Post on 15-Jan-2015
description
transcript
Tbilisis saxelmwifo universiteti
pirovneba
kultura
sazogadoeba
socialur mecnierebaTa aqtualuri problemebi
eduard koduas dabadebis 80 wlisTavisadmi miZRvnili samecniero konferenciis
(23-24 oqtomberi 2009) masalebi
Tbilisi 2010
anotacia
konferenciismasalebiskrebulimoicavsTsu-ssocialur
da politikur mecnierebaTa fakultetis profesorTa da
doqtorantTa naSromebs, sadac ganxilulia Tanamedrove mso-
flios, kerZod ki saqarTvelosTvis aqtualuri socialuri
da politikuri problemebi,xSir SemTxvevaSi mocemulia maTi
gadaWrisoptimalurigzebida saSualebebi.
statiaTa avtorebi, ara marto sxvadasxva Taobebsa da
socialur mecnierebaTa gansxvavebul dargebs ganekuTnebian,
aramed problemebis xedvis gansxvavebuli manera da pozicia
aqvT, rac aZnelebs krebulis erTiani suliskveTebis da sti-
lisdacvas.amitomSeiZlebaerTsadaimaveproblemisSesaxeb
dapirispirebuli Tvalsazrisebi da midgomebi dainaxoT. rac
CveniazriT,kiaramcrobskrebulismecnierulRirebulebas,
aramed piriqiT.
vimedovnebT, rom krebuli saintereso aRmoCndeba yvela
Taobis inteleqtualisTvis da sargeblobas moutans qarTul
sazogadoebas.
samecnieroredaqtori:filosofiisdoqtori amiran berZeniSvili
recenzentebi:
1. valerianramiSvili,filosofiur mecnierebaTadoqtori
2.revazjorbenaZe,fsiqologiis mecnierebaTadoqtori
3. mariwereTeli,filologiisdoqtori
ISBN 978-9941-0-2969-1
3
sarCevi
winasityva (amiran berZeniSvilis) .....................................................7
donaZe naTela
eduard kodua rogorc pirovneba da mecnieri .......................14
CikvilaZe dali
eduard kodua,qarTvel publicistTa wignebis
Semdgeneli da redaqtori .............................................................28
abaSiZe zviadi, dundua salome
eTnikuri identobebi da samoqalaqo integraciis
sakiTxi saqarTveloSi .....................................................................36
belqania nodari
definiciis problema da sokrates logikuri
memkvidreoba ......................................................................................57
berZeniSvili amirani
informaciul-teqnologiuri revolucia da misi
kulturuli Sedegebi ....................................................................80
biWikaSvili ira
realobis amsaxveli forma. ra aris infografika? ..............99
gersamia mariami
Tanamedrove sagazeTo statiis saxeebi: editoriali
da opedi ............................................................................................106
goroSiZe giorgi, a. sxirtlaZe, x. matkava
qarTuli organizaciuli kulturis genderuli
Taviseburebani ................................................................................118
danelia rozeta
adamiani da Tanamedroveoba .......................................................130
dolbaia Tamari
Tavisufali ekonomikuri zonebis msoflio
gamocdileba da saqarTvelo ......................................................138
4
doliZe maka
XX saukunis pirveli naxevris politikuri movlen ebis
asaxva JurnalSi `eri~ ....................................................................156
kalandariSvili maia
samomxmareblo arCevanis fsiqologiuri
determinantebi ...............................................................................165
kankia nargiza
kino gadacema `wiTeli zona~ ......................................................184
kvinikaZe giorgi
migracia da eri – saxelmwifos geo ekonomikuri
problemebi transnacionalizaciisa da
trans lokalurobis koncefciebSi ...........................................196
kaWkaWiSvili iago
