+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

Date post: 17-Jul-2021
Category:
Upload: others
View: 11 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
165
Title 「も」の多様性に関する統語論的研究 Author(s) 榎原, 実香 Citation Issue Date Text Version ETD URL https://doi.org/10.18910/72214 DOI 10.18910/72214 rights Note Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA https://ir.library.osaka-u.ac.jp/ Osaka University
Transcript
Page 1: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

Title 「も」の多様性に関する統語論的研究

Author(s) 榎原, 実香

Citation

Issue Date

Text Version ETD

URL https://doi.org/10.18910/72214

DOI 10.18910/72214

rights

Note

Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKAOsaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA

https://ir.library.osaka-u.ac.jp/

Osaka University

Page 2: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

2018

Page 3: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

i

��

Page 4: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

1 ................................ ................................ ....... 1 1.1. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2

1.1.1. ......................................................................................................... 2 1.1.2. .................................................................................................. 4 1.1.3. .................................................................................................. 6

1.2. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 1.2.1. ............................................................................................ 12 1.2.2. ............................................................................................ 14 1.2.3. ......................................................................................... 20 1.2.4. .............................................................................. 26 1.2.5. ..................................................................................... 26 1.2.6. ..................................................................................... 27 1.2.7. ....................................................................................................... 28

2 ................................ ............................... 30 2.1. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 30 2.2. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 31 2.3. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 34 2.4. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 36

2.4.1. ....................................................................................................... 36 2.4.2. ................................................................................................... 40

2.5. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 47 2.5.1. .......................................................................... 47 2.5.2. Kuroda (1965) .......................................................................................... 49 2.5.3. 2006 ........................................................................................... 50 2.5.4. ..................................................................................... 53 2.5.5. .......................................................................... 55

2.6. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 56

3 ................................ ....... 57

Page 5: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

3.1. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 57 3.2. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 61

3.2.1. .............................................. 61 3.2.2. .......................................... 64

3.3. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 73 3.3.1. ................................................................... 75 3.3.2. ................................................................... 75 3.3.3. ................................................................... 76 3.3.4. ....................................................................... 79

3.4. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 80

4 ................................ ................... 82 4.1. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 82 4.2. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 87 4.3. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 89 4.4. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 91

4.4.1. .......................................................................... 91 4.4.2. ....................................................................... 97

4.5. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 98 4.5.1. ....................................................................................... 100 4.5.2. C ................................................... 101 4.5.3. A B ........................................ 103

4.6. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 105

5 ................................ ..................... 107 5.1. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 107 5.2. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 110

5.2.1. + ................................................................... 110 5.2.2. + ............................................................... 114

5.3. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 117 5.3.1. A .......................................................... 117

Page 6: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

5.3.2. B .......................................................... 120 5.3.3. C .......................................................... 122

5.4. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 126

6 ................................ .................. 128 6.1. + .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 128 6.2. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 130 6.3. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 133 6.4. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 134 6.5. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 135 6.6. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 136

7 ................................ ... 138 7.1. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 138 7.2. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 140

8 ................................ ..................... 142 8.1. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 145 8.2. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 150

151

Page 7: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

1

1

1936 2006

1986 2007

(1)

(2)

(3) 3

(4)

(5)

2

3

4

Agreement

5

Page 8: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

2

6 Negative Concord Item

4 7

5

1.1.

1.1.1.

1 1897

1908

1936: 472 ≠

1 1977, 1940

1981, 1991

1) a. 3 b. 3 c. *3

Page 9: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

3

(6) a.

b. * 2

c.

d. *

1908 ≠

(7) ⅳ ≠

(8)

(9)

(7) a.

b.

(8) a. *

b.

(9) a. # 3 4

b.

2 *

3 #

4

Page 10: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

4

1936

(10) a. ↑ CHJ

951

b. *

1.1.2.

1948

1948

(11)

1948: 178

1974, 1986

α

Page 11: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

5

(12) ( )

( )

( )

1984

≠ 1984: 80

(13)

×

1981, 1991

1981

(14)

(14)

∩ 1981: 66

1991 X P ⅳ X

P

Page 12: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

6

(15) 1984

(15)

1.1.3.

2016

(16) ( )

( )

( ) 2016: 10

2016

Page 13: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

7

5

(17) { *Ø}

(18) { *Ø}

(19) { ??Ø}

(20) { *Ø}

(21) a. { *Ø} ( ) 2009: 27

b.

(22) a. { *Ø} ‥ ( ) 2009: 27

b. ‥

(23) a. { *Ø} { *Ø}

b.

(24) a. { *Ø}

b.

1.2.

( ) 2009

5 ―

2) 2014: 621 3) 2014: 621

Page 14: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

8

( ) 2009: 19

(25)

( ) 2009: 87

(26) 86

(27) 5

(28)

( ) 2009: 137

(29) 1

(30)

(31) 3 2

( ) 2009: 27

(32) ( ) 2009: 27

( ) 2009:

28

(33) 3

Page 15: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

9

( ) 2009: 28

(34)

φ 1995

= ←

∩ =

ⅳ =

= ⅳ

( ) 2009

(35) ∩ 300 φ 1995: 236

/

φ 1995: 229

1 φ 1995

Page 16: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

10

(36) 10 φ 1995: 243

2009: 37-43 4

(37) (38)

(37) ( )

2009: 37

( )

2009: 38

( ) ⅰ

ⅰ 2009: 39

( )

2009: 41-42

(38)

2009: 121-122

2009

(37 ) ⅰ (37 )

Page 17: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

11

(37 ) (37 )

6

(39) 1 2009: 122

2009: 129

(40) 2 2009: 122

ⅰ 2009: 135

(41) 3

2009: 130

(42) (42) ∃ H ⅵ x F

H [y1] [y2] x

(43) (44)

6 2009 3 1

1

Page 18: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

12

(42) H = {y1, x, y2, ……}

(43) a. =(1)

b. = {↑ , , , ……}

(44) a. =(2)

b. = { , , …… }

(45) (46) 3

(47)

(45) a. =(3)

b. = { , * }

(46) a. 3 =(4)

b. = {3 , *3 }

(47) a. =(5)

b. = { , ??↑ }

( ) 2009

1.2.1.

( ) 2009: 19

2010, 2014

Page 19: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

13

(48) ⅵ a.

b. 1991: 75

= { , , , ……}

(49) ⅵ a.

b.

= { , , , ……}

‥ ⅵ (50)

(51) (52)

(50) a. … 2016: 15

b. … = { , , , ……}

(51) a. 2016: 15

b. = { , , , ……}

(52) a. 2016: 15

b. = { , , , ……}

2007: 13

(53)-(55) ⅳ

(53) a. … 2016: 15

b. … = { , , …… }

(54) a. 2016: 15

b. = { , , …… }

Page 20: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

14

(55) a. 2016: 15

b. = { , , , …… }

1.2.2.

φ 1995

2009

( ) 2009: 87

(56) ∩

(57) (58)

(56) a. ∩ 2016: 16

b. ∩ = { , , …… }

(57) a. 2016: 16

b. = { , , …… }

(58) a. 2016: 16

b. = { , , …… }

Page 21: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

15

( )

2009: 103

‥ 1992: 153

(59) a.

b. = {??, }

(60) a.

b. = {??, }

1991

(61) 1

Intensity

(61)

(61) 1

Page 22: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

16

http://www.ableart.org/org/handbook/2-2.html

1991: 70 (62

a)

(62) a. 1991: 70

b.

c.

(63)

ⅳ (63) su-

do- ⅳ

(63) a. http://www00

2.upp.so-net.ne.jp/hidemi-k/thought/t061.html

b.

su-

1991

+ = +

ⅳ 2010

Page 23: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

17

(64) ⊆

(65) ??

(66) ??

(67) (68)

(67) a.

b. = {??, ?}

(68) a.

b. = {??, ?}

2010 +

(2010) even

∩ ⅳ

5 5

5 1 4

(69) a. 5

b. = {# , ↑ , …… 5 }

c. = {1 , 2 , …… 5 }

(70) a.

b. = {# , # , …… }

c. = { , 5 , , ……}

Page 24: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

18

( ) 2009 1993

2009 1993

(71)

(71) 1993: 156

ⅳ (72b)

(73)

(74)

(72) a.

b. = { , , , …… }

(73) a.

b. = { , , , …… }

(74) a.

b. = { , , , …… }

1993 ( ) 2000

Page 25: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

19

(75) ( ) 2000: 231

(76) ( ) 2000: 231

ⅳ ⅳ

+ (77a)

(77c) +

(77) a. ↑ 3

b. ↑ 3

c. * ↑ 3

d. ↑ 3 = { , }

(78a) (79a) (80a)

(78) a. *

b.

c. 3

(79) a. *

b.

c. 100

Page 26: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

20

(80) a. *

b.

φ ∃

1.2.3. 7

( ) 2009: 26

ⅳ 2007 1984, 2009

2007: 34

1991 2009

( ) 2009 1991 8

1

7 2017c, 2018c 8 1991 1991

α 1991: 81

Page 27: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

21

1 1991

2008

2008

2008

2008

(81) a.

b. = { , ??}

(82) a.

b. = { , ??}

Page 28: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

22

(83) a. α α

b. = { α, ??}

1.2.3.1.

2008

(84a)

(85)

(84) a. 2008: 39 9

b. = { , , , , ……}

(85) { } 2008: 40 10

1.2.3.2.

2008 (b)

(86) a. 2008: 39

b. = { , , ……}

(87) a. 3 2008: 45

9 ( ) 2009

2008

10 A A B A B2008 2009 A A B

A A B

Page 29: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

23

b. = { 3 , ,

……}

(88) a. 2008: 47 11

b. = { ,

, …… }

1.2.3.3.

