+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Í¡Ö - Columbia Universityww2040/framechno.pdfÍ¡Ö ×3Ø ÙbÚbÛ0ÜCÝ¦Þ ß#Û3Ø Üáà3Ý...

Í¡Ö - Columbia Universityww2040/framechno.pdfÍ¡Ö ×3Ø ÙbÚbÛ0ÜCÝ¦Þ ß#Û3Ø Üáà3Ý...

Date post: 03-Jul-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 2 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
22
Transcript
Page 1: Í¡Ö - Columbia Universityww2040/framechno.pdfÍ¡Ö ×3Ø ÙbÚbÛ0ÜCÝ¦Þ ß#Û3Ø Üáà3Ý Ùbâ*Ü ã¹äOÝ å TcN}U Ð Ê TVg>Rkg@fhg>|> ¯o~K¹g>Wn^}UXW TVg¿ ºU PS _fhU

� ��������� �

� � � ����� ��� ����� ������ � �"!#� �%$ ��& !('*) ���+!,�-$.$ / & � &0� $

132546287:9<;>=@?0ACBEDF;>GH?I9JLKMONQPSRQTVUXWZY\[]P>K_^`baEU\YcPdaeTcNQPST0R_fhg>TcYig>jkYVTVgmlnNQP>YVTcoplrqsRQWcgmltUuYcYvYcP>wxRyfhUERyPSTcNQYlXP>KzYc{}|>|>UuYVT\YVTVgmlnN_P>YVTco~lrqsRQWcgmltUuYcYOf~o~w�ohTcYX�<��gda�a]U�aOP>K�TETVg�^}Ut�yK}U�RQWcUulXo~YcUufh��a�NQPSTa]U�wxUuP>K��F�zTcN}g@YVU�YVTVgmlnN_P>YVTco~lrqsRQWcgmltUuYcY�f~o~wohTcYu��I�}����S���������n���p���s���������Q���L�����r�s�u X�F�¡�r�¢�� ¤£y¥L�d Z�r�Z�x�S���z¥L�>�y�@�S�¦�r§m�y u�¢���S�y¨©�ohTcN�TcNQPST�wo~KQ^QYcUXTXªmltg@K�«>UXWc|>UuKQltU�g>j3PYVUu¬F{}UuKQltU�g>j3YVTVgmlnNQP>YVTcopl¤RQWcgmltUuYcYVUuY­K_PSTc{mqWnP>fpfh��kUultg@wxUuY�ltg@K�«>UXWc|>UuKQltU�g>j3PYVUu¬F{}UuKQltU¤g>j3RQWcg>�_PS�yo~f~ohT5�wxUuP>Yc{}WcUuY­g@K®Pxj¢{QKQlrqTcohg@K¯YVR_P>ltU*°¢YVRyP>ltUg>jOj�{QK_ltTcohg@KQYZ±Z�²­NQUXWcUxTcN}UuK�WcUuw�P>o~K�TcN}WcUXU�RQWcg>�_fhUuw�YX³¤´io~WnYVTXªa�N_PST­YcN}g@{Qf~^za]U�wxUuP>K��F��TcNQU�ltg@K�«>UXWc|>UuK_ltU�g>j3PYVUu¬F{}UuKQltU¤g>jiRQWcg>�_PS�_opf~ohTH��wxUuP¡qYc{QWcUuY3g@K�P>KPS�yYVTVWnP>ltTCYVRyP>ltU:µ*¶FUultg@K_^6ª@a�NQPSTEYcN}g@{Qf~^��kU\TcN}U­{QK_^}UXWnfh�mo~K}|bj�{_KQltTcohg@KYVRyP>ltU·ltg@K�TcP>o~KQo~K}|�TcN}U�YcP>wxR_fhU�R_PSTcNQY�g>j0TcN}U·YVTVgmlnN_P>YVTco~l·RQWcgmltUuYcYVUuYZµ¹¸bKQ^6ª_TcN_ohWn^6ªa�N_PSTvYcN}g@{Qf~^��kU\TcN}U­TVg>Rkg@fhg>|>��°¢K}g>Tcohg@K�g>jºltg@K�«>UXWc|>UuKQltU:±Co~K�TcN}U�{QKQ^}UXWnf~�Fo~KQ|�j¢{QKQlrqTcohg@K»YVR_P>ltU:µ©�UYcTcPSWcT¤o~K¼¶FUultTcohg@K�½F�¾`z���¿^}Ut�yKQopK}|�TcN}UxYVTcP>K_^QPSWn^ÀK}g>Tcohg@K¿g>jEltg@K�«>UXWc|>UuKQltUj�g>W�PÀYVUu¬F{}UuKQltUzg>j­RQWng>�_PS�_o~f~o~TH�ÀwxUuP>Yc{}WcUuY�g@KÁP*wUXTVWno~lzYVR_P>ltU>�¿©�U�P>fpYVg¿^QUt�yK}UTcN}U·ÂvWcg@N}g>Wngd«�wxUXTVWno~l�g@K®TcN}U�YcR_P>ltU�g>jvP>f~fkRQWng>�_PS�_o~f~o~TH��wUuP>Yc{}WcUuY�g@K®TcN}U�wUXTVWno~lYVRyP>ltU>ªQa�NQo~lZN�o~KQ^Q{_ltUuYOTcNQPST�ltg@K�«>UXWc|>UuKQltU>�JLK�¶FUultTcohg@K�½F�¾½zaEU�^Qo~YnlX{QYcY�TcN}U·j¢{QKQltTco~g@K*YVRyP>ltU�ÃÄTcNQPSTÅaEU�a�o~f~f<{QYVU�TVg�WcUXR}qWcUuYcUuK�T�TcN}U�YcR_P>ltU�g>j�Rºg@YnYcoh�_fhUYnP>wxR_fhURyPSTcNQY�g>j�TcN}U�YVTVgmlnN_P>YVTco~lzRQWcgmltUuYcYVUuYX�»©�U^}Ut�ºK}U�THa]g�^QoÇÆkUXWcUuK�T�wxUXTVWnoplXY�g@K*TcN}U�j�{QK_ltTcohg@KQY�YcR_P>ltU�Ã*³�ÈÅK}U�o~Y�TcNQU·YVTcP>KQ^_PSWn^É}ÊCwxUXTVWZo~lSª�a�N_o~lnNxo~K_^Q{QltUuY3TcN}U˶mÌ>g>Wcg@N}gm^»°L[uÍ>Î>Ï@±OÉ}ÊvTVg>Rkg@fhg>|>�>�v²�N}U\g>TcN}UXWEopY3TcN}UÐ Ê wxUXTVWno~lSª>a�N_o~lnN�o~KQ^_{QltUuYiTcN}U�¶FÌ>g>Wcg@N}gm^®°L[uÍ>Î>Ï@±0Ð Ê TVg>Rºg@f~g>|>�>�3²�N}U\ltg@wwxg@KQfh�{QYcUu^ÑÉ Ê TVg>Rkg@fhg>|>��o~YÅg>j�TVUuK¯WcUXj�UXWcWcUu^�TVg¿P>Y®ÒLTcN}U�¶mÌ>g>Wcg@N}gm^ÀTVg>Rºg@f~g>|>�>�ÔÓÕ©�Uz{QYVU

Í>½

Page 2: Í¡Ö - Columbia Universityww2040/framechno.pdfÍ¡Ö ×3Ø ÙbÚbÛ0ÜCÝ¦Þ ß#Û3Ø Üáà3Ý Ùbâ*Ü ã¹äOÝ å TcN}U Ð Ê TVg>Rkg@fhg>|> ¯o~K¹g>Wn^}UXW TVg¿ ºU PS _fhU

Í¡Ö ×3Ø�ÙbÚbÛ0ÜCݦÞ�ß#Û3Ø�Üáà3Ý�Ùbâ*Ü�ã¹äOÝ�åTcN}U�Ð Ê TVg>Rkg@fhg>|>�¯o~K¹g>Wn^}UXW�TVg¿�ºU�PS�_fhU�TVgÀUuYVTcPS�_f~o~YnN¯YVTVgmlnNQP>YcTco~lrqsRQWcgmltUuYcYxf~o~w�ohTcYa�ohTcN�{QK_wPSTclnN}Uu^�æV{QwR_Y\o~K�TcN}U�fpo~wohT]RQWcgmltUuYcYX�JLK�¶FUultTco~g@K�½F�çÖÅa]U]YcTcPSTVU]TcNQWcUXUE«>UXWZYcohg@KQY<g>j}TcN}UOltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QYVqHwPSRQR_o~KQ|­TcN}UXg>WcUuwTcNQPST<Yn{}RQRkg>WcT6TcN}UCltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QYLqHw�PSRQR_o~K}|­PSR_RQWcg@P>lnN·j�g>WIg>�QTcP>o~K_o~K}|­K}UXaÁYVTVgFlZNQP>YVTco~lrqRQWcgmltUuYcYÅf~o~wo~TcY­j�Wcg@wèUuYcTcPS�_f~o~YcNQUu^*YVTVgmlnN_P>YVTco~lrqsRQWcgmltUuYcY¤f~opwohTcYX��JéK�¶FUultTcohg@K�½F�¾Î�aEUo~K�TVWcgF^_{QltUv{QYVUXj¢{Qf¡j�{_KQltTcohg@KQY6wPSR_R_o~K}|\Ã(g>WITcN}UvR_WcgF^_{QltT6YVR_P>ltUCÃÁêvÃëo~K�TVg­ÃìTcNQPSTRQWcUuYVUXWn«>U·ltg@K�«>UXWc|>UuKQltU�P>KQ^®TcNF{QY­j¢P>lXo~f~o~TcPSTVU�TcN}U·ltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QYLqHw�PSRQR_o~K}|xPSRQR_Wcg@P>lnN6�©�U·ltg@KQlXfp{Q^}U¤o~K*¶FUultTco~g@K»½F�¾Ï��F�z^}UuYnltWnoh�_o~KQ|�TcNQU¤g>Wc|@P>KQohíuPSTcohg@K»g>j<TcNQU��kg�g>̺�²­NQopYClnN_PSRQTVUXW­o~YCopK�TVUuKQ^QUu^�TVg��kU��QWno~UXj5ª�RQWcgd«mo~^QopK}|��_P>lnÌ�|>Wcg@{_KQ^zj�g>W]TcN}UÅo~K�TVWngSq^Q{QltTVg>Wc��lnNQPSR_TVUXWnYX�0©�U\Uuf~PS�kg>WnPSTVU­o~K�M\NQPSRQTVUXW\[>[­P>KQ^�WcUXj�UXW0TVg�îOo~f~f~opK}|@YcfhUX��°L[uÍ>Ï>ïFª[uÍ>Í>Í@±\j�g>W�wxg>WnU�^}UXTcP>o~f~YX�132�ð32òñ�óCôeõ3öC÷6DmôÑøÈÅ{}W<|>g@P>f�opYùTVg�R_WcUulXo~YVUufh�Å^}Ut�yKQUva�NQPST<aEU]wxUuP>K��F��P �t�s�u t�F�S�r�¢�� Xúp£y¥L�d Z�r�Z�­ûü������� ªo��çU>�hª6TcN}Uxltg@K�«>UXWc|>UuKQltU�g>j]P�YVUu¬�{QUuKQltUxg>jEYVTVgmlnN_P>YVTco~l�RQWcgmltUuYcYVUuYX�·©�U{QYVU�wxUXTVWno~lXYj�g>W¤TcN_PST¤R_{}WcRkg@YVU>��©�U�^}Ut�yK}UxP�wxUXTVWno~l�g@K¼P�YVRyP>ltUxg>j]YVTVgmlnN_P>YVTco~l�RQWcgmltUuYcYVUuY¤opKTHa]g�YVTVUXR_YX³�´3ohWZYVTXª3aEU�^}Ut�yK}UzP*wUXTVWno~lg@KÁTcN}U�YVR_P>ltUzg>j­RQWng>�_PS�_o~f~o~TH�ÀwxUuP>Yc{}WcUuYg@K�P�|>UuK}UXWZP>fºwUXTVWno~l�YcR_P>ltUbP>K_^6ªFYcUultg@KQ^6ªmaEUÅ^}Ut�yKQU�P�wxUXTVWno~l�g@K�TcNQUb{QK_^}UXWnfh�mo~K}|j�{_KQltTcohg@K�YVR_P>ltU·ltg@K�TcP>o~K_o~K}|xTcN}U�YnP>wxR_fhUÅR_PSTcNQY­g>jiTcNQU�YVTVgFlZNQP>YVTco~l�RQWcgmltUuYcYVUuYX�¸ ���X�¢¥r�¢  o~Y­P�^Qo~YVTcP>K_ltU�j�{_KQltTcohg@K�YcPSTco~Ycj��mo~K}|ltUXWcTcP>opK»P¡ý}ohg@wYX�]JéK®R_PSWcTco~lX{QfpPSWuªPwxUXTVWnoplÅþ8g@K®PYVUXTbÿ�o~Y­PK}g@K_K}UX|@PSTcoh«>U�WcUuP>fhqs«¡P>f~{QUu^�j�{QK_ltTcohg@K�g@K®TcN}U¤R_WcgF^_{QltTYVR_P>ltUÿeêÀÿ�����°��>Ê����d±�³��>Ê �¹ÿ������¹ÿ��xYc{QlZN»TcN_PSTbþ¯°������}±����zohjvP>KQ^*g@KQfh�ohj������ºªQYcPSTco~YVj��mo~K}|�TcN}U ���¡�����X�¢¥���£y¥L�r£}�t¥t���

þ¯°�� ���Q±!�Ëþ¯°��"���k±"j�g>W�P>f~f#�������¿ÿP>KQ^�TcN}U �¢¥Z���S�%$@ûh�·���º�'&u§Q�Sûü�¢���

þ¯°�� �'(�±*)eþ¯°�� ���Q±,+¹þ¯°��"�'(�±+j�g>W�P>fpf-� ���"�'(.�*ÿ0/¸ �X��&X§_�t�º Z� o~K¯P*YVUXTÿ o~Y·P®j¢{QKQltTcohg@K¹wPSRQR_opK}|�TcN}UzRºg@YnohTcoh«>U�o~K�TVUX|>UXWnY�o~K�TVgÿ]�\¸¦YVUu¬F{}UuKQltU1���32�³5476#[8��o~K®P�wUXTVWno~l�YcR_P>ltUz°sÿ��Vþ*±  n�S�:9S�t¥�$��t� TVgzP�f~o~wohT��o~K¼ÿËohjéª6j�g>W�P>f~f<;>=?�mªITcN}UXWcU�UtýmopYVTcY¤P>K�o~K�TVUX|>UXW@4,A·Yn{QlnNÀTcNQPST¤þ¯°�� 2 ���6±CBD;Åj�g>WP>f~f�4E6F4 A �¤J5jCaEUx{QYVU�TcN}UxwxUXTVWnopl�g@KQf~�®TVg�YVRkUulXohj���a�NQo~lnNÀYVUu¬F{}UuKQltUuY¤ltg@K�«>UXWc|>U>ªTcN}UuK�aEUÅlnNQPSWZP>ltTVUXWnohíXUÅTcN}U�TVg>Rkg@fhg>|>��o~KQ^Q{QltUu^���xTcN}UÅwxUXTVWnoplS³iJLK�P�wxUXTVWnopl�YVR_P>ltU>ªTcN}U»TVg>Rkg@fhg>|>�eopYP¯YVRkUulXoÇ�ºlXPSTcohg@K�g>j¤a�NQoplnNeYVUu¬F{}UuKQltUuY�ltg@K�«>UXWn|>U>�ì²Ig>Rkg@fhg>|>�eopYTcN}U»wxg>WnU»|>UuK}UXWnP>f�ltg@KQltUXRQTXª\�kUulXP>{QYVU*^QoÇÆkUXWcUuK�T�wxUXTVWno~lXYlXP>KËo~KQ^_{QltU�TcN}U»YcP>wxUTVg>Rkg@fhg>|>�>�E´}g>W�j�{QWcTcN}UXW­^Qo~YnlX{QYcYcohg@K�PS�kg@{}T\TVg>Rkg@fhg>|@ohUuYuªQYVUXU�¶FUultTcohg@K¯[>[S�¾`F�¸bY�P¹WcUX|@{Qf~PSWZohTH��ltg@KQ^Qo~Tcohg@K6ªOaEUÀP>YcYc{_wxU»TcNQPSTzTcN}U¿wxUXTVWno~l*YVR_P>ltU�°sÿ��Vþ*±opY�X�é£m�S¥V�5Gtû~� ªka�NQoplnN»wUuP>KQY­TcNQPST�TcN}UXWcU�o~Y­P�ltg@{_K�TcPS�_f~U·^}UuKQYcU�Yc{}�_YcUXTIHyo��çU>�hªyTcN}UXWcU·opY

Page 3: Í¡Ö - Columbia Universityww2040/framechno.pdfÍ¡Ö ×3Ø ÙbÚbÛ0ÜCÝ¦Þ ß#Û3Ø Üáà3Ý Ùbâ*Ü ã¹äOÝ å TcN}U Ð Ê TVg>Rkg@fhg>|> ¯o~K¹g>Wn^}UXW TVg¿ ºU PS _fhU

Þ�ßKJmßëÛ3Ø�ÜMLmÚkÙ�×3Ü�N Í>ÎP·ltg@{QK�TcPS�yfh�o~Km�yK_ohTVU�°�g>W]�yKQohTVU:±3Yn{}�_YVUXT\ÿ A g>j<ÿ¯Yc{QlnN�TcNQPSTXªmj�g>W]P>f~f:�O�¿ÿ¯P>KQ^zP>f~f;P=Q�mªQTcN}UXWcU¤Utý}o~YVTcYP�R�*ÿSA¤Yc{QlnN®TcNQPST­þ¯°�� ���Q±TBU;u�©�UÀ�yWnYVT�ltg@KQYco~^QUXWzR_Wcg>�_PS�_o~fpohTH�ewxUuP>Yn{}WcUuY�g@K�PÑ|>UuK}UXWZP>f¤YVUXR_PSWnPS�_f~UÀwUXTVWno~lYVRyP>ltU¹°sÿ��Vþ*±Z�.JLK�g@{}W�PSRQR_f~o~lXPSTco~g@KQYXªCTcNQU»{QKQ^}UXWZfh�FopK}|*wxUXTVWZo~l�YVR_P>ltU�ÿ#a�o~f~f]�kUTcN}U�j¢{QKQltTcohg@KÑYVRyP>ltU�Ã*ªv�_{QT�K}g:a�ÿ#lXP>K��kUzP>K��¹KQg@K}UuwxRQT5�¹YVUXTX�Á²Ig¼ltg@KQYno~^}UXWRQWng>�_PS�_o~f~o~TH��wxUuP>Yc{}WcUuYEg@K�°sÿ��Vþ*±ZªmaEUÅwPSÌ>U�ÿ¹P ���n�¡�Z§m¥V�5Gtû~���s£m�@ r� �F�xUuKQ^}gda�o~K}|ohT�a�ohTcN®PRVºq��_Uuf~^�g>jvwUuP>Yc{}WnPS�_f~U�YVUXTcY�°¢^Qo~YclX{QYnYVUu^®j¢{}WcTcN}UXW�o~K*¶FUultTcohg@KÁ[>[S�¾½@±Z��´Qg>WTcN}U*YVUXR_PSWnPS�_f~U»wxUXTVWno~l»YVR_P>ltUÁ°sÿW�Vþ*±Zª­aEU¿P>fhaOPu�mY�{QYcU®TcN}UYX �S¥c�tû V ú[Z]�XûÇ�]\ °sÿv±Zªa�N_o~lnN�o~YOTcNQU�YcwP>f~f~UuYVT*Vºq��_Uuf~^®ltg@K�TcP>o~KQo~KQ|xTcN}U �Z£}�X�7Gc�Sû�û¾�

^`_·°�� ��a�±!�����R�ÀÿÁ³>þ¯°�� ���Q±TB�ab�c/²­NQU\UufhUuwxUuK�TcYCg>j \ °sÿv±3PSWcUblXP>f~fhUu^wxUuP>Yn{}WnPS�_fhU�YVUXTcYX�3©�UbwUuK�Tcohg@K�wxUuP>Yc{}WnPS�yo~f~ohT5�P>KQ^EVºq��yUuf~^QY��kUulXP>{QYVU>ª]o~KÁ|>UuK}UXWnP>f�ªOohTxo~YxK}g>TxRkg@YcYco~�_fhU�TVg¹^}Ut�yK}U�PÀRQWcg>�yPS�_o~f~ohT5�wxUuP>Yn{}WcU°¢YcPSTco~YVj��mo~K}|�TcN}U�P¡ýmo~g@wYOg>j<P�RQWng>�_PS�_o~f~o~TH�wxUuP>Yc{QWcU:±Cg@K®P>f~fkYc{}�_YcUXTcYIH}YVUXURù�C`>½>½g>jiîOo~fpf~o~K}|@Ycf~UX�»°L[uÍ>Ï>ï@±Z�©�U�YcPd�®TcNQPSTÅP�YVUu¬F{}UuKQltU�g>j0RQWcg>�_PS�yo~f~ohT5�zwxUuP>Yn{}WcUuY��ed 2®³b4f6ë[8��g@KÑ°sÿ��Vþ*± Z�S��9S�X¥�$F�r�hgE�c�S�:ûi� g>W¤æV{QYcT  Z�S��9>�t¥�$��r� TVg¼PÀRQWcg>�_PS�yo~f~ohT5�¼wxUuP>Yc{}WcUjd g@K °sÿW�Vþ*±ZªP>KQ^®aEU¤a­WZohTVU@d 21k-dxªQo~j

f~o~w2ml�nporqPsut d�2v� o�qPsut d °�`F�~[d±j�g>W­P>f~fkj¢{QKQltTcohg@KQY s o~Kjw�°sÿv±ZªQTcN}U�YVRyP>ltU¤g>jiP>f~f6ltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QY\�kg@{QK_^}Uu^�WnUuP>fÇqs«¡P>fp{}Uu^j¢{QKQltTcohg@K_Y�g@K¯ÿO�·²­N}UxwxUXTVWZo~l�þ%UuK�TVUXWnY¤o~K¿�F�*^}UXTVUXWZwo~KQo~KQ|�a�N_o~lnN*j�{_KQltTcohg@KQY sg@K¯ÿáPSWcUltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QYX��JéTÅWcUuwP>o~K_Y�TVg�YcNQgda¦TcNQPST¤TcNQopY�o~YÅP�|>gFgF^À^}Ut�ºKQohTcohg@KSHka]U^QopYclX{QYcY]TcNQPST­Rkg@o~K�T\j¢{}WcTcN}UXW­o~K»¶mUultTcohg@K¼[>[S�¾½F�©�U¤K}g:a�^}Ut�yK}U�TcN}UCx ¥L�S�F�S¥V�m9x���X�¢¥r�¢  g@KzTcN}UÅYVR_P>ltU N���N�°sÿC±vg>j<P>f~f_R_Wcg>�_P¡q�_opf~ohTH�xwxUuP>Yn{}WcUuY]g@KzTcN}UbwUXTVWno~lbYVR_P>ltU°sÿ��Vþ*±yH}TcN}UÅwxUXTVWno~l�aOP>YEg>Wn|@o~KQP>f~fh�^QUt�yK}Uu^�F�¼ÂvWcg@NQg>Wcgd«.°L[uÍ>Î>Ï@±yHOYVUXU�zb{_^QfhUX�e°L[uÍ>Ï>ï@±�P>KQ^¯îOo~fpf~o~K}|@Ycf~UX�Á°L[uÍ>Í>Í@±Z�|{ùUXT~}��Å�kUTcN}U �r£}�t� ; ú5�º�X��$>�rGc�>¥n�F�d�u� g>jW}·ª_o��çU>�hª