sazogadoebrivi azris cvlilebebi
saqarTve lo-ruseTis omis Suqze ..............................................218
lomiZe marine
krizisuli komunikaciis roli P PR– saqmi anobaSi ................240
maRraZe guguli
demokratiis perspeqtivebi gardamaval qveynebSi ...............256
malxaz macaberiZe
ivane javaxiSvili da saqarTvelos saxelmwifoebrivi
mSeneblobis ZiriTadi sakiTxebi (1919 weli) .........................269
memaniSvili magda
geronti qiqoZe da gazeTi `saqarTvelo~ (1915-20) ............. 283
osefaSvili dali
rogor Secvala web-ma swavleba – personal uri
veb-gverdidan LMS-mde (Jurnalisturi ganaTlebis
magaliTze) ....................................................................................... 294
saluqvaZe iosebi, gogiSvili daviTi
`TviTSemoqmedebiTi urban iz mi~ TbilisSi: `miSenebebi~
da samosaxlo garemos gardaqmna dedaqalaqis
sacxovrebel masivebSi .................................................................307
5
sumbaZe nana
agvistos omi: mosaxleobis Sefasebebi da ganwyobebi .........324
Rvineria irine
multimediuri formebis gamoyenebis pirveli
Sedegebi Jurnalisturi ganaTlebis sistemaSi ....................343
wereTeli baaduri
brendis roli regionis kulturuli landSaftis
CamoyalibebaSi da qveynis ekonomikur ganviTar ebaSi
(borjomis magaliTze) ..................................................................356
yifiani giorgi
samoqalaqo sazogadoeba mcirewlovanTa dacva mediis
mavne zegavlenisagan saqarTveloSi .........................................366
xutaSvili mari
socialuri ekologia da sociologia .....................................389
javaxiSvili nino, xositaSvili maia, siraZe nino,
Zagania lika, iohan Snaideri.
qarTvel da germanel morwmuneTa Sedareba locvis
aspeqtebis mixedviT .......................................................................399
399
nino javaxiSvili, maia xositaSvili,
nino siraZe, lika Zagania,
ivane javaxiSvilis saxelobis Tbilisissaxelmwifo universiteti
iohan Snaiderizaarlandis universiteti
qarTvel da germanel morwmuneTa Sedarebalocvis aspeqtebis mixedviT
religiuri rwmenis indikatorialocva, romelic warmoad-
gens `religiis sulsa da arss~ (Josephs, 1998). aSS-Si Catare-
bulmakvlevebmaaCvena,romadamianebisakmaodxSiradloculo-
ben(amerikelTa90%zogjermaincloculobs(Gallup Organiza-
tion, 1993). esexebarogorceklesiaSimosiarulemlocvelebs,
asevemaT,vinceklesiaSiardadis.kvlevebismixedviT,aTeiste-
bic ki loculoben. mlocvelTagan umravlesoba sxvebTan erT-
adlocvas Cumadlocvas amjobinebs. aseveumravlesobas swams,
rommaTilocvaSesmeniliqneba (97%),pasuxicgaecema,darom
locva maT ukeTes adamianebad aqcevs (86%) (Josephs, 1998).
mlocvelTa77% kmayofilia aseTicxovrebiT. mravali adamiani
iyenebslocvas,raTagadaWrascxovrebiseulisirTuleebi,daZ-
lios janmrTelobis problemebi. locva daZlevis strategiaa
da mniSvnelovan rols TamaSobs stresul situaciebSi, avad-
myofobis, frustraciis da sxvadasxva mZime danakargebis dros.
uaryofiTma da dadebiTma emociebma SeiZleba gazardonlocvis
sixSire.usiamovnosituaciaSiizrdebaTxovniTilocvissixSi-
400
re,sasiamovnosdroski–madlierebiTilocvissixSire(Harris,
Schoneman, Carrera, 2005).
locvis intimurobidan gamomdinare, misi empiriuli aRwera
rTulia.saqmesisicarTulebs,romsxvadasxvareligiurganzo-
milebasa da fsiqikur janmrTelobas Soris arsebuli kavSiris
Sesaxeb monacemebi xSirSemTxvevaSiorazrovanidaurTierTsa-
winaaRmdegoa. igive SeiZleba iTqvaslocvis kavSirze adamianis
fsiqikurdafizikurjanmrTelobasTan (Harris, Schoneman, Car-
rera, 2005).
