+ All Categories
Home > Documents > >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U`...

>=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U`...

Date post: 23-Jul-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 3 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
42
Transcript
Page 1: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

����������� ������������� ��������� ����� ������������ � ������

��� � !"� #$%� &'���(�)�*�,+-�.����� ��&/�,� �0� 1 � +����*�

2 3547698�:(;*<�=>:�?@8?9A B�6�=>:":DCFEHGI8KJL8(=

MONPM�B/Q.RSLTUQ.VW

X>Y Z\["]_^.`bac^.X>dfeUg,hUifjkalZ\mne[UjpoqjrYp]�^.`pac^.X>dfeUg,hnisjkalZtmUe

u ZtvUjwYyxygzZt[{x|Xr}�~|X{g�vneKxyZ\Y*�7^.ifZt[U^.Z~|X>dfeUg,hUifj0�_[Ui��qZ\Y `)i�x�o� Z�����X>Y �"� � a��0a��t�{�k�>�

� X��qZtg h(ZtY����\�>�k�

� Z.�nis`)Ztm(���7ZthUY enjrY)o>��t�>�{�

� if[nX{Y�Y Z��nif`)ifX>[����7ZtvKxyZ\g,h(Z\Y.�"�t�>�>�

���t�{�w�t�% >¡.¢£�%¤¥  {¡§¦%¤ ¥ ¡.¨.¤{© ¥ �pªp¤>©.�¬«�ªb�r¨.¤>©\��ªb­£®¯ª °w±\� ¥ ¡²¨z³q�t�\�.ªp¤�´�³>ªt��µ)¶/·¹¸

Page 2: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

� �*�_�"���_�(+

� �)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ �

� � jrmnisX>g�Z.x Y is^ u Z���[Ui�x ifX>[U` �

� �7enY)}¹jr^.Z � X>e���U[nZ\`�` � X7mnZ\d �

� � Z�"Zt^px jr[n^.Z � X7mnZtd � ���� ���������������! #"�$&%'��$&�(�*),+($&�-"/.0�213$&"�4��&��%51��&��6�87#$:9;+(�<$�=�>�+<$��-" ?@?8?@?8?@?A?B?A?@?B?A? ��C

����-��� DE�F�-GH��+(�<$I)!JK+(+<��"�>.*+<$&��"ML.-),+(�-�N?A?B?A?@?8?@?@?8?@?8?@?8?@?A?B?A?@?B?A? �-� ����-�PO QR"�+<�F�<�<�TS�*),+($&�-"ULV.�),+<���W?@?8?@?8?@?A?B?A?@?8?@?@?8?@?8?@?8?@?A?B?A?@?B?A? ��X

��PO ���������������!Q595�-+<�(�-6�$I)81�$&"�4��&��%51����-6�A7E$:95+<�<$�=�>�+($&�-" ?@?@?8?@?8?@?8?@?A?B?A?@?B?A? ��Y ��PX ���������������BDZ.*>9<95$:.0"[1��&��6��%\J#�<�*.]7E$:95+<�($&=�>�+($&��" ?8?@?@?8?@?8?@?8?@?A?B?A?@?B?A? �0^ ��_ `#>.0��$&+a.0+<$�b��@���������c?A?@?8?@?8?@?@?8?@?8?@?A?B?A?@?8?@?@?8?@?8?@?8?@?A?B?A?@?B?A? O��

� dEenv(Z\Y ifg�Z\[>x ` � �

� �)g�vndsif^.j\x ifX>[U`�}¹X>Y � jr^*�nis[nZ�f_if`)ifX{[ �>�Y���� gh�*.0��.*"��gh��"���F�<�*�HQ\GM.*4-�*9i?@?@?8?@?8?@?A?B?A?@?8?@?@?8?@?8?@?8?@?A?B?A?@?B?A? O-jY��PO gh�,S�*),+a.0")T�@�i.069k?A?@?8?@?8?@?@?8?@?8?@?A?B?A?@?8?@?@?8?@?8?@?8?@?A?B?A?@?B?A? O-lY��PX mon��-+(�-GH�F+<�<$I)B1�+(���<���p?@?8?@?8?@?@?8?@?8?@?A?B?A?@?8?@?@?8?@?8?@?8?@?A?B?A?@?B?A? X-CY��_ qr$&"s��),>��:.*�!1�+<�F�<���].*"������+<$&��"utv95+<$�GM.0+($&�-" ?A?@?8?@?@?8?@?8?@?8?@?A?B?A?@?B?A? X-O

� �7eng�g�jrY)o � �

w � jrmnisjw[U^.Z X¯}#��`)Xrx Y X{vnif^�� enYy} jr^.Z ��i xx� �7if[2�>dfZ�y �7dfX>v(Z u is` xyY%ifhneKx ifX>[ ��J8�&�zg#.-��$I.0"),�A��>s�8+<�]7#$&�<�x),+hQ\�&��>�GH$�".0+($&�-"M?@?A?B?A?@?8?@?@?8?@?8?@?8?@?A?B?A?@?B?A? X-XJ8�{O|g#.-��$I.0"),�A��>s�8+<�]Q\"�+<���(�<�,S/�*),+<$��-"9T}�?@?8?@?A?B?A?@?8?@?@?8?@?8?@?8?@?A?B?A?@?B?A? X-Y

$

Page 3: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

�������>=>8(4��

� .0G]=V�F�<+P9oGH�����������-� ��$�� >95�!�<�TS�*),+($&�-"]$:9c� �+<��"95$&b������@>9;�*�]$&"M),��GH6�>�+a.0+($&�-"/.0�b�$I9;$��-" �Q\+r$I9 >/9;�*�H� �6��&$I),$&+(���@=�� GH��+<ns����9r95>) n .-9h95n.06�!���<��G 95n.-��$&"�4].*"� 6�n���+<��GH��+<�($:)#9;+(���<������.0"�$&G 6��&$I),$&+(���]=��iGH��+<ns����9!9;>/) n[.�9 =s$&"���),>s�:.0�A95+<���(���u.0"�iGH�-+($&��"i����+(�*),+($&�-" � L��-�A9;��b��F� .0���<�x.0�&%� ���<�I���-=��5�*),+a9�� +<ns� � .0G]=V�F�<+<$I.0"iGH�������o)F.0"[6��<�*b�� +<�M=� .Ub��F���M$&".�)�),>��a.0+(�].06�6��(�� �$�GM.0+($&�-"+<� +<n�� ��$�� >95�]),�-GH6��"���"�+����Wn�$&���8+(n��8=��($&4�n�+("��*9<9h�0� . � .*G =���(+<$I.0"i95>��;�'.�),� $:9h$&"/����6��"���F"�+�0� b�$�� � $&"�4[��$&�<�x),+<$��-"��c+<n��u=��<$�4-n�+<"��x9<98�0�B. �<��>�4-n ��$�� >95�i9;>s�;�'.-)T��$&"/),�<�*.�9;�*9 .�9 +<ns��b�$&� � ���.06s6��<�3.-) n��*9!+<n�� 9;��>�� ),� ��$��<�*),+($&��" �!J ),��GH6��(��n���"95$&b��!G ��������$:9#����b������-6�*� +(n.0+@6��(�*��$I),+ 9h�<��%S�*)T+ .0"/),� ���<��G �(�->�4�n ��$�� >95��95>��;�'.�),�*9T���rns�HGH������� .-)�)T�->�"�+ 9!���-�]),��GH6��&�� �4-�F�-GH��+(�<$I) .0"�� .���$&��GH��+(�<$:)r6sn���"���GH��".@9;>/) nM.�9vGM.�9! �$&"�4���9;n.���� � $&"�4��.0"� $�"�+(���<�(�,S�*)T+<$&��"9o=��+ � ����"]6�-$�"�+a9�-"M+(n��!95>��;�'.�),���ct" �6V�F�<$&G ��"�+a92n.�b��#=V�F��"M),��"��>),+(�*� ��" �(�*.0� 9<.*GH6��&�x9���95>) nU.-9���6s�:.-95+<������),�I.�#�9<.*"�$� .0"� )T�&�-+(n �HJ#�&�o+(n��*9;� 9;>s�;�'.-)T�*98���FGH�-"95+<�a.0+<�]95$&4�"�$�% )F.0"�+8����b�$I.0+($&�-"i���<��G � .0G]=���<+($:.0"=��n.�b�$&�-�F�&�rns� �<�,S�x),+ .*"),�8G �*.-95>��<��G ��"�+a9v��=�+ .*$&"��*�[.0�(� $&"[95+<�<��"�4u.04��<����G ��"�+ � $�+<ni+(n�� �<��%S�*)T+ .0"/),�!6��(�*��$:)T+<�*� =��]+<ns�B6s�<�-6�39;�*�MGH�������'�'�rns�B6/.06���h$:9 ),�-"/),�&>���*� � $&+(nu. ��$:9(),>9<95$&��" ��"+<ns�B$�GH6���$:)�.*+<$&��"9o�0�c+(n��*95�!�<�*95>��&+a9v���-�#GM.-) n�$�"��Eb�$:95$&��" �

$�$

Page 4: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

� !"�_���� ���,&'�����*�

� "��H�*�!+(n��H6��($&GM.*���i4-�3.0�I9 �*�@.�GM.�) ns$&"�� b�$:95$&�-" 9!�s9;+<�FG $I98+<�i�<�x),�*b����!6�n���95$:)�.*�r6��(�-6���(+<$&�x9�0� .i9<)T��"�� ���(�-G $�GM.04��*9,�iQ\GM.*4-�]=��<$�4-n�+<"��x9<98b�.0��>��*9 .0�(�M),����9;�F���[�<���I.0+<�x� +<�i+(n��H�<�TS�*),+a.0"),�6��(�-6���<+($&�*9c�0� 6�-$&"�+ 9r$�"H+<ns�@9<),�F"������#��"),�#��.�)�),>��a.0+<�@�(�,S�*),+a.0")T�EGH�������:9c.0�(�!��>�"��.*GH��"�+ .0�+(�+<ns�h.-��b-.*"),��G ��"�+ �0� GM.�) n�$�"��ob�$:95$&�-" � 13��b���� .*��GH�*) n.0"s$:9;GU9/$�"�b����&b��*�#$&"8+(n��r�(�,S�*)T+<$&��"@6��<��),�x9<9.0�(�8�(��b�$�� � �x� $�"���!.��.0�� ������� %(��l-l��,=���� �2.*4�.*�<�].0"/�����*L�$&4->s��$&�(�*���-%(��l�l����\� �rn��*9;�AGH�*) n.0"s$:9;G 9���-�])T�-GH6�-"s��"�+a9��c)�.*" =�u),�:.�9<95$�%�*�[$&"�+<�i+ � �i=��(��.�� )�.*+<��4��-�<$��*9�� ��$�� >95��.*"�N9;6�*),>s�:.0����� J9;>s�;�'.-)T�r+<n/.0+o��=V����9 � .*G =���(+P9 � . � � � .0G]=V�F�<+<%(�0^xY-C���.*6�6�*.0�a9 ����>.*�&���!=��<$�4-n�+ ���(�-G .0����b�$&� � $&"�4��$��<�*),+($&��"9,� �rn�$:9oGH�����F�����-� ��$ ��>/9;�#�<�,S�x),+<$��-" � .-9c.���b�.0"),�x� =�� � .0G]=���<+c�*b����cO�C-C ���x.0� 9c.*4-�.0"/� �<�FGM.0$�"9v��"��8�*�c+<n��@GH�39;+ � $I������� >9;�*�HGH�������:9r$�" GU.-) n�$&"��Zb�$I9;$&��" � QR+h$I9r>9;�x� � �6��&$I),$&+(���=���95n.06�]�<�*)T�0b��F���H+(�*) ns"�$���>��*9h95>) n[.�9!9;n/.06� ���(�-G 9;n.���$&"�4U.0"�i6�n���+<�-G ��+<�($:)@9;+(���<���s�@Q\+E$I9.0�I9;� $�"�b�� ��*� =��]b�$I9;$&��"M+<�*) n�"�$ ��>��x9v95>) nM.-9r=�$�"���),>��I.0�#95+<���(���].0"�HGH��+<$��-"M���F+<�*),+($&��"H+<�]95�-�&b��+<ns��)T�-�<�(�*9;6��"����")T� 6s�<�-=s�&��Gi� QR"N+(n�� %���I� �0�Z�<��GH��+<� 9;��"/9;$&"s4��c+<n�� � .*G =���(+<$I.0"NGH�������c$I9�0��+(��"[>9;�*�i+<� .06�6s����=s�<$&4�n�+("��*9(9B)T�-�<�(�*),+($&�-"/9 +(�M$&GM.*4-�*9E�*�#+<n��]9(.0GH�]9(),��"��]�-=s+ .0$�"��*�i>�"���F���$ ���F�<��"�+8$��&�&>sGH$&".*+<$��-"[),��"��$&+($&��"9,� �rn�� � $:���*956��<�x.-� >9;�M�*�!+(n�� � .0G]=���<+($:.*" GH������� .0�($:9;�x9���<��G $&+a9h9;$�GH6��&$I),$&+ � .0"�M=V�x)�.0>95�@$&+#�����*9h�<�x.-9;��".0=s��� � ������$�"�.*6�6��(� �$&GU.0+<$�"�4 �<�TS�*),+($&�-"]���<�-G. � $:���!�a.0"�4��8�*�cGM.0+(+<�@95>��;�'.�),�*9T�

L/���!95��b����a.0� �<�x.0�&% � ���<�I� �-=��5�x),+ 9 ��n�� � ��b�������+(n�� � .*G =���(+<$:.*"MGH������� )�.0"u6��<�*b��@+<�H=� .6���-�A.0"/� $&"/.-������>.*+<� .*6�6��(� �$&GU.0+<$��-"M+<� +<n��A��$ ��>/9;�]),��GH6�-"���"�+�� L2$&4�>��<�]��!'.#"#95n�� � 9!. �<�*.*�$&GU.04-�@�*� . )T�:.�Hb�.-95� �-=�+a.0$&"s�*� >95$&"�4U.%$&$ 7 )�.*GH���a.�� �rn��8b�.-95� $:9r$��&�&>sGH$&".*+<�*�]=��M. 9;$&"s4-�&���$I9;+ .*"�+@��$&4-n�+A9;��>�� ),�]$&"[+<ns�H9(.0GH�]��$��<�*)T+<$&��" .�9!+<n�� 9;��"/9;�-�F�ML2$&4�>��<�u��!�='"@95n�� � 98.M�<��"�����<�*�$&GU.04-�]�0� .�b�.-95� � $�+<n +(n��M9(.0GH� 9;n.*6�i.-98+(n��H��"��u9;n�� � "N$&"NL�$&4->s�<�i�(!\.#"a� �rn�$I9B$�GM.04�� $I9�<�F"�����(�*� >/9;$&"s4B+(n�� � .0G]=V�F�<+<$I.0"]GH������� ��.0"/� +<n��Z9<.*GH�h$&���&>�G $&".*+<$&��" ��$��<�*)T+<$&��"].-9c$&"]+<n��Z)�.-95��0� +<n��@�<�x.0� b�.-95���hJ!9h� �6V�x),+<�*� ��+<ns� � .*G =���(+<$I.0"MGH������� 6��<�x��$:),+a9r+<n.*+E+(n��8=s�<$&4�n�+("��*9(9r�0�c+(n��)����&$�"���<$I)�.0�cb�.-95� � $��&�h���*),�<�x.-9;�U.-9 � �u.06�6s�<��.�) n +<n��M��)�)T�&>��$�"�4i=�->�"/��.0�($&�*9 �-" =V��+<n 9;$:���*9,��E� � �Fb�����o+(n����(�*.0�hb�.-95��$I9 b���� � S .*+ $�"W.06s6V�x.0� .*"),�#� $&GM.*4-�M=��<$�4-n�+<"��x9<9 �<��GM.*$&"�$�"�4i.*�&GH�39;+),��"9;+a.0"�+h�0b��F�r+<ns�!��"�+<$&�(�!95>��;�'.�),��� �rn��Zb-.�9;�@$:9 ),�&�x.0�<���*)�+�� � .*G =���(+<$:.*"H$&" �<�,S�x),+ .*"),��,T� �rn������b�$:.*+<$��-" ���(�-G � .*G =���(+<$I.0"�=��n/.xb�$&���E$��&��>9;+(� .0+(�*�M.0=�*b�� )�.*"�=� 95$&4�"�$�% )F.0"�+K�����!. b�.*�<$&�F+!� �0��-+(n����!�(�*.0��% � �-�(�:�iGM.0+(���<$I.0�:9 �9;>) n[.-9 ��),�-")T�<��+(�#� 9<.*"�$��.0"/� ),���-+(n �8J#"[.-)�),>s� .0+(� G ��������+<n.*+���*9(),�<$�=�*98��$ � >9;�H�(�,S�*)T+ .0"/),� ���(�-G 9;>) n ),�-GHG �-"[9;>s�;�'.-)T�*9B$I9B"����x���*� �����8=�-+(n-��>.*�&$&+a.0+($&b��.0"/.0���s9;$I9r�0��$�GM.04��*9r.�9 � ������.�9h.-)�)T>�� .*+<�!�*95+<$�GM.0+($&�-"]�0� 9;>s�;�'.-)T�!6��<��6���<+($&�*9h95>) nU.-9h9;n/.06�A.0"��<�TS�*),+a.0"),�3�

.0/21�3&465(387:9�;=< >&70?�@A5(?�B�3CBEDF4�>F3G4F9�;HDJIK>F?�@LDF1M3N>F3:O(3870D6PQ?�B�?RISPHB(70P=TE3GBUDJ;QPHV�1UDW<RDXD61�3NPHBEDF3G>�I <�703&Y(3GD�Z[3C3GB�D�Z'?@N3\TEP=<�]0I�?�>^PHB�46D_<RB(703�]E< PH>`<RB(TW<RBa?�Y�b03870D�PHBWDF1M324_703CBM3�c�/21�PH4�PQ4�<d4F9�>eI <�703'5�1�3GB�?�@A3CB�?�Bfcg/21�32TEPihj9�463k70?�@A5(?�B�3CBED>F3G4F9�;HDF4lIK>F?�@m;HPHV�1EDn>_<\oE42D61(< D25�3CB�3CD6>_<RDF3W;=<\o�3G>F42? I�DF1�3�469�>�I <�703�]�9�B(T�3C>FV�?&@&9�;HDFPH5�;H3[>630O(387:DFPH?�B�4�< B(TA>630IK>_<�70DFPH?�B�48]< B�T�>630p�3C@N3C>6V�3q< DrDF1M3q4F9�>eI <�7:3�cs/21�PH4&@N38761(<RB�PH4F@tPH4N< ;H4F?u>F3:IK3C>F>638TsD6?�< 4rY(?�TEov>F30O(3\70DFPH?�Bfc*wE3C3�xzyk<\oE< >q{0|} ~i� pC�8���M�CY^]�/n< VE< >F3�< B(T�TE3\�^PHV�9�3CPH>F38T�? pC�8���M�0�gIK?�>ST�3CD_<RPQ;H4\c

�\y2?�DF3WD61(< D2D61�3W>638< ;f��< 4F3rTE?E3C4kB�?�D21(<\��3W<RBUoA4FPHV�BMP�g7C< BED24F5�38709M;�<R>W70?�@A5(?�B�3CBED8]EPHB�Z21�P=761�7G< 4F3�]j<r��3C>FD6P=7C< ;1�PHV�1M;QPHV�1UD�Z[?�9�;=T&1(<\��3�<R5�5�38< >638T�PHBND61�3W@NP=T�T�;Q3�c

Page 5: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

!\.g" ! ='"L2$�4->��(�H�-}������������� ��������������������� ����! " #�$���%�&�#���(')��*"��+,�.-/�0.�����������21435�,')��*"�� 4�$���!�$ &��76�*8 ��5�(1435�9 ����-:�$ 41" #���; &��<����1=�������>�?���!���.+@08�;-��A143B�$��*C�*$DA E����65�� �����1" ����F G*H�I 4���J1435�>'A ��$K ��5�L�A � 4���1C M�A�N+

�Wn.0+@GM.� ��*9r+<n��Ab�.-9;� 9;ns� � "i$�"[L2$&4�>��<� ��!'.#"h"���"�% � .0G]=V�F�<+<$I.0"�O �[� � $��&� 9;n�� � +<n.*++<ns�!6��<$�GM.0� � )�.*>9;�#���-�r+(n�$:9 ����b�$:.*+<$&��" $I9r95>��;�'.�),�E�(�->�4�n�"��*9(9,� Q\"H+<n�� .0�<�x.-9v�*��GM.-) n�$�"��hb�$I9;$��-"���<�FGH�-+(�]9;��"95$&"�4��c.0"�N),��GH6�>�+(���@4-�a.06�n�$I)�9��o+(n��HGM.*4-"�$ % )�.*+<$&��" �*�#+<n�� $&GM.*4-$&"s4�9 ��95+<��G|>95�*�)�.*" b�.0� �i95>�=9;+a.0"�+<$I.0�&��� ���(�-G ��"�� 9<),��"s�8+<�M+(n�� "�� �+��AL2$&4�>��<�]OH$��&�&>/9;+<�a.0+(�*9K+(n�� �<�F�:.0+($&��"9;n�$�6=��+ � ���F" GU.04-"s$�% )�.*+<$��-" .0"�N�<�,S/�*),+ .*"),��� �rns�i9;>s�;�'.-)T� GU. �[=��b�$&� � �*� .�9H. )T�-�&���*),+($&�-" �0�6��I.0".*�v�'.-)T��+ 9T�cJK+ons$&4-n GM.04�"�$�% )F.0+<$��-"����*.�) n]6�$I),+<>��(�E�F�&��GH�F"�+r!�6�$� ����6" $&"),��>���*9c.A9;$&"s4-�&�h�'.-)T��+��Jh+ �&� � ��� GU.04-"s$�% )�.*+<$��-"9�!�>9;�*�@$&"@+<ns�h)�.�9;�r�*��->s+ �������c9<),�F"��*9R" �0�x.-) nB6s$� �����)�.*"8$�"),�&>/��� .K�I.0�<4��"�>�G =��� �0�o�'.�),��+a9,� �rn��->�4�ni+<n�� � .0G]=���<+($:.0"u.�9<9;>sGH6�+<$��-"M$:9h�0��+(��"��(�*.-95�-".*=��&� � n���"u�&��� �$&"s4.0+ .H9;$�"�4-���86��I.0".*�E�'.-),�F+�+<n�� �(�,S�*),+a.0")T�B$I9E"���+ � .0G]=���<+($:.0" � n���"[.H)T�-�&���*),+($&�-"M�*�v�'.�),��+a9K$I9$&GU.04-�x� ��"�+(�i.i9;$�"�4-���H6�$� ����'� �rn��M���Fb�$I.0+<$��-" ���(�-G � .0G]=���<+($:.0"[=��n.�b�$&�-�A$:9A9;$&4�"�$�%V)�.0"�+B�����b���� � �<�->s4-nu9;>��5�'.-),�x9��.0"/� $&")T�<�*.�9;�*9 � $&+<n +<n��@.*"�4-���@�0��$&"/),$:���F"),����Q\"H+<ns$:9r6.*6V�F�� � �@����b��F�&�-6.8)T�-GH6��(��n���"/9;$&b��cGH��������+<n/.0+c6��<�x��$:),+a9o�<�,S�x),+ .*"),�r���<��G �<��>�4-nM��$�� >9;�Z9;>s�;�'.-)T�*9���.0"/� 6��<�*b�$:���� �6���<$�GH��"�+ .0� �(�*9;>s�&+ 9!+(n.0+A9;>s6�6�-�<+A+<n��]GH�����F�\� �rn�� � .*G =���(+<$I.0"iGH�����F�o$:[email protected];6�*),$I.0�c)F.-9;� ��-�#$&"/9;+ .*"),�#���0�c+(n��@6��<��6��9;�x� GH�����F�\�

�rn��H+<��6�$:)]�0�#�<��>�4-n ��$ � >9;�M95>��;�'.�),�*[email protected]=����" � �+(��"95$&b�������95+<>��$&�*� $�" +(n��M.*�<�*.�98�0�.06s6��&$��*�H6�n��s9;$I)�9h.0"/� 4-�F�-6�n���95$:)�9T� �rns�B���-���&� � $&"s4 $:9#. =��($&�,� 95>�GHGM.*���]�0�c6s�<��b�$&��>9r�<�*95>��&+a9K��"+<ns�@9;>�=��5�x),+�� QR"u��l�O0 �� � 6s$� �$P� 6�$� �%(��l�O0 � ���*9;$�4-"��x� .*" �FGH6�$&�($:)�.*��G ��������+(� ���*9(),�<$�=�!+<n��#"���"�%� .0G]=���<+($:.*"i=V�Fn.�b�$��-�!�*�h+<ns� GH����" � Q\"N��l* �� �o��$&"s".0���(+ � ��$�"�".*���<+(%<�Fl0 �� � GH����$�%/�*� � 6�$� {9GH�����F��+<�]�-=s+ .0$�"M+<n��!���-���&� � $&"s4 �<�,S�x),+ .*"),�E��>�"/),+<$��-" }

QARTS U�V �OXW !'),��9NY�Z*),�39NY R "=[�\^] �&_ !\C(` U ` �M"

� n����(�#�@Y�Zc.*"�aY R .0�(� +(n��86�-�I.0�A.0"s4-�&�x9 �*� $&"),$I����")T�8.*"�i�<�,S�x),+<$��-"�� .0"� U $:9Z.UG �*.-95>��<�A�0�9;>s�;�'.-)T�B�(�->�4�n�"��*9(9,���rns$:9r��>�"),+($&�-" � .-9#���*9;$�4-"��x�U+(� ��=��*�E���&G n��-��+�b#_9o�<�*)T$&6��(��),$&+ �]6��<$�"),$&6s�&�!\95��� � qr�x) �GM.0"s"�.*"� 1�6�$cb)b�$:) n�$&"s�-%(��l-Y�X � "h=�>�+@$:9!"���+@=.-95�*� ��" .*"��i+(n������<��+($:)�.*� ����>�"��.*+<$&��" �Q\+M.-9(9;>�G �*9 +<n/.0+M+<n��i�a.-��$I.0")T� �*�8"s�-"�% � .0G]=���<+($:.0" ��$ ��>/9;� 9;>��5�'.-),�*9]$:9M9!��GHGH��+(�5$:)�.*� � $&+(n�<�x9;6�*),+c+<�@+(n��!95>��;�'.�),�#"��-�(GM.0� ��.0"M.�9<95>�GH6�+($&�-"]+<n/.0+c6��<�*b��*9�+<�8=�#$&")T�-�<�(�*),+F���!.*6� ��#.0"� b�.0"

O

Page 6: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

Reflectance and Scale

pixel

pixel

Specular facets (Torrance-Sparrow)

Lambertian facets (Oren-Nayar)

L2$�4->��(�[O�}��35�7 4��65��35�5�*4*?����� *"65 C� �����7�$��6�*"�*? �1=*� 4��<����1����������5 4�����$ &1" ��*�14� '��� 4�aK �143a M������������A�! �� �$� 1" ����N+

�E���<" ��!.06� ���.*"� b�.0" �E�-�("�%<�Fl-Y�XM�A.0�I9;� ��=�+ .*$&"��*�N�<�,S/�*),+ .*"),�MGH�*.�9;>��(��GH��"�+ 9E���(�-G �<��>�4-n��$ ��>/9;� 95>��;�'.�),�*9h=��Mb�.0� ��$�"�4]+<n�� 9;�->s� ),� ��$&�(�*),+<$��-"H���-�Z. % ��*�M9;�F"9;���@��$&�(�*),+($&�-" ���rn��� ����>�"�+<ns�H6�*. �*�#+<n�� � .-��$:.0"/),� ��>�")T+<$&��" +<�i=�M95n�$ ��+(�*� ���(�-G|+<n��H6�*.� 6��95$&+<$��-"N� �6�*),+<�x� �����].� .0G]=���<+($:.*" 95>��;�'.�),��� �rns$:9 � .-9@$&"�+<���(6��<��+(�*��.�98.MGH$&"����@��$I9<),�(��6.0"/)��[.0"�[+<n�� � .0G]=���<+($:.0"GH�����F� � .�9 .�9<95>�GH�*� +(� =�u.i�<�*.�9;�-"/.0=�����.*6�6��(� �$&GU.0+<$��-" � � >�� G �*.-95>��<��G ��"�+ 9@9;ns� � +<n.*+"���"�% � .*G =���(+<$I.0" =��n.�b�$&��� $:98)T�&�*.*�<���i"s�-+<$I),�*.*=��&� .0"�N95$&4-"s$�% )�.*"�+ � n���" b�$&� � ���A��$��<�*),+($&��" $I9b�.0�($&�*�H� .*+<n��F�h+<n.*"i9;��>�� )T�8��$&�<�x),+<$��-" �

�rn��A.0=�*b��@9;+(>��$&�x9 � �F�<�@.*+<+<�FGH6�+ 9o+(�]���*9;$�4-"H�(�,S�*)T+ .0"/),�EG �������:9c=.-95�*� ��" G �*.-95>��<�*��<�TS�*),+a.0"),� ��.0+a.��oQ\"A),��"�+(� .-95+��9;��b��F� .0��$&"�b��*9;+($&43.0+<��� 9 ���Fb����&��6V�x�E+<n��F�-�<�F+<$:)F.0�-G �������:9����-� ��$�� >95��<�TS�*),+($&�-"H���(�-G �<��>�4-n 9;>��5�'.-),�x9,� �rns�*9;�@��� �-�(+ 9 � ���<�AGH�-+($&b�.0+(�*�H6��<$�GM.0�($&��� =��M+<ns�8�<�TS�*),+a.0"),�) n.0�a.-),+(���<$I9;+<$I)�9o�0�c+(n��!GH����" �cQ\"���� .*�<�*�]��GH$:9(9;$��-"M.*"�Hb�$I9;$&=s�&�#�&$&4�n�+ �<�,S/�*),+<$��-" ���(�-G +(n��!GH����"!\95��� � � �<�&�*b�.0%(��l��-Y�� 13$&��4����!.*"�L�E� � �����&%(��l�^xO � " $&"��$:)�.*+<��+(n.0+ +<n��iGH����"�{9 9;>��5�'.-),�i�a.-��$I.0+<�x9GH���<�8�F"����<4 ��=.�) u$&"i+(n��]��$&�(�*),+($&�-"u�0� +<n��]95�->��a),� !�+<n��]95>�"'"#+<n/.0"i$&"i+(n��]"��-�(GM.0� ��$&�(�*),+($&�-"�-�A$&"[+<n�� ���-� � .*� � ��$��<�*)T+<$&��" � �rns$:9B6sn���"���GH��"���" $I9 �(�,�����(�<�*��+(�i.-9 ���� ���� ���F�G�����)�������1�GH$�+<n� 13GH$&+(n�%<�Fl-Y�^E�!GH�������&�*�N+<n��[�<��>�4-ns"��*9<9M�0� +<n��iGH����"k.�9M. � .*"����G 6��<��),�x9<9M.0"� .-9<95>�GH�*��*.�) n 6��$&"�+8�-"N+(n��M9;>s�;�'.-)T�H+<�i=� � .*G =���(+<$:.*" $&" �<�,S�x),+ .*"),���i1�GH$�+<n�P9B.*".0����95$:9 �on�� � ��b���������mTEPihj3G>F3CBEDWY(<�7��U407C< D6DF3C>6PHB�V�@N38761(<RB�PH4F@ ]�7C< ;H;H38T >F3CD6>F?�>F30O(3\70DFPH?�Bv?�>�?�5M5(?�4FPHDFPH?�B 30hj3\70D8]f5�>F?�TE9�703C4&<&4F1�< >F5

