PE NYEJII{KA E bJITAPI,I,flTIHCIIEKTOPAT KbM Bl4c,fi-tug CbAEEEH CbBET
rp. CoQur 1000, yn. ,,leopr BaruuHrroH,'Ng 17, ren.(barc 02/ggg 4g 66
IIPOBEPKAHA I,IHCTIEKTOPATA KbM BT,ICIIIU,. CbAEEEH CbBET
AKT3A PE3YJITATII OT IBBbPIIIEHA KOHTPOJIHA NPOBEPKArlo 3ATIOBEA J\& K[-01-28/ 06.il.20r5 r. HA fJrABHnr I,rHcnEKTop
pafrouua [poKypATypA KA3AHJIIK
OcHoeaHue Ha np_oBepKara - u,r.5g, Bp. .{n. 54, a,r.1 or 3CB,f-911rryara nporpaMa ua l,Iucnixropara Kr,M gCC * 2015r. u3anoaeg J\b KfI_01-28/06.11.2015r. Ha frasHr.rs t4 HcneKroo.
CrrlacHo 3anoBenra Ha fnasun, uHcneKTop, 3a npoBeprBall eKnrr,xofiro ga r43Br,prxx KoHTpoJ,rHara- npoBepra ca onpereJ,reHrr r4HcnexTop A,r6euaKocrosa u e(cneprr4 - Mapue.rra Mrlresa n O,rer [ie,,]rnoe.
IJe,r n o6xnar Ha npoBepKara:
Ilponepra Ha pearrHoro u3rrr,JrHeHrze Ha IaAeHZre npenopbrrl s Ama gape3yJrrarr4Te or nJraHoBara npoBepKa e prl Ka3aHrr,K, r43Bl,p reHa no 3anouez1J\b II[-01-2611 5.03.2012r. Ha frasHu.{ xHcneKrop;
B ngnuueHn e Ha 3anoBeAra Ha f,raeHr4, r4Hcne(rop na I4BCC,npoBeprBa lurr e(ur r.r3Bbptx, KoHTpoJrHa npoBepKa Ha pll Ka3aH.,tt,x, nnepl4oAa or 25.1 1.2015r. ilo 27.11.2015r.
IIpu urnrpl_reHara nraHoBara npoBepKa ua pII Ka:aHlbK rrpe3 2012 r..npoBeptBalll4tr eKun or I4BCC e orrrpaBuJr *rno uArrHrcTparfiBH!tfpbKoBoAtrreJr Ha PII KasanrbK H npoKypopure n pfl Kagau,rrx ,p" .pyr,,IIpenopbK14.
Bse npl:ra c floJ'ryqeHr.rq Axr c pe:ylrarl4 or H3Bl,puleHara [JlaHoBanpoBepKa or I4BCC Ha pfl Ka3aH,,trr, AgrrauHucrpal.r4BHr4rr plroBoltrreJr rranpoKyparypara e rr3rajr Parnopexrlaue Ns3106.07.2012 fo.q. c Koero eHa6erqgaHo npoBexlaHero Ha HTKoJIKo cbBeulaHr.r, Bt,B Bpb3r(a cx3nbJlHeHtieTo Ha la,qeHr4Te c aKTa npenopbKrl.
B ngnr,lHesze Ha pa3nope)r(AaHero Ha 10.07.2012 roa.. Ha pa6orHo:lt",uunr., AnMr'rHr'icrparr4BHlfiT pbKoBoAllreJr e 3arro3HaJr nporcypopure n pflKasaH,'ltx c Ama 3a pe3yJrrarr4re or npoBepKara. Karo ca o6cl,resuHanpaBeHure KoHcraraurzu u ra!eHvre npenopbr{r, or I4BCC. Toea aeiicrnue corpa3eHo B nporo*oJr, nolnrrcaH or Bcr4r{Kr4 npo*ypopu s pfl Ka3aurlK, KaroBb3pa)r(eHr4r IIo aKTa He ca HanpaBeHI{.
C nucno Ne A- 163/23.07.2012 rot., rocrbnuJro e I4BCC na27.07.2015rog., A4ruunucrpar[BHl4rr pr,KoBonr{Ter Ha pfl Ka:aHJrbK e yBeAoMr.tJ 3anpeAnptrertre opraHu3auuoHHr{ Mepxr,t no la.qeHrzre rrpenopbrrj s Ax.ra :ape3ylTaTlrTe oT rrraHoBaTa npoBepKa.
Ha 19.07.2012 foA. B l.t3rrbrrueHue Ha r.2 or paslopeN,laHeNs3106.07.2012 roA. BlB Bpr,3Ka c noryrreHr4, Axr :a pe:ylraru or nJraHoBa.ranpoBepKa sa I4BCC, e npoBeleHo cbBMecTHo cbBeulaHr4e Ha npoKypopl{Te orPfl, :neuoro prucneABar{r4 norrrzuafi rc,rrl pVfI Ha Mtsp KaaaHlt,r uP''I(OBOI.TB.T. Ha PY|I ua MBP KasaHIl,K oTHocHo Ha6eflq:saHero Ha M.DKH3a orcrpaHrBaHe Ha rocoqeHr4Te npolycKr4 ta nolo6prBaHe Ha
B3anMOAefrCTBr.reTO rrpl4 npoBexIaHeTO Ha pa3cJrelBaHeTo or cTpaHa HaPA3CJIEIBAIUXTC IIOJII4IIAfr U KOHTPOJIA Y PAXH'BAH OT HAoJIIOAABATIITTCnpoKypoprr.
