?,%=))G!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!.&N!(Y2![``[O!#b_)!

4<FC9?!W_`"^VO!"2!ED)![#)!!

3<:@8<:!W_"V2!]]^]aO!b[)!!

'B<:?D<;C5:2!17B:<:9!W__b2!b_)[)!

!

!

!

! !

Page 418: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #_[!

T)(()_]! %'!a!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:?!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!M&^*-#<%!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %8<B:<)!%8)!(Y)!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)!'AC6M:9??!5I!;A9!57;9B!L<DDO!/<?;!?C@9)!

T)!357;A!@55BO!d<8>?)!

*)!+C:;9D!5I!;A9!357;A^@55Bk!L5B@?!?E5M9:!>J!;A9!5L:9B!LA5!

<EE9<B?!<;!>5;A!A<:@?O!<@5BC:P!;A9!6<B;576A9?!5I!;A9!%;9:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)!!

DD)!W[^W"G%899:%$094%(%-'"0%'&%*;%7+%+!0%$+0%899:%(%"+2*#0'%)"+%0#+%(%,-%%%T)!!

-'"%.$%*#0'%8@+2>1'*:%.$%,*)%.'%*--%.$94%,P%"+'%(%"+2*#0'%%*)!

DD)!W^#G%$094%D*#0'NE%,&0%(%,-%$*%;&C%'"<%*%>1'*%(%"+2>1'*%(%&)*2>1'*%8M&2*-#<%(&,2)+0:%%%%

!

,:9!LA5!C?!A9<D;AJ!LA9:!A9!C?!?<;C?IC9@!<:@!

9F9BJ!D<:@!C?!D<@9:!LC;A!d5J!LACD9!

<66D<8<;C5:!C?!@5:9!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'!<:@!E5L9B!6589!;5!E<??!C:!;A9!,-%!

%!>55:!LAC6A!;A9!MC:P!PCF9?!5I!8@+2>1'*:%PCF9:!DCI9!I5B9F9B!65:;C:7<DDJ)!1<J!A9!PCF9!9:;BJ!

<:@!9KC;!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%!

='A9!MC:PqG!C?!8<P:CIC9@!C:!;A9!,-%>J!;A9!ICB?;!?9BF<:;!5I!;A9!%;9:!C:!;A9!X57?9!5I!&)*2>1'*%eM&2*-#<%d7?;CIC9@f!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

%)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!4<FC9?!W_`"^VO![2!"`k!ED)!V)!!

3<:@8<:!W_"V2![bO![W)!!

'B<:?D<;C5:2!17B:<:9!W__b2!W#[O!:5)!##T)[)!

T)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!4<FC9?!W_`"^VO![2!"`k!ED)!_)!!

3<:@8<:!W_"V2![aO![[)!!

'B<:?D<;C5:2!17B:<:9!W__b2!W#"O!:5)!##T)")!

*)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!4<FC9?!W_`"^VO![2!"`k!ED)!b)!!

3<:@8<:!W_"V2![#O![")!!

'B<:?D<;C5:2!17B:<:9!W__b2!W#aO!:5)!##T)W[)!

!

! !

Page 419: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #_"!

T)(()_b! %'!#!!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:?!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!M&2+*2*4+!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %8<B:<)!%8)!(Y)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'AC6M:9??!5I!;A9!;58>)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%DD)!"^bG%.$94%,-,0%*4+%-+%*#0'%!(#%(%$;%+!0%+,%*;%"-D'<E%**%(%P+#'%*4+'%+%(%-#80:%*%8*'+:%*4+%8,P%"+':%(%"+2*#0'%-,0%7*(%(%-#0%*%+.$94%D99E%%%%%

!

1<J!A9!PB<:;!<!P55@!DCI9!;C89!C:!;A9!MC:PQ?!

I5DD5LC:PO!65:;9:;89:;!<:@!d5JI7D:9??!9F9BJ!

@<JO!<:@!;A9!<;;<C:89:;!5I!;A9?9!C:!<!P55@!

I7:9B<D!>J!89<:?!5I!;A9!I<F5B!5I!;A9!P55@!

=P5@Gk!e658C:P!<:@!P5C:Pf!IB58!;A9!"+2*#0'%LC;A!DC8>?!9:A<:69@!>J!;A9!I<F5B!;A<;!C?!AC?!

;5!PCF9!=))G!

!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

4<FC9?!W_`"^VO!a2!ED)!"^V)!!

3<:@8<:!W_"V2!a_^#`!=0*(YG)!!!

17B:<:9!W__b2!W#VO!:5)!#V)[)!!

!

! !

Page 420: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #_]!

T)(()_a! %'!V!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:?!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!H02'0!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %8<B:<)!%8)!(Y)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 357;A^L<DD!;AC6M:9??)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!_G%+%"'%*%;0%&0%)+09$%*%"+2*#0'%*%;0%0#)'9$%(%,-%;0%!#"%4P&%*%7+%;$*%+%.+%(&,'%*%,.&%0"02-+%$+'%(&,'%*%*#0'%%%D)!W`G%D99E%;0%.$9$%7+%;$*%(%7'9$%$09$%('94%(%,-%(%899:%-#<094%%%%

!

1J!F5C69!C?!:5;!D57@!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'9%(!@5!:5;!?L<PP9B!C:!;A9!,-)!(!@5!:5;!B969CF9!;A9!B9L<B@!5I!LB5:P@5C:P!C:!5B@9B!;5!B9EB9??!1<<;!

I<D?9DJO!>7;!(!@5!LA<;!C?!BCPA;957?!;5!;A9!MC:P!

!

(!@5!:5;!?9;!LB5:P^@5C:P!C:!8J!C::9B85?;!

>9C:P!LA9:!(!<8!>9I5B9!AC8!C:!;A9!,-O!C:!;A9!e658E<:Jqf!5I!;A9!I<F5BC;9?%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!4<FC9?!W_`"^VO!a2![b^aO!ED)!Wb)!!

3<:@8<:!W_"V2!#b^V!=*(YG)!!

TB9<?;9@!W_`a^#O![2!]Wa^#)!!

'B<:?D<;C5:2!17B:<:9!W__b2!W_[O!:5)!V_)#)!

!

! !

Page 421: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #_b!

T)(()_#! %'!W]!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!=,<!<;!9D^%8<B:<)!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %8<B:<)!%8)!(Y)!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!?57;A^;AC6M:9??!5I!;A9!;58>!5I!=,<)!

T)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!9:;B<:69!d<8>?O!D9I;!?C@9)!

*)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!9:;B<:69!d<8>O!BCPA;!?C@9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)!D)![G%$+<2",'%,&%(%,-%*4+'%-+%*4+%(%!0'<%%%%T)!!8*#0'%.$%-'":%8*#0'%C&%,*)%(%(&,':%8*;%),<%&)*2>1'*%*:%,&%(%,-,094%.$94%,P%"+'%(%"+2*#0'%7+%-#0D'E%*%*'+%*4+%%%%*)!*%C&%*%-#0%*%*'+%*4+%#%)*'<%*'%#'%(%"+2*#0'%"&%)0%*#0'%-+%0*($%,%8*#0'%#!%(&,94:%=,<%8(&,2)+0:%%%

!'A9!A9B9@C;<BJ!EBC:69??O!?A9!LA5!C?!PB9<;!C:!;A9!,-I%E<D9!5I!I<69!<:@!>9<7;CI7D!C:!;A9!'L5!$D789?)!!!e%!>55:!LAC6A!;A9!MC:P!PCF9?!5I!;A9!MC:PQ?!C&!LAC6A!DCF9?!5:!1<n<;O!;A9!+5B@!5I!;A9!*B5L:O!&)*2>1'*fO!D5:P!C:!AC?!DCI9;C89k!8<J!A9!PB<:;!9:;BJ!<:@!9KC;!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%C:!;A9!I<F5B!5I!;A9!P55@!P5@)!!!c5B!;A9!C&!5I!;A9!P55@!P5@O!P5@Q?!I<F5BC;9O!5:9!LA5?9!ED<69!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'!L<?!9K<D;9@O!;A9!I<:^>9<B9B!<;!;A9!BCPA;!A<:@!5I!;A9!MC:P!e;A9!;B79!MC:PQ?!?6BC>9O!AC?!>9D5F9@O!1<JO!d7?;CIC9@f)!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!%)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!4<FC9?!W_`"^VO!b2!ED)!])!!3<:@8<:!W_"V2!aWO!#_)!!'B<:?D<;C5:2!4<FC9?!W_`"^VO!b2!WV)!!17B:<:9!W__b2!W]]^bO!:5)!aV)[)!T)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!!4<FC9?!W_`"^VO!b2!ED)!])!!3<:@8<:!W_"V2!a[^"O!V`)!!'B<:?D<;C5:2!4<FC9?!W_`"^VO!b2!W#^V)!!17B:<:9!W__b2!W]a^#O!:5)!aV)])!!

! !

Page 422: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #_a!

T)(()_V! %'!WV!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:?!IB58!%8<B:<!;58>!:5)!WV!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %8<B:<)!%8)!(Y)!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!D9I;!d<8>!5I!;A9!57;9B!@55B)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%4G%$&0%*%C&%*#0'%7('%0+'%*%"&%W,2*2?,%*%P&D$E%0)DNE%'-*'%)+0%*.(%)+09$%(%,-%%%

!

%@5B<;C5:!;5!J57B!C&O!MC:PQ?!6AC9I!LCI9!5I!W,2*2?,I%?A9!LA5?9!@57>D9!ED789?!<B9!ACPAO!?A9!

LA5!C?!@<ZZDC:P!5I!\7<DC;C9?!<:@!?L99;!5I!

F5C69!C:!;A9!,-%%

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!

4<FC9?!W_`"^VO!b2![b^aO!ED)!0((()!!

3<:@8<:!W_"V2!ab!=+000YG)!!

'B<:?D<;C5:2!17B:<:9!W__b2!W__O!:5)!_`)*)!

!

! !

Page 423: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #_#!

T)(()__! %'![b!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!,<!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %8<B:<)!%8)!(Y)!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)!(:?6BCE;C5:!C:!;A9!9<?;!;AC6M:9??!5I!;A9!;58>!5I!,<)!!!

T)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!C::9B!@55B!5I!;A9!;58>!5I!,<)!!

WG!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!D9I;!d<8>)!

[G!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!BCPA;!d<8>)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)!

DD)!WW^W[G%*'+%$'4%"&%)0%-+%0*($%,%*%*#0'%$(<2+%##(0'%*;D0E%*%-(94%*#0'%#!%(&,'94%$'4%*'+%,<%..94%*0%C0$%(&,%*%*#0'%#)"+%*94%,P&%*;%'&0<%&)%*%*;94%!(#9$%C&%*%-(94%($%-#<94%(&&%*4+094%),$94%(%,-94%%%%T)!!

"&2)0%-+%0*($%*#0'%#(+%,&%7*C94%*#0'%#!%(+0'94%*'+%$'4%,<%(&,%)+0%..94%D0*E%$*C%('<%(&,%0+%(%,0*%"-%+*9$%,-%-+%&)%*%*#0'%-+%#.(%#;&<'94%$+'%"0%7"094%%%%%%"&2)0%-+%0*($%*#0'%#(+%,&%*%&;)%*94%$;%*#0'%#!%(&,94%*'+%$'4%,<%0-(%,*)%..94%*09C0$%(&,%*%*#0'%*%#)"+94%,P&%*;%'&0<%&)%*;94%(&&%*4+094%),D$E94%(%,-%$0%(28-&:'%#(+0%*#0'%-+%'"D<E%*%!#(0%*;94%%%

!

'A9!P5@Q?!I<;A9BO!I<:>9<B9B!<;!;A9!BCPA;!A<:@!

5I!;A9!MC:PO!6588<:@9B!5I!A<DD!;A9!A5B?9!5I!

AC?!E9B?5:O!;A9!MC:PQ?!?6BC>9O!AC?!>9D5F9@O!,<)!X9!?<J?!o(!<8!;A9!5:9!LA5!C?!;B79!;5!;A9!MC:PO!

5:9!LA58!A9!I5?;9B9@O!LA5!C?!

?;B<CPA;I5BL<B@!;5!;A9!+5B@!5I!;A9!'L5!+<:@?!

<:@!9II96;CF9!I5B!AC?!+5B@)!%?!AC?!I<F5BC;9O!LA5!

?99?!AC?!>9<7;J!LA9:!A9!<EE9<B?!C:!AC?!,-9!!

'A9!I<:^>9<B9B!<;!;A9!BCPA;!A<:@!5I!;A9!MC:PO!

;A9!PB9<;!658E<:C5:!LA5!C?!:9<B!;5!AC?!+5B@O!

;A9!B5J<D!?6BC>9O!AC?!>9D5F9@O!;A9!P5@Q?!I<;A9B!

,<O!d7?;CIC9@)!X9!?<J?!o(!L<?!?;B<CPA;I5BL<B@!<:@!;B79O!@9F5C@!5I!B<E<6C;J)!1J!:<89!

B9<6A9@!;A9!,-%5:DJ!>96<7?9!5I!>9C:P!9II96;CF9!I5B!;A9!MC:PO!>96<7?9!5I!A9<BM9:C:P!;5!AC?!

;9<6AC:P!<:@!9K967;C:P!AC?!D<L?r)!

!

'A9!I<:^>9<B9B!<;!;A9!BCPA;!A<:@!5I!;A9!MC:PO!

;A9!PB9<;!658E<:C5:!;5!>9!65:IC@9@!C:O!;A9!

;B79!MC:PQ?!?6BC>9O!AC?!>9D5F9@O!;A9!P5@Q?!

I<;A9B!,<O!8<J!A9!DCF9!<P<C:)!X9!?<J?!o(!L<?!

5:9!;B79!;5!;A9!MC:PO!5:9!LA58!A9!I5?;9B9@O!

?;B<CPA;I5BL<B@!;5!;A9!+5B@!5I!;A9!'L5!+<:@?O!

9II96;CF9!I5B!AC?!+5B@k!5:9!LA5!?<L!AC?!>9<7;J!

LA9:!A9!<EE9<B9@!C:!AC?!,-I%LACD9!(!L<?!C:!IB5:;!5I!;A9!5IIC6C<D?!<:@!658E<:C5:?!5I!;A9!

MC:PO!=>9C:PG!;A9!ICB?;!5I!AC?!+5B@^I5DD5L9B?)!!

!

U5;9?2!!

Page 424: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #_V!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

%)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!4<FC9?!W_`"^V2!aO![b)!!

3<:@8<:!W_"V2!_W)!!

'B<:?D<;C5:2!TB9<?;9@!W_`a^#O![2!]`V^WW)!!

4<FC9?!W_`"^VO!a2![V^_)!

+C6A;A9C8!W_#"^W_V`O!((2!_"^a)!!

17B:<:9!W__b2!bVT)"!

T)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!4<FC9?!W_`"^VO!a2!"[O!"])!!

3<:@8<:!W_"V2!_V^W``O!*0Y()!!

'B<:?D<;C5:2!4<FC9?!W_`"^aO!Y(2!""^])!!

X9D6M!W_aWO!"bW!=*^/!5:DJG)!!

17B:<:9!W__b2!WW#^VO!:5)!bVT)#)!!

!

! !

Page 425: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! #__!

T)(()W``! T9BDC:![Wb_#!

456789:;!;C;D9! 455Bd<8>!IB58!;A9!A57?9!5I!;A9!?;9L<B@!>1"<!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %8<B:<)!%8)!(Y)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'A9!5L:9B!C?!?A5L:!M:99DC:P!<:@!<@5BC:P!;A9!:<89?!5I!;A9!

P5@O! @+2>1'*! <:@! 5I! ;A9! MC:PO! LACD9! 7;;9BC:P! ;A9! I5DD5LC:P!L5B@?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%

DD)!W^VG%+.$%$&0%*%*'+%*4+%#*P%'&%*%*#0'%*)'%$*%*#0'%#!%$(<2+%"+%*%=*2*4+%>1"<%(&,2)+0%..94%.$9$%*9C%$&0%$;9$%(%+!0'%$+D0E'9$%-+%(&&%*4+09C%"&%-P&%*4+%(&,2#)"+2'&0%(%C&94%.$9C%,*)%*4+%+,2*;%*%C&%*%*#0'%#!%$(<2+%D"&E%C;%,&%*%M+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%(%&)*2>1'*%$(<2+%"+%>1"<%(&,2)+0%

%

!

-CFC:P!<@5B<;C5:?!;5!;A9!P55@!P5@O!MC??C:P!

;A9!PB57:@!;5!;A9!FC6;5BC57?!MC:P!>J!;A9!

MC:PQ?!?6BC>9O!;A9!?;9L<B@!5I!198EAC?O!>1"<O!d7?;CIC9@)!X9!?<J?!o(!PCF9!<@5B<;C5:?!LACD9!8J!

9<B;A!B9d5C69?!<:@!8J!9J9?!?99!J57B!>9<7;J)!

,!B7D9B!LA5!DCF9?!5:!1<<;!<:@!6<7?9?!;A9!

D<:@!;5!PB5L!>J!89<:?!5I!AC?!C3O!8<J!J57!

PCF9!P55@!<!DCI9!9F9BJ!@<J!;5!;A9!M<!5I!;A9!

MC:PQ?!?6BC>9O!;A9!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!D<BP9!C::9B!

E<D<69!5I!;A9!$A<B<5AO!D)!E)!A)O!C:!&)2*2>1'*O!;A9!?;9L<B@!>1"<O!d7?;CIC9@)%

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!3<:@8<:!W_"V2!WbV!=*+00(G)!!

&59@9B!W_[]O!((2!"__!:5)!W_[]W)!!

X9D6M!W_bV2!]Vb)!

'B<:?D<;C5:2!17B:<:9!W__b2!W[aO!:5)!aW%)!

!

! !

Page 426: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V``!

T)(()W`W! 3<\\<B<![!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:?!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!@+*2(2-;!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3<\\<B<)!'7;)!

49?6BCE;C5:! %) (:?6BCE;C5:! 5:! ;A9! ECD<?;9B! 5I! ;A9! :5B;A!L<DD! 5I! ;A9!

?965:@!657B;J<B@)!

T) (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!?57;A!?;<;79!:C6A9!<:@!;A9!:5B;A!

d<8>!5I!;A9!L9?;!L<DD!5I!;A9!@55BL<J!5I!;A9!3;<;79!

B558)!

*) (:?6BCE;C5:! 5:! ;A9! ?;9D9! IB58! ;A9! L9?;! L<DD! 5I! ;A9!

ICB?;!657B;J<B@k!5:!;A9!?57;A!<:@!:5B;A!d<8>?!5I!;A9!

9:;B<:69!5I! ;A9!?;<;79!B558k!5:!;A9!ECD<?;9B!5I! ;A9!

?57;A!L<DD!5I!;A9!?965:@!657B;J<B@)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%%)!$(<2+%$&0'%,-%%T)!$(<2+%$&0'%"+2*#0'%%*)!-+<2#!'&%*%"+2*#0'!

!!,F9B?99B!5I!5IIC69?!C:!;A9%,-%%%,F9B?99B!5I!5IIC69?!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%%%N99E9B!5I!;A9!?96B9;?!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!1<B;C:!W_V_2!$D)!["O!ED)!b`!=ba^#GO!ED)!b#!=b#^bVGk!ab!=a"Gk!WW`!=#"Gk!W[a!=V]G)!!

! !

Page 427: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V`W!

T)(()W`[! T1!bb`!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BC>9@!E<:9D!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!@+*2(2-;!<;!3<\\<B<!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3<\\<B<)!'7;)!

49?6BCE;C5:! +C89?;5:9! E<:9D! LC;A! ;A9! ICP7B9! 5I! ;A9! @969<?9@! ?;<:@C:P!

LC;A!A<:@?!7EDCI;9@!C:!<:!<;;C;7@9!5I!<@5B<;C5:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

D)![G%$(<2$;%*%@+%(%,-94%%D)!aG%-+<2#!'&%*%"+2*#0'%

!

c<F5BC;9!5I!X5B7?!LA5!C?!C:!AC?!,-!!

N99E9B!5I!?96B9;?!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2![W``O![k![W`[O!b)%%$7>DC6<;C5:2!X'T1O!V2!"`^"WO!ED)![#O!:5)!bb`)!!

! !

Page 428: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V`[!

T)(()W`"! ''!]`!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!;A9!YCZC9B!5I!U7>C<!@0<%!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 'A9>9?)!'7;)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

)'(%*&<%(%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%!

5(+0%$(<%,-%%%"+$%-#0'%(%#'"2#&%,*)%0.&%#*;%.7*0%(%('<%*'+%*4+%+%*#0'%#&%$(<2+%)&#'%G(,0%@0<%

!

'B9<?7B9B!5I!;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)!!

*58E<:C5:?!LA5!<B9!C:!;A9!,-%!

,:9!LA5!P59?!I5B;A!I<F5B?HEB<C?9?!C:!;A9!#'"2#&I% D)! E)! A)O! >5LC:P! <;! ;A9! EB9?9:69! 5I! ;A9!65BB96;! P55@! P5@! ;5! ;A9! MC:PQ?! ?5:O! ;A9!

5F9B?99B!5I! ;A9! I5B9CP:! D<:@!5I!.EE9B!/PJE;O!

@0<%!

U5;9?2!%

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2![`a]O!ak![`]O!W[k![`abO!W)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!4<FC9?!h!-<B@C:9B!W_[a)!!$1!(OW2!#b^#V)!!N<8EE!W__a2![""^["bO!ICP)!W"")!!

! !

Page 429: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V`"!

T)(()W`]! 3<\\<B<!"!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!85:789:;!5I!5&2"&2$+%IB58!3<\\<B<!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3<\\<B<)!/<BDJ!WV;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! UC6A9!LC;A! ?;<;79?!LC;A!9<6A!5I! ;A9![! I<69?! C:?6BC>9@!LC;A!

A5BCZ5:;<D! DC:9?! ;9K;?)! (:?6BCE;C5:! 5:! ;A9! I<69! %! 5I! ;A9!

85:789:;)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%%!W^"G%#.(%DNE%(.094%(%!*<'%*8':%#+<0%DNE%)+%*#0%$+%,-%8*#0':%+%$+'%#)+%'&0%$+8+0:%-+%(0%$+8+0:%-+%'&%$(<2+%,7*0'<%5&2"&2$+%%%%!"G%$+<28"2,':%-&'<2,%('<%(&,%DNE%()'%%*;%'&0<%')%,-%*#0'%)'(8':%*;8':%*8':%*#0'!

!,:9!LA5?9!L5B@?!<B9!DC?;9:9@!=qG!<85:P!;A9!657B<P9!5I!657B;C9B?!LC;A!;A9!MC:PO!5:9!LA58!;A9!eB5J<Df!,-!<EE5C:;9@!;5!<@8C:C?;9B!;A9!D<:@?O!<6;9@!5:!L<;9B!<:@!<6;9@!5:!D<:@O!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!,7*0'<I%5&2"&2$+I%'A9!A9B9@C;<BJ!EBC:69O!657:;O!5:9!;B7DJ!9K<6;O!;A9!><D<:69!5I!;A9!+5B@!5I!;A9!'L5!+<:@?O!;A9!ED7889;!5I!;A9!B5J<D%,-I%5:9!LA5!?9<D?!<DD!;A9!;AC:P?!5I!;A9!MC:P!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!1<D9M!W_V_2!a"O!%!W^")!%

! !

Page 430: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V`]!

T)(()W`b! %:C><!

456789:;!;C;D9! Y5;CF9!(:?6BCE;C5:!5I!?,2*4+!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %:C><!=+5L9B!U7>C<G)!WV;A!4J:)!='A7;)!(((!h!%8)!((O!(((O!(YG!

49?6BCE;C5:! 3<:@?;5:9!B9DC9I!LC;A!F5;CF9!C:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!6C;J!;98ED9!

<;!%:C><)!'C;D9!B9I9BB9@!;5!P5@@9??!W+2C&0'9!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!DD)!W^[G%*;'%,-%%

!+<@J!5I!;A9!,-%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;9K;2!3;9C:@5BII!W_"#O((2!["O!:B)!"]k!$D)!W`O!"W>)!!*5889:;2!+9C;Z![``[O!(Y2!"[)!!

! !

Page 431: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V`b!

T)(()W`a! T1!W["!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!;A9!ACPA!?;9L<B@!>1(*2(2-&'%50++!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!WV;A!4J:)!=%8)!(((!qG!

49?6BCE;C5:! $<B;!5I!<!B57:@^;5EE9@!?;9D9!5I!PB9J!DC89?;5:9!5:!LAC6A!C?!<!

B9EB9?9:;<;C5:! 5I! MC:P! %89:A5;9E! (((O! 5II9BC:P! ;5! ;A9! P5@!

%87:^&<! 5I! N<B:<M)! T9D5L! <B9! EB<J9B?! ;5! %87:^&<! >J! ;A9!

5L:9B!<:@!<;! ;A9! ?C@9?!<B9! C:?6BCE;C5:?!PCFC:P!AC?! ;C;D9?!<:@!

I7B;A9B!EB<J9B?)!!

%)!1<C:!;9K;)!

T)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!EDC:;A!<;!;A9!><6M)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%%)!D)![G%)*'<%8#'%(%"+2*#0':%%T)!D)![G%8,&%(:%"+2*#0'%,*)%0.&%#*;!!

!!c5B985?;!5I!E5?C;C5:!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'!!!!e-B9<;!C:!;A9f%"+2*#0'I%D!E)!A)!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!WV_#O!WWk!WV__O!W`)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!X'T1!Y((O!][)!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!W_bO!:5)!aVWk!]]WO!:5)!WbWa)!!

! !

Page 432: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V`a!

T)(()W`#! g/!]aa``!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;<;79!C:?6BCE;C5:!5I!;A9!6588<:@9B!5I!;A9!;B55E?!520&#!!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3<I;!9D^X9::<)!WV;A!4J:)!=%8)!(((!5B!X5B98A9>!qG)!

49?6BCE;C5:! TD<6M! PB<:C;9! ?;<;79! PB57E2! <! ?9<;9@!8<:! C:! ;A9!8C@@D9O! <!

L58<:!?9<;9@!5:!AC?!D9I;!?C@9!<:@!;A9CB!@<7PA;9B!<;!AC?!BCPA;!

?C@9)!!

%)!'A9!><6M!>9<B?!<!B9EB9?9:;<;C5:!5I!520&#% C:!<@5B<;C5:!C:!IB5:;!5I!;A9!P5@!39E;)!(:?6BCE;C5:!:9<B!;A9!5L:9B)!!

T)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!><?989:;!5I!;A9!85:789:;)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%%)!,&%".'<0%"+2,&%%T)!-&'<2,%*%".'<0%"+2,&!!!

!!-B9<;!5I!>5L89:!5I!"+2,&!!!!*AC9I!5I!>5L89:!5I!;A9!"+2,&!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$1!(Y2!WW)!!4<B9??J!W_[`<2!W[]^a)!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!W_bO!:5)!aV`)!!

! !

Page 433: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V`#!

T)(()W`V! T1!W""[!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!;A9!?ACE!8<?;9B!>10*&!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!1C@@D9!5I!;A9!D<;9!WV;A!4J:)!='A7;)!(YG)!

49?6BCE;C5:! &57:@^;5EE9@! DC89?;5:9! ?;9D9)! WW! A5BCZ5:;<D! DC:9?! 5I! ;9K;!

C:?6BC>9@!C:!;A9!;ACB@!B9PC?;9B)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%

D)!_G%-(0%0+%*%"&%0$&%*%5)('%(%"&%!%*%"+2,&%

!

-B9<;!?;99BC:P!5<B!5I!;A9!>5<;!5I!5)('%C:!;A9!D<M9H@C?;BC6;!5I!;A9!"+2,&!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(Y2!Wa"[O![!<:@!b)!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!-D<:FCDD9!W_"[2!"_O!ED)![)!!X'T1O!Y(((2!"V^]`k!ED)!"")!!*5889:;2!+9C;Z![``[O!Y(2!ba#)!!!

! !

Page 434: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V`V!

T)(()W`_! *-!##_!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;<;79!PB57E!5I!;A9!P9:9B<D!C:!6AC9I!F)'2($*!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!WV;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:! 658E5?9@! 5I! ]! 65D78:?! 6<BF9@! 5:! ;A9! ><6M! 5I!

;A9!?;<;79)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

"6)!"G%$(<2$;%8@+:%*;%,-!!

!c<F5BC;9!5I!X5B7?O!+5B@!5I!;A9!,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!.&N!(YO!W_`V2!_)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!T5B6A<B@;!W_WW^W_"aO!(((2!V#^_)!!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2![VbO!:5)!__[)!!

! !

Page 435: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V`_!

T)(()WW`! T1![_b!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!?;9D9!5I!>1"0!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!WV;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! &57:@^;5EE9@! ?;9D9! @CFC@9@! C:! ;AB99! B9PC?;9B?)! (:?6BCE;C5:!

IB58!;A9!?965:@!B9PC?;9B)!%>5F9!;A9!5II9BC:P?!<:@!C:!IB5:;!5I!

;A9!@969<?9@!C?!<:!C:?6BCE;C5:!C:6C?9@!C:!]!F9B;C6<D!65D78:?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%0,0%*%7*0%*%7*<'%),2(2(&,'!

!

3<CD5B!5I!;A9!7*0!!5I!;A9!>5<;Q?!65:;C:P9:;!),2(2(&,'%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!X'T1!V2!b`O!ED)!]W)!%

! !

Page 436: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! VW`!

T)(()WWW! U9L!R5BM!

11%![")V!

456789:;!;C;D9! *7>9!?;<;79!5I!@+!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 49:@9B<A!=qG)!WV;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'C;D9!B9I9BB9@!;5!W+'2@C&0'!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%*;'%,-D'E%

!

+<@J!5I!;A9!,-%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;9K;2!F<:!@9!S<DD9!W_#W2!W"[)!!X9D6M!W_V"2!bV!="aG)!*5889:;2!+9C;Z![``[O!(Y2!"[)!!

! !

Page 437: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! VWW!

T)(()WW[! 3C:<C!["]!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!a+094!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!WV;A!4J:)!=qG!

49?6BCE;C5:! ,:!;A9!D9I;!<!8<D9!ICP7B9!A5D@?!C:!;A9!D9I;!A<:@!<!>B<ZC9BO!<:@!C:!;A9!BCPA;!<!E5;!IB58!LAC6A!A9!E57B?!C:;5!<!D<BP9B!F9??9D!5:!;A9!PB57:@)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

"'&<2(.&'%*%-(0%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%!!

!/:PB<F9B!5I!6<BE9:;9BQ?!?A5E!5I!$A<B<5AO!D)!E)!A)!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!h!$99;!W_[`2!ED)!b#O!((O!W#[)!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!a"[O!:5)![WWV)!!

! !

Page 438: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! VW[!

T)(()WW"! *-!"]`_"!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!\0&!=qG!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!WV;A!4J:)!=qG!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:! C:! ;A9! ICB?;! B9PC?;9B! :9<B! ;A9! B9EB9?9:;<;C5:! 5:!;A9! BCPA;! 5I! <!8<:! <:@! <! L58<:! ?;<:@C:PO! I<6C:P! D9I;! <:@!B<C?C:P!>5;A!;A9CB!A<:@?!C:!L5B?ACE)!'C;D9!B9I9BB9@!;5!5:9!5I!;A9!5IIC6C<D?!B9EB9?9:;9@!<;!;A9!>5;;58!5I!;A9!?;9D9)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

"'&0%)0%*%"&%#&%*%"+2,&!,*)%0.&%#*;!

!c<:^>9<B9B!5I!;A9!ICDC<;C5:!5I!$A<B<5AO!D)!E)!A)!!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!1<BC9;;9!WVV`2!:5)!W`V#)!!+<6<7!W_`_2!W]"^W]bk!ED)!0+Y)!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!a""O!:5)![W[W)!!

! !

Page 439: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! VW"!

T)(()WW]! *-!bba!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;<;79!5I!5*2*4+!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %6A8C8)!WV;A!4J:)!=qG!

49?6BCE;C5:! $<C:;9@!?;<;79!5I!<!?9<;9@!8<:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

D)!]G%-#8$:%@+%(%,-%%DD)!#^VG%$(<2+%-(0'%*;'%*'%"+2*#0'%,*)%0.&%#*;!!

!

c<F5BC:PHEB<C?C:P!X5B7?!C:!;A9!,-!!

1<?;9B!5I!<DD!6B<I;?89:!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'O!D)!E)!A)!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!T5B6A<B@;!W_WW^W_"aO!((2!W`"^W`])!

*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!_[O!:5)!"`"!

!

! !

Page 440: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! VW]!

T)(()WWb! T9BDC:!W_#][!!

456789:;!;C;D9! c<C9:69!>5LD!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!WV;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!BC8!5I!;A9!>5LD)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%-+<2#!'&%*%"+2*#0'%

!

N99E9B!5I!?96B9;?!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;9K;2!X9D6M!W_bV2!]b`)!!

-j:;9B!W_W"^[]O!((2!"`bO!:5)!W_#][)!!

!

! !

Page 441: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! VWb!

T)(()WWa! *-![b["`!

456789:;!;C;D9! ,?;B<65:!IB58!;A9!'58>!:5)!a!<;!TC><:!9D^15D57M)!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! Y<DD9J!5I!;A9!NC:P?)!WV;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%-+<2#!'&%*%"+2*#0'%,*)%0.&%#*;%

!

N99E9B!5I!?96B9;?!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'I%D)E)A)!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;9K;2!X9D6M!W_bV2!]aW)!!4<B9??J!W_`W2![b["`)!!

! !

Page 442: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! VWa!

T)(()WW#! ''!WW[!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!=*2)"+2?,25*;!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3A9CMA!%>@!9D^l7B:<)!WV;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!9<?;!L<DDO!:5B;A!?C@9)!

T)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!9<?;!L<DDO!?57;A!?C@9)!

*)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!9<?;!L<DDO!:5B;A!?C@9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)!

#)*'<%899:%#'%(%,-94%%%T)!

-+<2'"%,&%(%"+2*#0'%%*)!

,&%(%"+2*#0'%!

!

,:9!LA5?9!E5?C;C5:H?;<;7?!L<?!EB585;9@!C:!

;A9!,-%2%X9!8<@9!AC?!E5?C;C5:!EB58C:9:;!C:!

;A9%,-!!!

-B9<;!6AC9I!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%!

!

-B9<;!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!4<FC9?!h!4<FC9?!W_""2!ED)!W]O![]O![V)!%

% %

Page 443: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! VW#!

T)(()WWV! NA<B;578!

17?978!

]]]a!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!@&'<2,%IB58!c<B<?)!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! c<B<?!=U7>C<G)!+<;9!WV;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! +C89?;5:9!?;9D9!@965B<;9@!LC;A!<!?69:9!C:!LAC6A!;A9!5L:9B!

5:!;A9!D9I;!C?!EB<C?C:P!"!@CFC:C;C9?O!$;<A!<:@!;L5!P5@@9??9?O!

?;<:@C:P! <;! ;A9! E5@C78! 5:! ;A9! BCPA;! 5I! AC8)! ! 'A9! ;C;D9! C?!

B9I9BB9@!;5!5:9!5I!;A9?9!P5@@9??9?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%@*0'%,-%%

!1C?;B9??!5I!;A9!,-%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;9K;2!N<BM5L?MC!W_VWO!Y2!W"#!<:@!ED)!W#!=:5)!VWG)!!*5889:;2!+9C;Z![``[O!Y2!W#W)!!

! !

Page 444: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! VWV!

T)(()WW_! TB55MDJ:!!

17?978!

]#)W[`)"!

456789:;!;C;D9! S55@9:!ICP7B9!5I!;A9!o?C:P9B%=$r!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 19@C:9;!-7B5>)!+<;9!WV;A!4J:)!=%8)!(((G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! S55@9:! ICP7B9!5I!<!L58<:!L9<BC:P!<!A9<FJ!LCP!<:@! D5:P!

ED9<;9@!P<B89:;O!?;<:@C:P!5:!<!L55@9:!><?9)!,:!;A9!;5E!5I!

;A9!><?9!<B9!C:6C?9@!"!DC:9?!5I!;9K;!LAC6A!EB5FC@9!;A9!:<89!

;A9!L58<:!<?!o;A9!?C:P9B%=$r)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%@*0'%,-%%%

!1C?;B9??!5I!;A9!,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;9K;2!g<89?!W_#]2!:5)![V]O!$D)!0(O!+00((()!*5889:;2!+9C;Z![``[O!Y2!W#W)!!

! !

Page 445: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! VW_!

T)(()W[`! +9C@9:!

")W)W)"#!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!<!?A<>;C!5I!N!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 'A9>9?)!WVHW_;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!<!L55@9:!?A<>;C!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%$(<2+%C&0'%(%-0'%-;02#.%(%,-%*%"+2*#0'%

!

,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!L5BM?!C:!;A9!;98ED9!5I!56.^I9?;CF<D?!IB58!;A9!,-!=<:@!C:!;A9G!"+2*#0'W!

!

U5;9?2!W!o5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!L5BM?!C:!;A9!8<:?C5:!5I!56.^I9?;CF<D?!C:!;A9!"3J3T62'6("J6!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'e2!;B<:?D<;C5:!C:2!36A:9C@9B!W_##2!]b^a)!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!36A:9C@9B!W_##2!")W)W)"#O!ED)!V_)!!

! !

Page 446: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V[`!

T)(()W[W!

!

/D9EA<:;C:9!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!;9BB<69!5I!/D9EA<:;C:9)!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! /D9EA<:;C:9)!+<;9!U9L!NC:P@58)!

49?6BCE;C5:! -B<IIC;5! 5:! ;A9! ;9BB<69! ;A9! ;98ED9! >7CD;! >J! %89:A5;9E! ((!

<:@!&<89?9?!((!<;!/D9EA<:;C:9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!#G%M#.'%,&'%$(<'%"+2*#0'%

!

'A9!-B9<;!/::9<@!LA5!C?!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;9K;2!15BP<:!WV_]^W_`_O!(2!W[`O!IO!#)!!*5889:;2!+9C;Z![``[O!(((2!W]a)!!

! !

Page 447: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V[W!

T)(()W[[! *-!WW]`!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;<;79!5I!FCZC9B!F;2,1(*!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!39;J!()%

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!&9<B!ECDD<BO!L9?;!?C@9)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!WG%#&;%,.%-&'<2,%*%0+0%,-%(2;&-%D*#0'E%%%DD)!"^]G%-(%*'+%(&,'%*#0'%-(94%),$%#'&%0+0%+%,-%*#0'%+.$'%+)9#%*(''94%!

!

'A9!@CP:C;<BJO!<@8C:C?;B<;5BO!D9<@9B!5I!;A9!

PB9<;?!5I!;A9!,-!C:!;A9!B5J<D!EB9?9:69)!!!

$B5EA9;!5I!'B7;AO!B5J<D!A9B<D@!=<;!;A9G!

<EE9<BC:P!5I!XC?!1<d9?;JO!@B<LC:P!5I!;A9!

PB9<;!5:9?!<;!;A9!,-%5I!;A9!MC:PO!6<7?C:P!9<6A!8<:!;5!M:5L!AC?!EB569??C5:<D!5B@9B!

!

U5;9?2!!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!(2![V]O[!<:@!a)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$1!Y2!_])!1<BC9;;9!WVV`O!((2!ED)!ba!@O!9O!I)!!@9!&57P{!WV##^#_2!ED)!]#)!!T5B6A<B@;!W_WW^W_"aO!(Y2!#a^##)!!!

! !

Page 448: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V[[!

T)(()W["! T<:M9?!

*5DD96;C5:!

456789:;!;C;D9! &<89??C@!?;9D9!IB58!;A9!T<:M9?!65DD96;C5:!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M5L:)!39;J!()!!

49?6BCE;C5:! +C89?;5:9! B57:@^;5EE9@! ?;9D9)! %;! ;A9! D9I;! ?C@9! C?!

B9EB9?9:;9@! ;A9! EB5L! 5I! ;A9! NA5:?! ?ACEk! <;! ;A9! BCPA;! 5:9!

;A9!<@5B<;C5:!5I![!89:!LC;A!>7B:;!5II9BC:P)!'A9!W`!65D78:?!

C:?6BCE;C5:!C?!D56<;9@!<>5F9!;A9!;L5!89:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!6)!"G!D*#0'E%.$%$&'%*%(+'%*94%,-,0%(%7*094%%

!=;A9!MC:PG!LA5!PCF9?!<:!5IIC69!;5!AC8!LA58!A9!D5F9?!<:@!<!DCI9;C89!C?!C:!AC?!7*0%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!(O!"_aO!#)!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!y9B:J!W_bV2!:)!V)!!!

! !

Page 449: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V["!

T)(()W[]! N58!9D^

%A8<B!

456789:;!;C;D9! '58>!6A<E9D!5I!;A9!37E9BC:;9:@9:;!5I!-B<:<BC9?!F4+2#)+0!!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! !9D^19C;C:!=N58!9D^%A8<BG)!39;J!()!

49?6BCE;C5:! XJE5?;JD9!X<DD2!?C@9!&558!b)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%#!%*#0'%(+D0E94%$(<2+%0+%*%*;%'&0<%$(<2+%!*0'%(%+#0'%(-0%#!%*#0'%(%,-%*%*#0D'E%F4+2#)+0%(&,2)+0%!

!

NC:PQ?!?6BC>9O!>9D5F9@!5I!AC8O!ACPA!?;9L<B@!5I!

;A9!+5B@!5I!;A9!;L5!D<:@?O!PB<:<BJ^

?7E9BC:;9:@9:;!C:!357;A!<:@!U5B;AO!B5J<D!

?6BC>9!C:!;A9!,-%5I!;A9!MC:PO!F4+2#)+0O!d7?;CIC9@!!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!(2!"`bOW)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!!$1!(Y2!W"_)!SB9?ZC:?MC!W_[#2!"")!!!

! !

Page 450: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V[]!

T)(()W[b! +57FB9!*!_[!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!?02+0O!NC:PQ?!XCPA!3;9L<B@!<:@!5'(^EBC9?;!C:!AC?!%>J@5?!;98ED9!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! !9D^19C;C:!=N58!9D^%A8<BG)!39;J!()!

49?6BCE;C5:! W`!A5BCZ5:;<D!DC:9?!C:?6BCE;C5:!C:!;A9!;5E!B9PC?;9B)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

DD)!W^[G!-&'<2,!)'(0%;$'<%(+D0E%*;%'&0<%,P%+%,-%(&&%*'+%*4+%!

!

1<J5BO!?9<D9B!5I!.EE9B!<:@!+5L9B!/PJE;O!

5:9!>9D5F9@!5I!;A9!+5B@!5I!;A9!;L5!D<:@?O!

5:9!LA5!9:;9B?!;A9!,-%<:@!?99?!;A9!P55@!P5@!!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!(2!"`#OW")!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$C9BB9;!WV#VO!((2![`)!!!

!

!

! !

Page 451: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V[b!

T)(()W[a! TB7K9DD9?!

17?978!

/b"``!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I%=,<!36BC>9!5I!,II9BC:P?!5I!<DD!P5@?!5I!;A9!'98ED9!5I!39;J!()!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!39;J!()!!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!C:!;A9![`!65D78:?!5I!;A9!D5L9B!B9PC?;9B)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!DD)!]^bG!*;%#)&%*4+%(%,-%,&%),0%(%&;.0%!

!+5B@!5I!P55@!B9E7;9!C:!;A9!,-O!PB9<;!5I!9ECEA<:C9?!C:!%>J@5?!!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!(2!"]"OWW)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!!$1!Y2!__)!!3E9D99B?!W_[W2!ED)!(Y)!!

! !

Page 452: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V[a!

T)(()W[#! T9BDC:!VW#[!

456789:;!;C;D9! +C:;9D!5I!>10*<O!*AC9I!&5J<D!36BC>9!LC;A!<:!XJ8:!;5!%>J@5?!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!39;J!()!

49?6BCE;C5:! +C:;9D!65:;<C:C:P!;A9!XJ8:!;5!%>J@5?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

D)!WG!@+%(%7*0%%!

D)!#G!$&0%&;.0%(%.&$%(%F!('%$0%"&%*;%&;.0%-'"%(%,-94%!

!

X5B7?!C:!;A9!7*0!!

$B<C?9!;5!%>J@5?O!<;!;A9!?<CDC:P!5I!;A9!F!('^?ACEO!LA9:!;A9!+5B@!5I!%>J@5?!=,?CBC?G!B9?;?!

C:!AC?!,-!!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!(2!"b#OW`k!"bVOW]^Wb)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!gjBP9:!W_V"2![[a^[[#)!!*DiB9!W_b_2!Va^W`]O!ED)!(Y^Y)!!

! !

Page 453: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V[#!

T)(()W[V! ''!W`a!

456789:;!;C;D9! '58>!5I!YCZC9B!M&2#+!!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3A9CMA!%>@!9D^l7B:<)!39;J!(!^!&<8)!((!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)!357;A9B:!?;9D9!5I!9K;9BC5B!5I!I<v<@9)<!'C;D9!B9I9BB9@!;5!1<n<;)!T)!cB<P89:;?!5I!;A9!\v'_6#%U4%'76%]_w_6+!IB58!;A9!>B5<@!A<DDO!B9<B!L<DDO!?57;A9B:^D9I;!A<DI>!

*)!35D<B!?ACE!<:@!I<8CDJ!?69:9?!IB58!;A9!>B5<@!A<DDO!:5B;A9B:^BCPA;!A<DIO!IB5:;!L<DD)6!*!CF2!M&2#+!B969CF9?!<:!C:F56<;C5:!IB58!<!EBC9?;)!4)!TC5PB<EAC6<D!;9K;O!EB<C?9!5I!;A9!MC:P!5:!;A9!ECDD<B!TO!I<69!%!C:!;A9!>B5<@!A<DD@!

/)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!$CDD<B!-!C:!;A9!TB5<@!X<DD!5I!;A9!;58>9!(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)!!

D=&,'E%;*+'%(+0'%(%,-%*%$'9#Dp4E%?,%%T)!

!DD)!W^[G!8*'94%#;%+%.(%*7D0E'%)'4%..':W!(%"+2*#0'%%!

DD)!#^VG%8*'94%$+99*;:%(%*$0'%+#0'%8(%7*0:[!

!

*)!

D)!]G!8#&'94%-#$':%*'%"+2*#0'%0+'%)*'%>1(*2H$<%%%CFO!D)!WG%*%C&%*%+"2,'%-&'<2,%)'(0%;$'<%,&%(%"+2*#0'%-&'<2,%0+0%(%"+2*#0'%%%%4)!!

D)!W`G%$0%0.%*;9$%'#0%;&C%$(%+%#(+%'"%*%,-%.7*9*94%#0%+%$(<2+&%C&0%-(%*'+%'"%*%0+'%-P&%0-(9*94%+.$'94%+%$(<2+&%*$0'%0"'2(&,'%.$0%(%-+94%+%!#"%$*0%)&#'%+#<'%(-''%+%"+2-.%*%*#0%%%%%%%

!

3L99;!5I!D5F9!C:!;A9!,-%>J!AC?!I<;A9B!&<!!!

!

e(;!C?!A9!LA5!?9:@?!57;O!;5!67;!@5L:!

?J6<85B9!;B99?O!C:!<665B@!LC;A!LA<;!L<?!

?<C@f!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%%!

e(;!C?!A9!LA5))9F9BJf!C:!'A9>9?!e<:@!C:!;A9!

7*0f!!

eXC?!@<7PA;9BO!I<F5BC;9f!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'I%*AC9I!5I!;A9!X<BC8!5I!>1(*2H$<!!

c5B!;A9!?ECBC;!5I!;A9!X9B9@C;<BJ!EBC:69O!<:@!

8<J5BO!?9<D9B!5I!.EE9B!<:@!+5L9B!/PJE;O!

PB9<;!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'I%D9<@9B!5I!;A9!PB<:@99?!C:!;A9%"+2*#0'%!

!

1J!+5B@!6588<:@9@!AC?!?9BF<:;!>9!B<C?9@!;5!

ICB?;!IBC9:@!5I!;A9!,-I%A9!A<FC:P!<EE5C:;9@!AC8!

<?!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!6<;;D9O!ICB?;!EB5EA9;!5I!-P&k!A9!65:;C:79@!>J!<EE5C:;C:P!=AC8G!<?!8<d5B!5I!

;A9!6C;J!<:@!d7?;C69O!PCFC:P!AC8!B9?E5:?C>CDC;J!

I5B!B969CFC:P!;A9!$*0!5I!;A9!:5B;A9B:!<:@!?57;A9B:!I5B9CP:!D<:@?!;5!;A9!;B9<?7BJ!5I!;A9!

MC:P)!

!

Page 454: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V[V!

D)!W]G!#(+0%0+0%,-%!*<'%$(<'%"+2*#0'%%!

/)!

DD)!#^VG!*;9$%'#%;&C9C%$&%+%#(+%'"<%*%,-!

658E<:C5:?!<:@!PB9<;!5:9?!5I!;A9!,-I%657B;C9B?!LA5!<B9!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%!

1J!+5B@!6588<:@9@!;A<;!AC?!?9BF<:;!?A57D@!

>9!9D9F<;9@!;5!;A9!B<:M!5I!ICB?;!658E<:C5:!C:!

;A9!,-%!

U5;9?2!W^[!B965:?;B76;9@!>J!658E<BC?5:!LC;A!;A9!;9K;!5I!;A9!;58>!5I!?)2($2+,%=T)(()""G!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!(2![V#OW[k![_`O!W]k![_WObk![_aO]k![_#OWk![__OW`k![__OW])!N&(!(((2!_Oa)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!!N<8EE!W_aa2!"V[^"VbO!ICP?)![ab^[a#)!!$1!(OW2![W_^[[])!!3wF9^3x@9B>9BPA!W_b#2!WW^[W)!*5889:;2!+9C;Z![``[O!((2!V`b)!<!$1!(2![W_!=WG!>!$1!(2!WO!E)![[W!=VG)!%:;A9?!W_"b2!Wbb!II)!4<FC9?!W_]]2!V_O!ED?)!W[W^W[[)!!6!$1!(2!WO!E)![[[)!@!$1!(O!E)![[[^[["2!ECDD<B!T=<GO!(^(()!!+j@@96M9:?!W_]"2!W``!II)!9!$1!(2!WO!E)![[])!!

! !

Page 455: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V[_!

T)(()W[_! /D9EA<:;C:9![!

456789:;!;C;D9! -B<IIC;5!5I!;A9!?;<>D9!8<?;9B!F)'2(*'0!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! /D9EA<:;C:9)!&<8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! a!A5BCZ5:;<D!DC:9?!PB<IIC;5!IB58!/D9EA<:;C:9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%*%C&%-+<2$-0%F)'2(*'0%*%"&%$-0%,&%*%W#+2(&,'2+,%>1(*%(+$%*%7*0%*#0'%0"0'<%+%)&#'%*;0!!

!c5B!;A9!C&%5I!;A9!?;<>D98<?;9B!F)'2(*'0%5I!;A9!PB9<;!?;<>D9!5I!W#+2(&,'2+,I%>9D5F9@!5I!%87:!C:!;A9%7*0I%B5J<D!9:F5J!;5!<DD!;A9!I5B9CP:!657:;BC9?%!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!(((O![b[2!W]^Wb)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!X<><6AC!W_#_2!["]!II)O!ICP)!bO!ED)!"2[)!!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!a[]O!:5)![`_`)!!

! !

Page 456: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V"`!

!

T)(()W"`! '<:C?!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!^I5B8!<87D9;!5I!YCZC9B!M&2#+!!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! '<:C?O!$CB<89??9)!&<8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!ECDD<B!-!C:!;A9!>B5<@!A<DD!5I!;A9!;58>)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!DD)![^"G!#&;%&)%(%$;%-&"%7'%-+%#)+0%,-%$(<2+%*$0'%'&'<%M&2#+%(&,2)+0!

!4CP:C;<BJ!LA5!C?!7EBCPA;!5I!A9<B;O!LA5!M99E?!?CD9:69!<>57;!;A9!>7?C:9??!5I!;A9!,-O!6C;J!P5F9B:5B!<:@!FCZC9BO!M&2#+O!d7?;CIC9@!!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;9K;2!N&(!(((2!WWOb)!!

!

! !

Page 457: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V"W!

T)(()W"W! *-!a"`!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;<;79!5I!M&2#+!!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 198EAC?O!'98ED9!5I!$;<A)!&<8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! 3;<;79!?;<:@C:PO!A5D@C:P!ICP7B9!5I!$;<A)!'9K;!5:!;A9!@5B?<D!ECDD<B)!!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!D)![G!0<%*%*#0'%(%'&%+%.+94%#7+$%+%$;%'&0<%*%0+94%,*)0<"*%*#0'%(%,-94%'&<'<%#&;%'&'<%M&2#+%(&,2)+0!%%D)!"G!(2;&-94%*%C&%*%+2",'%-&'<2,%#&;%&)%(%$;%D7+E%-+%#)+0%,-!

!/J9?!5I!;A9!NC:P!C:!;A9!9:;CB9!D<:@O!LA5!>BC:P?!65:;9:;89:;!;5!;A9!'L5!+<:@?!I5B!AC?!8<?;9BO!/<B?!5I!;A9!NC:P!C:!AC?!,-I%d7@P9!<:@!@CP:C;<BJO!;A9!FCZC9B!M&2#+I%d7?;CIC9@)!!T9I5B9!AC8!I5B!;A9!C&!5I!;A9!A9B9@C;<BJ!EBC:69!<:@!8<J5BO!<!@CP:C;<BJ!LA5!C?!9II96;CF9O!7EBCPA;!5I!A9<B;O!LA5!M99E?!?CD9:69!<>57;!;A9!>7?C:9??!5I!;A9!,-%!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!(((2!W"O#^Vk!W"O!W`)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!!4<B9??J!WV_">2!W#[^W#])!!T5B6A<B@;!W_WW^W_"aO!((2!W##^W#_O!ED)!Wa)!!!

! !

Page 458: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V"[!

T)(()W"[! S<@C!9D^

39>7<!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!@9@C6<;9@!>J!5'2&0%C:!;A9!;98ED9!5I!S<@C!9D^39>7<!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! S<@C!9D^39>7<)!&<8)!(()!!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'A9! >C5PB<EAJ! 65:?C?;?! 5I! ;L9:;J^I57B! DC:9?! 5I! A5BCZ5:;<D!;9K;!:<BB<;C:P!5'2&0Q?!6<B99B)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%#;&0%-(94%(%D-(E%,-%)"+9*9$%(%"+2*#0'%)"+%*%"+2*#0'%$%-0*%

!,:9!LA58!XC?!1<d9?;J!;A57PA;O!C:!;A9!8<d9?;J!5I!;A9!,-%I5B!(!PB9L!7E!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'!LA9:!(!L<?!J57:P!!

U5;9?2!'A9!?7BI<69!5I! ;A9!?;9D9! C?!><@DJ!@9PB<@9@!<:@!8<:J!B9<@C:P!<B9!7:69B;<C:)! (!A<F9!

7?9@!;A9!9@C;C5:!5I!S9:;9!W_Vb!I5B!8J!;B<:?DC;9B<;C5:)!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!S9:;9!W_Vb2!"]VO!")!!'B<:?D<;C5:2!+C6A;A9C8!W_#"^W_V`O!((2!WbV^Wa[)!!

! !

Page 459: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V""!

T)(()W""! +CF9BE55D! *C;J!

17?978! (:F)!

[])_)``)_[!

456789:;!;C;D9! (F5BJ!E9:^6<?9!5I!M&2#+!!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!&<8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!DD)!W^[G!D*)'E%*#0'%;$'<%W#$+2(,&2?,2#'"2*2?,%W+'2@C&0%-.'2.!+'%*;'%,-%!

!=3<I9P7<B@C:PG!;A9!NC:P!5I!357;A9B:!<:@!U5B;A9B:!/PJE;O!W#$+2(,&2?,2#'"2*2?,I%;A9!>9D5F9@!5I!;A9!;LC:!W+'2@C&0O!+<@J!5I!;A9!,-%!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!(((2!W]Ob)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$1!Y2!a_)!!&<:@<DD^1<6C:9B!^!1<69!W_`[2!##O!ED)!]`2W[)!*5889:;2!+9C;Z![``[O!(Y2!"[)!!

! !

Page 460: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V"]!

T)(()W"]! *-!][Wa]!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;<;79!5I!M&2#+20!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<MO!*<6A9;;9)!&<8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! -B9J!PB<:C;9!?;<;79!5I!M&2#+20%A<:@C:P!<!\7<@B<:P7D<B!>D56M!LC;A!>5;A!A<:@?)! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!"!F9B;C6<D! DC:9?! C:?6BC>9@!5:!

;A9!><6M)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!WG%-+<2#!'&%*%"+2*#0'%%

!N99E9B!5I!?96B9;?!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;9K;2!X9D6M!W_bV2!]b`)!!+9PB<C:!W_`a^[bO!((2!"W!!!

! !

Page 461: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V"b!

T)(()W"b! T1!aV#!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;<;79!IB58!49CB!9D^T<A<BC!5I!M&2#+20!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 49CB!9D^T<A<BC)!&<8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! Y5;CF9!?;<;79!5I!M&2#+20%C:!?;<:@C:P!E5?C;C5:)!b!F9B;C6<D!DC:9?!C:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!><6M!5I!;A9!?;<;79)%!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%6)!"G%#(%(%"+2*#0'%%6)!]G%-&'<2,%*%0+0%(%,-!

!

'A9!#(^EBC9?;!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%%+9<@9B!5I!;A9!PB9<;!5:9?!C:!;A9!,-%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;9K;2!X9D6M!W_bV2!]b`)!!U<FCDD9!W_`#^W"O!(((2!E)!bk!ED)!(Y!]O!0!TO!9)!!

! !

Page 462: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V"a!

T)(()W"a! g/!]VV]b!

456789:;!;C;D9! -B9<;!-B<:C;9!3;9D9!5I!FCZC9B!DME?,2-'"!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 198EAC?O!'98ED9!5I!$;<A)!&<8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! $C:M! PB<:C;9! D<BP9! IB99?;<:@C:P! ?\7<B9! B57:@^;5EE9@! ?;9D9!C:?6BC>9@!5:!>5;A! I<69?! <:@!>5;A!9@P9?)! c<69! ()!%;! ;A9! ;5E!;A9! 5L:9B! C?! B9EB9?9:;9@! C:! <@5B<;C5:! 5I! $;<A! <;! ;A9!EB9?9:69!5I!%:7>C?k!;A9!>5;;58!C?!5667EC9@!>J!WW!A5BCZ5:;<D!DC:9?! C:?6BCE;C5:)! ! c<69! (()! %;! ;A9! ;5E! ;A9! 5L:9B! C?!B9EB9?9:;9@! C:! <@5B<;C5:!5I!,?CBC?! <;! ;A9!EB9?9:69!5I!%EC?)!T9D5L! ;A9B9! C?! <:! C:?6BCE;C5:! 65:?C?;C:P! 5I! W`! A5BCZ5:;<D!DC:9?)!%)!c<69!()!1<C:!;9K;)!T)!/@P9!4W)!*)!/@P9!T)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)!!DD)!]^bG%$(<2+%$(<0%)*'%,&%*%*;%'&0<%(%,-%-;2#.%%%%DD)!a^#G!#7+$%-(94%(%,-D'E9#%%T)!D)![G!*%C&%*%+2",'%-&'<2,%*'+%(+$%-+<2#!'&%"+2*#0'%!*)!%D)!WG%#,+%0&'%(%)+%,-%)0%*#0'%-+%0*($%$(<2+%*$0'%'&'<%?,2-'"%(,&2)+0%(%-'"%%%D)![G%*%C&%*%+2",'%-&'<2,%*'+%(+$%-+<2#!'&%*'<%"+2*#0'%%!

!,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!$(<0%)*'%=EBC9?;DJ!;C;D9GO!PB9<;!+5B@!5I!;A9!'L5!+<:@?!C:!;A9!,-%5I!;A9!-;2#.%%%,:9!LA5!8<M9?!65:;9:;!XC?!1<d9?;J!C:!AC?!,-!!!c5B!;A9!C&!5I!;A9!:5>D9!<:@!657:;O!-5@Q?!I<;A9BO!>9D5F9@!5I!;A9!-5@O!M99E9B!5I!?96B9;?!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'!!'A9!5:9!LA5!EB585;9?!BCPA;!<;!;A9!,-I%I<:^>9<B9B!5:!;A9!NC:PQ?!BCPA;!A<:@O!6C;J!P5F9B:5B!<:@!FCZC9BO!?,2-'"O!d7?;CIC9@!C:!E9<69!!c5B!;A9!?ECBC;!5I!;A9!:5>D9!<:@!657:;O!-5@Q?!I<;A9BO!>9D5F9@!5I!;A9!-5@O!6AC9I!5I!?96B9;?!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'!!

U5;9?2!W!(!7?9@!157B?CQ?!@9?CP:<;C5:?!5I!;A9!I<69?!<:@!9@P9?!<?!I<69?!%!<:@!T!<:@!9@P9?!*!<:@!4O!C:2!157B?C!W_VW)!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!(((2!b]OWbk!bbO#k!bbOW[!<:@!Wb)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$1!(((2![[a)!!TB7P?6A!WVV"^WV_WO!Y2!_b`!I)!!$C9AD!WVVa^W_`"O!(((2!ED?)!VWO!V[)!!157B?C!W_VW2!"b#O!ED)!WO!"*O!"4)!*5889:;2!X9D6M!W_bV2!]b])!'B<:?D<;C5:2!+C6A;A9C8!W_#"^W_V`O!((2!WbV^Wa[)!!

! !

Page 463: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V"#!

T)(()W"#! *<CB5!!

g)]W"_b!=3;9D9G!g)]W"_#!=DC:;9DG!g)]W"_#!=d<8>G!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!@9@C6<;9@!>J!5'2&0%C:!;A9!;98ED9!5I!S<@C!9D^39>7<)!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! S<@C!9D^39>7<)!&<8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! 1<C:!;9K;!658E5?9@!>J![]!A5BCZ5:;<D!DC:9?!5I!C:?6BCE;C5:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!D)!"G%$*C%8;&C:%#;&D0E%*%-(94%(%8.#94:%(%0#)'%K9(&,'<%.'%,-%)"+9*9$%(%"+2*#0'%$09$%(%-0*%!

!e(!L<?f!<!e?7>5B@C:<;9H?9BF<:;qf!LA58!XC?!1<d9?;J!eAC8?9DIf!C:?;B76;9@!C:!;A9!A<DD!5I!;A9!'LC:!'B7;A?O!=<?G!<!L<B@!5I!;A9!,-W9%(!PB9L!7E!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'I%LACD9!(!L<?!<!J57;A!!

U5;9?2!'A9!?7BI<69!5I!;A9!?;9D9!C?!><@DJ!@9PB<@9@!<:@!8<:J!B9<@C:P?!<B9!7:69B;<C:)!S9:;9!=S9:;9!W_Vb2!"]VO!"G!EB5E5?9?!<!@CII9B9:;!F9B?C5:!5I!;A9!;9K;2!#;&0%-(94%(%D-(E%,-%)"+%*9$%(%"+2*#0'%$09$%(%-0*I%,:9!LA58!XC?!1<d9?;J!;A57PA;O!C:!;A9!8<d9?;J!5I!;A9!,-%I5B!(!PB9L!7E!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'!LA9:!(!L<?!J57:P)!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!!N&(!(((2!_[OV)!S9:;9!W_Vb2!"]VO!")!'B<:?D<;C5:2!+C6A;A9C8!W_#"^W_V`O!((2!WbV^Wa[)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!X9D6M!W_#b>2!Vb^W[)!!T<B?<:;C!h!-<7;AC9B!W_WWO!ED)!((()!!-<7;AC9B!W_W[2!ED)!aa)!!NC;6A9:!W_#b^#a2![_b^"`[)!!!

! !

Page 464: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V"V!

T)(()W"_! T1!/%!W"##!

456789:;!;C;D9! U<5EA5B57?!?;<;79!5I!;A9!'B9<?7BJ^*AC9I!M&2*-#<9!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!&<8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'A9!85:789:;!C?!<!M:99DC:P!?;<;79!5I!;A9!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!;B9<?7BJ!M&2*-#<I!LA5!A5D@?!>9;L99:!AC?!A<:@?!<!:<5?!65:;<C:C:P!;A9!ICP7B9?!5I!X5B7?O!,?CBC?!<:@!(?C?!<:@!?7B857:;9@!>J!<!LC:P9@!?7:^@C?M)!'[!65D78:?!5:!;A9!><6M!ECDD<BO!;9K;?!5:!;A9!:<5?!<:@!;A9!><?9!C:65BE5B<;9!<7;5>C5PB<EAC6<D!9EC;A9;?!5I!;A9!?;<;79!5L:9B)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!><?9O!D9I;!A<DI)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!*%C&%*%+2",'%-&'<2,%)'(0%;$'<%DNE%#(+%0,%-+<2#!'&%#'0%,-!

!c5B!;A9!C&!5I!;A9!:5>D9!<:@!657:;O!?9<D9B!5I!.EE9B!<:@!+5L9B!/PJE;O!?5D9!658E<:C5:O!M99E9B!5I!?96B9;?!C:!;A9!5IIC69?!5I!;A9!,-%!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!(((2!W"#O!W])!$7>DC6<;C5:2!!TBC9>9B!W_V[2![[O!ED)!bW!gO!DC:9!W")!!!'B<:?D<;C5:2!+C6A;A9C8!W_#"^W_V`O!((2!Waa^W#`)!!%B7:@<D9!h!T5:58C!WV][2!ED)!bbO!ICP)!WV_)!!3A<BE9!WV"#^bbO!(2!ED)!b])!!$1!(2![O!E)!#_`)!!

! !

Page 465: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V"_!

T)(()W]`! T1!Wa#!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!;A9!36BC>9!5I!;A9!&5J<D!X<BC8%M'-2(20$&!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!&<8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! +C89?;5:9! B57:@^;5EE9@! ?;9D9! LC;A! ?69:9! 5I! <@5B<;C5:! 5I!,?CBC?!5667EJC:P!;A9!;5E)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5I!;A9!;5E^B9PC?;9BO!:9<B!;A9!B9EB9?9:;<;C5:!5I!;A9!5L:9B)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!D)!]G!*'+%$&0%*%W#$+%*%C&%*%#!%*#0'%$"'%#!2)&'%$"0'<%+%)&#'%*;D'E%-+<%$-0%*%7*0%M'-2(20$&%(&,2)+0!

!%@5BC:P!;A9!P5@O!I5B!,?CBC?O!I5B!;A9!C&!5I!;A9!?6BC>9!5I!;A9!B5J<D!A<BC8O!;<>D9!?6BC>9O!9:F5J!;5!9F9BJ!I5B9CP:!D<:@O!?;<>D9^8<?;9B!5I!;A9!7*0I%M'-2(20$&O!d7?;CIC9@!!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!(((2![`#O[)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!X'T1O!(02![_^"`O!ED?)![bH[b%)!!!

! !

Page 466: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V]`!

T)(()W]W! +57FB9!*!W]V!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!F4+2-'"I%&5J<D!;<>D9!?6BC>9!I5B!SC:9!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!&<8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! 3;9D9! LC;A! ;AB99! B9PC?;9B?! 5I! ?69:9?)! (:?6BCE;C5:! 5I! ;A9!8C@@D9! B9PC?;9B! :9<B! ;A9! B9EB9?9:;<;C5:! 5I! ;A9! 5L:9B! C:!<@5BC:P!E5?C;C5:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!D)![G!*#0'%#!%*+$94%+2,%P+-'%(%,'%$+"D0E%*%7*0!!

!&5J<D!?6BC>9!@9<DC:P!LC;A!F9??9D?!<:@!;A9!LC:9!@9E<B;89:;!5I!;A9!7*0%!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!'9K;2!N&(!(((2![W_OWa)!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!&7IID9!h!-<><DD<!^!NC;6A9:!W_#_2!!b`^b]O!ICP)!WO!ED)!()!!!

! !

Page 467: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V]W!

T)(()W][! 39A9D!

456789:;!;C;D9! -B<IIC;5!IB58!39A9D!5I!3;<>D98<?;9B!5I!&9?C@9:69!>1(*2-'"!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 39A9D!(?D<:@)!&<8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! -B<IIC;5!LC;A!]!A5BCZ5:;<D!DC:9?!C:?6BCE;C5:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!DD)!W^"E%-+<%$-0%>1(*2-'"%$+<%#&;%-(%*'+%>1(*%>1(*2-'"%"&%$-0%,&%?,2(+2(##D0E%7*0%$094%(%$"'%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%!

!'A9!?;<>D9^8<?;9BO!>1(*2-'"O!?5:!5I!;A9!@CP:C;<BJO!EB5EA9;!5I!%87:O!>1(*2-'"O!5I!;A9!PB9<;!?;<>D9!5I!&<89?9?O!5I!;A9!7*0I%A9!L<?!5:!;A9!>7?C:9??!5I!;A9!$A<B<5A!="+2,&GO!D)!E)!A)!!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!N&(!(((2![b`O[^")!X<><6AC!W_aV2!WW`O!ICP)!"O!ED)!W#)!$1!Y2![bW)!!

! !

Page 468: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V][!

T)(()W]"! E*-!*bV`b_!

456789:;!;C;D9! $<EJB7?!5I!F4+2,;0I%3;<>D9!8<?;9B!5I!;A9!B9?C@9:69!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!&<8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!D)!WG!0,;%F;$2(*2*0%-+%*.%)+'%*%-+<%$-0%F4+2,;0'%*%7*0%(%,*)%0.&%#*;%!

!'A9!0,;2EBC9?;!F;$2(*2*0!PB99;?!;A9!?;<>D9^8<?;9B!5I!;A9!7*0I%F4+2,;0'%C:!DCI9O!EB5?E9BC;J!<:@!A9<D;A!!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!'9K;2!N&(!(((2![bWOW`^WW)!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!T<MCB!W_#`2!ED?)!a^#O!(0)!!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

Page 469: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V]"!

T)(()W]]! T1!bbW]!

456789:;!;C;D9! S55@9:!?6BC><D!$<D9;;9!5I!;A9!?6BC>9!5I!A5B?9!H&!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 'A9>9?)!&<8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! 36BC>9!E<D9;;9!LC;A!;A9!D5J<D!C:?6BCE;C5:!<;!;A9!;5E!65:?C?;C:P!

5I! ;A9! :<89?! <:@! ;C;D9?! 5I! &<89?9?! ((! <:@! <! ;A9B9! F9B;C6<D!

DC:9?!@9@C6<;5BJ!C:?6BCE;C5:!5:!9C;A9B!?C@9!5I!;A9!69:;B<D!?D5;!

<:@!@5L:!;A9!69:;B9!5I!C;)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

"6)![G%#!%*%"&%-'+%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%

!36BC>9!5I!;A9!A5B?9^;9<8!5I!;A9!$A<B<5AO!D)!E)!A)!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!(((2![]_O!_)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!-D<:FCDD9!W_"[>2!b_O!ICP?)!WWO!W[O!ED)!#)!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!b[VO!:5)!W#VV)!!

! !

Page 470: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V]]!