2008 (89)

(90)

(89) a. 2008: 49

b. = { , , ……}

(90) a. # 2008: 49

b. = { , ??}

2008

1.2.3.4. 2008

2008

11 (4) ⅵ

ⅳ 4) ‥

2008: 47ⅳ

Page 30: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

24

2008 (91a)

(92a)

(91a) (92a)

(91) a. 12

b. = { , ↑ , ……}

(92) a.

b. = { , , ……}

(91a) (92a) ⅵ

2008 α

(93) (94)

2008

2001 (93)

(94) 2007 13

(93) a.

b.

(94) a.

b. ??

12 ⅵ

13 2007

2008

Page 31: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

25

c. = { , ??}

2008 ∩

2008 1991

2008 (95) (96) (97)

(95) (97) (b) (c)

(96)

(95) a.

b. #

c.

(96) a. 3

b. 3

c. ?8 3

(97) a.

b. #

c.

2

Page 32: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

26

2 2008

1.2.4.

( ) 2009: 28

(98) 3

25

(98) a. 3 ( ) 2009: 28

b. = {??, 3 }

(99) a. 25 ∩ ( ) 2009: 28

b. = {…… 27 , 26 , 25 }

1.2.5.

φ 1995: 236

[ ] [

] (100)

(101)

2008

Page 33: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

27

ⅳ ⅳ

(100) a.

b. 2016: 22

c. = { , ,

, ……}

(101) a.

b. 2016: 22

c. = { , ,

, ……}

(100) (101)

(102) (103)

(102) ?

(103) ?

1.2.6.

ⅳ (105) ∩

100

Page 34: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

28

(104) a. 100

b. = {??, 100 }

(105) #

(106) (107)

(106) 50 φ 1995: 243

(107) 100 #

1.2.7.

(108) a.

b.

c.

3 1991

Page 35: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

29

3

+

∩ ‥

Page 36: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

30

2

1

2.1.

2009: 25-32

4 4

(109) ( ) α +

α

( ) ⅳ

( )

( )

(109 ) (109

) (109 ) (109 )

Label

(110b) 3

(110a)

(110d)

(109 ) α (109 )

Page 37: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

31

(110c) (109 )

2009

(109 )

(110e)

(110) ( ) α

a. #

b. #3

( ) ⅳ

c. *

( )

d. #[ ]

( )

e.

(110 ) α (110 )

(110 ) ⅳ ⅳ

(110 )

2.2.

Page 38: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

32

NP VP

(111)

(112)

(111) a. +

b. ? [ ] ? +

c. [ ] +

(112) a. +

b. [ ] +

c. * [ ] * +

2006 [Case] D

DP

(113) a. *[DP { } ]

b. [PP { } ]

(114) a.

b. *[DP[DP ] ]

Bare Phrase Structure X0

Xmax

XP=Xmax X=X0

XP Xmax Label

(115) a. Maximal Projection

b. Minimal Projection

Page 39: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

33

c. Intermediate Projection

2016: 541

2006

N D

Watanabe (2008)

NP #P NP

CaseP

∃ Mass Partitives Abbott 1996 #P

#P QP CaseP

DP ⅳ Watanabe

DP 3 r 3 QP D

3 r 3

CaseP Q

3

r 3 #P Case

3 3 NP # 6

YP/Ymax

3 XP/Xmax Y/Y0

3 ZP/Zmax : 3 X/X0

3 Watanabe (2008) DP

2

Page 40: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

34

(2008) Takahashi (2002) D

(116) [DP [QP [CaseP [#P NP #] Case] Q] D] Watanabe 2008: 517

(117) *[DP[CaseP[NP ] Case] D]

(118) [DP[CaseP[NP ] Case] D]

2.3.

1974, 1993

∃ 1974, 1993

A D 4

1974, 1993 A B ⅰ

C D ∩

A D ≠

A B B C C D14

Luigi Rizzi C D

14 A D

D

C . / ……

B . / ……

A . / ……

4 1974, 1993

Page 41: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

35

CP

2012 2014 2015

5

(119) a. A ≒vP b. B ≒FinP c. C ≒ForceP 2015: 8

3 3

ForceP 3

3 TopP Force

3 3

FocP Top 3

3 ModP Foc

3 3

TopP Mod 3

3 FinP Top

3 3

TP Fin 3

3 NegP T

3 3

vP Neg 3

3 VP v

3 3

V

B

C

D

A

5

Page 42: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

36

2.4.

Agree

( ) 2016: 531 Value

Unvalued Feature Chomsky

(2000, 2001) ⅳ uF ⅳ iF

ⅳ uF c- ⅳ iF

(120) Wh C what [Q]

C ⅳ [Q] what ⅳ [wh]

(120) [CP C [TP John bought what]]. 2001: 217

[Q] [Q][wh]

Probe Goal

Wh

Kishimoto (2001) LF Hiraiwa (2005b) Transfer

Indeterminate-Agreement Hiraiwa

(2005b) c-

(121) The head of the chain of the indeterminate must be in cd(Q) at Transfer. Hiraiwa 2005b: 100

(122) a. ↑ i[PROi ]-

b. *? i[PROi MIT ]- Hiraiwa 2005b: 105

2.4.1.

Oku (1998)

pro LF

Page 43: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

37

(123) a.

b. Ø OK OK Otani and Whitman

1991: 346-347

Saito (2007) LF

PF

LF

(124) a. *[ ]i [↑ ti ] [ ]j Ø

b. *[ ]i [↑ ti ] [ ]j Ø

Saito 2007: 210

Saito (2007) Case

Absence of Overt Agreement

LF

LF

(125) a.

b. ↑ Ø Saito 2007: 216

(126) a. John brought [his friend].

b. *But Mary didn’t bring Ø. Saito 2007: 215

Page 44: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

38

Sugisaki (2011) Saito (2007) [Q]

(127) a. [DP ]

b. ↑ Ø

(128) a. A:

B: Sugisaki 2011: 69

b. A: Ø

B:

Ikawa (2013) LF

Phonetically Null

(129) a.

b. * Ø

(130) A:

B: { Ø Ø}

(131) A:

Page 45: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

39

B: { #Ø #Ø }

(132) A:

B: { Ø Ø Ø}

(133) A:

B: { Ø #Ø #Ø}

LF

(134) a.

b. Ø

c. * Ø

(135) A:

B1:

B2: Ø

Sato and Ginsburg (2007) Sakamoto and Saito (2018)

LF Sakamoto and Saito (2018) (136)

ⅵ pro

Page 46: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

40

(137) PF (137B2) LF

(136) i

a. [DP ]i-

b. [DP pro]i

c. *[DP ]i- Sakamoto and Saito 2018: 351

(137) A: [DP ]-

B1: [DP ]-

B2: *[DP ]- Sakamoto and Saito 2018: 354

2.4.2.

2006, 2009

Topic Particle Stranding 2012 Nasu 2012

2018 Argument Ellipsis

2006,

2009

Sloppy Identity ⅳ

pro

(138) A:

B: {Ø # } 2009: 104

(139) A:

B: {Ø # } 2006: 4

(140) A: − i ti

B: Ø − = OK − OK −

Page 47: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

41

2018 2006, 2009 2012

(141) A1:

B1: Ø

A2:

B2: Ø

(142bB)

(142) a. A:

B: Ø

b. A:

B: Ø

2018 ForceP

1994

Page 48: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

42

(143) A1:

B1: * Ø

A2:

B2: * Ø

(144) A:

B: [Ø … ] 2018: 90

(145) A:

B: [Ø … ] 2018: 90 15

(146) a. { }

b. { } 1994: 197

(147) a. # i { } ti

b. * i { } ti 1994: 125

2012 Nasu (2012) Topic Particle

Stranding

(148) A:

B: Ø × 2012: 8

15 2009

PFSato 2012 Sato and Maeda in press

(145)

Page 49: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

43

(149) A: ↑

B: { Ø *Ø} 2012: 2

2012

(150) ( )

( ) ⅳ

( ) > >

(150 )-(150 )

( )

(151) A:

B: Ø …… Nasu 2012: 223

(152) A:

B: Ø ……

(153) A:

B: *Ø *

Page 50: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

44

Hoji 1985 Saito 1985

( )

(154) A:

B: { Ø } 2012: 3

(155) A:

B: { Ø }

someone

(156) #

(157) # ↑

( ) > >

(158) A:

B1: *{ Ø } Ø

B2: Ø { Ø }

(159) A:

B1: *{ Ø } Ø

B2: Ø { Ø }

Page 51: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

45

(160) A:

B1: Ø Ø

B2: * Ø Ø

(161) A:

B1: Ø Ø

B2: * Ø Ø

(162) A:

B1: Ø Ø

B2: #Ø Ø

(163) A:

B1: Ø Ø

B2: #Ø Ø

4

Sentence-initial Topic

Root Phenomenon

Argument Ellipsis saP Speech Act Phrase

( )

( )

( ) > >

Page 52: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

46

Nasu 2012 saP

saP saP

CP saP

(164)

LF ⅳ

(164) saP >> ForceP > TopP > IntP > TopP > FocP > TopP > FinP16

saP FocP

(165) saP > > ForceP > TopP > TopP > FocP > TopP

LF

LF [Q]

(167)

(166) A:

B: {Ø Ø}

(167) A:

B: {#Ø Ø}

(168) PF: [Ø ]

16 1994 ’

CP (164)

Page 53: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

47

LF: [[ { [null] [null]} ] ]

2.5.

∃ ∃

2009

17

(169) ⅵ

2009: 85

(170)

α ⅵ

2009: 85

2.5.1.