} � �?���R�¿ÿÁ³@þ¯°������}±�BU; j�g>W�YVg@wU �O�O}��./´}g>W`d Ê ª�d �jN�°sÿv±ZªyTcN}U~x ¥L�¡�m�S¥L��9����X�¢¥r�¢  o~Y\^}Ut�ºK}Uu^����� °�d Ê �'d ±!��o~K}jy�;�=Q�x³cd Ê °�}űT)Ud °�} � ±S+�; j�g>W�P>f~f�}�� \ °sÿv±��Q/ °�`F�¾`@±¸OT��_WnYVT�|@f~P>KQltU>ªyo~T�wPd�®PSRQRkUuPSW­TcNQPST � o~K¯°�`F�¾`@±�f~P>lnÌFY�TcN}U·YV�mwwxUXTVWn�zR_Wcg>R}qUXWcT5�>ªO�_{}TohT�NQg@f~^QYX��©�U®R_Wcgd«>U*TcN}U®j�g@f~fhgda�o~K}|ÀTcN}UXg>WcUuw�o~K.¶FUultTcohg@K([S�¾`Àg>jÅTcN}UJLK�TVUXWZK}UXTb¶m{}R_R_fhUuwxUuK�TX�

Page 4: Í¡Ö - Columbia Universityww2040/framechno.pdfÍ¡Ö ×3Ø ÙbÚbÛ0ÜCÝ¦Þ ß#Û3Ø Üáà3Ý Ùbâ*Ü ã¹äOÝ å TcN}U Ð Ê TVg>Rkg@fhg>|> ¯o~K¹g>Wn^}UXW TVg¿ ºU PS _fhU

Í>Ï ×3Ø�ÙbÚbÛ0ÜCݦÞ�ß#Û3Ø�Üáà3Ý�Ùbâ*Ü�ã¹äOÝ�å�>���b�:�8�b���S���u����� °�TcN}UÁÂCWcg@N}g>Wcg:«ìwxUXTVWnopl¯g@K�N·±�� �S¥��S���Ë�u�5£m�S¥V�5GXûh�e���X�¢¥r�¢ �s£m�� Z� °sÿ��Vþ*±�� ���m�O�r§m�y u�¢���S� � �>� N�°sÿv± ��� °�`F�¾`@± �p�����X�é£m�S¥V�5Gtû~����u�¢¥Z�� d¨¿�I�m�t¥c��p� n�>��9S�X¥�$F�t�y r� � °�d�2:�'d·±���� ��� N�°sÿv± � �x�S�y�¿�S�Qûi��� � d 2jk�d�� �¡�����Zv�º�c�®���°�`F�~[d± ¨©�U®RQWZo~wPSWno~f~�¿aOP>K�TxTVg¼YVRkUulXohj��¯a�N}UuKÑa]UuPSÌÁltg@K�«>UXWc|>UuKQltUYd 2�k d8N}g@f~^_YXªTcN�{_Y�a]U�PSWcU�RQWno~wPSWZo~fh�»o~K�TVUXWcUuYVTVUu^¹o~K�TcN}U�TVg>Rkg@fhg>|>��o~KQ^Q{QltUu^¼���ÀTcN}UzÂvWcg@N}g>Wngd«wxUXTVWno~lS�ìJéKQ^QUXUu^6ª\TcN}UXWcUÀPSWcU»g>TcNQUXW�wUXTVWno~lXYzo~KQ^Q{QlXopK}|ÀTcNQo~Y�TVg>Rºg@f~g>|>�3HbU>�ç|}�hª�YVUXUzÅ{Q^QfhUX��°L[uÍ>Ï>ï@±Z�JLKQYVTVUuP>^�g>j\^QohWnUultTcfh�»WcUXj�UXWcWnopK}|�TVg®RQWcg>�_PS�yo~f~ohT5�»wxUuP>Yc{}WnUuYXªùa]Ug>j�TVUuK¹{QYVUxWnP>K}q^}g@w UufhUuwxUuK�TcYX��¸ ¥V�S�y���S�+�Xûh�X��X�_�`� g>j�°sÿ�� \ °sÿv±V±zo~Y�P °¢wxUuP>Yc{}WZPS�_fhU�H�YVUXU¶FUultTcohg@K¼[>[S�¾½@±\wPSRQR_o~KQ|·j�Wcg@w�YVg@wxU�{_KQ^}UXWnfh�mo~K}|·RQWcg>�_PS�yo~f~ohT5�YVR_P>ltU�°�� ���h�'d·±]TVg°sÿ�� \ °sÿv±V±Z�.°�JéK¹TcN}U�{QKQ^}UXWZfh�FopK}|�RQWcg>�_PS�yo~f~ohT5�¿YVRyP>ltU>ª�� o~Y�PÀYVUXTXªW��o~Y�P]Vºq��_Uufp^P>KQ^�d¦o~Y]P�RQWcg>�_PS�_opf~ohTH�xwxUuP>Yn{}WcU>�ü±�²­N}U £y¥V�5Gc�%Gt��ûü�¢����ûh�mg g>j � g>W\TcN}U £y¥L�%Gc�5GX��û ������S���r�¢¥r��GX§m�¢���S� g>j � opY\TcN}U�o~w�PS|>U�RQWcg>�_PS�yo~f~ohT5��wxUuP>Yc{}WnU�d �p� Ê o~KQ^Q{QltUu^��F� � g@K°sÿ�� \ °sÿv±V±yHyo��çU>�hª

d � � Ê °�}¤±�� d�° � � Ê °�}¤±V±��Md�°��I U�]��³ � °¡ ]±��O}@�¡±� d�° � �O}¤±+j�g>W }�� \ °sÿv±��a�N}UXWcUfd�o~Y»TcN}U¯R_Wcg>�_PS�_o~fpohTH��wxUuP>Yc{}WnU¹o~K�TcNQU¹{QKQ^QUXWnfh�mo~K}|ÑRQWcg>�_PS�yo~f~ohT5�áYVR_P>ltU°�� ���h�'d·±Z� ©�U�g>j�TVUuK�{QYcU¿WZP>KQ^}g@w UufhUuwxUuK�TcYXªb�_{}Tza�N}UuKËaEU�^}g}ªba]UÀ{_Yc{QP>f~fh�PSWcU�RQWnopwPSWno~fh�Ño~K�TVUXWcUuYVTVUu^�o~KËTcN}Uuo~WzR_Wcg>�_PS�_o~fpohTH�ef~Pda�YX�£¢�UuKQltU�TcN}U�{QK_^}UXWnfh�mo~K}|RQWcg>�_PS�yo~f~ohT5��YVR_P>ltU�°��C�����'d�±\o~YOg>j�TVUuK»fhUXj�T­{QKQYcRºUulXoh�_Uu^6�©�U�YcPu��TcNQPST·P»YVUu¬F{}UuKQltU�g>j]WZP>KQ^}g@w8UufhUuwUuK�TcY.� � 2¹³S4M6è[8�zg>j­P®wxUXTVWnoplYVR_P>ltU�°sÿ��Vþ*±  Z�S��9S�X¥�$F�r�����¯�S���r�¢¥r��GX§}�¢�¢�S� g>W  n�S��9>�t¥�$��t��gE�c�¡�¡û[� TVg�PWZP>KQ^}g@w Uuf~UtqwxUuK�T � g>jE°sÿW�Vþ*±ZªmP>K_^�a]U�a�WnohTVU � 21k � ªmo~jºTcNQUbo~w�PS|>U�RQWng>�_PS�_o~f~o~TH��wxUuP>Yc{}WcUuYltg@K�«>UXWn|>U·a]UuPSÌFf~�>ª_o��çU>�hª_ohj

d 2 � � Ê2 k-d � � Ê g@K °sÿW�Vþ*±`�{QYco~KQ|�TcN}UÅ^}Ut�yKQo~Tcohg@Ko~KÀ°�`F�~[d±Zª}a�N}UXWcU`d 2 P>K_^Rd#PSWcUÅTcN}UÅ{QKQ^}UXWZfh�FopK}|ÅRQWcg>�_PS�_opf~ohTH�wxUuP>Yc{}WnUuY]P>YnYVgFlXopPSTVUu^�a�ohTcN � 2P>KQ^ � ªmWcUuYcRºUultTco~«>Uufh�>�3J5T]j�g@fpfhgda�YEj�Wcg@w-°�`F�~[d±CTcNQPST� 2vk � ohjiP>KQ^�g@KQf~��ohj

fpo~w2ml@n�¤ s ° � 2}±<� ¤ s ° � ± j�g>W�P>f~f s �Yw°sÿC±`/ °�`F�¾½@±²­NF{QYEltg@K�«>UXWc|>UuKQltU·o~K�^_o~YVTVWnoh�y{}Tcohg@K�g>jùWnP>K_^}g@w UufhUuwxUuK�TcY]opY6æc{QYVTOP>K}g>TcN}UXWOaOPu��TVgTcP>fhÌ�PS�kg@{}TEaEUuPSÌ�ltg@K�«>UXWc|>UuKQltU¤g>jIRQWcg>�_PS�_opf~ohTH��wxUuP>Yc{QWcUuYX�0©�N}UuK�ÿ¹o~YEP�j¢{QKQltTco~g@KYVR_P>ltU>ªmYc{QlZN�P>Y]ûªFP�WnP>KQ^Qg@w,UufhUuwxUuK�TCg>jIÿ¼�kUultg@wxUuYCP ¥L�S�º�@�S� �r§m�y u�¢���S� ª�a�NQo~lZNaEU·P>f~YVglXP>f~fùP �r�s�u X�F�¡�r�¢�� �£y¥V�u r�r�n� �

Page 5: Í¡Ö - Columbia Universityww2040/framechno.pdfÍ¡Ö ×3Ø ÙbÚbÛ0ÜCÝ¦Þ ß#Û3Ø Üáà3Ý Ùbâ*Ü ã¹äOÝ å TcN}U Ð Ê TVg>Rkg@fhg>|> ¯o~K¹g>Wn^}UXW TVg¿ ºU PS _fhU

Þ�ß Þ�ßëÛ3Ø�ÜMLmÚkÙ�×3ÜQz Íc¥©�U�lXP>KÑ{QYVU�TcN}U®¶FÌ>g>Wcg@N}gm^¯WnUXRQWcUuYVUuK�TcPSTcohg@K¹TcN}UXg>WcUuw�ªvP>f~Ycg*j�Wcg@w�¶FÌ>g>Wcg@N}gm^°L[uÍ>Î>Ï@±ZªiTVg®N}UufhR�{QKQ^QUXWnYVTcP>KQ^¿TcN}UxTVg>Rkg@fhg>|>�¿g>jCa]UuPSÌ�ltg@K�«>UXWc|>UuK_ltU�o~KYN�°sÿv±Z�¸bY

�kUXj�g>WcU>ªP¦�ëwxUuP>KQY­Uu¬�{QP>fIo~K�^Qo~YVTVWZoh�_{}Tcohg@Kù��~� �b�:�8�r�§�S���S�¨�S� °s¶FÌ>g>Wcg@N}gm^xWcUXR_WcUuYVUuK�TcPSTcohg@KTcN}UXg>WnUuw�±�© �!� 2 k �����®�·�X�é£m�Sú¥V�5Gtû~����u�¢¥Z�� ��s£m�@ r� °sÿW�Vþ*±�� ���m�t�¿���m�t¥c�·��ª>���r�v�>���}�t¥¤¥V�S�y�@�S�8�tû~�t���t�y���Å�L� °sÿ��Vþ*±��«� 2 ��476¦[8� �S�y� «� � ����Zv�º�n�®�S�¹�� Z�S���x�>�¯§m�y���X¥Zûi�S���%$�£y¥V�5Gc�5GX��û �¢�����s£m�@ r� � �Z§Q X����F�@� «� 2 ¦� � 2"��4|6ì[m� «� ¦� ��S�º� d�°if~o~w2�l@n «� 21� «� ±!�¦[./²�N}U�¶FÌ>g>Wng@N}gF^¿WcUXR_WcUuYVUuK�TcPSTcohg@K¿TcN}UXg>WcUuw o~Yb{QYVUXj¢{Qfù�kUulXP>{QYVU�ohTbfhUXTcYÅ{QY�WnUuf~PSTVUTcN}U�YVTVWn{_ltTc{}WcUzg>j­TcN}U�YVR_P>ltUzg>j�RQWng>�_PS�_o~f~o~TH��wxUuP>Yc{}WnUuY�°�Nv� � ±·TVgÀTcN}U�YVTVWn{_ltTc{}WcUg>j�TcN}U¼{QKQ^QUXWnfh�mo~K}|¹wUXTVWno~lÀYVR_P>ltUá°sÿW�Vþ*±Z� JéT®P>f~YVgeYcUXWc«>UuY»P>Y®PÑ�yP>Yco~Y�j�g>W�TcN}Ultg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QYLqHwPSR_R_o~K}|ÀPSRQRQWcg@P>lZNSH­YVUXU*¶FUultTco~g@K.½F�çÖ¼�kUufhgda��¹©�U®R_Wcgd«>U®TcNQU*¶FÌ>gSqWcg@NQgF^.WcUXRQWcUuYVUuK�TcPSTcohg@KËTcN}UXg>WcUuw o~K�¶FUultTcohg@K#[S�¾½¼g>j�TcN}U»JLK�TVUXWZK}UXT�¶}{}RQR_fhUuwUuK�TX�

132�132Äñ�óCôáõiöC÷6Dmô�¬©�U¤K}g:aËltg@K_Yco~^}UXW]TcN}UÅ{QKQ^}UXWnf~�Fo~KQ|bj¢{QKQltTco~g@K�YVRyP>ltU�g>jùRkg@YcYnoh�_fhU­YcP>wR_fhU�RyPSTcNQYj�g>W­TcN}U�YcTVgFlZNQP>YVTco~l¤R_WcgFltUuYnYVUuYX�]¶mopKQltU¤aEU�a]P>K�T­TVg�ltg@K_Yco~^}UXW­YVTVgmlnN_P>YVTco~l�R_WcgFltUuYnYVUuYa�o~TcNe^Qo~Ycltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QYXªE�_{}T�KQg>TTVg�gÁohWcWcUX|@{_f~PSWuªEYnP>wxR_fhU®RyPSTcNQYXª]aEU¿ltg@KQYco~^}UXW�TcN}UYVRyP>ltU·Ã g>jvP>f~fIWnoh|@N�TLqHltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QY�­!®@qs«SP>f~{}Uu^*j¢{QKQltTcohg@KQY­a�ohTcN»f~UXj�T�fpo~wohTcY­^QUt�yK}Uu^g@K�P�Yc{}�yo~K�TVUXWn«¡P>f�¯�g>j�TcN}UÀWcUuP>f¤fpo~K}U>ª­{QYc{_P>f~fh��UuohTcN}UXWp° �r�u[�±�g>W�­�²-�§° �r�y³.±yHYVUXU�¶FUultTcohg@Ke[u`F�¾`»j�g>W·P>^Q^Qo~Tcohg@KQP>f0^}UXTcP>o~fpYX��©�UzWcUXj�UXW�TVg®TcN}UzYVR_P>ltUzP>Y�ÃÀ°�¯���­!®Q±ZªÃÀ°�° �r�u[�±´��­ ® ±Eg>W­Ã¿°�° �r�y³.±y��­ ® ±ZªQ^}UXRkUuKQ^Qo~K}|�{}Rkg@K�TcNQU¤j�{QK_ltTcohg@K�^Qg@wP>o~K6ªmg>Wiæc{QYVTÃ(a�N}UuK¤TcNQUCj¢{QKQltTcohg@K¤^}g@w�P>o~K�P>KQ^�WnP>K}|>UCPSWcUElXfhUuPSWIj�Wcg@w TcNQUCltg@K�TVUtýmTX�0²­N}UCYcR_P>ltUÃ�o~Y]P>f~YVg�ÌmK}gda�K�P>Y]TcN}UÅYVR_P>ltUÅg>j  Z�@�mûh��$ g>W  Wµ�@�}ûeµ��$ j�{QK_ltTcohg@KQYW¶P>K�P>ltWcg@K��Fw�j�g>WTcN}U�´QWcUuKQlnN  n�S�y�¢���Q§·µ���S¥V�S���H� � û �����¢�H�r��µ�~$��S§Q X�m� �²�N}U¿YcR_P>ltU�à o~KQlXf~{_^}UuY�P>f~fÅltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QYzj�{_KQltTcohg@KQYzP>KQ^ËTcN}UÀ^Qo~Ycltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QYj¢{QKQltTcohg@K_Yvg>jIo~K�TVUXWcUuYVTXªm�_{QTENQP>Y]{QYVUXj¢{QfyWcUX|@{Qf~PSWno~TH�xRQWcg>RkUXWcTco~UuYvj¢P>lXo~f~ohTcPSTco~KQ|�TcN}UÅ^}Utq«>Uufhg>RywxUuK�TIg>jFP­YnPSTco~YVj¢P>ltTVg>Wc�ÅTcN}UXg>Wc�>�W{ùUXT�w°�¯:��­!®Q±Zª�w�°�° �r�u[�±´��­�®}±kP>KQ^>w�°�° �r�y³e±y��­�®}±Zªg>W3æc{QYVT�wxªQ^}UuK}g>TVU�TcNQU�ltg>WcWcUuYVRkg@KQ^QopK}|xYc{}�_YVUXTcYOg>j0ltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QY\j¢{QKQltTcohg@K_YX�©�UbYVTcPSWcTv�F��ltg@KQYco~^}UXWZo~K}|¤Ã¿°�° �r�u[�±´��­\±Zªºos�çU>�hª��F��P>YcYn{Qwo~K}|ÅTcNQPSTCTcN}U�^}g@wP>opKxo~YTcN}U¤{QK_ohT]opK�TVUXWc«SP>f!° �r�u[�±<P>KQ^�TcNQU¤WnP>K}|>U�o~YT­\��¸�UulXP>f~fkTcNQPST\TcN}U�YVRyP>ltU�ÿ°�° �r�u[�±´��­\±aOP>Y�PSRQRQWng>RQWno~PSTVU�j�g>W�TcN}UYVTVgmlnNQP>YcTco~lrqsRQWcgmltUuYcY�fpo~wohTcYÅYc{}|>|>UuYcTVUu^����¿TcN}UxR_f~g>TcY�o~K

Page 6: Í¡Ö - Columbia Universityww2040/framechno.pdfÍ¡Ö ×3Ø ÙbÚbÛ0ÜCÝ¦Þ ß#Û3Ø Üáà3Ý Ùbâ*Ü ã¹äOÝ å TcN}U Ð Ê TVg>Rkg@fhg>|> ¯o~K¹g>Wn^}UXW TVg¿ ºU PS _fhU

Í>ï ×3Ø�ÙbÚbÛ0ÜCݦÞ�ß#Û3Ø�Üáà3Ý�Ùbâ*Ü�ã¹äOÝ�åMONQPSRQTVUXWÅ[S�C²­NQU�WcUXj�UXWcUuKQltUÅwxUXTVWno~l�o~YETcN}U §m�Q� �X�S¥Z�����u�¢¥Z�� >¹ � Ê,º � ¹ ªm^QUt�yK}Uu^�opKTVUXWnwY\g>j3TcN}U §F�_� �X�S¥r�è�y�S¥r�

¹ � ¹ � Yc{QRA�»�¼�»6Ê �b½ �3°�¾V±I½¿��/ °�½F�~[d±ÈÅK�TcN}U�Yn{}�_YVR_P>ltUCwìTcN}Ub{_KQohj�g>Wnw,wxUXTVWnopl­a]g>WcÌFYEa]Uuf~f�ªF�_{}TCohT]^}gFUuY �y�@� g@KzÃ*³©ËNQUuK¹j¢{QKQltTco~g@KQY�NQPd«>U�^Qo~Ycltg@K�Tco~KF{QohTcohUuYXª<aEU�^}gÀK}g>T�aOP>K�T�TVgÀo~KQYno~YVT�TcNQPST�ltg>WcWcUtqYVRkg@KQ^Qo~KQ|0æc{QwxR_YigmlXlX{}W0UtýmP>ltTcf~��PST0TcN}U­YnP>wxU\Tco~wxUuY0o~K�g>Wn^QUXW0j�g>W0TcN}UOj¢{QKQltTcohg@K_Y<TVg�kU·lXfhg@YVU>�Ÿ�RQRQWcg>RQWZo~PSTVU�TVg>Rkg@fhg>|@ohUuY�aEUXWnU�o~K�TVWcgm^Q{QltUu^»���¿¶mÌ>g>Wcg@N}gm^Á°L[uÍ>Î>Ï@±Z�¤´}g>WP®ltUufhUX�QWZPSTcohg@KÀg>j�¶FÌ>g>Wcg@N}gm^SÀÔY¤o~wxR_WcUuYcYcoh«>Uxltg@K�TVWnoh�_{QTcohg@KQYbTVg®RQWcg>�yPS�_o~f~ohT5�®TcN}UXg>Wc�>ªYVUXU�Á¤g>Wng@fh�F{QÌyªQÂig>WcTVUuK}Ì>gzP>KQ^»¶F�FTcP»°�`m������±Z�²<gÀ^QUt�yK}U�TcNQU��_WZYVT·wxUXTVWZo~l�g@KÑÃ*ª0fhUXT~Â,�ºUzTcN}U�YVUXT�g>j�YVTVWno~ltTcf~�¼o~KQltWcUuP>YcopK}|j�{_KQltTcohg@KQY ÿwPSRQR_o~KQ|TcN}U·^Qg@wP>o~K7° �r�u[�±0g@K�TVg�ohTcYVUufhjéª_Yc{QlZN»TcN_PST��kg>TcN|ÿP>KQ^*o~TcYo~K�«>UXWnYVU à � Ê PSWnU�ltg@K�Tco~K�{Qg@{QYX�<{ùUXT*Ä��ºU�TcN}U �����X�_�¢�����x��Z£ g@K�° �r�u[�±sªQo��çU>�hªÅÄ�°�¾c±!��¾rª�v)�¾T)ì[S�C²­NQUuK�TcN}U�YVTcP>KQ^_PSWn^¿É Ê wxUXTVWnoplÅg@K®ÃÆ��ÿ°�° �r�u[�±´��­\±¤o~Y

trÇIÈ °�� Ê ��� ±!��o~K}jÉmÊ8Ë � ¹ � Ê�Ì Ã º � ¹WÍf¹ à º Ä ¹ �Î� °�½F�¾`@±a�N}UXWcU@Ï ÍhÐ �ËþjÏ%�,�eÏ3� Ð �@��I�m�`$��X�º�t¥V�Sû6�����c�����R$��S���b$­�r¥L�>�����m��§m�Q� �t�S¥r� ���X�¢¥r�� 1¹WÑ%¹��s�����m� É Ê ���X�¢¥r�¢ tbÇ�È ���·�s�z�X�m�b�Z§m�y d�¢�¢�S�Q���S¥c� Xûh�¡�u��� �����m�Ò���S¥c��§m�Q� �t�>¥Z��ûi�� uûÇ�¡�u��m9>�t¥ ° �r�u[�± �L�r�H�X¥�Sû�ûÇ�mg0���%$z�r��Sû�ûQ£}�t¥t�¢§m¥IGn�>�¢���S�}���V���¢����� ° ���m�]�r§m�y u�¢���S�¼�S¥�$>§m���t�_� ±Z�]´}g>W�Utý}P>wxR_f~U>ªt Ç�È °�� 2 ���k±!�-�xP>YP4]��³Ëª}a�NQopfhU ¹ � 2 º � ¹ 6ì[Åj�g>W­P>f~f"40ªQo~K�ÃÀ°�° �r�u[�±´��­O±ba�NQUuK���M¯mÓ �Ô È�Õ Ê�Ö P>KQ^��:21�¦°L[�+×4 � Ê ±Ø¯mÓ �Ô È ²"2 Ô È�Õ Ê�Ö ª�4�6á½F�JLK�TcN}U�UtýmP>wR_fhU�PS�kgd«>U>ª}TcNQU�f~o~w�ohT0j�{_KQltTcohg@KNQP>Y]P�Yno~K}|@fhU3æc{QwxR�g>jùwPS|@KQohTc{_^}U[*PSTzTco~wxUÀ` � Ê �(²­NQU*ltg@K�«>UXWc|@o~K}|Ñj¢{QKQltTcohg@KQY�NQPu«>U�æc{QwxR_Y�g>j�YcohíXUÁ[C+Ù4 � Ê PSTTco~wxU¤` � Ê +Y4 � Ê H��kg>TcN�TcN}Ubw�PS|@KQohTc{Q^}UuY]P>KQ^zfhgmlXPSTcohg@KQYEg>jùTcN}UÅYco~K}|@fhU0æV{QwRzo~K.�:2ltg@K�«>UXWn|>U­TVg¤TcN}g@YVUOg>j_TcNQUOfpo~wohTùj¢{QKQltTco~g@K>�<�i²�NQPST0o~Y3PblZNQPSWnP>ltTVUXWnopYVTco~lORQWcg>RkUXWcT5��g>jTcN}U¤É Ê TVg>Rkg@fhg>|>�>�0JLKQ^}UXUu^ùª@j�Wng@wÕ^}Ut�yK_ohTcohg@K�°�½F�¾`@±vo~Tvj�g@fpfhgda�YvTcNQPSTXª�ohj tbÇ�È °��:23���k±!��Ào~K¹ÃÀ°�° �r�u[�±´��­O±Zª�TcN}UuKÁj�g>WxP>K��Ú¾�a�o~TcN7�7Bƾ.)8[�TcNQUXWcU�K}UultUuYcYcPSWnopfh��UtýmopYVTcY�PYVUu¬F{}UuKQltUh��¾Ø2�³u4U6�[8��Yc{_lnN�TcNQPST�¾�2]�§¾rª �:2k°�¾�2}± �Û�3°�¾V±Zª��:2k°�¾�2 º ±����3°�¾ º ±P>KQ^ �:2º°�¾Ø2m± º �:2k°�¾�2 º ±<�Ü�i°�¾c± º �3°�¾ º ±+P>Y 4]��³ÝHo��çU>�hª_TcNQUOæV{_wxR_Y­ltg@K�«>UXWc|>U>��°�JéT�Yc{rÞzltUuY­TVg�f~UXTP¾�21�ÙÃ�2º°�¾c±Zªºa�N}UXWcU ¹ ÃÅ2 º Ä ¹ �ß�P>KQ^ ¹ � 2 Ì Ã 2 º � ¹ �Û�m�ü±�²­NF{QYXªkohj!�¼N_P>Y¤P�æc{QwxRÀPST ¾Zªùos�çU>�hªko~j!�i°�¾c±~à�D�3°�¾ º ±ZªP>KQ^¯o~j��32Y�á�IªiTcN}UuK�j�g>W·P>fpf<4.Yc{rÞzlXohUuK�Tcf~�¿f~PSWn|>U1�:2Àw·{_YVT�NQPd«>U�PeÒVwPSTclZNQo~K}|æV{_wxR_Ó�PSTOYVg@wxUbTco~wxU`¾Ø2Q�v²­NQPSTOo~YXª�j�g>W\P>K��Î;*=Q�mªma]UblXP>K��yK_^14 A Yn{QlnN�TcNQPSTXªmj�g>WP>f~fu4|6�4 A ªQTcN}UXWnU�o~Y*¾Ø2�a�ohTcNÚ½ ¾Ø2 º ¾I½%BU;�P>KQ^

½Ç°��32k°�¾Ø2m± º �32º°�¾Ø2 º ±V± º °��i°�¾c± º �3°�¾ º ±V±I½rBU;S/

Page 7: Í¡Ö - Columbia Universityww2040/framechno.pdfÍ¡Ö ×3Ø ÙbÚbÛ0ÜCÝ¦Þ ß#Û3Ø Üáà3Ý Ùbâ*Ü ã¹äOÝ å TcN}U Ð Ê TVg>Rkg@fhg>|> ¯o~K¹g>Wn^}UXW TVg¿ ºU PS _fhU

Þ�ß Þ�ßëÛ3Ø�ÜMLmÚkÙ�×3ÜQz Í>Í©�U\K}UXUu^�P�^_oÇƺUXWnUuK�T<TVg>Rºg@f~g>|>��g@K·ÃÕohjmaEU]a]P>K�TiTcN}Uùæc{QwxR�o~K�Pbf~o~w�ohT6j�{_KQltTcohg@KTVgÅ�kU\{QKQwPSTclZN}Uu^xo~K·TcN}U\ltg@K�«>UXWc|@opK}|¤j�{_KQltTcohg@KQYX�i´}g>WvUtý}P>wxR_fhU>ª>a]U\aOP>K�T3TVg�P>f~fhg:altg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QY0j¢{QKQltTcohg@K_Y3TVg��kU­PSWc�_ohTVWZPSWno~fh��lXf~g@YVU­TVg·P�^Qo~Ycltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QY3j¢{QKQltTcohg@KSH�U>�ç|}�hªa]U�aOP>K�T­TVg�NQPu«>U t °��:23���k±!�#�xa�N}UuK��j�M¯ Ó Ô È Õ Ê�Ö P>KQ^

�32���4C°�¾ º ` � Ê +f4 � Ê ±Ø¯mÓ �Ô È � 2 Ô È�Õ �Ô Èãâ +E¯mÓ �Ô È�Õ Ê�Ö �P>YxYcNQgda�K�o~KÁ´3oh|@{}WcU®½F�~[S��°�©�U»o~KQlXfp{Q^}U�^Qo~R_Y�o~K¯TcNQU®P¡ýFUuY��kUulXP>{QYVU�TcN}U�Rkg@o~K�TcY` � Ê º 4 � Ê P>KQ^¿` � Ê PSWcU�K}g>TÅo~K»YnlXP>fhU>��¸bKQ^¿Yco~wo~fpPSWnfh��opK»f~PSTVUXW��_|@{}WcUuYu�ü±���g>Tco~ltU

A Ô È Ê Ô È � 2 Ô È

ä�åcæ ¼ â

¼´3oh|@{}WnU�½F�~[S³*²­N}U�ltg@K�TcopK�{}g@{_Yxj�{_KQltTcohg@KQY~�:2¹TcNQPSTa]U�a]P>K�T�ltg@K�«>UXWc|@o~K}|¯TVg�TcN}Uo~K_^Qo~lXPSTVg>W\j¢{QKQltTcohg@K��h�M¯ Ó �Ô È�Õ Ê�Ö o~K�Ã*�TcNQPST3�kg>TcN ¹ �:2 º � ¹ �ë[OP>KQ^ tbÇ È °��:2"���k±!�ë[]j�g>WvP>f~fb40ª@YVgÅTcNQPST0�kg>TcN�TcN}U­{QKQohj�g>WnwwxUXTVWZo~l¤P>KQ^�TcN}U�É Ê wUXTVWno~lÅg@K»Ã-PSWcU�TVgFg�YVTVWng@K}|}�¸bK}g>TcN}UXW3Utý}P>wxR_fhU]NQP>Y3^Qo~Ycltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QY<ltg@K�«>UXWc|@opK}|�j¢{QKQltTco~g@KQYXªS�_{}Tiltg@K�«>UXWc|@opK}|j¢{QKQltTcohg@K_Y¤o~K�a�NQoplnN�P®f~opwohTco~K}|�æc{QwxR¯o~Y¤PSR_RQWcg@P>lnNQUu^¹o~K�wg>WcUTcNQP>K¯g@K}UÅæc{QwxRù�©�ohTcN�TcN}U�YnP>wxU�f~o~w�ohT��¿PS�kgd«>U>ªyf~UXT

�:21��` � Ê ¯mÓ Ô È � 25Ô È Õ Ô È â +E¯mÓ Ô È Õ Ê�Ö �P>Y­^QUXR_o~ltTVUu^®o~K�´3oh|@{QWcU�½F�¾`F�]¸�|@P>o~K6ª ¹ �32 º � ¹ à�-��P>KQ^ tbÇ�È °��:2"���k±`à�#�o~K�Ã-P>Y4]��³��JLKzg>Wn^}UXWOTVg�UuYVTcPS�_f~opYcN�f~o~wohTcYCa�ohTcNz{QKQwPSTclZN}Uu^·æc{QwxR_Y]o~K�TcN}U¤f~o~wohTEj�{_KQltTcohg@K6ªa]U�{QYcU�TcN}UbÐ Ê wUXTVWno~lS�3©�Ub^QUt�yK}U­TcN}UbÐ Ê wxUXTVWno~l�{QYco~K}|¤TcNQU�ltg@wxR_f~UXTVUu^�|>WnPSRyNQYg>jiTcN}U�j¢{QKQltTcohg@K_YX�0´}g>W��]�»Ã¿°�° �r�u[�±´��­\±rªùTcN}U  n�S��£yû~�X�H�n�1$>¥V�Z£_� g>j��Ào~YOTcN}U·YVUXT

ç ä � ��°�(Å��¾c±��h­(êÚ° �r�u[�±<³(~�Mè �3°�¾ º ±,+�°L[ º è0±��i°�¾c±+j�g>W�YVg@wU è�� �v)Qèf)ì[8�.� °�½F�¾½@±

Page 8: Í¡Ö - Columbia Universityww2040/framechno.pdfÍ¡Ö ×3Ø ÙbÚbÛ0ÜCÝ¦Þ ß#Û3Ø Üáà3Ý Ùbâ*Ü ã¹äOÝ å TcN}U Ð Ê TVg>Rkg@fhg>|> ¯o~K¹g>Wn^}UXW TVg¿ ºU PS _fhU

[I��� ×3Ø�ÙbÚbÛ0ÜCݦÞ�ß#Û3Ø�Üáà3Ý�Ùbâ*Ü�ã¹äOÝ�å

é�ê8ë ìí

î�ï8ð¿ñ¨ò

ñé'ê8ëróTômê8ë´3oh|@{}WcU�½F�¾`F³v²­NQU\THa]gSqÇæV{QwR�^Qo~Ynltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QY3j¢{QKQltTco~g@KQYW�:2·TcNQPSTva]U­a]P>K�TEltg@K�«>UXWc|Sqo~K}|xTVgTcNQU�o~KQ^Qo~lXPSTVg>W\j¢{QKQltTco~g@Kh���M¯ Ó Ô È Õ Ê�Ö �a�N}UXWcU��3°�¾ º ±�o~Y�TcNQUÀf~UXj�T�f~o~w�ohT�g>j~�ìPSTh¾r� ²­N}U�ltg@wxRyfhUXTVUu^�|>WnPSR_N�o~Y�PÑltg@KmqK}UultTVUu^ÁYc{}�_YVUXT¤g>jOTcN}U�R_f~P>K}Uv­ ltg@K�TcP>o~K_o~K}|�TcN}Uzf~o~K}UxYVUX|@wxUuK�T\æVg@o~KQopK}|¯°��i°�¾c±y��¾V±P>KQ^¼°��i°�¾ º ±y��¾c±Ej�g>W\P>f~fk^QopYcltg@K�TcopK�{Qo~TH�Rkg@o~K�TcYT¾Z�v²<gxo~f~f~{QYcTVWnPSTVU>ªFP�j¢{QKQltTcohg@K�P>KQ^�o~TcYltg@wxR_fhUXTVUu^»|>WnPSR_N�PSWcU·^Qo~YVR_fpPu�>Uu^�o~K�´3oh|@{}WnU�½F�¾½F�

110 0

´3oh|@{}WcU�½F�¾½F³]¸ìj¢{QKQltTco~g@K�o~K®ÃÀ°�° �r�u[�±´��­O±ÅP>KQ^»ohTcY­ltg@wxR_f~UXTVUu^�|>WnPSR_N6�©�U�^QUt�yK}UOTcN}U�Ð Ê wxUXTVWno~l\{QYno~K}|ÅTcN}U­{QKQo~j�g>WnwëwxUXTVWZo~l\^}Ut�yK}Uu^�g@KR_PSWnP>wxUXTVWnoplWcUXRQWcUuYcUuK�TcPSTcohg@K_Y�g>j�TcN}U�ltg@wxR_f~UXTVUu^á|>WZPSR_NQYzg>j�TcN}UÀj¢{QKQltTcohg@K_YX�,²Ig�^}Ut�ºK}U*TcNQUR_PSWnP>wxUXTVWZo~lbWcUXRQWcUuYVUuK�TcPSTcohg@KQYuª}aEU�K}UXUu^�P>K�g>WZ^}UXW\g@K�TcN}U�ltg@wxR_f~UXTVUu^�|>WnPSR_NQYX�0©�U^}Ut�yK}U�P>K �S¥V���X¥ g@K¯TcNQU�|>WnPSR_N7ç ä �F�¼YcPu�mo~K}|»TcNQPST�°�( Ê ��¾ Ê ±v)�°�( ��¾ ±¤ohj]UuohTcN}UXW°¢o�±�¾ZÊ�B�¾�¤g>W�°¢o~o�±T¾nÊP�0¾��P>KQ^×½ �i°�¾ZÊ º ± º (>Ê8½r)�½ �i°�¾� º ± º (e5½ü�­²­NF{QY\TcNQU�g>Wn^}UXWo~Y�P¿TVg>TcP>fOg>Wn^}UXWuªCYcTcPSWcTco~K}|¿j�Wng@w TcN}U�ÒVfhUXj�T�UuKQ^QÓ¿g>j�TcN}U�ltg@wxR_fhUXTVUu^Á|>WnPSR_N�P>K_^ltg@KQlXf~{Q^_o~K}|�g@K�TcN}U»ÒLWZoh|@N�T\UuK_^QÓm�

Page 9: Í¡Ö - Columbia Universityww2040/framechno.pdfÍ¡Ö ×3Ø ÙbÚbÛ0ÜCÝ¦Þ ß#Û3Ø Üáà3Ý Ùbâ*Ü ã¹äOÝ å TcN}U Ð Ê TVg>Rkg@fhg>|> ¯o~K¹g>Wn^}UXW TVg¿ ºU PS _fhU

Þ�ß Þ�ßëÛ3Ø�ÜMLmÚkÙ�×3ÜQz [I�}[¸ £}�S¥L�>��u�¢¥Z�� �¥V�é£y¥V�t�X�X�_�s�>�¢���S� g>j0TcN}U�ltg@wR_fhUXTVUu^*|>WnPSR_NOç ä °�g>W�g>j0TcNQU�j¢{QKQlrqTcohg@KU�k±�o~Y�P¹ltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QY�K}g@KQ^}UultWnUuP>Yco~K}|¼j¢{QKQltTco~g@K#°�õ���a@±�wPSRQRyo~K}|U° �r�u[�±¤g@K�TVgç ä ªia�ohTcN�õÁ�kUuo~K}|�TcN}U�YVRyPSTco~P>f0ltg@wxRkg@K}UuK�T�P>KQ^|a��kUuo~K}|�TcN}U�Tco~wxUltg@wxRkg@K}UuK�TX�²­NQUxR_PSWnP>wxUXTVWnoplxWcUXRQWcUuYcUuK�TcPSTcohg@KË°�õ ��a�±¤opY�K}g@KQ^}UultWnUuP>Yco~K}|®{QYno~K}|�TcN}U�g>WZ^}UXWOæc{QYVT^}Ut�ºK}Uu^�g@K�TcN}U�ltg@wR_fhUXTVUu^�|>WnPSRyNjç ä �{IUXT>ö�°��k±¤�ºU�TcN}U�YVUXT�o~K¯Ã#��ÃÀ°�° �r�u[�±´��­O±Z�¼´Qg>W�P>K��|� Ê ªW� �áûªiTcN}U�Ð ÊwxUXTVWZo~l¤o~Y

t%÷@È °�� Ê ��� ±!� opK}jøKùØúIû üýú�þ�ÿ��%ø��´ú'þú�� È û � � ¹ õ Ê�º õ ¹WÍf¹ a Ê!º a ¹ �.� °�½F�çÖ�±

a�NQUXWcU�PS|@P>o~KOÏ ÍhÐ �ËþjÏ%�,�eÏ3� Ð �@�EJéT\Tc{}WnK_Y\g@{}T­TcNQPST t%÷@È opK¯°�½F�çÖ�±\o~Y�Px�kg@KQP¡�y^}UwxUXTVWZo~l¤g@K¿Ã»�·°¢²�N}U�TVWnopP>K}|@fhU�o~KQUu¬�{QP>fpohTH��o~Y�KQg>T�UuK�TcohWcUufh��g>�F«Fo~g@{QYIHyYcUXU�²­NQUXg>WcUuw[u`F�¾½F�~[S�ü±JéTOo~Y]UuP>YV�TVgxYVUXUÅTcNQPSTXªQohjS�®o~Y]ltg@K�Tco~K�{Qg@{QYXªmTcN}UuK t%÷@È °��:2:���6±!�-��ohjùP>KQ^�g@KQfh�ohj ¹ �:2 º � ¹ � �m��JéT�o~YxP>f~YVg�UuP>Yc�ÁTVg¹YVUXU®TcNQPST tb÷ È °��32:���k±R� �¯P>Y14�� ³j�g>W�TcN}U·UtýmP>wR_fhUuY�opK®´3oh|@{}WcUuYb½F�~[·P>KQ^¿½F�¾`F�­²Igzo~f~f~{_YVTVWnPSTVU>ªQa]U·^QopYVR_f~Pd�zo~K»´io~|@{}WcU½F�çÖ®YVRkUulXoÇ�ºl�R_PSWnP>wUXTVWno~l·WcUXRQWcUuYVUuK�TcPSTcohg@KQY°�õ���a�±�P>K_^Ñ°�õ323��ae2m±�g>jCTcN}Uxltg@wxRyfhUXTVUu^|>WnPSRyNQY¤g>j��ÁP>K_^p� 2 j�g>W�TcN}U�j¢{QKQltTco~g@KQY¤o~K¼´3oh|@{}WnU�½F�~[�TcNQPST��FohUufp^�TcN}U�^QopYVTcP>KQltUtb÷CÈ °��:23���k±!�M4 � Ê �3²­N}U­YcR_PSTco~P>fmltg@wxRkg@K}UuK�TcY<õ�P>KQ^�õ32·PSWcU­op^}UuK�TcoplXP>f��i²�N}UOTco~wxUltg@wxRkg@K}UuK�TcY­YcPSTcopYVj�� ¹ a�2 º a ¹ ��4 � Ê �´Qg>WbPSRQRyf~o~lXPSTcohg@KQYuªmo~T�o~Y­Yco~|@KQoÇ�ylXP>K�T\TcNQPST­RQWnUX«Fohg@{_Y­f~o~wo~TcYEj�g>W�YcTVgFlZNQP>YVTco~l�RQWcgSqltUuYcYcUuY�a�o~TcN¼TcN}U�j�P>wopf~o~PSWxÉ Ê TVg>Rkg@fhg>|>�¯g@K¯Ã a�o~fpf0P>f~YVg*NQg@f~^�a�N}UuK¯aEU�{QYVU�TcN}UÐ Ê TVg>Rkg@fhg>|>�o~KQYcTVUuP>^6ª��kUulXP>{QYVU�TcN}U�É Ê TVg>Rkg@fhg>|>�o~YCYcTVWcg@K}|>UXW¤°�g>WC�yKQUXWr±iTcNQP>K�TcN}UÐ.Ê­TVg>Rkg@fhg>|>�3HyYVUXU�²­N}UXg>WnUuwÄ[u`F�¾½F�¾`F�©�U�K}gdaìa]P>K�T�TVg�wgF^Qo~j���TcN}U�YVR_P>ltU·Ã¿°�° �r�u[�±´��­\±¤o~K�T5aEg�a]Pd�FYX³E©�U�aOP>K�T�TVgUtýmTVUuKQ^�TcN}UxWZP>K}|>Ug>j]TcN}Uxj�{_KQltTcohg@KQYÅj�Wcg@w ­¦TVgj­!®ÀP>KQ^Àa]UaOP>K�T�TVg»P>f~fhg:a¦TcN}U^}g@w�P>o~K¼g>j­TcNQU�j¢{QKQltTcohg@KQY��kU�TcN}U�YVUuwoÇqHopKm�yKQohTVUopK�TVUXWc«SP>f�° �r�y³.±�opKQYVTVUuP>^¹g>j\TcN}U{QK_ohT¤o~K�TVUXWn«¡P>f�° �r�u[�±s�®´3ohWZYVTXªITcN}U®É Ê P>KQ^¼Ð Ê wxUXTVWnoplXY¤UtýFTVUuK_^¯^QohWnUultTcfh�*TVg¿Ãή��ÃÀ°�° �r�u[�±´��­ ® ±0a�N}UuK�TcNQU�K}g>Wnw ½ Ñ ½>g@KR­�o~K*°�½F�~[d±Eo~YEWcUXR_f~P>ltUu^�����P·ltg>WcWnUuYVRkg@KQ^Qo~K}|K}g>WZw�g@Kj­ ® Yc{QlnN»P>Y­TcN}U�w�P¡ýmo~w�{Qw�K}g>WZw¹ Ï ¹ �%w�P¡ýÊ�»��¡» ® ½ Ï � ½u�

j�g>WCÏ���°�Ï Ê �I/I/I/e�'Ïb®>±`�p­<®º�¤©ËohTcN¿TcN}U�wP¡ý}o~w�{Qw K}g>Wnw�g@K�­W®ºªka]U�g>�_TcP>o~K¿TcN}UYVTcP>K_^QPSWn^�g>WOYcTVWcg@K}|�É Ê P>KQ^�Ð Ê wxUXTVWZo~lXY]g@Kzà ® �0©�U¤lXP>f~fºTcN}UbTVg>Rkg@fhg>|>��o~K_^Q{QltUu^�F��TcNQUuYVU·wxUXTVWZo~lXY\TcN}U�YcTcP>KQ^QPSWn^�g>W �r�¢¥V�S�%$®�s�r£m�Sûh�'$�� ªkP>KQ^»^}UuKQg>TVU�ohT\�F�®ÿ]É}Ê�P>KQ^ÿ3Ð Ê ªQWcUuYVRkUultTcoh«>Uuf~�>�©�U�P>f~Ycg¿{QYcU�TcN}U £y¥V�u�S§Q u�·�s�Z£m�Sûh�'$�� g@KÑÃR®�ª3WcUX|@PSWn^_o~K}|*ÃR®®P>Y�TcN}UzRQWcgm^Q{QltTYVRyP>ltU·Ã ê ÑIÑIÑ ê*ûªya�NQo~lZN®NQP>Y��:2.���¿P>Y�4�� ³ j�g>W��32.�Õ°�� Ê2 �I/I/I/e��� ®2 ±­P>KQ^