T)(()W]b! ''!]b!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:?! IB58!;A9! ;58>!5I!\-0'<I%7?7BE9@!>J!\-0'<2(27&;!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 'A9>9?)!&<8)!(()!!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:?! I5B8! ;A9!TB5<@!X<DDO!L9?;!L<DDO! :5B;A! ?C@9!5F9B!;A9!B9EB9?9:;<;C5:!5I!-5@@9??!17;^T<?;9;)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!D)!]G!@*0'%,-D'E%%

!1C?;B9??!5I!;A9!-D'E!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!(((2!"bbOW"^W])!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$12!Vb^VV)!4<FC9?!W_]V2!W^W`k!ED?)!W^_)!!N<8EE!W_aa2![][^[]]O!ICP)!W]`)!15:@!W_`b2!V[)!*5889:;2!+9C;Z![``[O!Y2!W#W)!!!

! !

Page 471: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V]b!

T)(()W]a! %>7!3C8>9D![!

456789:;!;C;D9! -B<IIC;5!5I!;A9!YC69B5J!5I!/;AC5EC<!5'D0E<!!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>7!3C8>9D)!&<8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%$(<2+%"+2-.%$(<2+%#!0%(%7*0%*%'&%@0'2?,82(#2#02(+$2>1(*:%7*0%

!,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!;B9<?7BJO!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!?6BC>9?!C:!;A9!7*0%C:!;A9!D<:@!5I%@0'2?,2(#2#02(+$2>1(*%7*0%%

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!X9D6M!W_bV2!]_")!1<?E9B5!W_W`2!W"W^W]]2!W"[)!!

! !

Page 472: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V]a!

T)(()W]#! T7A9:!W!

456789:;!;C;D9! -B<IIC;5!5I!;A9!?6BC>9!F4+2-+!!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! T7A9:)!&<8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! /K!F5;5!5I!<:!5IIC6C<D!LA5!?;<:@?!LC;A!>5;A!A<:@?!B<C?9@! C:!

<@5B<;C5:)!(:!IB5:;!5I!AC8!<B9!a!F9B;C6<D!DC:9?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%6)!]G%D#!E%*%'&%#'%*%&!,0%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%

!=36BC>9G!C:!;A9!B965B@!5IIC69!5I!;A9!$A<B<5AO!D)!E)!A)%%

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!X9D6M!W_bV2!]_")!&<:@<DD^1<6(F9B!h!S55DD9J!W_WW2![b)!!!

! !

Page 473: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V]#!

T)(()W]V! T7A9:![!

456789:;!;C;D9! -B<IIC;5!5I!;A9!?6BC>9!M$&<!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! T7A9:)!&<89?9?!((O!R)!")!

49?6BCE;C5:! /K! F5;5! 5I!M$&<! ?A5L:! <@5BC:P! ;A9! ?<6B9@! B<8!19:@9?)! (:!

IB5:;!<:@!<>5F9!M$&<%;A9B9!C?!<!a!F9B;C6<D!DC:9?!C:?6BCE;C5:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%6)!"G%*#0'%#!%$(<2+%"+2-.%*%'&%#'%&!,0%"+2,&%%

!&5J<D!?6BC>9O!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!;B9<?7BJ!C:!;A9!B965B@!5IIC69!5I!;A9!$A<B<5A%%

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!X9D6M!W_bV2!]_")!&<:@<DD^1<6(F9B!h!S55DD9J!W_WW2![a)!!!

! !

Page 474: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V]V!

T)(()W]_! T7A9:!"!

456789:;!;C;D9! -B<IIC;5!5I!@+$!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! T7A9:)!&<8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! /K! F5;5! 5I! M$% @+$% B9EB9?9:;9@! <?! M:99DC:P! <:@! <@5BC:P!.><?;9;)!(:!IB5:;!<:@!>9AC:@!@+$%C?!<:!C:?6BCE;C5:!5I!a!F9B;C6<D!DC:9?)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%6)!aG%*%"&%$-0%,&%*%5'<2(+$2*2M'-%*%7*0%%

!(:!;A9!PB9<;!?;<>D9!5I!5'<2(+$2*2M'-%5I!;A9%7*0!%

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!&<:@<DD^1<6(F9B!h!S55DD9J!W_WW2!"V)!!!

! !

Page 475: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V]_!

T)(()Wb`! T7A9:!]!

456789:;!;C;D9! Y5;CF9!C:?6BCE;C5:!5I!W*2'&20&'!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! T7A9:)!&<8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! cB<P89:;! 5I! <:! 9K^F5;5! LC;A! <! F9B;C6<D! DC:9! C:?6BCE;C5:O! ;5!

;A9! C889@C<;9! BCPA;! 5I!LAC6A! C?! <!8<:!LA5! <EE9<B?! ;5! >9!

5II9BC:P!ID5L9B?!=qG!;5!?589!@CFC:C;J)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%6)!aG%-+<%$-0%7*0%W*2'&20&'%%

!3;<>D9^8<?;9B!5I!;A9!7*0I%W*2'&20&'%%

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!&<:@<DD^1<6(F9B!h!S55DD9J!W_WW2!#_)!!!

! !

Page 476: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! Vb`!

T)(()WbW! 39@89:;! ,(*!

WW#"W!

456789:;!;C;D9! 455B!5I!;A9!DC97;9:<:;!6588<:@9B!5I!;A9!6A<BC5;BJ!M&2-(2*'+!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 39@89:;)!&<8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:! 5:! ;A9! >5;;58! B9PC?;9B! B9EB9?9:;C:P! <! ICD9! 5I!E95ED9)!'C;D9! B9I9BB9@!;5!5:9!5I! ;A98)!'C;D9!B9I9BB9@!;5!;A9!?5:!5I!;A9!5L:9B)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%-+<%$-0%*%7*0%!

!3;<>D9!8<?;9B!5I!;A9!7*0%!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!(((2![]]O!W]^Wb)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$9;BC9!h!TB7:;5:!W_[]O!((2!ED)!aV)!!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!"#WO!:5)!W[Wb)!!

! !

Page 477: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! VbW!

!T)(()Wb[! $ACD<@9DEAC<O!

.:CF)!

17?978! /)!

b"]!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;<;79!5I!M&2#+!!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 49CB!9D^T<A<BCO!'98ED9!5I!19:;7A5;9E)!&<8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! 3;<;79!IB58!19B9:E;<A^;98ED9!5I!49CB!9D^T<A<BC!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!D)!"G%#(%(%"+2*#0'%0,%(*)%D-+<2E'"%(%!*0'%-&'<%0+0%(%,-%,P%+%"'%+%(&&%$(<9#%%

!5(^EBC9?;!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'I%7:C\79!9IIC6C9:;!<;!;A9!A9<@!5I!;A9!657B;C9B?!D9<@9B!5I!;A9!PB9<;!5:9?!5I!;A9!,-I%LA5!9:;9B?!;A9!?MJ!;5!?99!AC8!LA5!C?!C:!C;!=;A9!MC:PG!!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!(((O!WV2a)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$1!((O!"_b)!!U<FCDD9!W_`#^W"O!(((2!ED)!0)!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!]_WO!:5)!Waa])!!

!

! !

Page 478: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! Vb[!

T)(()Wb"! ''!W_!

456789:;!;C;D9! 'A9><:!;58>!5I!;A9!ACPA!EBC9?;!>1(*2(#D<E!!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 'A9>9?)!&<8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!>9I5B9! ;A9! ICP7B9!5I! >1(*2(#%5:!;A9!BCPA;!A<DI!5I!;A9!B9<B!L<DD!5I!;A9!>B5<@!A<DDO!7EE9B!B9PC?;9B)%!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

"DD)!W^[G%#.(%,!%*%"+2,&!!

!39BF<:;!=DC;)!o5:9!LA5!A9<B?!;A9!6<DDC:PrG!5I!;A9!"+2,&%!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!(((O!"_bO!W")!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$1!(2!WO!"[^"])!!c576<B;!W_[V^W_"b)!!N<8EE!W__a2![``^[`WO!ICP)!W`[)!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!bVVO!:5)!W_a[)!!

!

!

! !

Page 479: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! Vb"!

T)(()Wb]! %>J@5?!a!

456789:;!;C;D9! &9DC9I!5I!;A9!B5J<D!?6BC>9!M'-2(+$!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!&<8)!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! 3<:@?;5:9! ><?^B9DC9I! @CFC@9@! C:! ;L5! >D56M?)! ,:9! DC:9!C:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!BCPA;!>D56M)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

"#!%*#0'%'&%!,'%*%"+2,&!

!&5J<D!?96B9;<BJH!D9;;9B!LBC;9B!5I!;A9!$A<B<5A!!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!(((O![WW2W`O!"##2W`)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!4<B9??J!WVV#2!_`)!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!bb]O!:5O!W]Vb)!!

!

!

! !

Page 480: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! Vb]!

T)(()Wbb! *-!"#[]W#!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!;A9!B5J<D!>7;D9B!`*2$'*!5B!?,2(#2*#0'2(2"+2?,!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!19B9:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! &57:@^;5EE9@! ?;9D9! B9EB9?9:;C:P! ;A9! 398C;9! `*2$'*%=B9:<89@! ?,2(#2*#0'2(2"+2?,% @7BC:P! ;A9! B9CP:! 5I!

19B9:E;<AG%C:!<6;!5I!<@5BC:P!19B9:E;<A!LC;A!#!65D78:?!5I!

C:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!BCPA;!A<DI!5I!;A9!D7:9;;9)!,;A9B!W`!F9B;C6<D!

DC:9?!5I! C:?6BCE;C5:!<B9!6<BF9@! C:!;A9!8C@@D9!B9EB9?9:;<;C5:!

5:!;A9!BCPA;!?C@9!5I!<!><:\79;C:P!?69:9)!'A9!>5;;58!5I!;A9!

?;9D9!C?!5667EC9@!>J!<!]!A5BCZ5:;<D!DC:9?!;9K;)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%0;&%*#0'%,&%*%,'%-*C!"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;!!!

!*AC9I!B5J<D!>7;D9B!C:!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!5II9BC:P!=MC;6A9:G!5I!;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!(YO!W`]2!W`^WW)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$1!YO!bV^b_)!!1<BC9;;9!WVV`O!((2!ED)!b`)!!&5L9!W_]`2!ED)!V)!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2![[#O!:5)!#V[)!!

!

!

%

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

Page 481: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! Vbb!

T)(()Wba! ''!["!

456789:;!;C;D9! '58>!5I!H&<O!&5J<D!?96B9;<BJ!5I!19B9:E;<A!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 'A9>9?)!19B9:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:! IB58! ;A9! ;ACB@! B558! 5I! ;A9! ?C@9! 6A<8>9B?!LC;A!

;A9!><>55:!C8<P9!5I!'A5;A)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!DD)!W^]G!\-0'<%#!%(%#'%,!,0'%"+2,&%%

!'A5;A!C:!;A9!ED<69!5I!;A9!B965B@!5IIC69%"+2,&!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!(YO!W`_O!a)!$1!(2!WO!"V^]W)!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!T5B6A<B@;!W_`#HV2!b_!II)!!*5DDC:?!W_#a2!WV^W_)!!!N<8EE!W__a2![`a^[`VO!ICP)!W`_)!!NC;6A9:!W__W2!a_^#])!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!]``O!:5)!WWW[)!!

!

!

!

! !

Page 482: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! Vba!

!T)(()Wb#! 3<\\<B<!456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!=#!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3<\\<B<)!&<8)!(()!49?6BCE;C5:! 'A9!C:?6BCE;C5:!5I!=#!65:?C?;?!5I!<!B9E5B;!5I!<!?C:PD9!D<L?7C;!

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o*;'! C:! X9DC5E5DC?)! T5;A! E<B;C9?! 6<89! ;5! 657B;!9\7CEE9@! LC;A! <! I5B8C@<>D9! <BB<J! 5I! 9FC@9:69)! SA9:! ;A9!FCZC9B! 5E9:9@! ;A9! E<EJB7?! B5DD?O! ;A9CB! ?;<;989:;?! L9B9!65:;B<@C6;5BJ! >96<7?9! 5:9! 5I! ;A9! ;L5!L57D@! A<F9! >99:! <!I<M9)%F4+'2*;0I%65:IC@9:;! C:! ;A9! d7?;C69!5I!A9B!6D<C8O!<?M9@!I5B! ;A9! B9PC?;9B?!5I! ;<K<;C5:!EB9?9BF9@! C:! ;A9!'B9<?7BJ!<:@!;A9! 49E<B;89:;! 5I! -B<:<BJ! 5I! ;A9! $A<B<5A)! X9B! EB5E5?<D!89;!LC;A! ;A9! <EEB5F<D! 5I! ;A9! FCZC9B! <:@! <!898>9B! 5I! ;A9!-B9<;! o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aG)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!%UO!aG%$+0%(%#*'<%+.$%(%,+<'%*'%"+2,&%%%UO!#G!..9D#E%$($%$*$9'0%*9$%'0%.*<%(%"+2-.%'&%!*0'%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%%%UO!W]G%F4+'2*;0%-+%..%*%'&'<%$($%$*$9'0%*9$%'&%8.*<99%$0%'&'<%-+:%..%*9#%*4+984:%+%$P+%"&%..%$0%..9$pC%-+%$'&9#*%(%).$%+%"+2?,2(#2*#0'2(+$%$0%'0%-+%,P%+%"+2-.%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%($D''E%'&%#'%'&%!*0'%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%$0%'0%-+%$*$%'&%.*<%(2;&-%'&'<%P*;'%%

!%! 65EJ! L<?!8<@9! <:@! C;! L<?! ED<69@! C:! ;A9!,++<'!5I!"+2,&%%'A9:!?A9!=F4+'2*;0!h!19?Q!85;A9BG!?<C@2!oD9;!;A9B9!>9!>B57PA;!A589!;A9!B9PC?;9B?!IB58!;A9!'B9<?7BJO!<:@!DCM9LC?9!IB58!;A9!@9E<B;89:;!5I!;A9!-B<:<BJ!5I!;A9!$A<B<5Ar!!'A9:%F4+'2*;0%?<C@!;5!;A9!FCZC9B2!oD9;!;A9B9!>9!>B57PA;!;5!89!e;L5!B9PC?;9B?!IB58!;A9!'B9<?7BJ!<:@!DCM9LC?9!IB58!;A9!49E<B;89:;!5I!;A9!-B<:<BJ!=qG!<:@!;A9!YCZC9Bf!?<C@!;5!A9B2!oF9BJ!P55@!C?!;A<;!LAC6A!J57!?<C@)!'A9:!;A9J!>B57PA;!7?!@5L:?;B9<8!;5!$CB<89??9!<:@!;A9J!9:;9B9@!C:;5!;A9!49E<B;89:;!5I!;A9!

Page 483: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! Vb#!

!!!!! !

%%%%UO!WaG%$0%#!%*#0'%0.-0%B,$%#&%=*'02(2(*%$0%-+%..%*%'&'<%$)%"&%#)+%$+9C%*%F4+'2*;0%$0%'&'<%-+%..%*%B,$%0$%'09C%*%7*0%$)%!(9C%+%"+2-.%(%'09C%"'+%(&&%"&<9#%#)+0%%%%%UO![`^[WG%..%*'%(%D$E*$0%,*)%=#2(*%80&-%>1(*%0&-%"&%-P&:%$0%..9$%(%(&,'%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%UO!"`G%8..%*':%;$'2$+<%*%"+2-.%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;!@+%DNE%%

-B<:<BJ!5I!;A9!$A<B<5AO!<:@!;A9J!>B57PA;!;A9!;L5!B9PC?;9B?!>9I5B9!;A9!FCZC9B!C:!;A9!PB9<;!%P*;'%%'A9:!;A9!?6BC>9!5I!;A9!B5J<D!;<>D9O!B,$O!?5:!5I%=*'02(2(*I%?<C@!;5!;A9!FCZC9B2!oLA<;!C?!;A9!@96C?C5:!LAC6A!J57!8<@9!LC;A!B9P<B@!;5!F4+'2*;0qr!%:@!;A9!FCZC9B!?<C@!;5!B,$2!oJ57!>9D5:P9@!;5!;A9!7*09%-5!;A9:!;5!;A9!;B9<?7BJ!<:@!?99!A5L!;A9!8<;;9B!?;<:@?!LC;A!A9B)!!!SA<;!L<?!?<C@!>J!;A9!P5<;A9B@!=#2(*!e>J!%87:!<:@!>J!;A9!EBC:69f)!(!?E9<M!>J!;A9!'B7;A!5I!=qG!$A<B<5A!<@!(!?E9<M!:5;!I<D?9DJ!!eSA<;!L<?!?<C@!>Jf!;A9!A5:9J^8<M9B!5I!;A9!'B9<?7BJ!5I!$A<B<5A%@+%DNE%!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!-<B@C:9B!W_`b)!

Page 484: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! VbV!

T)(()WbV! T1!Wb]!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!;A9!B5J<D!9:F5JO!W**2*4+!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!19B9:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 3<:@?;5:9! B57:@^;5EE9@! ?;9D9! LC;A! "! B9PC?;9B?! 5I!B9EB9?9:;<;C5:)!(:!;A9!7EE9B85?;!B9PC?;9BO!;A9!5L:9B!8<M9?!5II9BC:P?!;5!"!@9C;C9?k!C:!;A9!8C@@D9!B9PC?;9B!;A9B9!C?!<!B5L!5I![!89:! <:@! ]!L589:k! C:! ;A9! D5L9B! B9PC?;9B! C?! @9EC6;9@! ;A9!>BC:PC:P! 5I! 5II9BC:P?! >J! oAC?! ?5:O! ;A9! ?;<>D9^8<?;9B! 5I! ;A9!&9?C@9:69r!<:@!C:!IB5:;!5I!AC8!?C;![!89:!<:@!"!L589:O!5:9!5I! ;A98! <P<C:! 9:;C;D9@! o?;<>D9^8<?;9B! 5I! ;A9! &9?C@9:69r)!'C;D9!B9I9BB9@!;5!;A9!?5:!<:@!;A9!>B5;A9B!5I!;A9!5L:9B)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!"G%-+<%$-0%*%7*0%!

!3;<>D9^8<?;9B!5I!;A9!7*0%!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!(YO!W["2!Wbk!W[]O![)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!T1X'!(0O!"W^"[O!ED?)![#^[#<)!!TB7::9B!W_b_2!"^bO!ED)!()!!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!"#WO!:5)!W[Wb)!!

!

!

!

! !

Page 485: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! Vb_!

T)(()Wb_! '5@!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!&<89?9?!(((!B9I9BBC:P!;5!;A9!5IIC6C<D!M*2"&2'&!<;!'5@!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! '5@O!;98ED9!5I!15:;7)!&<8)!((()!!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!&<89?9?! (((!5:!;A9!9K;9B:<D!L<DDO!9<?;!?C@9O!5I!

;A9!?<:6;7<BJ)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

"-+<%$+<%#!0%*%"+2-.%*%"+2,É!,*)%0.&%#*;!!

!*AC9I!<B6ACFC?;!5I!;A9!;B9<?7BJ!5I!;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!YO![""2!"^])!$7>DC6<;C5:2!T<BP79;!W_b[2!__O!ED)!(Y)!!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!"aaO!:5)!W[]`)!!

!

!

!

!

!

! !

Page 486: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! Va`!

T)(()Wa`! ''!]"!

456789:;!;C;D9! '58>!5I!$BC:69!5'2-+2)"!94!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! Y<DD9J!5I!;A9!l799:?)!&<8)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!B9<B^L<DD!5I!;A9!;58>)!!369:9! C:!;A9!B9<B!L<DDO! BCPA;!?C@9!LC;A!;A9!B9EB9?9:;<;C5:!5I!;A9! P5@@9??! 19B;?9P9B! L5B?ACEE9@! >J! ;A9! MC:P! <:@! ;A9!EBC:69)!'C;D9!B9I9BB9@!;5!;A9!P5@!19B;?9P9B)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!DD)!W^[G!F;%,-!%

!+5B@!5I!;A9!,-%!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!Y2!"#]OW])!$7>DC6<;C5:2!!36AC<E<B9DDC!W_["^[#2!W[]^W"[)!!TB7JiB9!W_[b2!Wb_)!X<><6AC!W_b]2!b`b)!*5889:;2!+9C;Z![``[O!(Y2!"[)!!

! !

Page 487: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! VaW!

T)(()WaW! 19PC@@5!

456789:;!;C;D9! $9:!6<?9!5I!F)'2>1(*!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 19PC@@5)!&<8)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%-+<%$-0%*%7*0%!

!3;<>D9^8<?;9B!5I!;A9!7*0%!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!YO![bb2!Wb)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$1!Y((O!"V`^"VW)!!SCD?5:!W_"V2!WW^W[O!ED)!a[)!!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!"#WO!:5)!W[Wb)!!

!

!

% %

Page 488: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! Va[!

T)(()Wa[! *-![b#a_!

456789:;!;C;D9! +C:;9D!5I!;A9!B5J<D!9:F5J!M&2-(2*'+!!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! XCDD9A)!&<8)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! +C:;9D!LC;A!5:9!DC:9!5I!C:?6BCE;C5:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%-+<%$-0%8*%7*0:%!

!3;<>D9^8<?;9B!e5I!;A9!7*0f%!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!YO!"_"2!#^V)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!4<B9??J!W_[`>)!!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!"#WO!:5)!W[Wb!!

!

! !

Page 489: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! Va"!

T)(()Wa"! 19@C:9;!

X<>7!"!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:?!IB58!;A9!;58>^6A<E9D!5I!M&2#+%<;!19@C:9;!X<>7)!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 19@C:9;!X<>7)!&<8)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!@C;;5O!;5E!B9PC?;9B)!

T)! (:?6BCE;C5:! IB58! @C;;5O! T5;;58! B9PC?;9B2! ?9BC9?! 5I! I<8CDJ!

?69:9?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%DD)!W`^WWG%C&%*'+0%*0%"+2,&%%D)!VWG%-+<%$-0%*%7*0%

!'A9!C&%5I!;A9!P5@?!5I!;A9!"+2,&%!3;<>D9^8<?;9B!5I!;A9!7*0%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!Y2!"VaO![)!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!36A5;;!W_b#2![^bO!ED)!Wk!W_^[`)!$1!(2![O!##"^#])!!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!"#WO!:5)!W[Wb)!!+9C;Z![``[O!Y((2!["V)!!

!

!

!

!

!

! %

Page 490: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! Va]!

T)(()Wa]! ''!W]V!

456789:;!;C;D9! 'A9><:!;58>!5I!;A9!EBC9?;!5I!%87:!>1(*2(2$"'!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 4B<!%>7!9D^U<P<)!&<8)!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! !%)! 'C;D9! B9I9BB9@! ;5! 5:9! 5I! ;A9! B9D<;CF9?! B9EB9?9:;9@! C:! ;A9!8C@@D9! B9PC?;9B!5I! ;A9! ?57;A9B:!A<DI!5I! ;A9! B9<B!L<DD!5I! ;A9!>B5<@!A<DD)!!T)!1<C:!;9K;!C:!;A9!>B5<@!X<DDO!?57;A9B:!A<DI!5I!;A9!B9<B!L<DD)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)!!0O!WG%-+<%$-0%*%7*0%%!T)!D)![G%-(94%(%,-94%%

!3;<>D9^8<?;9B!5I!;A9!7*0%%%XC?!1<d9?;J!C:!AC?!,-%!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!Y(2!_[O_)!N&(!YO!]W[!II)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$1!(2!WO![b_^[a`)!!-<><DD<^NC;6A9:!W_VW2!WaW^WV`k!!N<8EE!W_aa2!]"]^]"#O!ICP?)!"[_^""W)!!,6MC:P<!W__"2!]W^b`)!!,6MC:P<!W__a2!ab^#")!!,6MC:P<![``_)!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!"#WO!:5)!W[Wb)!!

%

!

!

!

%

!

%

!

!

! !

Page 491: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! Vab!

T)(()Wab! NA<B;578!

"`aW!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!YC69B5J!@+<%IB58!%8<B:<!S9?;!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %8<B:<!S9?;)!&<8)!(((O!R)!b)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'C;D9!B9I9BB9@!;5!;A9!P5@@9??!T<?;9;)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!D)!"G%*;'%,-%!

!+<@J!5I!;A9!,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!Y2!"V[O!a)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$1!Y((2!Wa[O!;5E)!!c<CB8<:!W_"_2!ED)Wb!!*5889:;2!+9C;Z![``[O!(Y2!"[)!!!

! !

Page 492: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! Vaa!

T)(()Waa! T9BDC:![`VW!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!;A9!?6BC>9!5I!$A<B<5A!@+$!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!&<8)!Y((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!C:!;A9!8C@@D9!B9PC?;9B)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!D)!]G%#!%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%!

!36BC>9!5I!;A9!"+2,&O!D)!E)!A)!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!Y(2!]"_)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$1!YO!_V)!!&59@9B!W_[]O!((2!WVa^_)!!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!b"[O!:5)!W#__)!!

!

!

! !

Page 493: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! Va#!

T)(()Wa#! 3C:<C!"`[!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!5;C2-'"!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 39B<>C;!9D^NA<@C8)!&<8)!(0)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%-+<2#!'&%,-%!"#%!!

!N99E9B!5I!?96B9;?!5I!;A9!<7P7?;!,-!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!Y(2!VbO![)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$1!Y((O!"ab)!!-<B@C:9B!h!$99;!W_[`2!ED)!#bO!((O!W_])!!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!]`_O!:5)!W"_`)!!

!

! !

Page 494: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! VaV!

T)(()WaV! N<B:<M!W]!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!;A9!ACPA!EBC9?;!>1(*2-'"!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<M)!&<8)!(0)!!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!V;A!$JD5:!5I!;A9!;98ED9!5I!N<B:<M)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!"G%$(<2+%"+2-.%*%"+2,&%%D)!]G%#!%*%"+2,&%%D)!W[G%$%.$9C%$*0%+%"+2,&%"&<9C%*;%%%%D)!WbG%"&%$(<2+%"+2-.%"&%0."0%*%"+2,&%*%*;0%-.%

!,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!;B9<?7BJ!5I!;A9!$A<B<5A!!36BC>9!5I!;A9!$A<B<5A!!1CPA;!J57!PCF9!;A9!$*0%;5!;A9!$A<B<5AO!J57B!+5B@!!,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!;B9<?7BJO!>7;D9B!5I!;A9!$A<B<5A!5I!P5D@!<:@!?CDF9B!!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;9K;2!X9D6M!W_bV2!]aW)!!TB7P?6A!WVV"^WV_2!W"WV)!!

! !

Page 495: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! Va_!

T)(()Wa_! 398:<![!

456789:;!;C;D9! +C:;9D!5I!;A9!6AC9I!5I!;A9!?;<>D9O!W*D2'&E20,!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 398:<!S9?;)!&<8)!(0)!

49?6BCE;C5:! +9I;!9:@!5I!<!DC:;9D!LC;A!a!DC:9?!C:?6BC>9@!5:!C;)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!bG%-+<%$-0%*%7*0%%!

!3;<>D9^8<?;9B!5I!;A9!7*0!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!Y(O!b"`2b)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$1!Y((O!WbW)!!-<7;AC9B!W_[V2!W"]^W"aO!ED)![)!!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!"#WO!:5)!W[Wb!!

!

!

! !

Page 496: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V#`!

T)(()W#`! T1!#_[!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!;A9!FC69B5J!5I!N7?AO!W*20,&'!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!&<8)!(0!=qG!

49?6BCE;C5:! &57@^;5EE9@!?;9D9!LC;A!?DCPA;DJ!?D5EC:P!?C@9?!@CFC@9@! C:!;L5!B9PC?;9B?!5I!?69:9?)!!%)!'A9!;C;D9!C?!B9I9BB9@!;5!5:9!5I!;A9!?CK!E9B?5:?!C:!<;;C;7@9!5I!L5B?ACEO!B9EB9?9:;9@!C:!;A9!?965:@!B9PC?;9B)!T)! ,;A9B! ;C;D9! B9I9BB9@! ;5! F&2-+O! 5:! LA58! >9A<DI! C?! ;A9!EB<J9B!C:6C?9@!<;!;A9!>5;;58!5I!;A9!?;9D9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%%)!-+<%$-0%*%7*0%%%T)!D)!]G%-+<%$-0%*%7*0%%%

!!3;<>D9^8<?;9B!5I!;A9!7*0%%%3;<>D9^8<?;9B!5I!;A9!7*0!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!Y(2!b[bO!_^W`O!Wa)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!X'T1!W`O![`^[WO!ED?)!]]2[)!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!"#WO!:5)!W[Wb)!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

! !

Page 497: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V#W!

T)(()W#W! $9::?JDF<:C<!

.:CF9B?C;J!

17?978! /)!

W`__`!

456789:;!;C;D9! +C:;9D!5I!W*2'&20&'O!T7A9:!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! T7A9:)!&<8)!(0)!

49?6BCE;C5:! +C:;9D!LC;A!W!DC:9!C:?6BCE;C5:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!WG%-+<%$-0%*%7*0%%!

!3;<>D9^8<?;9B!5I!;A9!7*0!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!Y(2!b"`O!V)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!1<6CF9B!^!S55DD9J!W_[W2!#_!:5)!V)!!38C;A!W_#a2![WbO!ED)!VW)!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!"#WO!:5)!W[Wb)!!

!

! !

Page 498: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V#[!

T)(()W#[! %>J@5?!#!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!;A9!ACPA!EBC9?;!5I!%89:^&9!M&2,*)!!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!&<8)!0()!

49?6BCE;C5:! 3;9D9!LC;A!b!A5BCZ5:;<D!DC:9?!C:?6BCE;C5:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!"G!$(<2+%!*0'<%*%"+2,&%%D)!]G%$(<2+%".'<0%"+2,&!!

!,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!PB<:<BC9?!5I!;A9!$A<B<5A!!,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!>5L89:!5I!;A9!$A<B<5A!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!Y(2!V]V)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!1<BC9;;9!WVV`2!ED)!b#)!!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!W"WO!:5)!]"`)!!

! !

Page 499: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V#"!

T)(()W#"! *-![b#]b!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!M&2,*)!!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!&<8)!0()!

49?6BCE;C5:! 3;9D9!LC;A!b!A5BCZ5:;<D!DC:9?!C:?6BCE;C5:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!]G!$(<2+%!*0'<%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%

!,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!PB<:<BC9?!5I!;A9!$A<B<5AO!D)!E)!A)!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!Y(2!V]_O![)!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!W"WO!:5)!]"`)!!

! !

Page 500: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V#]!

T)(()W#]! YC6;5BC<!

17?978!

456789:;!;C;D9! 455Bd<8>!5I!>1(*20,2*899:!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .EE?<D<!q)!&<8)!0()!

49?6BCE;C5:! 455Bd<8>!LC;A!"!65D78:?!5I!C:?6BCE;C5:!9<6A!65:;<C:C:P!<:!C:F56<;C5:!;5!5:9!5I!;A9!898>9B?!5I!;A9!'A9><:!;BC<@9!<:@!;5!;A9!C&!5I!&<89?9?!(()!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

"O.*%'"<%*%-(94%*%"&%$-0%,&%*%W#+2(&,'2+,%5'"2*2?,%*%87*0:%!

!cCB?;!6A<BC5;99B!5I!XC?!1<d9?;J!C:!;A9!PB9<;!?;<>D9!5I!W#+2(&,'2+,%5'"2*2?,%C:!;A9!87*0:!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!(((O![b"2!W`O!W[)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!X<><6AC!W_b]2!b]])!!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!a[]O!:5)![`_`)!!

! !

Page 501: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V#b!

T)(()W#b! }<LJ9;!

37D;<:!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!;58>!5I!;A9!ACPA!?;9L<B@?!F4+2#+27+0!<;!}<LJ9;!37D;<:)!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! }<LJ9;!37D;<:O!1C@@D9!/PJE;)!W_;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)!'A9!>C5PB<EAC6<D!C:?6BCE;C5:!C?!6<BF9@!5:!;A9!L9?;!L<DD!5I!;A9! ?57;A9B:! A<DI! 5I! ;A9! A<DD! 5I! ;A9! ;58>O! :9K;! ;5! ;A9!9:;B<:69)!'A9!;9K;!EB9?9:;?!?;<P9?!5I!AC?!6<B99B!C:!@CII9B9:;!<@8C:C?;B<;CF9!<B9<?!5I!;A9!E<D<69)!!T)!'C;D9?!5I!;A9!5L:9B!C:!;A9!;58>)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)!D)!WG%"&%0+%(%"+2*#0'%%DD)!V^_E%#!9*9$%(%,7*0'<%;0%7+<%-(94%$*P09$%+%C&"%*%)*'$%%'$%0$%(%*4+%(.0%#0'%,-!!!D)!W"G!"+9$%-+%#;&0%*0%"+2*#0'%%T9%D)!WG!$(<2+%"+%0+%(%"+2*#0'%%D)!"G%#!%0.-0%(%,-%*%8*#0':%%%D)!]G%#!%*#0'%,;02+%(%,-%*%*#0'%!

!'A9!PB9<;!5:9!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'!!(!L<?!?6BC>9!C:!;A9!,7*0'<!'A9!ED<69!LA9B9!XC?!1<d9?;J!C?!(!L<?!9:6D5?9@!C:!;A9!EB5;96;9@!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!57;9B!E<D<69!>9C:P!<!J57;A!LA58!;A9!?;<II!5I!;A9!,-!D5F9@!!(!L9:;!I5B;A!IB58!;A9!P<;9?!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'%%!3;9L<B@!C:!;A9%"+2*#0'%!36BC>9!5I!;A9!;<>D9!5I!5II9BC:P?!C:!;A9%,-%5I!;A9!eMC:Pf!!&5J<D!?6BC>9!5I!;A9!>B9<MI<?;!C:!;A9!,-%5I!;A9!MC:P!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!,?C:P!W__[<2!"]k!]"^]bO!ED)!]b)!!'B<:?D<;C5:2!+C6A;A9C8!W_#"^W_V`O!((2!W]"^W]#)!!

!

!

! !

Page 502: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V#a!

T)(()W#a! .:M:5L:!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!@+(0$&!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!W_;A!4J:)!=39;J!(!qG!

49?6BCE;C5:! cB<P89:;<BJ!?<:@?;5:9!?;9D9!LC;A!;BC<:P7D<B!?A<E9!@CFC@9@!C:! "! B9PC?;9B?)! 'A9! EJB<8C@^?A<E9! B9PC?;9B! C?! D5?;)! 'A9!8C@@D9! 5:9! B9EB9?9:;?! <! ?69:9! 5I! <@5B<;C5:! 5I! P5@?)! 'A9!>5;;58!C?!5667EC9@!>J!a!A5BCZ5:;<D!DC:9?!C:?6BCE;C5:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!D)!WG!@+%(%7*0%%!D)!#G!$&0%&;.0%(%.&$%(%F!('%$0%"&%*;%&;.0%-'"%(%,-94%!

!X5B7?!C:!;A9!7*0!!$B<C?9!;5!%>J@5?O!<;!;A9!?<CDC:P!5I!;A9!F!('!?ACEO!LA9:!;A9!+5B@!5I!%>J@5?!B9?;?!C:!AC?!,-!!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!(2!"b#OW`k!"bVOW])!$7>DC6<;C5:2!*DiB9!W_b_2!Va^W`]O!ED)!(Y^Y)!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

! !

Page 503: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V##!

T)(()W##! /D^4<8<JC:!

456789:;!;C;D9! g<8>!5I!DC89?;5:9!@55B!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! /D^4<8<JC:!=c<\57?G)!W_;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! /KEB9??C5:! B9E9<;9@! "! ;C89?! C:! ;A9! C:?6BCE;C5:! B9I9BB9@! ;5!

;A9!P5@!$;<A)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%F'+%,&%-+<2$;%"+2*#0'%%

!-B9<;!P5@O!LA5!C?!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!4<B9??J!W_[#2!W[")!!*5889:;2!+9C;Z![``[O!Y2!][")!!

! %

Page 504: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V#V!

T)(()W#V! +57FB9!*!_a!

456789:;!;C;D9! +C89?;5:9!?;9D9!5I!;A9!B5J<D!6A<BC5;99BO!`&C!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!W_;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 3;9D9!LC;A!W!DC:9!5I!C:?6BCE;C5:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%O.*%'"<%*%-(94%*%"&%$-0%,&%*%?,2(#2#02(+$2>1(*%*%7*0!

!cCB?;!6A<BC5;99B!5I!XC?!1<d9?;J!C:!;A9!PB9<;!?;<>D9!5I!?,2(#2#0%=+$2>1(*%C:!;A9!7*0%!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!(((O!]]W2W`)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$C9BB9;!WV#]^#VO!((2!]W)!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!a[]O!:5)![`_`)!!

%

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

! !

Page 505: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V#_!

T)(()W#_! '7BC:![[`b"!

456789:;!;C;D9! c55;!5I!5II9BC:P!;<>D9!IB58!198EAC?!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 198EAC?)!W_;A!4J:)!=qG!

49?6BCE;C5:! -B9J!PB<:C;9!<B<!LC;A!;A9!:<89!5I!$9EC!()!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%@+%(%"+%)+"%,-%

!X5B7?!C?!C:!;A9!"+%)+"%,-%=A57?9!5I!;A9!5:9!LA5!C?!<;!;A9!A9<@H65:;B5DD9B!5I!;A9%,-G!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:!<:@!;9K;2!X<><6AC!W_##2![[`b"k!a#O*k!#`O![#)!*5889:;2!+9C;Z![``[O!Y2![b#)!!

! !

Page 506: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! VV`!

T)(()WV`! T1!W"[!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!;A9!6AC9I!5I!;A9!6<;;D9!@+$!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!W_;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! &57:@^;5EE9@! ?;9D9! C:! ?7:M! B9DC9I! LC;A! B9EB9?9:;<;C5:?!

<BB<:P9@! C:! "! B9PC?;9B?)! ! 'C;D9?! B9I9BB9@! ;5! ?589! 5I! ;A9! #!

E95ED9! C:! <@5BC:P! E5?C;C5:! B9EB9?9:;9@! C:! ;A9! >5;;58!

B9PC?;9B)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%6)!WbG"$.*0%*%"+0<2-.%*%"+2,&%%6)!W"G%-+<%$-0%*%7*0!!

!49E7;J!5I!;A9!@57>D9!;B9<?7BJ!5I!$A<B<5A!!!3;<>D9^8<?;9B!5I!;A9!7*0!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!(((2!"#a2[)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!XT1'!_2!bVO!ED)!]b2Wk!!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!W_VO!:5)!aa_)!!

! !

Page 507: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! VVW!

T)(()WVW! XCD@9?A9C8!

]`W!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!<!?MCEE9B!IB58!l<:;CB!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! l<:;CB)!W_;A!4J:)!=qG!

49?6BCE;C5:! 1<:! 6D<@! C:! <! LCP! <:@! <! 8CDC;<BJ! ?MCB;! DCI;C:P! AC?! <B8?! C:!

<@5B<;C5:!;5!<!?;<:@C:P!6B565@CD9^A9<@9@!P5@!5EE5?C;9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

"*40%*%"+2,&!!

!3MCEE9B!5I!;A9%"+2,&!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!(((2![aa2!W[)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!X<><6AC!W_b]2!b"])!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2![V#O!:5)!__a)!!

!

! !

Page 508: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! VV[!

T)(()WV[! XCD@9?A9C8!

W`##!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D9!5I!;A9!?9BF<:;!5I!;A9!$A<B<5A!=+$2>1(*!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! l<:;CB)!W_;A!4J:)!=qG!

49?6BCE;C5:! 1<:! C:!ED9<;9@!8CDC;<BJ! ?MCB;! ?A5L:!<@5BC:P!<! ?;<;79!LC;A!6A9?;!EB5ICD9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

"5.(0%D,!E%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%!

!39BF<:;?!=DC;)!o5:9!LA5!A9<B?!;A9!6<DDC:PrG!5I!;A9!"+2,&I!D)!E)!A)!!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!(((O![[_2!a)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!X<><6AC!W_b]2!b"[)!!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!b_WO!:5)!W_#a)!!

! !

Page 509: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! VV"!

T)(()WV"! g/!]Waa]!

456789:;!;C;D9! TD<6M!PB<:C;9!?;<;79!5I!;A9!6588<:@9B!5I!;A9!;B55E?!a+!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3<I;!9D^X9::<)!W_;A^[`;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 3;<;79! B9EB9?9:;C:P! <! 8<:! B9EB9?9:;9@! C:! 6B5??^D9PP9@!

E5?C;C5:O! LC;A! ;A9! A<:@?! ED<69?! E<D8! @5L:L<B@?! 5:! ;A9!

M:99?)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!?C@9!5I!;A9!D9I;^D9P)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

"-&'<2,%*%".<'%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;!

!*AC9I!5I!>5L89:!5I!;A9!"+2,&I%D)!E)!A)!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!$1!(YO!WW)!4<B9??J!W_WW2!W][^W]])!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!"W]O!:5)!W`a`)!!

! !

Page 510: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! VV]!

T)(()WV]! 5*-![b#]b!

456789:;!;C;D9! ,?;B<65:!*<CB5!*-![b#]b!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! TC><:!9D^15D57M)![`;A!4J:)!=qG!

49?6BCE;C5:! -B9<;!?<:@?;5:9!ED<\79!LC;A!<!DC?;!5I!5IIC6C<D?!C:!>D<6M!C:M)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!]G!$(<2+%!*0'<%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;!!

!,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!PB<:<BC9?!5I!;A9!$A<B<5AO!D)!E)!A)!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!N&(!Y(2!V]_O!")!$7>DC6<;C5:2!y9B:J!W_"bO!((2!#b!I)O!_`O!ED)!_[)!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!W"WO!:5)!]"`)!!

!

!

! !

Page 511: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! VVb!

T)(()WVb! *-!WW[`!

456789:;!;C;D9! U<5?!5I!%87:^&<!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 1Ö;!-A<8B!5B!3<\\<B<!=qG)![`;A!4J:)!=qG!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)!3C@9!%)!

T)!3C@9!T)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%%)%F#0'%*'+0%,&%*'+%-+<2$;%"+2*#0'%%%T)%F#0'%*'+%*;%"'%*'+%,&%(%,-%*%>1*;02-.%%

%NC:P!5I!;A9!P5@?O!;A9!PB9<;!P5@!LA5!C?!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'!%'A9!PB9<;!P5@!C:!;A9%,-%<;!198EAC?%!

U5;9?2!W!%665B@C:P!;5!X<><6ACO!C;!C?!L9DD!M:5L:!;A<;!<!"+2*#0'!9KC?;9@!<;!198EAC?!=-<7;AC9B!

W_[b^"WO!((2!_#G!<:@!;A<;!<!o$<D<69!5I!SAC;9!S<DDr!8CPA;!L9DD!B9I9B!;5!;A9!I<857?!:<89!5I!

;A9!6<EC;<D)!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;!<:@!'B<:?D<;C5:2!X<><6AC!W_bb^ba2!]a[)!!

!

! !

Page 512: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! VVa!

T)((()W! EX<BBC?!b``!

456789:;!;C;D9! 'A9!45589@!$BC:69!C:!;A9!Y9B?5!5I!EX<BBC?!b``!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!39;J!(!h!&<8)!((!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'A9!45589@!$BC:69!C?!5:!;A9!F9B?5!5I!$<EJB7?!W``a`!C:!;A9!

TBC;C?A!17?978O!85B9! 65885:DJ! M:5L:!<?! $<EJB7?!X<BBC?!

b``O! LA9B9! C;! C?! EB969@9@! >J! ;A9! ?;5BJ! 5I! ;A9! '<MC:P! 5I!

g5EE<W)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!DD)!]Ob^]OaG%%0*%$*%-(94%,*)%0.&%#*;%-+%.$%P.%'0%*94%0,%$%"+%*%$*+%-+%#('%$094%,"+%(%+'*0%(%)'%*;'%*4+%*0%"+2*#0'%,*)%0.&%#*;%%

!XC?!1<d9?;J!A<@!e<!A57?9f!5I!?;5:9!>7CD;!eI5B!AC8f!7E5:!;A9!@9?9B;O!?7EEDC9@!LC;A!E95ED9!<:@!LC;A!9F9BJ!P55@!;AC:P!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'%D)!E)!A)!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!W_"[2!Wk!]Ob^]Oa)!!T7@P9!W_["2!$D?)!]V^b[)!!'B<:?D<;C5:2!+C6A;A9C8!W_#"^W_V`O!((2![``^[`")!!W1xDD9B!W_[`2!][)!!

!

! !

Page 513: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! VV#!

T)((()[! ET1!W`WV"!

456789:;!;C;D9! $<EJB7?!4Q,B>C:9J!!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!39;J!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'A9!'<D9!5I!'L5!TB5;A9B?)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

"D)!W`O_G%+)'<0%"+2,&",*)%0.&%#*;!!

!S<?A9B8<:!5I!;A9!$A<B<5A!D)!E)!A)!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!-<B@C:9B!W_"[2![`O!WW^W[)!*5889:;2!%D^%J9@C![``a2!"`_O!:5)!W`]])!!

! !

Page 514: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! VVV!

T)((()"! E*A9?;9B!

T9<;;J! ((! ~!

ET1!W`aV[!

456789:;!;C;D9! *5D5EA5:!5I!;A9!$<EJB7?!*A9?;9B!T9<;;J!((!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!W_;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! *5D5EA5:!5I! ;A9!'<D9!5I! ;A9! ;L5!>B5;A9B?!65:;<C:9@! C:! ;A9!

$<EJB7?!*A9?;9B!T9<;;J!(()!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%#!%>1(*%*'%"+2*#0'%%

!36BC>9!5I!%87:!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!W_VW2!"`^"a)!!-<B@C:9B!W_"bO!(2!ak!((2!ED)!W])!!'B<:?D<;C5:2!+C6A;A9C8!W_#"^W_V`O!((2![WW^[W])!!

! !

Page 515: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! VV_!

T)((()]! ET1!W`]#]!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?;B76;C5:!5I!>1(*2(2$"'!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!W_^[`;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'A9!(:?;B76;C5:!5I!>1(*2(2$"'!C?!658ED9;9DJ!EB9?9BF9@!C:!;A9!

TBC;C?A! 17?978! $<EJB7?! W`]#])! 38<DD9B! E5B;C5:! 5I! C;! <B9!

I57:@! 5:! <! E<EJB7?! C:! 3;56MA5D8O! ;AB99! LBC;C:P! ;<>D9;?! C:!

'7BC:O! $<BC?! <:@! 15?65L! <:@! <:! 5?;B<65:! C:! ;A9! *<CB5!

17?978)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!0((O!W`^W[O!?L!!(%$$%(%''''%)+%0*(94%)+%#0+94%(%7*0%!0(0O!a^#I%(%$+$%+%(,%"&%)&$%(%'09C%-;,%&;'%7*0%%%00O!WaO!$+%($%.0&%#"+9C%(2;&-94%!00O!W#O!7*94%*%(.0'9C%*;%00O!WVO!..94%+9C%+%7*0%(2;&-%'&%(,;&<'%%!

!X9!P59?!<:@!6589?!LC;A!\7<BB9D?!LA9:!A9!9<;?!<:@!@BC:M?!C:!;A9!7*0%=C:;9BC5B!qG!%45!:5;!65:?ECB9!LC;A!;A9!89<?7B9BO!?5!<?!;5!@9IB<7@!;A9!?A<B9!5I!;A9!7*0%=B9?C@9:69!qG!%SA9:!C:!;A9!85B:C:P!J57!<BBCF9!C:!IB5:;!5I!AC8O!X9!LCDD!>5L!;5!<DD!J57B!L5B@?!X9!LCDD!B9D<;9!J57B!?E996A!;5!;A9!*57:6CD!5I!'ACB;J!5I!;A9!7*0%

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ)!+<:P9!W_[b2!0(O!W`^W[k!0(0O!a^#k!00O!WV)!!+<C?:9J![``#2!WW_^W[`O!W#[O!WV])!!'B<:?D<;C5:2!+C6A;A9C8!W_#"^W_V`O!((2![``^[`")!!

!

!

!

! !

Page 516: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V_`!

*)()W! !-9>9D9C:!

456789:;!;C;D9! &56M!?;9D9!5I!389:@9?!:9<B!-9>9D9C:!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! -9>9D9C:)!389:@9?!=W`a_^W`]"!T)*)G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!D)! "G! $#'% -(94% *% .($%@0'2C&2M'-% 7*094% !"#% *%P*'%*)'%($%?,%%

!XC?!1<d9?;J!L<?!C:!;A9!;5L:!5I!198EAC?O!AC?%7*0O!:5>D9!5I!I5B69!<:@!FC6;5BC57?!<?!&<!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!4<B9??J!WVVV2!W""!II)!!

! !

Page 517: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V_W!

*)()[! -9>9D!9D^

3CD?CD<A!:5)!

W``!

456789:;!;C;D9! -9>9D!9D^3CD?CD<A!?;9D9!:5)!W``!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! -9>9D!9D^3CD?CD<AO!<;!<!@C?;<:69!5I!<>57;!W``8!;5!;A9!?57;A!5I!

;A9!?E95?!5I!X5B98A9>)!3A9?A5:\!(!=_]b^_[]!T)*)G!

49?6BCE;C5:! 3;9D9!?9;!7E!C:!;A9!:<89!5I!3A9?A5:\!(!>J!AC?!?5:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!DD)!"_^]`G!a+%"*%$0%-(94%(%7*0%M+2&#'%"&%C&%,&%?,2@+02&)2'<%

!,:!;AC?!@<J!XC?!1<d9?;J!L<?!C:!;A9!7*0%5I!M+2&#'O!o'A9!-B9<;!357D!5I!&<^X<B<MA;9Ü!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!*<8C:5?!W_b[2!b`^bW)!!

! !

Page 518: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V_[!

*)()"! T7><?;C?!

456789:;!;C;D9! 'A9!*AB5:C6D9!5I!$BC:69!,?5BM5:!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! (:;9BC5B!L<DD?!5I! ;A9!T7><?;C;9!-<;9! C:! ;A9! I5B9657B;!5I! ;A9!

PB9<;! ;98ED9!5I!%87:!<;! N<B:<M)!,?5BM5:O! R)! WW^W[! =_"b^a!

T)*)G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'A9!AC9B5PDJEAC6!;9K;!B965B@!;A9!@99@?!5I!;A9!9D@9?;!?5:!5I!

NC:P!'<M9D5;A! ((!5I! ;A9![[;A!4J:<?;JO!,?5BM5:O!LA5!L<?! ;A9!

A5D@9B! 5I! B9DCPC57?O! E5DC;C6<D! <:@! 8CDC;<BJ! E5?;?! @7BC:P! ;A9!

;B57>D9@!B9CP:?!5I!AC?!I<;A9B!<:@!5I!NC:P!39?A5:\!((()!

T)!$B<C?9!5I!,?5BM5:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!t! [VG! $(<2+% G(,0% D99E% (% 7*094% H&2.7*'2*'2>1(*2,&27(7('%C&9'0%+9#%%

!'A9!P5F9B:5B!5I!.EE9B!/PJE;!=))G!L<?!C:!AC?!7*0O!;A9!D<:@!5I!%87:!-B9<;!5I!&5<BC:PO!;A7?!?A<DD!C;!>9!6<DD9@!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!*<8C:5?!W_bV2!W#O!t[V)! !!

! !

Page 519: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V_"!

*)()]! -9>9D!T<BM<D!

456789:;!;C;D9! $C<:MAJ!=qG!3;9D9!:5)![a!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! -9>9D!T<BM<D)!$C<:MAJ!=#]#^#Wa!T)*)G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 3<:@?;5:9! ?;9D9! LAC6A! A<?! ;A9! :<89! 5I! ;A9! MC:P! 9B<?9@O!

I57:@!C:!T!b`WO!;A9!65D5::<@9@!657B;!>9;L99:!$JD5:?!(!<:@!

((!>7CD;!>J!$C<:MAJ!<I;9B!AC?!/PJE;C<:!6<8E<CP:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!D)![aG!#&%?,%*;%,-%%

!35:!5I!&<O!+5B@!5I!;A9!,-%

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!&9C?:9B!W_a#2!_")!!

! !

Page 520: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V_]!

*)()b! g/!]#`Vb^

]#`Va^

]#`V#^

]#`VV^]#`V_!

T9BDC:!W`aV!

456789:;!;C;D9! $C<:MAJ!3;9D9!00Y!["!W`b!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! -9>9D!T<BM<D)!$C<:MAJ!=#]#^#Wa!T)*)G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! -B<:C;9! ?;9D9! C:! IB<P89:;?! B9E5B;C:P! ;A9!LC::9B! 9KE9@C;C5:!

5I!$C<:MAJ!C:!/PJE;)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

t!]O!aG%$*%$0%S+%*9C%+%#()%+#0'%G(,0%*0%7*0%%%t!W[ObaG!8-'"%+9C:@+%*;%,-!!

t!W"O!b_G!8-(94:%,-,%*%#),$94%%(%,-94%%tW"O!a[G!0.&%"0%$+$9*%-(94%+%"+2*#0'%DF(J'E!!(9*94%,'%*;'%*'%"+2*#0'%"+2-.94%0.&094%%!

t!W]O!#`^#WG!$$%"0%$+$9*%-P&%*%F*$2*#0'%DM42'&02,90$2`&#'E%7+$%$*0%+%"+2,&%*;0%-.%,&%*;9D'E%D99E%!

t!WVO!b^aG!$($%**%)'(%$($%**%,-&%7*0%G0%(%#"%'"$%%t![bO!W]a^W]#G%$(*'%$&;'%'&0%-'"0%-+<2$;%-+%7'9#*%*%#*.94%-+%+.$'%P(&%)'9#*%+%;0%-(94%($%*.#0%*'%,-'%%!

t![aOWbW^Wb[G%**%,P9*9#*%+%"+2*#0'%.+%*''%0**9#*%,(,0%-*,%PP%+(0%;0'%"0%*'%"+2*#0'%>1#%*#0'%F(+'%,P94%+%"+2*#0'%.+%*''%0*9*94%(%0,;%**%%PP94%+(0,-,9*%)('%Y+.09#*%0,%(%,P%"+2*#0'!%%%

!

R57!LCDD!>9!C:!?CD9:69!C:!5B@9B!;5!I5BP9;!;A9!

.EE9B!/PJE;!<:@!LA<;!>9D5:P?!;5!;A9!7*0%%eT9!\7C9;f!X5B7?O!+5B@!5I!;A9!,-!!

XC?!1<d9?;J!<BC?9!C:!PD5BJ!C:!AC?!,-%%XC?!1<d9?;J!EB5699@9@!;5!;A9!"+2*#0'%5I!UC8D5;)!X9!?;B5@9!;AB57PA!9F9BJ!6A<8>9B!5I!

;A9!"+2*#0'O!C;?!;B9<?7BJ!<:@!C;?!?;5B9B558!

!

'A9!&5J<D!$BC:69!(:I<:;!M42'&02,90$2`&#'!6<89O!6A<BP9@!5I!;BC>7;9?O!;5!;A9!"+2,&O[!5I!P5D@O!?CDF9B!<:@!<DD!;A9!?;5:9?!=))G!

!

@5!:5;!6D5?9O!@5!:5;!ICPA;!;A9%7*0%G0%C:!;A9!7E5:!;C89W!

!

'A9!S9?;!<:@!;A9!/<?;!<:@!;A9!D<:@?!5I!;A9!

69:;B9!<B9!ID<;^>9DDJ!I5B!I9<B!5I!C;O!8<MC:P!

5II9BC:P?!5I!;A9CB!P55@?!C:!;A9!ED<69!5I!XC?!

1<d9?;J!<?!;A9!E55B!89:!5I!;A9!,-D'E!!

'A9J!@5!:5;!9:;9B!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'!?C:69!;A9J!A<F9!>99:!6CB6786C?9@!<:@!9<;!IC?AO!;AC?!C?!<:!

<>58C:<;C5:!I5B!;A9!"+2*#0'9%'A9!MC:P!F(+'!9:;9B?!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'%?C:69!A9!A<?!>99:!E7B9!<:@!A9!@C@:Q;!9<;!IC?AO!;AB99!L9B9!57;!<:@!

5:9!L9:;!C:;5!;A9!"+2*#0'%

Page 521: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V_b!

U5;9?2! W$C<:MAJ! B9I9B?! ;5! ;A9! B9DCPC57?! 6C;J! 5I!198EAC?)! -BC8<D! W_VW2! W`VO! :5;9! :5)! [_[)![-BC8<D!;B<:?D<;9?!o<7EBi?!@9!$A<B<5Ar)!-BC8<D!W_VW2!#aO!:5;9!:5)![W")!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!-BC8<D!W_VW)!!

! !

Page 522: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V_a!

*)()a! g/!"VVaW!

456789:;!;C;D9! 198EAC;9!@5:<;C5:!?;9D9!5I!'<A<B\<!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:!=EB5><>DJ!198EAC?G)!'<A<B\<!=a_`^aa]!T)*)G)!!

49?6BCE;C5:! 3<:@?;5:9! ?;9D9! B9657:;C:P! ;A9! B9?;5B<;C5:! 5I! ;A9! DC;;D9!

;98ED9!5I!%87:!C:!198EAC?!5B@9B9@!>J!'<A<B\<)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!((G%-(94%(%-+%$(<2+&%C&'%*;'%*D'E%7*094%%%

!XC?!1<d9?;J!5B@9B9@!;5!9F9BJ!?7E9BC:;9:@9:;!5I!L5BM?!5I!AC?%7*0%%

U5;9?2! %665B@C:P! ;5! 199M?O! ;A9! ;9B8! 7*0! ?A57D@! >9! C:;9:@9@! <?! ;A9! LA5D9! 198EAC?O!

LA9B9! ;A9! B9?C@9:69!5I!'<A<B\<!L<?! D56<;9@)! =199M?!W_V#2!"[]O!:5)!Vk!R5J5;;9!W_b[2![VO!

<:@!:5)!"!h!B9I9BBC:P2!%!B97?9@!>D56M!IB58!;A9!DC;;D9!6A<E9D!5I!39;J!(!<;!1C;!&<AC:<!>BC:P?!;A9!

:<89! o'<A<B\<! D5F9! >J! $;<ArO! 7:@9BDJC:P! ;A9! 65::96;C5:! 5I! ;A9! MC:P! LC;A! 198EAC?!

=,BC9:;<DC<O![`O!W_bWO!E)!"]aG!<:@!;A9!E5:@!5I!'<A<B\<!@C?65F9B9@!C:!1C;B<AC:9A!=-)O!+)!&)O!]O!

"#O!00Y((G!<:@!;A9!?;9D<9!IB58!;A9!39B<E978!>9D5:P9@!;5!'<A<B\<!EB5F9!;A9!65::96;C5:!5I!

;A9!MC:P!LC;A!;A9!6<EC;<D!=C>C@)!""O!:5)![O!"]O!0(Y^0YO!9;!:)!W)G!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!199M?!W_#_2![[W^[b_)!!

! !

Page 523: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V_#!

*)()#! 19B5L9!

17?978!:5)!

b[!

456789:;!;C;D9! N<L<!3;9D9!(Y!5I!'<A<B\<!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! '98ED9!'!5I!N<L<O!W?;!657B;O!'<A<B\<O!R)!a!=a_a!T)*)G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! -B9J!-B<:C;9!?;9D9!LC;A!B57:@9@!;5E)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

(YO![`^[WG!+.$9*%-(94%!(D0E%(!,94%+%f(2D"&E2$'*%-*,%$#0'%,!&0'%-(0'$0%*4+0%*%+)%'*09#*%$(<2+%C&'%$(%-%*,9#*%+%)+"%C&'%(%+&2"+%"*%$#%-(94%(%7*0%>1;*2-.%,-,9*%P.0%-0'2%*'+%'*%%%

!

XC?!1<d9?;J!8<@9!AC?!;B55E?!P5!;5!f(2D"&E2$'*O!<6658E<:C9@!>J!:789B57?!P<:P?!5I!

L5BM89:!<:@!P55@!<B;C?<:?!LC;A57;!:78>9B)!

%!?7E9BC:;9:@9:;!5I!L5BM?!L<?!;A9B9!LC;A!

;A98O!C:!5B@9B!;5!5F9B?99!;A9!>7CD@C:P!9II5B;?!

<;!;AC?!;98ED9!?C;9!=LACD9G!XC?!1<d9?;J!L<?!C:!

;A9!7*0%5I!198EAC?)!'A9:!AC?!;98ED9!L<?!

>7CD;!5I!P55@!LAC;9!?<:@?;5:9!

!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

'9K;!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!1<6<@<8!W_]_2!Wb!I)k![WO!:)!bWk!F5D)!((O!ED)!V)!

!

! !

Page 524: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V_V!

*)()V! 4<A?A7B!

456789:;!;C;D9! '<A<B\<Q?!?;9D9!IB58!;A9!4<A?A7B!49?9B;!&5<@!!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 4<A?A7B! 49?9B;! &5<@O! b! M8! ;5! ;A9!L9?;! 5I! ;A9! EJB<8C@! 5I!

$9EC!(()!'<A<B\<!=a_`^aa]!T)*)G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

![O![^"G!0.%-(94%#(*'%80.:%8-+:%#&%)&#'%$(*''%-+%$(<20+'%*'%7*0%%%[O!W"G%"-+9*94%-*,9#*%-+%#&%)&#'%x*;2-.%(%0*0'%5-'"*#%"-9#*%8W&.:0+%(%0*0'%0;*%,**9#*%+%7*0%(%0*0'%(C'28*;:%#%!%%

!XC?!1<d9?;J!6588C??C5:9@!;5!?9;!7E!e<!?;9D9f!>9AC:@!;A9!=9@P9!5I!;A9G!L9?;9B:!@9?9B;!5:!;A9!L9?;9B:!?C@9!5I!;A9!7*0!%X9!L9:;!LC;A!;A98!IB58!;A9!@9?9B;!5I!198EAC?!C:!;A9!_;A!A57B!5I!;A9!:CPA;)!'A9J!B9<6A9@!;A9!-B9<;!-B99:!=;A9!c<CJ78G!C:!;A9!W?;!A57B!5I!;A9!@<J!<:@!B9;7B:9@!;5!;A9!7*0!C:!;A9!"B@!A57B!5I!;A9!@<J!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!%D;9:8jDD9B!^!157??<!W_VW)!!

! !

Page 525: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! V__!

*)()_! g/!a#`_b!

456789:;!;C;D9! '<:C?!?;9D9!5I!$?<8;9M!((!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! '<:C?O!'98ED9!5I!%87:)!R9<B!"!5I!$?<8;9M!((!=b_"!T)*)G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 3<:@?;5:9! IB<P89:;9@! ?;9D9! I9<;7BC:P! <:! <6657:;! 5I! ;A9!

MC:PQ?!U7>C<:!6<8E<CP:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!D)! aG! 8-:(94% !(% (!,% +% '&% G&#% #+<0% -*,94% *'%,-*0'<%#"+%"0%$+9*9#*%899:+28SN:2;&%7*0%"0%*%C0&+%*'<%$(%-*,%.($%H&2.7*%+*9#*!%%%D)!VG!,-,9*%&!+9#*N%"D&E%C0&+%*'<%(%899:%$;9#'%(28,N:94%7*094%$+0&DNE%!

!XC?!e1f<d9?;J!?9:;!;A9!<B8J!;5!;A9!D<:@!5I!G&#O!;A9!ACPA!5IIC6C<D?!>9C:P!LC;A!AC8!IB58!;A9!,7*0D'<E9%'A9J!B9<6A9@!899:+28SN:2;&%;A9!7*0%5I!;A9!MC:P!>9C:P!D56<;9@!;A9B9O!<D5:P!LC;A!;A9!;5L:!>J!;A9!:<89!5I!H&2.7*!!'A9:!;A9J!>7B:9@!;A9!MC:P!LA5!L<?!C:!e))f!;A9CB!8C@?;=qG!LC;A!AC8!=;A9!MC:PqG!5I!AC?!7*0%5I!$+0&DNE%!

U5;9?2! %I;9B! C:;B5@76;5BJ! B5J<D! 9EC;A9;?O! ;A9! MC:P! C?! ?;<;9@! ;5! >9! C:! ;A9! EB569??! 5I!

B9I7B>C?AC:P!F<BC57?!;98ED9?!<:@!5II9BC:P!EB5FC?C5:?O!LA9:!B9E5B;!6589?!C:!J9<B!"!;A<;!;A9!

U7>C<:?!A<F9!65:?ECB9@!<P<C:?;!AC8)!X9!?9:@?!AC?!<B8J!LC;A!?9:C5B!5IIC6C<D?!I5B;A!;5!?7>@79!

;A9! B9>9D! I5B69?O! <:@!85?;! 5I! ;A9! <6;C5:! ;<M9?! ED<69! C:! ;A9! A9<B;A! 5I! ;A9! N7?AC;9! B9<D8!

>9;L99:!;A9!'ACB@!<:@!c5B;A!*<;<B<6;?)!'A9!U7>C<:?!<B9!B57;9@O!E9BA<E?!;A9!N7?AC;9!MC:P!

AC8?9DI! C?!MCDD9@O!<:@!?589!?5B;!5I!A5?;<P9!C?!;<M9:O!>7;!;A9!?;9D9! C?!;55!><@DJ!@<8<P9@!;5!

L<BB<:;!;55!876A!?E967D<;C5:!5:!;A9!9F9:;?!B9D<;9@!C:!;A9!D5L9B!A<DI!;9K;!=49B!1<:79DC<:!

W__]2!"aaG)!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!*A<??C:<;!W_``2!WaaO!:5)!+000(0)!!'B<:?D<;C5:2!3<7:9B5:!^!R5J5;;9!W_b[2!W#])!!15:;9;!W_]_2!"_!I)2!#a^V[)!!49B!1<:79DC<:!W__]2!"ab^"#W)!!

! !

Page 526: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _``!

*)()W`! 3A9DD<D!3;9D9!!

! 3A9DD<D!?;9D9!5I!$?<8;9M!((!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3A9DD<D)!R9<B!"!5I!$?<8;9M!((!=b_"!T)*)G!

49?6BCE;C5:! &9@! PB<:C;9! ?;9D9! @C?65F9B9@! (! W_a]! >! %?L<:! XCPA! 4<8!

65:?;B76;C5:!L5BM9B?!L9?;!5I!;A9!B<CDL<J!65::96;C:P!3A9DD<D!

;5!%?L<:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!DD)! W`^W[G! +.$'%*%-(94%(&,% ,&;0'% ,&'%(% $0&0%0*.0% *% *'+0% *;0% G(,0% H&2(-0% 0.*0% *%*'+0%#'"2#&%(%,-'!

!XC?!1<d9?;J!A<?!PCF9:!PB9<;!5II9BC:P?!65:?C?;C:P!5I!D5:P^!<:@!?A5B;^A5B:9@!6<;;D9!I5B!<DD!;A9!P5@?!5I!.EE9B!<:@!+5L9B!/PJE;O!=<:@G!B9F9B?C5:!5II9BC:P?!I5B!;A9!P5@?!5I!;A9!B5J<D!EB9?9:69!C:!;A9!,-'%!

U5;9?2!(:!J9<B!"!5I!AC?!B9CP:O!$?<8;9M!((!C?!C:;9BB7E;9@!C:!AC?!C:?E96;C5:!5I!;A9!o+<M9!5I!F4+2$;2?,nr!>J!<!B9E5B;!;A<;!;A9!;B55E?!A9!@C?E<;6A9@!;5!N7?A!A<F9!B9<6A9@!;A9!D<:@!5I!$:7>?)!c7B;A9B85B9O!7EBC?C:P?!<B9!B9E5B;9@!C:!;A9!?57;A)!'A9!MC:P!<;;<6M?!;A9!B9>9D!U7>C<:?O!LA5!

ID99!C:!;9BB5B)!U789B57?!6<E;CF9?!<B9!;<M9:O!<:@!$?<8;9M!EB5FC@9?!5II9BC:P?!;5!;A9!P5@?!C:!

;A<:M?!I5B!AC?!FC6;5BJ)!=@9B!1<7:9DC<:!W__]2!""VG)!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!49B!1<:79DC<:!W__]2!"]`)!!

!

!

! !

Page 527: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _`W!

*)()WW! g/!"a"[#!

456789:;!;C;D9! %@5E;C5:!?;9D9!5I!UC;56BC?!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<MO! C:! ;A9! I5B9657B;! 5I! ;A9! ;98ED9! 5I! %87:! :9<B! ;A9!

;BCED9!?ABC:9!5I!39;J!(()!$?<8;9M!(O!R)!_!=aba!T)*)G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! *5<B?9^PB<C:9@! B9@! PB<:C;9! ?;9D9! LAC6A! @56789:;?! ;A9!

I5B8<D! 9:;B<:69! 5I! $BC:69??! UC;56BC?! C:;5! ;A9! 65DD9P9! 5I!

EBC9?;9??9?!<;!N<B:<M)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!DD)!#^VG!"+%(%$"'%*#0'%$*%#&'94%0+'%DrE%!(#09#%-+9#%,!&'%(%'*0%!*,0%-+%#.#+%0&0'9#%%%%%D)!VG!#!"%0&'%*4+'%+%'"2!%+%+.$'%-+%(%)*'%+%W&#'%,->0%-+9#%(%'*0%,&'%$#0'%(%*)'2,0%&'"%+%&0%+%)&0%$+0%(%)'%*;%*4+'%*'%"+2*#0'!

!49E<B;7B9!IB58!;A9!B5J<D!<E<B;89:;?!>J!AC?!9D@9?;!@<7PA;9B!A9B!B9;<C:9B?!<B57:@!A9B!>9C:P!C:!PB9<;!:78>9BO!<;;9:@<:;?!6D9<BC:P!A9B!L<J?)!!'A9J!;55M!;A9!B5<@!A<EECDJ!;5!;A9!\7<JHD<M9O!C:!5B@9B!;5!A9<@!?57;A!5I!;A9!'A9><:!:589O!?ACE?!<>57;!A9B!C:!PB9<;!:78>9B?O!6B9L?!65:?C?;C:P!5I!?;B5:P^<B89@!89:O!D<@9:!7E!;5!;A9!P7:L<D9?!;A9B95I!LC;A!9F9BJ!P55@!;AC:P!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'!!

U5;9?2! $?<8;9M! (! <::57:69?! AC?! 'A9><:! <@5E;C5:! ED<:?! I5B! AC?! @<7PA;9B! UC;56BC?O! ;5! AC?!

657B;C9B?! =<;! 3<C?qGO! LA5! 7:CF9B?<DDJ! EB<C?9! AC?! C:;9:;C5:?)! (:! J9<B! _O! UC;56BC?! @9E<B;?! I5B!

'A9>9?! <:@! C?!L9D6589@! ;A9B9! >J! >5;A! 3A9E9:L9E9;! (C! <:@! ;A9! 67BB9:;!4CFC:9! Y5;<B9??O!

%89:CB@C?! ((O! LA5! @96B99! <:! $(<'2"+O! 69@C:P! <DD! ;A9CB! EB5E9B;J! 5F9B! ;5! A9B)! %! DC?;! 5I! ;A9!EB5FC?C5:?! C:6D7@9@! I5DD5L?O! :<8C:P! 5I! ;A9! 5IIC6C<D?! <:@! D56<DC;C9?! C:F5DF9@)! (:;9B?E9B?9@!