monacemTa amgvari aRrevis mizezi SeiZleba dakavSirebuli
iyoslocvis definiciis sakiTxTan, terminis standartizaciis
problemasTan.iTvleba,romlocvaRmerTTankomunikaciisgzaa,
komunikaciis terminis qveS SesaZlebelia mravalgvari qceva
igulisxmebodes. aqedan gamomdinare, arsebobslocvis tipebisa
dafunqciebis klasifikaciis problema. cnobilia elkinis mier
SemoTavazebulilocvistipebi:gamomqomagebeli(qomagi)daCa-
fiqrebuli (moazrovne); riCardsis TxovniTi da urTierTobis;
melonisa da finis verbaluri da meditaciuri locvis tipe-
bi. magram am tipologiebze dayrdonibiT ver moxerxdalocvis
sakvlevi validuri testis Seqmna. igive suraTs vxedavT loc-
vis funqciebis klasifikaciis SemTxvevaSic,locvis funqciebs
Soris gamoyves: moTxovnilebis gamoxatva, rwmenis ganmtkiceba,
relaqsacia,desensitizaciadasxva.magramesfunqceibiempiri-
uladvaliduriararis(Ladd, Spilka, 2002; Richards, 1991;Finney,
Malony, 1985; Byrd & Boe, 2001; Harris, Schoneman & Carrera ,
2005; Maltby, Lewis & Day, 1998).
401
reliigis fsiqologiaSi arsebuli `SeTanxmebulobis hipo-
Tezis~mixedviT,locvissixSiredasaerTodadamianisreligi-
uroba, rwmena da qcevebi damokidebulia imaze, igi amrideblu-
ri Tu mSfoTvare tipia. pirvel SemTxvevaSi adamiani erideba
urTierTobebs sxvebTan, adamianebTan kontaqti misTvis diskom-
fortswarmoadgens.meoresdrossaqmegvaqvsuaryofisdamito-
vebisSiSTan.erT-erTikvlevisSedegaddadginda,romzemoTxse-
nebulitipebi kavSirSi iyo imasTan, mimarTavdaTu aralocvas
adamiani stresul situaciaSi. amridebluri tipi stresuli
situaciis dros ar mimarTavs locvas, radgan locva mxolod
gazrdis mis diskoforts. misgan gansxvavebiT, araamridebluri
tipistresulisituaciebisdrosmimarTavslocvas.mSfoTvare
tipiamgvarsituaciebSimxolodTxovniTlocvasambobs(Byrd,
Boe, 2001).
locvis saintereso klasifikacias gvTavazoben poloma da
pendletoni. maT mier gamoyofili locvis oTxi saxe sxva av-
torebmaSemdgomkvlevebSigamoiyenes(Beasler, 2002;McCullough,
Larson, 1999;Laird, Snyder, Rapoff, Green, 2004):
WvretiT-meditaciurimlocvelsRvTaebrivTanintimuri,pi-
radi urTierToba aqvs; iyenebs daZlevis religiur meqanizmebs
(sulieridasayrdenisZieba),racxSiraddakavSirebuliacxovre-
biseuli stresuli situaciis Semdgom periodTan; amsubuqebs
dapozitiurcvlilebebsiwvevsfsiqologiursimptomatikaSi;
iklebs kunTuridaWimuloba, brazi, SfoTvadadepresia ;
402
ritualuri mlocveli locvans kiTxulobs an damaxsovre-
bullocvebsimeorebs.estipidadebiTkavSirSiacxovrebiseul
keTildReobasTan, religiurkmayofilebasTan;
mTxovneli mlocveli ufals sakuTari Tavisa da sxvaTaT-
vis SesTxovs; Txovna locvis yvelaze primitiuli, pirveladi
formaadapozitiuri,religiuriTusulieri,funqcionirebis
maCvenebelia.amgvarilocvafsiqosocialuristresisniSaniada
aRiniSnebanegatiuricxovrebiseulisituaciisSemdeg.locvis
am saxes iyeneben Zlieri tkivilebis regulirebisa da Semcire-
bisaTvis;
sakuTarisityvebiT mlocveli esaubrebaRmerTs; misiTxov-
nis elementebi ufro specifiuri da konkretulia, vidre mTx-
ovneli mlocvelis. aseT dros adamianebi uflisagan iTxoven:
Zalas, gaZRolas, sxvaTa dalocvas; is erTgvari progresis am-
saxvelia_axalgazrdobidanzrdasrulobamdedapozitiurkav-
SirSiajanmrTelobasa da keTildReobasTan (Poloma, Pendleton,
1989; Poloma, Pendleton, 1990; Poloma, Pendleton, 1991).