Bpb3Ka c
flpoeeaeHo e n pa6oruo cr,BetrlaHr4e Ha flpoKypopr4re or pfl Kagas,rr,ncbc c6luure pa3rne)K.qautr HaKa3areJrHr4 AeJra or pC KasaH,,IT,K er'sHaflpaBeHnTe KoHcTaTauuI.{ r4 AaAeHr4Te npenopbKr4.
KOHCTATA4UU OTHOCHO N3N6JIHEHNE HA IANEHI4TEIIPEIIOPLRII :
flo npenopua Ns I. 1. AguuHrzcrparuBHr{rr pbKoBo.[r.treJr - paioneunporypop na Pfl KasannbK Aa cBr4Ka cbBeruaH e Ha npoKypoprare or pllKa:aHllx 3a : - yeIHaKBrBaHe Ha npaKTr,lKara flplr r43rorB.rrHe Hacnopa3yMeHr4rTa, KaTo rcHo ce pa3rpaHr4rtx ocHoBaHueTo 3a cKJrroLrBaHe Hacnopa3yMeHr4eTo, a B cryqa[Te Ha ycnoBHo ocbx.qaHe,qa ce onpeAeJ''It lla KofoAa ce Bb3noxn Br,3nr4TareJrHara pa6ora, cr,rJracHo q.rr.3 81,,ar.5,r.4 or HfIK:- yerHaKBrBaHe Ha npaxTrrKara no npuJ.roxeHr4ero Ha q1.9, a.,r.2 or HK.
BuAuo or Pasnopex<laHe Ns 3/06.07.2012 rot. ra flporono,r J\r4119.07.2012 foA. or O6rlo cT,6paur.re ca Ha6er.f,gaHr4 MepKn 3a npeo;oJrrBaHeHa Hefarr,tBHr4Te reHneHultrl e pa6orara na PfI KasaHrT,K c rleJr yeAHaKBrBaHeHa npaKTr4KaTa, BKJrroqnTeJrHo 14 BLB Bpb3Ka C BHaCtHr4Te r{ CKJ OrrBaHr4Te OT
rpoKyparypara cnopa3yMeHur.Brxa nponepenr.r HrKoJlKo fl.{ no rolrro npou3Bo4crBoro e fipuKnrcrlrJ'ro
cbc cIropa3yMeHr{e:
III Ne 62112013 roA.np. np. 127312013 ror.; AII Ns 50-M013 roa., np.np. Nr 3383/2012 roa.; lll Ne 43 1/2014 ros., np. np. Nr1014/2014 ror.; A|I Ns82412014 roA., np. rp. Nr 2065/2014 roa.; In Ns 31/2015 ro4., np. np. J\!65612013 ror.; An I& 188/2004 roA., np. np. J.1!293l2004 noa.; lII Ng 78-IV2013 roa., np. np. Ns1211/2013 roa.; AII Ns 200512012 ro.q., rp. np.
"11!333812012 roA.;AlI I1e215/2013 noA., np. np. Nr491/2013 roa.
KoHcraraquqra Kotro Moxe.qa ce HanpaB[ e, qe laleHara npenopbKa 3a
yeIHaKBrBaHe Ha npaKTr4KaTa npr{ r43foTBrHe Ha cnopa3yMeHr4qTa e l43rrbrrreHa.Karo npoKypopzre o6aqe npoAr,Jr)r{aBar .qa cKJrrortBar cnopa3yMeHr.rrra 6es aanpflJ]arar pa:nopegbara ua qn. 381,a.,r.5,r.4 or H|IK e cnyqaure Ha ycnoBHoocl,xIaHe.
Oruono, Karo npenoptra ocraBa rrpr4JroxeHnero na q,r.381,an.5.r.4 o'rHIIK.
Br,n nprrra c AaAeHara npenopT,Ka 3a yeAHaKBrBaHe Ha nparTl.rKara flo\r.9 ar'.2 or HI(, nporypopure cJreIBa Aa ce npt{Abpxar KbM 3aAbJt}rorreJrHaranpaKruKa Ha BKC, a uMeHHo TuryrarelHure pertreHrdq na O6uoro cr,6pauueHa cr,Ar,rr4Te or HaKa3areJrHara Ko;rerr4r ua BKC.
flo npenoprra l,(!l I.2. AAvuH r4crparvBHLrrr pbKoBoAxrerr _ pafioHeHnpoKypop ua PfI - KasaHarK Aa cb3rane neo6xo4rzvara opraHr{3aur4, cryxoa,,Perucrparypa r4 reJroBoacrBa" ga npurara KbM Bcr4qKn ua6arogarerHunpor'r3BoAcrBa cfipaBKfl cbruracHo r. 30 0r vxasau e na BK|I- coQur J\o I4-21l16.01.2002 roA., a cera VrasaHr.re llb I,l-30/05.03.2009roa. r.47,rcar<ro 14 Korrr4eor nocraHoBeHnq crAe6eH arr.