LC;AC:! ;A9! :<BB<;CF9! <B9! AJ8:?! 5I! EB<C?9! ;5! >5;A! %89:! <:@! $?<8;9M! ()! =49B! 1<:79DC<:!

W__]2![_VG)!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!*<8C:5?!W_a])!!-59@C6M9!W_a_^#`)!'9K;!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!49B!1<:79DC<:!W__]2![_#^"[W)!!!

! !

Page 528: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _`[!

*)()W[! *<CB5!3&![]W!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3<\\<B<!?;9D9!5I!$?<8;9M!(!89:;C5:C:P!<!+C>J<:!6<8E<CP:!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 4<A?A7B! 49?9B;! &5<@O! L9?;! 5I! ;A9! EJB<8C@! 5I! $9EC! (()!

$?<8;9M!(O!R)!WW!=ab]!T)*)G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! X<B@! PB<JC?A! DC89?;5:9! ?;9D9! @9?6BC>C:P! ;A9! B9;7B:! 5I!

$?<8;9M! (O! EB9?78<>DJ! IB58! FC?C;C:P! <! ?;B76;7B9! 5I!

%89:98A<;! (! ;5! D9<B:!5I!7EBC?C:P?!<85:P! ;A9!+C>J<:! ;BC>9?!

;5!;A9!L9?;)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!DD)! #^VG! -&C02$;% "0% *0% "+2*#0'% 0*9#*% -+%"!*'%+%'+899:0%899:%8(*:24&0'%$(<2+%*0%'#0%*;%*%(!,%*;%*%7*0%!

!'A9J!<B9!B9>9D?!<P<C:?;!;A9!"+2*#0'9%'A9J!=;A9!+C>J<:?G!L9B9!C:!B9?C?;<:69!<P<C:?;!e))f!5I!;B55E?O!5F9B?99B!5I!A7:;9B?O!9F9BJ!6588<:@9B!5I!9F9BJ!<B8!5I!;A9!7*0%!

U5;9?2!(:!J9<B!WW!$?<8;9M!(!B9;7B:9@O!EB9?78<>DJ!IB58!FC?C;C:P!<!?;B76;7B9!5I!%89:98A<;!

,O!;5! D9<B:!7EBC?C:P?!<85:P!;A9!+C>J<:!;BC>9?!;5!;A9!L9?;)!3589!?5B;!5I!69:?7?!=<!8CDC;<BJ!

9:DC?;89:;qG! 5I! <DD! B9PC5:<D! <@8C:C?;B<;5B?! 5I! ;A9! 657:;BJ! L<?! ;<M9:O! C:! EB9E<B<;C5:! I5B!

B9;<DC<;C5:!<P<C:?;!+C>J<:?)!'A9!?965:@!A<DI!5I!;A9!;9K;!C?!C:!9F9:!L5B?9!65:@C;C5:!;A<:!;A9!

ICB?;O!>7;!C;!?998?!;A<;!;A9!MC:P!?76699@9@!C:!?7BB57:@C:P!<:@!@9I9<;C:P!9:98C9?O!<:@!9C;A9B!

>7CD@C:P! ?589! ?5B;! 5I! 65:;<C:89:;! ?;B76;7B9O! 5B! <;;<6MC:P! ;A<;! 5I! ;A9! +C>J<:?)! =49B!

1<:79DC<:!W__]2!"[]G)!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!-59@C6M9!W_a[>)!!'9K;!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!49B!1<:79DC<:!W__]2!"["^""W)!!!

! !

Page 529: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _`"!

*)()W"! +57FB9!/!

"""b!

456789:;!;C;D9! 39B<E978!?;9D9!5I!$?<8;9M!(!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 198EAC?O!39B<E978)!$?<8;9M!(O!J9<B!b[!=aW"!T)*)G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 3<:@?;5:9! ?;9D9! 65:;<C:C:P! ;A9! 5IIC6C<D! 9EC;<EA! 5I! %EC?!

000Y(((!<:@!L<?!5BCPC:<DDJ!?9;!7E!C:!;A9!-B9<;9B!Y<7D;?!5I!;A9!

39B<E978)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%-'+D0E%;&C09#*%+%7*0%($%H&2(+$%

!'A9CB!;BC>7;9?!L9B9!@CB96;9@!;5!;A9!7*0%<?!=CI!;A9J!A<@!6589!IB58G!/PJE;!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!*A<??C:<;!W_``2!WaaO!:5)!+000(0)!!

! !

Page 530: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _`]!

*)()W]! *<CB5!

W")a)[])W!

456789:;!;C;D9! /D9EA<:;C:9!?;9D9!5I!%8<?C?!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! *<CB5)!%8<?C?O!R)!"!=ba#!T)*)G!

49?6BCE;C5:! &9@!PB<:C;9!?;9D9!B965F9B9@!C:!*<CB5!C:!?965:@<BJ!7?<P9O!>7;!

5BCPC:<DDJ!?9;!7E!C:!<!?C;9!C:!;A9!B9PC5:!5I!;A9!cCB?;!*<;<B<6;)!

(;!:<BB<;9?!9F9:;?!5I!;A9!6CFCD!L<B!>9;L99:!%EBC9?!<:@!

%8<?C?!C:!B9;B5?E96;O!IB58!;A9!FC6;5BQ?!E5C:;!5I!FC9L)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

DD)![^"G!0**%-(94%(%,-94%F$'D<E%-+%*.%#)+%*%'&%+%.+94%%

!

XC?!1<d9?;J!L<?!C:!AC?!n-W%5I!F$'D<E%;5!EB5;96;!;A9!I5B;7:9!5I!;A9!LA5D9!+<:@!!

U5;9?2!W!,LC:P!;5!;A9!?;9D9!Q?!><@!EB9?9BF<;C5:O!;A9!B9<@C:P!C?!7:69B;<C:)!4<B9??J!;B<:?D<;9?!

o3<!1<d9?;{!{;<C;!<7!*5:?9CDO!á!?Q5667E9B!@9?!@9?;C:{9?!@9!D<!;9BB9!9:;CB9r!;55MC:P!;A9!?CP:!

I5DD5LC:P!;A9!EB9E5?C;C5:%(!<?!<:!<EEB5KC8<;C5:!5I!;A9!;9B8!$4.O!o@CL<:r!!=4<B9??J!W_``>2!"!I)G)!/@9DO!<7;A5B!5I!<!:9L!65DD96;C5:!5I!;A9!;9K;!B9:@9B9@!C;!<?!o%D?!?C6A!39C:9!1<d9?;w;!C:!

?9C:98!$<D<?;!C8!?<C;C?6A9:!-<7!>9I<:@O!C:@98!9B!@<?!-9?6AC6M!@9?!P<:Z9:!+<:@9?!

>9?EB<6Ar!=/@9D!W_#V2!W_G)!$5?9:9B!65:ICB8?!/@9DQ?!B9:@9BC:P!5I!;A9!E<??<P9!=$5?9:9B!W_"]2!

W]VG)!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!4<B9??J!W_``>)!!

'9K;!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!/@9D!W_#V2!W"!II)!

+9<AJ!W_VV2!WV_!II)!

49B!1<:79DC<:!W__]2!ED)!WW!I)!

!

! !

Page 531: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _`b!

*)()Wb! +57FB9!4![_!

456789:;!;C;D9! U<5?!5I!%8<?C?!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 39<!5I!%D9K<:@BC<)!%8<?C?!=b#`^b[a!T)*)G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!7EE9B!E<B;!5I!;A9!IB5:;<D!@55B!LC;A!;A9!

9EC;A9;?!5I!;A9!MC:P)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%F'+%*4+%*;%'&0<%@+0%)*'<%"+2,&%

!

-55@!P5@O!+5B@!5I!;A9!;L5!+<:@?O!X5B7?!5I!

;A5?9!LA5!<B9!C:!;A9!"+2,&%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

'9K;!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!$C<:M5II!W_""2!Wa[O!ICP)!W)!

!

! !

Page 532: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _`a!

*)()Wa! +9C@9:!

%1)W`#!

456789:;!;C;D9! U<5?!5I!%8<?C?!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!%8<?C?!=b#`^b[a!T)*)G!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:! 5:! ;A9! 7EE9B! E<B;! 5I! ;A9! IB5:;<D! @55B!LC;A! ;A9!

9EC;A9;?!5I!;A9!MC:P)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%@+0%*4+%)*'<%"+2,&%

!-55@!X5B7?!LA5!>9D5:P?!;5!;A9!"+2,&%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!T59?9B!W_`b^W_"[O!#2!ED)![O!ICP)!W>)!!

! !

Page 533: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _`#!

*)()W#! E&JD<:@?!(0!

456789:;!;C;D9! 'A9!$9;C;C5:!5I!M&2.$2&#'!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! /D9EA<:;C:9)!%8<?C?O!R9<B!]W!=b[_!T)*)G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 4985;C6! @56789:;! DC?;C:P!8CDC;<BJ! E9B?5::9DO! 6CFCD! ?9BF<:;?!

<:@!?ACE!6B9L?!;A<;!L9B9!;5!<6658E<:J!;A9!MC:P)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!YOW]OW_^Y(((OW]^0OWW^0Y(OWG! )"+% -&'2#"% Uu% *%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%M#('C%%YOWaG% DM&2.$2&#'E% $*'94% +% "&% "+% "+2,&% ,*)%0.&%#*;%%YOW_O[`^Y(O[^Y(((OWbOWaOW_^0O[O#OW"OW_O[WG%(2;&-%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%Y(O"G% $*0%M&2.$2&#'%#&% >1+'02+D0E%(2;&-%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%..9*94%"+2,&%%%Y(O]Ob^Y(((OWb^0OW[OW]OWbOWa^0YOW]G% ..% "+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%5B!..9*949%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%Y(Oa^#G%#!%*#0'%(%;&-%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%0O]G% DM&2.$2&#'E% +('% $#%"&%"+%*%"+2,&% ,*)%0.&%#*;%%0YOVG!M&2.$2&#'%+%(7.%+2+&%*%"&%"+%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%0YO_G%;0%$+%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%$$%+%;*+%%%0Y(OV^_G%'0'0%*%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%%0Y(OW]G%".%*&%0,;0%+%(7.%+%+&%*%"&%"+%"+2,&%%%0Y(OWbG%+('%$#%"+2,&%%0Y(OWaG%+('%"&%)*%*%"&%"+%"+2,&%%0Y(OWbG!+('%$094%'0'%+%"+2,&%*%'&%P*-%"&$!

!(:!;A9!;5;)!J9<B!5I!;A9!$A<B<5AO!D)!E)!A)!$?<8;9M!(!!X9!=M&2.$2&#'G!A<F9!>99:!>B57PA;!;5!;A9!"+%"+2,&%!(:!;A9!EB9?9:69!5I!;A9!$A<B<5AO!D)!E)!A)!!!M&2.$2&#'O!?5:!5I!>1+'02+D0EI%!L<?!>B57PA;!;5!;A9!EB9?9:69!5I!;A9!$A<B<5AO!D)!E)!A)O!<:@!A9!?<C@!;5!;A9!$A<B<5AO!D)!E)!A)!=))G!!3E996A!5I!;A9!$A<B<5AO!D)!E)!A)!5B!;A9!$A<B<5A)!D)!E)!A)!?<C@!!&5J<D!?6BC>9!5I!;A9!$A<B<5AO!D)!E)!A)!!=M&2.$2&#'G!8<:!>9D5:PC:P!;5!;A9!"+%*%"+2,&%%%M&2.$2&#'!;B<F9DD9@!:5B;AL<B@?!;5!;A9!"+%*%"+2,&O!D)!E)!A)%%'A9! $A<B<5AO! D)! E)! A)O! C?! 7:<>D9! ;5! 6589!57;?C@9!!3;<;79!5I!;A9!$A<B<5AO!D)!E)!A)!!'A9:!;A9!EBC9?;!A7BBC9@!;5!;A9!:5B;A!;5!;A9!"+%"+2,&%%1<:!>9D5:PC:P!;5!;A9!$A<B<5A!!1<:!5I!;A9!"+%"+2,&%%%!8<:!LA5!ED9<?9?!;A9!$A<B<5A!9F9:!C:!;A9!>9@6A<8>9B!!

Page 534: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _`V!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!YC;;8<::!W__V)!!

! !

Page 535: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _`_!

*)()WV! ET9BDC:!

W"aWb!

456789:;!;C;D9! 4985;C6!E<EJB7?!T9BDC:!W"aWb!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! /D9EA<:;C:9)!%8<?C?O!R)!]W!=b[_!T)*)G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 4985;C6! @56789:;! DC?;C:P!8CDC;<BJ! E9B?5::9DO! 6CFCD! ?9BF<:;?!

<:@!?ACE!6B9L?!;A<;!L9B9!;5!<6658E<:J!;A9!MC:P)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%+('%$094%,-,%(2;&-%"+2,&%%!

!1<:!?;<:@C:P!>9I5B9!;A9!$A<B<5A!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!}<7ZC6A!W__[2!"aW^"a])!/BC?6A9:!W_][2!ba^aW)!!

! !

Page 536: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _W`!

*)()W_! E)498)3<\)(O!

;9K;!WHW<!

456789:;!;C;D9! $<EJB7?!3<\\<B<!(O!;9K;!WHW<!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3<\\<B<)!#;A!;5!"B@!69:;7BC9?!T)*)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!aOaG!!&0'$0%*&%(+2(!&0!:É!+('0%,&%*%"+2"+2,&%!W"O[]^W]OW`G!!(%"+2,&%+%"+%"+2,&%%W]O_G%-('2*#0'%$0%+2+&%'&%-0'%%!W]O"aG%#*0%+%"&%,)%+%$+0%-+2+&%'&%-0'%%!

!'A9!P7<B@?O!;A9!P9:9B<D?!<:@!;A9!PB9<;!89:!5I!;A9!"+%"+2,&!!49E<B;!5I!;A9!$A<B<5A!;5!;A9!"+%"+2,&%%'A9!l799:!6<89!;5!;A9!@55B!5I!;A9!E<D<69!=qG!!XC?!>B5;A9B?!7E5:!;A9!>B<ZC9B!LAC6A!A<@!>99:!@5:9!<;!;A9!@55B!5I!;A9!E<D<69!=qG!!

U5;9?2!38C;A!<:@!'<C;!E5C:;9@!57;!;A<;!;A<;!C:!;A9!;9K;!<!EAB<?9!?C8CD<B!;5!ET1!W`b`VO!65D)!

(YO!]!=*%'G!C?!I57:@O!>7;!LC;A!;A9!;9B8!-0'!?7>?;C;7;9@!I5B!"+%"+2,&b)!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;!<:@!'B<:?D<;C5:2!38C;A!h!'<C;!W_V")!!

! !

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!0!38C;A!h!'<C;!W_V"2!b"O!:5)!6')!

Page 537: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _WW!

*)(()W! *-!g/!"#b[#!

456789:;!;C;D9! 39<;9@!?;<;79!5I!\.2\-0'<2$0942,*)!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<M)!,?5BM5:!()!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!T!aG!0,'<%0,'<0%*D'E%$(<%,-D'E%%

!;A9!7:C\79!5I!;A9!7:C\79!5:9?!5I!;A9!5:9!LA5!=;A9!MC:PG!C?!C:!;A9!,-D'E!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!g<:?9:^SC:M9D:!W_Vb2!'9CD!W2![bb^[bak!'9CD![2!"[`)!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$1!((2!WbW)!1<?E9B5!W_Wb2!Wa#!=bV#G!!

! !

Page 538: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _W[!

*)(()[! *-!bb_!

456789:;!;C;D9! *7>9!?;<;79!5I!\#2B*#02$0942,*)!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! '98ED9!5I!+7K5B)!'<M9D5;!()!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!F9?;)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!D)![G%*;%*(''%(%#'"2#&%D99E%(&&D0E%.#+0%,-%%%D)!#G%**%#0&$9*9$%-(94%(%,-D'E94%%%%

!+5B@!=~IB99G!5I!?;9E?!C:!;A9!#'"2#&%=))G!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!?<6B9@!ED<69?!5I!;A9!,-%%(!@C@!:5;!D9<F9!XC?!1<d9?;J!C:!AC?!,-D'E!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!$7>DC6<;C5:2!T5B6A<B@;!W_WW^W_"aO!((2!W`b^Vk!ED)!_])!'9K;!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!g<:?9:!h!SC:M9D:!W_Vb2!'9CD!W2!_^[]k!'9CD![2!"WVO!"[WO!]"b^b)!!$1!((2!""#)!4<B9??J!WV_]2!ba^a`!=*Y(((G)!g<:??9:!W_bb2!WW#^[_)!!

! !

Page 539: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _W"!

*)(()"! *-!][[[bk!g/!"#b[Wk!N<B:<M!*<6A9;;9!:5)!"]#!

456789:;!;C;D9! *7>9!?;<;79!5I!F;2*'+0!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<M)!,?5BM5:!((!^!X<B?C9?9!%)!49?6BCE;C5:! %)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!IB5:;!5I!;A9!>5@J!C:!V!65D78:?)!

T)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!BCPA;!?C@9!C:!W"!DC:9?)!*)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!D9I;!?C@9!C:!W"!A5BCZ5:;<D!DC:9?)!4)!,:!;A9!><6M!EDC:;!C:!]!65D78:?)!/)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!BCPA;!<:@!D9I;!I<69?!5I!;A9!><?9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!%)!D)!"G%;#9*94%+%,-%(%.#+09#%%%D)!bG!(&&9*9$%#(&%!4<'%&)'%DNE%8-#$:%(%*#0'%(%#'"2#&%!T)!D)!WG%,P%(%,-%(%.#+09#%%D)![G%(&&%$$94%(%#'"2#&%%D)!]G%$(<2$;%*%*#0'%(%,-%%*)!D)!WG%+)%+94%-+%..%(.00%(%,-%%%D)!aG%.7*%0$%+%_(<2$;%(%,-%%4)!!D)!WG%$(<2$;%*%*#0'%;$'<%*;%-#0'%(%#'"2#&%%%D)!]G%$(<2+%*$0'%'&'<%$(<2+%#(+0%,-%D99E%(-2$;%@+%*;%,-%%/)!#!%*#0'%,'%*%"+2,&%%

!e%87:f!>B57PA;!89!C:!;A9!,-!C:!AC?!EBCF<;9!ED<69?!!(!?<L!AC?!L5B;A!<?!A9!6CB6D9@!;A9!?ABC:9!=qG!<?!5:9!A5:5B9@!>J!;A9!MC:P!C:!;A9!#'"2#&!!!,:9!LA5!9:;9B?!;A9!,-%C:!C;?!EBCF<;9!ED<69?!!,:9!LA5?9!658C:P!C?!L<C;9@!C:!;A9!#'"2#&!!(:;C8<;9!5I!;A9!MC:P!C:!;A9!,-!!!,:9!LA5!M:9L!AC?!?E996A!LA9:!?E9<MC:P!C:!;A9!,-!!X9!e%87:f!<EE5C:;9@!89!C:;C8<;9!5I!;A9!,-%%!(:;C8<;9!5I!;A9!MC:P!5I!.EE9B!<:@?!+5L9B!/PJE;O!+5B@!5I!EB<C?9?HI<F5B?!C:!;A9!#'"2#&!!1<J5BO!FCZC9BO!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!658E<:C5:!5I!;A9!,-!=))G!C:;C8<;9!5I!X5B7?!C:!;A9!,-!%!&5J<D!?6BC>9!C:!;A9!6A<8>9B!5I!;A9!"+2,&!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!+9PB<C:!W_`a^[bO!(((2!bV^a[O!ED)!"[)!'9K;!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!g<:?9:!h!SC:M9D:!W_Vb2!'9CD!W2!WW#^W"bk!'9CD![2!"W#O!"WVO!"[`O!"[aO!"[V)!!$1!((2!Wb`)!X5B:98<::!W_bW^O!((2!:5)!]#]!T5??9!W_"a2!"W^[O!:5)!a")!!

Page 540: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _W]!

!*)(()]! *-!][[`#k!g/!

"a_"Wk!N<B:<M!*<6A9;;9!:5)!Wb[!

456789:;!;C;D9! 39<;9@!?;<;79!5I!\.2\-0'<2$0942,*)!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<M)!,?5BM5:!((!^!X<B?C9?9!%)!49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!WW!F9B;C6<D!DC:9?!?;<B;C:P!5:!;A9!IB5:;<D!I<69!5I!

;A9!?9<;?!<:@!65:;C:7C:P!5:!;A9!BCPA;!?C@9)!!(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!!D)!aG!0+%(%S#'%(%#'"2#&%%%D)!VG%*#0'%#*0%*#0'%(%,-D'E94%

!-B9<;!5I!B7::C:P!C:!;A9!#'"2#&%!'A9!?965:@!5I!;A9!MC:P!=LA9:G!;A9!MC:P!C?!C:!AC?!,-D'E%!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!+9PB<C:!W_`a^[bO!(((2!W#^[`k!ED)!0(Y)!'9K;!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!g<:?9:!h!SC:M9D:!W_Vb2!'9CD!W2!"b^]"k!'9CD![2!"W_O!"[V)!!$1!((2!W]V)!1<?E9B5!W_Wb2!WWb!=""[G)!T5??9!W_"a2![W!:5)![a)!!! !

Page 541: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _Wb!

*)(()b! N<B:<M!'!"b!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!?;<;79!5I!=+<2>1(*%W#+C'*!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<M)!,?5BM5:!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!><6M?C@9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%0+%S#'%(%#'"2#&%

!

-B9<;!5I!B7::C:P!C:!;A9!#'"2#&%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!T<BP79;!h!+96D<:;!W_]_^W_bW2!ICP)!W]W)!

'9K;!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!!g<:?9:!h!SC:M9D:!W_Vb2!'9CD!W2![#b^ak!'9CD![2!"W_)!

N99?!W_bV>2![WW!II)!!

! !

Page 542: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _Wa!

*)(()a! *-!][[W"k!g/!

"#][_k!

N<B:<M!

*<6A9;;9!:5)!

Wb]!

456789:;!;C;D9! *7>9!?;<;79!5I!`8&C:2*2B*#0!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<M)!,?5BM5:!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)!cB5:;<D!?C@9!LC;A!b!65D78:?!5I!C:?6BCE;C5:)!

T)!W"!F9B;C6<D!DC:9?!5I!C:?6BCE;C5:!IB58!;A9!D9I;!M:99!;5!;A9!

BCPA;!?A57D@9B)!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)!

6)![^"G!(&&%*#0'%*%.#+0%,-D'E!!

!

6)!W`G!$0!,P9*9$%C*-%,-%(%.#+09#%%

!

&5J<D!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!?<6B9@!ED<69?!5I!;A9!

,-D'E!!

(!9:;9B9@!C:!;A9!,-%C:!C;?!?<6B9@!ED<69?!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!+9PB<C:!W_`a^[bO!(((2!"]^ak!ED)!00((!

$1!((2!W]V)!

N99?!W_bV>2![[W^[)!

'9K;!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!g<:?9:!^!SC:M9D:!W_Vb2!'9CD!W2!W``^W`#k!'9CD![2!"W#O!"WVO!]V[^")!!

!

! !

Page 543: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _W#!

*)(()#! *<CB5!*-!

][[[Wk!g/!

"a_W_k!

N<B:<M!

*<6A9;;9!:5)!

W[[!

456789:;!;C;D9! *7>9!?;<;79!5I!F#2"&2?,!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<M)!,?5BM5:!((!^!'<M9D5;!((!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)! (:?6BCE;C5:! 5:! ;A9! ><6M! 5I! ;A9! ?;<;79! LC;A! a! F9B;C6<D!

65D78:?!<:@!"!A5BCZ5:;<D!DC:9?)!

T)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!D9I;!?C@9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!%)!!6)!aG!$+'0%*#0'2;$'<%,*)0<%*%$(<2$;%*%@+%*;%,-%!T)!DD)![^"G!,P9$%(%,-%0+<0%(%+0'<9#%%

!!/J9?!5I!;A9!MC:P!5I!.EE9B!<:@!+5L9B!/PJE;O!A9<B?!5I!;A9!I<F5BC;9!5I!X5B7?O!+5B@!5I!;A9!,-!!(!9:;9B!C:!;A9!,-%LACD9!;A9!D<BP9!57;?C@9!B98<C:!<;!C;?!@55B!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!+9PB<C:!W_`a^[bO!(((2!]#^b`k!ED)!00(0!$1!((2!W]_)!N99?!W_bV>2!["Wk!["#^["_k![]"^[]b)!'9K;!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!g<:?9:!h!SC:M9D:!W_Vb2!'9CD!W2!WV"^W_[k!'9CD![2!"W#)!!!

! !

Page 544: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _WV!

*)(()V! *<CB5!*-!

][[WVk!g/!

"#Wbbk!

N<B:<M!

*<6A9;;9!:5)!

]a_!

456789:;!;C;D9! *7>9!?;<;79!5I!M&2.$2=0'!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<M!*<6A9;;9)!,?5BM5:!((!^!'<M9D5;!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5I!a!A5BCZ5:;<D!DC:9?!5:!;A9!><6M!5I!;A9!?;<;79)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!D)![G!-(%#(+%(&,%*%0+0%,-%%

!&5J<D!;B79!IBC9:@!5I!;A9!PB9<;?!5I!;A9!,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!+9PB<C:!W_`a^[bO!(((2!][^]k!ED)!00Y()!$1!((2!Wb`)!'9K;!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!g<:?9:!h!SC:M9D:!W_Vb2!'9CD!W2!WW[^WWak!'9CD![2!"a_O!]_W)!!

! !

Page 545: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _W_!

*)(()_! *<CB5!*-!

][[[`k!g/!

"a#W`k!

N<B:<M!

*<6A9;;9!:5)!

[W!

456789:;!;C;D9! *7>9!?;<;79!5I!\.2=0'2$0942,*)!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<M)!,?5BM5:!((!^!'<M9D5;!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!LC;A!b!A5BCZ5:;<D!DC:9?!5:!;A9!><6M!5I!;A9!?;<;79)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!T!W#O!IObG!'#$9*94%#&9$%-+%#'%+.0<9$%(%,-D'E94%*'%x"'2#0'%

!X9!e%87:f!I7B;A9B9@!8J!?5:!C:!8J!E5?C;C5:!C:!AC?!,-D'E%5I!N<B:<M!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!+9PB<C:!W_`a^[bO!(((2!]b^#k!ED)!00Y((()!$1!((2!W]V^W]_)!N99?!W_bV>2![]Wk![]])!'9K;!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!g<:?9:!h!SC:M9D:!W_Vb2!'9CD!W2![#V^[V[k!'9CD![2!]WV)!,;;5!W_b]2!W"b^aO!:5)!])!!

! !

Page 546: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _[`!

!*)(()W`! *-!][["`k!g/!

"a#`ak!

N<B:<M!

*<6A9;;9!:5)!

VW!

456789:;!;C;D9! *7>9!?;<;79!5I!>1(*2(2$*'!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<M!*<6A9;;9)!'<M9D5;!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!IB5:;<D!I<69)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!D)!_G!;#%$*C%+%,-D'E%(%),$D'E%*#0'%S+%,*)%*;%*%W#+%!!!D)!W`G!$+9$%-#$%@+%(%,-94%%

!(!L<?!C:;B5@769@!C:;5!;A9!,-D'E%<;!;A9!<EE9<B<:69!5I!;A9!MC:P!LC;A!<!>57\79;!5I!;A9!+5B@!5I!'A9>9?!!(!@C@!<?!;A9!X5B7?!EB<C?9@!C:!AC?!,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!+9PB<C:!W_`a^[bO!(((2!#[^]O!ED)!"V)!$1!((2!Wb`)!X5B:98<::!W_bWO!((2!:5)!]#])!T5??9!W_"a2!"W^[O!UB)!a")!'9K;!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!g<:?9:!h!SC:M9D:!W_Vb2!'9CD!W2!W#`^WV[k!'9CD![2!"W#O!"[")!!!

! !

Page 547: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _[W!

*)(()WW! &<89??978!

456789:;!;C;D9! *A<E9D!5I!@+02#&2&#'!C:!;A9!&<89??978)!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! &<89??978)!'<M9D5;!(()!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!+)%#!'&%(%#'"2#&%

!,:9!LA5!M:5L?!?96B9;?!C:!;A9!#'"2#&%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!g<:?9:!^!SC:M9D:!W_Vb2!'9CD!W2![V"k!'9CD![2!"WV)!!$1!((2!a#_)!3EC9P9D>9BP!WV_V2!WWk!WVk!ED)!["O!]^b)!!

! !

Page 548: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _[[!

*)(()W[! *-!][["[k!g/!

"aaabk!

N<B:<M!

*<6A9;;9!:5)!

__!

456789:;!;C;D9! *7>9!?;<;79!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<M)!3A9?A5:\!(((!^!X<B?C9?9!T!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:! 5:! ;A9! BCPA;! ?C@9! 5I! ;A9! ?;<;79! LC;A! "! DC:9?! 5I!

C:?6BCE;C5:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

%!W_O!AOWG!-&'<2,%,-%-&'<2,%.+$%%%%!W_O!AO[G%!#"9$%=&,'%(%7C+9#%(%,-%

!

'A9!EBC:69!5I!;A9!,-%DNEO!;A9!EBC:69!5I!;A9!L<DD!9:6D5?7B9!=qG!

!

(!B969CF9@!;A9!1<<;!C:!AC?!5B:<89:;?!C:!;A9!

,-%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!!+9PB<C:!W_`a^[bO!(((2!#V^V`k!ED)!0+O!0+()!$1!((2!W]_)!T5??9!W_"a2![#^VO!:5)!]a)!N99?!W_a]2!W""^W"])!-<7;AC9B!W_W]2![`V="G)!+9PB<C:!W_`#>2![b])!N99?!W_bV>2!["W^"[)!!'9K;!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!g<:?9:^SC:M9D:!g)!W_Vb2!'9CD!W2![W`^[Wbk!'9CD![2!"[#O!"]`!bb#)!!

! !

Page 549: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _["!

*)(()W"! *-!VV]!

456789:;!;C;D9! cB<P89:;!5I!;A9!*7>9!?;<;79!5I!>1(*2(2$*'!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<M)!3A9?A5:\!(((!^!X<B?C9?9!T)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!D)!WG!+)%*#0'%0+%,-D'E94%%D)!]G!#(+%)+"%'&0<%*D,E%*;%,-D'E%%

!,:9!LA5!M:5L?!;A9!MC:PO!PB9<;!5I!AC?!,-D'E!!cBC9:@!5I!;A9!5:9!LA5!@CB96;?!;A9!;L5!+<:@?!I5B!;A9!+5B@!5I!;A9!,-D'E%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!T5B6A<B@;!W_WW^"aO!(((2!W"a^#k!ED)!Wbb)!4<B9??J!WV_">2!Wa_!=b_G)!N99?!W_bV>2!["[^")!!'9K;!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!g<:?9:!^!SC:M9D:!W_Vb2!'9CD!W2![a`^[a[k!'9CD![2!"[#O!"a_)!!

! !

Page 550: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _[]!

*)(()W]! 4<MAD9A!3;9D9!!

%?A85D9<:!

17?978!

=,KI5B@G!

456789:;!;C;D9! 4<MAD9A!3;9D9!!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 4<MAD9A!5<?C?O!FCDD<P9!5I!17;)![[;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%D)!WG!+*"'%Q%&;.%l%"+'%AL%7+0%*#0'%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%G&%!&P&%%%D)!"G%0.%$0%*#0'%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%+%##".%"&%'&20-&%%%%D)!bG%#&%5'2*)'%$%7'%'&<%.*<%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;%M&2#;&2),$2*$0'W%,*)%0.&%#*;%"&%*'+%,&%+*"'%Ak%%D)!W[G%$0%(0%*(-0%*&%(2,%**%(0%"+2,&%,*)%0.&%#*;"

!R<9B!bO!I57B;A!85:;A!5I!LC:;9BO!@<J!Wa!5I!;A9!MC:P!$A<B<5AO!D)E)!A)O!3A9?A5:\!!$A<B<5AO!D)!E)!A)!A<@!?9:;!AC8!;5!B9?;5B9!5B@9B!C:!;A9!,<?C?^D<:@!!'A9!?5:!5I!5'2*)'!C??79@!<!65EJ!5I!;A9!B9PC?;9B!5I!$A<B<5A!M&2#;&2),$2*$0'%=~$?7?9::9?GO!;A9!PB9<;!P5@!C:!J9<B!W_!!'A9?9!<B9!EBCF<;9!L<;9B?O!<:@!;A9B9!C?!:5!L<;9B!5I!$A<B<5A!<85:P!;A98)!!

U5;9?2!W!T96M9B<;A!W___2!WV")!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!-<B@C:9B!W_""2!["!II)O!ED?)!Y^Y(()!!!

!

!

!

! !

Page 551: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _[b!

*)(()Wb! *-!][[[ak!g/!

"ab#bk!

N<B:<M!

*<6A9;;9!:5)!

[!

456789:;!;C;D9! *7>9!?;<;79!5I!@+0!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<M)!$9;7><?;C?!()!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)!T5;;58!B5L)!

T)!V!F9B;C6<D!DC:9?!C:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!><6M)!

*)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!><?9!5I!;A9!?;<;79)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%%)!D)!WG!0**9*9$%$#%(%-+<2'"%*%,-D'E%)+"0%$#%*%+)<0'%!T)!D)![G!(-%,-%(%#;&'94%!D)!bG!!4<'%(%7"0%*'%"+2*#0'%'"2+.%*!$(<0%-&'94!%*)!%!WWOMG%"+$%-#<%(%#'"2#&%

!!(!L<?!<;!;A9!A9<@!5I!;A9!,-D'EI%<!P7C@9!;5!;A9!?7>d96;?!5I!;A9!NC:P!!!,:9!LA5!ICDD?!;A9!,-%LC;A!AC?!;9<6AC:P!!4CP:C;J!5I!D<L?!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'O!B7D9?!5I!;A5?9!LA5!<B9!C:!IB5:;!5I!AC8!!,:9!LA5!P59?!I5B;A!EB<C?9?HI<F5B?!C:!;A9!#'"2#&%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!+9PB<C:!W_`a^[bO!(((2!a[^bk!ED)!000((()!$1!((2!W]_)!+96D<:;!W_#_2!ED)![ba)!T5??9!W_"a2![VO!:5)!]#)!1<?E9B5!W_Wb2!W__!=#_"G)!'9K;!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!g<:?9:^SC:M9D:!W_Vb2!'9CD!W2!W"a^W]_k!'9CD![2!"[#O!"[VO!""`O!"aWO!b`a^WW)!!

!

! !

Page 552: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _[a!

*)(()Wa! N<B:<M!

456789:;!;C;D9! %::<D9?!5I!;A9!$BC:69!,?5BM5:!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<M)!$9;7><?;C?!()!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!T![[O!TO!Z)]G!*'2,0%(%#'"28#&:%)"+0%+%8#&:+94%-+9#D*E%%T![[O!TO!Z)"G!0"$%%7'%$(94%*'%0+'%-#0'%8P(&:9*%0+8':%-'#%*4+094%(%-+<2$;%,-D'E%0+'!

!'A9!B7D9?!6B9<;9@!C:!;A9!#'"28#&: <?!A9!:99@?!5:!;A98!!,:9!LA5!@C?;C:P7C?A!AC8?9DI!>9;L99:!;A9!0+'%-#0'I%5:9!LA5?9!PB9<;!>9<7;J!L<?!6B9<;9@!>J!;A5?9!LA5!<B9!C:!C:!;A9!PB9<;!,-D'E%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!g<:?9:!^!SC:M9D:!W_Vb2!'9CD!W2![_`^[_]k!'9CD![2!"[VO!][W)!!

!

! !

Page 553: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _[#!

*)(()W#! *<CB5!*-!][[WWk!g/!"#Wb_k!N<B:<M!*<6A9;;9!:5)!"#V!

456789:;!;C;D9! *7>9!?;<;79!5I!F)'942=0'!$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<M)!,?5BM5:!(((!^!'<M9D5;!((()!49?6BCE;C5:! %)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!IB5:;<D!?7BI<69!5I!;A9!?;<;79)!&CPA;!

?C@9)!T)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!IB5:;<D!?7BI<69!5I!;A9!?;<;79)!+9I;!?C@9)!*)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!><6M!5I!;A9!?;<;79!LC;A!V!F9B;C6<D!DC:9?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!%)!D)![G!-&'<2,%,-D'E%-&'<2,%#;)'%!D)!"G%+)%#!'&%(%#'"2#&%(&&%.#+0%,-%%%D)!WWG%,P%+%,-%0+0%(%+0'<9#%%%%T)!D)!W[G%0&-%"+2,&I%,*)%0.&%#*;%%*)!!D)!]^bG!(&&%.#+0%,-%%

!$BC:69!5I!;A9!,-D'EI!EBC:69!5I!;A9!P<;9L<J!!,:9!LA5!M:5L?!;A9!?96B9;?!C:!;A9!#'"2#&9%,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!?<6B9@!ED<69?!5I!;A9!,-%!/:;9BC:P!C:!;A9!,-I%;A9!PB9<;?!=>9C:PG!<;!C;?!P<;9!!!!/:@7B9!5I!;A9!$A<B<5AO!D)!E)!A)!!!,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!?<6B9@!ED<69?!5I!;A9!,-!!

U5;9?2!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!+9PB<C:!W_`a^[bO!(((2![V^"[O!ED)![`)!'9K;!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!g<:?9:!^!SC:M9D:!W_Vb2!'9CD!W2!V"^__k!'9CD![2!"WVO!"[`O!"[#O!""]O!]#`^b)!!$1!((2!W]_^Wb`)!1<?E9B5!W_bV2!E)![`b!=V]]G!X5B:98<::!W_bW^!((2!:5)!]#")!!! !

Page 554: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _[V!

!*)(()WV! T9BDC:!W#[#[!

456789:;!;C;D9! *7>9!?;<;79!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<M)!,?5BM5:!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%;#%-+%*#0'%(%0,,0%(&&%,-%(%.#+09#%%

!

'A9!7:C\79!5:9!LA5!C?!C:;B5@769@!;A9!MC:PO!

5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!,-!5I!;A9!?<6B9@!ED<69?!!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$1!((2!Wa[)!SB9?ZC:?MC!W_Wb2!"b"^_)!'9K;!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!g<:?9:^SC:M9D:!W_Vb2!'9CD!W2!"``^"`Wk!'9CD![2!"WV)!!!

! !

Page 555: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _[_!

*)(()W_! T1!W``#!

456789:;!;C;D9! *7>9!?;<;79!5I!,*)2+*"2*4+!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<M)!,?5BM5:!((()!

49?6BCE;C5:! TC5PB<EAC6<D!C:?6BCE;C5:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

D)!WG!$*C%*;%*(''%D(E%,-D'E%.#+'%%

!

(!L<?!IB99!5I!?;9E?!C:!;A9!?<6B9@!,-D'E!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!

$7>DC6<;C5:2!!

'9K;!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!g<:?9:^SC:M9D:!W_Vb2!'9CD!W2![a_^[#Wk!'9CD![2!"W_)!!

$1!(Y2!b")!

T7@P9!W_`_2![Wb!=##aG)!

!

! !

Page 556: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _"`!

*)(()[`! *-!"_[W#2!g/!

[bW][!

456789:;!;C;D9! -B57E^?;<;79!5I!\.2\-0'<2$0942,*)!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<M)![[;A^[";A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! TC5PB<EAC6<D!C:?6BCE;C5:!=><6M!?C@9G)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!T![VO!Z)]G!0-(%-#0'%*%@+0%(%,-%-+<D'E9*9$%%%%T![VO!Z)bG!"+$9$%-+%#;&0%*0%"+2*#0'%7&0%*;0%(%+!0'%+%P&$%*%"'!

!&9E9<;9@!I<F5B?!I5B!X5B7?!C:!;A9!,-%=I5B!LA<;G!(!A<@!@5:9!!(!L9:;!;AB57PA!;A9!@55B?!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'O!=LACD9G!<DD!L9B9!B9D<;9@!;5!;A9!d7>CD<;C5:!;5!;A9!ACPA!5I!;A9!?MJ!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!g<:?9:^SC:M9D:!W_Vb2!'9CD!W2!"`"^"`bk!'9CD![2!"[`O!]`a)!!$1!(Y2!""!T<B;<!W_aV2!WV`k!W#bk!WV`k!W#_)!!

!

! !

Page 557: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _"W!

*)(()[W! 3<\\<B<!+![]!

456789:;!;C;D9! -B57E^?;<;79!5I!`&C2*2+*4%

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<M)!$?<8;9M!(!=aa]^aW`!T)*)G!

49?6BCE;C5:! TC5PB<EAC6<D!C:?6BCE;C5:!=(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!><6M!?C@9G!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

)+"%,-!!

,:9!LA5!C?!<;!;A9!A9<@H65:;B5DD9B!5I!;A9!,-!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!+9E?C7?!W_#"O!(((2![a])!!TB9?6C<:C!W_VV2!ICP)![)!/D^U<PP<B!W_Va2!Wb!II)!YC;;8<:!W_#V2!W]a^#)!/D^3<J9@!W_#b2![a`O!t]a)!$B9??D!W__V2!WaVO!:5)!T!#)W)!!

! !

Page 558: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _"[!

!

*)(()[[! g/!]"#WW!

456789:;!;C;D9! -B57E^?;<;79!5I!M&2.$2@+0D2"E94/M&2.$2@+2(.*%

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N<B:<M)![[;A^[";A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! TC5PB<EAC6<D!C:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!><6M?C@9!5I!;A9!?;<;79)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!

)+"%,-!!

,:9!LA5!C?!<;!;A9!A9<@H65:;B5DD9B!5I!;A9!,-!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!4<B9??J!W_W[2!W_]^_b)!$B9??D!W__V2!W##O!:5)!T!Wb)[!!

! !

Page 559: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _""!

*)(()["! ''!W[V!

456789:;!;C;D9! '58>!5I!M&2'*4$!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 'A9>9?)!$?<8;9M!(!=aa]^aW`!T)*)G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! %)!&9E9<;9@!;C;D9!!

T)!'C;D9!B9I9BB9@!;5!;A9!?965:@!@<7PA;9B!\$'2>1#'2-;!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!%)%$(<2+%"+2-.%"+2,&%!T)!-#<%D(E%7*0%*D9$E%>1(*D0E%%

!,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!;B9<?7BJ!5I!;A9!"+2,&!!c<F5B9@!C:!;A9!7*0!5I!%87:!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!36A9:M9D!W_#b<2!W]a)!&x??D9B^NxAD9B!W__W2!W_]^[``O!]")!!YC;;8<::!W_#V2!a]!IIO!W#b^W#_)!$B9??D!W__V2!W#_O!:5)!T!WV!!

! !

Page 560: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _"]!

*)(()[]! T1!/%!W""!

456789:;!;C;D9! ,II9BC:P!?D<>!5I!Fy2M'-!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!$?<8;9M!(!=aa]^aW`!T)*)G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)+"%,-%!

!,:9!LA5!C?!<;!;A9!A9<@H65:;B5DD9B!5I!;A9%,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!3A<BE9!WV"#^bbO!((2!ED)!"#)!+9PB<C:!W_W]2!abO!456)!a])!$B9??D!W__V2!WV#O!:5)!T![])[!!

! !

Page 561: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _"b!

*)(()[b! '<:;<!:5)!

a_]!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;<;79!LC;A!5II9BC:P!?D<>!5I!5(&2'&0<2'42*)'!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! T<DMC8!=49D;<G)!$?<8;9M!(!=aa]^aW`!T)*)G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!9@P9!5I!;A9!:<5?!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)+"%,-%!

!,:9!LA5!C?!<;!;A9!A9<@H65:;B5DD9B!5I!;A9%,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!T<MBJ!W_#`<2!W_^[[)!&x??D9B^NxAD9B!W__W2![`_O!]V!6)!$B9??D!W__V2!W_aO!:5)!T!"W)]!!

! !

Page 562: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _"a!

*)(()[a! *<CB5!:5)q!

456789:;!;C;D9! U<5EA5B7?!?;<;79!5I!5(&2'&0<2'42*)'!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %?A878!9D^&588<:!=49D;<G)!$?<8;9M!(!=aa]^aW`!T)*)G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!D9I;!?C@9!5I!;A9!:<5?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)+"%,-%!

!,:9!LA5!C?!<;!;A9!A9<@H65:;B5DD9B!5I!;A9%,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!T<MBJ!W_#`<2![[^"a)!&x??D9B^NxAD9B!W__W2![W`O!]V!I)!Y9B:7?!W_#V2!_`^_[O!UB)!_V)!$B9??D!W__V2!W_aO!:5)!T!"W)b!!

! !

Page 563: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _"#!

*)(()[#! +57FB9!%!V"!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;9D5EA5B7?!?;<;79!5I!`*'2@+!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!U9M<5!((O!R)!W!=aW`!T)*)G!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%-(94%(%7*0%F$'D$E%%

!XC?!1<d9?;J!L<?!C:!;A9!7*0%5I%F$'D$E!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$9B@7!W_Va2!["^[]O!ICP)!W)!!'9K;!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!R5J5;;9!W_a`2!"aV^"#`O!ICP)!a`_)!!

! !

Page 564: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _"V!

*)(()[V! +57FB9!4!ab!

=~!g/!"Va#G!

456789:;!;C;D9! ,II9BC:P!?D<>!5I!@+02$+2,&!!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3<\\<B<O! '58>! +3! ["! =/! "Va#G)! $?<8;9M! ((! =b_b^bV_!

T)*)GH%EBC9?!==bV_^b#`!T)*)G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)+"%,-%!

!,:9!LA5!C?!<;!;A9!A9<@H65:;B5DD9B!5I!;A9%,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$C9BB9;!WV#]^#V2!V[^V")!!&x??D9B^NxAD9B!W__W2!!["WO!b#!I)!$B9??D!W__V2![`bO!:5)!*![)]!!

! !

Page 565: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _"_!

*)(()[_! Y<;C6<:!:5)!

Waa!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;<;79!5I!M#('C2#*;!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! =3<C?qG)!$?<8;9M!((!=b_b^bV_!T)*)G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! -B99:!><?<D;!:<5EA5B57?!?;<;79)!!!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

'C;D9?!5:!;A9!IB5:;<D!:<5?2!!)+"%,-%%0'%$;-%"+2,&%%'C;D9?!5:!;A9!IB5:;<D!ECDD<B2!%)+"%,-%%

!!,:9!LA5!C?!<;!;A9!A9<@H65:;B5DD9B!5I!;A9%,-%%*AC9I!5I!;A9!@9:;C?;?!5I!;A9!$A<B<5A!!!!,:9!LA5!C?!<;!;A9!A9<@H65:;B5DD9B!5I!;A9%,-%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!Nw:9D!W_V]2!W_"^W_aO!@56)![])!*A9F9B9<7!W_Vb2!W"]^W"bO!@56)!W_b)!T5;;C!^!&58<:9DDC!W_bW2![V^[_O!:5)!"#O!ED)!00Y()!$B9??D!W__V2![W#O!:5)!4)!W`)W!!

! !

Page 566: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _]`!

*)(()"`! +57FB9!%!_]!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;<;79!5I!F)'2@+02-;!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! '9DD!T<\DCJ<)!$?<8;9M!((!=b_b^bV_!T)*)GW)!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!BCPA;!?C@9!5I!;A9!?;<;79!<:@!5:!;A9!@5B?<D!

ECDD<B)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)+"%,-%%

!,:9!LA5!C?!<;!;A9!A9<@H65:;B5DD9B!5I!;A9%,-!

U5;9?2!W!$5?9:9B!W_bW)!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!}CFC9!W_#b2!_V^W`]O!456)![b)!*A9F9B9<7!W_Vb2!_`^_[O!456)!WWa)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!/D^3<J9@!W_#b2![[b^[[#!3A7>9B;!W_V_2!"W)!49!197D9:<9B9!W_aa2!W]!=]]G!$B9??D!W__V2![W#O!:5)!4)!WW)W!!

! !

Page 567: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _]W!

*)(()"W! T1!/%!Wa]a!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;<;79!5I!F)'2@+02-;!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!$?<8;9M!((!=b_b^bV_!T)*)G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!BCPA;!?C@9!5I!;A9!><?9!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)+"%,-%%

!,:9!LA5!C?!<;!;A9!A9<@H65:;B5DD9B!5I!;A9%,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!*A9F9B9<7!W_Vb2!_`^_[O!456)!WWa!=Y((G)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!3A7>9B;!W_V_2!"W)!!$B9??D!W__V2![W#O!:5)!4)!WW)[!!

! !

Page 568: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _][!

*)(()"[! Y<;C6<:!:5)!

W]`!

456789:;!;C;D9! ,?CB5EA5B7?!?;<;79!5I!F)'2@+02-;!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3<C?)!$?<8;9M!((!=b_b^bV_!T)*)G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!><6M!5I!;A9!?;<;79)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)+"%,-%%

!,:9!LA5!C?!<;!;A9!A9<@H65:;B5DD9B!5I!;A9%,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!SC9@98<:!WVVb2!W[]!=#G)!T5;;C!h!&58<:9DDC!W_bW2![#^[V)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!*A9F9B9<7!W_Vb2!_WO!456)!WWa!=(((G!$B9??D!W__V2![[`O!:5)!4)!WW)]!!

! !

Page 569: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _]"!

*)(()""! *-!"_[#b!

456789:;!;C;D9! cB<P89:;!5I!<:!(?C?^?;<;79!LC;A!X5B7?!5I!F)'2@+02-;!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3<C?)!$?<8;9M!((!=b_b^bV_!T)*)G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:I9BC5B!E<B;!5I!<!>D<6M!><?<D;!?;<;79!LC;A!X5B7?!5:!AC?!M:99)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%P;;%(%"+2*#0'%%

!*<D8!C:!;A9!"+2*#0'!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;2!4<B9??J!W_`b^a2!"W_^"[`)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!*A9F9B9<7!W_Vb2!!_WO!456)!WWa!=(YG)!$B9??D!W__V2![[WO!:5)!4)!WW)b!!

! !

Page 570: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _]]!

*)(()"]! .EE9B!E<B;2!

*5E9:A<P9:O!

-DJE;5;A9M!UR!

*<BD?>9BP!

%/(U!Wa]V!

+5L9B!E<B;2!

T5D5P:<O!

17?95!*CFC65!

%B6A95D5PC65!

N3!WV"V!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;<;79!5I!FC&0!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3<C?)!$?<8;9M!((!=b_b^bV_!T)*)GO!U9M<5!((!=aW`^b_b!T)*)GW)!

49?6BCE;C5:! -B9J^PB99:!><?<D;!?;<;792!8<:!M:99DC:P!5:!<!ACPA!E9@9?;<D!

LC;A! A<:@?! E<D8! 57;?;B9;6A9@! 5:! ;A9! D9P?! <:@! D9<:C:P!

<P<C:?;!<!;<DD!><6M!ECDD<B)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!ECDD<B)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)+"%,-%

!,:9!LA5!C?!<;!;A9!A9<@H65:;B5DD9B!5I!;A9%,-%!

U5;9?2!W!17?95!*CFC65!%B6A95D5PC65!@C!T5D5P:<!W__`2!Wa`^WaW)!!TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!17?95!*CFC65!%B6A95D5PC65!@C!T5D5P:<!W__`2!Wa`^WaW)!/D^3<J9@!W_#b2![[b)!49!197D9:<9B9!W_V"2!"b^]W)!!$B9??D!W__V2![[#O!:5)!4)!W")W!!

! !

Page 571: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _]b!

*)(()"b! T1!/%!V"!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:?!5:!;A9!?;<;79!5I!M42,D0E2F'Q?!!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!%EBC9?!=bV_^b#`!T)*)G!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!ECDD<B)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!#,+*D<E%)'D0E9#*%+27*0%,-%%%

!,:9!LA5!C:;B5@769?!;A9CB!P55@?!C:?C@9!;A9!,-%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!3A<BE9!WV"#^bbO!(2!ED)!WWW)!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$C9AD!W_V"2!VV^_`)!!

! !

Page 572: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _]a!

*)(()"a! 1C;!&<AC:<O!

3;5B9^A57?9!

:5)!b]b!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;<;79!5I!M&42'&0D2(E2,02F'!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 1C;!&<AC:<)!%EBC9?!=bV_^b#`!T)*)G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%5,+D<E%)+'9#*%+%7*0%,-'%%

!SA5!C:;B5@769?!;A9CB!P55@?!C:?C@9!;A9!%,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!T<MBJ!W_#`>2!"[b^""")!$B9??D!W__V2!["[O!:5)!/!")]!!

! !

Page 573: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _]#!

*)(()"#! +57FB9!%!_"!

456789:;!;C;D9! U<5EA5B7?!?;<;79!5I!M&42'&0D2(E2,02F'!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! %>J@5?)!%8<?C?!=b#`^b[a!T)*)G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! -B9J!PB<:C;9!?;<;79!5I!;A9!8<:!6<BBJC:P!C:!AC?!A<:@?!<!:<5?!

LC;A!;A9!C8<P9!5I!,?CBC?)!(:?6BCE;C5:!@9?6BC>C:P!;A9!89<?7B9?!

M&42'&0D2(E2,02F'! A<?! ;<M9:! C:! 5B@9B! ;5! B9?;5B9! ;A9!

<B6AC;96;7B<DO! C:?;C;7;C5:<D! <:@! 965:58C6! IB<89L5BM! 5I! ;A9!

67D;?!5I!,?CBC?!<;!%>J@5?)!'A9! ;9K;! C:!W]!65D78:?!>9PC:?!5:!

;A9! >D<6M! EDC:;A! <:@! 65:;C:79?! 5:! ;A9! D9I;! ?C@9! 5I! ;A9! ?D<>!

;A<;!?7EE5B;?!;A9!<@F<:69@!D9P)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!D)! WG% $+<2",'% -&'<2,% #(+% 0,'<% )+"% ,-% D99E% 0+%#0*0%$(<2+%"+0<2-.%*;0%$(&)%,&%(%"+2*#0'%%%%D)![G%$0%#,+*D<E%(.'%&;.0%+27*%,-%+%#.(%-(94!

!$BC:69O!657:;O!?5D9!658E<:C5:O!,:9!LA5!C?!<;!;A9!A9<@H65:;B5DD9B!5I!;A9!,)I%6AC9I!5I!EAJ?C6C<:?O!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!A57?9!5I!?CDF9B!<:@!P5D@O!PB9<;!F9:9B<;9@!5I!;A9!"+2*#0'%!X9!B9I9B?!;A9!<II<CB?!5I!%>J@5?!<;!;A9!,-!I5B!;A9!M:5LD9@P9!5I!;A9!MC:P!%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$C9BB9;!WV#]^#VO![2!"_^]W)!$C9AD!WV_]2!WWV!II)!g9DC:M5F<^&9J85:@!W_b#2![#b!II)!!&x??D9B!^!NxAD9B!W__W2![]"O!a]!>)!$B9??D!W__V2!["WO!:5)!/!")[!'B<:?D<;C5:2!,;;5!W_b]2!Wa]^aa)!!TB9<?;9@!W_`a^#O!]2!t!W`Wb^W`[b)!!+C6A;A9C8!W_#"^W_V`O!(((2!"]^"a)!!

! !

Page 574: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _]V!

*)(()"V! 15?\79!b#]`!

s!TB55MDJ:!+!

#V)]a)[!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;<;79!5I!>1,-2(#D2#&2F'E!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!%8<?C?!=b#`^b[a!T)*)G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 45B?<D!C:?6BCE;C5:)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)+"%+#%*#0'%,-%%

!4CB96;5B!5I!;A9!B5J<D!P7<B@!5I!;A9!,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!X5@d<6A9!W_#W2!ED)!a#)!!49!197D9:<9B9!W__W2![b`^[bW)!$B9??D!W__V2![]`O!:5)!c!")[!!

! !

Page 575: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _]_!

*)(()"_! 3;56MA5D8!U)!

1)!W!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3<B65EA<P7?!5I!>1,-2(#D2#&2F'E!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!%8<?C?!=b#`^b[a!T)*)G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!DC@!5I!;A9!?<B65EA<P7?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)+"%,-%

!,:9!LA5!C?!<;!;A9!A9<@H65:;B5DD9B!5I!;A9%,-%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<7;AC9B!W_`#^W_W#O!(Y2!W[_!T)!&{FCDD57;!WVVW2!_#)!$C9AD!WV_`2!_^Wb)!!$B9??D!W__V2![]WO!:5)!c!")b!!

! !

Page 576: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _b`!

*)(()]`! +57FB9!4!b`!

456789:;!;C;D9! ,II9BC:P!?D<>!5I!>1,-2(#D2#&2F'E!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!%8<?C?!=b#`^b[a!T)*)G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)+"%,-%

!,:9!LA5!C?!<;!;A9!A9<@H65:;B5DD9B!5I!;A9%,-%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!-<7;AC9B!W_`#^W_W#O!(Y2!W[VH+00(()!g9DC:M5F<!W_bV2!_[!=W`G!<:@!WW[!=WVG)!&{FCDD57;!WVVW2!_a^_V)!49!197D9:<9B9!W__W2![b[)!$B9??D!W__V2![]WO!:5)!c!")a!!

! !

Page 577: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _bW!

*)(()]W! '5E2!+57FB9!/!

[b!"_`!

T<?92!

TB55MDJ:!UR!

b_)##!

456789:;!;C;D9! ,II9BC:P!?D<>!5I!>1,-2(#D2#&2F'E!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 1C;!&<AC:<)!%8<?C?!=b#`^b[a!T)*)G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)+"%,-%+#%%

!,:9!LA5!C?!<;!;A9!A9<@H65:;B5DD9B!5I!;A9%,-%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!T5;A89B!W_a_2!a#O!:5)!b#)!!$B9??D!W__V2![][O!:5)!c!")V!!

! !

Page 578: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _b[!

*)(()][! T1!/%!WWW!

=VWVG!

456789:;!;C;D9! U<5EA5B7?!?;<;79!5I!W&-2$;2?,0!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!%8<?C?!=b#`^b[a!T)*)G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! TD<6M!><?<D;!:<5EA5B7?!?;<;79!LC;A!,?CBC?)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)+"%,-%+#%%

!,:9!LA5!C?!<;!;A9!A9<@H65:;B5DD9B!5I!;A9%,-%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!*A9F9B9<7!W_Vb2!W`V!=((Gk!TB7::9B!^!'B<7;!W_b#2!_a!=Y((G)!$B9??D!W__V2![]VO!:5)!c!])W`!!

! !

Page 579: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _b"!

*)(()]"! *<CB5!:5)!(!

"]!a]V!

456789:;!;C;D9! '58>!5I!M&2.$2*D$E2x#'!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3<\\<B<)!%8<?C?!=b#`^b[a!T)*)G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'C;D9!B9E9<;9@!5:!@CII9B9:;!E<B;?!5I!;A9!;58>)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)+"%,-%%%

!,:9!LA5!C?!<;!;A9!A9<@H65:;B5DD9B!5I!;A9%,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!T<B?<:;C!!^!1<?E9B5!W_``2!["`!II)!$B9??D!W__V2![aWO!:5)!c!W[)W!!

! !

Page 580: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _b]!

*)(()]]! *<CB5!:5)!(!

"]a]V!

456789:;!;C;D9! *5IIC:!5I!M&2.$2*D$E2x#'!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3<\\<B<)!%8<?C?!=b#`^b[a!T)*)G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)+"%,-%+#%%

!,:9!LA5!C?!<;!;A9!A9<@H65:;B5DD9B!5I!;A9%,-!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!$B9??D!W__V2![aWO!:5)!c!W[)[!T7AD!W_b_2![`^[WO!%OW)!!

! !

Page 581: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _bb!

*)(()]b! 3<\\<B<!=<G!

456789:;!;C;D9! '58>!5I!M#('C!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3<\\<B<)!%8<?C?!=b#`^b[a!T)*)G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:?!IB58!;A9!I7:9B<BJ!6A<8>9B)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)+"%,-%-+<2#!'&%*D$E%"+2*#0'%%

!,:9!LA5!C?!<;!;A9!A9<@H65:;B5DD9B!5I!;A9%,-k!M99E9B!5I!?96B9;?!C:!;A9%"+2*#0'%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!T<B?<:;C!W_``2!W#`O!W#b)!-A<DC57:P7C!W_V"2!"[O!:5)!W[W)!*A9F9B9<7!W_Vb2!W"`O!456)!WVV)!$B9??D!W__V2![a"O!:5)!c!Wb)W!!

! !

Page 582: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _ba!

*)(()]a! *-!#V]!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;<;79!5I!M#('C!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3<\\<B<)!%8<?C?!=b#`^b[a!T)*)G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!)"+%,-%!$(<2+%,7*0'<%

!%;!;A9!A9<@H65:;B5DD9B!5I!;A9%,-%%,F9B?99B!5I!;A9%,7*0'<%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!T5B6A<B@;!W_WW^W_"aO!(((2!_W^_[)!R5J5;;9!W_#[2![[`)!$B9??D!W__V2![a]O!:5)!c!Wa)W!!

!

! !

Page 583: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _b#!

*)(()]#! 3<\\<B<!=>G!

456789:;!;C;D9! '58>!5I!M#('C!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3<\\<B<)!!%8<?C?!=b#`^b[a!T)*)G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!?57;A!L<DD!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)"+%,-%%

!%;!;A9!A9<@H65:;B5DD9B!5I!;A9%,-%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!4<B9??J!WV_b2!W#^[b)!$B9??D!W__V2![aaO!:5)!c!Wa)b!!

! !

Page 584: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _bV!

*)(()]V! $ACD<@9DEAC<O!

.:CF9B?C;J!

17?978!:5)!

][)_W!

456789:;!;C;D9! U<5EA5B7?!?;<;79!5I!M#('C2#&2F'!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3<C?)!%8<?C?!=b#`^b[a!T)*)G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9%><?9O!7EE9B!?96;C5:)%!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%#%D$E,+%#(<0%*'<0%*D<E%*94%(%#'"2#&%%

!%!8<:!<EEB5<6AC:P!<?!;A5?9!LA5!<B9!I5B!AC8!C:!;A9!#'"2#&%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!&<:M9!W_]"2!WW"O!W")!&x??D9B^NxAD9B!W__W2![]VO!aa)!/D^3<J9@!W_#b2![bbO!t"_)!$B9??D!W__V2![aVO!:5)!c!W_!!

! !

Page 585: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _b_!

*)(()]_! T1!/%!W"]!

=VW_G!

456789:;!;C;D9! U<5EA5B7?!?;<;79!5I!a*(02$;2?,02(*!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3<C?)!%8<?C?!=b#`^b[a!T)*)G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!IB5:;!><?9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)+"%,-%%

!,:9!LA5!C?!<;!;A9!A9<@H65:;B5DD9B!5I!;A9!,-%!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!%:;A9?!W_"_2![a^[#!=(YG)!/D^3<J9@!W_#b2!W"b^W]]O!456)!W`O!ED)!00^00((()!$B9??D!W__V2![#[O!:5)!c![")[!!

! !

Page 586: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _a`!

*)(()b`! 3<\\<B<!=6G!

456789:;!;C;D9! '58>!5I!@P&2(2#&94!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! 3<\\<B<)!%8<?C?!=b#`^b[a!T)*)G)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'C;D9?!B9E9<;9@!C:!@CII9B9:;!?96;C5:?!5I!;A9!;58>)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)+"%,-%%$(<2+%"+2-.%*;0%*D9$E%7*0%%

!,:9!LA5!C?!<;!;A9!A9<@H65:;B5DD9B!5I!;A9!,-!!,F9B?99B!5I!;A9!;B9<?7BJ!5I!;A9!P5D@!5I!;A9!7*0%!

U5;9?2!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!1<?E9B5!W_`]2!#V^V")!T<B?<:;C!W_`]2!a_^#V)!-5J5:!W_a_2!Wa[^Wa")!$B9??D!W__V2![#bO!:5)!c![b)[!!

! !

Page 587: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _aW!

*)(()bW! *<CB5!:5q!

456789:;!;C;D9! 3;<;79!C:?6BCE;C5:!5I!,*)2@+0%!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! N58!%>7!TCDD7!=qG)!9<BDJ![a;A!4J:<?;J!=qG)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'A95EA5B57?!>D56M!?;<;79!LC;A!C8<P9!5I!X<;A5B)!

%)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!BCPA;!?C@9!5I!;A9!><?9)!

T)!(:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!><6M!ECDD<B)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)!)+"%,-%%T)!$*C% ;&C%(&,% *% +2"+% "*% $*C% #+.$% #"+% *;% *% *'+%-0'%'*%+%7*0%,-%

!,:9!LA5!C?!<;!;A9!A9<@H65:;B5DD9B!5I!;A9!,-!!!(!<8!;A9!;B79!?9BF<:;!5I!;A9!?<:6;7<BJO!C;!C?!89!LA5!8<M9!<BBCF9!9F9BJ!B9\79?;!5I!;A9!;98ED9!;5!;A9!C:?C@9!5I!;A9!,-%!

U5;9?2! o(D! ?Q5IIB9! h! á! D<! 8<:CiB9! @9! >C9:! @9! E9B?5::<P9?! B9EB{?9:;{?! E<B! @9?! ?;<;79?!

?C?;B5EA5B9?! h! á! ;B<:?89;;B9! D9?! EBCiB9?! @9?! @{F5;?! á! 69! \7QCD! <EE9DD99! ààD9! E<D<C?ââ! =,-GO!@{?CP:<;C5:!\7CO!C6CO!:9!?Q<EEDC\79!?äB989:;!E<?!<7!$D<C?!B5J<DO!8<C?!<7!;98ED9!@9!D<!@CFC:C;{O!

9:!DQ5667BB9:69!69D7C!@QX<;A5B!@9!19IM<;O!D<!@{9??9!ICP7B{9!@<:?!D9!:<5?!\79!ã:MAÇ5B!;C9:;!

@9F<:;!D7CrO!C:!*DiB9!W_#[2!b])!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!*DiB9!W_#[2!b`!II)!$B9??D!W__V2!WaaO!:5)!T!b)!!

! !

Page 588: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _a[!

*)(()b[! !*-!V`#!

456789:;!;C;D9! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!<!I<C9:69!?;<;79;;9!5I!@+2$+2?,%!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)![a;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! (:?6BCE;C5:!5:!;A9!IB5:;<D!><?9!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!G(#%*#0'%;$'<%'*09%$%*%-(94%(%&'%+%&'%"-9$%$&'%0+%*'%"+2*#0'%+.$'9*94%0$%$(<2+%+0'<%0*(9*9$%#0D+E$9*9$%+2S#%*#0'%;$'<%+,%*;%(%,+0%#'%&)'%8#7;9*%N:%(&&9*9$%%!'&0%*%"+2*#0'%P*%7+%-#0%"+%*2(%-,,0'%(%0.%*'%*'+%DNE%$+9*9$%.;-0%*%#%*94%#"+0%)+%*;%'&0<%%%

!c5B!;A9!?9BFC69!5I!;A9!MC:P!5I!+5L9B!/PJE;O!(!<8!6A5?9:!5I!XC?!1<d9?;J!<;!<:J!;C89)!(!B969CF9@!;A9!5IIC69!5I!@CP:C;<BJ!5I!"+2*#0')!X9!=;A9!MC:PG!<EE5C:;9@!89!5F9B?99B!5I!;A9!+0'<)!(!<;9!<:@!(!@B<:M!;5!;A9!MC:PÄ?!?C@9!9F9BJ!@<J!<;!;A9!A9<@\7<B;9B?!5I!;A9!A5BCZ5:)!(!?<L!;A9!?96B9;?!5I!;A9!"+2*#0')!(!9:;9B9@!I7DD!5I!EB<C?9!<:@!B9d5C6C:P!I5B!LA<;!(!P5;!57;!8J!E5L9BI7D!+5B@!6588<:@9@)!(!@C@!LA<;!(!<?M9@!I5B!<!E9B?5:!CIO!>J!E9;C;C5:!;5!;A9!+5B@!5I!'L5!+<:@?!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!'9K;!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!T5B6A<B@;!W_WW^W_"aO!(((2!W`]^b)!!T75:P<BZ5:9!W__b2!bW)!!

! !

Page 589: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _a"!

*)(()b"! '7BC:![[`W!

456789:;!;C;D9! *5IIC:!!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)![a;A!4J:)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

%)+"%,-%

!,:9!LA5!C?!<;!;A9!A9<@H65:;B5DD9B!5I!;A9!,-!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!/D^3<J9@!W_#b2!W`V^W[_O!456)!Vk![[W^[[O!t![)!YC;;8<::!W_#V2!W]#)!$B9??D!W__V2!"WbO!:5)!3!_`!!

! !

Page 590: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _a]!

*)(()b]! E*-!"WWa#!

456789:;!;C;D9! 4985;C6!E<EJB7?!*<CB5!*-!"WWa#!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)![a;A!4J:<?;J)!

49?6BCE;C5:! 'A9!B96;5!65:;<C:?!<!D9;;9B!5I!<!69B;<C:!'95?O!?5:!5I!$9@C9?9O!

<@@B9??9@!;5!AC?!-+<O!DCM9LC?9!:<89@!$9@C9?9)!

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!DD)![a^[#G!)"+%;*2"09$%.$%"-%"+2,&%%!

!(;!A<EE9:9@!;A<;!(!657D@!:5;!B9<6A!;A9!$A<B<5A!!!

U5;9?2!!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!3EC9P9D>9BP!W_`V2![ab^[aa)!!

! !

Page 591: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _ab!

*)((()W! ET1!/%!

W`b`VW!

456789:;!;C;D9! 'A9!(:?;B76;C5:?!5I!,*)2G!*P<!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)[!$BC5B!;5!";A!69:;7BJ!T*!=38C;A!W_V`k!&JA5D;![```2!

W[`GH!D<;9!3<C;9!E9BC5@!=l7<6M![``[G)"!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

![OWWG! $+% *9C% "+2,&% (.'% *4+'% ,!&<% 899:% "+% "+2,&%.+0%$+0%$*9C%+%"+%"+2,&%('0C%*C'%*%"&%'&!%%%[OWbG!*&%#&0'0%*&%$(<2+%(!,0%*&%+('0%,&0%"+%"+2,&%('+%+9#%.+0%8%+%:%$+9#%%%%"OVG%.0<%+%'&%8$p4%+#:%'<%-(#%"+2,&%*%"&%0+)%"+%"+2,&%D*E%=*2*4+%%%"OW`^WWG!..9*94% "+2,&% @+2#&2>1#'% #&% ?,2(#% $+0%$*9C%+%"+%"+2,&%$0%(*%('0C%*C'%*%"&%'&!!!]O"^]G%.$%"+2,&%X.0%0,'%)0&'%&#'%-+%+&%"+%"+2,&% .$94% .$0%@+2#&2>1#'% #&% ?,2(#% D*E% "&% ,)% -('%$+(%+('%*;%*'%('4% %'+0%$+(%*;%$+(%"&%,!2#-*%;*%"+2,&%!!]O#G! +94% )"+94% $0% )+% $*0% '&$94% -+9+% 82;*+% *:% "+%"+2,&!!!