gert hofstedes mixedviT, kultura gavlenas axdens re-
ligiaze, Sesabamisad, sxvadasxva religiis warmomadgenlebs
gansxvavebulireligiuriSexedulebebidaqcevebi aramxolod
Tavadrwmenisdogmebidan, aramedamaTuimkulturasTanmikuT-
vnebulobis gamo aqvT. gamonakliss arc qristianoba da masSi
gamoyofili sami msxvili jgufi – protestantebi, kaTolikebi
da marTlmadideblebi warmoadgenen. miuxedavad imisa,rom pro-
testantebi, kaTolikebi da marTlmadideblebi, rigi sxva deno-
403
minaciebisagan gansxvavebiT,Tanxmdebian,rom arsebobs erTiWeS-
mariteba, maT Soris aris sxvaoba hofstedes mier gamoyofil
iseTfsiqologiurganzmilebebze,rogorebicaa:
Zalauflebis manZili
feminuroba-maskulinoba
gaurkvevlobisTavidan arideba
Zalauflebis manZilis konstruqti aRniSnavs, Tu ramdenad
misaRebiaorganizaciaSinaklebiZalauflebismqonewevrisaTvis
ismosazreba,romZalauflebisganawilebaTanabariararis.sxva
sityvebiT, sazogadoebebi gansxvavdeba erTmaneTisagn imisda mi-
xedviT, uWeren Tu ara misi wevrebi mxars ierarqias sazogado-
ebaSi. protestantuli religiis mqone qveynebSi Zalauflebis
manZili dabalia, es ufro demokratiuli qveynebia, xolo ka-
Tolikurda marTlmadideblur qveynebSi Zalauflebis manZili
maRalia.qristianulqveynebSiZlieri,maskulinurisazogadoe-
bebiRmerTismniSvnelobisumTavresobasaRiareben.maskulinuri
sazogadoebisaTvis mama RmerTis saxeli mniSvnelovania, xolo
feminur sazogadoebebSi, da aseTebi ZiriTadad protestantebi
arian, ufro SeimCneva sekularizmisaken ltolva. gaurkvevlo-
bis Tavidan arideba niSnavs, rom adamianma ar icis, ra moxdeba
xval, momavali gaurkvevelia, xolo ukiduresi gaurkvevloba
autanelSfoTvasiwvevs. yovelmasazogadoebam amSfoTvisSem-
cirebisgzebimonaxa.esteqnologiis,kanonmdeblobisadareli-
giismeSveobiTmoxda.religiaadamianispiradimomavlismakon-
troleblad miCneul transcedentur ZalebTan dakavSirebis
404
saSualebaa. religia gvexmareba iseT gaurkvevlobas SeveguoT,
romlisganac Tavs ver davicavT. zogierTi religia sicocxlis
Semdeg sikvdilis, an mowinaaRmdegis damarcxebis saboloo ga-
rkveulobas gvTavazobs (Hofstede, Hofstede, 2004).
mravali qveynis monacemebis safuZvelze hofstedem aCvena,
rom zemoT aRniSnul ganzomilebebze protestantebs nakle-
bi qulebi aqvT, vidre marTlmadideblebs (Hofstede, Hofstede,
2004). amrigad, gamoikveTa sainteresogansxvavebebi protestan-
tebsa da marTlmadideblebs Soris. sainteresoa, aris Tu ara
gansxvavebasxvadasxvakulturismorwmuneebsSoris,miTumetes,
TuisinisxvadasxvareligiasmiekuTvnebian.ammizniTSevadareT
erTmaneTsqarTveli–marTlmadidebelidagermaneli–protes-
tantimorwmuneebilocviskuTxiT.SevarCieTlocvisramdenime
komponenti
locvisdaRvTismsaxurebazedaswrebis sixSire;
locvissaxeebi;
locviT kmayofileba.