Quantifier wh

Logical Operator ( ) 1992: 420

17 1995

θ

1986 19951995 2009

Page 54: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

48

=

2014: 15

(171a) someone someone > everyone

ⅳ everyone someone someone

everyone > someone ⅳ everyone

someone someone

May (1977) LF: Logical Form

(171b) (171c)

everyone everyone

someone everyone someone someone

(171) a. Someone loves everyone.

b. [someone[loves everyone]]

c. [everyonei[someone[loves ti]]]

(SS) someone > everyone S

3 3 someone 3

loves everyone

(LF) everyone > someone S

3 (everyone)

3 someone

3 loves everyone

6 May (1977) everyone

Page 55: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

49

2006: 126 ⅳ LF

2006

Kuroda (1965)

2.5.2. Kuroda (1965)

Kuroda (1965)

Kuroda (1965) 2009

mo (mo-Attachment) mo (mo-Deletion)

Kuroda (1965)

≠ ∃

(172) [X-NP-Y]-mo

mo [X-NP+mo-Y]-mo

mo [X-NP+mo-Y]-mo

Kuroda 1965: 80 2006: 124

Kuroda (1965)

(173) ↑ ↑

Page 56: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

50

2.5.3. 2006

2006, 2008 Scope

Propagation of Focus Kuroda (1965)

2006, 2008

LF c-

vP

(174) ↑ …

a.

b.

c. 2006: 123

(175)

(176b) (176c)

Kuroda (1965)

LF XP

3 2 X+Q 6

K 3

K tQ

6 1

2006: 127 7 2006

Page 57: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

51

(175) a. ↑ #

b. Hanako’s mother came. Taro’s mother also came.

(176) a.

b.

c.

2006 (174b)

(177) (174b)18

(177) ↑ …

a. * ↑

b. ↑

c. * ↑

(178) (179) (a)

(174b)

(178) (179) (b)

vP

FocP19 c-

18 2008

2006 19 2013 CP Luigi Rizzi vP

vP vP2013

5) [AspP[TopP*[FocP[TopP*[VoiceP ] ] ] ] ] 2013: 166

Page 58: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

52

(178) a. ∀

b. ∀ [FocP i j [VoiceP ti [VP tj ] ]]

(179) a.

b. [FocP i j k [VoiceP ti [CP[VoiceP tj [VP

tk ]] ] ] ]

2006

(180)

(180)

(180) [ [ ] ]

1990 6981

(181)

(181)

[ [ ]]

KG094

Page 59: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

53

LF

LF

2.5.4.

É. Kiss (1998)

(Identificational Focus) Information Focus É. Kiss (1998: 248)

(182) ( ) The identificational focus expresses exhaustive identification; information focus merely

marks the nonpresupposed nature of the information it carries.

( ) Certain types of constituents, universal quantifiers, also-phrases, and even-phrases, for

example, cannot function as identificational foci; but the type of constituents that can function

as information focus is not restricted.

( ) The identificational focus does, information focus does not, take scope.

( ) The identificational focus is moved to the specifier of a functional projection; information

focus, however, does not involve any movement.

( ) The identificational focus is always coextensive with an XP available for operator

movement, but information focus can be either smaller or larger.

( ) The identificational focus can be iterated, but information focus can project.

(182 ) ⅳ ‥

Vallduví (1995) 1998

(183) A:

B:

Page 60: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

54

É. Kiss (1998: 245)

Exhaustive Subset ⅳ

(184) The function of identificational focus: An identificational focus represents a subset of the set of

contextually or situationally given elements for which the predicate phrase can potentially

hold; it is identified as the exhaustive subset of this set for which the predicate phrase actually

holds.

(182 ) ⅳ

also

also

(185) *Mari egy kalapot is nézett ki magának.

Mary a hat.ACC also picked out herself.DAT

'It was also a hat that Mary picked for herself.' É. Kiss 1998: 252

(186)

(182 ) (182 )

(182 )

(182 )

(187) ↑

(188) ↑

Page 61: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

55

(182 )-(182 ) (182 )-(182

)

2.5.5.

Shudo (2002)

(189a) ↑ (x)

∃(F) (190) ∃ F x

(189b)

∃(F) ↑ (x)

(191) ⅵ R(H(x), C) F ⅵ F(x)

cH(x) ∃ H Shudo (2002)

(189) a. ↑

b. ↑

(190) MO (x, F)

x is a constituent marked by mo;

F is a property

Proposition: F(x)

Presupposition: y [y x & F(y)] Shudo 2002: 4-5

(191) MO (x, F)

Host proposition: F(x)

Mo-presupposition: y H [y x & H(y) & F(x) cH(x) & R(H(x), C)] Shudo 2002: 57

Page 62: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

56

2.6.

Uriagereka (1999)

Multiple Spell-Out 8

ⅳ PF: Phonetic Form

LF: Logical form

Phase 20 Merge Agree

Articulatory-Perceptual System

Conceptual-Intentional System Spell-Out 21

LF

Narrow Syntax

[wh] ⅳ

Narrow Syntax

20 Chomsky (2000) CP v(*)P PhaseDP Chomsky (2000)

PIC: Phase Impenetrability Condition

2001: 253-254

6) a. [ ] b. [ ] 1995: 179 21 Transfer Multiple Transfer Model

CHL (C-I System)

︎ ︎ ︎ (Lexicon) (Numeration) (Syntactic Computation)

︎ ︎ ︎ (A-P System)

8

Page 63: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

57

3

2.2

X0 Xmax 2.3

vP FinP ForceP

3.1.

1948 1991

α

1.1.2 2.1 α

(192)

(193)

2008: 40

α

1995: 190 1974

(194) * +

Page 64: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

58

(195) *

(196) *↑

(197) ??

2006 Host

Clitic ∃ 22

(198) a. Xmax

b. X0

… X0 + Q0 ...

(199) A: ↑

B: Ø

(200) A:

B: {Ø #Ø}

22 2006 PF

PF Morphological Component 2006: 5

Xmax 3 Xmax Q0/max

6 … X0 ...

2006: 23

9 2006

Page 65: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

59

(201) a. [DP ] DP

b. * [DP ]

(202) a. [PP ] PP

b. * [PP ]

(203) a. ↑ [VP ] VP

b. *↑ [TP ]

(204) a. [AP ] AP

b. * [AP ]

(205) a. [CP↑ ] CP

b. [CP↑ ]

2015 vP

2015 2011 23

23

1989 20111989

7) a. (i)

(ii) (iii)

non-finite tense

(iv) 1974 C

(v)

b. ( )

Page 66: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

60

2011

(206) a. *

b. *

(207) a. *

b. * 2016: 34

IP V

VP

VP

(208) a.

b.

(209) a.

b.

(210) a.

b. 2016: 31

2012 vP A

1989 1974

A 1989

B ⅳ B

(211) * 1989: 166

(212) 3 1989: 166

( ) ( )( ) ⅳ ( ) 2011: 16-17

Page 67: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

61

(213) [ ] 1989: 167

A A

(214) a. [ ] A

b. *[ ] B

c. *[ − ] C

A

ⅳ A 1974

B 1989

(215) [ ] ⅱ https://qa.mamari.jp/question/3093

349

(216) [

] http://www.sakai015-office.jp/article/14255961.html

A vP

3.2.

3.2.1.

Wh- Indeterminate

Pronominals Kuroda 1965 Tsai 1994

Page 68: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

62

2006 Hiraiwa (2005ab)

(217) A:

B: #Ø

(218) A:

B: Ø

D

Head Movement Takahashi (2002)

c-

(219) (220e)

(219) a. *[ -ti ][ i]

b. *[ i][ -ti ] Takahashi 2002: 584

(220) a.

b. [TP[DP ][vP[DP[ ]D+ ] ] ]

c.

d. [TP[DP ][vP[DP[DP ]D+ ] ] ]

e. *

f. [TP[DP[DP ] ][vP ] ]

24Takahashi (2002)

D Scope Shift

Quantificational D 24

8) a. [ ] b.*[ ]

Page 69: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

63

D

(221) VP

(222) ∧ PP

(223) ←

http://brasileiro.jugem.jp/?eid=21 AP

Takahashi (2002)

(224) a. *

b.

(225) a. *

b.

(226) a. * ↑

b. ↑ 2006: 244

1989

A

(227) − −

http://u-note.me/note/47505836

(228) β

http://www3.ssj.gr.jp/himeji/sosa-es/

Page 70: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

64

sfs6_diary/sfs6_diary/200810.html

A

4

3.2.2. 25

(229a) (230a)

(229b)

(230b)

(229) a. 100

b. *

(230) a. ↑ 3

b. A:

B: * I-JAS JJE41-I 00540

3.2.2.1.

3 5

2013 10 Q NC [[[NQ] ][NP]] N QC [[NP ]NQ]

NQC [[NP][NQ]] Q N C

25 2017a

Page 71: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

65

Watanabe (2008) DP Q NC N QC NQC

N Q

DP

NQ: Numeral Quantifier UQ: Universal Quantifier

Ochi (2012) Fitzpatrick (2006) (231)

30 6

(231) a. 30

b. * 30

Ochi (2012) Classifier ∩

3 3 3

2 2 NP 2 NP 2 #P CaseP 2 #P #P 5 2 DP2 2 2 NQ NP 2 5 2 2 t#P Case NP2 tNP # tNP

3 3 3 3 : : 3 NP 3 NQ 6 6NQ NQ NP NP

11

10

Page 72: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

66

CLP26

P ∩ DP

(232) [XP[NPN] [ P[CLP tNP CL] UQ]X]

(233) [DP[NP ][ P[CLP 30 tNP CL] UQ] ]

(234) [DP[NP ] ] [ P[CLP 30 tNP CL] UQ]

UQ

UQ 30

Q NC

(235) [30 ]

(236) [30 ]

N QC

(237) [ 30 ]

(238) [ 30 ]

NQC

(239) [ 30 ]

(240) [ 30 ]

26 Nakanishi (2008) Floating Numeral Quantifier

Watanabe (2008)

Ochi (2012) Nakanishi (2008)

Page 73: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

67

UQ 12

Q NC N QC NQC UQ

UQ CLP

UQ NQ 30

(242) 30 = (242)

Q NC

(241) * [30 ]

(242) [[[30 ] ] ]

(243) DP

30

(242) 30 (244) 30

(245)

30

N QC

(243) [[[ ] ] 30 ]

(244) *[[[ ] ] 30 ]

3 3 3 3 : 2 : 2 : 2 5 2 6 CLP 2 NP 2 2 CLP NP tCLP UQ NP+ tCLP UQ CLP tCLP UQ 12 UQ

Page 74: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

68

(245) [[ ] 30 ]

NQC UQ NQ 30

NQC

(246) * [ 30 ]

(247) *[[[ ] ]30 ]

(248) [[ ]30 ]

UQ (252) NQ UQ NP

(254) NQ UQ NP

NCQ/QNC

(249) * [ ] [30 ]

(250) *[ ] [30 ]

(251) * [30 ]

(252) [30 ]

(253) * [30 ]

(254) [[30 ] ][ ]

(255) *[30 ][ ]

(256) *[30 ][ ]

NQ CLP UQ

Q NC [DP[[[NQ]UQ] ][NP]]

Watanabe (2008) QP

UQ DP

Q NC DP

N QC [DP[NP[DPNP ]][[NQ]UQ]]

Page 75: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

69

DP UQ

CLP NQC

NP CLP [DP[NP][[NQ]UQ]]

3.2.2.2.