C Pa:nopeNaane Ns 3/06.07.20 1 2r., Alruunucrparr4BHru pbxoBorriren epa3rroperr4jr crpr4KrHo Aa ce rr3nbrrHrsa vKa3aHrae na BKII Nc 14-21/2002 rol..Karo cbfJracHo r. 30 0r cburoro, pecneKruBHo vrcasauue Ne z-30105.03.200grol. r.47 , 3aAbJrxr{TeJrHo Ia nonbJrBar cnpaB*a c.,reA IIpr4KJrroqBaHe Hacrge6noro 3aceAaHr4e rro u3rorBeHr4r 14 npr4J,roxeH KbM npoKypopcKoro Aeroo6paseu, Karo AeJroBorcrBoro Ha pafiouna npoKyparypa Karaurir Aa He rr4rrpxeMa 6eg nonuneua raKaBa cnpaBKa.
IIpu r-rsnt pureHara npoBepKa ce KoHcrarupa, qe npenopbrara ceH3ltbirHrBa, Karo Kr,M fI.{ ce npn,rarar cnpaBKtrre n npeflAcLr or nptrcbaara ,crropa3yMeHliero ultr4 perxeHlrero I1o AeJrara no .{r.7ga or HK. He BbB Bcr.rrtKt4c,ryvafi o6ave cnpaBKr4Te ca r.r3qepnareJrHrr.
flo npenop'r,ra J\b Il. Ilporypopnre n pfl Ka:aHmr :
l. Ha sceKu rpu Meceqa Aa u3r,rcKBar ranQopnaqun 14 Aa r43BT,p[tsa.lrrpoBepKa, rurld ca HaJ'II4rle ocHoBaHl,rr ga slgo6HosgBaHe no c[peHr{TeHaKa3aTeJrHI4 .qeJra;
2. la cnegnr crpuKrHo 3a cnrBBaHe Ha cpoKa uo u1.244,r.g or HflK;3. !a pa6orrt aKTuBHo rro AeJrara, cnpeHrz cpexty r43BecreH u3Btpllr.lreJl
c ofJle.II HeAonycKaHe Ha npeKpaTrBaHeTo r4M nopaA[ r.r3TeKJ]a AaBHOCT;4. !a nporeprBar cnpeunre Aera u La HanpaBr r. aKTyarHa rrperreHKa 3a
npeKpaTrBaHeTo Ha qacT oT Trx nopaAu u3TeKJra IaBHOCT;5. flo aenara cnpeHu cpeqy r43BecreH r,t3Bbprxr{TeJr, Koraro r.rMa raHHr.t,
qe nuuero e HanycHaro crpaHara' Aa rl3npaluar Konue or nocraHoBreHuero HafpauuvHa noJ'rr{q}ir c yKa3aHr4e npr4 3aBptrrlauero My .qa 6rge yaegoneua pllKa:au:nr c orJreA gr3o6HoergaHero Ha HaKa3areJrHoro [po[3BoAcrBo.
C parnopexgaHe Ne 4/06.07.2012 rol,. Ha arM. pbK. Ha pfl KasaurlK eyKa3aHo, rrpoKypoptrre crpnKrHo .{a r43nbJrHrBar 3anosel Ns p|I_24l I 5_05.20 12FoI. flpeABlrAeHo e Ia ce r{3Bbplx}t nperneA Ha Bcfirtrr4 cnpeHn leJra, KarocnpeHr4re Ha ocHoBaHr.re wr.244,at.1,r.3 or HIIK, rro Kor4To e u3TeKbn cpoKa flo,il244,ail.8 or HIIK, Hesa6anHo 4a 6r4ar srso6HoseHu h ce HanpaBu np.u."*un?Urv ca 6ultt saruqe ocHoBaHnrTa Ha ,rr.244,an.1,r.3 or HIIK. llo cnpeuureaeJra cpeqy r43BecreH r.r3BbptxrrreJr e pa3rrope.qeHo Aa 6rAe r,r3BbprreH nperJreAHa BeurecrBeHl4Te AoKa3areJrcrBa Ir npu H0r'Iuqlie Ha ocHoBaHr4e ,[a nocreaBa apa3nope)KAaHe c rrx. C,re4na Aa ce npeueHr,r or BceKr4 ear4H npoxypop, no Koriaera oT Ta3It KaTeropxr e r43TeKJrra aaBHocTTa, rro Kot4 cJreABa ,4a ce r,r3Bbprxr4qacrr'rqHo npeKpartBaHe r{ rro Kor4 e Hanriue xl4flore3ara ua qn.g.an.2 0r HK.
flporepeuu 6rxa crelHlrre JraKa3are:rHr4 nporl3Bo,IcrBa BoreHa cpeuy".":9r:l rz3Br,puure!.r: np- np. Nr3479/2013 rot., lll No 1896/2Ot: roa.; np.np,. Nt 1920/2015 ros., An Ne 284/2015 ros.; np. np. Ne 584/201: .oa., Air lrn1.99?/291? ror.; rp. np Ni-3j78/2014 ro4., 5n Ni zt+tzot4 ror.; rrp. il. N;4115/2013 roA., All Ns 1823/2013 roA.; np. np. No 27t3l2OtS roa., Aif .Ns
?l!/2.015 :or np. np. Ne.3t93/2013.oa., 4n .N, t+:OiZOt: .oa.; np.'np. wo283412007 ror., .qn Ns 132112007 roa.