Sesabamisad, kvlevis kiTxva Semdegnairad Camoyalibda: ra
gansxvavebebia qarTvelda germanel mlocvelebsSoris
•locvisdaRvTismsaxurebazedaswrebis sixSiris
•locvis saxeebisda
•locvis gavlenis mixedviT?
meTodi:
405
gamokiTxva Catarda germaniaSi da saqarTveloSi. qarTuli
SerCeva Sedgeboda 184 morwmunisagan, maTgan, 122 (66,5%) qali
da62(33,5%)mamakaci;110(60,0%)arastudentida74(40,0%)
studenti.asakimeryeobda14 – 83wlamde,xolosaSualoasaki
iyoM = 34,74 (SD = 16,389). kvlevis 182 (98,9%) monawile iyo
marTlmadidebeli,xolo2 (1,1%)– aramarTlmadidebeli. ger-
maniaSi kvleva Catarda206 adamianze, maTgan, 133 (64,6%) qali
da79(34,4%)mamakaci;96(46,8%)arastudentida109(53,2%)
studenti.asakimeryeobda14 – 83wlamde,xolosaSualoasaki
iyoM = 27,32 (SD = 162,657).kvlevis175(85,3%)monawileiyo
protestanti, xolo30 (14,7%)– kaTolike.
instrumentadgamoviyeneTkiTxvari,romelicsaminawilisa-
ganSedgeba.locvissaxeebissazomiskala,locvisgavlenissa-
zomiskaladakiTxvebilocvisdaRvTismsaxurebazedaswrebis
sixSirisSesaxeb. yvela kiTxvalikertisskalistipisaa.
polomasa da pendletonislocvis sazomi skala moicavs 15
debulebas,romlebicadgenenlocvisromelsaxesiyenebsufro
xSiradmlocveli:ritualurs(2debuleba),sakuTarisityvebiT
locvas(6debuleba), meditaciurs(5debuleba)TumTxovnels(2
debuleba). mag., debuleba _ `ramdenad xSirad kiTxulobTlo-
cvans?~Seesabamebaritualurilocvissaxes.debuleba_`ram-
denad xSirad SeigrZnobT, rom RmerTi TqvenTanaa? Seesabameba
meditaciurilocvis saxes da a.S.locvis skalis maqsimaluri
qulaa75.
locvisgavlenissazomiskala9debulebisaganSedgeba.de-
bulebebilocvisdrosaRmocenebulemociurdamokidebulebas
406
daganwyobebsafasebs.skalamoicavsiseTkiTxvebs,rogorebicaa:
`locva amcirebs Cems SiSs~, `locva maniWebs ukeTes emociebs~,
`locvamamSvidebs~dasxv.locvisgavlenissaerTomaqsimaluri
qula aris36.
esoriskalainglisurienidanqarTuladvTargmneT,Semdeg
isev inglisurad. gansvlebis aRmofxvris Semdeg skalebi pilo-
turkvlevaSigamovcadeT,mcireodeniSesworebebisSemdegkiTx-
vari mzad iyo kvlevaSi gamosayeneblad.
Sedegebi:
radganlocvissaxeebisdalocvisgavlenisskalebisaqarT-
veloSi pirvelad tardeboda, qarTul SerCevaze sandoobis Se-
samowmeblad gamovTvaleT maTiα koeficientebi.locvis kiTx-
varis saerTo (15 debuleba) qulis mixedviTα= .8867. locvis
TiToeuli qveskalis mixedviT ki: ritualurilocvaα= .7205,
sakuTari sityvebiT locva α= .8020, meditaciuri locva α=
.7390, mTxovnelilocvaα= .7167. locvisgavlenisskalisalfa
koeficientia α= .9179 amrigad, yvela skala da qveskala san-
doa.
qvemoT mogvyavs qarTveli da germaneli mlocvelebis mona-
cemebi:
locvis sixSiris monacemTa mixedviT, qarTveli da ger-
maneli morwmuneebi arsebiTad gansxvavdebian ori maCvenebliT:
metigermanelimorwmunearloculobsdaSesabamisad,naklebi
germanelimorwmuneloculobsdReSierTxelandReSiramden-jerme (χ2= 98,373, df = 7, p < .000).
