of 28
8/3/2019 Pro Pied a Des
1/28
1
W.J. van Ooij501E ERC
Phone 556-3194Fax 556-3773
Email: [email protected] , [email protected]: http://www.eng.uc.edu/~wvanooij
20-MTSC-642-001
Spring 2002MW 2:00-3:15
422D RIEVESCHL
RUBBER SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING
Prerequisites :
Basic knowledge of organic chemistryKnowledge of mechanical properties of materials (e.g., NAPOM)
CHAPTER 6PROPERTIES OF VULCANIZATES
8/3/2019 Pro Pied a Des
2/28
2
PROPIEDADES DE LOS VULCANIZADOS [1] INTRODUCTION [1]
What are the properties of the vulcanizates and how arethey tested?
VulcanizateProperties
The major application is automobile tires; each application
has its own set of additional, specific test methods
Applications of theVulcanizates
How do we form and cure the mixtures into strong elasticmaterials?
Vulcanization
How do we mix these ingredients into the elastomers?Processing
The most important additive to the elastomer and the leastunderstood
Fillers
What do we mix into the elastomers and why?Compounding
Which ones exist and what are their basic properties?Elastomers
So far we have discussed:
8/3/2019 Pro Pied a Des
3/28
3
PROPIEDADES DE LOS VULCANIZADOS [2] TEST METHODS
Some important tests for rubber properties done in industry:
1. Tests of Raw Materials: the material is mixed with other compounding ingredientsusing a standard formulation and standard mixing procedures; standard sheets arethen vulcanized from the standard compound; its properties are then tested; specs
are given in various ASTM methods (see Long, page 174); we will not discuss themhere (note: before a supplier is approved, the rubber company has to do all this work)
2. Tests for Processibility: ASTM D1646 and D2084 are used; see VULCANIZATION [5]and [6] for the latter (rheometer); D1646 is shown on the next page
3. Tests of Rubber Vulcanizates: comprise >70% of all ASTM rubber test methods;the methods are summarized in ASTM D297; there are more than 200 test methods
Tensile tests stress-strain curves
Stiffness including hardness, indentationElastic recovery compression set, tension setDurability aging, liquid, ozone, lightFatigue test dynamic flexing (cracking)Abrasion tests tread wearTemperature effects high and low T, with and without oxygen
Tear resistance with or without nick or cutElectrical tests electrical conductivity, static charging
8/3/2019 Pro Pied a Des
4/28
4
PROPIEDADES DE LOS VULCANIZADOS [3]
Mooney viscosimeter; ASTM D1646
The Mooney viscosity scale is arbitrary and basedon one rate of shear
Processing is more difficult and requires moreenergy if the Mooney viscosity increases
Sensitive to the condition of the apparatus,temperature of the rubber, and slippage
This test does not provide the modulus or the timerequired for vulcanization (t 90); it only measures thefirst part of the rheometer curve
TEST FOR PROCESSIBILITY [1]
Processibility equipment can also measure die swell= % increase in diameter or area after extrusion
Is caused by relaxation after elongation
8/3/2019 Pro Pied a Des
5/28
5
PROPIEDADES DE LOS VULCANIZADOS [4] TEST FOR PROCESSIBILITY [2]
Mooney scorch curve
Notice the meaning of T5 and T 35
8/3/2019 Pro Pied a Des
6/28
8/3/2019 Pro Pied a Des
7/28
7
PROPIEDADES DE LOS VULCANIZADOS [6] TEST OF VULCANIZATES [2]
Hardness
Resistance to indentation
Important property
Expressed as number depending oninstrument used
Shore durometers are most widely used Their scale is from 0 to 100
Shore A is for soft rubber
Shore D for harder products
Hardness testers
8/3/2019 Pro Pied a Des
8/28
8
PROPERTIES OF VULCANIZATES [7] TEST OF VULCANIZATES [3]
Tear ResistanceDie C tear sample
Other tear samples
Ease of tearing of rubber when nicked or cutvaries considerably
Depends on: rate of tearing, crystallization ofrubber (NR), amount and type of filler, shapeof sample and others
Results between tests do not agree
No tests correlates well with field service