floctauon,teHu frTa 3a cflupaHe Ha HaKa3areJrHxre npou3BorcrBa car{3rorBrHr.r B cpoK. Ha6rrcIaeaunre rrpoKypopu, ynpa)r(HrBar pbKoBorcrBo lrHaA3op Ha pa6orara no !fl, xaro e npeo6.nalaBaruara qacr or npor.r3BorcrBarar.r3r4c(Bar or pa3cnerBarqrlr opfaH Aa 6lAar yBeroMrBaH 3a pe3ynrara orOI4M. Cruro rarca, na6;rrcgaBa rr{Te npoKypopu KoHTpoJrlrpar n3nbJrHeHr{eroHa raaeHfiTe yKaBaHr4r' Karo B noBeqero cnyvafr cBoeBpeMeHHO, O6ZrHOneuoHa rpl4 Meceua li3npa[Iar HarroMHr4TeJrHr4 nlzcMa, Karo ll3rlcKBar ga 6tgalYBCAOMqBAHI,I B III4CMCH BI4.q OTHOCHO NPCANPI4ETI4TE MCPKI,I 3A YCTAHOB'BAHC I{Ar.r3Bbptxnrert, r,t3BbprueHltre OI,IM, sarerua.,,I4 B flJraHa, KaKTo I{ pe3yrrara orH3AUpBaHeTO.
C Pa:noperrgaHe J\b 4/16.09.2015 roa. e BbBeneH ,,perrzcrrp Ha cnpeHurecpeqy r'r3BecreH h3Bbprrrr4TeJr aocrAe6Hu nporl3BoacrBa ua6mogaeauu or pflKagau,'llx". Peruclrpa ce BoAr,r Ha eJreKTpoHeH r,r xaprr4eH Hocr4TeJr.
Or rara r43Br,pttreHara rrpoBepKa ce ycraHoBrBa, qe s pfl Kasaulrx ca6r'rnn npegnpueru geo6xornMr.rre MepKH 3a octureci BrBaHe Ha r(oHTpor Ha.qpa6orara no cfipeHu ge,ra cpeqy HI4. flo scuqxu npoBepeHr.r renaua6rrcAasauure npoKypopu ca rl3r{cKBaJr[ un$oprnrarllu or cr,orBerrrr]re[orr4rleitcKr4 opfaHr4 3a npoBexAaHr.rre oI4M, sa Koero ca 6Hru npeAocraseHcboTBeTHUTe CrrpaBKtr.
flponepeHrz 6txa cleaHure Hara3areJrHr,t npou3BoacrBa Bo.leHu cpeulyHer43BeCTeH r.r3Bbpllrr4TeJl :
flp. np. Ng 334712012 ro4., {Il Ng202612012 roa.; np. np. 237412012ro4., ,{fl Ns 1375/2012 roA.; np. rry.300712012 roa., !|I.]'tb 1816/2012 roA.; np.np. Nr 890/2013 ror1., lfl Ns 63-K/2013 foa.; np. ry. M4142/2013 ror., AfI Xc1835/2013 foa.; np.np. J,(b l39g/2013 ro4., llr Ns 1tg_K/2013 ro4.; np. np. Nr344412013 roa., lll Ns 160212013 ror.; np. np. Na 3944120t3 roa., An N,l
17?4/2013 ro.q.; np. np. Nr1633/2014 roa., [tI Nt 64412014 ro,r.; np. np. Nr277212012 rol.. Afl Ne 1668/2012 roir.; np. np. J,,tr 22ltfZOt3 ioa.. AilJlg1668/2012 roa.;
Or lr:nlpureuara npoBepKa ce ycraHoB ,qe ca npeanpr.reru NrepKri o.rcrpaHa rra arMlrHr,rcrparr4BHr.tr pbxoBo.quren !r or Ha6rrcnaeauure npoK).pop,r3a crra3BaHe pa:nope46ara Ha wr.245 ar.l 0r HllK. B noctaHo",reH""ia sacnupaHe Ha HaKa3aTeJrHOTO npor,r3BolcTBo ca aaBa]Hv yKa3aHu, KbMcborBsrHr,rre no,rl,tqeftcxrl opfaHn Ia AoKJ,ra.qBar Ha Ha6rrc^qasauu, nporypop
PC3YJ'ITATI.TC OT TIPOBCNEHI4 OI,IM. HSTOTS NH, CA V HAIIOMHHTCJIHI4 TII4CMA 01'crpaHa Ha Ha6,rroAasaqzre npoKypopr.I, c Kor.rro ce r43r.rcKBa rr3nbJrHeHl{e HaIaAeHrzre yra^:auu.rr. rlo Bcr.rrtxtr npoBepeHr4 npov3BolcrBa ce cbnbpr(arc[paBKx or nonuuarra orHocHo pe3yJrrarr4Te or ozM. f]o roarprara
"uai oaAeJIaTa, CJI.A KaTo Ca 6u,u cn[paHl4 14 B nocJle.qcTuue sbgo6HonrBaHlr. canp[4KJIroqeHr4 c nprrcbaa.
IIp* 2014 foA. ca npeKpareHr.r 161 An ropa.qu r3rerra AaBHocr 3aHaKa3areJIHo npecJrelBaHe. Ha clyvaeu nprzHunn 6.rxa nponepeulr Hqxofi orrrx : np. np. No 3480/2014 roa., AII Xb 28412014 ro4.; np. np. J'.lb 2112014 ros.,AII I& 3M-192612013 rot.; np. np. Nrl227 12014 rot.,, !il Ne'49212014 roa.; np.np. Nt279212014 ros., ,All Ne 1285/2014 ror.; np. np. Nrt783/2014 ro,r., A|I Xs
98!2014 ror.; np. np. Na 278120t2 ror., lfl _ SOfi JVo 4120t2 rot.; 'p.
