+ All Categories
Home > Documents > UNO$M - University of Birmingham

UNO$M - University of Birmingham

Date post: 13-Feb-2022
Category:
Upload: others
View: 1 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
171
Transcript
Page 1: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

�������������� ����������������������������� �!�!����#"������#��� ���$�&%��������'���(�)�*"�+�,�����- ��!� $�.�/���������0�1���

��2

�����(34���65���

�����.�7�1�

�'8/9;:=<?>#>#@BAC<EDGFIHKJL>1<EHNMPOQ8IMSR;MEME:=@BDT>�UNO�>1VW@4J1@BX78W<?J1@B:Y@BDZ>1[OQUNJ�>1V/@\A/@^]NJ1@^@4UNO���U7_`>#UNJUNO�!�VW<EMEUa[#UNFIVZbc<EDd".Ua:YF;8/>#@^J��'_^<?@BDI_`@<EDG>1VW@e�'_LVWUZUaMfUNO���D/OgUNJh:=HK>1<?UaDiHNDWAd"�Ua:=:\8IDW<E_^HK>1<?UaDi��@B_LVID/UaM?UN]Nb

+�DW<?jN@^JL[1<E>kblUNO�!�HN<E[1ME@^bNmInKoNo/p

!�HN<E[1M?@^bNm;�/_`UN>1MEHNDWArqs+�3\t

Page 2: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

_� ".UNF7b7JL<?]aVZ>09ZbG��>1Hl34HK9 5HNDfmLnKoNo/p

Page 3: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

�������������

��VI<E[4>1V/@B[L<E[*FIJ1@B[#@BDZ>1[\>1VW@�A/@^jN@BMEUNFI:Y@BDZ>\UNO$M HK>#@BDT> jKHKJL<EHK9IM?@ :YU7AW@BME[��VW<E_LV HKJ1@GHKFWFWJ1UNFWJh<EHK>#@lOQUNJ

:YU'A/@BMEME< D/]d>#@� '>Y9IHN[#@BA AWU7_^8W:=@BDT>1[YHNDWA6HKJL@i_^HKFIHK9IM?@GUNO�FWJ1U j'<EAW< D/] H�V78W:=HND��k8IDWA/@^JL[#>1HNDIAWHK9IM?@ J1@^F��

J1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaD UNO�>1VW@G[1@B:=HNDT>1< _�_`UaDZ>#@BDZ>=<EDWV/@^J1@BDZ>\< Dr>1V/@C_`UNJ1F;8W[�� ��V/@B[#@C:YU'A/@BME[e_`Ua8WMEA 9P@�8W[1@BArOQUNJ

@� '>#@BDWAW<ED/]4_^8WJ1J1@BDZ>�J1@B[#@BHKJL_hVl@��PUNJ1>1[�< DY_`J1@BHK>1<ED/]*H49IHN[1<E[�OQUNJ�H)FIJL<EDW_^<?F;M?@BA\< D/OgUNJh:=HK>1<?UaDYHN_^_`@B[1[.[#b'[#>#@B:��

�.UN>1V�FWJ1UN9IHK9;<EME<E[#>1< _�HNDWAlFWJ1U��#@B_`>1<?UaD�� 9IHN[1@BA HKFWFIJ1UaHN_LV/@B[��.@^J1@<EDZjN@B[#>1<?]aHK>#@BA���� >1V/@^UNJ1@^>1<E_^HNMEMEbYFWJL<ED��

_^<?FIME@BAl:YU'A/@BMEME< D/])OgJhHN:Y@���UNJ��=OgUNJ0A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>�j'<E[18IHNME<E[1HK>1<?UaDlVWHN[.9 @^@BD�A/@^jN@BM?UNFP@BA�����VI<E[�VWHN[�HNME[1U\9P@^@BD

@� '>#@BDWA/@BA�>#U,HiA/b'DWHN:=<E_ :YU'A/@BM m OQUNJ4>1V/@ _^HN[#@=UNO�j7< [18WHNME<E[L<ED/] [1@B:=HNDT>1< _^HNMEM?b _`UaV/@^J1@BDZ>4>#@� 7>18IHNM�<ED/OQUNJ��

:=HK>1<?UaD��$�(FWJ1UN9IHK9;<EME<E[#>1< _OQUNJL:=HNM <E[1: VWHN[9P@^@BD HNAWUNFW>#@BA < Di9PUN>1Vd>1VW@B[#@\_`UaDZ>#JL<?9I8W>1<?UaDW[��0��DdHNAWAI<?>1<?UaDfm

H=ME< D/@BHKJ0FWJ1U��#@B_`>1<?UaDi:Y@^>1VWU7ACVWHN[$9P@^@BDCA/@^JL<?jN@BAiHNDIAC<EDTjN@B[1>1<?]aHK>#@BAiOQUNJ[#@B:lHNDT>1<E_)HNDIHNM?b7[L<E[��

��jN@BDG>1V/Ua8/]aVG>1V/@�FWJL< :=HKJ1bl:YUN>1<Ej HK>1<?UaD�OQUNJ0>1VW<E[��.UNJ���VIHN[�9P@^@BDGJ1@BM HK>#@BAG>#UY>#@� 7>09IHN[1@BA�AIHK>1H'mW>1V/@

:YU'A/@BME[)A/@^jN@BMEUNF @BArV/@^J1@B<ED HKJL@lHKFWFIME< _^HK9IM?@Nm <ED�[#Ua:=@l_^HN[#@B[^m�>#UdH��<EA/@^J)JLHND/]N@lUNO�AIHK>1H'm�HN[\<E[4[1V/U �$D

97b=[#Ua:Y@< MEME8W[#>#JhHK>1<?jN@0@� 'HN:=FIM?@B[�UNO HKFWFIME<E_^HK>1<EUaDW[���&HKJL<?Ua8W[�@� 7>#@BDW[L<?UaDW[�UNOf>1V/@A/@^jN@BMEUNF @BAlFWJ1UN9IHK9;<EME<E[#>1< _

:YU'A/@BME[0HKJ1@\HNME[#UYFPUa[1[1<?9;M?@!�

"$#&%�')(+*�,.-0/ M HK>#@BDT>�>#JLHN<?>�:YU7AW@BM m�>#UNF UN]NJhHKFIVW<E_i:lHKFWFI<ED/]/m�<EDWAW@^F @BDIA/@BDT>=_`Ua:=F UaDW@BDT>�HNDWHNM?b'[1<E[^m

��HK>#@BDZ>��'@B:=HNDT>1< _)�DWHNMEb7[1< [^m'>#UNFI<E_)A/@^>#@B_`>1<?UaD mW>#UNFI<E_)j'<E[18IHNME<E[1HK>1<?UaD mZ>#UNFI< _�@^jNUaME8/>1<?UaD

< <E<

Page 4: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

��Ul:\b�:YUN>1VW@^J

<?j

Page 5: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

���������� ��� ��� ��� � �

�)>1H �N@�>1VW<E[*UNFWFPUNJ1>18WDW<?> b >#U,>1VWHND�� :\b�>#U7U �'<EDWA [18WF @^JLj7<E[1UNJ*!&J1UNO �i�,HKJ�����<?J1UaM HN:=<�OQUNJeHNMEM�VW<E[

[18/FIF UNJL>�AW8WJL<ED/]�>1V/@0FP@^JL<?U'A*UNOP!�VI� [1>18WAW<?@B[�� [#FP@B_^<SR _^HNMEM?b)OQUNJ�HKFWFPUa<EDZ>1<ED/]�:Y@�>#U4>1V/@0J1@B[#@BHKJh_LV=HN[1[L<E[ �

>1HNDZ>1[1VW<?F)�$<?>1VeVW<E[�FWJLU���@B_`>�� ��:YFWJ1U jN@BA UaDWME<ED/@.<ED/OQUNJL:=HK>1<?UaDeHN_^_`@B[1[��NOs8WDWAW@BA*97b����&/ [#Ua8/JL_`@NmT�$V/@0"�Ua8WDW_^<EM

OQUNJ$� 8I[#@B8W:=[��JL_hVW<?jN@B[�HNDWAd��<?9WJhHKJL<?@B[���JLHNDZ>$��8W:*9P@^J� ��� o��NnY>#U �$VW<E_hVG�.HN: :YUa[#>�]NJLHK>#@^Os8WM �

� ��Ua8WM A,HNM [#U�M < �N@ >#U�@� 'FWJ1@B[L[):*b ]NJLHK>1<?>18WA/@ >#UG>1V/@YV/@BHNA UNO�>1V/@Y��HK9PUNJLHK>#UNJ1b UNO�".Ua:YF;8/>#@^J4HNDWA

��D/OgUNJh:=HK>1<?UaDY�'_^<?@BDW_`@Nma�@BME[1<ED �7<Z+DW<EjN@^JL[1<?> b4UNOI��@B_LVWD/UaMEUN]NbNmZ!&JLUNO ���&J�� �'<'� �1HOgUNJ�HNMEM?U �$<ED/]�:Y@�>#U ��UNJ��

HN[�H$j'<E[1<?>1< D/]0J1@B[#@BHKJL_hV/@^J�<ED*VI<E[ MEHK9PUNJLHK>#UNJ1b)OQUNJ�H$FP@^JL<?U'A)UNOW[1< ):=UaDT>1Ve<ED �T8WD/@��k��@B_`@B:\9 @^J&nKoNoNo����,HNDTb

>1VWHND��'[.>#UYVW<E[�!�VW�-[1>18WA/@BDZ>.��MEMEH*��<EDW]aVWHN: OgUNJ�>1V/@�FWJ1Ua:=< [1<ED/]*_`UaM MEHK9PUNJLHK>1<?jN@ ��UNJ�� <EDW<?>1<EHK>#@BA HK>�>1VWHK>

>1<E:Y@ HNDWA�>#Ud>1VW@l:=HNDZb,JL@B[#@BHKJL_LVW@^JL[4OQJ1Ua: >1VW@lMEHK9PUNJLHK>#UNJ1b �$V/Ui]aH jN@�VW@BM?FWOs8WM�_`Ua:=:Y@BDZ>1[*J1@^]aHKJhAW<ED/]

:\b �.UNJ�� �

�0HN: HNME[1U=>1VWHND��7OQ8IMP>#Ul!&J1UNO ���,HNME_`UaME: ".J1U �.@Nm;!�J1UNO �.".UaME<ED"!�b7Og@\HNDWAi��J ��� �.HND � _^�J1>1V78/J�OQUNJ

V/@BM?FIOQ8WMP_`Ua:=:=@BDT>1[$UaDiHNDC@BHKJLM?bGA/JLHKOQ>0UNO�>1V/@)>1V/@B[1< [��

��D Hi:YUNJ1@�<ED/OQUNJL:=HNM�M?@^jN@BM m��)HN: >1VIHND��ZOs8WM�>#U,�J ����DWA/J 5HN[\�$#UNJL< DW_&%YOgJLUa: >1V/@��'#UN>#j(#Ua[\��UNJ 5HNDWA

+�DW<?jN@^JL[1<E>kb�UNO���8WAWHKFP@B[#>0OQUNJ�>1V/@\<EDW[1<?]aVZ>#Os8WM;HNDIAi:YUN>1<?jKHK>1<ED/]Y@��k:=HN< M _`Ua:=:e8WDW<E_^HK>1<?UaD��

j

Page 6: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

�$� � � � � � � � ��� � � �

��������� � ������

� ��� # * ��� # ' � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � pp �Ep ��DT>#J1U'AW8W_`>1<EUaD � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � pp � n ".UaDZ>#JL<?9I8W>1<?UaDW[.UNO�>1V/@*HN8/>1V/UNJ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �p ��� ��V/@\�'>#JL8W_`>18/J1@)UNO�>1V/@*�$V/@B[1<E[ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �

� ��� � *�(�,"!�# �$� ( �%� ( � # � # *$& �'�(� #*) (�,.#,+ - � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � pNpn �Ep ��D/Og@^JL@BDW_`@*HNDWAGFIHKJhHN:Y@^>#@^J$@B[#>1< :=HK>1<?UaDi<EDG]N@BDW@^JLHK>1<?jN@\:=U7A/@BM [ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � p��

n �Ep �Ep ��D/OQ@^J1@BDW_`@�� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � p��n �Ep � n !�HKJLHN:Y@^>#@^J�@B[#>1<E:lHK>1<?UaD � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � p.-

n �Ep � n �Ep ��HBbN@B[1<EHND @B[#>1<E:lHK>1<?UaD � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � p.-n �Ep � n � n � H� /<E:e8W: � !�Ua[#>#@^JL<?UNJL<�qs� ��!.t0@B[#>1<E:=HK>1<?UaD�� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � p�/n �Ep � n ��� � H� /<E:e8W: ��< �N@BME<EV/U7U'A qs�,��t�@B[#>1<E:=HK>1<?UaD � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � p�0

n � n ��< D/@BHKJ ��@BD/@^JhHK>1<?jN@*:YU'A/@BME[ �$<E>1V��HN8W[1[1< HNDiMEHK>#@BDZ>�FWJL<?UNJ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � p �n � n �Ep !�J1UN9IHK9I<EM <E[#>1<E_�!&JL<EDI_^<?FIHNM/".Ua:YFPUaD/@BDZ>&�DWHNMEb7[1< [�qs!�!."��)t�HNDWAY!�JL<EDW_^<?F;HNM'".Ua: �

FPUaD/@BDZ>��DIHNM?b7[L<E[4qs!."��)t � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � p �n � n � n � jKHKJL<EHNDZ>0OgUNJ�9;<EDWHKJ1b�AWHK>1H � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �CnNn

n ��� !�<EDW<?>#@4�,< '>18/J1@4:YU'A/@BMEM <ED/]�� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �Cn$-n �1- ��< D/@BHKJ�]N@BD/@^JLHK>1<EjN@*:YU'A/@BME[ �$<?>1VdD/UaD�� ��HN8W[L[1<EHNDCMEHK>#@BDZ>�FWJL<EUNJL[ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �Cn2/

n �1-��Ep ��DWA/@^FP@BDWA/@BDZ> !WHN_`>#UNJ��DWHNMEb7[1< [4qQ� !'�)t � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �Cn20n �1-�� n � 7FP@B_`>1HK>1<?UaD�� H� /<E:=< [1HK>1<?UaDYOQUNJ�[1X78WHKJ1@BAl� DIA/@^FP@BDWA/@BDZ>�".Ua:YFPUaD/@BDZ>��DIHNM?b7[L<E[

UaD [#FIV/@^J1@BACAIHK>1H � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �Cn �n �1-���� !�J1U���@B_`>1<EUaDd!�8WJL[18W<?>)qs!�!�t � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �Cn �

n ��/ �UaDWME<ED/@BHKJ0]N@BDW@^JLHK>1<?jN@\:=U7A/@BM [)� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �3�Nnn ��/ �Ep ��U7_^HNM���<ED/@BHKJ�HKFIFWJ1UaHN_LV�/�� < 7>18/JL@B[0UNO ��@BD/@^JLHK>1<?jN@e�dU'A/@BME[�� � � � � � � � � � � � � �3�2�n ��/ � n � 7FIM <E_^<?>0�$UaD��k��<ED/@BHKJ��FWFWJLUaHN_LV�� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �3�$-

n ��/ � n �Ep ��@BD/@^JLHK>1<EjN@\��UNF UN]NJhHKFIVW<E_��,HKFWFI<ED/]iq ���$� t � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �3�2/n ��0 ".UaDW_^M 8W[1<?UaD � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �3�54

6 7 & � # � ��8 & * � &:9;+ #*) (�, #,+<+ �=�?> (A@ #CB � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �3�2�� �Ep ��V/@)�@B_`>#UNJ4�7FIHN_`@�qQ)�Wt0�U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>$� U7AW@BM � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �3� �

� �Ep �Ep ".Ua:l:YUaDCFWJ1U'_`@BAW8/JL@B[�OgUNJ�FIJ1@^FWJ1U'_`@B[1[1<EDW] � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ��-Wp� �Ep �Ep �Ep �7>#UNF�� �.UNJLAW[0JL@B:YU jKHNM � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ��-Wp� �Ep �Ep � n �7>#@B:=:=< D/] � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ��-Wp� �Ep �Ep ��� DP<?FWO�� [0M H � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ��-Wp

� � n ��HK>#@BDZ>��'@B:=HNDT>1< _4�DIHNM?b7[L<E[)qs���'�)t � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ��-Tn� ��� �,< 7>18WJ1@4:YU'A/@BME[�UNO�>#@� 7> � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ��-2-

� ��� �Ep ��HN<?jN@*��HBbN@B[Yqs����t�:YU'A/@BME[�� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ��-2-� ��� �Ep �Ep ��V/@4��<ED/Ua:l<EHNMP� DIA/@^FP@BDWA/@BDW_`@��dU'A/@BM�qs�.��� t$� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ��-C/� ��� �Ep � n ��V/@4�,8WM?>1<EDWUa:=<EHNMP�dU'A/@BM � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ��-C0

j7<

Page 7: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

� ��� � n �,< '>18/J1@=:YU'A/@BM�OQUNJ*A/baHNAW<E_YAIHK>1H�/*!&J1UN9;HK9I<EME<E[1>1<E_*��HK>#@BDT>Y�7@B:=HNDZ>1<E_Y�DIHNM?b7[L<E[qs!����'�)t � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ��- 4

� �1- ��< D/@BHKJ��1"�� HKFIFWJ1UaHN_LVW@B[�>#U=>1V/@)>#@� '>AWUa:=HN<ED � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ��-C�� ��/ n �k� >#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVI<E_):=HKFI[0UNO�>#@� '>�/�� �����W��� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ��-C�� ��0 "�VWHNM M?@BD/]N@B[�HNDWAC� UN>1<?jKHK>1<?UaD�� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �3/Ko

� � � (��*9 �<� # , 7 & � # � � � +<& - - & � , *'& �(� ) (�,.#,+ @ ( * ��� # � � &:+ %�- � - & � , 8 � - !�&A+ ��� & �'� ( �(A@� � -�#0*�# � #�3& � & � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �3/2�-��Ep ��DT>#J1U'AW8W_`>1<EUaD � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �3/$--�� n ��@BD/@^JhHNM OQUNJL:\8IMEHK>1<?UaDGUNO�>1V/@4FWJ1UN9;HK9I<EME<E[1>1<E_�]N@BD/@^JhHK>1<?jN@\:YU'A/@BM�� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �3/2/

-�� n �Ep � U7AW@BMEME<ED/] >1V/@4M HK>#@BDT>�jKHKJL<EHK9;M?@ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �3/20-�� n �Ep �Ep ��V/@4MEHK>#@BDZ>$_^MEHN[L[�:YU'A/@BM � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �3/20-�� n �Ep � n ��V/@4MEHK>#@BDZ>�>#JLHN<E>�:YU7AW@BM.� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �3/54

-�� n � n ��<E[#>#Jh<?9I8/>1<?UaDIHNM HN[L[18W:YFW>1<EUaDW[.U jN@^J�>1V/@*D/Ua<E[1@�:=U7A/@BM�� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �3/ �-�� n ��� ��VW@4[#>1HK>#@\[#F;HN_`@4OgUNJh: UNO�>1VW@*:YU'A/@BM�� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �30Ko

-���� ��V/@4��� [#UaME8/>1<?UaD � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �30'p-���� �Ep ��HK>#@BDT>���JLHN<E>�[#UaME8/>1<?UaD � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �30Nn-���� � n ��HK>#@BDT>)"�MEHN[1[0[#UaM 8/>1<?UaD$� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �302�-���� ��� ��VW@4HNM?]NUNJL<?>1VW: � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �30$--���� �1- ��:YFIME< _^HK>1<?UaDGUNO�AIHK>1H=[#FIHKJL[1@BD/@B[1[�<EDG]N@BDW@^JLHK>1<?jN@\_^M HN[1[�:YU'A/@BMEME< D/] � � � � � � � � � � �3020

-��1- !�HKJ1>1<E_^8WM HKJ$_^HN[#@B[$< DC:YU7AW@BMEME<ED/] AW<E[L_`J1@^>#@4AWHK>1H � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �3054-��1-��Ep ��VW@)� DWAW@^F @BDIA/@BDT>0�.@^JLD/Ua8IMEME<P�$Ua< [#@4�dU'A/@BM � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �302�-��1-�� n ��VW@)� DWAW@^F @BDIA/@BDT>0!�Ua<E[1[1UaDi�$Ua< [#@4�dU'A/@BM � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 4 o-��1-���� ��VW@4� 8WME>1<ED/Ua:=<EHNMP�Ua<E[#@4� U7AW@BM � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 4 o-��1-��1- ��@� 7>AWHK>1Hl:YU'A/@BMEM <ED/] � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 47p

-���/ � 'FP@^JL<E:Y@BDZ>1HNMf �@B[L8WM?>1[ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 4Kn-���/ �Ep ��U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[$AWHK>1H=:l<EDW<ED/]�� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 4 �-���/ � n ��<?]a<?>1[$AWHK>1H=_`Ua:YFWJL@B[1[1<?UaDiHNDIAGj7<E[L8WHNME<E[1HK>1<EUaD � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 4 0

-���0 ".UaDW_^M 8W[1<?UaDW[�� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 424

� ( � ( > *$&�� �?� # 8 � -'!�&:+ � -�& �$� ( � (A@�� � & � # � (A+=! �'� ( � �=� #���� ( *'&A+<+ % � ( � # * # � � �3& � & �2// �Ep ��DT>#J1U'AW8W_`>1<EUaD � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �3�20

/ �Ep �Ep ��<EAWA/@BDC�,HKJ��NU ji�dU'A/@BME[*qs���,� t � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �3�54/ �Ep � n ���$� �$V/J1Ua8/]aVC��< :Y@!�&��HK>#@BDZ>$��JLHN<?>�� U7A/@BM [0>1V/J1Ua8/]aVd��<E:Y@ � � � � � � � � � � � �3� �

/ � n ��UNF UN]NJhHKFIVW<E_�j'<E[18WHNM <E[1HK>1<?UaD�UNO�>#@B:YFPUNJLHNMEM?b�_`UaV/@^J1@BDZ>$AWHK>1H � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �"�'p/ � n �Ep �<E[18WHNM <E[1HK>1<?UaD � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �"�$-

/ ��� ��<E[1_^8W[L[1<?UaD � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �"�2// �1- �'<E:e8WMEHK>1<EUaDW[�� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �"�54

/ �1-��Ep �<E[18WHNM <E[1<ED/]e��UNF;<E_)�&jNUaME8W>1<?UaDi<EDd".UaVW@^J1@BDT>��@� '>��7>#J1@BHN:l[ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �"�54/ �1-��Ep �Ep ��b7DWHN:l<E_)��@� '>$��HK>1H � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �"�54/ �1-��Ep � n �< [18WHNME<E[L<ED/]\�@��$[#]NJLUa8/FI[�� @B[1[1HK]N@B[ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �"�54/ �1-��Ep ��� �< [18WHNME<E[L<ED/]\H�"�VWHK>�7@B[1[L<?UaD � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �`p^oan

/ �1-�� n ��DWHK@B[#>1V/@B[L<EH=AWHK>1H � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �`p^o -/ ��/ ".UaDW_^M 8W[1<?UaDW[�HNDWAiOQ8/>18WJ1@ ��UNJ�� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �`p^o5/

� ( � � #�� #��;& *'& �'� ( � & � , "$#&%�')(+*�, � , # � �'��� #5& �'� ( � �=� 7 & � # � � ��#�� & � �'� # ��� , # B�# ,��( #C!�� # � � � (A+=+ # # �$� ( � -�� � � * (�� # # �'� ( � � ���.*�(:&:# � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �`pNp�/0 �Ep ��DT>#J1U'AW8W_`>1<EUaD � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �`pNp�00 � n ��HK>1Hl!�J1@^FWJ1U'_`@B[1[1<EDW]e97bG>1V/@4��HK>#@BDZ>��'@B:=HNDT>1< _) �@^FWJ1@B[1@BDT>1HK>1<?UaDdUNO�>1V/@\".UNJ1FI8I[ � � � � � �`pNp��0 ��� �7@^FIHKJhHK>1<ED/] �7@B:=HNDZ>1<E_ !IHN_`>#UNJL[$OQJ1Ua: Hl�U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>�".UNJLFI8W[$� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �`pNp �

0 ��� �Ep ��VW@\� �N@��$D/@B[1[$�.HN[1@BA,��9��#@B_`>1<?jN@ !I8WDW_`>1<?UaD � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �`pBnKo

j'<E<

Page 8: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

0 �1- "�ME8I[#>#@^JL<ED/]Y��U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[�97bC�7@^F;HKJLHK>1<ED/]=��UNFI<E_ !/@BHK>18WJ1@B[�OQJ1Ua: ��UNJLA�� !/@BHK>18/J1@B[�� � � � � �`pBn2�0 ��/ ".Ua:\9I<EDW< D/] >1V/@)> �.Ul>1HN[��'[$< DCHY[1<ED/]aM?@4HNME]NUNJL<?>1VW: � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �`pBn2�

0 ��/ �Ep �'8I:=:=HKJ1b � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �`p��Nn0 ��0 �'<E:e8WMEHK>1<EUaDC �@B[18WME>1[ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �`p��2�0 � 4 �@BM HK>1<?UaDC>#U��7b':=:Y@^>#Jh<E_^HNMf��@B_`Ua:YFPUa[1<?>1<?UaDi��@B_LVIDW<EX78/@B[0OQUNJ$��@� '>$��DWHNM?b'[1<E[ � � � � � � � � �`p��20

0 � 4 �Ep �UaD��kD/@^]aHK>1<?jN@e:=HK>#JL< GOsHN_`>#UNJL<E[1HK>1<?UaD � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �`p��540 � 4 � n !�J1UN9IHK9I<EM <E[#>1<E_���HK>#@BDZ>��7@B:=HNDZ>1<E_4��DWHNM?b'[1<E[ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �`p��540 � 4 ��� ��<E[1_^8I[1[1<?UaD � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �`p��540 � 4 �1- �'< :\8WM HK>1<?UaDW[ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �`p��2�

0 � 4 �1-��Ep ��@� '>$AWHK>1H �$<?>1V �.@BMEM �k[#@^FIHKJhHK9IM?@)_^MEHN[1[[#>#JL8W_`>18/JL@ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �`p��2�0 � 4 �1-�� n !WHN_`>#UNJL< %B< D/]lD/UaD��k[1@^FIHKJLHK9IM?@)>#@� '>$AWHK>1H � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �`p�� �

0 ��� ".UaDW_^M 8W[1<?UaDW[�� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �`p.-C�

� � ! � � & * % & � , � ( � #C+=! - � ( � -� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �`p.-C�4 �Ep ".UaDW_^M 8WAW<ED/]eJ1@B:=HKJ��7[ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �`p.-C�4 � n !W8/JL>1V/@^J<EDZjN@B[#>1<?]aHK>1<EUaDW[ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �`p.- �

���� ���� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �`p�/'p

83� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �`p�0Ko

j7<E< <

Page 9: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

��� ��� � � � � ��� � � �

� �<> !.*�# � & > #

n �Ep �7FI<EJLHNMPAWHK>1H�� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �3�Nnn � n ��MEME8W[#>#JhHK>1<?UaD�UNO�>1VW@*D/UaD��kME< D/@BHKJ�]N@BD/@^JLHK>1<?jN@e:=HKFWFI<EDW]e<ED�)��� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �3�2/

-��Ep ".UNJ1JL@BMEHK>1<?UaD _`UaDT>#Ua8/Jh[\UNO�< DWAW<?j'<EAW8WHNM�FPUa[1[1<E9IM?@=MEHK>#@BDZ>\jN@B_`>#UNJh[Y_`UNJ1J1@B[#FPUaDWAW< D/]C>#U >1VW@]NJL<EAGFPUa<EDZ>1[0UNO�UaD/@4J1U ��UNO�>1V/@)]NJL<EA m'AW@`R;D/@BAG97b�>1VW@4D/UaDWME<EDW@BHKJBm/8WDW<?>.j HKJh<EHNDW_`@4JLHNAI<EHNM9IHN[1< [0jN@B_`>#UNJL[���qQUaD/@*_`UaDZ>#Ua8/J<E[�UaDW@4J1@B[1VWHKFP@BAGJ1U �-UNO�>1V/@*:=HK>#Jh< ������dt � � � � � � � � � �3/2�

-�� n !�Ua[#>#@^JL<?UNJ�:Y@BHNDW[&FWJ1U j'<EA/@BA=9Zb >1V/@$AI< � @^JL@BDT>�FWJLUN9IHK9I<EME< [#>1<E_.MEHK>#@BDT>�>#JLHN<?>&HNM?]NUNJh<?>1VW:=[�UaD>#JLHN<EDI<ED/] AWHK>1HY8W[1<EDW]�-=AW< [#>1<EDW_`>�A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>�_^M HN[1[#@B[0OQJ1Ua: >1V/@*nKo��k�@��$[#]NJ1Ua8WFI[�_`UNJ1FI8I[�/� � [L_^< � _`J1b7FW>��?m�U � [L_^< � :Y@BA(�?m � � [1_^< � [1FIHN_`@ ��HNDWA�� � [#U7_ � JL@BME<?]a<?UaD�� _hV/JL<E[1>1<EHND(� ���V/@ JL<E]aVT>CFIMEUN>1[�[LV/U � >1VW@ _`UNJ1J1@B[#FPUaDWAW< D/]rJ1@B[L8WM?>1[G<?O\8I[1<ED/] >1V/@�>1V/@^UNJ1@^>1< _^HNMEM?b�DWUN>HKFWFWJLUNFWJL<EHK>#@�9I8/>�FWJLHN_`>1<E_^HNMEMEb=:YUNJ1@�[1<E:YFIME@$UNJL<?]a< DWHNM ��HN8I[1[1<EHND"����� HNM?]NUNJL<?>1VW: ���$V/@[1HN:Y@\MEHK>#@BDT>[#@^>#>1<ED/]a[HNDWAGFIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^J�<EDW<?>1< HNME< %BHK>1<?UaDW[��.@^J1@*8W[#@BAiOgUNJ�@BHN_hV :=U7A/@BM � � � � � 4 �

-���� !�Ua[#>#@^JL<?UNJ�:Y@BHNDW[&FWJ1U j'<EA/@BA=9Zb >1V/@$AI< � @^JL@BDT>�FWJLUN9IHK9I<EME< [#>1<E_.MEHK>#@BDT>�>#JLHN<?>&HNM?]NUNJh<?>1VW:=[�UaD>#@B[#>*AIHK>1H�8I[1<ED/]�-iAW<E[#>1< DW_`>A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>4_^MEHN[1[1@B[�OgJ1Ua: >1VW@YnKo��k�@��$[#]NJLUa8/FI[4_`UNJ1F;8W[�/ � [1_^< � _`J1bZFI>��?mWU � [1_^< � :Y@BA(�?m�� � [L_^< � [#FIHN_`@ � HNDWA�� � [#U'_ � J1@BME<E]a<?UaD�� _LVWJL<E[#>1<EHND �'�$V/@[1HN:Y@\MEHK>#@BDT>[#@^>#>1<ED/]a[HNDWAGFIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^J�<EDW<?>1< HNME< %BHK>1<?UaDW[��.@^J1@*8W[#@BAiOgUNJ�@BHN_hV :=U7A/@BM � � � � � 4 �

-��1- ��JLHN<EDW<EDW]dHNDWA >#@B[#>eAIHK>1HdJ1@B[L8WM?>1[ �<?>1V >1V/@G:e8WM?>1<ED/Ua:l<EHNM&:YU'A/@BM&UaD >#@� '> AIHK>1H 8W[L<ED/]VW<?]aVW@^J*AW<E:Y@BDI[1<?UaDWHNM�AW<E_`>1<EUaDWHKJ1b6q 0Ko5054C>#@^JL:l[^m�_hV/Ua[#@BD 9Zb �N@^@^FI< D/]i>#@^JL:=[��$VW<E_hV U7_ �_^8/J1JL@BAi:YUNJ1@)>1VWHND / >1<E:Y@B[�< DG>1V/@4>#@� '>ht � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �3�Ko

-���/ ".Ua:YF;HKJLHK>1<?jN@ FPUa[#>#@^JL<EUNJd:Y@BHNDW[CFIJ1U j'<EA/@BA 97b >1V/@ �.@^JLD/Ua8WMEM <)HNDWA :\8IM?>1<ED/Ua:=< HNM�M H��>#@BDZ>4>#JLHN<?>)HNM?]NUNJL<E>1VW: UaD > �.UiU jN@^JhMEHKFWFI<EDW]�q � � _`Ua:=F�� [#b'[�� <?9I:�� Ff_ � VWHKJhA��.HKJL@ �?mfU � _`Ua:YF�� [1b7[�� :lHN_ � VWHKJLA���HKJ1@ � t�HNDWAYUaD/@$AI<E[#>1<EDW_`>�q�� � [1_^< � :Y@BA � t�_^MEHN[1[#@B[�HNDWA=<EDI[#FP@B_`>1<ED/][#Ua:Y@*UNO�>1VW@)]NJL<EAGFPUa<EDZ>1[0OgUNJ$>1V/@4:YUa[#>�FIJ1UN9IHK9IM?@ �.UNJLAW[�� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �3�'p

-���0 ��V/@,:YUa[#> FWJ1UN9IHK9IME@���UNJLAI[=OQUNJL:Y@BAc< D @BHN_LV UNO)>1V/@ p^o 97b�p^o ]NJL< A FPUa<EDZ>1[Y9Zb6>1VW@9I<EDWUa:=<EHNM4MEHK>#@BDZ> >#JLHN<?>,:YU7AW@BM*UaD > �.U U jN@^JLMEHKFIFI<ED/](q � _`Ua:YF�� [#b'[�� <?9I: � FP_ � VIHKJLA���HKJ1@ �?m� _`Ua:YF�� [1b7[�� :lHN_ � VWHKJLA���HKJ1@ � t�HNDWAYUaD/@�AW<E[#>1<EDI_`>0q � [L_^< � :Y@BA(� t�_^M HN[1[#@B[&UNOfAW< [1_^8W[1[1<EUaDW[�OgJLUa:>1V/@4nKo �$@��[#]NJ1Ua8/FI[._`UaMEM?@B_`>1<EUaD���nKoNo A/U7_^8I:Y@BDT>1[��.@^J1@�>1H �N@BDGOgJLUa: @BHN_hVi_^MEHN[1[^m7U jN@^JHAW<E_`>1<EUaDWHKJ1b�UNO.p�/Kol>#@^JL:=[�� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �3�Nn

-�� 4 ��V/@,:YUa[#> FWJ1UN9IHK9IME@���UNJLAI[=OQUNJL:Y@BAc< D @BHN_LV UNO)>1V/@ p^o 97b�p^o ]NJL< A FPUa<EDZ>1[Y9Zb6>1VW@:e8WM?>1<ED/Ua:l<EHNMIMEHK>#@BDZ>�>#JLHN<?>0:YU'A/@BM;UaD > ��UYU jN@^JLMEHKFWF;<ED/]Cq � _`Ua:YF�� [#b'[�� <?9I: � FP_ � VIHKJLA���HKJ1@ �?m� _`Ua:YF�� [1b7[�� :lHN_ � VWHKJLA���HKJ1@ � t�HNDWAYUaD/@�AW<E[#>1<EDI_`>0q � [L_^< � :Y@BA(� t�_^M HN[1[#@B[&UNOfAW< [1_^8W[1[1<EUaDW[�OgJLUa:>1V/@4nKo �$@��[#]NJ1Ua8/FI[._`UaMEM?@B_`>1<EUaD���nKoNo A/U7_^8I:Y@BDT>1[��.@^J1@�>1H �N@BDGOgJLUa: @BHN_hVi_^MEHN[1[^m7U jN@^JHAW<E_`>1<EUaDWHKJ1b�UNO.p�/Kol>#@^JL:=[�� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �3�2�

-���� ��V/@)UN9;[#@^J1jN@BAdAIHK>1H � �Y<EDI[#>1HNDW_`@B[0OQJ1Ua: @BHN_hVd_^MEHN[1[ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �3�$--�� � !�Ua[#>#@^JL<?UNJe:Y@BHNDW[)FIJ1U j'<EA/@BA 97b >1VW@l�.@^JLD/Ua8WMEM <�>#JLHN<E>*HNM?]NUNJL<?>1VI: UaD HiAWHK>1H��k[#@^>��$VW<E_hV

_`UaDW[1< [#>#@BA=UNOfVWHNDWA ��JL<?>#>#@BD=AI<?]a<?>1[�HNDWA <EDW[#FP@B_`>1<?UaD UNOPJ1@^OQ@^J1@BDW_`@jN@B_`>#UNJL[�< D=[#Ua:Y@UNO >1VW@]NJL<EAiF Ua< DT>1[��� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �3�$-

<

Page 10: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

-��Ep^o ��V/@,:=HKFcUNO*J1@^Og@^JL@BDW_`@��k<E:=HK]N@B[ qs< � @!�?m�>1V/@ J1@B[1VWHKFP@BA��&q������KtYjKHNME8/@B[Bm��V/@^J1@���q t=< [_`Ua:YFPUaD/@BDZ> � �$<E[#@ [1<?]a:YUa<EA Os8WDW_`>1<EUaD <ED6>1VW< [Y_^HN[#@ HNDWA�� p �Ep^oNoTtlOgUNJh:Y@BA6UaD >1VW@RIJL[1>�R;jN@�VIHNDWA���JL<E>#>#@BD AW<E]a<?>1[�_^MEHN[1[#@B[��&�@B<?]aVZ9PUNJ0]NJL<EA�FPUa<EDT>1[�VWH jN@4[1<E:=< MEHKJ�J1@^OQ@^J1@BDW_`@��<E:=HK]N@B[ �e��VW@ :=UNJ1FIVW<EDW]l9P@^> �.@^@BD�>1V/@ J1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>1HK>1<EUaD UNO�>1V/@YAW<E]a<?>1[�<E:=HK]N@B[)<E[):YUa[1>HKFWFIHKJL@BDT>�� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �3�$-

/ �Ep �<E[18WHNME< [1HK>1<?UaD�J1@B[18IM?>1[PUN9W>1HN<ED/@BA*UaD���DW@��$[#]NJ1Ua8/F;[f8W[1<ED/]0>1VW@�RIJL[#>PR;jN@����'� OQ@BHK>18/J1@B[ 97bAW< �P@^J1@BDZ>0@� '< [#>1<ED/]ej7< [18WHNME<E[LHK>1<?UaD HNME]NUNJL<?>1VW:=[4qQ@BHN_hVd[#b':\9 UaMP_`UNJ1JL@B[#FPUaDWAW[�>#UYUaD/@4:Y@B[��[1HK]N@ t ����V/@&_^M HN[1[#@B[ �� _`Ua:YF�� [#b'[�� <?9I: � FP_ � VIHKJLA���HKJ1@ �^HNDWA�� �� _`Ua:YF � [#b7[ � :=HN_ � VWHKJLA���HKJ1@ �HKJ1@.[#>#J1UaD/]aM?b�U jN@^JLMEHKFWFI< D/] �$VW< M?@ � �� [L_^< � :Y@BA(� < [ :[email protected]<E[#>1<EDI_`>����[�>1V/@B[#@.HNM?]NUNJL<?>1VW:l[�.@^J1@*A/@B[1<E]aD/@BAGOgUNJ< � < � A���AWHK>1H'm;>1V/@^b�_^HND D/UN>�:=H �N@e8W[#@)UNO�>1V/@)>#@B:YFPUNJLHNMfUNJLAW@^JL<ED/] UNO>1V/@*AIHK>1H=HNDWACOsHN<EMP>#Ul[#@^F;HKJLHK>#@4>1V/@4>#UNF;<E_)_^MEHN[1[#@B[<EDG>1V/@B<?J�M HK>#@BDT>�JL@^FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaD�� � � � �`p^oC4

/ � n !�Ua[#>#@^JL<?UNJG:Y@BHNDW[lU jN@^J�>1V/@i]NJL< A6FPUa<EDT>1[=UN9W>1HN<ED/@BA697b >1V/@iFWJLUNF Ua[1@BA :YU'A/@BM0UaD >1VW@[1HN:Y@,AWHK>1H HN[�<ED !�<?]���/ �Ep � �M M�>1V/J1@^@d_^MEHN[L[#@B[lHKJ1@,D/U � [#@^FIHKJLHK>#@BA�HNDWA :Y@BHNDI<ED/]NOs8WM>#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVW< _^HNM J1@BMEHK>1<EUaDW[$HKJ1@e<EDWAW8I_`@BA�����VW@4>#JLH �#@B_`>#UNJ1biUNO�>1V/@B[#@\U jN@^J�>1<E:Y@\<E[0>#JLHN_`@BAHN[ �.@BMEM&qs_`UaDZ>1<ED78/Ua8W[$M <ED/@ t ����HN_hVdA/UN>$[1>1HNDWAW[0OQUNJ�UaD/@*:=@B[1[1HK]N@!� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �`p^o5�

/ ��� !�Ua[#>#@^JL<?UNJ :Y@BHNDW[\UN9W>1HN<EDW@BA UaD p^o _^MEHN[L[#@B[4UNO�AW< [1_^8W[1[1<EUaDW[�OgJLUa: >1V/@�nKo��k�$@��$[1]NJ1Ua8/FI[_`UNJ1FI8I[.q �� HNM?>�� HK>1V/@B<E[L:"�?mKU �� _`Ua:YF�� ]NJLHKFIVI<E_^[��?m�� �� _`Ua:YF�� Ua[�� :l[ � �$<EDWAWU �$[�� :l<E[1_ �?m���� _`Ua:YF � [#b7[ � <?9I:�� Ff_ � VWHKJLA �.HKJ1@ �?m�� �� _`Ua:YF�� [1b7[�� :lHN_ � VWHKJLA���HKJ1@ �?m�� �� _`Ua:YF � �$<EDWA/U �$[�� �?m���� :l<E[1_ � OQUNJL[1HNM?@ �?m�� �� [1_^< � @BME@B_`>#J1UaDW<E_^[��?m � �� [1_^< � :Y@BA(� HNDWA�� �� [1_^< � [#F;HN_`@ � t �l��D[#FI<E>#@\UNO�>1V/@e[1>#J1UaD/]aM?biU jN@^JLMEHKFWF;<ED/] DIHK>18/J1@ UNO&>1V/@YAWHK>1H�qQ@!� ]��*_`Ua:YF;8/>#@^J�� J1@BMEHK>#@BA AW< [ �_^8W[1[L<?UaDW[hthm&>1VW@B<?JYJ1@^FWJ1@B[1@BDT>1HK>1<?UaD6< [e< DWA/@^@BA :Y@BHNDW<EDW]NOQ8WM �r��HN_hV A/UN>Y_`UNJ1J1@B[#FPUaDWAI[\>#UUaD/@*:=@B[1[1HK]N@!�� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �`p^o��

/ �1- !�Ua[#>#@^JL<?UNJ :Y@BHNDW[\UN9W>1HN<EDW@BA UaD :Y@B[1[1HK]N@B[\OgJLUa: -,D/@��$[#]NJ1Ua8WFI[lqQ>#JLHN<EDI<ED/]iAWHK>1H�/ U � [1_^< � _`JLbZFW>��?m � �� [L_^< � [#FIHN_`@ �?m � �� [1_^< � :Y@BA(�?m! �� [#U'_ � J1@BME<?]a<EUaD�� _LV/Jh<E[#>1<EHND(��".>#@B[#>1<EDW]AWHK>1H�/�� #� [1_^< � _`JLbZFW>��?m$� #� [1_^< � [1FIHN_`@ �� %� [1_^< � :Y@BA(�&� #� [#U7_ � JL@BME<?]a<?UaD�� _hV/JL<E[1>1<EHND(� t�$V/@BDr>1V/@l>#UNF;<E_^[4J1@BHKFIF @BHKJe<ED�>1<E:=@!/\9I< DW[)UNO4p^oNo,_`UaDW[#@B_^8/>1<?jN@�[1HN:YFIME@l<EDW[#>1HNDI_`@B[4UNO>1V/@�[1HN:Y@)_^MEHN[1[��.@^J1@�OgUNJL:=@BAfmZ>1V78W[�@BHN_LVC_^HK>#@^]NUNJ1bGHKFWFP@BHKJ1@BA > �$< _`@�AW8WJL<ED/]4>1VW@>#JLHN< D��<ED/]�� ��VW<E[�_`UaDZ>1<EDZ8I<?>kb UNO�p^oNod<EDW[1>1HNDW_`@B[ �$<?>1V JL@BMEHK>1<?jN@BM?b V/Ua:YUN]N@BD/@^Ua8I[*_`UaDZ>#@BDT> �.HN[[1<E:e8WMEHK>1< D/]=>1V/@\>1<E:Y@��k_`UaV/@^J1@BDI_`@ < Di>1V/@eAWHK>1H HNDIAd>1V/@\>#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVW<E_^HNM�[#>#JL8I_`>18/J1@*>1VIHK>VWHN[�9P@^@BDG<ED/OQ@^J1J1@BA 9Zb >1V/@)HNM?]NUNJL<?>1VI: FP@^JL:l<?>#>#@BA <E>.>#U � J1@B_`UN]aDI< %^@ �W>1V/@�J1@��kHKFWFP@BHKJLHNDI_`@UNO&>1V/@ [1HN:Y@ _^HK>#@^]NUNJ1b!����DW[#>1HNDW_`@B[�OQJ1Ua: H FWJ1@^j'<?Ua8W[LM?b�[1@^@BD,_^HK>#@^]NUNJLb HKJ1@ :=HKFWFP@BAd< D>1V/@4[1HN:=@4J1@^]a<?UaDCHN[0>1VW@4<EDW[#>1HNDW_`@B[�OQJ1Ua: >1VW@4[1HN:Y@4_^HK>#@^]NUNJ1b��$VI<E_LV �.@^J1@*[#@^@BDC<EDG>1VW@FIHN[#>�����VW<E[�FWJLUNF @^JL>kbG<E[�FIHKJ1>1<E_^8IMEHKJLM?bl8I[#@^OQ8IMf<EDG>#UNFI<E_�>#JLHN_��7< D/]lHKFWFIM <E_^HK>1<?UaDW[�� � � � � � � �`pNp^o

/ ��/ !�Ua[#>#@^JL<?UNJG:Y@BHNDW[=UaD >1V/@d[LHN:Y@ AWHK>1HrHN[l<ED !�<?]�� / �1-�� FWJ1U j'<EA/@BA 97b >1V/@iFWJLUNF Ua[1@BA>#@B:YFPUNJLHNM HNME]NUNJL<?>1VW:Cm��$VW@BDG>1V/@*:Y@B[1[LHK]N@B[ �.@^J1@)JLHNDWA/Ua:lM?blFP@^JL:e8/>#@BA�����[0@� 7FP@B_`>#@BAfmD/U*[1>#JL8W_`>18/J1@0<E[�_^HKFI>18/J1@BA=<ED >1VI<E[�_^HN[#@Nm'[1<EDW_`@0<ED >1V/@$FWJ1UNFPUa[#@BAY:YU'A/@BM'>1V/@0>#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVZb<E[�HNDiUa8/>1_`Ua:Y@*UNO�>1V/@*_`UaVW@^J1@BDW_`@*<EDG>1< :Y@!����HN_hVdA/UN>�_`UNJLJ1@B[#FPUaDWAW[�>#U=UaDW@*:Y@B[1[1HK]N@!� � �`pNpNp

/ ��0 ��<E:=@ @^jNUaME8W>1<?UaD UNO*>1V/@,FPUa[#>#@^JL<?UNJL[G<ED _`UaDW[#@B_^8W>1<?jN@ >1<E:Y@,F Ua< DT>1[G<ED H >1<E:Y@,OgJLHN:=@Nm_`UaDZ>1HN<EDW<ED/]6H _LVIHND/]N@�UNO*>1V/@,>#UNFI<E_,UNOeAW<E[1_^8W[L[1<?UaD OQJ1Ua: � ]N@BD/@^JLHNM�FPUaME<E>1<E_^[���>#U � ]a8WD_`UaDZ>#J1UaM � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �`pNpNp

/ � 4 ��<E:=@@^jNUaME8W>1<?UaDGUNO�>1V/@�FPUa[#>#@^JL<EUNJL[�<EDGH\>1< :Y@�OgJLHN:=@�_`UaDI_`@BDT>#JLHK>#@BAdHKJ1Ua8WDWA�UaD/@)[1<EDW]aM?@>#UNFI<E_ q � �'8W[1HNDd�':l<?>1V(� t � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �`pNpNp

/ ��� n �k� :=HKFWF;<ED/],UNO>1V/@i_hVWHK>=[#>#J1@BHN: UN9W>1HN<ED/@BA 97b >1VW@�FPUa[#>#@^Jh<?UNJ=:Y@BHNDW[�� ��V/@C:=HN< D>#UNFI<E_^[�_^HNDl9P@�_hVWHKJLHN_`>#@^JL< %^@BAGHN[�/ '� �/8W[1HND �':l<?>1V(�?m � (� ��8WD _`UaDT>#J1UaM;<EDY>1V/@+�� � � �?m� )� "�ME<EDZ>#UaDCHNDWAi]N@BDW@^JLHNMfFPUaME<?>1<E_^[0< DG>1V/@*+�� � � �IHNDWACU *� �(ME<?>#>1M?@)9PU b���ME<EHND �$V/Ua[1@OsHK>1V/@^JME<EjN@BAC<EDd"�8/9IH � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �`pNpBn

/ � � ��V/@dJ1@^FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaD�UNO)>1V/@d_hVWHK>�[1@B[1[1<?UaDfm0< � @!� >1V/@dOQ8WM M0]NJL<EA6UNO�J1@^OQ@^J1@BDW_`@ jN@B_`>#UNJL[��+F�>#UG[1Ua:Y@YD/Ua<E[#@Nmf_^HN8W[#@BA,97b MEHN_��dUNO�_`UaVW@^J1@BDW_`@=<ED,[#Ua:Y@ FPUa<EDZ>1[$UNO�>1V/@YAW<E[1_^8W[L[1<?UaD[#>#J1@BHN:im'He>#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVI<E_^HNMIUNJL]aHNDW<E[1HK>1<?UaD UNO >1V/@�[18/9���@B_`>1[.UNO�AW< [1_^8W[1[1<EUaD=_^HND�9 @�UN9I[#@^JLjN@BA�� pNp��

Page 11: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

/ �Ep^o !�Ua[#>#@^JL<?UNJ):Y@BHNDI[U jN@^J)>1V/@e]NJL<EA F Ua< DT>1[$UN9W>1HN<ED/@BA 9Zbd>1V/@e[1>1HK>1<E_ �)��� HNM?]NUNJL<E>1VW: UaD>#JLHN<EDI<ED/]i[#@BX78/@BDW_`@ UNO������ AWHK>1H��i��JLHN_^<ED/]i>1VW@=>#JLH �#@B_`>#UNJ1b U jN@^J >1<E:=@ ��Ua8IMEA�J1@B[18IM?><ED HND 8IDW_^M?@BHKJ*F;M?UN>^m�HN[eAIHK>1H <E[\[#@^@BD HN[\< � < � A��i97b�>1VW<E[\:YU7AW@BM � q � � H ��H �N@ �&HNDWA U � HN[1ME@^@^F � t�� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �`pNp.-

/ �EpNp !�Ua[#>#@^JL<?UNJ.:Y@BHNDW[�U jN@^J�>1VW@�]NJL<EA FPUa<EDZ>1[�UN9W>1HN<ED/@BA=9Zbe>1V/@�FWJLUNF Ua[1@BAY:YU7AW@BM'UaD=>#JLHN<EDI<ED/]HNDWAl>#@B[#>�[#@BX78/@BDW_`@B[�UNOP������AWHK>1H��&��V/@0>#JLH �#@B_`>#UNJ1bYUNOP>1V/@B[#@U jN@^J.>1<E:Y@�<E[&>#JLHN_`@BA �$<E>1V_`UaDZ>1<EDZ8WUa8W[$ME< D/@B[��0q � *� H �.H �N@ �PHNDWACU *� HN[LM?@^@^F � t � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �`pNp.-

0 �Ep �7@^FIHKJhHK>1<ED/]=[#@B:=HNDZ>1<E_)OsHN_`>#UNJL[eqQFWJ1UN>#UN>kb7FP@��kA/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[ht�OQJ1Ua: H=AWU7_^8W:=@BDT>�_`UNJ1F;8W[�� � � �`pBnKo0 � n �7@^FIHKJhHK>1<ED/]Y>#UNFI<E_ � OQ@BHK>18/J1@B[$OgJLUa: ��UNJhA�� Og@BHK>18WJ1@B[$<EDCHlA/U7_^8I:Y@BDT>�_`UNJLFI8W[)� � � � � � � � � � �`pBn2�0 ��� "�VWHKJhHN_`>#@^JL<E[#>1<E_�[1VWHKFP@�UNO�n �k� ���/� FWJ1U��#@B_`>1<?UaD UNO$H A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ> [1@^> _`UaDZ>1HN<EDW< D/] > ��U

AW<E[1>1<EDW_`>�>#UNFI<E_4_^M HN[1[#@B[*q � _`J1b7FW>#UN]NJLHKF;VTb �IHNDWA � [1FIHN_`@ � t � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �`pBn540 �1- ��@^FP@BDWA/@BDW_`bG[#>#JL8W_`>18WJ1@)UNO�>1V/@4[#FIME<E>#>1<ED/] <EDC��HK9;M?@*n � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �`p��2/0 ��/ � _`UNJ1FI8W[�UNO�OgUa8WJ�A/U7_^8I:Y@BDT>0_^MEHN[L[#@B[^mW<EDW<E>1<EHNMEM?b FWJ1U��#@B_`>#@BAi<EDGH > ��U �kAW< :Y@BDW[1<?UaDIHNMf���'�

[#FIHN_`@ HNDWAdJ1@B_^8/JL[1<EjN@BM?b�AI<?j7< A/@BAGOQ8WJ1>1V/@^J$8W[L<ED/]=[��N@��$DW@B[1[:lH� '<E:l<E[1HK>1<?UaDfm/97bC[#FIME<E>#>1<ED/]>1V/@�_^MEHN[1[��$<?>1VlVI<?]aV/@^J&jKHKJL<EHNDW_`@!� � [1_^< � _`J1b7FW>��?m7U (� [1_^< � [#FIHN_`@ �?m � '� [1_^< � :Y@BA(�ZHNDIA� *� [1U7_ � J1@BM <?]a<?UaD�� _hV/JL<E[#>1< HND(� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �`p.-C/

0 ��0 ��< D/@BHKJlUa8/>#F;8/>1[=FWJLU j'<EA/@BA697b6[��N@��$D/@B[1[�:=H� /<E:=<E[LHK>1<?UaD OgUNJ�� �&m������4UN9I>1HN<ED/@BA 97b��� ! HNDWA���q� �� �Wt$]a<?jN@BD,97b !����'� UaD ��AW<E[#>1< DW_`>D/@��[#]NJ1Ua8/FI[ / � [1_^< � :Y@BA �?m � [1_^< � [#FIHN_`@ �HNDWA � [1U7_ � J1@BM <?]a<?UaD�� _hV/JL<E[#>1< HND(� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �`p.-C0

0 � 4 �UaDWME<ED/@BHKJ�Ua8/>#FI8/>1[�� � FWJ1U j7< A/@BA)97b�[��N@��D/@B[1[�:lH� '<E:l<E[1HK>1<?UaD�OQUNJ�� � HNDIA���q� �� �Wt ]a<?jN@BD97b�!����'���^ �@B[18IM?>1[fUaD4A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[fOQJ1Ua: /�D/@��[#]NJ1Ua8/FI[ / � HNM?>�� HK>1V/@B<E[1: �?m � J1@B_ � :=UN>#UNJL_`b7_^ME@B[��?m� [1_^< � @BME@B_`>#J1UaDW<E_^[��?m � >1HNM � � FPUaME<?>1<E_^[�� ]a8IDW[��?m � [#FPUNJ1>�� V/U'_��N@^b � � !/J1Ua: H�_^ME8W[#>#@^Jh<ED/],F Ua< DT> UNOj'<?@��4m � J1@B_ � :=UN>#UNJL_`b7_^ME@B[��T>#@BDWAI[�>#U*_^HKFW>18/JL@0>1V/@ � [#@B:=HNDZ>1<E_�D/Ua< [#@ � �$<?>1V 9PUN>1VY>1V/@�:Y@^>1V��U'AW[^mWHN[$_^HNDd9P@�[1@^@BDd<EDG>1V/@4:l<EAWAWM?@�J1U � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �`p.- 4

'<

Page 12: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

�� ��� ��� � �

������� �����

����� �������������� ���!���

��HK>#@BDT> jKHKJL<EHK9IM?@�:YU'A/@BME[eHKJ1@ FPU ��@^J1Os8WM�>#UZUaM [\OQUNJ AW<E[1_`U jN@^JL<ED/] MEHK>#@BDZ>e[#>#Jh8W_`>18/J1@G<ED VW<?]aVrAI<E:Y@BD��

[1<?UaDIHNM�UN9I[1@^J1j HK9;M?@�AIHK>1H�� ��V/@B[#@G:YU'A/@BME[eHN[1[18W:Y@�>1VWHK> >1V/@GAWHK>1H ��@GUN9I[1@^J1jN@C_^HND 9 @ @� 7F;MEHN<ED/@BA UNJ

VWHN[)9P@^@BD�]N@BDW@^JLHK>#@BAr97b [#Ua:Y@lMEHK>#@BDZ>\_^HN8I[#@B[ qsMEHK>#@BDZ>*jKHKJL<EHK9;M?@B[ht �=�,HNDTb�:Y@^>1V/U'AW[)UNO0AWHK>1HdHNDWHNM?b'[1<E[

[18W_hV HN[�HN8/>#Ua:lHK>1<E__^M HN[1[1<SR;_^HK>1<EUaDlHNDWA j7< [18WHNME<E[LHK>1<?UaD J1@BM?bYUaD�MEHK>#@BDZ>�jKHKJL<EHK9IME@$:YU'A/@BME[����J1@BHN[�UNO�FWJLHN_ �

>1<E_^HNM�HKFWFIME<E_^HK>1<EUaDW[)<EDW_^ME8IA/@eAIHK>1Hd:=<EDI<ED/]/mf>#@BM?@��k_`Ua:=:e8WDW< _^HK>1<?UaDW[^m�9I<?U �k<EDWOgUNJL:lHK>1<E_^[^mfOQJLHN8WA A/@^>#@B_`>1<EUaDfm

<ED/OQUNJL:=HK>1<EUaDGJ1@^>#JL<?@^jKHNMfHNDWAi:=HKJ��N@^>1<ED/]lHNDWHNMEb7[1< [��

��VW@^J1@YHKJ1@lHCD78W:*9P@^J�UNO.j HKJL< HNDT>1[)UNO�MEHK>#@BDZ>)j HKJh<EHK9IM?@Y:YU'A/@BME[)<ED 8W[1@ �$<?>1VW<ED >1V/@=ME<E>#@^JLHK>18/J1@Nm AW<EO �

OQ@^JL<ED/]r< D6>1V/@B<?J�8/>1<EME< %^@BA 9;8W<EMEAW< D/] 9;M?U7_��7[ HNDWA >1VW@B<?J _`Ua:YF;M?@� '<E>kb!� ��V/@iUNFI>1<E:=HNM�>#JhHNA/@^U ��9P@^> �.@^@BD

J1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>1HK>1<EUaDWHNM�FPU �.@^JlHNDWA6_`Ua:YFI8W>1HK>1<?UaDWHNM0J1@BX78W<?JL@B:Y@BDT>1[ VWHN[=>#U�9 @CA/@B_^< A/@BA OgUNJl@BHN_LV _`UaDW_`JL@^>#@

HKFWFIM <E_^HK>1<?UaD���� >���HN[0Ua8/J�HN< : <ED�>1VW<E[.J1@B[#@BHKJL_hV��.UNJ��l>#UYFWJLUNF Ua[1@�HNDIACA/@^jN@BM?UNFi:YU'A/@BME[��$VW< _LVGME<?@�<EDCH

8W[#@^Os8WM A/Ua:=HN<ED�UNO�F Ua[L[1<?9I<EM <?>1<?@B[�OQUNJ0>1V/@)_^HN[#@)UNO�>1V/@)[#FP@B_^<SR _�>kb7FP@�UNO�AWHK>1H 9IHN[1@BA UaDG>#@� '>�A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[��

��VW< [0<E[0UNO�FIHKJ1>1<E_^8IMEHKJ�<E:YFPUNJ1>1HNDW_`@4HNDIAi<EDZ>#@^J1@B[#>$[1< DW_`@)>1V/@4@� 'FIM?Ua[1<EjN@4]NJ1U �$>1ViUNO�HBjKHN<EMEHK9IME@Nm/FWJL<E:=HKJh<EM?b

>#@� '> � 9IHN[#@BAd< D/OgUNJh:=HK>1<?UaD �$VW<E_hVG_LVWHKJLHN_`>#@^Jh< %^@B[$Ua8WJ�[#U7_^<E@^>kb!���-]NJ1@BHK>$HN:YUa8IDT>�UNO�_^8/J1JL@BDT>�J1@B[#@BHKJh_LVi@^O �

OQUNJ1>�<E[�_`UaDW_`@^JLD/@BA �$<?>1V=_`J1@BHK>1< D/]\H*9IHN[1<E[�OQUNJ�>1VW@^UNJ1@^>1<E_^HNMEM?b FWJh<EDW_^<?FIME@BA\>#@� '>�HNDIHNM?b7[L<E[&HNDWA <ED/OQUNJL:=HK>1<?UaD

J1@^>#JL<E@^j HNM�[#b'[#>#@B:=[ � >1V/@^J1@ _^HND,[1>1<EMEMf9P@eUN9I[#@^J1jN@BA H�A/@^]NJ1@^@eUNO�V/@B8/JL< [#>1<E_^[$< D [#Ua:=@\UNO&>1VW@e_^8/JLJ1@BDT>1MEb

8W[#@BAi>#@B_LVWDW< XZ8/@B[ �

!/UNJ�[#>1HK>1<E_AWHK>1H'm7>1V/@�9I8W< MEAW<ED/]�@BM?@B:Y@BDZ>1[&UNOf>1VW@$MEHK>#@BDZ>�jKHKJL<EHK9IM?@�:=U7A/@BM [�JLHND/]N@OgJ1Ua: H*AW<E[1>#JL<?9I8/>#@BA

_`Ua:YFIHN_`>Y_`U'AW<ED/]/m�@!� ]�� !&JL<EDI_^<?FIHNM�".Ua:=F UaDW@BDT>1[\�DWHNMEb7[1< [ qs!."0��t � �VW<E_LV VWHN[\>1V/@�MEU �.@B[#>\JL@B_`UaD��

[#>#JL8I_`>1<?UaDe@^J1J1UNJ�HN:YUaD/]a[#>�HNMEM7ME<EDW@BHKJ�:Y@^>1VWU7AW[�HNDWAe>1V/@0VW<?]aVW@B[#>�@BDZ>#J1UNF7b*UNOI>[email protected]@^FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaD � �$<?>1V

>1V/@ FWJ1UN>#UN> bZF;<E_^HNM�J1@^FWJ1@B[1@BDT>1HK>1<?UaD UNO��@B_`>#UNJ�"�8IHNDT>1<E[LHK>1<?UaD6qQ�"4t � �$VW<E_hV,VIHN[>1VW@ MEU �.@B[#>)@BDT>#JLUNFZb

p

Page 13: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

UNO >1V/@J1@^FWJ1@B[1@BDT>1HK>1<?UaDGHNDWAl>1V/@�VW<?]aV/@B[#>�J1@B_`UaDW[#>#Jh8W_`>1<?UaD @^J1J1UNJ��Sp^oNo�� �&!&J1UN9;HK9I<EME<E[1>1<E_.]N@BD/@^JLHK>1<?jN@):YU'A/@BM

OQUNJL:\8IMEHK>1<?UaDW[�UNO >1V/@B[#@):YU'A/@BME[�@� '<E[1> "7>1VW@B[#@�HKJL@]N@BD/@^JhHNMEM?b=_`Ua:YFI8W>1HK>1<?UaDWHNMEM?b=:=UNJ1@�_`Ua[1>1M?bNm'9I8/>�VIHBjN@4H

D78W:*9P@^J&UNOf>1VW@^UNJ1@^>1<E_^HNMIHNAWj HNDZ>1HK]N@B[^mW[18W_hVlHN[�HNMEM?U �<ED/]*H)FIJL<EDW_^<?F;M?@BA �.H bYUNO _`Ua:*9I< DW<ED/]4[18I_LV=9;8W<EMEAW< D/]

9IM?U'_��'[��

� >�>#JLHNDW[#FI<EJ1@B[�OQJ1Ua: >1V/@):=HN_hVW<ED/@�M?@BHKJLDI<ED/]\M <?>#@^JLHK>18/J1@Nm'>1VWHK>0<EDGA/@B[L_`JL<?9I<EDW]\H _`Ua:YFIM?@� �[#b7[1>#@B:CmW< � @!�

OQUNJ4_^HKFW>18/JL<EDW]G[1Ua:Y@=8WDWA/@^JhM?b7< D/] [#>#Jh8W_`>18/J1@ UNO.>1V/@YAWHK>1Hrq �$<?>1VWUa8/>)D/@B_`@B[1[1HKJL< M?bd<EDW_`JL@BHN[1<ED/]G>1V/@YD78W:)�

9P@^J�UNO�_`UaDW[#>1<?>18/@BDZ>�@BM?@B:Y@BDZ>1[hthm/[#UaME8/>1<EUaDW[ �VW<E_LV�ME<?@9P@^> �.@^@BDG>1V/@�HK9PU jN@�> ��UY@� '>#J1@B:Y@�J1@^FIJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaD

:YU'A/@BME[�HNMEM?U � _`UaDW[1<EA/@^JhHK>1<?UaD,UNO�>#JLHNAW@^U �P[�9P@^> �.@^@BD�>1V/@Y<EDZ>18W<?>1<EjN@e:Y@BHNDI<ED/]�UNO�FWJLUN>#UN>kb7FI<E_^HNM�_`Ua:YFPU �

D/@BDZ>1[�HNDWAd>1VW@e]NU7U'A,HKFIFWJ1U /<E:=HK>1<EUaD HN_hVW<?@^jN@BA,9Zb H�AI<E[#>#JL<?9;8/>#@BACJ1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>1HK>1<EUaD��)��@B_hVWDW<E_^HNMEMEbNm <ED,H

]N@BD/@^JLHK>1<EjN@�:YU'A/@BM/OQUNJL:e8WMEHK>1<?UaD mT>1VW<E[&Og@BHK>18/JL@<E[�_`UaDT>#J1UaM M?@BA=97b >1V/@[#>1HK>1< [#>1<E_^HNMWFIJ1UNFP@^J1>1<?@B[&<E:=F Ua[1@BAYUaD

>1V/@�MEHK>#@BDZ>�]N@BD/@^JhHK>1<?jN@jKHKJL<EHK9;M?@\qQUNJ0MEHK>#@BDZ>�OsHN_`>#UNJ thm��$VW<E_hVl<E[�>#Ue9 @�[#@^>�< DlHN_^_`UNJLAWHNDI_`@ �<?>1V=>1V/@�[1_`UNFP@

UNO&>1V/@ HKFWFIM <E_^HK>1<?UaD��� >�<E[ �7D/U �$D,OgUNJ�@� /HN:YFIM?@Nm >1VWHK>)H"��HN8W[1[1< HND MEHK>#@BDZ>�FWJL<?UNJJ1@B[18WME>1[<ED,!."0� � > bZFP@

_`U'AW<ED/] :YU'A/@BME[Bm �$VW< ME[#>YHK>=>1V/@iUN>1VW@^Jl@� '>#J1@B:Y@Nm0Hr:=H� /<E:=HNM M?br[#FIHKJh[#@dAW<E[L_`J1@^>#@iMEHK>#@BDZ> AW<E[1>#JL<?9I8/>1<EUaD

qs:=HNA/@Y8/F,UNO&>1V/@ _^HND/UaDW< _^HNM�9;HN[1<E[jN@B_`>#UNJL[4HN[�FPUa[1[1<?9IME@4jN@B_`>#UNJ4jKHNME8/@B[ht�J1@B[18WME>1[<ED,HND 8WDW_`UaDW[1>#JLHN<ED/@BA

:=< '>18/J1@Y:YU'A/@BM m�HKFWFWJ1UNFWJh<EHK>#@ OgUNJe_^ME8W[#>#@^JL< D/]CAWHK>1Hi<EDZ>#Ui:\8W>18WHNMEM?b,AW<E[ �#Ua<EDZ>�_^M HN[1[#@B[��l��A/UNFW>1< D/]CD/UaD��

��HN8W[L[1<EHNDYMEHK>#@BDZ>&FWJL<EUNJL[�_`Ua:*9;<ED/@B[�>1V/@$HNAWj HNDZ>1HK]N@B[&UNOP>1V/@�HK9PU jN@$> �.U\:YU'A/@BME[�HNDWAYVIHN[�9P@^@BD=[1V/U �$D >#U

J1@^jN@BHNM�<ED/OQUNJL:=HK>1<EjN@e[#>#Jh8W_`>18/J1@e<EDd>1VW@eAWHK>1H��*�'8I_LV,:YU7AW@BME[$HKJ1@ J1@BM HK>#@BA >#U���DWA/@^FP@BDWA/@BDZ>�".Ua:YFPUaD/@BDZ>

��DWHNM?b'[1<E[iqQ�1"���thm��$V/Ua[#@ HK9I<EME<?>1<E@B[ OgUNJlR;DWAW<EDW],:Y@BHNDI<ED/]NOs8WM0[#>#JL8W_`>18WJ1@d<ED6>1VW@dAWHK>1HrVIHN[=UNOQ>#@BDc9P@^@BD

AW<E[L_^8W[1[#@BAG<EDC>1VW@4ME<?>#@^JLHK>18/JL@!�

�U �.@^jN@^JBmN9P@^bNUaDWA)>1V/@�>#@B_LVWDW< _^HNMTAW<���_^8WM?>1<?@B[PUNO/_^HKJ1J1b'<ED/]0Ua8W>�[18W_hV4H$D/UaD�� ��HN8W[1[1< HND4MEHK>#@BDZ> j HKJh<EHK9IM?@

HNM?]NUNJL<E>1VW: <EDiH=OQ8WM M?blFWJLUN9IHK9I<EME< [#>1<E_OgJLHN:=@���UNJ�� mW>1V/@*FWJ1UN9IM?@B: UNO�_hV/U7Ua[1<ED/]=>1VW@*MEHK>#@BDZ>$FWJL<EUNJ �$VW<E_hVi<E[

HKFWFWJLUNFWJL<EHK>#@eHNDWA [18W_^_`@B[1[#Os8WM�<EDdR;DWAW<EDW]=>1V/@ A/@B[1<?J1@BA,:Y@BHNDW< D/]NOQ8IM�[#>#JL8I_`>18/J1@ <E[HNM �.H b7[)HGX78/@B[#>1<?UaD >#U

HNDW[��.@^J0OQUNJ0@BHN_LViHKFWF;ME<E_^HK>1<?UaD UaDCH [#FP@B_^<SR;_�AWHK>1He>kb7F @!��� D�>1V/@)[#FP@B_^<SR;_�_^HN[#@)UNO�>#@� 7>�:=< DW<ED/]/m7<EDG[#FI<?>#@

UNO >1V/@0OQHN_`>�>1VIHK>&FWJ1@^j'<?Ua8W[�HKFWFIM <E_^HK>1<?UaDW[�UNO �#"����10547m �20��IVWH jN@�9P@^@BD J1@^FPUNJ1>#@BAY<EDe>1V/@0J1@B_`@BDZ>�ME<E>#@^JLHK>18/J1@Nm

>1V/@Y�1"�� jKHKJL<EHNDZ>)@B:YFIMEU bN@BA VWHN[�9P@^@BD�[#@BME@B_`>#@BAr<ED HC[#Ua:Y@��VWHK>4HKJ19I<?>#JhHKJ1b :=HNDID/@^J � ��VW<E[�<E[�UaD/@YUNO

>1V/@e<E[1[18/@B[HNAWA/J1@B[L[#@BAd<EDd>1VW<E[$J1@B[#@BHKJL_hV OQUNJ�>1V/@\_^HN[#@eUNO&>#@� '>�AWU7_^8W:=@BDT>1[�AWHK>1H'mPHNDWAd>1VW@\HKFWFWJLUNFWJL<EHK>#@

�1"�� :=U7A/@BMPFIJ1UNFPUa[#@BAC<E[�:YUN>1<Ej HK>#@BAiHNDIAiA/@^JL<?jN@BAiOgJ1Ua: :\8WME>1<?FIM?@�[#>1HKJ1>1<EDW]YF Ua< DT>1[��

��:YFPUa[1<ED/]�H _`@^J1>1HN<ED > bZFP@iUNO4_`UNJLJ1@BMEHK>1<?UaD69P@^> ��@^@BD�>1V/@ M HK>#@BDT>l_`Ua:=F UaDW@BDT>1[^m�HN_^_`UNJhAW<ED/] >#U >1V/@

D/@B<?]aVZ9PUNJLV/U7U7A J1@BMEHK>1<?UaDW[*UaD Hi]NJL<EA UNO0@BX78W<EAW<E[1>1HNDT>4FPUa<EDZ>1[^m�:=H �N@B[ H ]N@BD/@^JLHK>1<?jN@G:YU'A/@BM�_^HKFIHK9;M?@ UNO

_`UaDW[#>#Jh8W_`>1<ED/]eH*>#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVI<E_0J1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>1HK>1<EUaD UNOf>1VW@�AWHK>1H��&�$VWHK>�<E[Bm7[1< :=<EMEHKJ&AWHK>1H\FPUa<EDZ>1[�HKJ1@�:=HKFWFP@BA

n

Page 14: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

_^M?Ua[#@Y>#Ud@BHN_LV�UN>1V/@^J��$VW<EM?@ 8WD/JL@BMEHK>#@BA�AWHK>1HGFPUa<EDZ>1[)HKJ1@=:=HKFWFP@BA,OQ8WJ1>1V/@^J4H ��HBb�<ED >1VW@=MEHK>#@BDT>4[1FIHN_`@!�

��D <ED/]N@BDW<EUa8W[ ��HBb >#U <E:=FIM?@B:Y@BDZ>�>1VW<E[^m�HNM?UaD/] �$<E>1V�HdD/UaD�� �)HN8W[1[1<EHND�M HK>#@BDT>\FWJL<?UNJBm�<ED HCFWJh<EDW_^<?FIME@BA

FWJ1UN9;HK9I<EME<E[1>1<E_�OQJLHN:Y@��.UNJ��iVWHN[09P@^@BDiAW@^jN@BM?UNFP@BAiOQUNJ$_`UaDT>1< DZ8/Ua8I[�J1@BHNMfjKHNME8/@BAdAWHK>1H=97bG>1V/@ ��@BD/@^JhHK>1<?jN@

��UNF UN]NJhHKFIVW<E_=�,HKFWFI< D/]rq ������t ��� >\[1@^@B:=[*A/@B[L<?J1Ua8W[)>#U ]N@BD/@^JLHNME< %^@l>1VW<E[*OgJhHN:Y@���UNJ�� �<?>1V�@B:YFIVIHN[1<E[

UaDCjKHKJL<EHNDZ>1[ �$VW<E_hVCHKJ1@4HKFWFWJLUNFWJL<EHK>#@�OgUNJAW<E[1_`J1@^>#@)AWHK>1H'mI@!� ]���>#@� '>�A/U7_^8I:Y@BDT>1[ �&��VW<E[.>1HN[�� �$<EM MI9P@)HNA��

A/J1@B[L[#@BAYV/@^J1@NmaUN9I>1HN<EDW<ED/])H)FIJL<EDW_^<?F;M?@BA*HNM?>#@^JhDWHK>1<?jN@0>#U4>1V/@�DWUaD�� FWJ1UN9IHK9;<EME<E[#>1< _�HNDWAY[#Ua:=@��$VWHK>�V/@B8WJL<E[#>1<E_

� �����W��� :YU'A/@BM � �54 � �

!/UNJ�VWHNDWAWM <ED/] AWb7DWHN:l<E_ AIHK>1H'm�@� '>#@BDW[1<?UaDI[ UNO>1V/@i[1>1HK>1<E_C:YU'A/@BME[YHKJ1@i<ED UNJLAW@^JBm�97b <EDI_^ME8WAW<EDW] H

FWJ1@BAI<E_`>1<?UaD=:YU'A/@BM/UaD >1V/@$M HK>#@BDT>.j HKJh<EHK9IM?@B[�UNOP>1V/@�:YU'A/@BM � !/UNJ0AW<E[1_`J1@^>#@�� jKHNME8/@BA=UNJ.AW< [1_`J1@^>1< %^@BA=VI<EAWA/@BD

jKHKJL<EHK9IM?@C:YU'A/@BME[Bm�>1V/@C9IHN[L<E_CA/b'DWHN:=<E_�@� '>#@BDW[1<?UaD < [ >1V/@d��<EAWA/@BD �,HKJ��NU j � U7AW@BM*qs��,��t HNDWA6OQUNJ

_`UaDZ>1<EDZ8WUa8W[ ��HN8W[1[1< HND MEHK>#@BDZ>�j HKJh<EHK9IM?@B[�<?>< [$>1V/@Y34HNM :=HND !�<EME>#@^J ����[�>1V/@ ��UNJ�� �$<?>1V,D/UaD�� ��HN8W[L[1<EHND

MEHK>#@BDZ>4jKHKJL<EHK9IM?@B[)VIHN[4D/@B_`@B[1[1<E>1HK>#@BArHCAW<E[L_`J1@^>1< %BHK>1<?UaD UNO�>1V/@=MEHK>#@BDZ>*[#F;HN_`@l<ED >1V/@=_`Ua:YF;8/>1HK>1<?UaDW[^m�>1V/@

��� � :YU'A/@BM�_`Ua:\9I<EDW@B[ ��@BMEM �$<E>1V >1VW@eFIJ1@^j7<EUa8W[1M?bG@B:YFIMEU bN@BA ����� � >kb7FP@=AW<E[1_`JL@^>1<E[#@BA,MEHK>#@BDT>4[1FIHN_`@!�

��DWA/@^@BA [18I_LVrHNDr@� 7>#@BDI[1<?UaD UNO ���$� >1V/J1Ua8/]aV�>1< :Y@=@� /<E[#>1[*< D >1V/@ ME<E>#@^JLHK>18/J1@dqs��<E[1VWUNFrHNDWAr��<EDZ>#UaD;t

HNDWA OQUNJL:=HNMEMEbi<?> ��Ua8WM A 9P@Y[#>#JLHN<E]aVT>#OQUNJ���HKJLA >#UC@� 7>#@BDIA >1VW<E[�>#UiHNMEM?U � OgUNJ)>1V/@=_^HN[1@YUNO�AW<E[L_`J1@^>#@YAWHK>1H

[18W_hV6HN[Y>#@� '>lA/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[�� �U �.@^jN@^JBm�>1V/@^J1@iHKJL@iH�DZ8W:\9P@^J UNO�A/JhH ��9IHN_��7[ �$<?>1V >1VW<E[Y:YU'A/@BM m�:YUa[#>

<E:YFPUNJ1>1HNDZ>1M?b�>1V/@G]NJ1@BHK>=D78W:\9P@^JeUNOOgJL@^@ FIHKJhHN:Y@^>#@^JL[=HNDWA :YU'A/@BM�FIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^Jh[^m �$VI<E_LV ��Ua8IMEA :=H �N@

>1VW<E[0HYME@B[1[�FWJLHN_`>1<E_^HNMfHKFIFWJ1UaHN_LV��&� DI[#>#@BHNAfmWHY[1<E:=FIME<SRI@BAl>#@B:YFPUNJLHNMf:YU'A/@BMfVWHN[09P@^@BDC<EDZjN@B[#>1<?]aHK>#@BAdV/@^J1@

OQUNJ�>#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVW<E_^HNM j7<E[L8WHNME<E[1HK>1<EUaDl9IHN[1@BACUaDi>#@B:YFPUNJLHNMf_`UaVW@^J1@BDW_`@\HN[L[18W:YFW>1<EUaDW[.J1@^]aHKJLAW<EDW]Y>1V/@4AWHK>1H��

��� � ������ ��� � ���!����� ��� ����� � ������

� b\_`UaDZ>#JL<?9I8W>1<?UaDW[ >#U�>1V/@�RI@BMEAeHKJ1@0[18W:l:=HKJL< %^@BA\<ED*JL@^Og@^J1@^@BA _`UaD/OQ@^J1@BDW_`@�FI8W9IME<E_^HK>1<?UaDI[�HNDWA ��Ua8WJLDWHNM

FIHKFP@^JL[^m HN[ �.@BMEMZHN[�>#@B_hVWDW<E_^HNMZJ1@^FPUNJ1>1[�����V/@&]N@BD/@^JhHNMZHN<E:-UNO/>1V/@B[#@.<EDTjN@B[1>1<?]aHK>1<?UaDW[.�.HN[�>1V/@.A/@^jN@BM?UNFI:Y@BDZ>

UNO;M HK>#@BDT>�jKHKJL<EHK9IME@.:YU'A/@BME[�[18I<?>1HK9IM?@�OgUNJ�>#@� '>�9IHN[#@BAYA/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[�AWHK>1H'm0�VW<E_LV HKJ1@�_^HKF;HK9IM?@�UNOIFWJLU j'<EAW<ED/]

HdV78W:=HND��k8WDWA/@^JL[1>1HNDWAWHK9IM?@eJ1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>1HK>1<EUaDrUNO0>1V/@ [#@B:=HNDZ>1<E_l_`UaDZ>#@BDT> <EDWVW@^J1@BDT>\<ED�>1V/@l_`UNJLFI8W[*< D HND

HN8/>#Ua:=HK>1< _$:=HNDWDW@^J ���$U ��@^jN@^J0<?>&<E[�A/@B:YUaDW[1>#JLHK>#@BA=>1VWHK>�>1V/@^J1@$< [&HNME[#U*H��$<EA/@^J&AWUa:=HN<EDYUNO HKFWF;ME<E_^HK>1<?UaD

OQUNJ�>1V/@4FWJLUNF Ua[1@BAC:Y@^>1V/U'AW[��

Page 15: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

��D,UNJLA/@^J)>#U��N@^@^F�>#JLHN_��$�$<E>1V >1VW@e>1VW@^UNJ1@^>1<E_^HNM&HNA/jKHNDZ>1HK]N@B[)UNO.H�FWJLUN9IHK9I<EME< [#>1<E_4:YU'A/@BM mfHN[ �.@BMEM�HN[

>1V/@�FWJLHN_`>1< _^HNM/HNA/j HNDZ>1HK]N@B[&UNOPH�FWJ1U��#@B_`>1<?UaD 9IHN[1@BAYHNM?]NUNJL<?>1VW:im��.@0@B:YFIMEU bN@BAY> ��U4AW< � @^J1@BDZ>�>#@� 7>&:l<EDW<ED/]

>#@B_LVIDW<EX78/@B[�/

� H=FWJ1UN9IHK9I< ME<E[#>1<E_HKFWFWJ1UaHN_hV ��HN[�HNA/UNFW>#@BA <EDGFI8/9;ME<E_^HK>1<?UaDW[��Sp � m � n ��HNDWA � -��

� H=FWJ1U��#@B_`>1<?UaD�� 9IHN[#@BAdHKFWFWJ1UaHN_hV ��HN[$8/>1<EM < %^@BAG<ED �1� � m �1/ � m �10 � m � 4 ��HNDWA �1� � �

��VW@B[#@)FI8/9IM <E_^HK>1<?UaDW[�HKJ1@4>1VW@)OgUaMEMEU �$<EDW]�/

����� ����� ������ ������������� �����!/

�Sp ��34HK9 5HND m�� HNDWA �)<?J1UaMEHN:=< m�� � ��� ��������� ���! "�#� �$�%� � �&�'���(�����*) �+�����,-�.� �$��/$� �0��1 � � �����32

4 ���5�6�����879�:�� ����3�5���;�<�<���=�+/?>@�:� � ���$� �0>A�#�B�Km � *$& � -�& # �$� ( � - ( � � & ��� # * � � � &:+ %�- � - & � ,

) & # �?�=� # ��� � # +=+ �<> # � #0#;m/�UaM ��n2�7m �$U�� 4Cq �a8WMEb�nKoNo/p thmP<EDGFWJ1@B[1[ �

� n �034HK9 5HNDfm�����HNDWA ��<?JLUaMEHN:=< m�� �?m � > 4 �����C� ��D �+�E���E�����3�5���<� � ,F�.� �$�G�B�H79�:�� ����3�5���F)%����� �?IKJ �#2

�L ��<�M���N�5�H) ��O;�KP�� � �����A�hm�_`UaDWAW<?>1<?UaDIHNMEM?biHN_^_`@^FW>#@BArOgUNJ)FI8W9IME<E_^HK>1<?UaD <ED >1V/@CQ�(A!.* � &:+ (:@ ��� � # +=+ �<> # � �

��� @ (+* � & �'� ( � � %�- � #�� -NmW[#FP@B_^<EHNMf<E[L[18/@�UaDi��8/>#Ua:=HK>#@BAd��@� '>�"�HK>#@^]NUNJL< %BHK>1<?UaD��

�1� �;3*HK9 5HNDfmZ� HNDWA �)<?J1UaMEHN:=< ma� �?mSR"�'��� I O;� �+� � �<�M���6�+/TP ���U�����<� � R ���#�< �����V/ �+���W�X 9�#� �����VP ���U����2

�<� �XY ��� ��O ��� � � �Z�� [� � � #,! *$&:+ � *�( #0# - - �=��> 7 # ��� # *�-Nm/>#UlHKFWFP@BHKJ

\��M/���� ����� � ���./ �&����� � �]����� �&��� /

� -���34HK9 5HNDfm0����HNDWA��)<?J1UaMEHN:=< m�� � Y ���<�<�<�#�3�5�����^�����`_K ��<� ��� I ,a2 � �L [��� �&�����cbd�+/eP#��� �����gfh����� � 4>A�#�B�jik����1 � �;���L� � �#�<�M���S�C�B�l) ��OE�mf�'� ���U>A� � [���$�%��� ��!�J1U'_ �&UNO�>1V/@lp�/ � >1Vi��DZ>#@^JLDWHK>1<?UaDWHNM�".UaD/OQ@^J1@BDW_`@

UaD�!�HK>#>#@^JhDC �@B_`UN]aDW<?>1<EUaD � �����gnpo%o �&��HKJL_`@BM?UaDWH'mI�7FIHN< Dfm7�7@^FW>#@B:\9P@^JBm/nKoNoNo'm/� ����� ".Ua:YFI8W>#@^J�!&JL@B[1[^m

jNUaM � n7mWFIF���4'-C�rq,4 /'p �

�1/ ��34HK9 5HNDfm�� HNDIA ��<?J1UaMEHN:l< mf� � � �L [��� �&�����cbl�s/6) ��O;�t>A� � �� �$�%���j� 4 P�u���ik� �����v,-�rO#���A�5���;�<�<���+�

!&JLU7_ �(UNO4>1V/@ n � DWA ��DT>#@^JhDWHK>1<?UaDWHNM��UNJ��'[1V/UNF UaD � DIA/@^FP@BDWA/@BDZ>�".Ua:YFPUaD/@BDZ>���DWHNM?b'[1<E[ HNDWA ��ME<EDWA

�7Ua8/Jh_`@\�7@^FIHKJLHK>1<?UaD m � � �6n � o%o�o m �T8WD/@*nKoNoNo'm;�@BME[1< D��7< mZFWF � -C�2/ -2-ao��

�10 ����<ED/]aVIHN:Cm7� �?m/34HK9 5HNDfm/���'HNDIA ��<EJ1UaMEHN:=< m'� ��Rw���������cbj�B����� � �x�5�l� 4 �����C� � ���9� ��O;�ByX���;���3� � �#�<�M���

�B� � 1��#�G�3��� �C���5� � c�����M���S� m�z{z|z � o m;�,HBb p�q /7mfnKoNo/pKm �UaD/]�3)UaD/]/mI!�Ua[#>#@^J�!&J1U'_`@^@BAW<EDW]a[0FWF���p �2�rq

p � � �

-

Page 16: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

) � � 1E��� � ��� � � ��� ���By

� 4 ��34HK9 5HNDfm � HNDWA ��<?J1UaMEHN:l< mI� ���V�S�� � ��� J �:� ���F)������ � P � ��� �+�#�<�M��� �#����� � 4 iw� �+� Y � ���%�<� � � �;�<�<���

���(>A� � �� �$�%� � ���5� � � �<�<�#�S��y �8D �s�+�� � �<�M��� � �E� �s�r� � 1&����@B_LVWDW< _^HNM �@^FPUNJ1>��U��$p^o'mI�1�W�'� p.-C0'p � 0'pBnNn �

P% %�$�A�<�M� ���?�U���% c� � ��� � � /

�1� ����<ED/]aVWHN:Cm � HNDWA 3*HK9 5HNDfmP� HNDWA ��<EJ1UaMEHN:=< m � �?mh)������ �vY � �$�%�<� � � �#�<�M���F��� � 1[�#�h�3��� � >@�5� � [��2

���M���S�x� 4 I O;� �+� � �<���cb Y ��� ��� �$��� �����9,l�����5�C �� � ������� ��O;��� 4 ) ����� � �#�]�S��� �������hmI�'8/9I:l<?>#>#@BA >#U*�@B8/JLHNM

!&JLU7_`@B[1[L<ED/]Y� @^>#>#@^JL[

� # , # � # + ( � � # � � & � , ��� # � ,.# & - (A@ ��� # �"!?9;+ � #5& �'� ( � -

��D�HGRIJL[1>�[1>18WA/bNm J1@^FPUNJ1>#@BA�< D�"!?9;+ � #5& �'� ( ��� �� m�[1<E:YF;M?@\FIJ1UNFPUa[1HNME[�OgUNJ*>1V/@Y@� 7F;M?Ua<?>1HK>1<?UaD UNO.>1V/@

HBjKHN<EMEHK9;M?@$FWJh<?UNJ �'D/U �M?@BA/]N@�HKJ1@FIJ1UNFPUa[#@BAlOQUNJ.FWJ1UN9IHK9I< ME<E[#>1<E_0:l< 7>18WJ1@$:YU'A/@BMEME< D/])UNO�:e8WM?>1<EAW< :Y@BDW[1<?UaDIHNM

[#FIHKJh[#@l9I< DWHKJ1b AWHK>1Hd[18I_LV HN[*9I< DWHKJ1b _`U7A/@BA >#@� '>eA/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[��i��VI<E[4<E:YFIJ1U jN@B[\>1V/@lFP@^J1OQUNJL:=HNDI_`@l<ED

HKFWFIMEb7<EDW]*>1V/@)� 'FP@B_`>1HK>1<?UaDC�,H� '<E:l<E[1HK>1<?UaD�qs����t.HNM?]NUNJL<E>1VW: 9Zb J1@BAW8W_^<EDW]e<?>1[��'D/U �DCA/@^FP@BDWA/@BDW_`@�UaD

<EDW<E>1<EHNME<E[1HK>1<EUaDW[^m �$VW<E_hV6<E[ :YUNJ1@CFWJ1UaDWUa8WDW_`@BA UaD6:e8WM?>1<?jKHKJL<EHK>#@C[#FIHKJh[#@CAWHK>1H��6��UN>1V�[18/FP@^J1j'<E[#@BA HNDWA

AWHK>1H�� J1@BM HK>#@BACFWJL<?UNJ��'D/U �$ME@BA/]N@ �.HN[�_`UaDI[1<EA/@^J1@BA�����D�>1V/@)_^HN[#@)UNO�[18/FP@^J1j'<E[#@BA=@BME@B:Y@BDT>1[4qsH OQ@���MEHK9P@BM?@BA

A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[hthm >1V/@B[1@=_^HND�9P@ 8I[#@BA OgUNJ\<EDW<?>1<EHNM <E[1<ED/]Y>1VW@=��� HNM?]NUNJL<?>1VW: �e�FIHKJ1>�OQJ1Ua: >1V/@=H j HN<EM HK9I<EME<?> b

UNO�[18I_LV <ED/OQUNJL:=HK>1<?UaD mI>1V/@e> �.U � j HNM 8/@BA�!�Ua<E[1[#UaD AW<E[1>#JL<?9I8/>1<EUaDC<E[$FIJ1UNFPUa[#@BA < Dd>1VW< [$FIHKFP@^J�HN[�H [#F;HKJL[#@

[18/9;[#>1<?>18/>#@4OQUNJ$>1VW@\�.@^JLD/Ua8WM ME< AW<E[1>#JL<?9I8/>1<EUaDfm��$VW<E_hVi<E[$8I[18WHNM�< Di:YU'A/@BMEME<EDW]e9;<EDWHKJ1bCAWHK>1H�����VI<E[$<E[$:YU �

>1<?jKHK>#@BAi97bG>1V/@ qsAWHK>1H�� J1@BM HK>#@BA;t0FIJL<?UNJ �'D/U �$ME@BA/]N@4UNO�[#FIHKJL[L<?>kb�UNO�>1V/@*A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[$AWHK>1H���".Ua:YF;HKJLHK>1<?jN@

@� 'F @^Jh<E:Y@BDZ>1HNMIJ1@B[L8WM?>1[�UaD 9PUN>1V�qs[#FIHKJh[#@ t�9;<EDWHKJ1b=_`U'A/@BAGA/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[�OQJ1Ua: >1V/@4nKo��k�$@��[#]NJ1Ua8/FI[0_`UNJLFI8W[

HNDWA qsD/UaD��k[#FIHKJh[#@ t�9I< DWHKJ1b _`U7A/@BA VWHNDWA��$JL<?>#>#@BD AW<E]a<?>1[4_^ME8W[1>#@^JL<ED/]d_`UaD/RIJL:Y@BA�>1VIHK>\>1V/@ OgJL@BXZ8/@BDI_`b,UNO

_`UaDZjN@^J1]N@BDW_`@�>#U*H)FPUZUNJ&MEU7_^HNM/UNFI>1<E:\8I: UNO;>1VW@$ME< �N@BME< V/UZU'A\OQ8WDI_`>1<?UaDY<EDY>1V/@�_^HN[1@$UNOP[#FIHKJL[#@$9I<EDWHKJ1b\AWHK>1H

_^HNDi9P@�>1V78W[0J1@BAW8I_`@BA��

$@B_`UN]aDW< %B<ED/] [#Ua:=@ UNOl>1V/@ FWJLHN_`>1<E_^HNM AW<E[LHNA/j HNDZ>1HK]N@B[�HKJL<E[L<ED/] �<?>1V H FWJLUN9IHK9I<EME< [#>1<E_�_^ME8W[1>#@^JL<ED/]

:Y@^>1V/U'A OgUNJ=VI<?]aV AI<E:Y@BDW[1<EUaDWHNM�AWHK>1H'm.HNDWA HNME[#U�:YUN>1<?jKHK>#@BA 97b >1V/@G]NJ1@BHK>=<EDZ>#@^J1@B[#> UNO< DTjN@B[#>1<E]aHK>1<ED/]

>1V/@YJ1@BM HK>1<?jN@BM?bdD/@�� 8IDW[18/FWJLj7<E[1@BAd[#>1HK>1<E[1>1<E_^HNM�:Y@^>1V/U'A UNO��1"�� >#Ui:YU7AW@BMEME<ED/] UNO�>#@� '>*AWHK>1H'm 9;HN[#@BA UaD

[#Ua:Y@�FWJ1Ua:l<E[1<ED/]�J1@B[L8WM?>1[�< D=>1V/@�ME<?>#@^JLHK>18/JL@NmZ<ED �;!?9;+ � #5& �$� ( �� ��� ��FWJLUNF Ua[1@H4jKHKJL<EHNDZ>�UNO�� DWAW@^F @BDIA/@BDT>

".Ua:YFPUaD/@BDZ>���DWHNM?b'[1<E[4qQ�1"���t0HN[$H=_`Ua:YF;8/>1HK>1<?UaDWHNMEMEb�HK>#>#JLHN_`>1<EjN@\_^ME8W[1>#@^JL<ED/]Y>#U7UaM ����VW@48W[18WHNMfFIJ1@^FWJ1U �

/

Page 17: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

_`@B[1<EDW]�:Y@^>1VWU7A <ED\>1V/@.FWJLHN_`>1<E_`@�UNOI�1"�� �VW<E_LVeHBjNUa< AW[�>1V/@0_`Ua:YFI8/>1HK>1<?UaDIHNM7AW@B:=HNDWAW[�UNO;HFWJ1UN9IHK9;<EME<E[#>1< _

D/Ua<E[1b��#"�� HNME]NUNJL<?>1VW:Cm�VWHKFIF @BDI[4>#U 9P@ HK> >1V/@G[1HN:Y@�>1<E:Y@GH �.@BMEM��7D/U �$D @ � _^<?@BDZ>e>#@B_hVWDW<EX78/@ �$<?>1V

HdMEUaD/]i>#JLHNAW<E>1<?UaD <ED���D/OQUNJL:=HK>1<?UaDr �@^>#JL<?@^jKHNM m�>#@^JL:Y@BA ��HK>#@BDZ>Y�7@B:lHNDT>1<E_l�DWHNMEb7[1< [lqs���'�)t�UNJ ��HK>#@BDZ>

�7@B:=HNDZ>1<E_)��DWA/@� /<ED/]Cqs���'�#t �I�$V/@)FWJ1UNFPUa[#@BAG�1"�� HNM?]NUNJL<?>1VW: <E[�>1V/@BDi:Y@BHNDZ>$>#U <EA/@BDZ>1<?Ogb >1V/@4[#>#JL8I_`>18/J1@

<ED,>1V/@=���'� � JL@^FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>#@BA�_`UNJ1FI8W[ �e��VW@ HNME]NUNJL<?>1VW: <E[)A/@^Jh<?jN@BA <ED >1VW<E[�FIHKFP@^J)OQJ1Ua: >1V/@ FWJ1UN9IHK9;<EME<E[#>1< _

[#>1HKJ1>1< D/] FPUa<EDZ>$UNO ��HN8W[1[L<EHND :l< 7>18WJ1@\:YU'A/@BMEM <ED/]l<ED >1V/@ ���'� [#FIHN_`@YHNDWA >1H �7<EDW]G< DT>#UGHN_^_`Ua8WDZ>)FWJL<?UNJ

�'D/U �$ME@BA/]N@UNO�H\[1F @B_^<?R;_�]N@^Ua:Y@^>#Jh<E_)[#>#JL8W_`>18WJ1@$@� /VW<?9I<E>#@BAl97b=>1V/@�_`Ua:YFWJ1@B[L[#@BAGA/U7_^8I:Y@BDT>1[�AWHK>1H�����VW<E[

]N@^Ua:Y@^>#JL< _0[#>#JL8W_`>18/JL@.<E[�H)AW<EJ1@B_`>�_`UaDI[#@BXZ8W@BDW_`@0UNOI>1V/@0_`UNJ1JL@BMEHK>1<?UaD FWJ1UNFP@^J1>1<E@B[�UNO :\8WME>1< �k_^MEHN[1[�>#@� '>&AWHK>1H��

��V/@�J1@B[18IM?>1HNDT>0HNM?]NUNJh<?>1VW: :=H� '< :=< %^@B[�HNDGUN9��#@B_`>1<?jN@)9IHN[#@BA�UaDG>1V/@)AW<E[1>#JL<?9I8/>1<EUaD=HN[#b':=:Y@^>#J1b UNJ�[��N@�� �

D/@B[1[�HNDWA=>1VW@^J1@^OgUNJL@<E[�[1<?]aDW<SR _^HNDT>1M?beAW< �P@^J1@BDZ>&OgJLUa: UN>1V/@^J.HKFWFWJ1UaHN_hV/@B[.UNOfHKFWFIM?b'<ED/])�1"�� >#U\A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>

_^ME8W[1>#@^JL<ED/]/m��$VW<E_hV6DWHN<?jN@BM?b HN[1[18W:=@i[#b7:l:Y@^>#JL<E_^HNM�M HK>#@BDT>lAW@BDW[1<?>1<?@B[ � �$V/@CJ1@BMEHK>1<?UaD >#U FWJ1UN9IHK9;<EME<E[#>1< _

:YU'A/@BMEME< D/]eHNM [#U=VWHN[0>1V/@\HNA/j HNDZ>1HK]N@*UNO�<EDZ>#@^J1FWJL@^>1HK9I<EME<?> b=UNO�>1V/@4J1@B[18IM?>1[�OgJLUa: H=V78W:=HNDGFP@^JL[#FP@B_`>1<?jN@!�

��D # # �?�;� #5&:+ � # � ( * � � � � m�>1V/@)��UNJ�� UNO�FI8W9IME<E_^HK>1<?UaD �1/ ��<E[�@� '>#@BDWA/@BA��e��V/@ [��N@��$D/@B[1[�FIJL<?UNJ)<E[

D/U � :=UN>1<?j HK>#@BA OQJ1Ua: > �.U AI< � @^JL@BDT>\F Ua< DT>1[*UNO�j7<E@�� /dq�p t)>1VW@ J1@BM HK>1<?UaDr9P@^> ��@^@BD H,_`@BDT>#JLHNM�_^ME8I[#>#@^J��

<ED/]iHNME]NUNJL<?>1VW: HNDIA�>1V/@=FWJLUNF Ua[1@BA�[��N@��$D/@B[1[\:=H� /<E:=<E[1HK>1<EUaD�HNM?]NUNJL<?>1VW: <E[)HNDWHNM?b7>1<E_^HNMEM?b A/@^JL<EjN@BA HNDWA

q nat�@^j'<EA/@BDI_`@=OgJLUa: >1V/@lM <?>#@^JLHK>18/J1@ _`UaDW_`@^JLDW<EDW]C>1V/@=U jN@^JhHNMEM�_hVWHKJLHN_`>#@^JL< [#>1<E_=UNO �.UNJLArAI<E[#>#JL<?9;8/>1<?UaDW[�<ED

A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[�9P@B<ED/] FPUa[1<?>1<EjN@BM?b�[��N@���@BA <E[�8/>1<EM <E[#@BA��.�'>1HKJ1>1<ED/]YOQJ1Ua: >1VW@B[#@4> �.U=R DWAW<ED/]a[Bm7��FWJLUNF Ua[1@4> �.U

_`Ua:YFIME@B:Y@BDT>1HKJLb HKJh_LVW<?>#@B_`>18WJ1@B[^m'< � @!��_`UaDW[1<EA/@^Jh<ED/])[��N@��$D/@B[L[�:=H� /<E:=<E[LHK>1<?UaD UaD=9PUN>1VY>1V/@v� �&���v� �E� � 2

������%���GAWHK>1H :lHK>#JL< rHNDWA <?>1[\>#JLHNDW[#FPUa[#@!�,�DWHNMEUN]NUa8W[*FIJ1UNFPUa[1HNME[4UNO_`Ua:YFIM?@B:Y@BDZ>1HKJ1b HKJL_hVW<?>#@B_`>18/JL@B[

@� /<E[#>&<ED <E:=HK]N@HNDWHNM?b'[1<E[^maV/U ��@^jN@^J�@B:YFIM?U b7< D/])H)AW< �P@^J1@BDT>�UN9���@B_`>1<?jN@!�&� UNJ1@^U jN@^JBmZ>1VW@0>#UNFI<E_0[#@^FIHKJhHK>1<?UaD

qs< � @!�i_^ME8I[#>#@^JL<ED/]iHKJLUa8WDWA >1VW@=>#UNFI<E_^[e<EDWV/@^JL@BDT>4<EDr>1V/@ _`UNJLFI8W[ht�FP@^J1OQUNJL:Y@BA 9Zb�>1V/@=RIJL[#>*HKJh_LVW<?>#@B_`>18WJ1@

HNDWAG>1V/@��N@^b �.UNJLAi<EAW@BDT>1<SR _^HK>1<?UaDGFWJ1U j7<EAW@BA 97b�>1V/@*[#@B_`UaDWAdHKJL_LVW<E>#@B_`>18/J1@4HKJ1@4>1VW@BDC8WDW<SRI@BAG<EDCHY[L<ED/]aM?@

HNM?]NUNJL<E>1VW: <ED�UaD/@YUNO�>1V/@=[1@B_`>1<?UaDW[4UNO.>1VW<E[4J1@^FPUNJ1>��=��VW<E[)< [�FIHKJ1>1<E_^8WM HKJLM?bd8W[1@^OQ8WM�>#Ud@B:YFIM?U b,<ED�_^HN[1@B[

�$V/@^JL@4>1V/@^J1@e<E[$H [1:=HNMEM [LHN:YFIM?@*[L< %^@4UNO&AWHK>1H <EDW[#>1HNDW_`@B[eqsA/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[ht ��� [1<E:YF;M?@4<E:YFIME@B:Y@BDT>1HK>1<EUaDi<E[

FWJ1U j7< A/@BAfm �$V/Ua[#@Y_`Ua:YF;M?@� '<E>kb < [�M <ED/@BHKJ)<ED,>1V/@YDZ8I:*9P@^J�UNO�>#JhHN<EDW<ED/] FPUa<EDT>1[ � �'<E:e8WMEHK>1<EUaDdJ1@B[L8WM?>1[�HKJ1@

]a<?jN@BDCUaDdj HKJh<?Ua8W[0[18/9;[#@^>1[0UNO�>1V/@\nKo��k�@��$[#]NJ1Ua8/F;[$_`UNJ1FI8I[��

� !?9"+ � #5& �'� ( � � 6 � FPUa<EDZ>1[*Ua8/>e>1V/@�J1@BMEHK>1<?UaD UNO�[��N@��$DW@B[1[ :=H� '< :=<E[1HK>1<?UaD m�HN[ H,[#b7:l:Y@^>#JL<E_ HNM?]NU �

JL<?>1VI: qs< � @!� �VW<E_LV >#JL@BHK>1[&>1V/@�A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[�HNDWAY>1VW@ ��UNJLAI[�<ED >1V/@�[1HN:Y@ ��HBbWt�>#U*H�JL@B_`@BDT>1M?bY<EDZ>#J1U'AW8W_`@BA

0

Page 18: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

FWJ1UN9;HK9I<EME<E[1>1<E_[1b7:=:=@^>#JL<E_)HNM?]NUNJL<E>1VW: OQUNJA/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>$_`UaMEM?@B_`>1<EUaDW[^mW>1V/@\!&J1UN9IHK9;<EME<E[#>1< _��HK>#@BDT>4�7@B:=HNDZ>1<E_

��DWHNM?b'[1<E[�qs!����'�)t � � >�<E[ @� 'FP@^JL<E:Y@BDZ>1HNMEM?b)[1VWU �$D\>1VWHK>�<ED*[#Ua:=@.[1<E>18WHK>1<?UaDW[�>1V/@.> �.U�HNME]NUNJL<?>1VW:=[�FWJ1U'AW8W_`@

jN@^J1bC[1<E:l<EMEHKJ�HNDWAi_`Ua:=FIHKJLHK9IM?@*J1@^FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaDW[$UaDi>1V/@*>#@� 7>�AWHK>1H��.�U �.@^jN@^JBmP>1V/@4FIJ1UNFPUa[#@BAC:Y@^>1V/U'A

�.UNJ��7[)< D HG[1:=HNM M�AW< :Y@BDW[1<?UaDIHNM����/� [18/9I[1FIHN_`@eHNDIA,< [�[L8W<?>#@BA >#UC>1V/@ >#UNFI<E_^HNM�HNDWHNM?b'[1<E[UNO�A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>

_`UNJ1FPUNJLHYHNM?JL@BHNA/b�[1>#UNJ1@BA qs<EDIA/@� 7@BA t&97bC���7� �

� !?9"+ � #5& �'� ( � �(� � FIJ1@B[#@BDZ>1[4Hd8WDI<SRI@BA,>1V/@^UNJ1@^>1<E_^HNM�OgJhHN:Y@���UNJ��,OQUNJ*FIJ1UN9IHK9I<EM <E[#>1<E_eMEHK>#@BDZ>4j HKJh<EHK9IM?@

:YU'A/@BMEME< D/]/m �$<?>1V @B:YFIVIHN[1<E[�UaDl:=U7A/@BM ME<ED/]�AW<E[1_`JL@^>#@�AWHK>1H'mZ@!� ]���>#@� '>�����D=HNAWAW<?>1<EUaD >#U*_^ME8W[#>#@^Jh<ED/]/m!�$VW< _LV

<E[lFIHKJ1>lUNO)>1VW@ [#b'[#>#@B:Cm�>1VW@ :YU'A/@BM$HNM M?U �$[lOgUNJ�j'<E[18WHNME< [1HK>1<?UaD 97b6>#UNF UN]NJhHKFIVW<E_CUNJL]aHNDW<E[1HK>1<?UaD�����V/@

:Y@^>1V/U'Ar< [4A/@B[1<?]aDW@BA�>#Ud_^HKFW>18/JL@ [#>#JL8I_`>18/J1@=<ED�>1VW@lAWHK>1Hi>1VIHK>\:=H �N@B[e[#@BDW[#@lOgUNJeHiVZ8I:=HND�UN9I[#@^JLjN@^JBm

@!� ]�� UNJLA/@^JL< D/],AWU7_^8W:=@BDT>1[=< D [L8W_LV6H�:=HNDID/@^JY>1VWHK>Y>1V/@B:=HK>1< _^HNM?b [1< :=<EMEHKJ A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[YHKJ1@i:=HKFWFP@BA

_^M?Ua[#@�>#UY@BHN_hVCUN>1V/@^J�<ED >1VW<E[.UNJLA/@^Jh<ED/]�����< � @^JL@BDT>1M?b OgJLUa: >1VW@�DWUaD�� FWJ1UN9IHK9;<EME<E[#>1< _�� ���0�I��� V/U ��@^jN@^J m

Ua8/Je:YU7AW@BM�<E[4AW@B[1_`JL<?9P@BA <EDrHiOs8WMEM?b,FWJ1UN9IHK9;<EME<E[#>1< _���HBbrHNDIAr<?>1[\:YU7AW@BMEME<ED/]GFPU �.@^J\< [*Hd_`UaDI[#@BXZ8W@BDW_`@

UNO�<E:YFPUa[1<ED/] _`@^J1>1HN<ED D/UaD�� ��HN8W[1[1< HND,HN[L[18W:YFW>1<EUaDW[�U jN@^J4>1V/@=HN[L[18W:Y@BA 8WDWAW@^JLM?b'<ED/]l]N@BDW@^JLHK>1<?jN@=MEHK>#@BDZ>

OsHN_`>#UNJL[��

��VW@�[#b'[#>#@B:"� [�D/Ua< [#@�< [�:YU'A/@BM?@BA <ED�H\F;HKJLHN:Y@^>#JL<E_$OgUNJh:Cm/HN[.H :Y@B:\9P@^J�UNO�>1V/@@� 'FPUaD/@BDZ>1<EHNM OQHN:=< M?b

UNO AW<E[1>#JL<?9I8/>1<EUaDW[�HNDWA=>1VW< [�HNMEM?U �$[�8I[&>#U A/@BHNM �$<E>1VlAW< �P@^J1@BDZ>qs_`UaDZ>1<EDZ8WUa8W[�HNDIAlAW<E[L_`J1@^>#@ t�> bZFP@B[�UNO AWHK>1H

<EDeH8IDW<SRI@BA*OgUNJL:lHNMZOQJLHN:Y@��.UNJ�� ����[�H�FIHKJ1>1<E_^8WM HKJ�_^HN[#@�UNOI>1VW@.:YU'A/@BM m �$VW@BD ��HN8I[1[1<EHNDeD/Ua<E[#@�<E[�_LV/Ua[1@BDfm

>1V/@ ����� HNM?]NUNJh<?>1VW: JL@B[18WM?>1[����U �.@^jN@^JBmf>1V/@ AW<E[L_`J1@^>#@*OQUNJL:e8WMEHK>1<?UaDW[ ��@eOgU'_^8W[UaD < Di>1VW<E[$FIHKFP@^JAW<EO �

OQ@^J$97bG< :YFIM?b'<ED/]Y�.J1@^]a:=HND AW<?jN@^J1]N@BDW_^<E@B[$HN[�:Y@BHN[18/J1@B[$UNO�AW<E[1[1< :=<EMEHKJL<E>kb=9P@^> �.@^@BD,AWHK>1HlHNDWAiJ1@^Og@^JL@BDW_`@

FPUa<EDZ>1[^m <EDW[#>#@BHNA UNO�>1V/@ ��8W_^ME< A/@BHND AW<E[#>1HNDW_`@!�=�$V/@B[#@=HNME[#UiAW@`R;D/@ >1V/@l:=HK>1_hVW<ED/]iDWUaDWME<ED/@BHKJ�J1@BM HK>1<?UaDW[

9P@^> �.@^@BD�MEHK>#@BDZ>�HNDIA UN9;[#@^J1jN@BA jKHKJL<EHK9IM?@B[UNO�>1VW@e]N@BDW@^JLHK>1<?jN@Y:YU'A/@BM �)��V/@eFWJ1UNFPUa[#@BA :YU'A/@BM�_^HND�HNME[#U

9P@�[1@^@BDCHN[0HeAIHK>1H��kA/JL<?jN@BDCD/Ua< [#b=D/UaDWME< D/@BHKJ��1"�� _`Ua:*9I< D/@BA �<?>1VGHeAIHK>1H��kA/JL<?jN@BDGFIHKJhHN:Y@^>#JL<E_�:=< '>18/J1@

:YU'A/@BMEME< D/]l@BM?@B:=@BDT>��Y��V/@Y_`Ua:\9I<ED/@BA�:=U7A/@BM�HNM?UaDW]��$<?>1V,>1V/@=HN[1[#U'_^<EHK>#@BA�@B[1>1<E:=HK>1<?UaD�FIJ1U7_`@BAI8/J1@B[�HNM �

M?U �$[\8I[\>#U <EDZ>#@^J1FWJ1@^>\>1V/@�j7<E[L8WHNME<E[1HK>1<EUaD�Ua8/>#FI8/>�� � 'FP@^JL<E:Y@BDZ>1HNM&JL@B[18WM?>1[eA/@B:YUaDW[1>#JLHK>#@ >1VW@�AW< [1_`J1@^>#@

jN@^JL[1<EUaDW[�UNO�>1V/@=:=U7A/@BM�HN[)HGjKHNME8WHK9IME@\>#U7UaM�OgUNJ)>1VW@=AW<E[1_`U jN@^J1bdUNO�8WDWA/@^JhM?b7< D/]l[#@B:=HNDZ>1<E_ [#>#JL8I_`>18/J1@Y<ED

@B<?>1V/@^J�9I< DWHKJ1bCUNJ ��UNJhA�� U7_^_^8WJ1J1@BDW_`@ 9IHN[#@BA _`U'AW<ED/] UNO�>#@� '>)A/U7_^8I:Y@BDT>1[ �4�D,@� /HN:YFIM?@ HKFWFIME< _^HK>1<?UaDdUNO

VWHNDWA ��JL<?>#>#@BDiAI<?]a<?>1[�_`Ua:YFIJ1@B[1[1<?UaD HNDWAij'<E[18IHNME<E[1HK>1<?UaDC< [$HNME[#U ]a<?jN@BDi97b���HBbiUNO&A/@B:=UaDW[#>#JLHK>1<?UaDdUNO�>1V/@

FWJ1UNFPUa[#@BAC:=U7A/@BM �

4

Page 19: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

� !?9"+ � #5& �'� ( � � � � FWJLUNF Ua[1@B[HGD/U jN@BM�FIJ1UN9IHK9I<EM <E[#>1<E_)MEHK>#@BDZ> � jKHKJL<EHK9IM?@ :Y@^>1V/U'A,OgUNJ�>#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVI<E_4j'< �

[18WHNM <E[1HK>1<?UaD UNOfA/b'DWHN:=<E_�AWHK>1H*@!� ]���>#@� 7> � 9;HN[#@BA < D/OgUNJh:=HK>1<?UaDfm!�$VI<E_LV=_^HNDl9P@�[#@^@BDlHN[�H4_`Ua:YFIM?@B:=@BDT>1HKJ1b

>#U7UaM�OQUNJ\>#UNF;<E_lA/@^>#@B_`>1<EUaD HNDIAr>#JLHN_��7< D/] HKFWF;ME<E_^HK>1<?UaDW[ �i��V/@ :=U7A/@BM�<E[*[L8W<?>#@BA >#U HNDZb�UNO�>1V/@l�@B_`>#UNJ

�7FIHN_`@ J1@^FIJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaDW[��e��V/@Y<EA/@BHGV/@^J1@Y<E[�>1V/@ @� 'FIM?Ua<?>1HK>1<EUaD UNO�>1V/@(� � ���M� ����AWUa:=HN<ED �7DWU �$M?@BAW]N@eUNO

>1V/@�@� /<E[#>#@BDI_`@�UNOPJ1@BMEHK>1<?jN@BM?b V/Ua:YUN]N@BDW@^Ua8W[&>#@B:YFPUNJLHNMI[#@^]a:Y@BDZ>1[�<ED >1VW@$<ED/OQUNJL:=HK>1<?UaDY[1>#J1@BHN: J1@^]aHKJhAW<ED/]

>1V/@)>#UNFI< _)<EDTjNUaMEjN@BA��&��DCH=AW< �P@^J1@BDZ>�:lHNDWD/@^J�OQJ1Ua: >#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVW< _^HNMf>#@B_LVWDI<EXZ8W@B[�FWJ1@^j'<?Ua8W[1M?b 8/>1<EME< %^@BA�OQUNJ

[#>1HK>1<E_4>#@� 7>�_`UaMEM?@B_`>1<?UaDW[<EDG>1V/@*:=U7A/@BM FWJ1UNFPUa[#@BACV/@^J1@Nm;>1V/@4>#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVZbC<E[0HNDiUa8W>1_`Ua:Y@*UNO�>1V/@*_`UaVW@^J��

@BDW_`@�<ED >1<E:Y@=UNO�>1V/@ AWHK>1Hi[#>#J1@BHN: �C�'< :\8WM HK>1<?UaD J1@B[18WME>1[�UaD UNJLA/@^JL@BA D/@��$[*]NJ1Ua8/Fr:Y@B[L[1HK]N@B[\HNDIA�UaD

��DT>#@^JLDW@^>$_LVWHK>ME<ED/@)AW<E[L_^8W[1[1<?UaDGHNDWHNMEb7[1< [0HKJ1@)FWJ1U j7<EAW@BA��

��D � & � !.-�#0* � � � ��� � m$[1Ua:Y@ FIJ1@BME<E:=< DWHKJ1brJL@B[18WM?>1[ J1@��I@B_`>1<EDW] :\bc_`UaMEMEHK9PUNJLHK>1<?UaD �$<?>1Vc>1V/@ !�VW�

[#>18WAW@BDT>�� �T��<ED/]aVWHN: OgJ1Ua: >1V/@$�@BME[1<ED��'</+�DW<?j ��UNOf��@B_LVWD/UaMEUN]NbCqs��+��t �$VI<EM?@�j7< [1<?>1<ED/]�HKJ1@FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>#@BA��

��DcHKFWFIM <E_^HK>1<?UaD6UNO)H JL@B_`@BDT>1M?b6<EDZ>#J1U'AW8W_`@BA6FIJ1@BAW<E_`>1<?jN@d�#"�� � J1@BMEHK>#@BA�:Y@^>1V/U'Afm�>#@^JL:Y@BA ".Ua:YFIM?@� /<?> b

!�8WJL[18W<?>Cq "�!�te>#Ur_LVIHK> ME<EDW@�AWHK>1HrFWJ1U'AW8W_`@BA <ED ��DT>#@^JhD/@^>=J1@BMEH b6_LVWHK>=JLUZUa:=[lVWHN[=9P@^@BD68WDWAW@^J1>1H �N@BD

q >1VW<E[ 9P@B<ED/]rH M?UN]a<E_^HNM�_`UaDZ>1<ED78WHK>1<?UaD UNO*:\bcFWJ1U��#@B_`>1<?UaD�� 9;HN[#@BA�HKFIFWJ1UaHN_LVW@B[G>#U ��HKJLAW[CA/b'DWHN:=<E_^HNM M?b

@^jNUaM?j'<ED/],>#@� 7>18IHNM.AIHK>1H�� ��@G@� 7FP@^JL<E:=@BDT>1HNMEMEb,OQUa8WDWA >1VWHK> >1V/@CAW<?JL@B_`>1<?UaDW[4UNO�:=<EDW< :\8W: _`Ua:YFIM?@� /<?>kb

>1<E:Y@Y[#@^Jh<?@B[�@� 7>#JhHN_`>#@BA 97b >1V/@ "0!�HNM?]NUNJL<?>1VI: _^HNDr<EA/@BDZ>1<?Ogbd>1V/@=:Y@BHNDW<EDW]NOQ8WM�>#UNFI< _^[)<ED,>1V/@=A/b'DWHN:=<E_

>#@� '>�AIHK>1H��&� �.HN[�JL@B[#FPUaDW[1<?9IME@0OgUNJ�>1V/@�<EA/@BH\UNO >1V/@�FIHKFP@^J.HNDIAlFIHKJL>1M?bYOgUNJ�@BAW<E>1<ED/]*>1VW@>#@� '>�����[1VWUNJ1>#@^J

jN@^JL[1<EUaDiVWHN[09P@^@BDCFWJL@B[#@BDT>#@BAd<ED �;!?9"+ � #5& �'� ( � �10 � �

����� � ��� � �� ��� ������ ��� ���� � ��� ��� �

��VI<E[ >1V/@B[1<E[l<E[YUNJ1]aHNDW< %^@BAc<ED6[#@^jN@BD _LVIHKFW>#@^JL[l< D �$VW<E_hV >1V/@^J1@dHKJL@d> �.UrJL@^j7<?@�� �k_LVWHKFW>#@^Jh[^m�>1V/J1@^@

_LVIHKFW>#@^JL[$[L8W:=:=HKJL< %B<ED/]eUNJL<?]a<EDWHNMf_`UaDZ>#JL<?9;8/>1<?UaDW[.UNO�>1V/@4HN8/>1V/UNJ�HNDWAGUaD/@*_`UaDI_^ME8WAW<EDW] _hVWHKFW>#@^J �

��D,"�VIHKFW>#@^J�n7mPH=JL@^j7<?@�� UNO�>1V/@e<E:YFPUNJ1>1HNDZ>�@� '< [#>1<ED/]=]N@BDW@^JLHK>1<?jN@Y:YU'A/@BME[�<E[$FWJ1U j7<EAW@BA�����V/@B[#@eHKJ1@

HNMEM;FPU �.@^J1OQ8IM;HNDWA�>1V/@^UNJL@^>1<E_^HNMEM?b=FIJL<EDW_^<?F;M?@BA=_`Ua:YFI8W>1HK>1<?UaDWHNMP<EDZ>#@BMEME<?]N@BDW_`@�:Y@^>1V/U'AW[��$<?>1V�H��<EA/@�JLHND/]N@

UNO�HKFWFIME<E_^HK9;<EME<?> b!�\��V/@ J1@^j'<?@�� FWJLU j'<EA/@BA�V/@^J1@YA/U7@B[4D/UN>4[1@^@��,>#UCFIJ1U j'<EA/@YHND�@� /VWHN8W[#>1<EjN@Y>#J1@BHK>1:Y@BDZ>��

��V/@)OQU'_^8W[�<E[�>#U=FIJ1U j'<EA/@)>1V/@4DW@B_`@B[1[1HKJ1bG9IHN_��Z]NJ1Ua8IDWACOQUNJ�>1V/@ �.UNJ��G>#U=9P@�FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>#@BAd<EDG>1VW@4_LVWHKFW>#@^Jh[

Page 20: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

�$VW< _LVGOQUaMEM?U ���

"�VIHKFW>#@^J���<E[&H�JL@^j7<?@��cUNO MEHK>#@BDZ>�[#>#Jh8W_`>18/J1@�:YU'A/@BM'>#@B_hVWDW<EX78/@B[ �$VI<E_LV HKJ1@$< DY8W[#@0OQUNJ&>#@� 7>�HNDWHNM?b'[1<E[��

��V/@ <EA/@BHrUNO4>1V/@ UN9I[#@^JLjN@BA �.UNJLAW[ 9P@B<ED/] H D/Ua< [#b6@� 7F;HNDW[1<?UaD�UNO*[#Ua:Y@�:YUNJL@,A/@BDI[#@,8ID/UN9I[#@^J1jKHK9IM?@

_`UaDW_`@^FW>1[ � _LVIHKJLHN_`>#@^JL<E[#>1< _C>#U ]N@BD/@^JLHK>1<EjN@ :YU'A/@BMEME< D/]"� _^HND69P@COgUaMEMEU �.@BA6>1V/J1Ua8/]aVWUa8/>�� �$U ��@^jN@^J

UaDWM?bYH\Og@�� UNOf>1V/@�>#@B_LVWDI<EXZ8W@B[�:=H �N@�>1VW<E[�HN[1[18W:=FW>1<?UaDY@� 'FIME<E_^<E>�<EDlH*FWJL<EDI_^<?FIM?@BA)��HBbNm/HNDWA�[#Ua:Y@UNO >1V/@

HKFWFWJLUaHN_LV/@B[_`UaDT>1HN<ED H ]NJ1@BHK>AW@BHNMfUNO�VW@B8/JL<E[#>1< _^[��

��VW@�FWJ1@B[1@BDT>1HK>1<?UaD <E[�[#>#JL8I_`>18/J1@BAe<ED*>1VW@.[1HN:=@.:=HNDID/@^J�HN[&"�VIHKFW>#@^J.p.[1V/U �$<ED/]>1V/@�HNDWHNM?UN]a<?@B[�<ED\>1V/@

>kb7FP@�UNO >1V/@)[#>#JL8W_`>18WJ1@B[�HNDWA�J1@^FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaDW[��$VI<E_LV�@� /<E[#>.OgUNJ�>#@� '>�AWHK>1H � AW@BDW[#@)AW<E[#>#Jh<?9I8/>#@BAYJL@^FWJ1@��

[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaDW[^ma:l< 7>18WJ1@�JL@^FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaDW[^ma[1FIHKJL[#@.AW<E[#>#JL<E9I8/>#@BA4JL@^FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaDW[�HNDWAeJ1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>1HK>1<EUaDW[ �$<?>1V

>#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVW< _^HNM _^HKFIHK9I<EM <?>1<?@B[��&��VW@^J1@4HKJ1@*_^M?@BHKJFWJL<EDI_^<?FIM?@B[.<EDi�,HN_LVW< D/@*� @BHKJhDW<ED/] J1@B[#@BHKJh_LV OgUNJ$HN_hVW<?@^j �

<ED/]Y>1VW@B[#@4UN9��#@B_`>1<?jN@B[��.� ><E[�A/@B[1<EJ1Ua8W[�>#U :=U7AW<EOgb�HNDWAiA/@^jN@BM?UNF,[#Ua:Y@4UNO�>1V/@B[1@*:YU'A/@BME[�[#FP@B_^<SR _^HNMEM?b=OQUNJ

>#@� '>18WHNM�AWHK>1H'm;HN[�>1VW<E[ �.Ua8WMEACHNM M?U �-Hl:YUNJ1@)FWJL< DW_^<?FIM?@BA >#J1@BHK>1:Y@BDZ>$UNO�>#@� '>�J1@^FWJ1@B[1@BDT>1HK>1<?UaD��

"�VIHKFW>#@^J�-e<E[�HND @� /HN:YFIM?@UNOf@� 7>#@BDWAI<ED/]*HND @� '< [#>1<ED/]4FIJL<EDW_^<?F;M?@BAej7<E[L8WHNME<E[1HK>1<EUaDY>#@B_LVWDI<EXZ8W@$<EDW<?>1< HNMEM?b

A/@B[1<E]aD/@BA OQUNJ\_`UaDZ>1<ED78/Ua8W[4JL@BHNM�jKHNME8/@BA AWHK>1Hi>#U,>1V/@l_^HN[#@�UNO�AW<E[L_`J1@^>#@ AWHK>1H��i� UNJ1@�FWJ1@B_^<E[1@BM?bNm�Hd]N@BD��

@^JLHNMf8WDI<SRI@BA FWJ1UN9IHK9I< ME<E[#>1<E_$>1V/@^UNJ1@^>1<E_^HNM OgJLHN:=@���UNJ�� OgUNJAWHK>1HYHNDWHNM?b'[1<E[�HNDWAGj'<E[18WHNM <E[1HK>1<?UaD 9Zb�:Y@BHNDW[0UNO

>#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVW< _*UNJ1]aHNDI<E[1HK>1<?UaD HNDWA _^ME8W[1>#@^JL<ED/]�<E[$FIJ1@B[#@BDZ>#@BA�<EDd>1VI<E[_hVWHKFW>#@^JBm��<?>1V,>1V/@\@B:=FIVWHN[1<E[9P@B<ED/]

UaD,AW<E[1_`J1@^>#@ _^HN[#@eOgUNJh:\8WM HK>1<?UaDW[�HN[$>1VW< [<E[HKFWFWJ1UNFIJL<EHK>#@*OQUNJ�>#@� 7>18WHNM�AWHK>1H�����V/@��N@^bd<E[1[L8/@��$VI<E_LV AW<E[ �

>1<ED/]a8I<E[1V/@B[0>1VI<E[�OQJ1Ua: >1V/@e< DW<?>1<EHNMf:YU'A/@BM�OgUNJ�_`UaDZ>1<EDZ8WUa8W[AIHK>1H <E[$>1V/@ HKFWFWJ1UNFWJh<EHK>#@*AW<E[1>1HNDW_`@\:Y@BHN[L8/J1@

�$VW< _LV @B:Y@^J1]N@B[ OQJ1Ua: >1VW@G[L8W<?>1HK9IM?@ :YU7AW@BME[��,� >e>18/JLDW[\Ua8/> >1VWHK>eOgUNJ >1V/@C_^HN[#@GUNO$AI<E[1_`J1@^>#@GAWHK>1H,>1V/@

HKFWFWJLUNFWJL<EHK>#@eAW<E[1[1< :=<EMEHKJL<E>kbl:Y@BHN[L8/J1@B[�>#U�8I[#@\HKJ1@ jKHKJL<EHNDZ>1[$UNO���JL@^]a:=HND AW<?jN@^J1]N@BDW_^<E@B[^m < Dd_`UaDZ>#JLHN[#>�>#U

>1V/@d��8W_^ME<EAW@BHND AI<E[#>1HNDW_`@Nm��$VW<E_hV6<E[Y[18W<E>1HK9IM?@GUaDWM?b OgUNJlJ1@BHNM0jKHNME8/@BA6_`UaDZ>1<EDZ8WUa8W[=AWHK>1H�� �$FWF;ME<E_^HK>1<?UaD

@� /HN:YFIM?@B[0UaDi>#@� 7>�HNDWACAW<?]a<?>1HNMf< :=HK]N@*AWHK>1H=HKJL@4]a<?jN@BD��

��D "�VWHKFI>#@^J�/7m�>1V/@l_^M 8W[#>#@^JL<EDW]GHNDIA j7<E[L8WHNME<E[1HK>1<EUaD,:=U7A/@BM�< [)_`UaDW[1<EA/@^JL@BA OgUNJ4>1VW@l_^HN[#@=UNO�A/b'DWHN:)�

<E_^HNMEMEb @^jNUaM?j'<ED/] AWHK>1H�� � DI[#>#@BHNA UNO4H AI<?J1@B_`>=@� '>#@BDW[1<?UaDcUNO)>1V/@dFIJ1@^j7<EUa8W[1M?b FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>#@BAc:YU'A/@BME[ �$<?>1V

>1<E:Y@�� JL@BMEHK>1<?UaDW[^mZH4[1<E:YF;ME<SRI@BAe9I8/>&< D >1V/@$_^HN[#@UNO >#@B:=F UNJhHNMEM?b _`UaV/@^J1@BDZ>�AWHK>1H4[1>1<EMEM'@� 'FWJ1@B[1[1<EjN@�>#@B:YFPUNJLHNM

:YU'A/@BMf<E[0_`UaDW[L<EA/@^J1@BA��&�$VW<E[�<E[�FWJ1@^OQ@^J1J1@BACHN[$<?>�_`UaDT>1HN< DW[�_`UaDW[1< A/@^JLHK9IM?b Og@��.@^J�OQJ1@^@4HNDWAi:=U7A/@BMPF;HKJLHN:)�

@^>#@^JL[�HNDWA <E[HK9IM?@e>#U FWJLU j'<EA/@\HG[1< :YFIM?@4_^M?Ua[1@BA OQUNJL: [#UaME8/>1<EUaDdOQUNJ�HNDZbd> bZFP@eUNO�AWHK>1H���� HNDZb DIHK>18/JLHNM

Page 21: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

[#Ua8/Jh_`@B[4UNO�>1<E:Y@�� jKHKJ1b'<ED/]iAWHK>1H"� <EDW_^M 8WAW<ED/] >#UNFI<E_Y@^jNUaM 8/>1<?UaDr< D�Hi_`UaV/@^J1@BDZ>\AW< [1_^8W[1[1<EUaD � _`UaDZ>1HN<ED

>#@B:YFPUNJLHNMW[1@^]a:Y@BDT>1[��$<?>1V=J1@BMEHK>1<?jN@BM?bYV/Ua:=UN]N@BD/@^Ua8W[._`UaDT>#@BDZ>^m'>1V/@^J1@^OQUNJ1@ �.@VWH jN@$>1V/@�FIJL<?UNJ �'D/U �M?@BA/]N@

>1VWHK>.[1:YU7UN>1V _hVWHND/]N@B[�_^HNDl9P@@� 7FP@B_`>#@BA�<EDY>1V/@�MEHK>#@BDT>.J1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>1HK>1<EUaD [#F;HN_`@!�&��VW<E[&HNM M?U �$[�8W[�>#U\[1VW<EOg>

>1V/@@BM?@B:Y@BDZ>�J1@B[1F UaDI[1<?9IM?@�OQUNJ�>1VW@$>#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVW< _^HNMI_^HKFIHK9I< ME<?>1<?@B[�UNOf>1VW@:YU'A/@BMWOQJ1Ua: >1V/@[1FIHK>1<EHNMIAWUa:=HN<ED

>#Ul>1VW@4>#@B:YFPUNJLHNMfUaD/@!���FWFIME<E_^HK>1<EUaDG@� 'HN:YF;M?@B[�OQJ1Ua: @^jNUaM?j'<ED/]l>#@� 7>�HNDWAijKHKJL<?Ua8W[�UN>1V/@^J$@� /HN:YFIM?@B[HKJ1@

FWJ1U j7< A/@BA��

"�VIHKFW>#@^J 0l<E[$A/@^jNUN>#@BA >#UG<EDTjN@B[1>1<?]aHK>1<?UaDW[$UNO&HNDi�1"�� � JL@BMEHK>#@BA M <ED/@BHKJ0FWJ1U��#@B_`>1<?UaD,:Y@^>1V/U'Ai>#U >#UNFI<E_

HNDWHNM?b'[1<E[$<EDi>#@� '>��$��V/@*FWJ1U��#@B_`>1<?UaDd:Y@^>1VWU7A �.HN[�HNA/UNFW>#@BA,V/@^J1@\>#U HBjNUa< A >1VW@\_`Ua:YFI8W>1HK>1<?UaDWHNM 9;8/JLA/@BD

�$VW< _LV$��Ua8WM A,HKJh<E[#@e9Zbi@B:=FIM?U b'<ED/]GHG:YUNJ1@e]N@BD/@^JLHNM���DWA/@^FP@BDWA/@BDZ>'!IHN_`>#UNJ*�DIHNM?b7[L<E[:=U7A/@BM ���.b,_`UaD��

>#JLHN[#>�>#UGFWJ1@^j'<?Ua8W[ �.UNJ��d<ED >1VW<E[$RI@BMEA UNO�HKFWF;ME<E_^HK>1<?UaDfm;>1V/@ UN9��#@B_`>1<?jN@ UNO�>1V/@eUNFW>1<E:=< %BHK>1<?UaD <E[AW@^JL<?jN@BA

OQJ1Ua:(>1V/@0HKFWFWJ1UaHN_hV/@BAYFWJLUN9IM?@B: HNDWA >1V/@0HBjKHN<EMEHK9IME@�AI<E[#>#JL<?9;8/>1<?UaDWHNMa_hVWHKJLHN_`>#@^JL< [#>1<E_^[�UNO;>1V/@0>#@� 7>18IHNM/AWHK>1H

HNDWA�<?>4< [�[LV/U �$D >1VWHK>4HC:Y@BHN[18/JL@YUNO.[��N@��D/@B[1[�UNO.>1V/@YFWJ1U��#@B_`>1<?UaDW[4< [�>1V/@=HKFWFWJ1UNFIJL<EHK>#@eUN9���@B_`>1<EjN@=>#U

:=H� /<E:=< %^@eOQUNJ�[1@^FIHKJLHK>1<ED/]�>1V/@e>#UNFI<E_^[�UNJ4<EA/@BDZ>1<?OQb7< D/]=>1V/@ �N@^b �.UNJLAW[�UNO�>1V/@B[#@ >#UNFI<E_^[�<EDWVW@^J1@BDT>�<ED >1V/@

A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>0_`UNJ1FI8W[��&��DCHNM?]NUNJL<E>1VW: �$VW<E_hV�F @^JLOgUNJL:l[�9PUN>1VGUNO�>1V/@B[#@)> �.U=>1HN[��'[�[1< :\8WME>1HND/@^Ua8W[1M?b=< [0HNME[#U

A/@^JL<EjN@BA HNDWA H [1<E:=FIM?@l<E:=FIM?@B:Y@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaD UNO<?>e<E[eFWJ1U j'<EA/@BA��,��VI<E[\< [\<EDIA/@^FP@BDWA/@BDZ>4UNO�>1V/@C[��N@��$DW@B[1[

UN9��#@B_`>1<?jN@ HNDIA6<E[=8W[#@^Os8WM �$<E>1V6HNDTb UN>1V/@^J UN9���@B_`>1<EjN@B[ �$V/@BD >1VW@d[1HN:YFIME@i[1< %^@i<E[=[L:=HNMEM �6��VW< [ ��Ua<EDZ>

HNM?]NUNJL<E>1VW: >#UN]N@^>1V/@^J �<?>1Vi>1V/@e[��N@��$D/@B[L[$FWJh<?UNJ$HNMEM?U �$[�8W[�>#U�FWJ1U j7<EAW@*H M <ED���>#U�[#Ua:=@*UNO&>1V/@\@� '< [#>1<ED/]

[#b':=:Y@^>#JL< _^HNM�:=HK>#Jh< � OsHN_`>#UNJL< %BHK>1<EUaD�:Y@^>1V/U'AW[�OgUNJ�>#@� '>�HNDIHNM?b7[L<E[^m �$VW<E_hV <ED,_`UaDZ>#JLHN[#>)>#UGUa8/J):Y@^>1V/U'Afm

J1@B_`UaDW[L<EA/@^J.>1V/@@BDZ>1<?J1@�A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ> �k<EDWA/@� /<ED/]*FWJ1UN9IM?@B: HNDWA ��UNJ��l<ED=>1VW@ �.UNJLAW[�[#FIHN_`@�JLHK>1V/@^J�>1VWHNDG<ED�H

MEHK>#@BDZ>)[#@B:=HNDZ>1<E_\[1FIHN_`@!�)� 'F @^Jh<E:Y@BDZ>1HNM�A/@B:=UaDW[#>#JLHK>1<?UaDI[HKJ1@eFWJ1U j7< A/@BAdUaD,jKHKJL<?Ua8W[�[#@^>#>1<EDW]a[UNO�>#UNFI<E_

_^MEHN[1[1@B[��

!�<EDWHNM M?bNm."�VWHKFI>#@^J�4 [18W:l[Y8/F6>1V/@iHN_LVI<?@^jN@B:Y@BDZ>1[^m0>#JLHN_^<ED/] [1Ua:Y@iFPUa[1[1<?9;M?@ Os8/>18/JL@GAI<?J1@B_`>1<?UaDW[ UNO

<EDZjN@B[#>1<?]aHK>1<?UaD��

p^o

Page 22: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

�� ��� ��� � �

����� �� ����� ������� � � � ���� � ��� ��� � ��� ��� �

��A/@BDZ>1<?Ogb'<ED/],>1V/@C[#>#JL8I_`>18/J1@ �$<?>1VW< D UNJ=@� '>#JLHN_`>1<ED/] :=@BHNDW<ED/]NOs8WM.<ED/OQUNJL:=HK>1<?UaD OgJLUa: _`UaMEM?@B_`>1<?UaDW[ UNO

:e8WM?>1<?jKHKJL<EHK>#@.AWHK>1H)<E[�UNO;:=H �#UNJ�<EDT>#@^JL@B[#>�<ED\HNDZb\AWUa:=HN<ED���"�M?@BHKJLM?bNmN<EDe>1V/@�:=H �#UNJL<?> b*UNO;HKJL@BHN[ �$<?>1VW<ED*>1V/@

FIVZb7[L<E_^HNMf[1_^<?@BDW_`@B[$HNDWAC@BD/]a<EDW@^@^JL<ED/]/m'UN9I[#@^JLj HK9IME@4AWHK>1H=<E[0[18W9���@B_`>$>#Ul:Y@BHN[18/JL@B:Y@BDT>�DWUa<E[#@!��� UNJ1@^U jN@^J m

J1@B[#@BHKJh_LV �.UNJ��N@^JL[�<ED)HKJ1@BHN[�[18W_LV*HN[ >1V/@&[#U'_^<EHNMa[L_^<?@BDW_`@B[fOQUNJ @� /HN:YFIM?@NmKHKJ1@�UNOQ>#@BD*<EDZ>#@^J1@B[#>#@BA\<ED):YU'A/@BMEME<EDW]

jKHKJL<EHK>1<?UaD HNDWA,_`U jKHKJL<EHK>1<?UaD UNO�>#JLHN<?>1[�>1VWHK>)_^HNDWD/UN>�9P@ :Y@BHN[18/J1@BA,AW<?JL@B_`>1M?b � -C0�� �)��V/@B[1@ 8ID/UN9I[#@^J1jKHK9IM?@

jKHKJL<EHK9IM?@B[Bm�>1V/@G[#U _^HNMEM?@BA*� �#� �$�%� J � ���M�E��� ��� m�HKJ1@�UNOg>#@BD >1V/@^UNJL@^>1<E_^HNM�_`UaDI_`@^FW>1[Y[18W_hV HN[ <EDZ>#@BMEME<?]N@BDI_`@=UNJ

[#U'_^<EHNMW_^MEHN[L[ � -C0�� m'[#U4>1VWHK>.<EDYFWJhHN_`>1<E_`@ �.@VWH jN@$>#U\:lH �N@:Y@BHN[18WJ1@B:Y@BDZ>1[&UaD=UN9;[#@^J1jKHK9IM?@�jKHKJL<EHK9IME@B[�>1VWHK>

HKJ1@*HN[L[18W:Y@BAG>#U�_`UaDT>1HN<EDd<ED/OQUNJL:=HK>1<?UaDCHK9PUa8/>0>1V/@*j HKJL< HK9IM?@B[0<ED �$VI<E_LV �.@*HKJ1@)J1@BHNM M?b�< DT>#@^J1@B[1>#@BA��

��D >1VW<E[�_LVIHKFW>#@^JBmT[#Ua:=@0UNO;>1V/@0<E:=F UNJL>1HNDT>�@� /<E[#>1<ED/]�:YU'A/@BME[�HNDWAY:Y@^>1VWU7AW[�>1VWHK>&HKJL@�[18W<?>1HK9IME@�OQUNJ�>1V/@

@� 'FIM?UNJLHK>1<?UaD UNO >1V/@�J1@BM HK>1<?UaDW[1VW<EFI[�9P@^> �.@^@BDCMEHK>#@BDZ>�HNDIAlUN9I[1@^J1j HK9;M?@$jKHKJL<EHK9IME@B[�HKJ1@�J1@^j'<?@��.@BA���� <E>1V/Ua8/>

[#@^@��'<ED/]Y>#U=9P@4HNDd@� 'VWHN8I[#>1<?jN@)>#J1@BHK>1:Y@BDZ>^m >1V/@)OgU'_^8W[�< [0UaDCFWJ1U j7< AW<ED/]YH 9IHN_��Z]NJ1Ua8IDWAiOQUNJ�>1V/@ �.UNJ���>#U

9P@)FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>#@BAi<EDCM HK>#@^J$_LVWHKFI>#@^JL[��

��@BDW@^JLHK>1<?jN@=:YU'A/@BME[�UNJ4MEHK>#@BDZ>)j HKJh<EHK9IM?@ :YU'A/@BME[�HKJ1@=[#>1HK>1<E[#>1< _^HNM�>#UZUaME[ �VW<E_LV,[#@^@�� HG:YUNJ1@=8W[#@^Os8WM

qs_`Ua:YFIHN_`>htYJ1@^FWJ1@B[1@BDT>1HK>1<?UaD UNO>1V/@CUN9;[#@^J1jN@BA AWHK>1H �Sp^oIm�pNpBn'm�p�/$-Wm�nKo/m�p��2�Wm /7m -C��� �6� >=<E[e>1V/@^J1@^OQUNJ1@

HN[1[18I:Y@BA <ED >1V/@B[#@ :=U7A/@BM [G>1VWHK>C>1V/@�� �kAW< :Y@BDW[1<?UaDIHNM$UN9I[1@^J1j HK9;M?@�AWHK>1H <E[G]N@BD/@^JhHK>#@BA�97b [#Ua:=@�� �AW<E:=@BDW[1<?UaDWHNM�qQ>kb7FI<E_^HNMEMEb�������t�8WD/UN9I[#@^JLjN@BA qsM HK>#@BDT>ht.jKHKJL<EHK9;M?@B[ �VW<E_LV m'<E>.<E[0VWUNF @BA m7_^HNDG9P@)<ED/OQ@^J1J1@BAOQJ1Ua:->1VW@�AWHK>1H�����VW< [ <E[�HN_hVW<?@^jN@BAe97b4HN[1[18W:=< D/]$HNDeHKFWFWJ1UNFWJh<EHK>#@�:YU'A/@BMaOQUNJ�>1VW@�]N@BD/@^JhHK>1<?UaD*FIJ1U7_`@B[L[�����D

>1VW<E[�_LVWHKFI>#@^JBm!��@��$<EM MNJ1@B[#>#JL< _`>�Ua8/JL[1@BM?jN@B[�>#U�>1V/@�_^HN[#@��$V/@BD �.@�_^HNDeHN[L[18W:Y@�>1VWHK>�>1VW@��#Ua<EDT>�AW<E[1>#JL<?9I8/>1<EUaD

UNO�HNDWA��6<E[$<EDWA/@^FP@BDWA/@BDZ>�HNDWAi<EA/@BDZ>1<E_^HNMEMEblAW<E[#>#Jh<?9I8/>#@BA qs< � < � A�� t ���-]N@BD/@^JhHNMfOgUNJh: UNO�>1V/@4:YU'A/@BM <E[

� q������Ct ��� q n �Ep t

pNp

Page 23: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

�$V/@^JL@ A/@BD/UN>#@B[4>1V/@ � �kAW<E:Y@BDI[1<?UaDWHNMfUN9;[#@^J1jN@BA jKHKJL<EHK9IM?@Nm q t$< [�H�Os8WDW_`>1<?UaD,UNO�>1V/@ � �kAW<E:=@BDW[1<?UaDWHNMMEHK>#@BDZ>4jKHKJL<EHK9IM?@ ��m�HNDWA � _`UaDZ>1HN<EDW[*>1V/@=:YU'A/@BM�FIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^JL[ �$<?>1V � ��� � >1V/@=:=U7A/@BM�D/Ua<E[#@ 9P@B<ED/]<EDWAW@^F @BDIA/@BDT>�UNO ���Sp^o/m:-C0�� �0��VW@)RIJL[#>$>#@^JL: UaDd>1V/@*Jh<?]aVT>�VWHNDWAi[L<EA/@ qQJ � V�� [�� tlUNO$q n �Ep t�<E[$>#@^JL:Y@BA >1V/@

� 4 ��� ���U�#�<� �v� ��������� �$�%�.UNOf>1V/@�:=U7A/@BM+�$VW<EME@�>1V/@�[#@B_`UaDWA >#@^JL: <E[&>1V/@�[#U _^HNMEM?@BAg���B� � 1[�'���<� �A� �������#� ���%�

UNJ*:YU'A/@BM�D/Ua< [#@ �Sp^oWm&pNp��'m&pNpBn � � !W8/J1>1V/@^Jh:YUNJ1@Nm�<?>4< [)H �N@^b HN[L[18W:YFW>1<EUaD�<ED,]N@BD/@^JLHK>1<?jN@�:YU7AW@BME[�>1VWHK>

>1V/@*_`UaDIAW<?>1<?UaDWHNMPAW< [#>#JL<?9I8W>1<?UaDlU jN@^J>1VW@4AWHK>1HYjKHKJL<EHK9IM?@B[0[LV/Ua8WMEAGOsHN_`>#UNJL<E[#@ �Sp^o�� �

��q��� �����it ������ ��q� � � �����Gt q n � nat

��DGUN>1V/@^J �.UNJLAW[^m/>1V/@4AIHK>1H j HKJL< HK9IM?@B[� � � �� � HKJ1@4_`UaDWAI<?>1<?UaDWHNMEMEb=<EDWA/@^FP@BDWA/@BDZ>.]a<?jN@BDC>1V/@4MEHK>#@BDZ>0jKHKJL< �HK9IM?@B[ �rHNDIA �$����VI<E[�<E:=F Ua[1@B[&>1V/@�_`UaDW[#>#JLHN<EDZ>.>1VWHK>�>1VW@MEHK>#@BDZ>�jKHKJL<EHK9;M?@B[ �$< MEMW_^HKJ1J1bY>1VW@A/@^FP@BDWA/@BDI_`b

[#>#JL8I_`>18/J1@C<EDWV/@^JL@BDT>Y<ED >1V/@iAIHK>1H HNDWA6[#U�>1V/@i:=U7A/@BM �<EMEM�9 @iHK9;M?@G>#U @� 7>#JhHN_`>=j HNM 8WHK9IM?@C[#>#JL8I_`>18/J1@BA

<ED/OQUNJL:=HK>1<EUaD�< D >1VW@lqQ>kb7FI<E_^HNMEM?b J1@BAW8W_`@BACAI<E:Y@BDW[1<EUaDWHNMgt�M HK>#@BDT>�jKHKJL<EHK9;M?@B[.OgJ1Ua: >1VW@4:\8WME>1<?j HKJh<EHK>#@)AWHK>1H��

��V/@_`UaDWAW<?>1<?UaDIHNMWAW<E[#>#Jh<?9I8/>1<?UaD ��q��� � ���Gt&<E[&A/@`R D/@BA=97b >1V/@$AW<E[1>#JL<?9I8/>1<EUaD\UNOf>1VW@$D/Ua<E[#@���q��$thmT>#UN]N@^>1V/@^J�$<?>1VG>1VW@*:YU'A/@BM&q n �Ep t �

��[1[18W:l<ED/]*H\FIHKJ1>1<E_^8IMEHKJ�:YU'A/@BM;[#>#JL8W_`>18/JL@�� m7>1V/@�:=U7A/@BMIOgUNJ�>1V/@�AW<E[#>#Jh<?9I8/>1<?UaD ��q��� � ��� t�UNO >1V/@UN9I[#@^JLjN@BAiAWHK>1Hl< [�>1V/@BDCUN9W>1HN<EDW@BAC9ZbG:=HKJ1]a< DWHNME<E[1< D/]*U jN@^J>1V/@\MEHK>#@BDT>$j HKJL< HK9IM?@B[

��q� � � ��� t �� ��q��� ����� ��� t ��q���� � ��� t� � q n ���at

HNDWA >1V/@Y>#JhHN_`>1HK9I<EME<?> bdUNO.>1VW<E[�<EDZ>#@^]NJLHNM&<E[�_`JL8I_^<EHNM�<ED RI>#>1<ED/]CHC_`@^J1>1HN< D�>kb7FP@YUNO�FIHKJLHN:=@^>#JL<E_Y:YU'A/@BM�>#U

>1V/@*AIHK>1H �Sp^o/m pNpBn�� �

��M?]NUNJL<?>1VI:=[4VWH j7<EDW]dAW< �P@^J1@BDZ>*_`Ua:YFI8/>1HK>1<EUaDWHNM�M?UaHNAI<ED/]a[4HKJ1@ J1@BX78W<?J1@BA AW@^F @BDIAW<ED/]GUaD >1VW@ _LVWUa<E_`@

UNO0>1V/@ OQ8WDI_`>1<?UaD q t*HNDWAr>1V/@lOQUNJL: UNO0>1VW@ HN[1[18I:Y@BArAW< [#>#JL<?9I8W>1<?UaD,UaD � HNDWA � �i� ]NJ1@BHK> HN:YUa8WDZ>UNO0ME<?>#@^JLHK>18WJ1@=<E[4_`UaDW_`@^JhD/@BA �$<E>1V�_`UaDW[1<EA/@^Jh<ED/]3@Zq t4HN[*HiME< D/@BHKJ)OQ8IDW_`>1<?UaD �Sp��547m�p�/$-Im�p��2�'m;/�� � ��<ED/@BHKJ

:YU'A/@BME[�J1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>�H)_^MEHN[L[�UNOIJ1@BMEHK>1<EjN@BM?b*[1<E:=FIM?@�:=U7A/@BM [�bN@^> �$<?>1VeXZ8W<E>#@�[1>#J1UaD/]):YU'A/@BMEME<EDW]_^HKFIHK9I< ME<?>1<?@B[��

� U7A/@BM [.[L8W_LVCHN[0�,< '>18/J1@��dU'A/@BME[^m !WHN_`>#UNJ��DIHNM?b7[L<E[^mZ!�J1UN9IHK9I< ME<E[#>1<E_$!&JL<EDI_^<?FIHNM "�Ua:YFPUaD/@BDT>���DWHNM?b'[1<E[^m

UNJ�ME<ED/@BHKJ� DWAW@^F @BDIA/@BDT>"�Ua:YFPUaD/@BDT>��DIHNM?b7[L<E[$_^HND 9P@*UN9W>1HN<EDW@BA)�18W[#>$97bCjKHKJ1b7< D/]=>1V/@ AW<E[#>#Jh<?9I8/>1<?UaDIHNM

HN[1[18I:YFW>1<?UaDW[ �Sp��54�� ���)D >1VW@�UN>1VW@^J�VWHNDWAfm/DWHK>18/JhHNMEM?bNm'HNMEM >1V/@B[#@)HN[1[18W:=FW>1<?UaDW[.VWHBjN@4He]NJ1@BHK><E:YFIHN_`>.UaD

�$VWHK>\>1V/@lJL@B[18WM?>1<EDW]iHNM?]NUNJL<?>1VW:l[*HKJ1@�A/Ua<ED/]iUaD Hd_`@^JL>1HN<ED AIHK>1H [#@^>�� !&JL<?UNJ��7DWU �$M?@BAW]N@lUaD 9 UN>1Vr>1V/@

AWHK>1H\HNDWA=>1V/@FWJLHN_`>1<E_^HNMI>1HN[��=:=H bY9 @_`UaDW[1<EA/@^JL@BAl<ED=_hV/U7Ua[1<ED/]*H\_`UaDW_`J1@^>#@�:YU'A/@BMI[#>#Jh8W_`>18/J1@�OQJ1Ua: >1VW<E[

OsHN:=<EM?b!�

pBn

Page 24: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

� ��� ����� ��������� ������ ��� ��� � � ������� ������� ���������� � ��� ����� ��� ��� �

��D _`@^J1>1HN<EDrHKFWFIME<E_^HK>1<EUaDW[^mf>1V/@=VW< AWA/@BD,j HKJh<EHK9IM?@B[)VWH jN@lHi_`UaDW_`JL@^>#@l:Y@BHNDW<EDW] � -C0�� � OQUNJ4@� 'HN:=FIM?@

<ED H=>#@� '>�_^MEHN[L[1<SR;_^HK>1<?UaDdFWJ1UN9IME@B: >1V/@B[#@e_`Ua8WMEAi9P@4>#UNF;<E_*_^HK>#@^]NUNJL<E@B[ �SpBn'p � " < Dij'<E[1<?UaDi:=U7A/@BM ME<ED/]/m/>1V/@^b

HKJ1@\UNOg>#@BDd>1V/@\M?U'_^HK>1<?UaDdUNJ$FPUa[#@4UNO&HNDdUN9���@B_`> �1020�� ��� Dd[#Ua:Y@*UNO�>1VW@B[#@*[1<?>18IHK>1<?UaDW[^mI< DC>1V/@4FWJL@B[#@BDW_`@*UNO

>#JLHN<EDI<ED/]�AWHK>1H'mTUaD/@0_^HND R+ \97b0�T� ���<� ��� �7D/U �$M?@BA/]N@0>1VW@�HKFWFWJ1UNFWJh<EHK>#@�F;HKJLHN:Y@^>#@^J&jKHNME8/@B[�OQUNJ�>1V/@�:YU'A/@BM

HNDWAl>1V/@�@B:YFIVIHN[1<E[&<E[�UaD=9P@B<ED/]4HK9;M?@�>#U HN_^_^8/JLHK>#@BM?b=<EDWOg@^J&>1VW@$8WD/UN9I[1@^J1jN@BAl<EDWOgUNJL:lHK>1<?UaDYOQJ1Ua: >1V/@AWHK>1H

�.@0UN9I[#@^J1jN@�� >1VI<E[�<E[�>1V/@�_^HN[#@�@!� ]��&<ED :YU jN@B:Y@BDZ>&>#JLHN_��'<ED/]4HKFIFIME<E_^HK>1<?UaDI[ �1020�� ����D UN>1V/@^J�_^HN[1@B[^m&�.@�HKJ1@

>#J1b'<ED/]�>#U4AW<E[L_`U jN@^J�VW< AWA/@BD � _^HN8W[#@B[��aUNJ�OsHN_`>#UNJL[ �$VW<E_hV\@� 'FIMEHN< D\Ua8WJ&AWHK>1H4<ED H):YUNJ1@�_`UaDZjN@BDW<?@BDZ> ��HBb �

>1VW<E[�<E[�>1V/@�_^HN[#@�<ED=8WDW[L8/FP@^J1j7< [#@BA M?@BHKJLDW<EDW] � 4Kn�� m&�V/@^J1@ �.@HKJL@$J1@BX78W<?J1@BA=>#U*9PUN>1V=@B[#>1< :=HK>#@>1VW@$jKHNME8/@B[

UNO >1V/@�:YU'A/@BM � [�FIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^Jh[&HNDWAY<ED/OQ@^J�>1V/@�:YUa[#>�FIJ1UN9IHK9IM?@�jKHNME8/@B[�UNO;>1V/@�VW<EAWAW@BD*jKHKJL<EHK9IME@B[���� 'HN:=FIM?@B[

<EDW_^M 8WA/@0_^HN[#@B[ �V/@^J1@ �.@HKJ1@$:lHN<EDWM?be<EDT>#@^JL@B[#>#@BAl<EDeR DWAW<ED/])H4_`UaDZjN@BDW<?@BDZ>�JL@^FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaDYOQUNJ�Ua8/J�AWHK>1H

OQUNJlH [18/9;[#@BXZ8W@BDT>YJ1@B_`UN]aDI<?>1<?UaD6>1HN[�� qQ@!� ]�� [#FP@^@B_LV6J1@B_`UN]aDI<?>1<?UaD6UNJl< D/OgUNJh:=HK>1<?UaD J1@^>#JL<E@^j HNMgt��<?>1V/Ua8/>

9P@B<ED/] <EDZ>#@^J1@B[#>#@BA <ED AW<?J1@B_`>C<EDZ>#@^J1FWJL@^>1HK9I<EME<?> b6UNO*>1V/@�<EDIAW<?j'<EAW8WHNM�jKHNME8/@B[GUNO\>1V/@ OQHN_`>#UNJL[Bm�HNDIA _^HN[1@B[

�$V/@^JL@�>1V/@$@� 'FIMEHNDIHK>1<?UaDYOQUa8WDWA=97b >1V/@:=U7A/@BMI[1V/Ua8WMEA=9 @<EDT>#@^JLFWJ1@^>1HK9IM?@NmZHN[ �.@ �$< [1VY>#U\HN8W>#Ua:=HK>1<E_^HNMEM?b

R;DWA Ua8/>0HNDWAG8WDWAW@^JL[#>1HNDWA >1V/@):=HN<ED�OQ@BHK>18/J1@B[ �$VW< _LV ]NU jN@^JLDiHeFPUa[1[1<E9IM?bYMEHKJ1]N@)AWHK>1HK9IHN[1@ � @!� ]���AWHK>1H

:=<EDI<ED/]YUNJ$>#@� '>�:=<EDW<EDW]YFWJ1UN9IM?@B:l[��.��@B_LVIDW<E_^HNMEM?bNm HKFIHKJ1>OgJ1Ua: >1V/@e[#FP@B_^<SR;_)[1_`UNFP@*UNO�>1VW@\HKFWFIM <E_^HK>1<?UaDfm

>1V/@\> �.U ]NUaHNME[�<EDi]N@BD/@^JLHK>1<?jN@Y:YU'A/@BMEME< D/]YHKJ1@�q�p t$<ED/OQ@^J1JL<EDW]Y>1V/@*jKHNME8/@B[$UNO&[#Ua:Y@ VW<EAWA/@BDC[1>1HK>#@B[^mP]a<?jN@BD

UN9I[#@^JLj HK>1<?UaDI[�HNDWAiH FIHKJhHN:Y@^>#@^JL< %^@BA :YU7AW@BMfHNDWArq nat.@B[#>1< :=HK>1<ED/]Y>1V/@\:YU7AW@BMPFIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^JL[ �

��VW@�<E[1[18W@�UNO'[1@BM?@B_`>1<ED/]�>1VW@�OQUNJL:�UNO'>1V/@.:YU7AW@BM m >1V/@�:YU7AW@BMNUNJLA/@^J�UNJ�:YU'A/@BMa_`Ua:YF;M?@� '<E>kb=qsDZ8I:*9P@^J�UNO

OQJ1@^@�FIHKJhHN:Y@^>#@^JL[ht�<E[�HNM [#UHNDe<E:YFPUNJ1>1HNDZ> FWJ1UN9;M?@B:-<ED*]N@BD/@^JLHK>1<?jN@�:YU'A/@BMEME< D/]�� �$U ��@^jN@^J mT[18W_hV*]N@BD/@^JhHNME<?>kb

�$<EM MaD/UN>�[email protected]/J1@B[1[1@BA*<ED*>1V/@��.UNJ��)FWJL@B[#@BDT>#@BAeV/@^J1@�HNDWA*>1V/@^J1@^OQUNJ1@��.@��$<EMEMND/UN>�HNAWA/JL@B[1[ >1VW< [�FIHKJL>1<E_^8WMEHKJ

HN[#FP@B_`>$<EDG>1VW@)@BDW[18W<EDW] _hVWHKFW>#@^JL[ �

��� �� �����������������

��Di<ED/OQ@^J1@BDW_`@ �.@4[#@^@��C>#UlHNDI[���@^J$>1V/@*X78/@B[#>1<?UaD�/�]a<EjN@BDGR '@BAi:YU'A/@BMfFIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^JL[�HNDWAC>1VW@4UN9I[#@^J1j �

HK9IM?@B[Bm �$VWHK>=_^HND69P@C[1HN<EA HK9PUa8/> >1V/@iAW< [#>#JL<?9I8W>1<?UaD�qsA/@BDI[1<?>kbWt*UNO>1VW@iVW<EAWA/@BD jKHKJL<EHK9IM?@B[�� �)DW_`@C>1V/@

<EDZ>#@^]NJLHNMq n ���at*OQUNJ\_`Ua:YF;8/>1<ED/]i>1VW@lAWHK>1H,ME< �N@BME<EVWUZU'A <E[*H j HN<EM HK9IM?@Nm�>1VW@BDr>1VW< [4XZ8W@B[#>1<?UaDr_^HND @BHN[1<EMEb,9P@

HNDW[��.@^J1@BAC97bGHKFWFIM?b'<ED/]Y��HBbN@B[��;JL8WM?@!/

��q�� � ��� ��� t ��q� � ����� ��� t ��q�� ��� ��� t��q� � � ��� t q n �1-Zt

p��

Page 25: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

��V/@4ME@^Og>�VWHNDIAC[1<EA/@)UNO�>1V/@*HK9PU jN@\<E[0>#@^JL:Y@BAi>1V/@X���'��� �&���<� �YFWJ1UN9IHK9I< ME<?>kb,qsA/@BDW[1<?> b/t�UNO� �� O\>1VW@�F Ua[1>#@^JL<?UNJi<E[��HN8I[1[1<EHNDfm�>1V/@BD >1V/@�FPUa[#>#@^Jh<?UNJi[18 � _^<E@BDT>i[#>1HK>1< [#>1<E_^[��$VI<E_LV J1@BX78W<?J1@ >#U 9P@

_`Ua:YFI8W>#@BAiHKJ1@4>1V/@\:Y@BHNDiHNDWAi_`U j HKJh<EHNDW_`@*_`Ua:YF;8/>#@BAd8WDIA/@^J�>1V/@4FPUa[#>#@^JL<?UNJ0FIJ1UN9IHK9I<EM <?>kblAW@BDW[1<?> b!�

� � � � � � ��q�� � �t � � q n ��/at

� � �� � � � � ��q�� � �t �� � � q n ��0at

�$V/@^JL@4_`UaDWAW<?>1<?UaDI<ED/]eUaDC>1V/@4FIHKJhHN:Y@^>#@^JL[$HNDIAC:YU7AW@BM��.HN[�Ua:=<?>#>#@BAiOQUNJ$[1< :YFIME<E_^<E>kb=UNO�>1V/@*D/UN>1HK>1<EUaD��

��� � ��� ����� ��� ��� ��� ����������� �

��D,FIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^J4@B[1>1<E:=HK>1<?UaDfmfHNME[1U�>#@^Jh:Y@BA�HN[)[#b'[#>#@B: <EA/@BDZ>1<SR;_^HK>1<?UaD �Sp��54�� m��.@=HKJ1@ ]a<?jN@BD UaDWMEbi>1V/@

UN9I[#@^JLj HK9IME@B[ �� � p � ���� HNDWA HKJL@�JL@BXZ8W<EJ1@BA=>#UeR;DWA >1V/@�:YU'A/@BME[�FIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^JL[��$VI<E_LV�:=H� /<E:=< %^@�>1V/@ME< �N@BM <EV/U7U7A\UNOP>1V/@�UN9I[#@^JLjN@BAlAWHK>1H48IDWA/@^J�>1V/@$:=U7A/@BM ����DY[#>1HK>1<E_:YU7AW@BME[^mN>1V/@$M < �N@BME<EV/U7U'A\_^HNDl9 @ �$JL<?>#>#@BD

HN[�HeFWJ1U'AW8W_`>�U jN@^J�>1V/@4ME< �N@BM <EV/U7U7Alj HNME8W@B[�UNO�>1V/@)<EDIAW<?j'<EAW8WHNMWAIHK>1HY[1HN:YFIM?@B[Bm'HN[�>1V/@B[#@4HKJ1@)HN[1[18I:Y@BAG>#U

9P@4<EDWA/@^FP@BDWAW@BDT>.OgJLUa: @BHN_LVdUN>1V/@^J �

� ��q� � � � � �� � ��t ��� �� ��q���/t q n � 4Nt

�$V/@^JL@ ��q���'te<E[ _`Ua:YF;8/>#@BA6OQJ1Ua: q n ���at �c��V/@^JL@GHKJL@i:=HNDTb ��HBb'[YUNO�:lH� '<E:l<E[1<ED/] >1VW<E[YX78WHNDZ>1<?>kbNm�HN[

>1VW<E[\FWJ1UN9;M?@B: VIHN[ 9 @^@BD @� '>#@BDW[1<?jN@BM?b <EDZjN@B[#>1<?]aHK>#@BA 97br[#>1HK>1<E[#>1< _^[^m&@BD/]a<EDW@^@^JL<ED/],HNDWA D/@B8/JLHNM.D/@^> �.UNJ��

J1@B[#@BHKJh_LV/@^JL[ �Sp��54 � � ��@ �<EMEM�9WJL<?@��Ib J1@^j'<?@�� >1V/@d:YUa[1>=<E:YFPUNJ1>1HNDZ>e>#@B_hVWDW<EX78/@B[^m�_`UaDW_`@BDZ>#JLHK>1<ED/]rFIHKJ��

>1<E_^8WM HKJLM?bdUaDr>1V/@lFPU ��@^J1Os8WM�� 7FP@B_`>1HK>1<?UaD � H� /<E:=< [1HK>1<?UaDcqs��� t4HKFWFWJ1UaHN_hV >#U �,H� /<E:\8I: ��< �N@BME<EV/U7U7A

qs�,��t�@B[#>1<E:=HK>1<?UaD,<EDd>1V/@\FIJ1@B[#@BDW_`@\UNO�:=<E[1[L<ED/]=AWHK>1H������ U �P@^JL[�H 8WDI<SRI@BAC>1V/@^UNJL@^>1<E_^HNM�>#J1@BHK>1:Y@BDZ>�UNO

:=HNDZb AW< � @^J1@BDZ>�:=U7A/@BM ME<ED/]*[L_LV/@B:Y@B[ �Sp��54�� �&�$U ��@^jN@^J mI<ED�[#Ua:Y@)[1<E:YF;ME<SRI@BAYFIJLHN_`>1<E_^HNMP[1<?>18WHK>1<EUaDW[^m':YUNJ1@

@ � _^<?@BDZ>�:=@^>1V/U7AI[�_^HND�9P@$8W[#@BAfm7[18W_hVlHN[��$@��$>#UaD�� UNFW>1<E:=< [1HK>1<?UaDl< DY>1V/@_^HN[1@UNO !WHN_`>#UNJ���DWHNM?b'[1<E[ �Sp��54��

UNJ$ME< D/@BHKJ�HNM?]N@^9WJLHN< _�J1Ua8/>1<ED/@B[0< DC>1V/@4_^HN[#@\UNO�!�J1UN9IHK9I<EM <E[#>1<E_!&JL<EDI_^<?FIHNM ".Ua:YFPUaD/@BDZ>��DIHNM?b7[L<E[��Sp�/$- � �

��� �� ��� � � & % # - � & � # - �'� � & �'� ( �

��D4��HBbN@B[1< HND*@B[#>1< :=HK>1<?UaD �Sp 4'mTp^oC47m'�'pNm$0�� m >1VW@&FIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^Jh[�HKJ1@�_`UaDI[1<EA/@^J1@BA4>#U$9P@�JLHNDWA/Ua:�j HKJL< HK9IM?@B[��

��V/@^JL@�<E[�D/U AW< �P@^J1@BDW_`@�9P@^> �.@^@BDC:=<E[1[L<ED/]*AWHK>1HYHNDIAlFIHKJhHN:Y@^>#@^JL[����$VW<E[�FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>1[�[#@^jN@^JLHNMfHNA/jKHNDT>1HK]N@B[Bm

[18W_hV HN[\R;DIAW<ED/]dH Os8WMEM&AW< [#>#JL<?9I8W>1<?UaD U jN@^JY>1V/@�FIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^JL[^m�H jNUa<EAW<ED/] >1V/@�U jN@^J#RI>#>1< D/] FIJ1UN9IM?@B: HNDWA

HN[1[#@B[L[1<ED/]G:YU'A/@BM�UNJhA/@^J�[1@BM?@B_`>1<?UaD <ED,H���H bN@B[1<EHND OQJLHN:Y@��.UNJ�� �10'm /'p � �4��[�[L8W_LVfmfH FWJL<?UNJ�AW<E[1>#JL<?9I8/>1<EUaD

p.-

Page 26: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

��q �Gt�<E[�HN[1[18W:Y@BAlU jN@^J0>1V/@�:YU'A/@BMWFIHKJhHN:Y@^>#@^JL[ � <EDI_^ME8WAW<EDW]�F;HKJLHN:Y@^>#@^JL[��$VW<E_hVl_`UaDZ>#J1UaM >1V/@$UNJhA/@^J�UNO>1V/@ :YU'A/@BM.qsD78W:\9P@^J$UNO�MEHK>#@BDZ>)AW<E:Y@BDI[1<?UaDW[ht � �$VI<E_LV @� 7FIJ1@B[1[#@B[�HNDTbdFWJL<?UNJ �7D/U �$M?@BA/]N@eUNJ)<EDZ>18W<?>1<?UaD

HK9PUa8/> >1V/@�AW<E[#>#JL<E9I8/>1<?UaDUNO/>1V/@&FIHKJhHN:Y@^>#@^JL[^m @!� ]���>1V/@�<EDZ>18W<?>1<?UaD�UNO'>1VW< [f9P@B<ED/]�[1:YU7UN>1V���� D*>1V/@���HBbN@B[1< HND

OQJLHN:Y@��.UNJ��;m/UaDW@4D/@^jN@^J�@B[#>1<E:lHK>#@B[�HY[1<ED/]aME@�jKHNME8/@�OQUNJ0>1V/@)FIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^JL[09I8/>0HKOQ>#@^J�UN9I[#@^JLj7<EDW]e>1VW@4AWHK>1H'm

>1V/@4FPUa[#>#@^Jh<?UNJ�<E[0_`Ua:YFI8W>#@BA��

��q � � ��� �t ��q� ��� � � �Ct ��q �Ct��q� ��� � t q n ���at

�$V/@^JL@ ��� �([#>1HNDIAW[�OgUNJ � � � � �� � ���)��VW<E[$@� 7FIJ1@B[1[#@B[�V/U � >1VW@eFIJL<?UNJ$9P@BME<E@^O&_LVWHND/]N@B[)HN_^_`UNJhAW<ED/]�>#U

>1V/@4UN9;[#@^J1jKHK9IM?@B[��

!/UNJ=_`Ua:=FI8/>1<ED/] q n ���athm �.@�D/@^@BA >#U�[#FP@B_^<?OQb H,ME< �N@BM <EV/U7U7A ��q� � �Ct*HNDWA HNM [#U D/@^@BA >#U,9P@ HK9IM?@ >#U_`Ua:YFI8W>#@4>1V/@4<EDZ>#@^]NJLHNM

��q��t � ��q��� �Gt ��q �it� � q n � �at

��VW< [f<E[�HNME[1U�>#@^JL:Y@BA\HN[ >1V/@ � J �M� �$� � ��UNJG� � �<b;�5���#�[�L�5u ���L�51[�.�.� ���/<E:=<EMEHKJhM?bNmB<?O'_`Ua:YFI8/>1<EDW]0>1V/@&FWJ1UN9;HK9I<EME<?> b

UNO�HYD/@��-AWHK>1H=F Ua< DT>0]a<?jN@BDi>1V/@4J1@B[#>0UNO�>1V/@4AIHK>1H=<E[0J1@BX78W<?JL@BAfmZ>1VW@*<EDZ>#@^]NJLHNM

��q� � ��� � �t � ��q� � ��� � �Gt ��q � � �t� � q n �Ep^oTt

VWHN[�>#U\9P@0@^j HNME8IHK>#@BA���".Ua:YFI8/>1< D/]�>1V/@B[#@$<EDZ>#@^]NJLHNME[�<E[�>1V/@$:=Ua[#>�AW<���_^8WM?>�FIHKJ1>&UNOf��HBbN@B[1< HND=@B[#>1<E:lHK>1<?UaD

HNDWA\UNOg>#@BDYD78W:Y@^Jh<E_^HNMT<EDZ>#@^]NJLHK>1<?UaDeUNJ�HNDWHNM?b7>1<E_.HKFWFWJ1U '< :=HK>1<?UaDW[�[email protected]@BXZ8I<?J1@BA �10/m �2��� ����D/UN>1V/@^J�Og@BHK>18WJ1@

<E[�>1VIHK>�:e8W_LV UNOP>1V/@[18I_^_`@B[1[&UNO ��HBbN@B[L<EHNDl@B[1>1<E:=HK>1<?UaD HNM?]NUNJL<?>1VW:l[&A/@^FP@BDWAW[�UaD�VWHBj'<ED/]\HN[1[18W:Y@BA=]NUZU'A

FWJL<EUNJL[.OgUNJ�>1VW@)FIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^JL[ ��+[L8WHNMEM?b >1V/@4[#U=_^HNMEM?@BA � ���.� ;bE�#� �h� ���M� ��� �Sp 4 �.qQFWJL<EUNJL[.UNO�[1< :=<EMEHKJ�OQUNJL: >#U

>1V/@4OQUNJL: HN[1[L8W:Y@BACOQUNJ�>1V/@*M < �N@BME<EV/U7U'A;t�HKJ1@\_`UaDW[1<EA/@^JL@BAfm/OgUNJHNDWHNM?b7>1<E_^HNMf_`UaDTjN@BDI<?@BDW_`@ �1/'p � �

��� �� ��� � ) & B � � !�� � � ( - � # * � (+* ��� ) ����� # - �'� � & �'� ( �

��U\H jNUa<EA=>1V/@UNOg>#@BD <EDZ>#JLHN_`>1HK9IM?@$< DT>#@^]NJLHNM [&UNOP>1V/@$��HBbN@B[L<EHND HKFIFWJ1UaHN_LV m7�,�! @B[#>1<E:lHK>1<?UaD �Sp��$-;mIp 4 �

FWJ1UNFPUa[#@B[�HNDlHKFWFWJ1U '<E:lHK>1<?UaDY[1_LVW@B:Y@$<ED �$VW< _LVY<EDW[1>#@BHNA UNO <EDZ>#@^]NJLHK>1<EDW])U jN@^J�HNMEM'FPUa[1[1<?9IME@�jKHNME8/@B[�UNO >1V/@

FIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^JBm'>1V/@�< DT>#@^]NJLHK>1<EUaD <E[�FP@^J1OQUNJL:Y@BA=UaDIM?bYU jN@^J�HeA/@BM?>1H\OQ8IDW_`>1<?UaDl_`@BDZ>#@^J1@BAGHK>�>1V/@�� H� /<E:e8W: �

!�Ua[#>#@^JL<?UNJh<�qs�,�!�t�j HNME8W@$UNO >1V/@�FIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^JL[�A/@BDW[1<?> bNm/< � @!��>1V/@�:lH� '<E:e8W: HKJ1]a8W:Y@BDZ>.UNO >1V/@�F Ua[1>#@^JL<?UNJ

HKJ1]a:=H� �

��q � � �t q n �EpNp t

��VW< [0:=H �N@B[�>1V/@4< DT>#@^]NJLHK>1<EUaDi>#JL<?j'<EHNM � @!� ]���q n �Ep^oTt09P@B_`Ua:Y@B[

��q� � ��� � �t � ��q� � �� � �Ct ��q � � �t� �� ��q� � ��� � � �����&t q n �EpBnat

p�/

Page 27: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

��V78W[^m <EDd�,�! @B[#>1< :=HK>1<?UaD >1V/@^J1@\< [$[#>1<EM M HlFIJL<?UNJ$HN[1[L8W:Y@BA UaDd>1V/@\FIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^Jh[^m;9;8/>$UaDWMEb�>1VW@*jKHNME8/@

� ����� <E[)>#U 9 @=_`Ua:=FI8/>#@BA�����VW<E[4< [)@BXZ8I<?j HNME@BDT>)>#U,:=H� '< :=< %B<ED/]G>1V/@ ��Ua<EDZ>*AW< [#>#JL<?9I8W>1<?UaD AW@BDW[1<?> b,UNO>1V/@*AIHK>1H=HNDWAGFIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^JL[��

� ����� HKJ1]a:=H� �

��q��� �Gt ��q �it��q��t q n �Ep��at

HKJ1]a:=H� �

��q��� �Gt ��q �it q n �Ep.-Zt

HKJ1]a:=H� � � M?UN] ��q� � �it � M?UN]���q �Gt�� q n �Ep�/at

��VW< [�[1<E:YF;ME<SRI@B[.]NJ1@BHK>1M?bd>1V/@*@B[#>1< :=HK>1<?UaDiFIJ1U7_`@BAI8/J1@Nm;HN[>1V/@e_^HNME_^8WMEHK>1<?UaDdUNO�>1V/@\< DT>#@^]NJLHNM ��q��t�<E[$D/U �D/UN>�J1@BM?@^jKHNDZ>��.��O�_`Ua8WJL[#@Nm'>1V/@)FWJL< _`@FIHN< A�< [.H >#JhHNA/@^U �,UNO�[#Ua:Y@)<ED/OQUNJL:=HK>1<EUaD�HK]aHN< DW[#>0_`Ua:YFI8/>1HK>1<EUaDWHNM

@ � _^<?@BDI_`bNm [1< DW_`@��.@\HKJ1@ 8W[1< D/]YUaDWM?bC>1V/@e� ��! j HNM 8/@*UNO�>1V/@eFIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^J�<EDI[#>#@BHNAdUNO&HND @BDZ>1<?J1@\AI<E[#>#JL< �

9I8/>1<EUaD��=�$U ��@^jN@^J m&<?>4<E[)>#Ui9P@=D/UN>#@BAr>1VWHK>\VIHBj'<ED/]iHCFWJh<?UNJ4AW<E[#>#Jh<?9I8/>1<?UaD U jN@^Je>1V/@=F;HKJLHN:Y@^>#@^J*F;MEHBb'[

>1V/@�<E:YFPUNJ1>1HNDZ>�J1UaM?@$UNOfFWJ1UN>#@B_`>1<ED/] HK]aHN<EDW[1>�U jN@^J1RI>#>1<ED/] �Sp 47m;p��$- � m �VW<E_LV <E[�HND�<E:YFPUNJ1>1HNDZ>�<E[L[18/@$<EDl>1V/@

_^HN[#@UNOPH*[1:=HNMEM/D78W:\9 @^J�UNOPUN9I[1@^J1j HK9;M?@�AWHK>1H4FPUa<EDZ>1[�����@$_^HND=@BHN[L<EM?b [#@^@$>1VW< [�OgJ1Ua: q n �Ep�/athmW<?O+�.@�>1VW<ED �

UNO&>1V/@YM?UN]�FWJL<EUNJU jN@^J)>1V/@\F;HKJLHN:Y@^>#@^JL[)ME< �N@\[#Ua:Y@ � j'<?J1>18WHNM �;AWHK>1H�FPUa<EDZ>1[ �$VI<E_LV,VWHBjN@ 9P@^@BD HNAWA/@BA >#U

>1V/@4UN9;[#@^J1jKHK9IM?@B[��

��� �� ��� 6 ) & B � � !�� 7 ��� # + � � (�(�, � ) 7 � # - �'� � & �$� ( �

� O �.@ Ua:=<E>\>1V/@GFWJh<?UNJ*UaD >1V/@GFIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^JL[ HNDWA :=H� '< :=< %^@l>1VW@�ME< �N@BME<EV/U7U7ArHNM?UaD/@Nm&>1V/@BD >1V/@C�,�

FIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^J$@B[#>1<E:lHK>#@B[$HKJ1@4UN9I>1HN<ED/@BA��

� ��� HKJ1]a:=H� �M?UN]���q� � �Ct q n �Ep�0at

��V78W[^mK<ED\>1V/@.�,��OgJhHN:Y@���UNJ��;mN>1V/@.@BM?@B:Y@BDZ>1[�UNO � HKJ1@�[1<E:YFIMEbFIHKJhHN:Y@^>#@^JL[�HNDWAeD/UN>�JhHNDWA/Ua: j HKJL< HK9IM?@B[��� >e_^HND 9P@lFWJ1U jN@BA >1VWHK>e<EO�[18 � _^<?@BDZ>\AIHK>1H <E[eHBjKHN<EMEHK9;M?@lOQUNJ\>#JhHN<EDW<ED/]d>1V/@BDr>1VW@��,� @B[#>1<E:=HK>#UNJY<E[eHND

8WDZ9I<EHN[#@BAcHNDWAc:=H� /<E:=HNM M?b @ ��_^<?@BDT> @B[#>1<E:=HK>#UNJ �Sp��$- � � >1VWHK>�<E[=>1V/@,:Y@BHND UNO)>1VW@ AW<E[1>#JL<?9I8/>1<EUaD UNO

>1V/@d�,� FIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^J�@B[#>1<E:=HK>#@B[l>#@BDWAW[l>#U >1V/@d>#Jh8/@CFIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^J�jKHNME8/@rqsD/U 9;<EHN[ht HN[l>1V/@dD78W:*9P@^J=UNO

[1HN:YF;M?@B[&<EDW_`JL@BHN[#@B[�HNDWA=>1V/@�jKHKJL<EHNDW_`@�UNOP>1V/@$@B[#>1<E:=HK>#@B[.<E[&:=< DW<E:=HNM7U jN@^J�HNMEMW[L8W_LV 8WDT9;<EHN[#@BA @B[#>1<E:lHK>#@B[��

��VW< [&UNO�_`Ua8/Jh[#@)[18/FWFPUa[#@B[�>1VWHK>�>1V/@�AIHK>1He< [�<EDIA/@^@BA=]N@BD/@^JhHK>#@BAGOgJ1Ua: He:YU'A/@BMIUNO�>1V/@�FIHKJLHN:Y@^>#JL< _�OQUNJL:

_`UaDW[1< A/@^J1@BA���� �G@B[#>1< :=HK>1<?UaDeHNME[#UVIHN[�>1V/@�HNA/jKHNDT>1HK]N@0UNOWDWUN>�J1@BX78W<?Jh<ED/]0>#U)[#FP@B_^<?OQb�HFWJL<EUNJ�AW<E[1>#JL<?9I8/>1<EUaD

UaDC>1V/@*FIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^JL[ ��� >$VWHN[�<EDG>18WJLDC>1V/@*AI<E[1HNA/jKHNDT>1HK]N@*UNO�U jN@^J#RI>#>1<EDW]/mI<?O�>1V/@*D78W:*9P@^J0UNO�AWHK>1HYFPUa<EDZ>1[

<E[0[1:lHNMEM �Sp��$- � �

p�0

Page 28: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

� # B � # # � & �'� ( � ) & B � � � -�& �$� ( � � ) � &:+ > (+* � � � �

!/UNJ)FIJ1UN9IM?@B:=[ �$V/@^JL@\:=<E[L[1<ED/]=UNJ)VW< AWA/@BDijKHKJL<EHK9;M?@B[HKJL@eFIJ1@B[#@BDZ>�<ED >1V/@ :YU'A/@BM(� @!� ]��4<ED,MEHK>#@BDZ>

jKHKJL<EHK9IM?@Y:YU'A/@BME[ � >1VW@=��� HNM?]NUNJL<?>1VW: �1�2���&U � @^JL[*HCFPU �.@^J1OQ8IM�:=@^>1V/U7A OQUNJ4FIHKJhHN:Y@^>#@^J4@B[#>1<E:lHK>1<?UaD

HNDWA�<E[�<EDWA/@^@BA �$<EA/@BMEb 8I[#@BAG<ED=>1V/@�]N@BD/@^JhHK>1<?jN@):YU7AW@BMEME<ED/]4M <?>#@^JLHK>18/J1@ �Sp��54�� ����@ �$< MEM/J1@^j'<?@�� >1V/@�9IHN[1<E_

<EA/@BHN[�UNO���� <ED�>1V/@4�,� OQJLHN:Y@��.UNJ��lOQUNJ�@BHN[#@)UNO�D/UN>1HK>1<?UaDfmWVWU �.@^jN@^JBmW@� '>#@BDW[1<?UaDG>#U=>1VW@�_^HN[1@4UNO��,��!

@B[#>1<E:lHK>1<?UaDC<E[�[#>#JLHN<?]aVZ>#OQUNJ��.HKJhA���� '>#@BDW[1<EUaDW[.UNO�>1V/@4��� FWJLU7_`@BAW8WJ1@>#UY>1VW@4�.H bN@B[1<EHNDCOQJLHN:Y@��.UNJ��G_^HND

HNME[#UY9P@)OQUa8WDWAC<EDG>1VW@*ME<?>#@^JLHK>18WJ1@ �1/'p � �

��VW@dUN9��#@B_`>1<?jN@�<E[=>#U6:=H� /<E:=< %^@i>1V/@ AWHK>1H qsMEUN]ZtlM < �N@BME<EV/U7U'A�q n �Ep�0at�<ED >1V/@,FWJ1@B[1@BDW_`@ UNO4VI<EAWA/@BD

jKHKJL<EHK9IM?@B[ � �� M?UN]���q��� �Gt M?UN] � ��q��� � � �Ct� � q n �Ep 4Nt

��V/@4< A/@BHeUNO�>1V/@4��� FWJ1U'_`@BAW8/J1@)_`Ua:Y@B[0OQJ1Ua: UN9;[#@^J1j'<ED/] >1VWHK>$HNDZb�AI<E[#>#JL<?9;8/>1<?UaD��/q t.U jN@^J$>1V/@4VI<EAWA/@BDjKHKJL<EHK9IM?@B[\OQUNJL:=[YH M?U �.@^JY9PUa8WDWArUaD � m �<?>1Vr@BX78WHNME<E>kb UN9W>1HN< D/@BA OgUNJ��/q t*9P@B<ED/],>1V/@ >#Jh8/@GF Ua[1>#@^JL<?UNJ��q�� � �t � � U ��@^J�9PUa8WDWAW[ �$VW< _LV HNME[1Ur[1HK>1<E[#OQb >1V/@i@BX78WHNME<?> b OQUNJlHND�HKFWFWJ1UNFWJh<EHK>#@i_LV/Ua< _`@ HKJ1@i>#@^Jh:Y@BA

������ ���������� ���� �� �� �Sp 4'm�p��$- �0OgUNJ � � !/UNJ=>1VW<E[e_^HN[#@Nm�>1V/@C_`J1@BHK>1<?UaD UNOHND6HN8� '<EM <EHKJ1b OQ8IDW_`>1<?UaD _^HND

@BHN[1<EMEb 9P@)[#@^@BDdHN[�OgUaMEMEU �$[��

M?UN]���q� � �Ct M?UN] � ��q�� � � �Gt� � M?UN] � �'q���t ��q�� ��� �Gt�/q���t � q n �Ep��at

� � �/q���t7M?UN] ��q� � ��� �Gt�/q���t � q n �Ep �at

�$V/@^JL@ �a@BDW[#@BD(� [�<ED/@BX78WHNME<E>kb �1�20��&VWHN[�9P@^@BD 8W[#@BA <ED >1V/@YMEHN[#>�ME<ED/@Nm �$VW< _LV V/UaMEAW[�HN[��/q���t<E[�H�AW@BDW[1<?> bOs8WDW_`>1<?UaD HNDWAY9P@B_^HN8W[[email protected] >1V/@�M?UN]aHKJh<?>1VW:(Os8WDW_`>1<?UaDe9P@B<ED/])_`UaDW_^H jN@!� !W8/J1>1VW@^JBm;q n �Ep �at�_^HND=9 @0A/@B_`Ua8WFIM?@BA

HN[YH�[18W: UNO> �.UrXZ8IHNDT>1<?>1<E@B[ � H F;HKJLHN:Y@^>#@^J��kA/@^FP@BDWAW@BDT> >#@^JL:Cm �$VW<E_hV < [\>1VW@C@� 7FP@B_`>1HK>1<?UaD UNO�>1V/@

_`Ua:YFIME@^>#@*AWHK>1H=ME< �N@BME<EV/U7U7A�8WDWAW@^J��'q���thm;HNME[#UY>#@^JL:Y@BAd>1V/@ �����&�#�<� J �A�L�:u����L�:1[�r�.�

� q � ���at � �'q���t7MEUN] ��q�� � � �it� � � � M?UN] ��q� � ��t � � ! � � q n � nKoTt

HNDWAC>1VW@)@BDT>#J1UNF7b �1�20�� UNO"�/q thm �$VW< _LVCA/U7@B[�D/UN>$AW@^F @BDIA UaDi>1V/@4FIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^JL[��

# q$�at &% � �'q���t7MEUN]'�/q���t� � q n � n'p t

� >�_^HND=9 @�[1V/U �$D �Sp 47m/p��$- �/>1VWHK>�>1VW@�AI< � @^JL@BDW_`@�9 @^> ��@^@BD >1VW@�ME< �N@BME<EVWUZU'A*HNDWAe>1V/@0M?U ��@^J�9 Ua8IDWA\_`JL@BHK>#@BA

97b HKFIFIM?b'<ED/]G>1V/@ �a@BDW[#@BD <EDW@BXZ8WHNM <?>kb <E[)>1V/@ 348WMEM?9;HN_�� �k� @B<?9IME@^JYqs3*��t�AW<EjN@^J1]N@BDW_`@=9P@^> �.@^@BD(�'q���t4HNDWA

p 4

Page 29: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

��q�� � �thm�� ��q$�/q���t � � ��q���� �t#t �� �/q���t7M?UN] ! � � � � � � ��m �VW<E_LV <E[eUNO�_`Ua8/JL[#@Nm�H,FPUa[1<?>1<EjN@�X78WHNDZ>1<?>kb �1�20�� �

��V78W[^mW[18I:=:=<ED/] 8/F m/>1VW@4AWHK>1H=M?UN]lM < �N@BME<EV/U7U'A <E[�@� 'FWJ1@B[L[#@BAiHN[

� � q � ���at � # q$�at ������q$�'q���t � � ��q���� �t#t q n � nNnat

��VW@l��� HNM?]NUNJh<?>1VW: HNME>#@^JLDWHK>#@B[\9 @^> ��@^@BD :=H� /<E:=< %B< D/] � �<?>1V J1@B[1F @B_`>*>#U >1V/@ AW<E[#>#JL<E9I8/>1<?UaD �/q t�$VW< M?@4>1V/@ FIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^JL[ � HKJ1@)�N@^FW>�R 7@BA mPHNDIA :=H� /<E:=< %B<ED/] � �<?>1VdJL@B[#FP@B_`>>#UG>1V/@ FIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^JL[ � m�$VW< M?@ �/q t<E[�R+ 7@BA�����V/@B[1@\OQUNJL: >1V/@Y� 'F @B_`>1HK>1<EUaD,[1>#@^F6qs� �k[#>#@^F tHNDWA,� H� /<E:=< [1HK>1<?UaD,[#>#@^Fcqs� �k[1>#@^F t

UNO$>1VW@�HNM?]NUNJh<?>1VW:Cm&[#>1HKJL>1<ED/],OgJ1Ua: [#Ua:=@�<EDI<?>1<EHNM&F;HKJLHN:Y@^>#@^JL[ ����� �a@BDW[#@BD(� [ <ED/@BX78WHNME<E>kb 9P@B_`Ua:Y@B[YHND@BX78WHNME<?> b �V/@BD �/q���t ��q�� � �thm�[#U <ED�>1V/@�� �k[#>#@^F m�>1V/@ FPUa[#>#@^JL<?UNJ��$<EMEM�9P@ _`Ua:=FI8/>#@BAfm �$VW<E_hVr<E[*>1V/@

<ED/OQ@^J1@BDW_`@ FWJ1UN9IME@B:��d��V/@BD >1V/@G� �k[1>#@^F 8I[#@B[*>1VW@�[#UaM 8/>1<?UaD UNO0>1V/@�< D/Og@^JL@BDW_`@lFWJLUN9IM?@B: qsHN[Y<EO�<E>���HN[

_`Ua:YFIME@^>#@eAWHK>1HTt$>#UG[#UaM?jN@eOgUNJ�D/@�� FIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^Jh[��$��Dd>1VW@eD/@� '>�<?>#@^JLHK>1<?UaDfm >1V/@eD/@�� :=U7A/@BM�FIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^JL[

HKJ1@*8I[#@BAC>#Ul<EDWOg@^J0>1V/@4VI<EAWA/@BDG[#>1HK>#@B[�HK]aHN<EDdHNDIAi[#UYUaD��&� >$<E[�@BHN[1b�>#U�[#@^@4>1VWHK>$>1VW<E[0<?>#@^JLHK>1<EjN@*[1_LVW@B:Y@

A/U7@B[DWUN>�A/@B_`JL@BHN[#@\>1VW@eME< �N@BME<EV/U7U7ACHK>�@B<?>1V/@^J�UNO�>1V/@ <?>#@^JLHK>1<?UaD,[#>#@^FI[Bm HNDWA,<?>$_^HND,9P@\[LV/U �$D �1�2�'m�pNp.- �

>1VWHK>$<E>�_`UaDTjN@^J1]N@B[UaDWM?b �$V/@BDC<E>�VWHN[0J1@BHN_hV/@BAdH=MEU7_^HNM :lH� '<E:e8W: � UNO�>1V/@4ME< �N@BM <EV/U7U7A��� # � # *$&:+ � - # , ) � �� ) � ��V/@09;HN[1<E_���� HNME]NUNJL<?>1VW:CmZHN[&FWJ1@B[1@BDT>#@BA HK9 U jN@<E[�H)]NJ1@^@BA/b=HNM?]NUNJh<?>1VW:Cm

HN[)<?>�>1H �N@B[)>1V/@e9P@B[#>)[#>#@^F�<EDd9PUN>1V,>1V/@Y� HNDWA � [1>#@^FI[��4�U �.@^jN@^JBm OQJ1Ua: >1V/@ FWJ1UNFP@^J1>kbdUNO���� >1VWHK>

<EDc@BHN_LV [#>#@^F <?> A/U7@B[�D/UN> A/@B_`JL@BHN[#@ >1VW@,ME< �N@BME<EV/U7U7A m�Hr[L<E:YFIM?@iHNDIAc@ � _^<E@BDT> ]N@BD/@^JLHNME<E[LHK>1<?UaD�HKJh<E[#@B[

�SpBnKoWm�pNp.- � /���@e_^HNDdFP@^J1OQUNJL: FIHKJL>1<EHNM � �k[#>#@^FI[^mP< � @!��<?><E[$[18 � _^<?@BDZ>�>#U�<EDW_`J1@BHN[#@\>1V/@*ME< �N@BME<EV/U7U7AC< DC>1V/@

� �k[#>#@^F�HNDWA DWUN>D/@B_`@B[1[LHKJL<EM?bG>#UG:=H� '< :=< %^@\<E>���� Dd>1V/@ [1HN:Y@ [#FI<?JL<E>^m���@ _^HND HNME[#UlFP@^J1OQUNJL: FIHKJ1>1<EHNM�� �

[#>#@^FI[ � < DW[#>#@BHNAYUNO :=H� /<E:=< %B<ED/] � � # �$<E>1VYJ1@B[#FP@B_`>&>#U ��9Zb=[18W9I[#>1<?>18/>1< D/])<?>&97be>1VW@$>#JL8/@$F Ua[1>#@^JL<?UNJBm<?>l< [l[18 ��_^<?@BDT>l>#U <EDI_`J1@BHN[#@d<?>����$VW<E[=_^HND�9P@dA/UaD/@ @!� ]���9Zb6:YU'A/@BMEM <ED/] � HN[�H Os8WDW_`>1<?UaDcUNO4[#Ua:Y@HNAWAW<E>1<?UaDWHNM/FIHKJhHN:Y@^>#@^JL[.HNDWAlFPUa[1[L<?9IM?b\UaD=>1V/@�AWHK>1H � � �/q���� "��et �&�$V/@$UNFW>1< :=<E[1HK>1<?UaD=U jN@^J� _^HND9P@*FP@^J1OQUNJL:Y@BA @!� ]���9Zbi]NJhHNAW<?@BDZ>�HN[1_`@BDZ>��)�[�M?UaDW]�HN[�@BHN_LV�� HNDIA � [1>#@^F < :YFWJ1U jN@B[ � m �.@YHKJ1@ [#>1<EMEM]a8WHKJLHNDZ>#@^@BA >1VIHK>4>1V/@=M?UN]iME< �N@BME<EV/U7U7A,<EDW_`JL@BHN[#@B[)HK>4@^jN@^J1b�<?>#@^JLHK>1<EUaD��Y��V/@Y>#JL8/@=�,�c[1UaME8/>1<?UaD �$<EM M�9P@

HN_LVI<?@^jN@BAdUaDIM?b�<EO � J1@BHN_hV/@B[>1V/@4>#JL8/@*F Ua[1>#@^JL<?UNJ ��� O�>1V/@4>#Jh8/@4FPUa[#>#@^JL<?UNJ<E[�D/UN>$< DC>1V/@*[#@BHKJh_LV,[#FIHN_`@*UNO�7m/>1V/@BDG>1V/@4M?U ��@^J$9 Ua8IDWAG<E[.UNFW>1<E:=<E[1@BAfm��$VW<E_hV�[1>1<EMEMP_^HNDCFWJ1U j7< A/@�H JL@BHN[#UaDWHK9IM?@4HKFIFWJ1U /<E:=HK>1<EUaD�����V/@J1@BHN[#UaD�OQUNJ0[18W_LVGHKFWFIJ1U /<E:=HK>1<?UaDI[�<ED FWJLHN_`>1<E_`@�_^HNDG9P@$OQUa8WDWA�<EDl_^HN[1@B[ �$V/@BD >1V/@>#Jh8/@FPUa[#>#@^Jh<?UNJ.< [�>#U7U

AW<���_^8WM?>.>#Ul_`Ua:YFI8/>#@\HNDWHNM?b7>1<E_^HNMEM?b � [#@^@4@!� ]�� �1/�� �� ��������������������������! �"#�%$&�'�(�*),+-�(��./���0 ��213�����41/�5�6 17 ����*)817���9�!�*��)� 4�8:;"<�=� "9�41�)>1������2?!�@1�)BA<)�:C1/)� ��4DE��1*D#D�����!�/�=)� 4F

G �<A<�����*A<�H�����41��<IJ17K<��IJ1C17���L1/�����0�/MN ��()�A<)<MO���� �A#)#1� ��P�/A< ����/I���H��)% �"#�Q�41/���&�/M#���*I�<�=�RKS�7)<�*)TU�(�*),+-�(KV�=��W-�(�=��"<���,D���A<��MO1/���(��FX �4:P��+-�(�4�<+*17�����*A#�C ���� "#)<�=Y,A<���C�/MZ��+*�(�����*I��)<.[ �"#���;D� 1�:;?#1/� WE�(K���6 @\�]*]�^/_`F

p��

Page 30: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

��D >1V/@GJ1@B:=HN<EDWAW@^J\UNO>1VW<E[e_LVWHKFW>#@^J m�[#Ua:Y@GUNO>1V/@G@� '<E[1>1<ED/] :=U7A/@BM [^m �$VW<E_hV HKJL@�JL@BM?@^j HNDZ> >#U�>1V/@

�.UNJ�� FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>#@BA <ED >1VW< [�>1V/@B[1<E[ �<EMEM�9P@YJ1@^j7<E@���@BA HNMEUaD/]��$<?>1V�[��N@^>1_hVW<ED/]dUa8/>4>1V/@B<?J\[#UaME8/>1<?UaDI[)<ED >1V/@

��� � OQJLHN:Y@��.UNJ�� �C��@GHNA/UNFW>\Hi>1H� 'UaD/Ua:*b �$VW<E_hVr<E[)FIJL<E:=HKJL< M?bi9IHN[#@BA UaD >1VW@l>kb7FP@lUNO0MEHK>#@BDZ>\FIJL<?UNJL[

HN[1[18I:Y@BAc<ED >1V/@d:YU'A/@BM m�HN[l>1VI<E[=<E[ H �N@^b HN[1[18W:=FW>1<?UaD �$VI<E_LV AI< � @^JL@BDT>1<EHK>#@B[l>1V/@d9P@BVWH j7<EUNJ=UNO)>1V/@

AW< �P@^J1@BDZ>0]N@BD/@^JLHK>1<?jN@\HNM?]NUNJL<?>1VW:l[��

� � � � ����� � � ��� � ������� � ��� ����� � � ��� � ��� ��� � �� � �� � �� �!��

��DW@ UNO�>1VW@G:=Ua[#>e[L<E:YFIM?@�MEHK>#@BDZ>ejKHKJL<EHK9;M?@ :YU'A/@BME[\<E[e>1V/@GME<ED/@BHKJ !WHN_`>#UNJl��DWHNM?b'[1<E[Gq !'��t\:YU'A/@BM �

!/UNJL:lHNMEM?bNmW>1VW< [0<E[

��������� � q n � n2�at

�$V/@^JL@ � � � ��� � <E[�>#@^JL:Y@BAG>1V/@C�&�.�;�����cb?�U�#� ��� OdUNJ]b �$� �&�+�#�<� J � � �;� ���&O �Sp��54�� m���<E[.>1V/@):Y@BHNDGUNO�>1V/@AWHK>1H'm �����(q o �ft�HNDIA �����(q o � �Yt �$<?>1V�� AW<EHK]NUaDIHNM ����V/@AI<EHK]NUaDWHNME<?> b UNO >1VW@D/Ua<E[1@AW<E[1>#JL<?9I8/>1<EUaD<E[\H �N@^brHN[1[L8W:YFW>1<?UaD m�HN[e<?>\<E[\:Y@BHNDZ>*>#U <E:YFIM?@B:=@BDT>)>1V/@�<EA/@BHd>1VWHK> � �$<EMEM�:YU'A/@BM�HNMEM&>1V/@ @� '< [#>1<ED/]

A/@^FP@BDWA/@BDI_^<?@B[�<ED,>1V/@YUN9I[#@^J1jKHK9IM?@YAWHK>1H � n2�'m&p��2��� �Y��V/@���HN8W[L[1<EHND�HN[1[18I:YFW>1<?UaDW[�HKJ1@Y> bZF;<E_^HNMEM?b,:=HNA/@

>#UCHNMEM?U � HND,HNDIHNM?bZ>1< _\@^jKHNME8WHK>1<EUaD UNO�>1V/@Y<EDZ>#@^]NJLHNM�<ED q n ���at �e��DWA/@^@BAfmP97bd>1VW<E[�_LVWUa<E_`@Nm >1V/@Y<EDZ>#@^]NJLHNM�<ED

q n ���at49 @B_`Ua:=@B[\Hi_`UaDZjNUaME8/>1<EUaDrUNO�> �.U ��HN8W[1[1< HNDW[ � m ��q��t�9P@B_`Ua:=<ED/]dHK]aHN< DrH �)HN8W[1[1<EHND m �$<?>1Vr:Y@BHND� HNDIA _`U j HKJL< HNDW_`@�� � ����� � �,�$V/@lFIHKJhHN:Y@^>#@^JL[ UNO0>1V/@G:YU'A/@BM � � m�� HNDWA�� � _^HND 9P@@B[#>1<E:lHK>#@BA 9Zb,� � �P��D�<?>#@^JLHK>1<EjN@ ��� HNM?]NUNJh<?>1VW: :=HBb,9P@e8I[#@BA �Sp��2��� m HN[�>1V/@^J1@Y<E[�D/U �'D/U �D,_^MEUa[#@BA

OQUNJL: HNDWHNM?b7>1<E_^HNM [1UaME8/>1<?UaD��

� � �� � ����� ��� ������������ � � � ������� ����� � ��� � ����� ��� � ����� ���� � ��� ��! � �#" � � ��������� ���� � ��� � ��� � �$� � ����� ��%� ��� ��!

!�"��(<E[�H �$< A/@BM?b 8I[#@BACFPU �.@^J1Os8WMf:Y@^>1V/U'AiUNO�AWHK>1H=HNDIHNM?b7[L<E[�HNDWACUNFI>1<E:=HNM�qs<EDdM?@BHN[#>$:Y@BHND [1X78WHKJ1@

[#@BDW[1@ t�_`Ua:=FWJ1@B[1[1<EUaD � 4 o/m/p 4 � ����Jh<?]a<EDWHNMEMEbNm !."0� VWHN[�9P@^@BD\OQUNJL:e8WMEHK>#@BA HN[�H�D/UaD�� FWJLUN9IHK9I<EME< [#>1<E_�:Y@^>1V/U'A

�$VW< _LVCA/@^>#@^JL:l<ED/@B[0HNDCUNJ1>1VWUN]NUaDWHNMf9IHN[1< [0[#@^>�<EDG>1V/@4AW<EJ1@B_`>1<?UaDGUNO�:=H� '< :=HNMPj HKJh<EHNDW_`@4<EDG>1V/@4AIHK>1H=HNDWA

FWJ1U��#@B_`>1[�>1V/@�AWHK>1H$UaDT>#U�>1V/@B[#@.AW<?J1@B_`>1<EUaDW[ � 4 o/m7p 4 � ���U �.@^jN@^JBma>1VW@ � _`UaDTjN@BDZ>1<?UaDWHNM � !�"��6A/U7@B[�D/UN>�A/@`R;D/@

H4FIJ1UN9IHK9I<EM <?>kb AW<E[#>#Jh<?9I8/>1<?UaD���� [#Ua:Y@��$VIHK>�J1@B_`@BDZ>.J1@B:=HKJ��KHK9IM?@�JL@B[18WM?>&UNO �$<?FWFI<EDW]4HNDWAl��<E[1VWUNF �Sp�/$- �P<E[

>1VWHK>&>1VW@^b ��@^J1@HK9IM?@0>#U\[LV/U � V/U � !."���OgUaM M?U �$[�HN[�H4�,� [1UaME8/>1<?UaDYUNOfH)FIJ1UN9IHK9I<EM <E[#>1<E_.MEHK>#@BDZ>&j HKJh<EHK9IM?@&('*),+*-/.102'3),+54 65-7'3)86/-:9;6<.102= + )?>@6BADC2EGF�-H= 6 )8IJE�KL-:9;6M.D= + )8C2ENF�AD>B>PO3-

p �

Page 31: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

:YU'A/@BM ����V/@�MEHK>#>#@^J.< [&H*[#FP@B_^<EHNM;_^HN[#@$UNO !'�\m&�$VW@^J1@<E[1UN>#J1UNFI<E_0D/Ua< [#@$UNOPjKHKJL<EHNDW_`@�� � <E[�_`UaDI[1<EA/@^J1@BA�����D<E:YFPUNJ1>1HNDZ>�_`UaDW[1@BXZ8/@BDI_`@�UNO/>1V/@B<EJ�A/@^JL<Ej HK>1<?UaD*<E[ >1VWHK>�!."0�6_^HND*9P@&@� 'FWJ1@B[1[1@BA*<ED*>#@^JL:=[�UNOWH�FWJ1UN9;HK9I<EME<?> b

A/@BDW[L<?>kb*:=U7A/@BM ����VW< [�VWHN[�H�D78W:\9 @^J�UNOIHNAWj HNDZ>1HK]N@B[&jN@^JL[L8W[�>1V/@4qsD/UaD�� FWJ1UN9;HK9I<EME<E[1>1<E_ t FWJ1U��#@B_`>1<?UaD�� 9;HN[#@BA

!."0� � 4 o�� mI@!� ]���@� '>#@BDW[1<?9I< ME<?>kblUNO�>1VW@*:YU'A/@BMP>#Ul:=< '>18/J1@)UNO�!�!�"���[ �Sp�/2//mIn$- ��UNJ�@� 7>#@BDI[1<?9I<EM <?>kb >#U=>1V/@

��HBbN@B[1< HND OgJLHN:=@���UNJ�� �Sp��'m�p � � �VW<E_LV HNMEM?U �$[�>1V/@\FPUa[1[L<?9I<EME<E>kblUNO�@B:YFIM?U b7<EDW]l>1V/@^UNJ1@^>1< _^HNMEM?biFWJh<EDW_^<?FIME@BA

:YU'A/@BMPUNJLA/@^J[#@BM?@B_`>1<?UaDi_`Jh<?>#@^JL<EH��

��Di!�!�"��\m/>1V/@4_`UaDWAW<?>1<EUaDWHNMfAWHK>1H=AW< [#>#JL<?9I8W>1<?UaDlOQUNJ$H=AIHK>1HYFPUa<EDT> � <E[0A/@`R;DW@BAiHN[

��q��� � ��t q n���� � t�� ��� � @� 7F % pn�� � q��� % � � % ��t ��� q n � n$-Zt

".@BDZ>#@^J1@BAcAIHK>1Hr_^HND 9P@iHN[1[L8W:Y@BA6OQUNJ=>1V/@i@BHN[1@dUNO)D/UN>1HK>1<?UaDfm�UNJBm�@BX78W<?jKHNM?@BDZ>1M?bNm�>1VW@iOgUaM M?U �$< D/]�[18/9��

[#>1<?>18W>1<?UaDW[*_^HND 9P@ :=HNAW@!/�� / � � � � �.HNDWA ��/ � � � �Bp � � �d��V/@�MEHK>#>#@^J �$<EMEM�9P@ HNAWUNFW>#@BArOQUNJe@BHN[#@UNO0D/UN>1HK>1<?UaD����[\<ED >1V/@�!'� :YU'A/@BM m�HND <E[#UN>#J1UNF;<E_���HN8W[1[L<EHND �$<?>1V %^@^J1U �k:Y@BHND HNDWA 8WDW<E>�jKHKJL<EHNDI_`@l<E[

HN[1[18I:Y@BACUaDC>1V/@4M HK>#@BDT>j HKJL< HK9IM?@!�

��q���t q n���t � � � � @� 'F %pn � � � � q n � n2/at

��DGRI>#>1<ED/] >1V/@\:YU7AW@BM m���@*HKJL@*<EDZ>#@^J1@B[#>#@BAi<ED �$JL<?>1<ED/] >1V/@4_`Ua:=FIM?@^>#@*AWHK>1HlM?UN] �kME< �N@BME< V/UZU'Afm

�� ��� �� M?UN] � ��q��� � ��t ��q���t�� q n � n20at

>1V/@,@� 7FP@B_`>1HK>1<?UaD UNO �VW<E_LV(qQ>#@^JL:Y@BA >1V/@ J1@BMEHK>1<?jN@ M?UN] �kME< �N@BME<EV/U7U7A �Sp 4 �Qt _^HND�9P@,:=H� '< :=<E[#@BAcj7<EH HND

<?>#@^JLHK>1<EjN@d��� HNM?]NUNJL<E>1VW:�� ��@BD/UN>1<ED/]�>1VW@iFPUa[#>#@^JL<?UNJ=A/@BDI[1<?>kb��������aq�� � ��'thm0HN[l<?>=< [Y_`Ua:YFI8/>#@BA 8I[1<ED/]FIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^JejKHNME8/@B[*@B[#>1<E:=HK>#@BA <EDr>1V/@�� �k[#>#@^F UNO�>1V/@ FWJ1@^j'<?Ua8W[*<E>#@^JLHK>1<?UaDfm�>1V/@�J1@BMEHK>1<?jN@�ME< �N@BME<EVWUZU'A�<E[

>1V/@4OQUaMEM?U �$<ED/]��

� pn��� �� � � ����� q�� � ��/t� �,M?UN] p� � % p� � q��� % � ��t ��� � q n � n54Nt

��V/@lF Ua[1>#@^JL<?UNJ*A/@BDI[1<?>kb <E[4_`Ua:=FI8/>#@BAr< D�>1V/@ � [#>#@^F 8W[1<ED/]G>1V/@ � UaMEA(� jKHNME8/@B[4UNO.>1VW@lFIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^JL[4j'<EH

��HBbN@B[�� JL8WME@

��q�� � �t � q�� � �����LPt:� � q o �ft

��q��t q n � n2�at

HNM?UaD/] �$<?>1VC[#Ua:Y@ ��HN8W[1[1< HNDi<EA/@BDZ>1<?>1<?@B[�� �$VI<E_LVfm/97bG[1<E:YFIM <?Ogb'<ED/]eHNDWAiD/UN>1< D/]Y>1VWHK> �.@\A/U=DWUN>$VWHBjN@\>#U

_^HKJ1@YHK9PUa8/>$>1VW@eA/@BDWUa:=<EDWHK>#UNJBmPHN[ ��@)�'D/U �(>1V/@eFPUa[#>#@^JL<?UNJ �$<EMEM�9P@ ��HN8W[L[1<EHND q �$V/Ua[#@ D/UNJL:=HNM <E[1HK>1<?UaD� = + )?>@6�E�� & KL- � = 6 \ )?> O ��! & >@-"! � > O � ! & +$# E )?> O ��! & >B-"! � _

nKo

Page 32: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

OsHN_`>#UNJ<E[ �'D/U �$D;thm/>1V/@4OQUaMEM?U �$<ED/] OQUNJL: J1@B[L8WM?>1[��

� ����� q���� ���t#��� � q#q�� � � � � � ft � � � � � ��� � q�� � � � � � ft � � t q n � n �at

��VW@.� [#>#@^F @BXZ8WHK>1<EUaDW[�HKJ1@�UN9W>1HN<ED/@BA\97b\[#UaM?j'<ED/]>1V/@0[#>1HK>1<?UaDWHKJLb4@BXZ8IHK>1<?UaDW[����� � o�HNDWA������� & o'm]N@^>#>1<ED/]l>1V/@*[#>1HNDWAIHKJLAGJ1@B[18WME>1[

� ��� �� � � � ��� � � ��

��� �� � � �� � � � �

� �q n ���KoTt

� � p� p���� �� � � � �� % � � � � � ��� �� ��� q n ���'p t

��D �Sp�/$- � m >1V/@�HN8/>1VWUNJL[��.@^J1@�HK9IM?@�>#U[1V/U � >1VWHK> >1V/@&MEUN] �kME< �N@BME<EVWUZU'A�<E[ :=H� /<E:=<E[1@BA �V/@BD)>1V/@&_`UaME8I:=DW[

UNO � [#F;HND >1V/@U� ����� � � ���#�t�� %���B�S� � �CUNO0>1V/@ AWHK>1H'm�< � @!�iHKJL@�[1_^HNME@BA HNDWArJ1UN>1HK>#@BA @B<?]N@BDZjN@B_`>#UNJL[ UNO0>1V/@

[1HN:YF;M?@ _`U j HKJL< HNDW_`@C:=HK>#JL< �d� UNJ1@G@� 'HN_`>1M?bNm�<?>\<E[\[1V/U �$D �Sp�/$- �.>1VIHK>\>1V/@�UaDWM?b DWUaD�� %^@^J1U [#>1HK>1<?UaDWHKJ1b

FPUa<EDZ>.UNO � U7_^_^8WJL[0OQUNJ

� �� ��q�� � % � � Pt � � ��� q n ���Nnat

�$V/@^JL@�>1V/@3� _`UaME8I:=DW[ UNO � �YHKJ1@.@B<?]N@BDZjN@B_`>#UNJL[�UNO/>1V/@�[1HN:YF;M?@�_`U j HKJL< HNDW_`@0:=HK>#JL< � ���� �� �� q��� %���t`q��� % ��$t � �$<?>1VC_`UNJ1JL@B[#FPUaDWAW<ED/]e@B<?]N@BDZj HNM 8/@B[�<EDG>1V/@\AW<EHK]NUaDWHNMf:=HK>#Jh< ���� HNDWA � <E[0HNDdHKJ19I<?>#JLHKJLb

� � J1UN>1HK>1<?UaD :lHK>#JL< q �$VW< _LV�J1UN>1HK>#@B[C>1V/@,9IHN[1<E[�<EDW[L<EA/@i>1V/@,FWJL< DW_^<?FIHNM�[L8/9I[#FIHN_`@ t��!� � UNJ1@^U jN@^J m>1V/@^b�VWH jN@ >1V/@^UNJL@^>1<E_^HNMEM?b�[1V/U �$D�>1VWHK>\>1V/@l]aMEUN9IHNM&:=H� /<E:e8W: UNO0>1V/@lM < �N@BME<EV/U7U'A,[L8/J1OsHN_`@l<E[4UN9I>1HN<ED/@BA

UaDWM?b �$VW@BD � ��_`UaDW[1<E[#>1[$UNO�>1V/@ MEHKJ1]N@B[#>@B<?]N@BDTjN@B_`>#UNJh[�UNO �mPHNMEM UN>1VW@^J�_`Ua:\9I<EDWHK>1<EUaDW[$UNO�@B<E]N@BDTjN@B_`>#UNJL[J1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>�[LHNAWAWM?@�� FPUa<EDZ>1[�UNO�>1VW@*ME< �N@BME< V/UZU'A�[18/J1OsHN_`@!����V/@4�,� @B[1>1<E:=HK>#@4OQUNJ � � <E[0]a<EjN@BDC9Zb

� � p� % �

��� � ��� � � � q n ���2�at

< � @!�&>1VW@)j HKJL< HNDW_`@4M?Ua[#>$< DG>1V/@)FWJ1U��#@B_`>1<?UaDfmIH jN@^JLHK]N@BA U jN@^J�>1V/@4M?Ua[#>$AI<E:Y@BDW[1<EUaDW[��

��V78W[^m�<EDWA/@^@BA >1VW< [ ]N@BDW@^JLHK>1<?jN@r:YU'A/@BM�J1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>1[CH FIJ1UN9IHK9I<EM <E[#>1<E_COQUNJL:e8WMEHK>1<?UaD UNOe!."����0��V/@

_`UaDZjN@BDT>1<?UaDIHNM�!."0� <E[�J1@B_`U jN@^J1@BA,<EDG>1V/@ %^@^JLUlD/Ua<E[#@4M <E:=<?>1<EDW]e_^HN[#@�q � ��! oTt �Sp�/$- � ���DC[18W:=:lHKJ1bNm'>1V/@4!�!�"��-:YU'A/@BMf_^HNDC9P@�UN9W>1HN<EDW@BAG9ZblR;DWAW<EDW]*>1V/@ �cFWJL<EDW_^<EFIHNMW@B<?]N@BDZjN@B_`>#UNJL[�HNDWA

@B<?]N@BDZj HNM 8/@B[)UNO.>1V/@l[1HN:YF;M?@Y_`U jKHKJL<EHNDW_`@l:lHK>#JL< �=��V/@=A/@BDW[L<?>kb,:YU7AW@BM�<E[�>1V/@BD�]a<?jN@BD 9Zb H ��HN8W[L[1<EHND

�$<?>1V :Y@BHND �� qQ>1V/@G[1HN:YF;M?@ :Y@BHND t4HNDWA _`U jKHKJL<EHNDI_`@�:=HK>#Jh< ��� � � � � 6<ED �VW<E_LV � <E[*]a<?jN@BD 9Zb

q n ���Nnat\HNDWA �c9Zb q n ���2�at �,��VW<E[4< [4HND < :YFPUNJ1>1HNDT>*J1@B[18WM?>)OQUNJ*FIJLHN_`>1<E_^HNM._`UaDW[1<EA/@^JhHK>1<?UaDW[^m�HN[\[#>1HNDIAWHKJLA"�# )8D���4DS�* �"#�C���*.@���=W*�����="<���,D�=�&��)+/1����=1�), Q �� ���/ 17 ��=�/)#� $ �1��& �"#�;���7+/1����=1/)<��� �/M �"#� D#17 1&%\ )?>P6#A(' -N)?>@6#A(' - O _ .>@>PO@A�3&GK 1/)8D2 �"#���;D<����� )#�� ;�R"#1/)<.*� ��M > ���C�����<� 1����4DE:;�� �" > $9F

n'p

Page 33: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

@B<?]N@BD�� JLUa8/>1<ED/@B[^m&�$<?>1V �.@BMEM � �'D/U �D=[#>1HK9I<EM <?>kbeFWJ1UNFP@^J1>1<?@B[�_^HND=9P@�8W[#@BA <EDYFWJLHN_`>1< _`@Nm&�$VW< M?@0VWHBj'<ED/]*H*DW<E_`@

>1V/@^UNJ1@^>1< _^HNMEM?b�FWJL<EDW_^<EFIM?@BA=>1VW@^UNJ1@^>1<E_^HNM FIJ1UN9IHK9I<EM <E[#>1<E_$OgJLHN:=@���UNJ�� �

!�!."�� VWHN[49P@^@BD [L8W_^_`@B[1[#Os8WMEM?b,HKFWFIME<E@BA >#U FWJ1UN9IME@B:=[)<ED�AWHK>1H _`Ua:YFWJ1@B[1[L<?UaDfm�A/@BDI[1<?>kb,@B[#>1<E:lHK>1<?UaD

�Sp�/$- ��HNDIAiAWHK>1HYj'<E[18WHNM <E[1HK>1<?UaD � n$- � �

� � � ��� � � ��� � � � � � � ��� � �L� " � � �

��@.VWHBjN@.[#@^@BD4>1VWHK>�9PUN>1V)>1V/@ !'� HNDWA4!�!."�� :YU'A/@BME[ HN[1[L8W:Y@&H �)HN8W[1[1<EHND*D/Ua<E[#@&:YU'A/@BM ����V/@^J1@^OQUNJ1@

>1V/@B[#@e:YU'A/@BME[$HKJL@\[18W<E>1HK9IM?@4OQUNJ$J1@BHNM�jKHNME8/@BAd_`UaDZ>1<ED78/Ua8W[AWHK>1H��$�U �.@^jN@^J)>1V/@^J1@\HKJL@e[1<E>18WHK>1<?UaDW[ �V/@^J1@

>1V/@.AWHK>1H$<E[�AW<E[1_`J1@^>#@�j HNME8W@BA*HNDWA\:YU7AW@BME[��$VW< _LV4_`UaDW[L<EA/@^J ��HN8I[1[1<EHND\D/Ua<E[#@�HKJL@�<EDWHKFIFWJ1UNFWJL< HK>#@!�f� D �Sp�/2��� m

>1V/@���HN8W[1[L<EHND*MEHK>#@BDZ>�FWJL<?UNJ�]N@BD/@^JLHK>1<?jN@0:YU'A/@BMTVIHN[�9P@^@BD\A/@^jN@BM?UNFP@BA*OQUNJ�9I<EDWHKJ1b)AWHK>1H�����VW@�HKFWFWJLUNFWJL<EHK>#@

D/Ua<E[1@�:=U7A/@BM/< [�>1V/@^J1@^OQUNJ1@��.@^JLD/Ua8WMEM <ZAW< [#>#JL<?9I8W>#@BA �SpNp��WmWp�/2�'mC02��� ����@BD/UN>1<ED/])>1V/@�_^HNDWUaDW<E_^HNM/<EDZjN@^JL[#@�ME< D��

Os8WDW_`>1<?UaDdUNO&>1V/@\�.@^JLDWUa8WMEME< AI<E[#>#JL<?9;8/>1<?UaD �SpNp�����9Zb �&q��7t ����� �� � ����� � m;>1VW@\_`UaDWAW<E>1<?UaDWHNM�AIHK>1H ME< �N@BME<EV/U7U7A<E[�UNO�>1V/@4OQUaMEM?U �$<ED/]eOQUNJL:��

��q� � � � ��t �&q�� � ����� � t �� # q�p % �&q�� � � ��� � t#t � � �� # � � q n � � % p t`q�� � ����� � t�� q n ���$-Zt

�$V/@^JL@ � � <E[�>1V/@ � � >1V JLU � UNO �$�*��[)HND�<E[#UN>#JLUNFI<E_ ��HN8W[1[1< HND FIJL<?UNJ�<E[�:=HNA/@Nm [1<E:l<EMEHKJ�>#U�>1VW@ !�!."��

HNDWA !'� :YU'A/@BME[^mN>1VW@$<EDZ>#@^]NJLHNM�q n ���at�OQUNJ�_`Ua:=FI8/>1<ED/]�>1V/@ME< �N@BME<EVWUZU'A\< [&D/U ��<EDT>#JhHN_`>1HK9IM?@!��� j HKJL< HK>1<?UaDWHNM

HKFWFWJLU /<E:=HK>1<?UaD,OQUNJ ��q��� � ��t�VIHN[�>1V/@^J1@^OQUNJ1@Y9P@^@BD @B:YFIM?U bN@BA�<ED �Sp�/2��� m��$VI<E_LV :=H �N@B[)>1VW@Yj HKJL< HK>1<?UaDWHNMHKFWFWJLU /<E:=HK>1<?UaDc>#U M?UN]���q��� � ��tlX78WHNA/JLHK>1<E_d<ED >1V/@ FIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^J �$�-�UN>#@ >1VWHK>^m�<EDc_`UaDZ>#JLHN[#>G>#U >1V/@

FWJ1@^j'<?Ua8W[LM?b)A/@B[1_`JL<?9P@BA\:YU7AW@BME[^m �$VW<E_hV\HN[L[18W:Y@���HN8W[1[L<EHND\DWUa<E[#@NmaHNDWAeA/@^FP@BDWAW<EDW]�UaDe>1V/@�OgUNJL:(HN[1[L8W:Y@BA

OQUNJi>1V/@ _`U jKHKJL<EHNDI_`@r:=HK>#JL< @B<?>1V/@^JC>1V/@ !'� UNJd!�!�"�� :=U7A/@BM [GJ1@B[18WM?>#@BA m<ED >1V/@ _^HN[#@rUNOeAW< [1_`J1@^>#@

AWHK>1H'm�>1V/@^J1@i<E[ D/U�[18W_hV AW< �P@^J1@BDW_`@Nm�HN[Y>1VW@^J1@C<E[ D/U j HKJL< HNDW_`@GFIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^J=OQUNJY>1V/@C_`UaDWAW<E>1<?UaDWHNM.AWHK>1H

AW<E[1>#JL<?9I8/>1<EUaD��r��D/UN>1V/@^J=AW< �P@^J1@BDW_`@i< [ >1VWHK>=D/U � >1V/@i:Y@BHND6FIHKJhHN:Y@^>#@^J � _^HNDWD/UN>Y9P@i_^HNDW_`@BM M?@BA 9Zb[18/9;[#>#JLHN_`>1<ED/]l>1V/@\:Y@BHND OQJ1Ua: >1VW@\AWHK>1H��$�$VW<E[�<E[$9P@B_^HN8W[#@\DWU � >1V/@*]N@BD/@^JhHNM�OQUNJL: UNO�>1V/@\:YU'A/@BM m;>1V/@

@BX78W<?jKHNM?@BDT>0UNO0q n � n2�at$<E[

�&q�� � ����t � � q n ���2/at

�$<?>1V�9I< D/Ua:=<EHNM D/Ua<E[#@ � �&��VW@�DWUaDWME<ED/@BHKJh<?>kb �&q t.< [�>1V/@4_^HND/UaDW<E_^HNMfM <ED��YOs8WDW_`>1<?UaDCHN[1[1U7_^<EHK>#@BA �$<?>1V�>1V/@

9I<EDWUa:=<EHNMPD/Ua<E[#@ �SpNp���� �

nNn

Page 34: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

��@BD/UN>1<EDW]Y>1V/@4HKJ1]a8W:Y@BDZ>0UNO0q n ���$-Zt�97b�� � � / q n � � % p t`q�� � ��� � � thmW>1VW@��.@^JLDWUa8WMEME<PAW<E[1>#JL<?9I8/>1<EUaD<E[�9PUa8WDWAW@BAG9 @BMEU � �Sp�/2��� 97bG>1V/@)@� 'FWJ1@B[1[1<EUaD

��q� � � � ��t �����q� � � � ��t�/ �&q�� � � tZ@� 7F � q�� � � % � � � t��Kn � � q�� � � t`q�� �� � % � �� � t � q n ���20at

�$V/@^JL@ ���q� � � � ��t�<E[�[1V/UNJ1>1VWHNDIA\OQUNJ ���q� � � � � � � �� � �Wt�HNDWA � q�� � �Wt &% ��� # >1HNDWV�q�� � ���Knat�A/U7@B[�D/UN>&A/@^FP@BDWAUaD,>1V/@Y:YU'A/@BM�F;HKJLHN:Y@^>#@^J �$�4��V/@ HKFWFWJ1U '< :=HK>1<?UaDfm ���q� � � � ��thmf<E[�>#@^JL:Y@BA,>1V/@ J � ���M�#�<�M�������w�3�5u �$�3�51[�.�.�HNDWAr>1V/@�DW@��$M?b <EDT>#JLU7AW8I_`@BArHNAWAW<E>1<?UaDWHNM�FIHKJhHN:Y@^>#@^JL[ � � � HKJL@ >#@^JL:=@BA J � ���M�#�<�M������� ��� �s�����.� �&��� � ��V/@<ED/@BX78WHNME<E>kbCV/UaMEAW[$OgUNJ�HNDZbij HNM 8/@*UNO&>1VW@\jKHKJL<EHK>1<?UaDIHNM FIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^JL[^m �$<?>1Vd@BXZ8WHNM <?>kbiV/UaM AW<ED/]=<?O&HNDIAdUaDWMEb

<?O�� � � � � �+�C��VW@=]NUaHNM�< [4>#U HNA �#8W[1>4>1V/@ljKHKJL<EHK>1<EUaDWHNM�FIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^JL[\HK>\@BHN_LV [#>#@^F UNO0>1V/@ HNM?]NUNJh<?>1VW:Cm[18W_hVr>1VIHK>e>1VW@l>#JL8/@GHNDWA HKFWFWJ1U '< :=HK>#@�AW@BDW[1<?> b,Os8WDW_`>1<EUaDW[*]N@^> HN[ _^M?Ua[#@�>#U @BHN_LV UN>1V/@^JYHN[eF Ua[L[1<?9IM?@!�

��V/@Y]NU7U'AWD/@B[1[)UNO.>1VW<E[*HKFWFWJ1U '<E:lHK>1<?UaD�VWHN[)9P@^@BD HN[1[1@B[1[#@BAr< D �102�'m�p�/2��� �=��D R;DIAW<ED/]�>1V/@YFIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^J

@B[#>1<E:lHK>#@B[^ma>1V/@�jKHKJL<EHK>1<?UaDWHNM7J1@BM HK>1<?jN@0ME< �N@BME<EVWUZU'A*<E[�:=H� /<E:=< [#@BA����$VW<E[�<E[�A/@BD/UN>#@BA 97b �� HNDWAY< [�UN9I>1HN<ED/@BA97b J1@^F;MEHN_^<ED/]iq n ���20at$<EDG>1V/@4@� 'FWJ1@B[1[L<?UaDGUNO�>1VW@4J1@BMEHK>1<?jN@4M < �N@BME<EV/U7U'A��

�� ��� ��

������ � � ����� q���� � �/t � M?UN] ���q� � � � ��t� � � M?UN]���q���t�� q n ���54Nt

��VW< [�]a8WHKJLHNDZ>#@^@B[�>1VWHK>)HND,��� HNM?]NUNJh<?>1VW: �$<EMEM _`UaDZjN@^J1]N@Y>#UCH�M?U7_^HNM�:=H� /<E:e8W: qQUNJ)[1HNAIAWM?@*FPUa<EDZ>ht�UNO

>1V/@YjKHKJL<EHK>1<?UaDIHNM�ME< �N@BME<EVWUZU'Ad97b <EDW_`J1@BHN[1< D/]�<E>4HK>4@BHN_LV <?>#@^JLHK>1<?UaDfm �$<?>1V/Ua8/>)HNDZb ]a8IHKJLHNDT>#@^@�HK9PUa8/>)>1V/@

>#JL8/@GME< �N@BM <EV/U7U7A�9P@B<EDW] <EDW_`JL@BHN[#@BA�� �$@^jN@^J1>1VW@BM?@B[1[^m�<EO0>1V/@�HKFIFWJ1U /<E:=HK>1<EUaD <E[eJ1@BHN[1UaDWHK9IM?b�]NU7U7A m�>1V/@BD

H ]NUZU'A HKFWFWJ1U '<E:lHK>#@ [1UaME8/>1<?UaD _^HND 9 @\@� 7FP@B_`>#@BA��)��VW@eHN_^_^8/JhHN_`bdUNO�>1VI<E[$F;HKJ1>1<E_^8WMEHKJ�HKFWFWJ1U '< :=HK>1<?UaD

VWHN[l9 @^@BDc<EDTjN@B[1>1<?]aHK>#@BA�< D69PUN>1V �102����HNDIA �Sp�/2��� � ��V/@i]NJL@BHK> HNA/jKHNDT>1HK]N@,UNO�>1V/@ HKFIFWJ1U /<E:=HK>1<EUaD <E[

>1VWHK>.M?UN] ���q� � � � ��t�< [�X78WHNA/JLHK>1<E_0< DY>1V/@$<EDI<?>1<EHNM':YU'A/@BM/FIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^JL[ � m&�VW<E_LVl:=H �N@B[�>1VW@$_`Ua:YFI8/>1HK>1<EUaDW[>#JLHN_`>1HK9IME@!�

��VW@d��� HNM?]NUNJL<E>1VW: <E[Y>1VW@BDcHN[ OgUaMEMEU �$[���� D >1V/@ � �k[#>#@^F m�>1V/@iFPUa[#>#@^JL<EUNJlA/@BDW[1<E>kb6<E[=_`Ua:YF;8/>#@BA

HN_^_`UNJLAW< D/]Y>#U=>1V/@*MEU �.@^J$9PUa8WDWAfm �$VW< _LVG>1H �N@B[�H ��HN8W[1[L<EHNDGOgUNJh:��

���q���� �� ��� � t���� � q���� � � �'t q n ���2�at

�$<?>1V

� � % n

������ � q�� � �Wt � � � � �

� �q n ��� �at

��� � � ������ q� � � %

pn �6n � q�� � �Wt � � t � � q n �1-aoTt

n2�

Page 35: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

��V/@B[1@�XZ8WHNDZ>1<?>1<?@B[&FWJ1U j'<EA/@0>1VW@�FPUa[#>#@^JL<?UNJ&[18 � _^<?@BDZ>&[#>1HK>1<E[#>1<E_^[ � FPUa[#>#@^JL<?UNJ�:Y@BHND � � � � �� � ��� HNDWA

FPUa[#>#@^JL<?UNJ�_`U jKHKJL<EHNDW_`@ � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �$VW<E_hVdHKJ1@ D/@B_`@B[1[LHKJ1bCOgUNJ�>1V/@ � �k[1>#@^F��

��V/@=� �k[#>#@^F 8/FfAWHK>#@B[^mfUN9W>1HN<EDW@BA�9Zb [#UaM?j'<ED/]G>1V/@=[1>1HK>1<?UaDWHKJ1b,@BXZ8IHK>1<?UaDW[)UNO �� �<?>1V J1@B[#FP@B_`>)>#Ui9PUN>1V

>1V/@4jKHKJL<EHK>1<EUaDWHNMfHNDWAi:YU'A/@BMPFIHKJhHN:Y@^>#@^JL[^mIHKJL@4>1V/@)OQUaMEM?U �<ED/]��

� �� � � � � � � �� � � �� � � � �6n � � � � � � � ��� �� � ��� �� q n �1-Wp t

���� % ��� �� n � q�� � �Wt � � ��� ��� � � �� �

� � ��� �� q� � � % pn t � � ��� � �� � q n �1-Tnat

�$V/@^JL@�>1V/@&D/UN>1HK>1<?UaD � � / � � � � � � � � � HNDWA � � / � � � �Bp �7VWHN[ 9 @^@BD)8I[#@BAfm [1U � � � � � � � q � � ��� � � � �Bp t �HNDWA � � � � � � � � � � ��

� � � �� � � � � � � � � � �� � � � �� � p

��

��VW@*FWJL< DW_^<?FIHNMf:Y@^Jh<?>$UNO&>1VI<E[$:YU'A/@BM�<E[$>1VIHK>�<?>U � @^Jh[�H�[#Ua8WDIAiOQJLHN:Y@��.UNJ��iOQUNJ�:YU'A/@BMEM <ED/]Y9I<EDIHKJ1b

AWHK>1H�����V/@.:YU'A/@BM&��HN[�FWJ1UNFPUa[#@BA*OgUNJ�j'<E[18WHNM <E[1HK>1<?UaD �Sp�/2� � maV/U �.@^jN@^J&<ED �1/$- �/<?>�VIHN[�9P@^@BD\@� 7FP@^JL< :Y@BDT>1HNM M?b

[1V/U �$D�>1VWHK>^m'9P@B_^HN8W[#@�H �)HN8W[1[1<EHND FWJL<EUNJ.<E[.<E:YFPUa[#@BA mT>1V/@�J1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>1HK>1<EUaD FIJ1U7AI8W_`@BAl97b=>1VW< [�:YU'A/@BM <E[

jN@^J1bC[1<E:l<EMEHKJ.>#Ul>1VWHK>�UNO�H=[#>1HNDIAWHKJLAC!."0���

� ��� � ��� � � � � ���������� � ��� ��� �!��� �

!�<EDW<E>#@\:=< '>18/J1@e:YU'A/@BMEME<EDW]=<E[$HG[#>1HK>1<E[1>1<E_^HNM�>#@B_hVWDW<EX78/@eOgUNJ�A/@BDW[L<?>kbC@B[#>1< :=HK>1<?UaD �SpNpBn'm�p 47m�p��$- � �� >

HNME[#UGVWHN[ �$< A/@\HKFWF;ME<E_^HK9I<EM <?>kbG<ED AWHK>1HGHNDWHNM?b'[1<E[�HNDWA,@B[#FP@B_^<EHNMEM?bi_^M 8W[#>#@^JL<EDW]�����VW@ AIHK>1H�< [HN[1[L8W:Y@BA,>#U

9P@)]N@BD/@^JLHK>#@BAd9ZbGH=D78W:*9P@^J0UNO�:=< '>18/J1@)_`Ua:YFPUaD/@BDZ>1[^mW@BHN_hVdVWH j7< D/]=<?>1[0U �$DCFWJ1UN9;HK9I<EME<?> bl:YU'A/@BM �

��q���'t ��� �� ��q����Kt ��q��� � ��� ���Ct q n �1-C�at

��U\J1@BM HK>#@>1VW< [�:YU'A/@BMI>#U\>1V/@�]N@BD/@^JLHNM OQUNJL: UNO ]N@BD/@^JLHK>1<?jN@):YU'A/@BME[�FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>#@BA�9P@^OgUNJ1@Nm �.@�_^HND�>1VW<ED �eUNO

<?>�HN[�VWHBj'<ED/]�H�M HK>#@BDT>)A/@BDW[L<?>kbCUNO&>1VW@\OQUNJL: UNO�H�:=< '>18/J1@*UNO�A/@BM?>1H OQ8WDI_`>1<?UaDW[^mP_`@BDT>#@^JL@BA @BHN_LV�HK>�UaD/@

UNO.>1V/@ � _^HND/UaDW<E_^HNM�8IDW<?>�jN@B_`>#UNJL[ ���&� �7U/m�>1V/@lAW<E:=@BDW[1<?UaDWHNM <?>kbCUNO.>1V/@lMEHK>#@BDZ>*[#F;HN_`@l<E[)<ED >1VW< [)_^HN[#@� � �&� jN@^J1bC[1< :=<EMEHKJ.>#J1@BHK>1:Y@BDZ>_^HNDd9 @)OQUa8WDWAC< D �Sp��54�� �

��q���t ��� ��� q�� % ���Kt ��q�� ���Kt q n �1-2-Zt

��VW< [0<E:YFIME<E@B[�>1VIHK>H=AW< [1_`J1@^>#@*AW< [#>#JL<?9I8W>1<?UaD < [�HN[1[18W:=@BACUaDi>1V/@\MEHK>#@BDT>j HKJh<EHK9IM?@�jN@B_`>#UNJBm �$<?>1ViHYR;DW<?>#@

[#@^>CUNO\UaDWM?b � FPUa[1[1<?9;M?@djKHNME8/@B[�qQ>1V/@ _^HND/UaDI<E_^HNM)8WDW<?>�jN@B_`>#UNJL[htCHNDWA HN[i[18W_hVfm$>1VI<E[GFWJL<?UNJGHN[1[18I:Y@B[UaDWM?bGUaD/@\_`Ua:YFPUaD/@BDT>9P@B<ED/] � UaD(� HK>H=>1< :Y@ � < DCUNFWFPUa[1<?>1<?UaDi>#Ul>1V/@ ��HN8W[1[1< HNDiMEHK>#@BDZ>$FWJL<EUNJ$:YU'A/@BME[

n$-

Page 36: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

J1@^j'<?@��.@BAd@BHKJLM <?@^JBm+�VW<E_LV HKJ1@ M?UZU!�'<ED/]lOgUNJ�:=H� /<E:=HNMEM?bGA/@BDW[1@*J1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>1HK>1<EUaDW[��'!WUNJ�@BHN[1@\UNO&D/UN>1HK>1<EUaDfm

>1V/@F Ua[L[1<?9IM?@�AI<E[1_`J1@^>#@�jKHNME8/@B[�UNO �r_^HND 9P@<EA/@BDZ>1<SRI@BA)�<?>1V=>1V/@B<EJ�<EDWAW@� mT[1U��.@ �$< MEM���JL<?>#@���q��Wt&< DW[#>#@BHNA

UNO ��q���� t�UNJ ��q�� ���Nt ����V/@)JL@BMEHK>1<?jN@4ME< �N@BM <EV/U7U7A�UNO�>1V/@*:=< '>18/J1@):YU'A/@BM ��Jh<?>#@B[0HN[�OQUaMEM?U �$[��

� ��� ��

��� �� � ��� � q�� � � t � MEUN] ��q� � � � ���it � MEUN] ��q��Wt�� q n �1-C/at

�$V/@^JL@\>1V/@eFPUa[#>#@^JL<?UNJh[HKJ1@Y_`Ua:YF;8/>#@BA,@BHN[1<EM?bC97bd��HBbN@B[��f>1VW@^UNJ1@B:Cm HN[�D/U �(>1V/@Y<EDZ>#@^]NJLHK>1<?UaD,OQJ1Ua: >1V/@

D/UNJL:lHNME<E[1HK>1<?UaDG_`UaDW[1>1HNDT>9 @B_`Ua:=@B[$H=[18I:=:=HK>1<?UaD��

� � � / � ����� q�� � ��/t ��q� � � � ���Ct ��q��Wt� �� � �� ��q� � � �������Ct ��q���� t q n �1-C0at

��V/@eFPUa[#>#@^JL<?UNJh[ � � � HKJ1@YHNME[1U�_^HNMEME@BA � JL@B[#FPUaDW[1<?9I< ME<?>1<?@B[��/HNDWA,>1V/@^bdFWJ1U j'<EA/@ HND,@B[#>1<E:=HK>1<EUaD UNO�>#U �$VWHK>

@� '>#@BDT>>1V/@ � � >1Vd:=< 7>18/JL@�< [0J1@B[#FPUaDW[1<E9IM?@$OQUNJ�>1V/@*]N@BD/@^JLHK>1<?UaDCUNO�>1V/@\AWHK>18W: FPUa<EDZ> ��+���FI>1<E:=<E[1< D/] � � � J � >��*>1V/@ FIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^JL[)]a<?jN@Y>1V/@Y� �k[#>#@^Fr8/FfAWHK>#@eOQUNJL:\8IMEHN[�9Zb,[#UaM?j'<ED/] ���� � o��

!�<EDWHNMEMEbNm0>1V/@,:l< '< D/]r_`U7@ � _^<?@BDZ>1[ ��q��Wt=HKJL@ OQUa8WDWA�9Zb�:=H� '< :=<E[1HK>1<?UaDcUNO � m8WDWA/@^J�>1V/@ _`UaDW[#>#JLHN<EDZ>

� �� �� ��q��Wt pKm�< � @!� � % � q � �

� �� ��q��Wt % p t�<E[):lH� '<E:l<E[#@BAfm �$V/@^JL@ � <E[�>1VW@=��HK]NJLHND/]N@ :\8WME>1<?FIME<?@^J ��7UaM?j'<ED/]/m'>1V/@\8/FfAWHK>#@�UNO ��q��Wt�<E[

��q��Wt p�

��� �� � � � q n �1- 4Nt

��VW@r:YUa[#>,[1<E:YFIME@ HNDIA-_`Ua:=:YUaDIM?b @B:YFIM?U bN@BA :=< 7>18/JL@ :YU7AW@BM4<E[i>1VW@r� < 7>18/JL@ UNO ��HN8W[1[L<EHNDW[

qs� U �4thm��VW<E_LVc<E[=[18W<E>#@BA OgUNJ�:YU7AW@BMEME<ED/],>1V/@dAW@BDW[1<?> b OQUNJlJ1@BHNM$j HNM 8/@BA _`UaDZ>1<EDZ8WUa8W[=AWHK>1H�� !/UNJ�>1VW<E[

_^HN[#@Nm

��q� � � � ���Ct � q � � � � �Kt q n �1-C�at

HNDWAC>1VW@4� �k[#>#@^F,8/FfAWHK>#@B[�HKJ1@

� � � �� �� � � � ��� �� �� � � � q n �1- �at

� � � �� �� � � � � � �� �

� �� � � � % � � � � � q n ��/KoTt

� ��� � ����� ������ � ������� � ��� � � � � � ��� ������� � ��� ��� � � ������ �� ������

��VW@\ME<E:l<?>1HK>1<?UaDiUNO$!7� HNDWA !�!."�� :=U7A/@BM [^m;9P@B[1< A/@B[�9P@B<ED/] ME<ED/@BHKJBm <E[>1V/@ �)HN8W[1[1<EHND HN[1[18W:=FW>1<?UaD

UaD >1V/@CMEHK>#@BDZ> j HKJL< HK9IM?@B[���� >YVWHN[ UNOg>#@BD 9P@^@BD HKJ1]a8/@BA �102�/m�p.-C0���>1VIHK>Y>1V/@��HN8W[1[1< HND AW@BDW[1<?> br<E[e>1V/@

:YUa[#>\8WDW<EDZ>#@^J1@B[#>1<EDW]�A/@BDI[1<?>kbNm�HN[*<?>4<E[�Os8WMEMEbd_LVWHKJhHN_`>#@^JL< %^@BA 97b <?>1[�RIJL[1>�HNDIA [#@B_`UaDWA�UNJhA/@^J*[#>1HK>1<E[1>1<E_^[��

n2/

Page 37: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

��DC>1V/@)J1@B_`@BDZ>$FIHN[1>0bN@BHKJL[�>1V/@^JL@*VWHN[09P@^@BDC]NJ1@BHK>�<EDZ>#@^J1@B[#>�<EDCA/@^jN@BMEUNFI<ED/]=HNM?]NUNJh<?>1VW:=[ �$VI<E_LVCHNMEMEU ��OQUNJ

UN9W>1HN<EDI<ED/]iHiOsHN_`>#UNJ1@BA D/UaD�� �)HN8W[1[1<EHNDrJ1@^FWJ1@B[1@BDT>1HK>1<?UaDrUNO0>1V/@ AIHK>1H �1/7m"�Ko�� �i��V/@=FIJ1UN9IM?@B: VIHN[*9P@^@BD

HKFWFWJLUaHN_LV/@BA OQJ1Ua: [#@^jN@^JhHNM.[1>1HKJ1>1<ED/] F Ua< DT>1[\<EDr[#>1HK>1< [#>1<E_^HNM�HNDWArDW@B8/JLHNM�DW@^> �.UNJ�� J1@B[#@BHKJh_LVfm&<EDI_^ME8WAW<EDW]

:YUN>1<?jKHK>1<?UaDW[�9;HN[#@BA UaD�[#Ua:Y@=HNDWHNMEUN]a<?@B[ �$<?>1V,>1V/@ ��HBb VZ8I:=HNDW[�J1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>)[#@BDI[#UNJ1b < D/OgUNJh:=HK>1<?UaD � � � m

�$<?>1VrHi>1V/@^UNJ1@^>1< _^HNM&9IHN[1< [4_`Ua:=<ED/]dOgJ1Ua: <ED/OQUNJL:=HK>1<?UaD >1VW@^UNJ1b!�C�$OQ>#@^JeHNAIA/J1@B[1[1< D/]G>1V/@lFWJLUN9IM?@B: OQJ1Ua:

HdDW@B8/JLHNM&JL@B[#@BHKJL_LV FP@^JL[#FP@B_`>1<?jN@=97b �a8W>#>#@BD HNDWA �$@^JhHN8WM?> � 47p �.HNDWAr>1V/@ [#@B:l<EDWHNM&F;HKF @^J\9Zb��[email protected]

�7@ �1D/U �[��7< �Sp���� m'H\MEHKJL]N@D78W:*9P@^J�UNO�HNM?]NUNJL<?>1VI:=[�VWH jN@9P@^@BD FWJ1UNFPUa[#@BA � n7m,�2/'m'n �'m;pBnNnWm /20'm,�'p � �&�FWFIME< �

_^HK>1<?UaDW[�<EDW_^M 8WA/@�9IME< DWA)[#Ua8/JL_`@.[#@^FIHKJLHK>1<EUaD\HNDWAeA/@B_`UaDZjNUaME8/>1<?UaD m OQ@BHK>18/J1@�@� 7>#JhHN_`>1<?UaDfmaAWHK>1H�_`Ua:YFWJ1@B[L[1<?UaDfm

j'<E[18WHNME< [1HK>1<?UaDfm/FIHK>#>#@^JhDdJ1@B_`UN]aDI<?>1<?UaDdHNDIAdA/@BD/Ua< [1<ED/]�����V/@B[#@e_^HNDd9P@4OQUa8WDWA <EDi[1<E]aDWHNM�HNDWA <E:=HK]N@\FWJ1U �

_`@B[1[1< D/]/m�>#@BME@B_`Ua:=:\8IDW<E_^HK>1<?UaDW[Bm�AWHK>1H :l<EDW<ED/] HNDWA :=@BAW<E_^HNM0AWHK>1H�FIJ1U7_`@B[L[1<ED/]��c�7Ua:Y@��VWHK>YJ1@B_`@BDZ>1M?bNm

�SpBn54'm�pNp^o���HNDWA MEHK>#@^J �1/�� m�<?>eVWHN[e9P@^@BD FPUa<EDZ>#@BA Ua8/>\>1VIHK>e>1VW@�MEHKJL]N@�jKHKJL<?@^> b UNO$HKFWFIJ1UaHN_LV/@B[Y_^HND 9P@

A/@B[1_`Jh<?9P@BA �<?>1VW<ED�>1V/@*�,� OQJLHN:Y@��.UNJ��CHN[�HY]N@BDW@^JLHK>1<?jN@\:=U7A/@BMPOQUNJ$H=AW@BDW[1<?> bl@B[#>1<E:lHK>1<?UaDCFWJ1UN9;M?@B:��

��@ �$< MEM 9WJh<?@��IbCFWJ1@B[1@BDT>)[#Ua:Y@ UNO�>1V/@ OgUNJL:e8WMEHK>1<EUaDW[�UNO�>1V/@ �1"�� :YU'A/@BM �4��VW@\UNJLAW@^J�HNAWUNFW>#@BA�<ED

>1VW<E[eFWJL@B[#@BDT>1HK>1<EUaD <E[ D/UN>Y>1V/@C_LVWJ1UaD/UaM?UN]a<E_^HNM�UaD/@G9I8/> JLHK>1V/@^J=_`UaDZ>1HN<EDW[ �N@^b � FPUa<EDZ>1[ OgUNJ=F;MEHN_^<ED/],>1V/@

:Y@^>1V/U'Ad< Di>1V/@e_`UaDT>#@� '>�UNO�]N@BD/@^JLHK>1<?jN@ :YU'A/@BME[$HNDIAiFWJ1U j7< AW<ED/]=Hl9IHN_��7]NJ1Ua8WDWA OQUNJ[#Ua:Y@eUNO�>1V/@���UNJ��

FWJ1@B[1@BDT>#@BAi< DCMEHK>#@^J_hVWHKFW>#@^JL[��

������ ���#"��/� � �#"�� � ��� � � � � �$� � ����� �� � ��� ��!

� >1V/@^UNJL@^>1<E_^HNMEM?b FWJL< DW_^<?FIM?@BA HNDWAc]N@BD/@^JLHNMOgUNJh:\8WM HK>1<?UaD6UNO)>1V/@,<EA/@BH�UNO)@B[#>1< :=HK>1<ED/]r[1>1HK>1<E[#>1<E_^HNMEMEb

<EDWAW@^F @BDIA/@BDT>D/UaD�� ��HN8W[L[1<EHND,@� 7F;MEHNDWHK>#UNJ1bijKHKJL<EHK9;M?@B[HN[)H�]N@BD/@^JhHK>1<?jN@ FWJ1UN9IHK9I< ME<E[#>1<E_):=U7A/@BM�VWHN[�9P@^@BD

HN_LVI<?@^jN@BAG9Zb �1/ � m �V/@^J1@�>1V/@�:=U7A/@BM _`Ua:Y@B[�HN[0HND @� 7>#@BDW[L<?UaD�>#Ue>1VW@ !'��:YU'A/@BM HNDWA�<E[�>#@^Jh:Y@BA�� !'���7��D

� !7�\m >1V/@eM HK>#@BDT>�j HKJh<EHK9IM?@B[ ��HKJ1@ HNMEM?U ��@BA >#U�9 @eD/UaD�� ��HN8I[1[1<EHND,HNDWA,:YU7AW@BM?@BAdHN[�9P@B<ED/]l[1>1HK>1<E[#>1<E_^HNMEMEb<EDWAW@^F @BDIA/@BDT>�����V78W[^m'>1V/@\:YU7AW@BMPOgUNJ�>1VW@*AW<E[#>#Jh<?9I8/>1<?UaDlUNO�>1V/@4AWHK>1H=<E[

��q��t � ��q��� ��t ��q���t� � � � q�� � � � t

�� � �� ��q � � � � � t� � � �� � � q n ��/'p t

�.@B_^HN8W[#@ OgUNJdDWUaD�� ��HN8W[1[L<EHND FIHKJLHN:Y@^>#Jh<E_ OgUNJh:=[CUNO���q � � � � � t�>1VI<E[C<EDZ>#@^]NJLHNM4<E[C> bZF;<E_^HNMEM?b <EDT>#JhHN_`>1HK9IM?@HNDWA D78W:Y@^Jh<E_^HNM�@^j HNM 8WHK>1<?UaD �.Ua8WMEA�9P@ @� 7FP@BDW[L<?jN@Nm�D/@�� M HK>#@BDT>4jKHKJL<EHK9;M?@B[ ��@^JL@l<EDZ>#J1U7AI8W_`@BA�<ED �1/��&OQUNJ

n20

Page 38: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

:YU'A/@BMEME< D/]\>1VW@���q � � � � � t�HN[$H=:=< '>18/J1@�UNO � � �)HN8W[1[1<EHNDI[0UNO�:=@BHND�� � ! HNDWACjKHKJL<EHNDW_`@�� � ! ���q � � � � � t ����

! � ��� � q$� � t:��� � q�� � ! �� � ! t q n ��/Nnat

�$V/@^JL@ � � <E[0H=AI<E[1_`J1@^>#@4VW< AWA/@BDG[#>1HK>#@�� jKHKJL<EHK9IM?@*OgUNJ � � mW>1V/@4< DT>#J1U'AW8W_`@BAGF;HKJLHN:Y@^>#@^JL[HKJ1@� � � � ! ��� � ! � � � q$� � t ! � ���� � � � �$<?>1Vc>1V/@�_`UaDW[#>#JLHN<EDZ> � � �! � �� � � q$� � t p �(��D���JL<?>1<EDW] >1V/@,>#UN>1HNM)AWHK>1H

ME< �N@BM <EV/U7U7AfmZ<?>0<E[�8W[#@^Os8WMI>#U �$JL<?>#@�>1V/@���Ua< DT>�MEHK>#@BDZ>�A/@BDW[1<?> b=RIJh[#>�����b�A/@BD/UN>1<EDW]� q$� � � �� ��� �fthm��$VW< _LV_^HND >1H �N@=HN[�FPUa[1[1<?9;M?@4jKHNME8/@B[�HNMEM�FPUa[1[1<?9IME@*_`Ua:*9;<EDWHK>1<?UaDW[�UNO.<?>1[�_`Ua:YFPUaD/@BDT>1[)HNDIA FPUa<EDZ>1<ED/]lUa8/>�>1VWHK>

��q�ft � �� �� � � q$� � thm � q�� � � �� �� �ft)HNDIA � ��� q�� � ! � � ���� � !�� thm�>1V/@ �#Ua<EDZ>*MEHK>#@BDZ>eAW@BDW[1<?> b_^HNDi9P@ ��JL<E>#>#@BDiHN[

��q�� � � t ��� �� ��q � � � � � t �

��q�ft:� � q�� � � t q n ��/2�at

�U �4mI>1V/@*_`Ua:YFIME@^>#@*AWHK>1H=ME< �N@BME<EV/U7U7A�<E[�UNO�>1V/@4OQUNJL:

� ��� �� ��q��� � � � �� � t

��� �� ��q� � t ��q�� � � � t ��q��� � � �'t q n ��/$-Zt

HNDWA >1V/@�@� 7FP@B_`>1HK>1<?UaD�U jN@^J�9PUN>1V�� HNDWA� �$<EMEM;_`UaDW[#>1<?>18W>#@>1V/@�J1@BMEHK>1<EjN@�M < �N@BME<EV/U7U'A >#U :lH� '<E:l< %^@!����V/@

FIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^J��kA/@^FP@BDWA/@BDZ>�FIHKJ1>�UNO�>1VW< [�_^HND 9 @ ��JL<E>#>#@BD,HN[*H�[L8W: UNO�>1V/JL@^@e>#@^Jh:=[^mf@BHN_LVrA/@^FP@BDWAW<ED/] UaD

AW<E[ ��Ua<EDZ>0[18/9I[1@^>1[�UNO�>1VW@)FIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^J�[#@^>�� � � � � � � � � � �$V/@^JL@)>1V/@4>#@^JL:=[$HKJ1@*HN[0OQUaMEM?U �$[��

� �

��� �� � � � � � q�� � ��'t7MEUN] ��q��� � ��t� � q n ��/2/at

� �

��� �� �

�� ����� q����� � � t7M?UN]���q�� � ft� � q n ��/20at

� �

��� ��

�� � ��� ��! ���q$� � � ��/t7M?UN] ��q$� � t q n ��/54Nt

��<EjN@BD >1VIHK>.HNMEM;>1V/@�J1@BX78W<?J1@BAlF Ua[1>#@^JL<?UNJ�[1>1HK>1<E[#>1<E_^[�HKJ1@�_`Ua:YFI8/>#@BAG<EDl>1V/@�� �k[#>#@^F m'>1V/@BD >1V/@�� �k[1>#@^F

_`UaDW[1< [#>1[0UNO�8/FfAWHK>1<ED/] >1V/@)FIHKJhHN:Y@^>#@^JL[$HN[$OgUaM M?U �$[ �

� ��� �� �� � � � � � �� � �

��� �� � � ���� � �� �

� �q n ��/2�at

��� �� q��� � � % �� � � � � �� � � � � t q n ��/ �at

� � ! � � �� �� �������Tq$� � � � t � � � � � � � � � �� �

� �� � � � � q$� � � � t q n ��0KoTt

� � ! � � �� �� �������Tq$� � � ��'t � � � �� � � � � � �� �

� �� � ����� q$� � � ��'t % � �� ! � q n ��0'p t

��q$� � t p�

��� �� � � � � q$� � � ��/t q n ��0Nnat

n54

Page 39: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

��V/@,OQUNJL:\8IMEHN[�OgUNJ � HNDWA � HKJ1@ UNO*>1V/@ OQUNJL: UNO*>1VW@ [1>1HNDWAWHKJLA � @BHN[1> �'XZ8IHKJ1@B[�J1@B[18WM?>^mHNDWA >1V/@J1@B:=HN< DWA/@^J)UNO.>1V/@=FIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^J\8/FfAWHK>#@B[)HKJ1@ HNDWHNM?UN]NUa8W[)>#Ud>1V/Ua[#@=U'_^_^8/J1JL< D/]C<ED >1V/@=@B[#>1< :=HK>1<?UaD OQUNJ\H

� U � �

��VW@)FWJLHN_`>1<E_^HNM AI<E[1HNA/jKHNDT>1HK]N@*UNO�>1VI<E[0HKFWFWJ1UaHN_hV � HN[VWHKFWFP@BDW[0<EDC:lHNDTbG:=<E[1[L<ED/] �kAWHK>1H FWJLUN9IM?@B:=[

� <E[0>1V/@e_`Ua:YFI8/>1HK>1<?UaDIHNM�9I8WJLA/@BDi<EDd_`Ua:YFIM?@^>1<EDW]=>1V/@\� �k[#>#@^F m �$V/@^J1@*>1V/@\_`UaDWAI<?>1<?UaDWHNM H jN@^JLHK]N@B[)U jN@^J

>1V/@4FPUa[#>#@^Jh<?UNJ$A/@BDW[L<?>1<?@B[0VWH jN@*>#Ul9P@)@B[#>1< :=HK>#@BAfm;HNDIAC>1V/@^J1@^OQUNJ1@4@� 'FWJ1@B[1[1@BAi@� 'FIME<E_^<?>1MEbl<EDC>#@^JL:l[�UNO�>1V/@

:YU'A/@BM/FIHKJhHN:Y@^>#@^JL[�����V/@B[1@�HKJ1@������ �aq$� � � � thm � � � � � � � � � � m � � � �� � � � � � � m�� � � � � �;HNDIA � � �� � � � � ����V/@[#>1HKJ1>1< D/] F Ua< DT> UNO�A/@^JL<?j'<ED/] >1V/@B[#@iX78WHNDT>1<E>1<?@B[Y<E[ >#Ur_`Ua:YF;8/>#@G>1V/@iHNDWHNM?b7>1<E_^HNM�OQUNJL: UNO ��q� � ��/teHNDWA��q�� � � ��'t)@B:YFIM?U b7< D/]i��HBbN@B[eOgUNJh:\8WM H'm�HN[\>1V/@ �#Ua<EDZ>*FPUa[#>#@^JL<?UNJ*UNO0>1V/@ VW< AWA/@BD jKHKJL<EHK9IM?@B[ ��q����� � �'tOsHN_`>#UNJL<E[#@B[.<ED >1V/@B[#@> �.UeX78WHNDZ>1<?>1<?@B[��&� �'<?FWFI< D/])A/@^>1HN<EME[^mZ<?>�<E[&_^ME@BHKJ�>1VWHK>.[18W:=[�U jN@^J �$< MEM/HKFWFP@BHKJ�9PUN>1V

<ED >1V/@ A/@BDWUa:=<EDWHK>#UNJGOQUNJi_`Ua:YFI8/>1<EDW]�� � � � q� � �'t HNDWA�$V/@BD :=HKJL]a<EDWHNME<E[L<ED/]r>#U _`Ua:=FI8/>#@ � � ��� � � ��.@B_^HN8W[#@G>1V/@�[18W:=[ � :Y@BHND � ! � � ! & �� � ! � m�>1V/@�_`Ua:=FI8/>1HK>1<?UaDWHNM._`Ua:YFIME@� '<?> b�]NJ1U �[*@� 'FPUaD/@BD��>1<EHNMEMEb �$<?>1V=>1VW@�D78W:\9P@^J�UNO�[1Ua8/JL_`@B[���&HKJL< HK>1<?UaDWHNM HKFWFWJ1U '<E:lHK>1<?UaDW[.HKJ1@)A/@^jN@BM?UNFP@BA < D �1/��P>#U U jN@^JL_`Ua:=@

>1VW<E[\FWJ1UN9;M?@B:Cm�V/U �.@^jN@^J=9P@B_^HN8W[#@�>1V/@BD >1V/@C� �k[#>#@^F6VWHN[e>#U,9 @G[#UaM?jN@BA <?>#@^JLHK>1<EjN@BM?bNm&>1VW<E[eHKFWFWJLUaHN_LV <E[

_`Ua:YFI8W>1HK>1<?UaDWHNMEM?b @� 'FP@BDW[1<?jN@lHN[��.@BMEM �i�@^jN@^J1>1V/@BM?@B[1[Bm�>1VW@lOQUNJL:=HNME<E[L: FWJ1UNFPUa[#@BAr9Zb �1/��.U � @^Jh[\H DW<E_`@

>1V/@^UNJ1@^>1< _^HNMfOgJhHN:Y@���UNJ�� �$VI<E_LVGHNMEM?U �$[�>1V/@)@B[#>1< :=HK>1<?UaDGUNO�]N@BD/@^JLHNM�q ��HN8I[1[1<EHND;t.DWUa<E[#@)_`U jKHKJL<EHNDW_`@B[HNDWA

D/UaD��k[LXZ8WHKJL@]N@BD/@^JhHK>1<?jN@4:=HK>#JL< �FIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^Jh[ �$VW<EM?@�<?>�[1<E:e8WM?>1HND/@^Ua8W[LM?bY@B[#>1<E:=HK>#@B[�>1VW@�M HK>#@BDT>�A/@BDI[1<?>1<?@B[

<EDCHYF;HKJLHN:Y@^>#JL<E_�OQUNJL:��

".Ua:=FI8/>1HK>1<?UaDWHNM M?brM?@B[1[ @� 'FP@BDW[1<?jN@C[#UaM 8/>1<?UaDW[e@� /<E[#>YOQUNJ=[#Ua:Y@d[#FP@B_^<EHNM�_^HN[#@B[ � !/UNJ=@� /HN:YFIM?@Nm��1/2/��

A/@^JL<EjN@B[4HGj HKJh<EHK>1<?UaDWHNM&��� HNME]NUNJL<?>1VW: OQUNJ*>1V/@=_^HN[1@ �$V/@BD�FIJL<?UNJ �7DWU �$M?@BAW]N@l[18/]N]N@B[#>1[*>1VWHK>*HC[#F;HKJL[#@

��HKF;MEHN_^<EHND=MEHK>#@BDZ>&FWJh<?UNJ&<E[&[18I<?>1HK9IM?@0HNDWAY>1VW@^J1@^OgUNJL@�>1V/@^J1@$< [�D/U*D/@^@BAYOQUNJ�H4]N@BD/@^JLHNM/FIHKJhHN:Y@^>#JL<E_�AW@BDW[1<?> b

@B[#>1<E:lHK>1<?UaD UNO*>1V/@ OsHN_`>#UNJL[�� �$V/@,HKFIFWJ1U /<E:=HK>1<EUaD < [�< DT>#J1U'AW8W_`@BA <ED�>1VW<E[G_^HN[#@�>#U6:=H �N@�>1V/@�<EDZ>#@��

]NJLHNM�>#JhHN_`>1HK9IM?@Y9P@B_^HN8W[#@YUNO.>1V/@=D/UaD�� �)HN8W[1[1<EHND�HNDIHNM?bZ>1< _^HNM�OgUNJh: UNO�>1V/@YFIJL<?UNJ � ��V/@=HKFWFIJ1UaHN_LV [L_^HNM?@B[

_^8/9I< _^HNMEM?b��<?>1V >1V/@$AW< :Y@BDW[1<?UaDIHNME<?>kb*UNO >1VW@$AWHK>1H4[#F;HN_`@Nm7HNDWA=>1V/@^J1@^OQUNJ1@$<E[&[L8/]N]N@B[#>#@BAl:lHN<EDWM?b\OgUNJ.HKFWFIME< �

_^HK>1<?UaDW[ �$V/@^J1@$>1V/@$AWHK>1H4AI<E:Y@BDW[1<EUaDWHNME<?> b\<E[&[L:=HNMEM qQU jN@^Jh_`Ua:YFIM?@^>#@�J1@^FWJ1@B[1@BDT>1HK>1<?UaDI[ht ����@ �$< MEM'[��7<EF=>1V/@

A/@^>1HN<EM [�UNO�>1VW< [.HKFIFWJ1UaHN_LVdV/@^J1@NmWHN[0>1V/@4AIHK>1H ��@4HKJL@4A/@BHNME<ED/])�$<E>1V�< DG>1VW<E[.>1V/@B[1<E[0< [0<EDT>#Jh<EDW[1<E_^HNM M?bYVW<?]aV

AW<E:=@BDW[1<?UaDWHNM ����D/UN>1V/@^J$[L<E:YFIME<EOgb'<ED/]*HKFIFWJ1UaHN_LV <E[0>1VWHK>$FWJ1UNFPUa[#@BAC<ED �Sp�/ � � m/OgUNJ�AWHK>1HYFWJ1@^FIJ1U7_`@B[L[#@BAG9Zb

[#FIVW@^JL<ED/]�����V/@4:lHN<EDCAW< �P@^J1@BDW_`@B[0OQJ1Ua: >1V/@*� !'�(:YU'A/@BMfHKJ1@*AW< [1_^8W[1[#@BA�9P@BM?U � �

n2�

Page 40: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

���� � ��� � � � � � ��� � ��� � � ��� �� � � ��� � � � � ���� � � �5" � �#"��/� � � "�� � ��� � � � � ��� � � � � ���� �� � � ����� ���5" " ��� �

��VW@ ��UNJ���UNO �Sp�/ � ��FWJ1U j7< A/@B[$HND ��� [#UaME8/>1<EUaDCOgUNJ>1V/@\[1F @B_^< HNM _^HN[#@*UNO&[LXZ8WHKJL@BAi:=< /<ED/]=:=HK>#Jh<E_`@B[

HNDWA < [#UN>#J1UNFI<E_YDWUa<E[#@Y:YU'A/@BM �$<?>1V�AIHK>1HCFWJ1@^FWJLU7_`@B[1[1@BA�9Zb [#FIVW@^JL<ED/]/m��$VI<E_LV [L_^HNM?@B[4ME<EDW@BHKJLM?b �$<E>1V�>1V/@

D78W:*9P@^J UNOW[1Ua8/JL_`@B[��&�7FIV/@^Jh<ED/]0J1@^OQ@^JL[ >#U�H$ME< D/@BHKJ�>#JLHNDI[#OgUNJh:=HK>1<?UaD4UNO'>1V/@.AWHK>1H�[18W_LV*>1VWHK>�<?>1[�_`U j HKJL< HNDW_`@

:=HK>#JL< 9P@B_`Ua:Y@B[\>1V/@G<EA/@BDZ>1<?>kb!�i�$VW<E[4<E[\8W[#@^Os8WM m�HN[*>1V/@�[#@BHKJL_hV [1FIHN_`@ OQUNJ*>1VW@l]N@BD/@^JLHK>1<EjN@G:lHK>#JL< <E[

J1@B[#>#Jh<E_`>#@BAC>#U=UNJ1>1VWUN]NUaDWHNM�:=HK>#Jh<E_`@B[����.bG[#FIV/@^JL< D/]/m'UaD/@*VWHN[

� � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � ��� � � � � q n ��02�at

�$V/@^JL@0>1V/@�MEHN[#>�@BX78WHNME<?> beVWUaMEAW[�97beHN[1[L8W:=<ED/] � � �� � � �m0�$VW<E_hVY<E[�D/UN>�H�JL@B[#>#JL<E_`>1<?UaD mTHN[&HNDZb [L_^HNME<ED/]UNOP>1V/@M HK>#@BDT>�j HKJL< HK9IM?@B[�_^HND 9 @�_`Ua:=F @BDI[1HK>#@BAl97bYHNDlHKFWFIJ1UNFWJL<EHK>#@0JL@B[1_^HNME<ED/])UNOf>1VW@�FIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^J�:=HK>#JL<

�$����V/@^JL@^OgUNJ1@Nm ��� � q�p % � � t HNDIAi[#U� � p % � � � q n ��0$-Zt

�$V/@^JL@ � <E[\H J1UN>1HK>1<?UaD :=HK>#Jh< m&< � @!� � � � � � � �� ��V/@G_`UaDWAW<?>1<EUaDWHNM�AWHK>1H AW< [#>#JL<?9I8W>1<?UaD�<E[D/U � [1<E:l<EMEHKJ.>#Ul>1VWHK>�UNO�>1V/@4!�!."�� :YU'A/@BM ��q��� � ��t q n���� � t ��� � @� 'F � % �

� � & q��� % � ��t � � HNDIA � <E[[#@BHKJL_hV/@BAG<ED >1V/@OQUNJL: � �� p % � � � HNDWA � <E[�J1UN>1HK>1<?UaD��&��V/@�]NJ1@BHK>0_`Ua:YFI8/>1HK>1<?UaDIHNM;[1H j7< D/]e_`Ua:=@B[OQJ1Ua: >1V/@)FWJLUNF @^JL>kb�>1VWHK>$8WDWAW@^J0>1V/@B[#@*_`UaDWAI<?>1<?UaDW[�>1V/@)FPUa[#>#@^Jh<?UNJ�9P@B_`Ua:Y@B[0OsHN_`>#UNJLHK9IM?@!�

� ����� q����� � � t ��� �� � ��� � q$� � � � t:� � � q�� ! ��� � ��� ! ��� � t q n ��02/at

�$V/@^JL@�� ! � � �YHNDWA�� ! � � �YHKJ1@@BHN[L<EM?b=_`Ua:YFI8W>1HK9IM?@eqs[1@^@ �Sp�/ � �;OQUNJ0A/@^>1HN<EME[ht ����VW@^J1@^OgUNJL@$>1V/@�_`Ua:YFI8/>1HK>1<EUaDWHNM[1_^HNME< D/]Y<E[�ME<EDW@BHKJ�<EDG>1V/@4D78W:*9P@^J0UNO�[#Ua8/Jh_`@B[0OgUNJ$>1VW<E[�HNM?]NUNJh<?>1VW:��

� '_`@^FW>YOQUNJ >1V/@i� �k[#>#@^F 8/FfAWHK>#@B[eOgUNJY>1VW@�]N@BDW@^JLHK>1<?jN@d:=HK>#Jh< HNDWA :YU'A/@BM�D/Ua<E[#@GjKHKJL<EHNDW_`@B[Bm&>1V/@

J1@B:=HN< DW<ED/] 8/FfAWHK>#@B[0HKJ1@*[L<E:=<EMEHKJ.>#U=>1V/Ua[1@4UNO�� !'�*m;HN[0>1V/@*MEHK>#@BDZ>�A/@BDW[L<?>1<?@B[0HKJ1@4[1< :=<EMEHKJLMEb=:YU7AW@BM?@BAG9Zb

FIHKJLHN:=@^>#JL<E_&:=< 7>18/JL@&UNO ��HN8W[1[1< HNDW[����U �.@^jN@^JBm �Sp�/ ���7HNME[#U$FWJ1UNFPUa[#@B[�[L<E:YFIM?@^JfjN@^Jh[1<?UaDW[�UNOWVW<E[ HNM?]NUNJh<?>1VW:Cm

9IHN[#@BA UaD R '@BA FIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^JejKHNME8/@B[e<EDr>1V/@�� U ��[ OQUNJ\>1VW@�MEHK>#@BDZ>ej HKJL< HK9IM?@B[*< D UNJLA/@^Je>#U,J1@BAW8W_`@�>1V/@

D78W:*9P@^J0UNO�OQJ1@^@)FIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^Jh[��

������ � ������� � ����� � ����� �� � ��� � � !