5�38<���70;H?�4F3�D6?aD61�3�4F?�9M>_703aT�PQ>63870D6PQ?�B �K4F3G3 x"! < 5���3�<RB(T&��<RB ! ?�>FB�p:�\��#�$M]�%d9�VE<a<RB(T'&�461�PH@ <R>F9EpC�8��(�)(]R/24_< BMV�<RB(T&�4F1MPQ@�< >69Ep:�\��(�)(]�*d3CD+�EPHB�V pC�8��#�# �-, c /21�PH4aPH4rB�?�DrDF1�3�@A38761(< B�PH46@ T�PQ40709�464F38TsPHBvDF1�PH4r5(< 5�3C>8c.�->F38703GBUD�< >6DFP=70;H3YEo ! <R5���3q{:| } ~i� x"! <R5���3q{0| } ~i� p:�\����$ � D61�>F? Z24�B�3GZ ;HPHV�1EDd?�BuDF1�PH4�@N38761(<RB�PH4F@uc/&�DXPH4�4F3G;�T�?�@L3GB(70?�9MBUD63C>F3\T�PHB@ <�761�PHB�3k�EPH4FPH?�BA4FPHB(703JPQD'PH42?�Y�463C>F��38T�?�B�;Ho&Z21�3CBqD61�3W4F3GB�4F?�>X< B�TN46?�9�>0703a<R>F3�Z2PHDF1�PHBq<�I�3CZ T�3CV�>63C3C4dIK>F?�@m38<�7F1?�D61�3C>�0(<r4FPHD69(< D6PQ?�B TEP21 709M;QD'DF?&3G@&9�;=< DF32PHB�5�>0<�70D6P�7:3WZ2PHDF1�?�9�D[D61�3W46?�9�>0703W?�>2D61�3�4F3CBM4F?�>d?�7C70;H9(TEPHB�V&D61�3W?�D61�3C>\c

X

Page 7: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

� .�9!),��"�%"��*�M+<�H+(n��86s�:.0"s�8�0� $�"),$:����"),�@.*"��$:9h"���+!�*.-95$&���H� �+<��"95$&=����@+<�]�<�,S�x),+<$��-"9h�->�+a9;$I���+<ns$:9E6��I.0"��3�8L�>��(+<n������21�GH$�+<n�P9rGH������� �����*9!"���[email protected])F),�->�"�+!���-�!$�"�+(���<�(�,S�*)T+<$&��"M��� �*),+ 9T�8qr>sn��2�F+.0�'� � qr>sn��� ������� %(��l�Y-jM�ZGH���������*� +<n��u9;>s�;�'.-)T�i.-9 . ),���&���*),+<$��-"N�0�B9;6�n��F�<$:)F.0�#)�.�b�$&+<$��*9,� �rn���.0"/.0����b��*�N$&"�+<���(�<�,S/�*),+<$��-"9 >95$&"�4 +(n�$:9 9;>��5�'.-),�u4-����GH��+<� �#�r=�>s+M��$:�N"��-+M6��(�*9;�F"�+ . ),��GH6��&�F+<��<�TS�*),+a.0"),�AGH������� +<n.*+8.�)�),��>�"�+a9E���-�!GM.�9! �$&"�4U.0"�[9;n.���� � $&"�4u��� �*),+a9K���-�A.0�(=�$&+(� .*���[.0"s4-�&�x9�0�Z�<�TS�*),+($&�-" .0"�N$&"),$I����")T��� 1�>�=/9;����>���"�+<���#�W�E���($&"�4 .0"�W1�GH$&+(n � �E�F�<$&"s4[.0"� 1�GH$�+<n�%(��l�^*C ������($&b��*�N. ����+ .*$&�&�x� +(n����(GM.0�h��G $:9<95$&��" G �������r���-� 9;>s�;�'.-)T�*9 GH�����F�&�*�N.-9 . ),�-���&�*)T+<$&��" �0���!%)�.�b�$&+<$��*9,� �E� � �Fb����� .0���o+<n��])F.xb�$&+($&�*9#.0�(�H.�9<95>�GH�*��+(�H=� $I����"�+<$:)F.0� .0"�[.0��$&4-"s�*��$&"[+<n��]9(.0GH���$��<�*),+($&��"��V"/.0GH�����#��6���<6��"/��$:),>s�:.0�Z+<�H+(n��]9;��>�� ),�F% b�$&� � ���#6��:.*"������rn�$I9 G ������� $:9Z.0�:95�M�&$&G $&+<�x�+<�]�<�TS�*),+($&�-"/9v$&"M+(n��@6��:.*"��@�0�c$�"),$:����"),���

gK�*)T��"�+(���#�$&" ),��GH6�>�+(���E4�� .*6�n�$:)F9��om��->���$&"[.0"/� L��->s�<"�$���� � m��->���$&" .0"�[L��->��("�$&���(%<�Fl-l�C ������($&b��*�Z.E��$ � >9;� �<�,S�x),+ .*"),�o��>�"),+($&��" �����c.0"s$:9;+(�<��6�$:)c9;>s�;�'.-)T�*9 G �������&�x�!.-9o.#),���&�&�x),+<$��-"!�*�6.0�(%.0���&���s)����&$�"���<$I)�.0��95�*),+($&�-"/9,�"�rns$:9o�<�*95>��&+ n�� � ��b���� )�.*"�"��-+c=�#.06s6��&$��*�8+<�@95>��;�'.�),�*9 � $&+(n $:95�-+<�(�-6�$I)�<��>�4-ns"��*9<9T� � +(n����o�(�*9;�*.*� ) n����a92$&" ),�-G 6�>�+<�F�24�� .06sn�$:)�9on.�b��h"�>�GH���($:)�.*�&���E6��(��%'),�-GH6s>�+<�*�B�'.*$&�(���),��GH6��&�� ��<�TS�*),+a.0"),�8��>s"),+<$��-"9A.0"� 9;+<���<�*� +(n�� �(�*9;>s�&+ 9@$&"[+<n��]���-�<G �*�#�&��� �%�>�6N+ .*=��&�*9�! ������ s.0GH6s�&�*9 ��9;��� ��$ .0=s� .0�&��r���K� %<�Fl-j�^U�&���@. �5$���.*%<�Fl-l����6"a�"�Wn�$&���E�(��"�����($&"�4 .0"M$&GU.04-� ��6/.0� .*GH��+(��� 99;>/) nu.-9h+<ns�@.0"�4��&�*9h�0� $&"/),$:���F"),�Z.0"�M�<�,S�x),+ .*"),�@.*�<�@>9;�x�U+(� $�"��� ]+<ns�B+a.0=����A.0"�H�<�x.-�M9;>��(%�'.-)T�B�a.-��$I.0")T�Bb�.*�&>��*9T� �rn�$:9h.*6�6��(��.-) ni)F.0"M=�B� ���x),+<$�b��K�����E4�� .06sn�$:)�9r�(��"���F�<$&"s4 =�>�+#�����*9h"���+�<�F6��:.�),�!+<ns�B"s���*� ���-�Z.-)�)T>�� .*+<�@�<�,S/�*),+ .*"),�E��>s"),+<$��-"9T�

�rn��hGH��������6s�<�*95��"�+(�*�B$I9 +(n�$:9 6.*6V�F�r)F.0"8=�#.*6�6��&$��*�B+(�!$:95�-+(�<�-6s$:)r.�9 � �F�&�s.-9o.*"�$:95�-+<�(�-6�$I)�<��>�4-n[95>��;�'.�),�*9 �.0"�u)�.0"un.0"���&� .*�<=�$�+<�a.0���U9;�->s� ),� .0"�Mb�$�� � ���#��$&�<�x),+<$��-"9T�cL/>s�<+<ns�����$�+h+ . ��x9$&"�+<�Z.-)F),�->�"�+ ),�-GH6s�&� !4����-G ��+<�($:)�.*�-��� �*),+a9295>) n .-9�GM.-9 �$�"�4���9;n.���� � $&"�4���.0"�8$�"�+(���<�(�,S�*),+($&��"9=��+ � ���F"H6�-$&"�+ 9h�-"u+<n��A95>��;�'.�),���"�[�8=��4-$�"M=��HG �������&$�"�48+(n��A9;>��5�'.-),�A.�9E.]),�-���&�*)T+<$&��"H�0� �&�-"s49!��GHGH�F+<�<$�)��!%')�.�b�$�+<$&�x9,�otc.�) n��!%')�.�b�$�+ � n.�9K+ � � �-6�6��95$&"�4]�'.-),��+a9h.0"�M�*.-) nH�'.-),�F+h$:9#.-9<95>�GH�*�+<�u=� G]>) n��:.*�<4����@+<n.*" +<n�� � .�b�������"�4�+<ni�0�#$�"),$I����"�+!�&$�4-n�+�� �rn�$:9A9;>��5�'.-),�]GH�����F� � .�9B>95�*�=�� � ���<�a.0"),�u.*"� 1�6/.0�<�(� � � � �-�(� .0"/),�i.*"� 1�6/.0�<�(� � %<�Fl-Y�^ � +<� ���*9(),�<$�=��956�*),>��I.0� �<�TS�*),+($&�-"���<��G �(�->�4�nu9;>��5�'.-),�*9T�W�E���(�#� � �Z.-9<95>�GH�!+(n��E�'.�),��+ 9c+<�A=V� � .0G]=V�F�<+<$I.0"H$�" �(�,S�*)T+ .0"/),�����cL�$&� 95+�. �(�,S�*),+a.0")T� G �������#$:9]����b������-6�*� �����H.*"�$:95�-+(�<�-6s$:)i9;>s�;�'.-)T�*9 � $&+(nW�-"��u+ ��6���*���!%\)F.xb�$&+($&�*9 �.0"/� � $&+(n .*�&�c)�.�b�$&+($&�*9!.*�&$�4-"��*�i$&"i+(n�� 9<.0G �]��$&�(�*),+<$��-"i��" +<n�� 9;>s�;�'.-)T� 6��I.0"��3� �rns$:9B�(�*9;>s�&+!$I9+<ns��"N>9;�*� +(� ���F�<$&b�� .iGH�������c���-� +<ns� G �-�<� 4-��"��F� .0� )�.-95���*�!$I9;�-+(�<��6�$:)M9;>s�;�'.-)T�*98+<n.*+ n/.xb��"����<GM.*�v�'.-)T��+ ��$I9;+(�<$&=s>�+<$��-"9 � $�+<n b��F�<��G �*.0"N.*"�N.0�(=�$&+(� .0� �N9;+a.0"�s.0� � ����b�$:.*+<$&��" !�d"a� �rn��9;+a.0"�s.0� � ����b�$:.0+($&��"W6.0�a.0GH��+(�<$#b��*98+<ns� GM.�),�<�39<),��6�$:)M�<��>�4-n�"s�*9<9M�0�A+<n�� 9;>s�;�'.-)T��� L2$�4->��(�[X9;ns� � 9]+<n��(����$�GM.04��*98�0� 9;6sn����<�x9 �(��"�����(�*� >/9;$&"s4 +<n��u6��<��6��9;�x� �(�,S�*),+a.0")T� G �������\� QR" .*�&�+<ns�<���A)�.�9;�*9 ��+<n��A9;6sn����<�@$I9K$��&�&>sGH$&".*+<�*�B���(�-G +<ns�Bb�$&� � ��� ��$&�(�*),+<$��-" � Q\" +(n�� %/� 9;+#)F.-9;� �� S C��.0"/� n��F"),�r+(n��#9;6sn����<� $:9 � .*G =���(+<$I.0"8$�" �<�,S/�*),+ .*"),����J!9�+<n��h�(�->�4�n�"��*9(9 $�"),�(�*.-95�*9��-+(n��h956�n����(�=��4-$�"9r+<� .06�6�*.*�rS .0+(+<���F�cQ\"H+<n��Z� �+(�<��G �h�<�->s4-n�"��x9<9h)�.�9;�A9;n�� � "M$&" L2$�4->��(�@Xf!')M" ��+<n��@956�n����(�.06s6V�x.0� 9H��$� ��u. S .*+M��$:9() � $&+(n "��*.*�<���W),��"9;+a.0"�+H=��<$�4-n�+<"��x9<9,� �rns$:9 6�ns��"��-G ��"��-" n.-9]=V�F��"� $:�������]�-=95���<b��x� .*"� �(��6�-�(+<�*�H$&"M+(n��A)�.-95�B�*�c+<ns� ��>s�&��G ���-" �

�\/21�PH4k< 464F9�@A5�DFPH?�B TE?E3C4dB�?�Dd;QPH@APQD�D61�3WPH@N5�;HP=7C<RDFPH?�B�4�? InDF1�3J>F30O(3\70D_<RB(703&@N?�TE3G;g5�>F3C463CBEDF38Tu1M3C>F3�c'/21�3JB�?�BEp� <R@&Y(3G>FDFP=<RBNY�3C1(<\�EPH?�>2>F3G5(?�>FDF3\Tu1�3C>F3JPQ4d3 �5(3\70DF38T�IK?�>X<rZ2P=TE3�>_<RB�V�3W?RIn;Q?�7C<R;`TEPihg9�4F3J>F30O(3\70D_<RB(703&@N?�TE3G;Q4/��4F3C3x�� 1(< B�TE>_<R4F3 �E1(<R>�pC�8��#�� � ]�IK?�>23 (<R@N5�;H3 , 46PHB(703W469�>�I <�703W>6?�9�V�1�B�3C464kPH424F1�? Z2B�D6?a5�;=<\oN<&TE?�@NPHB(<RBUD�>6?�;H3�c

Page 8: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

!'.#" !�='" !\)�"L2$�4->��(� X�}%08�������* ����* �535�$ &�* 4�$���!�$ &��;6�*� M�5�(1&35� �5 4���:�X*"�� 4��<����1=� ����� �?���!����� ���!�������(� 9 ����-��$ &1" #���B* �535�$ &����/�.-/��� ��������/������� �������+

1���b����a.0�#� �6���($&GH�F"�+a.0�r�(�*9;>s�&+ 9 .0�<�i6s�<�*95��"�+(�*� +(�N����G �-"95+<� .*+<�u+<n��[.�)�),>��a.-)��N�0�A+(n�������($&b��*� GH�������\� �rns�*9;�i� �6���<$�GH��"�+ 9 � �F�<�i)T�-"��>/),+<�*�N�-" ),��GHGH��"�6��:.�),�M9(.0GH6����*9 9;>/) n .-99<.*"�$�#6��:.�9;+<�F�� � �����$�!.*"� )T�&�-+(n � Q\" .0�&�Z)�.�9;�*9 �K�(�,S�*)T+ .0"/),�M6��<�*��$:),+(�*� =��N+<n��uGH������� � .�9���->s"� +<�i=�]$&"N95+<�(�-"�4[.*4-�<�F��GH��"�+ � $&+(n G �*.-95>��<��G ��"�+a9,� �rn��*95�H�<�x9;>���+ 9!$&���&>95+<� .*+<�]+<n.*+8+(n������b�$:.*+<$��-" ���(�-G � .0G]=���<+($:.*" =��n/.xb�$&���!)F.0"i=� 95>�=9;+a.0"�+<$I.0�\� � � ),�-"/),�&>��� � $�+<n .H��$:9(),>9(9;$&��"�-"]+<ns�r$&G 6��&$I)�.0+($&�-"/9��0� +(n��r6s�<�-6�39;�*� G �����������-�oGM.�) ns$&"��cb�$:9;$��-" ��L2$�� 95+� � �#9;n�� � +(n.0+ $&GM.*4-�*9�0���(�->�4�nu��$�� >95�!�-=��5�*)T+ 9r)F.0"H=�@.�)�),>��a.0+<�F���]���*9(),�<$�=�*� >/9;$&"s48+<ns�!6��<��6��9;�x�UG �������\�X�E� �+� � �9;+(>���H�(�,S�*)T+ .0"/),�@GM.069c4-��"s��� .*+<�*�M>9;$�"�4 +<n�� � .*G =���(+<$:.*"MGH������� .0"�M+<n��@6��(�-6��95�*��GH�������'�J!9!+<ns� �(�->�4�n�"��*9(98�0�#+<ns�H95>��;�'.�),�H$&"/),�<�*.�9;�*9 � +<n��]�<�,S/�*),+ .*"),� GM.*6 b�.*�<$&�x9Z���(�-G � .0G]=���<+($:.0"+<� +<n�� ��$&"��*.*�E�(�,S�*)T+ .0"/),�8GM.*6 � �E�-�("�%<�Fl-j�Y � 6��<�Fb�$��->95���Mn���6�-+(n��*9;$#b��*�H���-�!��>�".0�@�(�,S�*),+a.0")T���L2$�".0�����#� � �h����G �-"95+<� .*+<� +<n�� .06�6���$:)�.*+<$��-"8�*�+<ns�rGH�����F��+(�!95n.06�h�<�x),�*b������!>/9;$&"s4!6�n���+<�-G ��+<�($:)9;+(���<�F��� �Wn�$��&�u+<n��i"�� � GH�����F�!.�)�),>��a.0+<�F��� �x9;+<$�GM.0+(�*98+<ns� 95n.06�[�0�]. �(�->�4�n ��=��5�*),+�h+(n��� .0G]=���<+($:.*" G �������6��<����>),�*9h�:.*�<4-�A���<�(�-�a9r$&"u9;>��5�'.-),�@���<$&�F"�+a.0+<$��-" �

�rn��@�<�*95>��&+a9r6��<�*95��"�+<�*� $�"H+<ns$:9r6.*6V�F�#����GH��"9;+(� .0+(�!+ � � 6�-$�"�+a9r+<n.*+!.*�<�E��>s"��.0G ��"�+a.0�+<�Z),��GH6�>�+(����b�$:95$&�-" �J!'.#"�1���b����a.0���(�*.0��% � �-�<�I�!�-=��5�*),+a9�n.�b�� ��$�� >95�h),��GH6�-"���"�+ 9+<n.*+o.*�<� 9;$&4�"�$ ��%$:)F.0"�+<���]"���"�% � .*G =���(+<$I.0" � �rn��8�(�,S�*)T+ .0"/),�@�0� 9;>) n���=��5�*),+ 9h)F.0"�"���+E=� .-)�),>s� .0+(�����U���*9<)T�<$&=�*�>95$&"�4i6��(��b�$&�->/98GH�������I9,�-!�='" �rn��MGH�����F�r6��(�*9;��"�+<�x� $�" +<ns$:986.*6V�F�H)�.*"N=V�u>9;�x� =��[b�$I9;$&��".0��4-���<$&+(n�GM9c+<�].0"/.0����b��!$�GM.04��*9o�0� ��$�� >95�@9;>s�;�'.-)T�*9h.0"�H�(�*),�*b���� .-)�)T>�� .*+<�@95n.06�8$�"����-�(GM.0+($&��" �

� � ��� ���*� ���"� � &�� ���z�,���������,+

Q\"N+<n�$I9 9;�*),+($&��"�� � �M����%/"��M� .-��$&�-G ��+<�($:)]),�-")T��6�+ 98+(n.0+ .0�(�M>9;�*� $�" +(n��M�<��GU.0$&"s$&"�4u�0�Z+<n�$I96.*6V�F��� �rn��*95�@),��"),��6�+a9r.*�<�@��$I9<),>/9<9;�x� $&"M����+ .*$&�$&" � �E$:)T������G]>9A �a����� %(��l�^-^ � �cL�$&4->s�<�! 9;n�� � 9.@9;>��5�'.-),�h�F�&��GH�F"�+���� $&�&��>�GH$�".0+(�*�K���<��G +(n��#��$&�(�*),+($&�-"� ! S !�Y Z#"�$/ZF"�.0"/� b�$&� � �*�!=�� .@9;��"95�-�o$�"+<ns� ��$��<�*),+($&��"% & S !�Y R "�$ R " � � n��F�<�(Y].0"/�'$ ����"���+<�86���:.0�Z.0"/�i.Ab�$�G >�+(nM.0"s4-�&�x9���<�*956V�x),+<$�b���������rn��A9;�F"9;���!95>�=�+<�F"��9#.0"�$�"�%"�$�+<�*95$&GM.*�9;���&$I� .*"�4-���(�*) R ���<��G .0"��H6�-$�"�+h��"�+<ns�895>��;�'.�),���

�rn��E��$&4�n�+���"����(4 �A�<�,S�x),+<�*�@=��@+(n��#9;>��5�'.-),�h6/.0+ ) n $:9�6��<��6V���<+($&�-"/.0��+(�!+<ns�h�&$&4�n�+ $&"),$I����"�+

Page 9: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

s

θi

φrφ

i-

z

x

dωr

v

ydA

L2$&4�>��<�@ �}��%�$�A���$14 4��6�*C��(14���!�����5�� =���A ������$1& " #� 14�$ 4��*$+

�-"u$&+F�������\�������g) ��v$I9h����%"s�*�M.-9r+<ns�B��$&4�n�+rS>� H$&")T$:����"�+r6���h>s"�$&+#95>��;�'.�),�A.0�<�x.�}

� !�Y Z "�$ Z " S ��� Z0!"Y�Z#"�$/ZF"��� !<��"

�rn�$I9 $I9o+<n��#��$��<�*)T+<$&��".0�s$&�<�a.-��$I.0")T�h�0��+<ns�#9;>��5�'.-),�Z.-9c$&+o�(��6��<�x9;��"�+ 92��$&4�n�+o�F"����<4 � $&")T$:����"�+ ���<�-G+<ns����$&�<�x),+<$��-"L!"Y�Z " $/Z6"a� �rns���_+��0��� � ���\�������g) ��Z�0�@+(n��i95>��;�'.�),�M$:9 +<n��HS>� N$�"),$:����"�+@���<��G .*�&���$��<�*),+($&��"9 .0"�NGM.� =� ����"���+<�*�N9;$�GH6����[.-9 � � �rn��M=��($&4�n�+("��*9<9 GH�*.�9;>��(�*� =�� +<ns��95��"95�-�$:9 6��(�-6�-�(+<$&��".0�Z+<�[+<n�� �\�������g) ��@�0�A+(n��u9;>��5�'.-),�u6.0+a) n $&" +(n��i��$&�<�x),+<$��-" !�Y R "�$ R " � 13>��;�'.�),�� .���$:.*"),�@$:9h����%"��*�M.�9,}

R !"Y R "�$ R �$Y�Z " $/Z6" S ��� R !�Y R "�$ R �$Y�Z " $/Z�"���z),��9NY R �*) R !\Og"

Q\+@$:9B+(n�� S>� [� .-��$:.0+(�*� =��i+<n�� 9;>s�;�'.-)T�H6���8>�"s$&+A9;���&$:� .0"�4��&�#��6V�F�8>�"�$�+�U+��R����`+�� �GR)� � .*�<�*.��Q\+ ���F6V�F"��9B��" +<ns�M��$&�(�*),+($&�-"[�0�#$��&��>�GH$&"/.0+<$��-" .0"� +<ns�M9;��"/9;�-� ��$&�(�*),+($&�-" � �rn��H�<�F�:.0+($&��"9;n�$�6=��+ � ���F"H$&�(� .-��$:.0"/),�A.0"�M� .-��$:.0"/),�@�0� .]9;>��5�'.-),�@$I9h����+<�F�<GH$�"��*� =��H$�+ 9r�(�,S�*),+a.0")T�!6��<��6���<+($&�*9T��rn�� �������� � ��� ��+g)`��� �R�� ���_�g) ������ ��� ��� ��#� ��+g)���^) ��� ��+g)�������� �"!u$I9H����%"s�*�W.-9M+<n��i�a.0+<$��N�0�� .���$:.*"),�@+<�]$&�(� .���$:.*"),��}

QAR !"Y R "�$ R �$Y�Z "�$ Z6" S ��# R !"Y R "�$ R �$Y�Z "�$ Z�"� � !�Y Z "�$ Z " !\Xg"

JE���v+(n��u.0=�*b��u����%"�$�+<$��-"9A.0�<�M4���"����a.0� �c$&" +<n.*+�c+<n��� .0�(�Mb-.*�&$I� �����]9;>��5�'.-),�x9 � $&+<n .0"�� �<��%S�*)T+ .0"/),� ) n.0�a.-),+(���<$I9;+($:)�9T�hL��-�@.*" � �U+�� �8+%$ � �E9;>s�;�'.-)T�#�V�a.-��$I.0")T� .0"/�&����� �N��� "��-+@) n.*"�4-� $ �+<ns�895>��;�'.�),�@$:9r�(�-+ .*+<�*�u.0=�->s+!$&+a9r"��-�(GM.0� b��*),+<����� L/���#9;>) ni95>��;�'.�),�*9 ��+<n��'����� �i$I9h9;$�GH6���� }

QAR !�Y R " Y Z#"�$ R)( $ Z6" S ��# R !"Y R "$Y�Z "�$ R)( $ Z6"� � !"Y Z " ! ^"

J � .0G]=���<+($:.*"i9;>s�;�'.-)T� $:9!.*"i$:���*.*�c��$ ��>/9;��� � ns��9;�]� .���$:.*"),� $I9K$�"����6��"����"�+Z�0� +<n�� b�$&� � $&"�4��$��<�*),+($&��" �*�o+(n��@9;�F"9;���E��$&+ .06�6�*.*� 9h����>.0����� =��($&4-n�+v���(�-G .*�&� ��$��<�*),+($&��"9,�cQ\+ 9������ �i$I9 QARTS+*

,� n����(��+(n�� ��� � �g+.- �<�F6��<�*95��"�+ 9 +<n��M��� .-)T+<$&��"W�0�A$&"/),$:���F"�+ ��"s���<4 � +(n.0+ $:9 �(�,S�*),+(�*� =��N+(n��9;>s�;�'.-)T���

Y

Page 10: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

� � ����.��&'� � �s�����,�0��+(+�� � ���

�rn����(�#.0�(�#9;��b����a.0� � . �s92�*� GH�����F�&$&"s4#9;>��5�'.-),�h�(�->�4�n�"��*9(9,� �rn��h4���"����a.0�.*6�6��<�3.-) n $I92+<� 9;�����*),+ .GH�����F��+<n.*+2$I9 )�.06.*=��&� �0��(��6��(�*9;��"�+<$�"�4h�<�x.0��9;>s�;�'.-)T�*92.*"� .0+�+<ns�h9<.*GH�o+($&GH�o�x.-9!�@+(�E>95�h��>s�<$&"s4+<ns� GU.0+<ns��GM.0+($:)�.*� ����b������-6�GH�F"�+@�0� +<n��M�<�TS�*),+a.0"),�MGH�������\�NJE���#9;>��5�'.-),�MGH�������:9B����>�"� $�".06s6��&$��*�B6�n��s9;$:)F92.*"� 4����-6sn��s9;$I)�9 ��$&+(��� .*+<>��(�h)�.*" =V�#��$&b�$:���*�@$&"�+<�#+ � �!=��(��.�� )�.*+<��4��-�($&�*9T�oQ\"8+(n��%�a9;+ )�.-95�#�-+<ns�h9;>s�;�'.-)T�r$:9 GH�����F�&�*�!.�9o.h� .0"/���-G 6��<��),�x9<9r!'9;����� qr�x) �GM.0"s"�%<�Fl-Y����� .04-"s���<%(��l�Y-Y��1�GH$�+<n�%(��l�Y�^U�6" �� !95$&"�4h+(n�$:9 .*6�6��(��.-) n��-$�+�$I9 ��$��U),>���+�+<�Z�����($&b�� .K�(�,S�*)T+ .0"/),�oGH�����F�0���-��.*�<=�$�+<�a.0���9;��>�� )T�i.0"/� b�$&� � ��� ��$��<�*)T+<$&��"9�� .0"/� +<� .0".*����b��M$&"�+<���(�<�,S�x),+<$��-"9T�NQR" +<n��u95�*),�-"/� )�.*+<��4��-��� �9;>s�;�'.-)T�*9H.0�(�i.�9<9;>sGH�*� +(� =�[),��GH6��95�*� �*� 95��b����a.0�h������GH��"�+ 9 � $&+(n 9;��GH�M6��<$�GH$&+($&b�� 9;n.*6V� ����-� � �.*GH6����#�r956�n����($:)�.*�@)�.�b�$&+<$��*9�� �!%')�.�b�$�+<$��*9��rns�-�&�x9��h��+ ) !\95��� � qr>�n��s �����K� %<�Fl-Y-j�� � �-�(� .0"/),�.0"/� 1�6.*�<�(� � %(��l�Y�^U�G"a�WJ!9 9;ns� � "W$�"N+<n�$I986.06�����r+<n��u��� �*),+a98�0�A95n.-��� � $�"�4��hGM.�9! �$&"�4��c.0"�$&"�+<�F�<�<�TS�*),+($&�-"N"��F�*� +<� =�[.*".0���:b��x� $&" ��� ���F� +(� �-=s+ .0$�" .0" .-)�)T>�� .*+<�i�<�TS�*),+a.0"),�uGH�������'�� � .�)�),��GH6��&$I9;nN+<ns$:9�� � �u>9;�[+<n��u�<��>�4-n�"s�*9<9MGH�������#6��<��6��9;�x� =�� � �-�(� .0"/),�[.0"�k1�6.*�<�(� �� � �-�(� .*"),�Z.0"�H1�6.*�<�<� � %(��l�Y�^ � +(n.0+ .�9<9;>sGH�*92+(n��!95>��;�'.�),�h+<�A=�#),�-GH6�39;�*� �0� �&�-"s489 ��G GH��+<�($�)�!%')�.�b�$�+<$��*9�!\95���]L2$&4�>��<� �#"a�8tc.-) n[)�.�b�$&+ �M),��"9;$I9;+ 9!�*�r+ � �H6��:.*".0�#�'.-),��+a9,���rn�� � $I��+<ni�*�h�*.�) n�'.-)T��+ $:9A.-9<95>�GH�*�[+<�[=V�u95GM.0���r)T�-GH6.*�<�*�[+<�i$&+a98�&��"s4-+<n � �rn��H�(�->�4�n�"��*9(9 �0�Z+<ns�M9;>��5�'.-),�M$I99;6�*)T$�%�*�H>95$&"�4]. 6��(�-=.*=�$&��$&+ � ��>s"),+<$��-"H���-�#+<ns�8��$:9;+(�<$�=�>�+<$��-"M�0���'.-)T��+#9;���-6�*9,�

d

a

dA

an

θa

^

L2$�4->��(� ��}���65 C� �����T�?���!������7��*�������������1" ����7���� �.�$��'A M1C M�*^+

�rn����!%')�.�b�$�+!�#�<��>�4-ns"��*9<9oGH��������)�.0" =�h>95�*�B+(�@���*9(),�<$�=�h9;>s�;�'.-)T�*9 � $�+<n =�-+(n $:95�-+<�(�-6�$I).-9 � �F�&� .-9].0"�$I9;��+<�<��6�$:) !'��$&�(�*),+<$��-".*�6"Z�<�->s4-n�"��x9<9,� �[�u.-9(9;>�GH� �*.-) n �'.-)T��+].0�(�*.��� $:9 95GM.0���),��GH6.0�(�*�i+<��+(n��M.*�<�*. ��� �0�#+(n��M9;>s�;�'.-)T�H6.0+a) n[+<n/.0+ $:9@$&GM.*4-�*��=�� .�9;$�"�4-���H95��"95�-� 6�$� ����'��E��"/),�#���*.-) nM6�$� ����$&"/),�&>���*9r. b������ �I.0�(4-�@"�>sG =���c�0� �'.-),��+a9,�cL�>��(+<n�������+(n��E�'.-)T��+#.0�(�*.8$:9r�I.0�<4��),��GH6.0�(�*� +(�H+<ns� � .�b�������"�4�+<n �u�0� $�"),$:����"�+h��$&4�n�+Z.0"��+(n����(�,���-�(�84-�F�-GH��+(�<$I)�.0� �-6�+($:)�9!)F.0"i=�>95�*�H+<� �����<$�b��!+<ns�B�(�,S�*)T+ .0"/),�!GH�����F�\�"�rns�8.*=�0b��A.�9<9;>sGH6�+<$��-"9h)F.0"�=�A9;>sGHGM.0�($cb��x� .-9,}