Q NC N QC

NQC

30

Q NC

(257) * [30 ]

(258) [[30 ] ]

(259) #[30 ]

(260) *[30 ]

N QC

(261) *[[ ] 30 ]

(262) *[[ ] 30 ]

(263) [30 ]

(264) #[ 30 ]

(265) *[ 30 ]

3 3 3 2 5 NP 2 5 2 : NP 2 CLP UQ NP CLP UQ 2 DP2 2 2 DP2 5 2 2 6 NP2 CL t CL CLP UQ

13 UQ NQ

Page 76: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

70

NQC

(266) * [ 30 ]

(267) #[ 30 ]

(268) [30 ]

(269) ??[ 30 ]

(270) *[ 30 ]

NCQ/QNC

(271) * [ ] [30 ]

(272) #[ ] [30 ]

(273) * [30 ]

(274) [30 ]

(275) * [30 ]

(276) [30 ] [ ]

(277) #[30 ][ ]

(278) *[30 ][ ]

(279) a. 30

b. [TP[DP ][vP [CLP30 ] ] ]

(280) a. # 30

b. [TP[DP[DP ] ][vP 30 ] ]

c. # 30

d. [TP[DP ][vP[DP[DP ] ]30 ] ]

e. # 30

f. [TP[DP ][vP[DP[DP30 ] ] ] ]

Page 77: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

71

(281c) (282b)

(281c) (282b) 30

30 (282c)

(281) a.

b. *

c. 30

(282) a. 30

b. 30

c. 30

1989

1974 A

Watanabe (2008) QP DP

QP DP

DP ⅳ 30

5

CL

4

DP DP DP 3 3 3

2 4 NP CLP 4 3 CLP NP 5 3 NP CLP 3 NP2 3 3 3 tNP 1 3

tNP 1 CL tNP 1 CL CL

14

Page 78: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

72

3.2.2.3.

UQ

CL CLP UQ (284)

UQ ⅳ

(283) *

(284) a. [30 ]

b. [30 ]

c. [ 30 ]

d. [ 30 ]

NQ UQ (285)

UQ

NQ UQ

(285) a. * [30 ]

b. * [30 ]

c. * [30 ]

e. *[30 ]

3 DP 3

2 : 1 4 3 CLP NP tCLP UQ 3 3

tNP 2 CL

15 (284b)

Page 79: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

73

CL

3.3. 27

1.2.3

φ 1995 1995

(287c) (288c) (286c) (287e) (288e)

(286) a.

b. [CP[TP[vP[DP ] ] ] ]

c. #

d. [CP[TP[vP[DP ] ] ] ]

(287) a. 3

b. [CP[DP3 ][TP[vP ] ] ]

c. #3

27 2017c, 2018c

* DP 3 5 3 NP : D 3 CLP UQ

3 3 1 CL

16

Page 80: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

74

d. [CP[DP3 ][TP[vP[DP ] ] ] ]

e. #3

f. [CP[DP3 ][TP[vP[vP ] ] ] ]

(288) a.

b. [CP[DP ][TP[vP ] ] ]

c. #

d. [CP[DP ][TP[vP[DP ] ] ] ]

e. #

f. [CP[DP ][TP[vP[vP ] ] ] ]

1.2.3

1989 (289)

(290) B 2001

(291) (292)

C 28

(289) 3 1989: 179

(290) 12 1989: 179

(291) 2001: 71

(292) 2001: 71

1989 (289)

(290) 2001 (291) (292)

28 1995 D

4.5

Page 81: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

75

3.3.1.

(293) + + ⅳ A

(294) A +

A B C

A

(293) [ ] A h

ttp://www.vill.shimukappu.lg.jp/shimukappu/today/nmudtq0000009ckz.html

(294) [ ] Φ A

(295) [ ] C http://www2.k

obe-u.ac.jp/~ymiura/hp/RA_letter_1108.html

A vP

(296) [DP[NP[NP + ] ] ]

3.3.2.

(297) (298) A

(299)

(300) (301) (302) B

(303) C B

2008 2001

B ⅳ

Page 82: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

76

(297) #[ ] A

(298) #[ ] A

(299) [ ] B http://tanaka-yuki.com/spring/post-10903/

(300) [ ]

B http://nekogatasan.jugem.jp/?eid=61

(301) [ ] B https://news.w

alkerplus.com/article/119185/

(302) [ ]

B http://keisukenaga.com/?p=16844

(303) [3 ] C

https://ameblo.jp/20-8/entry-12255431738.html

B FinP

vP

(304)

(305) *[NP ]

3.3.3.

(306ab) 2001

(306) a. #[CP[TP[DP ][vP ] ] ]

b. #[CP[FinP[DP ][vP ] ] ]

c. [CP[ForceP[DP ][FinP[vP ] ] ] ]

A

Page 83: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

77

(307)

(308) *[NP ] 10

(309) [CP[DP[DP ] ][FinP[vP ] ] ]

(310) (313) A (311)

(314) B

(312)

(315) (316) C

C

(310) * [ ] A

(311) #[ ] B

(312) [ ] C https://retty.

me/area/PRE33/ARE239/SUB23901/100000613839/23623192/

(313) *[ α ] A

(314) #[ ] B

(315) [ ] ↘ C ht

tps://www.1101.com/store/nihoncha/report_02.html

(316) [ ] ↘

↘ C https://syoset

u.org/novel/70727/178.html

C

5

Page 84: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

78

FinP FinP

vP

FinP FocP

5 C

(317) (318)

ⅳ (317)

CP

(319) FinP

FinP ForceP

(317) a.

b. [CP[DP ]i [FinP[DP i][vP ]] ]

(318) a. ??3

b. [CP[DP3 ]i [FinP[DP i][vP ] ] ]

(319) a.

b. [CP[FinP[DP[DP ] ][vP ]] ]

c. [CP[DP ]i [FinP[DP proi][vP ]] ]

(320) a. 3

b. [CP[FinP[DP[DP3 ] ][vP ] ] ]

ForceP

TopP

FinP #[ ]

TP #

vP #

Page 85: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

79

c. *[CP[DP3 ]i [FinP[DP proi][vP ] ] ]

A B C

vP

vP FinP FinP

A

B C

3.3.4.

2.2 DP DP

(321c) (321d)

29

(321) a. [DP ] DP h

ttps://ameblo.jp/akane12777/entry-11744879852.html

b. [NP + ]

c. [NP ]

http://kakeru.town.kawara.fukuoka.jp/enjoy/384/

d. ??

29

Page 86: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

80

30

(322) #[DP ] DP

(323) #[DP ] DP

vP FinP

ForceP

3.4.

X0 Xmax

30 NP DP

3 Xmax + 3 + 3 + 1 X0 + + +

17

Page 87: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

81

A vP

B vP FinP

C FinP

ForceP

FinP

vP

18

Page 88: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

82

4

3

Shimoyama (2006) (324)

Wh

(324) [[[ ] ] ]

Shimoyama 2006: 146

4.1.

2006: 135

[+focus] Feature Sharing Agreement

LF

[+focus]

H’ 3 KP H+Q[+focus] 6

[+focus] 6 [+focus]

2006: 135 19 [+focus]

Page 89: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

83

2

[Q]

(325) a. A:

B: #Ø

b. A:

B: Ø

Shudo (2002) 2006

[+focus]

Vallduví (1992, 1995)

LF IS: Information Structure

LF S-Structure

(326) LINK a la festa to the party

FOCUS TOTHOM everybody IP

TOTHOM everybody

(326) a. [IP A la festa1 [IP=F hi1 vaig enviar TOTHOM t1 ]]

to the party loc 1s-past-send everybody

‘The party [F (I) sent EVERYBODY to ].’

b. IS: [IP A la festa1 [IP=F vaig enviar TOTHOM t1 ]]

c. LF: [IP tothom2 [IP a la festa1 [IP hi1 vaig enviar t2 t1 ]] Vallduví 1992: 127

Vallduví (1992, 1995) LF Information Composing

Page 90: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

84

Information Structure

Knowledge-Store FOCUS

LINK TAIL

Update 20

(327) IS Configuration: [IP link [IP [IP focus ] tail ]] Vallduví 1992: 126

ⅳ 1978 1998

FOCUS ∃

Vallduví (1992, 1995)

(328) A: ↑

B1: #

B2: ↑ 1978: 54

(329)

∩ 1998: 131

(330)

1978: 60

(331) [S |V] 1998: 131

(332) [ link[[ focus] tail]] 31

31 TAIL Vallduví (1992, 1995) FOCUS

TAIL

LF | DS—SS—IS (Information Composing) | PF

20 Vallduví (1992, 1995)

Page 91: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

85

2011

FocP

Otsu (1994) ⅵ

Discourse Topic

LINK

(333b)

ⅳ FocP

FinP LINK ⅳ

(333) a.

b. i ti

c.