Page 10: Í¡Ö - Columbia Universityww2040/framechno.pdfÍ¡Ö ×3Ø ÙbÚbÛ0ÜCÝ¦Þ ß#Û3Ø Üáà3Ý Ùbâ*Ü ã¹äOÝ å TcN}U Ð Ê TVg>Rkg@fhg>|> ¯o~K¹g>Wn^}UXW TVg¿ ºU PS _fhU

[I�@` ×3Ø�ÙbÚbÛ0ÜCݦÞ�ß#Û3Ø�Üáà3Ý�Ùbâ*Ü�ã¹äOÝ�å

Ê

Ê

A A

A

��å Ô È Ô È � 2 Ô È

� Õ � å

� Õ � å

Ê

Ê

A

´3oh|@{}WcU½F�çÖ}³ÅÂCfhg>TcYÅg>jER_PSWnP>wxUXTVWnopl·WnUXRQWcUuYVUuK�TcPSTcohg@KQYx°�õ ��a�±�g>jTç ä P>KQ^�°�õ:2:��ae2}±�g>jç ä�å �mohUuf~^QopK}| tb÷ È °��:23���k±!�M4 � Ê j�g>W\TcN}U¤j¢{QKQltTcohg@KQY]o~K�´3oh|@{}WcU�½F�~[S�C²�N}UÅRºg@opK�TcY�ÏP>KQ^ Ð PSWcU�PSWn�_ohTVWnPSWc�>ªQYnPSTco~YVj��Fo~KQ|��1BQÏ.B Ð B([S��Y��°�� Ê �I/I/I/��� ® ±­o~K*à ® o~j�� �2 � � � P>Y�4Ú��³ o~K»Ã8j�g>WbUuP>lnN� c�b²­N}U�R_WcgF^_{QltTTVg>Rkg@fhg>|>��g@K®Ã ® o~Y\o~K_^Q{QltUu^��F��TcN}U·wxUXTVWno~l

t�� °�� ���Q±!� ®� ���<Ê t °�� � ��� � ±�� °�½F�¾Î@±

a�N}UXWcU t o~Y\TcN}U�wxUXTVWno~l�g@K*Ã Ê ��¶mo~KQltU�ltg@K�«>UXWc|>UuKQltUxo~K®TcN}U·YVTVWng@K}|�TVg>Rkg@fhg>|>�»opw�qR_f~ohUuYCltg@K�«>UXWc|>UuK_ltUÅopKxTcN}U�R_WcgF^_{QltT0TVg>Rkg@fhg>|>�>ªmaEUbP>f~YVg�lXP>f~f_TcN}U�R_WcgF^_{QltTvTVg>Rkg@fhg>|>�TcN}U gE�n�¡���s�Z£m�Sûh�'$c� ª6P>KQ^�a]U�^}UuKQg>TVU�ohT\�F���,É}Ê�P>KQ^��(Ð.ÊX�²­N}Uz^}Ut�yKQo~Tcohg@KQYÅj�g>W·ÃÀ°�° �r�u[�±´��­ ® ±ÅUtýmTVUuKQ^Á^QohWcUultTcfh�¿TVgÀÿ°�° �r��¾�±´��­ ® ±Åj�g>W�P>K��¾�=Ù�m�bJéTbo~YbKQPSTc{}WZP>fITVg�lnN_PSWnP>ltTVUXWnohíXUxltg@K�«>UXWc|>UuKQltUg>jCPzYVUu¬F{}UuKQltUÎ���:2*³Å4f6,[8�o~K�ÿ°�° �r�y³.±y��­ ® ±]o~K�TVUXWZwYOg>j<P>YcYcgFlXo~PSTVUu^»ltg@K�«>UXWc|>UuK_ltU�g>j<TcNQUbWnUuYVTVWno~ltTcohg@K_YEg>j��:2

Page 11: Í¡Ö - Columbia Universityww2040/framechno.pdfÍ¡Ö ×3Ø ÙbÚbÛ0ÜCÝ¦Þ ß#Û3Ø Üáà3Ý Ùbâ*Ü ã¹äOÝ å TcN}U Ð Ê TVg>Rkg@fhg>|> ¯o~K¹g>Wn^}UXW TVg¿ ºU PS _fhU

Þ�ß Þ�ßëÛ3Ø�ÜMLmÚkÙ�×3ÜQz [I�@½TVgÀTcN}U�Yc{}�_opK�TVUXWc«SP>f~YR° �r��¾ã±­o~K¹TcN}U�YVR_P>ltU�ÿ°�° �r��¾�±´��­ ® ±�j�g>WxP>f~f�¾1= �m�|¢�g:aEUX«>UXWuªK}g>TVU¿TcNQPST�aEU¿UuKQltg@{QK�TVUXW�^Qo�Þ�lX{Qf~TcohUuYxo~K.ÃÀ°�° �r��¾�±´��­ ® ±ohjÅTcN}U*Wnoh|@N�T�UuKQ^QRºg@opK�T1¾o~Y·P*^_o~Ycltg@K�Tco~K�{_ohTH�¿Rkg@o~K�T·g>j­P»R_Wcg@YVRkUultTcoh«>U�fpo~wohT¤j¢{QKQltTcohg@Kp�I�*´Qg>W�Utý}P>wxR_f~U>ª3o~j¾Ø2��ݾÅP>Y>4U� ³Ëªi�_{}T�¾�2f=�¾Åj�g>W�P>f~f<40ªiTcN}UuK¯TcN}U�WcUuYcTVWno~ltTcohg@KQY�g>jP¯ Ó ¼ å Õ n â TVgTcN}U�Yc{}�_opK�TVUXWc«SP>f�° �r��¾�±3PSWnU�TcN}U·íXUXWcg�j¢{QKQltTcohg@Kùª_a�NQopfhUC¯ Ó ¼ Õ n â opY�K}g>TXªkYVg�a]U·lXP>K_K}g>T|>UXT�TcN}U»^}UuYco~WcUu^�ltg@K�«>UXWn|>UuKQltU|¯ Ó ¼ å Õ n â � ¯ Ó ¼ Õ n â a]U»aOP>K�TX��²­NF{QYxa]U»YcPd��TcNQPSTTcN}U®YcUu¬�{}UuK_ltU����:2˳!4 6 [8�*ltg@K�«>UXWc|>UuYTVg|�ËP>Yv4?� ³ opKÁÃÀ°�° �r�y³e±y��­T®}±�o~jTcN}U¿WcUuYVTVWZo~ltTcohg@KQY�g>j@�:2ÑTVg0° �r��¾ã±�ltg@K�«>UXWc|>U�TVg¹TcNQU*WcUuYcTVWno~ltTcohg@Kág>jC��TVgM° �r��¾�±�o~KÃÀ°�° �r��¾ã±´��­ ® ±Ej�g>W�P>fpfu¾�=Q�TcNQPST�PSWcU�ltg@K�Tco~KF{QohTH��Rkg@o~K�TcYOg>j��<�²�N}U�wxgF^QU¿g>j�ltg@K�«>UXWn|>UuKQltU�æc{QYVT�^}Ut�yK}Uu^�lXP>K��kU�P>lnN_ohUX«>Uu^�a�ohTcN�wxUXTVWZo~lXYX�� o~«>UuK®PwxUXTVWnopl t ¼ g@K»ÃÀ°�° �r��¾�±´��­]±¤PSRQRyf~ohUu^zTVgTcN}U�WnUuYVTVWno~ltTcohg@K_YOg>j<TcN}U�j�{QK_ltTcohg@KQYTVg]° �r��¾�±sª_a]U�^}Ut�yKQU�PwxUXTVWno~l t n g@K»ÃÀ°�° �r�y³e±y��­]±¤����fhUXTVTco~K}|

t n °��ùÊ����3d±<� o nA Ä � ¼ ° t ¼n°��ùÊ����3d±���[�± t ¾ �a�NQUXWcU>Ï�� Ð �ëwo~K3�eÏ3� Ð ��P>K_^ t ¼ °�� Ê ��� ±�o~Yb{QKQ^}UXWZYVTVg�gm^®TVg�wxUuP>K¿TcN}Ux^QopYVTcP>KQltUt ¼ °�UuohTcN}UXW¤É Ê g>WbÐ Ê ±OPSRQRyf~ohUu^zTVgTcN}U�WnUuYVTVWno~ltTcohg@K_YOg>j�� Ê P>KQ^h� TVgY° �r��¾ã±s�²�N}U�j¢{QKQltTcohg@K*YVR_P>ltUxà a�ohTcN»TcN}U�É Ê g>WÅÐ Ê TVg>Rkg@fhg>|>�»o~YbYVg@wxUXa�N_PST�g@{}TcYno~^}UTcN}U�w�P>o~KQYVTVWcUuP>w�g>j<TVWnP>^QohTco~g@KQP>fºj�{QK_ltTcohg@KQP>fkP>KQP>fh�mYco~YXªm�kUulXP>{QYVU ���@�S�¢�¢�¢�S�����Å�y�>�O� Z�S�_�¢���Q§Q�S§F����Z£ j�Wcg@w�TcN}U�RQWcgm^Q{QltTbYVR_P>ltUxÃ8ê*ÃÄa�ohTcN*TcN}U·R_WcgF^_{QltT�TVg>Rkg@fhg>|>�TVg�Ã*������:�! #"��O�,�¨�S�����%$��@�S�¢�¢���S���p�¤�y�@�O Z�S�_�¢���Q§Q�S§F�t¨¸#Yco~wR_fhUÅUtýmP>wR_fhU�NQP>Y*�h� º �1�M¯ Ó Ô È Õ Ê�Ö a�o~TcN�:2v�M¯ Ó Ô È � 25Ô È Õ Ê�Ö P>K_^ ��2�� º ¯ Ó Ô È ²"2%Ô È Õ Ê�Ö /²­NQUuK¼°��v+f�Q±t°�¾c±!��� j�g>W�P>f~f#¾rª}a�NQopfhU

�32C+7��2v�M¯mÓ Ô È � 2%Ô È Õ Ô È ²"25Ô È Ö /©�ohTcN�TcN}U¤K}g@KmqH{_KQohj�g>Wnw�¶mÌ>g>Wcg@N}gm^�TVg>Rºg@f~g>|@ohUuYXªr� 2 �Ü�»P>KQ^�� 2 �Ü��P>Y�4]�߳˪�_{QTT�32C+7��2]à�Ü�1+7��P>YP4]��³Ë�²�N�{QYuªvUX«>UuKeTcN}g@{Q|@NeÃ�o~YxP¼«>UultTVg>W�YVR_P>ltUÁ°�aEU®lXP>K�TcP>f~ÌÁPS�kg@{}TxTcN}U®fpo~K}UuPSWltg@w·�_o~KQPSTco~g@KQY@Ï%�Î+ Ð �¿j�g>W�j¢{QKQltTcohg@KQY �ÁP>KQ^|��o~K�Ã%P>KQ^¼KF{Qw·�ºUXWZY@Ï*P>K_^ Ð o~K­C±rª3à �����y�>�­�z�s�Z£m�Sûh�'$@�¢ Z�Sû<9S�n u�s�S¥·�s£m�� Z� °¢P>KQ^*TcN�{QY�K}g>T�P�î]P>K_P>lnN¿YVR_P>ltU:±­a�ohTcNTcN}UzÉ Ê P>KQ^�Ð Ê TVg>Rkg@fhg>|@ohUuY°��kUulXP>{QYVUxTcN}g@YcUYVTVWn{QltTc{}WnUuYÅWcUu¬�{_ohWcU�P>^Q^QohTcohg@K¿TVg��kUltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QYZ±Z���UX«>UXWcTcN}Uuf~UuYcYXªQo~K�PSRQR_fpo~lXPSTcohg@KQYEg>jITcN}U¤ltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QYLqHwPSR_R_o~K}|�PSRQRQWcg@P>lZN�TVgxUuYLqTcPS�_fpo~YcN®YVTVgmlnN_P>YVTco~lrqsRQWcgmltUuYcYbf~o~wo~TcYXªQa]U�a�o~fpfkg>j�TVUuK¿aOP>K�T�TVgzP>^Q^»g>WbYn{}�QTVWnP>ltT�THa]g

Page 12: Í¡Ö - Columbia Universityww2040/framechno.pdfÍ¡Ö ×3Ø ÙbÚbÛ0ÜCÝ¦Þ ß#Û3Ø Üáà3Ý Ùbâ*Ü ã¹äOÝ å TcN}U Ð Ê TVg>Rkg@fhg>|> ¯o~K¹g>Wn^}UXW TVg¿ ºU PS _fhU

[I�SÖ ×3Ø�ÙbÚbÛ0ÜCݦÞ�ß#Û3Ø�Üáà3Ý�Ùbâ*Ü�ã¹äOÝ�åj�{_KQltTcohg@KQYX�0²­NF{QY\ohT­opYO«>UXWc�zopwxRkg>WcTcP>K�TOTcNQPST�P>^Q^QohTcohg@K�lXP>K»�ºU¤wP>^QU¤TVgRQWcUuYVUXWn«>Ultg@K�«>UXWn|>UuKQltU>��J5T¤Tc{}WZKQYÅg@{}T�TcNQPST·P>^Q^QohTcohg@KÀg@K¯ÃÄê�ÃòopY¤wxUuP>Yc{}WnPS�yfhUP>KQ^¼ohT�opYltg@K�TcopK�{}g@{_Y]PST\f~opwohTcY]o~K�P�f~PSWc|>U¤Yc{Q�_YVUXT]g>jIÃ�ê�Ã*�v´}g>W­P>K���g>jITcN}UÅK}g@KmqH{_KQohj�g>Wnw¶FÌ>g>Wcg@N}gm^xTVg>Rkg@fhg>|@ohUuYuª�ohTCYn{rÞ�ltUuY0TVg�P>YcYc{QwxU\TcN_PSTCTcN}U­T5aEg�f~o~wo~T<j¢{QKQltTcohg@K_Y<�zP>K_^�xNQPu«>UbK}g�ltg@wwxg@K�^Qo~Ycltg@K�Tco~KF{QohT5��Rkg@o~K�TcYX�<©�ohTcNxTcNQU�Ð Ê TVg>Rºg@f~g>|>��°��y{}TCK}g>TvTcNQUÉ Ê TVg>Rkg@fhg>|>�Q±Zª}ohTEYc{ÅÞ�ltUuYCTVg�P>YcYc{_wxU�TcNQPST]TcN}UbTHa]gxf~o~wohT0j¢{QKQltTco~g@KQY!��P>KQ^Î�NQPu«>UK}g·ltg@w�wxg@K�^Qo~Ycltg@K�Tco~KF{QohTH��Rkg@o~K�TcYva�o~TcNÅæc{QwxR_YCg>j6g>RQRkg@YcohTVU�Ynoh|@K6�­°¢´}g>W\o~KQYVTcP>K_ltU>ªo~K�&0ý}P>wxR_fhUx½F�¾½F�~[Sª,�32 º ��2h��� º �»o~K�°¢ÃO�cÐ Ê ±Z�ü±¿JLKÀwP>K��¿PSRQR_f~oplXPSTcohg@KQYXªºaEUPSWcU�PS�_fhU�TVgÀYnN}gda TcNQPST�TcN}UzTHa]gSqH^Qo~wxUuKQYnohg@KQP>f]f~o~wohTcopK}|®YVTVgmlnNQP>YVTcopl�R_WcgFltUuYnY·NQP>YYcP>wxR_f~U�R_PSTcNQYo~Keg@K}U®g>jÅTcN}g@YVU»Yn{}�_YVUXTcYxg>jÅR_P>o~WnY®°�� ���Q±�a��çRI�~[S�á²­N}UuKÑa]U*lXP>KPSRQR_fh��TcN}U�ltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QYLqHwPSR_R_o~K}|�TcN}UXg>WcUuw a�ohTcN�P>^Q^Qo~Tcohg@K6�132('v2òñ�óCô*)�?<9I;@G59iBC?IB,+.-0/�÷köCöEG592143ÀöEöC=@?ù÷6D�ó²­N}U�ltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QYVqHwPSRQR_o~KQ|�PSR_RQWcg@P>lnN¯TVg*YVTVgmlnN_P>YVTco~lrqsRQWcgmltUuYcY·f~o~wohTcYÅUtýmR_fhg@o~TcYRQWcUX«mohg@{QYcf~��UuYVTcPS�_f~opYcN}Uu^�YVTVgmlnNQP>YVTcoplrqsRQWcgmltUuYcYvf~o~w�ohTcY<P>K_^xTcN}U\ltg@K�TcopK�{}g@{_YLqHwPSRQR_opK}|TcN}UXg>WcUuw�TVg�g>�QTcP>o~K�K}UXa YVTVgmlnN_P>YVTco~lrqsRQWcgmltUuYcY�f~o~wohTcYEg>j3o~K�TVUXWnUuYVTX�C¸bfhTVUXWnKQPSTcoh«>U�PSRQqRQWcg@P>lZN}UuYÅPSWcU�TcN}U�ltg@wxR_P>ltTcK}UuYnYbPSR_RQWcg@P>lnN¿^}UuYcltWZoh�kUu^®o~K¿¶mUultTcohg@K¹[>[S�¾Ï�P>KQ^»«¡PSWnohqg@{QYIYcTVgFlZNQP>YVTco~lEPSRQRQWcg@P>lZN}UuY]°�a�NQo~lnN�{QYc{QP>f~f~��UtýmR_fhg@ohTùTcNQUCltg@wxR_P>ltTcK}UuYnY<PSRQR_Wcg@P>lnNy±Zªa�NQo~lZNÀUtýFRyfhg@ohT�YVRkUulXo~P>f0YVTVgmlnN_P>YVTco~l�YcTVWn{QltTc{}WcU>ª<Yc{QlnN¯P>Y65¿PSWcÌ>gd«¯P>K_^�wPSWcTco~K}|@P>f~UYVTVWn{QltTc{QWcU�H}U>�ç|}�hª_YVUXU¤îOo~f~f~opK}|@YcfhUX�®°L[uÍ>Ï>ïFª<[uÍ>Í>Í@±Zª7&vTcNQo~UXWOP>K_^hÁ�{}WcTVí°L[uÍ>ï>Ï@±Zª78�P>ltgF^P>KQ^*¶mN_ohWc�@PSUX«¿°L[uÍ>ïc¥>±�P>KQ^jÁ�{QYcNQK}UXW�°�`m���}[d±Z�¢�UXWcU�o~Y­PxYno~wxR_fhUÅj�g>Wnw�g>jiTcN}U�ltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QYLqHwPSR_R_o~K}|�TcN}UXg>WcUuw®³

�>���b�:�8�b���S��9,����� °¢Yco~wxR_f~U»ltg@K�TcopK�{}g@{_YLqHwPSRQR_opK}|¼TcN}UXg>WcUuwz± ¨ © �.� 2Ùk � ���°sÿ��Vþ*± �S�y�6: ³º°sÿ��Vþ*±!� °sÿ#;��Vþ�;p± ���� n�S�y�¢���Q§Q�S§F� � ���m�X�: ° � 2}±<k : ° � ± ��� °sÿ ; �Vþ ; ±@/