� ,�� �� � ��� ! �g"

�rn��!�'.-)T��+ 9h),��>��:�H=�@�<���I.0+($&b������ 9;GU.0�&� .-9r$�" +(n��A)�.-95�@�0� 9<.0"/��.0"/�U6s�:.-95+<�������-�h�I.0�<4��A.-9h$&"H+(n��)�.�9;�@�0�c��>�+ �����-�@9(),��"��*9r�*�o+(���<�a.0$�" �

^

Page 11: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

� dsX>v(Z�y w Y Z\j���Y%X>hnjrhnisdfi x�o u if` x Y ishne7x isX>[ }� � ����"���+<�h+<ns�h9;���-6�h.*"�8�-�($&��"�+ .*+<$��-"8�*� �*.-) nB�'.�),��+�$&"8+(n�� �Z%\)�.�b�$&+ �#GH��������.�9r!"Y���"�$���"a�

� �-�<�a.0")T�[.0"� 1�6/.0�<�(� � n/.xb�� .-9(9;>�GH�x� .0���K�'.�),��+a9 +<�[n.�b�������>.*�!.*�<�*.������rns�� >95��+(n����$I9;+<�($&=�>s+<$&��"�� !"Y�� "�$��E" +<�H�(��6��<�x9;��"�+h+<n��A"�>sG =��� �0�o�'.�),��+ 9h6���!>�"s$&+Z9;>��5�'.-),� .0�<�x. +(n.0+!n/.xb��+<ns� "����<GM.*�� S !"Y�� "�$���"a���E���<� � � � >95�H.M��$I9;+(�<$&=s>�+<$��-"i��>�"),+($&�-"i+(���(��6��<�x9;��"�+E+(n�� ��� .-)T+<$&��"�0� +<ns�895>��;�'.�),�A.0�(�*. +(n.0+h$I9r��)�),>�6s$&�*�H=�� �'.�),��+ 9 � $�+<nu. 4-$&b��F"H"��-�(GM.0�'�"�rn�$I9r$:9r�(�,�����<�(�*� +(�].-9+<ns�.���=+%$n��C��� 8� ��� ��� ��� ��g� ��+g)� !�Y��*"�$���"a� �rn��B�'.�),��+<%�"�>�G =��� .0"�i95�&��6V�F%\.*�<�*.H��$:9;+(�<$�=�>�+<$��-"9#.0�(��<�F�:.0+(�*�M.-9v�����&�&� � 9T}

��!"Y���"�$��E" S � !"Y���"�$��E" ��H),�39NY� !\Yg"�rn�� 9;�&��6��%\.*�<�*. ��$:95+<�<$�=�>�+($&�-"N$I9 �*.�9;$���� +<�[>9;�u+<n.*"W+<n��H�'.�),��+<%�"�>�G =��� ��$:95+<�($&=�>�+($&��" $&"N+(n�����-���&� � $&"s4 GH�������������($&b�.0+($&�-" �hL��-�!$I9;�-+(�<��6�$:)A9;>��5�'.-),�*9 ��� !"Y � "�$ � " S ��!�Y � " �!.0"/����!"Y � "�$ � " S��!"Y � " �*9;$�"),�c+<ns�r��$:9;+(�<$�=�>�+<$��-"9 .*�<�c�<��+ .*+<$&��".0�����@9 ��G GH��+<�($:) � $�+<n@�<�*956�*),+ +<�h+(n��c4-���-=.*��95>��;�'.�),�"����<GM.*�� � �

� � ��� ��&'�"���,&'� � � ���

Q\" +(n�$:9A9;�*)T+<$&��"�� � �M�����<$�b��]. �<�TS�*),+a.0"),� G �������2�����8�<��>�4-n ��$ � >9;�M95>��;�'.�),�*9T� �rn�� �!%')�.�b�$�+ �GH�����F��$I92>9;�x�8+<�A���*9(),�<$�=V� 9;>��5�'.-),�#4-�F�-GH��+(���@.*"� �*.-) n8�'.-),�F+o�-" +(n��#9;>��5�'.-),�#$:9 .-9<95>�GH�*�@+<�@=�� .0G]=���<+($:.*" $&"]�<�,S�x),+ .*"),��� �rn��K�����&��� � $�"�4@+<n��(���#+!��6�*9o�0� 9;>��5�'.-),�*9 � $&+(nH��$ � ���<��"�+c95�&�-6��%'.0�(�*.��$I9;+<�($&=�>s+<$&��"9].0�<�M� s.0G $&"��*� � !\.#" �_[Ui:y�mnifY%Zt^px ifX>[Ujrd��7if[��{dfZ�y � dsX>v(Z u if` x Y ishne7x isX>[(� �rn�$I9��$I9;+<�($&=�>s+<$&��" �<�*95>��&+a9o$&"].!"��-"s% $I9;�-+(�<��6�$:)!95>��;�'.�),� � n����<�#.*�&���'.�),��+a9 n/.xb��h+(n��#9<.*GH�#9;���-6�Z.0"�H.*�&�)�.�b�$&+<$��*9h.0�(�].0��$&4-"s�*��$&"u+<n��]9(.0GH�A��$��<�*),+($&��" �u!�='" ��`)Xrx Y X{vnif^ �7if[2�>dfZ�y �7dfX>v(Z u is` x Y ishneKxyisX>[(��E���(�#��.0���V�'.-)T��+ 9rn.�b��#+<n��A9(.0GH�Z9;���-6�@=�>�+h+<ns��H.*�<�@>�"�$ ���-�(GH��� ��$:95+<�<$�=�>�+(�*� $&" �-�<$���"�+ .0+($&��" ��"+<ns�@9;>��5�'.-),�Z6��:.*"����&!\)�"�� jweU`)`�isjr[ u is` xyY%ifhneKx ifX>[�� �rns$:9v$I9r+<n��#GH�39;+r4���"����a.0� )�.-95�!� s.0GH$�"��*�� n����(�r+(n�� 9;�&��6��%\.*�<�*.Z��$:95+<�<$�=�>�+($&�-"A$:9 .�9<9;>sGH�*�B+(�E=� "��-�(GM.0� � $�+<n�bF���<�hGH�x.0" � �rn�� �<�->s4-n�"��x9<9�0� +(n��]9;>��5�'.-),� $I9!����+(���<G $&"��*�]=��u+<n�� 9;+ .*"��.*� � ���Fb�$I.0+<$��-"u�0� +<n�� "s�-�<GU.0� ��$:95+<�<$�=�>�+($&�-" ���rn���<�TS�*),+a.0"),�uGH�������Z�-=�+a.0$&"s�*� ���-�M�*.�) nW�*� +<ns�[.0=�*b�� 95>��;�'.�),�i+ ��6�*9H$:9]>9;�*� +(� �����<$�b���+(n��9;>/)�),���*��$&"�4A�-"����d���Zt^px�Xr} � X{e���U[nZt`)`�X>[ u i��en`)Z � Z�"Zt^px jr[n^.Z>�

qr�,���-�(� � � 6��(��),���*�[+<�i�����<$�b�� �<�,S�x),+ .*"),� GH�����F�:9E���-�A+<n�� .0=�*b���%�GH��"�+<$&��"��*�i95>��;�'.�),�+ ��6�*9 �. =s�<$&�T��$&�&��>9;+(� .*+<$&��"M�0�c+(n��@��� �*),+h�0� �<��>�4-ns"��*9<9#�-"i��$�� >9;�@�(�,S�*),+($&��" � �->��I�H=V�A>9;�T��>��\�$c�-"/9;$:������o���-�]+<n��M6�>s�<6��95���0�B��$:9(),>9<95$&��"��r+<ns��95$&"�4��&���!%')�.�b�$�+ �[9;n�� � " $�" L2$&4�>��<�uY�� qr�-+(n�'.-)T��+ 98�*�!+(n��M)�.�b�$&+ �[.0�(�U��>s�&���i$��&��>�GH$&"/.0+<�x��=�� . ��$:9;+a.0"�+ 95�->��a),�M�-"N+<n��M�($&4-n�+ 95$:���3� Q �#+(n���'.-)T��+ 9!.*�<� � .0G]=���<+($:.0" � $�+<ni����>.*�c.0��=V�x������+<n�� ���,��+E�'.-)T��[email protected]�x.0� 9@=��<$�4-n�+<���Z+<n.*" +(n�� �<$�4-n�+�-"s�H.�9 $�+!�<�x),��$&b��x9KGH���<�A$&"),$I����"�+E��$&4�n�+F� Q �r+(n�� �!%\)F.xb�$&+ �M$:9#b�$�� � �*�H���<��G +<n�� ���,��+@9;$I��� =��[.��$I9;+ .*"�+#�-=/9;���(b�����s. �I.0�<4����h��� .-)T+<$&��"M�0�c+(n��B�����<�*95n��-�(+<��"��x� )F.xb�$&+ � .0�(�*. $:9h�s.0�� u.*"��.]9;GM.*�&�������� .�),+<$��-"u$:9h=��<$�4-n�+��hJ!9h+<ns�8�-=/9;���(b����hGH�*b��*9v+(�H+<ns�8�<$�4-n�+��+(� � .0�a��9E+<ns�895�->��a),� ��$&�<�x),+<$��-"���+(n����� .�),+<$��-"H�*�o=s�<$&4�n�+(��� .0�(�*.8$&")T�<�*.�9;�*9 � n�$��&�!+(n.0+ �0� +<n��@�s.0�� ��F�r.*�<�*. ���*),�<�x.-9;�x9,�J$c��"9;����>��F"�+(���#�� &�B�x /�?�>6>_<RB(703W< B(T�wE5�< >F>6? Z'p:�\��#��\� ]�� ����� , PH4ST�3CB�?�D638T�YEo! ��" , Z21�3C>F3�"$#��%�

j

Page 12: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

+<ns�8+<��+ .*�o=��<$�4-n�+<"��x9<9�� �-�!�a.-��$I.0"),� �V�*�r+(n�� )F.xb�$&+ �H$�"),�(�*.-95�*9E.�9!+<n��A�-=95���<b����Z.06s6��<�3.-) n��*9E+(n��9;��>�� )T�M��$&�(�*),+($&�-" �s�E��+<�]+<n.*+8+<ns$:9B�(�*9;>s�&+ 9E���(�-G +<ns�H=��<$�4-n�+<"��x9<9@��$:956.0�($&+ �i=��+ � ���F" +(n�� + � ��'.-)T��+ 9 � � n�$:) n $�"),�(�*.-95�*9 � $�+<nN+<n��U.0"�4��&�H�*�!$�"),$:����"),��� �rns$:98��� �*),+A$:9@$&"N),��"�+(� .�9;+ +<� � .0GH%=���<+($:.*"[9;>��5�'.-),�*9 � n���95� =��($&4�n�+("��*9<9Z�����*9E"���+@b-.*��� � $&+<ni+(n�� b�$&� � $�"�4H��$&�<�x),+<$��-" � �rn��].0=�*b��$&���&>95+<�a.0+<$��-"]���FGH�-"95+<�a.0+<�x9 +(n.0+c�(�->�4�n � .0G]=���<+($:.0"]95>��;�'.�),�*9 .0�<�#$&"sn����<�F"�+(���@"��-"s% � .*G =���(+<$:.*"$&"[�<�TS�*),+a.0"),�3� �rn���$&�@�a.-��$I.0"),� $&"),�(�*.-95�*[email protected]+(n�� b�$&� � ���A.06s6��<�3.-) n��*9B+(n��M95�->��a),�H��$&�<�x),+<$��-" ��E� � � �@6��<�x9;��"�+#.B���-�(GM.0� +<�<�x.0+<G ��"�+ �0� +<n��A.*=V�*b��@��� �*),+F�

Brighter Darker

Source direction

Viewer direction Viewer direction

Brighter Darker Brighter Darker

L2$�4->��(�@Y�} �35� =���A #�������T���N1435� � �.�$��'A �1�� M���� &���*"�* ��* 1435� 'A M�$K�$ ����'��* 14��K �� =�5*�1435� ����M65� M��� 1" �����A � 4���1" ����N+

� �nZ���Y X��)Z\^pxyZ\m � jrmnisjr[n^.Z>�$c�-"95$:����� 95>��;�'.�),�#.0�(�*.���� +<n/.0+c$:9 $&GM.*4-�*�@=�� .!9;$�"�4-���#9;��"/9;�-�c������GH��"�+ $�"8+(n��#��$&�(�*),+($&�-"

& S !�Y R "�$ R " .0"��$��&�&>sGH$&".*+<�*� =���. ��$:95+ .0"�+#6V��$&"�+E��$&4�n�+Z9;��>�� ),�A$&"u+<n�� ��$&�(�*),+<$��-"� ! S !�Y Z#"�$/Z�"a��rn��@.*�<�*. ��� $I9r),��GH6��95�*� �*� .Bb���� �8�I.0�<4��!"�>�G =��� �0� 9!��GHGH�T+<�($:) �!%')�.�b�$�+<$��*9,��tc.-) n �!%')�.�b�$�+ �$:9A),�-G 6V�39;�*�[�0�Z+ � ���'.-),�F+ 9 � $�+<n +(n��u9<.*GH�H95�&��6V�M=�>s+8�'.-),$�"�4�$�" �-6�6�39;$&+(�i��$��<�*)T+<$&��"9,� � >s�.06s6��<�3.-) nH$:9o+<� ),�-G 6�>�+<�h+(n��#� .-��$:.0"/),�!)T�-"�+<�<$�=�>�+($&�-"]�0���x.-) n8�'.-),��+c��"H+<n��Z9;>s�;�'.-)T��� �rn���"���+(n��+<��+ .*��� .���$:.*"),�r�*� +<n�� 9;>��5�'.-),�h6.*+ ) n )�.*" =�h����+(���<G $&"��*�Z.-9o.*"].04-4��<��43.0+(�E�*��+(n��h)T�-"�+<�<$�=�>�+($&�-"/9�0� .0���V�'.�),��+ 9T�r$c�-"95$:���F�r+<ns�ES>� H�(�,S�*)T+<�*� =�� .B�'.-)T��+ � $�+<nM.*�<�*.(��H.*"�H"��-�(GM.0� S !"Y���"�$���"a��rn�� 6��<� �5�x),+<�*�A.0�(�*.E�-"A+<n�� 9;>��5�'.-),�h��)F),>�6�$��*�B=��@+<n��c�'.-),��+�$:9 ��H),�39NY�&!'9;��� L2$&4�>��<� �#"a�W�E��")T�#�� n�$��&�]),��GH6�>�+($&"�4H+(n�� ),�-"�+<�($&=�>�+($&��" �*�h+<ns� �'.�),��+@+<�u+<n��]� .���$:.*"),�]�0�h+(n�� 9;>��5�'.-),�]6.0+a) n � � �"����x�U+(�H>95�8+<ns�B6s�<� �5�*)T+<�*�M.0�(�*. ��H)T��9NY��!.0"��"s�-+#+<n�� .-),+(>.0���'.�),��+Z.0�<�x. �����rn��A� .-��$:.0"/),�

l

Page 13: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

),��"�+(�<$&=s>�+<$��-"M+<n�>9h����+(���<G $&"��*� $:9 � n/.0+ � �A)�.0����+(n�� $ �\+��� ���C ���\�������g) ��o�0�c+(n��!�'.-),�F+�}

R�� !�Y�� "�$��E" S ��� R !"Y���"�$���"!#��r),�39 Y � " ),��9NY R �*) R !;^("

L��-�]�*.-95�i�0�A���*9<),�($&6�+($&��"�� � �un.�b��u���<��6�6�*� +<n�� 9;��>�� ),� .0"� b�$&� � $&"�4 ��$&�(�*),+($&�-"/9B���<�-G +(n��"���+ .0+($&��"9 �����E6s�<� �5�*)T+<�*� �a.-��$I.0")T�8.*"�US/>� ��� Xrx jwd � jrmnisjr[n^.Z>�

�E� � ),��"9;$I�����@+<n��]95�&��6V�F%\.*�<�*.u��$:95+<�<$�=�>�+($&�-"i�*�h�'.-),�F+ 9E4�$&b���"i=�� ��!"Y�� "�$��E" � �rn��]+<��+ .*�� .���$:.*"),�A�0�c+(n�� 95>��;�'.�),�A)�.0"i=�8��=�+ .*$&"��x��.-9h+<ns� .�b���� .*4-�@�0� R�� !�Y� " $��E"c�0� .0�����'.-),��+a9K��"�+(n��9;>s�;�'.-)T��}

R !"Y R " $ R � Y Z�"�$ Z6" S�� , ,����� �, , ���� ��!"Y���"�$��E" R�� !�Y� " $��E" 9;$&" Y�� � $�� �5Y�� !\jg"

�rn�>9�� � �cn.�b��r���*),�-G 6V�39;�*�!+(n��c6��<��=��&��G �*� ),�-G 6�>�+<$�"�4r+(n��r�a.-��$I.0")T�r�0�V.0"��!�<��>�4-n]95>��;�'.�),�r+(��-"s�E�*� )T�-GH6�>s+<$&"s4!+<n��h6s�<� �5�*)T+<�*�@� .-��$:.0"/),�r���-�c�*.�) n8�'.�),��+o��" +(n��#9;>��5�'.-),�3�"�rn��#+<��+ .0�s� .-��$:.0"/),��0� +<n��@95>��;�'.�),�8$I9r+<n��F" ��=�+ .*$&"��x�U=��H$�"�+(��4-�a.0+<$�"�4 +<ns�B6s�<����>)T+E�*�o+(n��@6��<� �5�x),+<�*�]� .-��$:.0"/),�A.0"�+<ns�895�&��6V�F%\.*�<�*.]��$:95+<�($&=�>�+($&��"U��>s"),+<$��-"M�*b����h.*�&���'.�),��+h"����<GM.*�:9,�

� E�� 2 �'A�:�;����= N ?�3¹QbA�35=>:"4��q3�� ?98;�B 3�?��/;5:UQtB ;�����:�� 3 ���>=k3 ��� �k3��/?�rn�� %�a9;+ 9;>��5�'.-),�M+ ��6� � �u),�-"95$:���F� n.-9].0���r�'.-),��+a9 � $&+(n +(n��u9<.*GH�M9;���-6� Y��0�NL�>��(+<n������r.*�&��!%')�.�b�$�+<$��*9c.0�<�A.*�&$&4�"��*�H$&" +<n��A9<.*GH�@��$��<�*)T+<$&��"2��.�b�$&G]>�+(nH.*"�4-���*9r�0� .0���V�'.-)T��+ 9h.*�<�@��$&+(n���� $��E���$�� V Wo�"�rn��#�<�x9;>���+ 9o�-=�+a.0$�"��*� �����r+<ns$:9c.0"�$I9;��+<�<��6�$:)Z9;>��5�'.-),� � $��&��=�!>/9;�*� �:.*+<���c$&" +<n��Z.0".*���s9;$I9�0� $:9;��+<�(�-6�$I)B95>��;�'.�),�*9T�

� jrmnifjr[U^.Z_}¹Y X>g j��jrg,h(Z\Y)x ifjr[$�7jw^.Z�x.�$c�-"95$:�����#. � .*G =���(+<$I.0" �'.-),��+h+(n.0+ $:9v��>������ $��&�&>sGH$&".*+<�*��! "��]95n.-��� � $�"�4f" .0"/�U$I9r),��GH%

6�����+<�����Nb�$I9;$&=s�&�m! "s� GU.-9! �$&"s4f"8���(�-G +<ns�[9;��"95�-� ��$&�(�*),+<$��-" � �rn�� �a.-��$I.0")T� �*� +<ns� �'.�),��+H$I96��(�-6�-�(+<$&��".0�c+(� $�+ 9E$��<�a.-��$I.0"),� .0"�i$:9#����>/.0�o+(� *, � !"Y���"�$��E" ���rn��]$&�(� .���$:.*"),�8�*�h+(n��B�'.�),��+!$I9� !�Y��*"�$���" S � � � ! "� "!�� � ns���<�#� � � $:9c+<n��#$&�(� .-��$:.0"/),� � ns��"H+<ns�K�'.�),��+r$I9o$&�&��>�GH$�".0+(�*�Bn��x.-��%��-"! $'� ���� ! S f" ��.*"� � "#!W���F"��-+(�*92+<ns�!����+o6��(����>),+ =V�F+ � ����"A+ � �!b��*),+(�-�a9,�o Z9;$&"s4!+<n��#����%"�$�+<$&��"�0� � .-��$:.0"/),�#��+(n��!S>� H�(�,S�*)T+<�*� =��H+(n��!�'.-),��+h$�"M+<n��A9;�F"9;���!��$��<�*)T+<$&��"H$:9r��=�+ .*$&"��x��.-9T}

��� RJS *, � �$� ! " %! � & "� %!��� �*) R !\lg"

1�>�=/9;+<$�+<>�+($&"�4 +(n��A.0=�*b��8�(�,S�*),+(�*� S>� H$&" !;^(" � � �B4���+�}

R�� !"Y���"�$���" S -W � � � ! " %! � & "� "!

� " � ! � & " � ! S !<�FC#"-W � � ),�39NY Zx),��9NY��'&T� V + .0">Y�Z*+ .*">Y���),�39�! $ Z ( $��E")(*&T� V + .0" Y R + .*"�Y��),�39E! $ R)( $��E")(

��C

Page 14: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

�rn�$I9v� �6��<�x9<9;$��-" ),�&�x.0�<���8$�"��$:)F.0+<�x92+<n.*+r+(n��E6s�<� �5�*)T+<�*� � .���$:.*"),�#�0� .B+($&��+<�*� � .*G =���(+<$:.*"8�'.-),�F+$:9!"���+8����>.*�v$�" .*�&�cb�$&� � $�"�4u��$&�(�*),+<$��-"9T� $c��"9;����>���"�+<���#��. �(�->�4�n � .0G]=���<+($:.0" 9;>s�;�'.-)T�H),��GH%6��($:9;�x� �0� +($&�&+(�*� �'.-),�F+ 9h$:9h"��-"�% � .0G]=���<+($:.*"2��$&+a9K�a.-��$I.0")T�8b�.0�($&�*9 � $�+<nu+<n��Ab�$�� � $&"�4]��$&�<�x),+<$��-" �� � � � $ �nR)�+��v�)�+g) � � +��������M �v����) ��)v� �n ������) �� + ���� �� ��)���� ���`���g+��/��)������g) � ��)f�C����R�� �%�� ��+g)�q ��� ���

�7as�>af� � ZtX{g�Z.x Y is^ w x)x Zt[kenj\x ifX>[��7jr^px X>YQ �A+<n�� 9;>��5�'.-),�[$:9 $&���&>�GH$�".0+(�*�N.0"� b�$&� � �*� ���<�-G +<n��i"s�-�<GU.0�Z��$&�(�*),+<$��-" !* ! S & S � " �!.*�&��'.-)T��+ 9].0�(� ��>������ $��&�&>sGH$&".*+<�*�[.0"/� b�$I9;$&=s�&��� L��-�]�:.0�(4-��� .0"s4-�&�x9 �*�8$�"),$I����"),�U.0"�N�<�,S�x),+<$��-"��n�� � �Fb�������'.-),��+a9h.0�(� 9;n/.-��� � �x��.0"/� GM.�9! ��*� =��u.-� �(.�),��"�+r�'.-),�F+ 9�!\95��� L�$&4->s�<� ^�"a�rQ\"�+(n��A)�.-95��0� ���`���g+��/��)�� � .8�'.-),��+#$:9h�-"s����6/.0�<+($:.*�&��� $&�&��>�GH$�".0+(�*�H.-9#+<n�� .-� �(.�),��"�+K�'.�),��+#�-"i+<ns� �!%')�.�b�$�+ �)�.�9;+ 9A.i9;n.���� � �-"N$&+F�MQ\" +<n�� )�.�9;�H�*����� �� ���)�� �c+<n�� �'.-)T��+8$I9 ��"����[6.*�<+<$I.0�����ib�$:9;$�=��&� +(��+(n��9;�F"9;���].-9 $&+ 9A.-� �(.�),��"�+8�'.-),�F+8��)�),��>���*98$�+��[qr�-+(n +<ns�*9;�M4-�F�-GH��+(�<$I)�.0�o6sn���"���GH��".u. � �*),+ +(n��6��(� �5�*),+(�*��� .���$:.*"),�]�0�#+<ns� �'.�),��+@.*"� n���"/),� G]>95+E=�H+a. ���"i$�"�+(��.�)�),��>�"�+F� �rn��]�<�x9;>���+B$I9@.�f8+��v � ��� � �������F�GR) �f��� ��+g) U�����_+��J! ����� "+(n.0+��&$��*9 =��+ � ����"�b����(�!.*"�B>�"s$&+ ��!\.0�I9;�Z9;��� � � �-�(� .0"/),�.0"/� 1�6.*�<�(� � %(��l�Y�^ �N� qr��$&"�"�%(��l�^-^ � " �cQ\+h$I9r+<n��@�<�x��>),+($&�-" $&"M+<n��@6��(� �5�*),+(�*� �a.-��$I.0"),�@�*� .B�'.-),�F+��>�� +(�HGM.�9! �$&"�4].*"� 95n.-��� � $�"�4M��� �*),+a9��$&+!����>.*�:9h+<n��A� .0+($&�H�*� +<n��8�'.�),��+Z.0�<�x. +<n.*+@$:9h=V��+<nb�$:9;$�=��&� .0"�M$&�&��>�GH$ ".*+<�*�$��+<�]+<n��@+<��+ .*� �'.�),��+h.*�<�*.��

x

z

n

m s

sw

^

^

^θa x

z

n

w

^

^θa m v

v ^

!\.g" ! ='"L2$�4->��(� ^3} ����� ��3��A�!�)KH M�5�(����� �.-/� ����*��A ��5�� ��B� � �.�$��'� �1"��+

����� }¹X>Y �'ZtY%v(Zt[Umnif^.eUdfjrY8fHy ~|jp�ni x ifZt`p�� � %�a9;+H�(�*9;+(�<$I),+ ��>�� 95���&b��x9 +(� �!%')�.�b�$�+<$&�x98+<n.*+M.0�(�i�-�<$���"�+<�*�N6V�F�<6��"��$I),>��I.0�]+<� +(n��

9;�F"9;���<%'9;�->s� ),�H6s�:.0"s��� � .0+(����o+(n��H.*".0����95$:9@$:9!� �+<��"���*� +(�i.*�<=�$�+<� .*���[95��"9;��� .*"�N9;�->s� ),� ��$&%�<�x),+<$��-"9T�kL2$�4->��(� ^i$��&�&>/9;+<�a.0+(�*9 +(n���GU.-9! �$&"s4[.0"� 9;n.���� � $&"�4 6�n���"���GH��".����-� +<n�� )�.-95�i�0�6���<6��"/��$:),>s�:.0� �!%')�.�b�$&+<$��*9,� � >��A�-=��5�*),+($&b��A$:9!+<� ����+<�F�<GH$�"��#�����-� .M4-$�b���"[9;��>�� ),�U��$&�(�*),+<$��-" !.0"/� 9;��"/9;�-� ��$&�(�*),+($&�-" & +(n�� ��� .-)T+<$&��" �*�h�'.-),�F+8.*�<�*.H+(n.0+A$:9!$&���&>�GH$�".0+(�*��.*"� b�$:95$&=������ Q �h+(n��b�$:9;$�=��&� .0�(�*.�$:9A9;GM.*�&�����@+<n.*" +(n��H$��&�&>sGH$&".*+<�*�u.0�(�*.��cGM.-9 �$�"�4i���-GH$�".0+(�*9,� � $� �� � $I9;�#��$ �#+(n��$&���&>�G $&".*+<�*�H.*�<�*.H$I9!9;GM.*�&�����h+<n.*" +(n�� b�$:9;$�=��&� .0�(�*.���9;n/.-��� � $&"s4����-GH$�".0+(�*9,� �[�]����"���+<� +(n���&�F"�4-+(n !�� �+<��"�+8��" +<ns�i9;>s�;�'.-)T� 6s�:.0"s��"A.0"� � $:��+(n �*�@+<n��H�'.�),��+ =�� �!.*"��� � �<�*956V�x),+<$�b��������

�-�

Page 15: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

L�>��<+(n����������o.0"�����h.*�<�Z9;�*),+($&��"92�0� +<n��r�'.�),��+c+<n/.0+ .0�(�#9;n.���� � �*�H.*"� GM.-9 ��*�$�*�<�*956V�x),+<$�b���������rn��A.0�(�*.8�0� .B�'.�),��+h+(n.0+h$I9v=�-+(n $��&��>�GH$&"/.0+<�x� .0"�Hb�$:9;$�=��&�#$:9����� � ��� ( ��� " � ( ��� � � �rn������� $I9r�-=�+a.0$�"��*� =��M��$�b�$I��$&"s48+<ns$:9r� �6��<�x9<9;$��-"M=��H+<n��A.*�<�*. � � �*�o+(n��!�'.-),�F+�}

����� S �� ��� � ( ���� " � ( ������ !<���M"

�[� � �->s�:� �&$� ���+(� � �6��<�*9(9 +<ns� � ��� $&" +<���(GM9 �*� +(n��[.0"�4��&�*9]�0� $�"),$I����"),� !'9;�->s� ),��" .0"��<�TS�*),+($&�-" !\9;�F"9;����" � L��<��G +<n��@+(�<$:.*"�4-����! � �����R� � "c$&"uL2$�4->��(� ^g!\.g" � � �Bn/.xb��3}

� 95$&" Y Z S ����)T��9NY�� V � ),��9NY�� !<�FO#"� ),�39NY Z S ( ����95$&">Y�� V � 9;$�">Y�

q ��G]>���+<$&6s����$ "s4 +<n��&%�a9;+@� �6��<�x9<9;$��-"i=��i),�39/Y�Zc.0"/� +(n��]9;�*)T�-"�i=�� ( 9;$�">Y�Zc.0"�[.-�s��$&"�4M+(n���<�x9;>���+ 9 � �@4���+�}���� S ( ),��9'!�Y�� V Y�Z6"

),��9'!�Y�� ( Y�Z6" �-� � ( ���� S Oo),�39�Y���),�39/Y�Z),��92!"Y�� ( Y�Z6" !<�FX#"