!$A<B<5A!A<?!@5:9!I5B!J57!8<:J!P55@!;AC:P?!e85B9!;A<:f!I5B!<DD!e;A9!PB9<;!89:f!5I!;A9!"+%"+2,&I%R57!L9B9!>B57PA;!;5!;A9!"+%"+2,&!LA9:!J57!A<@!:5!EB5E9B;J!5:!;A9!9<B;A!!'A9!P7<B@?O!;A9!P9:9B<D?!<:@!<DD!;A9!PB9<;!89:!5I!;A9!"+%"+2,&%<B9!<DD!<PB99@!7E5:!C;!;5!@5!C;!%SA9:!;A9!85BB5L!@<L:9@O!;A9!$A<B<5A!?<;!C:!;A9!A<DD!5I!;A9!"+%"+2,&%<;!198EAC?!!$A<B<5A!?<C@!;5!AC82!@+2#&2>1#'I%?5:!5I!?,2(#O!C;!L<?!LA9:!J57!A<@!:5!EB5E9B;J!;A<;!J57!LA9B9!>B57PA;!;5!;A9!"+%"+2,&!!$A<B<5A!6<7?9@!<:!<D;<B!5I!9<B;A!;5!>9!>7CD;!<;!;A9!@55B!5I!;A9!"+%"+2,&9%X9!6<7?9@!@+2#&2>1#'%!?5:!5I!?,2(#!;5!>9!>B57PA;!LC;A!<DD!AC?!E95ED9!<:@!9F9BJ!8<:!LA5!A<?!65:?ECB9@!<P<C:?;!$A<B<5A!!XC?!I55@!7?9@!;5!>9!>B57PA;!C:!IB58!;A9!"+%"+2,&%@<CDJ%!

U5;9?2!W!1<:7?6BCE;! 5:! E)*<BD?>9BP! "`]! s! $3(! C:F)! 4! b! s! E*;! RT&! ]bW[! s! ET9BDC:! $! "`]V_!

I5B8C:P!E<B;!5I! ;A9!9K;9:?CF9!8<;9BC<D! I57:@!<;! ;A9!376A5?!;98ED9! C:!'9>;7:C?!65:;<C:?!<!

@CII9B9:;!F9B?C5:!5I! ;A9! C:;B5@76;C5:! ;5! ;A9!LC?@58!;9K;!LAC6A! C?! 65:?9BF9@! C:! ;A9!TBC;C?A!

17?978! 8<:7?6BCE;)! (:! ;A9! '9>;7:C?! 8<:7?6BCE;! :5! E<B;! 5I! ;A9! ;9<6AC:P! C?! EB9?9BF9@)!

$<D<95PB<EAC6<DDJO! C;! ?998?! ;5! >9! [b`^"``! J9<B?! J57:P9B! ;A<:! ;A9! TBC;C?A! 17?978!

8<:7?6BCE;)!'AC?!?965:@!F9B?C5:?!5I!;A9!'9<6AC:P!A<?!>99:!E7>DC?A9@!>J!NC8!&JA5D;!=&JA5D;!

[``G)!!

[! 'A9! TBC;C?A!17?978!8<:7?6BCE;! ?998?! ;5! A<F9! >99:! I57:@! B5DD9@! 7E! LC;A! ;A9! ;9K;! 5I!

$9;98C:C?!=/%!W`b`#G!C:!;A9!>7BC<D!5I!;A9!D<;;9B!<;!%MA8C8O!C:2!38C;A!W__]2![_"^"`")!

"!'A9!@<;9!5I!658E5?C;C5:!5I!;A9!'9<6AC:P?!5I!%:MA?A9?A5:\!A<?!>99:!;A9!?7>d96;!5I!?589!

Page 592: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _aa!

65:;B5F9B?J)! 'A9! I<6;! ;A<;! ;A9! C:;B5@76;C5:! C?! ?9;! C:! ;A9! 3<C;9! $9BC5@!EB5FC@9?! <! ;9B8C:7?!

E5?;!\798!I5B!C;?!@<;9!5I!658E5?C;C5:)!-9:9B<DDJO!A5L9F9B!<!876A!D<;9B!@<;9!C?!EB9I9BB9@O!

C:2!&JA5D;![```2!WW_)!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!'9K;!<:@!;B<:?D<;C5:2!'AC??9:!W_V])!&JA5D;![```)!'B<:?DC;9B<;C5:2!38C;A!W_V`)!!

! !

Page 593: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!"#$%&&%!

! _a#!

*)((()[! ETB55MDJ:!

]#)[WV)W"b!

456789:;!;C;D9! XC9B<;C6!LC?@58!;9K;!C:!$<EJB7?!TB55MDJ:!]#)[WV)W"b!

$B5F9:<:69!<:@!4<;9! .:M:5L:)!b;A!5B!];A!69:;7BJ)!

49?6BCE;C5:! !

(:?6BCE;C5:! 'B<:?D<;C5:!

!bO#G%899:A%%"+2*#0'%!

%"+2*#0'!

U5;9?2!W'A9! <7;A5B! C?! 7:<>D9! ;5! B9<@! ;A9! ;B<69?! EB969@C:P!"+2*#0'9%'A9J! <B9! E9BA<E?! ;A9!8<:! @9;9B8C:<;CF9!LC;A! ED7B<D! ?CP:!LA56A!L57D@! C8EDJ! <! ;C;D9! 5I! ;A9! E<D<69! 5B! ;A9! B5J<D!

<@8C:C?;B<;C5:!=g<?:5L!W__[2!_#O!bH"G!

TC>DC5PB<EAJ2!!$7>DC6<;C5:2!g<?:5L!W__[)!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!!

!

Page 594: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()$#(

( *+,(

!""#$%&'()$#((

-&./()0(.)123#.(

34!"/#2(56(7&%%-#(8&$9%)76(

(

!""#$#%&'()*$+#,-#.)*'

!:;<=<>?@A?<BC("ADE@<(

/!012345( (4607(85(!4( !9437' /:53( 0:5(D2C<>=C@(&&( "ADE@F>(2C<>=C@(&&( .C>6(&( !6&65G(

D2C<>=C@(&&&( "ADE@F>(2C<>=C@(&&&( .C>6(&( !6&65+(3A<@H(39(G,I+*( DJHFKAL(5,( 5M?N(%E=6( !6&65O(DJ@HHPKE=(MG65QQ+(

2HEAK(C:<R?(A::@C>>C:(?H(?NC(B<S<C@(!"#$(

.HTP6(&&( !6&65,(

DJ7(5IOG+(

(

"ADE@F>(2A;C>>CF;(&&&( 5M?N(%E=6( !6&65*(

(

3A<@H(

U#(+MIO( &=>R@<D?<H=(HV(P<=W(%&'()*+( .C>6(&&&( !6&65M(U#(QOXO+( $AH>(HV(.C>H>?@<>(&( .C>6(&( !6&6+(U#(G5*55( .?CKA(HV(,-."&'./0(123()*+( .HTP6(&Y( !6&65Q((

JC@K<=(

DJC@K<=(MIX*( JF<K:<=W(<.FTZCR?[=>R@<D?<H=(HV(.C>H>?@<(&(

.C>6(&((

!6&6G(

(

/CKK(JA>?A(

JFTA>?<>(5( JKHRP(\<?N(DA@?(HV(?NC(4H@F>(=A;C(HV(?NC(P<=W(!;C=C;NA?(&(V@H;(?NC(DAKARC(HV(/CKK(JA>?A(

!;6(&( !6&6X(

(

#KCDNA=?<=C(

#KCDNA=?<=C(].(5QI^(

JKHRP(<=>R@<D?<H=(V@H;(?NC(.A?C?_?C;DKC(A?(#KCDNA=?<=C(

.C>6(&( !6&6Q(

(

#STC?(4CK;<(

#STC?(4CK;<( &=>R@<D?<H=(HV(.C>H>?@<>(&&&( .C>6(&&&( !6&655(

Page 595: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()$#(

( *+*(

(

`A:<(4A;;A;A?(

4A;;A;A?( 2HRP(>?CKA(HV(8<=W($CT?A\E@C(7C=?FNH?CD(&Y((

7C=?6(&Y((

!6&65(

(

-ANF=(

-ANF=(5( `AKK(:CRH@A?<H=(V@H;(-ANF=( .C>6(&&( !6&6*((

-<>N?(

-<>N?(5( 3H=?@HK(=H?C(<=(<=P(V@H;(-<>N?( !;6(&( !6&6M((

7C:A;F:(

7C:A;F:(X+( &=>R@<D?<H=(HV(.C>H>?@<>(&&&( .C>6(&((

!6&65I(

(

7C;DN<>(

7C;DN<>( &=>R@<D?<H=(HV(!;C=C;NA?(&&(V@H;(?NC(?C;DKC(HV("?AN(A?(7<?(2AN<=A(

5X?N(%E=6( !6&6,(

(

/H:(

/H:(5( &=>R@<D?<H=(HV(.C>H>?@<>(&(A?(/H:(

.C>6(&( !6&6O(

(

"@<BA?C(RHKKCR?<H=>(

Ca(R0A@HFP( &=>R@<D?<H=(H=(A(VA<C=RC(TCA:(HV(bFCC=(123(3-(/!(

5X_5M?N(%E=6( !6&65X(

'

'

8+#;%-<'#)*$+#,-#.)*(

!TE:H>'

(4607(85(!46' (4607(85(!4' !9437' /:53' 0:5'!TE:H>( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 45'(5'*65"( .C>6(&&&( !6&&6G*((

Page 596: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()$#(

( *OI(

(

(!K=\<RP(

!K=\<RP(5*M+( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 45'(*5("(!"#( 7686( !6&&65OO((

!>\A=(

!>\A=(M+( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( 1-('"+*(*$( .C>6(&&&( !6&&6+5(;!>\A=(5QO5( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( a( .C>6(&c(d6(5O( !6&&6M*(

(

!>><F?(

!>><F?(5( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( 7&_.)!(+8( .C>6(&( !6&&6M5((

JC=<(4A>A=(

JC=<(4A>A=(X( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( 09:"(:()-*8( .C>6(&(_(!;6(&&( !6&&6QX(JC=<(4A>A=(M( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( ;":$()*+( !;6(&&(_(.C>6(&&( !6&&6G5((

JC@K<=(

JC@K<=(5XII( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( <=*("2(=:-)( 7686( !6&&65OX(JC@K<=(5XIM( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( a( !;6(&&( !6&&6Q+(JC@K<=(5XIQ( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( >'(==*("&'( 7686( !6&&6+I(JC@K<=(OMI*( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( a( 7686( !6&&65OM(DJC@K<=(5IIX5( "ADE@F>( ;?-(=*&. 7686( !6&&65G+(DJC@K<=(5IXQ,( "ADE@F>( @. 7686( !6&&65O*(DJC@K<=(5IQOI( -C??C@( @. 5X?N(%E=6( !6&&655,((

#K_JC@>NCN(

JC@>NCN(5( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( 7)$*8("#*(Y&( !;6(&(e(.C>6(&&( !6&&6QM(JC@>NCN(X( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( 7)$*8()*+( !;6(&&(e(.C>6(&&&( !6&&6GX(JC@>NCN(G( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( !)-("(#"*( 5If55?N(%E=6(

]g^(!6&&65M(

JC@>NCN(,( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( !)-( 5If55?N(%E=6(]g^(

!6&&65Q(

(

J@<?<>N(7F>CF;c(-H=:H=((

J7(5QG(h,X,i( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 1-(:"*$( !;6(&&( !6&&6Q,(J7(5Q+(hGOQi( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( A"*8(1:*B8C( !;6(&&( !6&&6Q+(J7(5GQ(hG+Gi( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 09:"88. .C>6(&&&(]g^( !6&&6+X(J7(5OG(h5I5i( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( %2(+$(45'*(

5"(!;6(&&&( !6&&6+,(

Page 597: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()$#(

( *O5(

J7(5*M([G++]( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 7D$(123( 5X?N(%E=6( !6&&65II(J7(5*+(h55OOi( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 09'*(&("(*$(*( .C>6(&( !6&&6MG(J7(5*O(hG,5i( (

.?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 09"*&(E'."(1"*( .C>6(&( !6&&6MM(

J7(X5,(hXQMi( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( A"*8(F*8(:()-*(

5X?N(%E=6(( !6&&65XO(

J7(X5*(hXGGi( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 1*:(5-6&( 7686( !6&&65IM(J7(XMX(hX5Gi( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( a( 5X?N(%E=6( !6&&6**(J7(XQ*(h5X5Mi( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 123(#$( .C>6(&&&( !6&&6G+(J7(XQ5(hXMOi( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 45'( 5X?N(%E=6( !6&&655*(J7(M5M(hXQ*i( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( G+(55( 5X?N(%E=6( !6&&655,(J7(M5G(hXQXi( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( a( 5XMN(%E=6( !6&&65M5(J7(M5*(hXG5i( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( A"*8.)!-B*C6=( 5X?N(%E=6( !6&&6*G(J7(GI+( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( >:)(=( 5X?N(%E=6( !6&&65X,(J7(GOX( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 09"*&. .C>6(&c(d6(M*( !6&&6QI(DJ7(5IOGX(]D2A;C>>CF;(3^(

"ADE@F>(V@H;(.C;=A( a( .C>6(&&&((

!6&&6GO(

(

JH>?H=c(7F>CF;(HV(0<=C(!@?>((

J70!(X*655MI(

.?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( H"*$(:()-*( 7686( !6&&65+O(

((

JFNC=(

JFNC=( -C??C@( a( 7686( !6&&65+X(((

3A<@H(

39(5Q,+( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( !9+*8( 5X?N(%E=6( !6&&65MI(39(XIIMI( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 45='(5"(+$( 7686( !6&&65+*(39(XIIOG( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( a( 5M?N(%E=6(]g^( !6&&65MI(39(XII,G( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( a( 7686( !6&&65+M(39(XI5IQ( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( a( 7686( !6&&65+Q(39(XI5QI( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 098(#'("&'*( .C>6(&&&(_(!;6(

&&&6(!6&&6+M(

39(XI5Q*( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( a( 7686( !6&&65OI(39(XIXXG( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( a( 7686( !6&&65O5(39(XIXMG( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( ;52$(==(:()*+( 7686( !6&&65+,(39(XIXGQ( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( /D(*$()I-(

$D)$(228(5X?N(%E=6( !6&&65XI(

39(XIXG*( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( J9:"8( .C>6(&&&( !6&&6GG(39(XIXO,( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( G:5$('"(52( 5X?N(%E=6( !6&&6*+(39(XIX,,( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( H'('$('==(*(+'=(

+=(7686( !6&&65G,(

39(XIQMG( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 09:"8(3:65( 7686( !6&&65++(39(XIQGO( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 4"#*=( 7686( !6&&65+I(

Page 598: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()$#(

( *OX(

39(XIQO+( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 4'("5$*(=$(*"=(

7686( !6&&65GO(

39(XIQ,G( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( @. 7686( !6&&65G,(39(XIG5,( ( K66LM":$."#*( 7686( !6&&65+5(39(XIGM,( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 1*+(=2(*('!( !;6(&&&( !6&&6+Q(39XIGM*( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( H"(*$()*+( .C>6(&( !6&&6MX(39(XIGOI( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( H-!(='('( 7686( !6&&65GG(39(XIGO5( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( /:"8(!"#( 5X?N(%E=6( !6&&65I5(39(XI+5+( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( /!("&'( 7686( !6&&65+G(39(XI+XO( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( %2(!"#( 7686( !6&&65+O(39(XIO5X( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 09"=("*(:"(*$(

N2(5X?N(%E=6( !6&&6*O(

39(XIOQ,( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( /:"(==(!"#( 5X?N(%E=6( !6&&65XM(39(OIIM+( $AH>(<=>R@<D?<H=( 09=$6&( 5X?N(%E=6( !6&&65XX(3A<@H(M6+6XG65( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( a( 7C=6(&&( !6&&6M((

%AN>NF@(

%AN>NF@(=H6(XII(

.?A?FC??C(<=>R@<D?<H=( @( 5X?N(%E=6( !6&&655*(

%AN>NF@( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( H"*$("5$( 5X?N(%E=6( !6&&655O((

%C<@(2<VCN(

%C<@(2<VCN(5( 9@AVV<?H( %&'(F":$( .C>6(&(_(!;6(&&( !6&&6QQ(%C<@(2<VCN(O( 9@AVV<?H( %*(!"#( 7686( !6&&65Q*(((

%F@NA;(

%F@NA;($5*MG(

.?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( M":$()*+( .C>6(&&( !6&&6GI(

%F@NA;($5*M+(

.?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 45'*(5"(!"#( .C>6(&&&( !6&&6GQ(

(

#:VF(

#:VF(5( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( ;'$(/!$( 5M?N(%E=6( !6&&65MM((

#STC?(2F>N:<(

#STC?(2F>N:<( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( 09:"8( 5X?N(%E=6( !6&&65M5((

0<@C=SC(

0KH@C=RC(=H6(XG5X(

.?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 092=( 5X_5M?N(%E=6( !6&&65XG(

Page 599: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()$#(

( *OM(

`A:<(4A;;A;A?(

4A;;A;A?(5O( 9@AVV<?H( ;*+8( !;6(&&&( !6&&6+O(4A;;A;A?(55M(

9@AVV<?H( @. 7C=6(&Yc(d6(X( !6&&65I(

4A;;A;A?(Q( 9@AVV<?H( !?!( .C>6(&c(d6(5+6( (4A;;A;A?(QI( 9@AVV<?H( 09+=(5-(=+=( 7C=6(&&( !6&&65(4A;;A;A?(QM( 9@AVV<?H( 09:"(:()-*( !;6(&&&( !6&&6OI(4A;;A;A?(,O( 9@AVV<?H( 09:"()-*( .C>6(&c(d6(M,6( !6&&6X,(4A;;A;A?(9(+5(

9@AVV<?H( 4):$.09:"8( !;6(&(e(.C>6(&( !6&&6XX(

4A;;A;A?(5XM(

9@AVV<?H( !?!(=2( .C>6(&( !6&&6XO(

((

4A?=FT(

4A?=FT(W@6(5Q( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( %*'()*+( 55?N(%E=6(]g^( !6&&655(4A?=FT(W@6(5+( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( %)'8(5( 55?N(%E=6(]g^( !6&&65O(4A?=FT(W@6(XM( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( 7)$*8("#*.O( !;6(&( !6&&65,(4A?=FT(W@6(XQ( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( ,-8( 7C=?6(&Y( !6&&6,(4A?=FT(W@6(XG( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( %)'8( 7C=?6(&Y( !6&&6*(4A?=FT(W@6(M5( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( 7)$*8("#*( !;6(&6( !6&&65*(4A?=FT(W@6(Q*( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( 09:"(:)-*( .C>6(&c(d6(M5( !6&&6MI((((

4CLA<T(

4CLA<T(X( .N@<=C(<=>R@<D?<H=((( 1'"(+$*... .C>6(&6( !6&&6MQ(4CLA<T(*(_;!>\A=(5MOM(

.?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 1-('"+*(*$( 5X?N(%E=6( !6&&65XX(

4CLA<T(Q*(_;!>\A=(5MMO(

.?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 1"2$( 5X?N(%E=6( !6&&65X5(

(

8HDC=AWNC=(

;8HDC=AWNC=($39(!#&$(,*5(

.?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 09"*&( 7C=6(&&( !6&&6+(

;8HDC=AWNC=($39(!#&$(5GM*(

.?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( A"*8(#*=(:(5&(5"2(

5X?N(%E=6( !6&&6*,(

((

-C<:C=(

-C<:C=(G(]Y(Q^( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 4+($-$*(!-( .C>6(&( !6&&6XQ(-C<:C=(+(]Y(G^( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( A+'(3-(/!( !;6(&&( !6&&6QO(-C<:C=(*(]Y(,,^( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( P2( 7686( !6&&65M+(-C<:C=(Q5(]Y(O^( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( /!(5-()*+(=2(

!"#(7686( !6&&65GQ(

Page 600: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()$#(

( *OQ(

-C<:C=(Q+((]Y(5IG^(

.?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 1"2( 5M?N(%E=6( !6&&65MQ(

-C<:C=(GX(]Y(**^(

.?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( /'$*( 5X?N(%E=6( !6&&65MX(

(

-HFB@Cc("A@<>(

-HFB@C(3(5( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( %5$(H"*$( !;6(&(e(.C>6(&( !6&&6XM(-HFB@C(3(G( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( M*(5*8($'*( !;6(&&&( !6&&6OI(-HFB@C(3(MM( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( Q+8( !;6(&&&( !6&&6++(-HFB@C(#(55IGM(

.?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( 09:"(:()-*("(!"#(

!;6(&&&6( !6&&6+G(

(

7AW:CTF@W(

7AW:CTF@W( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 09*( $CV6(&( !6&&65QQ((

7A=RNC>?C@(7F>CF;(

;7A=RN(MMI+( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 123(#$('"(6&("&'(

.C>6(&&&( !6&&6G,(

(

7A@>C<KKC(

7A@>C<KKC(=H6(XM(

JKHRP(<=>R@<D?<H=( A"(:5( 5X?N_5M?N(%E=6( !6&&65XM(

(

7C?@HDHK<?A=(7F>CF;(HV(!@?c($C\(dH@P(

77!(5X65,Q( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( H"*($5'*( .C>6(&c(d6(5O( !6&&6X*(77!(MG6O6GG6( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( R'(")(#!6&( 5M?N(%E=6( !6&&65MX(77!(GO6*G( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 09"(=*6&.='.".09&=( 7C=?6(&&( !6&&6X(

(

7F=<RN(

9-(`!0(MG(]HK:(=H6(QI^(

.?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 4+($-$*(!-( .C>6(&_!;6(&&6( !6&&6QX(

(

7F>jC(9F<;C?c("A@<>(

7F>jC(9F<;C?(3(+(

.?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 1=("8(45'*.S!"#.B@C..(

.C>6(&c(d6(5O( !6&&6O5(

(

(

Page 601: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()$#(

( *OG(

Ca()aVH@:(bFCC=>(3HKKCWC(7F>CF;(

;)a!>N;(]Ca(bFCC=>(3(b3(55I*^(

.?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( A"*8(F*8(:()-*(

5X_5M?N(%E=6( !6&&65XO(

(

"<??>TF@WNc(3A@=CW<C(7F>CF;>((

;"<??(3A@=CW<C(QGG,(

.?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( %2(!"#.='.".=:8('.+'.123()*+(

$CV6(&(e(.HT6(&Y( !6&&6OX(

(

8F;=A(

2&8(5I+( 2HRP(<=>R@<D?<H=( %2(T-2*( .C>6(&&( !6&&6OM(2&8(55O( 2HRP(<=>R@<D?<H=( -#*8(#*+$( !;6(&&&(]g^( !6&&6*X(2&8(55,( 2HRP(<=>R@<D?<H=( -#*8(#*+$( !;6(&&&(]g^( !6&&6*M((

2H:<=(

2H:<=(QX( JA>_@CK<CV( @. 5X?N(%E=6( !6&&65X5((

.ALLA@A(

.ALLA@A(5( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 9"2(=:8( 5I?N(%E=6(]g^( !6&&65X(

.ALLA@A(55.L( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( R*+. !;6(&( !6&&6XI(

.ALLA@A(5,'( YA@<HF>(<=>R@<D?<H=>( .k9)88( !;6(&( !6&&6X5((

.<=A<(

.<=A<(XG(_(;3A<@H(U#(M,GOM(

/ATKC?(<=>R@<D?<H=( ;2(!-. !;6(&&&( !6&&6,+(

.<=A<(X,( 2HRP(<=>R@<D?<H=( 1"2(*=(&8( !;6(&&&c(d6(QX( !6&&6,,(

.<=A<(QO( 2HRP(<=>R@<D?<H=( H"B*$C()*+. !;6(&&c(d6(XQ( !6&&6Q*(

.<=A<(G5( 2HRP(<=>R@<D?<H=( /"&(5"2( !;6(&&&c(d6(M,( !6&&6,O(

.<=A<(GM( 2HRP(<=>R@<D?<H=( 123()'()2( !;6(&&&c(d6(QQ( !6&&6,*(

.<=A<(GQ( 2HRP(<=>R@<D?<H=( Q*)($'. !;6(&&&c(d6(QG( !6&&6*I(

.<=A<(,G( 2HRP(<=>R@<D?<H=( %2(:5( !;6(&&&c(d6(Q( !6&&6O,(

.<=A<(,+( 2HRP(<=>R@<D?<H=( 09"8( !;6(&&&c(d6(G( !6&&6O*(

.<=A<(,O( 2HRP(<=>R@<D?<H=( 1-(09"+$. !;6(&&&c(d6(G( !6&&6,I(

.<=A<(,,(_(;"N<K1=<B(#(5GIMI(!_3(

.?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( a( !;6(&&&c(d6(G( !6&&6,5(

.<=A<(*X(( 2HRP(<=>R@<D?<H=( 1=("8(45'*[email protected]":$U.M":$(

!;6(&&&c(d6(5M( !6&&6,X(

Page 602: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()$#(

( *O+(

.<=A<(*,( 2HRP(<=>R@<D?<H=( '. !;6(&&&( !6&&6OQ(

.<=A<(5IG( 2HRP(<=>R@<D?<H=( '( !;6(&&&c(d6(MI( !6&&6,G(

.<=A<(55I( 2HRP(<=>R@<D?<H=( /"6&(5"2U./"(5"2(

!;6(&&&( !6&&6OG(

.<=A<(55X( 2HRP(<=>R@<D?<H=( 1"&('*((. !;6(&&&( !6&&6O+(

.<=A<(55Q( 2HRP(<=>R@<D?<H=( ( !;6(&&&( !6&&6OO(

.<=A<(55G( 2HRP(<=>R@<D?<H=( ,:5B$C( !;6(&&&c(d6(5,( !6&&6,Q(

.<=A<(5QI( 2HRP(<=>R@<D?<H=( @. 7686( !6&&65GM(

.<=A<(5QM( 2HRP(<=>R@<D?<H=( 09$6&("6=( !;6(&&&c(d6(5O( !6&&6,M(

.<=A<(5QQ( 2HRP(<=>R@<D?<H=( /"(52&( 7686( !6&&65GX(

.<=A<(MM5( 2HRP(<=>R@<D?<H=( !"#(5"( %E=6(5X( (

.<=A<(Q5X( 2HRP(<=>R@<D?<H=( A"*8()*+( %E=6(5X( !6&&65GI((

.NA??(C@(2<WAK(

.NA??(C@(2<WAK(QG*(

2HRP(<=>R@<D?<H=( H'$. 7C=6(&&( !6&&6Q(

.RNA??(CK_2<WAK(QOM(

2HRP(<=>R@<D?<H=( 45=("'( 7C=6(&&( !6&&6O(

(

1=<BC@><?E(3HKKCWC(HV(-H=:H=(

13(5QMMM( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( H"(*$()*+( 7C=6(&&(]g^( !6&&6G(13(5QM,G( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( @. 5X?N(%E=6( !6&&65X+(13(5Q+*+( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( ;"3$( 7686( !6&&65O,(D13(MX5X,( -C??C@( 1"(2$2$( 7686( !6&&6M+(D13(MXXII( "ADE@F>( Q+$( 7686( !6&&6M,(D13(MXXIX( "ADE@F>( 09=(=2( 7686( !6&&6MO(

(

7AW:CTF@W(

.?CKC(7AW:CTF@W(

.?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=. 09*( $CV6(&( !6&&65X,(

((

.CAK(<=>R@<D?<H=>(

>CAK(=H6(5IX((7<RNACK<:C>(3HKKCR?<H=((

.CAK(<=>R@<D?<H=( 092( 55?N(%E=6( !6&&65+(

>CAK(=H6(MM5(((J7(MO+*G(

.CAK(<=>R@<D?<H=( !"#(5( 7686( !6&&65Q5(

>CAK(=H6(M*O((13(55QX,(

.CAK(<=>R@<D?<H=( 4=-$( 7686( !6&&65QX(

>CAK(=H6(M*,(13(55Q,I(

.CAK(<=>R@<D?<H=( 4=-$( 7686( !6&&65QM(

>CAK(=H6(QII(3N<RAWH(5,G,5(

.CAK(<=>R@<D?<H=( 4=-$( 7686( !6&&65QQ(

Page 603: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()$#(

( *OO(

>CAK(=H6(QI5((7<RNACK<:C>(3HKKCR?<H=((

.CAK(<=>R@<D?<H=. 4=-$( 7686( !6&&65QG(

>CAK(=H6(Q5+((J7(++OX,(

.CAK(<=>R@<D?<H=. 4'("2( 55?N(%E=6( !6&&65G(

>CAK(=H6(QMQ((3KCBCKA=:(5Q6OOX(

.CAK(<=>R@<D?<H=. 45'(3-('!(!"#$( 7686( !6&&65M*(

>CAK(=H6(GQG((77!(5I65MI6X*O(

.CAK(<=>R@<D?<H=. H"( 5M?N(%E=6( !6&&65X*(

>CAK(=H6(GQO(("N<KA:CKDN<A(5I55+(

.CAK(<=>R@<D?<H=. H"()*+( 7686( !6&&65M,(

>CAK(=H6(++X(((7<RNACK<:C>(3HKKCR?<H=(

.CAK(<=>R@<D?<H=. %2('(5)$8( 7686( !6&&65Q+(

>CAK(=H6(OQMA(77!(X+6O6M5X(]#a(3A@=ABH=(3HKKCR?<H=^(

.CAK(<=>R@<D?<H=. %:265"6=("6=B@C( 5X?N(%E=6( !6&&65X*(

>CAK(=H6(5555(("N<KA:CKDN<A(#(*5*X(

.CAK(<=>R@<D?<H=. ;'( 5X?N(%E=6( !6&&6*Q(

>CAK(=H6(55MX(#K_-ANF=(

.CAK(<=>R@<D?<H=. ;'=( .C>6(&&&_!;6(&&&( !6&&6GM(

>CAK(=H6(55Q5((J7(MIGQ,(

.CAK(<=>R@<D?<H=. ;'(T&()*+( 7686( !6&&65Q,(

.CAK(=H6(5MQ*(13(55MQ5!(

.CAK(<=>R@<D?<H=. 1-K66L=2*@( 7686( !6&&65OG(

.CAK(=H6(5QOG( .CAK(<=>R@<D?<H=. 1"!!(=2( 7686( !6&&65O+(>CAK(=H6(5++M((J7(MIGQ5(

.CAK(<=>R@<D?<H=. 1*F( 7686( !6&&65QI(

>CAK(=H6(5,5G((8NAF=(

.CAK(<=>R@<D?<H=. @. 7686( !6&&65QO(

((

/NCTA=(/H;T(

//(+G( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=. !)-*8( 5M?N(%E=6( !6&&65MG(//(+GT( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=. !)-*8( 5M?N(%E=6( !6&&65MO(//(+I(( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=. 09"=(*&(=?'( .C>6(&( !6&&6XG(

(

/HFKH>C(

/HFKH>C(55,5( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 1"(+$( 7686( !6&&65OQ((

(

Page 604: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()$#(

( *O,(

/F@<=c(#WED?<A=(7F>CF;(

/F@<=(5+XI( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=. A"(:5( 5X_5M?N(%E=6( !6&&65XQ(/F@<=(5+X,(]XO+^(

.?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 1"(+$(. 5X?N(%E=6( !6&&65XG(

/F@<=(5MI( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=. 1"2( 5X_5M?N(%E=6( !6&&65XI((

lAW@CT(

lAW@CT(=H6(,( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=. @( 5X?N_5M?N(%E=6( !6&&65X+((

"@<BA?C(RHKKCR?<H=>(

JA=PC>(7>6(=H6('&&(3(Q(

.?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 7D$(09="*6&( .C>6(&( !6&&6X+(

7<RNACK<:<>(.?CKA(!(

.?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 4":=( 5X?N(%E=6( !6&&65XQ(

(

=#-<+%+>'-<?-*'

=(537:7@'(4607(85(!46(

(4607(85(!4( /:53( 0:5( 0:5(

/NC(?AKC(HV(?NC(.N<D\@CRPC:(.A<KH@((

D-C=<=W@A:(555G. 7686( !6&&&6O(

/NC(&=>?@FR?<H=(A::@C>>C:(?H(8<=W(7C@<PA@C((

D-C=<=W@A:(555+!m(D7H>RH\(Q+G,m(D3A@K>TC@W(+6.

5X?N(%E=6( !6&&&6M(

/NC(&=>?@FR?<H=(HV(8<=W(!;C=C;NA?(&(VH@(N<>(>H=(.C>H>?@<>(&((

D7<KK<=WC=c(H>?@ARA(A=:(?ATKC?>.

.C>6(&(]g^( !6&&&6X(

/NC(!:;H=<?<H=>(HV(&DF\C@((

D-C<:C=(MQQc('VW*X. 5X?N(%E=6( !6&&&6,(

/N@CC(?AKC>(HV(\H=:C@(

DJC@K<=(MIMM(]D`C>?RA@^(

5X?N(%E=6(]g^( !6&&&6+(

4E;=(?H()><@<>(( >?CKA(HV(123(='8.-HFB@C(3(MIc('VW*X.

5X?N(%E=6( !6&&&6Q(

/N@CC(?AKC>(HV(\H=:C@((

>?CKA(HV(123(='8.-HFB@C(3(MIc('VW*X.

5X?N(%E=6( (

/NC(?AKC(HV(.<=FNC((

DJC@K<=(MIXXm(DJC@K<=(5IQ**m(!>N;HKCA=(7F>CF;()>?@ARH=(HV(.<=FNC.

5X?N(%E=6( !6&&&6G(

/NC(7Aa<;C>(HV("?ANH?CD((

D"A@<>(J<T($A?(5,M_5*Q(]D"@<>>C^.

5X?N(%E=6( !6&&&65(

(

Page 605: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()$#(

( *O*(

34!"/#2(X6($#`(8&$9%)76(

(

!""#$#%&'()*$+#,-#.)*'

!TF(.<;TCK(

/!012345( /3607(85(!4( !9437( /:53( 0:5(!TF(.<;TCK( &=>R@<D?<H=>(V@H;(?NC(?C;DKC(

HV(!TF(.<;TCK(2A;6(&&&( J6&6GO(

(

!TE:H>(

!TE:H>(5( &=>R@<D?<H=>(V@H;(?NC()><@<>(.F<?C(HV(?NC(?C;DKC(HV(.C?E(&(

.C?E(&( J6&6MX(

!TE:H>(X( $AF@<(%CR@CC(HV(.C?E(&( .C?E(&( J6&6MM(!TE:H>(M( &=>R@<D?<H=>(V@H;(?NC(9AKKC@E(

HV(?NC(8<=W>(HV(?NC(?C;DKC(HV(.C?E(&(

.C?E(&( J6&6MQ(

!TE:H>(Q( %C:<RA?H@E(&=>R@<D?<H=(HV(!TE:H>(

2A;6(&&( J6&6QM(

!TE:H>(G( &=>R@<D?<H=>(HV(2A;C>C>(&&k>(/C;DKC(A?(!TE:H>(

2A;6(&&( J6&6QQ(

(

!;A@=A(

!;A@=A(5( #A@K<C@(D@HRKA;A?<H=(H=(THF=:A@E(>?CKA(V@H;(!;A@=A(

!;6(&Y( J6&65*(

!;A@=A(X( .?A?FC(HV($CVC@?<?<(V@H;(!;A@=A(

!;6(&Y( J6&6XI(

!;A@=A(M( YH?<BC(>NAT?<(HV($CVC@?<?<(V@H;(!;A@=A(

!;6(&Y( J6&6X5(

(

JAN?<;(

JAN?<;( .?A?FC(TA>C(HV($CVC@?A@<( bFCC=($CVC@?A@<( 2A;6((&&((

J@<?<>N(7F>CF;c(-H=:H=(

J7(5*Q( 3@H>>\H@:(>?CKA(HV(2A;C>C>(Y&(

2A;C>C>(Y&( J6&6+I(

(

J@FaCKKC>(7F>CF;(

J@FaCKKC>(;06OGII(

.?A?FC(HV(bFCC=($CVC@?A@<(\<?N("@<=RC(7C@<?HF;k>(V<WF@C(

bFCC=($CVC@?A@<(

2A;6((&&( J6&6GM(

Page 606: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()$#(

( *,I(

3A<@H(

36(X5c(36(XX( /\<=(.?CKA(V@H;(!TF(.<;TCK( 2A;6(&&( J6&6QX(39(5M656X565Q( 0@AW;C=?(HV(A(>?CKA(HV(

4H@C;NCT(4H@6( J6&6X*(

%FDK6(39(MQ5+X(( 4H@C;NCTk>(:CR@CC( 4H@6( J6&6X+(39(QX5GQ( 9@HFD_>?A?FC(HV(bFCC=(

$CVC@?A@<(A=:("@<=RC(bFCC=($CVC@?A@<( 2A;6(&&( J6&6G5(

39(Q5G+G(( /NC(@C>?H@A?<H=(<=>R@<D?<H=(HV(/F?A=PNA;F=(H=(?NC(>?CKA(C@CR?C:(<=(?NC(?C;DKC(A?(8A@=AP(

/F?6( J6&6XM(

U#(Q5O*I( 3A@=ABH=(/ATKC?( 8A;H>C( J6&65(U#(+5Q,5( (9HK:C=(>N@<=C(HV(

/F?A=PNA;F=(V@H;(N<>(?H;T(A?(/NCTC>(

/F?6( J6&6XQ(

3A<@H(5( .CPN;C?(>?A?FC(HV(!;C=NH?CD(&&&(

!;C=NH?CD(&&&( J6&65+(

D39(G,IM,( "ADE@F>(JHFKAL(5O( @. 5,?N(%E=A>?E(]!;6&&(g^(

J6&6M5(

(

%C<@(CK_JANA@<(

%C<@(CK_JANA@<(5( 3H@H=A?<H=(/Ca?(HV(4A?>NCD>F?(V@H;(%C<@(CK_JANA@<(

4A?>N6( J6&65I(

%C<@(CK_JANA@<(X( 3H@H=A?<H=(/Ca?(RA@BC:(H=(?NC(7<::KC(3HKH==A:C(<=(?NC(/C;DKC(HV(%C<@(CK_JANA@<(

4A?>N6( J6&655(

%C<@(CK_JANA@<(M( &=>R@<D?<H=(HV(bFCC=(4A?>NCD>F?(@CWA@:<=W(?NC(CaDC:<?<H=(?H.Q$"*((

4A?>N6( J6&65X(

(

#KCDNA=?<=C(

#KCDNA=?<=C((

&=>R@<D?<H=(HV(2A;C>C>(&&&(A?(#KCDNA=?<=C(

2A;6(&&&( J6&6G,(

(

8A@=AP(

8A@=AP(5( /NC(/C;DC>?(.?CKA(HV(!N;H>C( !N;H>C( J6&65(8A@=AP(X( %H=A?<H=(>?CKA(HV(bFCC=(

!N;H>C($CVC@?A@<(!N;H>C( J6&6M(

8A@=AP(M( &=>R@<D?<H=(HV(/NF?;H>C(&&&(V@H;(?NC(?C;DKC(HV(8A@=AP(

/NF?6(&&&( J6&6Q(

8A@=AP(Q( &=>R@<D?<H=>(HV(/NF?;H>C(&&&(V@H;(?NC(0C>?<BAK(4AKK(A?(8A@=AP(

/NF?6(&&&( J6&6G(

Page 607: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()$#(

( *,5(

8A@=AP(G( !==AK>(HV(/NF?;H>C(&&&(V@H;(?NC(?C;DKC(HV(8A@=AP(

/NF?6(&&&' J6&6+(

8A@=AP(+( 3H@H=A?<H=(/Ca?(HV(4A?>NCD>F?(V@H;(?NC(2C:(3NADCK((

4A?>N6( J6&6*(

8A@=AP(O( )TCK<>P(<=>R@<D?<H=(HV(bFCC=(4A?>NCD>F?(<=(?NC(?C;DKC(HV(8A@=AP(

4A?>N6( J6&65M(

8A@=AP(,( .?CKA(HV(!;C=NH?CD(&&(<=(V@H=?(HV(?NC(,?N(DEKH=(A?(8A@=AP(

!;6(&&( J6&65Q(

8A@=AP(*( &=>R@<D?<H=>(V@H;(?NC(?C;DKC(HV("?ANc(8A@=AP(NAKK(

4H@6( J6&6XO(

8A@=AP(5I( .?CKA(V@H;(?NC(Q?N("EKH=(HV(?NC(?C;DKC(HV("?AN(

4H@6( J6&6X,(

8A@=AP(55( &=>R@<D?<H=(HV(.C?E(&(V@H;(?NC(4EDH>?EKC(4AKK(HV(8A@=AP(

.C?E(&( J6&6M+(

8A@=AP(5X( &=>R@<D?<H=>(V@H;(?NC(7A<=(4AKK(HV(!;F=(/C;DKC(A?(8A@=AP(

.C?E(&( J6&6MO(

8A@=AP(5M( &=>R@<D?<H=(V@H;(?NC(4EDH>?EKC(4AKK(HV(8A@=AP(

2A;6(&&( J6&6QO(

(

9<SA(

9<SA(5( /NC(W@CA?(>DN<=a(>?CKA(HV(!;C=NH?CD(&&(A?(9<SA(

!;6(&&( J6&65G(

(

-HFB@Cc("A@<>(

-HFB@C(3(X,Q( JC=?@C>N(.?CKA( 2A;6(&&( J6&6Q5((

-FaH@(

-FaH@(5( &=>R@<D?<H=>(V@H;(?NC(?C;DKC(HV(-FaH@(

2A;6(&&( J6&6QG(

-FaH@(X( 2CD@C>C=?A?<H=(HV(bFCC=($CVC@?A@<(TCVH@C(?NC(@HEAK(RN<K:@C=(

2A;6(&&' J6&6GX(

(

7AKPA?A(

7AKLA?A( .CAK(<=>R@<D?<H=( !;6(&&&( J6&65,((

7C:<=C?(4ATF(

7C:<=C?(4ATF(5(

&=>R@<D?<H=>(H=(?NC(\AKK>(HV(?NC(?C;DKC(HV(7C:<=C?(4ATF(

2A;6(&&&( J6&6GG(

Page 608: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()$#(

( *,X(

7C:<=C?(4ATF(X(

&=>R@<D?<H=>(V@H;(?NC(?C;DKC_DAKARC(A?(7C:<=C?(4ATF(

2A;6(&&&( J6&6G+(

(

7C;DN<>(

7C;DN<>(5( &=>R@<D?<H=>(VH@;(?NC(?C;DKC(HV("?AN(A?(7C;DN<>(

4H@6( J6&6MI(

7C;DN<>(X( &=>R@<D?<H=>(V@H;(?NC("AKARC(HV(7C@C=D?AN(

7C@C=6( J6&6Q*(

(

7F>CF;(HV(0<=C(!@?>c(JH>?H=(

70!(XM6OMM( 9CTCK(JA@PAK(>?CKA(HV(/NF?;H>C(&&&((

/NF?6(&&&( J6&6,(

(

7C?@HDHK<?A=(7F>CF;(HV(!@?c($C\(dH@P(

77!(GQ65,G( #=:H\;C=?(.?CKA(( 2A;6(&&( J6&6Q+((

"AKC>?<=C(!@RNACHKHW<RAK(7F>CF;(

"AKC>?<=C(!@RNACHKHW<RAK(7F>CF;(HV(UC@F>AKC;(M+65**M(

J@H=SC(>?A?FC_TA>C(HV(2A;C>C>(Y&(

2A;6(Y&( J6&6G*(

(

bF@=A(

bF@=A( /C;DKC(HV(.C?E(&(A?(bF@=A( .C?E(&( J6&6MG((

2A;C>>CF;c(7H@?FA@E(/C;DKC(HV(2A;C>C>(&&(

2A;C>>CF;( &=>R@<D?<H=(HV(2A;C>C>(&&(V@H;(?NC(2A;C>>CF;(

2A;6(&&( J6&6Q,(

(

.C;=A(

.C;=A(5( &=>R@<D?<H=(HV(/NF?;H>C(&&&(V@H;(?NC(?C;DKC(HV(.C;=A(

/NF?6(&&&( J6&6O(

(

(

(

Page 609: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()$#(

( *,M(

.C>CT<(

.C>CT<( &=>R@<D?<H=(HV(bFCC=($CVC@?<?<(V@H;(?NC(/C;DKC(HV(.HKCT(

!;6(&Y( J6&6XX(

(

.HKCT(

.HKCT( &=>R@<D?<H=>(VH@;(?NC(/C;DKC(HV(.HKCT(

!;6(&&&( J6&65O(

(

/F@<=(

D/F@<=( 3H@H=A?<H=(/Ca?(HV(4H@C;NCT( 4H@6( J6&6XG(D/F@<=(]A^( "ADE@F>(V@H;(?NC(5,?N(

%E=A>?E(5,?N(%E=6(( J6&6+5(

(

1=<BC@><?E(7F>CF;(HV("C==>EKBA=<A(

1=<BC@><?E(7F>CF;("C==>EKBA=<A($@6(X*65IO6*G,(

JC?_.NCA=(>?CKA(( 2A;6(&&' J6&6M*(

(

YA@<HF>(D@HBC=A=RC>(

YA@<HF>( 7A@@<AWC(>?CKA(HV(2A;C>C>(&&( 2A;6(&&( J6&6QI(YA@<HF>( %CR@CC(HV(TKC>><=W("?AN(FDH=(

2A;C>C>(&&(A=:(&&&(2A;6(&&_&&&( J6&6GQ(

YA@<HF>( JA??KC(HV(bA:C>N( 2A;6(&&( J6&6M,(((

!:;<=<>?@A?<BC("ADE@<(

D/F@<=(]g^( "ADE@F>(/F@<=(]g^( .C?E(&( J6&6G*(D!=A>?A><(&Y( "ADE@F>(!=A>?A><(&Y( .C?E(&( J6&6+X(D9F@HT(JJ( "ADE@F>(9F@HT(JJ( .C?E(&( J6&6+M(DJ7(5I+,M( "ADE@F>(3NC>?C@(JCA??E(&&&( 7C@6( J6&6+Q(DJHKHW=A(5I*Q( "ADE@F>(JHKHW=A(5I*Q( 7C@6( J6&6+G(DJ7(5IXQM(

(

"ADE@F>(!=A>?A><(&&( 7C@6( J6&6++(

DJ7(5IXQG(

(

"ADE@F>(!=A>?A><(Y&( .C?E(&&( J6&6O5(

DJ7(5IXQ+(

(

"ADE@F>(!=A>?A><(&&&( 7C@6( J6&6+O(

DJ7(5IXQ+T(

(

"ADE@F>(!=A>?A><(&&&(YV'5X( 7C@6( J6&6+,(

D.AKK<C@(&(

(

"ADE@F>(.AKK<C@(&(

(

7C@6( J6&6+*(

Page 610: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()$#(

( *,Q(

D!=A>?A><(Y(( "ADE@F>(!=A>?A><(Y( .C?E(&&( J6&6OI(D!=A>?A><(&&&!(

(

"ADE@F>(!=A>?A><(&&&!( 5*?N(%E=6( J6&6OX(

D4A@@<>(&(

(

"ADE@F>(4A@@<>(&(

.2A;6(&&&( J6&6OM(

DJ7(5IIGM(

(

"ADE@F>(J7(5IIGM(

'VW*X.2A;6(&'( J6&6OQ(

D/F@<=(

5*MIfXIGInXI5

M(

(

"ADE@F>(/F@<=(

5*MIfXIGInXI5M(

.

2A;6(&'( J6&6OG(

DJ7(5IXX5(

(

"ADE@F>(!TTH??(

.2A;6(&'( J6&6O+(

D-CHDHK:(&&( "ADE@F>(-CHDHK:(&&(

.2A;6(&'( J6&6OO(

D/F@<=(XIOQ( "ADE@F>(/F@<=(XIOQ(

.2A;6(&'( J6&6O,(

D!;NC@>?(3HK6(

Y&(

"ADE@F>(!;NC@>?(

.2A;6(&'( J6&6O*(

DJ7(5IIGX( "ADE@F>(J7(5IIGX(

.2A;6('&( J6&6,I(

DJ7(5IIGQ( "ADE@F>(J7(5IIGQ(

.2A;6('&( J6&6,5(

DJ7(5IM,M( "ADE@F>(J7(5IM,M(

.2A;6('&( J6&6,X(

D/F@<=(

5,*+nXII+(

"ADE@F>(/F@<=(5,*+nXII+(

'VW*X(.

5*?N_XI?N(%E=6( J6&6,M(

D/F@<=(J( "ADE@F>(/F@<=(J(

.5*?N_XI?N(%E=6( J6&6,Q(

D-<BC@DHHK(

7F>CF;(76(

555+X(A=:((76(

555,+(

"ADE@F>(7AEC@(!(C(J(

.5*?N_XI?N(%E=6( J6&6,G(

D/F@<=(!( "ADE@F>(/F@<=(!(

.5*?N_XI?N(%E=6( J6&6,+(

D9@<VV<?N( "ADE@F>(9@<VV<?N. 5*?N_XI?N(%E=6( J6&6,O(

D-A=><=W( "ADE@F>(-A=><=W(

(

XI?N(%E=6( J6&6,,(

D/F@<=(39/(

GQIG5(

"ADE@F>(/F@<=(39/(GQIG5(

.XI?N(%E=6( J6&6,*(

DJ<TK<H?NjLFC(

$A?<H=AKC(5*+c(

&&(

"ADE@F>(J<TK<H?NjLFC(

$A?<H=AKC(5*+c(&&(

.

XI?N(%E=6( J6&6*I(

YA@<HF>( )=H;A>?<RH=(HV(k9:"(:(=+*..

XI?N(%E=6( J6&6*5(

Page 611: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()$#(

( *,G(

(

34!"/#2(M6(-!/#("#2&)%6(

'

8+#;%-<'()*$+#,-#.)*'

!TE:H>((

/!012345' /3607(85(!4' !9437' /:53' 0:5'!TE:H>(+( 2CK<CV( Q*)(:'=( 2A;6(&&( J6&&65GQ(!TE:H>(O( "A_A=PN( Q-(!"#. 2A;6('&( J6&&65OX(

(

!TF(.<;TCK(

!TF(.<;TCK(X( 9@AVV<?H( 1*B$C8( 2A;6(&&( J6&&65Q+((

!;A@AN(

!;A@AN( .?CKA(&=>R@<D?<H=( 45'(5-**( !;6(&&( J6&&6GQ((

!;A@=A(

!;A@=A(Q( .?A?FC(&=>R@<D?<H=( H$*("&'*( !;6(&Y( J6&&6,,(!;A@=A(G( )>?@ARH=( @( !;6(&Y( J6&&6*5(!/(5( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( <88( !;6(&Y( J6&&6*X(!/(M( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( !-(:5( !;6(&Y( J6&&6*M(!/(+( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( Q-(")58( !;6(&Y( J6&&6*Q(!/(O( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( Q-('"("&'( !;6(&Y( J6&&6*G(!/(,( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( <$(*$( !;6(&Y( J6&&6**(!/(5Q( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( H!8( !;6(&Y( J6&&6*O(!/(5,( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( @( !;6(&Y( J6&&6*,(!/(XG( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( !8( !;6(&Y( J6&&6**(

(

!=<TA(

!=<TA(( YH?<BC(&=>R@<D?<H=( /!("&'. /NF?6(&&&(e(!;6(&&&f&Y(

J6&&65IG(

(

JA=PC>(RHKKCR?<H=(

JA=PC>(3HKKCR?<H=(

.?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( g( .C?E(&( J6&&65XM(

(

(

Page 612: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()$#(

( *,+(

(

JC@K<=(

JC@K<=(XI,5( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( ;'=. 2A;6(Y&&&( J6&&65++(JC@K<=(,5OX( -<=?CK(<=>R@<D?<H=( 09$"8( .C?E(&( J6&&65XO(JC@K<=(5*OQX( &=>R@<TC:(VAoC=RC(TH\K( g( 5,?N(%E=6( J6&&655G(JC@K<=(X5G*O( %HH@ZA;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( 09+8( !;6(&Y( J6&&65II(

(

J@<?<>N(7F>CF;c(-H=:H=(

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gg( J6&&6O5(J7(5MMX( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 09$""( 5,?N(%E=6(

]/NF?6(&Y(g^(J6&&65I,(

J7(5G5M( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( 1"("(H$*( 4A?>6( J676QM(J7(GG5Q( "AKC??C(<=>R@<D?<H=( <-. 2A=6(&&( J6&&65QQ(J7(G+*X*( &=>R@<D?<H=(H=(A(;F;;<VH@;(

V<WF@C(,-("(09:". !;6(&&&( J6&&6+O(

J7(#!(5MOO( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( Q-(")58( 2A;6(&&( J6&&65M,((

J@HHPKE=((7F>CF;(

J@HHPKE=((7F>CF;(QO65XI6M(

0<WF@C(<=>R@<D?<H=( H=.( 5,?N(%E=6(]!;6(&&&(g^(

J6&&655*(

(

J@FaCKKC>(7F>CF;(

J@FaCKKC>(7F>CF;(#GMII(

.?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( H!8( .C?E(&( J6&&65X+(

(

(

Page 613: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()$#(

( *,O(

JFTA>?<>(

JFTA>?<>(( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( M'B=C$6&( !;6(&&&( J6&&6,5((

JFNC=(

JFNC=(5( 9@AVV<?H( %&'()'. 2A;6(&&(( J6&&65QO(JFNC=(X( 9@AVV<?H( Q=-8. 2A;6(&&( J6&&65Q,(JFNC=(M( 9@AVV<?H( ;'=. 2A;6(&&( J6&&65Q*(JFNC=(Q( 9@AVV<?H( 4"(*-($-*. 2A;6(&&( J6&&65GI(

(

3A<@H(

39(GG5( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( 09:"()*+( /NF?6(&&&6( J6&&65M(39(GG+( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=. 1"("&'( 5,?N(%E=6( J6&&655Q(39(GQO( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( H"(#+'(5"2. /NF?6(&&&6( J6&&65Q(39(GO*( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=(V@H;(?NC(

?C;DKC(HV(7F?(A?(8A@=AP(1"("(H$*. 4A?>6( J6&&6QO(

39(G,M( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( k9:"()*+c(>H=(HV(;+$(

!;6(&&&( J6&&6OM(

39(+MI( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( Q-(5'. 2A;6(&&( J6&&65M5(39(+Q,( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=(( ;+$(5"2$( 4A?>6(_(/NF?6(&&&( J6&&6X5(39(OO*( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( %#*(:=". 5,?N(%E=6( J6&&65I*(39(55XI( $AH>(<=>R@<D?<H=( @. XI?N(%E=6(]g^( J6&&65,G(39(55QI( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( %2(09:"( .C?E(&( J6&&65XX(39(XGXMI( )>?@ARH=(V@H;(?NC(/H;T(=H6(+(

A?(J<TA=(CK_7HKHFP(@. 5,?N(%E=6( J6&&655+(

93(XGOQG( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( Q-(!"#. 2A;6('&( J6&&65OM(39(XGO+*( -<=?CK(<=>R@<D?<H=( Q-():("*'. 2A;6(&&&( J6&&65+X(39(gg( .?A?FC_>?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 1"B$C(.=:5( /NF?6(&&&( J6&&65,(39(XO,5G( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 1"B$C(.=:5( /NF?6(&&&( J6&&6O(39(MQIXX( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( %&'()-*( /NF?6(&Y( J6&&6+I(39(MQI*M( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 7$-(]g^. 5,?N(%E=6( J6&&655M(39(MQ5OG( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( Q-(/!(:()2( !;6(&&&( J6&&6++(39(QX5X5( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( %&'(+'*('!( /NF?6(&&&( J6&&65X(39(QX5+Q( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( Q-(5'($. 2A;6(&&( J6&&65MQ(39(MOXQ5O( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( J=_=*".H@(/!(

:5("5$*(:(+'(/!.

7C@C=6( J6&&65GG(

U#(Q5++Q( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( ;'. 5*?N_XI?N(%E=6( J6&&65,M(U#(Q,,QG( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( BQC/!()*+( 2A;6(&&( J6&&65M+(U#(QMG*5( 2CK<CV(<=>R@<D?<H=( 09:"(:(!"B=C. .C?E(&( (U6Q5M*G(_(U6Q5M*O(_(U6Q5M*O((

.?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 1*(-$. 2A;6(&&( J6&&65MO(

U#(Q++II( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( 1($-5. 5,?N(%E=6(]!;6(&&&(_(4H@6^(

J6&&655I(

H39(XGOQG( )>?@ARH=( @. XI?N(%E=6(]g^( J6&&65,Q(

Page 614: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()$#(

( *,,(

D39(3G,IG*( "ADE@F>(HV(%&'(!2$( %&'(!2$@@( 2A;6(&&( J6&&65QM(3A<@H(g( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( %#*(:="( !;6(&&&( J6&&6+G(

(

#K_%A;AE<=(

#K_%A;AE<=( UA;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( @( 5*?N(%E=6( J6&&65OO((

#KCDNA=?<=C((

#KCDNA=?<=C( 9@AVV<?H( @. -A?C($C\(8<=W:H;(

J6&&65X5(

#KCDNA=?<=C(X( 9@AVV<?H( %#*(:"*$( 2A;6(&&( J6&&65M5((

#KPAT(

#KPAT(5( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( =-)(:5(%#2*( 5O?N(%E=6( J6&&6X(#KPAT(X( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( Q-()'8( /NF?6(&(_(4A?>6( J6&&6Q((

0KH@C=RC(

0KH@C=RC((&=B6(XG+G(

0AK>C(:HH@(<=>R@<D?<H=( 7)$*8(:5$. /NF?6(&&&(_(!;6(&&&6(

J6&&6+*(

(

9F@HT(

9F@HT( -C??C@( 09+8. !;6(&Y( J6&&6,*((

4<K:C>NC<;(

4<K:C>NC<;(QI5(

.?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( @. 5*?N(%E=6( J6&&65,5(

4<K:C>NC<;(5IOO(

.?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( H'=(09:". 5*?N(%E=6( J6&&65,X(

(

8A@=AP(

8A@=AP(5Q( `AKK(<=>R@<D?<H=( 09:"()*+. 2A;6(&'( J6&&65+,((

8NA@?HF;(7F>CF;(

8NA@?HF;(QQQ+(

&=>R@<TC:(>?CKA(V@H;(0A@A>( ;-*8(!( -A?C(5,?N(%E=6( J6&&655,(

8NA@?HF;(MI+5(

.?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( ;'8. 2A;6(&&&( J6&&65+G(

Page 615: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()$#(

( *,*(

8H;(CK_!N;A@(

8H;(CK_!N;A@( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( %&'(5#'$( .C?E(&( J6&&65XQ((

-C<:C=(

-C<:C=(Y(QM( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( %2=( /NF?6(&Y( J6&&6+5(-C<:C=(Y(5Q( ( H'(Q*). !;6(&&( J6&&6,+(-C<:C=(M65656MO(

>NAT?<(<=>R@<D?<H=( @. 5,_5*?N(%E=6( J6&&65XI(

(

-<BC@DHHK(7F>CF;(

-<BC@DHHK(7F>CF;((76(555+X(76(555,+(

"ADE@F>(7AEC@(!(A=:(J( Q-(5'. -A?C(5*?N(%E=6( J6&&65MM(

(

-HFB@Cc("A@<>(

-HFB@C(3(X+( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 09"(=*6&( /NF?6(&&&( J6&&65I(-HFB@C(!(G5( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( 09:"(:()-*( !;6(&&&( J6&&6,X(-HFB@C(3(Q*( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( =!). 5O?N(%E=6(g( J6&&65(-HFB@C(3(*X( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( /$('$. .C?E(&( J6&&65XG(-HBF@C(3(*+( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( P-3. 5*?N(%E=6( J6&&65O,(-HFB@C(3(5Q,( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( %&'()*+. 2A;6(&&( J6&&65Q5((

-EH=(

-EH=(,,( ( Q*)(:5$( !;6(&&&( J6&&6OX((

7AKPA?A(

7AKPA?A(5( ZA@_KATCK(<=>R@<D?<H=( H'8(Q*)( !;6(&&&( J6&&6OO((

7C:<=C?(4ATF(

7C:<=C?(4ATF(M(

/H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( Q-(5'. 2A;6(&&&( J6&&65+M(

(

7CW<::H(

7CW<::H( "C=(RA>C( %*#(09:". 2A;6(&&&( J6&&65+5((

Page 616: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()$#(

( **I(

7C;DN<>(

7C;DN<>( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( H'.+'.$'.0.9:"()*+(

!;6(&&&( J6&&65+,(

(

7C?@HDHK<?A=(7F>CF;(HV(0<=C(!@?>c($C\(dH@P(

77!(XM6,( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( ;'( 5,?N(%E=6( J6&&6555((

"C==>EKBA=<A(1=<BC@><?E(7F>CF;(

"C==>EKBA=<A(1=<BC@><?E(7F>CF;(#6(5I**I(

-<=?CK(<=>R@<D?<H=( 4"(*-($-*. 2A;6(&'( J6&&65O5((

(

"N<KA:CKDN<A(

"N<KA:CKDN<Ac(1=<B6(7F>CF;(#6(GMQ(

.?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( Q-(5'. 2A;6(&&( J6&&65GX(

(

"@<BA?C(RHKKCR?<H=>(

0ALHF>( UA;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( @( 5*?N(%E=6( J6&&65,X(.?6(0C@@<HK(RHKKCR?<H=((

.?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 45'(B"#*C( /NF?6(&&&( J6&&65O(

(

.ALLA@A(

.ALLA@A(5( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( H!=-( !;6(&&&( J6&&6O,(

.ALLA@A(X( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( ;'"(:()2( /F?6( J6&&65I5(

.ALLA@A(M( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( 1-(+-(='. 5,?N(%E=6( J6&&65IQ(

.ALLA@A(Q( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( H5. 2A;6(&&( J6&&65GO((

.C:;C=?(

.C:;C=?()&3(55OM5(

%HH@(<=>R@<D?<H=( Q-():("*'. 2A;6(&&( J6&&65G5(

(

.C;=A(

.C;=A(X((

-<=?CK(<=>R@<D?<H=( 4"B(*-C($!( 2A;6(&'( J6&&65+*(

(

Page 617: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()$#(

( **5(

.<CNC<K(

.CNCK( 9@AVV<?H( 09:"()*+( 2A;6(&&( J6&&65QX((

.<K><KCN(

.<K><KCN(55( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( 1"8("&'. !;6(&&6( J6&&6Q*(

.<K><KCN(5O( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( !:*$. 4A?>N6(_(/NF?6(&&&6(

J6&&6XI(

(

.<=A<(

.<=A<(XMQ( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( M'$6&. 5,?N(%E=6( J6&&655X(

.<=A<(MIX( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 123(.)*+. 2A;6(&'( J6&&65+O((

/A=<>(

/A=<>( !;FKC?(<=>R@<D?<H=( Q-(5'. 2A;6(&&( J6&&65MI((

/NCTC>(

//(55( $H@?NA;D?H=(>?CKA(( 7)$*8( /NF?6(&&&(_(4A?>6(( J6&&6XQ(//(5*( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( 09:"(:5B8C. 2A;6(&&( J6&&65GM(//(XM( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( <-8. 7C@C=6( J6&&65+5(//(XQ( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( %2(09:". /NF?6(&_&&( J6&&6M(//(M,( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( 75'(3-('(5"( /NF?6(&Y( J6&&6+X(//(QI( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( ;$8. /F?6( J6&&65IM(//(QM( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( 1*()'(#+T6&. 2A;6(&&&( J6&&65G,(//(QG( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( 7)$*8(:(#-2. 2A;6(&&( J6&&65QG(//(Q,( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( 09:"(:()-*. !;6(&&6( J6&&6G5(//(GM(]g^( 0F=C@A@E(RH=C(<=>R@<D?<H=( 09:"(:()-*. 4A?>N6(e(/NF?6(

&&&(J6&&6XX(

//(GG( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( /!(:5B=C$( !;6(&&&_&Y( J6&&6,Q(//(G+( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( 45'()-*( /NF?6(&&&(e(!;6(

&&(J6&&6MX(

//(GO( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( A!(:()-*( !;6(&&&( J6&&6OG(//(+M( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( 123()*+. /NF?6(&Y( J6&&6+M(//(+Q( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( ;3-('("))( /NF?;H>C(&Y( J6&&6GG(//(O5( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( 1"("(H$*( 4A?>6( J6&&6Q5(//(O5T( )>?@APH=(V@H;(?NC(?H;T(( 1"("(H$*( 4A?>6( J6&&6QX(//(OM( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( g. 4A?>6( J6&&6M*(//(OQ( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( <"$("8( /NF?6(&&&(e(!;6(

&&&(A=:(/NF?6(&Y(J6&&6M,(

//(O+( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( <"$"-. /NF?6(&Y( J6&&6G+(//(O,( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( ;'(:()2( /NF?6(&Y( J6&&6GO(//(,5( &=>R@<D?<H=(H=(>?CKA(V@H;(?NC(

?H;T((09""8( /NF?6(&f&&(_(

4A?>6(_(/NF?6(&&&(J6&&6+(

Page 618: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()$#(

( **X(

//(,X( 0F=C@A@E(RH=C>( 09:"(:()-*( /NF?6(&&&( J6&&65+(//(,Q( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( 09-:("D)( /NF?6(&( J6&&6*(//(,G( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( !9:"(:()2( /NF?6(&&&(e(!;6(

&&6(J6&&6MQ(

//(,+( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( H"(#+'(5"2( /NF?6(&&f&&&(_(!;6(&&(

J6&&6G(

//(,O( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( %#(H$". /NF?6(&&&6( J6&&65G(//(,,( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( QF(5$(#'. /NF?6(&&&(e(!;6(

&&(J6&&6X,(

//(*I( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( %2(09:"( /NF?;H>C(&Y( J6&&6G,(//(*X( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( 1$(:("$*( /NF?6(&&&(e(!;6(

&&(J6&&6M5(

//(*M( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( Z"(09:"( !;C=NH?CD(&&( J6&&6GX(//(*Q( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( Q-(5'. /NF?6(&&&(e(!;6(

&&6(J6&&6XO(

//(*G( 0F=C@A@E(RH=C>(( H'8. /NF?6(&&&_!;6(&&( J6&&6X*(//(*+( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( 09:"(:(=+*( /NF?6(&&&(e(!;6(

&&(J6&&6X+(

//(*O(( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( k9:"(:()-*( /NF?6(&&&(e(!;6(&&(

J6&&6MI(

//(**( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( 1"B=C("&'. 4A?>6( J6&&6Q,(//(5II( /NC(%F?<C>(HV(?NC(B<S<C@( /#(:=(/!( /NF?6(&&&(e(!;6(

&&(J6&&6MM(

//(5I5( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( <"($'$. !;6(&&( J6&&6GM(//(5I+( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( Q-(5'. .C?E(&( J6&&65X,(//(5IO( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( %&'(5#'\. !;6(&&&( J6&&6,G(//(55X( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( H"(#+'(/!(1"2. 5,?N(%E=6( J6&&655O(//(5XO( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( 1:(:(=-)( 4A?>6( J6&&6Q+(//(5M5( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( 09:"($5'. /NF?6(&&&(e(!;6(

&&(J6&&6M+(

//(5Q,( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( 09:"(:(=+*. 2A;6(&&&( J6&&65+Q(//(5,5( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( %2(09:".A=:(

09+$'(38(!;6(&&&( J6&&6O+(

//(5,M( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( %2(5$(:"$( 2A;6(&&( J6&&65M*(//(5,,( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( Q-('"("&'( !;6(&Y( J6&&6*I(//(5*X( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( M'B=C$6&( !;6(&&&_&Y( J6&&6O*(//(5*X(T( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=(_(4E;=(?H(

?NC(.F=(M'B=C$6&( !;6(&Y( J6&&6,I(

//(XII( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( 7DB8C. /NF?6(&&&(_(!;6(&&(

J6&&6XG(

//(X*G( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( 7)$*8(:5$. /NF?6(&Y(e(!;6(&&&6(

J6&&6+Q(

//(MGM( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( 1"("(H$*( 4A?>6( J6&&6M,(//(35( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( 09:"()*+. !;6(&&( J6&&6GI(/NCTC>(5( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 7$-('(")). 4A?>6(e(/NF?6(

&&&(J6&&6MG(

/NCTC>(X( "ADE@F>( 45('. /NF?6(&&&(e(!;6(&&(

J6&&6MO(

/NCTC>(M( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( 1"(H$*. 4A?>6( J6&&6QG((

Page 619: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()$#(

( **M(

/H:(

/H:( 9@AVV<?H( Q"(+-(*-. 2A;6(&&&( J6&&65G*((

/F@<=(7F>CF;(

/F@<=(]A^( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( Q-("$("8( /NF?6(&&&( J6&&65I(/F@<=(]T^( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( !-""( !;6(&&&( J6&&6OQ(/F@<=(GI( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( M'("2( !;6(&&&( J6&&6,O(/F@<=(XXIGM( )VVC@<=W(?ATKC( @.]5*?N(%E=6^( 5*?N(%E=6(]g^( J6&&65O*((

`A:<(CK_.CTFA(

`A:<(CK_.CTFA( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( 1*(-$. 2A;6(&&( J6&&65MX(((

1=P=H\=(

1=P=H\=( .?A?FC??C(<=>R@<D?<H=( ,-(:5B$C( !;C=NH?CD(&&&( J6&&6,M(1=P=H\=((

.?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( ;':$=-( .C?E(&( J6&&65O+(

((

YA@<HF>(

YA@<HF>( YH?<BC(<=>R@<D?<H=( %)8( /NF?6(&&&( J6&&65*((

Y<R?H@<A(7F>CF;(

Y<R?H@<A(7F>CF;(

%HH@_ZA;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( 09:"($!("K66L( 2A;6('&( J6&&65OQ(

(

lA\EC?(.FK?A=(

lA\EC?(.FK?A=( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( %&'(5'(F'$( 5*?N(%E=6( J6&&65OM((

(

=#-<+%+>'-<?-*'

/!012345' /3607(85(!4' /:53' 0:5'D4A@@<>(GII( /NC(%HH;C:("@<=RC( .C?E(&(e(2A;6(&&( J6&&&65(DJ7(5I5,M( /NC(/AKC(HV(?NC(/\H(J@H?NC@>(( 5*?N(%E=6( J6&&&6X(D3NC>?C@(JCA??E(&&(e(DJ7(5I+,X(

/NC(/AKC(HV(?NC(/\H(J@H?NC@>(_(RHKHDNH=(

7C@C=D?AN( J6&&&6M(

DJ7(5IQOQ( &=>?@FR?<H=(HV(09:"(:(=+*( 5*_XI?N(%E=6( J6&&&6Q((

Page 620: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()$#(

( **Q(

34!"/#2(M6(-!/#("#2&)%6(

(

!""#$#%&'()*$+#,-#.)*'

JFTA>?<>(

7!@:='(4607(85(!46(

(4607(85(!4( !9437( /:53( 0:5(

JFTA>?<>( /NC(3N@H=<RKC(HV("@<=RC()>H@PH=((

)>H@PH=c(d6(55_5X( 36&6M(

(

3A<@Hc(#WED?<A=(7F>CF;(

U#(QOI,G(e(QOI,+(e(QOI,O(e(QOI,,(e(QOI,*(A=:(JC@K<=(5I+,(

"<A=PNE(>?CKA(''Y(XM(5IG(( "<A=PNE(( 36&6G(

U#(M+MXO( !:HD?<H=(>?CKA(HV($<?HR@<>(( ">A;?CP(&&c(d6(*( 36&655(

U#(M,,+5( .?CKA(HV(/ANA@LA(( /ANA@LA( 36&6+(

U#(+OI*G( /A=<>(HV(">A;?CP(&&(( ">A;?CP(&&c(d6(M( 36&6*(

3A<@H(5M6+6XQ65(

#KCDNA=?<=C(>?CKA(HV(!;A><>(( !;A><>c(d6(M( 36&65Q(

3A<@H(.2(XQ5( .ALLA@A(>?CKA(HV(">A;?CP(&(( ">A;?CP(&c(d6(55( 36&65X(

(

%AN>NF@(

%AN>NF@( /ANA@LAk>(>?CKA(V@H;(%AN>NF@(%C>C@?(2HA:((

/ANA@LA( 36&6,(

(

9CTCKC<=(

9CTCKC<=( 2HRP(>?CKA(HV(.;C=:C>( .;C=:C>( 36&65((

( 9CTCK(JA@PAK( (

9CTCK(JA@PAK( .?CKA(HV("<A=PNE(=H6(X+( "<A=PNE( 36&6Q((

9CTCK(CK_.<K><KAN(

9CTCK(CK_.<K><KAN(5II(

.?CKA(HV(D@<=RC(09$(+$*.>C?(FD(<=(?NC(=A;C(HV(.NC>NH=L(&(

09$(+$*( .NC>NH=L(&( 36&6X(

(

Page 621: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()$#(

( **G(

-C<:C=(7F>CF;(

-C<:C=(

!765IO(

(

$AH>(HV(!;A><>(( !;A><>( 36&65+(

(

-HFB@Cc("A@<>(

-HFB@C(%(X*(

(

$AH>(HV(!;A><>(( !;A><>( 36&65G(

-HFB@C(#(MMMG(

(

.C@ADCF;(>?CKA(HV(">A;?CP(&(( ">A;?CP(&c(d6(GX( 36(&65M(

(

7C@H\C(7F>CF;((

7C@H\C(

7F>CF;(GI(

(

8A\A(>?CKA(&Y(( /ANA@LAc(d6(+( 36&6O(

((

.NCKKAK((

.NCKKAK(>?CKA((

(

.NCKKAK(>?CKA(HV(">A;?CP(&&( /ANA@LAc(d6(M( 36&65I(

(

(!:;<=<>?@A?<BC(:HRF;C=?>(

DJC@K<=(5M+5G( %C;H?<R(DADE@F>(JC@K<=(5M+5G( !;A><>c(d6(Q5( 36&65,(

D2EKA=:>(&'(

(

"C?<?<H=(HV("C:<C>C( !;A><>c(d6(Q5( 36&65O(

D6%C;6.AL6&c(?Ca?(5f5A((

"ADE@F>(.ALLA@A(&c(?Ca?(5f5A( O?N(?H(M@:(RC=?F@<C>(J63( 36&65*(

('

8+#;%-<'()*$+#,-#.)*'

JC@K<=(

JC@K<=(5OXOX( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( @( )>H@PH=(&&&( 36&&65,('

Page 622: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()$#(

( **+(

J@<?<>N(7F>CF;c(-H=:H=(

J7(#!(,M( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( Q&(!B$C(%*k>( !D@<C>( 36&&6MG(J7(#!(555(],5,^(

.?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( 4-)(=2(/!$( !;A><>( 36&&6QX(

J7(#!(5MM( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( %[(Q*)( ">A;?CP(&( 36&&6XQ(J7(#!(5MQ(],5*^(

.?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( M":$(=2(/!$(:"(

!;A><>( 36&&6Q*(

J7(5IIO( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( !"#('"+("&'( )>H@PH=(&&&( 36&&65*(J7(#!(5+Q+( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( %#*(;'$()2( ">A;?CP(&&( 36&&6M5(

(

3A<@H(

3A<@H(=H6(g( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( 1:-(*-$8(*&("#*(

">A;?CP(&( 36&&6X+(

3A<@H(=H6(g( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( !"#(;'$( CA@KE(X+?N(%E=6( 36&&6G5(3A<@H(=H6(&(MQ(+Q,(

/H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( Q-(D=("B=C(\5*( !;A><>( 36&&6QM(

3A<@H(=H6(&(MQ+Q,(

3HVV<=(<=>R@<D?<H=( Q-(D=("B=C(\5*( !;A><>( 36&&6QQ(

39(GG*( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( %>_p=>\_q\6V_r=s((

/APCKH?(&( 36&&6X(

3A<@H(=H6(g( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( 1:-(*-$8(*&("#*(

">A;?CP(&( 36&&6X+(

3A<@H(=H6(g( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( !"#(;'$( CA@KE(X+?N(%E=6( 36&&6G5(3A<@H(=H6(&(MQ(+Q,(

/H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( Q-(D=("B=C(\5*( !;A><>( 36&&6QM(

3A<@H(=H6(&(MQ+Q,(

3HVV<=(<=>R@<D?<H=( Q-(D=("B=C(\5*( !;A><>( 36&&6QQ(

39(GG*( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( %>_p=>\_q\6V_r=s((

/APCKH?(&( 36&&6X(

39(O,Q( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( Q5:*3( ">A;?CP(&&( 36&&6Q+(39(,IO( .?A?FC??C(<=>R@<D?<H=( ;'(='(/!( X+?N(%E=6( 36&&6GX(39(,,Q( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( 09:"(:(="*( .NC>NH=L(&&&(_(

4A@><C>C(J(36&&65M(

39(M*X5O[(U#(XG5QX(

.?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( 7D(7)$*8(=$6&(!"#(

XX_XM?N(%E=6( 36&&6XI(

39(M*XOG( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( %#*(;'$()2( ">A;?CP(&&( 36&&6MM(39(QXX5Mm(U#(MOQX*m(8A@=AP(3ARNC??C(=H6(5GQ(

.?A?FC(<=>R<D?<H=( PK-3L("(A"5$( )>H@PH=(&&( 36&&6+(

39(QXXIOm(U#(M+*M5m(8A@=AP(3ARNC??C(=H6(5GX(

.?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( 7D(7)$*8(=$6&(!"#((

)>H@PH=(&&(e(4A@><C>C(!(

36&&6Q(

3A<@H(39(QXX55m(U#(MO5G*m(8A@=AP(3ARNC??C(=H6(

.?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( %#*6&(H$*( )>H@PH=(&&&(e(/APCKH?(&&&(

36&&65O(

Page 623: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()$#(

( **O(

MO,(39(QXX5,m(U#(MO5GGm(8A@=AP(3ARNC??C(=H6(Q+*(

.?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( Q-(D=(H$*. )>H@PH=(&&(e(/APCKH?(&&(

36&&6,(

39(QXXXIm(U#(M+O5Im(8A@=AP(3ARNC??C(=H6(X5(

.?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( 7D(H$*(=$6&(!"#.