'np. Nr
247412013 rol., nr J\a 3M-112412013 roA.; np. np. Ns 3434/20t: roa., In -3M l\b 1555/2013 ror.
Or nponepeHrzre rocrAe6su npoH3Bo.qcrBa, KoHcraraur,rrra Korro Mo)r(era ce HanpaBII e, qe npolr3HactHero no aKToBere e craBiulo cJrea Ir3Br,prrIBaHeHa onpererreHare OI4M. flporypopcrnre nocraHoBJ,re Hus ca ,oru urounr.r43J]afaHa n o6cr,Nrana e npaBHara u Qaxrltvecra oocraHoera. Ha,ruue cacr'orBerHl4Te npol43HactHllt rlo B3err{Te MepKr4 3a HeorK!.roHeHHe r.r rpyfr4npuHynlrTeJ'rHtr MepKrr 3a npo{ecyaJlHa nprrHyAa, Ka(TO tr oTHocHopa3IIopexlaHeTO C HaJ]lrqHVTe BerqecTBeHU AOKa3aTeJrCTBa.
O6ulara KoHcrararlut, Korro ce HaJrafa e, qe e Hanuue pearHon3nr,JlHeHue Ha Aa.qeHnre npenop6Kr,r, Karo caMo no .qe.,.rara cnpeHr4 cpeqy 1414.Kofaro I4Ma AaHHI4' qe Jlullero e HanycHaJlo crpaHara, He ce l43rtpa[la Konre orIrocraHoBJreHr4ero Ha f.{ ., fpanr.rvua nolurllrl"- npr4MepHo rro np. np.Ilbl340/2013 roa., AfI Ne 636/2013 roA.; rp. np. tft 572t20tS roa.. AirNg284/2015 roA.; np. ry. J\b1920/2015 ro.q., lII N0284/2015 no4.; np. np.J\!4010/2015 roa., AI Ns 1697/2014 ror.; np. np. J,{!1201/20tr roa., nir,\s579/2013 ron.
B ragu nocoxa cJreIBaKOII}IC OT IIOCTAHOBJ'ICHUCTO
norlrul.t.r".
Ae ce npelnpr4eMar MepKrr, Karo 3a e 6lae tecrelBa Aa ce r43npaua Ha f!" fpaHu,rua
IIo npenoprra IL6. B raqecrBoro cr4 na ua6rru.qasaulr.r npoKvpoprj /racJleIrT cTpllrcTHo 3a [3Tt{qaHe Ha cpoKa Ha pa3cJreABaHe, KaTO npelnpueMaTcBoeBpeMeHHO MepKr4 3a nptIKIIOqBaHe Ha neJIoTo uJIU 3a ylbJ,lxaBaHe HacpoKa.
B ra:u HacoKa Ha cryr{aeH nptrHurrn 6lxa nponepeHl.t c;rerHureHaKa3aTerHH npor.t3Boac rBa:
flp.np. Ns2366/2012 roA., AII Ns l4l0/2012 roa.; np. up. Nu 1594/2014roa., Atr Ns 57212014 ror.; np. np. Ne 1624/2007 ro4., ltl Ne75/2007 roa.; rp.np. Nt2236/2012 rot., lll Ne 100-K/2013 roA.; np. np. J.{b 958/2013 .oa., Ah
!t:?1!t?913 roA.; np. np. .r\b 860/2012 roa., lrr M 492t2012 no.q.; np. np.Ne1l23l20l4 ro1., !|I Ns 46512014 ror.; np. np. J\! 959/20t: roa., .qn Ns5.!512913 ro.4.; np. np. Na 793t2013 roa., In Ib 2ggt20t3 foA.; np. np.Ns406212013 roa., .{|I Ns 1798/2013 roa.
He ce r<oncrarupaxa cny.rai Ha HapyruaBaHe Ha cpoKoBere, r. e. He 6.rxaycraHoBeHu locr,Ie6Hlt npou3BoacrBa rto Ko]tro r4cKagero 3a ylbJrxaBaHe Ia eHanpaBeHo r.r3BbH CpOKa, Ka(TO L TaKUBa nO KoLrTo Aa ca r.{3B}prrlBaHtlflpoqecyil'rH14 IeficrBt4r no pa3cJreABaHero, r.t3Br,H pa3pettreHure cpoKoBe.
KoHcrarupa ce peaJrHo r{3nbJrHeHue Ha AaAeHara npenopbKa.
flo npenoprrcu ll. 7 ,8 u 9 ;
7. llpor<ypopure Aa cre.qqr cBoeBpeMeHHoro tr3MeHeHurra a HK;8. Koraro no npenucKara r{Ma AaHHrl 3a rr3B.bpueHo npecr:bflJ]eHr4e!
Koero e or KoMrrereHTHocrra Ha ropecrorulara npoKyparypa, Ha6lrcAauauutrrlpoKypop, nbpBo Ia r43npaqa npelr4cKara 3a npor43HacrHe no roBanpecrbnreHue v c,'Ier HeiHoro eBeHTyaJrHo Bpr,r[ase ra u3Bbp[rBa rei4ctsug,orHocHo npecrbnJreHl,Iero, Koero e or KoMnereHrHoctra Ha pfl;
9. flpoxypopure Aa r{3BbpruBar no npequ3Ha npoBepKa HaIoKa3arercrBara no AeJroro npu perxaBaHe Ha Blnpocure no w.242,axI otHIIK.