< �8�S�>='� ¶mo~KQltU : o~Y�ltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QYuª s Ì : o~Y�PÀltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QY��kg@{QK_^}Uu^¼WcUuP>fhqs«¡P>f~{QUu^j�{_KQltTcohg@K�g@K�°sÿ��Vþ*±Åj�g>W�UuP>lZNÑltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QY��kg@{QKQ^}Uu^ÀWcUuP>fhqs«¡P>f~{QUu^�j�{_KQltTcohg@K s g@K°sÿ#;��Vþ�;h±Z��¢�UuKQltU>ªº{QKQ^}UXW\TcNQU�ltg@KQ^QohTcohg@K_YXª¤ ° s Ì : ° � 2}±ã±S� ¤ ° s Ì : ° � ±ã±

j�g>W�UuP>lnN¼ltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QY¤�kg@{QKQ^QUu^»WcUuP>fhqs«¡P>f~{QUu^Àj�{QK_ltTcohg@K s g@Ká°sÿ ; �Vþ ; ±Zªùa�NQo~lnN�opw�qR_f~ohUuYOTcNQU�^}UuYcohWcUu^�ltg@K_lXf~{QYcohg@K��F��°�`F�¾½@±Z�Â3PSWnP>f~fhUufpo~K}|�TcNQUÅYno~wxR_fhUbltg@K�TcopK�{}g@{_YLqHwPSRQR_opK}|�TcN}UXg>WnUuw�PS�ºg:«>U>ªQa]UÅlXP>K�{_YVU¤P? �¾£_�t X���¢�A@túé�x�r£@£y���%$����}�c�S¥c�t� TVg·YcN}g:a.TcNQPST]^Qo~YVTcP>K_ltUuYXª�P>KQ^TcN�{QYCWnPSTVUuYEg>jkltg@K�«>UXWVq|>UuKQltU�a�ohTcNxTcN}U�ÂCWcg@N}g>Wcg:«xwxUXTVWno~lSªFPSWcU­RQWcUuYcUXWc«>Uu^{QKQ^QUXW�{IohRyYclnNQo~TVíOw�PSRQR_o~K}|@Yu³<¸

Page 13: Í¡Ö - Columbia Universityww2040/framechno.pdfÍ¡Ö ×3Ø ÙbÚbÛ0ÜCÝ¦Þ ß#Û3Ø Üáà3Ý Ùbâ*Ü ã¹äOÝ å TcN}U Ð Ê TVg>Rkg@fhg>|> ¯o~K¹g>Wn^}UXW TVg¿ ºU PS _fhU

Þ�ßCBFßëÛ3Ø�Üë×­äEDxÛ#FGDIH\äJH<LLK¢â*ÙbÚCÚ,F�DNM�ÙbÚCÚEݤäCÙ�×3Ø [I�@Îj¢{QKQltTcohg@K : w�PSRQR_o~K}|�P·wxUXTVWno~l�YVR_P>ltUx°sÿ��Vþ*±0o~K�TVg·P>KQg>TcN}UXW]wUXTVWno~l�YcR_P>ltU�°sÿ#;��Vþ�;~±o~Y0YnP>o~^�TVg��kU�{<ohR_YclZNQohTVíOltg@K�TcopK�{}g@{_YXª@g>Wkæc{QYVT,? �¾£_�X t���¢�A@ ªFohj_TcN}UXWnU\Utýmo~YcTcY0P¤ltg@KQYVTcP>K�TO Yc{QlZN�TcNQPST

þ ; ° : °��k±y� : °��}±V±�)PO¿þ¯°�� ���Q±"j�g>W�P>f~f#�����Î�Àÿ�/ °�Ö}�~[d±²­NQUÅopKm�yw�{QwÕg>jiP>f~f6ltg@KQYVTcP>K�TcYQOòj�g>W\a�NQo~lnN¼°�Ö}�~[d±\N}g@f~^QYOo~YOlXP>f~fhUu^�TcNQUR? �Ô£y�t t�����A@ Z�S�}�r�s�>�_� �C¸bYv�kUXj�g>WnU>ª�fhUXT!Ï Í@Ð ��þjÏ5� �eÏ:� Ð �@�v²­N}U�j�g@f~f~gda�o~KQ| {<ohR_YclZNQohTVí­wPSR_R_o~K}|TcN}UXg>WnUuw�ª}TcPSÌ>UuK�j�Wcg@w�©ËN_ohTVT�°L[uÍc¥:Ö@P�±Zªºo~Y]RQWngd«>Uu^®o~K®¶FUultTco~g@K�[S�¾Î�g>j<TcN}UÅJLK�TVUXWZK}UXT¶m{QRQR_fhUuwxUuK�TX��¸�R_R_f~o~lXPSTcohg@K_Y�TVg�UuYVTcPS�yf~o~YcN¹WnPSTVUuYxg>jbltg@K�«>UXWc|>UuK_ltU*o~KÁYVTVgmlnNQP>YVTcoplrqRQWngFltUuYcYbf~o~w�ohTcY�PSWcU�^Qo~YnlX{QYcYVUu^*o~KÀ¶mUultTcohg@K¿`F�¾`�g>jvTcNQU�JLK�TVUXWnK}UXT�¶m{}RQR_f~UuwxUuK�TX��©�Ua­WZohTVU � ° � �TS�±­j�g>W�TcN}U�^Qo~YcTcP>KQltU��kUXTHa]UXUuK¿TcN}U�RQWcg>�_PS�_opf~ohTH��f~Pda�Y�g>jCTcN}U�WnP>K_^}g@wUufhUuwUuK�TcY � P>KQ^US���~� �b�:�8�r�§�S��9 �¨�S� °�{IohRyYclnNQo~TVíwPSRQR_o~KQ|�TcN}UXg>WnUuw�±JV §d£�£m�¡�X�����F�>�W: ³v°sÿ��Vþ*±C�°sÿ#;��Vþ�;p± ��� ? �¾£_�t X���¢�A@x�¡�����YX[Z_¨]\_^��S�¼���Z§:Gr�u�X� ^ �L� ÿ ¨x�I�m�X�

� ° : ° � ±y� : °`Sz±V±T)(°`O Í [d± � ° � �TS�±�X�S¥·�S�:��¥V�S�y�@�S� �Xûh�X��X�_���P� �S�y� S �V� °sÿ��Vþ*± �t�>¥@g3���� t� d�°`S �O^±<�ë[ ¨©�U·g>j�TVUuK*K}UXUu^�TVg�|>g�kUX�>g@KQ^�TcN}U�Yno~wxR_fhU¤ltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QYLqHwPSR_R_o~K}|�TcN}UXg>WcUuw�o~K²­NQUXg>WcUuw�½F�çÖ}�~[S�Á©�U�g>j�TVUuK�K}UXUu^ÑTVg�ltg@KQYcop^}UXWxwxUuP>Yc{}WnPS�yfhU�j¢{QKQltTco~g@KQY�TcNQPSTxPSWcUg@KQf~��ltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QYbP>f~wxg@YVT�UX«>UXWc�Fa�N}UXWcU·g>WbP�YVUu¬�{QUuKQltU·g>jvYn{QlnN»j�{QK_ltTcohg@KQYX�­´}g>WnTc{mqKQPSTVUuf~�>ªùTcN}Ultg@K�Tco~K�{Qg@{QYLqHwPSRQRyo~K}|zTcN}UXg>WcUuw UtýmTVUuKQ^QY¤TVg®Yc{_lnN�YVUXTVTco~KQ|@YX�·©�U�lXP>Ka]g>WcÌ»a�ohTcN*P�YVUu¬F{}UuKQltUxg>j]î]g>WcUuf3wxUuP>Yc{}WnPS�yfhU·j¢{QKQltTco~g@KQY>� : 2 ³�4E6 [8��P>f~f3wPSR}qR_opK}|�g@K}U�YVUXR_PSWZPS�_fhU�wxUXTVWnopl�YVR_P>ltU�°sÿW�Vþ*±\o~K�TVgP>K}g>TcN}UXWbYVUXR_PSWnPS�_f~U�wxUXTVWno~l�YcR_P>ltU°sÿ#a��Vþ�a�±Z�ÅJ5TÅYc{rÞzltUuY�TVg�NQPd«>U : 2k°��:2m±*� : °��k±�P>Y`4Ú�Û³ a�N}UuK}UX«>UXW`�:2h� �¼P>Y4]��³�j�g>W]P�Yc{Q�_YVUXT ¤ g>jùf~o~wo~TcYW�zo~Kzÿ¼Yc{_lnNTcN_PST�d�° � � ¤ ±��ë[S�0²­NQo~Y0|>UuKQUXWVqP>f~o~íuPSTcohg@Kj�g@f~fhg:a�Y0UuP>Yco~f~��j�Wcg@wÕTcN}UŶFÌ>g>Wng@N}gF^�WcUXRQWcUuYcUuK�TcPSTcohg@K�TcN}UXg>WcUuw®ªF²­NQUXg>WcUuw½F�¾`F�¾`F³­¶FTcPSWcTco~KQ|xa�ohTcN�TcN}U�ltg@K�«>UXWc|>UuKQltU�o~K�^QopYVTVWnoh�_{QTcohg@K � 2vk � ªQaEU·PSRQR_fh��TcN}U¶FÌ>g>Wng@N}gF^�WcUXRQWcUuYcUuK�TcPSTcohg@K�TcN}UXg>WcUuw TVg�g>�QTcP>opKTcN}UbYVRkUulXo~P>f}WnP>KQ^Qg@w¦UufhUuwxUuK�TcY «� 2P>KQ^ «� a�ohTcN®TcN}U·YcP>wxU·^_o~YVTVWnoh�y{}Tcohg@KQYOP>Y � 2 P>KQ^ � Yc{QlnN»TcNQPST «� 2 � «� a��çRù�~[S�

¶mopKQltU «� ¦� � P>KQ^pd�° � � ¤ ±`�£�mªIa]U�P>f~Ycg®NQPu«>U.d�° «� � ¤ ± �£�m�x©�U�TcN}UuKPSRQRyfh�TcN}U�^QUXTVUXWnwo~KQopYVTco~lbltg@K�«>UXWc|>UuK_ltU�RQWcUuYcUXWc«¡PSTco~g@K�P>YcYc{QwxUu^®j�g>W­TcNQU¤j�{QK_ltTcohg@KQY: 2�TVg�|>UXT­TcN}U�f~opwohT: ° «� 2}±<� : ° «� ±+P>Y 4O��³ o~K °sÿ ; �Vþ ; ±"a��çRù�~[c/

¶mopKQltU�ltg@K�«>UXWc|>UuK_ltU¹a��çRI�~[�o~wxR_f~o~UuY�ltg@K�«>UXWc|>UuKQltUÑo~K�^Qo~YcTVWnoh�_{}Tco~g@K6ª�P>Y®Peltg@K_YVUtq¬F{}UuKQltU¤a]U�g>�QTcP>o~K : ° «� 2Q±!k : ° «� ± o~K °sÿ ; �Vþ ; ±`/

Page 14: Í¡Ö - Columbia Universityww2040/framechno.pdfÍ¡Ö ×3Ø ÙbÚbÛ0ÜCÝ¦Þ ß#Û3Ø Üáà3Ý Ùbâ*Ü ã¹äOÝ å TcN}U Ð Ê TVg>Rkg@fhg>|> ¯o~K¹g>Wn^}UXW TVg¿ ºU PS _fhU

[I�@Ï ×3Ø�ÙbÚbÛ0ÜCݦÞ�ß#Û3Ø�Üáà3Ý�Ùbâ*Ü�ã¹äOÝ�å´3o~KQP>f~fh�>ªFYco~KQltU � 2P>KQ^ � PSWcUbWcUuYVRkUultTcoh«>Uuf~��Uu¬F{QP>fºo~K�^_o~YVTVWnoh�y{}Tcohg@K�TVg «� 2P>K_^ «� ªP>f~YVg : 2 ° � 2 ±�P>KQ^ : ° � ±�PSWcU�WcUuYVRkUultTcoh«>Uuf~��Uu¬�{QP>f3o~K*^Qo~YVTVWZoh�_{}Tcohg@K�TVg : 2 ° «� 2 ±­P>K_^: ° «� ±Z�i²�N�{QYuª>aEUOg>�QTcP>o~K�TcN}U\^}UuYnohWcUu^·|>UuK}UXWnP>f~ohíuPSTco~g@K�g>j_TcN}UOltg@K�TcopK�{}g@{_YLqHwPSRQR_opK}|TcN}UXg>WcUuw�³ : 2k° � 2}±!k : ° � ± o~K °sÿ ; �Vþ ; ±�/JéT�o~Y­P>f~YcgRkg@YcYcoh�_f~UbTVg�UuYVTcPS�_f~o~YnN®Yc{QlZN�UtýFTVUuK_Ycohg@KQY�g>jiTcNQU�Yco~wxRyfhU¤ltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QYVqwPSRQR_opK}|�TcN}UXg>WcUuw o~K�²­N}UXg>WcUuw ½F�çÖ}�~[b^_ohWcUultTcfh�>ª�a�ohTcN}g@{}TCWcUuYVg>WcTco~KQ|�TVg·TcNQUŶFÌ>g>WcgSqN}gm^*WnUXRQWcUuYVUuK�TcPSTcohg@KÀTcN}UXg>WcUuw®��©�U�lXP>K�{QYcU�TcNQU�ltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QYLqHw�PSRQR_o~K}|�TcN}UXg>WcUuwg>WvTcN}U\|>UuK}UXWZP>f~ohíXUu^ltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QYLqHwPSR_R_o~K}|bTcN}UXg>WcUuw�ª�RQWcg:«>Uu^o~K�¶FUultTcohg@K»[S�¾ÎÅg>jyTcNQUJéK�TVUXWnK}UXTŶm{}RQR_f~UuwxUuK�TX�´}g>W : ³<°sÿ��Vþ*±P� °sÿ ; �Vþ ; ±ZªùfhUXTÅÃb Ø�.c>° : ±��kU�TcN}U �u�X���V�x�>�p�X n�S�_�¢���Q§m�¢����£m�S���_���g>j : H<o��çU>�hªùÃb Ø�.c>° : ±bo~YbTcN}U�Yc{}�yYVUXT�g>j��¯o~K�ÿËYc{QlZN*TcN_PSTbTcNQUXWcU�Utýmo~YcTcYbP�YcUu¬�{}UuK_ltU��� 2 ³�4|6ì[8�·o~K»ÿ�a�ohTcN�þ¯°�� 2 ���k±��-�P>KQ^�þ�;s° : °�� 2 ±y� : °��6±V± à���m�

�>���b�:�8�b���S��9,�¨�S� °¢ltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QYVqHwPSRQR_o~KQ|�TcN}UXg>WcUuwz±�© ��� 2 k ����� °sÿ��Vþ*± �S�y�: ³y°sÿW�Vþ*±!� °sÿ ; �Vþ ; ± �p�O���c�¡�r§m¥L�5GXûh��g0�¢��� d�° � �»ÃI ���c>° : ±V±��M�b� ���}�t�R: ° � 2}±!k: ° � ± ¨�>���b�:�8�b���S��9,��9,� °�|>UuK}UXWnP>f~ohíXUu^»ltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QYVqHwPSRQR_o~KQ|·TcN}UXg>WnUuw�±d? �X��:¯�S�y��: 2��4p6ë[8� Gn�����n�¡�Z§m¥V�5Gtû~�O�r§m�y u�¢���S�}����Z£@£º���%$ °sÿ��Vþ*± ���y�s� °sÿ#;��Vþ�;h± ¨ ? �u�E���m��¥L�S�b$��°sÿ ; �Vþ ; ± Gn���u�5£m�>¥L�5GXûh�d¨ ? �u� ¤ GZ�����m���X�u�b�L� � ��� ÿ �r§Q t�¼���F�>�,: 26°��:2}±C� : °��k±�t�>��ûü�b�X�S¥z�t�>����X��&X§_�t�º Z� ���32e³<4�6Ä[8� g0����� �:2f� � ��� ÿ ¨ © �~� 2fk � ���°sÿ��Vþ*± �S�y� d�° � � ¤ ±��M�b� ���m�X�I: 2º° � 2Q±!k : ° � ± ��� °sÿ ; �Vþ ; ± ¨��g>TVU\TcNQPST ¤ ��ÃI ���cS° : ±iohj : 2v� : j�g>W3P>fpf540ª@YVgbTcNQPST0²­N}UXg>WnUuwë½F�çÖ}�çÖ�ltg@K�TcP>o~KQY�kg>TcN®²­N}UXg>WcUuw�Y�½F�çÖ}�~[�P>KQ^*½F�çÖ}�¾½P>Y�YcRºUulXopP>fºlXP>YcUuYX�

132[e32gfh+¡ô�iVB,jdkvBC9EDF;@Gs?I9W+JLK¤g>Wn^}UXWùTVg�PSRQR_fh��TcN}Uvltg@K�TcopK�{}g@{_YLqHwPSRQR_opK}|\PSRQRQWcg@P>lZN¤TVg­UuYVTcPS�_fpo~YcN¤YVTVgmlnNQP>YcTco~lrqRQWcgmltUuYcY�f~o~wo~TcYXª3aEU�K}UXUu^�o~K_ohTco~P>fCYcTVgFlZNQP>YVTco~lrqsRQWngFltUuYcYxfpo~wohTcY�o~KÁûªvTcNQUzR_WcgF^_{QltTYVR_P>ltU�à ® �(Ã8ê ÑIÑIÑ ê»Ã g>WÅYVg@wxU�g>TcN}UXWÅYVR_P>ltU>ªkP>KQ^*aEU�K}UXUu^»j¢{QKQltTco~g@KQY�wPSRQqR_o~K}|�Ã*ªmà ® g>WETcNQU�g>TcN}UXW]YVR_P>ltU�opK�TVg�à TcN_PSTCRQWcUuYcUXWc«>U�ltg@K�«>UXWc|>UuKQltU>�]²­N}U�o~K_ohTco~P>ff~o~wo~Tio~Yvg>j�TVUuK1zbg@KQYcÌ>UXW�ÀÔYvTcN}UXg>WnUuw,g>WCP¤|>UuKQUXWnP>f~ohíuPSTcohg@Kg>jko~TIH�YVUXUbMON_PSRQTVUXWnY0Ö�P>K_^¥�� ¶mo~K_ltU�a]U�PSWnU�opK�TVUXWcUuYcTVUu^¿opK»g>�QTcP>opKQo~K}|�YcTVgFlZNQP>YVTco~lrqsRQWngFltUuYcY¤fpo~wohTcYXªyTcN}U�j�{QK_lrqTcohg@KQYERQWcUuYVUXWn«Fo~KQ|�ltg@K�«>UXWc|>UuK_ltUÅw�{QYVTE�kU�Ã�qs«¡P>f~{QUu^WnPSTcN}UXW]TcNQP>K.­3qs«¡P@fp{}Uu^®g>WT­ ® q«¡P>fp{}Uu^6�iJéK�TcNQopY0YVUultTcohg@Kxa]U­o~^}UuK�Tcohj��¤�_«>U\�_P>YcoplEj¢{QKQltTco~g@KQYij�Wcg@wÕÃ,g>WCà ê¤Ã TVg�ÃTcNQPST\lXP>K��kUb{QYcUu^�TVgxUuYcTcPS�_f~o~YcNzK}UXa�YVTVgmlnNQP>YcTco~lrqsRQWcgmltUuYcY\f~o~w�ohTcYCj�Wcg@w |@oh«>UuKzg@K}UuYX³

Page 15: Í¡Ö - Columbia Universityww2040/framechno.pdfÍ¡Ö ×3Ø ÙbÚbÛ0ÜCÝ¦Þ ß#Û3Ø Üáà3Ý Ùbâ*Ü ã¹äOÝ å TcN}U Ð Ê TVg>Rkg@fhg>|> ¯o~K¹g>Wn^}UXW TVg¿ ºU PS _fhU

Þ�ßml�ßnHWLmÜEàdHpo¹à�H#Dx×­Û#FuäED L [I�5¥P>^Q^_ohTcohg@K6ª3ltg@wxRkg@YcohTcohg@KùªiYc{QRQWcUuw�{Qw�ªiWcU�q_UultTcohg@KÑP>KQ^Áo~K�«>UXWnYVU>�*²�N}UuYVUzj�{QK_ltTcohg@KQYa�opf~f_�kU�lXPSWcUXj¢{Qf~f~��Utý}P>wo~K}Uu^®opK»MONQPSRQTVUXWnY¤[u`�P>KQ^�[u½F�²�N}U �@�@�S�¢�¢���S����Z£ TcPSÌ>UuY�°�� ���Q±T�»Ã-ê®Ã-o~K�TVgv��+f�ºª}a�N}UXWcU

°���+×�}±t°�¾c±!���3°�¾V±,+×�k°�¾c±y� ¾�6��h/ °�ÎF�~[d±²­NQU  n�S��£m�¡�r���¢���S�¼��Z£ TcPSÌ>UuY�°�� ���Q±T�»Ã-ê�Ã-opK�TVgv� Ì �yª}a�N}UXWcU

°�� Ì �}±t°�¾c±!���3°��k°�¾c±V±y� ¾T6Q�h/ °�ÎF�¾`@±²­NQU �Z§:£y¥c�t��§m����Z£ TcPSÌ>UuY��]�»Ã�opK�TVgv�>r@ª}a�N}UXWcU

� r °�¾V±!� Yc{QRA�»ts�»�¼ �3°��¡±y� ¾�6Q�j/ °�ÎF�¾½@±²­NQU�°�g@K}UtqHYco~^}Uu^ùª}g@K}UtqH^Qo~wxUuK_Ycohg@KQP>f�± ¥c�`u­�c u�¢���S����Z£ o~KQ^}UtýTcPSÌ>UuY��O�*Ã�o~K�TVgbv3°��k±Zªya�N}UXWcU

v3°��6±!����+ ° º � Í ��± r � ¾T6U��� °�ÎF�çÖ�±a�o~TcN¼°�� Í ��±t°�¾c±����3°�¾V± Í �m�C²­N}U ����9S�X¥n�u� wPSR»TcPSÌ>UuY��Ào~K�TVgv� � Ê ªQa�N}UXWnU