)>H@PH=(&&(e(/APCKH?(&&(

36&&6*(

39(QXXX5m(U#(M+*5*m(8A@=AP(3ARNC??C(=H6(5XX(

.?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( %5(+-(/!. )>H@PH=(&&(e(/APCKH?(&&(

36&&6O(

39(QXXXGm(U#(MOGX5m(8A@=AP(3ARNC??C(=H6(MQO(

.?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( %2("*'$( )>H@PH=(&&(_(4A@><C>C(!(

36&&6M(

39(QXXX+m(U#(M+GOGm(8A@=AP(3ARNC??C(=H6(X(

.?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( ;'$( "C?FTA>?<>(&&( 36&&65G(

39(QXXMIm(U#(M+OI+m(8A@=AP(3ARNC??C(=H6(,5(

.?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( 09:"(:(="*( /APCKH?(&&( 36&&65I(

39(QXXMXm(U#(M+++Gm(8A@=AP(3ARNC??C(=H6(**(

.?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( @( .NC>NH=L(&&&(_(4A@><C>C(J(

36&&65X(

U#(MOGXO( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( 7D(7)$*8(=$6&(!"#(

)>H@PH=(&( 36&&65(

U#(QMO55( .?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( Q-(D=(;'$B(+C]Q-(D=(;'(:D"(

">A;?CP(&( 36&&6XX(

D39(M55+O( "ADE@F>(3A<@H(39(M55+O( /CH>(g( X+?N(%E=6( 36&&6GQ('

%APNKCN(

%APNKCN(>?CKA((

.?CKA(<=>R@<D?<H=( @( XX?N(%E=6( 36&&65Q(

'

8A@=AP(

8A@=AP(/(MG( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( H'8(09:".45'3*".

)>H@PH=(&&( 36&&6G(

!==AKC>(HV(?NC("@<=RC()>H@PH=(

&=>R@<D?<H=( "@<=RC()>H@PH=.

"C?FTA>?<>(&( 36&&65+(

'

Page 624: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()$#(

( **,(

YA@<HF>(

!#&$(5+Q,(n(JHKHW=A(8.(5,M,(

.?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( %3-$. ">A;?CP(&&(e($CPAH(&&(

36&&6MQ(

7H>LFC(GOQI(n(J@HHPKE=(-(O,6Q+6X(

.?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( 09!)(:5B(5-(%*C. !;A><>( 36&&6M,(

-HFB@C(#(XG(M*I(n(J@HHPKE=($d(G*6OO(

)VVC@<=W_>KAT(<=>R@<D?<H=( 09!)(:5B(5-(%*C. !;A><>( 36&&6Q5(

(

-HFB@C(

-HFB@C(!(,M( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( P"*(;'( $CPAH(&&( 36&&6XO(-HFB@C(!(*M( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( Q-&(*-$B(:C(

!$(%*(!;A><>( 36&&6MO(

-HFB@C(!(*Q( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( %#*(;'$()2( ">A;?CP(&&( 36&&6MI(-HFB@C(%(GI( )VVC@<=W_>KAT(<=>R@<D?<H=( 09!)(:5B(5-(%*C( !;A><>( 36&&6QI(-HFB@C(%(+G(]t(U#(M,+O^(

)VVC@<=W_>KAT(<=>R@<D?<H=( ;'$(='(!-( ">A;?CP(&&f!D@<C>(

36&&6X,(

'

7<?_2AN<=A(

7<?_2AN<=Ac(.?H@C_NHF>C(=H6(GQG(

.?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( Q-&(*-$B(:C(!$(%*(

!D@<C>( 36&&6M+(

'

"N<KA:CKDN<Ac(1=<BC@><?E(7F>CF;(

"N<KA:CKDN<Ac(1=<BC@><?E(7F>CF;(=H6(QX6*5(

.?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( Q5:*3(5-(%*( !D@<C>( 36&&6Q,(

'

2A;C>>CF;(

2A;C>>CF;( 3NADCK(<=>R@<D?<H=( ;'$(5-(-5*( /APCKH?(&&( 36&&655('

.ALLA@A(

.ALLA@A(-(XQ( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( P-3("('"&( ">A;?CP(&( 36&&6X5(

.ALLA@A(]A^( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( Q5:*3( !;A><>( 36&&6QG(

.ALLA@A(]T^( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( Q5:*3( !;A><>( 36&&6QO(

.ALLA@A(]R^( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( ;?-(:(5-6&( !;A><>( 36&&6GI('

Page 625: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()$#(

( ***(

.?HRPNHK;(

.?HRPNHK;(=H6(765((

.A@RHDNAWF>(<=>R@<D?<H=( 09!)(:5B(5-(%*C( ">A;?CP(&( 36&&6M*(

'

/A=?A(

/A=?A(XG( .?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( 1:-(*-$8(*&("#*(

">A;?CP(&( 36&&6XG(

(

/NCTC>(

//(5X,( /H;T(<=>R@<D?<H=( Q-(*"&=( ">A;?CP(&( 36&&6XM('

/F@<=(7F>CF;(

/F@<=(XXI5( 3HVV<=(<=>R@<D?<H=( @( X+?N(%E=6( 36&&6GM('

YA?<RA=(

YA?<RA=(=H6(5QI((

.?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( %#*(;'$()2( ">A;?CP(&&( 36&&6GM(

YA?<RA=(=H6(5++((

.?A?FC(<=>R@<D?<H=( Q5:*3(5"2( ">A;?CP(&&( 36&&6GM(

'

'

=#-<+%+>'5<?-*'

J@HHPKE=(7F>CF;(

DJ@HHPKE=(QO6X5,65MG(

`<>:H;(?Ca?(<=("ADE@F>(J@HHPKE=(QO6X5,65MG(

@( G?N(H@(Q?N(RC=?F@E(

36&&&6X(

'

J@<?<>N(7F>CF;(

DJ7(#!(5IGI,( &=>?@FR?<H=>(HV(!"#(GT"?8( @( 1=RC@?A<=( 36&&&65((

(

( (

Page 626: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()$#(

( 5III(

-<>?(HV(!TT@CB<A?<H=>[((

(

!>><F?[(3H:<=W(>E>?C;(TA>C:(H=(?NC(>CLFC=RC(=F;TC@(HV(C=?@<C>(V@H;(!>><F?6(

JC=<(4A>A=[($F;TC@<=W(.E>?C;(V@H;($C\TC@@E(5*,M6(

JC@>NCN[($F;TC@<=W(>E>?C;(V@H;($C\TC@@E(5*,G6((

JC@K<=[($F;TC@<=W(>E>?C;(HV(?NC(#WED?<A=(7F>CF;(<=(JC@K<=6(

J7[($F;TC@<=W(>E>?C;(HV(?NC(J@<?<>N(7F>CF;(&=(-H=:H=6(

J70![(7F>CF;(HV(0<=C(!@?>(JH>?H=6(

3KCBCKA=:[($F;TC@<=W(>E>?C;(HV(?NC(3KCBCKA=:(7F>CF;(HV(!@?6(

39[($F;TC@<=W(>E>?C;(HV(?NC(^_*_`XNaV.>b"b'_`V.DV5.c"*EdaE*b5.Da.Ha5bV.Da.^_E'V(V@H;(

-A=WC(e(.RNuVC@(5*IX_XG6(

3N<RAWH[($F;TC@<=W(>E>?C;(HV(?NC()@<C=?AK(&=>?<?F?C(HV(3N<RAWH6(

%C<@(2<VCN[($F;TC@<=W(>E>?C;(TA>C:(H=(?NC(>CLFC=RC(HV(?NC(?H;T>(A?(%C<@(2<VCN6(

%F@NA;[($F;TC@<=W(>E>?C;(V@H;(/NC()@<C=?AK(7F>CF;(<=(%F@NA;c(186(

#:VF[($F;TC@<=W(>E>?C;(V@H;(!KK<H?(5*MG6(

9-(`!0[($F;TC@<=W(>E>?C;(HV(?NC(9KED?H?NCP(<=(7v=RNC=6(

4A;;A;A?[($F;TC@<=W(>E>?C;(V@H;(3HFEA?(e(7H=?C?(5*5X6(

4A;;A;A?(9[($F;TC@<=W(>E>?C;(V@H;(9HEH=(5*GO6(

4A?=FT[($F;TC@<=W(>E>?C;(V@H;(!=?NC>(5*X,6(

4CLA<T[($F;TC@<=W(>E>?C;(V@H;(4ATARN<(5*,G6(

-C<:C=[($F;TC@<=W(>E>?C;(HV(?NC($<C:C@Ku=:<>RNC=(2C<RN>;F>CF;>(:C@(!K?C@?v;C@(<=(

-C<:C=6(]JHC>C@(5*IG_MX^(

-HFB@C[($F;TC@<=W(>E>?C;(V@H;(?NC(7F>jC(:F(-HFB@Cc("A@<>6(]9AEC?(5,,*6("<C@@C?(5,OQ_O,^(

77![($F;TC@<=W(>E>?C;(V@H;(?NC(7C?@HDHK<?A=(7F>CF;(HV(!@?6(

;7A=RN[($F;TC@<=W(>E>?C;(HV(?NC(7A=RNC>?C@(7F>CF;6(

7F>jC(9F<;C?[($F;TC@<=W(>E>?C;(HV(7F>jC(9F<;C?c(7F>jC(=A?<H=AK(0@A=wA<>(:C>(A@?>(

A><A?<LFC>(<=("A@<>6(7H@C?(5*I*6(

)a!>N;(]Ca()aVH@:(bFCC=>(3HKKCWC(7F>CF;(t(b3^[($F;TC@<=W(>E>?C;(HV(?NC(!>N;HKCA=(

7F>CF;c()aVH@:6(

Page 627: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()$#(

( 5II5(

"<??>TF@WN[($F;TC@<=W(>E>?C;(HV(?NC(3A@=CW<C(7F>CF;(HV("<??>TF@WN6(

"N<KA:CKDN<A[($F;TC@<=W(>E>?C;(HV(?NC(1=<BC@><?E(HV("C==>EKBA=<A(7F>CF;(HV(!@RNACHKHWE(

A=:(!=?N@HDHKHWE6(

2&8[($F;TC@<=W(.E>?C;(V@H;(TA>C:(H=(?NC(>CLFC=RC(HV(?NC(2HRP(&=>R@<D?<H=(HV(8F;=A6(

%F=NA;(e(UA==>C=(5*+I6(

.ALLA@A[($F;TC@<=W(>E>?C;(TA>C:(H=(?NC(>CLFC=RC(?H;T>(A?(.ALLA@A6(

.<=A<[($F;TC@<=W(>E>?C;(V@H;("CC?(e(xC@=E(5*GX6(

.NA??(C@(2<WAK[($F;TC@<=W(>E>?C;(TA>C:(H=(?NC(>CLFC=RC(?H;T>(A?(.NA??(C@(2<WAK6(

/NCTC>[(.ALLA@A[($F;TC@<=W(>E>?C;(TA>C:(H=(?NC(>CLFC=RC(?H;T>(A?(/NCTC>6(

/F@<=[($F;TC@<=W(>E>?C;(HV(?NC(#WED?<A=(7F>CF;(<=(/F@<=6(

13[($F;TC@<=W(>E>?C;(V@H;(?NC(1=<BC@><?E(3HKKCWC(HV(-H=:H=6(

(

(

Page 628: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!

Page 629: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,--.(

!""#$%&'()*+(/0$+"/&/(+1()2#(3/!4#(+1()2#(#40")&!$(*+5%/(15+(6"!7!8#9:(

(

/;<=>?@?(=A(BCD(E?FGD(=A(BCD(BDHI(!"! +J<DH! %=KEID<B! 8FBFL=G(HDADHD<KD?!

((M:5:! ((($:5:! 7:":!

#N>HD??@=<?( ( ( ( #( 7( #( 7( #( 7(

##$%&$#'()("*+(,(!"$-(#%#$%$-(*+.(/012*()(3#0(%(402*(3#0(+15*(6782(3#0(,25(9%:;02(

&(HDBEH<DO(@<(>DFKD(B=(C@?(!":(&(PH=EGCB(B=(C@I(BCD(PD?B(=A(BCD(A=HD@G<(LF<O?(@<(<DJ(IDBFL(=A(402*Q(?C@<@<G(IDBFL(=A(6782Q(CFHO(IDBFL(=A(9%:;02(

!"0*.(R,SBC(%;<:T( ))(UV( !:&&:,V,( ( N( ( ( ( (

#!3(%(<%3*(%*(!"(,(5#("12(&='(/-*2(58%$#(/-*2("12*(/+,*()(&%12*'(30"(5+*(,(%*(%12*(51$-(

W*CD<X(JDHD(K=LLDKBDO(RYT(BCD(<%3*(=A(BCD(!"(A=H(FJFHO@<G(>HF@?DZAF[=HQ(D\EFL(RYT(JF?(I;(F>>H=[FL(RYT(B=(BCD(>HF@?D?ZAF[=H?(BCFB(B==](>LFKD(@<(BCD(RH=;FLT(>HD?D<KD:(R=HT(BCD(EBBDHF<KD(=A(BCD(]@<G(C@I?DLA(

>%)2:"*+(R!I:(&&(^(/D?:(&&T(

_D<@(2F?F<(S( !:&&:V,( N( ( ( ( ( (

#2(!<$%$#(;%"(!"()(51,2$1( &(D<BDHDO(@<(BCD(!"(@<(@B?(?FKHDO(>LFKD?((

4?0;@:%:A%12((R+?=H]=<(&&T(

84(`..,Sa(b#(Sc`.da(eFH<F](8FKCDBBD(<=:(,V`(

8:&&:U( ( ( ( ( N( (

#2(25(%3$#(*12(30;(#)(,(1),(*+(%(!"(

M;(7=HO(K=IIF<ODO(BCFB(C@?(?DH[F<B(?C=ELO(PD(DLD[FBDO(B=(RBCD(HF<](=AT(A@H?B(K=I>F<@=<(=A(BCD(!"(

B0:1,(R/DB;(&(f(5FI:(&&T(

))(,-U( _:&&:,.g( ( ( ( N( ( (

#2("12*$#()%*#()(!"(),2*$#(/,(C%2*(

M;(>HF@?D(JF?(>DHIF<D<B(@<(BCD(!"Q(F<O(I;(L=[D(JF?(J@BC(BCD(K=EHB@DH?(

67%%.(R!I:(&(f(2FB?C:T(

))(g,( _:&&:U( ( ( N( ( ( (

#2(/+,(%$;(#1()(15*.(")$-(520&*'(2!(%(!"(

0=E(CF[D(@<ODDO(GH=J<(E>(F?(F(A=?BDH^?=<(=A(I;(IFhD?B;(F<O(?=LD(>E>@L(=A(BCD(!"(

67.:8,:%-,*(R/D?:(&&&T( _DHL@<(,.-`( !:&&:U,( ( ( ( ( ( (

#2(55$*2(%$;(1/,&2'(*02.(%3(#2$;("*+$*2()(!"(!%/(250(1%3(

0=E(RBCD("CFHF=CT(HDADH(BCD(K=<O@B@=<(=A(D[DH;(K=E<BH;(JC@L?B(;=EH(FHB(HD?B?(@<(BCD(!"D(L:(>:(C:(

=(R/DB;(&T( >!<F?BF?@(&i( _:&:U.( ( ( ( N( ( (

#2$-(&%12*='(!02()(!"(#%(30;(*+.(%(67*%()(+,:67*%()(0/%:67*%(?B0:%"1.()0!:/,2@(

+<D( JC=( @?( CDFLBC;( JCD<( CD( @?( ?FB@?A@DO( F<O(D[DH;(LF<O(@?(LFOD<(J@BC(h=;(JC@LD(FKKLFIFB@=<(@?(O=<D(@<(BCD(+,:%12*(F<O(>=JDH(K=ID(B=(>F??(@<(BCD(!"(

B0^%"1.(R!I:(&iT( !)(U( _:&&:d`( ( ( N( ( ( (

Page 630: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,--S(

?$$@(#2$-()("*+2(*0(%3(8,(,C2(#,2(?$$@()(+,:%12*(/+,(21,()(!"(

R)CD( ]@<GYT( @?( IFG<@A@DO( @<( BCD( !"( P;( BCD( A@H?B(?DH[F<B(=A(BCD(!BD<(@<(BCD(2=E?D(=A(0/%:67*%(WB0:%"1.(hE?B@A@DOX(

B0^%"1.(R!I:(&iT( !)(U( _:&&:d`( ( ( N( ( ( (

#2$-("*+(,(!"$-(%(1/)/:#3(2%2*(%*,("2*()("!!2*(

2D(D<BDH?(@<(>DFKD(@<B=(C@?(!"(=A(%DL@GCBQ(BCD(>H@D?BC==O(=A(BCD(BDI>LD(PD@<G(@<(GLFO<D??(

E3:+2:F1,*:1%(R!I:(&&&T(

_M(,cV(W,-,X( !:&&:Ud( N( ( ( ( ( (

#3$#(,(2,2(#).2(!"( M;(CDFHB(@?(B=(BCD(GHDFB?(JC=(PDL=<G(B=(BCD(!"( 67%%.(R!I:(&(f(2FB?C:T(

))(g,( _:&&:U( ( ( N( ( ( (

#).(!"$-(2020("".(0/2(,(/2#("2*$-(%(G0:2,(

2D(JC=(JF?(@<(C@?(!"(B==](K=E<?DL(F?(=<D(JC=(?DFHKCDO(A=H(PD<DAFKB@=<?Q(B=(K=<?BHEKB(C@?(BDI>LD(A=H(BCD()C@<@BD($=ID(

5FI:(&&( !P;O=?(V( _:&:``( ( ( ( N( ( (

#).:,(%#2*(*0*.(1),2(%12*(/*)2(!"(&$$'(#2()(20"(8,(#%2(

)CD(=[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(K@B;Q(BCD([@j@DHQ(BCD(H=;FL(K=I>F<@=<?Q(?DFLDH?(=A(BCD(!"(&$$'(JC=(K=ID(@<(=PD@?F<KDQ(PDFH@<G(BCD@H(BH@PEBD($$(

5FI:(&&( 7EN=H(,( _:&:`V( ( ( ( N( ( (

67)%(2#(10$-(8,("0*$-(,(!"(,(1)%(/!2$-(",.:*+$-(,(1<0&#'(!"!2$-()#:<5$-(

!IE<(@?(K=IDQ(C@?(?=<(@<(AH=<B(=A(C@IQ(B=(BCD(!"(@<(=HODH(B=(D?BFPL@?C(C@?(KH=J<(E>=<(C@?(CDFO(F<O(@<(=HODH(B=(>H=L=<G(C@?(>DH@=O(L@]D(B=(C@I?DLA(

2=HDICDP( >)EH@<(^8=H=<FB@=<()DNB(=A(2=HDICDP(

_:&:.V( ( ( N( ( ( (

67)%():!(%*(#1#(67)%(#2(12$-(8,("0*$-(,(!"(,(1)%*(/!2$-(",(*+$-(,(1<0#$-(!"!2$-(

!IE<Q(PDC=LO(!IE<(K=ID?Q(JC@B(C@?(?=<(@<(AH=<B(=A(C@IQ(B=(BCD(!"D(B=(D?BFPL@?C(BCD(KH=J<?(=[DH(C@?(CDFOQ(F<O(IF]@<G(L=<G(BCD(>DH@=O(=A(C@?(L@AD(

2=HDICDP( MDI>C@?(,( _:&:S-( ( ( N( ( ( (

#)%*(#03*(*02("*+2(",.:#3(",(8*$1%(%(1%5$-(",(,5#*(<)0(/*$1%(,(32(")$-()#(%512(%*(!"*(

)CD( *D?B( F<O( BCD( #F?B( F<O( BCD( LF<O?( =A( BCD(KD<BHD( FHD( ALFB^PDLL;( A=H( ADFH( =A( @BQ( IF]@<G(=AADH@<G?( =A( BCD@H( G==O?( @<( BCD( >LFKD( =A( 2@?(MFhD?B;(F?(BCD(>==H(ID<(=A(BCD(!"&*'(

"@F<]C;( b#(`c-gV^`c-gU^`c-gc^`c-gg^`c-gd(_DHL@<(,-Ug(

8:&:V( ( ( ( ( N( (

#)*$%$-(2#(,(#).(!"( 2D(W5F(2FHF]BDX(AF?C@=<DO(ID(F?(F(OJDLLDH(=A(BCD(!"(

/D?:(&( /D?=?BH@?(&( >_DHL@<(S-.d( N( ( ( ( ( (

#%(,1(%3*(*02.()(8%2(51,2(%2(!"$1(

)CD(7FO;(=A(BCD()J=(7F<O?(KFID(AH=I(@<?@OD(BCD(?>LD<O=H?(=A(CDH(k"(

2FB?C:( eFH<F](U( _:&:d( ( ( N( ( ( (

#%#(1?*(F1#,:/%*:#)%*(%3@(F1#,(0352(%(!"$-(

&(PH=EGCB(W+?@H@?(eCD<BFID<BCD?Q(7=HO(=AX(!P;O=?Q(B=(C@?(!"(

67.:8,:%-,*(R/D?:(&&&T( _DHL@<(,.-`( !:&&:U,( N( ( ( ( ( (

#%2$1%(#!3(&,'(!"(%12*(3#*.( )CD@H(R!?@FB@K(K=E<BH@D?lT(#%2(PD@<G(E<@BD(A=H(BCD( /D?:(&&&( MDOFIEO(.U( !:&:,-( N( ( ( ( ( (

Page 631: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,--`(

!"(=A(BCD(]@<G(=A(3>>DH(F<O(7=JDH(#G;>B(#%;(30;()0!(%(,:+,(+%(#%;(1,5#(1+,(%3(%(%*,("2*(*%(,(8%2(!"(

&(FI(BCD(BHED(?DH[F<B(=A(BCD(?F<KBEFH;Q(@B(@?(ID(JC=(IF]D(FHH@[D(D[DH;(HD\ED?B(=A(BCD(BDI>LD(B=(BCD(@<?@OD(=A(BCD(!"(

!%/:>,2(R.UBC(%;<:T(

8F@H=(Y( 8:&&:V,( ( ( ( ( N( (

#%;(?30;@(130&2'(%(")$-()(?51$-@()(21/*(H$)0!*.(5*(!"(

W&( JF?X( F( W?EP=HO@<FBDZ?DH[F<BYX( JC=I( 2@?(MFhD?B;( WC@I?DLAX( @<?BHEKBDO( @<( BCD( CFLL( =A( BCD()J@<()HEBC?Q(RF?T(F(JFHO(=A(BCD(!"(

I*:02(R5FI:(&&T( b:`,SdV(R?BDLFT(b:`,Sdc(RL@<BDLT(b:`,Sdc(RhFIPT(

_:&&:,Sc( ( ( ( N( ( (

#%;(+2(1%5)$%$#()(!"( &B(JF?(ID(JC=(D<h=;DO(I;?DLA(@<(BCD(!"( 2FB?C:( eFH<F](S( _:&:,S( ( ( N( ( ( (#%;(%3(%)**(&)'(!"&*'(51,*( &(JF?(AHDD(=A(?BD>?(@<(BCD(?FKHDO(!"&*'( !%/:,%+:%-,(

R+?=H]=<(&&&T(_M(,--c( 8:&&:,d( ( ( ( ( N( (

#,(8+2(%(#).:,(!"( 5D?>DKB@<G(BCD(LFJ?(=A(BCD(=[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(!"( l7)%:"*+(R!I:(&&&T( 84(VgS( _:&&:cS( ( ( N( ( ( (#,("112*J"11*(#).(!"( +<D(JC=(IF]D?(>HF@?D?ZAF[=H?(@<(BCD(!"( I2:):%2*(R)CEB:(

&&&(f(!I:(&&T())(d.( _:&&:S,( ( ( N( ( ( (

#,*(%$-(RBCD(G=OT(2,JC+1#J2!3(!"(( )CD(IF]@<G(A=H(C@I(=A(F<(FEGE?BZI@GCB;Z<DJ(!"( /DB;(&((5FI:(&&(

!P;O=?(,((5FID??DEI(

_:&:S.((_:&:`g(

( ( ( N( ( (

#,*(%$1%(!"(C+1#()("2*(&1'/)(%*,2(2%%(1%("*+()(#%3(

)CD(IF]@<G(A=H(BCDI(RG=O?(F<O(G=OOD??DOT(=A(F<(FEGE?B(!"(F?(F(BDI>LD(F<O(RFHKC@BDKBEHFLT(@IFGD(A=H(BCD(G=O?(JCD<(BCD;(HD?B(@<?@OD(BCD(JFLL?(

/DB;(&( mEH<F(,( _:&:SV( ( ( ( N( ( (

#,$#("1#(>,()(!"$-((

&(O@O(F?(BCD(2=HE?(>HF@?DO(@<(C@?(!"(( E3:%*,2(R+?=H]=<(&&(^(2FH?@D?D(!T(

84(`...Va(b#(ScV.,a(eFH<F](8FKCDBBD(<=:(S`c(

8:&&:S( ( ( ( ( N( (

#,$%$;(!"(C+1#(%12*()(8%2$1( &(CF[D(O=<D(F(<=PLD(!"(H=;FL(@<?@OD(@B(RBCD(BDI>LDT(

=(R5FI:(&&&T( >2FHH@?(&( _:&:cS( ( ( ( N( ( (

#1*(")$-()(!"$-((K).&*'()(+,:!0(!%/:/+,:;0:L!()#(L!()(8%2(+*(

)CD<(2@?(MFhD?B;(@?(@<(C@?(!"Q(D?BFBD(=A(!%/:/+,:;0:L!(R)EBCI=?@?(&TQ(L@]D(5F(@<(BCD(8%2(=A(BCD(?];(

)EB:( 84(`,VUV( _:&:.S( ( ( N( ( ( (

!0(%12*()()#**(L!(,5(!"*(21/*$-( )CD(GHDFB(]@<G(GH=J?(L@]D(5F(@<(C@?(!"(21/*( 5FI:(&&( MDO@<DB(2FPE(,( _:&:VV( ( ( ( N( ( (!<()(!"()(51,2$1((

+<D(JC=(D<BDH?(BCD(!"(@<(@B?(>H@[FBD(>LFKD?((

E3:%*,2(R(+?=H]=<(&&(^(2FH?@D?D(!T(

84(`...Va(b#(ScV.,a(eFH<F](8FKCDBBD(<=:(S`c(

8:&&:S( ( ( ( ( N( (

Page 632: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,--V(

!<("1#(?+,#@(?5#@(*,.*(%(#).(!"( #<BDH@<G(AF[=HDO(WG@[@<GX(HD?>DKB?(B=(BC=?D(JC=(FHD(@<(BCD(!"(

G%:2,2(R!I:(&&T( ))(,-,( _:&&:VS( ( ( N( ( ( (

!<(8%(!"( +<D(JC=(D<BDH?(@<(BCD(!"( 67%*-(RMD<:(&&T( Ie=>D<FGCD<($84(!#&$(gd,(

!:&&:U( N( ( ( ( ( (

!<(,(!"(2,2()(,2*.$1( #<BDH@<G(@<(BCD(!"D(BCD(GHDFB?(RPD@<GT(FB(@B?(GFBD( E/*$-:92*(R+?=H]=<(&&&(f()F]DL=B(&&&T(

8F@H=(84(`..,,a(b#(Sc,Vda(eFH<F](8FKCDBBD(<=:(Scg(

8:&&:,c( ( ( ( ( N( (

!<(,(!"(+,#(8,("12*( +<D(JC=(D<BDH?(@<(BCD(!"(F<O(K=ID?(=EB(J@BC(AF[=H?Z>HF@?D?(

M,&#'2$-(R!I:(&&&^&iT((L!:)1&#'2(R!I:(&&&^&iT((B0:,%:%-,(R!I:(&iT(

))(,d.((())(VV((())(,gg((

_:&&:cd(((_:&&:g`(((_:&&:d-(

( ( N( ( ( (

!<(,(!"()0!(%*,(%-,( +<D(JC=(D<BDH?(@<(BCD(!"(F<O(?DD?(BCD(G==O(G=O( L2:,2(R/DB;(&T( 7=E[HD(8(d.( _:&&:,.V( ( ( ( N( ( (!<(")$-(,(/%*(!"(%(%%(20#:,$-(+,:67)%(((

2@?( MFhD?B;( RBCD( G=OT( D<BDH?( @<B=( BCD( AH=<B( =A(BCD(!"(<FIDO((%%(20#:,$-Q(C=E?D(=A(!IE<(

2FB?C:( eFH<F](U( _:&:d( ( ( N( ( ( (

!<$#()(!"(2,.2()(,2*.$1( &(D<BDH(@<(BCD(!"(JC@LD(BCD(LFHGD(HDIF@<(=EB?@OD((

E1:+0:L!(R+?=H]=<(&&(f()F]DL=B(&&T(

8F@H=(84(`...,a(b#(SUd,da(eFH<F](8FKCDBBD(<=:(,..(

8:&&:c( ( ( ( ( N( (

!<$#(,(!"( &(D<BDH(@<(BCD(!"( 9,(+,(2,((6(7)%:"*+(R!I:(&&&T(

MDI>C@?( _:&&:Ug( ( ( N( ( ( (

!"(%3(*02.( !"(=A(BCD(7=HO(=A(BCD()J=(7F<O?( )EB:( 84(`,VUV( _:&:.S( ( ( N( ( ( (

!"$-()(+,:"!#( 2@?(!"(@<(BCD(2=E?D(=A(5Dh=@KD( M,&#'2$-(R!I:(&&&^&iT(

))(,d.( _:&&:cd( ( ( N( ( ( (

2%%$%$#(#1()(",.:*+(%(!"&*'(/,+2(#1(%(,/.2*(

&( JF?( FB( BCD( CDFO( =A( BCD( !"&*'D( F( GE@OD( B=( BCD(?EPhDKB?(=A(BCD(e@<G(

>,2(R"DBEPF?B@?(&T( 84(`...Ua(b#(SUVcVa(eFH<F](8FKCDBBD(<=:(.(

8:&&:,V( ( ( ( ( N( (

2%%(")$-()(!"$-(E#*&.'(",(%5(1/,(%(*0(,(5,$-(

2@?(MFhD?B;(JF?(@<(C@?(k"(=A(E#*&.'(B=(>H=BDKB(BCD(A=HBE<D(=A(BCD(JC=LD(7F<O(

!IF?@?( 8F@H=(,S:U:.`:,( 8:&:,`( ( ( ( ( N( (

Page 633: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,--U(

2%$#%(")(E3:,:5,(1/5$%(",$-(,(#03*(",(3#0.*(,(1302.(#)%*(!"(%(21/*(%*(%%(20#:,$-(%*.(",()0!(%(*+(#*,2(

)CD<(BCD(MFhD?B;Q(7=HO(=A(BCD(3<@[DH?D(CFO(C@?(CDFO(@<KL@<DO(B=(BCD(DF?B(IF]@<G(F<(=HFKLD(B=(BCD(JD?BDH<(O=EPLD(GFBD(=A(BCD(!"(@<(BCD(CFLL(=A(%%(20#:,$-Q(JC@KC(@?(=<(BCD(PF<](=A(BCD(CDFO(=A(BCD(H@[DH(

2FB?C:((2FB?C:(

eFH<F](U((%D@H(DL^_FCFH@(,(

_:&:d((_:&:,-(

( ( ( ( ( (

2")("12*(%(>,2()(!"(",.&*'$%$#(

5D>DFBDO(AF[=H?(A=H(2=HE?(@<(BCD(!"(RA=H(JCFBT(&(CFO(O=<D(

N5:N"2*.:#2$-:!%/(R..BC^.SBC(%;<:T(

84(Sd.,cn(b#(.V,`.(

8:&&:.-( ( ( ( ( N( (

250(!"( "H=?>DH=E?(!"( 67%:#*$-(R)CEB:(&&&T( 7=E[HD(8(.U( _:&&:,-( ( ( N( ( ( (

32(5#$#(8,(3#%()(8*$#(#2$#()*$-()(!"()(?$$@("1.2$-(

&(O=(<=B(?DB(JH=<G^O=@<G(@<(I;(@<<DHI=?B(PD@<G(JCD<( &( FI( PDA=HD( C@I( @<( BCD( !"Q( @<( BCD(WK=I>F<;YX(=A(BCD(1F[=H@BD?(

G2:*2(R!I:(&iT( !)(g( _:&&:dU( ( ( N( ( ( (

31(#%;(,(!"&*'()(/!#&*'(%12*(O,(!%/(%3(%(F1,(

&( JF?( @<BH=OEKDO( @<B=( BCD( !"&*'( FB( BCD(F>>DFHF<KD( =A( BCD( ]@<G( J@BC( F( P=E\EDB( =A( BCD(7=HO(=A()CDPD?(

67)%:):#%*(R)F]DL=B(&&T(

84(`..S-a(b#(SUc-Ua(eFH<F](8FKCDBBD(<=:(g,(

8:&&:,-( ( ( ( ( N( (

31$%$-(,(!"()(51,2$1( W!IE<X( PH=EGCB( ID( @<( BCD( !"( @<( C@?( >H@[FBD(>LFKD?((

E3:%*,2(R+?=H]=<(&&(^(2FH?@D?D(!T(

84(`...Va(b#(ScV.,a(eFH<F](8FKCDBBD(<=:(S`c(

8:&&:S( ( ( ( ( N( (

+,#*(2%(%?$$@(!"(%(8,(?$$@( #<BHF<KD(=>D<(B=(BCD(!"(W::X( M,&#'2$-(R!I:(&&&^&iT(

))(,d.( _:&&:cd( ( ( N( ( ( (

+"()("*+(,(G0:),#(,(L!)11&2'(!0(%(/*2("*+()(!"$-(!%/(201()#(L!(#).(0/*D((

!HH@[FL(@<(#G;>BQ(FB("@HFID??D(4HDFB(@<(i@KB=H@D?Q(HD?B@<G(@<(C@?(!"(=A(L@AD(F<O(O=I@<@=<(L@]D(5F(JC=(@?(@<(BCD(2=H@j=<(

5FI:(&&( _FBBLD(=A(mFOD?C( _:&:Sg( ( ( ( N( ( (

+"(,%$#(!"(",(0/(%(%12*(",(15)(130.*$-(#,*(+2(8+2$-(

M;(<FID(HDFKCDO(BCD(!"(=<L;(PDKFE?D(=A(PD@<G(DAADKB@[D(A=H(BCD(]@<GQ(PDKFE?D(=A(CDFH]D<@<G(B=(C@?(BDFKC@<G(F<O(DNDKEB@<G(C@?(LFJ?:(

!.(R!I:(&iT( !)(.V( _:&&:dd( ( ( N( ( ( (

)00$*(*+:,5$*()(!"(#,*(;02(C+12(C+1$*(1!"(1/)*.(0/*()(";02$*(((

0=E(?DD(;=EH(HELD?(@<(BCD(!"D(;=EH(;02(IFOD(<=PLDQ(HDKD@[@<G(;=EH(O@G<@B;Q(;=EH(O=EPLD(KH=J<(?C@<@<G(@<(;=EH(IFG@K([@HBED(

2FB?C:( %D@H(DL^_FCFH@(.( _:&:,,( ( ( N( ( ( (

?)(!"@(%-,2*$1*(%8)(!8%2*.( W@<(BCD(!"X(CDH(PDFEB;(>DH[FOD?(BCD(!8%2*.Q( $DADHBFH@(R5FI:(&&T( _HENDLLD?( _:&:VS( ( ( ( N( ( (

Page 634: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,--c(

20,/(8,(/%(O,(/%)$1*( RJC@LDT(CDH(AHFGHF<KD(A@LL?(BCD(K=L=<<FOD(CFLL(&20,/'(

ME?DEI(1:cV--(

)"(!"()(130*$-((

+<D(JC=(A@LL?(BCD(!"(J@BC(C@?(BDFKC@<G((

>,2(R"DBEPF?B@?(&T( 84(`...Ua(b#(SUVcVa(eFH<F](8FKCDBBD(<=:(.(

8:&&:,V( ( ( ( ( N( (

)522(+,*()(8%2(!"( *=HO?(BCFB(K=ID(AH=I(BCD(8%2(=A(BCD(!"( l7)%:"*+(R!I:(&&&T( 84(VgS( _:&&:cS( ( ( N( ( ( ()522(%(%3(!"( *=HO?(=A(BCD(7=HO(=A(BCD(!"( L!:)1&#'2(R!I:(&&&^

&iT())(VV( _:&&:g`( ( ( N( ( ( (

)5"(O%2*.()(!"( +[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(?KEL>B=H?(@<(BCD(!"( F1#:%,(RMD<:(&&T( /CFBB(DH(5@GFL(`cS( !:&&:c( N( ( ( ( ( (%(32(21/*$#()(!"( &(O=(<=B(?JFGGDH(@<(BCD(!":( G2:*2(R!I:(&iT( !)(g( _:&&:dU( ( ( N( ( ( (%2(8,2(#2$#()(!"( #[DH;(OF;(BCFB(&(FI(@<(BCD(!"( 5FI:(&&( _FBBLD(=A(mFOD?C( _:&:Sg( ( ( ( N( ( (%3(0352("*+()(!"$-( 5D?B@<G(@<(C@?(!"( 672%.(R/DB;(&T(

(>,)2#0(R/DB;(&(YT((

_DHL@<(g,c.((3<]<=J<((

_:&&:,.c((_:&&:,cU(

( ( ( N( ( (

%3$#(*1(30;$;(#0(,(1),(*+.(%(!"( M;(7=HO(K=IIF<ODO(BCFB(C@?(?DH[F<B(?C=ELO(PD(DLD[FBDO(B=(BCD(HF<](=A(A@H?B(K=I>F<@=<(@<(BCD(!"(

B0:1,(R/DB;(&(f(5FI:(&&T(

))(,-U( _:&&:,.g( ( ( ( N( ( (

%%(120#$%$#(")$-()(!"&*'$-((( &(O@O(<=B(LDF[D(2@?(MFhD?B;(@<(C@?(!"&*'( N1:A%12:#2$-:!%/(R)F]DL=B(&T(

84(VVd( 8:&&:.( ( ( ( ( N( (

%1()52(%(K).(!"( />DF]^B=<GED(=A(JC=(@?(@<(BCD(!"( 67%:#*$-(R)CEB:(&&&T( 7=E[HD(8(.U( _:&&:,-( ( ( N( ( ( (

%12*(!"( e@<G(=A(BCDZH=;FL(!"( !I:(&&( _EPF?B@?(,( !:&:.( N( ( ( ( ( (%12*:3#*.()(/!2$-(()(",*(",.:*+(130.*()(!"(C+1#(%*.()#(0/*(%(L!(

e@<G(=A(3>>DH(F<O(7=JDH(#G;>B(@<(C@?(F>>DFHF<KD(@<(CDF[D<(E>=<(BCD(O==H?(=A(BCD(<=PLD(!"(L@]D(5F(@<(BCD(C=H@j=<:(

5FI:(&&&( MDO@<DB(2FPE(.( _:&:VV( ( ( ( N( ( (

/!#&*'(%12*()(1/)*.(/+,(")1*()(5052(

!>>DFHF<KD(=A(BCD(]@<G(@<(BCD(O=EPLD(KH=J<:(!(?D??@=<(B==](>LFKD(@<(BCD(5052:(

/D?:(&( >_DHL@<(S-.d( !:&:V( N( ( ( ( ( (

/!#&*'(%12*()(1*(2,*()(!"(%2(672%2(

!>>DFHF<KD(=A(BCD(]@<G(@<(BCD(GHDFB(?DFB(=A(BCD(!"(=A(2DL@=>=L@?(

670):%5"(R)CEB:(&&&T(

))(g`( _:&&:d( ( ( N( ( ( (

/!#&*'(%12*(&)#(L!'()(!"( !>>DFHF<KD(=A(BCD(]@<G(L@]D(5D(@<(BCD(!"( MDHD<>BFC((

MDI>C@?(.((

_:&:`d( ( ( ( N( ( (

Page 635: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,--g(

/!#&*'(%12*(&)#(L!'()(!"(%("2*$-(C+1#(

!>>DFHF<KD(=A(BCD(]@<G(L@]D(5F(@<(C@?(!"(=A(C@?(<=PLD(BDI>LD(

5FI:(&&&( MDO@<DB(2FPE(.( _:&:VU( ( ( ( N( ( (

/!#&*'(%12*()#(L!()(!"(%(!%/(201( !>>DFHF<KD(=A(BCD(]@<G(L@]D(5F(@<(C@?(!"(=A(L@AD(F<O(A=HBE<D(

5FI:(&&&( MDO@<DB(2FPE(.( _:&:VU( ( ( ( N( ( (

/!#&*'(%12*(,(,2*.(2,*.(+,2.(!"$?-@(

!>>DFHF<KD(=A(BCD(]@<G(FB(BCD(O=EPLD(GFBD?(=A(!"( M,&#'2$-(R!I:(&&&^&iT(

))(,d.( _:&&:cd( ( ( N( ( ( (

%12*(/!#&*'()(1/)*.(",(1*(2,*(%*(5!)(8%2(51,2(%2(!"$-(

!>>DFHF<KD(=A(BCD(]@<G(@<(BCD(O=EPLD(KH=J<(=<(BCD(GHDFB(BCH=<D(=A(G=LO(@<(BCD(BCD(C=L;(8%2(=A(C@?(!"(

2FB?C:( %D@H(DL^_FCFH@(S( _:&:,.( ( ( N( ( ( (

%1.*(L!()(!"(67+*:I2*( e@<G?C@>(=A(5F(@<(BCD(!"(=A(eFH<F]( !I:(&&( eFH<F](c( _:&:,`( ( ( N( ( ( (%*,(!"(,5#(!%/( 4=O(=A(BCD(!"D(D<O=JDO(J@BC(L@AD( MD<B:(&i( 2FIIFIFB( !:&:,( N( ( ( ( ( (E*,2()(!"(( )CD(G=O?(@<(BCD(!"( =(R.-BC(%;<:T( >)EH@<(84)(V`-V,( _:&:gd( ( ( ( N( ( (,$#(),2*()(8*(%*(1),2(2,(!"(/!2(#)(!P(",(%3$-(

7=[D(=A(ID(JF?(@<(BCD(P=O@D?(=A(BCD(K=EHB@DH?Q(BCD(GHDFB(=<D(=A(BCD(!"(F<O(C@I(JC=(JF?(D<BCH=<DO(BCDHD(

9%*2:>*+(RMD<:(&&T(

38(,`SSS( !:&&:V( N( ( ( ( ( (

,/(,$-(",(55()522()(!"(( +<D(JC=(]<DJ(C@?(?>DDKC(JCD<(?>DF]@<G(@<(BCD(!"((

E3:%*,2(R+?=H]=<(&&(^(2FH?@D?D(!T(

84(`...Va(b#(ScV.,a(eFH<F](8FKCDBBD(<=:(S`c(

8:&&:S( ( ( ( ( N( (

,5#*(%(")$-()0!(!032*(!0*()(#202(2%52(%(%*,2(%32(Q)!2(G0:)"2(25%2(%(%*,2(1*+:10()(!"*(

2@?(MFhD?B;(CF?(G@[D<(GHDFB(=AADH@<G?(K=<?@?B@<G(=A(L=<G^(F<O(?C=HB^C=H<DO(KFBBLD(A=H(FLL(BCD(G=O?(=A(3>>DH(F<O(7=JDH(#G;>BQ(RF<OT(HD[DH?@=<(=AADH@<G?(A=H(BCD(G=O?(=A(BCD(H=;FL(>HD?D<KD(@<(BCD(!"*(

"?FIBD](&&( eFLFP?CF(BDI>LD( 8:&:,-( ( ( ( ( N( (

80.$#(&<)0$#='(#)#$#(1%(#).*2(51():30"$#(*%(%2(8,2(#2$#()(!"(

&(?CFLL(?B=>(B=(ADDO@<G(BCDI(I;?DLA(>DH?=<FLL;(D[DH;(OF;(BCFB(&(FI(@<(BCD(!"(

5FI:(&&( _FBBLD(=A(mFOD?C( _:&:Sg( ( ( ( N( ( (

8383(*02.(&/012*'(%(%*.()(!"( +<D(JC=(BHDFO?(BCD(A=HD@G<(LF<O?(A=H(C@I(JC=(@?(@<(BCD(!"(

=(RM:e:T( /@<F@(,`-( !:&&:,Ud( N( N( ( ( ( (

8,2(+%(#2$*2()(!"(%-,(K).&*'(+,:!0(!%/:/+,:;0:L!()0!(/,2(

+<(BC@?(OF;(&(JF?(@<(BCD(G==O(!"Q(JC@KC(@?(BCD(D?BFBD(=A(!%/:/+,:;0:L!(hE?B@A@DO(

)EB:( 84(`,VUV( _:&:.S( ( (( N( ( ( (

")$-(!%/(250(1%3(")2(")2*(C)6.*(/30.*(2%()(30;2()(+,:

2@?(MFhD?B;Q(IF;(CD(L@[D(>H=?>DH(F<O(PD(@C(CDFLBCQ(CF?(K=<?DKHFBDO(ID<(F<O(J=ID<(

)EB:( 84(`,VUV( _:&:.S( ( ( N( ( ( (

Page 636: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,--d(

%12*(#+$*2(30;2$1%(,((?$$@(!"(%3(*02.(

?LF[D?Q(KCF<BHD??D?(F<O(OF<KDH?(JC=(FHD(?DH[F<B(@<(BCD(+,:%12*(F<O(BCD@H(JFGD?(FHD(KCFHGDO(B=(BCD(W::X(!"(=A(BCD(7=HO(=A(BCD()J=(7F<O?(

")$-()(!"$-( 2@?(MFhD?B;(@<(C@?(!"( 67)%:):#+*(R5FI:(&&&T(

))(,`g( _:&&:,U`( ( ( ( N( ( (

")$;()%()(!"$-( 0=EH(MFhD?B;(?BF<O?(A@HI(@<(C@?(!"( 5FI:(&&^(&&&( %DKHDD(=A(PLD??@<G("BFC(

_:&:V`( ( ( ( N( ( (

"%;$1&R-'(,(!"(%(%3$1&R-'( 2D(=AADH?(B=(BCD(!"(A=H(C@?(7=HO( L!:)1&#'2(R!I:(&&&^&iT(

))(VV( _:&&:g`( ( ( N( ( ( (

"1#$#(2#()(!"(),2$#()(1*%(1*+:10( !?(=<D(>HF@?DO(O@O(&(K=ID(A=HBC(AH=I(BCD(k"Q(=<D(PDL=[DO(=A(BCD(1*+:10(

F+:202*:!0(R/D?:(&(^(!I:(&&:T(

47(*!1(SV( !:&&:`,( ( ( ( ( ( (

"1#(%(%*,(%-,(8%(!"(1*+(%(%12*( "HF@?@<G(BCD(G==O(G=OQ(=<D(JC=(F>>H=FKCDO(BCD(!"D(>H=BDKB@<G(BCD(]@<G((

B0:L!:):"3(R!I:(&&&T(

84(S`,cV( _:&&:UU( ( ( N( ( ( (

"*+()(!"(##(",(#,*(#,,2*(%3(%(>3:&15'(

5D?B@<G(@<(BCD(!"(JCD<(K=I@<G(B=(>DHA=HI(FLL(BCD(H@BD?(=A(BCD(IS5:AD?B@[FL(

!I:(&&&( /=LDP( _:&:,c( ( ( N( ( ( (

"*+()(!"(#%(%?12@(/-*(##*(",(*%*0*(?)(8,2(T(%@(>3:&15'(

5D?B@<G(@<(BCD(!"(JCD<(K=I@<G(AH=I(BCD(OF@?(W=<(OF;(SX(=A(BCD(IS5^AD?B@[FL(

!I:(&&&( /=LDP( _:&:,c( N( ( ( ( ( (

"*+()(!"$-( 5D?B@<G(@<(C@?(!"( 672%.(R/DB;(&T((>,)2#0(R,dBC(%;<:T((

_DHL@<(g,c.((3<]<=J<((

_:&&:,.c((_:&&:,cU(

( ( ( N( ( (

"*+$-()(!"$-(02#(#3$-( 2D(HD?B?(@<(C@?(!"(F<O(C@?(CDFHB(@?(GLFO(A=HD[DH( E3:+2:F1,*:1%(R!I:(&&&T(

_M(,cV(W,-,X( !:&&:Ud( N( ( ( ( ( (

/!#&*'()(!"(K%(%12*( !>>DFH@<G(@<(BCD(!"(@<(HDLFB@=<(B=(BCD(]@<G( M,&#'2$-(R!I:(&&&^&iT(

))(,d.( _:&&:cd( ( ( N( ( ( (

/!#(")$-(",(1*(>,()(!"( 2@?(MFhD?B;(F>>DFH?(@<(GL=H;(=<(BCD(?DFB(=A(2=HE?(@<(BCD(!"(

$DCDHC=BD>( b#(US-c( !:&:,S( ( N( ( ( ( (

/!#$*()(!"(8;,("0*$*()(1/)*.( 0=E(F>>DFH(@<(GL=H;(R;=E(FHD(D<BCH=<DOT(@<(BCD( 2FB?C:( %D@H(DL^_FCFH@(S( _:&:,,( ( ( N( ( ( (

Page 637: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-,-(

!"(F<O(;=EH(CDFO(@?(FO=H<DO(J@BC(BCD(%=EPLD(8H=J<((

/!2$-(()(",*(",.:*+(130.*()(!"(C+1#(%*.()#(0/*(%(L!(

Re@<Gl?T(F>>DFHF<KD(@<(CDF[D<(E>=<(BCD(O==H?(=A(BCD(<=PLD(!"(L@]D(5F(@<(BCD(C=H@j=<(

5FI:(&&( MDO@<DB(2FPE(.( _:&:VU( ( ( ( N( ( (

/+,(,52.(%(%12*(130*&.'(>,(%3(!"(#2(#,$%$#((1),(8,(,5(%12*()("3:15(

!(KC@LO(JC=(GHDJ(E>(FB(BCD(ADDB(=A(BCD(]@<GQ(F(O@?K@>LD(=A(2=HE?Q(7=HO(=A(BCD(!"(?F;?n(&(FKBDO(F?(K=I>F<@=<(JC=(KFHH@D?(BCD(e@<Gl?(A==B^D[DH(FB(BCD(IS5^AD?B@[FL(

E3:+2:F1,*:1%(R!I:(&&&T(

_M(,cV(W,-,X( !:&&:Ud( N( ( ( ( ( (

/+,(")1*(%12*()(5052(%(#).(2,*()([!"]$-(

)CDHD(=KKEHHDO(F(?@BB@<G(=A(BCD(]@<G(@<(BCD(FEO@D<KD(CFLL(=A(BCD(JD?B(@<(C@?([!"](

)CEB:(&&&( eFH<F](V( _:&:V( ( ( N( ( ( (

/,(%12*(#,(!"(?%12*@(,(#,*(1/,(*02( +<D(JC=I(BCD(WH=;FLX(!"(F>>=@<BDO(B=(FOI@<@?BDH(BCD(LF<O?(

I0:+0:#,(R,gBC(%;<:T(

/F\\FHF(S( _:&&:,-`( ( ( N( ( ( (

100(#2*$-()(5302()(1/!*(>,(%3(!"(

+<D(JC=?D(K=I@<G(@?(FJF@BDO(FB(BCD(KH=J@<G(FB(BCD(F>>DFHF<KD(=A(2=HE?Q(7=HO(=A(BCD(!"(

A%*.:I)*&.'(R!I:(&&T(

_M(,`U(WVc`X( !:&&:`V( N( ( ( ( ( (

10*(?*0(2,(!0*(%(A*0@("*+1()(!"(+,:%12*((

)CD(OFEGCBDH(=A(BCD(4HDFB(5ELDH(=A(2FBB@(JF?(@<?BFLLDO(@<(BCD(!"(+,:%12*(

5FI:(&&( MFHH@FGD(?BDLF( _:&:`-( ( ( N( ( ( (

1!0$%(%3(*02.()(!"( +<D(JC=I(BCD(7=HO(=A(BCD()J=(7F<O?(KFE?DO(B=(PD(GHDFB(@<(BCD(!"(

>;0:,:%""(R!I:(&&T( ))(U`( _:&&:VV( ( ( N( ( ( (

1!+,(!"()(8,((( +<D(JC=(>H=[@OD?(BCD(!"(J@BC(<DKD??@B@D?( A%*.:"*+(RM:e:T( /@<F@(`,.((

!:&&:,UU( N( N( ( ( ( (

1!,(20*()(/,(!"( +<D(JC=(>H=I=BD?(H@GCB(FB(BCD(!"( &B'L!:"*+(R5FI:(&&T( b#(`gg`V( _:&&:,SU( ( ( ( N( ( (1!,%&.'(/*&2'$1%(,:8%2(!"(( +<D(JC=(@<BH=OEKD?(BCD@H(G==O?(@<?@OD(BCD(!"( !>H@D?(

(!>H@D?(((

_M(#!(gS((M@B^5FC@<FQ(/B=HD^C=E?D(<=:(V`V(

8:&&:SV((8:&&:SU(

( ( ( ( N( (

130(50502[.](!"(67)%:):/0*( %==H(=A(BCD(50502[.](=A(BCD(!"(=A(!ID<DICFB( /D?:(&&&( #jPDB(2DLI@( !:&:,,( N( ( ( ( ( (1302(")$-()(&")'(!"( +<D(JC=I(2@?(MFhD?B;(BC=EGCBQ(@<(BCD(IFhD?B;(

=A(BCD(!"(I*:02(R5FI:(&&T( *FO@(DL^/DPEF( _:&&:,S.( ( ( ( N( ( (

?$$130@.*()(!"(C+1#(%*.()#(0/*(%( WO=X=H?(BCD(<=PLD(!"D(L@]D(5F(@<(BCD(C=H@j=<( 5FI:(&&( MDO@<DB(2FPE(.( _:&:VU( ( ( ( N( ( (

Page 638: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-,,(

L!( (1+,(")$-(,(*+(#*,2(",(3#0.*(!0*(2,*(,(1302.(%(!"(%12*(

2@?(MFhD?B;(FHH@[D?(B=(BCD(CDFO(=A(BCD(H@[DH(A=H(F([DH;(P@G(=HFKLD(B=(BCD(O=EPLD(GFBD?(=A(BCD(!"(=A(BCD(]@<G(

2FB?C:((2FB?C:(

eFH<F](U((%D@H(DL^_FCFH@(,(

_:&:d((_:&:,-(

( ( N( ( ( (

1+,$%$#(!"(#3$#(02*( &(D<BDHDO(@<(BCD(!"D(I;(CDFHB(RAELL(=AT(=AADH@<G?( E*:!%/(RM:e:T( %D@H(5@ADC(c( !:&&:,UV( N( N( ( ( ( (1)1(%(>,(%3(!"( 1=LL=J@<G(2=HE?Q(BCD(7=HO(=A(BCD(!"( >+2:1%32(R)CEB:(

&&&(f(2FB?C:T(84(U`g( _:&&:.,( ( ( N( ( ( (

1,2(O,(#%#(%2(#%2$1%(,(!"$-( )CD@H(KC@DA(PDFH(BCD@H(BH@PEBD(B=(C@?(!"( 5FI:(&&( 8F@H=(8:.,Q(8:..( _:&:`.( ( ( ( N( ( (18,#(")$-()(!"( +<D(JC=(K=<BD<BDO(2@?(MFhD?B;(@<(BCD(!"( Lk:"*+(R5FI:(&&T(( b#(`gg`V( _:&&:,SU( ( ( ( N( ( (1"3:15(#%2$-(!"(6+,2("2*( +<D(JC=?D(=AADH@<G?(IF]D(BCD(k"(ADF?B( 9%*2:):"0*(

RM:e:T(M1!(.d:,,S-( !:&&:,Uc( N( N( ( ( ( (

1/+,(%(>,(%3(!"( MFOD(@<(L@AD(P;(2=HE?Q(7=HO(=A(BCD(!"( I3;:/2(R/D?:(&&&T( _M(.`d(W,.,SX( !:&&:VU( N( ( ( ( ( (

1/+,$%$-()(8%2(!"$-( MFOD(@<(L@AD(P;(C@I(@<(BCD(8%2(=A(C@?(!"( M,&#'2$-(R!I:(&&&T( _EPF?B@?( _:&&:g,( ( ( N( ( ( (1*+:102(",.:#3(#).(!"( 2D(>H=BDKB?(BCD(@<CFP@BF<B?(=A(BCD!"( E3:12:)%2(

R5FI:(&&T())(,gS( _:&&:,Sd( ( ( ( N( ( (

1*%#(&%'(>,(%3(!"( 5F@?DO(E>(RP;T(2=EH?Q(7=HO(=A(BCD(!"(( 91:%:!)0!*(R,.BC(%;<:T(

_DHL@<(gg--( !:&&:,-d( N( ( ( ( ( (

C-.*$1()(!"( 2DH(RMEBl?T(O@G<@B;(@<(BCD(!"( 5FI:(i&( _M(,d`( _:&:U-( ( ( ( N( ( (C1+("%;()(C+1(5#(%12*()(!"( 5DKD@[@<G(>HD?D<B?(=A(BCD(K=?BL;(BC@<G?(G@[D<(P;(

BCD(]@<G(@<(BCD(!"(I0:,%+2*(R/D?:(&&&T( !?JF<(B=IP(SU( !:&&:U.( ( ( ( ( ( (

C1+$#(90!*()(8;,$1()(!"( &(HDKD@[DO(BCD(MFFB(@<(C@?(=H<FID<B?(@<(BCD(!"((

Y(R/CD?C=<\(&&&(^(2FH?@D?D(_T(

84(`..S.a(b#(SUUUVa(eFH<F](8FKCDBBD(<=:(dd(

8:&&:,.( ( ( ( ( N( (

?<)0@$%(2,?*@("*1(%-,2$-()(",.:#3(!"&*'(2,*(

+<D(JC=?D(GHDFB(PDFEB;(JF?(KHDFBDO(P;(BC=?D(JC=(FHD(@<(BCD(GHDFB(!"&*'(

"H@<KD(+?=H]=<(R"DBEPF?B@?(&T(

!<<FLD?(=A(BCD("H@<KD(+?=H]=<(

8:&&:,U( ( ( ( ( N( (

O,O$%$-(2#()(+,.*(#+*:%12*()(1%*(%-,2(!"(

2D(R/DB;(&T(D\E@>>DO(ID(J@BC(C=E?DC=LO(J=ID<Q(F(H=;FL(CFH@IQ(L@]D(BCD(PDFEB@D?(=A(BCD(!"(

5FI:(&&( !P;O=?(`( _:&&:`S( ( ( ( N( ( (

*#(2#()(%-,()52(12*(!"(( _D@<G(F(;=EBC(JC=I(BCD(?BFAA(=A(BCD(!"(L=[DO( E-,:1,:8,2(R,dBC(%;<:T(

oFJ;DB(/ELBF<( _:&&:,cV( ( ( ( N( ( (

*1#$%$-(10$#(",(1*(,52.$#()(!"&*'$-( 2D(W!IE<X(AEHBCDHDO(I;(?=<(@<(I;(>=?@B@=<(@<( N5:92*:#2$-:!%/(R+?H=]=<(&&(f(

8F@H=(84(`...-a(b#(SUc,-a(eFH<F](

( ( ( ( ( N( (

Page 639: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-,.(

%*(67+*:12*( C@?(!"&*'(=A(eFH<F]( )F]DL=B(&&T( 8FKCDBBD(<=:(.,(

5#(!%/()(!8%2*.,:?()(!"(),&2*'(%(!"&*'(

4@[@<G(L@AD(@<(BCD(@<BDH@=H(=A(BCD(!"D(L=[DO(P;(BCD(!"(

2FB?C:( %D@H(DL^_FCFH@(.( _:,:,,( ( ( N( ( ( (

5#$-(02*:K3()(!"(?<)0@(C-.*()(8%2(1*(2,*(

2D( G@[D?( =AADH@<G?( @<( BCD( !"Q( =<D( JC=( KHDFBD?(O@G<@B;(@<(BCD(8%2(=A(BCD(4HDFB(/DFB(

67%:#*$-(R)CEB:(&&&T( 7=E[HD(8(.U( _:&&:,-( ( ( N( ( ( (

5#$-(/*#(!0)2("*+(,(!"0(/+,2()(32*(%*.(#32$1%(#3$1%(#2$1%(%$-(*2*()(20"(*+(,(!"$-(!%/(201(+,(L!:)112:67)%(!0(/*2(

2D(KFE?D?(BCD(!?@FB@K(B=(HDBHDFB(\E@K]L;Q(A@GCB@<G(CF[@<G(PDK=ID(FP=I@<FB@=<(B=(BCD@H(CDFHB?:()CD;(K=ID(B=(C@I(FLL(B=GDBCDH(J@BC(P=JDO(CDFO(B=(C@?(!"(=A(L@AD(F<O(O=I@<@=<Q("@HFID??DQ(4HDFB(=A(i@KB=H@D?(

5FI:(&&( 3<@[DH?@B;(ME?DEI("D<<?;L[F<@F($H:(.d:,-c:dVg(

_:&:Sd( ( ( ( N( ( (

5#$-(1*(,5()(8%2(!"(()00(%12*(F!:%:L!(R::T(

MF;(CD(GHF<B(F(?BFB@=<(J@BC@<(BCD(8%2(!"(@<(=HODH(B=(?DD(BCD(]@<G(F!:%:L!(R::T(

!0:)1(R!I:(&iT( !)(S( _:&&:dS( ( ( ( ( ( (

5#$%$#(*+:,5()(",$1%(8+2()(8,2.*$1%(#).(?!"@(

&(GF[D(=HODH?(B=(BCDI(F<O(LFJ?(@<(BCD@H(OF;?(@<(BCD(?!"@(

2=HDICDP( %E>L:84(S`,U.( _:&:.U( ( ( N( ( ( (

53%$%$#(!"$-( &(D<BDHDO(@<(C@?(!"( 67%#:%*:)%:*2:O3(R,.BC(%;<:T(

84(.-c,.( !:&&:dc( N( ( ( ( ( (

5,(*0(,(*+"*(%*(!"(2,( !HH@[FL(FB(BCD(LF<O(AH=I(BCD(@<<DH(RL@B:(BCD(KF[DH<YT(=A(BCD(GHDFB(!"(

67%#:*-:#<,(R/D?:(&T( ))(U-( !:&&:.V( N( ( ( ( ( (

55()522(%(")$-(!"$-(%(5050*(2,2(%*.():/*$-(

/F;@<G(BC@<G?(@<(BCD(>HD?D<KD(=A(2@?(MFhD?B;(@<(C@?(!"(P;(BCD(K=E<K@L(=A(BCD(GHDFB(=<D?(JC=(FBBD<O(C@I((

eFI=?D( 8F@H=(b#(`,cd-(f(8FH<F[=<(BFPLDB(&(

_:&:,( ( ( N( ( ( (

55$-(1),2(%12*(!"(#)#(#02*(%(%12*(1<02(302$-(520(%12*(

2D(?F;?n(;=E(H=;FL(K=I>F<@=<?(=A(BCD(!"Q(G@[D(>HF@?D(B=(BCD(]@<GQ(DNB=L(C@?(I@GCBQ(>HF@?D(BCD(]@<G(

I3;:",:"3(R!I:(&&&T( /@<F@(VS( !:&&:gd( N( ( ( ( ( (

552(%$-(##2&*'()(+,:%12*(#%(1),2(#).2(!"(

(6*DLK=ID(B=(BCD(+,:%12*9(P;(BC=?D(JC=(FHD(@<(BCD(!"(

I,%:+2*(R/D?:(&T(((I0:,%+2*(R,.BC(%;<:T(

2D\F@P(.((2D\F@P(d(^I!?JF<(,ScS(

!:&&:S`((!:&&:,-V(

N( ( ( ( ( (

?55*@(")$-(#%#$%$#(1),2(2,2(!"(#).&2':,()%-.*(?#).@2:,(;02*(

)CD<(?F@O(C@?("DH?=<Q(6_H@<G(ID(BCD(]@<Gl?(K=I>F<@=<?(F<O(BCD(GHDFB(=<D?(=A(!"D(BCD(

!I:(&i( !IFH<F(,( _:&:,d( ( ( N( ( ( (

Page 640: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-,S(

1,2(%3(?<%3*@( ?E>DH[@?=H?(=A(BCD(GEFHOQ(BCD(W=[DH?DDHX(=A(BCD(J=H]?Q(BCD(=AA@K@FL?(F<O(FLL(BCD(WK=EHBX(@<(@B?(D<B@H@B;(

)@BLD?(F<O(D>@BCDB?(#+2*.(2,(%3*(!"(,(#%#J2(%*()%2(%(")(%$-(

4HDFB(ID??D<GDH(=A(D[DH;(!"(A=H(BCD(#%2(RYT(=A(D[DH;(I=<EID<B?(=A(2@?(MFhD?B;(

>*+.(R!I:(&&&T( 2FIIFIFB(,c( !:&&:Uc( N( ( ( ( ( (

#)0/.(/,(%12*()(!"( 5D[DHDO(=<D(PDA=HD(BCD(]@<G(@<(BCD(!"( 67)%:):#+*(R)CEB:(&&&(f(!I:(&&T(

))(dU( _:&&:.U( ( ( N( ( ( (

#).:?#3@(&)'(#).(!"( +<D(JC=(>H=BDKB?(JC=(@?(@<(BCD(!"( >+2:1%32(R)CEB:(&&&(f(2FB?C:T((I%&#':%-,(R2FB?C:T((L/:)#:,!(R)CEB:(&&&(f(!I:(&&T(