B rasfi Hacoxa 6rxa npoaepeufi cJIeaHr4Te HaKa3areJIHu IIpor43BoAcrBa :
- IIp. np. Np 136212013 roa., !il Ns 795/2013 ror.; np. rp. J\b31 19t2008roa., AII J\e 1344/2008 roA.; rp. np. J,,tb 1113t2013 roa., AtI N! 507/2013 roa.;np. np. J\s884/2014 ros., An l,{e 361/2014 no4.; np. np. Nr 1963/2014 roa.,.4IlNs 64512074 roA.; np. np. Ns 1754i2014 roA., III No 688/2014 foA.; np. np.Xb1550/2014 ro,q., All Ns 600i2014 noA.; rp. np. Ne 23t412014 roa., Aft J\!92712014 rot.
flpn lrsnrpureHara npoBepKa ce KoHcrarr.{pa, qe e Ha!.rrjue peaJrHou3rILiIHeHr4e Ha AaAeHrrTe flpenopbKH.
flo npenoptra II.10. Koraro AeJroro ce BHacr B claa c OA r.r Ha lllcpeqy o6nraHreMr4r e B3era MHO ,,3agrpNaHe nor crpaNa", B npr,tJroxeHrreroxru OA cJreABa Ia ce orpa3rBa Aarara Ha Korro e mera MHO, a a c,ryuafi, ue eu3MeHeHa .qa ce or6ertgea v narara Ha r43MeHeHr,re.
B valroro cnytairl np. np. l,'l! 50812014 noa., AII Ns 19712014 ror.; np.ry. Na2616/2013 roa., fin Ne 120512013 ro1.;/ no Kolrro e ssrNaaHa MHO,,3agr,pNaue no4 crpax<a" rosa o16el.ssnaHe ce npaBr4.
llpenoprrara e r,l3rrbJrHeHa.
flo npenoprra II.1l. B OA aa ce onr{cBar Bcr{rrKrl cr,cranovepuu QaxruorHactulr4 ce iqo flpecrbnJ]eHuero r,r yqacrr4ero Ira o6sr4uret\aur B Hero; Ia He cenonxoxra $opuraluo flpu oflpe,qenrHe Ha cMexqaBa Iure 14 orerqaBaulureo6crorrercrsa; npu r.r3forBrHe na OA Aa ce cna3Ba nopeAHocra sa,tt.246,an.2
u 3 or HIIK v Aa ce pa1oru tro npeuu3Ho c ornel HaMa.,,rrBaHe 6poa Ha rerara,BbpHaTr4 or cbAa Ha npoKypopa.
B rasli Hacoxa Ha cnyqaeH nplrHuxn 6.axa nponepeHr{ Aena c BHeceHr4 tscr.ua OA:
fitl Ns 728/2012 roa., np. np. No l2L5l20t2up. np. Ns 163312014 roa.; AII Ns 728/2012 rot.,lll Ne 699/2014 rop., np. np. J\b 178U2014 rot;lp. Nt 394412013 roa.; III Ns 186/2013 noa.. np.J',1b1602i2013 ror.. np. np. Nt 3444/2012 roa.; .1,Il414212013 ros.; {|I ]l! 63-K/2013 ron., rp. rp.87312012 roA., np. np. Nt177612012 rop.
roa.; AII Ng 64412014 rot.np. np. Nr 1225/2012 roa.':
!t1 Ns 1794t2013 ro.r.. np.np. J,{b 584/2013 ro,r.: Ifl1835/2013 ro.q., np. np. Nb
Ne 890/2013 roa.: {[ll\.1rl
llpu nponepr<ara no re3u AeJra He ce KoHcrarr4paxa nponycKl4. C;re4ea;ace or6e,reNu, qe rro BcrqKr,r re3r4 Aera uMa rrocraHoBesr.r csae6nu aKToBe. KaroNO IIOBCI]CTO OT T'X TC CA BJIC3JII4 Ll B QI/'JA.
flo nqxou or AeJlara OA ca usrorstHr4 B cpoK HaA TpuAecer ,1un, rri;iKaro ce e HaJ.rariuo Ha6,uoAaBar(xre npoKypopr4 ::Ia npeKparrBar qacrrdqHoHaKa3areJrHure npor43BoAcrBa rro orHo[eHr{e Ha onpeAereHu rrnr\a. B ra:]uBpb3Ka e cJieABiuto Aa ce u3qaKa rroJryqaBaHero Ha o6parHara pa3nt4cKa, cnerBirr43aHe B cuJra Ha cborBerHr4Te nocraHoBJreHufl, TaKuBa ca cnyqaure no : 7]flNs 22/1998 roA., np. np. Nr 2834/1995 ror.; III Nrl04/2014 noa., np. np. Ns258/2014 roa.; AII Ns 1798112013 ror., np. np. Na4062/2013 roa.
Or usnrpureuara rrpoBepKa, Mo)r(e Aa ce HanpaBrr KoHcrarautrqra, qe
o6BLIHHTerHr4Te aKToBe Karo urro ca u3forBrHr.r B cr,orBercrBue cr.r3r.{cKBaHrrrra Ha 'fi. 246 or H|IK, Karo e cniBBaH r{ 3aKoHoycraHoBeHulTpr4leceT IHeBeH CpOK.
flo npenoptra II.12. llporypopr{Te aa nonbr.rBar HartJrexHo cflpaBKtire nor.30 or Vra:anue na BKII Ns VI-21116.01.2002 roa., a cera Ha r. 47 orVnagauue J\e 14-30105.03.2009 roa. Karro 6e or6e,'rr3aHo no fope, roBa Heruoce npaBu , Karo He BbB Bcr4qKr4 clyvafi cnpaaxure ca rrbJtHr.r.