(335) 32 1994 2015

FOCUS

Vallduví (1995)

LINK (336) ’

1994, 2015

LINK (327)

32

’ 1994

Page 92: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

86

(334) A:

B:

(335) a. [L i] [T ei ] 1994: 197

b. i ei 1994: 197

c. i ei 1994: 197

(336) a. [L ] [[F ] ]

b. [L ] [[F ] ] 1994: 197

(337) a. *[F i [L ] ti ]

b. *[F i [L ] ti ] 2015: 23

1974, 1993 1987

C B

(338) a. *[ ] C

b. [ ] B 1987: 41

Vallduví (1992, 1995)

LINK ⅳ CP

LINK

Narrow Syntax

FinP FOCUS FinP LINK

Page 93: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

87

4.2.

2006 ∩ [+FOCUS]

FOCUS

Information

FOCUS [+FOCUS] LINK [+LINK]33FOCUS

ⅳ ⅳ

ⅵ Shudo (2002)

33 [+FOCUS] [+LINK]

[+FOCUS] ⅳ [+LINK] ⅳ

XBP 3 YBP XB’ 3 XB FinP 3 Fin’ 3 Fin XAP 3 YAP XA’ 3 XA

LINK

FOCUS

21

Page 94: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

88

Hoji (1985) Tomioka (2007) Wh [+FOCUS]

Intervention Effects

[+FOCUS]

Tomioka (2007) [+FOCUS] [+FOCUS]

C

[+FOCUS] Relativity

(339) a. ?*

b.

(340) a. ?? Tomioka 2007: 98

b.

(341) a. ??? Tomioka 2007: 98

b.

(342) [Wh1 [~ [INTV [+FOCUS] t1 ]]] Tomioka 2007: 109

LF movement *

(343) [Wh1 [~ [intv [-FOCUS] t1 ]]] Tomioka 2007: 109

LF movement OK

[+FOCUS]

(344b) [+FOCUS]

Cmax 3 Xmax[+LINK] 3 : C0[+LINK] Ymax

3 Zmax[+FOCUS] 3 Y0[+FOCUS]

LINK

FOCUS

22

Page 95: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

89

C C

(344a) (344c) [+FOCUS]

C [+FOCUS]

(344) a. [CP[TP[DP ]F [ ] ] ]

b. [CP[[DP[DP[C ] ] ]F ] ]

c. [CP[TP[DP ]F [ ] ] ]

[wh] [Q]

[+FOCUS]

[+FOCUS] [+LINK]

4.3.

(345) (346)

LF

[Q]

(345) A:

B: { Ø Ø Ø}

(346) A: TOEIC [ ]F

B: { Ø Ø Ø}

2006 Tomioka (2007) [+FOCUS]

Page 96: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

90

2006 [+FOCUS]

[+FOCUS]

(347)

(348b)

(347) [CP[TP [vP ] ] ]

[+FOCUS]

(348) a.

b.

[+FOCUS] C

[+FOCUS] C

[+FOCUS] [+FOCUS]

(350B2)

(349) [CP i[TP [vP ti ] ]

[+FOCUS]

(350) A:

B1:

B2: ??

[+FOCUS]

FOCUS

Page 97: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

91

4.4.

4.4.1. 34

Nishigauchi (1990) LF Wh-

Nishigauchi (1990)

(351)

(351) [[ ] ]

Nishigauchi 1990: 164

Nishigauchi (1990) Φ Island Wh- D D-Linked 35

D Non-D-Linked

Φ Wh- LF

Φ

(352) a. [ ]

b. A: [ ]

B:

(353) a. [ ]

b. A: [ ]

B:

(354) a. [ ]

b. A: [ ]

34 2017b 35 D Wh-

Pesetsky (1987)

Page 98: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

92

B:

Unselective Binding Heim 1982 Tsai 1994

(355) [ ]

(356) [ ]

Takahashi (2002) (357)

(357) Takahashi 2002: 580

Shimoyama (2006)

Shimoyama (2006) (358)

Shimoyama (2006)

(358) [[[ ] ] ]

Shimoyama 2006: 146 =(324)

Page 99: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

93

(359)

Yes/No

Wh (B1) (B2)

3

(359) A:

B1:

B2: ↑

Ikawa (2013) (360)

(361)

(362) (363)

(360) A:

B: { Ø #Ø #Ø Ø}

(361) A:

B: {#Ø Ø}

(362) A:

B: * Ø

(363) a.

b. * Ø

Page 100: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

94

Probe Goal

Chomsky (2000, 2001) 36Hiraiwa

(2005b) (355) (356)

Hiraiwa (2001, 2005ab) Multiple Agree

3

(364) [CP[DP[NP[CP ] ]D+ ] ]

[Q]

c- D D+

D+ Kishimoto (2001) Complex Head

ⅳ [uQ] [iQ] Indeterminate

Agreement D ⅳ

[uwh] ⅳ [iwh]

Goal

[Q]

Wh Yes/No Δ

36 2017b [Q]

Spec-Head Agreement Chomsky (1995) Move-F

[Q] LFLF Chomsky (2000, 2001) Hiraiwa (2001, 2005ab) Multiple Agreement

Spec-Head Move-F

Spec-Head Agreement

Page 101: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

95

(365) [CP[DP[DP[NP[CP ] ]D] ] ]

[Q]

DP [Q]

D [Q] [Q] C

[Q] Wh

CP 3 [Q]

DP 3 3 NP 1 3 D [Q]

CP i 3 3 vP 3 ti VP 3 [Q]

z

23

Page 102: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

96

v v+

vP

(366)

(367) A: [CP[FinP[vP[VP ]v+ ] ] ]

B:

CP 3

[Q] DP 3 DP [Q] 3 3 NP D 3 CP i 3 3 vP 3 ti VP 3 [Q]

z

24

Page 103: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

97

(368) A: [CP[FinP[vP[vP ] ] ] ]

B:

[Q]

[Q]

4.4.2.

3

(369) A: 3

B: {3 3 Ø Ø }

(370) (371)

(372)

(372B2) (373A) (373B2) 30

(373A) Wh

3.2.2

CL

CLP

Page 104: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

98

(370) A:

B: { * Ø #Ø }

(371) A:

B: { * Ø #Ø }

(372) A:

B1: 5

B2: 5

(373) A:

B1:

B2: # 30

(374) [CP[TP [CLP + ] [vP ] ] ]

CL

4.5. 37

A B C

A

[Q]

37 2018a 2017c, 2018c

Page 105: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

99

(375) a.

b. A:

B1: { Ø Ø Ø}

B2: Ø

(376) a.

b. A:

B1: { Ø Ø Ø}

B2: Ø

B

[Q]

(377) a.

b. A:

B1: { Ø Ø Ø}

B2: Ø

(378) a.

b. A:

B1: { Ø Ø Ø}

B2: Ø

C

[Q]

[Q]

Page 106: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

100

(379) A:

B1: { Ø Ø Ø}

B2: Ø

(380) A:

B1: { Ø Ø Ø }

B2: Ø

A B C [Q]

4.5.1.

1987 1993 Watanabe (2002)

11

2012

(381) a.

b. # 2012: 34

2012 CP

ForceP

(382) CP

A

B

ⅳ ⅳ 2012: 31-32

Page 107: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

101

∃ CP

C 1995

1974, 1993 D

(383) #

(384) # 1995: 23 #

(383) (384) C

C

C

4.5.2. C

FinP

ModP

( ) 2003

(385) a.

b.

c.

d.

6

∃ ( ) 2003: 15

Force

Page 108: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

102

6 C

6 C

ForceP

(b)

ⅳ C

(386) a. #

b.

(387) a. #

b.

CP

C

[+FOCUS]

(388)

#

#

#

??

Page 109: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

103

C LINK

[+LINK] 4.2

LINK ∃ 1.2.3

2008

[+LINK]

ForceP 38

C Force [+LINK]

[-LINK]

2012 C

4.5.3. A B

A B

38 2018a C ForceP

ForcePForceP

[+LINK] Force

ForceP 3

3 [+LINK] Force [+LINK] 25 ForceP

Page 110: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

104

7 A

7 A

A

A

3.3 vP [+FOCUS]

8 B

B

B

T [+FOCUS]

B

#

#

#

#

Page 111: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

105

TP FinP

[+FOCUS]

[Q] [+FOCUS/+LINK]

4.6.

[Q] [+FOCUS] [+LINK]

[Q]

[Q]

[+FOCUS] [+LINK] FinP

[+FOCUS] ForceP [+LINK]

[Q] [+FOCUS/+LINK]

(389) ( ) [Q]

( ) [+FOCUS]

( ) [+LINK]

[Q] [+FOCUS/+LINK]

TP 3

3 [+FOCUS] T [+FOCUS] 26 TP

Page 112: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

106

Narrow Syntax

27

2.4 LF

[Q]

[+FOCUS] [+LINK]

LF

[+FOCUS]

Shudo (2002) ⅳ

[+FOCUS/+LINK]

[+FOCUS] [+LINK]

Syntactic Computation

[Q]

[+FOCUS] [+LINK]

27

Page 113: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

107

5 39

4

5.1.

1991

(390) a. ↑

b. = { , , ↑ , ……}

(391) a.

b. = { , , , ……}

(392) (393)

(392) a.

b. = { , , , ……}

(393) a.

b. = { , , , ……}

39 2018b

Page 114: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

108

2009

(394) Normal Focus

Backward Focus

Forward Focus

40

1995

Merge

(396a) (395b)

(396b)

(395) a. ↑

b. [TP[DP[DP ] ][vP ] ]

(396) a. ↑ #

b. [TP[DP ][vP[DP[DP ] ] ] ]

2016 2009 (396)

40 1986

(9a) (9b) 9) a. b. 1986: 150

2009: 71 [ …… NP AdvP ……Pred T] c- VP

(175) (176)

10) 11) a. *

b. Ⅲ

Page 115: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

109

c- c-

(a) (c)

(c)

2009

c-

(397) a. ?? ∀

b. [vP[PP ] [VP[DP[DP ] ] ] ]

c. ∀

d. [vP[PP[PP ] ][VP[DP ] ] ]

(398) a. ??

b. [CP[TP [vP [FinP[DP[DP ] ] ] ] ]]

c.

d. [CP[DP[DP ] ]i[TP [vP [FinP ti ] ] ]]

4.3

[+FOCUS] c- [+FOCUS]

(399) a. [DP[DP ] ]

[+FOCUS]

b. [DP ]

(400) a.[vP[DP ][ ]]

[+FOCUS]

Page 116: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

110

b. [vP ]

5.2.