&HKJL<EUa8W[�j HKJL< HNDT>1[�UNO�>1VW@e!�J1U���@B_`>1<EUaD�!�8/JL[L8W<?>\qs!�!.t � - 4 ��>#@B_LVWDW< XZ8/@eU �P@^J4H�_`Ua:=FI8/>1HK>1<?UaDWHNM M?biHK> �

>#JLHN_`>1<?jN@ �.H b\UNO;F @^JLOgUNJL:l<ED/]AIHK>1H)HNDWHNM?b'[1<E[^mNFIHKJL>1<E_^8WMEHKJLMEb4<EDe>1V/@0_^HN[#@�UNO;VI<?]aV AW<E:Y@BDW[L<?UaDWHNMZUN9I[#@^J1jKHK9IM?@

n �

Page 41: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

AWHK>1H��C!�! :Y@^>1V/U'AW[*]aHN<ED/@BA Hd]NJ1@BHK>eAW@BHNM�UNO�<EDZ>#@^J1@B[#>*<ED >1V/@lFIHN[1>4bN@BHKJL[eHN[*HdAIHK>1Hd:=<EDI<ED/]G>#UZUaM�<ED

>1V/@)[#>1HK>1<E[1>1<E_^HNM HNDWAGD/@B8/JhHNM DW@^> �.UNJ�� JL@B[#@BHKJL_LVd_`Ua:=:\8IDW<?>kb �1� �'m p.-C0'm - 47m 02�'m -C�7m:/2��� �&�[0>1VW@�DWUa:Y@BD��

_^MEHK>18/JL@)UNO�>1VW< [0>#@B_LVWDI<EXZ8W@4[18/]N]N@B[#>1[^mI>1V/@4AWHK>1H=:YU'A/@BMEM <ED/]*>1HN[��G< [0OgUNJh:\8WM HK>#@BAGUaDiHYFWJ1U��#@B_`>1<?UaDC9;HN[1<E[^m

HN[4[#@^@��'<ED/]COQUNJ � <EDZ>#@^J1@B[#>1< D/] ��qs<ED/OQUNJL:=HK>1<?jN@ t�M <ED/@BHKJ)FWJ1U��#@B_`>1<?UaDW[�UNO0:e8WM?>1<EAI<E:Y@BDW[1<EUaDWHNM�AWHK>1H��=�$V/@=<ED��

>#@^J1@B[#>1< D/]aD/@B[1[�<E[�:Y@BHN[18/J1@BA <ED,[#>1HK>1<E[#>1<E_^HNM�>#@^JL:=[�HN[�HlFIJ1U���@B_`>1<EUaD <EDIA/@� ��$VW<E_hVd:=H� /<E:=< %^@B[H _`@^JL>1HN<ED

[#>1HK>1<E[1>1<E_^HNM.FWJ1UNFP@^J1>kb!����VW@�:YUa[1>e_`Ua:=:=UaD FWJ1U��#@B_`>1<?UaD < DWA/@� '@B[\HKJ1@CVW<E]aV/@^J\UNJhA/@^JY:YUa:Y@BDZ>1[ �1�2/���UNO

>1V/@=FIJ1U���@B_`>1<EUaDfm�HN[4>1VW@B[#@l:Y@BHN[18WJ1@Y>1V/@l<EDWOgUNJL:lHK>1<?UaD >1VWHK>*<E[)DWUN>*_`UaDT>1HN< D/@BAr<ED >1VW@l_`U jKHKJL<EHNDW_`@ :=H��

>#JL< Pm >1VZ8W[�UNFW>1< :=<E[1<EDW]=H�AW@^FIHKJ1>18/J1@\OgJLUa: >1VW@ ��HN8I[1[1<EHND,A/@BDW[1<E>kb!�)��V/@e:YUN>1<?jKHK>1<?UaD,OgUNJ)HBjNUa< AW<ED/]�>1V/@

��HN8W[L[1<EHND FWJ1U��#@B_`>1<?UaDW[�<E[�>1VIHK> ��HN8W[1[1< HND,AI<E[#>#JL<?9;8/>#@BAdFIJ1U���@B_`>1<EUaDW[�J1@B[18WME>OQJ1Ua: JLHNDWAWUa: FIJ1U���@B_`>1<EUaDW[

UNO�:e8WM?>1<?jKHKJL<EHK>#@=AWHK>1H �1� ��� �C��D �102����HNDWA �Sp.-C0�� m�>1VW@ HN8/>1V/UNJh[*HNME[#U,HKJ1]a8/@ >1VWHK>*>1V/@�:YUa[#>e<EDT>#@^JL@B[#>1<ED/]

AW<?JL@B_`>1<?UaDW[0HKJ1@4>1VWUa[#@4>1VWHK>$[LV/U ��>1VW@4M?@BHN[#> ��HN8I[1[1<EHNDCAW< [#>#JL<?9I8W>1<?UaD��

!�! <E[�J1@BMEHK>#@BA >#U)�1"�� 97b4>1V/@�DWUaD�� ��HN8W[1[L<EHND DWHK>18/J1@�UNOI>1VW@ � M HK>#@BDT>�jKHKJL<EHK9IME@B[�� �VW<E_LV HKJ1@0@� 'FP@B_`>#@BA

>#U�9P@�J1@^jN@BHNME@BA 9Zb\>1V/@�FIJ1U���@B_`>1<EUaD�� !W8/J1>1V/@^Jh:YUNJ1@NmNUNOQ>#@BD UaD/@0<E[�[1@BHKJL_LVW< D/]�OgUNJ�<EDWAW@^F @BDIA/@BDT>�FWJ1U��#@B_`>1<?UaD

AW<?JL@B_`>1<?UaDW[��d�$V/@B[#@GAW<?J1@B_`>1<?UaDI[*HKJ1@G8W[18WHNM M?b�[#@BHKJL_LVW@BA OQUNJY[#@BX78/@BDT>1< HNMEM?bNm�UaD/@GHK>eH >1<E:Y@Nm&HNDWA UaDW_`@CH

AW<?JL@B_`>1<?UaD < [�OQUa8WDWAfm >1V/@BD,<?>1[�@�� @B_`>)<E[�A/@B_`UNJ1J1@BM HK>#@BA OQJ1Ua: UN>1V/@^J)AW<?JL@B_`>1<?UaDW[��$�U �.@^jN@^J*[1< :\8WME>1HND/@^Ua8W[

[#@BHKJL_hVd<E[0HNM [#U=FPUa[1[1<?9;M?@Nm7< D �$VW<E_hVC_^HN[#@*>1V/@4HNME]NUNJL<?>1VW:=[0HKJL@4J1@BMEHK>#@BAC>#Ul�#"����

��M?>1V/Ua8/]aV AW< � @^J1@BDZ>1M?b�FPUa[#@BAfm�>1V/@GFWJLUN9IM?@B: <ED !�!�m�>1V/@G]NUaHNM�UNO$_`JL@BHK>1<ED/]�H D/UaD�� ��HN8W[L[1<EHND J1@^F��

J1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaD UNO0>1V/@GAWHK>1H'm&<E[\[#Ua:Y@��$VWHK> [1<E:l<EMEHKJ)>#U <E:YFPUa[1<ED/]iH,D/UaD�� �)HN8W[1[1<EHNDrFWJL<?UNJ\UaDr>1VW@ MEHK>#@BDZ>

J1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>1HK>1<EUaD�����VW<E[�<E[�:YUNJ1@�@^j'<EA/@BDZ>�<ED >1V/@_^HN[#@B[ �V/@BD �.@$VWHBjN@�[#Ua:Y@FWJL<?UNJ �'D/U �M?@BA/]N@�J1@^]aHKJhAW<ED/]

>1V/@CMEHK>#@BDZ> J1@^FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaDW[ ��[#>1HK>1< [#>1<E_^HNM.FWJ1UNFP@^J1>1<?@B[Bm �$VW<E_hV _^HND 9P@ OQUNJL:e8WMEHK>#@BA <ED >#@^JL:=[eUNOAI<E[#>#JL< �

9I8/>1<EUaDWHNM�HN[L[18W:YFW>1<EUaDW[��r� [18/]N]N@B[#>1<?jN@C@� /HN:YFIME@G_^HND 9 @�OQUa8WDWA <ED �SpBn2/���<ED >1V/@C_`UaDZ>#@� 7>=UNO�9I<EDIHKJ1b

FIHKJ1>1<E>1<?UaDW<ED/]/m.�$V/@^J1@�Hd:=< 7>18/JL@=UNO�> �.U ��HN8W[1<EHNDI[��$<E>1V�R '@BAr:Y@BHND q �LpGHNDWAcp thm�jKHKJL<EHNDI_`@,q�p t\HNDWA

:=< /<ED/] FWJ1UNFPUNJ1>1<?UaDI[\q�p �Knat�<E[�>1V/@ [#>1HK>1<E[1>1<E_^HNM�HN[#FP@B_`>�UNO�>1V/@YME<EDW@BHKJFWJLU���@B_`>1<?UaD,UaD/@Y<E[�[#@BHKJL_hVW<ED/]GOQUNJ �

��V/@4AIHK>1H=M?UN]=ME< �N@BM <EV/U7U7A�OQUNJ�>1VW<E[�FIHKJL>1<E_^8WMEHKJ�_^HN[#@\<E[�OgUNJh:\8WM HK>#@BAiHN[�>1V/@*OgUaMEMEU �$<EDW]��

� ��� �� M?UN]

pn ��� O # q % p �Bp t � pn ��� O # q�p �Bp t � q n ��020at

��D ��� FIJ1U7_`@BAI8/J1@ <E[�@B:YFIM?U bN@BA >#U6UNFW>1<E:=< %^@ >1VW< [�X78WHNDZ>1<?>kbNm �$V/@^JL@,>1VW@ VI<EAWA/@BD�j HKJh<EHK9IM?@ <E[�>1V/@

:Y@B:\9P@^JL[1VW<?F6<ED @B<E>1V/@^J=UNO�>1V/@i> ��U _^MEHN[1[#@B[�����V/@i_^MEHN[1[�� j HKJL< HK9IM?@��$<EM M�9P@iA/@BDWUN>#@BA 97b(� �c��[=@BHN_hVFWJ1U��#@B_`>#@BA�AWHK>18I: F Ua< DT>C<E[G_`UaDW[1< A/@^J1@BA >#U69P@BM?UaD/] >#U6UaDWM?b�UaD/@ UNO\>1VW@�> �.U ]aHN8W[1[1< HNDW[^m$>1VW@BD >1V/@

�Ko

Page 42: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

J1@BMEHK>1<EjN@4ME< �N@BME<EVWUZU'AG<E[ ��JL<?>#>#@BDCHN[

� &% pn��� �� � ����� q$� p � � �/t`q � � % p t � q�p % � ����� q$� p � � �/t#t`q � � � p t � q n ��054Nt

�$V/@^JL@ � � � � ��+�)��D,>1V/@Y� �k[#>#@^F�>1VW@\FPUa[#>#@^JL<EUNJ�� � � �aq$� p � � �Wt$<E[�_`Ua:YFI8/>#@BA HNDWA <ED,>1V/@ � �k[1>#@^F

>1V/@FIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^J � <E[.8/FfAWHK>#@BA���� >.<E[.[1V/U �D �SpBn2/�� >1VWHK>.OgUNJ.>1V/@_^HN[1@�UNO [1FIV/@^J1@BA <ED/FI8/>&AIHK>1H'm7>1VW@$OQUNJL:

UNO�>1VW<E[HNM?]NUNJL<?>1VI: <E[$[L<E:=<EMEHKJ0>#U�>1V/@*R 7@BAdFPUa<EDT><?>#@^JLHK>1<?jN@eHNM?]NUNJL<?>1VW: OgUNJ�!�! HNDWAd�#"�� @B:YF;M?U bN@BA,<ED

>1V/@*:=@^>1V/U7A �1�'p � �

!/JLUa: >1V/@0:YU'A/@BMEME<EDW]$FP@^JL[#FP@B_`>1<?jN@Nm!�.@0_^HND=[#@^@0>1VWHK>�>1V/@�:=HN< DeAI< � @^JL@BDW_`@�9 @^> ��@^@BD=>1V/@�FWJ1U��#@B_`>1<?UaD��

9IHN[#@BAGHNDWA >1V/@�]N@BD/@^JLHK>1<?jN@�OQUNJL:e8WMEHK>1<?UaDW[.<E[�>1V/@�AW<?J1@B_`>1<?UaDlUNO >1V/@�:YU'A/@BMEME<EDW]���� ]N@BDW@^JLHK>1<?jN@)HKFWFWJ1UaHN_hV

�$<EM M HN[L[18W:Y@�>1V/@*AIHK>1H01[�'�A� � ���(b ��� ���s�#� ���C97b�[1Ua:Y@*VW<EAIA/@BD < D/FI8/>1[^m/HN_^_`UNJLAI<ED/]Y>#UlHYA/@BDI[1<?>kbG:YU'A/@BM �

��D _`UaDZ>#JLHN[#>^m�H�FWJLU���@B_`>1<?UaD�� 9IHN[#@BA :Y@^>1V/U'A �<EMEM�_`UaDI[1<EA/@^J�>1V/@ UN9I[#@^J1jKHK9IM?@eAWHK>1HGHN[�<ED/FI8/>1[Bm �$VI<E_LV,HKJ1@

� �+� � ����� ��� � 4 � �s�s � � �<�<�#� >#U R;DWA [#Ua:Y@ VI<EAWA/@BD HN[#FP@B_`>1[�� � _`Ua:*9I< DWHK>1<?UaD UNOe>1V/@B[#@�> �.U�< A/@BHN[C<E[

FWJ1@B[1@BDT>�<EDi>1V/@ _^<?>#@BA @� 'HN:=FIM?@ �SpBn2/ � m �V/@^J1@\H ]N@BD/@^JLHK>1<EjN@e:YU'A/@BM�UNO�>1V/@ AWHK>1HlFIJ1U���@B_`>1<EUaD <E[[#Ua8/]aVZ>��

� UNJ1@ OgUNJL:lHNMEM?bNmP>1V/@ !�! >#@B_LVIDW<EX78/@\JL@B[18WM?>1[�OQJ1Ua: H ]N@BDW@^JLHK>1<?jN@Y:YU'A/@BM�< D >1VW@ %^@^J1UiDWUa<E[#@\M <E:=<?>�_^HN[#@!�

��V/@BD >1V/@C_`UaDWAI<?>1<?UaDWHNM.AWHK>1H A/@BDW[1<E>kb 9P@B_`Ua:Y@B[YH A/@BM?>1H,Os8WDW_`>1<?UaD HNDWA [#U >1V/@C<EDZ>#@^]NJLHK>1<?UaD U jN@^J=>1V/@

MEHK>#@BDZ>�@� 7FIM HNDWHK>#UNJ1bijKHKJL<EHK9IME@*9P@B_`Ua:Y@B[�>#JL<?j'<EHNM �� D >1V/@ HK9 U jN@ @� 'HN:YF;M?@Nm&q n ��054Nt�_^HND 9 @eA/@^JL<?jN@BA,HN[)H

FIHKJ1>1< _^8WMEHKJ)_^HN[#@YUNO�q n ��/$-Zt)9Zb,HN[1[18W:l<ED/] R 7@BA MEHK>#@BDZ>4A/@BDW[L<?>1<?@B[�HNDWA _`UaDWAW<?>1<EUaDWHNM�AWHK>1HCAW<E[#>#Jh<?9I8/>1<?UaDI[

UNO�>1V/@=OQUNJL: ��q� � � ��t � q � � � % ��t ���$V/@BD � <E[)UNO0[1<E:l<EMEHKJ�OQ8IDW_`>1<?UaDWHNME<E>kb,>#U Hi_`UaME8I:=D�UNO�>1V/@

� <EDZjN@^JL[#@ �W]N@BDW@^JLHK>1<?jN@*:=HK>#Jh< �$�

��[�HNM?J1@BHNA/b4:Y@BDZ>1<?UaD/@BA mK< D*UN>1V/@^J�:YUNJL@�]N@BD/@^JhHNM7[L<?>18WHK>1<?UaDW[Bm >1V/@�_LVIHKJLHN_`>#@^JL<E[#>1< _^[�UNOI>1V/@�FIJ1U���@B_`>1<EUaDW[

HKJ1@eOgUNJh:\8WM HK>#@BA D/UN>)D/@B_`@B[L[1HKJL<EM?bCHN[�H�A/@BDW[1<?> bd:YU'A/@BM m;9I8/>$JhHK>1V/@^J)HN[�H�[#>1HK>1<E[1>1<E_^HNM�_LVWHKJLHN_`>#@^Jh<E[#>1<E_ �

@^]�� VI<?]aV/@^J*UNJhA/@^Je[LHN:YFIM?@�:YUa:Y@BDZ>1[^m�UNJ HKFIFWJ1U /<E:=HK>#@�AW< �P@^J1@BDZ>1<EHNM&@BDZ>#J1UNF7b �1�Ko�� � �$VW<E[4<E[*>1V/@G_^HN[#@

<ED >1V/@ :Y@^>1V/U'A A/@B[1_`JL<E9 @BA�< D �1�'p � � ��@BD/UN>1<EDW]i>1V/@=@BX78W<?jKHNM?@BDZ>)UNO�MEUN] ��q � �/t�97b��lq � � ��/thm�>1V/@BDr>1V/@X78WHNDT>1<E>kbG>#Ul:=H� /<E:=< %^@)<E[

����� q � t ��� �� �=q � � t % � q � � � � � � � % p t q n ��02�at

�$V/@^JL@ � < [0>1V/@*��HK]NJLHND/]N@*:e8WM?>1<?F;ME<?@^J0HNDWAC>1V/@\_`UaDW[#>#JLHN<EDZ>�@� 'FWJ1@B[1[1@B[�_`UaDW[#>#JLHN< DW<ED/]Y>1V/@)jKHKJL<EHNDI_`@4UNO �>#U48WDW<E>kb!����VW<E[�<E[�D/UN>&H�JL@B[#>#JL<E_`>1<?UaD maHN[ �.HN[&HNMEJ1@BHNA/be@� 7FIM HN<ED/@BAfmNHNDWAY<E[�D/@B_`@B[L[1HKJ1b V/@^J1@0OQUNJ�FWJ1@^jN@BDZ>1<ED/]

A/@^]N@BD/@^JhHK>#@)UNJ�<ED'R;DW<E>#@$[#UaME8/>1<EUaDW[�����V/@�[1HN:Y@�UN9��#@B_`>1<?jN@4_^HND�9P@�OQUNJL:e8WMEHK>#@BA�OQUNJ�[L<E:\8IM?>1HND/@^Ua8W[.[#@BHKJL_hV

�'p

Page 43: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

UNO�cAW<EJ1@B_`>1<?UaDW[��� � � q�� t

��� ��

�� � �� �=q � � � t % � q�� � � � � ��� % ft q n ��0 �at

�$V/@^JL@ � <E[eH [#b':=:Y@^>#JL<E_ :=HK>#JL< UNO��HK]NJLHND/]N@C:e8WM?>1<?F;ME<?@^JL[)HNDWA >1V/@G_`UaDW[#>#JhHN<EDT>e@BDW[18WJ1@B[*9PUN>1V >1V/@8WDW<E>0j HKJL< HNDW_`@*UNO�>1V/@*FWJ1U��#@B_`>1<?UaDW[$HNDIA [#b':=:Y@^>#Jh<E_)A/@B_`UNJ1J1@BM HK>1<?UaDdUNO�>1V/@eAW<?J1@B_`>1<EUaDW[��.� >�<E[$HNME[1U=>#U 9P@

:Y@BDZ>1<?UaD/@BA >1VWHK>)UNOQ>#@BD�>1V/@=AIHK>1HC<E[)[#FIV/@^JL@BA,< D�HGFWJ1@^FWJ1U'_`@B[1[1< D/] [#>1HK]N@ OgUNJ4[L<E:YFIME<EOgb'<ED/]Y>1V/@=_`Ua:=FI8��

>1HK>1<?UaDW[ ��� D >1VW<E[ _^HN[#@Nm � � � � <ED >1V/@GHK9PU jN@CUN9��#@B_`>1<?jN@B[�� ��[ FWJ1UNFPUa[#@BA <ED � 4 ��� m�[#UaM?j'<ED/] >1V/@[#>1HK>1<?UaDIHKJ1bl@BX78WHK>1<?UaD�97bl<?>#@^JLHK>1<?jN@�R '@BA F Ua< DT>�:Y@^>1V/U'A�FWJ1U j'<EA/@B[.H [1<E:YF;M?@$HNM?]NUNJL<E>1VW: �VW<E_LV�VWHN[�OsHN[#>

_`UaDZjN@^J1]N@BDW_`@eFWJ1UNFP@^J1>1<?@B[�����DiHKFWFWJLU /<E:=HK>#@4�@���>#UaD��k:Y@^>1V/U'Ad[1UaME8/>1<?UaDC<E[0HNM [#U=]a<?jN@BDi< D �1�'p �

� ��� � ��� �!�!��� ������� ��� ����� ��� �����

��DW@)UN9Zj'<?Ua8W[�M <E:=<?>1HK>1<?UaD�UNO�>1V/@*ME< D/@BHKJ�MEHK>#@BDZ>�j HKJh<EHK9IM?@):YU'A/@BME[0<E[�>1VIHK>�>1V/@4>#JLHNDI[#OgUNJh:=HK>1<?UaDGOQJ1Ua:

>1V/@=MEHK>#@BDZ>*[#F;HN_`@=>#UdAWHK>1Hi[1FIHN_`@ q t�< [�J1@B[#>#JL<E_`>#@BA >#Ui9P@=ME<ED/@BHKJ � ��VW< [�:=@BHNDW[4:YU'A/@BMEME< D/] >1VW@=AWHK>1HHN[=M?b'<ED/],UaD H�ME< D/@BHKJY[18/9I[#F;HN_`@CUNO>1V/@iAIHK>1H�[#FIHN_`@!� �U �.@^jN@^JBm0<ED6:=HNDZb J1@BHNM0[L<?>18WHK>1<?UaDW[ >1VI<E[Y<E[YH

_`UaHKJL[#@�HKFWFIJ1U /<E:=HK>1<?UaD�� !�<?]�� n �Ep � <E[ HND <EMEM 8W[#>#JLHK>1<?jN@d>#U b � @� 'HN:YF;M?@ UNO\AWHK>1H MEb7<EDW]r<ED H D/UaD��kME<ED/@BHKJ

−1−0.5

00.5

11.5

2

−1

−0.5

0

0.5

1

1.5

2−2

0

2

4

6

8

10

� �<> !.*�# ���=� �7FI<EJLHNMPAWHK>1H��

p �kAW<E:=@BDW[1<?UaDWHNMP[18W9I[#FIHN_`@)UNO�>1V/@)UN9I[1@^J1j HK9;M?@�� �kAW<E:Y@BDI[1<?UaDWHNMP[#FIHN_`@!�

��VW@^J1@4HKJ1@*_hVW<?@��Ib�> �.Ul[#UaME8W>1<?UaDW[�>#UlA/@BHNM <ED/])�$<?>1VCH=:=UNJ1@*_`Ua:YFIME@� G:YU'A/@BMEM <ED/]*FIJ1UN9IM?@B:��

�Nn

Page 44: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

� >1VW@M?U'_^HNMWME<EDW@BHKJ�HKFWFWJ1UaHN_hVl8W[1@B[&FI<?@B_`@��<E[#@�ME<EDW@BHKJ�:YU'A/@BME[ �$VI<E_LV=HKJL@�FIHK>1_LVW@BAl>#UN]N@^>1V/@^J0<EDl[#Ua:Y@

:lHNDWD/@^JBm/@!� ]�� �Sp�/2/'m;n$-Wm:/2�'m /Nn'm � ���

� HNDd@� 7F;ME<E_^<?>�D/UaDWME< D/@BHKJ0:YU7AW@BM��$VW<E_hVCHK>#>#@B:YFW>1[HY]aM?UN9IHNM :=U7A/@BM ME<ED/]/mZ@!� ]�� � nKo��

��OI_`Ua8WJL[#@NmT_`Ua:\9I<EDW< D/]>1VW@.> ��U)FIJL<EDW_^<?F;M?@B[ <E[�HNME[1UFPUa[1[1<E9IM?@NmK<EDe>1V/@0<EA/@BH�>1VWHK>�@^jN@BD=H�D/UaD��kME< D/@BHKJ�]aM?UN9IHNM

:YU'A/@BMEME< D/]e:lHBbCD/UN>09P@ �I@� /<?9IM?@�@BD/Ua8/]aVd<EDG>1V/@4_^HN[#@\UNO�_`Ua:YF;M?@� G[1>#JL8W_`>18/J1@BAdAWHK>1HdqQ@!� ]�� �Sp�/'p �Qt �

��HN_LVGUNO >1V/@B[1@> ��U FWJL< DW_^<?FIM?@B[�VIHN[.<E>1[�U �$DGHNA/j HNDZ>1HK]N@B[^mWA/@^FP@BDWAI<ED/]4UaD >1V/@�[1_`UNFP@UNO�HeFIHKJL>1<E_^8WMEHKJ

HKFWFIM <E_^HK>1<?UaD�� !/UNJ)@� /HN:YFIM?@NmPOQUNJ4AWHK>1H�j7< [18WHNME<E[LHK>1<?UaDiFI8WJ1FPUa[#@B[ � �$VI<E_LV,<E[�HND <E:YFPUNJ1>1HNDZ>>#@B_hVWDW<EX78/@

OQUNJ*AWHK>1HiHNDWHNMEb7[1< [)HNDWA AWHK>1Hi:l<EDW<ED/]�� >1VW@=M?U7_^HNM�ME<ED/@BHKJ4HKFWFIJ1UaHN_LV�UNO�>1V/@ VW<?@^JLHKJL_hVW<E_^HNM�:=< 7>18/JL@eUNO

!�!�"�� � n$- �VWHN[Y>1VW@dHNA/jKHNDT>1HK]N@ UNO�HNM M?U �$< D/] >1V/@d<EDW[1F @B_`>1<EUaD UNO�>1V/@ AWHK>1H HK>lAW< � @^J1@BDZ>=M?@^jN@BME[l<ED H

8W[#@^J�� UNJL<?@BDZ>#@BA AWHK>1H,HNDWHNM?b7>1<E_ :=HNDWD/@^J � �$U ��@^jN@^JBm�>1V/@�@� 7FIM <E_^<?>4D/UaD��kM <ED/@BHKJ\:=U7A/@BM m�<?O�< [*[18 ��_^<?@BDT>1MEb

�I@� /<?9IM?@Nm'FP@^JL:=<E>1[.HlV/UaME<E[#>1< _j'<?@�� UNO�>1V/@*AIHK>1HY9ZbG_^HKFW>18/Jh<ED/]Y:YUNJ1@*_`Ua:=FIM?@� C[#>#JL8W_`>18/JL@)@!� ]�� � nKo � �

��� �� � � � � ��� ����� � � � �#� ��� � � ����� � � � ����� � ��� � ����� ����� � � � � "��5��

��VW@)FWJ1UN9IHK9I< ME<E[#>1<E_$OgJhHN:Y@���UNJ�� U �P@^JL[$HlDWHK>18/JLHNM ��HBbGUNO�_`Ua:*9;<EDW<ED/] >#UN]N@^>1V/@^J]N@BD/@^JLHK>1<?jN@e:YU'A/@BME[��

��D >1VW@ [L<E:YFIM?@B[1>_^HN[#@Y>1VW< [�< [HN_hVW<?@^jN@BA�97b _`UaDW[1>#JL8W_`>1<ED/]GHG:=< '>18/J1@eUNO�HG_`@^J1>1HN<ED ]N@BDW@^JLHK>1<?jN@=:YU'A/@BM �

� /HN:YFIME@B[�<EDW_^M 8WA/@0:=< '>18/J1@B[�UNO !�!."0� �Sp�/2/ � m � n$- � m7:=< 7>18/JL@B[�UNO !'� �1/2��� m �1/Nn � m7:l< 7>18WJ1@B[�UNOf�1"�� � � ��� �

��V/@�_`Ua:YFIM?@^>#@�AWHK>1H,ME< �N@BME<EVWUZU'A�OQUNJeH � �k_`Ua:=F UaDW@BDT> :=< '>18/J1@=UNO ��q��� �����Ct4:YU7AW@BME[^m�Ua:=<?>#>1<ED/] >1V/@_`UaDWAW<E>1<?UaDW<ED/]eUaDCFIHKJhHN:Y@^>#@^JL[�OQUNJ$[1< :YFIME<E_^<E>kbNm/_^HNDC9P@ ��JL<?>#>#@BDCHN[

�� ��� �� � ��q��� � ��� �Wt ��q���� �Wt ��q��Wt�� q n � 4 oTt

�$V/@^JL@ ��q� � � ��� �Wt_^HND 9P@\UNO�>1V/@ OgUNJL: UNO.HNDTb ]N@BD/@^JLHK>1<?jN@=:YU'A/@BM �)� V/@BD ��JL<E>1<ED/]l>1VW@eJL@BMEHK>1<?jN@ ME< �N@��

ME<EVWUZU'AfmI>1VW@\@� 'FP@B_`>1HK>1<?UaD U jN@^J4>1VW@\FPUa[#>#@^JL<EUNJ�� � � � q���� � � ��� ��t*q �$<E>1V UaM AdFIHKJhHN:Y@^>#@^J)j HNM 8/@B[ht$<E[$>#UC9P@>1H �N@BDfm��$VI<E_LV,A/@B_`Ua:YFPUa[#@B[�HN[ ��q���� � � � t ��q�� � � � � t ��q�� � � t �4��V/@4R;JL[#>�>#@^JL: <E[$>1VW@eFPUa[#>#@^Jh<?UNJUNO>1V/@ � � >1Vd[18/9��k:YU'A/@BMfHNDWAG>1VW@*[#@B_`UaDWAC>#@^Jh: <E[0_`Ua:YF;8/>#@BACOQJ1Ua: ��HBbN@B[�>1V/@^UNJ1@B: HN[

��q�� � �t � ��q� � � � �Wt ��q��Wt� �� �� � �� � ��q� � � � ���Et ��q����Et� � q n � 47p t

��V/@)JL@BMEHK>1<?jN@4ME< �N@BM <EV/U7U7A�<E[0>1V78W[

��� ��

��� �� � � � � q�� � ��'t � � ����� q�� � � � ��/t7M?UN] � ��q��� � ��t ��q�� � �Wt�� �

���� ��

��� �� MEUN] ��q��Wt q n � 4Knat

�2�

Page 45: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

��D �Sp�/2/��fHNDIA � n$- � m7>1VW@�:l< 7>18WJ1@_`Ua:YFPUaD/@BDZ>1[0HKJ1@)!�!�"���[�����V/@�j7<E[L8WHNME<E[1HK>1<EUaDlHKFWFIM <E_^HK>1<?UaD FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>#@BA

<ED � n$- ��<E[.9IHN[1@BAGUaDC>1V/@�UN9I[#@^J1jKHK>1<?UaDG>1VWHK>0FIJ1U���@B_`>1< D/] >1V/@)@BDT>1<EJ1@)AWHK>1HY[#@^>0>#U=HY[1<EDW]aM?@�n �k�(F;MEHND/@�VWHN[

UNOQ>#@BD 9P@^@BD OgUa8IDWA >#UiFWJ1U j7< A/@Y<EDW[18 ��_^<?@BDT>�A/@^>1HN<EM [)OgUNJ*j7<E[L8WHNME<E[1HK>1<EUaD"� >1VW@^b,_^HND V/U �.@^jN@^J\8W[1@^OQ8WM M?b

AW<E[1FIMEHBbC>1VW@=[#>#JL8W_`>18/JL@\UNO�[1<E:YF;M?@\AWHK>1HC[1@^>1[��\��VW@^J1@^OgUNJL@ < D >1VI<E[ ��UNJ�� m�HG:=< '>18/J1@�� 9;HN[#@BA <EDT>#@^JhHN_`>1<?jN@

VW<?@^JhHKJL_LVW< _^HNM�@� '>#@BDW[1<EUaD,VIHN[�9 @^@BD FIJ1UNFPUa[#@BA HNDIA�[18W_^_`@B[1[#Os8WMEMEbiA/@B:YUaDW[#>#JhHK>#@BA UaD�AWHK>1HN[#@^>1[4UN9I>1HN<ED/@BA

OQJ1Ua: :e8WM?>1<?FIVIHN[#@ �;U �$[4HNMEUaD/]CUa<EM�FI<?FP@BME< D/@B[$HNDWA OQJ1Ua: [LHK>#@BMEME<?>#@Y<E:=HK]N@ AWHK>1H��=�.@^]a<EDWDW<EDW]�97b RI>#>1<ED/]

H [1< D/]aM?@CMEHK>#@BDZ>ljKHKJL<EHK9IM?@C:YU'A/@BM�>#U >1V/@ �$V/UaME@GAIHK>1Hr[#@^>lHNDIA6FIM?UN>#>1<EDW]�>1V/@CFPUa[#>#@^JL<?UNJl:=@BHNDW[=HKOQ>#@^J

_`UaDZjN@^J1]N@BDW_`@Nm�>1V/@i8W[#@^JYA/@B_^< A/@B[)�$VW<E_hV [18/9WJ1@^]a<EUaDW[*UaD >1V/@GFIM?UN>Y[1V/Ua8WM Ar9P@C[#FIME<E>*Os8/J1>1V/@^JYHNDWA6V/U �

:=HNDZb*:YU'A/@BME[�>#U�RI>�HK>�>1V/@0D/@� '>�M?@^jN@BM'A/U �$D�����VW@�HN[1[#U'_^<EHK>#@BA j'<E[18WHNM <E[1HK>1<?UaD\<E[�FP@^J1OQUNJL:Y@BA\J1@B_^8/Jh[1<?jN@BM?b!�

��� � ��� � ������� ��� � � � � ��� � �$�$�#� ��� � � �

��VW@D/UaD�� �)HN8W[1[1<EHND�:YU'A/@BME[�M?@BHNAGDWHK>18/JLHNMEMEbe>#U D/UaD��kM <ED/@BHKJ�@� '>#@BDW[1<EUaDW[^m7OgUaMEMEU �$<EDW]4>1V/@�F Ua< DT>.:=HNA/@

<ED �Sp��54�� m�>1VWHK>*DWUaD�� ��HN8W[1[L<EHND�MEHK>#@BDZ>*FWJL<EUNJL[�_^HND 9P@Y@BXZ8IHNMEM?b [1@^@BDrHN[4:YU'A/@BME[ �<?>1V���HN8W[L[1<EHND�MEHK>#@BDZ>

FWJL<EUNJL[ �VW<E_LV VWH jN@=9P@^@BD D/UaDWME<EDW@BHKJLM?bC>#JLHNDW[1OgUNJL:=@BA,HNDIA 9 @B_^HN:=@ DWUaD�� ��HN8W[1[L<EHND��*�U �.@^jN@^JBm�HN[)M?UaD/]

HN[ ��@YA/UGD/UN>�:=H �N@ >1VW<E[�D/UaDWME< D/@BHKJ$>#JLHNDI[#OgUNJh:=HK>1<?UaD @� 7FIM <E_^<?>^mI>1VW@BD$�.@ _^HND�8/>1<EME< %^@*UaDWM?bC>1V/@eOgUNJh:Y@^J

<EDZ>#@^J1FWJ1@^>1HK>1<EUaDfm�HN[���@lVIHBjN@lHN_^_`@B[1[\UaDWM?b,>#U [1Ua:Y@lME<EDW@BHKJ4MEHK>#@BDT>*j HKJL< HK9IM?@B[��=��VI<E[)<E[)UNO0HCFIHKJL>1<E_^8WMEHKJ

<EDZ>#@^J1@B[#>0OQUNJ0j7< [18WHNME<E[LHK>1<?UaD HKFIFIME<E_^HK>1<?UaDI[^m �V/@^J1@�>1V/@)8WM?>1<E:lHK>#@�[L_`UNF @)UNO�>1V/@4HKFWFIM <E_^HK>1<?UaDG<E[.>#UYFWJ1U��#@B_`>

>1V/@4VW<E]aVCAW<E:Y@BDW[L<?UaDWHNMPAWHK>1HYUaDZ>#U=UaDWM?bCn AW<E:=@BDW[1<?UaDW[Bm7HNDWAibN@^>$[#>1<EMEMP_^HKFW>18WJ1@*HN[�:e8W_LVdHN[�FPUa[1[1<?9;M?@UNO

>1V/@*< :YFPUNJ1>1HNDT>0[#>#Jh8W_`>18/J1@)UNO�>1V/@4AWHK>1H��

� DZ8W:\9P@^J�UNO�:YU'A/@BME[�A/@BHNME<EDW] �$<E>1V,DWUaDWME<ED/@BHKJ>#JLHNDW[#OQUNJL:=HK>1<EUaDW[�VWHBjN@=9P@^@BD,FWJ1UNFPUa[#@BA mPVWU �.@^jN@^J

>1V/@B[#@ UNOg>#@BD M?@BHNA >#U,<EDZ>#JLHN_`>1HK9IM?@l< DT>#@^]NJLHNM [*HNDWA :YUNJ1@l_`Ua:YF;M?@� �>#JLHN<EDW<EDW]iHNM?]NUNJL<?>1VW:l[ � �2�'m�p^o5� � ����D

HKFWFWJLUaHN_LV �$VW<E_hV*HNMEMEU �$[�HNDe@� 7FIM <E_^<?>�D/UaDIME<ED/@BHKJL<E>kb �$VW<EME@&HNME[#U�9 @B< D/]$_`Ua:YFI8W>1HK>1<?UaDWHNMEM?b)>#JhHN_`>1HK9IM?@Nma<E[�>1V/@

��@BD/@^JhHK>1<?jN@.��UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVW< _&� HKFIFI<ED/]\q �)��� t�:YU'A/@BM � nKo � m��VW<E_LV\<E[�< D)OQHN_`>�HFWJ1UN9IHK9I< ME<E[#>1<E_�OQUNJL:\8IMEHK>1<?UaD

UNOf>1V/@9I<?UaM?UN]a<E_^HNM M?be< DW[#FI<?JL@BAYHNDWA :=UNJ1@V/@B8WJL<E[#>1<E_$�'@BM?O � ��J1]aHNDW< %B<EDW]4� HKF�q �W����t�HNM?]NUNJh<?>1VW: � �2/ � ����V/@

����� _^HND,9P@*_`UaDW[L<EA/@^J1@BA HN[HND @� 7>#@BDI[1<?UaD UNJ]N@BD/@^JhHNME<E[1HK>1<?UaDdUNO�D78W:Y@^J1Ua8W[$@BHKJLME<?@^J>#@B_LVWDI<EXZ8W@B[$[18W_hV

HN[ FWJL< DW_^<?FIHNM�_^8/J1jN@B[=HN[ ]N@BD/@^JhHK>1<?jN@i:YU'A/@BME[ �Sp�/Ko � m.A/@BDW[1<?> brD/@^> ��UNJ��'[ �Sp^o5�Wm�p^o50�� m�@BMEHN[#>1< _�DW@^>1[ � -2- � m

�'HN:=:=UaD :=HKFWFI< D/] �Sp.-C� ��HNDWA�FWJLUN9IHK9I<EME< [#>1<E_4JL@^OgUNJL:e8WMEHK>1<EUaDW[�UNO�>1VW@��W��� �Sp^o5/�� ���7@^@ "0VWHKFW>#@^J\nGUNO

�Sp.- ��� OQUNJ$:YUNJL@*A/@^>1HN<EM?@BACAI<E[1_^8W[1[L<?UaD��

�$-

Page 46: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

��� ��� ��� � � # � # *$& �'�(� # ( � ( > *$&�� �?� #*) & � � �=��> � �� ) �

".UaDI[1<EA/@^J HND � �kAW<E:=@BDW[1<?UaDWHNM�MEHK>#@BDZ>=[#FIHN_`@Nm&@!� ]�� OgUNJ j'<E[18WHNME< [1HK>1<?UaD F;8/J1FPUa[#@B[eH n �k� A/Ua:=HN< D UNO� % p �Bp � � % p �Bp � �.��VW@HN<E: <E[�>#UeJL@^FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>�>1VW@�VW<E]aV��kAW<E:Y@BDI[1<?UaDWHNM/AWHK>1H\jN@B_`>#UNJL[�UaD�>1VW<E[.MEHK>#@BDZ>.[1FIHN_`@[18W_hV�>1VWHK>4>1VW@l<E:YFPUNJ1>1HNDZ>4[#>#JL8W_`>18WJLHNM�_LVWHKJhHN_`>#@^JL<E[#>1<E_^[eHKJ1@=JL@^jN@BHNM?@BA��l��VW@^J1@l<E[)HiDWUaDWME<ED/@BHKJ)JL@BMEHK>1<?UaD

9P@^> �.@^@BDl>1VW@$FIMEHNDW@$HNDWA=>1VW@$AWHK>1He[#FIHN_`@!�&��V/@D/UaDWME<EDW@BHKJL<?>kbe<E:YFIM <?@B[�>1VWHK>�>1VW@MEHK>#@BDZ>�FIM HND/@$_^HND�_^8/J1jN@

>#UC9P@B_`Ua:Y@=HG]N@BD/@^JLHNM�n �k� :lHNDW<?OQUaMEA <ED,>1V/@YVW<?]aV�AW<E:=@BDW[1<?UaDWHNM�AWHK>1HC[#FIHN_`@!�Y��VW@ < D/]N@BDW<?Ua8W[�<EAW@BH UNO

����� mT>#UeHN_LVW<E@^jN@$>1VW<E[�<EDYFWJLHN_`>1< _`@Nm7<E[&>#U\AW<E[L_`J1@^>1<E[#@0>1V/@�MEHK>#@BDZ>�[#FIHN_`@$9ZbY<EDZ>#J1U'AW8W_^<ED/])H*J1@^]a8WMEHKJ�HKJLJLHBb

qQ]NJL<EA t�UNO � MEHK>#@BDZ>.FPUa<EDZ>1[ � � � �� � � q �$VW< _LV�HKJ1@�HNDIHNM?UN]NUa8W[�>#U >1V/@�D/U7AW@B[�UNO��W����t$qs[#@^@ !�<?]�� n �EpBneOQUNJ<EMEM 8W[#>#JLHK>1<?UaD t �

� �<> !.* # ��� � � M ME8W[#>#JLHK>1<EUaD UNO�>1V/@*DWUaD��kME<ED/@BHKJ�]N@BD/@^JhHK>1<?jN@\:=HKFIFI<ED/]Y<ED���$�

��Dc>1VI<E[ ��HBbNm>1V/@ D/UaD�� ��HN8W[1[1< HND qs8WDW<EOgUNJL:�t MEHK>#@BDZ>�AW< [#>#JL<?9I8W>1<?UaD 9 @B_`Ua:=@B[�H :=< '>18/J1@dUNO4A/@BM?>1H

Os8WDW_`>1<?UaDW[

��q���t p�

��� �� q�� % � �Nt q n � 4 �at

HNDWAC>1VW@4<EDT>#@^]NJhHNM�q n ���at�_^HNDi9 @)@^jKHNME8WHK>#@BAd>#JL<?j'<EHNMEM?b=HN[H=[18W: �

��q��t p�

��� �� ��q� � ��t q n � 4'-Zt

�$V/@^JL@�>1VW@G_`U7@ � _^<?@BDZ>ip �#� J1@^FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>1[ >1V/@CFWJh<?UNJ\FIJ1UN9IHK9I<EM <?>kb�jKHNME8/@B[���q����Nthm&R '@BA <ED >1VW<E[ :YU'A/@BM ���V/@_`UaDWAW<?>1<?UaDIHNMWAW<E[#>#Jh<?9I8/>1<?UaD U jN@^J�>1V/@AWHK>1H\<E[�HN[L[18W:Y@BAl>#U\9P@ ��HN8I[1[1<EHND � >1VW< [&<E[�[L8W<?>1HK9IM?@$OgUNJ�J1@BHNM

jKHNME8/@BAC_`UaDZ>1<EDZ8WUa8W[�AWHK>1H��

��q��� ��t � � q���� �Gt ��� � � q n � 4 /at

�2/

Page 47: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

��V/@4[LHN:Y@)FIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^J�� � <E[�_`UaDW[1< A/@^J1@BA�OgUNJHNMEMf:=< '>18/J1@)_`Ua:YFPUaD/@BDZ>1[�����VW@4D/UaDWME<[email protected]_`>1<EUaD q t<E[&_`UaDZjN@BDW<?@BDZ>1M?bY_LVWUa[#@BD=UNOP>1V/@�OQUNJL: q���� � �ft ����q����Nthm&�V/@^J1@ � � � � � � <E[�H)FIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^J�:=HK>#JL< HNDWA���q t q�� � q t � �� ����� q t#t � �����eq t / � � ! � <E[eHd[1@^>\UNO� DWUaD�� FIHKJLHN:Y@^>#Jh<E_lD/UaDIME<ED/@BHKJ49;HN[1<E[Os8WDW_`>1<?UaDW[ � �$V/@B[#@i_`Ua8WMEA 9P@iHNDZb [L:YUZUN>1V OQ8WDI_`>1<?UaDW[^m�>kb7FI<E_^HNMEM?b ��HN8W[1[L<EHNDW[Y:=H b 9P@G@B:YFIMEU bN@BA��c�

ME<EDW@BHKJ�9;HN[1<E[�Os8WDW_`>1<?UaD�P�aq���t p ��� � <E[�>#Ui9P@=<EDW_^ME8IA/@BA <EO�>1V/@=AWHK>1Hd<E[)D/UN>4_`@BDZ>#@^J1@BA >#U %^@^JLU��=��V/@D/UN>1HK>1<?UaD � � � � ��� � �$<EM MT9P@08W[#@BAYHN[&[LV/UNJ1>1VWHNDWA�����VI<E[�:YU7AW@BM/_^HNDY9P@�< DT>#@^J1FIJ1@^>#@BAYHN[&H � �#�S��� �+����� ���:=< '>18/J1@�UNO ��HN8I[1[1<EHNDW[BmaHN[�>1VW@��)HN8W[1[1<EHND _`@BDZ>#@^JL[&_^HNDWDWUN>�:=U jN@�<EDWAW@^F @BDIA/@BDT>1MEb�OQJ1Ua: @BHN_LV=UN>1V/@^J ����V/@

AWHK>1H=M < �N@BME<EV/U7U'A <E[�>1V/@)OgUaM M?U �$< D/]��

� ��� ��p�

��� ��

� pn���� ��� � � � @� 'F % pn�� � q� � % ��� � t ��� q n � 4 0at

��V/@)@� 'FP@B_`>1HK>1<?UaDiUNO�>1V/@*_`Ua:=FIM?@^>#@*AWHK>1HlM?UN] �kME< �N@BME< V/UZU'A UNO�>1VW@4:YU7AW@BM <E[

� pn��� ��

��� �� � ��� � q�� � ��'t % �dM?UN] p� � % p� � q��� % ��� � t � � q n � 424Nt

�$V/@^JL@��������aq���� � ��'t.<E[$_`Ua:YFI8/>#@BACj'<EHY��HBbN@B[ �I>1V/@^UNJ1@B: <EDG>1V/@*� �k[#>#@^F�/� ��� � q���� � ��/t @� 7F � % �

�q��� % ��� � t � �� �

� � �� @� 'F � % ��q��� % ��� � � t � � q n � 4 �at

HNDWA < [=[#Ua:Y@^>1<E:=@B[YJ1@^OQ@^J1J1@BA6>#UrHN[lJ1@B[#FPUaDW[1<E9I<EME<?>1<E@B[*HNDWA6A/@BDWUN>#@BAcHN[ � � � m�HN[=9 @^OQUNJ1@ qs[1@^@i@BXZ8IHK>1<?UaDq n �1-C0at#t � ��V/@�J1@B[#FPUaDW[L<?9I<EME<E>kb � � � <E[e>1V/@CFPUa[#>#@^JL<?UNJ FWJLUN9IHK9I<EME<E>kb >1VWHK>=H ��HN8W[L[1<EHND���q��� � � � thm�_`UNJLJ1@��[#FPUaDWAW< D/]\>#Ul>1V/@*MEHK>#@BDZ>$[#FIHN_`@\_`@BDT>#@^J ���\VWHN[�]N@BD/@^JLHK>#@BAi>1VW@ � >1VCUN9I[#@^JLj HK9IME@4AWHK>18W: FPUa<EDZ> ��+���VW@.� �k[#>#@^F @BXZ8IHK>1<?UaDW[�[email protected]>1HN<ED/@BA\9Zb\[#UaM?j'<ED/]$>1VW@.[#>1HK>1<EUaDWHKJ1b4@BX78WHK>1<?UaDW[ ���� � o�HNDWA ������ & o'm

�$VW< _LVG]a<?jN@*8I[0>1V/@4� �k[#>#@^F 8/FfAWHK>#@B[

� � ��� � � ����� � q n � 4 �at

� � p� �

��� ��

��� �� � � � � � � % � � � � � � q n ���KoTt

�.@^J1@ � q � � � t� ���� � � � ���� � HNDIA � <E[�H=AI<EHK]NUaDWHNM :=HK>#Jh< �$<E>1VG@BM?@B:Y@BDZ>1[ � � � � �� �� � � � m � <E[0HND� � :=HK>#JL< �$<?>1V�� � <EDC<?>1[ � � >1Vd_`UaME8W:=DCHNDWA�� < [�>1V/@*AWHK>1H=:lHK>#JL< �

��VW@�FIJL<E:=HKJ1b=HKFIFIME<E_^HK>1<?UaD�HKJ1@BH UNO ����� <E[.OgUNJ�AWHK>1H j'<E[18IHNME<E[1HK>1<?UaD mTU �P@^JL<ED/] H FPU �.@^J1OQ8IM;>1VW@^UNJ1@^> �

<E_^HNMEMEbdFWJL< DW_^<?FIM?@BAd>#UZUaM�OgUNJ\AWHK>1Hi:=<EDI<ED/]GHKFWFIME<E_^HK>1<EUaDW[�� �$OQ>#@^J*>1V/@=:=U7A/@BM�VWHN[)9P@^@BD,RI>)>#Ui>1V/@ AWHK>1H'm

>1V/@�>#JLHNDW[1OgUNJL:lHK>1<?UaD _^HNDG9P@�<EDZjN@^J1>#@BAC8W[1<EDW]*��HBbN@B[��WJh8WM?@Nm'HNDWA�>1V/@�F Ua[1>#@^JL<?UNJL[._^HNDG9P@@ � _^<E@BDT>1M?b 8W[#@BA

OQUNJ)j7<E[L8WHNME<E[1HK>1<EUaDdUNO�>1V/@=AWHK>1HC<ED,>1V/@YMEHK>#@BDZ>*[#FIHN_`@!� ��V/@YMEHK>#@BDZ>4[#FIHN_`@ J1@^FIJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaD�UNO�>1VW@YF Ua< DT>

�20

Page 48: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

��i<E[$>1H �N@BD >#U 9P@4>1V/@eFPUa[#>#@^JL<?UNJ�:Y@BHNDW[ � � ��� � � �$��[�<EDi>1V/@ ����� :=U7A/@BM�>1V/@ MEHK>#@BDT>�[#FIHN_`@ <E[AW<E[ �_`J1@^>1<E[1@BAfm/>1V/@�FPUa[#>#@^JL<?UNJ�:Y@BHNDG>1H �N@B[$>1V/@)OQUNJL: � �

� �� � � � ���Tm/UNJ�< D�:lHK>#JL< �DWUN>1HK>1<?UaD � ��� � �V/@^J1@

� AW@BD/UN>#@B[�>1V/@ � � :=HK>#JL< UNO�� ]NJL<EA F Ua< DT>1[��4��:YUaD/]a[1>4DZ8W:=@^J1Ua8W[�_`UaDTj'<EDW_^< D/] >#U b&� @� /HN:YFIME@B[^mHNDiHKFWF;ME<E_^HK>1<?UaDG>#U=j'<E[18IHNME<E[1<EDW]*>1V/@�� � F;VWHN[#@)FI<?FP@ �IU �-AWHK>1H=[#@^>VWHN[09P@^@BDCFWJ1@B[1@BDT>#@BAi< D �Sp.- ��� �

� ��� ����� �!���������

�7Ua:=@\UNO&>1VW@e:YUa[1>�<E:=F UNJL>1HNDT>]N@BD/@^JLHK>1<?jN@=:YU'A/@BME[VWHBjN@ 9P@^@BD J1@^j7<E@���@BA <EDd>1VW<E[�_LVWHKFW>#@^J ���$V/@B[#@

_^HND 9P@YAW<?j'<EA/@BAd< DT>#UC:YU'A/@BME[ �$VW< _LV,HN[1[18W:Y@YHC:=H� /<E:=HNM M?biA/@BDW[#@e]N@BD/@^JLHK>1<EjN@YJ1@^FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaD�UNO�>1V/@

AWHK>1Hcqs:=U7A/@BM [)�$<?>1V H���HN8W[L[1<EHND6MEHK>#@BDZ>YFWJL<?UNJ m�< � @!� !."0� � > bZFP@i:YU'A/@BME[hthm.:YU'A/@BME[ �$<?>1V6:=H� /<E:=HNM M?b

[#FIHKJh[#@�]N@BD/@^JLHK>1<?jN@4[#>#Jh8W_`>18/J1@=qs:=< '>18/J1@�:YU'A/@BME[ht�HNDWAG:YU'A/@BME[��$VI<E_LVG[#@^@��GHYD/UaD�� ��HN8I[1[1<EHNDGMEHK>#@BDZ>�<ED��

>#@^J1FWJL@^>1HK>1<?UaDfm;< DC>1V/@*V/UNFP@4UNO�R;DIAW<ED/]Y:YUNJ1@e<ED/OQUNJL:=HK>1<?jN@4[1>#JL8W_`>18/J1@�qQUNOg>#@BD >#@^JL:Y@BA HN[$�1"��(:YU'A/@BME[ht �

� D/UN>1HK9;M?@�HN[#FP@B_`> UNO\>1V/@B[#@ :YU7AW@BMEME<ED/] <EA/@BHN[G<E[ >1V/@ @� '<E[1>#@BDW_`@,< Dc>1V/@�ME<E>#@^JLHK>18/J1@ UNO*9PUN>1VcFIJ1UN9IH��

9I<EM <E[#>1<E_ HNDWA D/UaD�� FWJ1UN9;HK9IME<E[#>1< _\OQUNJL:e8WMEHK>1<?UaDI[4UNO0>1V/@B[#@�:YU'A/@BME[ � >1V/@ [L<E:=<EMEHKJh<?>1<?@B[�9P@^> �.@^@BD !�"�� q

!�!�"��\m�3 �k:Y@BHNDW[vqr:=< '>18/J1@G:YU'A/@BMEME<EDW]/m�!�! q � !'� HNDIAc�W��� q ���$� HKJ1@CX78W<?>#@GUN9Zj'<?Ua8W[ � ��V/@

D/UaD�� FIJ1UN9IHK9I<EM <E[#>1<E_�jN@^JL[L<?UaDW[�VW<E[#>#UNJh<E_^HNMEM?bCFWJL@B_`@BA/@BA,>1V/@ FWJ1UN9IHK9I< ME<E[#>1<E_4UaD/@B[)HNDWA,UNOg>#@BD >18WJLD/@BA,Ua8/>�>#U

_`UaDW[1< [#>�UNO�_`Ua:=FI8/>1HK>1<?UaDWHNM M?bY_LV/@BHKFP@^J0<E:YFIME@B:Y@BDT>1HK>1<EUaDW[&UNO�[1Ua:Y@[#FP@B_^<EHNM _^HN[#@B[.UNO�H\FPUN>#@BDT>1<EHNM M?bY:YUNJ1@

]N@BD/@^JLHNM�FWJ1UN9;HK9I<EME<E[1>1<E_ :YU7AW@BM&9P@BVW<EDWA >1V/@B:Cm �$VW<E_hVrVWH jN@ 9P@^@BD OgUNJh:\8WM HK>#@BA MEHK>#@^J �d�ME>1V/Ua8/]aV >1VW@B[#@

D/UaD�� FIJ1UN9IHK9I<EM <E[#>1<E_�>#U7UaME[�HKJ1@ UNOg>#@BD�X78W<?>#@\@ � _^<?@BDZ>)<ED [L<E:YFIM?@\FWJLHN_`>1<E_^HNM�[1<E>18WHK>1<?UaDW[^m >1V/@eFWJ1UN9IHK9;<EME<E[#>1< _

OQJLHN:Y@��.UNJ�� U �P@^JL[�H=>1V/@^UNJ1@^>1<E_^HNMEMEblFWJL< DW_^<?FIM?@BA 8WDW<SR;@BA >#JL@BHK>1:Y@BDT>$UNO�:YU'A/@BM RI>#>1< D/]YHNDWAG@� 7>#@BDI[1<?9I<EM <?>kbNm

@!� ]���:=U7A/@BMf_`Ua:\9I<EDIHK>1<?UaDCUNJ�>#J1@BHK>1:=@BDT>UNO�< DW_`Ua:YFIM?@^>#@)AWHK>1H��

�7Ua:=@0j HKJL< HNDT>1[�UNO >1V/@09IHN[L<E_�]N@BD/@^JLHK>1<?jN@:YU7AW@BME[ �$VW<E_hVYHKJ1@�[18W<E>1HK9IM?@�OgUNJ�>#@� '> � J1@BMEHK>#@BA�HKFWFIM <E_^HK>1<?UaDW[

�$<EM M�9 @dFWJ1UNFPUa[#@BAc< D [#Ua:Y@,UNO)>1V/@ M HK>#@^J _LVIHKFW>#@^JL[��-�$V/@iOQUaMEM?U �<ED/]r_hVWHKFW>#@^J�J1@^j7<E@��$[=>1V/@ @� '< [#>1<ED/]

ME<?>#@^JhHK>18/J1@�UaDi]N@BD/@^JhHK>1<?jN@*:YU'A/@BMEME< D/]\UNO�>#@� '>$A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[��

�54

Page 49: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

�� ��� ��� � �

� � �� ��� �� � ��� � ��� � � �!��� � � � � �����

��VI<E[�_LVWHKFI>#@^J�FWJL@B[#@BDT>1[&>1V/@$_^8/J1JL@BDT>�[1>1HK>#@$UNOP>1V/@$HKJ1>�J1@^]aHKJLAW<EDW]4MEHK>#@BDT>�j HKJL< HK9IM?@�:YU'A/@BMEME< D/]UNOP>#@� '>

9IHN[#@BA A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[��i��V/@l�@B_`>#UNJ �7FIHN_`@,qQ4�Wt4_`U7AW< D/]iUNO0>#@� '>eA/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[ � A/@B[L_`JL<?9P@BA�<ED �'@B_`>1<?UaD

� �Ep � < [$@B:YF;M?U bN@BA,HN[�H [#>1HKJL>1<ED/]lFPUa<EDZ>^m �$VW<E_hViJ1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>1[>1V/@ A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[<ED >1V/@e[#FIHN_`@eUNO ��UNJhAW[��

��D�[#FI<?>#@ UNO�<?>1[)[1<E:YF;ME<E_^<?> bNm >1VW@Y)�,:YU'A/@BM�_`UaDZ>1<EDZ8W@B[)>#Ui9P@ >1V/@=:YUa[#>)FPUNFI8WM HKJ�HNDWA @��P@B_`>1<?jN@�<EDW<?>1<EHNM

J1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>1HK>1<EUaDCUNO�>#@� 7>$< DCHKFWFWJ1UaHN_hVW<ED/]=H=[L8/9I[#@BX78/@BDZ>�[#>1HK>1<E[#>1<E_^HNM�HNDWHNM?b'[1<E[��

��DiUN97j7<EUa8W[�<EDW_`UaDZjN@BDW<?@BDI_`@4UNO�>1V/@44�C:YU'A/@BM <E[�>1V/@*VW<?]aVdAW<E:Y@BDW[L<?UaDWHNME<?> bNm��$VW<E_hVC<E[�A/@^>#@^JL:l<ED/@BA

97b=>1V/@)DZ8I:*9P@^J.UNO�AW< �P@^J1@BDZ>��.UNJLAW[ ���$V/@�8I[1HK]N@�UNO�[#b'D/UaDZb7:=[�HNDWA�AW< �P@^J1@BDZ>��$JL<?>1<ED/]e[#>kb'M?@B[�<EDW_`JL@BHN[#@B[

>1V/@YAW<E:=@BDW[1<?UaDWHNM <?>kbGUNO&>1V/@)�.UNJLAW[�[#FIHN_`@!�*� D HNAWAW<E>1<?UaDfm >1V/@ >kb7FI<E_^HNM�AW<E:Y@BDI[1<?UaDiUNO�>1V/@YAW<E_`>1<?UaDIHKJ1bi<E[

UNO�>1V/@)UNJLA/@^J$UNO�>#@BDI[0UNO�>1VWUa8W[1HNDWAW[�UNO.�.UNJLAW[��

� >YVWHN[e9 @^@BD HKJ1]a8W@BA �1/Ko��0>1VWHK>YH,:=UNJ1@CHKFWFWJ1UNFWJh<EHK>#@�:=U7A/@BM.[1V/Ua8IMEA _`UaDI[1<EA/@^JY[#Ua:Y@C_`UaDW_`@^FI>18WHNM

AW<E:=@BDW[1<?UaDW[�<EDW[1>#@BHNA�UNO��.UNJLAW[Bm��$VW<E_hV ��Ua8WM A FWJ1U j'<EA/@YHi:=UNJ1@=_`UaDW_^<E[#@YJL@^FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaD�� �7@^jN@^JhHNM&HK> �

>#@B:YFW>1[�VIHBjN@�9P@^@BDe:lHNA/@�>#U�UN9W>1HN< DeH�M?U ��@^J��kAW<E:Y@BDW[L<?UaDWHNMaJL@^FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaDY<EDeH�AWHK>1H��kAW<?J1@B_`>#@BAY:lHNDWD/@^JBm

[#Ua:Y@*UNO.�$VI<E_LVCHKJ1@*J1@^j7<E@���@BAi< DG>1V/@*[18/9;[#@BXZ8W@BDT>0[#@B_`>1<?UaDI[�UNO�>1VW<E[�_hVWHKFW>#@^J �

��VI<E[ _hVWHKFW>#@^J <E[ UNJ1]aHNDW< %^@BA HN[ OgUaMEMEU �$[�� ��VW@ 4� :YU7AW@BM\HNDWA([#Ua:=@ UNOl>1V/@6[#>1HNDWAWHKJLA >#@� '> �

FWJ1@^FIJ1U7_`@B[L[1<ED/] [1_hV/@B:Y@B[�HKJ1@ AW@B[1_`JL<?9P@BA6<EDc>1V/@CRIJL[1>l[#@B_`>1<?UaD�� �'@B_`>1<?UaD�nr<E[=A/@^jNUN>#@BA >#U HrFPUNFI8WMEHKJ

HNDWA @��P@B_`>1<?jN@ ME<ED/@BHKJ�>#@B_LVIDW<EX78/@,_^HNM M?@BA���HK>#@BDT> �'@B:=HNDT>1< _,��DWHNM?b'[1<E[,qs���'�)thm �$VW<E_hVcJL@BHNME< %^@B[GH AW<E[ �

>#JL<?9;8/>#@BA _`Ua:YFIHN_`>eJ1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>1HK>1<EUaDrUNO0>1V/@ >#@� 7> AWHK>1H'm�9IHN[#@BA UaD @� /<E[#>1< D/]d_`UNJ1J1@BM HK>1<?UaDW[e<ED�>1V/@�AWHK>1H��

�7@B_`>1<?UaD*� _`UaDW_`@^JLDW[�:=< '>18/J1@e:YU'A/@BME[ �VW<E_LV HKJ1@ <ED 8I[#@\<EDd>#@� 7>)_^MEHN[L[1<SR;_^HK>1<?UaD,HNDWA,_^ME8W[#>#@^Jh<ED/]��$� �.U

jN@^J1bGAW< �P@^J1@BDZ>�_^HK>#@^]NUNJh<?@B[�UNO�:YU'A/@BME[�HKJ1@4A/@^>1HN<EME@BACV/@^J1@!/�9P@B[1<EA/@B[.>1V/@4:l< 7>18WJ1@�:=U7A/@BM [�OgUNJ�A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>

<EDW[1>1HNDW_`@B[�qQ>1VW@G��HN<?jN@G��HBbN@B[=:YU'A/@BME[ t'� �$VW<E_hVrHN[1[L8W:Y@G8WDW<EX78/@l:Y@B:\9P@^JL[1VW<EFI[)UNO�>1V/@GA/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[

>#U�UaD/@\UNO�>1V/@\>#UNF;<E_*_^MEHN[L[#@B[^mPHlJ1@B_`@BDZ>1M?bdAW@^jN@BM?UNFP@BA :YU'A/@BM�J1@BHNME< %^@B[�H�AW<E[#>#JL<E9I8/>#@BAC:Y@B:\9P@^JL[1VW<?FdJ1@^F��

J1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaDrUNO.>1VW@lA/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[4>#Ui>1V/@ AW< �P@^J1@BDT>)>#UNF;<E_=_^MEHN[1[1@B[497b OQUNJL:e8WMEHK>1<ED/]C>1VW@l:=< '>18/J1@Y:YU'A/@BM

�2�

Page 50: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

OQUNJ ��UNJLA��kA/U7_^8I:Y@BDT>�FIHN<EJL[�<EDW[#>#@BHNA,UNO�A/U7_^8I:Y@BDT>1[ �*��VW<E[�:YU'A/@BM�<E[�>#@^JL:Y@BA�HN[*!&J1UN9IHK9;<EME<E[#>1< _4��HK>#@BDZ>

�7@B:=HNDZ>1<E_4��DWHNM?b'[1<E[)qs!����'�)thmW97bGHNDIHNM?UN]NbG>#U=>1V/@4>#JLHNAI<?>1<?UaDWHNMfAW< [#>#JL<?9I8W>#@BA A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>�J1@^FIJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaD

97bl���'���'� DG_`UaDZ>#JLHN[#>�V/U ��@^jN@^J m/>1V/@)!����/� OQHN_`>#UNJh[0HKJ1@�@BHN[1<EM?bl< DT>#@^J1FIJ1@^>1HK9IM?@OgUNJ�V78W:=HND�8WDWA/@^Jh[#>1HNDWA��

<ED/] HNDWAG>1V/@B<EJ�D78W:Y@^Jh<E_^HNM j HNME8W@B[.HKJL@4HNM �.H b7[�FPUa[1<E>1<?jN@)HNDWA�>#@BDWAG>#UY9P@�[#F;HKJL[#@!�&��V/@B[1@�OQ@BHK>18/J1@B[�J1@BMEHK>#@

!����'� >#U=�#"0� � > bZFP@*:YU'A/@BME[BmWHN[ �$<EM M < DWA/@^@BAG9P@4A/@B:YUaDW[1>#JLHK>#@BAdMEHK>#@^J�<EDd"�VWHKFI>#@^J 0 ���1"��(:YU'A/@BMEME<EDW]

UNO�>#@� '>AWHK>1H�VWHN[$HNM [#U=9P@^@BDi@� 'FIME<E_^<E>1M?b _`UaDW[L<EA/@^J1@BA <EDC>1V/@eME<?>#@^JLHK>18/JL@4OgUNJ9PUN>1Vd<ED/OQUNJL:=HK>1<EUaDCJ1@^>#JL<?@^jKHNM

HNDWA A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>)_^ME8W[#>#@^JL< D/]��*��V/@B[1@eHKFWFIJ1UaHN_LV/@B[*:=HN<EDWM?bi_`UaDI[1<E[#>�UNO�< :YFPUa[1<ED/] >1V/@Y8W[18WHNM��#"0� :YU'A/@BM

HKFWFWJLUNFWJL<EHK>#@)OQUNJ9;ME<EDWAG[1<?]aDIHNM [#@^FIHKJLHK>1<EUaDi>#U�>1V/@4>#@� '>�AWHK>1H HNDWAi>1VW@B[#@\HKJ1@*J1@^j7<E@���@BA,<ED �7@B_`>1<EUaD -lUNO

>1VW<E[�_LVWHKFI>#@^J �.�7@B_`>1<?UaD�/\A/@^>1HN<EME[�>1V/@>#UNFPUN]NJLHKF;VW<E_�j'<E[18IHNME<E[1HK>1<?UaD=UNOf>#@� 7>0A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[�@B:=FIM?U bN@BAG<EDl>1V/@

� �����W��� FWJ1U��#@B_`>^m �$VW<E_hV�<E[4HNDrHKFIFIME<E_^HK>1<?UaD UNO�>1V/@ 3)UaV/UaD/@BD [1@BM?O�UNJL]aHNDW< %B<ED/]i:lHKFrHNM?]NUNJL<?>1VI: >#U

j'<E[18WHNME< %B<ED/]\M HKJ1]N@*_`UaMEM?@B_`>1<EUaDW[�UNO�A/U7_^8I:Y@BDT>1[ � !�< DWHNMEM?bNmI�7@B_`>1<?UaD 0Y_`UaDW_^ME8WAW@B[�9Zb�OgUNJh:\8WM HK>1<ED/]Y[#Ua:Y@4UNO

>1V/@�:YUN>1<?jKHK>1<?UaDW[ �VW<E_LV=OgUNJL:=@BA=>1V/@9IHN[1<E[�UNOf>1VW@$J1@B[#@BHKJh_LV�<EDTjN@B[1>1<?]aHK>1<?UaDW[�FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>#@BA < DY>1V/@�OQUaMEM?U �$<ED/]

_LVIHKFW>#@^JL[�UNO�>1VW<E[�>1V/@B[1<E[��

� ��� � ��� � �� � �� � �� ��� � � ��� ��� � � ���� � ��� � �

��VW@��@B_`>#UNJ��7F;HN_`@qQ)�ItP:YU'A/@BMKOgUNJ�>#@� 7>�9IHN[#@BA4A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[ <EDZ>#J1U'AW8W_`@BA�97b)�/HNM?>#UaD �Sp.-Wp �TJL@^FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>1[

A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[�HN[ � �kAW<E:Y@BDI[1<?UaDWHNM'jN@B_`>#UNJL[ � m&�$VW@^J1@ � < [�>1V/@ME@BD/]N>1VYUNOf>1V/@�jNU'_^HK9I8WM HKJ1b!�&��HN_hV AW< :Y@BDW[1<?UaDUNOI>[email protected]/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ> � jN@B_`>#UNJ�_`UNJ1JL@B[#FPUaDWAW[�>#U�H �.UNJLACqQ>#@^JL: t�UNOI>[email protected]'_^HK9I8WM HKJ1b4HNDWAe@� 7FIJ1@B[1[#@B[�H�OQ8IDW_`>1<?UaD

� UNO�>1V/@�DZ8W:\9P@^J4UNO0>1<E:Y@B[*>1V/@ �.UNJLA VWHN[*U'_^_^8/J1JL@BA <ED >1VW@lA/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>��G�$VZ8W[*>1V/@ AIHK>1Hd:=HK>#JL< �_`UaDW[1< [#>1[)D/U � UNO � _`UaME8W:=DW[Bmf@BHN_LVr[1>#UNJL<ED/]CHCA/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>�J1@^FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>#@BA�97b H � �kAI<E:Y@BDW[1<EUaDWHNM�_`UaM 8W:=DjN@B_`>#UNJ �.��V/@4:=HK>#JL< �� <E[0J1@^OQ@^J1J1@BAG>#U�HN[0>1V/@�� ����� �E� � ������%�0:lHK>#JL< GUNO�>1VW@4A/U7_^8I:Y@BDT>�_`UNJLFI8W[��

��M?>1V/Ua8/]aVc>1VW<E[=< [YUN9Zj'<?Ua8W[LM?b :=@^J1@BM?b6H�R;DW]N@^J1FWJL<EDZ> JLHK>1V/@^J�>1VWHNDcHrOQHN<E>1V/OQ8IM0A/@B[1_`JL<?FI>1<?UaD UNO)>1V/@

_`UaDZ>#@BDT>\UNO.HCA/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>'� HN[4<?>)<?]aDWUNJ1@B[)>1V/@YUNJLAW@^J)UNO�>1V/@ �.UNJLAW[Bm�HNDTb,FI8WDI_`>18WHK>1<?UaD,UNJ*[#>#JL8I_`>18/JLHNM

<ED/OQUNJL:=HK>1<EUaD � <?>�U �P@^JL[�H=[1>#JLHN<?]aVZ>#OgUNJ���HKJLA �.H b�OQUNJ$@ ��_^<?@BDT>[#>1HK>1<E[#>1<E_^HNM >#UZUaME[$>#U=9P@4HKFWFIME<E@BA >#U >1V/@

>#@� '>�:l<EDW<ED/]0FIJ1UN9IM?@B:�����VW<E[�_^HND\[email protected]_LVW<?@^jN@BA HN[�>1V/@.)�*:YU'A/@BMT[1>1<EMEMaFIJ1U j'<EA/@B[�H_`UaDW[L<EA/@^JLHK9IME@�HN:YUa8WDZ>

UNO�< D/OgUNJh:=HK>1<?UaD HK9PUa8/>)HN[1[#U'_^<EHK>1<?UaDW[�9P@^> �.@^@BD �.UNJLAW[)HNDWA�A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[ �$VW< _LV [#@^@B:=[�>#UC9P@ [18 � _^<?@BDZ>

@!� ]��&OQUNJ0>#UNFI<E_^HNMf_^ME8I[#>#@^JL<ED/]eHNDWAC<ED/OQUNJL:=HK>1<EUaDlJ1@^>#Jh<?@^j HNM �SpNpNpTmPp^o5�/mPpBn'pTm,-Tn'm:4 �'mfp�/20�� �.�7Ua:Y@��VWHK>0[18/J����� �� �"#�*A<.*" �"<�=� ���0 �"<�@I�/�6 ���*II�/)#����A<���4D9D<���(A#I��)� C�������������)� 1� ����*)9MN�/�VMNA<�� �"<�(�V���������������)#.�!:;"#��� "9�=I�<���=�(�� ����?!��)<���# ��[M ���*I �"<���/�!�(� 1� ����*)<�21/)8D �<���/�!�(�� �������/M 1/)�1/��.*��?� 1/���9+-���R ��/�J���81����*�L1/�( �A#1/����� �"<��+-�(�( ��/���3������A<�� ��=)<.>M ���*I��)<���,D<��)#.��/MCD����A#I�(), ��V�=����/)#���B�=) 1E��A<?#���( %��ML �"#��;TUD<��I��)<�����*)81��5+-���( ����%���81����*�H:;"<���R" 1/���*)<�JD<�����%)#�� MOA<��#��� �"<�1�K���*I�P�/M 1@�=��)<�41��;���#1/��� ) 1��;1/)�1/��.*��?� 1/��� �6 ���A#�R �A<��� - �<1/�;1���� �"<� ���/I�!�*)#�(), ��&�/MZ �"<�����V+*���( ��/���;17��� )#�/)<T`)#�(.-1� ���+-�V1/)#D�/M ���)9D�=���R���( �� +*1���A#����F��L"81�)#W,�C ��� 5���/MUF��P�/�=��)��H�,MO� MN�/� �!�*��)� ���)#.3�/A< ; �"#���C�/?#���(��+/1� ����*)SF

� �

Page 51: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

FWJL< [1<ED/]aM?bNmaHeD78W:*9P@^J�UNO�[#>18WAW<E@B[�VWH jN@�[1VWU �$D >1VWHK>�ME<?>#>1M?@$< [�>#Ue9P@�]aHN<ED/@BA 9ZbY@B:=FIM?U b'<ED/]e[#UNFIVW< [#>1<E_^HK>#@BA

_`Ua:YFI8W>1HK>1<?UaDWHNMIM <ED/]a8W<E[1>1<E_^[�:YU7AW@BME[�U jN@^J�>1VW<E[�[1<E:[email protected]@^FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaD � -Tn/mIp�� ���;HNDIAlA/@^jN@BM?UNF;<ED/])JL<E_hV/@^J

:YU'A/@BME[�>1VWHK>HKJ1@*HNME[#U=_`Ua:=FI8/>1HK>1<?UaDWHNM M?blOQ@BHN[1<?9IME@)J1@B:=HN<EDW[0HY_hVWHNMEM?@BDW]a<ED/]YFWJ1UN9;M?@B:��

�.b=jKHKJ1b'<ED/]*>1VW@Os8WDW_`>1<?UaD � m'HNM?>#@^JLDWHK>1<?jN@�>#@^JL: � �.@B<?]aVT>1< D/]a[��'_^HND 9P@FWJ1U'AW8W_`@BA �Sp.-Wp � m/[#Ua:Y@�UNO >1V/@[#>1HNDWAIHKJLA _hV/Ua<E_`@B[�9P@B<ED/] >1V/@\OQUaMEM?U �$<ED/],q�� �$<EMEM AW@BD/UN>#@ >1V/@eD78W:\9P@^J$UNO&U'_^_^8/J1J1@BDI_`@B[UNO&H�FIHKJL>1<E_^8WMEHKJ

�.UNJLAi<EDCH=AWU7_^8W:=@BDT>ht /

� q���t � q � �Ep t

� q���t M?UN];q�� � p t q � � nat

� q���t � � q � ���at

� q���t �,MEUN] � �

q � �1-Zt

� q���t ��� �� p � � po � ���� � � �� q � ��/at

��Dd[1_hV/@B:Y@�q � �1-Zt � A/@BD/UN>#@B[>1V/@\D78W:\9P@^J�UNO�U7_^_^8WJ1J1@BDW_`@B[UNO�>1V/@��.UNJLA��(< DC>1V/@*@BDZ>1<?J1@e_`UNJ1FI8W[HNDWA>1VW<E[.OQUNJL:e8WMEHe<E[�_^HNMEM?@BA�>1V/@)��@^Jh:�!/J1@BX78/@BDW_`b � ��DTjN@^Jh[#@4��U7_^8W:=@BDT> !/J1@BX78/@BDW_`b�qs��!���� !&t��.@B<?]aVZ>1<ED/]����O�_`Ua8/JL[#@Nm�HNMEM0>1VW@B[#@i>#@^JL: �.@B<?]aVZ>1<ED/]r[L_LV/@B:Y@B[ HKJ1@d[#Ua:=@��$VWHK>=V/@B8/Jh<E[#>1<E_G<E:YF;M?@B:Y@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaDW[ UNO�>1V/@

<EDZ>18W<?>1<?UaDd>1VWHK>�HNM?>1V/Ua8/]aV >1V/@eOgJ1@BX78/@BDW_`bCUNO�U7_^_^8/JLJ1@BDW_`@eUNO�H �.UNJLA,[#@^@B:=[�>#U�9 @e8W[#@^Os8WM�< D/OgUNJh:=HK>1<?UaDfm

<ED :lHNDTb [1<E>18WHK>1<?UaDW[Y>1VW@ <E:YFPUNJ1>1HNDI_`@CUNO4H �.UNJLAc<E[ D/UN>lJL@��I@B_`>#@BA�< D6>1V/@iOQJ1@BX78/@BDW_`b UNO4<?>1[l8I[1HK]N@!�

�@^jN@^J1>1V/@BM?@B[1[BmI>1V/@*:=Ua[#>[1< :YFIM?@)[1_hV/@B:Y@B[^m�q � �Ep t0HNDWA q � ��/athm VWH jN@��$< A/@48/>1<EME<E>kb HNDIAdVWH jN@*9P@^@BDCOQUa8WDWA

>#U�FWJ1U j7< A/@CH ]NUZU'A @BD/Ua8/]aV AW@B[1_`JL<?FW>1<EUaDrOQUNJ=>#@� '>=_^MEHN[1[1<SR;@^JL[eUNJl_^ME8W[#>#@^Jh<ED/] HNM?]NUNJL<?>1VW:l[ � [1@^@i@!� ]��

�SpNpNpamPp^o5�'mfpBn'pNm -Tn'm 4 �'mfp�/20��PHNDIA�HNM [#Ue_`UaDZ>1HN<EDGH [18/]N]N@B[#>1<EjN@�[1>1HK>1<E[#>1<E_^HNM ]N@BD/@^JLHK>1<EjN@�< DT>#@^J1FIJ1@^>1HK>1<?UaDGHN[

�$<EM M;9P@)A/@^>1HN<EME@BAi<EDd�7@B_`>1<?UaD � �

+�[1<ED/]e>1V/@�)� :YU'A/@BM m'<?>�<E[._^M?@BHKJ0>1VWHK>�>1V/@�J1@B[18WM?>1< D/]\AW< :Y@BDW[1<?UaDIHNME<?>kbeUNO�>1VW@�[#F;HN_`@�< [�@BDWUNJL:YUa8W[wq

UNO >1V/@�UNJLA/@^J�UNO >#@BDW[�UNO;>1V/Ua8I[1HNDWAW[�UNO ��UNJhAW[�����V/@^J1@0HKJ1@V/U �.@^jN@^J�H4_`Ua8WFIM?@�UNOf<EDT>18I<?>1<?jN@08WDW[18WF @^JLj7<E[1@BA

FWJ1@^FIJ1U7_`@B[L[1<ED/]�:Y@^>1V/U'AW[ �$VW<E_hVeFWJ1U j'<EA/@0[1< :YFIM?@��.H b7[�UNO;AW<E:=@BDW[1<?UaDWHNM <?>kb)J1@BAI8W_`>1<?UaDe9P@^OgUNJ1@�@B:YF;M?U b'<ED/]

HNDZb,UNO.>1V/@=:Y@^>1VWU7AW[4OgUNJ4>#@� '>*:=< DW<ED/]�� ��V/@B[#@ �<EMEM�9P@eJL@^j7<?@��.@BA <ED >1VW@=OgUaM M?U �$< D/]�[L8/9I[#@B_`>1<?UaDI[4HNDWA

VWH jN@)9 @^@BD�@B:YF;M?U bN@BAG<EDG[#Ua:Y@�UNO >1VW@�@� 'FP@^JL<E:Y@BDZ>1HNM [#@^>#>1<ED/]a[�J1@^FPUNJ1>#@BAG<ED >1V/@)MEHK>#@^J0_LVIHKFW>#@^JL[��&��D�>1V/@

_^HN[#@ �$V/@BDiM HK9 @BME@BAiA/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>$<EDW[#>1HNDI_`@B[$HKJ1@eHBjKHN<EMEHK9IM?@NmI>1V/@BDdH _`Ua:=:YUaD,HNDWAi@ � _^<E@BDT> �.H bCUNO�>#@^JL:

[#@BM?@B_`>1<EUaD�<E[�>#Ui_LV/U7Ua[#@=>1VW@e>#@^Jh:=[ �$VW< _LV VWHBjN@ :=H� '< :=HNM�� 8/>18IHNM�� D/OQUNJL:=HK>1<EUaD �1�20�� �$<?>1V,>1V/@=MEHK9P@BME[

�SpNpNpam.p^o5��� �,�dUNJ1@G[#UNFIVI<E[#>1<E_^HK>#@BA � �&��� � ��� � � �<�<����:Y@^>1V/U'AW[\HKJL@�HNME[1U HBjKHN<EMEHK9;M?@ <EDr>1V/@GME<?>#@^JLHK>18/JL@ �

-ao

Page 52: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

@!� ]�� �Sp^oanWm�p�0Nn'm�p�� ���(� V/U ��@^jN@^J�>1VW<E[�< [0HNDi@� '>#@BDW[1<?jN@*HKJL@BHYUNO�J1@B[#@BHKJL_hV �$VW< _LVC<E[0Ua8W> �$<?>1Vi>1V/@*[1_`UNFP@

UNO�>1VW<E[�>1V/@B[L<E[��

��� �� � � � � � � � ��� ���5" ����� � � � � ���/� ��� ��� � ���

6�� ��=�� � � � ( ����')(+*�,.- *�#�� ( � &:+

� >4VWHN[�9P@^@BD UN9I[#@^J1jN@BA �Sp��2����>1VWHK>4>1V/@^JL@ HKJL@=:=HNDTb �.UNJLAW[)<ED���D/]aME<E[1V$�$<?>1V D/Ui< DWV/@^J1@BDZ>>#UNF;<E_^HNM

_`UaDZ>#@BDT>��,��V/@B[#@�HKJ1@lOQUNJ*@� /HN:YFIM?@ FWJ1@^FPUa[1<?>1<EUaDW[^m�_`UaD��18WDW_`>1<EUaDW[*HNDWArFWJ1UaD/Ua8IDW[^m �VW<E_LV HKJ1@ 8I[#@BA OQUNJ

FWJ1U j7< AW<ED/] _`UaDT>1< DZ8W<E>kbCHNDWAC]NJLHN:l:=HK>1<E_^HNM [#>#Jh8W_`>18/J1@4<EDdMEHND/]a8WHK]N@4JhHK>1V/@^J�>1VWHNDi_`UaDZ>#@BDZ>��.��VW@B[#@ ��UNJhAW[

_^HND�9P@$@BME<E:l<EDWHK>#@BA=OQJ1Ua: >1V/@ ��UNJLAG[#F;HN_`@ �.@�< DT>#@BDWA >#UY8W[#@OgUNJ�J1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>1< D/]*>1V/@�A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>�jN@B_`>#UNJL[Bm

HN[�>1V/@^b���Ua8IMEAe9 @�UNOPME<?>#>1M?@�8W[#@0<ED _^ME8I[#>#@^JL<ED/]�UNJ&_^MEHN[1[L<?Ogb'<ED/]�A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[��&�'8W_LV)�.UNJLAW[�HKJL@.>#@^Jh:Y@BA0���B���

iw� �+�'� �e��V/@eJ1@B:YU j HNM�UNO.HlFWJL@BA/@`R;D/@BA,ME<E[#>UNO�[#>#UNF �.UNJLAW[�_`UaDW[L<E[#>1<ED/] UNO�[#@^jN@^JhHNM�V78WDWAWJ1@BAW[UNO ��UNJhAW[

qQ@!� ]�� � H �?m � HK9IM?@ �?m � HK9PUa8/>��?m � @BM [#@ �?m � >1V/@ �?m � UNO��?m;@^>1_ � tY<E[0Hl_`Ua:=:YUaDiFIJLHN_`>1<E_`@*<EDG��D/OQUNJL:=HK>1<?UaDC $@^>#JL<?@^jKHNM �

6�� ��=�� � � � #�� � �=��>

HK>1V/@^J�>1VWHNDiAW@`R;DW<ED/]e>#@^JL:=[$HN[�AW<E[#>1< DW_`>��.UNJLAW[ �$VW<E_hVGU7_^_^8/J�< DG>1V/@4_`UNJ1FI8W[BmW[#Ua:Y@)UNO�>1V/@ ��UNJhAW[

�$VW< _LV�A/@^JL<?jN@OgJ1Ua: He_`Ua:=:YUaD�J1U7UN>�q���� ����t�_^HNDG9P@$JL@BAW8W_`@BA >#UeUaDW@�[#b':\9 UaM � !WUNJ.@� /HN:YFIME@Nm � _`Ua:=FI8��

>1HK>1<?UaD(�?m � _`Ua:=FI8/>1<ED/] �KHNDWA � _`Ua:YFI8/>#@^J � A/@^Jh<[email protected] MTOQJ1Ua: >1V/@.[1>#@B: � _`Ua:YFI8/>�� ����V/@�[#>#@B:=:=< D/]HNM?]NUNJh<?>1VW:

A/@^jN@BM?UNFP@BA 9Zbi!�UNJ1>#@^J �Sp�� ����_^HND,9P@*@ � _^<E@BDT>1M?b 8/>1<EME< %^@BAi>#U J1@^F;MEHN_`@��.UNJLAW[97bd[#>#@B:=[����ME>1V/Ua8/]aV >1VW<E[

J1@BAW8I_`@B[0>1V/@*AW< :Y@BDW[1<?UaDIHNME<?>kbYUNO�>1V/@)UN9;[#@^J1jKHK>1<?UaDi[#FIHN_`@Nm <?>�<E[0HNME[1U ��UNJ1>1V D/UN>1<ED/]Y>1VIHK>$[#>#@B:=:=< D/]YVWHN[

9P@^@BDCOQUa8WDWAG>#U=J1@BAI8W_`@)FP@^J1OgUNJh:=HNDW_`@4<EDC[#Ua:=@)@� 7FP@^JL<E:=@BDT>1HNMf@^jKHNME8WHK>1<EUaDW[ �SpNpNp � �

6�� ��=�� 6 � � �?@ n - +<&&'

��U Os8/J1>1VW@^JJ1@BAI8W_`@\>1VW@eAW< :Y@BDW[1<?UaDIHNME<?>kb�UNO&>1V/@ A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>jN@B_`>#UNJh[^m HND/UN>1V/@^J)_`Ua:=:YUaD,>#@B_hVWDW<EX78/@

<E[Y>#U J1@^>1HN<ED6UaDIM?b �.UNJLAW[ �$VW<E_hV U7_^_^8WJ :YUNJ1@d>1<E:Y@B[=>1VIHNDcH�FWJL@BA/@`R;D/@BA >1V/JL@B[1V/UaMEA��c� D �Sp�� � � m�>1VW<E[

>1V/J1@B[LV/UaMEA �.HN[l[#@^>Y>#U p^o'm�9;HN[#@BA UaD [#Ua:Y@GFWJL@BME<E:=<EDIHKJ1b�@� 7FP@^JL< :Y@BDT>1HK>1<EUaD�� ��VW@�@� 'FIMEHNDIHK>1<?UaD �$VTb

>1VW<E[*_^HNDr9P@=A/UaD/@lJ1@B[1<EA/@B[*<ED�>1V/@�[#Ud_^HNMEM?@BA DP<?FWO�� [)M H � �Sp�0KoIm�p�� �����$VW<E_hV _`UaDW[1<E[1>1[4UNO�>1V/@=OQUaMEM?U �$<ED/]

UN9I[#@^JLj HK>1<?UaD�����@BD/UN>1<ED/]l9Zb � >1V/@*D78W:\9P@^J�UNO�>1<E:Y@B[�>1VW@4>#@^JL:���VWHN[�HKFIF @BHKJL@BAd<EDCH _`UNJ1FI8W[�HNDIAC9Zb� � >1V/@4<EDWAW@� =UNO�>1V/@�>#@^JL:�� < D�AW@B[1_`@BDWAW<EDW]*UNJLA/@^Jh<ED/]eUNO�>1V/@�>#@^JL:=[�9;HN[#@BA�UaDG>1V/@B<?J�OgJL@BXZ8/@BDI_`b=j HNM 8/@B[^m>1V/@BD

� � � � � �� � � � q � ��0at

-Wp

Page 53: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

�7>1HKJ1>1< D/]OQJ1Ua: >1VW<E[�UN9I[#@^J1jKHK>1<?UaDfma[L<E:YFIM?@�_^HNME_^8WME8W[ �Sp�� ���/FWJ1U j7< A/@B[�@^j'<EA/@BDI_`@�>1VWHK>�H�[1<?]aDW<?R;_^HNDT>�OgJhHN_`>1<?UaD

UNO�>1VW@�AI<E[#>1<EDW_`>�>#@^JL:=[0<EDGH _`UNJ1FI8I[.HKJL@4:=HNA/@)8/F�9Zb >1V/@):YUa[#>�<ED/OQJ1@BX78/@BDZ>1M?b U7_^_^8/JLJL<ED/]e>#@^JL:=[��&�$V/@B[#@

_^HNDi9P@�@BME<E:l<EDWHK>#@BA �$<?>1VWUa8/>0HNDTbC[1<?]aDI<SR;_^HNDZ>�MEUa[1[0UNO�<ED/OQUNJL:=HK>1<?UaD �Sp�� � � �

��D >1V/@ J1@B:=HN<EDIA/@^JUNO.>1VW<E[�_hVWHKFW>#@^JBm 9;HN[1<E_e[#>1HK>#@�� UNO � >1VW@��kHKJ1>\>#@B_hVWDW<EX78/@B[ � J1@BM?@^jKHNDZ>)>#UC>1V/@)��UNJ��

FWJ1@B[1@BDT>#@BA <EDG>1VW<E[0>1VW@B[1<E[�� �$VW<E_hViHKJ1@49IHN[1@BAiUaDC>1V/@\<EA/@BHYUNO�MEHK>#@BDZ>$jKHKJL<EHK9IME@�:=U7A/@BM ME<ED/] UNO�>#@� 7>�HKJ1@

J1@^j'<?@��.@BA�����HN_LV UNO>1V/@B[#@C:YU'A/@BME[\>1H �N@C>1V/@GA/U7_^8I:Y@BDT>1[eJ1@^FIJ1@B[#@BDZ>#@BA6<EDr>1VW@ �.UNJLAW[CqQ>#@^JL:=[ t*[1FIHN_`@

HN[\FWJ1U j'<EA/@BA <ED HN� �&���A� �;� � ����������G:=HK>#Jh< HNDWA [1@BHKJL_LV OgUNJ Hd:=UNJ1@ HKFWFIJ1UNFWJL<EHK>#@Nm � _`UaDW_`@^FW>18IHNM �

J1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>1HK>1<EUaD��

� � � � ������ � ��� � ����� ���� ��� � ��� � � ��� �

��HK>#@BDT>l�7@B:=HNDZ>1<E_��DIHNM?b7[L<E[ qs���'��t)UNJY��HK>#@BDZ>=�'@B:=HNDT>1< _l��DWA/@� /<ED/]rqs���7�#t*<E[eHNDr@��P@B_`>1<?jN@CA/U'_^8��

:Y@BDZ>*J1@^FIJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaD :=@^>1V/U7A �$<?>1V H M?UaD/]i>#JhHNAW<?>1<?UaD < D�� DWOgUNJL:lHK>1<?UaDr $@^>#JL<?@^jKHNM �1�547m.pBn20'm�p�/�� �G� >1[

@��P@B_`>1<?jN@BD/@B[1[�J1@B[L<EA/@B[$< Dd>1V/@ _^HKFIHK9I< ME<?>kbG>#UCA/@BHNM.�$<?>1V [#Ua:Y@eUNO&>1V/@e>kb7FI<E_^HNM�FIV/@BD/Ua:=@BDWH=UNO�M HND/]a8WHK]N@

[18W_hVGHN[.[1b7D/UaDZb':*b � < � @!��AW< � @^J1@BDZ>�ME<?>#@^JLHNMI>#@^JL:=[��$<?>1V >1V/@�[1HN:Y@�:Y@BHNDW<ED/] � HNDWA F UaMEb7[#@B:\b � < � @!�

�.UNJLAW[ �<?>1Vr:e8WM?>1<?F;M?@Y:Y@BHNDW<ED/]��C��VW@B[#@=FIV/@BDWUa:Y@BDWH��.Ua8WMEA :=H �N@�H ME<?>#@^JLHNM�:=HK>1_LV 9IHN[#@BA J1@^>#JL<?@^jKHNM

<ED/@ ��_^<?@BDT>^m.V/U �.@^jN@^J�>1V/@i���7� m&HN[=<?>1[lDWHN:Y@i<EDWAI<E_^HK>#@B[^m�VIHN[ 9 @^@BDcA/@B:YUaDW[#>#JhHK>#@BA6>#U 9P@i_^HKFIHK9IM?@CUNO

J1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>1< D/]Y>1V/@4A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>�jN@B_`>#UNJL[�<EDCH=MEHK>#@BDZ>$[#@B:lHNDT>1<E_*[#FIHN_`@ �$VW@^J1@)>1V/@ � :Y@BHNDI<ED/] �/JLHK>1V/@^J$>1VWHND

>1V/@�ME<?>#@^JLHNM;OQUNJL: UNO >1V/@ ��UNJLAI[.< [�_^HKFW>18WJ1@BA��&��VW< [�[#FIHN_`@)<E[�OQUa8WDWA 9Zb=>1VW@����7��OgJLUa: >1VW@�HN[1[1U7_^<EHK>1<EUaDWHNM

qs_`UNJ1J1@BM HK>1<?UaDWHNMgt.<EDWOgUNJL:lHK>1<?UaDGFWJ1@B[#@BDZ>$<EDG>1VW@U� �&���v� �;� � ������%���\AIHK>1H=:=HK>#JL< �

��@B_LVWDI<E_^HNMEM?bNm�>1VW@,���7�=<E[G_`Ua:YFI8/>#@BA HN[CH >#JL8WDW_^HK>#@BA��7�� UNO\>1V/@,[1FIHKJL[#@ AWHK>1H :=HK>#JL< �(��VW<E[

_^HND 9P@ A/UaDW@,@ ��_^<?@BDT>1MEb OgUNJC[#F;HKJL[#@ :=HK>#JL<E_`@B[�97bc@B:YFIMEU b'<ED/]r>1VW@ ��HNDW_&%^Ua[CHNM?]NUNJL<E>1VW: �Sp�/ � �V/Ua[#@

_`Ua:YFI8W>1HK>1<?UaDWHNM&_`Ua[#>\[1_^HNM?@B[4ME< D/@BHKJLM?bd< D >1V/@=DZ8I:*9P@^J)UNO0D/UaD�� %^@^J1UC@BME@B:Y@BDT>1[\<ED >1V/@=AWHK>1H�� ��V/@Y���'�

J1@B_`UaDW[1>#JL8W_`>#@BAd_`UNJLFI8W[ � m �$V/@BD � [1< D/]a8WMEHKJ0jKHNME8/@B[0HKJ1@*J1@^>1HN<ED/@BAi< [�]a<?jN@BDdHN[

� � � ��� � � q � � 4Nt

�$V/@^JL@ � � � � � � _`UaDZ>1HN<EDW[l>1V/@CRIJh[#> � M?@^Og>l@B<?]N@BDTjN@B_`>#UNJh[,qsM?@^OQ>l[1< D/]a8WMEHKJ jN@B_`>#UNJL[hthm � � � � � �_`UaDZ>1HN<EDW[.>1V/@RIJL[#>[� JL<?]aVZ>�@B<E]N@BDTjN@B_`>#UNJL[\qQJL<?]aVZ>.[1< D/]a8WMEHKJ�jN@B_`>#UNJL[hthm � � � � � � <E[.HeAW<EHK]NUaDWHNMP:=HK>#JL< UNO�>1V/@ � [1<ED/]a8WM HKJejKHNME8/@B[ � �[ � � �fq�� t���� � m.>1V/@i[1<ED/]a8IMEHKJ j HNME8W@B[ OgUNJ � � HKJ1@iHNMEM0D/UaD�� %^@^J1U& �L"<�2 ��R��I����� ����%���[���/II�*)<���>A#����D �=) �"<� # )<MN�/��IJ1� ����/)��0�( �������+/1/�P�=�� ��(� 17 �A<���J:;"#��) ���RMO�(������)#. ��B19D<����A<I��)� ���/�=�����R ��=�/) F

-Tn

Page 54: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

qQFPUa[1<?>1<?jN@ t � !W8WJ1>1V/@^J � � � ��� � �\m �V/@^J1@ � <E[�>1V/@ � AW<E:Y@BDI[1<?UaDWHNM/<EAW@BDT>1<?> b=:=HK>#JL< ���.UN>1V>#@^JL:=[)HNDIA,AWU7_^8W:=@BDT>1[)HKJ1@ >1V/@BD FIJ1U���@B_`>#@BA�< DT>#UG>1V/@Y[#FIHN_`@Y[#F;HNDWD/@BA,9Zb >1V/@eRIJL[#> � ME@^Og>)HNDWA,JL<?]aVZ>[1<EDW]a8WMEHKJ0jN@B_`>#UNJL[^m _^HNMEM?@BA-��1 �A� �;� ���%�t���$�U���%�<� � �B��� � ���0� UNJ1@4FWJ1@B_^< [#@BM?bNm � _`UaDZ>1HN<EDW[�>1VW@4>#@^JL: jN@B_`>#UNJL[HNDWA � _`UaDZ>1HN<EDW[�>1V/@*A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>0jN@B_`>#UNJL[�<EDG>1V/@*MEHK>#@BDZ>$[#@B:lHNDT>1<E_*[#FIHN_`@!�

� >�_^HND 9P@$[1V/U �$Dl>1VIHK>�>1V/@J1@B_`UaDW[#>#JL8I_`>#@BA AWHK>1He:=HK>#JL< � � OQJ1Ua: >1VW@$@BM?@B:Y@BDZ>1[�UNOf>1V/@$>#JL8IDW_^HK>#@BA�7��(<E[�>1V/@)9P@B[#>�HKFWFWJLU /<E:=HK>1<?UaDG>#UY>1V/@)UNJh<?]a<EDWHNMPAWHK>1H=:lHK>#JL< �� OQUNJ$HNDTbG8WDW<E>1HKJL<EM?bl< DTjKHKJL<EHNDZ>0D/UNJL:�1�547m -C/�� mW< � @!�

:l<ED���

� � � � � � � � � � % � � � � � � � � % � � � � � ��� � � q � ���at

�$V/@^JL@ ��� � � AW@BD/UN>#@B[�>1VW@[1<EDW]a8WMEHKJ�jKHNME8/@$D78W:\9 @^J[��� p �&��V/@�>#Jh8WDW_^HK>1<?UaD HNDWAl<?>1[�_`UaDW[#@BX78/@BDW_`@>1VWHK>>1V/@=<EDI<?>1<EHNM�AIHK>1HC:=HK>#JL< _^HNDWD/UN>)9P@e< A/@BDT>1< _^HNMEM?biJ1@B_`UaDI[#>#JL8W_`>#@BA�HNDZb7:=UNJ1@=<E[�>1V/@Y_`UNJ1@YOQ@BHK>18/J1@YUNO.>1V/@

���'��>#@B_LVWDI<EXZ8W@Nm HN[)>1V/@ >#JL8WDW_^HK>#@BAr�'�� _^HKFW>18/J1@B[):=Ua[#>)UNO�>1V/@Y<E:=F UNJL>1HNDT>)8WDWAW@^JLM?b'<ED/]l[#>#Jh8W_`>18/J1@ <ED

>1V/@ HN[1[#U'_^<EHK>1<?UaDW[�UNO&>#@^Jh:=[HNDIA,AWU7_^8W:=@BDT>1[^m bN@^>)HK>�>1V/@e[LHN:Y@\>1< :Y@\<?>�J1@B:YU jN@B[�>1V/@ � D/Ua<E[#@ �?mf< � @!��>1V/@

jKHKJL<EHK9I<EM <?>kbl< DG>1V/@ �.UNJLAi8W[1HK]N@ �1�547m�p�/�� �&��DZ>18W<?>1<?jN@BM?bNm/[1< DW_`@)>1V/@*D78W:\9 @^J0UNO�AW<E:=@BDW[1<?UaDW[3� <E[0[1:lHNMEM?@^J>1VWHND�>1VIHK>*UNO.>1V/@=>#@^JL:=[\[#FIHN_`@Nm�:=<ED/UNJ4AW< � @^J1@BDI_`@B[4<ED�>#@^JL:l<ED/UaM?UN]Nb �$<EMEM�9P@Y<?]aD/UNJ1@BA��l��@^Jh:=[ �$VW< _LV

U'_^_^8/J�< Dd[1<E:l<EMEHKJ$A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[�HKJ1@\D/@BHKJ�>#U�@BHN_LV,UN>1V/@^J)<EDd>1V/@\MEHK>#@BDZ>�[#@B:=HNDZ>1<E_\[1FIHN_`@GqQ@!� ]�� � _^HKJ �fHNDWA

� HN8/>#Ua:YUN9;<EM?@ � t �

� >*<E[*>#Ud9P@=D/UN>#@BA >1VWHK>49P@B_^HN8W[#@ >1V/@=>#JL8WDI_^HK>#@BA �7�� [#FIHN_`@�<E[4<EDZj HKJh<EHNDT>\8WDWA/@^J)J1UN>1HK>1<EUaDW[^m�UaD/@

_^HNDWD/UN>C@� 'FP@B_`>iHNDTb <EDZ>#@^J1FWJ1@^>1HK9IME@,[#>#Jh8W_`>18/J1@ >#U69P@ @BDW_`U7AW@BA < D�>1VW@ <EDWAW<?j'<EAW8IHNM0[1<ED/]a8WM HKJ jN@B_`>#UNJL[

>1V/@B:=[1@BM?jN@B[���� DW[1>#@BHNAfm <E>�<E[f>1V/@._^HKFIHK9I<EM <?>kb�UNO/>1V/@�:Y@^>1VWU7A*>#U$FWJ1@B[1@^J1jN@�>1V/@�J1@BMEHK>1<?jN@.[#@B:=HNDZ>1<E_&AW<E[1>1HNDW_`@B[

9P@^> �.@^@BDr>1VW@ A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[*HNDWA ��UNJhAW[*<ED >1V/@ ����[#FIHN_`@ �$VW<E_hV :=H �N@B[ ���'��HND HKFWFWJ1UNFIJL<EHK>#@=>#U7UaM&OQUNJ

X78/@^J1b � 9IHN[#@BAC��D/OQUNJL:=HK>1<?UaDC $@^>#JL<?@^jKHNM �

"�VWUZUa[1< D/]�>1V/@�MEHK>#@BDZ>�AW<E:Y@BDI[1<?UaDWHNME<E>kbB� <EDY���7��<E[�HNDl<EDT>#@^JL@B[#>1<ED/])FWJLUN9IM?@B:CmaHN[%� [1VWUa8WMEAe9P@�MEHKJ1]N@@BD/Ua8/]aV�>#U _^HKFW>18/J1@�>1V/@�<E:YFPUNJ1>1HNDZ>�<EDWOgUNJL:lHK>1<?UaD=9I8W>.[1:lHNMEMW@BD/Ua8W]aV >#U\R;M?>#@^J.>1V/@�[#@B:=HNDZ>1<E_�D/Ua<E[#@�HNDWA

>#U,@BDWHK9IM?@ OQHN[#> [18/9;[#@BXZ8W@BDT>4UNFP@^JLHK>1<EUaDW[��i��D �1�54�� m�H,[18W<E>1HK9IM?@lD78W:\9 @^J � 9P@^> �.@^@BD 4 o HNDWA p^oNo,VWHN[9P@^@BDC@� 'F @^Jh<E:Y@BDZ>1HNMEM?b�OgUa8WDIACOgUNJ�H=AWHK>1HK9IHN[1@*UNO&:Y@BAW< _^HNM HK9I[#>#JLHN_`>1[ �.��D �SpBn20 ��<?>$<E[[1V/U �$DC>1VWHK> �$V/@BD

�.@iVWHBjN@iFIJL<?UNJ �7D/U �$M?@BA/]N@C>1VIHK>Y>1V/@i_`UNJ1FI8W[ VWHN[lH jN@^J1b _^M?@BHKJ m�[#@^FIHKJhHK9IM?@C_^MEHN[1[=[1>#JL8W_`>18/J1@CHNDWA �.@

�'D/U � >1V/@\D78W:\9P@^J$UNO&_^MEHN[1[1@B[^mI>1V/@BD,<?>$< [�@BD/Ua8/]aV >#U [1@^>�� >#U�>1V/@\D78W:\9P@^J$UNO&_^MEHN[1[1@B[HNDWAd>1V/@\_^M HN[1[[#>#JL8I_`>18/J1@)UNO�>1V/@*_`UNJ1FI8I[ �$<EMEM;9P@)FWJ1@B[#@^JLjN@BAi<EDG>1V/@*MEU �-AW< :Y@BDW[1<?UaDIHNM;[#F;HN_`@ �$<?>1VCVW<E]aVGFWJ1UN9IHK9I< ME<?>kb!�

-C�

Page 55: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

� ��� � � �������� � � � ��� � ��� � �����".UaDI[1<EA/@^JY>1V/@C>1HN[�� UNO�>#@� '> _^MEHN[1[L<SR;_^HK>1<?UaD UNJl_^M 8W[#>#@^JL<EDW] < D6H��.H bN@B[1<EHND�OgJhHN:Y@���UNJ�� � ��VI<E[YHKF��

FWJ1UaHN_hV HN[L[18W:Y@B[�>1VWHK>�>1VW@A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[�UNOf>1VW@_`UNJ1FI8I[ �.@^J1@$]N@BD/@^JhHK>#@BA OQJ1Ua: H\:=< 7>18/JL@0UNO [#@^jN@^JLHNM�qs3\t

FIHKJLHN:=@^>#JL<E_)AW<E[1>#JL<?9I8/>1<EUaDW[�� !WUNJ$>1V/@ � >1VdA/U7_^8I:Y@BDT>^m/>1VI<E[0_^HNDi9P@ ��JL<E>#>#@BDCHN[

��q� � � �Ct ��� �� ��q� � � � � � �Kt��lq��Wt q � � �at

�$V/@^JL@ � � � � � � p / � �\HKJ1@\AW<E[ �#Ua<EDZ>.F;HKJLHN:Y@^>#@^JL[0OQUNJ$@BHN_hVd:=< 7>18/JL@�_`Ua:=F UaDW@BDT>��.��HN_LVdUNO�>1VW@B[#@_`Ua:YFPUaD/@BDZ>�AW<E[#>#Jh<?9I8/>1<?UaDI[ ��q��� � � � � � t._^HNDfmW<EDG>18WJLDfm'9P@j'<?@��.@BAiHN[�>1V/@)FWJL< :=HKJ1b=]N@BD/@^JhHK>#UNJ�OgUNJ[#Ua:Y@[18/9;[#@^>)UNO0>1V/@lAWHK>1H��G��HN_hV [L8/9I[#@^>4_^HNDr>1V/@BD 9P@=<EDZ>#@^J1FWJ1@^>#@BA HN[*HC>#UNF;<E_=_^ME8W[1>#@^JBm�HN[\HNMEM&A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[

<ED >1VWHK>\_^ME8W[#>#@^J*HKJL@Y]N@BD/@^JLHK>#@BA OgJ1Ua: >1V/@=[1HN:Y@l:l< 7>18WJ1@Y_`Ua:YFPUaD/@BDT>��l� D�>1VW@=_^HN[#@=UNO0_^MEHN[1[1<?R;_^HK>1<?UaD

qs��HN<?jN@e��H bN@B[4_^MEHN[1[1<?RI@^JL[ �Sp^o5�/m�pNpNp �QthmP>1V/@ ��HBbN@B[�UNFW>1< :=HNM FIHKJhHN:Y@^>#@^JL[�HKJ1@e@B[#>1<E:=HK>#@BA 8W[1< D/]lMEHK9P@BM?@BA

A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[&HNDWAY>1VW@B[#@�FIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^JL[&HKJ1@$8I[#@BAYOQUNJ�<ED/OQ@^J1JL<EDW]�MEHK9P@BME[�OQUNJ�8WDW[1@^@BD=A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[���� D >1V/@_^HN[#@

UNO�_^M 8W[#>#@^JL<EDW] qs�8W>#UZ"�MEHN[1[ �1�Nn��Qthmf>1VW@e_^MEHN[L[ � j HKJh<EHK9IM?@ <E[�VW<EAWA/@BD HNDWA,>1V/@ ��� HNME]NUNJL<?>1VW: <E[�@B:YFIM?U bN@BA

OQUNJ$:=H� /<E:=< %B<EDW]e>1VW@4M?UN] �kME< �N@BME< V/UZU'AGM?UN] ��q�� � � t�_`UaDWAI<?>1<?UaD/@BAGUaDC>1VW@4:YU7AW@BM � �

��� �� � ����� ��� ��� ���� ��� ! ����"�� ��

��VW@\��HN<?jN@\��HBbN@B[):=U7A/@BM�<E[�H=FWJ1UN9;HK9I<EME<E[1>1<E_�:YU7AW@BM mIDWHN:Y@BMEbiHl[1<E:=FIM?@4��HBbN@B[1< HND,DW@^> �.UNJ�� �$VW< _LV

[1<?]aDI<SR;_^HNDZ>1M?b=FWJ1@BAIHK>#@B[0>1V/@4A/@^jN@BM?UNF;:Y@BDT>0UNO���HBbN@B[1< HNDdD/@^> ��UNJ��'[09I8W>�< [0[#>1<EMEM �$<EA/@BMEbl8W[#@BA �Sp�� � � �&��V/@

[1<E:=FIME<SR;_^HK>1<EUaDC_`UaDW[1<E[#>1[UNO&>1V/@ HN[1[18I:YFW>1<?UaDd>1VWHK>>1VW@*OQ@BHK>18/J1@B[�HKJ1@ _`UaDWAW<?>1<?UaDIHNMEM?bG<EDWA/@^FP@BDWA/@BDZ>0OQJ1Ua:

@BHN_LViUN>1V/@^J�]a<?jN@BDG>1V/@)_^MEHN[L[�j HKJL< HK9IM?@!����V/@�_^MEHN[1[�jKHKJL<EHK9IME@�_^HNDG9P@�UN9I[#@^J1jN@BAGUNJ�VI<EAWA/@BD � A/@^FP@BDWAW<ED/]

UaDC>1V/@\_^MEHN[1[1<SR _^HK>1<?UaDGUNJ_^ME8I[#>#@^JL<ED/]e>1HN[�� �

��D >1V/@�>#@� '>dA/Ua:=HN<ED m<?>CVWHN[C9P@^@BD D/UN>1< _`@BA >1VWHK>^m4<ED [#FI<?>#@ UNOe>1V/@�OsHN_`>C>1VWHK>i>1V/@ _`UaDWAI<?>1<?UaDWHNM

<EDWAW@^F @BDIA/@BDW_`@ HN[L[18W:YFW>1<EUaD�UNO\>1V/@ :YU'A/@BM�<E[C_^M?@BHKJLMEbc8WDZ>#JL8/@�<ED J1@BHNME<?> bNm>1VW@ �HN<?jN@ ��H bN@B[d:YU'A/@BM

FP@^J1OQUNJL:=[)jN@^J1b�@��P@B_`>1<?jN@BM?b <EDr[18WF @^JLj7<E[1@BA�_^MEHN[1[1<SR _^HK>1<?UaD��"!/UNJ _^ME8W[#>#@^JL< D/]d<ED�>18WJLDfm�>1V/@ [1HN:=@ :YU'A/@BM

VWHN[�UNOQ>#@BD 9 @^@BD=OgUa8WDIAY:\8W_hVlM?@B[L[�@�� @B_`>1<EjN@ �Sp�� ��� ����DY>1V/@�OQUaMEM?U �$<ED/])[18W9I[#@B_`>1<?UaDW[&> �.U\AW< �P@^J1@BDZ>&:YU'A/@BME[

�$<EM M�9P@iA/@B[1_`Jh<?9P@BA �VW<E_LV 9PUN>1V6HKJ1@d>#@^JL:Y@BA ��HN<?jN@d��HBbN@B[�:YU'A/@BME[ �SpNpNp � � �$V/@iAW< �P@^J1@BDW_`@C_`UaDW[1< [#>1[

UNO&>1V/@eHN[1[18W:=@BA 8WDIA/@^JLM?b'<ED/]Y[#>1HK>1<E[1>1<E_^HNM�]N@BDW@^JLHK>1<?UaD :YU'A/@BM UNO�H A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>^m;UNJBm @BX78W<?jKHNM?@BDT>1MEbNm <EDd>1V/@

HN[1[18I:Y@BA OgUNJh: OgUNJ ��q��� � �Wt �l�$VW<E[�<E[)A/@`R;DW@BA 9Zb,>1V/@Y>kb7FP@=UNO)qQ9I<EDWHKJ1b UNJ4OQJ1@BXZ8W@BDW_`b _`Ua8WDZ>1[49;HN[#@BA;t_`U'AW<ED/])UNOP>1V/@�A/U7_^8I:Y@BDT>1[�<ED >1V/@ ��UNJLAI[&[#FIHN_`@!����DWA/@^@BAfm7<?>&:=H bY9 @ �.UNJ1>1V�D/UN>1<ED/])>1VIHK>�<ED=_`UaDZ>#JLHN[#>�>#U

���'� �$VW< _LV �.HN[&9IHN[#@BA UaD >1V/@�7�� >#@B_LVWDI<EXZ8W@�HNDIAYVWHN[�9P@^@BDYD/UN>1<E_`@BA >#U)9P@�FWJLHN_`>1<E_^HNMEMEb\<EDW[1@BDW[1<?>1<?jN@�>#U

-2-

Page 56: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

>1V/@�>#@^Jh: ��@B<E]aVT>1<EDW]4@B:YFIM?U bN@BA �SpBn20�� m7<ED=H)FIJ1UN9IHK9I<EM <E[#>1<E_�:YU7AW@BM'>1V/@�>kb7FP@�UNOfAWHK>1H4VWHN[�<E:YFIME< _^HK>1<?UaDW[�<ED

>1V/@�jN@^J1b�OgUNJh:\8WM HK>1<?UaD�UNO�>1V/@4:YU'A/@BM ����[0<ED�>1V/@B[#@):YU'A/@BME[.>1V/@�UN9I[#@^JLj HK9IME@�AIHK>1HiqsA/U7_^8I:Y@BDT>�jN@B_`>#UNJL[ t

<E[)HN[1[L8W:Y@BA >#Ui9P@Ub �$� �&�+�#� ���=9Zb,>1V/@=8WDIA/@^JLM?b'<ED/] qQFPUa[1[L<?9IM?bdVI<EAWA/@BD;t�_^MEHN[1[ � jKHKJL<EHK9;M?@Nm >1V/@Y]N@BD/@^JhHK>1<?UaD

:YU'A/@BM/<E[&AI< � @^JL@BDT>�@!� ]���<EOI>1V/@$AWU7_^8W:=@BDT>1[&HKJL@$_`U7AW@BA=97b\9I< DWHKJ1b\< DWAW<E_^HK>#UNJL[�UNOPFWJL@B[#@BDW_`@�UNJ.HK9I[#@BDW_`@�UNO

>1V/@ �.UNJLAW[ � OQUNJL:e8WMEHiq � ��/at�UNJ$>1V/@ �.UNJLAdU7_^_^8/JLJ1@BDW_`@*_`Ua8WDZ>1[�� OgUNJh:\8WM Hdq � �Ep t �0��V/@B[#@4> ��U�_LV/Ua< _`@B[

HKJ1@*< DC8W[#@4<EDG>1V/@\�HN<?jN@\�.H bN@B[:=U7A/@BM [�UNO�>#@� '>^mIHN[A/@^>1HN<EM?@BAG9P@BM?U � �

6�� 6 �=�� � � # ���<� (�� � &:+ ��� , #�� # � , # � #0#*) (�, #,+ � � � ) �

��D >1V/@ ��<ED/Ua:=<EHNM��DWA/@^FP@BDWA/@BDW_`@,:YU'A/@BM mH A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>C<E[�J1@^FWJ1@B[1@BDT>#@BA 97b�H jN@B_`>#UNJiUNOe9I<EDIHKJ1b

HK>#>#JL<?9;8/>#@B[�<EDWAW<E_^HK>1< D/] �$VI<E_LV$��UNJhAW[�U7_^_^8/J)HNDWA �$VI<E_LV �.UNJLAW[�A/UGD/UN>�U7_^_^8/J)<ED H�A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>Yqs_`UNJLJ1@��

[#FPUaDWAW< D/] >#U >1V/@*>#@^JL: �.@B<?]aVZ>1<ED/] OgUNJL:e8WMEH q � ��/at#t �$�_^_`UNJhAW<ED/]aM?bNm;>1V/@\AWU7_^8W:=@BDT>�]N@BDW@^JLHK>1<?UaD FWJ1U'_`@B[1[

HN[1[18I:Y@BA 9Zb >1VW<E[ :YU'A/@BM�[#FP@B_^<SRI@B[\>1V/@CA/U7_^8I:Y@BDT> >#U�9P@�>1V/@C[#>1HK>1<E[#>1<E_^HNM � @^jN@BDZ>���HNDWA >1V/@GFWJL@B[#@BDW_`@

�GHK9I[1@BDW_`@lUNO �.UNJLAW[4HKJ1@ >1V/@lHK>#>#JL<E9I8/>#@B[)UNO�>1VW<E[4@^jN@BDT>��C��VW< [)A/@B[1_`JL<?9P@B[4HdAW<E[#>#JL<E9I8/>1<?UaD 9IHN[#@BArUaDrH

:e8WM?>1< � jKHKJL<EHK>#@���@^JhD/Ua8WMEME<&@^jN@BDT>Y:YU'A/@BM �i��VW@ DWHN<?jN@���HBbN@B[=HN[1[L8W:YFW>1<?UaD <E[*:lHNA/@ � �$VW< _LV OQUNJe>1VW<E[

_^HN[#@):Y@BHNDW[.>1VWHK>�>1V/@�HK>#>#JL<?9;8/>#@B[�HKJ1@�HN[L[18W:Y@BA�>#Ue9 @�<EDWAW@^F @BDIA/@BDT>�<?Of>1V/@�_^MEHN[1[�<E[��7D/U �$D�� < � @!��>1VWHK>

>1V/@iFIJ1UN9IHK9I<EM <?>kb UNO�@BHN_hV �.UNJLA U'_^_^8/J1Jh<ED/]�<ED H AWU7_^8W:=@BDT>l< [YHN[1[18W:Y@BA >#Ur9P@i<EDWA/@^FP@BDWAW@BDT> UNO�>1V/@

U'_^_^8/J1J1@BDW_`@*UNO�UN>1V/@^J ��UNJhAW[�<EDCHYA/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>��

��q��� � �Wt ������ ��q� � � � �Wt q � �Ep^oTt

�$V/@^JL@���q� � � � �Wt�HKJ1@*�.@^JLDWUa8WMEME<PAW<E[1>#JL<?9I8/>1<EUaDW[�/��q� � � � �Wt �lq � � �Wt � # q�p % �lq � � �Wt#t � � � # q � �EpNp t

HNDWA �lq � � �Wt�HKJL@�>1VW@FIHKJhHN:Y@^>#@^JL[�UNO >1V/@ � � >1VG]N@BD/@^JLHK>1< D/]e_`Ua:=F UaDW@BDT>^m/:Y@BHNDW< D/]*>1V/@�FWJLUN9IHK9I<EME<E>kbe>1VWHK>>1V/@�>#@^JL: DZ8I:*9P@^J ��OQJ1Ua: >1V/@�AW<E_`>1<?UaDWHKJLb=<E[�FIJ1@B[#@BDZ>�<ED�_^MEHN[1[ � �&�$UN>#@�>1VWHK>�HN_^_`UNJLAW< D/]\>#Ue>1VW<E[.:YU'A/@BM m>1V/@�FWJ1UN9;HK9I<EME<?> bYUNO�HYA/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>0<E[.>1V/@�FWJ1U'AW8W_`>.UNO�>1V/@)FIJ1UN9IHK9I<EM <?>1<?@B[�UNO�9PUN>1V >1VW@�U'_^_^8/J1Jh<ED/] HNDWAG>1V/@

D/UaD�� U'_^_^8/J1Jh<ED/])��UNJhAW[��

��VW@��.��� :YU'A/@BM�<E[ :YUNJ1@�>#JLHNAW<?>1<EUaDWHNM�<EDr>1VW@ R;@BMEArUNO���HBbN@B[1<EHNDcD/@^> �.UNJ��'[^m�HN[Y<?>Y_`UaDW[1< [#>1[eUNOH

[1<E:=FIM?@l��HBbN@B[L<EHND D/@^> ��UNJ�� VWH j7<EDW] UaDWMEb�>1V/@CA/@^FP@BDWA/@BDW_`@G_`UaDWD/@B_`>1<?UaDI[\9P@^> ��@^@BD >1V/@C_^MEHN[L[ � j HKJh<EHK9IM?@

HNDWAC>1VW@4AW< �P@^J1@BDT>�HK>#>#Jh<?9I8/>#@B[�HNDIAiD/U=_`UaDWD/@B_`>1<EUaDW[�9P@^> �.@^@BDi>1VW@4HK>#>#JL<?9I8/>#@B[ �

��HBj'<ED/]=[#@^>�8WF�>1VI<E[�:YU7AW@BM m'>1V/@�F Ua[1>#@^JL<?UNJ0FWJ1UN9;HK9I<EME<?>1<E@B[ �lq�� � � t�HKJ1@4<ED/OQ@^J1J1@BA 9ZbG��HBbN@B[��IJL8WM?@�<ED>1V/@�� �k[#>#@^F UNO HND ��� HNME]NUNJL<?>1VW: <EDY>1V/@�_^HN[#@$UNO _^ME8I[#>#@^JL<ED/]�����Dl_^MEHN[1[L<SR;_^HK>1<?UaDfmT>1V/@$>#JL8W@$A/@^>#@^JL:=< DW<E[#>1<E_

-C/

Page 57: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

jKHNME8/@B[YOQUNJl>1VW< [YXZ8WHNDZ>1<?> b HKJL@dA/@^>#@^JL:=< D/@BA697b >1VW@dMEHK9P@BME[��6��D69PUN>1V _^HN[#@B[^m�>1V/@ � ��! @B[1>1<E:=HK>#@dUNO

>1V/@ FIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^JL[eHKJ1@�>1V/@BDrDW@^@BA/@BAfm �$V/@^J1@ H [1:=UZUN>1VW< D/]iFWJL<EUNJ qQFWJL<E:l<ED/]G@BHN_LV �.UNJLA(� [eHK9I[#@BDW_`@GHNDWA

FWJ1@B[1@BDW_`@4_`Ua8WDZ> �$<?>1VCHYD78W:*9P@^J t�<E[�D/@B_`@B[L[1HKJ1bG>#U=HBjNUa<EAiFWJ1UN9IHK9I< ME<?>1<?@B[�UNO %^@^JLUYUNJ�UaD/@ �SpNpNpam �2��� �&��V/@

FIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^J8/FfAWHK>#@)HN_^_`UNJLAW< D/]=>#U=>1V/@ � ��HKFIMEHN_`@��k[1:=UZUN>1VW< D/] �I<E[ � �2� �Qt /

�lq � � �Wt � � � �� �� � � �lq�� � � t

n � � � �� �� �lq�� � � t q � �EpBnat

�$V/@^JL@ � <E[eHND HKJ19I<?>#JLHKJLb D78W:\9P@^J �i��V/@�8W[18WHNM&_hV/Ua<E_`@C<E[ � pKm&M?@BHNAI<ED/]i>#U,>1V/@ [1U,_^HNMEME@BA � MEH � UNO[18W_^_`@B[L[1<?UaD(�?m V/U ��@^jN@^J � p � � q �$V/@^J1@ � < [>1VW@ D78W:\9P@^J�UNO.A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[)<EDd>1VW@ _`UNJLFI8W[htVWHN[�9P@^@BDOQUa8WDWAG>#U=b'<?@BMEAC[18WF @^Jh<?UNJ0_^MEHN[1[1<SR _^HK>1<?UaDGJ1@B[18WME>1[0<EDG>1V/@*_^HN[#@*UNO���HN<?jN@*��H bN@B[_^MEHN[L[1<SRI@^JL[0< D � �2��� �

6�� 6 �=�� � � #�) !?+ �'�=� (�� � &A+ ) (�, # +

��Dd>1VW@e:e8WM?>1<EDWUa:=<EHNM @^jN@BDZ>):YU'A/@BM m >1V/@eHK9;[#>#JLHN_`>1<?UaD,UNO�H�A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>�<E[>1VWHK>�UNO�H � 9IHK]�UNO ��UNJhAW[��

HNDWA�H\AWU7_^8W:=@BDT>.<E[�HN[1[L8W:Y@BA >#U\9P@$]N@BDW@^JLHK>#@BAG9Zb=AWJLH �$< D/] � [1HN:=FIM?@B[ �<?>1V=J1@^F;MEHN_`@B:Y@BDZ>�OQJ1Ua: >1VW<E[9IHK]/m.�$V/@^J1@ � A/@BD/UN>#@B[*>1V/@=M?@BD/]N>1V�UNO.>1V/@lAWU7_^8W:=@BDT>��=��VW@ < DWAW<?j'<EAW8WHNM ��UNJhA�U7_^_^8WJ1J1@BDW_`@B[4HKJL@=>1V/@[#>1HK>1<E[1>1<E_^HNM�@^jN@BDZ>1[\<ED >1VI<E[�]N@BD/@^JLHK>1<?jN@ :YU7AW@BM �Y��V/@YUNJLA/@^J*UNO�>1V/@ �.UNJLAW[*<E[)HK]aHN<EDrMEUa[#>^m�V/U ��@^jN@^Je>1V/@

D78W:*9P@^J�UNOWU'_^_^8/J1J1@BDW_`@B[�UNOW@BHN_hV ��UNJhA\<ED\>1V/@�A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>�<E[�D/U �6_^HKFW>18WJ1@BA�����[1[#@BDZ>1<EHNMEMEbNmK< D4>1VW<E[�:YU'A/@BM m

@BHN_LV�AWU7_^8W:=@BDT>�<E[�J1@^FIJ1@B[#@BDZ>#@BA 97biH�VW<E[#>#UN]NJLHN: U jN@^J)>1VW@��.UNJLAW[����V/@\��HN<?jN@Y��HBbN@B[)HN[1[L8W:YFW>1<?UaD <E[

FWJ1@B[1@BDT>G<ED�>1VW<E[�:YU7AW@BM97bcHN[1[L8W:=<ED/] >1VWHK>�>1V/@ FWJ1UN9IHK9I< ME<?>kb UNO*H A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>G<E[ _`Ua:=FI8/>#@BA HN[G>1V/@

FWJ1U'AW8W_`>�UNO�>1V/@)FWJ1UN9;HK9I<EME<?>1<E@B[�UNO�HNMEMP>1V/@ �.UNJLAW[ �VW<E_LV�U'_^_^8/J$<EDG>1VW@4A/U7_^8I:Y@BDT>�����DCUN>1V/@^J ��UNJLAI[^m/>1V/@

<EDWAI<?j7< AW8WHNM/U'_^_^8/J1J1@BDI_`@B[0UNO�>1V/@ ��UNJhAW[0AW8/JL< D/]\>1VW@4_`J1@BHK>1<?UaDCUNO�HYA/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>�HKJ1@4HNMEMf_`UaDW[L<EA/@^J1@BAG>#U=9P@

<EDWAW@^F @BDIA/@BDT>$@^jN@BDT>1[)OQJ1Ua: @BHN_LV UN>1VW@^J �*��V/@e:\8IM?>1<ED/Ua:=< HNM�:YU'A/@BM�<E[�:YUNJ1@e>#JLHNAW<?>1<?UaDIHNM�<ED,[#>1HK>1<E[1>1<E_^HNM

MEHND/]a8IHK]N@4:YU7AW@BMEME<ED/]�����V/@)M?@BD/]N>1VGUNO�>1V/@)A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[0<E[0_`UaDW[1<EAW@^J1@BA�>#UY9 @�<EDWAW@^F @BDIA/@BDT>�UNO�>1VW@�_^M HN[1[��

��V/@*OgUNJL: UNO�UaDW@\:=< '>18/J1@)_`Ua:YFPUaD/@BDZ>^m;HN[Hl:e8WM?>1<EDWUa:=<EHNMP_`UaDWAW<?>1<EUaD/@BAGUaDi>1V/@eM?@BD/]N>1VCUNO�A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>

<E[�>1V78W[0>1V/@*OgUaMEMEU �$<EDW]��

��q��� � � � � � � t � q� �� � t � �� � �������

�lq � � � � � � t �� # � � � q � �Ep��at

�$V/@^JL@�>1V/@�FIHKJhHN:Y@^>#@^J �lq � � � � � � t�J1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>1[�>[email protected]<EM <?>kb)UNO ��UNJLA D78W:\9 @^J�� OQJ1Ua:(>1V/@0AW< _`>1<?UaDWHKJ1bNm<EDW[L<EA/@4>1V/@ _^MEHN[1[ � "��$VW@^J1@eo�� �lq � � � � � �Nt�� peHNDWA � � ���� �lq � � � � � � t p HNDWA,HKJ1@ @B[#>1<E:lHK>#@BA,8I[1<ED/]��HKF;MEHN_`@��k[1:YU7UN>1VW<ED/]=HN[

�lq � � � � � �Nt p � � �� �� � � ��q�� � ��'t

� � � � � � �� � �� �� � � � ��q�� � ��/t q � �Ep.-Zt

-C0

Page 58: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

�.UN>1Ve>1V/@B[#@.:YU7AW@BME[��$<EM MK9 @�J1@^j7< [1<?>#@BA*HNDIA4@B:YFIMEU bN@BAe<ED4H�9IJ1UaHNA/@^J�HNDWA*:YUNJL@�]N@BD/@^JLHNMTFWJ1UN9IHK9;<EME<E[#>1< _

OQJLHN:Y@��.UNJ���< DC>1V/@4D/@� '>$_LVIHKFW>#@^J ��� :=< '>18/J1@4:YU'A/@BM �$<E>1VCAW< �P@^J1@BDT>0FIJ1UNFP@^J1>1<?@B[0<E[0D/U ��J1@^j'<?@��.@BA��

��� � � � � � ����� ����"�� � � � �<"�� � " ��� " ��� � � � � ��� � � �G���� ��� � � � � � � ��� ���� � ����� � � ����� ��� � ��� ��!

!����'� VWHN[49P@^@BD�FIJ1UNFPUa[#@BA � 4 ����HN[\HiD/U jN@BM�FWJ1UN9;HK9I<EME<E[1>1<E_4>#U7UaM �$VI<E_LV J1@^OQUNJL:e8WMEHK>#@B[*>1V/@=<EA/@BHCUNO

���/�*m�< � @!��>1VIHK>*UNO�Hd[1b7:=:=@^>#JL<E_^HNM�AW@B_`Ua:YFPUa[1<?>1<?UaD�UNO�>1V/@!� �&���A� �;� � ����������GAWHK>1H :=HK>#JL< �G��V/@

:YU'A/@BM�HN[L[18W:Y@B[>1V/@ :\8WME>1<ED/Ua:=<EHNM�_`U7AW< D/]/m;< � @!�>1V/@ ��UNJLAI[$OQJ1@BX78/@BDW_`bi_`Ua8WDZ>1[�HKJ1@e< DWAW<E_^HK>#@BA�����[�>1V/@

UN9I[#@^JLj HK9IME@�AWHK>1HY< [�FPUa[1<E>1<?jN@NmZ>1VW@�AIHK>1HY:=HK>#JL< < [�JL@^]aHKJLA/@BACHN[0H _`U � U7_^_^8WJ1J1@BDW_`@)>1HK9IME@NmWHNDWAGHeAW@B_`Ua:)�

FPUa[1HK9IM?@Y:YU'A/@BM�<E[)RI>#>#@BA�>#Ui>1V/@ AWHK>1HrqQ>#@^JL:=[\HNDWA A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[4HKJ1@=:=U7A/@BME@BA HN[)9P@B<ED/]C<EDWAW@^F @BDIA/@BDT>

]a<?jN@BDiHlMEHK>#@BDT> � 9 UN>#>1ME@BD/@B_�� �IjKHKJL<EHK9IME@ t �&��V/@)M?UN] �kME< �N@BM <EV/U7U7A�UNO�!����'�-<E[ � 4 ���

� ��� ��

������ � ��M?UN]

��� �� �lq��Wt��lq � � �Wt��lq� �� �Wt q � �Ep�/at

�$V/@^JL@ �Y<E[&H4M HK>#@BDT>�j HKJL< HK9IM?@!��� DYUN>1VW@^J �.UNJLAW[^mZ>1V/@$X78WHNDT>1<E>kb >#U\:=H� /<E:=< %^@�<EDiq � �Ep�/at&< [�>1V/@$348IMEM?9IHN_��&�

� @B<E9IM?@^J�AW<EjN@^J1]N@BDW_`@$9P@^> ��@^@BD�>1V/@@B:YFI<?JL< _^HNM'FWJ1UN9IHK9I< ME<?>kbeFWJ1U j7< A/@BAY97bY>1V/@AWHK>1HeHNDWAl>1V/@:YU'A/@BMIFWJ1UN9��

HK9I<EM <?>kb � �$VW<E_hV VW@^J1@i<E[YH�:=< '>18/J1@�UNO�H 9I< � jKHKJL<EHK>#@COsHN_`>#UNJLHK9IM?@CFWJLUN9IHK9I<EME<E>kb�U jN@^J >1V/@iA/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[

HNDWA �.UNJLAW[�� ��VW@GAW@B_`Ua:YFPUa[1<?>1<?UaD <E:YFPUa[#@BA 9Zb >1V/@G:YU7AW@BM.< [eHNDIHNM?UN]NUa8W[Y<ED OgUNJh: >#U,>1VW@i�'�� /�9Zb

A/@BD/UN>1< D/]��� q �lq� �� �Wt#t � � �7m��8 q �lq � � �Wt#t � � �'m HNDWA�� �� � q � q��Wt#t�'m;>1V/@ �#Ua<EDT>$FWJ1UN9IHK9I< ME<?>kbG:YU'A/@BM� A/@B_`Ua:YFPUa[#@B[eHN[ � �� � �8 � �i��V/@�<E:YFIME< _^<?>�_`UaDI[#>#JLHN<EDZ>*>1VWHK>e>1V/@B[#@ @BM?@B:Y@BDZ>e:lHK>#JL<E_`@B[eHKJ1@ D/U �

qs_`UaDWAW<E>1<?UaDWHNMgt�FWJLUN9IHK9I<EME<E>kb=>1HK9IME@B[\qQFPUa[1<?>1<?jN@4HNDIAd[18W:l:=<ED/] >#U=UaD/@ t�<E[0>1V/@\:=HN<EDiAW< � @^J1@BDI_`@)OgJ1Ua: >1V/@

�7�� �I�Dd<?>#@^JLHK>1<?jN@*��� :=@^>1V/U7Ad<E[�>1V/@BDi8W[1@BACOgUNJ:=H� '< :=< %B<ED/]Cq � �Ep�/at � 4 ��� /

� ��[#>#@^F�/

�lq�� � � �1t �lq��Wt��lq� �� �Wt�� q � � �Wt� � � �lq���� t��lq� �� ��� t��lq � � ��� t q � �Ep�0at

� � [#>#@^F /

�lq � � �Wt � � � � �lq�� � � �1t� � � � � � � � �lq�� � � � � t q � �Ep 4Nt

�lq� � �Wt � � � � �lq�� � � �1t� � � � � � � � �lq�� � ��� �#t q � �Ep��at

� q��Wt �� � � �lq�� � � �1t�� � � � � � � q � �Ep �at

��V/@ [#@B:=HNDZ>1<E_dOsHN_`>#UNJL[GHKJ1@ >1V/@BD�< A/@BDT>1<?RI@BA697b �lq � � �WtYOgUNJ�@BHN_LV UNO)>1V/@ � p � ���� m$HNDWA �lq� �� �Wt_`UaDZ>1HN<EDW[�>1VW@)J1@BM?@^jKHNDW_`@B[\qs_`U7UNJLAW<EDIHK>#@B[ht�UNO�@BHN_LV,A/U7_^8I:Y@BDT> �<?>1VGJ1@B[#FP@B_`>0>#U=@BHN_hVdUNO�>1V/@B� OsHN_`>#UNJL[��

- 4

Page 59: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

� ��� � ����� � � �� ����� � ��� ����� ����� � ��� � � � � �!�

��VW@^J1@eVIHN[9P@^@BD H ]NJ1@BHK>4A/@BHNM�UNO�<EDZ>#@^J1@B[#>)AW8/Jh<ED/]=>1V/@ MEHN[#>�OQ@�� bN@BHKJL[�J1@^]aHKJLAW< D/]l>1V/@ >1V/@^UNJL@^>1<E_^HNM

A/@^jN@BM?UNF;:Y@BDT>1[$HNDWACHKFWFIME< _^HK>1<?UaDW[�UNO��1"�� q [1@^@)@!� ]�� �1�Ko�� OQUNJ�HY[18/J1jN@^b!�&�.@B[1<EAW@B[0<?>1[0:=HN<EDCHKFWF;ME<E_^HK>1<?UaD

>#Ui9IM <EDWA,[1<?]aDWHNM�[#@^F;HKJLHK>1<?UaDfm��#"�� � @^jN@BD <ED <?>1[)9IHN[1< _YME<ED/@BHKJ�OQUNJL:�� VWHN[49 @^@BDrA/@B:YUaDW[#>#JhHK>#@BA�>#U

9P@ H j HNM 8WHK9IM?@i>#U7UaMOgUNJCAWHK>1H HNDWHNM?b'[1<E[ � 47m�� �'m 0Ko/m �Ko�� � �'F @B_^< HNM�@B:YFIVIHN[1<E[=UNO)JL@B[#@BHKJL_LV VWHN[�9P@^@BD

_`UaDW_`@^JLDW@BA �$<?>1V >1V/@ HNDWHNMEb7[1< [ UNO DWHK>18/JhHNM)<E:=HK]N@B[ � H6A/Ua:lHN<ED <ED��$VW<E_hV �#"0� VWHN[G9P@^@BD OQUa8WDWA

>#UrJL@^jN@BHNM�9I<?UaMEUN]a<E_^HNMEM?b FIMEHN8W[1<E9IM?@�J1@^FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaDW[ [1<E:=< MEHKJ >#Ur>1V/Ua[#@ <ED6>1V/@iFIJL<E:=HKJ1b j7< [18WHNM0_`UNJ1>#@�

�SpBn2�/m �Ko/m�pNpNm&p^o -Im��Nn�� �\��HN[#@BA�UaD >1VI<E[�OQHN_`>^m�<EDWA/@� /<ED/]�HNDWA J1@^>#JL<?@^jKHNM�[#b'[#>#@B:=[)OQUNJ4<E:=HK]N@YAWHK>1HK9IHN[1@B[

VWH jN@l9P@^@BD A/@^jN@BM?UNFP@BA � n20 � � ��VW@Y@� 7FIMEUa[1<?jN@=]NJ1U ��>1V UNO0<EDWOgUNJL:lHK>1<?UaD�HBjKHN<EMEHK9IME@YUaD >1V/@=��UNJhMEA�� <EA/@

��@^9rVWHN[�9P@^@BD HC[#Ua8/JL_`@ UNO.<EDW_`J1@BHN[1< D/]�< DT>#@^J1@B[1>�OQUNJ)<EDZjN@B[#>1<?]aHK>1<ED/]G>1V/@ �1"�� :=U7A/@BM�OQUNJ�>1V/@YHNDWHNM?b'[1<E[

UNO�>#@� 7>$9IHN[#@BAiAWHK>1H �10547m �20�� �

��[CHND @� 7>#@BDW[L<?UaD UNO*>1V/@ <EA/@BHN[ �$VW< _LV���@^JL@,@B:=FIM?U bN@BA OQUNJC<E:=HK]N@�<EDWA/@� /<ED/] <ED � n20�� mH J1@B_`@BDZ>

FWJ1@BM <E:=<EDWHKJLb FIHKFP@^J �1054 � m0J1@^FPUNJ1>1[ HNDc<EDI_`J1@BHN[#@d<ED >1V/@dFP@^J1OQUNJL:=HNDW_`@CUNO)>#@� '> � 9IHN[#@BA�J1@^>#JL<E@^j HNM �$V/@BD

>1V/@e>#@� 7> ��HN[�J1@^FWJ1@B[1@BDT>#@BA6qs<EDWAW@� 7@BA;t09Zbd@B:YFIM?U b7<EDW] HND,�#"0� :YU'A/@BM ����V/@*UNJh<?]a<EDWHNM�D/@B8/JLHNM�D/@^> �.UNJ��

<E:YF;M?@B:Y@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaDiUNO �Sp�����VWHN[9P@^@BD 8W>1<EME< %^@BAi< Dd>1V/@e:Y@BDZ>1<?UaD/@BA [#>18WA/b!���V/@\VZb7F UN>1VW@B[1<E[UNO�>1VW<E[ ��UNJ��

<E[.>1VWHK> �.UNJLAW[�HKJ1@�]N@BD/@^JLHK>#@BAGOQJ1Ua: [#Ua:Y@)<EDWAW@^F @BDIA/@BDT>�_`UaDW_`@^FW>1[����$V/@]N@BDW@^JLHK>1<?UaDGFWJ1U'_`@B[1[�VWHN[�9P@^@BD

HN[1[18I:Y@BA H ME< D/@BHKJ�UaD/@)HNDWA�[#U H ME<ED/@BHKJ��#"���J1@^FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaD �Sp���� [1V/Ua8IMEAl8WDI_`U jN@^J0>1V/@B[#@�<EDWAW@^F @BDIA/@BDT>

_`UaDW_`@^FW>1[ ����D\>1V/@�ME<E]aVT>�UNO/>1VW<E[ ]N@BDW@^JLHK>1<?jN@0VTb7FPUN>1V/@B[1<E[�9P@B<ED/]�J1@BHNM <E[#>1<E_Km >1V/@BDeHND*�1"�� J1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>1HK>1<EUaD\UNO

>1V/@4A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[0[1V/Ua8IMEAlFIJ1U j'<EA/@�HY:\8I_LVC:YUNJ1@)FIJ1UaD/Ua8WDW_`@BAGAW< [1_`JL<E:=< DWHK>1<ED/]*_^HKF;HK9I<EME<?> b=>1VWHNDG>1V/@�4�

UNJ����7� J1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>1HK>1<EUaDW[^ma9P@B<ED/]�>1V/@^J1@^OQUNJ1@$:=UNJ1@0_`UaDTjN@BDW<E@BDT>&OQUNJ&AW<E[1>1HNDW_`@�� 9IHN[#@BA=< D/OgUNJh:=HK>1<?UaDeJ1@^>#JL<?@^jKHNM

OQJ1Ua: >#@� '>��

��D � �20�� mNHND\�#"0� HNME]NUNJL<?>1VW:-9IHN[#@BA\UaD*H$[L<E:=<EMEHKJ��#"�� >#JLHNDI[#OgUNJh:=HK>1<?UaD*:=U7A/@BMTUNO/>1V/@�4��JL@^FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>1H��

>1<?UaD VWHN[&9P@^@BD=FIJ1UNFPUa[#@BAYOQUNJ�>1V/@_^ME8W[#>#@^JL< D/])UNOf>#@� 7>.A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>�_`UaMEM?@B_`>1<EUaDW[�HNDWA <?>�<E[&J1@^FPUNJ1>#@BA=>1VWHK>.<ED

[#Ua:Y@$UNOf>1V/@�@� 'F @^Jh<E:Y@BDZ>1[&H4[#>#J1UaDW]*_`UNJ1J1@BMEHK>1<EUaD=9P@^> �.@^@BDlV78W:=HND MEHK9P@BME[�HNDWAY>1V/@$�#"�� J1@^FIJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaD

_^HNDi9P@�UN9I[#@^JLjN@BA��

� ��� � � ��� � � ����� � ��� � ���� � � � ��� ��� � � ��� � �

��VW@�<EAW@BHiUNO�>1V/@�� �����W��� FIJ1U���@B_`> � �54 �0<E[\>#U,_`JL@BHK>#@iH,n �k� J1@^FWJ1@B[1@BDT>1HK>1<?UaD OQUNJYH A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>

_`UNJ1FI8I[<ED$�$VW< _LV,D/@BHKJ197biM?U7_^HK>1<EUaDW[�J1@^FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>�[1<E:=<EM HKJ$A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[����$VW<E[�n �k� :=HKF _^HND 9P@\8W[1@BAdOQUNJ

-C�

Page 60: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

j'<E[18WHNME< [1<ED/]�HNDWA=@� 'FIM?UNJL< D/]�>1V/@�>#UNFI<E_^HNMI_`UaDT>#@BDZ>�UNOP>1V/@A/U7_^8I:Y@BDT>�_`UaMEM?@B_`>1<?UaD�����VI<E[�<E[&HN_hVW<?@^jN@BAl< DY>1V/@

� �����W��� 9ZbCHKFWF;M?b7< D/]\>1VW@\�7@BM?O&��J1]aHNDW< %B< D/]e�,HKF q �I��� t0HNM?]NUNJL<?>1VW: AW@^jN@BM?UNFP@BAC9ZbG3)UaV/UaDW@BD � �2/��

>#U=FWJLU���@B_`>1<EDW] AWU7_^8W:=@BDT>1[0OQJ1Ua: >1V/@)4��J1@^FIJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaDCUaDZ>#UlH=n �k�(]NJL<EAC:=HKF <EDGHY>#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVW<E_^HNM M?b

UNJ1]aHNDW< %^@BAi:=HNDWD/@^J �

��VW@ �W��� � �2/��\<E[CHND 8WDW[18/FP@^J1j'<E[#@BA D/@B8/JhHNM)D/@^> �.UNJ�� HKJL_LVI<?>#@B_`>18/J1@ �VW<E_LV VIHN[d<EDW<E>1<EHNMEM?b69P@^@BD

FWJ1UNFPUa[#@BA�HNDWA :YUN>1<?jKHK>#@BA�OQJ1Ua: 9I<?UaM?UN]a< _^HNM$_`UaDW[1< A/@^JLHK>1<?UaDW[ ��� �W��� :YU'A/@BM�_`UaDW[1<E[#>1[ UNO4H [#@^> UNO

D/U'A/@B[ ��� � � p�/Z� qQJ1@^OQ@^J1J1@BAi>#UGHN[ � D/@B8/J1UaDW[ � t0HKJ1JLHNDW]N@BA <EDdH=J1@^]a8WM HKJ]NJL< Ai<EDdH�n �k� [#F;HN_`@!�$��HN_hVD/U'A/@ VIHN[\HND HN[1[#U'_^<EHK>#@BA � �kAW<E:=@BDW[1<?UaDWHNM&J1@^Og@^JL@BDW_`@�� jN@B_`>#UNJ�� �&�,�$OQ>#@^Je< DW<?>1<EHNME< %B<ED/]G>1V/@B[#@ J1@^Og@^JL@BDW_`@

jN@B_`>#UNJL[JLHNDWA/Ua:lM?bNm'>1V/@4OQUaMEM?U �<ED/]Y<?>#@^JLHK>1<?jN@\HNM?]NUNJL<?>1VW: < [�@B:YFIM?U bN@BA q#q t�A/@BD/UN>#@B[0>1V/@\<?>#@^JLHK>1<?UaD;t /

� [1@BHKJL_LV OgUNJ�>1V/@*_^MEUa[#@B[#>$JL@^Og@^J1@BDI_`@*jN@B_`>#UNJ�>#U H AWHK>18W: FPUa<EDZ> ���qs<EDdH [1X78WHKJ1@BAiAW< [#>1HNDW_`@\[1@BDW[#@ tq�>1VW<E[ �$<EM M;9P@)>#@^JL:=@BAiHN[�>1V/@ � �<EDWD/@^J �

� � HKJL]a:=<ED�� � �� % � ��� � � � � � � q � � nKoTt

� 8WFPAIHK>#@�>1VW@�JL@^Og@^J1@BDI_`@)jN@B_`>#UNJL[$<ED�>1V/@4DW@B<?]aVT9PUNJLVWUZU'AlUNO�>1V/@ �$<EDID/@^J�>#U �.HKJhAW[0>1V/@4AWHK>18I: F Ua< DT>

�� ��� � / � ��� � � � ��� ��� � ��� q�� � � � t`q� � % � ��� � � � # t q � � n'p t

�$V/@^JL@�� ��� � qso �Bp t<E[0>1VW@\[#>#@^F [1< %^@GqQUNJ�M?@BHKJhDW<ED/]YJLHK>#@ t$HNDWA � ��� q t�<E[�>1V/@ � D/@B<E]aVT9PUNJLV/U7U'ACOQ8IDW_`>1<?UaD(�?m�$VW< _LV,<E[$FIJ1@��kA/@`R;D/@BA m HNDWA >kb7FI<E_^HNM M?bC>1H �N@B[�j HNM 8/@B[�9 @^> ��@^@BD�o�HNDWA pKm <E[�8WDW<E:YU'AWHNM m;[#b7:l:Y@^>#JL<E_eHNDWA

_`@BDZ>#@^J1@BAiUaD � �Im/@!� ]��.HNDd8WD��kD/UNJL:=HNME< %^@BA"�)HN8W[1[1<EHND��

��q�� � � �It @� 'F %q���� % ��� # t �n�� � q t � q � � nNnat

��V/@�<EDZ>#@BDWA/@BA @�� @B_`>�UNO >1V/@�D/@B<?]aVZ9PUNJLV/U7U7AlOQ8WDI_`>1<?UaDl<E[�>#Ue@BDW_`Ua8/JLHK]N@�>1V/@�J1@^OQ@^J1@BDW_`@�jN@B_`>#UNJL[�UNO�D/U'A/@B[

�$VW< [email protected]@BHKJ�@BHN_hV UN>1V/@^J�UaDe>1V/@.:lHKF mK>#U�HNME[1U9P@�DW@BHKJ�@BHN_hV UN>1V/@^J�<ED\>1V/@.AIHK>1H�[1FIHN_`@!���$V/@��<EA/>1V4UNO

>1V/@�D/@B<?]aVZ9 UNJhV/UZU'AYOs8WDW_`>1<?UaD=]NJLHNAW8WHNMEMEbeA/@B_`JL@BHN[#@B[.>#UeHNMEMEU ��AI< � @^JL@BDT>1<EHK>1<EUaD=9P@^> �.@^@BDl>1VW@D/@B<?]aVZ9PUNJL<ED/]

D/U'A/@B[�<EDG>1VW@4MEHK>#@^J[#>1HK]N@B[$UNO�>1V/@4HNM?]NUNJL<?>1VI:��

�'< :YFIM?@�V/@B8/JL<E[1>1<E_^[ HKJ1@i8/>1<EME< %^@BArOQUNJY>1V/@iA/@B_`J1@B:=@BDT>1<EDW] [1_LV/@BAI8WM?@B[eUNO�� ��� HNDWA �$<EA/>1V UNO � ��� q t ��@^jN@^J1>1V/@BM?@B[1[BmZ>1V/@)�W��� VWHN[�FWJ1U j7<EAW@BA=J1@BHN[#UaDIHK9IM?@�J1@B[L8WM?>1[�HNDIAlVWHN[�9P@^@BDl8/>1<EM < %^@BAY<EDlH��$<EA/@$JLHND/]N@$UNO

HKFWFIM <E_^HK>1<?UaDW[ � >1VW@\� �����W��� 9 @B< D/]lUaD/@eUNO&>1V/@ :=H �#UNJ)HKJ1@BHN[���� >1[�8W[1@^OQ8WM D/@B[1[�JL@B[1<EA/@B[<ED <E>$9P@B<ED/]

H=>#U7UaM��VW<E_LViU � @^JL[�H ��HBbCUNO�UNJL]aHNDW< %B<ED/]YFPUa[1[L<?9IM?b�VW<?]aViAW< :Y@BDW[1<?UaDIHNM AIHK>1H=UaD,Hln �k� MEHK>#>1< _`@Nm+�$VW< _LV

- �

Page 61: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

_^HNDC9P@)8W[#@BAG>#UY]N@BD/@^JhHK>#@*HNDi<EMEM 8W[#>#JLHK>1<?jN@]NJLHKFIVW< _^HNMfAW<E[#FIM HBb=UNO�>1V/@)AWHK>1H=[#@^>���� >�<E[�[1_^HNM HK9IM?@�OgUNJMEHKJ1]N@

AWHK>1HK9IHN[1@B[ HNDWA j HKJL<EUa8W[=[#FP@^@BAW8/F;[YHKJ1@iOs8/J1>1V/@^JYUN9W>1HN< D/@BA @!� ]�� 9Zb HNDc< DT>#@^JL:=@BAW<EHK>#@iFWJL@^FWJ1U'_`@B[1[1<ED/]

[#>1HK]N@ �$VI<E_LV J1@BAW8I_`@B[CAW<E:Y@BDW[L<?UaDWHNME<?> b UNO*>1V/@ 4��9ZbcH JhHNDWA/Ua: FWJ1U��#@B_`>1<?UaD >#@B_LVIDW<EX78/@ �1� ���4FWJL<?UNJ

>#U @BDT>#@^Jh<ED/] <EDT>#U >1V/@r�W��� HNME]NUNJL<?>1VW:�� ��VW@d� �����W��� VWHN[�9 @^@BD A/@B:YUaDI[#>#JLHK>#@BA >#U FWJ1U j'<EA/@ H

:Y@BHNDW< D/]NOQ8IMIA/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>0:=HKFGUNO jN@^J1b M HKJ1]N@�>#@� 7>0_`UNJ1FPUNJLH �$VW< _LV�HNME[#U OQHN_^< ME<?>1HK>#@�<ED/OQUNJL:=HK>1<?UaD J1@^>#JL<?@^jKHNM

97b @� 'FIM?UNJLHK>#UNJLbGAIHK>1H=HNDWHNM?b'[1<E[��

� ��� �� � ��� � ��� � ��� � � ��� � ���!���

��U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>4J1@^FWJ1@B[1@BDT>1HK>1<?UaD UNJ\<EDWA/@� /<ED/]�<E[)HND @� 7>#JL@B:Y@BM?b <E:YFPUNJ1>1HNDZ>�< [1[18/@e9P@B_^HN8W[#@=<?>)<E[�UaD/@YUNO

>1V/@ �N@^bG:YU7AI8WM?@B[�<EDGHNDC<ED/OQUNJL:=HK>1<?UaD J1@^>#JL<E@^j HNM&qQ�� �t�[#b'[#>#@B: <ED @B<?>1V/@^J�HY[1@BHKJL_LVCUNJ�He9WJLU �$[1< D/]\9;HN[#@BA

HKFWFWJLUaHN_LV����'< DW_`@0>1V/@$@� 'FIM?Ua[L<?jN@�]NJ1U ��>1VlUNOf>1VW@HN:YUa8WDZ>�UNO < D/OgUNJh:=HK>1<?UaD UaD >1V/@$��@^9 m7�� �VWHN[�9P@B_^HN:Y@

Hl_`@BDZ>#JLHNM�J1@B[#@BHKJL_hVdFWJLUN9IM?@B: HN:YUaDW]a[#>:=HNDZbCJ1@B[#@BHKJh_LV/@^JL[ ���$V/@*D/@^@BAdOgUNJ@ � _^<?@BDZ>HNDWAC>1VW@^UNJ1@^>1<E_^HNMEM?b

[#Ua8WDIAC:Y@^>1V/U'AW[�HNDWAC:YU'A/@BME[�OQUNJ�>1VW< [0FI8/J1FPUa[#@�<E[�HNDi@� 7>#J1@B:=@BM?b >1< :Y@BM?bl>#UNF;<E_�UNO�J1@B[#@BHKJL_hV��� �@B_`@BDZ>1M?b

A/@^jN@BM?UNFP@BA*F U ��@^JLOQ8WMZ:=HN_LVI<ED/@�ME@BHKJLDW<ED/]0>#@B_hVWDW<EX78/@B[�OgUNJ�>1V/@^UNJ1@^>1< _^HNMEM?b)FWJL< DW_^<?FIM?@BA�AWHK>1H�:YU'A/@BMEME< D/]0D/@^@BA

>#U)9P@.< DTjN@B[#>1<E]aHK>#@BAfmaFPUa[1[1<?9;M?b)HNAWHKFW>#@BAYHNDWAeOs8/J1>1V/@^J�A/@^jN@BM?UNFP@BAeOQUNJ�jKHKJL<?Ua8I[�[L8/9W>1HN[��'[�UNO;HND �� [#b'[#>#@B:Cm

[#>1HKJ1>1< D/]*OQJ1Ua: >1V/@$>#@� '>0A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>�J1@^FIJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaD���� >�<E[�>#U\9P@�D/UN>#@BA�>1VWHK>�>1VW@^J1@�< [�[#>1< MEMWHe]NJ1@BHK>�A/@BHNM

UNO�V/@B8/JL< [#>1<E_^[�<EDG>1VW<E[0AWUa:=HN<ED��

� >e< [\>#U 9P@lUN9;[#@^J1jN@BA @!� ]���>1VWHK> 9PUN>1V HKFIFIME<E_^HK>1<?UaDI[*UNO��1"�� >#U >#@� '>YAWHK>1H �10547m �20��0HN[L[18W:Y@�>1V/@

VZbZFP@^J19PUaME<E_,"�HN8W_LVZbcMEHK>#@BDZ>CAW<E[#>#Jh<?9I8/>1<?UaD��-�$U ��@^jN@^J m>1VW< [�HN[L[18W:YFW>1<EUaDc[1<E:=FIM?b6_`Ua:Y@B[GOQJ1Ua: UN>1V/@^J

HKFWFIM <E_^HK>1<?UaDeHKJ1@BHN[�UNO �#"��\mN[18W_hVYHN[�[1<?]aDWHNM'[#@^FIHKJhHK>1<?UaDfm!�$V/@^JL@.>1VW@�AW@BDW[1<?> b*UNOI>[email protected]<?]a<EDWHNM'8WD/UN9;[#@^J1jN@BA

[1<?]aDIHNM�[#Ua8/Jh_`@B[VWH jN@e< DWA/@^@BAi>1VI<E[$[#>1HK>1< [#>1<E_^HNM�FWJ1UNFP@^J1>kbGOQUNJ>1VW@e:YUa[1>DWHK>18/JhHNM�[#Ua8/Jh_`@e[1<E]aDWHNME[��0��[$OQUNJ

>1V/@Y<E:=HK]N@��k_`U'AW<EDW]GHKFIFIME<E_^HK>1<?UaDI[$>1V/@^JL@ < [�DWUGAI<?J1@B_`> �.H b >#UiHN[L[#@B[1[�>1V/@YAW<E[1>#JL<?9I8/>1<EUaDWHNMfFWJ1UNFP@^J1>1<E@B[UNO

>1V/@�_`Ua:YFPUaD/@BDT>1[�UNOf>1V/@�MEHK>#@BDT>�[#>#JL8I_`>18/J1@NmZVWU �.@^jN@^J�<?>1[�[#F;HKJL[#@BD/@B[1[�FWJ1UNFP@^J1> b < [ �'D/U �$D��&�'b7:=:=@^>#JL<E_^HNM

VW<?]aVIM?bCFP@BH �N@BA�MEHK>#@BDT>)A/@BDI[1<?>1<?@B[�VWHBjN@l9 @^@BD,UNOQ>#@BD�HN[1[18W:=@BA,< D >1VW@ < :=HK]N@Y_`U7AW< D/]�AWUa:=HN<ED �SpBn2�/m �Ko/m

pNpNm p^o -;m:�Nn�� �

�7FP@B_^<?OQb'<ED/]=H�_`@^J1>1HN<ED,MEHK>#@BDT>�FWJh<?UNJAW< [#>#JL<?9I8W>1<?UaDG:Y@BHNDW[�<EDiOsHN_`>�[#FP@B_^<?Ogb'<ED/] �$VWHK> �.@ HKJ1@eMEUZU!�'<ED/]

OQUNJ&<ED*>1VW@�AWHK>1H � < � @!��Ua8/J�FWJL<?UNJ�9P@BME<?@^OWHK9PUa8/>�>1V/@�[#>1HK>1<E[1>1<E_^HNM'DWHK>18/J1@�UNOI>1VW@�8ID/UN9I[#@^J1jN@BA jKHKJL<EHK9;M?@B[����

]N@BD/@^JLHNMIHKFWFWJ1UaHN_hV �.Ua8WMEA 9P@�>#U*:YU'A/@BM'>1V/@�MEHK>#@BDZ>&jKHKJL<EHK9IM?@0_`Ua:YFPUaD/@BDZ>1[�< DeH4FIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^JL< %^@BA=:=< '>18/J1@

OQUNJL:CmK@!� ]���>1V/@��dU � HNA/UNFI>#@BAe< D*>1V/@.� !7�c:YU7AW@BM ����VI<E[�V/U ��@^jN@^J ��Ua8WM A*J1@BX78W<?JL@�:\8I_LV _`Ua:YFI8/>1HK>1<EUaDWHNM

/Ko

Page 62: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

A/@B:=HNDIA HNDWA >1VW@=JL<E[��,UNO�UN9W>1HN<EDW< D/]iHNDr8WD ��HNDT>#@BA M?U7_^HNM M?b UNFI>1<E:=HNM&[#UaM 8/>1<?UaD <E[*HNM �.H b7[eHCFWJLUN9IM?@B:��

!&Jh<?UNJ �'D/U �$ME@BA/]N@*U jN@^J>1V/@\OgUNJh: UNO�>1V/@\HKFIFWJ1UNFWJL< HK>#@4MEHK>#@BDT>�A/@BDW[L<?>kb�OgUNJ�>1V/@4F;HKJ1>1<E_^8WMEHKJ_^HN[#@*UNO�>#@� '>

AWHK>1H �.Ua8WMEAe>1V/@^JL@^OgUNJ1@09P@�:e8W_LVY:=UNJ1@�A/@B[1<?JhHK9IM?@�HN[�>1V/@$:YU'A/@BM �.Ua8WMEA 9P@ �N@^FW>&[1<E:YF;M?@^J ���FWFWJLUNFWJL<EHK>#@��

D/@B[1[�<E[�8ID/OgUNJL>18WDWHK>#@BM?b ]N@BD/@^JLHNM M?bYAW<�� _^8WME>�>#UeHN[1[1@B[1[ �V/@BDl_`UaDW[L<EA/@^JL<EDW]4[#Ua:Y@VI<EAWA/@BDYjKHKJL<EHK9;M?@B[ �$VW< _LV

HKJ1@4@� 'FP@B_`>#@BAd>#U�A/@B[1_`JL<E9 @)[#Ua:=@\8WD/UN9;[#@^J1jKHK9IM?@�9I8/>$:=@BHNDW<ED/]NOs8WMP[#>#JL8W_`>18WJ1@*<EDC>1VW@*AWHK>1H��0��VWHK>$< [0>1V/@

J1@BHN[#UaD �VTb >1V/@=MEHK>#@BDZ>)FWJL<?UNJL[�HKJ1@=_hV/Ua[#@BD�[#Ua:Y@��VWHK>4HKJ19I<?>#JhHKJL<EM?bC<ED :=HNDZb,HKFIFIME<E_^HK>1<?UaDI[$UNO��#"�� >#U

AWHK>1H,:=<EDW< D/] � �20/m;054'm"4 � �d�$V/@^J1@^OQUNJ1@Nm�H,_LVIHNMEM?@BD/]a<EDW]iUN9��#@B_`>1<?jN@ UNO�:\b�J1@B[#@BHKJh_LV VWHN[\9 @^@BD A/@^JL<?j'<ED/]

>1VW<E[�<EDWOgUNJL:lHK>1<?UaD�OgUNJ0>1V/@)_^HN[#@*UNO�>#@� '>�AWHK>1H'mW97b 8/>1<EM < %B<ED/]*HNDZb�FWJL<?UNJ �'D/U �$ME@BA/]N@ ��@4:=H b�VIHBjN@4HK9PUa8/>

>1V/@YHN_`>18WHNM�AWHK>1HGHNDWA,>1V/@YHN_`>18WHNM�>1HN[�� <ED,UNJLA/@^J�>#UGUN9W>1HN<ED HG[1_^HNMEHK9;M?@YHNM?]NUNJL<?>1VW: >1VWHK>)J1@^jN@BHNM [)[#Ua:Y@

[#@B:=HNDZ>1<E_4[1>#JL8W_`>18/J1@)@BHN[L<EM?b 8IDWA/@^JL[#>1HNDIAWHK9IM?@�HNDWAi<EDZ>#@^J1FWJL@^>1HK9IM?@�9ZbCV78W:=HNDW[ �

��HK>18/JLHNMEMEb)@^jN@BD\>1VW@�UN9��#@B_`>1<?jN@�FWJ1UNFPUa[#@BA\HK9PU jN@�9P@B<ED/]$HN_hVW<?@^jN@BAYA/U7@B[�DWUN>�HK>�HNMEMZ]a8WHKJLHNDZ>#@^@�R DWAW<ED/]

>1V/@�UNFW>1<E:lHNM/:YU7AW@BMZOQUNJ�>#@� '>&HNDWHNM?b'[1<E[�����V/@0ME<ED/@BHKJh<?>kb)UNO >1V/@0:YU'A/@BM'<E[�H)XZ8W<E>#@�[1>#J1UaD/])HN[1[18W:=FW>1<?UaD HNDWA

D/UaD��kM <ED/@BHKJ�D/UaD�� ��HN8W[L[1<EHND MEHK>#@BDZ>�jKHKJL<EHK9;M?@\:YU'A/@BME[ �.Ua8WMEA,HNME[#UG9P@��.UNJ1>1V�<EDZjN@B[#>1<?]aHK>1< D/]��\��O�_`Ua8WJL[#@Nm

>1V/@eXZ8/@B[1>1<?UaDdU jN@^J�>1V/@*OQUNJL: UNO�>1V/@\D/UaDIME<ED/@BHKJL<E>kbG<E[$H�DWHK>18/JLHNM�UaD/@!�$� :YU'A/@BM�[1<E:=<EM HKJ0>#U >1V/@ ����� m

�$V/@^JL@C>1V/@dD/UaDWM <ED/@BHKJL<?> b VWHN[=>1V/@dAW<?JL@B_`>=_`UaDW[#@BX78/@BDW_`@dUNO):=H �'<ED/]�>1VW@d:YU'A/@BM0_^HKFIHK9IM?@dUNO�_`JL@BHK>1<ED/]

H >#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVW< _^HNM�JL@^FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaD UNO�>1V/@CAWHK>1H � H >#UNFI<E_G:=HKF <ED >1VW<E[Y_^HN[1@ � <ED H >1VW@^UNJ1@^>1<E_^HNMEM?b