407
qarTvelebi germanelebi
saerTodarloculobs 0.5% 8.7%
kviraSiramdenjerme 13% 14.3%
dReSierTxel 20% 13.9%
dReSiramdenjerme 31.9% 24.2%
ufroiSviaTad 34.6% 38.9
χ2= 98.373, df = 7, p < .000
cxrili#1locvis sixSire qarTvel da germanel morwmu-neebTan.
RvTismsaxurebaze daswrebis sixSiris mixedviT, qarTve-lebTan SedarebiT, meti germaneli arasodes dadis eklesiaSi,xolo naklebi dadis kviraSi ramdenjerme (χ2= 41, 551, df = 7,p< .000).
qarTvelebi germanelebi
arasodes 5.9% 11.1 %
kviraSierTxel 20.0% 22.7 %kviraSiramdenjerme 20.5% 8.9 %
ufroiSviaTad 53.6% 57.3%
χ2= 41. 551, df = 7, p < .000
cxrili #2 RvTismsaxurebaze daswrebis sixSire qarTvelda germanel morwmuneebTan.
locvis skalis maqsimaluri 75 qulidan qarTvelebis Ser-Cevam daagrovaM = 51,11 (SD = 10,67). locvis skalaze qulebimeryeobda 15-dan 70-mde. locvis calkeuli saxis mixedviT sa-
SualomonacemebiaseTia:ritualurilocva M =6,82 SD = 2,164,
sakuTarisityvebiTlocvaM = 22,76 (SD = 4,692), meditaciuri
408
locvaM =16,39 (SD = 3,841), mTxovnelilocvaM = 5,17 (SD =
2,257). germanelebis SerCevam daagrovaM = 44,89 (SD = 13,55).
locvis calkeuli saxis mixedviT saSualo monacemebi aseTia:
ritualurilocva M =5,42 SD = 2,742, sakuTarisityvebiTloc-
vaM = 20,43 (SD = 5,298), meditaciurilocvaM =15,02 SD =
4,765, mTxovnelilocvaM = 4,09 SD = 2,763. F (3, 386)=1.153,
p >.05
locvis gavlenis skalis mixedviT maqsimaluri 36 qulidan
qarTvelebmadaagrovesM = 28,79, SD = 5,695.xologermaneleb-
ma: M = 27,93, SD = 6,369. amasTan, locvis gavlenis skalaze
qulebi meryeobda9-dan 36-mde.
korelaciebi:
aRmoCnda, rom qarTvelebis SerCevisaTvis locvis skala
dadebiT korelaciaSia locvis gavlenis skala sTan, locvis
sixSiresa da RvTismsaxurebaze daswrebis sixSiresTan.locvis
gavlenis skala dadebiT korelaciaSia locvis sixSiresa da
RvTismasaxurebaze daswrebis sixSiresTan, aseve Tavad locvis
sixSiresa da RvTismsaxurebaze daswrebis sixSireebs Sorisac
dafiqsirdadadebiTikorelacia.yvelaeskorelaciamniSvnelo-
vaniap < .01 -isdoneze.
409
cxrili #3: locvis maCveneblebis pirsonis korelaciebi
saqarTvelosSerCevis mixedviT
germanelebisSerCevisaTvis:locvisskaladadebiTkorela-
ciaSialocvisgavlenisskalasTan,locvissixSiresadaRvTi-
smsaxurebaze daswrebis sixSiresTan. locvis gavlenis skala
dadebiT korelaciaSialocvis sixSiresadaRvTismasaxurebaze
daswrebis sixSiresTan, aseveTavadlocvis sixSiresa da RvTi-
smsaxurebaze daswrebis sixSireebs Sorisac dafiqsirda dade-
biTi korelacia. yvela es korelacia mniSvnelovaniap < .01 -is
doneze.