� � Ê °�¾c±!��o~K}jy���6Q�x³c�3°��¡±�=�¾y�c� ¾T6Q�h/ °�ÎF�¾Î@±¸�UX|@{Qf~PSWnohT5�xltg@KQ^QohTcohg@K_YvPSWcU�WnUu¬�{Qo~WcUu^o~Kxg>WZ^}UXWCj�g>WCTcN}Ubltg@wxRkg@YcohTcohg@K1� Ì �xo~K¿°�ÎF�¾`@±P>KQ^·TcN}U\o~K�«>UXWnYVUT� � Ê o~K�°�ÎF�¾Î@±<TVgb�kUufhg@KQ|�TVg¤ÃOH�TcN}g@YVU\ltg@KQ^QohTco~g@KQYIa�o~f~f>�kUOYVRkUulXoÇ�_Uu^o~KÀMONQPSRQTVUXW�[u½F��©�U�a�o~f~f6P>fpYVg�YVRkUulXohj���TcN}U·^Qg@wP>o~K®j�g>WbTcN}U�j¢{QKQltTcohg@K_Y�o~K®Ã]HºTcN}Ultg@wwg@K®lXP>YVU·opY�­�²�� ° �r�y³e±Z�²�N}U�|>UuK}UXWZP>f]op^}UuP»o~Y·TcNQPSTXª0�F�¯YVg@wxU�wxUuP>KQYuª0aEU�NQPu«>U�P>fhWnUuP>^}��UuYVTcPS�_f~opYcN}Uu^ltg@K�«>UXWc|>UuKQltU�o~K�^Qo~YcTVWnoh�_{}Tco~g@K

w 2 kxw o~K Ã �P>KQ^®aEU¤a�opYcN�TVg�^}Uu^Q{_ltU¤TcNQPST

y °`wÎ2Q±!k y °`w®± o~K Ãj�g>W�g@K}UÀg>j�TcN}U�j¢{QKQltTco~g@KQY y PS�kgd«>U>��îE�á«Fo~WcTc{}U¿g>j·TcN}U�ltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QYLqHwPSR_R_o~K}|TcN}UXg>WnUuw g>WxTcN}U»¶FÌ>g>Wcg@N}gm^ÑWcUXRQWcUuYcUuK�TcPSTcohg@KÑTcNQUXg>WcUuw�ªEo~T�Yc{ÅÞ�ltUuY�TVg¼YcN}g:a�TcNQPSTy ³�ÃÆ��ÃÕo~Y3wxUuP>Yc{QWnPS�_fhU\P>KQ^�ltg@K�Tco~K�{Qg@{QY0PSTvP>f~fb�O�O}·ª@a�NQUXWcU*d�°`w �O}ű��ë[S�&E¬�{Qo~«¡P>fhUuK�Tcfh�>ªOo~K.P>^_^QohTcohg@K�TVgÁTcN}U¿wxUuP>Yc{}WnPS�yo~f~ohT5�>ª]ohTzYc{rÞ�ltUuY�TVgÁYnN}gda-TcNQPST yRQWnUuYVUXWc«>UuY¤ltg@K�«>UXWc|>UuKQltU�opK¿Ã]H<os�çU>�hªùTcNQPST y °��32}±�� y °��k±ba�N}UuK}UX«>UXWC�:2O�Û�¯j�g>W�]�O}�ª_a�N}UXWcUCd�°`w �O}¤±!�ë[S�

Page 16: Í¡Ö - Columbia Universityww2040/framechno.pdfÍ¡Ö ×3Ø ÙbÚbÛ0ÜCÝ¦Þ ß#Û3Ø Üáà3Ý Ùbâ*Ü ã¹äOÝ å TcN}U Ð Ê TVg>Rkg@fhg>|> ¯o~K¹g>Wn^}UXW TVg¿ ºU PS _fhU

[I�@ï ×3Ø�ÙbÚbÛ0ÜCݦÞ�ß#Û3Ø�Üáà3Ý�Ùbâ*Ü�ã¹äOÝ�å²­N}UXWnU�TVUuKQ^QYETVg��ºU�WcUuf~PSTcoh«>Uufh�fpohTVTcfhU�^QoýÞ�lX{QfhT5��ohjS} opYCP�Yn{}�_YVUXTEg>jùltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QYj�{_KQltTcohg@KQYXªO�_{QTaEU¿PSWcU»R_Wno~wPSWnopfh�¹o~K�TVUXWcUuYVTVUu^Ëo~K�TcNQU*lXP>YVUÀo~Kea�NQo~lnNeTcN}U*f~opwohTNQP>Y�^_o~Ycltg@K�Tco~K�{_ohTcohUuYX�0¸bY�o~f~fp{QYVTVWnPSTVUu^��F�z&výmP>wR_fhU�½F�¾½F�~[·j�g>W�P>^_^QohTcohg@K6ª}a�N}UuK��7à�w�ª<TcN}Ux�_P>Yco~l�j¢{QKQltTco~g@KQY¤g>j�TVUuK¼PSWcU�K}g>T·ltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QY�o~K�|>UuK}UXWnP>fs�©�U�w�{QYVT¤TcN}UuKo~^}UuK�Tcohj��·P>KPSRQR_Wcg>RQWno~PSTVU\Yc{Q�_YVUXT!}Ëo~Kxûª�P>KQ^�aEg>WnÌ�N_PSWn^}UXW0TVg�^}Uuwg@KQYVTVWnPSTVU\TcNQPSTltg@K�«>UXWn|>UuKQltU�opY\o~KQ^}UXUu^�RQWnUuYVUXWc«>Uu^6�5¿P>K���PSRQR_f~oplXPSTcohg@KQYig>jºopK�TVUXWcUuYcT3P>ltTc{_P>f~fh�·^QgÅKQg>Tvo~K�«>g@f~«>UOltg@K�«>UXWc|>UuKQltU�RQWcUuYVUXWcq«¡PSTco~g@Keo~KÑYc{QlZNeP�Yco~wxRyfhUz^_ohWcUultT�j�g>WZw P>YPS�kgd«>U>��JLKQYVTVUuP>^6ªETcN}U®f~o~w�ohTcY�o~K�«>g@f~«>U Z�X�_�H�t¥r���b$ �0JLK�TcNQUb^}UXTVUXWZwo~KQo~YcTco~l\j�WnP>wxUXa]g>WcÌ¿°�g>�QTcP>opK}Uu^�PSj�TVUXW\o~K�«>g>ÌFopK}|·TcNQU¤¶FÌ>gSqWcg@N}gm^�WcUXRQWnUuYVUuK�TcPSTco~g@K�TcN}UXg>WcUuw�±Zª_aEU�g>j�TVUuK»YcTcPSWcT­a�ohTcN

c�2º°��:2 º �6±<�Ü� o~K à � °�ÎF�¾Ï@±a�N}UXWcURc�21��³Ëª}j�Wcg@w�a�N_o~lnN�a]U�lXP>K»^QUu^Q{QltU¤TcNQPST

�32��Ü� o~K à / °�ÎF�[¥>±´}Wcg@w%°�ÎF�[¥>±Oa]U�lXP>K»^Qo~WcUultTcfh��^QUu^Q{QltU¤TcNQPST

y °�� 2 ±!� y °��6± o~K ÃRQWcg:«Fo~^QUu^»TcNQPST y RQWnUuYVUXWc«>UuYÅltg@K�«>UXWn|>UuKQltU>��¢�gda]UX«>UXWuªùa]U·aOP>K�T¤wxg>WnU>�b©�U�aOP>K�TTVg�^}Uu^Q{_ltU¤TcNQPST c 2 ° y °�� 2 ± º y °��6±V±��-( o~K à °�ÎF�¾ï@±P>KQ^®o~^QUuK�Tcohj���TcNQU�f~o~wohT�(}�v©�U·a�o~f~fºaOP>K�T�TVg�YcN}g:a TcNQPST·°�ÎF�¾Ï@±­o~wxR_f~o~UuYÅ°�ÎF�¾ï@±Z�²­N}U�ltg@w�wxg@K»lXP>YVU·o~Y\j�g>WP�*o~K¼°�ÎF�¾Ï@±´¶º°�ÎF�¾ï@±�TVg��ºU¤f~opK}UuPSWuª}o��çU>�hªQj�g>W

�h� Ð Ä�� a�N}UXWcU Ð �j­ìP>KQ^jÄ��»Ã�a�ohTcNjÄ�°�¾V±!�M¾"j�g>W�P>f~f�¾�/©�UxlXP>f~fITcN_PSTbTcNQU�lXP>YVU�g>j û ���k�c�S¥ Z�X�_�H�t¥r���%$ �b©�U�a�o~f~f<ltg@KQYco~^}UXW��kg>TcN*f~opK}UuPSWbP>K_^K}g@KQf~opK}UuPSW\ltUuK�TVUXWnopK}|}�²­N}U�YVTVgmlnNQP>YVTcopl�PSRQR_fpo~lXPSTcohg@KQY\a�ohTcN»ltUuK�TVUXWno~K}|zPSWcU·f~UuYcY�YcTVWnP>oh|@N�TVj�g>WcaOPSWn^6�\©�Uwoh|@N�T­YVTcPSWcT­a�ohTcN wR2vkx{ o~K Ã?� °�ÎF�¾Í@±a�N}UXWcU wR2v� Ð � Ê2 ° � 26°�4S¾c± º ÃÅ4S¾c±y�F¾T6Q���j�g>W�YVg@wU¿YVTVgmlnN_P>YVTco~l¿RQWcgmltUuYcYVUuYO� � 2k°�¾c±À³�¾Y6 �b�@� � oh«>UuK¦°�ÎF�¾Í@±Zª�a]U*a�o~YcNeTVg^}Uu^Q{QltU¤TcN_PST | 2vk~} o~K à °�ÎF�~[I��±

Page 17: Í¡Ö - Columbia Universityww2040/framechno.pdfÍ¡Ö ×3Ø ÙbÚbÛ0ÜCÝ¦Þ ß#Û3Ø Üáà3Ý Ùbâ*Ü ã¹äOÝ å TcN}U Ð Ê TVg>Rkg@fhg>|> ¯o~K¹g>Wn^}UXW TVg¿ ºU PS _fhU

Þ�ßml�ßnHWLmÜEàdHpo¹à�H#Dx×­Û#FuäED L [I�@ÍP>KQ^»o~^}UuK�Tcohj���TcN}U�f~o~w�ohTER_WcgFltUuYnY�}Äj�g>W| 2v� Ð � Ê2 ° y ° � 2Q±t°�4S¾c± ºh� 4S¾c±y� ¾T6Q��/ °�ÎF�~[>[d±²<g�PSRQR_f~��TcN}U�ltg@K�«>UXWc|>UuKQltUtqsRQWnUuYVUXWc«SPSTcohg@K¿WcUuYc{QfhTcYOa�ohTcN�ltUuK�TVUXWZo~K}|}ªQa]U�lXP>K®fhUXT

�:2k°�¾V±!�,°�4�Ãy± � Ê � 26°�4S¾V±y� �3°�¾V±��0Ä�°�¾c±!��¾�� c�2���4�Ã7� Ð 2P>KQ^�P>YnYc{QwxUxTcNQPSTν c�2,½3� ³Ë�x²­NQU�a��çRù�~[�WcUXRQWcUuYcUuK�TcPSTcohg@K¼g>jETcN}Uxa]UuPSÌ�ltg@K�«>UXWcq|>UuKQltU·o~K¼°�ÎF�¾Í@±O�mohUuf~^QY

c�2º°��32 º �6±!�Üõ a��çRù�~[ o~K ÃÙ�a�NQUXWcU]õ(o~Y�^Qo~YVTVWno~�_{}TVUu^.P>Y�{À� ²­N}UÀltg@K�«>UXWc|>UuKQltUtqsRQWcUuYcUXWc«¡PSTco~g@K WcUuYc{_fhTÀ°V°�ÎF�¾Ï@±o~wR_f~ohUuYÅ°�ÎF�¾ï@±V±\TcNQUuK��Fo~Uuf~^QY

c�2"° y °��32}± º y °��6±ã±u�~� a��çRù�~[ opK ÃÙ/ °�ÎF�~[u`@±©�U�TcN�{_YvK}UXUu^xTVg�WnUuf~PSTVU­TcN}U­UuYcTcPS�_f~o~YcNQUu^�a��çRù�~[\ltg@K�«>UXWc|>UuKQltUÅo~K®°�ÎF�~[u`@±0TVg�TcN}U^}UuYnohWcUu^Àltg@K�«>UXWn|>UuKQltU�o~KÀ^Qo~YcTVWnoh�_{}Tco~g@K»o~K�°�ÎF�~[I��±Z�²­NQopYbfpP>YVT¤YVTVUXR¯^}UXRkUuKQ^QYb{}Rkg@KTcN}U¤j¢{QKQltTco~g@K y �E²<go~f~fp{QYVTVWnPSTVU>ª}Yc{}R_Rºg@YcU>ªQP>Y­o~Y\TcN}U�lXP>YcU�j�g>W­TcN}U�Yc{}R_WcUuw·{_w�P>KQ^WcU�qyUultTcohg@K�w�PSR_YEopK*°�ÎF�¾½@±EP>KQ^*°�ÎF�çÖ�±Zª}TcN_PST y °�Ä:±��FÄÅP>KQ^ y o~YEN}g@wxg>|>UuK}UXg@{_YXª}o��çU>�hªTcNQPST y °�Ï%�k±!�0Ï y °��k±+j�g>W �]�»Ã P>KQ^ ÏR=Q��/

²­NQUuK c�2u° y °��:2Q± º y °�Ä:±ã±,� Ð � Ê2 ° y ° � 2_±t°�4S¾V± º Ã�4S¾�±c/²­NF{QYXª}{QK_^}UXWOTcN}g@YVU�ltg@KQ^Qo~Tcohg@KQYOg@K y ª_aEU�lXP>K®^QUu^Q{QltUÅTcNQPST·°�ÎF�~[I��±­N}g@f~^QY]j�g>W | 2o~K¼°�ÎF�~[>[d±\a�ohTcN � �ÙîP>KQ^U}Ä^Qo~YVTVWno~�_{}TVUu^�P>Y���o~K¼°�ÎF�~[u`@±Z�JLKÀPSRQR_f~oplXPSTcohg@KQYXªºg@{}WÅRQWno~w�PSWc��|>g@P>f3g>j�TVUuK�opY�TVg�g>�QTcP>opK¿ltg@K�«>UXWc|>UuKQltU�o~KÀ^Qo~YLqTVWno~�_{}Tcohg@K�j�g>W�PYcUu¬�{}UuK_ltU�g>j3WcUuP>fÇqs«SP>f~{}Uu^�WZP>KQ^}g@w «SPSWno~PS�yfhUuYXª}j�g>W�a�NQoplnN�a]U�g@KQfh�K}UXUu^.TVgÁltg@K_Yco~^}UXW�TcN}U*ltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QY�w�PSRQR_o~K}|�TcNQUXg>WcUuw a�ohTcN�WcUuP>fhqs«¡P>f~{QUu^ej¢{QKQlrqTcohg@K_YX��¢�gda]UX«>UXWuªQohTvopY0g>j�TVUuKzltg@K�«>UuKQohUuK�TCTVg·lXPSWnWc��g@{}TvTcN}U­R_Wcg>|>WnP>wÕopKxTHa]g·YVTVUXRyYX³©�UbYVTcPSWcTva�o~TcNP�´<M*{F²áo~Kxà j�g>W]P�YVUu¬F{}UuKQltU�g>jº�yP>Yco~l\YVTVgmlnNQP>YcTco~l­RQWngFltUuYcYcUuYCYc{QlZNP>Y]WnP>KQ^Qg@w,aOP>fhÌFYu�0©�UbTcNQUuK�PSRQRyfh��TcN}Ubltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QYLqHw�PSRQR_o~K}|�TcN}UXg>WcUuw a�ohTcN�TcN}UÌmo~KQ^Åg>j}j¢{QKQltTcohg@K_Yùltg@KQYco~^QUXWcUu^�N}UXWnUvTVg�g>�QTcP>opK�K}UXaÁ´<M�{m²CÀÔY<j�g>WiTcN}Uv�_P>Yno~lvYVTVgmlnNQP>YVqTco~lÅR_WcgFltUuYnYVUuY­o~K�PSRQRyf~ohUu^zRQWcg>�_PS�yo~f~ohT5��wxgm^}Uuf~YXª}Yc{QlZN®P>Y�¬F{}Uu{}UtqHf~UuK}|>TcN®YVTVgmlnNQP>YcTco~lRQWngFltUuYcYcUuY­o~K®P¬F{}Uu{}UuopK}|xwxgF^QUuf��C¸�j�TVUXWcaOPSWn^QYuªQaEU�g>�QTcP>o~K®^}UuYnohWcUu^�f~o~w�ohTcY]j�g>WbP>YLqYVgmlXo~PSTVUu^¯WnP>KQ^}g@w8«SPSWno~PS�yfhUuYÅg>j\o~K�TVUXWnUuYVT��F�ÀPSR_R_fh�mo~K}|�TcN}U�ltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QYLqHwPSR_R_o~K}|TcN}UXg>WnUuw�PS|@P>o~K�a�ohTcNzWcUuP>fÇqs«SP>f~{}Uu^�j¢{QKQltTcohg@KQY]g>jio~K�TVUXWnUuYVTX�v²­N}Ub�yKQP>fºwPSR®wPd���kUTcN}UOYco~wR_fhU0g@K}UtqH^QopwxUuKQYcohg@K_P>f@RQWcg¡æVUultTcohg@K�wPSR � ¼ºwPSRQR_o~KQ|P�]�®ÃÕo~K�TVg`�i°�¾c±��j­ ®a�NQUuK×­!®¹o~Y�TcNQU®WnP>K}|>U�g>jbTcN}U®j¢{QKQltTcohg@K_Y�opK�ûª]TcN}U®Pu«>UXWZPS|>U]¾ � Êt� ¼A �i°��S± t �»g>WYVg@wUXTcNQo~K}|wxg>WnU�ltg@wxR_f~o~lXPSTVUu^ù�

Page 18: Í¡Ö - Columbia Universityww2040/framechno.pdfÍ¡Ö ×3Ø ÙbÚbÛ0ÜCÝ¦Þ ß#Û3Ø Üáà3Ý Ùbâ*Ü ã¹äOÝ å TcN}U Ð Ê TVg>Rkg@fhg>|> ¯o~K¹g>Wn^}UXW TVg¿ ºU PS _fhU

[>[I� ×3Ø�ÙbÚbÛ0ÜCݦÞ�ß#Û3Ø�Üáà3Ý�Ùbâ*Ü�ã¹äOÝ�å132[�32���=�1ù÷69CG��}÷º;@Gs?<9ì?�i�;@óvôY��?i?��©�U»K}g:a�UtýFRyP>KQ^�{}Rkg@KÁTcN}U�^}UuYcltWnohR_Tcohg@KÁg>j�TcN}U�g>Wc|@P>K_ohíuPSTcohg@KÑg>jbTcN}U��kg�g>Ì|@oh«>UuK�PSTxTcN}U�UuKQ^Ág>jbTcN}U�RQWcUXj¢P>ltU>�¹¸bYxo~KQ^Qo~lXPSTVUu^¹TcN}UXWcU>ªETcN}U��kg�g>̯N_P>Y��_j�TVUXUuKlnNQPSR_TVUXWnYXª6a�NQoplnN¿lXP>K*�kU·Wcg@{}|@NQfh��|>Wng@{}RkUu^*o~K�TVgzj�g@{}WÅR_PSWnTcYXªyg>WZ^}UXWcUu^ÀP>lXltg>Wn^Qo~KQ|TVgÁopKQltWcUuP>Yco~KQ|¹^Qo�ÞzlX{QfhTH�>�(²­N}U ZC¥n�t�­£}�S¥r� ªÅltg@K�TcP>o~KQo~K}|¹TcN}U*�_WnYVTx�y«>U¿lZNQPSRQTVUXWnYXªRQWcg:«Fo~^QUuY\P>K»o~K}j�g>WnwP>fko~K�TVWcgm^Q{QltTcohg@KzTVgzYVTVgFlZNQP>YVTco~lrqsR_WcgFltUuYnY�f~o~w�ohTcYOP>KQ^�TcN}UuohW�PSRQqR_f~o~lXPSTco~g@K�TVg�¬�{QUu{}UuYX�MONQPSR_TVUXWÀ[*UtýmRºg@YcUuY�TcNQU¿YVTcPSTcopYVTco~lXP>fbWcUX|@{Qf~PSWZohTH�eP>YcYcgFlXo~PSTVUu^�a�ohTcNáPÁwP>ltWcgSqYcltg>R_o~l®«FohUXa�g>j¤{QK_ltUXWcTcP>o~K�TH�>ªOa�ohTcNePSR_RQWcg>RQWnopPSTVU�YnlXP>f~o~K}|}ª]«FopPÀR_fhg>TcYxg>jÅWnP>KQ^Qg@wa]P>f~ÌFYXªCg>�QTcP>o~K}Uu^Áj�Wcg@w%UufhUuwxUuK�TcPSWc�¹YVTVgmlnN_P>YVTco~l�Yco~w�{Qf~PSTcohg@K_YX�Y¸�UuwPSWcÌSPS�_fh�>ªvTcNQUR_fhg>TVTVUXW­P>{}TVg@w�PSTco~lXP>f~fh�z^}g�UuY]TcN}UÅRQWng>RºUXWOYclXP>f~opK}|·a�N}UuKzaEUÅR_fhg>TOTcN}Ub�_WZYVT�4ÀYVTVUXR_Yg>jùTcN}UbWnP>KQ^}g@wÕa]P>f~Ìj�g>W]«SPSWnohg@{QYC«¡P>f~{QUuYCg>j,40�0²­NQU�R_fhg>TcYETVUuKQ^�TVgxfhg�g>ÌxTcNQU�YcP>wxUj�g>W¤P>f~f�4¹Yn{rÞ�lXohUuK�Tcfh�®f~PSWc|>U>ªkYcN}g:a�o~K}|�TcNQPSTÅTcN}UXWcU�w·{_YVT��kU�P�YVTVgmlnN_P>YVTco~lrqsRQWcgmltUuYcYf~o~wo~TX�·´}g>W�WZP>KQ^}g@w aOP>fhÌFYÅa�ohTcN¿JcJØz�YVTVUXRyY¤NQPu«mo~K}|�o~Km�ºKQohTVU�«¡PSWnopP>KQltU>ªùTcN}UxR_f~g>TcYYcN}g:a-TcN_PSTzTcNQU¿f~opwohTRQWngFltUuYcY�w�{QYVT�NQPu«>U�æc{QwxR_Yuª­o��çU>�hª�^Qo~Ynltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QYzYcP>wxRyfhUR_PSTcNQYX�MONQPSR_TVUXW�`�YcN}gda�Y\TcNQPST\TcN}U�PS�_YcTVWnP>ltT­WnP>KQ^Qg@w aOP>fhÌmY­ltg@KQYcop^}UXWcUu^�o~K®MONQPSRQTVUXW[ÅNQPu«>U�{_YVUXj�{_fyPSRQRyf~o~lXPSTcohg@KQYu�0MON_PSRQTVUXW­`�^Qo~YclX{QYnYVUuYEPSR_R_f~o~lXPSTcohg@K_YCTVgYVTVgmlcÌzRQWnopltUuYXªTcN}U|Á¤g@f~wxg>|>g>Wngd«�qé¶mwohWnKQgd«áYcTcPSTco~YVTco~l�P>KQ^�¬F{}Uu{}Uuo~KQ|Áwxgm^}Uuf~Yu� MONQPSRQTVUXW®`ÑP>f~Ycg^Qo~YclX{_YcYVUuY3TcN}U­UuKQ|@o~K}UXUXWno~KQ|ÅYnoh|@KQoÇ�ylXP>K_ltU]g>jkTcN}U­¬F{}Uu{}UuopK}|¤wxgF^QUuf~YvP>KQ^�TcN}U�N}UuPu«F��qTVWnP8Þ�lfpo~wohTcYX��²­N}UxUuK}|@opK}UXUXWno~K}|�Ycoh|@K_oÇ�ylXP>KQltUxo~Y¤o~fpf~{QYVTVWnPSTVUu^¿�F�¿PSR_R_f~o~lXPSTcohg@K_Y�TVg�_{mÆkUXWvYcohíuo~KQ|ÅopK�KQUXTHa]g>WcÌxYVa�ohTclZN}UuYvP>KQ^xYVUXWn«Fo~ltU­YnlnN}Uu^Q{_f~o~K}|bj�g>WEw·{Qf~TcohR_fhUOYVg@{}WnltUuYu�²­N}UORQWnUuYVUuK�T0lZNQPSRQTVUXWuª}MONQPSRQTVUXWC½Fª�opK�TVWcgm^Q{QltUuYiTcN}U\wPSTcNQUuwPSTco~lXP>f}j�WnP>wxUXa]g>WcÌj�g>W\YVTVgmlnN_P>YVTco~lrqsRQWcgmltUuYcYOf~o~w�ohTcYXª�o~K�«>g@fh«mo~K}|�TcNQUbltg@KQltUXR_TEg>jùa]UuPSÌ�ltg@K�«>UXWc|>UuKQltU¤g>j<PYVUu¬F{}UuKQltU¤g>jiRQWcg>�_PS�_opf~ohTH�wUuP>Yc{}WcUuY\g@K»PxYVUXR_PSWnPS�_f~UÅwUXTVWno~lÅYVR_P>ltU�P>KQ^®TcN}UÅj�{QK_lrqTcohg@K¿YVR_P>ltU�Ã8ltg@K�TcP>o~K_o~K}|�YcTVgFlZNQP>YVTco~lrqsRQWngFltUuYcYÅYcP>wR_fhU�RyPSTcNQYX��5*UXTVWno~lXYÅo~KQ^_{QlXo~K}|TcN}U�¶FÌ>g>Wcg@NQgF^ÁÉ}Ê�P>KQ^�Ð.ʤTVg>Rºg@f~g>|@ohUuYÅg@K�à PSWcU^QUt�yK}Uu^6��¸�KÀg:«>UXWc«Fo~UXa,g>jETcNQUltg@K�TcopK�{}g@{_YLqHwPSRQR_opK}|»PSRQRQWng@P>lnNÁTVg*UuYcTcPS�_f~o~YcN¯YVTVgFlZNQP>YVTco~lrqsR_WcgFltUuYnYxf~o~wohTcY�o~Y�P>f~Ycg|@oh«>UuK6�MONQPSR_TVUXW�ÖÁRQWcg:«Fo~^QUuY�P>Kágd«>UXWc«mohUXa g>j�UuYVTcPS�_fpo~YcN}Uu^eYcTVgFlZNQP>YVTco~lrqsRQWngFltUuYcY�f~opw�qohTcYX�¿²­N}UuYVU�YVTVgmlnNQP>YVTcoplrqsRQWcgmltUuYcY�f~o~wohTcY·PSWcUzg>j�o~K�TVUXWcUuYVT·opK¯TcN}Uuo~W·g:a�K¯WZoh|@N�TXª0�y{}TTcN}UX�¹P>fpYVg�YVUXWc«>U®P>YxYVTcPSWcTcopK}|ÀRºg@opK�TcY�o~K¹TcN}U®ltg@K�Tco~K�{Qg@{QYLqHwPSRQRyo~K}|*PSR_RQWcg@P>lnNÑTVgUuYVTcPS�_f~opYcN�K}UXaËYVTVgmlnNQP>YVTcoplrqsRQWcgmltUuYcYOf~o~wohTcYu�i²­NQU­j�{_KQ^QP>wxUuK�TcP>f_YVTVgmlnN_P>YVTco~lrqsRQWcgmltUuYcYf~o~wo~T�o~Y­R_Wcgd«mo~^}Uu^*���jzbg@KQYcÌ>UXW�ÀÔYÅTcN}UXg>WcUuw�ªka�N_o~lnN»a]P>YÅ^Qo~YnlX{QYcYVUu^*o~K¿MON_PSRQTVUXW�[S�²­N}U®g>TcNQUXW�YVTVgmlnNQP>YcTco~lrqsRQWcgmltUuYcYzf~o~wohTcYxPSWnU®|>UuK}UXWnP>f~o~íuPSTcohg@KQYg>jCzbg@KQYVÌ>UXWeÀÔY�TcN}UXgSqWcUuw���ÈÅjvR_PSWcTco~lX{_f~PSWbopK�TVUXWcUuYcTbj�g>W¤TcN}Uxf~o~w�ohTcY­a�o~TcNæc{QwxRyYXªºopY�TcNQU�|>UuKQUXWnP>f~ohíuPSTcohg@Kg>j!zbg@KQYVÌ>UXW�ÀÔYbTcN}UXg>WcUuw-o~K»a�NQo~lZN�TcN}U�WZP>KQ^}g@w�qsaOP>fhÌ�YVTVUXR_YbPSWcU�JnJØz¦a�ohTcN®o~Km�ºKQohTVU«¡PSWZo~P>KQltU>�i©ËN}UuK�TcN}UOWnP>K_^}g@w�qsaOP>fhÌ�YVTVUXR_Y0NQPd«>U\Yc{QlnN�N}UuPd«���qsTcP>o~fhUu^�^QopYVTVWnoh�_{QTcohg@KQYXª