FWJL< DW_^<?FIM?@BA ��HBblVIHN[�9P@^@BD FWJL<E:=HKJh<EM?b*>1VW@_LVWUa<E_`@�_`UaDI[1<EA/@^J1@BA <ED=>1VI<E[&>1V/@B[L<E[�����VW<E[�_LV/Ua<E_`@�<E[.:YUN>1<?jKHK>#@BA

97b=_`J1@BHK>1<ED/] H*>1VW@^UNJ1@^>1<E_^HNMEM?bYFIJL<EDW_^<?F;M?@BA HNM?>#@^JLDWHK>1<?jN@�>#U >1V/@:=UNJ1@�VW@B8/JL<E[#>1< _�� ���0�I��� �'� FIHKJL>1<E_^8WMEHKJ

OQU7_^8W[�UNO�< DT>#@^J1@B[1>�J1@^]aHKJLAW< D/]=>1VW<E[�>#UNF;<E_4<E[0>1H �'<ED/] <EDT>#U _`UaDW[1<EA/@^JhHK>1<?UaDC>1V/@*AI<E[1_`J1@^>#@4DWHK>18WJ1@4UNO�>1V/@44�

J1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>#@BAG>#@� '>0AWHK>1H HNDWAGA/@^jN@BM?UNFI< D/]eH [#>1HK>1< [#>1<E_^HNMEM?b HKFWFWJ1UNFWJh<EHK>#@:YU'A/@BM OQUNJ.9PUN>1V�>1V/@�9I<EDIHKJ1b=HNDWA

_`Ua8WDZ>&9IHN[#@BAl>#@� 7>�J1@^FWJ1@B[1@BDT>1HK>1<?UaDI[^ma@^jKHNME8WHK>1<ED/]\HNDWA=_`Ua:YFIHKJh<ED/])>1V/@B[#@$UaDlAW<E[L_`J1@^>#@�AWHK>1H4j'<E[18IHNME<E[1HK>1<?UaD

FWJ1UN9;M?@B:=[&HNDWA [#FP@B_^<SR;_^HNMEMEb\OQUNJ�>#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVI<E_^HNMWj'<E[18WHNM <E[1HK>1<?UaD=HNDIAl[#@B:=HNDZ>1<E_[#>#JL8W_`>18/JL@$AW<E[1_`U jN@^J1bYOQJ1Ua:

H�>#@� '>�_`UaMEM?@B_`>1<?UaD��&�/<E:=<EMEHKJ�HKJ1]a8W:Y@BDZ>1[�J1@^]aHKJhAW<ED/]�>1V/@�:Y@^Jh<?>1[�UNO;>1VW@'����� :YU7AW@BM'9 @B< D/]>1VW@^UNJ1@^>1<E_^HNMEM?b

FWJL< DW_^<?FIM?@BAlU jN@^J�>1V/@e�W�)� :YU'A/@BMfAW< [1_^8W[1[#@BAG<ED � nKo ��HKFWFIM?b�V/@^J1@!�

!�<EDWHNM M?bNm�9P@B[1< A/@B[*A/@BHNM <ED/] �<?>1Vr[#>1HK>1< _ A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ> _`UaMEM?@B_`>1<?UaDW[Bm�[1>#J1@BHN:)�kME< �N@GA/b'DWHN:=<E_l>#@� 7> A/U'_^8��

:Y@BDZ>1[0VWHBjN@)HN_hVW<?@^jN@BACH �$<EA/@B[1FWJ1@BHNAl8I[1HK]N@)<EDl>1VW@�_`UaDZ>#@� 7>0UNO�>1V/@���UNJLMEA�� < A/@��@^9 ���dU'A/@BME[��$VW< _LV

>1H �N@G<EDT>#U,_`UaDW[1<EAW@^JLHK>1<?UaDrAWb7DWHN:l<E_ �IU �[*UNO0>#@� '>18WHNM.<ED/OQUNJL:=HK>1<?UaDfm�[18W_LV HN[\>1V/Ua[#@l@B:l<?>#>#@BA _`UaDZ>1<ED78��

Ua8W[1MEb,97b�@!� ]�� DW@��$[*9IJ1UaHNAW_^HN[#> :Y@B[1[1HK]N@B[Bm&HKJ1@ D/@^@BAW@BA��d� '>#@BDW[1<EUaDW[4UNO0>1V/@G:YU'A/@BME[\A/@^jN@BM?UNFP@BA OQUNJ

[#>1HK>1<E_.>#@� '>&_`UaMEM?@B_`>1<?UaDI[�_^HND F Ua[L[1<?9IM?b�9P@�_`UaDW[1<EA/@^JL@BA�����D H�FWJ1UN9IHK9I< ME<E[#>1<E_�OQJLHN:Y@��.UNJ��\>1VW<E[�<E[�H�[#>#JLHN<?]aVZ> �

OQUNJ��.HKJhA�[1>#@^FC>#U=A/U/m/V/U �.@^jN@^JH :YUNJ1@)_`Ua:YF;ME<E_^HK>#@BAC:YU'A/@BM �$<?>1V�:YUNJ1@�OQJ1@^@�FIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^JL[�J1@B[18WM?>1[�OQJ1Ua:

/'p

Page 63: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

[18W_hV6H AW<?JL@B_`>e@� '>#@BDW[1<EUaD�� !�<EDIAW<ED/] H�[#Ua:Y@��$VIHK>=[1<E:YFIM <SRI@BA bN@^> D/UN>Y>#UZUrJ1@B[#>#JL<E_`>1<EjN@GHNDIHNM?b7[L<E[YHNDWA

j'<E[18WHNME< [1HK>1<?UaDi:YU'A/@BM�OgUNJ�>1V/@ [#FP@B_^<EHNM�_^HN[#@eUNO&>#@B:YFPUNJLHNM M?b�_`UaVW@^J1@BDT>�>#@� '>�[1>#J1@BHN:=[�<E[$HNDWUN>1V/@^J�jN@B<EDdUNO

>1V/@4JL@B[#@BHKJL_LV <EDZjN@B[#>1<?]aHK>1<?UaDW[�J1@^FPUNJ1>#@BAC<EDC>1VW< [�>1V/@B[1<E[��

/Nn

Page 64: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

�� ��� ��� � �

� �� � � ����� � � � ���� � � � ��� � � � � � ��� � � � �� ���� ���� � � � ��� ���� � ���� �!��� ������� � � ��� ������ � �

��Dr>1VI<E[\_hVWHKFW>#@^J � H ]N@BD/@^JLHNM.OQJLHN:Y@��.UNJ�� OQUNJ AIHK>1H,HNDIHNM?b7[L<E[\HNDIArj'<E[18WHNM <E[1HK>1<?UaDr9Zbr:=@BHNDW[eUNO�>#U �FPUN]NJLHKFIVW< _�UNJ1]aHNDW< %BHK>1<?UaD,HNDWAi_^M 8W[#>#@^JL<EDW]=<E[�FWJL@B[#@BDT>#@BA����$V/@4FWJL< :=HKJ1b :=UN>1<?j HK>1<EUaDiUNO�>1VW<E[ ��UNJ��i< [0>#U

FWJ1U j7< A/@�H >1VW@^UNJ1@^>1<E_^HNMEM?b FWJL<EDI_^<?FIM?@BA=HNME>#@^JLDWHK>1<?jN@)>#UY>1V/@�� �����W��� � 9IHN[#@BAdA/U7_^8I:Y@BDT>�J1@^FIJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaD

OQUNJ4>#@� 7>*@BDW_`U7AW@BA�9Zb AW<E[L_`J1@^>#@ j HNME8W@B[4HN_^_`UNJLAW<EDW]C>#Ui>1V/@YjN@B_`>#UNJ [#FIHN_`@=:YU'A/@BM �Y��VW< [�< [)HN_LVW<?@^jN@BAr9Zb

@B:YFIMEU b'<ED/]lH�MEHK>#@BDZ>jKHKJL<EHK9IME@*:YU'A/@BM�HNDIAd<E:YFPUa[1< D/]=_`@^J1>1HN<ED,AW<E[#>#Jh<?9I8/>1<?UaDIHNMfHN[1[18W:YFI>1<?UaDW[�UaD >1V/@eHN[ �

[18W:=@BA,8IDWA/@^JLM?b'<ED/]=M HK>#@BDT>)jKHKJL<EHK9IME@B[��)��V/@Y:YU'A/@BM � [�D/Ua<E[#@)�$<EM M 9P@e:=U7A/@BME@BA <ED,FIHKJhHN:Y@^>#JL<E_\OgUNJh:Cm HN[

Hi:Y@B:\9P@^J*UNO�>1V/@=@� 'FPUaD/@BDZ>1<EHNM�OsHN:=<EM?b,UNO0AW<E[#>#JL<E9I8/>1<?UaDW[�HNDWAr>1VW<E[4HNMEMEU �$[48I[)>#U A/@BHNM �$<?>1V�AW< � @^J1@BDZ>

qs_`UaDZ>1<EDZ8WUa8W[4UNJeAW<E[1_`J1@^>#@ t�>kb7F @B[*UNO�UN9I[#@^J1jKHK9IM?@B[4< D Hd8WDI<SRI@BA,OgJhHN:Y@���UNJ�� ��� D >1VW<E[4_hVWHKFW>#@^JBm�>1V/@=OQU �

_^8W[�<E[$UaD,AI<E[1_`J1@^>#@ _^HN[#@eOgUNJL:e8WMEHK>1<EUaDW[ �VW<E_LV m;_`UaDZ>#JLHKJ1bd>#UG[#@BM?O�UNJL]aHNDW< %B<ED/]G:Y@^>1V/U'AW[OgUNJ�_`UaDZ>1<EDZ8WUa8W[

AWHK>1H'm�< :YFIM?b jKHKJL<EHNDZ>1[\UNO��JL@^]a:=HND6AW<?jN@^J1]N@BDI_^<?@B[\HN[Y:=@BHN[18/J1@B[\UNOAW< [1[1<E:=< MEHKJL<?> bd9P@^> �.@^@BD6AWHK>1H HNDWA

J1@^OQ@^J1@BDW_`@�FPUa<EDT>1[BmTHNDWA�HNME[#U\AW@`R;D/@$>1VW@:=HK>1_hVW<ED/]eD/UaDWME<EDW@BHKJ&J1@BMEHK>1<?UaDl9P@^> �.@^@BD�M HK>#@BDT>�HNDWA UN9I[#@^J1jKHK9IM?@

jKHKJL<EHK9IM?@B[ ����VW@^J1@^OgUNJL@Nma>1V/@�>#JLHN<E>&j HKJh<EHNDT>�UNOP>1V/@:YU7AW@BM/_^HND=9P@�[#@^@BDlHN[�H4AWHK>1H��kA/Jh<?jN@BD=D/Ua<E[1beD/UaDIME<ED/@BHKJ

��DWA/@^FP@BDWA/@BDZ> ".Ua:=F UaDW@BDT> �DIHNM?b7[L<E[^m �$VW<E_hV < [\_^HKFIHK9;M?@GUNO�J1@^jN@BHNME<EDW],:Y@BHNDI<ED/]NOs8WM�[1>#JL8W_`>18/J1@G<ED >1V/@

:e8WM?>1<?jKHKJL<EHK>#@)UN9I[1@^J1j HK9;M?@4AWHK>1H=HNDWAdHNMEM?U �[�8W[0>#U=j'<E[18IHNME<E[#@)<?>�<EDG> ��U�AW<E:Y@BDI[1<?UaDW[�����VW@*_^MEHN[1[0jKHKJL<EHNDZ>

q �$VW< _LV�FP@^J1OQUNJL:=[�>1V/@�_^ME8W[#>#@^Jh<ED/]Zt$UNO0Ua8/J*:YU'A/@BM�FP@^J1OQUNJL:=[)AIHK>1H��kA/JL<?jN@BDrFIHKJLHN:Y@^>#JL< _=:=< '>18/J1@Y:YU'A��

@BMEME< D/]�����V/@e_`Ua:*9I< D/@BA qQ>#JhHN<?>HNDWA,_^MEHN[1[ t�:YU'A/@BM�HNM?UaD/] �$<?>1Vi>1VW@\HN[1[#U'_^<EHK>#@BA,@B[#>1<E:lHK>1<?UaDdFIJ1U7_`@BAI8/J1@B[

HNMEM?U �$[$8I[�>#U < DT>#@^J1FIJ1@^>�>1V/@\j7<E[L8WHNME<E[1HK>1<EUaDGJ1@B[18WM?>^m;<EDC>1V/@e[#@BDW[#@4UNO&Hl>#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVW<E_4UNJLA/@^JL<EDW]��0��DW@*<E:)�

FPUNJ1>1HNDZ>.HKFWF;ME<E_^HK>1<?UaDlUNO >1VW<E[���UNJ��l<E[�>1V/@�AI<E[1_`U jN@^JLb=UNO�8WDWAW@^JLM?b'<ED/]4[#@B:=HNDZ>1<E_�[#>#JL8W_`>18WJ1@�< D=>#@� '>.9;HN[#@BA

A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[���� 'F @^Jh<E:Y@BDZ>1HNMZJL@B[18WM?>1[�UaD jKHKJL<?Ua8W[�[18/9;[#@^>1[�UNOI>1V/@�� ��@BDZ>kb �k�$@��[#]NJ1Ua8/FI[&>#@� 7>&_`UNJ1F;8W[�HNDWA

9I<EDIHKJ1b _`U'A/@BAiAW<E]a<?>1[0AWHK>1H=HKJ1@*]a<?jN@BDC97b ��HBbCUNO�A/@B:YUaDW[1>#JLHK>1<?UaD����� ���=��./", �������"#���� ��(�2+-�(�������*) ��M �"#� :P�/��W �<��������)� ��4D��=) �"#���J�R"#1/� ��(�2�=�2��) ����=)� 2��)���������� �����������������������

� ����������! "�#��$�%&�'�(�)����*!+,���.-����#�/���0���1$($(��2����#���!��3&�/� F54.6 )87 - �8�<� 7:9�; T�F 7:< 4��04�=�=]/F

/2�

Page 65: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

� ��� �������������� ���!���

��VW@ ��@BD/@^JLHK>1<?jN@d��UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVW< _��,HKFWFI< D/] q �)��� t � nKo��$<E[ H >#UZUaM�OgUNJ=AWHK>1H j'<E[18IHNME<E[1HK>1<?UaD �$VW< _LV

J1@^OQUNJL:e8WMEHK>#@B[ >1V/@C<EA/@BH UNO��'@BM?O��J1]aHNDW< %B<ED/] � HKFI[ � �2/ �0< D H,>1V/@^UNJ1@^>1< _^HNMEM?b FWJh<EDW_^<?FIME@BA�FWJ1UN9IHK9;<EME<E[#>1< _

:=HNDWDW@^J.HNDWAGA/@B:=UaDW[#>#JLHK>#@B[.>1V/@�>#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVW< _�UNJ1]aHNDW< %B<ED/]eF U ��@^J�UNO�He]N@BD/@^JhHK>1<?jN@):YU7AW@BM m7HN[L[18W:=<EDW]\H

[#FP@B_^<SR;_0DWUaD�� ��HN8W[1[L<EHNDlMEHK>#@BDZ>�FIJL<?UNJ ���$U ��@^jN@^J m/9ZbYHN[1[18I:=<ED/]4H ��HN8W[1[1< HNDlD/Ua<E[1@$:YU'A/@BM mZ<E>�<E[&[18I<?>1HK9IM?@

UaDWM?b,OQUNJ*>1V/@�HNDWHNM?b'[1<E[�UNO�_`UaDZ>1<EDZ8WUa8W[*AWHK>1H��G��D :=HNDZb�[1<?>18WHK>1<?UaDI[)>1V/@lUN9;[#@^J1jKHK>1<?UaDW[4HKJ1@�AW<E[1_`JL@^>#@=UNJ

_^HK>#@^]NUNJL<E_^HNM �&� D � n'p �W>1V/@$<EAW@BH�UNOPHNAIHKFW>1<ED/])>1V/@'�)��� OgUNJ�9I<EDWHKJ1b\AWHK>1H ��HN[&FWJLUNF Ua[1@BA�����D �1/54 � m �1/ � �I>1V/@

����� :YU7AW@BM ��HN[�JL@B_`UaDW[1<EA/@^JL@BA=OQUNJ�9I< DWHKJ1bYAWHK>1H\>1VWHK>.< [�:YU'A/@BM?@BA HN[.He:e8WM?>1< �kAW< :Y@BDW[1<?UaDIHNM7�.@^JLDWUa8WMEME<

AW<E[1>#JL<?9I8/>1<EUaD��6��:YFI<EJL<E_^HNM�J1@B[18IM?>1[=A/@B:YUaDI[#>#JLHK>#@BA >1VIHK>l>1V/@d:=U7AW<?RI@BA ����� <E[ H�j HNM 8WHK9IM?@C>#U7UaM�OQUNJ

R;DWAI<ED/]e>#UNFI<E_^HNM [#>#Jh8W_`>18/J1@4<EDG9;<EDWHKJ1b�_`U7A/@BAi>#@� 7>$AWU7_^8W:=@BDT>1[��

$@BMEHK>#@BA :=U7A/@BM�A/@B[1_`JL<?FI>1<?UaDW[�UNO&_^ME8W[1>#@^JL<ED/] �1�'p � �1�Nn���HNDIAij'<E[18WHNME< [1HK>1<?UaDG:YU'A/@BME[ �Sp.-Tn�� �Sp^o���� �Sp^o50��

_^HND 9P@ OQUa8WDWA <ED >1V/@C[#>1HK>1<E[#>1< _^HNM.M <?>#@^JLHK>18/J1@!��� MEHK>#@BDT> jKHKJL<EHK9IME@ :YU'A/@BM.OgUNJYAW< [1_`J1@^>#@GAWHK>1H HNDWHNM?b'[1<E[

_^HND 9P@\OQUa8WDWA <ED � 4 /��&HNDWA <?>1[�>#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVI<E_^HNM�@� 7>#@BDW[L<?UaD�<ED � 4'- � m >1V/@Y<EA/@BH UNO �VW<E_LV <E[�@B[1[1@BDT>1<EHNM M?bdH

[#b':=:Y@^>#JL< _^HNMfA/@B_`Ua:YFPUa[1<?>1<?UaDGUNO�>1V/@4AIHK>1Hl:=HK>#JL< �

��D4>1VW< [�_LVIHKFW>#@^J�>1V/@�]N@BD/@^JhHK>1<?jN@.:=U7A/@BMZ<E[�_`UaDI[#>#JL8W_`>#@BAe<ED*H$]N@BD/@^JLHNMZOgJhHN:Y@���UNJ��4OgUNJ�Ua8/>1_`Ua:Y@B[�OQJ1Ua:

>1V/@.@� 7FPUaD/@BDZ>1<EHNMZOQHN:l<EM?b�UNOIAW<E[1>#JL<?9I8/>1<EUaDW[POgUNJ�9PUN>1V*>1VW@._^HN[#@B[�UNO;AW<E[1_`J1@^>1< %^@BA\_`UaDZ>1<ED78/Ua8W[�D/UaD�� ��HN8W[L[1<EHND

q �&�#� ���%�C� �+���<� � -C��� � t HNDWAcAW<E[1_`J1@^>#@ _^HK>#@^]NUNJL<E_^HNM q � �#� �$�%� � �&�'��� tlMEHK>#@BDZ>=FWJL<?UNJh[��c��V/@B[1@dAW<E[#>#Jh<?9I8/>1<?UaDIHNM

HN[1[18I:YFW>1<?UaDW[�HNMEM?U � 8W[�>#U�>#JL@BHK>)>1V/@Y_^ME8W[#>#@^JL< D/] HNDWA,j'<E[18WHNM <E[1HK>1<?UaDdFWJ1UN9IM?@B: UNO�AI< � @^JL@BDT>)AWHK>1H�>kb7FP@B[

�$<?>1VI<ED�>1V/@4[1HN:Y@4OQUNJL:=HNM <E[1:��

��A/UNFW>1<EDW]=HKFWFWJ1U '<E:lHK>#@*�dUaDZ>#@ "0HKJLM?U=[1HN:YF;ME<ED/]eOgJLUa: H R '@BAC> �.U AI<E:Y@BDW[1<EUaDWHNM m'8WDW<?OQUNJL:=M?b AW<E[ �

>1HNDW_`@BAr]NJL<EA qsHN[4UNJh<?]a<EDWHNMEMEbCFWJ1UNFPUa[#@BA�<ED ���$� t�FIJ1U j'<EA/@B[�>1V/@ [1HN:Y@YOQUNJL:=HNME<E[L: OgUNJ49PUN>1V >#JLHN<E>*HNDWA

_^MEHN[1[�:YU'A/@BM�OgUNJL:e8WMEHK>1<EUaDW[��$��D >1V/@e_^HN[1@eUNO�_^MEHN[1[�:YU'A/@BMEME<EDW]/mW>1V/@ [1HN:YFIME< D/]l<E[FP@^J1OgUNJh:Y@BAiOQJ1Ua: 8WDW<?>

jN@B_`>#UNJG_`U � UNJLAW<EDWHK>#@BAc_`UNJLD/@^JL[ UNO)H�VZbZFP@^JL_^8/9P@GHNDWA6>1V/@iHNME]NUNJL<?>1VW: M?@BHKJhDW[Y<EDWA/@^FP@BDWAW@BDT>\FWJ1UN>#UN>kb7FP@

jN@B_`>#UNJL[l>1VWHK>lVWH jN@d_^HK>#@^]NUNJL<E_^HNM�:Y@BHNDW<EDW] �<?>1V/Ua8/>YHNDZb UNJLAW@^JL<ED/]�� !/J1Ua: >1V/@dMEHK>#@BDZ>Y>#JLHN<?>=[#UaM 8/>1<?UaD

@B:Y@^J1]N@B[�H�>#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVI<E_^HNM0UNJLA/@^Jh<ED/]�UNO�>1V/@d_`Ua:YFIJ1@B[1[#@BA�<E:=HK]N@B[=UNO�>1V/@ AWHK>1H FPUa<EDZ>1[^m�97b6HNMEM?U �$<ED/]

H,[1:YU7UN>1V DWUaDWME<ED/@BHKJ\J1@BMEHK>1<?UaD 9P@^> �.@^@BD UN9I[#@^J1jN@BA HNDWA MEHK>#@BDZ>ejKHKJL<EHK9;M?@B[�� �$VW<E[4JL@BMEHK>1<?UaD _`J1@BHK>#@B[YHND

HKFWFWJLUNFWJL<EHK>#@4D/UaD�� ��HN8W[1[1< HNDiMEHK>#@BDZ>$FWJL<EUNJ�HNDWAdHK>>1V/@*[1HN:Y@\>1<E:Y@4<E:=FIME<E_^<?>1MEblA/@`R;D/@B[$H=D/@B<?]aVZ9PUNJLV/U7U7A& # ) �"#� �6 1� ����6 ������ ���� ��(� 17 �A<���*�V1 ���*)� ���),A#�*A<�E�=17 ���)� �+/1����=1/?<���>��� 1�� �� 1/�� ��C��M@�� �(K�<� 1���)#�E1 ��1� ���./�/�����41/� �������!�/)#���*F

X �4:P��+-�(�4�� �"<� A<��1/./�0��M �"<�; ��R��I :L1/�L�(K, ���)#D<�4D��=) \�]*] 7 _8MN�/�CI��K�4D ) D�=���R���( �� 1�)8D3���/), ���),A#�/A#� - �*?<���(��+-�4D+/1����=1/?<�=�(��F � � �"#� MO����A<�C���LIJ1/��)#���J�/)EI�,D�����=��)<.[D�=���R���( �� 1/)#D�41� ���./�/�����41�� �������!�/)#��� +/1����=1/?<����� ) �*?<���(��+/1/?#����� - "<�(���*�� �"<�=�L ��R��I ���LA#����D ��2D<���6 ���)#./A#����" ���*)� ���),A#�*A<�0�=17 ���)� +/1����=1/?<�=�(�0MN���/I �417 ���.*�������41/��

��+-��)9��M �"#�%./��)#�(� 1��ZMO����I ��MP�/A<�0I�,D<���ZIJ1��E��)#����A8D�+/1����=1/)� ��;��A#�� 1/?<��� MO�/�0���/), ���),A#�/A#�C�/?#���(��+/1/?<�=�%D<1� 1,F

/$-

Page 66: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

Os8WDW_`>1<?UaDYU jN@^J�>1V/@�]NJL<EA=F Ua< DT>1[^mZ[18W_LVl>1VWHK>�H*>1V/@^UNJ1@^>1<E_^HNM M?b FWJL<EDW_^<EFIM?@BA\FIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^J.@B[#>1<E:=HK>1<EUaD=:Y@^>1V/U'A

_^HND 9P@Y@ � _^<E@BDT>1M?b,@B:YFIMEU bN@BA�����V/@=_^MEHN[1[\:YU'A/@BM�_^ME8W[#>#@^Jh<ED/]GFWJ1U j7<EAW@B[)FWJ1UN9IHK9;<EME<E[#>1< _*MEHK9P@BME[�>1VWHK>eHKJ1@

8W[#@^Os8WM7OQUNJ�<EDZ>#@^J1FWJ1@^>1<EDW]�>1VW@0j7<E[L8WHNME<E[1HK>1<EUaD*J1@B[L8WM?>^mT<EDe>1V/@[#@BDW[#@0UNO >1V/@0>#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVW< _�UNJLA/@^JL<EDW]FWJLU j'<EA/@BA

97b >1V/@*>#JLHN<?>�[#UaME8W>1<?UaD��

+�DWA/@^J)H ��HN8W[1[L<EHND�D/Ua<E[#@ HN[1[18I:YFW>1<?UaD >1V/@ FWJ1UNFPUa[#@BA,>#JLHN<?>�jKHKJL<EHNDZ>�UNO�>1V/@Y:YU'A/@BM.��Ua8WM A JL@BAW8W_`@

>#U=>1V/@\[#>1HNDWAWHKJLA ����� m �$VW<EME@>1V/@\_^MEHN[1[�jKHKJL<EHNDZ> �.Ua8WMEAGJ1@BAW8I_`@4>#U ��HN8W[L[1<EHNDi:=< 7>18/JL@�:=U7A/@BM ME<ED/]e9Zb

� 'FP@B_`>1HK>1<?UaD �,H� '< :=<E[1HK>1<?UaD qs��� t ���$U ��@^jN@^J [#FP@B_^<SR;_^HNMEMEbdAW<E[1_`JL@^>#@=AWHK>1HiHKFWFIM <E_^HK>1<?UaDW[�HKJ1@Y>1HKJ1]N@^>#@BA

V/@^J1@Nm7>1V/@FWJL<E:=HKJLbe:YUN>1<Ej HK>1<?UaD UNOf>1VW<E[ ��UNJ��Y9 @B< D/]4>#U*@� '>#@BDWA >1V/@�>#JLHN<?>�:=U7A/@BMWOgUNJL:e8WMEHK>1<EUaDlHN[�H4>#U7UaM

OQUNJ�>#@� 7> �k:l<EDW<ED/]��

��Di�7@B_`>1<?UaDGn*>1VW@]N@BD/@^JhHNME< %^@BA�]N@BD/@^JLHK>1<?jN@):YU'A/@BM <E[.FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>#@BA����7@B_`>1<EUaD��\FWJ1@B[1@BDT>1[.>1V/@���� [#UaME8��

>1<?UaD,<EDi>1VW@\]N@BD/@^JhHNM�_^HN[#@!�4�7@B_`>1<?UaD -�>#J1@BHK>1[�FIHKJ1>1<E_^8WM HKJ_^HN[#@B[�UNO�jKHKJL<?Ua8W[�AW<E[1_`JL@^>#@\AW<E[1>#JL<?9I8/>1<EUaDW[0HNDWA

[1V/U �$[0>1V/@\AW<E[1[1< :=<EMEHKJL<E>kb=:Y@BHN[18WJ1@B[�<EDWAI8W_`@BAG9Zb�>1V/@4jKHKJL<?Ua8I[�D/Ua<E[#@4:=U7A/@BM [����7@B_`>1<?UaD /YFWJ1U j'<EA/@B[$[1<E:)�

8WMEHK>1<EUaDGJ1@B[18WM?>1[0< DiVWHNDWA�� �$JL<?>#>#@BDGAW<?]a<?>0JL@B_`UN]aDW<?>1<?UaDiHNDIAC>#@� 7>:=<EDW<EDW]/m7>1VW@�R;DWHNMf[#@B_`>1<?UaD [18W:=:lHKJL< %^@B[

>1V/@*_`UaDI_^ME8W[1<?UaDI[��

� � � � � ��� � � � �� � � � ���!��� ��� ����� ���� �� � � �!� � ���!� ��� ��� � ������� � ��� ���

��@^>�8W[ A/@BD/UN>#@,9Zb � q� � �/t �������

� � � �����

� >1V/@,UN9I[#@^J1jN@BA AWHK>1H�� �$V/@ :=HK>#Jh< � _`UaDT>1HN< DW[ �<EDWAW@^F @BDIA/@BDT>.UN9I[#@^JLj HK>1<?UaDI[0UNO�>1VW@ � �kAW<E:=@BDW[1<?UaDWHNM AWHK>1HYjN@B_`>#UNJh[ ���$V/@�jN@B_`>#UNJ , � �$< MEM J1@^Og@^J$>#U=UaD/@

_`UaME8W:lD UNO >1VI<E[�:=HK>#JL< PmT< � @!�?mTUaD/@�UN9I[#@^JLjN@BA=AWHK>1H)FPUa<EDZ>����$V/@�[#>1HNDWAWHKJhA=HN[1[18W:=FW>1<?UaD OQUNJ�_`Ua:YFWJ1@B[L[1<?UaD��

>kb7FP@ ]N@BD/@^JLHK>1<?jN@Y:YU'A/@BME[ � >1VWHK>�>1V/@ UN9I[#@^J1jKHK>1<?UaDW[�HKJ1@YHGD/Ua<E[1bi@� 7F;HNDW[1<?UaD UNO�HGVW<EAIA/@BDi]N@BD/@^JhHK>1<?jN@

jKHKJL<EHK9IM?@&< [�:=HNA/@�V/@^J1@!��� DWAW@^F @BDIA/@BDW_`@�UNO'UN9I[#@^J1jKHK9IM?@B[�_`UaDWAW<?>1<EUaD/@BA)UaD4>1VW@�MEHK>#@BDZ>�jKHKJL<EHK9IME@&<E[�HN[1[L8W:Y@BA

V/@^J1@Nm��$VW<E_hV VWHN[YFWJ1U jN@BA6>#U�9P@CH J1@BHN[#UaDWHK9IME@G[L<E:YFIME<EOgb'<ED/]iHN[1[L8W:YFW>1<?UaD �SpNp�/�� m�@� 'FWJ1@B[1[1< D/] >1V/@iHN<E:

>1VWHK>\>1V/@ MEHK>#@BDZ>*]N@BDW@^JLHK>1<?jN@�OQHN_`>#UNJL[e[1V/Ua8IMEA _^HKFW>18/JL@ HNMEM�>1VW@ A/@^FP@BDWA/@BDI_`b$�$VI<E_LV�@� /<E[#>1[eHN:YUaD/] >1V/@

_`Ua:YFPUaD/@BDZ>1[�UNO�>1V/@4UN9I[1@^J1jN@BAiAWHK>1H �Sp�/2� � �

��VW@\AW<E[1>#JL<?9I8/>1<EUaDWHNMfHN[1[18W:=FW>1<?UaDW[HKJ1@)�7D/U �$D >#UGVIHBjN@YHl]NJL@BHK>�< D �;8/@BDW_`@*UaD >1VW@\J1@B[L8WM?>1HNDZ>>#@B_hV��

DW<EX78/@!����VW@*FWJ1UN9;HK9I<EME<?> b�AI<E[#>#JL<?9;8/>1<?UaD�U jN@^J)>1V/@e:YU'A/@BM�D/Ua< [#@\H��P@B_`>1[�>1V/@*> bZFP@eUNO&AWHK>1H >1V/@e:=U7A/@BM�<E[

[18W<E>#@BAGOgUNJBm��V/@^J1@BHN[�>1V/@4HN[1[L8W:Y@BAiMEHK>#@BDZ>0FWJL<EUNJ�AW@^>#@^JL:=<ED/@B[�>1VW@4HKFWFIME<E_^HK9;<EME<?> bYUNO�>1V/@4:=U7A/@BM m'< � @!�&>1V/@

[#>1HK>1<E[1>1<E_^HNM/FWJ1UNFP@^J1>1<E@B[�UNOP< DT>#@^J1@B[1> �$V/@BD=HNDWHNMEb %B<EDW]�>1VW@$:\8IM?>1<?jKHKJL<EHK>#@0AWHK>1H��&��]N@BD/@^JLHK>1<?jN@�:YU7AW@BM��$<?>1V

D/UaD�� �)HN8W[1[1<EHND HN[1[L8W:YFW>1<?UaDI[4UaD >1V/@CMEHK>#@BDZ> j HKJL< HK9IM?@B[e<E[ HNME[#U �7D/U �$D6HN[e� DIA/@^FP@BDWA/@BDZ> ".Ua:YFPUaD/@BDZ>

/2/

Page 67: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

��DWHNM?b'[1<E[iqQ�1"���t �1�'pam�/2�'m 0'p �$AW< � @^J1@BDZ>YjKHKJL<EHNDZ>1[YUNO �$VW<E_hV6VWHBjN@i9P@^@BD AW@B:YUaDW[#>#JLHK>#@BA >#UrVW<?]aVWM <?]aVT>

FPUN>#@BDT>1< HNM :Y@BHNDW<EDW]NOQ8WMP[#>#Jh8W_`>18/J1@4<EDCAIHK>1H��

�� � �� � � "��5������� � � ����� � � � � � ��� � � � � ���

��VW@4AW<E[#>#JL<E9I8/>1<?UaDWHNM HN[1[18I:YFW>1<?UaDGU jN@^J>1V/@\MEHK>#@BDT>$j HKJL< HK9IM?@4<E[0<EDiOQHN_`>�JL@B[#FPUaDW[1<?9IME@OQUNJ�>1V/@4> bZFP@4UNO

>1V/@�:YU'A/@BM'HNDWA <?>�:e8W[#>�9P@.[1@^>&<ED HN_^_`UNJLAWHNDW_`@�>#U)>1VW@�[1_`[email protected] >1V/@0HKFWFIM <E_^HK>1<?UaD����7Ua:Y@0@� /HN:YFIM?@B[ �.@^J1@

[#@^@BD <ED,"�VIHKFW>#@^Jn ����A/UNFW>1<ED/]=DWUaD�� ��HN8W[1[L<EHNDiMEHK>#@BDZ>FIJL<?UNJL[0VWHN[$9P@^@BDd[1V/U �$Di>#U J1@^jN@BHNM�<ED/OQUNJL:=HK>1<?jN@

[#>#JL8I_`>18/J1@ <ED >1V/@ AWHK>1H �10Ko�� � �[ HND�HNDWHNM?b7>1<E_^HNMEMEbc[#FP@B_^<SRI@BA _`UaDZ>1<EDZ8WUa8W[iMEHK>#@BDZ>dAW<E[1>#JL<?9I8/>1<EUaD �.Ua8WMEA

FPUa[1[1<?9;M?bdJ1@B[L8WM?>\< Dr<EDZ>#JLHN_`>1HK9IM?@�<EDZ>#@^]NJLHNME[^m�>1V/@�[1HN:YFIME< D/]i>#@B_LVIDW<EX78/@ 8/>1< ME< %^@BA <EDr>1V/@ �)��� � nKo�� � n'p �

�Sp��54��)<E[�HNA/UNFW>#@BA V/@^J1@ HNDWA�>1VW<E[ >kb7FP@ UNO*:=U7A/@BM �$<EM M09P@ J1@^OQ@^J1J1@BA HN[GH`� �#� �$�%� � �+�����C�U�.� ��� � ��V/@

AW<E[L_`J1@^>1< %^@BACOQUNJL:e8WMEHK>1<?UaDG@BDWHK9;M?@B[0>1V/@4>#JhHN<?>$:YU'A/@BMf>#U=9P@*_`UaDI[1<EA/@^J1@BA �<?>1VW<EDG>1V/@\[1HN:Y@4OQUNJL:=HNME< [1: HN[

>1V/@4_^MEHN[L[�:YU'A/@BMfHNDWAC>1V78W[0HNMEM?U �$[0OQUNJ$H >1V/@^UNJ1@^>1< _^HNMEM?b�FWJL<EDW_^<EFIM?@BA=>#UNFPUN]NJLHKF;VW<E_^HNMf:YU'A/@BMPOQUNJL:\8IMEHK>1<?UaD

� nKo�� �

��VW@[1HN:YF;ME<ED/]4:Y@^>1VWU7AlFWJ1UNFPUa[#@BAl< D �Sp^o50�� m �Sp^o���� OgUNJ.j7< [18WHNME<E[L<ED/])_^HK>#@^]NUNJL<E_^HNM jKHKJL<EHK9IM?@B[BmT>1V/@ � A/@BD��

[1<?> bYD/@^> �.UNJ�� � ��HN[�8I[#@BAYOQUNJ.AW< [1_`U jN@^JL< D/]*_`UNJ1J1@BM HK>1<?UaDW[�< DYFWJ1UN>#@B<EDl[#@BXZ8W@BDW_`@B[�HNDIA=>1V/@�JL@BXZ8W<EJ1@BAY>#UNFPUN] �

JLHKFIVZb �.HN[e]N@BD/@^JhHK>#@BA 97b HN[1[18I:=<ED/]iH FIHKJ1>1<E_^8IMEHKJ*MEHK>#@BDZ>eAW@BDW[1<?> b!�C� Dr>1V/@"�)��� >kb7FP@lOQUNJL:\8IMEHK>1<?UaD

V/U ��@^jN@^JBm'>1V/@�MEHK>#@BDZ>.A/@BDI[1<?>1<?@B[&HNDIAl_`UNJ1J1@BM HK>1<?UaDW[�9 @^> ��@^@BD >1V/@B[#@�HKJ1@@� 7FIM <E_^<?>1M?beA/@B[1<?]aD/@BAl>#Ue[1>1HNDWA=OQUNJ

FWJ1@��kAW@`R;D/@BA,V/Ua:YUN]N@BD/@^Ua8W[)DW@B<?]aVT9PUNJLVWUZU'AiJ1@BM HK>1<?UaDW[UaD,HCnK� ]NJL<EA�����VW< [HNMEMEU �$[�HG:YUNJ1@ _`UaDT>#J1UaM M?@BA

j'<E[18WHNME< [1HK>1<?UaDfm'[#@^>$HK]aHN<EDI[#>$H J1@^OQ@^J1@BDW_`@�� ]NJL< ACUNO�@BXZ8W< AW<E[#>1HNDZ>�F Ua< DT>1[��

�.UN>1V�>1V/@YMEHK>#@BDZ>4_^MEHN[1[�HNDWA�M HK>#@BDT>�>#JLHN<?>):YU'A/@BME[ �$< MEM 9P@ 9WJL<?@��;bCFWJ1@B[#@BDZ>#@BA�HNDWA,>1V/@ OgUNJh:Y@^J �$<EMEM

9P@48W[#@BAGOQUNJ�FWJ1U j7< AW<ED/] >1V/@4_^MEHN[L[�MEHK9P@BME[�OQUNJ�>1V/@4j'<E[18WHNM <E[1HK>1<?UaD FWJ1U j7<EAW@BAG9ZbG>1V/@4MEHK>#>#@^J�:YU'A/@BM �

� � ���=�� � � #�+<& � # � � #C+<& - - � (�, # +

!/UNJ�_^ME8W[#>#@^Jh<ED/]�<ED6:e8/>18WHNMEM?b @� '_^M 8W[1<?jN@C_^MEHN[1[1@B[^m�>1V/@CFPUa[1[1<?9IME@ jKHNME8/@B[ UNO�>1V/@�� �kAW<E:Y@BDW[L<?UaDWHNM�MEH��>#@BDZ>\jKHKJL<EHK9IME@B[4_^HNDr9P@=_`UaDW[L<EA/@^J1@BA HN[*Hd8IDW<?OQUNJL: [1HN:YF;ME<ED/]GOQJ1Ua: >1V/@�_`UNJLD/@^JL[*UNO�H �$�kAW<E:=@BDW[1<?UaDWHNM

VZbZFP@^JL_^8/9P@Nm.�$VW<E_hV HKJ1@ _`UaM 8W:=DW[)UNO�H � AW<E:Y@BDI[1<?UaDWHNM�<EA/@BDZ>1<?> b :lHK>#JL< �G��@^>\8W[*A/@BD/UN>#@�>1V/@lMEHK>#@BDZ>jKHKJL<EHK9IM?@B[&9Zb �eV/@^J1@Nm'HN[ � �$<EMEM'9P@$8W[1@BAl<EDl>1V/@D/UN>1HK>1<EUaDlUNOf>1V/@$>#JLHN<?>�:=U7A/@BM [����$V/@B[#@M HK>#@BDT>�j HKJL< HK9IM?@B[

J1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>4[1Ua:Y@lD/Ua:=< DWHNM�j HKJh<EHK9IM?@B[^m < � @!�?m �$VW< _LV >1H �N@lUaD _^MEHN[1[4M HK9 @BM [^mfUNJ4>#UNFI<E_YM HK9 @BM [��Y��V/@=MEHK>#@BDZ>

AW<E:=@BDW[1<?UaD,<E[�>1VZ8I[9� m HNDIA UaD/@iqQjN@B_`>#UNJ t�jKHNME8/@eUNO � �$<EMEM�9 @YA/@BDWUN>#@BA 9Zb�# �&� �,HK>1V/@B:=HK>1<E_^HNMEMEbNm >1V/@

/20

Page 68: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

MEHK>#@BDZ>$AW<E[1>#JL<?9I8/>1<EUaD <E[

��q=#Zt ��� �� q=# % #��Kt��lq=# # �Nt q<-��Ep t

�$VW< _LV,<E[HND�8IDW_`UaDW[#>#JLHN< D/@BAd:=< 7>18/JL@\:YU'A/@BM �)��V/@ :=< '>18/J1@e_`Ua:YFPUaD/@BDZ>1[�:e8W[#>�[1HK>1<E[1Ogbi>1VW@eJL@BMEHK>1<?UaD

� �� �� �lq � ���Kt pKmIHN[�>1V/@^bGOQUNJL: HlAW<E[1_`J1@^>#@\AW<E[#>#JL<E9I8/>1<?UaDfm7HNDWA �<EMEM 9P@4_`UaDW[1<EA/@^JL@BAiHN[$8WDI<?OgUNJh:=M?b

AW<E[1>#JL<?9I8/>#@BA <?O$D/U,UN>1V/@^JYFWJh<?UNJY<ED/OQUNJL:=HK>1<?UaD <E[ HBjKHN<EMEHK9IME@!� ��V/@B[#@C_^HND 9P@�M HK>#@^J=8/FfAWHK>#@BA 8I[1<ED/],>1V/@

@B[#>1<E:lHK>#@BAiFPUa[#>#@^JL<?UNJh[��

� � ���=�� � � #�+<& � # � ��� *'& � � � (�, # +

�'< :=<EMEHKJ.>#U=>1V/@ ���$�rm/>1V/@\[#>1HKJ1>1<ED/] FPUa<EDZ>�OgUNJ�Ua8WJ�MEHK>#@BDT>$j HKJL< HK9IM?@B[ �$<EM MI9P@)HlnK�(MEHK>#@BDZ>$8WDW<?OQUNJL:

]NJL<EA=UNO FPUa<EDZ>1[�� !/UNJ�AW@B[1<?]aDW<EDW]�H*D/UN>1HK>1<?UaD �$VW<E_hV F @^Jh:=<?>1[�H48WDI<SRI@BA OQUNJL:=HNM/>#J1@BHK>1:=@BDT>�UNOPM HK>#@BDT>�>#JLHN<?>

HNDWA,_^MEHN[1[:YU7AW@BME[^m�� �<EMEM A/@BDWUN>#@*>1V/@ AW<E:Y@BDI[1<?UaDWHNME<E>kblUNO�>1VW@\MEHK>#@BDZ>>#JhHN<?>[#F;HN_`@GqQ> bZFI< _^HNMEM?b�� n

OQUNJ4j7< [18WHNME<E[LHK>1<?UaD,FI8/J1FPUa[#@B[ht � ��V/@ � ]NJL< A F Ua< DT>1[)HKJ1@ [#>#UNJ1@BA <ED�HND � � :=HK>#JL< � �=��VW@Y]NJL<EA

FPUa<EDZ>1[)HKJ1@l:=HKFWFP@BA 97b�HC[#@^>4UNO �-D/UaDIME<ED/@BHKJ)9IHN[L<E[�jN@B_`>#UNJL[�� � [1<E:l<EMEHKJ�>#Ui>1V/@l:=U7A/@BM�FIJ1UNFPUa[#@BA�<ED� nKo�� �.��VZ8I[�<EDG>1VW<E[$_^HN[#@*>1V/@ � � >1V _`Ua:YFPUaD/@BDZ>�UNO�>1VW@*D/UaDWME< D/@BHKJ�<E:=HK]N@4UNO�>1V/@ � � >1VdMEHK>#@BDZ>�]NJL<EAiF Ua< DT><E[ � � � � � q����Nt��$V/@^JL@ ���\HKJ1@\_`UaME8W:=DW[�UNO�>1V/@*:lHK>#JL< � m/UNJ�<EDG@BXZ8I<?j HNME@BDT>�:=HK>#Jh< �D/UN>1HK>1<EUaD

� � q � t q<-�� nat

�$V/@^JL@ � <E[0HND�� � AW<E:Y@BDW[L<?UaDWHNMP:=HK>#JL< �� V/@BD 8/>1< ME< %B<ED/]�D/UaDWME< D/@BHKJ�9IHN[1<E[�Os8WDW_`>1<?UaDW[�UaDW@=VWHN[4HGOQJ1@^@=_LV/Ua< _`@lHN:YUaD/]a[#>4[L:YUZUN>1V OQ8WDI_`>1<?UaDW[��

��V/JLUa8/]aV/Ua8/>Y>1VW< [=_LVWHKFI>#@^Jl>1V/@iJhHNAW<EHNM09IHN[L<E[YOs8WDW_`>1<?UaD6[#@^> �$<?>1V6_`UaDW[1>1HNDT>G8WDW<?> jKHKJL<EHNDW_`@ VWHN[=9P@^@BD

8/>1<EM < %^@BAfm �$VW<E_hVd]a<?jN@B[)HG[#F;HKJL[#@eF Ua[L<?>1<?jN@ [1HN:YFIM?@ AW<E[1>#JL<?9I8/>1<EUaDCOgUNJ � � mf>1VWHK>)<E[�[��N@��.@BA >#U�>1VW@eUNJh<?]a<ED���7FIHKJh[#@0FPUa[1<?>1<?jN@�_`U'AW<ED/]4VIHN[&HNME[#U49P@^@BD=[LV/U �$Dl<ED �Sp^oNo��I>#UeVWHBjN@>1V/@$_^HKFIHN_^<E>kbYUNOPJ1@^jN@BHNME<EDW]48WDWA/@^JLMEb7<EDW]

_^HN8W[#@B[�UNJ�OsHN_`>#UNJL[�<EDYFPUa[1<E>1<?jN@�AWHK>1H'm/HNDWAl:=UNJ1@$[#FP@B_^<SR;_^HNM M?b\<EDl@� 7F;MEHN<EDW<EDW]�>1VW@$MEHK>#@BDZ>.[#>#Jh8W_`>18/J1@$< DY>1V/@

_^HN[#@4UNO�>#@� '>$A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>$AWHK>1H �1�54�� �

!/UaM M?U �$< D/] >1VW@ ���$� :YU'A/@BM � nKo � m�>1V/@�MEHK>#@BDZ> jKHKJL<EHK9;M?@dUNO\>1V/@ >#JhHN<?>�:=U7A/@BM�<E[ � JhHK>1V/@^JG>1VWHND�Wm&VWU �.@^jN@^J=<?>e:lHBbr9P@�<EDT>#@^JL@B[#>1<ED/],>#U,DWUN>#@�>1VIHK>@q HN[ >1V/@GMEHK>#@BDZ>e>#JhHN<?>eHNME]NUNJL<?>1VW: �$<EMEM�8/>1<EME< %^@ >1V/@

���=jN@B_`>#UNJL[4OQUNJ)J1@B_`UaDW[#>#Jh8W_`>1<ED/]�>1V/@YUN9I[#@^JLjN@BA�AWHK>1HGHNDWA >1V/@YD/UaDWME< D/@BHKJ�:lHKFWFI<ED/] >1V/J1Ua8/]aV >1VW@e9;HN[1<E[

Os8WDW_`>1<?UaDW[ � < [=R '@BA �6� ���<� ���Cq H :=UNJ1@,< DT>18W<E>1<?jN@d<EDZ>#@^J1FWJ1@^>1HK>1<EUaD < [lHNME[#U FPUa[1[1<?9;M?@C9P@B[1<EA/@B[l>1VWHK>]a<?jN@BDG<ED >1V/@�UNJL<?]a<EDWHNM(����� :YU7AW@BM /�>1V/@�DWUaDWME<ED/@BHKJ.<E:=HK]N@B[ ���4UNO >1V/@�]NJL<EA F Ua< DT>1[._^HNDG9P@_`UaDW[1< A/@^J1@BA

HN[�Hl[1HN:YF;M?@4HKFWFWJ1U '< :=HK>1<?UaDiUNO�[#Ua:=@\D/UaD�� �)HN8W[1[1<EHNDd9I8/>$_`UNJLJ1@BMEHK>#@BAdAI<E[#>#JL<?9;8/>#@BAC_`UaDT>1< DZ8/Ua8I[$MEHK>#@BDZ>

/54

Page 69: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

jKHKJL<EHK9IM?@B[ �Sp��54 � � ��Dr>1VW< [\ME<E]aVT>^m�>1V/@�J1UaM?@�UNO�>1V/@�]NJL<EA FPUa<EDZ>1[\<E[\>#U FWJ1U j7<EAW@l@BX78W<EAW<E[1>1HNDT>eHKJ1]a8W:Y@BDZ>1[

OQUNJ\>1V/@G[1HN:YF;ME<ED/]iOQJ1Ua: >1V/@G<E:=HK]N@�UNO � �,�$V/@ AW< [#>#JL<?9I8W>1<?UaDW[)_`Ua:YFPUa[#@BA UNO�>1V/@B[#@G[1HN:YF;M?@B[ � � �iHKJ1@D/UaD�� �)HN8W[1[1<EHND <EDe]N@BD/@^JhHNM mTHNDWAY:YUa[1>&<E:YFPUNJ1>1HNDZ>1M?bNmK>1VW<E[ ��HBbeUNO [1HN:=FIME<ED/]�<EDWAW8I_`@B[�H�R+ 7@BA _`UNJ1J1@BM HK>1<?UaD

[#>#JL8I_`>18/J1@Y<ED >1V/@ � �kAW<E:Y@BDW[L<?UaDWHNM�[18/9��k:=HNDI<?OgUaM A qs[#@^@ !�<?]�� -��Ep � t �l�$VW<E[�_`UNJ1J1@BMEHK>1<EUaD [#>#JL8W_`>18WJ1@Y<E[�>1V/@

� �<> !.*�# � � � "�UNJ1J1@BMEHK>1<?UaD _`UaDT>#Ua8WJL[.UNO <EDWAW<?j'<EAW8IHNMTFPUa[1[1<E9IM?@�MEHK>#@BDZ>�jN@B_`>#UNJL[0_`UNJLJ1@B[#FPUaDWAW<EDW]�>#Ue>1V/@]NJL<EA

FPUa<EDZ>1[�UNO�UaD/@)JLU ��UNO�>1V/@4]NJL< Afm/A/@`R;D/@BA�97b >1V/@4DWUaDWME<ED/@BHKJ m'8IDW<?>.j HKJL< HNDW_`@)JLHNAW<EHNM 9IHN[L<E[�jN@B_`>#UNJL[���qQUaD/@

_`UaDZ>#Ua8/J<E[�UaDW@4J1@B[1VWHKFP@BAGJ1U �-UNO�>1V/@*:=HK>#Jh< �� ���dt

UaD/@�>1VWHK>�FWJLU j'<EA/@B[�H � D/@B<?]aVZ9 UNJhV/UZU'A(� J1@BMEHK>1<?UaD � �2/��/OQUNJ�>#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVW<E_^HNM7UNJ1]aHNDI<E[1HK>1<?UaDfmaHN[ �<EMEMa9P@0[1V/U �$D

HNDWHNM?b7>1<E_^HNMEMEb <EDd�7@B_`>1<EUaDC�1�1� � ���

��VW@�AI<E[1_`J1@^>1< %^@BA OQUNJL:e8WMEHK>1<?UaDY< [�_`UaDTjN@BDW<E@BDT>&OQJ1Ua:(>1V/@0FP@^JL[1F @B_`>1<[email protected]_`Ua:YFI8W>1HK>1<?UaDWHNM'>#JLHN_`>1HK9I< ME<?>kb

qs<EDZ>#@^]NJLHNME[�J1@BAW8W_`@�>#U [18W:l:=HK>1<?UaDW[hthmZHN[�A/@B:=UaDW[#>#JLHK>#@BA <ED=AW<E[L_`J1@^>#@$ME<EDW@BHKJ�:YU'A/@BM/OQUNJL:\8IMEHK>1<?UaDW[ �<?>1VW<ED

>1V/@Y��ME<EDWA �7Ua8/JL_`@=�7@^FIHKJhHK>1<?UaD6qs�0�I�Wt�AWUa:=HN<ED �Sp.- � m �SpBn$- � � OQUNJ����W� �$<?>1V AW< [1_`J1@^>#@ [#Ua8/JL_`@B[^mP>1V/@�� �

jN@B_`>#UNJL[.HKJ1@_`Ua:=F Ua[1@BAYUNOfHNMEM/FPUa[1[1<?9;M?@0_`Ua:*9I< DWHK>1<?UaDW[�UNOP>1V/@$@BM?@B:Y@BDZ>1[&UNOP>1V/@$AW< _`>1<?UaDWHKJ1beUNOP>1V/@$MEHK>#@BDZ>

jKHKJL<EHK9IM?@0jN@B_`>#UNJ �&� Dl9PUN>1Vl_^HN[#@B[.>1V/@$M HK>#@BDT>.j HKJh<EHK9IM?@ # �)_^HNDl>1H �N@�UaDlH)R DW<?>#@�D78W:*9P@^J�q6��t�UNOPF Ua[L[1<?9IM?@jKHNME8/@B[�HNDWAYHN[�[18W_hV >1V/@0[1HN:Y@�OQUNJL:=HNM'>#@BHK>1:Y@BDZ>�<E[�FPUa[1[1<?9;M?@!��".UaDW[1@BXZ8/@BDZ>1M?b4@BX78WHK>1<?UaDiq<-��Ep t�<E[�HNME[#U�>1V/@

OQUNJL:=HNM�A/@B[1_`Jh<?FW>1<?UaD UNO�>1V/@=M HK>#@BDT>4AW< [#>#JL<?9I8W>1<?UaDiOQUNJ)>1V/@Y_^HN[#@=UNO.MEHK>#@BDT>)>#JhHN<?>4:YU'A/@BME[��*�U �.@^jN@^JBm�>1V/@

MEHK>#@BDZ>�>#JLHN<?>:=U7A/@BM�<E[�H � ���S��� �s����� ����:=< '>18/J1@e:YU7AW@BM � nKo�� mfHN[�>1V/@ :=< '>18/J1@\_`@BDZ>#@^JL[ � q���� � t�_^HNDID/UN>:YU jN@\<EDWAW@^F @BDIA/@BDT>1MEbYOgJ1Ua: @BHN_LV UN>1V/@^J�9I8/>�HKJL@*_`UaDW[#>#JLHN< D/@BAG9ZbG>1V/@)F;HKJLHN:Y@^>#@^J:lHK>#JL< � �

/2�

Page 70: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

�� � � � ���� � ��� � ��� � � ��� �� �� ��� ��� � � � � ��� � ��� � � �� � ����"��5�

��VW@iHN[1[18W:YFI>1<?UaD U jN@^J >1V/@dAW<E[1>#JL<?9I8/>1<EUaD UNO�>1V/@iD/Ua<E[1@iA/@`R;D/@B[ >1V/@d>kb7F @CUNO�AWHK>1H�>1VW@d:YU'A/@BM0<E[

[18W<E>1HK9IM?@eOgUNJ4HNDWA�HNM [#UC<E:YFIME<E@B[$>1V/@ OQUNJL: UNO.>1V/@YME<ED��COs8WDW_`>1<?UaD JL@BXZ8W<EJ1@BA �SpNp�� � m��$VW< _LV <E[�ME<ED/@BHKJ�UaDWMEb

OQUNJ4>1V/@ ��HN8I[1[1<EHND _^HN[1@!� � U7A/@BM ME<ED/]�>1V/@lD/Ua< [#@=HN[4<EDWAW@^F @BDIA/@BDT>)HNDWA�< A/@BDT>1< _^HNMEM?b AI<E[#>#JL<?9;8/>#@BA6qs< � < � A�� t

��HN8W[L[1<EHNDfm FWJ1U j7<EAW@B[$HND HNDWHNM?b7>1<E_^HNMEM?bG>#JLHN_`>1HK9;M?@e[1UaME8/>1<?UaDfm �$VW<E_hVdFIJ1U jN@BA,>#U�9 @e8W[#@^Os8WM OQUNJ):YU'A/@BMEME<EDW]

_`UaDZ>1<EDZ8WUa8W[�AWHK>1H'mW9;8/>�<E[0_^M?@BHKJLMEb�<EDIHKFWFWJ1UNFWJh<EHK>#@OQUNJ$AW< [1_`J1@^>#@*AWHK>1H��

!/UNJ�>1V/@d[LH �N@iUNO)[1<E:YFIM <E_^<?>kb HNDWA ]N@BD/@^JhHNME<?>kbNm�>1V/@d@� 7FPUaD/@BDZ>1<EHNM�OsHN:=<EM?b UNO)AW<E[#>#JL<E9I8/>1<?UaDW[��$<EMEM�9P@

_`UaDW[1< A/@^J1@BA,OgUNJ\:YU7AW@BMEME<ED/] >1V/@=D/Ua<E[1@ AI8/JL<ED/] >1V/@=A/@^JL<Ej HK>1<?UaD,UNO.>1V/@=HNM?]NUNJL<E>1VW:��\�$V/@���HN8W[1[1< HND�AW<E[ �

>#JL<?9;8/>1<?UaDr< [*H [#FP@B_^<EHNM�_^HN[1@�>1VIHK>eJL@BAW8W_`@B[\>#U �)��� OQUNJ\>1V/@GMEHK>#@BDZ> >#JLHN<?> :YU7AW@BM�HNDWA H,:=< '>18/J1@lUNO

��HN8W[L[1<EHNDW[)qs[#UNOQ>0jN@^JL[1<?UaD�UNO�3 �k:Y@BHNDW[0_^ME8I[#>#@^JL<ED/]Zt �Sp 4 �fOQUNJ0>1V/@)MEHK>#@BDT>�_^M HN[1[.OgUNJL:e8WMEHK>1<EUaD��&��:YF;VWHN[1<E[#@

�$<EM MP9 @*UaDiFIHKJ1>1< _^8WMEHKJ$_^HN[#@B[>1VWHK>�HKJ1@\[18I<?>1HK9IM?@)OQUNJ�_^HK>#@^]NUNJh<E_^HNM�AWHK>1H'm;HN[>1V/@B[#@e_^HND HNME[1U=9P@*:YU'A/@BM?@BA

97b�:Y@B:\9P@^JL[0UNO�>1V/@4@� 'FPUaD/@BDT>1< HNMPOQHN:=< M?b!�

��V78W[^mWME@^> ��q� � � ���Kt�9 @)OQJ1Ua: >1VW@4@� 7FPUaD/@BDZ>1<EHNMfOsHN:=<EMEblUNO�AW<E[#>#Jh<?9I8/>1<?UaDI[����$V/@4@� 'F UaDW@BDT>1<EHNM OQHN:=< M?bUNO�AW<E[#>#Jh<?9I8/>1<?UaDI[�VWHN[0>1VW@4OQ8IDW_`>1<?UaDWHNMPOQUNJL: � -WmA� � m+�$VW<E_hVCA/@^FP@BDWAW[�UaDC>1V/@4_^8I:\8WM HNDT>0Os8WDW_`>1<?UaD �

����q���� �ft @� 7F � � � % �=q �ft�� �&�Nq���t q<-����at

�$V/@^JL@���<E[e_^HNMEM?@BA >1V/@CDWHK>18/JLHNM�qs_^HND/UaDW< _^HNMgt*FIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^JYUNO>1V/@G@� 7FPUaD/@BDZ>1<EHNM.AW<E[#>#JL<E9I8/>1<?UaDfm �=q �ft � �q � @� 'F�q � ��t �&�Nq���t� ��t�<E[�>1VW@�_^8W:\8IMEHNDT>�Os8WDW_`>1<EUaDYHNDWAY<E[�H)[#>#JL< _`>1M?b\_`UaDZjN@� =OQ8IDW_`>1<?UaD UNO���mZHNDWA �&�Nq���t<E[0HYOsHN_`>#UNJ�<EDWA/@^FP@BDWA/@BDZ>.UNO�>1V/@*FIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^JL[ ��!&J1U'AW8W_`>1[�9P@^> ��@^@BDdjN@B_`>#UNJL[AW@BD/UN>#@*A/UN>�FIJ1U7AI8W_`>1[��

��DlUa8WJ�_`UaDIAW<?>1<?UaDWHNMIFWJ1UN9IHK9;<EME<?> b\OQUNJL:e8WMEHK>1<?UaD UNO >1V/@�D/Ua<E[#@�� � q� � � ��� � �Cthm'>1V/@�DWHK>18/JLHNM;FIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^J�$<EM M 9P@\HN[1[L8W:Y@BA,>#U 9P@ H�FIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^JL< %^@BA,M <ED/@BHKJ:l< '< D/]lUNO&>1VW@e_`Ua:YFPUaD/@BDZ>1[�UNO&>1V/@eFPUa[1[1<?9;M?@*MEHK>#@BDZ>

jN@B_`>#UNJL[ ���TmW>1VZ8I[ � � ��� �Zm �$VW@^J1@ � <E[�>1V/@4FIHKJhHN:Y@^>#@^J:=HK>#Jh< UNO�>1V/@)>#JLHN<E>$:YU'A/@BM �

����q��� � ��� � �it @� 'F � ��� � �� % �=q���� �Nt�� �&�Nq���'t q<-��1-Zt

��VW@\]NJLHNAI<?@BDT>�jN@B_`>#UNJ4UNO�>1V/@Y_^8W:\8IMEHNDT>�Os8WDW_`>1<?UaD$�$<?>1V J1@B[#FP@B_`>�>#UG>1V/@YDWHK>18/JLHNM�FIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^J�� � �����TmW>#@^JL:Y@BAC>1VW@4@� 7FP@B_`>1HK>1<?UaDdFIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^J m �$<EMEM 9P@)A/@BD/UN>#@BAd9Zb � �

� ��/ �&q������Kt � ����� �=q���� �Nt q<-���/at

�$V/@^JL@ ��

A/@BD/UN>#@B[0>1V/@*]NJLHNAW<?@BDZ>0UNFP@^JLHK>#UNJHNDWA��&q t�< [�>#@^JL:Y@BAi>1VW@4<EDTjN@^Jh[#@*ME<ED �=OQ8IDW_`>1<?UaD �SpNp���� �

/ �

Page 71: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

�.bi>1V/@*RIJL[#>�:YUa:Y@BDZ>�< A/@BDT>1<E>kbGOgUNJ�M?UN] �kME< �N@BME<EV/U7U7AiOQ8WDI_`>1<?UaDW[$HKFIFIME<?@BAC>#U�>1V/@\@� 7FPUaD/@BDZ>1<EHNM�OQHN:=< M?b

UNO�AW<E[#>#JL<E9I8/>1<?UaDW[ �1����<?>�< [ �7D/U �$DC>1VWHK> ���e<E[�>1V/@4:=@BHNDiUNO�_^MEHN[1[ �C8IDWA/@^J�>1V/@*AW< [#>#JL<?9I8W>1<?UaD ��q� � � ���Kt �

� � � � � ��� � q<-���0at

�$V/@^JL@ A/@BD/UN>#@B[0>1VW@4JLHNDWA/Ua: jN@B_`>#UNJUNO�UN9I[#@^J1jKHK>1<?UaDW[$HNDWA � � �\<E[�>1V/@4@� 'FP@B_`>1HK>1<?UaDiUNFP@^JLHK>#UNJ �� >�<E[�HNME[#U��7D/U �$D=OQJ1Ua: >1V/@[#@B_`UaDIA :YUa:=@BDT>.<EA/@BDZ>1<?>kbYOQUNJ�M?UN] �kM < �N@BME<EV/U7U'A OQ8WDI_`>1<?UaDW[�HKFIFIME<?@BA >#Ue>1V/@

@� 'F UaDW@BDT>1<EHNM OQHN:=< M?b UNO�AW< [#>#JL<?9I8W>1<?UaDW[ �1��� mI>1VWHK>$>1V/@*@� 'FP@B_`>#@BAijKHNME8/@4UNO�>1V/@*�@B[1[1< HNDiUNO�>1V/@*_^8W:e8WMEHNDZ>

Os8WDW_`>1<?UaD �$<?>1VlJ1@B[#FP@B_`>�>#U ��� �Zm/<E[�>1VW@�_`U j HKJL< HNDW_`@):=HK>#JL< =UNO�_^M HN[1[ �l8WDIA/@^J�>1V/@�AW<E[1>#JL<?9I8/>1<EUaD���q� � ���Nt< � @!�?mW>1VW@ !�< [1V/@^J$<EDWOgUNJL:lHK>1<?UaDG:=HK>#JL< ����VW< [.:lHK>#JL< �$<EMEM 9P@)A/@BD/UN>#@BAi97b � �0�

� ��/ � ��� ��� �� ��� � � ��� � q<-�� 4Nt

�� � �� � ��� �� � � � � � ��� � � � � � � � ��� ��� "��5�

�'8I:=:=HKJL< %B< D/]/mZ>1VW@*:YU'A/@BMP>1H �N@B[$>1VW@)OgUaMEMEU �$<EDW]eOQUNJL:�/

� ��q������'t � � q<-����at

�$V/@^JL@�� � HKJL@�>1V/@r8WD/UN9;[#@^J1jN@BA MEHK>#@BDZ>ijKHKJL<EHK9IM?@B[GUNJ [#Ua8/JL_`@B[^m �$VI<E_LV >1H �N@ UaD � F Ua[L[1<?9IM?@,jKHNME8/@B[

� ��� � � �� ��� � � < � @!�?mD/UaD�� ��HN8W[1[1< HNDWM?b6AW<E[#>#Jh<?9I8/>#@BA 8IDWA/@^Jl>1VW@ �)��� �kM < �N@,M HK>#@BDT>�>#JLHN<?>GHN[1[18W:=FW>1<?UaDfm

HNDWAiHl:=< '>18/J1@�UNO�AW@BM?>1HYOs8WDW_`>1<?UaDW[0_`@BDZ>#@^J1@BA HK>$_`UNJLD/@^JL[�UNO�HND ��AW< :Y@BDW[1<?UaDIHNM;VZbZFP@^JL_^8W9 @)8WDIA/@^J0>1V/@MEHK>#@BDZ>._^M HN[1[�HN[1[18W:YFI>1<?UaD�����V/@:lHK>#JL< � _^HND�9P@_`UaDI[1<EA/@^J1@BA�HN[�H\MEUaHNAW<ED/]*:lHK>#JL< Pm7HNDWA >1V/@�:=< '>18/J1@

OQUNJL:Y@BA 97b >1V/@CME< D/@BHKJ >#JLHNDW[#OQUNJL: � <E[ >1V/@BD6D/UaDIME<ED/@BHKJLMEb�>#JLHNDW[#OQUNJL:Y@BA 97b ��q t <ED >1V/@C]N@BD/@^JhHK>1<?jN@

FWJ1U'_`@B[1[^m �$V/@^JL@ �&q thm�<E[\A/@`R;D/@BAr<EDcq<-���/at\HNDWArVIHN[*<?>1[\:=HK>1_LVW< D/] D/Ua< [#@ � �C� O � < [ ��HN8W[L[1<EHNDfm�>1V/@BD� < [\>1VW@i<EA/@BDZ>1<?>kbNm�HNDIA >1V/@����� q �$VW<E_hV _^HND6HNM [#U�9P@ j'<?@��.@BA6HN[YH j HKJL< HNDT> UNO�D/Ua<E[#brM <ED/@BHKJe�#"��

�Sp��54��Qt<E[�J1@B_`U jN@^J1@BA��e��V/@YMEHK>#@BDZ>�>#JhHN<?>):YU7AW@BM�8W[L<ED/]GD/UaD�� ��HN8W[L[1<EHND,D/Ua<E[#@Y_^HND 9P@e[1@^@BD�HN[)H jKHKJL<EHNDZ>

UNO�D/UaDWME<EDW@BHKJ��1"�� �$<?>1V�H-�;�#�B�#2s� ��� J ��� ���#���3��� ��� ���<� 4 m.�VW<E_LV�_`UaDZ>#JLHKJ1b >#UC>1V/@=8I[18WHNM�D/UaDWM <ED/@BHKJ��#"��

HKFWFWJLUaHN_LV/@B[^mfVWHN[�<?>1[�D/Ua<E[1@\:YU'A/@BM�HNM <?]aD/@BA >#U >1V/@ :YU'A/@BM � [�D/UaDWME< D/@BHKJL<?> b!�$�[OsHKJ�HN[�>1V/@ MEHK>#@BDZ>�_^M HN[1[

:YU'A/@BM�< [_`UaDW_`@^JhD/@BAfm j HNME8W@B[$UNO�@BHN_hV ���YHKJ1@e_^HND/UaDW<E_^HNM�8WDW<?>$jN@B_`>#UNJL[)HNDWA >1VZ8W[�[1<E:=FIM?bG[#@BM?@B_`>�UaD/@\UNO

>1V/@=_`UaME8I:=DW[�UNO0:=HK>#JL< �$�=��V/@^J1@^OQUNJ1@Nm >1V/@ � �,< D q<-����at4_^HND 9P@)��JL<?>#>#@BD Ua8/>1[1<EA/@ >1V/@=DWUaDWME<ED/@BHKJh<?>kbNm

HNDWA�>1V/@):YU'A/@BM 9P@B_`Ua:Y@B[0ME<ED/@BHKJ �� � q��it��� � � �&��V/@�:YU'A/@BM 9P@B_`Ua:Y@B[0<ED�>1VW<E[�_^HN[#@4HeFIHKJLHN:=@^>#JL<E_:=< '>18/J1@�:YU'A/@BM m �$V/@^J1@)_`UaME8I:=DW[�UNO ��q��Ct�HKJL@)>1V/@)_^MEHN[1[0:Y@BHNDW[ ��� D�>1VW<E[�_^HN[#@NmI>1V/@)HNM?]NUNJL<?>1VW: OQUNJ0>1V/@

:YU'A/@BM RI>#>1<EDW]=<E[0[18W<?>1HK9;M?@�OgUNJ$_^M 8W[#>#@^JL<EDW]��

0Ko

Page 72: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

!�<EDWHNM M?bNm$<?>G[1V/Ua8WM A 9P@,DWUN>#@BA >1VWHK>CH Os8WMEMEb ��H bN@B[1<EHND >#J1@BHK>1:=@BDT>CUNO\>1V/@,_^M HN[1[C:YU'A/@BMEME<EDW]�>1VWHK>

<EDW_^M 8WA/@B[�>1V/@�@B[#>1<E:lHK>1<?UaD UNOe>1V/@rD78W:*9P@^JCUNO _^MEHN[1[#@B[d<E[iA/@B[1_`Jh<?9P@BA < D �1�'p � �1�Nn�� � ��VI<E[�>#J1@BHK>1:Y@BDZ>

A/U7@B[�D/UN>0VWHBjN@4HNDZb=>#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVW< _^HNM _^HKF;HK9I<EME<?> b!����V/@��.H bN@B[1<EHNDCOQJLHN:Y@��.UNJ���_`Ua8WMEA 9 @�@� '>#@BDWA/@BAG>#U >1V/@

_`UaDW[#>#JhHN<ED/@BAe:=< '>18/J1@�_^HN[#@NmNOQUNJ�@B[#>1<E:=HK>1<EDW]$>1V/@.UNFW>1<E:=HNMZDZ8I:*9P@^J�UNOI]NJL<EA4FPUa<EDZ>1[ OQUNJ�>1V/@�>#UNFPUN]NJLHKF;VW<E_^HNM

:=HKFWF;<ED/]/m/V/U �.@^jN@^J�>1VW<E[0<E[�Ua8/>1[L<EA/@)>1V/@*[L_`UNF @)UNO�>1VW< [ ��UNJ�� �

� ��� � ��� � � � � ��� �������

��[4D/UGUNJLA/@^Jh<ED/]G9P@^> �.@^@BD�>1V/@=AWHK>1HGFPUa<EDZ>1[�<E[)HN[1[18W:=@BAfmf>1V/@=M?UN] �kME< �N@BME<EV/U7U7A Os8WDW_`>1<?UaD,UNO.>1V/@YUN9��

[#@^J1jKHK9IM?@B[$<E[�]a<?jN@BDiHN[

� ��� �� M?UN] � ��q , � t��

��� �� M?UN]

��� �� ��q� � � ���Nt��lq ���Nt

�$V/@^JL@ � �GHKJ1@lVW< AWA/@BD jKHKJL<EHK9IM?@B[ qs:YUNJ1@lFIJ1@B_^<E[#@BM?bNm�>1V/@ D/UaDIME<ED/@BHKJ4<E:lHK]N@B[4UNO�>1V/@lVW< AWA/@BD ]NJL<EA F Ua< DT>

jKHKJL<EHK9IM?@B[ t ���$V/@^J1@^OQUNJ1@*>1V/@e:=H� /<E:=<E[1HK>1<EUaDi_^HND,9 @\[#UaM?jN@BA 9ZbC>1V/@e� 'FP@B_`>1HK>1<?UaD �,H� /<E:=< %BHK>1<?UaD qs����t

HNM?]NUNJL<E>1VW: �1�2��� m �Sp 4�� �SpNp.- � ����D HN_^_`UNJLAIHNDW_`@>#Ue>1V/@���� :Y@^>1V/U'A/UaM?UN]NbNm/<EDI[#>#@BHNA=UNO :=H� /<E:=< %B<ED/]4>1V/@�M?UN]

ME< �N@BM <EV/U7U7AC>1VW@\J1@BM HK>1<?jN@\ME< �N@BME<EV/U7U7A �Sp 4 � �1�2��� �SpNp.- ��_^HND,9P@\:=H� /<E:=< %^@BAfm �VW<E_LV A/U7@B[�DWUN>�_`UaDZ>1HN<ED,>1V/@

M?UN]YUNO�H=[18I:��&��V/@�J1@BMEHK>1<EjN@*ME< �N@BME< V/UZU'A 9 @^> ��@^@BDdUaMEAiHNDWACDW@���FIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^Jh[$<E[�>1V/@*OgUaMEMEU �$<EDW]�/

� ��� ��

��� �� � ����� q ��� � � t7M?UN] � �

� ��� q , � � ���Nt�� � �� q ���Nt�� q<-�� �at

�$V/@^JL@

� � � / � � � � q ��� � ��'t ��q , � � # �Nt��lq=# �at� �� � �� ��q , � � # � � t�� q=# � � t q<-��Ep^oTt

<E[@B[#>1<E:=HK>#@BA,<ED >1V/@\� [1>#@^F UNO&>1VW@\HNM?]NUNJL<E>1VW:Cm 9 @B< D/]l_`UaDW[1< A/@^J1@BAdHN[�_`UaDW[1>1HNDT>)<EDd>1V/@e:lH� '<E:l<E[1HK>1<?UaD

FIVWHN[1@YUNJ\� �k[#>#@^F��l� >4J1@^FIJ1@B[#@BDZ>1[)>1V/@=J1@B[1F UaDI[1<?9I<EM <?>kbCUNO�_^MEHN[1[ � <ED�]N@BD/@^JLHK>1< D/]i>1V/@YUN9I[1@^J1j HK>1<EUaD , � m

< � @!�?mW>1VW@)FWJ1UN9IHK9I< ME<E[#>1<E_MEHK9P@BMPUNO�AIHK>18W: , �+�

$@^FIMEHN_^<ED/]���q , � � ��� t�9Zb�q<-��1-Zthm;@BX78WHK>1<?UaD q<-�� �at�9P@B_`Ua:Y@B[�/

� ��� ��

��� �� � � � � � ��� � % �=q������Kt � MEUN];q � � q� � t#t � M?UN];q � � ��� q ���Nt#t�� q<-��EpNp t

��UY_`Ua:YFIM?@^>#@�>1V/@)� �k[#>#@^Fi<ED�HeM HK>#@BDT>�>#JLHN<?>�:YU'A/@BM � D/@^@BAW[.>#U 9P@�:=H� /<E:=< %^@BA <ED >1V/@)MEHK>#@BDZ>�>#JLHN<?>FIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^J �$� !/UNJ*_^ME8I[#>#@^JL<ED/] �$<E>1V�HC_^MEHN[1[4:YU'A/@BM m�UaD/@=<E[):=HN<EDIM?bd<EDZ>#@^J1@B[#>#@BA <ED A/@^>#@^JL:=<EDI<ED/] ���

OQUNJ�HNM M � p ��� ��� D,>1VW<E[�_^HN[#@Nmf:=H� /<E:=<E[L<ED/]=>1V/@ ME< �N@BM <EV/U7U7Ai< Di>1V/@e@� 7FP@B_`>1HK>1<?UaD F;HKJLHN:Y@^>#@^J�]a<?jN@B[)H

_^M?Ua[#@BAiOgUNJL: J1@B[18WM?>�OQUNJ$>1V/@4� �k[#>#@^F�����V/@4MEHK>#@BDZ>�>#JLHN<?>:YU7AW@BMf<E[�FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>#@BACR;JL[#>��

0'p

Page 73: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

���� �� � � � ��� � � ����� � � � � ��� � �

��DGH\MEHK>#@BDZ>�>#JLHN<?>�:YU'A/@BM m7>1V/@]NJhHNAW<?@BDZ>.UNO�>1V/@�AI<E[#>#JL<?9;8/>1<?UaD(� [&_^8I:\8WM HNDT>.OQ8IDW_`>1<?UaD�A/UZ@B[�:YU'A/@BM;>1V/@

_^MEHN[1[\@� 'F @B_`>1HK>1<EUaDW[��d��H �7< D/]d>1V/@�A/@^JL<?jKHK>1<?jN@ UNO � �<?>1V J1@B[1F @B_`>\>#U >1VW@lFIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^J�� UaD/@ UN9I>1HN<EDW[

OQJ1Ua: >1V/@)@BM?@B:=@BDT> � � �� ���� � � �

���

� � � � � � % � � q������Nt�� � � � q<-��EpBnat

�$V/@^JL@ � � < [)>1V/@�� ��� _`Ua:YFPUaD/@BDZ>4UNO�>1V/@=jN@B_`>#UNJYHKJ1]a8W:=@BDT>4jN@B_`>#UNJeOs8WDW_`>1<?UaD ��q thm�HN[ ��HN[\A/@`R D/@BA�<EDq<-���/at �.� DG@BX78W<?jKHNM?@BDZ>�:=HK>#JL< CD/UN>1HK>1<?UaD

� �� � � � � � % �&q����it � � � � q<-��Ep��at

�$V/@^JL@ � <E[�H � � AW<EHK]NUaDWHNM�:=HK>#Jh< dOQUNJL:Y@BA 97b � � � � � � � � m � q � � � t� ���� ��� � ���� � HNDWA�<E[�>1V/@�FWJL@^j7<?Ua8I[1M?blA/@`R D/@BAGAWHK>1HY:=HK>#JL< ��� V/@BDC>1V/@)D/Ua<E[1@�< [0<E[#UN>#J1UNFI< _ �)HN8W[1[1<EHND �<?>1VG8WDW<?>.j HKJh<EHNDW_`@

>1V/@BDC>1VW@4:=HK>1_LVW< D/]=Os8WDW_`>1<?UaD ��q t�<E[0HNDi< A/@BDT>1<E>kbNmWHNDWAi< DG>1VW<E[0_^HN[#@Nm;9ZbG[#@^>#>1<ED/]Y>1VW@*A/@^JL<?jKHK>1<?jN@�@BX78WHNM

>#U %^@^J1UlUaD/@4UN9W>1HN<EDI[0>1V/@4_^M?Ua[#@BAiOgUNJL: � �k[#>#@^F UNO ����� � nKo�� /

� ��� � � � � � � � q<-��Ep.-Zt

��D >1VW@\]N@BD/@^JhHNM�_^HN[1@=V/U �.@^jN@^JBm�D/UaDIME<ED/@BHKJUNFW>1<E:=< %BHK>1<EUaDd>#@B_hVWDW<EX78/@B[�:=HBb 9P@\J1@BX78W<?JL@BA����VI<E[_^HND 9P@

HN_LVI<?@^jN@BAfm&OQUNJ @� 'HN:YF;M?@Nm�8W[1< D/]d<?>#@^JLHK>1<EjN@GME@BHN[#> �k[1X78WHKJ1@B[Y:Y@^>1V/U'AW[ �SpNp���� � �U �.@^jN@^J=>1V/@ ��@BD/@^JLHNM < %^@BA

��� q ������t �SpNp.-Wm pBnKo �PHNM?]NUNJh<?>1VW: <E[�He:YUNJ1@FWJLHN_`>1<E_^HNMP_hV/Ua<E_`@Nm/HN[�_`UaDTjN@^J1]N@BDI_`@)>#UeHeM?U'_^HNM;:=H� /<E:e8W:

<E[ ]a8WHKJhHNDT>#@^@BA 8WF UaD <EDI_`J1@BHN[1<ED/] HNDWA6D/UN>=DW@B_`@B[1[1HKJL<EMEbr:=H� /<E:=< %B<EDW] >1V/@CJL@BMEHK>1<?jN@CME< �N@BME< V/UZU'A�� !/JLUa:

q<-��Ep��at$HY[1<E:YFIME@�]NJhHNAW<?@BDZ>�8/FfAWHK>#@4_^HNDC9P@)UN9W>1HN<ED/@BAiOgUNJ �

� � � � ��� % �&q����it � � � � q<-��Ep�/at

�$VW< _LVi_^HNDd9 @48I[#@BAd<EDCHND <EDWD/@^J�MEUZUNFd< DC>1V/@*� �k[#>#@^F��0��VW< [0[1_^HNM?@B[$HN[��Gq�� � � � ���6q � ��� � � t#t��M?>#@^JLDWHK>1<?jN@BMEbcUaD/@�_^HND�HKFWFP@BHNM�>#U HNDZb D/UaDIME<ED/@BHKJ�UNFW>1<E:=< %BHK>1<?UaD >#@B_LVWDW< XZ8/@Nm�[#Ua:Y@�UNO��$VW<E_hV :=HBb

J1@BX78W<?J1@)_`Ua:YF;8/>1HK>1<?UaDCUNO�>1V/@4�@B[1[1<EHNDd:=HK>#JL< Pm/>1V/@4@BM?@B:=@BDT>1[$UNO.�$VI<E_LVCHKJ1@

� � �� � � � � � � � � �

���

% � � ��

��� � � � � � � q�� ���Kt � � � � � � � �

���

% � � �Zq � � � � t� � � � � � � �!/UNJ>1V/@4[#FP@B_^<EHNMf_^HN[#@4UNO�9I<EDIHKJ1blUN9I[1@^J1j HK>1<EUaDW[^mWH jKHKJL<EHK>1<?UaDWHNMfHKFIFWJ1U /<E:=HK>1<EUaDG>#U=>1V/@4�.@^JLD/Ua8WM ME<PME< �N@BME< �

V/U7U7A,[1<E:l<EMEHKJ$>#UG>1VWHK>�<ED �Sp�/2����VWHN[�9P@^@BD @B:=FIM?U bN@BA <ED �1/$- ��>#UGUN9W>1HN<ED HG_^M?Ua[#@BA,OgUNJh: � �k[#>#@^F �$VW< _LV

0Nn

Page 74: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

[1_^HNM?@B[*HN[ �Gq6� �eq n � � p � n �.t ��� � �Bt �=�UN>#@ V/U ��@^jN@^J m�>1VWHK>48IDWME< �N@ >1V/@=:YU'A/@BM�UNO��Sp�/2��� m�HND HKF��FWJ1U '< :=HK>1<?UaD >#U�>1VW@ M < �N@BME<EV/U7U'Ai<E[�D/UN>)H D/@B_`@B[L[1<?>kb,V/@^J1@NmfHN[)HG[1HN:YFIM <ED/]=>#@B_hVWDW<EX78/@eOgJ1Ua: >1V/@ MEHK>#@BDZ>

[#FIHN_`@�<E[&HNA/UNFI>#@BA HNDZb ��HBb <EDY>1VW<E[�:YU7AW@BMIHNDWAY>1VW@$>1V/@ ��@BD/@^JLHNME< %^@BA=��� ]a8WHKJhHNDT>#@^@B[.>1V/@�_`UaDTjN@^J1]N@BDI_`@

8/FPUaD >1V/@�ME< �N@BME<EVWUZU'A,9 @B< D/]C<E:YFWJ1U jN@BArHNDWArD/UN>*D/@B_`@B[1[LHKJL<EM?b :=H� /<E:=< %^@BA < D�@BHN_LV ��� <?>#@^JLHK>1<EUaD�� ��D

>1V/@4@� 'FP@^JL<E:Y@BDZ>1[�J1@^FPUNJ1>#@BAi< DG>1VW<E[0_LVIHKFW>#@^J$>1V/@)]NJhHNAW<?@BDZ>$<EDWD/@^J0M?U7UNFd� �k[#>#@^F ��HN[�@B:=FIM?U bN@BA��

��U UN9I[#@^J1jN@G>1VWHK> <EDWA/@^@BA >1V/@G_`UNJ1J1@BMEHK>1<EUaDW[e9 @^> ��@^@BD >1VW@�� � AI<E:Y@BDW[1<EUaDW[4_`UaDW[#>1<E>18/>#@G>1V/@ � DW@B<?]aV��9PUNJLV/U7U7A � � �2/��)J1@BMEHK>1<EUaDW[lJL@BXZ8W<EJ1@BAcOQUNJCH >#UNF UN]NJhHKFIVW<E_^HNM�UNJ1]aHNDW< [1HK>1<?UaDfm$_`UaDI[1<EA/@^JCV/U � >1VW@ DIHK>18/JLHNM

FIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^J � �\:=U7AW<?RI@B[�8WDWA/@^J�HY]NJhHNAW<?@BDZ>�8/FfAWHK>#@)UNO �$���$VW<E[0<E[

� � ��� �� ��� ��� � ������ � �

��� ��

��� � �� q� � % � � � t � � � � � � � � � � q<-��Ep�0at

�$VW< _LV�<E[�HNDIHNM?UN]NUa8W[�>#U >1V/@4�7@BM?O���JL]aHNDW<E[1<EDW]*� HKF q �W�)� t � �2/�� 8/FfAWHK>#@!����V/@ �$<EAW>1V=UNO�>1VW@�D/@B<E]aVT9PUNJ��

V/U7U7A=J1@BMEHK>1<?UaDW[�:=HNA/@$8WF=9Zb � � � <E[&HNME[1U*_`UaDT>#JLUaMEM?@BA=97b >1V/@$JL@B[#FPUaDW[1<?9I< ME<?>kb)jKHNME8/@B[ � � � mZHN[.AW<E[L_^8W[1[#@BA<ED � nKo�� �

��VW@l@B[#>1<E:lHK>#@B[*UNO�MEHK>#@BDZ>eFWJL<?UNJL[ � � ����q ���Kt4_^HND 9P@=OQUa8WDWAr9Zb�_`UaDW[1>#JLHN<ED/@BA :=H� /<E:=<E[1HK>1<EUaD�UNO�"em

HN[C>1V/@rFWJ1UN9IHK9I< ME<?>1<?@B[�:\8I[#>i[18W: >#U UaDW@!� ��VZ8I[^m>1VW@rXZ8IHNDT>1<?> b�>#U�:=H� '< :=< %^@�<E[iD/U � �� � �

� q � �� �� � � ����q ���Nt % p t �V/@^J1@ � <E[)>1VW@ ��HK]NJhHND/]N@�:e8WM?>1<EFIME<?@^J �=��H �'<ED/]i>1V/@ ]NJLHNAW<?@BDZ> �$<E>1V�J1@B[#FP@B_`>>#U � � ��� q ���Nthm;[1@^>#>1<ED/]l<?>$>#U�%^@^J1U�HNDWAd[18I:=:=<ED/] U jN@^J �iM?@BHNAW[�>#U >1V/@*[#>1HNDIAWHKJLAd8WFPAIHK>#@)UNO�>1V/@*MEHK>#@BDZ>

FWJL<EUNJL[�/ � � �� q ���Kt �� � �� �� � � � ���$V/@4MEHK>#@BDZ>$_^MEHN[1[�[1UaME8/>1<?UaD �$< MEM 9 @)D/U � _`UaDW[L<EA/@^J1@BA��

���� � � � � ��� � � � �� � � � ��� � �

� [L<E:=<EMEHKJ�[1UaME8/>1<?UaD _^HND 9P@e8W[#@BA OgUNJ�_^ME8W[#>#@^Jh<ED/]=97bi[1HN:YFIM <ED/]YOQJ1Ua: >1VW@e_`UNJLDW@^JL[$UNO�H VZbZFP@^JL_^8W9 @

JLHK>1V/@^J.>1VWHND >1V/@$]NJh<EA�� !/UNJ0_^MEHN[1[.:YU7AW@BMEME<ED/])<?>.<E[�[L8 � _^<?@BDZ>&>#U :=H� '< :=< %^@�>1V/@�ME< �N@BME< V/UZU'A)�$<?>1VlJ1@B[#FP@B_`>

>#U=>1V/@*@� 7FP@B_`>1HK>1<?UaDdFIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^JBm+�$VW<E_hVG]a<?jN@B[�>1V/@)OQUaMEM?U �$<ED/]�/

� �� � �

� � �� ��

� � � q� � % ���Kt q<-��Ep 4Nt

�$V/@^JL@ � �0<E[�>1V/@�!�<E[1V/@^J�<ED/OQUNJL:=HK>1<?UaD\:=HK>#JL< 4OQUNJ�_^MEHN[1[ � maHN[.��HN[�AW<E[1_^8I[1[#@BA*< DT>#U>1V/@�FIJ1@^j7<EUa8W[�[1@B_`>1<?UaD���7@^>#>1<EDW]�>1VW@B[#@0@BXZ8IHNM/>#U %^@^J1U4HNDWA=[1UaM?j7< D/]OQUNJ&HNMEM�� ��]a<EjN@B[�>1V/@��,H� '<E:e8W: ��< �N@BME<EV/U7U'A�qs�,��t�@B[#>1< :=HK>#@

OQUNJ�>1V/@4@� 'FP@B_`>1HK>1<?UaDiFIHKJhHN:Y@^>#@^JL[^m �VW<E_LVC< DC:=HK>#JL< �OgUNJL:lHK>�9P@B_`Ua:Y@B[

� � ��� � � � � q<-��Ep��at

02�

Page 75: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

�$V/@^JL@ � <E[0H � � :=HK>#JL< �OQUNJL:Y@BAC97bG>1V/@4J1@B[1F UaDI[1<?9I<EM <?>1<?@B[ � � � m � <E[�H � � AW< HK]NUaDWHNM :=HK>#JL< �$<?>1V >1VW@ � ��� AW<EHK]NUaDWHNM�@BM?@B:=@BDT>)9P@B<ED/] � � � � � HNDWA � <E[�H � � :=HK>#JL< VWHBj'<ED/] � �lHN[*<?>1[ � ���_`UaME8W:lD��i��X78WHK>1<?UaD q<-��Ep��at*_^HND HNME[1Ud9P@=@� 'FWJ1@B[1[#@BA <ED�>#@^Jh:=[*UNO0@B[1>1<E:=HK>#@BA [#@B_`UaDWA UNJLA/@^Je[18 � _^<?@BDZ>

[#>1HK>1<E[1>1<E_^[�� $@B_`UN]aDW< %B<EDW]i>1VWHK> � � � / �� � � � � � � � � HNDWA ����

/ �� � � � ��� � � HKJ1@ >1V/@J1@B[#FP@B_`>1<?jN@_`U jKHKJL<EHNDW_`@�:=HK>#JL<E_`@B[�qQ>1V/@M HK>#>#@^J.V/UaM AW[�OQUNJ�>1V/@$_^M HN[1[�:YU'A/@BM mZHN[ � <E[&HNDl< A/@BDT>1<E>kbY:=HK>#JL< Ithm

HNDWA � � �eA/@BDWUN>#@B[0@� 7FP@B_`>1HK>1<?UaD m�q<-��Ep��at�9P@B_`Ua:Y@B[� � � � � ���

� � q<-��Ep �at

��V/@48WFPAIHK>#@�UNO�>1V/@\MEHK>#@BDT>$FWJL<?UNJL[�<E[$[#>1HNDWAWHKJLA m'HN[<EDG>1V/@4>#JhHN<?>�:YU'A/@BM � [0_^HN[#@!�

���� �� � ��� ��� � � � � � � �

��DC_`UaDW_^ME8W[L<?UaDfm7>1V/@�Ua8/>1ME<ED/@�UNO�>1V/@)_`Ua:*9I< D/@BACMEHK>#@BDZ>0>#JLHN<?>0HNDWAGMEHK>#@BDZ>�_^MEHN[1[0:YU'A/@BMEME< D/]\HNM?]NUNJh<?>1VW:

<E[$]a<?jN@BD,9 @BMEU � � ���� � �$<EMEMfAW@BD/UN>#@e< DW<?>1<EHNM _^M HN[1[ �k:Y@B:\9P@^JL[1VW<?Fd9 @BM <?@^OQ[�U jN@^J�>1V/@ AWHK>1H [1@^>UNJ�H [L8/9I[#@^>

UNO�<?>^m'HNDWA ���� � �$<EM M/A/@BD/UN>#@�>1V/@ qs[L8/9 t [#@^>.UNO AWHK>1HeOgUNJ��$VW< _LV=UaDW@�VWHN[.[#Ua:Y@�<EDW<E>1<EHNM/9P@BME<?@^Os[^maUNJ�MEHK9P@BME[��

� O&D/UlFWJh<?UNJ$<ED/OQUNJL:=HK>1<EUaDi@� /<E[#>1[^m;>1V/@BD����� � � HNDWA � � � � � �$<EM MP9 @e[#@^>�JLHNDWA/Ua:=MEb!����@B_^HN8I[#@eHGn �k�

FWJ1U��#@B_`>1<?UaD OgJLUa: >1V/@\>#JLHN<?>:=U7A/@BM�<E[$[#Ua8W]aVT>�OgUNJj7< [18WHNME<E[LHK>1<?UaDGFI8/J1FPUa[#@B[BmW>1V/@*JL@B[#FPUaDW[1<?9I< ME<?>1<?@B[�UNO�>1V/@

jN@B_`>#UNJYjKHNME8/@B[ ��� � q����Kt �$<EM M�9P@ <EDZ>#@^J1FWJ1@^>#@BA HN[e9P@B<ED/]i>1V/@�FPUa[#>#@^JL<?UNJeFWJ1UN9;HK9I<EME<?>1<E@B[�UNO�>1V/@�]NJL<EAFPUa<EDZ>1[ ���&�

� ���;�(�'� &:+ ��� & �'� ( �

�OQUNJ$MEHK>#@BDZ>$>#JhHN<?>�:YU'A/@BMEME<EDW]�/

� / � � � � " �lq����Kt�/ p �#�

�OQUNJ$MEHK>#@BDZ>_^M HN[1[�:YU'A/@BMEME< D/]�/

� � ��� � q � � � �����

��� � t � q � � � ����

��� � t � � " �lq ���Kt�/ p �#�

� �.� # *$& � #�! � �'� + #0( � � # * > # � #0#

� - � # � ��@B[#>1<E:=HK>#@4>1VW@4J1@B[#FPUaDW[1<E9I<EME<?>1<E@B[�UNO�>1V/@4MEHK>#@BDZ>�j HKJh<EHK9IM?@B[

� ����� q���� � � t ��q , � � B �Kt�� q<B �Nt� �� � �� ��q , � � B � � t��lq<B � � t / � � � � � � � �

� ����� q ��� � ��/t ��q , � � #��Kt��lq=#��Nt� �� � �� ��q , � � #�� � t��lq=# � � t / � � � ���� � �

0$-

Page 76: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

�) - � # � �

�rF;HKJLHN:Y@^>#@^J8WFPAIHK>#@)OgUNJ$M HK>#@BDT>�>#JhHN<?>�:YU'A/@BMEME<EDW]�/

�$<E>#@^JLHK>#@*8WDZ>1<EMf_`UaDZjN@^J1]N@BDW_`@

� � � � ��� � � � � � % �&q�� � t � � ��� � � � � ���UNJ�8W[#@�HNDZb=UN>1V/@^J0D/UaDWME< D/@BHKJ&UNFW>1<E:l< %BHK>1<?UaD FWJ1U'_`@BAW8/J1@�>#UY<EDI_`J1@BHN[#@$>1VW@�ME< �N@BME<EV/U7U7A

�rF;HKJLHN:Y@^>#@^J8WFPAIHK>#@)OgUNJ$M HK>#@BDT>$_^M HN[1[�:YU'A/@BMEME< D/]�/

� � ���� � ���� � � �

� � ������rUNFI>1<?UaDWHNMEM?b�8/FfAWHK>#@)>1V/@4MEHK>#@BDZ>�FWJh<?UNJL[

�� ��� q����Nt

p�

��� �� � � ��� � �� �

�� ��� q ���Nt

p�

��� �� � � � ������ �

��V/@�<EDI<?>1<EHNME< %BHK>1<EUaD�_^HND 9P@ JLHNDWAWUa: UNJdAWHK>1H��kA/@^FP@BDWA/@BDZ>rqs_^MEHN[1[d:Y@B:*9P@^JL[LVW<?F 9 @BM <?@^OQ[�UN9W>1HN< D/@BA HN[

Ua8/>#FI8W>1[&OQJ1Ua: HND/UN>1VW@^J._^MEHN[L[1<SRI@^J t �SpNp�/ � ��� 8W[#@^Os8WMWHNM?>#@^JLDIHK>1<?jN@NmZ<EDl>1V/@$_^HN[#@ �$V/@BD=>1V/@^J1@HKJL@H qs[L:=HNMEMgt

D78W:*9P@^J�UNO*V78W:=HND MEHK9P@BM?@BA�< DW[#>1HNDW_`@B[�HBjKHN<EMEHK9IME@Nm�>1V/@�<EDW<?>1< HNME< %BHK>1<?UaD [1>#@^F _^HND :=H �N@�8W[1@ UNO4>1VW@B[#@

OQUNJ�< DW<?>1<EHNME< [1<ED/] >1V/@Y��� <?>#@^JLHK>1<?UaDW[�OQJ1Ua: H _^MEUa[#@^JlqQ>#UG>1V/@Y:=H� '< :\8W:�t0[#>1HKJ1>1< D/] FPUa<EDZ>^mf< � @!�?mPUaD/@Y_^HND

9I8W< MEAYH\[L8/FP@^J1j7< [#@BAY:Y@^>1V/U'A < D=>1V/@�<EDW<?>1<EHNM < %BHK>1<?UaDY[#>1HK]N@ �SpBn'p � m �1�2��� �&��VW<E[&< [�FIHKJL>1<E_^8WMEHKJLMEb\8W[#@^Os8WM+�$V/@BD

>1V/@ UN9I[#@^JLj HK9IME@ AIHK>1H�HKJL@=VW<?]aV AW<E:Y@BDI[1<?UaDWHNM�HNDWA [#FIHKJL[#@!�\� D,>1VW< [�_^HN[1@Y>1V/@=A/@^FP@BDWA/@BDW_`bCUNO.>1V/@Y���

HNM?]NUNJL<E>1VW: UaDd<EDI<?>1<EHNME< %BHK>1<EUaDW[�< [�J1@B_`UN]aDW< %^@BA HN[�9P@B<ED/]e@^jN@BD :=UNJ1@)FWJ1UaD/Ua8IDW_`@BA �Sp�� ��� �

�UN>#@l>1VWHK>*>1V/@=HNM?]NUNJL<?>1VI: <E[�UNO�>1V/@=[1HN:Y@=OQUNJL: OQUNJ*HNMEM�AIHK>1HC>kb7FP@B[^m�< � @!�?m�OgUNJ*HNM M�D/Ua<E[#@=AW< [#>#JL<?9I8��

>1<?UaDW[4OgJ1Ua: >1V/@=@� 'FPUaD/@BDT>1< HNM�OQHN:=< M?b!�l�U �.@^jN@^JBm&_^HKJ1@ VIHN[)>#Ud9P@Y>1H �N@BD <ED�>1V/@l_^HN[1@=UNO�[#FIHKJL[1@=AWHK>1H'm

9P@B_^HN8W[#@*[1FIHKJL[1<?> b FPUa[#@B[_`@^J1>1HN<ED [#>1HK>1<E[#>1<E_^HNM�FWJ1UN9IME@B:=[0HNDWAi_`UaDW[1@BXZ8/@BDZ>1M?bC>1V/@\� � @B[#>1<E:=HK>1<EUaDiUNO�>1V/@

@� 'F @B_`>1HK>1<EUaDiFIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^J$J1@BX78W<?J1@B[�Os8/J1>1VW@^J�_`UNJ1J1@B_`>1<?UaDW[\qs[#@^@*>1V/@)OQUaMEM?U �$<ED/]Y[18W9I[#@B_`>1<?UaD;t �

� VWHK>)jKHKJL<?@B[ �$<?>1V AW< � @^J1@BDZ>�AWHK>1HG>kb7FP@B[4<E[�>1V/@=D/UaDWM <ED/@BHKJ�OQ8WDI_`>1<?UaD �&q t�<ED,>1V/@YMEHK>#@BDZ>)>#JLHN<?>)� �

[#>#@^F�����VW<E[�<E[�[#>#JL< _`>1M?blJ1@BM HK>#@BAC>#UY>1V/@4AWHK>1HYFPUa<EDZ>�� [�ME< �N@BME< V/UZU'A�<EDG_`Ua:YFI8/>1<EDW]e>1VW@4�c[#>#@^F mW< � @!�?m/>#U=>1V/@

:=HK>1_hVW<ED/]lDWUa<E[#@Nm/UNJ< DGUN>1V/@^J �.UNJLAW[0>#Ul>1V/@*AW<E[L[1<E:=<EM HKJL<?>kb=:=@BHN[18/J1@)9P@^> �.@^@BDdHlAWHK>18W: HNDWAiJ1@^Og@^JL@BDW_`@

FPUa<EDZ>^mZHNA/UNFW>#@BA 97bY>1V/@$FIHKJL>1<E_^8WMEHKJ�:=U7A/@BM ����VI<E[&AW<E[L[1<E:=<EM HKJL<?>kbNma< DY9PUN>1Vl>1V/@)�W��� � �2/��PHNDWAl>1VW@ �����

<E[\>1V/@G��8W_^ME< AW<EHND AW< [#>1HNDW_`@ � <ED >1V/@i�W��� 97b 9P@B<ED/]dDWUaD�� FWJ1UN9IHK9;<EME<E[#>1< _eHNDIA < D ����� 9ZbrAW@BHNME<ED/]

02/

Page 77: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

�$<?>1Vc_`UaDT>1<ED78/Ua8W[ AWHK>1H HNDWA >1V/@^JL@^OgUNJ1@ HN[1[18W:=< D/] ��HN8W[L[1<EHND D/Ua< [#@!� � Dc>1VW<E[=_hVWHKFW>#@^JBm�V/U ��@^jN@^J m�9Zb

OQU7_^8W[L<ED/]=[#FP@B_^<SR;_^HNM M?b UaD AW<E[1_`JL@^>#@\:Y@B:\9P@^JL[�UNO�>1V/@\@� 7FPUaD/@BDZ>1<EHNMfOsHN:=<EMEbNmW>1V/@\AI<E[1[1<E:l<EMEHKJL<?> bl:Y@BHN[18WJ1@B[

9P@B_`Ua:Y@YjKHKJL<EHNDZ>1[�UNO��.J1@^]a:=HND AI<?jN@^J1]N@BDW_`@B[ � -/m�� � � ��V/@B[1@ AI<?jN@^J1]N@BDW_`@=:Y@BHN[L8/J1@B[�>#UN]N@^>1V/@^J��$<?>1V,>1V/@

HKFWFWJLUNFWJL<EHK>#@=D/Ua< [#@lHN[1[18I:YFW>1<?UaDW[*<ED�>1V/@�_^HN[#@lUNO�AW< [1_`J1@^>#@lAWHK>1H :YU'A/@BMEME<EDW] �<EMEM�9P@=9WJL<E@��IbdJ1@^j'<?@��.@BA

<EDd>1V/@\OQUaMEM?U �$<ED/]=[1@B_`>1<?UaD���$V/@^bCJ1@B[18WME>$AW<?J1@B_`>1MEb�OQJ1Ua: >1V/@ :YU7AW@BM�<EDW[1>1HNDT>1<EHK>1<EUaDW[$HNDWA,HKJ1@ <E:YFIM <E_^<?>1M?b

A/@`R;DW@BAG9Zb�>1V/@4FWJLUN9IHK9I<EME< [#>1<E_$HN[L[18W:YFW>1<EUaDW[�U jN@^J>1V/@*:YU'A/@BMfD/Ua<E[1@!�

���� �� � ��� ��� � � � ��� � � �<" � � �� � � � ����� ��� � � ������� ����� � ��� �� ����"��5�G����� �

��[�>1VW@�_^MEHN[L[�:YU'A/@BM;<E[�ME< D/@BHKJBmZ< D=>1V/@�_^HN[#@ �V/@^J1@$>1VW@^J1@�< [�H4UaDW@>#UeUaD/@�_`UNJ1J1@B[#FPUaDWA/@BDI_`@�9P@^> �.@^@BD

:=< '>18/J1@�_`Ua:YFPUaD/@BDZ>1[0HNDWAG_^MEHN[1[0MEHK9P@BME[^mZ>1V/@):YU'A/@BM;< [._^HKF;HK9IM?@�UNO�_^ME8W[1>#@^JL<ED/]eUaDWM?b=ME< D/@BHKJLM?b=[#@^F;HKJLHK9IM?@

_^MEHN[1[1@B[����'FIHKJL[#@�AWHK>1H VWHN[eUNOg>#@BD >1VW<E[\FWJ1UNFP@^J1> bNm�J1@^jN@BHNM?@BAfm�OQUNJ @� 'HN:=FIM?@Nm�<ED >1V/@ >#@� '>Y_^MEHN[1[1<?R;_^HK>1<?UaD

A/Ua:=HN< D=97be>1VW@�[18I_^_`@B[1[�UNO M <ED/@BHKJ�_^MEHN[L[1<SRI@^JL[&UaDl>#@� '>18WHNM AWHK>1H � -Tn�� �Sp�02��� � !/UNJ�9I< DWHKJ1b _`U7A/@BA AWHK>1H\>1VW<E[

J1@B[#>#Jh<E_`>1<?UaD _^HND 9P@l:YUNJ1@=FIJ1UaD/Ua8WDW_`@BA�����Ud]a<?jN@�HNDr<EM ME8W[#>#JLHK>1<EUaDfmfJ1@B_^HNMEM�>1VWHK>*9I< DWHKJ1b AWHK>1Hd[1<E]aDW<SRI@B[

>1VWHK>Y@BHN_hV UN9I[#@^JLj HK9IME@ jN@B_`>#UNJ�<E[YH _`UNJLD/@^J=UNO�H=)��kAW<E:=@BDW[1<?UaDWHNM.8WDW<E>e_^8/9P@Nm�HNDIA >1VWHK>Y>1V/@CDZ8I:*9P@^J

UNO�ME<ED/@BHKJLMEbd[#@^FIHKJLHK9;M?@YFIHKJ1>1<?>1<EUaDW[�UNO.Hi� AW<E:Y@BDW[L<?UaDWHNM�_^8/9P@ < [ �Gq n � & thm �$VI<EM?@e>1V/@=DZ8I:*9P@^J)UNO.>#UN>1HNMFIHKJ1>1<E>1<?UaDW[4<E[\n � O �SpBn � � �C�'Ui>1V/@ D78W:\9P@^J)UNO�ME<ED/@BHKJLMEbd[#@^FIHKJLHK9;M?@=FIHKJ1>1<E>1<?UaDW[4A/@B_`JL@BHN[#@B[*JhHKFI<EAWM?b �$<?>1V

<EDW_`JL@BHN[1<ED/] AW<E:Y@BDI[1<?UaDWHNME<E>kb!� ��V/@^JL@^OgUNJ1@�VW<E]aV�AW< :Y@BDW[1<?UaDIHNM$9I< DWHKJ1b AWHK>1H6:e8W[#>G9P@ jN@^J1b�[#F;HKJL[#@ >#U

9P@�M <ED/@BHKJLM?b [1@^FIHKJLHK9IM?@!� ��VW<E[ <E[eFWJ1UN9;HK9IM?b�>1V/@GJ1@BHN[#UaD �VTb ��@^JhD/Ua8WMEME<._^MEHN[1[ :YU'A/@BMEM <ED/] ��HN[ OQUa8WDWA

_`UaDW[1< [#>#@BDT>1MEb �SpNpNp � m �Sp�/54���<ED/OQ@^JL<?UNJ.>#U :e8WM?>1< D/Ua:=<EHNM _^MEHN[1[�:YU'A/@BMEME< D/]*OQUNJ�VW<?]aV�AW<E:Y@BDI[1<?UaDWHNM AWHK>1H����UN>#@

>1VWHK>$:e8WM?>1< D/Ua:=<EHNMP_^MEHN[1[$:YU7AW@BMEME<ED/]e:=H �N@B[�8W[#@)UNO�>1V/@*HBjKHN<EMEHK9;M?@�OgJ1@BX78/@BDW_`bG<ED/OQUNJL:=HK>1<EUaD��

� VW<EME[1>l>1VW<E[ ME<ED/@BHKJG[#@^FIHKJhHK9I<EME<?> b6<E[ H �.@BME_`Ua:Y@,Og@BHK>18/JL@,UNO\[#FIHKJL[#@,VW<?]aV AW<E:Y@BDI[1<?UaDWHNM�AIHK>1HrOQUNJ

_^MEHN[1[L<SR;_^HK>1<?UaD*FI8/J1FPUa[#@B[^m >1V/@�[1FIHKJL[1<?> b�F Ua[1@B[�[#>1HK>1<E[1>1<E_^HNMTFIJ1UN9IM?@B:=[�HNDWA*[#UJ1@BX78W<?J1@B[fOs8/J1>1VW@^J�_`UNJ1J1@B_`>1<EUaDW[

>#Ul>1VW@*� H� /<E:e8W: ��< �N@BME<EV/U7U'A�[1UaME8/>1<?UaD�����V/@)FWJ1UN9;M?@B: <E[0>1VW@*[#Ul_^HNMEME@BA � %^@^J1U _`Ua8IDT>1[$FWJ1UN9IM?@B: �?mWHNME[#U

@BDW_`Ua8WDZ>#@^J1@BA < D ��H # �?jN@=��HBbN@B[�qs���t�_^MEHN[1[L<SRI@^JL[^m �$VI<E_LV :Y@BHNDW[�>1VIHK>�>1VW@^J1@Y@� '< [#>�_`Ua:=F UaDW@BDT>1[)UNO�>1V/@

Ua8/>1_`Ua:Y@B[$>1VWHK>�D/@^jN@^J�U'_^_^8/J$< D�[1Ua:Y@4_^MEHN[1[#@B[ �&��V/@^J1@^OQUNJ1@Nm/OQUNJ�>1V/@B[#@4D/UaD�� U7_^_^8/JLJL<ED/] _`Ua:YFPUaD/@BDZ>1[0>1V/@

_`UNJ1J1@B[1F UaDIAW<ED/]e_`Ua:YFPUaD/@BDT>�UNO�>1V/@)_^MEHN[1[#@B[��'@� 'FP@B_`>1HK>1<?UaDGFIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^J �$<EMEMI9 @ %^@^J1U/mW_^HNDW_`@BM ME<ED/]eUa8/>�>1V/@

<EDW[1>1HNDW_`@ � [�_^MEHN[1[�� FWJ1UN9IHK9I< ME<?>kbNm'9P@B_^HN8W[#@4<E>�<E[�:YU'A/@BM?@BACHN[0OsHN_`>#UNJLHK9IME@!�

��VW@^[email protected]@.> ��U4:lHN<ED\[1UaME8/>1<?UaDW[�>#U�>1VW<E[�FWJ1UN9IME@B: <EDe��� _^MEHN[L[1<SRI@^J�FWJLHN_`>1<E_`@NmN@BHN_hV=VWH j7<EDW]H�DZ8I:*9P@^J

UNO&jKHKJL<EHNDZ>1[��)�D @� '>#@BDWA/@BA,@B:YFI<?Jh<E_^HNM�_`Ua:YF;HKJLHK>1<?jN@ J1@^j'<?@�� _^HND 9P@\OgUa8WDIA <ED � �2��� �)��V/@*RIJL[#>�<EA/@BH�<E[

>#U � � ���&� � �d��1 ��� �&�+� � �� ��%� �$<?>1V H [L:=HNMEM�DZ8I:*9P@^J � ��V/@ [#@B_`UaDWA m[#>1HK>1<E[1>1<E_^HNMEM?b OQUa8WDWAW@BA�[#UaM 8/>1<?UaD

020

Page 78: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

�10Nn���< [ "����� � � � � � � � � � �<�M��� UNJ��HKFIMEHN_`@*[L:YUZUN>1VI<ED/]/m �$VI<E_LVi_`Ua:=@B[$OQJ1Ua: <E:=F Ua[L<ED/]YH=_`UaD��18/]aHK>#@eFWJL<?UNJ

UaD >1VW@l_^MEHN[1[\:YU7AW@BM � [)FIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^JL[��G� D FWJLHN_`>1<E_`@Nm�OgUNJeH � � jKHNME8/@BA�FIJ1UN9IM?@B: >1VI<E[4_`UaDW[1< [#>1[)UNO�:=H �'<ED/]

>1V/@C8WDW<EOgUNJL: FWJL<EUNJ HN[L[18W:YFW>1<EUaDrU jN@^J HNMEM � FPUa[1[1<?9IME@=j HNM 8/@B[���!WUNJL:=HNMEM?bNm�>1VW<E[ :Y@BHNDW[ >1V/@GOQUaMEM?U �$<ED/]

[18/9;[#>1<?>18/>1<?UaD�/ � % ! �� �

� ��� �q<-�� nKoTt

�$V/@^JL@ �e<E[�>1V/@0D78W:\9 @^J�UNO FPUa[1[1<?9IME@&j HNM 8/@B[�<ED H�_`Ua:YFPUaD/@BDT>�qQ@!� ]�� � n$OQUNJ�9I<EDIHKJ1b*AWHK>1HTt ����MEM7>1VWHK>&<E[

D/@^@BA/@BA=>1V/@BD OgUNJ�HKFWFIM?b'<ED/]���HKFIMEHN_^< HNDY[1:YU7UN>1VW<ED/])<E[�>#U �$JL<?>#@�>1V/@0@� 'F @B_`>1HK>1<EUaDYFIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^J�<ED >#@^JL:=[�UNO

[1HN:YF;M?@&FWJ1UN9;HK9I<EME<?>1<E@B[ < D4>1V/@._^HN[#@�UNO/>1V/@._`UaDW_`J1@^>#@�D/Ua<E[#@�AW<E[#>#JL<E9I8/>1<?UaDW[ � � < [ >1V/@.DZ8W:\9P@^J UNOW<EDW[1>1HNDW_`@B[^m

r<E[�>1V/@\D78W:\9 @^J$UNO�:lHK>1_LV/@B[�HNDWA � <E[�H=FIJ1@BA/@`R;D/@BAdDZ8W:\9P@^J ����D � �2� ��<?>$<E[�@B:YFI<?JL< _^HNMEM?b [LV/U �$Di>1VWHK>>1V/@Y��HN<?jN@Y�.H bN@B[���HN_^_^8/JhHN_`b,<E[�VW<?]aVIM?biA/@^FP@BDWA/@BDZ>UaD,>1V/@Y_hV/Ua<E_`@YUNO � �)� VW<EM?@eHC_`Ua:=:YUaD _LVWUa<E_`@=<E[

� pKm ME@BHNAW<ED/] >#UC>1V/@Y<EDT>#@^JLFWJ1@^>1HK>1<?UaD,>1VWHK> � @� 7>#JhHCA/JLH �[�HKJL@ HNAIA/@BAfmP@BHN_LV VIHBj'<ED/]�FWJ1UN9IHK9I< ME<?>kbCUNOp � � m;< D � �2����<?> ��HN[�OQUa8WDWAG>1VWHK> � p � � b'<?@BMEAI[.[L8/FP@^JL<?UNJ�J1@B[18WME>1[���UN>#@\>1VIHK>�MEHK>#@BDZ>�>#JLHN<?>$:YU'A/@BMEM <ED/]=DWHK>18/JhHNMEM?b�U jN@^JL_`Ua:Y@B[�>1VW@ %^@^J1UG_`Ua8WDZ>$FWJ1UN9;M?@B: 97bi:YU'A/@BMEME<EDW]

>1V/@�@� 'F @B_`>1HK>1<EUaDYFIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^J�HN[�H)D/UaDWME<EDW@BHKJ�Os8WDW_`>1<?UaD\>1VWHK>&HN[#b':YFW>#UN>1< _^HNMEM?b4J1@BHN_hV/@B[&>[email protected]/@�UNO %^@^J1U��

� ]N@BDW@^JLHNME<E[#@BA�FWJLUN9IHK9I<EME< [#>1<E_�:YU'A/@BMEME<EDW]4OgJhHN:Y@���UNJ��=OgUNJ08WDI[18/FP@^J1j'<E[#@BA j'<E[18WHNME< [1HK>1<?UaDlHNDIA _^ME8I[#>#@^J��

<ED/]dUNO�:\8WME>1<?j HKJh<EHK>#@=AWHK>1H,VWHN[49P@^@BDrAW@B[1_`JL<?9P@BA��G��V/@=FIJ1@B[#@BDZ>#@BAr]N@BD/@^JhHNM�:YU'A/@BM&FIJ1U j'<EA/@B[\HiOQUNJL:=HNM

HNDWA 8WDW<SRI@BAY:=@^>1V/U7AlUNO :YU'A/@BMWA/@B[1_`Jh<?FW>1<?UaD=HNDIA=FIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^J�@B[#>1< :=HK>1<?UaD���� > ��HN[�D/UN>#@BAl>1VWHK>�UaDW@[18W_hV

FIHKJ1>1< _^8WMEHKJ_^HN[1@eUNO�Ua8WJ�:=U7A/@BM mIJ1@B[18IM?>1<ED/]=97bi_LVWUZUa[1< D/]�H"��HN8W[L[1<EHND,D/Ua<E[#@e:YU7AW@BM b'<?@BMEAW[$>1V/@\UNJh<?]a<EDWHNM

����� HNME]NUNJL<?>1VW: � nKo � � ��V/@iJ1@B:lHN<EDWA/@^J=UNO)>1VW@ _LVIHKFW>#@^J �<EMEM0_`UaDW[1< A/@^Jl>1V/@,:YU'A/@BMEME<EDW] UNO4AW< [1_`J1@^>#@

:e8WM?>1<?jKHKJL<EHK>#@dAIHK>1H <ED FIHKJ1>1<E_^8WM HKJCq >1VW@dFWJL< :=HKJ1b :YUN>1<?jKHK>1<?UaDcUNO)>1VI<E[ �.UNJ�� 9P@B<ED/]�>#U FWJ1U j7<EAW@i>1V/@

>1V/@^UNJ1@^>1< _^HNM 9IHN[1< [�OgUNJ$H=>1V/@^UNJ1@^>1<E_^HNMEMEb FWJh<EDW_^<?FIME@BAlHNM?>#@^JLDIHK>1<?jN@4>#U=>1V/@*� ���0�I��� �

� ��� � ���!� � � � � � � �!��� ��� ��� ���!� � ��� � ���� � � � �

��D�>1VW<E[*[#@B_`>1<?UaD >1VW@lOQU7_^8W[*<E[)UaD >1VWUa[#@=FIHKJ1>1< _^8WMEHKJ*_^HN[#@B[\UNO�>1V/@=]N@BD/@^JhHNM�:YU'A/@BM m��V/@^J1@=>1V/@ AW<E[ �

>#JL<?9;8/>1<?UaDWHNM;HN[1[18W:YFI>1<?UaDW[&OQUNJ ��q��� � ��� t�HKJ1@)[18I<?>1HK9IM?@�OQUNJ�J1@^FWJ1@B[1@BDT>1HK>1<?UaDI[�UNO�_^HK>#@^]NUNJL<E_^HNM HNDIA AW< [1_`J1@^>#@AWHK>1H�� !/UNJ�:YUNJ1@�_`Ua:YFIM?@� =HKFWF;ME<E_^HK>1<?UaDW[ �$<?>1V=:=< 7@BAl>kb7F @B[�UNO AWHK>1H �Sp.-Tn � mZ>1VW@HKFWFWJLUNFWJL<EHK>#@�ME< �N@BME<EV/U7U7A

>#@^JL:=[�[1V/Ua8IMEAi[1<E:=FIM?bl9P@e:\8WME>1<?FIME<?@BA m'AI8/@4>#U�>1V/@\_`UaDWAI<?>1<?UaDWHNM�<EDWA/@^FP@BDWA/@BDI_`@�HN[L[18W:YFW>1<EUaDi]a<?jN@BD >1V/@

MEHK>#@BDZ>�jKHKJL<EHK9IM?@!�

054

Page 79: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

��VI<E[�[#@B_`>1<?UaD,_`UaDW_`@^JLDI[$9PUN>1Vi>#JhHN<?>$HNDWA _^MEHN[1[�:YU7AW@BME[�����@B[L<EA/@B[�[#@BM?@B_`>1<ED/] H=FIHKJ1>1< _^8WMEHKJ$_^8W:e8WMEHNDZ>

Os8WDW_`>1<?UaD � OgUNJCq<-Zt*>#U,UN9I>1HN<EDr>1VW@�<EDIAW<?j'<EAW8WHNM�AW<E[1>#JL<?9I8/>1<EUaDW[�UaD >1V/@�DWUa<E[#@Nm ��@GHNME[#U,FPUa<EDZ>*Ua8/>e>1V/@

AW<E[L[1<E:=<EM HKJL<?>kbC:Y@BHN[L8/J1@B[49P@^> ��@^@BD AWHK>1H��HNDWA�JL@^Og@^J1@BDI_`@=jN@B_`>#UNJL[e<E:YFIME<E@BAd97b @BHN_hV AI<E[#>#JL<?9;8/>1<?UaDWHNM�HN[ �

[18W:=FW>1<?UaD���!WUNJ�HNM Ma>1V/@.AW<E[1_`J1@^>#@�AWHK>1H_^HN[1@B[�>1VW@B[#@�:Y@BHN[L8/J1@B[�HKJ1@�jKHKJL<EHNDZ>1[�UNOW�.J1@^]a:lHNDeAI<?jN@^J1]N@BDW_`@B[ � -�� �

��V/@YOQUaMEM?U �$<ED/]C> ��U,AW<?jN@^J1]N@BDI_^<?@B[ �$<EM M�9 @=8I[#@BA��l��VW@ �v ��5�p��� � u 2B ��$�M�$� ����� �x ��6�#� J �&�Mb ��� � ��:Y@BHN[18WJ1@B[

>1V/@eAW<E[1[1< :=<EMEHKJL<E>kbl9P@^> ��@^@BD,> �.UGAW<E[#>#JL<E9I8/>1<?UaDW[ ��!/UNJ)AW< [1_`J1@^>#@*JhHNDWA/Ua: j HKJL< HK9IM?@B[^mW>1VW@e34� AW<EjN@^J1]N@BDW_`@

9P@^> �.@^@BDi> ��U FWJ1UN9IHK9I< ME<?>kbljN@B_`>#UNJL[�� HNDWA�� <E[0AW@`R;D/@BACHN[

���q�� � � ��t ������ � � MEUN] � �

� � q<-�� n'p t

HNDWA�9Zb�A/@`R;DW<?>1<EUaDfm0o�M?UN]�o o�� ��V/@d [�%2���� ���U���L� � ��� �v [���p��� � u 2B ����B��� �&�l��� J �&�Mb �$� � ��J1@B:YU jN@B[C>1V/@

J1@BX78W<?J1@B:=@BDT>0>1VWHK>$>1V/@4_`Ua:YFPUaD/@BDZ>1[�UNO�cHNDWA���[L8W: >#U=UaD/@NmI>1V/@^b�VIHBjN@*UaDIM?bl>#U=9P@4D/UaD��kD/@^]aHK>1<?jN@!�

����Wq�� � � ��t ������ q�� � % � � � � � M?UN] � �

� � t q<-�� nNnat

�UN>#@Y>1VWHK>�@BHN_LV FIHKJL>1<E_^8WMEHKJ�_^MEHN[1[�:YU'A/@BM�F @^JLOgUNJL:l[�FIHKJLHN:=@^>#JL<E_e:=< '>18/J1@\:=U7A/@BM ME<ED/]=UNO�H�_`@^JL>1HN<ED

:=< '>18/J1@4AI<E[#>#JL<?9;8/>1<?UaD�HNDWAi_^HNDi9P@4j'<?@��.@BAiHN[$[1UNOg>�jN@^Jh[1<?UaDW[$UNO�3 �k:Y@BHNDW[$_^M 8W[#>#@^JL<EDW]/m �V/@^J1@4>1V/@ � AW<E[ �

>1HNDW_`@ �08W[#@BA <ED�HN[1[1<?]aDW< D/]r<EDW[1>1HNDW_`@B[l>#U6MEHK>#@BDZ>�@BDT>1<?>1<E@B[ <E[�AW<?JL@B_`>1M?b ]N@BD/@^JLHK>#@BA OQJ1Ua: >1VW@,HN[1[L8W:Y@BA

FWJ1UN9;HK9I<EME<E[1>1<E_:=U7A/@BM ����V/@4[1HN:=@*<E[0>#JL8W@4OgUNJ>1V/@*MEHK>#@BDZ>$>#JhHN<?>�:YU'A/@BMEME<EDW] HNME]NUNJL<?>1VW:Cm��<?>1VC>1V/@4@B[L[#@BD��

>1<EHNM/AW< � @^J1@BDI_`@.>1VIHK>&>1V/@�MEHK>#>#@^J&FP@^J1OQUNJL:=[�H � ���S��� �+����� ���lFIHKJLHN:=@^>#JL<E_0:=< '>18/J1@�:YU'A/@BMEME< D/]/mK9 @B_^HN8I[#@0>1V/@

_`@BDZ>#@^JL[�_^HNDWD/UN>�:YU jN@)[#@^FIHKJhHK>#@BM?bY9I8/>�UaDWM?b >1V/J1Ua8/]aV >1V/@FIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^J�UNOf>1V/@�D/UaDWME< D/@BHKJ�:=HKFWF;<ED/])OQJ1Ua:

H*M HK>#@BDT>�]NJL<EA=[#F;HN_`@$>#U\AIHK>1H*[#FIHN_`@ � nKo�� ����V78W[^mZ8IDWME< �N@�>1V/@UNJL<?]a<EDWHNM �)���rmZ>1V/@_`UaDI[#>#JLHN<ED/@BAl:=< '>18/J1@B[

HKJ1@eD/U � D/UaD�� �)HN8W[1[1<EHND mIHNDWA,HN[H�AW<?J1@B_`>_`UaDW[#@BX78/@BDW_`@NmP>1V/@\AI<E[#>1HNDW_`@B[$9 @^> ��@^@BD AWHK>1H�HNDWAdJ1@^Og@^JL@BDW_`@

FPUa<EDZ>1[4HKJ1@lD/U � D/UN>\��8W_^ME< A/@BHNDfmf9I8/>4HKJL@l<EDW[#>#@BHNAr��JL@^]a:=HND AI<?jN@^J1]N@BDW_`@B[��$VW<E_hV�HNME[#UdAW<EJ1@B_`>1M?b HKJh<E[#@

OQJ1Ua: >1V/@*FWJ1UN9IHK9I< ME<E[#>1<E_�HN[1[18I:YFW>1<?UaDGU jN@^J�>1VW@*:YU'A/@BM D/Ua<E[1@!����DC>1V/@*OQUaMEM?U �$<ED/]Y[18W9I[#@B_`>1<?UaDW[�>1V/@*>#@B_hV��

DW<E_^HNM�A/@^>1HN<EME[_`UaDW_`@^JLDW< D/]l>1V/@e8W[#@\UNO&AW<E[1_`J1@^>#@e:Y@B:\9 @^Jh[$UNO�>1V/@e@� 'F UaDW@BDT>1<EHNM�OQHN:l<EM?b�UNO�AW<E[#>#Jh<?9I8/>1<?UaDI[

�$<?>1VI<ED�>1V/@)FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>#@BAiOQJLHN:Y@��.UNJ�� �$<EMEM 9P@)FWJ1U j7< A/@BA��

������� � ��� ���#"��5� � �#"�� � � � ��� � � � ����� � � ���� � ��"��5�

".UaDI[1<EA/@^J�9I<EDWHKJ1b J1@^FIJ1@B[#@BDZ>#@BA�AIHK>1H��&��HN_LVCAIHK>1H*FPUa<EDZ>�<E[�He9I<EDWHKJ1b jN@B_`>#UNJ �$VW@^J1@$>1V/@�FWJ1@B[1@BDW_`@UNO

H _`Ua:YFPUaD/@BDZ>�<E[�A/@BD/UN>#@BAG97bdp)HNDWAGHK9I[#@BDW_`@�97b o��&��DG[18W_hVC_^HN[#@B[�<?>�<E[�DWHK>18/JLHNM >1VWHK>0>1VW@�AIHK>1H\jN@B_`>#UNJ

9P@=_`UaDW[1<EAW@^J1@BA�HN[49P@B<ED/]G>1V/@ [#>1HK>1<E[#>1<E_^HNM�@^jN@BDT>^m �$<?>1V >1VW@l_`Ua:=:YUaDWMEb,8W[1@BA [1<E:YF;ME<?OQb7<EDW]lHN[1[18W:=FW>1<?UaD

02�

Page 80: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

>1VWHK>\>1V/@ 8WDIA/@^JLM?b'<ED/]CMEHK>#@BDZ>\]N@BDW@^JLHK>1<?jN@�OQHN_`>#UNJL[ [1VWUa8WMEA�_^HKFW>18/JL@ HNMEM�>1V/@ A/@^FP@BDWAW@BDW_`b �$VW<E_hV�@� '< [#>1[

9P@^> �.@^@BDi>1V/@\_`Ua:YFPUaD/@BDT>1[�UNO�>1VW@)UN9I[#@^J1jN@BA AWHK>1H'mI< � @!�&>1VW@4:YU7AW@BMfD/Ua<E[#@4[1VWUa8WMEA�OQHN_`>#UNJh< %^@!�

��q , � � # #��Kt ������ ��q� � � � # # �Kt q<-�� n2�at

��HBj'<ED/]�>#U�A/@BHNM.�$<?>1V 9I<EDIHKJ1bCAWHK>1H'mf< � < � A��$�.@^JLDWUa8WMEME< DWUa<E[#@\< [$>1V/@e8W[18WHNM�HN[1[18I:YFW>1<?UaD����$V/@\9;<ED/Ua:=<EHNM

�.@^JLD/Ua8WM ME<KAW<E[#>#JL<E9I8/>1<?UaD�<E[fUaD/@�UNO'>1V/@�AW<E[1_`J1@^>#@&:=@B:*9P@^JL[fUNO7>1V/@&@� 'FPUaD/@BDZ>1<EHNMNOsHN:=<EM?bNm DIHN:Y@BM?b�[#FP@B_^<?Ogb'<ED/]

>1V/@C_^8W:e8WMEHNDZ>\Os8WDW_`>1<EUaD HN[ �=q������ t M?UN] � p � @� 7F�q������Kt��&����VI<E[\HNM [#U,[1F @B_^<?RI@B[*>1VW@G< DTjN@^JL[1@�ME< D��Os8WDW_`>1<?UaDfm/HN[$>1V/@)]NJLHNAW<?@BDZ>�UNO ���$<E>1VGJ1@B[#FP@B_`>�>#U=>1V/@4DIHK>18/JLHNMfFIHKJhHN:Y@^>#@^J$UNO�>1V/@*AW< [#>#JL<?9I8W>1<?UaD�/

� � � q������Nt @� 7F�q������Ktp � @� 'F�q������Kt q<-�� n$-Zt

HNDWAC>1VW@ !�< [1V/@^J$<EDWOgUNJL:lHK>1<?UaDG:=HK>#JL< GOgUNJ$>1V/@ � � >1ViMEHK>#@BDZ>$8WDI<?>0<E[

��� � �� ���� � � � � � �7q�p % � � � t�� q<-�� n2/at

�$V/@^JL@ ���� ��q t � A/@BD/UN>#@B[*H�� � AW<EHK]NUaDIHNM&:=HK>#JL< UNO0<?>1[ � �kA/@^FP@BDWA/@BDZ>4HKJ1]a8W:=@BDT>*HN[eAW<EHK]NUaDIHNM�@BM �@B:Y@BDZ>1[�� ��V/@)�7DWU �$D,OQUNJL: UNO�>1V/@=�.@^JLDWUa8WMEME<�AW<E[#>#Jh<?9I8/>1<?UaDdHNDWA >1V/@ ]N@BD/@^JLHK>#@BA AI<?jN@^J1]N@BDW_`@=:Y@BHN[L8/J1@

HNME[#UY@B:=@^J1]N@B[DIHK>18/JLHNMEM?blOgJ1Ua: >1VW<E[�/

��q��� � ���Kt @� 7F � ����� �� % M?UN] q�p � @� 7F�q������Kt#t�� q<-�� n20at

@� 7F ������� � � � M?UN];q�� � �at�Yq�p % � �'t7M?UN]Pq�p % � � �Nt�� � q<-�� n54Nt

������ � �� #� � q�p % � � � t � � � # q<-�� n2�at

��[*_^HND 9P@l[1@^@BD OQJ1Ua: q<-�� n54Nthm�>1V/@ AW<E[1[1< :=<EMEHKJL<E>kbi:Y@BHN[18WJ1@=]N@BD/@^JLHK>#@BA 97b,>1VW@ < � < � A��l�.@^JLD/Ua8WMEM <�D/Ua<E[#@

HN[1[18I:YFW>1<?UaD <E[*>1VW@�[18I: UNO$_`Ua:=F UaDW@BDT> � �$< [#@�_`JLUa[1[e@BDT>#J1UNF;<?@B[e9 @^> ��@^@BD >1V/@Cn � jKHNME8/@BA AW<E[#>#Jh<?9I8/>1<?UaDI[

]N@BD/@^JLHK>#@BA�97b >1V/@ AWHK>1H <EDW[1>1HNDW_`@iHNDWA6J1@^OQ@^J1@BDW_`@ jN@B_`>#UNJBm �$VW< _LV6_^HND 9P@CJ1@��$JL<?>#>#@BD6HN[=>1VW@d[18W: UNO

_`Ua:YFPUaD/@BDZ> � �$<E[#@ 348WM M?9IHN_�� �k� @B<E9IM?@^J$AW<EjN@^J1]N@BDW_`@B[�����@BD/UN>1<ED/]G97b � � �dHNDWA �� � �Y>1V/@e> �.UCjKHNME8/@BA FWJ1UN9��HK9I<EM <?>kbiAW< [#>#JL<?9I8W>1<?UaDW[�U jN@^J*>1V/@ FWJ1@B[#@BDW_`@ HNDWA HK9I[#@BDI_`@eUNO�>1V/@ � � >1V,>#@^JL: <ED >1V/@ � >1V�AWHK>18W: HNDWA <ED>1V/@ � � >1ViFWJ1UN>#UN>kb7FP@4J1@B[#FP@B_`>1<?jN@BMEb

� � ���� �� � � � � � �� � � � �� �� �

� � p % � �� ���

�� � ���� �� � � � � � �� � � � � � �� �

� � � p % � � �� ���

0 �

Page 81: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

[#U ��q��� � ���Nt._^HNDi9P@)J1@��$JL<?>#>#@BDCHN[

��q��� � ���Kt @� 7F

%������ 34��q �A���� � � �: ��� t q<-�� n �at

�7U/m :=H� /<E:=< %B<ED/]�>1V/@Y��@^JhD/Ua8WMEME<�ME< �N@BM <EV/U7U7A <ED,OQHN_`>4:=< DW<E:=< %^@B[$>1V/@=_`Ua:YFPUaD/@BDZ> �$< [#@Y34� AW<?jN@^JL]N@BDW_`@B[

9P@^> �.@^@BDi>1V/@\AW<E[#>#JL<E9I8/>1<?UaDW[�:=HNA/@*8WFC9Zb�>1V/@*AWHK>18I: HNDWAG>1V/@*_`UNJLJ1@B[#FPUaDWAW<EDW]\J1@^OQ@^J1@BDW_`@*jN@B_`>#UNJ �

����� � � ��� ���#"��5� � �#"�� � � ��� �� � � � � ���� � ��"��5�

��D/UN>1V/@^J�AW<E[L_`J1@^>#@0:Y@B:*9P@^J�UNOI>1V/@�@� 'FPUaD/@BDT>1< HNMTOsHN:=<EM?bNmN8W[L8WHNMEM?b)8/>1<EM < %^@BA*<EDe_`Ua8WDZ>�AWHK>1H�:YU7AW@BMEME<ED/]/m

<E[e>1V/@C!�Ua<E[1[#UaD AW< [#>#JL<?9I8W>1<?UaD�� �/<E:=<EMEHKJhM?bNm�[1F @B_^<EOgb'<ED/] �=q���� �Nt @� 'F�q������Nthm�:Y@BHNDI[Y[#FP@B_^<?Ogb'<ED/] >1V/@

!�Ua<E[1[#UaDdAW<E[#>#JL<E9I8/>1<?UaD���".UaDW[#@BX78/@BDZ>1M?bNm/>1V/@*< DTjN@^JL[1@4ME<ED�� OQ8WDI_`>1<?UaDCD/U � <E[

� � � q���� �Kt @� 7F�q������Kt q<-����KoTt

HNDWA � � � �� ���� ��q�� � �at q<-����'p t

�@^F;MEHN_^<ED/] >1V/@*_^8I:\8WM HNDT>0Os8WDW_`>1<?UaDC< D q<-��1-Zt�UaD/@*VIHN[

��q��� � ��� t @� 7F ������ � � ��M?UN];q�� � �Nt % � � � � q<-����Nnat

������

p � � � � �� #� � @� 'F�q % � � �Nt q<-����2�at

OQJ1Ua: �$VW< _LV _^HND 9P@,[1@^@BD >1V/@�< � < � A�� !�Ua< [1[#UaD D/Ua<E[1@,]N@BDW@^JLHK>#@B[C>1V/@ 8WDID/UNJL:=HNME< %^@BA�34� AI<?jN@^J��

]N@BDW_`@Nm�< � @!�Y:\8IM?>1<?FIM?b'<ED/] �$<?>1V,@� 'F�q % # q���'t % ��'thm.�$VW<E_hV,< [)<EDWA/@^FP@BDWA/@BDZ>�UNO � � q �$V/@^J1@�# q��.t % � � ���� � � M?UN] � � <E[�>1V/@4@BDZ>#J1UNF7b �1�20���UNO ��t.UaD/@4_^HNDdJ1@���JL<?>#@

��q��� � � �Nt @� 'F

%������ � ��M?UN]

� �� � � � � � � % � � �

@� 'F � % ����Wq��� � � � �Kt�� q<-����$-Zt

������� � ��� � � � ����� � � � ��� � � ���� � ��"��5�

��VW@$:\8IM?>1<ED/Ua:=< HNM/<E[&HND/UN>1V/@^J�AW<E[L_`J1@^>#@$:Y@B:\9P@^J�UNOP>1V/@$@� 'FPUaD/@BDZ>1<EHNM/OsHN:=<EM?bNm �$VW<E_hV=<E[&[#FP@B_^<SR;@BAY9Zb

�=q������ t MEUN]�� � � ���� @� 'F�q�� � � �Nt��m��$V/@^J1@ � � <E[�>1V/@�� ��� J1U ��UNO �$��".UaDI[#@BXZ8W@BDT>1M?b >1V/@4<EDZjN@^JL[#@4ME< D��

Os8WDW_`>1<?UaDC<EDG>1VI<E[0_^HN[#@\< [

� � � q������Nt @� 7F�q�� � ���Kt� � � � �� @� 7F�q�� � � ���Nt q<-����2/at

4 o

Page 82: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

HNDWA

q � � � � t� � � � � � q������Nt� � � � ��� � � � � � � % � � � � � � � q<-����20at

�$V/@^JL@ � � � <E[&>1VW@�3)JLUaD/@B_��N@^J0A/@BM?>1H*OQ8IDW_`>1<?UaDfmIp �$V/@BD�� � � HNDWA o*UN>1VW@^J��$<E[#@!����V78W[^mZ>1V/@$OQUNJL: UNOf>1V/@AW<E[1>#JL<?9I8/>1<EUaD <E[

��q��� � ��� t @� 7F �

� � �.MEUN] q�� � �Nt q<-����54Nt

�� � � #� � q<-����2�at

HNDWA >1V/@$]N@BDW@^JLHK>#@BACAW<?jN@^J1]N@BDI_`@<E[�>1V/@DW@^]aHK>1<?jN@)_`J1Ua[1[ � @BDZ>#J1UNF7bNm'HN[�_^HND 9P@[#@^@BD�OQJ1Ua: q<-����54Nthm �VW<E_LV <E[

FWJ1UNFPUNJ1>1<EUaDWHNM >#U=>1V/@*348IMEM?9IHN_��&�k��@B<?9IM?@^J�AW<?jN@^J1]N@BDI_`@ qs<?O0q<-����54Nt0<E[�:e8WM?>1<EFIME<?@BA 9Zb�@� 'F�q % # q���'t#t#t ���'U/m

��q� � � ��� t @� 7F � % ���q� � � � ���Nt�� q<-���� �at

��VW@�:\8WME>1<ED/Ua:=<EHNM7:YU'A/@BM/<E[�]N@BDW@^JLHNMEM?be8W[#@BAY<EDY_^HN[#@B[ �$V/@BDY>1VW@0j HKJL< HK9IM?@B[�HKJ1@�D/Ua:l<EDWHNM ma<EDIAW<E_^HK>1<ED/]

UaD/@4UNO&HlDZ8W:\9P@^J UNO�:e8/>18WHNMEM?b @� '_^M 8W[1<?jN@*_^M HN[1[#@B[^m <ED �$VW<E_hVi_^HN[#@\>1V/@B[#@*jKHKJL<EHK9;M?@B[�HKJ1@*_`U'A/@BAd9Zb �

AW<E:=@BDW[1<?UaDWHNMZ9I<EDIHKJ1b4jN@B_`>#UNJL[.HNDWAY<?>&<E[�UaDIM?b*>1V/@_`Ua:YFPUaD/@BDT>�>1VIHK>�VWHN[�>1V/@�jKHNME8/@)p �VW<E_LV _`UNJ1JL@B[#FPUaDWAW[

>#U*>1VW@$_^MEHN[1[�>1V/@�jKHKJL<EHK9IM?@�9P@BM?UaD/]a[&>#U\HNDWA=HNM M/UN>1V/@^JL[�HKJ1@olq�p � UNO � _`U'AW<EDW]4[1_LV/@B:=@ t �&�$U ��@^jN@^JBmWHN[�>1V/@

AW<E[1>1HNDW_`@�]N@BD/@^JLHK>#@BA 97be>1VW@:YU'A/@BMW<E[&>1V/@34� AW<?jN@^J1]N@BDI_`@$9P@^> �.@^@BDl> ��UeAW<E[1_`JL@^>#@$AW<E[#>#Jh<?9I8/>1<?UaDI[ � >1V/@

AWHK>1HGFPUa<EDZ>)HNDWA,>1V/@Y@� 7FP@B_`>1HK>1<?UaD FIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^J � >1VI<E[�<EDWAW<E_^HK>#@B[�>1VW@ 8I[#@^OQ8IMED/@B[1[�UNO�>1VW@=:\8WME>1<ED/Ua:=<EHNM

:YU'A/@BMI< D=HNMEM/>1V/Ua[1@�_^HN[#@B[.<ED �$VW<E_hVY>1V/@AI<E[#>#JL<?9;8/>1<?UaDWHNM'<EDZ>#@^J1FWJ1@^>1HK>1<EUaD=UNOf>1V/@$AIHK>1H*FPUa<EDZ>1[&<E[�F Ua[L[1<?9IM?@!�

��DWA/@^@BAfm&<?O0>1VW@G_`Ua:=F UaDW@BDT>1[eUNO$@BHN_hV6AWHK>1H,FPUa<EDT> [18W: >#U UaD/@G>1V/@BD >1V/@G_`Ua:YFPUaD/@BDT>1[ UNO$>1V/@C:Y@BHND

jN@B_`>#UNJL[ �<EMEM�D/@B_`@B[1[1HKJL< M?bd[18W: >#UCUaD/@YHN[ �.@BMEM mfHNDWA >1VW< [FP@^JL:l<?>1[< DT>#@^J1FIJ1@^>1<ED/]�9PUN>1V >1VW@ AIHK>1HGF Ua< DT>

HNDWA >1V/@�:Y@BHND jN@B_`>#UNJdHN[CAI<E[1_`J1@^>#@�AW<E[1>#JL<?9I8/>1<EUaDW[YU jN@^Jd>1V/@�[1HN:Y@�[#@^>CUNO*OQ@BHK>18/J1@B[ � �[C[L8W_LVfm>1V/@

:e8WM?>1<ED/Ua:l<EHNM/<E[�HND�HNM?>#@^JLDIHK>1<?jN@_hV/Ua<E_`@HNM [#U*OQUNJ.:=U7A/@BM ME<ED/])_`Ua8WDZ>�AWHK>1H��&�$V/@_hV/Ua<E_`@[LV/Ua8WMEAY9P@$AWJL<?jN@BD

97b FWJh<?UNJ �7DWU �$M?@BAW]N@)UaDi>1V/@4AWHK>1H'm;OgUNJ$@ � _^<?@BDZ>0RI>#>1<ED/]��

������� � � � � " � � ����� "��5������� �

��VW@^J1@,HKJL@,> ��U6@^jN@BDZ>i:YU'A/@BME[�<ED 8W[#@ OgUNJG>1V/@ ]N@BD/@^JhHK>1<?jN@ J1@^FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaD UNO\>#@� 7>CA/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[

�SpNpNp � ����V/@4:e8WM?>1<Ej HKJL< HK>#@*�.@^JLD/Ua8WMEM <;@^jN@BDZ>�:YU7AW@BMfJ1@^FWJ1@B[1@BDT>1[$@BHN_LV,A/U7_^8I:Y@BDT>$9ZbCH=jN@B_`>#UNJ�UNO�9I<EDIHKJ1b

_`Ua:YFPUaD/@BDZ>1[^m7@BHN_LVC_`Ua:YFPUaD/@BDZ>�<EDIAW<E_^HK>#@B[ �V/@^>1V/@^J.UNJ.D/UN>.H\_`@^JL>1HN<EDl>#@^Jh: U'_^_^8/JL[.<ED=>1VIHK>.A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>��

��V/@ [#>1HK>1<E[#>1<E_^HNM�@^jN@BDT> <E[)>1VW@ A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>��C��V/@=:e8WM?>1<ED/Ua:l<EHNM�@^jN@BDT> :YU'A/@BM&<ED >18/JLD�J1@^FIJ1@B[#@BDZ>1[*@BHN_hV

A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ> HN[�H [1@^>lUNO �.UNJLA @^jN@BDZ>1[^m�HN[ � �� �&< DWA/@^FP@BDWA/@BDZ> >#JL<EHNME[lOgJ1Ua: H � 9;HK] UNO �.UNJLAW[��?m �V/@^J1@

47p

Page 83: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

� �� ��<E[ >1V/@iM?@BD/]N>1V UNO�>1V/@iA/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>��6��V/@GUNJLA/@^JYUNO�>1V/@��.UNJLAW[=< [YM?Ua[#>^m�VWU �.@^jN@^Jl>1V/@iD78W:\9 @^JYUNO

U'_^_^8/J1J1@BDW_`@B[*<E[�_^HKFW>18/J1@BA��e��D >1VW<E[�_^HN[#@Nm�@BHN_hVrA/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>)<E[)<ED,OsHN_`>4_`U7A/@BArHN[4HGVW<E[#>#UN]NJLHN: UNO �.UNJLA