Resistance is expressed as N/m (lbs/in)
Sensitive to state of cure and often shows a
sharp maximum
Undercure give smooth curves, tighter curegives knotty tear especially with black/NR
cut
8/3/2019 Pro Pied a Des
9/28
9
PROPERTIES OF VULCANIZATES [8] TEST OF VULCANIZATES [4]
NBS Abrader
Gives relative abrasion resistance comparedwith a standard compound
Widely use for shoe soles
Drum rotates at 45 rpm
No. of revs to wear compound 2.5 mmis measured (ASTM D1630)
The pico abrader is used for tread wear of tires(ASTM D2228)
Two tungsten carbide knives are rubbed overthe surface and the weight loss is measured
sample
abrasive paper on rubber-covered drum
weights
In the tire industry actual road tests need to beperformed on a test track
Abrasion Resistance
8/3/2019 Pro Pied a Des
10/28
10
PROPERTIES OF VULCANIZATES [9] TEST OF VULCANIZATES [5]
Elastic Recovery
Equipment for compression set measurement
using method B
Compression set is the amount (in %) by whicha standard test piece fails to return to itsoriginal thickness after having been subjected
to a standard compressive load or deflectionfor a fixed period of time
ASTM D395 method A = constant load ASTM D395 method B = constant deflection
Aging is included in the test, typically 22 hrsat 70C or 70 hrs at 100C, depending on thetype of rubber
There are many other tests for creep, tension
set and stress relaxation
8/3/2019 Pro Pied a Des
11/28
11
PROPERTIES OF VULCANIZATES [10] TEST OF VULCANIZATES [6]
Durability [1]
Equipment for heat aging ASTM D865
Dumbbell samples are heated in air in testtubes
At 70C or higher (up to 120C for unsaturated
rubbers)
The difference in ultimate elongation beforeand after heating is the criterion for durability
All rubbers deteriorate but rate depends ontime, temperature and composition
There are many other accelerated heat agingtests
One variation is ASTM D454, aging at 127C at550 kPa pressure (air bomb); very drastic;rubber deteriorates in hours
Heat aging [1]
8/3/2019 Pro Pied a Des
12/28
12
PROPERTIES OF VULCANIZATES [11] TEST OF VULCANIZATES [7]
Durability [2]
Heat aging [2]
Rubber samples are heated at 70C in 2 MPaoxygen (some rubbers at 80C)
Samples are heated in individual vessels to
avoid cross contamination
Heating time is 1-5 days
Equipment for oxygen bomb agingASTM D572
Several ASTM tests exist for testing resistance toozone; ASTM D149 is widely used
Severe surface cracking can occur at 0.00001%O3 in the air; antiozonants can prevent it
Ozone attack depends on rubber strain, so tape-
red or bent loop samples are used
8/3/2019 Pro Pied a Des
13/28
13
PROPERTIES OF VULCANIZATES [12] TEST OF VULCANIZATES [8]
Durability [3]
Comparison between natural aging andaccelerated aging for an NR tread compoundis shown here
Note the accelerating factor on the horizontal axis
Conclusion: the ASTM D865 test (page 10) givesthe best correlation and can be used to predictservice life
8/3/2019 Pro Pied a Des
14/28
14
PROPERTIES OF VULCANIZATES [13] TEST OF VULCANIZATES [9]
Resilience, Heat Buildup and Temperature Effects
Goodyear and Lpke resiliometers
Resilience is ratio of returned to impressed energy
Heat buildup is the amount of impressed energy that isabsorbed
A pendulum is released from a catch at a point marked
100 and hits a rubber specimen held on an anvil
The pendulum has a standard weight and dimensions
The scale at the point of rebound is less than 100; thisis the energy recovered; the difference is the percentof energy loss
Tg
Rebound vs. T
8/3/2019 Pro Pied a Des
15/28
15
PROPERTIES OF VULCANIZATES [14] TEST OF VULCANIZATES [10]
Equipment for heat buildup and low T
The Goodrich flexometer for heat buildupis ASTM D623
The sample is positioned between heatedanvils
The top one is connected to an adjustableeccentric driven at 1800 rpm
Samples are loaded between 0.7 and 2.1 MPa The stroke is between 4.4 and 9.4 mm
Under the lower load, high quality elastomerswill reach an equilibrium T after 25 min