Q\"@+<n�� .0=�*b��c� �6��<�*9(9;$��-"���+(n�� .0"�4��&�*92Y�Z�.0"��Y R .0�(�v6�39;$&+($&b��c$&"Z+<n�� ),��>�"�+(���<%'),����) � $:95�c��$&�(�*),+($&�-".0"/� "��F4�.0+($&b�� $&"8+(n��#),����) � $:95�h��$��<�*),+($&��" ��QR+ )�.*" =V�h�x.-9;$����A9;ns� � "]+<n/.0+o+(n����<�h$I9 "s�895n.-��� � $�"�4� n���"���Y � V Y Z ��` , , .0"���XY � ( Y Z ��` , , ��$\�_���c� (������� �-� � "]+<n��h��+<n��F�vn/.0"�$��+<n��h�F"�+($&�<�c�'.-),�F+$:9#9;n/.-��� � �x��$ ���5Y Z ( Y � � � , , �$\�_���@� (����� ` C��@J 9;$�GH$&�I.0� �<�*95>��&+#$:9E��=�+ .*$&"��x� ���-�#GM.-9 �$�"�4��JE���E+(n��*9;� ),��"��$&+($&��"9M.0�<�i$�"),��>���*� $�"W+<n��i���-���&� � $&"�4 � ��� � �6��<�*9(9;$��-" ���-�M6���(6V�F"��$:)T>��:.*��!%')�.�b�$�+<$��*9� F}

����� S � "!$#*C "%�� � #R� " Oo),�39NY ZI),��9NY��)T��9'!�Y Z ( Y���" "Oo)T��9NY R ),�39/Y��),��9'!�Y R)( Y��"'&(& !<�T f"

����� }¹X>Y�xx�UZ � Zt[UZtY jrd~|jr`)Z>�QR"M+(n��@4-��"��F� .0� )�.-95�#�9;��>�� )T�8.*"�M9;��"/9;�-�Z��$��<�*),+($&��"9r.*�<�A.0�(=�$&+(� .0� �M.0"/� )F.0"M�&$��!�->�+a9;$I���

+<ns� 6��:.*"�� 6���(6��"��$I),>��:.*�!+<�M+(n�� �!%')�.�b�$�+!�3��� �MGM.� ��8+<ns� GM.-9 �$�"�4")x9;n.���� � $&"�4u)�.*�:),>��I.0+($&�-"/9+<�a.-),+a.0=����#� � �A$&"�b�� ��!+(n�� .�9<95>�GH6�+($&�-"M+(n.0+!+(n��@�&��"s4-+<nu�0�o�'.�),��+a9K$I9K�I.0�<4�� ),��GH6.*�<�*� +(�H+<ns��$&�� $:��+<n%*�c$\�_��� �,+ �E� �rn���"��r+(n��u.0".*���s9;$I9 �*�!GM.�9! �$&"�4[.*"� 95n.-��� � $�"�4[$:9 �<�*��>/),�*� +(� +(n��6���<6��"/��$:),>s�:.0� �!%')�.�b�$�+ � )�.�9;�u=�� 6s�<� �5�*)T+<$&"s4i+<n�� 9;�->s� ),� ��$&�(�*),+<$��-" ! .0"/� 9;�F"9;���M��$&�(�*),+($&�-" & ��"�+(�i+<n��M6��I.0"��M6���<6��"/��$:),>s�:.0� +(� +(n��u)�.�b�$�+ ��� �rn��x9;�M6��<� �5�*),+<$��-"9 .*�<�u����"��M>9;$�"�4 =/.-9;$I)+<�($&4��-"���GH��+<� �H.�9h9;n�� � "M$&"uL2$�4->��(�@j�� �rns�B6s�<� �5�*)T+<�*�H.*"�4-���*9h.0�(�@+<n���"u95>�=9;+($&+(>�+<�*�]$&"�+<� !<�T f" �- &�BsDF1�3�5�>63C�EPH?�9�4A��3C>64FPH?�Bs? I�DF1�3 5(< 5�3C>8]'D61�3q?�>0TE3C>A? IXD61�3/.1032�< B�T�. }54 ?�5�3C>_<RDF?�>F4NZ2< 4&46Z2PHD_761�38TsYEo@NPH46D_<���3�cf/21�3�3C>F>6?�>kZ2< 42PHBADF1�3�5�>6PQBED6PQBMV&?�B�;HoN< B�T&DF1M3W>F3C46Dk?RI`DF1M3W376�9(< D6PH?�B�4k<RB(T&>63C4F9�;HD64X< >63W9�B(761(<RB�V�3\Tgc8:9 1�3GB�I <�7:3CDk;H3CB�V�DF1qPH4d@&9(761 ;=<R>FV�3G>kDF1�< B�I <�703CDdZ2P�T�DF1^]�DF1M3W3 (<�70D�461(< 5�3a?RInDF1�3&7C< 46Dk461(<�TE? Z <RDkD61�3WD�Z'?3CB(T�4k? I�DF1�3�I <�703GDk7C< B�Y�3XPHV�B�?�>638Tgc

��O

Page 16: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

θθp

φ

x

y

z

^

^

9;$�">Y � S 9;$&">Y ),��9 $� ),��9 , Y V 9;$&" , Yc),��9 , $

)T��9NY � S ),��9NY� ),��9 , Y V 9;$&" , Yc),��9 , $

+a.0" Y � S +a.0">Yc),��9 $

L2$&4�>��<�Aj�}%����#��1" �����*C3! -�7-:�$1�K�$�$�.�5 4���"���14��(�����(����1&6���� ���5�����*$+

$&"M6��I.-),�@�*� Y�Z�.0"/� Y R ��+(� �-=�+a.0$&"u+<n��@4���"����a.0� ����� �� �6��(�*9<95$&��" }

� ��� S � ! # C " � � # ��" Oo),�39 Y Z )T��9NY �),�39/Y�Z*),��9NY�� V 9;$&">Y�Z*95$&">Y���)T��92! $ Z ( $��E" "

Oo),�39 Y R )T��9NY��),�39/Y R ),��9NY � V 9;$&">Y R 95$&">Y � )T��9'! $ R ( $ � " & & !<���#"

JE��+<���(".0+($&b������#�V+(n�� � ���|)F.0" =�H� �6��(�*9<95�*� $�" +(���<GU9E�0�#+(n��H95�->��a),�#�c95��"9;���� �'.-),��+@"����<GM.*� �.0"/��9;>s�;�'.-)T�B"s�-�<GU.0��b��x),+<��� 9,}

����� S � "!$#�C " �� � #-��" O � ! " � ! � " � !� ! "� "! " O � & " � ! � " � !

� & "� %! & & !<�FY#"

��Y X �)Zt^px Ztm � jwmUifjr[n^.Z jr[nm ����� ��rn�� 6s�<� �5�*)T+<�*�M� .-��$:.0"/),� �0�K. � .*G =���(+<$I.0" �'.�),��+!$I9E�-=s+ .0$�"��*�i=�� 9;$�GH6���� G >���+<$�6�����$&"�4

+<ns�84-�F�-GH��+(�<$I)E.*+<+<�F"�>.*+<$��-" �'.�),+<��� � $�+<nu+<n��A6��<� �5�x),+<�*�]� .-��$:.0"/),�s!(��C#"K�����<$�b��*� >�"/�����#+<n��A.-95%9;>sGH6�+<$��-" �*��"��8GM.�9! �$&"�4 .0"�H95n.-��� � $�"�4�� ��.0=����8�Z����+ .*$&�I9 +(n�� � ��� .0"�]+<n��Z),�-�(�<�*956�-"��$�"�46��(� �5�*),+(�*� �a.-��$I.0"),�@���-�@.*�&� )�.-95�*9E�*� 9;n.���� � $&"�4u.*"��GM.-9 �$�"�4��N�E��+<�A+<n.*+!+<n�� 6s�<� �5�*)T+<�*�H� .*%��$I.0"),�A$:9#����"���+<�*�i.�9 �R�� ��+(n�� 95>�6��� 9(),�<$�6�+!$:9h>95�*��+<�H$�"��$I)�.0+(�B+(n.0+Z+<n��A� .-��$:.0"/),� $:9#��>�� +(���$��<�*),+c$��&�&>sGH$&".*+<$��-"8=��]+<n��@95�->��a),��� QR" +<n��!"s� �+ 95�*),+<$��-"�� � � � $&���V>/9;� W,R�� +(� ����"s�-+<�Z� .-��$:.0"/),���>��@+(� $�"�+(���<�(�,S�*),+($&��"9,�

�7as�>a�� �)[>x Z\Y Y Z�"Zt^px ifX{[��7jr^pxyX{YQ\"N�->��]�<�,S/�*),+ .*"),�MGH�����F� � � �u.*�:9;� .-)F),�->�"�+ ���-�]$&"�+<���(�<�,S�x),+<$��-"9��v��$&4-n�+ � .�s98=�->�")T$&"�4 =��%+ � ���F"].-� �(.�),��"�+2�'.-),�F+ 9,� �rn��*95�E��� �*)T+ 9o.*�<�Z9;$&4�"�$�%V)�.0"�+o���-�c�<��>�4-n 9;>��5�'.-),�x9 � $�+<n]�<���I.0+($&b������!n�$&4�n.0��=�*���Mb�.0�&>s�*9,�&�Wns��"i+<n��]95>��;�'.�),�]$:9E$��&�&>sGH$&".*+<�*� ���<�-G �I.0�(4-�].0"s4-�&�x9 !�Y�Z6"#.*"� b�$&� � �*�H���<�-G+<ns�H�-6�6�39;$&+(�M9;$I���M.*+8�:.*�<4��M.0"�4��&�*9�!"Y R " �2"���"��H�*�!+(n�� �'.�),��+a9B+<n/.0+ .*�<�Hb�$:95$&=���� +<�i+(n��H95��"95�-�

��X

Page 17: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

� ��� �R�� !�Y��"�$���"�E�]�i.-9 �$�"�4 *

, � � � ! "� %! � & "� %!� " � ! � & " � ! S�-� � *

, � � ),��9NY Z ),�39/Y � & � V + .*"�Y Z +a.0" Y � ),��9[! $ Z ( $ � " (1�n.-��� � $�"�4 & � V + .*"�Y R +a.0">Y � ),�392! $ R ( $ � " (�i.-9! �$&"s4 , � & " � ! � " � !� & "� "! *

,� � O � ! " %! S*, � � ),��9NY Z ),�39/Y � O & � V + .0" Y Z + .*"�Y � ),��9'! $ Z ( $ � " (

1�n.-��� � $�"�4 , � ! " � ! � " � !� ! "� "! *,� � , � ! " � ! � & "� "!� & " � ! S*, � � ),��9NY�Z*),�39/Y��hO &T� V + .0" Y R + .*"�Y�� ),��9'! $ R)( $���" (

�2.*=��&�]�-}��@ &���"���14��� ����A #�������>���2�,�.�����$1�I�� �A �� �$ &�$�X1 ����*��A ��5���)*"3��A�!�)KH M�5���������A �1" �����*$+

.0�(�8$��&�&>sGH$&".*+<�*�]=��H+(n�� 95�->��a),���ZQ'� $&"�+<���(�<�,S�x),+<$��-"9 .0�<�A"��-+ ),�-"95$:���F�<�*�$�+<ns�8� .���$:.*"),�A�0�c+(n��9;>s�;�'.-)T� � ��>��:�i=�7b����(� $�" +<ns$:9@)�.-95���*�E� � ��b�������+<ns� b�$:95$&=����8�'.-),��+a9B�(�*),��$�b��8�&$�4-n�+!���<�-G|+<ns��$&�.-���(.-),��"�+v�'.�),��+a9v+<n/.0+r�'.-)T�!+<n�� 9;�->s� ),�@.*"�Hn���")T�@.0�(�!$&���&>�GH$�".0+(�*�����rns�*9;�@$&"�+<�F�<�<�TS�*),+($&�-"/92�<��%9;>s�&+c$&"]"��-"s%8b��F�<� 95>��;�'.�),�#� .-��$:.0"/),��� � >�� .0".*���s9;$I9v.*"� � �6���<$�GH��"�+ .*���<�*95>��&+a9v95>�4-4��*9;+h+(n.0+c+(n��),��"�+(�<$&=s>�+<$��-"u��>��@+<� $�"�+(���<�(�,S�*)T+<$&��"9r)F.0"M=� 9;$�4-"�$ % )�.*"�+#.*"��)�.*"�"���+h$&"M4-��"s��� .*� =V�A$&4�"��-�(�*���

� �[n.�b���+(n��i+ .�9! W�0� GH��������$&"�4[$&"�+<�F�<�<�TS�*),+($&�-"/9 $�"W+<n��i6��(�*9;�F"),�i�0� GM.-9 �$�"�4 .0"�9;n/.-��� � $&"s4i��� �*),+ 9T�iQ\" +<ns�M)�.-95�H�0� � .0G]=���<+($:.*" 95>��;�'.�),�*9��o+(n��H��"s���<4 � $�"N.0" $�"),$I����"�+B��$&4�n�+� .�u��$�GH$&"�$I9;n��x9r� .06s$:����� � $�+<nu�*.-) n�$�"�+(���<�(�,S�*),+($&��" =��>�"),�����rns���<�,�����<�#� � �AGH������� ��"����u+ � �-%=�->�"/),�!$&"�+<�F�<�<�TS�*),+($&�-"/9o.0"�]$&4-"s�-�<�Z9;>s=9;����>���"�+c=�->�")T�*9,�r1�$�G >s�:.0+($&��"92�0��+(n��#$&"�+<���(�<�,S�x),+<$��-"6��(��),�*9<9 � �F�<�!>95�*� +(� b����<$ � � +(n.0+#+<ns$:9h.06s6��<�� �$&GM.*+<$&��"H$:9h.84������ ��"����

QR" +<n��E�����&��� � $�"�4A��$:9(),>9(9;$&��"�� � �!�<�T�����c+<�]9;>s�;�'.-)T�!� .���$:.*"),�Z��>��!+(�]��$&�(�*),+c$&���&>�GH$�".0+($&��"=�� +(n��M9;��>�� )T��.�9 �R .0"� � .���$:.*"),�M��>��M+<��$�"�+(���<�(�,S�*)T+<$&��"[email protected] ,R � � � � $&�&�c>95�M+<n��M9(.0GH�9;>s6V�F� 9<)T�<$&6s+ 9 ���-�M6��(� �5�*),+(�*� � .���$:.*"),��� �rn��[+ � �-%�=�->�"/),� $�"�+(���<�(�,S�*)T+<$&��"W),��GH6�-"��F"�+ �����u.� .0G]=���<+($:.*" �'.-),��+U)�.0" =� � �6��(�*9<95�*�W.-9 � 13$&��4����!.*"�L�E� � �����&%(��l�^xOM� ���!����"�����($&"� .0"�Wb�.0"7E�����<"�%(��l�j-X � � L/��� 9 ��+(n�.*"���$I9<95���<GM.*"�%(��l-j�l �a� �!.��.0�u��&����� %(��l�l���. � }

,R !�e " S -W � �� !��e " �o " �R !��o " ���o !<�*^�"

� n����(� �e $I9 .i6�-$�"�+]�-"W+(n�� �'.�),��+ � n���95�i$&"�+<���(�<�,S�x),+<$��-"N),��GH6�-"��F"�+ $I9 ���F+<���(GH$&"��x� .-9H.*"$&"�+<�F4-� .*�2�*� +<n��A� .-��$:.0"/),� �0� .0���26��$&"�+ 9 �o �-"i+(n��].-���(.-),��"�+h�'.-),��+F� ! �e " �o "h$:9#+<n�� g���)� � .0"��<�F6��<�*95��"�+ 9 +<n��i4����-GH�F+<�<$I)�.0�h�(���:.*+<$��-"95n�$&6W=��+ � �F��"��e .*"���o � 1�$�"),�u+<n�� �!%')�.�b�$&+ � $:9]�&�-"s4),��GH6.0�(�*��+<�M$�+ 9 � $I��+<n�� $�+8)F.0"[=V�]b�$&� � �*��.�9B.M�-"��F%\��$�GH��"95$&��".0� 9;n.*6� � $&+(ni+<� .*"9;�I.0+($&�-"/.0�9!��GHGH�F+<���3�kL��-�u9;>/) n 9;n.*6�*9��!+(n�� $�"�+(���<�(�,S�*)T+<$&��" ),�-GH6��"���"�+M)�.0" =� ����+<���(GH$&"s�*�N.-9�.*"$&"�+<�F4-� .*�c�0b��F�B+(n��]�-"���%'��$�GH��"95$&�-"/.0�c),�(��9(9;%'9;�*),+($&��" �0�#+(n��M9;n/.06��� �rn��H.*=�0b�� $&"�+<���(�<�,S�x),+<$��-"����>.0+($&��" $I9r+<n��F�<�,�����<�@�<�*��>),�*� +(��}

,R ! !'" S -W � �� ! ! "�� " �R !�� " ��� !<�Fj#"

�,

Page 18: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

� n����(�/!i.*"� �M.0�<� +(n�� 95n��-�(+<�*95+@��$I9;+ .*"),�*9h�0� 6�-$�"�+a9 �e .*"� �o ���<�-G +(n�� $&"�+<���a9;�*)T+<$&��"M�0�c+(n��+ � �M�'.-),��+a9v!'9;��� L2$&4�>��<�Ul#" � � $I9B+<ns� ����<"s���2���-� +(n��]+<� .*"9;�I.0+($&�-"/.0�#9!��GHGH�F+<���u)�.�9;�M.*"� $I9�����($&b��*�]$&" � � . ��-=s%<�Fl���^U�c.0"/��� L��-� 9 ��+(ni.*"���$I9<9;�F�<GM.*"�%<�Fl-j�lM� +<�]=��}

��! ! " ��" S W@95$&" , !'O!Y��E"O

! �! ! , V O ! � ),��9[!\O!Y��E" V � , " ��� ,

!<�Fl#"

�[� �"�� � +<n/.0+@+<n�� "s�-�<GU.0���0� +<n��])T�-"95$:�����(�*� �'.-)T��+!$:9 S !�Y�� "�$��E"#.0"/� +(n�� "��-�(GM.0���0� +(n��

x

z

^yx

sv^

L2$�4->��(�8l�} 0.�!14�$ 4 4��<����1" �����*H ��B� � �.�$��'� �1"��+.-���(.-),��"�+2�'.�),��+�$:9 � S !�Y � "�$ � V Wd"a� �rn��h�&$�GH$&+a9V�0� +(n��h$&"�+<��4�� .*��$�"8+<ns�r$&"�+<�F�<�<�TS�*),+($&�-"@����>.*+<$&��".0�(� ���F+<���(GH$&"��x� =��M+<n��@GM.�9! �$&"�4].*"�i9;n.���� � $&"�4 �0�c+(n��*9;�@�'.-),�F+ 9,� J!9r=�,���-�(�#�V����+ � � =�8+(n��� $:��+<n[�0�#+<ns� �'.�),��+ � n�$:) ni$:9!b�$:95$&=���� +<��+(n��]b�$�� � ���F� � ��+ � � =V� +<n�� � $:��+(n �*�h+(n�� �����U����R)f��'.-)T��+r+(n.0+h$I9r$&�&��>�GH$�".0+(�*��� J!9r$�"�1��*)T+<$&��"H ����-��� ��� �6��<�x9<9;$��-"9 )�.0"M=�@�-=�+a.0$�"��*� ���-�h+(n��@b�$I9;$&=s�&�.0"/� $&���&>�G $&".*+<�*� 95�*),+<$��-"9T} ���� S � ! � C "�� � � � " ( � � " & !� " & ! �7� !\O�C#"

� �� S � ! � C "��� � � ��" ( � " ! !� � " ! ! �7� !\O��M"

L��<��G +<n��A��� %"�$&+($&��" �*�o6s�<� �5�*)T+<�*�H� .���$:.*"),��!;^(" .0"�M� �6��<�*9(9;$��-" !<�Fj#" � �@n.�b���}

,R�� S � � " & !�� � " � ! � & " � ! � �

� ��� ,R ! !'" ��! !\O�O#"

S ! -W " , � � � � � " ! ! � " & !�� � " � ! � & " � ! � �

� � � � �� � � �� ! ! "�� " ��� ��! !95$&"�4 +(n��B�����&�&� � $�"�4]) n/.0"�4��8�0� b-.*�<$I.0=����*9,}� S �� �� S��� ��+<ns�B�a.-��$I.0")T� ��>��@+(� + � ��% =��>�"),�$&"�+<�F�<�<�TS�*),+($&�-"/9v4-$�b���"H=�� !\O�O#" )�.0"M=� � �<$�+<+<�F"�.�9,}

,R�� S ! -W " , � � � � " ! ! � "� & !� " � ! � & " � ! � � �� ��

� �R � �� �� !�� "��" ������ !\O�X#"

���

Page 19: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

!95$&"�4 !(��l#" �V+(n��A.0=�*b��@$&"�+<��4�� .0� $:9r��b�.*�&>.*+<�*�M.-9T}

� � �� ��

� �R � �� � ! �" � " �� ��� S , , # ��!<� " ���� " V ��!<��" � �� " ( ��! � �� " ���� " ( ��!(��"���" & !\O* f"

� n����(��}

��! ! " � " S � ! , V O ! � ),��92!'O!Y���" V � , !\O��#"�[� �<�,�����Z+<� !'O0 f"Z.�9 +(n�� ��)f�C����R�� ��� ��+g)'U�����0+��q! � � "a�8L��(�-G !'O-Xg" �2+(n�� $&"�+<�F�<�<�TS�*),+($&�-"u),��GH%6�-"��F"�+#�0� +<n��@6��(� �5�*),+(�*�H� .���$:.*"),�@�0� . �'.�),��+ � $�+<nM"��-�(GM.0�X!"Y���"�$���"c$I9,} ,R�� !"Y � "�$ � " S ! -W " , � � ),�39 Y Z )T��9/Y � !'O-Y#"

&T� ( +a.0" Y�Z�+ .*"�Y��),��92! $/Z ( $��E")($&T� V + .*">Y R + .0" Y���),�392! $ R ( $��E")( � � !* & "� ! "� �"�rn��M+<��+ .*�h6��<� �5�x),+<�*�[� .-��$:.0"/),�M�0�Z+<n�� �'.�),��+ $I9B+<ns��95>�G �*�!+(n��H6��(� �5�*),+(�*� � .���$:.*"),�u��>��M+(�9;��>�� )T�B$��&��>�GH$&"/.0+<$��-"*! 4�$&b���"H$�" �2.*=��&�]�M" .0"/� +<ns�8.*=�0b��@$�"�+(���<�(�,S�*),+($&��"H),��GH6�-"��F"�+F}

R�� !"Y���"�$���" S �R�� !�Y��"�$���" V ,R�� !"Y���"�$���" !\O�^�"�rn�� >�"s$&%'��$&�(�*),+<$��-".*��9;$�"�4-����%\95�&��6V�]95>��;�'.�),� � �An.�b�� ),��"9;$I�����(�*��$&"u+<n�$I9!9;�*)T+<$&��"�n.�9!�-"���� + � �+ ��6�*9c�0���'.-),�F+ 9 � $&+(nH"����<GM.*�:9A!�Y��*"�$���" .0"� !�Y��"�$�� V Wd"a�W�E��")T�#��+<n��!�a.-��$I.0")T�B�*�o+(n��@95>��;�'.�),����-� .0"�� 4�$&b���" 9;��>�� )T�@��$&�(�*),+($&�-" .0"/�H9;��"/9;�-�#��$&�<�x),+<$��-"]$:9c9;$�GH6����A+<n�� .xb��F� .04��E�*��+<n��Z6��<� �5�x),+<�*�� .���$:.*"),�*9r�*�c+<ns�B+ � �8�'.-),��+h+ ��6�*9,}

R !"Y R " $ R � Y Z�"�$ Z0�$Y���"�$���" S R�� !�Y� " $��E" V R�� !"Y���"�$�� V Wd"O !\O�j#"

� E W 2 �'A�:�;����=���� � �>= �'��354 B�3�?�� ;5:nQ\B�;�����: ��3 ���¯= 3 � � �k3��/?�[� "s� � ),��"9;$I�����].i9;>s�;�'.-)T� � $�+<n �!%')�.�b�$�+<$��*9!+<n.*+ n.�b�� �'.-),�F+ 9 � $&+(nN+<n��u9<.*GH�M95�&�-6� !"Y���" �=�>�+#>�"�$ ���-�(GH���]��$I9;+(�<$&=s>�+<�*�H$�" ���<$���"�+a.0+($&�-" ! $���" $&"M+<n��@6��I.0"��@�*�c+<n��A95>��;�'.�),��� �rn��A�<�*95>��&+ $:9#.9;>s�;�'.-)T� � $�+<nM$:95�-+(�<�-6s$:)!�<��>�4-n�"s�*9<9T� �rn��@�(�,S�*),+a.0")T�!GH������� �����($&b��*�8���-�#+<n�$I9h9;>��5�'.-),�@$I9r=.-95�*��-"[+<ns� �<�*95>��&+a9E�-=�+a.0$�"��*��$&"i+(n�� 6��(��b�$��->9Z9;�*),+($&��"����-�@+<n��]95$&"�4��&��%'9;���-6�]9;>s�;�'.-)T���&�rns� �<�*95>��&+a9�-=s+ .0$�"��*�H$&"M+(n�$:9h95�*),+<$��-"u.0�(�@$&GH6�-�(+ .*"�+ .-9h+<n��� )�.*"�=�@>9;�*�H+(�]�����<$�b��@.8�<�TS�*),+a.0"),�ZGH����������-�Z.0"��H$I9;�-+(�<��6�$:)@9;>s�;�'.-)T���

L/�(�-G +<n�� 6��<��b�$&��>9o95�*),+<$��-"�� � �� �"�� � +(n��h� .���$:.*"),� �R�� !�Y��*"�$���" �0� .K�'.�),��+ � $&+(n "��-�(GM.0� S !"Y � "�$ � " � �rn����(�,���-�(�#� +<n�� �a.-��$I.0"),�]�0�#+(n�� 9;$&"s4-�&�F%\95�&�-6�]$:95�-+<�(�-6�$I) 95>��;�'.�),� ��>��]+<�u��$&�(�*),+9;��>�� )T�B$��&��>�GH$&"/.0+<$��-"]$:9h���F+<���(GH$&"��x� .�9E.*" $�"�+(��4-�a.0� �*�o+(n��@6��<� �5�x),+<�*�H�a.-��$I.0"),�@�*b���� $ � }

�R�� !�Y�E" S �OXW � , , � � �R�� !"Y�� "�$���" � $�� !\O�l#"

D#$&b���"A95�->��a),�h��$��<�*)T+<$&��"�!"Y�Z#"�$/ZF" .*"�895��"9;���o��$&�<�x),+<$��-"�!"Y R " $ R " � � �"%� 95+2"��F�*�B+(� %"/�B+<ns�v�a.0"�4��*9�0� �'.-),�F+o�-�($&��"�+ .*+<$&��" $ � ���-� � n�$:) n +<ns�r�'.-),��+a9o.0�(�EGU.-9! ��x�$�-95n.-��� � �*�$��GM.�9! ��*�A.0"�]9;n.���� � �*� �

��Y

Page 20: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

.0"/� "���$�+<n���� GM.-9 ��*�8"��-� 9;n.���� � �*���*�"�rn��!�a.-��$I.0")T�K�����v�x.-) n �a.0"�4��!$:9o4-$�b���" $&" ��.0=����8��� �rn��6��(�-=�����G +<n��F"H$:9c+<� ���*),�-G 6V�39;�#+<n�� .0=�*b��!$&"�+<��4�� .*�V$�"�+(�A��$�� ���(��"�+c6.*�<+a9����*.�) n ),�-�(�<�*956�-"��$�"�4+<� .8��$ � ���<��"�+cGM.-9 �$�"�4")x9;n.���� � $&"�4A� .*"�4-��� �[�E�(�,�����c+<n��Z$&"�+<���(�*9;+(�*�8�<�*.������c+<� JE6�6��"��$� J8�&����-�#����+ .*$&�:9c�-"u+<n��!�Fb-.*�&>.*+<$��-"M�0� $&"�+<��4�� .*�W!\O-lg" � �rn�� %"/.0� � �6��<�x9<9;$��-"H���-�#95>��;�'.�),�@� .���$:.*"),�!$I9���->s"� +(� =V�3}

�R�� !"Y���" S *, � � ),�39NY Zx),��9NY��

�� V )T��9'! $ R)( $/ZF" &�� � !��W�$Y���"3+ .0"�� V � , !�� "�$ R ( $/Z0� Y��" ( V

!<� ( � ),��92! $ R ( $ Z " �i" � � !"Y R "$Y Z �$Y � "���!\X�C#"

� n����(�#�� S � ! � Y�Z " Y R � .0"�� S �� � � Y�Z " Y R � � �rn��A� �6��<�*9(9;$��-"9v�����E+(n��A),��� �U),$&��"�+ 9 � � � � , �.0"/��� � .*�<�A4-$&b��F" $�"iJE6s6V�F"��$� UJ8�&���&�E�-+(�8+(n.0+!+(n��A.0=�*b��86��(� �5�*),+(�*� �a.-��$I.0")T�B$I9K+(n�� 9(.0GH�.-9!+(n�� +(�-+a.0�c� .���$:.*"),� �0� +<n�� 9;>s�;�'.-)T� ! �R !"Y R " Y Z#"�$ R ( $/Z0� Y�E" S �R�� !"Y���"\"Z95$&"),�].*�&�2�'.�),��+a9 ��"+<ns�]9;>��5�'.-),� n.�b�� $I����"�+<$:)F.0��9;���-6�#�2Y��0� �rn��]���F�<$&b�.*+<$&��"i$&"[JE6s6V�F"��$� J8�&�A�����*9@"��-+ ),�-"95$:���F�G]>��&+($&6����B�(�,S�*)T+<$&��"9���.�9B+<ns� $�"�+(���<�(�,S�*),+($&��"i),��GH6�-"���"�+�!\O�Y#"!$I9@��$��U),>���+!+<�M$&"�+<�F�<4-�a.0+(� �*b����.0���@)�.�b�$&+ � �-�($&��"�+ .*+<$��-"9 $��0� Q\" JE6�6��"��$� WJA�{O��#.*" .06�6��(�� �$�GM.0+($&�-" +<�N+<ns�i$&"�+<���(�<�,S�x),+<$��-"),��GH6�-"���"�+�! ,R !"Y R "$Y�Z#"�$ R ( $/Z0� Y��" S ,R�� !�Y���"\" $:9r4-$�b���" �

� "/),�H.*4�.*$&"��o$�+B$I9B$�GH6�-�<+a.0"�+!+<�u"��-+(�H+<n/.0+8+(n��H�a.-��$I.0"),�]�0�#+(n��]�<�->s4-n 9;>��5�'.-),�U),�-"�%9;$I�����(�*� n��F�<�i$:9 "���+�)T�-"95+ .0"�+ � $�+<nW�<�x9;6�*),+H+(� +<ns�ib�$�� � $&"�4 ��$��<�*),+($&��"t!"Y R "�$ R " �!$�+ $I9 "���"�%� .0G]=���<+($:.*" �'�[� � $&�&��95+<>���H+<n�$I9r=��n.�b�$��-�hGH���<�@)T�&��95�����]$&"M+(n��!���-�&��� � $&"�4]95�*),+<$��-" �

� E�� 2 �'A�:�;����= � 8'� ���{358? B�;��'��:UQ � =>:"8 ��3 ���¯= 3 � � �k3��/?�rn��[95>��;�'.�),�[),�-"/9;$:�����<�*�W.*=�0b��[)T�-"95$:9;+a9 �0� �!%')�.�b�$�+<$&�x9 � $&+<nW����>.*�E�'.-)T��+H95�&��6V�3� gK�x.0�&$I9;+($:)9;>s�;�'.-)T�*9r)�.*" =�!G �������&�x�B�-"s���]$ � +<n��Z9;���-6��%'.0�(�*. ��$:95+<�($&=�>�+($&��" ��!"Y � "�$ � "�$�"),�&>/���*9c.!b-.*�<$���+ � �0���$ ���F�<��"�+ �'.�),��+c95�&��6V�x9,�cQ � +<n��#95>��;�'.�),�E�(�->�4�n�"��*9(9o$:92$I9;�-+(�<��6�$:) ��+<n��Z9;���-6��%'.0�<�x.B��$:9;+(�<$�=�>�+<$��-"])�.*"=�h���x9<),�($&=�*�B>/9;$&"s4@.!9;$�"�4-���r6.*� .*GH��+<�F� ".0GH�F��� Y � 95$&"),� +<n��c�'.-),�F+ 9�.0�<� >�"�$ ���-�<G ���@��$I9;+(�<$&=s>�+<�*�$&"�$��0� �rn��@�a.-��$I.0"),�@�*� .0"��H$:95�-+(�<�-6s$:)@9;>��5�'.-),�A)�.*"�+(n����<�T���-�<�Z=V� ����+(���<GH$�"��*� .�9,}

R !"Y R " Y Z#"�$ R ( $/ZF" S � , ,� ��!�Y�E" R�� !�Y���"h95$&">Y�� �5Y�� !\X��M"

� n����(�!+<ns�895�->��a),�@$&���&>�GH$�".0+($&��" ! "�� $�"�+(���<�(�,S�*),+($&��"'" ),�-GH6��"���"�+r�0� R�� !"Y � "c$I9r4-$&b��F" =�� !\X�C#"a��[�#.-9<95>�GH� +<n��h$I9;�-+(�<��6�$:)h��$I9;+(�<$&=s>�+<$��-"8+(�!=�BDZ.*>9<95$:.0" � $&+(n GH�*.*"��M.*"� 9;+a.0"��.*� �H����b�$I.0+($&�-"�"�-$'� ��� ��!"Y � � � "��2" �ogh�*.�9;�-"/.0=����8�<��>�4-nU9;>��5�'.-),�*9 )�.0" =�Z���*9<)T�<$&=�*�@>9;$�"�4A.�b����<�ZGH�*.0" !�� S Cg"DZ.0>9(9;$I.0"[��$I9;+<�($&=�>s+<$&��" }

��!"Y � " S � ]�������� � !\X�O#"� n����(�@+<n��@"����<GM.*�&$cbx.0+<$��-"M)T�-"95+ .0"�+ � $I9,}

����� S � , ,� � � �, , � � ] ������� � 9;$�">Y� � $�� �5Y���&�@ <RV�PHB�3�<��2pF7C<\�EPHD�o�>F?�D0< D638Ta<RY(?�9�D^D61�3'V�;H?�Y(<R;�469�>�I <�703'B�?�>6@ < ;RIK?�>�< BEo�V�PH��3GBW4F?�9�>_7032< B�TW463CB�4F?�>nTEPH>F3870D6PH?�B^c�[<R>FPH?�9�4'@ <R4+�EPHB�V! R4F1(<�TE? Z2PHB�V�4_703GB(< >6PQ?�4X7C<RB�Y(3��EPH4F9(<R;QP#"C3\Tgc

�0^

Page 21: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

�rn��E�(�,S�*)T+ .0"/),�hGH��������$:9o+(�B=�#�-=�+a.0$�"��*� =�� 9;>�=95+<$�+<>�+($&"�4@+<ns�h� .-��$:.0"/),� �R�� !�Y���"24�$&b���"=�� !\X�C#" .0"�M+<n�� DZ.0>9(9;$I.0"i��$:9;+(�<$�=�>�+<$��-"���!"Y���� � " Cg"c$&"M$&"�+<��4�� .*�W!\X���" � �rn��@�<�*95>��&+($&"�4 $�"�+(��4-�a.0�)�.*"�"��-+]=�M�*.-95$&���[��b�.0��>.0+(�*��� �rn��F�<�,�����<�#� � � 6s>�� 95>��*�N. ��>s"),+<$��-".*�#.06�6s�<�� �$�GM.0+($&��" +<�i+(n��$&"�+<�F4-� .*�!+<n/.0+M$:9M.-)F),>�� .*+<��������.*�<=�$�+<�a.0��� 95>��;�'.�),�i�<��>�4-ns"��*9<9u.0"� .0"�4��&�*9H�0� $&")T$:����"/),�u.0"��<�TS�*),+($&�-" ��Q\"N���F�<$&b�$&"s4�+<ns$:98.*6�6��(� �$&GU.0+<$��-"�� � �M)F.0�<�T��>��&���i9;+(>��$��*� +<ns� ��>�"),+($&��".0�r�����<G|�0� �R�� !"Y���" 4-$&b��F" =�� !'X-C#"a� �rns$:9o��".*=��&�*� >9c+<�8$I����"�+<$ � �8=.�9;$:9o��>�"),+($&��"9o+<n.*+h)�.*"H=�!>9;�x� $�" +(n��.06s6��<�� �$&GM.*+<$&��" � �rn���"�� � �#),��"��>),+(�*�8.#�:.0�(4-�#95��+o�0� "�>�GH���($:)�.*�-��b�.*�&>.*+<$&��"9o�0� +<ns�r$&"�+<�F4-� .*��$�"!\X��M"�=��Bb�.*����$&"�4A9;>s�;�'.-)T�h�<�->s4-n�"��x9<9 �"�-+<ns�#.0"�4��&�*92�*� $&"),$I����")T��!"Y�Z�"�$ Z6"�.*"� �(�,S�*)T+<$&��"s!�Y R "�$ R "a��rn��*95�]9;$�G >��I.0+($&�-"/9E.*"� +(n�� $:����"�+($�%�x� =.�9;$:9E��>�"/),+<$��-"9 � ���<� >/9;�*��+(��.*�<�($&b��].0+ .0" .-)�),>s� .0+(���>�")T+<$&��".0�s.06s6��<�� �$&GM.*+<$&��"!���-�c95>��;�'.�),�r�a.-��$I.0"),�3�"�rn�$I9 6��(��),�*��>s�<� � .-9o.*6�6���$&�*�@$&"���F6V�F"����"�+<���+<�]+<ns�8��$&�<�x),+r$��&�&>sGH$&".*+<$��-"]),��GH6�-"���"�+#.-9 � �F�&� .�9r+<n��@$�"�+(���<�(�,S�*),+($&��"M),�-G 6V��"���"�+��

�rn�� %"/.0� .06�6��(�� �$�GM.0+($&�-" �<�*95>��&+a9h.0�<�A4-$�b���"M=V�F�&� � � � ")T�8.*4�.*$&"���&��+ � S � ! � Y R "$Y Z �.0"/� � S �� � � Y R " Y Z � � �rn��U��$&�(�*),+!$��&�&>sGH$&".*+<$��-"i)T�-GH6�-"s��"�+@�*�#� .-��$:.0"/),�H�0�K.i9;>��5�'.-),� � $&+(n�<��>�4-ns"��*9<9 �i$:9,}

� �R ��� R�� �^Z ���:R�� Z ���� � *,�� � ���X* �^Z ��� � �#� ��� �����!����X*:� �:R���� Z"� � , ��� �� �:R�� Z ����!1=������� &�� ��� ���X* � �:R��� Z.� � ( � � ��� �� ����!1=��� & �����

� ( �� n����(�@+<n��A),��� �U),$���"�+a9 � .0�<�3}�

� � � � �"!$# � ,� , � �"!$����

, �%&' &( �"! �)# * �* �,+ �.- � � *8 ��/� ������X* � �:R�� Z8�0���"! �)# * �* �,+ �.- � �21 *8 ��/� � � ,43, � ��5 �A1435�$ 4K #*"�

�� � �"! � ��# 1 � ,

� , � �6! ��7 5 1 �)�8�9 , 5 ,

!95$&"�4 .�9;$�GH$&�I.0�@.*6�6��(��.-) n��c.*" .*6�6��(� �$&GU.0+<$��-"[+<�u+<n��H$�"�+(���<�(�,S�*)T+<$&��"[),�-G 6V��"���"�+ � .-9A.0�I9;������($&b��*� �cQR"M+(n�$:9#)�.-95�#��+<ns�B$�"�+(���<�(�,S�*)T+<$&��"M),��GH6�-"���"�+r���-�#+<ns�895$&"�4��&��%'9;���-6�8$I9;��+<�<��6�$:)@95>��;�'.�),�!\J#6�6��"��$� iJ8�PO#" � .-9!>9;�x� +(� 4�>��*9(9 +(n��]=.-95$:9E��>�"),+($&��"9,� �rns� %"/.0� .06�6s�<�� �$�GM.0+($&��"�+<�M+(n��$&"�+<�F�<�<�TS�*),+($&�-" ),��GH6�-"���"�+h�0� � .���$:.*"),�!���-�Z. 9;>s�;�'.-)T� � $&+(nM�<�->s4-n�"��x9<9 � $I9,}

,R !"Y R "$Y�Z "�$ R)( $/Z_� �d" S C�?��0^ - ,W � � ),�39 Y�Z � ,� , V C�?���X

�� ( ),�39'! $ R)( $/Z6" 1 O �W 5 , � !\X* f"

�rn��@+ � �]),��GH6�-"��F"�+a9h.0�<�A),��G =s$&"��*� +<�]�-=s+ .0$�"�+(n��@+<�-+a.0��95>��;�'.�),�@� .-��$:.0"/),��}

R !"Y R " Y Z "�$ R ( $ Z � �d" S �R !"Y R "$Y Z " $ R ( $ Z � �d" V ,R !"Y R "$Y Z "�$ R ( $ Z � �d" !\X��#":G/21�3C463 70?E3 1 7:PQ3GBUD64a>630O(387:D&4FPH@N5�;HPi�j7C<RDFPH?�BM4k@ <�TE3rDF?qD61�3&?�B�3G4aPHB�PHDFP=<R;Q;HoA5�>F3C463CBEDF38T%PQB x *d>F3CBs< B(T�yd<\oU< >ep�8����$ � c

��j

Page 22: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

Q �o+(n�� 95>��;�'.�),�8$I9K�� �+(�<��GH�F��� �<��>�4-n ��)�.*>9;$�"�4H+(n���b����<��% G �*.0"iDZ.0>9(9;$I.0"iGH�����F� +<�]=V�].*"�$�".-),%),>��a.0+(�8.*6�6��(� �$&GU.0+<$��-"���.*"i.-�s��$&+($&�-"/.0� 6.*� .0G ��+<��� )�.*"�=�@>9;�x�U+(� � ��$�4-n�+r+(n��@$&"�+<���(�<�,S�x),+<$��-"),��GH6�-"���"�+�� � >s�895$&G]>��:.*+<$��-"9#9;n�� � +<n.*+B+(n�$:9!��"/.0=����*9E+<ns� GH�������2+(�u9;+<�(��+ ) n[. =s$&+!=�����"�$&+a98+<n��F�-�<�F+<$:)F.0�h�&$�GH$&+a9,� L2$&".*�&���#�o+<n���� � � � �*�@+<n��u95>��;�'.�),��$I98�-=�+a.0$&"s�*� ���(�-G $&+a98� .-��$:.0"/),�.0"/� $&�(� .-��$:.0"/),�].-9 QAR !�Y R " Y Z#"�$ R ( $ Z0� �d" S R !"Y R "$Y�Z "�$ R�( $/Z0� �d" � � � ),�39/Y�Z\�HQ\+!$I9!$&GH6�-�(+ .*"�++<�["���+<�M+<n.*+ +(n��u.0=�*b��MGH������� �-=��s9v�E�F�&GHn����&+=b#_9 �(�*),$�6��<��),$�+ � 6��($&")T$&6���� !'9;��� � qr�*) �GM.*"�".0"/�U1�6s$cb�b�$I) ns$&"���%<�Fl-Y-X � "a���N�2�U+�)�+��CA���`���k� �n ��+ �f � � ��� ����N�_+u���n #l��� ��� � ���g) ��+ �f �z� � � �n�)� S C��

QR"]+<ns�h"�� �+c9;�*)T+<$&��"�� � �h6��(�*9;�F"�+c95��b����a.0��� �6���<$�GH��"�+ .*���<�*95>��&+a92+<n.*+cb����<$ � �B+(n��Z�����<$�b��*���$ ��>/9;�@�<�,S/�*),+ .*"),�#GH�������'���E�F�<�#� � �@4�$&b��Z. =��($&�,� $&���&>95+<� .*+<$��-"H�*�o+(n��@GM.0$�"H) n.0�a.-),+(���<$I9;+($:)�9c�0�+<ns�vG �������\� L2$&4�>��<�h�FCE95n�� � 9 +(n��c�<�,S/�*),+ .*"),��6��<�x��$:),+(�*�E=��!+<ns�oGH�������*���-��.rb���� �E�(�->�4�n 95>��;�'.�),�� $&+(n � S X-C � .0"� - S C�?{l�� �rn��@� .���$:.*"),� R $�"M+<n��@6��I.0"��@�0� $&"),$I����")T�u! $ RTS $/Z#"�$/Z V Wd"c$I96����-+<+(�*��.�9!.8��>�"),+($&�-"u�0� +<ns�B�(�,S�*)T+<$&��"i.*"�4-���(Y R �����E$�"),$I����"),� .0"�4��&�;Y�Z S ^�� � � � � �M),>s�<b��*9.0�(�H95n�� � " $&"[+<ns�&%4->��(�#�2=��+<n ��=�+ .*$&"��*�i=��i"�>�G ���<$I)�.0� ��b�.*�&>.*+<$&��" �0� +<n��]$&"�+<�F4-� .*�o$&" !\X��M"a�1�n����<+(���#� � �@9;n.*�&� � s.0G $&"��#+<n��A.�)�),>��a.-)��H�*�c+<ns� ��>s"),+<$��-".*��.06�6s�<�� �$�GM.0+($&��" �

�rn�� %�a9;+]),>s�<b�� !'9;�-��$:� �&$�"���"@$�"),�&>/���*9B=��+<nW��$&�<�x),+8$��&�&>sGH$&".*+<$��-" .0"�N$&"�+<���(�<�,S�x),+<$��-"),��GH6�-"���"�+ 9�0��a.-��$I.0")T�#� � n�$&���o+<ns�r95�*),��"��! +<ns$&"@�&$�"���"�$I9V��"����!+(n�� ��$&�(�*),+ $&�&��>�GH$�".0+($&�-"#)T�-GH6�-%"���"�+��X�E�-+($:),� +<n.*+c+<n��*95�h� .���$:.*"),�h6����-+ 9c���Fb�$I.0+<�#95>�=95+ .0"�+<$I.0�����!���<��G � .0G]=V�F�<+<$I.0" �(�,S�*),+a.0")T���

-90 -75 -60 -45 -30 -15 15 30 45 60 75 90

0.025

0.05

0.075

0.1

0.125

0.15

Lr

rθiθrθ =

strong masking

strong interreflection

Lambertian

C + C tan rθ1 2

forward backward

L2$�4->��(�M��C�}�� ��N6�*"�� 4��<����1=�������, �� 1435� �!�#���5��� �@ M���& #�!�$�������I�� T�(*"65 "�.�����>K �143 � � ��� � D�� ���"! 7�� D����� ����& #�!�$����� ���5����� �$Z ��� # � + �35�(143! �� �� ��5�( #*� =���A #�������;�!65�(1&�F�A � 4���1 E����65�� �����1" ���� �.KH M1&35��651 ��X1&�$ 4 4��<����1" �����*���+� � � U���� �8�������g) �� ��) ��� 8� ���� � �q� �n ���6��/��)�� ��� �R ��� ��+g) �%$�$ �8+���� �n�� � �n �U+�� ���� ��� �R ��� ��+g)�� �rn��),>��(b��*9�)�.0"A=V�#��$&b�$:���*�!$�"�+(�!+<n��(���h95�*),+($&�-"/9,��Q\" +<n�� ���� ����� �A!\95�->��a),��"���$��<�*)T+<$&��"��*+<n�� � .-��$:.0"/),�$:9#GM. �$&G]>�G .0"/� 4���+ 9a),>�+(% �����i��>s� +<�M95+<�<��"�4MGM.-9 �$�"�4]��� �*),+ 9 � n���" Y R � s),���*�s9,Y�Z\� �rn�$I9

.� 9 1�3GB�� #��M]�� . # ��]�� � # �M]�< B(T�� � #��M]EoEPQ3G;�T�PQBMV��'.� #����� 70?�4 ���Cc

��l

Page 23: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

),>�+(% ���W��)�)T>�� 98� s.-)T+<��� .0+;Y R;S Y Z .0"� $I9B$&"/����6��"���F"�+A�0�Z�<�->s4-n�"��x9<9,� Q\" +(n��HGH$I�������]9;�*),%+<$��-"M�0� +<n��@6����-+���a.-��$I.0")T�8b�.0�($&�*9h.*6�6��<�� �$&GM.*+<�����].-9#. 9()�.0���*� � � Y R ��>�"/),+<$��-" � $&+(ni),��"9;+a.0"�+� � 95��+��AL2$&"/.0�&���#�$&"�+<���(�<�,S�x),+<$��-"9#���-G $&".*+<�@$&"i+(n�� U+�� �X��� �8��$��<�*)T+<$&��" � n��F�<� GH�39;+h�'.-),��+a9!.0�(�9;�F� ��%'9;n.���� � �*�u.0"�M+<n��Ab�$I9;$&=s�&�E�'.�),��+ 9h�<�x),��$&b��#�&$�4-n�+h6��<$�GM.0�($&���8���<�-Gz.�� �(.-),�F"�+h�'.-),�F+ 9,� �rn�$I9K$I9$&���&>95+<�a.0+<�x� =�� +<n��A��$ ���F�<��")T�!=��+ � ����"M+(n��@+ � �]),>��(b��*9,�

L2$&4�>��<� �-� 95n�� � 9E+<n��A��� �*),+h�*�rb�.*����$&"�4 9;>��5�'.-),�A�<��>�4-n�"s�*9<9T� �Wn���" � S C��+<n��AGH�������6��(�*��$:)T+ 9B�� �.�),+<��� � .*G =���(+<$:.*" �<�TS�*),+a.0"),�3���rns������b�$I.0+($&�-"[���<�-G � .0G]=V�F�<+<$I.0" =��n/.xb�$&��� $&"�%),�(�*.-95�*9h��� .*GM.0+($:)�.*�&��� � $&+<nM�(�->�4�n�"��*9(9,� QR"uL2$�4->��(� ��O^!\.g" �+<n��!� ���x),+h�0� b�.0����$&"s4 +<n��@$&"/),$:���F"),�

-90 -75 -60 -45 -30 -15 15 30 45 60 75 90

0.025

0.05

0.075

0.1

0.125

0.15

Lr

σ = 40

σ = 20

σ = 10

σ = 0

L�$&4->s�<�]�-��}�� �N���1 ���@ 4��65�A35�5�*4* �7���;*C65 "� �A���T =���A #���������4�$Z � � # � ����� � � �"! 7!��+

-90 -75 -60 -45 -30 -15 15 30 45 60 75 90

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

fr

iθ =75

iθ =60

iθ =45

iθ =0

-90 -75 -60 -45 -30 -15 15 30 45 60 75 90

0.025

0.05

0.075

0.1

0.125

0.15iφ rφ− = 0

iφ rφ− = 60

iφ rφ− = 90

Lr

iθ = 75

!\.g" ! ='"L2$�4->��(���FO�} !\.g"�������� �I�� �A ��N�$ 4�$�!1����5�����*,��� M���& #�!�$������+m! ='" � ���A #�������(��651=*8 #�!��1435� �!�G� �5����� ����& #�!�$������+ 0.�(-:��143.�!�M�A1=*$D � ����� � � ��� ����"! 75+.0"s4-�&� Y�Zh$:9 9;ns� � " � �E���(� � �Mn.�b��u) ns��9;�F" +<�i6s�&�-+��� �� �a.0+(n���� +<n/.0" �a.-��$I.0")T��+<�[=��+<%+<�F�8$&���&>95+<�a.0+<�]+<ns�H��� �*),+@�0�Zb�.0� ��$�"�4 Y�Z\� QR+A$:9@$&"�+<���(�*9;+($&"�4M+<�u"��-+(�H+<n/.0+ +<ns�HGH�������c6��(�*��$I),+ 9"��*.*�<% � .0G]=���<+($:.0" =V�Fn.�b�$��-�8���-� b��F��� 9;GM.*�&�c$&")T$:����"/),�H.*"�4-���*9s!"Y�Z��zC#"a� �rn�$:98�(�*9;>���+ 9!���<�-G

O-C

Page 24: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

Lr

rθ-90 -75 -60 -45 -30 -15 15 30 45 60 75 90

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2

0.25

Lr

rθ-90 -75 -60 -45 -30 -15 15 30 45 60 75 90

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2

!\.#" Y Z S C � ! =["%Y Z S � �

Lr

rθ-90 -75 -60 -45 -30 -15 15 30 45 60 75 90

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2

Lr

rθ-90 -75 -60 -45 -30 -15 15 30 45 60 75 90

0.02

0.04

0.06

0.08

0.1

0.12

!\)�"%Y Z S Y�C � !\�n"%Y Z S j�� �

L2$�4->��(� ��X�}��2��� ��� " #*"���(-��$1"K�$�$�(�!65���$ " #�$��� �$'�����6���1" ����;� � 1435�T���5�!���2�.143! #� ���� ��5��� �����?� 65����1C M�A����������5 4���! �����1" ����7�.1&3! M� �� M�5��� �I�� %��*"65 C� �����TKH M1&3 � � ��� � ����� � ���"! 7*�5+=�-+(nU�'.�),��+a9 �*� . �!%')�.�b�$&+ �8n.�b�$&"�4@"��x.0�<��� ����>.0� $&�<�a.-��$I.0")T�K�����r95GM.0���.0"s4-�&�x9v�0��$�"),$I����"),�3�2JZ9+<ns� $&"),$I����")T� .0"s4-�&�]$&"/),�<�*.�9;�*9 ��+<ns� =.-) �9()�.0+(+<���Z6�n���"���GH��"���"i=��4-$�"9!+<�u���-G $&".*+<���@L2$�4->��(���O^! ='"A95n�� � 98+<n��]��� �*),+A�0�#6��I.-),$�"�4�+(n�� 9;��"95�-� ��>�+ 95$:���H+(n��H6��I.0"�� �0�#$&"/),$:���F"),��� �Wn���" +(n��9;�F"9;���<%�"��-�(GM.0�6��I.0"��h$I9 6���(6��"��$I),>��:.*�o+<�@+(n��!95�->��a),��%�"��-�(GM.0�s6��:.*"��#�-+(n��E�(�->�4�nM9;>s�;�'.-)T�#.04�.*$&"� �n�$&=s$&+ 9c"��*.*�<% � .0G]=V�F�<+<$I.0"u) n.0�a.-),+(���<$I9;+<$I)�9,�

L2$&4�>��<�N�FX 95n�� � 9�),��GH6.*�<$:95�-"9]=V�F+ � ����" � .-��$:.0"/),�ib�.0�&>s�*9M),�-GH6s>�+<�*�N=�� "�>sGH���<$I)�.0���b�.0��>.0+($&��"H�0�a!'X��M"N!�+<n�$I) A�&$�"���" .0"�H+(n��K��>s"),+<$��-".*� .*6�6��<�� �$&GM.*+<$��-"*! +<ns$&"]�&$&"s��"�4-$&b��F" =�� !\X�X#".0"/��!\X0 ^" � � "),� .*4�.*$&"����a.-��$I.0")T� $:9EGH�x.-9;>s�<�*�H$&"i+(n��86s�:.0"s� �0� $&")T$:����"/),��! $ R�S $/Z#"�$/Z V Wd" �Q\"u.0�&��)F.-9;�x9���+<ns� ��>s"),+<$��-".*��.06�6s�<�� �$�GM.0+($&��"H6��<�*b��*9r+(� =�8b���� �H.�)�),>��a.0+<�3�

� E � � �98;�3 �>8"�k3��L: 2 � A�:�;J � �����&% �"�� � "W6��(�-=�����G $&" )T�-GH6�>s+<���Hb�$:95$&��" $�"�b����&b��*9 +<n��[>95� �*�]�<�,S�x),+ .*"),�iGH�����F�:9 �����),��GH6�>�+($&"�4A9<)T��"��#6��<��6V�F�<+<$��*9��s9;>) nM.�9���95>��;�'.�),�!���<$&�F"�+a.0+<$��-"����<�,S/�*),+ .*"),�#�3.0"�H�<��>�4-ns"��*9<9T�rL����9;>/) nu6��<��=��&��GU9v+<�]=�8+(� .-)T+ .0=s�&�#��$�+E$I9r"��*),�*9(9<.*���M+<�]n.�b��@GH�������I9 � $&+<nu95$&GH6����!GM.*+<n���GU.0+<$I)�.0����-�(GM92+(n.0+ )�.*" =V�#$&"�b����(+<�*�!+<�@�*95+<$�GM.0+(�r+<ns�h6.0�a.0GH��+(��� 9��0� $�"�+(���<�x9;+���J GM.��5�-���<�*.�9;�-" ���-�c+(n��

O��

Page 25: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

Lr

rθ-90 -75 -60 -45 -30 -15 15 30 45 60 75 90

0.025

0.05

0.075

0.1

0.125

0.15

Lr

rθ-90 -75 -60 -45 -30 -15 15 30 45 60 75 90

0.02

0.04

0.06

0.08

0.1

0.12

!\.#" $ R ( $ Z S C � ! =[" $ R ( $ Z S � �

L2$�4->��(���T �} �2��� ��� " #*"��� -:�$1�K�$�$� �!65���$ " #�$����$')����6���1C M�A� �.1&3! G� �7�� ��5���>�����71435� � 6����� �1=��1" �'������5�!����.143! ����� ��5����� ���!�� ��(1435�'�!�#���5�>��� M���& #�!�$������� �:R� � Z �������=D5����� �.-/�2��651=*� G�!�T1&35�'�!�G� �5�T��� ����& #�!�$������+0.� -���1&3;�$��*"�*$D � ��������D �� �6! 7��5D5�������^Z � � #���+6�-6�>s�:.0�($&+ �@�0�+(n�� � .*G =���(+<$I.0"@GH��������$:9 6���<n.*692$�+ 9�9;$&G 6��&$I),$&+ �3��Q\"@+<n�$I9295�*),+($&�-" � � �v6s�<�-6�39;�Z.��>��(+<n���� 95$&GH6���$�% )F.0+<$��-"@+<�@+(n��E�(�,S�*)T+ .0"/),�hGH��������6��(�*9;��"�+<�x� $�" +<n��#6��<�Fb�$��->9o95�*),+($&�-" �oQ\" ��� ���F�+<�M��=�+ .*$&"i+<ns$:9!95$&GH6���$�% )F.0+<$��-"��95�-GH� ����4��<��� �*�h.�)�),>��a.-)��uG >/9;+#�0� ),�->s� 9;� =� 9<.�),�<$ % ),�*���@L����+<ns�q��>/.0�&$�+ .*+<$&b��Z.0"/.0���s9;$I9r�0� 9;n.���$&"s4 $�"H$&GM.*4-�*9o���h+<n��@�<�F"�����($&"�4A�0� $&GM.*4-�*92���-�h4�� .*6�n�$:)F9h.0"�.0"s$&GM.*+<$&��"���.��<�*.�9;��".0=���� .�)�),>��a.0+(�HGH������� � �->��I� 9;> �U),��� �rns� ���-���&� � $&"�4 9;$�GH6��&$ %�*�MGH�������� .�9 .0�(�<$&b��x� .*+ =��[95+<>����$&"s4��o+<ns�<�->s4-nN"�>sGH���<��>9895$&G]>��:.*+<$��-"9 � +(n��H�(���:.*+<$&b��]95$&4�"�$�% )F.0"),� �0�b�.0�($&�->/98+<���(GM9!$&"[+<n�� ��>s"),+<$��-".*�h.*6�6��<�� �$&GM.*+<$��-"[4-$&b��F" =��m!'X-Xg" � �rn��M95$&G]>��:.*+<$&��"9@9;n�� � �*�+<n/.0+h)T��� �M)T$&��"�+�� � GM.� ��*9o.8�<�F�:.0+($&b������A9;GM.*�&� ),�-"�+<�($&=�>s+<$&��" +(�8+(n��!+<��+ .*��� .���$:.*"),���cJ 9;$�GH6������GH�����F��$:9r+(n�>/9r�-=�+a.0$&"s�*� =��M��$I9<)�.*� ��$�"�4�� � .*"� $�4-"����<$�"�4 $&"�+<���(�<�,S/�*),+<$��-"9T}

R !"Y R "$Y�Z "�$ R)( $/ZF� �d" S -W � � ),��9NY�Z0!�� V � � ! #�C " ),�392! $ R)( $ Z6" & 9;$&" �8+a.0" ��" !\X�Y#"

� S �-?PC ( C�?�� � ,� , V C�?PX-X

S C�?_ �� �2,� , V C�?{C�l

�rn��]+ � �M),��� � )T$&��"�+ 9�� .*"� .*�<�]�-=�+a.0$�"��*�[��$&�(�*),+<���H���<�-G�� � .0"��� , � �<�*956V�x),+<$�b�������� �E�-+(�+<n/.0+h+<ns�u��>.*�&$&+a.0+($&b��#GH������� .0�I9;� �(�*��>),�x9r+<� +<ns� � .0G]=���<+($:.0" GH������� � n���"�� S C��cQ\"ML2$�4->��(��, �� � � n.�b�� ),�-GH6/.0�<�x� +(n��&��>.*�&$&+a.0+($&b��oGH������� � $&+(n8+<ns�r"�>�GH���($:)�.*�0�Fb-.*�&>.*+<$��-"8�*� +<n��cGH�����F���C� ��rn�$I9 G �������c)�.*" =�]�0�Z95$&4-"s$�% )�.*"�+@6��a.-),+($:)�.*�ob�.0��>�� $�" .*6�6���$:)�.*+<$&��"9 � n����(� n�$&4�nN.-)�)T>�� .�)���$I9"���+!),�($&+($:)�.*�\�

.0.��dPH4_70>63C5(< B�70PH3C4a7C<R9�4F38TuYEoqD61�3&;=<�7���? I2DF1�3rPHBEDF3C>6>F30O(3\70DFPH?�Bs70?�@A5(?�B�3CBEDkPHBqD61�3 6�9(< ;HPHD_<RDFPH��3J@N?�TE3C;�7C< BuY(35(<R>FDFP=<R;Q;Ho&70?�@A5(3GB�4_<RDF38TAYEoN>63C5�;=<�70PHB�V&D61�3W70?�BM4FD_<RBED �"$�$�PHB�7:?U3 1 70PH3CBED�� Z2PQD61 �� �Mc