U'_^_^8/J1J1@BDW_`@B[ �&��VW<E[�J1@^FIJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaD VIHN[�9P@^@BDYOQUa8WDWA [18/FP@^JL<?UNJ�>#Ue>1V/@$�.@^JLD/Ua8IMEME<W<ED=9 UN>1V _^MEHN[1[1<?R;_^HK>1<?UaD

�SpNpNp �fHNDWA�_^ME8W[#>#@^Jh<ED/] �Sp�/54�� m �Sp�/20�� �&�UNJL:=HNME< %B< D/]4>1V/@�A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>.M?@BDW]N>1V VWHN[�>1V/@�9P@BD/@`RI>�UNO�FWJ1@^jN@BDZ>1<ED/]

M?UaD/]N@^J*>#@� 7>4A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[4_^HKFW>18WJL<ED/]C:YUNJ1@=< :YFPUNJ1>1HNDW_`@ >1VWHND�>1V/@=[LV/UNJ1>#@^J)UaD/@B[��Y��D UN>1V/@^J �.UNJLAW[Bm�HND

U'_^_^8/J1J1@BDW_`@�UNO�H ��UNJLAC< D�H [1VWUNJ1>0A/U7_^8I:Y@BDT>0[1VWUa8WMEA UN9Zj'<?Ua8W[1MEb=9P@>#J1@BHK>#@BAdHN[�:YUNJ1@)<E:YFPUNJ1>1HNDZ>.>1VWHND

HND,U7_^_^8WJ1J1@BDW_`@eUNO�H ��UNJLA <ED HGM?UaD/]l>#@� '>��)��V/@ :\8IM?>1<ED/Ua:=< HNM D/Ua<E[#@\9IHN[#@BA MEHK>#@BDZ>>#JhHN<?>�:=U7A/@BM � HN[

HNDC@� '>#@BDW[1<?UaDi>#U=>1V/@*�.@^JLD/Ua8IMEME< OgUNJh:\8WM HK>1<?UaD �1/ ���(� �<EMEM >1V/@^J1@^OQUNJ1@49P@)<EDZjN@B[#>1<?]aHK>#@BA��

��VW@!�Ua<E[1[#UaD�AW<E[1>#JL<?9I8/>1<EUaDY_^HND�HNM [#U\9P@$8I[#@BA < Dl:YU'A/@BMEME< D/]4_`Ua8WDZ>.AWHK>1H����$U ��@^jN@^JBmW< D=>1V/@�[#FP@B_^<SR;_

_^HN[#@eUNO�>#@� 7>�9IHN[#@BA <ED/OQUNJL:=HK>1<?UaDCJL@^>#JL<?@^jKHNM <?>VIHN[�9P@^@BDiFWJLUNF Ua[1@BAiHNDWAiOQUa8WDWAi>#Ul9P@*<ED/@ ��_^<?@BDT> �Sp^o5��� m

�SpNp 4�� m �1�$- ��UaDC>#@^JL: OgJ1@BX78/@BDW_`b�_`Ua8WDZ>$AWHK>1H'mI9P@B_^HN8W[1@)UNO�>1VW@4:=<E[1:=HK>1_hVC9P@^> �.@^@BDiFPUa[1[1<E9IM?blM?UaDW]Y>1HN<EM?@BA

�.UNJLAlAW< [#>#JL<?9I8W>1<?UaDW[�U jN@^J0A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[�HNDWAl>1V/@$!�Ua<E[1[#UaD AW<E[#>#Jh<?9I8/>1<?UaD �SpNp 4�� ���U �.@^jN@^JBm/>1V/@$> �.U � j HNME8W@BA

!�Ua<E[1[#UaD�:l< 7>18WJ1@e:=U7A/@BM ��HN[)8/>1<EME< %^@BA HN[4HG[#F;HKJL[#@Y[18/9I[1>1<?>18/>#@eUNO�>1V/@=�.@^JLD/Ua8IMEME<�:l< 7>18WJ1@e:=U7A/@BM�OQUNJ

_^ME8W[1>#@^JL<ED/]YHNDWA���HN[0OQUa8WDWAG>#U 9 @)M?@B[L[�[#@BDW[1<E>1<?jN@)>#Ul<EDW<E>1<EHNME<E[1HK>1<EUaDW[�<EDG>1VW@*_^HN[#@4UNO�[#FIHKJh[#@4AWHK>1H �1�2��� �

� ��� � � � � ��� ���� �$� � � � � � �

!/UNJ�>#@B[#>1<EDW]=>1V/@*FIJ1UNFPUa[#@BAi:YU'A/@BME[^mW[L<E:\8IMEHK>1<?UaDW[ �.@^J1@\_^HKJLJL<?@BACUa8/>$UaDd9I< DWHKJ1b VIHNDWA���JL<E>#>#@BDCAW<?]a<?>

AWHK>1H � HNDWA,jKHKJL<?Ua8W[�[18/9I[1@^>1[UNO�>1V/@YnKo��k�$@��$[1]NJ1Ua8/FI[)>#@� '>)_`UNJ1FI8W[ � mf<ED,9PUN>1V 9I<EDWHKJ1biHNDIA$�.UNJLA _`Ua8WDZ>

9IHN[#@BA�J1@^FIJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaDW[����$V/@�nKo��k�@��$[#]NJLUa8/FI[�>#@� '>09IHN[#@)_`UaDW[1<E[1>1[�UNO�nKo'm oNoNo=A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[�OgJLUa: 8I[#@BD/@^>

_`Ua:=:e8WDW<E_^HK>1<EUaDW[�UaD j HKJL<EUa8W[�>#UNFI<E_^[^m�HKJ1JLHND/]N@BA < D nKo6_^MEHN[L[#@B[^m�HNDWA <E[GAW<?jN@^JL[#@ @BD/Ua8W]aV >#U @BDIHK9IM?@

jKHKJL<?Ua8W[�[1@^>#>1<ED/]a[0OQUNJ$>#@B[#>1< D/]=>1V/@*HNME]NUNJL<?>1VW:=[ �&��V/@)@� 'F @^Jh<E:Y@BDZ>1[�HKJ1@*A/@B[L<?]aD/@BAC>#Ul_`Ua:=FIHKJ1@*HNDWACR;DWA

>1V/@*:=Ua[#>HKFWFIJ1UNFWJL<EHK>#@)FIJ1UN9IHK9I<EM <E[#>1<E_OgUNJh:\8WM HK>1<?UaDCOQUNJ$]a<?jN@BD AWHK>1H'm;HNDWAd>#U <EDZjN@B[#>1<?]aHK>#@\>1V/@4FPUN>#@BDZ>1<EHNM

FPU �.@^J$UNO�>1V/@4>#JLHN<E>$:YU'A/@BMf<ED�R;DWAI<ED/]Y:Y@BHNDW<EDW]NOQ8WMP[#>#Jh8W_`>18/J1@4<EDG>1VW@*:\8IM?>1<?jKHKJL<EHK>#@4AWHK>1H��0�7FP@B_^<SR;_^HNMEM?bNm

Ua8/Je<EDT>#@^JL@B[#>\VWHN[\9P@^@BDr<ED�R;DWAW<EDW]i[#@B:=HNDZ>1<E_l[#>#Jh8W_`>18/J1@l< D�>#@� 7>18IHNM�AWHK>1H'm�97b�:Y@BHNDW[\UNO09I8W<EM AW<ED/]G8/F

H > �.UGAI<E:Y@BDW[1<EUaDWHNMf[#@B:=HNDZ>1<E_e:=HKF UaD$�$VW< _LViUaDW@e_^HND,j'<E[18WHNME< %^@)>1V/@\>#@� '>�A/U7_^8I:Y@BDT>�<EDW[1>1HNDW_`@B[$<ED,H

>#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVW< _�UNJLA/@^JL<EDW]��� "� � ���� ���7:C:C: F ������F A#��� F �4DA���I���417��)��/��� G A<IIJ1�����F "� �I�" "� � ���� ���7:C:C: F ����F ��I�A F �4D<A��� ��(K, ����41���)<�=)<.��

4Kn

Page 84: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

���� �� � �� � � � � � 1" � � ��� ��� ��� �

��VW@d:YUa[#>l< :YFPUNJ1>1HNDT>=X78/@B[#>1<EUaDW[YOQJ1Ua: >1V/@dF @^Jh[#FP@B_`>1<?jN@CUNO�>1VW<E[ �.UNJ��6_`UaDW_`@^JLD p t >1V/@i]N@BDW@^JLHNM

HK9I<EM <?>1<?@B[ UNO)>1V/@i>#JhHN<?> :YU'A/@BME[l<ED6J1@^jN@BHNME< D/] [#Ua:=@ 8WDWAW@^JLM?b'<ED/] [#>#JL8W_`>18/JL@d<ED :e8WM?>1<?jKHKJL<EHK>#@ AWHK>1H'm$nat

�$V/@^>1VW@^J�UNJ�D/UN>�>1VW@�FWJLUNF Ua[1@BA*:e8WM?>1<ED/Ua:l<EHNMK>#JLHN<?>�:YU'A/@BMa9WJh<ED/]a[ HNDZb*<E:YFIJ1U jN@B:Y@BDZ>�U jN@^J�>1V/@��.@^JLDWUa8WMEME<

97b�HNMEMEU �$<EDW]�8W[P>#U<EDI_`UNJ1FPUNJLHK>#@�>#@^JL:�OQJ1@BX78/@BDW_`b �WUNJ�@^jN@BDZ>18WHNMEM?b ��@B<E]aVT>#@BA*>#@^JL:�OQJ1@BX78/@BDW_`b�<ED/OQUNJL:=HK>1<?UaD

<ED�>1VW@l_^HN[#@lUNO0>1VW@lMEHK>#@BDZ>*>#JLHN<?>\:YU7AW@BM m�HNDWA �at�>#U [1@^@ �$V/@^>1VW@^J4>1V/@^b�_^HND < DWA/@^@BA R;DIA�:Y@BHNDW<ED/]NOs8WM

[#@B:=HNDZ>1<E_)UNJL]aHNDW< %BHK>1<?UaDW[Bm���UNJLAi]NJ1Ua8/FI<EDW]a[0HNDWAC>#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVW< _^HNMPj7<E[L8WHNME<E[1HK>1<EUaD��

��DYHNMEM7@� 7FP@^JL< :Y@BDT>1[BmN>1V/@�:YU'A/@BM7FIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^JL[ ��@^J1@�[1@^>&HN[�OgUaMEMEU �$[�/�HYp^o p^o\8WDW<?OQUNJL: ]NJL<EA :=HKFWFP@BA

UaDZ>#U�n2/ ��HN8W[1[1< HNDC9IHN[1<E[�OQ8WDI_`>1<?UaDW[0UNO�8WDW<E>0j HKJL< HNDW_`@*VWHN[$9 @^@BD _LV/Ua[1@BD��0��V/@4FIHKJhHN:Y@^>#@^J�:lHK>#JL< CVWHN[

9P@^@BDd<EDI<?>1<EHNME<E[1@BA OQJ1Ua: !."�� qs[1< :=<EMEHKJLMEbl>#U � nKo��Qt0<ED HNMEM >1VW@*@� 'F @^Jh<E:Y@BDZ>1[$[1V/U �$DdVW@^J1@*>#U @BDW[18/J1@*>1VWHK>

J1@B[18IM?>1[ HKJ1@CJ1@^FP@BHK>1HK9IM?@ � �'D/U �$D 9P@B<EDW] >1VWHK>Y>1VW@i��� JL@B[18WM?>Y<E[ A/@^FP@BDWA/@BDZ>eUaD <EDW<?>1< HNME<E[1HK>1<?UaD�� �

D78W:*9P@^J�UNO /Koi<?>#@^JLHK>1<?UaDI[ ��@^J1@=[L8 � _^<?@BDZ>�OgUNJ)J1@BHN_hVW<ED/]i_`UaDZjN@^J1]N@BDW_`@�<ED�HNMEM�@� 'F @^Jh<E:Y@BDZ>1[�FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>#@BA��

��V/@4[1F @^@BAGUNO�_`UaDZjN@^J1]N@BDW_`@ �.HN[$V/U �.@^jN@^J�AW@^F @BDIAW<ED/]eUaDC>1V/@*[L< %^@4HNDWAi_`Ua:YF;M?@� '<E>kb�UNO�>1VW@4AWHK>1H=[#@^>��

��Ui<EMEME8I[#>#JLHK>#@*>1VW@ HNME]NUNJL<?>1VW:=[BmP< D >1VW@\R;JL[#>�@� 7FP@^JL< :Y@BDT>�OQUa8/J)A/U7_^8I:Y@BDT>)_^MEHN[L[#@B[)VWHBjN@l9 @^@BD _hV/U �

[#@BD�UaD [#FP@B_^<SR;_^HNMEMEbdAW<E[#>1< DW_`>�>#UNFI<E_^[�/ � [L_^< � _`J1b7FW>��?m � [1_^< � [#FIHN_`@ �?m�� [1_^< � :Y@BA(��HNDWA � [#U'_ � J1@BME<?]a<EUaD�� _LV/Jh<E[#>1<EHND(� �

�J19I<?>#JLHKJh<EM?bNm&p^oNo,A/U7_^8I:Y@BDT>1[���@^JL@ 8W[#@BA OgJ1Ua: @BHN_LV UNO�>1V/@B[#@�_^MEHN[1[#@B[\HNDWArH AW<E_`>1<?UaDWHKJLb,[1< %^@=UNO4p^oNo

>#@^JL:=[ �.HN[8/>1<EME<E[1@BA���� >$<E[�>#Ul9 @4:=@BDT>1<?UaDW@BAC>1VWHK>�>1V/@*J1@BM?@^jKHNDT>0>#@^JL: [#@BM?@B_`>1<?UaDiFWJ1U'_`@BAW8/J1@)<E[�HNDWUN>1V/@^J

@� '>#@BDW[1<?jN@CHKJ1@BH UNOJ1@B[#@BHKJL_hV �Sp�0Nn�� �Sp^oan�� �Sp�� ��� m �VW<E_LV <E[eUa8/>1[L<EA/@�UNO�>1V/@C[1_`UNFP@GUNO$>1VW<E[e>1V/@B[L<E[�� �.@��

_^HN8W[#@*>1V/@*HN<E: UNO�>1VW< [�@� 7FP@^JL<E:=@BDT> ��HN[$:=HN< DWM?bl@^jKHNME8WHK>1< D/]YFPUa[1[1<?9IME@�:YU'A/@BME[Bm/>1V/@)>#@^JL:=[:=H �7< D/]=8/F

>1V/@4A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[0OQ@BHK>18/J1@B[ �.@^J1@4_hV/Ua[#@BDiOQUNJ0>1VW<E[�@� 'FP@^JL<E:Y@BDZ>�9ZbG�,8/>18WHNMP��D/OgUNJh:=HK>1<?UaD qs� �#t��1�20����$<?>1V

V78W:=HND��kA/@`R D/@BAi_^MEHN[1[�MEHK9P@BME[�����VW< [0>#@^JL: [#@BM?@B_`>1<?UaD,:Y@^>1V/U'Ad<E[V/U �.@^jN@^J)FPUa[1[1<?9;M?@)<EDiFWJhHN_`>1<E_`@*UaDWMEbG<EO

>1V/@^J1@4HKJL@*MEHK9P@BM?@BAG<EDW[#>1HNDI_`@B[�HBjKHN<EMEHK9IME@!��� D !�<?]�� -�� n ��UaD/@*_^HNDi[1@^@4>1V/@)FPUa[#>#@^JL<?UNJ�:=@BHNDW[0UN9W>1HN<EDW@BACUaD

>1V/@)>#JLHN< DW<ED/]Y[#@^>\qs< � @!�?mW>1V/@*n �k� FPUa<EDZ>1[�UNO�>1VW@*:=HK>#JL< � � � m+�$V/@^J1@ � <E[�>1VW@ � � J1@B[1F UaDI[1<?9I<EM <?>kb

:=HK>#JL< HNDWA � <E[\>1V/@ � n,:=HK>#JL< r_`UaDZ>1HN<EDW<EDW] >1V/@G]NJL< A�� FPUa<EDT>1[ t�]a<?jN@BD 97b >1V/@G<EDWAW<?j'<EAW8IHNM�>#JLHN<?>

:YU'A/@BME[�UaD�>1VW@l[1HN:Y@=AWHK>1H�����V/@YAW< �P@^J1@BDZ>4_^MEHN[1[4M HK9 @BM [)HKJ1@=[1V/U �$D �$<?>1V�AI< � @^JL@BDT>4[#b':\9 UaM [�UaD�>1V/@

FIM?UN>1[ ����DW@$_^HND=[#@^@>1VWHK>&@BHN_LV�:YU'A/@BM/VWHN[�OQUa8WDWAYH4j HNME< AY:Y@BHNDW<ED/]NOs8WM/:=HKFIFI<ED/]/maHN[�J1@BMEHK>#@BA=A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>

<EDW[1>1HNDW_`@B[�HKJ1@�_^ME8W:YFP@BA\>#UN]N@^>1V/@^J&UaD >1V/@0:=HKF;[^m!�$VW<EME@�>1V/Ua[#@0_`UaDW_`@^JhDW<ED/])AW< �P@^J1@BDZ>�>#UNF;<E_^[�HKJ1@0:=HKFWFP@BA

Os8/J1>1V/@^J0OQJ1Ua: @BHN_hViUN>1V/@^J ����V/@)UNJh<?]a<EDWHNM����$� ��HN[$HNM [#U=JL8WDGUaDi>1VW<E[�AWHK>1H=OgUNJ�_`Ua:YFIHKJL<E[1UaD��&��DWA/@^@BAfm

4 �

Page 85: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

<?>�_^HNDG9P@�[#@^@BD�>1VWHK>0>1VW@>1V/@^UNJL@^>1<E_^HNMfHNA/jKHNDT>1HK]N@B[$UNO >1V/@)AW<E[1_`JL@^>#@jN@^JL[L<?UaDW[.UNO�>1V/@):YU'A/@BM;FWJ1UNFPUa[#@BA�<ED

>1VW<E[0_hVWHKFW>#@^J�HKJ1@4J1@��I@B_`>#@BA <EDG>1V/@4j'<E[18IHNMEM?b=AW<E[L_`JL<E:=<EDIHK>1<?jN@�X78WHNME<E>kb�UNO�>1V/@\:=HKFWFI<EDW]a[��

!�<?]�� -���� �*[1VWU �$[�>1V/@eFPUa[#>#@^JL<?UNJ�:Y@BHNDW[�UaD�D/@��4mP8WDW[1@^@BD >#@B[1>�AIHK>1H�8I[1<ED/]=>1VW@eFIJ1@^j7<EUa8W[$F;HKJLHN:Y@��

>#@^JL<E[1@BA�:YU7AW@BME[��*�]aHN<ED6p^oNoiA/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[ �.@^J1@YFWJ1@B[#@BDZ>#@BA OQJ1Ua: @BHN_LV _^MEHN[1[��e��V/@Y[18/FP@^JL<?UNJh<?>kbCUNO.>1V/@

>1V/@^UNJ1@^>1< _^HNMEM?bCHKFWFWJ1UNFIJL<EHK>#@4:YU'A/@BMfOQUNJL:e8WMEHK>1<?UaDW[0< [�HNME[#U=JL@��I@B_`>#@BA < DC>1V/@ � ]N@BD/@^JhHNME<E[1HK>1<?UaD �W_^HKFIHK9I<EME<E>kb!�

� UNJ1@^U jN@^JBm�>1V/@=:e8WM?>1<ED/Ua:l<EHNM�:YU'A/@BM�@B:YFI<EJL<E_^HNMEM?bGFWJLU jN@B[�>#UC9P@YXZ8WHNM <?>1HK>1<?jN@BM?bi[18WF @^Jh<?UNJOQUNJ)>1V/@ j'<E[18��

HNME<E[LHK>1<?UaDdUNO�>#@� 7>)<EDd>1V/@B[#@ @� 7FP@^JL< :Y@BDT>1[�� >1VW<E[_^HND 9 @\@^j HNM 8WHK>#@BA,j7<E[L8WHNMEM?b�UaD,9 UN>1V !�<?]�� -�� n �4HNDWA

!�<?] -���� ��� < � @!�?m�>1V/@l:lHKFWFP@BA _`UNJ1FI8W[*VWHN[4UNJ1]aHNDI< %^@BA <ED :=UNJ1@l[#@^FIHKJhHK>#@BArJ1@^]a<EUaDW[)UNJ\_^M HN[1[#@B[�����V/@

UN9I[#@^JLj HK>1<?UaD UNO&>1V/@ :e8WM?>1<ED/Ua:l<EHNM :YU'A/@BM�b7<?@BM AW<ED/]=[18WF @^Jh<?UNJ�J1@B[18IM?>1[$UaD,>#@� '>�AIHK>1H ��HN[�HNME[#U�J1@^FPUNJ1>#@BA

<EDG>1V/@\ME<?>#@^JLHK>18/JL@�OQUNJ�9PUN>1Vi[18WF @^JLj7<E[1@BA�HNDIAC8WDW[18/FP@^J1j'<E[#@BA >#@� '> �k_^MEHN[1[1<SR _^HK>1<?UaD �SpNpNp � �Sp�/54�� �

��VW@GHNME]NUNJL<?>1VW:=[ �.@^J1@iHNME[#U >#@B[#>#@BAc8W[1<ED/] HND68WDW[L8/FP@^J1j7< [#@BA >#@^JL: [1@BM?@B_`>1<?UaD6:Y@^>1V/U'Afm&9;HN[#@BA UaD

DP<?FIO�� [.M H � �Sp�� � � mW< � @!�?mWJ1@^>1HN<EDI<ED/]Y<ED�>1V/@*AW< _`>1<?UaDWHKJ1b=UaDIM?b >1VW@)>#@^JL:=[0>1VWHK>$U7_^_^8/J�:=UNJ1@4>1VWHNDiHY_`@^JL>1HN<ED

D78W:*9P@^J�UNOW>1<E:Y@B[BmKHKOQ>#@^J�J1@B:YU j7< D/]>1VW@'� [#>#UNF � ��UNJLAI[��'q �.UNJLAW[�ME< �N@ � >1V/@ �?mT< [��?mK@^>1_ � t �&��< � @^J1@BDZ>�AW<E_`>1<?UaDWHKJLb

[1< %^@B[)�.@^J1@i<EDZjN@B[#>1<?]aHK>#@BA OgUNJ=_`Ua:YF;M?@^>#@BD/@B[1[^m.V/U �.@^jN@^J <E> < [eH �'D/U �$D OQHN_`>Y>1VIHK>=:=< '>18/J1@C:YU'A/@BMEME<EDW]

9P@B_`Ua:Y@B[GM?@B[1[l@ � _^<?@BDZ>�HN[�>1V/@,AW<E:Y@BDW[L<?UaD6UNO)>1V/@ AW<E_`>1<?UaDIHKJ1b6<EDW_`J1@BHN[#@B[ �Sp�� ��� � �$U ��@^jN@^J m$�YOQUa8WDWA

>1V/@=:e8WM?>1<EDWUa:=<EHNM�:YU'A/@BM�:YUNJ1@=>#UaM?@^JhHNDT>)>#Ui9PUN>1V�>1VW@=[18/9PUNFW>1<E:=HNM�>#@^JL: [1@BM?@B_`>1<?UaD HNDWA >1V/@=_^8/JL[#@YUNO

AW<E:=@BDW[1<?UaDWHNM <?>kb!� ��VI<E[ R;DWAW< D/].< [ _`UaDW[1<E[1>#@BDT>��<?>1V�J1@^FPUNJ1>#@BA4_`Ua:YF;HKJLHK>1<?jN@�_^M HN[1[1<SR;_^HK>1<EUaD)HNDWA4_^ME8W[1>#@^JL<ED/]

J1@B[18IM?>1[�<ED�>1V/@)ME<?>#@^JLHK>18/JL@ �SpNpNp � �Sp�/54�� �Sp�� ��� �Sp�/20�� � !�<?]�� -��1-���[1V/U �$[�>1V/@�9P@B[#>�J1@B[18WM?>1[)qs_hV/Ua[#@BDCj'<E[18WHNM M?b

OQJ1Ua: HC[#@^JL<?@B[�UNO��dUaDZ>#@�"�HKJhM?UGJL8WDW[^mf< � @!�e[#>1HKJ1>1<EDW] �<?>1V�AW< �P@^J1@BDZ>JLHNDIA/Ua:=M?bd< DW<?>1<EHNME< %^@BAiFIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^J

:=HK>#JL< Wthm UaD,9 UN>1V >#JLHN<EDI<ED/]lHNDWA >#@B[#>1<EDW]�[#@^>1[Bm UN9I>1HN<ED/@BA �$<?>1Vd>1V/@e:e8WM?>1< D/Ua:=<EHNM :=U7A/@BM�UaD,>1V/@ [1HN:Y@

AWHK>1H�HNDWA68I[1<ED/] H�AW<E_`>1<?UaDIHKJ1br[1< %^@GUNO 0Ko5054,>#@^JL:=[Bm�_LVWUa[#@BD6UaDWM?br9Zb OgJL@BXZ8/@BDI_`brUNO$U'_^_^8/J1JL@BDW_`@rqsHNMEM

>#@^JL:=[ �$VW<E_hVGU7_^_^8/JLJ1@BAi:YUNJ1@*>1VWHND / >1<E:=@B[0<EDG>1V/@4>#@� '>$HNDWA��VW<E_LVCHKJL@*D/UN>$[#>#UNF �.UNJLAW[ht �

!/UNJ�>1V/@*R;DWHNMf@� 'FP@^JL<E:Y@BDZ> �$<E>1Vi>#@� '>�AWHK>1Hl>1V/@*OQJ1@BX78/@BDW_`bi_`Ua8WDZ>< D/OgUNJh:=HK>1<?UaDC]a<?jN@B[�:YUNJL@*j'<E[18WHNM

AW<E[L_`JL<E:=<EDIHK>1<?UaD,9 @^> ��@^@BD UN>1V/@^J��<E[#@lFPUa[1[L<?9IM?b U jN@^JLMEHKFIFI<ED/]d_^M HN[1[#@B[��G��D >1VW<E[\_^HN[#@Nm�>1V/@ >#JLHN<?>4jN@^JL[L<?UaD

�$<?>1V*H$:e8WM?>1<ED/Ua:l<EHNMKD/Ua<E[#@�:=U7A/@BMaOgUNJL:e8WMEHK>1<EUaD4:=HBb)FIJ1U j'<EA/@&[18WF @^Jh<?UNJfJ1@B[18WME>1[f>#U$>1VWHK>.�$VW<E_hV4_`UaDW[1< A/@^JL[

UaDWM?b 9I< DWHKJ1b U7_^_^8/JLJ1@BDW_`@ < D/OgUNJh:=HK>1<?UaD�� ��V/JL@^@d_^MEHN[1[#@B[�HKJ1@,_LV/Ua[#@BD m�[18W_LV�>1VWHK> > �.U UNO)>1VW@B: �.@^J1@

[#>#J1UaDW]aM?b U jN@^JLMEHKFIFI<ED/]�/ � _`Ua:=F�� [#b'[�� <?9I:�� Ff_ � VWHKJhA��.HKJL@ �?m � _`Ua:YF�� [1b7[�� :lHN_ � VWHKJLA���HKJ1@ ��HNDIA � [1_^< � :=@BA(� ���

D78W:*9P@^J)UNO0nKoNodA/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[ �.@^J1@=>1H �N@BDrOgJ1Ua: @BHN_LV _^MEHN[1[4HNDWA�HdAW<E_`>1<?UaDWHKJLb [1< %^@YUNO)p�/KoC>#@^Jh:=[ ��HN[

8W[#@BA�� �$V/@CAW<E_`>1<?UaDWHKJLb �.HN[YHK]aHN<ED HNA/jKHNDZ>1HK]N@^Ua8W[1M?b _LV/Ua[1@BD 9Zbr� � m�>1VW@^J1@^OgUNJL@�>1VI<E[ AW<E_`>1<?UaDWHKJLb [1< %^@

[1V/Ua8IMEAG9P@*[18 � _^<E@BDT> �Sp�� � ��>#U _^HKFW>18WJ1@4>1V/@*[1>#JL8W_`>18/J1@*UNO�>1VW@*_`UNJ1FI8W[ ��!�<?]��1-���/ �0[1V/U �$[$_`Ua:=FIHKJLHK>1<?jN@BM?b

4'-

Page 86: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

>1V/@ nK� :lHKFWFI<ED/]GUN9W>1HN< D/@BA�97b,>1VW@l�.@^JLD/Ua8WMEM <�HNDIA :\8IM?>1<ED/Ua:=< HNM�>#JhHN<?>*:YU'A/@BM�jKHKJL<EHNDZ>1[��=��DW[#FP@B_`>1<ED/]

>1V/@YME<E[1>1[$UNO�>1V/@Y:YUa[#>�FWJ1UN9IHK9;M?@��.UNJLAW[^m HN[L[#U7_^< HK>#@BA >#U�>1VW@ AI< � @^JL@BDT>�]NJL<EA,FPUa<EDZ>1[ � < � @!�?mf>1VW@e>#UNF�UNO

>1V/@ J1@^Og@^JL@BDW_`@ljN@B_`>#UNJL[ ��q������ t �$VW<E_hV VWH jN@ 9P@^@BD OQUNJL:Y@BA � UaD/@�_^HNDrJL@B_`UN]aDW< %^@ :=@BHNDW<ED/]NOs8WM �.UNJLA

]NJ1Ua8/F;<ED/]a[��l�7Ua:Y@lUNO�>1V/@B[1@lME<E[#>1[)HKJL@l[1V/U �$D UaD !�<?]���-���0 �C��D/@=_^HNDrHNM [#UCUN9I[#@^J1jN@l>1VWHK>4]NJL<EA FPUa<EDZ>1[

>1VWHK>=ME<E@G< D UaDW@CUNO>1V/@i_^M HN[1[#@B[��&_`@BDZ>#JLHNM0J1@^]a<EUaDW[Y[#>#UNJ1@i:Y@BHNDI<ED/]NOs8WM��N@^b �.UNJLAW[=< D >1VW@B<?J=ME<E[#>1[eUNO�>1V/@

:YUa[#>lFWJ1UN9IHK9IME@ �.UNJLAW[Bm �$V/@^JL@BHN[Y>1V/Ua[#@dMEb7<EDW] < D6HND6U jN@^JLM HKFWFI<ED/]�HKJ1@BH [#>#UNJ1@��.UNJLAW[Y>1VIHK>=U7_^_^8WJl<ED

A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[l_`UaDW_`@^JhDW<ED/]�>1V/@ �#8IDW_`>1<?UaD6UNO�>1V/@B[#@,AW<E[1_^8I[1[1<?UaD >#UNFI<E_^[ <ED69PUN>1V :YU'A/@BME[ � !/UNJ�@� 'HN:=FIM?@

A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[.J1@^]aHKJLAW<EDW]*>1V/@�D/@^]aHK>1<?jN@�@��P@B_`>1[�UNO�_`Ua:YFI8W>#@^JL[�UaDG[1_hV/U7UaM _hVW<EMEAWJ1@BDlHNDWA >1V/Ua[#@)_`UaDW_`@^JhDW<ED/]

>1V/@=8W[1@YUNO._`Ua:YF;8/>#@^JL[)<ED�:Y@BAI<E_^<ED/@ ��@^JL@l:=HKFWFP@BA HK>4>1V/@ �18WDW_`>1<?UaD,9P@^> �.@^@BD >1VW@=HKJ1@BHN[*_`UaDW_`@^JhDW<ED/]

_`Ua:YFI8W>#@^JL[4HNDWA :=@BAW<E_^<ED/@!�Y��VW@=HK9 U jN@ _`Ua:=:=@BDT>1[���@^J1@ :=HNA/@=HKOQ>#@^J*@� /VWHN8W[#>1<?jN@ <EDW[#FP@B_`>1<?UaD,UNO�>1V/@

J1@^OQ@^J1@BDW_`@CjN@B_`>#UNJL[ �$VW<E_hV6VWHBjN@d9 @^@BD @B[1>1<E:=HK>#@BA697br>1V/@iHNME]NUNJL<?>1VW: OQUNJ=@^jKHNME8WHK>1<?UaD FI8WJ1FPUa[#@B[^m�>1V78W[

A/@B:YUaDI[#>#JLHK>1<ED/]l>1VWHK>$>1V/@*FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>#@BA :=U7A/@BM�_^HNDd<EDWAW@^@BAi_`UaDW[1<E[1>#@BDT>1M?bGJ1@^jN@BHNM�>1V/@e[#@B:=HNDZ>1<E_4[#>#JL8I_`>18/J1@

UNO$>1VW@G_`UNJLFI8W[eUaD6H n �k� :=HKF��r��VW@ >1HK9IME@B[ UNO$>1V/@G@� /VWHN8W[#>1<?jN@GJ1@^OQ@^J1@BDW_`@�� jN@B_`>#UNJh[l_^HND69P@G[#@^@BD UaD

!�<?]�� -���0 HNDWA !�<?]�� -�� 4 J1@B[#FP@B_`>1<?jN@BM?b!� �$V/@B[#@6p^o p^o >1HK9IM?@B[C[1V/U � >1V/@ >#UNF�ME<E[#>1[ UNO*>1VW@ :YUa[#>

FWJ1UN9;HK9IM?@ �.UNJLAW[lJ1@^FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>#@BA�9Zb HNMEM$>1V/@ p^o p^or]NJh<EA FPUa<EDZ>1[l<ED >1V/@B[#@,> �.U @� 'FP@^JL<E:Y@BDZ>1[�� ��HN_hV

_`@BMEM�UNO�>1VW@e>1HK9;M?@Y_`UNJ1J1@B[#FPUaDWAW[�>#UGUaD/@Y]NJL< AdFPUa<EDZ>�� !/UNJ)>1V/@ @BHN[#@YUNO�OgUaM M?U �$< D/] OQUNJ�>1V/@YJ1@BHNA/@^J m [#Ua:Y@

UNJL<?@BDZ>1HK>1<?jN@\9 Ua8IDWAWHKJL<?@B[$HKJ1@4FWJ1U j7< A/@BAiUaDd>1V/@4RI]a8WJ1@49P@^> �.@^@BDdJL@^]a<?UaDW[ �VW<E_LVi>#J1@BHK>�AI< � @^JL@BDT>�>#UNF;<E_^[��

��D/@0_^HND <EDWA/@^@BAeOQUaMEM?U � H)AI<E[#>1<EDW_`>�>#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVW< _�UNJLA/@^JL<EDW]UNO >1V/@0J1@^OQ@^J1@BDW_`@�� jN@B_`>#UNJL[ /�D/@B<?]aVZ9PUNJL<ED/]]NJL<EA

FPUa<EDZ>1[VWH jN@=:=HNDZb �.UNJLAW[�<ED,_`Ua:=:YUaD HNDWA ��UNJhAW[�]NJ1Ua8/FP@BA,>#UN]N@^>1V/@^J*HKJL<E[1@\OQJ1Ua: >1V/@ [1HN:Y@Y[18/9��#@B_`>

HKJ1@BH�� �$U ��@^jN@^J <ED >1V/@GAW< �P@^J1@BDZ>1<EHK>1<?UaDrUNO�>1V/@�> �.U,U jN@^JLMEHKFWF;<ED/] _^M HN[1[#@B[^m�>1V/@G:\8IM?>1<ED/Ua:=< HNM&:YU'A/@BM � [

J1@B[18IM?>4<E[*_^ME@BHKJLM?b [18/FP@^JL<?UNJ � ��VW<E[4_^HND HNME[#U 9 @=[1@^@BDrOQJ1Ua: >1VW@l:=HKFWFI< D/]CUNO0A/U7_^8I:Y@BDT>1[�q !�<?]���-���/ � t �

��V/@��.@^JLD/Ua8WM ME<W>#JLHN<E>.:YU'A/@BM _^M?@BHKJLM?b AW<E[#>1<EDW]a8W<E[1V/@B[&9 @^> ��@^@BDC_`Ua:=FI8/>#@^J0[1_^<?@BDW_`@�J1@BM HK>#@BA�HNDIA�:=@BAW<E_^<ED/@

J1@BMEHK>#@BA J1@^]a<?UaDW[�� � >l_`UaDZ>1HN<EDW[=[#Ua:=@CJ1@^]a<?UaDW[=< DW[1<EA/@�>1V/@i_`Ua:YF;8/>#@^J � [=[18W9���@B_`>Y>1VIHK>lHKJ1@i[#FP@B_^<SR;_^HNM M?b

J1@BMEHK>#@BA >#U�!�"�[ HNDWA >#U � HN_^<EDZ>#Ua[1V J1@B[1F @B_`>1<EjN@BM?bNm&9I8/> <ED :YUa[#> UNO>1V/@GJ1@^]a<?UaD !." HNDWA �,HN_^<EDT>#Ua[LV

J1@BMEHK>#@BA,[18/9���@B_`>1[�_`UZ@� /<E[#>��$� Dd>18/JLDi>1VW@\:e8WM?>1<ED/Ua:l<EHNMf:=HKFWFI< D/]lVWHN[�[#@^FIHKJLHK>#@BA,:YUNJ1@ AW<E[1>1<EDW_`>1M?b @^jN@BD

>1V/@ [#Ua:Y@��$VIHK>U jN@^JLMEHKFWFI< D/] _`Ua:YF;8/>#@^J�� J1@BMEHK>#@BA,>#UNFI< _^[97bd:=HKFIFI<ED/]=>1VW@B: >#UGAW<E[1>1<EDW_`>$JL@^]a<?UaDW[��)��D/@

_^HND=OQUaMEM?U �cUaD !�<E]��;-�� 4 ��<EDY>1V/@$8WFWFP@^J�J1@^]a<?UaD=UNOP>1V/@]NJL<EA �N@^b �.UNJLAW[&JL@^]aHKJLAW<ED/]4�,HN_^<EDZ>#Ua[1V�VWHKJLA���HKJ1@Nm

<EDC>1VW@\M?@^OQ>�J1@^]a<?UaD �N@^b �.UNJLAW[�_`UaDW_`@^JLDI<ED/]l!�" VWHKJLA �.HKJ1@\HNDWAi>1V/@*JL<?]aVZ>1:YUa[#>HKJL@BHl<E[_`UaDW_`@^JLD/@BA �$<?>1V

>1V/@�!." �7�$UN>#@�>1VWHK>.>1V/@9 Ua8IDWAWHKJL<?@B[&>#JLHN_`@BAGHKJ1@ �18W[#>.HKFWFWJ1U '< :=HK>#@�HNDIAlHKJ1@�D/UN>�8WD/@BX78W<?jNU'_^HNMW9I8/>�>1V/@

FIHN[1[L<ED/] OgJLUa: HYJ1@^]a<?UaDi>#UlHND/UN>1V/@^J�<E[�JLHK>1V/@^J�]NJhHNAW8WHNM �

4 /

Page 87: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

��DW[#FP@B_`>1<ED/]COs8/J1>1VW@^J !�<?]��3-�� 4 �?m�UaD/@�_^HND AW< [#>1<ED/]a8W< [1V [18/9�� FIHKJL>1<?>1<?UaDW<EDW] �<?>1VW<ED UaD/@�D/@��$[#]NJLUa8/F � [

HKJ1@BH*>1HNM �7< D/]4HK9PUa8/>�J1@BMEHK>#@BAl9I8/>&[1ME<E]aVT>1M?beAW<E[#>1< DW_`>�>#UNFI<E_^[^m7[18W_hV=HN[�_`Ua:=:=UaDlV/@BHNM?>1V <ED >1V/@$8WFWFP@^J�FIHKJ1>

UNO�>1V/@G:Y@BAW< _^<ED/@ � [4JhHND/]N@ �V/@^J1@BHN[e:YUNJ1@G[#FP@B_^<SR;_l:=@BAW<E_^HNM&>#@^Jh:=[ _`Ua:Y@�< Dr>1V/@�JL<?]aVZ>\MEU �.@^J _`UNJhD/@^J �

��DW[1<EA/@�!."�VWHKJLA �.HKJ1@)AW< [1_^8W[1[1<EUaDW[&>1V/@^JL@�HKJL@�[1F @B_^<?R;_�>#UNFI< _^[0HK9 Ua8W>�j'<EA/@^UY_^HKJLAW[�HNDWAG:YUaDI<?>#UNJL[�<ED�>1V/@

M?U ��@^J�J1@^]a<?UaDfmZ>1V/@BDl:YU j7< D/]*8/F >1V/@�]NJL<EA maFWJ1U'_`@B[1[#UNJ._`Ua:YFPUaD/@BDT>1[BmT>1V/@BD <EDT>#@^JhDWHNMW:Y@B:YUNJLb HNDIAYR;DWHNM M?b

@� '>#@^JLDWHNM :Y@B:=UNJ1bC<EDG>1V/@48/FWFP@^J�[18W9CJ1@^]a<?UaD��

���� � � � � � � �" � � � � � �������� ��� � � � " � �� � ������ ������� �

��U*[#@^@�V/U �c>1V/@�[LHN:Y@�HNM?]NUNJL<?>1VI: _^HND=9P@0HKFWFIME<?@BAe>#U*AIHK>1H4_`Ua:=<ED/])OQJ1Ua: AW< � @^J1@BDZ>�J1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>1HK>1<EUaDW[

<ED AW< �P@^J1@BDZ>�_`UaDZ>#@� '>1[^mZHND @� 'FP@^JL<E:Y@BDZ>�UaD 9;<EDWHKJ1b4_`U'A/@BAYVWHNDWA ��JL<?>#>#@BDeAW<?]a<?>1[BmK< [�FIJ1@B[#@BDZ>#@BA���� ��U)V78WD��

A/J1@BA @� /HN:YFIM?@B[.UNO�@BHN_hVGUNO�>1V/@�VWHNDWA ��JL<?>#>#@BD�AW<?]a<?>1['� o �?m(�Ep �?m � n �?m(��� �WHNDWA �1- �/OgUNJL:=@BAl>1V/@)<EDWFI8/>1[&UNO�>1V/@

�.@^JLD/Ua8WM ME<P>#JLHN<?>$HNME]NUNJL<?>1VW:���!�<?]�� -���� ��[1V/U �$[ �l<EDW[#>1HNDW_`@B[$OgJLUa: @BHN_LV,_^HK>#@^]NUNJ1b!���<EDW@4D/UaDWME<EDW@BHKJ$HNDWA

UaD/@$M <ED/@BHKJ&9IHN[L<E[�jN@B_`>#UNJ ��@^JL@_LVWUa[#@BD=>#U\FWJ1U j'<EA/@$>1V/@$[1HN:YF;M?@B[�OQJ1Ua: >1V/@HN[1[18W:Y@BA MEHK>#@BDZ>�AW<E[1>#JL<?9I8/>1<EUaD

<EDG>1VW< [�@� 7FP@^JL<E:=@BDT>��&�(AWHK>1H=_`Ua:=FWJ1@B[1[1<EUaDGOgJ1Ua: n$-aolAW<E:=@BDW[1<?UaDW[.>#U n=<E[�FP@^J1OgUNJh:Y@BAfm']NUa<ED/]=>1VWJ1Ua8/]aV

>1V/@,p^od9IHN[L<E[*Os8WDW_`>1<EUaDW[��C��VW<E[\[#@^>#>1<ED/],<E:YFIM <?@B[)9WJ1UaHNAW@^J\D/@B<?]aVZ9PUNJLV/U7U7A J1@BMEHK>1<?UaDW[*>1VWHND >1V/@�[1@^>#>1<ED/]

�$VW< _LV ��HN[�8/>1<EME< %^@BAlOQUNJ$A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[0AWHK>1H=HNDWAG@� 'FP@^JL<E:Y@BDZ>1HNMEM?blFWJ1U jN@BAi>#U=9P@�[L8 � _^<?@BDZ>�OgUNJ�>1VI<E[�AWHK>1H

� �4OQUa8WDWA >1VWHK>YAW< �P@^J1@BDZ>YDZ8W:\9P@^JL[\UNOD/UaDWM <ED/@BHKJe9IHN[1<E[eOs8WDW_`>1<?UaDW[\FWJ1U j7< A/@BA XZ8WHNM <?>1HK>1<?jN@BM?br[L<E:=<EMEHKJ

J1@B[18IM?>1[��

�'< :=<EMEHKJ0>#U >1V/@*>#@� '> �k:=<EDW< D/]=HKFWFIME< _^HK>1<?UaDfm �$VW@^J1@4>1V/@\J1@^Og@^JL@BDW_`@�� jN@B_`>#UNJL[^mf< � @!�?m;>1V/@ ��q������Nt�jKHNME8/@B[

]aHBjN@\8W[�>1V/@)FWJ1UN9;HK9I<EME<?> b UNO�@BHN_hV���UNJhAGOgUNJ0@BHN_hViUNO�>1VW@ � p ��� ]NJL<EA�� FPUa<EDZ>1[^m'<ED�>1V/@4_^HN[#@)UNO�< :=HK]N@��AWHK>1H�>1V/@Y[1HN:Y@ @� 'FWJ1@B[1[L<?UaD [1<?]aDW<SR;@B[$>1V/@ FWJLUN9IHK9I<EME<E>1<?@B[0UNO�@BHN_hV�FI< '@BM�<EDd>1VW@eJL@^Og@^J1@BDI_`@�� jN@B_`>#UNJ*9P@B<ED/]

HN_`>1<?jN@!��� D UN>1V/@^J ��UNJhAW[^m >1V/@^J1@ <E[$H J1@^OQ@^J1@BDW_`@��k<E:=HK]N@eOQUNJ�@BHN_hV,]NJL<EA�� FPUa<EDZ>�����V/@e��@^JhD/Ua8WMEME< F Ua[1>#@^JL<?UNJ

:Y@BHNDW[ HNDWA >1V/@GJ1@^OQ@^J1@BDW_`@��k<E:lHK]N@B[Y<EDW[#FP@B_`>#@BAr< DrJ1@^]a<EUaDW[*UNO�HK]N]aM?Ua:Y@^JLHK>1<EUaD UNO>1V/@�F Ua[1>#@^JL<?UNJ :Y@BHND

FWJ1U��#@B_`>1<?UaDW[$HKJ1@4FWJ1@B[1@BDT>#@BAi< D"!�<E]�� -�� � �

!/UNJ.>1V/@�9;<EDWHKJ1b _`U7AW@BAlAW<?]a<E>1[�AWHK>1H'mZ>1VW@AW< �P@^J1@BDW_`@B[&9 @^> ��@^@BD >1V/@�FP@^J1OQUNJL:=HNDI_`@�UNOfHNDlHKFWFWJLUNFWJL<EHK>#@

�.@^JLD/Ua8WM ME<I:YU'A/@BM HNDWA >1V/@):YUNJ1@�[1<E:YFIME@ ��HN8W[1[L<EHND �)��� :YU'A/@BM ��@^JL@OQUa8WDWA�:\8I_LVGM?@B[1[.FWJ1UaDWUa8WDW_`@BA��

��V/@eJ1@BHN[#UaD�< [FIJ1UN9IHK9IM?biAI8/@\>#UC>1VW@ :=UNJ1@eAW@BDW[#@YDWHK>18/J1@eUNO�>1VI<E[�AWHK>1H�>1VWHND >1VWHK>�UNO�>1V/@YA/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>

AWHK>1H��

� UNJ1@�<EDT>#@^JL@B[#>1<ED/]�<E[ >#U�[#@^@.>1V/@�JL@^FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaD\>1VWHK>�>1VW@�HNM?]NUNJL<E>1VW: VIHN[�9I8I<EM?> HNDWA��$VW<E_hV*8WDIA/@^JLME<?@B[

>1V/@�>#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVZb UNO$>1V/@Cn �k� FWJ1U��#@B_`>1<?UaD�� ��V/@�OQ8WM M&[#@^> UNO�J1@^OQ@^J1@BDW_`@��k<E:lHK]N@B[Y_`UNJ1J1@B[#FPUaDWAW< D/]i>#U >1V/@

4 0

Page 88: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

p^o p^o ]NJL<EAiFPUa<EDZ>1[$HKJL@e[1VWU �$D,<ED!�<?]�� -��Ep^o��4�)Di>1VW<E[:=HKF,UaD/@e_^HND [#@^@ D/UN>UaDWM?bC>1V/@e:Y@BHNDW<ED/]NOs8WM

]NJ1Ua8/F;<ED/]a[ UNOIFI< '@BME[^m��$VW<E_hV*<EDWAW@^@BA4OQUNJL: < :=HK]N@B[�J1@^FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>1<ED/]>1V/@.OgUa8/J�AW<?]a<E>1[^m 9;8/>�HNME[1UH�:Y@BHNDW<ED/]NOs8WM

]NJ1Ua8/F;<ED/]CUNO0>1V/@B[#@ J1@^OQ@^J1@BDW_`@��k<E:=HK]N@B[Bm�HN[eHi:=HN_`JLU �k[#>#JL8W_`>18/JL@Nm�< D [18W_hV Hi:lHNDWD/@^J*>1VIHK>\D/@B<?]aVZ9PUNJL<ED/]

<E:=HK]N@B[lHKJ1@i]N@^Ua:Y@^>#JL< _^HNMEM?b6:YUNJ1@i[1< :=<EMEHKJ >#U @BHN_hVcUN>1V/@^Jl>1VWHND6>1V/Ua[#@dOgUa8WDIA6HK>lH�Os8/J1>1V/@^J=AW< [#>1HNDW_`@

H ��HBb!� ��VW<E[l<E[lHr9IHN[1<E_COQ@BHK>18/J1@,UNO�>1V/@dFIJ1@B[#@BDZ>#@BAc>#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVI<E_i:YU'A/@BM � ��DcHNAWAW<E>1<?UaDfm�!�<E]�� -��Ep^o��

<EMEM 8W[#>#JLHK>#@B[)>1VW@�_^HN[#@ �$V/@^JL@l>1V/@�>#JLHN<?>eHNM?]NUNJL<?>1VW: ��UNJ��7[eUa8/>e<EDT>#@^Jh:Y@BAW<EHK>#@ OgUNJL:l[^m�@^jN@BD <EO.>1VW@^brHKJ1@

D/UN>.J1@^FWJ1@B[1@BDT>#@BA�97b=J1@BHNM @� 'HN:=FIM?@B[^m7]a<?j'<ED/]*Jh<E[#@$>#U H :YUNJ1FIVI<ED/])9P@^> �.@^@BDG>1V/@�AW< �P@^J1@BDT>�AW<?]a<E>1[����$V/@B[#@

<EDZ>#@^JL:Y@BAW< HK>#@YOgUNJL:l[4HNAWAW<?>1<EUaDWHNMEM?bd_`JL@BHK>#@ >1V/@Y9;MEHND�� HKJ1@BHN[49P@^> �.@^@BDr< :=HK]N@B[4UNO0AW< �P@^J1@BDZ>4_^MEHN[1[#@B[*UaD

>1V/@\n �k� :lHKFiUNO�>1V/@)FPUa[#>#@^JL<?UNJ$:=@BHNDW[�HNDWAi[1U=V/@BM?FC>1V/@4F;HKJ1>1<?>1<?UaDW< D/]e< DGj7<E[L8WHNME<E[1HK>1<EUaD��

� ��� ����� �!�����������

�6]N@BDW@^JLHNMTFIJ1UN9IHK9I<EM <E[#>1<E_�OQJLHN:Y@��.UNJ��*VWHN[�9P@^@BD*FWJL@B[#@BDT>#@BA m OQJ1Ua: �$VW<E_hV*jKHKJL<EHNDZ>1[�UNOI_^MEHN[1[ �PHNDWA\>#JLHN<?>

:YU'A/@BME[4[L8W<?>1HK9IM?@YOQUNJ\HNDIHNM?b7[L<E[^m�_^M 8W[#>#@^JL<EDW]iHNDWA j'<E[18WHNM <E[1HK>1<?UaD UNO�:e8WM?>1<?jKHKJL<EHK>#@=AIHK>1HiOQUaMEM?U ���G� U'A/@BME[

[#FP@B_^<SR;_^HNM M?b=HKFWFIME< _^HK9IM?@�OgUNJ*qQFPUa[1[1<E9IM?b=[#FIHKJh[#@ t.AW<E[1_`JL@^>#@�:e8WM?>1<Ej HKJL< HK>#@�AWHK>1H ��@^J1@4AW@B[1_`JL<?9P@BA����$FIFIME<E_^H��

>1<?UaDW[*UNO�>1V/@lFWJLUNF Ua[1@BA :YU'A/@BME[)OQUNJ*>#@� '>\:=< DW<ED/]CHNDWA AW<?]a<?>1HNM&< :=HK]N@ HNDWHNMEb7[1< [ ��@^JL@lHNME[#U FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>#@BA��

�(J1@BHNAW< M?bC<EDT>#@^JLFWJ1@^>1HK9IM?@*J1@^FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaDWHNM�[#>#JL8I_`>18/J1@ ��HN[�UN9W>1HN<ED/@BAdUaDd>#@� '>9;HN[#@BA AWU7_^8W:=@BDT>�AWHK>1H'm

HNDWAYHND=HKFIFIHKJ1@BDZ>�>#UNFPUN]NJLHKF;VW<E_�FWJ1UN>#UN> bZF;<E_^HNM'J1@^FWJ1@B[1@BDT>1HK>1<?UaD=J1@B[18WM?>#@BA <ED >1VW@�_^HN[#@0UNO < :=HK]N@B[�UNOPVWHNDWA��

��JL<E>#>#@BD�AW<?]a<?>1[�� ��V/@ FWJL@B[#@BDT>#@BAr:Y@^>1V/U'A <E[)8W[#@^Os8WM�OQUNJ4HNDTb�[18W_hV�AWHK>1HiHNDWHNMEb7[1< [�HKFIFIME<E_^HK>1<?UaDI[ �V/@^J1@

>1V/@4j'<E[18IHNME<E[1HK>1<?UaD UNO�H=:e8WM?>1<?jKHKJL<EHK>#@)AW<E[L_`J1@^>#@4AWHK>1H=[#@^><E[0[#Ua8/]aVZ>��

��DiHNMEMf>1VW@4:YU7AW@BME[0FWJ1@B[1@BDT>#@BAi< DC>1VW<E[0_hVWHKFW>#@^J�>1V/@4<E:YFIM <E_^<?>�HN[1[18W:YFI>1<?UaDGUNO�AWHK>1H=<EDW[1>1HNDW_`@B[09P@B<ED/]

<EDWAW@^F @BDIA/@BDT>HNDWA < A/@BDT>1< _^HNMEM?bCAW<E[#>#Jh<?9I8/>#@BA qs< � < � A�� t��.HN[):=HNAW@!���$V/@\D/@� '>)_LVWHKFI>#@^J �<EMEM�_`UaDI[1<EA/@^J�>1V/@

j'<E[18WHNME< [1HK>1<?UaD�UNO�>1< :Y@��kA/@^FP@BDWA/@BDZ>�AWHK>1H��

424

Page 89: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

Bernoulli Gaussian on binary data

Multinomial Gaussian on normalized freq. data

Poisson Gaussian on log−freq. data

� �<> !.*�# � � � !�Ua[#>#@^Jh<?UNJ):Y@BHNDW[�FWJ1U j7< A/@BAd97bi>1V/@YAW< � @^J1@BDZ>�FWJ1UN9IHK9I< ME<E[#>1<E_)M HK>#@BDT>�>#JLHN<?>)HNM?]NUNJh<?>1VW:=[UaD

>#JLHN<EDI<ED/]AIHK>1H�8I[1<ED/] -�AI<E[#>1<EDW_`>�A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>�_^MEHN[L[#@B[�OgJ1Ua: >1V/@�nKo��k�@��$[#]NJ1Ua8WFI[�_`UNJ1FI8W[ / � � [1_^< � _`J1b7FW>��?m

U � [L_^< � :Y@BA(�?m � � [1_^< � [#F;HN_`@ �;HNDWA�� � [#U'_ � J1@BME<?]a<?UaD�� _LV/JL< [#>1<EHND(� ����V/@)Jh<?]aVT>0F;M?UN>1[�[1V/U ��>1V/@*_`UNJLJ1@��

[#FPUaDWAW< D/]\JL@B[18WM?>1[0<?O�8W[1<EDW]e>1VW@)>1V/@^UNJ1@^>1<E_^HNMEMEb�D/UN>�HKFIFWJ1UNFWJL< HK>#@)9I8/>�FWJLHN_`>1<E_^HNM M?b :YUNJL@*[1<E:YF;M?@UNJh<?]a<EDWHNM

��HN8W[L[1<EHND �)��� HNM?]NUNJL<?>1VI:��i��V/@l[LHN:Y@ MEHK>#@BDZ> [#@^>#>1<ED/]a[eHNDWA F;HKJLHN:Y@^>#@^JY<EDW<?>1< HNME< %BHK>1<?UaDW[ �.@^J1@G8W[#@BA

OQUNJ�@BHN_LV,:YU'A/@BM �

4 �

Page 90: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

Bernoulli Gaussian on binary data

Multinomial Gaussian on normalized freq. data

Poisson Gaussian on log−freq. data

� �<> !.*�# � � 6 !�Ua[#>#@^Jh<?UNJ):Y@BHNDW[�FWJ1U j7< A/@BAd97bi>1V/@YAW< � @^J1@BDZ>�FWJ1UN9IHK9I< ME<E[#>1<E_)M HK>#@BDT>�>#JLHN<?>)HNM?]NUNJh<?>1VW:=[UaD

>#@B[#>eAWHK>1Hd8W[L<ED/]�- AW< [#>1<EDW_`>)A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>*_^MEHN[1[1@B[4OQJ1Ua: >1V/@�nKo��k�$@��$[1]NJ1Ua8/FI[e_`UNJ1FI8W[ / � [1_^< � _`J1b7FW>��?m

U � [1_^< � :Y@BA �?m � � [1_^< � [#FIHN_`@ �&HNDIA � � [#U'_ � J1@BME<E]a<?UaD�� _LVWJL<E[#>1<EHND ����V/@C[1HN:=@GM HK>#@BDT>=[#@^>#>1< D/]a[YHNDWA

FIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^J<EDW<E>1<EHNME< %BHK>1<?UaDI[ �.@^J1@*8W[1@BAGOgUNJ@BHN_LVd:=U7A/@BM �

4 �

Page 91: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

Training data Test data

� �<> !.*�# � � � ��JhHN<EDW<ED/]HNDWAe>#@B[#>�AIHK>1HJL@B[18WM?>1[.�$<?>1V\>1V/@�:\8WME>1<ED/Ua:=<EHNMT:YU7AW@BMTUaDe>#@� '>�AIHK>1H�8I[1<ED/]$VI<?]aV/@^J

AW<E:=@BDW[1<?UaDWHNM7AW<E_`>1<EUaDWHKJ1b�q 0Ko5054)>#@^JL:=[^m7_LV/Ua[1@BDY9Zb �N@^@^FI<EDW])>#@^JL:=[ �$VI<E_LV U'_^_^8/J1J1@BAl:YUNJ1@0>1VWHND /�>1< :Y@B[

<EDG>1V/@*>#@� 7>ht �

�Ko

Page 92: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

Binomial Trait Mapping

write articl school comput year water person appl machin involv set

bu card dx mb write ram spe run window cach controll

appl write mac articl quadra comput machin price run softwar ram

drive controll disk set id scsi jumper floppi card comput pc

write articl comput mac year upgrad appl port school effect person

monitor mac appl ibm card board upgrad lciii driver pc hardwar

write articl effect year school comput doctor water machin person research

write articl peopl food msg chines reaction year eat person result

pain medic doctor write treat condition diseas patient diagnos articl treatment

Multinomial Trait Mapping

doctor medic write clinic articl treatment patient diseas evid medicin treat

appl duo mac macintosh mhz run write fpu powerbook lc softwar

appl write mac articl price centri comput softwar macintosh machin hardwar

drive disk scsi id articl install floppi mb write card controll

mb id disk ram articl install scsi spe memori write drive

mac drive meg scsi hd driver comput mb run iisi articl

write year articl school effect machin comput set involv person result

card monitor video window articl write driver pc spe appl board

write patient articl medic treatment doctor diseas condition treat peopl yeast

� �<> !.*�# � � � ".Ua:YFIHKJhHK>1<?jN@&FPUa[#>#@^JL<?UNJ�:Y@BHNDW[fFWJLU j'<EA/@BA)97b>1VW@��.@^JLD/Ua8WMEM <NHNDWA4:e8WM?>1<ED/Ua:l<EHNMKMEHK>#@BDT>�>#JLHN<?>

HNM?]NUNJL<E>1VW: UaD=> ��UeU jN@^JhMEHKFWFI<EDW]lq � _`Ua:YF�� [#b'[�� <?9I: � FP_ � VIHKJLA���HKJ1@ �?maU � _`Ua:YF�� [#b'[�� :=HN_ � VWHKJhA��.HKJL@ � t

HNDWA UaD/@CAW<E[#>1< DW_`> q�� � [L_^< � :Y@BA(� t*_^MEHN[1[#@B[ HNDWA <EDI[#FP@B_`>1<ED/]d[#Ua:=@ UNO�>1VW@ ]NJL< ArFPUa<EDZ>1[*OQUNJe>1V/@C:YUa[#>

FWJ1UN9;HK9IM?@ ��UNJhAW[��

�'p

Page 93: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

articlwrite

applprice

writearticlmacdrive

mac

machinmacarticlappl

applpricemachin

write

comput

mac

upgradapplprice

hardwar

maccomputdrive

drive

writedrivearticlprice

mac

computpricewritearticl

price

computdrivemac

appl

computpchardwardrive

pc

diskpcwrite

drive

comput

porthardwar

drivemac

mac

videomonitor

computquadra

applwritemacarticl

card

boardcardapplpc

mac

boardapplwindow

monitor

upgrad

pricearticlcomputwrite

applmonitorwrite

mac

appl

articlwrite

pricecomput

writearticlmacappl

comput

ibmmacresearchmonitor

ibmvideocardresult

upgrad

applcomput

macupgrad

research

appl

monitormacupgrad

appl

windowibmapplcard

computquadra

monitorvideo

monitor

macmonitorapplcomput

board

macapplibmcard

mac

pricemacapplarticl

macpricecomput

write

comput

price

applwritearticl

comput

writeapplarticlmac

mac

comput

computhardwarpc

appl

cardboardmac

mac

diskpccomputdrive

carddriveboardpc

slot

runwritecardmb

controllid

dxbu

bu

cardboardvideomonitor

ram

carddxmbwrite

mac

mbwrite

diskinstall

writearticldrivemb

run

cardrunmbspe

ram

articlmemoriram

write

pc

drive

cablsetpc

cabl

drivediskcomput

disk

diskwritearticlinstall

drive

pcwritescsiset

bu

runramarticlmac

memorimachinrun

write

memori

videoisalc

card

slot

cardboard

mac

macarticlwritedrive

diskwritearticlpc

disk

installdrive

writearticl

memori

pc

writearticlmac

board

setiddiskcontroll

setidscsi

drive

scsi

scsi

mbdrivedx

set

driveidcontrolldisk

disk

drivecomputboardcard

slotcomputportpc

controll

diskjumper

drivecontroll

comput

port

drivecontrollcard

research

articlwrite

bank

person

articldiseastreatment

write

write

yearpittdoctoreffect

articlgeb

writearticl

doctor

articlwrite

year

doctor

medic

writearticlpeopl

peopl

yearmsg

personyear

food

doctor

writearticlpeopl

doctoreffectwrite

yearresult

writeeffectarticlresearch

doctor

effectyeartreatment

write

articl

articlyear

writedoctor

result

write

gordonpitt

gordon

effectpainarticl

pitt

articl

articlresearcheffectdrug

write

gordonbankgebpitt

peopl

doctormedicpain

treat

medicwritedoctorarticl

write

writetreatmentdiseas

medic

pain

treatcondition

medicdoctor

pain

pittgordon

writearticl

gordonbankpittgeb

bank

articlgordonbankgeb

write

gebwritearticl

pitt

write

write

year

write

bank

diseastreatmentstudi

geb

pain

writearticldoctortreatment

medic

doctorarticlpaintreatment

write

treatmentmedicwritearticl

articltreatmentdoctorpationt

peopl

diseaspatient

articlpeopl

treatment

patient

articlwritepeopl

articl

effectwrite

resultwrite

researchmonitoreffectupgrad

upgrad

yearmaccomputarticl

articlresearchmonitor

write

ibm

write

schoolcomputappl

peopl

writearticlpeopl

articl

monitorresultriskdrug

research

peoplapplfoodmsg

upgrad

articlapplwrite

peopl

articlapplcomputprice

comput

oralibm

risk

monitor

result

peoplmac

researchmonitor

write

articlwrite

portschool

writearticlcomputappl

appl

applcomputschoolmachin

articl

computschoolmachin

write

appl

msgfoodpeoplarticl

personfoodyear

write

chines

scidrug

researchwrite

oral

treatment

researchwritearticl

peopl

schooldoctorarticlwrite

doctoryearwaterschool

year

doctoryear

writearticl

person

person

writearticlpeopl

drug

computwateryearschool

schoolcomput

writearticl

write

writearticlschoolcomput

water

articlschoolcomputyear

year

resultdrugwriteeffect

articlresulteffect

research

articl

result

writearticleffect

research

writeeffectarticlyear

� �<> !.*�# � � � ��VW@.:YUa[1>�FIJ1UN9IHK9IM?@���UNJhAW[�OgUNJL:=@BAe< D\@BHN_hVYUNOI>1VW@�p^o�97b p^o�]NJL<EAeFPUa<EDZ>1[�97b*>[email protected];<ED/Ua:=<EHNM

MEHK>#@BDZ>�>#JLHN<?>�:YU7AW@BM�UaD > �.UCU jN@^JLM HKFWFI<ED/] q � _`Ua:YF�� [#b'[�� <?9;:�� Ff_ � VWHKJLA���HKJ1@ �?m � _`Ua:YF�� [#b'[�� :=HN_ � VWHKJhA��.HKJL@ � t

HNDWA UaD/@ AW<E[#>1<EDI_`> q � [1_^< � :Y@BA(� tG_^MEHN[L[#@B[CUNO AW<E[1_^8W[L[1<?UaDW[�OQJ1Ua: >1V/@ nKo �@��$[#]NJLUa8/FI[C_`UaMEM?@B_`>1<EUaD�� nKoNo

A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[ �.@^J1@4>1H �N@BDiOQJ1Ua: @BHN_hV _^M HN[1[^m/U jN@^J�H=AW< _`>1<?UaDWHKJ1b UNO.p�/Kol>#@^JL:=[��

�Nn

Page 94: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

therapiwritepaindoctor

humanprevent

effectprevent

pain

skindiseastreatment

skin

treatmentdoctorwriteresult

year

computyearpricewrite

computarticlmachin

machin

effect

price

effectmachindrug

comput

effectmachinyearwrite

result

write

yearcomputappl

mac

writearticlschool

year

writeyeardrugmachin

effect

articlschooleffectmachin

comput

diagnospersonmuscltreatment

paindiagnos

diseasliteratur

write

writearticlapplschool

modem

articlpowerbookduoappl

price

simmeffectmemorimachin

writememorisimmcomput

price

ibm

yearmemoriprevent

write

machineffectwrite

machin

pricemacappl

run

applduomac

mhz

write

writemachinarticl

price

mac

softwarcentri

applprice

prevent

powerbookwriteapplduo

resultskinresearch

macintoshmacintosh

pricecentri

applwrite

articl

articl

applwritemac

muscl

painwriteibmresult

writeyeareffectmachin

skin

peoplwrite

personliteratur

person

peopl

skinresultmuscl

human

write

schoolriskupgrad

skin

writearticlwater

articl

foodarticlpeoplewrite

waterriskpeoplsymptom

cancer

doctortreatmentmedicarticl

articltreatment

writepatient

write

writearticlirqupgrad

diet

conditionarticldiseaspatient

water

writearticl

evidmedic

articlwriteyeastdoctor

pitt

bankgebwritearticl

gordon

yeastblankmedic

pitt

sci

peopl

chinesarticlwrite

risk

foodpeoplmsg

msg

writepeopldoctorevid

articl

foodwritearticlchines

clinic

conditiondiagnosdiseas

patient

diseasconditiondiagnoswrite

treatment

modemportinstall

write

powerbook

writediet

writearticl

treatment

doctoreffect

bodihuman

effectdrugdoctorwrite

drug

medicdiseaspainpatient

doctor

medicwritebodi

treatment

articl

drugeffectdoctorpeopl

msgarticlyear

write

articl

peopl

doctormedicwrite

clinic

doctorwritemedicarticl

food

yearschoolarticlwrite

schoolapplportcomput

water

yearwater

writepeopl

school

peopl

writearticlpeopl

research

pccardsetbio

controllwritecard

board

run

boardpc

slotrun

boardpccardsoftwar

drive

writefloppidiskdrive

cablcomputscsiarticl

set

writefloppi

bioset

disk

controll

drivesetcontroll

softwar

mbhdarticldisk

hddriver

drivescsi

drive

iddiskdrivecontroll

install

diskscsiidarticl

scsi

videosoftwarcomputappl

monitorcomputvideo

monitor

window

run

macdrivemeg

research

macdriveriisimeg

disk

port

writedrivefloppi

disk

portsetcabl

set

portjumperirqwrite

set

jumperwritedrivefloppi

modem

megresearchupgradhardwar

macmodem

modem

portcabldrivecomput

mac

cablporthardwarcomput

bio

researchmegmac

board

softwarmonitorpcappl

upgrad

cablmegupgrad

drive

comput

hardwariisi

macdrive

comput

softwarboard

pcirq

boardsetsoftwarhardwar

hardwar

softwarpchardwarlciii

comput

pclciiicomput

board

scsi

lcdriverpricequadra

fpumachin

macappl

price

memorirammb

write

applmacdrivemb

run

writeupgradarticlcard

ibmupgradbu

monitor

video

card

lcmacdriver

appl

monitorpersonarticlwrite

price

upgrad

resultmhzwrite

mhz

ibmupgradarticl

result

articlliteraturupgradwrite

person

articlpersonwritepeople

write

writespesimmmb

simmwrite

rammemori

memori

ibmdxburun

machin

rammbdxbu

video

applmonitor

writearticl

cardmonitorvideowindow

card

lcruniisimachin

driver

articlvideowindow

mac

isa

card

eisacontrolldx

articl

bubiocard

bu

videosperunwindow

card

dxisarunspe

mac

spembbudx

diskramarticlinstall

ram

mhzcach

cardmhz

spe

run

dxburun

id

scsimbdrive

lc

drivedriverscsimb

install

diskscsiarticl

mb

install

macarticl

mbdrive

� �<> !.*�# � � � ��VW@ :YUa[#> FWJLUN9IHK9IM?@ �.UNJLAW[ OQUNJL:Y@BA <ED @BHN_LV UNO >1V/@ p^o 97b p^o ]NJL<EA FPUa<EDZ>1[

97b >1VW@ :e8WM?>1<ED/Ua:l<EHNM�MEHK>#@BDZ>->#JLHN<?> :YU'A/@BM�UaD > �.U U jN@^JLMEHKFWFI< D/] q � _`Ua:YF�� [#b'[�� <?9;:�� Ff_ � VWHKJLA���HKJ1@ �?m

� _`Ua:YF�� [1b7[�� :lHN_ � VWHKJLA���HKJ1@ � t�HNDWAiUaD/@4AW<E[#>1< DW_`>�q � [L_^< � :Y@BA(� t._^MEHN[L[#@B[0UNO�AW<E[1_^8W[L[1<?UaDW[�OgJLUa: >1V/@*nKo=�@��$[ �

]NJ1Ua8/F;[�_`UaMEM?@B_`>1<?UaD���nKoNolA/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[ �.@^J1@4>1H �N@BDiOQJ1Ua: @BHN_hV _^M HN[1[^m/U jN@^J�HYAW<E_`>1<EUaDWHKJ1blUNO0p�/Kol>#@^JL:=[��

�2�

Page 95: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

� �<> ! *�# � � � ��VW@)UN9I[#@^J1jN@BAiAIHK>1H � � <EDI[#>1HNDW_`@B[0OQJ1Ua: @BHN_hV _^MEHN[L[��

� �<> !.*�# � ��� !�Ua[#>#@^Jh<?UNJ :Y@BHNDI[=FWJ1U j7< A/@BA 9Zb >1V/@ ��@^JhD/Ua8WMEME<.>#JLHN<E>=HNM?]NUNJL<?>1VW: UaDcH AWHK>1H��k[1@^> �$VW< _LV

_`UaDW[1< [#>#@BACUNO�VWHNDWA���Jh<?>#>#@BDCAW<?]a<?>1[0HNDIAi<EDW[#FP@B_`>1<?UaD�UNO�J1@^OQ@^J1@BDW_`@4jN@B_`>#UNJL[�<EDC[#Ua:=@4UNO�>1VW@4]NJL<EAGFPUa<EDZ>1[��

� �<> !.*�# � � � o ��V/@ :lHKF�UNO)J1@^OQ@^J1@BDW_`@��k< :=HK]N@B[�qs< � @!�?m�>1V/@,J1@B[1VWHKFP@BA��&q������KtYjKHNME8/@B[Bm �$V/@^J1@ �&q tl<E[

_`Ua:YFPUaD/@BDZ> � �$<E[#@[1<?]a:YUa<EA Os8WDW_`>1<EUaD=<EDY>1VW< [&_^HN[#@HNDIA � p �Ep^oNoTt&OgUNJh:Y@BA=UaDl>1V/@0RIJL[1>�RIjN@VWHNDIA���JL<?> �

>#@BD,AW<?]a<?>1[_^MEHN[1[#@B[����$@B<E]aVT9PUNJ$]NJh<EAiFPUa<EDZ>1[$VWH jN@Y[1<E:=<EM HKJ0J1@^Og@^JL@BDW_`@��k<E:=HK]N@B[�����V/@e:YUNJ1FIVW< D/]Y9P@^> �.@^@BD

>1V/@4JL@^FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaDCUNO�>1V/@4AW<E]a<?>1[0<E:=HK]N@B[<E[0:YUa[#>$HKFIFIHKJ1@BDZ>��

�$-

Page 96: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

�� ��� ��� � �

� � � � ����� � ��� � � ���� �!� � ���!��� ��� � � � � � ��� �!� ������� �!� � ��� � ��� � ����� ��� ����� �

��VI<E[�_hVWHKFW>#@^J � FWJ1@B[1@BDT>1[0HeMEHK>#@BDZ>.jKHKJL<EHK9;M?@�:=U7A/@BM;OQUNJ.>1VW@�j'<E[18IHNME<E[1HK>1<?UaD=UNO�>1<E:Y@�� jKHKJ1b'<ED/]eAWHK>1H'mW<ED�$VW< _LV >1V/@\>#UNFPUN]NJLHKF;VTbd< [H OQ8IDW_`>1<?UaD,HNDWAdUa8W>1_`Ua:Y@ UNO�>1V/@e>#@B:YFPUNJLHNM�_`UaV/@^J1@BDW_`@Y<EDd>1V/@YAWHK>1H��)��VW<E[

<E[4HN_hVW<?@^jN@BA 9Zb�>1VW@=@� 7F;M?Ua<?>1HK>1<?UaDrUNO.>1VW@=UN9I[#@^J1jKHK>1<?UaDr>1VWHK>\:=HNDZb DWHK>18/JhHNM&[#Ua8/JL_`@B[*UNO0>1<E:Y@=jKHKJ1b'<ED/]

AWHK>1H � < DW_^ME8WAW< D/]*>#@� '> � 9IHN[#@BA _`UaDTjN@^JL[LHK>1<?UaDWHNM AWHK>1H � _`UaDT>1HN< DC>#@B:YFPUNJLHNMf[#@^]a:Y@BDZ>1[ �<?>1VGJ1@BMEHK>1<?jN@BMEb

V/Ua:YUN]N@BDW@^Ua8W[�_`UaDZ>#@BDZ>��&� Dl_`UaDW[#@BX78/@BDW_`@[L:YUZUN>1V _LVWHNDW]N@B[�HNDWAlJ1@BMEHK>1<?jN@BMEb\OQ@���AW< [1_`UaDT>1< DZ8W<E>1<?@B[�_^HNDl9P@

@� 'F @B_`>#@BAl<ED >1V/@�MEHK>#@BDZ>�J1@^FWJ1@B[1@BDT>1HK>1<?UaDl[#FIHN_`@!����V/@0FWJLUNF Ua[1@BAe:=@^>1V/U7AY< [�@BXZ8WHNM M?b\[18I<?>#@BAeOgUNJ�8I[#@ �$<?>1V

9PUN>1V=_`UaDZ>1<EDZ8WUa8W[�UNJ�AW< [1_`J1@^>#@�:e8WM?>1<?jKHKJL<EHK>#@�AWHK>1H*HNDWA=_^M?Ua[#@BA=OgUNJL: @B[#>1<E:=HK>1<?UaDI[&HKJ1@�HBjKHN<EMEHK9;M?@0OgUNJ�AWHK>1H

OQJ1Ua: >1VW@*@� 'F UaDW@BDT>1<EHNM�OQHN:l<EM?b!����VW< [$<E[<EDd_`UaDZ>#JLHN[#>�>#U�>1V/@\<?>#@^JhHK>1<?jN@\UNJ�HKFWFWJLU /<E:=HK>#@\� �k[#>#@^F �$VW< _LV

�.Ua8WMEA 9 @eJ1@BX78W<?J1@BA OQUNJ�HG:YUNJL@\]N@BD/@^JhHNM m AW<?J1@B_`>�@� '>#@BDW[1<?UaD,UNO&>1V/@YMEHK>#@BDZ>�>#JLHN<?>):YU'A/@BME[FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>#@BA <ED

>1V/@4FIJ1@^j7<EUa8W[�_LVWHKFW>#@^J mIOQUaMEM?U �<ED/] >1V/@4<EA/@BH UNO�>1V/@ � �)��� >1V/J1Ua8/]aVC>1< :Y@ � �

� AW<E[#>1< DW_`>1<?jN@ Og@BHK>18WJ1@YUNO�>1VW@YFWJ1UNFPUa[#@BA�:YU'A/@BM�<E[�>1VWHK>^m�[#Ua:Y@��$VWHK>4AI< � @^JL@BDT>1M?b OgJLUa: >1V/@ � �����

>1V/J1Ua8W]aVl>1<E:=@ �Z<EA/@BH'm7>1V/@�D/UaD��kME<EDW@BHKJ�J1@BMEHK>1<EUaDW[&9P@^> �.@^@BD�>1V/@�MEHK>#@BDT>�HNDWA UN9I[#@^J1jN@BA jKHKJL<EHK9IM?@B[.D/@^@BA�D/UN>

9P@)@� 7F;ME<E_^<?>1M?b <E:YFPUa[#@BAGHN[�>1V/@B[1@*HKJ1@4<E:YF;ME<E_^<?>�<EDCH=��<EAWA/@BDG�,HKJ��NU ji� U'A/@BM �

��@B:YUaDW[1>#JLHK>1<?UaDW[0UNO�>1V/@)FWJ1UNFPUa[#@BAGHNM?]NUNJh<?>1VW: UaDG9PUN>1VCHKJ1>1<SR;_^<EHNM M?b=_`J1@BHK>#@BAC@� /HN:YFIM?@B[0HNDIACHN_`>18WHNM

HKFWFIM <E_^HK>1<?UaDW[ �$<EMEM09P@ FWJ1U j'<EA/@BA�� ��D/@ UNO4<?>1[ < :YFPUNJ1>1HNDT>�HKFWFIME< _^HK>1<?UaDW[l< [l>1V/@ >#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVW<E_^HNMj'<E[18��

HNME<E[LHK>1<?UaD6UNO4A/b'DWHN:=<E_^HNM M?b @^jNUaMEj7<EDW] >#@� 7> � 9;HN[#@BA AWHK>1H�����VW<E[l[#@^@��7[ >#U HNAIA/J1@B[1[l>1V/@d>1HN[��'[ UNO)>#UNFI<E_

[#@^]a:Y@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaDfm A/@^>#@B_`>1<?UaD HNDWAG>#JLHN_��'<ED/]����� ��"#���� ��(�@+-�(�������*)>�/M& �"#��:P�/��W �<���(����)� ��4DB��)B �"#��� �R"#1/� ��(� "81�� ?!����)>���*)#D<�� ����*)81������ 1/�(�����< ���D MN�/�@�#A<?#�����41� ����*)>��) �"#�V���!�����=1/� �=����A<�%�*) � A< ��/IJ1� ��4D �H�(K, �L1� ���./�/������1� ����/)B��M5 �"#��� ���&.�&��$���� ���0���1$($(� 2��1� � � ��� ���� ���'�����0%#������� �*F

�2/

Page 97: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

� ��� �������������� ���!���

&HKJL< HNDT>1[YUNO>1V/@iMEHK>#@BDZ> >#JLHN<?>=HNDWA MEHK>#@BDZ>=_^MEHN[1[Y:YU'A/@BME[ VWH jN@C9P@^@BD6A/@^jN@BM?UNFP@BA <ED >1V/@GFWJ1@^j'<?Ua8W[

_LVIHKFW>#@^JCHN[�H >1V/@^UNJ1@^>1< _^HNMEM?b6FWJL< DW_^<?FIM?@BA FIJ1UN9IHK9I<EM <E[#>1<E_GHNM?>#@^JLDIHK>1<?jN@ >#U >1V/@,� �����W��� � �54�� � �.@B<ED/]

[18W<E>1HK9IM?@*OQUNJ4AW< �P@^J1@BDZ>@^jN@BDZ> �k:YU'A/@BM�J1@^FIJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaDW[�UNO�>#@� '> �SpNpNp � mf>1V/@B[1@=VWHBjN@Y9P@^@BD A/@B:YUaDW[1>#JLHK>#@BA

HN[0jKHNME8WHK9IME@>#U7UaME[�OQUNJ�HNDWHNM?b %B<ED/] HNDWAGj7< [18WHNME<E[L<ED/]*[#>1HK>1< _)A/U7_^8I:Y@BDT>0_`UaMEME@B_`>1<?UaDW[ �1�$- � ���U �.@^jN@^JBmW>1VW@B[#@

:YU'A/@BME[0HN[1[L8W:Y@)>1VWHK>�>1VW@^J1@*<E[0D/UY>#@B:=F UNJhHNMfUNJLA/@^JL< D/]YHN:YUaD/]a[#>�>1VW@*AWHK>1HdqsA/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>ht�<EDI[#>1HNDW_`@B[��

�7Ua:=@��$VWHK>.J1@B_`@BDT>1MEblV/U �.@^jN@^JBm/>1V/@^JL@�VWHN[.9P@^@BD�HND <EDI_`J1@BHN[1<ED/]e<EDZ>#@^J1@B[#>�<EDlHNDWHNMEb %B<EDW]\A/b'DWHN:=<E_^HNM M?b

@^jNUaM?j'<ED/] <EDWOgUNJL:lHK>1<?UaDfm�HN[lH�]NJ1@BHK> HN:=Ua8WDT>lUNO�< D/OgUNJh:=HK>1<?UaD <E[=_`UaDZ>1<ED78/Ua8W[1M?b @B:=<?>#>#@BAc9Zb :\8IM?>1<?FIM?@

<ED/OQUNJL:=HK>1<EUaDe[1Ua8/JL_`@B[^mT[L8W_LV=HN[&j HKJL<EUa8W[�D/@��$[��<?J1@B[�HNDWAYD/@��$[&9WJ1UaHNAW_^HN[#>�FIJ1UN]NJLHN:=[�����VI<E[�<ED/OQUNJL:=HK>1<?UaD

:=H b 9P@ FWJh<E:=HKJL<EMEb _LVIHKJLHN_`>#@^JL< %^@BA 97brH,[#>#J1@BHN: UNO�>#@� '>CqQUNJ FPUa[1[1<E9IM?b,UN>1V/@^JY:\8WME>1<E:Y@BAW<EHi@BM?@B:Y@BDZ>1[ht

HNDWA�>1VW@l>1HN[��'[*HKJ1@ D/U � >#U <EA/@BDZ>1<?OQb,MEU7_^HK>1<?UaDI[ �$V/@^J1@l>1V/@=>#UNFI<E_l_LVWHND/]N@B[GqQ>#UNFI<E_l[#@^]a:Y@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaD;thm�>#U

<EA/@BDZ>1<?OQb >1V/@C[#>1HKJ1>1< D/] F Ua< DT>eUNO�H D/@�� [1>#UNJ1b qQ>#UNF;<E_GA/@^>#@B_`>1<?UaD;teHNDWA >#U�9P@CHK9IM?@�>#U�J1@B_`UN]aDW< %^@dHNDWA

>#JLHN_��,>1VW@ _`UaDZ>1<ED78WHK>1<?UaD�UNO.HGFWJ1@^j'<?Ua8W[1MEbd[#@^@BD >#UNFI<E_iqQ>#UNF;<E_e>#JLHN_��'<ED/]Zt �Sp � � &HKJL<EUa8W[)[18/FP@^J1j'<E[#@BA,HNDWA

8WDW[L8/FP@^J1j7< [#@BA HNME]NUNJL<?>1VW:=[0VIHBjN@*9P@^@BDGFWJLUNF Ua[1@BAGOgUNJ$[1Ua:Y@4UNO�>1V/@B[#@4>1HN[��7[ �SpBnWm p�0'p � �

��D >1VW<E[C_hVWHKFW>#@^JBm)H6FWJLUN9IHK9I<EME< [#>1<E_iMEHK>#@BDZ>ijKHKJL<EHK9IME@,:YU'A/@BM)<E[GFIJ1UNFPUa[#@BAfm �VW<E_LV < [C[18W<?>1HK9IME@ OQUNJ

j'<E[18WHNME< [1<ED/]lHCAWb7DWHN:l<E_^HNMEM?bi@^jNUaMEj7<EDW] � �'1 ��� �$�%�)AWHK>1HC[#>#J1@BHN: � �$VWHK>4<E[^mf>1V/@=HN[L[18W:YFW>1<EUaD,< [):=HNA/@Y<ED

>1V/@*:=U7A/@BMP>1VIHK>$_`UaDW[#@B_^8/>1<EjN@*AWHK>1Hl[LHN:YFIM?@B[0<EDG>1< :Y@4VWHBjN@e[1<E:=< MEHKJ08WDWA/@^JLMEb7<EDW] � :Y@BHNDW< D/] �WUNJ � _^HN8W[1@B[��

:e8W_LVi:=UNJ1@4OQJ1@BXZ8W@BDT>1M?b >1VWHNDi>1VW@^b�VWH jN@\HK9WJh8/FW>0_LVWHNDW]N@B[��

��M?>1V/Ua8/]aV >1V/@=[1_`UNFP@=UNO�j7< [18WHNM�<EDW[#FP@B_`>1<?UaD�< [)HNDWHNM?UN]NUa8W[*>#Ud>1VWHK>4FIJ1@^j7<EUa8W[1M?bd_`UaDI[1<EA/@^J1@BA OQUNJ4j'< �

[18WHNM <E[1<ED/]=H [#>1HK>1<E_eAWHK>1H�_`UaMEM?@B_`>1<?UaDfmPH�AW< �P@^J1@BDT>^m :\8I_LV [1<E:YF;ME<SRI@BAG:YU'A/@BM.�$<?>1Vd[L<?]aDW<SR;_^HNDZ>�J1@BAI8W_`>1<?UaD

<EDc>1V/@,D78W:\9P@^JlUNO49PUN>1Vc:=U7A/@BM�HNDWA�OgJL@^@dFIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^JL[G_^HND�9P@ UN9W>1HN<ED/@BA�U jN@^JCH AW<?J1@B_`> @� 7>#@BDW[L<?UaD

UNO0>1V/@�[#>1HK>1<E_=>#UNFPUN]NJLHKF;VW<E_=:YU'A/@BME[49Zb <EDI_^ME8WAW<EDW] >1V/@ >#@B:YFPUNJLHNM�:=U7A/@BM <ED/]i<ED H [1<E:=< MEHKJ4:=HNDWD/@^J\>#U

�$VWHK>�VWHN[�9P@^@BDdFWJLUNF Ua[1@BAd<EDd>1V/@ � �)��� ��V/JLUa8/]aVd��< :Y@ � � nNn�� ����VW< [�<E[�HN_LVW<?@^jN@BA,97bi@� 'FIM?Ua<?>1<EDW]=>1V/@

M?U'_^HNMEM?bdVWUa:YUN]N@BD/@^Ua8W[\DWHK>18/J1@ UNO.>1V/@=AWHK>1H'm�HN[ �$<EMEM�9P@ AW@^>1HN<EM?@BA <ED >1V/@YOQUaMEM?U �$<ED/]G[#@B_`>1<?UaDW[ � � U'A/@BME[

9IHN[#@BA=UaDl[#Ua:Y@��VWHK>�[1<E:l<EMEHKJ�<EA/@BHN[ ��@^J1@$FWJ1UNFPUa[#@BAY<EDY>1VW@$A/Ua:=HN<ED UNOf[#FP@^@B_hVlHNDWA=:=Ua8/>1V��k:YU jN@B:Y@BDT>1[

J1@B_`UN]aDW<E>1<?UaD < D � �Nn'mPp��20�� "/V/U ��@^jN@^J0>1V/@B[1@�VIHBjN@)D/UN>.9 @^@BD�_`UaDW[1< A/@^J1@BAl< Dl>1V/@�_`UaDZ>#@� 7>�UNO j'<E[18WHNM <E[1HK>1<?UaD��

��DC>1V/@4_^HN[#@*UaDC>#@� 7> � 9;HN[#@BAdA/b'DWHN:=< _^HNMf<ED/OQUNJL:=HK>1<?UaDfm'>1V/@)FIJ1UNFPUa[#@BAC:Y@^>1V/U'AC_^HNDdHNME[1UY9 @)[#@^@BD HN[

Hl_`Ua:=FIM?@B:Y@BDZ>1HKJ1bi>#U7UaM�>#U�>#UNFI<E_\A/@^>#@B_`>1<?UaD,HNDWA >#JLHN_��'<ED/]�HKFWFIME<E_^HK>1<EUaDW[^mIHN[�<?>$HNAIA/J1@B[1[#@B[>1V/@B[#@\>1HN[��'[

97b <EDZ>#J1U'AW8W_^<ED/]eHe>#UNF UN]NJhHKFIVTb�<ED�>1V/@)MEHK>#@BDZ>�[#FIHN_`@�UNO�>#UNFI< _^[^m��$VW<E_hVlOQUNJ0j'<E[18WHNME< [1HK>1<?UaD=F;8/J1FPUa[#@B[��$<EMEM

�20

Page 98: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

9P@=Hdn �k� 8WDI<?OgUNJh: ]NJL<EA�[1<E:l<EMEHKJ)<ED [#F;<?JL<?>�>#U �Sp.- �Wm�nKo�� � � V/@BD/@^jN@^J\>1V/@=>#UNFI< _=_LVWHNDW]N@B[^m.�.@l_^HND [#@^@

V/U � >1V/@=>#JhH ��@B_`>#UNJ1b :=U jN@B[ H ��HBb >#U HND/UN>1V/@^J*JL@^]a<?UaD�� !�J1@^j'<?Ua8W[1M?b UN9I[#@^J1jN@BA >#UNFI<E_^[*HKJ1@lJ1@B_`UN]aDI< %^@BA

qQ>#JLHN_��N@BA;t�[1<E:=FIM?b 9Zb >1V/@�@� '< [#>#@BDW_`@�UNO�>1V/@�>#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVI<E_$JL@BMEHK>1<?UaDW[.9P@^> �.@^@BDC>1V/@)MEHK>#@BDZ>�>#UNFI<E_^[^m��$VW< _LV

_^HN8W[#@*>1V/@4MEHK>#@BDZ>$>#JLH �#@B_`>#UNJ1bG>#Ul:YU jN@*>#U=>1V/@*J1@^]a<?UaDCJ1@B[1F UaDI[1<?9IM?@OgUNJ�HY_`@^J1>1HN<EDd>#UNFI<E_ �

��VW@$J1@B:=HN< DWA/@^J&UNOf>1VW< [�_LVIHKFW>#@^J0<E[&UNJ1]aHNDI< %^@BA HN[�OQUaMEM?U �[�/�>1VW@$OQUaMEM?U �<ED/]4> ��U [18/9I[1@B_`>1<?UaDW[&FIJ1U j'<EA/@

>1V/@ D/@B_`@B[1[1HKJLbi9IHN_��7]NJ1Ua8WDIAdUaD ��<EAWA/@BD � HKJ��NU j � U7AW@BME<ED/]lHNDIAdJ1@^j'<?@�� >1V/@ � ����� ��VWJ1Ua8/]aV,��<E:Y@ �

:YU'A/@BM � nNn�� �$VI<E_LV�<E[=@B[1[1@BDT>1<EHNM M?b6H ��� � VWHBj'<ED/] H ����� ME< �N@BME<EVWUZU'A6HN[�@B:=<E[1[1<EUaD6FWJ1UN9IHK9;<EME<?>1<?@B[ �

�7@B_`>1<?UaD�/ � n*FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>1[�>1VW@$FWJ1UNFPUa[#@BA :YU'A/@BMWHNDWA�:YUN>1<?jKHK>#@B[�<E>�OQJ1Ua: >1V/@FP@^JL[#FP@B_`>1<?jN@$UNO < DW_`UNJ1FPUNJLHK>1<ED/]

>1V/@ _`UaV/@^J1@BDW_`@YFIJL<?UNJ< DT>#UG>1V/@ � ����� ��V/J1Ua8/]aV,��<E:=@ �?mf�7@B_`>1<EUaD*/ ����FIJ1U j'<EA/@B[�H AI<E[1_^8W[1[L<?UaDfmP�'@B_`>1<?UaD

/ �1-YFWJ1@B[1@BDT>1[.jKHKJL<?Ua8W[�[1<E:e8WMEHK>1<EUaD=J1@B[18IM?>1[ �<?>1VGHND @B:=FIVWHN[1<E[�UNO�>#@� '> � 9IHN[#@BACAIHK>1He[1>#J1@BHN:=[0HNDWA R;DWHNM M?b

[#Ua:Y@\_`UaDW_^ME8WAW< D/]\JL@B:=HKJ��'[�HKJ1@4FWJLU j'<EA/@BAC<EDG>1V/@\MEHN[#>�[#@B_`>1<?UaD��

��� �� � ��" "�� � � � ��� � � � ��"��5�� ��� � � !

��<EAWA/@BD �,HKJ��NU j � U'A/@BME[Cqs��,��t �Sp��'pNm�p��Nn��$HKJL@iMEHK>#@BDT>lj HKJL< HK9IM?@G:YU7AW@BME[ OgUNJ=:=U7A/@BM ME<ED/] >1<E:Y@

[#>#JL8I_`>18/J1@Nm;_^MEUa[#@BM?bGJ1@BMEHK>#@BAd>#U�34HNM :=HND !�<EM?>#@^JL[eqs3 !&t �Sp.-aoIm�p��'p � ����U :=H �N@\>1V/@\DW@B_`@B[1[1HKJ1bi_`Ua:YF;8/>1H��

>1<?UaDW[�>#JLHN_`>1HK9IME@Nm7>1VW@�,HKJ��NU j�FWJ1UNFP@^J1> b < [�HN[1[L8W:Y@BA U jN@^J�>1V/@�MEHK>#@BDT>.jKHKJL<EHK9IM?@B[�<ED=9PUN>1V >1V/@B[#@�:YU'A/@BME[^m

< � @!�i>1VW@ jKHNME8/@ UNO0>1V/@�M HK>#@BDT>ej HKJh<EHK9IM?@lHK> Hi>1< :Y@lFPUa<EDZ> c< [\_`UaDW[L<EA/@^J1@BAr>#U 9P@ < DWA/@^FP@BDWA/@BDZ>)UNO�HNMEM

FWJ1@^j'<?Ua8W[�MEHK>#@BDZ>)jKHNME8/@B[)HNDWA UN9I[1@^J1j HK>1<EUaDW[�]a<?jN@BD >1V/@=MEHK>#@BDZ>)jKHNME8/@YHK>)>1<E:Y@ % p �Y��V/@Y_`UaDW_`@^FI>18WHNMAW< �P@^J1@BDW_`@Y9P@^> ��@^@BDr>1V/@l��� � HNDWA�>1VW@l3 ! <E[)>1VW@YOQHN_`>\>1VWHK>*<ED >1V/@ 3 ! >1V/@lVW< AWA/@BD [#>1HK>#@ < [)_`UaD��

>1<ED78/Ua8W[^m��V/@^J1@BHN[�<EDCHl��,� <?>�<E[0AW<E[L_`J1@^>#@!����U=J1@BMEHK>#@4>1VW@B: >#U=]N@BD/@^JLHK>1<EjN@\:YU'A/@BME[�OQUNJ$[#>1HK>1<E_*AWHK>1H'm

>1V/@)3 ! _^HNDG9P@>1V/Ua8W]aVT>�UNO�HN[0HND"!'�-U jN@^J�>1<E:=@ �V/@^J1@BHN[.>1V/@)��,� <E[�He:l< 7>18WJ1@:YU'A/@BM U jN@^J$>1<E:Y@!�

��V/@eFPUa[1[1<?9;M?@4jKHNME8/@B[>1V/@Y��,� VW< AWA/@BDijKHKJL<EHK9;M?@\_^HND >1H �N@=HKJ1@e>#@^JL:Y@BAN���B�#� ��� �4� ]NJ1@BHK>4HNA/jKHNDZ>1HK]N@

UNO�<E>1[�AI<E[1_`J1@^>#@YDWHK>18/JL@ < [>1VIHK>�>1VW@ ���,� _^HND�:YU'A/@BM�VW<?]aVIM?biD/UaDWME< D/@BHKJ>1< :Y@\@^jNUaM 8/>1<?UaD�HNDWA VW<?]aVIM?b

D/UaDWM <ED/@BHKJ�J1@BMEHK>1<?UaDW[�9P@^> �.@^@BD�UN9I[1@^J1j HK9;M?@YHNDWA VW<EAWA/@BD jKHKJL<EHK9IM?@B[ �*3 !�[)_^HND UaDWM?b,:YU7AW@BM�M <ED/@BHKJ�@^jNU �

ME8/>1<EUaD HNDWAr:=@BHN[18/J1@B:Y@BDZ>1[��i�U �.@^jN@^JBm�9P@B_^HN8W[#@�Hd��� � _^HND UaDWM?b 9P@l<ED�UaDW@ [#>1HK>#@GHK>\Hd>1<E:Y@Nm�<?>1[

J1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>1HK>1<EUaDWHNM _^HKFIHN_^<?> bi<E[0ME<E:l<?>#@BAG_`Ua:YFIHKJ1@BAd>#U=>1V/@43 !��

��� �,[&HNDWA 3 !�[�VWH jN@09P@^@BDe[L8W_^_`@B[1[#Os8WMEM?b4HKFIFIME<?@BA*>#U4H �<EA/@.j HKJL<E@^>kb*UNO A/b'DWHN:=<E_^HNM7[#b'[#>#@B:=[ "7:YUa[#>

<E:YFPUNJ1>1HNDZ>1M?b\>1V/@��� � <E[�8W[#@BA=<EDl[#FP@^@B_LV=JL@B_`UN]aDW<?>1<?UaD �Sp��Nn�� �&��V/@�VW< AWA/@BDY[#>1HK>#@B[.HKJ1@$<EAW@BDT>1<SR;@BA)�$<?>1V

FIV/UaDW@B:Y@B[HNDIA,HGAW< � @^J1@BDZ>���,� <E[>#JLHN<ED/@BA OQUNJ�@^jN@^JLb �.UNJLA��)�$OQ>#@^J�>#JLHN<EDW< D/]/m;>1VW@e��� � �$<?>1V >1V/@

VW<?]aVW@B[#>�ME< �N@BME< V/UZU'A�<EA/@BDZ>1<SRI@B[0H ]a<?jN@BD ��UNJLA qs[#@^@4@!� ]�� �Sp��'p ��OgUNJHNDC@� '_`@BM M?@BDT>$>18/>#UNJL<EHNMgt �

�54

Page 99: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

��VW@4AWHK>1H=ME< �N@BM <EV/U7U7A UNO�HY>1<E:Y@4[#@^Jh<?@B[0_`UaDW[1<EAW@^J1@BAC_^HNDi9P@ ��JL<E>#>#@BDCHN[�OQUaMEM?U �[��

� ��q� ��� �t ��q� � t��� � � ��q� � � ��� � � � t q / �Ep t

�$V/@^JL@$>1V/@�D/UN>1HK>1<?UaD ��� � � � � � � �� � � ��< [�@B:YF;M?U bN@BA��&�UN>#@�>1VWHK>.>1V/@^J1@�<E[�DWU\�,HKJ��NU j�FWJ1UNFP@^J1> bUaD >1V/@e>#@B:YFPUNJLHNM�[#>#JL8W_`>18WJ1@ UNO�>1V/@ AWHK>1H'm�< � @!����q��� � ��� � � � t�� ��q� � � �� � � t �*��V/@ MEHK>#@BDZ>�jKHKJL<EHK9;M?@\UNO>1V/@4:YU'A/@BMP<EDG>18/JhD�< [0HN[1[18W:Y@BAG>#U VWHBjN@)>1V/@4�,HKJ��NU jCFWJ1UNFP@^J1>kb!�&��@BD/UN>1< D/]Y>1V/@4VW<EAIA/@BDljKHKJL<EHK9;M?@�9Zb��

HNDWAC<?>1[�FPUa[1[L<?9IM?@�[#>1HK>#@B[�97b�� �V/@^J1@ � � p / � m/>1V/@4_`Ua:YF;M?@^>#@4AWHK>1H=ME< �N@BME<EV/U7U7AlUNO�HY���,� >1H �N@B[$>1V/@OQUaMEM?U �<ED/] OgUNJh:��

� ��q$� � t ��� � � ��q$� � � � � � � t��� �� ��q� � � � � t q / � nat

�@^J1@ ��q$� � t�<E[�>1V/@�MEHK>#@BDZ>V� ���M� �m� �s�E���E�����L��� 4 HK>�>1V/@.RIJL[1>�>1< :Y@0[#>#@^F m ��q$� � � � � � � t�HKJ1@0>1V/@���B�;� �� �s�������<�<�<���� �+�E���c�����3�<�<� ���UNOP[#>1HK>#@ � � � � >#U*[#>1HK>#@ � �eHNDWA���q��� � � �/t�HKJ1@$>1V/@ ���C�5�����<���v� �+�E���E�����3�<�<� ��� �.��V/@�>#JLHNDW[L<?>1<?UaDFWJ1UN9;HK9I<EME<?> biA/U7@B[)D/UN>4A/@^FP@BDWA,UaD >1V/@YUN9I[#@^JLj HK>1<?UaDI[)HNDWA�<E[�:YU'A/@BM?@BA,9Zb HC_`UaDW[#>1HNDZ>4:=HK>#JL< qs< � @!�YH

V/Ua:YUN]N@BDW@^Ua8W[$�,HKJ��NU jCFIJ1U7_`@B[L[�<E[0HN[1[18I:Y@BA;t �

��VW@�J1@BMEHK>1<?jN@ME< �N@BME<EVWUZU'ACqQ@� 7FP@B_`>1HK>1<?UaD UNOP>1V/@$_`Ua:YFIME@^>#@$M?UN]\M < �N@BME<EV/U7U'A;t AW@B_`Ua8/FIM?@B[&< DY>1V/J1@^@�>#@^Jh:=[

HN[�OQUaMEM?U �$[

��� �� � �� �

��� �� ��q$� ��� � � ��� �t7M?UN]

��q$� � t

��� � � ��q$� � � � � � � t

��� �� ��q��� � � �Wt

��� �� � � � M?UN] ��q$� � �Wt

���� � �

��� ��

�� � �� ��q$� � � ��� � � � � � ��� �t7MEUN] ��q$� � � � � � � � � t

���� ��

��� �� � � � M?UN] ��q� � � � � �Wt q / ���at

�$V/@^JL@�>1V/@�FWJLUN9IHK9I<EME<E>1<?@B[;HNDIHNM?UN]NUa8W[ >#U>1V/@�[#U_^HNMEM?@BA � J1@B[1F UaDI[1<?9I<EM <?>1<?@B[�� HKJ1@�D/U � � � � ��q$� � � � ��� ��t ���VW@�FIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^J�@B[#>1< :=HK>1<?UaDl< D=��,�,[.< [�9IHN[#@BA UaD=>1V/@���� HNM?]NUNJh<?>1VW: HNDIAl<E[�HNME[#U��'D/U �$DlHN[�>1V/@

f�� ��C2�� �$� � 1a�#� bc� ���<��1E� �Sp��'p �qsV/U ��@^jN@^JeVW<E[#>#UNJh<E_^HNMEM?bNmf>1V/@=��HN8W: � ��@BME_LV HNM?]NUNJL<?>1VW: HKFIF @BHKJL@BA�M?UaD/]

9P@^OgUNJL@���@B:YF;[#>#@^J � [�FIHKFP@^J �1�2���fUaDC����t �W��V/@)� �k[1>#@^F m/< � @!�&>1V/@)<ED/OQ@^J1@BDW_`@�<EDG��� �,[0>1H �N@B[�HNA/jKHNDZ>1HK]N@

UNO�>1VW@��,HKJ��NU jGHN[1[18I:YFW>1<?UaD �$VW<E_hVG:=H �N@B[�FPUa[1[1<?9IME@$HeJ1@B_^8/JL[1<EjN@>#J1@BHK>1:=@BDT>�<EDI[#>#@BHNAlUNO�@^j HNM 8WHK>1<ED/] HNMEM

>1V/@3� � FPUa[1[L<?9IM?@&VW< AWA/@BD4[#@BX78/@BDW_`@B[�q6� 9P@B<EDW]0>1V/@.D78W:\9P@^J�UNOWVW<EAIA/@BD4[#>1HK>#@B[�HNDWA � >1V/@.M?@BD/]N>1V\UNOW>1V/@[#@BX78/@BDW_`@ t�HNDWAY< [�>#@^JL:Y@BA >1V/@k/$� ��iw� �s�#2+��� � u'iw� �s�?��� bE� ���<��1E� �Sp��'p � ���$V/@0XZ8WHNDZ>1<?>1<?@B[�>#U)9P@0A/@^>#@^JL:l<ED/@BA

<ED,>1V/@Y� �k[1>#@^FrHKJ1@ � � � HNDWA ��q$� � � ��� � � � � � ��� �t � �[�>1VW@e@B[1>1<E:=HK>1<?UaD UNO.>1V/@Y[#@B_`UaDWA X78WHNDZ>1<?>kb�2�

Page 100: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

�$<EM M�D/UN>Y9P@CD/@^@BA/@BA6< D >1V/@C:Y@^>1V/U'A FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>#@BA <ED �7@B_`>1<?UaD%/ �Ep � n�HNDWA >1V/@CJ1@B_^8WJL[1<?jN@GFWJ1U'_`@BAW8/JL@�UNO

@B[#>1<E:lHK>1<ED/] � � � �$<EMEMP9P@eA/@^>1HN<EM?@BAC>1VW@^J1@*OQUNJ�_`Ua:=FIM?@^>#@BD/@B[1[BmI>1V/@B[#@eA/@^>1HN<EME[ �$<EMEMP9P@4Ua:l<?>#>#@BA VW@^J1@!�0��V/@

<EDZ>#@^J1@B[#>#@BACJL@BHNA/@^J<E[�JL@^Og@^J1JL@BAC>#U �Sp��'pNm�pNpBn�� �

��Di>1V/@ � �k[#>#@^F >1V/@*>#JLHNDI[1<?>1<?UaDCFIJ1UN9IHK9I<EM <?>1<?@B[0HNDWA >1V/@*F;HKJLHN:Y@^>#@^JL[UNO&>1V/@\@B:=<E[1[1<EUaDCFWJ1UN9IHK9;<EME<?>1<?@B[

HKJ1@\@B[#>1<E:=HK>#@BA,97bCUNFW>1<E:=< %B< D/]Y>1V/@*JL@BMEHK>1<?jN@\M < �N@BME<EV/U7U'A���!WUNJ�>1VW@\_^HN[#@eUNO�>1V/@e@B:=<E[1[1<EUaDCFWJ1UN9IHK9;<EME<?>1<?@B[Bm

>1V/@*_`UaDI[#>#JLHN<EDZ>0UNO � �� �� ��q$� � � � � � � � � t p4:e8W[#>09P@)>1H �N@BDd<EDZ>#U=HN_^_`Ua8WDZ>HNDWAi>1V/@*8/FfAWHK>#@)<E[

��q$� � � � � � � � � t � �� �� ��q$� � � ��� � � � � � ��� ��t� �

� �� ��q$� � �� � � ��� �t q / �1-Zt

��VW@@B:=< [1[1<?UaD FWJ1UN9IHK9;<EME<?> bCqsAW@BDW[1<?> b/t�_^HNDG>1H �N@4HNDZblOQUNJL: UNO�He]N@BD/@^JLHK>1<?jN@4M HK>#@BDT>�jKHKJL<EHK9IM?@�:YU'A/@BM m

[18W_hVGHN[�>1V/Ua[#@�J1@^j'<?@���@BAG<EDC"�VWHKFI>#@^J0neHNDWAGH _^M?Ua[#@BA�OQUNJL: [#UaME8/>1<EUaD <E[.]a8WHKJhHNDT>#@^@BAC<ED�>1V/@�@B[#>1<E:lHK>1<?UaD

FWJ1U'_`@BAW8/JL@\8/FPUaDi>1VW@e@� /<E[#>#@BDI_`@\UNO�HG_^M?Ua[1@BA OQUNJL: [#UaME8/>1<EUaDdOQUNJ�>1V/@\]N@BDW@^JLHK>1<?jN@Y:YU'A/@BM�@B:=FIM?U bN@BA,OQUNJ

>1V/@ @B:=<E[L[1<?UaD�FWJ1UN9IHK9I< ME<?>kb!� �$V/@ OQUNJL: UNO\>1V/@�[#UaME8/>1<?UaD <E[G[1< :=<EMEHKJ >#U6>1VWHK>CUNO*>1V/@�_`UNJ1JL@B[#FPUaDWAW<ED/]

[#>1HK>1<E_ ]N@BDW@^JLHK>1<?jN@l:YU'A/@BM m HNM M�>1VIHK>4AW< �P@^JL[)<E[�>1V/@=:Y@BHNDW< D/]GUNO�>1V/@YJL@B[#FPUaDW[1<?9I< ME<?>1<?@B[ � � � �e� Ua[#>4UNOQ>#@BDH��HN8W[L[1<EHND UNJ4:=< '>18/J1@ UNO ��HN8W[1[1< HNDW[)<E[�@B:YFIM?U bN@BA�OQUNJ4:YU7AW@BMEME<ED/] >1V/@Y@B:=<E[L[1<?UaD,FWJ1UN9IHK9;<EME<?> b �Sp��Nn�� m

V/U ��@^jN@^J�UN>1V/@^J�_hV/Ua<E_`@B[�HKJ1@�HNME[#U�F Ua[L[1<?9IM?@Vq)OQUNJ�@� /HN:YFIM?@NmNHNDe�1"��6:YU'A/@BMTVWHN[�9P@^@BD*_`UaDI[1<EA/@^J1@BAe<ED �SpBn2���

HNDWA�A/@B:YUaDW[1>#JLHK>#@BA�UaD������ [1<?]aDIHNME[�����V/@�_LV/Ua<E_`@�U jN@^J0>1V/@�OgUNJL: UNO >1V/@�@B:=<E[L[1<?UaD FWJ1UN9IHK9I< ME<?>kb :YU'A/@BM

[1V/Ua8IMEAr9P@�]NU jN@^JLDW@BA69Zb H FWJL<?UNJ �7DWU �$M?@BAW]N@ UNO �$VW<E_hV :=U7A/@BM.<E[ HK9IM?@G>#U FWJ1U j7< A/@�H :YUNJL@�UNFI>1<E:=HNM

A/@B[1_`Jh<?FW>1<?UaD�UNO�>1V/@*A/@BDI[1<?>kb�:YU'A/@BMPOgUNJ$>1V/@*AWHK>1H=8IDWA/@^J�_`UaDW[1< A/@^JLHK>1<?UaD��

��� � � � � � ��� � ��� � � ��� � � � � ��� � � � ��� � � ��"��5�� � ��� � ��� � � ��� �

��Dr@� '>#@BDW[1<EUaDr>#U >1V/@"�)��� :YU'A/@BM �$VI<E_LV HNMEM?U �[*8W[*>#U,A/@BHNM��$<?>1VrUN9I[#@^J1jKHK>1<?UaDW[\<ED �VW<E_LVr>1V/@

[1HN:YF;M?@B[&_`Ua:Y@�OQJ1Ua: H4>1<E:Y@��k[#@^JL<E@B[�UNJ�[#@BX78/@BDW_`@$UNO AWHK>1H\VWHN[�9P@^@BDYFWJLUNF Ua[1@BAY<ED � nNn�� �&��V/@09;HN[1<E_ �����

ME< �N@BM <EV/U7U7Ae<E[�J1@^>1HN< D/@BA=HN[&>1VW@�@B:=<E[1[L<?UaDeFWJ1UN9IHK9I< ME<?>kb*UNOPH)RIJL[#>�UNJLAW@^J��< AWA/@BDY�,HKJ��NU j=� U7AW@BM�qs��,��t �

��DrHd:=UNJ1@=]N@BD/@^JLHNM�>#J1@BHK>1:Y@BDZ> �$VW<E_hV ��Ua8IMEA HNME[#U <EDW_^ME8WAW@Y>1V/@lHKFWFIM <E_^HK9I<EME<E>kbi>#U AW<E[1_`JL@^>#@lAWHK>1H'm�UaD/@

_^HNDd_`UaDI[1<EA/@^J�HNDC@B:l<E[1[1<?UaDGFIJ1UN9IHK9I<EM <?>kblHN[$H=:Y@B:\9 @^J$UNO�>1V/@*@� 7FPUaD/@BDZ>1<EHNMPOsHN:=<EM?b

� �.q��� � � � � � �it @� 7F � ����q����Nt �� % �=q�����q����Kt#t�� q / ��/at

�$V/@^JL@ � ��HKJ1@�>1VW@�AW<E[1_`J1@^>#@0]NJh<EAeF Ua< DT>1[�@B:YF;M?U bN@BA=< D >1V/@'����� �a��D UN>1V/@^J �.UNJLAW[^ma>1VW@$AW<E[1_`JL@^>#@�VI<EAWA/@BD

[#>1HK>#@B[ UNO0>1VW< [*:YU'A/@BM.HKJ1@ >1VW@�� AW< [1_`J1@^>#@l]NJh<EA FPUa<EDZ>1[^m�MEHK9P@BM?@BA�97br<EDWAW@� ��r_`UNJ1J1@B[#FPUaDWAI<ED/]i>#U,>1V/@MEHK>#@BDZ>�FPUa<EDZ> ��� ���$V/@$>#JLHNDI[1<?>1<?UaDYFIJ1UN9IHK9I<EM <?>1<?@B[�9P@^> �.@^@BD >1VW@B[#@Nm ��q$� � � � � � � thm'VWHBjN@�>#Ue9 @$@B[#>1<E:=HK>#@BA�<ED

� �

Page 101: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

HNAWAW<E>1<?UaDe>#U)@B[#>1<E:=HK>1<EDW]�>1VW@'����� FIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^JL[ � HNDWA >1VW@'��HN8W[1[1< HND j HKJL< HNDW_`@B[�<ED >1V/@0_^HN[#@ �V/@BD >1V/@

@B:=<E[L[1<?UaDCA/@BDW[L<?>kbG<E[0@� 'FWJ1@B[1[1@BAi<EDC>#@^JL:l[�UNO ��HN8W[1[L<EHNDW[����$VZ8W[�>1VW<E[0:YU'A/@BM mW<EDdHNAWAW<?>1<?UaDG>#U @BD/OQUNJL_^<ED/]

H�>#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVW<E_^HNM�J1@^FIJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaD <ED HND,< A/@BDT>1< _^HNM�:lHNDWD/@^J)HN[�OgUNJ4< � < � A��)AWHK>1H'm HK>#>#@B:YFW>1[)>#UG@B[#>1< :=HK>#@

[1<E:e8WM?>1HNDW@^Ua8W[1M?b >1V/@*A/b'DWHN:=<E_^[�UNO�>1VW@4>#JLH �#@B_`>#UNJ1bd<EDC>1VW@*MEHK>#@BDZ>[#FIHN_`@!�.� >$<E[�:Y@BDZ>1<?UaD/@BA <ED � nNn���>1VWHK>

<ED :=HNDTbCJL@BHNM�[1<E>18WHK>1<?UaDW[UaD/@\_^HND,@� 'FP@B_`>�[1:=UZUN>1V,_LVWHNDW]N@B[�< Di>1V/@ MEHK>#@BDZ>�[#F;HN_`@eHNDWAdJ1@BMEHK>1<?jN@BMEbCJLHKJ1@

�18W:YFI[l9 @^> ��@^@BD AW< � @^J1@BDZ>�J1@^]a<E:Y@B[�� ��U <EDW_`UNJLF UNJhHK>#@d>1VW<E[�<ED/OQUNJL:=HK>1<EUaDcHNDWA�FWJL<E:lHKJL<EM?b :YUN>1<?jKHK>#@BA

97b >1VW@ AW<���_^8WM?>kb UNO)@B[#>1<E:=HK>1< D/] � � >#JLHNDW[1<E>1<?UaD FWJ1UN9IHK9;<EME<?>1<?@B[Bm&>1V/@ HN8W>1V/UNJL[YFWJLUNF Ua[1@dHr[#Ua:=@��$VWHK>

[1<E:=FIME<SRI@BA6[1>1HK>#@ _`UaDWD/@B_`>1<?UaD [#>#JL8I_`>18/J1@,UNO4>1V/@ [#>1HK>#@ >#JLHNDW[1<?>1<EUaD�:=HK>#Jh< 9Zb�_`UaDW[1<EA/@^Jh<ED/]rUaDIM?b6>1V/@

A/b'DWHN:=<E_^[�OQJ1Ua: ]NJL<EA,FPUa<EDZ>1[$>#UC]NJ1Ua8WFI[�UNO�]NJL<EA,FPUa<EDZ>1[��4�U �.@^jN@^J*>1VW<E[�HKFWFWJLUaHN_LV�VWHN[�> ��UCFWJhHN_`>1<E_^HNM

A/JLH ��9IHN_��7[�/

� �$V/@�:=U7AWHNM <?>kbYUNO F;HKJ1>1<?>1<?UaDW< D/]4>1V/@�]NJL<EA <ED ]NJ1Ua8/FI[.UNO FPUa<EDZ>1[�HNDIA >1VW@�D78W:\9 @^J.UNO >1V/@B[1@�]NJLUa8/FI[

< DT>#J1U'AW8W_`@B[�HNAWAW<?>1<EUaDWHNM/:YU'A/@BMWFIHKJhHN:Y@^>#@^JL[��$VW<E_hVlVWH jN@$>#Ue9 @A/@B_^<EA/@BAlUaD6��� ���M� ���Qm��$VW<EME@0>1V/@^J1@

HKJL@4[#>1<EMEML� ���� � � � OgJ1@^@)>#JhHNDW[1<?>1<?UaD�FWJLUN9IHK9I<EME<E>1<?@B[&>#UY@B[#>1< :=HK>#@Nm �$VW< _LVC:=H �N@B[0>1VW@4:Y@^>1V/U'AC[18/9��

�#@B_`>$>#U [#@^JL<?Ua8W[�U jN@^J#RI>#>1<EDW]��

� �FIHKJ1>�OQJ1Ua: >1V/@0_^HN[#@�UNOWJ1@BHNM'AWHK>1H�:YU'A/@BM?@BAe<ED �)HN8W[1[1<EHND\OQUNJL: � nKo/mKnNn�� mN>1V/@^J1@0<E[�D/U�_^MEUa[#@BA�� OQUNJL:

� �k[#>#@^F HBjKHN<EMEHK9IM?@!�Y� V/@BD�>1VW@=_^8W:\8IMEHK>1<?jN@YOs8WDW_`>1<?UaD �lq t�<E[)D/UN>4X78WHNA/JLHK>1< _Km @!� ]�� <ED,>1V/@ _^HN[#@

UNO�AW<E[1_`J1@^>#@�� jKHNME8/@BAdUN9I[#@^J1jKHK>1<?UaDW[Bm HND,<?>#@^JLHK>1<?jN@e� [#>#@^F,UNJ�j HKJL< HK>1<?UaDWHNM�HKFIFWJ1U /<E:=HK>1<EUaDW[�>#U�>1V/@

M < �N@BME<EV/U7U'A �1/$- ��HKJ1@4J1@BX78W<?J1@BA��

$@^>1HN<EDW<ED/]�>1VW@iUN9I[#@^J1jKHK>1<?UaD :lHNA/@d<ED � nNn�� m�>1VWHK> <E[YOQUNJ=>1<E:Y@��kA/@^FP@BDWAW@BDT>=AWHK>1HrUaD/@i_^HND @� 'FP@B_`>

[1:YU7UN>1Vr_hVWHND/]N@B[eHNDWA JL@BMEHK>1<?jN@BM?b OQ@�� AW<E[L_`UaDT>1<ED78W<?>1<E@B[)<ED�>1V/@lM HK>#@BDT>e[#FIHN_`@Nm�<?>4<E[*>#Ud9P@YFPUa<EDT>#@BArUa8/>

>1VWHK>e>1VW<E[\<E[*<EDrOQHN_`> HiJL@��I@B_`>1<?UaD UNO�H _hVWHKJLHN_`>#@^JL<E[1>1<E_=@� /VW<?9I<E>#@BA 97b :=HNDTb DIHK>18/JLHNM�[1Ua8/JL_`@B[\UNO0>1<E:Y@

[#@^JL<E@B[^mZDWHN:=@BM?bY>1VWHK>.>1V/@^bY@B:=<?>.AWHK>1H\[1>#J1@BHN:=[��$VW<E_hVlHKJ1@�ME< �N@BM?be>#Uej HKJ1b=[LM?U �$MEb=<EDY>1<E:Y@Nm7UNJ.>#Ue_`UaDW[L<E[#>

UNO�>#@B:YFPUNJLHNM�[#@^]a:Y@BDZ>1[ �$<?>1ViJL@BMEHK>1<?jN@BM?bCV/Ua:YUN]N@BDW@^Ua8W[�_`UaDT>#@BDZ>���!�VTb'[1<E_^HNM�qQ@!� ]��:lHN_LVW<EDW@*UNJ�FWJ1U'_`@B[1[

_`UaDWAW<E>1<?UaDG:YUaDW<?>#UNJL< D/]Zt�UNJ0FIVTb'[1<?UaMEUN]a<E_^HNMPAWHK>1HdqQ@!� ]�������� J1@B_`UNJhAW<ED/]YAW8/Jh<ED/]\HNDdHNDWHK@B[#>1V/@^>1<E_)HNAI:=<ED��

<E[#>#JhHK>1<?UaD;tUNOQ>#@BD�@� 'VI<?9I<?>�>1VW<E[�FIJ1UNFP@^J1>kb!� ��>1VW@^J4@� 'HN:=FIM?@B[)<EDW_^M 8WA/@e>#UNFI<E_YA/@^>#@B_`>1<?UaD <ED�A/b'DWHN:=<E_^HNM M?b

]N@BD/@^JLHK>#@BAl>#@� 7>�UNJ&OgJhHN8WAYA/@^>#@B_`>1<?UaD � 424 �I<ED jKHKJL<?Ua8W[�A/Ua:lHN<EDW[���".UaDW[#@BX78/@BDZ>1M?bNma>1VW<E[�< [h�T� ���M� ����AWUa:=HN<ED

�'D/U �$ME@BA/]N@�HNDIA <EDr>1V/@�OgUaMEMEU �$<EDW]d[#@B_`>1<?UaD H [L<E:YFIME<?RI@BA�A/b'DWHN:=<E_ :YU7AW@BM�<E[\FWJ1UNFPUa[#@BAr9Zb�@� 'FIME<E_^<E>1M?b

�Ko

Page 102: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

<EDW_`UNJLF UNJhHK>1<ED/]�>1VW<E[�FWJL<?UNJ �'D/U �M?@BA/]N@=HN[)HC:YU'A/@BMEME< D/] HN[1[L8W:YFW>1<?UaD��\��VW< [UNO._`Ua8/JL[#@=< [�F Ua[L[1<?9IM?@eAW8/@

>#U=>1V/@*OQ8WM M?b=FWJ1UN9;HK9I<EME<E[1>1<E_$DWHK>18WJ1@)UNO�>1VW@*:YU'A/@BM �

� � � � � � � ����� � ��� � ��� �� ��� � ���!��� � � � � � � ��� � ��� ��� ��� ����� � �

��VW@e@B[1>1<E:=HK>1<?UaD,UNO����,� A/b'DWHN:=< _^[$UaD >1V/@YAW< [1_`J1@^>#@ j HKJh<EHK9IM?@��$<?>1V H�J1@BMEHK>1<?jN@BM?b MEHKJ1]N@YDZ8I:*9P@^J

UNO�[#>1HK>#@B[ <E[��7D/U �$D >#Ud9P@lHND @� 7>#J1@B:=@BM?b AW<�� _^8IM?>)>1HN[�� �Sp��'p ���Sp��20����1/'p � m�HN[\<EDrFWJL<EDI_^<?FIM?@ HNDTb [#>1HK>#@

qQUNJC]NJ1Ua8/F UNOe[#>1HK>#@B[ht�<E[�J1@BHN_hVWHK9IM?@ OQJ1Ua: HNDTb�UN>1V/@^JiHK>C@BHN_LV >1<E:=@ [1>#@^F �$VW<EM?@d>1V/@�_^8/J1J1@BDZ>C[#>1HK>#@

A/@^FP@BDWAW[*UaDWM?b�UaD >1V/@�FWJ1@^j'<?Ua8W[*UaD/@�< D >1V/@G:YU'A/@BM � �$V/@^J1@^OQUNJ1@Nm&<EDr_^HN[1@B[)�$V/@BD ��@ �7DWU � �j� ���<� ���

>1VWHK> >1V/@ AWHK>1H <E[l[L8W_LVc>1VWHK> :Y@BHN[L8/J1@B:Y@BDZ>1[ < D _`UaDW[#@B_^8/>1<EjN@ >1<E:=@iFPUa<EDT>1[ HKJ1@ M < �N@BM?b >#Ur9P@dVW<?]aVIM?b

_`UNJ1J1@BM HK>#@BAfmZ< � @!��J1@BM HK>#@BA=<EDY_`UaDZ>#@BDT>�qQ@!� ]��&9P@BM?UaD/]a<ED/]�>#U4>1V/@[1HN:Y@0UNJ�_^MEUa[#@BM?beJ1@BMEHK>#@BA=_^HK>#@^]NUNJ1bWt�HNDWAY<ED

_`UaDW[#@BX78/@BDW_`@)@� 'FP@B_`>#@BAG>#UY9P@�:=HKFIF @BAGD/@BHKJ0>#U @BHN_hVCUN>1V/@^J$<ED >1V/@)MEHK>#@BDZ>0>#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVW<E_^HNMP[#F;HN_`@Nm/>1V/@BD

<?>)<E[�HNA/jKHNDT>1HK]N@^Ua8I[*>#UC@B:YF;M?U b >1VW<E[�FWJL<?UNJ �'D/U �M?@BA/]N@Y<ED [1<E:YF;ME<?OQb7<EDW]=>1V/@Y:YU'A/@BM�HNDWA ME<?>#>1M?@Y:=H b 9P@

]aHN<ED/@BA�97b=>#J1b'<ED/]\>#Ue@B[1>1<E:=HK>#@�>1VW<E[.<ED/OQUNJL:=HK>1<?UaD OgJLUa: >1VW@�AWHK>1H��&�$V/@�_`UNJLJ1@BMEHK>#@BACDWHK>18/JL@$UNO�HNA �#HN_`@BDZ>

[1HN:YF;M?@B[\< D >1<E:Y@�_^HND 9 @ @B:*9PU'AW<?@BA <ED >1V/@G:YU'A/@BM&97b�R /<ED/]d>1V/@l>#JLHNDI[1<?>1<?UaD FWJ1UN9IHK9;<EME<?> b,:=HK>#Jh< �

� ���<� ���Qmf>1VZ8I[[18W9I[#>1HNDZ>1<EHNMEM?bGJ1@BAW8I_^<ED/]=>1V/@ D78W:*9P@^JUNO@� � OgJ1@^@\FIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^Jh[�HN[�<ED,H OQ8WM M?b ]N@BDW@^JLHNM����� >1V/J1Ua8/]aV >1<E:Y@�:YU'A/@BM � nNn�� � !/UNJ0@� 'HN:=FIM?@Nm'[#@^>#>1<ED/]e>1V/@�>#JLHNDW[1<?>1<EUaDlFWJLUN9IHK9I<EME<E>1<?@B[�HN_^_`UNJLAW<EDW]\>#UYH

��HN8W[L[1<EHND �$<?>1V=jKHKJL<EHNDI_`@ � � U jN@^J�Hen �k�-]NJL<EA UNOf@BXZ8I< �kAW<E[#>1HNDZ>�FPUa<EDZ>1[�< [�FWJLUNF Ua[1@BAfmZHK]aHN<EDI[#>��VW<E_LVl>1V/@AWHK>1H [1V/Ua8IMEAl9P@�:=HKFWFP@BA OgUNJ0j'<E[18WHNM <E[1HK>1<?UaDlFI8/J1FPUa[#@B[����.b A/Ua< D/]e[1U/mWHND���8W_^ME<EAW@BHND :Y@^>#Jh<E_< [.AW@`R;D/@BA

HNDWAi< DT>#J1U'AW8W_`@BAC< DG>1V/@4[#FIHN_`@4UNO�>1V/@4M HK>#@BDT>$[1>1HK>#@B[��

�� � / ��q$� � � � � � � � � t

@� 7F�q % �� � & q�� � % ��� t � t� � � @� 7F�q % �� � & q�� � � % ��� t � t q / ��0at

��>1V/@^JlqsHNDIHNM?bZ>1< _^HNM�UNJ4AW<E[1_`J1@^>#@ tOQUNJL:=[�UNO�>1V/@=[#>1HK>#@=>#JhHNDW[1<?>1<?UaD :=HK>#Jh< ,HKJ1@YUNO._`Ua8/JL[#@=HNM [#UGF Ua[L[1<?9IM?@Nm

[18W_hVlHN[.HNDTbY[#b':=:Y@^>#Jh<E_^HNMI8WDI<E:YU'AWHNM'AW<E[#>#JL<E9I8/>1<?UaD _`@BDZ>#@^J1@BA < DY>1V/@$UNJh<?]a<ED�����V/@B[#@ �$<EMEM'[#FP@B_^<?OQbeVI<?]aV/@^J

>#JLHNDW[L<?>1<?UaD FWJ1UN9IHK9I< ME<?>kbGjKHNME8/@B[�OQUNJ�DW@BHKJ19Zb FPUa<EDT>1[�HNDWA M?U ��@^J)FWJLUN9IHK9I<EME<E>1<?@B[0OQUNJ�:=UNJ1@YAW<E[#>1HNDZ>FPUa<EDZ>1[

UaD,>1V/@ ]NJL<EA��)��VW@e:=HK>#Jh< q�� � t� � � ���� � mfHN[ �$<EMEM�9P@e:=HNAW@e_^M?@BHKJ4[LV/UNJ1>1M?bNmfVWHN[�>1V/@e@�� @B_`>)UNO�@BDW_`U'AW<ED/]

>1V/@�>#UNFPUN]NJLHKF;VW<E_^HNM/J1@BM HK>1<?UaDW[$qsD/@B<E]aVT9PUNJLV/U7U'AW[ht�UaD/@ �$< [1V/@B[�>#U*A/@`R D/@$<EDW[L<EA/@.>1V/@$HN[1[18I:Y@BA=AW<E[L_`J1@^>1< %^@BA

MEHK>#@BDZ>$[18/JLOQHN_`@lq �$VI<E_LViVW@^J1@)OgUNJ_`UaDTjN@BDW<E@BDW_`@\<E[ � % p �Bp � � % p �Bp �Qt ���VW@ J1@BM HK>1<?jN@�MEUN],ME< �N@BME<EV/U7U7A�q / ���ate<E[*>#U 9P@G:=H� '< :=< %^@BA 9Zb @B[1>1<E:=HK>1<ED/],>1V/@�FIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^Jh[\UNO>1V/@

:YU'A/@BM ����8/@�>#UY>1V/@�FWJ1UNFPUa[#@BAG_`UaDW[#>#JhHN<EDT>^mWH [1< :YFIME<SR;@BA=jN@^JL[1<EUaD UNO�>1V/@4[#>1HNDWAIHKJLAG�.HN8I:)� ��@BME_LVdHNM?]NU �

�'p

Page 103: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

JL<?>1VI: �Sp��'p �P_^HNDG9P@�8W[#@BA�OgUNJ�:lH� '<E:l< %B<ED/]4>1VW@�HK9PU jN@)UN9���@B_`>1<EjN@NmWHN[�>1V/@)[#@B_`UaDWAG>#@^JL: <E[�<EDWAW@^F @BDIA/@BDT>

UNO�>1V/@)OQJ1@^@4FIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^JL[�<EDG>1VW< [0>#@^JL: AW8W@)>#U ��q$� � � � � � � � � t�9P@B<ED/]eR '@BAi<EDCHNA/jKHNDW_`@!�� UNJ1@^U jN@^J mNR /<ED/]�>1V/@�[#>1HK>#@�>#JLHNDW[L<?>1<?UaDW[ HN_^_`UNJhAW<ED/]�>#U>1VW@�[#FIHK>1< HNMZAW< [#>1HNDW_`@�JL@BMEHK>1<?UaDW[�UaD\>1VW@�MEHK>#@BDZ>

]NJL<EAcUNO)FPUa<EDT>1[lFWJ1U j7<EAW@B[l8W[ �$<?>1V >1VW@dUNFWFPUNJ1>18WDI<?>kb UNO*:=H �'<ED/] >1VW@ [#>1HK>#@,>#JLHNDW[1<E>1<?UaDW[=JL@B[#FPUaDW[1<?9IME@

OQUNJ*]N@BD/@^JLHK>1< D/]d>1V/@ >#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVW<E_^HNM�J1@^FWJ1@B[1@BDT>1HK>1<?UaDrUNO0>1V/@ AIHK>1H��i��V/@^J1@^OQUNJ1@Nm�<?O�>1V/@ AWHK>1H [#>#J1@BHN: <E[

[18 ��_^<?@BDT>1MEb4_`UaV/@^J1@BDZ>�� >1VWHK>�<E[�<?O/>1V/@^J1@�HKJ1@�<EDWA/@^@BA\[#@BX78/@BDW_`@B[�UNOWJ1@BM HK>1<?jN@BM?b4V/Ua:YUN]N@BDW@^Ua8W[�_`UaDT>#@BDZ>&<ED

>1V/@�AWHK>1H'� >1VW@BD >1V/@0@B:=<E[1[L<?UaD A/@BDW[1<?> b\_^HND 9P@0HK9I[#UaM?jN@BA=OgJ1Ua:(>1VW@.>1HN[��\UNOP<EDWAW8I_^<ED/]H�>#UNFPUN]NJLHKF;VW<E_^HNM

J1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>1HK>1<EUaD�����VW< [�FP@^JL:l<?>1[0HY[1<E:YF;ME<SR;_^HK>1<?UaD�<EDG>1V/@4:=U7A/@BM mWHN[�D/U � <?>�<E[0D/UN>�JL@BXZ8W<EJ1@BA�>#Ul<E:YFPUa[#@

>1V/@@� 7FIM <E_^<?>�HNDWHNMEbZ>1<E_^HNMIOgUNJh: UNO�D/UaDIME<ED/@BHKJL<E>kbeUNOf>1V/@$@B:=< [1[1<?UaD=AW@BDW[1<?> b < DTjNUaM?j'<ED/]*>1V/@D/UaDIME<ED/@BHKJ&9;HN[1<E[

Os8WDW_`>1<?UaDW[ � ����J1UNFWFI< D/] >1V/@B[#@Nm;<E>�<E[�D/U � [18 ��_^<?@BDT>0>#U :YU7AW@BMf>1V/@4@B:=< [1[1<?UaDGFWJLUN9IHK9I<EME<E>1<?@B[�[L<E:YFIM?b�HN[

HY]N@BD/@^JhHNME< %^@BAiME< D/@BHKJ0:YU7AW@BM

����q��� � � � �Wt � � � � � � �� % �=q � �Nt�� q / � 4Nt

� UNJ1@*_`Ua:YFIME@� GOQUNJL:=[BmW<EDTjNUaMEj7<EDW] :=UNJ1@4FIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^JL[\qQ@!� ]���:=< '>18/J1@�UNO�]N@BD/@^JLHNME< %^@BAiME<ED/@BHKJ�:=U7A/@BM [^mWHN[

<E[\8W[18WHNM�<ED [#FP@^@B_LV J1@B_`UN]aDW<E>1<?UaD �Sp��'p �Qt4_`Ua8WM ArHNME[#U 9P@=@B:YFIM?U bN@BA��d��VW@l@� /<E[#>#@BDW_`@ UNO�H _^M?Ua[1@BA OQUNJL:

� �k[#>#@^F=<E[�]a8WHKJLHNDZ>#@^@BAY8/FPUaD*>1V/@�@� /<E[#>#@BDW_`@.UNO;H�_^M?Ua[#@BAeOQUNJL: UNOI>1V/@.@B:=<E[L[1<?UaD4FIJ1UN9IHK9I<EM <?>kb):YU'A/@BM ����V/@

OQUNJL: q / � 4Nt �$<EM Ma9P@08/>1<EME< %^@BAe<ED\>1V/@0@� 'F @^Jh<E:Y@BDZ>1[�JL@^F UNJL>#@BAeHN[&>1VW<E[�<E[ �I@� /<?9IM?@�@BD/Ua8/]aV OQUNJ�>1V/@�@� 'HN:YF;M?@B[

_`UaDW[1< A/@^J1@BA,V/@^J1@!��$V/@\_hV/Ua<E_`@ OgUNJ�UN>1V/@^JBmf:YUNJL@e_`Ua:YF;M?@� i@B:=<E[1[L<?UaDdA/@BDI[1<?>kbi:=U7A/@BM [^m < DTjNUaM?j'<ED/] :YUNJ1@

FIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^JL[�qQ@!� ]�� :=< '>18/J1@B[*UNO0]N@BD/@^JLHNME< %^@BA ME< D/@BHKJ*:YU'A/@BME[^m�HN[e8W[18WHNM�<EDr[#FP@^@B_hVrJ1@B_`UN]aDI<?>1<?UaD �Sp��Nn��Qt

_`Ua8WMEAG9P@4HNME[1UY@B:YFIM?U bN@BAd<EDC_`@^J1>1HN< DiHKFWFIME< _^HK>1<?UaDW[��

� >0_`Ua8WMEA�HKFWFP@BHKJBm/V/U �.@^jN@^JBm/>1VWHK>0[18W_hVCH\:=U7A/@BM �$< MEMIVWH jN@):\8W_hVGJ1@B[#>#JL< _`>#@BA�_^HKF;HK9I<EME<?>1<E@B[^m&�$VW@^J1@BHN[

>1V/@ ����� M < �N@BME<EV/U7U'AC<EDdOQUNJL:e8WMEH,q / ��/at$VIHN[�H FPU �.@^J1Os8WM�D/UaDIME<ED/@BHKJL<E>kb!�$��VI<E[$<EDdOQHN_`>)<E[�D/UN>�>1V/@ _^HN[#@Nm

HN[$���,� [�HNMEM?U ��OgUNJ�H=_`Ua:YFIME@� G[#>1HK>#@�� >#U � Ua8W>#FI8/>�J1@BMEHK>1<?UaD m��$VW<E_hVi<E[�VW<E]aVWM?b DWUaD��kME<ED/@BHKJ m'DWUN>$[1:YU7UN>1V

HNDWA :=HNDTb � >#U � UaD/@ �Sp��20�� �&��MEM/>1VWHK>�_hVWHND/]N@B[.<E[&>1VW@$HNDWHNM?b7>1<E_^HNM/OQUNJL: q � � ����q����Kt#t�UNOP>1VW<E[&:=HKFIFI<ED/]/mHN[ � � ��q��$� t�< [0D/U � AW<E[1_`J1@^>#@!���Ul<EDZ>18W<?>1<?jN@BMEb 8WDWAW@^JL[#>1HNDWA �$VZb�>1VW<E[�:YU'A/@BM < [0HK9IM?@4>#Ul< DWAW8W_`@4HY>#UNFPUN]NJLHKF;VW<E_^HNMfJ1@^FIJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaDfm

D/UN>#@ >1VIHK>i9Zb @BD/OQUNJL_^<EDW] [1:YU7UN>1V�_LVWHNDW]N@B[ <ED >1VW@rMEHK>#@BDZ>d[#FIHN_`@Nm4D/@BHKJL9Zb FIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^JdjN@B_`>#UNJL[$�$<EMEM

J1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>�AWHK>1H4FPUa<EDZ>1[ �$VW< _LVYU'_^_^8/J�_^MEUa[#@$<EDY>1< :Y@!����@B_^HN8I[#@>1VW@B[#@�FPUa<EDZ>1[&HKJ1@A�]� ���M� ���&HNME[#U*HN[1[L8W:Y@BA

[#>#J1UaDW]aM?b\_`UNJ1JL@BMEHK>#@BAiqs[1<E:=< MEHKJ�< De_`UaDZ>#@BDZ>hthmZ>1V/@BD D/@BHKJL9Zb\FIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^J&jN@B_`>#UNJh[ �$<EM MaJ1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>�[1< :=<EMEHKJ0qs<ED

_`UaDZ>#@BDT>ht�AWHK>1He<EDW[#>1HNDI_`@B[�����V/@^J1@^OQUNJ1@$>1VW@�VW< AWA/@BDY[#>1HK>#@B[ �$<E>1V=[1<?]aDW<?R;_^HNDT>�qsD/UaD�� %^@^J1UZt�J1@B[#FPUaDW[L<?9I<EME<E>1<?@B[

�Nn

Page 104: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

OQUNJ�H]a<?jN@BDeUN9I[#@^JLj HK>1<?UaD �$< MEMa> bZFI< _^HNMEM?b)@� /<E[#>�<ED4]NJ1Ua8WFI[�UNOID/@B<?]aVZ9PUNJL<ED/]$VI<EAWA/@BD\[#>1HK>#@B[�qs:\8IM?>1<E:YU'AWHNME<?> b

UNOW>1V/@.FPUa[#>#@^JL<?UNJh[�<E[�DWHK>18/JhHNMEM?b�FPUa[1[1<?9IME@ t;UaD\>[email protected]>#@BDZ>�[#FIHN_`@!����V/@�FIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^J�8/FfAWHK>#@��$<EMEMT>1H �N@�FIMEHN_`@

<ED)>1VW@B[#@&@B:Y@^J1]N@BDZ>�DW@B<?]aVT9PUNJLVWUZU'AW[��f��D)>1VW<E[��.H bNm >1VW@�>#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVZb�@B:Y@^J1]N@B[�DIHK>18/JLHNMEM?b�HN[�H�9Zb � FWJ1U'AW8W_`>

UNO0>1V/@�_`UaV/@^J1@BDW_`@�qs_`UaDT>1< DZ8W<E>kbWt)FWJL@B[#@BDT>\<ED >1V/@�AWHK>1H,[#>#J1@BHN:�� �7@BX78/@BDW_`@B[��$VW< _LVr_`UaDZ>1HN<ED @� 7>#@BDIA/@BA

_`UaV/@^J1@BDZ>C[18/9I[1@BXZ8/@BDI_`@B[ qs[18/9;[#@BXZ8W@BDW_`@B[lUNO\V/Ua:YUN]N@BD/@^Ua8W[G_`UaDZ>#@BDT>ht �<EMEM0]a<?jN@,JL<E[1@i>#U >#UNF UN]NJhHKFIVW<E_

J1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>1HK>1<EUaD qQUN9I[#@^J1jKHK>1<?UaDW[ �VW<E_LVGHKJ1@4_^MEUa[#@)<EDG_`UaDT>#@BDZ> �$< MEMW9P@):=HKFWFP@BA�>#U=D/@BHKJ197blFPUa<EDZ>1[0<ED�>1V/@

MEHK>#@BDZ>.[1FIHN_`@�HNDIAl>1V/Ua[1@ �$VI<E_LV HKJ1@�AI<E[1[1<E:l<EMEHKJ �$<EM M/9P@$:=HKFWFP@BA OQ8/JL>1V/@^J�H �.H b/t �.��b _`UaDT>#JLHN[1>^m'<EOf>1V/@^J1@

<E[0D/Ul>1<E:Y@��kA/@^FP@BDWA/@BDI_`b <EDG>1V/@4AIHK>1HdqQ@!� ]���>1V/@\[1HN:YFIM?@B[0HKJL@4FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>#@BAi<EDCH=JLHNDWA/Ua: UNJLAW@^J thmW>1V/@BDCUNO

_`Ua8/JL[1@NmW>1VW<E[0:YU'A/@BMf<E[$HNDi<EDWHKFWFIJ1UNFWJL<EHK>#@�j'<E[18WHNME< [1HK>1<?UaD�>#UZUaM�HNDWAiD/U=:=@BHNDW<ED/]NOs8WM J1@^FWJ1@B[1@BDT>1HK>1<?UaD �$<EMEM

9P@=UN9W>1HN<EDW@BA��C� D [18W_hVr_^HN[#@B[e>1V/@�:YU'A/@BME[4OQUNJ < � < � A��CAWHK>1H'm&HN[\>1V/@ �)��� � nKo���UNJ\>1V/@�MEHK>#@BDZ>\>#JLHN<E> �

MEHK>#@BDZ>�_^MEHN[1[ �1�$- � :YU'A/@BME[�HKJ1@4< D UNJhA/@^J ����MEME8W[#>#JhHK>1<?jN@[1< :\8WM HK>1<?UaDGHNDWA�@� 7FP@^JL<E:=@BDT>1HNM @� /HN:YFIM?@B[ �$< MEMI9P@

FWJ1U j7< A/@BAC<EDd�7@B_`>1<?UaD / �1-��

!/UNJ�_`Ua:YFIM?@^>#@BDW@B[1[^mW>1V/@*U jN@^JLHNMEM�HNM?]NUNJL<?>1VI: <E[0A/@^>1HN<EME@BAC9P@BM?U � qs[#@^@\@!� ]�� �Sp��'p ��UNJ �SpNpBn���OgUNJ$Hl:YUNJ1@

]N@BD/@^JLHNMPHNDWA A/@^>1HN<EM?@BA�A/@B[1_`Jh<?FW>1<?UaDlUNO ��,� [ t ����V/@�HNM?]NUNJL<?>1VW: <E[�]a8WHKJLHNDZ>#@^@BAG>#Ue_`UaDZjN@^J1]N@)>#U H\M?U'_^HNM

:=H� /<E:e8W: UNO�>1V/@4ME< �N@BME< V/UZU'A��

� ��- � # � �

� � � � � � � � � q / ���at

�V/@^[email protected] UN>1Ve>1V/@�OQUNJ���HKJLAe>#@^JL: �&� � HNDWAe>1V/@�9IHN_�� ��HKJLA >#@^JL: � � � _^HND 9 @�_`Ua:YFI8W>#@BA\JL@B_^8/JL[1<?jN@BMEb< DG>1V/@*[#>1HNDWAIHKJLA �.H b /

�&� � ��q$� � � � ��� � t ��q� � � � � �Wt � � �� � � � � � � �

��q��� � ��� � � � t q / � �at

q �V/@^J1@�� � <E[l]a<?jN@BD�9Zb-q / ��0at#t �$<?>1V >1V/@ <EDI<?>1<EHNME<E[LHK>1<?UaD �&� � ��q$� � � � � t ��q� � � � �

�Wt ��q$� � �Wt�� � � � ��q� � � � � � � t ��q$� � � � t.HNDWA� � � � � ��q��� � � � � � � � � t

��q��� � � � ��� � � � t � �� �� ��q��� � � � �Wt � � � �

� ���q��� � ��� � � � t q / �Ep^oTt

�<?>1V < DW<?>1<EHNME< [1HK>1<?UaD � � � p �&��V/@�A/@BD/Ua:=< DWHK>#UNJL[�UNO 9PUN>1Vl>1V/@OgUNJ��.HKJLA�HNDWA 9IHN_�� ��HKJLA�>#@^JL:=[�<E[_`Ua:=FI8/>#@BAdHN[���q��� � ��� � � � t � �

� �� � �� �� ��q��� � � � �Wt �� � � � � � � m;HNDWA ��q� � t � �

� �� ��q$� � � � � t ��q� � t �

� ) ��- � # � �

�2�

Page 105: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

�$V/@ [1HN:=@,_^M?Ua[1@BA�OQUNJL: 8/FfAWHK>#@d]a<EjN@B[ >1VW@ �,H� '<E:e8W: ��< �N@BM <EV/U7U7A-qs�,��tl@B[#>1< :=HK>1<?UaD�UNO4>1V/@