Page 19: Í¡Ö - Columbia Universityww2040/framechno.pdfÍ¡Ö ×3Ø ÙbÚbÛ0ÜCÝ¦Þ ß#Û3Ø Üáà3Ý Ùbâ*Ü ã¹äOÝ å TcN}U Ð Ê TVg>Rkg@fhg>|> ¯o~K¹g>Wn^}UXW TVg¿ ºU PS _fhU

Þ�ß��>ßëäOÝRMOÙ�D�FT�kÙ�Û#FuäED�ä\àìÛ3Ø�Ü���ä�äOå [>[>[TcN}U�f~o~w�ohT¤RQWcgmltUuYcY�o~Y·P¿YVTcPS�_f~UR{d�UX«F�¯wxg>Tco~g@KÁopK¼TcN}U�lXP>YVU�g>j�P¿Yco~K}|@fhU�YVUu¬�{QUuKQltUg>W�P¼|>UuK}UXWnP>fP{d�UX«F��RQWcgmltUuYcYopKÑTcN}U®lXP>YVU»g>jÅP�TVWnopP>K}|@{Qf~PSWPSWcWZPu�Ñg>W�^}g@{}�yfhU�YVUtq¬F{}UuKQltU>�¼©�N}UuKÑTcN}UuYcU�fpo~wohT�R_WcgFltUuYnYVUuYxPSWcU�K}g>Txî]Wcgda�K_o~P>KÑwxg>Tcohg@K6ªvTcNQUX�¹NQPd«>U^QopYcltg@K�TcopK�{}g@{_YxYcP>wxR_fhU�RyPSTcNQYX�á²�N}U®YVTVgmlnNQP>YVTcoplrqsRQWcgmltUuYcY�fpo~wohTcY�a�ohTcNÀæV{QwR_Yxo~KTcN}U�f~o~wohT3RQWngFltUuYcYCUtýFRyf~P>o~KYVg@wU�g>jkTcN}U0æc{QwxRyY0g>�_YVUXWc«>Uu^�o~KxTcN}UbYco~w�{Qf~PSTcohg@K�Ryfhg>TcYo~K»M\NQPSRQTVUXW�[S�{d�UX«���RQWngFltUuYcYcUuY�PSWcU®«>UXWn�ÑYcRºUulXopP>f\�kUulXP>{QYVU®TcN}UX��NQPd«>U*o~K_^}UXRkUuKQ^}UuK�T�opKQltWcUtqwxUuK�TcYX�]M\NQPSRQTVUXW\ÖP>f~YVg^_o~YclX{QYcYcUuY]YcTVgFlZNQP>YVTco~lrqsRQWngFltUuYcY�f~o~wo~TcYEo~K�a�NQo~lnN�TcNQU�f~o~wohTRQWngFltUuYcY�NQP>Y�^}UXRkUuKQ^QUuK�T�o~K_ltWcUuwxUuK�TcYX�z²�N}UxRQWno~K_lXohR_P>f3YVTVgmlnNQP>YVTcoplrqsRQWcgmltUuYcY·fpo~wohTcYg>jOTcNQo~Y�ÌFo~K_^¼o~K�«>g@fh«>U�ltg@K�«>UXWc|>UuKQltU�TVg»j�WnP>ltTcohg@KQP>fEî]Wcgda�K_o~P>K¼wxg>Tcohg@K¹P>KQ^¯fpo~K}UuPSWj�WnP>ltTcohg@KQP>fiYVTcPS�_f~U�wxg>Tco~g@K6�¤²­N}UuYVU�f~o~wo~T­RQWcgmltUuYcYVUuYba�ohTcN¿^}UXRkUuKQ^}UuK�T�opKQltWcUuwxUuK�TcYPSWnopYVUCa�NQUuK�TcN}UXWnU]o~YiYVTVWcg@KQ|b^}UXRkUuKQ^QUuKQltUEo~K·TcN}UOltg@K�«>UXWn|@o~K}|¤YVTVgmlnNQP>YVTcoplCRQWngFltUuYcYcUuYX�²­NQUuYVU\R_PSWcTco~lX{_f~PSWvf~o~wo~T<RQWngFltUuYcYcUuYvNQPu«>Ubltg@K�TcopK�{}g@{_YvYcP>wxR_f~U]RyPSTcNQYXª�YVg�TcN}U­TVg>Rkg@fÇqg>|>�¿g@K¼Ã opY¤K}g>T�ltWnohTco~lXP>fs����UX«>UXWcTcN}UufhUuYnYXª<f~o~Ì>U�NQUuPu«F�*TcP>o~fpYXªIYVTVWcg@KQ|�^QUXRºUuK_^}UuKQltUNQP>Y�P¿^}WnP>wPSTcopl�o~wR_P>ltT·g@KÁTcN}U�YVTVgmlnNQP>YcTco~lrqsRQWcgmltUuYcYxf~o~w�ohTXªilZNQP>K}|@o~KQ|*�kg>TcN¹TcN}UYclXP>fpo~K}|xP>KQ^�TcN}U·f~o~wohT]RQWcgmltUuYcYX�M\NQPSRQTVUXW�μRQWcgd«mo~^}UuYxP>Káo~K�TVWcgF^_{QltTcohg@KÑTVg¹NQUuPu«F��qsTVWnP8Þzl»f~o~w�ohTcY�j�g>Wz¬�{QUu{}UuYX�²­N_o~Y��_WnYVT�¬F{}Uu{}Uuo~K}|ÑlnN_PSRQTVUXW»j�gFlX{_YVUuY�g@K PÑ|>UuK}UXWnP>f�qº{Qo~^�¬�{QUu{}U�wxgF^QUufÅTcNQPSTlXPSRQTc{QWcUuYTcN}U*UuYcYVUuKQltU¿g>j�wP>K��ewxg>WcUtqH^}UXTcP>opfhUu^.¬F{}Uu{}Uuo~KQ|¼wxgF^QUuf~YX��²­NQo~YNqy{Qo~^¬F{}Uu{}U�wxgm^}Uuf3o~Y�UuYcRºUulXopP>f~fh��UuP>YV�*TVg®P>KQP>fh�FíXU��kUulXP>{QYcU·TcN}Uxltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QYLqHwPSR_R_o~K}|PSRQR_Wcg@P>lnN¹a�ohTcN�TcNQU�WcU�q_UultTco~g@K¹wPSRÑlXP>K¹�ºU�PSRQR_f~ohUu^¯^QohWcUultTcfh�>�»¶FUultTco~g@K¹ÎF�¾Î*^}UtqWno~«>UuY�YclXP>fpo~K}|j¢{QKQltTcohg@K_YXª_UtýmRQWcUuYcYcUu^»P>Ybj�{_KQltTcohg@KQY�g>j0TcN}U·TVWZP8Þ�l·opK�TVUuKQYnohTH��o~K»TcN}U¬F{}Uu{}U>ªEa�NQo~lZN¹R_Wcgd«mo~^}U�o~KQYnoh|@N�T�o~K�TVg�¬�{}Uu{QUuo~K}|ÀRkUXWcj�g>WZwP>KQltU>�ÑÂvWcgFg>j�YxPSWnU�RQWcgSq«mo~^}Uu^zo~K�MONQPSRQTVUXW\ÎFª}�_{}TETcN}UÅUuwxR_NQP>YcopYEo~YEg@KzTcN}U¤YVTcPSTVUuwxUuK�T­P>KQ^�PSRQR_f~o~Uu^«SP>f~{}Ug>jºTcN}U�N}UuPd«���qsTVWnP8Þ�l�f~o~wo~TcY3WnPSTcN}UXWvTcNQP>KTcN}U­TVUulnN_KQo~lXP>f_^QUXTcP>o~f~YX�3²­NQo~Yi�yWnYVT0¬�{QUu{}Utqo~KQ|®lnNQPSRQTVUXW�UuwxR_N_P>YcohíXUuY�TcNQU�lXf~P>YcYno~lXP>fvî]Wcgda�KQo~P>K¯PSR_RQWcguý}o~wPSTco~g@K.°¢o~K�«>g@fh«FopK}|®PWcU�qyUultTVUu^Áî]Wcg:a�KQo~P>K¹wxg>Tcohg@KÁf~o~wo~T¤RQWcgmltUuYcYZ±Z�»²­NQU�«SP>f~{}U�g>j\TcNQUzî]Wcg:a�KQo~P>K¹PSR}qRQWnguý}o~wPSTcohg@K�o~Y\o~fpf~{QYVTVWnPSTVUu^zo~K�TcN}U�¶FUultTco~g@K»ÎF�¾ïFªQa�NQoplnN�^Qo~YclX{_YcYVUuYOohTcY\PSRQR_fpo~lXPSTcohg@KTVg*R_f~P>K¼¬F{}Uu{}Uuo~KQ|»Yco~w�{Qf~PSTcohg@K_YX³�²­N}U�N}UuPu«F��qsTVWZP8Þ�l�YnlXP>f~o~K}|�RQWngF^Q{_ltUuY�P»Yno~wxR_fhUPSRQR_Wcguý}o~wPSTcohg@Kj�g>WETcN}U�Ycopw·{QfpPSTcohg@K�Wn{QKf~UuK}|>TcNWcUu¬F{QohWnUu^xTVg·P>lZNQohUX«>UÅ^}UuYcohWcUu^�YVTcP¡qTco~YcTco~lXP>fkRQWcUulXo~Ynohg@K6ª}P>Y�P�j¢{QKQltTcohg@K�g>j0wxgm^}UufkR_PSWZP>wxUXTVUXWnYX�²�N}U �X�n n�S�º�]£m�S¥t� ª�ltg@K�TcP>o~KQo~KQ|bMONQPSRQTVUXWZY<ÏT¶x[I�mª>YcN}gdaÑN}g:aÁ{QK_wPSTclnN}Uu^\æV{_wxR_YlXP>K¼PSWZo~YVUxP>KQ^ÀUtýmR_P>KQ^QYbTcN}UxTVWcUuPSTcwUuK�T�g>jO¬F{}Uu{}Uuo~K}|�wxgm^}Uuf~YX�xMONQPSRQTVUXW�Ïz|@o~«>UuYYVUX«>UXWZP>f3UtýmP>wxRyfhUuY�g>j]YVTVgmlnNQP>YVTcoplrqsRQWcgmltUuYcY¤f~o~wo~TcY­a�ohTcN¿{QKQw�PSTclnN}Uu^�æc{QwxR_Ybo~K*TcN}Uf~opwohTxRQWcgmltUuYcYX�(JéKËP>f~f�TcN}U¿UtýmP>wxRyfhUuY�o~T�o~Y�g>��«mohg@{QY�TcNQPSTzUuohTcN}UXW�TcN}UXWcUÀPSWcUÀK}gæc{QwxR_Y�o~K®TcNQU·YcP>wxRyfhU�R_PSTcN_Y�g>jvTcNQU·ltg@K�«>UXWc|@o~K}|�RQWcgmltUuYcYVUuY�g>WÅTcN}U\æc{QwxRyY�o~K»TcN}Ultg@K�«>UXWc|@o~K}|zRQWcgmltUuYcYVUuYbPSWcU�P>YV�mwxRQTVg>Tco~lXP>f~f~�®K}UX|@f~oh|@oh�yfhU>�O©ËNQPSTÅo~YbK}g>T�Ycg�g>�F«Fo~g@{QYo~Y�TcNQPSTÅTcN}U�f~o~wohT\R_WcgFltUuYnY�P>ltTc{QP>fpfh�»lXP>KÀNQPu«>U�^Qo~Ynltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QY�YcP>wxR_f~U�R_PSTcNQYu�b¸bYo~K»M\NQPSRQTVUXW�[Sª_Yno~w·{_f~PSTcohg@KQYOPSWcU�{_YVUu^�TVgRQWcg:«Fop^}U�ltg@K�«mo~KQlXopK}|�UX«Fo~^QUuKQltU>�M\NQPSRQTVUXW~¥�ltg@K�Tco~KF{}UuY�TcNQUgd«>UXWc«mohUXa g>jOYcTVgFlZNQP>YVTco~lrqsRQWngFltUuYcY�f~o~w�ohTcYb�ºUX|@{_K¼o~K

Page 20: Í¡Ö - Columbia Universityww2040/framechno.pdfÍ¡Ö ×3Ø ÙbÚbÛ0ÜCÝ¦Þ ß#Û3Ø Üáà3Ý Ùbâ*Ü ã¹äOÝ å TcN}U Ð Ê TVg>Rkg@fhg>|> ¯o~K¹g>Wn^}UXW TVg¿ ºU PS _fhU