locvisskala
locvisgavlenisskala
locvissixSire
RvTismsaxurebazedaswrebissixSire
locvisskala 1 .566** .482** .457**
locvisgavlenis
skala.566** 1 .421** .462**
locvissixSire .482** .421** 1 .592**
RvTismsaxurebaze
daswrebis
sixSire .457** .462** .592** 1
410
cxrili #4: locvis maCveneblebis pirsonis korelaciebigermaniisSerCevis mixedviT
qarTvelebisSerCevaSilocvisyvelaqveskala:ritualuri,sakuTari sityvebiTlocva, meditaciuri locva da mTxovnelilocva korelirebs erTmaneTTan:
cxrili#5::locvissaxeebis pirsonis korlaciebisaqarT-velosSerCevis mixedviT
locvisskala
locvisgavlenisskala
locvissixSire
RvTismsaxurebazedaswrebissixSire
locvisskala 1 .746** .763** .660**
locvisgavlenisskala
.746** 1 .671** .473**
locvissixSire .763** .671** 1 .665**
RvTismsaxurebazedaswrebissixSire
.660** .473** .665** 1
ritualuri sakuTarisityvebiTlocva
meditaciuri mTxovneli
ritualuri 1 .584** .609** .177*
sakuTarisityvebiTlocva
.584** 1 .764** .346**
meditaciuri .609** .764** 1 .323**
mTxovneli .177* .346** .323** 1
411
germanelebisSerCevaSicmsgavsisuraTia:locvisqveskalebi–ritualuri,sakuTarisityvebiTlocva, meditaciuri locvada mTxovnelilocva– korelireben erTmaneTTan.
cxrili#6:locvissaxeebispirsoniskorlaciebigermaniisSerCevis mixedviT
Sedegebis ganxilva:
gansxvavebagermaneldaqarTvelmlocvelebsSorispraqti-kuladargamovlinda.sxvaobaCansmxolodlocvisdaeklesiaSisiarulis sixSiris mixedviT: germanelebi nakleb loculoben,vidre qarTvelebi da ufro iSviaTad eswrebian RvTismsaxure-bas.esmaCvenebeligermanulisazogadoebisSedarebiTmetseku-larizmze metyvelebs, hofstedes mixedviTac, protestanturi,feminuri sazogadoebebi ufro sekularulebi arian (Hofstede,
Hofstede, 2004).
rogorcqarTvel,asevegermanelmorwmuneebTanlocvissix-Siresa da RvTismsaxurebaze daswrebis sixSires Soris dafiq-sirdadadebiTikorelacia. analogiuriSedegimiiRoSnaiderma
ritualuri sakuTarisityvebiTlocva
meditaciuri mTxovneli
ritualuri 1 .567** .589** .213*
sakuTarisityvebiTlocva
.567** 1 .812** .314**
meditaciuri .589** .812** 1 .378**
mTxovneli .213* .314** .378** 1
412
erT-erT kvlevaSi: aRmoCnda statistikurad mniSvnelovani ko-relacialocvis sixSiresa da eklesiaSi siaruls Soris (Sch-
neider, 2004).
qarTvelebisTvisac da germanelebisTvisac yvela skaladadebiT korelaciaSia erTmaneTTan. gamodis, rom is adamianebi,vincxSiradeswrebianRvTsimsaxurebas,asevexSiradloculo-ben da miaCniaT, rom locvas maTze pozitiuri gavlena aqvs da– piriqiT. skalebs Soris korelaciis koefiecientebis maCven-eblebi am or SerCevaSi msgavsia, germanelebTan es korelaciebiodnavufro maRalia.
aRmoCnda,romqarTvelebicdagermanelebiclocviserTidaigive saxeebs iyeneben. yvelaze maRali saSualo qula miiRo sa-kuTarisityvebiTlocvam,Semdegmeditaciurmalocvam,Semdeg,TiTqmisTanabradritualurmada mTxovnelmalocvebma.
marTalia,germanelebisSerCevismxolod14%iyokaTolike,magramSesaZloasworedamfaqtmagamoiwviakvlevisaseTiSede-gi. rodesac hofstede ganzomilebebis mixedviT qristianulireligiisSigniTgansxvavebebzesaubrobs,ZiriTadaqcentsimazeakeTebs, rom protestantebi gansxvavdebian marTlmadideblebisda kaTolikeebisagan da amave dros, marTlamadideblebi da ka-Tolikeebi erTmaneTTan SedarebiT axlos dganan. garda amisa,hofstedeaRniSnavs,romreligiurimikuTvnebulobakulturu-li Rirebulebebis mTlianad Secvlas ar iwvevs. misi azriT,`Zalauflebis manZilis, individualizmisa da koleqtivizmis,feminuroba maskulinobis da gaukrvevlobis Tavidan aridebisRirebulebebi religiur moqcevebs gadaurCa~ (Hofstede, Hofst-
ede, 2004, p. 126).