O-O

Page 26: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

� ��� #���� � � ������+

�[�8n.�b�� )T�-"��>/),+<�*�u9;��b��F� .0� �� �6���($&GH��"�+ 9c+<�Hb��F�<$ � �]+<ns�].-)�),>s� .-) � �*�c+<ns�]��$�� >95�8�<�TS�*),+a.0"),�GH�����F�\�uQR" +<n��M)F.-9;� �0�#�->s+ �������H9(),��"��*9 �o�*.-) n 9;��"95�-� ������GH��"�+ ! 6�$� ����F"#+!��6�$I)�.0������$�"),��>���*9A.�:.*�<4��@9;>��5�'.-),�Z.0�(�*.v!'9;��b��F� .0�s$&") n��*9o$&" ��$�GH��"95$&�-"/9o.0"�]�0��+<�F"HGH�-�(��" ��$c��GHGH���a),$:.*�&� �A.xb�.*$&�:.*=��&��<�TS�*),+a.0"),�ZGH�*.-95>��<�FGH��"�+c���Fb�$I),�*9r.*�<�@.*6�6���$:)�.*=��&�!��"���� +<�]9;GU.0�&� 9(.0GH6����*9,�W$c�-"95����>���"�+<��� � � �����b��F�&�-6�*�]�->��h� � "MGH�*.�9;>��(��GH��"�+c����b�$:)T�u!'9;���AL2$�4->��(� ���g" � tv.�) nu9(.0GH6����E$I9h.06�6s�<�� �$�GM.0+(�*�����O�� O�$&") n��*9T�iQ\+ $:9@$&GM.*4-�*�i>9;$�"�4[. ���FO�� �j-C[6�$� ����&$&$ 7 )�.0GH�F� . +(n.0+ $I9BGH��>�"�+<�*�[.0+ +(n����"� �*�@.iY������-+]�&��"�4i=�*.0Gi� �rn��M�-+(n���� ��"� �*�!+(n��M=V�x.0G $I98.0+(+ .�) n��x� +(� .��(�-+a.0��� 9;+ .*4-�+<�M�'.-),$��&$�+ .0+(� 6��<�x),$:95� b-.*�<$I.0+<$��-" �*�h+(n�� b�$&� � $&"�4u.0"s4-�&�BY R � �rn�� 9<.*GH6���� $:9!$&���&>�GH$�".0+(�*� >/9;$&"s4.[X-C-C � .*+<+]$&")�.*"���*9(),��"�+ �&$�4-n�+]9;�->s� ),��� �rn�� 9;�-��$:� .0"�4��&�*9]9;>�=s+<��"���*� =��N+<ns��95��"95�-� .0"�9;��>�� )T� ���<��G +(n��i9(.0GH6����u.0�<� .06�6s�<�� �$�GM.0+(����� �*)2Z S C�?{C-C�X 9;+(��� .���$:.*"9H.*"���*) RaS C�?PC-C�C-l9;+(��� .���$:.*"9����(�*9;6�*)T+<$&b��F����� �rn��@$&���&>�G $ "/.0+<$��-" ��$&�(�*),+($&�-" !"Y�Z�"�$/ZF"c$:9h.-���5>9;+(�*�HGM.0"�>.0��������Q\GM.*4-�*9�0� +(n��]9<.*GH6��&�A.*�<�]��$�4-$&+($cb��x��.0"/��� .-��$:.0"/),� $:9!)T�-GH6�>s+<�*�M.-9!+(n�� .�b����a.04-� =s�<$&4�n�+("��*9(9E�*b����!.*�&�6�$� ����I9 � $&+<ns$&"M.*" $�GM.04�� � $�"��� � +<n.*+h�&$&�x9 ��"M+<n��@9(.0GH6s�&��� �rn��@$&GU.04-� � $&"/��� � 95$cb��#$:9cb-.*�<$��*�.-9A. ��>�"),+($&�-"[�0�K9;��"/9;�-� ��$&�(�*),+($&�-"i+(����"/9;>��(� +<n.*+8+<ns�H9(.0GH�].*�<�*.H�-" +<n�� 9<.*GH6��&�A$:[email protected]� � .�s9>95�*���

camera

light source

sample

θr θi

!\.g" ! ='"L2$&4�>��<�]����}T�"�!� � ���$1=�&3B����� �.-/� �535��14���� ����53�� � 1435�>*C�$1 �I6��;6�*"�� 14�������*"65 &�T 4��<����1=��������+

L2$&4�>��<�[��Yi95n�� � 98�<�*95>��&+a98�-=�+a.0$�"��*� ���-�].i9(.0GH6���� �*� � .0���r6��I.-9;+(����� �rn��u9(.0GH6���� n/.-9GM.*+<+<�#�&��)F.0���(�,S�*)T+ .0"/),�E6s�<�-6���(+<$��*9v=�>s+r$:9cb������ �(�->�4�n2��$&+c$I9v� s.-),+(��� +(n��!+ ��6�#�0� 9;>��5�'.-),�Z+<n.*+�->s�#��$�� >95�!�<�,S/�*),+ .*"),�#GH������� ) n.0�a.-),+(���<$#b��*9T�2gh�,S�x),+ .*"),�#$:9v�(��6��(�*9;��"�+<�x� =�� +(n��!"����<GM.*�&$#b��*�� .���$:.*"),� R !"Y R " � R !'C#" � ns���<� R !'C#"h$I9K+(n��@� .-��$:.0"/),�8GH�x.-9;>s�<�*� � n���"u+<n�� 9<.*GH6��&�@$I9rb�$�� � �*����<��G +(n���"����<GM.*�!��$&�<�x),+<$��-" � �rn��i"��-�(GM.0��$cb��x� � .���$:.*"),�i$:9 .0�:95� ����>.0�#+<� +<n��i"����<GM.*�&$#b��*���� �� QAR !"Y R " � Q�R !\Cg" � �rn��u� .���$:.*"),�i�0�A�*.�) n 9<.*GH6��&�M$I9 6����-+(+<�*�W.�9H. ��>�")T+<$&��" �*� 95��"95�-���$��<�*),+($&��" Y R ���-�]��$�� ���<�F"�+ .0"�4��&�*98�*�!$�"),$:����"),�BY�Z\� �rns�*9;�MGH�*.�9;>��(��GH��"�+a9!.0�(�MGM.-��� $&" +(n��6��I.0"��@�0� $&"),$I����")T�u! $ RTS $ Z S C#"a� �rn��A����+ 9h�<��6s�<�*95��"�+ GH�*.�9;>��(�*� � .���$:.*"),�@b�.0��>��*9 � n�$��&�

O-X

Page 27: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

� .0��� mo�:.�9;+<�F�Lr

iθ = 30

iθ = 45

iθ = 60

-90 -75 -60 -45 -30 -15 15 30 45 60 75 90

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2

0.25

L2$�4->��(� ��Y�} �H��<����1=�������>�?���*"65 4�$���$�!1 �����? 4��<����1=�������T���5�!���@�.6�*8 ��5� � � �*� � D � � �"! 7���� �!����1=* �I�� K ����� �!�#��*"14�$ ,��*4� � �!�����,�=+�� ���A #�������, #* �!�M�A1414��;�A*%�,�I65����1" ����7���2*"�$��*"�� �A M &���1" ���� ��� R �2�I�� %�A ��N�$ 4�$�!1���5�����* ���N ����& #�!�$�����(���^Z ����� � � �)# � ��� � � �=+

1�.0"�Mmo.*6V�F�Lr

iθ = 45

iθ = 60

iθ = 75

-90 -75 -60 -45 -30 -15 15 30 45 60 75 90

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2

0.25

L2$�4->��(� �0^3} �H��<����1=�������>�?���*"65 4�$���$�!1 �����? 4��<����1=�������T���5�!���@�.6�*8 ��5� � ����� � D � � �"!������ �!����1=* �I�� ���� ��!14��;*4� ����� �������$ ,��*4��� �!�M��� �=+

1�.0"�Lr

iθ = 45

iθ = 60

iθ = 75

-90 -75 -60 -45 -30 -15 15 30 45 60 75 90

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2

0.25

L2$�4->��(� ��j�} �H��<����1=�������>�?���*"65 4�$���$�!1 �����? 4��<����1=�������T���5�!���@�.6�*8 ��5� � � � # � D � � �"!������ �!����1=* �I�� K 3! �14��*4����� ��*4� � �!��� � �=+

O0

Page 28: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

Lr

iθ 60=

rφ 45=

-90 -75 -60 -45 -30 -15 15 30 45 60 75 90

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2

Lr

rθ-90 -75 -60 -45 -30 -15 15 30 45 60 75 90

0.02

0.04

0.06

0.08

0.1

0.12

0.14

iθ 75=

rφ 60=

!\.g" ! ='"L2$�4->��(�i��l�}MgK�,S/�*),+ .*"),�HG �*.-95>��<��G ��"�+Z.0"/� �<�TS�*),+a.0"),� GH�������c6����-+ 9B�����]9<.*GH6��&�*$#�"�rn��*95�GH�*.�9;>��(��GH��"�+ 9 � ���<�u�-=�+a.0$&"s�*� �����M9;��"/9;�-� ��$��<�*),+($&��"9 ��>�+ 95$:���u+<n��u6��:.*"����*�@$&"/),$:���F"),��} !\.g"Y Z S Y�C � .*"�'$ R S �� � �.0"/��! =["%Y Z S ^ � � .0"��$ R S Y�C � �

+<ns�895�-��$:� ��$&"��x9h.0�<�@6��(�*��$I),+<$��-"9r��=�+ .*$&"��*�M>9;$�"�4]+<n��@�<�TS�*),+a.0"),�@GH�������V�����BDZ.0>/9<9;$I.0"[95>��;�'.�),��<��>�4-ns"��*9<9T� Q\"N+<n��x9;�H$�"�$&+($:.0�c� �6���<$�GH��"�+ 9 � � � .-9 95���&�*)T+<�*�i��GH6�$��<$I)�.0�����M+<�i��=�+ .*$&"N+<n��M=�*95+GM.*+ ) n�=��+ � ���F" GH�x.-9;>s�<�*�u.0"� 6s�<�*��$I),+<�x���<�,S�x),+ .*"),�����E���(�#� � � n.�b�� >95�*�i+<n��]"�>sGH���<$I)�.0���b�.0��>.0+($&��" �*��+<n��#GH�������S!\X���" � �rn�$I9 � .-9 ���-"s�E+(� ����G �-"95+<� .*+<�h"���+r��"���� +(n��!.�)�),>��a.-)�� �*� +(n��GH�����F��=�>�+#.*�:95� +(n��@b-.*�&$I��$&+ �]�0� .*�&��+(n��A.-9(9;>�GH6s+<$&��"9rGM.���� � n�$&���@����b������-6�$�"�48+(n��@GH�������'�

1�$&GH$��:.*�o�<�*95>��&+a9h.0�(�!6��<�x9;��"�+<�*� $&"UL2$&4�>��<�*9!�*^A.0"�i�FjB���-�h9(.0GH6s�&�Zqt! 6.*$&"�+<�*�H9(.0"�H6.*%6����" .0"� 9<.0G 6��&��$L! � n�$&+(�!9(.0"��"a�cL��-�h.*�&�+<ns�<���Z9<.*GH6��&�x9���� .���$:.*"),�#$&"),�(�*.-95�*9c.-9c+<n��!b�$&� � $&"�4��$��<�*),+($&��" Y R .06�6��(��.�) n��x9r+<n��A9;��>�� )T�8��$&�<�x),+<$��-" Y�ZW! =/.-) � .0� �H�(�,S�*),+($&��"'" � �rn�$:9r$I9r$&"u),�-"�+<�a.-95++<�]+<ns�8=��n.�b�$&�-�#�0� �<�->s4-n[9;6�*)T>��:.*�!95>��;�'.�),�*9h+<n.*+!�<�,S/�*),+hGH���<�!$�"�+<ns� ����� � .0� �i��$&�<�x),+<$��-"������� .0G]=���<+($:.*"�95>��;�'.�),�*9 � ns���<�A� .-��$:.0"/),� �����x9K"���+!b�.0� � � $�+<nub�$�� � $&"�4 ��$��<�*),+($&��" �hL��-�Z.0���2+(n��<���9<.*GH6����*9���+<n��@GH�����F��6��(�*��$:)T+<$&��"9r.*"� �� �6���($&GH��"�+ .*��GH�*.�9;>��(��GH��"�+ 9�GM.0+a) nH�(��GM.*�� �.0=���� � ���&�'�Q\"N.0���h)�.�9;�*9 �c.i9;GM.*�&�c6�*. $:9B"s�-+<$I),�*� "s�*.0� +(n��M9;��>�� )T�M��$&�(�*),+($&�-" � �rn�$:986sn���"���GH��"���" � .�9��$I9<),>9(9;�*�i�*.*�<�&$����@$&"[+<n��]6.*6V�F� .0"/� $:9@��$ ���F�<��"�+!���<�-G +(n��H��"��H���*9<),�($&=�*�i=��i��>��8G �������0� $�+$:9 +<ns� =/.-) �9()�.0+(+<��� 6�*.� 95+<>��$&�*�N=��N95��b����a.0�h�<�x9;�*.*� ) n���� 9 � � ��+ �$�"�4-%(��l�Y-YM� � �Z.06� ��u.0"/� b�.0"�E���<"�%(��l�Y-XM�%�i�!.*6� �� � ����� %(��l-l�XM�%� �!>�43. .*"� Q595n�$&GM.*�<>�%(��l�j0 (�s� �h9<.*"�4W.*"� Q595n�$&GM.*�<>�%(��l�j0 (�.0"/�i��$:9(),>9<95�*��$&"u+<n�� ),�-"�+<�� �+#�0� GM.�) n�$�"��!b�$:95$&�-"i$�"m� ��.04�.*�<� .0"�i���*L2$&4�>���$��<�*����%<�Fl-l����\�@7#$:9;%),�(��6.0"/),$&�*9c=��+ � ����"M+(n��@GH������� .0"�MGH�*.-95>��<�x�H��.0+a. ���->s"� $�" +(n��!���-� � .0�a����$��<�*)T+<$&��"M)�.*"�=�.0+(+<�($&=�>�+(�*�86.*�<+<���8+(�!+<n��h���-"�4 �!%')�.�b�$&+ �@.-9(9;>�G 6�+<$��-" � QR" +(n��#)�.�9;�h�0� 9(.0GH6����A$ !\9<.*"��" � � �h95���.895GM.0��� 9;6�*),>��I.0� ),�-GH6��"���"�+v$�"H+<ns�K����� � .*� �M��$��<�*),+($&��" �"�rn�$I9v$I9r��>��Z+<�8+(n��@956V�x),>��:.*�h) n.0�a.-),%+<�F�<$:95+<$I)�9o�0��$&"/��$&b�$:��>/.0� 9<.*"�H6.0�(+<$:)T�&�*9T�oL��-�#9(.0GH6�����$ � � �!n.�b��!.*�:95� $&"),��>���*� GH�*.�9;>��(��GH��"�+ 9�-=s+ .0$�"��*����>�+ 95$:��� +(n�� 6��:.*"�� �0� $�"),$:����"),��!\L�$&4->s�<�H�Fl#"a� �rn��*95�8GH�*.�9;>��(��GH��"�+ 9 .0�(�]. )T�<$&+($:)�.*�GH�*.�9;>��(� �*�!+(n��u.-)�)T>�� .�)�� �*�@.*"�� �<�,S�x),+ .*"),�]GH������� =�>�+ .*�<�u9;�F�:����G ����>�"� $�" �<�TS�*),+a.0"),��&$�+<���a.0+(>��<��� � "),�A.043.0$&" ��+<n��@GH�����F� .0"/� GH�*.�9;>��(�*�H��.*+ .].0�(�8$&"U9;+<�(�-"�4U.04-�(����GH�F"�+F�

L2$&4�>��<�*9hO�C +(n��<��>�4-n[O�O 95n�� � �<�x9;>���+ 9v���-�#9(.0GH6s�&�*9c+<n.*+En.�b��!"s�-+#�-"����M. ��$�� >9;�A),��GH%6�-"��F"�+#=�>�+@.*�:95�M. 95$&4�"�$�% )F.0"�+!956V�x),>��:.*�!)T�-GH6�-"s��"�+F�hQ\"�+(n��*9;�A� �6V�F�<$&G ��"�+a9���+<ns�8�<�TS�*),+a.0"),�

O��

Page 29: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

L��3.0GLr

iθ = 45

iθ = 60

iθ = 75

-90 -75 -60 -45 -30 -15 15 30 45 60 75 90

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2

L2$�4->��(�8O�C�}>���<����1=� ����� �?���*"65 4�$���$�!1%����� 4��<����1=�����������5�!���2�#� � �*� � D � � �6!��5D�� ������� � �"! � � 7���!����1=* �I�� �I�X��� ��*&��� �!�����,�=+

$c���-+(n

-90 -75 -60 -45 -30 -15 15 30 45 60 75 90

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2

Lr

iθ = 45

iθ = 60

iθ = 75

L2$�4->��(�!O��-}%�H��<����1=�������T�����*C65 4�$���$�!1H� ���� 4��<����1��������%�?���!���@�#� ����� � D � � �"! � # D�� ������� ���"! � ��#���!����1=* �I�� %�?����1414����14��K���@��*4��� �!��� �H�=+

� ����� 13n.�b�$�"�4

-90 -75 -60 -45 -30 -15 15 30 45 60 75 90

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2

Lr

iθ = 45

iθ = 60

iθ = 75

L2$�4->��(� O-O�}����<����1=�������?�����*"65 4�$�?�$�X1T����� 4��<����1=�����������5�!��� �.6�*8 ��5� � � � � � D��(���"! �XD�� ������� ��"! � �)�!� �!����1�*�I�� ���5�>K�!���(*"3���'A ��5�X* ��*4� � �!���� �=+

O-Y

Page 30: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

GH�����F�V>/9;�*�H$:9 .8�&$�"��*.0� ),�-G]=�$�".0+($&�-"]�0� "�� � GH�����F��.*"�H+<n�� � ���<� .*"),��%51�6.*�<�(� � GH��������� � �-�(%� .*"),� .0"� 1�6.*�<�(� � %(��l�Y�^U�h+<n.*+8���*9<),�($&=�*9@9;6�*)T>��:.*�� �-�A9;>s�;�'.-)T�#� �<�,S�x),+<$��-"����<��G �<��>�4-n 9;>��(%�'.-)T�*9,� �[� 95���&�*)T+<�*�N+<n�$I9UG �������@.�9U$�+M$:9H=.-95�*�W�-"k� s.-)T+<���N+(n�� 9(.0GH�[95>��;�'.�),�[�<�->s4-n�"��x9<9.-9(9;>�G 6�+<$��-"9q!\9 ��GHG ��+<�($&) �-�&��"�4 �Z%\)�.�b�$&+($&�*9 "c.-9#+<n��@6��(�*9;��"�+hGH�����F�\� �rn��8�a.-��$I.0"),�@6��(�*��$I),+<�*�=��H+<n��@GH��������$I9,}

�R S ��! � " �����),�39/Y R ),�39/Y�� �W ] � ����� � !\X�^�"

� n����(�#� � $:9r+(n�� L��(�*9;"��F� �<�,S�x),+<$��-"M),��� �M),$���"�+��.*"� � $:9h+<ns�B�(�,��� .�),+<$�b��!$&"/��� H�*�c+<n��A95>��;�'.�),�GH�*��$&>�Gi� �rn��U),��9NY�� $�" +(n��M���F"��-GH$�".0+(�-�@�<�x9;>���+ 9 ���(�-G|>9;$�"�4i+<ns�H95�&�-6��%'.0�(�*.i��$I9;+<�($&=�>s+<$&��"$&"/9;+<�x.-���0� +(n��B�'.�),��+<%�"�>�G =���#��$:9;+(�<$�=�>�+<$��-" !\9;�F� 1��*)T+<$&��"iXg" ���rn�$I9KGH�������26s�<�*��$I),+ 9h.]6V�x. �$�"+<ns�v���-� � .*� �]��$&�(�*),+<$��-"�!\)T�&��95�r+(�!+<n��#956�*),>��I.0� ��$&�(�*),+<$��-"'" .0"/�8+<n��#��$I9;+(�<$&=s>�+<$��-"8�*� +<n�� �<�,S�x),+<�*�� .���$:.*"),�#4-��+a9 � $I����� � $&+(n $�"),�<�x.-9;�h$�"H95>��;�'.�),�!�(�->�4�n�"��*9(9 �o�"�rns�!+<��+ .0��a.-��$I.0"),�#$:9c� �6��<�*9(9;�*�.-9#. �&$&"s�*.0� ),�-G]=�$&"/.0+<$��-"H�*�o+(n��A��$�� >95� .*"��956V�x),>��:.*�#),�-G 6V��"���"�+ 9T}

RJS U � �R V U � �R !\X�j#"

� n����(�H+<ns�H��$ � >9;�M)T�-GH6�-"s��"�+ �R $:9@6��<�x��$:),+(�*�i=��i+(n��HGH�����F�o6��<��6��9;�x� $�" +<ns$:9B6/.06�����uQ\"+<ns�*9;� � �6���<$�GH��"�+ 9 � � � >95�*� +(n��8��>�")T+<$&��".0� .06�6��(�� �$�GM.0+($&�-" !\X�X#"#$&"95+<�*.�� �*�h+(n�� "�>sGH���<$I)�.0���b�.0��>.0+($&��" �*�h$&"�+<�F4-� .*�&!\X��M"a� �����<���*b�������+<ns� �(�,S�*),+a.0")T�86.*� .0G ��+<���a9 �"� -�� U ���2.*"� U � � ���<��*95+<$&GU.0+<�x�U=�� %+<+($&"�4���>95$&"�4H"s�-"�%��&$�"��*.0�Z�-6�+($&GH$#b*.0+($&�-" ��+<n�� .0=�*b�� GH������� +(�HGH�*.�9;>��(�*����.*+ .��1�$�"),�]$&+8$I98��$ �M)T>��&+@+<�i��=�+ .*$&" G �*.0"�$�"�40��>s�v�x9;+<$�GM.0+(�*9!�0� � ���-� +<ns�M9<.*GH6��&�x9 � �Hn.�b��]>9;�*� �+<ns�H��� �*),+@�0�#+(n�� L/�(�*9;"s��� ),��� �U),$&��"�+ � .-98$&4�"��-�(�*� =��[.-9(9;>�GH$�"�4 � S �-�*�E��+<�]+<n.*+B���-�].*�&�+<ns�<���u9<.*GH6����*9���+<n��u��$ ��>/9;�MGH������� �����*9 b������ � �F�&�r$�" ���*9<)T�<$&=s$&"�4u+<n��M$&"/),�<�*.�9;�H$�"N� .-��$:.0"/),�.-9]+<n��ib�$&� � ���].06s6��<�3.-) n��*9 +(n��i95�->��a),�#�#.-9 � ���&�Z.-9]+<n�� ),>�+<%�� � $&" �a.-��$I.0")T�[.0+H+(n��i95�->��a),���$��<�*),+($&��" � �rn�$:9 ���x9;6�$�+<�H+(n�� �'.-)T+ +<n.*+ +<n��M+<ns�<���M9(.0GH6s�&�*9!n.�b��H�(�->�4�n�"��*9(9 ) n.0�a.-),+(���<$I9;+($:)�9+<n/.0+u��$�� ���H���(�-G +(n�� �!%\)F.xb�$&+ �NGH�����F�\� L/���M+<n��i����.*G 9<.0G 6��&�#�h+(n��[9;6�*),>s�:.0�u),��GH6�-"��F"�+! �a.-��$I.0")T�H$&")T�<�*.�9;�]$&"[+<n�� ����� � .0� � ��$&�(�*),+<$��-"'"#$I98���*9(),�<$�=�*� � ���&�c=��i+<n�� � ���<� .*"),��%51�6.*�<�(� �GH�����F�\� �rns� � ���<� .*"),��%51�6.*�<�(� � G ������� �����*9E��"����u�<�*.�9;�-"/.0=���� � ���������-�@+<n��])T�&�-+(n�+(� � ��� .0"�"���+8b���� � � �����2���-�A+<n�� � ������%'9;n.�b�$&"�4 9<.*GH6��&�3� �rn��HGU.0$&"i�(�*.-95�-" ���-�A+<n�$I9B$I9 +(n�� �����&�&� � $�"�4�}�Wn�$��&�!+(n�� D!.*>9<95$:.*"��<��>�4-ns"��*9<9#GH������� .06s6V�x.0� 9#� �6s�&$:)T$&+<���8$�"H+<n�� � �-�(� .0"/),��%51�6.0�(�<� � GH������� �$&+ $:92$�"�+(��4-�a.0+<�x�8�0b��F�c.0�����'.-),�F+o�-�($&��"�+ .*+<$&��"92$�" �->�� )�.�9;���cJ!9 . �(�*9;>s�&+��+<n��#��$ � >9;�#GH��������$:9��&�*9(99;�F"9;$�+<$&b��#+<�]+<ns�8.�),+<>/.0��9;>s�;�'.-)T�B�(�->�4�n�"��*9(9E��$:9;+(�<$�=�>�+<$��-"M+<n/.0"M+<n�� � �-�(� .0"/),��%51�6.0�(�<� � GH�������'��E� � �Fb�����o$�+ $:9 $&GH6�-�(+ .*"�+ +(� "���+<�u+<n.*+H+<n��u),��G =s$&"��*�[GH�������q!'X-j#" .0+<+(��GH6�+a9B+(�N���*9(),�<$�=V�b���� ��)T�-GH6���� ]�<�,S�x),+ .*"),�86s�<�-6���(+<$��*9�� ��$�� >9;�].*"�[9;6�*),>��I.0�!�(�,S�*)T+ .0"/),�8GH�x) n.*"�$:95GH9r$�"�+(n��6��(�*9;��"/),�M�0�A95>�=9;+a.0"�+<$I.0�Z9;>��5�'.-),�u�<�->s4-n�"��x9<9,� D#$&b���" +(n�$:9 �r+<ns���*b���� .*�&� 6V�F�;���-�(GM.0"/),�M�0�@+(n��),��G =�$�"��*� GH������� $:9r��"/),�->��a.04�$&"�4s�

� !"� #$ � &'���������,+��.����� ��&/�,�%��� 1 � +(�����

1���b��F� .0�s.0��4-���<$&+(n�GM92$�"H)T�-GH6�>s+<����b�$I9;$��-" GM.� ��h.-9(9;>�G 6�+<$��-"92�(��4�.*� ��$�"�4@�<�,S/�*),+ .*"),�h6��(�-6���(+<$&�x9�0� �-=��5�*)T+ 9!$&"[+<n�� 9<)T��"����]Q\"),���<�<�x),+!GH�����F�&$&"s4H�0� �<�,S�x),+ .*"),� ".*+<>��a.0�&���i�&�*.���9!+<�u$&".�)�),>��a.0+<�

O�^

Page 31: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

�<�x9;>���+ 9,� �rn��M�<�,S/�*),+ .*"),�]GH������� 6��<�x9;��"�+<�*�[n����<�U),�&�*.*�<��� ���FGH�-"95+<�a.0+<�x9B+<n/.0+ �<��>�4-n ��$�� >95�9;>s�;�'.-)T�*9H)�.*"�"��-+ =V� .-9(9;>�GH�x� +<� =V� � .0G]=���<+($:.0" $&" �<�,S�x),+ .*"),���WL�>��(+<n��F��r+(n�$:9H����b�$I.0+($&�-"���<��G � .*G =���(+<$:.*"�=��n.�b�$&���!$&")T�<�*.�9;�*9 � $�+<ni+(n�� �<��>�4-n�"s�*9<9!�0� +(n��]9;>��5�'.-),�].*"�i+<n��].*"�4-��� �0�$&"/),$:���F"�+!��$&4�n�+F� �rn��HGH�����F�r)F.0" +(n����<�T���-�<�]=�H>95�*� +<�u$&GH6s�<�*b��8+(n��H6���;�����<GM.*"),� �*�#b�$I9;$&��".0��4-���<$&+(n�GM9c� .0"s4-$&"s4 ���(�-Gp9;n.*6V�A�<�*)T�0b��F��� +<� �x9;+<$�GM.0+($&��" �*�c95>��;�'.�),�@6��<��6V�F�<+<$��*9,�"�[�@95+ .0�(+E=��9;+(>����$&"�4i�(�*.0� .0"� �(��"�����(�*� $�GM.04��*9B�*�@.i��$ � >9;�M�-=��5�x),+�� �E� �+� � �H>/9;�M�<�,S/�*),+ .*"),�HGU.069+<�N$��&�&>/9;+<�a.0+(�i+<n.*+�+<ns� 6��(�-6��95�*� GH�������!$:9 �E$�" �'.�),+�Z.0" $&GH6�-�(+ .*"�+M4-�F"���� .*�&$#b*.0+($&�-"W�*� +(n��� .0G]=���<+($:.*" GH�������'� �rns�HGH�������c$I9B+<ns��" >95�*� +<���(�*),�*b����A.-)F),>�� .*+<�M95n.06�M$&"����-�<GU.0+<$��-" =��6�n���+<��GH��+<�($:)H95+<���(����� gK�*)T�0b��F�<�*� 95n.06�i$I9 ),�-GH6/.0�<�x� � $�+<n +<n��u9;n/.06�i�-=�+a.0$�"��*� >/9;$&"s4 +(n��� .0G]=���<+($:.*"HGH�������'�'�[�@.0�I9;� ��$:9(),>9(9vn�� � ��$ � >9;�!�(�,S�*)T+<$&��" ���<��G "���"�% � .*G =���(+<$I.0"u9;>��5�'.-),�x9)�.*"�.� �*),+#b�$I9;$&��"u.0�&4��-�($&+<nsGM9 �����E=�$�"���),>��I.0�#95+<���(���].0"�MGH�-+($&��"H�*9;+($&GM.*+<$��-" �

� E�� �£:�8L; 8?9A �£:�?9A�:"=>:"A ��� 8"��:"�L2$�4->��(�MO-X^!\.#"A95n�� � 9 .0"N$&GU.04-� �*�!+(n��H�(�->�4�n ) ����$&"���($:)�.*�c),�I. �ib�.�9;�M��$I9<),>/9<9;�x� $&" +(n��H$�"�+(�<�-%��>)T+<$&��" � �rn��H$�GM.04�� � .�98�-=�+a.0$&"s�*� >95$&"�4 . $&$ 7 )�.*GH���a.�� �rns�Hb�.-9;� $:9B$��&��>�GH$&"/.0+<�x�U=�� .9;$�"�4-���M�&$&4�n�+ 9;��>�� ),�M���<��G +<n��u95��"9;���H��$&�<�x),+<$��-" �NL��-�])T�:.0�($&+ �[�0�A��$I9;6��I.�#� � �Mn.�b��M�<��G �0b��x�+<ns� =/.-) �4��<�->s"� �(��4-$��-" ���(�-G +(n��M$&GM.*4-���NL�$&4->s�<�uO-X^! ='" 9;n�� � 9H.��(��"���F�<�*� $&GU.04-� +<n.*+ $I94-�F"���� .*+<�*� >95$&"�4A+<n�� �"s� � " 4-����GH��+<� �8�*� +<ns�Eb�.-95�@.0"/� +<n�� � .0G]=���<+($:.*" GH�������\��$c�&�x.0�<���#�-+(n���<�x.0�b�.-9;�Z.06s6V�x.0� 9rG]>) nBS .*+<+(���� � $&+(n ���*9<9o=��($&4�n�+("��*9<9ob�.0�($:.*+<$&��"H.*�&��"�48$�+ 9c),�<�39<95%\95�*),+<$��-"���+(n.0"+<ns� � .0G]=���<+($:.*"�b�.-95���!L2$�4->��(� O�Xf!\)�"#9;n�� � 9!.*"i$&GM.*4-�A+<n.*+!$:9h�<��"/�����<�x� >95$&"�4]+<n�� 6s�<�-6�39;�*��<�TS�*),+a.0"),�AGH������� � $�+<n � S �C � .0"��- S C�? ^xC�� �E�-+(�8+<n/.0+!+(n��86��(�-6��95�*�iGH������� �����*9Eb��F���� �F�&� $&"i6s�<�*��$I),+<$�"�4 +<ns�].06�6�*.*� .0"/),� �0� +<ns�8b�.-95�����rn��8�(�->�4�n�"��*9(9!b-.*�&>�� � .-9!95���&�x),+<�*�H��G 6�$&�(%$:)F.0�&�����H1�$&"/),� �(�->�4�n�"��*9(98GH�������I9E�0�Z.�),+<>/.0�h95>��;�'.�),�*9@)�.*"N����b�$:.*+<� ���<�-G +(n�� �!%')�.�b�$&+ �MGH�������.-9(9;>�G �*� n����(�#� �"�s.0+h+($&GH�*9 �-�-"s���H6.*� .*GH��+<�($cb��x9v95>��;�'.�),�!�(�->�4�n�"��*9(9E.*"� GM.� "���+#),�-�(�<�*956�-"�+<�]+<ns�8.�),+<>/.0� �<��>�4-ns"��*9<9T�

!\.g" gK�x.0� $&GU.04-� !�='" � .0G]=���<+($:.*" G ������� !')M"cmo�<��6��9;�x��GH�������L2$�4->��(��O�X�} ���)� ��������(���T� ������ ����! " #�$���>�&�#�� ')�A*"�B����� ���� 4�� K �143 ������A�*> &�$���!�$ 4�� 6�*8 ��5� 1435�9 ����-:�$ 41" #���B� ��� �5 4�����!*"��(���5�!���#*$+@0 �E��65�� �����1C M�A�7 #*�I 4���J1435���A M &���1" ���� � Z ��� � +

L2$&4�>��<�uO0 `!\.g" ),��GH6.*�<�*9!=��($&4-n�+<"s�*9<98b�.0��>��*9 .*�&�-"s4 .i),�(��9(9;%'9;�*),+($&��" �*�!+(n��H+(n��<���Mb�.-95�$&GU.04-�x9h9;n�� � "i$&" L2$&4�>��<� O-X��!Q\+h$:9h$&"�+<���(�*9;+($&"�4]+<�]"���+<�8+(n.0+Z+<n��A=��<$�4-n�+<"��*9(9K�*� +<n��A�<�*.*�2b�.-95�

O-j

Page 32: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

Lambertian

ModelMeasurements

Brightness

X

Brightness

X

!'.#"%Y Z S C � ! =["%Y Z S O-C �

L2$�4->��(�@O0 s}��2��� ��� " #*"���(-��$1"K�$�$�� ��������T-5 C M�A3X14�5�*&* �������5��1435�>�� &�X*4* �.*"���1C M�A�(��� 1&35�T 4����N')��*C��D������')�A*"�* 4�$���!�$ 4�� 6�*8 ��5��1&35� 9 ����-:�$ 41" #���;����� �5 4�����!*"������5�!���G*^+

�<�FGM.0$�"9!"��*.0�(��� ),�-"/9;+ .*"�+ �*b����@GH�39;+A�0�#+<ns�M),�<�39<95%\95�*),+<$��-" .0"/� ���<�-6/9���>�$I) ����u+<� b��F�<��b��F���),����9;�Z+<� +<ns�B��$&G]=9,� �rn��@6��<��6V�39;�*�MGH������� �����x9Kb���� � � �����$&"M6��<�x��$:),+($&"�4@+(n�$:9r=��n.�b�$&���� � ns$&�&�+<ns� � .*G =���(+<$:.*" G ��������6��(����>),�x9v�:.*�<4��!=��<$�4-n�+<"��x9<9o���<�(�-�a9,�cL2$�4->��(�!O* �! =["c9;ns� � 9 9;$�GH$&�I.0�o6����-+a9���-�h$��&��>�GH$&"/.0+<$��-" ���<��G O-C � +<� +(n��@�<$&4�n�+h�*�c+<ns�@9;��"/9;�-�F�rQ\"M+<ns$:9h)�.�9;�#��=��($&4�n�+("��*9<9rb�.*�<$:.*+<$��-"���"+<ns� �(�*.0�cb�.-95�H$:9A.-9!��GHGH�F+<�<$�)-� � "/),�H.*4�.*$&"��o+(n�� 6s�<�-6�39;�*� GH�����F�c),�&�39;������GM.*+ ) n��*9E+(n��]�<�*.*�$&GU.04-�3�q�E� � ��b������V+(n�� � .0G]=���<+($:.*"�GH�����F�2���-�a),�*9E+(n�� =��<$�4-n�+<"��x9<9!),����95� +<�M+<n�� �($&4�n�+!��$&G]=M�0�+<ns� b�.-95�H+<� ���<��6 G]>) n��'.�9;+(���@+<n.*" $�" +(n��]�<�*.*�v$�GM.04����HJZ9B.M�<�*95>��&+��2+(n�� =s�<$&4�n�+("��*9(9B6�*. 6��(�*��$:)T+<�*� =��H+(n�� � .0G]=V�F�<+<$I.0"HG ��������$I9 � .�H���i���<�-G +(n��A.-),+(>.0� 6�*.� ��

� E W �£:���:�4��>8?94n: 2 8"� �gh�,S�*),+a.0")T�!GM.06/9r.0�(� � $:������� >9;�x�U$�"Hb�$:9;$��-"H���-�h��=�+ .*$&"�$�"�4]9;n/.06�8$�"����-�(GM.0+($&�-" ���<��G =��($&4-n�+<%"��*9(9v$�GM.04��*9 � �#�-�<"U.0"�Hqr�(��� s9;%(��l�j-l � �cL��-� .B4-$�b���" �<�TS�*),+a.0"),�#GH�����F�.0"�M95�->��a),�!��$&�<�x),+<$��-"��+<ns�h�<�,S�x),+ .*"),�hGM.*6 �*9;+a.0=���$:9;ns�*92+<ns�E�(���:.*+<$&��"9;ns$&6 =��+ � ���F"]9;>��5�'.-),�#�-�($&��"�+ .*+<$&��"��-4�$&b���" =��8+(n��4-�a.-��$���"�+�9;6.�),�c6.0�a.0GH��+(��� 9k!�� "��#" �*.0"�@$&GM.*4-��=��<$�4-n�+<"��*9(9,� L2$&4�>��<�cO��f!'.#"�95n�� � 9�+<n��c�<�TS�*),+a.0"),�GM.*6 �0�Z. � .*G =���(+<$:.*"N9;>s�;�'.-)T� ���-� $��&�&>sGH$&".*+<$��-"����<��G +(n��u��$&�(�*),+($&�-" !"Y�Z S ��C � " $/Z S � � "a��rn��Z9<.*GH�hGM.06 $I9o�-=�+a.0$&"s�*� >/9;$&"s4B+(n��#6��<��6V�39;�*�]GH������� � $�+<n]�<��>�4-n�"s�*9<9 � S C��cL2$�4->��(�#O��f!�='"9;ns� � 9 +<ns�H�<�,S/�*),+ .*"),�HGU.06 �*�@.��(�->�4�n ��$�� >9;�u95>��;�'.�),� � $&+<n � S Y�C � � Q\"�+<���(�*9;+($&"�4����#� +(n���<��>�4-n 95>��;�'.�),�M6��<����>/),�*98.�GU.06 +(n.0+ .06�6�*.*� 9 b������[95$&GH$��:.0�Z+<�i+<ns�H�&$�"��*.0�A�<�,S/�*),+ .*"),�]GM.06�i�#�-�<" .*"�Nqr�<��� s9;%(��l�j-l��!n���6�-+(n��*9;$#b��*� ���-� +(n��M�&>�"/.0�]9;>s�;�'.-)T��� �rn��M6��<��6��9;�x� �<�TS�*),+a.0"),�GH�����F��+<ns���<�,�����<�!�x9;+ .*=��&$I9;n��x9h. ),�-"�+<$�"�>�>sG ���(�-G 6�>s�<� � .0G]=���<+($:.0" +<� �&>s".0�(% ��$� ��!�(�,S�*),+a.0")T���L�>��<+(n�������+<n�� G �������o6��(�*��$I),+ 9h+<n.*+@+<n��]�&$�"��*.0�($&+ �H$�"i+<n��]�<�,S/�*),+ .*"),�AGM.06i��)�)T>�� 9!�-"s��� � ns��"+<ns�Bb�$&� � ��� $:9h),����9;�@+(� +<n��A9;��>�� )T���

O-l

Page 33: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

0.0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5

p

q

0.0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6

p

q

!'.#" � .0G]=���<+($:.0" ! ='" gh�->s4-ni��$�� >9;�L2$�4->��(�hO���}���<����1=������� ������* �I�� 2�"�!� 9 ����-��$ 41" #����*"65 C� ����� ������"! 7!�=D������?�.-/�/ 4��65��3��A ��N6�*"� *"65 "�.������#�'� � � � D � � �"!$7!�=+ �5�� T-:��143 ��� ��* 1435�����5�����* ��� M���& #�!�$�����;�� &� �^Z � � � � ����� � Z ���)# � +�� ��14�1435��*� M� E�#�� C M1"� -��$1"K�$�$� 1435��*C�������� ����� �����71&35��K���E� � �!�5��K � �� ��5��� � &��<����1=������������� �5 4�$'A ���6�*8���*"65���A�*"14��?�I�� ��65���� 4��<����1���������+

� E�� �$6�� � � � :'�>=k354PB��>:�={: ��rn��]6��<��=��&�FG �0� �<�*)T�0b��F�<$&"s4H95n.06� ���<�-G =s�<$&4�n�+("��*9(9E$&GM.*4-�*9#n.-9!=����"[$&"�+<��"/9;����� �(�*9;�x.0� ) n��*�$&" +<n��i6/.-9;+ + � � ���*)�.-���*9,� 1��Fb���� .*�#.0�&4��-�($&+<nsGM9 n/.xb��u=����" 6s�<�-6�39;�*�$�#+<n��iG ��9;+ "s�-+<� � �-�(%+<n����*�h+(n��*9;� =��$�"�4u9;n.*6� ���(�-G|9;n/.-��$�"�4 �i�E���<"[.0"/� qr�(��� s9;%(��l-j�lM�#.*"� 6sn��-+(�-GH��+(�<$I)89;+(���<�F�� �[������n.*GH%(��l-j�CM�(� Q\"i�-�a�����!+(��)T�-"95+<� .*$&"[+<n�� �(�*),�*b���� � 6s�<�-=s�&��G �+<ns�*9;� +(�*) ns"�$���>��*9#.-9(9;>�GH�+<n/.0+@+<n��A�<�,S/�*),+ .*"),�A6��<��6V�F�<+<$��*9!�0� +<ns� �-=��5�*),+a9!.0�(� �"s� � "[.*% 6s�<$&���<$'�8L��-�Z+<n��*95� GH��+(n�����9E+(�6��(����>),�MGH�*.*"�$&"s40��>�� 9;n/.06�M�*9;+($&GM.*+<�*9 � $�+8$I98$&GH6���a.0+<$�b��8+(n.0+].�)�),>��a.0+<�M�(�,S�*),+a.0")T� GH�������:9=� >/9;�*��� �E���(�#� � �]6��(�*9;��"�+!�(�*9;>���+ 9!�-=s+ .0$�"��*� =��i.*6�6�����$�"�4M6�n��-+(�-GH�F+<�<$I) 9;+(���<���M+(� +(n�� ),�:.�b�.-95�]9;n�� � "i$&" L2$&4�>��<� O-X��@m ns�-+<��GH��+(�<$:)@95+<���(��� >/9;�*9EG]>���+<$&6s�&�#�&$&4�n�+Z9;��>�� )T�*9K+(�H�-=s+ .0$�"[.H9;�F+�0�Z$&GU.04-� $&"�+<��"95$&+($&�*[email protected]+]�*.�) nN95>��;�'.�),��6��$&"�+�� �rns�*9;�M$&"�+<�F"9;$�+<$&�x98.0�(�M>9;�*� � $�+<nN+<n�� �"�� � "9;��>�� )T�i��$��<�*),+($&��"98+<� ),�-G 6�>�+<�U9;>��5�'.-),�M�-�($&��"�+ .*+<$��-" � 13$&"),� +<n��u4-����GH��+<� � �*�@+<ns� b�.�9;��n/.-9+<�a.0"95�:.*+<$&��".0��9 ��G GH��+<� ��!\.*�&��"�4 +<n�� )�����$&"���<$:)F.0�.� �$I9R" ���-"���� + � � 9;��>�� )T�*9r.*�<�!"��F�*���*� +(� ),��GH%6�>�+(�u9;n.*6V�3� �rn��i95�->��a),�*9 � �F�<�H6��95$&+($&�-"s�*� .*+ ( ��C � .*"� �FC � .*"�4-���*9 � $&+(nN�<�*956V�x),+ +<�i+(n��9;�F"9;���@��$&�(�*),+($&�-" �hL2$&4�>��<�AO�Yf!\.g"#9;ns� � 9#+<n�� 9;n.*6V� �*� +<n��@b�.-95� �<�*),�*b����(�*� >95$&"�4 +<n�� � .0G]=���<%+<$I.0"uGH�������'�hL2$&4�>��<� O-Y^! ='"#95n�� � 9E+<ns� 9;n/.06�]),�-G 6�>�+<�x�U>/9;$&"s4 +(n��86��(�-6��95�*�iGH������� .0"��+(n���<��>�4-ns"��*9<98b�.*�&>��H>/9;�*� +(�i�<��"/�����@+<n�� $&GM.*4-�]$&" L2$&4�>��<�MO�Xf!')M" �iL�$&4->s�<�MO�^M),��GH6.0�(�*9Bns��$&4�n�+b�.0��>��*9@),�-G 6�>�+<�x�i.0�&��"�4�+(n��]b-.�9;�M)T�<��9(9;%'9;�*)T+<$&��" >/9;$&"s4�+<ns� + � �MGH�������:9T� Q\+@$:9!��b�$:����"�+#���<�-G+<ns$:9r6����-+#+<n.*+E+(n�� � .0G]=V�F�<+<$I.0"MGH�����F���<�x9;>���+ 9r$&"u�:.*�<4-�@���(�<��� 9h$&"u),�-G 6�>�+<�x� �-�($&��"�+ .*+<$&��"u.0"�n���"/),�M.0�I9;�i$�"N),�-G 6�>�+<�x� n��F$&4-n�+��[1�$&GH$��:.*�!���<�(�-�a9 .0�<� � �6�*)T+<�*�i$&"N+<ns�M)�.-95�H�0� 9;n/.06�H���<�-G9;n/.-��$�"�4��

QR"]+<ns�@),�-"�+<�� �+o�*��b�$I9;>.*�$&"956V�x),+<$��-"����<��>�4-ns"��*9<9r�*� .@9;>��5�'.-),�!$I9o�0��+<�F"M.!GH�*.-95>��<�h�*��$&+a9��>.0��$&+ � ! %"�$I9;n'"a�@Q\"[9;>) ni)�.�9;�*9 ��. � .���$:.*"),� 6����-+� 9;$&G $&�:.*�h+<�H+(n�� �-"s�*9!9;ns� � "[$&" L2$&4�>��<�x9,��Y*%

X-C

Page 34: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

��j )�.0" =V�u>9;�x� +<�[�*95+<$&GU.0+<� +<n��uGM.-),�(��9(),�-6�$I) �<��>�4-ns"��*9<9]�0�A+<n��u95>��;�'.�),��� �E��+<�u+<n.*+ +(n��9;��>�� )T�]��$&�(�*),+<$��-"i$I9 �"s� � "i$�"i�*.-) ni� .���$:.*"),� 6����-+F� gK��>�4-ns"��*9<9@)�.*" +(n����(�,���-�(�8=� �x9;+<$�GM.0+(�*�=�� %"��$�"�4M+<n�� � b-.*�&>�� ���-� � n�$I) n[+<ns� GH�x.-9;>s�<�*�M� .-��$:.0"/),�H�s.0+ .M=�*9;+�%+ 9!+<ns� GH�������\� 7#>��+<� +<n��8��>�"/),+<$��-".*� �����<G �*� +<n��AGH������� �V+(n�� %+(+<$�"�4H$:9#"��-"�%��&$�"��*.*�!.*"� .*"i$&+(��� .*+<$&b��@+(�*) ns"�$���>��9;>/) n .-9@+<n�� � �Fb���"�=���(4-%'�i.0����>.*"��+ � mo�(�*9<9s �q���K� %<�Fl-j-l � G ��+<n����i)F.0" =�H>95�*���MQ\"i�'.-),+�� � �.-���-6�+(�*��� s.-),+(���M+<n�$I9E.*6�6��(��.-) ni$&" %/+<+<$�"�4]+<n��]),��G =s$&"��*�]GH�������W!'X-j#"#+(�H� �6V�F�<$&G ��"�+a.0� ��.*+ .$&"i1��x),+<$��-" ���

!'.#" � .0G]=���<+($:.0" ! ='" ���������L2$�4->��(� O-Y�} ��3�� �������21435�,')��*"�, �� � ���65 4� � �!���!���!�$1&�$ 4�� ��5��7-!� �535��14�����$1& " #�>*"14�$ &�$��6�*8 ��5�7�����21435�9 ����-:�$ 41" #�������5�!���.D5�����(�8-/�N1435� �5 4���:�X*"��?���5�!��� + 0.��-:��143��$��*C�*$D� ������A�*@K�$ 4� ��-51��� ��5���6�*8 ��5�,1�K��� ���3X1T*"��65 ����* ��1%���5� �M�* � � � � � � � � K �143 4�* �����1 14��1435�>*"�$��*C�� %�A � 4���1" ����N+

-1 -0.5 0.5 1

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

Lambertian

Model

Height Actual shape

X

L2$�4->��(� O�^3} � ��1&6���� �5 &���5��� � �21435��')��*"������� ���� &��;KH M1&3�5 &���5���*T����� �56514�� 6�*8 ��5�(1435� 9 ����-��$ 41C G� ������ �5 4� ���X*"�� ���5�!���>�#�%� � � � D ��� �"! � �!�=+ �H35� 9 ����-:�$ 41" #��� ���5�!��� �5 4�5�!6����*��#�� &���;�$ 4 &�� =* ������� �5651&��;*"3����:��+

X��

Page 35: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

� E � � 3�? �'4*� ;58(= B��>:"=>:*�F8?9A 2 � �k3��/?�� ���k3 � 8 �q3�� ?qr$&"s��),>��:.*�@9;+(���<�F�M.0��4-�-�($&+(n�GM9h�<�*),��"9;+(�<>)T+!+<n�� 9;n.*6� �*�#.H9(),��"��8���(�-G + � � ���BG �-�<�A$&GM.*4-�*9T��rn��#$&GM.*4-�*9 .0�<�Z�-=�+a.0$&"s�*� =�� b�.0� ��$�"�4@+<n��#b�$�� � $&"s4@��$&�(�*),+($&�-"]�0� +<n��Z9;�F"9;�����cQ\" ��� ���F�v+(� ),��GH%6�>�+(� +(n��<�F��%\��$&GH��"/9;$&��".0� ),����� ��$�".0+(�*9B�*�#6V��$&"�+ 9@$&"[+<n�� 9<),�F"��#� +<n�� ),���<�<�x9;6�-"����"),�]=��+ � ����"6�-$�"�+a9 $�" +<n��u��$ � ���<��"�+ $&GU.04-�x9BG]>9;+@=���*95+ .*=��&$I9;n��*� � Q\"N+<n��u)�.�9;�M�0�@G �-+<$��-" �x9;+<$�GM.0+($&��"���-=��5�x),+ 9E$�"�+(n��]9<),�F"�� GH�*b�� � $&+<nu�<�*956�*),+!+(��. 9;+ .*+<$��-".*���i�-�ZGH�*b�$�"�4H95��"95�-���AJE43.0$&" � ),�-�(�<��%9;6��"����")T�B=��+ � ����"]6V��$&"�+ 9c$&"M),��"9;�x),>�+<$�b��E$�GM.04��*9oG >/9;+o=�A����+(���<GH$�"��*�@+<�]),��GH6�>�+(�h�-6�+($:)�.*�S� � �*9;+($&GM.*+<�*9T�"�rn����(�@.0�(�A9;��b����a.0� .0��4-���<$&+(n�GM9o���-�#GM.0+a) n�$�"�4A9;GM.*�&� .0�(�*.-9r$�"M�-"��@$&GU.04-� � $&+(n.0�(�*.-9!$�"��-+(n����!$�GM.04��*9,���rns�*9;� .0�&4��-�($&+<nsGM9!.-9(9;>�G �8+<n/.0+!=��($&4�n�+("��*9<9#b-.*�&>��x9E�0� 6�-$�"�+a9 $�"�+(n��9<)T��"��]���H"s�-+@b�.0��� � $&+(nib�$�� � $&"�4U��$&�(�*),+<$��-"��$\�_���@.H9(),��"�� 6�-$�"�+Zn.-9!+<ns�]9<.0G �8=��($&4-n�+<"s�*9<9E$�".0���2$�GM.04��*9,� �rn�$:9!.�9<95>�GH6�+($&�-"u$:9hb�.0�&$I��+g)f���B$ �c+(n�� 9(),��"��A$:9 � .0G]=���<+($:.0" � � >��#�<�x9;>���+ 9#9;n�� � 9+<n/.0+8�(�*.0� �-=��5�*)T+ 9@)�.0" ����b�$:.0+(�H95>�=95+ .0"�+<$I.0���������<��G � .*G =���(+<$I.0"[=V�Fn.�b�$��-�E�o+(n���$��B=s�<$&4�n�+("��*9(9� $&��� b�.0��� � $&+(nib�$�� � $&"�4]��$&�<�x),+<$��-" �#JE"i$�"�+(���<�*95+<$�"�4 6��<��=��&�FG � �->��I��$&"�b��-��b��@����b������-6�$�"�4]9;$�GH%$&�I.0�($&+ ��GH�x.-9;>s�<�*9K�����A),�-�(�<�*956V��"����"/),�H+<n/.0+A.0�(�H$&"95��"95$&+<$�b��8+(� =s�<$&4�n�+("��*9(9Bb�.0�($:.0+($&��"98��>s� +(�"���"�% � .*G =���(+<$I.0"M�<�,S/�*),+ .*"),���

� � �,� � �����

Q\"H)T�-"),��>9;$��-"�� � �#n.�b��#����b������-6�*� .@),�-G 6��<��ns��"9;$�b��cGH�����������-� ��$�� >95�E�(�,S�*),+a.0")T����J GH�������� .�9'%� 95+r�����<$�b��*� �����r.*"�$:95�-+(�<�-6s$:)#9;>��5�'.-),�*9o+(n.0+ n.�b��v�'.-)T��+ 9 � $&+(n ��"����A�-"��Z9;���-6��� �rn�$I9o�<�*95>��&+� .�9v>95�*� +(� ����b��F�&�-6].@GH�����������-�r$I9;��+<�<��6�$:)#9;>s�;�'.-)T�*9 � $�+<n�DZ.0>/9<9;$I.0"M95�&��6V�F%\.*�<�*. ��$I9;+(�<$&=s>�+<$��-" ��[�Bn/.xb��A.*�:9;�]6��(�*9;��"�+<�x�H.v��>.*�&$&+a.0+($&b��!GH�������V�����!��$ � >9;�@�<�TS�*),+($&�-"M+(n.0+#n.-9#.]9;$&G 6��&�h��>�"),%+<$��-".*�����-�(Gi���E>sGH���<��>9v�� �6���($&GH��"�+ 9 � ���(�@),�-"/��>),+(�*�H+<� b����($ � �]+<n��!�(�,S�*)T+ .0"/),�!GH�*) n.*"�$:95G���*9(),�<$�=�*� $�" +<n�$I9o6.06���F� �rn��!�<�x9;>���+ 926��(�*9;�F"�+(�*� ns���<�hn.�b��Z9;���($&��>9o$&GH6���$:)�.*+<$��-"9����-�cGM.�) n�$�"��b�$:9;$��-"2� +(n���[9;ns� � +<n.*+@b�$I9;$&��" .*�&4��-�<$�+<n�GU9E=.-95�*�i�-" +(n�� � .0G]=���<+($:.0"[.�9<95>�GH6�+($&�-" � $&���o"���+6��(����>),�u�<����$:.0=s�&�M�<�*95>��&+a9B���-� . b�.*�<$&�F+!� �0�@�(�*.0��% � �-�<�I� ��$ � >9;� 9;>��5�'.-),�*9T� �[�i����G �-"95+<� .*+<�*�9;��GH�]�0�#+<ns�*9;�H$�GH6���$:)�.*+<$&��"9E=��i>9;$�"�4i+<ns�HGH�����������-� �<�F"�����($&"�4M$&GU.04-�x9 �*�@��$�� >9;� �-=��5�*),+a9��9;+(>����$&"�4@�(�,S�*),+a.0")T�hGM.069��0� �(�->�4�nM��$ ��>/9;�Z9;>��5�'.-),�*9 ��.0"� �<�*)T�0b��F�<$&"s4@9;n.*6�E=�� 6�n���+<�-G ��+<�($:)9;+(���<�F���

� 4� ?��� ;5:"A ��: � :�? � ��rn�$:9@�<�*95�*.0�a) n � .�989;>s6�6�-�<+(�*� $�" 6.0�(+@=�� .0"m�@1�L gh�*95�*.0�a) n[Q\"�$�+<$:.*+<$��-" J � .*� �[.0"�

$&"u6.0�(+E=��uJ!g#m�J $c�-"�+<�a.-),+q�#���#7EJ�$ J ^*Y*%\l�O0%C$c%\C�C-C�^��A��$:) n.*��� � �<�F"�$:9#9;>s6�6�-�<+(�*��=���.*"Q5qh� D#� .-��>.0+(� L����&��� � 9;n�$�6 �

X-O

Page 36: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

� � ���,����� &'� ���D!"+����"����#$� & � �0���.��&'� � ����� � �%���*)��� � ���#��� � +"��� ��� �������*�

Q\"N+<n�$I98.06s6V�F"��$� � � �H��>�+<��$&"��u�����($&b�.0+($&��"9B���-� +(n��M��$��<�*),+A$&���&>�GH$�".0+($&��" .*"� $&"�+<���(�<�,S�x),+<$��-"),��GH6�-"���"�+ 9 �0� 6��(� �5�*),+(�*�!� .���$:.*"),�r���-��+<ns�h$:9;��+<�(�-6�$I)r9;>s�;�'.-)T�h��$I9<),>9(9;�*�8$�" 1��x),+<$��-"8 s�{O��"�rn��*95��<�x9;>���+ 9c.0�(�h>9;�*� $&"M1��*)T+<$&��" ��PX +(� ���F�<$&b�� +<n��#�<�TS�*),+a.0"),� GH�����������-� .@9;>��5�'.-),� � $&+(n DZ.0>/9<9;$I.0"9;���-6��%'.0�(�*. ��$:9;+(�<$�=�>�+<$��-" �

�DE�� � 8�A�358?94U: A ��: � � ��35={:�4�� �r;�; � ��35?�8"�k3��/?� >�� �-=��5�x),+<$�b�� n��F�<�M$:98+(�i��b�.0�&>/.0+<�M+(n��M$&"�+<��4�� .0�h$�"L!\O-lg" �NL��-� .0"�� 4�$&b���"N95�->��a),�u��$&�(�*),+($&�-"!"Y Z "�$ Z " .*"�W9;��"/9;�-�U��$&�(�*),+<$��-" !"Y R "�$ R " �r�'.-),�F+ 9 �-"W+<ns��$:95�-+(�<�-6s$:)i9;>s�;�'.-)T�i),��>��:�N=V�iGU.-9! ��x�$�9;n/.-��� � �x�$�vGU.-9! ��x� .*"� 95n.-��� � �*�$�c�-� "���$�+<n��F�8GM.�9! ��*�i"��-� 9;n/.-��� � �x��� �rn��M�a.-��$I.0"),�H������*.�) nA�0� +<n��x9;�h)F.-9;�x9 $I924-$�b���"@$&" ��.0=s�&�@�-� �rn��r6s�<�-=s�&��G +<ns���<�,�����<� $:9 +<�@���x),�-GH6�39;�r+(n��r$�"�+(��4-�a.0�$&" !\O-lg"@$&"�+<�u6.0�(+ 9��o�x.-) nN),�-�(�<�*956�-"��$�"�4i+<�[.u��$�� ���(��"�+8GM.�9! �$&"�4 )*9;n/.-��� � $&"s4�� .*"�4-�3� Z9;$&"s4=.�9;$:) 4-�F�-GH��+(���#� � � n/.xb�� $I����"�+<$ %�*� +(n�� �&$�GH$&+a9r�0� +<n�� $�"�+(��4-�a.0�:9Z),�-�(�<�*956V��"��$�"�4�+(����$�� ���<�F"�+� .*"�4-�x9r�0� 9;n.���� � $&"�4 )�GM.�9! �$&"�4s� �rn��x9;�@�&$�GH$&+a9o.0�(�!�<��6s�<�*95��"�+(�*� =�� +(n�� ������� � � ���k�g)������� $ Z � ! �����9;n/.-��� � $&"s4f" .0"� $ R � !:���-�oGU.-9! �$&"s4f" � �rn�� ),�<$�+<$I)�.0��.*"�4-����$ Z � $I92�<�F�:.0+(�*�!+<�!+(n��h95�&��6V�>Y��o�0� 95>��;�'.�),��'.-)T��+ 9T}

$ Z � S%&' &( )T��9 ] �2! ����� ��� ���� ��� " $ �&!�+ .*"�Y���+ .*"�Y�Z6"�!k�C ��+<n��F� � $:95�

!\X�l#"

�rn��u.0"s4-�&� $ R � $:9A����+(���<GH$�"��*��>95$&"�4i+(n��M9(.0GH�]� �6��<�*9(9;$��-"N=��[�<�F6��:.�),$&"�4 Y�Z � $&+(n Y R � �rn��*95�),�($&+<$I)�.0� .0"�4��&�*9h.*�<�@�<�F�:.0+(�*�H+<�]+<n��@GM.�9! �$&"�4 )*95n.-��� � $�"�4 � .*"�4-�*9#.-9#9;ns� � "u$&" ��.0=����8O��

mo.*�<+($:.0�o13n.-��� � �E�H1�n.���� � $c��GH6��&�F+<�81��F� ��%51�n.-��� �� $�� ( $/Z � � $ Z � $ Z � `�� $�� ( $/Z7�5` W ( $ Z � � $�� ( ! $/Z V Wd" � � $ Z �mo.*�<+($:.0���i.�9! �$&"�4 �E�]�i.-9 �$�"�4 $c��GH6��&�F+<�81��F� ��%'�i.-9! �$&"s4� $ � ( $ R � � $ R � $ R � ` � $ � ( $ R ��` W ( $ R � � $ � ( ! $ R V Wd" � � $ R �

��.0=s�&�AO�}� 7��*��A ��5���)*"3��A�!�)KH M�5��������1435�>�� " �1" #�$���2���5�����*$+ !9;$�"�4M+<n��M.*=�0b�� ),�($&+<$I)�.0� .0"s4-�&� � �6s�<�*9(9;$&��"9�� ��.0=����MO�� .0"� �2.*=��&�u� � � � ���*),��GH6��9;�

!\O�l#"�$&"�+<�@+(n��#9;>�G �0� 9;��b����a.0��$�"�+(��4-�a.0�I9,�otc.�) n $�"�+(��4-�a.0�)�.*" =�#��b�.0��>.0+(�*�B���-� .0"�� % ��*� b�$&� � �����$��<�*),+($&��" � �#� � ��b������ ����� .*�<=�$�+<� .*���N��$&�<�x),+<$��-"9@9;�Fb���� .*�r)F.-9;�x9 .0�<$I9;�M.*"� +(n��H�<�x9;>���+ 98.*�<�M"���+�*.�9!�H+(� >9;�@$&" 6�� .�),+<$I),���"�rns���<�,�����<�#� � �!n/.xb�� ) n��39;��"M+(� � �6s�<�*9(9v+<ns�B�a.-��$I.0")T�B�*�o+(n��@95>��;�'.�),����-� .0"��H.*�<=�$�+<�a.0���]b�$&� � $�"�4 ��$��<�*)T+<$&��" !�Y R "�$ R " .-9h. � ��$�4-n�+<�*�H95>�G �0��+<ns�!� .���$:.*"),� �R���� $�" +(n��6��I.0"��]�0� $&"),$I����")T� ! $ R�S $/Z#"�$/Z V Wd" ��.*"� +(n��]� .-��$:.0"/),� �R���� $&"[+<n�� 6���(6��"��$I),>��:.*�@6��:.*"��! $ RTS $ Z�� , , " �

X-X

Page 37: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

� jrmnifjr[U^.Z is[Oxx�UZ�� dfjr[nZ Xr}#�)[n^.ismnZt[U^.Z>��rn����<� .0�(�B+ � �H)�.�9;�*9h+<� ),��"9;$I������� Q\"�+(n�� %� 95+� $ R,S $/Z\� �W$&+<ns�->�+#�&�39<9h�0�c4���"����a.0�&$�+ �#�

� �A)�.*"u.-9<95>�GH�($ R%S $/Z S C��"�Wn���" Y�Z � Y R ��� .���$:.*"),�8$I9r�-=�+a.0$�"��*�M.-9T}

�R�� � !�Y��" S *,� � ),�39/Y�Z*),��9NY�� �O!W # � $

Z �] $ Z �

Of!(� V + .0" Y��V+a.0" Y R ),��9 $���" � $�� V

O � , ] $ Z �$ Z � !<� V +a.0" Y��V+ .*">Y�Z*),��9 $���"�!<� V +a.0" Y��V+ .*"�Y R )T��9 $���" � $�� &S *

,� � ),�39/Y�Z*),��9NY�� # � V O*+ .0" Y��V+a.0" Y R 95$&"$

Z �W V

�O +a.0" , Y��V+a.0" Y ZF+ .0" Y R !<� ( O $ Z � V 9;$&" !\O�$ Z � "

W " & ! 3C#"

�Wn���" Y R � Y�Z �o+<ns�M9;��"/9;�-�].*"�N9;��>�� ),�u��$��<�*)T+<$&��"[email protected]�(��95$&GH6s���i9 � $&+a) n��x� $�" +<n�� � �6s�<�*9(9;$&��"$&"/9;$:���!+<n��A98��>.*�<�A=�� .�) ���+a9,�

QR"M+(n��A9;�*),��"�M)�.-95�#� $ RTS $/Z V Wo�cJ#4�.0$�"�� � $�+<n���>�+#�&��9(9r�0� 4-��"s��� .*�&$&+ �#� � �8)F.0"u.-9(9;>�GH�$/Z S C "�$ RTS Wo�'�Wns��" Y Z � Y R � � �@4-��+F}

�R�� � !"Y���" S *, � � )T��9/Y�Z*),�39NY� �O!W # O � $

Z �$ R � Of!<� V +a.0" Y��V+ .*">Y R ),��92!�W ( $��E"\" � $�� V

O � , ] $ Z �$ Z � !<� V + .*"�Y��V+a.0">Y�Z*),�39 $��E" !<� V + .*"�Y��V+a.0" Y R ),��9[!"W ( $��E"\" � $�� &S *

, � � )T��9/Y�Z*),�39NY� # � ( O�$ R �W V O*+ .*"�Y��V+a.0" Y R 95$&"$

R � ( 9;$&"$ Z �W (

�O + .0" , Y��+ .0" Y�Z�+ .*"�Y R !<� ( O $ Z � V 9;$�"u!'O $ Z � "

W " & ! s�M"

� "),�u.043.0$�"�� � n���" Y R � Y�Z �c+<ns��95��"95�-� .0"� 9;�->s� ),�u��$��<�*),+($&��"9 .0�(��9 � $&+a) n��x� $�"N+<n��M+<�F�<G$&"/9;$:���!+<n��A98��>.*�<�A=�� .�) ���+a9,�

� jrmnifjr[U^.Z is[Oxx�UZ�� ZtY v�Zt[nmUif^.eUdfjrY��dsjr[nZ>�� � "�� � )�.*�:),>��I.0+(�8� .���$:.*"),�8�����!+<n��])F.-9;� � ns���<�A+<n�� b�$&� � ���#$:9h$&"i+<ns� 6��:.*"��86���(6V�F"�%

��$I),>��:.*�8+(�i+<n��M6��I.0"��H�*�!$�"),$I����"),�j�o$\� �3� $ R S $ Z � , , �[JE4�.*$&"��c+<n��F�<�M.*�<�H+ � �[)F.-9;�x98+<�i=�),��"9;$I�����<�x���#QR"i+(n�� %/� 9;+ )�.-95�#� $ Z � V $ R � ` , , � �E���<� ��+<n�� �(��4-$��-"9h�0� 9;n/.-��� � $&"s4�.*"��GM.�9! �$&"�4���]"��-+h�*b����(�:.*6 �c !9;$�"�4 +<ns�*9;�@�&$�GH$&+a9��-+(n��@$&"�+<��4�� .*� $&" !'O-l#" $:9h��b�.0��>.0+(�*�M.-9T}

�R�� � !"Y � " S *, � � ),��9/Y Z )T��9NY � ! 3O#"

X0

Page 38: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

Q\"i+<n��]95�*),��"� )F.-9;� � � � n.�b�� $ Z � V $ R � ! , , � �E���(�#��+(n�� �<��4�$&��"9!�0� GM.-9 �$�"�4M.*"� 95n.-��� � $�"�4���]�*b����<�I.06 �"�W$�+<n���>�+E����9(9K�*�c4-��"s��� .*�&$&+ �#� � � )�.*"�) n����39;� $ Z S C].0"/�'$ RTS , , � �[�A����%"��@+(n��.0"s4-�&��� ��C `�� ` , , � +(n.0+A9;�F6.0�a.0+<�x9 +(n��]�<��4�$&�-"/9 �*�#95n.-��� � $�"�4 ! ( , , V $ R � ` $�� `��l"K.0"�GM.�9! �$&"�4 !�� ` $���`JW ( $ Z � "a���[$:9#����+(���<G $&"��*� .-9,}h+a.0">Y�Z�),��9�� S + .0" Y R ),�39l! , , ( �2" � �rn���" �+<ns�B�� �6��(�*9<95$&��"U�����h� .���$:.*"),�8$I9,}

�R�� � !"Y���" S *, � � )T��9NY�Z*),��9 Y� �O!W # ���] , , + $ R � Of!(� V + .0" Y R + .*">Y���),�39l! $�� ( , , "\" � $�� V

� , ] $ Z ��

Of!(� V + .*"�Y�Z�+a.0" Y� ),��9 $��E" � $�� &S *

,� � )T��9NY Z ),��9 Y � # � V �

O ($ Z � V $

R �W V

� + .*" , Y R + .*" , Y�� ( � V� +a.0" , Y ZF+ .0" , Y�� ( � ( +a.0" Y�� � + .0" , Y�Z V + .0" , Y R

W & ! 3X#"

� jrmnifjr[U^.Z is[ w Y%hni�x Y jrY)o w isg,eKxx� w [2�>dfZ\`p�� �An.�b�� ����+(���<G $&"��*�]b�$I. 95$&G]>��:.*+<$&��"9r+<n/.0+!+(n��8�a.-��$I.0"),�A�0� +<ns�8$:95�-+(�<�-6s$:)895>��;�'.�),�8$�"

.0"��i.*�<=�$�+<�a.0���[��$&�<�x),+<$��-"�$I9 � �����&%'.06�6��(�� �$�GM.0+(�*�H=��u+<n��8�����&�&� � $�"�4 � �F$&4-n�+<�x�i9;>�Gz�0� W�R�� � !�Y���".0"/� �R�� � !�Y���"a}

R�� !�Y��" � ��),��9[! $ R)( $ Z6" � R�� � !�Y�E" V !(� ( �*),�392! $ R)( $ Z6" �" R���� !�Y��" ! � f"

�rn�$I9B.*6�6��(� �$&GU.0+<$��-" � .-9!�-=�+a.0$�"��*� =��i95+<>����$&"s4 +(n��]� �6s�<�*9(9;$&��"9E���-�@+<ns� � .-��$:.0"/),�H)T�-GH6�-%"���"�+ 9c$&"H+(n��!+ � �A6��:.*"��*9T�cQR+c$I9v$&" 4-��"��F� .0� b������].�)�),>��a.0+(�#� � $�+<nM. 95�&$&4�n�+c�*b����(% �*95+<$�GM.0+($&�-" ��"�������-� Y R � Y�Z�.0"� Y Z�� W �*O��

!9;$�"�4H+<ns� .0=�*b�� �&$�"��*.*�!),��G =s$&".*+<$&��"M�0� � .���$:.*"),�8$�"�+(n�� + � �]6��:.*"��*9�� � �8��=�+ .*$&"i+(n��%".*�2�� �6��(�*9<95$&��" ���-�Z6��<� �5�x),+<�*�H�a.-��$I.0"),�3� �rn��@���-�&��� � $&"�4]"��-+a.0+($&�-"i$I9K>/9;�*��} � S � ! � Y�Z�"$Y R �.0"/� � S �� � � Y�Z " Y R � ��$ � � S Y�Z � $� � S $ Z � �����I9;� $� � S $ R � �.*"� +(n��A9<.*GH�!�<>s�&�*9h.*6�6���� +<� $ 3 � �

�R�� !"Y���" S *, � � ),�39NY Zx),��9NY��

�� V ),�392! $ R ( $/ZF" &�� � !��W�$Y���"�+a.0"�� V � , !�� "�$ R ( $/ZF�$Y��E")( V

!<� ( � ),��92! $ R ( $ Z6" �i" � � !"Y R "$Y�Z0�$Y���" � ! �#"

� n����(�@+<n��A),��� �U),$���"�+a9r.*�<��}

� � ! �J� Y � " S + .*">Y � Oo95$&"$ �

W V�O +a.0" , Y � +a.0"��J!(� ( O�$ � V 95$&"q!\O�$ � "

W "

X��

Page 39: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

� , ! � " $ R ( $ Z0�$Y��E" S%&' &( , $ 3 �,( + .0">Y��!+ .*" � ,���� � $ 3 �

, $ � ),��92! $ R)( $/ZF" � CC $ � ),��92! $ R)( $/ZF" � C

� � !�Y R "$Y�Z0� Y��" S%&&&&' &&&&(C $ � $ Z � V $

R � ` , ,�, (

$ Z � + $ R �, V� � �� � ��� ���� � � � ] � + � � �� � ��� � �� � � � ] � ] � �� � � � � �� � ��� + ���� � ���, $ � $ Z � V $R � ! , ,

�DE W � 8�A�358?94U: A ��: � � �¯? �>:"=>=>: �|:"4��k3�� ? ��

� �N)�.0�I),>��I.0+<�M+(n����a.-��$I.0"),� ),�-G 6V��"���"�+]��>��u+<� $�"�+(���<�(�,S�*),+($&��"9�� � ��"����x� +<�[��b�.0��>.0+(��+(n�����-���&� � $&"s4 $&"�+<��4�� .0�'}

,R�� !�Y�E" S �OXW � , ,

��� � ,R�� !"Y�� "�$���" � $�� ! 3Y#"

Q\"i1��*),+($&�-"M s�&�-�PO�� � � ����>�"�H+<ns�B$�"�+(���<�(�,S�*)T+<$&��" �'.-)T+<�-�q! � � "c+<�]=�]}

� � S , , # ��!<� " ���� " V ��!<� " � �� " ( ��! � �� " ���� " ( ��!(��"���" & ! �^�"

�rn��].*=V�*b�� �'.-),+(�-�@)F.0"�"���+@=V� �x.-9;$����u$&"�+<��4�� .0+(�*��� �rn����(�,���-�(�#� � � >/9;� +<ns�8���-�&��� � $&"�4M.*6�6��(� �$&%GM.*+<$&��" }

� � � W�!<� ( ),��9NY��E" !<� ( � � " !(� ( ���E" ! 3j#"

J!9H$&" J#6�6��"��$� J8�&� �K+(n��[�<��4�$&�-"/9U�*� 9;n.���� � $&"�4 .0"�WGM.�9! �$&"�4 � ���<�i$I����"�+<$ %�*�W.0"/� +(n��.0=�*b��Z.06�6��(�� �$�GM.0+($&�-"A+<� � � � .-9o>95�*� +<�@��b�.0��>.0+(�u!� �Y#"a� �rn�� %".*�� �6s�<�*9(9;$&��" �����c6��<� �5�x),+<�*�� .���$:.*"),�@�0� +<n��@$:95�-+(�<�-6s$:)@9;>��5�'.-),�A��>s�B+(� $�"�+(���<�(�,S�*)T+<$&��"9o$:9T}

,R�� !"Y � " �- ,W � � ),�39NY Z ),��9/Y � !<� ( ),�39NY � " � � ( ! 3l#"

),��92! $ R)( $ Z6" 1 O�$ 3 �W V O�+ .0" Y��V+a.0"�� 95$&" $� � ( 95$&"�$ 3 �W V

�O +a.0" , Y��+a.0"��8+ .0"��W!<� ( O�$ � V 95$&"q!\O�$ � "

W "45 �

X-Y

Page 40: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

� ���.������,&'��+

� qr�x) �GH.*"�" .0"�i1�6�$cb)b�$:) n�$&"s�����l�Y-XM�]m���qr�*) �G .0"�" .0"� JA� 136�$cb�bF$:) n�$&"��s� � �n � � ���F�G�����)�� + � �K ��� �8+������g)� � � ��� ���M��)��8+�� � +�� � � � � ��U������T� m2���(4�.0G �-"��`�E� ��� ���� ���Fl-Y-X��

� qr�x) �GH.*"�"����l�Y�� � m2� qr�*) �GM.*"�" �E1�n/.-��� � $&"s4H�0� � .*"����G �<�->s4-n[9;>s�;�'.-)T�*9,� � ����� � �\�g)��U���%�� ��+g) � +g) � )f�C�)�)`� ���g) ��� �\+%$`���g��� ��+g)���JZm %(��X�}{X�j0 �X-j�j��o�Fl-Y����

� qr��$&"�" �V�Fl�^�^E� � � Lr��qr��$&"�" � ���������:9!�*�#�&$&4�n�+Z�<�,S�x),+<$��-"����-� ),�-G 6�>�+<�F�!9 ��"�+<n��x9;$cbF�*��6�$:)T+<>��(�*9,����� �W+�� $ �g�G���� �\�%$ � � ��� � � ������� ��������� ! ���Flf!(��C#"a} �* �O� �0 �^ �v�Fl�^�^��

� qr>sn��r ������� � ��l�Y-j��]78��qr>�ns� �#� � � ��� ���I) n .0"/� 7A��D8�sgK�x.��ogh���a.-��$I.0+<$��-"M.*"�H+<n��F�<GM.*�V�FGH$:95%9;$&��" ���(�-Gz$&�&��>�GH$�".0+(�*�M),� .*+<���a9E�-"[+<n�� ��>�".*�@9;>��5�'.-),�3����+�� ��)�����+ ���8+%$ � � ��� � ��� �����8��� � ���^*Xf!(��Yg" } ��O-j��� ��O�l�����JE>�4�>9;+@�Fl-Y�j��

� $ .*=�� .*�& �&���K� �2�Fl-j�^ � q!�&$ .0=��a.0� ���8� �i. .0"/� g@�K136��<$�"�4-GH���������Wqr$I��$&�(�*),+($&�-"/.0�h�<�TS�*),+($&�-"��>�"),+($&�-"/9 ���<�-G 9;>��5�'.-),�N=�>�G 6kGM.06/9,� ���� �W+�� $ �#�C���� �8�%$ � � ��� � � ������� ����� ��� ! �O���!� f"a}{O�^xX��O-j��#�c�Fl-j�^3�

��$cn/.0"���a.-95� �n/.0�����l�Y-C�� 1��$cn.*"��� .�9;� �n.*��� �N��������� � �M � �\�g) ����� � 7E�*b����cmo>�=���$:)�.*+<$��-"9 �V�Fl-Y�C��� L���� 9!��+<nu.*"���$I9<9;�F�<GM.*"����l-j�lM�]78�3L/��� 9 ��+(n].0"�]J8� �$I9<9;�F�<GM.*" ����>�+(>.0�s$&�&��>�GH$�".0+($&�-" � � �8+ ����W+g) ��!�W+�� $ �#�C��#" � ����+g) �g) �$�����F�G���) � � +��j) ��� ��+g)���6.*4-�*9h �Y�Y�� �^*X��v�Fl-j�l��

�i�Z.06� ��@.*"� b�.*" �E���<"�� ��l-Y�XM�]q!� � �2�!.*6� ��].0"� �E>�4�� b�.0" �E���<" � mon���+<��GH��+<�($:)A9;+<>/��$&�*9#�0�),�-GH6s�&� [95>��;�'.�),�*9�� � $&+(n .06�6���$:)�.*+<$��-"9@+<�[+<n��HG ���-" �%��+�� ��)`���&+ &��8+%$ � ����� � ��� �����8��� � ���Y-jf!(���g" } �0 ��� ��^�C���JE>�4�>9;+@�Fl-Y�X��

�i�Z.06� ��s��&����� � �Fl-l-X��]q!�'� �a�!.06� ��#�cgB� � �W�E���I9;��" .*"� � �c7A�K1�G ��+<n���� �rn�����6�6��95$&+<$��-"��� �*),+@�0� +<n��]GH���-" }&�rn�� ),��"�+(�<$&=s>�+<$��-"[�0�#)T�-n����(��"�+B=/.-) �9()�.0+(+<���F� � ���6�) �� �cO�Y-C^!\O-Xg" }��-C-l'���-� ��J#6��<$��o��l�l-X��

� �#���<$�"�4 .*"� 1�G $&+<n �V�Fl�^xC � g@�VDA�n�E���($&"�4].*"� �!�Lr��13GH$&+(n ��JE6�6.*�<��"�+h� .���$:.*+<$&��"�6��(�-6���(+<$&�x9�0� .!�<��>�4-nM95>��;�'.�),��� � � � ��� �\+���� ���� ��) � ��� �\+g)����g� � ���q�g) � � ��\+g)`���#� � ��� ��O-X�}{X-X�^(�X-Y�� �2�Fl�^xC��

� �#�-�<"u.*"��qr�(��� s9�� ��l�j-l � q!� � ��m��n�E�-�("�.*"��� � � �qr�<��� �9 ���*��$&+(�-�a9,� � �`�%$n ��\+�� � �`������)�����rn�� �iQ � m �(�*9<9 � ��l�j-l��

�i�#�-�<" ����l�j-Y��]q!� � �m2�n�E���<" ��� +� +���" � ����+g)�� �rns�8�iQ � mo�<�*9(9�� ��l�j-Y��

� � .� ��-=�� �Fl���^E� � � � .� ��-= �)� 8��� � �\�g)������ � �W$&����#���Fl���^��

� �@. �5$���.�� ��l-l�� � � � �!� �@. �5$���.�� J#"�$:95�-+<�(�-6�$I) �(�,S�*),+($&��" GH�����F�\� ���� �W+�� $ �g�C��*� �\�%$ � � ���� � ������� �+���-,/. ! �O��f!� f"a}&�0^ ��/��j-Y��c��l-l��-�

X�^

Page 41: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

� �!����"/�����<$�"� .0"�Mb-.*"i7E�����<"�����l�j-X�� � � � � �!����"�����<$�"� u.0"�iJ8� � ��b�.*"[7E���-�(" �BD#����GH��+<�($:)�.*�GH�����*9!.�9!.H4-��"s��� .*�2GH�F+<n�����+(�H+<�(�*.0+@��$�� >9;� $�"�+(���<�(�,S�*)T+<$&��"9r$&"i�a.-��$��-GH�F+<���3���`+�� ��)����X+ � �n�� $n� � � ��� � +����6 � �v+ � �v���� � � �V^xXf!\Yg" }Pj0 �X'�j��-C��c�Fl-j-X��

� �!>�43. .*"�MQ59;n�$�GM.0�(>����Fl-j0 (� � � � >s4�.8.*"�]J8��Q59;n�$�GM.0�(> ��gh��+(�<�-�(�,S�*)T+ .0"/),�r���<��G .@����"95�!��$:9;%+<�<$�=�>�+($&�-"]�0� 956�n����($:)�.*��6.*�<+<$I),�&�x9,� ��+�� ��)`���'+ N���n�� $n� � � ��� � +����6 � ��+ � �v���� � � � ��(!\j#"a}{j�X���j-X�����J#>�4->95+8�Fl-j* ��

� � .*G =���(+� �0^*Y�CM� � �n�8� � .*G =���(+��cmon��-+(�-GH�F+<�<$I.895$&b��@���@GH�F"9;>��(�@���@4-�a.0+($&=�>9h�&>sGH$&"�$I9���),���&�-%�<>�G >sG =��a.0��� � ��� �`��� ������ �F� �o�*^*Y�C��

�$P� 6�$� � ��l�O0 �� th�>P� 6�$� �� m ns�-+<��GH��+(�<$:)rG �*.-95>��<�*9o�*��+<n��#GH���-" .0"/� +<n��ZGH���-"]+<n��#�*.*�<+<ns%\95n�$&"��3���� �� � � ��� ��+g) � �f.#����'�������E���_+����6 � ��� �8+g)�+�� � � ��� �f #���X) � �M��������C �f � ��� � �#�!O�Yf!(�M" }����Y-j����l-O* ��

� ��$�"�".*���<+�����l* �� � � �o��$�"�".*���<+F���rns� �(�*),$�6��<��),$�+ �i6��<$�"),$&6s�&�]$&"N�&>�"/.0� 6�n���+<��GH��+<� ��� � ��� �8+ �$ � � ��� � ��� �`+�� ��)���� �sl-X�}_ �C�X�� s��C��v�Fl0 s�-�

� �Z. ��.*�u ������� � ��l�l��F. � 1� � ���!.��.*�� � �*Q ���>/) n�$3.0"� �!� �@.0".������1�n.06�r���(�-G $&"�+<���(�<�,S/�*),+<$��-"9T���)f�C���)���� ��+g)`�����`+�� ��)����k+ �W+�� $ �g�C��#" � ����+g)��Y�}{X�}&�0^xX�/��l����c��l-l��-�

�i�Z. ��.*�u ������� � ��l�l��T=��H1� � �(�!.��.0��� � ��Q ���>) n�$�.*"� �!� �@.0".������1�>��;�'.�),�r�(�,S�*)T+<$&��" }�mon��s9;$I)�.0�.0"� 4����-G ��+<�($:)�.*�o6��� 956V�x),+<$�b��*9,� � ����� � �8�g) �U����� ��+g) � +g)*�����6�C���) � )`��� � ��� � �g) � ��� � ��)���)f�C ���-� �f�) �� �c��X^!;^�"a}{Y��-���Y-X* �� � >���� ��l-l��-�

�i�#$:),�����FG >9� ������� � ��l�^-^U� Lr� tK�W�#$:),�����FG >9 � � �J$#�cgh$:) n�GH�-"/�i.0"� � � � ���Z9;$:.�����8+��v�� ������ ���)�W+g) �����f��\��� ��+g) � �g) ��q+��v�) ���=��� � � �U+�� ���� ���0�g) �� �&�!.*+<$&��".0� qr>��(�*.0>u�0�h1�+a.0"�s.0� �s9��� )T+<�-=���A��l�^-^3�h���-"���4-�a.06�n �E��� �FY-C��

� � ��+ �$�"�4�� ��l�Y-Y � m2� � ��+ �$�"�4�� m ns�-+<��GH��+(�<$:)Z9;+<>/��$&�*9r�*�c��$�� >9;�F���H�(�,S�*),+($&"�4 9;>��5�'.-),�x9 � $&+<nu.*6�%6��&$I)�.0+($&�-" +(�@+<n�� =��<$�4-n�+<"��*9(9o�0� +<n��hG ���-" � �`+�� ��)����n+ ��8+%$ � � ��� � ���������8��� � ����^3��!(��C#"a}{O��-C��'O����FX�� �i.�i�Fl-Y�Y��

� � �(��"M.0"/� �!.��.0�����Fl-l-X � � � � �<��" .0"/� 1� � �k�!.��.0�F� 7#$�� >9;�]�<�TS�*),+a.0"),�8���(�-G �(�->�4�nN9;>��(%�'.-),�*9T� � ����� �W+g)����R�) �� +g) �W+�� $ �#�C��#" � ����+g) �g) � �����6�C���) � � +��j) ��� ��+g)�� � >�"��]�Fl-l-X��

� � �(�&�*b�.����Fl���YM���8��1/� � �(�&�*b�.�� m ns�-+<��GH��+(�<$:)r�(���&$��,��*� +<ns�E��>�".0� 95>��;�'.�),��� � ��� �8+g)�� � ��X�Xf!<��" }Pl-X���C-C��2�Fl���Y��

� m��->���$&"M.*"��L��->s�<"�$����� ��l-l�CM�]m��*m2�->���$&"@.*"�8JA��L��->��("�$&�F����J GH�������*���-��.*"�$:95�-+<�(�-6�$I)o�<�,S�x),+<$��-" ����� �W+�� $ �g�G���� �\�%$ � � ��� � � ������� �����-,�� ! ��O* �!� f" }PO�^xX��O�j-O��c��l�l-C��

� mo�(�*9<9u ������� � ��l�j-l�� � �n�8�mo�<�*9(9��q!�m2�L��:.0"s"������ ��1�J8� � ��>� ��-�I9! ��#��.*"� � � �!� �c��+<+(���<��$&"�4s� � �v���� � ���"�� ��� $n�� ��) �o�r$ .*G =s�<$:��4-�@ E"s$&b����a9;$&+ � m �(�*9<9 � ��l�j-l��

� 13$&��4���� .*"� �E� � ���&� �V�Fl�^xO � g@�V13$&��4���� .*"� � �gB�`�E� � �����\� � �n�������� �N��������� ��+g)��u8��� � �\�g) ����� ��E��GH$I9;6�n��F�<�Zm >s=��&$I9;n�$�"�4s$c�-�(6V��� .*+<$&��"���+(n�$&�a�U�x��$&+($&�-" ����l�^*O��

X-j

Page 42: >=>8(4 - Columbia University)[>x Y X7mUen^px ifX>[ jrmnisX>g Z.x Y is^ u Z [Ui x ifX>[U` 7enY)}¹jr^.Z X>e U[nZ\` ` X7mnZ\d Z "Zt^px jr[n^.Z X7mnZtd ! #" $&%' $& ( *),+($& -"/.0 213$&"

� 13GH$&+(n����l-Y�^E� q!��D8� 1�GH$�+<n � � >s".0�@95>��;�'.�),�@�<��>�4-n�"s�*9<9T} 13n.-��� � $�"�4M.0"/� +<ns���<GM.*����G $:9<95$&��" ���+�� ��)`���k+ ��8+%$ � � ��� � ��� � ���8���������/^xOf!(��Y#"a} 3C��-l'� �C�Y�^�� JE>s4->95+8�Fl-Y�^3�

� ��.043.0�(� .0"/�����*L�$&4->s��$&�(�*������Fl-l������8��78�"��.043.0�(��.*"� g@� � ��m2� ���*L2$�4->��F$&�<�x�����MJ +(n��������[�0�6�n��-+(�-GH�F+<�<$I)!9;+(���<�F� �����#. ),�I.-9(9K�*�c��$ � >9;�A"��-"�% � .0G]=���<+($:.*"i9;>s�;�'.-)T�*9,��� ����� � �8�g) �U����� ��+g) �+g) �&���F�C���) � )`��� � ��� � �g) �� ����� ��)� ��)f�C �K� � �f�) �� �v�FXf!'O#" }���X�X����-O�� L���=s�<>.*���i�Fl-l����

� � �-�(� .*"),�A.0"�i1�6.*�<�<� � ����l�Y�^E� � ��� ���<�a.0"),�].*"�[tK��1�6.0�(�<� � � �rn�������� �����@� � %\956�*),>��I.0�@�<��%S�*),+($&�-"]���<�-G �<��>�4-nU9;>��5�'.-),�*9T����+�� ��)`���'+ ���n � $n� � � ��� � +����6�� ��+ � �v���� � � � ��^3}&����C��'���-�, ��1���6�+(��G =���Z��l�Y�^��

� �h9(.0"�4 .0"/��Q59;n�$�GM.0�(>����l�j0 � � � �h9<.*"�4u.0"�iJA��Q59;ns$&GM.*�<> �hqh.�) s9<)F.0+<+(���<$�"�4 ��"�n/.0"),�FGH��"�+h�0�� .0"/���-Gp��$:9(),�<�F+<�h9()�.0+(+<���(��� 9T���`+�� ��)���� + N� �n � $n� � � ��� � +����6 � ��+ � �v���� � � � ����!'j#"a}{j-X�Y��j-X-l��JE>�4->/9;+A��l-j* ��

� � .04�"������ ��l-Y�Y � gB� � �'� .04-"s����� 1�n.���� � $&"�4i�*�!�a.0"���-GH���i�<�->s4-n 9;>��5�'.-),�x9,� �`+�� ��)����a+ � �n� � +������ � � ��� � +����6�� �s+ �� �v���� � � �� ��(!<�M"a}&�FX-j�/�, �^�� � >s"��]��l-Y�Y��

� �[������n.*G � ��l�j-C��]gB� � �$�[������n.0G �8mon���+<�-G ��+<�($:)BG ��+<n����H���-�@����+<���(GH$&"s$&"�4]95>��;�'.�),� �-�($&��"�%+ .0+($&��" ���(�-G G]>���+<$&6s�&�8$�GM.04��*9,� � $n� � � ��� � )�����)n �����)�� �!��l^!<��" }&�FX-l'�, � � � .0"�>.0� ��%'L���=��<>/.0�����l-j�C��

X-l


Recommended