8F@H=(84(U`g((())(dd(())(,--(

_:&&:.,(((_:&&:`g((_:&&:SS(

( ( N( ( ( (

#).:#3()(1*(!"(%3$-( )CD(=<D(JC=(@?(@<(BCD(CDFHB(=A(BCD(?DFB(=A(BCD(!"(=A(C@?(7=HO(

670):%5"(R)CEB:(&&&T(

))(g`( _:&&:d( ( ( N( ( ( (

#).:#3(%(%12*()(!"( &<B@IFBD(=A(BCD(]@<G(=A(BCD(!"( 67%:#*$-(RMD<:(&&T((E3:%*,2(R+?=H]=<(&&(^(2FH?@D?D(!T(

MM!(Vc:dV(((84(`...Va(b#(ScV.,a(eFH<F](8FKCDBBD(<=:(S`c(

!:&&:.((8:&&:S(

N( ( ( ( N( (

#).:#3(&%'(>,(%3(!"$-( 1F[=H@BD(=A(2=HE?(7=HO(=A(C@?(!"( N52:67#%*$-(R/D?:(&T(((N-^"!+.(R/D?:(&T((67,*:-:%:*2:*(R/D?:(&T((I0:)%*2(R!I:(&&T(

_F<]D?(M?:($=:('&&(8(`((!??@EB(,((_M(,dU(W,,ccX(((_M(,`V(Wg.gX(

!:&&:.U(((!:&&:S,((!:&&:SV(((!:&&:`g(

N( ( N( ( N( (

Page 641: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-,`(

(N"2*.:"*+(R!I:(&&^/D?:(&&&T((L/:)0!:#,,(RM:e:T((M,&#'2$-(R!I:(&&&^&iT((E/*:)#%(R,gBC(

%;<:T((>,%:):"3(R!I:(&iT((E1:+0:L!(R+?=H]=<(&&(f()F]DL=B(&&T((

(_DH?CDC(.(((84(.-cV-((())(,d.(((_M(VV-(((84(ccd(((8F@H=(84(`...,a(b#(SUd,da(eFH<F](8FKCDBBD(<=:(,..(

(!:&&:V.(((!:&&:,c,((_:&&:cd^g-(((_:&&:,-.(((_:&&:,-d(((8:&&:c((((

#).:#3(>,(%3(!"(*%%$-(/%*.()#*.2$-(

1F[=H@BD(=A(2=HE?Q(7=HO(=A(BCD(!"(JC=(>H=I=BD?(C@I(PDA=HD(C@?(>DDH?(

N-^"!+.(R/D?:(,T( !??@EB(,( !:&&:S,( N( ( ( ( ( (

#).(!"( +<D(JC=(@?(@<(BCD(!"( =(R!I:(&&T( >_=ELF\(,c( _:&:S,( ( ( N( ( ( (#).:,(#02*(!"( +[DH?DDH(=A(=AA@KD?(@<(BCD(!"( >,%:):"3(R)EB:T( /F\\FHF(.( _:&&:,-,( ( ( N( ( ( (#).:,(#).2(/%*(!0(%(%3(*02.()(!"("3:15(

+[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(#).2(/%*(GHDFB(=A(BCD(7=HO(=A(BCD(BJ=(LF<O?(@<(BCD(!"("3:15(

&B'L!:"*+(R5FI:(&&T( bO#(`gg`V( _:&&:,SU( ( ( ( N( ( (

#).:,(1),2(!"((

+[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(K=I>F<@=<(=A(BCD(!"(( E3:%*,2(R(+?=H]=<(&&(^(2FH?@D?D(!T(

84(`...Va(b#(ScV.,a(eFH<F](8FKCDBBD(<=:(S`c(

8:&&:S( ( ( ( ( N( (

#).:,(1*(%(!"( +[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(>LFKDZ>=?@B@=<Z?DFB(=A(BCD(!"( I0?$$@:#3*(&='(RM:e:T(

/DFL(<=:(,S`d(f(38(,,S`,!(

!:&&:,d.( N( ( ( ( (

#).:,(;02*()("2*("32:15()(!"(%(+,:%12*(

+[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(J=H]?(@<(BCD(BDI>LD(=A(IS5^AD?B@[FL?(@<(BCD(!"(RF<O(@<(BCDT(+,:%12*(

=(R,g^,dBC(%;<:T( 7D@OD<(S:,:,:Sc( _:&&:,.-( ( ( N( ( ( (

#%<(*02.(%(%3(!"( +<D(JC=(E<@BD?(BCD()J=(7F<O?(A=H(BCD(7=HO(=A( I%&#':%-,(R2FB?C:T( ))(dd( _:&&:`g( ( ( N( ( ( (

Page 642: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-,V(

BCD(!"(#,(!"(,(#,*(1/,(*"2(#,(",(*0( +<D(JC=I(BCD(!"(F>>=@<BDO(B=(FOI@<@?BDH(BCD(

LF<O?Q(FKBDO(=<(JFBDH(F<O(FKBDO(=<(LF<O(I0:+0:#,(R,gBC(%;<:T(

/F\\FHF(S( _:&&:,-`( ( ( N( ( ( (

#,(8+2(%(#).(!"( +<D(JC=(KFHH@D?(=EB(BCD(LFJ?(A=H(BCD(=<D(JC=(@?(@<(BCD(!"(

l7)%:"*+(R!I:(&&&T( 84(VgS( _:&&:cS( ( ( N( ( ( (

#,("112*J"11*(#).:!"(&)(8,*:8,2(%*(,!(%3'(

+<D(JC=(O@O(JCFB(@?(>HF@?DO(J@BC@<(BCD(!"(OEH@<G(BCD(K=EH?D(=A(D[DH;(OF;(

I2:):%2*(R)CEB:(&&&^!I:&iT((U%:67)%(R!I:(&&T((I3;:"*+(R)CEB:(&iT(((

))(d.((())(dS(())(US((

_:&&:S,(((_:&&:V.((_:&&:US((

( ( N( ( ( (

#,.(!*(%&*'(!"( +[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(KCFIPDH(=A(BCD(!"( >,#((R/D?:(&&&^!I:(&&&T((F1,:1,*$1%(R/D?:(&&&T((0/*.:"*+2(R!I:(&&&T((0/*.:/*+2(R!I:(&&&T((V)":#(R,.BC(%;<:T((673#(R,.BC(%;<:T((=(R,.BC(%;<:T((67*(R,SBC(%;<:T((W)"2(R,SBC(%;<:T(

/DFL(,,S.(((!P;O=?(((5&e(,,c(((5&e(,,g(((_M(V-U((1@HD<jD(.V,.((oFGHDP(g((/BDLD(MFGODPEHG((#OAE(

(!:&&:VS(((!:&&:Vd(((!:&&:d,(((!:&&:d.(((!:&&:,,,((!:&&:,.V((!:&&:,.U((!:&&:,.g((!:&&:,`d(

N( N( ( ( ( (

Page 643: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-,U(

((I%3(R,SBC(%;<:T((F1,:;0:,!:!%/2(R,SBC(%;<:T((>,:C-:"*+(R,SBC(%;<:T((L%:13-(RM:e:T((I%:+2(RM:e:T((>,:C-:"*+(RM:e:T((

(7D@OD<(`U((Ri(,-VT((/DFL(`S`(^(8LD[DLF<O(,`:cc.((/DFL(,,`,(^(_M(S-V`g((/@<F@(,``(()=EL=?D(,,g,((/DFL(<=:(,,`,(f(_M(S-V`g(((

(!:&&:,V-((!:&&:,VV(((!:&&:,U`(((!:&&:,Ug((!:&&:,d,((!:&&:,dU(

#,.:!*(%(50502.(%(!"( +AA@K@FL(@<(BCD(50502.(=A(BCD(!"( I*8(R,SBC(%;<:T( /DFL(,UUS(f(_M(S-V`,(

!:&&:,VU( ( N( ( ( ( (

#,.:+!*(!0()(!"(%-,*(",(%-,()(C2*.(

)CD(CDHDO@BFH;(>H@<KD??Q(?CD(JC=(@?(GHDFB(@<(BCD(!"D(>FLD(=A(AFKD(F<O(PDFEB@AEL(@<(BCD()J=("LEID?(

9!.(R!I:(&iT( !)(,`( _:&&:dc( ( ( N( ( ( (

#,.:+!*(2,&*'("12&*'(%3*(),2*()"(!"()(%-,2(

)CD(CDHDO@BFH;( >H@<KD??Q( GHDFB( =A( AF[=HQ( LFO;( =A(KCFHIQ( ?JDDB( =A( L=[DQ(JC=( A@LL?( BCD( !"(J@BC(CDH(PDFEB;(

G..(R!I:(&iT((

!)(,( _:&&:d.( ( ( N( ( ( (

#,.:+!*(2,*("12*("%2*(*02(%32()"(!"()(),2*(%12*(

2DHDO@BFH;(>H@<KD??Q(GHDFB(=A(AF[=H?Q(I@?BHD??(=A(D[DH;(LF<OQ(A@LL@<G(BCD(!"(F?(PDL=[DO(=A(BCD(]@<G(

M,&#'2$-(R!I:(&&&^&iT((

))(,d.( _:&&:cd( ( ( N( ( ( (

#,*.$-(+2(#2(%12*()(!"$-( +<D(JC=(JF?(C@?(D;D?(JCD<(BCD(]@<G(JF?(@<(BCD(!"(

U%:67)%(R!I:(&&T( ))(dS( _:&&:V.( ( ( N( ( ( (

#")1%(!"( !BBD<OF<B(=A(BCD(!"( I%:+2(RM:e:T( )=EL=?D(,,g,( !:&&:,d,( N( ( ( ( (

!%/2.(&%'(%12*()(!"$-( #FH?(=A(BCD(]@<G(@<(C@?(!"( E-,:1/,J(R!I:(&&&T((B0:1,(R5FI:(&&T(

))(,-c(((

_:&&:gV(((

( ( N( N( ( (

Page 644: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-,c(

84(US-( _:&&:,S,(!%/2.(>,()(!"$-( #FH?(=A(BCD(2=HE?(@<(C@?(!"( 67)%:):#+*(R)CEB:(

&&&(f(!I:(&&T())(dU( _:&&:.U( ( ( N( ( ( (

!<()(8+2(%(#).(!"( +<D(JC=(=PD;?(BCD(LFJ?(=A(BCD(=<D(JC=(@?(@<(BCD(!"(

!7)%:):"3(R)CEB:(&&&(f(!I:(&&T(

))(gV( _:&&:S`( ( ( N( ( ( (

!<(,(!"(+,#(8,("12*( +<D(JC=(D<BDH?(BCD(!"(F<O(K=ID?(A=HBC(PDFH@<G(>HF@?D?ZAF[=H?(

M,&#'2$-(R!I:(&&&^&iT((L!:)1&#'2(R!I:(&&&^&iT((

))(,d.((())(VV(

_:&&:cd(((_:&&:g`(

( ( N( ( ( (

!<(",(%3$-(51,2()(!"( +<D(JC=(CF?(FKKD??(B=(C@?(7=HO(@<(BCD(?FKHDO(>LFKD(@<(BCD(!"(

G%&2':%.(R)CEB:(&&&(f()CEB:(&iT(

))(c`( _:&&:Sg( ( ( N( ( ( (

2!()%/(&",.:'*+()(C%2*("0*.(2,2()(!"(

3<@\ED(DAA@K@D<B(FB(BCD(CDFO(=A(BCD(K=EHB@DH?(LDFODH(=A(BCD(GHDFB(=<D?(=A(BCD(!"(

B0:1,(R5FI:(&&T( "C@LFODL>C@FQ(3<@[:(ME?DEI(#:(VS`(

_:&&:,V.( ( ( ( N( ( (

2!(",(5-52(%(#).&2'(!"( )CD(=<D(JC=(@?(E>=<(BCD(>E>@L?(=A(BC=?D(JC=(FHD(@<(BCD(!"(

l7)%:"*+(R!I:(&&&T( 84(VgS( _:&&:cS( ( ( N( ( ( (

2!(",:/2(%(#).(!"( 3<@\ED(A=H(BCD(=<D(JC=(@?(@<(BCD(!"( N-^"!+.(R/D?:(&T( !??@EB(,( !:&&:S,( N( ( ( ( ( (2!*.(#).2(/*(!"( 3<@\ED(=A(BCD(=<D?(JC=(FHD(@<(BCD(!"(( U%:67)%(R!I:(&&T( ))(dS( _:&&:V.( ( ( N( ( ( (2!*.(2!*.2(%&*'(#).(!"&*'( )CD(E<@\ED(=A(BCD(E<@\ED(=<D?(=A(BCD(=<D(JC=(

RBCD(]@<GT(@?(@<(BCD(!"&*'(N5:N"2*.:#2$-:!%/(R+?=H]=<(&T(

b#(ScV.c( 8:&&:,( ( ( ( ( N( (

230:",()(20*(!"( +<D(JC=(@?(KLDFH(?@GCBDO(=<(BCD(JF;(=A(BCD(!"( I%:%:92*(R2FB?C:T((9,(+,(2,(6(7)%:"*+(R!I:(&&&T(

_M(,V,S(((MDI>C@?(

_:&&:`S((((_:&&:Ug(

( ( N( ( ( (

2+()0!*()(8,*:8,2("%;(1.(,(!"(%(%3$1(

%@?>D<KDH(=A(hE?B@KD(OF@L;(F<O(JC=(>HD?D<B?(@B(B=(BCD(!"(=A(@B?(7=HO(

L!:)1&#'2(R!I:(&&&^&iT((

))(VV( _:&&:g`( ( ( N( ( ( (

2+(*02.(>,()(!"$-( +<D(JC=(=>D<?(BCD()J=(7F<O?(=A(2=HE?(@<(C@?(!"( l7)%:):"0*(R)CEB:(&&&(f(!I:(&&T(

))(dc( _:&&:S-( ( ( N( ( ( (

Page 645: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-,g(

2,(2,2(?$$@(!"( 4HDFBD?B(=A(BCD(GHF<ODD?(W@<(BCDX(!"( mEDD<($DADHBFH@(R(5FI:(&&T(

84(`.,V`( _:&:V,( ( ( ( N( ( (

2,()(!"( !<(@I>=HBF<B(IF<(@<(BCD(!"( I3;:"*+(R)CEB:(&iT( ))(US( _:&&:US( ( ( N( ( ( (2,("12*()(!"(%(%12*(!%/(250(1%3(

4HDFB(=A(>HF@?D?(@<(BCD(!"(=A(BCD(]@<G( E/*:)#%(R!I:(&&&T( 8F@H=(Y( _:&&:UV( ( ( N( ( ( (

2,(/%*(%(>,(%3(!"( 8C@DA(=A(BCD(2FH@I(=A(2=HE?Q(7=HO(=A(BCD(!"( 5FI:(&&( 7EN=H(.( _:&:V.( ( ( ( N( ( (2,(C-.*()(!"J(C-.*$1()(!"( RMEBT(GHDFB(=A(O@G<@B;(@<(BCD(!"J(2DHRMEBl?T(

O@G<@B;(@<(BCD(!"(5FI:(i&( _M(,d`( _:&:U-( ( ( ( N( ( (

2,2(!"( )CD(GHDFB(=<D?(=A(BCD(!"(( U%:67)%(R!I:(&&T( ))(dS( _:&&:V.( ( ( N( ( ( (2")&2'(*+.(%12*(%(#).:!"( 1@H?B(H=;FL(CDHFLO(=A(BCD(=<D(JC=(@?(@<(BCD(!"( M,&#'2$-(R!I:(&&&^

&iT())(,d.( _:&&:cd( ( ( N( ( ( (

)00(%-,2$-(/!#$-()(!"$-( +<D(JC=(?DD?(C@?(PDFEB;(JCD<(CD(F>>DFH?(@<(C@?(!"(

!.(R!I:(&iT( !)(.V( _:&&:dd( ( ( N( ( ( (

)00(%12*(%(51,2(!"&*'( 5=;FL(=[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(?FKHDO(>LFKD?(=A(BCD(!"&*'( 4?0;@:%:A%12((R+?=H]=<(&&T(

84(`..,Sa(b#(Sc`.da(eFH<F](8FKCDBBD(<=:(,V`(

8:&&:U( ( ( ( ( N( (

)00&2'(51,2(!"( +[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(?FKHDO(>LFKD?(=A(BCD(!"( N1:A%12:#2$-:!%/(R)F]DL=B(&T((E/*$-:92*(R+?=H]=<(&&&(f()F]DL=B(&&&T(((=(R+?=H]=<(&&&T(

84(VVd(((8F@H=(84(`..,,a(b#(Sc,Vda(eFH<F](8FKCDBBD(<=:(Scg(((_DHL@<(,c.c.(

8:&&:.(((8:&&:,c(((((8:&&:,g(

( ( ( ( N( (

)0!(?%@(>,()(!"()(8,*:8,2(%*(,!(?%3@(

+<D(BHED(WB=X(2=HE?(@<(BCD(!"(OEH@<G(BCD(K=EH?D(=A(WD[DH;X(OF;(

I3;:"*+(R)CEB:(&iT( ))(US( _:&&:US( ( ( N( ( ( (

&90!*'(3%,*(),2&*'()(!"(%(#*$1(L!(

/JDDB(L=[DO(@<(BCD(!"(P;(C@?(AFBCDH(5F( B0:1,(R/DB;(&(f(5FI:((&&T(

))(,-U( _:&&:,.g( ( ( ( N( ( (

)%(?$$@((,(%""(8,(!"&*'( 1@HI(W::X(DBDH<FLL;(@<(BCD(!"&*'( M,&#'2$-(R!I:(&&&^&iT(

))(,d.( _:&&:cd( ( ( N( ( ( (

)%/(55("0+(",(1C)(!"( #AADKB@[D(=A(?DKHDB(?>DDKC(@<(BCD(PE?@<D??(=A(BCD( 9%:*2:"*+(R/D?:(&T( 84(.-VSd( !:&&:S.( N( ( ( ( ( (

Page 646: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-,d(

!"(()":#3(>,(%3(!"( 1F[=H@BD(=A(2=HE?Q(7=HO(=A(BCD(!"( N"2*.(R)CEB:(&&&(f(

2FB?C:T((E3:%*,2(R+?=H]=<(&&(f(2FH?D@D?D(!T(

))(,,(((84(`...Va(b#(ScV.,a(eFH<F](8FKCDBBD(<=:(S`c(

_:&&:.`(((8:&&:S(

( ( N( ( N( (

)*.()0!()(30"(%3$-(#,(0/(%(%3(!"&*'(%:!0:%()%/$-(%(%12*(

)HEL;(>HDK@?D(=<D(@<(BCD(>HD?D<KD(=A(C@?(7=HO(JC=(O@O(JCFB(@?(E?DAEL(AH=I(BCD(7=HO(=A(BCD(!"&*'(F?(IEKC(F?(CD(JF?(DAA@K@D<B(A=H(BCD(]@<G(

67)%:):#+*(R)CEB:(&&&(f(!I:(&&T(

))(dU( _:&&:.U( ( ( N( ( ( (

)*.(*%%(1,2(%(!"(( "HDK@?DQ(JC=I(=AA@K@FL?(=A(BCD(!"(>H=I=BD( N##:#P2(R/D?:(&T( _DHL@<(,,dd( !:&&:`-( N( ( ( ( ( (%3(!"( Re@<GZ2=HE?(YT(7=HO(=A(BCD(!"( /D?:(&&(

(N1,:;0:,:1%(R)CEB:(&iT(

7FCE<(,(())(Sg(

!:&:d((_:&&:U.(

N( ( N( ( ( (

%3(!"(( RMDHB?DGDHT(7=HO(A(BCD(!"( I*:",/+C$-(R5FI:(&&&T(

))(`S( _:&&:,U-( ( ( ( N( ( (

%3(1/0()*.(!"( 7=HO(=A(BCD(>DHADKB(HDIDIPHF<KDZHD>EBD(@<(BCD(!"(

F%)#(R,.BC(%;<:T( M@KCFDL@O@?(/BDLF(!((((

!:&&:,-c( N( ( ( ( ( (

%3(1/0(%-,()(!"(( 7=HO(=A(G==O(HDIDIPHF<KDZHD>EBD(@<(BCD(!"( A%*.:8*.:):"0*(R,.BC(%;<:T((A%*.:8*.:):"0*(R,SBC(%;<:T(((9!.(R/DB;(&T(

_M(.,g(W.`SX(((I+N!?CI(RDN(mEDD<?(8(m8(,,-dT((_HENDLLD?(ME?DEI(#VS--(

!:&&:,,-(((!:&&:,.c((((_:&&:,.U(

N( N( ( ( ( (

&F,*:>;02'(%3*(!"( 7FO;(=A(BCD(!"( 2=HDICDP((/DB;(&((

eFH<F](d(((eFH<F](,,((

_:&:.g((_:&:SU((

( ( N( N( ( (

Page 647: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-.-(

/DB;(&((5FI:(&&((5FI:(&&&((5FI:(&i((((((L!:%-,(R)CEB:(&&&(f(!I:(&&&Z&iT((>,(R,gBC(%;<:T((B0:1,(R5FI:(&&T(

eFH<F](,.((eFH<F](,`((MDO@<DB(2FPE(,(("FLD?B@<D(!HKCFD=L=G@KFL(ME?DEI(=A(bDHE?FLDI(SU:,ddS((!<@PF(((MM!(.S:g((7@[DH>==L(8@B;(ME?DEI(&<[:(.`:d:--:d.(

_:&:Sc((_:&:`c((_:&:VV((_:&:Vd((((((_:&&:V(((_:&&:,,,((_:&&:,SS(((

R+BCDH(G=OOD??D?T(%3*(!"(&),2*'(

7FO;(=A(BCD(!"(RPDL=[DOT( !I:(&&&((!I:(&&&(()EB:((MDHD<>BFC((5FI:(&&&((I%:%:92*(R2FB?C:T((

8F@H=(,((8F@H=(,((b#(U,`g,((MDI>C@?(.((!PE(/@IPDL(())(SVS(((

_:&:,U((_:&:,U((_:&:.`((_:&:`d((_:&:Vc((_:&&:`-(((

( ( N( N( ( (

Page 648: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-.,(

>,.(R5FI:(&&&T((

eCFHB=EI(S-U,( _:&&:,UV(

&%12*(3#*.('(?$$@(%3()(!"(%(67+*:12*(

Re@<G(=A(3>>DH(F<O(7=JDH(#G;>BT(W::X(7=HO(=A(BCD(!"(=A()CDPD?(

2=HDICDP( 84(,S:,:.,:,`( _:&:.d( ( ( N( ( ( (

%12*(%*,(%3(+*(%*,(!0()(!"(%(67%32:"5((

R!IE<^5DT(]@<G(=A(BCD(G=O?Q(BCD(GHDFB(G=O(@<(BCD(!"(=A(BCD(*C@BD(*FLL(RMDI>C@?T(

=(R.-BC(%;<:T( 84(,,.-( _:&&:,g,( ( ( ( N( ( (

?%12*(")*@(2,*(%3*(!"(!0*(),*()(+,:67*%(

7FO;(=A(BCD(!"Q(GHDFB(=A(L=[D(@<(BCD(2=E?D(=A(!BD<(

!I:(&i( !IFH<F(.( _:&:.-( ( ( N( ( ( (

%12*(1%2(%12*()(!"&*'$-( )CD(?DK=<O(=A(BCD(]@<G(RJCD<T(BCD(]@<G(@?(@<(C@?(!"&*'((

N5:N"2*.:#2$-:!%/(R+?=H]=<(&&(f(2FH?@D?D(!T(

84(`..-ca(b#(SUdS,a(eFH<F](8FKCDBBD(<=:(,V.(

8:&&:`( ( ( ( ( N( (

%5)(/,2$#()(!"( /JDDB(=A([=@KD(@<(BCD(!"( =(R!I:(&iT( !)(,g( _:&&:dg( ( ( ( ( ( (,(18?,,()@(!"( />=]D?IF<(JC=(IF]D?ZKFE?D?(>DFKD(W@<X(BCD(!"( 67)%:"*+(R)CEB:(

&&&T(84(VV,( _:&&:,S( ( ( N( ( ( (

,/(%12*(2,(!"&*'$-( !K\EF@<BF<KD(=A(BCD(]@<GQ(GHDFB(=A(C@?(!"&*'((

67)%:):#%*(R(/CD?C=<\(&&&(^(2FH?@D?D(_T(

84(gg`( 8:&&:,S( ( ( ( ( N( (

,/(1C)(%(!"((

+<D(JC=(]<=J?(BCD(PE?@<D??(@<(BCD(!"( !"0(R,-^,,BC(%;<:T( _DH?CDC(g( !:&&:,`( N( ( ( ( ( (

,/(1C*0(%3(%(!"( +<D(JC=(]<=J?(FLL(BCD(?DKHDB?(=A(BCD(!"( N"2*.(R)CEB:(&&&(f(2FB?C:T((67)%:):"0*(R!I:(&&T(

))(,,((())(`g(

_:&&:.`(((_:&&:V,(

( ( N( ( ( (

8,(",.:#3(%(#).(!"( 1F[=HDO(=A(BCD(=<D(JC=(@?(@<(BCD(!"( G%&2':%.(R)CEB:(&&&(f()CEB:(&iT(

))(c`( _:&&:Sg( ( ( N( ( ( (

"0+(&8*'(",(1/,2(!"( *C=(]DD>?(?@LD<KD(FP=EB(BCD(PE?@<D??(=A(BCD(!"( B0:1,(R5FI:(&&T((B0:1,(R5FI:(&&T((

)F<@?((84(US-(

_:&&:,S-((_:&&:,S,(

( ( ( N( ( (

Page 649: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-..(

"0*.:!(!"( )CD(>H@<KD(=A(BCD(!"( Y(R/CD?C=<\(&&&(^(2FH?@D?D(_T(((E/*$-:92*(R+?=H]=<(&&&(f()F]DL=B(&&&T(

84(`..S.a(b#(SUUUVa(eFH<F](8FKCDBBD(<=:(dd((8F@H=(84(`..,,a(b#(Sc,Vda(eFH<F](8FKCDBBD(<=:(Scg(

8:&&:,.((((8:&&:,c(

( ( ( ( N( (

"0*.2:!(!"(51-(%12*( "H@<KD?(=A(BCD(!"(A=H(BCD(>H=BDKB@=<(=A(BCD(]@<G( !I:(&&:( MDI>C@?( !:&:g( N( ( ( ( ( ("0*.:!(%(2,2(!"(&):30"(%12*'( 7DFODH(=A(BCD(GHDFB?(=A(BCD(!"(@<(BCD(H=;FL(

>HD?D<KD(E3:!7)%(R/DB;(&T((B0:1,:2(R5FI:(&&T(

84(,,`-((_M(Ugc(

_:&&:,..((_:&&:,SV(

( ( ( N( ( (

?")$-@(!"!(%(1/!#$-(()(!"$-( 2@?(MFhD?B;(FH@?D?(@<(GL=H;(@<(C@?(!"(

(

"@F<]C;! b#(`c-gV^`c-gU^`c-gc^`c-gg^`c-gd(

8:&:VU( ( ( ( ( N( (

")(1),()0!(%(2,2(!"( 5=;FL(BHED(AH@D<O(=A(BCD(GHDFB?(=A(BCD(!"( B0:5#:92*(R+?=H]=<(&&(f()F]DL=B(&&T(

8F@H=(84(`..,ga(b#(Sc,VVa(eFH<F](8FKCDBBD(<=:(`Ud(

8:&&:g( ( ( ( ( N( (

>%2*(!"( M@?BHD??(=A(BCD(!"( =(R!I:(&&&(YT(((>0*.:!(R,gBC(%;<:T(((N"2*.(R5FI:(&&T(((

_H==]L;<((ME?DEI(`c:,.-:S((eCFHB=EI(ME?DEI(```U(())(`V(

_:&&:,,d(((_:&&:,,g(((_:&&:,`V(

( ( N( N( ( (

>%2*(),2*()(!"()(%3(%*,2( M@?BHD??(L=[DO(@<(BCD(!"(P;(FLL(BCD(G=O?( 2=HDICDP(RYT( eFH<F](d( _:&:.c( ( ( N( ( ( (>,(!"( 2=HE?(=A(BCD(!"( Q)12:,%:13(R,.BC(

%;<:T(84(.-.cg( !:&&:dU( N( ( ( ( ( (

>,()(!"$&-'( 2=HE?(=A(BCDRZC@?T(!"( l7)%:):"0*(R)CEB:(&&&(f(!I:(&&T((

))(dc(((

_:&&:S-(((

( ( N( N( ( (

Page 650: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-.S(

G%2%0(R)CEB:(&iT((I3;:"*+(R)CEB:(&iT((67)%:21,(R)CEB:(&&&(f(!I:(&&T((

))(cU(())(US(())(,S,((

_:&&:VU((_:&&:US((_:&&:SU((

>,()(+,(/,+(!"( 2=HE?(@<(BCD(+,(/,+(!"( /DB;(&((=(R,dBC(%;<:T(

!P;O=?(S(()EH@<(..-VS((

_:&:S`((_:&&:,cV(

( ( ( N( ( (

>,(%3(!"&*'( 2=HE?(7=HO(=A(BCD(!"&*'( =(R!I:(&&&T((((((I0:67%+2(R!I:(&&&T((>,:2,:,!(R!I:(&&&T((((>3:!0(R!I:(&&&T((L!:10:"*+:#3:!%/(RM:e:T((("@F<]C;(

/@<F@(dg(^(+&M(gUUS(R+H@D<BFL(&<?B@BEBD(ME?DEIQ(8C@KFG=Q(3/!T(((/@<F@(gc(((/@<F@(gg(^(I"C@L3<@[(#(,V-S-(!^8(((/@<F@(.V(^(I8F@H=(b#(SgVcS((7D@OD<(`,(Ri(cT(((b#(`c-gV^`c-gU^`c-gc^`c-gg^`c-gda(_DHL@<(

!:&&:c`((((((!:&&:g-((!:&&:g,((((!:&&:gU(((!:&&:,c-(((8:&:V(

N( N( ( ( ( (

Page 651: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-.`(

,-Ug(

>,(",.:#3(Q5.*(%3(G0:C(",.:#3(!"(),2*(

2=HE?(JC=(@?(@<(BCD(1F@;EIQ(IF?BDH(=A(BCD(LF]D^LF<O(>LDF?@<G(BCD(!"D(PDL=[DO(

mEDD<(I3;:;0:L!(R,.BC^,SBC(%;<:T(

#N(K1FH=E]( !:&:,.( ( N( ( ( ( (

",.:+,(%(!"((

MFh=HO=I=ZO=ID?B@K(?DH[F<B(=A(BCD(!"( I%3(R,SBC(%;<:T( 7D@OD<(`U((Ri(,-VT( !:&&:,V-( ( N( ( ( ( (

",.:*+(1),2(!"( !B(BCD(CDFO(=A(BCD(K=I>F<@=<?(=A(BCD(!"( I%&#':%-,(R2FB?C:T( ))(dd( _:&&:`g( ( ( N( ( ( (",.:1C*0(!"(C+1( eDD>DH(=A(?DKHDB?(=A(BCD(FEGE?B(!"( I3;:"*+(R5FI:(&'T( /@<F@(S-.( _:&&:,UV( ( ( ( N( ( (",.:1C*0(%(1*(2,*()(!"(2,( eDD>DH(=A(?DKHDB?(@<(BCD(GHDFB(>LFKD(=A(BCD(GHDFB(

!"(67)%:):"0*:%:!%/(R!I:(&&&T(

7=E[HD(#(,,-VS( !:&&:UV( N( ( ( ( ( (

",.:1C*0(1*2(!"( eDD>DH(=A(?DKHDB?(@<(BCD(=AA@KD?(=A(BCD(!"( B0:%"1.(R5FI:(&&T( _M(#!(,Scc( _:&&:,Sg( ( ( ( N( ( ("1?#@(>,()(!"( "HF@?@<G(2=HE?(@<(BCD(!"( I%:%-,(R,gBC(%;<:T( 84(VVU( _:&&:,,`( ( ( N( ( ( ("1.(%(#).(!"( "HF@?DOZAF[=HDO(=<D(@<(BCD(!"( !7)%:):"3(R)CEB:(

&&&(f(!I:(&&T((>;0:,:%""(R()CEB:(&iT((G%2%0(R)CEB:(&iT((I3;:"*+(R)CEB:(&iT((

))(gV((())(U`((())(cU(())(US((

_:&&:S`((((_:&&:VV(((_:&&:VU((_:&&:US((

( ( N( ( ( (

"?1.@(%(%3(*02.()(!"( "HF@?DOZAF[=HDO(=<D(=A(BCD(7=HO(=A(BCD()J=(7F<O?(=A(BCD(!"(

67)%:"*+(R!I:(&&T( ))(8,( _:&&:V-( ( ( N( ( ( (

"112(>,(",.:#3(!"( 1F[=HDO(P;(2=HE?(JC=(@?(@<(BCD(!"( N-^"!+.(R/D?:(&T( !??@EB(,( !:&&:S,((

N( ( ( ( ( (

"*+:#3(>,(%3(!"( "LDF?@<G(B=(2=HE?Q(7=HO(=A(BCD(!"( N-^"!+.(R/D?:(&T((67)%:):"0*(R!I:(&&&T(

!??@EB(,((2FIIFIFB(`S(((

!:&&:S,((!:&&:c-(((

N( ( ( ( ( (

/2(%(#).:!"( "H=BDKB=H(=A(BCD(=<D(JC=(@?(@<(BCD(!"( N"2*.:"*+(R!I:(&&( _DH?CDC(.( ((!:&&:V.( N( ( ( ( ( (

Page 652: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-.V(

^(/D?:(&&&T((

(

/,+(!"( !B(BCD(CDFO(=A(BCD(!"( 9%*2:%12(R,.BC(%;<:T((!%/:1%(R,SBC(%;<:T((((F#02(R,SBC(%;<:T(((F#02(R,SBC(%;<:T(((F#02(R,SBC(%;<:T(((F#02(R,SBC(%;<:T((((E3:,:1"2.(R,SBC(%;<:T(((((=(R,SBC(%;<:T((67)%.:;)$1(RM:e:T((>%;2(RM:e:T(

%FC?CEH(&(((/DFL(SS,(^(_M(ScUdV(RDN(MEHKC(8=LLDKB@=<T((/DFL(Sdc(^(38(,,`.g(((/DFL(Sdg(^(38(,,`g-((/DFL(`--(^(8C@KFG=(,gVg,((/DFL(`-,(^(M@KCFDL@O@?(8=LLDKB@=<(((/DFL(UU.(^(M@KCFDL@O@?(8=LLDKB@=<(RDN(_LF<KCFHO(8=LLDKB@=<T((/DFL(,g,V((84(.-`SV((38(,`UdU(

!:&&:,,c(((!:&&:,Vc((((!:&&:,Vg(((!:&&:,Vd(((!:&&:,U-(((!:&&:,U,((((!:&&:,U.((((((!:&&:,US((!:&&:,gS((!:&&:,dV(

N( N( N( ( N( (

Page 653: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-.U(

(I%:%:92*(R2FB?C:T((M,&#'2$-(R!I:(&&&^&iT((M,&#'2$-(R!I:(&&&^&iT((40;:%:,%-(R"?FI:(&T((B0:5#:>,2&+'JB0:5#:>,:)5%(R"?FI:(&T((EX:B*"(R"?FI:(&T((I)0:*02.:*-:%/*(R"?FI:(&T((I)0:*02.:*-:%/*(R"?FI:(&T((>,2:#,:!0(R"?FI:(&&T((B1)*;:1%3(R"?FI:(&&T((E/*:>,2:"3(R"?FI:(&&T(

()CDPD?(S((())(,d.(((_EPF?B@?(((/F\\FHF(7(.`(((b#(`Sc,,((((_M(#!(,SS(()F<BF(<=:(Ud`(((8F@H=(Y(((7=E[HD(%(UV(Rp(b#(SgUcT((iFB@KF<(<=:(,UU(((7=E[HD(!(d`((

(_:(&&:`V(((_:&&:cd(((_:&&:g,(((8:&&:.,(((8:&&:..((((8:&&:.`((8:&&:.V(((8:&&:.U(((8:&&:.g(((8:&&:.d(((8:&&:S-((

Page 654: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-.c(

(E/*:>,2:"3(R"?FI:(&&T((E/*:>,2:"3(R"?FI:(&&T((E;02(R"?FI:(&&T((((((B0-:*02&:)':!2:E*(R!IF?@?T((67!":)1&:10:E*'(R!IF?@?T((67!":)1&:10:E*'(R!IF?@?T((B0:5#:%&#':Y1*(R!IF?@?T((B1)*;(R!IF?@?T((B1)*;(R!IF?@?T((B1)*;(R!IF?@?T((M%)2:#3:L!2:)%(R!IF?@?T(

(_M(#!(,U`U(((iFB@KF<(<=:(,`-(((!#&$(,U`g(^(_=L=G<FQ(ME?D=(8@[@K=(!HKCD=L=G@K=(e/(,gSg((7=E[HD(!(dS(((/B=K]C=LI($:(M:(,((7=E[HD(%(V-(((8F@H=(<=:(&(S`(U`g(((/F\\FHF(RFT((84(cg`((/F\\FHF(RPT((_M(#!(,S`(Rg,dT((

(8:&&:S,(((8:&&:S.(((8:&&:S`((((((8:&&:Sc(((8:&&:,d(((8:&&:`-(((8:&&:`S(((8:&&:`V((8:&&:`U((8:&&:`c((8:&&:`d((

Page 655: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-.g(

(><0:):10$-(R!IF?@?T((!%/:>,2(R.UBC(%;<:T((=(R.UBC(%;<:T((

(/F\\FHF(RKT(((8F@H=(<=Y((()EH@<(..-,((

(8:&&:V-(((8:&&:V,(((8:&&:VS(

/,+(!"(,1( !B(BCD(CDFOZK=<BH=LLDH(=A(BCD(!"(( 67!":)1&:10:E*'(R!IF?@?T(((F0":#3:L!2(R!IF?@?T((B0:5#:%&#':Y1*(R!IF?@?T((

7=E[HD(#(.V(Sd-(^(_H==]L;<($0(Vd:cc((_M(#!(,,,(Rg,gT(((8F@H=(<=:(&(S`U`g(

8:&&:`,((((8:&&:..(((8:&&:``(

( ( ( ( N( (

/,+(,1(%12*(!"( %@HDKB=H(=A(BCD(H=;FL(GEFHO(=A(BCD(!"( 67!":)1&:10:E*'(R!IF?@?T(

M=?\ED(Vc`-(q(_H==]L;<(7(cg:`U:.(

8:&&:Sg( ( ( ( ( N( (

?8%$;(%3(*02.(#2(>,@()(+,$-(#*-(#*.2(%12*()(!"$-(

0=E(RBCD([@j@DHT(F>>H=FKC(BCD(7=HO(=A(BCD(BJ=(LF<O?(JCD<(2=HE?(@?(@<(C@?(C=E?DQ(BCD(AFBCDH^]@<G(JCD<(BCD(HEL@<G(]@<G(@?(@<(C@?(!"(

F:1,(R)CEB:(&&&(f(!I:(&&T(

)CDPD?(.( _:&&:Sc( ( ( ( ( N( (

1!,()0!*(,(!"((( +<D(JC=(HF@?D?(E>(MFlFB(B=(BCD(!"((((

9%*2:>*+(R/D?:(&T( 84(.-VSd( !:&&:S.( N( ( ( ( ( (

1(%-,(,(!"( _DFEB@AEL(IF<(@<(BCD(!"( 67%:#*$-(R)CEB:(&&&T( 7=E[HD(8(.U( _:&&:,-( ( ( N( ( ( (

10(L!(%3(!"( /=<(=A(5FQ(7=HO(=A(BCD(!"( "@F<]C;( 4DPDL(_FH]FL( 8:&:S( ( ( ( ( N( (1!0$%(%3(*02.()(!"( +<D(JC=I(BCD(7=HO(=A(BCD()J=(7F<O?(KFE?DO(B=(

PD(GHDFB(@<(BCD(!"(>;0:,:%""(R)CEB:(&iT(

))(U`( _:&&:VU( ( ( N( ( ( (

Page 656: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-.d(

1!,()0!*(,(!"( +<D(JC=(>HD?D<B?(BHEBCZFKB?(H@GCBAELL;(B=JFHO?(BCD(!"(

U%:67)%(R!I:(&&T( ))(dS( _:&&:V.( ( ( N( ( ( (

1)0.(>,(",.:K3(!"( !??=K@FBDO(=A(2=HE?(JC=(@?(@<(BCD(k"( 67)%.(R,.BC(%;<:T( #jPDB(5E?CO@( !:&&:,,`( N( ( ( ( ( (1),(!"( 8=I>F<@=<(=A(BCD(!"( E3:!%/(R,SBC(%;<:T( I"@BB(8FH<@DGD(

`VVg(!:&&:c.( ( N( ( ( ( (

1),(>,(%3(!"( 1H@D<O(=A(2=HE?Q(7=HO(=A(BCD(!"( I*+:#3:*:,!(R!I:(&&&T( 84(.-VSg( !:&&:U`( N( ( ( ( ( (1),(/,+(!"(%12*( 8=I>F<@=<(FB(BCD(CDFO(=A(BCD(!"(=A(BCD(]@<G( I%:%:92*(

R2FB?C:T(84(Vcd( _:&&:`c( ( ( N( ( ( (

1),(/,+(*02.(%&!'(%3(!"&*'((

1H@D<O(=A(BCD(=<D(JC=(O@HDKB?(BCD(BJ=(7F<O?(A=H(BCD(7=HO(=A(BCD(!"&*'((

67)%:):#%*(R/CD?C=<\(&&&(^(2FH?@D?D(_T(

84(gg`( 8:&&:,S( ( ( ( ( N( (

1),(*+.(8%$%(>,()(8%2(!"$-( 1@H?B(K=I>F<@=<(JC=(F>>H=FKCD?(2=HE?(J@BC@<(C@?(8%2(!"(

E-,:1/,J(R!I:(&&&T( ))(,-c( _:&&:gV( ( ( N( ( ( (

1),(*;%(!<(",(!"( 8=I>F<@=<(JC=(F>>H=FKCDO(F<O(D<BDHDO(BCD(!"( E-,:1/,J(R!I:(&&&T( ))(,-c( _:&&:gV( ( ( N( ( ( (1),2(#).(!"(( 8=I>F<@=<?(JC=(FHD(@<(BCD(!"( >2.(R)EB:T( ))(`-( _:&&:,-S( ( ( N( ( ( ([1),2](!<&.2'()(!"( 8=I>F<@=<?(@<B@IFBD?(=A(BCD(!"( !I:(&&( eFH<F](c( _:&:,`( ( ( N( ( ( (1),2(2,2(!"( 8=I>F<@=<?(F<O(GHF<ODD?(=A(BCD(!"( L!:)1&#'2(R!I:(&&&^

&iT(((B0:1,(R/DB;(&(f(5FI:(&&T(((

))(VV((())(,-U(

_:&&:g`((((_:&&:,.g(((

( ( ( N( ( (

1/%?*@.(&%$-'(1*$-()(!"( +<D(JC=?D(>=?@B@=<Z?BFBE?(JF?(>H=I=BDO(@<(BCD(!"((

9%:/+,:,!:1%3&2'(R)CEB:(&&Z&&&(f(!I:(&&T((N"2*.(R)CEB:(&&&(f(2FB?C:T((

))gU(((())(,,(

_:&&:V((((_:&&:.`(

( ( N( ( ( (

1/%*.(?$$@(1*()(!"$-( +<D(JC=?D(>=?@B@=<Z?BFBE?(JF?(>H=I=BDO(@<(BCD(!"(

N"2*.(R)CEB:(&&&(f(2FB?C:T((

))(,,(((

_:&&:.`(((

( ( N( ( ( (

Page 657: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-S-(

(

( (

9%:/+,:L!:I%3(R,gBC(%;<:T(

))(,,.( _:&&:,,c(

1/,.(!"( 8=IIF<ODH(=A(BCD(!"( I0:,%+2*(R/D?:(&&&'( !?JF<(B=IP(SU( !:&&:U.( N( ( ( ( ( (1C(25"2()(!"(%(?%12*@( /KH@PD(=A(BCD(BFPLD(=A(=AADH@<G?(@<(BCD(!"(=A(BCD(

W]@<GX(E-,:1,:8,2(R,dBC(%;<:T(

oFJ;DB(/ELBF<( _:&&:,cV( ( ( ( N( ( (

1C(%12*(!32:,()(!"(%(%12*( 5=;FL(?KH@PD(=A(BCD(PHDF]AF?B(@<(BCD(!"(=A(BCD(]@<G(

E-,:1,:8,2(R,dBC(%;<:T(

oFJ;DB(/ELBF<( _:&&:,cV( ( ( ( N( ( (

1C(%12*()(!"(%12*( /KH@PD(=A(BCD(H=;FL(!"(( E-,:1,:/,2(R/DB;(&T( e=I(DL^!CIFH( _:&&:,.`( ( ( N( ( ( (1*0(2,2(,(!"(%12*( %HFJ@<G(=A(BCD(GHDFB(=<D?(FB(BCD(!"(=A(BCD(]@<G( E3:!7)%(R/DB;(&T( 84(,,`-( _:&&:,..( ( ( ( N( ( (15*?.@(&15*.'(>,()(!"$-( 1=H?BDH(KC@LO(=A(2=HE?(@<(C@?(!"( G%2%0(R)CEB:(&iT( ))(cU( _:&&:VU( ( ( N( ( ( (C+1#(/*,&2'(!"$-(&$$'(C+1#(1C)(!"( $=PLD(=A(JCFB(PDL=<G?(B=(C@?(!"(&$$'(<=PLD(FB(BCD(

GE@OD(=A(BCD(!"(N"2*.(R)CEB:(&&&(f(2FB?C:T(

))(,,( _:&&:.`( ( ( N( ( ( (

C%.*(1,2(>,()(!"$-( )CD(D<B=EHFGD(=A(62=HE?(@<(BCD(!"9( 67)%:21,(R)CEB:(&&&(f(!I:(&&T(

))(,S,( _:&&:SU( ( ( ( ( ( (

<%(,1:*+(%(%3(!"( _HF[DQ([@G@LF<B(A=H(BCD(7=HO(=A(BCD(!"( E".(R)CEB:(&&&T( iFH@=E?( _:&&:,d( ( ( N( ( ( (O)()5*(%*(!"( +<D(JC=(A@<O?(BCD(?>DDKC(=A(BCD(( 9%*2:>*+(R/D?:(&T( 84(.-VSd( !:&&:S.( N( ( ( ( ( (*+.:!2.(C%2*(*;%()(!"( +<D(JC=(>HDKDOD?(BCD(D<B=EHFGD(F>>H=FKC@<G(

BCD(!"(67%:#*$-(RMD<:(&&T( MM!(Vc:dV( !:&&:.( N( ( ( ( ( (

*/(!"(%12*( )CD(>LEIIDB(=A(BCD(H=;FL(!"( I0:+0:#,(R,gBC(

%;<:T(/F\\FHF(S( _:&&:,-`( ( ( N( ( ( (

M@??@<G(A@H?B(?@G<R?T($$2(1**(%(%*.()(!"( ::!?@F(A=H(BCD(=<D(JC=(@?(@<(BCD(!"( B*":JH(R!I:(&&&T( /@<F@(V`( !:&&:d-( N( ( ( ( ( (

Page 658: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-S,(

(

"#$%&'('!%)!*+,!-'./,!%)!*+,!*,01!"#$%&! 23$,0! 4%5-1,$*! 6.*.7%/!0,),0,$5,'!

!!!!89:9!

!!!!!;9:9!

!<9=9!

#N>HD??@=<?( ( ( ( #( 7( #( 7( #( 7(

0*+J-0#(/*()(+,:!0( +<D(JC=(KFHH@D?(J==O(@<(BCD(+,:!0( /D?:(&( >5D@?<DH(&&&( !:&:,U( N( ( ( ( ( (!"(#)$1(18;(*2,#()(%32()0!(%(*+(1)*((( )CD(!"(J@BC@<(@B(@?(IEKC(DIPDLL@?CDO(J@BC(

A@<D(G=LO(BHED(F<O(AHD?C(AH=I(BCD(OD?DHB(/DB;(&( !P;O=?(.( _:&:SS( ( ( ( N( ( (

!"!2(/(2/,*(%*(+,:!0( 5=F?BDH(=A(BCD(O=K];FHO(J=H]?C=>(=A(BCD(+,:!0((

/D?:(&( >5D@?<DH(&&( !:&:,V( N( ( ( ( ( (

!<2()(20/.(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3( >H=[@?@=<?(A=H(BCD((20/.(=A(BCD(+,:!0D(L:(>:(C:(

Y(R,SBC(%;<:T( >_=ELF\(,g( !:&:,c( ( N( ( ( ( (

#(5#$;(#%2(,(+,:!0(+0.$;(%3( M@GCB(;=E(G@[D(BCD(#%2(B=(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0TQ(0=EH(7=HO(

67)%:"*+(R5FI:(&'T(

eFH<F](,`( _:&&:,Ug( ( ( ( N( ( (

#2$-()(#+*(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3( 2D(JF?(=<(BCD(PE?@<D??(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0TQ(L:(>:(C:((

67)%:"*+(R5FI:(&&T(

/DCDL( _:&&:,`.( ( ( ( N( ( (

#2$-(",(C)1(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3( 2D(@?(=<(A=LL=J@<G(BCD(+,:!0D(L:(>:(C:( E3:67)%(R)CEB:(&iT(

))(d-( _:&&:Vg( ( ( N( ( ( (

#)#(*2(+0(%;*(%(*0(25.*(21-&2'(/,();(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3(",(#,*(*0(25.*(%("3(Y+0*(*%2(,%+*(#2(%&%'(21-(*2$*2(",(O,O(,("0*(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3(

)CDHDA=HD(G@[D(BCD(K=<BH@PEB@=<(B=(BCD(DN>DO@B@=<Q(<=B(>F@OQ(B=(GEFHO(BCD(+,:!0D(L:(>:(C:Q(B=(IF]D(BCD(h=EH<D;(=A(BCD(+>DB(AD?B@[FLQ(D[DH;(;DFH?Q(J@BC=EB(C@?(I@??@<GQ(B=(>HD>FHD(@<(F<B@K@>FB@=<(=A(BCD(FHH@[FL(=A(BCD(+,:!0D(L:(>:(C:((

2=HDICDP( %E>L:(84(S`,U.( _:&:.U( ( ( N( ( ( (

#%2(B0:5#:01*(10(67,*2:,&2'():30"(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3(55$%$-(+,:!0(

B0:5#:01*Q(?=<(=A(67,*2:,&2'D((JF?(PH=EGCB(B=(BCD(>HD?D<KD(=A(BCD("CFHF=CQ(L:(>:(C:Q(F<O(CD(?F@O(B=(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0TQ(L:(>:(C:(R::T(

!IF?@?( >5;LF<O?(&'( 8:&:,c( ( ( ( ( N( (

&B0:5#:01*'(#%*$-(,(+0(+,(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3(

2D(RB0:5#:01*T(CF[D(PDD<(PH=EGCB(B=(BCD(D?BFBD(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,(+,:!0T(

!IF?@?( >5;LF<O?(&'( 8:&:,c( ( ( ( ( N( (

#,(#,.(%$-(+0(%)".(2!(%(!"62(8,(*0.$-( )CD;(>H@[FBD(>DH?=<?(PE@LO(A=H(C@I(F(P=FB( 2=HDICDP( %E>L:(84(S`,U.( _:&:.U( ( ( N( ( ( (

Page 659: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-S.(

*%-.*(,(,/(C)1#(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3( =<(C@?(BD<B(B=(PD(FPLD(B=(?DH[D(BCD(+,:!0Q(L:(>:(C:(

#,(!"!2(%3(%*.("*,(,(%0(%(F!32*(12*(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3(

!?(A=H(F<;(P=FB(BCFB(@?(>EB(B=(J=H](A=H(BCD(PD<DA@B(=A(F!32*(=A(BCD(+,:!0D(L:(>:(C:(

2=HDICDP( %E>L:(84(S`,U.( _:&:.U( ( ( N( ( ( (

#,#$-(C)1#(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3( 2D(IF]D?(B=(FKK=I>F<;(BCD(+,:!0D(L:(>:(C:( 2=HDICDP( %E>L:(84(S`,U.( _:&:.U( ( ( N( ( ( (#,*(%$-(RBCD(G=OT(+,:!0(C+1#( )CD(IF]@<G(A=H(C@I(=A(F<(FEGE?B(+,:!0( /DB;(&( !P;O=?(,( _:&:S.( ( ( ( N( ( N(2%$#%(")$-(/(,(8%2(+,:!0(!%/(&2'50(1&%3'(

)CD<(C@?(@<KFH<FB@=<(?F@LDO(O=J<?BHDFI(B=(BCD(8%2(+,:!0D(L:(>:(C:(

!CI=?D( eFH<F](,(( _:&:.( ( ( N( ( ( (

2%%(%0(%(15)(?!C@(%(!*("%;*(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3(&$$'(

_D@<G(=<D(JC=(?DH[D?(RCDFH?(WBCD(KFLL@<GXT(A=H(!*(=AADH@<G?(FB(BCD(+,:!0D(L:(>:(C:(R::T(

2=HDICDP( %E>L:(84(S`,U.( _:&:.U( ( ( N( ( ( (

2%%$-(",(C)?1#(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3@( 2D(@?(=<(B=(FKK=I>F<;(WBCD(+,:!0D(L:(>:(C:X( 2=HDICDP( %E>L:(84(S`,U.( _:&:.U( ( ( N( ( ( ():)#**(%0(%(*0(1)2(%(%0(%(F!32*(12*(?+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3@(

)C=?D(JC=(K=LLDKB(BCD(A=OODH(A=H(BCD(F!32*(=A(BCD(+,:!0D(L:(>:(C:(

2=HDICDP( %E>L:(84(S`,U.( _:&:.U( ( ( N( ( ( (

)()*.(##()(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3(%$#R-( *@BC(>HDK@?@=<Q(CD(G=D?(B=(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0TQ(L:(>:(C:(

!7)%:):"3(R)CEB:(&&&(f(!I:(&&T(

))(gV( _:&&:S`( ( ( N( ( ( (

%(""(%(,%+2*(%(+,:!0(%/(250(1%3( $DKH=>=L@?(A=H(I@LL@=<(;DFH?(=A(BCD(+,:!0D(L:(>:(C(

=(R5FI:(&'T( >!PP=BB(_M(,-..,(

_:&:cU( ( ( ( N( ( (

%12*(3#*.(A+,:;0:L!()(C(%(+,:?!0@( e@<G(=A(3>>DH(F<O(7=JDH(#G;>B(/D?=?BH@?(@<(BCD(LF]D(=A(BCD(+,:?!0@(

!I:(&( MDI>C@?( !:&:g( N( ( ( ( ( (

?+0(+,@(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3( )CD(C=E?D(=A("CFHF=C(R+,:!0TQ(L:(>:(C:( !I:(&i( 4EH=P( _:&&:gd( ( ( N( ( ( (+0(%(+,.*(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3( )CD(+,.*(RC=E?D?T(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0TQ(

L:(>:(C:(!I:(&i( 4EH=P( _:&&:gd( ( ( N( ( ( (

+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3(B1)*;( )CD("CFHF=CQ(L:(>:(C:("?FIBD](( !IF?@?( >5;LF<O?(&'( 8:&:,c( ( ( ( ( N( (+,:"5(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3( )HDF?EH;(=A(BCD("CFHF=CR+,:!0TQ(L:(>:(C:( =(R/DB;(&&T( >!<F?BF?@(i&( _:&:c,( ( ( ( N( ( (+,#$#()(+0()(+,(%(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3( &(D<BDH(@<(BCD(BCD(D?BFBD(=A(BCD(+,:!0(D(L:(>:(

C:(Y(R5FI:('&T( >_M(,-SgS( _:&:gS( ( ( ( N( ( (

,)*(#2$-(!"!():30"(+,:!0(( MF<(?BF<O@<G(PDA=HD(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0T( !IF?@?( >_DHL@<(,SU,V( 8:&:,g( ( ( ( ( ( (,)*(#2$-(*2*(,(+,:!0(%(*0(<%"(+0#( !(IF<(JC=(>LDF?D?(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0T(

D[D<(@<(BCD(PDOKCFIPDH(!IF?@?( >5;LF<O?(&'( 8:&:,c( ( ( ( ( N( (

,)*(#1(+0(+,(%(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3( MF<(PDL=<G@<G(B=(BCD(D?BFBD(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,(%(+,:!0T(

!IF?@?( >5;LF<O?(&'( 8:&:,c( ( ( ( ( N( (

Page 660: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-SS(

,)*(#1(+,:!0( MF<(PDL=<G@<G(B=(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0T( !IF?@?( >5;LF<O?(&'( 8:&:,c( ( ( ( ( N( (,)*(+0(/%(%(+0(+,(+,:!0( MF<(=A(BCD(+,(+,:!0( !IF?@?( >5;LF<O?(&'( 8:&:,c( ( ( ( ( N( (,/*("132(+,:!0D(HZZ("132( !KK=E<B(=A("132Q(>FLFKDQ(.--("132( /D?:(&( >5D@?<DH(&&&( !:&:,U( ( ( ( ( ( (R")(,5#*'(*+*(W)*(#532(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3(,(C%2*(%*,(

RM;(MFhD?B;(K=IIF<ODOT(BCD(PD?B(=A(#G;>BQ(BCD(?=@L(=A(BCD(+,:!0Q(L:(>:(C:(B=(BCD(GHF<FH;(=A(O@[@<D(=AADH@<G?(

)CEB:(&&&( eFH<F](`( _:&:V( ( ( N( ( ( (

")2(2,(%(+0(2#0(%(I/)*()(+0(C(%(+,:!0(

4HDFB(?BDDH@<G(=FH(=A(BCD(P=FB(=A(I/)*(@<(BCD(LF]D(=A(BCD(+,:!0(

672%%(R)CEB:(&i(YT(

_M(,SS.( _:&&:,-g( ( ( N( ( ( (

")*(%()(1302.(%(+0(+,(%(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3(

8=>>DH(PDL=<G@<G(B=(BCD(O==H?(=A(BCD(D?BFBD(=A(BCD(+,:!0D(L:(>:(C:(

=(R5FI:('&T( >_M(,-SgS( _:&:g.((

( ( ( N( ( (

""&2'(,%+2*(%(+,:!0( R2=E?DT(=A(BCD(M@LL@=<(0DFH?(=A(BCD(B,:!0( =(R,gBC(%;<:T( >)EH@<( _:&:U,( ( ( N( ( ( (/+,(3%:+2$#(5#(+"(+,:!0(( &B(CF>>D<DO(BCFB(&(K=ELO(<=B(HDFKC(BCD(

"CFHF=C(R+,:!0T(=(R.UBC(%;<:T( >84S,,Uc( 8:&&:V`( ( ( ( ( N( (

1%5)(+2(#,$%(")$-()(8%2(+,:!0( *CFB(C@?(@<KFH<FB@=<(O@O(JF?(B=(HD?B(@<(BCD(8%2(+,:!0Q(L:(>:(C:((

!CI=?D( eFH<F](,( _:&:.( ( ( N( ( ( (

11%3(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3( +<D(JC=(IF]D?(PD(CDFLBC;(BCD(+,:!0D(L:(>:(C:(

L!:)1&#'2(R!I:(&&&T(

))(VV((

_:&&:g`((

( ( N( N( ( (

C)(+,:!0(,(+,(+,:!0( %D>FHB(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(B=(BCD(D?BFBD(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,(+,:!0T((

=(RcBC^SHO(_:8T( >%DI:/F\:&Q(BDNB(,Z,F(

8:&:,d( ( ( ( ( ( (

;0(%*,2(%2(+,:!0( )CD(;0(=A(BCD(G=O?(=A(BCD(+,:!0(R+,:!0T( B0:1,(R5FI:(&&&T( MDO@<DB(2FPE(S(

_:&&:,US( ( ( ( N( ( (

*2*2(%(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3( /BFBED(=A(BCD("CFHF=CQ(L:(>:(C:(( !IF?@?( >5;LF<O?(&'( 8:&:,c( ( ( ( ( N( (50,$#(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3( &(JF?(?EPOED(=A(BCD(+,:!0D(L:(>:(C:( I%&2':#)1(

R)CEB:(&&&T(84(.cg,V( _:&&:c( ( ( N( ( ( (

5#(%$-(")*.(+,:!0( 4@[D(B=(C@IQ(BCD(K=>>DH?I@BC(=A(BCD(+,:!0( /D?:(&( >5D@?<DH(&&( !:&:,V( N( ( ( ( ( (5#(,(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3(50*(15):!C(>,:%/*(#,+(%-,.(",(0!!()%:<,"*([(?$$@()1:80,\(*0:%3*\(#C1()(?$$@()1:80,(

4@[D<(B=(BCD(+,:!0D(L:(>:(C:Q(P;(BCD(CF<O(=A(BCD(?DH[@B=H(>,:%/*D([DH;(G==O(J@<D(@<(hFH?Q(`()%^[D??DL?Q(=A(BCD(KF>FK@B;(=A(RYTQ(()%^[D??DL?(R::T(B=GDBCDH(J@BC(,(I?^PF?]DBQ(,(*0^K=<BF@<DH(J@BC(RYT()1^PF?]DB(

!I:(&i( !IFH<F(V( _:&&:d,( ( ( N( ( ( (

5#(,(+,:!0()(!<(%(25+22(/%*.()%*(%*( %DL@[DHDO(B=(BCD(+,:!0(FB(BCD(FHH@[FL(=A(BCD( =(R,SBC(%;<:T( >_=ELF\(,g( !:&:,c( ( N( ( ( ( (

Page 661: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-S`(

C%!(55*(%(,)*(+,()%!2*()%*(%*(C%!(55*(%(!<.2(!C0(

KE>PDFHDH?(=A(BCD(+EBDH("FLFKDQ(A@NDO(>=HB@=<(=A(BCD(>H=[@?@=<@<G^\EFHBDH?(G@[D<(B=(BCD(>D=>LD(=A(BCD(C=E?D(=A(<EH?D?Q(A@NDO(>=HB@=<(=A(BCD(>H=[@?@=<@<G^\EFHBDH?(G@[D<(B=(BCD(=HO@<FH;(D<BHF<B?(

5?)#(+,:!@0(!%/(250(1%3( )CD(\EFHBDH(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0TQ(L:(>:(C:( !I:(&i( 4EH=P( _:&&:gd( ( ( N( ( ( (5)5(%*,2(,(/2$-(,(1"*+(#3(%12*:3#*.(2%%(%-,(31$1%(%12*()(!"(C+1#(

)CD(G=O?(CF[D(E<@BDO(B=(>H=BDKB(C@I(F<O(B=(>FK@A;(BCD(CDFHBC(=A(BCD(]@<G(=A(3>>DH(F<O(7=JDH(#G;>BQ(BCD;(CF[D(K=<OEKBDO(C@I(@<B=(BCD(<=PLD(!"(

/DB;(&( !P;O=?(.( _:&:SS( ( ( ( N( ( (

55(+,:!0( !%/(250( 1%3(=H(55$%$-$( +,:!0(!%/(250(1%3(

/>DDKC(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0TQ(L:(>:(C:(=H(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0T(L:(>:(C:(?F@O(

!IF?@?( >5;LF<O?(&'( 8:&:,c( ( ( ( ( N( (

)@BLD?(F<O(D>@BCDB?(#).():30"(+,:!0( +<D(JC=(@?(@<(AH=<B(=A(BCD(+,:!0( N-^"!+.(R/D?:(&T( !??@EB(,( !:&&:S,( N( ( ( ( ( (#).:,(#"2(%(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3( +[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(CDHO?(=A(BCD(+,:!0D(L:(>:(C:( 2=HDICDP( %E>L:(84(S`,U.( _:&:.U( ( ( N( ( ( (#).:,(#"2(%/*(%(%0()%)%*(%(+,:!0( +[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(CDHO?(=A(BCD(+,:!0( =(R5FI:(&&T( >4EH=P(__( _:&:US( ( ( ( N( ( (#).:,(!8%2*.(%(+,:!0( +[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(!8%2*.(=A(BCD(+,:!0( A%*.("!0&*'$#(

R,.BC(%;<:T(_M(S,d(W.V,X( !:&&:dV( N( ( ( ( ( (

#).:,(!8%2*.(%(+,:"5(+,:!0( +<D(JC=(@?(@<(BCD(!8%2*.(@<(BCD(BHDF?EH;(=A(BCD(+,:!0((

E)3$1%$#:%$#&='(R,.BC(%;<:T(

/DFL(c`SF^(MM!(.U:c:S,.(R#N(8FH<F[=<(8=LLDKB@=<T(

!:&&:,,.( N( ( ( ( ( (

#).:,(+,(+,:!0( +[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(D?BFBD(=A(BCD(+,:!0( A!:):"0*(R!I:(&&&T(

))(Vc( _:&&:cV( ( ( N( ( ( (

#).:,(+,(%(!*(+,:!0( +[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(D?BFBD(=A(BCD(H==I(=A(BCD(+,:!0(

>,:):"3(R)CEB:(&iT(

))(cg( _:&&:Vc( ( ( N( ( ( (

#).:,(+,(%(*0("2*(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3((

+[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(D?BFBD(@<(BCD(LF<O(=A(BCD("2*(=A(BCD(+,:!0D(L:(>:(C:(

9,.:B*"(R!I:(&&&T(

MFL]FBF( _:&&:cc( ( ( N( ( ( (

#).:,(+,:"5(%(+,:!0(&!%/(250(1%3'( +[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(BHDF?EH;(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0T(RL:(>:(C:T(

=(RMDHD<>BFCT(((=((R5FI:(&'T(

>8CD?BDH(_DFBB;(&&&((>_M(,-..,(f(

_:&:U`(((_:&:cU(

( ( ( N( ( N(

Page 662: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-SV(

((=(R5FI:((&'T((=(R5FI:(('&T((67)%:"*+((R5FI:(&'T((B0:*%-#(R"?FI:(&T(

>!PP=B((>_M(,--V.((>_M(,-SgS((eFH<F](,`((())(,.g(

((_:&:g-((_:&:g.((_:&&:,Ug(((8:&&:.S((

#).:,(+,:"5(%(*0(1*(0C!2(+,:!0( +[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(BHDF?EH;(@<(BCD(HDK=HO(=AA@KD(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0T(

B#0.(R5FI:('&T( _ECD<(.( _:&&:,`g( ( ( N( ( ( (

#).:,(+5*.2(+,:!0( +[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(P=JID<(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0T(

B0:!%/(R5FI:('&T(

!P;O=?(c( _:&&:,c.( ( ( ( N( ( (

#).:,(")2*(%(+0(/+C(%(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3(

+[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(J=H]?C=>(=A(BCD(FHI=H;(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0TQ(L:(>:(C:(

=(RMDHD<>BFCT( >_=L=G<F(,-d`( _:&:UV( ( ( ( N( ( (

').:,(/*)2*()(*0("2*(%*(+,:!0( +[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(BHDF?EH@D?ZD<KL=?EHD?(@<(BCD(("2*((=A(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0T(

=(R!I:(&&&T( MFL]FBF(.(((

_:&:,g( ( ( N( ( ( (

#).:,(12*(C+12*(+,:!0((

+[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(<=PLD(>LFKD?(=A(BCD(+,:!0( !7+*.(R,.BC(%;<:T( 84(,`gU( !:&&:,S-( N( ( ( ( ( (

#).:,(1C(%(+,:!0( +[DH?DDH(=A(JH@B@<G(@<(BCD(+,:!0( G#*:%3:#)0"(RM:e:T(

_DHL@<(,.--( !:&&:,gd( N( ( ( ( (

#).:,(1*(%(+,:?!0@( +[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(>LFKD(@<(BCD(+,:?!0@( 9%(R,SBC(%;<:T( /DFL(V`V((

!:&&:,.d((MM!(,-:,S-:.dc(

( N( ( ( ( (

#).:,(C%2*.()(C%22*(%*(B,:!0(!%/(250(1%3(

+[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(BJ=(GHF<FH@D?(=A(BCD(GHF<FH@D?(=A(BCD(+,:!0D(L:(>:(C:(

=(R,dBC(%;<:T( 7@[DH>==L(ME?DEI((M:(,,,U.(M:(,,,gU(

_:&:gV( ( ( ( N( ( (

Page 663: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-SU(

#).:,(C%2*.(%(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3( +[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(GHF<FH@D?(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0TQ(L:(>:(C:(

B0:!%/(R5FI:('&T((B0:!%/(R5FI:('&T((=(R.-BC(%;<:T(

!P;O=?(c((((84(.Vc`V(((=84(.Vc`V(

_:&&:,c-(((_:&&:,cS(((_:&&:,g-(

( ( ( N( ( (

#).:,(;02*(%(*0("2*(+,:!0()(0352( +[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(J=H]ID<(@<(BCD(LF<O(=A(BCD("2*(=A(BCD(+,:!0D(L:(>:(C:(

E-,:"0*(R)CEB:(&iT((

_M(,`g((

_:&&:Vd((

( ( N( ( ( (

#).:,(O1(+,(%(+,:!0((

+[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(?@OD(=A(BCD(D?BFBD(=A(BCD(+,:!0((

A!:):"0*(R!I:(&&&T(

))(Vc( _:&&:cV( ( ( N( ( ( (

#).2:,(+,(%2(+,:!0(%*.2()(*0:2,( )CD(?BDJFHO?(=A(BCD(+,:!0(JC=(FHD( @<(BCD()C@<@BD(<=ID(

/D?:(&( >5D@?<DH(&&( !:&:,V( N( ( ( ( ( (

#).2:,(+,(%*.&2'(?,@(#**(#)22(%2(!,,.*(%*(+,:!0(

)CD( ?BDJFHO?( JC=( ?CFLL( BF]D( BCD( #)2:P=FB?(=A(BCD(CFLL(=A(BCD(+,:!0(

/D?:(&( >5D@?<DH(&&( !:&:,V( N( ( ( ( ( (

#,.:!*(%(+,:!0((

+[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(KCFIPDH(=A(BCD(+,:!0( F,:%3(R,,BC(%;<:T((M%)2:"*+(R/D?:(&&T((I%:21,*(]!%/(R/D?:(&&&T((^7)%.(R/D?:(&&&T((67)%..(R/D?:(&&&T((67.:/,:%-,*(R/D?:(&&&^!I:(&&&T((