413
Comparing Georgian and German Believers via Prayer aspects
Nino Javakhishvili, Maya Khositashvili,
Nino Siradze, Lika Dzagania
Tbilisi State University
Johan Schneider
Saarland University
The study looks at the differences in prayer in German (main-
ly Protestant) and Georgian (Orthodox) believers. Such aspects of
prayer as: prayer and church attendance frequency, prayer types
and prayer fulfillment were studied using Likert type scales. 184
Georgian and 206 German believers were questioned. The results
yielded no significant difference in prayer types used by Georgian
and German believers; neither prayer fulfillment revealed any dif-
ference. The reason might be a composition of German believers’
sample that consisted of although relatively small, but still sub
sample of Catholics.
gamoyenebuliliteratura:
Byrd, K. R. & Boe, A. (2001). The correspondence between 1. attachment dimensions and prayer in college students. The
international Journal for the Psychology of Religion, 11(1), pp.
9-24.
Finney, J., Malony, H. (1985) An empirical study of contem-2. plative prayer as an adjust to psychotherapy.Journal of Psy-chology and Theology, 13, 284-290Gallup Organization. (1993). GO LIFE Survey on Prayer. Princ-3. eton, NJ
414
Harris, J. I., Schoneman S. W. & Carrera S. R. (2005). Pre-4. ferred prayer styles and anxiety control.Journal of Religion
and Health, Vol. 44, No. 4, Winter pp. 403-412
Hauenstein H. U. (2002). Auf den Spuren des Gebets, Metho-5. den und Ergebnisse der empirischen Gebetsforschung, Asan-
ger Verlag, Heidelberg, Kroening, pp.49-64
Hofstede, G. Hofstede, G. (2004) Cultures and Organizations: 6. Software of the Mind. Oxford University Press
Jospehs, I. (1998) Constructing One’s Self in the City of the 7. Silent: Dialogue, Symbols and the Role of `As-if~ in Self-De-
velopment. Human Development, 41, pp.180-195
Ladd, K., Spilka, B. (2002). Inward, Outward, and Upward: 8. Cognitive Aspects of Prayer. Journal for the Scientific Study
of Religion 41:3 475-484
Laird, S. P. Snyder, C. R., Rapoff, M. A. & Green, S. (2004). 9. Measuring Private Prayer: Development, Validation, and Clini-
cal Application of the Multidimensional Prayer inventory. The
International Journal For The Psychology of Religion, 14(4),
251-272.
Maltby, J. Lewis, C.A. & Day, L. (1998). Religious orienta-10. tion and psychological well-being: The role of the frequency
of personal prayer. British Journal of Psychology (1999), 4,
pp.363-378
McCullough, M. E., & Larson, D. B. (1999). Prayer. W. R. Mill-11. er (Ed.), Integrating spirituality into treatment: Resources for
practitioners (pp. 85-110).
Poloma, M., Pendleton B. (1989). Exploring types of prayer 12. and quality of life. Review of Religious Research 31:46-53. Poloma, M., Pendleton, B. (1990). Religious domains and gen-13. eral well-being. Social Indicators Research 22:255-276.
415
Poloma, M., Pendleton. B. (1991). The effects of prayer and 14. prayer experiences on measures of general well-being. Journal of Psychology and Theology 19:71-83. Richards, D. (1991). The phenomenology and psychological 15. correlates of verbal prayer. Journal of Psychology and Theol-ogy, 19, 354-363Schneider J. F. (2004). Prayer and Inner Speech: is there a con-16. nection? Psychological Reports, 2004, 94, pp.1382 – 1384.
416