@� 'FP@B_`>1HK>1<?UaD F;HKJLHN:Y@^>#@^JL[�� � / � � q � �KteUNO�>1V/@C@B:=<E[1[L<?UaD A/@BDW[1<?> bNm�OQUNJlHNDZb :=@B:*9P@^J=UNO�>1V/@@� 'FPUaD/@BDZ>1<EHNM�OQHN:=< M?bdHNDWA,>1VW<E[�<E[�UNO.HG[1<E:=<EM HKJOQUNJL: >#UC>1V/@Y]N@BD/@^JLHNM <E[#@BA ME<ED/@BHKJ�:=< '>18/J1@ :YU'A/@BM

8WFPAIHK>#@!�

� � ��� � � � q / �EpNp t

�V/@^J1@ >1V/@Y_`UaME8W:=DI[UNO�>1V/@Y:=HK>#JL< � _`UaDZ>1HN<ED�>1V/@Y:Y@BHND jN@B_`>#UNJh[ � � � � p /P� m � <E[�>1V/@AIHK>1H :=HK>#JL< Pm � q � � � t� ���� � � � ���� � HNDWA � <E[YH � � AW< HK]NUaDWHNM0:=HK>#JL< �$<?>1V6AI<EHK]NUaDWHNM

@BME@B:Y@BDT>1[ � � � � �� �� � � � � !/UNJ>1V/@*_^HN[#@4UNO ��HN8I[1[1<EHNDG@B:=< [1[1<?UaDGFWJLUN9IHK9I<EME<E>1<?@B[

��q��� � � �Nt q ���� t � � � � A/@^> � � � @� 7F � % ��q� � % � � t � � � � q��� % � �Kt � m0>1VW@,_`U j HKJL< HNDW_`@B[GHNME[#U

JL@BXZ8W<EJ1@�>#U=9P@48/FfAWHK>#@BAC<EDG>1V/@*[LHN:Y@ ��HBbCHN[$<ED�)HN8W[1[1<EHNDC:l< 7>18WJ1@):YU7AW@BME[��

� p�

��� ��

��� �� � � � q��� % � � t`q��� % � �Kt � q / �EpBnat

��[email protected]/FfAWHK>#@.<EDGq / �EpNp t�<E:YFIM <?@B[ H�_`UaDW[1<EAW@^JLHK9IM?@._`Ua:YFI8/>1HK>1<?UaDIHNM7HNAWj HNDZ>1HK]N@�HK]aHN<EDW[#>�>1V/@������ � >kb7FP@

>#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVW< _^HNM :=U7A/@BM [^mZ@B[1F @B_^< HNMEM?bl<ED >1V/@4_^HN[#@)UNO�:\8IM?>1<?jKHKJL<EHK>#@�[#FIHKJL[#@)AWHK>1H'mWHN[ �<EMEM;9 @�AW<E[L_^8W[1[#@BA�<ED

>1V/@4OQUaMEM?U �$<ED/] [#@B_`>1<?UaD��

� � �� � �� � �������� ��� � �

��[$HND Ua8/>1_`Ua:Y@\UNO�>1V/@*HNM?]NUNJL<E>1VW:CmW>1V/@*F Ua[1>#@^JL<?UNJ�FWJLUN9IHK9I<EME<E>1<?@B[ � � � � � p /H� HKJ1@*UN9I>1HN<ED/@BACOQUNJ@BHN_LVr>1<E:Y@ FPUa<EDZ> p /�� �Y��V/@B[1@ _^HND 9 @ j'<?@��.@BA <ED,>1V/@B<?J4A/b'DWHN:=< _\@^jNUaM 8/>1<?UaD�� � �Y��>)@BHN_LVr>1<E:Y@

FPUa<EDZ> �m�>1V/@^J1@=<E[*HiAW<E[#>#Jh<?9I8/>1<?UaD U jN@^J\>1V/@ �$VWUaM?@YVW<EAWA/@BD�[1FIHN_`@dqQj7< [18WHNME<E[LHK>1<?UaD�[#FIHN_`@ t�JL@^FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>#@BA

97b�>1VW@4]NJL<EA��&�UN>#@e>1VWHK>$:e8WM?>1<?FIME@�_^HN8W[1@B[eqQ@!� ]���:\8IM?>1<?FIM?@�>#UNFI<E_^[$UNJ$>#UNFI< _^HNM HN:*9;<?]a8W<?>1<?@B[ t��$VW<E_hVC:=HBb

9P@ FIJ1@B[#@BDZ> HK>=H,]a<?jN@BD >1< :Y@GF Ua< DT> HKJ1@CDWHK>18/JLHNM M?b�J1@^FWJ1@B[1@BDT>#@BA 97b VWH j7< D/]�:\8WME>1<?FIM?@l:=U7A/@B[ UNO>1V/@

AW<E[1>#JL<?9I8/>1<EUaD � � � � �V/@^J1@ � p / � �

��[�H)_`UaDW_^<E[#@0[18I:=:=HKJ1b*VWU �.@^jN@^JBmZOQUNJ�>1V/@�FI8/JLF Ua[1@�UNO FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaDY<EDe>1VW<E[�_hVWHKFW>#@^JBmZ>1V/@�F Ua[1>#@^JL<?UNJ

:Y@BHNDW[)_^HND 9P@eFIM?UN>#>#@BAfm HN[)< D >1VW@ _^HN[1@YUNO�[#>1HK>1<E_Y:=U7A/@BM [��4��VW<E[�<E[ � � � m��$V/@^J1@ � q � � � t� � HNDWA� <E[�HND � � :=HK>#JL< �$VW<E_hV _`UaDZ>1HN<EDW[�>1V/@YMEHK>#@BDZ>�]NJL<EA FPUa<EDT>1[�HN[)_`UaME8W:lDW[����D/UN>1VW@^J�FPUa[1[L<?9I<EME<E>kb

<E[>#UCOgUaM M?U � >1V/@ UNFW>1<E:=HNM�>#JLH �#@B_`>#UNJ1b,UN9W>1HN<ED/@BA,97bi>1V/@ �<E>#@^J19I<�A/@B_`U7AI<ED/] HNME]NUNJL<?>1VW: �Sp��'p � m��$VI<E_LV,<E[

HNDWHNM?UN]NUa8I[�>#U=>1V/@)FPUa[#>#@^Jh<?UNJ$:YU'A/@B[�8/>1< ME< %^@BAG<EDG>1V/@4:YU'A/@BME[�OQUNJ< � < � A���AWHK>1H��&�� D��I� �/M D,�)81/I��� +,����A81/������1� ����/) �/M �"#� ������A#�� �����1/) ?!� MO�/A#)#D �/) �"<� :P��? ���� �� �/M �"#� 1/A< �"<�/� �"� � �� � � �7������F �81/�������(��F 1/�/F A<W ��W/1/?817T`��� = ����)#D<�(K F "� �I

�$-

Page 106: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

� ��� � � � ��� �������

��VW@e<E[L[18/@*UNO._`Ua:YFI8/>1HK>1<EUaDWHNM�_`Ua[#>)[1V/Ua8WMEA,D/U � 9P@ HNAWA/J1@B[L[#@BA��)��V/@ � �k[#>#@^F [L_^HNM?@B[�HN[ �Gq6� � ��thmHN[9 UN>1Vd>1V/@4OQUNJ���HKJLAdHNDWAd9IHN_�� ��HKJLAd@BX78WHK>1<?UaDI[$J1@BX78W<?JL@ �Gq6� � ��t0:e8WM?>1<?F;ME<E_^HK>1<?UaDW[Bm �V/@^J1@B� <E[$>1V/@D78W:*9P@^J UNO/]NJh<EA)FPUa<EDZ>1[ HNDWA � <E[�>1V/@�D78W:\9 @^J�UNOW[1HN:YFIM?@�FPUa<EDZ>1[����$U ��@^jN@^JBmaDWUN>#@�>1VWHK>�<?O'>1V/@&>#JLHNDW[L<?>1<?UaD

:=HK>#JL< d<E[$[#F;HKJL[#@lm >1V/@e_`Ua:YFI8/>1HK>1<?UaDI[HKJ1@ ME<EDW@BHKJ<EDd>1V/@\D78W:\9 @^JUNO&_`UaDWD/@B_`>1<?UaDI[�HNDIAdHNME[#UGME<EDW@BHKJ$<ED

>1V/@CD78W:*9P@^JeUNO[1HN:=FIM?@�F Ua< DT>1[��r�':lHNMEM�>#JhHNDW[1<?>1<?UaD FWJ1UN9;HK9I<EME<?> b j HNME8W@B[��VW<E_LV OsHNMEM�9P@BM?U � H,_`@^JL>1HN<ED

>1V/J1@B[LV/UaMEAi_^HND >1V/@^J1@^OQUNJ1@e9 @\8W[#@^Os8WMEM?b J1@B:YU jN@BA,FWJh<?UNJ�>#UGD/UNJL:=HNME< [1HK>1<?UaDC<EDdUNJLA/@^J$>#U�UN9W>1HN<ED Hl[#F;HKJL[#@

>#JLHNDW[L<?>1<?UaD6:=HK>#JL< �6!&JhHN_`>1<E_^HNMEM?b UaDWM?br>1VW@C]NJL<EA FPUa<EDZ>1[)�$<?>1VW<ED H [1:lHNMEM�D/@B<?]aVZ9 UNJhV/UZU'A D/@^@BA6>#U 9P@

_`UaDWD/@B_`>#@BA m �$VI<E_LVi:=@BHNDW[�UaDWMEb � � � � � � � � � � � D/UaD�� %^@^J1Ul>#JLHNDI[1<?>1<?UaDCFIJ1UN9IHK9I<EM <?>1<?@B[)qQUa8/>$UNO%� � thm+�V/@^J1@

� � � � � � � � � � AW@BD/UN>#@B[.>1V/@�D78W:\9P@^J�UNO�[L8/J1J1Ua8WDIAW<ED/])FPUa<EDZ>1[ �$VI<E_LV�HKJ1@�_`UaDW[1<EA/@^JL@BA HN[.>1V/@�D/@B<?]aVZ9PUNJLV/U7U7AUNO�H ]NJL<EAGFPUa<EDZ>��

��VW@ 8/FfAWHK>#@iUNO)>1VW@ :Y@BHNDW[�<ED6>1VW@,�,H� '< :=<E[1HK>1<?UaDc[#>#@^F [L_^HNM?@B[ HN[ �Gq � � � thm �$V/@^J1@�� <E[l>1V/@AW<E:=@BDW[1<?UaDWHNM <?>kb UNO)>1V/@ AWHK>1H�� �$UN>#@ HNME[#U/m0>1VIHK> OQUNJ :e8WM?>1<?jKHKJL<EHK>#@ [#FIHKJL[#@,AWHK>1H�qQ@!� ]�� jN@B_`>#UNJ��k[#FIHN_`@

J1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>#@BAG>#@� '>hthmW>1VW< [�_`Ua[#> �<EMEMWJL@BAW8W_`@�>#U �Gq � � � � ��� � � � � t � �$V/@^J1@ � � � � ��� � � � < [�>1VW@�D78W:\9P@^J.UNOD/UaD�� %^@^JLUl@BM?@B:Y@BDZ>1[�<EDC>1V/@*AIHK>1HljN@B_`>#UNJL[ � AW8/@4>#U >1V/@*[#FIHKJh[1<?>kbGUNO�UaD/@*UNO�>1V/@*>#@^JL:l[$<EDC>1VW@\:=HK>#JL<

:e8WM?>1<?FIM <E_^HK>1<?UaD,<ED >1V/@l� �k[#>#@^F�� qs�U �.@^jN@^JBm�HN[ �.UNJ��'<ED/]CUaD VW<E]aV�AW<E:Y@BDW[L<?UaDWHNM�[#FIHKJL[#@=AIHK>1HiAW<?J1@B_`>1MEb

<E[C[18W9���@B_`>C>#UcU jN@^J#RI>#>1< D/]/m)[#Ua:Y@rM?U ��@^J AW<E:Y@BDW[L<?UaDWHNMOg@BHK>18/JL@B[dHKJ1@�FWJL@^Og@^J1JL@BA <EDW[#>#@BHNA�� t &HKJL< HNDW_`@

@B[#>1<E:lHK>1<?UaDi<E[�J1@BX78W<?JL@BAGUaDWM?blOQUNJ �)HN8W[1[1<EHNDG@B:l<E[1[1<?UaDCAW@BDW[1<?>1<?@B[ �

��D/UN>1V/@^J4HNA/jKHNDZ>1HK]N@=UNO�>1VW@eFIJ1UNFPUa[#@BA :YU7AW@BM�< [>1VIHK>)>1V/@ UaDWM?b :=U7A/@BM�FIHKJhHN:Y@^>#@^J �$VW<E_hV VWHN[�>#U

9P@�[#@^>�]� ���M� ���&<E[�>1V/@ �<EA/>1V UNOf>1V/@ �)HN8W[1[1<EHNDl<ED=_`Ua:YFI8W>1<ED/])>1V/@�>#JhHNDW[1<?>1<?UaDl:=HK>#JL< PmTUNJ�@BXZ8W<Ej HNM?@BDZ>1M?bNm

>1V/@4D/@B<E]aVT9PUNJLV/U7U'AlJ1@BM HK>1<?UaDW[)qQ>1V/@4D78W:*9P@^J0UNO�D/@B<?]aVZ9 UNJh[�FP@^J0]NJL< A FPUa<EDZ>ht ����D�_`UaDZ>#JLHN[#>^m <ED�>1V/@ �����

>1V/J1Ua8W]aVd>1<E:=@ � nNn���>1V/@\:=U7A/@BM�FIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^JL[_`UaDI[1<E[#>#@BA UNO /$>1V/@*OQUNJL: q �$<EA/>1V;t0UNO�>1V/@e9IHN[1<E[$OQ8WDI_`>1<?UaDW[^m

>1V/@GDZ8I:*9P@^JeUNO$9IHN[1< [*Os8WDW_`>1<?UaDI[^m�>1V/@�D78W:\9P@^J\UNO�]NJLUa8/FI[ _`UaDW[1<EAW@^J1@BA < Dr>1V/@GMEHK>#@BDZ>Y[#FIHN_`@CHNDWA >1V/@

:YU'AWHNME<?> bYUNO�OQUNJL:=<EDW]*>1V/@B[#@�]NJ1Ua8WFI[ � �VW<E_LV�>1V/@BD�UNO�_`Ua8/JL[#@�FWJ1U j7<EAW@B[.HeFPUN>#@BDZ>1<EHNMEM?b=:YUNJL@FPU �.@^J1Os8WM

:YU'A/@BMEME< D/]e_^HKF;HK9I<EME<?> b!�

��VW@_`UaV/@^J1@BDI_`@HN[1[18I:YFW>1<?UaD [1V/Ua8WMEA=9 @8WDWA/@^JL[1>#UZU'A=<EDYFIJ1UN9IHK9I<EM <E[#>1<E_.>#@^JL:=[ /�>1VW@$FIV/@BDWUa:Y@BD/UaD=UNO

HK9WJL8WFW>�>#UNFI<E_^HNM�_LVIHND/]N@B[�<E[$D/UN>�A/@BDW<?@BAd9ZbC>1VW@\_`UaV/@^J1@BDI_`@ HN[L[18W:YFW>1<EUaD���� DW[1>#@BHNA <?>�<E[$HN[L[18W:Y@BAd>1VWHK>

HK9WJL8WFW>$_LVIHND/]N@B[�U7_^_^8WJ�[1<E]aDW<SR;_^HNDZ>1M?bCM?@B[1[$OgJ1@BX78/@BDZ>1M?bC>1VWHND >1V/@eFWJ1@B[#@^J1jKHK>1<?UaDdUNO&>1V/@*>#UNF;<E_\< DdH�_^M?Ua[#@

D/@B<?]aVZ9PUNJLV/U7U7AeU jN@^J�_`UaDI[#@B_^8/>1<?jN@�>1< :Y@�OQJLHN:Y@B[���� O HND HK9WJL8/FW>&_hVWHND/]N@U7_^_^8/Jh[^ma>1V/@BDlUNOP_`Ua8WJL[#@NmZ:=U j'<ED/]

�2/

Page 107: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

H ��HBbY>#U �.HKJhAW[&H4AW< � @^J1@BDZ>�J1@^]a<?UaD)�$< MEM7UaDWM?b*9P@�FPUa[1[1<?9;M?@�<EDYH)D78W:\9P@^J�UNOf[#>#@^F;[����U �.@^jN@^J.UaDWM?b\H)[L:=HNMEM

HN:YUa8WDZ>�UNO�AWHK>1H�[1HN:YFIME@B[ �$< MEM 9P@*OQUNJL_`@BA,>#UG9P@\:=HKFWFP@BA�� UaD H ��HBb �P>#U ��HKJLAW[�>1V/@ D/@��(J1@^]a<?UaDfmPHN[)H

MEHK>#@BDZ>*]NJL< A UNOJ� FPUa<EDZ>1[4_^HNDr9 @l>#JLHBjN@^JL[1@BA <EDrHK>*:YUa[#> � � [#>#@^FI[ � <?O.UaDWM?b,>#JLHNDW[1<?>1<EUaDW[�9P@^> �.@^@BD_^M?Ua[#@CD/@B<E]aVT9PUNJL[\HKJ1@GF @^Jh:=<?>#>#@BA � UNJYM?@B[L[ � <ED UN>1V/@^JY_^HN[#@B[�� �$VZ8W[Bm&HNAWHKFW>1HK>1<?UaD <E[\JLHKFI<EA <ED >1V/@

_^HN[#@ UNO�HK9WJh8/FW>$>#UNF;<E_^HNM�_hVWHND/]N@YHNDWA,<E[�D/UN>�HG[#@^Jh<?Ua8W[$M <E:=<?>1HK>1<?UaD��$��V/@ _`UaDWAW<?>1<EUaDiOQUNJ�>1VI<E[:=U7A/@BM�>#U

�.UNJ��l<E[.V/U �.@^jN@^J�>1V/@�@� /<E[#>#@BDW_`@�UNO�H [18 ��_^<?@BDT>._`UaDW[#@B_^8/>1<EjN@�AIHK>18W: F Ua< DT>1[��$VW<E_hV AWUeD/UN>�_LVIHND/]N@)>1V/@

>#UNFI<E_ HK9WJh8/FW>1M?bNmf[#UC>1VWHK>�>1V/@=DW@B<?]aVT9PUNJLVWUZU'AW[�HNDWA,>#UNF UN]NJhHKFIVW<E_eJ1@BMEHK>1<EUaDW[ �$<EMEM�9P@eA/@^jN@BMEUNF @BA��\� UNJ1@

<EDW[L<?]aVT>1[�UaDGV/U � HNDWAG<ED �$VW<E_hV _`UaDWAI<?>1<?UaDW[�>1VW<E[.HNM?]NUNJL<?>1VW: �.UNJ��7[.@ � _^<E@BDT>1M?b �$<EMEM/9P@FWJ1U j'<EA/@BA�<ED >1V/@

OQUaMEM?U �<ED/]Y[#@B_`>1<?UaD��

� >$[1V/Ua8IMEA�9 @4:=@BDT>1<?UaDW@BAC>1VWHK>$HND/UN>1VW@^J$OQUNJL: UNO�>1V/@ ���$�rmW>1VW@ ��HN8W[1[L<EHNDC!&J1U'_`@B[1[eq ��!.t.OQUNJL:e8��

MEHK>1<?UaD � n'p ��< [�J1@BMEHK>#@BA�<ED,OQUNJL: >#UC>1V/@ FWJ1UNFPUa[#@BA :YU'A/@BM m <ED,>1VWHK>)>1VW@e> ��Ud9I8W<EMEAI<ED/]=@BM?@B:=@BDT>1[�UNO.>1V/@

>#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVW< _�:YU'A/@BM ma>1V/@D/@B<?]aVZ9 UNJhV/UZU'A)�N@^JLD/@BMIHNDWA=>1V/@:=< '>18/J1@�:YU'A/@BMWHKJ1@�A/@B_`Ua8/FIME@BA����$V/@0OgUNJh:Y@^J

<E[eH :YU7AW@BM�OQUNJY< � < � A�� AWHK>1H,>1VWHK>YVWHN[e>1V/@C[1HN:Y@CD78W:*9P@^JeUNO$:YU'A/@BM�FIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^JL[iqQ>1VW@ �<EA/>1V UNO>1V/@

��HN8W[L[1<EHNDC<EDC_`Ua:YF;8/>1<ED/]Y>1V/@4[1>1HK>#@4>#JLHNDW[1<E>1<?UaDC:=HK>#JL< It.HN[�>1VW@)FWJ1UNFPUa[#@BAC:YU'A/@BMPOQUNJ�>1<E:Y@��kA/@^FP@BDWAW@BDT>

AWHK>1H��.� Di>1V/@ ��!�OgUNJh:\8WM HK>1<?UaDfm/>1V/@*DW@B<?]aVT9PUNJLVWUZU'AC:=HK>#JL< C<E[0F;MEHN_`@BAiHN[�>1VW@*_`U jKHKJL<EHNDW_`@e:=HK>#JL< CUNO�H

��HN8W[L[1<EHND FWJL<?UNJ �VW<E_LV <E[>1V/@*FWJh<?UNJ$FIM HN_`@BAdUaD >1V/@ _`@BDT>#@^JL[�UNO�H�:=< '>18/J1@\:YU7AW@BM ���$U ��@^jN@^J m 9P@B[1<EA/@B[

>1V/@�_`Ua:YFI8/>1HK>1<EUaDWHNMPM?UaHNAW<ED/]\UNO�[18I_LV�HNDCHKFWFWJ1UaHN_hV qs< DTjN@^JL[L<?UaDlUNO�H>� � :=HK>#JL< Wt�<?>�HNME[#U ME<E:=<?>1[�>1V/@:YU'A/@BME[��7HKFWFIME< _^HK>1<?UaD=>#UY_`UaDZ>1<EDZ8WUa8W[.J1@BHNM j HNME8W@BA AWHK>1H'm/HN[�>1V/@ �N@^blF;HKJ1>�UNO�>1V/@�:=U7A/@BM _`UaDW[1< [#>1[.UNO >1V/@

��HN8W[L[1<EHND FIHKJLHN:Y@^>#@^J�FWJL<EUNJ�HNDWA�ME< �N@BME< V/UZU'AYA/@BDW[L<?>1<?@B[&UN>1VW@^J�>1VWHND�>1V/@ ��HN8W[1[L<EHND �.Ua8WMEAlJ1@BX78W<?J1@UN>1V/@^J

_`UaD��18/]aHK>#@�FWJL<?UNJL[&>1VWHND=>1V/@ ��HN8W[1[L<EHND���� Dl>18/JLDfmTFIMEHN_^<ED/]*>1V/@$D/@B<?]aVZ9PUNJLV/U7U7Al:=HK>#JL< =HN[�>1V/@�>#JLHNDW[L<?>1<?UaD

FWJ1UN9;HK9I<EME<?> bi:=HK>#JL< �:=H �N@B[)>1VW@=:YU7AW@BM�<EDWA/@^FP@BDWA/@BDZ>�UNO�>1V/@Y> bZFP@YUNO�AWHK>1H qsHNDWA VW@BDW_`@YUaD >1V/@YOQUNJL:

UNO$ME< �N@BME<EV/U7U7A A/@BDW[1<E>kbWt)HNDWA A/U7@B[ D/UN>Y<EDW_`J1@BHN[#@�>1V/@G_`Ua:YFI8/>1HK>1<EUaDWHNM�A/@B:=HNDWAW[e_`UaDW[1< A/@^JLHK9IM?b�U jN@^JlH

[#>1HNDWAIHKJLAG:=< '>18/J1@:=U7A/@BM ���U=:=HK>#JL< <EDZjN@^JL[1<?UaD�<E[.J1@BX78W<?J1@BA�HNDWAGH _^M?Ua[#@BA�OgUNJh: � �k[#>#@^Fd< [.H j HN< MEHK9IM?@

�$VW< _LVC<E[�_`UaDZjN@BDW<?@BDZ>1M?b�UNO�>1V/@4[1HN:Y@4OQUNJL: OQUNJ$HNMEMf:=@B:*9P@^JL[0UNO�>1V/@)@� 'FPUaD/@BDZ>1<EHNMPOQHN:l<EM?b!�

� >:=H biHNME[#U=9P@4<EDZ>#@^J1@B[#>1< D/]=>#U :=@BDT>1<?UaDd>1VWHK>$>1VW@*FWJ1UNFPUa[#@BAd:YU7AW@BM <E[�[#Ua:=@BV/U � J1@BMEHK>#@BA <EDCOQUNJL:

>#UCD/Ua<E[#bd>#JLHNDW[1:=< [1[1<?UaD,_LVWHNDID/@BM�_`U7AW< D/] � 4 0 � �*��VW<E[<E[�HND/UN>1V/@^J4:YU'A/@BM�OQUNJ�< � < � A��)AWHK>1H'm�<ED$�$VW< _LV,>1V/@

>#JLHNDW[L:=<E[1[1<EUaDiUNO�@BHN_hV�[1<ED/]aME@*@BDW_`U'A/@BA AWHK>18W: FPUa<EDZ>$>1V/J1Ua8W]aV,HGAW< [1_`J1@^>#@ :Y@B:YUNJ1b'M?@B[1[�_LVWHNDID/@BM �$<?>1V

�'D/U �$DYDWUa<E[#@�_LVWHKJLHN_`>#@^Jh<E[#>1<E_^[&VIHN[�9 @^@BD FIJ1@^j7<EUa8W[1M?b4D/UN>#@BA � 4 0��W>#U�< :YFPUa[#@.HND6�K� ���M� ����[#FP@B_^<SRI@BA\>#UNFPUaM �

UN]Nb=<EDY>1VW@$[#FIHN_`@UNO FIJ1UN>#UN>kb7FP@B[^m&�$VW@^J1@�>1V/@$DWUa<E[#be>#JLHNDW[1:=< [1[1<?UaDY:=HK>#Jh< =<E[�>1V/@�@BME@B:Y@BDT>�UNOP>1V/@$:YU'A/@BM

J1@B[#FPUaDW[L<?9IM?@\OgUNJ4<EDIAW8W_^<ED/]�HG>#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVW<E_^HNM�JL@^FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaD�UNO.>1V/@=AWHK>1HG97b,:l<EDW<E:=< %B<ED/]=>1V/@=AI<E[#>#UNJ��

�20

Page 108: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

>1<?UaDrFWJ1U'AW8W_`@BA 97b,>1VW@lD/Ua<E[#@!����D�Ua8/J*FIJ1UNFPUa[#@BA�>#@B:YFPUNJLHNM&:=U7A/@BM m�>1V/@=>#JhHNDW[1<?>1<?UaDr:=HK>#JL< 9P@^> �.@^@BD

_`UaDW[#@B_^8W>1<?jN@)>1<E:Y@4:YUa:=@BDT>1[�< [�>1VW@4:YU7AW@BM;@BME@B:Y@BDT> �VW<E_LVG<EDIAW8W_`@B[.>1V/@)>#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVW< _^HNMPFWJ1UNFP@^J1>kb�HNDWA

<ED _`UaDZ>#JLHN[#>=>#U�>1V/@G>#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVI<E_^HNM�FWJL<EDI_^<?FIM?@B[*OgUNJ=< � < � A��rAWHK>1H'm.>1V/@C_`UaV/@^J1@BDW_`@CUNO�>1V/@iAWHK>1H�[1>#J1@BHN:

<E[eJ1@��I@B_`>#@BAc<ED >1V/@i:=HKFWFI< D/]/m&<ED _`UaDW[#@BX78/@BDW_`@i>1VW@�>#UNFPUN]NJLHKF;VTb <ED _`UaDT>#@BDZ>=OQUaMEM?U �$[YHN[YHND6@BM?@^]aHNDZ>

Ua8/>1_`Ua:Y@\UNO�>1VW@*_`UaV/@^J1@BDW_`@\<EDG>1<E:Y@)UNO�>1V/@4AWHK>1H��

��M?>1V/Ua8/]aV,A/@^JL<EjN@BAiOQJ1Ua: H�AW< �P@^J1@BDZ>[#>1HKJL>1<ED/]lFPUa<EDZ>$HNDWA OQUNJ�AW< � @^J1@BDZ>$F;8/J1FPUa[#@NmI>1VW@^J1@\<E[�H�[1<E:=< �

MEHKJL<E>kblUNO�>1V/@)FWJLUNF Ua[1@BA j'<E[18IHNME<E[1HK>1<?UaD�:YU'A/@BMP>#UY>1V/@\".UaDI[#>#JLHN<ED/@BAG��<EAWA/@BDG�,HKJ��NU ji� U'A/@BM&q "���� ��t

FWJ1UNFPUa[#@BA <ED �Sp��20���HN[ H :Y@BHNDI[\UNO�8WDW[18WF @^JLj7<E[1@BA�M?@BHKJLDW<EDW]d<ED [#>#JL8W_`>18/JL@BAr>1<E:=@�[#@^Jh<?@B[ HNDWA AW@B:YUaD��

[#>#JLHK>#@BA,HN[�9P@B<ED/]=[18/FP@^JL<EUNJ�>#U 34HNM :=HND!�<EM?>#@^Jh[�OQUNJ>1V/@\>1HN[��CUNO�J1@B_`U jN@^JL<ED/]G:YUa8/>1V,:YU jN@B:=@BDT>1[�OQJ1Ua:

[#FP@^@B_LV HN8IAW<?U [1<?]aDWHNME[ � ��V/@ <EA/@BH <ED OQHN_`>iVWHN[GHNME[1U HKFIF @BHKJL@BA�@BHKJhME<?@^JC<ED�>1V/@�[#FP@^@B_LV J1@B_`UN]aDW<E>1<?UaD

_`Ua:=:e8WDW<?> b�8IDWA/@^J0>1V/@*DIHN:Y@)UNO��'<?>18WHK>#@BAd�7>1HK>#@e�< AWA/@BDG� HKJ��NU ji� U7A/@BM � �Nn�� �

� ��� � � � � �� ���������

������ � �� � ������ � ��� � ��� ��� � � � � � � ��� � � ��� � ��� ��� � � � � � � � � ������

��� � �=�� � � % � & � � # # B � �3& � &

��VW@ AWHK>1H _`UaDW[1< A/@^J1@BA <ED >1VW< [\[#@B_`>1<EUaD _`UaDI[1<E[#>1[\UNO$H,[#>#J1@BHN: UNO�>#@� '> UNJe[#>#JL@BHN: UNO ��UNJhAW[�� !WUNJ

Os8/J1>1V/@^J4FIJ1U7_`@B[L[1<ED/]/m�>1V/@ 8W[L8WHNM&HNDWA _`UaDZjN@BDW<?@BDZ> �.H b <E[4>#U,_`UaDW[1<EA/@^J\_`UaDW[#@B_^8/>1<?jN@�U jN@^JhMEHKFWFI<EDW]C>1<E:Y@

OQJLHN:Y@B[.HN[�_`UaDW[1@B_^8/>1<?jN@�UN9I[#@^J1jKHK>1<?UaDW[ ���$V/@B[#@HKJL@$>#@^JL:Y@BA � �#�%� ��OE��� �SpBn � ���OQ>#@^J.>1VW@[#>1HNDWAIHKJLAlFIJ1@^FWJ1U �

_`@B[1[1< D/]e[1>1HK]N@ � [1>#UNF�� ��UNJhAW[.J1@B:YU jKHNM m/[#>#@B:=:l<ED/] � >1VW@�@B_`>#UNJ��'FIHN_`@�:=U7A/@BM �Sp.-Wp � <E[�@B:YFIMEU bN@BA�>#U

UN9W>1HN<EDlH*D78W:Y@^JL<E_^HNM'JL@^FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaD=UNOP>1V/@B[1@$_`UaDT>#@� '>1[^m��$VW< _LVYFWJLU j'<EA/@B[&H4AI<E[1_`J1@^>#@�jKHNME8/@BAiqQ9;<EDWHKJ1beUNJ

OQJ1@BXZ8W@BDW_`bd_`Ua8WDZ>�9IHN[#@BA;t � �kAW<E:=@BDW[1<?UaDWHNM jN@B_`>#UNJBm��$V/@^JL@ � <E[>1V/@YDZ8I:*9P@^J�UNO�AW<E[#>1< DW_`> �.UNJLAW[�<ED >1V/@jNU'_^HK9I8WMEHKJ1bYUNJ�AW<E_`>1<EUaDWHKJ1b �Sp�� ��� �&��VW@AWHK>1He[#@^JL<?@B[�>1VZ8I[�_`UaDW[L<E[#>�UNO�HNDlUNJLAW@^J1@BA [1@BXZ8/@BDI_`@$UNO�_`UaDZ>#@� 7>1[ �

��V/@���HK>#@BDZ>0�'@B:=HNDT>1< _��DWHNM?b'[1<E[$qs���'�)t �1�54 �POQ@BHK>18/J1@B[._^HND 9P@�@� '>#JLHN_`>#@BAGFWJh<?UNJ�>#UeOQ8WJ1>1V/@^J�FIJ1U7_`@B[L[1<ED/]/m

�$VW< _LV �$<EM M 8I[#@^OQ8IMEM?b=J1@BAI8W_`@)>1V/@4AW<E:=@BDW[1<?UaDWHNM <?>kb=UNO�>1V/@*AIHK>1H��

��� � �=�� � 8 � - !?&:+ � - �<�?> � # ' - > *�(A! � - ) # - - & > # -

��De>1VW<E[�[18/9I[1@B_`>1<?UaDfma<EMEM 8W[#>#JLHK>1<?jN@�@� 'HN:=FIM?@B[�UaDYHKJ1>1<SR;_^< HNMEM?b)UNJLA/@^JL@BAY:Y@B[1[1HK]N@B[&HKJL@.]a<EjN@BDY<EDeUNJLA/@^J�>#U

A/@B:YUaDI[#>#JLHK>#@*>1VW@\[#>#J1@BDW]N>1VW[$HNDWA ME<E:=<E>1HK>1<?UaDW[�UNO�>1V/@*FIJ1UNFPUa[#@BAi:Y@^>1V/U'Ad< Di_`Ua:YFIHKJL< [#UaDi>#U UN>1V/@^J$@� �

<E[#>1< D/])j7< [18WHNME<E[LHK>1<?UaD :Y@^>1V/U'AW[&<EDYjKHKJL<?Ua8I[&[1<?>18WHK>1<EUaDW[�����V/@$AWHK>1H\8/>1<EME< %^@BAY_`UaDW[1<E[#>#@BA=UNO UNJhA/@^J1@BAl8I[#@BD/@^>

�54

Page 109: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

:Y@B[1[LHK]N@B[0OgJLUa: >1V/@4nKo��k�$@��$[1]NJ1Ua8/Fd_`UNJ1F;8W[����&��HN_hVCUN9I[#@^J1jKHK9IM?@)AWHK>18I: F Ua< DT>�<E[.UaD/@4:Y@B[1[LHK]N@4<ED�>1VW<E[_^HN[#@!�C�Og>#@^Je>1V/@l8W[L8WHNM�FWJ1@�� FIJ1U7_`@B[L[1<ED/]CUNO�>1V/@ JLH � >#@� 7>\9Zb�[#>#@B:=:l<ED/]/m�HNDIAr[#>#UNF�� �.UNJLArJ1@B:YU jKHNM m�H

OQ@�� ���/� � OQ@BHK>18/J1@B[0UNO�>1V/@*�@B_`>#UNJ�� �7FIHN_`@eJ1@^FWJ1@B[1@BDT>#@BAd>#@� 7> ��@^J1@*@B:YFIM?U bN@BAdHN[$< D/FI8/>1[�>#U=>1VW@4j7< [18WHNME< �

[1HK>1<?UaD,HNM?]NUNJL<E>1VW:=[^mW>1VW@*@� /HN_`>�AI<E:Y@BDW[1<EUaDWHNME<?> blUNO �$VW< _LV �<EMEMP9P@*[#>1HK>#@BA <EDd@BHN_LV,UNO�>1V/@*@� 'FP@^JL<E:Y@BDZ>1[

FWJ1@B[1@BDT>#@BA����$UN>#@ >1VWHK>4@^jN@BD >1V/Ua8/]aV�>1VW@l���'� A/U7@B[4D/UN>4>1H �N@G<EDZ>#UiHN_^_`Ua8WDZ>\>#@B:YFPUNJLHNM�<ED/OQUNJL:=HK>1<?UaD

�$VW< M?@)@� 7>#JhHN_`>1<ED/]�>1V/@*OQ@BHK>18/J1@B[^mP<?>�A/UZ@B[�D/UN>J1@B:YU jN@e>1V/@e>#@B:YFPUNJLHNM�[1>#JL8W_`>18/J1@\OgJLUa: >1V/@eAWHK>1Hl@B<E>1V/@^J �

��DG@� 'HN:YF;M?@�UNO�@B:YFIMEU b'<ED/] HY[#Ua:Y@��$VWHK>0[1< :=<EMEHKJ�[#@B_`UaDWAGUNJLAW@^J�AW<E:Y@BDW[L<?UaDWHNME<?> b J1@BAW8W_`>1<?UaD�>#@B_hVWDW<EX78/@

FWJL<EUNJ0>#UlHNDC@BDZ>#@^JL<ED/]=<EDCH=>#@B:YFPUNJLHNM HNM?]NUNJL<E>1VW: _^HNDi9P@)OQUa8WDWAG@!� ]���<ED �102/ � �

� VW<EM?@�H)A/JLHN[1>1<E_�JL@BAW8W_`>1<?UaD <ED AW<E:=@BDW[1<?UaDWHNM <?>kb):=H b\J1@BAI8W_`@�>1V/@0[#@^FIHKJLHK9I< ME<?>kb*FWJ1UNFP@^J1>kb*UNOI>1V/@�A/U'_ �

8W:Y@BDZ>0_^MEHN[1[#@B[$HNDWAC:=HBb�>1V78W[�9P@�ME@B[1[�OQH jNUNJLHK9IM?@)OQUNJ�_`@^J1>1HN<EDC_^M 8W[#>#@^JL<EDW]\UNJ�j'<E[18IHNME<E[1HK>1<?UaD�HNM?]NUNJL<E>1VW:=[^m

�.@ �<EMEM�A/@B:YUaDW[#>#JhHK>#@e>1VI<E[�<E[�UNO.ME<E>#>1M?@\_`UaDW_`@^JhD�OgUNJ�>1V/@ >#@B:YFPUNJLHNM�HNME]NUNJL<?>1VW: FWJ1UNFPUa[#@BA V/@^JL@!�*�.@B<ED/]

HK9IM?@)>#U ��UNJ��C<EDCMEU �-AW< :Y@BDW[1<?UaDI[�<EDG>18WJLDiVWHN[0>1VW@4HNA/j HNDZ>1HK]N@eUNO�_`Ua:YF;8/>1HK>1<?UaDWHNMf@ ��_^<?@BDW_`b!�

��VW@4j HKJh<EHNDW_`@)UNO�>1V/@ �)HN8W[1[1<EHNDd<EDC_`Ua:YFI8/>1< D/]Y>1V/@\[1>1HK>#@*>#JLHNDW[L<?>1<?UaDC:=HK>#JL< ��HN[$[1@^>�>#U � � o nU jN@^J4H,p^o p^o�]NJL<EAd>1V/J1Ua8/]aV/Ua8W>HNMEM�>1V/@e@� 7FP@^JL<E:=@BDT>1[$J1@^FPUNJ1>#@BA < Dd>1VW< [�FIHKFP@^JYqs:YUNJ1@e]N@BD/@^JLHNMEM?bNm � �[1V/Ua8IMEA*D/UN>�@� /_`@^@BA=n � � ��t ����VW<E[�j HNM 8/@ ��HN[�A/@^>#@^JL:=< D/@BA*@� 'FP@^JL<E:Y@BDZ>1HNMEM?b)HNDWAe@B:YF;M?U bN@BAe>1V/J1Ua8W]aV/Ua8/>>1V/@4@� 'FP@^JL<E:Y@BDZ>1[�J1@^FPUNJ1>#@BA�����@*[1V/Ua8WM AC:Y@BDT>1<EUaDC>1VWHK>�>1V/@\XZ8WHNM <?>kb�UNO�>1VW@*<E:=HK]N@*< [�]NJ1@BHK>1M?bCH�� @B_`>#@BA

97b�>1VW@*_LV/Ua< _`@*UNO�>1VW<E[�FIHKJhHN:Y@^>#@^JBm;HN[HlMEHKJL]N@^J�j HNM 8/@4UNO �$<EA/>1VC:lH �N@B[$>1V/@\:=HKFWFI<EDW] [1FWJ1@BHNA��$VW@^J1@BHN[

@� /_`@B[1[1<?jN@BM?b=[L:=HNMEM��$<EAW>1VYj HNM 8/@B[ �.Ua8WMEA=:lH �N@<?>&>#U7U\MEU7_^HNME< %^@BA�����V/@0OQJ1@^@$FIHKJhHN:Y@^>#@^JL[���@^J1@$JLHNDWA/Ua:=MEb

<EDW<E>1<EHNME<E[#@BA��

��DrHGR;JL[#>4@� 'FP@^JL<E:Y@BDZ>)>1V/@=j'<E[18WHNM <E[1HK>1<?UaD J1@B[L8WM?>)UaDrH [#FP@B_^<EHNMEM?b,_LV/Ua[1@BDrUNJLAW@^J1@BA _`UaMEM?@B_`>1<EUaD UNO �

D/@��$[1]NJ1Ua8/FCAW<E[1_^8I[1[1<?UaDW[�<E[.FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>#@BA��&��V/@RIJL[1>�RIjN@)���'� OQ@BHK>18/J1@B[ �.@^J1@�@B:YFIM?U bN@BACHN[0<ED/FI8/>1[�>#UY>1V/@

AW< �P@^J1@BDZ>0j7< [18WHNME<E[LHK>1<?UaDGHNM?]NUNJL<?>1VW:l[�����V/@)>#UNFI<E_^[ ��@^J1@ � _`Ua:YF�� [#b'[�� <?9I: � FP_ � VIHKJLA���HKJ1@ �?m

� _`Ua:YF�� [1b7[�� :lHN_ � VWHKJLA���HKJ1@ �ZHNDIA � [1_^< � :Y@BA(� � >1V/@$[1HN:=@�[#@^>#>1<ED/] �VW<E_LVYVIHN[�9P@^@BD=HNDWHNM?b'[#@BAY<ED "0VWHKFW>#@^J

- qs[#@^@=RI]�� -���/ � HNDIA >1V/@lHN[1[#U'_^<EHK>#@BA A/@B[1_`JL<?FI>1<?UaD <ED�[18/9I[1@B_`>1<?UaD -���/ �Ep � t �<?>1V�>1V/@=MEHK>#@BDZ>4>#JLHN<E>*HNDWA

_^MEHN[1[e:YU'A/@BME[\OgUNJ < � < � A��dAWHK>1H HNDWA [#>1HKJ1>1<ED/] OgJLUa: >1VW@ �@B_`>#UNJ �7F;HN_`@�A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ> � J1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>1HK>1<EUaD�� � >

VWHN[�9P@^@BD HNM?J1@BHNA/b FPUa<EDT>#@BA Ua8/>4V/U � AW<�� _^8IM?>$>1VW< [AWHK>1HC[1@^>4<E[^mfDWHN:Y@BM?bd>1VWHK>)>1V/@eRIJL[#>�> �.UCUNO�>1VW@B[#@

>#UNFI<E_^[*HKJ1@l[#>#J1UaDW]aM?bdU jN@^JLMEHKFWFI< D/]/m�HN[4>1VW@^b,8/>1< ME< %^@YHG]NJ1@BHK>\HN:=Ua8WDT>*UNO._`Ua:YF;8/>#@^J*VWHKJLA �.HKJ1@YJL@BMEHK>#@BA

�.UNJLAW[ �$VW<EME@4>1V/@Y_^MEHN[1[�UNO�:Y@B[L[1HK]N@B[)HK9PUa8/>�:=@BAW<E_^<ED/@e<E[�HKFWFIHKJ1@BDZ>1M?bCjN@^J1b,AW<E[#>1< DW_`>����U �*m H�[LME<?]aVZ>1M?b

AW< �P@^J1@BDZ>j'<?@���FPUa<EDZ>$<E[OQUaMEM?U �.@BA <ED >1VW<E[@� 7FP@^JL<E:=@BDT>�/$�$V/@\D/@��$]NJ1Ua8/F :Y@B[1[1HK]N@B[4HKJL@eD/U �(j7<?@��.@BA <ED� "� � ���� ���7:C:C: F ����F ��I�A F �4D<A��� ��(K, ����41���)<�=)<.���2�

Page 110: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

>1V/@B<?J.>#@B:YFPUNJLHNM;UNJLA/@^JBm/nKoNo _`UaDW[#@B_^8/>1<EjN@�:=@B[1[1HK]N@B[�9P@B<ED/]4FIJ1@B[#@BDZ>#@BA OQJ1Ua: @BHN_LVG>#UNF;<E__^M HN[1[�����V/@�HN<E:

<E[�>#U4A/@B:YUaDI[#>#JLHK>#@0>1VWHK>�>1V/@0FWJLUNF Ua[1@BAeHNME]NUNJL<?>1VW:(_^HND >1H �N@$HNA/jKHNDZ>1HK]N@�UNOI>1VW< [�>#@B:=F UNJhHNM/[#>#JL8W_`>18/JL@�OQUNJ

9P@^>#>#@^J0_^HKFW>18/JL<EDW]*>1V/@�[#>#JL8W_`>18WJ1@$UNO >1VW@�AWHK>1H����dUNJ1@^U jN@^JBmW<?>�<E[�_^HKF;HK9IM?@�UNO�A/Ua<ED/]e[#U HK>�He[1<?]aDI<SR;_^HNDZ>1M?b

J1@BAW8I_`@BA _`Ua:YF;8/>1HK>1<?UaDWHNM._`Ua[#>^m&HN[ <?>��<EMEM�8/>1<EM < %^@lH,A/JLHN[#>1<E_ AW<E:Y@BDI[1<?UaDWHNME<E>kbdJL@BAW8W_`>1<?UaD UNO0>1V/@G<ED/FI8/>

AWHK>1H\>#U UaDWM?b /\���'� OQ@BHK>18/J1@B[ � �$VW<E_hVlUNO _`Ua8/Jh[#@Nm'OQ8/JL>1V/@^J�J1@BAI8W_`@B[.>1V/@AW< [1_`JL<E:=< DWHK>1<?UaD 9P@^> �.@^@BDG>1V/@

HNM?J1@BHNAWb�U jN@^JLMEHKFIFI<ED/] >#UNFI<E_�_^MEHN[1[#@B[�� ��HK>18/JLHNMEM?bNm&DWUaD/@lUNO�>1VW@ j'<E[18WHNM <E[1HK>1<?UaD�UNJY_^ME8I[#>#@^JL<ED/],:Y@^>1V/U'AW[

A/@BHNME< D/] �$<?>1V < � < � A��iAWHK>1H _^HND AI<E[1_`JL<E:l<EDWHK>#@Y9P@^> �.@^@BD _^MEHN[1[#@B[��$VW<E_hV HKJL@�D/UN> [#@^FIHKJhHK9IM?@!�!�<?]�� / �Ep �

[1V/U �$[\J1@^FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaDW[\UN9W>1HN<EDW@BAr97b�OgUa8WJ*@� /<E[#>1<ED/] j7< [18WHNME<E[LHK>1<?UaD�HNM?]NUNJL<?>1VI:=[4OQUNJY< � < � A��CAWHK>1H��,��V/@

J1@B[18IM?>*UNO0>1V/@�OQUaMEM?U �<ED/] :=@^>1V/U7AI[\_^HND 9P@�[#@^@BD UaD >1VW<E[*RI]a8/J1@!/iq�p t*j'<E[18WHNME< [1HK>1<?UaD�UaD >1V/@ RIJL[#>\> �.U

���/� H� '< [^meq nat >1V/@ �/HN:=:YUaD :=HKFWFI< D/] �Sp.-C� �=q �at >1VW@ �)��� � nKo��*HNDIA(q<-Zt�H J1@B_`@BDZ>1M?b A/@^jN@BM?UNFP@BA

HNM?]NUNJL<E>1VW: OQUNJl>#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVW< _GJ1@^FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaDW[Bm.>1VW@d� U'_^HNM$��<ED/@BHKJ=��:\9P@BAWAW<EDW]6qs������te9Zbc�'HN8IM�HNDWA

�U ��@B< [ �Sp.-2- � ���.@B[1< A/@B[0>1V/@4���'��FWJLU���@B_`>1<?UaD mW>1V/@)FIHKJLHN:=@^>#@^JL[ �.@^J1@4@� 'F @^Jh<E:Y@BDZ>1HNMEM?bl_hV/Ua[#@BDd< D >1VW@B[#@

HNM?]NUNJL<E>1VW:=[�<EDYUNJhA/@^J&>#U4UN9W>1HN< DY>1V/@�9P@B[#>�j'<E[18WHNM <E[1HK>1<?UaDeFIM?UN>1[ ����[�@� 'FP@B_`>#@BAfmZ<?>&_^HNDl9P@�[#@^@BD=>1VWHK>�D/UaD/@

UNO0>1V/@B[#@GHNM?]NUNJL<E>1VW:=[*_^HND FWJ1U'AW8W_`@ HdJ1@^FIJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaD �VW<E_LV _`Ua8WMEA :Y@BHNDW<ED/]NOs8WMEMEb AW<E[1>1<ED/]a8W<E[LV >1VW@B[#@

>1V/J1@^@l>#UNFI<E_^[��l�$VW<E[)<E[)9P@B_^HN8W[1@=@BHN_LV <EDWAW<Ej7<EAI8WHNM�:Y@B[L[1HK]N@ <E[�JL@^]aHKJLA/@BArHNDIA�J1@^FWJ1@B[1@BDT>#@BA [#@^FIHKJLHK>#@BM?b

97bl>1V/@B[#@4HNME]NUNJL<?>1VW:=[Bm7HN[0>1VW@�>#@B:=F UNJhHNM;UNJhA/@^JL<ED/]Cqs_`UaDZ>#@� 7>ht�A/UZ@B[0DWUN>�:lH �N@4HNDTbGAW< �P@^J1@BDW_`@�OQUNJ.>1VW@B[#@

HNM?]NUNJL<E>1VW:=[�����D UN>1VW@^J ��UNJLAI[^m/<?O >1V/@�OQ@BHK>18/J1@�jN@B_`>#UNJL[0UNO�> �.Ul:Y@B[1[1HK]N@B[0HKJL@4[1<E:=<EM HKJ�<ED OgUNJh: UNJ.F;MEHN_`@BA

HK>�H[1:lHNMEMTAW< [#>1HNDW_`@�<ED4>1V/@�AWHK>1H�[#FIHN_`@)qs��8W_^M <EA/@BHND*AI<E[#>1HNDW_`@B[�VWHBjN@�9P@^@BDe_`UaDW[1<EA/@^JL@BA\V/@^JL@NmKHN[�>1V/@.���'�

OQ@BHK>18/J1@B[4HKJ1@YJL@BHNM�j HNM 8/@BA;t$>1V/@BD�>1V/@^b HKJ1@=:=HKFIF @BA�_^MEUa[#@Y>#UC@BHN_LV UN>1V/@^JBm JL@^]aHKJLAWM?@B[1[�UNO.>1V/@Y9WJLUaHNA/@^J

>#UNFI<E_^HNM�_`UaDT>#@� '>eUNO.>1VW@lAW<E[1_^8I[1[1<?UaD�[#>#JL@BHN: U jN@^J >1<E:=@!� �FWFIM?b'<ED/]CH � �)��� ��V/J1Ua8/]aVr��<E:Y@ � � nNn ��<E[

<E:YFIJLHN_`>1<E_^HNM�AW8/@e>#UC>1V/@\U jN@^J#RI>#>1<EDW]CFWJ1UN9IM?@B: � :YUNJ1@^U jN@^JBm�HG[1<E:YF;M?@\��� � VWHBj'<ED/]GUaDWMEb � VI<EAWA/@BD

[#>1HK>#@B[ qs< � @!���=>#JLHNDW[1<E>1<?UaDGFWJ1UN9IHK9;<EME<?>1<?@B[�>#Ul@B[1>1<E:=HK>#@ t0VIHN[�9P@^@BDCOQUa8WDWAG>#U _`UaDZjN@^J1]N@e>#Ul[#FI8WJL<?Ua8W[0M?U'_^HNM

UNFW>1<E:lHY<EDC:YUa[#>�UNO�>1V/@4JL@��k<EDW<?>1<EHNM < %^@BAlJh8WDW[��

��D >18/JLDfm !�<?]�� / � n � FIM?UN>1[e>1V/@G>#JLH �#@B_`>#UNJ1b UNO�>1V/@GFPUa[#>#@^JL<?UNJY:Y@BHNDW[ UN9I>1HN<ED/@BA 9Zbr>1V/@GFWJ1UNFPUa[#@BA

>#@B:YFPUNJLHNM�j'<E[18WHNM <E[1HK>1<?UaD :YU7AW@BM � ��[Y<E[ _^M?@BHKJYOQJ1Ua: <?>1[ OQUNJL:=HNM0A/@B[1_`Jh<?FW>1<?UaDfm �$VI<EM?@�>1VW<E[ :YU'A/@BM�HNME[#U

FIH b7[HK>#>#@BDT>1<?UaD >#Ul@BHN_hV < DWAW<?j'<EAW8WHNM;AWHK>18W: FPUa<EDZ>0>1V/J1Ua8W]aVi>1V/@4@B:l<E[1[1<?UaDGFIJ1UN9IHK9I<EM <?>1<?@B[^m'HK>�>1V/@e[1HN:Y@

>1<E:Y@ <?> � �.HK>1_hV/@B[��f>1V/@eOQ8IMSR;MEME:=@BDT>0UNO�_`UaVW@^J1@BDW_`@Y<ED >1<E:Y@!����VWHK>�<E[^m @^jN@BD�<?O�> �.UC:Y@B[1[1HK]N@B[�@!� ]���OQJ1Ua:

Ff_ �kVWHKJLA���HKJ1@dHNDIAc:=HN_ �kVWHKJhA��.HKJL@ HKJ1@ijN@^JLb [1<E:=<EM HKJBm�>1V/@^b :lHBb6]N@^> :lHKFWFP@BAc<ED [LME<?]aVZ>1M?b AW< � @^J1@BDZ>

M?U'_^HK>1<?UaDW[HN_^_`UNJLAW<ED/] >#Ul>1V/@\>#UNFI<E_^HNM�_`UaDT>#@� '>�U jN@^J�>1<E:Y@Gqs< � @!�0UN>1V/@^J�:Y@B[1[1HK]N@B[�HKJ1Ua8WDIAi<EDi>1< :Y@ t�>1V/@^b

U'_^_^8/J ����DCUN>1V/@^J ��UNJhAW[^mI<?O�H=:Y@B[L[1HK]N@*UNO�]N@BD/@^JLHNM�_`UaDT>#@BDZ>�HK9 Ua8W>�_`Ua:YFI8/>#@^J�VWHKJLA���HKJ1@4U'_^_^8/JL[�< DC>1V/@

� �

Page 111: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

:=<EAIAWM?@*UNO.HCAW<E[1_^8I[1[1<?UaD HK9 Ua8W>�!�"�[�>1V/@BD�<?> �$<EM M�9P@eJ1@^FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>#@BA <ED,AW< �P@^J1@BDZ>)M?U7_^HK>1<EUaD >1VWHND�<ED,>1V/@

_^HN[#@YUNO&U'_^_^8/J1JL@BDW_`@YHN:YUaD/]a[#>):Y@B[1[LHK]N@B[4HK9PUa8/>�:lHN_��'<EDT>#Ua[LV��)� >)_^HND 9P@\[1@^@BD UaD !�<?]���/ � n �\>1VWHK>�>1V/@

>1V/J1@^@�>#UNFI< _�JL@^]a<E:Y@B[�<EDWV/@^JL@BDT>�<ED\>1V/@0AWHK>1H�HKJ1@�D/U �6DW< _`@BM?b4J1@��I@B_`>#@BAYHNDIAeH�:Y@BHNDI<ED/]NOs8WMT>#UNFPUN]NJLHKF;VW<E_^HNM

J1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>1HK>1<EUaDCUNO�>1V/@*:Y@B[1[LHK]N@B[$VWHN[09P@^@BDi< DWAW8W_`@BA��

�UN>#@ HNME[1Ui>1VWHK>4>1V/@Y>1< :Y@��k_`UaV/@^J1@BDW_`@�HN[1[18W:=FW>1<?UaD�A/U7@B[4D/UN>4@� /_^ME8WAW@=HK9WJL8/FW>4_hVWHND/]N@B[*UNO.>#UNF;<E_^[��

��V/@)HN[1[L8W:YFW>1<?UaDG_`UaDW_`@^JhDW[0UaDWM?b >1V/@�@� '< [#>#@BDW_`@4UNO�>1<E:Y@4[#@^]a:Y@BDZ>1[ �$<E>1V/Ua8/>0HK9WJL8/FI>._hVWHND/]N@B[^mI< � @!�&>1V/@

@� /<E[#>#@BDW_`@\UNO&Hl[1<?]aDI<SR;_^HNDZ>1M?b�[L:=HNMEM?@^J�HN:YUa8WDZ>$UNO&AW<E[L_`UaDT>1<ED78W<?>1<E@B[0<EDd_`Ua:YF;HKJL<E[#UaDd>#Ul>1V/@e[#@^]a:Y@BDZ>1[UNO

>#UNFI<E_^HNM M?b,_`UaDZ>1<ED78/Ua8W[*@^jNUaME8/>1<?UaD��G��D�>1V/@�HK9 U jN@l@� /HN:YFIM?@Nm�>1V/@�_LVWHND/]N@ OgJLUa: >1V/@�_`Ua:YFI8/>#@^J�� JL@BMEHK>#@BA

>#UNFI<E_4>#Ul:Y@BAW<E_^< D/@)<E[�HK9WJL8WFW>��&��V/@4HNM?]NUNJh<?>1VW: HNAWHKFI>1[�XZ8I<E_��'M?b�>#Ul[18W_hVi_LVWHNDW]N@B[�/�UaDdHip^o p^ol]NJL<EAfm

HY:=H� /<E:e8W: p^o � [#>#@^FI[ ��qs:Y@B[1[1HK]N@B[ht �$<EMEM;9P@ � [1HN_`JL<SRI@BA �W<ED�J1@BHN_LVW< D/]YUaD/@*_`UNJLDW@^J0UNO�>1V/@*]NJL<EA�OgJLUa: >1V/@

UNFWFPUa[1<?>#@�UaD/@NmZ@^jN@BDl<?O;>1V/@�[1:=HNM M?@B[#>�FPUa[1[1<?9;M?@�D/@B<E]aVT9PUNJLV/U7U'Ae< [�_`UaDW[1<EA/@^JL@BA�� ��@BD/@^JLHNMEM?beV/U �.@^jN@^J�:\8W_hV

OQ@���@^J.:Y@B[1[1HK]N@�<EDW[#>1HNDW_`@B[ �$<EMEM79P@�:=HKFWFP@BA � UaD=>1VW@ �.H b �TOgJ1Ua: UaD/@0J1@^]a<?UaDl>#U*HND/UN>1V/@^J mZHN[�_^HNDl9P@�[#@^@BD

<EDG>1V/@4RI]a8/J1@!�

��D�!�<?]�� / ���7m&>#@BD D/@��$[1]NJ1Ua8/F AI<E[1_^8W[1[L<?UaD _^MEHN[1[1@B[eHKJL@ j'<E[18WHNM <E[#@BA�97b�>1V/@�FWJ1UNFPUa[#@BA HNM?]NUNJL<?>1VW: q

�$VW< _LVl< [&UN97j7<?Ua8I[1M?bYHND=@^jN@BDG:YUNJ1@�AW<�� _^8IM?>�>1HN[��=>1VWHND >1V/@UaD/@$FWJL@B[#@BDT>#@BA @BHKJLME<E@^JBmZHN[�<?>�_`UaDZ>1HN<EDW[.[#@^j �

@^JLHNM�U jN@^JLMEHKFIFI<ED/]=AW< [1_^8W[1[1<EUaDG>#UNFI<E_^[�HK9PUa8/>$_`Ua:=FI8/>#@^J�� J1@BM HK>#@BA [18W9���@B_`>1[ ����HN_hV _^M HN[1[$_`UaDZ>1HN<ED/@BA p^oNoNo

_`UaDW[#@B_^8W>1<?jN@4:Y@B[1[1HK]N@��kAWU7_^8W:=@BDT>1[�HNDIA�HK]aHN< Dfm'@BHN_LVi:Y@B[L[1HK]N@4VWHN[�9P@^@BDG_`UaDW[1<EA/@^JL@BA UaDW@�AIHK>18W: F Ua< DT>

HK>�H�]a<?jN@BD=>1<E:Y@0FPUa<EDZ>�����VW@�RIJL[#>0p^o4���'� OQ@BHK>18/J1@B[�UNO HND=< DW<?>1<EHNMZ9I<EDWHKJLb4�@B_`>#UNJ0�'FIHN_`@�_`U7AI<ED/]�OgUNJh:Y@BA

>1V/@ <ED/FI8W>$[#@BX78/@BDW_`@eUNO&>1V/@ HNM?]NUNJL<?>1VW: ���V/@e>#JLH �#@B_`>#UNJL<?@B[)HKJ1@ D/U �(DWUN>>#JLHN_`@BA,OQUNJ�>1V/@e[LH �N@eUNO�_^MEHKJ��

<?> b!����VW@\_^MEHN[1[1@B[$UNO�AI<E[1_^8W[1[L<?UaDW[ �.@^J1@e>1V/@*OQUaMEM?U �$<ED/]�/ � HNM?>�� HK>1V/@B< [1:"�?m � _`Ua:YF�� ]NJLHKF;VW<E_^[��?m � _`Ua:YF�� Ua[�� :l[ �

�$<EDIA/U �$[ � :=<E[1_ �?m � _`Ua:YF�� [1b7[�� <E9I:�� Ff_ � VWHKJLA���HKJ1@ �?m � _`Ua:YF�� [1b7[�� :lHN_ � VWHKJLA���HKJ1@ �?m � _`Ua:=F�� �$<EDWAWU �$[�� �?m

� :=<E[L_ � OgUNJL[LHNM?@ �?m � [L_^< � @BM?@B_`>#J1UaDW< _^[��?m � [1_^< � :Y@BA(�7HNDWA � [1_^< � [#FIHN_`@ � ����V/@M HK>#@BDT>.>#JLHN<?>�:YU'A/@BMWOQUNJ.[1>1HK>1<E_�_`UaMEM?@B_ �

>1<?UaDW[Bm���UNJ��7<EDW]CUaDrHCJLHNDIA/Ua:=M?b UNJLA/@^J1@BA�jN@^Jh[1<?UaD�UNO.>1VW<E[4AIHK>1HCUaDrHi[LHN:Y@=J1@B[#UaM 8/>1<?UaD UNO.>1V/@lMEHK>#@BDZ>

]NJL<EAGFIJ1U7AI8W_`@BA�� HN[0@� 'F @B_`>#@BA"� @� '>#J1@B:Y@BM?b�FPUZUNJ0J1@^FIJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaDW[^mWD/UN>$]a<?jN@BDiV/@^J1@!�&�U �.@^jN@^JBm >1V/@

<E:=HK]N@ UN9W>1HN< D/@BA �<?>1Vd>1VW@eFIJ1UNFPUa[#@BA :=U7A/@BM�[1V/U �$[�HK]aHN<ED�H�:Y@BHNDW<ED/]NOs8WM�>#UNF UN]NJhHKFIVW<E_\UNJ1]aHNDW<E[LHK>1<?UaD��

��V/@ :YUa[#>eJ1@BMEHK>#@BA >#UNFI<E_^[^m�>1V/@ _`Ua:=FI8/>#@^JeJ1@BMEHK>#@BA FP_ �kVIHKJLA���HKJ1@ HNDWA :=HN_^<EDZ>#Ua[1V��kVWHKJhA��.HKJL@ [1VWHKJL@ H

OsHN<?J$HN:YUa8WDZ>�UNO�U jN@^JhMEHKF,< DG>1VW<E[�_`Ua:YF;M?@� G[1@^>#>1<ED/]/mI>1VW@4UN>1V/@^J_`Ua:=FI8/>#@^J�� J1@BM HK>#@BAd[18/9���@B_`>1[�HKJL@\_^M?@BHKJLMEb

:=HKFWFP@BAi_^MEUa[#@^J>#U @BHN_LV,UN>1V/@^JBm �$VW< M?@)[#Ua:Y@*UNO�>1VW@\AW<E[1>1<EDW_`>0>#UNFI<E_^[Bm;[18W_hVdHN[>1V/@*UaDW@\HK9PUa8/>$HK>1V/@B< [1:

UNJ0>1V/@4[1_^<E@BDT>1<SR _:Y@B[L[1HK]N@B[�_`UaDW_`@^JLDI<ED/]Y[#FIHN_`@4HKJ1@4:=UNJ1@)AW<E[#>1<EDI_`>�UaDG>1V/@�FIMEUN>���� >0:=H b�HNME[1Ue9P@ �.UNJ1>1V

D/UN>1<EDW]l>1VWHK>)8W[18IHNMEM?bGHljN@^J1b Og@�� q � � /at���� <?>#@^JLHK>1<?UaDW[�HKJ1@ [18 � _^<E@BDT>>#U�UN9I>1HN<ED H ]NU7U7A X78WHNME<?> bi[#>1<EMEM

p^oNo

Page 112: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

<E:=HK]N@�UNO�>1V/@)FPUa[#>#@^JL<?UNJ�:Y@BHNDW[�����b ]NUZU'ACX78WHNME<?> b ��@):Y@BHNDG>1VIHK>�AW<E[#>1<EDI_`>�>#UNFI<E_^[0HKJL@ �.@BMEMP[#@^FIHKJhHK>#@BA

UaD >1V/@=<E:lHK]N@=HNDWA�_`UaDT>#@� '>4jN@B_`>#UNJL[*>1HNM �'<ED/]CHK9PUa8/>�>1V/@=[1HN:Y@ >#UNFI<E_^[*HKJ1@=_^ME8W:YFP@BA >#UN]N@^>1V/@^J � � <?>1V

Os8/J1>1V/@^J)<?>#@^JLHK>1<EUaDW[�>1V/@ FPUa[#>#@^JL<?UNJL[�]N@^>4[LVWHKJ1FP@BD/@BA� HN[4:YUNJ1@Y_`@^J1>1HN< DT> b HK9PUa8/>�>1V/@Y<EAW@BDT>1<?> bdUNO.>1V/@

MEHK>#@BDZ>l>#UNFI< _^[l<E[ HN_LVW<?@^jN@BA�� !WUNJ @� /HN:YFIM?@Nm�>1V/@,<E:=HK]N@iUaD !�<?]���/ �Ep ��HN[ FWJ1U'AW8W_`@BA6HKOQ>#@^J >1V/JL@^@ ���

<?>#@^JLHK>1<EUaDW[�� !�<?]���/ � n ��OQUNJ�>1V/@\D/@� 7>$@� 7FP@^JL<E:=@BDT> ��HN[�FIM?UN>#>#@BAdHKOg>#@^J$RIOg>#@^@BDd��� [#>#@^FI[��

��Ur<EMEM 8W[#>#JLHK>#@C>1VWHK>l>1V/@i>1<E:Y@ _`UaV/@^J1@BDW_`@,<E[=<EDWAW@^@BA6[18 � _^<?@BDZ>Y>#U ME@BHKJLD H MEHK>#@BDZ>l>#UNFPUN]NJLHKF;VW<E_^HNM

[#>#JL8I_`>18/J1@Nm���@)[1VWU � >1VWHK>0_^HK>#@^]NUNJL<?@B[ �$VW<E_hV �.@^J1@�UN9I[#@^JLjN@BAGFWJ1@^j'<?Ua8W[1M?b=< Dl>1<E:=@Nm'<EO >1V/@^blFP@^JL[L<E[#>�OQUNJ�H

[18 ��_^<?@BDT>FP@^JL<?U'Afm;[1VWUa8WMEAi9P@\J1@B_`UN]aDW< %^@BA qs< � @!��>1V/@^b ]N@^>�:lHKFWFP@BAi>#UG>1V/@ [1HN:Y@eJ1@^]a<?UaD HN[�>1V/@^b �.@^J1@

:=HKFWFP@BA HK>)>1V/@ RIJh[#>�HKFIF @BHKJhHNDW_`@ t � !�<E]���/ �1-d[1V/U �$[�>1V/@ Ua8/>1_`Ua:Y@=UNO�[18W_hV�HND @� 7FP@^JL< :Y@BDT>^m 8W>1<EME< %B<EDW]

- AW<E[#>1<EDI_`>=_^MEHN[1[#@B[ UNO*AW<E[L_^8W[1[1<?UaDI[ OgJ1Ua: >1V/@,[1HN:Y@ _`UNJLFI8W[�/ � [1_^< � _`JLbZFW>��?m � [L_^< � [#FIHN_`@ �?m � [1_^< � :Y@BA(�.HNDWA

� [#U'_ � J1@BME<?]a<EUaD�� _LV/Jh<E[#>1<EHND(� ��!/Ua8/J����'� OQ@BHK>18/J1@B[�VWHBjN@e9P@^@BDd8W[1@BA��.�$V/@*_`UaDZ>#@� 7>�jN@B_`>#UNJL[ �.@^J1@\HKJ1JhHND/]N@BA

[18W_hVd>1VIHK>$>1V/@*RIJL[#>�>#UNF;<E_4FP@^JL[1< [#>#@BAi<EDd>1V/@4RIJh[#>*p^oNo >1<E:Y@4FPUa[1<?>1<EUaDW[^mW9I8W>$HNME[#U�<EDCFPUa[1<?>1<?UaDI[�DZ8I:*9P@^J

0Ko/p�q,4 oNo'm >1V/@e[#@B_`UaDWA >#UNFI<E_��.HN[FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>�<EDC>1V/@eFPUa[1<?>1<?UaDW[)p^o/p�q7nKoNodHNDWA /Ko/p�q 0KoNoCHNDWA,[#U UaD"� >1V/@

UNJLA/@^Jh<ED/] UNO�>1VW@4>#UNFI<E_^[0JL@^FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>#@BAC97b >1V/@ p^oNo��k[1HN:YFIM?@*9I<EDW[���HN[$_LVWUa[#@BDC>#U=9P@4AW< �P@^J1@BDZ>0OgJLUa: >1VWHK>

UNOP>1V/@0RIJh[#>&FWJ1@B[1@BDT>1HK>1<?UaD mZHN[&>1VI<E[&_`Ua8WMEA=@BHN[1<EM?be9P@�>1V/@$_^HN[#@�<EDY[#Ua:Y@J1@BHNMWFIJLHN_`>1<E_^HNMW[1<E>18WHK>1<?UaDW[����.b=<?>1[

_`UaDW[#>#Jh8W_`>1<?UaD,>1V/@Y:YU'A/@BM�HNDIA >1VW@ HN[L[#U7_^< HK>#@BA�HNM?]NUNJL<?>1VW: <E[�D/UN>)[#@BDW[L<?>1<?jN@e>#U�>1VI<E[ � :lHN_`J1U � UNJLA/@^JL< D/] �?m

< � @!�\>#U�>1VW@YUNJLA/@^J�UNO�HKFWFP@BHKJLHNDI_`@eUNO.>1V/@ >#UNFI<E_^[ �*��V/@Y:YU'A/@BM �.HN[�>#JhHN<ED/@BA,UaDWM?biUaD >1VW@ RIJL[#>�VWHNM?O&UNO

>1VW<E[�AWHK>1H'mI>1V/@)[#@B_`UaDWAiVWHNMEO�_`UaDT>1HN< DW<ED/] J1@��kHKFWFP@BHKJLHNDI_`@B[0UNO�>1VW@�>#UNF;<E_^[ �.HN[$8/>1<EME< %^@BA�HN[0>#@B[#>�AIHK>1H=HNDWA

>1V/@eUNJLA/@^J�UNO&>1V/@e>#UNFI<E_^[ ��HN[�_LV/Ua[#@BD >#U�9P@eAI< � @^JL@BDT>OgJ1Ua: >1VWHK>�<ED >1V/@e>#JLHN<EDW<EDW]l[#@BX78/@BDW_`@!����@=_^HND

[#@^@�OgJLUa: >1V/@ F Ua[1>#@^JL<?UNJ\:=@BHND :=HKFIFI<ED/]i>1VIHK>\<EDWAW@^@BAr[#Ua:Y@ >#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVW<E_^HNM�J1@BMEHK>1<?UaDI[ �.@^J1@�ME@BHKJLD/@BA

HNDWAY>1VW@B[#@$OQUNJL_`@BAY>1V/@$F Ua[1>#@^JL<?UNJ�:Y@BHNDl>#JLH �#@B_`>#UNJ1bY>#U*>1H �N@�[#>#@^FI[&>#U �.HKJhAW[�>1VW@�J1@^]a<?UaD �V/@^J1@�<EDW[1>1HNDW_`@B[

OQJ1Ua: >1V/@lRIJL[#>4HKFIF @BHKJhHNDW_`@lUNO�>1V/@�[1HN:Y@ _^HK>#@^]NUNJLb ��@^JL@ :=HKFWFP@BAfm.�$V/@BD/@^jN@^JeHd[��<?>1_LVW< D/]C9P@^> �.@^@BD

>1V/@$_^M HN[1[#@B[�U'_^_^8/J1J1@BAl<ED >1V/@$AWHK>1H�����[&@� 'FP@B_`>#@BAfmT>1V/@�:lHN_`J1U �kA/b'DWHN:=<E_^[�UNOP>1V/@$FWJ1U'_`@B[1[^mT< � @!��>1V/@0UNJhA/@^J

UNO�[18W_^_`@B[1[L<?UaDGUNO�>1V/@)>#UNFI<E_^[VWHN[�D/U=<ED �;8/@BDW_`@�UaDC>1V/@\HNM?]NUNJL<?>1VW: �

��HK>18/JLHNMEMEbNm HN[�>1V/@Y_`UaV/@^J1@BDZ>*[#@^]a:Y@BDZ>1[)]N@^>4[1V/UNJL>#@^JBmf>1V/@ >#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVW<E_^HNM�_^HKF;HK9I<EME<?>1<E@B[$UNO�>1V/@ FWJ1U �

FPUa[#@BAd:=U7A/@BM�HKJ1@��.@BH �N@BD/@BA��0��Di>1V/@*@� 7>#J1@B:=@e_^HN[#@Nm �$V/@BDi>1V/@\[1HN:=FIM?@B[�HKJ1@\FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>#@BA,<EDiH=JhHNDWA/Ua:

UNJLA/@^J mW>1V/@BDCUNO&_`Ua8/Jh[#@NmID/Ul:=@BHNDW<ED/]NOs8WMPJ1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>1HK>1<EUaD �$<EM M;>1H �N@\FIMEHN_`@!���'8W_hViHNDi@� /HN:YFIM?@\<E[�[1V/U �$D

<ED !�<?]�� / ��/ �0��VW<E[$HNM?]NUNJL<?>1VW: <E[�D/UN>�[18W<?>1HK9IME@�OQUNJ_hV/UNFWF7bCFWJ1U'_`@B[1[#@B[HNDWAi<?O�D/Ul>#@B:=F UNJhHNMfUNJLA/@^JL< D/]=<E[

FWJ1@B[1@BDT>�<EDG>1VW@4AWHK>1HY>1V/@BDC:Y@^>1VWU7AW[�OgUNJ�< � < � A���AWHK>1H=HKJ1@*< D UNJhA/@^J �&�U �.@^jN@^JBm <EO�>1V/@4AWHK>1Hl<E[0[18W_hVG>1VWHK>

<?>�_`UaDZ>1HN<EDW[&_`UaDZ>1<ED78/Ua8W[&[#@^]a:=@BDT>1[�9;8/>�[��$<?>1_hV/@B[&HKJ1@0OQJ1@BX78/@BDT>�>1VW@BDY[18/9��k[1HN:=FIME<ED/]�_`Ua8WMEA 9P@�@B:YFIM?U bN@BA

p^o/p

Page 113: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

>#UlUN9I>1HN<ED :=UNJ1@4@� '>#@BDWA/@BA,V/Ua:YUN]N@BD/@^Ua8W[�[#@^]a:=@BDT>1[�����M?>#@^JLDIHK>1<?jN@BM?bNmI>1VW@\[1:YU7UN>1VW<EDW]l_`Ua8WMEAd9 @\HN<EA/@BA

97biHNDTbC>#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVI<E_^HNM FWJh<EDW_^<?FIME@�OQUNJ�< � < � A��0AWHK>1H � @!� ]��$9Zbi8/>1< ME< %B<ED/]Y@BX78WHK>1<?UaD q / ��/at<EDW[#>#@BHNA UNO�>1V/@

:YUNJ1@e[1<E:YF;M?@4@BX78WHK>1<?UaD q / � 4Nt$HN[>1V/@e@B:=<E[1[L<?UaDCFWJ1UN9;HK9I<EME<?>1<E@B[0<EDi>1V/@e:YU'A/@BM�q �$VI<E_LV UNO&_`Ua8/JL[#@Nm �.Ua8WMEA

_LVIHND/]N@�>1V/@�[L<E:YFIM?@�� �k[#>#@^Fi8/FfAWHK>#@OgUNJh:\8WM H q �at&>#Ue>1VW@ ���$� UNJ�>#JhHN<?> �k:YU'A/@BM;8WFPAIHK>#@!� t\� D�HNDTb _^HN[#@Nm

R /<ED/])>1V/@>#JLHNDW[1<E>1<?UaDYFWJ1UN9;HK9I<EME<?>1<E@B[�J1@B:=HN<EDW[�A/@B[1<?J1Ua8I[&<ED=HN:Y@BM <?UNJLHK>1<ED/]*>1V/@$FWJLUN9IM?@B: UNO M?U'_^HNMWUNFI>1<E:=H��

��� � �=�� 6 8 � - !?&:+ � - �<�?> & � � & � � # - - � ( �

��D HN_`>18IHNM.HKFIFIME<E_^HK>1<?UaDr<E[*FIJ1@B[#@BDZ>#@BA <EDr>1V/@GD/@� 7>\@� 'HN:=FIM?@!�d��VW@ AWHK>1H,_`UaDW[1<E[1>1[*UNO�H,_LVWHK> �kM <ED/@

AW<E[L_^8W[1[1<?UaD [#>#JL@BHN: �!�C�/8W_LV�@^jNUaMEj7<EDW]C>#@� 7>eAWHK>1Hd<E[4FWJ1U'AW8W_`@BA�<ED���DZ>#@^JLD/@^>4J1@BM HBb�_LVWHK>\J1U7Ua:=[^m �V/@^J1@>1V/@GFIHKJ1>1< _^<?FIHNDZ>1[\AW< [1_^8W[1[eAWHN<EM?b DW@��$[ HNDWA >1V/@G>#UNFI<E_�_LVWHND/]N@B[=U jN@^JY>1<E:Y@!� �$V/@GJLH � AWHK>1H _`UaDW[1< [#>1[

UNO�H�[#>#J1@BHN: UNO �.UNJLAW[Bm �$VI<E_LV,_^HND,9 @eHNDWHNM?b %^@BA,9Zbd_`UaDI[1<EA/@^JL< D/]=>1V/@ _`UaDT>#@BDZ>�UNO�_`UaDW[1@B_^8/>1<?jN@NmPFPUa[1[1< �

9IM?@YU jN@^JLMEHKFWF;<ED/]i>1<E:=@�� �$<EDWA/U �$[lqs_`UaDZ>#@� 7>1[ t �i� �$<EDWA/U � [1< %^@lUNO �KoNo,_LVIHKJLHN_`>#@^JL[ �$<?>1V 4 /�� U jN@^JLM HKF

9P@^> �.@^@BD�_`UaDW[#@B_^8/>1<EjN@ �$<EDWA/U �$[�VWHN[�9P@^@BD @B:=FIM?U bN@BA�< Dd>1VW< [@� /HN:YFIME@\>#UiHN<EA _`UaDZ>1<ED78W<?>kb!�\��V/@e>1<E:Y@

�$<EDIA/U �$[�_`UaDZ>1HN<EDW<EDW]�>1VW@ _hVWHK>*:YU'A/@^JLHK>#UNJh[��f_`UaDT>#JL<E9I8/>1<?UaDW[ �.@^J1@YJ1@B:YU jN@BA OQJ1Ua: >1V/@=AWHK>1H'm FIJL<?UNJ�>#U

@BDZ>#@^JL<ED/]*< DT>#U)>1V/@HNM?]NUNJL<?>1VW:imTHN[�<?>�9WJ1@BH �'[�>1V/@$_`UaDZ>1<ED78W<?>kb UNOP>1V/@$AI<E[1_^8W[1[L<?UaD [#>#J1@BHN:��&��VI<E[�UNF @^JhHK>1<?UaD

<E[=[1>#JLHN<?]aVZ>#OgUNJ���HKJLA6>#U A/UrHN[l>1V/@dDWHN:Y@B[=UNO�_`UaDZ>#JL<?9;8/>#UNJL[=HKJ1@,HBjKHN<EMEHK9IME@i<ED >1V/@iJLH � 8WD�� FWJ1U'_`@B[1[#@BA

AW<E[L_^8W[1[1<?UaDG[#>#JL@BHN:�� !W8/JL>1V/@^JBm/UaDWM?b�>1V/@�RIJh[#>0OgUa8WJ����'� Og@BHK>18WJ1@B[ �.@^J1@*8/>1< ME< %^@BA��

��VW@�_hVWHK>=AWHK>1H _`UaDW[1<E[1>1[\UNO�[#@^jN@^JLHNM m�[#Ua:Y@^>1<E:Y@B[Y[1>#J1UaD/]aM?b U jN@^JLMEHKFWF;<ED/]dJL@^]a<E:Y@B[iqQ>#UNFI<E_^[eUNO�AW<E[ �

_^8W[1[L<?UaD;t HNDWAc<ED _`UaDZ>#JLHN[#>�>#U [#Ua:Y@ UNO)>1V/@dHKJ1>1<?R;_^<EHNM0@� /HN:YFIM?@B[Bm.>1VW@B[#@ :=H b6J1@��kHKFWFP@BHKJlU jN@^JG>1<E:Y@Nm

FPUa[1[1<?9;M?b=<EDGAW< �P@^J1@BDZ>�_`UaDZ>#@� '>1[�����DCHN:YUa8WDZ>0UNO�AW< [1_`UaDT>1< DZ8W<E>kbl<E[0< D/@^j7<E>1HK9IM?bYFWJ1@B[1@BDT>�<ED�>1VW< [.AIHK>1H'mIHN[

[#Ua:Y@eUNO&>1V/@ FIHKJL>1<E_^<?FIHNDZ>1[$>#@BDIAd>#UCAW<E[L_^8W[1[�>1VW@B<?JU �$D,>#UNFI<E_ ����V78W[^m >1VW<E[�[#@^>#>1<ED/]G<E[UN9Zj'<?Ua8W[1MEbi:YUNJ1@

AW<���_^8WM?>�HNDWA UNO�<EDZ>#@^J1@B[#>.>#UY[#>18WA/bY>1VW@9P@BVWH j7<?UNJ.UNO Ua8/J�HNM?]NUNJL<E>1VW: UaD�>1VW< [�AWHK>1H��&�$V/@>#UNFPUN]NJLHKF;VW<E_^HNM

J1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>1HK>1<EUaD�UNO�[18I_LV�_LVIHK>*ME<ED/@ AW<E[L_^8W[1[1<?UaDI[�OQUNJ)OQ8/JL>1V/@^J4[#@BHKJL_hVW<ED/]CHNDWA J1@^>#Jh<?@^j HNM�FI8WJ1FPUa[#@B[�_`Ua8WMEA

9P@$UNO�< DT>#@^J1@B[1>�OQUNJ�>1VWUa[#@ �V/U\[#>18IA/bY>1V/@�@^jNUaME8/>1<?UaD UNO FI8/9;ME<E_�UNFI<EDI<?UaD=UNJ.@!� ]��&OQUNJ�:lHKJ��N@^>1<ED/]eHNDWHNM?b'[1<E[

FI8/JLF Ua[1@B[�����>1V/@^J�[1< :=<EMEHKJ&HKFWF;ME<E_^HK>1<?UaDW[�< D ".Ua:YFI8W>#@^J��'8/FIF UNJL>#@BA ".U7UNF @^JhHK>1<?jN@���UNJ��YUNJ�<ED �$VIHK>#@^jN@^J

_^HN[#@ �$V/@BDY>1VW@_`Ua:YFI8W>#@^J.HN_`>1[.HN[�H\:Y@BAW<EHK>#UNJ �10 ��� HN:=UaD/]a[#>�AI<?jN@^JL[#@�F;HKJ1>1<E_^<?FIHNDZ>1[ �V/U49WJL< D/])j HKJh<?Ua8W[

HKJ1]a8W:=@BDT>1[=HNDIA ��UNJ�� >#UN]N@^>1V/@^J�>#U ��HKJLAW[l>1H �7< D/] H�_`Ua:=:YUaD�A/@B_^<E[1<?UaD OQUNJ=@� /HN:YFIM?@Nm�<E[Y_`UaDW[1< A/@^J1@BA" �L"<�L� "81� 5D#1� 1;:C1��5���*�������( ��4D �-������<�������(�����4D�?�� ����I�7+,��)#.; �"#�&�6 ��*�<T :P�/� D<� 1�)8D �"#�&���*)� �����?#A ��/���Z)#1/I���51�)8D%W,�=)#D<����<���7+,�=D<�4D2?�� �L"<�*IJ1���� �*����)8D<1� �H��� "#)#���41����0)#��+-�(������ U�E��M�� ��)<IJ1���W!F

p^oan

Page 114: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

� �/8W[1HNDd�':=<E>1V(� � "�ME<EDZ>#UaD(� � �)8WD(� � ��ME< HND(�

� �'8I[1HND �':=<E>1V(� o � � � � � o�� o -C�Nn o�� o5/54 � o�� oNo502�

� "�ME<EDZ>#UaD(� o�� o/p 47p o � � � o � o�� o -ao5� o�� o5/'p�/

� ��8WD � o�� o��'pBn o�� n2/Nn20 o � �:6 �:� o�� oan$-ao

� ��ME<EHND(� o�� oNo�� � o�� nNn2�2� o�� o5�$-Tn o � � 6 ���

& 9"+ # ���=� �7>1HK>#@\>#JLHNDW[1<?>1<EUaD�:lHK>#JL< CM?@BHKJLD/@BAC97bGH=[1<E:YF;M?@����,� �<?>1VGOgUa8WJ$VW<EAWAW@BD >#UNF;<E_^[�[#>1HK>#@B[��

HN[eH A/Ua:lHN<ED�UNO�FPUa[1[1<E9IM?@ OQ8W>18/J1@l<EDZjN@B[#>1<?]aHK>1<EUaDW[��i��V/@B[1@lFWJ1U'_`@B[1[#@B[eHKJ1@�<EDWA/@^@BA ME< �N@BM?b,>#U Os8WMSR MEM�Ua8/J

_`UaV/@^J1@BDI_`@*HN[1[18W:=FW>1<?UaDW[��

� [L<E:YFIM?@ ��,� �$<?>1VrUaD/@GVW<EAWA/@BD [#>1HK>#@GFP@^J*>#UNFI<E_�VWHN[\9P@^@BD RIJh[#>4RI>#>#@BA >#U,>1V/@G_LVWHK>YAWHK>1H,<ED

UNJLA/@^J�>#U�@^j HNME8IHK>#@��$VW@^>1V/@^J>1VW@\_`UaDZ>1<EDZ8I<?>kbiHN[1[L8W:YFW>1<?UaD <E[�FIJ1UN9IHK9I<EM <E[#>1<E_^HNMEMEb=j HNM <EA�����V/@eDZ8I:*9P@^J$UNO

>#UNFI<E_^[�VWHN[�9P@^@BD [#@^> � :=HND78WHNMEM?b � >#U�OQUa8/J)V/@^J1@Nm VWU �.@^jN@^J4j HKJh<?Ua8W[�:YU'A/@BM�[1@BM?@B_`>1<?UaD >#@B_LVIDW<EX78/@B[�_`Ua8WMEA

9P@ @B:YFIM?U bN@BA >#UdHN8/>#Ua:lHK>#@=>1V/@l[#@BME@B_`>1<?UaD�UNO.>1V/@=HKFWFWJ1UNFIJL<EHK>#@YDZ8I:*9P@^J)UNO�VW<EAWA/@BD [#>1HK>#@B[ �l� 8IM?>1<?FIM?@

J1@B[#>1HKJL>1[�UNO�>1V/@Y��� � VWHBjN@Y9P@^@BD,FP@^J1OQUNJL:Y@BA,HNDWA,>1V/@ UaD/@)�$VW<E_hV FIJ1U j'<EA/@BA >1V/@YVW<?]aV/@B[1>�ME< �N@BME<EV/U7U7A

VWHN[�9P@^@BD [1@BM?@B_`>#@BA��)��V/@\@B[#>1<E:=HK>#@BA >#JLHNDI[1<?>1<?UaD :=HK>#JL< iUNO&>1VI<E[���,� <E[�[1V/U �$DdUaD ��HK9IM?@Gp ��� >�_^HND

9P@=[#@^@BD�>1VWHK>\<ED�[#FI<?>#@ UNO.>1V/@ � D/Ua< [#@=<ED�_`UaV/@^J1@BDI_`@ �?m�>1V/@YFIJ1UN9IHK9I<EM <?>kbiUNO��N@^@^FI<EDW]C>1V/@l[1HN:Y@Y>#UNF;<E_Y<ED

_`UaDW[#@B_^8W>1<?jN@\>1< :Y@*FPUa<EDZ>1[$<E[VW<?]aV/@^J>1VWHND >1V/@\FIJ1UN9IHK9I<EM <?>kb�UNO&_LVWHNDW]a<ED/]l>1VW@\>#UNFI< _ �$��VW<E[$:Y@BHNDW[>1VWHK>

@^jN@BD �$<?>1VC>1VW@\AW<E[L_`UaDT>1<ED78W<?>1<E@B[�<ED/@^j'<?>1HK9IM?b FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>< Di>1V/@e_LVWHK>�AWHK>1H'm >1V/@\_`UaDZ>1<ED78W<?>kbiHN[L[18W:YFW>1<EUaDi<E[

FWJ1UN9;HK9I<EME<E[1>1<E_^HNMEM?bY:YUN>1<?jKHK>#@BAiOQUNJ�>1VW< [0AWHK>1H��

�@� 7>^m�>1V/@ >1<E:=@,OQJLHN:Y@B[ �.@^J1@ VWHNDIA��kMEHK9P@BM?@BA HNDWA >1V/@�FWJ1UNFPUa[#@BA j'<E[18WHNME< [1HK>1<?UaDcHNME]NUNJL<?>1VW: ��HN[

FP@^J1OQUNJL:Y@BA,UaD >1VW<E[�AWHK>1H�� ��V/@B[#@YMEHK9P@BME[�HKJ1@Y8W[1@BA�<ED :=HKJ��'<ED/]�>1V/@ FIM?UN>1[ �$<?>1V�-CAW< �P@^J1@BDZ>)[#b7:\9PUaME[��

!�<?]���/ ��0 ��[1VWU �$[�>1VW@�@^jNUaME8/>1<?UaDl<ED >1<E:Y@0UNOP>1V/@�FPUa[#>#@^Jh<?UNJL[�U jN@^J.>1V/@�]NJh<EA FPUa<EDT>1[�< D=H)>1<E:Y@0OQJLHN:Y@ �V/@^J1@

>1V/@�AW<E[1_^8I[1[1<?UaD �.HN[0_hVWHND/]a<ED/]eOQJ1Ua: UaD/@�[L8/9��#@B_`>�>#UYHND/UN>1V/@^J�HNDIA !�<?]���/ � 4 ��J1@^FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>1[�HND�@� 'HN:YF;M?@UNO

AW<E[L_^8W[1[1<?UaD HKJ1Ua8WDWA UaD/@�FIHKJ1>1<E_^8IMEHKJ�>#UNFI< _UNO�<EDT>#@^JL@B[#>���� >�_^HNDG9P@$UN9I[1@^J1jN@BAfm'>1VWHK>0<EDWA/@^@BA mZD/@B<?]aVZ9PUNJL<ED/]

]NJL<EA=F Ua< DT>1[ � J1@B[#FPUaDWA(�N>#U HNDTbYUNOP>1V/@�<ED/FI8W>�jN@B_`>#UNJL[����U �.@^jN@^JBm'>1VW<E[�<E[�D/UN>�HKJ1>1<SR;_^<EHNM M?be_`U'A/@BA <EDT>#U\>1V/@

HNM?]NUNJL<E>1VW: 9I8/>�<E[0[L<E:YFIM?bl>1V/@4Ua8/>1_`Ua:Y@\UNO�>1VW@4>1<E:Y@��k_`UaV/@^JL@BDW_`@4FWJ1@B[1@BDT>$< DG>1V/@4AWHK>1H��

��VW@�[18W:=:=HKJLben �k� >#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVW< _0:=HKF=UNO >1V/@�AW<E[1_^8I[1[1<?UaD [#@BX78/@BDW_`@�_^HNDl9 @0[#@^@BD <ED !�<?]���/ ���7m&�V/@^J1@

>1V/@eFPUa[#>#@^JL<?UNJ�:Y@BHNDW[�HKJ1@\F;M?UN>#>#@BA�����@Y[1V/Ua8IMEAiD/UN>#@e>1VWHK>�>1V/@^J1@ <E[$D/U�_^M?@BHKJ)[#@^FIHKJLHK>1<EUaDd9P@^> �.@^@BD HNMEM

>1V/@ >#UNFI<E_^[�<ED,>1VW< [AWHK>1H��e��V/@ � ]N@BD/@^JLHNM�FPUaME<?>1< _^[��I<ED,>1V/@Y+�� � �fM?@BAd97b "0ME<EDZ>#UaDdU'_^_^8/FI<?@B[�:YUa[1>�UNO�>1V/@

p^o5�

Page 115: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

AW<E[L_^8W[1[1<?UaDI[$>1<E:=@!�=� ��UCUN>1VW@^J4>#UNFI<E_^[4_^HND 9 @YAW< [#>1<ED/]a8W< [1V/@BA�/�>1VW@=UaD/@=HK9PUa8/> � �'8W[LHNDr�':=<?>1V(��qQ>1<?]aVZ>

HNDWAYOQU'_^8W[#@BA=AW< [1_^8W[1[1<EUaDfmN:=HKFWFP@BA 9Zbe>1V/@$HNME]NUNJL<?>1VW: :=HN< DWM?b\< D >1V/@$8/FWFP@^J�M?@^OQ>&_`UNJLD/@^J�UNO >1VW@�!�<E]���/ ���at

HNDWA�UaDW@ HK9PUa8/> � ]a8WD _`UaDT>#J1UaM.<ED >1V/@ +�� � � ��qs:=HKFWFP@BA <ED >1VW@ 8/FWFP@^J)JL<E]aVT>4_`UNJLDW@^J t ���$V/@lAW<E[L_^8W[1[1<?UaD

HK9PUa8/> � ��ME<EHND(��qQJL<?]aVZ>lM?U ��@^J J1@^]a<?UaD6UNO�>1V/@iRI]a8/J1@ teOQUNJL:=[lH M?@B[1[=AI<E[#>1<ED/]a8I<E[1VWHK9IME@ [18/9 � >#UNFI<E_GUNO�>1V/@

]N@BD/@^JLHNM F UaM <?>1<E_^[�>#UNFI<E_ �

��VW@ �V/UaM?@ ]NJL<EA UNO.J1@^OQ@^J1@BDW_`@YjN@B_`>#UNJL[\<E[�]a<?jN@BD <ED >1VW@Y>1HK9IM?@Y<ED !�<?]���/ � � �=��HN_hV J1@^OQ@^J1@BDW_`@�� jN@B_`>#UNJ

<E[GJ1@^FIJ1@B[#@BDZ>#@BA 9Zb >1V/@ :YUa[#>CFIJ1UN9IHK9IM?@ �.UNJLAW[^m�<ED A/@B[1_`@BDIAW<ED/] UNJLA/@^JCUNOe>1V/@B<?JCFWJLUN9IHK9I<EME<E>kb6jKHNME8/@!�

��VW< [G>1HK9IM?@�J1@��I@B_`>1[d>1V/@rHK9PU jN@ <EDT>#@^JLFWJ1@^>1HK>1<?UaD UNO >1V/@ :lHKFWFI<ED/]6<ED !�<?]���/ ��� � HNDWA�< [C<ED OQHN_`> >1V/@

J1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>1HK>1<EUaDrUNO0>1V/@GHNDWHNM?b %^@BA _LVWHK> [#@B[1[1<EUaDfm�FIJ1U j'<EA/@BAr9Zb�>1V/@�HNM?]NUNJL<?>1VI:��i�$UN>#@CHK]aHN<ED >1VWHK>e>1V/@

]NJLHNA/@GUNO�[1:YU7UN>1VWD/@B[1[eUNO�>1VW< [^m&< � @!��>#U �$VWHK>e@� '>#@BDT>=D/@BHKJL9Zb jN@B_`>#UNJh[=HKJ1@C[1<E:=< MEHKJ*>#U�@BHN_hV UN>1V/@^J=<ED

_`UaDZ>#@BDT>�<E[ �#8W[1>�H J1@��I@B_`>1<?UaDGUNO�V/U � :\8W_hVC>1V/@4_`UaDZ>#@BDT>$UNO�>1V/@4_hVWHK>$<EDC_`UaDI[#@B_^8/>1<?jN@)>1<E:=@ �$<EDWA/U �$[�<E[

J1@BMEHK>#@BAl>#U4@BHN_LV UN>1V/@^J ����D �$VWHK>�>1V/@�>#@B:YFPUNJLHNMW_`UaDZ>#@� '>�:YU'A/@BME<EDW]�< [&_`UaDW_`@^JLD/@BA � _`UaDZ>#@� 7>�:YU'A/@BME<ED/]

<E[�HND UaMEAeFWJ1UN9;M?@B:(<EDe>#@� 7>�FWJLU7_`@B[1[L<ED/]HNDIAYVWHN[�9P@^@BDeHNMEJ1@BHNA/b\HNAIA/J1@B[1[#@BAe97b\AW< � @^J1@BDZ>�AW<E:Y@BDW[L<?UaDWHNME<?> b&�

J1@BAW8I_`>1<?UaDGHKFWFWJ1UaHN_hV/@B[�<ED�>1V/@4_^HN[#@)UNO�[#>1HK>1<E_�>#@� '>�A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[$� >1V/@�FWJ1UNFPUa[#@BAGHNM?]NUNJh<?>1VW: FWJ1@B[1@^J1jN@B[

>1V/@e< � < � A���AWHK>1H�:YU7AW@BME[��W_^HKFIHK9I< ME<?>kbGUNO&:YU'A/@BME< D/]YFPUaM?b7[1@B:*bNm HN[$>1V/@\[1HN:Y@ ��UNJLA <E[�FPUa[1[L<?9IM?@�>#U�OgJ1@^@BMEb

HKFWFP@BHKJ*HN:YUaDW]C>1V/@l_`Ua:YFPUaD/@BDZ>1[)UNO�AW< �P@^J1@BDT>)JL@^Og@^J1@BDI_`@�� jN@B_`>#UNJL[��l��D�HNAWAW<E>1<?UaDfmf>1V/@l:=U7A/@BM�_^HNDrHNME[#U

_^HKFW>18/JL@)qs[LV/UNJ1>�>#@^JL: t�>#@B:YFPUNJLHNM'_`UaDZ>#@� 7>&97b\<E>1[�_^HKF;HK9I<EME<?> b)>#U4:YU'A/@BM':=HNDTb � >#U � UaD/@0J1@BM HK>1<?UaDW[�9P@^> �.@^@BD

>1V/@lVI<EAWA/@BD HNDWA�UN9;[#@^J1jN@BA�jKHKJL<EHK9IME@B[^m�HN[4VWHN[*9P@^@BD�HNME[#UdA/@B:=UaDW[#>#JLHK>#@BA�UaD HND�@� /HN:YFIM?@YUaD�!�<E]a8/J1@B[

/ �Ep�HNDWA3/ � n ����VW< [�<E[.>1V/@�:=HN<ED�:YU'A/@BME<ED/]\AW< �P@^J1@BDW_`@�OgJ1Ua: >1V/@�[#>1HK>1<E_�HNM?]NUNJh<?>1VW:=[�����DlUN>1VW@^J ��UNJLAI[^m7<EO

He>#UNFI<E_�<E[�:Y@BDZ>1<?UaD/@BA��#8I[#>�9IJL<?@��IbY<EDW[L<EA/@�UaD/@�UN>1V/@^J �VW<E_LV FP@^JL[1<E[1>1[�H M?UaD/]N@^J�FP@^JL<?U'A=UNO�>1<E:Y@Nm'>1V/@BDG<?>

�$<EM MW9P@�J1@^FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>#@BAGHN[0FIHKJ1>.UNO�<?>���� DG>1V/@�@� /HN:YFIM?@�<ED !�<?]���/ � �7mW>1V/@)_`Ua:=:=@BDT>1[�HK9PUa8/> � �'8W[LHNDC�/:=<?>1V(�

<ED,>1V/@Y_`UaDZ>#@� 7>4UNO � ��ME< HND(� HNDIA >1V/@YXZ8/@B[1>1<?UaDW[�J1@^]aHKJLAW< D/] ]N@BDW@^JLHNM�FPUaME<?>1<E_^[�HKJ1@YJ1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>#@BA�< D,H�OQ@��

_`@BMEME[�<EDY>1V/@9PUN>#>#Ua: JL<E]aVT>&JL@^]a<?UaDfm �$V/@^J1@BHN[�>1V/@$@� '>#@BDW[1<?jN@�_LVIHK>�HK9PUa8/>�>1VI<E[�>#UNFI<E_$U7_^_^8WFI<?@B[&>1VW@8/FWFP@^J

M?@^OQ>�_`UNJLD/@^J ���$@^jN@^J1>1VW@BM?@B[1[^mW>1VW@*_`J1@BHK>#@BAiJL@^FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaDi<E[$HKFWFIHKJ1@BDZ>1M?b�>#UNF UN]NJhHKFIVW<E_^HNMEMEb=UNJ1]aHNDW<E[1@BA��

���� � � � � ��� ��� � ��" � � �

� J1@BHNM <E[#>1<E_&[L<E:\8IMEHK>1<?UaD)OQJ1Ua:-HAW< �P@^J1@BDZ>�A/Ua:=HN< D4<E[ FIJ1@B[#@BDZ>#@BA\<ED*>1V/@�OQUaMEM?U �$<ED/]�����V/@�j'<E[18IHNME<E[1HK>1<?UaD

UNO�H�>1<E:=@��k[#@^JL<?@B[�_`UaDW[1< [#>1<ED/] UNO�H p �k_LVWHNDID/@BM������ JL@B_`UNJLAW<ED/]G<E[�A/@B:YUaDI[#>#JLHK>#@BAfm �$VW< _LV _`UaDT>1HN< DW[�> �.U

[#>1HK]N@B[ � H �.H �N@lHNDIA,HNDIHK@B[#>1V/@^>1<E[#@BA�� �4� D �Sp��2/�� mf>1VW@e@� '>#J1@B:Y@ jKHNME8/@ [#>1HK>1<E[#>1< _^[�>#@B_LVWDW< XZ8/@ VWHN[�9P@^@BD� �L"<� D<1� 1 :L1/� ���/���=�(�( ��4D ?�� �V�4F � �=�=1�) X �*�!��� ���/)#��A<�� 1�)� 1�)81/�(�6 �"#�( ����6 4� �V���817�� �I��)� J�/M � )81����6 �"#�(���=�/���*./�

� �(�6 ��(��) # ) �<��IJ1��������V�=1/��.*�4: �01/�J�#1��� ��M �"#�E�<����6���( ��V?��6���( ���+-�9���41/��A�����E��M � �(�< �" �/M � )81/�(�6 �"#�����=1 �����0)#��+!F ��M

p^o -

Page 116: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

HKFWFIM <?@BA)OQUNJ�>1VW<E[�>kb7FP@�UNOWAWHK>1H$>#U�:Y@BHN[L8/J1@&>1V/@.A/@^FIHKJ1>18WJ1@&>#U�>1V/@�HNDWHK@B[1>1V/@^>1<E[#@BAe[#>1HK>#@.OgJ1Ua:->1V/@�DWUNJL:=HNM

H ��H �N@eUaD/@!����DC>1VW< [0@� 7FP@^JL< :Y@BDT>�Hlj7< [18WHNME<E[LHK>1<?UaD�UNO�>1VW@*A/@^jN@BM?UNFI:=@BDT>�<EDG>1<E:Y@4UNO�>1V/@*J1@B_`UNJLA/@BA AWHK>1H

9IHN[#@BArUaD <E>1[*[#FP@B_`>#JLHNM�_`UaDT>#@BDZ>Y<E[*[#Ua8W]aVT>��i��VW@l[#FP@B_`>#JLHNM�_hVWHKJLHN_`>#@^JL< [#>1<E_^[ HKJ1@ :=@BHN[18/J1@B[\_`Ua:=:YUaDWM?b

8/>1<EM < %^@BAG<EDCHNDWHK@B[#>1V/@B[L<EH � - ��� �

��VW@e[#FP@B_`>#J1UN]NJhHN: UNO�>1VW<E[�[1<?]aDWHNM�[#@^J1jN@BA�HN[�H�:\8WME>1<EAW<E:Y@BDI[1<?UaDWHNMf<EDWFI8/>�>1<E:=@��k[#@^JL<?@B[�>#UG>1V/@ HNM?]NU �

JL<?>1VI:�����<E:Y@�OQJLHN:Y@B[0UNO �Nn >1<E:Y@)FPUa<EDZ>1[ �.@^J1@48/>1<EME< %^@BAfm �<?>1VCHNDCU jN@^JhMEHKFdUNO�n2/ >1<E:Y@�FPUa<EDZ>1[�9P@^> �.@^@BD

_`UaDW[#@B_^8W>1<?jN@C>1<E:Y@GOQJLHN:Y@B[�� � >Y<E[ >#U�9P@G:Y@BDT>1<EUaD/@BA >1VWHK>YOQ@BHK>18/J1@G@� 7>#JhHN_`>1<?UaD6OQJ1Ua: ����� AWHK>1H�<E[YH

D/UaD�� >#Jh<?j7< HNM'FWJ1UN9IM?@B: HNDIAY>1V/@�OQJ1@BX78/@BDW_`b Og@BHK>18WJ1@B[ �$VI<E_LV �.@^J1@$8I[#@BA=V/@^J1@HKJ1@�UaD/@UNO >1VW@$:YUa[#>�[L<E:YFIM?@

A/@B[1_`Jh<?FW>1<?UaDW[�UNO0HND ����� [1<?]aDWHNM � ��V/@ ����� � nKo����.HN[4RIJL[#>4HKFWF;ME<?@BA >#Ud>1VW@=UN9W>1HN<ED/@BAr:\8WME>1<EAW<E:Y@BD��

[1<?UaDIHNM;>1< :Y@)[#@^JL<?@B[0HNDWA�>1V/@)FPUa[#>#@^Jh<?UNJ0:Y@BHNDW[0HKJ1@)FIMEUN>#>#@BAC<ED !�<E]���/ �Ep^o�����D/@)_^HNDGUN9I[1@^J1jN@4HNDCHN:YUa8WDZ>

UNO U jN@^JLMEHKFi<ED >1V/@)[#>1HK>1<E_ ����� j7<E[L8WHNME<E[1HK>1<EUaDfmT<EDWAI<E_^HK>1<ED/]\>1VWHK>�>1VW@B[#@�Og@BHK>18/JL@B[0HNM?UaD/@Nm��$<?>1V/Ua8W>�>1H �'<ED/]

<EDZ>#UiHN_^_`Ua8WDZ>4>1V/@ >#@B:YFPUNJLHNM�[#>#JL8I_`>18/J1@ UNO�>1VW@=AWHK>1H'm�HKJ1@=<EDI[18 � _^<?@BDZ>�@B<?>1V/@^J)OQUNJ4[#@^FIHKJLHK>1<EDW]C>1V/@Y> �.U

[#>1HK]N@B[UNJ�OQUNJ�FWJ1U j7<EAI<ED/]YHY:Y@BHNDW<EDW]NOQ8WMPj'<E[18IHNME<E[1HK>1<?UaD�����DG>18/JLDC9PUN>1VG>1V/@*>#JLH ��@B_`>#UNJLbCUNO�>1V/@*F Ua[1>#@^JL<?UNJ

:Y@BHNDW[�HNDIA >1V/@�_`J1@BHK>#@BAY>#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVI<E_^HNM'J1@^FWJ1@B[1@BDT>1HK>1<?UaD OQJ1Ua:(>1V/@�FWJLUNF Ua[1@BAY:YU7AW@BM7DI<E_`@BM?b4J1@��;@B_`>1[�>1V/@

> �.U AI< � @^JL@BDT>0J1@^]a< :Y@B[�@� /<E[#>1<EDW]=<EDG>1V/@*AWHK>1H q !�<E]���/ �EpNp�q / �EpBn � t ���V/@\AW<E[#>1<EDW]a8W<E[1VW< D/]*:=HKJ��N@^J��k[#b7:\9PUaME[

�.@^J1@e8I[#@BAdHN_^_`UNJLAI<ED/]l>#U�>1V/@\>#JL8/@\M HK9 @BM [�]a<?jN@BD 9ZbC>1VW@\HNDWHK@B[#>1VW@^>1<E[#>�HNDWAdOQUNJ�@BHN[#@\UNO�j'<E[18IHNM @^jKHNME8WH��

>1<?UaDY_`UaDZ>1<ED78/Ua8W[�ME<EDW@B[�HKJL@.>#JhHN_`@BA=9P@^> �.@^@BDY>1V/@�FPUa[#>#@^JL<?UNJ&:=@BHNDYMEHK>#@BDT>&< :=HK]N@B[�UNO;_`UaDI[#@B_^8/>1<?jN@$[LHN:YFIM?@

FPUa<EDZ>1[��

� ��� ����� �!����������� ��� � � ������ � ����

� >#UNF UN]NJhHKFIVW<E_^HNM�j'<E[18WHNME< [1HK>1<?UaD >#U7UaM�OQUNJ�>#@B:=F UNJhHNMEM?b _`UaV/@^J1@BDZ>iAWHK>1H6VWHN[�9P@^@BD FWJ1UNFPUa[#@BA�� ��D

_`UaDZ>#JLHN[#>$>#UlUN>1V/@^J$>#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVI<E_^HNM :Y@^>1V/U'AW[^mW< DC>1VW<E[0:YU'A/@BMP>1V/@*>#UNF UN]NJhHKFIVTbC<E[$HYJ1@B[18WME>.UNO�>1V/@*>1<E:Y@��

_`UaV/@^J1@BDI_`@lFWJ1@B[1@BDT>e<ED�>1V/@lAIHK>1H��i��V/@^J1@^OQUNJ1@l<?>\<E[ �.@BMEM�[18I<?>#@BA�OQUNJ\HKFWFIM <E_^HK>1<?UaDW[4< D �$VW<E_hV�>1V/@^J1@�HKJ1@

J1@BMEHK>1<EjN@BM?bdOQ@�� HK9WJL8/FI>�_hVWHND/]N@B[4U jN@^J*>1<E:=@ < D >1VW@=8WDWA/@^JLMEb7<EDW]l_^HN8W[#@B[)UNO.>1V/@YAWHK>1HCHNDWA�<E> �.Ua8WMEA 9P@

<EDWHKFIFWJ1UNFWJL< HK>#@Nm�<ED6>1VW@ij7< [18WHNME<E[LHK>1<?UaD6_`UaDT>#@� '>^m0@!� ]�� OgUNJ�Hr_hV/UNFWF7b FIJ1U7_`@B[L[�� � [#Ua:=@��$VWHK> [L<E:=<EMEHKJ

:YU'A/@BM ��HN[0FWJ1UNFPUa[#@BACHNDWAC[L8W_^_`@B[1[#Os8WMEM?b HKFWFIME<?@BA�>#U=>1VW@)>1HN[��GUNO�J1@B_`U jN@^JL<ED/] :YUa8/>1Vi:YU jN@B:Y@BDZ>1[�OQJ1Ua:

[#FP@^@B_LVd<ED �Sp��20���HNDIAG@BHKJLME<?@^J$< D � �Nn���<EDC>1V/@4[1F @^@B_hVCJ1@B_`UN]aDW<E>1<?UaDiA/Ua:=HN< D�� 51/�������(��1/)#D �V�=1/��./�4: � �(�6 ��(��) # ) �<��IJ1������ X G ���A#�6 � �<���(�<��������������D�?��J�=�4: �81���� �8�� ��(����)#.�A#�J ��)6.= X�� 1/)8D2W,�=)#D<����<���7+,�=D<�4D2?�� � �*IJ1�) � �*�����#1/� � �0)#��+-�(������ �2��M 51/�������(��F

p^o5/

Page 117: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

��:YUaD/]a[#>)FPUa[1[L<?9IM?@eHKFWFIME<E_^HK>1<EUaDW[^mf>1V/@ FWJ1UNFPUa[#@BA�:=U7A/@BM�U �P@^JL[4HCD/U jN@BM�>#UNFPUN]NJLHKFIVW< _^HNM�j7<E[L8WHNME<E[1H��

>1<?UaDc>#UZUaMOgUNJ�A/b'DWHN:=<E_^HNMEMEb @^jNUaM?j'<ED/]r>#@� 7> � 9IHN[1@BA AIHK>1H 97b [#@^@��7< D/] >#U HNAIA/J1@B[1[l>1V/@d>1HN[��'[ UNO)>#UNFI<E_

[#@^]a:Y@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaDfmfA/@^>#@B_`>1<EUaD HNDWAd>#JLHN_��'<ED/]��0��Di>1VI<E[$_^HN[#@ <EDWAW@^@BAfmW>1V/@eHN[1[18W:YFI>1<?UaDW[0UNO�>1V/@\@� '< [#>#@BDW_`@*UNO

V/Ua:YUN]N@BDWUa8W[�J1@^]a<?UaDW[<EDi>1V/@e>#@� '>�[#>#JL@BHN: _^HND,9P@*:=HNAW@!���V/@\FPUN>#@BDT>1<EHNM�8W[#@^Os8WMEDW@B[1[0UNO�>1VW<E[:Y@^>1V/U'A

<EDC��UNFI<E_)��@^>#@B_`>1<?UaD,HNDWAi��JLHN_��'<ED/] �Sp ��HKFWFIME<E_^HK>1<EUaDW[0_`Ua8WMEAG9P@4<EDZjN@B[#>1<?]aHK>#@BA��

!�Ua[1[1<E9IM?@=@� '>#@BDW[1<?UaDI[*UNO0>1V/@G:YU'A/@BM�< DW_^ME8WA/@=8W>1<EME< %B<EDW]G:=UNJ1@lFPU �.@^J1Os8WM&@B:l<E[1[1<?UaD A/@BDW[1<E>kb�:YU'A/@BME[

qQ@!� ]��dFIJ1UN9IHK9I<EM <E[#>1<E_ !&Jh<EDW_^<?FIHNM�"�Ua:YFPUaD/@BDT>\:YU7AW@BME[ht �i� VW<?@^JhHKJL_LVW< _^HNM&@� '>#@BDW[1<?UaDrUNO�>1V/@ :=U7A/@BM � 424 �

_`Ua8WMEA 9P@Y_`UaDW[1< A/@^J1@BA OQUNJ4HC:YUNJ1@YJ1@`R;DW@BA�HNDWHNM?b'[1<E[^m��$VW@BD >1V/@=A/b'DWHN:=<E_^[�UNO.>1V/@YJ1@^]a<E:Y@��k[��$<?>1_LVW@B[4<E[

HNME[#U <ED/OQUNJL:=HK>1<EjN@!����D/UN>1V/@^J�FPUa[1[1<E9IM?@0@� '>#@BDW[1<?UaD �.Ua8WMEA 9 @>#U ��HKJLAW[0��HBbN@B[L<EHNDCHKFWFWJ1UaHN_hV/@B[�>#UeFWJ1U'_`@B[1[

:YU'A/@BME[ �Sp�/2� � �

p^o50

Page 118: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

0 0.05 0.1 0.15

−0.1

−0.05

0

0.05

0.1

0.152D LSA

−0.2 −0.1 0 0.1 0.2 0.3

−0.2

−0.1

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

Sammon

−1 −0.5 0 0.5 1−1

−0.5

0

0.5

1GTM

−4 −2 0 2 4−3

−2

−1

0

1

2

3

4

LLE

� �<> !.*�# ��� � �<E[18WHNME< [1HK>1<?UaD�J1@B[L8WM?>1[\UN9W>1HN<ED/@BA UaD � D/@��$[1]NJ1Ua8/FI[\8W[1<ED/]d>1V/@lR;JL[#>4R;jN@����'� Og@BHK>18WJ1@B[

97b AW< �P@^J1@BDZ>�@� '<E[1>1<ED/]�j7<E[L8WHNME<E[1HK>1<EUaD HNM?]NUNJh<?>1VW:=[YqQ@BHN_LVr[#b7:\9PUaM�_`UNJ1J1@B[#FPUaDWAW[�>#UCUaD/@=:=@B[1[1HK]N@ t � ��V/@

_^MEHN[1[1@B[ (� _`Ua:YF � [#b7[ � <?9I:�� Ff_ � VWHKJLA �.HKJ1@ �aHNDIA � � _`Ua:YF�� [1b7[�� :lHN_ � VWHKJLA���HKJ1@ �'HKJ1@[#>#JLUaD/]aM?b U jN@^JLM HKF��

FI<EDW] �VW<EM?@ � �� [L_^< � :Y@BA(� <E[*:YUNJ1@=AW<E[1>1<EDW_`>��=��[)>1V/@B[#@lHNME]NUNJL<?>1VW:=[ �.@^J1@lAW@B[1<?]aD/@BA OQUNJ\< � < � A��YAWHK>1H'm

>1V/@^b _^HNDlD/UN>&:lH �N@$8W[#@0UNO >1V/@�>#@B:YFPUNJLHNM'UNJhA/@^JL<ED/]�UNO >1V/@�AWHK>1H4HNDIAYOQHN< M'>#U4[#@^FIHKJLHK>#@>1V/@0>#UNFI<E_0_^MEHN[L[#@B[

<EDG>1V/@B<EJ�MEHK>#@BDT>J1@^FWJ1@B[1@BDT>1HK>1<?UaD��

p^oC4

Page 119: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

−1 −0.5 0 0.5 1−1

−0.5

0

0.5

1

� �<> !.*�# ��� � !�Ua[#>#@^Jh<?UNJ$:Y@BHNDW[�U jN@^J$>1V/@�]NJL< A FPUa<EDZ>1[.UN9W>1HN<ED/@BAG97bl>1VW@�FIJ1UNFPUa[#@BAG:YU7AW@BM;UaDG>1VW@4[1HN:Y@

AWHK>1H HN[$<ED !�<?]���/ �Ep �0��MEMP>1V/J1@^@e_^MEHN[1[#@B[HKJ1@*D/U � [#@^F;HKJLHK>#@BA HNDIAi:Y@BHNDW<EDW]NOQ8WMP>#UNFPUN]NJLHKF;VW<E_^HNMfJ1@BM HK>1<?UaDW[

HKJ1@�<EDWAW8W_`@BA�����VW@=>#JLH �#@B_`>#UNJ1b UNO0>1V/@B[#@ U jN@^J >1<E:Y@ <E[4>#JLHN_`@BA HN[���@BMEMqs_`UaDT>1<ED78/Ua8W[eME<EDW@ t ����HN_LV A/UN>

[#>1HNDWAI[0OgUNJ$UaD/@*:Y@B[1[LHK]N@!�

p^o5�

Page 120: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

� �<> !.*�# ��� 6 !�Ua[#>#@^JL<EUNJ�:Y@BHNDI[ UN9I>1HN<ED/@BA�UaD p^o _^MEHN[1[#@B[�UNO4AW< [1_^8W[1[1<EUaDW[YOQJ1Ua: >1VW@,nKo��k�@��$[#]NJ1Ua8/F;[

_`UNJ1FI8I[ q � HNM?>�� HK>1V/@B< [1:"�?m U � _`Ua:=F�� ]NJLHKFIVW< _^[��?m � � _`Ua:=F�� Ua[�� :=[ � �<EDWA/U �$[�� :=<E[L_ �?m �

� _`Ua:YF�� [1b7[�� <E9I:�� Ff_ � VWHKJLA���HKJ1@ �?m � � _`Ua:YF�� [1b7[�� :lHN_ � VWHKJLA���HKJ1@ �?m � � _`Ua:YF � �$<EDWA/U �$[�� �?m �

� :=<E[L_ � OgUNJL[LHNM?@ �?m � *� [L_^< � @BM?@B_`>#J1UaDW< _^[��?m � *� [L_^< � :Y@BA(�WHNDWA � *� [1_^< � [1FIHN_`@ � t ����DC[#FI<E>#@)UNO�>1VW@*[#>#J1UaD/]aMEb

U jN@^JhMEHKFWFI<EDW]GDIHK>18/J1@ UNO�>1VW@=AWHK>1H qQ@!� ]��=_`Ua:YFI8/>#@^J�� J1@BMEHK>#@BA AW< [1_^8W[1[1<EUaDW[hthm >1V/@B<?J)J1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>1HK>1<EUaD�<E[)<ED��

A/@^@BAi:=@BHNDW<ED/]NOs8WM ����HN_hVdA/UN>�_`UNJLJ1@B[#FPUaDWAW[�>#U=UaDW@*:Y@B[1[1HK]N@!�

p^o��

Page 121: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

� �<> !.*�# ��� � !�Ua[#>#@^JL<?UNJG:Y@BHNDW[lUN9W>1HN<ED/@BAcUaD�:Y@B[L[1HK]N@B[lOQJ1Ua: - D/@��$[1]NJ1Ua8/FI[dqQ>#JhHN<EDW<ED/] AWHK>1H�/ U

� [1_^< � _`JLbZFW>��?m � � [1_^< � [#FIHN_`@ �?m�� � [1_^< � :=@BA(�?m � [#U7_ � JL@BME<?]a<?UaD�� _hV/JL<E[1>1<EHND(��"l>#@B[1>1<ED/]�AWHK>1H�/ �

� [1_^< � _`JLbZFW>��?m � � [1_^< � [#FIHN_`@ �� � [1_^< � :Y@BA � � � [#U'_ � J1@BME<?]a<?UaD�� _LV/JL< [#>1<EHND(� t �V/@BDc>1VW@,>#UNF;<E_^[�J1@BHKF��

FP@BHKJ�<EDl>1<E:Y@!/�9I<EDW[&UNO&p^oNo\_`UaDW[1@B_^8/>1<?jN@[LHN:YFIM?@$< DW[#>1HNDW_`@B[�UNOf>1V/@$[1HN:=@�_^MEHN[L[ �.@^J1@$OQUNJL:Y@BAfmZ>1VZ8I[�@BHN_hV

_^HK>#@^]NUNJ1b HKFWFP@BHKJ1@BA > �$<E_`@=AW8WJL<ED/]�>1V/@Y>#JLHN<EDI<ED/]�� ��VW<E[�_`UaDZ>1<EDZ8I<?>kb UNO�p^oNo <EDW[#>1HNDW_`@B[ �<?>1V J1@BMEHK>1<?jN@BMEb

V/Ua:YUN]N@BDW@^Ua8W[G_`UaDT>#@BDZ> �.HN[�[1<E:e8WMEHK>1<EDW]�>1V/@ >1< :Y@��k_`UaV/@^J1@BDW_`@ <EDc>1V/@ AWHK>1H HNDWAc>1V/@ >#UNFPUN]NJLHKF;VW<E_^HNM

[#>#JL8I_`>18/J1@�>1VWHK>0VWHN[.9 @^@BDG<EDWOg@^J1JL@BA=97b=>1V/@)HNM?]NUNJL<?>1VI: FP@^JL:=<E>#>#@BA <?>.>#U � J1@B_`UN]aDW< %^@ �/>1VW@J1@��kHKFIF @BHKJhHNDW_`@

UNO�>1V/@=[1HN:Y@ _^HK>#@^]NUNJ1b!�G� DW[1>1HNDW_`@B[)OQJ1Ua: HCFWJL@^j7<?Ua8I[1M?bd[#@^@BD _^HK>#@^]NUNJ1b HKJ1@l:lHKFWFP@BA�<ED >1V/@l[1HN:=@=J1@��

]a<?UaD HN[e>1V/@ <EDI[#>1HNDW_`@B[\OgJ1Ua: >1V/@G[1HN:Y@�_^HK>#@^]NUNJ1b �VW<E_LV ��@^JL@�[#@^@BD <EDr>1V/@ F;HN[#>�� ��VI<E[)FWJ1UNFP@^J1> b <E[

FIHKJ1>1< _^8WMEHKJLM?b 8W[#@^Os8WMf<EDG>#UNFI<E_�>#JhHN_��'<ED/]lHKFWF;ME<E_^HK>1<?UaDW[ �

pNp^o

Page 122: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

� �<> !.*�# ��� � !�Ua[#>#@^Jh<?UNJ�:=@BHNDW[�UaD\>1V/@.[1HN:Y@�AIHK>1HHN[�<ED !�<?]��"/ �1-���FWJ1U j'<EA/@BA*9Zb)>1VW@�FWJ1UNFPUa[#@BA*>#@B:YFPUNJLHNM

HNM?]NUNJL<E>1VW:Cm �$V/@BD >1V/@�:=@B[1[1HK]N@B[ �.@^J1@�JLHNDWA/Ua:=MEbeFP@^JL:e8/>#@BA�����[.@� 7FP@B_`>#@BAfmWD/U [#>#JL8I_`>18/J1@< [�_^HKFW>18WJ1@BA

<ED >1VW<E[ _^HN[#@Nm.[1<EDW_`@G<ED >1V/@GFWJ1UNFPUa[#@BA :YU'A/@BM.>1V/@ >#UNFPUN]NJLHKF;VTb <E[ HND Ua8/>1_`Ua:Y@CUNO$>1VW@�_`UaV/@^JL@BDW_`@i<ED

>1<E:Y@!�&��HN_LV A/UN>$_`UNJ1J1@B[1F UaDIAW[�>#U=UaD/@*:=@B[1[1HK]N@!�

� �<> !.*�# ��� � ��< :Y@*@^jNUaME8W>1<?UaD,UNO&>1V/@eF Ua[1>#@^JL<?UNJL[�<ED,_`UaDW[#@B_^8/>1<?jN@ >1<E:=@\FPUa<EDZ>1[< D H >1<E:Y@eOgJhHN:Y@Nmf_`UaD��

>1HN<EDW< D/]YH=_LVWHNDW]N@4UNO�>1V/@)>#UNFI<E_)UNO�AW<E[L_^8W[1[1<?UaD�OQJ1Ua: � ]N@BD/@^JhHNM FPUaME<?>1<E_^[ �Z>#U � ]a8IDi_`UaDT>#JLUaM � �

� �<> !.*�# ��� ����<E:=@e@^jNUaM 8/>1<?UaD UNO�>1V/@YFPUa[#>#@^JL<?UNJh[)<ED HC>1<E:Y@ OQJLHN:Y@=_`UaDW_`@BDZ>#JLHK>#@BA HKJ1Ua8WDWA UaD/@=[L<ED/]aM?@

>#UNFI<E_=q � �/8W[1HND �':l<?>1V(� t �

pNpNp

Page 123: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

� �<> !.*�# ��� � n �k� :=HKFWFI< D/])UNOf>1V/@_hVWHK>�[#>#J1@BHN: UN9W>1HN<ED/@BAl9ZbY>1V/@FPUa[#>#@^JL<?UNJ.:Y@BHNDW[�����V/@:=HN<ED=>#UNF;<E_^[

_^HND�9P@ _LVWHKJLHN_`>#@^Jh< %^@BArHN[�/ � �/8W[1HNDr�':=<E>1V(�?m � � �)8WD�_`UaDT>#JLUaM&<ED,>1V/@Y+�� � � �?m�� � "�ME<EDZ>#UaD HNDWA

]N@BD/@^JLHNM F UaM <?>1<E_^[0<EDG>1V/@4+�� � � �IHNDIACU *� �(ME<?>#>1M?@�9PU bC��ME<EHND �$V/Ua[#@)OsHK>1V/@^J�ME<?jN@BAC<EDd"�8W9IH �

pNpBn

Page 124: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

susansmith

childrenkidkilltimelife

susansmithmotherchildrenkidtime

life

susansmithtimekidchildrenmotherkilllife

peopletimesusangoodsmiththingyearclinton

peopleclintongoodcensusthingfacttimeyear

peopleclintongoodcensusfactthingtimeform

peopleclintoncensuseliangoodthingstateyear

peopleclintongoodtimethingfactyearmake

peopleclintongoodtimethingfactyeargun

peopleguntimeclintongoodshowyearthing

mother

kill

susansmithtimechildrenkidmotherkilllife

susansmithmotherchildrenkidtimekilllife

guneliantimeshowyearpeoplestatefather

peopleelianstatetimeyearclintonthinggood

peopleclintongoodfacttimethingcensusyear

peopleclintongoodfactcensusthingtimeyear

peopleclintongoodfacttimecensusthingyear

peopleclintongoodtimefactthingcensusyear

peopleclintongoodtimethingfactyearmake

peoplegunclintongoodshowtimefactmake

elianfatherstatecubacubanboyyearmiami

peoplesusantimesmithgoodyearkidthing

gunpeopleeliantimeshowyearstatething

elianstatefathercubacubanboygovernmntmiami

peopleclintongoodfactcensusthingtimeform

peopleclintongoodfactcensustimethingmake

peopleclintongoodfacttimethingcensusyear

peopleclintongoodfacttimethingcensusyear

peopleclintongoodtimethingfactyearcensus

elianfatherstatecubacubanboygovernmntmiami

susansmithchildrenmothertimekidkilllife

peoplegunclintongoodtimeshowfactmake

gunpeopleshowtimegoodclintonmakefact

peopleclintongoodtimethingfactyearcensus

peopleclintongoodcensusfactthingtimeform

peopleclintongoodcensusthingfacteliantime

peopleclintoneliangoodcensusthingtimeyear

peopleclintongoodcensusfactthingtimeyear

peopleclintongoodcensusfacttimethingyear

peopleelianstategunyear

clintontime

show

gunshowtimelawpointmakeyearfelon

guntimeshowpeoplegoodyearsusanmake

gunshowlawstatetimeelianpointyear

elianfatherstatecubacubanboymiamigovernmnt

peopleclintoncensusgoodfactthingformgovernmnt

peopleclintoncensusgoodfactthingformgovernmnt

elianpeoplestatefathercubacubangovernmntboy

peopleelianstateclintoncensusgovernmntyearcuba

elianstatefathercubacubanpeopleboyyear

peopleelianstategunclintonshowyeartime

year

gunshowlaw

felonstateguyin

smithtime

fathermotherkid

gunshowtimelawmakefelonpointwhack

gunelianstateshowfatherpeoplecubayear

peopleelianstatecensuscubaclintongovernmnt

elian

timepoint

susan

father

elianpeoplestatecensusfathercubagovernmntcuban

elianfatherstatecubacubanboygovernmntmiami

elianpeoplestatefathercubacubancensusgovernmnt

elianstatefathercubacubanboyyear

elianfatherstatepeoplecubayearcubanboy

miami

gunshowpeopletimeclintonlawgoodmake

peopleguntimegoodshowyearclintonthing

elianfatherstatecubacubanboymiamigovernmnt

gunpeopleshowtimeelianyearstatelaw

elianstatefathercubacubanboyyeargovernmnt

elianfatherstatecubacubanboygovernmntmiami

elianfatherstatecubacubanboygovernmntmiami

elianfatherstatecubacubanboygovernmntmiami

elianpeoplefatherstateyeartimecubathing

guntimepeopleyearelianshowsusanstate

gunshowtimelawpointfelonmakebuy

elianfatherstatecubacubanboymiamigovernmnt

gunshowpeopletimelawclintonmakegood

gunpeopletimeshowyeargoodthingmake

guntimepeopleshowyeargoodsusankid

peopleclintongoodtimethingfactcensusyear

peopleeliantimegoodclintonthingyearcensus

elianfatherstatecubacubanboymiamigovernmnt

susansmithtimechildrenmotherkidkillyear

peopletimegoodclintonthingsusanyearsmith

gunshowlawfelonbuyguyinpointtime

gunshowlawfelontimebuyguyinpoint

gunshowlawfelonbuyguyinpointschool

gunshowtimelawfelonpointbuywhack

gunpeopletimeshowyeareliangoodstate

peopletimeelianyeargungoodthingstate

elianfatherstatecubacubanboyyearmiami

elianfathercubastatecubanboyyearsusan

susaneliansmithfathermothercubakidyear

peopletimesusansmithgoodthingyearclinton

susansmithtimechildrenmotherkidkilllife

peoplesusansmithtimegoodthingyearkid

susansmithchildrentimemotherkidkilllife

peopletimegoodclintonthingyearsusanfact

peoplegunclintontimegoodshowyearthing

peopleclintongoodcensusfactthingtimeform

peopleclintoncensusgoodfactthingform

gunshowpeoplelowtimeclintonfelonmake

peopleclintongoodtimegunthingfactyear

elianfatherstatecubacubanboy

miami

governmnt

governmnt

� �<> !.*�# ����� ��VW@$J1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>1HK>1<EUaDGUNO >1V/@)_LVWHK>0[#@B[L[1<?UaDfm/< � @!��>1V/@�Os8WMEMW]NJh<EAlUNO�J1@^OQ@^J1@BDW_`@�jN@B_`>#UNJL[���+FG>#U

[#Ua:Y@�DWUa<E[#@Nma_^HN8W[#@BA 97b\M HN_��*UNOP_`UaV/@^J1@BDI_`@�<ED [#Ua:Y@�FPUa<EDT>1[�UNO;>1V/@�AW<E[1_^8I[1[1<?UaD\[#>#J1@BHN:CmTH�>#UNFPUN]NJLHKF;VW<E_^HNM

UNJ1]aHNDW< [1HK>1<?UaDCUNO�>1V/@*[18W9���@B_`>1[�UNO�AI<E[1_^8W[1[L<?UaD _^HNDd9P@)UN9I[#@^J1jN@BA��

pNp��

Page 125: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

� �<> !.*�# ���=� o !�Ua[#>#@^JL<EUNJ*:Y@BHNDW[�U jN@^J*>1V/@Y]NJL< A FPUa<EDZ>1[�UN9W>1HN<EDW@BA 97b,>1V/@=[#>1HK>1<E_����$� HNM?]NUNJL<E>1VW: UaD

>#JLHN<EDI<ED/]i[#@BX78/@BDW_`@�UNO������ AWHK>1H�� ��JLHN_^< D/]i>1V/@�>#JLH �#@B_`>#UNJ1b U jN@^J >1<E:=@ �.Ua8WMEA JL@B[18WM?>4<ED HND 8IDW_^M?@BHKJ

FIM?UN>^mWHN[AWHK>1H=<E[0[1@^@BDdHN[�< � < � A���9ZbG>1VW<E[0:=U7A/@BM �$q � � H ��H �N@ �PHNDWAGU � HN[1ME@^@^F � t

H�� ��JLHN< DW<ED/] [#@BX78/@BDW_`@ 9�� ��@B[#>$[1@BXZ8/@BDI_`@

� �<> !.*�# ��� �:� !�Ua[1>#@^JL<?UNJ0:Y@BHNDW[.U jN@^J$>1V/@�]NJL<EA F Ua< DT>1[�UN9W>1HN<ED/@BA�97b=>1V/@�FWJ1UNFPUa[#@BA�:YU'A/@BMIUaDG>#JhHN<EDW<ED/]

HNDWA,>#@B[#>4[#@BX78/@BDW_`@B[�UNO������ AWHK>1H��\�$V/@\>#JhH ��@B_`>#UNJ1b,UNO.>1V/@B[#@ U jN@^J4>1< :Y@Y<E[�>#JLHN_`@BA �$<?>1V,_`UaDZ>1<EDZ8WUa8W[

ME<EDW@B[���q � *� H ��H �N@ �PHNDWACU *� HN[LM?@^@^F � t

pNp.-

Page 126: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

�� ��� ��� � �

� � � ��� � ���� � ���!��� ��� � � � ������ � � ���������� ���!��� ��� � � � ���� � � ������� ����� ��� � � � � � � ���� �� � ���� ��������� �� � ���� � � ���!���

� � ���� � �

��D6>1VW<E[Y_hVWHKFW>#@^J � m�A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[ J1@^FWJ1@B[1@BDT>#@BA�<ED >1V/@d��HK>#@BDZ>��7@B:lHNDT>1<E_ qs���Wt [#F;HN_`@��$<EMEM.9P@C_`UaD��

[1<EAW@^J1@BA�� � _`Ua:=FI8/>1HK>1<?UaDWHNM M?b @ � _^<?@BDZ>lME< D/@BHKJYFWJ1U��#@B_`>1<?UaD6:Y@^>1V/U'A <E[YAW@^jN@BM?UNFP@BA OgUNJ=>1VW@d[#@B:=HNDZ>1<E_

HNDWHNM?b'[1<E[�UNOf>#@� 7>�A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[�[1>#UNJ1@BA < DY>1V/@����Y[1FIHN_`@!�&�[�>1V/@�_`Ua:YFI8/>1HK>1<?UaDI[�HKJ1@�FP@^J1OQUNJL:Y@BA=<ED H*M?U �

AW<E:=@BDW[1<?UaDWHNM����'� [18W9I[#FIHN_`@Nm�>1V/@�FWJ1UNFPUa[#@BA HNM?]NUNJL<?>1VI: [1_^HNME@B[\ME< D/@BHKJLM?b�<EDr>1V/@�D78W:\9P@^J\UNO�>#JhHN<EDW<ED/]

FPUa<EDZ>1[��

�,H� '< :=< %B<ED/]�H�:Y@BHN[L8/J1@GUNO�AI<E[#>#JL<?9;8/>1<?UaD HN[#b7:l:Y@^>#J1b �<EMEM.9P@�@B:=FIM?U bN@BA m�<ED6_`UaDZ>#JLHN[#>=>#UrUN>1V/@^J

FWJ1U��#@B_`>1<?UaD�� 9;HN[#@BA HKFIFWJ1UaHN_LVW@B[�>#UYA/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>�HNDIHNM?b7[L<E[^m&�VW<E_LV <E:YFIM <E_^<?>1M?beHN[1[18W:Y@�[#b':=:Y@^>#JL< _^HNMIMEHK>#@BDZ>

AW<E[1>#JL<?9I8/>1<EUaDW[ �10547m��20�� �e��VW@ [��N@��$D/@B[1[)FIJ1U���@B_`>1<EUaD�<EDWA/@� < [)A/@^JL<?jN@BA�V/@^JL@eOQJ1Ua: FWJh<?UNJ �7D/U �$M?@BA/]N@YUNO

>1V/@4FIJ1UN9IM?@B:��

��DlHNM?]NUNJh<?>1VW: �$VI<E_LVYFP@^J1OQUNJL:=[&>1V/@�FWJ1U��#@B_`>1<?UaDl>1HN[��=[1<E:e8WM?>1HND/@^Ua8I[1M?b*UaDl>1V/@$AWHK>1H\:=HK>#JL< =HNDWA <?>1[

>#JLHNDW[1F Ua[1@4<E[�HNME[#U=AW@^jN@BM?UNFP@BAiHNDWAiH=[L<E:YFIM?@)<E:=FIM?@B:Y@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaDC<E[�FWJLU j'<EA/@BA�����DC>1V/@*_^HN[1@*UNO�>#@� 7>�AWHK>1H'm

>1VW<E[*R;DWAI[4>1V/@GA/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>*>#UNFI<E_�HN[1[1<E]aDW:Y@BDZ>1[\HNDWA <EAW@BDT>1<SR;@B[4>1V/@ �N@^b �.UNJLAW[eUNO0>1V/@�j HKJL<EUa8W[*>#UNF;<E_^[

<EDWVW@^J1@BDT>�<ED >1V/@0A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>&_`UNJ1FI8I[����$VW<E[�OgUNJL: UNOI>1V/@�HNM?]NUNJh<?>1VW: ��Ua8IMEA [email protected];HKJ1>1<E_^8WMEHKJhM?b48W[#@^Os8WM'<EDe>1V/@

_^HN[#@ �$V/@BDY>1VW@_`UaMEM?@B_`>1<EUaDl<ED �VW<E_LVlUaD/@< [&<EDZ>#@^J1@B[#>#@BA�_`UaDT>1HN<EDI[�H\[1:=HNMEMWD78W:\9P@^J&UNO A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[�����VW<E[

OQUNJL:�UNO'>1V/@.HNM?]NUNJL<?>1VW:-HNME[#U$HNMEMEU �$[�8W[f>#U$JL@BMEHK>#@�HME<ED��9 @^> ��@^@BD\>1V/@&FIJ1UNFPUa[#@BA4[��N@��$DW@B[1[�:lH� '<E:l<E[1HK>1<?UaD

FWJ1U'_`@BAW8/JL@$>#U @� '< [#>1<ED/]eJ1@B_`@BDZ>�[1b7:=:=@^>#JL<E_^HNMP:=HK>#JL< � OsHN_`>#UNJL< %BHK>1<?UaDG:Y@^>1V/U'AW[.OQUNJ.>#@� '>�HNDWHNM?b'[1<E[Bm&�$VW< _LV

J1@B_`UaDW[L<EA/@^JC>1V/@�@BDZ>1<?J1@ A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ> �k<EDWAW@� '<EDW]rFWJ1UN9;M?@B: HNDWA�.UNJ�� AI<?J1@B_`>1M?b �<?>1V >1V/@��@B_`>#UNJ �7FIHN_`@

>#@� '>J1@^FIJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaD���� 'FP@^JL<E:Y@BDZ>1HNM JL@B[18WM?>1[�AW@B:YUaDW[#>#JLHK>#@e>1VWHK>�[��N@��$D/@B[1[�:=H� /<E:=<E[LHK>1<?UaDi<EDd>1V/@\M?U �� 517�� ;�/MZ �"<�0:P�/��W�<���(����)� ��4DE��)J �"#���C�R"#1/� ��(�L:;�����H1��#�!�417�;�=)J �"#��� � �# ��$ � � ���1�'�'�(�#2��5������������6�/A<��)81�� �#+-�/� FC] 9 �������A#�3]/�04.=.=:4�F

pNp�/

Page 127: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

AW<E:=@BDW[1<?UaDWHNMK���'�r[#F;HN_`@&b7<E@BMEAW[f<ED)[#Ua:=@�[1<?>18WHK>1<EUaDW[fH�_`Ua:YFIHKJhHK9IM?@�J1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>1HK>1<EUaD)>#U�>1V/@&OsHN_`>#UNJL<E[LHK>1<?UaD

:Y@^>1V/U'AW[�_`UaDI[1<EA/@^J1@BA��

� ��� �������������� ���!���

��DWA/@^FP@BDWA/@BDZ>�"�Ua:YFPUaD/@BDT>��DIHNM?b7[L<E[\qQ�1"��)t$VIHN[UNOQ>#@BD,9P@^@BD FIJ1UNFPUa[#@BAdHN[)H�8W[#@^Os8WM >#@B_hVWDW<EX78/@e>#U

R;DWA :Y@BHNDW<EDW]NOQ8WM�AW<?J1@B_`>1<EUaDW[$<ED :\8IM?>1<?jKHKJL<EHK>#@\AIHK>1H qs[1@^@Nm OQUNJ�@� 'HN:=FIM?@Nm �1/2����HNDIAdJ1@^OQ@^J1@BDW_`@B[�>1V/@^JL@B<ED;t �

��V/@�OQUNJL: UNO�>1VW@�FPUN>#@BDZ>1<EHNMf[#>#JL8I_`>18/J1@)AW<E[1_`U jN@^J1@BAC<EDGAWHK>1HY<E[�A/@^FP@BDWAW@BDT>�8/FPUaD�>1V/@�>kb7F @)UNO�UN9��#@B_`>1<?jN@

Os8WDW_`>1<?UaD�8W[#@BA�<ED >1V/@��#"��-HNM?]NUNJL<?>1VW: HNDWA �$<?>1V/Ua8W>�FWJh<?UNJ �'D/U �M?@BA/]N@�UNO >1V/@�AWHK>1He>1VW<E[�OQ8IDW_`>1<?UaD�:=HBb

�.@BMEMP9P@4_LV/Ua[#@BD <EDCH=[#Ua:=@��$VWHK>$HKJ19;<?>#JLHKJ1b�:=HNDWD/@^J �

��D*_`UaDZ>#JLHN[#>^mN>1VW< [�_LVIHKFW>#@^J�_`UaDI[1<EA/@^JL[ >1V/@�FWJLUN9IM?@B: UNOW[#@B:lHNDT>1<E_�HNDWHNM?b'[1<E[ HNDIA\<ED*A/Ua<ED/]$[1U/mKH j HN< MEHK9IM?@

FWJL<EUNJ �'D/U �$ME@BA/]N@e< [$@� 'FIM?Ua<?>#@BA,<ED,A/@^JL<?j'<ED/] HND HKFWFIJ1UNFWJL<EHK>#@eHNDWA _`Ua:YFI8/>1HK>1<EUaDWHNMEM?bC<ED/@� 'FP@BDW[1<?jN@*�#"��

9IHN[#@BAd:Y@^>1V/U'ACOgUNJ$>1V/@4FIHKJ1>1< _^8WMEHKJ�OgUNJh: UNO�AWHK>1H�����VW@�AIHK>1Hl8WDWAW@^J�_`UaDI[1<EA/@^JLHK>1<EUaDi_`UaDW[1<E[1>1[0UNO�jN@B_`>#UNJ

[#FIHN_`@\J1@^FWJ1@B[1@BDT>1HK>1<?UaDI[�UNO�>#@� '>A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[ �1�54�� �. $@B_`@BDT>�HKFWFIME< _^HK>1<?UaDW[0UNO��1"�� >#U >#@� '>$J1@^>#Jh<?@^j HNM �1054 �

HNDWA=_^M 8W[#>#@^JL<EDW] � �20��;VWHBjN@�<EDWAW< _^HK>#@BA >1VW<E[&HN[�H)FWJ1Ua:=< [1<ED/]�HKJ1@BH)UNOf<EDZjN@B[#>1<?]aHK>1<?UaD����U �.@^jN@^JBm/<?>�J1@B:lHN<EDW[

>#U�9 @\@BME8W_^<EAIHK>#@BA �$VZbiHNDWA,V/U �(�1"�� :=H bi9P@*@��P@B_`>1<?jN@Y<EDd>#@� '>�:=<EDW<EDW]/mIHNDWA >1VW<E[�_LVWHKFW>#@^J)[#@^@��'[�>#U

HNAWA/JL@B[1[&>1VW< [&FIHKJ1>1< _^8WMEHKJ�<E[L[18/@!����V/@$:lHN<EDl:YUN>1<Ej HK>1<?UaD UNOf>1VW<E[ ��UNJ��=<E[&>#UeFWJ1U j7<EAW@$H*_`Ua:YF;8/>1HK>1<?UaDWHNMEMEb

@ � _^<?@BDZ>�:Y@^>1V/U'AlOQUNJ0A/U7_^8I:Y@BDT>._^ME8W[#>#@^Jh<ED/]\HNDIA �N@^b �.UNJLA�qQUNJ0<EDWA/@� Y>#@^JL:�t �1�54 �f<EA/@BDZ>1<SR;_^HK>1<EUaD�����VW<E[

<E[�HN_LVW<E@^jN@BA 9ZbdH�ME<EDW@BHKJ>#JLHNDI[#OgUNJh:=HK>1<?UaD F @^JLOgUNJL:=@BA <EDd>1V/@Y���'� [L8/9I[#FIHN_`@ �$VW< _LVd:lH� '<E:l< %^@B[�[#Ua:Y@

:Y@BHN[18WJ1@)UNO�AW<E[#>#JL<E9I8/>1<?UaD�[��N@��$D/@B[L[��

��DGHY[1<E:=<EM HKJ�OsHN[1VW<?UaD�>#UY�1"�� 9IHN[#@BAC:=@^>1V/U7AI[��VW<E_LVGVWH jN@49P@^@BDGA/@^jN@BM?UNFP@BA�OgUNJ�!W8IDW_`>1<?UaDWHNMP�,HK] �

D/@^>1<E_ $@B[#UaDWHNDW_`@ ��:=HK]N@cq !�� $�#t���DWHNM?b'[1<E[�HNDWA <E:=HK]N@�J1@B_`UN]aDI<?>1<?UaD �SpNpNm -ao/m)p.-C�/m)p��Ko/m �2��� m�> �.U