3a4rlNure,ruo e:a n 6r,geqe, ToBa Herrlo .qa ce trpaBrl no Bcuqx]r.{eJla,Karo crrpaBKure cne.qBa Aa 6t:Tat nr,rHlr u [3qepnareJrHn .
flo npenoprxa II.13. llpu oraenrHe Ha Marepualrrre or 4ageuo [fl. eIIA aa ce nocraBrr BcurtKr4 Heo6xo.{nult ,4oKvMeHTr4. BKnx)rrrire.lHonocraHoBJleHr4ero :a o6pa:ynaue ua {fI.
flporepeHz 6rxa c:reIHlrre HaKa3areJrHr4 npor,r3BoIcrBa:np. np. Ilb 294312014 ro4., {[ Ne 1136/2014 noA.; np. np. Nr 176612014
roa., AfI Ns 708/2014 ror.; np. np. Nr 2838i2014 roa.. [t7 Nu 284-22/2014 rot.;rp. np. No 2834/1995 roa., AII Ne22-M998 ro.[.; np. np. J',1b1905/2014 for.,lfl Nr 853/2014 ros.; np. np. 152512014 roA., An Ns 60212014 ro1.; np. np. Ns406212013 roa., All Ns 1798/2013 noa.; np. np. Nr 3358/2013 roa., A|I Ns1442/2013 roA.; np. np. J,{r 1978/2014 ros., !|I J',lb 791l2014 rog.
flpenucrczte ca oKoMIIreKToBaHI4 c Bcrirr*Iz ueo6xorlrl,'.r 14 I43I4cKyeMu ce.qoKyMeHTn.
I4sroga, Kotiro Moxe Aa ce HanpaBrr e, qe npenopbKara e r43n6nHeHapeiurHo.
IIo npenoplr<a ll.l4. Brs scuqrli cnyvafi, Kofaro cMrrar, qepa3nope)KlaHeTo Ha c'bla 3a Bpbn]aHe Ha .4eJrro r.() 3a aopa3c.jreaBaHe eHenpaBnJ'rHo, ra noraBar nporecrz cbrrracHo qr. 249,ar.3 or H[k.
Bu,tuo or flpororo,r Ns 6120.12.2012 roa. e npoBeAeHo pa6orHocbBerrlaHrre c npoKypopr4Te or pfl Karaslrx Br,B Bpb3ra c npo6.rreuurecBT,p3aHI4 C BpblqaHeTo Ha .qenaTa 3a Aopa3cJreaeaHe. AHarzi hpaHt4 canphqr4Hr.rre, KoI4To Hafr qecro Bo,4rr Ao BpbrrlaHe Ha AeJIara. Ha1etszauu caonpeleJreH, .qeicrBur 3a HelonycKaHe Ha nolo6'r, ltponyc*n, Korrro or cBo,cTpaHa nI,K BO.tlrT AO BpbrrlaHe Ha IeJraTa.
Ha 06.03.2015 roA. e npoBeAeHo pa6orHo cr,BeuraHue c nporypopr.rre orf-n^Ka111,rrr naK Br,B Bpb3Ka c BpbulaHr4re 3a aopa3cneaBaue 4era/hporor<onNs 2/06.03.2015 ror./.
ITpez 2014 ror. or nporypopr,rre e p Ka3aH,,tlK ca noAaaeHr,r r{e.lupu6p. uacrHu nporecra Bt,B Bpb3Ka c BT,pHarI4 or cb;1a Ae,,ra 3a aopa3cnelBaHe.Karo ABa or rrx ca yBaxeHr4 : qacreH nporecr Ha npo(ypop flas,,tos rto np. np.Ns176612014 rol. c/y pa3nopexAaHero Ha c6:]a 3a rrpeKparrBaue ua HOX{ }lr58312014 ror.; qacreH rporecr Ha npo*ypop flasros no np. np. Ns3375/2014ron. c/y pa3nopexAaHe Ha cbAa 3a npeKparrBaue Ha HOX! No 16q412014 ,ot.
B o6qra Jrr4HI4r,I! or aHaJ.Irr3r,rre Ha npr4ql4Hl'Te aoBeJrr.t Ao BpT,uIaHe HareJrara 3a ropa3cJrerBaHe. MOXe .qa ce HanpaBr4 r43Bo.qa, qe r 60ruruHctBoro orcJryrrar4Te, cbAa npaBr,rJrHo e BpbulaJ'r IeJraTa 3a aopa3cJreABaHe.
Pa6orara B Ta3r4 Hacoxa cJTenBa Ia 6r,Ae nocro_snna r4 Henpex.bcHara, 3aIa ce lonycKaT no MaJrIKo npoflycKlr u rperxKrl! BoIeUIU Aa Bpbn]aHeTo HaAeJraTa 3a aopa3cne.qBaHe.
IIo npenoptKa 11.15. Ilporypoprzre ra crreArr crpr.tKrHonprrroxeHr.rero na .tr. 343r or HK nplt cKJrroqBaHe ua cnopa.yveuu"ru.