5.2.1. +

(401b) (401a)

(401) a.

b.

2007 ( ) 2009

(402)

2007: 60

Hamblin (1973)

(403) a.

b.

Page 117: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

111

c.

d. = {A , B , C , D , ……}

e. = A + B + C + D + ……

Shimoyama (2006)

(404) a.

b.

(405) a.

b.

Kobuchi-Philip (2009)

(408) (407) (a)-(d)

(406) a. Kobuchi-Philip 2009: 182

b.

(407)

a.

b. ↑

c.

d.

(408) = { , ↑ , , }

Kobuchi-Philip (2009)

— (409)

Page 118: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

112

(409) Mo: λPλRλx[ …… (((AT(x)-AT( + P)) R) ∅)] Kobuchi-Philip 2009: 185

(410) a.

b. x

X

X

(411) a.

b. = { , , , ……}

(412) a.

b. = { , , ……}

(413c) −

(413d)

(414)

vP v vP

(415c)

(413) a.

b. [TP[DP ][vP[DP[DP ] ] ] ]

Page 119: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

113

c. # − 41

d. [TP[DP ][VP[DP − D+ ] ] ]

(414) a.

b. [TP[vP[vP [DP ][DP ] ] ] ]

c. # −

d. [TP[vP[DP ][DP − ] v+ ] ]

(415) a. ↑

b. [TP[DP[DP↑ ] ][vP ] ]

c. #

d. [TP[DP D+ ][vP ] ]

+

[+FOCUS]

[Q] [+FOCUS]

(c)

A AP

(416) AP

(417) A

(416) a.

[[[ [AP[AP ] ] ] ] ]

https://blog.goo.ne.jp/atatakasa11tk13/e/93b819

341a9a86627b73728043285992

b. = { , , ……}

41 Kishimoto (2001) m- Kishimoto (2001) X

Y Xc-

Page 120: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

114

(417) a. [AP + ]

https://blogs.yahoo.co.jp/four2945

29/67683057.html

b. = { , , , ……}

c-

[Q]

[+FOCUS]

(418) a. [DP − ]

[Q, +FOCUS]

b. [DP x−]

5.2.2. +

3 5 100g

Kobuchi-Philip (2010) 30

many

(419) 3

2007

Page 121: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

115

(420) 3

‥ 1 2

2007: 41

(421) a. 30

b. = {1 , 2 , 3 , …… 29 , 30 }

(422) a.

b. = {1 , 2 , 3 , …… }

(423) 5

∃ (424) 5

(425) 1 (423)

(423) a. 5

b. = {1 , 2 , …… 5 }

(424) a. 5

b. ~ = {60 , 30 , …… 5 }

(425) a. 1

b. ~ = {10 , 5 , …… 1 }

(426)

Page 122: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

116

3 3

3.2.2 CL

(426) a.

b. [TP[DP ][vP[DP[DP ] ] ] ]

c. # 3

d. [TP[DP i ] [vP[CLP 3 ti + ] ] ]

3.2.2 4.4.2 CL

(427) a. [CLP3 ]

[+FOCUS]

b. [CLP x ]

42

42 vP (12)

v

v+Head Movement Neg ⅳ

12) a. ↑ b. [TP[NegP[vP[vP ] ] ] ] c. ?? ↑

Page 123: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

117

5.3.

ⅳ A B C

(428) ⅲ

( ) 2009: 3

(430)

(431)

A B C

(429) a. ↑

b. = {↑ , , ……}

(430) a. ↑

b. = {↑ , ,

……}

(431) a.

b. = { , , ……}

5.3.1. A

A

(432)

(433) d. [TP[NegP[vP[VP ]v+ ] ] ]

Page 124: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

118

(432)

https://www.tripadvisor.jp/ShowUserR

eviews-g1066444-d4776956-r221568783-Tosa_Dining_Okyaku-Chuo_Tokyo_Tokyo_Prefect

ure_Kanto.html

(433)

https://okinawaupgiri.amebaownd.com/posts/2573

802

A

A

(434) (435)

A ⅳ

1989 (434)

A (435) A

2008

(434) 1989: 179

(435) ⅱ

40 http://kizyunokoro.web.fc2.com/essay985.htm

(436) = { , , , , , …… }

X X (437)

A

Page 125: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

119

(437) a.

b.

c. = { , , , ……}

A (440) (441) (442)

A

N ∃

NP A

(438) ??

(439) #

(440) #

(441) #

(442) #

(443) a. [NP[NP + ] ]

b. [NP[NP + ] ]

A

[+FOCUS]

(444) a. [NP[NP + ] ]

[+FOCUS]

b. [NP x]

Page 126: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

120

5.3.2. B

B

(445)

(446) = { , , 12 , ……}

(447) B

(448)

Δ

B

B

(447) https://tokoya.biz/index.php?QBlog-2017

0831-1

(448) #

http://www.dr-ueno.com/i

mg/news/news29_9.pdf

3.3.2 4.5 B TP DP

T A TP

(449)

(450) # 5 6

(451) [TP[DP[DP ] ] ]

Page 127: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

121

(452) B

ⅳ B

(452) a. 8 http://soen.tokyo/blog/akane/2016/08/

b. = { , 8 , , ……}

B

B C

CHJ

0 3

1900

B 190043 B C

B

(453)

CHJ 1909

(454) CHJ 1917

(455)

ⅴ CHJ

43 β

‥ 2C ‥

13)

CHJ 1306

Page 128: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

122

1925

(456) CHJ 1925

B

B

T

(457) a. [TP[DP ] ]

[+FOCUS]

b. [TP ]

5.3.3. C

C

2008

(458) (459)

(458d) (459d)

Shudo (2002)

(458) a.

b. = { , , , ……}

c.

d. ↑ #

Page 129: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

123

(459) a.

b. = { , ,

, ……}

c.

d. #

2008

C

(460)

https://nariyuki.org/chibalot

te20180204

(461) = { , ,

, ……}

(462)

(462) http://yurulu.net/

retire/hujii-souta-8/

(463) = { , ,

, ……}

Page 130: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

124

ForceP

c-

(464) a. 3

b. [TP[DP[DP ] ][vP3 ] ]

(465) a. ↑

b. [CP[DP[DP↑ ] ][FinP ] ]

(466a) (467a)

(466) a. ↑

b. ↑

(467) a. ↑ #

b. ⅲ

(468a) (468b) (469a)

(468) a. # ↑

b. #

c.

(469) a. #

b. ↑

C

Page 131: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

125

CP [+LINK]

(470) ↑

(471) [ForceP[DP[DP↑ ] ][TP[vP ] ] ]

C

(472) a. [CP[DP↑ ] [TP ] ]

[+LINK]

b. [CP↑ ]

vP [+FOCUS]

TP T [+FOCUS]

ForceP ForceP

ⅳ CP

‥ Shudo

(2002) 9

Page 132: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

126

9

5.4.

[Q] [Q]

(473) [NP[NP + ] ]

(474) [DP [NP ]D+ ]

(475) [NP ]i [CLP3 ti + ]

A

B

C

C

XAmax 3 YA 3 ZA 1

XA0

28

Page 133: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

127

c-

[+FOCUS/+LINK]

(476) [TP[DP[DP ] ] ]

(477) [TP[DP[DP ] ] ]

(478) [CP[DP[DP ] ] ]

[+FOCUS/+LINK]

Zmax wi

2 3 Xmax Ymax Z0 5

29

Page 134: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

128

6

5

C [+LINK]

NPI NCI 44

NCI C

6.1. +

Negative Concord Item

(479) a. {* }

b. {* }

c. { }

10

44 Negative Concord Item

AgreeConcord

- -

Page 135: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

129

1991

(480) a. {* }

b. { }

(481) a. {* }

b. ?? { }

+45

(482) a. {* }

b. {* }

c. {* }

d. {* }

1987 2005, 2006 2011

(483) × 2005: 22 2009: 73

45

Page 136: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

130

35-11

(484) × × 2005: 22 2009: 73

21-77

4.5 (485)

ForceP (486)

(485) a. [ ↑ ]

b. # [ ↑ ]

c. ↑

d. ↑

(486) [ForceP↑ { # } ]

NegP (487)

NegP C

∩ C

(487) a. [NegP { *Ø} ]

b. * [ ][NegP ]

6.2.

NPI: Negative Polarity Item

46 NCI: Negative Concord Item

any- Kato (1985)

46

Page 137: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

131

NPI 47 c-48

(488) a. [ ] Kato 1985: 150

b. # [ ] Kato 1985: 151

NCI

4

( ) NCI almost

(489) *John didn’t eat almost anything. NPI

(490) NCI

( ) NCI ∃ ⅳ

(491) A: What did you see?