Under the higher load and stroke, all but the
highest quality rubber will blow out
The blow-out time is a measure of theresistance to failure
The brittle point (ASTM D746) is that tempera-
ture at which a specimen becomes brittle andwill shatter upon bending or impact
Elastomers are far superior to plastics in low-temperature performance
They can be compounded for low-T perfor-
mance
The brittle point can be as low as 100C(silicones)
8/3/2019 Pro Pied a Des
16/28
8/3/2019 Pro Pied a Des
17/28
8/3/2019 Pro Pied a Des
18/28
18
PROPERTIES OF VULCANIZATES [17] TEST OF VULCANIZATES [13]
Flex Resistance or Fatigue Testing [2]
Samples are 25 x 6.5 x 150 mm with a trans-verse groove
The grips approach each other from 19 to 76mm; cracking occurs in the groove which
simulates a groove in a tire tread
Flexing speed is 300 cycles per min.
After a number of cycles, the specimens arerated by comparison with a set of standards(see insert) grade 0 to 10
Test can be continued until all samples becomecracked; number of flexures is then recorded
Test can be done at non-ambient temperatureand in gases other than air
DeMattia flex machine
8/3/2019 Pro Pied a Des
19/28
19
PROPERTIES OF VULCANIZATES [18] TEST OF VULCANIZATES [14]
Flex Resistance or Fatigue Testing [3]
Ross flex machine
Used mainly for soling materials
Test pieces are 25 x 150 mm
They are flexed to an angle of 90at 100 flexings/min.
One end is clamped, the other canslide between rollers during flexing
Before the test a 2.5 mm cut is madewith an awl at the point of maximum flex
In the tests the cut growth is measured
in 2.5 mm increments
8/3/2019 Pro Pied a Des
20/28
8/3/2019 Pro Pied a Des
21/28
21
PROPERTIES OF VULCANIZATES [20] TEST OF VULCANIZATES [16]
Compared here are black-filled rubbers vs. extension ratio or strain energy
The latter is calculated from the stress-strain curve for a prefatigued sampleand integrating the area under the curve up to the extension used in the test
Comparison at equal strain energy eliminates differences due to differences inmodulus
The degree of mixing has a strong influence on the fatigue properties
Flex Resistance or Fatigue Testing [5]
8/3/2019 Pro Pied a Des
22/28
22
PROPERTIES OF VULCANIZATES [21] TEST OF VULCANIZATES [17]
Weather Resistance [1]
Effect of weathering on inadequately protected rubbers
sponge
stress
edbybendingaro
undamandril
Outdoor exposure of stressed rubber strips on the roof of a plant or test farms is widely done
There are several ASTM tests, e.g., D518 and D1171
Rubber inherently has a very poor weathering resistance, but is protected by additives
The factors that contribute to the degradation are: heat, oxygen, moisture, light (200-250 nm)and O 3 at 1 ppm or higher levels
Similar to paint and other polymers, there are accelerated tests for rubber compounds
8/3/2019 Pro Pied a Des
23/28
23
PROPERTIES OF VULCANIZATES [22] TEST OF VULCANIZATES [18]
Weather Resistance [2]
Weather-o-meter for rubber
In this chamber rubber samples are testedfor discoloration by exposing them to astandard source of UV light under control-led conditions
ASTM D1148, 925, 750 describe theconditions
This test is performed with white or lightcolored products
8/3/2019 Pro Pied a Des
24/28
24
PROPERTIES OF VULCANIZATES [23] TEST OF VULCANIZATES [19]
Weather Resistance [3]
Outdoor dynamic testing using the Goodrich
flex machine
The component of the weathering conditionsresponsible for the cracking under stressed orstrained conditions is ozone, O3
The severity of the attack is modulus dependent
and a direct function of the ozone concentra-tion
The strain at which maximum ozone damageoccurs is lower for rubbers that crystallizeupon stretching, such as polyisoprene
Ozone cracking does not occur in saturatedpolymers, it is an attack of the double bond
The extent of damage increases with degree ofmain chain unsaturation
This sensitivity is one of the reasons why NRis not used in treads or sidewalls