/DFL(`,U((_M(UUc.g((%EHCFI($,dSV(((%EHCFI($,dSU(((84(.-.Vd((_M(,V`(WVUVX((84(.-,`-(((

!:&&:,V(((!:&&:V-(((!:&&:V`(((!:&&:VV((!:&&:U.((!:&&:US(((

N( ( ( ( ( (

Page 664: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-Sc(

B+.(R!I:(&&&T(((M*:1*.:2,*(R!I:(&&&T(((F1,*:1%:!%/(R/D?:(&&&T((E3:C03*(R/D?:(&&&T((L%$-:1%3(R!I:(&&&T((I#:%.:F1,(R!I:(&&&T((E3:)1(R!I:(&&&T((I#:%.:F1,(R!I:(&&&T((672$-:%$#(R!I:(&&&T((W)1&2'(R!I:(&&&T((Q+:11(R,.BC(%;<:T((F1,(R,.BC(%;<:T((

7=E[HD(8(SS((7=E[HD(8(V(((ME?rD(4E@IDB(8(U((5&e(,-U(((/@<F@(,,-(((/@<F@(,,`(((/@<F@(gV((/@<F@(d.(((/@<F@(,`S(((/@<F@(,,V(((_M(S,S(W.`dX(((_M(.`,(W.ScX((

!:&&:UU((!:&&:Ud(((!:&&:c,(((!:&&:cS(((!:&&:cV(((!:&&:cc(((!:&&:cg((!:&&:g.(((!:&&:gS(((!:&&:g`(((!:&&:,-.(((!:&&:,-S((

Page 665: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-Sg(

L,2*(R,.BC(

%;<:T((B2:20":+*"(R,.BC(%;<:T((=(R,.BC(%;<:T((67#2$-((R,.BC(

%;<:T((I%3(12():!$&#'(R,SBC(%;<:T((G0:,,2&*'(R,SBC(

%;<:T((67")1:%:0/*:201:"*+(RM:e:T((L12*:1%3:1(RM:e:T((=(RM:e:T((I%!!:#3(RM:e:T((F1,:*1:%:!%/(RM:e:T(

7D@OD<(V.(Ri(ddT((%FC?CEH(.--(((5=O@<(`.((84(c--SU(((84(.--cV(((_M(S,V(W.`.X(((84(.-,`d(((84(.-..V(((_DHL@<(cS-d((/DFL(,`cV((!L<J@K](,dSU(((

!:&&:,,V(((!:&&:,,d(((!:&&:,.,((!:&&:,..(((!:&&:,S-(((!:&&:,`c(((!:&&:,gd(((!:&&:,gg(((!:&&:,d-((!:&&:,dS((!:&&:,d`((

#,.(%(+,(/,(!0(C+1(%(+,:!0( 4EFHO@F<(=A(BCD(GHDFB(F<O(<=PLD(<DKH=>=L@?(=A("CFHF=C(R+,:!0T(

=(R.-BC(%;<:T( >_@PL:$FB:(,dU( _:&:d-( ( ( ( N( ( (

#"2*.2(%(*0()#%*(+,:!0( 8ELB@[FB=H?(=A(BCD()#%*^A@DLO?(=A("CFHF=C( =(RMDHD<>BFCT( >_=L=G<F(,-d`( _:&:UV( ( ( ( N( ( (

Page 666: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-Sd(

R+,:!0T(#5%2(%(+,:"5(%(+,:!0( %D>EB;(=A(BCD(BHDF?EH;(=A(+,:!0( >,#(R,dBC(%;<:T(

(=(RMDHD<>BFCT(

_M(,S.((>8CD?B(_DFB:(&&&(

_:&&:,g-((_:&&&:S(

( ( ( N( ( (

#5%2(%0(%(#)%*.2(+,:"5(%(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3(

%D>EB;(=A(BCD(JD?BDH<(BHDF?EH;(=A(BCD(+,:!0D(L:(>:(C:(

9!#0(R!I:(&&&T((

/F\\FHF( _:&&:cd( ( ( (N((( (((( ( ((((

!0(+5*.2(+,:!0( 4HDFB(=A(P=JID<(=A(+,:!0(( I:201(R!I:(&&&(f(2=HDI:T(

bO#(`UU--( _:&&:,-c( ( ( N( ( ( (

!+,()(#C*$-(%3*()(+,:%12*( MF?BDH(=A(D[DH;(>H=>DHB;(@<(BCD(+,:%12*( !I:(&&( MDI>C@?( !:&:g( N( ( ( ( ( (20"(+,:!0D(!%/(250(1%3( #<OEHD(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0TQ(L:(>:(C:(( E/*$-:92*(

R+?=H]=<(&&&(f()F]DL=B(&&&T(

8F@H=(84(`..,,a(b#(Sc,Vda(eFH<F](8FKCDBBD(<=:(Scg(

8:&&:,c( ( ( ( ( N( (

2!2(%(*0(8%.*(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3( /F@L=H(=A(BCD(P=FBl?(K=<B@<GD<B(=A("CFHF=C(R+,:!0TQ(L:(>:(C:(

N"2*.:)12(R!I:(&&T(

_M(SUV( _:&&:c-( ( ( N( ( ( (

230(%(+,:!0( _EBLDH(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0T( =(R/DB;(&&T((=(R5FI:((&'T((

>!<F?BF?@(i((>!PP=B(_M(,-..,(

_:&:c-((_:&:cU(

( ( ( N( ( (

230(%12*(!0(%(!"%<*(+,:!0( 8C@DA(H=;FL(PEBLDH(@<(BCD(]@BKCD<(=A(BCD(+,:!0(

4%:#*%(R5FI:(&&T( 84(Sc.`,c( _:&&:,VV( ( ( ( N( ( (

2%:!0()(%#2*()(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3( %==H(=>D<DH(@<(BCD(K@B;(J@BC("CFHF=C(R+,:!0TQ(L:(>:(C:(

A!:):"0*(R!I:(&&&T(

))(,g,( _:&&:cU( ( ( N( ( ( (

2,(+,:"5(%(+,:!0( 4HDFB(=<D(=A(BCD(BHDF?EH;(=A(BCD(+,:!0( =(R,gBC(%;<:T( >)EH@<( _:&:U,( ( ( N( ( ( (2")2(%(+,:!0( 2DHFLO(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0T( =(R5FI:((&'T( >!PP=BB(_M(

,-..,(_:&:cU( ( ( ( N( ( (

2*(#3"(+,:!0( 8C@DA(=A(BCD(OD<B@?B?(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0T(

B1)*;:1%3(R"?FI:(&&T(

iFB@KF<(<=:(,UU( 8:&&:.d( ( ( ( ( N( (

25+2(%(+,:!0(%(%32("5( _EBLDH(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0T(=A(G=LO(F<O(?@L[DH(

67)%:"*+(R5FI:(&'T(

eFH<F](,`( _:&&:,Ug( ( ( ( N( ( (

3";()(+0(/,(%(+,:!0( /DH[F<B(@<(BCD(<DKH=>=L@?(=A(BCD("CFHF=C( =(R5FI:((&'T( >)EH@<(.-c`(( _:&:cg( ( ( ( N( ( (

Page 667: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-`-(

R+,:!0T( ( ()00(!32(30"(%(+0(12,#(8%2(#,2*(",(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3(

/DD@<G(BCD(>EH@A@KFB@=<(=A(>HD?D<KD(=A(BCD(8%2(PF<\EDB(A=H(BCD(+,:!0D(L:(>:(C:((

I2:):%2*(R)CEB:(&&&(f(!I:(&&T(

))(d.( _:&&:S,( ( ( N( ( ( (

)0!(/%*:C(%(+,:!0( &<?>DKB=H(=A(BCD(GFHOD<(=A(BCD(+,:!0( F1#,:1%:+2(RM:e:T(

84(.--S-( !:&&:,gU( N( ( ( ( (

),2*(%12*()(21/*(+,:!0( _DL=[DO(P;(BCD(]@<G(@<(BCD(CFLL(=A(BCD(+,:!0( 9%*2:>*+(R/D?:(&T(

84(.-VSd( !:&&:S.( N( ( ( ( ( (

)*.(%(+,:!0( "HDK@?D(@<(BCD(+,:!0((

67%3:#).(R,,BC(%;<:T(

/F\\FHF(,( !:&&:,.( N( ( ( ( ( (

%-2(%(+,:!0( /]@>>DH(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0T( =(R,dBC(%;<:T( 2@LOD?CD@I(`-,( _:&&:,cc( ( ( ( N( ( (%-,(>,(/%*.(+,:!0( "DHADKB(2=HE?(JC=(HD?@OD?(@<(BCD(+,:!0( /D?:(&( b#(`c.cU( ( N( ( ( ( ( (,/*.2(+,:!0!!%/(250(1%3( *F?CDHIF<(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0T(L:(>:(C:( =(R/DB;(&&T( =( _:&&&:.( ( ( ( ( ( ("0*.2(%(%0(+5*(+,:!0( 8C@DA(=A(BCD(BH==>?(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0T( 5FI:('&( >)EH@<(

,gdUq.--U(_:&:gS( ( ( ( N( ( (

"0*.:!(%(+5*.2(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3( 8C@DA(=A(P=JID<(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0TQ(L:(>:(C:(

I:201(R,gBC(%;<:T((M,(R,d^.-BC(%;<:T(

b#(`UU--((((b#(`,UU`(

_:&&:,cd(((_:&&:,gS((

( ( N( N( ( (

"0*.:!(950.2(%(+0(/,(!0(C+1#(?%(""@(%(,%+2*(%(B,:!0(!%/(250(1%3(

"H@<KD(=A(MDOhF;Q(BCD(GHDFB(<=PLD(A=H(I@LL@=<(;DFH?(=A(BCD(+,:!0D(L:(>:(C:Q(

=(R5FI:((&'T( >7D=>=LO(&&( _:&:cc( ( ( ( N( ( (

"):%*,(&#').:,(+,(%(*0("2*(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3(

"H=>CDB(F<O(?BDJFHO(=A(BCD("2*(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0TQ(L:(>:(C:(

9,.:B*"(R!I:(&&&T(

MFL]FBF( _:&&:cc( ( ( N( ( ( (

>,&2'(%-,(/%*.(+,:!0( 4==O(2=HE?(JC=(PDL=<G?(B=(BCD(+,:!0( !IF?@?( 7D@OD<(!M:,-c! 8:&:,U( ( ( ( ( N( (>,(/%*.(+,:!0( 2=HE?(JC=(HD?@OD?(@<(BCD(+,:!0( /D?:(&(

(!IF?@?(

b#(`c.cU((7=E[HD(%(.d(

!:&:U((8:&:,V(

N( ( ( ( ( (

",.(#,.(1C2(%(+,2.("5(%(+,:!0( 8C@DA(FHKC@[@?B(=A("CFHF=Cl?(R+,:!06?T(BHDF?EH;(

B%:+0:*0(R5FI:(&&T(

)=O( _:&&:,Vd( ( ( ( N( ( (

",.(#"2(2!(C)12(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3( /BFPLD^IF?BDHQ(=H(F(HDBF@<DH(=A("CFHF=C(R+,:!0T(L:(>:(C:(

=(R,dBC(%;<:T( >)EH@<(!( _:&:gU( ( ( ( N( ( (

Page 668: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-`,(

",.:+,(%(+,:!0((

MFh=HO=I=ZO=ID?B@K(?DH[F<B(=A(BCD(+,:!0( 673(R,,BC(%;<:T((((((=(R!I:(&&&T(((I%3:*#:-.(R!I:(&&&T((I*):10$-(R!I:(&&&^&iT((I%3:12:)!(R,.BC(%;<:T((A%:)1(R,.^,SBC(%;<:T((A%:)1(R,.^,SBC(%;<:T((I5):%2(&='(RM:e:T((!%/2(RM:e:T((I%3#(RM:e:T((L!:%-,(RM:e:T(((

/DFL(,-.(M@KCFDL@OD?(8=LLDKB@=<(RDN((_LF<KCFHO(K=LLDKB@=<T((/@<F@(,-V(((/@<F@(.g(((_M(.,d(((_M(.S.(W.,VX(((MFH?D@LLD(.S(((()EH@<(,U.-(((84(.--gV(((84(.-,-`((84(.-V.,(((84(.-U,U(

!:&&:,U((((((!:&&:gV((!:&&:dg(((!:&&:dS(((!:&&:dd(((!:&&:,.S(((!:&&:,.`(((!:&&:,cd(((!:&&:,g-((!:&&:,g,((!:&&:,g.((

N( ( ( ( ( (

",.()50(2!0(%(+0(/,(!0(C+1.(%(""(%( 4HDFB(KC@DA(=A(>=L@KD(=A(BCD(GHDFB(F<O( =(R5FI:((&'T( >7D=>=LO(&&( _:&:cc( ( ( ( N( ( (

Page 669: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-`.(

,%+2*(%(+,:!0( <=PLD(<DKH=>=L@?(=A(M@LL@=<?(=A(0DFH?(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0T(

",.(%(+0(102(%(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3( 8C@DA(=A(BCD(HDG@ID<B(=A(BCD(+,:!0Q(L:(>:(C:( N5&2'(R)CEB:(&&&(f(!I:(&&T(

))(.--( _:&&:.V( ( ( N( ( ( (

",.(102(1C2(%(+,:"5(&%'(+,:!0( 8C@DA(=A(HDK=HO^]DD>DH?(=A(BCD(BHDF?EH;(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0T(

=(RMDHD<>BFCT( >/FLL@DH(&( _:&:Ud( ( ( ( N( ( (

",.(102(1C2(%(*0(1*(*0(C%2*(+,:!0( 8C@DA(=A(HDK=HO^]DD>DH?(=A(BCD(=AA@KD(=A(BCD(GHF<FH;(=A("CFHF=C(R+,:!0T(

=(R/DB;(&&T((=(R,dBC(%;<:T(

>!<F?BF?@(i&((>)EH@<(!(

_:&:c,((_:&:gU(

( ( ( N( ( (

",.(;0&2'*(%&*'(*0("2*(+,:!0()(0352( 8C@DA(=A(BCD(J=H]?(=A(BCD(RI=HBEFH;T(BDI>LD(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0TQ(L:(>:(C:(@<(!P;O=?(

E-,:"0*(R)CEB:(&iT(((E-,:"0*(R)CEB:(&iT(

_M(,`g(((84(S`-..(

_:&&:Vd(((_:&&:U-((

( ( N( ( ( (

",.(*0(!*(+,:!0()(%"2*(,1.*( 8C@DA(=A(BCD(KCFIPDHZ?B=HDH==I(=A(BCD((+,:!0(@<(BCD(/=EBCDH<(8@B;(

I%.:%-,(R!I:&&T( /@L?@LDC(,,( _:&&:`d( ( ( N( ( ( (

"13(#*()(C%2*(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3( 8=E<BDH(=A(GHF@<(@<(BCD(GHF<FH;(=A(BCD(+,:!0Q(L:(>:(C:(

67)%:):"0*(R)CEB:(&&&T(

))(g.( _:&&:,U( ( ( N( ( ( (

/2(%(+,:!0(#).:,(C%2*.(%(+,:!0( 1F<^PDFHDH(=A(BCD("CFHF=CQ(=[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(GHF<FH@D?(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0T(

=(R5FI:((&'T( >)EH@<(,dS-Z.-V-q.-,S(

_:&:cV( ( ( ( N( ( (

/%*.(1*()(+,:!0( 1=HDI=?B(=A(>LFKD(@<(BCD(+,:!0( E-,:8%)2(R/D?:(&^!I:(&T(

%D@H(5@ADC(,( !:&&:``( N( ( ( ( ( (

/*)(%0.()(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3( /DFLDH(=A(BCD(+,:!0D(L:(>:(C:( >2.(R)EB:T( ))(`-( _:&&:,-S( ( ( N( ( ( (102(!*$#(%(#2*(%2(!<2(*0(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3(

4EFHO(=A(BCD(KCFIPDH(=A(BCD(@<K=I@<G(=A(JFBDH(F<O(?E>>L@D?(=A(BCD(LF<O(=A(BCD(+,:!0D(L:(>:(C:(

><0:#*-(RM:e:T( >_DHL@<(,--.,( !:&&:,c.( N( N( ( ( ( (

1%3(1,.*(%(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3( 1F<^PDFHDH(=A(BCD(+,:!0D(L:(>:(C:( =(R5FI:(('&T( >_DHL@<(,--V.( _:&:g-( ( ( ( N( ( (1,(+,:!0( 8=EHB@DH(=A(BCD(+,:!0( 67%.(R!I:(&&&T( /@<F@(gU( !:&&:cd( N( ( ( ( ( (C02*#2(%0(),:)C02(<s(,)*2(!0(%(+,:+,:!0(

)CD(GEFHO?Q(BCD(GD<DHFL?(F<O(BCD(GHDFB(ID<(=A(BCD(D?BFBD(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,(+,:!0T(

=(RcBC^SHO(_:8T( >:%DI:/F\:&Q(BDNB(,Z,F(

8:&:,d( ( ( ( ( ( N(

Page 670: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-`S(

1C(%(#).:,(+,:"5(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3( /KH@PD(=A(BCD(=[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(BHDF?EH;(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0TQ(L:(>:(C:(

=(R/DB;(&&T( >!<F?BF?@(i&( _:&:c,( ( ( ( N( ( (

1C(%(+0(#).:,(+,:"5(%(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3(

/KH@PD(=A(BCD(=[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(O=EPLD(BHDF?EH;(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0T(

=(R5FI:((&'T( >!PP=BB(_M(,-..,(

_:&:cU( ( ( ( N( ( (

1C(%(+0(+,(%(+,:!0( /KH@PD(=A(BCD(D?BFBD(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0T( =(R5FI:((&'T( >_M(,--VS( _:&:c`( ( ( ( N( ( (1C(%(+0("*,(%(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3( /KH@PD(=A(BCD(C=H?D^BDFI(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(

R+,:!0TQ(L:(>:(C:(G0(R5FI:(&&T( _M(VV,`( _:&&:,``( ( ( ( N( ( (

1C(%(+0(/+C(%(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3( /KH@PD(=A(BCD(J=H]?C=>(=A(BCD(FHI=H;(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0TQ(L:(>:(C:(

=(RMDHD<>BFCT( >_=L=G<F(,-d`( _:&:UV( ( ( ( N( ( (

1C(%(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3( /KH@PD(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0T( =(R,gBC(%;<:T((=(R5FI:(&'T(((=(R5FI:(&'T((=(R5FI:(&'T((=(R5FI:('&T((=(R5FI:('&T((>,#(R5FI:(i&&&T((67)%:"*+(R5FI:(&'T(

>)EH@<(RFT((>!PP=BB(_M(,-..,((>7D=>=LO(&&((>!ICDH?B((>_M(,--V.((>_M(,--V`((_DHL@<(.-g,((eFH<F](,`((

_:&:U,((_:&:cU(((_:&:cc((_:&:cd((_:&:g-((_:&:g,((_:&&:,UU((_:&&:,Ug((

( ( ( N( ( (

1C(%(+,(/,(!0(C+1(""(,%+2*(%(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3(

/KH@PD(=A(BCD(GHDFB(F<O(<=PLD($DKH=>=L@?(=A(M@LL@=<(0DFH?(=A("CFHF=C(R+,:!0T(

=(R,d^.-BC(%;<:T((=(R.-BC(%;<:T(

>4H@AA@BC((>_@PL:($FB:(,dU((

_:&:gc((_:&:d-(

( ( ( N( ( (

1C(%12*(!*(%(+,:!0((

5=;FL(?KH@PD(@<(BCD(KCFIPDH(=A(BCD(+,:!0( E3:%*,2(R(+?=H]=<(&&(^(2FH?@D?D(!T(

84(`...Va(b#(ScV.,a(eFH<F](8FKCDBBD(<=:(

8:&&:S( ( ( ( ( N( (

Page 671: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-``(

S`c(1C(%12*()(30"(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3( 5=;FL(?KH@PD(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0TQ(L:(>:(C:(( !IF?@?( >5;LF<O?(&'( 8:&:,c( ( ( ( ( N( (1C(%12*(*0(C!*(%(+,:!0( 5=;FL(?DKHDBFH;(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0T( B*":),#(R5FI:(

&&T(!P;O=?(U( _:&&:,V`( ( ( ( N( ( (

1C(%(/%,*(+,:!0(( /KH@PD(=A(BCD(?DH[F<B?(=A(BCD(+,:!0( I0:)%*2(R!I:(&&T(

_M(,`V(Wg.gX( !:&&:`g( N( ( ( ( ( (

1C(%(C%2*(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3( /KH@PD(=A(BCD(GHF<FH;(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0TQ(L:(>:(C:(

A!:):"0*(R!I:(&&&T(

))(Vc( _:&&:cV( ( ( N( ( ( (

&1C'(%(*0(1*(%(0C!2(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3( /KH@PD(@<(BC@?(O@?>FBKC(=A(BCD(+,:!0( E-,:",(R5FI:(&&T( _ECD<(,( _:&&:,`c( ( ( ( N( ( (1C("13(#*(%(C%2*(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3( /KH@PD(F<O(HDK]=<DH(=A(BCD(GHF@<(=A(BCD(

GHF<FH;(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0TQ(L:(>:(C:((

A!:):"0*(R!I:(&&&T(

))(Vc( _:&&:cV( ( ( N( ( ( (

1C(C!*(%(+,:!0( 7DBBDH(JH@BDH(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0T( =(R,d^.-BC(%;<:T( >)EH@<(_( _:&:g`( ( ( ( N( ( (1C2(+0(C%2*.(%(+,:!0( /KH@PD?(=A(BCD(GHF<FH@D?(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(

R+,:!0T(=(R5FI:((&'T( >)EH@<(

,dS-Z.-V-q.-,S(

_:&:cV( ( ( ( N( ( (

1*02(%2()%-0*(!%/2(%2(1(,(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3(,(1%)$1*()(*(#2-([%](#02(#,+(&_'(

%HFJ(=A(L@[@<G(?=LO@DH?(B=(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0TQ(L:(>:(C:(B=(ADDO(=<(PHDFOQ(IDDB(=A(=NQ(J@<D(RtT(

B8:12:/,(R)CEB:(&&&(f(!I:(&&T(

))(gg( _:&&:.g( ( ( N( ( ( (

/*)2(+,:!0(! /DFLDH(=A(BCD(+,:!0( =(RMD<:(&iT( 2FIIFIFB(,,S(

!:&&:,-( N( ( ( ( ( (

15)(!C(%(+,:!0( /DH[F<B(RL@B:((=<D(JC=(CDFH?(BCD(KFLL@<GT(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0T(

67)%:)1&.'(R5FI:(&&T(

))(,d( _:&&:,VS( ( ( ( N( ( (

15)(!C(&%3'(%(!*("%;*(%(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3!

/DH[F<B(RL@B:(=<D(JC=(CDFH?(RD[DH;T(KFLL@<GT(A=H(!*(=AADH@<G?(FB(BCD(+,:!0D(L:(>:(C:(

2=HDICDP( %E>L:(84(S`,U.( _:&:.U( ( ( N( ( ( (

15)2(&!C'(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3( /DH[F<B?(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(R+,:!0TQ(L:(>:(C:( 9,#:67)%(R,dBC(%;<:T(

2@LOD?CD@I(,-cc(

_:&&:,cg( ( ( ( N( ( (

C)12(&%'(+,:!0( 5DBF@<DH(=A(BCD(+,:!0( E3:+2:F1,*:1%(R!I:(&&&T(((

_M(,cV(W,-,X(((

!:&&:Ug(((

N((

( ( ( (

Page 672: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-`V(

(

( (

9%:"*+(RM:e:T((((E3:!%/(RM:e:T((>132:##:):"*+((RM:e:T(

/DFL(<=:(V`c(f("C@LFODL>C@F(,-,,U((84(.-U.c((84(.-.SV((((

!:&&:,V`((((!:&&:,g`((!:&&:,gV(

*0.:)50*(%(")2(%(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3( #<GHF[DH(=A(KFH>D<BDHl?(?C=>(=A("CFHF=C(R+,:!0TQ(L:(>:(C:(

M,2$-(R,gBC(%;<:(YT(

/@<F@(.S`( _:&&:,,.( ( ( N( ( ( (

*02(/2(%(+0(10(%(+,:!0(!%/(250(1%3( 1F<^PDFHDH(=A(BCD(>C;LD(=A("CFHF=C(R+,:!0TQ(L:(>:(C:(

N20(RYT((R,gBC(%;<:(YT(

84(S`-dS( _:&&:,,S( ( ( N( ( ( (

&N"2*.'(1C()(1*(!C!2*(+,:!0( )C=BCQ(?KH@PD(@<(BCD(>LFKD(=A(BCD(HDK=HO(=AA@KD(+,:!0(

G0.(RMDHD<>BFCT(

))(.S( _:&&:,VU( ( ( ( N( ( (

Page 673: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-`U(

"#$%&'('!%)!*+,!-'./,!%)!*+,!*,01!"#$()*+! 23$,0! 4%5-1,$*! 6.*.7%/!0,),0,$5,'!

!!!!89:9!

!!!!;9:9! <9=9!

#N>HD??@=<?( ( ( ( #( 7( #( 7( #( 7(

#02*$#( +2( )( +,:%12*( !%/( 250( 1%3(2%2*$#(+2()(1*+:10(!%/(250(1%3(

)C@?(JF?(I;(=AA@KD(@<(BCD(+,:%12*D(L:(>:(C:a(BC@?(JF?(I;(OEB;(@<(BCD(1*+:10D(L:(>:(C:(

67%:#*$-(R)CEB:(&&&T( 7=E[HD(8(.U( _:&&:,-( ( ( N( ( ( (

#2(%(")$%$#(%#2*(,!(120C():!(",*(),(,*%*(+,:%12*(

&(BF]D(FJF;(AH=I(BCD(K@B;(=<(BCD(OF;(=A(H=PPDH@D?(FJF;(AH=I(BCD(J=HBC(C=HH=H(=A(BCD(+,:%12*(

W0.(RMD<:(&iT((N"2*.:%/*(`(R!I:(&T(

2FB<EP(.`((2FB<EP(.S(

!:&&:g((!:&&:,g(

N( ( ( ( ( (

#2(802(%3(%(+,:%12*(!%/(250(1%3(!5(250(

!LL(BCD(FAAF@H?(=A(BCD(+,:%12*(FHD(?FAD(F<O(>H=?>DH(

=(R/D?:(&&&T( >_M(,-cV.(R>5FID??DEI(8T(

!:&&:Vc( N( ( ( ( ( (

#2(",(!<(1+,(%(%0.(21/*(+,:%12*(>,:+,(!%/(250(1%3(

)CD;(G=(@<(F<O(=EB(=A(BCD(_H=FO(2FLL(=A(BCD(+,:%12*(L:(>:(C:(

=(R.-BC(%;<:T( >7F<?@<G( _:&:g-( ( ( ( N( ( (

#2("13$%$#(&_'(/*(%3*(%*(+,:%12*(!%/(250(1%3(

&(K=E<BDO(RtT(FLL(BC@<G?(=A(BCD(+,:%12*D(L:(>:(C:(

B0:",.(R)CEB:(&(^2FB?C:T(

#L]FP(.( _:&&:`( ( ( ( ( ( (

#2$%("1*$-()()%*()(%0(21/*(+,:%12*(>,:+,(!%/(250(1%3()(T(#0"(Q%2(a(8,2(

&(?DB(A=HBC(AH=I(BCD(_H=FO(2FLL(=A(BCD(+,:%12*(L:(>:(C:(@<(BCD(BC@HO(I=<BC(=A(/C=IEQ(OF;(<@<D(

=(R/DB;(&&T( >!<F?BF?@(i( _:&:c-( ( ( ( N( ( (

#)#$%$#(+"(#02*()12(%32(2+2*()(+,:%12*(

&(JF?(GHF<BDO(B=(HDFKC(=LO(FGD(J@BC(I;(KC@LOHD<(C=LO@<G(=AA@KD(@<(BCD(+,:%12*(

67%*-(R/D?:(&T( _M(Vc.( !:&&:`-( N( ( ( ( ( (

#,#$%(")$-(,(+,:%12*(&E)b*'(C)$%$-(!*(%3*(%*(+,:%12*(+,:"5$-(2502$-(

2@?(MFhD?B;(>H=KDDODO(B=(BCD(+,:%12*(=A($@IL=B:(2D(?BH=OD(BCH=EGC(D[DH;(KCFIPDH(=A(BCD(+,:%12*Q(@B?(BHDF?EH;(F<O(@B?(?B=HDH==I(

"@F<]C;( b#(`c-gV^`c-gU^`c-gc^`c-gg^`c-gda(_DHL@<(,-Ug(

8:&:V( ( ( ( ( N( (

#,*(!%/(%(+,:%12*( MFOD(@<(L@AD(@<(BCD(+,:%12*( N"2*.:%/*(R!I:(&T(

2FB<EP(S,( !:&&:,d( N( ( ( ( ( (

#,*(1;)(%(#3$#()(#+2*(%(+,:%12*(( &(O@O(?DH[@KD(A=H(I;(7=HO(@<(BCD(I@??@=<?(=AZA=H(BCD(+,:%12*(

E*,:"*+(R,,BC(%;<:T(

2FB<EP(,`( !:&&:,,( N( ( ( ( ( (

!+,()(/!2(+,:%12*()%/*()(/*(%3*()"()(8;,2(!+,()(!<2(1/21()(0/*(%$-(%3*(

"H=[@ODO(J@BC(AEH<@BEHD(=A(BCD(+,:%12*Q(FO=H<DO(J@BC([DH;(HD\E@?@BDQ(A@LLDO(J@BC(

I0:,%+2*(R/D?:(&&&T(

!?JF<(B=IP(SU( !:&&:U.( N( ( ( ( ( (

Page 674: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-`c(

=H<FID<B?Q(>H=[@ODO(J@BC(PHDFO^=AADH@<G?Q(A@BBDO(=EB(J@BC(FLL(BCFB(JF?(PD<DA@B@<G(B=(@B(

!C0(#%2(+,:%12*( !PE<OF<B(#%2(=A(BCD(+,:%12*( >%)2:"*+(R!I:(&&^/D?:(&&T(

_D<@(2F?F<(S( !:&&:V,( N( ( ( ( ( (

?!<(+,*@()(+,:%12*("!2(8%)()("12(%(,5#$-(&$$'(

W8=I@<G(F<O(G=@<GX(AH=I(BCD(+,:%12*(J@BC(L@IP?(D<F<KCDO(P;(BCD(AF[=H(BCFB(@?(C@?(B=(G@[D(R::T(

B0:,%:%-,(R!I:(&iT((

!)(c( _:&&:dV( ( ( N( ( ( (

?20*(=@#,(0/*(%(+,:%12*(803(,(%#2*(%(G""(&='(

WH=FO(YX(IFOD(GL=H@=E?(@<(BCD(+,:%12*(?D<B(B=(BCD(K@B;(=A(G""(&='(

=(RM:e:T( 84(.-`gV( !:&&:,cV( N((

( ( ( (

2%(#%(")$-(!%/(250(1%3(",(5#(<5(*2(%$-(2!(#(+,(%(#%,(",(1)*(#2$-(!+,()(,*%2()(/*(%3*(%-,(%2(+,:%12*(!%/(250(1%3(

2@?(MFhD?B;(CFO(WF(C=E?DX(=A(?B=<D(PE@LB(WA=H(C@IX(E>=<(BCD(OD?DHBQ(?E>>L@DO(J@BC(>D=>LD(F<O(J@BC(D[DH;(G==O(BC@<G(=A(BCD(+,:%12*(

=(R/DB;(&(f(5FI:(&&T(

>2FHH@?(V--( _:&&&:,( ( ( ( N( ( (

)1#(!02*()(#0*(%3*(%*(+,:%12*( _=H<(RPDBJDD<T(BCD(GHDFB?(@<(BCD(=AA@KD(=A(D[DH;BC@<G(@?(@<(BCD(+,:%12*(

!<!:#3(R/D?:(&T( 2FIIFIFB(,.S( !:&&:.c( ( ( ( ( ( (

%3(25$#((%$-()(;02*(%3*(%*(+,:%12*( !LL(&(K=IIF<O(B=(C@I(FP=EB(FLL(BCD(J=H]?(@<(BCD(+,:%12*(

F")2(67)%.(R!I:(&(f(/D?:(&T(

2FIIFIFB(4(U,( !:&&:..( N( ( ( ( ( (

%3(%(;02*(%(#02*(%3*(%*(+,:%12*()(+,2.:"5(%(%3(!%/(250(1%3(

!LL(R@?(<DKD??FH;T(A=H(BCD(J=H]?(=A(D[DH;(KCFHGD(=A(BCD(+,:%12*Q(AH=I(BCD(O=EPLD(BHDF?EH;(=A(BCD(7=HOQ(L:(>:(C:(

F")2(67)%.(R!I:(&(f(/D?:(&T(

2FIIFIFB(4(U,( !:&&:..( N( ( ( ( ( (

%%(!<$%$1%(,(+,:%12*(5,(%**(2%%$1%(!)!2("%!(<<(,)2(32*(+2(%*(+,:%12*(671(%12*(E),*(!<$-(,(+,:%12*(5,(%**(2%$%$-()(2!3(%%((<<$-(,)2!"!$%(/)*(T,52$1%(2!()(!<(+,:%12*(

)CD;(O=(<=B(D<BDH(@<(BCD(+,:%12*(?@<KD(BCD;(CF[D(PDD<(K@HKEIK@?DO(F<O(DFB(A@?CQ(BC@?(@?(F<(FP=I@<FB@=<(A=H(BCD(+,:%12*$()CD(]@<G(E),*(D<BDH?(@<(BCD(+,:%12*(?@<KD(CD(CF?(PDD<(>EHD(F<O(CD(O@O<lB(DFB(A@?CQ(BCHDD(JDHD(=EB(F<O(=<D(JD<B(@<B=(BCD(+,:%12*(

"@F<]C;( b#(`c-gV^`c-gU^`c-gc^`c-gg^`c-gd(_DHL@<(,-Ug(

8:&:V( ( ( ( ( N( (

+0(1(%*.()(1%(#2$-(,(%0(2!3*(,(#,#("%<*(U5.(%(+,:%12*(>,:+,(!%/(250(1%3(1,)*(%(*0(!%&*'(+0(1(

)C=?D(FI=<G(BCDI(BCFB(FHD(GH=J<(ID<(J@LL(G=(B=(BCD(>=?@B@=<^C=E?D?(&2!3*'(B=(IF]D(PDDH(=A(eDO;(=A(BCD(+,:%12*(L:(>:(C:(F<O(1),*:PHDJ(=A(BC=?D(JC=(FHD(ID<(

=(R,dBC(%;<:T( >!<F?BF?@(&&&!( _:&:c.( ( ( ( N( ( (

Page 675: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-`g(

+"(%0(21/*(+,:%12*(>,:+,(!%/(250(1%3(12()#(*0(5%(80(%*(%2(+0():!(%2.*(!<0(2%(2!(!%/2(#2(/0(",()&2'*((

*C=(HDFKCD?(BCD(PH=FO(CFLL(=A(BCD(+,:%12*(L:(>:(C:(CD(@?(DNFKBL;(L@]D(BCD(JDF[D?(=A(BCD(?DFQ(=<D(HDIF@<?(FL@[D(JC@LD(F(BC=E?F<O(O@D((

=(R7FBD(,dBC(%;<:(f(.-BC(%;<:(RYTT(

"F>;HE?()EH@<(!( _:&:gU( ( ( ( '( ( (

+,$#(",(1302(%2(+,:%12*( &(JD<B(A=HBC(AH=I(BCD(GFBD?(=A(BCD(+,:%12*(

E-,:1,:8,2(R,dBC(%;<:T(

oFJ;DB(/ELBF<( _:&&:,cV( ( ( ( N( ( (

+,#$#(",(1302(%2(+,:%12*(&802(%32()(,C2*(,(<0#(%(+*'(

&(JD<B(BCH=EGC(BCD(O==H?(=A(BCD(+,:%12*(D(RJC@LDT(FLL(JDHD(HDLFBDO(B=(BCD(hEP@LFB@=<(B=(BCD(C@GC(=A(BCD(?];(

N5:N"2*.:#2$-:!%/(R..BC^.SBC(%;<:T(

84(Sd.,cn(b#(.V,`.(

8:&&:.-( ( ( ( ( c( (

+"$#(#0*(2,(%*(+,:%12*(,5#*$%$-(2#(#).:,(,2*.(2%)$%$#(12&,'#$%$#(,:O1(%12*(3#*.(,!(%3()(!,2(1*(0/*(?183$%(=@()00$%$#((C*02(%(+,:%12*(<%(8,("12(+,(%:)("!!2*()(25(%*(%*,(&='(#,$%$#(53"2(%(1(%$-(1+,2(/,(%3(*02.(

&(HDKD@[DO(BCD(=AA@KD(=A(O@G<@BFH;(=A(+,:%12*:(2D(RBCD(]@<GT(F>>=@<BDO(ID(=[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(,2*.:(&(FBD(F<O(&(OHF<](B=(BCD(]@<Gu?(?@OD(D[DH;(OF;(FB(BCD(CDFO\EFHBDH?(=A(BCD(C=H@j=<:(&(?FJ(BCD(?DKHDB?(=A(BCD(+,:%12*:(&(D<BDHDO(AELL(=A(>HF@?D(F<O(HDh=@K@<G(A=H(JCFB(&(G=B(=EB(I;(>=JDHAEL(7=HO(K=IIF<ODO:(&(O@O(JCFB(&(F?]DO(A=H(F(>DH?=<(@AQ(P;(>DB@B@=<(B=(BCD(7=HO(=A()J=(7F<O?(

>,:#,:L!(R.UBC(%;<:T(

84(g-c( 8:&&:S.( ( ( ( ( N( (

B15*(!0(#).*(+,:%12*( )CD(4HDFB(#<<DFO(JC=(@?(@<(BCD(+,:%12*( Y(R,gBC(%;<:T( #LD>CF<B@<D( _::&&:,.,( ( ( N( ( ( ()(+%(8,2(#2$*2()(B,:L!)112:),.:67)%(!%/(250(1%3(+0(;0(!0(%(B0:L!:>,:0/*.(+,:%12*(!%/(1%3(%-,(%(""(%("3:?15@(",(#,("1.(67)%(%(B,:L!)112:),.:67)%(!%/(250(1%3(

+<(BC@?(OF;(BCD(]@<G(JF?(@<(B,:L!)112:),.:67)%Q(6BCD(4HDFB(/=EL(=A("HD^2FHF]CB@9Q(BCD(PDFEB@AEL(+,:%12*(L:(>:(C:(=A(I@LL@=<?(=A(hEP@LDD?(O=@<G(BCD(>LDF?EHD(=A(!IE<(=A(B,:L!)112:),.:67)%Q(L:(>:(C:((

=(R/DB;(&&T( >_M,-.`V(f(>!<F?BF?@(i&(

_:&:c,( ( ( ( N( ( (

)00(32(%-,(%2(+,:%12*(( +<D(JC=(?DD?(G==O(>H=?>DH@B;(@<(BCD(+,:%12*(

I2:):%2*(R)CEB:(&&&(f(!I:(&&T(

))(d.( _:&&:S,( ( ( N( ( ( (

%%(1+(#,#(",(%(,*(%3()(#+(,(#,2(+,:%12*( $D[DH(O@O(&(BCD(P@OO@<G(=A(F<;(IF<(@<(HD[@?@<G(BCD(KFBBLD^L@?B?(=A(BCD(+,:%12*(

!"0*.(R,SBC(%;<:T( ))(UVP( !:&&:,VS( ( N( ( ( ( (

?%*$-(13(,(5)(%8&2'*(/*-(55*@()(+,:%12*(

W@B(@?(CD(JC=(?D<O?(=EBQ(B=(KEB(O=J<(?;KFI=HD(BHDD?Q(@<(FKK=HO(J@BC(JCFB(JF?(?F@OX(@<(BCD(+,:%12*((

L/:)#:,!(R)CEB:(&&&(f(!I:(&&T((

))(,--(((

_:&&:SS(((

( ( N( N( ( (

Page 676: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-`d(

B0:1,(R/DB;(&(f(5FI:((&&T((

))(,-U((

_:&&:,.g((

E*,(!0(",.:#3(+,:%12*( 4HDFB(G=OQ(JC=(@?(@<(BCD(+,:%12*( =(R,dBC(%;<:T( #L^%FIF;@<( _:&&:,cc( ( ( ( N( ( (,(+*(%(32(02(/,2$#(%(+,:%12*( M;([=@KD(@?(<=B(L=EO(@<(BCD(+,:%12*( G2:*2(R!I:(&iT( !)(g( _:&&:dU( ( ( N( ( ( (,5#()(",(",.2&:*+'(!C0(,(",.(")*(%3*(%*(+,:%12*(,(1/):#32(

+<D(JC=(G@[D?(=HODH?(B=(BCD(KC@DA?(=A(BCD(IELB@BEOD(I=HD(BCF<(F<;(KC@DA(=A(BCD(KHFAB(=A(BCD(+,:%12*(B=(BCD(?DH[F<B?(

I%32(R,.BC(%;<:T( 2D\F@P(`d(^(I!?JF<(,SSc(

!:&&:,-V( N( ( ( ( ( (

802(%3(%(+,:%12*(&!5(250'( !LL(BCD(K=<KDH<?(=A(BCD(+,:%12*(RFHD(?FAD(F<O(JDLLT(

=(RM:e:T( _ECD<( !:&&:,cg( N((

( ( ( (

"0;2:#3(+2(%2(+,:%12*(( )CD;(FHD(HDPDL?(FGF@<?B(BCD(+,:%12*( "?FIBD](&( 8F@H=(/5(.`,( 8:&:,.( ( ( ( ( ( N(")$-(!%/(250(1%3(")2(")2*(C)6.*(/30.*(2%()(30;2()(+,:%12*(#+$*2(30;2$1%(,((?$$@(!"(%3(*02.(

2@?(MFhD?B;Q(IF;(CD(L@[D(>H=?>DH(F<O(PD(@<(CDFLBCQ(CF?(K=<?DKHFBDO(ID<(F<O(J=ID<(?LF[D?Q(?@<GDH?(F<O(OF<KDH?(JC=(FHD(?DH[F<B(@<(BCD(+,:%12*(F<O(BCD@H(JFGD?(FHD(KCFHGDO(B=(BCD(W::X(!"(=A(BCD(7=HO(=A(BCD()J=(7F<O?(

)EB:( 84(`,VUV( _:&:.S( ( ( N( ( ( (

"12&*'$#()%()(+,:%12*( +<D(JC=?D(>HF@?D?ZAF[=H?(HDIF@<(HDIF@<(A@HI(@<(BCD(+,:%12*(

9,(+,(2,((6(7)%:"*+(R!I:(&&&T((92*:%-,*(&!I:(&&&T(

MDI>C@?(((!IFH<F(`(

_:&&:Ug(((_:&&:gg(

( ( N( ( ( (

/+,$%$#()(+,:%12*(#2$#()("2%(( &(GHDJ(E>(@<(BCD(+,:%12*(JCD<(&(JF?(;=E<G(

I*:02(R5FI:(&&T((

b:`,SdV(^(b:`,Sdc(^(b:`,Sdc((

_:&&:,S.(((

( ( ( N( ( (

/%*.(%*(1*()(+,:%12*( +<D(JC=?D(>LFKD(@<(BCD(+,:%12*(JF?(DNFLBDO(

9!.(R!I:(&iT( !)(,`( _:&&:dc( ( ( N( ( ( (

/,+(%$#("312(,(+,:"5(#2(K+()(!$#()(+,:%12*(

&(ODL@[DHDO(KL=BC@<G(B=(BCD(BHDF?EH;Q(BCD(FKK=E<B@<G(PD@<G(@<(I;(CF<O?(@<(BCD(+,:%12*(

9%*:21,*(R/D?:(&T( MM!(,.:,g`( !:&&:.d( N( ( ( ( ( (

/*)2(%*.2()(+,:%12*(!%/2(%*(,(!,,.*()00(1*0$#(,(+,:%12*(

)CD(?DFLDH?(JC=(FHD(@<(BCD(+,:%12*((F<O(BCD(>DH?=<?(FB(BCD(!,,.*(R>=HBFLQ(>=HKCYT(

F+:202*:!0(R/D?:(&(^(!I:(&&:T(

47(*!1(SV( !:&&:`,( N( ( ( ( ( (

Page 677: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-V-(

?DD(I;(FOI@BBF<KD(B=(BCD(+,:%12*(10"(%$2#(")$-()(),2*(!;2$#(",(C%*(%*(+,:%12*()(8,*(",2(%*(,!(%3(!(

2@?(MFhD?B;(CFO(PD?B=JDO(ID(J@BC(/DH[F<B?Q(F<O(I;(A==O(JD<B(B=(BCD(GHF<FH@D?(=A(BCD(+,:%12*(D[DH;(?@<GLD(OF;(

67%%.(R!I:(&(f(2FB?C:T(

))(g,( _:&&:U( ( ( N( ( ( (

10*(?*0(2,(%12(!0*(%/*@("*+1()(!"(+,:%12*(

)CD(OFEGCBDH(=A(BCD(4HDFBDH(5ELDH(=A(2FBB@(JF?(@<?BFLLDO(@<(BCD(!"(+,:%12*D(

5FI:(&&( MFHH@FGD(?BDLF(=A(5FID??D?(&&(

_:&&:`-( ( ( N( ( ( (

1!0$%$-(,(2,2(+,:%12*( +<D(JC=(IF]D?(BCDI(GHDFBDH(BCF<(BCD(GHDFB(=<D?(@<(BCD(+,:%12*(

F1,:10**(R!I:(&&T( !IFHFC( _:&&:V`( ( ( N( ( ( (

1/25$%$1(2#()(#/,2*(1!0$%$1(2#()"$%$1(#0)$#()("5(%32()(C1,(%3(%-,(%(+,:%12*((

/CD(D<H@KCDO(ID(J@BC(>=??D??@=<?Q(?CD(IFOD(ID(GHDFB(F<O(A@LLDO(I;(CEIPLD(FP=OD(J@BC(?@L[DHQ(G=LOQ(F<O(D[DH;(G==O(BC@<G(=A(BCD(+,:%12*(

67%%.(R!I:(&(f(2FB?C:T(

))(g,( _:&&:U( ( ( N( ( ( (

1/+,(*+:,5()(+,:%12*(!%/(250(1%3( 8HDFBD(CDFO(F<O(A==B(@<(BCD(+,:%12*Q(L:(>:(C:(

67%:#*$-(R)CEB:(&&&T( 7=E[HD(8(.U( _:&&:,-( ( ( N( ( ( (

1C+(20*(%-,*(,(*+:C(,(,5#*(",()(/%*(,(F01*(!"62(",$1()(*%2(!0*(#12*()(%/*:!2(0*+(,(02(,(/02(#,2()(/*(%3(%-,*(%*(+,:%12*(

)CD;(B==](BCD(H=FO(CF>>@L;(B=(BCD(\EF;ZLF]DQ(@<(=HODH(B=(CDFO(?=EBC(=A(BCD()CDPF<(<=IDQ(?C@>?(FP=EB(CDH(@<(GHDFB(<EIPDH?Q(KHDJ?(K=<?@?B@<G(=A(?BH=<G^FHIDO(ID<Q(LFOD<(E>(B=(BCD(GE<JFLD?(BCDHD=A(J@BC(D[DH;(G==O(BC@<G(=A(BCD(+,:%12*(

"?FIBD](&( b#(SUS.c( 8:&:,,( ( ( ( ( N( (

I5)(*2()(+,:%12*( *CD<(&(JF?(CDFHO(@<(BCD(+,:%12*((( !I:(&&( 4@jF( _:&:,V( ( ( N( ( ( (C(%(+,:%12*( )CD(LF]D(=A(BCD(+,:%12*( !I:(&&( MDI>C@?( !:&:g( N( ( ( ( ( (C+1$#(&)'(1,2()(+,:%12*( +<D(JC=(@?(FKKD>BDO(P;(BCD(=AA@K@FL?(=A(

BCD(+,:%12*(M,&#'2$-(R!I:(&&&T( ))(,d.( (_:&&:cd( ( ( N( ( ( (

C-.*()(8+2(%*(+,:%12*(*+:,5(%(#).2("0*$-(

%@G<@B;(=A(LFJ?(=A(BCD(+,:%12*Q(HELD?(=A(BC=?D(JC=(FHD(@<(AH=<B(=A(C@I(

(

>,2(R"DBEPF?B@?(&T(

84(`...Ua(b#(SUVcVa(eFH<F](8FKCDBBD(<=:(.(

8:&&:,V( ( ( ( ( N( (

C1+( )( #%.*( )( ?$$@( +,:%12*( >,:+,( !%/(250(1%3()(#%2(%(#).:,(

5DKD@[@<G(JCFB(JF?(PH=EGCB(AH=I(RYT(W::X(BCD(+,:%12*(L:(>:(C:(F?(F(BH@PEBD(=A(BCD(?BDJFHO(

=(RMDHD<>BFCT( >!<F?BF?@(&&&(dS,1e(

_:&:Ug( ( ( ( N( ( (

Page 678: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-V,(

15-02()(/*(+,:%12*(#2(12*(2%%$1%(",(C5(5#2(",(C%2*.(

!I>LD(?E>>L@D?(=A(BC@<G?(=A(BCD(+,:%12*D(JC@LD(BCD;(HDKD@[D(",(C5(HFB@=<?(FB(BCD(BJ=(GHF<FH@D?(

2=HDICDP( %E>L:84(S`,U.( _:&:.U( N( ( ( ( ( (

<%32*(%*(+,:%12*("!#( )CD(IFG@?BHFBD?(=A(BCD(+,:%12*(HDh=@KD( E*,:"*+(R,,BC(%;<:T(

2FB<EP(,`( !:&&:,,( N( ( ( ( ( (

5#$-(,(?!<@(+,*()(+,:%12*( MF;(CD(GHF<B(D<BH;(F<O(DN@B(@<(BCD(+,:%12*(

!0:)1(R!I:(&iT((B0^%"1.(R!I:(&iT((9!.(R!I:(&iT(

!)(S((!)(U((!)(,`(

_:&&:dS((_:&&:d`((_:&&:dc(

( ( N( ( ( (

5050*()(;1#(,(,2*.(+,:%12*( )CD(K=EK@LL=H?(O=@<G(=PD@?F<KD(FB(BCD(GFBD?(=A(BCD((+,:%12*(

2=HDICDP( >)EH@<(8=H=<FB@=<()DNB(=A(2=HDICDP(

_:&:.V( ( ( N( ( ( (

)@BLD?(F<O(D>@BCDB?(#2(%$-(2,2()(;12)(;12(,(,2*.(+,:%12*(

+<D(B=(JC=I(BCD(GHDFB(=<D?(=A(BCD($=HBC(F<O(BCD(/=EBC(K=ID(P=J@<G(FB(BCD(GFBD?(=A(BCD(+,:%12*(

9%*2:>*+(R/D?:(&T((67%:#*$-(RMD<:(&&T(((9,2(RMD<:(&&T(

84(.-VSd(((MM!(Vc:dVa(((/CFBB(DH(5@GFL(`Vd(

!:&&:S.(((!:&&:.((!:&&:`(

N( ( ( ( ( (

#2%(,1.(!0(%(+,:%12*( 4HDFB(?=EBCDH<(>@LLFH(=A(BCD(+,:%12*( N-^"!+.(R/D?:(&T((9%*2:>*+(R/D?:(&T(((I*+:#3:*:,!(R!I:(&&&T(

!??@EB(,((84(.-VSd((((84(.-VSg(

!:&&:S,((!:&&:S.(((!:&&:U`(

N(((

( ( ( ( (

#2%(Q)!2(%(+,:%12*(( 3>>DH(#G;>B@F<(>@LLFH(=A(BCD(+,:%12*( f*+(R!I:(&T((l7"..(R!I:(&T(

/F\\FHF(,,/\((/F\\FHF(,gN((

!:&&:.-((!:&&:.,(

N( ( ( ( ( (

Page 679: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-V.(

#)0/(!0()(+,:%12*( 4HDFB([D<DHFBDO(=A(BCD(+,:%12*( B0-:*02&:)':!2:E*(R!IF?@?T(

7=E[HD(!(dS( 8:&&:Sc( ( ( ( ( N( (

#).(&)'(+,:%12*( +<D(JC=(@?(@<(BCD(+,:%12*( !I:(&&((=(R,.BC(%;<:T((=(R,,^,.BC(%;<:T(

MDI>C@?(((38(,`SgV((>"FH@?(_@P($FB(,gS^,d`(R>"H@??DT(

!:&:g((!:&&:,-d((!:&&&:,(

N( ( ( ( ( (

#).:#3(!0()(+,:%12*( 4HDFB(AF[=HDO(@<(BCD(+,:%12*( 67)%:):#+*(R)CEB:(&&(f(!I:(&&T((B0:1,(R)CEB:(&&(f(!I:(&&T(

))(dU((())(d`(

_:&&:.U(((_:&&:.c(

( ( N( ( ( (

#).:,(#02*(+,:%12*( +[DH?DDH(=A(=AA@KD?(@<(BCD(+,:%12*( >,%:):"3(R)EB:T( /F\\FHF(.( _:&&:,-,( ( ( N( ( ( (#).:,(!"!2(2,()(+,:%12*(1+55(+,:"52.(

4HDFB(=[DH?DDH(=A(?C@>?(@<(BCD(+,:%12*Q(AEH<@?C@<G(BCD(BHDF?EH;^C=E?D?(

I0:,%+2*(R/D?:(&&&T(

!?JF<(B=IP(SU( !:&&:U.( N( ( ( ( ( (

#).:,(!8%2*.(%(+,:%12*( 8CFIPDHLF@<(=H(=[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(@<BDH@=H(=A(+,:%12*(

=(R.,^..BC(%;<:T( +<=IF?B@K=<(=A(67)%:%:#+*(

_:&:d,( ( ( ( N( ( (

#).:,(+,(2,()(+,:%12*( /BDJFHOZIFh=HO=I=(@<(BCD(+,:%12*((

E-,:1,:8,2(R,dBC(%;<:T(

oFJ;DB(/ELBF<( _:&&:,cV( ( ( ( N( ( (

#).:,(+,:%12*( +[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(+,:%12*( E",.(RMD<:(&iT((F1#,:1%:+2(RM:(e:T((I%:%:92*(R2FB?C:T(((>,:):"3(R)CEB:(&iT((

2FB<EP(.V(((84(.--S-(((())(c,P(((())(cg(((

!:&&:d((!:&&:,gU(((_:&&:`.(((_:&&:Vc(((

N( ( ( N( ( (

Page 680: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-VS(

=(R5FI:(('&T((=(R,dBC(%;<:T((=(

>_M,--V.((>MF;DH(!(F<O(_((+<=IF?B@K=<(=A(67)%:):#+*((

_:&:g-((_:&:gV((_:&:d,(

#).:,(+,:%12*(")*(&3#0'((

+[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(K=>>DH(=A(BCD(+,:%12*( I%:%:92*(R2FB?C:T((

))(c,P( _:&&:`.( ( ( N( ( ( (

#).:,(),"2*(%32*(%(+,:%12*( +[DH?DDH(=A(FLL(BCD(=@L?(=A(BCD(+,:%12*( ?$$@M%)2(%/*(RM:e:T(

84(.-V,g( !:&&:,cc( N( ( ( ( (

#).:,()C!(%(+,:%12*( 8=IIF<ODH(=A(BCD(>FLFKD(GEFHO( 43(RM:e:T( 7D@OD<(d(Ri(ggT( !:&&:,V.((

( N( ( ( ( (

#).:,(,2*.(+,:%12*( +[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(O==H?(=A(BCD(+,:%12*( 670):%5"(R)CEB:(&&&T(

))(g`( _:&&:d( ( ( N( ( ( (

#).:,(")2*(%3*(%*(+,(%12*( MF?BDH(=A(FLL(KHFAB?ID<(=A(BCD(+,:%12*( I%:%-,(R,gBC(%;<:T( 8F@H=(VVU( _:&&:,,`( ( ( N( ( ( (#).:,(/02(+,:%12*( +[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(<D@GCP=HC==O(=A(BCD(+,:

%12*(E3:67)%(R)CEB:(&^&&T(

))(.`( _:&&:S( ( ( N( ( ( (

#).:,(1C*0(?+,@:%12*( +[DH?DDH(=A(?DKHDB?(=A(BCD(?+,@:%12*((

N"2*.:%/*(R!I:(&^/D?:(&&T(

_DH?CDC(,((

!:&&:`S( N( ( ( ( ( (

#).:,(*0(9"2(+,:%12*( +[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(7=JDH(#G;>B(=A(BCD(+,:%12*(

A+,:;0:L!(R!I:(&&T(

7D@OD<(U(Ri(VT( !:&&:`c( N( ( ( ( ( (

K).:,(;02*(%32(%(+,:%12*((

+[DH?DDH(=A(FLL(BCD(J=H]?(@<(BCD(+,:%12*((

I*+:#3:*:,!(R!I:(&&&T(

84(.-VSg( !:&&:U`( N( ( ( ( ( (

#).:,(;02*()(("2*("32:15()(!"(%(+,:%12*(

+[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(J=H]?(@<(BCD(BDI>LD(=A(IS5^AD?B@[FL?(@<(BCD(!"(RF<O(@<(BCDT(+,:%12*(

E-,:"0*(R)CEB:(&iT((=(R,g^,dBC(%;<:T(

_M(,`g((7D@OD<(S:,:,:Sc(

_:&&:Vd((_:&&:,.-(

( ( N( N( ( (

#).:,(C%!.(+,:%12*(%12*:3#*.( +[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(IFGFj@<D?(=A(+,:%12*(=A(BCD(]@<G(=A(3>>DH(F<O(7=JDH(#G;>B(

670):%5"(R)CEB:(&&&T(

))(g`( _:&&:d( ( ( N( ( ( (

!0()(+,:%12*(&!%/(250(1%3'( MFG<FBD(@<(BCD(+,:%12*D(&b$(+$(8$'( 670):%5"(R)CEB:(&&&T(((B8:12:/,(R)CEB:(

))(g`((())(gg(

_:&&:d(((_:&&:.g(

( ( N( N( ( (

Page 681: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-V`(

&&&(f(!I:(&&T((l7)%:):"0*(R)CEB:(&&&(f(!I:(&&T((!7)%:):"3(R)CEB:(&&&(f(!I:(&&T((G%2%0(R)CEB:(&iT((E3#(R)CEB:(&iT((I3;:"*+(R)CEB:(&iT((B*":)12(R!I:(&&&T((E-,:1/,2(R!I:(&&&T((B*":)1(R!I:(&&&T((67)%:):"0*(I2,,(R!I:(&&&(YT((9%:/+,:L!:I%3(R,gBC(%;<:T((B0:1,(R/DB;(&(f(5FI:((&&T(

(())(dc(((())(gV((())(cU((7D@OD<(i(`S(())(US(((7;=<(gg((())(,-c(((7D@OD<(i(,`((_M(,.S((())(,,.((())(,-U((

((_:&&:S-((((_:&&:S`(((_:&&:VU((_:&&:U,((_:&&:US(((_:&&:c.(((_:&&:gV(((_:&&:gU((_:&&:,-U(((_:&&:,,c(((_:&&:,.g(

Page 682: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-VV(

!+,()(#C*$-(%3*()(+,:%12*( MF?BDH(=A(D[DH;(>H=>DHB;(@<(BCD(+,:%12*( !I:(&&( MDI>C@?( !:&:g( N( ( ( ( ( (

!+,2()(C%!2(1()(!<2(%(+,:%12*( MF?BDH(=A(BCD(?B=HD?Q(IF<(=A(BCD(>H=[@?@=<?(A=H(BCD(+,:%12*(

67)%:"0*(R/D?:(&Q(0:(SgT(

2FIIFIFB(gc( !:&&:.g( N( ( ( ( ( (

2!(*+&.'()(#12*(+,:%12*( 3<@\ED(=<D(JC=(@?(BCD(A@H?B(FI=<G(BCD(J=H]DH?Z?BFAA(=A(BCD(+,:%12*(

M,&#'2$-(R!I:(&&&^&iT(

))(,d.( _:&&:cd( ( ( N( ( ( (

2%(%(+,:%12*(!*$-( +<D(JC=(@?(@<(BCD(+,:%12*(@<(C@?(KCFIPDH( =(RMD<:(&&T( I8F@H=(S:U:.V:,( !:&&:S( N( ( ( ( ( (2,(#5*()(+,:%12*( 4HDFB(=A(KD<?@<G(@<(BCD(+,:%12*( 67#:G,:%-,*(RM:e:T((

(67)%:):"0*(R/D?:(&(f(!I:(&&T(

_DHL@<(,.-`((_D<@(2F?F<(.((

!:&&:U-((!:&&:,dS((

( ( ( ( ( (

2,(!0()(+,:%12*( !([DH;(GHDFB(=<D(@<(BCD(+,:%12*( N52:67#%*$-(R/D?:(&T(

_F<]D?(M?:($=:('&&(8(`(

!:&&:.U( N( ( ( ( ( (

2,()(#02*$-()(+,:%12*( 4HDFB(=<D(@<(C@?(=AA@KD?(@<(BCD(+,:%12*( G%:2,2(R!I:(&&T((

))(,-,( _:&&:VS( ( ( N( ( ( (

2,()(#0*$-()(+,:%12*(!%/(250(1%3( 4HDFB(=<D(@<(C@?(=AA@KD(@<(BCD(+,:%12*D(L:(>:(C:(

A!:):"0*(R!I:(&&&T(

))(Vc( _:&&:cV( ( ( N( ( ( (

2,()(!<(,(+,:%12*( 4HDFB(=<D(JC=(D<BDH?(BCD(+,:%12*( N"2*.:)12(R)CEB:(&iT(

))(.dV( _:&&:U`( ( ( N( ( ( (

2,(),2*()(+,:%12*( 4HDFB(=<D(PDL=[DO(@<(BCD(+,:%12*( 67)%:"*+(R)CEB:(&&&T((E/:92%(R)CEB:(&&&T((!0%%(R!I:(&&&T((M,:%3(R!I:(&&&T(

84(VV,((())(gc((()EH@<(P(()EH@<(V-(

_:&&:,`(((_:&&:,V(((_:&&:c`((_:&&:gc(

( ( N( ( ( (

2,("1&2'*()(+,:%12*(( +<D(GHDFB(=A(AF[=H(@<(BCD(+,:%12*( 67)%:):"0*(&='(R/D?:(&(f(!I:(&&T((L/:)0!:#,,(RM:e:T(

_D<@(2F?F<(.((((84(.-cV-(

!:&&:`.(((!:&&:,c,(

N( ( ( ( (

Page 683: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-VU(

(9,:,2:,.:*:+,#:+#(RM:e:T((

(84(.-.gg((

(!:&&:,c`((

2,("12*()(+,:%12*(!%/(250(1%3( 4HDFB(=A(>HF@?D?ZAF[=H?(@<(BCD(+,:%12*Q(L:(>:(C:(

I):):#0"((R2FB?C:T(

))(,.c( _:&&:`U( ( ( N( ( ( (

2,(1%5():8%2(+,:%12*( +<D(GHDFB(=A(ADFH(@<(BCD(+,:%12*( 9%*2:>*+(R/D?:(&T(

84(.-VSd( !:&&:S.( N( ( ( ( ( (

21*%(%)**()(+,:%12*(!%/(250(1%3( +<D(JC=(?BH@OD?(AHDDL;(@<(BCD(+,:%12*Q(L:(>:(C:(

=(R2FB?C:T( ))(cS( _:&&:Sd( ( ( N( ( ( (

+0(2,()(+,:%12*( 2@GC(?BDJFHO(@<(BCD(+,:%12*( E-,:1,:8,2(R,dBC(%;<:T(

oFJ;DB(/ELBF<( _:&&:,cV( ( ( ( N( ( (

)02(C%2*(%(+,:%12*(!%/(250(1%3( 8=<BH=LLDH?(=A(BCD(GHF<FH@D?(=A(BCD(+,:%12*D(L:(>:(C:(

I3;:"*+(R)CEB:(&iT(

))(US( _:&&:US( ( ( N( ( ( (

)%(),*()(+,:%12*( 1@HI(=A(L=[D(@<(BCD(+,:%12*( W0:%:67)%(R)CEB:(&iT((#!"(R,cBC(%;<:T(

_M(VUd.d(((7=E[HD(8(`d(

_:&&:Uc(((_:&&:,(

( ( N( ( ( (

)%("12*(!0(),&2'*(1/%*.(%(+,:%12*( 1@HI(=A(>HF@?D?Q(GHDFB(=A(L=[DQ(BCD(=<D(JC=(@?(@<(AH=<B(=A(BCD(+,:%12*((

>+2:1%32(R)CEB:(&&&(f(2FB?C:T(

84(U`g( _:&&:.,( ( ( N( ( ( (

)"(+,:%12*(!%/(250(1%3()("2(5-02( +<D(JC=(A@LL?(BCD(+,:%12*Q(L:>:CQ(J@BC(A==O(F<O(>H=[@?@=<?(

G%2%0(R)CEB:(&iT( ))(cU( _:&&:VU( ( ( N( ( ( (

)"(+,:%12*()(?"5(%32@(#).:,(/*)2*(I3;:"*+(

)CD(+,:%12*(PD@<G(AELL(=A(W?@L[DH(F<O(G=LOXQ(=[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(BHDF?EH@D?ZD<KL=HEHD?(

I3;:"*+(R)CEB:(&iT(

))(US( _:&&:US( ( ( N( ( ( (

)"(+,:%12*()("5(",(%32(!0*(%3*(C+1*( +<D(JC=(A@LL?(BCD(+,:%12*(J@BC(?@L[DHQ(G=LO(F<O(FLL(K=?BL;Z[FLEFPLD(?B=<DZIDBFL(

U%:67)%(R2FB?C:T( ))(dS( _:&&:V.( ( ( N( ( ( (

)"(+,:%12*()(8,*$8,2()(32(%3(%-,( +<D(JC=(A@LL?(BCD(+,:%12*(D[DH;(OF;(J@BC(D[DH;(G==O(BC@<G(

E-,:1/,J(R!I:(&&&T(

))(,-c( _:&&:gV( ( ( N( ( ( (

)*.()J%(+,:%12*(( "HDK@?D(@<(BCD(+,:%12*( E12:9%*2(R!I:(&(f(/D?:(&T(((I%:+2(R,.BC(

7=E[HD(8,((()EH@<(,U.g(R.cUT(

!:&&:.S(((!:&&:,-g(

N( ( ( ( ( (

Page 684: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-Vc(

%;<:T( (( ()*.()(+,:%12*(,/(55*()(/0(%3( "HDK@?D(@<(BCD(+,:%12*Q(=<D(JC=(]<=J?(

JCFB(@?(?F@O(@<(D[DH;(=AA@KD(67%*-(R/D?:(&T((

_M(,dc(WVg,X((

!:(&&:SS((

N( ( ( ( ( (

%3(2%)2*()(+,:%12*(!%/(250(1%3(((

7=HO(=A(BCD(C=EHL;(>H@D?B(=A(BCD(+,:%12*D(L:(>:(C:(

670):%5"(R)CEB:(&&&T(

))(g`( _:&&:d( ( ( N( ( ( (

%3(%(+,:%12*( 7=HO(=A(BCD(+,:%12*( /D?:(&( #LD>CF<B@<D(/(,`-(

!:&:`( N( ( (((( (((( ( (((((

%3*(%*.(+,:%12*( !LL(JC=(PDL=<G(RAE<KB@=<FH@D?T(@<(BCD(+,:%12*(

A%*.:/*#:):1-:1%3(R,.BC(%;<:T(

Ie=>D<FGCD<($84(!#&$(,VSd(

!:&&:dg( N( ( (((( (((( ( (((((

%12*(%*,2(",.:#3(+,:%12*( e@<G(=A(BCD(G=O?Q(BCD(GHDFB(G=O(JC=(@?(@<(BCD(+,:%12*(

=(R.-BC(%;<:T( 84(,,.-( _:&&:,g,( ( ( ( N( ( (

%*,(!0(",.*:#3(+,:%12*( 4HDFB(G=OQ(>H=BDKB=H(=A(BCD(+,:%12*( =(R,dBC(%;<:T( #L^%FIF;@<( _:&&:,cc( ( ( ( N( ( (?,252@(%(+,:%12*( )CD(WFGD<B?X(=A(BCD(+,:%12*( 2=HDICDP( %E>L:(84(S`,U.( _:&:.U( ( ( N( ( ( (

,/(1*:,5$-()(+,:%12*((

+<D(JC=(]<=J?(C@?(?BF<O@<G(@<(BCD(+,:%12*(

N-^"!+.(R/D?:(&T((67)%:):"0*(R/D?:(&(f(!I:(&&T((67%:#*$-(RMD<:(&&T((9%&*2':"*+(R!I:(&&T((I%-:,*(R!I:(&&&T((L)%.:!%/(R,.BC(%;<:T((A%*.:"*+(RM:e:T(

!??@EB(,((_D<@(2F?F<(.(((MM!(Vc:dV((/@<F@(`c(((/@<F@(,,.((84(.-Vc,(((/@<F@(`,.(((

!:&&:S,((!:&&:`.(((!:&&:.((!:&&:`d(((!:&&:cU((!:&&:,-.(((!:&&:,UU((

N( ( ( ( ( (

8,#(%)**()(+,:%12*( 8=<BD<B(?BD>(@<(BCD(+,:%12*( M,&#'2$-(R!I:(&&&T( ))(,d.( _:&&:cd( ( ( N( ( ( ("0+(,0(",(/,*(+,:%12*(!%/(250(1%3( +<D(JC=(]DD>?(?@LD<B(FP=EB(BCD(FAAF@H?(=A( 67%%#(R!I:(&(f( ))(g,( _:&&:U( ( ( N( ( ( (