B: *Anything. NPI

(492) A:

B: NCI

47 1994 PPI

∃ PPIPPIⅳ

14) 1994: 117 15) 48 2007 XP-

NPI NCIKobuchi-Philip (2009) ∃

16) a. *↑ b. ↑ 2007: 81 17) a. b. ↑

Page 138: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

132

( ) NCI Yes/No

(493) a. Have you seen anything? NPI

b. If John steals anything, he’ll be arrested. NPI

(494) a. * NCI

b. * NCI

( ) NCI

(495) I didn’t say that John admired anyone. NPI

(496) ?* [ ] NCI Watanabe 2004: 565

Watanabe (2004)49

LF

Watanabe (2004) [Q]

(497) A:

B1: {#Ø Ø}

B2: Ø

(498) A:

B1: {Ø Ø}

B2: Ø

Wanatabe (2004)

LF

(499) 0

49 Watanabe (2004)

Page 139: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

133

LF 2007 (500)

LF LF

[Q] LF

LF

(499) A:

B: [ ] Watanabe 2004: 584

(500) A:

B: ↑ 2007: 93

C

[+FOCUS/+LINK]

C ∩

6.3.

(501) *

(502) *

(503)

(504) a. [[DP ] ] {* } 50

50 ∃

Page 140: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

134

b. [[PP ] ] { }

c. [[PP ] ] {?? }

C

(505)

(506)

(507) #

(508) a. [[DP ] ]

b. [[PP ] ]

c. *[[PP10 ] ]

6.4.

ForceP FinP

(509) a. *[ForceP [FinP[NegP↑ ] ] ] 51

b. [ForceP↑ [FinP[NegP ] ] ]

(510) a. #[ForceP[TP[DP ] ] ]

b. [ForceP[DP ] ]

51 (18a) (18a) (18b)(18b)

(18a) (18b) (18b) 18) a. [ ]

b. [ ]

Page 141: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

135

C

ⅳ Neg

(511) a. *[ForceP [CP [NegP ] ] ]

b. [ForceP[CP[FinP [NegP ] ] ] ]

[+FOCUS]

(512) [NegP ]

[+FOCUS]

C NegP

[+FOCUS]

30

6.5.

(513b)

[+FOCUS]

[+FOCUS]

(515b)

[+FOCUS]

NegP 3 3 6 Neg + [+FOCUS] [+FOCUS]

30 [+FOCUS]

Page 142: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

136

[+FOCUS]

(513) a. [[ ] { * } ]

b. [[ ] { } ]

[+FOCUS]

(514) a. [FinP ] https://www.city.satsumasendai.lg.jp/

www/genre/1207717373116/index.html

b. [FinP ]

(515) a. [ForceP [ ] { # } ]

b. [ForceP[ ] {*? ?? } ]

[+FOCUS] [+LINK]

6.6.

ⅳ CP

FOCUS

LINK

[+FOCUS] NegP FOCUS

ForceP 3

+ Force’ 3 Force NegP 3

Neg’ 3 6 Neg

LINK

FOCUS

z

z

31

Page 143: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

137

C

NegP C ForceP

[+FOCUS]

[+FOCUS]

[Q]

(516) a.

b. = { , , , , ……}

c. ?? CD

d. CD

e. [NegP[DP ] ]

[Q] [+FOCUS]

f. [DP x < >]

(517) a.

b. = { , , , , ……}

c. ??

d.

e. [NegP[DP ] ]

[Q] [+FOCUS]

f. [DP x < >]

C

Page 144: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

138

7

6

7.1.

1.2.4

( ) 2009: 28 (518) 3

3

(519) 25

(518) a. 3 ( ) 2009: 28

b. = {……, 5 , 4 , 3 }

(519) a. 25 ∩ ( ) 2009: 28

b. = {……, 27 , 26 , 25 }

( ) 2009

(520) a. { * }

Page 145: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

139

( ) 2009: 28

b. = { , , …… }

(521) a. 4

b. #4

c. #4

d. #4

PP

P

(522) a. [PP[NP8 3 ] + ]

b. [PP[PP8 3 ] ]

c. # 3

P PP

(523) CHJ

1100

(524b)(524c) (524d)(524e)

Page 146: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

140

P

(524) a. {Ø }

b. [PP[PP[NP ] ] ]

c. [PP[NP ] + ]

d. [PP[PP[NP ]Ø] ]

e. * [PP[NP ]Ø+ ]

P

7.2.

φ 1995

(525) 5

(525) a. 5 https://ncode.syosetu.com/n5848ej/1/

b. 5 = { , , , ……}

(527) (528)

A B C

C

(526)

(527) #[ ] A

Page 147: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

141

(528) #[ ] B 52

(529) [ — ] C

(530)

(531a) (531b) (531c)

FinP ForceP

(530) a.

b. ??

(531) a. #5

b. #5

c. 5

C

CP FinP ForceP

CP

52 (19)

19)

Page 148: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

142

8

X0 Xmax

A

1974, 1993

vP A

A

vP TP B

ForceP C

Page 149: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

143

LF

[Q]

+

(532) A: [CP[FinP[vP[VP ]v+ ] ] ]

B:

(533) A: [CP[FinP[vP[vP ] ] ] ]

B:

+

(534) A: [CP[FinP − [CLP ] ] ]

B: { #3 #Ø Ø }

LINK FOCUS

[+FOCUS/+LINK] LF

B C

B

(535) a.

b. #

C

(536) a.

Page 150: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

144

b. #

c. #

(537) a. *

b.

32

Narrow Syntax

[Q] [+LINK] [+FOCUS]

Narrow Syntax

Transfer

+ + A

B C TP ForceP

[+FOCUS/+LINK]

/[Q]

32

Page 151: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

145

c-

8.1.

[+FOCUS/+LINK]

A

[+FOCUS]

(538) [[[DP ] ] ] =(1)

(539) [[[DP ] ] ] =(1)

(540) [[DP ] ] =(2)

+ + A

A + CL + D

v

Page 152: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

146

(541) [CLP3 ] =(3)

3

2

(542) [DP ] =(4)

{ , ↑ , ……}

A

(543) [[NP ] ]

B TP T

B

B

(544) [TP[ ] ]

C ForceP Force

ForceP c-

C

(545) [ForceP[ ] ] =(5)

Page 153: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

147

[Q]

NegP Neg [+FOCUS]

(546) [NegP[ ] ]

{ , , ……}

11

11

+ X0 vP A [Q] [+FOCUS]

+ X0 CL vP A /[Q] [+FOCUS]

A X0 vP A [+FOCUS]

Xmax vP A [+FOCUS]

B Xmax TP B [+FOCUS]

C Xmax ForceP C [+LINK]

Page 154: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

148

(547) ( ) [Q]

( ) [+FOCUS/+LINK] 53

[Q]

FinP [+FOCUS]

ForceP [+LINK]

[Q]

[Q] [+FOCUS/+LINK]

[+FOCUS] [+LINK]

[Q]

[Q] [+FOCUS/+LINK]

X0 +

+ A Xmax B

C CL0

+ X0 [Q] +

A Xmax

TP B

ForceP C

[+FOCUS/+LINK]

[Q] NegP

[+FOCUS]

53 Watanabe (2002) ⅳ

-Interpretable Focus Feature

Page 155: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

149

Forcemax 3 2 3 YCmax Force0 C Tmax 3 2 3 YBmax T0 B

33

Xmax 3

3 Xmax 3 3

2 3 X0 A X0 CL0 +

[Q] X max 3

3 [Q] 2

X0 + [Q]

[+FOCUS/+LINK] Xmax 3 6 3 Ymax X0 [+FOCUS/+LINK] [+FOCUS/+LINK]

Negmax 3 [+FOCUS]Ymax 3 2 Neg0 Y0/max [+FOCUS] [Q] [Q]

33

Page 156: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

150

8.2.

ⅳ ∃

(548)

(549)

Page 157: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

151

2006 ⅳ .

2008

8(2): 37-53. .

2010 ( )

193-225. .

2006 wa ⅳ

8 2005 1-8

2009

16: 95-107.

2000

.

2001 ⅳ

568: 947-973.

2007 ( )

227-260. .

2011 ( ) 70

1-36. .

2013 .

2015 α 2015

ⅱ 147-152.

2016 , .

2017a 11: 85-104.

2017b

155 276-281.

2017c

18 270-277.

2018a 12: 187-198.

Page 158: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

152

2018b

2017 ‥ 11-20.

2018c 18(2):

110-126. .

2009 136: 93-119.

2010 ( )

67-94. .

2014 .

1897 .

1993 .

2010

A 10(7): 213-222.

2014

A 13(4): 1-7.

1974 .

1986

1-27. .

2014 1 ( ) 619-622. .

2007 Neg c- + 131: 77-113.

2011 7(2): 32-47.

1978 .

↗ 2009 ↓ 821: 66-75.

1940 .

φ 1995

( ) 227-260. .

2009

21(2): 191-216.

2010 ( )

151-192. .

2007 .

Page 159: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

153

1998 ⅳ

2: 113-203. .

1987 ⅵ 6(5): 37-48. .

, 2009

, .

1991

10(9): 80-86. .

1981 (3) →

6: 53-67.

1991 .

Σ 2008 8(1): 36-52.

.

2010 ( )

260-284. .

2012 .

2011 ⅳ

( ) 70 207-229. .

2001

.

2012 CLAVEL 2: 1-12.

1989 ( )

1-56. .

1991 .

( ) 2003 4 8 .

( ) 2009 5 9 10

.

1984

3(4): 79-89. .

1986

105-225. .

Page 160: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

154

1989 ( )

159-192. .

2008 α

( ) 8(2): 20-36. .

2009 .

1995

( ) 175-207. .

1995

( ) 1-35. .

1994 23(2): 116-119. .

( ) 2007 .

2010 ⅳ ( )

1-30. .

2012 CP

12(2): 24-42. .

( ) 1992 .

( ) 2016 .

2007 13: 1-14.

2015 ,

.

2011 ( ) 70

61-84. .

1987 ( ) 3: 278-306. .

1993 ( )

149-167. .

2013 Derivational Feature-Based Relativized Minimality

( ) 163-184. .

1990 9(5): 4-15. .

1991 .

1992 .

Page 161: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

155

( ) 1995 .

1977 .

1960 .

2001 32: 65-79.

1974 .

1993 .

1994 .

2012 ( )

115-151. .

2015 .

2018

48: 87-96.