_`Ua:YFIME@B:Y@BDT>1HKJLbGHKJh_LVW<?>#@B_`>18WJ1@B[$_^HNDC9P@4_`UaDW[1>#JL8W_`>#@BA �VW<E_LVC< DG>1VW<E[0_^HN[#@*_`UaDI[1<E[#>0UNO�>1V/@4OQUaMEM?U �$<ED/]��

� �$V/@)[#@^FIHKJLHK>1<?UaD�UNOw�����U�����<� � /$� � �B� ����qsAWU7_^8W:=@BDT> � FWJLUN>#UN>kb7F @B[�UNJ � 9IHN[1<E[ �kAWU7_^8W:=@BDT>1[�� t&OQJ1Ua: >1V/@

UN9;[#@^J1jN@BA A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[�� ��VW@B[#@ OsHN_`>#UNJL[CFIJ1U j'<EA/@,OgUNJG>1V/@�HN8/>#Ua:lHK>1<E_ @� 7>#JhHN_`>1<?UaD UNO4FPUN>#@BDZ>1<EHNM

< DWA/@� � >#@^JL:=[0J1@BM HK>#@BAC>#U=>1V/@4>#UNF;<E_^[0UNJ$_`UaDW_`@^FI>1[$HN[1[#U'_^<EHK>#@BA �$<?>1VG@BHN_LV,_^ME8W[1>#@^J0UNO�[L<E:=<EMEHKJ0A/U'_ �

8I:Y@BDT>1[ �

� �$V/@�[1@^FIHKJLHK>1<?UaD UNOv�B����� � 23/ ���;�< �����eOgJLUa: >1VW@ UN9I[1@^J1jN@BA ��UNJhAW[�����V/@B[#@�>#UNFI<E_ UNJ=_`UaDW_`@^FW> OQ@BH��

>18WJ1@B[*@BDIHK9IM?@l@BHN_hV A/U7_^8I:Y@BDT>\>#U 9P@�HN[1[#U'_^<EHK>#@BA �$<?>1V�UaD/@�UNJ :YUNJ1@�UNO0>1V/@B[#@GMEHK>#@BDT>e>#UNFI<E_^[ �

pNp�0

Page 128: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

_`UaDI_`@^FW>1[���$VW<E[$< [$HNDWHNM?UN]NUa8I[$>#UG_^ME8W[#>#@^Jh<ED/]=>#UN]N@^>1V/@^J4AWU7_^8W:=@BDT>1[ �$VW<E_hVdVWH jN@ [L<E:=<EMEHKJ0>#UNF;<E_^HNM

UNJ�_`UaDW_`@^FW>18WHNM�_`UaDT>#@BDZ>��

��Dl9PUN>1V�>1V/@B[#@�_^HN[#@B[0<?>��$<EMEMI9P@[1V/U �$D >1VWHK>0H\:Y@BHN[L8/J1@�UNO�[��N@��$D/@B[L[�UNJ0HN[#b':=:Y@^>#JLbl<E[�>1V/@�HKFIFWJ1U �

FWJL< HK>#@�UN9��#@B_`>1<?jN@�>#U�UNFW>1<E:=< [#@�OQUNJ�@BHN_LV UNOI>1VW@B[#@�>1HN[��7[ ����VW@�> ��U)J1@BX78W<?JL@B:Y@BDT>1[.�$<EM Ma>1V/@BDe9P@�@ � _^<E@BDT>1M?b

8WDW<?RI@BA �$<?>1VW<EDGH=[L<ED/]aM?@)HNM?]NUNJL<E>1VW: �$<?>1V/Ua8W>�HNDZbC[1<?]aDW<?R;_^HNDT>0HNAWAI<?>1<?UaDWHNMf_`Ua:YF;8/>1HK>1<?UaDWHNM _`Ua[1>��

��VW@J1@B[L8WM?>1HNDZ>.HNM?]NUNJh<?>1VW: VWHN[.OQHN[1>�_`UaDZjN@^J1]N@BDW_`@\HNDWAG<?>1[�_`Ua:=FI8/>1HK>1<?UaDWHNMP_`Ua[#>�[L_^HNM?@B[0HN[ �Gq6� � ��tqQFWJ1U j7< A/@BA,>1VWHK>4���7�VWHN[�HNM?J1@BHNA/b 9 @^@BD,FP@^J1OQUNJL:Y@BA;tKqdME<ED/@BHKJ)<ED,>1V/@YD78W:\9 @^J�UNO.>#JLHN<EDW<EDW]lFPUa<EDZ>1[ � m

�$V/@^JL@ � <E[)>1V/@�AW<E:Y@BDW[L<?UaD,UNO.>1VW@ ���/� [18W9I[#FIHN_`@lHNDIA � � � � ���[*>1V/@ :=@^>1V/U7A UaDWM?b,J1@BXZ8I<?J1@B[

HND����/� [18/9I[1FIHN_`@\UNO.AW<E:Y@BDI[1<?UaD � >1V/@BD >#@B_LVIDW<EX78/@B[�[18W_LV HN[�>1V/@ >1V/@Y��HNDW_&%^Ua[4:Y@^>1V/U'A,OgUNJ)[#F;HKJL[#@:=HK>#JL< _`@B[ �Sp�/�� m��$VI<E_LV [1_^HNM?@HN[ �Gq � � � � ��� � � � t$qsM <ED/@BHKJ�< D=>1V/@�DZ8W:\9P@^J�UNO�DWUaD�� %^@^J1Ue@BM?@B:Y@BDZ>1[hthm/:=HBb=9P@8W[#@BA <ED _`J1@BHK>1< D/]�>1V/@0���'�cFWJ1U��#@B_`>1<?UaD�����V/@0[18/9I[1@BXZ8/@BDZ>�FWJ1U'_`@B[1[1<ED/]�>1H �N@B[&HNA/jKHNDZ>1HK]N@�UNOI>1V/@0[#>1HK9;<EME<?> b

FWJ1UNFP@^J1>1<E@B[=UNO4>1VW< [ HNM?]NUNJh<?>1VW: HNDIA �.UNJ��'[�< DcH A/JLHN[#>1<E_^HNM M?b J1@BAW8W_`@BA AW<E:Y@BDI[1<?UaDWHNM����'� [18/9;[#FIHN_`@!�

��VW< [Y<E[=<ED _`UaDZ>#JLHN[#> >#UrFWJLUN9IHK9I<EME< [#>1<E_�:Y@^>1V/U'AW[=[18W_hVcHN[ !&J1UN9IHK9;<EME<E[#>1< _ ��HK>#@BDT>i�7@B:=HNDZ>1<E_i��DWHNM?b'[1<E[

qs!����'�)t � 4 �'mIp�/20�� �$VW<E_hV J1@BXZ8I<?J1@0H4D/UaD��k_`UaDZjN@� =UNFW>1<E:l< %BHK>1<?UaDY>#U49P@0FP@^J1OQUNJL:Y@BAY<ED >1VW@�UNJL<?]a<EDIHNM qsVW<?]aV

AW<E:=@BDW[1<?UaDWHNMQt�>#@^JL: Og@BHK>18/JL@*[#FIHN_`@ � �$VW<E_hVCHNME[#U=9WJh<ED/]a[�DZ8I:Y@^JL<E_^HNMPFWJLUN9IM?@B:=[ �Sp�� �'m n2/�� �

��D�>1VW<E[ �.UNJ���<?>4<E[*<E:YFIME< _^<?>1M?bCHN[1[18W:=@BA�>1VWHK>4>1V/@ DZ8W:\9P@^J)UNO0_^ME8W[#>#@^JL[�UNJ\>#UNFI<E_^[4< [4[#@^>j� � ���<� ��� �

��DWA/@^@BA�<?>��<EMEMW9P@�A/@B:YUaDW[#>#JhHK>#@BA >1VIHK>.>1VW@�_^M HN[1[�HN[1[1<?]aDW:=@BDT>1[�]a<?jN@BDG97blH\V78W:=HNDG<EDIA/@� 7@^J�>#UYHe[1@^>.UNO

A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[:lHBbC9P@*M?U ��@^J�>1VWHNDd>1V/@\D78W:\9 @^JUNO�FPUN>#@BDT>1<EHNM�<EDZ>#JL<EDW[L<E_�>#UNFI<E_^[UNJ�_`UaDW_`@^FI>1[<EDIV/@^J1@BDZ>$<ED

>1V/@*AWU7_^8W:=@BDT>�_`UaMEME@B_`>1<?UaD��

��VW@�J1@B:=HN<EDIA/@^J&UNOf>1V/@�_LVWHKFW>#@^J0<E[�[#>#JL8W_`>18/JL@BAlHN[�OgUaMEMEU �$[�/���D��7@B_`>1<?UaDGn4H\A/@B[1_`JL<EFW>1<?UaD UNOf>1V/@�AWHK>1H

J1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>1HK>1<EUaDl<E[�FWJLU j'<EA/@BA��&�7@B_`>1<?UaDW[�0 ���)HNDWA 0 �1-\FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>1[�>1V/@�> ��U\AW< �P@^J1@BDT>&:=U7AWHNM <?>1<?@B[�UNOPHNDWHNM?b'[1<E[

FWJL<EUNJe>#U�FIJ1U7_`@^@BAI<ED/],>#U�>1V/@C8WDW<SRI@BA HNM?]NUNJL<E>1VW: <ED �7@B_`>1<?UaD 0 ��/ � ��Ua<ED/] [#U ]a<?jN@B[Y>1VW@CUNFWFPUNJ1>18WDW<?> b

OQUNJ=:YUN>1<?jKHK>1<ED/] OgJLUa: > �.U AW< �P@^J1@BDZ>eFP@^JL[1F @B_`>1<EjN@B[ Ua8/J �N@^b HN[L[18W:YFW>1<EUaD�/ >1VW@GHN[1b7:=:=@^>#JL<E_^HNM0MEHK>#@BDZ>

FWJL<EUNJ � �7Ua:Y@G[1<E:e8WMEHK>1<?UaD J1@B[18WM?>1[��$<EMEM&9 @�A/@B:YUaDW[1>#JLHK>#@BA < D �7@B_`>1<?UaD 0 ��0 �,@� 7>#@BDWAW@BA HN[1F @B_`>1[��$VW< _LV

�$<?>1V�AW@B:YUaDW[#>#JLHK>#@ >1V/@=J1@BM HK>1<?UaD�UNO�>1V/@l:Y@^>1VWU7A�>#U UN>1V/@^J*@� /<E[#>1< D/]CD/U jN@BM.:Y@^>1V/U'AW[4HNDWA�R;DWHNMEM?b >1V/@

MEHN[#>�[1@B_`>1<?UaDi@BDWAI[ �$<?>1VC_`UaDW_^ME8I[1<?UaDW[0HNDWAdAW<E[1_^8W[L[1<?UaDW[.UaDCOs8/>18/J1@)AW<EJ1@B_`>1<?UaDW[�UNO�<EDZjN@B[#>1<?]aHK>1<?UaD��

pNp 4

Page 129: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

� � � � � ����������� � ���!� � � � ���� � �������� ��� � ����� � ������ � ���� �������

� � ���� ��� � ���

��VW@��@B_`>#UNJ��7F;HN_`@$qQ)�WtPJ1@^FWJ1@B[#@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaD)UNO/H0A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ> FWJLU j'<EA/@B[P>1V/@&AW< [1_`J1@^>#@�jKHNME8/@BA � �kAW< :Y@BDW[1<?UaDIHNMjN@B_`>#UNJBm �V/@^J1@ ��<E[.>1V/@�D78W:*9P@^J.UNO�AW< [#>1<EDW_`> �.UNJLAW[�<ED >1V/@�jNU'_^HK9I8WMEHKJ1blUNJ�AI<E_`>1<?UaDWHKJ1b �Sp�� � � �&��V/@�> �.UJLH ��HNDWA=8ID/FWJ1U'_`@B[1[#@BAY4� :YU'A/@BME[�HKJ1@�@B<?>1V/@^J�9I<EDWHKJ1b\UNJ�OQJ1@BX78/@BDW_`b 9IHN[#@BAAq HN[�VWHN[&9 @^@BDlAW<E[1_^8W[L[#@BAY<ED

"�VWHKFI>#@^J � �&��<?>1V/@^J�>1VW@9I< DWHKJ1b UNJ�>#@^Jh: OQJ1@BX78/@BDW_`b � 9IHN[#@BA J1@^FWJ1@B[1@BDT>1HK>1<?UaDI[�UNO >1VW@�A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[._^HND 9P@

8W[#@BAYVW@^J1@!� � >&< [�>#U)9P@0D/UN>#@BAY>1VIHK>^m0�$VW<EM [#>�FIJ1UN9IHK9I<EM <E[#>1<E_&:=@^>1V/U7AI[�HKJ1@�VW<?]aVWMEb4A/@^FP@BDWA/@BDZ>�UaD >1VW@�<EDW<?>1<EHNM

A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ> � @BDW_`U'AW<ED/] � H*AI< � @^JL@BDT>�HNDIAlHKFWFWJLUNFWJL<EHK>#@$AI<E[#>#JL<?9;8/>1<?UaDWHNM':YU'A/@BMIVIHN[&>#Ue9 @$OgUNJL:e8WMEHK>#@BA <ED

>1V/@4_^HN[#@*UNO�9I< DWHKJ1blAWHK>1H=UNJ0OgJ1@BX78/@BDW_`bG_`Ua8WDZ>1[�AWHK>1H � < DG>1V/@4���'�->#@B_LVWDI<EXZ8W@)>1V/@)FWJ1@B_^<E[1@�_hV/Ua<E_`@4UNO

>1VW<E[.>#@^JL: �.@B<?]aVZ>1<ED/] Os8WDW_`>1<?UaDGA/U7@B[0D/UN>0H�� @B_`>$>1V/@�J1@B[18WM?>1[��SpBn20 � ��� D�>1V/@)@� 'FP@^JL<E:Y@BDZ>1[.J1@^FPUNJ1>#@BAfm'>1V/@

9I<EDIHKJ1bl>#@� '>�J1@^FWJL@B[#@BDT>1HK>1<EUaDiVWHN[�9P@^@BDG@B:YF;M?U bN@BA��

��VW@h� �&��� �;� � ������%�f:=HK>#Jh< UNO'>1V/@&A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ> _`UaMEM?@B_`>1<EUaD4<E[ A/@BDWUN>#@BA)9Zb � q� � �Wt �������

� � � �����

�$V/@^JL@ � <E[�>1V/@*D78W:\9P@^J0UNO�>#@^Jh:=[�<EDG>1V/@4AI<E_`>1<?UaDWHKJ1b�HNDWA � <E[�>1V/@)>#UN>1HNM�D78W:*9P@^J0UNO�A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[����D �N@^@^FI<ED/])�$<?>1VG[#>1HNDIAWHKJLA�]N@BD/@^JLHK>1<?jN@4:=U7A/@BM [ �1/�� m/>1VW@�HN[L[18W:YFW>1<EUaDl>1VWHK>0>1VW@�UN9;[#@^J1jKHK>1<?UaDW[�HKJ1@4H

D/Ua<E[1bY@� 7FIHNDI[1<?UaD=UNO�[#Ua:Y@�:\8W_hV AW@BDW[#@^J.]NJ1Ua8/F�UNO�MEHK>#@BDZ>�>#UNFI< _^[�qs_^M HN[1[#@B[^m7UNJ0_`UaDW_`@^FW>1[ht�<E[�:=HNA/@�V/@^J1@!�

��HN[#@BA UaD [#Ua:=@$UNOf>1V/@�FWJ1@^j'<?Ua8W[1MEb*J1@^FPUNJ1>#@BA ��UNJ��=< D=>1VW<E[�A/Ua:=HN<ED �10547m �20 � m7>1V/@�� �kAI<E:Y@BDW[1<EUaDWHNM/���'�

[#FIHN_`@ �$<EM M�9P@ HNA/UNFW>#@BA HN[\>1V/@l�B����� � 2 � ��� � �������i[18W9��k[#FIHN_`@!�,��V/@ljKHNME8/@�[#@^>eOgUNJ � [1VWUa8WMEA�9P@ [L:=HNMEM@BD/Ua8/]aVe>#U�@BDWHK9IME@�OsHN[#>�[18/9I[1@BXZ8/@BDZ>�UNF @^JhHK>1<?UaDW[0qs[18W_hVeHN[�OsHN[#>�J1@^>#JL<?@^jKHNMgthmN9I8W>�MEHKJL]N@�@BD/Ua8W]aV >#U�_^HKFI>18/J1@

>1V/@4[#>#Jh8W_`>18/J1@�UNO�>1V/@*_`UNJ1FI8I[�����V/@^UNJ1@^>1<E_^HNM @^j7<EAW@BDW_`@4<ED�>1V/@4ME<?>#@^JhHK>18/J1@)[1V/U �$[0>1VWHK>�<?O�>1V/@4_`UNJ1FI8I[0VWHN[

H jN@^J1b _^M?@BHKJ)_^MEHN[L[[#>#Jh8W_`>18/J1@ HNDWA$��@)�'D/U �(>1V/@ DZ8I:*9P@^J$UNO._^MEHN[1[#@B[Bm;>1V/@BD <?>�<E[@BD/Ua8/]aV >#UC[#@^>9� >#U>1V/@*D78W:\9P@^J0UNO�_^MEHN[L[#@B[ �SpBn20�� �

��D�>1V/@)[#@B_`UaDWAG[#>1HK]N@)UNO�>1VW@�FIJ1U7_`@B[L[^m7H [#@BHKJh_LVC>#UY<EA/@BDZ>1<?OQb=[#Ua:Y@�J1@BM?@^jKHNDZ>�HNDIA�:=@BHNDW<ED/]NOs8WMI[1>#JL8W_ �

>18/J1@\<EDG>1VW<E[�[L8/9��k[#FIHN_`@\<E[�8WDWAW@^J1>1H �N@BD���� >$VWHN[$9P@^@BDiD/UN>#@BA,<EDG>1V/@*[1<E]aDWHNM � FWJ1U'_`@B[1[1< D/]YME<?>#@^JLHK>18/JL@)>1VWHK>

H=FIJ1@^FWJ1U'_`@B[1[1<EDW]=UNO&AW<E:Y@BDI[1<?UaDWHNME<E>kblJL@BAW8W_`>1<?UaDd9Zbi[#@B_`UaDIAdUNJLAW@^J�A/@B_`UNJLJ1@BMEHK>1<?UaD :=HBbdMEUa[#@\<E:=F UNJL>1HNDT>

_`Ua:YFPUaD/@BDZ>1[&UNOP>1V/@$AIHK>1H��&�$U ��@^jN@^J0<ED >1VW< [&HKFWFIME< _^HK>1<?UaDY<?>&<E[�@B[L[#@BDT>1< HNMW>#U*D/UN>#@>1VWHK>�<EDYH\[#FIHKJL[1@0@BDTj'< �

J1UaDW:=@BDT>�>1VW< [�JL<E[��e<E[�M?@B[1[�UNOfH)_`UaDW_`@^JLD mZHN[&_`UNJ1JL@BMEHK>1<?UaDW[�9P@^> ��@^@BD=[1FIHKJL[#@0jN@B_`>#UNJL[.HKJ1@�:YUNJL@�<ED/OQJ1@BXZ8W@BDT>

HNDWA�>1VW@^J1@^OgUNJL@ :YUNJ1@ [1<?]aDW<SR _^HNDT>)>1VWHND <ED�>1V/@ _^HN[#@lUNO0A/@BDW[1@lAWHK>1H���� >e<E[)OQUNJ*>1VW<E[4J1@BHN[#UaD >1VIHK>*���'�

�1�547m p�/���< [0[18W_^_`@B[1[#Os8WMf<EDGFIJ1U7_`@B[L[1<ED/] [#FIHKJL[1@4AWHK>1H=[18W_hVCHN[$H 4�GA/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>0_`UaMEM?@B_`>1<?UaD�����FP@^JLHK>1<ED/] <ED

H=M?U � �kAW<E:=@BDW[1<?UaDWHNM [#FIHN_`@\<E[�HNME[#U=_`Ua:=FI8/>1HK>1<?UaDWHNM M?b HKFWFP@BHNME< D/]��

pNp��

Page 130: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

���'� FWJ1U j7<EAW@B[�He>#JL8WDI_^HK>#@BAC�'�� UNO�>1V/@�[#FIHKJL[#@�AWHK>1H :=HK>#JL< ����VW<E[�_^HND�9 @@ � _^<?@BDZ>1M?bl_`Ua:YF;8/>#@BA

OQUNJ4[#FIHKJL[#@ :=HK>#JL< _`@B[)8W[1<ED/] >1V/@Y��HNDW_&%^Ua[*HNM?]NUNJL<?>1VW: �Sp�/�� �$VWUa[#@e_`Ua:=FI8/>1HK>1<?UaDWHNM�_`Ua[1>�[L_^HNM?@B[)ME<ED/@BHKJhM?b

<EDd>1V/@eDWUaD�� %^@^J1U�@BM?@B:Y@BDZ>1[<EDd>1V/@ AWHK>1H����VW@\���/�(J1@B_`UaDW[#>#JL8I_`>#@BA,_`UNJLFI8W[^m �$V/@BD � [1<ED/]a8WM HKJ$jKHNME8/@B[HKJ1@4JL@^>1HN<ED/@BA��$< MEMI9P@4A/@BDWUN>#@BAiHN[�>1V/@*OgUaMEMEU �$<EDW]��

� � � ��� � � q 0 �Ep t

�$V/@^JL@ � � � � � � _`UaDZ>1HN<EDW[>1V/@4R;JL[#>E� ME@^Og>@B<?]N@BDTjN@B_`>#UNJh[^m � � � � � � _`UaDT>1HN< DW[$>1VW@4RIJL[1>E� JL<?]aVZ>@B<?]N@BDZjN@B_`>#UNJL[^m � � � � � � <E[&H4AW< HK]NUaDWHNMI:=HK>#Jh< eUNOP>1V/@E� [L<ED/]a8WMEHKJ�jKHNME8/@B[ ����[ � � �fq�� t ��� � mZ>1V/@[1<EDW]a8WMEHKJ�jKHNME8/@B[�OQUNJ � ��HKJL@�HNMEM D/UaD�� %^@^JLUCqQFPUa[1<E>1<?jN@ t � !W8/J1>1V/@^J � � � ��� � �4m��$V/@^JL@ � <E[�H� AW< :Y@BDW[1<?UaDIHNM/<EA/@BDZ>1<?>kb=:=HK>#Jh< ����VW@�@�� @B_`>1<EjN@BD/@B[1[�UNOf>1VW<E[�A/@B_`Ua:YFPUa[1<?>1<EUaDl<EDY>#@^Jh:=[�UNO�<ED/OQUNJL:=HK>1<?UaDFWJ1@B[1@^J1j HK>1<EUaDCHNDWAiD/Ua<E[1@�_^HNDI_`@BMEMEHK>1<?UaDCOQUNJ$[#F;HKJL[#@)AWHK>1H �Sp�0$- � mWVWHN[09P@^@BDG@� 7>#@BDI[1<?jN@BM?bG[#>18WAW<E@BA �1�54'm�p�/ � �

��[�AW@B[1_`JL<?9P@BA4<ED "�VWHKFW>#@^J �7mN9PUN>1V*>#@^Jh:=[�HNDIA\A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[�HKJ1@.>1V/@BD*FIJ1U���@B_`>#@BA <EDZ>#U$>1VW@.[#F;HN_`@.[#F;HNDWD/@BA

97bC>1V/@)RIJL[1>2� M?@^OQ>$HNDWAdJL<?]aVZ>$[1<ED/]a8IMEHKJ�jN@B_`>#UNJL[����V/@4FWJLU���@B_`>#@BA,AWHK>1Hl< [$A/@BD/UN>#@BA 97b � � � � � � � �HNDWA � � � � � � � � J1@B[#FP@B_`>1<?jN@BMEb!��� >�<E[�HNME[#U)8W[#@^Os8WM7OQUNJ�[L<E:YFIME<EOgb'<ED/]0>1V/@�[L8/9I[#@BX78/@BDZ>�HNM?]NUNJh<?>1VW:=[ �$VW< _LV�$<EM MP9 @\FWJ1UNFPUa[#@BAiVW@^J1@Nm <EO�>1V/@ejKHKJL<EHNDW_`@*< [$[#@^>�>#Ul9P@*@BX78WHNM�HNM?UaD/]l>1VW@*FWJL< DW_^<?FIHNMfAW<EJ1@B_`>1<?UaDW[ �1��� ����V/@

OQUaMEM?U �<ED/]Y[#@B_`>1<?UaDCFIJ1@B[#@BDZ>1[�>1V/@�RIJh[#>0FIHKJ1>0UNO�>1V/@)FWJLUNF Ua[1@BACA/U7_^8I:Y@BDT>0FIJ1U7_`@B[L[1<ED/]=HNM?]NUNJh<?>1VW:��

� ��� � ���� � ���!� � � ��� � ����� � � ������ � �� � � � � � ���� ��� � ���

��D=>1VW< [&[#@B_`>1<?UaD >1V/@$_`Ua:=:=UaD HN[1[L8W:YFW>1<?UaD=UNOf]N@BD/@^JLHK>1<?jN@�:YU7AW@BMEME<ED/])<E[�:=HNA/@$U jN@^J�>1V/@$A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[

AWHK>1H�/ >1VW@�A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>1[ HKJ1@�HN[1[L8W:Y@BA)>#U�9P@&H�DWUa<E[#bM <ED/@BHKJ :=< '>18/J1@�UNO/[#Ua:Y@�qs:YUNJ1@&UNJ�ME@B[1[ <EDWAW@^F @BDIA/@BDT>ht

[#@B:=HNDZ>1<E_�OQHN_`>#UNJL[�q !�<?]���0 �Ep t ����V/@�D78W:\9P@^J UNO/[#@B:=HNDZ>1<E_&OsHN_`>#UNJL[.�$<EMEM 9P@�_LVWUa[#@BD\HN[�@BXZ8IHNMa>#U$>1VW@�DZ8I:*9P@^J

UNOI>#UNF;<E_^[�qQUNJ�_^ME8W[1>#@^JL[ht � ��VZ8I[^mN>1V/@�$�kAW<E:Y@BDW[L<?UaDWHNM7���'� �k[#FIHN_`@tq��$V/@^JL@3� _^HND 9P@0[#@^>�>#U)>1V/@0DZ8I:*9P@^JUNO'>1V/@�:=Ua[#>�[1<?]aDI<SR;_^HNDZ>f@B<?]N@BDTjKHNME8/@B[ q �$< MEM 9 @�HNA/UNFW>#@BA*HN[�9P@B<ED/]0>1V/@.[18/9��k[#F;HN_`@&<ED �$VW< _LV)>1V/@.[#@B:=HNDZ>1<E_

OsHN_`>#UNJL[�J1@B[L<EA/@!�&��V/@)FIJ1U���@B_`>1<EUaDC>#UN]N@^>1V/@^J �$<?>1VGjKHKJL<EHNDW_`@4D/UNJh:=HNME<E[1HK>1<EUaDGOgUaMEMEU �$[0[1< :YFIM?blHN[

� � � / � � � � � q�� � t �� � q 0 � nat& # L:;����� ?!� D��I�*)<�6 �� 1� ��4D3 �"#1� C �"#�0),A#I[?!�R�P��M��� �� � �0IJ1��J�(K�����4D �"#�0),A#I[?!�R�L�/MH���=1/���;�=1/?!����� ) ����A#�6 ��R��� - 1/������.*)<�4D?��E1[",A#IJ1/)2�=1/?!�������(�4F

pNp �

Page 131: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

2

1

K

1

1

T

N

1

doc

S (1)

term term

doc

term

D

termdoc

topic

Ttopic

TW E V−1(1)T

� �<> !.* # ��� � �7@^FIHKJLHK>1<EDW]=[#@B:=HNDZ>1<E_)OsHN_`>#UNJL[\qQFWJLUN>#UN>kb7F @��kAWU7_^8W:=@BDT>1[ht0OgJLUa: H=A/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>�_`UNJ1FI8W[

��V/@ >1HN[��r<E[\>#U [#@BHKJL_LV OQUNJeH � � :=HK>#JL< � � � HNDWA � [#Ua8/JL_`@�A/U7_^8I:Y@BDT>1[ � � � � m&[18W_LV >1VWHK>e>1V/@OQUaMEM?U �<ED/] @BXZ8IHK>1<?UaDiV/UaMEAI[

� � � � � � � � � q 0 ���at

8WDWAW@^J4[#Ua:Y@=_`UaDW[#>#JhHN<EDT>1[ �$VW<E_hV �$<EMEM�9P@YAW<E[1_^8W[L[#@BA <ED >1V/@YOQUaMEM?U �<ED/]C[18/9I[1@B_`>1<?UaD��Y��V/@=[18WF @^Jh[1_`JL<?FW>1[

�$<EM Mf9P@e8W[1@^OQ8WM�<ED��7@B_`>1<?UaD 0 ��/7m V/U �.@^jN@^J)>1V/@^b �<EMEM 9P@\Ua:=<?>#>#@BA <ED >1V/@\JL@B:=HN<EDWA/@^J�UNO&>1V/@ [#@B_`>1<?UaD,OQUNJ

>1V/@4F;8/J1FPUa[#@B[.UNO�_^MEHKJL<?> b!�

��� �� � ��� � � ��� ��� � ����5"�� � ��� � ��� � � � ����� ����� �

��VW@l<E:YFPUNJ1>1HNDZ>*<E[1[L8/@YUNO�OgUNJL:e8WMEHK>1< D/]iHNDrUN9���@B_`>1<?jN@ OQ8IDW_`>1<?UaD D/U � HKJh<E[#@B[^m�>1VWHK>\<E[Bm�OQUNJL:\8IMEHK>1<ED/]

>1V/@ _`UaDW[1>#JLHN<EDZ>1[iUaD � � � �� �[i>1V/@�9IHN[1<E[GjN@B_`>#UNJh[dUNO >1V/@�>#UNFI< _�[#FIHN_`@ �$VI<E_LV >1V/@ _`UNJ1FI8W[GJ1@B[L<EA/@B[

�.@^J1@eHN[L[18W:Y@BAd>#U 9P@\AI< � @^JL@BDT>^m H [#@BHKJh_LV,OgUNJA����� ��� ����� �$�%� � ��������� �$�%��� ��Ua8WM Ai9P@*J1@BHN[1UaDWHK9IM?@��$V/@BD

HK>#>#@B:YFW>1< D/]$>#U�[#@^FIHKJLHK>#@�[#@B:=HNDZ>1<E_&OsHN_`>#UNJL[����UN>#@�>1VIHK>�@BHN_LV A/@B[L<?J1@BA4[#Ua8WJL_`@��kA/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>�<E[�@B[1[#@BDZ>1<EHNMEM?b)H

[#@B:=HNDZ>1<E_.OsHN_`>#UNJ&_`UNJ1J1@B[#FPUaDWAW< D/]$>#U�@BHN_LVY_`UaDI_`@^FW>�UNJ�>#UNFI<E_ "THN[�[18I_LV <?>�[1V/Ua8WMEA\VWHBjN@�_`Ua:=F UaDW@BDT>�jKHNME8/@B[

FWJ1UNFPUNJ1>1<EUaDWHNM'>#U*>1V/@[#>#J1@BD/]N>1V qQUNJ�U jN@^JLHNMEM;OgJ1@BX78/@BDW_`bWt�UNOP>1V/@$< DWAW<?j'<EAW8WHNM �.UNJLAW[�_`UNJLJ1@B[#FPUaDWAW<EDW]�>#U\>1V/@

>#UNFI<E_ � ��V/@=[1>18WA/biUNO.>1V/@=AW<E[1>#JL<?9I8/>1<EUaDiUNO���UNJLAI[)<ED A/U7_^8I:Y@BDT>1[*VWHN[)HCM?UaD/]CVW<E[1>#UNJ1b �Sp.- 4/m�p��2�Wm��Ko�� �

��V/@4:lHN<EDGUN9I[#@^J1jKHK>1<?UaDfm;HN[0OQHKJ�HN[0>1VW<E[ ��UNJ��G<E[�_`UaDI_`@^JLD/@BAfmI< [�>1VWHK> �.UNJLAW[�<EDCAWU7_^8W:=@BDT>1[HKJ1@4HNM ��HBb'[

AW<E[1>#JL<?9I8/>#@BAe<ED=H�FPUa[1<E>1<?jN@BM?b\[��N@���@BA :=HNDWD/@^J � �KoWmWp.- 4�� ��� DZ>18W<?>1<EjN@BM?b\<?>&_^HNDl9P@�[1@^@BD=>1VWHK>&>1VW@^J1@�HKJ1@�OQ@��

J1@BM?@^jKHNDZ>��.UNJLAW[^m7OQUNJ�HNDZb=]a<?jN@BDGA/U'_^8W:Y@BDZ>�_`UaDW_`@^JLDW<EDW]eHe[#FP@B_^<SR;_$>#UNFI<E_Km'_`Ua:YFIHKJ1@BA�>#U >1V/@�DZ8W:\9P@^J�UNO

<?J1JL@BM?@^j HNDZ> �.UNJLAW[�����V/@^JL@^OgUNJ1@\<?>$<E[$J1@BXZ8I<?J1@BAG>#UlJL@B[#>#JL<E_`>>1V/@*[#@BHKJL_hVd>#U FPUa[1[1<?9IMEb HN[#b':=:Y@^>#JL< _4[��N@��.@BA

AW<E[1>#JL<?9I8/>1<EUaDW[��f��8/@�>#U�>1V/@.���'� FWJLU���@B_`>1<?UaD\>#UN]N@^>1V/@^J �$<E>1V4jKHKJL<EHNDW_`@��kD/UNJh:=HNME< %BHK>1<?UaD m >1V/@.[#@BHKJL_hVe[1FIHN_`@

OQUNJ�>1V/@U ����C�&O#���cb4:=HK>#Jh< G_^HNDi9 @)JL@B[#>#JL<E_`>#@BAC>#Ul>1V/@4UNJ1>1V/UN]NUaDIHNM ]NJ1Ua8/F �1� � �

pBnKo

Page 132: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

��DCUN9��#@B_`>1<?jN@*Os8WDW_`>1<EUaD �$VW<E_hVi:=H� /<E:=< %^@B[0[#Ua:=@*:Y@BHN[18/JL@4UNO�>1V/@*[��N@��$DW@B[1[0UNO�>1V/@4FWJLU���@B_`>1<?UaDI[�<E[

FWJ1UNFPUa[#@BA���� DZ8I:*9P@^J�UNO�:Y@BHN[18WJ1@B[�UNO�[��N@��$DW@B[1[�HKJ1@YHBjKHN<EMEHK9IM?@ � �'p � " >1VW@ !�<E[LV/@^J��k[��N@��$DW@B[1[ � �'p � mfUaD/@

UNO�>1V/@\:=Ua[#> �$<EAW@BM?b 8W[1@BAfmI<E[�8W>1<EME<E[#@BAC< DC>1VW<E[�[1@B_`>1<?UaD�����VW<E[0<E[H=:YUa:Y@BDZ>$9;HN[#@BAd:Y@BHN[L8/J1@NmIV/U ��@^jN@^J m

HNDZb,[��N@��.@BArHNDIA�[18 � _^<?@BDZ>1M?bd[L:YUZUN>1V UN9���@B_`>1<EjN@=OQ8IDW_`>1<?UaD _`Ua8WMEA 9P@Y8W[#@BA��Y��VW@ !�<E[LV/@^J��k[��N@��$DW@B[1[)<E[

A/@`R;DW@BACHN[

��� � �� � � ��

q 0 �1-Zt

�$V/@^JL@ � �\A/@BDWUN>#@B[0>1V/@ � � >1VdUNJLA/@^J$:YUa:=@BDT>$HK9PUa8/>0>1VW@4:Y@BHND��

� 9 Ua8IDWA/@BAdHNDIA,DWUaD�� %^@^J1UCD/UNJL: UaD @BHN_LV ��< [�HNM [#U�DW@^@BA/@BA >#UGFWJ1@^jN@BDZ>�AW@^]N@BD/@^JLHK>#@=[#UaME8W>1<?UaDW[��

��V/@ FWJL<?UNJ��7DWU �$M?@BAW]N@ OQUNJ >1VW<E[*AIHK>1H,< [*>1VWHK>e>1V/@G:Y@BHND UNO�>1V/@G_`Ua:YFPUaD/@BDZ>1[��.@CHKJ1@�MEUZU!�'<ED/]iOQUNJY<E[

D/@^]aME<E]a<?9IM?@ qs[L:=HNMEM�FPUa[1<?>1<?jN@\j HNME8W@ t � �Ko ��HNDWA,>1V/@ jKHKJL<EHNDW_`@ UNO&>1VW@eFIJ1U���@B_`>1<EUaDW[�<E[�J1@B[#>#JL<E_`>#@BA,>#UC8WDW<E>kb!�

��V/@^JL@^OgUNJ1@Nm;>1V/@*UN9���@B_`>1<?jN@eOQUNJL:\8IMEHK>#@BA VW@^J1@NmIOQUNJUaDW@*FWJ1U��#@B_`>1<?UaDfm [1<E:YF;ME<SRI@B[�>#U >1V/@*@B[#>1< :=HK>#@BAd>1VI<?JLA��

UNJLA/@^J:YUa:Y@BDZ>��

�lq � t p�����

p� �

������ � ��

p� �

������ q

� � � � t � q 0 ��/at

�$V/@^JL@e>1VW@eFIJ1UNFPUNJ1>1<?UaDWHNME<E>kbi_`UaDW[#>1HNDZ>=p � � ��HN[)HNA/UNFW>#@BA OQUNJ)>1V/@ J1@BHN[#UaD�UNO.[1<E:YF;ME<?OQb7<EDW]Y>1V/@ OgUNJL: UNO

>1V/@*[L8/9I[#@BX78/@BDZ>.UNFI>1<E:=<E[1HK>1<EUaD��

��:YFPUa[1<ED/])>1VW@$J1@B[#>#Jh<E_`>1<?UaDYUNO 8WDI<?>&D/UNJL: � � � pKm7>1V/@$[#>1HK>1<EUaDWHKJ1bYFPUa<EDZ>1[&UNOf>1V/@�UN9���@B_`>1<?jN@�:e8W[#>

[1HK>1<E[1Ogb� �=q �Kt� �

p������� � � � q

� � � � t % � � o q 0 ��0at

�$V/@^JL@ � <E[�>1VW@���HK]NJLHND/]N@:\8WME>1<?FIME<?@^J�HNDWA � q � � t � �� ��� � ���$V/@�D/UN>1HK>1<?UaDW[ �=q t�HNDWA � q t �$<EM MT9P@�8W[#@^Os8WMMEHK>#@^J$< DC:=H �7< D/]=[#Ua:Y@*HNDIHNM?UN]a<?@B[��

�.@B[1<EAW@B[0FPUa[1[1<?9IME@]NJLHNAI<?@BDT>09;HN[#@BAi:Y@^>1V/U'AW[^m/>1VI<E[0@BX78WHK>1<?UaDi_^HNDC9P@4<?>#@^JhHK>1<?jN@BM?bG[#UaM?jN@BAiHN[

� � ��� p

� ������� � � � � q

� �� ��� � � � t � q 0 � 4Nt

p

� � � � q � � � ����� � t � q 0 ���at

��VW@ejKHNME8/@ UNO�>1V/@=��HK]NJLHNDW]N@=:\8WME>1<?FIME<?@^J�<E[ � �� � � �� � � q �� � thm��$VW@^J1@ �� � HKJ1@Y@^jKHNME8WHK>#@BA�8W[1< D/] �

HK>e>1V/@lUNFW>1< :\8W: �1�'p � m&< � @!�i<E[eHd_`UaDI[#>1HNDT>��,��V/@^J1@^OQUNJ1@�<?>1[*@��P@B_`> _^HND 9P@=JL@^FIMEHN_`@BA 9Zb�@� 'FIME<E_^<E>4D/UNJ��

:=HNME< %BHK>1<?UaD6<ED >1V/@d< :YFIM?@B:Y@BDZ>1HK>1<?UaD �1�'p � �c� D HNAIAW<?>1<?UaDfm�HN[ ��@ �7D/U � >1V/@i[1Ua8/JL_`@B[ �.@iHKJ1@dMEUZU!�'<ED/]

OQUNJ*HKJ1@=FPUa[1<?>1<EjN@Nm�>1V/@BD � <E[)[1>#JL<E_`>1M?b,FPUa[1<?>1<?jN@Nm >1VW@^J1@^OgUNJL@lD/Ud[1<E]aD�_LVWHND/]N@ �$V/@BD <E>#@^JLHK>1<ED/]rq 0 ���at �$<EMEMpBn'p

Page 133: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

U'_^_^8/J �$�UN>#@\>1VIHK>�<EDd:=HNDTbd�#"��(:Y@^>1VWU7AW[>1V/@e[1<?]aDiUNO�>1VW@*Ua8/>#FI8W>1[<E[D/UN>< :YFPUNJ1>1HNDT>�HNDWAd< [$<EDZ>#@^J��

_LVIHND/]N@BHK9IM?@Nm�AI8/@ >#UC>1V/@=AW<E[#>#Jh<?9I8/>1<?UaDd[#b7:l:Y@^>#J1b!�e� D Ua8/J)HKFWF;ME<E_^HK>1<?UaD <?>)<E[�HND <E:=F UNJL>1HNDT>�@BM?@B:Y@BDZ>^m

HNMEM?U �$<ED/]�<EAW@BDT>1<SR _^HK>1<?UaD6UNO�J1@BM?@^jKHNDT>lAIHK>1Hr<EDW[1>1HNDW_`@B[YOQJ1Ua: FP@BH �7[l<ED6>1V/@CUa8/>#F;8/>1[ �$<E>1V/Ua8/> OQ8WJ1>1V/@^J

FPUa[#>#FWJ1U'_`@B[1[1< D/]��

�7UaMEj7<EDW]eOQUNJ$>1VW@B� UNJ1>1V/UaD/UNJL:lHNMfFWJ1U��#@B_`>1<?UaDdAI<?J1@B_`>1<?UaDW[�]a<EjN@B[�>1V/@4OQUaMEM?U �$<ED/]=<E>#@^JLHK>1<?jN@*HNM?]NUNJh<?>1VW:<EDC:=HK>#Jh< �OQUNJL:=HK>�/

� � � q�� �� ����� � t � q 0 � �at

� � � �� ��� ����� ����� ���� ��������������� � ��������� �"!$#&% ���('*)+��,-�/.102)3, % )34��/4657� !�# � 98 �:�;)+��5(��)+<+)34:=+>?.��/02)+�(���/>�=�5 ! )34 ���� ������@% ��)BA ! .�� #C )+5(�14�)+��,�=+> !$# =�5 ! )34D)+'E5(��� % �()GFH�/025 ! )34IAG=�� ! =+4:02� # 5H)DJ:4 ! 5LKD=+4:.I)+�(5(��)+<+)34:=+> ! 57KM)+'�5(���N02)3>�J:,O4 # )+'P � C = #(!�# A+�/025H)+� #Q�SRUTV�2WX Y8 ���S,�=�5H� ![Z;#(\ J:=��(�]�()�)+5^02)3, % J�5(=�5 ! )34 # 0�=+4 C �_02)3, % >`��5H�/.NJ #(! 4�<ba�c_d@e:= #� �Lf��gfh���i�kjml � j"� e���������� fn�gf �kjol;j"�Y

p )+5H�b'q)+�_5(� !�#E% =��(5 ! 0�J:>�=���) C Fr�/025 ! A+�b=+4:.s.:=�5(=;=+4s= %:% �() ZV! ,O=�5H� p ���^5H)34Vt7uE= % � # )34v) % 5 ! , !�# =�5 ! )34J:4:.:���@5(�:�wJx4 ! 5@AG=�� ! =+4:02�N02)34 # 5H��= ! 465-�i)3J:>�.1>`�/=+.15H)D= #(! , ! >�=��&=+>�<+)+� ! 5(�:, My 4x.����/.eY'*)3>�>`) � ! 4�<v5(���.���� ! AG=�5 ! )34w)+'gz:= # 5 yH{}|~RUTV�2W ex5(����= %:% �() ZV! ,�=�5H� p ���^5H)34oJ % .:=�5H�_�i)3J:>�. C �

f � �����Lf � ���r����� �k� �m� f��3�L�3���x���X�Lf � ���r����� �k�Q��� ���� ��+�B�f �����7�� � f�� �Lf��gfh��� ���� ��/�3�

��������� �M!�# =s��. ! ,��/4 #(! )34:=+>}02)3>�Jx,�41A+�/025H)+�")+'_)34�� # =+4:. ���7�3������� 5H��=+4 # 'q)+� , # =D¡¢. ! ,��/4 #(! )34:=+>A+�/025H)+�@5H)£=m¡¥¤s¡¦. ! =�<+)34:=+>Y,O=�5H� ![Z� O§¨\© v���� ��+�B� 0�=+4 C �-'ªJ��(5(����� #(! , % > ![« �/. C K¬4�)+5 ! 4�<N5(�:=�5&5(���A�=+>�J�� # )+'i5(����>�= # 5S5H����,�­O®�¯±°+­ �® � ° )34 ! 5 # 02)3>�J:,O4 # e²=��(��4���<3> ! < ! C >`�b02)3, % =����/.¬5H)m5(��� « � # 5_5H����,C �/0�=+J # �@)+'Y5(��� #H% =�� #�! 57KN)+'Y5(�:�&� ZV% �/025H�/. # )3J���02�2tX)3J�5 % J�5 #� _8 � !�#E! 4:. ! 0�=�5H� # 5(�:=�5]'q)+�_5(� !$#�% =���5 ! 0�J:>�=��0�= # �+e�=b'*= # 5E02)34�A+���(<+�/4x02� #H% ���/.N0�=+4 C �S� ZV% �/025H�/.m'*�()3, ���� �³3� t ���� ������ 

8 �:�"02)3, % J:5(=�5 ! )34:=+>}02)3, % >`� Z�! 5LK¬)+'^5(� !�# =+>`<+)+� ! 5(�:, # 0�=+>`� # = #-´���� ¡ � �¶µ¶¡£�±µ±·3¡s¸ � e !� � v!�#> ! 4:�/=�� ! 4"5(���_46J:, C ���¹)+'º5H��= ! 4 ! 4:< % ) ! 4�5 # e6=+4:.;5(���_02) # 5(>`K�) % ����=�5 ! )34 #]� ,O=�5H� ![Z"! 46A+��� #(! )34O=+4:.w,�=�5H� !`Z#(\ J:=��(����)6)+5 � =��(� % ���('*)+��,-�/. ! 49=o¡£t7. ! ,-�/4 #(! )34:=+> # J C #H% =+02�+e»��� ! 0 � !�#�# ,O=+>�>Y02)3, % =����/.D5H)m� ;|]#¡ � � �~5(���/495(�:�;. ! ,-�/4 #(! )34s)+'^�¼.�)3, ! 4:=�5H� # =+4:. # )¬½ � � ��# 0�=+> ! 4�< !�# � Z�% �/025H�/.I'*)+�@.�)V0�J:,-�/46502)3>�>`�/025 ! )34 #� s|E# )3J�5 % J:5�)+'^5(���N=+>`<+)+� ! 5(�:,Ne¾5(��� ! 4:. ! A ! .xJ:=+>¾. ! ,-�/4 #�! )34 # )+'^5(�:� % ��)GFr�/025 ! )34 #@# ��)3J:>�.02)3465(= ! 4 # )3,-� # �/,�=+465 ! 0;'ª=+025H)+� # e ! 4M��� ! 0��I5(��� ! 4:. ! A ! .:Jx=+> % �/=�¿ #-! 4:. ! 0�=�5H�O5(���w5H����, # �E� ! 0��M�i���(�

�/�+�

Page 134: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

'*)3J:4:. C Kv5(���-=+>`<+)+� ! 5(�:,�5H) C �@5(�:��,-) # 5_�(� % �(� # �/4�5(=�5 ! A+�O'q)+�S5(�:=�5 % =��(5 ! 0�J:>�=��S0�>�= #�# )+��5H) %x! 0��²5(�:� # �0�=+4m�����/025 ! A+�/>`K C ��02)34 #(! .����(�/.N= #^! 4x.�� Z 5H����, #&R[���+³ e ���GWX

8 �:�]4�� Z 5 % =��(5})+'º5(�:�_=+>�<+)+� ! 5(�:,NeV� Z 5H��=+025 ! 4�<b�i)+��.w'*�/=�5(J��(� # '*�()3, 5H) %x! 0]'q�/=�5(J:�(� #?!�# 4�)B� 02)34 #(! .Vt���(�/.

��� ������������������ �"!$#��&%'�(�)�*�,+.- /$�(0�12�314�*����� 56!)0&�7#'8���14�3���3���,9��3!)%

: !;�3<>=?8���14�3���3���

8 �:� # �/02)34x. � 02)3, % >`�/,-�/465(=��(K � ,�)�.��/> � ! >$>²02)34 #(! .:���E5(���@5H����, # = # =A@CB�DFE�Gm> ! 4��/=��E� ZV% =+4 #�! )34o)+'# )3,-� � ,-)+�(��)+��>�� #(#^! 4:.:� % �/4x.��/4�5 � 02)34:02� % 5 #/ ¹8 ���S5H��� ,IH�02)34:02� % 5KJ�,�=/Kw�(��'*���^5H)O=-5H) %©! 0 RU��� e ³+�GWX

N

N2

1

1

1

1

K

T

S

term

term

doc doc

doc

(2)T

term

Dtopic

doc

topic

(2)TW E U−1

L;MONCPRQTSAU�VXW a�� % =�� =�5 ! 4�<-5H) %x! 0QtX'*�/=�5(J��(� # 'q��)3,~�¹)+� .VtX'q�/=�5(J:�(� #^! 4N=�.:)�0�J:,��/4�5^02)+� % J #

a�� % =���=�5 ! )34 )34�5(���ZY�[K\�]^E¶¤`_�B�a�bc]d[K@�YOE¬,�=�5H� ![Z !�#O# )3,-�����:=�5 #(! , ! >$=��-5H)95(��� # � % =���=�5 ! )34�)345(���e_�B�a�bc]d[K@�YOE9¤fY�[�\g]^E-,O=�5H� ![ZI�ª# ����z ! < @�� ��3�  >h )B�i��A+���/eº5(���b�(�/= # )34s5(�:=�5_5(� !�#_# ��)3J:>$.m�i)+�(¿o'*)+�0�>�J # 5H��� ! 4�< #H% =�� # � % ) #(! 5 ! A+��.:=�5(=�� ! >�> C ��,-)+5 ! A�=�5H�/. ! 4m=O. ! �����(�/465�,�=+4x4���� }| '*5H���E02)3, % �(� #(#(! 4:<�5(���.:=�5(= C K

� � � �ji ��k ��l � �nmI�Y�po � ���� ����3�=�¡ ¤m¡ ,�=�5H� !`Zof � � � =+4:. % ��)GFr�/025 ! )34 #.q � � � e�� ! >�> C �S� # 5 ! ,�=�5H�/.ex=+0�02)+� . ! 4�<-5H)�5(�:��> ! 4��/=��?,-)V.��/>

� � � � � f � � � q � � � ���� �� · ����������O4�)B� 5(��� # ��5H5 ! 4�<m)+'^02)34 # 5H��= ! 465 # =+4:.9'q)+��,@J:>�=�5 ! 4�<N5(����) C FH�/025 ! A+�;� ! >�> C �O,-)+5 ! AG=�5H�/.M'q��)3,�=0�>�J # 5H��� ! 4�<�02� ! 5H��� ! )34 ¾8 ��� # J % ��� # 02� !`% 5 # � ! >$> C �^)3, ! 5H5H�/.w=�<3= ! 4 ! 4�5(�:���(� # 5¹)+'²5(��� # �/025 ! )34;'q)+�}0�>�=�� ! 57K

�/�r�

Page 135: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

� ��5EJ # 02)34 #(! .����^= # =�0�>�J # 5H��� ! 4�<-02) # 5�'*J:4x025 ! )34N5(���S5H��=+02�&)+' 5(�:��� ! 5(� ! 4Vt70�>�= #(# 02)BA�=�� ! =+4x02��,�=�5H� ![Z i������� �� �����

� � �� �� ��� � � ­

� ��� ���� ����3���������� �

� =����b= #�#(! <34:,-�/465rtXA�=�� ! = C >`� # e �@! ' � � C �/>`)34�< # 5H)N0�>�= #(#�� =+4:. � )+5(�:���(� !�# �+e=+4:.v­ !�# 5(���

02�/465H��� �*% �()+5H)+57K % � � )+'º5(���_0�>�= #(#�� e !� � ­ � ¯ ���� � � � ��� ¯ � �

� Y| # 5H)V0��:= # 5 ! 0_, ! 4 ! , !�# =�5 ! )34-)+'5(� !�# 02) # 5�'ªJ:4:025 ! )34wK ! �/>�. # 5(����'q)3>�>�)B� ! 4:< §�� tX5LK % ��=+>�<+)+� ! 5(�:, RU��� W

� � ��� � � Z�%»� ��� ��� � � ­

���B�¯ � � Z�%»� ��� ��� � � ­

� � � �k�"!�#%$'&m�)(»� �*� ��� � � ­ � � � ���� ��/�3�

� ­ � � ¯ � � � ��� � �

¯ � � � ��� ���� �� �+�

��������� � � � .:�/4�)+5H� # � ZV% �/025(=�5 ! )34±=+4:. 5(��� % =���=+,-��5H��� � !�# =9.:��5H����, ! 4 !$# 5 ! 0N=+4:4��/=+> ! 4�< % =���=+,���5H���/e.��/02�(�/= #�! 4�<-)BA+���]5(��� ! 5H��� =�5 ! )34 #�

8 �:��= C ) A+�&02) # 5 ���� ����3� 'ªJ:4:025 ! )34m0�=+4 C �S�(���^� ! 5H5H�/4m= # '*)3>�>`) � #� ¨§YZ�% =+4:. ! 4�<-=+4:.o.��/4�)+5 ! 4�< � �¯ � �

� e�)34���) C 5(= ! 4 # i

����� � �� ����� � � �

� � � � � � � � ­ � � � µ ­ � ­ � ���� ��/T3�� �� �����

� � � �,+-/. � � � � � � �� ��

® � �® � � ® � � µ �� � ��

® � ��0 � �

® � 0 � � ® � 021/34

p )+5 ! 4�<s5(�:=�5O¯ � � � �h��57628:9 ���`�;� e¨5(��� « � # 5@5H����, !�#@! 4:.�� % �/4:.:�/4�5&)+'^5(��� % =���=+,-��5H���-5H) C �

� # 5 ! ,O=�5H�/.e !� � �� �����

� � )� � � � � � � � �� ����� � � � � � �,<=!"8º�>$Q�

z:J���5(�����/e�. ! A ! . ! 4�<^�(�2t7,@J:>`5 !�% >`K ! 4�< C K � 5(�:� # �/02)34:.-5H����, )+'�5(���^= C )BA+�^� ZV% �(� #�#(! )34b=+4:.b�(�/=��(� =+4�< ! 4�<

)34���) C 5(= ! 4 # '*)+�^5(��� # �/02)34x.N5H����,� �� �����

� � )� � �� � ��

® � �® � � ® � � � � � �� � �

��0 � � 0 �� � �����

��® � �

� �® � � ® � �

��� ! 0�� !�# 5L� ! 02�S5(����5(� ! ��.;5H����, � ! 5(�N4���<3=�5 ! A+� #(! <34 a�)�ex5(����0�>�= #(#(!`« 0�=�5 ! )34m02) # 5��(���^� ! 5H� # = #����� � � �� �����

� � � � �� � ��

® � ��0 � �

® � 0 � � ® � 0 µ <=!?8º�>$

� � �� ��® �

� � ��® ­ � � ®:µ <=!"8º�>$Q� ���� ��/³3�

�/� ·

Page 136: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

§¹\ J ! AG=+>`�/465(>`K+e ���� ��/�3� t ���� �� �+� e²'*)+�^�/=+0��v­�(����� ! 5H� # = #

� � ­ � �[�r����� �¶�������� � � ��� �k�"!�#%$'&m�)(»� � ­ � �[������� �k� ���� ������­ ���r����� � �� � � � � ­ � �[������� �k� ���� ��V�B�

���������&5(��� �"!�#%$'&m�)( '*Jx4:025 ! )34s=+025 # 02)3>�J:,O4�� !$# �&=+4:. � !�# 5(���b� # 5 ! ,�=�5H�/.D4�J:, C ���])+'¹.:=�5(= % ) ! 465 #5(���@0�>�= #(# �o!�# ��� #H% )34 #(! C >��]'*)+� ?8 � !$#^!�#�# 5H� ! 025(>`K % ) #(! 5 ! A+�+e:5(�:���(��'q)+���@.�)�� # 4:)+5E=+>`5H���]5(����. ! �(�/025 ! )34m)+'­

=+4:.v0�=+4 C �b02)3, C ! 4��/.£� ! 5(� � ! 4£5(��� �>!�#%$7&m��( 4�)+� ,�=+> !�# =�5 ! )34 4��b0�=+4v5(�����(��'*)+�(�b4�)+5 ! 02�b5(���

=+4:=+>`)+<+)3J # '*)+��,¼)+'¾5(� !�# =+>`<+)+� ! 5(�:,¼5H) ���� �T3� ex5(�:��,�= ! 4N. ! �����(�/4x02� C � ! 4:<@5(�:� �>!�#%$7&m��( 4:)34:> ! 4��/=�� ! 57K y 4¶,�=�¿ ! 4�<M5(�:�£�(�/>$=�5 ! )34±5H)I5(�:� % �(��A ! )3J #"# �/025 ! )34¶,-)+�(�¬= %:% =��(�/465�eE02)34 #(! .����w= # ��5w)+' C ! 4x=��(K

0�>�= #(#�![« ��� # � =�5(������5(�:=+49)34��O,@J:>`5 ! 0�>$= #(# 0�>�= #(#�![« ���/eº=+4 ! .��/=N�E� ! 0��9�:= # C ���/4 # J:0�02� #(# 'ªJ:>�>`K£�/, % >`) K+�/.! 4 R[�+�/³ e �r�GW 'q)+� # J % ���(A !�# �/.N0�>�= #(#�![« 0�=�5 ! )34 aVJ:0 �o=+4oJx4 # J % ���(A !�# �/. C ! 4x=��(K;0�>$= #(#(![« ���E0�=+4 C � # ���/4v= #)34����_=+J #(#(! =+4m.��/4 #(! 57K;� # 5 ! ,�=�5H)+�]� \ J !`%:% �/.w� ! 5(�m=+4o)3J�5(> ! �����(��Fr�/025H)+� z:)+�E�/=+0 �£)+'¾5(��� # �+ex5(�����(�@=��(�� .:=�5(= # =+, % >`� # )3J:5�)+'Y��� ! 0�� �� =��(�@)3J�5(> ! ��� #/ �8 ��� ! 4:. ! A ! .:Jx=+>�02) # 5]'ªJ:4:025 ! )34 # 5H)N, ! 4 ! , !�� ���:=BA+�5(����'*)+��, � ����� �� � �� ����� � � ��� � � ­ � � ���� ��+�3���������� � � =��(� C ! 4:=���Km= #(#(! <34:,��/4�5]AG=�� ! = C >`� # e�� ! 5(�£5(���bA�=+>�J�� �@! ' � � C �/>`)34�< # 5H)w5(���-0�>�J # 5H���S=+4:. �)+5(�����(� !�# �

� K #(! , ! >�=��¨,O=+4 !`% J:>$=�5 ! )34 # = # '*)+�i5(�:�],@J:>`5 ! 0�>$= #(# 0�= # �+e # ���/4 % �(��A ! )3J # >`K+e�=+4x.O5(=�¿ ! 4�<b¡ � � eV5(� !�#!�# � \ J ! A�=+>`�/465?5H)O,�= Z�! , !�� �S5(���S) C Fr�/025 ! A+�

´���� � �� � �� ����� � � ­ � � � ���� ��r�3�{ )3, % =�� ! 4�< ���� ��+�3� 5H) ���� ��r�3� �����/4�¡ � � )34��¹0�=+4&=+> # ) # ���¹5(�:=�5 ! 5 !�# 4�)+5º=��(� # 5H� ! 025 ! )34S5H) ! , % ) # �gJ:4 ! 54�)+��, )34-­ve C �/0�=+J # �i� ! 5(�b5(� !�# 02)34 # 5H� = ! 4�5g)34:� !�#g# 5 ! >�>�, ! 4 ! , !��/! 4:<�= \ Jx=+4�5 ! 5LK&�E� ! 0�� !�#¾% �() % )+�(5 ! )34:=+>5H) ���� ��+�3�  ��±! 5(�N5(� !�# 02)34 # 5H��= ! 465�e:5(���}FH) C )+'»5(��� � tX5(�m02)3, % )34��/465^)+'¾5(����, !`Z 5(J����+e:=+>`)34��+e !�#

��� ­ � �k�¥� �B����& !G�7��� � ­ � �k� ���� �� · �­

� ����� ­ � � � � ���� ����3�­

� ­ ����� ­

��� ���� ��+�3����������S5(����. ! A !�#(! )34 C K �

�i= # �(� % >�=+02�/. C K;5(����4�)+��,�=+> !�# =�5 ! )34

�/���

Page 137: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

p )B� 5(���&= C ) A+�@0�=+4 C ��) C 5(= ! 4��/.o� Z =+025(>�K C K # �/=���0 � ! 4�<"'q)+�]= % ��)GFr�/025 ! )34£­�E� ! 0��o,�= ZV! , !�� � #

5(����'*)3>�>`) � ! 4�<@) C FH�/025 ! A+� ! 4w5(��� % �()GFH�/025 ! )34 # C K «:Z �/. % ) ! 4�5 ! 5H��� =�5 ! )34 # i� � ­

�¨� �� ����� >`)+< �r� µI� Z�%»� � ­ � � � �H� µ <=!?8º�>$ � ���� ����+�� ! 5(�o5(���&02)34 # 5H��= ! 465�)+'Y­ � ­ � ��! 4o5(��� # =+,����}=/Ko= # �i= #E% �(� # �/4�5H�/. ! 4m5(�:� % �(��A ! )3J #�# �/025 ! )34 ^y 4# J:,O,�=��(K+e�5(�:�^�(�/= # )34O'q)+�¹5(��� # �E02)34 #(! .�����=�5 ! )34 # �}= # 5H) # ��)B� 5(�:=�5 ! 4:.����/. ���� ����+�¹!�# 0�>`�/=�� >`K-= # ¿+���i�/.� 4�)34Vt # K�,�,���5H� ! 0�=+> � e�,-)34�)+5H)34 ! 0�=+>�>`K ! 4x02�(�/= #(! 4�<O'*J:4x025 ! )34o)+' �

]8 � !�#]! 4:. ! 0�=�5H� # 5(�:=�5]�¹�-,�=BK£��) % �5(�:=�5i=+4"= # KV,�,-��5H� ! 0�=+>:)+� # ¿+���i�/. % ��)GFr�/025 ! )34",�=/K"=+> # ) C ��=+4;= %:% �() % � ! =�5H��0 ��) ! 02��'*)+�}0�>�J # 5H��� ! 4�<S5(���.�)V0�J:,-�/465 #�

p )B� 5(��� !�#(# J:�E)+'©FH) ! 4 ! 4�<@5H)+<+��5(�����E5(����= C )BA+��0�>�J # 5H��� ! 4�<-02)3, % )34��/465 #^!�# >`��'*5?'*)+��02)34 #(! .:����=�5 ! )34 � ��'q)+��� % �()V02���/. ! 4�<�e ! 5_,�=/K£�¹)+��5(�s�(�/0�=+>�> ! 4:<"=w5(����)+�(��5 ! 0�=+>¾�(� # J:>`5E)+' R[�/�+�+W e²4:=+,-�/>`Km5(�x=�5_Jx4:.����_5(���H��rt # � % =���= C ! > ! 57K�J�02)+� % J # ,-)V.��/>�¸E� ! 5(�N¡ 5H) %x! 0 # 5(���S��=+4�¿6t7¡ � a y = #(#(! <34 # 4:�/=���>`KO)+��5(��)+<+)34:=+>A+�/025H)+� #5H)v57�i)v.�)V0�J:,-�/465 # 'q�()3,h. ! �����(�/465�5H) %x! 0 # =+4:.I4��/=���>`K % =���=+>$>`�/>gA+�/025H)+� # 5H)v57�i)v.�)V0�J:,-�/465 # 'q�()3, =#(! 4:<3>`�?5H) %x! 0�� ! 5(��� ! <3� % �() C = C ! > ! 5LK R[�/�+��WX ¾y 5 !�#¨! 4�5H����� # 5 ! 4�<�5H)@4�)+5H�+eV5(�:=�5¨��A+�/4 ! '�5(��� H��Ht # � % =���= C ! > ! 5LKCJ02)34:. ! 5 ! )341,�=/K C �;5H)�) # 5H��)34�< ! 4 % ��=+025 ! 02�+ei=¬0��:=�� =+025H��� !�# 5 ! 0 H C ��J # ��t7> ! ¿+�rJ # �:= % �w�x= #�! 4:.����/. C ���/4) C # ����A+�/. ! 4O5(���_>`) �¶. ! ,-�/4 #(! )34:=+> � a % ��)GFr�/025H�/.w.�)V0�J:,-�/465i02)3>$>`�/025 ! )34 #}! 4O5(���S0�= # �_�����/4"5(���E5H) %©! 0 #=��(�-0�>`�/=���>�Km. !�# 5 ! 4x025 z ! < ��� �� .��/,-)34 # 5H��=�5H� # =+4v� Z =+, % >`�&)+'¨5(���@0 �:=���=+025H��� !$# 5 ! 0 # �:= % ��)+'i= # ��5])+'.�)V0�J:,-�/465 # 02)34�5(= ! 4 ! 4�<-4���� # <+��)3J % ,�� #(# =�<+� # )34;57�i)�. !�# 5 ! 4:025 �ª! 4:.�� % �/4:.��/465 � 5H) %©! 0 #�� H�02�(K % 5H)+<+��=Gt% �6KCJ©=+4:. H #H% =+02�rJ �¢% ) #�# � #(# � # �����/4 % �()GFr�/025H�/. ! 465H)"= � t7d � a #(% =+02� ^| A+)�0�= C J:>�=��(Kw)+' T��+� 5H��� , #�}= # �/, % >`)BK+�/."'*)+�i<+�/4:����=�5 ! 4�<&5(� !�#¹% >`)+5¹=+4x. ���+� .�)V0�J:,-�/465 ! 4 # 5(=+4:02� # =���� % ��� # �/4�5i'*�()3, �/=+0 �;)+'²5(���0�>�= #(# � #� 5(�����_� Z =+, % >`� # 0�=+4 C ���/4 # ���/4 ! 4£� < 5(���bJ %:% ���_>`��'q5 % >`)+5E)+'¹z ! < ��� ��� �! 4£5(��� % �(��A ! )3J #0��x= % 5H���/e)+� ! 4vz ! < ��� ·w>$=�5H��� ! 4o5(� !�# 0 �:= % 5H��� aV)3,-�b)+'Y5(��� « <3J��(� #]! 4 RU³+�GW =+> # )w.��/,-)34 # 5H��=�5H�b5(� !�#'*�/=�5(J��(��5(����)3J�<3��)3J�5

8 �:���(��'q)+��� ! 5 !�# �(�/= # )34:= C >`�v5H) # �/=���0��±'*)+� # )3,��o)+�(5(��)34:)+��,�=+>]= Z � # =+>`)34�<M��� ! 0 � 5(���s.:=�5(= !�#=+> ! <34:�/.s�����/4;FH) ! 4 ! 4:<;5H)+<+��5(�:���&5(���". ! �����(�/4�5�0�>$J # 5H��� ! 4:<m02)3, % )34��/4�5 #/ z��()3, = % ��=+025 ! 0�=+> % ) ! 4�5S)+'A ! ����e ! , % ) #(! 4�<_)+�(5(��)+<+)34x=+> ! 57KO)+'5(��� % ��)GFr�/025 ! )34 # � ! >$>�=+> # )&�x=/A+�]5(����<+�(�/=�5 C �/4�� « 5Y)+'�/4 # J�� ! 4:<S5(�:=�5�/=+0��±0�>�J # 5H����)+� # )3J�� 02�o02)3, % )34��/465 !�# . ! �����(�/465�=+4:. =+> # )D�(� # 5H� ! 025 # 5(��� % =�� =+,-��5H��� # �/=�� 0�� #(% =+02�+e#H% ���/. ! 4:<_J % 02)34�A+����<+�/4:02� � '�02)3J�� # �+e�= #(# J:, ! 4�<_5(��� # =+,���J:4 ! 5g4�)+� , 'q)+�i=+>�>�­

% =�� =+,-��5H���¨A+�/025H)+� #�������� ����������������������� �����"!$#&%'�(�� ����)�+*,���.-�/1032��4����5768#:9<;+/1�$=3�>�(�@?:+=A?��@������BDC>���:���(�(E��� ��?����F03�$?�2F���+�)2F?�+ ����

GIH ;�JLKM�(N?�2O�P?QBDC��P�����R��?��O��� �$ST�,���VU&+� WE?Q��WO�T=V��3���+�)2X?�+ ���� G ?�2,�Q?��?)�+�Y ,��+*O�+*,��� �$?ZS G �+�(�(��[.W,�3?�:?�2��3?��@�����A� W\BDC���Q��?Q�����+�&?�;^]_#�`

�/�+�

Page 138: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

0 2 4 6 8−4

−2

0

2

4

6

8

10

L;MONCPRQTSpU�V�� { �:=���=+025H��� !$# 5 ! 0 # �:= % �£)+' � t7d � a |�% ��)GFr�/025 ! )34±)+'�=1.�)V0�J:,-�/465 # ��5N02)34�5(= ! 4 ! 4�<I57�i). !�# 5 ! 4:025}5H) %x! 0S0�>�= #�# � #�� H�02�(K % 5H)+<+��= % �6K�J©=+4:. H #(% =+02�rJ � 

!�# � \ J ! A�=+>`�/4�5]5H)N5(���-= #(# Jx, % 5 ! )34£5(�:=�5S�/=+0��90�>�= #(# �i�b=����b>�)6)+¿ ! 4�<;'q)+���x= # 5(�:� # =+,-��02)3, % =+025(4�� #�# e= # ­ � ­ � ���C ¯ ���� ¯ �0 � �

® � 0 � � ® � 0 � � � � � � � � � �������(�@= # �/=���> ! ���/e � � � .��/4�)+5H� # � ZV% �/025(=�5 ! )34 � e

!� � 5(����,��/= # J��(�?)+'02)3, % =+025(4:� #(#¹! 4 #(! .��i5(��� � tX5(�"0�>�J # 5H��� »8 � !�#g!�# 4:=�5(J:��=+>�>`K}F(J # 5Y=+4"= %:% �() ZV! ,�=�5 ! )34,�=+.�� C KO5(��� % ��) % ) # �/. % �()GFr�/025 ! )34;,���5(��)�.²e��E� ! 0��w0�=+4 C �_,-)+5 ! A�=�5H�/. C K # �/=���0�� ! 4�<b'q)+� # �/>`'$t #�! , ! >�=��0�>�J # 5H��� #� jh ) �¹��A+���?5(�:� % � ! 4:0 !`% =+>�,-)+5 ! AG=�5 ! )34")+'5(� !�# = #(# J:, % 5 ! )34 !�# 5(��� #(! , % > ! 0 ! 57K&)+'²02)3, % J�5(=�5 ! )34 #=+4:.k02)3J:>$. ��A+�/465(J:=+>�>�K C �s�(�/>�= Z �/. ! 4±'*J:�(5(�����N.���A+�/>`) % ,��/4�5 #� ~§¹#(# �/465 ! =+>�>`K ���x=�5 !�# <3= ! 4��/.¶'*�()3,02)34 #(! .���� ! 4�<O5(� !�# 02)34:4��/025 ! )34 C ��57�i���/4¬02�/465H��=+>¾0�>�J # 5H��� ! 4�<"=+4:.s0�>�J # 5H��� ! 4�< C K % �()GFr�/025 ! )34 !$# 5(�x=�5E�i�=��(�¨4:)B�9= C >��g5H)�'*)+��,&Jx>�=�5H� ! 4_5H����, # )+' # 5(=�5 !�# 5 ! 0�=+> % �() % ���(5 ! � # ���x=�5�¹�¨=����¨>`)�)+¿ ! 4:<i'*)+�º�E���/4S= %:% >`K ! 4�<5(��� % �()GFH�/025 ! )34 C = # �/. y({}| ,-��5(��)V.m5H);5(���&= %x% �()3=+0��:�/.o5(= # ¿ ^8 � !$#?% �() A ! .:� # C )+5(� ! 465H��� % ����5(= C ! > ! 5LK)+'Y5(���&�(� # J:>�5 # =+4:.vJ:4:.:��� # 5(=+4:. ! 4�<b)+'Y���:=�5]02)3J:>�. C �&'*J:�(5(����� ! , % �() A+�/.o)34£5(���b,-��5(��)V. ! 4 # )3>`A ! 4�<5(����5(= # ¿

a ! , ! >�=��}5H)�5(���&=+>`<+)+� ! 5(�:, % �(� # �/465H�/. ! 4w5(��� % �(��A ! )3J #?# �/025 ! )34ex5(��� # KV,�,-��5H� ! 0�=+>'q)+� ,~)+' ���� �� · � t���� ��+�3� 0�=+4 C �}�^� ! 5H5H�/4e+�(� % >$=+0 ! 4�<]5(��� « 4:=+> # 5H� % )+'�4�)+��,O=+> !�# =�5 ! )34 C K&5(��� # K�,�,���5H� ! 0�=+>V.��/02)+�(�(�/>$=�5 ! )34f � f � �Lf��gfh� � ¹y 5�0�=+4 C � # ���/4m5(�:=�5^5(�:��) C 5(= ! 4��/.£=+>`<+)+� ! 5(�x, . ! ����� # '*�()3, 5(�:=�5 % �(� # �/465H�/.! 4¬a��/025 ! )34 � )34:>`K ! 4£5(���-4�)34:> ! 4��/=�� ! 5LKNJ # �/. S8 � !$# . ! �����(�/4:02�b��) �¹��A+��� !$# 02)3, % �/4 # =�5H�/.£'*)+� C Km5(���'ª=+025]5(�x=�5E5(���b,�= ! 4o'q�/=�5(J:�(�@,O= ZV! , !�� �/. C K C )+5(� !$# =;,-�/= # J����&)+'¨= # K�,�,���5H�(K Ey 4£)3J�� #�! ,&Jx>�=�5 ! )34 #

�/���

Page 139: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

5(���s= C )BA+�¬=+>`<+)+� ! 5(�x, % ���('*)+��,-�/.�� \ J:=+>$>`K1�¹�/>�>]= # 5(���s,-)3,-�/465rt C = # �/. # ¿+����4�� #�# 'ªJ:4:025 ! )34 ! 4 5(���% �(��A ! )3J #�# �/025 ! )34 N| 4�J:, C ����)+'?)+5(�:���@4�)34x> ! 4��/=�� ! 5 ! � # �¹���(�;=+> # )£5H� # 5H�/.e¾��� ! 0 �D=��(�;.���� ! A�=�5 ! A+� # )+'# )3,-�?,-)34:)+5H)34 ! 0 ! 4:02�(�/= #�! 4�<�) C Fr�/025 ! A+� # e�� ! 5(�&� \ J:=+> # J:0�02� #(#� g| �(�/= # )34b'*)+�»5(� !�#¾!�# 5(���}'*=+025¾5(�:=�5 C )+5(�5(���-)+�(5(�:)+<+)34:=+> ! 5LK£=+4:. % ) #(! 5 ! A+�/>`K # ¿+��� . ! �(�/025 ! )34s=��(�-A+���(K # 5H�()34�<N��� # 5H� ! 025 ! )34 # '*)+�S5(��� % =���=+,���5H���# �/=���0 � #H% =+02�+eº�����/4v5(��� ! 4 % J�5E=+4:.v)3J�5 % J�5S. ! ,-�/4 #�! )34 # =��(�b� \ J:=+>Xe²=+4:. !�# 5(���-�(�/= # )34s'*)+�S5(���-'ª= # 502)346A+���(<+�/4:02�@)+' 5(���&=+>`<+)+� ! 5(�:,

z ! 4:=+>$>`K+e ! 5 !�# =+> # )w5H) C �-4�)+5H�/.¬5(�x=�5�= # =N02)34 # � \ J��/4:02�-)+'}J #(! 4:< % ��)GFr�/025 ! )349,-��5(��)V. #��ª!� � .��2t02)3J % >��/.£4�)34x> ! 4��/=�� ! 5 ! � # � e©= # )�t70�=+>$>`�/.ZH�,&J:>�5 !`% >`�2t70�=+J # �rJ©0�>�J # 5H��� ! 4�< R[� · ��W 5(=�¿+� #S% >�=+02�+e !� � �/=+0 �¬.:=�5(=! 4 # 5(=+4:02� C �/>`)34�< # 5H) �ª!�# = #�# J:,-�/.-5H) % ) #�#(! C >`K C �?<+�/4���� =�5H�/. C K � =�4�J:, C ���g)+'©5H) %x! 0 # e64�)+5Y4:�/02� #(# =�� ! >�K5H)_)34:>`KS)34��+e3= #¾!�# 5(���}0�= # �})+'3H #(! 4�<3>`�2t70�=+J # �rJ R · �2W )+�g, ![Z 5(J��(�i,-)�.:�/> #� 8 �����(��'*)+�(�+e+0�=��(�?,&J # 5 C �i5(=�¿+�/4�(��<3=���. ! 4�<£=v. ! ���/025@02)3, % =�� !�# )34M)+'^)3J�5 % J:5�A�=+>�J�� # .:J��;5H) % ) #(#(! C >`Ks. ! �����(�/4�5 # 0�=+> ! 4�<�e¾��A+�/4 ! '?5(� !�## ���/, # 5H)��¹)+��¿O�(�/= # )34x= C >`K ! 4 % ��=+025 ! 02�S'*)+� % =��(5 ! 5 ! )34 ! 4�< ! 465H)�. !�# FH) ! 465i0�>�= #�# � #�RU³+�GWX a % �/=�¿ ! 4�<b= C )3J�5.�)V0�J:,-�/465].x=�5(=Ve)34�� # ��)3J:>�.o��=�5(�����_A ! ��� 5(�:�@,�=�<34 ! 5(J:.�� # )+'Y5(��� ! 4:. ! A ! .:J:=+>�)3J�5 % J�5 # = # EgY \7[�@���Y���E)+']5(���NAG=�� ! )3J # 5H) %x! 0 #o� 02)34x02� % 5 # �b! 415(�:� ! 4:. ! A ! .:Jx=+>Y.�)V0�J:,-�/465 # )+'E5(���m02)34 #(! .����(�/.102)+� % J #� 4��0�=+4v> !�# 5?5(���@,-) # 5E�(� % �(� # �/465(=�5 ! A+�b.�)V0�J:,-�/465 # '*)+�E�/=+0 �£5H) %©! 0 ! 4o5(��� # =+,����}=/Ko= # 'q)+�E�¹)+� . #�! 4o5(���% �(��A ! )3J #?# �/025 ! )34

��� ! % +&���&����� ����� ��� !'�*12�$�f��� 1 ������� ��� 1 �7� !;��� ���&%

8 �:� % �(��A ! )3J #b# �/025 ! )34 # �:=/A+� # ��)B�E4 5(�:=�5 C )+5(� 0�>�J # 5H��� ! 4�<s)+'_.�)�0�Jx,-�/4�5 # =+4:.1¿+��K6�i)+��. ! .��/4Vt5 ![« 0�=�5 ! )34 0�=+4 C �N=+0 � ! ��A+�/. C K # �/=���0�� ! 4�<s'q)+�-)+�(5(�:)+<+)34:=+>�e # ¿+���¹�/. % �()GFr�/025 ! )34 #� Iy 5 !�# .�� #(! �()3J # 5H)�:=BA+�"= #(! 4�<3>`�-=+>`<+)+� ! 5(�x,���� ! 0 �s�¹)3Jx>�. % �() A ! .:� C )+5(�D5(��� # �/,�=+465 ! 0-'ª=+025H)+� # =+4:.¬5(����5H) %©! 0QtX'q�/=�5(J:�(��(� % ��� # �/4�5(=�5 ! )34 # )+'}5(���;.�)�0�Jx,-�/4�5 #/ � =�5(���/,�=�5 ! 0�=+>�>�K+e 5(����Fr) ! 4�5�) % 5 ! , !�# =�5 ! )34 % �() C >`�/, # ��)3J:>�. C �# )3>`A+�/.

´����x�Lf � � 52f � � � �Y� � � � ��� � � � µ � � � ��� � � � � ���� ��+T3���������� f � � =+4:. � � � =��(�o5(���v�(� #H% �/025 ! A+� % =���=+,-��5H��� # )+'�5(�:� % �()GFH�/025 ! )34 # 02)+�(�(� #(% )34x. ! 4�<¬5H)I5(���=���0 � ! 5H�/025(J��(� % �(� # �/465H�/. ! 4�a��/025 ! )34 � ei��� ! 0��1) % ����=�5H� # )34 5(�:� _�B�aKbc] [�@CYOE ¤ Y�[�\g]^Eo.:=�5(=D,�=�5H� !`Z=+4:. f � � � =+4:. � � � � =��(�-5(�:� % =���=+,-��5H��� # 02)+�(�(� #H% )34:. ! 4�<"5H)N5(�:��=���0�� ! 5H�/025(J��(� % �(� # �/4�5H�/. ! 4¬aV�/025 ! )34·�eV��� ! 0 �O) % ����=�5H� # ) A+���^5(����Y�[�\g]^Ew¤�_�B�a�bc]d[K@�YOE�,�=�5H� ![Z� � �����¨!�# = # ,-)�)+5(�") C Fr�/025 ! A+�S'ªJ:4:025 ! )34e�'*)+�� Z =+, % >`� ���� �3�»% �() A+�/.b5H) C �¹���"0 ! �/4�5¾'*)+�»)3J:�Y= %:% > ! 0�=�5 ! )34 |]#¾! 5¾� ! >�> C � # ���/4 # �:)+�(5(>`K+e�5(��� # =+,-�}'*)+��,

�/�+T

Page 140: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

)+'Y) C FH�/025 ! A+�@'q)+� C )+5(�o5H��� , # )+' ���� ��+T3�]!�# 02)346A+�/4 ! �/465_=+4:.o� ! >�><+�(�/=�5(>�K #(! , % > ! '*KO5(���b02)3, % J�5(=�5 ! )34 #� 8 ���SJ:4 ! 5¹4�)+� , 02)34 # 5H��= ! 465?5H����, !�# )3, ! 5H5H�/.N�:���(�_'q)+�^0�>�=�� ! 57K+e ! 5 !�# ��) �¹��A+��� ! , % > ! 0 ! 5 8 �:�E'*)3>�>`) � ! 4�<# ��)+��5(�:=+4:.w� ! >$>�=+> # ) C ��J # �/. i

� � q � ® � � � � �� �� � � ��� � ® � �H� ���� ��+³3�=+4:. # )

´����©�Lf � � 52f � � � � � � � q � � � µ � � q � � � �¨� � �Lf � � � l � � µ � �Lf � � � � o � �� � �Lf � � � l � � µ � �Lf � � � � k � l � m1�

p )B� =��(�/>�=�5 ! )34 C ��57�i���/4 f � � =+4:. f � � � !�# �(� \ J ! �(�/. 8 �:� ! .��/=�5(�:=�5i5(��� ! 4:'q)+��,O=�5 ! )34�) C 5(= ! 4��/.�)34"5(���_> ! 4��/=��Y)3J:5 % J�5 # =+4:.O5(�x=�5¹< ! A+�/4 C K-5(���E�i� ! <3�65 #

=��(� # )3,������:=�5m02)3, % >��/,-�/4�5(=���K !�# � ! .��/>`K J # �/. ! 4 ! ,�=�<+�D=+4:=+>`K #(!�#¬R[�+� e �����3WX y 4¶)3J��m0�= # �95(� !�#�i)3J:>�.v,-�/=+4s5(�:=�5S=�'q5H���S� J:4:4 ! 4:<-5(��� # ¿+����4�� #(# t7,�= ZV! , !�# ���]'q)+�_� Z =+, % >`�b)34v5(��� Y�[�\g] ¤ _�B�a�b ] [K@�Y,�=�5H� !`Z e ! 4I=+.x. ! 5 ! )34M5H)¬5(���m0�>�J # 5H��� ! 4�< ! 4�'*)+��,�=�5 ! )34 ! 4I5(��� % �()GFH�/025 ! )34 # )34:�N�¹)3J:>$.M<+��5-5(�:�m,-) # 5�(� % ��� # �/4�5(=�5 ! A+�¬�¹)+��. # '*�()3,¥5(��� % �/=�¿ # )+'&5(���¬= #(# )V0 ! =�5H�/.¶�i� ! <3��5wA+�/025H)+� #���!� � ~f � � � � k � l �# ��)3Jx>�.1< ! A+� q � � J % 5H) # 0�=+> ! 4�< { )346A+��� # �/>`K+e C K % ���('*)+��, ! 4�<s5(���m=+>`<+)+� ! 5(�x, )34 5(���m5H� =+4 #H% ) # �/.,�=�5H� !`Z e©5(��� % ��)GFr�/025 ! )34 # �i)3J:>�. ! 4x. ! 0�=�5H��5(��� ! 4:.�� Z tX5H����, # e:�������(�/= # 5(���@= #(# )V0 ! =�5H�/.o�i� ! <3�65�A+�/025H)+� #�i)3J:>�. < ! A+�s5(���¬0�>�J # 5H��� ! 4�< ! 4:'q)+��,O=�5 ! )34 ��!� � ¼f � � � k � oN� # �:)3J:>�. < ! A+� q � � � J % 5H) # 0�=+> ! 4�< 8 ��� # �^57�i) # )3>�J�5 ! )34 # � ! >�>�0�>`�/=���>�Kb. ! �����¹=+4:.-5(��� % �() C >`�/, )+'�,O=�5(0�� ! 4:<�5(���^��� # J:>`5 # �}= # =+.:.��(� #(# �/. ! 4R[�+�2WX *� )+�(��) A+���/e ! 4m5(�:�&0�= # �@)+'Y' � u y .:=�5(= � �������(��5(���&5L�¹)w=+>`5H����4x=�5 ! A+�@=+>�<+)+� ! 5(�:, # =��(�&,��/=+4�5]5H)# � % =�� =�5H� #H% =�5 ! =+>©=+4x.O5H�/, % )+��=+>�.:=�5(=&�(� #H% �/025 ! A+�/>`K ��! 5i�:= # C ���/4") C # ���(A+�/. R[������W 5(�:=�5i5(���]�(� # J:>`5 # )345(���^)3J:5 % J�5 # �i���(��=+>`�}=/K #¨\ J:=+> ! 5(=�5 ! A+�/>`K C ��5H5H���¨5(�:=+4�5(��) # �^< ! A+�/4 C Kb5(����= #(# )V0 ! =�5H�/.O�¹� ! <3�65 # =+4x.-5(���=+.:. ! 5 ! )34:=+>�02)3, % >��/,-�/4�5(=���Kb02)34 # 5H��= ! 465Y)+' ! 4:.�� % �/4:.:�/4:02� C ��5L�¹���/4"5(���^�i� ! <3�65YA+�/025H)+� # �i= #¨% �() % ) # �/.5H)OJ:4 ! 'qKO5(�����(� # Jx>`5 # e�=-5H�/0��x4 !�\ J��S5H����,-�/. H #H% =�5 ! )�tX5H�/, % )+��=+> yH{}| J R[������WX

| 4 �/>`��<3=+465 # )3>�J�5 ! )341'*�()3, 5(��� % ��� #H% �/025 ! A+�N)+'_)3J��;= %:% > ! 0�=�5 ! )34 =+4:. .:=�5(=¬� ! >$> C � % �(� # �/465H�/.e= # �i� C �/> ! ��A+�@5(���-02)34:02�(��5H�-,-�/=+4 ! 4�<;)+'¨�/=+0��s�/>��/,-�/4�5 % ����, ! 5 # ="<+)6)V. ! 4 #�! <3��5 ! 465H)"5(� !$#�% ��) C >`�/, h )B�i��A+����5(��� # )3>�J�5 ! )34o)+'iJ:4 ! '*K ! 4�<-5(���b57�i)N02)3, % >`�/,-�/465(=��(K£�i=BK # )+' yH{}| =+4:=+>`K #(!�# = %:% > ! � # 5H)m=+4�K57K % �_)+' .:=�5(=b=+4:.w=+46KO57K % �_)+'²) C FH�/025 ! A+�S'*Jx4:025 ! )34 u^��5(J:��4 ! 4�<&5H)b)3J�� yH{}| % �()V02�/.:J��(�])34;5(���&Y�[�\g]>E¤ _�B�a�b ] [K@�YOEO,�=�5H� ![Z m e²4�)+5 ! 02�@5(�x=�5 ! 4 #H% �/025 ! 4�<�5(�:�@) A+����=+>�> # � % =���=�5 ! 4�<;�¹� ! <3��5 # '*)+�S5(� !�# ,�=�5H� ![Z e��� ! 0�� !�#

f � � � � k �gl � ���� ������/�+³

Page 141: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

�i)3J:>�.D,-�/=+4 % �()GFH�/025 ! 4�<£=N�^t7. ! ,-�/4 #(! )34x=+> ! .��/465 ! 57K¬,�=�5H� !`Z � ! 5(� ���� �����  £8 � !�#S! .��/465 ! 5LKs,O=�5H� ![ZD! 45H����, # )+'x.�)V0�J:,-�/465 ! 4 % J�5 # �(� % �(� # �/465 # ��)+�(5 .:)�0�J:,��/4�5 # ��� ! 0 ���/=+0 �b02)34 #(!�# 5 )+'x= #(! 4�<3>`�¨�¹)+��. RU³+� e ���BWX p )+5H�;��) �¹��A+���Beg5(�:=�5&5(�:���(� !�# = % ��) C >`�/, ! 4M.�) ! 4�< # )�e 5(� !�#�!�# .:J���5H)v5(��� ! .��/465 ! 57K¬,�=�5H� !`Z �x=/A ! 4�<5(��� # =+,-��A�=�� ! =+4:02��=+>`)34:<N5(��� % � ! 4:0 !`% =+>». ! �(�/025 ! )34 #�� 02)3>�J:,�4 # )+' l � e �������(�/= # 5(�:�O.:=�5(=N'*)+����� ! 0������ ����� �}= # � # 5 ! ,�=�5H�/.w.�)�� # 4�)+5 gy ' m �}= #?#H% �������/.O=+4"���"0 ! �/465 ! , % >`�/,-�/465(=�5 ! )34O� ZV!�# 5 #]RUTr�GWX gy 4")3J��= %:% > ! 0�=�5 ! )34N��) �¹��A+���/e #H% ����� ! 4�< m�! 4w5(���_� . ! ,��/4 #(! )34:=+> #H% =+02� !�# 4�)+5�= % ��=+025 ! 0�=+> # )3>$J�5 ! )34

� �/0�=+J # �")3J��&,���5(��)�.D�(� \ J ! �(� # )34:>�K£5(��� « � # 5�¡¦. ! ,-�/4 #(! )34 # �E�����(��¡ � � � eº5(�����(��'*)+�(� ! 5 !�#�/4�)3J�<3�"5H)-4�)+��,�=+> !�� ��5(���]A�=�� ! =+4:02�]=+>`)34�<@5(��� « � # 5¹¡ % � ! 4:0 !�% =+>:. ! ���/025 ! )34 #¨! 4 m� Y8 � !�# 0�=+4 C �].�)34��J #(! 4�<b5(���S�/>`�/,-�/465 # ��� ! 0��N=��(�&=/A�= ! >�= C >`�S'*�()3,~5(�:�S5H��J:4:0�=�5H�/.sa�c]d C K"5(�:��'q)3>$>`)B� ! 4�<b) % ��� =�5 ! )34 i

m�i � l k � l � m ���� �V�B�

8 ���",�=�5H� ![ZZm�!$# 5(���;��=+4�¿6t7¡ �(� % �(� # �/4�5(=�5 ! )34M)+'?5(���")+� ! < ! 4:=+>;Y�[�\g]¢¤ _�B�a�bc]d[K@�YOEN,�=�5H� ![Z� N8 ���

a�c_d¶)+' m�!$#(m

�� l oN� e35(�:=�5¨,-�/=+4 # 5(�:=�5 ! 4:.����/.b5(���^A�=�� ! =+4x02�^=+>`)34�<S5(����¡ % � ! 4:0 !`% =+>�. ! ���/025 ! )34 #

=��(�"� \ J:=+> �� 4�'*)+�(5(J:4:=�5H�/>�Ks�:)B�i��A+���/eg5(� !�# =+> # )£,-�/=+4 # 5(�:=�5&5(���O) A+����=+>�>iJ:4:, ![Z�! 4�<N,�=�5H� ![Z 'q)+�&5(� !�#4�)+��,O=+> !�� �/.m.:=�5(= m

��:= # 5H) C ��02)3, % J�5H�/. ! 4 # 5H�/=+.m)+'g5(�:=�5E) C 5(= ! 4��/.o'q)+� m � =+4:.o5(� !�# �i)3J:>�.m< ! A+�

J # 5(�:��02)+�(�(�/025�02)3, % >`�/,-�/465(=��(K ! 4�'*)+��,�=�5 ! )34²e !� � 2q � � ]�ªp )+5H�@5(�:=�5^5(���&4�)34Vt7=+, C ! <3J ! 5LK"A #� ¨# 0�=+> ! 4�<��)3>�. # C �/0�=+J # �@)+'¹5(��� «:Z �/.¬J:4 ! 5]4�)+��,�5(���()3J:<3��)3J�5 �� aV)�e�¹� # 5(=���5_=�<3= ! 4s'q�()3,�5(�:� C ��< ! 4x4 ! 4�<�e C K>`)�)+¿ ! 4�<_'q)+�¨=�,�=�5H� ![Z;f � �

� � ��� ! 0 �-,�= Z�! , !�� � # 5(�:�?) C Fr�/025 ! A+� ! 4b5(��� % �()GFr�/025 ! )34 # )+' m� ¾8 � !�# ,�=�5H� !`Z

! 4 � a | #(% =+02� !�# l �Rm�=+4:. # )O�¹����� \ J ! �(�_5(����,�= Z�! ,&Jx,~=��(<3J:,-�/465 f � �

� � )+'� �Lf � �

� � � l � m �� ���� �+�3�

� )+'¨02)3J�� # �+e©J:4x.�����5(���@J:4 ! 5E4�)+��, 02)34 # 5H��= ! 465 �  u^� % >�=+0 ! 4�<"5(���&=+4:=+>�K65 ! 0�=+>º'q)+� , )+' m�e©)34��&) C 5(= ! 4 #

'*)+� ���� �+�3�� �Lf � �

� � � l � l k ��l � m1�Y� � �Lf � �� � � k ��l � m �g� � �Lf � �

� � � � � � � ���� ! 0�� !�# '*)+�(5(J:4:=�5H�/>`KM5(��� # =+,-�N) C Fr�/025 ! A+�+e}= # =s'ªJ:4:025 ! )34I)+' f � �

� � ei= # �x= # C ���/4 ,�= ZV! , !�� �/. �ª! 4a��/025 ! )34v· � 'q)+�_5(���b02)3, % ��� #(# �/.v=+4:.oA�=�� ! =+4x02�2t74�)+��,�=+> ! � �/. � 5H����, # C Ko.�)V0�J:,-�/465 # � .:=�5(= m e=+4:. # )5(��� #�! , % >`�]�(� # Jx>`5 f � �

� � � f � � � !�# ) C 5(= ! 4:�/. 8 ��J # e�5(�:� # � % =���=�5 ! 4:<�,�=�5H� ![Z 'q)+� m

��:= # C ���/4N'*)3J:4:.eV��� ! 0�� !�# 4:)+5 ���� ����� C J:5 !�# 4�)B�

f � � � � l � ���� �r�3������

Page 142: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

=+4:. # )O5(� !�#?!�# 5(����02)+���(�/025^5H��=+4 # 'q)+��,¼5H)"= %:% >`K"5H)-5(��� ! .��/465 ! 57Kw,�=�5H� !`Z 5H)�< ! A+�S5(�:��02)3, % >`�/,��/4�5(=��(K! 4�'*)+��,�=�5 ! )34 �ª!� � 2q � � � 

8 � !�# ,-�/=+4 # 5(�x=�5^)34���4�) � �:= # 5(�:���(�/>�=�5 ! )34f � � � � l � �pq � � ���� � · �

� �_=+> # )�¿V4�)B� � C K-5(���E02)34 # 5H��J:025 ! )34O)+'5(��� « � # 5¨=���0 � ! 5H�/025(J��(� ! 4"a��/025 ! )34 �3� 5(�:=�5 f � ��� l �s�pq � � y 4m02)34 # � \ J��/4:02�+e

l f � � � l f � � � � f � � � f � � � 9 ¡�� �:� l �����H�¨����� ���� ���3���������� l ����� .��/4�)+5H� # 5(�:�¨> ! 4��/=��5H� =+4 # '*)+��,k)+'�,�= %:%x! 4�< C K l eG¡�� �:����� .:�/4�)+5H� # 5(���¨¿+����4��/>3)+� 46J:>$> #H% =+02�)+'¹=w5H� =+4 # '*)+��,�=+4:. ���O!$# 5(�:� # ��5�02)34�5(= ! 4 ! 4�<;)34:>`K£5(���-¡ ¤v¡�4�J:>�>[t7,O=�5H� ![Z� �8 ���bJ:4 ! 0 ! 57Km)+'i5(���# )3>�J:5 ! )34 ! 4N5(�:��>�= # 5^� \ J:=+> ! 57Kw'q)3>$>`)B� # 'q�()3, l C � ! 4�<b� ¤o¡ . ! ,-�/4 #(! )34:=+>�=+4:.m¡ � � � dE�/4:)+5 ! 4�<5(� !�# ,O=�5H� ![ZN#(! , % >�K C K f e:5(���S) C FH�/025 ! A+�&'q)+�^5(�:�iFr) ! 465?) % 5 ! , !�# =�5 ! )34w�(����� ! 5H� # = #

´����©�Lf��¨� � �Lf � l � � µ � �Lf � o � � ���� �+�3�8 �:�E� \ J:=�5 ! )34 ���� �+�3�}# �:)B� # 5(�:=�5?= #(! , % >`� ! , % >`�/,-�/465(=�5 ! )34")+'²5(���¹Fr) ! 4�5 � )3J�5 % J�5 # =+4:.;�i� ! <3�65 # �

) % 5 ! , !�# =�5 ! )34 !�#�% ) #(#(! C >`� ! 4M= #(! , ! >�=���,O=+4:4����@5H)£5(�:=�5 % �() % ) # �/. ! 4 RUTr�+W '*)+�&5(�:�;0�= # �w)+' #H% �����(�/.! 4 ! 5 ! =+>¹.x=�5(=Ve}4x=+,-�/>`K95H)M=+J�<3,-�/465-5(���o02)3, % ��� #(# �/. .�)V0�J:,-�/465�.:=�5(=¬� ! 5(�15(���m02)3, % �(� #�# �/.1�¹)+� . #.:=�5(= �8 � !�#�!$# .xJ��&5H)w5(��� # =+,��@'*)+��,n)+' % � ! )+� # )34 C )+5(�v5(���b�i� ! <3��5 # =+4x.£5(�:�&)3J�5 % J�5 #-� 02)34GFHJ:<3=�5H�% � ! )+� # �  ¾y 4 % � =+025 ! 02�_5(� !�# ,-�/=+4 # ��Jx4:4 ! 4�<�5(���S=+>`<+)+� ! 5(�:, )34:02�S)34;5(���S02)34:0�=�5H�/4x=�5H�/. R l � 5�oN�W .:=�5(=,�=�5H� !`Z� Yp )+5H��5(�:=�5�5(� !�# .:=�5(= !$# =+> # ) #H% �����(�/. � =+4:.m�x= # 02)BA�=�� ! =+4x02� ���� e:5(�����(��'*)+�(��)34:��0�=+4o. ! A ! .��5(� !�# .:=�5(=^5(�:�()3J�<3��)3J�5 C K�� � 5H)]4:)+��,�=+> !�� �¨5H)]J:4 ! 57K � e �E�����(�/= #¹R l � 5�k � oN�W �i)3J:>�.&4�)+5 C � #H% �����(�/.

|]# )3J:5 % J�5¨)+'5(�:�]=+>`<+)+� ! 5(�:, �i��<+��5}5(���],-�/, C ��� # � !`%O# 5H�(�/4�<+5(�"AG=+>�J:� # )+'5(���]�¹)+� . # '*)3>�>`) �¹�/. C K5(��) # �&)+'¾5(����.�)V0�J:,-�/465 # e:'*)+���/=+0 �o5H) %x! 0 ! 4m= # � % =���=�5H�@. ! ,-�/4 #�! )34 �]#(! 4�<-5(� !$#}« 4:. ! 4�<�e�5(�����(� !$# 4�)4����/.£'q)+�_,�=�5(0 � ! 4�<"5(��� # ��5L�¹)w'*)+��, # )+' ! 4�'*)+��,�=�5 ! )34m< ! A+�/4 C KN��J:4x4 ! 4�< # � % =���=�5H�/>`KN)34 m =+4:. mD� e= # �i= #¹% �() % ) # �/. ! 4 R[�+�/WX ¾y 4;=+.:. ! 5 ! )34e35(� !�#i# )3>`A+� # 5(���>H�, !�# ,O=�5(0��3J C ��5L�¹���/4ma�c_d =+4x. y({}| eV4:=+,-�/>�K5(�:=�5¹a�c_d ! , % ) # � # 5(��� # =+,��?)+�(5(��)+<+)34:=+> ! 57K % �() % ���(57K&)BA+��� C )+5(�b5(�:�^>`��'q5g=+4:.b5(�:�?� ! <3�65»� ! <+�/4�A+�/025H)+� #���������/= #¨y({}|k! , % ) # � #¨! 5 # ) C Fr�/025 ! A+�])34:>`Kb)34"5(���])3J�5 % J�5¨. ! ,-�/4 #(! )34 # e�02)3,�,��/4�5H�/. ! 4 R[�����3WX z��()3,¼=# 5(=�5 !�# 5 ! 0�=+> % ) ! 465Y)+'A ! ����e ! 4O5(� !�# �}=/K-�i�E�x=/A+�E�mµ ��# =+, % >�� # '*)+�¨5(��� % =���=+,-��5H���i� # 5 ! ,�=�5 ! )34 g8 � !�#!�# J # ��'ªJ:> ! 4o5(�:=�5 ! 5E,O=/K ! , % �()BA+�&5(���b=+0�0�J���=+02Km)+'Y5(�:�&�(� # J:>`5 #�! 4m5(���b0�= # � # �����/4£�¹�b=��(�@�(� \ J ! �(�/.

���V�

Page 143: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

5H);�¹)+�(¿o)34£= # ,�=+>�> # =+, % >�� #(!�� � # �9 �E#�! 4�<"=+>$>²5(��� # �b=/A�= ! >�= C >`� # =+, % >`� # e©5(��� % �() % ) # �/.o=+>`<+)+� ! 5(�:,# 0�=+>`� # = # ½ ��� ¡ �3� � µ �¬� µ ¡ � � µ �¬� µ ·3¡s¸ � � > ! 4��/=�� ! 4m5(���b46Jx, C ����)+'g5H� = ! 4 ! 4�< % ) ! 465 # �E�����(�5(� !�# 4�J:, C ��� !�# �1µ �M ��������� ����� ����

8 �:�O�(� # Jx>`5(=+4�5&=+>`<+)+� ! 5(�:,me»J #�! 4�<m5(���"5(� ! ��.D)+��.����b,-)3,-�/465 C = # �/. # ¿+����4:� #(# ) C Fr�/025 ! A+�+e !$# 5(��J #5(����'*)3>�>`) � ! 4�<

� y 4 % J:5 # i m e:¡� d]�/02)3, % ) # � m e�J #(! 4�< � =+4:0 � ) # JV=+>`<+)+� ! 5(�:,Ne��(��5(= ! 4 ! 4:<�5(��� « � # 5i¡ #(! 4�<3Jx>�=��¨A�=+>�J�� # =+4:.O) C 5(= ! 4l e k e oD

� � ��5 � � R l � 5�o � W� y 5H����=�5H�@J:4�5 ! >02)34�A+���(<+�/4x02�

q � f � ���r����� �f � � � q��;q^� �

f ���G�L�� � f � �Lf � fh� �� J�5 % J�5 # i

� q,9�� �� � ��� � �� f 9�� ���

���������S5(����4�)+5(=�5 ! )34 � .��/4�)+5H� # 5(���S�/>`�/,-�/4657� !$# ��,�=�5H� !`Z"% �()V.:J:025 8 �:� ! 465H��� % ����5(= C >`�;)3J�5 % J�5 # =��(� ! 4 q e¨4:=+,-�/>`KM5(��� « � # 5&� 02)3>�J:,�4 # 02)3465(= ! 415(���N¡ # �/,�=+465 ! 0

'ª=+025H)+� # =+4:.±5(���¬>�= # 5 � 02)3>�J:,�4 # 02)3465(= ! 4¶5(���¬5H) %x! 0QtX'*�/=�5(J��(�s�(� % �(� # �/465(=�5 ! )34¶'q)+�N�/=+0 �k)+'�5(�:� �.�)V0�J:,-�/465 #�

8 �:�?)3J�5 % J�5 f !�# J # ��'*Jx>65H) # 5H)+�(�+e�5H)+<+��5(�����¨� ! 5(�-5(���?5H��J:4x0�=�5H�/.;a�c_d C �/0�=+J # � ! 5Y02)34 #(!$# 5 # )+'�5(���a�B _ [ # J �;0 ! �/4�5¨5H)�) C 5(= ! 4 q '*�()3, 5(���^�/>`�/,-�/465 # )+'�5(�:�^5H��J:4:0�=�5H�/.Na�c_d �{ )3, % ��� #(# �/. ! 4�)34:>`Kb¡ ¤&¡�/>`�/,-�/465 # e f 02)3465(= ! 4 # 5(��� # 5H��J:025(J:�(� ! 4�'*)+��,�=�5 ! )34N= C )3J�5?5(�:� ! .��/465 ![« �/.;5H) %x! 0 # )+'»5(�:��02)+� % J #�

���+�

Page 144: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

� � />��%`�&��14�*�7!)��� ���*�&� �*�

a ! ,&J:>$=�5 ! )34 # �i���(�b��J:4o)34o5H� Z 5S.�)�0�Jx,-�/4�5 # '*�()3,�5(��� ���;p ��� # <+�()3J %©#�� 02)+� % J #� aV5H�/,�, ! 4�<;=+4:.# 5H) % tX�i)+��.£�(�/,-) AG=+>º�i= # = %:% > ! �/.w5H)"5(������=/� .:=�5(= % � ! )+�^5H)"�/4�5H��� ! 4�< ! 465H)�5(���@=+>`<+)+� ! 5(�x,NexJ #(! 4�<-5(���u�= ! 4 � )B���@5H)�)3>`¿ ! 5 @y 4¬=+>�>»� ZV% ��� ! ,-�/465 # eº02)346A+���(<+�/4:02�O�}= # =+0 � ! ��A+�/. ! 4¬=wA+����K£'*��� �n� t T3�_! 5H��� =�5 ! )34# 5H� %x#/ i8 �:� ! 4�5H��� % �(��5(= C ! > ! 57K")+'»�/=+0 � \ J:=+465 ! 57KN)+'¾5(���&=+>`<+)+� ! 5(�:, �/4:= C >`� # = # 5H��= ! <3�65H'*)+�(�i=�� .m��A�=+>�J:=Gt5 ! )34")+'5(��� # 5H��J:025(J�� ! 4�<�0�= % = C ! > ! 5 ! � # )+'²5(��� % �() % ) # �/.O,-��5(�:)�. Y8 � Z 5rt7, ! 4 ! 4:<�= %:% > ! 0�=�5 ! )34 # �:=BA+�_5(� !�#=+.�A�=+4�5(=�<+�b) A+��� # )3,-�@)+'Y)+5(�����S.�)3,�= ! 4 # ����������)+'*5H�/4v=;,@J:0��v� ! <3�����]=+, C ! <3J ! 5LK ! 4 ! 4�5H��� % �(��5(=�5 ! )34� Z�!�# 5 #�

y 4I5(��� « � # 5�� ZV% ��� ! ,-�/465�eg· p ��� # <+�()3J % . !�# 0�J #(#(! )34M0�>�= #(# � # �i���(�w5(=�¿+�/4 � H # 0 !� 02�(K % 5KJ`e2H # 0 !X ,-�/.3J`eH # 0 !� #(% =+02�rJx=+4:. H # )�0 ���/> ! < ! )34 0 ��� !�# 5 ! =+43J �  g8 = C >`� �� ��� ¹# ��)B� # 5(����> !$# 5})+'»�i)+��. # 02)+�(�(� #H% )34:. ! 4�<&5H)"5(���« � # 5 ��� <+�(�/=�5H� # 5 % �/=�¿ # )+'�5(�:��· # �/,O=+4�5 ! 0^'*=+025H)+� # ) C 5(= ! 4:�/.�J #(! 4:<S5(��� % �() % ) # �/.O,-��5(��)V. ! 4-5(��� « � # 5·b02)3>�J:,�4 #/ 8 ��� # ��0�=+4 ! 4x.����/. C ��02)34 #�! .����(�/.;= # ¿+��K��i)+��. # 'q)+�i5(���]·&5H) %©! 0 #¹! 4:�����(�/465 ! 4O5(���]02)+� % J #�

,-�/. ! 0 <+)V. #H% =+02� ¿+� !% =�5 ! �/4�5 0��:� !�# 5 ! =+4 4:= # = �/4:02�(K % 5K+�/=�� % ��) % > )+� C ! 5 # �/0�J�������/025 ��J�5H<+��� >�=+J:4x0�� <+)BA+����4. !$# �/= # 5(� ! 4:< .:= ! # K # 5H�/,.�)V025H)+� C ! C > , !�#�#(! )34 0�> !`%:% ���# 5(Jx. ! 0��:� !�# 5 � ! <3�65 0�� !`%���/=+>�5(� J:4:.:��� # 5(=+4:. �/4�< ! 4 % J C > ! 00�=+>�> 0���J���0 � # ��J�5H5(> � # 02�()B�5H� # 5 % ) ! 465 # K # 5H�/, .��% �6K #(! 0 ! =+4 \ J�� # 5 ! )34 # 0 ! �/4x0 >�=/�

��� �FS U3V �£8 ��� ��� ,-) # 5S��� % �(� # �/465(=�5 ! A+���i)+��. #S# �/>��/025H�/. C Kv5(��� % ��) % ) # �/.v=+>�<+)+� ! 5(�:, ! 4¬=N02)+� % J #02)3465(= ! 4 ! 4�<-·".�)�0�Jx,-�/4�5^0�>$= #(# � # i H # 0 !� 02�(K % 5KJ`e*H # 0 !� ,-�/.�J`e3H # 0 !� #H% =+02�rJx=+4:. H # )V0 �(�/> ! < ! )34 0��:� !�# 5 ! =+4�J

8 )I.:�/,-)34 # 5H��=�5H�£5(���v�(�/>�=�5 ! A+���x� ZV! C ! > ! 5LK ! 4 # ��5H5 ! 4�<M5(���£4�J:, C ���O)+'S5H) %x! 0 # e?57�i) p ��� # <+��)3J %x#� H # 0 !� #(% =+02�rJ?=+4:. H # )�0 �(�/> ! < ! )34 0 ��� !�# 5 ! =+43J � �:=BA+� C ���/4 0���) # �/4¶�E� ! >`� # ��5H5 ! 4�<I¡ � � e !� � >�)6)+¿ ! 4�<� 2E?(?� J ���P0^0^0�` ����` ���N� ` ���,���N?�����?���������W,� W,[���42E?(?� J ���P0^0^0�` ����` ���N� ` ���,�����@�������+���������P* �0

���r�

Page 145: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

'*)+� � . ! �����(�/465 % )+5H�/4�5 ! =+>Y5H) %x! 0 #� �8 = C >`� �� ��� ;# ��)B� # 5(��� ! .:�/4�5 ![« �/. � 5H) %x! 0 # 5(����)3J�<3�¬5(��� ��� ,-) # 5#(! <34 ![« 0�=+465 H ! 4:.�� Z 5H����, # J�'*)3J:4:. C K"5(�:��=+>`<+)+� ! 5(�x,

{ >�= #(#?yQ { >�= #(#}y(yQ { >�= #(#^y(y(yQ { >$= #(#?y c { >�= #�# c % ��) % >�� <+)�. .:= ! #H% =+02� # � Z0 �6J:��0�� ,�=+4 K+�/=�� # K # 5H�/, !�#(# J<+��)3J % > ! '*� 4:= # = # ��J�5H5(> 5H����,5(� ! 4�< >`)BA+� ,-)�)34 .�� #�! <34 # � Z J:=+>K+�/=�� 0���� !$# 5 ! =+4 F % > �(� # �/=���0�� C = #(!« 4:. > ! A+� �/=��(5(� 02) # 5 �(� #H% )34 #\ J�� # 5 ! )34 Fr� # J )+� C ! 5 ��J:,�=+4 ��)3,-) # � Z JC ! C > 0���� !$# 5 % =��(5 . !$# 0�J #(# �(��'*������/=+. ��J�5H<+��� <+)BA >�=+Jx4:0�� '*)+��4 ! 0'ª= ! 5(� �6J:,O=+4 �()34 .�� ! 465H����02)3J�� #!$#(# J # =/A+� A+�/46J # 5(=�5 ! )34 >�=B�

��� �FS U3V W 8 ��� ��� ,�) # 5&��� % �(� # �/465(=�5 ! A+�w�¹)+� . #&! 4M= # ��5@)+' � .:)�0�J:,��/4�5b0�>�= #(# � #N� J # 0 !X #H% =+02�rJg=+4:.J # )V0 �(�/> ! < ! )34 0���� !�# 5 ! =+43J � eV���:���(�S5(����4�J:, C ���^)+'»5H) %x! 0 # �i= #E# ��5^5H) ��

y 5¨0�=+4 C � # ���/4O5(�:=�5Y5(��� % �() % ) # �/.-=+>`<+)+� ! 5(�:, �:= # '*)3J:4:.-02)3�:���(�/4�5i=+4:.�02)3, % =+025¨�i)+��.-<+�()3J %©! 4�< #=+4:.m�x= #�#H% > ! 5}5(����.:=�5(= ! 4�5H)�Jx4:.���� # 5(=+4x.:= C >`� # �/>`'qtX� ZV% >�=+4:=�5H)+�(K # J C <+�()3J %x# e:� ! <3�:> ! <3�65 ! 4�< # J C tX5H) %x! 0 #��� ! 0��-�i���(� % ��� # �/4�5 ! 4b5(����02)+� % J #� g8 ��� # �?�i)+��.O<+�()3J %x! 4:< # 0�=+4 ! 4:.:���/. C �?�(�/02)+<34 !�� �/."= #¨# J C tX5H) %x! 0 #! 4 #�! .��@5(����57�i)£,O= Fr)+��5H) %©! 0�0�>�= #(# � #�! 4:. ! 0�=�5H�/. C Ks=m��J:,�=+4D>$= C �/>���� � 4���0�=+4D�/= #�! >`K ! .��/465 ! 'qK£5(���# 5H��Jx025(J��(� ! 4Mz ! < o�� · C K ! 4 #H% �/025 ! 4:< 8 = C >�� �� ��� oy 5&,�=BK C � ! 465H���(� # 5 ! 4:<m5H)v4:)+5 ! 02�"= % )+5H�/465 ! =+>�>�KJ # ��'ªJ:> % �() % ���(57K¬)+'?5(� !$# ,-��5(�:)�.e¾4:=+,-�/>�K¬5(�:=�5&5(�:� # 5H��Jx025(J��(�".:� %x! 025H�/. ! 49z ! < £�� · 0�=+4M=+> # ) C �! .��/465 ![« �/. ! 4w=+4NJ:4 # J % ���(A !$# �/.O,�=+4x4���� C K"5(����J # �_)+'º5(�:�S�(� #(! .:Jx=+>©.�� % �/4:.:�/4:0 ! � # C ��5L�¹���/4m5(��� yH{}|C = #(!$# A+�/025H)+� #Ef RUT+��WX ¹{ )3, % J�5 ! 4�<_'q)+�Y� Z =+, % >��?5(����02)+�(�(�/>$=�5 ! )34�,�=�5H� !`Z )+'�5(���^�/4:���(< ! � # )+'�5(��� C = #(!�#A+�/025H)+� #b�H�Lf �Efh� � �Lf ��f��H� =+4:.mJ:4 ! 'qK ! 4�<&5(����,-) # 5?���/>�=�5H�/.m5L�¹)�5H) %©! 0 # 02)+�(�(� #(% )34x. ! 4�<b5H)��/=+0 ��() �k)+'º5(� !�# ,�=�5H� !`Z eV�i�]) C 5(= ! 4;5(���_57�i)O. !�# FH) ! 465 # ��5 # )+' 5(��� # J C tX5H) %©! 0 # e ! 4O5(�:� # =+,-�_'q)+��,~.:� %x! 025H�/.! 4Nz ! < ¹�� ·

��� ·

Page 146: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

(II)space shuttle missionspace shuttle design christian morality

(I)(III)(IV)christian religion

soc.religion.christian

(V)christian church

sci.space

L;MONCPRQ S U3V�� dE� % �/4:.:�/4:02K # 5H� J:025(J��(�S)+'¾5(��� #H% > ! 5H5 ! 4�< ! 4 8 = C >`� ��

8 � !�# .��/,-)34 # 5H��=�5H� # 5(�:=�5 ! 4x.����/.m5(��� % )+5H�/465 ! =+>»46Jx, C ���^)+' ! 465H� ! 4 #(! 0]5H) %x! 0 #E! 4o=".�)�0�Jx,-�/4�5E02)+�Ht% J # 0�=+4 C �m<+�(�/=�5H���;5(�:=+4 ! 4:. ! 0�=�5H�/. C K =D��J:,�=+4 ! 4:.�� Z ��� �8 � !$# =+> # )9,��/=+4 # 5(�:=�5O5(�������C\gD Br\�D¿V4�)B��>��/.�<+�N)+'E5(�:�m46J:, C ���-)+'E5H) %©! 0 # e¹= #�# J:,-�/. ! 415(� !�# 0��:= % 5H���/e !$# 4�)+5�=s�(�/=+>^02)34 # 5H��= ! 465�=+4:. !�#4�)+5?4��/02� #(# =�� ! >`K�.�� % �/4:.:�/4�5i)34w�6J:,O=+4;>$= C �/>$> ! 4�< y 4:.:���/. ! 4O5H����, # )+'²5(���_� Z�% >`)+��=�5H)+�(K;=+4:=+>`K #(!�# )+' =.�)V0�J:,-�/465g02)3>�>`�/025 ! )34b���:���(�}�(�/>�=�5H�/.b5H) %x! 0 # e # J C tX5H) %x! 0 # =+4x.b�(�/>�=�5H�/.-02)34:02� % 5 # � ! 5(� ! 4@.�)V0�J:,-�/465 # =��(�C � ! 4�< # �/=���0 ���/.s'q)+�Be²5(� !�# ,-��5(��)V. % �() A ! .:� # 5(�:��0�= % = C ! > ! 57Km5H)N. !�# 02)BA+�����(�/>���AG=+465 # J C tX5H) %x! 0 # � ! 5(� ! 4.�)V0�J:,-�/465 # )+')34��]0�>�= #(#(!`« 0�=�5 ! )34 ¾8 ���^A�=+> ! . ! 57K@)+'5(��� # ��_�D EKa�B��r[�\7[7_]5H) %x! 0 # 0�=+4"�/= #(! >`K C ��0��:�/0(¿+�/. C K5(��� ! 4�'*)+��,�=�5 ! )34£02)3465H�/4�5S)+'¹5(���-,-) # 5_�(� % ��� # �/4�5(=�5 ! A+�-�¹)+��. #]! 4£=w,-) # 5S4:=�5(J:��=+>»�i=BKv= #_% )+�(5H��=BK+�/.! 4 8 = C >`� �� ���

y 4 # )3,-� #�! 5(J:=�5 ! )34 #»! 5»0�=+4 C �iJ # ��'ªJ:>35H) % ���('*)+��, =]� ! ����=�� 0�� ! 0�=+> % =��(5 ! 5 ! )34 ! 4�< z:)+�g� Z =+, % >`�+e ! '�)34��.��/=+> # � ! 5(�-=�02)+� % J # �:=BA ! 4:< # )3,-�^)+'�5(���^5H) %x! 0 # ,-)+�(�^���/>�=�5H�/.-5(�:=+4O)+5(����� #�� ��� ! 0�� !$# 5H) # )3,-��� Z 5H�/465=+>`�}=/K # 5(�:��0�= # � � e�5(���/4m5(����)+�(5(��)+<+)34:=+> ! 57Km= #(# Jx, % 5 ! )34N) A+���E5(�:� % �()GFH�/025 ! 4�<�. ! �(�/025 ! )34 #&� � \ J ! AG=+>`�/465! 495(� !�# 02)34�5H� Z 5-5H)£5(�:� ! 4x.�� % �/4:.��/4:02��= #(# J:, % 5 ! )34M)BA+���-5(�:�"0�>�= #(# � # eY= # �:= # C ���/4 % ) ! 465H�/.D)3J�5 ! 45(��� % �(��A ! )3J #i# �/025 ! )34 � ,O=/K C �]>`� #(# = %:% �() % � ! =�5H� 4��]�i=BK !$# 5H) % �()V02���/.;� ! 5(�w=&�(�/0�J�� #(! A+� #H% > ! 5H5 ! 4�<R[�/����W e # �/=���0 � ! 4�< ! 41�/=+0 � >`��A+�/>?'*)+�eY�(BD. !$# 5 ! 4:025@5H) %x! 0 #&h )B�i��A+���"5(�:�m.���5(= ! > # )+' # J:0�� = %x% �()3=+0��:� #=��(� C ��K+)34:.v5(��� # 02) % �b)+'i5(� !�# �¹)+��¿ b| 4s� ZV% ��� ! ,-�/465 !�# 4�)B� .��/,-)34 # 5H� =�5H�/. ! 4v��� ! 0 �£5(�:� # =+,-�-·.�)V0�J:,-�/465]0�>$= #(# � # �¹���(�-J # �/.e C J:5�5(���b46Jx, C ���])+'Y5H) %x! 0 # �i= #_# ��5_5H) �� ]8 ���@,�) # 5]4:)34Vt702)3, % =+025 �! 4N5(�:� # �/4 # �S)+'g,-�/=+4 #(\ J:=��(��. !$# 5(=+4:02� � C ��=+4:0��m'q)3J:4x. ! 4w5(��� % �(��A ! )3J # >`��A+�/>²�}= # 5(�:�/4 #H% > ! 5?=�<3= ! 4! 4¬5(�:� # =+,-�O,O=+4:4���� z ! < N�� �� w# ��)B� # 5(������� # J:>`5 # )+' % =��(5 ! 5 ! )34 ! 4�< z:)+�&5(���O�/= # �O)+'}� ZV% ) #�! 5 ! )34e)34:>`K¬5(�:�w.x=�5(= % ) ! 465 # 02)+�(�(� #H% )34:. ! 4�<m5H)s5(���w.�)�0�Jx,-�/4�5 ! 4 # 5(=+4:02� # =��(� # ��)B��4 ! 4M5(��� # 0�=�5H5H��� % >�)+5 #� 5(��) # � C �/>`)34�< ! 4�<-5H)"�¹)+� . # =��(�&)3, ! 5H5H�/. � =+4:.m5(�:�&. ! �����(�/465 #(! <34m)34o5(��� # � # 0�=�5H5H��� % >`)+5 # �i���(�@,�=+.��=+0�02)+��. ! 4�<£5H)s��J:,�=+4I>�= C �/> # '*)+�&�/= # �;)+'�A !�# J:=+>Y��A�=+>�J:=�5 ! )34 £8 � !$# 57K % �")+'E>�=/K+���(�/. % =���5 ! 5 ! )34 ! 4:< !�#=+> # )-J # ��'*J:>©�����/4 ! 4x.�� ZV! 4�<�'*)+�?'*J���5(����� # �/=���0�� % �()�02�/.xJ��(� #_R[�/��� e ���GW e�= # 5(��� # �/=���0 � !�# A+���(KO'ª= # 5 ! 4w=C ! 4x=��(KO5H�(��� # 5H��J:025(J����/.N.:=�5(= C = # �

�����

Page 147: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

��� � �(��14�*��! � �*! / -^% %'�j�����7#j1 � � ��#j! % 0 ! ��� �*��! �,5 ��# �&�&���$�����A9�!;� 5 ��� �

� ��1 � -$�*�7�

h =/A ! 4�<s'*)+��,&Jx>�=�5H�/.I5(���N=+>`<+)+� ! 5(�:, '*)+�b5(���&Fr) ! 465 � H #H% =�5 ! )�tX5H�/, % )+� =+>nJ ��yH{}| % �() C >��/,Ne¾5(� !�# 0�=+4=+> # ) C �oA ! ���i�/.�= # = # KV,�,-��5H� ! 0�=+>?�(�2tX'ª=+025H)+� !�� =�5 ! )34 )+'�=D.:=�5(=M,�=�5H� ![Z # 5(=���5 ! 4�<D'*�()3,�5(�:�m'*=+025H)+� #% �() A ! .��/. C KM5(���£a�c_d ¨8 ) # ���m5(� !�# e¹02)34 #(! .�����=�<3= ! 4 5(���N��=+4�¿6t7¡ �(� % �(� # �/4�5(=�5 ! )34 )+'E5(���N)+� ! < ! 4:=+>.:=�5(=",�=�5H� ![Zem e !� � 2m

�� l k � l � m � l o � iy 5 !�# ¿V4�)B��4o5(�:=�5�5(�:� � 5H��J:4:0�=�5H�/. � a�c_d '*=+025H)+� #

�ª#(! 4:<3J:>�=��}A+�/025H)+� # � 5(���/, # �/>`A+� # 0�=+4:4�)+5^�:=BA+��=+4�K # �/,O=+4�5 ! 0�=+>$>`K ! 465H��� % ����5(= C >`� % �() % ���(5 ! � # C �/0�=+J # �S)+'5(��� ! �b�()+5(=�5 ! )34Vt ! 4:.���5H��� , ! 4:=+02K D8 �:��K #H% =+4eY�:)B�i��A+���/ei=s> ! 4��/=�� # J C #H% =+02�;)+'�5(�:�w.x=�5(= #(% =+02�w� ! 5(�02)346A+�/4 ! �/465 % ��) % ����5 ! � #� h ) �¹��A+���/e:=+4:)+5(����� # K�,�,���5H� ! 0^.��/02)3, % ) #�! 5 ! )34-)+'º= #(! , ! >�=��g'q)+� , 0�=+4 C �^) C t5(= ! 4��/.²e3��� ! 0 �-�()+5(=�5H� # 5(��� #(! 4:<3J:>�=��gA+�/025H)+� # =+0�02)+��. ! 4:<S5H)�5(��� # 5(=�5 !�# 5 ! 0�=+> % �() % ���(5 ! � # )34�� #(% �/0 !`« � # )345(����4:��� '*=+025H)+� # e ! 4-)+��.����Y5H)�<+��5 ! 465H��� % �(��5(= C >`�^=+4:.�,-�/=+4 ! 4�<+'ªJ:> # �/,�=+465 ! 0?'ª=+025H)+� #� � =�5(���/,�=�5 ! 0�=+>$>`K+e�i� # �/=���0 �m'*)+��=-�()+5(=�5 ! )34o,�=�5H� ![Zvf # J:0��m5(�:=�5

m�� l o � � l f � f o � � � l f � �2�Lf o � �Y� i q � � � q � � � ���� ���+�

z�)+��� # 5 ! ,�=�5 ! 4�<v5(���N= %:% ��) % � ! =�5H�;�()+5(=�5 ! )34 f 5(���N= %:% �() % � ! =�5H�") C Fr�/025 ! A+�m�x= # 5H) C � #H% �/0 ![« �/.M)34q � � =+4:. q � � � =+0�02)+��. ! 4:<m5H)o)3J�� % � ! )+��¿�4�) ��>`�/.�<+�"= C )3J:5���)B� 5(��� # � # ��)3J:>�.¬>�)6)+¿ "y 4¬5(���;0�= # �O)+'5H� Z 5@=+4:=+>�K #(!$# e 5(� !�# � ! >�> C �O= # ¿+����4�� #�# ,��/= # J��(�"'q)+� C )+5(� q � � =+4:. q � � � eg= #@% �() % ) # �/. ! 4D�/=�� > ! ���# �/025 ! )34 #� �])�)�.;= %:% �() ZV! ,�=�5H���(�/02)34 # 5H��J:025 ! )34 % �() % ���(5 ! � # =��(�]<3J:=���=+465H���/.wJ % )34�5(���]4�)34Vt #(! 4:<3J:>�=�� ! 5LK)+'i5(��� # ��,�=�5H� ! 02� # eº= # �i� # 5(=/K ! 4 #�! .��@5(��� #H% =+02� % ��)BA ! .��/. C K£5(���-5H��J:4x0�=�5H�/.Ma�c_d&e�E� ! 0��v�/4 # J��(� #5(��� C � # 5S= %:% ��) Z�! ,�=�5 ! )34 ! 4 � � a # �/4 # � -p )+5H�"5(�:=�5S5(��� # ¿+���E4�� #(#S% ��) % ����57K !$# =N0��:=���=+025H��� !�# 5 ! 0-)+'#H% =�� # � % ) #(! 5 ! A+�?)3J�5(02)3,-� #S� ��� ! 0 ���i�E� !�# �-5H)@) C 5(= ! 4 � e���)B�i��A+��� ! , % ) #(! 4:<S5(��� % ) #(! 5 ! A ! 5LK&�i)3J:>�."4�)+5C �SJ # ��'ªJ:>������(��= # �i���i)+�(¿ ! 4;=�5H��J:4:0�=�5H�/. #(% =+02�S��� ! 0 �N02)3J:>�.N,�=�¿+��5(� !�# 02)34 # 5H� = ! 4�5 ! , % ) #(#(! C >��^5H)'ªJ:> « >�> z��()3, ���� ���+� � ! 5(� #(! , ! >�=��²) C FH�/025 ! A+� # '*)+��,@J:>�=�5H�/.@)BA+��� q � � =+4x. q � � � e ! 5 !$# # 5H� = ! <3��5H'*)+�(�}=���.@5H)02�(�/=�5H�]5(��� ! 4 % J�5Y.:=�5(=&= # 5(�:�E02)34:0�=�5H�/4:=�5 ! )34")+' l � =+4x. oN� e6.:�/4�)+5 ! 4�<�5(� !�# C K � � R l � � om�W =+4:.% ���('*)+��, � = #(! 4�<3>�� ��# ¿+����4�� #�# ,�= Z�! , !$# =�5 ! )34�=+>`<+)+� ! 5(�:, 5H)]) C 5(= ! 4&5(���i02)34:0�=�5H�/4:=�5H�/. q�� R q � � � q � � � WX 8 � !$#?!�# 5(��� # =+,���=+>`<+)+� ! 5(�:, % �(��A ! )3J # >`KO)3J�5(> ! 4��/. ! 4w5(�:� % �(��A ! )3J #?# �/025 ! )34

8 �:���(�o=��(�v57�i)M� Z�!�# 5 ! 4�<D4�)BA+�/>]�(�/>$=�5H�/.�,-��5(��)V. # ��� ! 0 � �(�/02)34 #�! .����O5(�:� # KV,�,-��5H� ! 0�=+>^,�=�5H� ![Z t'ª=+025H)+� !�# =�5 ! )34 % �() A ! .:�/. C Kma�c_d ! 4N)+��.����^5H)O) C 5(= ! 4m=-.��/02)3, % ) #�! 5 ! )34w)+'g= % ) #(! 5 ! A+�S.:=�5(=O,�=�5H� ![ZN! 457�i) % ) #(! 5 ! A+�@,�=�5H� ! 02� # e²��� ! 0��s�:=BA+� #(! , ! >�=�� % �() % ���(5 ! � # 5H)N�/=+0��9)+5(����� � )+5(�D5(��� # ��,-��5(��)V. # �:=BA+�

���+�

Page 148: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

C ���/49'*)3J:4:.M5H) C � # J:0�02� #�# '*Jx> ! 4I. !�# 02)BA+��� ! 4:< # �/,�=+465 ! 0;'*�/=�5(J��(� # =+4:. C )+5(�9) % ����=�5H�w)34M5(��� ! 4 ! 5 ! =+>.:=�5(= #H% =+02�r��5(���E) C FH�/025 ! A+�_5H)&) % 5 ! , !�� �E�x= # 5H)-02)3465(= ! 4 C )+5(�"5(���]4���<3=�5 ! A+�_�(�/02)34 # 5H� J:025 ! )34"���(�()+�?=+4:.5(����02)34 # 5H��= ! 465 #� ����� ��� ��������� � ������� � ���������� ������ ����� ��������

y 4 5(��� p � z 5H�/0��x4 !�\ J�� R[���+�+W 5(���£.:=�5(=M,�=�5H� ![Z !�# '*=+025H)+� !$# �/. ! 4 57�i)I,�=�5H� ! 02� #O! , % ) #�! 4�<s5(���% ) #(! 5 ! A ! 5LK"02)34 # 5H� = ! 4�5?)34 C )+5(�m)+'»5(�:� # �S5H����, #� ¨y 5 # ) C Fr�/025 ! A+�

� � � � � 5� � � � �g� �� ° � ����� ��� ° � >`)+< �H� � � � � � � � � � ° � � � � � � � � � � � � � ° � � ���� �+T3�

��� ! 0�� !�#&! 4¬'ª=+025�5(���;J:4:4�)+� ,�=+> !�# �/.¬02��) #(# tX�/465H�() % K¬)+�Be¾J % 5H)£=£02)34 # 5(=+465&5H����,me 5(���;J:4:4�)+� ,�=+> !�# �/.! J:>$> C =+0(¿6t � � ! C >`���}. ! A+���(<+�/4:02� C ��5L�¹���/4o5(����) C # ���(AG= C >`�S.:=�5(=�=+4:.N5(�:��'*=+025H)+� !�# =�5 ! )34m,�)�.��/>¡#"�$ ��% ��� � � � ��� � � � � 0 �:=���=+025H��� !��/! 4�<�='& ) !$#(# )34N. !�# 5H� ! C J�5 ! )34-)+'º5(���S.:=�5(=-02)34x. ! 5 ! )34��/.")34w5(���S,-)V.��/> 8 ����=+>�<+)+� ! 5(�:,�5(�:�/4D02)34 #(!�# 5 # )+'?=+4 ! 5H����=�5 ! A+�O, ! 4 ! , !�# =�5 ! )34v)+'?=+4DJ %x% ��� C )3J:4x.s)34 ���� �+T3��! 4¬5(���% =���=+,���5H��� #'� � � =+4:. � � � � �ª# ��� R[������W '*)+��.���5(= ! > # � e ! 4s��� ! 0��¬,@J:>`5 !`% > ! 0�=�5 ! A+�bJ % .:=�5H� # �(� # Jx>`5 -| '*5H���02)346A+���(<+�/4:02�+e�5(���^02)3>�J:,�4 # )+' � � � 02)3465(= ! 4-A+�/025H)+� # 5(�:=�5Y=��(�E.��/,-)34 # 5H� =�5H�/. R[���+�+W 5H) C � ! 4:.����/. ! 465H���Ht% �(��5(= C >`��= #�# �/,O=+4�5 ! 0�'*=+025H)+� # =+4:.m02)+���(� #H% )34:. ! 4:<@�/>��/,-�/4�5 # 'q��)3, � � � � 02)3465(= ! 4o�(�/>`��A�=+4:02� # 5H�(�/4:<+5(� #'*)+�^�/=+0��v.�)V0�J:,-�/465^=+4:.m0�>�= #(#^% = ! � ����� �)( * �+�-, �,.��/ ���0�+���#1 ��� �2� �3 � ��2�+���546� 7/ ���8���

& � a | R ���GW�!�# = % �() C = C ! > !�# 5 ! 0¹�(��'*)+��,&Jx>�=�5 ! )34�)+'�5(���]= C )BA+� ! .��/= ! 4�5(��� # �/4 # �^5(�:=�5¹5(����'ª=+025H)+� # =��(�4�) � 02)34 # 5H��= ! 4��/.N5H) C � % �() C = C ! > ! 5 ! � #� 8 �:�S) C Fr�/025 ! A+��)+'�& � a | !�#�R ����W

9 � ����� �� ° � � ° � >`)+< � � :O�<; ° � �:�=:O� � � 8 � ���� �+³3�

��������� � ° � ��� % �(� # �/465 #?>:O� $ � 8 � =+4:. !�# ) C 5(= ! 4��/. C K94�)+� ,�=+> !��/! 4:<N�/=+0�� .�)V0�J:,-�/465�A+�/025H)+� # Jx0��M5(�:=�5! 5 # 02)3, % )34��/465 #@# J:,�5H) �� s8 ���"02)34 # 5H��= ! 4��/.M) % 5 ! , !�# =�5 ! )34 !�# 5(�:�/4I=+0 � ! ��A+�/. C K9,�= Z�! , !�#(! 4�<N5(���=/A+��� =�<+�/.m>`)+<3=�� ! 5(�x, )+' ���� �+³3� ex02)34 #(! .:��� ! 4�< � = # =@� ! .:.:�/4�A�=�� ! = C >`�+e ! 4;=+4 ! 5H����=�5 ! A+� § ��% �()V02� #(# e�= #.�� # 02� ! C �/. ! 4 { �:= % 5H��� �� ����� �)@ A5���8� B�8�8�����

z���)3,�= % ��=+025 ! 0�=+> % ) ! 465?)+'gA ! ����e:5(��������=��(�&=�'q��� .���=/� C =+0(¿ # 5H) C )+5(�N)+'g5(��� # ��,���5(��)�. #� i§ A+�/4! '¾5(���@= %:% =��(�/465E0�J C ! 0 # 0�=+> ! 4�<;½ � � � ¡ � 0�=+4 C �&�(�/.:J:02�/.o5H)w½ � � �G��� � C ��DH� ¡ �S� �������(� � ����� � C ��DH� !�#

�����

Page 149: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

5(���O4�J:, C ���S)+'i4�)34�t � ���()m�/>`�/,-�/465 #�! 4s5(���O.:=�5(= � C Kv�/, % >`) K ! 4�< #H% =�� # ��,O=�5H� ![Z ) % ��� =�5 ! )34 # eº=o02)34Vt#(! .:����= C >`�;46J:, C ���b)+' §�� ! 5H����=�5 ! )34 # =��(�w�(� \ J ! �(�/.I5H)s�(�/=+0���02)34�A+���(<+�/4x02� y 4 =+.:. ! 5 ! )34e¾)34:>`KM5(���02)346A+���(<+�/4:02�@5H)O=�>`)V0�=+>,�= Z�! ,&Jx,~)+� # =+.:.x>`�2t % ) ! 4�5})+'»5(����> ! ¿+�/> ! ��)�)�. # J���'*=+02� !�# <3J:=���=+465H���/.e:��� ! 0��!�# =¬02)3,�,�)34 % �() C >`�/, � ! 5(� =+>�>?4�)34�t702)34�A+� Z ) % 5 ! , !�� =�5 ! )3415(= # ¿ # =+4:. !$# ,-)+�(�m=+0�J�5H� ! 4I� ! <3� . ! t,-�/4 #�! )34:=+>¨.x=�5(= #(% =+02� # e # Jx0��I= #-! 4D5(���w0�= # �w)+'E=£A+�/025H)+� #H% =+02�"�(� % �(� # �/465(=�5 ! )34I)+'^5H� Z 5 R[���+³+WX s|.���5H����, ! 4 !�# 5 ! 0"=+4:4:�/=+> ! 4�< # 0 ���/.:J:>��m�:= # C ���/4 % �() % ) # �/.1'*)+��5(���£0�= # �o)+' & � a | R ����W 5H) # )3,������:=�50 ! ��0�Jx,�A+�/465&5(� !�#�% ��=+025 ! 0�=+>¹�¹�/=�¿V4�� #(#� � K902)3465H��= # 5�e¨5(�:�;,-��5(�:)�.M)+' # ¿+����4:� #(# ,O= ZV! , !�# =�5 ! )34 % �(�2t# �/465H�/.o�/=�� > ! ���^5H� ! � # 5H)"02)34:.:�/4 # ��5(���@4��/02� #(# =���Kw>$=�5H�/4�5 #H% =+02�&= # ,&Jx0��v= #^% ) #(#(! C >`�_��� ! >`� % ��)BA ! . ! 4�<# �/,�=+465 ! 0�=+>�>�K ! 465H��� % �(��5(= C >`�S'*=+025H)+� #� � '¾02)3J�� # �+e�)3J:��,-��5(��)V. % �() A ! .�� # =+4m= %:% ��) Z�! ,�=�5H� # )3>�J:5 ! )34N= #! 5S�i)+�(¿ #�! 4¬5(�:� #H% =+02��)+'?=m.:��= # 5 ! 0�=+>�>�K£5H��Jx4:0�=�5H�/.Ma�c_d Rh )B�i��A+���/e C Ks5(��� #�\ J:=����/. yH{?| % �() C >`�/,! 4 # ,�=+>�>». ! ,��/4 #(! )34 # =+4:.v� ! 5(�£5(���@)+�(5(��)+<+)34:=+> ! 57K£02)34 # 5H��= ! 465 # )34v5(��� % =���=+,-��5H���S,�=�5H� !`Z£! 5 !�# >`� #(#> ! ¿+�/>�K"5H);<+��5 # 5(J:0(¿ ! 4 #H% J�� ! )3J # >`)V0�=+>²) % 5 ! ,�=Ve©= # �i= #]! 4:.:���/.o02)34 « � ,-�/. ! 4£=+>�>²)3J�� #(! ,@J:>�=�5 ! )34 #� ¹y 5=+> # )b�:= # 5(���_=+.�A�=+4�5(=�<+��)+'º02)34�A+����< ! 4�< ! 4;=@A+���(KO'*��� ! 5H����=�5 ! )34 # =+4:. ! , % >`�/,-�/465(= C >`�^)34N=+46K"02)+� % J #��� ! 0�� !�# =+>`�(�/=+.�K ! 4:.�� Z �/. C K � =�5H�/4�5"a��/,O=+4�5 ! 0 y 4:.�� Z�! 4�<£=+4x.M5(��J #b# 5H)+�(�/. ! 4M=v�(�/.:Jx02�/.I. ! ,-�/4Vt#(! )34x=+>º'*)+��,�=�5 a�)3,-�@57K %x! 0�=+>»02)3, % =�� =�5 ! A+� #(! ,@J:>�=�5 ! )34o� Z =+, % >`� # =��(� # ��)B��4 ! 4£5(��� # � \ J:�/> ]8 ��� # �� ZV% ��� ! ,-�/465(=+>�>`Kw.��/,-)34 # 5H� =�5H�&5(�:=�5 ! 4 % ��=+025 ! 02��5(�:� # �&5(�:�(���&=+>`<+)+� ! 5(�:, # < ! A+�&A+����K #(! , ! >$=�� # �/,�=+465 ! 0�(� % ��� # �/4�5(=�5 ! )34 #¨! 4 # )3,-� #�! 5(J:=�5 ! )34 # =+4:.�5(��� # )3>�J�5 ! )34 % �()BA ! .��/. C K # ¿+����4:� #(# ,�= Z�! , !$# =�5 ! )34-'*)+�¨5H� Z 5.:=�5(= !�#S\ J:=+> ! 5(=�5 ! A+�/>`K£02)3, % =���= C >`�b5H)m5(�x=�5 % �()V.:J:02�/. C Kv5(���-,-��5(��)V. # )+' & � a | )+� p � z '*)+��5H� Z 5C = # �/.o.:=�5(= ����� ��� ���� / ��+����� �

U3V���V � V � �4S���� ��� � � M�������S � ������S�� � Q � �OS�� � ��������� QTP���� PRQ S

{ )3, % =���=�5 ! A+�@� Z�% ��� ! ,-�/4�5 # )34 # ��5H5 ! 4�< # �:=/A ! 4�<;="0�>��/=��_0�>$= #(# t # 5H��Jx025(J��(��)+'¨5(���&5H) %©! 0 # e !� � �/=+0 �5H) %x! 0 !�# �¹�/>$> # � % =���= C >`�&'q�()3,n)+5(����� # e�:=/A+� ! 4:. ! 0�=�5H�/.m5(�:=�5 ! 4 # J:0 �£=w0�= # �+e�5(���-. !$# 0�J #(# �/.£,-��5(��)V. #K ! �/>�.@A+���(K #(! , ! >�=�� 'ª=+025H)+� !�# =�5 ! )34-�(� # Jx>`5 # =+4:. ! '©5(����4�J:, C ���¾)+'�'*=+025H)+� # 02) ! 4:0 ! .:� # � ! 5(�b5(���^4�J:, C ���g)+'0�>�= #(# � # e�5(���/4w5(��� ! .:�/4�5 ![« �/. # �/,�=+4�5 ! 0_'*=+025H)+� # =��(�S��=�5(����� % ��)+5H)+57K %x! 0�=+>²=+4:.N=���� ! 4;� #(# �/4:02��= %:% �() Z�! t,�=�5 ! )34 # 5H)�5(���@,-�/=+4o. ! �(�/025 ! )34 # )+'¾5(���&5H) %x! 0S0�>�= #�# � #� }8 ��� # � « 4:. ! 4�< # =��(� ! 4N=+0�02)+��.:=+4x02�&� ! 5(�N5(���\ J:= #(! tX)+�(5(�:)+<+)34:=+>²<+��)3,-��5H� ! 0 # �x= % ��)+'»�i�/>�>[t # � % =���= C >`��.:)�0�J:,��/4�5�0�>$= #(# � #]! 4N5(����¡£t7. ! ,-�/4 #(! )34x=+> � a

���+T

Page 150: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

#H% =+02�+e C )+5(�£�/, %x! � ! 0�=+>�>`KO) C # ���(A+�/.s=+4:.£� ! <+)+�()3J # >`K % �()BA+�/. ! 4 R[�/�+��W J:4:.����E5(���@,�)+�(� # 5H�()34�< �ª! .��/=+> �= #(# Jx, % 5 ! )34w)+'»5(���&H��Ht # � % =���= C ! > ! 57K�J�02)34:. ! 5 ! )34

z ! � # 5(>`Km�i� ! >�>�J # 5H��=�5H�&5(� !�# )34¬= # J C # ��5S)+'¨5(��� ��� t p ��� # <+�()3J %x# 02)3>�>`�/025 ! )34D02)34�5(= ! 4 ! 4�<N,-� #(# =�<+� #'*�()3, 5(���$H # 0 !� ,-�/.�J`e H # 0 !� #(% =+02�rJ�=+4x. H # )V0 �(�/> ! < ! )34 0���� !�# 5 ! =+43J�<+�()3J %x#� g8 ���^)3J:5 % J�5¨. ! ,-�/4 #(! )34b�}= #i# ��55H) �� z ! < Y�� ��� ¨# �:)B� # 5(�:��4�)34:> ! 4��/=��g)3J�5 % J�5 # )+'�5(�:� # ¿+����4�� #�# ,�= Z�! , !�# =�5 ! )34-=+>`<+)+� ! 5(�x, A+��� # J # q � � �< ! A+�/4 C K p � z =+4x.�� � 8 � �:� ) C 5(= ! 4:�/.o� ! 5(� & � a |& �| # 5H� ! ¿ ! 4�< #(! , ! >�=�� ! 5LK C ��5L�¹���/4s5(��� # �&)3J�5(02)3,�� #0�=+4 C � # ���/4e^J % 5H) # 0�=+> ! 4�<9=+4x. % ����,@J�5(=�5 ! )34 ky 5 !�# 5H) C �o4:)+5H�/.±�:)B�i��A+���/e^5(�:=�5 ! 4 'ª=+025O5(�:� # �. ! =�<+� =+, # �x=/A+�_5H) C � # ���/4"= #}! 4x. ! A ! .:J:=+>V. ! ,��/4 #(! )34 # =+4:.O)+� .���� ! 4�<��/=+0��N. ! ,��/4 #(! )34 C K�,�=�<34 ! 5(J:.�� #< ! A+� # 5(���v)+��.����(�/. > !�# 5")+'�.�)V0�J:,-�/465 #"! 4 )+��.����;)+'S�(�/>`��A�=+4:02�v'q)+�;�/=+0��¶)+'�5(��� # � � 5H) %x! 0 #/ 8 = C >`��� �� ¨# �:)B� # 5(��� # �/,O=+4�5 ! 0_'ª=+025H)+� #^! .��/4�5 !`« �/.O)34w5(� !�# 02)+� % J # C KO5(��� ! 46A+� # 5 ! <3=�5H�/.m=+>�<+)+� ! 5(�:, # e6A+��� # J #5(��) # �w=+0�02)+��. ! 4�<o5H)s�6Jx,�=+4M>$= C �/> ! 4�< N|E# �/=+0��I'ª=+025H)+� !�# =v� ! <3�M. ! ,-�/4 #(! )34:=+>¾A+�/025H)+� � �i�;J:5 ! > !�� �/.=w. ! 025 ! )34x=��(Kw)+' T��+� 5H����, #_! 4£5(� !�# � Z�% ��� ! ,-�/4�5 � e�5(���@)+��.������/.v> !�# 5�)+'¨5(���-,-) # 5 #(! <34 ![« 0�=+4�5E)+��,-) # 5% �() C = C >`� ��� 5H����, #]!�#^% �()BA ! .��/.o'q)+�]�/=+0��s)+'g5(���@'ª=+025H)+� #� �y 5 !$# 0�>`�/=��_5(�:=�5]�/=+0��v)+'g5(��� # �b=+>`<+)+� ! 5(�:, #�:= #^! .��/4�5 !`« �/.w5(����,�= ! 4w5H) %©! 0 # )+'»5(����02)+� % J # e���� ! 0��N=��(�S5(��) # ���(� �x�/025H�/. C K;5(������J:,�=+4m>$= C �/> #�

|]# =+4�)+5(�:���&� Z =+, % >`�+e ! 4Dz ! < N�� �6 �¹� # ��)B� 5(���"02)3, % =���=�5 ! A+�"�(� # J:>`5 # 'q)+�-a � =+4:.5& � a | )34=+4�)+5(�����&.:=�5(=N,�=�5H� ![Z e²��� ! 0��s�}= # .�� #(! <34��/.v5H)m� Z � ! C ! 5_=wA+���(Ks02)3,�,-)34 % �:�/4�)3,-�/4�)34s)+' ! 4�'*)+��,�=Gt5 ! )34 % �()V02� #(#(! 4�< i )34��N0�>�= #�# )+'E.�)V0�J:,-�/465 #m� H �(�/0 ,-)+5H)+��02KV0�>`� # J � 02)34�5(= ! 4 # ,-) # 5(>`KM5H����, # ��� ! 0��1=��(�02)3,�,-)34D5H)o=+>�>g0�>�= #(# � #� -8 ���-)+5(������·m0�>$= #(# � #O� H�=+>`5 =�5(�:� !�# , J`e(H # 0 !� �/>`�/025H�()34 ! 0 # J`e�H 5(=+>�¿ U% )3> ! 5 ! 0 #� <3J:4 # J`eH #H% )+�(5 ��)V0(¿+��K�J � =��(�b,�=+.��bJ % C KmA+���(K£. !�# 5 ! 4x025^5H) %x! 0 # )+'¨. !$# 0�J #(#(! )34 � �x=�5]0�=+4 C � # ���/4o'*�()3,n5(���« <3J���� #&!�# 5(�:=�5 # ¿+����4�� #�# ,O= ZV! , !�# =�5 ! )34M=+4:.�& � a | �x=/A+� #(! , ! >�=�� C �/�:=/A ! )+� ! 4D5(� !�#&#�! 5(J:=�5 ! )34I=+4:.5H�(K;5H)�0�= % 5(J��(�S5(�:��H # �/,�=+465 ! 0�4�) !�# �rJ�)+' 5(���S5H��� , # )+'¾5(����02)3,�,-)34N5H) %©! 0 ! 4;)34��S)+'»5(����. ! ,-�/4 #(! )34 #� 8 ���_�(� # 5?)+' 5(����0�>$= #(# � # e���� ! 0��;�i���(� C ��5H5H���^. !�# 5 ! 4�<3J !�# �x= C >`��=��(��=+> # )-�(��A+�/=+>`�/. ! 4"5(�:� # =+,-�S�}=/K C K5(���S5L�¹);=+>`<+)+� ! 5(�:, #� g8 ��� ! .��/465 ![« �/. # �/,O=+4�5 ! 0_'*�/=�5(J��(� # �¹������=�<3= ! 4N��=�5(����� % �()+5H)+57K %x! 0�=+> �ª# ��� 8 = C >`��� · ��  U3V���V � V W L � �����CQTM�� M��RN���� ����S�� � Q �� �OS�� S���� ��� �

y 4 8 = C >`� �� �� e��(� # Jx>`5 # )+'�=^H « 4:���»��� # )3>�J�5 ! )34�J`e C K@=+4:=+>`K #(! 4�<_,-� #(# =�<+� # 'q�()3, 5(�:� #(! 4�<3>`�}4���� # <+�()3J %H # 0 !� ,��/.3JB=��(� # ��)B��4²e ! 4S= # �/=���0��&'q)+� � '*=+025H)+� #� '�02)3J�� # �+e 5(� !�# .:=�5(=^.:)6� # 4�)+5º�:=BA+�¹=^0�>`�/=��Be # � % =���= C >`�0�>�J # 5H���(�/. # 5H��Jx025(J��(�O=+46K�,�)+�(�"=+4:.95(�����(��'*)+�(�O,�=�¿+� # J % = # ��5H5 ! 4�<o��� ! 0 �D0�=+49����A+�/=+> # )3,���'*J:�(5(�����0��x=���=+025H��� !�# 5 ! 0 # =+4:.9. ! �����(�/4:02� # )+'}5(���;. !�# 0�J #�# �/.¬,-��5(��)V. #� ;|E# =+>�>Y.:=�5(= ! 4 # 5(=+4:02� # =��(���(�/>�=�5H�/.95H)

���+³

Page 151: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

a � '*=+025H)+� ##(% =+02� ,-�/. ! 0 <+)V.4:= # = % =�5 ! �/4�5 % ��) % >)+� C ! 5 .�)V025H)+� 0 ��� !�# 5 ! =+4# K # 5H�/, K+�/=�� ��J:5H<+���.:= ! �����/025 5(� ! 4�<

>�=+J:4:0 � 5H�(�/=�5(,-�/465 C ! C >�/4�< ! 4 . !�# �/= # 0 ��� !�# 5# 0 ! �/4:0 0�=+>�> FH� # J, !�#(#(! )34 ,��/. ! 0 ! 4 \ J�� # 5 ! )34� ! <3��5 % ��K #(! 0 ! =+4 'ª= ! 5(�

p � z1'*=+025H)+� #K+�/=�� #H% =+02� % ��) % >0�=+>$> 4:= # = <+)V.�����/025 K+�/=�� 0 ��� !�# 5 ! =+4,-�/. ! 0 )+� C ! 5 ��J:5H<+���% ��) % > �/4�< ! 4 5(� ! 4�<

\ J�� # 5 ! )34 .:= ! 0 �6J:��0��# 5(J:. ! # 0 ! �/4x0 \ J�� # 5 ! )34A+� # K # 5H�/, % =��(5

� Z�% ��� ! ,�=+4 C ! C >.�)�025H)+� � ! <3� 0 ��� !�# 5

& � a | 'ª=+025H)+� #<+)V. . !�# �/= # #H% =+02�

0���� !�# 5 ! =+4 # 5(J:. ! >�=+J:4x0��% ��) % > 0�=+4:. ! .:= )+� C ! 50���J���0 � # K # 5H�/, 4:= # =FH� # J ,-�/. ! 0 A+�/46J'ª= ! 5(� .�)V025H)+� , !�#(#(! )34

��)3,-) # � Z J % =�5 ! �/465 # ��J�5H5(>% =+J:> % ��) % > # K # 5H�/,#(! 4 �����/025 # 5(=�5 ! )34

\ J:� # 5 ! )34 ���/=+>`5(� �/=��(5(�

h J:,O=+4m>�= C �/> C = # �/.�����/025 #H% =+02� % ��) % >`�K+�/=�� 4:= # = 0��:� !�# 5 ! =+40�=+>�> )+� C ! 5 <+)�.