[>[u` ×3Ø�ÙbÚbÛ0ÜCݦÞ�ß#Û3Ø�Üáà3Ý�Ùbâ*Ü�ã¹äOÝ�åMONQPSRQTVUXWCÖ}�0J5T0�yWnYVTv^Qo~YnlX{QYcYVUuY3RQWngFltUuYcYOM�{m²CÀÔYXª@a�NQo~lnN�PSWcU�ltUuK�TVWnP>f_f~opwohT3TcN}UXg>WcUuwYj�g>W®PSR_RQWcg>RQWnopPSTVUufh�eYclXP>fhUu^�Yc{_wYzg>j�WnP>KQ^Qg@w�Uuf~UuwxUuK�TcY®g>j·Ã*�ÕÂvWcgmltUuYcY»M�{m²CÀÔYR_f~Pd�*P>K�o~wxRkg>WcTcP>K�TÅWcg@fhUxo~K¿N}UuPu«F��qsTVWnP8Þ�lYVTVgmlnN_P>YVTco~lrqsRQWcgmltUuYcY�fpo~wohTcY�j�g>W�¬F{}Uu{}UuYa�ohTcNYn{}RkUXWcRkg@YcohTcohg@KxPSWcWZoh«¡P>fQRQWcgmltUuYcYVUuYXª�a�N}UuKTcNQU�K�{_w��kUXWCg>jùltg@wRºg@KQUuK�TCPSWnWnoh«SP>fRQWcgmltUuYcYVUuY­opKQltWcUuP>YVUuY­opK�TcN}U�N}UuPd«���qsTVWnP8Þ�l·f~o~wohTX�²­N}UuK MON_PSRQTVUXW]¥Á^Qo~YclX{_YcYVUuY�M�{m²CÀÔY�P>KQ^�´<M�{m²CÀÔY�j�g>W®ltg@{QK�Tco~K}|ÑRQWcgmltUuYcYVUuYu�²­N}UX�ÀPSWcU�YcNQgda�K�TVg»�ºUxUu¬F{Qoh«SP>fhUuK�T¤TVg»ltg>WcWcUuYcRºg@K_^Qo~K}|�f~o~wo~TcY�j�g>W�R_PSWnTco~P>fvYc{Qw�YX�MONQPSRQTVUXW�¥bltg@KQlXfp{Q^}UuYi����PSRQR_fh�mo~K}|�TcN}U­ltg@K�TcopK�{}g@{_YLqHwPSRQR_opK}|�PSRQR_Wcg@P>lnN�a�o~TcN·TcNQUltg@wxRkg@YcohTcohg@K�P>K_^®o~K�«>UXWnYVU�wPSRyYXª}TVg>|>UXTcN}UXWba�ohTcN�UuYVTcPS�_fpo~YcN}Uu^�YVTVgmlnN_P>YVTco~lrqsRQWcgmltUuYcYf~o~wo~TcYiopK�MONQPSRQTVUXWCÖ}ª�TVg�UuYVTcPS�yf~o~YcNxYVTVgmlnN_P>YVTco~lrqsRQWcgmltUuYcY]f~o~wo~TcY<j�g>WvWcUuKQUXa]P>fÇqsWnUXa]PSWn^YVTVgmlnNQP>YVTcopl·R_WcgFltUuYnYVUuYX��²�N}U·Ð Ê TVg>Rkg@fhg>|>�®Ryf~Pu�mY�P>K¿o~wxRkg>WcTcP>K�T�Wng@fhU·o~KÀMONQPSRQTVUXW¥�� ²­N}U�WcUuwP>o~KQopK}|xlnNQPSRQTVUXWZY�o~K®TcN}U�YVUultg@KQ^*R_PSWcT�PSRQR_fh�zTcN}U�YVTVgmlnN_P>YVTco~lrqsRQWcgmltUuYcYf~o~wo~TcYXª�a�o~TcN�TcN}U¤ltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QYLqHwPSR_R_o~K}|�PSRQRQWcg@P>lZN6ª}TVg�g>�QTcP>o~K�wxg>WcU¤N}UuPd«���qsTVWnP8Þ�lf~o~wo~TcY\j�g>WŬF{}Uu{}UuYX��¸bYbo~K¿MON_PSRQTVUXWÅÎFªùMONQPSR_TVUXWnYbï�¶�[I��UuwxR_N_P>YcohíXU�TcNQU·PSRQR_fpohUu^«¡P>fp{}U�g>j�TcN}U�YVTVgmlnNQP>YVTcoplrqsRQWcgmltUuYcYf~o~w�ohTcYXªi�_{}T�K}gda wxg>WnU�PSTVTVUuK�Tcohg@KeopY�|@oh«>UuKÑTVgTVUulnNQK_o~lXP>fO^}UXTcP>o~f~YX��MONQPSRQTVUXWxï*ltg@KQYco~^}UXWZY·P¿wxg>WcUtqH^}UXTcP>opfhUu^¹w�{QfhTcohqHYVg@{}WnltU�g@KmqsgSÆqy{Qo~^}qH¬�{}Uu{QU�wxgm^}UufvTcNQPST�NQP>Y��kUXUuK¯R_Wcg>Rkg@YVUu^¼TVgÀUX«SP>f~{QPSTVUzTcN}U�RkUXWcj�g>WnwP>K_ltU�g>jltg@ww�{QKQo~lXPSTcohg@K�KQUXTHa]g>WcÌFYu�e²­NQPSTwxgm^}UufOo~f~f~{_YVTVWnPSTVUuY�N}gda�N}UuPu«F��qsTVWZP8Þ�l®f~o~w�ohTcYlXP>K»UtýmRkg@YVU�TcNQU�UuYcYVUuK�Tco~P>fIj�UuPSTc{}WnUuY�g>jvltg@wxRyfhUtý®wxgF^QUuf~YX�O²­NQo~Y­YcUultg@KQ^*¬F{}Uu{}UuopK}|lnNQPSR_TVUXW·P>f~YVg®^_o~YclX{QYcYcUuYbKQg@KmqHlXf~P>YcYcoplXP>f0PSRQRQWcgdýmo~w�PSTcohg@KQYÅo~K�«>g@fh«FopK}|�WcU�q_UultTVUu^¼YVTcP¡q�_fhU~{��UX«��*wxg>Tcohg@KÀP>KQ^*WcU�q_UultTVUu^¿j�WZP>ltTcohg@KQP>fiîEWngda�KQopP>K*wxg>Tco~g@K6ªºYcTVUuwwo~K}|�j�Wcg@wN}UuPu«F��qsTcP>o~fhUu^®R_Wcg>�_PS�_o~fpohTH��^_o~YVTVWnoh�y{}Tcohg@KQYEP>KQ^®YVTVWcg@KQ|�^}UXRkUuKQ^}UuKQltU>�MONQPSR_TVUXW�Í¿j�gmlX{QYVUuY�g@K�YVTcP>K_^QPSWn^�Yco~KQ|@fhUtqHYVUXWc«>UXWx¬F{}Uu{}UuYXªEa�NQo~fhU�MONQPSRQTVUXW®[I�j�gmlX{QYVUuYCg@K�YVTcP>K_^QPSWn^w�{QfhTcoÇqHYcUXWc«>UXWC¬F{}Uu{}UuYX�3JLKP>^Q^QohTco~g@KxTVg�TcN}UbYVTcP>KQ^QPSWn^�N}UuPu«F��qTVWnP8Þ�l�f~o~w�ohTcYXª_a]Uxltg@KQYco~^QUXWbN}UuPd«���qsTVWnP8Þ�lxfpo~wohTcYbo~K*a�NQo~lZN»TcN}U�KF{Qw��kUXWbg>jEltg@w�qRkg@K}UuK�T\PSWcWZoh«¡P>fºRQWngFltUuYcYcUuY\o~K�PxYc{}RkUXWcRkg@YcohTcohg@K�PSWcWnoh«SP>fºRQWcgmltUuYcYOg>W\TcN}U�KF{Qw��kUXWOg>jYVUXWc«>UXWnY�o~K¹P*w�{QfhTcohqHYVUXWc«>UXW�¬�{}Uu{QUzo~K_ltWcUuP>YVUuY�o~K¼TcN}U�N}UuPd«���qsTVWnP8Þ�l�f~opwohTX�®²­N}g@YcUf~o~wo~TcY<TVUuK_^xTVg�lXPSRQTc{}WcU�TcN}U\�kUuNQPu«mohg>W0g>jkYV�FYcTVUuwY0a�ohTcNxfpPSWc|>U­K�{_w��kUXWnY3g>jkYVg@{}WnltUuYg>W�YVUXWn«>UXWnYX�²­N}U ������¥V�·£m�>¥r� ªkltg@K�TcP>opKQo~K}|�MON_PSRQTVUXWnY�[>[ ¶À[tÖ}ªyopY­^}UX«>g>TVUu^*TVg�TcN}U�TVUulZNQKQo~lXP>fj�g@{_KQ^QPSTcohg@KQY�K}UXUu^}Uu^�TVg¼UuYcTcPS�_f~o~YcN.YVTVgFlZNQP>YVTco~lrqsR_WcgFltUuYnY�f~o~w�ohTcY�a�ohTcN�{QK_wPSTclnN}Uu^æV{_wxR_YÅo~K¿TcN}Uxf~o~wo~T�RQWngFltUuYcYu�·²­N}U�TcNQo~Wn^»RyPSWcTÅ�ºUX|@opKQYba�ohTcN¼MONQPSRQTVUXW[>[SªIa�NQo~lZNRQWcg:«Fo~^QUuYvwxg>WcUb^}UXTcP>o~f~Y0g@K�TcN}U�wPSTcNQUuwPSTco~lXP>fyj�WnP>wUXaEg>WcÌ�j�g>WEYVTVgmlnN_P>YVTco~lrqsRQWcgmltUuYcYf~o~wo~TcYXª�UtýmR_P>KQ^_o~K}|x{}Rkg@K�TcN}U��QWZohUXj<o~K�TVWcgm^Q{QltTcohg@K�o~K»M\NQPSRQTVUXW�½F�MONQPSR_TVUXW»[u`ÀRQWcUuYcUuK�TcYxTcNQU®�_P>Yco~l�TcNQUXg>Wc�¹j�g>WTcN}U»j�{QK_ltTcohg@K�YVR_P>ltU®Ã*�.´}g@{}WTVg>Rkg@fhg>|@ohUuYbPSWcU�ltg@KQYcop^}UXWcUu^®g@K*û³OYVTVWcg@KQ|�P>KQ^�a]UuPSÌ®«>UXWnYnohg@KQY­g>j3TcN}U�Ð Ê TVg>Rºg@fhqg>|>�ËP>K_^áYVTVWng@K}|�P>KQ^ËaEUuPSÌá«>UXWnYcohg@KQYzg>j·TcN}U�Ð7*TVg>Rkg@fhg>|>�>�Õ²­N}UÀYVTVWcg@KQ|ÑP>K_^aEUuPSÌÁTVg>Rkg@fhg>|@ohUuYx^QohƺUXW�a�N}UuKÁTcN}U�j¢{QKQltTcohg@KQY�NQPd«>U�WnP>K}|>U�­!®¼j�g>Wb��=Ä[S�¯²­NQUYVTVWcg@K}|¿TVg>Rkg@fhg>|@ohUuY�PS|>WcUXU�a�ohTcN¯TcN}UzYcTcP>KQ^QPSWn^¯TVg>Rºg@f~g>|@ohUuY�^}Ut�yK}Uu^¯���Á¶mÌ>g>Wcg@N}gm^

Page 21: Í¡Ö - Columbia Universityww2040/framechno.pdfÍ¡Ö ×3Ø ÙbÚbÛ0ÜCÝ¦Þ ß#Û3Ø Üáà3Ý Ùbâ*Ü ã¹äOÝ å TcN}U Ð Ê TVg>Rkg@fhg>|> ¯o~K¹g>Wn^}UXW TVg¿ ºU PS _fhU

Þ�ß��>ßëäOÝRMOÙ�D�FT�kÙ�Û#FuäED�ä\àìÛ3Ø�Ü���ä�äOå [>[u½°L[uÍ>Î>Ï@±Zª6a�N_o~fhUÅTcN}U�a]UuPSÌ®TVg>Rkg@fhg>|@ohUuYbPS|>WcUXU�a�ohTcN�TcNQU�RQWcgm^Q{QltT�TVg>Rºg@f~g>|>�>ªyWcUX|@PSWZ^mqo~KQ|�ÃÀ°�° �r�G�P±´��­ ® ±­P>YbTcN}UN��qsj�g@f~^»R_WcgF^_{QltT­g>jvTcN}U�YVR_P>ltUxÃÀ°�° �r�G�P±´��­]±�a�ohTcN*ohTcYVUufhjé�²­NQU�Ð TVg>Rkg@fhg>|@ohUuY¤PSWcU^}Ut�ºK}Uu^ÀP>KQ^ÀlnNQPSWnP>ltTVUXWZohíXUu^¯o~K¼MON_PSRQTVUXW[u`F��²�N}UxwP>o~Ko~^QUuP>Y�|>gz�_P>lcÌ*TVg�¶mÌ>g>Wcg@N}gm^Á°L[uÍ>Î>Ï@±Zªù�y{}T�wxg>WnU�^}UXTcP>opf~Y�PSWnU·RQWngd«mo~^}Uu^»NQUXWcU>�b´Qg>WUtý}P>wxR_fhU>ªyYVUX«>UXWnP>fi{QYVUXj¢{Qf6P>fhTVUXWnKQPSTco~«>U·lnN_PSWnP>ltTVUXWnohíuPSTcohg@K_Y�g>j3TcN}UuYcU�TVg>Rkg@fhg>|@ohUuY�PSWcU|@oh«>UuK,H}U>�ç|}�hªyYVUXU�²�N}UXg>WcUuwÄ[u`F�¾ÎF�~[S�M\NQPSRQTVUXWÅ[u½�j�gmlX{QYVUuY]g@K�TcNQUb{QYcUXj�{Qf_j�{_KQltTcohg@KQYEj�Wng@w Ã�g>W\à êÃ�TVgxà o~K�TVWcgSq^Q{_ltUu^�o~K�¶FUultTcohg@K�½F�¾ÎFªFa�NQo~lnNRQWcUuYVUXWc«>UÅltg@K�«>UXWc|>UuKQltUÅa�ohTcN�TcN}UŶFÌ>g>Wng@N}gF^�TVg>Rkg@fhgSq|@ohUuYuªyP>KQ^»TcN�{QY�j¢P>lXo~f~ohTcPSTVU·TcN}U·ltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QYLqHwPSR_R_o~K}|PSRQR_Wcg@P>lnN*TVg�UuYcTcPS�_f~o~YcN»K}UXaYVTVgmlnN_P>YVTco~lrqsRQWcgmltUuYcY�f~o~wohTcYu�C¸�Y�o~f~f~{_YVTVWnPSTVUu^�o~K�TcN}U·¬�{}Uu{QUuo~K}|lnN_PSRQTVUXWnYXªyTcN}U�j¢{QKQlrqTcohg@K_Y<o~KxMONQPSR_TVUXW][u½blXP>K��kU]ltg@w·�_o~K}Uu^·a�ohTcN�TcN}U\´<M�{m²CÀÔY3o~KxMONQPSRQTVUXWiÖbTVgbg>�_TcP>o~KwP>K���K}UXaìYVTVgmlnNQP>YcTco~lrqsRQWcgmltUuYcY�fpo~wohTcYX�²�N}U�TcNQohWn^ÁR_PSWcTltg@K_lXf~{Q^}UuY�a�o~TcNÁP��yKQP>fOlnNQPSR_TVUXW�g@K�¬F{}Uu{}UuYX³»MONQPSR_TVUXW»[tÖUuYVTcPS�yf~o~YcN}UuY�N}UuPu«F��qsTVWnP8Þ�lÀf~o~wo~TcYj�g>WzK}UXT5aEg>WnÌFY�g>j�¬F{}Uu{}UuYu�(²­N}U*UtýFTVUuK_Ycohg@KËTVgK}UXT5aEg>WnÌFY¤g>jO¬F{}Uu{}UuY¤o~K¼MONQPSR_TVUXW[tÖ®o~Y¤wxg>WcUxltg@wxR_fpo~lXPSTVUu^��kUulXP>{QYVU>ªù{QK_f~ohÌ>U�TcN}Ug@K}UtqH^_o~wxUuKQYco~g@KQP>fmWcU�q_UultTcohg@K�wPSR�{_YVUu^xj�g>WEYco~KQ|@fhU­¬�{QUu{}UuYXª�TcNQU�w�{QfhTco~^QopwxUuKQYcohg@K_P>fWcU�qyUultTcohg@K*w�PSR¿o~Y�K}g>TÅYco~wxR_f~�zltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QYbo~K®TcN}U�Ð Ê TVg>Rkg@fhg>|>�>��¢�gda]UX«>UXWuªIohT�o~Yltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QYXª3{QYco~KQ|®TcN}U�R_WcgF^_{QltT�Ð Ê TVg>Rkg@fhg>|>�>ªvPST·P>f~fEf~o~wo~T¤j�{QK_ltTcohg@KQY¤a�o~TcN}g@{}TYcopw·{Qf~TcP>K}UXg@{QY<æc{QwxR_Y]g>j3g>RQRkg@YcohTVU�Yco~|@K�o~K�ohTcY­ltgFg>Wn^Qo~K_PSTVU¤j�{QK_ltTcohg@KQYX�²�N}U �t�>§F¥t���¿£m�S¥t� ª\ltg@K�TcP>o~K_o~K}|�g@KQfh�ÁTcN}U��yK_P>f\lnNQPSRQTVUXWdª­M\NQPSRQTVUXW»[uÎFª\o~K�TVWcgSq^Q{_ltUuYCK}UXaáj�{QK_ltTcohg@KYVR_P>ltUuY]f~PSWc|>UXWETcNQP>K�Ã*�0²­N}UuYVU�YVR_P>ltUuYXªmlXP>f~fhUu^ ¤ P>K_^b�xªFPSWcUo~K�TVUuKQ^}Uu^zTVgxUtýmRQWcUuYcYOf~opwohTcYEj�g>W­YVUu¬F{}UuKQltUuYOg>j3YVTVgmlnNQP>YcTco~lÅRQWcgmltUuYcYVUuY]a�ohTcNzg@YclXopf~f~P¡qTcohg@K_Y\o~K�TcN}UuohW�YnP>wxR_fhUÅR_PSTcNQY�YVgx|>WcUuPST�TcN_PST­TcN}UXWcU�o~Y\KQgf~o~wohT\o~K�Ã*�C²­N}U�K_P>wxUuYPSWcU·lnN}g@YVUuK®�ºUulXP>{_YVU�g>jiTcN}U�g>Wn^}UXWZo~K}|w��.Ã�� ¤ �*� /�����:�! #"��O�,�(�S�����%�¯�>�¢��9¡�>�¢���S�¼�X�S¥À���m�¿�H£m�@ Z�t� ¤ �S�y� � ¨ ¶m{}RQRkg@YVU»TcNQPST�TcN}U4��]�j�{_KQltTcohg@K¿o~K*PzYVUu¬F{}UuKQltU�g>jCltg@K�Tco~KF{}g@{QYbj�{_KQltTcohg@KQY�TcPSÌ>UuYÅTcN}U�«¡P>f~{QU·Ö�o~K*TcN}Uo~K�TVUXWc«SP>f�° �r�n` � Ê º 4 � Ê ±sªOTcN}U®«SP>f~{}U»Î�opK�TcN}U»o~K�TVUXWc«SP>f�°ç` � Ê +F4 � Ê �u[�±bP>KQ^.NQP>Yg@YclXopf~f~PSTcohg@KQY6opK¤TcN}UEYn{}�_o~K�TVUXWc«SP>f�°ç` � Ê º 4 � Ê �n` � Ê +C4 � Ê ±�j�g>W<P>f~f54�6á½F�0¶mRºUulXoh�ylXP>f~fh�>ªa�o~TcNQo~KáTcN}U¯Yc{}�yo~K�TVUXWn«¡P>fv°ç` � Ê º 4 � Ê �n` � Ê +�4 � Ê ±sª¤fhUXT�TcNQo~Y�4 �]� j¢{QKQltTcohg@KË�yWnYVTo~K_ltWcUuP>YVUÅj�Wng@w TcNQU¤«¡P>f~{QU�ÖPST\TcN}U¤fhUXj�TOUuKQ^}Rkg@o~K�T]` � Ê º 4 � Ê TVgÎ¥�ª}TcN}UuK�^}UultWnUuP>YVUTVgz[SªmP>K_^TcN}UuKzo~KQltWcUuP>YcU�PS|@P>o~K�TVg�ηPSTETcNQU�Wnoh|@N�TvUuKQ^QRºg@opK�TE` � Ê +O4 � Ê ªFP>Y]YcN}g:a�Ko~K�´3oh|@{QWcU�½F�¾ÎF�²�NQPSTbYcUu¬�{}UuK_ltU�g>j]ltg@K�TcopK�{}g@{_YÅj�{QK_ltTcohg@KQYbltg@K�«>UXWc|>UuY�Rºg@opK�T5a�o~YVU�TVg�TcN}Uxf~o~wohTj¢{QKQltTcohg@K��j��Öc¯ Ó A Õ �Ô È�â +eÎm¯ Ó �Ô È�Õ Ê�Ö UX«>UXWc�Fa�N}UXWcU�UtýmltUXRQT�Rkg@YcYcoh�_f~��PSTP¾��¦[.�S`Fªy�_{}TohT3^}gFUuY3K}g>T0ltg@K�«>UXWc|>U�o~K·Ã,a�ohTcN�P>K��·g>jQTcN}U�¶FÌ>g>Wcg@NQgF^�TVg>Rkg@fhg>|@ohUuYX�0��UX«>UXWcTcN}UufhUuYnYXªa]Uzw�oh|@N�T·a]P>K�T�TVg¿YcPd�¼TcNQPST�ltg@K�«>UXWn|>UuKQltU®^}gFUuY·o~K¯j�P>ltT�gmlXlX{}Wuª3a�ohTcN¯TcN}U�f~o~wohTYVg@wUuN}gda¦WcUX«>UuP>fpo~K}|�TcN}U�g@YclXo~f~fpPSTcohg@KQYbg>jCTcN}U�j¢{QKQltTcohg@K_YbopK»TcN}UKQUuoh|@N��kg>WnNQg�gm^®g>j¾!�ë[.�S`F�E²�N}U�YVR_P>ltUuY ¤ P>KQ^U�ÕP>f~fhgdaìj�g>W�Yn{QlnN®fpo~wohTcY

Page 22: Í¡Ö - Columbia Universityww2040/framechno.pdfÍ¡Ö ×3Ø ÙbÚbÛ0ÜCÝ¦Þ ß#Û3Ø Üáà3Ý Ùbâ*Ü ã¹äOÝ å TcN}U Ð Ê TVg>Rkg@fhg>|> ¯o~K¹g>Wn^}UXW TVg¿ ºU PS _fhU

[>[tÖ ×3Ø�ÙbÚbÛ0ÜCݦÞ�ß#Û3Ø�Üáà3Ý�Ùbâ*Ü�ã¹äOÝ�å

  ¡¢

£¤

¥

¤ Ô È ¤ Ô È§¦©¨ Ô È¤ Ô È>ª%¨ Ô È£«

´3oh|@{}WcU·½F�¾ÎF³\²­NQU@4 �[� j¢{QKQltTcohg@K*o~K]w1° �r�u[�±3o~K®P�YVUu¬�{QUuKQltU�g>j3j¢{QKQltTcohg@KQY­TcNQPST�ltg@Kmq«>UXWc|>UuY�TVg�PxRQWcg>RkUXW\f~o~w�ohT\o~K�TcN}U�YVR_P>ltU ¤ �_{QTOKQg>T�o~K�TcN}U�YcR_P>ltU�Ã*�JLK ¤ ªiTcN}U�fpo~wohT¤ltg>WcWcUuYcRºg@K_^QY¤TVg»TcNQU�YVUXTLqs«SP>f~{}Uu^¼j¢{QKQltTco~g@K�TcNQPST·opY¤TcN}Ug@K}UtqRkg@o~K�T¤YVUXT~�uÖr��j�g>WC¾C�0° �r�n` � Ê ±Zª6TcN}Uxg@K}UtqsRkg@o~K�T¤YVUXT��:Î%��j�g>WC¾C�Ë°�` � Ê �u[�±�±ÅP>KQ^�opYTcN}U�o~K�TVUXWc«SP>f!°Ç[m�y¥e±iPST�¾<�ë[.�S`F�JLK ¤ ªQTcNQU�f~o~wohTOj¢P>o~f~YOTVg�lXPSR_Tc{}WcU¤TcN}U�g>WZ^}UXW�o~K�a�N_o~lnN�TcN}U¤Rkg@o~K�TcY­PSWcU¤«mo~Yco~TVUu^o~K�TcN}U·K}Uuoh|@N��ºg>WZN}g�gm^zg>jW¾!�,[.�S`F�\²­N}U�YVR_P>ltU%�,UtýmR_fhg@ohTcY­R_PSWnP>wxUXTVWnoplÅWcUXRQWcUuYVUuK}qTcPSTcohg@KQYOTVgP>f~Ycg�lXPSRQTc{QWcUÅTcN}UÅg>Wn^}UXW\o~Kza�NQo~lZN�TcNQUbRkg@o~K�TcYOPSWcUÅ«FopYcohTVUu^6�0²­N}UÅf~PSWc|>UXWYVR_P>ltUuY ¤ P>KQ^N�(PSWcU­|@oh«>UuKTVg>Rºg@f~g>|@ohUuYvYco~w�o~f~PSW3TVg�TcN}U�Ð P>KQ^Ð Ê TVg>Rkg@fhg>|@ohUuY0g@Kû�v²�N�{QY­MON_PSRQTVUXW�[uÎ�^}WnPda�YON}UuPu«mo~fh�z{}Rkg@K�TcN}U¤^}UX«>Uuf~g>R_wxUuK�T\g>jITcN}U�Ð TVg>Rºg@f~gSq|@ohUuY­o~K»M\NQPSRQTVUXW�[u`F��¢�gda]UX«>UXWuª6MONQPSRQTVUXW�[uÎxg@KQfh���kUX|@o~K_YOTVg^}UX«>Uufhg>R®TcN}U�TcN}UXg>Wc�g>j ¤ P>KQ^U��C´Q{}WcTcNQUXW�^}UX«>Uufhg>R_wUuK�T�opY\PxTVg>R_o~lÅj�g>W­j¢{}Tc{}WcU¤WcUuYcUuPSWnlnN6�¸OT�TcNQU�UuKQ^�g>jÅTcN}U®�kgFg>̯TcN}UXWcU*PSWcU®THa]g¹PSR_RºUuK_^Qo~ltUuYX��¸�RQRkUuKQ^QoÇý¹¸-|@oh«>UuY�_P>Yco~lj�P>ltTcY�PS�kg@{}T�WcUX|@{_f~PSWnfh�À«SPSWc�FopK}|�j�{_KQltTcohg@KQYXªia�NQopfhUx¸�RQRkUuKQ^_oÇý¿îÕ|@oh«>UuY�TcNQUo~K�Tco~P>f6ltg@K�TVUuK�TcY�g>jiTcNQU¤JéK�TVUXWnK}UXTb¶}{}RQR_fhUuwUuK�TX�


Recommended