2006

.

1948 .

2005 74(1): 15-32.

2006 75(2): 34-52.

1908 .

1922 .

1936 .

1987 64(7): 47-66.

Abbott, Barbara (1996) Doing without a partitive constraint. In: Jacob Hoeksema (ed.) Partitives:

Studies on the Syntax and Semantics of Partitive and Related Constructions, 25-56. Berlin:

Mouton de Gruyter.

Beck, Sigrid and Shin-Sook Kim (1997) On wh- and operator scope in Korean. Journal of East

Asian Linguistics 6: 339-384.

Chomsky, Noam (1995) The Minimalist Program. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

Chomsky, Noam (2000) Minimalist inquiries: The framework. In: Roger Martin, David Michaels,

Page 162: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

156

and Juan Uriagereka (eds.) Step by Step: Essays on Minimalist Syntax in Honor of Howard

Lasnik, 89-155. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

Chomsky, Noam (2001) Derivation by phase. In: Michael Kenstowicz (ed.) Ken Hale: A Life in

Language, 1-52. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

Chomsky, Noam (2004) Beyond explanatory adequacy. In: Adriana Belletti (ed.) Structures and

Beyond: The Cartography of Syntactic Structures 3: 104-131. New York: Oxford University

Press.

É. Kiss, Katalin (1998) Identificational focus versus information focus. Language 74: 245-273.

Endo, Yoshio (2007) Locality and Information Structure: A Cartographic Approach to Japanese.

Amsterdam: John Benjamins Publishing Company.

Fitzpatrick, Justin (2006) The Syntactic and Semantic Roots of Floating Quantification. Doctoral

dissertation, MIT.

Hamblin, C.L. (1973) Questions in Montague English. Foundations of Language 10: 41-53.

Heim, Irene R. (1982) The Semantics of Definite and Indefinite Noun Phrases. Doctoral dissertation,

University of Massachusetts, Amherst.

Hiraiwa, Ken (2001) Multiple agree and the defective intervention constraint in Japanese. In: Ora

Matushansky et al. (eds.) Proceedings of the HUMIT 2000, MIT Working Papers in

Linguistics 40: 67-80. Cambridge, MA: MIT.

Hiraiwa, Ken (2005a) Dimensions of Symmetry in Syntax: Agreement and Clausal Architechture.

Doctoral dissertation, MIT.

Hiraiwa, Ken (2005b) Indeterminate-agreement: Some consequences for the Case system. In: Ken

Hiraiwa and Joseph Sabbagh (eds.) Minimalist Approaches to Clause Structure, MIT

Working Papers in Linguistics 50: 93-128. Cambridge, MA: MIT.

Hoji, Hajime (1985) Logical Form Constraints and Configurational Structures in Japanese.

Doctoral dissertation, University of Washington.

Huang, C.-T. James (1982) Logical Relations in Chinese and the Theory of Grammar. Doctoral

dissertation, MIT.

Ikawa, Hajime (2013) What the ineligibility of wh-phrases for argument ellipsis tells us: On the

inertness of phonetically null elements. In: Online Proceedings of GLOW in Asia IX.

Kato, Yasuhiko (1985) Negative sentences in Japanese. Sophia Linguistica 19.

Page 163: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

157

Kishimoto, Hideki (2001) Binding of indeterminate pronouns and clause structure in Japanese.

Linguistic Inquiry 32: 597-633.

Kobuchi-Philip, Mana (2009) Japanese mo: universal, additive, and NPI. Journal of Cognitive

Science 10: 173-194.

Kobuchi-Philip, Mana (2010) Indeterminate numeral quantifiers, ‘some’ and ‘many’ readings, and

questions in Japanese. Korean Journal of Linguistics 35: 503-530.

Kuroda, S.-Y. (1965 [1979]) Generative Grammatical Studies in the Japanese Language. Doctoral

dissertation, MIT. Reprinted, New York: Garland Press, 1979.

May, Robert (1977 [1991]) The Grammar of Quantification. Doctoral dissertation, MIT. Reprinted,

New York: Garland Press, 1991.

Nakanishi, Kimiko (2008) The syntax and semantics of floating numeral quantifiers. In: Shigeru

Miyagawa and Mamoru Saito (eds.) The Oxford Handbook of Japanese Linguistics, 287-319.

Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Nasu, Norio (2012) Topic particle stranding and the structure of CP. In: Lobke Aelbrecht, Liliane

Haegeman and Rachel Nye (eds.) Main Clause Phenomena: New Horizons, 205-228.

Amsterdam: John Benjamins Publishing Company.

Nishigauchi, Taisuke (1990) Quantification in the Theory of Grammar. Dordrecht: Kluwer

Academic Publishers.

Nishiyama, Kunio (1999) Adjectives and the copulas in Japanese. Journal of East Asian Linguistics

8: 183-222.

Ochi, Masao (2012) Universal numeric quantifiers in Japanese. Iberia 4(2): 40-77.

Oku, Satoshi (1998) A Theory of Selection and Reconstruction in the Minimalist Perspective.

Doctoral dissertation, University of Connecticut.

Otani, Kazuyo and John Whitman (1991) V-raising and VP-ellipsis. Linguistic Inquiry 22: 345-358.

Otsu, Yukio (1994) Early acquisition of scrambling in Japanese. In: Teun Hoekstra and Bonnie D.

Schwartz (eds.) Language Acquisition Studies in Generative Grammar, 253-264. Amsterdam:

John Benjamins Publishing Company.

Pesetsky, David (1987) Wh-in-situ: Movement and unselective binding. In: Eric J. Reuland and

Alice G. B. ter Meulen (eds.) The Representation of (In) definiteness, 98-129. Cambridge,

MA: MIT Press.

Page 164: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

158

Rizzi, Luigi (1990) Relativized Minimality. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

Rizzi, Luigi (1997) The fine structure of the left periphery. In: Liliane Haegeman (ed.) Elements of

Grammar: Handbook of Generative Syntax, 281-337. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic

Publishers.

Rizzi, Luigi (2004) Locality and left periphery. In: Adriana Belleti (ed.) Structures and Beyond: The

Cartography of Syntactic Structures 3: 223-251. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Rooth, Mats (1985) Association with Focus. Doctoral dissertation, University of Massachusetts,

Amherst.

Saito, Mamoru (1985) Some Asymmetries in Japanese and Their Theoretical Implications. Doctoral

dissertation, MIT.

Saito, Mamoru (2007) Notes on East Asian argument ellipsis. Language Research 43: 203-227.

Sakamoto, Yuta and Hiroaki Saito (2018) Overtly stranded but covertly not. In: Wm. G. Bennett,

Lindsay Hracs, and Dennis Ryan Storoshenko (eds.) Proceedings of the 35th West Coast

Conference on Formal Linguistics, 349-356. Somerville, MA: Cascadilla Proceedings Project.

Sato, Yosuke (2012) Particle-stranding ellipsis in Japanese, phase theory, and the privilege of the

root. Linguistic Inquiry 43: 495–504.

Sato, Yosuke and Jason Ginsburg (2007) A new type of nominal ellipsis in Japanese. In: Yoichi

Miyamoto and Masao Ochi (eds.) Formal Approaches to Japanese Linguistics: Proceedings

of FAJL 4, 197-204.

Sato, Yosuke and Masako Maeda (in press) Particle stranding ellipsis involves PF-deletion. Natural

Language & Linguistic Theory.

Shimoyama, Junko (2006) Indeterminate phrase quantification in Japanese. Natural Language

Semantics 14: 139-173.

Shudo, Sachiko (2002) Presupposition and Discourse Functions of the Japanese Particle Mo. New

York & London: Routledge.

Sugisaki, Koji (2011) A constraint on argument ellipsis in child Japanese. Nanzan Linguistics 7:

63-76.

Takahashi, Daiko (2002) Determiner raising and scope shift. Linguistic Inquiry 33: 575-615.

Tomioka, Satoshi (2007) Intervention effects in focus: From a Japanese point of view. In: Shinichiro

Ishihara, Svetlana Petrova, and Anne Schwarz (eds.) Working Papers of the SFB 632,

Page 165: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA...2 yxP,

159

Interdisciplinary Studies on Information Structure (ISIS) 9: 97-118. Potsdam: Universität

Potsdam.

Tsai, Wei-Tien (1994) On Economizing the Theory of A-Bar Dependencies. Doctoral dissertation,

MIT.

Uriagereka, Juan (1999) Multiple spell-out. In: Samuel David Epstein and Norbert Hornstein (eds.)

Working Minimalism, 251-282. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

Uriagereka, Juan (2012) Spell-Out and the Minimalist Program. New York: Oxford University

Press.

Vallduví, Enric (1992) The Informational Component. New York: Garland.

Vallduví, Enric (1995) Structural properties of information packaging in Catalan. In: Katalin É. Kiss

(ed.) Discourse Configurational Languages, 122-152. New York: Oxford University Press.

Watanabe, Akira (2002) Loss of overt wh-movement in old Japanese. In: David W. Lightfoot (ed.)

Syntactic Effects of Morphological Change, 179-195. New York: Oxford University Press.

Watanabe, Akira (2004) The genesis of negative concord: Syntax and morphology of negative

doubling. Linguistic Inquiry 35: 559-612.

Watanabe, Akira (2008) The structure of DP. In: Shigeru Miyagawa and Mamoru Saito (eds.) The

Oxford Handbook of Japanese Linguistics, 513-540. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Yatsushiro, Kazuko (2001) The distribution of mo and ka and its implications. In: Formal

Approaches to Japanese Linguistics 3: 181-198.

I-JAS http://lsaj.ninjal.ac.jp/?ca

t=3 [2018 11 ]

CHJ https://chunagon.ninjal.ac.jp/ [2018 11

]

http://sakubun.jpn.org [2018 11 ]

1990[2011] 2011 http://ter

amuradb.ninjal.ac.jp/db/ [2018 11 ]


Recommended