% ��) % >`� .:= ! ��J�5H<+���,-�/. ! 0 K+�/=�� 5(� ! 4�<

\ J�� # 5 ! )34 # K # 5H�/, 0 �6J�� 0��A+� � ! <3� C ! C >

.�)V025H)+� >�=+J:4x0�� \ J�� # 5 ! )34« 4:. ,�=+4 % =��(5

% =�5 ! �/465 # 0 ! �/4:0 « 4:.��� �FS�U�V�� a��/,�=+465 ! 0w'ª=+025H)+� # '*)3J:4:. C K # ¿+����4�� #(# ,O= ZV! , !�# =�5 ! )34 � a �¬� e p � z � �i)+��. # =+0�02)+� .Vt! 4�<95H)M<+�(�/=�5H� # 5 % �/=�¿ # )+' q � � � =+4x. & � a | � ,�) # 5 % ��) C = C >`�m�i)+��. # =+0�02)+��. ! 4:<95H) � � $ � �:� �

)34 =¶02)+� % J # 'q)+� ,-�/. C K .�)V0�J:,-�/465 # 'q��)3, � . ! �����(�/465v4:��� # <+�()3J %©# i H # 0 !� ,-�/.�J`e H # 0 !X #H% =+02�rJS=+4:.H # )V0 �(�/> ! < ! )34 0���� !�# 5 ! =+43J¾=+4:. 5(�:�o,-) # 5-'*�(� \ J��/4�5-�i)+��. # )+']5(�:�m0�>�= #(# ,-�/=+4 # =+0�02)+��. ! 4:<D5H)D5(���m��JVt,�=+4m>$= C �/> ! 4�<

� · �

Page 152: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

��� ���������� ��� ��� ���������� � ����� ����� ����� � � � ������ � ��! ���� � � ���"� � ���� � � ����� �#��� ��#��� � ���$ ���� �������"��� �%��"�#� �"�"��� ���&��"��� ��������� �������"��� �������%�� � �����' (�)! ��� �+*�� �� � �)���"! ����� �� � ���"������� � � ������ ���� � � ���,���

���,��� �-��� *��"! � ���,���"� �".� �/��)��� ������ ����� ������ � ������ ' ��)! ������,��0 ��� � ������ ��� �� � �(���1* ��� � ������ �2.� ��� ��.$ ���� �������"��� ���,��0 ������,��0#�3 ����� ��� ��� � ��� ��� ����� � �*�4 ����� �"�" &� *��"! � 0 ����� 0 ���������� �,��� � ��! ' ���5��� �������"�"� ���,���"� *2.6 ' � �,��� �7������,��0 ����*��"�"� ��! �"�/���"� ������ ���#� ������� ��� ������� &�)�8� � 9�� ������ ��#���

0 �.��� �-�8���"�� ����� $ � ��������� ���"������ � ��$�� � ' �� �:��! ����"�/�"� ���� � � �.�� ��� �������2�� �/�������0���� � ���"�"���"�� ��� ��������� �*� ���&$ �"�� �����"� ����� ����� ����(����� ���

��� �FS^U3V�� a��/,�=+465 ! 0g'ª=+025H)+� # 'q)3J:4x. C K # ¿+���E4�� #(# ,O= ZV! , !�# =�5 ! )34�=+4x. & � a | )34�5(���¨02)+� % J #²! 4�z ! < ��� �6 5(��� # =+,��S<+�/4�����=+>5H) %x! 0E)+'¾,-�/. ! 0 ! 4��+eV�¹��0�=+4m� Z�% �/025?5H) « 4:.;'ª=+025H)+� #&� ¿+��K��i)+��. # � �E� ! 0��w=��(�S���/>�=�5H�/.5H)��/=+0 �m)+5(����� Y8 � !�#}!�#?! 4:.:���/."5(�:��0�= # �+e©= # 0�=+4 C � # ���/4m'q�()3, 8 = C >`� �� �� e©��)B�i��A+��� ! 5 !$#?! 4�5H����� # 5 ! 4�<5H) # ���+e©5(��)3J:<3�ex5(�:=�5],-)+�(��. !�# 5 ! 4:025 � ,�)+�(� ! 4x.�� % �/4:.��/465 � '*=+025H)+� # =��(� ! .��/465 ![« �/. C KN5(����)+�(5(�:)+<+)34:=+>. ! ���/025 ! )34 # .���5H����, ! 4��/. C Kv5(��� # ¿+����4�� #�# ,�= Z�! , !�# =�5 ! )34v=+>�<+)+� ! 5(�:,�=+4:.s5(�:=�5S5(� !�# )+�(5(��)+<+)34:=+> ! 57K !�#�(� �x�/025H�/. ! 4w5(��� # �/4 # ��)+'¾5(���S�i)+��.m<+��)3J %x! 4�< #?! 4N=��6Jx,�=+4Vt ! 465H�/>�> ! < ! C >`�E,O=+4:4���� Y| 5E5(� !�# �(� # )3>$J�5 ! )34>`��A+�/>º5(����=+>`<+)+� ! 5(�:, ! .��/465 ![« � # e ! 4N'ª=+025�e©. ! �����(�/465�02)3465H� Z 5 # )+� # J C 5H) %x! 0 # )+'¾5(���&5H) %x! 0S)+'4H�,-�/. ! 0 ! 4��rJ y 5E0�=+4 C �&4�)+5H�/.£5(�:=�5 # )3,-�@)+'g5(��� # �b=��(��'*)3J:4:. C Ko=+>$>²5(���&5(���(���b=+>`<+)+� ! 5(�:, # e©> ! ¿+��5(��) # �@�(�/>�=�5H�/.£5H)H ! 4�'*�/025 ! )3J # . !�# �/= # � # J`e4H�=+> ! ,-�/465(=�5 ! )34 \ J�� # 5 ! )34 # J =+4:. H�,-�/. ! 0�=+>¹�(� # �/=�� 0��3J a�¿+����4�� #�# ,O= ZV! , !�# =�5 ! )34�:= # =+> # ) ! .��/4�5 !`« �/.�=+4�)+5(�����»57�i) ! 4:.�� % �/4:.��/465 # J C 5H) %x! 0 # = C )3J�5(H %x# KV0���)3>`)+< ! 0�=+>����/=+>`5(��J =+4:.dH # J��(<+���(K�J

u��/>�=�5H�/.s5H)m02)34�5H� Z 5�. !$# 02)BA+���(K !�# 5(��� # KV4�)34�KV,&K£=+4:. % )3>`K # �/,�Ko)+'¨5(���->�=+4�<3Jx=�<+� &8 ��� # Jx0�02� #(#)+' � a | �(�/> ! � # )34 # Jx0�02� #(# 'ªJ:>�>`KO,�)�.��/>$> ! 4�<@5(��� # � % ���/4�)3,-�/4x= R ��� WX ¨y 5 #^% ��) C = C ! > !$# 5 ! 0EA+��� #(! )34e & � a | e�:= # =+> # ) C ���/4¬.:�/,-)34 # 5H��=�5H�/. R ���GW 5H) C �b0�= % = C >`�-)+'¹,�)�.��/>$> ! 4�<"5(��� # � �� K£5(����=+4x=+>`)+<+)3J #�# 5(=���5 ! 4�<) C FH�/025 ! A+� # )+'i5(����=+>`<+)+� ! 5(�:, #_% �(� # �/4�5H�/. ! 5 !�# � ZV% �/025H�/.¬5H) « 4x.£5(� !�# 'q�/=�5(J���� ! 4¬=+>�>»5(����=+>`<+)+� ! 5(�:, #! 46A+� # 5 ! <3=�5H�/. a�KV4�)34�KV,&K !�# �(� �x�/025H�/. C Ko�i)+��. # � ! 5(�v�(�/>$=�5H�/.v,��/=+4 ! 4�< C � ! 4�<;<+�()3J % �/.o� ! 5(� ! 4£5(���# =+,-�-'ª=+025H)+� z:)+�&.��/,-)34 # 5H��=�5 ! 4�<w5(����,�)�.��/>$> ! 4�<;)+' % )3>`K # �/,&K+e 8 = C >`� �N# ��) � # 02)3, % =�� =�5 ! A+�/>`Ks5(���'ª=+025H)+� # ��� ! 0��;=��(�S,-)+�(�_�(�/>�=�5H�/.w5H) � ,-)+�(��> ! ¿+�/>`K-5H)-� ZV% >�= ! 4 � 5(���_�¹)+� .6H�.:� ! A+�rJ`e ! .��/465 ![« �/. ! 4w=b,-)+�(�02)3, % >�� Z ���/=+> !�# 5 ! 0 # ��5H5 ! 4�< i C � #(! .�� # 5(���m� =�5(�����O<+�/4���� =+> # J C Fr�/025O)+'_. !�# 0�J #(#�! )34 # 02)34�5(= ! 4��/. ! 4 5(���4���� # <+�()3J % H �(�/0 ,-)+5H)+� 02K�0�>`� # J`e �i���:=/A+�;0���) # �/4D=w�(�/>�=�5H�/.¬)34:�+e�H �(�/0 =+J�5H) # J`e 5L�¹)m)+5(�:����4���� # <+��)3J %x#)34@02)3, % J�5H��� # 0 ! �/4:02� i H�02)3, %² # K #� ! C , U% 0 �x=���.��}=��(�rJ`e =+4:.dH�02)3, %² # K #� ,�=+0 �x=���.��}=��(�rJ`e3=+4:.�)34:�¨��� ! 0��!�# . !�# 5 ! 4:025»'q�()3, =+>�>�5(���?��� # 5 i H # 0 !X ,-�/.3J g|E# � ZV% �/025H�/.e�0�>�J # 5H��� ! 4�<]5(��� # � ! 4b=+4-J:4 # J % ���(A !�# �/.�,O=+4:4����/e

� · �

Page 153: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

��� �7�������� �"� � ����� 0 ����� ���� ����� � ��� ��� � ���"�� ' ���! ��3 ����� ���� ���#��" &� �� �0�� ' ��"���� *��)���"�

���(���"*��"�� � ������ �-���&� � ���� � �-�8��� ���(�����$��"� �(���� ����"�� ���"� � ���� � �"�

*������ ����,� $ � ����/����� � ' �"� � �� &��.��� ��� �-� �����"� � ' ���� � ����� ��$ ����:��5��� � ' �"��� ���" ���$ ����� ���"��* (�������

������� ���8� *��"��"���� � ' ���&� ��� ! ����������#��� � �� ��� � �-��$�� � � ' ���� ' ����� � '

�"�(� �� ����"� 9-� � ���" ���� � 4��� � ��� ���� $������"�-� ���� � ������ �+� � � �����8� '

�������� ���"�� ��( � 9 ��� � � �������� �� ����"�

� ��� ���������� �(���� ����"�� �"� � ����� $ � � ' 0� �"���,��� � ������ � � ����$��"� ��3 ����� ���" ���� � ���������#��� ��� ��� 0 ����� ���,������� ��3 ����� �� ' (�� ���#���"*��"�� ���� � ���� �� �/ �

� ������ � ��5��� ��������� � � ���"� �����������"� � � ��� ���(� ���8� ' ����� � ' � ' �"���

�����"� �-��� 9-��� �(���� ����"�� � �� ��� � ���� ���#���" �� �����"� ���� ������� ���"�"���"� $ � �0� �� ��� �0��/������ ��6�� ���� ��3 ����� 0 �.���0 ����� 9-� � �-��� ' �� �����"�

��� ����� ����� � ' �"��� � ' �������)��� ' � � ��� ����� �� &� ��(����� �)�� &� �������� ���8�� ���#�

� � ��� �7�������� ��������� ��� ����� ������� ��� ��������� �-� ��3 ��������" �.�� ���� ���#���" �� ������ &0� &� ��� � �� ��2��� � � ���"� � ������ ' ����� � ' �"� � ����� � �� ��

&0��/������ ����� ���"� ��� ��� 0 ���� �� �/ ��

0 ����� !(�"��"�,��� ���" ���� �+�����#��� �-�8��� ���#��-�8�� ���#� �+� � ��3 ����� *-����� �����,� $ ������"� ����/����� �+� � ��(����� � �8� ���� ��� �� *��"��"���� �������� &� ��$ � �0��/�����

���� � �/ � � �� ������ ' ���)����� ��0 ����-���"� &0� &� ��� � � ���"� $������"� ' .�

&������ &����������� ���������� ���#��"*��"�� � ������� �� ������� ' ��� �� ��� �(�-���)! �� �.�8��� ���(�

��� �FSAU3V�� a��/,�=+465 ! 0S'ª=+025H)+� # )+'¾5(����4���� # <+�()3J % H # 0 !X ,-�/.3J� · �

Page 154: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

a � 'ª=+025H)+� #��������� 0�=��% �() C >`�/, �/4:< ! 4# K # 5H�/, ! 465H���(� # 5�i)+�(¿ ���������

C )3=�� . % ) # 502)3, % J�5 C ! ¿+�0�=�� . '*�()3465

# )+'*57�}=�� % � ! 02�, C .�)�.�x=���. � ! .��

p � z 'ª=+025H)+� ## K # 5H�/, 0�=����������� �^� ! 5H��i)+�(¿ =��(5 ! 0�>

�:=���.��}=�� K+�/=��% ��) C >`�/, �/4�< ! 4C )3=���. % �() C >`�/,# )+'*57�}=�� ���������

0�=���. �i)+�(¿# 0 #(! ! 465H���(� # 5# ��5 % ��) % >

& � a | '*=+025H)+� #0�=�� ���������

�^� ! 5H� % �() C >`�/,=���5 ! 0�> �^� ! 5H�C ! ¿+� �i)+�(¿= % � # K # 5H�/,�/4�< ! 4 , C� ! .:� 0�=���..:)�. # 0 #(!

�������� ,�� �C ,&� C )3=���.

��� �FS U�V U 8 ��� # �/,�=+465 ! 0I'*=+025H)+� # eb= # 02)3465H� Z 5 # e-'q)3Jx4:. 5H) C �I5(��� ,-) # 5s�(�/>�=�5H�/. 5H)¶5(���1�i)+��.H�.�� ! A+�rJ ! 4M5(�:�m02)+� % J # '*)+��,-�/. C KI.:)�0�J:,��/4�5 # '*�()3, � 4���� # <+�()3J %x# i H�02)3, %² # K #� ! C , U% 0 �:=���.��}=��(�rJ`eH�02)3, %² # K #� ,O=+0 �:=���.��}=��(�rJ`e�H # 0 !� ,-�/.3J`e*H �(�/0 =+J:5H) # J`e H ���/0 ,-)+5H)+��02KV0�>`� # J ! 4¬=+0�02)+��.x=+4:02��5H)o��J:,�=+4¬>�= C �/> ! 4�< !�# �x=���. ! '¹4:)+5 ! , % ) #(#(! C >`�+e�=+4x.¬, ![Z 5(J��(�-,-)V.��/>�> ! 4:<O5H�/0��x4 !�\ J�� #! 4:.:���/. % ���('*)+��, % )6)+� >`Km)34¬5(� !$# .x=�5(= �� �"=��(�-5H�(K ! 4�<�e²��) �¹��A+���/e 5H) « 4:. # )3,���J:4:.�����>�K ! 4:<�'*=+025H)+� #��� ! 0���=���� C )+5(��,-�/=+4 ! 4�<+'ªJ:>?'*)+�;��J:,�=+4 J:4:.���� # 5(=+4:. ! 4�<D=+4x. % �() A ! .��o=D<+)�)V. = %:% �() Z�! ,�=�5 ! )34 ! 45H����, # )+'Y���/02)34 # 5H��J:025 ! 4�<"5(�:�@.:=�5(= �§ =+0��¬.�)V0�J:,-�/465 ! 4 # 5(=+4:02�b0�=+4s5(���/4 C �@5(��)3J�<3�65])+'¹= # =w> ! 4��/=��02)3, C ! 4:=�5 ! )34 � 02)34�A+� Z 02)3, C ! 4:=�5 ! )34 ! 4w5(����0�= # �&)+' & � a |S� )+'¾5(��� # ��'ª=+025H)+� #�

8 � !�#S# ��5H5 ! 4�< !$#S# )3,-�����:=�5 ! 4 C ��57�i���/4D5(��� % � ! )+�_)34�� # e 5(�����(��'*)+�(�O4:=�5(J�� =+>�>`K+e5(���O,���5(��)�. # � ! >�>« 4:. . ! �����(�/465O�}=/K # )+'�'*=+025H)+� !$# =�5 ! )34 ph ) �¹��A+���/e ! 5 !�#"! 4�5H���(� # 5 ! 4�<95H)I) C # ����A+�£5(�:=�5w=+>�> # )3>`A+�v5(���% �() C >`�/, )+' % )3>`K # �/,&K ! 4N= #(! , ! >�=��},�=+4:4���� i = # 0�=+4 C � # ���/4 ! 4 8 = C >�� �� ��� ex�����/025 ! A+�/>�Kw=+>$>©5(�:�S5(���(���=+>`<+)+� ! 5(�:, # �:=/A+� ! .:�/4�5 ![« �/.O5(��� # =+,��]5L�¹)�. ! �������/4�5}02)34�5H� Z 5 # )+' 5(���]�¹)+��.AH�.:� ! A+�rJ ! 4O5(� !�# .:=�5(= i = # =02)3, % J:5H���HtX�(�/>�=�5H�/.£�:=���.��}=��(�2tX�/>`�/,-�/465^=+4:.m=+4o=+025 ! )34 ! 4w5(�:��02)34�5H� Z 5�)+'g=+J�5H) # =+4:.m,-)+5H)+��02KV0�>`� #�

�� ! ��#������*�7!)���

� �-�:=BA+� % �(� # �/465H�/.£=+4v�����/025 ! A+�-,-��5(��)V.o'*)+�]=+4x=+>`K #�! 4�<�5(���b02)3465H�/4�5S)+'g5H� Z 5S.�)�0�Jx,-�/4�5 # ��� ! 0��=��(� # 5H)+�(�/. ! 4o5(��� � a | #H% =+02� �� K£�¹)+��¿ ! 4:< ! 4v=;�(�/.:J:02�/.s. ! ,-�/4 #(! )34x=+> � a | #H% =+02�+e5(���-=+>`<+)+� ! 5(�:,

� · �

Page 155: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

C �/4�� « 5 # 'q�()3, 5(���������/025 ! A+�/4�� #�# )+'5(�:�E02)+�(�(�/>$=�5 ! )34Vt C = # �/. � a | 5H�/0 �:4 !�\ J��E'q)+�i� ! <3�O. ! ,-�/4 #(! )34:=+>�=+4:.#H% =�� # ��.:=�5(=N= # �i�/>�>g= #�! 5 # �¹�/>$>gJ:4:.���� # 5H)6)V. # 5(= C ! > ! 57K£=+4x.¬02)34�A+���(<+�/4x02� % ��) % ����5 ! � #X� =w'*=+025�5(�:=�5,-)+5 ! A�=�5H� # 5(��� % ) % J:>�=�� ! 5LKb)+'5(��� � a | 5H�/0��x4 !�\ J�� ! 4O=+J�5H)3,�=�5 ! 0 ! 4x.�� ZV! 4�<�=+4:. ! 4�'*)+��,�=�5 ! )34O�(��5H� ! ��A�=+>� =+4:. !$# .���A+�/>`) % �/.£= # ="4:=�5(J���=+>º� Z 5H�/4 #(! )34£)+'g5(� !�# 5H�/0 �:4 !�\ J�� �8 ���&.���� ! AG=�5 ! )34m)+'g5(��� % �()GFH�/025 ! )34) C FH�/025 ! A+�-= %:% �() % � ! =�5H��'*)+�]5H� Z 5S=+4:=+>`K #(!�#>� ��� ! 0 �o5(J�� 4��/.m)3J�5]5H) C �&=;,-�/= # J��(�@)+'¨= # KV,�,-��5H��K �

% ����, ! 5H5H�/.s=N,-)+��� % � ! 4:0 !`% >`�/.m�}=/Kv)+'i= %x% >`K ! 4�< y({}| 5H)N5(� !�#]% �() C >��/,�5(�x=+4s�i= # .:)34�� ! 4 % �(��A ! )3J #= %:% ��)3=+0���� # eE��� ! 0 � ! , % > ! 0 ! 5(>`KM02)34 #�! .���� # K�,O,-��5H� ! 0�=+> % �()GFH�/025 ! )34 # =+4:. )������ # C )+5(�¶=+4 ! , % ��)BA+�/.� ZV% >`) ! 5(=�5 ! )34;)+' 5(����0�= % = C ! > ! 5 ! � # )+'»5(��� y({}| ,-��5(�:)�.w=+4:. ! 465H��� % �(��5(= C ! > ! 5LK-)+' 5(���_�(� # J:>`5 #� g| #�! , % >`�# )3>�J:5 ! )3415H)95(���-Fr) ! 465 % �() C >`�/, )+' yH{}| )34 =M.:=�5(=D,�=�5H� ![Z =+4x. ! 5 # 5H��=+4 #H% ) # � � H #H% =�5 ! )�tX5H�/, % )+��=+>nJy({}|_� �:= # =+> # ) C ���/4 'q)+� ,&J:>$=�5H�/. ! 4 ,-)+���m<+�/4�����=+>�5H����, #� a�)3,-�o= #(% �/025 # )+'_5(���m�(�/>�=�5 ! )34 )+'_5(���% �() % ) # �/.N,���5(��)�.m5H)�)+5(�����E4:)BA+�/>²5H� Z 5�=+4:=+>�K #(!$# 5H�/0��:4 !$\ J�� #�# J:0��o= # & � a | =+4x. p � z15(���()3J:<3�N5(���! .��/=&)+' # KV,�,-��5H� ! 0�=+>�,�=�5H� ![Z tX'*=+025H)+� !�# =�5 ! )34w�:= # =+> # ) C ���/4". !�# 0�J #(# �/."=+4:. #(! ,&J:>$=�5 ! )34�� Z =+, % >`� # �:=BA+�.��/,-)34 # 5H��=�5H�/.N5(��� % �() % ) # �/.N,-��5(��)V.N5H) C ��02)3, % =���= C >`�S5H)�5(�:� # � ! 4w5(����0�= # ��)+'»5H� Z 5]=+4:=+>`K #(!�#�

� ·+·

Page 156: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

L;MONCPRQTS U�V�� | 02)+� % J # )+'}'q)3J:��.�)V0�J:,-�/465�0�>�= #(# � # e ! 4 ! 5 ! =+>�>`K % �()GFr�/025H�/. ! 4¬=m5L�¹)�t7. ! ,-�/4 #(! )34:=+> � a |#H% =+02�@=+4:.m���/0�J�� #(! A+�/>�K;. ! A ! .:�/."'ªJ��(5(�:����J #(! 4:< # ¿+����4�� #(# ,�= Z�! , !�# =�5 ! )34e C K #(% > ! 5H5 ! 4:<@5(�:��0�>�= #(# � ! 5(�� ! <3�:���?AG=�� ! =+4:02� gZo� H # 0 !� 02�(K % 5KJ`e:) � H # 0 !� #H% =+02�rJ`e�� � H # 0 !X ,-�/.3J:=+4:. � � H # )V0 �(�/> ! < ! )34 0���� !$# 5 ! =+43J

� · �

Page 157: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

0 90 180 270

0 90 180 270

0 90 180 270

0 90 180 270

0 90 180 270

0 90 180 270

= # ¿+���E4�� #(# ,�= Z�! , !$# =�5 ! )34 C & � a |

0 90 180 270

0 90 180 270

0 90 180 270

0 p � zL;MONCPRQTS U3VXU � ! 4��/=��±)3J�5 % J�5 #±% �() A ! .��/. C K # ¿+����4�� #(# ,�= Z�! , !$# =�5 ! )34�'q)+� o � e q � � � ) C 5(= ! 4��/.C K p � z =+4:. � � 8 � �:� < ! A+�/4 C K & � a | )34 � . !�# 5 ! 4:025M4���� # <+�()3J %x# i H # 0 !� ,��/.3J`e H # 0 !� #H% =+02�rJO=+4:.H # )V0 �(�/> ! < ! )34 0���� !�# 5 ! =+43J

� · �

Page 158: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

0 87 174 261 348 435

0 87 174 261 348 435

0 87 174 261 348 435

0 87 174 261 348 435

0 87 174 261 348 435

0 87 174 261 348 435

0 87 174 261 348 435

0 87 174 261 348 435

0 87 174 261 348 435

0 87 174 261 348 435

= # ¿+���E4�� #(# ,�= Z�! , !$# =�5 ! )34 C & � a |L;MONCPRQTS U�V�� p )34:> ! 4��/=��v)3J�5 % J�5 #s�B�9% �() A ! .:�/. C K # ¿+����4:� #(# ,�= ZV! , !�# =�5 ! )34 'q)+� o � =+4:. � � 8 � �:�< ! A+�/4 C K & � a |& u�� # J:>`5 # )34¶.�)V0�J:,-�/465 # '*�()3, � 4���� # <+��)3J %x# i H�=+>�5 =�5(��� !�# , J`e>H �(�/0 ,-)+5H)+� 02K�0�>`� # J`eH # 0 !� �/>��/025H�()34 ! 0 # J`e H 5(=+>`¿ U% )3> ! 5 ! 0 #� <3J:4 # J`e H #H% )+�(5 ��)V0(¿+��K�J z��()3, = 0�>�J # 5H��� ! 4�< % ) ! 465 )+' A ! ����eH �(�/0 ,-)+5H)+� 02K�0�>`� # J�5H�/4x. # 5H)w0�= % 5(J�����5(��� H # �/,�=+465 ! 0@4�) !�# �rJ:� ! 5(� C )+5(�£5(���&,-��5(�:)�. # e©= # 0�=+4 C � # ���/4! 4w5(���&, ! .:.:>��E�() �

� · �

Page 159: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

�� ��� 5�� � �

/>�&% %'12�*- 1 ��< ! ��#������*�7!)���

y 4�5(� !$# 0��x= % 5H���/e�5(���¨�i)+�(¿ % ��� # �/4�5H�/. ! 4�5(�:� % �(��A ! )3J # 0��:= % 5H��� # !�# # J:,�,O=�� !�� �/. aV)3,-�¹02)34:0�>$J:. ! 4�<�(�/,�=���¿ # =��(�?5H� =+02�/.�= # �i�/>�>V= #g% )+5H�/4�5 ! =+>V'ªJ�5(J����¹�(� # �/=���0��-)34 # )3,-�})+'©5(�:�?) % �/4 \ J�� # 5 ! )34 # )+� % ) #�#(! C >`�� Z 5H�/4 #(! )34 #/

�.�� ! ��#�����<d����� �3�(% 12� �

8 � !�# 5(��� #(!�# �:= # C ���/4m02)34x02����4��/.m� ! 5(�m.���A !�#(! 4:<b>$=�5H�/4�5EAG=�� ! = C >`��,-)V.��/> # �E� ! 0��N=����&= %:% ��) % � ! =�5H�'*)+�¹02�(�/=�5 ! 4:<@,-�/=+4 ! 4�<+'ªJ:>V�(� % �(� # �/4�5(=�5 ! )34 # '*)+�¨5H� Z 5(J:=+>�.:=�5(=�'*)+�i��J:,�=+4"J:4:.���� # 5(=+4:. ! 4:< ºy 4�5(� !�#¨! .��/=Ve5(������� # �/=���0�� % �(� # �/465H�/.m������� ! 4N02)3,-� # 5H)O� Z 5H�/4:.o� ZV!$# 5 ! 4�<-0�J��(���/4�5?����)+�(5 # '*)+��02�(�/=�5 ! 4�<O= % � ! 4:0 !`% >��/.C = #(!$# '*)+�b���"0 ! �/465 ! 4�'q)+� ,�=�5 ! )34D����5H� ! ��A�=+> # K # 5H�/, #/ D8 � !�#&!�# =+4I� Z 5H�(�/,-�/>`K95 ! ,-�/>`K % �() C >`�/,Ne C � ! 4�<% � ! ,�=�� ! >`K�,�)+5 ! AG=�5H�/. C K;5(����� ZV% >`) #�! A+�_<+�()B�^5(�o)+'¾5(����=/A�= ! >�= C >�� ! 4�'*)+��,�=�5 ! )34 ! 4w�/>��/025H�()34 ! 0_'*)+��,�=�5

y 4O5(�:���i)+�(¿ % �(� # �/4�5H�/.e�5(���]= C ) A+�_) C Fr�/025 ! A+�]�:= # C ���/4O=+0 � ! ��A+�/. C K-'*J���5(�����¹.���A+�/>�) %x! 4�< # )3,-�E)+'5(���@4�)BA+�/>¾=+4:.o5(����)+�(��5 ! 0�=+>�>�K # )3J:4:.£02)3, % J�5(=�5 ! )34x=+> ! 465H�/>�> ! <+�/4:02��,-)V.��/> # =+4:.o,-��5(�:)�. # e #H% �/0 ![« 0�=+>$>`K'*)+�b.:�/=+> ! 4�<v� ! 5(� ! 4�'*)+��,�=�5 ! )34 ! 4I=v5H� Z 5(J:=+>}'*)+��,�=�5 M8 ��� % �() % ) # �/.I,-)�.:�/> # =���� ! 4 % � ! 4:0 !`% >��O4�)+5�(� # 5H� ! 025H�/.o5H)w5H� Z 5 � 5(� !$# �:= # C ���/4£�/, % �:= #(! � �/. C Km� Z =+, % >`� #(! ,@J:>�=�5 ! )34 # )34£)+5(�:���_.x=�5(=O5LK % � #_! 4# )3,-�-)+'i5(����0�= # � # � ��)B�i��A+����5H� Z 5(J:=+>Y.x=�5(=m=+4:. ! 4:02)+� % )+� =�5 ! 4�< % � ! )+�S.�)3,�= ! 4s¿�4�) ��>`�/.�<+��=�� !�#(! 4�<'*�()3,~5(� !�# 5LK % �S)+'¾.:=�5(= ! 4w)+� .����?5H)�) C 5(= ! 4o= %:% �() % � ! =�5H�S,-)�.:�/> # =+4:. # 0�=+>�= C >`��=+>`<+)+� ! 5(�x, # �:= # C ���/4! 4w5(���&02�/4�5H���E)+'¾=�5H5H�/465 ! )34£�����(�

� )+5(� 4�)34Vt7> ! 4��/=��b=+4:.1> ! 4��/=��b>�=�5H�/465-AG=�� ! = C >`�",�)�.��/> # �x=/A+� C ���/4102)34 #(! .������/.e¾� ! 5(�1=v'q)V0�J # )344�)34Vt �S=+J #(#(! =+4¬>$=�5H�/4�5&AG=�� ! = C >`�-,-)V.��/> # e²= # 5(��� # �O�:=BA+� C ���/4 ! 4:. ! 0�=�5H�/.s5H) C ��0�= % = C >`�O)+'¹�(��A+�/=+> ! 4�<! 465H���(� # 5 ! 4:<w=+4x.¬,-�/=+4 ! 4�<+'ªJ:> # 5H��J:025(J:�(� ! 4v5(����.:=�5(= ! 4 C )+5(�s5(��� # 5(=�5 !$# 5 ! 0�=+>g=+4:.¬,�=+0 � ! 4���>��/=���4 ! 4�<�(� # �/=�� 0��D> ! 5H����=�5(J��(� �| 4 ! , % )+�(5(=+465 % =��(5_)+'¨5(���b�(� # �/=���0��D02)34x02�/4�5H��=�5H�/.9)34s5H) % )+<+��= % � ! 0@)+�(<3=+4 !�# =Gt

� · T

Page 160: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

5 ! )34£=+4:.mA !�# J:=+> !�# =�5 ! )34;)+'g5(����5H� Z 5(J:=+>».:=�5(= u^��A+�/=+> ! 4�<�5(��� # 5H��J:025(J�����)+'g=�5H� Z 5E02)+� % J #�! 4 � t7d �:= #C ���/4N02)34 #(! .:���(�/. ! 4w=&<+�/4:����=+> % �() C = C ! > !�# 5 ! 0}'q� =+,-���¹)+��¿"'*)+� C )+5(� # 5(=�5 ! 0S=+4:.N.�KV4:=+, ! 0�=+>$>`K-��A+)3>`A ! 4�<�e5H�/, % )+��=+>�>�K"02)3�����(�/465�.:=�5(=

{ )34x0�>�J:. ! 4:<�e65(���&=+0�� ! ��A+�/,��/4�5 # 0�=+4 C � # J:,�,O=�� !�� �/.N= # '*)3>�>`) � # i

� =o5(����)+�(��5 ! 0�=+>$>`K % � ! 4:0 !`% >`�/.s=+>`5H����4:=�5 ! A+�O5H)o5(��� �¶§ � a �� ,-)�.:�/>g'q)+�&A !$# J:=+> !�#�! 4�< # 5(=�5 ! 0�5H� Z 502)3>$>`�/025 ! )34 # eV5(=�¿ ! 4�< ! 465H)�=+0�02)3J:465?5(����. ! �����(�/465 % ) % J:>$=��¹5H� Z 5rtX<+�/4�����=�5 ! )34o��A+�/4�5E,-)�.:�/> # eV=+>`)34�<� ! 5(�w5(����= #(# )�0 ! =�5H�/. � § � � # 5 ! ,�=�5 ! )34 % ��)�02�/.:J:�(� # �:=/A+� C ���/4o.���A !$# �/.

� =o5H) % )+<+��= % � ! 0bA !�# Jx=+> !�# =�5 ! )34¬,�)�.��/>Y'q)+� # �/,�=+465 ! 0�=+>�>`Ks02)3�����(�/465&5H� Z 5���A+)3>�A ! 4:<m5(���()3J�<3�D5 ! ,-��x= # C ���/4 % �() % ) # �/.e���� ! 0 �s0�=+4 C � # ���/4¬= # =N02)3, % >`�/,��/4�5(=��(K£5H)6)3>Y5H) 8 ) %x! 0@d]��5H�/025 ! )34M=+4:.8 ��=+0�¿ ! 4:<O= %:% > ! 0�=�5 ! )34 #

� =o> ! 4��/=�� % ��)GFr�/025 ! )34M,-��5(��)V.¬'*)+��5(���-5H) %x! 0�=+>¨=+4:=+>`K #(!�# )+' � a6t y 4x.�� Z �/. # 5(=�5 ! 0�5H� Z 5�02)3>�>`�/025 ! )34 #�x= # C ���/4s.���� ! A+�/.£= # 5(���@�(� # J:>�5�)+'¨5(�:� ! 46A+� # 5 ! <3=�5 ! )34 # )BA+���S5(���-= %:% > ! 0�= C ! > ! 57Kw=+4:.£J # ��'*Jx>�4�� #(#)+'¾5(��� y({}| tX�(�/>�=�5H�/. % �()GFH�/025 ! )34m,-��5(��)V. # 5H)�5H� Z 5E=+4x=+>`K #�!�#

p =�5(J���=+>�>�K+e�=&46J:, C ���¨)+' !�#�# J�� #�� ) % �/4 \ J�� # 5 ! )34 # )+���G=+4:."� Z 5H�/4 #(! )34 # 5H)@5(��� # �E,�)�.��/> #�� 02)3J:>�.C �S'*J:�(5(����� ! 46A+� # 5 ! <3=�5H�/. a�)3,-��)+'»5(��� # ��=�����. !�# 0�J #(# �/. C �/>`)B�

�.�� 8&���������(�f����� �(� �3�7�;14�3�7!)���

8 �:� % ) #(#(! C ! > ! 5LK&)+' ! 4:02)+� % )+��=�5 ! 4:<�5(���S,-)V.��/> #¹% �() % ) # �/. ! 4"5(� !�# 5(��� #(!�# = # ,-)V.:J:>`� #i! 4;=&�i)+�(¿ ! 4�<! 4�'*)+��,�=�5 ! )34N=+0�02� #(#�# K # 5H�/, !�# )34���)+'»5(����,�= FH)+�^5H) %x! 0 # '*)+�^'*J:5(J��(� ! 46A+� # 5 ! <3=�5 ! )34 #/

|]# =N02)3465 ! 46Jx=�5 ! )34¬5H)N5(��� % ��)GFr�/025 ! )34�t C = # �/.¬= %:% ��)3=+0��9.:��A+�/>`) % �/.s'q)+� # 5(=�5 ! 0b5H� Z 5�.x=�5(=Veº� Z 5H�/4Vt#(! )34 # 5H) % �(�/. ! 025 ! A+�N=+>`<+)+� ! 5(�:, # �:=BA+�N�(�/02�/4�5(>�KI= %:% �/=��(�/. ! 4I5(���m> ! 5H����=�5(J��(� RU����W =+4:. =���� ! 4M)+� .����5H) C � ! 46A+� # 5 ! <3=�5H�/.9'q)+��= %x% > ! 0�=�5 ! )34v5H)o.:K�4:=+, ! 0�=+>¾5H� Z 5&, ! 4 ! 4:< @§YZ�% ��� ! ,��/4�5(=+>¾�i)+�(¿v)34D0��:=�5@> ! 4��.:=�5(=VeJ:4:.:���(5(=�¿+�/4s.:J�� ! 4:<�,�KmA !�#(! 5 ! 4�< # 5(=�<+� ! 4£5(��� h �/> #(! 4�¿ ! � 4 ! A+��� #(! 57KN)+' 8 �/0��:4:)3>`)+<+K+e ! 4o02)3>$>�= C t)+��=�5 ! )34o� ! 5(� § >�>�= �}! 4�<3�:=+, �¹�������/4:02)3J���=�< ! 4�< R[�/�GWX }8 � !�# ,�)�.��/>Xex= # �i�/>�>²= # 5(��� % �()GFH�/025 ! )34Vt C = # �/.y({}| tX���/>�=�5H�/.£,�)�.��/> % �() % ) # �/. ! 4 { �:= % 5H��� � =+>�)34�<O� ! 5(� # )3,��&�(�/>$=�5H�/.£,�=�5H� ![Z tX'ª=+025H)+� !�# =�5 ! )34s,-��5(�Vt)V. # �(�/02�/465(>`K % �() % ) # �/.1'q)+�O5H� Z 5O=+4x=+>`K #�!�# e¨=��(�m,�)�.��/> # �E� ! 0�� ! , % >`K #(% =�� # �/4�� #�# e C J�5�=+>$>`)B�~'*)+�O=. !�# 5H� ! C J�5H�/.w��� % �(� # �/465(=�5 ! )34£)+'g5(����5H� Z 5].:)�0�J:,��/4�5 #� ?y 4o02)3465H��= # 5]5H);5(����c�� =+4:.o=+> # )O5(���@, ![Z 5(J��(�

� · ³

Page 161: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

,-)V.��/>�> ! 4�< % � ! 4x0 !`% >`�+e»=+4 y({}| tX57K % �;,-)V.��/>¹.�)6� # 4�)+5b,�=�¿+�w5(���w= #(# J:, % 5 ! )34D5(�x=�5@�/=+0 � .:=�5(J:, ! 4Vt# 5(=+4:02� # ��)3Jx>�. C �/>`)34�<O5H)w= #(! 4:<3>`��0�>�= #(# e C � ! 4�<O5(�����(��'*)+�(� % )+5H�/465 ! =+>�>`KN,-)+���&� ZV% �(� #(#�! A+� �y 5��(�/,O= ! 4 #��) �¹��A+���}5H) C ���/>�J:0 ! .:=�5H�/. ! 4��E� ! 0�� #(! 5(J:=�5 ! )34 # 5(� !$# 0�=+4;�(�/=+>�>`K C � ! 4�<�= #(! <34 ![« 0�=+465¨=+.�A�=+4�5(=�<+� ! 4O5(���0�= # ��)+'¾5H� Z 5(J:=+>º.x=�5(=

|]# '*=��?= # 5(��� % �() C = C ! > !�# 5 ! 0?>�=�5H�/465?5H��= ! 5},-)�.:�/> # =����_02)34x02����4��/.e�=b,-)+�(�_5(��)+�()3J:<3� ! 4�A+� # 5 ! <3=�5 ! )34)+' ! 5 #-% �() % ���(5 ! � #-# J:0���= # =+4:=+>`K �/! 4�<s5(���£,�=�<34 ![« 0�=�5 ! )341'*=+025H)+� #vR[� · ³�W )+� �s=+4:. 0�J��(A�=�5(J��(� #£R[���+��W02)3J:>�. % �()BA ! .��b)+5(�����&�i=BK # )+' « 4x. ! 4�<;5(����0�>�= #(#�# 5H��J:025(J���� ! 4s5(��� % �()GFH�/025 ! )34 #H% =+02��5(�:=+4¬5(����0�>$= #(#=+4:=+>`K #(!�# 0�J����(�/4�5(>�K9�/, % >�)BK+�/. ! 4 { �:= % 5H���-· 1| � ! ����=�� 0�� ! 0�=+>i� Z 5H�/4 #(! )341)+']5(��� % ��) % ) # �/.M<+�/4:����=+>5H��= ! 5E,-)�.:�/>�'*=+, ! >`K+e #(! , ! >�=�� ! 4 #H%x! � ! 5¹5H)"5(�:=�5�.���A+�/>�) % �/.m'q)+��S=+J #(#(! =+4o.:=�5(= ! 4 R[���V�/W �¹)3Jx>�.N=+> # ) C �,-)+5 ! A�=�5H�/.;'q)+� ! 465H����=+025 ! A+�/>`KOA !�# J:=+> !�#(! 4�<S=&>�=���<+�E=+4:.;02)3, % >`� Z 5H� Z 5}02)3>�>`�/025 ! )34 a ! 4:02�^5(�:�],-)V.��/>©�:= #C ���/4N'*)+��,&Jx>�=�5H�/.N= # =-<+�/4:����=�5 ! A+��,-)V.��/>�e�5(� !�#?!�# '*)+��,�=+>�>�KO= # 5H��= ! <3��5H'*)+�(�}=���.m,�=�5H5H���

|]# =+4�)+5(�:��� % ) #(#(! C >��}. ! �(�/025 ! )34b'*�()3, 5(���E,-)�.:�/>�> ! 4�< % ��� #H% �/025 ! A+�+e�= # =�02)34�5 ! 46J:=�5 ! )34�5H)�5(��� % �() C t= C ! > !�# 5 ! 0g,-)V.��/> # )+'�5H) % )+<+��= % � ! 0¨A !�# J:=+> !�# =�5 ! )34e =],�)+�(�¨<+�/4���� =+>�,�)�.��/>$> ! 4�<?'*��=+,-���i)+�(¿�'*)+� A !�# Jx=+> !�#(! 4:<) C FH�/025 #¨# Jx0��O= # � =��(¿+) A { �:= ! 4 #^� �s{�� �¹)3Jx>�. C �?)+' ! 4�5H���(� # 5 Y{ >�J # 5H��� ! 4�< �¬{}# �:= # C ���/4�02)34 #(! .����(�/.! 4 RU�+TGWX ¹| 5H) % )+<+��= % � ! 0�=+>�� Z 5H�/4 #(! )34N���/>�=�5H�/.N5H)O5(� !�# �¹)+��¿;=+4:.m�/, % >`) K ! 4:<@5(�:�@a �� =+>`<+)+� ! 5(�x,~�:= #C ���/4 % �() % ) # �/. ! 4 R ��TGW '*)+� C ! 4x=��(KmA�=+>�J��/.¬.:=�5(=w)+'i�/>`�/025H�()34 ! 0-0�=+>�> # 'q)+��'q��=+Jx.v.:��5H�/025 ! )34 -| % �() C =GtC ! > !�# 5 ! 0�'q)+��,@J:>�=�5 ! )34")+'»5(���S5H) % )+<+��= % � ! 0�=+>�0�>�J # 5H��� ! 4�<b)+' �¬{}# '*)+�^. !�# 02�(��5H�_)+���G=+4x.m02)34�5 ! 46J�)3J # .:=�5(=�i)3J:>�. C ��=�5(����)+�(��5 ! 0�=+> !�#(# J�� # )3,-���E�:=�5 # 5H� = ! <3��5H'*)+�(�}=���."5H)�'*)3>�>`)B� ! 4-� Z 5H�/4 #(! )34O5H)&5(�����i)+�(¿-��� ! 0���:= # C ���/4 % ���('*)+��,-�/. � )+����)BA+���/ei02)34 #(! .���� ! 4�<m) C FH�/025 # = #�h � �v#@! 4 # 5H�/=+.M)+' �s{?# �i)3J:>�.9'*J:�(5(�����# 5H�(�/4:<+5(���/4 5(��� % )B�i����)+'_5(���m,-��5(�:)�. C K1=+>�>`)B� ! 4�<v'q)+��5 ! ,-� # ��� ! � # ��� ! 0 �I.:)94�)+5-�(� \ J ! �(�w5H) C ��¬{}#� ¨|E%:% > ! 0�=�5 ! )34w)+' 5(�:� # ��,-)V.��/> # 5H)O� < A !�# J:=+> !$#(! 4�<@�¹� C 4:=/A ! <3=�5 ! )34£J # ��� % ��) « >`� # �i)3J:>�. C � ! 4Vt5H���(� # 5 ! 4�< 'º02)3J�� # �+e�J�5 ! > !��/! 4�<�=&02)34 # 5H��= ! 4��/.;A+��� #�! )34O)+' 5(��� h � �£#N� ��� ! 0��;=+>`)34��_0�=+4 % �()BA ! .��_=5H) % )+<+��= % � ! 0?�(� % �(� # �/4�5(=�5 ! )34 ! '�5(���].:=�5(= # ��� ! � #¨!$# 02)3�����(�/465�e�= # �i�E�x=/A+� # ��)B�E4 ! 4 { �:= % 5H��� �7� =+4:.0�>�J # 5H��� ! 4�<S)+�iA !$# J:=+> !�#�! 4�<]5(��� # �]�¹)3J:>$. % �() A ! .:��=�,-�/0 �:=+4 !�# , )+'²4�) A+�/>�� ! ����=���0 � ! 0�=+>�A !�# J:=+> !�# =�5 ! )34b'*)+�5(���S0�= # �S)+'²5 ! ,-� # ��� ! � #� z:J:�(5(�����^02)34 #(! .���� ! 4�<@=@5H�/, % )+��=+>�,-)�.:�/>x)34w5(���_5H) % >`��A+�/>�)+' 5(� !�# � ! ����=���0 ��K�i)3J:>�.N=+> # ) C � % ) #(#(! C >`�

�����

Page 162: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

� � 8 � � � � � /

R[�QW��: º| >�>�=+4e �� »{ =�� C )34:�/>�>�e � dE)V.:. ! 4�<+5H)34e �: �� =���,-)34²e»=+4:. �@ �� =+4�<�e�� 8 ) %x! 0�.���5H�/025 ! )34I=+4:.5H� =+0(¿ ! 4�< %x! >`)+5 # 5(J:.�K « 4:=+>©�(� % )+�(5�e� ! 4�2\ B�a �jB�������������;\ B ��_�a �TEgY��^[ � E�� \ ��@ EKaK\gD �*Y D B�@ ��@�_� @C_ [K\�E�Y ��@C_�DO@ ��� B�\ � E � B �©e �/³+³+T e %:%² ²�/³ · ���V�/T�

RU� W a �| ,�=�� ! e |� &{ � ! 0���)V0(¿ ! eb=+4:. h& !� =+4�<�e"� | 4�����>`�/=���4 ! 4�<¶=+>`<+)+� ! 5(�:,¢'*)+� C > ! 4:. # )3J���02�# � % =���=�5 ! )34e� ! 4# \ B�a$� B��%� _�����@Ca�[�E DO@&�>[Kb \ �('*)�@+��Br\�] �rY DnB�@,2\ B�ag[gE�E�DO@ �.-�GTE�Y�[�]^E0/1�2)34-65 798 ed x8 )3J��(��5 � ¿�K+e �M � ) � ���/e �M �h = #(# �/>�,�)�e § . #� e �£yr8 &Y��� #(# e �/³+³+� e %x%² C����� �c���r�� R � W a ©| ,�=�� ! e:� � �/=���4 ! 4:< ! 4 # 5H��J:025(J��(�/. % =���=+,-��5H��� #H% =+02� # � 4:=�5(J���=+> u ! �/,�=+4x4 ! =+4w<+��=+. ! �/4�5�e� ! 4

2\ B a$��� _�� ��@�a�[gE&DO@.�^[�bc\ �('�)�@+��Br\�] �rY DnB�@; \ B�a�[�E�EgDF@ �<-CG E�Y�[�]^E>=�e �M � ) � ���/e �9 ?� )+� .:=+4¬=+4:.8 � &»��5 # 0����+e § . #/ e �oyr8 &¨�(� #(# e �/³+³�� e %:%² ²�/��� �©���r�� R · W a :| ,�=�� ! e@�$D A)[K\ [K@�Y D �(':B;[7Br]d[�Y \�Dna �C'�DZ[KY�� B�_�E$DF@0-CY ��Y D E�Y D aKE � ����> ! 4 i a % � ! 4:<+���icg��� >�=�<�e �/³+T��� R/� W>h& +| 5H5 ! = # e?� y 4:.�� % �/4:.��/465º'ª=+025H)+�Y=+4:=+>`K #(!�# e���^[�bc\ �('�EjB�] �Cb Y �rY DnB�@:e6A+)3> ��+� e64�) ·�e %x%² �T���� ��T��V� e�/³+³+³� RU� W>h& ¾| 5H5 ! = # eF� y 4�'q����� ! 4�< % =���=+,-��5H��� # =+4:. # 5H��J:025(J:�(�O)+'^>�=�5H�/465@AG=�� ! = C >`�",�)�.��/> # C K¬AG=�� ! =�5 ! )34:=+>

� =BK+� # e� ! 4G \ B�a$�IHKJrY��&EjB�@+��[�\7[�@�a�[�B�@ � @Ca�[K\gY ��DO@�Y G DF@G�)\�Y D L aKD �('@)�@�Y�[9'M' D � [�@Cag[2e �/³+³+³� R �BW&|& � =+0(¿¶=+4:. |& �� � ! <+�/4:.e�� |�« � # 5;= %:% > ! 0�=�5 ! )34±)+' ! 4:.�� % �/4:.��/465O02)3, % )34��/465m=+4:=+>`K #(!�# 5H)� Z 5H��=+025 ! 4:< # 5H��Jx025(J��(�^'*�()3, # 5H)�0�¿��(��5(J���4 # e�N)�@�Y�[K\�@ ��Y D B�@ �('�OcBrb \g@ �('3B��P�>[Kb \ �('Q-�GTEgY�[�]^EQe�A+)3> 6T e%x%² · ��� � · T ·�e | J�<3J # 5 �/³+³��6 RUT W b � =���4:.�)+� ��t p]! �/> # �/4eR)�@+��Br\�] �rY DnB�@ ��@�_TS�U �cB�@�[K@�Y D�C'WV ��]�DM' Dn[�E;DO@�-CY �rY DFEgY Dna �('�� �c[7Br\�G { � ! 0��Vt� # 5H��� i �¶! >`��K+e �/³���T� RU³ W>h& � =���>`) ��e�� � �:=�5 !�# 5(�:��02)3, % J�5(=�5 ! )34x=+><+)3=+>²)+'»5(����4���)V02)+�(5H� ZQX e� ! 4GY ��\ �?[9Z�EKa �('X[F�^[�bc\ B�@ �('

� � [7B�\gDn[�E^B��$Y�� [�� \ ��DO@:e {_ h )V0��£=+4:. �� d_=BA !�# e § . #/ e { =+, C � ! .�<+�+e �v| i �oyr8 &Y��� #(# e �/³+³ · R[���GW d � =��(5(��)3>�)3,-����e[Y ��Y�[�@�Y]\ ��\gD�_^9' [�D B _ [`' E ��@C_�V ��a Y B�\N�)@ �(' GTE�DFE � )34:.�)34 i { �:=���>�� # �_� ! �"4a { ) � 5(.²e �/³+T��6 R[�+�QW �M � =��(5(>���5H5�e4�Hzx=+02� ! ,O=�<+�&=+4:=+>`K #(!�# C KmJ:4 # J % ���(A !�# �/.w>`�/=���4 ! 4�<�=+4:.N�(�/.xJ:4:.:=+4:02K;�(�/.:Jx025 ! )34e�

&¹� d . !�#�# ���(5(=�5 ! )34e � 4 ! A+��� #�! 57K;)+' { =+> ! '*)+��4 ! =Ve:aV=+4md ! ��<+)�e �/³+³+T� R[�/� W d � ����'q����,O=+4e |� �� ���(<+���/e^=+4:. �� �� =T������57K+e���a�5(=�5 !$# 5 ! 0�=+>],-)�.:�/> # '*)+�O5H� Z 5 # ��<3,��/4�5(=�5 ! )34²e�

D ��a��?DF@�[2Y [ ��\�@�DF@ �Cb E � [�aKD �('3D E�E�b�[B�@�� �rY bc\ �('@Y �r@ �rb � � [�Y [ ��\g@ DF@��+eVA+)3> � ·�eV4:) ©� � � e %:%² ©� �r� ��V��� e �/³+³+³� R[��� W@|& � �/>$>¹=+4:. 8S a���FH4:)B� # ¿ ! e!� | 4 ! 4:'q)+��,O=�5 ! )34Vt7,�= Z�! , !�# =�5 ! )34¬= %:% �()3=+0 �I5H) C > ! 4:. # � % =�� =�5 ! )34=+4x. C > ! 4x.".��/02)346A+)3>�J�5 ! )34e�c�^[�bc\ �C'IEjB�] �Cb Y �rY DnB�@:e�A+)3> �� e %:%º ²�+�/�+³ �©�+���+³ e �/³+³��� R[� · W@|& � �/>`)3J:0��:��=+4 ! =+4:. �� ¨{ =���.�) # )�eF� | ,�= Z�! ,@J:,h> ! ¿+�/> ! ��)�)V. # )3J���02� # � % =���=�5 ! )34I'q)+�-. !$# 02�(��5H�# )3J���02� # e� ! 4# \ B�a$� B��%S2b \ B � [ ��@d-CD ��@ �('e2\ B a�[gE�E�DO@ �dEjB�@$�K[K\ [K@Ca�["/fS � -RI)(E4gh8 e²A+)3> ¾� e �/³+³ ·�e%x%² C���+T �c�r���� R[��� W �M � �����(K+e�� � =��(<+�2t # 0�=+>�� #H% =�� # � #�! 4�<3J:>�=��SA�=+>�J��"02)3, % J�5(=�5 ! )34 # e�i� �c[>)�@�Y�[K\�@ ��Y D B�@ �('4OcB�bc\g@ �('B3��-�b � [�\jZ a�B�] �Cb Y�[�\F� � �@' D a �rY D Br@ E e©A+)3> ©� ex4�) � e %:%² ��� � · ³ e �/³+³+��

���V�

Page 163: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

R[�/� W@§� �}! 4�<3�:=+,me |� �! = C��=+4e�=+4:. �M � ! �()3>$=+, ! e?�Hz ! 4:. ! 4�<_5H) %x! 0 #¨! 4-.�K�4x=+, ! 0�=+>V5H� Z 5 i |�%:% > ! 0�=�5 ! )345H)"0��:=�5]> ! 4��S. !�# 0�J #(#(! )34 # e� ! 4 �d�d�GH��%;BTEgY�[K\� \ B�a�[�[7_�DO@ �rE e ���+��� e %:%² ²�/³+T �©�/³+³� R[� �BW-{_ �}!�# ��) % eQ�^[�bc\ �(' �^[KY�(B�\ � E��KB�\! �rYnY�[�\g@G� [7a�B �r@�DOY DnB�@ EZ 'q)+��. � 4 ! A+��� #(! 57K &Y��� #(# e �/³+³��� R[�/T W-{_ �}!�# ��) % e � � =BK+� #(! =+4 & {}| e� ! 4 2\ B a$� B3� �^[�bc\ �C'.)�@+�KB�\g] ��Y D B�@ \ B�a�[�E�EgDF@ � -�GTEgY�[K]>E

/1�2)34-65 HKHj8 e �9 ! �/=���4 # e©a aV)3>�>�=-=+4:.Nd �{ )3�x4e § . #/ e �oyr8 &Y��� #(# e �/³+³+³ e %:%² �+T+� � �+T+T� R[�/³ W-{_ �}!�# ��) % =+4:. p& � =/���(�/4:02�+e��rcY=�� ! =�5 ! )34:=+> � =BK+� #(! =+4 ! 4:.:� % �/4x.��/4�5-02)3, % )34��/465w=+4:=+>`K #(!�# e�8 �/0�� u^� %º e { )3, % J�5H��� � = C )+��=�5H)+�(K+e � 4 ! A+��� #(! 57K;)+' { =+, C � ! .�<+�+e ���+�+�V RU���GW-{_ �i!$# ��) % e �M a�A+�/4 # ��/4e©=+4:. {] ��¶! >�> ! =+, # eh� � 8�� i 8 ���_<+�/4�����=�5 ! A+��5H) % )+<+� = % � ! 0S,�= %x%x! 4�<�e�

�^[�bc\ �('IEjB�] �Cb Y �rY DnB�@:e�A+)3> º��� e�4�) ²� e %:%º x�V��� ���r��� e �/³+³+T� RU�V�QW-{_ �}!�# ��) % e �9 aVA+�/4 # ��/4e =+4x. {] �¶! >�> ! =+, # eP�Hd]��A+�/>`) % ,-�/465 # )+'}5(���O<+�/4�����=�5 ! A+�"5H) % )+<+� = % � ! 0,O= %:%x! 4�<�e���^[�bc\ B�a�Br] ��bcY DO@ �3exA+)3> ©�V� e %:%² x����� ���+� ·�e �/³+³+T� RU�+� W-{_ �}!�# �:) % e � 3h]! 465H)34e�=+4x. yQ aV5H��=+0��:=+4²e6� � 8*� 5(���()3J:<3�o5 ! ,��+e� ! 40 \ B�a �h)3SIS�V(D ��Y���)�@�Y�[K\ Z@ �rY D Br@ �('PEjB�@+��[�\7[�@Cag[�B�@G�)\gY D L a�D�(' �>[Kb \ �(' �^[KY�(Br\ � E e yr§¨§ e �/³+³�� e %:%º ²�+�+� �©�+�/��

RU�r� W-{_ �}!�# ��) % =+4:. �9 �8^!`%x%x! 4�<�e�� � =�5H�/4�5�AG=�� ! = C >`�E,�)�.��/> # =+4x.;.x=�5(=&A !�# Jx=+> !�# =�5 ! )34²e� ! 4<-CY �rY DFEgY Dna�E�r@C_"�>[Kbc\ �('I�^[KY�(Br\ � E��"� [�a�[�@CY�� _�����@Ca�[�E �rY^Y��c[ )�@�Y�[�\f� ��a�[�e �: B! =BK =+4:. �M ¹8^! 5H5H��� ! 4�<+5H)34e§ . #� e EZ '*)+��. i EZ 'q)+� . � 4 ! A+��� #(! 5LK &¨�(� #(# e �/³+³+³ e %:%² � · � �©�/� ·

RU� · W-{_ �i!$# ��) % =+4:. �M x8^!`%:%©! 4�<�e[� | � ! ��� =���0�� ! 0�=+>�>$=�5H�/4�5^A�=�� ! = C >`�],�)�.��/>�'*)+�^.:=�5(=bA !�# J:=+> !�� =�5 ! )34e�)3SIS:S � \ ��@ E ��a Y D B�@ E.B�@� ��YnY�[�\g@c�)@ �(' GTE�DFE �r@C_FD ��a � DO@�[P)�@�Y�[`'f' D � [�@Cag[2e3A+)3> ���� e�4�) � e %x%² 3�+TV� ��+³r� e �/³+³+T�

RU��� W d � )3>`��K+eT� &Y� ! 4:0 !`% =+>¨. ! �(�/025 ! )34M. ! A !�#(! A+� % =��(5 ! 5 ! )34 ! 4�<�e�.� �rY �<D DO@ DF@�� ��@C_��>@�B��P' [�_ �?[c�$D EjZa�B���[K\�G�e©A+)3> x� ex4�) ·�e %:%² �+��� � � ·+·�e �/³+³+T�

RU�+� W%�: �� )34:��5^=+4:. & c ! )3>�=Ve*��a�5H� J:025(J��(�S.�� ! A+�/4 ! ,O=�<+��.:=�5(= C = # �S�(��5H� ! ��AG=+>Xe� ! 4�2\ B�a �jB��2� _�� ��@�a�[gEDO@��^[�bc\ �('C)�@$��B�\g] �rY DnB�@ 2\ B a�[gE�E�DO@ �F-�GTEgY�[�]^E!/f��)36-65 =��8Ge �M � )+��.:=+4e �M 0! �/=���4 # eG=+4x.@a a�)3>�>�=Ve§ . #� e �£y�8 &Y�(� #(# e �/³+³+T e %:%º xT+��� ��T�����

RU���BW%�: � J:�:,�=+4:4²e4��aV5H)�0 �:= # 5 ! 0-=+>`<+)+� ! 5(�:, # '*)+�S� Z�% >`)+��=�5H)+�(Kv.:=�5(=N=+4:=+>`K #(!�# i d_=�5(=m0�>�J # 5H��� ! 4�<w=+4:..x=�5(="A !�# Jx=+> !�# =�5 ! )34²e� ! 4 Y [ ��\�@�DF@ �6DO@ B \ � � � Dna �('hD B�_ [9' EQe �9 ?� )+� .:=+4e § . e �£y�8 &Y�(� #�# e �/³+³+³ e%x%² · � � � · �/³� RU�+T W&yQ �{ =+.:� � exd Ch �/0(¿+����,�=+4²e {] � ����¿�e�& aV,&K65(�²e:=+4:.va �� � ! 5H�+eI�rc !�# J:=+> !�� =�5 ! )34w)+'g4:=BA ! <3=�5 ! )34% =�5H5H����4 # )34"=��¹� C #(! 5H�EJ #(! 4�<�,-)V.��/>[t C = # �/.O0�>�J # 5H��� ! 4�<�e� ! 4]2\ B�a �RB3�)Y��c[� Z Y��%� E?D -R) B����!�

)�@CY�[�\g@ �rY DnB�@ �('!EjB�@+��[�\7[�@Cag[ Br@ �>@CB��P'X[7_ �?[%�$D EKa�B��r[�\gG ��@C_�� �rY �]D DF@�DF@ �3eu u�=+,�=�¿�� !�# �:4:=+4ea a�5H)3>`'*)�exu � =/K3=�� .�)�e�=+4x. y  &¾=�� # =Ve § . #/ e | J�<3J # 5 ���+�+� e %x%² :�+T�� ���+T+³� RU�+³ W%�: ©{ =���.�) # )b=+4x. & ©{ )3,-)34e*� y 4x.�� % �/4:.��/465}02)3, % )34:�/4�5?=+4:=+>`K #(!�# eV= # J��(A+��KO)+' # )3,-��=+>`<+� C ��= ! 0,���5(��)�. # e� ! 4 )3S:S:S&)�@�Y�[�\g@ �rY DnB�@ �C'W-�G�] �cBTE�DObc] B�@ E DO\ a�b D YOE ��@C_F-�GTEgY�[�]^EF/f) -eE?�!-65 =� 8Ge3A+)3> +� e�/³+³+� e %:%² :³r� ��³+�� R ���GW d 3{ �:=���>�� # =+4:. {_ z»K6'*�+e�� � )V.��/>�> ! 4�<^,&Jx>`5 !`% >`�g0�=+J # � # 5H��Jx025(J��(�¨J #�! 4�<?�(�/025 ![« 0�=�5 ! )34&02)34 # 5H��= ! 465 #4:��57�i)+�(¿©e�,EjB�] �Cb Y �rY DnB�@ DO@ �^[�bc\ �('�-�GTE�Y�[�]^E e %x%² ²�/��� �©�/T+� e � =BK �/³+³+T� R �V�QW & g{ ����� # �/,�=+4M=+4:. �: a�5(J�5 � e�� � =BK+� #(! =+410�>�= #(#�![« 0�=�5 ! )34 �ª| J�5H) { >$= #(# � i 8 ����)+�(Ks=+4:.¬�(� # Jx>`5 # e�| .�A�=+4:02� #�! 4 ! 4�)B�E>`�/.�<+��d !�# 02) A+���(Km=+4:.Nd_=�5(= �v! 4 ! 4:<�e |]|]|�y &Y��� #(# � �£y�8 &¨�(� #(# e �/³+³+�� R �+� W & g{ ����� # �/,�=+4²e �: �! �/>�>`K+e �9 a��/>`'�e �� a�5(J�5 � e � »8 =BK�>`)+�Be»=+4:.9d z��(���/,�=+4²e!� | J�5H) { >$= #(# i |

� =BK+� #(! =+4-0�>�= #(#�![« 0�=�5 ! )34 # K # 5H�/,Ne� ! 4N2\ B�a �*B��2Y��c[:V(D �gY��F)�@�Y�[�\g@ �rY DnB�@ �('�EjBr@+�K[K\ [K@Ca�[ B�@ D ��a � DF@*[YR[ ��\g@ DO@ �+e � )+��<3=+4 ! =+J�'ª,�=+4:4²e �/³+T+T�

R �r� W !� Y{ ���/4e �Y �� J²e¨=+4:. h� ¨{ � ! e!� y , % ��)BA+�/. >`�/=���4 ! 4�<o=+>`<+)+� ! 5(�:, # '*)+�b, ![Z 5(J:�(�O)+'^� ZV% ���(5 #b! 4,@J:>`5 ! 0�>�= #(# 0�>�= #(#�![« 0�=�5 ! )34e���^[�bc\ �(' �^[KY�(B�\ � EQex4�) ©³ e %:%² ²�/�+�+³ �©�/���+� e �/³+³+³� ���+�

Page 164: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

R � · W !� �{ ��J���0��N=+4x. � �_=+>`�+e:� &») !�#(# )34m, ![Z 5(J��(� # e��� �rY bc\ �(' Y ��@ �rb � � [�S @ ��DF@*[�[�\gDO@ �(b2E ��]�^K\�Dn_ �?[� @ D ��[K\�EgDOY G \7[gE�EQe:A+)3> º� e©4�) x� e %:%² ²�/�r� �©�/³�� e �/³+³���

R ��� W & ]{ )3,-)34e � y 4x.�� % �/4:.��/465w02)3, % )34:�/4�5m=+4:=+>�K #(!$# � = 4�����02)34:02� % 5 X e� -�D �r@ �('� \ B�a�[�E�E�DO@ �3eA+)3> C�+� e %:%º ��+T�� � �V� ·�e �/³+³ · R �+� W@8� ²{ )BA+����=+4:. �: 8 ��)3,�= # e�SP' [K]d[K@�YOE B��T)�@+�KB�\�] �rY DnB�@�� �c[�B�\�G � )3�:4 �¶! >`��K£=+4:.Da�)34 # e y 4:0 e�/³+³V�� R ���BW a d]�����(�i� # 5H���/e�a d_J:,O= !�# e � z:J���4:= # e 8S ?� =+4:.:=+J����Be�=+4x.@u Th =�� # �x,�=+4e�� y 4x.�� ZV! 4�< C K�>�=�5H�/465# �/,�=+4�5 ! 0�=+4:=+>`K #(!�# e��Oc�.]d[K\!-�B�a�-*aKD*e�A+)3> · � ex4�) �� e %:%² �+³V� � · � � e �/³+³��V R �+T W@|& d]�/, %©# 5H���/e p& � = ! ��.eº=+4x.9d u�J C ! 4e�� � = ZV! ,&J:,h> ! ¿+�/> ! ��)6)V.£'q�()3, ! 4:02)3, % >`��5H��.:=�5(=NA ! =5(�:� § � =+>`<+)+� ! 5(�x,Ne��OcBrb \g@ �(' B��$Y��c[�� B�G �('�-�Y �rY D E�Y D a �('?-*B�aKD [KY G�e:A+)3> ��+³ e %:%² � � �+T e �/³��r�6 R �+³ W & d ! =+02)34:= # =+4:.od z��(���/.:,O=+4e:� |]# K�, % 5H)+5 ! 0 # )+'¾<+��= % � ! 0�=+> % ��)GFr�/025 ! )34 % J�� # J ! 5�e�>�)@ @ �(' E^B��

-�Y �rY D E�Y D aKE e©A+)3> º�/� e %:%º C��³r� ��TV��� e �/³+T · R · �GW � d])34:=�5H)�e �M � =��(5(>`��5H5�e �: Rh =�<+���/e�& ¾§ ¿V,�=+4e»=+4:. 8S a���F(4�)B� # ¿ ! e2� { >�= #�#(! '*K ! 4:<N'*=+0 ! =+>¹=+0Qt5 ! )34 # e� )3S:S:S � \ ��@ E ��a�Y DnB�@ E$B�@] �rYnY�[�\g@��.@ �(' G EgD E ��@C_TD ��a��?DF@�[2)�@�Y�[`'f' D � [�@Cag[2e�A+)3> V�V� eV4�) ���� e%x%² x³�� · ��³+T+³ e �/³+³+³� R · �QW u d_J:.:=-=+4:. & Ch =��(5�e �rYnY�[K\�@dEh'��TE�EgD L a �rY DnB�@ ��@C_c-*a�[�@*[��.@ �(' G EgD E �¶! >`��K+e �/³����� R · � W a d_J:,�= !�# e �� &¹>�=�5H5�e�d �h �/0�¿+����,�=+4e=+4:. �9 aV=+�:=+, ! e:� y 4x.:J:025 ! A+��>��/=���4 ! 4�<�=+>�<+)+� ! 5(�:, # =+4:.��� % �(� # �/465(=�5 ! )34 # 'q)+�@5H� Z 5@0�=�5H��<+)+� ! � =�5 ! )34e� ! 4# \ B�a$�)B�� )�@�Y�[�\g@ �rY DnB�@ �('FEjB�@$�K[K\ [K@Ca�[ Br@,)�@+�KB�\ Z] �rY DnB�@ ��@�_ �>@CB��P'X[7_ � [�D ��@ � �?[�] [K@�Y!/f� E?D Z`E?) ��D�5 =C798 e �/³+³+T e %x%² � · T�� ������

R · � W@|& d]Jx4:,&J:�]=+4:.vd 8^! 5H5H��� ! 4:<+5H)34eI� | 4:=+>`K #(!�# )+'¨>�=�5H�/465 # 5H��J:025(J��(�b,-)V.��/> # � ! 5(�v,&J:>�5 ! . ! ,-�/4�t#�! )34:=+>�>�=�5H�/4�5iA�=�� ! = C >`� # e� ! 4 -CY �rY DFEgY Dna�E ��@C_��>[Kb \ �('Q�^[KY�(B�\ � E �4�;[7a�[K@�Y[� _�� �r@Ca�[�E �rYjY�� [2)�@�Y�[K\ Z� ��ag[2e �: ! =BKw=+4x.md ©8^! 5H5H��� ! 4�<+5H)34e § . #� e EZ '*)+��. i EZ 'q)+� . � 4 ! A+��� #(! 5LK &¨�(� #(# e �/³+³+³ e %:%º ²�/��� ��/³ ·

R ·+· W u d_J�� C ! 4²eYu a � �/> !$# ¿ ! eY=+4:. |� e� J ! >�>`�+eF� | 4 =+4:=+>`K #(!�# )+'E5(���N�/>�= # 5 ! 0N4:��5�= %:% �()3=+0 �15H)D5(���5H� =/A+�/>�> ! 4�< # =+>`� # ,O=+4 % �() C >��/,Ne�>�>[Kb \ �('4EjB�] �Cb Y �rY D Br@:e©A+)3> ²� ex4�) C� e %x%² � · T � ���+T e �/³+T+³� R · � W-{_ �§ 0(¿�=��(5¨=+4:. � (� )3Jx4�<�e�� | &Y� ! 4x0 !`% =+> |�Z�!�#¾8 ��=+4 # 'q)+� ,�=�5 ! )34@'q)+� p )34Vt h ����, ! 5 ! =+4 � =�5H� ! 02� # e�

�;bR'f' ���.]d[K\`�?D �rY�� �h-*B�a$� � J�e �+�/T ���V�� R · � W��] �§ A+��� ! 5H5�e �)@c)�@�Y \ B�_�b a Y D B�@AY BTY ��Y�[�@�YF\ �r\�D �_^`'X[�D B�_ [9' E � )34:.�)34"=+4:. p ��� � )+�(¿ i { �x= % ,�=+4=+4x. h =+>$>�e �/³+T · R · �BW%�: z�� ! �/.:,O=+4@=+4x. �: +8 J�¿+��K+e[� | % �()GFH�/025 ! )34 % J:� # J ! 5 =+>`<+)+� ! 5(�:, '*)+�¾� Z�% >�)+��=�5H)+�(K&.x=�5(=S=+4:=+>`K #(!�# e�

)3SIS:S � \ ��@ E ��a Y D B�@ E�B��cEjBr] ��bcY�[K\�EQexA+)3> 0Qt �r� e©4�) ©³ e %:%² :T+TV� ��T+³�� e �/³�� · R · T W-{_ z»K6'*�£=+4:. u � =+.:.:�/>`��K+e>� p )34�t7> ! 4��/=��O.x=�5(= # 5H��Jx025(J��(�m� Z 5H��=+025 ! )34±J #(! 4:< #(! , % >��w�:� C:C ! =+44:��57�i)+�(¿ # e�]�;D BC' B ��D a �('PE GK^�[�\g@�[KY Dna�EQe:A+)3> C��� e %:%² �r�r� ��� · � e �/³+³��� R · ³ W �¨ �S= ! 5 ! 4 ! e {] cY= ! .:=Ve � g{ )3>�> ! 4 # e �M a�)3,-� ! e»=+4x. §� aV= C )�e!� | �}=��(�/4�� #(# .���5H�/025 ! )34I.xJ�� ! 4�<02�/= # =��(�/=+4 # �/025 ! )34�Jx4:.����-<+�/4�����=+>E=+4:=�� # 5(��� #�! =9J #�! 4�< §¨§ � #H% �/025H��J:, =+4:=+>`K #(!�# e� E ��@ ��_rD��@

O B�bc\g@ �(' B3���)@ � [�EgY��c[�E�D ��e:A+)3> · � e %:%² ����r� � �+TV�� R/���GW & �S=���.��/4�'*)+� # e:EjB�@�a�[ �*Y b �C'�- � ��a�[�E ��£yr8 &Y�(� #�# e ���+�+�V R/�V�QW��¾ �_�:=+�:��=+,�=+4 ! =+4:. �M � �/=+>�e4� �]��= % � ! 0�=+>»,-)�.:�/> # =+4:.oAG=�� ! =�5 ! )34:=+> ,-��5(��)V. # e� ! 4<� _�� ��@�a�[7_

DZ[ ��@GV(D [`' _%DZ[KY�� B _�� � � [7B�\gG ��@C_ \ ��a Y D ag[+�$exd aV=+=+.o=+4x. �9 _%:% ���/e § . #� e ���+�+�V R/�+� W��¾ �_�:=+�:��=+,�=+4 ! =+4:. � *h]! 4�5H)34²eI� h]! ����=���0 � ! 0�=+>»4�)34Vt7> ! 4:�/=��^'*=+025H)+�S=+4:=+>�K #(!$# =+4:.£5H) % )+<+� = % � ! 0,O= %x# e� ! 4d�;_�����@Cag[gEeDO@#�^[�bc\ �C'I)�@+��Br\�] �rY DnB�@ \ B�a�[�E�EgDF@ �&-CG E�Y�[�]^E"/f��)36-65 H�� 8Ge �M I� )+��.:=+4e�M ! �/=�� 4 # e:=+4:.£a a�)3>�>�=Ve § . #� e { =+, C � ! .:<+�+e �v| i �oyr8 &¨�(� #(# e �/³+³+T�

���r�

Page 165: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

R/�r� W��¾ �_�:=+����=+,O=+4 ! =+4:. � �h]! 4�5H)34²eN� 8 ��� §�� =+>`<+)+� ! 5(�:, '*)+��, ![Z 5(J��(� # )+'�'ª=+025H)+�"=+4x=+>`K # ��� # e�8 �/0�� u^� %º ©{ u �Et 8 u?t ³+� t � e�4�) · T+� � · ³+� e � 4 ! A+��� #(! 57K;)+' 8 )+�()3465H)�e©d]� % =��(5(,��/4�5^)+' { )3, % J�5H���a�0 ! �/4:02�+e �/³+³��6 R/� · W �M � ! �()3>�=+, ! e�� � =�5H�/465]0�>�= #�# =+4:.m5H� = ! 5�,-)V.��/> # '*)+�E.x=�5(=�0�>�= #(#(!`« 0�=�5 ! )34m=+4:.oA !$# J:=+> !�# =�5 ! )34e� ! 4

)(E?� �4 \gDF@Ca�D � ' [�E ��@C_< \ ��a�Y Dna�[�eia u^) C ���(5 # =+4:.Iu ¾§ A+��� # )34²e § . #/ e { =+, C � ! .�<+� � 4 ! A+��� #(! 5LK&¨�(� #(# e %x%² x��� · ������³ e ���+����

R/��� W �M � ! �()3>�=+, ! e � | AG=�� ! =�5 ! )34:=+>E,-��5(��)V.�'*)+�;>��/=���4 ! 4�< #(% =�� # �v=+4:.�) A+����02)3, % >���5H�v��� % �(� # �/465(=Gt5 ! )34 #� e�c�^[�bc\ �('IEjB�] �Cb Y �rY DnB�@:e�A+)3> º��� e ���+���� R/�+� W �M � ! �()3>�=+, ! =+4:. {] z»K6'*�+e � | 4S� Z 5H�/4:.��/.�� Z�% >�)+��=�5H)+�(K % �()GFH�/025 ! )34 % J�� # J ! 5�4���57�i)+�(¿_� ! 5(��> ! 4��/=��=+4x. 4�)34x> ! 4��/=���=+465 ! t7��� C:C ! =+4�02)34:4:�/025 ! )34 # = %:% > ! �/.15H)I5(���v02)�025(= ! > % =��(5LK % �() C >��/,Ne�d�>[Kb \ �('

�^[KY�(Br\ � E exA+)3> ²��� e %:%² �/��� � �©�/�V�/T e �/³+³��6 R/���BW �M � ! �()3>$=+, ! e�� | <+�/4�����=�5 ! A+�_,-)V.��/>x'*)+� #H% =�� # �_. !�# 02�(��5H� C ! 4:=��(K-.:=�5(=&� ! 5(�;4�)34Vt7J:4 ! 'q)+��, 0�=�5H�2t<+)+� ! 0�=+> % � ! )+� # e� ! 4 \ B�a �RS2bc\ B � [ ��@]-�G�] �cBTEgDFbc] Br@%�)\�Y D L4aKD �('_�>[Kb \ �('_�^[KY�(B�\ � E�/fS4-R�2���<5 � �j8 e���+�+� e %:%² � ���� R/�+T W �M � ! �()3>�=+, ! e |& ]{}! 0 ��)�0�¿ ! e_=+4x. a ^| ,�=�� ! e � | 02)3,�,-)34 4:�/J���=+>S4���5L�¹)+�(¿ ,�)�.��/>_'*)+�m� Z t% >`)+��=�5H)+�(K�.x=�5(=M=+4:=+>�K #(!$# =+4:. ! 4:.�� % �/4:.:�/4�5O02)3, % )34:�/4�5w=+4:=+>`K #(!�# e� )3SIS:S � \ �r@ E ��a Y D Br@ E Br@

�^[�bc\ �(' �^[KY�(B�\ � EQexA+)3> x³ e©4�) ©� e %:%º ²� · ³�� �©������� e �/³+³+T� R/�+³ W �M � ! �()3>�=+, ! e��Hd])�0�J:,��/4�5&�(� % �(� # �/465(=�5 ! )34 # C = # �/.9)34D<+�/4�����=�5 ! A+�;,@J:>`5 ! A�=�� ! =�5H� C ����4:)3J:>�> ! >�=Gt5H�/465_5H) %x! 0@,-)V.��/> # e� ! 4.2\ B a$�4B��^Y�� [N��E[-QZ )3�2-[B���� @C_c�)@�@ b �('4EjBC'M' B��KbcDObc] Br@.)�@+�KB�\g] ��Y D B�@

�;[KY \gDn[ � �('�� [gE�[ ��\ a���e ���+�+� e %x%² ²�/³ · �������� RU���GW �M � ! �()3>�=+, ! e -*[9' �jZ`g \ � ��@ D���DO@ �>�>[Kbc\ �(' �>[�Y�(B�\ � E a % � ! 4�<+���}cg����>$=�<�e �/³+³+³� RU�V�QW �M � ! �()3>�=+, ! e § . e@� _�� ��@�a�[gE>DF@G)�@C_ [ � [�@�_ [�@�Y�EjB�] �cBr@�[�@�Y:�.@ �(' G EgD E9��;[K\�E � [7a Y D �r[gE$DO@ �>[Kb \ �('

EjBr] ��bcY ��Y D B�@ a % � ! 4�<+���}cg����>�=�<�e ���+�+�V RU�+� W&yQ � �])�)�.²e*� �c[2S4E�Y DF] �rY DnB�@ B��P2\ B ^ �_^KDM' DOY D [gE ���)@cS4E�E ��G Br@]D B�_?[�\g@�� ��G [gEgD��@ D [�Y�� B�_TEQe �oyr8

&¨�(� #(# e �/³+���� RU�r� W & 4h J C ���/e�� &Y�()GFH�/025 ! )34 % J�� # J ! 5�e� � �c[��)@�@ �(' EeB3� -CY �rY DFEgY Dna�EQeiA+)3> ���� e^4�) ¹� e %:%² · ��� � · ��� e�/³+T��� RU� · W c �h J:>�>`�S=+4:. �9 � =���0�e�V ��D Y�� �gb '�� [ ��\ [�EK[�@CY �rY D Br@ E �r@C_ ��B � B �r\ � � � Dna D � �CE��e�g\ Br] �$DFEgY B�\�Y D Br@Y B>)�@$��B�\g] �rY DnB�@ ¹p ��� � )+��¿ i { � ! 0��:� # 5H��� i �¶! >`��K+e ���+�+�V

RU��� W@|& h K�A��=�� ! 4��/4e � { )3, % >`� Z�! 5LK % J�� # J ! 5 i a�� % =���=�5 ! 4�< ! 4�5H���(� # 5 ! 4�<�02)3, % )34��/465 # 'q�()3, 5 ! ,-�2t # ��� ! � # e��^[�bc\ �('IEjB�] �Cb Y �rY DnB�@Wb2Y B � � � [ ��\

RU�+� W �M �y�# =�� .o=+4:. |� � >$=�¿+�+e4� { )34�5H)3J��]5H��=+0�¿ ! 4:< C K # 5H)�0 �:= # 5 ! 0 % �() % =�<3=�5 ! )34o)+'Y02)34x. ! 5 ! )34:=+>º.��/4Vt#�! 57K+e�� \ B�a$��S2bc\ B � [ ��@ EjBr@+�`�(B�@dEjB�] �Cb Y�[�\0\ DFE�DnB�@:e�A+)3> º� e %:%² �� · � � ���+� e �/³+³+�� RU���BW-{_ yr# C �/>�>3=+4:. & c ! )3>�=Ve��Hu�� # 5H��J:025(J�� ! 4�< #H% =�� # �¹� ! <3�&. ! ,-�/4 #(! )34:=+>+.:=�5(=]'q)+�»�����/025 ! A+�}�(��5H� ! ��A�=+>�e�! 4�2\ B�a ���;_�����@Cag[gEDF@��>[Kb \ �('Q)�@+�KB�\g] ��Y D B�@G2\ B�ag[gE�E�DO@ ��-�GTEgY�[�]^EFHKH�e �M �! �/=���4 # exa a�)3>�>�=&=+4:.d �{ )3�:4e § . #� e �oyr8 &¨�(� #(# e �/³+³+³ e %:%² · T�� � · T+�� RU�+T W@8� e� =+=�¿6¿+)3>�=s=+4:. �M *� )+��.:=+4e�� � =/K+� #�! =+4 >`)+< !�# 5 ! 0O�(��<+��� #(#(! )34 i | AG=�� ! =�5 ! )34:=+>¨= %x% �()3=+0��²e� ! 4

2\ B a$�jB�@ Y��c[NHK=K=� EjB�@+��[�\7[�@�a�[>B�@ �.\gY D L aKD �('Q)�@�Y�[9'M' D � [�@Cag[ �r@C_ -�Y �rY D E�Y D aKE e �/³+³�� e %x%² V�+Tr� ���+³ · RU�+³ W@8� I� � C =�� =Ve �b Yy AG=+4�) A©e |& u�=+� ! , ! e¹=+4x. |� &»�/465(>�=+4:. e � 8 ��=+0(¿ ! 4�<M02)34�A+��� # =�5 ! )34:=+>�02)3465H� Z 5'*)+�O,�=+0 � ! 4��N,-�/. ! =�5 ! )34I)+']��J:,�=+41. !$# 02)3J�� # �+e� ! 4d�2����) V �('f'� � � �"-�G�] �cBTEgDFbc] Z�-�B aKD �('M' G

)�@CY�[`'f' D �?[K@�Ye� �?[K@�YOEFZN� �c[� b ] ��@ DO@ Y��c[�Y�B�B �©e p )BA ����+�+�V R �G�GW&yQ @� )3>�> ! ���+eQ \gDF@Ca�D � �('IEjB�] �cB�@*[�@�Y:�)@ �(' GTEgD E a % � ! 4�<+���HtXcg����>�=�<�e �/³+T+�� R ���QW-{_ e� J�5H5H�/4M=+4x. �: Rh ����=+J:>`5�eF� � > ! 4:. # � % =���=�5 ! )34M)+' # )3J���02� # e % =��(5 ! i | 41=+.:= % 5 ! A+�;=+>`<+)+� ! 5(�:,C = # �/.N)34o4:�/J��()3, ! ,���5 ! 0_=���0�� ! 5H�/025(J��(�+e��-�D �r@ �(' \ B�ag[gE�EgDF@��+exA+)3> ©� ·�e %:%² ²� �©��� e �/³+³V��

��� ·

Page 166: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

R ��� W � �hE! 4�5H)34m=+4x. 8S a���F(4�)B� # ¿ ! e § . #� e � @ Egb � [�\ � DFEK[7_ YR[ ��\g@ DO@ � �oyr8 &Y��� #(# e � Jx4�� �/³+³+³� R ��� W@8� h )+'ª,�=+4:4e�� &¨�() C = C ! > !�# 5 ! 0]>�=�5H�/465 # �/,�=+465 ! 0�=+4x=+>`K #�!�# e� ! 4G \ B�a ��B��$Y��c[%H_J(Z Y��c�)@�@ b �('IEjB�@ Z

��[�\7[�@�a�[�B�@ � @Ca�[K\gY ��DO@�Y G DF@ �)\�Y D L4aKD �(' )�@�Y�[9'M' D � [�@Cag[c/ � �2)R5 =K=j8Ge �/³+³+³ e %x%² :�+T�� ���+³+�� R � · W@8� h )+'*,O=+4:4e�� &Y�() C � = % i | % �() C = C ! > !�# 5 ! 0b= %:% �()3=+0��M'q)+�-,�= %x%x! 4�<o>$=��(<+�".�)V0�J:,-�/465b02)3>�>`�/0Qt5 ! )34 # e� O B�bc\�@ �('K�KB�\!)�@�Y�[9'M' D �?[�@CYh� �rY �>�)@ �C' GTE�DFE exA+)3> ·�e %:%² ²� · ³ �©�/� ·�e ���+�+�V ¹y a &¨�(� #(#� R ��� W@8� ch )+'ª,�=+4:4e*� � �/=�� 4 ! 4�<@5(��� #(! , ! >�=�� ! 5LK@)+'».�)V0�J:,-�/465 # e� ! 4�2\ B a$�?� _�� ��@�a�[gEDO@��^[�bc\ �('@)�@+�KB�\ Z] �rY DnB�@; \ B�ag[gE�EgDF@��<-�GTEgY�[�]^EG/1�2)34-�� H �98Ge 8S !� � ���/4e 8� � d ! ��5H5H��� ! 0 �D=+4:.sc º8 �(� #H% e § . #� e�v! 5 &¨�(� #(# e ���+�+� e %:%² x³V��� ��³+���V

R ��� W@8� h )+'ª,�=+4:4m=+4x. �� � J:�:,O=+4:4e*� { )3, % ��5 ! 5 ! A+��>��/=���4 ! 4�<b=+>`<+)+� ! 5(�:, # '*)+�^�() C J # 5iA+�/025H)+� \ J:=+4Vt5 ! � =�5 ! )34e�c)3SIS:S � \ ��@ E ��a�Y DnB�@ZBr@<-CD ��@ �(' 2\ B�ag[gE�E�DO@ �+e©A+)3> · � ex4�) �� e %:%² �/�+��� �©�/����� e �/³+³+T� R �r�BW%�: �h )3>$>�,-�/4b=+4:.bc 38 �(� #(% e�� { =+>�> C = # �/.b'q� =+J:.b.���5H�/025 ! )34 ! 4@,�) C ! >`�}02)3,�,@J:4 ! 0�=�5 ! )34 # 4���57�i)+�(¿ #J #(! 4�<m=m� ! ����=���0 � ! 0�=+>g�(��< ! ,-�2t # � ! 5(0 � ! 4�<m,�)�.��/>Xe� ! 4;2\ B�a �I� _�� �r@Ca�[�E DF@"�^[�bc\ �C'e)�@+�KB�\g] ��Y D B�@

2\ B a�[gE�E�DO@ �N-�GTEgY�[K]^E�H_H�e �M 8! �/=���4 # e6a a�)3>�>$=Ve�=+4x.@d 6{ )34:�+e § . #� e �£y�8 &¨�(� #(# e �/³+³+³ e %:%² +T+T+³ �T+³��� R ��T W%�: �h )3>$>�,-�/4eYc Y8 �(� #H% e¨=+4x. @ a ! ,@J:>�=VeT� |n# �/>`'qtX)+�(<3=+4 !��/! 4�<v,O= % =+>`<+)+� ! 5(�:, '*)+��0�>�J # 5H��� ! 4�<% �() C = C ! > !�# 5 ! 0S,-)V.��/> # e� ! 4 \ B�a �4B3��Y�� [>=(Z Y�� )�@�Y�[K\�@ �rY D Br@ �('�EjB�@+��[�\7[�@�a�[ B�@.�)\�Y D L aKD �('?�>[Kb \ �('

�^[KY�(Br\ � Ec/f)(E?���2�<5 =K=j8 e�A+)3> ©� e�a�� % 5H�/, C ��� �/³+³+³ e %x%² x³ · � ��³��V�� R ��³ W@|& h K6A �=�� ! 4��/4²ee� | 'ª=+, ! >`KO)+' «:Z �/. % ) ! 4�5?=+>`<+)+� ! 5(�:, # '*)+� ! 4:.�� % �/4:.:�/4�5}02)3, % )34��/465^=+4:=+>`K #(!�# e�! 4] \ B�a � )3SIS:S�)�@�Y �IEjB�@+�9�RB�@c� a�Brb?E�Y D aKE be- � [�[7a � ��@C_�-CD ��@ �(' \ B�a�[�E�E�DO@ �</f)(E?��- -R�5 =�38 e �/³+³�� e%x%² ��+³V� � � �+³+���V RUT��GW@|& ch K�A��=�� ! 4��/4eh��aVJ��(A+��K-)34 ! 4:.�� % �/4:.:�/4�5¨02)3, % )34:�/4�5i=+4:=+>`K #(!�# e�%�>[Kb \ �('�EjB�] �Cb Y DO@ � -Cb \ ��[KGTE eA+)3> ©� e %:%² x³ · �©�/�+T e �/³+³+³� RUTV�QW@|& �h K6A �=�� ! 4:�/4e*�Hz:= # 5E=+4x.N�() C J # 5 «xZ �/.Vt % ) ! 465?=+>`<+)+� ! 5(�x, # 'q)+� ! 4:.�� % �/4:.��/465?02)3, % )34��/465^=+4:=+>[tK #(!�# e��)3S:S:S � \ �r@ E ��a Y D Br@ E�B�@G�^[�bc\ �(' �^[KY�(B�\ � EQexA+)3> ²��� e�4�) �� e %:%² x�+�+� ���r� ·�e �/³+³+³� RUT+� W@|& h K�A��=�� ! 4��/4e & 4h ) K+���/e^=+4:. �9 ¹y 4�¿ ! e�� 8 ��� ! 4x.�� % �/4:.��/4:02�N= #(# Jx, % 5 ! )34 i | 4:=+>�K #(! 4�<¬5(���! 4:.�� % �/4:.��/4:02�i)+'�5(���^02)3, % )34��/465 # C K@5H) % )+<+��= % �6K+e� ! 4�� _�����@Ca�[�E DF@>)�@C_ [ � [�@�_ [�@�Y�EjBr] � B�@�[�@CY

�.@ �(' G EgD EQe �M � ! �()3>$=+, ! e § . e©a % � ! 4�<+���}cg����>$=�<�e ���+�+� e %x%² · � ���+³� RUTr� W@|& Ch K�A��=�� ! 4��/4m=+4:. !- uE= FHJeI��a % =�� # � % � ! )+� # )34m5(���@, ![Z�! 4�<-,�=�5H� ![Zm! 4 ! 4:.�� % �/4:.��/465^02)3, % )�t4:�/4�5g=+4:=+>`K #(!�# e� ! 4� \ B�a �3B��2Y��c[�-*[7a�B�@C_!)�@�Y�[�\g@ �rY DnB�@ �('6�6B�\ � E � B �6B�@ )�@�_ [ � [K@C_ [K@�Y6EjBr] � B�@�[�@CY

�.@ �(' G EgD E �r@C_>��' DO@C_�-�D �r@ �('?-*[ � �r\ �rY DnB�@:e ���+�+� e %:%² · �r� � · T+�� RUT · W@|& 3! = C��=+49=+4x. �M � ! �()3>�=+, ! e!� | 02)3, C ! 4��/.M>�=�5H�/4�5b0�>�= #(# =+4:.95H��= ! 5&,�)�.��/>¨'q)+�@5(���;=+4:=+>`K #(!�#=+4x.mA !�# J:=+> ! � =�5 ! )34;)+'¾. !�# 02�(��5H��.x=�5(=Ve�])3S:SIS � \ ��@ E �rY D Br@ E&Br@< �rYnY�[K\�@<�)@ �(' GTEgD E ��@�_>D ��a � DF@*[

)�@CY�[`'f' D �?[K@Ca�[�e �r����T3� e %:%�T��+³ t �T���� e ���+���� RUT�� W@|& �! = C��=+4o=+4:. �9 � ! ��)3>�=+, ! e�� | .�KV4:=+, ! 0 % �() C = C ! > !�# 5 ! 0E,-)V.��/>5H);A !�# J:=+> !$# �_5H) %x! 0S��A+)3>�J:5 ! )34! 4�5H� Z 5 # 5H���/=+, # e�]OcBrb \g@ �('3B���)�@�Y�[`'f' D � [�@�Y�)�@+�KB�\g] �rY D Br@ -�GTEgY�[K]^E be- � [�aKD �('Q)�E�E�b�[$B�@]�)b Y B�] �rY�[�_

��[ U Y�E ��Y�[ � Br\�D�� �rY DnB�@:e�02)34:. ! 5 ! )34:=+>�>`K"=+0�02� % 5H�/.o'*)+� % J C > ! 0�=�5 ! )34 RUT+� W@|& ! = C��=+4N=+4x. �M � ! ��)3>�=+, ! ee�Hz:= # 5^� Z 5H��=+025 ! )34m)+' # �/,�=+465 ! 0_'*�/=�5(J��(� # '*�()3,~=->�=�5H�/465 # �/,�=+465 ! 0! 4:.�� Z �/.w5H� Z 5]02)+� % J # e���^[�bc\ �(' 2\ B�ag[gE�E�DO@ ��Y [�YnY�[�\�E e:A+)3> ���� e !�#(# J�� � e ���+�3� e ! 4 % � ! 465 RUT��BW@|& 7! = C��=+4s=+4:. �9 � ! �()3>�=+, ! e6� { >�J # 5H��� ! 4�<")+'Y5H� Z 5S.�)V0�J:,-�/465 # C K # ¿+����4�� #(# ,�= Z�! , ! � =�5 ! )34e�! 4 \ B�a$�B�� Y��c[ �KZ @C_.)�@�Y�[�\g@ �rY DnB�@ �C'��6B�\ � E � B � B�@d)�@C_ [ � [�@C_ [K@�Y�EjB�] �cB�@�[K@�Y!�.@ �(' G EgD E ��@�_

��' DF@�_c-�D ��@ �('�-3[ � ��\ �rY DnB�@ /1)(E?�G5 � � � �j8 e ���+�+� e %:%² · ��� � ·+· �V RUT+T W@|& 7! = C��=+4s=+4:. �M � ! �()3>�=+, ! e6� y 4 ! 5 ! =+> !�� �/.o=+4:.v<3J ! .��/.o�/,-t70�>�J # 5H��� ! 4�<O)+' #H% =�� # � C ! 4x=��(KN.:=�5(=� ! 5(�-= %:% > ! 0�=�5 ! )34@5H)�5H� Z 5 C = # �/.�.�)V0�J:,-�/465 # e� ! 4� \ B�a$��B3�;Y��c[!HKJ?5 Y���)�@�Y�[K\�@ ��Y D B�@ �('eEjBr@+�K[K\ [K@Ca�[Br@ �rYnY�[�\g@<� [�a�B ��@ DOY DnB�@:e yr§¨§¨§±{ )3, % J�5H��� &Y�(� #(# e ���+�+� e %:%² C� · T �c���V��

�����

Page 167: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

RUT+³ W a ! = # ¿ ! eF�Hd ! ,��/4 #(! )34:=+> ! 57K¬�(�/.xJ:025 ! )34 C K9��=+4:.�)3, ,�= %:%©! 4�< i z:= # 5 #�! , ! >�=�� ! 57K¬02)3, % J:5(=�5 ! )34'*)+��0�>�J # 5H��� ! 4�<�e� ! 4� \ B�a�[�[7_�DO@ �rEeB3�>) O�E?���G5 =C7(b2)�@�Y�[K\�@ ��Y D B�@ �('�O B�DF@CY>EjB�@+��[�\7[�@Cag[6B�@#�>[Kb \ �('�^[KY�(Br\ � E e � =/K �/³+³+T e %:%² · ��� � · �/T�

RU³��GW a 3! =�5 � e��Hd !�# 5H� ! C J�5 ! )349)+']02)3465H�/465��¹)+� . # =+4:. % ����= # � #@! 4M5H� Z 5�=+4:.1>�=+4�<3Jx=�<+�m,-)�.:�/>�> ! 4�<�e�� �rY bc\ �(' Y ��@ �rb � � [�S @ ��DF@*[�[�\gDO@ �+e:A+)3> x� ex4�) º� e %x%² ²��� ���+³ e �/³+³+��

RU³V�QW �M ! �/4x.:=+>�>�e |& a�5(J:=���5�e_=+4x. �� ��.e �&[�@�_ �('f'�5 E � _�����@Ca�[�_ � �c[7B�\gG B��0-CY ��Y D E�Y D aKE bd\ B(' �!)���$DFEgY \gD ^Kb Y D B�@ � �c[�B�\gG EZ 'q)+��. � 4 ! A+��� #(! 5LK &Y��� #(# e � tX5(�m�/. e �/³+T��6

RU³+� W d !�! , C ��� =+4:. �M � J # �²e ��a ! 5(J:=�5H�/. # 5(=�5H�}� ! .x.��/4S,�=��(¿+) A�,-)V.��/> # e� ! 4�2\ B�a �CB3�*)�@�Y�[K\�@ �rY D Br@ �('EjBr@+�K[K\ [K@Ca�[dB�@G�;a�B�b EgY Dna�E b:- � [�[�a��Kb ��@C_�-�D �r@ �C' \ B�ag[gE�EgDF@��./f)(E?��- -Rh8Ge �/³+³r��

RU³r� W u ! )3�:=BA ! e �] � =+0�¿+���/e©=+4:.Nd a�)3,O,-��� « �/>�.²ee� y , % ��)BA ! 4�< #(! , % >`� � =BK+� # e� ! 4G2\ B a$��B��2S2bc\ B(Z� [ ��@ EjB�@$�K[K\ [K@Ca�[&Br@ D ��a��?DF@�[�YR[ ��\g@ DO@ �./fSTE?DGY*Z�=�38 e �/³+³��6

RU³ · W@8� ! )3��)34��/4e���aV�/>`'$tX)+��<3=+4 !�� �/.w'*)+��,�=�5 ! )34N)+'»5H) % )+<+��= % � ! 0�=+>�>`KO02)+�(���/025^'q�/=�5(J:�(��,�= %x# e���;DnB(' B �CZDna �C'6E G_^�[K\�@�[�Y D aKE e:A+)3> · � e %:%² �+³ ���+³ e �/³+T+��

RU³�� W@8� ! )3��)34��/4²e -*[`' � Z`g \ � ��@ D���DO@ � D � ��E`� h � ! .��/> C ���(< i a % � ! 4�<+���/e �/³+³��� RU³+� W@8� 3! )3>`�/4:.:=Ve �¨ h =+4 # �/4²eY=+4:. a a ! <3J���. #(# )34e!� y 4x.�� % �/4:.��/465&02)3, % )34��/465 #-! 4M5H� Z 5�e� ! 4��;_(Z

����@Cag[gE6DO@ )�@C_ [ � [�@C_ [K@�Y EjB�] �cB�@*[�@�YT�)@ �(' GTEgD EQe �9 � ! �()3>�=+, ! e § . e�a % � ! 4�<+���-cg����>�=�<�e ���+�+� e%x%² x� · � ���+�+�� RU³��BW !� � =�<3J # e 8S h )34�¿+�/>$=Ve¹a 2! = # ¿ ! eg=+4:. 8S ! )3��)34��/4e�� � � C # )3, 'q)+�b5H� Z 5(J:=+>¹.x=�5(=v, ! 4 ! 4�<�e�

�.\gY D L aKD �('�)�@�Y�[`'f' D � [�@Cag[�� [ � D [ �geYA+)3> ?��� e %x%² � · � � �+� ·�e?d]�/02�/, C ��� �/³+³+³� 5! >�J��i��� | 0�=+.:�/, ! 0&¹J C > !$# ����� #�

RU³+T W^h& �� = %:% =+>�= ! 4��/4&=+4:. |& �h )34�¿+�/>$=Ve�� � =/K+� #(! =+4-4:)34Vt7> ! 4��/=�� ! 4:.:� % �/4x.��/4�5²02)3, % )34:�/4�5g=+4:=+>`K #(!�# C K,@J:>`5 ! t7>�=/K+��� % ����02� % 5H�()34 # e� ! 4�� _�����@Ca�[�EDF@ )�@C_ [ � [�@C_ [K@�Y!EjB�] �cB�@�[K@�Ye�.@ �(' G EgD EQe �9 � ! ��)3>�=+, ! e§ . e�a % � ! 4�<+���/e ���+�+� e %x%² x³r� �©�/�V�� RU³+³ W@8� >� ���+e �M >� ��� ! 0(¿ ! eG=+4x. 8S a���F(4�) � # ¿ ! e@� y({}| , ![Z 5(J��(�g,-)V.��/> # '*)+� Jx4 # J % ���(A !�# �/.]0�>�= #(#(!`« 0�=�5 ! )34)+':4:)34VtX<3=+J #(#(! =+4 # )3J���02� # =+4:.�=+J�5H)3,O=�5 ! 0¨02)3465H� Z 5 # � ! 5(0�� ! 4:< ! 4 C > ! 4:. #(! <34:=+> # � % =���=�5 ! )34e��)3S:SIS

� \ ��@ E � a�Y DnB�@ E�Br@ �rYnY�[�\g@G� [7a�B �r@�DOY DnB�@ ��@C_>D ��a��?DF@�[!)�@�Y�[9'M' D �?[�@�a�[2e�A+)3> x�+� ex4�) º��� e %x%² � �©�/� e���+�+�V R[���+�GW d ?� ���¨=+4:. h� aV�/J:4�<�e@� � �/=���4 ! 4:<?5(��� % =��(5 # )+'�) C Fr�/025 # C KS4�)34Vt74:��<3=�5 ! A+�¹,�=�5H� ![Z 'ª=+025H)+� !�� =�5 ! )34e�

� �rY bc\7[2e:A+)3> · ��� e %:%² C��T+T �c��³V� e �/³+³+³� R[�����QW d � ���v=+4:.±a a��/J:4�<�e � | >`<+)+� ! 5(�x, # '*)+�"4�)34�t74���<3=�5 ! A+�s,�=�5H� ![Z 'ª=+025H)+� !�� =�5 ! )34e� ! 4 2\ B�a �$B��

� _�����@Ca�[�E DO@&�>[Kbc\ �('�)�@+�KB�\g] ��Y D B�@� \ B�a�[�E�EgDF@ � -�GTEgY�[K]>E./f��)36- H��`8 e 8S � ���/4e 8S d ! ��5H5H��� ! 0 �e=+4x.Nc ©8 �(� #(% e § . #/ e �oyr8 &Y��� #(# e ���+��� e %:%² ���+� ���+�+�� R[���3� W d �� ��� !�# e��Hz:�/=�5(J��(� # �/>��/025 ! )34k=+4:.±'q�/=�5(J:�(�¬� Z 5H� =+025 ! )34¶'q)+�N5H� Z 5m0�=�5H��<+)+� !�� =�5 ! )34e� ! 4 \ B�a$�B3�.- � [�[�a�� ��@C_#� �rY bc\ �('2Y ��@ ��b � �?[ �6B�\ � E � B �©e |& u & E| <+�/4:02K+e § . eSd]��'q�/4 # � i � )+��<3=+4! =+J�'*,O=+4:4e �/³+³+� e %x%² :�V�/� ���V� �6

R[����� W d *� ��� !�# e�� p = ! A+� � � =/K+� # � =�5m'*)+�(57K i 8 �:� ! 4:.�� % �/4:.��/4:02�s= #(# Jx, % 5 ! )34 ! 4 ! 4:'q)+��,O=�5 ! )34¶�(�2t5H� ! ��AG=+>Xe� ! 4G \ B�a ��S bc\ B � [ �r@ EjB�@+��[�\7[�@Cag[�B�@GD ��a � DO@�[�Y [ ��\�@�DF@ �"/fSFE?D<YeZ3=C7`8Ge �/³+³+T� R[��� · W@|& �� �)+� ! 4:0 � e �] a � =�5(, �=��(K+e:=+4x. |& �! = C��=+4ee��a ! <34Vt70 �:=+4�< ! 4�< « >`5H��� #¨#(! , ! >�=��¨5H)b02�/>�> #i! 4 % � ! ,O=��(KA !�# Jx=+>:02)+�(5H� Z �/,-���(<+� C K ! 4x.�� % �/4:.��/465¾02)3, % )34:�/4�5¨=+4x=+>`K #�!�# )+'�5H�/, % )+��=+>�>`K@02)34�A+)3>�A+�/.;4x=�5(J���=+>! ,�=�<+� # � \ J��/4:02� # e�]�>[Kb \ B�a�B�] �Cb Y DF@ �3e �+T � · � e %:%² � · ��� �©� ·+· � e ���+���� R[��� � W a � J�5H5H���/>�>�e�� | � =/K+� #�! =+4M=+4x=+>`K #�!�# )+' # �/>`'})+�(<3=+4 !$#(! 4�<m,�= %©# e�0�^[�bc\ �('�EjB�] �Cb Y �rY DnB�@:egA+)3> � e4:) 2� e %:%² ������ �c��³ ·�e �/³+³ · R[���3� W d � =+0 ! =BK+e6� � =/K+� #�! =+4o4��/J:��=+>4���57�i)+�(¿ # =+4:.N.:�/4 #(! 5LK"4���5L�¹)+�(¿ # e���b a9'X[ �r\2)�@ EgY \gbc]d[K@�YOE ��@�_

DZ[KY�� B _TE$DO@ � DFE�Dna�E2� [gE�[ ��\ a��_bI-*[�a�Y DnB�@G�Se�A+)3> C��� ·�e©4�) � e %:%² ���� ��T�� e �/³+³��� ���+�

Page 168: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

R[��� �BW d �� =+0 ! =/K+e � |h% ��=+025 ! 0�=+> � =/K+� #�! =+4k'*��=+,-���i)+�(¿�'*)+� C =+0(¿ % �() % =�<3=�5 ! )34 4���57�i)+�(¿ # e� �>[Kb \ �('�^[KY�(Br\ � E exA+)3> ·�e %:%² ·+· T � · ��� e �/³+³+��

R[���3T W d � =+0 ! =/K-=+4:. �M � ! CxC # e��Hd]�/4 #(! 5LK@4���5L�¹)+��¿ # e� ! 4c-CY �rY DFEgY Dna�E ��@�_!�^[�bc\ �(' �^[KY�(B�\ � E �6� [�a�[K@�Y� _�����@Ca�[�E �rY2Y�� [T)�@�Y�[K\M� ��a�[�e �� �! =/Ko=+4:.£d �8^! 5H5H��� ! 4�<+5H)34e § . #/ e EZ 'q)+� . i EZ '*)+��. � 4 ! A+��� #(! 5LK&¨�(� #(# e �/³+³+³ e %:%² �/�+³ �©� · T�

R[���3³ W d � =+0 ! =/K+e%�Hd]�/4 #(! 5LKM4���5L�¹)+�(¿ # =+4:.M5(��� ! �-= %:% > ! 0�=�5 ! )34D5H) % ��)+5H� ! 4M,�)�.��/>$> ! 4�<�e� D �+U�DF]�bc]S2@�Y \ B �CG���@C_ � ��G [gEgD��@<DZ[KY�� B _TE e %:%² :���+³ ���+�+T e �/³+³+��

R[�+���GW d � =+0 ! =/K+e�� � = ZV! ,@J:,n> ! ¿+�/> ! ��)6)V.w=+4:.v02)BA�=�� ! =+465]=+>`<+)+� ! 5(�:, # 'q)+� ! 4:.�� % �/4:.:�/4�5^02)3, % )34��/465=+4x=+>`K #�!�# e�=/A�= ! >�= C >��S'q�()3, ��5H5 % i � � �i)3> ��= U% ��K 0�=+, =+0 J:¿ �G,�=+0�¿G=BK �6e �/³+³+�� R[�+�+�QW@|& � 0 { =+>�>�J:,�=+4:. !- �p]! <3=+,NeP� | 02)3, % =�� !�# )34o)+'Y��A+�/465�,-)V.��/> # 'q)+� p = ! A+� � =BK+� # 5H� Z 5S0�>�= # t#�![« 0�=�5 ! )34e� ! 4; \ B�a$�;B��N�2����)��R)(E?DGY*Z�=C7 �6B�\ � E � B � B�@"Y [ ��\g@ DF@�����B�\.�C[ U�YNE ��Y�[ � Br\�D�� �rY DnB�@:e�/³+³+T e %:%² · � � · T� R[�+�/� W � � 0 � =+0��:>$=+4o=+4:.md &»���/>�e V�DO@ D Y�[�D D U�Y bc\7[�D B�_ [9' E 6� )3�x4 �±! >���K;=+4:.va�)34 # e y 4:0 e ���+�+�V R[�+��� W & � 0 { J:>$>�=�<3�N=+4:. �¨ :p �/>�.:���/e�B;[�@�[K\ �C' D�� [�_�Y DO@�[ �r\!D B _ [`' E i{ �:= % ,�=+4N=+4:. h =+>�>Xe �/³+T��� R[�+� · W � � 0 � =+0 �:>�=+4I=+4:. 8S ! � !�# �:4:=+4e�� � [>S:D ��' � Br\�D Y�� ] ��@C_GS:U�Y�[�@ E�DnB�@ E mp ��� � )+�(¿ i � )3�:4

�¶! >`��Kw=+4:.£aV)34 # e y 4:0 e �/³+³��6 R[�+��� W �M �� � ! >�=I=+4:.¶d 2h �/0(¿+����,O=+4e � | 4¶� ZV% ��� ! ,-�/465(=+>E02)3, % =�� !�# )34±)+' # ��A+����=+>S0�>�J # 5H��� ! 4�<1=+4:.! 4 ! 5 ! =+> ! � =�5 ! )34w,-��5(��)V. # e� 8 �/0�� u�� %² e � aVu?t 8 u?t ³+T t �3� e �£! 02��) # )+'q5Eu^� # �/=���0 �e �/³+³+T� R[�+�/� W%�: �v!�# ¿ ! 4 =+4:. d � =+0 ! =/K+e>� § 4 # �/, C >`�m>`�/=�� 4 ! 4�<s'*)+� C > ! 4:. ! ,�=�<+� # � % =�� =�5 ! )34 =+4:. .:�/02)34VtA+)3>$J�5 ! )34e� ! 4.�;_�����@Cag[gE�DF@0)�@�_ [ � [K@C_ [K@�YNEjB�] �cBr@�[�@�Y4�)@ �(' GTE�DFE e �M � ! �()3>�=+, ! e § . ea % � ! 4�<+���cg��� >�=�<�e ���+�+�V R[�+� �BW z � ) # 5H�/>�>�����=+4:.md � =+>�>$=+02�+e � � �@' D [7_>� ��G [�E�D ��@ ��@C_ Eh'��TE�EgD a �(' )�@+��[�\7[�@�a�[ a % � ! 4:<+���icg��� >�=�<�e�/³+T · R[�+�/T W&yQ �� )3J # 5(=�¿ ! e*� | >�=�5H�/4�5i5H��= ! 5}=+4:.w>�=�5H�/465i0�>$= #(# ,-)�.:�/>x'*)+�i, ![Z �/.") C # ����A+�/."A�=�� ! = C >`� # e� � \gD Y D E �

O B�bc\g@ �(' B3��D �rY�� [�] �rY Dna �(' ��@C_�-CY �rY DFEgY Dna �C'� E�G�a�� BC' B ��G�exA+)3> · ³ e %:%² ��V��� � �r� ·�e �/³+³+�� R[�+�/³ W&yQ :p = C 4���K+e:� § �"0 ! �/465?5H��= ! 4 ! 4:<&)+'»� C '»4���57�i)+�(¿ # '*)+�^0�>�= #(#(![« 0�=�5 ! )34e� ! 4 \ B�a ��B��N=(Z Y���)�@�Y�[�\g@ �(ZY DnB�@ �C'6EjB�@+��[�\7[�@�a�[&B�@G�)\�Y D L aKD �('@�^[�bc\ �C' �^[KY�(B�\ � E�/1)(E?�2���G5 =K=j8Ge �/³+³+³ e %x%² :�V��� ���V����

R[�/���GW u Gp �/=+>V=+4:.�� Th]! 465H)34e�� | A ! ���M)+':5(�:� § � =+>`<+)+� ! 5(�:, 5(�:=�5©FHJ # 5 ![« � #²! 4:02�(�/,-�/465(=+> #(% =�� # �}=+4:.)+5(�:���EA�=�� ! =+465 # e� ! 40YR[ ��\g@ DO@ � DO@dB \ � � � Dna �('[D B�_ [`' E e �M � )+��.:=+4e § . e p )+�(�i�/>�>�e �£| i ! >�J��i���| 0�=+.��/, ! 0 &Y�(� #�# e �/³+³+T e %x%² ����� � �+�+T� R[�/�V�QW !� ¾p]! <3=+,Ne !- � 0 { =+>�>$J:,Ne¹a ¾8 ����Jx4eg=+4:. 8S �v! 5(0 ���/>�>�eF� 8 � Z 5�0�>$= #(#(![« 0�=�5 ! )34M'*�()3, >�= C �/>`�/.=+4x.mJ:4:>�= C �/>`�/.w.�)V0�J:,-�/465 # J #�! 4�<b�/,Ne�cD ��a�� DO@�[!Y [ ��\g@ DF@��+e %x%² ²� � � ·�e �/³+³+³� R[�/�+� W@§� FH=Ve2� 8 ���-4�)34:> ! 4��/=�� & {}| >`�/=�� 4 ! 4�<;��J:>`� ! 4 ! 4:.:� % �/4x.��/4�5E02)3, % )34��/4�5�=+4x=+>`K #�!�# e� �>[Kbc\ B(Za�B�] �Cb Y DF@��+exA+)3> º� � ex4�) º� e %:%² :��� � · � e �/³+³��6

R[�/�r� W��] > # �x=+J # �/49=+4x.Md z ! �/>�.e!��a % =�� # �;02)�. ! 4�<m� ! 5(�9=+4I)BA+����02)3, % >`��5H� C = #(!�#&# ��5 i = # 5H��=�5H��<+K�/, % >`)BK+�/. C K;c �$X e� \�DFE�DnB�@ � [gE�[ ��\ a���e�A+)3> C��� e %:%² ��r�V�+� � �r�+��� e �/³+³��6 R[�/� · W & &¾= F(J:4��/4e*� � > ! 4x. # � % =���=�5 ! )34N)+' C ! 4x=��(K # )3J�� 02� # � ! 5(�w>`� #(#?# �/4 # )+� # 5(�:=+4 # )3J���02� # e� ! 4 \ B�a$�B3� )�@�Y�[K\�@ �rY D Br@ �('>EjB�@+��[�\7[�@Cag[ B�@ �^[�bc\ �('��>[�Y�(B�\ � E&/f)(E?���<5 =�38 e�A+)3> � )+'�·�e yr§¨§¹§ e �/³+³�� e%x%² ²�/³+³ · �©�/³+³��6

R[�/��� W & &¾= F(J:4��/4k=+4:. �9 � ! �()3>�=+, ! e�� y , % >`�/,-�/465 ! 4�< .��/0 !$#(! )34 #w! 4 C ! 4:=��(K�.��/0 !$#(! )34¶5H�(��� # J #(! 4�<! 4:.�� % �/4:.��/465�02)3, % )34��/465 # =+4:=+>`K #(!�# e� ! 4 \ B�a$�$B��6Y��c[G-*[�a�B�@�_;)�@�Y�[�\g@ �rY DnB�@ �C']�6Br\ � E � B �pBr@)(E?� ��@C_�-�D �r@ �('?-*[ � �r\ �rY DnB�@:e ���+�+� e %:%² · Tr� � · T+T�

�����

Page 169: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

R[�/�+� W-{_ &»= % =+. ! , ! 5H� ! )3J&=+4x. & uE=�<3�:=/A�=+4eh� � =�5H�/465 # �/,�=+465 ! 0 ! 4x.�� ZV! 4�< i | % �() C = C ! > !�# 5 ! 0¹=+4:=+>`K #(!�# e�! 4] \ B�a �RB���H�9Z Y��%� E?D -CGT] �cB�E�DOb ] B�@6Y��c[2 \gDF@Ca�D � ' [�E)B���� ��Y �_^ �TE�[!-CG E�Y�[�]^E e �/³+³+T e %:%² ©���+³ ��/�+T� R[�/���BW��] &»�/=���>�,@J�5H5H���S=+4:. �¨ &¾=��(��=VeP� � = ZV! ,&J:,n> ! ¿+�/> ! ��)�)�. C > ! 4:. # )3J:��02� # � % =���=�5 ! )34 i | 02)3465H� Z 5rt# �/4 #(! 5 ! A+�&<+�/4�����=+> ! � =�5 ! )34v)+' yH{?| e� ! 4 �;_�����@Cag[gE�DF@<�^[�bc\ �('�)�@+��Br\�] �rY DnB�@" \ B�a�[�E�E�DO@ � -�GTEgY�[K]>E

/1�2)34-65 =j8 e �: �9 2� ) � ���/e �9 =+4:. 8S &»��5 # 0 ���+e § . #� e �£y�8 &¨�(� #(# e �/³+³�� e %:%² :�V��� ���V�/³� R[�/�+T W�� & �/4x4�K+eu �§ A+��� # )34e�=+4x.va u^) C ���(5 # e4� hE! .:.��/4m,�=���¿+)BA ! 4:.�� % �/4:.��/465^02)3, % )34��/465E=+4:=+>`K6t#�!�# e� ! 4>� _�� �r@Ca�[�E;DF@>)�@C_ [ � [�@�_ [�@�YPEjB�] �cBr@�[�@�Y��.@ �(' G EgD EQe �M � ! �()3>$=+, ! e § . e6a % � ! 4:<+���»cg��� >�=�<�e���+�+�V R[�/�+³ W �M &»��)+5�e�� �]��)3,-��5H� ! 0 ! , % > ! 0�=�5 ! )34 # )+'¹5(���@4x= ! A+� � =BK+� # = #(# Jx, % 5 ! )34e� ! 4 \ B�a$� B��&Y��c[<EjB�@ Z

��[�\7[�@�a�[�B�@ � @Ca�[K\gY ��DO@�Y G DF@ �)\�Y D L4aKD �(' )�@�Y�[9'M' D � [�@Cag[c/ � �2)R5 =� 8Ge �/³+³+� e %x%² · � · � · �/³� R[�����GW%�: &»)+�(� ! >�>�e�c aV5H)34��+e �� � ���(� ! 0(¿�e �: 2� =/KV������e=+4:. & { )�����K+eP� | 4x=+>`K #�!�# )+'Y) % 5 ! 0�=+> ! ,�=�< ! 4�<.x=�5(=IJ #(! 4�<D�i�/=�¿�,-)V.��/> # =+4:. yH{}| e� ! 4 � _�� �r@Ca�[�E DO@ )�@C_ [ � [�@C_ [K@�Y EjB�] �cB�@*[�@�YN�.@ �(' G EgD EQe�M � ! �()3>�=+, ! e § . e©a % � ! 4�<+���}cg����>�=�<�e ���+�+� e %:%² x�V� � ���r�r�� R[���V�QW �¨ u�= C ! 4:���;=+4:. �] �� J:=+4�<�e]� | 4 ! 465H�()V.:J:025 ! )34 5H) � ! .:.:�/4�,�=��(¿+) A ,-)V.��/> # e� )3S:SIS �!-Q-R

D � � � ��DO@�[2e %x%² · �©�/� e � =+46J:=���K �/³+T+�� R[���+� W �¨ u�= C ! 4����/e�� | 5(J:5H)+� ! =+>})34�� ! .:.��/41,�=��(¿+) A ,-)�.:�/> # =+4:. # �/>��/025H�/.�= %:% > ! 0�=�5 ! )34 #-! 4 #(% ���/0 ����/02)+<34 ! 5 ! )34e� ! 4G \ B�a$�(B��$Y��c[�)3SIS:S}e�A+)3> ��r� e �/³+T+³ e %x%² x����� ���+T��� R[���r� W-{_ u ! F # C ���(<+�/4e )�@+�KB�\g] ��Y D B�@.� [KY \gDn[ � �(' � J�5H5H�����¹)+�(5(� # e � t74:.N�/. �/. e �/³���³� R[��� · W��] u !`% >`��K+e@ �rYnY�[�\g@G� [7a�B �r@�DOY DnB�@ ��@�_%�^[�bc\ �(' �^[KY�(B�\ � E }{ =+, C � ! .�<+� � 4 ! A+��� #(! 5LK &¨�(� #(# e �/³+³+�� R[����� W a u�) C ����5 # e�� §gZ 5H�(�/,-�}AG=+>$J�� # 5(=�5 !$# 5 ! 0 # 'q)+�g4�) A+�/>`57K@.���5H�/025 ! )34 ! 4 C ! )3,��/. ! 0�=+>�.x=�5(= % ��)�02� #(#�! 4�<�e�! 4G)3S:S \ B�a�[�[7_�DO@ �rET-�a�Dn[K@Ca�[`b��C[�a�� @CBC' B ��G���@C_ D [ �TE�bc\7[�] [�@�Yªe©A+)3> º� · � e ���+�+� e %:%² �+�r� � �+���6 R[���+� W a u^) �¹� !�# e � { )34 # 5H��= ! 4��/.�� ! .:.��/4S,O=��(¿+)BA�,-)V.��/> # e� ! 4N2\ B a$�R�;_�����@Cag[gE(DO@N�>[Kbc\ �('K)�@+�KB�\g] ��Y D B�@

2\ B a�[gE�E�DO@ �]-�GTE�Y�[�]^E�H �3e�a a�)3>�>�=Ve 8� � ���/4ex=+4x. !- � J:>�>`���/e § . #� e �/³+³+³ e %x%² ���T+� �c��T+T� R[�����BW a u^)B�i� !�# =+4:. �» �_�x=+����=+,�=+4 ! eN� | J:4 ! '*K ! 4�<v�(��A ! ���~)+'_> ! 4��/=��b<3=+J #(#(! =+4 ,-)V.��/> # e�#�>[Kb \ �('

EjBr] ��bcY ��Y D B�@xe©A+)3> �+� ex4�) ©� e %x%² ���� � � � · � e �/³+³+³� R[���+T W d uEJ C ! 4@=+4:.-d 38 �:=BK+���/e[� §�� =+>�<+)+� ! 5(�:, # '*)+� � � 'ª=+025H)+�¹=+4:=+>`K #(!�# e�T4E�G�a � B�] [KY \gD a ��eV4�) · � e%x%² x�+³ �c��� e �/³+T+�� R[���+³ W �M aV=+�:=+, ! eh� �]#(! 4:<b,O=+0�� ! 4:�]>`�/=�� 4 ! 4�<@5H) ! , % �() A+� ! 4�'*)+��,�=�5 ! )34;=+0�02� #(# e� &¨� d . !�#(# ���(5(=�5 ! )34eaV5(=+4�'q)+� . � 4 ! A+��� #(! 5LK+e �/³+³+T� R[� · �GW �M aV=+�x=+4 ! eQY �rY�[K@�Y \ ��\gD� ^`'X[�D B�_ [9' EI��B�\!�>[Kb \ �(' � �rY � �)@ �(' GTEgD E ��/³+³+³� R[� · �QW � aV=+>`5H)34m=+4x. �9 2� 0 � ! >�>�eQ)�@�Y \ B�_�b a�Y DnB�@ Y B ]dB�_ [K\�@0)�@$��B�\g] �rY DnB�@0� [�Y \�D [ ���(' E�/³+Tr�� R[� · � W �M aV=+,�,-�/>Xe �Y u^K3=+4²eE=+4:. �� � ��<3>`���/ec� � =�5H�/4�5NA�=�� ! = C >`�£,-)V.��/> # '*)+�N, ![Z �/. . !$# 02�(��5H�¬=+4:.02)3465 ! 4�J�)3J # )3J:5(02)3,-� # e�cOcB�bc\g@ �('*B��;Y��c[�� B�G �(' -CY ��Y D E�Y D a �('Q-*B�aKD [KY G bh-*[�\gDn[�EI�^e�A+)3> ��+³ e %x%² 3�+��� �����T e �/³+³��6 R[� · � W%�: aV=+,�,�)34e2� | 4�)34:> ! 4��/=��S,�= %:%x! 4�<w'q)+�@.:=�5(= # 5H��Jx025(J��(�O=+4:=+>�K #(!$# e�<)3S:SIS � \ ��@ E � a�Y DnB�@ E Br@

EjBr] ��bcY�[K\�EQe©A+)3> ©{ t �/T e©4�) � e %:%² · ��� � · �3³ e �/³+�+³� R[� ·+· W �¨ a�=+J:>º=+4:.¬a u^)B�i� !�# eP� p )34:> ! 4:�/=��E. ! ,��/4 #(! )34:=+> ! 57K;�(�/.:J:025 ! )34 C Km>`)�0�=+>»> ! 4:�/=����/, C �/.x. ! 4�<�e�

-*aKD [�@Cag[2exd]�/0 ©���+�+�V R[� · � W@§� aV=+J:4x.e?� � 4 # J % ���(A !�# �/.b>`�/=���4 ! 4�<E)+', !`Z 5(J���� # )+'�,@J:>`5 !�% >`�}0�=+J # � #¨! 4 C ! 4:=��(K&.:=�5(=Ve� ! 4� \ B�a$�

� _�����@Ca�[�E$DO@ �^[�bc\ �(' )�@+�KB�\g] ��Y D B�@. \ B�a�[�E�E�DO@ �]-CG E�Y�[�]^E Ge �/³+³ ·�e %:%² :��� � � · R[� · � W �M �� )34�� # =+4:.vu a ! C # )34e:� � �:=�5 !�#�% �()GFr�/025 ! )34 % J:� # J ! 5 X e� O B�bc\g@ �('jB��^Y�� [T�2B�G �('e-�Y �rY D E�Y D a �('

-*B�aKD [KY G b(E�[�\9� ��e�A+)3> º����� e %:%² ²� � �+� e �/³+T��6 ���+T

Page 170: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

R[� · �BW^h& a ! ,-)34e*� 4m=�0�>$= #(# )+' # ¿+��� . !$# 5H� ! C J:5 ! )34 # e�%� DnB�] [KY \gDM����e©A+)3> · � e %:%º · ��� � ·+· � e �/³����� R[� · T W%�: a�5H)34��+e �: &»)+�(� ! >�>�e {] � Jx0����/>�eY=+4x. !� z:� !�# 5H)34eF��a % =�5 ! =+>�eg5H�/, % )+��=+>}=+4:. #H% =�5 ! )+5H�/, % )+��=+>! 4:.�� % �/4:.��/465�02)3, % )34��/465&=+4:=+>`K #(!�# )+'?' � u y .x=�5(=Ve� ! 4 Y��c[ HK7CZ Y�� Y [�[�_TE�-�Y �rY D E�Y D a �(':� [gE�[ ��\ a��

� B�\ � E � B � B�@0- � �rY D �(' Z Y�[K] �cB�\ �('j]dB�_ [`' DO@ ����@C_ D YOE � � � ' Dna �rY DnB�@ EQe � J:>`K �/³+³+³� R[� · ³ W%�: a�A+�/4 # ��/4e � � 8�� i 8 ���¬<+�/4�����=�5 ! A+�95H) % )+<+� = % � ! 0s,�= %:%©! 4�<�e� &¨� d . !�#�# ���(5(=�5 ! )34e |]# 5H)34

� 4 ! A+��� #(! 57K+e �/³+³+T� R[�����GW u �8^! C # � ! ��=+4 ! e@� &¨� ! 4:0 !`% =+>�0�J:�(A+� # �(��A !�#(! 5H�/.²e��-CY �rY DFEgY Dna�E ��@�_ EjB�] �Cb Y DF@ �3e6A+)3> �� e %:%² :�/Tr� �©�/³�� e�/³+³+�� R[���V�QW & V8^! 4�)&=+4:. yQ 6p = C 4���K+e*� { )34 # 5H��J:025 ! 4:<�>`)V0�=+> !�� �/.;4�)34Vt7> ! 4:�/=�� % �()GFH�/025 ! )34;,�=+4 ! '*)3>�. #Y! 4O= % � ! 4Vt0 !�% >`�/.��}=/K i � ! ����=���0�� ! 0�=+>:<+�/4���� =�5 ! A+�_5H) % )+<+� = % � ! 0E,�= %:%x! 4:<�e� 8 �/0�� u^� %º e pS{ u � � ���+�+� � ���+� epS{ u �@e � 4 ! A )+' |E# 5H)34²e ���+�+�V R[���+� W & »8^! 4�)�e y  »p = C 4:��K+e¾=+4x. �b aVJ:4²e�� �E#�! 4�<£. ! �(�/025 ! )34:=+>g0�J:�(AG=�5(J:�(� # 5H)£A !$# J:=+> !�� �-'*)3>�. ! 4�< % =�5rt5H��� 4 # )+'5(��� � 8��n% �()GFH�/025 ! )34;,�=+4 ! '*)3>�. # e� ! 4])�@�Y�[K\�@ �rY D Br@ �('�EjB�@+��[�\7[�@Cag[ B�@c�.\gY D L aKD �('W�>[Kb \ �('

�^[KY�(Br\ � Ec/f)(E?���2�P8 eVc ! �/4:4:=Ve | J # 5H� ! = i a % � ! 4�<+���}cg����>�=�<�e ���+���� R[���r� W �M ^8^!`%x%x! 4�<�e � &Y��) C = C ! > ! 5 ! 0mA !�# J:=+> !�# =�5 ! )34�)+'&� ! <3�¶. ! ,-�/4 #(! )34x=+> C ! 4x=��(K .:=�5(=Ve� ! 4i \ B�a$��B��

� _�����@Ca�[�E DO@"�^[�bc\ �('e2\ B a�[gE�E�DO@ �G2\ B�ag[gE�E�DO@ �0-�GTEgY�[K]^E</f��)36-65 HKHj8Ge �M 2! �/=���4 # eYa a�)3>�>$=m=+4:.d �{ )3�:4e § . #� e �oyr8 &¨�(� #(# e �/³+³+³ e %:%² �+³+� ���+³+T� R[��� · W �M �8^!`%:%x! 4�<@=+4x. {] �i!$# ��) % e:� &¨�() C = C ! > !�# 5 ! 0 % � ! 4:0 !`% =+>�02)3, % )34:�/4�5]=+4:=+>`K #(!�# e� O B�bc\g@ �('jB��^Y�� [

� B�G �('�-�Y �rY D E�Y D a �('?-*B�aKD [KY G b:-3[�\gDn[�E���e:A+)3> x�V� e©4�) �� e %x%² x�V�+� ���+�+� e �/³+³+³� R[����� W �M g8^!`%:%©! 4�<m=+4:. {] �i!$# ��) % e�� �v![Z 5(J:�(� # )+' % �() C = C ! > !�# 5 ! 0 % � ! 4:0 !�% =+>Y02)3, % )34��/465@=+4x=+>`K # ��� # e�

�^[�bc\ �('IEjB�] �Cb Y �rY DnB�@:e�A+)3> º�+� e %:%² ·+· � � · T+� e �/³+³+³� R[���+� W@|& c ! 4�)+¿+)3J��() A£=+4:. �M � ! �()3>�=+, ! e6� | % �() C = C ! > !�# 5 ! 0S� ! ����=���0 � ! 0�=+>»0�>�J # 5H��� ! 4�<",���5(��)�.v'*)+�S)+�Ht<3=+4 !��/! 4�<v02)3>�>`�/025 ! )34 # )+'?5H� Z 5-.�)V0�J:,-�/465 # e� ! 4&2\ B a$�)B�� Y��c[ HKJ(Z Y��.)�@�Y�[�\g@ �rY DnB�@ �C'�EjBr@+�K[K\ [K@Ca�[Br@ �rYnY�[�\g@<� [�a�B ��@ DOY DnB�@ /1)(E?:� 5 � � ��� 8 e©A+)3> ©� e ���+�+� e %:%² ²�/T+� �©�/T���

R[�����BW a cY= ! 5(�6K3=+4:=�5(�:=+4 =+4:. �] d])3,Ne � �]�/4���� =+> !�� �/. ,�)�.��/> # �/>`�/025 ! )34 '*)+�oJ:4 # J % ���(A !�� �/. >��/=���4Vt! 4�< ! 4 � ! <3�1. ! ,-�/4 #(! )34 # e� ! 4 2\ B�a ���;_ � ��@Cag[gEeDO@#�^[�bc\ �('I)�@+�KB�\�] �rY DnB�@ 2\ B�ag[gE�E�DO@ �&-�GTEgY�[K]>E/1�2)34-65 =K=j8 e�a a�)3>�>�=Ve 8� � ���/4o=+4x. !- u � J:>�>����/e § . #� e �£yr8 &Y�(� #�# e �/³+³+³ e %:%º x³���� ��³�����

R[���+T W^h& cY=+> % )3>$=Ve � � 4 # J % ����A !�# �/.S>`�/=���4 ! 4:<?)+':4�)34:> ! 4:�/=��².�K�4x=+, ! 0 # 5(=�5H�2t #(% =+02�?,-)�.:�/> # e� 8 �/0 � u�� %² eh �/> #(! 4�¿ ! � 4 ! A+��� #�! 57K;)+' 8 �/0��x4�)3>`)+<+K+e §¹#H% )6)�e:z ! 4x>�=+4:.e ���+�+�V R[���+³ W �M � �/>$> ! 4�<¬=+4:. �M � � C ���/e � | 02)34 # 5H��= ! 4��/. § � =+>`<+)+� ! 5(�:, '*)+� ! 4:.:� % �/4x.��/4�5-02)3, % )34��/465=+4x=+>`K #�!�# e� ! 4G2\ B�a ��B��$Y�� [ Z Y���-�G�] �cBTEgDFbc]'B�@G�^[�bc\ �C'IEjB�] �Cb Y �rY DnB�@:e �/³+³+³� R[�/���GW � ��!`% '�e bc] ��@G�.[ � � � DnB�\ ��@C_ Y�� [� \gDF@Ca�D � ' [�B��!Y [ ��EgY*S A B�\�Y ¨| .:. !�# )34Vt � � # >`��K+e �/³ · ³� R[�/�V�QW%�: (� =+,-�()34e[� 8 ) %x! 0i.:��5H�/025 ! )34�=+4:.b5H��=+0�¿ ! 4�< # ��<3,-�/465(=�5 ! )34-5(= # ¿�e� ! 4 2\ B a$��B��4� \ B ��_ a �TE�Y��>[ � E

� \ ��@ E�a�\�D ��Y DnB�@��r@C_ � @C_?[�\�EgY ��@C_rDF@ �d�6B�\ � E �cB �©e �/³+³+T� R[�/�+� W^h& � =+4�<]=+4x. �: "� )6)V.�K+e��Hd_=�5(=EA !�# Jx=+> !�� =�5 ! )34�=+4x.�'*�/=�5(J��(� # �/>`�/025 ! )34 i p ���1=+>`<+)+� ! 5(�:, # '*)+�¾4�)34Vt<3=+J #(#(! =+4N.:=�5(=Ve� ! 4 \ B�a$�?� _�� �r@Ca�[�E DF@ �>[Kbc\ �('@)�@$��B�\g] �rY DnB�@< \ B�a�[�E�EgDF@ �c-CG E�Y�[�]^E>/f��)36-65 H �98Gea a�)3>�>�=Ve 8S � ���/4o=+4:. !� u � J:>�>`���Be § . #� e �£y�8 &Y�(� #(# e ���+�+�V R[�/�r� WT�b 6� =+4�< =+4:. �& �º! J²e>� | �(�2tX� Z =+, ! 4:=�5 ! )34�)+'�5H� Z 5N0�=�5H��<+)+� !�� =�5 ! )34 ,-��5(��)V. # e� ! 4 \ B�a �>B��

�>E?D -W) B:)3� EjBr@+�K[K\ [K@Ca�[ Br@&� [gE�[ ��\ a�� ��@�_ �^[ ��[9' B ��]d[K@�Y DF@;)�@+�KB�\g] ��Y D B�@&�;[KY \gDn[ � �('�e �/³+³+³ e%x%² · � � · ³� R[�/� · WT�b C� =+4�<�eh� p ) !$# �^�(�/.:Jx025 ! )34 ! 4-= # 5(=�5 !�# 5 ! 0�=+>:= %:% ��)3=+0��-5H)�5H� Z 5¨0�=�5H��<+)+� !$# =�5 ! )34e� ! 4� \ B�a � B��;Y�� [

HK7CZ Y��]�.@ @ b �(' � E?D EjB�@$�K[K\ [K@Ca�[&Br@<� [gE�[ ��\ a�� �r@C_>��[ ��[9' B �C] [�@�Y4DO@ )�@$��B�\g] �rY DnB�@ �c�;[KY \gDn[ � �('/ -R) B:)3�I8Ge �/³+³�� e %x%² x���+� ���+�r��

���+³

Page 171: UNO$M - University of Birmingham

��� 5 �

| 5(= ! = C��=+4��(�/02� ! A+�/.±����� �i| � ! 5(����)34:)+� #O! 4 � J #(! 0�=+> { )3, % ) #(! 5 ! )34e}����� �£| =+4x. &¹�:d ! 4� J #(! 02)3>`)+<+K-'*�()3, 5(��� � J #(! 0 | 0�=+.:�/,�K J �_� d ! ,�=cJ�)+' { >�JGFrt p = % )V0�=Ve6u�)3,�=+4 ! = jh ���i5(�:� #(!�# 5H���/=�5H�/.=+>`<+� C � = ! 0��/>��/,-�/4�5 #_! 4 � � tX5(�¬02�/465(J��(K�J # ,@J #(! 0�=+>º02�(�/=�5 ! )34²e�.:��'q�/4:.:�/.£=�<3= ! 4 # 5 &¨�()+'*� #(# )+� �_� z ! ��0�='*�()3, � J:0��x=��(� # 5 aV�:�-�(�/02� ! A+�/.9�:��� � aV0b� ! 5(�¬��)34:)+� #�! 4 { )3, % J�5H���@aV0 ! �/4:02�-'q��)3, J � = C � # t � )3>�K3= ! J� 4 ! A+��� #(! 57Ko)+' { >�JGFrt p = % )V0�=Ve²u^)3,O=+4 ! = aV��� !�# =w�(� # �/=���0 �9= #(#�!�# 5(=+465_=�5�5(��� � 4 ! A+��� #(! 5LKo)+' &»= !$# >`��K+e�i)+�(¿ ! 4�<w)34s5(����.���A+�/>`) % ,��/4�5S)+' % �() C = C ! > !�# 5 ! 0�,-)�.:�/> # 'q)+��5H� Z 5 C = # �/. y 4�'*)+��,�=�5 ! )34¬u���5H� ! ��A�=+>g=+4:.'*�()3, � Jx4��N5H)Md]�/02�/, C ��� ���+�+� �}= # =9A !$#(! 5 ! 4�<v�(� # �/=�� 0������w=�5�5(��� � = C )+��=�5H)+�(K1)+' { )3, % J:5H���O=+4:.y 4�'q)+� ,�=�5 ! )34oaV0 ! �/4x02�+e h �/> #(! 4�¿ ! � 4 ! A+��� #(! 5LKO)+' 8 �/0 �:4�)3>`)+<+K

�/���


Recommended