There are several ASTM tests, e.g., D1149
The ozone concentration in such tests is typi-cally 50-100 ppm
8/3/2019 Pro Pied a Des
25/28
25
PROPERTIES OF VULCANIZATES [24] TEST OF VULCANIZATES [20]
Rapid cycles of loading/unloading occurs intires, belts, shocks mounts, diaphragms, tanktrack pads, and many others
The question of how elastomers respond has been extensively studied in the last decade
Cyclic stresses are modeled as a sine curve,i.e., stress builds up smoothly and declinessmoothly in both direction s
The two extremes in dynamic responses areelastic vs. viscous materials
A steel spring is completely elastic: the springdeforms in complete synchronization with aforce so that the deflection is maximum whenthe force is at its maximum
As it is forced to deflect, the spring stores100% of the energy expended through theapplication of the force to compress it
The ratio of the deformation to the force is a constant (the spring constant)
A viscous damper is a cylinder filled with a fluidof high viscosity; a piston can move in thecylinder but the liquid can flow through the
clearance between the cylinder and the wall When a force is applied to the piston it will
move, causing the fluid to flow through theclearance
The flow lags behind the force and the viscous
flow of the liquid translates all the energy of thepistons motion to heat due to internal friction:0% energy is stored
Dynamic Properties [1]
8/3/2019 Pro Pied a Des
26/28
26
PROPERTIES OF VULCANIZATES [25] TEST OF VULCANIZATES [21]
Dynamic Properties [2]
Force diagram for rubber specimen
damping force
(viscous)
elastic force
complex force(rubber)
phase or loss angle, delta
deflection
Rubber is neither purely elastic nor purely viscous in its dynamic behavior: some energy is storedand some is dissipated
It has a complex dynamic spring rate K* and a complex modulus E*
8/3/2019 Pro Pied a Des
27/28
27
PROPERTIES OF VULCANIZATES [26] TEST OF VULCANIZATES [22]
Dynamic Properties [3]
Mechanical model of dynamicresponse of rubber
The complex modulus E* is the vector sum of the two: E is the storage modulus (100% is stored);the E is the loss modulus (100% is lost, 0% is stored); the angle between the two is d
For rubber in shear, G and G are used
Both E* and d depend on the compound formulation The degree of storage can be measured in the resilience test (see properties [14])
The loss factor or tan d = E/E is measured more accurately in a Dynamic Mechanical Analyzeras a function of T: it measures the tiny time delay between the force applied and the strainbeing reached; that plus the complex spring rate gives E, E and tan d
NR has a loss factor of 0.08-0.14; very damped polymers can get to 0.3 or higher; a higher factormeans: more energy is converted to heat when the rubber is repeatedly strained
Relationship between complex,storage and loss moduli
loss; heat
8/3/2019 Pro Pied a Des
28/28
28
PROPERTIES OF VULCANIZATES [27] TEST OF VULCANIZATES [23]
Dynamic Properties [4]
Thus, higher levels of strain and faster cycling of the stress on the rubber will increase theheat that is liberated
We arrive at the important conclusion that for ANY rubber compound, past some point,the amount of strain and the frequency of the dynamic input will combine to produce heat
faster than can be conducted away, and heat buildup in the rubber (which is a poor thermalconductor!) can go out of control, possibly resulting in catastrophic failure
Since the belt region of a steel-belted tire undergoes the highest shear, such a tire will blow outby complete belt separation (BLB mode)
The chances of experiencing such an event increase with the speed (higher frequency of
dynamic input), and with the degree of underinflation (higher strain) Two other factors are the outside temperature (conduction!) and vehicle load (higher strain)
Important advice: keep the tires inflated, obey the speed limits and do not overload the vehicle!