Page 685: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-Vg(

BCD(+,:%12*( 2FB?C:T("0*.:!(2,2()(+,:%12*( 7DFODH(=A(BCD(GHF<ODD?(@<(BCD(+,:%12*( B0:1,(R/DB;(&(f(

5FI:((&&T())(,-U( _:&&:,.g( ( ( ( N( ( (

"0*.:!("0*.2:!()(+,:%12*((

7DFODH(=A(BCD(>H@<KD?(=A(BCD(+,:%12*((

E",.:1(R,,BC(%;<:T(

2FB<EP(,U( !:&&:,c( N( ( ( ( ( (

"0*.:!(1),(!0()(+,:%12*( )CD(CDHDO@BFH;(>H@<KDQ(F(IFG<FBD(GHDFB(@<(BCD(+,:%12*(

$DADHBFH@(F<O("H@<KD(R5FI:(&&T(

84(`.,V`( _:&:V,( ( ( ( N( ( (

"%*(%-,2(+,:%12*( M@?BHD??(=A(IF@OD<?(=A(BCD(+,:%12*( $DADHBFH@(R5FI:(&&T(

_FCB@I( _:&:V-( ( ( (((( (N( ( ((((

",.(",.2()!0*(%3*(C+11*(%*(+,:%12*( !HB@?F<(@<(D[DH;(K=?BL;(?B=<D(=A(BCD(+,:%12*(

67+#:10:#+#(RMD<B:(&&T(

2FIIFIFB(`-( !:&&:,( N( ( ( ( ( (

",.(1,25(+,:%12*((

+<D(JC=(@?(FB(BCD(CDFO(=A(BCD(K=<BH=LLDH?(=A(BCD(+,:%12*(

Y(RMD<:(&&T( I8F@H=(S:U:.V:,( !:&&:S( N( ( ( ( ( (

",.:1C*0(%J%*.J)(+,:%12*(&!%/(250(1%3'(

eDD>DH(=A(?DKHDB?(@<(BCD(+,:%12*( l7"..(R!I:(&T(((L%-:1%3(R!I:(&&&T(((>,(R,.BC(%;<:T((((F1,:&%/*'(R)CEB:(&&&T((L/:)#:,!(R)CEB:(&&&(f(!I:(&&&T((!)*2(R)CEB:(&&&(^(2FB?C:T((>,%:):"3(R)EB:T((

/F\\FHF(,gN((/@<F@(V,((/DFL(,,,,(^("C@LFODL>C@F(#(d,d.((/B:(1DHH@=L(8=LLDKB@=<(())(,--(((/@L?@LDC(,c(((/F\\FHF(.((

!:&&:.,((!:&&:gc((!:&&:d`((((_:&&:,c(((_:&&:SS(((_:&&:.-(((_:&&:,-,((

N( ( N( ( ( (

Page 686: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-Vd(

>,%:):"3(R)EB:T((M,&#'2$-(R!I:(&&&T((L!:)1&#'2(R!I:(&&&T((=(R,gBC(%;<:T((=(R,gBC(%;<:T((B0:1,:2(R5FI:(&&T((&B'L!:"*+(R5FI:(&&T((B1)*;(R!IF?@?T((

_M(VV-(())(,d.(())(VV(((_DHL@<(,dc`.((84(.V.S-((84(`.,U`((b#(`gg`V(((/F\\FHF(RFT(

_:&&:,-.((_:&&:cd((_:&&:g`(((_:&&:,,V((_:&&:,,U((_:&&:,S`((_:&&:,SU(((8:&&:`V(

",.:*+(!0()(+,:%12*( 4HDFB(KC@DA(@<(BCD(+,:%12*( 9%:/+,:,!:1%3&2'(R)CEB:&&Z&&&(f(!I:(&&T((I%&$#':%-,(R)CEB:(&&&T((I%:%-,(R)CEB:(&&&(f(2FB?C:T((I%:%:92*(R2FB?C:T((I%:%:92*(

))(gU(((((_M(VSc(((_M(`g((())(SVS((())(c,(

_:&&:V(((((_:&&:g(((_:&&:.S(((_:&&:`-(((_:&&:`,(

( ( N( ( ( (

Page 687: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-U-(

R2FB?C:T((67)%:):"0*(R2FB?C:T((67)%:):"0*(R!I:(&&&T((9%:/+,:L!:I%3(R,gBC(%;<:T(

(())(`g(((7=E[HD(!(V,((())(,,.(

((_:&&:V,(((_:&&:g.(((_:&&:,,c(

"12*$#()(+,:%12*(!%/(250(1%3( 1F[=HDO(@<(BCD(+,:%12*Q(L:(>:(C:( 670):%5"(R)CEB:(&&&T(

))(g`( _:&&:d( ( ( N( ( ( (

"1&.'(!0*()(+,:%12*( +<D(GHDFBL;(AF[=HDO(@<(BCD(+,:%12*( 67)%:):"0*(R/D?:(&(f(!I:(&&T(

_D<@(2F?F<(.( !:&&:`.( N( ( ( ( ( (

/,+(/,+2(",(;0&2'*(%3&2'*(%*(+,:%12*( 8=<BH=LLDH(=A(BCD(K=<BH=LLDH?(=A(FLL(J=H]?(=A(BCD(+,:%12*(

I%:%:92*(R2FB?C:T(

)CDPD?(S( _:&&:`V( ( ( N( ( ( (

/,+(;02*(%32*(%*(+,:%12*(!%/(250(1%3(

8=<BH=LLDH(=A(FLL(BCD(J=H]?(=A(BCD(+,:%12*D(L:(>:(C:(

670):%5"(R)CEB:(&&&T((67%:#*$-(R)CEB:(&&&T((I%:%:92*(R2FB?C:T(

))(g`(((7=E[HD(8(.U((84(Vcd((

_:&&:d(((_:&&:,-((_:&&:`c((

( ( N( ( ( (

/%*.(#02*()(+,:%12*( 1=HDI=?B(=A(=AA@KD?(@<(BCD(+,:%12*( 67%:#*$-(RMD<:(&&T( MM!(Vc:dV( !:&&:.( N( ( ( ( ( (/%*.(&%'(1*()(+,:%12*( 1=HDI=?B(=A(>=?@B@=<(@<(BCD(+,:%12*( !"0:%:/%*(R,-^

,,BC(%;<:T((N-^"!+.(R/D?:(&T(

_DH?CDC(V(((!??@EB(,((

!:&&:,S(((!:&&:S,(

N( ( ( ( ( (

/%*.(?1*()(+,:%12*@( 1=HDI=?B(=A(>=?@B@=<(@<(BCD(+,:%12*(( 67)%:):"0*(I2,,(R!I:(&&&(YT(

_M(,.S( _:&&:,-U( ( ( N( ( ( (

/*)2(%3()(+,:%12*( 2D(JC=(?DFL?(D[DH;BC@<G(@<(BCD(+,:%12*( 9,.(R)CEB:(&&&(f(!I:(&&T(

))(dV( _:&&:.d( ( ( N( ( ( (

Page 688: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-U,(

/*)2(/*)(C+112()(+,:%12*( /DFLDH(?DFL@<G(>HDK@=E?(BC@<G?(@<(BCD(+,:%12*(

N"2*.(R)CEB:(&&&(f(2FB?C:T(

))(,,( _:&&:.`( ( ( N( ( ( (

8,52(%(;0+(%(+,:%12*( 8C@LOHD<(@<(BCD(;0+(=A(BCD(+,:%12*( I0:301**(R)CEB:(&&&T(

84(.cg,V( _:&&:,g( ( ( N( ( ( (

1)()(+,:%12*( I)^>H@D?B(@<(BCD(+,:%12*( B0:1,:2(R5FI:(&&T((B0:1,:2(R5FI:(&&T(

_M(Ugc((("C@LFODL>C@FQ(3<@[:(ME?DEI(#:(VS`(

_:&&:,SV((_:&&:,V.(

( ( ( N( ( (

1)%(#02*()(+,:%12*(!%/(250(1%3( +<D(JC=(IF@<BF@<DO(BCD(=AA@KD?(@<(BCD(+,:%12*Q(L:>:C:(

=(R2FB?C:T( ))(cS( _:&&:Sd( ( ( N( ( ( (

1),(!0(+,:%12*( 4HDFB(K=I>F<@=<(@<(BCD(+,:%12*( l7"..(R!I:(&T( /F\\FHF(,gN( !:&&:.,( N( ( ( ( ( (1),()(+,:%12*( 8=I>F<@=<(=A(BCD(+,:%12*( 9%*2:>*+(R/D?:(

&T(84(.-VSd( !:&&:S.( N( ( ( ( ( (

1%2(P%()(+,:%12*( _HF[D(K=I>F<@=<(@<(BCD(+,:%12*( 9%*:21,*(R/D?:(&T( MM!(,.:,g`( !:&&:.d( N( ( ( ( ( (1%3("02*.(%(2,2(!"( 1=HDI=?B(=A(BCD(GHDFB?(=A(BCD(+,:%12*Q(L:(

>:(C:(E-,:1/,J(R!I:(&&&T(

))(,-c( _:&&:gV( ( ( N( ( ( (

1,(!0()(+,:%12*( 4HDFB(=AA@K@FL(@<(BCD(+,:%12*( 670):%5"(R)CEB:(&&&T(

))(g`( _:&&:d( ( ( N( ( ( (

1C(67)%(%*(+,:%12( /KH@PD(=A(!IE<(=A(BCD(+,:%12*( Y(R,dBC(%;<:T( >8CD?BDH(_DFBB;(&&(p(>_M(,-Ug.(

_:&&&:S( ( ( ( N( ( (

1C(!0()(+,:%12*(!%/(250(1%3( 4HDFB(?KH@PD(@<(BCD(+,:%12*D(L:(>:(C:( 67)%:):"0*(R)CEB:(&&&T((67)%:):"0*(R)CEB:(&&&(f(2FB?C:T(

))(g.((())(VS(

_:&&:,U(((_:&&:..(

( ( N( ( ( (

1C(+,:%12*( /KH@PD(BCD(+,:%12*( I%3(R,.BC(%;<:T( )EH@<(,S-( !:&&:,SU( N( ( ( ( ( (1C(%12*()(8%2(+,:%12*( 5=;FL(?KH@PD(=A(BCD(8%2(=A(BCD(+,:%12*( +<=IF?B@K=<(=A(

l7)%:):#+*(.-BC(%;<:( _:&:d,( ( ( ( N( ( (

Page 689: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-U.(

1C(<52*()(+,:%12*( %HFABIF<(@<(BCD(+,:%12*( F%/*#(RM:e:T( 84(.-`Vc( !:&&:,cU( N( ( ( ( (

15).2()5*(+,:%12(8+2(%2(!,6.*( +PDO@D<B(B=(BCD(@<hE<KB@=<?(=A(BCD(+,:%12((F<O(BCD(LFJ?(=A(BCD(K=EHB(

2=HDICDP( %E>L:(84(S`,U.( _:&:.U( ( ( N( ( ( (

/*)2(&3#*.'(!0()(+,:%12*( 4HDFB(?DFLDH(R=A(BCD(]@<G(=A(3>>DH(F<O(7=JDH(#G;>BT(@<(BCD(+,:%12*(

W0:)1(R!I:(&&&T((9!#0(R!I:(&&&T((W0:)1&2'(R!I:(&&&T(

_M(,.,-((/F\\FHF(Y((3<]<=J<(

_:&&:c,((_:&&:cd((_:&&:gS(

( ( N( ( ( (

/*)2(%3(%*(+,:"5(#0*(%3*(%*(+,:%12*((

/DFLDH(=A(FLL(JCFB(@?(@<(BCD(+,:"5D(=AA@KD(=A(D[DH;BC@<G(@?(@<(BCD(+,:%12*(

=(RMD<:(&iT( 2FIIFIFB(,,S( !:&&:,-( N( ( ( ( ( (

C2#()(!!2.(",("%&*'(%3(%(+,:%12*( +<D(AHDD(=A(?LDD>@<G(@<(D[DH;(=KKE>FB@=<ZK=IIF<O(=A(BCD(+,:%12*(

67)%:)"0*(R/D?:(&T(

2FB<EP(`d( !:&&:S-( N( ( ( ( ( (

C%.*(#).*(+,:%12*(( 8=EHB@DH?(JC=(FHD(@<(BCD(+,:%12*( B0:1,(R/DB;(&(f(5FI:((&&T(

))(,-U( _:&&:,.g( ( ( ( N( ( (

<33()(+,:%12*( 8FLI(@<(BCD(+,:%12*( E/*:>,2:"3(R"?FI:(&&T(

84(Sd.cV( 8:&&:SS( ( ( ( ( ( N(

M@??@<G(A@H?B(?@G<R?T($$):!(+,:%12*( ::@<(BCD(+,:%12*( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ((

( (

Page 690: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-US(

"#$%&'('!%)!*+,!-'./,!%)!*+,!*,01!,(*! 23$,0! 4%5-1,$*! 6.*.7%/!0,),0,$5,'!

89:9! !!!!;9:9! <9=9!

#N>HD??@=<?( ( ( ( #( 7( #( 7( #( 7(

[$$](#3(%(8%2()"()/+C$-( W::X(BCD(CDFHB(@<(BCD(8%2(@?(AELL(P;(C@?(FHI( E",.(RMD<:(&iT( 2FB<EP(.V( !:&&:d( N( ( ( ( ( (

#2$;(/!#()#(",(O*$-()#(,25(L!(",(50#(",*(+*(#2$;()(%12&*'(3#*.()(%-,2$;()(8%2(

0=E(F>>DFH(=<(;=EH(BCH=<D(L@]D(5F(AL=EH@?CD?(JCD<(CD(KH=??D?(BCD(?];(@<(\EFL@B;(=A(]@<G(=A(3>>DH(F<O(7=JDH(#G;>BQ(BCF<]?(B=(;=EH(\EFL@B@D?Q(@<(BCD(8%2((

5FI:((&&( !P;O=?(V( _:&:`S( ( ( ( N( ( (

#2$;(,/(*2(1,(%(8%2(,$1( 0=E(]<=J(JCFB(8%2(A=HDB=LO(FP=EB(@B( =(R,.BC(%;<:T( >7D<@<GHFO(,,,U!Q(>M=?K=J(`UVgQ(>8FHL?PDHG(U(

!:&&&:.( N( ( ( ( ( (

#)#(%%(/*)(#)#(%%(!"0(8%2(Q2()(1+(*+#(

%=(<=B(KL=?DQ(O=(<=B(A@GCB(BCD(8%2(Q2(@<(BCD(E>=<(B@ID(

"@F<]C;( b#(`c-gV^`c-gU^`c-gc^`c-gg^`c-gd(_DHL@<(,-Ug(

8:&:V( ( ( ( ( N( (

#).:,(Q)!2(&$$'()(8%2$-(G0:58%*:%*:67)%:!0:8)8)*(

)CD(G=[DH<=H(=A(3>>DH(#G;>B(R::T(JF?(@<(C@?(8%2Q(BCD(LF<O(=A(!IE<(4HDFB(=A(5=FH@<G(

+?=H]=<(&( _EPF?B@?( 8:&:`( ( ( ( ( N( (

#).:,(;0*(#)("(%!$1%(,(/,+(;0*()(,0:+,(+%(#1(")$-()(8%2(673%:"5(!"!$%(<52("2*:(%*,(*%(

!(?E>DH@<BD<OD<B(=A(J=H]?(JF?(BCDHD(J@BC(BCDIQ(@<(=HODH(B=(=[DH?DD(BCD(PE@LO@<G(DAA=HB?(FB(BC@?(BDI>LD(?@BD(RJC@LDT(2@?(MFhD?B;(JF?(@<(BCD(8%2(=A(MDI>C@?:()CD<(C@?(BDI>LD(JF?(PE@LB(=A(G==O(JC@BD(?F<O?B=<D(

)FCFH\F( MDH=JD(ME?DEI(<=:(V.(

8:&:c( ( ( ( ( N( (

#%(#2(C5#(*2(8%%2()(8%2( !HD(HDPDL?(B==](=EB(AH=I(BCD(8%2Y( =(R,.BC(%;<:T( "F>;HE?(M@LL@<GD<( !:&&&:S( N( ( ( ( ( (

#%(#2(O,(%$;(,(1)/(,12*(Q)!2(%2(8%2(

0=E(J@LL(PD(@<(?@LD<KD(@<(=HODH(B=(A=HGDB(BCD(3>>DH(#G;>B(F<O(JCFB(PDL=<G?(B=(BCD(8%2(

"@F<]C;( #(`c-gV^`c-gU^`c-gc^`c-gg^`c-gda(_DHL@<(

8:&:V( ( ( ( ( N( (

Page 691: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-U`(

,-Ug(

#,$%$-(8%2(!0(C+1#(,(%/*(*0C(G0:),#(B,:L!:)112:),#:67)%(5#(!%/(

2D(CF?(IFOD(F<(FEGE?B(8%2(B=(?BHD<GBCD<(BCD(P=HODH?(=A(#G;>Bn("@HFID??DQ(G@[D<(L@AD(

5FI:((&&( %DKHDD(=A(PLD??@<G("BFC(

_:&:V`( ( ( ( N( ( (

#1*( ")$-( %( 5)#( >2*:;0:B*"( 8%2$-(C+1(%(<%*(%/*()#(L!(

2@?(MFhD?B;(JF?(@<(BCD(B=J<(=A(MDI>C@?Q(C@?(8%2Q(<=PLD(=A(A=HKD(F<O([@KB=H@=E?(F?(5F(

/ID<OD?( 4DPDLD@<( 8:&:,( ( ( ( ( N( (

#1*$#()(/5#$#(,(%5(/,*(8%2( &(CFO(G=<D(<=HBC(B=(=AADH(?FLEBFB@=<?(FB(BCD(8%2(

F+:202*:!0(R/D?:(&^!I:(&&T(

47(*!1(SV( !:&&:`,( N( ( ( ( ( (

!0("0(8%2(/1-()(80<2:#3( )CD(O==H(PDC@<O(BCD(8%2(>E<@?C@<G(BCD(HDPDLL@=E?(

!"0:%:/%*(R,-^,,BC(%;<:T(

_DH?CDC(V( !:&&:,S( N( ( ( ( ( (

!"!$%( 0C,$1%=( +&0'( ;20,( %*.( )( ?$$@(#3$1*():?!=@$-(8%2$-(#,20&='(

)CD<(BCD;(PEH<DO(BCD(]@<G(JC=(JF?(@<(W::X(BCD@H(I@O?BRYT(J@BC(C@I(RBCD(]@<GYT(=A(C@?(8%2(=A(#,20&='(

"?FIBD](&&( b#(Uc-dV( 8:&:d( ( ( ( ( N( (

!"!$%$#(/5#(2#(",("1()(1(g(%(8%2( &(KFID(O=J<?BHDFI(@<(FBBD<OF<KD(FI=<G(U(ID<(=A(BCD(8%2(

I3;:/2:,%:$-:%-,(R/D?:(&&&T(

IMF<KC(SS-U( !:&&:Vg( N( ( ( ( ( (

!"!2$-(53!"#(*,(?#*,2(!0()@(B2%*(1+,(+2(#,$1%(,(8%2(&='(

2@?(P=FB?(@<(BCD(?DF?=<(=A(BCD(@<E<OFB@=<(W=A(BCD(GHDFB(H@[DHX(@<(B2%*(FHH@[DOQ(CF[@<G(PDD<(IFOD(A=H(BCD(8%2(&='(

E-,:"*+(R$DADHC=BD>(&T(

b#(US-c( !:&:,S( ( N( ( ( ( (

!<2(/%*2(/0(*0*.(#%2(,(8%2(552*( "H=[@?@=<?(=A(HFK]?(=A(JFBDH(>=B?(=A(BCD(=AA@KD(=A(BCD([@j@DHQ(#%2(RB=(PD(PH=EGCBT(B=(BCD(8%2(

/=P]:(&i( b#(V,d,,( !:&:,`( ( N( ( ( ( (

!<2(&='(1%2(%(G0:),#(5#(%(8%2( .(>H=[@?@=<?(RYT(=A(#G;>B(B=(PD(G@[D<(B=(BCD(8%2(

=(R,SBC(%;<:T( >5FID??DEI(&&&( !:&:,d((

( N( ( ( ( (

2%$1%(",(+C%*(,(*,?$$@2(?$$@(?)%@:-02*(#).:,(%2(*12(%3(%()C!(%3(%(8%2(

)CD;(RBCD(7@P;F<?T(JDHD(@<(HD?@?BF<KD(FGF@<?B(W::X(=A(BH==>?Q(=[DH?DDH(=A(CE<BDH?Q(D[DH;(K=IIF<ODH(=A(D[DH;(FHI(=A(BCD(8%2(

"?FIBD](&( 8F@H=(/5(.`,( 8:&:,.( ( ( ( ( N( (

2,2(%(L*%2(1*0(%0(%(1%2*(",(#"2(,(),.*(%*1%(#.#(8,(30;2$1%(,(32(8,(")$-(,(8%2()(8,()0!(%3(%-,(#%2()#(

)CD(>H@<KD?(=A(L*%2(OHFGGDO(BCD?D(ALFG(>=LD?(J@BC(=ND<(B=(BCD(CFHP=EHQ(F<O(BCD;(KFID(J@BC(BCD@H(BH@PEBD?(B=(BCD(>LFKD(JCDHD(

)CEB:(&&&( M1!(.S:cSS( _:&:g( ( ( N( ( ( (

Page 692: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-UV(

%5*(%3*(%*(")$#(((( 2@?(MFhD?B;(JF?Q(B=(BCD(8%2(@<(W:::X(J@BC(FLL(G==O(>H=OEKB?(BCFB(JDHD(PH=EGCB(F?(>HDK@=E?(G==O?(AH=I(BCD(?=EBCQ(W:::X(KCFHGDO(F?(BH@PEBD?(=A(BCD(F<<EFL(HD\E@HDID<B?Q(F?(FLL(?EPhDKB?(=A(M;(MFhD?B;(

25(%*&2'()(")(%(1*+:10(!%/(250(1%3(

8=IIF<O(=A(BCD(MFhD?B;(@<(BCD(1*+:10D(L:(>:(C:(

2FB?C:( %D@H(DL^_FCFH@(S( _:&:,.( ( ( N( ( ( (

25(")$-(#,*([_]()(5!)(%(*+(/01*()(8%2(21/*(>3*(

2@?(MFhD?B;(K=IIF<O(B=(O=([_](=A(G=LO(FB(BCD(CDFO(=A(BCD(C@LL(K=E<BH@D?(=A(BCD(8%2(=A(BCD(A=HB@A@DO(D<KL=?EHD?(=A(BCD(1D?B@[FL(

N"2*.(R)CEB:(&&&(f(2FB?C:T(

))(,,( _:&&:.`( ( ( N( ( ( (

25(")$-(1)%*(?25@(?",@(10(/01*(#)%**(",(#).:2,*(%*(8%2(

2@?(MFhD?B;(K=II@??@=<DO(B=(?DB(E>(WF(?BDLFX(PDC@<O(BCD(RDOGD(=A(BCDT(JD?BDH<(OD?DHB(=<(BCD(JD?BDH<(?@OD(=A(BCD(8%2(

)FCFH\F( %FC?CEH( 8:&:g( ( ( ( ( N( (

+0(3/%(%*.(8%2$-(%12()#(0/*(%(+*(L!:)1:12:),#:67)%(1#()$-()(%*,(

)CD(KF?BLD(JC@KC(@?(J@BC@<(C@?(8%2(@B(@?(L@]D(BCD(C=H@j=<(=A(CDF[D<Q(L!:)1:12:),#:67)%(@?(@<(@B(F?(G=O(

=(R/DB;(&T((Y(RMDHD<>BFCT(

>!<F?BF?@(&i((>!<F?BF?@(&&(

_:&:U.((_:&:UU(

( ( ( N( ( (

+",$%$-("%!$1%(",(10(/01*(Y%3:"5()(2%2*(I"*+%1(+"$1%(?F05@2,()(2%2*(23%(!%%$1%(,(8%2()(2%2*();*:?%3@(1((

2D(JD<B(J@BC(BCDI(AH=I(BCD(OD?DHB(=A(MDI>C@?(@<(BCD(dBC(C=EH(=A(BCD(<@GCB:()CD;(HDFKCDO(BCD(4HDFB(4HDD<(RBCD(1F;EIT(@<(BCD(,?B(C=EH(=A(BCD(OF;(F<O(HDBEH<DO(B=(BCD(8%2(@<(BCD(SHO(C=EH(=A(BCD(OF;(

)FCFH\F( %FC?CEH( 8:&:g( ( ( ( ( N( (

&67)%'(),#(%(8%2( _DL=[DO(=A(BCD(8%2( E/*:)%*2(R5FI:(&&T(

#LD>CF<B@<D(.( _:&&:,.d( ( ( ( N( ( (

),2*$#(%3$#()(8%2(5050*(&='(+,( &(JF?(L=[DO(P;(M;(7=HO(@<(BCD(8%2(=A(BCD(C=E?D(=A(BCD(IFG@?BHFBD?(RYT(

E*,:"*+(R,,BC(%;<:(YT(

2FB<EP(,`( !:&&:,,( N( ( ( ( ( (

)1(<1%(#,,*()(8%2(,(/*(%3*( *CFB(@?(PD@<G(O=<D(@<(BCD(8%2(@?(I=HD(O@AA@KELB(BCF<(F<;BC@<G(RDL?DT(

B+2(RM:e:T( >38(S..--( !:&&:Sg( N( ( ( ( ( (

)522(+,*()(8%2(!"( *=HO?(BCFB(K=ID(A=HBC(BCD(8%2(=A(BCD(!"( >+2(R!I:(&&&T( 84(VgS( _:&&:cS( ( ( N( ( ( (

Page 693: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-UU(

%(+0(#"2(!0(&$$'(%(8%2( &<(BCD(GHDFB(?BFPLD(R::T(=A(BCD(8%2( >,#(R5FI:(&&T( _ECD<(S( _:&&:,`d( ( ( ( N( ( (

%3*(*02.()(8%2(51,2(%2(!"$1( )CD(7FO;(=A(BCD()J=(7F<O?(KFID(AH=I(@<?@OD(BCD(?>LD<O=H?(=A(CDH(k"(

2FB?C:( eFH<F](U( _:&:d( ( ( N( ( ( (

%-,()(8%2(/02( _DFEB@AEL(=A(BCD(8%2(=A(BCD(=AA@KD( 67%*-(R/D?:(&T( _M(,dc(WVg,X( !:&&:SS( N( ( ( ( ( (

%12*:3#*.(F1#:)0!:L!:1*+:%:L!(10(L!(L!:),:)12(5#(!%/(#%#(3C2*(&)(13#2'(,(G0:),#(1,2(O,(#%#(%2(#%2$1%(,(!"$-(

e@<G(=A(BCD(/=EBCDH<(F<O($=HBCDH<(#G;>BQ(F1#:)0!:L!:1*+:%:L!Q(?=<(=A(5DQ(5FI:(Q(G@[D<(L@AD(JC=(KFHH@D?(BCD(HDPDL?(B=(#G;>BQ(RJC@LDT(BCD@H(KC@DA?(PDFH(BCD@H(BH@PEBD(B=(C@?(!"(

5FI:((&&( 8F@H=(8:.,Q(8:..( _:&&:`.( ( ( ( ( ( (

&%12*'(5#(#0*(%(),*(%$-(!"!2()(8%2$-( RBCD(]@<GT(JC=(G@[D?(F<(=AA@KD(B=(C@I(JC=I(CD(L=[D?(F<O(F(L@ADB@ID(@?(@<(C@?(8%2((

=(R/DB;(&T( _F<]D?(8=LLDKB@=<( _:&&:,.S( ( ( ( N( ( (

?%*$-(#,$$%3@()(%#2*(,12*(?)(8%2@( W@B(@?(CD(JC=::D[DH;X(@<()CDPD?(WF<O(@<(BCD(8%2X(

B0:1,(R/DB;(&(f(5FI:((&&T(

))(,-U( _:&&:,.g( ( ( ( N( ( (

?$$@(,(#%*(%$1*(!<2()(8%2( W::X(B=(PH@<G(A=H(BCD(>H=[@?@=<?(AH=I(BCD(8%2( 67#:#3(RM:e:T( >38(S..-.( !:&&:Sc( N( ( ( ( (

$$(,(8%2(0"*(\(/0( ::B=(BCD(8%2(F(A@DLO(=A(,-(/0( !I:(&&( MDI>C@?( !:&:g( N( ( ( ( ( (

,/%$%$#(<3$-(,(02$-(10"$%$#(5,:!()(8%2$-(&$$'(%-,2(3#*(,/2(25!(#).&2':8*(15).2()5*(+,:%12*(8+2(%2(!,6.*(

&(]<=J(C@?(@<BDH@=H(D<B@HDL;(RPDKFE?DT(&(HDFKC(BCD(ODD>(=A(C@?(8%2(R::T(J@BC(F(K=HHDKB(BDI>DHQ(FPLD(B=(AFBC=I(BCD(BC=EGCB?Q(=PDO@D<B(B=(BCD(@<hE<KB@=<?(=A(BCD(+,:%12*((F<O(BCD(LFJ?(=A(BCD(K=EHB(

2=HDICDP( %E>L:84(S`,U.( _:&:.U( ( ( N( ( ( (

,5#*(#%$*2$-(,(8%2(2C5$#*2$-(",(+0(*;;(#,$%$-(

8FE?@<G(C@I(B=(PD(PH=EGCB(B=(BCD(8%2(F<O(\ED?B@=<DO(K=<KDH<@<G(BCD([@=LFB@=<(JC@KC(CD(CF?(K=II@BBDO(

Y(R/=P]:(&&T( >_H==]L;<(SV:,``U(

!:&:,g( ( N( ( ( ( (

,5#*(")$-(*+(%-,(250(,(8%2(!%/(250(1%3(

2@?(MFhD?B;(IFOD(F(>H=?>DH=E?(PDG@<<@<G(=A(HDBEH<@<G(B=(BCD(8%2D(L:(>:(C:(

I3;:/2:,%:$-:%-,(R/D?:(&&&T(

IMF<KC(SS-U( !:&&:Vd( N( ( ( ( ( (

,5#*$;(02#(#2(%*.()(8%2(#/(#,$;(02#(*2(",((

7DB(C@I(JC=(@?(@<(BCD(8%2(K=IDRYT:()CD<(?CFLL(;=E(KFE?D(RF(O@HDKB@[DT(B=(PD(@??EDO(RK=<KDH<@<GT::(

Y(R/=P]:(&&T( >_H==]L;<(SV:,``U(

!:&:,g( ( N( ( ( ( (

Page 694: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-Uc(

8,(+%(#2(")$-()(8%2(B,:01*(+0(;0(!0(L!:>,2:0/:*.(

+<(BC@?(OF;(2@?(MFhD?B;(JF?(@<(BCD(8%2(=A(B,:01*Q(6)CD(4HDFB(/=EL(=A(5F^2FHF]CBD9(

/CD?C=<\(&( 4DPDL(DL^/@L?@LFC(<=:(,--(

8:&:.( ( ( ( ( N( (

")$-()(",(#).:,0(;0*(%3*(%&*'(8%2$-( 2@?(MFhD?B;(=HODHDO(B=(D[DH;(?E>DH@<BD<OD<B(=A(J=H]?(=A(C@?(8%2(

)FCFH\F( b#(SggU,( 8:&:U( ( ( ( ( N( (

")$-()(8%2(E#*&#'( 2@?(MFhD?B;(JF?(@<(BCD(8%2(=A(E#*&#'( 4%*:>,(R$D]=(&&T( 7=E[HD(!(gS( 8:&&:.c( ( ( ( ( N( (

?"@)$-(C)()C!(,(*0(Q01(1,.2("%!$-(%*(!"%2*.( 1+,( +2( #,$%$1%( ?$$@,:?O=@:30(8%2(+2(%(;20,(%*.( #)("%!(5)#(G0:58%(,%$1%(

2@?(WMXFhD?B;(?D<B(BCD(FHI;(B=(BCD(LF<O(=A(Q01Q(BCD(C@GC(=AA@K@FL?(PD@<G(J@BC(C@I(AH=I(BCD(!"%2&*.'$()CD;(HDFKCDO(?$$@,:?O=@:30(BCD(8%2(=A(BCD(]@<G(PD@<G(L=KFBDO(BCDHDQ(FL=<G(J@BC(BCD(B=J<(P;(BCD(<FID(=A(G0:58%(

"?FIBD](&&( b#(Uc-dV( 8:&:d( ( ( ( ( N( (

>,(#%5(",(*-()(",$#(,(8%2(,(#%#(>,(E/%("%:!(92*$-(6712*()!0:/,2(

2=HE?Q(F[D<GDH(=A(2@?(1FBCDHQ(GF[D(ID(F(K=II@??@=<(B=(BCD(8%2(RL@B:(>LFKDO(@<(I;(AFKD(B=(BCD(8%2T(B=(ADBKC(2=HE?(=A($D]CD<(B=GDBCDH(J@BC(C@?(I=BCDHQ(&?@?Q(hE?B@A@DO(

f,:%":/!$-(R,SBC(%;<:T(

MM!(SV:c:VV( !:&&:,`g( N( ( ( ( ( (

>,()(8%2( 2=HE?(=A(BCD(8%2( 672%.(R/DB;(&T( _DHL@<(g,c.( _:&&:,.c( ( ( ( N( ( (

",#(%(8%2(8,(1/,(55$-(( 8=<BD<B(@<(BCD(8%2(=[DH(BCD(K=E<?DL(=A(JCFB(?F@O(P;(C@I(

E",.(RMD<:(&iT( 2FB<EP(.V( !:&&:d( N( ( ( ( ( (

"*,&2'(30;2$1%(,(8%2()#(G0:),#( )CD@H(BH@PEBD?(JDHD(O@HDKBDO(B=(BCD(8%2(F?(R@A(BCD;(CFO(K=ID(AH=IT(#G;>B(

"?FIDB@](&( 7=E[HD(#(SSSV( 8:&:,S( ( ( ( ( ( N(

"*,2(%(+0(#"2(!0(%(40:%:L!:),.:67)%(%(8%2(

2=H?D?(=A(BCD(4HDFB(/BFPLD(=A(40:%:L!(),:67)%(PDL=<G@<G(B=(BCD(8%2(

=(RMDHD<>BFCT( >_=L=G<F(,-d`( _:&:UV( ( ( ( N( ( (

/5#$%$#(/%*#$%$#((8%2(( &(AFHDO(O=J<?BHDFI(F<O(&(?F@LDO(E>?BHDFI(B=(BCD(8%2(

F+:202*:!0(R/D?:(&T(

7D@OD<(V(Ri(`T( !:&&:.`( N( ( ( ( ( (

1(Ehi(8%2( !(\EF<B@B;(=A(ID<(=A(BCD(8%2( =(R/D?:(&T((I3;:/2:,%:$-:%-,(R/D?:(&&&T(

I!?JF<(,`c,(((IMF<KC(SS-U(

!:&&:Sd((!:&&:Vd(

N( ( ( ( ( (

10"2(!"62(%-,(8%2( 10"2Q(FI=E<BQ(G==O(\EFL@B;(=A(BCD(8%2( /D?:(&( >5D@?<DH(&&( !:&:,V( N( ( ( ( ( (

Page 695: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-Ug(

1)%*$%$-(B2%*()(8%2$-( /CD(IFOD(B2%*(D?BFPL@?CDO(@<(C@?(8%2( 2FB?C:( %D@H(DL^_FCFH@(S( _:&:,.( ( ( N( ( ( (

1/5#(12*(\jZ(&='(8!<(O1("%!(H(&='(3v0(8!<("%!(\Z$ZZZ(&='(*,(,(8%2(",(2!(1(#)$*%(%3();(#+$#(1*(,(8%2((

/D<O@<G(O=J<?BHDFI(,V-(RYT("<0*(=A(JCDFBQ(O=EPLD(RYT("<0*(IFLB(F<O(,-:---(RYT(*,^L=F[D?(B=(BCD(8%2(A=H(DFKC(=<D(;=E:(&(?CFLL(HDK]=<(@B(FB(BCD(8%2(

=(R/D?:(&T( >5D@?<DH(&&( !:&:,V( N( ( ( ( ( (

C)(##()(****(/,(2%)$-(/,(12,$-()(8%2(

2D(G=D?(F<O(K=ID?(J@BC(\EFHHDL?(JCD<(CD(DFB?(F<O(OH@<]?(@<(BCD(8%2(

=(R,d^.-BC(%;<:T( >_M(,-`c`(^&<?BHEKB@=<(=A(67)%:):#+*(

_:&&&:`( ( ( ( N( ( (

C1+()(#%.*()(?$$@(+,:%12*(>,:+,(!%/(250(1%3()(#%2(%(#).:,(

5DKD@[@<G(JCFB(JF?(PH=EGCB(AH=I(RYT(W::X(BCD(+,:%12*(L:(>:(C:(F?(F(BH@PEBD(=A(BCD(?BDJFHO(

=(RMDHD<>BFCT( >_M(,-.`UP((^(>!<F?BF?@(&&&(dS,1e(

_:&:Ug( ( ( ( N( ( (

?<)0@(C-.*()(8%2(1*(2,*( +<D(JC=(KHDFBD?(O@G<@B;( @<(BCD(8%2(=A(BCD(4HDFB(/DFB(

67%:#*$-(R)CEB:(&&&T( 7=E[HD(8(.U( _:&&:,-( ( ( N( ( ( (

O)$%$-(&='(30;(#)()(/%,*(%(<%3*.(%(2(/*)$%$-(,(8%2(

2D(A=E<O(BCD(?DH[F<B(BCDHD(@<(BCD(D<KL=?EHD(=A(BCD(O@?BH@KB^K=E<K@LL=H(RFABDHT(CD(CFO(?F@LDO(B=(BCD(8%2(

I%:3232(RM:eT( >38(S.,.g( !:&&:SU( N( ( ( ( ( (

*1#(50)2$;(),.(*2(8%2( )CD(HDG@=<(=A(MDI>C@?(J@BC(,-:---(ID<Q(=AA@K@FL?(FHD(@<(@B(?@<KD(BCD(B@ID(@B(JF?(F(8%2(

=(R,.BC(%;<:T( >7D<@<GHFO(,,,U!Q(>M=?K=J(`UVgQ(>8FHL?PDHG(U(

!:&&&:.( N( ( ( ( ( (

50#&*'(&='(,)*(%(8%2()(*02*(&='(,(#0*:1/*.2(=H(/*(10"2&='(

)HF<?>=HB@<G(RYT(>D=>LD(B=(BCD(8%2(@<(BCD(?D@jEHD(&='((B=(#0*:1/*.2`J@<(BCD(KCFHGD(=A(RYT(=A(I;(D?BFBD^J=H]DH?(RYT(

=(R/=P]:(&&T( >_H==]L;<(SV:,``U(

!:&:,g( ( N( ( ( ( (

5#$%$-(/!#(>,()(8%2(F01*( /CD(IFOD(2=HE?(F>>DFH(@<(BCD(8%2(=A()CDPD?(

)CEB:(&&&( eFH<F](`( _:&:`( ( ( N( ( ( (

5%"2(%-,2(,5#(8%2( 4==O(\EFL@B;(FKFK@F(5%"2(BCD(8%2(G@[D?( /D?:(&( >5D@?<DH(&&( !:&:,V( ( ( ( ( ( (

55$-(,$;(8%2()*2(TZ( 2D(J@LL(HDLFBD(;=EH(?>DDKC(B=(BCD(8=E<K@L(=A()C@HB;(=A(BCD(8%2(

Y(R,d^.-BC(%;<:T( &<?BHEKB@=<(=A(67)%:):#+*(

_:&&&:`( ( ( N( (((( ( ((((

55$%(")$-(#%#(%$#(**(!,<(%*(+,:!%/(!,<2( )CD<(2@?(MFhD?B;(?F@On(6_H@<G(ID(BCD( 5FI:((&&( 7=E[HD(8(.g`( _:&:`,( ( ( ( N( ( (

Page 696: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-Ud(

%*(8%2( >DH?=<<DL(=A(BCD(2=E?D(=A(7@ADQ(F<O(BCD(AE<KB@=<FH@D?(=A(BCD(8%2k(

)@BLD?(F<O(D>@BCDB?(#).:,(+,:"5(%32(%&$#'(8%2( +[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(BHDF?EH;(=A(BCD(G=LO(=A(BCD(

8%2(><0:):10$-(R!IF?@?T(

/F\\FHF(RKT( 8:&&:V-( ( ( ( ( N( (

#).:,(8%2( +[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(8%2( L)%:##:!%/(R,.BC(%;<:T((I%:%:92*(R2FB?C:T((

84(.-c`g((())(c,(

!:&&:,-U(((_:&&:Sd((

N( ( ( ( ( (

#).:,(8%2(%(/0(%(#).:,(/*)( +[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(8%2(@<(BCD(=AA@KD(=A(BCD(=[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(BHDF?EH;(

L)%.:!%/(R,.BC(%;<:T(

84(.-Vc,( !:&&:,,.( N( ( ( ( ( (

#).:,(1C2()(8%2(%(*0(>2*:L!?:)112:),#:Y)%@(8%2(

+[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(BHDF?EH;Q(=[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(?KH@PD?(@<(BCD(8%2(@<(BCD(LF<O(=A(>2*:L!:)112:),#:67)%(8%2(

I*&2'.(R5FI:(&&T( !PE(/@IPDL(.( _:&&:,`U( ( ( ( N( ( (

2!2(%(8%2(%(8%.*(/!:):)0!*( /F@L=H(=A(BCD(P=FBl?(K=<B@<GD<B(/!:):)0!*( 67+2(R,gBC(%;<:T( _M(.dV( _:&&:,,-( ( ( N( ( ( (

),.(<3%*(%*(8%2((

_DL=[DO(=A(BCD(<3%*(=A(BCD(8%2( 67)%:):"0*(R/D?:(&^!I:(&&T(

_D<@(2F?F<(.( !:&&:`.( N( ( ( ( ( (

%3*(8%2$1( RMEBT(LFO;(=A(CDH(8%2( 5FI:((i&( _M(,d`( _:&:U-( ( ( ( N( ( (

",.(#"2(&$$'(67)%(),#(%(8%2(8%2( /BFPLD^IF?BDH(RPDL=[DOT(=A(!IE<Q(=A(BCD(8%2(

E/*:)%*2(R5FI:(&&T(

#LD>CF<B@<D(.( _:&&:,.d( ( ( ( N( ( (

",.(#"2(%(8%2( /BFPLD(IF?BDH(=A(BCD(8%2( B*":):2#0(R5FI:(&&T((67)%:"*+((R5FI:(&&T((E-,:!32(R5FI:(&&T((F%:*0:20*(R5FI:(

_M(,Uc(((/DCDL((>84(8Vg-Vd((_ECD<(`(

_:&&:,`-(((_:&&:,`.((_:&&:,`S((_:&&:,V-(

( ( ( N( ( (

Page 697: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-c-(

&&T((B0:"):%*,(R5FI:(&&T((F%%:%-,(RMDHD<:T((E/*:67)%(R5FI:(&&&T((B0:"):%*,(R5FI:(&&&T((B0:1,(R5FI:(&&&T((67)%:):#+*(R5FI:(&&&T((F%&:*0':2!(R5FI:(&'T((F%:2!0*(R5FI:(&'T((F%:*0:20*(R5FI:(&'T(((>,#(R,dBC(%;<:T(

((+&8:(,,cS,((((_M(,V`((MDG@OO=(((84(.VcUd(((MDO@<DB(2FPE(S(())(,`g(((/DI<F(.(((_M(cd.(("D<<?;L[F<@F(3<@[DH?@B;(ME?DEI(#:(,-dd-((_M(,S.(

((_:&&:,V,(((_:&&:,Vg(((_:&&:,U,(((_:&&:,U.(((_:&&:,U,((_:&&:,U`(((_:&&:,Ud(((_:&&:,c-((_:&&:,c,((((_:&&:,g-(

",.(&$$'(%(+0(#"2(!0(%(L!:)112:),#:67)%(!%/(250(1%3(%(8%2(

/BFPLD^IF?BDH(=A(BCD(GHDFB(?BFPLD(=A(L!:)112:),#:67)%(L:(>:(C:(=A(BCD(8%2(

=(RMDHD<>BFCT( >/FLL@DH(&( _:&:Ud( ( ( ( N( ( (

"1.(&)'(8%2(%&$#'(67)%&2'( 1F[=HDO(@<(BCD(8%2(=A(!IE<( B0:*%-#(R"?FI:(&T( ))(,.g( 8:&&:.S( ( ( ( ( N( (

1),(,(8%2( 8=I>F<@=<(=A(BCD(8%2( 67%#:%*:)%:*2:O3( 84(.-c,.( !:&&:dc( N( ( ( ( ( (

Page 698: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-c,(

R,.BC(%;<:T(1),(*+.!8%(%(>,()(8%2(!"$-(,(%12( 1@H?B(K=I>F<@=<(JC=(F>>H=FKCD?(2=HE?(

J@BC@<(C@?(8%2(!"(B=(BCD(]@<G(E-,:1/,J(R!I:(&&&T( ))(,-c( _:&&:gV( ( ( N( ( ( (

1C(%(8%2( /KH@PD(=A(BCD(8%2( Y(R5FI:(&'T( >_M(,--VS(,Sl*e( _:&:c`( ( ( ( N( ( (

1C(%12*()(8%2(+,:%12*( 5=;FL(?KH@PD(=A(BCD(8%2(=A(BCD(+,:%12*( =(R.-BC(%;<:T( +<=IF?B@K=<(=A(l7)%:):#+*(

_:&:d,( ( ( ( N( ( (

1C(%12*(%,#$-(,(!(<,"*()(!*(#,+&2'(%(8%2(

5=;FL(?KH@PD(ODFL@<G(J@BC([D??DL?(F<O(BCD(J@<D(OD>FHBID<B(=A(BCD(8%2(

E-,:"*+(R5FI:(&&T( 7=E[HD(8(,`g( _:&&:,`,( ( ( ( N( ( (

/*)2(3#*.(12,(%(8%2( /DFLDH( =A( 3>>DH( F<O( 7=JDH( #G;>B( JC=(OH@<]?(@<(BCD(8%2((

I2:):%2*(R)CEB:(&&&(f(!I:(&&T(

))(d.( _:&&:S,( ( ( N( ( ( (

;5%(%(+0(#"2(+,:!0(%(40:L!:),.(67)%(8%.(&R8%2'(

8CFH@=BDDH(=A(BCD(4HDFB(/BFPLD(=A(BCD("CFHF=C(=A(40:L!:),.(67)%(L:(>:(C:(=A(BCD(8%2(

=(RMDHD<>BFCT( >_M(,-.`UP((^(>!<F?BF?@(&&&(dS,1e(

_:&:Ug( ( ( ( N( ( (

;5%(*+.(%(")$-(%(+0(#"2(!0(%(F1,:)0!*:,!(I*+:%:,!(%(?8%2@(

1@H?B(KCFH@=BDDH(=A(C@?(MFhD?B;(@<(BCD(GHDFB(?BFPLD(=A(F1,:)0!*:,!(I*+:%:,!(@<(BCD(?8%2@(

67)%:2!:%?$$@(R5FI:(&'T(

i@KB=H@F(ME?DEI( _:&&:,c`( ( ( ( N( ( (

;5%(*+.(%(")$-(%(+0(#"2(!0(%(L!:)112:),#:67)%(%(8%2(

1@H?B(KCFH@=BDDH(=A(C@?(MFhD?B;(@<(BCD(GHDFB(?BFPLD(=A(L!:)112:),#:67)%(@<(BCD(8%2(

40;(R,dBC(%;<:T((

7=E[HD(8(dU((

_:&&:,cg( ( ( ( N( ( (

*0*.(%(%#2*(,1*(%(8%2( i@j@DH(=A(BCD(/=EBCDH<(8@B;(F<O(BCD(8%2( L/:)#:,!( ))(,--( _:&&:SS( ( ( N( ( ( (

(

( (

Page 699: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-c.(

/;<=>?@?(=A(BCD(E?FGD(=A(BCD(BDHI(1*+:10! +J<DH! %=KEID<B! 8FBFL=G(HDADHD<KD?!

((M:5:! (($:5:! 7:":!

#N>HD??@=<?( #( 7( #( 7( #( 7(

#02*$#( +2( )( +,:%12*( !%/( 250( 1%3(2%2*$#(+2()(1*+:10(!%/(250(1%3(

)C@?(JF?(I;(=AA@KD(@<(BCD(+,:%12*D(L:(>:(C:a(BC@?(JF?(I;(OEB;(@<(BCD(1*+:10D(L:(>:(C:(

67%:#*$-(R)CEB:(&&&T( 7=E[HD(8(.U( _:&&:,-( ( ( N( ( ( (

##*()("*+()(1*+:10(!%/(250(1%3( &(KFID(=EB(@<(>DFKD(@<(BCD(1*+:10Q(L:(>:(C:( L/:)#:,!(R)CEB:(&&&(f(!I:(&&T(

))(,--( _:&&:SS( ( ( N( ( ( (

#2(),2*$#()(1*+:10(!%/(250(1%3( &(JF?(=<D(PDL=[DO(@<(BCD(1*+:10D(L:(>:(C:( #0":)1:E/3*(R,cBC(%;<:T(

#L]FP(,( _:&&:.( ( ( N( ( ( (

#2$-(2!*.(%(1*+:10(!%/(250(1%3( 2D(@?(BCD(=<D(@<(BCD(1*+:10D(L:(>:(C:( A!:):"0*(R!I:(&&&T( ))(Vc( _:&&:cV( ( ( N( ( ( (

#).:#3()(1*+:10( 1F[=H@BD(@<(BCD(1*+:10( 91:%:!)0!*(R,.BC(%;<:T(

_DHL@<(gg--( !:&&:,-d( N( ( ( ( ( (

205(")$-(C+12(1,2(%2(1*+:[10]( 8=IIF<O(@??EDO(@<(C@?(MFhD?B;(RF<OT(BCD(

<=PLD(K=EHB@DH?(=A(BCD(1*+:[10](!I:(&&((E3:67)%(R)CEB:(&iT(

eFH<F](c(())(d-(

_:&:,`((_:&&:Vg(

( ( N( ( ( (

2,("1&2'*$#()(1*+:10(,(1),(2!#((%3( 4HDFB(JF?(I;(>HF@?DZAF[=H(@<(BCD(1*+:10(I=HD(BCF<(F<;(K=EHB@DH(

>%)2:"*+(R!I:(&&^/D?:(&&T(

_D<@(2F?F<(S( !:&&:V,( N( ( ( ( ( (

21*%(,5()(1*+:10(55K( +<D(JC=(JFL]DO(FH=E<O(@<(BCD(1*+:10(RL@B:(6AHDD(=A(A==B(@<(BCD(1*+:10T(

N"2*.(R2FB?C:(f()CEB:(&&&T(

))(,,((

_:&&:.`( ( ( N( ( ( (

25$%$#()(1*+:10(!%/(250(1%3(",(;0*(#3(")*$1(,(<5($$(

&(K=IIF<ODO(@<(BCD(1*+:10D(L:(>:(C:Q(>LF<<@<G(BCD(OD?@HD(=A(2DH(MFhD?B;(B=(PE@LO(::(

I%:%:92*(R2FB?C:T(

))(c,( _:&&:`,( ( ( N( ( ( (

!<(",(51,2()(1*+:10(!%/(250(1%3( +<D(JC=(CF?(FKKD??(B=(BCD(?FKHDO(>LFKD(@<(BCD(1*+:10(

N"2*.:)12(R)CEB:(&&&(f(!I:(&&T(

1L=HD<KD(.VUV( _:&&:Ud( ( ( N( ( ( (

+,#("1.()(1*+:10( +<D(JC=(G=D?(A=HBC(>HF@?D?ZAF[=H?(@<(BCD(1*+:10(

>,2(R"DBEPF?B@?(&T( 84(`...Ua(b#(SUVcVa(eFH<F](8FKCDBBD(<=:(.(

8:&&:,V( ( ( ( ( N( (

+"$-(2!!2*(/%*(1*()(1*+:10(8,2()(15)( 2D(D<BDH?(@<(BCD(>H@[FK;(A=HDI=?B(=A( N52:I3;(R,.BC( _M(,dS([VUU]( !:&&:,--( N( ( ( ( ( (

Page 700: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-cS(

)52(2!(",.2()(30"(%3(*02.( >=?@B@=<(@<(BCD(1*+:10(OEH@<G(BCD(OF;(B=(CDFH(BCD(E<@\ED(J=HO(=A(BCD(KC@DA?(@<(BCD(>HD?D<KD(=A(BCD(7=HO(=A(BCD(BJ=(LF<O?(

%;<:T(

)00(##$-()(1*+:10( +<D(JC=?D(K=I@<G(@?(JF@BDO(@<(BCD(1*+:10((

E3:%*,2(R(+?=H]=<(&&(^(2FH?@D?D(!T(

84(`...Va(b#(ScV.,a(eFH<F](8FKCDBBD(<=:(S`c(

8:&&:S( ( ( ( ( N( (

)00$%$#(1)0(C-.*(0/*(&='(?"1#@()(%12*()(1*+:10(

&(?FJ(C@?(J=HBC(F?(CD(K@HKLDO(BCD(?CH@<D(RYT(F?(=<D(C=<=HDO(P;(BCD(]@<G(@<(BCD(1*+:10((

E3:%*,2(R(+?=H]=<(&&(^(2FH?@D?D(!T(

84(`...Va(b#(ScV.,a(eFH<F](8FKCDBBD(<=:(S`c(

8:&&:S( ( ( ( ( N( (

)00$*(*+:,5$*()(!"(#,*(;02(C+12(C+1$*(1!"(1/)*.(0/*()(";02$*(

0=E(?DD(;=EH(HELD?(@<(BCD(!"D(;=EH(;02(IFOD(<=PLDQ(HDKD@[@<G(;=EH(O@G<@B;Q(;=EH(O=EPLD(KH=J<(?C@<@<G(@<(;=EH(IFG@K([@HBED(

2FB?C:( %D@H(DL^_FCFH@(S( _:&:,,( ( ( N( ( ( (

)#(255*()(1*+:10(!%/(250(1%3( !?(K=IIF<ODO(@<(BCD(1*+:10(RL:>:C:wT( 2FB?C:((I%:%:92*(R2FB?C:T(

%D@H(DL^_FCFH@(S((84(Vcd(

_:&:,.((_:&&:`c(

( ( N( ( ( (

),2*()(1*+:10(!%/(250(1%3( _DL=[DO(@<(BCD(1*+:10D(L:(>:(C:( U%:67)%(R!I:(&&T( ))(dS( _:&&:V.( ( ( N( ( ( (

)5"(%$#([)(N08.](*%2(,%+*(%3*()(!C()0!(%(L)%%(#%2(,(1*+:10(!%/(250(1%3(

)CDHD(@?(CDJ<(A=H(ID(@<(%hFC;(DFKC(F<O(D[DH;(;DFH(K=<?@?B@<G(=A(HDFL(!C:J==O(=A(7DPF<=<Q(R@BT(@?(PH=EGCB(B=(BCD(1*+:10D(L:(>:(C:(

)CEB:(&&&( M1!(.S:cSS( _:&:g( ( ( N( ( ( (

)5"*(2#():,(1*+:10(!%/(250(1%3(*%2(,%+*(%3*()(/)*.2(",(!"!2(

)CDHD(JDHD(PE@LB(BCDHD(A=H(1*+:10D(L:(>:(C:Q(DFKC(F<O(D[DH;(OF;(/)*.2:?C@>?(F<O(IF<;(!"!2:?C@>?(

)CEB:(&&&( M1!(.S:cSS( _:&:g( ( ( N( ( ( (

%-,2()52*(*%(55*(/,$1%(15)(%*(%2()(1*+:10(!%/(250(1%3(

2=J(>DHADKB(@?(BC@?(?>DDKC(BCFB(JF?(?F@O(PDA=HD(E?Q(JC@KC(JD(CF[D(CDFHO(@<(BCD(1*+:10D(L:(>:(C:(

)CEB:(&&&( eFH<F](`( _:&:`( ( ( N( ( ( (

%%(#2(1+/(#)(1*+:10( $=(AFELB(=A(I@<D(KFID(=EB(@<(BCD(1*+:10( N20:,:%""(R)CEB:( )CDPD?(Y( _:&&:SV( ( ( N( ( ( (

Page 701: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-c`(

&&&(f(!I:(&&T(

%%(1+,$#()(1*+:10( &lLL(FHH@[D(@<(BCD(1*+:10( >+2:1%32(R)CEB:(&&&(f(2FB?C:T(

84(U`g( _:&&:.,( ( ( N( (((( ( (((N(

,/(1C*0()(1*+:10( +<D(JC=(]<=J?(?DKHDB?(@<(BCD(1*+:10( >,2:10:01*(R)F]DL=B(&&T((E/*$-:92*(R+?=H]=<(&&&(f()F]DL=B(&&&T(

5FID??DEI(((8F@H=(84(`..,,a(b#(Sc,Vda(eFH<F](8FKCDBBD(<=:(Scg(

8:&&:,,(((8:&&:,c(

( ( ( ( N( (

"0(%12*()0!$-(1,2(%2(1*+:10((( #NFLB@<G(BCD(]@<G(JCD<(CD(?DD?(BCD(=AA@K@FL?(=A(BCD(1*+:10(((

W)1&2'(R!I:(&&&T( /@<F@(,,V( !:&&:d`( N( ( ( ( ( (

")*$1(),#$%$1(2#(,/$%$1(#;,2$#()(1*+:10(((

2DH(IFhD?B;(L=[DO(IDQ(?CD(CF[@<G(HDK=G<@jDO(I;(\EFL@B@D?(@<(BCD(1*+:10(

67%%.(R!I:(&(f(2FB?C:T(

))(g,( _:&&:U( ( ( N( ( ( (

/+,(")1*(%12*(51$-()(5052(%(#).(F,*(#2(,)*2(#+2(%(",(8*2$1%()(1*+:10(

)CDHD(=KKEHHDO(F(?@BB@<G(=A(BCD(]@<G(@<(BCD(FEO@D<KD(CFLL(=A(BCD(*D?B:()CD?D(>D=>LD(FHD(=<(BCD@H(PDLL@D?(@<(BCD(1*+:10(

2FB?C:( %D@H(DL^_FCFH@(.( _:&:,,( ( ( N( ( ( (

13()(#/*(%3*(%-,*()(1*+:10(!%/(250(1%3(%(>2*:>,(%3*(B2%*(>,&:*+'(!%/(250(")*$1(

_H@<G@<G(=A(D[DH;(G==O(BC@<G(AH=I(BCD(1*+:10(RL:>:C:wT(B=(2FBC=HQ(I@?BHD??(=A(B2%*Q(A=H(BCD(L@ADQ(>H=?>DH@B;(F<O(CDFLBC(=A(2DH(MFhD?B;(

2FB?C:( %D@H(DL^_FCFH@(S( _:&:,.( ( ( N( ( ( (

1+,(")(%(1*+:10(!%/(250(1%3(,(,25(%(%3(%*,2(15)(25()(1*:2,*(%52*:,0(%*(%*,(51$-(5!,(202*(,(B2%*((

"DB@B@=<(=A(BCD(MFhD?B;(=A(BCD(1*+:10D(L:(>:(C:(B=(BCD(?BF@H?(=A(BCD(7=HO(=A(BCD(G=O?(F<O(@<?BHEKB@=<?(JDHD(CDFHO(AH=I(BCD(4HDFB()CH=<DQ(F<(=HFKLD(AH=I(BCD(G=O(C@I?DLAn(6DN>L=HD(BCD(H=EBD?(B=(B2%*(R::T9(

2FB?C:( %D@H(DL^_FCFH@(S( _:&:,.( ( ( N( ( ( (

1*0(1,2(1),2(%2(1*+:10(,(15)(1C)(%(25*((

*FL](=A(=AA@K@FL?(F<O(K=EHB@DH?(=A(BCD(1*+:10(B=(CDFH(BCD(GE@OD(=A(BCD(K=IIF<O(

2FB?C:( %D@(DL(_FCFH@(S( _:&:,.( ( ( N( ( ( (

Page 702: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-cV(

5#$#%(")$#(#%#$*2(%$-(%12*(C+12(1!"2(1),2(C%2*(%*(8%2("0*.:!(,/*.2(,(#,*$1%(25*(",(5#*(")(%(I0*(>,(+%()(!8%2*.$-()(!"$-(?),&2*@'(%(!"&*'(

M;(MFhD?B;(CF?(IFOD(K=ID(BCD(H=;FL(<=PLD?Q(BCD(O@G<@BFH@D?(F<O(BCD(K=I>F<@=<?Q(BCD(D<B=EHFGD(=A(BCD(8%2Q(BCD(>H@<K@>FL(KC@DA?(B=(DNDKEBD(;=EH(K=IIF<OQ(@<(=HODH(B=(G@[D(BCD(MFhD?B;(=A(2=HE?l(OFEGCBDH(@<(C@?(!8%2*.(@<(C@?(!"D(PDL=[DO(@<(BCD(!"$(

2FB?C:( %D@H(DL^_FCFH@(.( _:,:,,( ( ( N( ( ( (

5#*(%(#%#(,(1*+:10( _D@<G(PH=EGCB(B=(BCD(1*+:10( !I:(&&( MDI>C@?( !:&:g( N( ( ( ( ( (

55*(205&*'(02.$*2()(")(%(1*+:10(!%/(250(1%3()(8,2(+%(

%DKHDD(FOOHD??DO(@<(BCD(MFhD?B;(=A(BCD(1*+:10Q(L:(>:(C:(=<(BC@?(OF;(

/DB;(&((5FI:((&&(

!P;O=?(.((#LD>CF<B@<D((

_:&:SS((_:&:Vg(

( ( N( ( ( (

N55&2'*()(")(%(1*+:10(!%/(250(1%3( *CFB(JF?(?F@O(PDA=HD(BCD(MFhD?B;(=A(BCD(1*+:10D(L:(>:(C:(

!CI=?D((()CEB:(&&&(()CEB:(&&&((5FI:(&&((E-,:+,*:,!(R)CEB:(&&&T(

eFH<F](.(((eFH<F](V((/DI<F(,((MM!(V`:,gV((84(`.,.,(

_:&:S((_:&:U((_:&:c((_:&:`U((_:&&:,.(

( ( N( ( ( (

)@BLD?(F<O(D>@BCDB?n(#).:,(%(1*+:10( +[DH?DDH(=A(BCD(1*+:10( L/:)#:,!(R)CEB:(&&&(

f(!I:(&&T())(,--( _:&&:SS( ( ( N( ( ( (

!<(",(51,2()(1*+:10(!%/(250(1%3( +<D(JC=(CF?(FKKD??(B=(BCD(?FKHDO(>LFKD(@<(BCD(1*+:10(

N"2*.:)12( 1L=HD<KD(.VUV( _:&&:Ud( ( ( N( ( ( (

!<(8,(%-,*(32(8,(%12*(+,("12()(1*+:10( +<D(JC=(D<BDH?(PDFH@<G(G==O(BC@<G?(B=(BCD( F1,:"0*(R)CEB:(&&&( ))(VU( _:&&:S.( ( ( N( ( ( (

Page 703: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-cU(

!%/(250(1%3( >LFKD(PDFH@<G(BCD(]@<G(F<O(JC=(K=ID?(A=HBC(

f(!I:(&&T((>,:):"3(

(())(cg(

((_:&&:Vc(

2,(#%2()(1*+:10([!%/(250(1%3]( 4HDFB(=A(#%2(@<(BCD(1*+:10D([L:>:C:]( E".(R)CEB:(&&&T( iFH@=E?( _:&&:,d( ( ( N( ( ( (

2,()(O1*()(1*+:10( 4HDFB(=A(HE<<@<G(@<(BCD(1*+:10((

N5:N"2*.:#2$-:!%/(R+?=H]=<(&&(f(2FH?@D?D(!T((9,.:67)%(F1,;*%(R+?=H]=<(&&T(

84(`..-ca(b#(SUdS,a(eFH<F](8FKCDBBD(<=:(,V.((eFH<F]()(SV(

8:&&:`((((8:&&:V(

( ( ( ( N( (

2,("12*()(1*+:10(%3(1/0(%-,()(!"( 4HDFB(=A(>HF@?D?(@<(BCD(1*+:10Q(7=HO(=A(G==O(HDIDIPHF<KD(@<(BCD(!"((

L5:*2:"P0:25"2:33.(R,.BC(%;<:T(

84(.-.V`( !:&&:,-`( '( ( ( ( ( (

2,(/%*.2()(1*+:10( 4HDFB(A=HDI=?B(A(BCD(1*+:10( I):):#0"( ))(,.c( _:&&:`U( ( ( N( ( ( (

2,2(%2(1*+:10( 4HDFB(=<D?(=A(BCD(1*+:10( 67)%:21,(R)CEB:(&&&^!I:(&&&T(

))(,S,( _:&&:SU( ( ( N( ( ( (

25+2()(1*+:10(!%/(250(1%3( _EBLDH(@<(BCD(1*+:10Q(L:(>:(C:( E3:67)%(R)CEB:(&^&&T(

))(.`( _:&&:S( ( ( N( ( ( (

+,&2'( &)'( "1KJ"12()( 1*+:10( !%/(250(1%3(

+<D(JC=(K=ID?(A=HBC(>HF@?D?ZAF[=H?(AH=I(BCD(1*+:&10'Q(L:>:C:((

B0:%2:%.(R)CEB:(&&&T((l7)%:"*+(R!I:(&&&T((G%2%0(R)CEB:(&iT((>,:):"3(R)CEB:(&iT((>2.(R)EB:T(

)EH@<(RFT(((84(VgS((())(cU((())(cg(((())(`-(

_:&&:,.(((_:&&:cS((_:&&:VU((_:&&:Vc(((_:&&:,-S(

( ( N( ( ( (

Page 704: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-cc(

)%(),*()(+,:%12*(%3("12()(1*+:10(!%/(250(1%3(

1@HI(=A(L=[D(@<(BCD(+,:%12*Q(7=HO(=A(>HF@?D?ZAF[=H?(@<(BCD(1*+:10D(L:(>:(C:(

#!"((#0":)1:E/3*( (

7=E[HD(8(`d((#L]FP(,(

_:&&:,((_:&&:.(

( ( N( ( ( (

)%("12()(1*+:10(&!%/(250(1%3'( 1@HI(=A(>HF@?D?ZAF[=H?(@<(BCD(1*+:10(RL:(>:(C:T( L)%:##:!%/(R,.BC(%;<:T((l7)%:):"0*(R)CEB:(&&&(f(!I:(&&T((I2:):%2*(R)CEB:(&&&(f(!I:(&&T((G%&2':%.(R)CEB:(&&&(f()CEB:(&iT((I%:%:)2*(R2FB?C:T((>;0:,:%""(R)CEB:(&iT((I3;:"*+(R)CEB:(&iT((l7)%:"*+(R!I:(&&&T((!0%%(R!I:(&&&T(

84(.-c`g((())(dc((())(d.((())(c`(((_M(,c`(())(U`((())(US((84(VgS(()EH@<(RPT((

!:&&:,-U(((_:&&:S-(((_:&&:S,(((_:&&:Sg(((_:&&:``((_:&&:VV(((_:&&:US((_:&&:cS((_:&&:c`((

( ( N( ( ( (

),2*()(1*+:10(!%/(250(1%3( _DL=[DO(@<(BCD(1*+:10D(L:(>:(C:( U%:67)%( ))(dS( _:&&:V.( ( ( ( ( ( (

),2*$-(&%12*'()(1*+:10( 2@?(R]@<Gl?T(L=[D(@<(BCD(1*+:10( >%)2:"*+(R!I:( _D<@(2F?F<(S( !:&&:V,( N( ( (((( (((( ( (((

Page 705: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-cg(

( &&^/D?:(&&T((F+:202*:!0(R/D?:(&(^(!I:(&&:T(

((47(*!1(SV(R=LO(<=:(`-T(

((!:&&:`,(

N(

%3(#)0*()(1*+:10( "=??D??=H(=A(GHFK@=E?<D??(@<(BCD(1*+:10( 9%:/+,:1%3(R)CEB:(&&&T((67)%:):#+*(R)CEB:(&&&(f(!I:(&&T(

8F@H=(V`c(((())(dU((

_:&&:,`(((_:&&:.U(

( ( N( ( ( (

%3(%)**()(1*+:10( 7=HO(RpAHDDT(=A(?BD>?(@<(BCD(1*+:10( N1:A%12:#2$-:!%/(R)F]DL=B(&T(

84(VVd( 8:&&:.( ( ( ( ( N( (

%3("12*()(1*+:10(&!%/(250(1%3'( 7=HO(=A(BCD(>HF@?D?ZAF[=H?(@<(BCD(1*+:10D(L:(>:(C:(

F,:%12*:#2:*%#(RM:e:T((E3:%*,2(R+?=H]=<(&&(^(2FH?@D?D(!T(

84(.-`cU(((84(`...Va(b#(ScV.,a(eFH<F](8FKCDBBD(<=:(S`c(

!:&&:,cS(((8:&&:S(

N( N( ( ( N( (

%5)(#3()(1*+:10(!%/(250(1%3( /JDDB(=A(CDFHB(@<(BCD(1*+:10Q(L:(>:(C:( G%&2':%.(R)CEB:( &&&(f()CEB:(&iT(

))(c`( _:&&:Sg( ( ( N( ( ( (

,0(18,()(1*+:10( &lI(BCD(I=EBC(BCFB(IFOD(1*+:10(K=<BD<B(( 9,(+,(2,(6(7)%:"*+(R!I:(&&&T(

MDI>C@?( _:&&:Ug( N( ( ( ( ( (

",(,%(2,(%(")$#(%(1*+:10(!%/(250(1%3(",(%(>,2(;0(%/*(),#()0!*(

&<(BCD(I@GCB;(<FID(=A(I;(MFhD?B;(=A(BCD(1*+:10(=A(2=HE?Q(/BH=<G(_ELLQ(PDL=[DO(=A(MFFB(

5FI:((&&( _FBBLD(=A(mFOD?C( _:&:Sg( ( ( ( N( ( (

1(&#'!,(1).2(%*.2(%&.'(%$-()(1*+:10( !(IF<(F>>H=FKC@<G(F?(BC=?D(JC=(FHD(A=H(C@I(@<(BCD(1*+:10(

B1)*;:10:E*(R!IF?@?T(

"C@LFODL>C@FQ(3<@[DH?@B;(ME?DEI(<=:(`.:d,(

8:&&:`g( ( ( ( ( N( (

Page 706: 2 4 5( 1 - University of Birminghametheses.bham.ac.uk/3657/2/Pagliari12PhD2.pdf · 2+% $*0^ "+2,&)! % % % % % % % % %! %!.*-0! #&-0!! "+2,&%! "+2,&%! '+!!"#$%&&%!! "_"! % ...

!""#$%&'()*+(

( ,-cd(

1),2(#3(1*+:10(!%/(250(1%3( 8=I>F<@=<?(=A(CDFHB(=A(BCD(1*+:10D(L:(>:(C:( M,&#'2$-(R!I:(&&&T(((

))(,d.( _:&&:cd((

( ( N( ( ( (

1,(%(1),2(%12*(%(1*+:10( %@G<@BFH;(=A(BCD(K=I>F<@=<?(=A(BCD(]@<G(PDL=<G@<G(B=(BCD(1*+:10(

=(R!I:(&&T( _DHL@<(,.-S( !:&&:`U( N( ( ( ( ( (

*)(*8#(*+:,5(%(!"(*+*:,(%(1*+:10( +<D(JC=(O=D?(<=B(O@?=PD;(BCD(@<?BHEKB@=<?(=A(BCD(!"(=H(BCD(EBBDHF<KD(=A(BCD(1*+:10(

M%)2:"*+(R/D?:(&&T(

%EHCFI($,dSV( !:&&:V-( N( ( ( ( ( (

((

(


Recommended