B ra:u HacoKa npl4 npoBepKara Ha .qeJ,rara ce KoHcrarr.rpa.npenopbKaTa e u3III,J'rHeHa peiL[HO.
qe
flo npenop*a 11.16. la cna3Bar c'rpr.rKrHo vna^:aHue ],rb I,I-30/09r. na|lraeHns npoKypop Ha PB sa 4efiHocrra Hu npo*yparypara no npr4BexaaHe Br3nr'JIHeHIre Ha BJ'Ie3rr{Te B cl4Jra npucbrt4, peneHr4r u onpereJreHx tt Ha c.r,Aa,Koero BMeHrBa 3aA6JrxeHr4r He caMo Ha npoKypopa, roiro ocr,utecrBrBaHaa3opa 3a r43nljrHeHr.re Ha HaKa3aHr4rTa, HO r4 Ha BCnrrKr4 lpyf npoKypopfi.
flpra nperne4a Ha fipr4cr,rHara KHr{ra 3a Z0l4 rol.. He ce KoHcrarnpa, na eAOnycKaHo sa6aasHe npfi nprrBexraHero B H3frbJrHeHrze Ha nocrr,r] HJlr.rrecrge6Hr'r aKToBe C KOI4TO Ca 6U,U.r HaroNeur4 HaKa3aHUr JTr4IIraBaHe or cso60ra.
B xsunure 3a r{3IIT,JIHeHue Ha npr4cblr4Te ca orpa3rBaHr4 peryJrrpHorl3BbprllBaHfiTe npoBepr(u Ha npo(ypopa no Ha.q3op 3a r43n:bJTHeHhe HaHaKa3aHr4rTa c HefoB nolrrr4c 14 AaTa Ha npoBepKaTa.
flpenoprxara e r,r3nbJrHeHa DeffrHo.
flo npenoprxa III. r. l-7 Aa1enu no orHorrreur4e Ha KoHKperHr.rnpoKypopr4, KoHcraraul{tra Korro Moxe aa ce HanpaB[ e, qe re ca fi3IbJHeHHpeanHo.
Or lrantpruenara KoHTpoJrHa npoBepKa ua pa6orara na pII Ka:as,rr,r loIt3nbrHeHt4e Ha IaAeHr4Te npenopt,rlr c Arr ga pe3yJrrarr4 or nJIaHoBanpoBepKa' H3Bbp eHa cbfrracHo 3anoeeA J\! nr-01 -261 15.03 .2012 foa. Haf.[asHuq r{HcneKTop Ha l4BCC,rr,rorar Aa ce I43BeAar cJreIHI4Te KoHcraraul{u:
Br,g ocgona Ha HanpaBeHr4Te r{38o.{u, ce ycraHoBn qyBcrBHTenHonogobplnaHe Ha opraHu3aurtrra na pa6ora B npoKyparypara, He3aBr4cr,tMo orTIOBI4IIICHATA HATOBAPCHOCT B NCPI4OAA CJICA KOMIIJICKCHATA NJIAHOBA NPOBCPKAHa PfI KasaHrbK npe3 2012r., raxro no orHorxeHue Ha aAMr{Hl4crpr4paHero.TaKa 14 no orHorrreHr4e Ha flpoKypopcKara 4efiuocr s Aocl,re6Hara u cue6HaraQa:a ua HaKa3are;rHr4r rrpouec.
{ageHzre peflopl,Ktr Karo IIrJro ca r43IIbJrHeH!{.
Hacroaqzlr A*r 4a ce r,I3nparu Ha al*rlHuc.rpa.r'BHnfl, pb*oBorr4.reJ,r HaPfl Ka3aH,rbr. Ko[To na 3ano3Hae npo*ypopr4Te or pf] Kararr,rrK c pe3ynrar,reoT r43Bl,pllreHara KoHTpoJrHa npoBepKa, KaTo Ha BCeKr4 eArrH oT rrpoKypopxTe ceBpr,r{Il KcepoKonr4e oT aKTa.
Ha ocuosaHue .rr.58,an.3 or 3axoua ra crge6uara Bracr" B 7-aHeeeHcpoK or Bpr,qBaHe Ha Hacrorrqr4fl Axr sa perylrarr.r or r43BbptxeHa npoBepKa,Mofar .qa 6r,,rar uanpaneHr4 Bb3paxeHnt [peA f.[agnlalt uHcneKTop.
LK3CMNJT'P OT AKTA HA CJIEKTPOHCH HOCIITCJI AA CC I,T3IIPATI,I rrA BTJCTUITqcr,Ae6eH cr,ser.
Eraeltnnrp or aKTa Ha ereKTpoHeH Hocl4t.cJr Aa ce r43nparll HaaaMr4Hr4crpar[BHr4r pbKoBolr,trel ua OxprNHa npoKyparypa Crapa 3aropa;
E:eup,rrp or aKTa Ha eJreKTpoHeH Hocr,rren ra ce r{3npa.rul HaalMuHt{crpart{BHur pbr(oBo.qure,r sa Ane,raruBHa npoKyparypa fl.norlun.
Ex:etnrnnrp or aKTa Ha eJreK,rpoHeH HocrrreJr Ia ce l43nparl,t ua f,rasufirrnpoKypop sa BKII na PE.
TIPI{JIOXEHLIE:
10
l.3anoaeA Ne KII- 0l-2g/06.11.2015 roA. r. na faasHx, r{HcneKrop Har4BCC.2.[ouaagt, cqpaBrr{, usB4AKr.r or peruclpr4, Kourl, or 3arroBeAr{,
pByrrlaru.
n
w)F#9
11
